12

A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

� ��������� � ��������������� �����������! ��" ���#�$� �����&%����'���( ��*)+����, �-.�#����0/1�(�'�2�����3 �����

4,57698;:�<=6?>�@�:A6A576?>A<=B�C�D?EF576AG=HAI

J,K3LFM�NPORQ&K3STO.UWVYXZUWQ&L\[]ORK^N�_=`3abK3S]`3KcdUWNPORefX�M�NRUhgbabSFM�_iOjM�ORKlk,S]abmnKoNRpPaqOsr

tWtnu&vYw,x�Xdy{z3|=z}|�~�Ma�SfX�MWQ&L\[]p.J,NRabmnKx,Mg�Koa��We{y\c�X��h�uh�h���s�h��Wt]yAkl_]��}�n�h�����=�]�h���T�h�]���n�T�T�{���]�n�����s�h�h�

 �¡£¢3¤3¥�¦F§W¤h¨&© NR[]pªOlabp�abQ&L«UWNPOjMSiOd¬;e\KoNRKomnKoN�M�hK3STORp�Q"[]pªOlabSTORKoNjMW`^O}­«®�K"`oUhS]�pPa�¯]K^NYORe]K�abQ&L«UNPOjMWSTO�`}MWpPK�UWV?abSTORKoNjMW`^ORa�UWS\p°abS&K3gbK3`oOPNRUhS]ab`d`3UWQ&Q"[]S\aqORabK3p3y�¬;e\KoNRKORe]K�MW�WK3STORp£MWpPpPabpªO°MSF¯�NRK3L]NRK3pPKoSiO±L]NRabS\`oa�L\MWgTK3STORaqORabK3p3ypP[\`je�MWp£L«K3UWL\gbK�MSF¯�²\[]pPab�S]K3pPpPK3p3­®�KZL=NRUhL«UWpPK.MdpPUT`3a�Mg\Q&K3`jeFMS\abpPQ³UVFNRK3L][]OjMORabUWS´Q�MSFMW�WK3Q&K3STO}y}¬;e\ab`jeMa�Q&p�M�OYM�mhUha�¯]abS\�dabSiORK^NjMW`oORabUhS´¬;abORe"[\SF¯=K3pPaqNjMW²]g�KZLFMNPORab`3abL\MWSTORp3­T_iUT`3a�MWg]Q&K3`^e\M�S]a�pPQ&pZ`3UhQ&L]g�KoQ&K3STO�eFM�Nj¯�pPKo`3[]NRaqOsr&ORKo`^e]S\a�µT[\K3pd¶·pP[\`je(Mp.LFMWpPpª¬ZUWNj¯=pdMSF¯�¯]ab�W�aqOjMWg«`oKoNPORaq¸F`}M�ORK3pj¹^yi¬;e\ab`^e�UWS\gqr&�h[\MNjMSiORKoKdOReFM�O.M�LFM�NPOsrºabp.M[]ORe]K3STORa�`3MORK}¯�MWS\¯M[]ORe\UNRab»3K}¯?yn²\[]OZ¯]U�S]UWOYK3S\pP[=NRK;ORe\MOZabOYKo¼=KoNR`3abpPK3pZabORpZMW[=ORe\UWNRab»}M�ORabUhS�abS#Ml¬�M}rORe\MOda�p,¯]K3pPaqNjM²\gbK´ORU&UORe\KoNRp3­?_iUT`3a�MWg£Q&K3`jeFMS\abpPQ&p�MNRK�K3mnK3SfQ&UNRK�abQ&L«UWNPOjMWSTO¬;e]K3S�OPNR[\pªORK}¯�ORe\aqNj¯�L\MNPORabK3p&M�NRK#S]UWO&M}mWMWabg�MW²]g�KW­�½,[=N"pPL«Ko`3aq¸F`#MWL\L=NRUnM`^e�ORUNRK3L][]OjM�ORa�UWS(Q�MSFMW�WK3Q&K3STO.gbK}MW¯]p.ORUºMº¯=K3`3K3STOPNjMg�ab»3K3¯#pPUT`3abKoO¾r(abS#¬;e]ab`^e(MW�hKoSiORpe]K3gbL�K}MW`je(UORe\KoN;¬ZK3K}¯(UW[]O�[\S\¯]K3pPaqNjMW²]gbK�L\g�M3rTKoNRp3­

¿ À\Á�«ÃAÄ�Å´Æ�DZÂAÈRÄ�Á

ÉlHAÊ�Ë,Ì=BoÍ7>«Ë�5Î>«Ê�ÊÏFÐ{<i6?Ñ^5ÒÌ]6�ÌiÓÔ6AÊ�ÕRË,Ì=BoÖ#<]××�ÊhÑ^Ñ�5ÎÑ�>AB^57ØF5Ò6AG�<=6f5Ò6{×�BoÊW<=Ñ^Êl5Ò6f576\Õ^ÊWBo<]×}Õ^57Ì=6{Ñ<iÙ�Ì=6AG#Ð{ÊWÌ=ÐAÍ7Ê&<i6?>�Ú{ÊÕRËdÊWÊ6!Ð{ÊWÌ=ÐAÍ7Ê&<i6?>�ÚA:?Ñ^5Ò6AÊhÑ^Ñ^ÊWÑWDFÛÜÊ&>«ÊÝ?6Aʺ<i6!ÊÍ7ÊW×}ÕoB^Ì]6A5Î×(Þ3ßTà(áà#â«ã{ä·å¾æº<=Ñ�<�ÑjÊÕ�ÌiÓ.5Ò6\ÕoÊB3<=×}Õo5Ò6?GfÐ?<iB^Õ^57ÊWÑ�ç�Ð{ÊWÌ=ÐAÍ7Ê�Ì]B�ÚA:?Ñ^5Ò6AÊhÑ^Ñ^ÊWÑ3è}D±ÉlHAÊ&Ù�ÊÙ#Ú{ÊWBoÑ�ÌiÓ.<×�Ì=Ù�Ù#:A6A5ÒÕRéêÐABoÌTØ\5Î>«Ê�ÑjÊWB^ØF5Î×�ÊhÑ"<]ѺËdÊWÍÒÍ;<]Ñ"B^ÊÓëÊBoBo<=Í7Ñ´ÓëÌ=B&Ñ^ÊBoØF57×ÊWÑ´Õ^Ì�ÊW<]×3HÜÌ=Õ^HAÊWBWDYì´:?B6AÌiÕo5ÒÌ]6!Ì=Ó�íî�ï}ðhä�Þ3î}í,57Ñ�G=Ê6?ÊB3<iͱ5Ò69Õ^H{<TÕlÕ^HAÊWé�6AÊWÊW>!6AÌiÕ�ڱʺÚA:?Ñ^5Ò6?ÊWÑoÑ�ÑjÊWB^ØF5Î×�ÊWÑ,ÐABoÌTØF57>AÊW>ÓëÌ=Bd<&ÓëÊÊ=ñ]ÚA:«Õ,Ù�<né(Ú±Ê�Ø=Ì]ÍÒ:?6]ÕoÊÊWB�ÑjÊWB^ØF5Î×�ÊhÑñiÌ]B;6AÌ=ÕdÊØ]Ê6�òoÑjÊWB^ØF5Î×�ÊWÑoó"5Ò6�ÕoHAÊ�ÕoBo<]>«5ÒÕ^57Ì=6?<=ÍÑjÊW6?ÑjÊ]ñ«Ê=D G?D7ñnôR:?ÑjÕ´×�Ì]Ù(Ð{<i6A57Ì=6?Ñ^HA57Ð�Ì]B�ÍÒ57Ø=ÊWÍÒé�>A57Ño×�:?ÑoÑ^5ÒÌ]6�D

ÛÜÊ�Ù�Ì«>«ÊWÍY<i6�ÊWÍÒÊh×}ÕoB^Ì]6A57×&×Ì=Ù�Ù�:?6A5�ÕRé�<=Ñ�<fÑjÌ«×�5Î<iÍY6AÊ�ÕRË,Ì=BoÖÔñ«Ë�HA5Î×3HêÑj:AÐ?Ð{Ì]BjÕ3Ñ�Õ^H?ÊÐ?<iB^Õ^5Î×�57Ð?<i6\Õ3Ñõ.ï^îPö±â«åP÷Tåsä�ßTã?í´Ú±ÌiÕoHÜÓëÌ]B&Ê�ϫбÊB^Õ^5ÎÑjÊêç�ÐAB^ÌTØF5Î>«576AG!G]ÌFÌF>øÑ^ÊBoØ\5Î×�Ênè"<i6?>øHAÊWÍÒЫùÓë:AÍÒ6?ÊWÑoÑ"ç�ÐABoÌTØ\5Î>«576AG�G]ÌFÌF>�B^ÊÓëÊBoBo<=Í7Ñ3è}D\ÉlHAÊ"Ñ^Ì«×�5Î<iÍ{6AÊ�ÕRË,Ì=BoÖ�57ÑdÙf<i576]Õ3<i576AÊW>�ÚFé(бÊB3Ñ^Ì=6?<=Í<iG=ÊW6\ÕoÑ(<=ÑoÑj5ÎÑRÕo5Ò6?GÜ>«5Òú±ÊWB^ÊW6\Õ(:?Ñ^ÊB3ÑWDZû�G=Ê6\Õ3Ñ(<=6?>�ÕoHAÊ57B�:?Ñ^ÊB3Ñ�H?<nØ]Ê�Óë:AÍ7Í�<i:AÕ^Ì=6?Ì=Ù�éü576>«ÊW×57>«576AG!Ë�HAÊ�ÕoHAÊB"Ì=B"HAÌTË+Õ^Ì!B^ÊhÑjбÌ=6{>�Õ^Ì9<�BoÊWý\:AÊWÑjÕWD±ÉlHAÊ�<iG=ÊW6\ÕoÑ�<]Ñ^Ñ^5ÎÑRÕ´Õ^HAÊW5ÒB":?Ñ^ÊB3Ñ5Ò6�ÊØT<=ÍÒ:?<iÕ^576AG(Õ^HAÊ#ÑjÊWB^ØF5Î×�ÊWÑl<=6?>9B^ÊÓëÊBoBo<=Í7Ñ,ÐABoÌTØF57>«Êh>�ÚFé�Ì=Õ^HAÊWBoÑWñAÙf<i576\Õo<=5Ò6A576AGf×�Ì]6\Õo<=×�ÕÍÒ5ÎÑRÕ3Ññ\<i6?>�>«Êh×�5Î>«576AG&Ë�HAÌ=ÙþÕ^Ì�×Ì=6\Õo<]×}ÕhDTÿP6�Õ^HA5ÎÑ;Ùf<i6?6AÊBhñTÕ^H?Ê�<iG]Ê6\ÕoÑ.<]Ñ^Ñ^57ÑjÕ�Õ^HAÊW5ÒBd:?Ñ^ÊB3Ñ� © e\abplNRK3pPK}M�NR`^e!¬.MWp�pP[]L\L«UNPORK}¯�²TrfORe]K"clM�ORabUhSFMg�_i`3abK3S\`oK��\UW[\SF¯]MORabUhS![\S\¯]KoN,�WNjMWSTO����ª_i��huh�thtn�h��¶�X�MNRKoKoN���¬�MNj¯F¹^­A®9KºMNRK&abS\¯]K3²=ORK}¯�ORU�ORe\K"MWS\UWSTr]Q&UW[\p�NRK3mia�K^¬�KoNRp�VÎUN�e\K3gbL]V7[\g`3UhQ&Q&KoSiORp3­

Page 2: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

����� ���������������������������! �"$#��&%'� �(��)���*%'+��!�, �%-(��.���/�0���1���)%-�320�����54768����(.�)9:�����;�)����%'<���!�-���=+?>,�����@ 7��(A���-��%-�B%-�-���B�A�C%-(��@+�%-���)�D�-�;%�(.�� �(.�)�����B�A%E���!�-�D�'"����E2F�D#�9A�G�����8�-�����)( �%'(����!�)�G9�%'�H+7�I�.(�#������/�J4&68���K%'�����B�.��+�#��!�!�L%-���M�I%'��%-�-���.���)���K(.�� �(.�)�����B�A%E���!�-� ���'"��(.#��N�/4-6C����������OP�.����%'�����B�.�=���-�Q�-���!>,�A%'R-�8�!�B���,%-9)9:�-#����&�.���0 �(.��S?����#��=�:T� 7��(.���)��9:�/�&�'"�����)��(�# ���)(.�)O?+�#��U%-�!���;9��-���D#����!9)%E�.�V20������-�����)(�%'�-�)�B�.�,W$+7���!�-���-�!���;�����'�.����(0#�����(A�AXY4

68���D���-���!�-�Z�-"Q��(.#����V9��-�� ��!�������B�.�V��%-(.�[���/9:#�(.�\�N>�O���4 � 4�O7����(���#��-�Z9�(�>? ��.�-�-(A%' ��B>�4] %'(A�[���)9�#�(.�\�N>^%' � �(��B%-9A���/�����)�� _�)���.%-+����*���Z��� %E�V������ �%-(��N>>-��#[%'(.�G���)%'�!�!���120�����_�!�%'#��.�����B���*9�%'���/�L%'���F%'#��.���-(.��`)�)�a�.�^�.%-R-�KSE%-(��!�-#��D%-9Y�.�������)4=68���)>a���-�5b �G�)����#�(��K����%'�����%'�c �%'(��N>D�*�c���-�!����20��%'�Q>-�-#I��T� �/9Y�d%-���I�����!�!S-��(.�!���,�-�?�������)(�S?�*9:�-4-e��I�'������(Q2@�-(A���)O��������%-(.�����)9�#�(.�\�N>�%- � �(.��%-9A���)�c���!�; ���>I ��*%-9��V%G�!�E2f�?#�(.�����V�'"3�!���B%'�!�\�N>;�.��%E�����-����������D#����g9�(��B���K���h�-(A����(K���F %'(����*9:�! �%E�.�-Oc20����(.�)%-����(.#����g�I%'� %'�-�)�����B�K�I%'R��)�� 7���� ��!�%-9�9��-#��B�A%'+��!�U�)S-�)�K"$��(0�����,�!���B%'�J%-9:���!�-���@�.��%E�0�.����>1 �)(�"$��(��4

68���!�V �%- �)(U�*�V�-(.��%-����`)�)�^%���"$�����!�E2��)4ji?�/9Y�.�����akI �(��/���)���A�U���-���;(��)�!%'���/�^2d��(�R�!�(��) �#��.%'���!�-�g�I%'��%-�-�����)���/4�i?�)9:���!�-�^l; �(.�)�����B�.�0���-�������)9��)�.��%-(�>I+ %-9AR?�-(.�-#�� �I�-����E2�����)���.%-+����*���1%'�g���!�)9:��(.�-���*9V9:�-���G#������N>-4�i?�)9:���!�-�gm����B��(.����#�9��)�@�-#�(0%- � �(.��%-9A�3O�����S?�!��������IR���>[������������!�-���D%'���a���*��9�#������!���^�����;���!��"$�-(.�I%'�n �(.�- 7��(����!�)���-"c�.(�#����)4=i?�)9:���!�-�Ho �(��/���)�B�.�8�-#�(@��T� �)(��!�����B�.%-�J�;�����)�3%'� �1���-����+�%-���*9�(.�)��#����.�@��� %E��2@�V� %PS-�V�-+��A%'�!���)�J4i?�)9:���!�-�Dp�9��-��9���# ���)�3�-#�(C �%' 7��(=20�\�.�D%����*�.9:#��.���!�-�,�-"������d�I%'�!��(��/��#��\�A�3%'� �����!(��/9Y���!�-� �"$�-(8"$#��.#�(��,(.�)���)%-(.9A�34

q rts3u�vCw�s3xzy|{Q}�~

� � i�%'�!�8�nT�9A��%'���-�c%-���D�/�8%P>�%-(��d���� 7�-(��.%-���& �(A%-9:���*9�%'�B�:T�%-�; ����/�C�-" (.�� �#��.%E�.�������I%'��<%'�-�)�����B�)4 � � i�%'�!�K%-���!�E2��,���.�G#����)(.�,���[(A%E�.�K%'� �H��#�+��;���D�.�:T?��# %'�89:�-�������B�A�D%'+7�-#�����)���!��(A��4j68���;�ES-�)(.%-���5(.�� �#��.%'���!�-�[�-"c%1�����!�!��(V�!�U�����;%PS���(A%'�-�,�-"n������(A%E�.�����B����+��.%-�����/�"$(��������!�&9:# �N�.�-����(A��4/e��D�/�8%P>-OP���)���!��(A�5(.�)9����!S-�Q"$�)�)��+ %-9ARIW��G��O/��OB�,�PXj"$��(3�.�����!(&(��)���*%'+��!��<�\�N>;���K�)%-9A��%-#�9Y�.�����I%'�����.�����!(c(.�� �#��.%'���!�-�I�*�c9�%-�!9�#��*%E���/�I%-�Q��������#����'"j�.��������(A%E���!���B��ES-��(G�����1�*%-��������TL�;���B�����)4ne�� � � i�%'�!�-O=��������)2@9��-����(A��� %PS-�g���_(.�� �#��.%'���!�-�F#����.��������;�)�-���D(.%'���)�������)�O720�����!�G���Z�)�8%P>1�����)>^�N�A%'(��U20�����Z`)��(.�I"$���/��+�%-9AR 7�-�!�B�.�)47�@�'�.�%' � �(.��%�9A���)�=(.�)�B#��!(��8#�����(A�&�.�,�:T� ��!�!9��\�.��>G��%-R-��%-���;(��)S-�)%-�?�����)��(c(.%'���!�����&�-"7�-�����)(.�)4-���%G(.�)��#����)O��.���,#�����(A�@���B���,9:���B��(.�-�7�����.����9:�)���.(.%-�5%'#��.���-(.���N>-4

i?�-���c �(��-���'�N>? 7�c%' � �(��B%-9A���/�3%-(��Q(.���!��SE%-���/4��Q�)�B�.%D� lE��O/2d�/%PSB�!����%�2d�)+��'"���(.#��N�8� m-��O%'���;�,%-��+�%'�g� k�O:�/kE��(��/��#���(.�@����%'�&# ���)(.�=�-�!S-�8%V(.%'���!���U"$�-(&�������I���)��S��)�&%'� �D�)�\�.����(n��%PS��%g9����B��(A%'�n%-�-��� 9:>HW����!(.�)9Y�,(A%E�.�����B�.X��-(��-�����)(���(.#��N�.�)�_#�����(A�;W�9:�����*%'+7�-(A%E�.��S��D(A%E���!���B�.X:4��9����B��(A%'�8��>?�����)��R-�)�� ��G��(A%-9ARM�-"������#�����(A�)bC��T? ����*9:���I(.%'���!�����G�'"��/%-9A�L�-�����)()On%-���#����/�U�����/����(A%E���!���B���.�g9��-�� �#��.�I%1 7��(A���-�5b ���ES���(A%'�!�C(.�� �#��.%'���!�-�[��(�(��) �#��.%'���!�-�_20�\�.�(��/�� 7�)9:�0���I%I�� 7�)9��\79�#����)()4�68���)������>��N�.���I�0(.�)�B#��!(��V �(.����T?�*�����!���I����9:�*%'�J(.���*%E�.������������ �%'���-���K�����;#�����(A���-"Q�����)��(��)���/9Y��(.�-���!9G9:�-���G#������N>-47e��V�*�V���'��9:�!�)%'(V���E2��.�K�)���.%-+��!�!�����#�9A�g(.���*%E���!�-� �����! ��0%-���K���E2f�����,(.%'���!�����8 �(.�- %'��%'��������(.�-#����K�.���*��9:���;�G#������N>-4

63(.#������)�^68����(A�^�n%'(����!�)��W�6060�dXD� �P�=%-9:�U%-�U%I+�(.�!���-��+7�:�N2@���)�^+�#�>-�)(.�U%'���^�����!�!��(A����M���!�)9:��(.�-���*9;�I%'(.R-�:�. ��*%-9:�/��4 ] �E2d�)S-��(/Oj6060�h�*�,��������%' � �(��� �(��*%E�.�D"$��(�9:�!�����)�_�I%'(�<R-�:�. ��*%-9:�/��4�e����!�B�B���)��>;"$�/����(A%E�.�)�JO��- 7���1��>��N�.���I�c%G6060�H�I%P>����������)(d���-�d+7�U%PSE%'�!�*%'+��!��-(0��%PS��U�!���������/� �E2@��(@�����)��"$�-(A9:���-�?���1+ �)��%PS?����()4

� %-���D#��.���-�L���B%'�����-�F �(��� �B���/�H�.���1���'���!�-���'"G�:���A�,�� A¡:¢�£Y¤¥��¦�+�%����/�L�-�§����9��!%-�9:�-�B�.(���������(���#��-�f(.�� �#��.%'���!�-�¨� pE��48e��©���-"¥����)9�#�(.�\�N>�Oc�.���a%-�-�)���A�� 7�-�!�!9��[�.�����I�����!S-�/�

Page 3: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

ª0«\¬.­�®-¯�¬C°�±/²-³�´U°�±/µ:®-¯�°.¶�±=¬�®�²0µ�±�·B¬�°A²'¸-²-¯�¬�­�®-°.«\¬N´�¹)º?®'»¥¬=¶�±/µ:¯�°.«\¬N´U«!¶3±)¶�¼ ±/µ:«*²'¸!¸�´V²E¬�¬�°A²-µY¬.«�½�±«�·®-¼7±�·^¶�±:¬�¬�«!·�¾�¶)¿�²'·�³1À�®'¬.«�½E²E¬.±)¶0®�¯�°�²'¼�¼�°�®B²-µA­5¹

Á ²'°A¶�­1¼�°.±)¶�±�·B¬.¶0²;»$®�°�ÀI²'¸!«!Â)²E¬.«�®�·K®-»C¬.­�±�µ:®�·�µ:±)¼�¬�®'»=¬�°.¯�¶�¬Dà ÄEÅ�¹�Æ�«!¶8»$®�°�ÀI²-¸�«!Â)²'¬�«!®-·µ:®-· ¶�«*³�±�°A¶8®-·�¸�´g²'·^²'¾�±�·B¬)Ç ¶8®Eª0·±:È�¼ ±)°�«!±�· µ:±)¶0²-·�³³�®?±)¶�·5Ç ¬�«�·?½�®-¸!½-±,²'·?´K¶�®�µ:«*²'¸JÀ�±)µA­�ɲ'·�«*¶�ÀI¶)¹5Æ�±)·�µ:±�¿5²1¾�°�®�¯�¼[®-»@²-¾-±�·B¬A¶Vµ)²'·�·�®'¬�µ:®�¸�¸!±)µ:¬�«!½-±�¸!´^Ê�¯�«!¸*³_¯�¼a²g°.±�¼�¯�¬A²E¬.«�®�·[»$®�°®'¬�­�±�°A¶�¹E˧À�®-°.±c°.±�¸!±�½E²'·B¬nµ:®-À�¼�¯�¬.²E¬.«�®�·�²'¸?À�±:¬.­�®�³D«*¶C»$°�®�ÀÍÌjÎ/Ï�Ð�ÑEÒ�Ó:Ô�Õ�Ö:×�Ñ�Ï:Õ�Ð�ÎEÔ�ØJ×�Ñ'Ù�Ö�ÚÛ Î'×�Ü�Ý�º?ÞNßnà0à áEÅ�¹'Þ�·�º?ÞNß@¿-²-·�²-¾-±)·�¬&±�½E²-¸�¯�²'¬�±/¶&¬�­�±0°.±�¼�¯�¬.²'¬�«!®-·;®'»J²'·�®-¬�­�±)°Q²'¾-±)·B¬&Ê ²-¶�±)³®-·M³�«�°.±)µ:¬,®-Ê�¶�±�°.½E²E¬�«!®-· ¶U²�¶�ªd±)¸�¸=¬�­�°�®�¯�¾-­a®'¬.­�±�°�ânÐ¥Õ�Ô7Ö:ã.ã�Ö:ãY¹3Æ�®Eª@±�½�±�°/¿jº?ÞNß©³�®?±)¶�·�®-¬³�±)¶.µ:°.«�Ê7±@­�®EªH¬�®Vä�· ³G¶�¯�µA­Dª0«�¬�·�±)¶.¶�±/¶�¿Eª0­�±)°�±/²-¶C«�·G¬�­�±@±)¸�±/µY¬.°�®�·�«!µ@µ:®�À�ÀD¯�·�«�¬�«!±)¶)¿'³�±/²'¸*¶²'°.±VÊ�°�®�å-±�°.±)³K²'À�®-·�¾�¼7±�®�¼�¸�±,ª0­�®;¼�°�®�Ê�²'Ê�¸!´I­�²P½�±V·�±�½-±)°8À;±�¬�±)²�µA­1®-¬�­�±)°)¹æ5ç ÑEÒ¥Ò�Ö�ÔBèBÖ:ã:égê8­�±K»$®-¸!¸�®Eª0«!·�¾Z²-°�±K¶�®-À�±�«!À�¼ ®�°�¬A²'·B¬;µA­ ²'¸!¸�±)·�¾-±/¶�»$®-°�²'·?´M²'¾-±)·B¬�É�Ê�²-¶�±)³²'¼�¼�°.®�²�µA­D»$®�°c°.±�¼�¯�¬.²E¬.«�®�·IÀI²'·�²-¾-±�À�±)·�¬/ë'­�®Eª�¬�®gÝNì/àn¾-«!½-±8»$¯�¸!¸7µ�®-·B¬�°.®-¸�¬�®,¬.­�±�¯�¶�±�°A¶Q«!·¬�±�°.ÀI¶8®'»&ª0­�±�·1¬�®I°.±�½�±)²-¸ ¬.­�±�«!°0°A²E¬�«!·�¾B¶�íJÝ�î�à@­�±�¸!¼^²'·²'¾�±�·B¬dä ·�³1¬�°.¯�¶N¬Nª@®-°�¬�­?´�²-¾-±�·B¬A¶Ý$½-±)°�«�¬.²-Ê�¸!±_¶�¬�°A²'·�¾�±�°A¶.à;±)½-±�·©ª0«\¬.­�®-¯�¬¼�°.«�®�°K°.±�¸*²E¬.«�®�·�¶�­�«�¼�¶)íd²-·�³J¿�Ý�ïBàK¶�¼ ±)±)³ð¯�¼f¬�­�±¼�°�®�¼�²'¾B²E¬.«�®�·[®'»0«!·�»$®-°.ÀI²E¬.«�®�·[¬.­�°�®�¯�¾-­a¬.­�±K¶�®?µ�«!²-¸n·�±:¬Nª@®-°.åj¹CñU¯�°D¶�®�µ:«*²'¸nÀ�±)µA­�²-·�«*¶�À¶�±)±�å�¶=¬�®,²-³�³�°�±/¶�¶=¬.­�±0²'Ê7®E½-±0µA­�²-¸�¸!±�·�¾�±)¶)¹PÞ�·;¼ ²'°�¬�«*µ:¯�¸*²'°/¿P°.²'¬�«!·�¾�¶&²'°.±0µ:®�·B½�±�´�±)³DòB¯�«*µAå?¸�´²'À�®-·�¾1²'¾-±)·B¬.¶)¿ ±)½-±�·_²-µ:°.®�¶.¶�¶�¯�Ê�É�µ:®�À;ÀG¯�·�«�¬�«!±)¶)¹7ê8­�±�°.±:»$®-°.±-¿ ¯�·�³�±/¶�«!°A²'Ê�¸!±G²-¾-±�·B¬A¶�µ�²-·ò�¯�«!µAå?¸!´�Ê ±,°.¯�¸!±)³1®-¯�¬/¹

ó ô^õNöC÷7ø?ù�úcû�ü�÷hý_úcþ�þ ÿ�ûUü�ø�üNö �

ê3®VÊ ±�¬�¬.±�°&¯�·�³�±)°.¶�¬.²-·�³,¬.­�±8·�®'¬.«�®�·D®-»�¬�°.¯�¶�¬=«!·;µ�®-À�ÀD¯�·�«\¬.«�±/¶�¿P¸!±:¬/Ç ¶&³�«*¶�µ�¯�¶.¶3¬.­�±d»�²'À�®-¯�¶¼�°�«*¶�®-·�±)°.¶)Ç'³�«!¸�±)À;ÀI²�Ã�ì:Å�¹�ê8­�±�¼�°.«!¶�®-·�±)°)Ç ¶n³�«!¸�±)À�À�²D²'°.«!¶�±)¶n«!·�²�·�®�·�É�µ�®?®-¼7±�°A²E¬�«!½-±8¾B²'À�±ª0«\¬.­1¬Nª@®I²'¾�±�·B¬.¶)¹�ê8­�±�²'¾�±�·B¬.¶@­�²P½�±V¬�®I³�±)µ�«!³�±,ª0­�±:¬.­�±�°0¬.®ZÏ.Î/Î���Ö�×�ÑEÕ�Ö0®�°��-Ö��:Ö.Ï�ÕJ»$°.®-À²;³�±)²'¸�¹�ê8­�±�¼�²P´-®�j¶@«!·K¬.­�±,¾�²-À�±V²-°�±�¶�¯ µA­�¬�­ ²E¬�Ê7®'¬�­²'¾�±�·B¬.¶@ª@®-¯�¸*³�Ê7±�·�±:ä�¬�«�»=Ê7®'¬.­µ:®?®-¼7±�°A²E¬.±-¹PÆ�®Eª@±�½-±)°)¿)«\»7®-·�±@²'¾�±�·B¬Cª@±�°.±Q¬.®�¬.°�´�¬.®Vµ�®B®�¼ ±)°.²'¬�±dª0­�±�·D¬�­�±@®'¬.­�±�°n³�±�»$±)µY¬A¶�¿¬�­�±,µ:®?®�¼ ±)°.²'¬�®-°dªd®�¯�¸*³1¶�¯�j±�°0µ:®�·�¶�«*³�±)°.²-Ê�¸�´�¹Bê8­�«!¶@ÀI²'å�±)¶d¬�­�±�¸!®�µ�²'¸!¸!´I°.²'¬�«!®-·�²-¸7µA­�®�«!µ�±»$®-°0±)²�µA­g²-¾-±)·�¬8¬.®�³�±:»$±/µY¬)¿�¬�­�±)°�±)ÊB´K¸�±/²-³�«!·�¾;¬�®�²;ª@®-°A¶�±V¼�²P´-®�^»$®-°0Ê7®'¬.­²-¾-±)·�¬A¶@¬�­�²-·«\»&Ê ®-¬�­ª@±�°.±U¬.®Iµ:®?®-¼7±�°A²E¬.±-¹

ê8­�±K¼�°.«*¶�®�·�±�°/Ç ¶D³�«�¸!±�À�ÀI²Z«*¶G«�·B¬�«!ÀI²E¬.±�¸!´a°.±�¸*²E¬.±)³M¬.®Z¬.­�±K±)½-®-¸!¯�¬.«�®�·H®'»0¬�°.¯�¶�¬)¹QñU·¬�­�±V®-·�±U­�²'· ³J¿�«�»5¬.­�±U¼�¸!²P´�±�°A¶n¬�°.¯�¶�¬d±/²-µA­�®-¬�­�±)°)¿�¬�­�±)´Iµ�²'·KÊ ®-¬�­1µ�®?®-¼7±�°A²E¬�±U²'·�³1²P½-±�°�¬²1ÀG¯�¬�¯ ²'¸c³�±�»$±)µ:¬�«!®-·Mª0­�±�°.±�Ê ®-¬�­H¶�¯�7±)°)¹&ñU·[¬.­�±I®'¬.­�±�°,­�²-·�³J¿3¶�¯�µA­_¬�°.¯�¶�¬Dµ�²'·a®-·�¸�´Ê�¯�«!¸!³�¯�¼�«!·�²�¶�±�¬�¬�«!·�¾,ª0­�±)°�±8¬.­�±0¼�¸*²P´-±)°.¶&­�²P½�±@¬�®,°.±�¼7±)²E¬.¸�´D«�·B¬�±)°.²�µY¬Qª0«�¬�­�±)²�µA­�®'¬�­�±�°/¹ñU¯�°U®�Ê�¶�±�°.½P²'¬�«!®-·Z«*¶U¬�­�²'¬�²K°.±�¼�¯�¬.²E¬.«�®�·ZÀ�±)µA­�²-·�«*¶�À�¶�¯�¶�¬.²'«!·�¶U°.²'¬�«!®-·�²-¸=µ�®?®-¼7±�°A²E¬�«!®-·3¿Ê ±/µ�²'¯ ¶�±;¬�­�±;¾�®?®?³[¼�¸*²P´-±�°A¶�²'°.±G°.±�ª8²'°A³�±/³^Ê?´[¶�®�µ�«�±�¬N´^ª0­�±�°.±)²�¶�¬.­�±�Ê�²-³_¼�¸*²P´-±)°.¶V²'°.±¼ ±)·�²'¸!«�Â)±)³J¹��d®-¬�­g¬�­�±,°�±)ª@²-°.³�¶@²'· ³1¼7±�· ²'¸�¬�«!±)¶8»$°.®-À ²I¶�®�µ:«!±:¬N´K²-°�±V¾-°.±)²'¬�±)°d¬.­�²'·g»$°.®-À²'·g«�·�³�«�½?«*³�¯�²'¸�¹

ê8­�±8¼�°�®�¼ ®B¶�±/³�²'¼�¼�°�®B²-µA­�Ê�¯�«�¸*³�¶n®�·1Ý�²'·�³;²'¼�¼�¸�«!±)¶&«!· àC®-¯�°&ª@®-°.å,®-·;µ:®-· ¶N¬.°�¯�µ:¬�«!·�¾�²¶�®�µ:«*²'¸?·�±�¬Nªd®�°�å�»$®�°&«�·�»$®�°�ÀI²'¬�«!®-·;¾�²E¬.­�±�°.«!·�¾GÃ�ì� �¿:ì-ì�Å�¹PÞ�·�®-¯�°n²-°.µA­�«�¬�±/µY¬.¯�°�±�¿P±)²-µA­G¯�¶�±�°&«!¶²-¶.¶�®�µ:«*²E¬.±)³;ª0«�¬�­�²,¼7±�°A¶�®�·�²'¸ ²'¾-±)·B¬)¹�U¶�±)°.¶n¼7®�¶�±�òB¯�±)°�«!±)¶&¬.®,¬�­�±�«!°d²'¾�±�·B¬.¶)¹-ê8­�±Uò�¯�±�°.«�±/¶ÊB´L¬�­�±¯�¶�±�°�²-°�±1ä�°A¶N¬�¶�±�±�·§Ê?´L­�«*¶I²'¾�±�·B¬;ª0­�®M³�±)µ:«*³�±/¶;¬�­�±^¼7®'¬.±�·B¬�«*²'¸�µ�®-·B¬.²�µY¬.¶G¬.®ª0­�®-À�¬�®g¶�±)·�³¬.­�±;òB¯�±)°�´�¹ Ë�»¥¬�±�°,µ�®-·�¶�¯�¸�¬.²E¬.«�®�·^ª0«\¬.­Z¬.­�±D¯�¶�±�°/¿ ¬�­�±�²'¾�±�·B¬U¶�±�·�³�¶�¬�­�±ò�¯�±�°.´I¬�®�¬.­�±�²'¾�±�·B¬.¶@»$®�°0®'¬�­�±�°�¸!«�å�±�¸!´�¼7±�®-¼�¸�±�¹�ê8­�±�²'¾�±�·B¬0ª0­�®�°�±/µ:±)«�½�±)¶0²�òB¯�±�°.´Kµ�²-·³�±)µ�«!³�±0«�»J«\¬@¶�¯�«�¬.¶c«\¬A¶n¯�¶�±�°c²-·�³;¸�±�¬Q¬�­�±�¯�¶�±�°Q¶�±�±8¬�­ ²E¬dòB¯�±)°�´�¹'Þ�·I²-³�³�«�¬�«!®-·;¬.®�®-°n«!·�¶�¬�±)²�³

Page 4: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

���������������������� !#"�$%��&�')(*��'+��,-���-!.�������/'+�10*�/&�')��$*'+"2�435�6,7�/'1��89�"� 5�:!;��&<��'=��'��/�>��?@�A������/&�'+�:���/'+�>�+B

C (*��'+��,D!."�E=?#�� '��:�/&�'F(2��'1����!.�*"G�*�H�4'�?.?I�*���/&�'%��'�(2��'1����'+�1J �HK�LM��"� N� � �/'1�/�H�"� ��?#!.37!.�O�"<�/&�')"P��3�Q9'+�:��I��'=��'+���>��?@�R��'�(2��'1����'� SB C �/'1��89�"���'T35�6,5!."�E+?.�� '%��"U�"��/�4'����U�V�/'+��'+�����?�04��UQ���/&W0H��G"�'�!;��&�'+�YX�!#"Z�:&�!@E>&ZE���/'["��V��'��/89�"��/'\!@�<"�'+'� �'� �]=B C "��$'�"2����"��/�4'����)�*"�?#,\!.�H!.��!@�%��'���/�"���Q�?#,\E=�*"^� '�"2�%�/&�����!;�>�%'=_89'+�/�/!@��'<37����E>&�'1�)�/&�'!."�E+�37!#"�$\(2��'+��,B C ��'=��'��/�>��?R �'+89'+"� ��-�"Y��&�'U(2��'��/,Y��"� `�"Y��&�'<��'=��'��/��!."�$[��$'�"2��J �3a� '�?W���b����&�'+�O�$'+"2�>�+c��a��'=��'+���>��?d!#�O$!#e'+"U�"�?#,<!.�b�/&�'%��'=��'��/��!."�$a�$'+"2�:8�?@�E+'��:�/�37'�/�������O!#"G�/&�'F�$'�"*�HQ9'+!#"�$5�/'+��'+���/'1 SB

f &�'+"\�/&�'7���!#$!#"��g��!."�$G��$*'+"2�h��'�E+'+!#e'��T�U�/'+��'+�����?�09!;�% '1E=!@ '��T�:&�'+�/&�'��)�/�U���?#?.�g�!;�G��8WB f &�'+"i��&�'\�$'+"2�<��'�E+'+!#e'1�D��"j�"�����'+�10k!.�U���/'��D�/&�'l��"��/�4'��<��U�`Q��*��!@�5���*�'+eg��?#���g��!."�$:�/&�'4'=_89'+�/�/!@��'4����/&�'4��$*'+"2�I�:&��m$*�6e'n��&�'H��"��/�4'���B�oH&�!#�p'+eg�?.�����/!#�"F��q9'1Er���!;�>�)3a� '�?A���k��&�'7'=_89'+�/�/!@��'a���4�/&�'5��"�����'+��!."�$U��$*'+"2��0S�"� [!.���)37� '+?@�T���H��"P,[��$*'+"2��:&��h35�6,)&��6e*'R$!#e'�"-�m�/'+��'+�����?���m��&�!#�n�"�����'+��!#"�$h�$'+"2�1B�Ks"-$'+"�'+�>��?t0+��&�'H���!.$*!."����/!#"�$��$'�"2�T35�6,Nu'�'+8[�����*E>uv���R37�*�/'a8�'�'+�>�h�/&��"\&�!@�)"�'+!#$&PQ9��>�+Bdwn'+��!#�P �!#E���?#?.,G&�'5 '�E+!# �'�:&�!#E>&N89'+'��������au*'+'�8G�*�H"�'+!#$&PQ9��>�+0!tB '*B.0�:&�!#E>&v����')�4�*����&<��'+37'+3-Q�'��/!#"�$�B

x y{zW|T}:~�b~���R��y{�p~��/�O�M�A�h���\���R|m�n�k�b~����R�

Ks"V����a�8�8����*�E>&I0I��$*'+"2�a�������!#$"����[�>�g��!."�$[�/�Y��$*'+"2�-��Q���/'� ��"�X��1]F!;�>�a �!.��'�E=��Q��/'+��eg�g�/!#�"��R��p���g�T�R�+���p�g�hX��*]A��&�')�����/!#"�$*�4���p���*�R$*!.e*'+"<QP,D�<J ��"�'�!.$*&2Q9��>��02�"� �FJ �p�>�g��!."�$m�����&��*�/'R"�'+!#$&PQ��*����B6oH&�'��/'�E+�"� ���/8�'1Er�p35�u'��p����b�8�8����*�E>&%�T���E+!#�?�"�'��"� U'+"��Q�?#'��:!#"�����35�g��!.�*"U��Q9����O�/'�8�������/!#�"������78��/�*8���$2�g��'m��&��/�*��$&U�/&�'%"�'=�������udB

oI�>� !.�/!#�"���?S��8�8��/�2�E>&�'1�4'�!;��&�'+�:!#$"����'m��&�'F���E+!#�?W��/8�'1Er���m��?.�/�$*'=��&�'+�H��:'�378�?.�g,�\�/!.378�?#!#���/!@EG��8�8����*�*E>&Y�/&����7 �!.��'�E=�/?#,YE+�3-Q�!."�'����/&�'N�>�g�/!#"�$2������/!.$*"�'� `QP,` !.q9'��/'�"2����*����E+'���BS�O�g��'+e'���0d�/��E>&��8�8����*�*E>&�'��T �N"����FE+�"��/!# �'+�T�/&�'5��'+8�������/!#�"��T���4�/&�'5�:!.���"�'�����'1�-�/&�'�37�/'+?#e'1�+B4�4?#'���/?#,0b��&�'N�4'�!.$*&*�D�*�/�/!.$*"�'� `�/�`�������/!#"�$��/&��*��?# � '�8�'�"� V�*"�/&�'7��'+8���>�g��!.�*"\���R�/&�'7�>�g�/'���BS�v�*�/'��ge'���0��/'�8�������/!#�"l�����/!#"�$*�TE+�"�"����)Q9'7�?.?#�g��'� N���!."�E+�/'1��/'F� G!#"^�"�!.�/��3NBSop�D�E>&�!#'+e*')�/&�'��Q��ge*'0���')^��>���T '=^�"�'���"[�$'+"2�1J �:�>�g��!."�$5�����"���/&�'��O��$'�"2��BPKs"�!.�/!@��?#?.,*0�/&�'%�>�g��!."�$a!@�H�+'��/��B�U�2 n¡p¢¤£�¢¤¥9¡§¦�¨T©Sª X#«2]�¬:!#�O�/&�'-�/�������h�>�g��!."�$U�����!#$"�'1 NQP,G�$'+"2�m­����U��$*'+"2��«G�g�m�/!#3a'® B f '%��'�(2��!#��'m��&��g�F¯%�)° ©dª X.«P]s¬�°§�)�"� ©dª X.«P]s±)²j³�B

´ �E>&l��$'�"2�)�:!#?#?k� ��8�T!.���F�����/!#"�$U����"�����&�'+�%��$*'+"2�)Q���/'� \�"�!;�>�)�Q��/'+��eg�g�/!#�"IB�4�2�*8�'������/!#�"�QP,[�/&�'D����&�'+���$'�"*�%$*'+"�'������/'��%�N89�*�/!.�/!#e'5'+eP!@ '+"�E='<µ���"� Y '+��'�Er��!.�*"�N"�'+$2�g�/!#e'7'�e2!@ '�"�E='D¶RBpoH&P���Fµ¸·¹³v��"� Y¶»º¹³�BIop�v8������/'1Er�%��&��*�/'D�:&��v!#"2�/'+�>�E=��:!;��&7�"a�$'�"*�n�:&��%E>&�'1�g���A�/�37'����9�/&�'���!.37'0�4'����u'H�)E=�"���'��/eg�g��!.e*'������"�E='����g����� �/'�8�������/!#�"���093a'1��"�!#"�$<�/&����h��'+8���>�g��!.�*"��h�/&��*��?# [Q�'a&����> N���<Q���!#?@ [��8W0dQ����T'1��/,<����/'���% �g�:"WBSoH&�!@�%E=�"2�����*���>�m�:!.�/&Y�[���>�/&½¼ ¾6¿À0S�:&�'+��'a�"l�$'+"2�)35�6,[E>&�'����)�N�/!.�1��Q�?#'�����*Er�/!#�"{X��³2Áa]T�����/&�'7�/!#3a'5Q���-���/!#?.?k35�!."2���!."Y�N37�"���/�*"�!#E���?#?.,v!#"�E+�/'1��/!."�$N��'+8�������g��!.�*"WB f '7E+�"\�E>&�!.'�e'F��&�'7 '��/!.��'� ['=qd'�Er�)QP,v�/'1(2��!.��!#"�$5�/&��g�D µHÂS°Ã ¶�ÂÄB f '-����'a���!#378�?.'F�8�8����*�*E>&5�/�DE+�3�Q�!."�')!#"N'+eP!# �'+"�E+'h�����3Å�/'1E='�"*�:!#"2�/'+�>�E=�/!#�"���B�U�2 n¡p¢¤£�¢¤¥9¡jÆS¨ C ����'+�F�"\!#"*��'+�>�E=�/!#�"W09�/&�'a��89 ����/'1 \���/�����)�����/!#"�$ ©dª X.«P]�¬�ÇpÈ�!#�)$*!.e*'+"Q2,D�/&�')���*?.?#�g�:!."�$-�>��Q�?#'%��"� N '�8�'�"� ��:�*"<��&�'%8���'+eP!#��������/�����:�����/!#"�$�B

Page 5: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

ÉSÊ�Ë#Ì2Í�Î Ï�ÐIÐ�ÑRÒ2ÓgÔÕ1Ö¤Ð9×½ØSÙ`Ì ÚGÒPÛÀÒ2ÜÕ�Ö�Ð�×{ØSÙYÌÝ½Þ ÉdÊ�Ë.ÌPÍ ÎSßVà Ë�á:âlÉSÊ�Ë.ÌPÍ Î Í Ë¤ÉSÊ�Ë.ÌPÍ ÎWß�ã Í�äË�á:â�å7æ.çWèPé ÉdÊ/Ë.ÌPÍ Î é;ê1é ã é Í>ëì½Þ Ë�ÉSÊ/Ë#ÌPÍsÎ ß�à Í/ä�Ë�áOâ�å7æ.çSèé ÉSÊ/Ë.ÌPÍsÎ=é;ê1é à éÄë6Í ÉSÊ/Ë.ÌPÍsÎ ß`ã Ë�á ß ÉSÊ�Ë.ÌPÍ�Î�Íí Þ à ãî�ïð#ð#ïgñ:æ.ç�ò%ó[ôõ�ö/÷vø ùgútû*ñ4ühýü=þ�ç�ü:ÿ�ïõkü1ô��>÷5ô�ò*ü+ç��Rô�ç�������ü�õ4ôç�ý5ô)ð.ïgñ�ü+õ�/÷�õ�ü�ö/÷�ïð@ý

ÿ�ïõ�/õ���ö��� ÚUÒ��n×pÖ¤Õ�Ö¤Ð9×����)î�ï*õOô�ò*ü+ç������Wâ%á���� Ê ��áFô�ç�ýlâ%á���� Ê ��áû�ñ:÷�ü�õ/ü�� Ê � � Ê ÉdÊ/Ë.ÌPÍ � �bÊ�æ#ç�ýæ!�+ô"�/ü1ö#�/÷�ô"�$�%�/õ���ö&�>ö�Ìmô�ç�ý)ñ:æ#ð.ð��=ïPï��9ü+õ>ô'��üAñ:æ(��÷mÌ%)+ÉSÊ�Ë#Ì2Í*���:Êæ#ç�ýæ!�+ô"�/ü�ö�/÷�ô"�+�Rå7æ@ö&��õ,��ö���ö4ÌDô�ç�ýUñ:æ#ð#ðIýü=ÿ�ü-�.�hôò*ôæ.ç�ö��RÌ%)$�:Ê ì ÉSÊ/Ë#Ì2Í ì �nÊAå7ü�ôç�ö��/÷�ô"�+�Rå/��ö��ýü��+æ#ýü%ï*çGö/ïå7ü)ï"��÷�ü+õ:ò*õ/ï0��ç�ý�ö�

1 �32 4)ÓgÐ�ÑbÔ�59ÔÕ1Ö¤Ð9×iÐ�Û*6UÒ*Ñ 7pÕ�ÔÕ1Ö¤Ð9×�6<ÔÕ1Ö¤×859Rô��>÷Fôòü�ç0�b÷�ôöbôTö�ü:�pï�ÿ%��ï��/ü+ç���æ#ôð.ð<;=�>÷�ô�ç�ò*æ.ç�ò?>A@:B(CED�F�G'H�IIñ:æJ�/÷-ñ:÷�ïå»æJ�bå5ôE;%ýæ#õ/ü-�.��ðJ;æ.ç��/ü�õ�ô0�.�- #KmïgñMô�ç�ô�ò*ü+ç��hü�L6ôðJ��ô'�/ü1öM�/÷�ü7õ�ü:���N�>ô'��æ.ï*ç�ömïÿ4ï��/÷�ü�õ�öhñ:æ.ð#ðkýü���ü�ç�ý\æ#çO��ô�õ,�ïçP��÷�ü��/ü1ö&��æ.å7ïç�æ.ü1ö4ïÿIæJ��ö�ç�ü+æ#ò÷RQ9ïõ>ö: NSH÷�æ@ö�ç�ô'����õ>ô�ð#ðJ;7ð#ü�ôý�öT��ï?��÷�ü)æ#ý�ü�ô-ï�ÿpô-õ/ü+ÿ�ü+õ�õ�ôð�>÷�ô�æ#ç� ÚUÒ��n×pÖ¤Õ�Ö¤Ð9× 1 ��U íWV3XZY ê:[:[�[+ê X+\�] æ@ömô[Ë^��ï2ö/ö/æ<Q�ð.ü6ÍHõ�ü=ÿ�ü+õ�õ>ô�ð��>÷�ôæ.çGÿ�õ�ïå ô�òü�ç�� XZY ��ïô�òü�ç�� XM\ û�ñ:÷�ü�õ/ü X Ê<_a`Tæ@ö:ôaç�ü+æ#ò÷RQ9ïõ:ïÿ X Ê,

X Y ñ:æ#ð.ð���ö�ü%ôaõ/ü+ÿ�ü+õ�õ�ôðb�>÷�ô�æ#çc��ï X \ �/ï��=ï*åd���N�/ü%æJ��öOõ�ô"�/æ#ç�ò-É Y ËfeIÍg�/ïgñHô�õ>ý�ö X \ hlüFýü+þ�ç�ü%ôi�/õ���ö��*��õ/ï0��ô�ò2ô'��æ.ï*ç<ï��9ü+õ>ô'��ïõ1û�j/ ÚUÒ��n×pÖ¤Õ�Ö¤Ð9×lkb��mijon í æ;ÿ:Ëfm � ÞZp n � Þ Íg�/÷�ü�çqmsrtn<ü+ð@ö�ü7â�é msrtnWé

usçaï��/÷�ü�õRñ�ïõ>ý�ö�ûE�/÷�üOð#ü:L*ü+ð�ïÿ#�/õ���ö&�g��õ/ï0��ô�ò2ô'��ü�ý-ï'Lü+õkô)ç�ü+ò*ô"�/æ<LüHð#æ.ç�vaæ#çDô%õ/ü+ÿ�ü+õ�õ�ôð�>÷�ô�æ#ç<æ@ö�ç�ü+ò2ô'�/æ<Lü0 �w�ü�ð.ïgñ%ûPð#üx�U íyV3XZY ê:[:[�[=ê XM\�] Q�ü%ô-õ/ü+ÿ�ü+õ�õ�ôð%�>÷�ôæ.ç<ÿ�õ/ï*å ô�òü�ç�� XZY�/ïDô�ò*ü+ç�� X+\ ô'�*�/æ#å7ü=z. �h�ü%ç�ïgñ�ýü+þ�ç�ü��/õ���ö��Z��õ�ï���ôò*ô'��æ.ï*ç<ï'L*ü+õHô7õ/ü+ÿ�ü+õ�õ�ôðA�>÷�ôæ.ç$ ÚUÒ��n×pÖ¤Õ�Ö¤Ð9×�{��)î�ï*õOô�çR;c|dû Þ �}|t�~eAûÉ+�Y Ë�|�ÍsÎ í ÉM�Y Ë�á1Í�Îbjl[:[�[-j�É+��E� ` Ë�|�ÍsÎ

SH÷�ü���ü�çR��ð(��æ.å5ô"�/ü[ô�ò*ü+ç��5ïçiô�õ/ü+ÿ�ü+õ�õ�ôðZ�>÷�ô�æ#ç�÷�ôöDý�æ.õ�ü��x�7ü�LPæ#ýü�ç��=üvïÿM��÷�üvð@ôö��ô�òü�ç���öAï*çd�/÷�ü��>÷�ô�æ#ç� *î�ïõ���÷�æ@öRõ�ü�ô*ö�ï*çWûgñ4üZ�/ü+õ�åW�/÷�üM��ü�ç���ð(��æ.å5ô'��ühôòü+ç�����÷�ü?��B���>A@xI�I� ÚUÒ��n×pÖ¤Õ�Ö¤Ð9×l�b�����/ü�ö��/æ#å7ïçR;Yÿ�ïõ5ôòü+ç�� Þ ÿ�õ�ïå ôòü+ç��P|`õ�ü+ð@ô'��æJL*üP�/ïYô��>÷�ô�æ#ç�U§æ#öýü=þ�ç�ü�ýNôö*� �Y Ë3|�Í�Î í É �Y Ë3|�Í�ÎÀÉ �� Ë3| ß á1Í�Î� �Kmü+õ�ü?|Dæ@ö��÷�ü%ñ:æ(��ç�ü�ö�öHï�ÿ8�/÷�æ#ö��ü�ö��/æ#å7ïçR;�

SIü1ö&��æ.å7ïçR;7ÿ�õ�ïå ô-ñ:æJ�/ç�ü1ö/öHæ@ö��ö/ü�ýUñ:÷�ü+ç��/÷�üTñ:æJ�/ç�ü�ö�öHæ#ö*�+ïç�ö/æ#ý�ü+õ�ü�ý<ö,�N�P�=æ#ü+ç���ðJ;õ/ü�ð.æ@ô"Q�ð#ü� A�PïDôö��ïDô�ð#ð.ïgñ��/ü1ö&��æ.å7ïçR;<ÿ�õ/ï*å ñ�ü�ô"vGô�ò*ü+ç���ö���ï�Q�ü?�+ïå/Q�æ.ç�ü�ýGæ.çIû�ñ�ü��=ïç��ö�æ@ýü+õ:ñ:æJ�/ç�ü�ö�ö�ü1öHõ/ü�ð.æ@ô"Q�ð#ü%ôöHð#ïç�ò5ô*ö��/÷�ü�;<÷�ôEL*üTôi�9ï*ö/æ(��æJL*üM��õ,��ö&�Oõ>ô'��æ.ç�ò% ÚUÒ��n×pÖ¤Õ�Ö¤Ð9×����)î�ï*õ:ô�òü�ç���4ô'��/æ#å7ü=zrû�ô/�/ü�ö��/æ#å7ïçR;5ÿ�õ�ïå ôòü�ç0�Z|Uæ#ö�H�@x��B^�0Fx�<@:æ.ÿnôç�ýïç�ð<;Dæ.ÿnôòü+ç��+|Uæ#ö���õ,��ö&��ü�ýSû�æ� ü� #û�É+�Ê Ë3|�Í�Î Ý{Þ

SHñ4ïUõ/ü+ÿ�ü+õ�õ�ôð8�>÷�ôæ.ç�ö+U�`�ôç�ýsU8��å5ôE;���ô*ö/ö+�/÷�õ/ï0��ò÷O�/÷�ü7ö/ôå7üaôòü+ç��=|# #usçO��÷�æ#ö�+ôö/üûñ�ü=�>÷�ïPï*ö/üTô7õ�ü=ÿ�ü�õ/õ>ô�ðb�>÷�ôæ.çt�/÷�ô'�Z;Pæ.ü�ð#ý�ö��/÷�ü%÷�æ#ò÷�ü�ö�����õ,��ö&�Oõ>ô'��æ.ç�òaÿ�ï*õ+|# ÚUÒ��n×pÖ¤Õ�Ö¤Ð9×����)î�ï*õ-ôòü+ç��i��ûnô���ü�ö��/æ#å7ïçR;�ÿ�õ/ï*å ôòü�ç0��|Yñ:æJ�/÷Võ�ü�ö,�9ü��.�/�/ï�õ/ü+ÿ�ü+õ�õ�ôð�>÷�ô�æ#çcU ` æ@öHå7ïõ�ühõ�ü+ð#æ@ô"Q�ð#üZ��÷�ô�çGñ:æ(��÷Uõ�ü�ö,�9ü��.���ï-õ�ü=ÿ�ü�õ/õ>ô�ð#�>÷�ô�æ#ç�U � æ;ÿnô�ç�ý<ïç�ð<;Dæ.ÿaU `;2æ#ü+ð@ý�ö:ô7÷�æ#ò÷�ü+õ�/õ���ö��:õ�ô"�/æ#ç�òaÿ�ïõOô�ò*ü+ç��+|dûæ� ü0 .û�ÉM�0�Ê Ë3|�Í � É+���Ê Ë3|�Íx

Page 6: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

�$��� �x�8 �¡%¢E£T¡%¢E¤�¥�¦^�8§©¨�ª�«�¥�¦3¬o¡A�a¦3ª�«?­3¢'¡A¬¯®�¦f°Tª�¢'ªR�#¥d±²¦^¥��8ªR«�«-ªR«³µ´t¶�·'¸º¹�»�·'¸¼»�·'¸¼½�´�¹�½,¾<¿d·�¶�¾<´�¹�ÀfÁ,·0¿ÃÂ�¾(Ä#´:Á�´:¶�½iÅ�Æ�´�¶0½�¹�Ç:Å�¶oÈA´c¾<¶�Çx·0Á,ÉA·�Á�Å'½�´�Â�¾J¶�½�·½,»�´�Á�Å"½,¾<¶�ÆiÈ�Ê�Å/Æ�¾<Ë�´�¶cÅ"Æ0´:¶�½�ÌRÍ8¾JÁ�¹&½-Î�½,·i´:Ï<¾J¿d¾<¶�Å'½�´�ÂN·0Ð�È�Ï<´�Ç:·�Ð�¶�½�¾J¶�Æi·"Àa¸*¾(½�¶�´�¹�¹�´-¹:Î�¸�´ÂN´xÑ�¶�´cÒ'Ó!Ô.Õ3Ó�Ö#×xÕa¹�´:½�¹·"À8½,´-¹&½�¾J¿d·0¶�¾J´-¹:Ì�Ø3ÙZÚoÁ�´xÀf´�Á�¹�½�·i½,»�´=¸*¾J½,¶�´-¹,¹Z·"À$½�´�¹�½,¾<¿d·�¶RÊtÙ?ÛxÌ®tª�Ü �a¦^¥�¦^¡A�ÞÝRß$�Mà ¹�´:½µ·�Ài½�´�¹�½,¾<¿d·�¶�¾<´�¹OáãâåäEÙMæEç�è:è:è�ç,ÙZé8ê�½,·'¸Å"Á�Â�¹�Å"Æ0´:¶�½Oë¼¾<¹Ò'Ó!Ô.Õ3Ó�Ö#×xÕ�¾JÀ?Å"¶�Âl·�¶�Ï<Ê}¾(À�½�»�´O¸*¾J½,¶�´�¹�¹�´-¹c·�À?Å"Ï<Ï+½�´�¹�½,¾<¿i·0¶�¾<´�¹t¾J¶láìÅ"Á�´OÂN¾!¹&½�¾J¶%Ç.½�ξ�Ì ´0ÌJÎí äEÙ æ&Ú ç�è:è:è:ç,Ù é�Ú ê í âlî+Ì

ï»�´Mð�ñ:ò0Ó�ð�ñ'ó�ó�ô?õ,öxó(Ó^ñ�÷:óJö�Ò'Ó!Ô.Õ3Ó�Ö#×xÕgø�ùPú+û*üT¹,Ð�È�¹,´x½�·"ÀAÅ�¹,´x½ ·"À%½,´-¹&½�¾J¿d·�¶�¾J´-¹8Ç:·�¶�½�Å�¾J¶%¹Å"Ï<Ï�½�»�´Z½�Á,Ð�¹�½�Å�È�Ï<´Z½,´-¹&½�¾J¿d·0¶�¾J´-¹:ÎRÅ"¶%ÂdÀf·�Á�Å"¶RÊd¸*¾(½�¶�´�¹�¹:Î�¾J½�Çx·0¶�½�Å"¾<¶�¹½,»�´�È%´-¹&½g½,´-¹&½�¾J¿d·�¶RÊÀfÁ,·0¿ý½,»�Å"½�¸*¾(½�¶�´�¹�¹:Ì"þ+·"½�¾<Ç:´½,»�Å"½8½�»�´¾J¶%ÂN¾JËR¾!ÂNÐ�Å�Ï�¸*¾(½�¶�´�¹�¹,´�¹ ÂN·�¶�·"½�»�ÅEË0´T½�·�È%´½�Á,Ð�¹�½,´-ÂÆ�Á�´�Å'½�´:Á�½,»%Å"¶�ÿ��8Àf·0Á½,»�´�¾JÁ½�´�¹�½,¾<¿i·0¶RÊ�½,·�ÈA´=Ð�¹,´�ÂbÌ®tª�Ü �a¦^¥�¦^¡A�ÞÝ%ÝA��� ¾<¹+Å����� ¹,Ð�È�¹,´x½Z·�ÀÅ�¹�´:½Z·"À ½,´-¹&½�¾J¿d·�¶�¾J´-¹*᩾(ÀÅ�¶�Â�·�¶�Ï<Êc¾JÀ � ¾<¹ÂN¾<¹�½,¾<¶�Çx½�Î �� áÎ8Å�¶�Â�Ø �bÙ��gØ^Ù���á��������� Ø3ÙZÚÛ����0Û�� Ø �"!#��!�� � �$!�ÚýâÙZÚ%�&� �('� Ø)!�Ú�Û+*,� ���� Ø3ÙZÚÛ�Û,Û.Ì

- ¾JË0´:¶cÅi¹�´:½g·�À�½,´-¹&½�¾J¿d·�¶�¾J´-¹gá�Å"ÈA·�ÐN½+.�/bÎR¸�´ZÑ�Á�¹�½gÑ�¶%ÂP¾J½�¹+���� ¹,Ð�È�¹,´x½ � ÌNþZ´10R½¸g´qÇx·0¿iÉ�ÐN½,´t½,»�´�ÅEË0´:Á�Å"Æ�´�·�ÀZ½,´-¹&½�¾J¿d·0¶�¾J´-¹iÀfÁ,·0¿ � � Ùãâ�243'î6587 9:7�<;aæ ! � Ì�ï»�´:Á�´xÀf·0Á,´0ÎÅ"Æ�´�¶�½=.�>�¸*¾JÏ<Ï�Ð�É#Â�Å'½�´i¾J½�¹�½�Á,Ð%¹&½=Á�Å'½,¾<¶�Æq·"À�Å"Æ�´�¶�½?.�/OÅ0¹+Àf·0ÏJÏ<·'¸Z¹dØ^Å�ÏJÏ�Á�Å'½�¾J¶�Æ�¹�Å"Á�´iÅ"½½,¾<¿i´?@�´A0�Ç:´:ÉN½*¸*»�´�Á,´=¹,É%´-Çx¾JÑ�´�Â�ÛxÌB�C ªR� ¥ C ªR� � > Ø^ë$ÛEDGF æ â� > Øfë$ÛZÅ"¶� ټÅ"Á�´MÉA·0¹,¾(½�¾JË0´ � > Ø^ë$ÛIH ÙPØJ2LK$� > Øfë$Û,Û·�¶�´�·�ÀM� > Ø^ë$ÛÅ"¶� ÙW¾<¹Z¶�´:Æ�Å'½,¾<Ë�´ � > Ø^ë$ÛIH ÙN3NØO2PK$Q%R�ë ä í � > Ø^ë$Û í ç í Ù í êEÛ� > Øfë$ÛZÅ"¶� ټÅ"Á�´M¶�´�Æ0Å"½,¾<Ë�´ � > Ø^ë$ÛIH ÙPØJ2SHT� > Øfë$Û,Û

�$� U V�¡A«�«-¦f£W ÀbÅ�¶PÅ"Æ0´:¶�½:.�´:¶%Çx·�Ð�¶0½�´:Á�¹�Å=È�Å0Â/É%Å"Á,½,¶�´�Á:XyÂNÐ�Á�¾<¶�Æ�¹�·0¿d´Z´A0�Ç�»�Å�¶�Æ�´0ÎY.�¸*¾JÏ<Ï�ÉA´:¶%Å"Ï<¾[Z�´X ÈRÊ�ÂN´�Ç:Á,´-Å�¹,¾J¶�Æ�¾(½�¹TÁ�Å'½�¾J¶�Æ?·"ÀIXWÈRÊ�\µÅ"¶%Â�¾J¶�Àf·�Á�¿i¾<¶�Æ/¾(½�¹g¶�´:¾<Æ�»RÈ%·0Á�¹�Ì à ¶tÅ�Æ�´:¶�½T¸*»�·Á,´-Çx´:¾<Ë�´-¹g½,»�¾!¹*¾<¶NÀf·�Á�¿�Å'½,¾<·�¶qÇ:Å�¶�Ç:·�¿/È�¾J¶�´�¾J½Z¾<¶0½�·�¾(½�¹�½,Á�Ð�¹�½Z¿i·NÂN´�Ï�·"À]XPÌ

- ·0¹�¹�¾<Él¾!¹�Â�¾(Ä#´:Á�´:¶�½�ÀfÁ,·0¿ ½,»�´ Ð�¹,Ð�Å"Ï�Á�´xÀf´:Á�Á�Å"Ï�É�Á,·NÇ:´�¹�¹:Î�È%´-Ç:Å�Ð�¹�´�Å"¶ÞÅ"Æ�´�¶�½�Ç:Å�¶É�Á,·0É�Å"Æ�Å'½�´ÅZÁ�Ð�¿d·�Á$¸*¾J½,»�·�ÐN½8»�ÅEËR¾J¶�Æ+È%´�´:¶�´10RÉ�ÏJ¾!Çx¾J½,Ï<Ê�^�Ð�´:Á�¾J´-ÂbÌ�Í�·�Á$½,»�¾!¹8Á,´-Å�¹,·�¶�ÎxÆ0·0¹�¹�¾<ɾ<¹*É�Á,·NÇx´-¹,¹,´�Âc¾J¶%ÇxÁ�´:¿d´:¶�½�Å�ÏJÏ<Ê�Ì®tª�Ü �a¦^¥�¦^¡A�ÞÝN���`_ Ð�É�ÉA·0¹,´?Å"Æ0´:¶�½LRTÁ�´�Çx´�¾JË0´�¹*Åi¿d´�¹�¹,Å�Æ�´=�baNØfë$Û�ØfÀfÁ,·0¿ Å�Æ�´�¶0½�c�Å"ÈA·�Ð�½Å"Æ�´�¶�½?ë$Û.Ì�W À�d��Ø c�Û=¾!¹�¶�´�Æ0Å'½�¾JË0´�Î$½,»�´�¶TRM¾<Æ�¶�·�Á�´�¹�½�»�´c¿d´�¹�¹�Å"Æ�´0ÌIW À�d��Ø)c�Û=¾!¹�ÉA·0¹,¾J½,¾<Ë�´�ν,»�´�¶qÅ�Æ�´�¶0½LRÐ�ÉAÂ�Å"½,´-¹*¾(½�¹½,Á�Ð�¹�½*Á�Å"½,¾<¶�Æd·"À�Å"Æ�´�¶�½�ë Å�¹�Àf·0ÏJÏ<·'¸Z¹:ÌB�C ªR� � � Ø^ë$Û ¤��Me � a Ø^ë$Û ¥ C ªR� � � Øfë$ÛJDGF æ âÅ"Á�´�È%·�½,»qÉ%·�¹�¾J½,¾<Ë�´ � � Øfë$Ûgâf� � Ø^ë$ÛIHg� � Ø c�ÛJ� a Øfë$ÛxØO2K$� � Øfë$Û,ÛÅ"Á�´�È%·�½,»q¶�´:Æ�Å'½�¾JË0´ �d��Øfë$ÛMHg�d��Ø)c�ÛE�baNØ^ë$ÛxØO2PHg�d�,Øfë$Û�Û»�ÅEË0´M·0É�É%·�¹�¾J½,´=¹,¾JÆ0¶�¹ ØG� � Ø^ë$ÛIHT� � Ø c�ÛJ� a Øfë$Û,Ûh3NØO2K$Q6R ë ä í � � Øfë$Û í ç í � � Ø c�ÛJ� a Øfë$Û í êEÛ

Page 7: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

iIj<i k=l4mon:pqlsrstupwvxmoyzSl4{Mv|r}�~?�"�4����~|���A���<�o~?�Y�o�&�G�(�h�����[�<�1~=�O�(��~`�<���o�(�O���Y�q��"������~1�h�h�<~|�P�Y���h�����O�|�

� �`�o�4�x���1�)��� E�¢¡(~1�"~|����� £s�O¤w����~A�h��¤=�L�[�<�q�"�Y�]¥"��� �d£s�o~s�1�����O~P�Y�¢��¡�~|�(�M���¦¤`���h���O�����"�Y��¥"~1��������~�h¥����§�¨���<�+���h�o�J��~|�%������©ª��«��4�S~|¬�~|�|£��L¥"~|�%�h¥"~¢��¡�~|�(���L�Y��~=�h�����O�J�S�(�O��¥q¤(£w�h¥"������¡�¥�h~|�o~s�4��~|���[�q�h~|���(�����[�(���1£���¥"~1¤��L�<�<�­�A���w¬(~1��¡�~����®¥"�[¡(¥��N���h�o�Y�]�h�����O�|�M¯S�(�q¬(~1���O~|�[¤(£�¨��(�"~&���L�h¥"~%�Y¡(~1�q�����"�q~s�O�I° �������x�[�,�®�h�����O�J�S�(�O��¥q¤����Y�"�"~|�|£M�h¥�~&�Y��¥"~1�x�Y¡(~1�q��L�[�<���o~��G�����A~|���h����~1�����[�<�1~��¨�s£(�<~|�(���<�"¡?�h�N�[�4�f�N���h���������h�o�J�s�q±����­��¥"� �:��~|�(�O�(�b£Y�P~¥��¦¬�~`�G�(��Y�w¤��J�S����¡�~1�q���L²�³��Y���®²�´w£"µd³"¶G·"¸E¹­ºfµd´�¶u»�¸E¹P�L¥"~|�6¼­½¿¾À�

Á �&Â���Ã4Ä"Å�ÆÇ�)ÆÇÈ|ÆÇ�)�ÉI�����O��<�+���Y�L�h���Y�o�O�[�h�<¬�~(£q������h¥�~=�G���<�[�4�L�<�"¡x�L�[�<�b¥"�(�<�6�¨�Ê»§� �L�x���Y�h�<�������b�Y¡�~|�q�|˶Gµd³�¶u·"¸E¹:Ì͵d³"¶uÎw¸E¹J¸bÏ$¶uµª³�¶uÎw¸E¹PÌеd³�¶uÑ�¸E¹O¸­ÒÓ¶uµd³�¶G·"¸J¹SÌ,µª³o¶GÑ�¸J¹O¸

Ô �`�ª�1Õ Ö�×E�h�1ÆÇÄ|ÖAØY�hÙ��A���AÄo�ÉI�����O�:� �:�h~1�[�ÇÚ)��~1�<���G�����A�<�"¡o£Y�o~s�1�����O~��¡�~|�(���­���A�:���(�h�¨���[¬(~1�<¤N�L�[�h¥���¥"�(�h~�L¥"�(�Û��¥"~1¤�h�����O�|�SÉ+¥�~��A�(�q¬(~1���O~®� �����h�"~(£:���&�o~|�[�4�Ü�T�1~1�h���Y�<�Í�h�����O�|£:�<�����<¬w�<�"���Y� ����~1���Í����A�(��Ý����Þ��¥"~1�<�?�O�o�O�"� �A�<���o��Y�S�Y�h¥�~1���Nß à4áâ��É+¥�~¢Ý����O�������O�`�Y�Ê�h¥�~¢�G�(�[�<�4�L�[��¡&���"�[~N�<������h~|�6���&�h¥"~=� ��~|�N��¥��4�L�[�M���h���O�L�o~1�J�S~|~1�6�J�S���Y¡(~1�q���S� �+�[�"�[�h� �Y�<�<¤&�Y���4¬�~�ã£q�h¥"~|��h¥"~N�h�����O�`��~A�J�P~1~|����¥"�(�h~��J�P�6��¡�~1�q�����L�<�[�]�"���=�"~|�A��~|�(�O~¢�o~|�[�4�8��¥��4�`�h¥"��~|�h¥"�(�<�d�É+¥"~®�A���w¬(~1���O~�� �N�h���"~�£Ê�h�[���1~&�[�����Y�h¥Í�Y¡(~1�q���¢�h�����O�N~|�(��¥T�Y��¥"~1�x��~1�<�4�åäN£���¥"~1¤�L�[�<�=�h~|���æ�"�Y�%�h�f�A�w����~1���4��~��L�[�h¥æ~|�(��¥ç�Y��¥"~1�®�L¥��Y�h~|¬�~1�6�h¥�~è�h�[�h���Y�h�<���b£P�h¥w����h~|�[�"�G�����A�<�"¡L�h¥�~S���h¥"~|�|° �I�(�"�<�"�[�(�¢�Y�����"�M��¥"~1�é�(�I�"�(��ÚE�A�w����~1���4���[¬(~­�Y���¢�"�"¥"~|�[���G��� �êP~A�J�P~1~1�6ãÍ�����$äN£o�Y�w¤q�h¥"�<�"¡��1���6¥����"��~1�gß ë4á)�ì  â�L¶Gµ ³ ¶u·�¸J¹:Ì,ã ³ ¸dÏ�¶uµ ´ ¶G»�¸J¹SÌ,ã ´ ¸S��¥"~1�

¶Gµ ³ ¶G·"¸E¹GíMî=ïе ³ ¶G·"¸J¹O¸bÏ�¶uµ ´ ¶G»�¸J¹GíMî=ï,µ ´ ¶G»�¸J¹O¸ì  â�L¶Gµ ³ ¶u·�¸ ¹:ð ä ³ ¸bÏ$¶Gµ ´ ¶G»ª¸ ¹+ð ä ´ ¸S��¥"~1�

¶Gµ ³ ¶G·"¸E¹GíMî=ñе ³ ¶G·"¸J¹O¸bÏ�¶uµ ´ ¶G»�¸J¹GíMî=ñ,µ ´ ¶G»�¸J¹O¸ò���óP�hØ�ô"Ã|õ(ÃY� ÆuØYÄ

¯S�����h� ��~1���h¥"��~1~x�Y¡�~|�q���L»M£�·ª£��Y����Îo�� â�­»�©w�"�4��·§�Y�o�®·%©w�"�4���Î�£��"���`»����w~|��"�Y�=©w�"�4�éÎo�ª«��4�ö�¢����¥�»$�h�����J���=Î6�h¥"�����<����~1��~1��������¥"�4�é�¢�o��¥�»��h�����J���`·�£�Y���%¥"�4�æ�¢����¥%·����h���O����Î��"É+¥"~`�G�(�[�<�4�L�[��¡x���"�<~=�L�[�<�b¥"�(�<�6�¨�Ê»§� �+���Y�h�<������� �

¶uµ ³ ¶uÎw¸E¹GíMî�ñ͵ ³ ¶G·"¸J¹O¸bÏ�¶uµ ³ ¶uÎw¸E¹Gí�î�ñ,µ ´ ¶uÎw¸E¹J¸

÷ �h�[���"�<~L�G�(�h�N�"�<�`�G�(�S��~1�h~|�h���<�"�[��¡?�h�����O�­�h¥��Y�S���4�h� �OÝ�~|�­�h¥"~����o�4¬(~�A�(���J�������[�q�s£Y�<�µ ³ ¶uÎw¸E¹GíMîLøÀµ ³ ¶G·"¸E¹Eµ ´ ¶uÎw¸E¹

ù ú%ûLü?ýbþ�ÿ�� ý����������� Íý����������

 E�$�(�"�¢�h�[�N�"� �4�h~s���h~A���"�b£M~|����¥è�Y¡(~1�q�?¥����¢�Y�fÆÇÄ��E�A����Å��ʬ�~s�������s£b�Y�À���Aô��A���)Æ Å1�=¬�~s�������s£�Y����������~1� �­���I�O~|¬�~|�����dÄ��1ƨõ�����ØY��Å��q E��¡(~1�"~|����� £Y�h¥"~��"~1�<¡�¥w�����­������~1� �P��~1��~1��� ����¥"�4������w¤��Y¡�~|�q���M©q���4�è�h¥"~+¡��<¬�~|�¢�Y¡(~1�q�|£¦¥"�4�g�����q¤���¡�~|�(���I�[�Ê©w�"�4��1£s�L¥"� ��¥N�1�����¢�"���¨�J¤�¨����~1�<����¡(�P�h�o£o�����®�O�����I�" E�§���"��|���h~�£���¥"~?�"~|�[¡(¥q�����L������~|�<��©�~1�"��q¤%�Y�§�Y¡(~1�q��Y��~�h¥"~?¡(�[¬(~1�®�Y¡�~|�q�|° �S��~1���h~s�O~|�(���4���[�(�&�Y���h¥�~?�Y�h¥�~1��Y¡(~1�q���|°w~�����~1�h�h� �O~?�Y�o�6��~1�������Y�h�<���b�

Page 8: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

�����! #"$��%'& ()�*�"$+-,."'(/�0+�"1 0"'��"$+2�3%-"'465��0(�"'487#�9,:%2(,;��%-"$+-"'(<%�=0"�>?%�7#+'@!A1B�"�)#*�"$+-,;"�(/�!+-" 0"$��"$+2�3%�"�4C�#(D=0"'>�%�7#+-(E5GFIHJ"$+�%�*�+-5�,.�� K%�B�"L,.�#%-"$+-"'(<%M=0"'>�%�7#+E70N�%-B�"9 0,.=0"'�O�! #"$��%'@PA1B�"Q 70%�,.=3�3%�,.70��NR70+/%-B�,S(�,S(/%-76>'�!HT%-*�+�"�%�B�"�,;��%�*�,:%-,;7#��%�BU�3%V�0���! #"$��%�WX,.Y;YJH�+-7G4�*�>�"E)#*�"$+-,;"�(4T"$HJ"$��4�,;�� 97#�Z,;%-(�,;��%�"'+�"�([%2($@

\ B�"$�9�!�9�0 0"$��%+-"'>�"',;=#"'(�M)�*�"'+�F#]3,:%�WX,.Y.YT%�+-F^%-7^�!��(�W_"'+,:%_5��0(�"'4670�L,;%-("$`GHJ"$+�%�,S(�"=0"'>�%�7#+']?7#+P+�"$NR"$+a%-7�7!%-B�"$+P�0 0"$��%2(b,:%PcG��73W�('@$A1B�"7#+�,. 0,.���!%�,.�� X�! 0"'��%b>$70Y.Y;"�>?%2(P�!Y.Y!HJ7#(-(<,.5�Y."+�"$NR"$+-+-�0Y.(']'�0��4^>�7#��%�,.��*�"'(d%�B�"VH�+-7G>$"'(-(P5GFM>�7#�#%2�0>�%�,.�� �(�7 Q "�70NT%�B�"1(�*� 0 #"'(<%�"'4^+�"$NR"$+-+-�0Y.('@�V%X%�B�"^(-� Q "E%�, Q "0]�,;%�>2B��!�� 0"'(V,;%-( Q 7T4T"'Y.(1NR7#+X7!%-B�"$+��0 0"$��%2($@

e *�+P"�`THJ"$+-, Q "'�#%2(d,.�G=07#Y;=#"f5J"�%[WV"$"'�6g!h��!��4Mi#h��! #"$��%-(bWX,;%�Bj,;��%�"'+�"�([%f�!��4D"$`GHJ"$+�%�,S(�"=0"'>�%�7#+-(V7!N4T, Q "$��(�,;7#�lk�@�A1B�"M�! #"$��%-(X(�"$�U4Z)�*�"'+�,."'(']T+�"$NR"$+-+-�0Y.(']T�!��4K+-"'(�HU7#��(�"'(_%�7L70��"�!��70%�B�"'+']��!Y.YU%-B�"�WXB�,;Y."�Y."'�0+���,;�� 6�!5J70*T%V"'�0>2Bm7!%�B�"$+2($&#,;��%�"'+�"�([%1�!��4m"�`THJ"$+�%�,S(<"�=#"'>�%�70+2('@A1B�"j�! #"$��%-(��!+-"MY;, Q ,:%-"'4n,.�l%�B�"j��* Q 5J"$+�70N��"$,. 0BG5J70+2(V%�B�"'F Q �oFKB��o=0"�pq,.�l70*�+�>'�0(�"%�B�"MY., Q ,;%�,.(�r�@

sbtvu wyx�z'{o|v}0~\ "D��73W�4T"$����"M(�7 Q "�*�(�"�NR*�Y Q "$%�+-,.>'(V,;�ZWXB�,.>2BZ%�78,.�#%-*�,;%�,.=0"$Y.F�>$�0HT%�*�+�"�%�B�"E+-"'(�*�Y:%2(V7!N70*�+X"$`GHJ"$+-, Q "'��%-('@� x�����|�z'|��J��uG�dt A1B�"j�o=0"'+-�0 0"�+-"$H�*T%-�!%�,.70�l7!N�!�n�! #"$��%�����NR+-7 Q %�B�"jHU7#,;��%�7!N70%�B�"'+�! 0"'��%-(V,.(� 0,.=0"$�K5GF �T��� �����

�T��� ���/�y�o�3�^��������a� � ��� ���WXB�"$+-"Z��,S(8%�B�"l�G* Q 5J"$+970NE�0 0"$��%2(jWXB�7cG��73W��0 0"'�#%9� � @ \ "l(-�oF%�BU�3%��! #"$��%L�E�c���73W�(X�! 0"'��%1� � ,:N�!�U4m7#��Y;FZ,:N� � ,S(��8��"',; #B�5J70+170N��E�G@� x�����|�z'|��J��u���t A1B�"��o=0"$+2�! #"j+-"$H�*�%-�3%-,;7#�O70N1�0Y;Y/�0 0"'�#%2(D,.( �  ��¡�3�?¢ ��£� ��� �G�v��� � ]WXB�"$+-"M¤¥,.(1%-B�"D%�70%-�0Yb��* Q 5J"$+X7!N�! #"$��%-('@

A1B�,.(X�o=#"$+2�! #"�,S(X� Q "$%�+-,.>�NR7#+�4T"�%-"$+ Q ,.��,.�� L%�B�"^([%2�!5�,.Y;,.¦'�!%�,.70�Z7!N�8>$7 QLQ *���,:%[F#@

sbt¨§ ©dxGª�xG}!z�|��J�«�J¬�­mx�®j¯�{o°f~9¯��f°�±�xG�f¯�ªRz�|�xG~² ,. 0*�+�" � ,;Y.Y.*�([%-+-�!%�"�(�%�B�"�>2BU�!�� #"_70NU%-+�*�(<%/+2�3%�,.�� �(f4�"$HJ"$��4T,.�� M7#�L4�,:³a"$+-"$��%=3�!Y.*�"'(70Na´�!��48µ/@�¶�!+�%����0H�H�Y.,;"�(f%�7^�D��"'W��0 0"'�#%WXB�7M,.��,;%�,S�!Y.Y;F6B��0(��E%�+-*�([%/70Nah�]!5�*T%/5�*�,;YS4�(�*�H%�B�"8+-�!%�,.�� Z%�B�+-70*� #BIHJ7#(�,:%-,;=#"6,.��%�"$+2�0>�%�,.70��('·a¶�!+�%�¸¹�!H�H�Y;,."'(�%�7l�m>$7G70HJ"$+2�3%�,.=0"8�! #"$��%WXB�7�,S(��!Y.+-"'�04�FmWV"$Y.Y:º�%�+-*�(<%�"'4P·U¶�!+�%E»¼�!H�H�Y;,."'(�%�7m�0�n*���%�+-*�([%-"'4n�0 0"$��%�WXB�79%�B�+-70*� 0B+�"'HU"��3%�"�4CHJ7#(�,;%�,.=0"L,;��%-"$+2�0>?%-,;7#��(E5U"�>�7 Q "�(E%�+-*�(<%�"'4P·P¶�!+�%D½¾�0H�H�Y.,;"�(E%�7n�K��"$W¿�! #"$��%WXB�7#(�"9+-�!%�,.�� KN��!Y.Y.(^5U"�>$�!*U(<"970NV��"' #�!%�,.=0"L,;��%-"$+2�0>?%-,;7#��('·P¶�!+�%MÀ¹4�"'(->�+-,;5J"'(M�K%-+�*�(<%�"�4�! 0"'��%�WXB�7K5U"�>�7 Q "�(E*���%�+-*�([%-"'4O5U"�>$�0*�(<"87!NV4T"�NR"�>?%�,.70�U($·b�!�U4b]P¶�!+�% ² �0H�H�Y.,;"�(�%-7K�0�*���%�+-*�([%-"'4l�! #"$��%1WXB�795U"�>�7 Q "�(VNR*�+�%�B�"'+X*���%�+-*�([%-"'4K5J"'>$�0*�(�"E70N�4�"�NR"'>�%�,.70��('@

»_70��(�,.4�"$+��!�I�0 0"'�#%�WXB�7�>�7G70HJ"$+2�3%-"'(X�!�U4n4T"�NR"�>?%-(�70�n4T,;³J"'+�"'��%�,;��%-"$+2�0>?%-,;7#��('@�ÁP"$% 5U"m%�B�"�+2�3%-,;7n5J"�%[WV"$"'�%�B�"Z�G* Q 5J"$+^70N�>�7G70HJ"$+2�3%-,;7#��(^�!�U4Ã4T"�NR"�>?%�,.70�U($@f¸_FÄ�!H�H�+�70ºH�+�,S�3%-"$Y.FZ(�"$Y."'>�%�,.�� L%�B�"j+-�!%�,.�� #(170N´«�!��4Kµ/]JWV"^>$�!�lY."�% ÂLÅÇÆ @U��(-(�* Q "M%�B�"j,;��,;%�,S�!Y%�+-*�([%X+2�3%-,;�� L70Nf�! #"$��%X� � ,S(Xh�È i�@�ÁP"$%  � kTÉ � h�É-g!h�@ ² ,. 0*�+-"Mg64�,.(�H�YS�oFG(_%-B�"^>2B��!�� 0"E7!N%�+-*�([%M+2�3%-,;�� U@b¤�7!%-,.>$"8%�B��!%E%-+�*U([%M5�*�,.Y;%^*�HC%-B�+-70*� #BÄ(�"$=#"$+2�!YfHU7�(<,;%�,.=0"8,;��%-"$+2�0>?%-,;7#��(E,.(Y;7�([%1%�B�+�7#*� 0BK"$=#"$�l�8(�,.�� 0Y."^4T"�NR"�>?%-,;7#�P@

Page 9: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

0 5 100

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Tru

st v

alue

s

Part A. T0=0,α=0.05,0.1,0.2

0 5 10−1

−0.8

−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

Tru

st v

alue

s

Part D. T0=0,β=−0.1,−0.2,−0.3

0 5 100.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

Tru

st v

alue

s

Part B. T0=0.6,α=0.05,0.1,0.2

0 5 10−1

−0.5

0

0.5

1

Tru

st v

alue

s

Part E. T0=0.6,β=−0.1,−0.2,−0.3

0 5 10−0.6

−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

Tru

st v

alue

s

Part C. T0=−0.6,α=0.05,0.1,0.2

0 5 10−1

−0.9

−0.8

−0.7

−0.6

Tru

st v

alue

s

Part F. T0=−0.6,β=−0.1,−0.2,−0.3

Ê/Ë.ÌUÍ3ÎGÍ�Ï0Ð-Ñ:Ð-Ò-Ó[ÔÖÕ�×ØÕ'ÙDÚ¥Û'×GÜÃÝdÞß/à�Ð-á[ÐlÚãâåä0æ ä�ç0è¨é�ê/é.ë�Þ�ä0æÖìoè¨é�êXæ é¨ë�Þ�ä0æ í!è¨évêXê/é.ë8Û'×�ÜîÝ¿âê�ä!æÖìoè é.ï�é ë�Þ�ê�ä0æ í0è éSðVé ë�Þ�ê�ä0æ ñ0è éRò�é ë

óbôSõ öm÷UøJù�úfù�ûfüÄýKûfú�þGÿ�ù���������þnömüJþGû�'ÿ��� ������������������ �!���"��#%$"&'$"(�)*�+ ��-,.���/ .�+0���,.��,��"(1���2(�34�5�6$879���:�1;1�6�!,��+<>=?(1�9�5��@��+ �,����3�(1$"$A(�)B�"��;-�+C��1��0�$A�!<ED����������F��;1�6�E,?GIHJ���?�K��(1��LM�+(E(!09�6 .��,��"N1�O�1;1�+�E,�PE�1��@Q(1��$A&2,��� ��6���;1�6�E,.�BGIR�P�GIS�P��1��@TGIUV#%��(�)W���"�X<9YZ���+�" B�A���8,.�"�1$[ .��,��"��;!�*,.(�)*�1 .@��*G H �� .�V\�] ^�P�\�] _�P����@X\�] `�P� .�6��09���a,.�AN!�+$"&1<b%(-,.���4�cN!�+ ���;!�* .�+0���,.��,��"(1�d(13e��;!�+�E,*G H ��,?,.�A���F\-���?\�] _�<EfI(�)?�6N1�6 6PE���c&���,?,��"�2�

g P���;!�+�E,*G H @��h3����a,.�Z�1;!���"���5,*�1;1�+�E,ZGIR�<�ij�h,Okmln\�] \!_V�1��@domlqpO\�] r�<%DI�+�+(1 �@��"��;-,.(,����I3�(1 .�K��$��F3�(1 ?��0@���,.�A��;K,� .���5,6PEsR�t�u�vwlxty\�] ^?z{t|pO\�] rEv5v.}�t g pX~X���w� \�] ^��8���ap'\�] r�� v>l\�] g }�\�]��FlW\�] g ^%����<%YZ���-���+)� .�+0���,���,.�A(!�X(13�,����-�1;1�+�E,O��� ��tyG H v?lW\�] ^ g r�<���(! ��6(�N1�+ �P��;1�6�E,wG R )B�"$A$�@��������+���"����,.�B�8,��>(1�9�5�6 �N���,.�A(!��(�3���;1�6�E,wGIH�,��� .(1��;!��(1��,�,����I��(��h����$����h,5L)?(! �#<c�>N1�6�E,����1$A$"&4,����Z�cN1�6 .�1;1�> .�+0���,.��,.�A(!�K(139��;!�+�E,�G�H��Q�c&F@��6�h .�6�!�5�w,�(F�I$"(�)�$"�+N1�6$�<YZ���"�O�"�*,.���4�����w�h�2�|�F�����h�h�a�.�����a<9���";1�� .�Vr2�hC�09�6 ��"���+�E,.�1$A$"&��+(1��7� .�Q�Z(1�� B�%&%0�(�,����6���"�6<

óbô"  ¡�û�6�3øPúe¢�£0ùvû�ü�¤nþE¥�öZüUþGû�'ÿ=?$A���� .$A&!P>�'��(��h����$Z���+,|)?(! �#�)B�"$A$I��(�,d .�+�Q���"�:�5,.�1��$"�T3�(1 Q$"(1��;9P����6�6����������;!�+�E,.��)B�"$A$�h(1�E,.�A�%���1$A$"&-�"�!,. �(�@��9�h�O���9@K .�+��(�N1�*,.���+�Q���+$"N1�6��3� .(1�x,����B���h,|)*(1 .#�<�Ye(F�+N���$"����,��B��(�)(1�� T��0�0� �(E�1���n�!�+�h(!���2(�@���,����������1��;1����(13-,������TN��� .�A�+,|&1P*)?�'���+;1�"�n)B�A,��¦�{�5,.�1��$"����h,|)*(1 .#m�1��@J�A�E,. �(�@����+�������6)§��;!�+�E,- .�1��@�(!�2$"&��"�E,�(¨�A,6<�YZ���/���+)©��;!�+�E,K���-;!�AN!�+� .�1��@�(1�ª���+�";1�%��(1 ��+P!����@Q�1$A$�(13,����6�A w,� .���|,? .��,��"��;!��,.(�)*�1 .@���,������w���+)«��;!�+�E,w�� .�B¬+�6 �(9<DI�.�5����� ­�ln\�] `1rE�*��,e,.�A���*®a<6¯°��(1 �@��+ j,�(4�9�*�+���9��@�@���@V�A�E,.(I,.���*��(��h����$!���h,|)*(1 .#P

,����Z���6){��;!�+�E,e)*(1��$�@-�9�cN1�>,.(�#!�+�60K�h(%(10��+ ���,.�A��;I .�+$"�"�1��$A&V(! e�6$"���*�9�*(!�5,� ��1�+�A¬6�6@V���� .$A&!<

Page 10: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20−0.4

−0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Times of interactions

Tru

st v

alue

s

±>²"³9´6µ�´E¶�·%¸6¹!º�»>¼6½�¾°¿|À!ÁM¾j½"¼6¿�ÂBÃÅÄ1ÆÈÇ�É>Ç"Ê�ËEÌ�Í!ÆÈÇyÉBÎ Ç"Ê�Ë�Ï+Í!ÆÈÇyÉ?Ð*Ç�ÊÑ>·E»�¹4ÒXÃ�Í�Î Í�ÄB¸6¹%Ó4ÔQÃÕÉwÍ1Î Ö

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 2000.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5

Ave

rage

rep

utat

ion

Numbers of messages

±>²"³9´6×�´�Ø?Ùc»�¿5¸6º�»Z¿|».ÚEÀ!¾5¸h¾|Ûܼ�¹�¼+½[¸6º6»�¹�¾*Ý?ÞX½�¼+¿ZßàÃÅÖ�Í�ËEÒ/Ã�Í1Î ÍcÄF¸+¹%Ó-Ô�ÃÕÉwÍ1Î Ö

áMâ.ã?äAå�äAâ�ä�æ�ç�â�è�é.ê6ã�è�ë!ç"ì2í�ë!é?îhë%ë!ï9ê6é.æ�â�ä"å�ðVä"ãwçAë�ñVòEó*ôKí�é.ê6õEö�ê6å!â.çAôQî+ëEë!ï9ê6é.æ�â�ä"å�ðVñBäAâ�èdë1â�è�ê6éæ�ð1ê6åEâ.ã6÷�â�è�ê�å�ê+ñ«æ1ð1ê+åEâ?î6æ�åQè�æcø!êBä8â�ãwæcø!ê+é�æ�ð1êZé.ê+ï�ö�â.æ�â.äAë!åQäAå9îhé.ê6æ1ã�êOã5â�ê6æ!ì�ä"çAô!ò!ù�äAð!ö�é.êBúîhë1å�û�é�üQã*â.è�ä"ãOèEô%ï�ë�â.è�ê6ã�ä"ã6ò

ý þ ÿ ��������� ÿ��

� çAâ�è�ë!ö�ð1èJñ*êQï�é�ê�ã5ê6åEâ-ë1ö�é-é.ê6ã�ö�çAâ.ãFä"åJâ�è�ê/îhë1åEâ.ê �%â-ë�íZê+ç"ê6îhâ�é.ë1å�ä�îQîhë!ü2ü�ö�å�äAâ�ä"ê6ã6÷[ë1ö�éæ�ï�ï�é.ë!æ!î�è2æ1ï�ï�ç"äAê�ã�â.ë-üKö�çAâ�ä�æ�ð!ê+åEâ?ã�ô�ã|â.ê+üQã�ä"ådð1ê6å�ê+é�æ�ç�ò���ë!ã5â?î+ö�é�é.ê+åEâ>ü�ö�ç8â.ä"æ1ð1ê6å!â*ã5ô�ã��â�ê+üQã*æ1ã.ã5ö�ü2ê��9ê6å�ê+ø!ë1ç"ê+å�î+ê1÷!ü2ê�æ�å�ä"å�ðKâ�è�æ�âwâ�è�ê4æ1ð1ê+åEâ�ã>ä"ü2ï�çAä�îhäAâ�ç"ôdæ1ã.ã5ö�ü2êOâ�è�æ�â*ë1â�è�ê6éæ�ð1ê6åEâ.ãwæ1é�êIâ�é.ö�ã5â|ñ?ë!é5â.èEô2æ�å�ì�é�ê6çAä�æ���çAê!ò � ï�ï�é�ëEæ1î�è�ê�ã�í�ë!é?ê��%ï�çAä�îhäAâ*é.ê+ï�ö�â.æ�â�ä"ë1ådüQæ�å9æ�ð1ê��ü2ê6åEâ*î+æ1åQè�ê+ç"ï�â�è�ê�æ�ð!ê+åEâ.ã�û�å�ê6ã.ã�êBâ�è�ê6äAé?äAåEâ.ê+é�æ1îaâ.äAë!å�ã>ì�ê6ï9ê6å�ì�ä"å�ðKë!å�â�è�ê�é�ê6ï�ö�â�æ�â�ä"ë1å9ãë�íFâ�è�ê�ë�â�è�ê+é�æ1ð1ê+åEâ�ã+ò�Zè�ê�æ���ä"ç"ä8â|ô:â�ëÅì�ê�æ�ç�ñBä8â.è ã5ê6ç8û9ã�è[÷*æ�åEâ�ä�ã5ë�î+ä"æ1ç�÷>ë!édö�å�é.ê+ç"ä�æ���ç"êæ�ð1ê6åEâ.ãZî+æ1åXç"ê6æ!ìdâ.ë�ü2ë!é�êFé.ë���ö9ã|âBüKö�ç8â.ä"æ1ð1ê+åEâOã�ô%ã5â�ê6üQã+ò

Page 11: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 20000

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

Numbers of messages

Ave

rage

rep

utat

ion

������� ��� �!#"%$�&�'(")$�"+*-,-.�&�.�/10324035�2-"%67&3'3"+28.:9<;(=?>@5�03$<ACBED3F�GIHJBKF�L F(MN&32IOQPRBTSF�L D

U�VXWZYXW%[3\][�^I_a`�YXYXW%b-`-c+dN`-e#f�V \�_%\Z_]dX[:W+`8_]g�^XhI\�b�i `�h�[�^I_+\kj `-\�[(elb�^N_%dX[�g�Wag�^I_][3W%`-cm_]g�b�^n\o gp_%dQb�_%dX[�W+\3q(r�b o [3s�[�W(t�gu_�evb�[3\a^Xb�_wixVXy�yuzlY W]b�_][3c _{`�h-`�gu^ \�_w\]YXVXW%g�b�V \ZW%`�_]g�^Xh-\ah�[3^X[�W+`8_%[3ejIz}|~`�y�g�c�gub-V \�`�h-[�^I_%\3qv�?_�W%[�y�gu[(\�b�^ yuz}b�^J_]dX[3W][Qjn[3gu^Xh�`4y�`�W%h�[N^�VX|�jn[3W�b�i�`�h-[�^I_%\ o d bb���[�W{dXb�^ [3\�_wW+`8_%gu^XhI\a_]b�b8s�[�W%W%g�ev[_]dX[)[���[(cm_�b�iX_%dX[)W%`�_]g�^Xh-\wYXW%b8s�g�eX[3elj�zl_%dX[)|4`�yug�c g�b�Vn\`�h�[3^I_%\3q�)dXg�\~g�\R^Xb�_}g�ev[(`�y�t�jXVv_}^Xb�_}`�^�z o b�W+\�[J_]dn`�^�ev[3|�bvc�W%`�_]g�c@W]VXy�[�g�^�dIV |4`�^\�bvc g�[ _%gu[(\�qv��[�|4bvc W+`8_%g�c�\�bvc g�[ _%gu[(\<c3`�^X^ b�_)h�V `�W%`�^-_%[�[�_%d `8_�`�|4`�yug�c g�b�Vn\W%VXy�[�W o b-^k� _)j�[[�y�[3cm_%[3e�t�jXVv_�_%dX[�z�W][(evV c�[<_%dX[�c+d `�^ c [)b�i�\]V c+d~`�^4[�s-[�^I_�j�zQ[3^Xh-`�h�g�^Xh�`Ny�`�W%h�[:ixW+`�c _]g�b�^b�iw_]dX[lY�b�YXV y�`�_]g�b�^Jgu^J_]d [lW%`�_]g�^Xh4YXW]bvc�[3\%\�q

��^�ixVv_%VXW%[ o b�W%��t o [4YXy�`�^�_]b�\�_]V evz�_]dX[~\]Yn[(c g�`�y�YXW%b�jXy�[�|~\Nb�i<y�zIg�^Xh@`�^ e�W%VX|4b�W+\`�\ o [�y�y�`-\�b�iQc b�|4|�VX^Xgu_�z�ixb-W]|~`8_%gub-^kq��[�`�y�\]b o `�^I_�_%b�\�_%V evzT_]d [�[�s-b�y�Vv_]g�b�^n`�W%z\�gu_]V `�_]g�b�^ \ o dX[3W][Nh-W]b-VXY \<b�iw`�h�[3^-_+\)c b�^n\�g�ev[�W)W+`8_%gu^Xh�\]c+d [�|4[3\:ixb-W:b�_]dX[3W�`�h�[3^I_%\3q��)d [YXVXW%YnbI\�[lg�\�^Xb�_�b�^Xy�z~_]b�\�_]VnevzJ`�yp_%[�W%^ `8_%gus-[�`�YXYXW%b-`-c+dX[3\<ixb�W�`�c+dXg�[�s�g�^Xh4|�b-W][N[��~c�gu[3^I_c b�|4|�VX^Xgu_]g�[3\3t�j Vv_N`�y�\]b�_%bR_%[3\�_�guib-VXW�|4[(c+d `�^Xg�\]|�g�\�W]b-jXV \�_�`�h-`�g�^ \�_�g�^�s#`-\�g�b�^�`�^ e�tdX[�^ c�[�tX|4b-W][l\�_%`�j yu[-q

�T�Z�%�Z�X�Z�� ��a¡

¢(£�¤ 0(¥v"]$�.�¦�"+§¨$�0�O £�©nªI«<¬�­�®3¯ °�±³²³®3´}®?µN¶Z®m®]·-«]¸�¹3±³²³®3´I£{º &3»�/1¼ º 080(½�»+GI¾:"%6E¿a03$�½vG ¢mÀ(Á�Â-£Ã�£ �28.�ÄI0(28ÅQÆwÄI&m!#"+Ç�&�2�O�È�& .�.�/1"�É4&3"+» £ZÊ &3»�¥I&3Ä ËI�24&�'("+28.�ÌÍ&�$�½("%.�*I§p&3¼%":5�0�$<¥-,-Å�/12I'�&32IO

»�"%§p§1/12I'Í'3080�O-» £<Î 2�Ï ¸�®mÐ�«�«�Ñ3²�´�Ò3Ó�®?µ�±�ªI«lÔ�Ó�±aÕ�´I±Ö«]¸�´v¹�±³²x®3´v¹3¯�¶Z®�´mµm«]¸�«]´vÐ�«N®3´R±�ªI« Ï ¸?¹#Ð%±³²xÐ�¹(¯× ·#·v¯ ²³Ð�¹�±³²x®3´}®?µ<Õ�´I±Ö«%¯�¯ ²1Ò8«]´I± × Ò8«]´I±³Ó�¹3´�ÑNØ~°-¯ ±³²³¹mÒ8«]´I±:©X«�Ð�ª�´v®(¯1®�Ò3Ù�Ú Ï ×<× Ø�Û Ü#Ý]Þ G ¢+À(À(ß�£

D £�à "+2I28Å�áI0(2-"%$ £ ¿w"%2�.�&�Ëv�âÌ�,I§¨.�/¨ã�&�'("+28.mG-$�"%5�"%$�$�&�§¨ãÖ¥I&3»�"mO�ÌÍ&�.�¼�ÄIÌÍ&�½�/p2-'N»?Å�»?.�"+Ì £�Î 2RÏ ¸�®3äÐ�«�«�Ñ3²�´8Ò3ÓQ®?µÍ±�ª-«4Ô�Ó�±<Õ�´I±Ö«]¸�´v¹�±³²x®3´v¹3¯:¶Z®3´mµ+«]¸�«]´vÐ�«�®�´ × °�±å®3´�®3æl®3°�Ó × Ò8«]´I±³Ó Gk*�&�'("+»�D(F ¢]çD3F#è8G ¢mÀ3À è £

Â-£�¤ 0(Ä-/¨. Ê Ä�& $�"�&32IO��:O-&3Ì ¤ /¨5�½�/12 £�é "m&m!�/12-':&<6w"+¥�035�.�$�,-»?. £ê�®3¸]¯1Ñ4ê�²xÑ#«lê4«+ë G Ã�ì D#í]Ë è3è ç¢3¢ à G ¢mÀ3À è £

M £ È £aî .�"+!#"+2�É4& $�»�Ä £�ï�®3¸�æl¹3¯ ²�Ó�²�´�Ò�©I¸�°�Ó�±�¹�Ó4¹�¶Z®�æ:·�°�±å¹3±³²x®�´v¹(¯�¶Z®3´�Ð]«Ö·I±³£ ÈkÄIðñ.�ÄI"%»�/p»+Gð:"+*�& $�.�Ìl"+28.�035aÆw03Ìl*I,-.�/12-' î ¼%/p"%2I¼+"�&�2�O~É4& .�ÄI"+ÌÍ& .�/p¼%»+GIò<2I/1!#"%$�»�/¨.�ÅQ0�5 î .�/¨$�§1/p2-'-G��<*-$�/1§¢+À(À�Â-£

ß�£�à &�$�» ¤ &�»�Ì�,-»�»�0(2~&�2�O î !("%$�½#"%$<ó#&�2I»�0(2 £<î /1Ì�,-§p&�.�"mOQ»�08¼+/p&3§�¼+032�.�$�03§�5�0�$)»�"+¼%,-$�" Î 28.�"%$�2-"%.¼%0(ÌlÌl"%$�¼+" £�Î 24Ï ¸?®mÐ]«�«�Ñ3²�´8Ò3Ó�®?µ)±�ªI«�ê�®3¸�ô�Ó�ª�®]·�®3´4õ�«]öø÷X«�Ð%°�¸�²�±³Ù Ï ¹3¸?¹#Ñ3²pÒ3æ�Ó G ¢mÀ3À(ß�£

Page 12: A Social Mechanism of Reputation Management in Electronic

ù�ú�û{ü1ý�þÿ�����������ÿ�ÿ� ���#ÿ���ü��������� ú������(ÿ���-ÿ���ü����� ��!�"#aü��Nÿ�$1ÿ�% �����Iü�%&%�(ýlýlÿ��%+ÿ3ú('*),+.-/+.0#12�34�3�5�6�787:9<; + 5,= -/+ 6�; 0*> ;@? + ;A3�3 ),+ ;<?�BDC ù�EGF�H�I CKJ�L�M�C�J ù B�C�N�N�O ú

O úQP�ü�%,R���ÿ�$S��%,RIü�$�$��T�����U��ÿ �,�WV�!����vú&XYR��Z%����\[@��!] ��!�"#�I�^)ÿ���$1ü����W_�ü`�R\�-ÿ%+ÿ�a��ü����núcbd�e ) 6�5,3�3 f + ;@? 0 6#g -h1 38ij6 )�k�0#1 6�lnmQ3�5,3ol -/+ 6�;�prq ) =�9�f]=�;�f -/) 9 0�-s+ ;\tr?@3�; -*u 6�5 + 3 -/+ 3 0 = -*-h1 3ts9 - 6�;�6�7�6�9 0 tS?@3�; -/0�v 6�;�g�3 ) 3�;�5,3�B a����(ÿ�" NwJ�M�C�L�x�ByC�N�N�N ú

N úQ�<!�"����U��úA��R���aIü`���-ú<û R-ÿ8" �@%+ü���$S%���@ ����$z��{Züpý�avÿ���" ������$y ��!�"#mú 2 1 3cts7�3 )�+ 5,=�;n|<6�9 ) ;�=�46dg u 6�5 + 6�4�6�?�}�B�N F�EGFwH�I x�~ F M@xwJ�O�B�C�N�O ù�ú

C�L úc�aü��W�j!�������P�!��-ü������K����ú���ü�����RnúS�s��ý:!�$`�ü����(ÿ��@*��ÿ{�ÿ� �,��$D"#[�"#�ÿ%ý�{.���<ÿ��avÿ� �ü�"�ÿ�$��@%�����ü����nú<bd��� 6 )�k�+ ;<?&�c6 - 3 0 6#g -h1 3 tstst&� � 6 )�k�0#1 6,lT6�;:�,; - 34.4 + ?@3�; - �,;�g�6 ) 7�= -/+ 6�; u } 0,- 3�7 0 Ba����3ÿ�" x�xKM@x�N<BzC�N�N�N ú

C�C úc�aü����r! B PT��R����-ÿ��������Zÿ������� �,��ýZ��� B ������P�!��Iü�����������úS��ü�����Rnún�&��������a��ü��(ÿW" �@%+ü���$�-ÿd_j������{h����ü���{h����ýZ���ü����T��%%+ÿ�" "�IIû RIÿ�����ÿ�ü�%���$y�����Íÿ��avÿ��ü1ýlÿ��@,��$���ÿ" !�$`�"+ú tjlwl�4 + 3 fQt )��-/+ � 5 + =�4��,; - 34h4 + ?@3�;�5,3�B�~�L�L�L úwûy����a�avÿ��K�mú

C�~ úQ�:ü���������"&�A��%,R��K��ü�� B �&$1ÿ������������"�P���!�����" B ���������� �ü1ÿcPT�3ÿ"+úS�j��$�$��������,���ü��#ÿ���ÿ�a�!�,���ü����ýlÿ%�R����Iü�"�ý�"Zü���ÿ�$1ÿ�%� �����Iü�%)ýZ�K���#ÿ�a�$���%+ÿ�"+úDbd� e ) 6�5,3,3 f + ;<? 0 6#g -h1 3��s� v�u�u��o���:�U+ ; +h-/) =w5 k6�; > 4�3 5 -/) 6�; + 5 v 6�7:7Z3 ) 5,3W2A3 5 1 ;�6�4�6�?�}�BDC�N�N�N ú