Strategy and Reward; why does Business plan for the future but reward for the past?

  • Published on
    24-Jan-2015

  • View
    706

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Paul Williams; Former President of the Smith& Nephew subsidiary company in Japan and member of the Senior Civil Service Pay Review Body (SSRB), presented on "Strategy and Reward; why does Business plan for the future but reward for the past?" at Warwick Business School 25/02/2008

Transcript

  • 1. WHY does business plan for the FUTUREbut reward for the PAST? Paul Williams, Warwick Business School 25 February 2008 STRATEGY AND REWARD

2. PAUL WILLIAMS CV 5 RADICAL CHANGE SCENARIOS

  • WHO WHAT WHY
  • NCR Data Processing Technology
  • HEINZ Food Retail Superbrands
  • GLAXO Pharmaceuticals Generics
  • ROLLS ROYCE Engineering Market
  • SMITH & NEPHEW Medical Devices Technology
  • SMITH & NEPHEW JapanCulture

3. TYPICALWOWSTATISTICS

  • In 1992top US CEOs were paid 82 x blue collar pay
    • $2.7 million
  • In 2004top US CEOs were paid 400 x blue collar pay
    • $14.7 million

Professor Robert Daine - Stanford Graduate School of Business 4. THE BIG ISSUE

  • The relentless focus onHOW MUCHChief Executive Officers are paid diverts public attention from the real problem:
  • HOWthey are paid

Michael Jensen & Kevin Murphy HBR 5. CLASSIC PROFILEOF EXECUTIVE REWARD STRUCTURE

  • Element Objective Timeframes
  • BASE PAY Personal targets -currentannual/quarter
  • Business targets -current annual/quarter
  • BONUS Profit targets -currentannual
  • Revenue targets -currentannual
  • ROCE targets -currentannual
  • Margin targets -currentannual
  • LONG TERM Stock price -
  • Earnings per share -retrospectivethree
  • Total shareholder return -year roll-up

6. CLASSIC QUANTUMOF CEO REWARD (UK)

  • FTSE 30 FTSE 31-100 Source
  • Median Base979k 690k (1)
  • Bonus Target 636k 448k (2)
  • LTIP Expected Value2075k 669k (1)
  • 3,690k1,807k
  • The Changing Face of Senior Executive Remuneration (New Bridge Street 2007 Report)
  • Deloittes Executive Directors Remuneration 2007 Guide

7. LONG TERM PERFORMANCE - UK

  • Performance Share Plansare currently in operation in 86% of FTSE 100 Companies
  • TSRis the most popular PSP metric 85% of FTSE 100 plans
  • Median actual awardto FTSE directors is 130% of base salary

Deloitte Executive Directors Remuneration Guide 2007 8. LONG TERM PERFORMANCE US TOP 250 Category Performance Measures Percent of Companies Using Profit Earnings per share, net income 51% EBIT/EBITDA, operating income pretax profit Total Shareholder Return Stock price appreciation plus dividends 38% Efficiency Return on equity, return on assets,34% return on operating income, return on capital, economic value added Other Cash flow, revenue growth,28% discretionary, individual performance Frederic W. Cook & Co. Inc. 9. WHAT ARE THE REASONS FOR THISSHORT TERMISM ?

  • Financials are concrete and easy to communicate
  • CFO and analysts are most comfortable with these numbers
  • Recent corporate governance initiatives discourage subjectivity
  • Relatively short-term tenure of CEOs undermines long-term perspective
  • Stock options as a proxy for success encourage simplistic metrics
  • Current reward structures have served incumbents well

Parc 2007 Report: Resilience How Companies prepare for Success in the Future 10. Top managers and the main players in the financial markets have tended to become part of a system of connected and symbiotic interests.This system, whilst informal, is coherent and well understood by insiders and can create huge opportunities for rewarding the players Don Young, Founder YSC 11. THE COMMON LIFE CYCLE ALL THINGS Maturity Birth Maturity Demise Renewal 12.

  • Growth
  • Feed the top line
  • Organisation vitality
  • Investment mentality
  • High engagement & trust
  • Expanding
  • Acquisition

CLASSIC GROWTHvMATURITY MODEL

  • Maturity
  • Protect the bottom line
  • Operational efficiency
  • Cost mentality
  • Caution & control
  • Downsizing
  • Divestment

13. THE NEED: A NEW FRAME OF REFERENCE FOR REWARD STRATEGY

  • SUSTAINABILITY
    • the ability of the organisation to sustain its current business model
  • RESILIENCE
    • the organisations ability to dynamically reinvent its business model as circumstances change

Professor Sir Andrew Likierman - LBS 14. THE COMMON LIFE CYCLE ALL THINGS Maturity Birth Maturity Demise Renewal 15. SUSTAINABILITY (S) ANDRESILIENCE(R) DEMAND DIFFERENT METRICS WITHIN A TYPICAL STRATEGY MODEL

  • Time Horizon Drivers Metrics
  • SHORT operating efficiency Profit (S)
  • cost control Revenue (S)
  • sales initiatives ROCE (S)
  • MID customer focus ??? (S) & (R)
  • product development
  • marketing initiatives
  • LONG technology bets ??? (R)
  • research bets
  • strategic initiatives

16. A REALITY CHECK 6 CASE STUDIES

  • ENRON : leaders consumed by wealth creation
  • NORTHERN ROCK : risk assessment sidelined by growth sirens
  • GSK : expansion at huge shareholder cost
  • ICI : an iconic brand: died January 2008: RIP
  • Cadbury-Schweppes : Nelson Peltz and shareholder activism
  • BRIC 2015 : will the same rules apply?

17. BUT NO ROOM FOR COMPLACENCY:the number of Emerging Economy companies in the Fortune Global 500 2003 2006 2010 20 40 ? - - - Challenging old approaches to strategy & organisation Led by Brazil, Russia, India & China 18. BUT WHO CARES?

  • INVESTORS?
  • EXECUTIVES?
  • ACADEMICS?
  • CORPORATE GOVERNANCE BODIES?
  • BUSINESS COMMUNITY?
  • GOVERNMENT?

19. SOME POSITIVE IDEAS FOR DEBATE & FURTHER RESEARCH

  • THE DOMINANT SHORT TERM CITY MINDSET CAN BE CHANGED
  • NED ROLE SHOULD BE MORE INTRUSIVE
  • CORPORATE GOVERNANCE BODIES SHOULD ADD MORE VALUE
  • HR EXECUTIVES SHOULD STAND UP AND BE COUNTED

20.

  • THE DOMINANT SHORT TERM CITY MINDSET CAN BE CHANGED

In 2004 the Enhanced Analytics Initiative (EAI) was launched by institutional investors to examine the obstacles to investors taking a longer term and more rounded assessment of corporate performance in particular to take a hard look at the current focus of much sell-side research. In City jargon the intention is to give more emphasis to extra-financials and intangibles which in the words of Peter Moon, CIO of one of the founding members (USS Ltd) can account for a significant proportion of the value of a company, especially over the long term. Current members of EAI include amongst others; ABP Pension Fund BNP Paribas Asset Management BT Pension Scheme Hermes Pensions Management Investec asset Management Deutscher Investment Trust/Dresdnerbank Investment Management Universities Superannuation Scheme EAI member institutions collectively own or manage more than US$ 2.6 trillion in assets 21.

  • NED ROLE SHOULD BE MORE INTRUSIVE
    • Board role can learn from Private Equity model
      • Buy, build, and sell strategy
      • Flexible ownership mindset
      • Stronger Chairman role
    • Remuneration Committee should be pro-active/demanding on strategy metrics
  • CORPORATE GOVERNANCE BODIES SHOULD ADD MORE VALUE
    • Should worry less about fat cats
    • Should worry more about relevant growth and strategy delivery
    • Should establish and promote best practice

22.

  • HR EXECUTIVES SHOULD STAND UP AND BE COUNTED
    • Exploit their exposure to RemCo and NEDS
    • Utilise their technical expertise to design better schemes, e.g.
      • 5 year vesting with better use of ROIC
      • Bigger retained shareholding for executives
      • Strategic targets for CEO and CFO
      • Significant metrics for talent management
      • Negative penalties for non-achievement escrow accounts and bonus deferral
      • Sharpening of objectives clarity
      • Higher profile for risk assessment
      • Influencing the CEO/CFO to sell a broader picture to analysts

23. TWO QUOTES FROM MICHAEL PORTER

  • In essence the job of the strategist is to understand and cope with competition.Often, however, managers define competition too narrowly as if it occurred only amongst todays direct competitors.
  • The conversation between investors and executives (should) focus on thestructuralnot thetransient .Imagine the improvement in company performance and in the economy as a whole if all the energy expended in pleasing the Street were redirected towards the factors that createtrue economic value

HBR January 2008 24. AND FINALLY

  • NOT EVERYTHING THAT COUNTS
  • can be counted
  • NOT EVERYTHING THAT CAN BE COUNTED
  • counts

Albert Einstein

Recommended

View more >