Extraction Manufacturing DeliveryMining(ore(for(steel*Drilling(for(gas*Extracting(chemicals(paintz(plasticsz(inks*(Wood(for(for(labels

Making(steel*Producing(cylinder*Refining(gas*Produce(and(apply(paintz(plasticsz(label.

Shipping(materials(for(assembly*Shipping(product(materials(?paperz(plasticsz(inksCFuel(for(shipping*

EmbodiedAenergy

Electricityz(waterz(fossil(fuels(and(materials(required(for(extractionz(manufacturing(and(delivery*

*mFederalmlawmforbidsmtransportationmofmthismsizemofmcylindermNtypem39mDOTmcylinderMmifmitmhasmbeenmrefilled,mthereforemrefillingmismnotmpracticalmormrecommended.mInm2009monemmanufacturermamincludedmventingmkeymwithmcanistersmtomaidmrecycling.mUnfortunatelymthemprogrammwasmnotmacceptedmbymanymrecyclingmagenciesmandmdiscontinued.m

DisposableAGasAcanistersAorAwoodA?AAre(disposable(gas(canisters(a(viable(lowNimpact(alternative(to(wood(stoves(or(campfires?(

DISPOSABLEAGASACANISTERS

Extraction Manufacturing DeliveryMining(ore(for(steel*Extracting(chemicals(paintz(plasticsz(inks*(Wood(for(for(labelsz(shipping(boxesz(etc*

Making(steel*Producing(stove*

Shipping(materials(for(assembly*Shipping(product(materials(?paperz(plasticsz(inksCFuel(for(shipping*

EmbodiedAenergy

Electricityz(waterz(fossil(fuels(and(materials(required(for(extractionz(manufacturing(and(delivery*

Can(be(used(for(years*(If(it(becomes(unusable(the(materials(can(be(readily(recycled*

WoodASTOVESA

ONEATIMEAUSEOnce(used(canisters(must(be(disposed(of(as(hazardous(waste*(?No(manufacturer(recommends(refilling(and(recycling(is(not(widely(availableIC((

Extraction Manufacturing DeliveryNoneI NoneI NoneI

Campfires

CarbonAfootprintProduction(of(the(stove(requires(resources(but(has(a(much(longer(useful(life*(Wood(is(also(a(carbon(neutral(fuel(source*

EmbodiedAenergy

Sunlight(and(and(the(naturally(occurring(elements(of(photosynthesis*

CarbonAfootprintOne(use(canister(requires(significant(resources(and(creates(hazardouswastez(Burns(fossil(fuel*

lifetimeAUSEAlthough(campfires(emit(greenhouse(gasesthe(fuel(source(renders(them(carbonNneutral*((

CarbonAfootprintMore(fuel(required(than(a(wood(stove*(Over(many(campfires(the(impact(may(be(greater(than(using(a(wood(stove

*mNotmincludingmthemsourcemofmignitionmNMatches,mlighters,metc.Mm

CampfiresWoodASTOVESAGASACANISTERS

PRO

con

(N(Convenientz(easily(lit*(N(Alternative(where(fires(are(((((((not(allowed*(N(Lightweight*

(N(Lasting(product(uses(resources(more(sustainably*(N(Equal(to(canister(stoves(in(weight(when(fuel(is(factored(in*N(Efficient(use(of(fuel*

(N(No(carry(weight*(N(Provides(warmthz(cheer(and(light*

(N(Heavy(use(of(resources*(N(Burns(fossil(fuel*(N(Creates(hazardous(waste*(N(Cannot(be(recycled*

(N(Less(convenient(than(gas*(N(Problematic(in(wet(weather*(N(Smoke(and(soot*

(N(Less(convenient(than(gas*(N(Problematic(in(wet(weather*(N(Smoke(and(soot*(N(Heavier(site(impact(N(Less(efficient(use(of(fuel*

Best(sustainable(choice(for(most(camping(situations

ScoutmasterCG.comIDEAS, INFORMATION, AND INSPIRATION FOR SCOUT LEADERS

(N(Camping(skills(and(outdoorsmanship(N(Gear(reviews(and(advice(N(Practical(help(for(Scout(volunteers(

Listen to the weeklySCOUTMASTER

PODCAST

lifetimeAUSE