Rochester ward options

Current Wards

Current total % dev minority % minority 1 18,932 6.4% 3,372 17.8% 2 17,863 0.4% 3,230 18.1% 3 23,265 30.7% 4,899 21.1% 4 16,668 -‐6.3% 5,206 31.2% 5 16,161 -‐9.2% 2,734 16.9% 6 13,880 -‐22.0% 2,720 19.6%

total 106,769 22,161 20.8% 9,385 30.7% 2,486 14.3%

max-‐min max %dev max-‐min max-‐min

Council RedistricCng Principles •  Balance populaCon among wards based on 2010 populaCon (based on past decade, this would result in 2012 Ward 3 popula9on high by 6%)

•  Make wards compact and conCguous •  Comply with the VoCng Rights Act •  Protect neighborhood integrity •  Avoid cracking (diluCon) and packing (over-‐concentraCon) of minority and low income voters

Other RedistricCng Principles

•  Minimize confusion •  Change as liTle as possible, consistent with principles

•  Follow logical boundaries (rivers, freeways, and other barriers to interacCon

•  Balance the inconvenience

OpCon 2

OpCon 2

OpCon 2

opCon 2 1 2 3 4 5 6 total

total 17,433 18,199 18,100 17,575 17,484 17,978 106,769 766

% dev -‐2.03% 2.27% 1.71% -‐1.24% -‐1.75% 1.03% 2.27%

nhwa 14,829 14,923 14,327 11,788 14,336 14,405 84,608

minority 2,604 3,276 3,773 5,787 3,148 3,573 22,161 3,183

% min 14.9% 18.0% 20.8% 32.9% 18.0% 19.9% 20.8% 18.0%

moved in 438 1,022 0 1,937 1,323 4,124 8,844

moved out 1,937 686 5,165 1,030 0 26 8,844 total change 2,375 1,708 5,165 2,967 1,323 4,150 8,844 8.28%

OpCon 5

OpCon 5

OpCon 5

opCon 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 total measure

total 17,629 17,925 17,774 17,794 17,738 17,909 106,769 296

% dev -‐0.93% 0.73% -‐0.12% 0.00% -‐0.32% 0.64% 0.93%

nhwa 15,074 14,727 14,118 11,848 14,594 14,247 84,608

minority 2,555 3,198 3,656 5,946 3,144 3,662 22,161 3,391

% min 14.5% 17.8% 20.6% 33.4% 17.7% 20.4% 18.9%

moved in 748 659 0 2,192 1,718 4,450 9,767

moved out 2,051 597 5,491 1,066 141 421 9,767

total change 2,799 1,256 5,491 3,258 1,859 4,871 9,767 9.15%

OpCon 1

OpCon 1

OpCon 1


total 18,078 17,984 17,292 17,820 17,527 18,068 106,769 786

% dev 1.6% 1.1% -‐2.8% 0.1% -‐1.5% 1.5% 2.83%

nhwa 15,517 14,703 14,305 11,799 14,699 13,585 84,608

minority 2,561 3,281 2,987 6,021 2,828 4,483 22,161 3,460

% min 14.2% 18.2% 17.3% 33.8% 16.1% 24.8% 20.8% 19.6%

moved in 2,082 2,052 0 2,936 2,040 3,963 13,073

moved out 2,936 1,931 5,748 1,784 674 0 13,073

total change 5,018 3,983 5,748 4,720 2,714 3,963 13,073 12.24%

OpCon 3

OpCon 3

OpCon 3


total 17,876 17,690 17,981 17,515 17,968 17,739 106,769 466

% dev 0.46% -‐0.59% 1.05% -‐1.57% 0.97% -‐0.31% 1.57%

nhwa 15,250 14,718 14,645 11,565 14,878 13,552 84,608

minority 2,626 2,972 3,336 5,950 3,090 4,187 22,161 3,324

% min 14.7% 16.8% 18.6% 34.0% 17.2% 23.6% 20.8% 19.3%

moved in 569 2,051 0 2,143 3,359 3,859 11,981

moved out 1,625 2,224 5,284 1,296 1,552 0 11,981

total change 2,194 4,275 5,284 3,439 4,911 3,859 11,981 11.2%

OpCon 4

OpCon 4

OpCon 4


total 17,656 17,700 17,981 17,725 17,968 17,739 106,769 325

% dev -‐0.78% -‐0.53% 1.05% -‐0.39% 0.97% -‐0.31% 1.05%

nhwa 15,077 14,703 14,645 11,753 14,878 13,552 84,608

minority 2,579 2,997 3,336 5,972 3,090 4,187 22,161 3,393

% min 14.6% 16.9% 18.6% 33.7% 17.2% 23.6% 20.8% 19.1%

moved in 349 2,240 0 2,143 3,359 3,859 11,950

moved out 1,625 2,403 5,284 1,086 1,552 0 11,950

total change 1,974 4,643 5,284 3,229 4,911 3,859 11,950 11.2%

OpCon 6

OpCon 6


total 17,419 17,573 18,089 17,879 17,806 18,003 106,769 670

% dev -‐2.1% -‐1.2% 1.7% 0.5% 0.1% 1.2% 2.11%

nhwa 14,901 14,350 14,631 11,901 15,054 13,771 84,608

minority 2,518 3,223 3,458 5,978 2,752 4,232 22,161 3,460

% min 14.5% 18.3% 19.1% 33.4% 15.5% 23.5% 20.8% 19.0%

moved in 748 2,213 2,154 2,892 2,917 6,289 17,213

moved out 2,261 2,503 7,330 1,681 1,272 2,166 17,213

total change 3,009 4,716 9,484 4,573 4,189 8,455 17,213 16.12%

OpCon 6

Comparison

OpCon max deviaCon minority

range populaCon

shiVed 1 2.83% 19.6% 13,073 2 2.27% 18.0% 8,844 3 1.57% 19.3% 11,981 4 1.05% 19.1% 11,950 5 0.93% 18.9% 9,767 6 2.11% 19.0% 17,213

Business

Rochester ward options