40
The Third Revolution: The Convergence of the Life Sciences , Physical Sciences , and Engineering MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY

Mit white paper on convergence

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

 

Citation preview

Page 1: Mit white paper on convergence

The Third Revolution:

The Convergence ofthe Life Sciences,Physical Sciences,and Engineering

M A S S A C H U S E T T S I N S T I T U T E O F T E C H N O L O G Y

Convergence.cover.final 12/13/10 10:04 AM Page 2

Page 2: Mit white paper on convergence

Convergence.cover.final 12/13/10 10:04 AM Page 3

Page 3: Mit white paper on convergence

!

!

"#$$#%!$&!&'%!(&))#*+'#,-!!

./0,!%#1&%$!0,!1%#,#2$#3!$&!$/#!/#*)$/!,40#24#!%#,#*%4/!4&55'20$6!$&!/#)1!3#)02#*$#!*2!051&%$*2$!2#7!%#,#*%4/!5&3#)84&29#%+#24#87/04/!3%*7,!&2!*2!&2+&02+!5#%+#%!&:!)0:#;!1/6,04*)!*23!#2+02##%02+!,40#24#,<!!!!

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

(&29#%+#24#!70))!=#!$/#!#5#%+02+!1*%*30+5!:&%!/&7!5#304*)!%#,#*%4/!70))!=#!4&23'4$#3!02!$/#!:'$'%#<!@&7#9#%;!4&29#%+#24#!:*4#,!*!,#%0#,!&:!1&)046!4/*))#2+#,!$/*$!5',$!=#!%#,&)9#3!$&!*))&7!0$!$&!#5#%+#!*$!*!,4*)#!$/*$!4&')3!=#!$%')6!$%*2,:&%5*$09#<!!

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

K024#%#)6;!

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

K*2+##$*!S<!J/*$0*!!P&/2!*23!O&%&$/6!A0),&2!L%&:#,,&%;!@*%9*%3QCD.!O090,0&2!&:!@#*)$/!K40#24#,!*23!.#4/2&)&+6!!.6)#%!N<!P*4B,!O*903!@!I&4/!L%&:#,,&%;!!O0%#4$&%;!I&4/!D2,$0$'$#!:&%!D2$#+%*$09#!(*24#%!M#,#*%4/!

O&'+)*,!G<!"*'::#2='%+#%! H&%3!L%&:#,,&%!*23!@#*3;!O#1*%$5#2$!&:!J0&)&+04*)!N2+02##%02+!!M&=#%$!"*2+#%!O*903!@<!I&4/!D2,$0$'$#!L%&:#,,&%!!!L*')*!.<!@*55&23!J*6#%!L%&:#,,&%!&:!(/#504*)!N2+02##%02+!!C%0+*2B*!K'% L*')!N<!S#7$&2!L%&:#,,&%!&:!S#'%&,40#24#;!@#*3;!O#1*%$5#2$!&:!J%*02!*23!(&+20$09#!K40#24#,!!!

!

!"#$"%&'()**

Page 4: Mit white paper on convergence

!"#$%"#&$'()"#%*+'"($*,"-+$+.'/$#&0"#+1$

2"(+*2+$+.&$345$6*/.'(7+"($8))'2&9$

:;<$=/+$>+?$@A1$>+&?$B=<$

6*/.'(7+"(1$CD$;<<<;$

;<;?E:F?=:;:$GG$B=E?H;I?FF:=$

$

5.'/$#&0"#+$'/$*J/"$*K*'J*,J&$"(J'(&$*+$.++09LLM&,?%'+?&N-LN2L$

$

O;<==$3*//*2.-/&++/$4(/+'+-+&$")$5&2.("J"7P?$$QJJ$#'7.+/$#&/&#K&N?$

Convergence is a new paradigm that can

yield critical advances in a broad array

of sectors, from health care to energy,

food, climate, and water.

Page 5: Mit white paper on convergence

!

"#$%&!'(!)'*+&*+,!

!"#$%&'(#!%")))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))*$

+),%-.$-!./,%0,(%"-.$1."(. )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))2$

MN(NS.!JDFCNOD(G"!MNTF"U.DFSK<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<V$

!"#$%&'()$*#+,-.)&,/0$1,-#2.-3'$3/4$5#--.-3'$6&,-,78999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999:$

!"#$;#2,/4$*#+,-.)&,/0$<#/,=&2(9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999>$

.@N!.@DMO!MNTF"U.DFS!8!(FSTNMWNS(N <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<X$

NYGCL"NK!FH!(FSTNMWNS(N!DS!JDFCNOD(G"!MNKNGM(@ <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<Z$

5,=?.)3)&,/3-$6&,-,78$@,'$A==./#$*#(?,/(#999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 BC$

A=37&/7$!#2"/,-,78$),$D'#+#/)$6-&/4/#((99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 BC$

E3/,)#2"/,-,78$@,'$!3'7#)#4$5"#=,)"#'3?8$F#-&+#'8 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 BB$

6'3&/$D-3()&2&)8$@,'$!'#3)&/7$6'3&/$F&(,'4#'($3/4$A/G.'8 99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 BH$

632)#'&3-$;#/(,'($@,'$!.=,'$F#)#2)&,/$3/4$F'.7$F#-&+#'899999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 BI$

(&*EJ$@,'$)"#$KAL$L322&/#99999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 BM$

5!5N2"&?$@,'$F#)#2)&/7$53/2#'$1#)3()3(#(9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 BM$

3),#4.,.(%"%5!(,(67.,0%$,7'88%$#!"1,(%"-.$1."(. )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))+9$

ONCFWMGL@D(!(@G""NSWNK!GSO!.@N!SNNO!HFM!DSSFTG.DFS <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<[\$

@DW@!MN.UMSK!HFM!HNONMG"!DSTNK.CNS.!DS!JDFCNOD(G"!MNKNGM(@ <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<[Z$

*),"!4:7,$%;.,!",6&-6"(!"1,(%"-.$1."(. ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))33$

HUSODSW!(@G""NSWNK!GSO!"FAQMDKI!MNKNGM(@ <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<]]$

(FSTNMWNS(NQK.R"N!LMFPN(.K!G.!SD@ <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<]^$

!"#$53/2#'$<#/,=#$J)-3($O!5<JP0$!3'7#)#4$!"#'3?#.)&2($@,'$53/2#'$;.Q)8?#(999999999999999999 HR$

!"#'3?#.)&2($@,'$*3'#$3/4$E#7-#2)#4$F&(#3(#($O!*EFP0$6'&47&/7$)"#$L3--#8$,@$F#3)"$@,'$

<-,Q3-$K#3-)" 999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999 H:$

DCL"D(G.DFSK!HFM!.@N!HU.UMN<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<]\$

2),$.(%55."&6#!%"7 ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))3<$

[<!NSKUMN!.@G.!(FSWMNKKDFSG"!HUSODSW!CNN.K!FM!JNG.K!JMOLD;!SD@EK!JDFCNOD(G"!MNKNGM(@!DSH"G.DFS!CN.MD(;!GSSUG""R< <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<]X$

]<!NK.GJ"DK@!G!(FSTNMWNS(N!N(FKRK.NC!JR!JUD"ODSW!(FSSN(.DFSK!G(MFKK!K.FTNLDLNO!KRK.NCK<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<]X$

_<!MNHFMC!LNNMQMNTDNA!LMF(NKKNK!.F!KULLFM.!DS.NMODK(DL"DSGMR!WMGS.K<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<]Z$

^<!JG"GS(N!"GMWNQK(G"N!NHHFM.K!AD.@!KCG""NM!WMGS.!LMFPN(.K< <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<_`$

a<!DCLMFTN!DS.NMODK(DL"DSGMR!MNKNGM(@!GCFSW!.@N!]\!SD@!DSK.D.U.NK!GSO!(NS.NMK< <<<<<<<<<<<<<<_`$

V<!NOU(G.N;!NYLGSO;!GSO!KULLFM.!.@N!SNY.!WNSNMG.DFS!FH!(FSTNMWNS(N!MNKNGM(@NMK<<<<<<<<<<<_`$

(;%7!"1 )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))*3

Page 6: Mit white paper on convergence
Page 7: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ :!

! !

;*+/'8<1+3'*!

!

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b#3;!*::&%3*=)#!/#*)$/!4*%#<!A#!*),&!30,4',,!$/#!%&)#!&:!+&9#%25#2$!*+#240#,!02!*33%#,,02+!$/0,!4/*))#2+#!*23!1%&90302+!:'2302+!:&%!022&9*$09#!%#,#*%4/<!H02*))6;!7#!%#4&55#23!,$%*$#+0#,!:&%!#5=#3302+!4&29#%+#24#!70$/02!*+#240#,!)0B#!$/#!S*$0&2*)!D2,$0$'$#,!&:!@#*)$/!cSD@d;!7/04/!*05,!$&!&1$050b#!=*,04!%#,#*%4/;!051%&9#!/#*)$/!$#4/2&)&+6;!*23!:&,$#%!051&%$*2$!5#304*)!*39*24#,<!

Page 8: Mit white paper on convergence

=! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!

EF!B.&/.3&G!'(!)'*.&/0&*1&!

!

A/*$!#>*4$)6!0,!4&29#%+#24#e!A#!3#:02#!0$!*,!$/#!5#%+02+!&:!30,$024$!$#4/2&)&+0#,;!1%&4#,,02+!30,401)02#,;!&%!3#904#,!02$&!*!'20:0#3!7/&)#!$/*$!4%#*$#,!*!/&,$!&:!2#7!1*$/7*6,!*23!&11&%$'20$0#,<!D$!029&)9#,!$/#!4&502+!$&+#$/#%!&:!30::#%#2$!:0#)3,!&:!,$'3681*%$04')*%)6!#2+02##%02+;!1/6,04*)!,40#24#,;!*23!)0:#!,40#24#,8$/%&'+/!4&))*=&%*$0&2!*5&2+!%#,#*%4/!+%&'1,!*23!$/#!02$#+%*$0&2!&:!*11%&*4/#,!$/*$!7#%#!&%0+02*))6!90#7#3!*,!30,$024$!*23!1&$#2$0*))6!4&2$%*304$&%6<!!

A#!,##!4&29#%+#24#!*,!*!=)'#1%02$!:&%!022&9*$0&2<!G39*24#,!02!02:&%5*$0&2!$#4/2&)&+6;!5*$#%0*),;!05*+02+;!2*2&$#4/2&)&+6;!&1$04,;!*23!?'*2$'5!1/6,04,;!4&'1)#3!70$/!*39*24#,!02!4&51'$02+;!5&3#)02+;!*23!,05')*$0&2;!/*9#!*)%#*36!$%*2,:&%5#3!1/6,04*)!,40#24#<!./#6!*%#!2&7!=#+02202+!$&!$%*2,:&%5!)0:#!,40#24#!*,!7#))<!(&29#%+#24#!$*B#,!$/#!$#4/204*)!$&&),;!*,!7#))!*,!$/#!f30,401)02#3!3#,0+2!*11%&*4/g!$%*30$0&2*)!$&!#2+02##%02+!*23!1/6,04,;!*23!*11)0#,!$/#5!$&!)0:#!,40#24#!%#,#*%4/<!J'$!4&29#%+#24#!0,!2&$!*!&2#Q7*6!,$%##$h!=0&)&+04*)!5&3#),!*%#!,05')$*2#&',)6!$%*2,:&%502+!#2+02##%02+!*23!1/6,04*)!,40#24#<!G39*24#,!02!=0&:'#),;!=0&5*$#%0*),;!*23!90%*)!,#):Q*,,#5=)6!*%#!i',$!*!:#7!#>*51)#,!&:!$/0,!%#401%&4*)!%#)*$0&2,/01<!

./#!4&29#%+#24#!%#9&)'$0&2!0,!*!1*%*30+5!,/0:$;!='$!2&$!i',$;!02!./&5*,!I'/2E,!$#%5,;!*!1*%*30+5!,/0:$!S&)"&/!*!30,401)02#<=!(&29#%+#24#!5#*2,!*!=%&*3!

%#$/02B02+!&:!/&7!*))!,40#2$0:04!%#,#*%4/!4*2!=#!4&23'4$#3;!,&!$/*$!7#!4*10$*)0b#!&2!3$'3/7#!&:!B2&7)#3+#!=*,#,;!:%&5!504%&=0&)&+6!$&!4&51'$#%!,40#24#!$&!#2+02##%02+!3#,0+2<!D2!&$/#%!7&%3,;!$/#!4&29#%+#24#!%#9&)'$0&2!3&#,!2&$!%#,$!&2!*!1*%$04')*%!,40#2$0:04!*39*24#!='$!&2!*!2#7!02$#+%*$#3!*11%&*4/!:&%!*4/0#902+!*39*24#,<!!

G!5*i&%!=#2#:040*%6!&:!4&29#%+#24#!70))!=#!=0&5#30402#;!*,!02$#%30,401)02*%6!%#,#*%4/!#2/*24#,!&'%!#>0,$02+!B2&7)#3+#!*23!)#*3,!$&!2#7!5#304*)!$%#*$5#2$,<!H%&5!$/#!02:',0&2!&:!30::#%#2$!03#*,!*23!=*4B+%&'23!3#,0+2,;!%#,#*%4/#%,!*%#!*)%#*36!5*B02+!#>40$02+!30,4&9#%0#,82#7!3%'+!3#)09#%6!5#4/*20,5,!*$!$/#!2*2&,4*)#;!051%&9#3!4/#504*)!*23!30,#*,#!,#2,02+;!2#7!1%#304$09#!4&51'$#%!5&3#),!&:!30,#*,#;!2#7!4*1*=0)0$0#,!$&!5&30:6!+#2#$04!30,&%3#%,;!*23!4&,$Q#::#4$09#!=0&5#$%04!*2*)6,0,!:&%!1#%,&2*)0b#3!5#30402#<!J6!%#4&+20b02+!4&29#%+#24#!*,!*!$%*2,:&%5*$09#!$%#23;!7#!/&1#!$&!&::#%!*!2#7!90,0&2!:&%!$/#!:'$'%#!*23!='0)3!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=$5."%*/$>?$R-.(1!"#$!%&'()&('$!*+!%),$-&,+,)!.$/*0(&,*-12$H#N$&N?$SD.'2*7"9$T('K&#/'+P$")$D.'2*7"$U#&//1$

=FFBV?$

HI&!,&&!1'*.&/0&*1&!#,!#!$%<&J/3*+!

('/!3**'.#+3'*FK!

Page 9: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ L!

! !*7*%#2#,,!&:!2#7!&11&%$'20$0#,!:&%!$/#!U20$#3!K$*$#,!$&!4&2$02'#!)#*302+!$/#!7&%)3!02!=0&5#304*)!022&9*$0&2<!

./&'+/$!)#*3#%,!*$!$/#!S*$0&2*)!G4*3#50#,!&:!K40#24#,!*23!#),#7/#%#!02!$/#!*35020,$%*$0&2!*%#!4&29#202+!,$'36!1*2#),!*23!7&%B,/&1,!$&!30,4',,!$/#!02$#%,#4$0&2!&:!,40#2$0:04!30,401)02#,;;!='$!5&%#!5',$!=#!3&2#<!J#4*',#!&:!0$,!4%&,,Q30,401)02*%6!2*$'%#;!4&29#%+#24#!4/*))#2+#,!$/#!/0,$&%04!,$%'4$'%#!&:!'209#%,0$0#,;!7/04/!*%#!&%+*20b#3!02$&!3#1*%$5#2$,!:&4',02+!&2!30,4%#$#!30,401)02#,<!H'%$/#%5&%#;!4&29#%+#24#Q,$6)#!%#,#*%4/!3&#,!2&$!:0$!2#*$)6!70$/02!$/#!:'2302+!4*$#+&%0#,!&:!$/#!:#3#%*)!%#,#*%4/Q,'11&%$!*+#240#,;!2&%!3&#,!0$!*)0+2!2#*$)6!70$/!$/#!50,,0&2,!&:!$/#,#!%#,#*%4/!02,$0$'$#,<!D$!0,!051#%*$09#!$/*$!7#!4&2$02'#!#::&%$,!$&!&9#%4&5#!$/0,!1%&=)#5!&:!f,$&9#101#,g!*23!3#9#)&1!=&$/!2#7!029#,$5#2$!5#4/*20,5,!*23!2#7!5&3#),!:&%!&%+*20b*$0&2*)!4&))*=&%*$0&2<!

G)%#*36;!$/#!1',/!$&!7&%B!*4%&,,!30,401)02#,!0,!#,4*)*$02+!70$/02!$/#!%#,#*%4/!4&55'20$6!*23!4&502+!$&!$/#!*$$#2$0&2!&:!,40#24#!1&)046!5*B#%,;!7/&!*%#!5&902+!$/#!4&29#%,*$0&2!=#6&23!$/#!02$#+%*$0&2!&:!30,401)02#,!*23!4*))02+!:&%!4&29#%+#24#!$&!=#!#5=#33#3!02$&!G5#%04*E,!MjO!,6,$#5<!H&%!02,$*24#;!02!/0,!%#5*%B,!*$!$/#!*22'*)!5##$02+!&:!$/#!S*$0&2*)!G4*3#56!&:!K40#24#,!02!]``Z;!L%#,03#2$!F=*5*!%#:#%%#3!$&!$/#!9*,$!1&$#2$0*)!$/*$!*!4%&,,Q4'$$02+!:#3#%*)!020$0*$09#!&2!4&29#%+#24#!4&')3!/*9#!:&%!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/-!

D2!=0&5#30402#;!7#!4*2!/*%2#,,!$/#!/0,$&%04!4&29#%+#24#!=#$7##2!)0:#!,40#24#,!*23!1/6,04*)!,40#24#,!$/*$k,!'23#%7*6!$&3*6h!'23#%$*B02+!1'=)04!1%&i#4$,802!$/#!,10%0$!&:!$/#!@'5*2!W#2&5#!L%&i#4$8$&!4%#*$#!3*$*!*23!4*1*=0)0$0#,!$/*$!:'#)!30,4&9#%0#,!02!$#2,!&:!$/&',*23,!&:!)*=&%*$&%0#,h!*23!03#2$0:602+!*23!&9#%4&502+!,40#2$0:04!*23!='%#*'4%*$04!=*%%0#%,!$&!%*103)6!$%*2,)*$02+!,40#2$0:04!=%#*B$/%&'+/,!02$&!30*+2&,$04,!*23!$/#%*1#'$04,!$/*$!,#%9#!1*$0#2$,<H!

K050)*%)6;!$7&!5#5=#%,!&:!$/#!L%#,03#2$k,!(&'240)!&:!G390,&%,!&2!K40#24#!*23!.#4/2&)&+6!7%&$#!02!]`[`!*=&'$!$/#!5#%+02+!&:!02:&%5*$0&2!$#4/2&)&+6;!=0&$#4/2&)&+6;!*23!2*2&$#4/2&)&+6-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;$>&&$@*+'"(*J$W&/&*#2.$D"-(2'J$D"%%'++&&$"($X'"%"J&2-J*#$3*+&#'*J/$*(N$U#"2&//&/1$3-14,'$5!67!8,*0*97:!

;'*<!=*0$)(0$1!&*!=>&$',>01!&*!=>)#,-$1$S6*/.'(7+"(1$CD9$@*+'"(*J$Q2*N&%'&/$U#&//1$;<<:VY$@*+'"(*J$

W&/&*#2.$D"-(2'J$D"%%'++&&$"($!"#&)#"(+/$")$>2'&(2&$*+$+.&$4(+&#)*2&$")$U.P/'2*J$*(N$Z')&$>2'&(2&/1!

.$1$>')#!>&!&#$!3-&$'1$)&,*-!*+!&#$!?#71,)>0!>-5!@,+$!%),$-)$1$S6*/.'(7+"(1$CD9$@*+'"(*J$Q2*N&%'&/$U#&//VY$

*(N$@*+'"(*J$W&/&*#2.$D"-(2'J$D"%%'++&&$"($*$@&M$X'"J"7P$)"#$+.&$;=/+$D&(+-#P1$"#$!.*0$!*+!@,+$!%),$-)$1!

,-!"'>-1+*'<,-9!A<$',)>B1!;(&('$:!%(<<>'7!*+!>!C*'D1#*4$S6*/.'(7+"(1$CD9$@*+'"(*J$Q2*N&%'&/$U#&//1$

;<<FV1$.++09LL,""[/?(*0?&N-L"0&(,""[?0.0\#&2"#N]'N^=;_F;?!

H$X*#*2[$8,*%*1$`W&%*#[/$,P$+.&$U#&/'N&(+$*+$+.&$@*+'"(*J$Q2*N&%P$")$>2'&(2&/$Q((-*J$3&&+'(71a$

6*/.'(7+"(1$CD1$Q0#'J$;E1$;<<F1$.++09LLMMM?M.'+&."-/&?7"KL+.&]0#&//]"))'2&LW&%*#[/b,Pb+.&b

U#&/'N&(+b*+b+.&b@*+'"(*JbQ2*N&%Pb")b>2'&(2&/bQ((-*Jb3&&+'(7L?!

Page 10: Mit white paper on convergence

M! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!N*4/!&:!$/#,#!%#,#*%4/!:0#)3,!/*,!$/#!1&$#2$0*)!$&!#2*=)#!*!7#*)$/!&:!022&9*$09#!*39*24#,!02!5#30402#;!#2#%+6!1%&3'4$0&2;!2*$0&2*)!,#4'%0$6;!*+%04')$'%#;!*#%&,1*4#;!5*2':*4$'%02+;!*23!,',$*02*=)#!#290%&25#2$,8*39*24#,!$/*$!4*2!02!$'%2!/#)1!4%#*$#!i&=,;!024%#*,#!$/#!2*$0&2E,!+%&,,!3&5#,$04!1%&3'4$!cWOLd;!*23!#2/*24#!?'*)0$6!&:!)0:#<!D2!4&5=02*$0&2;!$/%&'+/!7/*$!,&5#!/*9#!4*))#3!$/#!2*2&Q=0&Q02:&!4&29#%+#24#;!$/#!1&$#2$0*)!:&%!$/#,#!:0#)3,!$&!$%*2,:&%5!,&40#$6!0,!#9#2!+%#*$#%<I!!

./#!051*4$!&:!4&29#%+#24#!70))!2&$!=#!)050$#3!$&!5#30402#h!&$/#%!,40#2$0:04!*%#*,!,$*23!$&!=#2#:0$!*,!7#))<!G2!051&%$*2$!%#1&%$!=6!$/#!S*$0&2*)!G4*3#56!&:!K40#24#,!,'++#,$,!$/*$!4&29#%+#24#!4*2!60#)3!4%0$04*)!*39*24#,!02!*!=%&*3!*%%*6!&:!,#4$&%,;!024)'302+!#2#%+6;!:&&3;!4)05*$#;!*23!7*$#%<_!D2!$/0,!7/0$#!1*1#%;!/&7#9#%;!7#!:&4',!&2!$/#!*11)04*$0&2!&:!4&29#%+#24#!02!/#*)$/!%#,#*%4/!=#4*',#!7#!=#)0#9#!$/*$!$/0,!:0#)3!0,!%01#!:&%!2#7!30,4&9#%0#,!*23!4*2!1&7#%:'))6!3#5&2,$%*$#!$/#!=#2#:0$,!&:!4&29#%+#24#<!!

?&1&*+!N3'O&831#%!?&.'%<+3'*,!

./#%#!/*9#!=##2!$7&!3%*5*$04!3#9#)&15#2$,!02!)0:#!,40#24#!%#,#*%4/!02!$/#!)*,$!a`!6#*%,8$/#!5&)#4')*%!*23!4#))')*%!=0&)&+6!%#9&)'$0&2!*23!$/#!+#2&504,!%#9&)'$0&2<!./#,#!$7&!%#9&)'$0&2,!1*9#3!$/#!7*6!:&%!$/#!4&29#%+#24#!%#9&)'$0&2!2&7!$*B02+!,/*1#<!A#!=#)0#9#!$/*$!4&5=0202+!B2&7)#3+#!&:!#2+02##%02+!*23!1/6,04*)!,40#24#!70$/!)0:#!,40#24#!#>1#%$0,#!70))!='0)3!&2!%#4#2$!*39*24#,!02!5&)#4')*%!*23!4#))')*%!=0&)&+6!*23!+#2&504,!*23!1%&3'4#!2#7!=%#*B$/%&'+/,<!F:!4&'%,#;!7#!*%#!2&$!,'++#,$02+!$/*$!7#!/*9#!%#*4/#3!$/#!1022*4)#!&:!%#,#*%4/!02!5&)#4')*%!*23!4#))')*%!=0&)&+6!&%!+#2&504,h!$/#%#!0,!,$0))!5'4/!5&%#!$&!=#!30,4&9#%#3<!@&7#9#%;!4&29#%+#24#!&::#%,!*2!#>40$02+!&11&%$'20$6!$&!#2%04/!1%#,#2$!*23!:'$'%#!%#,#*%4/!02!$/#,#!:0#)3,8*23!02!&$/#%,<!!

"-&!P3/,+!?&.'%<+3'*Q!R'%&1<%#/!#*8!)&%%<%#/!N3'%'07!!

./#!:0%,$!=0&)&+04*)Q,40#24#!%#9&)'$0&2!029&)9#3!$/#!',#!&:!5&)#4')*%!*23!4#))')*%!=0&)&+6!$&!'23#%,$*23!4#)),!*23!30,#*,#,<!./0,!%#9&)'$0&2!=#+*2!70$/!$/#!30,4&9#%6!&:!$/#!,$%'4$'%#!&:!OSG!=6!P*5#,!O<!A*$,&2!*23!H%*240,!(%04B!02![Za_!*23!$/#!=0%$/!&:!5&)#4')*%!=0&)&+6<!D2!$/#!#*%)6![Z\`,;!$/0,!)#3!$&!$/#!3#9#)&15#2$!&:!+#2#$04!#2+02##%02+84&5=0202+!OSG!:%&5!30::#%#2$!&%+*20,5,!$&!1%&3'4#!2#7!1%&3'4$,!*23!1%&4#,,#,<!"#*3#%,!02!$/#!:0#)3;!)0B#!K*)9*3&%!"'%0*;!?'04B)6!='0)$!&2!$/0,!+*5#Q

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I$>.'#J&P$Q(($c*2[/"($*(N$A#'2$>2.%'N+1$aU"J'/.'(7$5&2.("J"7Pd/$e"JN&($5#'*(7J&1a$8))'2&$")$>2'&(2&$*(N$

5&2.("J"7P$U"J'2P$,J"71$c-(&$=_1$;<=<1$.++09LLMMM?M.'+&."-/&?7"KL,J"7L;<=<L<BL=_L0"J'/.'(7b

+&2.("J"7Pb/b7"JN&(b+#'*(7J&?!

_$@*+'"(*J$W&/&*#2.$D"-(2'J$")$+.&$@*+'"(*J$Q2*N&%'&/?$A!E$F!8,*0*97!+*'!&#$!GH1&!I$-&('7$S6*/.'(7+"(1$

CD9$@*+'"(*J$Q2*N&%'&/$U#&//1$;<<FV1$.++09LLMMM?(*0?&N-L"0&(,""[?0.0\#&2"#N]'N^=;EBI?$!"#$*$

#&J*+&N$K'N&"1$/&&$.++09LLMMM?P"-+-,&?2"%LM*+2.\K^X8cf.Q3!C8M?!

Page 11: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ S!

! !4/*2+02+!30,4&9#%6!*23!,$*%$#3!30,#*,#Q,1#40:04!%#,#*%4/!4#2$#%,!*$!'209#%,0$0#,!$&!*11)6!$/#!2#7!'23#%,$*2302+!&:!$/#!,$%'4$'%#!&:!90%',#,!*23!4*24#%&',!4#)),<$!

M#,#*%4/#%,!4&24)'3#3!$/*$!$/#6!4&')3!$%')6!'23#%,$*23!30,#*,#!&2)6!0:!$/#6!'23#%,$&&3!0$!*$!$/#!5&)#4')*%!)#9#)!02,03#!$/#!4#))<!./#!2#7!:0#)3!&:!5&)#4')*%!*23!4#))!=0&)&+6!*))&7#3!%#,#*%4/#%,!$&!1%&=#!$/#!022#%!7&%B02+,!&:!30,#*,#3!4#)),<!J6!3&02+!,&;!$/#6!5*3#!%#5*%B*=)#!*39*24#,!02!'23#%,$*2302+!4*24#%!*23!&$/#%!30,#*,#,<!H'2302+!*23!&$/#%!,'11&%$!4*5#!:%&5!$/#!+&9#%25#2$h!02![Z\^!$/#!SD@E,!S*$0&2*)!(*24#%!D2,$0$'$#!cS(Dd!,#$!'1!=*,04!,40#24#!4#2$#%,!:&%!4*24#%!%#,#*%4/!c((M,d!7/#%#!#>1#%$,!02!5&)#4')*%!=0&)&+6;!055'2&)&+6;!4#))!=0&)&+6;!90%&)&+6;!/'5*2!+#2#$04,;!*23!4/#504*)!4*%402&+#2#,0,!4&')3!4&))*=&%*$#!70$/!4*24#%!=0&)&+0,$,;!4)0204*)!&24&)&+0,$,;!1%#9#2$0&2!#>1#%$,;!*23!,'%+#&2,<!D2!4%#*$02+!$/#!((M,;!S(D!%#4&+20b#3!$/*$!2#7!,40#2$0:04!*39*24#,!%#?'0%#!022&9*$09#!02,$0$'$0&2*)!,'11&%$!5#4/*20,5,<!

K&&2!#2&'+/;!#2$%#1%#2#'%,!)*'24/#3!$/#!=0&$#4/2&)&+6!023',$%6!=6!:&'2302+!4&51*20#,!,'4/!*,!W#2#2$#4/;!J0&+#2;!*23!G5+#2;!7/#%#!'209#%,0$6Q$%*02#3!%#,#*%4/#%,!4&')3!$%*2,)*$#!$/#!2#7!$#4/2&)&+6!02$&!1%&3'4$,<!./#!=0&$#4/!023',$%6!/*,!+#2#%*$#3!$%#*$5#2$,!:&%!,&5#!&:!$/#!5&,$!3%#*3:')!/'5*2!30,#*,#,;!,'4/!*,!4*24#%;!5')$01)#!,4)#%&,0,;!*23!/#1*$0$0,;!*23!4%#*$#3!$#2,!&:!$/&',*23,!&:!i&=,<!

"-&!4&1'*8!?&.'%<+3'*Q!T&*'O31,!!

./#!,#4&23!5*i&%!%#9&)'$0&2!02!)0:#!,40#24#!%#,#*%4/!02!%#4#2$!3#4*3#,!0,!$/#!+#2&504!%#9&)'$0&2<!D$!#24&51*,,#,!*!3%09#!$&!,$'36!*2!&%+*20,5E,!#2$0%#!+#2&5#8%#*302+!$/#!=*,04!OSG!,#?'#24#;!03#2$0:602+!$/#!1/6,04*)!)&4*$0&2!&:!30,4%#$#!+#2#,;!*23!'23#%,$*2302+!02$%*+#2&504!1/#2&5#2*<!./0,!%#9&)'$0&2!+&$!&::!$/#!+%&'23!7/#2!$/#!O#1*%$5#2$!&:!N2#%+6!=#+*2!:'2302+!1%&i#4$,!$&!*11)6!,'1#%4&51'$02+!$&!+#2#$04,!%#,#*%4/<!G,!$05#!7#2$!&2;!+#2&5#!%#,#*%4/!,/0:$#3!$&!SD@<!

SD@!1%&+%#,,!&2!,#?'#2402+!$/#!/'5*2!+#2&5#!=#+*2!70$/!+#2#$04!*23!1/6,04*)!5*1102+!*23!,6,$#5*$04!OSG!,#?'#2402+<!L%&+%#,,!*44#)#%*$#3!+%#*$)6!7/#2!%#,#*%4/#%,!02$%&3'4#3!:*,$#%!02,$%'5#2$*$0&2!*23!4&51'$#%!$#4/20?'#,!$/*$!*))&7#3!,#?'#2402+!&:!$/#!+#2&5#!02!*!5'4/!,/&%$#%!$05#!:%*5#<!./0,!02!$'%2!,1*%B#3!&2#!&:!$/#!5&,$!4%#*$09#!4&51#$0$0&2,!02!,40#24#!/0,$&%6;!*,!SD@E,!@'5*2!W#2&5#!L%&i#4$;!)#3!=6!H%*240,!(&))02,!cL%#,03#2$!F=*5*E,!)*$#%!4/&04#!:&%!SD@!30%#4$&%d;!*23!(#)#%*E,!$#*5;!)#3!=6!(%*0+!T#2$#%;!90#3!$&!*3*1$!$/#!2#7!$#4/2&)&+6!*23!4&5=02#!0$!70$/!1%#90&',!5*1102+!%#,')$,<!./#!$7&!$#*5,!#9#2$'*))6!*22&'24#3!,'44#,,!i&02$)6;!70$/!1*%*))#)!/'5*2!+#2&5#!5*1,!1%02$#3!&2!$/#!,*5#!3*6!02!E3).'#!*23!;2&#/2#!5*+*b02#,;!1%&90302+!*2!#2&%5&',)6!',#:')!2#7!$&&)!,#$!:&%!'23#%,$*2302+!$/#!=*,0,!&:!/'5*2!30,#*,#<!!

H?&,&#/1-&/,!1'*1%<8&8!+-#+!+-&7!

1'<%8!+/<%7!<*8&/,+#*8!83,&#,&!'*%7!

3(!+-&7!<*8&/,+''8!3+!#+!+-&!

O'%&1<%#/!%&.&%!3*,38&!+-&!1&%%FK!

Page 12: Mit white paper on convergence

U! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!./#!*4/0#9#5#2$,!02!+#2&5#!5*1102+!*),&!/#%*)3#3!*!2#7!#%*!02!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/<!D:!$/#!5&)#4')*%!=0&)&+6!%#9&)'$0&2!#2*=)#3!30,#*,#,!$&!=#!'23#%,$&&3!*$!$/#!5&)#4')*%;!f/*%37*%#g!)#9#)!02,03#!$/#!4#));!$/#!+#2&504,!%#9&)'$0&2!#2*=)#3!*2!'23#%,$*2302+!&:!$/#!f,&:$7*%#g!$/*$!3%09#,!4#))!1%&4#,,#,<!!

./#!*39*24#,!02!+#2&504!,40#24#!/*9#!5*3#!0$!1&,,0=)#!$&!03#2$0:6!$/#!+#2#$04!:&'23*$0&2,!&:!5*26!30,#*,#,;!7/04/!0,!$/#!:0%,$!,$#1!02!3#9#)&102+!2#7!$%#*$5#2$,<!W#2#$04!5*1102+!0,!*),&!4%0$04*)!$&!3#9#)&102+!1#%,&2*)0b#3!5#30402#8$%#*$02+!1*$0#2$,!70$/!1%#9#2$09#!*23!4'%*$09#!$/#%*10#,!$*0)&%#3!$&!$/#0%!'20?'#!+#2#$04!5*B#'1!*23!,/&72!$&!=#!#::#4$09#!:&%!$/#0%!,1#40:04!30,#*,#!,'=$61#;!$/#%#=6!*9&0302+!4&,$)6;!02#::#4$09#!5#304*$0&2!*23!/*%5:')!,03#!#::#4$,<!

"-&!"-3/8!?&.'%<+3'*!V!)'*.&/0&*1&!

C'4/!&:!$/#!#>40$02+!,40#2$0:04!%#,#*%4/!2&7!&44'%%02+!029&)9#,!4&5=0202+!5&)#4')*%!*23!4#))')*%!=0&)&+6!70$/!+#2&504,;!#2+02##%02+;!*23!B2&7)#3+#!&:!$/#!1/6,04*)!,40#24#,<!G,!7#!*%#!=#+02202+!$&!,##;!4&29#%+#24#!$/',!4&2,$0$'$#,!*!$/0%3!+%#*$!%#9&)'$0&2!02!)0:#!,40#24#,!*23!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/<!!

./0,!0))',$%*$0&2!/#)1,!$&!90#7!$/#,#!$/%##!%#9&)'$0&2,!&9#%!$05#<!

G,!*)%#*36!2&$#3;!4&29#%+#24#!3&#,!2&$!,051)6!029&)9#!*!$%*2,:#%!&:!$&&)!,#$,!:%&5!&2#!,40#24#!$&!*2&$/#%h!:'23*5#2$*))6!30::#%#2$!4&24#1$'*)!*11%&*4/#,!:%&5!1/6,04*)!,40#24#!*23!#2+02##%02+!*%#!051&%$#3!02$&!=0&)&+04*)!%#,#*%4/;!7/0)#!)0:#!,40#24#E,!'23#%,$*2302+!&:!4&51)#>!#9&)'$0&2*%6!,6,$#5,!0,!%#401%&4*))6!02:)'#2402+!

!

0=>?@A,+B,.05#)02#!/0+/)0+/$02+!,&5#!#9#2$,!%#)*$#3!$&!$/#!5&)#4')*%!=0&)&+6;!+#2&504,;!*23!4&29#%+#24#!%#9&)'$0&2,<!

Page 13: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ W!

! !1/6,04*)!,40#24#!*23!#2+02##%02+<!(&29#%+#24#!0,!$/#!%#,')$!&:!$%'#!02$#))#4$'*)!4%&,,Q1&))02*$0&2<!!

G!2'5=#%!&:!'209#%,0$6Q/&',#3!4#2$#%,!/*9#!*)%#*36!#5#%+#3!*,!,/&74*,#,!&:!4&29#%+#24#;!1%&90302+!$/#!02$#))#4$'*)!*23!%#,#*%4/!,1*4#!:&%!)0:#!,40#2$0,$,!$&!02$#%*4$!*23!4&))*=&%*$#!70$/!1/6,04*)!,40#2$0,$,!*23!#2+02##%,<!SD@!/*,!=##2!4%0$04*)!$&!$/0,!#::&%$;!#,1#40*))6!02!4*24#%!%#,#*%4/<!H&%!#>*51)#;!$/#!S*$0&2*)!(*24#%!D2,$0$'$#!cS(Dd!4%#*$#3!#0+/$!(#2$#%,!&:!(*24#%!S*2&$#4/2&)&+6!N>4#))#24#!:&%!02$#%30,401)02*%6!*23!4%&,,Q'209#%,0$6!1%&i#4$,<!./#,#!4#2$#%,!*%#!1'%,'02+!*!9*%0#$6!&:!*4$090$0#,;!024)'302+!3#9#)&102+!2*2&,4*)#!3#904#,!:&%!$*%+#$#3!3%'+!3#)09#%6;!:&%!30*+2&,$04,;!:&%!2&2029*,09#!05*+02+;!*23!:&%!5&)#4')*%!,#2,02+!&:!4*24#%,;!70$/!*2!#51/*,0,!&2!1%&,$*$#;!=%*02;!)'2+;!&9*%0*2;!*23!4&)&2!4*24#%,<!!

S(D!*),&!4%#*$#3!202#!D2$#+%*$09#!(*24#%!J0&)&+6!L%&+%*5!(#2$#%,!$/%&'+/&'$!$/#!4&'2$%6!$/*$!#>#51)0:6!4&29#%+#24#<!./#,#!4#2$#%,!*%#!1'%,'02+!*!,6,$#5,Q=0&)&+6!*11%&*4/!$&!*,4#%$*02!7/*$!$/#!5&,$!#::#4$09#!4#))!%#+')*$&%6!2&3#,!50+/$!=#!:&%!'23#%,$*2302+!*23!$%#*$02+!4*24#%<!./0,!7&%B!/*,!30%#4$!*11)04*$0&2!$&!03#2$0:602+!$/#!=#,$!30*+2&,$04!*23!3#)09#%6!$*%+#$,!:&%!$/#!2#7!2*2&$#4/2&)&+6!$&&),<!

F:!4&'%,#;!*11)602+!#2+02##%02+!$&!/#*)$/!0,!2&$!*!2&9#)!03#*<!./#!=0%$/!&:!$/#!YQ%*6!02![XZa;!:&%!#>*51)#;!+*9#!7*6!$&!*!%#9&)'$0&2!02!05*+02+!$/*$!)#3!$&!$/#!#)#4$%&4*%30&+%*1/!02!$/#!#*%)6![Z``,;!:&))&7#3!=6!4&51'$#%0b#3!*>0*)!$&5&+%*1/6!c4&55&2)6!B2&7!*,!$/#!(G.!,4*2d!02!$/#![Z\`,;!*23!$/#!:0%,$!4&55#%40*)!CMD!c5*+2#$04!%#,&2*24#!05*+02+d!,4*22#%!02!$/#![ZX`,<!./#,#!029#2$0&2,!%#?'0%#3!$/#!5#%+02+!&:!5')$01)#!30,401)02#,<!@&7#9#%;!*!4&24#2$%*$#3!:&4',!&2!4&29#%+#24#!4*2!,1'%!#9#2!5&%#!022&9*$0&2<!T0*=)#!4&55#%40*)!1%&3'4$,!/*9#!*)%#*36!3#9#)&1#3!:%&5!$/0,!*11%&*4/<!./#!*39*24#3!OSG!,#?'#24#%,!*%#!#>4#))#2$!#>*51)#,<!./#!2#7!D))'502*!+#2&5#!,#?'#24#%;!:&%!02,$*24#;!0,!/#)102+!$&!)&7#%!$/#!4&,$!&:!*!:'))!+#2&5#!,#?'#2402+!:%&5!=0))0&2,!&:!3&))*%,!c$/#!1%04#!$*+!7/#2!$/#!:0%,$!+#2&5#!7*,!5*11#3d!$&!'23#%!l[`;```<B!!C&%#!4&29#%+#24#Q,$6)#!%#,#*%4/!0,!*)%#*36!'23#%!7*6<!

9X#OJ%&,!'(!)'*.&/0&*1&!3*!N3'O&831#%!?&,&#/1-!

(&29#%+#24#!=%#*B$/%&'+/,!3#1#23!2&$!&2)6!&2!2#7!%#,#*%4/!02,$0$'$0&2,!7/#%#!30::#%#2$!30,401)02#,!4*2!:023!4&55&2!,1*4#;!='$!*),&!&2!4&))*=&%*$09#;!02$#%30,401)02*%6!%#,#*%4/!$#*5,!$/*$!&1#%*$#!70$/02!$/#5<!./#!7&%B!&:!,&5#!)#*302+!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/!$#*5,!0,!,'55*%0b#3!=#)&7!$&!1%&903#!4&24%#$#!0))',$%*$0&2,!&:!4&29#%+#24#!02!*4$0&2<!K#9#%*)!&:!$/#!4&29#%+#24#!#>*51)#,!*%#!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

B$`@&M$4JJ-%'(*$e&("%&$>&g-&(2&#$C#*%*+'2*JJP$>J*/.&/$D"/+/1$5'%&1a$"(J'(&$*#+'2J&$*+$>&&['(7$QJ0.*1$c*(?$

=B1$;<=<1$.++09LL/&&['(7*J0.*?2"%L*#+'2J&L=:;FBF?!

H)'*.&/0&*1&!3,!+-&!/&,<%+!'(!+/<&!

3*+&%%&1+<#%!1/',,YJ'%%3*#+3'*FK!

Page 14: Mit white paper on convergence

EZ! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!3%*72!:%&5!CD.!=#4*',#!7#!*%#!5&,$!:*50)0*%!70$/!$/#5;!='$!4&51*%*=)#!%#,#*%4/!0,!,$*%$02+!$&!#9&)9#!*$!5*26!%#,#*%4/!4#2$#%,<!!

)'OJ<+#+3'*#%!N3'%'07!('/!;OO<*&!?&,J'*,&!

632T7',./40!G39*24#,!02!4&51'$*$0&2*)!,05')*$0&2!*23!5&3#)02+!*2*)6,0,!*4/0#9#3!$/%&'+/!,'1#%4&51'$02+!&1#2#3!$/#!3&&%!$&!$/#!+#2&504,!%#9&)'$0&2<!./#!3#9#)&102+!:0#)3!&:!4&51'$*$0&2*)!=0&)&+6!4&5=02#,!4&51'$#%!,40#24#;!1/6,04,;!*23!#2+02##%02+!70$/!5&)#4')*%!*23!+#2#$04!=0&)&+6!$&!#)'403*$#!5#4/*20,$04!1%02401)#,!$/*$!4&')3!)#*3!$&!$/#!%*103!03#2$0:04*$0&2!&:!4*2303*$#!+#2#!*23!4#))')*%!$*%+#$,!:&%!2#7!$/#%*10#,<$

H&%!#>*51)#;!%#,#*%4/#%,!02!G%'1!(/*B%*=&%$6E,!)*=!*$!CD.!/*9#!',#3!$/#&%#$04*)!*23!4&51'$*$0&2*)!*11%&*4/#,!$&!'24&9#%!2#7!5#4/*20,$04!1%02401)#,!'23#%)602+!$/#!*3*1$09#!055'2#!%#,1&2,#!$&!1*$/&+#2,<\!J6!=%02+02+!,$*$0,$04*)!5#4/*204,!$&+#$/#%!70$/!#2+02##%02+!*2*)6,#,!&:!4/#504*)!B02#$04,!*23!+#2#$04;!=0&4/#504*);!*23!05*+02+!#>1#%05#2$,;!*,!7#))!*,!4)0204*)!3*$*;!(/*B%*=&%$6E,!$#*5!/*,!3#,4%0=#3!$/#!5&)#4')*%!5#4/*20,5,!'23#%)602+!/&7!.!)651/&46$#,!c#,,#2$0*)!:&%!*3*1$09#!055'20$6d!3#9#)&1;!3#$#4$;!*23!%#4&+20b#!$/#!5&)#4')*%!,0+2*$'%#,!&:!1*$/&+#2,!30,1)*6#3!&2!$/#!,'%:*4#!&:!&$/#%!4#)),<!./0,!%#,#*%4/!0,!%#9#*)02+!2#7!1%02401)#,!$/*$!+&9#%2!$/#!055'2#!%#,1&2,#!$&!@DT!*23!$/#!#5#%+#24#!&:!.!)651/&46$#Q5#30*$#3!*'$&055'2#!30,#*,#,<$

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i&%!051*4$!&2!#>1#%05#2$*)!4#))')*%!*23!5&)#4')*%!055'2&)&+6!*,!7#))<!

;O#03*0!"&1-*'%'07!+'!6/&.&*+!N%3*8*&,,!

632T7',./40$G39*24#,!02!=0&5#304*)!05*+02+!/*9#!*)%#*36!)#3!$&!=%#*B$/%&'+/,!02!$/#!7*6!30,#*,#,!*%#!30*+2&,#3!*23!$%#*$#3<!CMD,!*23!&$/#%!,4*2,!*%#!2&7!703#)6!',#3!$&!3#$#4$!9*%0&',!30,&%3#%,!*,!7#))!*,!4&55&2!=&2#!02i'%0#,;!*23!$/#6!1%&903#!3&4$&%,!70$/!1&7#%:')!2#7!$&&),!02!$/#!=*$$)#!*+*02,$!#6#!30,#*,#<!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

\!Q#-0$D.*[#*,"#+P$'/$*$0#")&//"#$")$2.&%'2*J$&(7'(&&#'(71$2.&%'/+#P1$*(N$,'"J"7'2*J$&(7'(&&#'(7$*+$345?$

!"#$N&+*'J/$*,"-+$.'/$J*,1$/&&$.++09LLM&,?%'+?&N-L*[27#"-0L?!

Page 15: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ EE!

! !J#4*',#!$#,$02+!$/#!#6#E,!%#$02*!=6!%#5&902+!$0,,'#!4*',#,!3*5*+#!$&!$/#!%#$02*;!)*,#%!05*+02+!/*,!=##2!#9&)902+!*,!*2!*)$#%2*$09#!7*6!$&!30*+2&,#!30,#*,#,!$/*$!4*',#!=)0232#,,<!@&7#9#%;!1*$0#2$,!4*2!B##1!$/#0%!#6#,!,$0))!:&%!)#,,!$/*2!*!,#4&2382&$!#2&'+/!$05#!:&%!#>0,$02+!)*,#%,!$&!5#*,'%#!#*%)6!&2,#$!&:!30,#*,#<!D2!$/#![ZZ`,;!%#,#*%4/#%,!3#9#)&1#3!&1$04*)!4&/#%#24#!$&5&+%*1/6!cF(.d;!*!2#7!7*6!$&!,4*2!)*,#%,!=*4B!*23!:&%$/!*$!/0+/!,1##3,<!D2!]``\;!P*5#,!H'i05&$&E,!%#,#*%4/!+%&'1!*$!CD.!4%#*$#3!2#7!F(.!,4*2202+!$#4/2&)&+6!$/*$!4&')3!%#4&%3!]_V;```!)02#,!1#%!,#4&23;!*!,1##3![`!$05#,!:*,$#%!$/*2!7*,!1%#90&',)6!1&,,0=)#<:!./0,!2#7!5#$/&3!4&5=02#,!$7&Q305#2,0&2*)!4%&,,Q,#4$0&2*)!05*+#,!&:!$/#!%#$02*!$&!:&%5!*!/0+/)6!1%#40,#!$/%##Q305#2,0&2*)!104$'%#!&:!$/#!#6#<!./0,!$#4/2&)&+6!5*6!=#4&5#!*!4%0$04*)!2#7!30*+2&,$04!$&&)!:&%!#6#!30,#*,#,;!*,!051&%$*2$!*,!')$%*,&'23!0,!:&%!&$/#%!:0#)3,<!

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

D#*'+&1-*'%'07!('/!"#/0&+&8!)-&O'+-&/#J7!@&%3.&/7!

632T7',./40$M#,#*%4/#%,!/*9#!=#+'2!$&!',#!2*2&1*%$04)#,!$&!$%*2,1&%$!$05#Q%#)#*,#!*2$04*24#%!3%'+,!30%#4$)6!$&!4*24#%&',!4#)),;!,'4/!*,!$/&,#!02!$/#!1%&,$*$#<!S*2&1*%$04)#,;!#*4/!*!$026!:%*4$0&2!&:!$/#!,0b#!&:!*!/'5*2!4#))!*23!#2+02##%#3!$&!=#!*44#1$#3!=6!4#%$*02!4#)),!70$/02!$/#!=&36;!4*2!3#)09#%!,$%&2+!3&,#,!&:!$/#%*1#'$04,!$&!*!,1#40:04!)&4*$0&2<!G!$#*5!&:!CD.!%#,#*%4/#%,!'23#%!H%*24#,4&!K$#))*440!*23!O*%%#))!D%902#!/*,!3#5&2,$%*$#3!$/#!#2+02##%02+!&:!2*2&1*%$04)#,!02$&!/&502+!3#904#,!&%!f,5*%$!=&5=,g!$/*$!051%&9#!3%'+!3#)09#%6!=6!$*%+#$02+!&2)6!4*24#%&',!4#)),<F!!

./#%#!*%#!,#9#%*)!,0+20:04*2$!4/*))#2+#,!70$/!$/0,!3%'+!3#)09#%6!,6,$#5<!H0%,$;!%#,#*%4/#%,!5',$!0,&)*$#!/&502+!3#904#,;!,'4/!*,!MSG!5&)#4')#,!4*))#3!*1$*5#%,!$/*$!=023!,1#40:04*))6!$&!$'5&%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

X!c*%&/$!-h'%"+"$."JN/$*00"'(+%&(+/$'($345i/$AJ&2+#'2*J$A(7'(&&#'(7$*(N$D"%0-+&#$>2'&(2&$C&0*#+%&(+$

*(N$'($+.&$W&/&*#2.$Z*,"#*+"#P$")$AJ&2+#"('2/?$!"#$N&+*'J/$*,"-+$.'/$#&/&*#2.1$/&&$

.++09LLMMM?#J&?%'+?&N-LJ%%'L'(N&j?.+%$*(N$.++09LLMMM?#J&?%'+?&N-L8kAL?!

F!!#*(2&/2"$>+&JJ*22'$*(N$C*##&JJ$4#K'(&$*#&$%&%,&#/$")$+.&$)*2-J+P$'($345i/$C&0*#+%&(+$")$3*+&#'*J/$

>2'&(2&$*(N$A(7'(&&#'(7?!

H[!+&#O!\!-#,!8&O'*,+/#+&8!+-&!

&*03*&&/3*0!'(!*#*'J#/+31%&,!3*+'!-'O3*0!

8&.31&,!'/!],O#/+!$'O$,^!+-#+!3OJ/'.&!

8/<0!8&%3.&/7!$7!+#/0&+3*0!'*%7!!

1#*1&/'<,!1&%%,FK!

Page 16: Mit white paper on convergence

E_! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

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f,$%01#3g!2*2&1*%$04)#,;!4*2!?'04B)6!1#2#$%*$#!$/#!1%&$#4$09#!4#))!5#5=%*2#!70$/&'$!B0))02+!$/#!4#))<!

;&7/&@&23/2#0$G!5*i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

N/#3*!T/#(+,!('/!"/&#+3*0!N/#3*!@3,'/8&/,!#*8!;*`</7!

632T7',./40$./#!4&29#%+#24#!%#9&)'$0&2!0,!4%#*$02+!5*i&%!2#7!&11&%$'20$0#,!02!2#'%&,40#24#;!*!:0#)3!70$/02!$/#!)0:#!,40#24#,!$/*$!/*,!$%*30$0&2*))6!*$$%*4$#3!%#,#*%4/#%,!:%&5!309#%+#2$!=*4B+%&'23,!,'4/!*,!#)#4$%04*)!*23!4&51'$#%!#2+02##%02+!*23!4/#50,$%6<!A#!*%#!)#*%202+!$/*$!$/#!*3')$!=%*02!4&2,$*2$)6!*3*1$,!$&!4/*2+#,!02!,$05')0h!$/0,!1)*,$040$6!*11#*%,!2&$!&2)6!*,!)#*%202+!*23!5#5&%6;!='$!*),&!*,!362*504!4/*2+#,!02!02:&%5*$0&2!$%*2,50,,0&2!*23!1%&4#,,02+<!M#,#*%4/#%,!*%#!7&%B02+!$&!'23#%,$*23!)&2+Q$#%5!=%*02!1)*,$040$6!*23!,/&%$Q$#%5!362*504,!02!2#$7&%B,!&:!$/#!3#9#)&102+!*23!*3')$!4&%$#>!$&!'23#%,$*23!$/#!5#4/*20,5,!'23#%)602+!5*26!&:!$/#!2#'%&)&+04*)!30,#*,#,!*23!4&230$0&2,!$/*$!4/*))#2+#!$/#!2*$0&2E,!/#*)$/!4*%#!1%&903#%,<!!

M#,#*%4/#%,!,'4/!*,!CD.E,!C%0+*2B*!K'%=<!*%#!',02+!,$*$#Q&:Q$/#Q*%$!$#4/20?'#,!

3#9#)&1#3!:%&5!1/6,04*)!*23!#2+02##%02+!,40#24#,;!024)'302+-!

• $7&Q1/&$&2!*23!4&2:&4*)!504%&,4&16!&:!4#)),;!,62*1,#,;!*23!5&)#4')#,!02!90$%&!*23!02!909&!

• 5')$01)#Q#)#4$%&3#;!,02+)#Q'20$!%#4&%302+!02!$/#!4&%$#>!

• /0+/Q%#,&)'$0&2!&1$04*)!05*+02+!&:!*4$090$6!:%&5!*2!#>1*2,#!&:!4&%$#>!

• 7/&)#Q4#))!02$%*4#))')*%!%#4&%302+!02!,)04#,!*23!02!$/#!02$*4$!=%*02!

• 504%&*%%*6,!*23!4&51'$*$0&2*)!$&&),!$&!03#2$0:6!+#2#,!02!,1#40:04!$0,,'#,<!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[`!3#'7*([*$>-#$'/$*$0#")&//"#$")$(&-#"/2'&(2&$*+$345$*(N$.&*N$")$+.&$C&0*#+%&(+$")$X#*'($*(N$D"7('+'K&$

>2'&(2&/?$!"#$N&+*'J/$*,"-+$.'/$J*,1$/&&$.++09LLM&,?%'+?&N-L0'2"M&#L)*2-J+PL/-#?.+%J?!

Page 17: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ E:!

! !;&7/&@&23/2#0!M#4#2$!2#'%&,40#24#!%#,#*%4/!',02+!$#4/2&)&+0#,!*3*1$#3!:%&5!&$/#%!:0#)3,!/*,!,/#3!)0+/$!&2!$/#!$%'#!2*$'%#!&:!$/#!*3')$!=%*02<!J6!m%#70%02+m!$/#!3#9#)&102+!=%*02;!*23!=6!%#9#*)02+!%#5*%B*=)6!703#,1%#*3!4/*2+#,!02!$/#!*3')$!4&%$#>!3'%02+!)#*%202+;!%#,#*%4/!0,!3#5&2,$%*$02+!$/*$!$/#!=%*02!0,!:*%!5&%#!1)*,$04!*23!*3*1$*=)#!$/*2!7*,!1%#90&',)6!=#)0#9#3<!A0$/!$/0,!*330$0&2*)!02:&%5*$0&2;!%#,#*%4/#%,!*%#!1'%,'02+!022&9*$09#!%#,1&2,#,!$&!2#'%&)&+04*)!30,#*,#!*23!02i'%6;!024)'302+!$/#!3#9#)&15#2$!&:!2#$7&%B,!&:!2#'%&2,!+%&72!02!90$%&!$/*$!4&')3!&2#!3*6!,#%9#!*,!f=%*02!+%*:$,g!$&!$%#*$!904$05,!&:!$%*'5*$04!=%*02!02i'%6!&%!,$%&B#<!

N#1+&/3#%!6%#,+313+7!('/!"<O'/!@&+&1+3'*!#*8!@/<0!@&%3.&/7!

632T7',./40$G!5*i&%!4/*))#2+#!:&%!5#304*)!%#,#*%4/#%,!/*,!=##2!3#9#)&102+!3%'+,!$/*$!#::#4$09#)6!:0+/$!30,#*,#,!='$!3&!2&$!3*5*+#!/#*)$/6!$0,,'#,!*23!4#)),!02!1*$0#2$,<!K40#2$0,$,!/*9#!*$$#51$#3!$&!,&)9#!$/0,!1%&=)#5!:%&5!*!=0&)&+04*)!1#%,1#4$09#!=6!:&4',02+!&2!4#))!5*%B#%,!*23!055'2&)&+04*)!4&24#1$,<!G)$/&'+/!$/0,!*11%&*4/!/*,!/*3!,&5#!,'44#,,;!4&29#%+#24#Q3%09#2!5#$/&3,!$&!&1$050b#!3%'+!3#)09#%6!*%#!+*0202+!5&5#2$'5<!!

(/%0,!T&0+$E,!)*=!*$!$/#!U209#%,0$6!&:!(*)0:&%20*;!K*2!H%*240,4&;!,1#40*)0b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b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

;&7/&@&23/2#0!T&0+$E,!=*4$#%0*)!4%#*$0&2!0,!*!1%05#!#>*51)#!&:!4&29#%+#24#!02!7/04/!#2+02##%02+!1%02401)#,!*%#!*11)0#3!$&!*!=0&)&+04*)!,6,$#5<!./#!)*=!#,,#2$0*))6!4&10#3!$/#!,#2,&%!+#2#!02!&2#!=*4$#%0*)!,1#40#,!*23!02,#%$#3!0$!02!*2&$/#%<!./0,!#>1#%05#2$E,!1&$#2$0*)!:&%!3%'+!3#)09#%6!7&')3!%#?'0%#!#9#2!5&%#!4&))*=&%*$0&2!*4%&,,!$/#!30,401)02#,h!:&%!#>*51)#;!4/#50,$%6!7&')3!=#!%#?'0%#3!$&!4*)4')*$#!$/#!4&%%#4$!3&,*+#!&:!3%'+,!1#%!=*4$#%0'5<!J0&02:&%5*$04,!5*6!/#)1!03#2$0:6!=#$$#%!=*4$#%0*)!,1#40#,;!,#2,&%!+#2#,;!&%!*2$04*24#%!3%'+,!:&%!/'5*2!$/#%*1#'$04!',#;!*,!5&%#!02:&%5*$0&2!=#4&5#,!*9*0)*=)#<!U)$05*$#)6;!$/0,!=*4$#%0*)Q,#2,&%!3%'+!3#)09#%6!,6,$#5!7&')3!%#3'4#!$/#!,03#!#::#4$,!&:!4/#5&$/#%*16!*23!&$/#%!%0,B6!$%#*$5#2$,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

==$D.#'/$l"'7+$'/$*($*//"2'*+&$0#")&//"#$'($+.&$C&0*#+%&(+$")$U.*#%*2&-+'2*J$D.&%'/+#P$*+$5.&$T('K&#/'+P$

")$D*J')"#('*1$>*($!#*(2'/2"?$!"#$N&+*'J/$*,"-+$.'/$J*,1$/&&$.++09LLK"'7+J*,?-2/)?&N-?!

Page 18: Mit white paper on convergence

E=! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!$/*$!i#&1*%30b#!1*$0#2$,E!&9#%*))!/#*)$/!7/0)#!*$$*4B02+!$/#!4*24#%<!./#!1&$#2$0*)!5#304*)!=#2#:0$,!&:!$/0,!%#,#*%4/!3#5&2,$%*$#!$/#!%0,02+!2##3!$&!5*B#!4&29#%+#24#!*!1%0&%0$6!02!$/#!:'$'%#!&:!=0&)&+6<!

,3?D[!('/!+-&!>;A!A#113*&!

632T7',./40$D2$#%:#%02+!MSG!cMSG0d!0,!*!2*$'%*)!1%&4#,,!',#3!=6!&%+*20,5,!$&!$'%2!&::!&%!,0)#24#!$/#!#>1%#,,0&2!&:!4#%$*02!+#2#,!7/#2!$/#6!*%#!2&!)&2+#%!2##3#3<!M#,#*%4/#%,!/*9#!*)$#%#3!$/0,!2*$'%*)!1%&4#,,!,&!$/*$!,/&%$!02$#%:#%02+!MSG!c,0MSGd!4*2!=#!3#)09#%#3!$&!$/#!02,03#!&:!4#)),!$&!,0)#24#!$/#!+#2#,!*,,&40*$#3!70$/!$/#!1#%1#$'*$0&2!&:!30,#*,#,<!./#!*=0)0$6!$&!,0)#24#!+#2#,!02!5*55*)0*2!4#)),!$/%&'+/!MSG0!/*,!3%*5*$04*))6!#>1*23#3!$/#!1&,,0=0)0$0#,!:&%!+#2&$61#n1/#2&$61#!*2*)6,0,!02!4#))!=0&)&+6<!,0MSG,!/*9#!&9#%)*1102+!:'24$0&2,!70$/!504%&MSG,;!+#2#,!2&%5*))6!:&'23!02!5*55*)0*2!4#)),!$/*$;!7/#2!1*0%#3!=6!1*%$0*)!4&51)#5#2$*%0$6!$&!*2!5MSG;!1%#9#2$!1%&3'4$0&2!&:!$/#!#24&3#3!1%&$#02<!,0MSG!$*B#,!*39*2$*+#!&:!$/#!#>0,$02+!4#))')*%!504%&MSG!5*4/02#%6!$&!,0)#24#!,1#40:04!+#2#,<!M#,#*%4/#%,!/*9#!=#+'2!#2+02##%02+!,0MSG,!4&51)#5#2$*%6!$&!B2&72!30,#*,#!+#2#,;!,/'$$02+!&::!$/&,#!+#2#,!*23!$/#%#=6!1%&90302+!*!2#7!$61#!&:!$%#*$5#2$<!!

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

)")Y1-3J!('/!@&+&1+3*0!)#*1&/!R&+#,+#,&,!

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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=;$U.'JJ'0$>.*#0$'/$*$@",&J$U#'m&$M'((&#$*(N$4(/+'+-+&$U#")&//"#$*+$345?$!"#$N&+*'J/$*,"-+$.'/$J*,1$/&&$

.++09LLM&,?%'+?&N-L/.*#0J*,L?!

Page 19: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ EL!

! !C#/5#$!.&2#%!30%#4$,!*!J&,$&2Q*%#*!%#,#*%4/!1%&+%*5!$/*$!:&4',#,!&2!3#9#)&102+!$#4/2&)&+0#,!:&%!,&%$02+!*23!*2*)6b02+!=)&&3!4#)),<=H!M#4#2$)6;!.&2#%E,!+%&'1!3#9#)&1#3!$/#!(.(Q4/01;!*!,5*))!3#904#!$/*$!,/&7,!1%&50,#!:&%!9*,$)6!051%&902+!$/#!3#$#4$0&2!&:!4*24#%!1%&+%#,,0&2<!(0%4')*$02+!$'5&%!4#)),!c(.(,d!02!$/#!=)&&3,$%#*5!*%#!$/&'+/$!$&!=#!$/#!%&&$!&:!024'%*=)#!5#$*,$*$04!4*24#%,;!,&!$/#!,&&2#%!$/#6!*%#!3#$#4$#3;!$/#!,&&2#%!)0:#Q,*902+!$%#*$5#2$!4*2!=#!,$*%$#3<!@&7#9#%;!(.(,!*%#!#>$%#5#)6!%*%#!*23!30::04')$!$&!4*1$'%#h!,&5#!#>1#%$,!#,$05*$#!$/#!1%#,#24#!&:!(.(,!$&!=#!*,!%*%#!*,!&2#!4#))!02!*!=0))0&2!2&%5*)!=)&&3!4#)),<!!

.&2#%E,!02$#%30,401)02*%6!7&%B!,0+20:04*2$)6!051%&9#,!$/#!#::040#246!70$/!7/04/!(.(,!4*2!=#!3#$#4$#3<!./#!(.(Q4/01!0,!*!,5*))!4/01!4&9#%#3!70$/!\X;```!504%&1&,$,!70$/02!*!,'%:*4#!*%#*!&:!Z\`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h!02!&2#!,$'36;!$/#!4/01!4&%%#4$)6!3#$#4$#3!(.(,!02!&9#%!ZZ!1#%4#2$!&:!4*24#%!1*$0#2$,!70$/!5#$*,$*,#,<!./#!4/01!0,!2&7!02!4)0204*)!$%0*),<!!

;&7/&@&23/2#0$./#!(.(Q4/01!0,!*!,/0202+!#>*51)#!&:!4&29#%+#24#h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

o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!o!

(&29#%+#2$!$#4/2&)&+0#,!1%&50,#!$&!4&2$02'#!#>$#2302+!%#,#*%4/!:%&2$0#%,!*23!1',/02+!5#30402#!$&7*%3!*!5&%#!1#%,&2*)0b#3!*11%&*4/!$/*$!2&!)&2+#%!*44#1$,!/*%5:')!,03#!#::#4$,!*,!*!$%*3#&::!:&%!#::#4$09#!$%#*$5#2$<!A#!*%+'#!$/*$!$/#!+%&'23,7#))!4&29#%+#24#!5&9#5#2$!*)%#*36!'23#%!7*6!,/&')3!=#!,'11&%$#3!=6!$/#!:#3#%*)!+&9#%25#2$;!2&$!&2)6!=#4*',#!B2&7)#3+#!:&%!$/#!,*B#!&:!B2&7)#3+#!0,!7&%$/!1'%,'02+;!='$!*),&!=#4*',#!$/#!+&9#%25#2$!/*,!*!9#,$#3!02$#%#,$!02!$/#!/#*)$/!&:!G5#%04*2,!*23!$/#!7#*)$/!&:!$/#!G5#%04*2!#4&2&56<!D29#,$02+!02!4&29#%+#24#!4*2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=H$3&.%&+$5"(&#$'/$*$0#")&//"#$")$/-#7&#P$*+$3*//*2.-/&++/$e&(&#*J$f"/0'+*J$*(N$f*#K*#N$3&N'2*J$>2.""J1$

*(N$N'#&2+"#$")$+.&$X'"3A3>$W&/"-#2&$D&(+&#$S.++09LLMMM?,'"%&%/#2?"#7LV?!

Page 20: Mit white paper on convergence

EM! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!,&)9#!/#*)$/!4/*))#2+#,!$/*$!70))!&9#%7/#)5!&'%!#4&2&56!'23#%!$/#!,$*$',!?'&h!#?'*))6!051&%$*2$;!,'4/!029#,$5#2$!4*2!+09#!$/#!U20$#3!K$*$#,!*!+)&=*)!4&51#$0$09#!#3+#!02!$#4/2&)&+6!3#9#)&15#2$<!!

Page 21: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ ES!

! !

_F!"-&!91'*'O31!)#,&!('/!4<JJ'/+3*0!)'*.&/0&*1&!

!

N4&2&50,$!*23!S&=#)!)*'%#*$#!M&=#%$!K&)&7!7*,!*5&2+!$/#!:0%,$!$&!4)#*%)6!3#5&2,$%*$#!$/#!%#)*$0&2,/01!=#$7##2!022&9*$0&2!*23!#4&2&504!+%&7$/<!@#!,/&7#3!$/*$!*!)*%+#!1&%$0&2!&:!U<K<!#4&2&504!+%&7$/!02!$/#!#*%)6!]`$/!4#2$'%6!7*,!3#%09#3!:%&5!$#4/2&)&+04*)!*23!%#)*$#3!022&9*$0&2<!!

D2!/0,!7&%B!3'%02+!$/#![Za`,;!K&)&7!:&'23!$/*$!=#$7##2![Z`Z!*23![Z^Z;!+*02,!:%&5!)*=&%!*23!4*10$*)!02$#2,0$6!#>1)*02#3!&2)6!*!,5*))!1&%$0&2!&:!+%&7$/!02!U<K<!+%&,,!2*$0&2*)!1%&3'4$!cWSLd;!7/0)#!*)5&,$!]n_!&:!$/#!%#5*023#%!&:!WSL!+%&7$/!7*,!$/#!%#,')$!&:!7/*$!/#!4*))#3!f$#4/204*)!4/*2+#<g$=I!!@0,!1&02$!7*,!$/*$!$#4/2&)&+04*)!*23!%#)*$#3!022&9*$0&2!7*,!$/#!1%#3&502*2$!4*',*$09#!:*4$&%!=#/023!$/#!=')B!&:!U<K<!#4&2&504!+%&7$/<!

A#!*%#!&2)6!2&7!=#+02202+!$&!+%*,1!$/#!1%&:&'23!051)04*$0&2,!&:!K&)&7E,!7&%B<!D2!$/#!1&,$pA&%)3!A*%!DD!#%*;!$/#!U<K<!*3&1$#3!*!5&3#);!4'%%#2$)6!=#02+!4&10#3!7&%)3703#;!&:!022&9*$0&2Q)#3!4&51*%*$09#!*39*2$*+#!*23!4&%%#,1&2302+!+%&7$/<!I##102+!$/#!U<K<!*$!$/#!:&%#:%&2$!&:!022&9*$0&2!0,!4%'40*)!$&!&'%!4&'2$%6E,!#4&2&504!7#))Q=#02+<!./#!02:&%5*$0&2!$#4/2&)&+6!%#9&)'$0&2;!7/04/!=%&'+/$!/'+#!#4&2&504!+*02,!$&!$/#!U<K<!#4&2&56;!#,1#40*))6!:%&5![ZZ_!$&!]``[;!0,!5*$'%02+;!*23!$/#!020$0*)!1/*,#!&:!$/#!=0&$#4/!%#9&)'$0&2!0,!1)*602+!&'$<!C*26!*%#!1&23#%02+!$/#!2#>$!1/*,#!&:!022&9*$0&2<!

./#%#!*%#!)0B#)6!$&!=#!/0+/)6!:%'0$:')!#4&2&504!051)04*$0&2,;!1'%,'*2$!$&!K&)&7E,!5&3#);!:&%!#>1*2302+!U<K<Q)#3!,'11&%$!:&%!$/#!4&29#%+#24#!&:!$/#!)0:#!,40#24#,;!1/6,04*)!,40#24#,;!*23!#2+02##%02+!$/%&'+/!7/*$!,&5#!*%#!4*))02+!$/#!f=0&)&+6!#4&2&56g<!J%02+02+!&2!*!2#7!1/*,#!&:!$#4/2&)&+04*)!*39*24#,!$/*$!4&')3!4&2$%0='$#!$&!*2&$/#%!U<K<Q)#3!7*9#!&:!7&%)3703#!022&9*$0&2!4&')3!=#!&2#!&:!$/#!B#6,!$&!&'%!:'$'%#!#4&2&504!+%&7$/<!./#!4&'2$%6!0,!+%*11)02+!70$/!/&7!$&!4%#*$#!*!2#7!*23!,$%&2+#%!:&'23*$0&2!:&%!+%&7$/h!*!4#2$%*)!1*%$!&:!$/#!*2,7#%!0,!4*10$*)0b02+!&2!4&29#%+#24#<!

@&O'0/#J-31!)-#%%&*0&,!#*8!+-&!D&&8!('/!;**'.#+3'*!

./#!2##3!$&!029#,$!02!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/!0,!/#0+/$#2#3!=6!$/#!4'%%#2$!/#*)$/!4*%#!4%0,0,!*23!4&502+!3#5&+%*1/04!4/*))#2+#,<!G44&%302+!$&!$/#!G+#246!:&%!@#*)$/4*%#!M#,#*%4/!*23!q'*)0$6;!$/#!U<K<!,1#23,!*!)*%+#%!1&%$0&2!&:!0$,!+%&,,!3&5#,$04!1%&3'4$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=I$W",&#+$3?$>"J"M1$J'*F&#!"#$*'7:!A-!KL4*1,&,*-1$;(N$&N?$S@&M$n"#[9$8j)"#N$T('K&#/'+P$U#&//1$;<<<V9$'jo

jjK'?$>&&$*J/"$W",&#+$3?$>"J"M1$`e#"M+.$5.&"#P$*(N$Q)+&#1a$J&2+-#&$*+$@",&J$U#'m&$*M*#N/$2&#&%"(P1$

>+"2[."J%1$C&2?$:1$=F:E1$.++09LL(",&J0#'m&?"#7L(",&J]0#'m&/L&2"("%'2/LJ*-#&*+&/L=F:EL/"J"Mb

J&2+-#&?.+%J?$

Page 22: Mit white paper on convergence

EU! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!cWOLd!&2!/#*)$/!4*%#!$/*2!*26!&$/#%!5*i&%!023',$%0*)0b#3!4&'2$%6<!D2!:*4$;!02!]``];!/#*)$/!4*%#!#>1#230$'%#,!%#1%#,#2$#3!&2#Q,#9#2$/!&:!$/#!2*$0&2E,!WOL!*23!5*3#!'1!&2#!&:!$/#!:*,$#,$Q+%&702+!4&51&2#2$,!&:!$/#!:#3#%*)!='3+#$<=_!D2!*330$0&2;!*44&%302+!$&!$/#!(#2$#%,!:&%!C#304*%#!*23!C#304*03!K#%904#,!c(CKd;!02!]``X;!$&$*)!/#*)$/!#>1#230$'%#!#?'*)#3!l\;VX[!1#%!1#%,&2<=B!!

./0,!4&,$!0,,'#!0,2E$!i',$!*::#4$02+!0230903'*),!*23!:*50)0#,<!(CK!4*)4')*$#3!$/*$!02!]``^;!#9#%6!,$*$#!#>4#1$!O#)*7*%#!*23!A6&502+!,1#2$![`!1#%4#2$!&%!5&%#!&:!0$,!+%&,,!,$*$#!1%&3'4$!&2!/#*)$/!4*%#<!./#,#!,$*$0,$04,!4&2$02'#!$&!4)05=;!70$/!2*$0&2*)!/#*)$/!#>1#230$'%#,!#>1#4$#3!$&!024%#*,#!*2!*9#%*+#!&:!V<[!1#%4#2$!1#%!6#*%!$/&'+/!]`[Z<=E!!

G,!=0&5#304*)!*39*24#,!1%&)&2+!G5#%04*2!)09#,!*23!*,!$/#!=*=6Q=&&5!+#2#%*$0&2!*+#,;!&'%!/#*)$/!4*%#!,6,$#5!70))!:*4#!,'=,$*2$0*)!4/*))#2+#,;!,'4/!*,!$/#!02#90$*=)#!%0,#!&:!4#%$*02!30,#*,#,!*23!*2!024%#*,#3!2##3!:&%!#23Q&:Q)0:#!4*%#<!P',$!*,!4*24#%!%#4#2$)6!%#1)*4#3!/#*%$!30,#*,#!*,!$/#!)#*302+!U<K<!4*',#!&:!3#*$/!c$/*2B,!$&!5*i&%!*39*24#,!02!/#*%$Q30,#*,#!$%#*$5#2$d;!,&5#!#>1#4$!=%*02!30,#*,#,!$&;!02!$'%2;!30,1)*4#!4*24#%!02!'14&502+!6#*%,<!G)b/#05#%E,!30,#*,#;!:&%!#>*51)#;!70))!*::#4$!$/#!=*=6!=&&5#%,!*$!,'4/!*2!*)*%502+!%*$#!$/*$!0$!0,!'24)#*%!/&7!&'%!4'%%#2$!/#*)$/!4*%#!,6,$#5!70))!4&1#<!G44&%302+!$&!$/#!G)b/#05#%E,!G,,&40*$0&2;!f$/#!2'5=#%!&:!1#&1)#!*+#3!Va!*23!&)3#%!70$/!G)b/#05#%E,!30,#*,#!0,!#,$05*$#3!$&!%#*4/!\<\!50))0&2!02!]`_`85&%#!$/*2!*!a`!1#%4#2$!024%#*,#!:%&5!$/#!a<[!50))0&2!*+#3!Va!*23!&)3#%!4'%%#2$)6!*::#4$#3<g=:!

./#!3#5&+%*1/04!,/0:$!$/*$!$/#!4&'2$%6!:*4#,!=#4&5#,!,0+20:04*2$)6!5&%#!5*2*+#*=)#!0:!$/#!=*=6Q=&&5!+#2#%*$0&2!4*2!%#5*02!*!1%&3'4$09#!1*%$!&:!$/#!7&%B:&%4#<!./0,!70))!*))&7!$/#0%!/#*)$/!4*%#!4&,$,!$&!=#!,1%#*3!5&%#!#9#2)6!&9#%!*2!#>$#23#3!1#%0&3!*23!*4%&,,!$/#!1&1')*$0&2!=*,#<!(&29#%+#24#;!*23!$/#!4&%%#,1&2302+!$%*2,:&%5*$0&2!&:!/#*)$/!4*%#!0$!4*2!$%0++#%;!0,!B#6!$&!='602+!',!$/#!$05#!7#!70))!2##3!$&!022&9*$#!&'%!7*6!$/%&'+/!$/0,!3%*5*$04!1&1')*$0&2!4/*))#2+#<!

(&2+%#,,!$%0#3!$&!$*4B)#!5*26!&:!&'%!/#*)$/!4*%#!4/*))#2+#,!=6!1*,,02+!$/#!L*$0#2$!L%&$#4$0&2!*23!G::&%3*=)#!(*%#!G4$!cLLG(Gd!02!C*%4/!]`[`<!LLG(G!*$$#51$,!$&!#2,'%#!024%#*,#3!*44#,,!$&!/#*)$/!4*%#;!='$!0$!0,!'24)#*%!/&7!$/#!*,,&40*$#3!4&,$,!70))!=#!5*2*+#3<!(&,$!4&2$%&)!0,!4%0$04*);!*23!0$!70))!3#1#23!$&!*!)*%+#!3#+%##!&2!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!=_$`f&*J+.$D*#&$D"/+/9$!*2+$>.&&+1a$Q7&(2P$)"#$f&*J+.2*#&$W&/&*#2.$*(N$k-*J'+P1$W"2[K'JJ&1$3C1$>&0+?$;<<;1$

0?$=1$.++09LLMMM?*.#g?7"KL(&M/L2"/+/)*2+?0N)?

=B$`@*+'"(*J$f&*J+.$Aj0&(N'+-#&$C*+*9$@fA$!*2+$>.&&+1a$D&(+&#/$)"#$3&N'2*#&$*(N$3&N'2*'N$>&#K'2&/1$

X*J+'%"#&1$.++0/9LLMMM?2%/?7"KL@*+'"(*Jf&*J+.Aj0&(NC*+*L;_]@fA]!*2+]>.&&+?*/0$S*22&//&N$c-JP$;I1$

;<=<V?!

=E$4,'N?!

=:$`;<=<$QJm.&'%&#i/$C'/&*/&$!*2+/$*(N$!'7-#&/1a$A0M#$,<$'N1!O!P$<$-&,>$B$S;<=<V9$=I1$!

.++09LLMMM?*Jm?"#7LN"2-%&(+/]2-/+"%L#&0"#+]*Jm)*2+/)'7-#&/;<=<?0N)?!

Page 23: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ EW!

! !022&9*$0&2<!S#7!$#4/2&)&+0#,!*23!4%#*$09#!*11%&*4/#,!*%#!2##3#3!$&!3%09#!1%&3'4$090$6!+*02,!,&!$/*$!7#!4*2!#>1*23!*44#,,!$&!/#*)$/!4*%#!7/0)#!*),&!*$$#51$02+!$&!3#4%#*,#!$/#!4&,$!1#%!1#%,&2<!U2:&%$'2*$#)6;!LLG(G!303!)0$$)#!$&!*33%#,,!$/#!051&%$*24#!&:!022&9*$0&2<!G,!&2#!4&55#2$*$&%!1'$!0$;!f./#!/#*)$/4*%#!)#+0,)*$0&2!r!3&#,!2&$!/*9#!*2!022&9*$0&2!:&4',!r!sAt#!,/&')3!3&!#9#%6$/02+!7#!4*2!$&!#24&'%*+#!$/#!,&%$!&:!30,%'1$09#!022&9*$0&2!02!$/#!5#304*)!:0#)3!$/*$!/*,!4/*%*4$#%0b#3!$/#!$#4/2&)&+6!023',$%6<g=F!!

./#!3#5&+%*1/04!4/*))#2+#,!70))!=#!'1&2!',!,&&2;!%#+*%3)#,,!&:!&'%!2*$0&2E,!%#,#*%4/!1%0&%0$0#,<!A#!70))!=#!:*4#3!70$/!*2!*+02+!1&1')*$0&2!%#?'0%02+!+%#*$#%!5#304*)!*$$#2$0&2!*23!,'::#%02+!*$!*2!*)*%502+!%*$#!:%&5!4&230$0&2,!:&%!7/04/!7#!,$0))!/*9#!2&!4'%#,<!S&7!0,!$/#!$05#!$&!1%#1*%#!&'%!5#304*)!%#,#*%4/#%,!*23!022&9*$&%,!:&%!$/0,!,&40#$*)!4/*))#2+#!=6!#5=%*402+!4&29#%+#24#!*23!*))!0$,!1&$#2$0*)!=#2#:0$,<!!

>30-!?&+</*,!('/!P&8&/#%!;*.&,+O&*+!3*!N3'O&831#%!?&,&#/1-!

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

(&2,03#%!$/*$!G5#%04*2,!=&%2!*$!$/#!#23!&:!$/#!]`$/!4#2$'%6!4*2!#>1#4$!$&!)09#!*=&'$!_`!6#*%,!)&2+#%!$/*2!0:!$/#6!/*3!=##2!=&%2!02![Z``;;<!*23!5&,$!%#$0%##,!02!$/#0%!V`,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=F$e*#P$>.*0'#"1$`6.&#&$4/$4(("K*+'"($'($+.&$f&*J+.2*#&$C&,*+&\a$"#$!Q,002$c*(?$E1$;<=<1$0?$;1$

.++09LL+.&.'JJ?2"%L"0'('"(L"0b&NLEIE=_bM.&#&b'/b'(("K*+'"(b'(b+.&b.&*J+.b2*#&bN&,*+&b?$!"#$%"#&$

2"%%&(+*#P$"($+.&$(&&N$)"#$'(("K*+'"($'($.&*J+.$2*#&1$/&&$c".($D?$Z&2.J&'+&#1$`f&*J+.bD*#&$W&)"#%$*(N$

+.&$i4(("K*+'"($5&/+1ia$C>00!%&'$$&!R*('->02$3*P$=I1$;<<F1$

.++09LL"(J'(&?M/h?2"%L*#+'2J&L>X=;I;;E<_H:I;<=:H==?.+%JY$*(N$X#-2&$@-//,*-%1$`f&*J+.$D*#&$W&)"#%$

U*//&/p@"M$Z&+i/$>+*#+$f&*J+.$D*#&$4(("K*+'"(1q$80**<6$'9!8(1,-$11!C$$D2$3*#2.$;;1$;<=<1$

.++09LLMMM?,-/'(&//M&&[?2"%?!

;<$R&K'($3-#0.P$*(N$W",&#+$5"0&J1$`5.&$l*J-&$")$f&*J+.$*(N$Z"(7&K'+P1a$R*('->0!*+!?*0,&,)>0!K)*-*<7$==I1$

("?$_$S82+?$;<<BV9$:E=oF<I1$.++09LLMMM?h"-#(*J/?-2.'2*7"?&N-LN"'L)-JJL=<?=<:BL_<:<HH?!

H)',+!1'*+/'%!3,!1/3+31#%5!#*8!3+!G3%%!

8&J&*8!+'!#!%#/0&!8&0/&&!'*!

3**'.#+3'*FK!

Page 24: Mit white paper on convergence

_Z! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!*23!\`,!*%#!1/6,04*))6!*=)#!$&!7&%B<;=!J)&&5!*23!/0,!4&))#*+'#,$/*9#!4*)4')*$#3!$/*$!*!&2#Q6#*%!024%#*,#!02!)0:#!#>1#4$*246!051%&9#,!)*=&%!1%&3'4$090$6!=6!*!3%*5*$04!^!1#%4#2$<;;!./0,!$%*2,)*$#,!$&!,0+20:04*2$!#4&2&504!=#2#:0$<!J#$7##2![Z\`!*23!]```;!+*02,!02!)0:#!#>1#4$*246!*44&'2$#3!:&%!l_<]!$%0))0&2!1#%!6#*%!&:!2*$0&2*)!7#*)$/;!*23!*![!1#%4#2$!%#3'4$0&2!02!4*24#%!5&%$*)0$6!%*$#,!7*,!#,$05*$#3!$&!5#*2!4'5')*$09#!,*902+,!&:!la``!=0))0&2!$&!$/#!/#*)$/!#4&2&56<;H!!

H#3#%*)!029#,$5#2$!/*,!=##2!B#6!$&!$/0,!#::&%$<!G,!&:!]``V;!*44&%302+!$&!$/#!:&%5#%!30%#4$&%!&:!SD@;!$/#!f#,$05*$#3!$&$*)!4'5')*$09#!029#,$5#2$!*$!SD@!1#%!G5#%04*2!&9#%!$/#!1*,$!_`!6#*%,!r!0,!*=&'$!l[;__^!&%!*=&'$!l^^!1#%!G5#%04*2!1#%!6#*%!&9#%!$/#!#2$0%#!1#%0&3<!D2!%#$'%2;!G5#%04*2,!/*9#!+*02#3!&9#%!,0>!6#*%,!&:!)0:#!#>1#4$*246!*23!*%#!*+02+!/#*)$/0#%!$/*2!#9#%!=#:&%#<g;I!D2!:*4$;!SD@!029#,$5#2$,!02!/#*%$!30,#*,#!%#,#*%4/;!7/04/!*5&'2$!$&!*2!*9#%*+#!&:!l^!1#%!6#*%!1#%!G5#%04*2;!/*9#!/#)1#3!$&!4'$!$/#!02403#24#!&:!:*$*)!/#*%$!*$$*4B,!*23!,$%&B#!=6!5&%#!$/*2!V`!1#%4#2$!,024#![Z\a<!K050)*%)6;!SD@Q,1&2,&%#3!*39*24#,!/*9#!051%&9#3!,'%909*)!%*$#,!:&%!@DT!1*$0#2$,;!*23!#4&2&50,$,!#,$05*$#!$/*$!$/#!%#,')$02+!,*902+,!$&!&'%!#4&2&56!70))!=#!4)&,#!$&!l[<^!$%0))0&2!:&%!*))!1*,$!*23!:'$'%#!4&/&%$,!&:!02:#4$#3!0230903'*),<;_!D2,$#*3!&:!=#02+!*2!#103#504!4&,$02+!=0))0&2,!:&%!2#7!/&,10$*)!=#3,!*23!/#*)$/!4*%#;!GDOK!0,!=#4&502+!*!5*2*+#*=)#!&'$1*$0#2$!30,#*,#;!*23!@DTQGDOK!904$05,!*%#!%#5*0202+!1%&3'4$09#!02!$/#!#4&2&56<!!!

D2!*330$0&2!$&!=#2#:0$02+!$/#!#4&2&56!=6!051%&902+!/#*)$/;!SD@!029#,$5#2$,!4%#*$#!30%#4$!*23!0230%#4$!#4&2&504!+*02,!=6!4%#*$02+!i&=,!*23!2#7!+&&3,!*23!,#%904#,<!H*50)0#,!UKG!%#4#2$)6!%#)#*,#3!*!%#1&%$!$/*$!&'$)02#,!$/#!#::#4$!&:!SD@!%#,#*%4/!3&))*%,!&2!0230903'*)!,$*$#,<!./#!l]_!=0))0&2!$/*$!SD@!029#,$#3!02!*))!a`!,$*$#,!02!]``\!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;=$@'2"J&$3*&/+*/$*(N$c-J'&$r'//'%"0"-J"/1$`f"M$Z"(7&#$6"#[$Z'K&/$A*/&$+.&$D#-(2.$")$U"0-J*+'"($Q7'(71a$

M"#['(7$0*0&#1$WQ@C$D"#01$>*(+*$3"('2*1$DQ1$C&2?$;<<F1$

.++09LLMMM?#*(N?"#7L0-,/LM"#['(7]0*0&#/L;<=<LWQ@C]6WE;:?0N)?!

;;$C*K'N$XJ""%1$C*K'N$D*(('(71$*(N$3*#[$6&/+"(1$`5.&$l*J-&$")$l*22'(*+'"(1a$C*'05!K)*-*<,)1$B1$("?$H$

Sc-JPo>&0+?$;<<_V9$=_oHF1$

.++09LLMMM?/*,'(?"#7L)'J&/L*++*2.%&(+LK*J-&]K*22'(*+'"(],J""%]2*(('(7]M&/+"(?0N)?!

;H$R&K'($3?$3-#0.P$*(N$W",&#+$f?$5"0&J1$`5.&$l*J-&$")$f&*J+.$*(N$Z"(7&K'+P1a$C$$D07!?*0,)7!

I*<<$-&>'72$*$0-,J'2*+'"($")$W&/"-#2&/$)"#$+.&$!-+-#&$S>&0+?$;:1$;<<FV1$

.++09LLMMM?#))?"#7LU-,J'2*+'"(/L6UDLU*7&/L5.&bl*J-&b")bf&*J+.b*(NbZ"(7&K'+P?*/0j?!

;I!AJ'*/$Q?$r&#."-('1$`!n;<<E$C'#&2+"#i/$X-N7&+$W&g-&/+$>+*+&%&(+1a$0#&/&(+*+'"($,P$@4f$N'#&2+"#$+"$

f"-/&$>-,2"%%'++&&$"($Z*,"#1$Q0#'J$B1$;<<B1$

.++09LLMMM?('.?7"KL*,"-+LN'#&2+"#L,-N7&+#&g-&/+L)P;<<EN'#&2+"#/,-N7&+#&g-&/+?.+%?!

;_$4,'N?!

Page 25: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ _E!

! !+#2#%*$#3!&9#%!la`!=0))0&2!02!$/#!1%&3'4$0&2!&:!2#7!+&&3,!*23!,#%904#,<;B!./*$!5#*2,!$/*$!#9#%6!l[!50))0&2!SD@!029#,$#3!02!]``\!+#2#%*$#3!5&%#!$/*2!$704#!$/*$!cl]<][!50))0&2d!02!2#7!,$*$#!=',02#,,!*4$090$6<!H'%$/#%5&%#;!SD@!+%*2$,!02!]``\!,'11&%$#3!5&%#!$/*2!_a`;```!i&=,!*23!$/#!*9#%*+#!7*+#!&:!$/&,#!/0%#3!:&%!$/#!2#7!i&=,!7*,!la];```8,0+20:04*2$)6!/0+/#%!$/*2!$/#!#,$05*$#3!*9#%*+#!U<K<!7*+#!*$!$/#!$05#;!l^];```<;E!

SD@Q,'11&%$#3!023',$%0#,;!)0B#!$/#!=0&1/*%5*4#'$04*)!023',$%6;!&::#%!*2&$/#%!+&&3!)#2,!:&%!#>*50202+!$/#!051*4$!&:!SD@!:'2302+!&2!#51)&65#2$!*23!7#*)$/!4%#*$0&2<!G44&%302+!$&!*!%#4#2$!%#1&%$;!$/#!=0&$#4/!,#4$&%!4&2,0,$#2$)6!&'$1#%:&%5,!&$/#%,!02!i&=!4%#*$0&2-!

J0&,40#24#!#51)&65#2$!+%&7$/!+%#*$)6!&'$1*4#3!2*$0&2*)!#51)&65#2$!+%&7$/!:%&5!]``[!$&!]``X<,./#!=0&,40#24#!023',$%6!*33#3![Z_;\^X!i&=,!:%&5!]``[!$&!]``X;!*!/#:$6!+%&7$/!%*$#!&:![a<X!1#%4#2$<!./0,!%*103!%*$#!&:!i&=!+%&7$/!7*,!^<a!$05#,!*,!5'4/!*,!$/#!&9#%*))!+%&7$/!%*$#!:&%!$/#!2*$0&2*)!1%09*$#!,#4$&%!c_<a!1#%4#2$d<]X!

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

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

;B$3-!S*('!TF-!8>)D7>'5:!Q*F!E3Q!;(-5,-9!Q$041!S*('!%&>&$B1!K)*-*<7$S6*/.'(7+"(1$CD9$!*%'J'&/$T>Q$

!"-(N*+'"(1$;<<:V1$0?$H1$.++09LLMMM?)*%'J'&/-/*?"#7L*//&+/L0N)/L7J",*Jb.&*J+.L'(bP"-#b"M(b

,*2[P*#N?0N)?!

;E$4,'N?1$0?$I?!

;:$8>&&$00$U83T!%&>&$!8,*1),$-)$!3-,&,>&,/$1!GVHV2$SX'"+&2.("J"7P$4(N-/+#P$8#7*('m*+'"($*(N$X*++&JJ&$

5&2.("J"7P$U*#+(&#/.'0$U#*2+'2&1$3*P$;<=<V1$0?$''1$

.++09LLMMM?,'"?"#7LJ"2*JL,*++&JJ&;<=<LX*++&JJ&]W&0"#+];<=<?0N)?!

;F$R&K'($3?$3-#0.P$*(N$W",&#+$f?$5"0&J1$&N/?1$=$>1(',-9!&#$!J>,-1!+'*<!=$5,)>0!.$1$>')#:!A-!K)*-*<,)!

A44'*>)#$SD.'2*7"9$T('K&#/'+P$")$D.'2*7"$U#&//1$;<<HV?!

Page 26: Mit white paper on convergence

__! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!

:F!D;>^,!?'%&!3*![8.#*13*0!)'*.&/0&*1&!

!

A#!/*9#!*)%#*36!*%+'#3!$/*$!4&29#%+#24#!0,!$/#!2#>$!%#9&)'$0&2!02!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/<!./#!U<K<!0,!$/#!/0,$&%04!)#*3#%!02!=0&5#30402#!=#4*',#!&:!SD@E,!#*%)6!029#,$5#2$,!02!)0:#!,40#24#!*23!#3'4*$0&2!*23!=#4*',#!&:!$/#!1%09*$#Q,#4$&%!4*10$*)!$/*$!:&))&7#3<!S&7;!70$/!&$/#%!4&'2$%0#,!#*+#%)6!3'1)04*$02+!$/#!U<K<!5&3#)!&:!022&9*$0&2!02!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/;!0$!0,!4%0$04*)!$/*$!SD@!3#9#)&1!*!90,0&2!$&!$*B#!',!02$&!$/#!:'$'%#<!.&!3&!,&;!SD@!2##3,!4&2,0,$#2$!:'2302+;!+%#*$#%!70))02+2#,,!$&!:'23!,##502+)6!%0,B6!%#,#*%4/;!*23!$/#!02:%*,$%'4$'%#!$&!4*10$*)0b#!&2!$/#!2#>$!%#9&)'$0&2!02!)0:#!,40#24#,<!!

P<*83*0!)-#%%&*0&,!#*8!2'GY?3,a!?&,&#/1-!

./#!SD@!='3+#$!2#*%)6!3&'=)#3!=#$7##2![ZZX!*23!]``_<H<$@&7#9#%;!,024#!$/#2;!SD@!

30,4&9#%0#,;!7/04/!1%09*$#!029#,$5#2$!='0)3,!&2;!/*9#!=##2!*::#4$#3!=6!:'2302+!)#9#),!$/*$!*%#!3#4)0202+!02!%#*)!$#%5,<!!

./#!#2*4$#3!SD@!='3+#$!:&%!HR!]`[`!7*,!l_[<]!=0))0&2;!*!]<]\!1#%4#2$!024%#*,#!:%&5!$/#!1%#90&',!6#*%<$!@&7#9#%;!$/#!J'%#*'!&:!N4&2&504!G2*)6,0,!1%&i#4$#3!$/#!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/!02:)*$0&2!5#$%04!cJMOLDd!*$!_<[!1#%4#2$<H=!./0,!5#*2,!$/*$!$/#!='3+#$!/*,!2&$!B#1$!'1!70$/!02:)*$0&2!c,##!+%*1/d;!*23!$/*$!02!4&2,$*2$!3&))*%,!$/#!='3+#$!*4$'*))6!,/%*2B!=#$7##2!]``_!*23!]`[`<H;!N,,#2$0*))6;!SD@E,!*=0)0$6!$&!:'23!4'%%#2$!)#9#),!&:!%#,#*%4/;!)#$!*)&2#!$/#!#5#%+02+!4&29#%+#24#!%#9&)'$0&2;!3#4%#*,#3!,0+20:04*2$)6<!

D2!H#=%'*%6!]``Z;!$/#!2#7!*35020,$%*$0&2E,!G5#%04*2!M#4&9#%6!*23!M#029#,$5#2$!G4$!cGMMGd!1%&903#3!SD@!70$/!l[`!=0))0&2!02!5'4/Q2##3#3!,$05')',!:'2302+<!@&7#9#%;!$/0,!=&&,$!7*,!*!&2#Q$05#!:'2302+!&11&%$'20$6;!*23!0$!7*,!*9*0)*=)#!1%#3&502*2$)6!:&%!*)%#*36Q:0)#3!+%*2$!*11)04*$0&2,;!%*$/#%!$/*2!2#7!*7*%3,<!A0$/&'$!*!,',$*02#3!,&'%4#!&:!024%#*,#3!=*,#)02#!:'2302+!:&%!SD@;!*23!*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

H<$C*+*$2"%0'J&N$,P$+.&$Q%&#'2*($Q//"2'*+'"($)"#$+.&$QNK*(2&%&(+$")$>2'&(2&1$

.++09LLMMM?***/?"#7L/00L#NL('.2.+<F?0N)$S*22&//&N$c-JP$;I1$;<=<V?!

H=$`X'"%&N'2*J$W&/&*#2.$*(N$C&K&J"0%&(+$U#'2&$4(N&j$SXWCU4V9$!'/2*J$n&*#$;<<F$T0N*+&$*(N$U#"h&2+'"(/$

)"#$!n$;<=<o!n$;<=_1a$%&%"$)#"%$T?>?$C&0*#+%&(+$")$f&*J+.$*(N$f-%*($>&#K'2&/1$!&,?$=1$;<=<1$

.++09LL"))'2&"),-N7&+?"N?('.?7"KL0N)/L!n==LXWCU4]U#"h]!&,];<=<?0N)Y$*(N$`5.&$@4f$QJ%*(*2p

Q00#"0#'*+'"(/1a$0"/+'(7$*+$+.&$@*+'"(*J$4(/+'+-+&/$")$f&*J+.$M&,/'+&1$3*P$=I1$;<=<1$

.++09LLMMM?('.?7"KL*,"-+L*J%*(*2L*00#"0#'*+'"(/L'(N&j?.+%$S*22&//&N$@"K?$=:1$;<=<V!

H;$`5.&$@4f$QJ%*(*2pQ00#"0#'*+'"(/1a$0"/+'(7$*+$+.&$@*+'"(*J$4(/+'+-+&/$")$f&*J+.$M&,/'+&1$3*P$=I1$;<=<1$

.++09LLMMM?('.?7"KL*,"-+L*J%*(*2L*00#"0#'*+'"(/L'(N&j?.+%$S*22&//&N$c-JP$;I1$;<=<V?!

Page 27: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ _:!

! !4&%%#,1&2302+!%#2#7#3!:&4',!&2!4&29#%+#24#;!$/#!U<K<!4*22&$!#>1#4$!$&!%#$*02!0$,!)#*3#%,/01!02!5*B02+!=0&5#304*)!*39*24#,<HH!

H&%!,#9#%*)!6#*%,;!5#304*)Q%#,#*%4/!*39&4*$#,!/*9#!#>1%#,,#3!4&24#%2!$/*$!$/#,#!3#4)0202+!029#,$5#2$!)#9#),!70));!&9#%!$05#;!%#3'4#!%#,#*%4/!,'11&%$;!3#$#%!$*)#2$#3!0230903'*),!:%&5!+&02+!02$&!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/!:0#)3,;!#%&3#!U<K<!)#*3#%,/01!02!)0:#!,40#24#;!*23!7#*B#2!&'%!4*1*=0)0$6!$&!$*4B)#!5*i&%!/#*)$/!4&24#%2,<HI!A#!*%#!2&7!:*402+!$/*$!%#*)0$6<!G!%#4#2$!E3).'#!*%$04)#!2&$#,!$/*$!SD@!0,!2&7!:'2302+!:#7#%!$/*2!&2#!02!:09#!+%*2$!*11)04*$0&2,-!!

sD2!]`[`t;!,'44#,,!%*$#,!:&%!,40#2$0,$,!*11)602+!:&%!$/#!*+#246k,!%#,#*%4/Q1%&i#4$!+%*2$,!/*9#!3011#3!$&!*2!#,$05*$#3![Z!1#%4#2$;!3&72!:%&5!][!1#%4#2$!02!]``Z!*23!:*%!)&7#%!$/*2!$/#!4&5:&%$*=)#!_]!1#%4#2$!&:!*!3#4*3#!#*%)0#%r./#!7&%,#2#3!&33,!1*%$)6!%#:)#4$!*2!024%#*,#!&:!*=&'$![`!1#%4#2$!02!$/#!2'5=#%!&:!*11)04*$0&2,;!5*26!&:!7/04/!*%#!%#464)#3!:%&5!:*0)#3!,$05')',!+%*2$!1%&1&,*),<!D2!]`[[!*23!]`[];!$/#!+%*2$!,'44#,,!%*$#,!*%#!#>1#4$#3!$&!:*))!:'%$/#%!*,!,$05')',!:'2302+!%'2,!&'$!*23!0$,!%#4010#2$,!*$$#51$!$&!#>$#23!,'11&%$!:&%!$/#0%!1%&i#4$,<H_!!

G,!*!%#,')$!&:!3#4%#*,02+!+%*2$!,'44#,,!%*$#,;!,40#2$0,$,!7/&!1##%Q%#90#7!SD@!+%*2$!1%&1&,*),!/*9#!=#4&5#!5&%#!,#)#4$09#!*23!5&%#!4&2,#%9*$09#!7/#2!i'3+02+!$/#!5#%0$,!&:!%#,#*%4/!1%&i#4$,<HB!D2!*!7#))Q'23#%,$&&3!1/#2&5#2&2!$/*$!*::#4$,!*))!,40#24#!%#,#*%4/;!*!3#4)02#!02!+%*2$!*11%&9*)!%*$#,!1%#,,'%#,!1##%!%#90#7#%,!$&!3#5*23!5&%#!#903#24#!:&%!$/#!#9#2$'*)!,'44#,,!&:!1%&1&,#3!$/#&%0#,!=#:&%#!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

__!@"+&9$5.&$0#"0"/&N$@4f$,-N7&+$)"#$!n$;<==$N"&/$%&&+$+.&$XWCU4$%&+#'2?!f"M&K&#1$+.&#&$'/$("$2-/.'"(1$

*(N$+.&$)'(*J$*JJ"2*+'"($'/$-(2&#+*'(1$7'K&($+.&$N'))'2-J+$,-N7&+$2J'%*+&$'($D"(7#&//?$!

HI$X#"M($T('K&#/'+P$&+$*J?1$aQ$X#"[&($U'0&J'(&\$!J*+$!-(N'(7$")$+.&$@4f$U-+/$*$e&(&#*+'"($")$>2'&(2&$*+$

W'/[1a$/+*+&%&(+$,P$*$7#"-0$")$-('K&#/'+'&/$*(N$#&/&*#2.$'(/+'+-+'"(/1$3*#2.$;<<:1$

.++09LLMMM?,#"[&(0'0&J'(&?"#7L,#"[&(0'0&J'(&?0N)?!

H_$3&#&N'+.$6*N%*(1$a!#*(2'/$D"JJ'(/9$8(&$n&*#$*+$+.&$f&J%1a$E>&('$$IBB1$("?$EH<:$SQ-7?$==1$;<=<V9$:<:o

:=<1$.++09LLMMM?(*+-#&?2"%L(&M/L;<=<L=<<:==L)-JJLIBB:<:*?.+%J?!

HB$4,'N?!

!0=>?@A,3B,(/*2+#!02!$/#!SD@E,!='3+#$!9#%,',!JMOLD;!*!5#$%04!$/*$!5#*,'%#,!02:)*$0&2!02!/#*)$/!4*%#!4&,$,<!O*$*!K&'%4#-!gJ0&5#304*)!M#,#*%4/!*23!O#9#)&15#2$!L%04#!D23#>!cJMOLDd-!H0,4*)!R#*%!]``Z!U13*$#!*23!L%&i#4$0&2,!:&%!HR!]`[`pHR!]`[a;g!5#5&!:%&5!$/#!U<K<!O#1*%$5#2$!&:!@#*)$/!*23!@'5*2!K#%904#,;!H#=<![;!]`[`<!

Page 28: Mit white paper on convergence

_=! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!*11%&902+!:'2302+;!7/04/!)050$,!%0,B!$*B02+!02!$/#!%#,#*%4/!1&%$:&)0&<!./0,!02*39#%$#2$)6!4/*2+#,!$/#!7*6!,40#24#!0,!4&23'4$#3!=6!30,4&'%*+02+!022&9*$09#;!2&9#)!03#*,!02!:*9&%!&:!5&%#!4&29#2$0&2*)!*11%&*4/#,!*23!024%#5#2$*)!1%&+%#,,!$&7*%3!,40#2$0:04!30,4&9#%6<!!

SD@!2##3,!*!,&)03!:&'23*$0&2!&2!7/04/!$&!='0)3!*!2#7!4&29#%+#24#!%#9&)'$0&2!70$/!$%*2,:&%5*$0&2*)!051)04*$0&2,!:&%!$/#!U<K<!%#,#*%4/!*23!3#9#)&15#2$!,6,$#5<!./#!02/#%#2$!4&2,#%9*$0,5!&:!1##%!%#90#7!70$/02!$/#!#>0,$02+!,40#24#!,'11&%$!,6,$#5;!*23!$/#!024&2,0,$#2$!:'2302+!=*,#;!/*51#%!2#7!*11%&*4/#,!$&!%#,#*%4/!$/*$!5',$!=#!#5=%*4#3!:&%!G5#%04*!$&!5*02$*02!0$,!4&51#$0$09#2#,,!*23!022&9*$09#!#3+#<!

)'*.&/0&*1&Y4+7%&!6/'`&1+,!#+!D;>!

O#,10$#!$/#!4/*))#2+#,;!4&29#%+#24#!0,!,)&7)6!1#%4&)*$02+!$/%&'+/&'$!$/#!,40#2$0:04!4&55'20$6<!G$!SD@;!4&29#%+#24#Q,$6)#!1%&+%*5,!/*9#!+&$$#2!*!=&&,$!:%&5!,$05')',!3&))*%,!*23!:%&5!$/#!SD@!(&55&2!H'23;!4%#*$#3!02!]``V!$&!,'11&%$!4%&,,Q4'$$02+!%#,#*%4/!029&)902+!$7&!&%!5&%#!&:!$/#!*+#246E,!02,$0$'$#,!*23!4#2$#%,<!D2!*330$0&2;!4&29#%+#24#!0,!+*0202+!90,0=0)0$6!$/%&'+/!5*26!&:!$/#!020$0*$09#,!$/*$!H%*240,!(&))02,!/*,!1%&5&$#3!,024#!=#4&502+!SD@!30%#4$&%!02!G'+',$!]``Z<!!

D2!S&9#5=#%!]`[`;!O%<!(&))02,!1%#,#2$#3!/0,!:09#!%#,#*%4/!1%0&%0$0#,<!./#,#!:09#!10))*%,;!*,!$/#6E9#!4&5#!$&!=#!B2&72;!*%#-!

• /0+/Q$/%&'+/1'$!$#4/2&)&+0#,!!

• $%*2,)*$0&2*)!5#30402#!!

• /#*)$/!4*%#!%#:&%5!0,,'#,;!024)'302+!4&51*%*$09#Q#::#4$09#2#,,!%#,#*%4/;!30,#*,#!1%#9#2$0&2;!1#%,&2*)0b#3!5#30402#;!/#*)$/!30,1*%0$0#,!%#,#*%4/;!1/*%5*4&+#2&504,;!*23!/#*)$/!%#,#*%4/!#4&2&504,!!

• +)&=*)!/#*)$/!0,,'#,;!*23!!

• %#0290+&%*$02+!*23!#51&7#%02+!$/#!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/!4&55'20$6<HE!!!

G,!1*%$!&:!/0,!#::&%$!$&!5*B#!1%&+%#,,!02!$/#,#!*%#*,;!O%<!(&))02,!/#)3!$/#!fJ0+!./02Bg!5##$02+!02!C*6!]`[`!$&!4&2,03#%!022&9*$09#!03#*,!:&%!(&55&2!H'23!&%!&$/#%!SD@!,'11&%$<!(&02403#2$*))6;!$/0,!5##$02+!:&4',#3!&2!$/#!$/%##!10))*%,!5&,$!%#)#9*2$!$&!4&29#%+#24#-!*11)04*$0&2!&:!/0+/Q$/%&'+/1'$!$#4/2&)&+0#,;!$%*2,)*$0&2!&:!=*,04!%#,#*%4/!02$&!30*+2&,$04,!*23!$/#%*1#'$04,;!*23!'$0)0b*$0&2!&:!,40#24#!$&!=#2#:0$!/#*)$/!4*%#!%#:&%5<!!

D2!*2!#::&%$!$&!=%#*B!=#6&23!$/#!4'%%#2$!1*%*30+5,;!2&2$%*30$0&2*)!,$*B#/&)3#%,!:%&5!$/#!,40#24#!4&55'20$6!&'$,03#!&:!SD@!7#%#!0290$#3<!L%#,#2$#%,!30,4',,#3!*!=%&*3!*%%*6!&:!1%&50,02+!*%#*,;!024)'302+;!:&%!02,$*24#;!5#$*=*)&504,!*23!0$,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

HE$!#*(2'/$D"JJ'(/1$`800"#+-('+'&/$)"#$W&/&*#2.$*(N$@4f1a$%),$-)$$H;E$Sc*(?$=$;<=<V9$HBoHE?$

Page 29: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ _L!

! !*11)04*$0&2,!:&%!4)0204*)!5#30402#<!D2!*330$0&2;!*))!*$$#23##,!7#%#!&::#%#3!$/#!&11&%$'20$6!$&!,'=50$!&2#Q1*+#!5#5&,!&2!f=0+!03#*,g!:&%!SD@<!D2$#%#,$02+)6;!$/#!:&%5*$!:&%!$/#,#!5#5&,!:&))&7#3!$/#!f@#0)5#0#%!?'#,$0&2,g!:&%5')*$#3!=6!W#&%+#!@#0)5#0#%;!*!:&%5#%!30%#4$&%!&:!$/#!O#:#2,#!G39*24#3!M#,#*%4/!L%&i#4$,!G+#246;!02304*$02+!$/*$!O%<!(&))02,!0,!,#%0&',!*=&'$!=%02+02+!2#7!03#*,!02$&!SD@<!!

A0$/!O%<!(&))02,!*$!$/#!*+#246E,!/#)5;!0$!5*6!2&$!=#!,'%1%0,02+!$/*$!1%&i#4$,!$/*$!=)#23!,##502+)6!'2%#)*$#3!30,401)02#,!*%#!+*0202+!,&5#!,'11&%$<!A/0)#!$/#%#!0,!,$0))!5'4/!5&%#!$&!3&;!$7&!#>*51)#,!&:!4&29#%+#24#Q,$6)#!%#,#*%4/!*$!SD@!*%#!7&%$/!/0+/)0+/$02+-!./#!(*24#%!W#2&5#!G$)*,!c.(WGd!*23!./#%*1#'$04,!:&%!M*%#!*23!S#+)#4$#3!O0,#*,#,!c.MSOd<,

"-&!)#*1&/!T&*'O&![+%#,!b")T[cQ!"#/0&+&8!"-&/#J&<+31,!('/!)#*1&/!4<$+7J&,!

./#!(*24#%!W#2&5#!G$)*,!c.(WGd!0,!*!4&51%#/#2,09#!*23!4&&%302*$#3!#::&%$!$&!*44#)#%*$#!'23#%,$*2302+!&:!$/#!5&)#4')*%!+#2#$04!=*,0,!&:!4*24#%!$/%&'+/!$/#!*11)04*$0&2!&:!+#2&5#!*2*)6,0,!$#4/2&)&+0#,<!./#,#!$#4/2&)&+0#,!024)'3#!2#>$!+#2#%*$0&2!,#?'#2402+!1)*$:&%5,!*23!2*2&1&%#!$#4/2&)&+6;!*23!&$/#%!*39*24#,!%#?'0%02+!$/#!02$#+%*$0&2!&:!#2+02##%02+!70$/!=0&4/#50,$%6;!4/#50,$%6;!=0&02:&%5*$04,;!2*2&$#4/2&)&+6;!*23!1/6,04,<!G,!*!i&02$!#::&%$!&:!$/#!S*$0&2*)!(*24#%!D2,$0$'$#!cS(Dd!*23!$/#!S*$0&2*)!@'5*2!W#2&5#!M#,#*%4/!D2,$0$'$#;!.(WG!4'$,!*4%&,,!02,$0$'$0&2*)!)02#,!*,!7#))!*,!,40#2$0:04!30,401)02#,<!

J#+'2!02!]``V;!.(WG!0,!*)%#*36!60#)302+!051&%$*2$!2#7!:02302+,<!.(WG!029#,$0+*$&%,!%#4#2$)6!30,4&9#%#3!$/*$!$/#,5&,$!4&55&2!:&%5!&:!5*)0+2*2$!=%*02!4*24#%!02!*3')$,;!+)0&=)*,$&5*!5')$0:&%5#!cWJCd;!0,!2&$!*!,02+)#!30,#*,#!='$!02,$#*3!*11#*%,!$&!4&51%0,#!:&'%!30,$024$!5&)#4')*%!,'=$61#,<!M#,#*%4/#%,!*),&!:&'23!$/*$!%#,1&2,#!$&!*++%#,,09#!4/#5&$/#%*16!*23!%*30*$0&2!30::#%#3!=6!,'=$61#<!G++%#,,09#!$%#*$5#2$!7*,!5&,$!#::#4$09#!:&%!1*$0#2$,!70$/!&2#!1*%$04')*%!,'=$61#;!7/&!*11#*%#3!$&!,'44'5=!$&!$/#0%!30,#*,#!*$!*!%*$#!*11%&>05*$#)6!a`!1#%4#2$!,)&7#%!$/*2!1*$0#2$,!$%#*$#3!70$/!)#,,!*++%#,,09#!$/#%*16<!./#!#::#4$!7*,!)#,,!1%&2&'24#3!:&%!1*$0#2$,!70$/!$7&!&:!$/#!&$/#%!,'=$61#,;!*23!0$!7*,!2&$!1%#,#2$!*$!*))!:&%!1*$0#2$,!70$/!$/#!:&'%$/!,'=$61#<!./#,#!%#,')$,!5*6!)#*3!$&!5&%#!1#%,&2*)0b#3!*11%&*4/#,!$&!$%#*$02+!+%&'1,!&:!WJC!1*$0#2$,!=*,#3!&2!$/#0%!+#2&504!*)$#%*$0&2,<!./#!,$'36;!1'=)0,/#3!02!53/2#'$5#--;!1%&903#,!*!,&)03!:%*5#7&%B!:&%!029#,$0+*$02+!$*%+#$#3!$/#%*10#,!$/*$!5*6!051%&9#!$/#!1%&+2&,0,!:&%!1*$0#2$,!70$/!$/0,!4*24#%;!7/04/!0,!2#*%)6!*)7*6,!:*$*)<H:!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

H:$W?$e?$l&#.**[$&+$*J?1$`4(+&7#*+&N$e&("%'2$Q(*JP/'/$4N&(+')'&/$DJ'('2*JJP$W&J&K*(+$>-,+P0&/$")$

eJ'",J*/+"%*$D.*#*2+&#'m&N$,P$Q,("#%*J'+'&/$'($UCe!WQ1$4Cf=1$Ae!W1$*(N$@!=1a$I>-)$'!I$00!=E1$("?$=$Sc*(?$

=F1$;<=<V9$F:o==<?$!"#$*($@D4$(&M/$#&J&*/&$*,"-+$+.&$)'(N'(7/1$/&&$

.++09LL2*(2&#7&("%&?('.?7"KL%&N'*L7J'",J*/+"%*I/-,+P0&/?*/0?!

H6/'0/&,,!1#*!$&!d<31a!G-&*!

/&,&#/1-&/,!G3+-!83((&/&*+!

a*'G%&80&!$#,&,!#/&!&*1'</#0&8!+'!

1'O&!+'0&+-&/FK!

Page 30: Mit white paper on convergence

_M! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!G,!.(WGE,!30,4&9#%0#,!*=&'$!WJC!0))',$%*$#;!1%&+%#,,!4*2!=#!?'04B!7/#2!%#,#*%4/#%,!70$/!30::#%#2$!B2&7)#3+#!=*,#,!*%#!#24&'%*+#3!$&!4&5#!$&+#$/#%<!G,!4&29#%+#24#Q,$6)#!%#,#*%4/!,$%#$4/#,!=#6&23!+#2&504,!*23!=#4&5#,!5&%#!4&55&21)*4#!$/%&'+/&'$!SD@!*23!02!&$/#%!*+#240#,!*23!*4*3#504!4#2$#%,;!$/#!*39*24#,!*23!,&40#$*)!=#2#:0$,!$/*$!*%#!,'%#!$&!:&))&7!70))!:'%$/#%!3#5&2,$%*$#!$/#!9*)'#!&:!029#,$02+!02!5&%#!02$#+%*$#3!%#,#*%4/<!

"-&/#J&<+31,!('/!?#/&!#*8!D&0%&1+&8!@3,&#,&,!b"?D@cQ!N/3803*0!+-&!A#%%&7!'(!@&#+-!('/!T%'$#%!>&#%+-!

./#!./#%*1#'$04,!:&%!M*%#!*23!S#+)#4$#3!O0,#*,#,!c.MSOd!1%&+%*5!=#+*2!02!]``Z!*$!$/#!cSD@d!(/#504*)!W#2&504,!(#2$#%!cS(W(d<!.MSO!029#,$0+*$&%,!'$0)0b#!/0+/Q$/%&'+/1'$!$#4/2&)&+0#,!c%&=&$04,;!3*$*!1%&4#,,02+!*23!3*$*Q4&2$%&)!,&:$7*%#;!)0?'03Q/*23)02+!3#904#,;!*23!,#2,0$09#!3#$#4$&%,d!$&!?'04B)6!4&23'4$!50))0&2,!&:!=0&4/#504*);!+#2#$04;!&%!1/*%5*4&)&+04*)!$#,$,!&2!,5*))!5&)#4')#,!$/*$!/0$!30,#*,#Q5&30:602+!$*%+#$,<!./#!%#,')$,;!*!)0=%*%6!&:!&%+*204!4&51&'23,!&:!$/0,!4)*,,;!*%#!&:$#2!4*2303*$#,!:&%!',#!*,!1/*%5*4#'$04*),!&%!$*%+#$#3!$/#%*1#'$04,<!

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b#3!02!$/#!1%09*$#!,#4$&%8SD@!0,!1*902+!$/#!7*6!:&%!2#7!$%#*$5#2$,<HF!

D2!$/#!,/&%$!$05#!$/#!1%&+%*5!/*,!=##2!%'2202+;!029#,$0+*$&%,!/*9#!30,4&9#%#3!*!1&$#2$0*)!4&51&'23!$/*$!50+/$!=#!$/#!=*,0,!:&%!$%#*$02+!,4/0,$&,&50*,0,;!*),&!B2&72!*,!=0)/*%b0*!&%!,2*0)!:#9#%<!./0,!30,#*,#!*::#4$,!]`\!50))0&2!1#&1)#!7&%)3703#!*23!B0)),!]a`;```!#*4/!6#*%<!L'=)04Q/#*)$/!#>1#%$,!*%#!4&24#%2#3!$/*$!$/#!K4/0,$&,&5*!1*%*,0$#,!70))!=#4&5#!%#,0,$*2$!$&!*!4'%%#2$!3%'+!&:!4/&04#;!1%*b0?'*2$#);!7/04/!70))!$/#2!)&,#!0$,!#::#4$09#2#,,8*,!/*,!=##2!$/#!4*,#!70$/!*+#2$,!',#3!$&!4&5=*$!5*)*%0*;!$'=#%4')&,0,;!*23!5*26!&$/#%!02:#4$0&',!30,#*,#,<!G)$#%2*$09#!3%'+,!*%#!$/',!1&$#2$0*))6!&:!+%#*$!9*)'#;!2&$!&2)6!$&!$/#!\`!$%&104*)!2*$0&2,!7/#%#!$/#,#!30,#*,#,!*%#!1%#9*)#2$;!='$!*),&!$&!:&%#0+2Q*03!3&2&%,!)0B#!$/#!U<K<!!

J6!024&%1&%*$02+!4&51'$#%!,40#24#;!#2+02##%02+;!1/*%5*4&)&+6;!*23!=0&)&+6!02$&!&2#!4&24#%$#3!#::&%$;!.MSO!0,!*11%&*4/02+!,&)'$0&2,!$&!,&5#!&:!$/#!7&%)3E,!5&,$!&9#%)&&B#3!5#304*)!4&230$0&2,<!L#%/*1,!5&%#!051&%$*2$)6!:&%!$/#!4&29#%+#24#!5&3#);!$/#!.MSO!1%&+%*5!0,!1%&5&$02+!*!2#7!B023!&:!4&))*=&%*$0&2!*5&2+!*!=%&*3!2#$7&%B!&:!*4$&%,!$/*$!4'$,!*4%&,,!$%*30$0&2*)!%#,#*%4/!,$%'4$'%#,;!1'=)04Q1%09*$#!1*%$2#%,/01,;!*23!30,401)02#,<!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

HF$!"#$%"#&$'()"#%*+'"(1$/&&$`!#&g-&(+JP$Q/[&N$k-&/+'"(/a$*+$+.&$@4f$8))'2&$")$W*#&$C'/&*/&/$W&/&*#2.$

M&,/'+&1$.++09LL#*#&N'/&*/&/?'()"?('.?7"KL)'J&/L5W@C]!Qk/?0N)?!

Page 31: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ _S!

! !

;OJ%31#+3'*,!('/!+-&!P<+</&!

./#!4&29#%+#24#!%#9&)'$0&2!0,!*!,5*%$!029#,$5#2$!0:!7#!*%#!$&!B##1!&'%!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/!$/#!:02#,$!02!$/#!7&%)3;!*23!0:!7#!*%#!$&!#>$#23!1%&+%#,,!02!&$/#%!,40#2$0:04!*%#*,!*,!7#))<!./#!4&29#%+#24#!5&3#)!&::#%,!*!90,0&2!:&%!SD@!$/*$!70))!&24#!*+*02!4*1$'%#!$/#!05*+02*$0&2!*23!*),&!i',$0:6!4&2,0,$#2$!*23!1%&+%#,,09#!:'2302+!&:!$/#!*+#246<!!

L%&90302+!*3#?'*$#!:02*240*)!,'11&%$!:&%!02$#%30,401)02*%6!%#,#*%4/!0,!B#6;!='$!7#!5',$!*),&!#24&'%*+#!029#,$0+*$0&2!$/*$!4%&,,#,!#>0,$02+!=&'23*%0#,<!A/0)#!SD@!0,!1#%/*1,!$/#!5&,$!)0B#)6!)&4*)#!:&%!3%*5*$04!4&29#%+#24#Q3%09#2!*39*24#,;!*))!:#3#%*)!*+#240#,!,/&')3!7&%B!$&7*%3!,/*%#3!+&*),!=6!#5=%*402+!2&$!&2)6!02$#%30,401)02*%6!4&))*=&%*$0&2!='$!*),&!4%&,,Q*+#246!4&))*=&%*$0&2<!H&%$'2*$#)6;!(&2+%#,,!*)%#*36!%#4&+20b#,!$/#!051&%$*24#!&:!,'4/!02$#%*4$0&2<!D2!*!]``Z!%#1&%$;!:&%!#>*51)#;!$/#!K#2*$#!G11%&1%0*$0&2,!(&550$$##!,$*$#3-!

./#!(&550$$##!*11)*'3,!$/#!,'44#,,#,!7/04/!/*9#!=##2!*4/0#9#3!7/#2!$/#!O#1*%$5#2$!&:!N2#%+6!/*,!4&))*=&%*$#3!70$/!$/#!S*$0&2*)!D2,$0$'$#,!&:!@#*)$/!sSD@t<!./#,#!,'44#,,#,!024)'3#!$/#!/'5*2!+#2&5#!1%&i#4$;!*39*24#,!02!=0&02:&%5*$04,;!*23!=%#*B$/%&'+/,!02!*$&504!%#,&)'$0&2!,$%'4$'%*)!=0&)&+6<!./#!(&550$$##!,$%&2+)6!#24&'%*+#,!$/#!OFN!F::04#!&:!K40#24#!*23!$/#!S*$0&2*)!"*=&%*$&%0#,!$&!%#*4/!&'$!$&!$/#!SD@!$&!02,$0$'$0&2*)0b#!,#20&%!)#9#)!4&2$*4$,!70$/!$/#!+&*)!&:!03#2$0:602+!&11&%$'20$0#,!:&%!,',$*02#3!4&))*=&%*$0&2!02!%#,#*%4/!*23!3#9#)&15#2$<!./#!(&550$$##!2&$#,!$/*$!)&2+Q)*,$02+!%#)*$0&2,/01,!*%#!2#4#,,*%6!$&!='0)3!$/#!$61#,!&:!02$#+%*$#3!4&))*=&%*$09#!1%&+%*5,!$/*$!4&')3!=%02+!*=&'$!=%#*B$/%&'+/,!02!=0&5#304*)!05*+02+;!,6,$#5,!=0&)&+6;!*23!&$/#%!B#6!*%#*,!&:!%#,#*%4/<I<!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I<$>&(*+&$Q00#"0#'*+'"(/$D"%%'++&&1$K-$'97!>-5!C>&$'!P$/$0*4<$-&!A44'*4',>&,*-1!8,002!GVHV2$#&0"#+1$

===+.$D"(7?1$=/+$/&//?1$D"%%'++&&$U#'(+$===bI_9=<I1$.++09LL)#M&,7*+&?*22&//?70"?7"KL27'b

,'(L7&+N"2?27'\N,(*%&^===]2"(7]#&0"#+/sN"2'N^)9/#<I_?===?0N)?!

Page 32: Mit white paper on convergence

_U! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!

=F!?&1'OO&*8#+3'*,!

!

G,!7#E9#!#>1)*02#3;!$/#!%#4#2$!%#9&)'$0&2,!02!5&)#4')*%!*23!4#))')*%!=0&)&+6!*23!02!+#2&504,!4&2$02'#!$&!5*B#!4%'40*)!4&2$%0='$0&2,!$&!5#304*)!B2&7)#3+#!*23!/#*)$/!4*%#<!.&!4*10$*)0b#!&2!$/&,#!*39*24#,;!7#!2&7!2##3!$&!/##3!$/#!4*)),!:&%!*!2#7;!02$#+%*$#3!%#,#*%4/!5&3#)!*23!,'11&%$!*!$/0%3!%#9&)'$0&2;!$/#!4&29#%+#24#!&:!$/#!)0:#;!1/6,04*);!*23!#2+02##%02+!,40#24#,<!K#9#%*)!051&%$*2$!,$%*$#+0#,!*%#!&'$)02#3!=#)&7<!

EF!9*,</&!+-#+!)'*0/&,,3'*#%!(<*83*0!O&&+,!'/!$&#+,!N?@6;5!D;>^,!$3'O&831#%!

/&,&#/1-!3*(%#+3'*!O&+/315!#**<#%%7F!

H&%!$/#!1*,$!,#9#%*)!6#*%,;!*22'*)!SD@!:'2302+!)#9#),!/*9#!:*0)#3!$&!B##1!'1!70$/!$/#!SD@!=0&5#304*)!%#,#*%4/!02:)*$0&2!5#$%04!cJMOLDd<!J'3+#$*%6!,$%*02,;!4&'1)#3!70$/!*2!*)%#*36!4&2,#%9*$09#!1##%Q%#90#7!,6,$#5;!5#*2!$/*$!022&9*$09#!%#,#*%4/!*11%&*4/#,!*%#!)0B#)6!$&!+&!'2:'23#3!02!:*9&%!&:!5&%#!1%#304$*=)#;!024%#5#2$*)!%#,#*%4/<!!

(&2,0,$#2$!:'2302+!)#9#),!70))!*))&7!SD@!$&!1)*2!*23!024&%1&%*$#!*!5&%#!1%&50,02+!*23!309#%,0:0#3Q%0,B!%#,#*%4/!1&%$:&)0&<!D2!*330$0&2;!02!$05#,!&:!#4&2&504!%#4#,,0&2;!7/#2!=#*$02+!$/#!JMOLD!5*6!2&$!=#!1&,,0=)#;!:'2302+!:&%!#>$%*5'%*)!+%*2$,!*23!:)#>0=)#!:'2302+!1%&+%*5,!)0B#!$/#!(&55&2!H'23!,/&')3!=#!1%&$#4$#3!*,!$/#!)*,$!02!)02#!:&%!4'$,<!!

_F!9,+#$%3,-!#!1'*.&/0&*1&!&1',7,+&O!$7!$<3%83*0!1'**&1+3'*,!#1/',,!

,+'.&J3J&8!,7,+&O,F$

K40#2$0:04!%#,#*%4/!/*,!/0,$&%04*))6!=##2!:'23#3!02!,#1*%*$#!,$&9#101#,!=6!,40#24#Q50,,0&2!*+#240#,;!024)'302+!$/#!S*$0&2*)!K40#24#!H&'23*$0&2;!$/#!O#1*%$5#2$!&:!N2#%+6;!$/#!O#1*%$5#2$!&:!O#:#2,#;!*23!$/#!S*$0&2*)!D2,$0$'$#,!&:!@#*)$/<!D2!*%#*,!7/#%#!4&))*=&%*$0&2!4*2!=#!/0+/)6!1%&3'4$09#;!&'%!:'2302+!*+#240#,;!2&$!i',$!&'%!,40#2$0,$,;!,/&')3!=#4&5#!4&))*=&%*$&%,<!./*$!5#*2,!$*)B02+!$&!&2#!*2&$/#%;!i&02$)6!03#2$0:602+!$/#!*%#*,!&:!+%#*$#,$!&11&%$'20$6!*,!7#))!*,!$/#!$&1!,40#2$0:04!4/*))#2+#,;!*23!3#9#)&102+!4&55&2!,$%*$#+0#,!:&%!1%&+%#,,<!!

K&5#$02$#%*+#246!%#,#*%4/!3&#,!$*B#!1)*4#;!='$!,'4/!1%&i#4$,!,##5!$&!3#1#23!&2!02:&%5*)!:%0#23,/01,!&%!&2!,)&7)6!#,$*=)0,/#3!7&%B02+!%#)*$0&2,/01,!=#$7##2!0230903'*),!02!9*%0&',!*+#240#,<!C#4/*20,5,!$&!#2*=)#!*23!:&,$#%!,'4/!4&22#4$0&2,!2##3!$&!=#!02,$0$'$0&2*)0b#3<!!

./#!SD@!(/*))#2+#!W%*2$,;!7/04/!*%#!*9*0)*=)#!$&!029#,$0+*$&%,!:%&5!&'$,03#!SD@;!*%#!*!+&&3!:0%,$!,$#1<!./#!2#>$!,$#1!50+/$!024)'3#!024%#*,02+!&11&%$'20$0#,!:&%!

Page 33: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ _W!

! !#>1#%0#24#3!:#3#%*)!*+#246!%#,#*%4/#%,!$&!$*B#!&2!,/&%$Q$#%5!*,,0+25#2$,!02!&$/#%!%#,#*%4/!*+#240#,<!H&%!#>*51)#;!$/02BQ$*2B!#290%&25#2$,!4&')3!=#!#,$*=)0,/#3!70$/02!#*4/!%#,#*%4/!*+#246;!*23!*+#246!3#$*0)##,!:%&5!*4%&,,!$/#!#>#4'$09#!=%*24/!4&')3!=#!0290$#3!$&!90,0$!:&%!,#9#%*)!5&2$/,!*23!4&))*=&%*$#!&2!$/#!%#,#*%4/!1%0&%0$0#,!&:!$/#!/&,$!02,$0$'$0&2<!./0,!50+/$!=#!4&&%302*$#3!=6!$/#!S*$0&2*)!K40#24#!*23!.#4/2&)&+6!(&'240)<!!

A#!*),&!,'++#,$!$/*$!$/#!F::04#!&:!K40#24#!*23!.#4/2&)&+6!L&)046!024)'3#!4&29#%+#24#!*,!*!4%0$04*)!#2*=)02+!,40#2$0:04!5&3#)!02!*!(*=02#$Q703#!020$0*$09#!&2!$/#!)*%+#%!=0&)&+6!#4&2&56<!./0,!#::&%$!7&')3!/#)1!4&*)#,4#!4&29#%+#24#!#>1#%$,!*23!#>1&,#!%#,#*%4/!&11&%$'20$0#,;!5'4/!*,!$/#!S*$0&2*)!S*2&$#4/2&)&+6!D20$0*$09#!cSSDd!*23!$/#!@0+/!L#%:&%5*24#!(&51'$02+!*23!(&55'204*$0&2,!c@L((d!#::&%$!/*9#!4&&%302*$#3!*23!,1'%%#3!*4$090$6!02!2*2&$#4/2&)&+6;!*23!4&51'$02+!%#,1#4$09#)6<!

:F!?&('/O!J&&/Y/&.3&G!J/'1&,,&,!+'!,<JJ'/+!3*+&/83,13J%3*#/7!0/#*+,F!

L##%!%#90#7!*$!SD@!/*,!)&2+!1)*6#3!*!4%0$04*)!%&)#!02!$/#!,'44#,,!&:!$/#!U<K<!%#,#*%4/!#2$#%1%0,#!02!$#%5,!&:!=&$/!#2*=)02+!5#304*)!*39*24#,!*23!,'11&%$02+!$/#!=0&5#304*)!#4&2&504!,#4$&%<!@&7#9#%;!*2!024%#*,02+)6!4&2,#%9*$09#!1##%Q%#90#7!,6,$#5!70))!)#*3!$&!50,,#3!&11&%$'20$0#,<!!

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

(#%$*02!#::&%$,!$/*$!/*9#!*)%#*36!,$*%$#3!,/&')3!=#!02,$0$'$0&2*)0b#3!*23!#>1*23#3<!./#,#!024)'3#!$/#!3#9#)&15#2$!*23!'$0)0b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i#4$,<!!

./#%#!5*6!=#!*330$0&2*)!7*6,!$&!*3*1$!$/#!#>0,$02+!1##%Q%#90#7!,6,$#5!:&%!4&29#%+#24#<!.&!#>1)&%#!$/#!1&,,0=0)0$0#,;!*!+%&'1!&:!#>1#%$,!02!$/#!SD@!1##%Q%#90#7!1%&4#,,!,/&')3!=#!=%&'+/$!$&+#$/#%<!

Page 34: Mit white paper on convergence

:Z! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!

=F!N#%#*1&!%#/0&Y,1#%&!&(('/+,!G3+-!,O#%%&/!0/#*+!J/'`&1+,F!

D230903'*)!029#,$0+*$&%;!MF[Q,$6)#!+%*2$,!:&%!,5*))#%!1%&i#4$,!*%#!*!$05#Q/&2&%#3;!%#,1#4$#3!$%*30$0&2<!K5*))!1%&i#4$,!&:$#2!)#*3!$&!022&9*$0&2!*23!2#7!30,4&9#%0#,;!*23!,'11&%$!:&%!$/#5!,/&')3!4&2$02'#<!G$!$/#!,*5#!$05#;!0$!0,!90$*)!$&!*),&!30%#4$!%#,&'%4#,!$&!)*%+#Q,4*)#!1%&i#4$,!$/*$!024)'3#!5')$01)#!1%02401*)!029#,$0+*$&%,<!./#,#!'23#%$*B02+,!*))&7!%#,#*%4/#%,!:%&5!5*26!30,401)02#,!$&!4&23'4$!,6,$#5*$04!02?'0%0#,!02$&!+#2#%*)!$*%+#$!*%#*,!7/0)#!1'%,'02+!$/#0%!&72!,1#40:04!02$#%#,$,<!!

K024#!4&))*=&%*$0&2!*23!022&9*$0&2!02!%#,#*%4/!5#$/&3,!*%#!5&%#!30::04')$!0:!0230903'*)!%#,#*%4/#%,!*%#!0,&)*$#3!02!,#1*%*$#!3#1*%$5#2$,!*$!$/#0%!02,$0$'$0&2,;!7#!,'++#,$!$/#!:&'2302+!&:!4&29#%+#24#!4#2$#%,!*$!02,$0$'$0&2,!*4%&,,!$/#!4&'2$%6!$/*$!7&')3!024)'3#!5')$01)#!1%02401*)!029#,$0+*$&%,<!G!+%&'1!&:!*+#246!*23!*4*3#504!#>1#%$,!,/&')3!4&29#2#!*23!',#!*!,6,$#5,!*11%&*4/!$&!3#,0+2!$/#,#!4#2$#%,!*%&'23!2*$0&2*)!%#,#*%4/!1%0&%0$0#,<!!

LF!;OJ/'.&!3*+&/83,13J%3*#/7!/&,&#/1-!#O'*0!+-&!_S!D;>!3*,+3+<+&,!#*8!1&*+&/,F!

SD@!#9&)9#3!:&))&702+!A&%)3!A*%!DD!02!%#,1&2,#!$&!*2!*,,'51$0&2!$/*$!$/#!1*$/7*6!$&!5#304*)!,&)'$0&2,!:&%!#*4/!30,#*,#!7&')3!=#!'20?'#!$&!$/*$!30,#*,#<!@&7#9#%;!$/#!5&)#4')*%!*23!+#2#$04!%#9&)'$0&2,!/*9#!$*'+/$!',!$/*$!4%&,,Q4'$$02+!%#,#*%4/!4*2!1%&3'4#!*39*24#,!$/*$!70))!*::#4$!5*26!30,#*,#,<!SD@E,!30,#*,#Q4#2$#%#3!5&3#)!7*,!2&$!&%+*20b#3!$&!*44&55&3*$#!$/0,!*11%&*4/<!N*4/!&:!$/#!*+#246E,!]\!02,$0$'$#,!*23!4#2$#%,!cD(,d!/*,!0$,!&72!%#,#*%4/!*+#23*!*23!$#23,!$&!&1#%*$#!*'$&2&5&',)6<!!

K024#!]``V;!$/#!SD@!(&55&2!H'23!/*,!,'11&%$#3!$%*2,QSD@!%#,#*%4/;!='$!$/0,!#::&%$!2##3,!$&!=#!=%&*3#%<!./#!4'%%#2$!5#4/*20,5,!:&%!D(,!$&!4&))*=&%*$#!&2!5')$030,401)02*%6!+%*2$,!,/&')3!=#!%##>*502#3;!*23!*!5&%#!#::#4$09#!,6,$#5!,/&')3!=#!3#90,#3<$C#*27/0)#;!$/#!(&55&2!H'23!4*2!=#!*2!020$0*)!$&&)!$&!#24&'%*+#!4&29#%+#24#!%#,#*%4/!02!1%&50,02+!*%#*,<$

MF!98<1#+&5!&XJ#*85!#*8!,<JJ'/+!+-&!*&X+!0&*&/#+3'*!'(!1'*.&/0&*1&!

/&,&#/1-&/,F!!

U209#%,0$0#,!024%#*,02+)6!'23#%,$*23!$/*$!$/#!5#%+#%!&:!,40#2$0:04!*23!#2+02##%02+!:0#)3,!0,!*!%#*)0$6!*23!70))!=#!$/#!:'$'%#!&:!$/#!)0:#!,40#24#!#2$#%1%0,#<!S#7!#::&%$,!2##3!$&!=#!'23#%$*B#2!$&!#3'4*$#!$/#!2#>$!+#2#%*$0&2!&:!%#,#*%4/#%,!$&!7&%B!02!4%&,,Q30,401)02*%6!:0#)3,<!A/0)#!*!3##1!30,401)02*%6!=*4B+%&'23!%#5*02,!90$*);!024)'302+!*!%&=',$!4%&,,Q30,401)02*%6!#3'4*$0&2!0,!#,,#2$0*)!*330$0&2*)!1%#1*%*$0&2!:&%!&'%!:'$'%#!,40#2$0,$,!*23!051&%$*2$!:&%!%#,#*%4/!4*%##%,<!!

F2#!%#4&55#23*$0&2!0,!$&!&::#%!5&%#!%#,#*%4/!$%*0202+!+%*2$,!$&!#24&'%*+#!02,$0$'$0&2,!$&!3#9#)&1!2#7!4&'%,#,n1%&+%*5,!$/*$!1%#1*%#!,$'3#2$,;!1&,$3&4$&%*)!%#,#*%4/#%,;!*23!:#))&7,!:&%!4&29#%+#24#Q3%09#2!%#,#*%4/<!./0,!5#*2,!4%#*$02+!2#7!4'%%04')*;!*11%#2$04#,/01,;!*23!$%*0202+!1%&+%*5,!$&!#2*=)#!4%&,,Q30,401)02*%6!#>1#%$0,#<!

Page 35: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ :E!

! !D2!*330$0&2;!7#!5',$!,$%#2+$/#2!$/#!101#)02#!&:!:'$'%#!%#,#*%4/#%,!=6!*33%#,,02+!$/#!309#%,0$6!1%&=)#5!02!&'%!#3'4*$0&2*)!,6,$#5<!G44&%302+!$&!*!%#4#2$!%#1&%$;!&2)6![Z!1#%4#2$!&:!6&'2+!1#&1)#!:%&5!:*50)0#,!70$/!024&5#,!=#)&7!l]a;```!&=$*02!*!4&55'20$6!4&))#+#!3#+%##!&%!/0+/#%;!4&51*%#3!70$/!\V!1#%4#2$!:%&5!:*50)0#,!70$/!024&5#,!&:!l\V;```!&%!5&%#<I=!D$!0,!4)#*%!$/*$!7#!*%#!50,,02+!&'$!&2!*!)*%+#!1&&)!&:!1&$#2$0*)!$*)#2$<!A#!2##3!$&!4&2$02'#!#::&%$,!$&!#2+*+#!*!=%&*3!%*2+#!&:!6&'2+!1#&1)#!02!K40#24#;!.#4/2&)&+6;!N2+02##%02+;!*23!C*$/!cK.NCd!:0#)3,<!!

.&!$/*$!#23;!4*%#:')!4&2,03#%*$0&2!,/&')3!=#!+09#2!$&!$/#!%#4&55#23*$0&2,!4&2$*02#3!02!$7&!%#4#2$!,$'30#,<!F2#!0,!*!]``Z!%#1&%$!=6!$/#!(&'240)!&2!W%*3'*$#!K4/&&),;!$0$)#3!6',34#/&/7$D3')&2&?3)&,/$&/$<'34.3)#$U4.23)&,/V$7/04/!&'$)02#,!7*6,!$&!03#2$0:6!*23!4')$09*$#!$*)#2$#3!,$'3#2$,!:%&5!+%&'1,!$/*$!*%#!$%*30$0&2*))6!'23#%%#1%#,#2$#3!02!,40#24#!*23!#2+02##%02+!+%*3'*$#!1%&+%*5,9$./#!&$/#%!%#1&%$;!<#/4#'$F&@@#'#/2#($3)$5'&)&23-$!'3/(&)&,/($&/$)"#$53'##'($,@$;2&#/2#V$U/7&/##'&/7V$3/4$

13)"#=3)&2($%32.-)8!c%#)#*,#3!=6!$/#!S*$0&2*)!G4*3#50#,!02!]`[`d;!,'++#,$,!,1#40:04!,$%*$#+0#,!:&%!*4/0#902+!+#23#%!#?'*)0$6!&2!$/#!K.NC!:*4')$6!4*%##%!1*$/<!

D2!*330$0&2!$&!#::&%$,!#24&'%*+02+!6&'2+!1#&1)#!$&!1'%,'#!K.NC!4*%##%,;!)#+0,)*$0&2!0,!2##3#3!$&!#2*=)#!G5#%04*!$&!3%*7!*23!%#$*02!=%0))0*2$!%#,#*%4/#%,!:%&5!*4%&,,!$/#!+)&=#<!H&%!#>*51)#;!*2!#2/*24#3!@Q[J!T0,*!cL%&:#,,0&2*)!02!*!K1#40*)$6!F44'1*$0&2d!7&')3!#2*=)#!$*)#2$#3!2&2QG5#%04*2,!#3'4*$#3!*$!&'%!:02#,$!02,$0$'$0&2,!$&!:023!*!1*$/!$&!40$0b#2,/01!7/0)#!$/#6!7&%B!$&!#2/*24#!&'%!#4&2&56!*23!&'%!022&9*$0&2!#4&,6,$#5<!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I=!U*-J$8/+&#%*(1$`D"JJ&7&$)"#$QJJ\$5.&$Z*,"#$3*#[&+$)"#$D"JJ&7&bAN-2*+&N$6"#[&#/1a$#&0"#+$)"#$+.&$

D&(+&#$)"#$Q%&#'2*($U#"7#&//1$Q-7?$;<<:1$

.++09LLMMM?*%&#'2*(0#"7#&//?"#7L'//-&/L;<<:L<:L2"JJ&7&])"#]*JJ?.+%J<!

Page 36: Mit white paper on convergence

:_! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!

)2B4;DT!

!

./#!5#%+#%!&:!$/#!)0:#;!#2+02##%02+;!*23!1/6,04*)!,40#24#,!1%&50,#,!$&!:'23*5#2$*))6!*)$#%!*23!,1##3!&'%!,40#2$0:04!$%*i#4$&%6<!SD@!*23!&$/#%!*::#4$#3!*+#240#,;!0:!*3#?'*$#)6!:'23#3!*23!5*3#!%#*36;!4*2!=#!$/&'+/$!)#*3#%,!02!$/0,!2#>$!,40#2$0:04!%#9&)'$0&2<!./#!$05#!0,!%0+/$!:&%!SD@!*23!&$/#%!*+#240#,!$&!$*B#!'1!4&29#%+#24#!*,!$/#!7*9#!&:!$/#!:'$'%#;!4%#*$02+!3%*5*$04!2#7!&11&%$'20$0#,!02!5#30402#!:&%!2#7!$/#%*10#,!*23!30*+2&,$04,;!#4&2&504!&11&%$'20$6;!*,!7#))!*,!1%&50,#!02!5*26!&$/#%!,40#2$0:04!:0#)3,;!:%&5!#2#%+6!$&!4)05*$#!$&!*+%04')$'%#<!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 37: Mit white paper on convergence

"-&!)'*.&/0&*1&!'(!+-&!23(&!413&*1&,5!6-7,31#%!413&*1&,5!#*8!9*03*&&/3*0$ ::!

! !!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 38: Mit white paper on convergence

:=! ">9!">;?@!?9AB2C";BD!

!!

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

!"#$%"#&$'()"#%*+'"($*,"-+$+.'/$#&0"#+1$

2"(+*2+$+.&$345$6*/.'(7+"($8))'2&9$

:;<$=/+$>+?$@A1$>+&?$B=<$

6*/.'(7+"(1$CD$;<<<;$

;<;?E:F?=:;:$GG$B=E?H;I?FF:=!

Page 39: Mit white paper on convergence

Convergence.cover.final 12/13/10 10:04 AM Page 4

Page 40: Mit white paper on convergence

Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyWashington DC Office820 First Street NE, Suite 610Washington, DC 20002

202-789-1828

http://web.mit.edu/dc/

10-11-0527

Convergence.cover.final 12/13/10 10:04 AM Page 1