520
sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg Nay:an; can;da ERbsRmÜleday eTB em:gXan mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

Brother enemy

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg

Nay:an; can;da

ERbsRmÜleday eTB em:gXan

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

Page 2: Brother enemy

ÉksarbkERbTI5énmCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

Nay:an; can;da ³ sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg

ERbsRmÜlCaPasaExµreday eTB em:gXan BinitünigEksRmÜleday qaMg yu RkahViknigkMuBüÚrT½rkarIeday Kwm

suvNÑdanI rcnaRkb nig tYesovePAeday qaMg yu nig Kwm suvNÑdanI e)aHBum<pSayelIkTI1 enAqñaM2006

rkSasiT§i

Translation Series No.5 Documentation Center of Cambodia

Nayan Chanda: Brother Enemy, Cambodia and the Khmer Rouge RevolutionTranslated by Tep Meng Khean Edited by Youk Chhang Graphic by Kim Sovanndany Cover and

Book design by Youk Chhang and Kim Sovanndany Printed in Cambodia, 2007 Copyright

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

Searching for the truth.Documentation Center of CambodiaP.O. Box 1110, Phnom Penh, CambodiaTel.: + 855 (23) 211-875Fax.: + 855 (23) 210-358Email: [email protected]: www.dccam.org

DISCLAMER

The views expressed in this paper are solely those of the author.

TsSn³beBa©jenAkñúgesovePAenH KWrbs;GñkniBn§Etmñak;Kt;.

ISBN-10: 99950-6-08-6

lsxG-10³ 99950-6-08-6

ISBN-13: 978-99950-60-08-4

lsxG-13³ 978-99950-60-08-4

Printed in Cambodia

Page 3: Brother enemy

cMeBaH«Bukrbs;´ EdlCaedImehtunaM[´sresresovePAenH

nigcMeBaH hSItg;hSalI EdleFVI[esovePAenHGacecjpSay)an.

Page 4: Brother enemy
Page 5: Brother enemy

esckþIEføgGMNrKuN

tameyabl;rbs;elak E.H.Carr fa n½yrYmKWRtÚvBinitüemIlRbvtþisaRsþTukdUcCacegáammYyén

RBwtþikarN_TaMgLayEdlRtÚvemIlbBa¢ak;[dwgxusRtÚvEmnb¤minEmn ³ «RBwtþikarN_TaMgLay Edlbgðaj

[RbvtþiviTUdwg-ÉksarepSg² silacarwk.l. KWdUcCaRtIenAelItuGñklk;RtIG‘Ícwg. RbvtþiviTUeRCIs

erIsvaehIynaMmkpÞH erobcMeFVImðÚb nigpSMeRKÓgeRKARtITaMgenaHeTAtamlMnaMrbs;va». elak Carr )an

CMTas;RbkbedayvicarNBaØaNcMeBaHmUlkPaB ¬PaBsmehtusmpl¦ éneyabl;enH. dUecñH etIGVI

eTACaRBwtþikarN_CaRbvtþisaRsþmYy?. tamkarBit RBwtþikarN_CaRbvtþisaRsþmYyBuMRtÚvcat;Tukfa

vaminERbRbÜlenaHeT BIeRBaHRbvtþiviTU)anvinicä½yBIerOgenaHdUecñH. dUcCa«s®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTIbI»

bBaðaKWmanlkçN³xusKñatictYc b:uEnþ enAmanlkçN³CasarvnþdEdl. lkçN³Bi)aksMxan;bMputBuMEmn

sßitenARtg;critEdlERbRbÜleTAtamTmøab;énCnmñak;kñúgkareRCIserIsRBwtþikarN_mYykñúgcMeNamPaB

sm,ÚrhYsehtuénRBwtþikarN_epSg²eLIy tamFmµtaB½t’manTaMgLaykRmrk)anNas;. bNþardæaPi)al

rbs;cin evotNam nigkm<úCa yl;RBm[pSBVpSayCasaFarN³EtÉksarepSg²EdlRsal;eRCIs

edayp©itp©g; ehIyEdlGacbeRmIbuBVehturbs;eKb:ueNÑaH. vaCakar\tRbeyaCn_EdlsgÇwmfa rdæa

Pi)alTaMgenaHebIkbNÑsardæanrbs;xøÜn[RbvtþiviTUÉkraCücUlRsavRCav.

´cab;epþImsresrGVIEdlmankarTak;TgdMbUgGMBIs®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTIbIenH EdlminTan;RKb;sBV

edaysarEt\T§iBlénRBwtþikarN_epSg² CamYynwgkardwgB¤edayeBjeljBIRBMEdnTaMgenaH. ´RbEhl

CaGñkcUleTAekokbMputnwgRBwtþikarN_sMxan; edIm,IRbemIlemIlehtukarN_TaMgLayRbkbedaylkçN³

RsbtamPaBBitEdlRtÚvEtmanCacaM)ac; b:uEnþ´man¬sRmab;eRbIR)as;¦nUvGVIEdlGac[RbeyaCn_d¾

Cak;lak;mYyelIbNþaRbvtþiviTUCMnan;eRkay. kñúgGMLúgeBldb;R)aMqñaM ´KWCasakSIEdl)aneXIjnwgEPñk

nUvQutqakxøH²énesaknadkmµ. mü:ageTot ´)anCYbsnÞnaCamYy«tYÉk»sMxan;²RBmTaMgGñksegát

karN_breTsy:ageRcInGMBICemøaHenA\NÐÚcinpg. sMNagd¾FMrbs;´KW´manlT§PaBcUldl;RbPB

B½t’manepSg²edayKµan]bsKÁ. dUecñH ´GacRbmaNdwgmunGMBIkarKn;KUrEdlTTYlsarPaB minekIt/

l,icklsm¶at;epSg² EdlnwgkøayeTACaedImehtudMbUgénkardutbeBaäH[manCemøaH. vaeFVI[mansgÇwm

eLIgvijEdlsegáteXIjfa kñúgkarRbyuT§ts‘Ud¾nnHnenol ehIyhak;dUcCaKµankarsRmbsRmÜl

EdlnaM[Cab;édrvagbNþa«mitþ»BIyUrmkehIy nigGñkTTYlxusRtÚvxøHTaMgevotNam k¾dUccinb¤km<úCa

kalebIman»kasGaceFVIkarsnÞnaCaÉkCn edIm,IsEmþgBIkarminTukcitþxøH²sþIBImUlkPaB ¬PaBsm

Page 6: Brother enemy

ehtupl¦ énCMhrrbs;RbeTseKerog²xøÜn EfmTaMgcab;epþImeFVIkarriHKn;xøÜnÉgmYypg. esovePAenH

CMBak;KuNy:agsem,ImcMeBaHGñkTTYlxusRtÚvGnamikTaMgenaH EdlminrYjranwgrMElk[´nUvB½t’manepSg²

Edlpþl;RbeyaCn_y:agxøaMgcMeBaHrdæaPi)alrbs;xøÜn. ´sUmsEmþgnUvkardwgRBHKuN edayELk

cMeBaHsemþcRBH neratþm sIhnu EdlmanbnÞÚlerobrab;R)ab;´d¾EvgGnøaysþIBICIvitrbs;RBHGgÁEdl

cEmøkxusKñaRKb;cMNucTaMgGs;. \sSrCnCaeRcInrUb Edl´bgðajkñúgesovePAenH minsMéceBlevla

rbs;Kat;sRmab;´eT ehIy)anrYmviPaKTantictYckñúgkarbgðajpøÚvdl;karRsavRCavrbs;´eday

rebobepSg². enAeBlenH ´sUmsEmþgnUvkardwgKuNCaBnøwk.

elak est lIbsÁI nigelak vIløIyuaM sðavRkÚs KWCaGñkepþImKMnit[sresresovePAenHmuneK.

GñkTaMgBIr)anCMruj[´cab;epþImeFVIkarniBn§esovePAenHeLIg. niBn§naykrbs;´ elak dWerk edvIs

)anelIkTwkcitþ´ edayyl;RBmpþl;[´nUvkarQb;sRmakCabeNþaHGasnñmYycMnYnR)aMmYyEx edIm,I

ebIk»kas[´bMeBjkic©karRsavRCavrbs;´. ´k¾CMBak;KuNcMeBaH Research School of Pacific Studies

¬énsaklviTüal½yCatienAGURsþalI¦pgEdr ehIyCaBiesscMeBaHelak edvId m:ar Edlyl;RBmpþl;

[´nUvGaharUbkrN_sRmab;karRsavRCavmYy ebIKµanGaharUbkrN_enHeT cMENkCaRbvtþisaRsþ

d¾Cak;lak;énkic©karenHnwgBuMGacnaMeTAdl;TIbBa©b;)aneLIy.

mitþPkþinigshesviky:ageRcIn/ GñkÉkeTsxagbBaðaGasuIPaKGaeKñy_nigGñkkarTUt)anGan

sgáat;GtßbTsresrédrbs;´xøH² ehIy)ancarmk´vijnUvesckþIGFib,aynigmtiENnaMd¾mantémø

epSg². vaTMngfa KµanGñkNamñak;kñúgcMeNamGñkTaMgenaHnwgyl;RsbCamYynwgesckþIsnñidæanTaMgmUl

rbs;esovePAenHeLIy ehIy´nwgmineTIsTal;kñúgkarerobrab;eQµaHGñkTaMgenaHedayeBjelj

Edr.

Page 7: Brother enemy

´sUmsEmþgktBaØútacMeBaHelak

Graham Aliband, Desaix Anderson, Alain et Michèle Archambault, Jan Austin, DorothyAvery, Jacques Beaumont, Elizabeth Becker, Stanley Bedlington, Madhu Bhaduri, Chanthou Boua,Mohammed Bouabid, Lyall Breckon, Terry Breese, Richard Breeze, Fred Brown, RaymondBurghardt, James Burnet, Timothy Carney, David Chandler, Parris Chang, Helen Chauncey,Michael Chinoy, Kraisak Choonhavan, Evelyn Colbert, Shyamala Cowsik, Maryse Daviet, Patriceet Brigitte de Beer, Philippe Devillers, Neelam Dhamija, Nguyen Huu Dong, Michael Eiland,David Elliott, Donald Emmerson, Harold Evans, Philippe Franchini, John Girling, BanningGarrett, Jim Gerrand, Tushar et Rajeshwari Ghose, William Gleysteen, Donald Gregg, WangGungwu, Sandor Gyori, Harry Harding, Lilian Harris, Barbara Harvey, David Hawk, BobHawkins, Hollis Hebbel, Stephen Heder, Bill et Peggy Herod, Murray et Linda Hiebert, RichardHorne, Mario Iseppi, Raphael Iungerich, Stephen Johnson, Paul et Sophie Quinn-Judge, JérômeKanapa, Stanley Karnow, Kasem Kasemiri, Henry Kenny, Donald Keyser, Ben Kiernan, AllenKitchens, Tommy Koh, Gabriel Kolko, Charles Lahiguera, Dennison Lane, James Lilley, MichaelLombardo, Michel Lummoux, Steve Lyne, John MacAuliff, Jamie Mackie, A. Madhavan, KishoreMahbubani, Abdul Majid, Robert Manning, Glenn May, John McBeth, George McQuillen,Charles Meyer, Atsuo Miyake, John Mohanco, Don Oberdorfer, Jean-Christophe Oberg, BillO’Malley, Roland-Pierre Paringaux, Arun Phanupong, Douglas Pike, Jonathan Pollack, GarethPorter, Mark Pratt, Kailash Puri, Ken Quinn, Dragoslav Rancic, Sean Randolph, K.Ranganathan, David Reese, Philippe Richer, Robert Ross, Daniel Roussel, Malcolm Salmon,Kernial Sandhu, Renji Sathiah, Turid Sato, Jean Sauvageot, Tonia Shand, Robert Shaplen, FrankSieverts, Amarjit et Bhagwant Singh, Pami Singh, Richard Solomon, Daniel Southerland, Simonet Elise Spivak, Michel Strulovici, Roger Sullivan, Robert Sutter, Frank Tatu, CarlyleThayer,Jerry Tinker, William Turley, Lorenzo et Adriana de Vignal, Sarasin Viraphol, Jusuf Wanandi,Steve Wasserman, William Wilmott, Joseph Winder, William Wise, Leonard Woodcock, MariaZammit.

´exøacpSakñúgcitþcMeBaHmrNPaBd¾KYr[QWcab;rbs;elak ednhSúIl éPrIs/ R)aev:s kumar nig s>

sIuv:ar:am:aRKIsñan; Edl)anCYyeRCamERCg´y:agxøaMg b:uEnþ Kat;ElgmanCIvitedIm,I)aneXIjEpøpáaénkar

elIkTwkcitþrbs;Kat;eTotehIy.

´CMBak;KuNy:ageRcIncMeBaHelak lIn eNsb‘Ít Edl)anCYyTMnukbRmúgy:agsb,úrs edIm,I[

)anseRmckñúgkare)aHBum<pSayesovePAenH nigcMeBaHGñkTTYle)aHBum<pSayrbs;́ m:arIGa r:aNa v:ard_

Edl)anENnaM´edayGMNt;cb;cugcb;edImkñúgdMeNIrbBa©b;esovePAsresredayédd¾Bi)ak. BitNas;

esovePAenHnwgminRtÚv)ansresreLIy ebIKµanelak GamIt nig elak Getsð EdlRtÚv)at;bg;«Buk

rbs;xøÜnkñúgry³eBlmYyyUrlg;mkehIy.

Page 8: Brother enemy

Rbvtþirbs;GñkniBn§

elak Nay:an; can;da (Nayan Chanda) ekItkñúgqñaM1946 enARbeTs\NÐa. bnÞab;BI)ansikSa

muxviC¢aRbvtþisaRsþenATIRkúgkal;Kutþa (Calcutta) nigTIRkúg):arIsrYcmk enAqñaM1974 Kat;)ankøayeTA

CaGñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manrbs;TsSnavdþI «esdækic©cugbUB’a» (Far Eastern Economic Review) sRmab;\NÐÚcin

nig)antaMgsñak;karenATIRkúgéRBnKrbc©úb,nñKWRkúghUCImij. GtßbTepSg²rbs;elakRtÚv)ancuHpSay

kñúgsarB½t’manFM²rbs;BiPBelakdUcCakaEstjÚvy:kEfm (New York Times), kaEstv:asuInetanb:usþ×

(Washington Post), kaEstLWm:ug (Le Monde) nig LWm:ug DIbøÚm:aTik (Le Monde Diplomatique) CaedIm.

taMgBIqñaM1984 elak Nay:an; can;da )andwknaMkariyal½ycat;karrbs;TsSnavdþI «esdækic©

cugbUB’a» RbcaMenARkúgv:asuInetan.

Page 9: Brother enemy

matika

esckþIEføgGMNrKuN

Rbvtþirbs;GñkniBn§

bNþabuKÁlEdmantYnaTIsMxan;²kñúgesovePAenH

esckþIepþIm ³ vaMgngFøak;cuH>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>1

1> PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>9

- semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu ³ em:agénC½yCmñH>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>43

2> dgáÚvnag nig kNþúr >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>53

3> mnusSEdleKminsÁal;mñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>83

- semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu ³ cakecjBIqakneya)ay >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>117

4> karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>123

5> CMenarxül;BITisxaglic >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>155

6> xül;xagekItmaneRbóbCag>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>193

7> PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>217

- semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu ³ kñúgKukExµrRkhm >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>257

8> karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>263

9 > Yankee RtLb;mkvij >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>303

- semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu ³ rYcputBIeRKaHfñak; >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>340

10> NUEGlRkhm >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>349

11> \NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansnþiPaB >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>403

Gvsankfa>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>453

kalb,vtþisMxan;²>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>457

RbPBÉksarsMGag >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>462

Page 10: Brother enemy

bNþabuKÁlEdlmantYnaTIsMxan;²kñúgesovePAenH

b‘ÍkjÚ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI TIRbwkSasnþisuxCatirbs;elakRbFanaFibtI hSImI xaF½r ¬RbFanaFibtIshrdæ

Gaemrik 1977-1981¦

etg s‘avBIg GnuRbFanbkSkumµúynIsþcin

han nanLúg Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTscin

ehg sMrin RbFanRkúmRbwkSardæénsaFarNrdæRbCamanitkm<úCa

v:ag Tug niBn§naykkaEstjinhSinrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam

rIqad hUlRb‘Úk Gnurdæm®nþIRksYgkarbreTsGaemrikTTYlbnÞúkkic©karGasuIxagekIt nig ):asuIhVik

hVa KUehVg RbFanbkSkumµúynIsþcin

hYg hY rdæm®nþIkarbreTscin

eGog sarI ]bnaykrdæm®nþI nigCardæm®nþIkarbreTsénrdæaPi)alkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

exov sMpn RbFanKN³RbFanrdæénkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

eRKógsak; qUm:aNnþ naykrdæm®nþIéf

lI s‘annan ]bnaykrdæm®nþIcin

eL yn; GKÁelxabkSkumµúynIsþevotNam

eL DwkfU smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam

eL faj;gI RbFanKN³kmµkarEpnkarrbs;evotNam

egVón kUfac; rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam

pan; ehon Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam

paM v:an;dug naykrdæm®nþIevotNam

b:ul Bt GKÁelxabkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa

neratþm sIhnu GtItRBHRbmuxrdækm<úCa

esa Pwm elxabkSPUmiPaKbUBa’énkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

sUpanuvgS RbFanaFibtIénsaFarNrdæRbCamanitRbCaFibetyüLav

suIrus v:an;s_ rdæm®nþIkarbreTsGaemrikaMg

v: egVógy:ab rdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTsevotNam

eLGUNard_ vUdxUk ÉkGKÁrdæTUtGaemrikaMgRbcaMRbeTscin

Page 11: Brother enemy

esckþIepþImvaMgnnFøak;cuH

RbEhlenHCaeCaKvasnaényb;éf¶TI29 Exemsa qñaM1975ehIy EdlPaBGn§kar)anRKb

dNþb;mkelIRkúgéRBnKrTaMgmUl. enAem:ag6nig30naTIyb; GKÁisnIRtÚvdac;ehIy)anBnøicGVI²eTAkñúg

PaBggwtsUnüsugTaMgGs; hak;dUcCaCYybiT)aMgPaBGam:as; nigbraC½yrbs;TIRkúgenHG‘Ícwg. BIelI

dMbUlrabesµIénsNæaKar «kar:aEv:l» eRkamePøógrlwmRsic²RtCak;eRsg ´QrKyKn;TIRkúgéRBnKr

EdlenAKg;vgSnaraRtIcugeRkayenH. ]T§mÖaKcRkFM²rbs;GaemrikaMg EdlbeBa©jsMeLglan;RThwg

KYr[RBWxøac )anehaHsMkaMgelIGakasmYyry³xøI munnwgbnÞabxøÜncuHelId¿bUlGKarnanarbs;TIRkúg edIm,I

naMykGaemrikaMgcugeRkaynigshkarICatievotNammYycMnYneq<aHeTAkan;navaFM²énkgnavacrTI7

rbs;shrdæGaemrik Edle)aHyufáaenAkNþalsmuRTcinPaKxagt,Úg. BIrbInaTIeRkaymkynþehaH

TaMgenH)ane)aHBYyeTAkñúglMhemXkb;)at;kñúgBBkq¶ayeTA² edaybnSl;sMeLgB¤xÞ½rrNþMeBjépÞ

GakaseTAkñúgeBlyb;d¾eRkómRkMenH.

enAxageRkam TIRkúgEdllic)at;kñúgPaBggwtcak;EPñkminyl; nigs¶at;sUnüQwg ehIyEdleK

RbsiT§namfa «RKab;KC;bUBa’Tis » b:uEnþeKk¾ehA «éRBnKrTIRkúgRsIeBsüa »EdrenaH enAkMBugTnÞwgrg;caMGñk

EdlvayQñHrbs;xøÜn. GKarx<s;²)anelcrUbrageLIgCaRsemalsÞúg² enAÉnayeCIgemX BnøW)an

caMgPøWrnÞaledaysarkarpÞúHénRKab;ru:EkátnigBnøWciBa©acénkareqHXøaMgpÞúkRKab;rMesvenAcMNtGakasyan

tan; sWnjúwk. mhavifIeLLy nigvifITuydU manBnøWCHbMPøWmYyEPøt²EdredaysarePøIghVarénrfynþ

rbs;nayTahannigGñkman²evotNam rYmCamYyRkúmRKÜsarkMBugebIky:agelOndUcBüúHsMedAeTA

kan;kaNUtCaeRcIneRKÓgEdlkMBugrg;caM tammat;TenøénRkúgéRBnKr. TidæPaBTaMgenHKWCakarERbRbÜl

cugeRkaybMputénPaBekalahlmYy EdlRKbmkelIPaKxagt,Úg cab;taMgBIkardYlrlMeTAénTIRkúgev:

nigdaNag kalBIExmInaknøgmk.

karrt;eKcxøÜny:agsøn;esøaecjBImuxpÞaMgrlkkumµúynIsþ)anmkeTIrRtwmrbgcRmwgEdkrbs;sßanTUt

GaemrikaMg. enATIenaH naeBlk,alRBlb; ´GacemIleXIjCnCatievotNamrab;rynak;eLIg Rbyit

RbetagrbgEdkedayRKvIbgðajRkdassñamepSg² ¬GtþsBaØaNb½NÑ lixitbBa¢ak; nig)ac;R)ak;duløar¦

GgVrsuMcUlkñúgbrievNsßanTUtedIm,IeLIgeTAxagelICiH]T§mÖaKcRkEdlsMctenAelId¿bUlrabénGKarenaH.

eBjry³eBlmYyéf¶ GñkTaMgenH)anvaydMTajk®nþak;TVarcRmwgEdk EdlbiTcak;edayesaRtedak nig

1

Page 12: Brother enemy

yamkarBaredayRkúmTahanm:arInGaemrikaMgmanGavuFRKb;éd. enAeBlenHkarxUcTwkcitþ)anraldal

xøaMgeLIg². GñkÉeTot²Edlmanrab;rynak;enaH)aneTARbmUlpþú¿enAkñúgRbeLaHCeNþIrénGKarepSg²

EdlbRmúgTuksRmab;kar[ecjd¿eNIrbnþeTAeTot b:uEnþ eBjmYyraRtIesckþIsgÇwm)anrlt;bnþicmþg²

dUcCaePøIgeTonEdleqHexSayeTA²rhUtrlt;Pøwb.

vamankal³eTs³CaeRcIn EdlRbvtþisa®sþERbeTACamandMeNIrkan;EtelOny:agKMhuk ehIy

enHKWCakal³eTs³mYykñúgcMeNamkal³eTs³TaMgenaH. karedaHRsaybBa©b;bBaða)anvivtþeTAmuxy:ag

elOnTb;minQñH. enAéf¶TI10 ExmIna kalebIkgT½BevotNamxageCIg EdldwknaMbBa¢aeday]tþmesnIy_

v:an; eTogyug vayRbhareTAelI)anemFYt kñúgtMbn;sm,ÚrPñMPaKkNþalKWrbbrbs; egVón v:an;FIv

TaMgmUlEdlj½rxøacenAtammUldæannanarbs;xøÜn. kñúgkarvayRbharCafµId¾Gg;GackøahanGs©arü

rbs;kumµúynIsþenH kRmmanGñksmÁal;eXIjGVIEdlRtÚvEteXIj «karcab;epþIménTIbBa©b; »Nas; bnÞab;

BIkgT½BevotNamxageCIgvaydeNþIm)anextþPYkLúgenAExmkra. enAcMeBaHkarbbYlc,aMgKñafµIenH FIv

)anpøas;bþÚrviFIsa®sþrbs;Kat;TaMgRsug ³ ElgvayRbyuT§edIm,IdImYycMGam²eTotehIy. Kat;)an

bBa¢a[dkfytamk,ÜnyuT§sa®sþBIebøKU nig kn;Tum enAtMbn;x<g;rab nig[kgÉkPaBd¾eqñImmYycakecj

BITIRkúgev:. lT§plKWkar)ak;EbkTaMgpÞaMgdUcTwkFøayTMnb;. kgT½BevotNamxagt,Úg)anEbkExJkKña

r):at;r):aykñúgsPaBRcbUkRcbl;TaMgRsug. EtkñúgcenøaHbIs)aþh_ TIRkúgev:/ daNag/ j:aRtag nigPaK

xagt,ÚgTaMgmUl)andYlrlMdUcvimansagsg;BIsnøwkebomYydUecñaHEdr.

enAedImExemsa qñaM1975 rgVg;hu‘mB½T§)anrYmtUcmkenACu¿vijTIRkúgéRBnKr. GaemrikaMg)anbgçM

el,ÓnkñúgkarpÁt;pÁg;eRKÓgsa®sþavuFtampøÚvGakasRBmeBlKñanwgkarCemøós buKÁlik nigmitþPkþiCati

evotNamrbs;xøÜnecjeTAeRkAEdr. karvayRbyuT§deNþImRkúgéRBnKr)ancab;epþImenAéf¶bnÞab;BIkar

rt;ePosxøÜnrbs;RbFanaFibtI egVóg v:an;FIv tamynþehaHC.118mYyeRKÓgénkgGakascrN_GaemrikaMg.

enAeBlRBwkRBhaméf¶TI27 Exemsa qñaM1975 ´RtÚvdas;[PJak;BId¿eNkTaMgP½yj½redImRTÚg eday

sarkarpÞúHénRKab;r: uEkátTImYyrbs;RkúmkumµúynIsþEdl)aj;mkelITIRkúgéRBnKr Føak;cMsNæaKar

m:aehSsÞikEk,rkEnøg´sñak;enA. enAéf¶TI28 Exemsa GñkebIkynþehaHevotNammñak; ¬tamBitCa

Pñak;garkumµúynIsþ¦ EdlkalBImunFøab;manekrþ×eQµaHl,Il,ajedaysar)anTmøak;RKab;EbkeTAelI

vimanRbFanaFibtIenaH )anRtLb;mkvayRbharelImUldæaneCIgGakas tan; sWnjwúk vij. karqµk;

vaybgðinbegðacenHbUkbEnßmnwgkarepøagRKab;ru:EkátnigRKab;kaMePøIgFMEdlB¤kan;EtCiteLIg²enaH enA

TIbMput RtÚv)anrMBwgfas<anGakasmYy nwgRtÚverobcM[d¿eNIrkaredayGaemrikaMgminxan.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg2

Page 13: Brother enemy

Rbtibtþikar Frequent Wind rbs;kgm:arInGaemrikenAeBlresoléf¶TI29 Exemsa edIm,ICemøós

mnusSecjtam]T§mÖaKcRkGaemrikaMg nigevotNam)anRtÚvkat;pþac;enARBwkéf¶TI30 Exemsa. BIelI

d¿bUlsNæaKarkar:aEvl eKGacemIleXIjrfeRkaHevotNamxageCIgkMBugrulmkmuxrebobCaCYrdUchVÚg

RsemacedIrtampøÚvCatielx1EdlP¢ab;TIRkúgebonv:a mkTIRkúgéRBnKr. ´)ankEnøgRsYlGgÁúyemIl

edaymin)aMgEPñk enAeBlEdl]T§mÖaKcRkdac;BIeKÉgmYy)anelceFøaeLIgBIépÞemXBN’RbepH ehaH

mkbnÞabxøÜncuHelIdMbUlrabesµIénsßanTUtGaemrikaMg. b:unµannaTIeRkaymk ynþehaH)andwkykTahan

m:arIncugeRkayEdlenAyamkarBarsßanTUtecjeTA)at;. edaybt;y:agKMhuk edIm,IecosBIbegÁal

b:mb:usþiéRbsNIy_ ]T§mÖaKcRk)anykkm<s;Rtg;eLIgeTAelIehaHBIelITenøhUrkat;TIRkúgéRBnKr ehIy

rlay)at;BIeRkayeCIgemXxagekIt. eBlenaHKW em:ag7nig35naTIRBwk. émÖmYyqñaMbnÞab;BIkarmk

dl;TIRkúgéRBnKrrbs;vresnIy_eTaes>GuI>Ga>mñak; eQµaH eGdvWd eLndal EdlmkRtÜtBinitüemIlkar

hat;hVwkhVWnrbs;kgT½BmYyenAsaFarNrdæevotNamxagt,Úg EdlTTYlbnÞúkCaBiesskñúgkarvay

RbyuT§RbqaMgnwgkumµúynIsþenaH vaMgnn)anFøak;cuH RKbmkelIkarpSgeRBgrbs;GaemrikaMgenA\NÐÚcin

Edr.

bYnem:ageRkaymk enAkñúgkariyal½yd¾s¶at;RCg¿mYyénTIPñak;garB½t’manr:yT½r EdlenATl;mux

vimanRbFanaFibtI ´enAGgÁúyvaylixitTUrelxmYyTaMgRCÜlRcbl;kñúgcitþ edayerobrab;BIkarelceFøa

eLIgénTg;C½yrbs;kumµúynIsþenAtamCayRkúgCu¿vijTIRkúgéRBnKr. rMeBcenaH´)anB¤sUrsMeLgeraT×

eg:ag²énm:asuIn nigRcvak;kg;rfeRkaHmYyeRKÓgEdlmanedatTg;C½yevotkug BN’exov Rkhm nigTwk

mas kMBugebIkrulmkmuxeq<aHeTAkan;vimanRbFanaFibtI. ´Rsvacab;ykm:asuInftrUb ehIysÞúHrt;ecj

BIkariyal½yqøgkat;tamsYnc,ar EdlxNÐEckkariyal½yrbs; r:yT½r nigvimanRbFanaFibtI enAeBl

EdlrfeRkaH)an)aj;kaMePøIgmYyRKab;kemÞccRmwgTVarEdk ehIyebIkcUleTAkñúgsYn]Tüanrbs;viman.

TahanCaeRcInnak;elatcuHBIrfeRkaH ehIyrt;tamCeNþIreLIgeTAelI. enATIbBa©b; BYkenaH)anbgðÚtTg;C½y

evotkugeLIgeTAelIGakas. TahanTaMgenaH )anmkdl;cugbMputénpøÚvlMhUCImijehIy ehIys®gÁam

RtÚvbBa©b;RtwmenH.

RtÚveFVI[Pan;PaMgedayPaBelOnrh½sénRBwtþikarN_epSg² ´esÞIrEtmineCOfa s®gÁamenARbeTs

evotNamCas®gÁammYyEdl´Føab;Kitfa vanwgrIkFM EbrCaRtÚvcb;Pøam²G‘ÍcwgesaH. kalBImYyqñaMmun

enAeBlEdl´sñak;enATIRkúgéRBnKrkñúgzan³CaGñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manrbs;TsSnavdþI«esdækic©cugbUBa’»

RbcaM\NÐÚcin ´dwgR)akdfa kic©RBmeRBógsnþiPaBRkúg):arIs EdlerobcMeday elak hg;rI KIsSúIghÁ½r

vaMgnnFøak;cuH 3

Page 14: Brother enemy

nig eL DwkfU smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam tamkarBitRtÚveKbMePøcecal

eTAehIy. eKElgGacniyayBIkarrMelaPbTQb;)aj;KñaeTotehIy b:uEnþRbtibtþikareyaFaEdlman

kRmitRBMEdnenAEtman. pÞúyeTAvij KµannrNamñak; rYmTaMgGñkyuT§sa®sþRkúghaNUypg BuM)an

RbmaNTukCamunBIkar)ak;T½Br):at;r):aydUecñHeLIy. b:uEnþ enABak;kNþalExemsa vaERbeTACaCak;

c,as;Nas;fa eKxiteTACitrbt;naMeTArklT§plcugeRkaymYyehIy. tamkar[dMbUnµanEdletOnbgçM

énkariyal½yniBn§rbs;́ enATIRkúghugkug ´)anbBa©úHbBa©Úl[Priyarbs;́ cakecjBITIRkúgéRBnKr b:uEnþ

xøÜn´pÞal;bdiesFmincakecjeTkñúgeBlEdlKat;[eyabl;´BIerOgenH. niBn§naykrbs;´)an

sresrsMbuRtmk´fa ³ «GtßbTmYymantémøminesµInwgGayuCIvitrbs;elakeT sUmelakcakecj

RbesIrCagRbfuyeRKaHfñak; ». kareqøIytbrbs;´ EdlbBa¢ÚneTAhugkugenAéf¶TI25 Exemsa ´)an

R)ab;[dwgfa ´KµanKeRmagcakecj«munTIbBa©b;énRBwtþikarN_GaRkk; »eLIy. R)aMéf¶eRkaymkGVI²

)anmkdl;TIbBa©b;Emn.

´eXIjmitþPkþievotNamrbs;́ y:ageRcIncakecjTaMgTwkmuxRsgUtRsgat;. ´eXIjRKÜsarCaeRcIn

RBat;R)asKña enAeBleFVIdMeNIrcakecalRsukTaMghVÚgTaMghVayd¾KYr[exøaccitþ. ´eXIjPaBsøútsøn;

rbs;CnePosxøÜnrab;Ban;nak; CaGñkrs;enAtamtMbn;eqñrsmuRTPaKkNþal Edlrt;eKcecjBIrlk

kumµúynIsþ )anmkCab;GnÞak;CafµIenATIRkúgéRBnKrvij. karEckxNÐd¾yUrrvagPaKxageCIgnigPaKxagt,Úg

)anbBa©b;y:agcEmøk. eKeXIjGñkTIRkúgéRBnKrRbjab;Rbjal;eTAeramCuMvijrfeRkaH T-54 rbs;kgT½B

evotNamxageCIg ehIysakl,gepþImeFVIkarsnÞnaCamYyGñkmkBIPaKxageCIg Edlmanv½yekµg² min

sUvniyaysþI nigesøókÉksNæanBN’ébtg. mñak;²manGakar³RBÜy)armÖCaxøaMgcMeBaHéf¶GnaKt

b:uEnþ CamYykareFVI[mansnþiPaBdUcedImeLIgvij enATIbMput GVI²TaMgGs;nwgRtLb;eTArkreboberobry

vijedayxøÜnÉg.

CMenOTukcitþxøaMgenH BuMmanenARbeTskm<úCaCitxag Edls®gÁam)anbBa©b;munenH13éf¶eT. kñúg

»kasénd¿eNIrcugeRkayrbs;´eTARkúgPñMeBjenAExmkra qñaM1975 muxdgáab;rbs;kgT½BExµrRkhm

)anrYmrwtmkelIrdæFanICafµI. sMeLgpÞúHénRKab;ru:Ekát)aneFVI[TIRkúgmYyEdlENnNan;eTAedayCn

ePosxøÜnBIs®gÁamCit2lannak;P½yrn§t;jab;j½rElgeFVIGVIekIt. ExµrRkhm)anraMgxÞb;pøÚvCatisMxan;²

EdlEbkecjBITIRkúgTaMgGs; ehIyTenøemKgÁ)ankøayeTACapøÚvTak;TgEtmYyKt;CamYyBiPBxag

eRkA. karsakl,gTaMgGs;sgÇwmrbs;GaemrikaMgedIm,IbegáIts<anGakasmYysRmab;dwkes,óg nig

eRbg\n§n³mk[rbb ln; nl; min)anseRmcdUckareRKagKiteLIy eRkayeBlEdlGakasyandæan

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg4

Page 15: Brother enemy

eBaFicintugTTYlrgRKab;kaMePøIgFMrbs;bc©amitþEdlFøak;eRsacdUcTwkePøóg. RbFanaFibtI ln; nl; Edl

RsyutRsyg;citþ)ancakecjBIRbeTsenAéf¶TI1 Exemsa qñaM1975 ehIybuKÁlikénsßanTUtGaemrikaMg

k¾)anecjbnþCaeRkay KWéf¶TI12 Exemsa qñaM1975. éf¶TI17 Exemsa qñaM1975 ExµrRkhm

)ansRmúkcUlmkdl;rdæFanIGavuFP¢g;eTAmuxedaybeNþjRbCaCnTaMgGs;ecjBITIRkúg. BIrs)aþh_

eRkaymkCnbreTsEdlrt;eTARCkekanenAsßanTUt)araMg)aneLIgCiHRbeRCótKñaelIrfynþkaMmIj:úg

CaeRcIneRKÓg ehIycakecjeq<aHeTARbeTséf. mYyrMeBcenaHElgmanRbeTskm<úCaeTotehIy

dUccMNucmYyEdleXIjkan;EttUceTA²enAÉeCIgemXTIbMputk¾rlay)at;sUnü.

s®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTIBIresÞIrEtminTan;cb;RsYlbYlpg s®gÁamTIbIk¾RbúgnwgekItmankñúgeBl

qab;²Edr mþgenHKWs®gÁamrvagbgb¥Únnigbgb¥Ún rvagsmmitþnigsmmitþ. sRtÚvCacRkBtþieTIbnwgecj

putBIqak cab;BIeBlenHeTA karRbkYtKña karminTukcitþKña Edlmanrab;stvtSr_mkehIyenaH )anelc

eLIgCafµI. plRbeyaCn_Cati)ankøayeTACaGavuFmYyRKvIeLIgRbqaMgnwgsmmitþfµI²enHmþgeTot.

b:uEnþ CemøaHEdlruMB½T§edayerOgsm¶at; Edlpat;BN’labemSAedayevaharsa®sþsamKÁIPaBbdivtþn_

enABuMTan;ecjCak;EsþgenAeLIy. enAeBlenaH ´minsµanfa ´nwgeRbIeBlPaKeRcInkñúgry³eBldb;qñaM

bnÞab; edIm,Irk[)anB½t’manmYyTaMgRsugsþIBICemøaHmYyEdlmUlehtudMbUg²keRmIkeLIg enAcMeBlEdl

snþiPaBhak;dUcCasNæitenA\NÐÚcineTAehIyeT. dUcenAelIRkdaspþitrUbftmYyEdr kñúgdMeNIrRBav²

rbs;´kúñgtMbn; karBitEdldMbUgmanPaBminc,as;las; )anelceLIgsnSwm²-reNþAsaksBrab;min

Gs;enARbeTskm<úCarhUtdl;PñMTab²enAtamRBMEdncin-evotNam EdlsaksBCaeRcInRtÚvryHryay

edaykarRbyuT§Kña nigkarsnÞnaCabnþbnÞab; rbs;´CamYysakSIeRcIn\tKNna. edIm,Isakl,gpSMpÁúM

vaeLIgvij ´)anRbmUlcemøIyCasakSIrbs;GñkTTYlxusRtÚvRbmaNmYyrynak; TaMgm®nþIpøÚvkar

b¤minpøÚvkar nigmhaGMNacsMxan;²EdlBak;B½n§kñúgesaknadkmµenH. esovePAenHKWCalT§plénkar

esuIbrkkarBitmYyEdlcab;epþIm12qñaMmkehIy.

kardYlrlMénTIRkúgéRBnKrnigRkúgPñMeBj)anRtÚvbnþedaykarRbyuT§suIsac;hutQamrvag Rkúm

GñkQñHedIm,IdeNþImkarRtÜtRtaRbCu¿ekaHnanaenAQUgsmuRTéfeTot. b:ul Bt emdwknaMExµrRkhmEdl

)andwgmunBIkarRbQmmuxmYyCamYyevotNamCasRtÚvsYBUCenaH)andak;ecjCabnÞan; nUvkmµviFIeFVI

dMeNIrTaMgbgçMmYyeq<aHeTAkan;lT§isgÁmniymedayqab;rh½skñúgTisedAeFVI[RbeTskm<úCarwtEtrwgmaMeLIg.

karkm©at;d¾eXareXAeTAelIGñkRbqaMgEdlsgS½yfaCaGñkmansmancitþCitsñiT§nwgevotNam )an[

sBaØaCamunBIkarvaylukedayRtg;²eTAelIPUminanarbs;evotNamenAtamRBMEdn. sRmab;ExµrRkhm

vaMgnnFøak;cuH 5

Page 16: Brother enemy

yl;fa ³ enHKWCakic©karBarmYyRtwmRtÚvtamc,ab; Cas®gÁammYysRmab;bgáarCamunTl;nwgsRtÚv

Rbvtþisa®sþmYyEdlRbRBwtþGVI²sMedAEt«elbRt)ak; »km<úCab:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþ sRmab;evotNamk¾dUcKña

Edr PaBCasRtÚvrbs;km<úCaEdlelIkTwkcitþedayRbeTscin )aneFVI[nwkeXIjGnusSavrIy_GaRkk;²

eLIgvij. ehtuGVI)anCaevotNam emIlBuMeXIjkarb:unb:gmYyénsRtÚvtaMgBIedImerogmk KWRbeTs

cinEdlcg;ykRbeTsrbs;xøÜndak;CacMNuH? kñúgkarRbyuT§tsU‘CaeRcInelIkrbs;xøÜnRbqaMgnwg«GaNacRk

kNþal » ¬RbeTscin¦ kñúgfirevlamYyBan;qñaMknøgmkRbeTsevotNamhak;dUcCaeRtómxøÜnkarBarmun

rYcCaeRsccMeBaHkarKMramkMEhgNamYy ehIycaMvaybkeTAvijCadrab. GVI²)andl;TIbMputenAcugqñaM

1977. CemøaH)anRtÚvlatRtdag[BiPBelakdwgB¤enAéf¶TI1 Exmkra qñaM1978. viTüúPñMeBj )an

pSBVpSayCasaFarN³fa RbeTskm<úCaCaGñkrgeRKaHBI«karQøanBanrbs;evotNam ». kñúgry³eBl

5ExEdlmanCabnþbnÞab; karRCÜlRcbl;)anraldaleTAdl;PaKxageCIgeTot. karcakecjTaMghVÚg²

énGaNikCncinBIRbeTsevotNam )anpþl;[Rkúgeb:kaMgnUv»kaselIkeLIgnigbriharBI«kareFVITukç

bukemñj »CnCaticinedayRkúghaNUynigBI«mhicätaRtÜtRta »rbs;evotNamenA\NÐÚcin. karBRgwg

sm<½n§PaBrwtEtCitsñiT§eLIgrvagsUevotnigevotNam)aneFVI[erOgr:avCaRbvtþisa®sþénkarKMramkMEhg

d¾«eXareXA » EdlKµanlkçN³R)akdRbCakeRmIkeLIgvijelIrNsirSBIrKWenAPaKxageCIgnigPaKxag

t,Úg. taMgBIrdUvekþAqñaM1978 RbeTscin)aneRKagerobcMdak;TNÐkmµevotNamrYcCaeRsc cMeBaH

karrmilKuNrbs;xøÜnEdlFøab;Et)anTTYlGtßRbeyaCn_BIkarCYy]btßmÖrbs;cinGs;ry³eBlsamsib

qñaMmkehIy. enAqñaM1979 bnÞab;BIkarpþÜlrMlMsm<½n§mitþExµrRkhmrbs;xøÜnedaykarcUllukluy

rbs;evotNam RbeTscinGacrkSaTuknUvkardak;TNÐkmµmYyEdlxøÜn)ansnüarYcmkehIyCanic©.

cab;BIeBlenHeTA CemøaHrbs;\NÐÚcin)anERbkøayeTACaerOgEdlmanCab;Tak;TgnwgkarRbkYt

RbECgKñaminGacRsay)anrvagsUevot Gaemrik nigkarERbRbÜlEdlekIteLIgedayécdnü KWsm<½n§

PaBrvagcin-Gaemrik EdleBlenaHkMBugmankarrIklUtlas;y:agxøaMg. pÞúyBIkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

eRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;ExµrRkhmEdlbiTRBMEdnrbs;xøÜny:agCitsøúg nigBwgEp¥kEtelIRbeTscinenaH

cab;BIqñaM1975eTARkúghaNUy)anxMRbwgBRgIkneya)aykarbreTsÉkraCümYy edayEp¥kelImUldæan

énkareFVI[manTMnak;TMngesµIPaBKñaCamYymhaGMNacputelxTaMgBIr. kñúgGMLúgrdUvekþAqñaM1977

RbeTsevotNamehobnwg)anseRmceFVI[manTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUtCamYyshrdæGaemrikeTAehIy

b:uEnþkarcecsrbs;xøÜnedaytRmÚv[Gaemrikpþl;C¿nYysRmab;karsþarRbeTseLIgvij )aneFVI[KeRmagkar

enaHrlayxSúr. mYyqñaMeRkaymk enAeBlEdlCemøaHminTan;ecjmuxrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTskm<úCa nig

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg6

Page 17: Brother enemy

cinehobnwgkøayeTACas®gÁamecjmuxmYy nigenAeBlEdlkarxitcUlCitKñaCamYyRkúgv:asuInetan

køayeTACaPaBcaM)ac;xanmin)anenaH RbeTsevotNamRtÚvEtlHbg;lkçxNÐCaGaTiPaBenHsin. b:uEnþ

kñúgcenøaHeBlenaH lkçN³BiessEpñkkarTUt)anERbRkLas;Gs;. edaymin[evotNamdwgxøÜn

Rkúgeb:kaMg)anRbkan;ykkarseRmccitþ «pþl;emeronmYy » cMeBaHRbeTsCitxagenAPaKxagt,ÚgRBMEdn

xøÜnrYcCaeRsc. munnwgelatcUleTAkñúgkarpSgeRBgenH RbeTscin)anbegáInkic©RbwgERbgrbs;xøÜnrwt

EtxøaMgeLIgEfmeTot edIm,IsRmbsRmÜleFVI[TMnak;TMngkarTUtCamYyshrdæGaemrikmanRbRktIPaB

sin ehIykarseRmccitþrbs;cinenH k¾RsbKñay:agxøaMgeTAnwgeKaledAepSg²rbs;GaemrikaMgEdr

RbFanaFibtI hSImIxaF½r nigTIRbwkSasnþisuxCatirbs;Kat;manbMNgbBa©ÚlRbeTscinkñúgsm<½n§PaBmYy

RbqaMgsUevotxøaMgNas;. ehtuenHehIy)anCaGaemrikaMgseRmccitþe)aHbg;ecalKMniteFVI[man

RbRktIPaBkñúgTMnak;TMngGaemrik-evotNammYyGenøI ehIy)anC¿ruj[mankarxitcUlKñaCamYyRkúg

eb:kaMgCasm¶at;vij. samsibqñaMeRkaykareFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;xøÜnenA\NÐÚcinRbqaMgnwg«lT§ivatTI

niymcin » shrdæGaemrik)anRtLb;mksßitkñúgsßanPaBCa «GñkecjedImTun » kñúgs®gÁammYyEdldwknaM

edayRkúgeb:kaMgRbqaMgnwgevotNamdEdl ³ enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1979 emdwknaMcin etg s‘avBIg EdleTIb

nwgRtLb;BId¿eNIrTsSnkic©d¾maneCaKC½yenAshrdæGaemrik )anpSBVpSayy:agTUlMTUlaynUv «kic©

Rbtibtþikardak;TNÐkmµ»rbs;Kat;[eKdwgB¤CasaFarN³.

karcUlkan;kab;RbeTskm<úCaedayRbeTsevotNam nig «kic©Rbtibtþikardak;TNÐkmµ » rbs;cin

eTAelIevotNamCasBaØabgðaj[eXIjnUvkRmitx<s;bMputénCemøaHmYyEdlTuMeCaryUryarNas;mkehIy

b:uEnþCemøaHenHBuM)annaMmknUvd¿eNaHRsayEbbNamYyeLIy. enAedImqñaM1986 kgT½BevotNam

cMnYn180>000nak; )anenAvayRbyuT§Tl;nwgs®gÁamT½BéRBrbs;ExµrRkhmkñúgRbeTskm<úCaenA

eLIy. RbeTscinenAEtbnþ)aj;epøagRKab;kaMePøIgFMtamRBMEdnevotNamxageCIg ehIyTahanefµIreCIg

cink¾Etglbvayqµk;Canic©kalEdr. edayRtÚvbeNþjecjBITIRkúgPñMeBj RkúmExµrRkhmminsUvpþl;

kmøaMgcitþdl;rdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüEdlCardæaPi)alEtmYyKt;EdleKTTYlsÁal;enAkm<úCa

enaHeLIy. b:uEnþTal;EteBls®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTIbICab;KaMgeTIbbrikarN_ ¬karN_TaMgLayEdlekIt

munb¤eRkayRBwtþkarN_mYy¦ GnþrCaticab;epþImpøas;bþÚrTaMgRsug. edayTajGtßRbeyaCn_BIs®gÁam

cin-evotNam RkúgmUsÁÚ)anTTYlkarGnuBaØat[taMgmUldæanT½BCaeRcInkEnøgkñúgRbeTsevotNam Edl

RkúghaNUyFøab;)anbdiesFCayUrmkehIy dUecñHsUevotGaclatsn§wg\T§iBlrbs;xøÜnenAmhasmuRT

):asuIhVikEfmeTot. Rkúgv:asuInetan RtÚvEte)aHbg;ecalsm<½n§PaBRbqaMgsUevot EdlKeRmagkarenH

vaMgnnFøak;cuH 7

Page 18: Brother enemy

Føab;dwknaMedayGaemrik edIm,IKaMRTRbeTscinRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNammYyry³eBl TukNaCaRkúg

eb:kaMgEdlRBÜy)armÖBIÉkraCüPaBrbs;xøÜncab;epþImeFVIkic©crcasþIBIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRkúg

mUsÁÚk¾eday. pøÚvEdleq<aHeTArk «cMNuccab;epþIm » RtÚvxÞb;Cab;. RbeTsevotNamEdlBUEkxag

rebobeFVIcm,aMg b:uEnþ EdleKminsUveTAmkehIyedayesdækic©rbs;xøÜnRtÚvhinehacEfmeTotenaH )an

cab;epþImEsVgrkkarxitcUlCitKñaCamYyshrdæGaemrikCafµI eRBaHxøÜn)aneFVI[rbUtputBIédcMnYnBIr

dgrYcmkehIy.

TaMgGs;enHehIy CaCemøaHelIkTIbIrbs;\NÐÚcin nigCaEl,gkarTUtrbs;mhaGMNacFM².

taMgBIkarehaHehIrén]T§mÖaKcRkcugeRkayBId¿bUlGKarsßanTUtGaemrikRbcaMRkúgéRBnKr GVIEdlekIt

manenA\NÐÚcin)anbgðaj[eXIjy:agc,as;fa etIcMNucNaxøHCakareFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;shrdæGaemrik

EdlvayRcLMeKaledArbs;xøÜnenaH? edaymineFVIxøÜnCaRkúmQanmuxRbqaMgTl;nwgkarvatTIrbs;lT§i

kumµúynIsþcinenAGasuIdUcEdlRkúmGñkCMnajkarGaemrikaMgP½yxøacBIbBaðaenH RbeTsevotNammin

bEg¥bg¥g;ERbkøayxøÜneTACaKURbECgnwgRbeTscinEdlcUlcitþbgáCemøaHenaHeLIy. ExµrRkhmEdleK

cat;TuktaMgBIyUrmkehIyfa Ca]bkrN_rbs;RkúghaNUyenaH )anbgðajxøÜneLIgCasRtÚvsøab;rs;nwg

KñaeTAvij. Rbvtþisa®sþkñúgry³eBldb;qñaMcugeRkayenHmanlkçN³mYyEdleKeRbIR)as;Caemeron

)an ehIyEdlvabgðaj[eXIjfaKWRkúmGñkts‘U[manrebobrbbfµICaRbvtþisa®sþnigRkúmGñkCati

niymenHehIyEdlCaGñkkþab;kUnesasRmab;GnaKtPUmiPaKenH. fVIebIGVI²bgðaj[eXIjEtsMbkeRkA

k¾eday k¾bNþamnusSKµanqnÞ³EdlminKYrykcitþTukdak;ElgmaneKdwgB¤sussayenA\NÐÚcineTot

ehIy.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg8

Page 19: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI1PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg

enAEx]sPa qñaM1975 PaBs¶b;s¶at;)anekItmanCafµIenA\NÐÚcin bnÞab;BIPaBBuHke®Ba¢al kñúg

ry³eBlmYyEx. sMeLgj½rrNþMénhVÚgynþehaHEdlehaHEqVlqVat;enAelIGakasedIm,IEsVgrk

GñkrYcputBIesckþIsøab;)anrlt;sUnüQwg. RbtibtþikarCYyse®gÁaHGñkePosxøÜntamTUkrab;ry

eRKÓgEdlebIkrt;ecjy:agGs;el,ÓnBIRbeTsevotNamenaH )anRtÚvnaMmuxeFVIedaykgnavacrTI7

rbs;GaemrikaMg. karr¿eCIbrMCYlminsmehtuplTaMgenH)anerIbeLIgvij. y:agehack¾eKvaytémøBI

erOgenHEdr.

RBwkéf¶TI15 Ex]sPa qñaM1975 BnøWRss;bMRBgénRBHGaTitüenAÉeCIgemX)anecalrsµIciBa©ac

mkelIépÞsmuRTBN’exovføaenACu¿vijekaHtagkñúgQUgsmuRTéf enAeBlEdlsMeLgmYyEdlCalkçN³

Biesséns®gÁam)anlan;B¤eLIgCafµI. enATisxaglic ]T§mÖaKcRkdb;mYyeRKÓg )anelceLIgsÞúg²

enAÉnayeCIgemX. ]T§mÖaKcRkRbePT Jolly Green Giants nig Knife énkgGakascrGaemrikaMg)an

tRmg;k,aleq<aHmkrkekaHrbs;km<úCa. kmµvtßúrbs;eKKWEsVgrkk):al;dwkkugtWn½rcMNas;mYyeRKÓg

rbs;GaemrikeQµaH ém:y:aehÁ EdlRtÚvrujRcanedayTwkrlk ehIyTmøak;yufáaQb;enARtg;smuRTEk,r

ekaHtag. kalBIéf¶TI12 Ex]sPa navatUcmYyrbs;km<úCaEdlpÞúkeTAedayyuT§Cnekµg²kñúgsemøók

bMBak;BN’exµA)anvaydeNþImyknavaenHedaykmøaMgenAkñúglMhsmuRTRtg;tMbn;ekaHBUlUév: EdlenA

q¶aymkPaKxagt,ÚgeTot1. edayeqøIytbnwgkarbBa¢ÚnsBaØaR)ab;BIeRKaHGasnñrbs;navaelakRbFa

naFibtI ehSr:al; hV½rd_ )anecjbTbBa¢a[kgÉkPaB]T§mÖaKcRkmYyénkgGakascrshrdæGaemrik

EdlsMctRbcaMkarenAmUldæan GU‘ta):av RbeTséf nigm:arInénkgnavacrTI7RbcaMsmuRT):asuIhVikecj

CYyse®gÁaHnava ém:y:aehÁ nigRkúmnavikcMnYnsamsibR)aMbYnnak;. kñúgBnøWminTan;c,as;éneBlRBwk

RBhamenAeBlEdlTahanm:arInRbwgERbgvaylukdeNþImykekaHenH BYkeKBuM)andwgfa RkúmnavikTaMg

enaHRtÚvExµrRkhmepÞrmkkan;dIeKakenAÉkMBg;EpkMBg;esamrYcmkehIyeT. mü:ageTot GñkyuT§sa®sþ

GaemrikaMgk¾vaytémøxusy:agxøaMgBIkic©karBard¾emaHmutrbs;kgT½BExµrRkhmEdlmankMeNItCaksikr

manGavuFminRKb;RKan;EtGacTb;Tl;nwgkgkumµ:g;dUCYyse®gÁaHrbs;Gaemriky:ag manRbsiT§PaBbMput.

k):al;TImYyRbePT Knife )anbBa©úHTahanm:arInrbs;xøÜn[eLIgeKakswgEtminTan;cb;sBVRKb;pg Rsab;

EtenACYredImeQIEdlRKbdNþb;mkelIeqñrxSac; sñÚrpÞúHénkaMePøIgynþ nigkaMePøIgEvg )anlan;B¤eLIgdUc

9

Page 20: Brother enemy

laCpÞúH. tamkarGHGagrbs;GñkrYcputBIeRKaHfñak;mñak;CaGñkebIk]T§mÖaKcRk EdlsßitenAeRkamkarb:H

TgÁicxagpøÚvcitþenAeLIy )anniyayfa enaHCa «kRmgpáasa)auMgmYysRmab;NUEGl »2. mindl;mYy

em:agpg navaBIreRKÓg)anRtÚvExµrRkhmkemÞcenAelIeqñrxSac;. enAelIekaHKµanGñkNaCYyse®gÁaH

GñkNaeLIy elIkElgEtTahanm:arInenaHpÞal;EdlminGaceFVIGVIekItesaH eRkamePøógRKab;kaMePøIg

rbs;km<úCa. kñúgry³eBldb;bYnem:agbnÞab;BIenaH ynþehaHCaeRcIneRKÓgrbs;GaemrikEdlsMctenA

elIeqñrsmuRT nignavacm,aMgFM²rbs;kgnavacrTI7 )an)aj;eRsaceTAelItMbn;enaHeqHhuyRTelam.

RtÚveFVI[P½nþPaMgsµartIedaykarbgðajkmøaMgenH ExµrRkhm)anRBmedaHElgRkúmnavikk):al;y:agqab;

rh½s. b:uEnþTahanm:arInEdlCab; GnÞak;enAelIekaHtagenaHBuMTan;edaHxøÜnrYcenAeLIyeT. RbFanaFibtI

ehSr:al; hV½rd_ )anelIkerOgenHmkeFVICasMGagedIm,IbBa¢ak;fa karTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;xøÜnEdlbNþal

[zbnP½NÐTaMgLayrbs;km<úCaenAtameqñrsmuRTeqHexÞcxÞIGs;y:ageRcInenaH BitCaRtwmRtÚvEmn.

lT§plénkarRbyuT§enAéf¶enaHKWGaemrikaMgdb;R)aMnak; nigExµreRcInrab;minGs;)anRtÚvsøab; eragcRk

cRmaj;eRbgkatEtmYyKt; nigynþehaHcm,aMgmYykgtUcrbs;km<úCaRtÚvbMpøajexÞcxÞI. sRmab; hV½rd_

erOgnavaém:y:aehÁ KWCa»kaselIkkm<s;pøÚvcitþ EdlkMBugeRTteRTatbnþic enAGaemrik[egIbRtg;eLIg

vij bnÞab;BIkardkfyTaMgGam:as;BITIRkúgPñMeBjnigRkúgéRBnKr. enHCa «kemÞcePøIgEdlbeBaäH[man

C¿enOTukcitþeLIgvij ». shrdæGaemrikeTIbnwgqøgkat;ry³eBld¾exµAggwt mYyénsm½ykalrbs;xøÜn.

dUecñH «RBwtþikarN_enHGacebIk»kas[xøÜnRtLb;TMB½r nigkMNt;TisedAfµI²eTot »3. GMNwHteTAshrdæ

GaemriknwgcMNayeBlevlaTaMgGs;rbs;xøÜnedIm,IruMmuxrbYsknøgmk. GaemrikaMg)ane)aHbg;\NÐÚcin

[vileTArkPaBminR)akdRbCaCafµImþgeTot.

sac;erOgnavaém:y:aehÁ)anrlay)at;BITMB½rTImYyénkaEstnanay:agqab;rh½s. tamBit Gñk

sresrGtßbTGtßaFib,ayrbs;kaEst)aneFVIkarkt;smÁal;xøH²fa enHRKan;EtRBwtþikarN_bnÞab;bnSM

b:ueNÑaHenAkñúgCemøaHmYyEdleKniyayfarwtEtF¶n;F¶rCagmuneTAeTot KWbdibkçPaBdeNþImTwkdIKñarvag

RbeTsCitxagBIrEdlbBaÄb;yUrmkehIy. karRbyuT§cugeRkayedIm,Isþarkitþiysrbs;shrdæGaemrik

enA\NÐÚcin )anCYy[mankarbiT)aMgsBaØa[dwgdMbUg²éns®gÁamfµImYy elIkenHCas®gÁamsmøab;Et

bgb¥ÚnÉgEdlkMBugcab;epþImrvagGtItsmmitþTaMgLay EdlkalBIeBlfµI²enH )anBYtédKñaRbyuT§Tl;

nwgsRtÚvrYmKWGaemrikaMg. d,itGIkarcab;navaém:y:aehÁ )anekItmaneLIgkñúgCMhanénkarvayRbhar

rbs;ExµrRkhmeTAelIekaHTaMgLaykñúgQUgsmuRT Edlkan;kab;edayevotNamEdr. TahanExµr

Rkhmekµg²EdlBuHeBareTAedaykMhwg )anvayRbharnavaém:y:aehÁCamYynwgkaMePøIgGaka47rbs;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg10

Page 21: Brother enemy

xøÜnb:ueNÑaH. tamBitKWExµrRkhmcg;bgðaj[eXIjBIGFibetyüPaBTaMgRsugrbs;xøÜnCafµIelIRBMEdn

smuTÞrbs;km<úCab:ueNÑaH.

ekaHTaMgLayEdleKRsk;Twkmat;cg;)an

vaCaEbbEpnFmµCatimYyeTAehIy²EfmTaMgecosminrYcpgfa enAeRkayeBlmankarvay

RbyuT§d¾eCaKC½ymYyRbqaMgnwgkarkan;kab;rbs;breTs GñkQñHEtgEtRbwgERbgsEmþg[eXIjnUvkar

RtÜtRtaelITwkdITaMgLay EdleKTamTarTukdUcCacMENkmYyrYmbBa©ÚleTAkñúgebtikP½NÐCatirbs;eK.

b:uEnþ kñúgkrNIRbeTskm<úCa nigevotNam vaCavi)akénkarelceLIgCafµInUvkarRbkYtRbECg nig

GFikrN_taMgBIyUrmkehIy Edllak;xøÜnBIeRkayBakü «samKÁIPaBbdivtþn_ » EdlRKan;EtmanlkçN³

beBaäatb:ueNÑaH.

kalebIkþIsgÇwménC½yCmñHrbs;evotNamxageCIgenAPaKxagt,Úgcab;elcrUbragc,as;ehIy

karepþImKMnitmYykñúgcMeNamkarepþImKMnitCaeRcInrbs;RkúghaNUy KW «rMedaH »RbCuMekaH®s<atlIkñúg

smuRTcinxagt,ÚgBIkarRKb;RKgrbs;rbb FIv ¬RbFanaFibtIsaFarNrdæevotNamxagt,Úg¦ nigRbkas

TamTarekaH):ar:aEsl Edlkan;kab;edaycinCasaFarN³eTot. Etkñúgrvagb:unµans)aþh_b:ueNÑaH

eRkaykardeNþImkan;kab;TIRkúgPñMeBj ExµrRkhm)andak;BRgayT½BPøam edIm,IkarBarRBMEdneKak

nigsmuRT. kgT½BCaeRcIn)anRtÚvbBa¢ÚneTAkan;QUgsmuRTéf edIm,Ikan;kab;CakmµsiT§nUvekaHnanaEdl

rbbcas;Føab;)anRKb;RKg b¤TamTarCarbs;xøÜn.

eKaledACaeRcInkñúgkareFVIRbtibtiþkarTaMgenHBuMEmnRtwmEtTamTarTwkdIb:ueNÑaHeT. bMNgrbs;

ExµrRkhmEdlerobcMrdæGMNacrbs;xøÜn[mansßirPaBelITwkdITaMgmUlenaH KWkarelIkeRCagTg;ÉkraCüPaB

eLIgvijRbQmmuxTl;nwgGñk]btßmÖKaMBarxøÜnkñúgsm½ys®gÁam. tamTsSn³neya)aymYy eBlevla

)anmkdl;ehIysRmab;Gñkbdivtþn_evotNamnigkm<úCakñúgkareRCIserIsmaK’aedIrerog²xøÜn eTaHCaBYkeK

enAExVgKMnitKñaxøHk¾eday edaymin»bRkesabkarvinicä½yepSg²EdlnaM[rMxandl;ÉkPaBnigshRbtibtþikar

rbs;xøÜnEdlFøab;mankñúgry³eBleFVIs®gÁameLIy. taMgBICemøaHepSg²rlt;eTAevotNamElgrYjra

nwgeBalGHGagBIkarTamTarTwkdIrbs;xøÜncMeBaHmuxRbeTscineTotehIy ehIykm<úCak¾eFVIdUcenHcMeBaH

RbeTsevotNamEdr. mYyEpñk bdibkçPaBCaRbvtþisa®sþd¾cas;KMrwlrvagRbeTscinnigevotNam

ehIymYyEpñkeTotrvagRbeTsevotNamnigkm<úCaFøab;RtÚvbgçM[enAes¶óms¶at;edaykareFVIGaNaniKm

rbs;)araMgnigGnþraKmn_rbs;GaemrikaMgenAkñúgtMbn;enH. GMNwHteTA erOgenHGaccUlmkbMeBjcenøaH

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 11

Page 22: Brother enemy

enAxagmuxqakEdlBId¿bUgeFVIeLIgedays¶at;² bnÞab;mkRbkbedayPaBxøaMgkøamYykan;EtrIkFMeLIg².

fVIebIkMBugGHGagBIkarTamTarTwkdIEterog²xøÜnCacMhk¾eday k¾d¿Nak;kalenH Kµanrbbbdivtþn_NamYy

kñúgcMeNamrbbbdivtþn_TaMgBIrbeNþayxøÜn[Føak;eTAkñúgCemøaHmYyEdlmanTMhMFMEdr. PaBcaM)ac;Edl

BYkeKyl;eXIjdUcKñakñúgkarerobcMrdæGMNacrbs;xøÜnkñúgRbeTs nigkaredaHRsaybBaðay:ageRcIn\t

KNnabnÞab;BIsm½ys®gÁam)anbgçM[mankarxitcUlCitKñamYyy:agRby½tñRbEyg. mü:ageTot

emdwknaMciny:agsMxan;BIrrUb em:A esTug nig CU eGnLay )ansøab;)at;eTAehIy. bnÞab;PøamenaH

RbeTscinEdlCatYÉksMxan;mYykñúgcMeNamtYÉksMxan;²énCemøaHfµIenHBuMyl;RBm[mankarykcitþ

Tukdak;TaMgGs;cMeBaHbBaðaepSg²EdlekItmanenAtamRBMEdnPaKxagt,Úgrbs;xøÜneLIy. dUecñH edaysar

EtkarCab;rvl;edaHRsayerOgépÞkñúgrbs;tYÉkTaMgenaH CemøaHenH)ankMNt;nUvkarp¥akmYyry³eBl.

b:uEnþ kar)armÖP½yxøacEdldk;Cab;y:ageRCAkñúgpñt;KMnitEdlBYkeKmaneTAvijeTAmk mhicätanigPaB

smehtuplénneya)aykñúgnigeRkARbeTsEdlExVgKñay:agxøaMgenaH )anbgçM[RbeTskm<úCanigcin

Føak;eTAkñúgkarRbQmmuxdak;KñamYyCamYyRbeTsevotNamy:agqab;rh½s.

éf¶TI12 Exemsa qñaM1975 R)aMéf¶munkaredIrcUlRkúgPñMeBjRbkbedayeCaKC½yrbs;Exµr

Rkhm emdwknaMmñak;kñúgbNþaemdwknaMénclnatsU‘KW eGog sarI kMBugsßitenAextþkVagRTI (Quang Tri)

evotNamxagt,ÚgÉeNaH. sarI manedImkMeNItecjBIRKÜsarExµreRkammYyehAm:üageTotfa CnCati

PaKticExµr enAEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁénRbeTsevotNam. Kat;)ankøayeTACaCnm:akSsuIsniymmñak;

kñúgry³eBlEdlKat;sikSaenARkúg):arIs naTsvtSr_50 ehIyrYmCamYynwgnisSitdéTeTot Edlman

TaMg b:ul Bt pgenaH Kat;)anbegáItRkúmtsU‘Epñkneya)ayniymkumµúynIsþmYyenATIenaH. eRkaymk

Kat;)ankøayeTACamnusSTIBIrrbs;ExµrRkhmEfmeTotKW «bgTI2 » d¾KYr[RBWxøac. kñúgbTsmÖasn_mYy

enAqñaM1980 sarI )anerobrab;R)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa Kat;)aneFVId¿eNIrqøgkat;tMbn;EdleTIbnwgrMedaH

)anfµI²enAevotNamxagt,Úg edIm,IeTAkan;TIRkúgeb:kaMgtamtMbn;rMedaHrbs;km<úCaenAeBlKat;)anTTYl

TUrelxmYyrbs;RkúghaNUy EdlR)ab;[Kat;dwgBIkardkfyrbs;GaemrikaMg. sRmab; sarI pøÚvenA

sl;EdlKat;RtÚveFVIdMeNIrKW pøÚvlMhUCImijd¾EsnBi)aksµúKsµajCaBiesskñúgkarqøgkat;ERBknana

EdlmanTwkhUrxµÜlxµaj;kñúgextþrtnKirIrbs;km<úCaenaH KWRKan;EtedIm,IsÁal;b:ueNÑaH. kñúgGMLúgeBl

s®gÁam Kat;Føab;)anrs;enARbeTsevotNamCaeRcInqñaM edayBuHBartsU‘nwgeRKaHfñak;CaeRcInelIkkñúg

karedIrqøgkat;eTAmkrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr. b:uEnþdMNwgsþIBIkardYlrlMénTIRkúgPñMeBjEdlc,as;CaekIt

mankñúgeBlqab;² )anpøas;bþÚrGVI²TaMgGs;. Etkñúgry³eBld¾xøI pøÚvlMhUCImijEdlCapøÚvTak;Tgd¾sMxan;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg12

Page 23: Brother enemy

bMputCamYybdivtþn_km<úCa )anERbCaElgmanRbeyaCn_TaMgRsug. C¿nYskarbnþd¿eNIrqøgkat;CYrPñM

GaNÑam tamrfynþhSIúbEdleFVI[enOylM)akesÞIr)ak;cegáHenaH sarI )anERbKMniteFVIdMeNIrtam

ynþehaHeTARkúghaNUyvij ehIyecjBITIenaHKat;bnþd¿eNIreq<aHeTARkúgeb:kaMgeTot. Kat;)anmk

dl;RkúgPñMeBjenAéf¶TI24 Exemsa qñaM1975 tamynþehaH b‘UGIug707 rbs;cinmYyeRKÓg Edl

enHCaynþehaHbreTsd¿bUgbMputEdlmkcuHctenARbeTskm<úCafµI. sm½ykalénpøÚvlMhUCImij)an

eKacrmkbBa©b;RtwmenH.

GVIEdl sarI BuM)anniyayR)ab;´enAeBleFVIsmÖasn_enaH KWfakñúgry³eBléndMeNIrqøgkat;d¾xøI

rbs;Kat;enATIRkúgeb:kaMg Kat;)anCYbBiPakSaCamYyBYkemdwknaMcinGMBIkarBRgwgkgT½Brbs;km<úCa [

rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgeTot. Kat;)anesñIsuM[BYkcinbBaÄb;karpÁt;pÁg;GavuFnigsmÖareyaFa tammeFüa)ay

dUcsBVdgeToteTAKWkuM[eFVItamry³evotNam. BIrb¤bIs)aþh_eRkaymk navaFM²rbs;cinCaeRcIn

eRKÓgEdlpÞúkRsUv eRbg\n§n³ nigeRKÓg]bePaKbriePaK )ancUlmkctenAkMBg;EpkMBg;esam.

b:uEnþmunkarmkdl;rbs;navacinTaMgenH EdlbBa©b;CanimitþrUbmYynUvPaBÉekarbs;RbeTskm<úCa

bdivtþn_ ExµrRkhm)antv:aC¿Tas;nwgkarRtÜtRtarbs;evotNamelIekaHTaMgLaykñúgQUgsmuRTéf

eRsceTAehIy. edayykmkeRbIeLIgvijnUvkarTamTarBImunmYyrbs;km<úCaTak;TgnwgekaHPUkuk Exµr

ehAekaHRtl; ExµrRkhm)anvayluktampøÚvsmuRTcUlRtÜtRtaelIekaHenaHy:agrh½s. kgT½BTaMg

enaH)aneLIgeTAelIekaHenAéf¶4 Ex]sPa qñaM1975. R)aMmYyéf¶eRkaymk ExµrRkhm)anvayyk

ekaHBULÚb:g;hSg; evotNamehA fU CU ExµrehAekaHRkckesHEfmeTot. eRkamkarKMramkMEhgénGavuF

RbCaCnevotNam500nak;)anRtÚvbeNþjecjBITIenaH. BIrs)þah_eRkaykarkan;kab;rbs;Exµr

Rkhm evotNam)anebIkkarvaybkmYysgeTAvijeday)ansmøab;ExµrRkhmGs;CaeRcInnak; nig

cab;)an300nak;CaeQøIyswk4.

eGog sarI )anerobrab;R)ab;GñkmansmancitþGaemrikaMgmYyRkúmfa karcab;nava ém:y:aehÁ

kalBIéf¶TI12 Ex]sPa KWCakarseRmcedayÉkcitþEdleFVIeLIgedayGñkTTYlxusRtÚvxageyaFamñak;

enAmUldæanenaH edayKµansYreyabl;RkúgPñMeBjeLIy5. vaGacfa BYkkmµaPi)alEdlcUlcitþ

QWq¥alnwgkargar)anRbRBwtþRCúlhYsBIbTbBa¢akñúgParkic©karBarTwkdIkm<úCa edIm,IvayRbhareTAelI

ekaHTaMgLayrbs;evotNampgEdr. b:uEnþ GVIEdlTMngbMputKWfa bTbBa¢aEtgEtRtÚvpþl;BIfñak;elI

eTAeRkamCanic©. edayBit ExµrRkhmRbEhlCaeCOfa karkan;kab;ekaHTaMg enaHnwg)aneTACaTLðIkrN_

mYysRmab;CYyBRgwgdl;karseRmcepSg²kñúgkrNIEdlekItmanvivaTkmµTwkdIrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr.

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 13

Page 24: Brother enemy

taMgBIedImmk CnCatiExµrminEdlyl;RBme)aHbg;ekaHTaMgenaH CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;kUsaMgsuInrbs;

)araMg bnÞab;mkdl;saFarNrdæevotNamesaHeLIy. enAqñaM1960 semþcRBH neratþm sIhnu

EdleBlenaHCaRBHRbmuxrdækm<úCaFøab;)ansakl,geday\t)ankar edIm,ITamTarykekaHRtl;BI

evotNammkvijtamry³pøÚvTUtEdr. enAeBlenaH semþc)anEføgrebobCakarRBmanfa «kar)at;bg;

ekaHTaMgenaHnigEdnsmuRTEdlB½T§Cu ¿vij GacbNþal[kMBg;EpkMBg;esamRtÚvfb;degðIm>>>nigkñúg

ry³eBld¾xøIKWTIbBa©b;énÉkraCürbs;eyIg»6.

kñúgPaBRcbUkRcbl;EdlekItmanbnþbnÞab;BIkardYlrlMénTIRkúgéRBnKr ExµrRkhmTMngCaKit

eXIjfa eBlevla)anmkdl;ehIyedIm,IseRmcTamTarTwkdITaMgLayrbs;xøÜntamry³karcUlkan;kab;

edaykmøaMgT½BEtmþg. b:ul Bt GtItnisSitEdleTATIRkúg):arIseFVIkarsikSaxagEpñkviTüúGKÁisnI ehIy

RblgminCab;enaHKWCaGñkm:akSsuIsniymEdlgb;nwgRTwsþIkumµúynIsþhYsehtu )ankøayeTACaGKÁelxa

bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaenAedImTsvtSr_60. eBlenHKat;Gacdak;[GnuvtþnUvKMnitEdlcg;[mankarEk

TRmg;dac;xatxagneya)aynigkars¥b;ex<Im ¬edaymindwgerOgGVI¦ Edlkb;y:ageRCAkñúgcitþrbs;Kat;

cMeBaHRbeTsevotNamEdlCasRtÚvKµanTIbMput. bnÞab;BIkarvaydeNþImykTIRkúgPñMeBj)anPøam b:ul

Bt )anecjmtiENnaM¬b¤saracr¦mYyman8cMNuc kñúgenaHman2cMNucEdlbBaØtþi[eFVIkarbeNþj

GaNikCnevotNamTaMgGs;ecjBIkm<úCa nigkarbBa¢ÚnT½BeTAkan;RBMEdn CaBiessRBMEdnevotNam7.

b:uEnþPaBGmnusSFm’énRbtikmµrbs;evotNam )annaM[mankarBinitüeLIgvijnUvmUlkPaB ¬PaBsm

ehtupl¦ énviFankarmYyEdlRtÚveFVIeLIgedayRbjab;dUcKña. éf¶TI2 Exmifuna qñaM1975 egVón

v:an;lij smaCikkariyal½yneya)aymCÄimbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam )aneFVId¿eNIrmkRkúgPñMeBj

tamrfynþedIm,ICYb b:ul Bt BiPakSaKñaBIerOgenH. kñúgPaBesµaHRtg;BIkñúgdYgcitþ b:ul Bt )ankarBar

xøÜnedayRBmTTYlsÁal;kMhusenH nigsEmþgkaresaksþayrbs;Kat;pgEdr. enAcMeBaHmux lij Kat;

)anTTYlsÁal;karBiténkarcUllukluyrbs;km<úCa b:uEnþ Kat;)anGHGagfa «karRbQmmuxd¾exøacpSa

nigd¾bgðÚrQamenH» KWbNþalmkBI «yuT§Cnkm<úCaminsUvsÁal;PUmisa®sþtMbn;enaH».

«Fmµta/ srubeTAKWFmµta>>>»

evotNammineCOsmþId¿bUg²enHeT. BitNas; b:ul Bt KWCamnusSEdlRtÚveKTTYlsVaKmn_

rak;Tak;enATIRkúghaNUy. b:uEnþkñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH evotNam)anebIkkarvaylukmYyTaMgeCIg

Gakas TaMgeCIgTwkeTAelIekaHBULÚév:rbs;km<úCaCafµI. enAeBlEdl b:ul Bt EdlGmdMeNIreday

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg14

Page 25: Brother enemy

eGog sarI GKÁelxabkSrg nYn Ca nigemdwknaMmYycMnYneToteTAdl;RkúghaNUy enAéf¶TI12 Exmifuna

qñaM1975 edIm,IeFVI «TsSnkic©Cabgb¥Ún »mYyenaH GVI²)ancb;eRsceTAehIy enAekaHBULÚév: Edl

Tg;CatievotNam)anbk;rvicenATIenaHCaeRsc. éf¶TI14 Exmifuna qñaM1975 edayniyaybnþBIkar

minecHTb;mat;rbs;BYkPñak;garsm¶at;GaemrikaMg kaEstjÚvy:kEfm)anpSBVpSayCasaFarN³BIkar

deNþIm)anekaHenH. PaBd¿NalKñaénTsSnkic©rbs; b:ul Bt enAhaNUy CamYynwgerOgenHTal;Et

RbEhlbIqñaMeRkaymkeTIb)aneKdwgB¤.

eGog sarI )anniyayR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦enAeBleRkaymkeTotfa kñúg»kasénkarCYbBiPakSa

CaeRcInelIk KN³RbtiPUrbs;Kat;)anelIkeLIgBIbBaðaCemøaHRBMEdnCamYynwgevotNamEdr b:uEnþ\t

)ankar. tamKat;[dwgfa km<úCaR)afñaQan[dl;kic©RBmeRBógmYyedayEp¥kelImUldæanénesckþI

RbkasenAqñaM1967 rbs;saFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüevotNam ¬KWRbeTsevotNamxageCIg¦

EdlkaleNaH)anTTYlsÁal;km<úCakñúg «RBMEdnbc©úb,nñ » EdlesñIeLIgeday semþcRBH neratþm

sIhnu. b:uEnþevotNam)anRbqaMgC¿Tas;RKb;karCECkBiPakSaTaMgGs;. esckþIRbkasTaMgLayrbs;

evotNam EdlmaneRkay²mkeTot)aneRbIR)as;karbkRsaymYyepSgeTAvij ³ ebIkm<úCaBitCacg;

seRmckic©RBmeRBógmitþPaBmYy edayepþatCaBiess eTAelIkic©karC¿nYj TMnak;TMngEpñkkugsu‘l

nigkarkRmitRBMEdnenaH vanwgKµankarcrcaPøam²sþIBIerOgRBMEdneLIy. karKiteFVI[)anseRmckic©

RBmeRBógmitþPaBmYyEdlelIkeLIgedayBYkExµrRkhm edIm,Isakl,gbnÞn;citþevotNamnwgeFVI[

evotNamTTYlsÁal;PaBminGacb:HBal;)anénRBMEdnRbeTsTaMgBIrb¤y:agNa? erOgenHminEdlRtÚv

elIkykmkCECkKñaTal;EtesaH8.

éf¶TI2 ExsIha qñaM1975 eLyn; GKÁelxabkSkumµúynIsþevotNam paMhu‘g smaCikkariyal½y

neya)ay nig s‘n;Fuy mnusSeCIgcas;kñúgkic©crcasnþiPaBRkúg):arIs)aneLIgynþehaHeq<aHmkRkúg

PñMeBjedIm,IeFVITsSnkic©xøImYy. eRkayBI)anbgðaj[km<úCaeXIjBIkmøaMgeyaFarbs;xøÜnmYyRtÜsrYc

mk evotNamGacbgðaj[eXIjP½sþútagénPaBTn;Pøn;rbs;xøÜnmþg. eLyn; EdlCasmaCiksßabnik

bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcin ehIymunnwgkan;muxtMENgCaGKÁelxabkSrbs;evotNam Kat;Føab;)anrs;enA

kñúgKukdb;qñaM nigFøab;)andwknaMclnabdivtþn_enAevotNamxagt,ÚgGs;ry³eBlCaeRcInqñaMeTot.

xusEbøkBIshkarIKat; paMhu‘g KWCamnusSPaKxagt,Úg Fat;duHk,aleBaH ehIyFøab;)andwknaMeFVIkar

RbyuT§enAPaKxagt,ÚgnigrkSakarTak;TgCamYyemdwknaMExµrRkhmEdlenARBMEdnmçageTot. enHKWCa

elIkTImYyehIyEdl eLyn; eFVId¿eNIrmkkan;RbeTskm<úCa. kalEdlGñkTaMgBIrmkkan;RkúgPñMeBj

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 15

Page 26: Brother enemy

KWBuMEmnmkeFVIeTscrN_eT.

KN³RbtiPUevotNam)ancakecjBIRkúgPñMeBj EdlkøayeTACaTIRkúgexµacmYyeTAehIy taMgBI

mankarCemøósRbCaCnrbs;xøÜnTaMgGs;ecjTaMgkMeralkalBIExemsa. tamkaresñIsuMrbs;km<úCa

r)aykarN_epSg²sþIBITsSnkic©enHRtÚv)ankat;bMRBÜjCaGtibrma9. ebITukCakarTTYlePJóvy:ag

esaHkeRkaHEdleRtómbRmúgsRmab;Kat;k¾eday k¾ eLyn; enAEtbgðaj[eXIjfa Kat;CamnusS

EdlgayRsuHRsYlCanic©. Kat;TTYlsÁal;fa ekaHBULÚév: BitCacMENkmYyénTwkdIrbs;km<úCaR)akd

Emn ehIyKat;)ansnüanwgRbKl;[vijkñúgeBlqab;². esckþIEføgkarN_rYmmYyRtÚv)anPaKITaMgBIr

cuHhtßelxa kñúgenaHPaKInImYy²)ansnüaeFVIkaredaHRsayGFikrN_rbs;xøÜntamry³karcrcaKña

b:uEnþesckþIEføgkarN_enHBuMEdlRtÚvRbkaspSay[dwgB¤CasaFarN³Tal;EtesaH ehIyk¾BuMmankar

elogsayePaCn_ nigkarEføgsunÞrkfaCakic©KYrsmEdr. r)aykarN_xøIkMbutmYyénTsSnkic©enHRtÚv

)anpSaybnþd¿NalKña edayviTüúhaNUynigviTüúPñMeBjenAéf¶TI3 ExsIha qñaM1975 ³ «karpøas;bþÚr

eyabl;Kñad¾esµaHsµ½RK)anRbRBwtþeTArvagevotNam nigKN³RbtiPUkm<úCamYyRkúmkñúgbriyakasmYy

RbkbedayPatrPaBCabgb¥Ún. karpøas;bþÚreyabl;TaMgenaH)anepþateTAelIbBaðaepSg² EdlCapl

RbeyaCn_rYmrvagRbeTsTaMgBIredayesµIPaBKña»10.

ebIsinCaPaBesµaHGs;BIdYgcitþkñúgkarBiPakSaepSg² manbgáb;eTAedayBaküPUtkuhkenaH

briyakasmuxCaeqHqYlCafµI b:uEnþEbrCacuHfybnþiceTAvij enAeBlEdlevotNamseRmcRbKl;

ekaHBULÚév:mk[km<úCa. enAéf¶TI10 ExsIha qñaM1975 egVón v:an;lij )anCYb nYn Ca emdwknaM

Can;x<s;mñak;kñúgcMeNamemdwknaMCan;x<s;rbs;bkSkm<úCa edIm,Ipþl;B½t’manBIkardkfyrbs;kgT½B

evotNamecjBIekaHenaH. nYn Ca )anEføgGMNrKuNRbeTsevotNamcMeBaHkarseRmccitþenH

ehIy)anbBa¢ak;fa «kMhuskñúgkarminsUvsÁal;RBMEdn »11enaHehIyEdlCamUlehtunaM[manRBwtþi

karN_eQøaHTas;ETgKñaenH. tamBit mUlehtuedIménkareBIbRbyuT§suIsac;hutQamEdlekIt

manCabnþbnÞab;eRkayC½yCmñHenaH KWmkBIkarepþatcitþxøaMgeBkcMeBaHbBaðaRBMEdnnigKMnitCatiniym

d¾BuHeBarénPaKITaMgBIrenHÉg.

b:uEnþkñúgcMeNamRbeTsTaMgBIr KµanRbeTsNamYycab;epþImmuneKkñúgkarRbQmmuxKñaenHeLIy.

CaBiessxagevotNam)anrkSaTukCemøaHenHmin[saFarN³mtidwgB¤eT. edayxMRbwgbM)at;]bsKÁ

epSg² EdlCYnkaleRbIkmøaMg CYnkaleRbIneya)aykarTUtpgenaH RkúghaNUy)anseRmccitþ

EfrkSasamKÁIPaBmYyEdlmanEtsMbkeRkA CamYyRkúgPñMeBjCabnþeTAeTot.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg16

Page 27: Brother enemy

enAExkkáda qñaM1975 bnÞab;BIkarsñak;enABIrExknøHkñúg «RkúgéRBnKrrMedaH » ´)anCiHynþehaHeq<aH

eTARkúghaNUyeTotmunnwgcakecjBIRbeTsevotNam. kñúg»kasénkarsmÖasn_CamYy v:ag Tug GKÁniBn§

naykTinanub,vtþi jinhSin rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam ´)anesuIbsYrB½t’manGMBIsßanPaBénTMnak;

TMngCamYyRbeTskm<úCaEdr. Kat;)aneqøIyy:agrh½sR)ab;´fa «Fmµta ». bnÞab;BIQb;mYyRsbk;

Kat;)anbEnßmfa ³ «srubeTAKWFmµta ». Kat;)anbdiesFB½t’manmYysþIBIkarRbQmmuxdak;Kñarvag

RbeTskm<úCanigevotNamenAkñúgQUgsmuRTéfEdlmancuHpSayedaysarB½t’manelakxaglic.

kñúgeBlEdl´kMBugsnÞnaCamYy Tug kñúgkariyal½yminsUvPøWrbs;Kat;EdlelcRtEdtBIbwg

h½neKom enARkúghaNUy manCnCatievotNamrab;Ban;nak;-RbúsRsI nigkUnekµg)anRtÚvbeNþjecj

BIkm<úCaeq<aHeTAEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁenAevotNamxagt,Úg. enARtg;RBMEdnGñkTaMgenaHRtÚv)ankg

ÉkPaBevotNamr:ab;rgbnÞúk nigerobcM[rs;enAkñúgC¿rMbeNþaHGasnñCaeRcInkEnøgEdlksageLIg

edayrdæaPi)al. GñkePosxøÜnkm<úCaEdlmanedImkMeNItevotNamnigcinCaeRcInrynak;)anseRmc

cUleTArs;enAkñúgvtþmYyenARcWLWgedayxøÜnÉg. GñkqøgeqøIyB½t’manénTIPñak;garB½t’man)araMgGaeGhVeb:

eQµaH qal Gg;t½n dW ENsuIy:at_ minnwksµanfaxøÜnGacTTYl)anB½t’mansMxan;pþac;muxmYydUecñHeLIy

enAeBlEdlKat;eXIjBIcm¶aynUvGñkePosxøÜnecjBIkm<úCabdivtþn_Cabgb¥Únmkrs;enAkñúg «éRBnKr

rMedaH »enaH. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday edaysarkarRbúgRby½tñrbs;EpñkRtÜtBinitüevotNam TUrelx

rbs;Kat;minEdlRtÚveKbBa¢ÚneTAeKaledAEdlRtÚvepJIesaHeLIy. PaBKab;CYnEdlKYr[Gs;sMeNIc

KWenAéf¶dEdlenaH b:ul Bt )aneTAdl;RkúghaNUykñúgsPaBGaf’kM)aMgbMput. etIGñkRtÜtBinitüRtÚveK

R)ab;[dwgBITsSnkic©enHb¤eT? vaBi)aknwgniyayNas;. TukCay:agNak¾eday k¾evotNammin

beNþay[BYkGñkkaEstrbs;sarB½t’manKhbtIlatRtdagBIerOgKYr[ex<ImreGIménGñkePosxøÜn

ehIyeFVI[sµúKsµajdl;TMnak;TMngepSg²CamYykm<úCaEdr. eKRtÚvrg;caMrhUtdl;qñaM1978 eTIbkarBit

cab;epþImelceLIgedayxøÜnÉg. enAExmInaénqñaMdEdlenH¬1978¦ kñúg»kasénd¿eNIrmYyeTAkan;

tMbn;nanatamRBMEdn ´)andwgTaMgPJak;ep¥Ilfa kñúgGMLúgR)aMExbnÞab;BI «karrMedaH »RkúgPñMeBjCnCati

evotNamCag150>000nak; EdlRtÚvdkhUtRTBüsm,tþiGs;BIxøÜn)anhUrcUlmkkñúgextþdugfab

Gany:ag nig taynij y:agkuHkr. GñkEdlmanedImkMeNItCaevotNamRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[sßitenA

b:uEnþGñkePosxøÜnEdlmanedImkMeNItCacinnigExµrRtÚv)anrujRcanmkkm<úCavij.

vtþmanEGbmkxagRkúgPñMeBjnUvmitþd¾manGMNacmYyRbEhlCaCYyBRgwgkgVl;kñúgkarRbúg

Rby½tñEfmeTot EdlsEmþg[eXIjedayevotNam. mü:ageTotRkúgeb:kaMgKWCad¿Nak;kalTI2én

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 17

Page 28: Brother enemy

d¿eNIrsm¶at;rbs; b:ul Bt bnÞab;BIRkúghaNUy. enAéf¶TI21 Exmifuna b:ul Bt RtÚv)anTTYl

bdisNæarkic©rebobCavIrbursedayRbFan em:A EdlCamKÁúeTÞsk_menaKmviC¢arbs;Kat;. em:A )anEføg

R)ab; «sav½k » EdlmanTwkmuxRss;b:éRbrbs;Kat;fa «CamYyRbCaBlkrkm<úCa elak)anseRmc

eCaKC½ykñúgkarRbyuT§elIkd¿bUgEtmþg cMENkeyIgEbrCabraC½y »12. kñúgeBlEdl «mhamKÁúeTÞsk_ »

enHkMBugniyay RbCaCnkm<úCarab;ryBan;nak;EdlRtÚvbeNþjecjTaMgkMeralBITIRkúgnana RtÚv)an

bBa¢Ún[eTArs;enAkñúg «C¿rMRbmUlpþú¿ »nanaEdlmanenABaseBjépÞRbeTs rebobC¿rM hÁÚLak; enAGtIt

shPaBsUevotEdr (Goulag CaGkSrkat;énBakürusSúI GkSreBjKW Glavnoïe Oupravlenie Laguereï =

direction générale des camps = mnÞIrcat;karTUeTAsRmab;RKb;RKgC¿rM KWCaRbB½n§RbmUlpþú¿mnusSb¤b®gáab

mnusSrbs;GtItshPaBsUevotnigbNþaRbeTsEdlCarNbrbs;xøÜn-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb¦.

em:A GbGrsresIrTaMgRsugcMeBaHyuT§sa®sþbdivtþn_rbs; b:ul Bt nigbMNgedIrtampøÚvmYy

dac;edayELkBIpøÚvrbs;evotNam. karCYbsnÞnaKñaenH BIrqñaMeRkaymkeToteTIbRtÚv)anpSBVpSay

[dwgCasaFarN³enAeBlEdl b:ul Bt Tmøak;r)aMgmuxcuHnigTTYlsÁal;tYnaTIrbs;Kat; CaGKÁelxabkS

eBjlkçN³. BitNas; evotNamKµandwgBIkares¶IcsresIry:agxøaMgEdl em:A pþl;eTAelIExµrRkhm

esaHeLIy. Ca]TahrN_ enAqñaM1975 em:A )anTUnµanemdwknaMevotNammYyrUbfa «RtÚveronsURt

tamkm<úCaBIrebobdwknaMkarbdivtn_þmYyy:agRbesIr»13.

mitþPaBrvagRbeTscinrbs; em:A nigkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüEp¥kelIPaBdUcKñaxagmenaKmviC¢a nig

CaBiesselIPaBRsbKñaénplRbeyaCn_Catierog²xøÜn. b:ul Bt nigbNþamitþrbs;Kat;Edles¶Ic

sresIredayKµanRBMEdnmYycMeBaHRTwsþIem:Akñúg «kartsU‘vNѳ » nig «kareFVIbdivtþKµanQb;Qr »enaH KW

mkBIkarERkgrEGg nigkarP½yxøacshPaBsUevotdUcKña. kñúglMdab;EdlkarRbqaMgC¿Tas;cMeBaHkar

RKbsgát;rbs;evotNammkelIeRCay\NÐÚcinkøayeTACakar)armÖd¾cm,grbs;xøÜnenaH RkúmemdwknaM

ExµrRkhm)ansEmþgxøÜnCasm<½n§mitþd¾sMxan;rbs;RbeTscinedayÉg² kñúgyuT§sa®sþCaRbéBNIrbs;

xøÜn sMedAeFVIy:agNabeBa©óskarkekItrdæd¾xøaMgBUEkmYyenARBMEdnPaKxagt,Úgrbs;xøÜn. KµanGVIKYr[

PJak;ep¥IleLIyEdlfa enAExsIha qñaM1975 eBlEdl CU eGnLay manC¿gWedkCab;nwgERK)anEføg

R)ab; eLfaj;gI GñkTTYlxusRtÚvsMxan;bMputénKN³kmµkarEpnkarrbs;evotNamfa RbeTscinBuMGac

CYyRbeTsevotNameT Rkúgeb:kaMg)aneRtómbRmúgnUvkarsVaKmn_d¾G‘åkGFwkmYycMBaHRbFanrdæ exov

sMpn nig]bnaykrdæm®nþI eGog sarI rYcCaeRsc. C¿nYymYyEdlmanTwkR)ak;mYyekadiduløarGaemrik

sRmab;ry³eBlR)aMqñaM RtÚv)anpþl;[km<úCaRbCaFibetyü EdlkñúgenaHmanémÖlanduløarRtÚvcin

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg18

Page 29: Brother enemy

RbKl;[Pøam²Etmþg.

C½yCmñHRtÚvFøak;mkelI exov sMpn nig eGog sarI ehIyC¿nYyEpñkhirBaØvtßúenHCaP½sþútagmin

GacRbEkk)ankñúgkarKaMRTedayKµanlkçxNÐrbs;RbeTscincMeBaHRbeTskm<úCa. edayRsbKñakñúg

»kasénkareFVId¿eNIrrbs; b:ul Bt enARbeTscin naExmifuna mankarcab;epþImeFVIkarcrcasm¶at;

CaeRcInTak;TgeTAnwgC¿nYyeyaFarbs;cin. enAExsIhanigExtula GñkC¿najkarCa eRcInRkúménRksYg

karBarRbeTscin)anmkeFVIkarsikSaGegáty:agsuICeRmAmYysþIBIesckþIRtÚvkarepSg²rbs;km<úCaxag

vis½yeyaFaenHdl;kEnøgEtmþg. éf¶TI12 Extula qñaM1975 GñkC¿najkarTaMgenaH)andak;CUnRkúg

PñMeBjBinitünUvesckþIRBagd¿bUgmYyénKeRmagC¿nYyeyaFa edIm,IsuMkarGnum½tyl;RBm.

éf¶TI6 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1976 sßanTUtcinenARkúghaNUy)andak;BakübNþwgCapøÚvkardMbUgrbs;xøÜn

Tak;TgeTAnwgkarbgçM[GaNikCncinenAevotNamxagt,Úg cUlsBa¢atievotNam. enAéf¶dEdlenaH

emdwknaMCan;x<s;mñak;rbs;kgT½Bcin)aneFVIdMeNIrCasm¶at;mkkan;RkúgPñMeBj edIm,IseRmcbegðIykic©

RBmeRBógCMnYyEpñkyaFa. v:ag sagr:ug GKÁesnaFikarrgénkgT½BRbCaCncin)anR)ab; sun esn rdæ

m®nþIkarBarRbeTskm<úCaRbCaFibetyü[dwgBIkarseRmccitþrbs;cinkñúgkarRbKl;[muneKnUvkaMePøIgFM

naval,ateqñrsmuRT nigRbB½n§EpñkkarBarGakaspg. TIRbwkSacincMnYnR)aMrynak;nwgRtÚvcat;[mkTTYl

bnÞúkbgðat;beRgónkgT½BExµrRkhmBIrebobeRbIR)as;smÖarTaMgenaH. v:ag )anrMB£kBIkarRbKl;smÖarswk

EdleRKagsRmab;qñaM1977 nig1978pgEdr. enAéf¶TI10 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1976 v:ag nig sun esn

)ancuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógsþIBIkarpþl;C¿nYyeyaFaedayKµansMNgcMeBaHRbeTskm<úCa14.

shRbtibtþikarEpñkeyaFa)anrIklUtlas;kñúgsPaBs¶at;kM)aMgbMput kñúgrebobeFVIy:agNakuM[

TaMgRbeTséf TaMgevotNamP½yxøac. kareFVI[smehtupld¿bUgrbs;BYkcinhak;dUcCayl;RBmeFVI

tambMNgRtwmRtÚvtamc,ab;rbs;km<úCakñúgkarERbkøayT½BéRBrbs;xøÜn[eTACakgT½BerobrymYy Edl

GacRbQmmuxnwgkarekobsgát;fµI²kñúgkic©karBarRbeTs. KµanGVIEdlRtÚvsgS½yeLIyfa RbeTscin

manbMNgføwg[esµIKñanUvvismtay:agsem,Imrvagm:asuIns®gÁamevotNam-EdlKYr[es,ImTaMgcMnYn

Tahank¾dUccMnYnyueT§abkrN_ nigkgT½BExµrmYyEdlmanGavuFminRKb;RKan;. BYkkumµúynIsþevot

Nam)anTTYlmrtkCaeRKÓgsBaVvuFBIGtItsaFarNrdæevotNamxagt,Úg EdlmantémøRbmaN5

ekadiduløarGaemrik. tameKyl; RbeTscinrbs; em:A BuMmanTaMgmeFüa)ay TaMgqnÞ³ edIm,IC¿rujExµr

Rkhm[eFVIkarRbQmmuxmYyedayGavuFCamYyevotNameLIy. RbeTscinRKan;Etpþl; «sac;du¿ » [

sm<½n§mitþrbs;xøÜnsRmab;Tb;Tl;nwgkarKMramkMEhgCayfaehturbs;evotNamb:ueNÑaH.

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 19

Page 30: Brother enemy

eTaHfaPaKl¥itl¥n;énkarcrcaEpñkeyaFaRtÚv)anTukCasm¶at;k¾eday k¾C¿hrCaeKalkarN_rbs;

cin EdlKaMRTRbeTskm<úCaTaMgRsug )anRtÚvlatRtdagCasaFarN³ nigCa]LarikEdr. enAéf¶TI17

Exemsa qñaM1976 Rkúgeb:kaMg)anR)arB§eFVIBiFIbuNüxYbelIkTImYyén «karrMedaH »TwkdIrbs;RbCaCnkm<úCa

y:agKRKwkKeRKg. enAkñúg»kasenaHtamry³sarlixitmYyEdlepJICUn b:ul Bt/ em:A/ CU eGnLay/

CUti nig hVa KUehVg )ansEmþgnUvkarekatsresIrd¾esµaHsµ½RKcMeBaHkarkarBary:agmuWgm:at;nUvÉkraCüPaB

GFibetyüPaB nigbUrNPaBEdndInigqnÞ³rbs;Kat; EdlepþImclna «eFVI[bdivtþn_mankarERbRbÜly:ag

suICeRmA »sRmab;RbeTskm<úCa. edIm,IbEnßmTm¶n;[rwtEtxøaMgkøaeLIgeTot BYkemdwknaMcin)ansgát;

bBa¢ak;BIqnÞ³rbs;RbCaCnxøÜnfa «nwgvayRbyuT§sµa Rbekoksµa ehIybnþd¿eNIreTAmux» CamYyRbCaCn

km<úCaCanic©15.

GaRs½ydUcenH enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1976 RbeTskm<úCa)ankøayeTACaktþamYyénPaBtantwg

d¾cm,grvagcinnigevotNam b:uEnþkarFøak;cuHCalMdab;lMedaynUvTMnak;TMngrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr)an

cab;epþImmantaMgBImunmkemø:H. edayBit taMgBIC½yCmñHrbs;RkúghaNUyelIPaKxagt,Úg ehtupl

EdlbNþal[mankarGak;Gn;citþnwgKña)anRtÚveKTuk[knøgputeTAedayrkRckedaHRsaymineXIj.

karGak;Gn;citþTaMgenaH)annaMbNþal[mankarExVgKMnitKñaCasMxan;xagEpñkneya)ay nigmenaKmviC¢a

rvagbkSTaMgBIrpgEdr.

karsRmúkRseTAekaH®s<atlI

RbEhlbIs)aþh_muneBlEdlTg;kumµúynIsþminTan;bgðÚteLIgelITIRkúgéRBnKr EdleRkaymk

RtÚvdak;eQµaHfµIfaRkúghUCImijenaH kgT½Bm:arInevotNamxageCIg)andeNþImkan;kab;RbCuMekaH®s<atlI

CakmµsiT§iEdlkan;kab;edaykgT½BevotNamxagt,ÚgrhUtmkTl;nwgeBlenH. RkúghaNUyhak;dUcCa

dwgxøÜnmunfa sm½ytP¢ab;¬Gnþrkal¦ nigminc,as;las;mYynwgsNæitmanbnÞab;BIC½yCmñH ehIyman

bMNgykeRbóbelIRbeTscinkñúgkareFVICam©as;ekaHTaMgLay EdlkMBugTamTaredayRbeTsTaMgBIr.

enAéf¶TI5 Ex]sPa viTüúhaNUy)anRbkasfa enAéf¶TI11 Exemsa nigéf¶CabnþbnÞab;mkeTot «kgT½B

rMedaHnigkgm:arIn »)an «rMedaH »ekaHcMnYnR)aMmYyénRbCuMekaH®s<atlITaMgRsúg. BIréf¶eRkaymk sar

B½t’manpøÚvkareQµaH Saigon Giai Phong ¬éRBnKrRtÚvrMedaH¦ )ane)aHBum<pSay EpnTIBN’mYyrbs;

RbeTsevotNam EdlmanRbCuMekaH®s<atlIpg b:uEnþ RbCuMekaH):ar:aEsl Edlkan;kab;edayBYkcin

k¾manKUrbBa©ÚlCaEpñkmYyénTwkdIevotNamEdr.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg20

Page 31: Brother enemy

Rkúgeb:kaMg)anrkSaPaBes¶óms¶at;mYycMeBaH]bTÞvehtuenH. CaeRcInqñaMeRkaymk ´RKan;Et

)andwgBImat;rbs;elak lIn etkVan CaGñkeqøIyqøgénTIPñak;garB½t’mansuInhYnUvGVIEdlCamenaseBa©tna

d¾RCaleRCArbs;BYkcinenAeBlenaHfa «eyIgbRmúgxøÜncakecjBIRkúghaNUyedIm,IeTAeFVITsSnkic©

mYyenAPaKxagt,ÚgEdleTIbrMedaH TukNaCaeyIg)andwgdMNwgsþIBIkardeNþImykRbCuMekaHNansa

(Nansha)-)araMgehARs<atlIk¾eday. ´GYledIm-kniyayElgecj ». edaybMeBjmuxgarkñúgry³

eBlCaeRcInqñaMenAkariyal½yénTIPñak;garB½t’mancinfµIRbcaMTIRkúghaNUy elak lIg etkVan KWCa

smaCikmñak;énRkúmGñkkaEstkumµúynIsþelIkdMbUgkMBugsñak;enAkñúgTIRkúgenH Edl)aneTAeFVITsSnkic©

enAPaKxagt,ÚgevotNamnaEx]sPa qñaM1975. Kat;)anbEnßmfa kareFVIRbtibtþikarrbs;evotNam

manlkçN³CaGMeBIk,t;mYyrwtEtF¶n;F¶rCagkarEdlRbeTsevotNamTTYlsÁal;GFibetyürbs;cinelI

RbCuMekaH®s<atlIBImuneTAeTot. lIn )anniyayBenøIsbnþic edayminCMTas;edayCak;lak;cMeBaHkar

TamTarrbs;cin RkúghaNUy)ansEmþg[dwgedaysBaØaepSg² nUvlkçxNÐTaMgLayrbs;xøÜnsþIBIbBaða

enH. enAExmifuna qñaM1974 v:ag Tug )anRbkasR)ab;GñkkaEstéfmñak;fa «GasuIGaeKñy_CakmµsiT§i

rbs;RbCaCnenAGasuIGaeKñy_>>>. RbeTscinBuMEmnCaRbeTsmYyenAGasuIGaeKñy_eT edayehtuenH

karTamTarrbs;cinelIEdnsmuRTk¾BuMRtwmRtÚvEdr »16. enACMnan;EdlmanesckþIRbkasenH evotNam

xageCIgenAminTan;RbúgeRbóbdeNþImPaKxagt,Úgedayqab;rh½sdUecñHeT. b:uEnþ kalebIkgT½Brbs; FIv

cab;epþImbgðaj[eXIjnUvsBaØacuHexSayPøam vac,as;Nas;fa RkúghaNUyminenAQres¶óm»béd

eLIy ehIyk¾minbeNþay[RbeTscinkan;kab;RbCuMekaHRs<atlI dUcEdlcinFøab;)ankan;kab;RbCuMekaH

):ar:aEslkalBIqñaMmunEdr.

RbCuMekaHTaMgBIrenH EdlsßitenAsmuRTcinxagt,ÚgrYmmanekaHtUc²RbEhlmYyryhasib Edl

suT§EtekaHmanEtdIhuyep¥ag/ CYrfµb:RbHTwknigpñÚkxSac;. GñkensaTcin/ evotNam nig hVIlIBIn )an

RbmUlCIkakRtI ¬sRmab;eFVICaCI¦ nigsMbukRtecokkaMenATIenaHtaMgBIeRcInstvtSr_mkehIysRmab;

CamuxmðÚbsRmaMgmYyEdlCalkçN³BiessénmðÚbrbs;cin. tMbn;enHcab;manplRbeyaCn_fµImYyenA

edImTsvtSr_70 enAeBlEdlmankarcab;epþImrukrkEr:eRbgkatenAtMbn;GasuIGaeKñy_. karkMNt;fa

RbeTsNamYyRtÚvmanGFibetyüelIekaHTaMgenH BuMEmnCabBaðaFmµtamYyeLIy. RbeTscinEdl

TamTarRbCuMekaHenHTaMgmUl )anRTRTg;CMhrrbs;xøÜnedayTLðIkrN_epSg²xagburaNvtßúviTüanigRbvtþi

sa®sþ ¬mankarlukluyBIr-bIelIkmkehIyrbs;GaNikCncin¦. b:uEnþ kñúgry³eBlCaeRcInstvtSr_

mkehIy TaMgRbeTscin TaMgRbeTsevotNam TaMgRbeTshVIlIBIn k¾minEdlnwkKitkan;kab;ekaHTaMgenH

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 21

Page 32: Brother enemy

yUrGEgVgEdr. rhUtmkdl;dMNac;TsvtSr_50 rdæaPi)alevotNamxagt,Úg k¾ecosvagmintv:aCMTas;

nwgkarTamTarrbs;cineLIy. cMENkevotNamxageCIgEdlCasm<½n§mitþEpñkmenaKmviC¢a nigEdl

TTYlplRbeyaCn_BICMnYyrbs;cin k¾yl;eXIjdUcKña. karb:HTgÁicKñaelIkdMbUgrvagRkúgéRBnKr nig

Rkúgeb:kaMgsþIBIbBaðaekaHTaMgenaH KWmanmktaMgBIqñaM1959emø:H ehIyedaykarmincg;niyay

rbs;xøÜnrYmpSMpg RkúghaNUy)anecosvagedayRby½tñRbEygkñúgkarKaMRTRbeTscin.

RbtibtþikarenARbCuMekaH):ar:aEsl

enAqñaM1972 rbbrbs;RbFanaFibtI FIv )ancab;epþImcuHkic©snüaCamYyRkúmh‘uneRbgbreTs

nana edIm,ICaRbeyaCn_dl;karsagsg;kEnøgxYgeRbgCaeRcInkEnøg kñúgeKalbMNgeFVIGaCIvkmµEr:eRbg

EdlGacmanCayfaehtu. enHCasBaØaEdleFVI[BYkcinRBÜy)armÖ eRBaHbBaðaRbCuMekaH)anelceLIg

CafµIenAeBlenHPøam. enATIbMput BYkcinRKan;Etbgðaj[eXIjvtþmanrbs;xøÜnenAtamCYrekaHGMhVIRTIt

énRbCuMekaH):ar:aEslb:ueNÑaH xN³EdlevotNamxagt,Úg )anrkSaTukkgT½BtUc²enAelIbNþaekaHxøH

énCYrekaHeRksSg;. enAExemsaqñaMdEdl edayRbqaMgtv:anwgkarlukluyrbs;bNþanavaGaemrikaMg

mkkñúgEdnTwkénRbCuMekaH):ar:aEsl Rkúgeb:kaMg)anpþÜcepþImKMnitmYy Edlhak;dUcCamaneKalbMNg

begáInkarKaMRTrbs;GaemrikaMgcMeBaHkarTamTarEdndIrbs;xøÜn KWBIrExbnÞab;BITsSnkic©CaRbvtþisa®sþ

rbs;RbFanaFibtI nicsun enARbeTscin. edayvinicä½yerOgenHtamkarcgcaMrbs;Kat; elak hg;rI

KIsSúIghÁ½r minmanbMNgCMTas;cMeBaHPaBsmehtusmplénkarTamTarrbs;cineLIy eTaHbICa

evotNamxagt,Úg manGPimanHcg;)anRbCuMekaH):ar:aEsl ehIyEdlBYkeKFøab;)ankan;kab;mYyEpñk

k¾eday. elak KIsSúIghÁ½r )anR)ab;[BYkcindwgfa «edayminTan;niyaydl;CMhrpøÚvkarrbs;shrdæ

GaemriksþIBIbBaðaEdnsmuRT GMNwHteTA kgm:arInGaemrikaMgnwgRtÚvTTYlbBa¢amin[eTAEk,rRbCuMekaH

):ar:aEsleT y:agehackñúgcm¶ayBIekaH 20KILÚEm:Rt»17.

RkúghaNUyehIyTMngCaRkúgéRBnKrEdr mindwgGVITaMgGs;BIkarsnüarbs;GaemrikaMg. enA

éf¶TI26 ExFñÚ qñaM1973 evotNamxageCIg)an[dMNwgeTArdæaPi)alcinGMBIeKalbMNgrbs;xøÜnedIm,I

epþImeFVIkarcrcaCamYyRkúmh‘uneRbgGuItalImYy edIm,IrukrkeRbgenAQUgsmuRTtugkwg. enAéf¶TI11

Exmkra Rkúgeb:kaMg)anTamTarCapøÚvkarnUvekaHTaMgGs;EdlsßitenAsmuRTcinxagt,Úg. bYnéf¶eRkaymk

kgT½Brbs;cin)anRbmUlpþúMKñaeLIgeBjelIekaHeRksSg;. evotNam xagt,Úg)anxMRbwgvayrujRcan

BYkcin[ecjeTAvij b:uEnþ BYkeK)anTTYlrgkartbtmYyEdlmankarerobcMy:agRby½tñRbEyg.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg22

Page 33: Brother enemy

enAéf¶TI19 Exmkra RbtibtþikarrYmKñamYyrvagkgGakascr nigkgm:arInrbs;cin )anbgçM[T½BCMnYy

rbs;evotNamxagt,ÚgCemøósecjBIekaHnana ehIydak;ekaHTaMgenaH[sßitenAeRkamkarRtÜtRta

rbs;cin. eKniyayfa shrdæGaemrik)anCMTas;edaykarbdiesFy:agKYrsmmYycMeBaHsMeNIsuM[

CYyrbs;RbFanaFibtI FIv. mnÞIrbBa©ekaN ¬b:g;taehÁan¦ )anGHGagfa xøÜnBuM)anTTYlsMeNINamYy

RbePTenHeT ehIykgnavacrTI7rbs;GaemrikaMg )ansßitenAedayELkBIkarRbTUsr:ayenH. TIRbwkSa

GaemrikaMgmñak;EdlkMBugbeRmIkarenAkgnavacrrbs;evotNamxagt,Úg ehIyEdlRtÚvcab;xøÜneday

kgT½Bcin )anRtÚvbBa¢ÚneTARkúghugkug edayKµan]bsKÁbnÞab;BI]bTÞvehtuenH. munmankarvayluk

rbs;cin Rkúgeb:kaMg)anR)ab;[RkúghaNUydwgGMBIbMNgrbs;xøÜn edIm,IebIkkarcrcasþIBIbBaðaEdn

smuRT edaysgát;bBa¢ak;BIkarRbqaMgCMTas;rbs;xøÜn cMeBaHkarcab;epþImrukrkeRbgTaMgGs;.

CaeRcInqñaMeRkaymk ÉkGKÁrdæTUtevotNamRbcaMRkúg):arIs elak ém: v:an;bU )anniyayerOg

Gaf’kM)aMgR)ab;´fa RbtibtþikarenARbCuMekaH):ar:aEsl naExmkra qñaM1974 )anbgáCa«GMeBIQøanBan

edayGavuFelIkdMbUgrbs;RbeTscin RbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNam ». b:uEnþ enACMnan;enaH RkúghaNUy

RKan;EtbBa¢ak;fa karedaHRsayCemøaHTwkdId¾sµúKsµajTaMgenHrvagbNþaRbeTsCitxagtRmÚv[manCa

caM)ac;nUvkarRsavRCavBinitüd¾suICeRmAmYy. RkúghaNUy)anbEnßmfa «bNþaRbeTsEdlBak;B½n§

RtÚvEtedaHRsayPaBminRtÚvKñatamry³karcrcakñúgsµartIesµIPaBmYy kareKarBKñaeTAvijeTAmk nig

PaBCaGñkCitxagl¥»18.

esckþIRbkasenAqñaM1974enH EdleFVIeLIgbnÞab;BImankarc,aMgdeNþImRbCuMekaH):ar:aEsl

edayGavuF BitehIyKWCakarriHKn;lak;ButmYyrbs;RbeTscin. b:uEnþ edayEpñkkgT½B nigesdækic©RtÚv

BwgBak;elIRkúgeb:kaMg RkúghaNUyminGacniyayBIerOgenHeRcIneLIy. mYyqñaMeRkaymk CamYynwg

C½yCmñHTaMgRsugmYyenAPaKxagt,Úg rebobniyayrbs;evotNammanlkçN³xusKñaRsLH. BYk

kumµúynIsþevotNam)anbBa¢ak;y:agCak;lak;BIkarRbqaMgCMTas;rbs;xøÜn cMeBaHRbeTscineday)an

RbkasCasaFarN³BI «karrMedaH» ekaHcMnYn6énRbCMuekaH®s<atlI ¬evotNam ehAeRTÓgsa¦. taMgBI

Bak;kNþalTsvtSr_50 PaBminRtÚvKñaCaeRcIn)anelceLIg GMBIerOgceRmókdIxøH²enAtamRBMEdneKak

rvagcinnigevotNam b:uEnþ eTaHCay:agNak¾vaminERbBIl¥eTAGaRkk;Edr. eRkayBIdMeNIrTsSnkic©

rbs; nicsun enARbeTscinnaqñaM1972 bnÞab;mk CamYykarbBa©b;karTmøak;RKab;EbkenAPaKxageCIg

nigkarcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógsnþiPaBRkúg):arIs RkúghaNUy)ancab;epþImBRgwgCMhrrbs;xøÜn

sþIBIbBaðaRBMEdn. edaykEnøgdéTénBiPBelakGt;dwg ]bTÞvehtutUctacCaeRcInenAtamRBMEdn)anpÞúH

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 23

Page 34: Brother enemy

eLIg. tamkarniyay[dwgrbs;cinEdlmanmkCaeRkay eKvaytémøfa mankarRbyuT§KñaRsal²

CagmYyry)aøyelIkenAqñaM1974. bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHrbs;RkúghaNUyenAPaKxagt,Úg cMnYnénkar

b:HTgÁicKña)anekIneLIgbYndg19.

rvagxøaXµúMnignaK

vaCasMeNIccMGkénRbvtþisa®sþ eRBaHbEnßmBIelIshrdæGaemrik KWRbeTscinEdlcaj;

s®gÁamenAevotNam. CamYynwgkardkfyrbs;GaemrikaMg enAqñaM1975 KMnitEdlenAdk;Cab;Canic©

rbs;GñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinxagEpñkneya)ayhak;dUcCaCitelcCarUbrag ³ RbeTsevotNammYyEdl

xøaMgBUEk nigrYmKñaeLIgvij kMBugbgáehtunwgcintamRBMEdnPaKxagt,Úgrbs;xøÜnnigkMBugcUlédcUleCIg

CamYysRtÚvsøab;rs;rbs;xøÜnenAPaKxageCIgKW¬sUevot¦.

BiPBelakTaMgmUl)anrkSaTukkñúgcitþnUvrUbPaBepSg²EdlKYr[cg;emIlénkardYlrlMrbs;mha

GMNacGaemrikaMgenA\NÐÚcin ³ ÉkGKÁrdæTUtGaemrikenAkm<úCaelak hSn hánF½r eDon kMBugcakecjBI

RbeTsenHeday»bTg;Catirbs;xøÜnEdldak;kñúgfg;)øasIÞkmYy ]T§mÖaKcRkCaeRcIneRKÓgkMBugCemøós

mnusSecjBITIRkúgéRBnKr ehIyehaHeTAcuHctelInavarbs;GaemrikaMgEdlrg;caMenAÉmhasmuRT

):asIuhiVk. enAeBlEdlkardYlrlMenHekIteLIgedaymin)anRbúgeRbóbTukCamunRbeTscin)anRtÚveFIV

[xVl;citþEmnETnedaysar\Ti§Bl «sgÁmcRkBtiþniym » rbs;sUevotenAGasIuEdlkan;EtrIkFMeLIg².

taMgBITsSnkic©rbs; nicsun [RbFanaFibtIGaemrikBIrGaNtiþBIqñaM1968-1972 b:uEnþGaNtiþTI2kan;

GMNac)anEt2qñaMb:ueNÑaH edaysarmanerOgGaRsUv «Watergate» ehIy)ansMulaElgBItMENgenAqñaM

1974-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb] Rkúgeb:kaMg)anvaytémøedayRkEsEPñkeRCamERCgnUvvtþmanrbs;

GaemrikkñúgtMbn;énBiPBelakenH BitehIy elIkElgEtenAétv:an;. kardkfyTaMgrhn;rbs;BYk

GaemrikaMg)aneFVI[BYkcinnwkP½y)armÖEdr eRBaHfaGMNwHteTA «kEnøgTMenr »enH c,as;CaRtÚvRkúgmUsÁÚ

EdlCaGñkpÁt;pÁg;smÖareyaFad¾sMxan;bMput[RbeTsevotNamcUlkan;kab;Pøam. éf¶TI29 Exemsa

qñaM1975 kñúgeBlEdlRbtibtþikar «Frequent Wind » RbwgERbglubbM)at;søaksñamcugeRkayén

vtþmanGaemrikaMgenAevotNamenaH d¿NwgsMxan;Epñkneya)aybreTsrbs;TIPñak;garsarB½t’mancinfµI

)anniyaybBaäitbeBaäógeTArkkareFVIsmyuT§énkgnavacrshPaBsUevotEdlepþImeFVIkñúgmhasmuRT

):asuIhVikRBmeBlCamYyKñaenaHEdr. bnÞab;BI)anerobrab;bBa©ÚlnUvvtþmanénkgnavacrsUevotenA

cMNucepSg²énBiPBelak edayelIkeLIgCaBiessBIRBwtþikarN_én «kareRCótcUlmYyEdlKµanGVIGac

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg24

Page 35: Brother enemy

Tb;)ankñúgeRCay m:aLaka ¬Malacca CaeRCayenAcenøaHRbeTsm:aeLsuInig\NÐÚensuI¦ rhUtmkdl;PaK

xagt,ÚgevotNam»enaH TIPñak;garenH)ansEmþgnUvesckþIsgÇwmfa smyuT§EdlkMBugRbRBwtþeTAenH rwt

EtCYyBRgwg[mankarRbúgRby½tñxøaMgeLIgEfmeTot «RbqaMgnwgeRKaHfñak;epSg²énkarQøanBan nig

karvatTIrbs;sgÁmcRkBtþi »20.

RbFan em:A/ elak CUti nig CU eGnLay BitCarevosrévbBa¢ÚnsarTUrelxGbGrsresIrmYy

eTARkúghaNUycMeBaH «d¿Nwgl¥ »TaMgenH b:uEnþemdwknaMcin)aneFVIkarkt;smÁal;pgEdrfa C½yCmñHrbs;

evotNamCaP½sþútagbEnßmmYyénPaBminecHcaj;rbs;s®gÁamRbCaCn enHCaTsSn³mYyEdlelIk

eLIgCaerOy²edayRbeTscin. bTGtßaFib,aymYyénTinanub,vtþiRbCaCncuHéf¶TI1 Ex]sPa

qñaM1975 )anniyayBenøIsRCúlhYsehtukñúgkarbenßaktémøGMBItYnaTIrbs;sUevot. kaEst)an

sresrfa «C½yCmñHd¾FMeFgrbs;evotNam)anbgðaj[eXIjCafµImþgeTotfa GVIEdlkMNt;C½yCmñH

b¤braC½yKWRbCaCn nigkarKaMRTrbs;RbCaCnenHÉg BuMEmnedaysareRKÓgsa®sþavuFenaHeT ».

niyaymü:ageTotKWBuMEmnrfeRkaH kaMRCÜcmIsuIlsUevoteT Edlpþl;C½yCmñH[evotNamenaH b:uEnþKW

BitCakarcUlrYmrbs;RbCaCn.

karR)ab;[RbúgRby½tñTaMgenH bgðaj[eXIjBIPaBcaM)ac;sRmab;Rkúgeb:kaMgEdlsgS½y «BYk

esIerIniym »rbs;evotNambc©úb,nñ Edlsakl,gGnuBaØat[mankartaMgmUldæanT½Brbs;sUevot

CafñÚrnwgCMnYymYyEdlnwgmkdl;xagmux. RbeTscin)ankt;smÁal;RbkbedaykarRBÜy)armÖnUvkar

eTAdl;énKN³RbtiPUeyaFasUevotmYyRkúm eRkaykardYlrlMRkúgéRBnKrmindl;mYys)aþh_pg nig

karepþImcUlctKµandac; nUvnavaCMnYjsUevottambNþakMBg;EpenAPaKxagt,ÚgevotNamCaeRcInkEnøg.

db;R)aMéf¶eRkaymk Rkúgeb:kaMg)ansEmþg[dwgCasaFarN³nUvkarekþARkhayrbs;xøÜnCaelIkdMbUg

edayniyayR)ab;KN³RbtiPUCb:unmYyRkúmEdleFVIdMeNIrqøgkat;RbeTscinfa BYksUevot)an «esñI

edayetOnbgçM »[rdæaPi)albdivtþbeNþaHGasnñevotNamxagt,ÚgGnuBaØat[xøÜneRbIR)as;GtItmUldæan

nanarbs;kgT½BGaemrikaMg»21.

enAExkkáda qñaM1975 eday)anCYb g:U eDon GñkkarTUtevotNamTTYlbnÞúkEpñkB½t’manén

RksYgkarbreTs ¬eRkaymkCaÉkGKÁrdæTUtRbcaMRbeTskm<úCa¦ ´)ansYrKat;fa etIBitb¤eT erOg

EdlBYksUevotTamTareRbIR)as;GtItmUldæankgT½BGaemrikaMgenaH?. RbEhledayekþARkhaypg

Kat;)aneqøIyR)ab;´edayeBalBaküFM²fa «elakÉgKitfa BYksUevotGacTamTarmUldæanT½Bnana

EdlmankñúgRbeTseyIgR)akdEmnb¤? munsYrGVIk¾edaycMeBaHmitþPkþimñak; RtÚvyl;[c,as;BIGVIEdlxøÜn

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 25

Page 36: Brother enemy

KitenaHpg. ehtuGVIBYksUevotGacTamTar ¬mUldæanmYy¦ CamYynwgkøinGesac×RKb;Ebby:agCa

cRkBtþniymEdlcgP¢ab;nwgBaküenHpgenaH?». b:uEnþKat;)anbEnßmfa navarbs;sUevotmansiT§icUl

ctkMBg;EpkaMr:aj;)an ¬GtItmUldæannavacrrbs;Gaemrik¦ ebIsinCaRtÚvkarkñúglkçxNÐGnueRKaHdUcKña

cMeBaHnavaTaMgLayEdlmkBIbNþaRbeTsCamitþEdr. R)aMmYyqñaMeRkaymk GñkkarTUtevotNamdéT²

eTot)anTTYlsÁal;cMeBaHmux´fa enAqñaM1975 RkúgmUsÁÚ BitCamanbMNgeFVI[)anseRmckartaMg

zbnP½NÐeyaFaR)akdEmn b:uEnþ\t)ankar. mü:ageTot sUevotRtÚvrg;caMdl;eTAbYnqñaMÉeNaH eTIb

)anQñHkñúgkarCECkKñaBIerOgenH eBalKWeBlEdlCemøaHrvagcinnigevotNamkan;EtrIkFMeLIg².

eTaHCamanmUldæankgT½Brbs;sUevotb¤Kµank¾eday k¾karERbRbÜlPøam²éntulüPaBkmøaMgkñúg

PUmiPaKGasuIGaeKñy_ )aneFVI[RbeTscinRBÜy)armÖxøaMgEdr. CamYykgT½Bd¾eRcInsem,ImnigEdleCak

CaMkñúgcm,aMg CamYynwgbrimaNeRKÓgsBVavuFd¾sn§wksn§ab;rbs;GaemrikaMgEdlrwbGUs)anBIPaKxag

t,Úg eBlenH RkúghaNUy)ankøayeTACamhaGMNacfñak;TImYyenA\NÐÚcinCaeRsc kñúgkardeNþImyk

«RbTIb » kgQanmuxbdivtþmkkan;vijmþg. pÞúyeTAvijedayeFVIkarcMGkbBaÄWcitþGMBIkarRBÜy)armÖ

rbs;cincMeBaHlkçN³RbkbedayeRKaHfñak;edaysar «kEnøgTMenr » EdleTIbnwgekItmanfµI²kñúgtMbn;

vicarNkfamYyrbs;kaEstjinhSin cuHéf¶TI21 Ex]sPa qñaM1975 sb,aycitþnwgkarvinas

GnþrayExSbnÞat;karBarrbs;GaemrikaMgenHNas;. vicarNkfa)aneFVIGFib,ayfa C½yCmñHCaRbvtþi

sa®sþrbs;RbCaCnevotNam)anCYyeFVI[mankarpøas;bþÚrTaMgRsug nUvtulüPaBénkmøaMgTaMgGs;

kñúgBiPBelak>>>. GMNwHteTAlkçN³sm,tþiRKb;Ebby:ag)anRtÚvRbmUlpþú¿edIm,I[RbCaCnPUmiPaK

rbs;eyIgrMedaHxøÜnBIPaBcMNuHeKenAcMeBaHmuxcRkBtþinana22. RbkarenH Rkúgeb:kaMgBuMyl;RcL¿esaH

eLIy. edayesckþIRbkasEbbenaH)aneFVI[RkúghaNUyTamTarfaxøÜnCaGñkmantYnaTIdwknaMkñúgd¿eNIr

cat;Ecgkarbdivtþn_enAGasuIGaeKñy_.

´Føab;manTsSn³TUeTAmYyGMBIkarTTYlGarmµN_sb,aykñúgcitþ EdlsßitmanmYyry³enATIRkúg

haNUy kñúg»kasénkaredIrTsSnamYyEdl´)aneFVIenArdUvekþAqñaM1975. kñúgTIRkúg ´KµaneXIjGVI

eRkABIkgT½BRbdab;GavuFEdledIredrdasRKb;TIkEnøg nigeBareBjeTAedayb½NÑbiTpSayCasaFarN³

EdlGMBavnav[manbdivtþn_TUTaMgBiPBelakeLIy. RkúghaNUy)anpþl;nUvkarsb,aykñúgPaBs¶b;

s¶at;. BiPBmnusSmYyEdlpÞúyKñaTaMgcitþTaMgeføIm )anxNÐEckrdæFanIPaKxageCIgBIRkúgéRBnKr Edl´

Elgrvl; cMeBlkMBugmanvibtþieBlkMBugRCÜlRcbl;edaysUrkg rMBgényanynþnigPaBGnaFib-

etyü. manrbs;tictYcNas;Edlpøas;bþÚrenATIRkúghaNUy taMgBIkarcakecjrbs;BYk)araMgBI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg26

Page 37: Brother enemy

\NÐÚcinkalBIémÖmYyqñaMmun. TIRkúgmanPaBcMNas;RbkbedayPaBsmrmü CamYymhavifInanaEdl

manmøb;RtQwgRtéQ nigbwgTaMgLayrbs;xøÜnEdlmanlkçN³ ekSmkSanþ/ Pabs¶b;s¶at;énvifInana

EdleTIbnwgeFVI[)at;sNþab;Fñab;edaysUrsMeLgrgMdac;²BIKña énhVÚgeTacRkyany:ageRcIn EtTIRkúg

)anbgðaj[eXIjbriyakasTukcitþmYy\tP½yRBÜy. enAeBlEdleyIgsnÞnaKñaenAkñúgGKarRksYg

karbreTsEdlmanrcnab½TµGaNaniKm gU:eDon )ansURt[´sþab;nUvkRmgkMNaBüsm½ystvtSr_TI15

mYyEdlsresrbnÞab;BIkarcakecjBIevotNaménraCvgSmij CaGñklukluycugeRkayfa ³

ElgmanRtIqøamkñúgsmuRT

ehIyk¾ElgmanstVsahavelIdIEdr

épÞemXmansPaBRsLHl¥

eBlenHCaeBlEdlRtÚvksagsnþiPaB sRmab;ry³eBldb;Ban;qñaMeTAmuxeTot.

evotNam)anRtÚveFVI[vigs‘ugnwgetCédkñúgs®gÁamrbs;eKenAeLIy. kñúgeBlevlad¾exµAggwt

éns®gÁam enAeBlEdlynþehaHeb-52rbs;GaemrikaMgTmøak;RKab;EbkmkelIPaKxageCIg ehIy

EdlyuvCnrab;Ban;nak;ecjdMeNIreTAvayRbyuT§enAPaKxagt,ÚgedayminEdlvilRtLb;mkvijenaH

kRmmanGñkNaEdlsgÇwmrs;ranCIvit)anyUrbgÁÜr edIm,IemIlC½yCmñHEdlniyayTukCamuneday hU

CImij Nas;. bnÞab;BIkars‘URTaMkñúgs®gÁamnigTTYl)anC½yCmñHelIRbeTsmhaGMNacd¾xøaMgputelxén

PBEpndI GVI²TaMgGs;hak;dUcCaGacekItman. GMNwHteTARbeTsevotNam)anRbúgeRbóbCaeRsc

edIm,Ikan;kab;kEnøgnaMmuxeKeLIgvij ehIyQmmuxttaMgnwgbNþasRtÚvk¾dUcbNþamitþrbs;xøÜn nigGac

niyayedaysMeLgpÞal;rbs;xøÜnEfmeTot.

edayxVl;xVaycitþ RbeTscin)aneqøótTajRbeyaCn_kñúg»kasbuNüxYbelIkTI30 rbs;RbeTs

evotNamxageCIg edIm,I[dMNwgBYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUyedaypÞal;GMBIkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;xøÜn. RbeTs

cin)ancat;[]tþmesnIy_ ecn suIlan smaCikkariyal½yneya)aydwknaMKN³RbtiPUmYyeTAcUlrYm

BiFIbuNüEdlerobcMenARkúghaNUy. ecn CamnusSmanmaDRkGajmñak;. CaembBa¢akareyaF

PUmiPaKeb:kaMg Kat;)andwknaMbBa¢akgT½BcinedaypÞal; kñúg»kasmankarb:HTgÁicKñatamRBMEdncin-

sUevotkalBIqñaM1969. dUecñH Kat;BitCamnusSmanGMeNayTanedIm,IrMB£kRkúghaNUy[Rbúg

Rby½tñRbqaMgnwgeRKaHfñak;Edlbgðaj[eXIjedayRkúgmUsÁÚenAGasuI. enAkñúg «»kasBiFIbuNümYy

EdlRbRBwtþeTAenAkñúgeragcRkEdkEfb éf egVón (Thai Nguyen) EdlsßabnaedayBYkcin/ EdlRtÚvTmøak;

RKab;EbkkñúgGMLúgs®gÁamehIyEdlksageLIgvijedayCMnYyrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg ecn )anniyay

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 27

Page 38: Brother enemy

sresIrBIkarRbyuT§ «RbqaMgGnutþrPaB » ¬CaPasaeRbIkñúgmCÄdæanedayELkKWRbqaMgsUevot¦kñúgBiPB

elak. Kat;)anrMB£kBYkm©as;pÞHfa «karvayRbyuT§rbs;bNþamhaGMNacputelxedIm,IGnutþrPaB »

niyaymü:ageTot KWkarb:unb:grbs;sUevot edIm,Ikan;kab;kEnøg TMenr )anERbkøayeTACasahaveLIg²

ehIyEdlvabegáInnUveRKaHfñak;epSg²éns®gÁamEfmeTot. enAeBlEdl ecn eTAdl;RkúghaNUy

enAéf¶TI31 ExsIha naykrdæm®nþI paM v:an;dug )anmkTTYledaycab;»brwtKat;enAeCIgCeNþIrynþehaH

eTAtamRbéBNImYyEdlmanb£sKl;taMgBICMnan;yuT§samKÁIPaBem:øH. b:uEnþ esckþIKYrsmnigkar

eBalGHGagBIÉkraCüCati BMuEmnCakareFVI[RsúHRsÜlnwgKñaedayxanmin)anenaHeT ³ kñúgesckþIray

karN_Edle)aHBum<pSayedaysarB½t’manRkúghaNUy karniyayeyagBIGnutþrPaBkñúgsnÞrkfa

rbs; ecn )anRtÚvdkecalTaMgGs;. Rbvtþisa®sþminePøc «»kasmYyedIm,IykeRbóbelIRkúgeb:kaMg

eLIy » cMENkviTüúmUsÁÚ)ancab;fñak; ecn edayehAskmµPaBrbs;Kat;fa manlkçN³ «bgáehtuxag

neya)ay »bnþic. GñkeFVIGtßaFib,ay )anbnþfa ³ «RbCaCnevotNamecHeFVIkarEbgEckrvagsRtÚv

mñak; nigmitþmñak; » nigecH[témøcMeBaHkarKaMRTd¾mantémø nigminKitRbeyaCn_pÞal;xøÜnEdlshPaB

sUevotnaMmkpþl;[eK23.

kartbtKñaCasaFarN³rvagRkúgmUsÁÚnigeb:kaMgsþIBIbBaðacg;dwgfa GñkNamYyEdlRkúghaNUy

nwgeRCIserIsedIm,Idak;xøÜneRkam»vaTKWBitCamanRbpñÚlminl¥sRmab;eCaKC½yénneya)ayrbs;evot

Nam EdlseRmcdak;xøÜndac;edayELkBICemøaHrvagmhaGMNacCabgb¥ÚnTaMgBIrpgnigsuMCMnYypg.

éf¶TI22 ExkBaØa enAeBlEdl eL yn; nig eL faj;gI cab;epþImeFVIdMeNIreTARkúgeb:kaMg edIm,IGrKuN

BYkemdwknaMcin nigsuM[bnþCMnYyEfmeTot vaelceLIgy:agc,as;fa PaBbuinRbsb;eRbIl,icklrbs;

evotNamnwgRtÚvBiesaFemIly:agtwgEtgminxan. mYyéf¶munkarecjdMeNIrrbs;GñkTaMgBIr dMNwg

mYyEdlecjmkBIRkúgeb:kaMg)an[dwgCamunBIRbePTsunÞrkfa EdlBYkemdwknaMcinR)afñacg;sþab;BImat;

rbs; eL yn; pÞal;. enAeRkayeBlCYbKñatamkarNat;mYyCamYyRbFan em:A nig etg s‘avBIg GtIt

naykrdæm®nþIGg;eKøs eGdvWd hIt )anRbkaskñúgsnñisITkaEstmYyfa bMNgR)afñarbs;RkúgmUsÁÚEdl

RBmTTYlmUldæaneyaFaCaeRcInenARbeTsevotNamhak;dUcCaeFVI[ em:A ERbeTACamnusSGMBl;kñúgcitþ.

b:uEnþKat;yl;fa RbeTscinmineCO BI\T§iBlyUrGEgVgmYyrbs;RkúgmUsÁÚelIRbeTsevotNameLIy

y:agehackñúgry³eBlEvgEdr RBmTaMgkarTTYl)anmUldæannavacrpg. tamry³ hIt KWRtg;enH

ÉgCasBaØamYyEdleKGacyl;kan; Etc,as;BIbMNgrbs;RkúghaNUy. \LÚvenHvadl;eBlEdl eL

yn; RtÚveFVI[CMhrrbs;RbeTscinrwtEtrwgmaMeLIgkñúgsuTidæiniymrEGgRby½tñenHehIy.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg28

Page 39: Brother enemy

karepÁInbM)ak;muxmYycMeBaHRbeTscin

karTTYl eL yn; enARkúgeb:kaMgnaéf¶TI22 ExkBaØa qñaM1975 RbEhlCaminsUvGFikGFm dUc

karTTYl exov sMpn nig eGog sarI kalBIExmuneLIy. enAeBlcuHBIelIynþehaH yn; RtÚv)anTTYl

eday etg s‘avBIg nig\sSrCnl,Il,ajmYyRkúmEdlsuT§EtCaemdwknaMCan;x<s;. yn; )anedIrRtg;

CaRbéBNIeTArkCYrkgT½BrMedaHRbCaCnEdlQrCarbgkitþiys/ TTYl)ac;páanigr)aMsVaKmn_EdlsEmþg

edayRkúmyuvCneb:kaMg. etg EdlkaleNaHGayu71qñaM ¬søab;enAqñaM1997kñúgCnµayu93qñaM¦

kalBImunFøab;RtÚvBYkqµaMRkhmRbmafkatTan [qµaMRkhmCaclnayuvCncinEdl em:A begáIteLIgsRmab;

karBarbdivtþvb,Fm’enARbeTscinkñúgGMLúgqñaM1966-1969 -kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb] edaycat;Tuk

faCa «GñkdwkmuxlT§icRkBtþiniym »enaH )anTTYlrgTukçeTasGs;ry³bYnqñaMenAkñúgbnÞayTahanmYy kñúg

zan³CaGñklagsm¥atsalbriePaK)ayrbs;nayTahanenATIenaH. RtÚveFVI[mannItism,TaeLIgvij

eday CU eGnLay enAqñaM1973 karTTYleFVIbdisNæarkic© eL yn; RbEhlCakarelcmuxcugeRkay

rbs;Kat;CasaFarN³ehIyemIleTAmunnwgeCaKCtarasIrbs;Kat;Føak;cuHCafµIeTot. elITIlan eTon

Ganem:n enARkúgeb:kaMg eKeXIjmaneKamBN’RkhmnigBN’TwkmasFM² Tg;CatinigTg;CValaes¥ksáH

Edlbgðaj[eXIjBImitþPaBrvagRbCaCnTaMgBIr. b:uEnþ briyakasrIkrayERbeTACaesaHkeRkaHPøam

mYyrMeBc kñúgBiFICb;elogCUnePJóv. etg )anEføgsunÞrkfasVaKmn_mYyEdlmanTRmg;Ca «Fm’eTsna »

sþIBIKuNvibtþiepSg²énneya)ay «GnutþrPaBniym ». kñúgkarvinicä½yBImitþPaBrvagevotNam-sUevot

etg )anecosvagminniyayBIBYksUevotcM²eLIy edaycUlcitþelIkeLIgCaTUeTABIBYkmhaGMNacput

elxCag. etg )aneRkInrMB£kevotNamfa «\LÚvenHmanRbeTskan;EteRcIneLIgdwgxøÜnfa karvay

RbyuT§nwgGnutþrPaBniymrbs;bNþaRbeTsmhaGMNac KWCaParkic©mYysMxan;esµIGayuCIvitrbs;

RbCaCnRKb;RbeTsTaMgGs; ». enAeBlrMB£kBITMnak;TMngepSg²rvagRbeTscinnigevotNam etg

BuMmaneRbIR)as;XøaRbeyaKsRmab;eRbICapøÚvkar ¬EdlesÞIrdUcXøafa «samKÁIs¥itlµÜtdUcbbUrmat;

nigeFµj »¦ eLIy. cMeBaH eLyn; Kat;RtÚv)aneFVI[dwgxøÜneLIgvijfa kar]btßmÖKaMBarnigkarGPivDÆn_

cMNgmitþPaB KWCaplRbeyaCn_sMxan;esµIGayuCIvitrvagRbeTseyIgTaMgBIr24.

yn; BuMmanmuxenABiFICb;elogdMbUgrbs;Kat;kñúgmhasalénvimanRbCaCn EdltubEtglMG

edayeCIgeTonCaeRcIneT.enHCaelIkTImYyehIy Edl eLyn; mkkan;Rkúgeb:kaMgBuMRtwmEtmksuM

C¿nYymYymuxb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþedIm,IbBa¢ak;GHGagBIC¿hrrbs;evotNamEdlrYmKñaEtmYy nigÉkraCü

pg. Kat;)anEføgsresIry:ageRcInBIeCaKC½yrbs;cinkñúgkarksaglT§isgÁmniym. evotNam)an

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 29

Page 40: Brother enemy

sEmþgnUv «menaseBa©tnay:agkk;ekþAbMputnigkardwgKuNy:agRCaleRCApusecjBIRkeGAebHdUgBit²»

cMeBaHC¿nYyrbs;cin. edayKYrsm b:uEnþmuWgm:at; yn; )anKUsbBa¢ak;fa Kat;minyl;Rsbnwg «TsSn³

BiPBelak »rbs;bNþaemdwknaMKat;eT. edaykt;smÁal;fa C½yCmñHrbs;evotNamBuMGacekItmaneT

ebIsinCaKµansmancitþnigC¿nYyd¾sn§wksn§ab; nigd¾mantémørbs;bNþaRbeTssgÁmniymCabgb¥Ún

niyayedayELk KWbøúksUevotEtmþg. yn; )anbnþedayBaküeBcn_rebobenHfa «cMeBaHmUlehtuenH

C½yCmñHrbs;eyIgKWCaC½yCmñHrYmrbs;bNþakmøaMgsgÁmniymEdlRsLaj;ÉkraCüCatiRbCaFib-

etyü nigsnþiPaBkñúgkartsU‘rYmRbqaMgnwgcRkBtþiniymEdlmanGaemrikaMgCaemexøag ». eBaledayxøI

evotNamnwgmincUlrYmCamYyRbeTscinkñúgyuT§nakarRbqaMgshPaBsUevoteLIy. b:uEnþfVId,itEtman

karExVgmtiKñaEpñkneya)ayTaMgenHk¾eday k¾ yn; enAEtTTUcsuMC¿nYyrbs;cin. Kat;)anrMB£kR)ab;

m©as;pÞHfa RbCaCnevotNam «RtÚveFVI[eCOCak;y:agmuWgm:at;fa kñúgsm½ykalfµIenHk¾dUckñúgGtItkal

BYkeKnwgenAEtTTYlKuNRbeyaCn_BIkarKaMRTd¾kk;ekþAnigCMnYy d¾eRcInsn§wksn§ab; »rbs;RbeTscin

Canic©25. enARkúghaNUy TIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam)anhammin[pSaykñúgesckþIraykarN_rbs;

Kat; nUvkarniyayeyagTaMgGs;EdlelIkeLIgeday etg sþIBIGnutþrPaBniymrbs;mhaGMNacput

elxnanaeT.

yn; enAEteFVImindwgminB¤cMeBaHTLðIkrN_epSg²rbs;RbeTscinEdlCaplénkarBRgwgrbs;Rkúg

eb:kaMgeTAelIbBaðaC¿nYyxagEpñkesdækic©. R)aMs)aþh_mun eLfaj;gI EdlBYkcindak;rhsSnamfa «sµÚm

yack » edaysarEtkareFVIdMeNIrCajwkjab;rbs;Kat;eTATIRkúgeb:kaMgenaH)aneFVId¿eNIrmkrdæFanI

cinCafµImþgeTot edIm,IesñIsuMC¿nYyBIRbeTscin26. enAExmifuna qñaM1973 enAeBlEdl CU eGnLay

pþl;eyabl;[ yn; bBaÄb;karvayRbyuT§enAPaKxagt,Úgry³eBlBIrqñaMenaHCafñÚrmkvij CU )ansnüa

fanwgbnþC¿nYy[evotNamry³eBlR)aMqñaMeTotelImUldæanénC¿nYyqñaM1973. b:uEnþenAéf¶TI13 Ex

sIha qñaM1975 mtirbs;Cnmñak;manlkçN³xusEbøkTaMgRsug. gI )aneTAsYrsuxTukç CU EdlkMBug

Rtdrxül;CitputdegðImeTAehIy. tamesckþIraykarN_mYyEdlecjpSayeRkaymkedaykaEst

Peking Review )an[dwgfa CU )anEføgR)ab;ePJóvrbs;Kat;fa «kñúgsm½ys®gÁamenAeBlEdlRbeTs

elakRtÚvGt;es,óg eyIg)andkykrbbBIkgT½Brbs;eyIgpÞal;edIm,IykeTACYyBYkelak. eyIg

)aneFVIkarRbwgERbgmYyy:agsem,Im. srubeTA sBVéf¶enHC¿nYyrbs;eyIgEdlpþl;[RbeTs

evotNamenAEtmansarsMxan;CagC¿nYyEdleyIg)anseRmcpþl;dl;bNþaRbeTseRkAeTAeTot.

sUmTuk[eyIgFUrRsalbnþicedIm,IGnuBaØat[eyIgBRgwgkmøaMgeLIgvij»27.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg30

Page 41: Brother enemy

yn; BinitüeXIjfa RkúmemdwknaMcin)anseRmccitþbgá[manbBaðaCafµIedaymuWgm:at;bMputGMBI

CMnYyCaR)ak;nigC¿nYyes,ógGaharsrubEdlcin)ansnüapþl;[kalBIeBlknøgmk. RkúmemdwknaMcin

niyayfa s®gÁam)anputrlt;eTAehIy eBlenHRbeTsevotNamRtÚvEtciBa©wmRbCaCnxøÜnÉgeday

meFüa)aypÞal;rbs;xøÜn. gI EdleTACYb em:A enaH )anRbwgERbgeFVI[mankareyaKyl;mkelIrUbKat;

Edr. gI niyayfa «ebIKµanRbeTscinEdleyIgcat;TukCamUldæanbEg¥kd¾rwgmaMmYy Kµand¿bUnµan Kµan

C¿nYy eyIgBitCaKµansMNagNamYyTTYl)anC½yCmñHeLIy. eyIgenAEtvaytémøCab;Canic©fa man

EtRbeTscineTEdlGacmkCYy]btßmÖedaypÞal;nigKµanrYjrakñúgkal³eTs³sMxan;² EdleCaKvasna

rbs;eyIgeBIbRbTHnwg]bsKÁepSg² KWBuMEmnshPaBsUevoteT »28. karelIksresIrhYsehtuenH

)anRtwmEtTTYlplRbeyaCn_mankRmitkMNt;mYyb:ueNÑaH ³ KWkar[x©I\NTanmYyedayKµanykkar

R)ak; edIm,IRTRTg;karnaMcUleRbg\n§n³ nigeRKÓg]bePaKbriePaK. b:uEnþ gI )anbgðaj[eXIjfa Rkúg

eb:kaMgBMuTan; «KUssBaØaExVgeCIgEk¥kmYy » CasßaBrmkelIRbeTsevotNamenAeLIyeT. sBaØa

ÉeTot²nwgmandMeNIreTAkñúgTisEtmYyKW suqnÞ³EdlsEmþg[eXIjsþIBIbBaðaRbCuMekaH):ar:aEsl

nig®s<atlI. BYkcinminTan;biTTVarRbeTseT. kñúgkarsnÞnarbs;Kat; enAéf¶TI24 ExkBaØa CamYy

eLyn;/ etg )andkecalTsSn³ pøÚvkarrbs;Kat;Edlfa RbCuMekaHTaMgenaHCa «cMENkd¾BisidæénEdndI

cin » nigEdlminGaccrca)an. Kat;)anTTYlsÁal;karsßitmanGFikrN_mYyEdleFVI[eXIjeLIgtam

karcrcaeTVPaKI29.

b:uEnþGMNwHteTA PasaminsuIExSKñaEpñkneya)ayrvagPaKITaMgBIrmanlkçN³F¶n;F¶rbMput ehIy

karxkcitþrbs; yn; k¾manlkçN³xøaMgNas;Edr. enAqñaM1973 kñúgGMLúgdMeNIrpøÚvkarcugeRkayrbs;

Kat;eTAkan;RbeTscin Kat;)anlubecalBiFICb;eloglaKñaCaRbéBNImYyedIm,ICakitþiysdl;m©as;

pÞH. enHCakarseRmccitþmYy EdleRkaymkm®nþIcinmñak;)ancat;Tukfa ³ «CaGakb,kiriyaeQøIy

xuseK EdlecjmkBIemdwknaMbkSCabgb¥Únmñak; »30. éf¶TI25 ExkBaØa yn; )anCiHrfePøIgRtLb;mk

RkúghaNUyvijkat;tamTIRkúgeTogsuIn. RbeTsevotNameRkaysm½ys®gÁam eTIbnwgdak;eTas

Rkúgeb:kaMgcMeBaHkarTTYlsVaKmn_edayKMeraHKMerIyCasaFarN³elIkdMbUgrbs;xøÜn.

mYyExeRkaymk yn; )aneFVIdMeNIreTARkúgm:UsÁÚ. Kat;)anTTYlBaküsnüaBIshPaBsUevot kñúg

karpþl;CMnYyry³eBlEvgmYy ehIy)anyl;RBmcuHhtßelxaelIesckþIEføgkarN_rYmmYy edIm,IKaMRT

CMhrepSg²rbs;sUevotxagvis½yneya)aybreTs. eRkaymkemdwknaMcinmñak;)anniyayR)ab;´

fa esckþIEføgkarN_rYmsUevot-evotNam enAéf¶TI30 Extula qñaM1975 bBa¢ak;[eXIjBI «karcuH

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 31

Page 42: Brother enemy

j:mrbs;evotNamcMeBaHmuxGnutþrPaBniym»31.

karrIkduHdalénsßankarN_épÞkñúgrbs;evotNam GaceFVI[RbeTscinpþl;nUvsarsMxan;EfmeTot

kñúgkarERkgrEGgrbs;xøÜnEdlmanlkçN³TuTidæiniymbMput. fVId,itEtmankarKaMRTrbs;xøÜn edayvaca

cMeBaHeKaledAénkarbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTseLIgvij EdlmantémøsRmab;RkúghaNUy k¾eday k¾Rkúg

eb:kaMgvinicä½yedayKMnitGaRkk;y:agxøaMgBITsSnvis½yénkarrYbrYmKñamYyxagneya)aynigrdæaPi)al

rbs;RbeTsTaMgBIr EdlGaceFVI[ERbRbÜltulüPaBkmøaMgTaMgGs;enA\NÐÚcin. kñúgsarsEmþgkar

GbGrsresIrEdlRkúmemdwknaMcinepJIeTA[RbeTsevotNam bnÞab;BIC½yCmñH BYkcin)anbgðaj[

eXIjkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;xøÜnEdlmin[smÁal;)an. BYkeK)ansresrfa «eyIgsUmCUnBreday

esµaHsµ½RK EdlRbCaCnevotNamxagt,ÚgTTYl)aneCaKC½yy:agRtcHRtcg;Canic©kñúgkarRbyuT§d¾

x¢ab;x¢Ünrbs;xøÜn edIm,IdwknaMbdivtþn_CatinigRbCaFibetyü[)anseRmcpll¥ »32. dUecñH edayeFVI[

manrhUteTAfa C½yCmñHenH KWCasñaédd¾sMxan;elIslb;rbs;RbCaCnevotNamxagt,Úg ehIyBuMEmn

Casñaédrbs;kgT½BnigeRKÓgsa®sþavuFrbs;evotNamxageCIgeTenaH BYkcin)anbgðaj[eXIjy:ag

c,as;fa menaseBa©tnarbs;eKnwglMeGogeTArkPaKxagt,ÚgCagEdlxøÜncg;[manRbB½n§sgÁmkic©mYy

xusEbøkBIRbB½n§sgÁmkic©sgÁmniymenAPaKxageCIg.

kñúgbNþaExdMbUg²EdlmanbnþBIC½yCmñH BYkemdwknaMevotNam)ansEmþg[dwgBIbMNgcg;rkSa

TukRbB½n§sgÁmkic©nigesdækic©mYyepSgenAPaKxagt,Úgkñúgry³eBlR)aMqñaMy:agehac munnwgeFVIkar

rMlaybBa©ÚlKñaCamYyPaKxageCIgsgÁmniym33. kñúgsunÞrkfamYyEdlEføgkñúgRkbx½NÐénBiFIbuNü

GbGrC½yCmñHenAéf¶TI15 Ex]sPa eLyn; )anRbkasfa PaKxagt,ÚgnwgykcitþTukdak;ksag «rbb

RbCaFibetyüCati »mYy EdlkñúgPasaedayELkénlT§im:akSsuIs mann½yfa CardæbuersgÁmniym

mYy. mü:ageTot rdæaPi)albdivtþn_beNþaHGasnñevotNamxagt,Úg)andak;ebkçPaBrbs;xøÜnedIm,IsuM

Gasn³mYyenAGgÁkarshRbCaCatiedayrebobsVy½t. bnÞab;BImanbTBiesaFn_kñúgkarRKb;RKg

kic©karepSg²ry³eBlR)aMmYyExenAPaKxagt,Úg BYkemdwknaMbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamyl;eXIjfa

vamanplGaRkk;eRcInCagGtßRbeyaCn_EdlRtÚvBnüWtkarbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTseLIgvij. dUecñH ebIsin

CalubbM)at;rcnasm<n§GñkmanmUlFnenAPaKxagt,ÚgelOnrh½seBk vamuxCanwgbNþal[mankar

rMeCIbrMCYlnigkarts‘Uminxan. karrkSarebobRKb;RKgmYyEdlpþl;esrIPaBkñúgkarbegáItshRKas

muxCabgá[mankarRCÜlRcbl;Edr edaysarkarxVHRkbx½NÐGñkeFVIkarEdlmansmtßPaB ehIyrwtEt

F¶n;F¶rCagenH KWvaeFVI[GñkEdlmanninñakarpþac;xøÜnenAPaKxagt,ÚgrwtEtrwgmaMEfmeTot. BYkemdwknaM

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg32

Page 43: Brother enemy

evotNam )anBinitüemIlCamYykarRBÜy)armÖnUvExSry³Tak;TgKñaedaypÞal;rvagRkúmeb:kaMgnigBYk

kumµúynIsþenAPaKxagt,Úg tamry³meFüa)ayedaymincMeBaHenATIRkúgRcWLWg CaTIRkúgmYyEdl

PaKeRcInCaCnCaticin rYmTaMgkarTak;Tgd¾CitsñiT§rbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgCamYyRbeTskm<úCaCitxagpg.

edaysarRbeTscinbgðajBIeKalbMNgrbs;xøÜnedayxøÜnÉg edIm,I[mankarrkSaTukPaKxagt,ÚgenA

sVy½t KWdUcCabEnßmTLðIkrN_mYyCaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;karbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTseLIgvijy:agqab;

rh½s. etIenH minEmnedIm,IRbqaMgnwgkareRbIkll,icCayfaehturbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgeTb¤?.

edaymankarPJak;ep¥IlCaTUeTA esckþIRbkasmYyEdlpSBVpSaydMNalKñatamrlkFatuGakas

viTüúRkúghaNUy nigviTüúRkúghUCImIj enAéf¶TI9 Exvicäika )anRbkas[dwgBI «karRbCuMBieRKaHmYy»eCIg-

t,Úg enAeBlqab;²xagmuxenHedIm,IerobcMkarbRgÜbbRgÜmrdæaPi)alTaMgBIreLIgvij. BIr-bIs)aþh_

eRkaymk enAeBlEdlkarRbCuMpSBVpSayCasaFarN³BIkarseRmccitþrbs;xøÜn RkúghaNUy)an

eCarCn;eTAedaysarlixitGbGrsresIrCaeRcInEdlecjmkBIRbeTssgÁmniymnana elIkElgEt

RbeTscinmYy.

karekþARkhaykan;EtrIkFMeLIg²rbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg cMeBaHRbeTsevotNam)ansEmþg[dwgenA

éf¶TI24 Exvicäika KWbIéf¶bnÞab;BIkarbBa©b; «karRbCuMBieRKaH » enATIRkúghUCImij. RbeTscin)anTmøay

PaBes¶óms¶at;Pøam² EdlxøÜn)antamsegátemIlrhUtmkTl;nwgeBlenHBIbBaðaRbCuMekaH®s<atlI

Edl «rMedaH »enAExemsaedaykmøaMgT½Brbs;RkúghaNUy. kñúgGtßbTd¾EvgmYyrbs;kaEst hánmij

edlI EdlsresredIm,ITb;karykcitþTukdak;rbs;RbeTsevotNamenaH )anrMB¤kBIkarkan;kab;RtÜtRta

taMgBIyUryarNas;mkehIyrbs;RbeTscinelIRbCuMekaH):ar:aEslnig®s<atlI. GtßbTenH)an

GFib,ayb®Ba©asnwgCMhrrbs; etg EdlsEmþg[dwgenAExkBaØa KWfabBaðaénnaTIrbs;xøÜncMeBaHRbeTs

mYy b¤ RbeTsmYyeTot enABuMTan;seRmceT. pÞúyeTAvij kaEst hánmij edlI )aneFVI[keRmIkCafµI

nUvniekçbbTsþIBI «cMENkd¾BisidæénEdndIrbs;RbeTscin » nigRBmanfa RbCuMekaHTaMgenaH EdlCakmµsiT§i

rbs;cinRtÚvEtvilmkkñúgEpñkénmatuRbeTsCasßaBrvij34.

RtÚveFVI[cab;GarmµN_tictYcBIkarKMrambiTmuxenH RkúghaNUy)anbnþkmµviFIrbs;xøÜnkñúgkarBRgwg

karRtÜtRtaelIPaKxagt,ÚgnigelICnCaticinmYylanR)aMEsnnak;Edlrs;enAkñúgRbeTsxøÜnEfmeTot.

enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1976 kñúgRkbx½NÐénkare)aHeqñateRCIserIssmaCiksRmab;GnaKt rdæsPaCati kar

eFVICMerOnRbCaCn)ancab;epþImCMruj[RbCaBlrdæTaMgGs;RbkasBIsBa¢atirbs;xøÜn. mnusSTaMgGs;

EdlRbkasfaxøÜnmansBa¢atibreTs RtÚv)andkhUtCasV½yRbvtþinUvsiT§iBlrdæ nigrbbes,ógGahar

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 33

Page 44: Brother enemy

rbs;xøÜn. GaNikCncinmYyPaKy:agFMenAPaKxagt,Úg RtÚvEtbgç¿citþRbkan;yksBa¢atievotNam.

kñúgerOgenH BYkcin)ansmÁal;eXIjkarrMelaPmYyelIkic©RBmeRBógedaymat;TeTkalBIqñaM1955

rvagRbeTscinnigRbeTsevotNamxageCIg-Edltamry³enHfa BYkGaNikCncinminGackøayeTACa

BlrdæevotNam)aneT eRkABI «karsµ½RKcitþ »rbs;GñkTaMgenaH b:uEnþ k¾rMelaPelIxsnüadUcKñaEdl[

sc©ab½nedayrNsirSrMedaHCatienAevotNamxagt,ÚgpgEdr. RbeTscin)antv:aCaÉkCnRbqaMgnwg

GVIEdlxøÜnehAfa «karcUlsBa¢atiedaybgçM » énbNþaGaNikCnrbs;xøÜn. enAExkumÖ³ nigExemsa qñaM

1976 karRbCuMsm¶at;EdlerobcMeLIgcMnYnbIelIk edIm,Isakl,gedaHRsaykarvivaTenHKµan)an

TTYllT§plNamYyeLIy. bIqñaMeRkaymk erOgenH)anRtÚvÉkGKÁrdæTUtevotNamRbcaMRkúgeb:kaMg

egVóg Rtúgvij bMPøWR)ab;´fa evotNam)anGHGagfa RbeyaK «tamkarsµ½RKcitþ » KWBuMmankñúgkic©RBm

eRBógqñaM1955eT. BIrqñaMeRkaymkkarRbRBwtþminl¥rbs;RkúghaNUy cMeBaHGaNikCncin )an

beBaäH[rwtEtmanCemøaHnwgKña nigbgákarRbQmmuxdak;Kñarvagcin nigevotNamEfmeTot.

RbEhlkñúgeBlCamYyKñaEdlRtÚvcab;epþImeFVIkarCMerOnRbCaCnrbs;xøÜn nigerobcMkare)aHeqñat

eRCIserIssmaCiksRmab;rdæsPaCatibRgÜbbRgÜmmYy RbeTsevotNam)anbegáInkarRbwgERbgrwtEt

xøaMg edIm,IBRgwgCMhrrbs;xøÜnenA\NÐÚcin[kan;EtrwgmaMeLIgeTot. CabzmKW RbwgERbgrwtcMNgsm<n§PaB

rbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTsLav bnÞab;mk RbwgERbgbnßyCemøaHTwkdIrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTskm<úCa. eday

ehtuenH BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUy)anvaytémøfa karbegáIt[manenAkñúgRbeTsnUvrdæaPi)albRgÜb

bRgÜmmYynigk,alm:asuInsRmab;eFVIEpnkarmYy RtÚvEteFVIRBmKñanwgkarrwtcMNgTak;TgmYyCamYy

bNþaRbeTsCitxagenA\NÐÚcin EdlCaGaTiPaBcaM)ac;xanmin)ankñúgkarksagRbeTsmYyEdlbMpøic

bMpøajedaysars®gÁameLIgvij nigkarcab;RbtibtþiERbpøas;RTg;RTayRbeTseTACasgÁmniymvij.

b:uEnþ karcMGkbBaÄWneya)ayenH eTACamanlT§pleFVI[RbeTscin nigkm<úCa rYbrYmKñakñúgCemøaHEt

erog²xøÜnrbs;BYkeKCamYyRbeTsevotNameTAvij. mUlehtuepSg²énGriPaB KWRbEhlCaxusKña

b:uEnþ RbeTskm<úCanigcinmanKMnitRbqaMgdUcKñacMeBaHkarelceLIgnUvRbeTsevotNammYy EdlxøaMg

BUEkTaMgFnFanTaMgkmøaMgT½B nigGMNacRtÜtRtaeK.

etIenHCakarRbRBwtþedayKitTukCamun b¤CaPaBKab;CYnFmµta eRBaHBIréf¶eRkaykarcuHhtßelxa

elIkic©RBmeRBógxageyaFaCasm¶at;rvagcin-ExµrenARkúgPñMeBj evotNam)ane)aHCMhanmuneKenA

elIpøÚvénkarbegáIt[mansm<n§½PaB\NÐÚcinmYy. rdæm®nþITI1énsaFarNrdæRbCamanitRbCaFibetyü

LavnigCaGKÁelxabkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_Lav éksn PUmivihan EdlCasm½<n§mitþd¾yUrlg;rbs;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg34

Page 45: Brother enemy

evotNam)aneFVIdMeNIreTARkúghaNUy edIm,IeFVITsSnkic©CaÉkCnmYy. esckþIEføgkarN_rYmEdlKat;

)ancuHhtßelxaCamYy eLyn; enAéf¶TI12 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1976 )anKUsbBa¢ak;fa «TMnak;TMngBiess »

EdlkMBugsßitmanrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrnwgCYysRmÜldl;TsSnvis½yénshRbtibtþikard¾yUrGEgVgmYy

karCYy]btßmÖKñaeTAvijeTAmk nigkic©shkarkñúgkarRbqaMgTl;nwg «cRkBtþiniymnigBYkRbtikiriya

sIuQñÜl ». esckþIEføgkarN_k¾)ansgát;bBa¢ak;BIectnarbs;bkSTaMgBIredIm,I «begáInsamKÁIPaBrvag

Lav-km<úCanigevotNamkan;EtrIkceRmIneLIg » pgEdr. RbkarTaMgenHKWCanimitþrUbénectnarbs;

evotNamedIm,IbBa¢ak;BIkarkarkMNt;CaGaTiPaBénneya)aysñiT§evotNamrbs;Lav. b:uEnþdUcEdl

GñksegátkarN_mñak;kt;smÁal;eRkaymkeTot BI «kareRbIR)as;RbeyaK«TMnak;TMngBiess » EdlGac

RtÚveKbkRsayfa CakarRBmanmYycMeBaHRbeTscinnigbNþaRbeTsCamitþrbs; b:ul Bt. sarenH

mann½yfa RkúghaNUynwgminbeNþay[km<úCaRbCaFibetyüQrkñúgCYrCamYyRbeTscinRbqaMgnwg

evotNameLIy»35.

Rkúgeb:kaMgmin)aneFVIRbtikmµPøam²cMeBaHkarRbkasCasaFarN³BI «TMnak;TMngBiess »enHeT.

edayrebobdUcKña CaeRcIns)aþh_eRkaymk enAeBlEdlevotNamR)arB§buNüxYby:agKRKwkKeRKg

kñúg «karrMedaH»PaKxagt,Úg RbeTscin)anbgðaj[eXIjTwkcitþrbs;xøÜncMeBaHRBwtþikarN_enH edayenA

es¶ómQwgEtmþg. kñúgTinanub,vtþiRbCaCn¬rbs;cin¦BMumancuHvicarNkfa sEmþgGMNrsaTr ehIysar

lixitCUnBrk¾BMumanepJIeTA[BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUyEdr.

RkúgPñMeBjk¾ecosvagmineFVIGtßaFib,ayCasaFarN³dUcKña. k¾b:uEnþkarRbqaMgrbs;ExµrRkhm

cMeBaH «TMnak;TMngBiess »enHKWmanR)akdNas;. karbgðaj[dwgmYyGac[eKvas;CeRmAerOgenH

)an. karbgðajenaH)anRtÚvlatRtdagR)ab;eyIgedayGtItRBHRbmuxrdækmú<Ca EdleBlenaHCa

emdwknaMrNsirSrYbrYmCatikm<úCa KWsemþcRBH neratþm sIhnu. enAkñúgCMBUkmYyénesovePAk,alTIbIsþI

BIkRmgGnusSavrIy_rbs;RBHGgÁEdlmancMNgeCIgfa «karxaMmat;sgát;citþnwgkaremIlgayhYsehtu »

semþc)anRTg;lixitfa enAeBlRBHGgÁyageTARkúghaNUyCamYy exov sMpn enAExkBaØa qñaM1975

kñúg»kasbuNüxYbkMeNItelIkTI30rbs;evotNamxageCIg emdwknaMkm<úCaTaMgBIr)ancUlCYbrdæm®nþITI1

paM v:an;dug EdlCaGñkGeBa¢Ij[cUlrYmbriePaK «GahareBll¶acCalkçN³RKÜsarmYy »CamYyBYk

emdwknaMevotNamxageCIg bNþasmaCikénrdæaPi)albdivtþbeNþaHGasnñevotkugnigBYkemdwknaMLav

Edlsñak;enARkúghaNUymYyry³xøI. edayeFVI[semþcegOgq¶l; nigRsLaMgkaMg sMpn )an«bdiesF

y:agesaHkeRkaHnUvkarGeBa¢IjenHedaybBa¢ak;fa km<úCacUlcitþbriePaKGahareBll¶acCa]PetaPaKI

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 35

Page 46: Brother enemy

mYyCag ». eRkaymk sMpn )anBnül;R)ab;semþcfa «eyIgRtÚvEtecosvagCanic©kMu[Føak;cUlkñúg

GnÞak;enH. evotNamcg;RtÜtRtaRbeTskm<úCarbs;eyIgedayrYmbBa©ÚlenAkñúgshB½n§\NÐÚcinrbs;

eK ». sMpn )anGHGagfa KMnitEtmYyKt;kñúgkarbriePaK)ayl¶acmYyEbbenaHKWCaKMnitRbkbeday

eRKaHfñak;xøaMgNas;.

RsemalshB½n§\NÐÚcinEdlbkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcincab;epþImcak;RKwHkñúgTsvtSr_30 enAEteFVI[

ExµrKitmémBIerOgenaHerogrhUtmk. edayniyaysRmab;buNüxYbelIkTI1én «karrMedaH »RbeTs

km<úCaenAéf¶TI17 emsa eGog sarI )anedAeTArkGVIEdleKehAfa «TMnak;TMngBiess»enaH c,as;Nas;

enAeBlEdlKat;Rbkasfa «RbCaCneyIgnwgminGnuBaØat[bNþaRbeTseRkAbMpøajÉkraCüPaB GFib

etyüPaB nigbUrNPaBTwkdIrbs;km<úCaeLIy ». Kat;)aneRbIBakübBaäitbeBaäógmYyGMBIvtþmankgT½B

evotNamenARbeTsLavEdlGac[eKyl;FøúH)anfa «karkarBarRbeTsmYyRtÚvEtCasñaédrbs;

RbCaCnxøÜnpÞal; dUcKñanwgkarbdivtþn_Edr vaRtÚvEtseRmcedayRbCaCnrbs;xøÜnpÞal;edaymincMNuH

GñkNaTaMgRsug»36.

ebITukCamankarriHKn;minecjmuxTaMgenHEdlbeBa©jenAcMeBaHmuxÉkGKÁrdæTUtevotNamRbcaM

enARkúgPñMeBjKWelak paM v:an;)a k¾eday k¾km<úCa)anTTYlyl;RBmeFVIkic©RbCu¿kMBUlmYytamkar[

eyabl;rbs;evotNamenAExmifunaEdr. edayenAEtminTan;eTarTn;cMeBaHbBaðaepSg²Epñkneya)ay

km<úCaRbCaFibetyü)anxMRbwgERbgesñI[mankic©RbCu¿crcamYysþIBIbBaðaRBMEdnCanic©. tamBitsRmab;

RkúgPñMeBjKWRbkarenHÉgEdlCakarsakl,gdac;xat edIm,I[dwgBIsuqnÞ³rbs;RkúghaNUy ehIytam

dMeNIrehtuenH KWCaGaTiPaBEdlminGacecosvag)anenAkñúgkarRbCuMkMBUl.

enAéf¶TI4 Ex]sPa Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam pan;ehon )anmkdl;RkúgPMñeBj. kmµviFI

rbs;Kat;KWkic©crcaBIrs)þah_sþIBICemøaHTwkdI. karCYbBiPakSa)aneBIbRbTHnwgPaBsµúKsµajPøam

edaysarectnarbs;evotNamEdlsMGagelIEpnTIepSg²rbs;)araMgmankalbriecäT taMgBImunqñaM

1954emø:H edIm,IkMNt;RBMEdnrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr. cMENkxagkm<úCavij edayyl;RBmykEpnTI

TaMgenHeFVICamUldæansRmab;karBiPakSa )anTamTarsiT§iGMNacEkERbKMnUsbnÞat;RBMEdnEdr ebIsinCa

RtÚveFVI. dUcEdl eGog sarI )anbkRsayerOgenHeRkaymkfa «EpnTIrbs;)araMgmanlkçN³GMeNay

plbMputcMeBaHevotNam enAeBlEdlEpnTIenHRtÚv)anerobcMeLIg BIeRBaHkUsaMgsuInCaGaNaniKm

mYyrbs;)araMg. ebIsinCaeyIgRtÚvbgçMTTYlykEpnTIenH sRmab;kMNt;RBMEdndIeKakenaHevotNam

RbEhlCaTTYlsÁal;RBMEdnsmuRTEdlkMNt;edayBYk)araMgCafñÚrvijminxan»37.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg36

Page 47: Brother enemy

niyay[EmnETneTA vaBuMmanbBaðasþIBIRBMEdnsmuRTEdlKUsedayBYk)araMgeLIy. enAqñaM1939

ExSbnÞat;eRbvIey KWyktameQµaHelak hS‘úleRbvIey CaGKÁeTsaPi)alRbcaM\NÐÚcin EdlRtÚv)an

KUseLIgsRmab;kMNt;RBMEdnyutþaFikarEpñkrdæ)al nigb:Ulis erogxøÜnrbs;kUsaMgsuIn nigkm<úCaeTAelI

ekaHnanakñúglMhsmuRTb:ueNÑaH. ¬yutþaFikarKWsiT§iRtÜtBinitükñúgkarvinicä½y nigpþl;yutþiFm’elITwkdIEdl

rdæGMNackan;kab;¦. enAelIEpnTI ExSbnÞat;enH)anKUsecjBIRBMEdneqñrsmuRTrvagtMbn;TaMgBIr Edl

RtÜtRtaedayBYk)araMgkat;QUgsmuRTesomCamuM140dWeRk b:uEnþ ExSbnÞat;enH)anRtÚv)araMgKUsvag

Cu¿vijcm¶ayRbEhl1/5ém:l_ BIekaHPUkuk ¬ExµrehA ekaHRtl;¦ edIm,Idak;[sßitenAeRkamkarRtÜtRta

rbs;GaCJaFrkUsaMgsuIn. karseRmcenH bgðaj[eXIjP½sþútagy:agRKb;RKan;nUvTsSn³rbs;rdæa-

Pi)alGaNaniKm b:uEnþdUcEdlelak eRbvIey Rbkas[dwgedayxøÜnKat;pÞal;fa ³ «PaBsßitenAeRkam

GMNacénekaHTaMgenaH enAEtRtÚvtmál;TukTaMgRsugminTan;seRmcfa[eTAxagNa²eT »38.

b:uEnþsuBlPaB ¬PaBeRbIkar)an¦ rbs;ExSbnÞat;eRbvIey kñúgnaTICaExSkMNt;RBMEdnenHFøab;RtÚv

)anPaKITaMgBIrTTYlsÁal;mþgrYcehIy kñúg»kasénkic©crcaKñarvagkm<úCanigrNsirSrMedaHCati¬evotkug¦

kalBIqñaM1966. kñúgkal³eTs³mYyEdlrNsirSrMedaHCatiRtÚvkarkic©KaMRTBIsemþc RBHneratþm

sIhnu ehIyRbEhlCaedIm,IkuM[semþcGak;Gn;RBHT½y evotNam)anTTYlsÁal;y:agCak;lak;fa ExS

bnÞat;enHCaRBMEdnsmuRTrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr. enARkúg):arIsnaExmifuna qñaM1977 pan;ehon )anGnuBaØat

[´CYbeFVIkarsmÖasn_mYy. enAeBlenaH karsnÞnaenAEx]sPa qñaM1976 nigtYnaTIEdlKat;)an

sEmþgenAEtsßitkñúgPaBsm¶at;dEdl. ´)ansYrKat;fa etIRkúghaNUyTTYlsÁal;ExSbnÞat;eRbvIey

enHeT?. Kat;eqøIyfa «)aT¡ eRBaHfaenAeBlenaH eyIgBuMEdl)andwgBIbBaðaRBMEdnTwkRBMEdn)at

smuRTeLIy niyayedayxøIKWktþafµI²TaMgenH ». enHCarebobTTYlsÁal;EdlecHxµaseGonmYyfa

taMgBImankarcab;epþImsÞg;rkGNþÚgeRbgkatkñúgtMbn;enHkñúgTsvtSr_70 RkúghaNUycaM)ac;RtÚvEt

BinitüC¿hrrbs;xøÜnsþIBIRBMEdnsmuRTeLIgvij Edr.

GMeNayEdl[RbpñÚlGaRkk;

kñúgkMLúgénkarCYbsnÞnaKñaenARkúgPñMeBj ehon )anGHGagbEnßmBIkaryl;RBmrbs;evotNam

kñúgkarEbgEckekaHnanatamKMnUsExSbnÞat;eRbvIey KWekaHTaMgLayEdlenAxageCIgRtÚv)anmkkm<úCa

ehIyekaHTaMgLayEdlenAxagt,ÚgRtÚv)aneTAevotNam. b:uEnþKat;)anecaTRbkan;CafµIsþIBIkarkMNt;

RBMEdnsmuRT. cMeBaHcMNucenH Kat;esñI[mankarKUsExSbnÞat;RBMEdneLIgvij. minyUrb:unµaneRkay

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 37

Page 48: Brother enemy

mk enAeBlEdlCemøaHtams®gÁam):akkaeLIgdl;kRmitx<s;bMputenaH RkúgPñMeBj)anQanrhUtdl;

ecaTRbkan;sMeNIrbs;evotNamfa enHCaeKalbMNg «P¢ab;EdnTwkmYycMENky:agFMrbs;km<úCaeFVICa

rbs;xøÜn ». sRmab;Exµryl;fa enHCaP½sþútagénbMNgvatTIrbs;evotNammkelIkm<úCay:agBit

R)akd. kic©crca)anRtÚvp¥akedayKµankMNt;éf¶CYbKñaeToteLIy ehIyk¾minEdlRtÚvbnþeLIgvij

Tal;EtesaH CamYynwgkarcrcaTaMgenH KMnit[mankarCYbRbCu¿kMBUlrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrk¾rlaysUnü.

b:uEnþfVIebICYbbraC½yenHk¾eday k¾KµanRbeTsNamYykñúgcMeNamRbeTsTaMgBIreRtómbRmúgnwgpþac;

«s<anemRtI »enAeLIyEdr. pan;ehon )anvileTARkúghaNUyvijedayBaMnaMsMbuRtGeBa¢IjmYyrbs;

eGog sarI [GñkkaEstevotNameTAeFVITsSnkic©enAkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüpg EdlrhUtmkTl;nwg

eBlenH RtÚvkat;pþac;RbeTsTaMgRsugBIBiPBxageRkA.

enAExkkáda qñaM1776 RbtiPUGñksarB½t’man nigTUrTsSn_rbs;evotNammYyRkúmdwknaMeday

Rtan; faj;s‘n; GnuRbFanTIPñak;garB½t’manevotNamKWCaRkúmGñksarB½t’manbreTselIkd¿bUgbMput

EdleFVId¿eNIreTAkan;km<úCa. s‘n; EdlmanGayu50)aøyqñaM Bak;Ev:nta ragsÁmcm¥wg nigqab;mYem:A

RtÚv)aneRCIserIs[eFVICaemdwknaMKN³RbtiPU BIeRBaHKat;CaGtItnisSitenARkúg):arIs ehIyCaGñkFøab;

)anCYb b:ul Bt/ eGog sarI nigGnaKtemdwknaMkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüCaeRcInrUbeTotpg. enAkñúg»kas

enH buKÁld¾Gaf’kM)aMg b:ul Bt EdlGtþsBaØaNBitR)akdRtÚv)aneKykeTAeFVICakmµvtßúrkkéRmCanic©-

kalenAbreTsenaH TIbMput)anecjBI «TIkM)aMg »ehIy. b:ul Bt )anGnuBaØat[ s‘n; eFVIbTsmÖasn_

mYy ehIyyl;RBmbeNþayxøÜn[GñkTaMgenaHftrUbKat;tamcitþ. bYnqñaMeRkaymk edayenAnwkeXIj

BIkarCYbKñaenH s‘n; )anniyayfa enAeBlenaH b:ul Bt manb£kBaCabursmñak;EdlKYr[RsLaj;

cUlcitþBit². edaymineBjcitþnwgbgðajxøÜnCam©as;pÞHKYrsmmñak; kñúgkarsmÖaselIkd¿bUg Kat;)an

sEmþgnUvkardwgKuNrbs;km<úCacMeBaHRbCaCnevotNamCamitþnigCabgb¥ÚnEdlFøab;)anCYy]btßmÖ

kalBIeBlknøgmk. kñúgerOgenH tamEdlKat;yl;KWfamitþPaB nigsamKÁIPaBrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrman

lkçN³RBmKñaCa«bBaðayuT§sa®sþmYypgnigmenaseBa©tnad¾x<g;x<s;mYypg».

kñúg»kasénkarsmÖasmYyenARkúghUCImijkalBIqñaM1981 s‘n; )aneFVIGtßaFib,ayfa eKal

bMNgkñúgkarGeBa¢IjGñksarB½t’manevotNamrbs;km<úCaKWedIm,ICYsCulrUbPaBrbs;xøÜnEdlxUcxat

edaysarkarTietonrbs;BYkbs©imRbeTsd¿bUgeK Edl)aneTAeFVITsSnkic©enARbeTsenH kalBIExmIna

1976. b:ul Bt KitfaevotNamnwgRtÚv¬Kat;¦eRbIR)as;sRmab;KeRmagkarenH ehIyKat;minEdl

KitxuseLIy. b:uEnþedayRtÚveFVI[Tas;EPñkTas;RtecokxøaMg v:ag Tug EdlCamnusSEPñkmutdUcxøaRtI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg38

Page 49: Brother enemy

ehIyEdlKµanGVImYyGaceKcputBIRkEsEPñkKat;enaH )anvaytémøTal;EtKµancMNab;GarmµN_GviC¢man

NamYyelceLIgkñúgdMNwgsþIBIB½t’manrbs;Kat;eLIy. s‘n; )anrMB£kfa «RkúmTUrTsSn_rbs;eyIgman

karlM)aky:agxøaMg kñúgkarEsVgCYbRbCaksikrRbkbedayTwkmuxjjwmrYsrayEdlCab;rvl;ksag

RbeTsCatieLIgvij. GñkTaMgenaHmansPaBdUcCamnusSmYhµgkñúgcitþnigeRkómRkMEdlbgðaj[eXIj

TukçlM)akevTnarbs;xøÜnxøaMgNas; ». Tug )anQanrhUtdl;hammin[pSayXøamYyénGtßbTmYyrbs;

s‘n; kñúgkaEstjinhSineTotpg. GñkkaEst)ansresrfa «TIRkúgnanasuT§Ets¶at;RCgM RbCaCneTA

eFVIERscmáarTaMgGs; ». tamniBn§naykkaEstfa vaRbesIrCagEdlRtÚvykcitþTukdak;cMeBaHkar

xUcxatedaysars®gÁamEdlbgáeLIgeday ln; nl; nigshrdæGaemrik. kareFVITsSnkic©sm,ÚreTA

edayPaBCanimitþrUbKYr[RBWxøac. Tal;EtCaeRcInqñaMeRkaymkeToteTIb v:ag Tug R)ab;[dwgBIkayvikar

RbkbedayKMnitQñanIsrbs; b:ul Bt mkelIrUbKat;. CaC¿nYsC¿nUn emdwknaMExµrRkhm)anepJIstVsuI

sac;mYyk,almk[Kat; KWkUnRkeBImYy39. b:uEnþerOgenHvaGacfa b:ul Bt manKMnitmYyepSgeTotkñúg

xYrk,alrbs;Kat; ³ kñúgbNþaqñaMCabnþbnÞab;mkeTot kareXasnaTaMgb:unµanrbs;ExµrRkhmKW)andak;

smµtinam[evotNamCaerOy²fa «BYkRkeBIrmilKuN».

kñúglMdab;EdlPaBtantwgénTMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTscinnigkm<úCaeLIgkan;Etx<s;

enaH RkúghaNUy)anbegáItkic©xitxMRbwgERbgrwtEtxøaMgeLIgEfmeTot edIm,IP¢ab;TMnak;TMngCamitþPaB

CamYyBiPBminEmnkumµúynIsþvij. Pøam²bnÞab;BI)anTTYlC½yCmñH enAeBldMbUg BYkevotNam)an

briharCasaFarN³dl;bNþaRbeTsRbqaMgkumµúynIsþénsmaKmRbCaCatiGasuI-GaeKñy_ ¬ehAkat;

Gas‘an¦ y:agxøaMgcMeBaHkars‘umRKluMrbs;eKCamYycRkBtþiGaemrikaMg. evotNam)anTamTar[eFVIkar

rMlayecalmUldæanGaemrikaMgTaMgGs; EdlmanenARbeTséf nighV‘IlIBIn. b:uEnþenAcugqñaM1975

RkúghaNUyGacføwgEføgBIkarseRmccitþrbs;BYkcinEdlb:unb:gRbmUlbNþaRbeTsGas‘an [rYbrYm

kñúgyuT§sa®sþmYyRbqaMgsUevotnigRbqaMgevotNampgEdr. CaBiessevotNamk¾kt;smÁal;eXIj

nUvkarxñHExñgrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg kñúgeKalbMNgCYyeFVI[mankarxitcUlCitKñarvagkm<úCa nigRbeTséf

EfmeTot. RbeTscin)anEksRmÜlTMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTséf[manRbRktIPaBeLIg

vij KWmindl;mYyExpgbnÞab;BITIRkúgéRBnKr dYlrlMkñúgeBlEdlevotNamp¥akTukerOgenHmYyGenøI

sin. enAExtula qñaM1976 edaysarkarCYyeRCamERCgrbs;cin eGog sarI )ancab;epþImTak;Tg

mYyCMhanmunedayeFVIdMeNIreTAkan;Rkúg)agkktamynþehaHcinmYyeRKÓg.

eTaHCaRbeTsevotNamcat;TukxøÜnÉgCa «kgQanmuxénlT§isgÁmniymkñúgPUmiPaKGasuI-

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 39

Page 50: Brother enemy

GaeKñy_» nigciBa©wmmhicätaERbkøayxøÜnCa«GñkdwknaM»bNþaclnabdivtþkñúgtMbn;enHk¾eday k¾BYkemdwknaM

rbs;xøÜnsuT§Etyl;fa GVIEdlCaGaTiPaBKWRtÚvxitxMsþaresdækic©EdlbMpøicbMpøajedaysars®gÁameLIg

vij. mü:ageTot kñúgRbeTsenAGasIu-GaeKñy_TaMgGs; bNþaclnabdivtþEdleFVIkarts‘UedayGavuF

minEdlqøgputBIdMNak;kalEdleTIbnwgcab;epþImeLIy. dUecñHRkúghaNUyBMumankareRCIserIseT KWeK

RtÚvEtsRmbsRmÜlCamYyrbbRKb;RKgenAnwgkEnøgCamun. kareFVI[manTMnak;TMngCamYybNþa

RbeTsCitxagmanPaBRbRktIeLIgvij )ankøayeTACakatBVkic©mYysRmab;mUlehtuepSg²xagneya

)ayk¾dUcesdækic©. edIm,I[TTYl)anCMnYy nig\NTanBIbNþaRbeTselakxaglic RbeTsevotNam

minRtÚveFVIxøÜn[elceLIgCaGñknaMGaTi[mankarvwkvreLIy eTaHCamanGVIekIteLIgk¾eday.

Rkúgeb:kaMgElgeqøIytb

éf¶TI5 Exkkáda KWbIéf¶bnÞab;BIkarRbkasCapøÚvkarnUvkarbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTsEdlrdæaPi)albdivtþ

beNþaHGasnñ nigsaFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüevotNamseRmcRbsiT§namfµIfa «saFarNrdæsgÁm

niymevotNam »enaH RkúghaNUy)anEføgRbkasCasaFarN³nUvkmµviFImYyman4cMNuckñúgeKaledA

erobcMnigBRgIk «TMnak;TMngmitþPaBnigshRbtibtþikarkñúgvis½yCaeRcIn »CamYyRbeTsepSg²enA

GasuI-GaeKñy_. edayQrelImUldæanénkareKarBÉkraCüCatieTAvijeTAmk TMnak;TMngenH)anhammin

[mankarpþl;CamUldæanepSg²sRmab;karQøanBanTaMgGs;rbs;RbeTsTIbImYy RbqaMgnwgRbeTs

htßelxINamYyeLIy eTaHCaedaycMeBaHkþIb¤mincMeBaHkþI. PaBTak;TgKñaCaGñkCitxagl¥ KWRtÚvKitdl;

«sßanPaBedayELk »rbs;RbeTsnImYy² «edIm,ICaKuNRbeyaCn_y:agFMeFgdl;ÉkraCüPaB snþiPaB

nigGBüaRkwtPaBBitR)akdkñúgtMbn;»40.

mYys)aþh_eRkaymk pan; ehon )anecjdMeNIreTAeFVITsSnkic©enARbeTshV‘IlIBIn m:aeLsuI

sigðburI \NÐÚensuI nigPUma. kñúgdMeNIrTsSnkic©enHKat;)anRbwgERbgniyayedaHsaBIkarbriharriHKn;

epSg²Edlfa kñúgGtItkalRbB½n§pSBVpSayrbs;RkúghaNUyminEdlx¢Hx¢ayeBlevlaRbqaMgnwg

bNþaRbeTsGas‘anesaHeLIy. karGHGagrbs;Kat;manlkçN³buinRbsb;Emn Kat;)anbkRsayfa

«GñkkaEst)ansresrGVI²tamEdleKyl;dwg b:uEnþBMuEmnCaCMhrrbs;rdæaPi)aleT ». manEtRbeTs

sigðburImYyb:ueNÑaHEdlecHEtsgS½ycMeBaHmuxnUvbMNgCaGñkCitxagl¥EdlsEmþg[eXIjedayRkúg

haNUy. RbeTsÉeTot²hak;dUcCaRtÚveFVI[cab;GarmµN_cMeBaHsMbkeRkAénPaBesµaHRtg;Gs;BI

dYgcitþenH ebITukCareNþAmenaKmviC¢axNÐEckk¾eday. ehon )anEsVgrkcMNgmitþPaBrbs;Kat;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg40

Page 51: Brother enemy

CafµI. edaylHbg;\riyabfKMramkMEhgeK enAeBlenHRkúghaNUy)anbeBa©jsñamjjwmrbs;xøÜn

[eKeXIjmþg. bNþaRbeTsénsmaKmGas‘anGacRtwmEteFVI[FUrRsalkñúgcitþb:ueNÑaH.

eRkayTsSnkic©rbs; ehon enATIRkúgkULalMBYr m®nþICan;x<s;mñak;énRksYgkarbreTsm:aeLsuI

)anR)ab;erOgGaf’kM)aMg[´dwgfa «eyIgcab;GarmµN_fa evotNamxMRbwgERbgeFVI[RbeTsrbs;xøÜnsßit

enAcm¶ayesµIKñarvagRkúgeb:kaMgnigRkúgmUsÁÚ ». ehon )anGHGagR)ab;m:aeLsuIfa RbeTsrbs;Kat;

RbqaMgCMTas;nwgeKalbMNgcg;RtÜtRtaeKRKb;Ebby:agrbs;bNþaRbeTsmhaGMNacnigminGnuBaØat[

RbeTsNamYyeRbIR)as;mUldæannavacrenAqksmuRTkaMr:aj;eLIy. KUsnÞnarbs;´ ¬m®nþICan;x<s;

m:aeLsuI¦ kt;smÁal;eXIjfa «R)akdNas; Kat;eFVICa niyayedomdamrusSIú ehIyBaküsmþIrbs;Kat;

EdlniyayeTAkan;RbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþmYymanlkçN³minsmRsbtamsßanPaBeLIy ». BYk

m:aeL)anvinicä½yKYr[cab;GarmµN_xøaMgfa GñkkarTUtTaMgGs; TaMgBYksUevot TaMgBYksm<n§miRtGWr:ub

xagekItrbs;eK suT§Etbgðaj[eXIjnUvkaregOgq¶l;y:agxøaMgBIBaküsmþIePJóvevotNamrbs;Kat;.

eRkABIkarkMEbøgelgesIcmYyenAeBlkMBugehaHqøgkat;BIelI «ekaH®s<atlIrbs;eyIg »tampøÚvehaHehIr

BIRkúgm:anIl mkTIRkúgkULalMBYr ehon BMumanniyayBaküedomdamNamYycMeBaHkarTas;ETgKña

CamYyRbeTscinTal;EtesaH.

cMeBaHmux «Rbtibtþikardak;esñh_ » rbs;evotNamenAGasuI-GaeKñy_ RbeTscin)anrkSaPaB

es¶óms¶at;minniyayGVITaMgGs; KWCaPaBes¶óms¶at;mYyEdlpÞúkeTAedaykarKMramkMEhgy:agF¶n;.

TIPñak;garsarB½t’mancinfµI EdlmanTmøab;raykarN_BIRBwtþikarN_sMxan;²TaMgEpñképÞkñúgnigEpñkkar

TUtTak;TgnwgRbeTsevotNamenaH Kµan)andwgTaMgRsugBIdMeNIrB½T§CMuvijGasuI-GaeKñy_rbs; ehon

eLIy. b:uEnþCaeRcInéf¶eRkaykarvilRtLb;rbs;Kat;mkRbeTsvij viTüúeb:kaMg)aneFVIbTGtßaFib,ay

mYyRBman[bNþaRbeTsGas‘anRbúgRby½tñRbqaMgTl;nwgkarb:unb:grbs;sUevotkñúgkareRCótcUl nig

karvatTIkñúgtMbn;enH. «drabNaRbCaCnGasuI-GaeKñy_rYbrYmKñay:agCitsñiT§ nigbnþkarRbyuT§ts‘U

drabenaHBYkeKnwgeFVI[sRtÚvrYm)at;esckþIkøahan ehIykareFVIdUecñHGac[RbCaCnTaMgenaHkarBar

ÉkraCüPaB nigGFibetyüPaBpÞal;rbs;xøÜnRbkbedayeCaKC½y»41.

kalbriecäTénkarpSaytamviTüú KµanGVIKYr[sgS½yeLIycMeBaHRbeTsEdlkMNt;edayRkúg

eb:kaMgfaCaPñak;garénkareRCótcUlrbs;sUevot. ebIeTaHCaRbeTscinecosvagminbrihar RbeTs

evotNamedayecjeQµaHk¾eday k¾CnCatievotNamxøHminlak;)aMgkarrYmTsSn³rbs;xøÜnCamYy

shPaB sUevotRbqaMgnwgRbeTscinEdr. Ca]TahrN_ kñúgkareFVIsmÖasn_mYyEdlpþl;dl;GñkkaEst

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 41

Page 52: Brother enemy

s‘uyEGd eGricEBür v:ag Tug )anniyayminjejItmat;fa ³ «tamlkçN³Cak;Esþg plRbeyaCn_

rbs;sUevot RtÚvKñaCamYynwgplRbeyaCn_rbs;evotNamEdr EdlRtÚvkat;bnßy\T§iBlrbs;RbeTs

cinenAkñúg EpñkenHénBiPBelak ». smþIsnÞnaenHEdldkRsg;CasMGagedayBYkemdwknaMcinenAeBl

eRkaymkfaCa]TahrN_én«karRbmafd¾F¶n;F¶rmkelIRbCaCncinedayBYkevotNam»42.

eBjfirevlaénrdUvekþAqñaM1976 RbeTscinRtÚvCab;rvl;y:agxøaMgedaysarkarts‘UépÞkñúg

rbs;xøÜnedIm,IRbqaMgTl;nwgkarvaylukEpñkkarTUtrbs;evotNameRkABIBaküRTeKaHEdlbiT)aMgkar

eXasnarbs;xøÜn. taMgBIdMNac;qñaM1973 kariyal½yneya)ayrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþcin mankar

Ebk)ak;mtiKñay:agxøaMg. karExVgKMnitenH)aneFVI[BYkyuT§ikCnedIrtammaK’aRbtibtþiniymrbs; CU

eGnLay EdlxMRbwgrkpøÚvTb;Tl;nwgkarKMramkMEhgrbs;sUevotedaykarbegáInshRbtibtþikarmYy

CamYyshrdæGaemrikenaH RtÚvRbQmmuxnwgBYkr:aDIkal;mYyRkúmdwknaMeday hSagCunCav nig v:ag

hugev:n EdlGYtGagdUcKñaBIkarRbqaMgd¾Gg;GaccMeBaHmhaGMNacputelxTaMgBIr nigkarKaMRTcMeBaHkar

RbyuT§ts‘UedayGavuFRbqaMgcRkBtþiniymTaMgGs;d¾Gg;Gac43. BYkr:aDIkal;k¾CayuT§ikCnEdlminman

Cab;lkçxNÐnwgExµrRkhmEdr. BYkenH)aneFVI[GVI²eCOnelOneTAmuxsnSwm² edayehtufa kNþab;éd

Edkrbs; em:A )anbn§ÚrkarrwtrYtrbs;Kat;CalMdab; ehIykarTb;Tl;rbs; CU k¾Føak;cuHEdr. enAqñaM

1974-75 karriHKn;rbs;BYkenHRbqaMgnwgkarxitcUlCitCamYyshrdæGaemrikmansPaBy:ag

CUrct;bMput. mü:ageTot BYkeK)anbriharBIPaBFUrRsalrvagsUevotnigGaemrikaMgeTotpg Edltam

mtiBYkeKfaenHKWCaneya)ayEdl CU CYy[)anseRmc44.

mrNPaBrbs; CU enAExmkra 1976 RtÚv)anbnþbIExeRkaymk KWenAExemsaedaykar

beNþjecjBItMENgnUvmnusSédsþaMrbs;Kat;KW etg s‘avBIg. tulüPaBénbkçBYkepSg²kñúg

kariyal½yneya)ay)anERbRbÜlCaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;BYkr:aDIkal;mþg. hVa KUehVg EdlmanedIm

kMeNItenA extþh‘UNan ehIyEdleKrYmbBa©ÚlkñúgRkúmr:aDIkal;enaH RtÚv)anEtgtaMgCardæm®nþITI1

eBjzan³. b:uEnþ eCaKC½yenHBuMmanlkçN³CasßaBreT. enARBhaméf¶TI9 ExkBaØa em:A EdlCaGaCJa

kNþalFM)ancak ecjBIqakneya)ay. vasnarbs;RbeTscinnwgRtÚvsMEdgCafµI k¾dUcCa\riyabf

rbs;xøÜnEdlRtÚvRbQmnwgBiPBelakxageRkAEdr. dUcRbCaCncinrab;lannak; bNþaemdwknaMén

BiPBelakTaMgmUl ehIyedayELk BYkemdwknaMRkúgmUsÁÚ Rkúgv:asuInetan RkúghaNUy nigRkúgPñMeBj

)anEbrkarsmøwgemIlrbs;BYkeKeq<aHeTARkúgeb:kaMgvijmþg. karnwksgÇwm)ancab;epþIm.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg42

Page 53: Brother enemy

semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu ³ em:agénC½yCmñH

KWenARkúgeb:kaMgEdlsemþcRBH neratþm sIhnu RTg;RCabBIkardYlrlMrbs;RkúgPñMeBjkñúgPUmiRKwH

d¾l¥eqItqayrbs;RBHGgÁsßitenAtamvifImYyeQµaH «RbqaMgcRkBtþiniym ». lixitCaTUrelxmYyEdl

epJIfVayedaym®nþIcinmñak;R)ab;[dwgfa enARBwkéf¶TI17 Exemsa qñaM1975 ExµrRkhmEdlCasm<½n§mitþ

rbs;RBHGgÁtaMgBIR)aMqñaMmun)anedIrcUldl;TIRkúgPñMeBjehIy.

elak ln; nl; ]tþmesnIy_xVineCIg CaeménrdæRbharTmøak;semþc sIhnu kalBIqñaM1970 )an

nireTsxøÜneTAenAshrdæGaemrik)at;eTAehIy. «BYkk,t; » xøHEdlFøab;shkarCamYy ln; nl; )anrt;

ePosxøÜnecjBIRbeTs xøHcuHcaj;enAcMeBaHmuxExµrRkhm. s®gÁamRtÚv)anbBa©b;. karRbfuyRbfan

EdlsemþcseRmcRBHT½yenAExemsa qñaM1970 kñúgkarrYbrYmCamYyBYkkumµúynIsþ EdlCasRtÚvKµan

TIbMputrbs;RBHGgÁenaH RtÚv)antbsñgmkvij. semþck¾TTYl)ankitþiysrbs;RBHGgÁeLIgvijEdr.

eRkayrdæRbhar bNþa]tþmesnIy_ Gñkneya)ayRbtikiriyaEdlKitEtRbeyaCn_pÞal;xøÜn nigEdl

Føab;eCOfa GacsMGuyRBHkitþinamrbs;RBHGgÁenaH )ane)aHbg;KeRmagkarCaRbvtþisa®sþenHeTA

vij. CaRBHmhakSRtEdlRtÚvnireTs CaRBHbitaÉkraCürbs;RbeTskm<úCa RBHGgÁKµanRBHT½ybBa©b;

GaCIBneya)ayd¾GP½BVrbs;RBHGgÁeLIy. b:uEnþRBHGgÁmanlkçN³R)akdniymNas; EdlGac

vinicä½yCamunfa C½yCmñHrbs;ExµrRkhmGacmann½yfa enHCaTIbBa©b;éntYnaTIrbs;RBHGgÁ CanimitþrUbén

ÉkPaB nigPaBRsbc,ab;rbs;clnatsU‘pgEdr. RtÚv)ansaksYrenAqñaM1973 kñúgeBlEdlRBHGgÁ

ElgmanplRbeyaCn_NamYysRmab;sm<½n§mitþrbs;RBHGgÁehIyenaH semþc)anBüakrN_TukCamun

fa «BYkeKnwgx¢ak;´ecalmþgeTotdUcCaeKx¢ak;RKab;EpøsWrIecalG‘Ícwg ». enARkúgeb:kaMg)atukmµCaeRcIn

)anRtÚveKbMpuseLIgedIm,IGbGrsaTrC½yCmñHenH. bnÞab;mk ry³eBlCaeRcIns)aþh_)anknøgputeTA

edayKµanGñkNamñak;nwkPñkyagRBHGgÁRtLb;eTARbeTskm<úCaEdleTIbrMedaHeLIy. semþc sIhnu

Gacsnñidæanfa eBlevlaEdlKYr[xøacbMput)anmkdl;ehIy.

semþc)anmanbnÞÚlnwgBYktMNagExµrRkhmenArdæFanIcinfa «sUmGnuBaØat[´vilRtLb;eTA

RkúgPñMeBjvij. ebIsinCaGs;elakminRtÚvkar sIhnu kñúgzan³CaRBHRbmuxrdæ KWCakrNIykic©rbs;

Gs;elak. ´minR)afñacg;)anmuxtMENgeToteT b:uEnþ´cg;rs;enARbeTskm<úCa ´Elgcg;eFVICaGñk

ePosxøÜnmñak;eTotehIy ». ExµrRkhm)aneqøIytbnwgRBHGgÁfa RBHkruNaéføvíess RBHGgÁnwgRtÚv

yagvíleTAvíj b:uEnþBuMEmnenAeBlPøam²enHeT. BYkeK)anbEnßmfa «sRmab;eBlenH eyIgmanbBaða

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 43

Page 54: Brother enemy

CaeRcInEdlRtÚvedaHRsay eyIgmincg;[RBHGgÁcUlLÚkLMkñúgbBaðaenHeLIy ». CakarCak;c,as;

Nas;fa ExµrRkhmmincUlcitþRbfuyeRKaHfñak; edayyagsemþcmkkm<úCavíjeLIy. sb,úrsFm’ nig

RbCaRbiyPaBrbs;RBHGgÁ)aneFVI[ExµrRkhmP½y)armÖCaxøaMg. kñúgry³eBlEdlsemþc sIhnu enA

rg;caM ExµrRkhm)anbnþCemøósRbCaCnTaMgGs; ecjBITIRkúgTaMgtUcTaMgFM ehIyBRgayRbCaCnTIRkúg

«EdlcmøgemeraKedayBYkcRkBtþi nigBYkRbtikiriya »eTARKb;TisTI. enHKWCakarcab;epþImén «bdivtþn_

d¾l,Il,aj»mYy.

taMgBIkarcab;epþImcgsm<½n§PaBrbs;RBHGgÁenAqñaM1970 sm<½n§mitþExµrRkhmrbs;RBHGgÁ )an

cat;TuksemþcEdlFøak;BItMENgkñúgtYnaTIsamBaØFmµta EdlKµanGMNacBitR)akdeLIy. sMeNI

TaMgLayrbs;RBHGgÁmþgehIymþgeTot edIm,IyageFVITsSnkic©kñúgtMbn;EdlRtÜtRtaedayBYkT½BéRB

)anRtÚvbdiesFCajwkjy eRBaHEtmUlehtusnþisux. sRmab; «GtItRBHmhakSRt »RBHCnµ53RBH

vsSaGgÁenH GVIEdleFVI[FujRTan;CageK KWvtþmanenAekokkitCab;CaRbcaMénemExµrRkhmmñak;Edl

RBHGgÁFøab;s¥b;exI<mKW «bgelx2 » eGog sarI CatMNagclnatsU‘RbcaMkarenARkúgeb:kaMg EdleFVI[

RBHGgÁnwkeXIjdl; «BYkTIRbwkSa »)araMgEdltamRBHGgÁRbkitBIeRkayKµanQb;Qr eBjry³eBl

énbNþaqñaMEdlRBHGgÁFøab;eFVICaRBHmhakSRtGay:génRbeTsmYy EdlRtÜtRtaedayRbeTs)araMg

Edr. kñúg»kasénRBHraCd¿eNIreTAkan;RkúghaNUy kñúgqñaM1973 semþc sIhnu EdlTb;RBHT½yElg

)an )anbgá[man]bTÞvehtukarTUtmYyedaycg¥úlR)ab;elak hSg; RKIstUhV GUEb‘r ÉkGKÁrdæTUt

su‘yEGdRbcaMRkúghaNUy EdlGeBa¢IjmksaksYrsuxTukçsemþcenAnievsndæanrbs;RBHGgÁ nUvGñk

EdlcaMXøaMemIld¾twgEtgrbs;RBHGgÁenH. semþc)ant¥ÚjEt¥redaysMeLgmutRsYcfa «mnusSd¾KYr[

s¥b;rebob eGog sarI enH)ancMNayeBlevlaTaMgGs;rbs;Kat;edÍm,ItamykkarN_BI´ ». enAeBl

kMBugcakecjBIbnÞb; semþc)anmanbnÞÚleTotfa «sUmelakÉkGKÁraCTUtsmøwgemIlxageRkamvaMgnn

enH elaknwgeXIjcugEs,keCIgrbs;Kat;minxan KWKat;enAQrBIxageRkayenaHCanic© edÍm,IlYcsþab;

´manbnÞÚl». edayRtÚveFVI[TIeTIrkñúgcitþelak GUEb‘r BuMh‘anBinitüemIl[dwgfa Emnb¤BuMEmneLIy.

enAExmIna qñaM1973 ExµrRkhm)anRtÜtRtaTwkdIkm<úCamYyPaKy:agFM. karcuHhtßelxaelI

kic©RBmeRBógsnþiPaBRkúg):arIs mann½yfaCakarp¥akkarTmøak;RKab;EbkmYyrbs;GaemrikaMgenA

RbeTsevotNam. GMNwHteTA pøÚvlMhUCImijElgCapøÚvmaneRKaHfñak;eTotehIy. ehtuenH semþc

sIhnu )anRtÚvExµrRkhmGnuBaØat[eFVIRBHraCdMeNIrCaelIkdMbUgrbs;RBHGgÁmkkan;tMbn;rMedaHnana

enAkm<úCa. enHKWCakarlYgelamRBHT½ymYycMeBaHRBHGgÁ. b:uEnþ kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH RBHGgÁRTg;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg44

Page 55: Brother enemy

RCabfa RBHGgÁElgmantMENgmYykñúgkm<úCafµIEdlRtÜtRtaedayExµrRkhmeTotehIy. semþc nig

RBHmehsI m:Unik EtgRtÚv)antamdanedayBYkkmµaPi)alExµrRkhm dUcRsemalGenÞaltamR)aN

kñúgry³eBlénRBHraCdMeNIrrbs;RBHGgÁ edayminbeNþay[RBHGgÁTaMgBIrCYbR)aRs½yTak;Tg

CamYyRbCaCnpÞal;eLIy. RBHGgÁTteXIjEtTwkmuxKYr[xøacénhVÚgRbCaCnEdleKtRmÚv[mk

sRmab;EtelIkkNþab;édCasgVak;nigERskCyeXasb:ueNÑaH. semþcBMuGaceFVItamTmøab;BImun²rbs;

RBHGgÁ ³ KWkarRBElgRBHkaycUleTAkñúghVÚgmhaCnkan;Bal;GñkEdlmansVamIPkþi EdleramCMuCit

RBHGgÁkñúgsERmkfa ³ «semþc«²¡»eLIy.

CU eGnLay EdlCamitþnigCaGñkKaMBarsemþc)andwgy:agc,as;fa semþc)anGt;Fµt;TTYlrg

GMeBImYyTaMgGak;Gn;RBHT½y ehIy)anCYyrMElkkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;RBHGgÁcMeBaHBYkRCúlniymExµr

RkhmEdr. taMgBIExkumÖ³ qñaM1973 CU )anniyayR)ab; KIsSIúghÁ½r ¬rdæm®nþIkarbreTsGaemrik

GaNtþiRbFanaFibtI nicsun¦ Casm¶at;fa vahak;dUcCa «minGaceTArYcEdlfakm<úCaERbkøayeTACa

RkhmTaMgRsugenaH ». Kat;)ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa ³ ebIsinCaeKl,gBiesaFBIerOgenH eKKµan)anGVIeRkA

EtBIeFVI[bBaðaTaMgLaykan;EtsµúKsµajeLIy»1. tammtiKat;fa eKRtÚvEtdak;semþc[kan;GMNacenA

RkúgPñMeBjeLIgvij. b:uEnþkarb:unb:gTaMgb:unµanrbs;Kat; edIm,IjúaMg[shrdæGaemrikP¢ab;karCYbsnÞna

CamYysemþcsIhnuCafµI nigQaneTArkdMeNaHRsaysRmbsRmÜlmYyenaH)anRtÚvbraC½y. BIrqñaM

eRkaymk enAeBlEdlshrdæGaemrikyl;RBmTat;ecal ln; nl; nigesñIyagsemþcRtLb;cUlmatu

RbeTsvij cm,aMgT½BéRBrbs;ExµrRkhmQanCitdl;C½yCmñHeRsceTAehIy. RbFansßanebskkmµ

TMnak;TMngrbs;GaemrikenARkúgeb:kaMgKW elak hS½k b‘Us ¬eRkaymkCaRbFanaFitIshrdæGaemrikBIqñaM

1989-1993¦ tamry³sßanTUt)araMg CaGnþrkarI)anesñIsMu[semþc eLIgkan;cgáÚtdwknaMRbeTs

km<úCaGBüaRkwtmYy. enAéf¶TI11 Exemsa qñaM1975 shrdæGaemrik)anesñIedayCak;lak;[semþc

yagcUlRkúgPñMeBjvijtamynþehaHcinmYyeRKÓgehIyeLIgkan;GMNacenATIenaH. snþisuxpÞal;rbs;

RBHGgÁk¾RtÚv)anFanar:ab;rg. b:uEnþeBlenaHExµrRkhm)ancUlmkdl;mat;TVarTIRkúgeTAehIy ehIy CU

eGnLay k¾ElgGacyl;RsbtamEdr. enARBwkéf¶TI12 Exemsa qñaM1975 semþc sIhnu )an

bdiesFminTTYl «tgVay »rbs;GaemrikaMgenHeT. b:unµanem:agbnÞab;mk Rbtibtþikar «stV\®nÞIdkfy »

(Eagle Pull) )ancab;epþImkñúgsPaBbnÞan;bMputedIm,ICemøósbuKÁlikGaemrikaMg nigsm<n§½mitþExµrrbs;xøÜn

tam]T§mÖaKcRk. ElgmanGVIEdlRtÚveFVITaMgGs;. edayrMB£keLIgvijBIRBwtþikarN_enH semþc sIhnu

)aneFVIGtßaFib,ay edaysuPaBfa «yWteBlNas;eTAehIy».

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 45

Page 56: Brother enemy

xusEbøkBIqñaM1953 TukNaCaRBHGgÁseRmceCaKC½yTamTar)anÉkraCüBI)araMgk¾eday

k¾eBlenH semþc sIhnu ElgGaceFVIGVImYykñúgkardwknaMsgVak;RBwtþikarN_epSg² ehIyEfmTaMgminGac

kMNt;RBwtþikarN_TaMgenaHeTotpg. bTBiesaFn_TaMgLayEdlRbmUl)antaMgBIkareLIgesayraCü

rbs;RBHGgÁkalBI34qñaMmun ¬KitRtwmqñaM1975¦ hak;dUcCa\t)ankarGVITaMgGs;. enAqñaM1941

BYk)araMg)anseRmceRCIserIsExS neratþm KWsemþc neratþm sIhnu EdlmanRBHCnµ19RBHvsSa[

eLIgRKgraCüblø½g CaCagykKURbECgrbs;RBHGgÁxagExSsuIsuvtßi BIeRBaH)araMgeXIjfaRBHGgÁ

CayuvkSRtmYyGgÁRss;sgðaCageK. elakRsI dWKU enAeBlRkeLkeXIjsemþc sIhnu )an]Tan

eLIgfa ³ «KYr[RsLaj;Nas; ekµgtUcRcLwgenH¡ ». elakGKÁeTsaPi)al\NÐÚcin KW]tþmnavI)araMg

hSg;dWKU )ansMuyagRBHGgÁ[cUlrYmesayGaharéf¶Rtg;enAvimanrbs;elaknaTIRkúgéRBnKr.

yuvkSRtd¾Rss;sgðaGgÁenH)anepþImRbLÚkkñúgqakneya)ayedayqab;rh½s. muxtMENgrbs;

RBHGgÁ)anpþl;nUvkarGnueRKaH[RBHGgÁvijy:ageRcIn. semþc)ancat;kary:agqøatedIm,IdeNþIm

«kEnøg »KNbkSneya)aykm<úCanana EdlCaGñkTamTaredayTTUcnUvkarbBa©b;GaNaBüa)alrbs;

)araMg ehIyeFVI[eKeCOfabuBVehtuCatiniymCabuBVehtupÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁ. ÉkraCüPaBEdlRBHGgÁ

GHGagnwgRbFanaFibtI)araMg vuaMgsg; GUrIy:Ul (1947-1954) nigrdæm®nþIkarbreTsGaemrik hSn hVÚsÞ½r

Dul (1953-1959) KWCameFüa)ayseRmceCaKC½yEtmYyKt;RbqaMgTl;nwgBYkkumµúynIsþ BIeRBaHfa BYk

enH suT§EtCamnusSdMbUg²eK Edlkan;Tg;C½ykñúgkarRbyuT§RbqaMgGaNaniKmniym. RBHGgÁecHeRbI

R)as;sarB½t’manGnþrCati ehIyseRmc)anply:agsem,ImGs©arü dUcCaenAeBlEdlRBHGgÁnireTs

xøÜnedaysµ½RKRBHT½y edIm,IeFVI[BYk)araMgFøak;eTAkñúgsßanPaBlM)ak nigRbmUl)anyuT§ikCny:ageRcIn

EdleCOCak;elIbuBVehturbs;RBHGgÁCaedIm. TIbMput enAExvicäika qñaM1953 BYk)araMg)anRbKl;

ÉkraCümk[RBHGgÁvij rYcehIysemþc)anbUCafamBlrbs;RBHGgÁedIm,IvayRbyuT§nwgevotmij

EdldwknaMedayhUCImijEfmeTot.

kñúgry³eBl17qñaMEdlkñúgfirevlaenaH semþcCaGñkRKb;RKgRbeTskm<úCa RBHGgÁ)andwknaM

RbeTskñúgsPaBeBjeljTaMgRsug. edIm,Ikan;kab;GMNacTaMgRsugkñúgzan³CaRBHRbmuxrdæCaCagkñúg

zan³CaRBHmhakSRtGaRs½yrdæFmµnuBaØ enAqñaM1960 semþc sIhnu )andak;raCüedayelIkRBHbita

RBHGgÁ[eLIgRKgraCüvij. KµanGVImYyEdlminsMxan;cMeBaHRBHGgÁeLIy ³ RBHGgÁsresrbTvicarN

kfaCaeRcIncuHpSaykñúgkaEst dwknaMeFVIKeRmagkarkúñgvis½yneya)ayTwknigksagmNÐlsuxPaB

y:ageRcInenAtamCnbTTaMgLay. KWRBHGgÁenHehIyCaGñkeRCIserIs«smµtinam »¬eQµaHeRkA¦ dak;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg46

Page 57: Brother enemy

[KNbkSnanaEdlRbqaMgCMTas;nwgGMNacpÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁenaH ³ ExµrexovsRmab;ehABYkRbqaMgsþaM

niym b¤saFarNrdæniym ExµrRkhmsRmab;ehABYkmanninñakarniymeqVgRCúl edayecaTRbkan;Gñk

TaMgenaHfa suT§EtCarNbbreTs. RBHGgÁtamGMBl;ExµrRkhmKµanQb;Qr edaysakl,gyk

BYkenaHbBa©ÚlmkkñúgrdæaPi)alrbs;RBHGgÁeTAtamkal³eTs³huc[. ehtuenHehIy)anCaenAedIm

TsvtSr_60 emdwknaMrbs;BYkenHCaeRcInnak;dUcCa exov sMpn/ h‘U yn;/ h‘U nwm RtÚv)anEtgtaMgCa

rdæm®nþIkñúgrdæaPi)alrbs;RBHGgÁ. xagkñúgRbeTs RBHGgÁ)ansakl,g «pþac;eCIg »BYkniymeqVgRCúl

edayepþImbegáItclnamYyEdlmanlkçN³BiessxusEbøkBIFmµtaKW «sgÁmniymRBHBuT§sasna »Edl

kñúgkarRbRBwtþKWCaPaBpþac;muxmYyrbs;rdækan;kab;edayvrCnmñak; EdleRcInBukrlYyb¤CamnusSrs;enA

edaysareK. enAeRkARbeTs RBHGgÁecHsEmþgtYCa «GñkEsVgrk[mantulüPaBkmøaMg »edIm,IkarBar

ÉkraCüPaBnigbUrNPaBEdndIrbs;RbeTskm<úCa. b:uEnþs®gÁamenAevotNamkMBugraldaly:agxøaMg

ehIybBaðaepSg²kñúgRbeTsk¾kMBugkan;EtdundabxøaMgNas;Edr enATIbMput semþc sIhnu EdlCa «Gñk

EsVgrk[mantulüPaBkmøaMg »)anbraC½ykñúgerOgenH. edIm,IbMeBjcitþevotNamxageCIgEdlRBHGgÁ

cat;TukCaGñkmanC½yCmñHBitR)akdkñúgCemøaHenH ehIyEdlkñúgenaHRBHGgÁTteXIjkmøaMgfµIegIbeLIg

enA\NÐÚcineTotenaH RBHGgÁRtÚvEtBt;GBüaRkwtPaBrbs;RTg;[ep¥ógeTArkeK edayyl;RBmpþl;

TICRmkenAtamRBMEdn nigGnuBaØat[BYkenaHnaMGavuFqøgkat;tamRckkMBg;Ep¬kMBg;esam¦rbs;km<úCa

EfmeTot. GMeBIBukrlYy karRKb;RKgesdækic©Catiminl¥ nigkar)at;bg;CMnYyrbs;GaemrikaMg)an

bNþal[mankarrvatcitþxagneya)ay. karekIneLIgkñúgRbeTsnUvPaBRbTUsr:aycMeBaHvtþmanrbs;

evotNam )anRtwmEtdutkMhwg[qabeqHeLIgEfmeTotb:ueNÑaH. CamYynwgkarKaMRTCasm¶at;rbs;

shrdæGaemrik ]tþmesnIy_ ln; nl; )aneFVI[semþcxÞatecjBIGMNackñúgeBlEdlRBHGgÁyag

RtLb;BIkarsRmakBüa)alRBHeraKenARbeTs)araMg edaykat;tamTIRkúgmUsÁÚmkvij. RtÚvCMrujeday

evotNamnigcin RBHGgÁ)anCYyeRCamERCg[manclnats‘UmYy ehIyykTIRkúgeb:kaMgCalMenAsßan

beNþaHGasnñrbs;RBHGgÁ.

enArdUvekþAqñaM1975 semþc sIhnu )andNþwgsYrkñúgRBHT½yfa etIlMenAsßanbeNþaHGasnñenH

manlkçN³sm,tþilµmnwgkøayCaGcié®nþy_Emnb¤>>>? xusEbøkBIbNþaesþcEdlRtÚveKTmøak;BItMENg

RBHGgÁBMumanKNnINamYyenAÉFnaKarbreTssRmab;eRbIR)as;tamesckþIRtÚvkareLIy. dUecñH

RBHGgÁKµankareRCIserIsNaepSgeTot eRkAEtBIyl;RBmTTYlkar[sñak;enAedayesckþIsb,úrsBI

bNþamitþcinnigkUer:xageCIgb:ueNÑaH. em:A nig CU )anFanaGHGagnwgRBHGgÁfa semþcGacKg;Rbfab;enA

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 47

Page 58: Brother enemy

RbeTscinkñúgry³eBlyUrEfmeTottamEtRBHGgÁsBVRBHT½y. RbFanaFibtI KIm GuIls‘ug )ansßabna

vimand¾sáwmésámYyEbrmuxeTArkbwgqags‘UGun enATIRkúgBüúgy:agsRmab;fVayRBHGgÁKg;Rbfab;Ca

kitþiys. enAExkBaØa qñaM1975 semþc sIhnu )anKg;enAkñúgTIRkúgenHenAeBlEdl]bnaykrdæm®nþI

exov sMpn nigrdæm®nþIRksYgB½t’man eGog FIriT§ énrdæaPi)alrYbrYmCatikm<úCa CardæaPi)alnireTsEdl

begáIteLIgedaysemþcshkarCamYyExµrRkhm)aneTAdl;TIenaHedaynaMsarlixitmYysMuyagsemþc

RtLb;mkRbeTsvij EdlRBHGgÁTnÞwgrg;caMtaMgBIyUrmkehIy. xøwmsarénsarlixitrbs; exov sMpn

mandUcteTA «\LÚvenHeyIgeRtómxøÜnCaeRsc edIm,IsVaKmn_semþcedayrak;Tak;bMput. GMNwHteTA

lkçN³sm,tþiepSg²)anRtÚvbMeBjrYcral;Gs;ehIy EdleFVI[eyIgTaMgGs;KñakøayeTACaCnkumµúy

nIsþ100PaKry. eyIgGaceRKagKiteFVI[elIsBYkcinCabgb¥ÚneTAeTot. mhaelatepøaHEtmYy

CMhaneTAmux eyIgGacQaneTAdl;dMNak;kalkumµúynIsþ)anedayerobcMesdækic©tamliT§isgÁmniym

CadMNak;²». RbkarenHmanlkçN³KYr[RBÜy)armÖbgÁÜr b:uEnþ eTaHCay:agNak¾eday k¾semþc

sb,ayRBHT½yvilmkmatuRbeTsvijEdr.

semþcGñkmñag mU:nik nig eGog FIriT§ )anCiHrfePøIgmkkan;Rkúgeb:kaMgCamYyKñaEdlenATIenaH

ynþehaHb‘UGuIg-707rbs;cinmYyeRKÓgcaMCUndMeNIrmkkan;RkúgPñMeBjeTot. munnwgcakecjBI

rdæFanIcin semþcRBmTaMgmehsIEdlGmdMeNIreday exov sMpn )aneTAsYrsuxTukçRbFan em:A nig

naykrdæm®nþITI1 CU eGnLay Edr. kñúgGayu82qñaM¬GayukalBIqñaM1975¦ em:A )anTTYlrgkar

QWcab;edaysarCMgW ):arKInsun (KWCMgWFøak;Tn;exSayEpñkRbBn§½srésRbsaTmanlkçN³smÁal;eday

karj½rTeRTIk nigPaBrwgqáWténsac;duM-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb). karniyaysþIrbs;Kat;mansPaB

swgEtminGac[eKsþab;yl;)an. b:uEnþy:agehacNas; esckþIENnaMmYykñúgcMeNamesckþIENnaM

CaeRcInrbs;Kat;cMeBaH exov sMpn nig eGog FIriT§ KWmansPaBc,as;las;Nas; «´sUmsmmitþemtþa

kMubBa¢Únsemþc sIhnu nigRBHmehsI [eTArs;enAkñúgshkrN_ ». BaküsmþIrbs;Kat;TaMgenH)anCYy

se®gÁaHsemþc sIhnu [rYcputBIeRKaHfñak;dl;CIvit.

CU RtÚvyayIedayCMgWmharIk rs;enAdUcdak;KukxøÜnÉg. Kat;)anTTUcsuM exov sMpn edaysMeLg

mYyEdlswgEtsþab;minB¤fa «sUmsmmitþeFVId¿eNIreTAkan;lT§ikumµúynIsþedaysnSwm². smmitþBuMGac

QaneLIglT§ikumµúynIsþedayBuMmand¿Nak;kalepSg²enaHeT b:uEnþpÞúyeTAvíjKWRtÚvedÍrmYyCMhan

mþg². sUmsmmitþerobcMCMhantUc²[)aneRcInedayel,ÓnyWt² b:uEnþR)akdRbCa ». GVIEdleFVI[

eKcab;GarmµN_xøaMgEfmeTotenaH KWd¿bUnµanrbs;Kat;Edl[dwgehtumunfa «kuMeFVItamKMrUGaRkk;énneya

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg48

Page 59: Brother enemy

)aymhaelatepøaHrbs;eyIg ». enHCaBaküniyaybBaäitbeBaäóg cMeBaHKeRmagkard¾hYsvis½ymYy

KWkarb:unb:gksaglT§ikumµúynIsþ[)anPøam²enARbeTscin EdlbNþal[esdækic©cinexSaHrIgérenAcug

stvtSr_50. sMpn nig FIriT§ esIcjwm²rebobsmKMnitKña ehIysemþc sIhnu EdlFøab;B¤Gñk

TaMgBIrGYtfa)ancab;epþImGnuvtþlT§ikumµúynIsþEdrenaH GacdwgBIn½yénkarjjwmenHehIy.

éf¶TI9 ExkBaØa qñaM1975 Rkúgeb:kaMg)anerobcMeFVIBiFIbuNüGbGrmþgeTot. enAelITIlan

eTonGanem:n eKeXIjTg;Cati eKamFM²nigbdaCaeRcInedIm,IEføgGMNrsresIrnUvGVIEdl etg s‘avBIg

ehAfa «karCYbCuMKñaeLIgvijRbkbedaykitþiys »rbs; semþc sIhnu. ynþehaHcin)anepþImbnÞabxøÜn

cuHctelIGakasyandæaneBaFicintug. enHCaelIkdMbUgehIyEdlsemþcTteXIjraCFanIrbs;RBHGgÁ

BIelIynþehaHtaMgEtBIRBHGgÁcakecjenAExmkra qñaM1970mk. ebIeRbóbeFobnwgmnusSrab;Ban;

muWnnak;EdlQrelIkédCasBaØamitþPaB tampøÚveBlEdlRBHGgÁyagecjdMeNIrBITIRkúgeb:kaMgnwghVÚg

mnusSEdlQrray):aycaMTTYlRBHGgÁtampøÚvBIeBaFicintugmkRkúgPñMeBjenaH KWGñkTaMgenHsuT§Et

manTwkmuxesøksøaMgKYr[q¶l;. RBHsgÇBIr-bIGgÁRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[sURtCyenþafVayRBHGgÁ bnÞab;mk

k,ÜnrfynþmYy)anGmkarBarrfynþRBHGgÁeFVIdMeNIrqøgkat;TIRkúgmYy EdlmansPaBs¶at;RCgM. enH

Cakarpþl;kitþiyseTAtamRbéBNICaelIkcugeRkay EdleKeFVI[RBHGgÁTteXIjkñúgRbeTskm<úCarbs;

ExµrRkhm.

semþc)anRtÚveFVI[rMCYlRBHT½yrhUtRsk;TwkRBHenRtenAeBlEdlRTg;TteXIjTIRkúgexµacenH

EdlkalBIedImCaTIRkúgd¾Rss;RtkalbMputén\NÐÚcinrbs;)araMg. mhavifInanaEdlGmedayedImeQI

FM² sYnc,arTaMgLaynigkMBUlRsYcénRBHbrmraCvaMg vtþGaramsuT§EtenAl¥s¥atTaMgGs; b:uEnþhak;dUcCa

eRkómRkMrebobkan;Tukç. ExµrRkhm)anbkRsayCUnsemþcfa ³ «karCemøósRbCaCnKWCakarcaM)ac;

BIeRBaHTIRkúgElgGacciBa©wmRbCaCnrbs;xøÜn)aneTotehIy ehIybBaðasnþisuxk¾minGacedaHRsay

)anEdr ». BYkenHmin)anTUlRBHGgÁfa KWRtg;enHÉgCaneya)aymhaelatepøaHdMbUgbMputeq<aHeTA

kan;lT§ikumµúynIsþeLIy. kñúgkarcakecjTaMghVÚg²enAExemsa qñaM1975 semþcRkúmRBH munIer:t Ca

RBHbitulasemþc sIhnu RBmTaMgRBHmatucäamYyGgÁkñúgcMeNamRBHmatucäaCaeRcInrbs;RBHGgÁ)anRtÚv

ExµrRkhmbBa¢Ún[eTArs;enACnbTdUcRbCaCndéT²eTotEdr. kñúgeBlEdlRBHGgÁsuMeTAsYrsuxTukçGñk

TaMgenaH eK)anCMTas;edaykarbdiesFy:agKYrsmmYyfa ³ «maneKemIlEfTaMGñkTaMgenaHl¥ehIy.

RBHGgÁnwgRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[eTA)an enAeBlNaEdlRBHGgÁvilRtLb;BITIRkúgjÚvy:kmkvij ».

RBHGgÁElg)anCYbGñkTaMgenaHmþgeTotCaerogrhUt. kñúgyuT§sa®sþrbs;ExµrRkhm karsñak;GaRs½y

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 49

Page 60: Brother enemy

rbs;semþc sIhnu cMnYnbIs)aþh_enATIRkúgPñMeBj)anbMeBjeKaledAd¾Cak;lak;mYy. enaHKWCakareFVI

[eKTTYlsÁal;tampøÚvkarnUvkarRbDitkarcUlrYmrbs;RBHGgÁCamYyrdæGMNacfµImuneBlRBHGgÁyageTA

TamTarGasn³rbs;km<úCaenAÉmhasnñi)atGgÁkarshRbCaCati. semþc nigGñkEhhmRBHGgÁ)an

RtÚvyag[eFVIdMeNIreTscrN_tamdgTenøemKgÁedaymanerobcMBiFICb;elogd¾GFikGFmCakitþiysdl;

RBHGgÁpg ehIy)ansuMyagRBHGgÁnigraCbriBarcUlrYmraRtIsemasrbdivtþCaeRcIn b:uEnþGñkTaMgenaH

minEdl)anCYbGñkEdlFøab;rs;enATIRkúgNamñak;eLIy. GVI²)anrlay)at;dUcCaEpSg.

semþc sIhnu RTg;RCaby:agqab;rh½snUvGVIEdlExµrRkhmeFVItamd¿bUnµanrbs; CU eGnLay nig

sarsMxan;énkareFVIdMeNIredaysnSwm²eq<aHeTAkan;lT§isgÁmniym. sun esn GKÁesnaFikar kgT½B

nig exov sMpn )anTUlR)ab;RBHGgÁfa km<úCanwgbgðaj[BiPBelakeXIjfa eyIgerobcM[mansNþab;

Fñab;EtmYyxVac; nigy:agdac;RsLH eyIgmanlT§PaBGacQaneTAdl;lT§ikumµúynIsþ. GñkTaMgBIr)an

TUl[RBHGgÁdwgeTotfa «eFVIdUecñHeQµaHrbs;km<úCanwgRtÚv)ancarwkedayGkSrmaskñúgRbvtþisa®sþ

BiPBelakkñúgzan³CaRbeTsdMbUgeKbMput EdlseRmc)aneCaKC½ykñúgkarbegáItlT§ikumµúynIsþ eday

mincaM)ac;mand¿Nak;kalepSg²Edl\tRbeyaCn_eLIy».

enAedImExtula eBlyagRtLb;mkTIRkúgeb:kaMgvij semþc sIhnu )anpþl;dl;bNþasmaCik

raCvgSanuvgS nigGñkCitsñiT§rbs;RBHGgÁnUvesrIPaBkñúgkarseRmccitþ. rUbRBHGgÁpÞal;kñúgzan³CaGñk

esñhaCati nigCaRbmuxrdæ semþcnwgRtLb;eTAkm<úCavij bnÞab;BI)aneFVICatMNagRbeTsrbs;RBHGgÁ

enAÉGgÁkarshRbCaCatirYcehIy. b:uEnþ sRmab;GñkÉeTot RBHGgÁ)anTukesrIPaB[eRCIserIsTIkEnøg

rs;enAedayxøÜnÉgcuH. shkarIrbs;RBHGgÁCaeRcInnak;EdltUccitþy:agxøaMg edaysarGVIEdlBYkeK

eTIbnwg)ansmÁal;eXIjfµI² minh‘anvilmkPñMeBjvijeT ehIy)ancakecjeq<aHeTAkan;RbeTs)araMg

Etmþg.

semþc sIhnu pÞal;)anyagRtLb;mkRbeTsvijedayyagqøgkat;tamTIRkúg):arIs. CnCati

ExµrmYyhVÚgFM)anmkrg;caMTTYlsVaKmn_RBHGgÁenAGakasyandæansðaldWehÁal. bnþiceRkaymk

PaKeRcInkñúgcMeNamCnCatiExµrTaMgenaH)anmkCYbCMuKñaenAnievsndæanrbs;ÉkGKÁrdæTUtkm<úCaRbcaMTIRkúg

):arIs edIm,ITTYlB½t’mansMxan;²BIRBHGgÁsþIBIskmµPaBrbs;RbeTseRkamrbbBYkExµrRkhm. Gñk

TaMgGs;enaHegOgq¶l;BIPaBRbyt½ñRbEygrbs;RBHGgÁy:agxøaMg EdltamTmøab;KWRBHGgÁmansPaB

ekøóvkøaNas;. CnCatiExµrmñak;)ansYrRBHGgÁfa etITahanrbs; ln; nl; køayeTACay:agNaGs;eTA

ehIy?. RBHGgÁ)aneqøIytbfa GgÁkar ¬KWbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCad¾manGMNacbMput¦ )anpþl;[eK

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg50

Page 61: Brother enemy

mñak;²nUvkenÞlmYynigmugmYy ehIybBa¢Ún[eTAeFVIERsTaMgGs;. RBHGgÁ)anbEnßmfa ³ tamRBHGgÁ

yl; TahanTaMgenaH)anRtwmEtGVIEdlBYkeKs½kþismnwg)anb:ueNÑaH. eGog sarI EdlenAGgÁúyEk,r

RBHGgÁjjwmCab; ehIyBYkemdwknaMExµrRkhmdéTeTot2 )angk;k,alyl;Rsb. KµanGtItmitþPkþi

rbs;semþcNamñak;Gacqøgkat; «ExSsnþisux »Edllatsn§wg edayExµrRkhmenACMuvijRBHGgÁeLIy.

BMumankarCYbsnÞnaKñaCalkçN³ÉkCneT. dUecñHsemþc sIhnu manGarmµN_minl¥eRsceTAehIy cMeBaH

GVIEdlenArg;caMRBHGgÁ. b:uEnþ emaTnPaB nigkardwgBIkrNIykic©rbs;RBHGgÁ)anrIkeLIgy:agxøaMg edIm,I

Gacnwg[semþce)aHbg;ecalkargarenAeBleRkay. enAExFñÚ qñaM1975 semþc sIhnu EdlGm

edaymehsI m:Unik RBHmataekµk b:um RBmTaMgRBHraCbuRt nigRBHraCntþa¬ecA¦cMnYn22GgÁ)anvil

RtLb;mkkan;RkúgPñMeBjvij.

PaBCasRtÚvnwgKñad¿bUg 51

Page 62: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg52

Page 63: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI2dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr

enAeBlEdlGVI²mandMeNIrkareTAy:agl¥ k¾RkúghaNUyminsUvmanlkçN³rIkrayxøaMgEdr.

k¾b:uEnþ enAeBlEdlPaBRtCak;mutdl;q¥wgmYybgçM[RbCaBlrdærbs;xøÜn EdlesøókBak;esÞIrminCitxøÜn

R)aN[sßitenAEtkñúgpÞH TIRkúghak;dUcCarwtEtetaky:ak nigs¶at;RCgMEfmeTotCamYynwgrukçvifInana

EdlGmeTAedayedImeQInigTidæPaBcas;RTúDeRTamrbs;xøÜn. GñkCiHkg;)anFak;kg;y:aglM)ak xñgeLIg

ekag k,alRKbdNþb;kñúgkEnSgEvgsRmab;ruMknigcgáakuM[rga b¤GavyWt rwbxøÜnédEvgRKbdNþb;elIsµa

TaMgBIr. CamYyGaveramsMLI eRsamédnigkg;m:akr:aeLk (Raleigh) PøWrelagrbs;´ Edl´x©IBIGñkkarTUt

mñak; ´hak;dUcCamanGarmµN_cg;edIrlMEhbnþickñúghVÚgmnusS EdlminsUvniyaysþI nigEdlkMBugrga

jak;kñúgeBleFVIcracr. tamrfynþ PaBEbøkBIeKénsemøókbMBak;rbs;´ minsUveFVI[GñkdMeNIrkt;

smÁal;eT. ´)anseRmccitþElgRtÚvkarrfynþm:akv:ulv:U BN’RbepH EdlCYlBImnÞIreTscrN_Rkúg

haNUy Edl´RtÚvkareRbIR)as;sRmab;kareFVIdMeNIrCapøÚvkarepSg²rbs;´ ehIy´)an[mKÁúeTÞsk_

rbs;´enARksYgkarbreTsRtLb;eTAvij edayykelsfa ´BuMmankarNat;CYbKñaNamYyenAeBl

resolenHeT. b:uEnþenAéf¶TI23 Exvicäika qñaM1977enH ´mankarCYbKñatamkarNat;edaylYclak;

mYy EdlBitCamineFVI[rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNamsb,aycitþeT.

RBHGaTitü)anecalrsµIy:agRsTn;enAeBlresolenHEdlmanxül;bk;e)akCanic©. ´)ancak

ecjBIsNæaKarfugjiút edaylblak;min[eKdwg ehIytRmg;eq<aHeTAsßanTUtkm<úCaRbCaFibetyükñúg

RkúghaNUy. evotNamnigkm<úCa)anbnþpøas;bþÚrkarCUnBrsBÞsaFukarKñaeTAvijeTAmkkñúgéf¶R)arB§

BiFIbuNüCatierog²xøÜn b:uEnþTMnak;TMngrbs;BYkeK)anFøak;cuHy:agCak;c,as;. kareFVIdMeNIrrbs; b:ul

Bt eTARkúgeb:kaMgenAExtula karvayRbharRtg;²EdlesÞIrEtminbiT)aMgrbs;emdwknaMkm<úCaRbqaMg

nwgevotNam suT§EtCakarGHGagbEnßmCasaFarN³elIkdMbUgkñúgkarTas;ETgKñarbs;xøÜn. kñúgGMLúg

eBlQb;sMctry³xøImYyenARkúgevogc½nÞ ¬rdæFanIRbeTsLav¦ kñúgdMeNIreq<aHeTAkan;RkúghaNUyenaH

´)ansþab;B¤CaelIkdMbUgnUvsmþIrbs;GñkkarTUtevotNammñak;Edlerobrab;bBa¢ak;BIkarQøanBany:ag

eXareXARbqaMgnwgevotNamedayExµrRkhmkalBIb:unµanExfµI²enH. dUecñH´RtÚvRbjab;sþab;kar

bkRsayrbs;ExµrRkhmmþg. GñkkarTUtCnCati muicsuikmñak;EdlCitsñiT§nwgExµrRkhm)anerobcM[´

CYbCamYy Guin suIvuF CaTIRbwkSaneya)ayRbcaMsßanTUtkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. BIcm¶ayeKemIleXIj

53

Page 64: Brother enemy

Tg;CatiBN’RkhmQamrbs;sßanTUtbk;rvic²tamCMenarxül;enAelIPUmiRKwHmYyEdlmanrcnab½TµEbb

GaNaniKm. bg¥ÜcTaMgGs;énRKwHsßanenHsuT§EtbiTCitsøúg. xageRkAnigkñúgbrievNenaHeKBMueXIjman

skmµPaBNamYyeLIy elIkElgEtb:UlisevotNammñak;EdlQryamenAmat;RckTVarcUl esøókBak;

ÉksNæanBN’Gacm_esH nigBak;mYkrebobmYkGaNaniKmb:ueNÑaH. Kat;esÞIrEtminykcitþTukdak;nwg

´eLIy eBlEdl´cuHBIelIkg;edIreTArkTVarEdksßanTUt. kargarrbs;Kat;dUcKñanwgkargarrbs;qµaMEdl

yamkarBarenAmuxsßanTUtbrTsÉeTot²enARkúghaNUyEdr KWXat;XaMgmin[RbCaCnevotNam cUl

eTACitTIenaHeT. fVIebIkg;´mins½kþismnwgkarykcitþTukdak;rbs;Kat;k¾eday k¾´CaCn breTsmñak;y:ag

BitR)akd.

´cuckNþwgQrcaMmYysnÞúH bnþiceRkaymk TVarsßanTUt)anRtÚvebIkeLIgy:agRbúgRby½tñ eday

begðIbEtBIrb¤bIsg;TIEm:Rtb:ueNÑaH. tamRbeLaHbegðIb EPñkmYyKUsmøk;smøwg´TMngCacg;sYr rYcsMNYr

mYykñúgsMeLgfb;²)anbnøWfa ³ «elak can;da EmneT?». TVarebIkcMheLIgy:agrh½slµm[´cUleTA

kñúgrYcehIy)anbiTBIeRkayxñg´vijy:agrh½s. enAeBlEdlEPñkrbs;´Tmøab;)annwgBnøWd¾xøaMgenATVar

cUl ´GacemIlsÁal; Guin suIvuF y:agc,as;. enAxagkñúgsßanTUtmansPaBhak;dUcCayb;eTAehIy.

cegáógmYyEdlBüÜrenABitan)anCHBnøWCargVg;mYykñúgkariyal½yeFVIkarEdlmansPaBRsTMCab;. bg¥Üc

TaMgGs;RtÚvbiTy:agCit ehIyvaMgnnbg¥Ück¾TajbiTCitEdr. suIvuF CamnusSmaDtUc sÁm GayuRbEhl

Cag40qñaM )anesIcjjwmTaMgmYhµgkñúgcitþ. Kat;)anBnül;´CaPasa)araMg\tqÁgfa ³ «GVI²Edl

elakeXIjenH KWCakarcaM)ac;edIm,IbeBa©ósevotNamkMu[ykkarN_BIeyIg)an». suIvuF niyayBIExµr

RkhmtictYcNas;. Kat;minEdlcUléRBm:aKIts‘UmþgNaesaHeLIy. Kat;)ankøayeTACaCnkumµúynIsþ

ehIycUlrYmCamYyExµrRkhmtaMgBIsm½y EdlKat;eronsURtenATIRkúg):arIsem:øH. kñúgry³eBlénkar

sñak;GaRs½yd¾yUrrbs;Kat;enARkúg):arIs Kat;)andwgerOgr:avy:ageRcInsþIBIRkúmes>GIu>Ga nigmeFüa-

)ayepSg²EdlRkúmenHmansRmab;eRbIR)as;pg. Kat;yl;eXIjfa BYkPñak;garesuIbkarN_Gac

cab;karsnÞnaKñaBIcm¶ay)anedayeRbIRbBn§½rlksBaØamYyEdlqøúHRtLb;eTAvijtamkBa©k;bg¥Üc. tam

mtiKat;fa ³ «BYkbisac »evotNamTaMgenHBitCabegáIteRKÓgtUc²RbePTdUcKñaenaH edIm,IQøbyk

karN_BIsßanTUtkm<úCa edayeRbImeFüa)ayeGLicRtÚnicenH. kñúgsemøókbMBak;BN’etñatrebob em:A/

Guin suIvuF GgÁúy Rtg;PøwgelIekAGIBUkFMmYy edayniyayxSwb²R)ab;´BIrebobEdlevotNam «k,t; »

nwgkm<úCaEbbNaxøH. «enAqñaM1973 eBlEdlevotNamcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógsnþiPaBenA

TIRkúg):arIsCamYyshrdæGaemrik evotNam)ansakl,gbgçM[eyIgcrcaCamYy ln; nl;. TIRbwkSa

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg54

Page 65: Brother enemy

neya)ayrUbenH)anrMB£kkñúgsñamjjwmrebobQWcab;mYyfa ³ témøEdleKRtÚvbg;[eyIgcMeBaHkar

eFVImindwgminB¤BIkar[eyabl;enH KWkarsRmbsRmÜlmYyrvagevotNamnigBYkGaemrikaMgenHÉg.

hVÚgynþehaHeb-52 EdlFøab;Tmøak;RKab;EbkenAevotNam )anRtÚvbBa¢Ún[mkTmøak;RKab;EbkenA

km<úCaTaMgGs;kñúgry³eBlR)aMExknøH».

munnwgRtÚvEtgtaMg[mkkan;RkúghaNUy suIvuF Føab;)aneFVIkarenAsßanTUténraCrdæaPi)alrYbrYm

Catikm<úCaRbcaMRkúgeb:kaMgGs;CaeRcInqñaMmkehIy. cab;taMgBIC½yCmñHrbs;ExµrRkhmKat;BMuEdlman

»kasRtLb;mkkm<úCaedIm,Irs;enAEk,rkUnnigRbBn§rbs;Kat;eLIy. Kat;)ansarPaBR)ab;´fa mYy

qñaMknøHmkehIyEdlKat;BuMEdl)anTTYldMNwgbnþicNaesaHBIRKÜsarrbs;Kat;. Kat;niyaydUceTIs

Tal;kñúgcitþR)ab;´eTotfa ³ Kat;)andwgBIRBwtþikarN_nanaenAkm<úCaKW edaysarEtsþab;viTüúPñMeBj

b:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþ PaBmindwgBIehtukarN_epSg²rbs;Kat;)anTUTat;mkvijy:agTUlMTUlay edayesckþI

TukcitþRbEhlKµanRBMEdncMeBaHKat; EdlmanenAkñúgkartRmg;Tisbdivtþn_EdlRbkan;ykedayRbeTs

CatiKat;. edaybeNþjRbCaCn[ecjGs;BITIRkúgnana nigbBa¢ÚnmnusSTaMgGs;[eTAeFVIERs GgÁkar

)anRbkan;yksßanPaBneya)ayelIkMNat;pøÚvd¾lM)ak b:uEnþs½kþisiT§iKWneya)ay «ÉkraCüm©as;kar ».

CamYykarjjwmmYyrebobeBbRCay Kat;)anbEnßmfa ³ «evotNamElgGacykeyIgdak;[sßitenA

eRkamGMNaceKeTotehIy ». RbeTskm<úCaBMuEmnRbeTsLaveT. Kat;eCOCak;fa sn§isBaØamitþPaB

Lav-evotNamEdlcuHhtßelxaenAExkkáda qñaM1976 )anrYmbgáCadMNak;kaldMbUgkñúgkareFVI

GaNaniKmeTAelIRbeTsLav. etIelakcg;eXIjGVIEdlekIteLIgknøgmkehIyeT? eBlenaHKat;cab;

ykRkdaskaEstLavmYysnøwkEdlsßitenAelItudak;GaharmYy. «P½sþútag » KWrUbKøIesSmYyEdl

bgðaj[eXIjRbCaksikrLavkMBugsÞÚgRsUv. suIvuF )anGHGagedaycg¥úlmnusSmñak;enAelIrUbft

EdlBak;mYkdYn rebobksikrevotNamfa «evotNam)ankan;kab;ERsrbs;ksikrLavtaMgBIeBlenH

eTAehIy ». tamKat;yl; eKalbMNgepSg²rbs;evotNammkelI\NÐÚcinnwgeTAÉg². P½sþútagKW

mYkdYnEtmYyKt;EdlKat;rkeXIjkñúgCYrksikrLav BuMbeRmIGVIeRkAEtBIbBaÄb;karminRBmeCOGVI²TaMgGs;

rbs;breTsb:ueNÑaH.

Pøam²enaH kareBalGagnigP½sþútagsþIBI «karelaPln; » nig «karevock,t; »TaMgGs;rbs;BYk

evotNam)anERbeTACakarEføgCasaFarN³BIkareCOCak;rbs;xøÜneTAvij ³ critevotNammanlkçN³

«GaRkk;CYCati »BIkMeNIt karRbQmmuxc,as;Caecosminput ebIsinRbCaCnExµrcg;RbyuT§ edIm,IPaB

Kg;vgSrbs;xøÜn. karBiBN’naEtcMNucsMxan;²Edl suIvuF niyayR)ab;´enAeBlresolenH )aneFVI[

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 55

Page 66: Brother enemy

´EdlGgÁúykñúgkariyal½yggwtsøúbrbs;Kat;dwgy:agc,as;R)akdfa ehtukarN_epSg² )anERbRbÜl

bnþicbnþÜcb:ueNÑaH. eRkamsMbkénesckþIKYrsmEdlPøWrelagEteRkA nigBIeRkaykarniyayrMBgBI

liT§m:akSsuIsniym Edlbgáb;eTAedayKMnMuRbvtþisa®sþmingayrebH nigKMniterIseGIgCatisasn_enaH

KWGVI²enAEtmanlkçN³CaRBlwgExµrCanic©.

«kMueFVI[kMBb;TwkEtecAhVay»

cMeBaHedImkMeNIténbdibkçPaBerIseGIgCatisasn_rvagRbCaCnExµrnigevotNam eK)anrk

eXIjehtukarN_Edlbgá[man)atuPUtenHCitmYyBan;qñaMmkehIy enAkñúgkarTak;TgKñarvagRbCaCn

TaMgBIr. mYyPaKbIcugeRkayénRbvtþisa®sþenH RtÚv)ankt;smÁal;edaykarRbyuT§KñarvagcRkPB

evotNammYy EdlkMBugvatTwkdInigRbeTskm<úCamYyEdlkMBugcuHdundab.

dMeNIreq<aHmkTisxagt,ÚgKWCaPaKsMxan;bMputénRbvtþisa®sþrbs;evotNam taMgBIeBlEdl

RbeTsenHrMedaHxøÜnrYcputBInwmrbs;cinenAstvtSr_TI10. GñkÉkeTs)araMgmñak;)ankt;Rtafa «Rbvtþi

sa®sþrbs;evotNam)anraldalmkelI\NÐÚcinbIdUcCakmøaMgTwkhUrmYy edaynaMmktampøÚvqøgkat;

rbs;vanUvRbCaCnepSg² EdlkMBugrs;enAkñúgtMbn;valksikmµ b¤EdlgayeFVI[køayeTACavalERs

)an »1. kñúgEdndIsNþTenøRkhmCaTIkMeNIténRbCaCnevotNam sm<aF EpñkRbCasa®sþ ¬karekIn

b¤RskcuHéncMnYnRbCaCn¦ karrujRcanBIGñkCitxagcinnigGsßirPaB Epñkneya)ay)anbNþal[

RbCaCnsVHEsVgrkdIfµI² EdlCaclnamYyRbRBwtþeTAedayÉg²2. evotNam)aneFVIdMeNIrcuHmkTis

xagt,Úg EdlRtÚvCMrujCaGaT×edaykmøaMgT½Bk¾dUcPUmisa®sþ ³ latsn§wgenAPaKxageCIgKWmhaykScin

enAPaKxaglicKWCYrPñMGaNÑamEdlminsUvGMeNayplkñúgkarrs;enA ehIyenAPaKxagekItKWsmuRT

cinxagt,Úg.

kñúgkarrulmkmuxrbs;xøÜneq<aHmkPaKxagt,ÚgEdlmanral;EtstvtSr_ evotNamminRtwmEt

c,aMgdeNþImykTwkdIb:ueNÑaHeT BYkeKEfmTaMgykRbCaCndak;CacMNuHxøÜneTot. RbCaCatidMbUgbMput

Edldl;nUvkþIvinas KWCnCaticamEdlmanraCaNacRkeQµaH «cm,:a » CaGtItKURbECgmYyrbs;evot-

Nam. edaysarkareFVIcm,aMgpÞÜn² karP¢ab;TwkdIedayevotNam nigdMeNIrpøas;bþÚrRsukeTsbnþic

mþg²nigedayeTogTat;rbs;RbCaCn enATIbMputRbeTsenHk¾RtÚvrlub)at;eQµaHBIEpnTIsklelakenA

cugstvtSr_TI17. PaKeRcInénCnCaticam)anRtÚvsmøab;rgÁal nigRtÚvbeNþjecjBITwkdIrbs;xøÜn

b¤RtÚvrMlaybBa©ÚlCatisasn_CamYyCnCatievotNamEdleK)anvaytémøfa kñúgcMnYnRbCaCncam

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg56

Page 67: Brother enemy

30>000RKÜsar ¬manmnusSRbEhlBI240eTA300>000nak;¦ kalBIstvtSr_TI11enaH

sBVéf¶enHCnCaticammanenAkñúgRbeTsevotNamenAsl;EtCag 65>000nak;b:ueNÑaH3. kñúg

cMeNamenaH CnCaticamCaeRcInBan;nak;eTot)anrt;ePosxøÜnmkkm<úCa EdlenATIbMput k¾RtÚvrbb b:ul

Bt smøab;esÞIrEtGs;rlIgkñúgzan³xøÜnCaGñkkan;sasnaGIusøam.

eTaHCaenAmuncRkPBevotNamminTan;elbRt)ak;nKrcm,:a)anTaMgRsugk¾eday k¾niKmCn

evotNam )ancab;epþImbegáItPUmikrCaeRcInenAelITwkdIEdlsm,ÚréRBeQIrbs;km<úCaeRsceTAehIy

kñúgtMbn;mYyEdlbc©úb,nñKWTIRkúgebonv:a nig)araC. kalBIedIm ExµrmancRkPBd¾FMlVwgelVIymYy

latsn§wgBIeRCaym:aeLsuIrhUtdl;PaKkNþalRbeTsLav b:uEnþ RbCaCnExµrEdlexSaHrIgéreRkamkar

RKb;RKgminl¥rbs;rbbraCaFibetyümYyEdlFøak;cuHdundabtaMgBIyUrlg;Nas;mkehIyenaH )an

sißtenAkñúgsßanPaBRbQmmuxnwgRbeTsevotNammYyEdlERbpøas;TwkcitþCafµI nigsEmþg[eXIj

ectnaminl¥kñúgkarvatTwkdIeTot. karRbyuT§KñapÞÜn²rvagRkúmbkSepSg²kñúgraCvgSExµrnigkarb:unb:g

ykRbeTskm<úCadak;CacMNuHedayRbeTsesom ¬KWRbeTséfsBVéf¶CaRbeTsCitxagenAPaKxaglic

Edlkan;EtxøaMgCagkm<úCa¦ )anpþl;[evotNamnUvelsepSg² EdlmaneLIgÉg²sRmab;kareFVI

GnþraKmn_rbs;eK. GnþraKmn_TaMgenaH eTaHCamaneKaledAsRmab;CYyeRCamERCgRBHraCamYyGgÁ

EdlkMBugesayraCü b¤erobcMelIkkSRtmYyGgÁEdlmansiT§iesayraCü[eLIgRKgraCüblø½gáExµr

k¾eday k¾RtÚvTUTat;eTAvijedaykarRbKl;TwkdIkm<úCamYycMENktUceTA[evotNamminEdlxaneLIy.

enAstvtSr_TI18]tþmesnIy_evotNammñak;)aneRbóbeFobl,icklelbTwkdIExµrCalMdab;lMeday

enHeTAnwg «karsuIyWt²énstVdgáÚvnag »4 eRkamelsfaCYyKaMRTRBHraCarbs;xøÜn. evotNamKWCaGñk

elµaPsIustVdgáÚvnagdUcKña. cenøaHKñaEtmYystvtSr_KWenAcenøaHqñaM1650 nig1750 GagTenø v:amkU

nigdIsNþTenøemKgÁTaMgmUlrYmTaMgPUmiGñkensaTenAéRBnKr ¬EdleRkaymkevotNamehAéshÁn¦

pg)anRtÚvP¢ab;bBa©ÚlCaTwkdIrbs;evotNamTaMgRsug.

kalebIeFVICam©as;TwkdId¾manCICatienAPaKxagt,ÚgrYcehIy RBHecAGFiraCevotNamEdleBl

enaHmanraCFanIenATIRkúgev: )anKitKUrCabzmBIerOgkarBarEdndIenHRbqaMgTl;nwgBYkéfsin. RbeTs

km<úCaGacCa«TVarebIkcMh»sRmab;karcUllukluyRkúgéRBnKrBIsMNak;kgT½Béf ³ enHCamUlehtuRtwm

RtÚvmYyEdleFVI[RbeTskm<úCaeTACardæGaNaBüa)almYy. GFiraC mij m:ag )anGHGagenAqñaM1831

fa «can;Lab; (Chan Lap KWRbeTskm<úCa¦ CardæRTnab;rbs;eyIg. eyIgminGacbeNþay[RbeTs

enHRsútdYleLIy»5.

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 57

Page 68: Brother enemy

bnÞab;BIbraC½ykñúgkarb:unb:gP¢ab;RbeTskm<úCaCarNbedayBYkéfenAqñaM1833-34 evot-

Nam)anepþImvayluky:agKeXøInkñúgRbtibtþikarmYyEdlGacnaMeTAdl;karrlt;rlayRbeTskm<úCa

Etmþg ebIsinCaevotNamseRmceCaKC½yEmn. evotNam)ansagsg;bnÞay CaeRcInkEnøgkñúg

TUTaMgRbeTsnig)anerobcMeyaFPUmimYy¬kgT½BRbcaMbnÞaykñúgRkúg¦enAPñMeBjpg. RbeTskm<úCa

ÉkraCü)anERbeTACa «rdæPaKxaglicEdleKeFVI[mansnþiPaBeLIgvij » sßitenAeRkamcMNuHevot-

Nam. mij m:ag )ancab;epþImGnuvtþyuT§nakard¾xøaMgkøamYyedIm,IeFVI[CnCatiExµr Ca «mnusSéRBKµan

GarüFm’ »manTmøab;rs;enAsmrmükñúgsgÁmvij. RBHGgÁ)anbBa¢Únsa®sþacarüevotNamCaeRcInnak;

mkkan;km<úCaedIm,IbeRgónTsSnviC¢axugCW cMeBaHm®nþICan;x<s;ExµrTaMgLay. RBHGgÁk¾)ansakl,g

kMhit[RbCaCnExµrkat;sk; nigesøókBak;CarebobevotNam ehIybBa©ÚlRbBn§½Bn§darmYyeday

GnuelamtamRbeTsevotNam RBmTaMgbgçM[RbCaksikrdaMdMNaMepSg²dUcKñanwgksikrevotNam

Edr. GñkEdlTTwgrwgrUsRtÚv)anpþnÞaeTasy:agF¶n;F¶rbMput.

karegIbbHe)arCaeRcIn)anpÞúHeLIgRbqaMgnwgkarbgÁab;bBa¢arbs;evotNam. enAqñaM1820

RBHsgÇmYyGgÁRBHnam ék )andwknaMkarbHe)arCaelIkdMbUgmYykñúgcMeNamkarbHe)ardMbUg² RbqaMg

nwg «vin½yEdkEfb » Edldak;bgçMedaykgT½BRtÜtRtanigRbBn§½kargarKµankéRmEdleKbBaØtþi[bMeBj.

GñkbHe)ar)ansmøab;evotNamEdltaMgenAPaKxagekItRbeTskm<úCay:agrgÁalrhUtdl;ecAhVayextþ

evotNamenAtambNþaextþPaKxagt,ÚgRtÚvEtbBa¢ÚnkgT½BCMnYymkCYy edIm,IykQñHelIkarRCÜl

eRCImbHe)arenH6. b:uEnþKWenAqñaM1840 EdlpÞúHeLIgnUvkarbHe)arF¶n;F¶rCageKbMput ³ eRkayBIkar

cab;xøÜnbNþam®nþICan;x<s;ExµrnigRBHraCaEdlRKgraCüeTAXMuXaMgenAevotNam RbCaCnExµrk¾cab;nwkPñk

)armÖcMeBaHGtßiPaBénRbeTskm<úCaÉkraCüpgEdr. m®nþICan;x<s;Exµrmñak;eQµaH RBhµ )anGHGagenA

eBlenaHfa «eyIgsb,aynwgsmøab;evotNamNas; eyIgElgxøacBYkeKeTotehIy ebITukCaBYkeK

xøaMgBUEkk¾eday ». Kat;)anelIkTwkcitþ[BYkyuT§ikCnrbs;Kat;smøab;CnCatievotNamTaMgGs;Edl

BYkeKCYbRbTHtampøÚv «BIPaKxageCIgrhUtdl;PaKxagt,Úg »RbeTs. kñúglixitmYyEdlepJICUnGñkrdækar

éf Kat;)anesñI «bnþsmøab;rgÁalCnCatievotNameTot »7 enHCaesckþIRbkasEdleKsnñidæanfaCa

rbs; b:ul Bt GnaKtemdwknaMRbeTskm<úCa.

GnusSavrIy_énkaregIbbHe)arTaMgLayrbs;ExµrenAedImstvtSr_TI19 nigerOgniTanepSg²sþIBI

PaBsahavéRBépSénkarekobsgát;rbs;evotNamsuT§EtRtÚvcmøgdak;kñúgkalb,vtþi nigRbéBNInig

TMenomTmøab;GñkRsukrbs;km<úCa. edIm,IbnøacekµgEdlminsþab;bgÁab;mñak; mataExµrTaMgLayeRcInman

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg58

Page 69: Brother enemy

Tmøab;KMramfa ³ «ebIÉgedIreTAelgq¶ay²kñúgéRB yYn ¬CaBakübnþúHbg¥ab;rbs;Exµr mann½yR)akdfa

mnusSKµanGarüFm’¦ nwgcab;ykÉgeTAminxan ». ERBkCIkvijet (Vinh Te) CapøÚvTwkmYyRbEvg40

KILÚEm:Rt P¢ab;BIQUgsmuRTesommkERBkvijet RtÚv)anCIkenAqñaM1820 edaysarevotNambgçit

bgçM[RbCaCnExµrbMeBjkic©karenHedayxanmin)an ehIyenHKWCa «muxrbYscMh »mYyEdldk;Cab;kúñg

citþKMnitrbs;RbCaCnExµrCanic©. munnigeRkaysm½y b:ul Bt ´mindwgfab:unµandgeTEdl´¬GñkniBn§¦

)ansþab;erOgniTansþIBIkardak;eTasrbs;evotNammkelIRbCaCnExµrbInak;EdleFVIkarminsUvsVahab;

enAkardæanCIkERBkenaH. tameKGHGagfa CnGP½BVTaMgbIRtÚvevotNamCIkreNþAkb;Rtwm-k bnÞab;mk

ykxÞHmYyEdleBjeRbóbeTAedayTwkBuHmkdak;BIelIk,alGñkTaMgbI enAeBlEdlGñkrgeRKaHrmYl

Rbkac;edaykarQWcab;nigeFVI[RkLkTwkecjBIxÞH evotNam)anKMramfa «kuMeFVI[kMBb;Etrbs;ecA

hVay ». eRkaymkRbvtþierOgenH)aneTACaelsEdlRTRTg;dl;kareXasnarbs;ExµrRkhmsMedA

GuCGal[man«kMhwgbdivtþn_»RbqaMgnwgsRtÚvevotNam8.

menaseBa©tnaGriPaB nigbuernicä½yerIseGIgCatisasn_EdlExµrRkhmBRgIkRbqaMgnwgevotNam

enaH KWCaGMeBIdUcKñaNas;. RtÚvedAy:ageRCAedaykarRtÜtRtarbs;cincMnYnmYyBan;qñaM RbeTsevotNam

emIleXIjxøÜnÉgfaCa «GaNacRkkNþaltUc »mYyEdlB½T§CuMvijedayBYkGanarüCn b¤mnusSéRB.

ebITukCaBaküenHBuMmaneRbICapøÚvkark¾eday k¾CnCatievotNamsamBaØ enAEteRbIR)as;Bakücinfa ³

kavemon (Cao Mien) mann½yfa mnusSéRBéntMbn;PñMCanic©edÍm,IsmÁal;RbCaCnkm<úCa. sBVéf¶

RbEhlmanCnCatievotNamtictYcb:ueNÑaHEdldwgBIedImkMeNIténBakürbs;cinenH edaysnñidæanfa

enHCakarehAtamEbbevotNamnUvBaküfa «Exµr ». bNþaRBHecAGFiraCénsnþtivgS egVón Edl

esayraCüelIRbeTsevotNamrYbrYmnigrwgmaMmYy Etgcat;TukxøÜnÉgCaGñkTTYlParkic©bMeBjebsk

kmµd¾]tþmmYyKWnaMykBnøWGarüFm’eTAkan;raCaNacRkEdlniymsasnahiNÐÚnigeFVI[RbeTskm<úCa

cuHexSay. kñúgkayvikaremIlgaycMeBaHGsmtßPaBrbs;CnCatiExµrkñúgkarRtab;tam[dUcvb,Fm’

cin-evotNamenaH RBHecAGFiraCmYyGgÁ)ancat;TukExµrfa ³ «stVsVaCab;kñúglb» b¤«bkSIenAkñúgRTúg».

enAqñaM1840 enAeBlEdlRbCaCnkm<úCaegIbbHe)arRbqaMgnwgebskkmµpþl;GarüFm’rbs;RbeTs

evotNam RBHecAGFiraC mij m:ag )anxwgRceLatfa «eyIgFøab;)anCYyse®gÁaHBYkeKkñúgeBlman

Gasnñ eyIgFøab;)anCYyRsg;BYkeKecjBICIvitefakTab ¬dUcPk;RCaM¦ emIlcuH¡ eBlenHBYkeKEbrCa

egIbbHe)arRbqaMg¡. GMeBIeXareXA )aneFVI[sk;´eLIgbHsk;RcÚg. eKRtÚvkarkaMbitrab;rysRmab;

ci®Ba©aMBYkenHCakMNat;² nigkat;Gv³yv³ecjBIxøÜn ». kñúgerOgniTanmYyeTotsþIBIkaregIbbHe)ar

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 59

Page 70: Brother enemy

enAqñaM1840 KWevotNam)anbeNþay[FøayecjkarekþARkhayrbs;xøÜnenAmuxkll,icén «Rbti

btþikarvayqµk;y:agkøahan nigelOnrh½s »EdlkgT½BéRBExµrRkhmcUlcitþeRbI ehIykMBugrt;eKc «dUc

stVkNþúrERbg nigkNþúrElµH»BImuxkgT½Berobryrbs;evotNam9.

sRmab;RbCaCnExµrmYycMnYnFMyl;fa eTaHCaRbCaCnevotNamenAEtCaBUCsasn_mYy min

eTogRtg;Ca «GñkelbRt)ak;TwkdÍExµr»k¾eday k¾bc©úb,nñevotNamhak;dUcCaminsEmþgnUvKMnuMBüa)aT

cMeBaHExµrEdr. BitNas;fa KWRbCaCnExµrEdlrgkarQWcab;F¶n;F¶rCageKkñúgzan³CaRbCaCatimYy

EdlmanRbvtþiTMnak;TMngd¾yUrlg;rvagRbCaCnTaMgBIr. evotNamEdlrs;enAkm<úCak¾sÁal;nUvkal³eTs³

lM)akevTnadUcKñaEdr b:uEnþbBaðaenHTMngCaminb:HBal;dl;menaseBa©tna rbs;RbCaCnevotNamCa

TUeTAeT. pÞúyeTAvij kñúgkarsMeNHsMNalrbs;mnusSeFVIkarrdæ b¤mnusSsamBaØ menaseBa©tna

RbesIrelIseKrbs;evotNam CaBiessTak;TgeTAnwgkarGb;rMneya)ay karerobcMGgÁkarnigsmtßPaB

bBa¢aT½Brbs;evotNam)anpusecjmkPøam². enAeBlEdlBYkeKmanGarmµN_sb,úrsevotNam

)ancat;TukedayrIkrayfa ExµrCaekµgFMEdlBi)akRbedA. b:uEnþ CajwkjyevotNamBi)aknwg

lak;)aMgkarxVHGMNt;rbs;xøÜncMeBaHExµr EdlminecHenAes¶ómnigEdllem¥ógeTArkkarbHe)arNas;

EdlenHehIyKWCaRbPBénbBaðaepSg²EdlekItmanminecHcb;.

sticgcaMrbs;RbCaCnnig«karxwgs¥b;KñaCaRbéBNI» EdlkøayeTACaTmøab;eTAehIyenaH suT§Et

CasBaØaNEdlminGacsmÁal;eXIjnigGrUbI EdleKBi)aknwgeFVI[eTACa]bkrN_viTüasa®sþkñúgkar

viPaKmYyxagsgÁmsa®sþb¤Rbvtþisa®sþNas;. b:uEnÒ KMnitminsmehtuplTaMgGs;manlkçN³c,as;

las;Nas;sRmab;GñkNamñak; Edl)ansñak;GaRs½ymYyry³enARbeTskm<úCa. kñúgGMLúgrC¢kal

rbs;RBHGgÁ semþc sIhnu )anEfrkSasticgcaMrbs;RbCaCnenH[enAsßitesßryUrGEgVgedayRTg;

eRcInmanbnÞÚleLIgvijGMBIRbvtþisa®sþénkarrMelaPrbs;evotNammkelITwkdIkm<úCaCaerOy².

mYyEpñkBIeRBaHRbCaCnExµr)anRtÚvjúaMg[eCOBIcritCa «GñkvatTwkdI »BIkMeNItrbs;evotNammYy

EpñkeTotGñkeRbIneya)ayRsbtamkal³eTs³ KWBYkemdwknaMkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü)antaMgcitþbk

RsayCemøaHrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTsevotNam edayTLðIkrN_epSg²xagCatisasn_ KWBuMEmnxagvb,Fm’

nigsgÁmeT. «esovePAexµA »Edle)aHBum<pSayedayrbb b:ul Bt enAExkBaØa qñaM1978 KWeRcIn

ExeRkayEdl Guin suIvuF niyayeday\tKitR)ab;´tamkarerobrab;d¾EvgGnøayKYr[FujnUvkar

tiHedold¾CUrct;rbs;Kat; EdlmanbBa©ÚlPaBxusKñabnþicbnþÜcénerOgr:avEtmYy ³ «GMeBIQøanBan nig

karP¢ab;TwkdÍEdlRbRBwtþeLIgedayevotNamkñúgGtItkal k¾dUcbc©úb,nñkal)anbgðaj[eXIjy:ag

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg60

Page 71: Brother enemy

c,as;nigCanic©kalnUvmuxmat;BitR)akdrbs;CnCatievotNam nigRbeTsevotNamfa ³ CaGñkQøanBan

GñkvatTI EdleRskXøancg;)anTwkdIbNþaRbeTsdéTy:agxøaMg ». eK)anGanesovePAenHedaysegçb

fa eTaHCaenAeRkamrbbskþiPUmi rbbGaNaniKm b¤eRkamkardwknaMrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþk¾eday k¾

evotNamenAEtdUcBImundEdl. eRkaymkRkúm b:ul Bt )anQanrhUtdl;Rbkasfa bkSkumµúynIsþ

km<úCaRtÚv)anbegáIteLIgenAqñaM1960 «edIm,ItTl;nwgevotNam »CaTsSnvis½yEdlnwgeFVI[bNþa

sßabnikbegáItlT§ikumµúynIsþRsLaMgkaMg10.

kartaMg[manGaNaBüa)alPaBmYyrbs;)araMgenAqñaM1863 )anbeBa©ósmin[mankarEbg

EckTwkdIkm<úCaCafµIrvagRbeTsevotNamnigéf. k¾b:uEnþ ehtukarN_EdlEdndIkUsaMgsuInCitxag -PaK

xagt,ÚgevotNambc©úb,nñ- køayeTACaGaNaniKmmYyrbs;)araMgTaMgRsugenaH )anbMpøajplRbeyaCn_

rbs;RbeTskm<úCapgEdr enAeBlEdlmankarkMNt;RBMEdnrvagRbeTsTaMgBIredayBYk)araMg. kar

KUsbnÞat;RBMEdn)anRtÚverobcMeLIgedayBYkGaCJaFrGaNaniKmrbs;kUsaMgsuIn edayEp¥kelIlkçN³

vinicä½yEpñkPUmisa®sþ nigPaBgayRsYlkñúgkarRKb;RKgEpñkrdæ)alCaCagEp¥kelIRbvtþisa®sþ Pasa

b¤BUCsasn_. taMgBIkarKUsbnÞat;RBMEdnCabnþbnÞab;EdlykcitþTukdak;edayBYk)araMg tMbn;):ak;es

¬sBVéf¶sßitenAPaKxagt,ÚgRbeTsLav¦ extþdaLak; nigtMbn;nanamansugeb/ taynij/ háÚdUha nig

haeTog ¬sBVéf¶Carbs;evotNam¦ )anRtÚvRbbicRbe)acbnþicmþg²ykBIRbeTskm<úCaGs;. kñúg

niekçbbTfñak;bNÐitmYyEdle)aHBum<pSayenAqñaM1966 sarin qak rdæm®nþIkarbreTsénraCrdæaPi)al

rYbrYmCatikm<úCaqñaM1970 )anlatRtdagy:agEvgBIkarkat;TwkdITaMgenH ehIy)anTTUc[evotNam

ebIkeFVIkarcrcaKñakñúgeKaledAKUsbnÞat;RBMEdnmYyEdlmanlkçN³RtwmRtÚv nigyutþiFm’Cagmun11.

emdwknaMTaMgGs;rbs;RbeTskm<úCataMgBIesþc GgÁDYg ¬qñaM1848-1860¦ rhUtmkdl; b:ul

Bt minEdlQb;tv:aRbqaMgnwgkarkat;TwkdITaMgenHeLIy. kñúglixitd¾KYr[rMePIbcitþmYyenAqñaM1856

RBHmhakSRtGgÁDYg)anCMrujRBHecAGFiraC Nab:UeLGugTI3 kMu[TTYlykdIExµrEdlBYkevotNam)an

P¢ab;eFVICaTwkdIrbs;xøÜnkalBIeBlfµI²enH edayRBHGgÁ)anbeBa©jRBHraCeyabl;fa «edayécdnü

ebIsin CaevotNamRbKl;TwkdIfVayRBHecAGFiraCvij ». kñúgqñaM1949 enAeBlkUsaMgsIunCa

GaNaniKm)araMg RtÚvbBa©ÚleTAkñúgrdæbRgÜbbRgÜm¬b:uEnþBuMTan;manGFibetyüeT¦evotNamenaH Rkúg

PñMeBj)an ecjpSaynUvkarRbqaMgtv:aCapøÚvkarmYy. eTaHCabnÞab;BI\NÐÚcinTTYl)anÉkraCüenAqñaM

1954 k¾eday k¾RbeTskm<úCaenAEtbnþTamTar[evotNamxagt,ÚgRbKl;mk[vijnUvTwkdIkm<úCa

eRkamEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁ¬BIedImCakm<úCaPaKxageRkam¦ nigekaHmYycMnYntameqñrsmuRTCaBiess

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 61

Page 72: Brother enemy

ekaHRtl;Edr. edayRBÜy)armÖBIsßanPaBrbs;CnCatiExµr eRkamenARbeTsevotNamCab;Canic©enaH

semþc sIhnu )aneFVIkarRbqaMgtv:aBIerOgenHtampøÚvkarCaeRcInelIk12.

karhUrcUlénCnCatievotNammkkñúgRbeTskm<úCaecHEtmanCabnþeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;GWr:ub

Edlmankarbn§ÚrbnßyeRcIn. BYk)araMgEdlemIleXIjfa evotNamCaGñk]sSah_ nigsVitsVajkñúg

kargarCagExµr)anykBYkenaHmkeRbIR)as; edIm,ICYyeFVI[km<úCarIklUtlas;. enAqñaM1921 CnCati

evotNammanCit7PaKryéncMnYnRbCaCnkm<úCaTaMgGs;. mnusSTuK’tCaeRcInEdlmkBIevotNam

xageCIg )ancakecalmatuRbeTsmkeFVIkareRkamkic©snüatamcmáarekAsU‘nanarbs;)araMgenAkm<úCa

CakargarEdlmanExµrtictYcb:ueNÑaHeBjcitþeFVI. mü:ageTotksikr nigGñkensaTCaeRcIn)ancakecj

BIEdndIkUsaMgsuIn edIm,ImkRbECgykBIExµrnUvdIksikmµ nigtMbn;ensaTrbs;BYkeKEfmeTot. Gñkkan;

sasnakatUlikevotNam EdlCYyCMrujedayBYksasnTUt)araMgBuMEmnCaBYkcugeRkay Edlmk

deNþImykdIFøIrbs;km<úCaeT EdlkarN_enH)aneFVI[KMnuMekIneLIgkan;EtFM13.

GsµimanH ¬esckþIRbkan;citþrwgt¥wgfaGjfaeK¦ rbs;Exµr)anrgkarb:HBal;y:agxøaMg CaBiess

cMeBaHkarEdlrdæ)al)araMgeRCIserIsGñkeFVIkar PaKeRcInEtkñúgcMeNamevotNamb:ueNÑaH. Gñk

bHe)arRbqaMg)araMgenAqñaM1885-86 )anbenÞasRbeTs)araMgEdleRbIR)as;BYkevotNamkñúgkar

bMpøicbMpøajsgÁmCati nigvb,Fm’rbs;km<úCa. k¾b:uEnþshKmn_TaMgBIrenHBuMEmnrs;enACaxµaMgsRtÚvnwgKña

Cab;CaRbcaMenaHeT. kñúg»kasénkarbHe)arRbqaMgGaNaniKmmanBYkevotNamy:ageRcIn)anvay

RbyuT§rYmCamYyExµrEdr. ebIeTaHCamanPaBtantwgnigkarmincUlcitþKñaeTAvíjeTAmkk¾eday k¾RbCaCn

km<úCanigevotNam)ansÁal;nUvPaBekSmkSanþCaGñkCitxagl¥kñúgry³eBly:agyUrmYy b:uEnþRKan;Et

manvibtþimYyb¤RBwtþikarN_xageRkAmYyb:ueNÑaH KWEtgEtmanelcecjKMnuMcas;Pøam.

enARbeTskm<úCa emeraKRbkan;Catisasn_)aneFVI[vinasdl;clnakumµúynIsþpÞal;rbs;xøÜn Edl

tamkarGYtrbs;eKfaCaclnaGnþrCatiniym. lkçN³sm,tþiepSg²kñúgkarbegáItnigkarGPivDÆn_rbs;

xøÜn EdlmaneRkaymkeTot)anCYybMb:n[RbCaCnExµrmanKMnitCatiniymceg¥ótcg¥l; (Chauvinisme)

nigmenaseBa©tnaRbqaMgevotNamdk;Cab;kñúgcitþCanic©.

BYkGenþaRbevsn_evotNam )anrYmbgáCasñÚld¾rwgmaMénRkúmts‘Uxagneya)ayCaeRcInrbs;

bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinenARbeTsLavk¾dUcenAkm<úCa. enAqñaM1950 clnaExµr\sSr³¬ExµresrI¦ KW

sßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinenAeLIy. hU CImij dwgc,as;Nas;BIKMnuMRbqaMg

evotNamEdldk;Cab;kñúgcitþrbs;BYkLavnigkm<úCa. ehtuenHehIy)anCaenAqñaM1951 Kat;)an

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg62

Page 73: Brother enemy

seRmccitþbMEbkbkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcineTACabIbkSdac;edayELkBIKña. karbgðaj[eXIjP½sþútagkñúg

karbMEbkenH KWmanenAkñúgÉksarépÞkñúgmYyrbs;bkSBlkrevotNam EdlCaGñkTTYltMENgbnþBI

bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcin ³ «smasPaBxøHénGñkCatiniymLavnigkm<úCaGacenAmnÞilsgS½yfa RbeTs

evotNammanbMNgdak;bgçM[Gnuvtþc,ab;rbs;xøÜnenARbeTsLavnigkm<úCa. bncRkBtþinigBYkGay:g

rbs;vaGaceqøót»kasenAeBlenaHTajykRbeyaCn_BIerOgenH edIm,IebIkyuT§nakarRbqaMgmYysMedA

bMEbkbM)ak;RbeTsevotNam km<úCa nigLav edaysabeRBaHkarsgS½yenAkñúgcMeNamRbCaCnkm<úCa

nigRbCaCnLav»14.

karEbk)ak;rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcineTACabIbkSsRmab;RbeTsnImYy² )aneFVI[GñkCati

niym kñúgRbeTsTaMgenaHFUrRsalkñúgcitþ ehIy)anRbqaMgtTl;nwgkarb:unb:g «bMEbkbM)ak;edIm,I

RtÜtRta »rbs;)araMgvij. b:uEnþkarcat;EcgdwknaMclnakumµúynIsþrbs;\NÐÚcinenAEtsßitkñúgkNþab;éd

evotNamCanic©. enAExmifuna qñaM1952 RbCaCnevotNamnigcinEdlsñak;enARbeTskm<úCa)an

TTYllixitsm¶at;mYyecjmkBIbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam edaydak;kMhit[BYkeKcUlCasmaCikbkS

BlkrevotNamCaCagcUlbkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_ExµrEdlBuMEmnCa «bkSQanmuxrbs;vNѳkmµkr b:uEnþKW

CabkSQanmuxrbs;RbCaCatimYyEdlRbmUlpþúMRKb;smasPaBGñkesñhaCati nigsmasPaBceRmIn

niym edayminerIsmuxrbs;RbCaCnExµr»15. eTaHCay:agNak¾edayKN³kmµaFikarRbtibtþibeNþaH

GasnñénbkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_Exµr EdlbegáIteLIgenAExkBaØa qñaM1951 enaH KWmansmasPaB

evotNameRcInCagExµr ³ 1>800nak;CaevotNamekItenARbeTskm<úCaTl;nwgExµr150nak;.

rYmCamYy sIhnu RbqaMgnwgcRkBtþiiniym

enAExmkra qñaM1953 saLút s )anRtLb;mkRkúgPñMeBjvijbnÞab;BIrs;enATIRkúg):arIs

Gs;ry³eBlbIqñaM. Gñkbdivtþn_Gayu25qñaMenH eRkaymk)ankøayeTACamnusSl,Il,ajbMput eRkam

rhsSnamfa «b:ul Bt ». lixitsuMcUlbkSrbs;Kat;cMeBaHbkSRbCaCnbdivtþExµrd¾fµIsnøag RtÚv)an

BinitüBic½yy:aghµt;ct;edaykmµaPi)albkSrbs;evotNammñak;eQµaH paM v:an;)a CabkçCneCIgcas;

rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcin EdlRtÚvEtgtaMg[eFVIkarenARkúgPñMeBjCakEnøgEdlKat;bMeBjskmµPaB

y:ageRcInrYmTaMgskmµPaBCaGñkkaEstpg. CaGñk)at;xøÜnenAkñúgstvtSr_50 Kat;)anelcmuxeLIg

vijkñúgzan³CaGñkkarTUtmñak;rbs;evotkug. bnÞab;BI)anbeRmIkñúgzan³CaRbFansßanebskkmµén

rdæaPi)albdivtþn_beNþaHGasnñRbcaMTIRkúg):arIsrhUtdl;qñaM1975 )a )ankøayeTACaÉkGKÁrdæTUt

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 63

Page 74: Brother enemy

d¿bUgrbs;evotNamRbcaMkm<úCaRbCaFibetyürbs; b:ul Bt.

R)aMBIrqñaMeRkayBIkarCYbKñaelIkd¿bUgrbs;´CamYyKat; kñúgkariyal½yénrdæaPi)albdivtþn_

beNþaHGasnñenATIRkúg):arIs ´)anCYbKat;CafµImþgeTotenATIRkúghUCImijkalBIExmkra qñaM1981.

enAeBlenaH edayeRtkGrcMeBaHkarmkdl;edaymindwgxøÜnrbs;´ )a )anerobrab;nUvGVIEdlKat;BuMGac

niyayR)ab;´ muneBlBuMTan;mankarkat;pþac;cMNgmitþPaBCamYyExµrRkhmfa «kaleNaH ´Caelxa

kariyal½ycat;Ecg ¬lYclak;¦ rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinenARkúgPñMeBj. b:ul Bt )ancab;Tak;Tg

CamYy´edIm,ITTUcsuMcUlCasmaCikbkS. Kat;manb½NÑsmaCikbkSkumµúynIsþ)araMg kñúgGMLúgeBlén

karsikSarbs;Kat;enAsalaviTüúGKÁisnInaTIRkúg):arIs kñúgzan³CasmaCiksaxakm<úCaénbkSkumµúynIsþ

)araMg. ´)anesñIeTATIsñak;karbkSenA )ak;bU evotNamxageCIg edIm,I[cat;EcgeFVIkarepÞógpÞat;erOg

enHCamYybkSkumµúynIsþ)araMgEfmeTot. minyUrb:unµaneRkaymk ´)anTTYlBIRkúg)agkknUvsarTUr

elx¬eRbIsBaØaCaGkSr¦mYyrbs; h½g v:an;hn EdldwknaMsaxa CnCatievotNamenAbreTsrbs;bkS

edayKat;bBa¢ak;fa b:ul Bt BitCasmaCikbkSkumµúynIsþ)araMgEmn. dUecñH´k¾yl;RBmTTYlkarsuM

cUlbkSrbs;Kat;».

karRKb;RKgedaypÞal;elIbkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_ExµrBIsMNak;evotNam)anRtÚvbBa©b; mYyqñaM

bnÞab;BIkarputrlt;éns®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTI1. eRkamkarekobsgát;rbs;KN³RbtiPUcin nigsUevot

enAsm½yRbCuMsnñisIThSWENv qñaM1954 BYkkumµúynIsþevotNam)anRtÚvbgçitbgçM[RBmTTYlyknUv

karEbgEckRbeTsevotNamCabeNþaHGasnñ nigkare)aHbg;eTA[raCrdæaPi)alkm<úCavijnUvtMbn;nana

EdlrMedaHedayExµr\sSr³. clnatsU‘rbs;LavRtÚv)anTTYlsÁal;enAhSWENv nigGnuBaØat[kmøaMg

ts‘URbmUlpþúMeLIgvij kñúgextþcMnYnBIrEdlmanRBMEdnCab;RbeTscin nigevotNam. pÞúyeTAvij Exµr

\sSr³RtÚvrMlayclnarbs;xøÜnÉgecal. semþcRBH ]byuvraC neratþm sIhnu EdldwknaMclna

TamTarÉkraCüedaypÞal;RBHGgÁedIm,IRbqaMg\sSr³ EdlKaMRTedayevotmijenaH )ancakecjBI

snñisIThSWENv CaGñkQñHBitR)akd. GnuelameTAtamkic©RBmeRBóg kgT½Bevotmij nigGñktsU‘Exµr

EdlvayRbyuT§edaylYclak;kñúgCYrkgT½Brbs;evotNamRbEhl2>000nak; )anRtÚvbBa¢ÚneTA

evotNamxageCIgvijedayrg;caMkal³eTs³GnueRKaHmkdl;. )a )anbMPøWfa «eyIgminEdleCOesaH

fa BYk)araMgnwgGnuvtþkic©RBmeRBógRkúghSWENvrhUtdl;cugbMputeT dUecñHlµmEteFVI[eyIgerobcM

RbúgeRbóbrYcmunCaeRsc». erOgEdlKYr[PJak;ep¥IlKW ³ enAcenøaHqñaM1972nig1975Rkúm b:ul Bt

)ankm©at;PaKeRcInénCnkm<úCa EdlbNþúHbNþaledayRkúghaNUyesÞIrEtTaMgGs;. k¾b:uEnþenAman

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg64

Page 75: Brother enemy

sl;GñkEdlrYcBIeRKaHfñak;dl;CIvitlµmRKb;RKan;sRmab;begáItrdæaPi)alsñiT§evotNammYyenARbeTs

km<úCaenAeBleRkaymkeTotEdr.

eTaHebIGñkeCIgcas;mYycMnYnénKN³dwknaMclna\sSr³suxcitþTTYlTukçevTnaenHkarxaMmat;sgát;

citþ edIm,IyuT§ikCnekµg²EdlbNþúHbNþalenAbreTsk¾eday k¾va)anbnSl;nUvrsCatiCUrct;mYyEdr.

eBlRtLb;mkBIRkúg):arIsvij BYkkumµúynIsþEdlCaGñkesñhaCatiRCúlhYsehtu dUcCa b:ul Bt/ eGog

sarI nig sun esn CaedIm )anecaTRbkan;evotNamfa )ancMNaykarBiesaFn_ rbs;clnatsU‘Exµr

EdlRbmUl)anTaMgGs;enAkñúgkarRbyuT§RbqaMgGaNaniKmrbs;xøÜn. b:uEnþ CamYykardkfyeTARbeTs

evotNamnUvGñkRbyuT§tsU‘PaKeRcIn nigbNþaemdwknaMCaRbvtþisa®sþEdlcgsm<½n§PaBnwgevotmij

b:ul Bt manesrIPaBy:ageBjeljedIm,Idak;[GnuvtþnUvmaK’aneya)aypÞal;rbs;Kat; CamYynwgkar

e)aHbg;ecalbkçBYk b¤kar)at;xøÜnrbs;GñkEdlsßitenARbeTskm<úCapg.

emdwknaMkumµúynIsþénclna\sSr³ sWg g:ukmij )anseRmccitþsßitenATIRkúghaNUybnÞab;BI

snñisITRkúghSWENv dUecñHkarRKb;RKgdwknaMbkSrbs;km<úCaRtÚvFøak;eTAelI suIv ehg EdlbgðajxøÜn

eLIgCaPñak;gar[karN_sm¶at;mñak;. shRbtibtþikarCaeRcInqñaMrbs;Kat;CamYyb:Ulisrbs; semþc

sIhnu )aneFVI[Gnþraydl;bNþajts‘UPaKeRcInrbs;bkS. ehg )ancuHcUlnwgrdæaPi)alrbs;semþc

enAqñaM1959. kñúg»kasmhasniñ)atbkSlYclak;mYyEdlR)arB§eLIgenAkardæansßabnapøÚvrfePøIg

enARkúgPñMeBjBIéf¶TI28 dl;éf¶TI30 ExkBaØa qñaM1960 RBHsgÇmYyGgÁRBHnam TU samut Edlpøas;

KMnitmkeCOlT§ikumµúynIsþ )anRtÚveRCIstaMgCaGKÁelxabkS¬Kat;CamnusSmanTMnak;TMngy:agCitsñiT§

CamYyevotNam¦16.

b:ul Bt EdleBlenaHCasa®sþacarübeRgónenAPñMeBj)ankøayeTACaGKÁelxabkSrgenA

qñaM1961. bnÞab;BIkar)at;xøÜn TU samut y:agGaf’kM)aMgenAExkkáda qñaM1962 b:ul Bt RtÚv)an

dMeLIgzan³CaGKÁelxabkS. eRkaymkminyUrb:unµan b:ul Bt/ eGog sarI ¬b¥Únéførbs;Kat;¦/ sun esn

nigmnusSmYycMnYneTot)anrt;cUléRB edÍm,IerobcMcat;taMgbkSedaylYclak;eLIgvij. eKminEdlB¤

GñkNaniyayBIBYkenHeToteTrhUtmkdl;qñaM1970.

enAcenøaHeBlenaH PaBXøatBIKñamansPaBkan;Etq¶ayeTA²rvagbnÞat;neya)ayr:aDIkal;

nigCatiniymceg¥ótcg¥l;rbs;Rkúm b:ul Bt nigbnÞat;neya)ayniymkNþalEdlminBitR)akdrbs;

GñkEdlGYtBIkareFVIshRbtibtþikarCamYyrdæaPi)alRbqaMgGaemrikaMgrbs; semþc sIhnu nigCamYy

evotNam. kñúg»kaséndMeNIrmYyeTARkúghaNUyenAExmIna qñaM1978 ´RtÚv)anGeBa¢Ij[cUlrYm

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 65

Page 76: Brother enemy

kñúgkarbriePaKGahareBlla¶cmYyedaym®nþICan;x<s;mñak;RBmTaMgmankarRbkasCUnB½t’manepSg²xus

EbøkBIsBVdgpg. Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam v: dugy:ag )anEføgenAeBll¶acenaHBIkarvivaTmYy

EdlmancMNas;CagémÖqñaMmkehIy BIkarmincuHsRmúgKñay:agRCaleRCAmYyrvagbkSevotNamnig

RkúmbkS b:ul Bt énbkSrbs;km<úCa. y:ag )anniyayR)ab;´fa taMgBIkarcab;epþImdMbUg² evotNam

)anyl;Rsbtam«maK’adwknaMd¾RtwmRtÚv»kñúgépÞbkSrbs;km<úCaRbqaMgnwgbn b:ul Bt edaycMGkLk

LWyeTAelI«GñkmkBITIRkúg):arIsTaMgenaHfa Bi)aknwgniyayGMBIkarcUlrYmd¾skmµ kñúgkartsU‘RbqaMgnwg

BYk)araMgNas;». viFIsa®sþEdlBYkeKeRbIR)as; edIm,IdwknaMkarbdivtþn_rbs;eK)anbgðaj[eXIjBI

«KMnitekµgx©IénlT§ikumµúynIsþ»mYy semþc sIhnu Føab;)aneRCagTg;RbqaMgnwgcRkBtþiGaemriky:agxøaMgkøa

ehIyRbkarenH)anpþl;mk[RBHGgÁvijnUvkitüanuPaBy:agsem,ImmYykñúgcMeNamRbCara®sþrbs;RBH

GgÁ. BYkkumµúynIsþ EdlecHeRbIR)as;y:agbuinRbsb;nUv\T§iBlrbs;semþcRbqaMgnwgcRkBtþiGaemrik

enaHk¾cMeNjRbCaRbiyPaBy:ageRcInEdr. ebIBYkkumµúynIsþExµrmankitüanuPaBKWkitüanuPaBrbs;semþc

sIhnu tmkeTotKW\T§iBlénmaKa’neya)ay¬kñúgépÞbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa¦eT EdlGMeNaypldl;kar

rYmkmøaMgy:agkuHkrrbs;RbCaCnRbqaMgnwgxµaMgsRtÚvenaH. b:uEnþeTaHCa)anseRmceCaKC½yk¾eday

k¾BuMEmnedaysarkitüanuPaBrbs; b:ul Bt Edr. karrYbrYmKñarvagkmøaMgepSg²kñúgkartsU‘RbqaMgxµaMg

sRtÚv nigkarCYyCMruj[mansamKÁIPaBrvagRbCaCn\NÐÚcinTaMgbI KWCa«maK’aminERbRbÜlénkarbdivtþn_

pÞal;rbs;eyIgcab;BIcab;kMeNItrhUtmkdl;sBVéf¶». k¾b:uEnþ b:ul Bt )anRbTajkarbdivtþn_rbs;

km<úCa [Føak;eTAkñúgpøÚveqVgRCúledayeRbI])ayklfa bkS)anqøgkat;«dMNak;kald¾lM)akbMputmYy»

enArvagqñaM1967nigqñaM1969. y:ag )anniyayrebobsRmalBakümYymin[muteBk ¬]TahrN_

edÍm,Ifa «GaRkk;»sRmalfa«minsUvl¥»vij¦ edIm,IrMB£kBIkarb®gáabRbqaMgCnkumµúynIsþ EdldwknaM

edaysemþc sIhnu.

y:ag )ansgát;bBa¢ak;BIRbCaRbiyPaBEdlsemþcTTYl)ankñúgzan³RBHGgÁCaRBHbitaÉkraCü

Cati b:uEnþKat;k¾rMB£keLIgvijEdrfa munqñaM1954 evotmijnigExµr\sSr³)ancat;TukRBHGgÁerogral;

éf¶fa Ca´kBa¢H)araMg. edaybBa¢ak;GMBIneya)aykarbreTsRbqaMgGaemrikrbs;semþc sIhnu kñúg

TsvtSr_60enaH y:ag )anePøcniyayBIkarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;Kat;kñúgkarkm©at;BYkeqVgniymrbs;

km<úCaeTAvij. tamBit kñúgGMLúgénbNþaqñaMTaMgenaHevotNam)anENnaMmþgeTot [Exµrp¥akskmµPaB

kñúgkarts‘UvNѳenAkm<úCa KWkMu[«ykdMbgeTAxÞas;kg;»rbs;semþc sIhnu nigkMueFVI[TMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜn

CamYyRkúghaNUykøayeTACaCemøaH.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg66

Page 77: Brother enemy

d,itGIevotNam)anelIktemáIgkarEfrkSacMNgTak;Tgy:agsuxdumCamYy semþc sIhnu enABI

elIGVI²TaMgGs;. CamYykarekIneLIgéns®gÁamenAevotNam cab;taMgBIqñaM1965 evotkug nigkgT½B

evotNamxageCIgGac)at;bg;TICRmk nigkarpÁt;pÁg;kgT½BEdlBYkeKerobcMbRmúgenARbeTskm<úCaenA

eBlNamYyminxan. eRkamelsénGBüaRkwtPaB semþc sIhnu )anyl;RBmbMeBjesckþIRtÚvkar

rbs;BYkenaHedays¶at;kM)aMg. semþc sIhnu )aneRbIkNþab;édEdkmYyRbqaMgnwgExµrRkhm b:uEnþ

sb,ayRBHT½yedaymansmancitþcMeBaHBYkkumµúynIsþevotNam. RBHGgÁ)anecaTBYkkumµúynIsþExµr

kñúgRbeTsfa CaPñak;garrbs;RkúghaNUynigeb:kaMg b:uEnþmanRBHraCtRmiHfa CasMxan;KWs®gÁamenA

evotNamCakarRbyuT§tsU‘rbs;RbCaCnmYy RbqaMgnwgkareFVIGnþraKmn_mYyrbs;breTsEdlminGac

edaHsa)an. semþc)anTTYlsÁal;eRkaymkkñúgkRmgGnusSavrIy_rbs;RBHGgÁfa )aneFVImindwgminB¤

cMeBaHkartaMgCMrMT½B mnÞIreBTünigkEnøgpÁt;pÁg;es,ógrbs;evotNamenAelITwkdIkm<úCaEmn. RBHGgÁk¾

)anGnuBaØat[navacin sUevot eqkUsøÚv:aKI ¬bc©úb,nñEbkCa2RbeTsehIy KWsaFarNrdæeqk nig

saFarNrdæsøÚv:aKI¦ nigbNþaRbeTssgÁmniymdéTeTotcUlctenAkMBg;EpRkúgRBHsIhnu edIm,IerIdak;

smÖarsRmab;pþl;[evotkug bnÞab;mkeTIbdwkCBa¢Úneq<aHeTAkan;RBMEdnevotNamedays¶at;kM)aMg

ehIyRtÚvkgT½Brbs;km<úCadkykmYycMENkFMsRmab;karqøgkat;enH17.

karykcitþykeføÍmrbs; semþc sIhnu kñúgkarCYyBYkkumµúynIsþevotNam KWEp¥kelIkarKn;KUr

d¾évqøatmYy ³ RKb;cMNucTaMgGs;KWCaerOgEdl[RbeyaCn_Cag kñúgkarEfrkSaTMnak;TMngl¥CamYyGñk

TMngCaQñHBitR)akd. eRkaymk semþc)anmanbnÞÚlTmøayGaf’kM)aMgfa ³ «mUlehtuEdl´eFVI

shRbtibtþikarenH KW´cg;eFVI[evotNamenACMBak;KuNkm<úCa ehIyElgh‘anelIkédvaymkelIeyIg

RbeTseyIg nigRbCaCneyIgteTAeTot EdlCaGñkeFVIKuNeTAelIBYkeK»18.

RBHGgÁk¾RbEhlCaRBWxøacpgEdrfa evotNamxageCIgc,as;CaRbqaMgnwgRBHGgÁ RbsinebI

RBHGgÁminCYyBYkeKkñúgkarRbyuT§enH. ehIyerOgenaH RBHGgÁ)anRtUvjúaMg[eCOfa RbeTscin nig

evotNamnwgeTACakmøaMgEdlxøaMgCageKenAGasuI eRkaykarcakecjrbs;BYkGaemrikaMg. enAExsIha

qñaM1963 semþc)ankat;pþac;TMnak;TMngkarTUtCamYyevotNamxagt,Úg ehIyminyUrb:unµaneRkaymk

kñúgqñaMdEdl RBHGgÁ)anRcanecalCMnYyesdækic©nigeyaFarbs;GaemrikaMgEfmeTot. enAEx]sPa qñaM

1965 km<úCa)anpþac;cMNgkarTUtCamYyRkúgv:asuInetan ehIysemþc)anTTYlnUvkarGbGrsresIr

CaeRcInBIRkúgeb:kaMgnighaNUy. enAExmifuna qñaMdEdlenaH RBHGgÁ)ansEmþgnUvkarKaMRTcMeBaH

rNsirSCatirMedaHevotNamxagt,Úgtamry³CMnYy]btßmÖmYyEpñkfñaMeBTü. semþc)anbBa¢ak;R)ab;

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 67

Page 78: Brother enemy

GñkkaEstmñak;EdleFVIsmÖasRBHGgÁenAExvicäika qñaM1965 fa «BitehIy BYkGaemrikaMgGacsmøab;

RbCaCnevotNamBI10eTA20lannak;. yUrb¤qab;BYkeKnwgtRmÚv[e)aHbg;RbeTsenHeTA[GñkEdl

enArs;ranmanCIvitvij>>>. shrdæGaemrik)anRbfuyxøÜnkñúgkarpSgeRBgmYyEdlecosminputBI

braC½yeLIy»19.

evotNam)ansEmþgnUvkardwgKuNsemþc sIhnu cMeBaHkarCYyKaMRTrbs;RBHGgÁ. BuMEmn

CaerOgKYr[PJak;ep¥IleLIy EdlfaenArdUvekþAqñaM1965 eBlEdl b:ul Bt eFVIdMeNIreTARbeTscin

nigeFVITsSnkic©sm¶at;mYyenARkúghaNUy evotNam)anENnaMKat;[KaMRTneya)aybreTs RbqaMg

cRkBtþirbs;semþcEdr. edayepþÍmeFVIkarts‘UedayGavuFRbqaMgnwgrdæaPi)alrbs;semþc sIhnu bkS

kumµúynIsþkm<úCa)aneFVI[Gnþrayy:agxøaMgdl;yuT§sa®sþrbs;evotNam. RkúghaNUyKitfa kartsU‘

vNѳenAkm<úCaenAminTan;dl;dMNak;kaleFVIkarbHe)arRbqaMgedayGavuFeT. mü:agvijeTot Rkúg

haNUyeCOfa C½yCmñHenAPaKxagt,Úgnwgbgá[manlkçN³sm,tþiepSg²kñúgkarvayRbyuT§d¾Caj

C½ykñúgTIbMputRbqaMgnwgrbbsemþc sIhnu.

karcab;epþImdMbUg²kñúgkartsU‘edayGavuF

Rkúm b:ul Bt minTTYlRBmtamKMnitENnaMrbs;evotNameT. ry³eBlR)aMExEdlemdwknaM

km<úCasñak;enARbeTscinkalBIcugqñaM1965 nigedImqñaM1966 RbEhlBuMEmnCaerOg«cEmøk»

sRmab;Kat;eT enAeBlcab;epþÍmkarbdivtþvb,Fm’ ¬karP½nþERbdl;TICeRmAnUvtémøCamUldæanénsgÁm

mYy¦ nigkarrMeCIbrMCYlRbqaMgcRkBtþiniym niglT§iesIrIniymEdlvabMpus[maneLIg. ehtuenHehIy

)anCa b:ul BtseRmccitþeFVIkarRbQmmuxedayGavuFCaCageFVIshRbtibtþikarCamYyrbbskþiPUmi

enaH. [sUmmitþGñkGanEsVgyl;BIbdivtþn_vb,Fm’rbs;RbeTscinCMnan;RbFan em:A dUcteTA ³ bdivtþ

vb,Fm’énvNѳBlkrenARbeTscinmanry³eBl10qñaMKWcab;BIqñaM1966-76 EdlenAeBlenaHGñk

kan;GMNackñúgrdæaPi)alnigneya)ay)anRtÚvbeNþjecjBItMENgdUcCa etg s‘avBIg nig lIv cavCI

CaedIm kñúgeBlEdlBYkyuvCntamsalaeron nigmhaviTüal½y¬biTTVarBIqñaM1966-72¦ erobcM

begáItCaRkúm«qµaMRkhm»CaeRcInRkúm edIm,ITamTar[eFVItamKMnit em:A esTug. bdivtþn_vb,Fm’enH

kt;smÁal;edaykarpøas;bþÚrRbCaCnTaMghVÚg²BICnbTeTATIRkúgepSg² nigBIRkúgnanamkCnbTERs

cmáarvij edaykarRbyuT§Kñay:agexøacpSatambNþaextþCaeRcIn edaykarcab;dak;Kuk karsmøab;BYk

sil,krnigbBaØvnþ karkemÞcbMpøajsil,³ RbéBNI vimanRbvtþisa®sþ nigesovePA. bdivtþvb,Fm’

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg68

Page 79: Brother enemy

)anbBa©b;eTACamYymrNPaBrbs; em:A nigkarcab;xøÜnBYk«bn4nak;»enAqñaM1976 [bn4nak;CaRkúm

mYyEdldwknaMRKb;RKgRbeTscin bnÞab;BI em:A TTYlmrNPaBrYm man cagQij ¬RbBn§em:A¦/ v:ag

hugvuin/ y:av viunyn; nig hSag CunCIv. BYkenHRtÚvecaTRbkan;BIbTrYmKMnitk,t;rMlMrdæGMNac ehIy

RtÚvcab;xøÜnenAqñaM1976¦-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb]. eTaHbICaRbeTscinBuM)anCMruj[mankartsU‘

Tl;nwg sIhnu CacMhk¾eday k¾Gacfa RbeTscinEdlkan;EtRBÜy)armÖxøaMgeLIg² edaysarkareFVI

shRbtibtþikarrvagevotNam-sUevotenaH Ebrmkkan;eCIg b:ul Bt kñúgCemøaHEdleFVI[ExµrRbQm

muxnwgevotNamvij20.

«esovePAexµA»rbs; b:ul Bt EtgEtGHGageRkaymkfa enAqñaM1966 «eKaledAepSg²én

karbdivtþn_rbs;km<úCanigevotNam suT§EtTak;TgeTAnwgCemøaH b¤karRbkYtRbECgKñay:agc,as;RkELt.

evotNamcg;dak;karbdivtþn_rbs;km<úCa[sßitenAeRkamcMNuHrbs;xøÜnTaMgRsug». RbkarenHBuMEmnmann½y

fa BYkeKBüayamRtÜtRtakarbdivtþn_eT b:uEnþCaCagfabdivtþn_km<úCaBMuTan;manGaTiPaBdac;xatenAeLIy.

edIm,IkuM[ExµrRkhmmYem:A nigRbEhledIm,IbnßykMhwgEdrenaH enATIbMput RkúghaNUy)anyl;RBmCYy

xagEpñkhVwkhVWnkgT½B nigCMnYyEpñkeyaFaeTot. enAqñaM1973 Gñkrt;ecalCYrCabkçCnkumµúynIsþ

fñak;x<s;mñak;EdlsaksYredayBYkGaemrikaMg)anEføgfa enAqñaM1966evotNam)anbegáItkgÉkPaB

mYyedaydak;eQµaHfa P-36edIm,ICYyKaMRTbkSkumµúynIsþrbs;km<úCa. enAmunkarpþÜlrMlMsemþc sIhnu

kñúgqñaM1970RkúmP-36)ancab;epþÍmhVwkhat;Exµr nigevotNamEdlekItenARbeTskm<úCataMgBIeBlenaH

emø:H21.

eKBuM)anbgðajP½sþútag[eXIjfa kgÉkPaB P-36 d¾Gaf’kM)aMgenHCaemjúHjg;[mankar

bHe)arRbqaMgrbs;RbCaCnkm<úCaeLIy. GVIEdlEbøkenaHKWkgÉkPaBenHRtÚv)anbegáIteLIgenAmun

karcab;epþImeFVIskmµPaBrbs;va. enAExmIna-emsa qñaM1967 bnÞab;BIkaregIbbHe)aredayÉg²

rbs;RbCaksikrenAsMLÚt ¬extþ)at;dMbg¦ RbqaMgnwgkarrwbGUsdIFøIrbs;BYkeK edayBYkGgÁkaryuvCn

mYyEdlmankarKaMRTBIfñak;elI eTIb b:ul Bt seRmcbegáItkgT½Bbdivtþn_mYy ehIyepþImRbLÚkkñúgkar

tsU‘edayGavuFRbqaMgnwgrbbsemþc sIhnu Etmþg. enAéf¶TI17 Exmkra qñaM1968 s®gÁamqµk;rbs;

ExµrRkhm)aneFVI[eKsÁal;xøÜnkñúgyuT§nakarmYy ³ karBYnsÞak;vayRbhar karcab;BRgt;mnusS nigkar

smøab;TahannigbuKÁlikraCkarEdleKcab;)an. bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam )anRtÚveFVI[xVl;citþy:ag

xøaMgkñúgerOgenH BuMenaHeTk¾RtÚveFVI[Gak;Gn;citþxøHEdr. edaymindwgBIkarmincuHsRmúgKñarebobCal,ic

klrbs;PaKITaMgBIr semþc sIhnu )anecaTRbkan;RkúghaNUynigRkúgeb:kaMgeTAvij. GñkÉkeTs

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 69

Page 80: Brother enemy

d¾eqñImmñak; GMBIclnakumµúynIsþkm<úCa)ankt;smÁal;fa ³ «kalNabkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaTTYlC½yCmñH

kan;EteRcIn kalenaHpøÚvpÁt;pÁg;es,óg smÖareyaFa nigTICRmkTaMgLayrbs;evotNamenAkm<úCa k¾

kan;EtgayvinasGnþrayEdr. eTaHCaevotNamFøab;man b¤KµanKMnitb:unb:gbMpøajkartsU‘rbs;bkS

kumµúynIsþkm<úCak¾eday k¾c,as;Nas;fa PaBtantwg nigkarsgS½yKñarvagbkSTaMgBIrkan;EtekIneLIg

eTVeTot»22.

kñúgkartbvijPøam²cMeBaHkaregIbbHe)arrbs;RbCaksikr semþc)anBRgwgkarb®gáabRbqaMgnwg

BYkeqVgniym edaybegáInkarRbmUlpþúMkarykRBHT½yTukdak;eTAelIskmµPaBepSg²kñúgCIvPaBneya)ay

rbs;RbeTs. exov sMpn nig hU‘ yn; CaGñkesdæsa®sþEdlbNþúHbNþalenAsalas½re)an (Sorbonne)

naTIRkúg):arIs RBmTaMgbBaØvnþkumµúynIsþdéTeTotrYmTaMg h‘U nwm pg EdlrhUtmkdl;eBlenaH)an

sRmbxøÜneTAtamRbB½n§dwknaMrbs;semþc sIhnu )aneKcxøÜnrt;cUléRB. mü:ageTot bNþaKNbkSniym

sþaM nigbNþa]tþmesnIy_Edlminyl;Rsbnwgneya)ayRbqaMgGaemrikaMgrbs;semþc CaBiesskar

bdiesFminTTYlykCMnYyshrdæGaemrikrbs;RBHGgÁ enAqñaM1963 )ancat;TukRBHGgÁCaGñkTTYl

xusRtÚvcMeBaHkartaMgTICRmkrbs;evotkugenAelITwkdIkm<úCa nig\T§iBlrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaEdl

kan;EtrIkFMeLIg²pg. enAqñaM1968 semþc cab;epþImsgS½yBIkarKaMRTrbs;RbeTscin. RBHGgÁ)an

RtÚveFVI[rMCYlRBHT½yy:agxøaMg edaykarehorkMBb;énbdivtþn_vb,Fm’enARbeTscinEdllT§plrbs;va

nwgsayPaymkdl;km<úCaminxankalebI»kashuc[. edayBinitüeXIjBYkcinrlas;ecalRbFana

FibtI lIv cavCI CaTIeKarBy:agRCaleRCArbs;RBHGgÁ edaysarmUlehtumenaKmviC¢aenaH semþc

sIhnu k¾)andNþwgsYrkñúgRBHT½y BIeCaKvasnapÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁEdr23. mü:ageTot semþc)an

cab;epþImxVayxVl;BIkareRbIR)as;TwkdIkm<úCa edayevotkugEdlmansPaBkan;EtraldalFMeLIg²

EfmeTot. karekIneLIgnUvcMnYn kgT½BGaemrikaMgy:ageRcInenAevotNam eRkamGaNtþiRbFanaFibtI

lIndun Eb‘n hSnsun [)aneLIgkan;tMENgCaRbFanaFibtIbnÞab;BIkarlYceFVIXatRbFanaFibtI ekNÑWDI

enAqñaM1963 ehIyRtÚv)aneRCIstaMgCafµIsRmab;GaNtþiTIBIreTotBIqñaM1964-1968] )annaM[

semþc manRBHraCtRmiHsaCafµI ³ etIC½yCmñHrbs;kumµúynIsþBitCaTb;min)anEmnb¤? enAqñaM1969

semþc sIhnu )anseRmcRBHT½yerobcMTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUtCamYyRkúgv:asuInetaneLIgvij. kñúgeBl

CamYyKñaenaH RBHGgÁ)aneFVI[BYkGaemrikaMgdwgCasm¶at;fa RBHGgÁ «nwgbiTRBHenRt» ebIsinCaBYk

GaemrikaMgTmøak;RKab;EbkelICRmknanarbs;evotkug kñúgtMbn;nanarbs;km<úCaEdlminsUvmanmnusS

rs;enA24.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg70

Page 81: Brother enemy

karKYrsmfµIenHrbs;semþccMeBaHmhaGMNacGaemrikaMg KµanGVIeRkAEtBICYyBRgwg[]tþm

esnIy_ ln; nl; nig RBHGgÁm©as; suIsuvtiß sirimt³ EdlCaemdwknaMRkúmRbqaMgminEmnkumµúynIsþrwtEt

rwgmaMeLIg²kñúgkarRbqaMgrbs;GñkTaMgBIrcMeBaHrbbrbs;semþcb:ueNÑaH. RBwtþikarN_epSg²kan;EtsµúK

sµajeLIg² edaysarvis½yesdækic©)anFøak;cuHy:agF¶n;F¶r. enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1970 karekIneLIgnUv

karrMeCIbrMCYl)anpþl;»kas[BYksþaMniymbBa©b;bBaðaenHCamYysemþc nigPkþIPaBEdlRtg;Kµanl,ickl

rbs;RBHGgÁ kñúgkarsnüaCamYyevotkugnigevotNamxageCIg. karxVayxVl;RBHT½yTaMgenH)anekIt

manRBmKñanwgEpnkarrbs;GaemrikaMg EdlkMBuge)assm¥atTICRmknanarbs;evotkugenAkm<úCa edIm,I

deNþImykQñHBYkenHenAevotNamxagt,Úg. KµanGñkNamñak;Gacpþl;P½sþútagEdlminGacRbEkk)an

sþIBIkarcUlBak;B½n§edaypÞal;rbs;Gaemrik kñúgkarrYmKMnitk,t;RbqaMgnwgsemþc sIhnu eLIy. b:uEnþRkúg

v:asuInetan )andwgBIerOgenHehIyBuMmaneFVIskmµPaBGVITaMgGs;edIm,IXat;XaMgpgeT. shrdæGaemrik

cUlcitþCYysemþc sIhnu mYyédmYyeCIgCasm¶at;kñúgkarRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgBYkkumµúynIsþevotNamEdr.

k¾b:uEnþ GnusSavrIy_énPaBCasRtÚvknøgmkrbs;RBHGgÁmanlkçN³F¶n;F¶reBk eRBaHEtebIkéd[eKeFVI

GnþraKmn_CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;RBHGgÁ. bkSBYkRbqaMgEdlRbqaMgevotNamy:agxøaMgkøa)anke®Ba¢al

eLIgTl;nwgsemþc dUcEdlGtItCMnajkarmñak;rbs;es>GuI>Ga> eQµaH RhVg;sñIb )ankt;smÁal;BIerOg

enHfa «eyIgminGaceFVIGVIeRkAEtBIsEmþgkarsb,aycitþ ehIycaMEteqøótTajykRbeyaCn_BIsßan

karN_enHb:ueNÑaH»25.

bnÞab;BIman)atukmµRbqaMgevotNamenARkúgPñMeBj nigkarlukluybMpøicbMpøajsßanTUtevotNam

xageCIgedayhVÚgnisSitmYyRkúm enAéf¶18 mIna 1970 rdæsPaCatinigBYksþaMniymPaKeRcInkñúg

sPa)ane)aHeqñatTmøak;semþc sIhnu BItMENg edayRbKl;esckþITukcitþeTA[]tþmesnIy_ ln; nl;

EdleBlenaHCardæm®nþITI1 nigCardæm®nþIkarBarRbeTskan;tMENgCMnYsvij. semþc sIhnu EdleBl

enaH sßitenATIRkúgmUsÁÚ)aneLIgynþehaHeq<aHmkRkúgeb:kaMgCaTIEdlRBHGgÁnwgerobcMCakEnøgnireTs

xøÜnenATIenHEtmþg.

rdæRbharRbqaMgnwgsemþc sIhnu )aneFVI[BYkeqVgniymrbs;km<úCasßitkñúgeRKaHfñak; ehIyk¾eFVI

[b:HBal;dl;CRmkTaMgLaynigpøÚvpÁt;pÁg;smÖarsRmab;evotkugpgEdr. edayehtuenH ExµrRkhm nig

evotNam)anRtÚvbgçMcitþeFVIsm<½n§PaBnwgKñaRbqaMgTl;nwgsRtÚvrYmrbs;xøÜnKWrdæaPi)alrbs; ln; nl;

EdlRTRTg;edayshrdæGaemrik. semþcEdlRtÚveKTmøak;BItMENg)aneFVICaGñkTTYlxusRtÚvsMxan;én

sm<½n§PaBfµIenH. ExµrRkhmRtÚvkarRBHnamRBHGgÁedIm,IseRmc[)anPaBRsbc,ab;CaGnþrCatimYy

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 71

Page 82: Brother enemy

nigedIm,IRbmUlkarKaMRTBIRbCaksikrEdlmancMnYny:ageRcInelIslb;. cMENkBYkevotNamvij)an

vinicä½yBItYGgÁsemþcfa minRtwmEtCacnÞl;mYyrbs;clnatsU‘RbqaMgshrdæGaemrik nig ln; nl;

b:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþk¾CameFüa)aymYyraraMg]tþmanuPaB ¬PaBmanGMNacelIslb;eKÉg¦énclnarbs;

b:ul Bt enAB§d_épÞkñúgsm<½n§PaBEdr.

\riyabfrbs;RbeTscinmanlkçN³RseBcRsBilbMput. CamYykarKaMBarrbs;BYkCMnajkar

breTsxøH semþc sIhnu )anbdiesFedaymuWgm:at;nUvbBaðaEdlelIkeLIgedayRkúghaNUy eRBaHfa

BYkcinGacrYjrakñúgkarKaMRTRBHGgÁ. semþc)anGHGagfa «taMgBImankarCYbKñaelIkdMbUg enAnievsndæan

rbs;´enAéf¶TI19 Ex]sPa qñaM1975 CU eGnLay )anRBmeRBógCamYy´edIm,IbBa¢ak;fa KµanbBaða

RtÚvTTYlsÁal; «ehtukarN_seRmceFVIRCúlehIy»Edldak;bgçMedayGñkeFVIrdæRbhareLIy ehIyfa

RtÚvbdiesFdac;xatnUvPaBeBjc,ab;TaMgGs;énrbbfµIrbs;Exµrpg». k¾b:uEnþ CU BuM)ansakl,gbBa©úH

bBa©Úlsemþc[rYbrYmCamYyExµrRkhmeT. semþc)anmanRBHbnÞÚlfa RBHGgÁCaGñkBaMnaMsarrbs;

RbFan em:A enH EdlmanxøwmsardUcxageRkam ³

«Rkúgeb:kaMgnwgeKarBeday\tgaker nUvesckþIseRmccitþTaMgGs;Edlsemþc)anRbkan;yk

ebIRBHGgÁsBVRBHT½ybBa©b;GaCIBneya)ay eRkayBImanrdæRbharkñúgeBlfµI² RbeTscinnwgeKarB

eTAtamkarseRmcRBHT½yenH. b:uEnþebIRBHGgÁminTTYlsÁal;ehtukarN_EdlekIteLIgrYcmk ehIyeT

ehIysBVRBHT½yeFVICaemdwknaMclnaCatimYykñúgkartsU‘RbqaMgnwgGaemrikaMg edIm,IrMedaHRbeTs

km<úCaenaH RbeTscinnwgpþl;nUvkarKaMRTrbs;xøÜny:ageBjTMhwg ehIyyl;RBmpþl;CMnYyRKb;Ebby:ag

fVayRBHGgÁtamEdlGaceFVIeTA)an»26.

rebobbkRsayrbs;semþc sIhnu GacR)ab;[dwgedayEpñkfa Rkúgeb:kaMg GacenAmaneBl

evlamYykñúgkarrkSacMNgTak;TgepSg²CamYyrbb ln; nl; sin. edayCak;Esþg RbeTscinKµan

bMNgkat;pþac;TMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜnCamYyRkúgPñMeBj edayminTan;eFVI[R)akdRbCaBIlT§PaBmYykñúgkar

RbqaMgedayGavuFeTenaH. kñúgeBlEdlmankareFVIrdæRbhar Rkúgeb:kaMg)ancab;epþIméllkEklMG

TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYyRkúgv:asuInetan[)anRbesIrCagmunEdr edaydkRsg;BIemeronepSg²

énkarRbQmmuxxagkgT½BCaelIkdMbUgrbs;xøÜnCamYyshPaBsUevot. s®gÁammYyRbqaMgTl;nwg

ln; nl; GaceFVI[GVI²RKb;Ebby:agvinasGnþray.

kareXasnarbs;evotNam)anGHGageRkaymkfa RbeTscinEdlcUlédcUleCIgCamYy ln; nl;

KWedIm,IraraMgC½yCmñHrbs;evotkugenAPaKxagt,ÚgevotNam. GñknaMBaküpøÚvkarrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg72

Page 83: Brother enemy

evotNam v:ag Tug )anniyayerOgGaf’kM)aMgR)ab;´fa enAExmIna qñaM1970 BYkcin)anbgðajnUvkar

raErkcitþxøH²cMeBaHsemþc sIhnu BIeRBaHBYkcinmineBjcitþnwgRBHGgÁEdlTietonRbFan em:A kñúgsm½y

cineFVIbdivtþvb,Fm’. Tug )anbEnßmR)ab;´eTotfa «cMENkBYkmitþkumµúynIsþkm<úCarbs;eyIgk¾mincUl

citþ semþc sIhnu Edr BIeRBaHRBHGgÁCaGñkkemÞcbkSrbs;eKenAcenøaH qñaM1955-1965>>>27.

kñúg»kasénkarKg;Rbfab;rbs;semþc sIhnu enARkúgeb:kaMgkñúgExmIna qñaM970 TaMg CU eGnLay TaMg

b:ul Bt BuM)anpþÜcepþImKMnitedIm,IKaMRTsemþc[cUlrYmkñúgclnatsU‘eLIy. KWeyIgeT ¬evotNam¦ Edl

CaGñknwkeXIjeFVIkarpþÜcepþÍmKMnitenH. paM v:an;dug EdldwknaMKN³RbtiPUsm¶at;mYyeTARkúgeb:kaMgbIéf¶

eRkayrdæRbhar)anRtÚvcat;[TTYlParkic©bBa©úHbBa©Úl CU eGnLay. cMENk paM h‘ug smaCikkariya

l½y neya)ayEdlGmdMeNIr dug ehIyEdlFøab;beRmICaGnþrkarITak;TgCamYyExµrRkhmmunqñaM

1970 enaHKWmankrNIykic©RbwgERbgbBa©úHbBa©Úl b:ul Bt».

semþc sIhnu )anGHGagBIkarTTYl)ankic©KaMRTmYyy:agkk;ekþABI paM v:an;dug. enAéf¶TI23 ExmIna

qñaM1970 bnÞab;BIkarCYbsnÞnaEtBIrnak;ttYGs;ry³eBly:agyUrmk semþc)anRbkasesckþI

GMBavnavmYysuM[RbCaBlrdæcUlrYmeFVIkartsU‘edayGavuF. kñúglixitmYysresredayédepJIfVay

semþcenAeBlEdlKat;ecjBIRkúgeb:kaMgenAéf¶TI24 ExmInaenaH dug )ansEmþgkñúgnamRbCaCnevot

NamnUv«menaseBa©tnamitþPaB karesI¶csresIrnigkareKarBrab;Gand¾RCaleRCAbMputcMeBaHsemþc

cMeBaHneya)ay nigkarRbyuT§rbs;RBHGgÁkñúgzan³CaemdwknaMRbCaCnExµrd¾Gg;Gackøahan»28.

karTak;TgKñad¾kk;ekþA nigRbkbedaymitþPaB)anbRgÜbbRgÜmsemþc sIhnu nigBYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUy

kñúgry³eBlR)aMqñaMEdr.

b:unµanéf¶eRkayBIkarsnüaKaMRTenH kgT½BevotkugCaeRcInkgÉkPaB)anRtÚvcat;[eFVIdMeNIr

xVat;ExVgtamPUmiCaeRcInenAPaKxagekItkm<úCaedIm,IEckpSayxitþb½NÑ EdlcmøgtamesckþIGMBavnav

rbs;semþc sIhnu enAtamPUmiTaMgenaH nig[RbCaksikrsþab;sarrbs;RBHGgÁ Edlftcmøgmk

cak;pSaybnþeTotpg. RbCaRbiyPaBrbs;semþckñúgcMeNamRbCaksikrExµr)anTak;Taj[GñkTaMg

enaHcUleFVIkgT½Brab;rynak; edayevotNamCaGñkbNþúHbNþalhVwkhVWnk,ÜnyuT§sa®sþ nigbMBak;

GavuF[ edIm,IbegáItkgT½BsIhnuniymmYyEdlRbsiT§namfaExµrrMedaH. mü:ageTot BYkRKÚbgðat;Ca

TahanevotNamxageCIg)anbegáItsalaeyaFamYyenAkñúgextþRkecH¬PaK|san¦ edIm,IhVwkhVWn

kgT½BExµrEdleTIbcUlfµI. edayGagelIGVIEdlsemþc sIhnu [eQµaHfa «Exlrbs;evotNam

xageCIgEdlRbkbedayRbsiT§PaBmYy nigvIrPaBmYyminGacRbEkk)an»enaH cMnYnkgT½Brbs;clna

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 73

Page 84: Brother enemy

tsU‘Exµr)anrIkFMFat;BI4000nak; enAExmIna qñaM1970 eLIgdl;Cit30>000nak;enAqñaM1975.

ln; nl; )ancab;epþImeFVIRbtibtþikarswkepSg² edIm,IrMedaHTIRkúgnanaEdleLamB½T§edayExµrRkhm[

)anFUrRsalxøH b:uEnþRtÚveBIbRbTHnwgkgkaMePøIgFM kgrfeRkaH nigkgT½BefµIreCIgrbs;evotNam

y:ageRcIn. enAdMNac;qñaM1972 ExµrRkhmnigkgÉkPaBrbs;ExµrrMedaHCaeRcIn )ancab;epþÍmeFVI

RbtibtþikaredayÉkraCüerog²xøÜn. enAeBlCamYyKñaenaH kgT½Berobryrbs;RkúghaNUy)anvay

kemÞckgT½B ln; nl; min[seRmceCaKC½yrYceRsceTAehIy. TwkdIrbs;km<úCamYyPaKFM)anFøak;eTA

kñúgkNþab;édBYk]TÞambHe)ar.

Gaf’kM)aMgénsm<½n§PaBmYy

eCaKC½yrbs;clnatsU‘ k¾[RbpñÚlBITIbBa©b;énsm<½n§PaBrvagbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCanigRkúg

haNUyEdr. karEklm¥KYr[kt;smÁal;nUvTMnak;TMngrbs;BYkeK[kan;EtRbesIreLIgeRkayExmIna

qñaM1970 BuM)aneFVI[karsgS½yrbs; b:ul Bt rlay)at;eLIy. kñúgkRmgGnusSavrIy_rbs;

RBHGgÁEdlmanBIqñaM1970-71 semþc)anerobrab;BIRBwtþikarN_xøI²Ebøk²KYr[Ck;citþdUcteTA ³

rdæm®nþICaeRcInrUbénrdæaPi)alrbs;clnatsU‘ExµrEdleTAeFVITsSnkic©enARkúghaNUy )anBiPakSaKña

CaÉkCnGMBI«karlak;Butrbs;yYn» edayrMB£kpgEdrBIPaBcaM)ac;sRmab;BYkm®nþIExµrénrNsirSrYbrYm

Catikm<úCakuM[TukcitþmhicätaRtÜtRtaeKrbs;evotNam bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHrYmelIBYkQøanBan y:an;XI

(Yankee) nigCnk,t; ln; nl;». [¬y:an; XI eQµaHEdlBYkGg;eKøsehArebobcMGkcMeBaHniKmCn

bHe)arenAnUEv:lGg;KøWETr EdlbegáIteLIgenAstvtSr_TI17 sßittameqñrsmuRTGatøg;Tic KWrdæEm:n/

jÚvehmesðór/ Ev:m:ugt_/ m:asSaQUEsSt/ rU:déGLin nig xunENtFIxIt tmkeTotKWCaeQµaHEdlBYkPaK

xagt,ÚgehABYkPaKxageCIg ehIyTIbMputehARbCaBlrdæGg;køÚ-sak;sug(Anglo-saxons) TUTaMgshrdæ

GaemrikEtmþg-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb]. b:uEnþ«CBa¢aMgmanRtecok»dUcEdlsemþc sIhnu RTg;lixit

edaykareBbRCaymYyfa ³ edaymaneKraykarN_R)ab;]tþmesnIy_ v:egVóg y:ab BaküsmþIenH)an

eFVI[Kat;Gak;Gn;citþCaxøaMg. enAeBlEdlKat;CYbsemþc sIhnu enAéf¶bnÞab; Kat;)anRbkasfa «smþI

RbqaMgevotNam»TaMgenHrbs;bNþam®nþIénrNsirSrYbrYmCatikm<úCaEdleBalBaküeCrRkúghaNUy

«)aneFVI[eyIgQWcab;éRkElg kñúgeBlEdlkgT½Brbs;eyIgsuxcitþXøatq¶ayBImatuPUmiCaTIRsLaj;

nigBIRkúmRKÜsarCaTIesñhabMputrbs;xøÜn edIm,IvayRbyuT§nigsøab;erogral;éf¶enAelITwkdId¾Bisidærbs;

bgb¥ÚnExµr edayc,aMgttaMgnwgsRtÚvrYmrbs;eyIg edIm,IeFVIkarse®gÁaHCati nigkarrMedaHRbeTsrbs;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg74

Page 85: Brother enemy

RBHGgÁKWkm<úCa».

karEbkFøaysmþIrbs; y:ab manlkçN³føwgEføgmunrYcCaeRsc. karEbkFøayenHKWCakar

eqøIytbeTAsmþIminsmrmüxøH. karEbkFøayenHk¾bgðaj[eXIjkarxkcitþEdlbNþalmkBIkareFVIsh

Rbtibtþikarrbs;eKCamYyExµrRkhmEdr. kñúg»kasénkic©crcaKñaCamYy eL yn; enARkúghaNUy

naExemsa qñaM1970 b:ul Bt )anRbqaMgCMTas;nwgkarbegáItbBa¢akarÉkPaBmYyEdlesñIeLIgeday

evotNam. enAqñaM1970-71 rNsirSExµrEdleTIbnwgkekIt)anRtÚvExµrRkhmykeTAdak;CMnYs

evotNamedIm,IRKb;RKgPUmirMedaHnana. enAqñaM1971 TMnak;TMngrvagBYkExµrRkhmnigkgT½BevotNam

enAkm<úCa)anFøak;cuHCabeNþIr². enAqñaM1978 Exµr)anQanrhUtdl;ecaTRbkan;evotNamEfmeTot

fa )anb:unb:gdak;fñaMbMBulsmøab; b:ul Bt enAqñaM1970 kñúg»kasénkic©RbCuMmYy. ExµrminEdlbgðaj

[eXIjP½sþútagNamYysþIBIerOgenHesaH b:uEnþkarecaTRbkan;enH KWCasBaØadMbUgénbriyakasmnÞil

sgS½yKña EdlkMBugelIkykmkCasMGagrvagPaKITaMgBIr. eK)anGankñúgr)aykarN_mYyrbs;Rkúm

es>GuI>Ga> cuHkalbriecäTExkBaØa qñaM1970fa BYkkgT½BExµrRkhm)an)aj;eRsacBIeRkayeTAelI

BYkkumµúynIsþevotNam EdlCab;édRbyuT§CamYykgÉkPaBmYyrbs; ln; nl; enAkñúgextþkMBg;FM29.

®sþIevotNammñak;eQµaH egVóg FIKU )anr:ayr:ab;Rbvtþirbs;nagR)ab;´enAqñaM1978fa nag)an

rYcputeRKaHfñak;BIkarqµk;vayRbharmYyrbs;ExµrRkhmenAqñaM1972 enAkñúgextþtaynij. nagyl;

c,as;dUcRbCaCnevotNamrab;Ban;nak;Edlrs;enAkm<úCaEdrfa CakarRbesIrRtÚvEtrt;ePosxøÜnecjBI

tMbn;EdlExµrRkhmRtÜtRta. kalBIedImRKÜsarnag)ancakecjBIevotNamxageCIgedIm,ImkeFVIkar

kñúgcmáarekAsU‘)araMgmYyenACb;¬extþkMBg;cam¦. bþInigb¥ÚnRbúsBIrnak;rbs;nag)ancUleFVIT½BCamYy

evotkugenAcugTsvtSr_60. kgT½BTaMgenaH)aneFVIkarTak;TgCamYyBYkExµrRkhmeRkayBImankarpþÜl

rMlMsemþc sIhnu. enAcugqñaM1971 ExµrRkhm)ancab;epþImeFVITukçbukemñjshKmn_evotNam enA

cmáarekAsU‘ ehIyQb;lk;RsUvGgár[BYkenHEfmeTot. nag)anniyayR)ab;´fa «kgT½BrMedaHCati

rbs;evotNam)ansakl,gkarBarBYkeyIgEdr b:uEnþvamansPaBkan;EtlM)akxøaMgeLIg². enAqñaM

1972 b¥ÚnRbúsrbs;´EdleFVIT½B)anCYyRkúmRKÜsarrbs;eyIg[ePosxøÜnecjBIRbeTskm<úCa».

vibtþiEdlenAekþAgMrvagevotNam nigExµrRkhm)anpÞúHeLIgenAcugqñaM1972 kñúgry³eBlénkic©

crcasnþiPaBdMNak;kalcugeRkayrvagGaemrik-evotNam nigkarsakl,gCaeRcIn)anRtÚverobcM

eLIgedIm,IbBa©úHbBa©Úl[ExµrRkhmeFVIkic©BiPakSaCamYy ln; nl;. hg;rI KIsSúIghÁ½r (Henry Kissinger)

Gñkcrcarbs;Gaemrik)anbBa¢ÚnsMeNIenHeTA[BYkemdwknaMExµrRkhmkñúg»kasénkarRbCuMKñaCahUrEhmYy

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 75

Page 86: Brother enemy

EdleFVIedaylYclak;enAcugqñaM1972 ehIyCaelIkcugeRkayKWenAcenøaH éf¶TI24 nigTI26 Exmkra

kñúg»kasénkarCYbKñamYyrvag paM hu‘g smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayevotNamCamYy b:ul Bt.

b:ul Bt )anCMTas;nwgKat; edaykarbdiesFrebobemIlgaymYy eRBaHKat;emIleXIjc,as;fa rbbÉeka

nwgs¥úyekrþ×eQµaHrbs; ln; nl; manCIvitmkdl;em:agcugeRkayrbs;xøÜnehIy ehIyfasßankarN_

EpñkeyaFak¾manPaBGnueRKaHsRmab;Kat;Edr. evotNam)aneRkInrMB£kExµrRkhmfa karbdiesFmin

RBmcrcaenHnwgnaM[mankarsgswky:agF¶n;F¶rBIsMNak;BYkGaemrikaMgminxan EdlerOgenH b:ul Bt

yl;faCakarsakl,gKMramkMEhgmYy. eRkaymkesovePAexµA)anGHGagfa edayGs;meFüa)ay

eRbIkmøaMgevotNamRtÚvkarbnøayeBlevla ehIyCaBiessmincg;[clnatsU‘rbs;km<úCa QñHeday

KµankarCYyrbs;xøÜneLIy BIeRBaHenAeBlenaHxøÜnRtÚvkarlHbg;mineFVI[RbeTskm<úCaeTACarNbmYy

rbs;evotNameT30.

eTaHCay:agNak¾eday evotNamBitCayl;eXIjRtwmRtÚvEmncMeBaHGVIEdlCakarsgswk.

edaykøayeTACaKµanRbeyaCn_kñúgPaKesssl;én\NÐÚcin hVÚgynþehaHcm,aMgrbs;GaemrikaMg)an

Tmøak;RKab;EbkcMnYn257>465etan mkelIRbeTskm<úCaenAcenøaHExkumÖ³ nigExsIha qñaM1973 KW

RtÚvCaBak;kNþaleRcInCagRKab;EbkEdlTmøak;elIRbeTsCb:unkñúgsm½ys®gÁamelakelIkTI2eTAeTot

edaybgá[manGñkrgeRKaHCaRbCaCnsuIvily:ageRcIn\tKNna. bYnqñaMeRkaymk kñúgsßanTUtrebob

bnÞayTahanrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüenARkúghaNUy Guin suIvuF )anrMB£kenAcMeBaHmux´CamYykar

tUccitþBI«GMeBIk,t;rbs;evotNam»EdlRbRBwtþelµIseday)ancuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógsnþiPaB

mYydac;edayELkCamYysRtÚv ehIydUcCabeNþay[BYkGaemrikaMgmanesrIPaBRbmUlpþú¿kMhwgxøaMg

rbs;eKRbqaMgnwgRbeTskm<úCaEtmþg. ]TahrN_ EdlmaneKalbMNgCak;lak;rbs;Rkúm b:ul Bt KW

Tmøak;karTTYlxusRtÚvBIeRKaHGaRkk;TaMgGs;rbs;xøÜneTAelIevotNam tamry³karerIseGIsCati

sasn_nigPaBCasRtÚvsYBUC. edayCak;Esþg kartsU‘rbs;km<úCaEdleFVI[BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUy

eBjcitþEtkñúgkrNIEdlkarts‘UenaHGacCMrujbuBVehtupÞal;rbs;eK[eCOneTAmuxb:ueNÑaH ehIycMENk

ExµrRkhmvijk¾minsUvbgðaj[eXIjkarrevosrévCYyevotNam[bRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTsrbs;eKeLIg

vijEdr.

edaypÞúynwgmtirYm ebIBYkGaemrikaMgmanesrIPaBnwgeFVIGIV²enARbeTskm<úCa BitehIyBYkeK

RtÚvEtmankic©RBmeRBógEdlcuHhtßelxaCamYyevotNam b:uEnþ tamelak hg;rI KIsSúIghÁ½r fa k¾RtÚv

mankarKaMRTCasm¶at;BI CU eGnLay Edl«RtÚvkary:agehacnUvGnþraKmn_eyaFarbs;eyIgenA

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg76

Page 87: Brother enemy

RbeTskm<úCaEdr edIm,IeFVI[eKalbMNgrbs;Kat;maneRbóbCag». tam KIsSúIghá½r dEdlfa karTmøak;

RKab;Ebkrbs;GaemrikaMgRKan;EtCacMENkmYyénkartéfød¾FMmYyb:ueNÑaH EdlRsbeTAtamenaH

RbeTscinmanesckþIsgÇwmCMruj[BYksm<n§miRtrbs;xøÜnyl;RBmeFVIkaredaHRsay edaykarcrca

mYy EdlkñúgenaHsemþc sIhnu nwgsEmþgtYnaTIsMxan;CageK31. munkarcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBóg

Rkúg):arIs BYkemdwknaMExµrRkhmRbEhlmindwgfa CU )anniyaynwg KIsSúIghÁ½r fa dMeNaHRsaynwg

kan;EtgayRsYlenARbeTskm<úCak¾dUcenAevotNam «BIeRBaHeTaHCamanGVIekIteLIgk¾eday k¾vac,as;

Nas;fa smasPaBvNѳKhbtICatienAkm<úCa [nwgmancMENkmYy] kñúgrdæaPi)alehIyfa semþc

sIhnu nwgkøayCaRbmuxrdæedayecosminput»32.

R)aMBIrExeRkaymk ebITukCaExµrRkhm)anbdiesFmincrcaCamYy ln; nl; ehIyebITukCaman

karvaybukTmøúHy:agelOnrh½srbs;kgT½BExµrRkhmk¾eday k¾ CU eGnLay enAEtCamnusSmñak;cg;[

mankarrkdMeNaHRsayedaykarcrcaCanic©. evotNamBuM)anseRmceCaKC½ykñúgkarnaMExµrRkhm

mkkan;tucrcaeLIy. enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1973 evotNam)anesñIeyabl;[elak KIsSúIghÁ½r CYbsemþc

sIhnu. R)aMbIqñaMeRkaymk enAeBlEdlrdæm®nþIkarbreTsGaemrikaMgrMB£kBIerOgenH Kat;)anvinicä½yfa

karesIñeyabl;rbs;evotNamCa«sMeNImanlkçN³KeXøIn» ebIeRbóbeFobeTAnwgkarxVayxVl;xøaMg

EmnETnrbs; CU edIm,InaMyksemþcmkkan;GMNacvij33. k¾b:uEnþGVI²)aneFVI[eKKitfa evotNamman

eKalbMNgelgsnøwkebo sIhnu y:agR)akd. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday k¾evotNammanlT§PaBeFVIGVI²

eRcInCag CU enAeBlCECkCamYyBYkExµrRkhmEdlmanninñakarem:Aniym.

b:uEnþ GñksegátkarN_xøHnwkq¶l;Etmñak;Égfa kñúgerOgenH CU cg;[mankarvilRtLb;rbs;semþc

mkkan;GMNacEmnb¤? b¤Kat;RKan;Etcg;eRbIR)as;RbCaRbiyPaBnigkitüanuPaBCaGnþrCatirbs;RBHGgÁ

edIm,IFana[manC½yCmñHdl;ExµrRkhmEdlCasm<½n§mitþxagmenaKmviC¢arbs;RbeTscineTdwg? b:uEnþ

naykrdæm®nþI CU eGnLay EdlQWy:agF¶n; ehIyEfmTaMgRtÚveBIbRbTHnwgkarRbqaMgCMTas;dac;xat

mYyEdldwknaMeday cag Qij RbBn§ em:A enAqñaM1973 pgenaH ElgGaceFVI[plRbeyaCn_

epSg²rbs;semþc sIhnu maneRbóbelIplRbeyaCn_rbs;ExµrRkhmeTotehIy. enAcugqñaM1974

enAeBlEdlBYk)araMgcab;epþImeRbImeFüa)ayepSg² xagkarTUtCasm¶at;edayshkarCamYyRkúg

v:asuInetankñúgeKaledAnaMyksemþc[eFVICaemdwknaMrdæaPi)alcRmúHTUlMTUlaymYyenaH \riyabf

rbs;BYkcinEbreTACamanlkçN³minc,as;las;y:agxøaMg34.

semþc)ansEmþgnUvkardwgKuNcMeBaH CU GMBImitþPaBnigkarKaMRTEdlKat;FanakarBarRBHGgÁ

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 77

Page 88: Brother enemy

RbqaMgnwgExµrRkhmEdlCaBYkniymRCúlhYsehtu b:uEnþeTaHbIy:agNak¾eday k¾RBHGgÁ)anqøgkat;

karsgS½ykñúg»kasxøHEdr. semþc)anmanbnÞÚlR)ab;´Casm¶at;TaMgQWcab;fa «taMgBIdMbUg²emø:H ´

eCOCak;dUcBYkcinEdrfa ExµrRkhmnwgrlas;´ecal». enAExemsa qñaM1980 kñúgGMLúgénkarCYb

snÞnay:agyUrkñúgnievsndæand¾l¥eqItqayrbs;RBHGgÁenARkúgeb:kaMg semþc)anrMB£kBIbNþaqñaMCabnþ

bnÞab;eRkayBIkarpþÜlrMlMRBHGgÁ. KWenAqñaM1971 Edlsemþc)anesñI CU CaelIkdMbUgbMput [CYy

bBa©úHbBa©ÚlExµrRkhmGnuBaØat[RBHGgÁyageTAkan;tMbn;rMedaHenAkm<úCaedayGHGagfa lkçN³Edl

KYr[eCO)ankñúgzan³RBHGgÁCaemdwknaMrdæaPi)alclnatsU‘GacnwgxVHcenøaHebIRBHGgÁKg;nireTsdUecñH

b:uEnþKµanGñkNamYyrvl;eGIeBIeLIy. «GVIEdleFVI[´Gak;Gn;RBHT½ybnþicbnþÜcKWfa RbeTscinminKaMRT

´bnþicesaH». CU )anniyayedaHsaedayelIkBImUlehtuxagsnþisuxedIm,IhamXat;RBHraCdMeNIr

rbs;RBHGgÁ. pøÚvlMhUCImijCapøÚvRtÚveFVIdMeNIrmkkan;km<úCarMedaHenaHKWsßitenAeRkamkarTmøak;RKab;

EbkCaRbcaM. bnÞab;BIkarcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógsnþiPaBRkúg):arIs semþc sIhnu )anesñIsuM

karGnuBaØatmkeFVITsSnkic©matuPUmi cMeBaH eGog sarI EdlsßitenATIRkúgeb:kaMgkñúgcenøaHExsIha

qñaM1971 nigExemsa qñaM1975 CaTIEdlKat;TTYlr:ab;rgTMnak;TMngrvagExµrRkhmnigbkSkumµúynIsþ

cin ehIyRBmeBlCamYyenaH Kat;k¾Ca«GñkcaMXVal»esþcEdlEkmineLIgenHEdr. enHCakarbdiesF

dac;xatmYy. semþc)ansakl,gpSgsMNagrbs;RBHGgÁCafµImþgeTotenATIRkúghaNUy. cab;taMg

BIRBHGgÁseRmcRBHT½yKg;enATIRkúgeb:kaMg semþcEtgEtyageTATIenaHerogral;buNücUlqñaMcin-yYn

edIm,ICatwgtagénsamKÁIPaBrbs;RBHGgÁcMeBaHRbCaCnevotNam. kñúg»kasénTsSnkic©cUlrYmBiFI

buNücUlqñaMenAExkumÖ³ qñaM1973 RBHGgÁ)anTTUcsuM[ paM v:an;dug CYyeFVIGnþraKmn_CamYyExµrRkhm

CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;RBHGgÁfa «elakmanmeFüa)ayekobsgát;mYyeTAelIBYkenaH BYkeKBuMGacbnþkar

vayRbyuT§)aneT ebIsinCaelakmindwkCBa¢ÚnsmÖarswkEdlRbeTscin)anpþl;[tamry³RbeTs

elakenaH. sUmelakniyayR)ab;fa sIhnu mankrNIykic©vilRtLb;eTAkm<úCavij ebIsinCaBYkeK

cg;[´eFVICatMNagRbeTsrbs;eKRbkbedaykitþiys nigPaBéføfñÚrkñúgsm½yRbCu¿énbNþaRbeTsmin

cUlbkSsm<½n§enATIRkúgGal;ehSr ¬RbeTsGal;ehSrI¦». bnÞab;mk dug )anCYbBiPakSaKñay:agyUr

CamYy eGog sarI BIPaBcaM)ac;kñúgkarGnuBaØat[semþcyageTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtMbn;rMedaH. sarI

enAEtmineTarTn;. TIbMput dug )anniyaynwgBYkcinvijmþg ehIyTTYl)aneCaKC½yy:agRbesIr. «enA

eBl´¬semþc¦vilRtLb;eTARbeTscinvij eGog sarI )anmkTUl´fa ´)anTTYlkarGnuBaØatBI«Gñk

enAkñúgRbeTs»[yageTAeFVITsSnkic©enAkm<úCaehIy. erOgenH KWedaysarEtGnþraKmn_rbs; paM

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg78

Page 89: Brother enemy

v:an;dug b:ueNÑaH»35.

ebIsinkarvilRtLb;CaRbvtþisa®sþrbs;semþc sIhnu eTARbeTskm<úCabIqñaMeRkayBIkarpþÜlrMlM

RBHGgÁKWCalT§plénkarbgçitbgçMrbs;RkúghaNUyEmnenaH dMeNIrenH)aneFVI[RBHGgÁføwgEføgGMBIkar

ExVgKMnitKñaEdlkan;EteRCAeTA² edayeFVI[ExµrRkhmRbQmmuxnwgevotNamEdltaMgxøÜnCasmmitþ

rbs;BYkeKy:agBitR)akd. enAExmIna qñaM1973 semþc)aneLIgynþehaHeq<aHeTARkúghaNUy

bnÞab;mk tamynþehaHGg;tUNUv-26 mYyeRKÓgrbs;kgT½BGakasevotNameq<aHmkkan;tMbn; dugh½r

enAPaKxagt,ÚgbMputrbs;RbeTsevotNamxageCIg. GmdMeNIredaymehsIRBHGgÁ/ egVón eFOg

ÉkGKÁrdæTUtevotNamEdlmanGMNacelIseKenAkm<úCa nig eGog sarI pÞal; semþc sIhnu )anyag

eFVIdMeNIrcuHtampøÚvlMhUCImijedayrfynþkumµ:g;ka (Command Car). ry³eBleBjmYyExEdlRBHGgÁ

yagBIkEnøgmYyeTAkEnøgmYyenAkñúgPaKxageCIg nig|sanRbeTs RBHGgÁRTg;RBHsNþab;B¤BaküecaT

Rbkan;evotNamfa manbMNg«bMpøajrdæGMNacExµrRkhmtaMgBIminTan;ekItemø:H». sun esn )an

benÞaskgT½BevotNamfa )ancUlqk;bøn;GñkRsukkm<úCa rMelaPRbBn§rbs;BYkeK taMgmUldæanT½Bkñúg

RbeTsedayKµankarGnuBaØat eRCIserIsRbCaCnExµr[eFVICaT½BCMnYysRmab;kgT½BevotNam nigekg

bnøMsmÖareyaFarbs;cinEdlpþl;mk[km<úCa. cMENk exov sMpn )anTUlfVay RBHGgÁfa evotNam

)anRbúgeRbóbxøÜnbegáItrdæaPi)alEkøgkøaymYyrbs;km<úCaenApÞal;nwgkEnøg EdltamBitsßitenAeRkam

GMNacRbeTsevotNamTaMgRsug.

enAeBlEdlsemþc sIhnu rkeXIjGaf’kM)aMgrbs;EdlehAfa «karrYmKMnit»rvagBYkevotNam

nigkm<úCa b:ul Bt nigbNþamitþrbs;Kat;EdledIrtamlMGanrbs;semþctaMgBIRBHraCaNacRkmanEt

Rsemal )ankt;smÁal;fa RbCaRbiyPaBrbs;mhakSRtEdlFøak;BItMENgenAs¥atbrisuT§KµanRsk

RsuteLIy. fVIebImankgT½BraykarBarCuMvijRBHGgÁkñúgeBlEdlRBHGgÁCYbR)aRs½yTak;Tgd¾kRm

manCamYyRbCara®sþk¾eday k¾PkþIPaB nigkarrMePIbcitþEdlGñkTaMgenaHbgðaj[eXIj KWBitCaminGac

bdiesF)an. semþc sIhnu esÞIrEtminTan;bBa©b;TsSnkic©RsYlbYlpg Rkúmb:ulBt)anepþImyuT§nakar

niyaybgáac;sMGuymYyRbqaMgnwgRBHGgÁPøam ehIybegáInkic©xitxMRbwgERbgkan;EtxøaMgeLIgEfmeTot

edIm,Ikm©at;\T§iBlrbs;evotNam. BYkkmµaPi)alExµrRkhmEdlFøab;cUlrYmeFVIskmµPaBneya)ay

kñúgcMeNammhaCn kñúgzan³CaGñknaMBaküsIhnuniymtaMgBIyUrmkehIy )ancab;epþImElglak;elom

TwkcitþBitR)akdrbs;xøÜn ehIyniyaybriharsemþckñúgkarRbCuMCasaFarN³epSg². enAqñaM1973

®sþIGñkePosxøÜnmñak;)anerobrab;fa «kalmunExµrRkhm manbMNgcg;B¤eyIgniyaydEdl²fa «eyIg

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 79

Page 90: Brother enemy

RtÚvkarsemþc sIhnu» b:uEnþbc©úb,nñElgmaneTotehIy. «kalmunGñkGacniyayGVI²BIsemþc sIhnu

tamEtcitþGñkcg; b:uEnþenAeBlenH eKEfmTaMghammin[taMgRBHqayalkçN_rbs;RBHGgÁEfmeTot».

nag)anR)ab;[dwgeTotfa KµanGñkNamñak;h‘ansaksYrBIbBaðaGVIeLIy BIeRBaHRbkarenHmann½yfa

esckþIsøab; 36. BYkeK)anRbúgeRbóbrYcCaeRscnUvéf¶EdlbkSTTYlbnÞúkkan;kab;RbeTskñúgéd KW

BuMEmnsemþc sIhnu eT. enAedImrdUvekþAqñaM1973 kmµsiT§idIFøIÉkCn nigkareRbIR)as;RkdasR)ak;

RtÚv)anlubbM)at;ecaledIm,IBRgwgkarRKb;RKgEdndInigesdækic©rbs;bkS. shkrN_plitkmµCaeRcIn

RtÚv)anbegáIteLIg. cMENkBYkGñkCMnYj nigGñkensaTsBa¢atievotNamRtÚveKbeNþjecjBIRbeTs.

evotNamEdlseRmccitþsßitenAkñúgRbeTsRtÚv)anRbmUlpþúM[rs;enAkñúgshkrN_nanaEdltambnÞÚl

GHGagrbs;semþc sIhnu fa ³ «shkrN_TaMgenaH )anERbkøayeTACaCMrMRbmUlpþúMy:agqab;rh½s».

enAcugqñaM1973 erOgdMNalepSg²sþIBIkarRbQmmuxedayGavuFrvagExµrrMedaH nigBYkExµr

Rkhm)anepþImelcB¤sussay. dUecñH vaTMngfa kar)aj;kaMePøIgtKña)anekItmanenAextþkNþalkñúg

Exvicäika qñaM1973 bnÞab;BIkarbdiesFrbs;ExµrrMedaHEdlminRbtibtþitamkarbgÁab;bBa¢adac;xatrbs;

ExµrRkhmEdl[bBaÄb;shRbtibtþikarTaMgGs;CamYyevotkug nigevotNamxageCIg. elak exn

XVIn m®nþIbMeBjmuxgarenAsßankugsu‘lGaemrikaMgRbcaMTIRkúgkgfW )anvayTUrelxeTARkúgv:asuInetan

enAéf¶TI24 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1974fa «ExµrrMedaHEdlKaMRTedayT½Bevotkug-evotNamxageCIgmYykg

ÉkPaB)ansmøab;ExµrRkhm42nak; nigbgçM[GñkÉeTotrt;dkfyGs;. taMgBIeBlenaHmkExµrRkhm

nigExµrrMedaH)ancab;epþImlYcvayqµk;kñúgTwkdIerogxøÜnrbs;BYkeKeTAvijeTAmk»37.

enAqñaM1974 edayeFVI[mansßirPaBkñúgkardak;[GnuvtþviFankarEpñkesdækic©dac;xat smUh

PavUbnIykmµEpñkksikmµ nigkarlubbM)at;EpñkBaNiC¢kmµ-ExµrRkhm)ancab;epþImeFVIkarkm©at;bkçBYk

RbqaMgCaelIkdMbUgrbs;xÜøn eTaHCaminEmn b¤RKan;EtsgS½yk¾eday. enAExsIha qñaMdEdl enAPaK

xagekItkm<úCa kmµaPi)alcMnYncitsibmYynak;EdlbNþúHbNþaledayRkúghaNUy )anRtÚvehAmk

RbCuMeFVI«kareronsURt»mYy Edlkñúg»kasenaHeK)ansþIbenÞasBYkenaHy:agxøaMg eRBaHEteKcxøÜneTA

rs;enARbeTsevotNam. kñúgcMeNamenaH mandb;nak;RtÚv)at;xøÜn. GñkdéTeTotRtÚvbBa¢Ún[eTAeFVI

ERseRkamkartamXøaMemIlCab;. RbEhlmanEtmñak;Kt;EdlrYcputeRKaHfñak;dl;CIvitKW Ehm samin

eday)anseRmccitþrt;ePosxøÜneTAdl;RbeTsevotNamvij. enAPUmiPaKnirtIkñúgcMeNamkmµaPi)al

mYyrynak; EdleTIbRtLb;mkBIevotNam KWmankmµaPi)alcMnYnekAsibnak;eTAehIy EdlRtÚvsmøab;

enAExkBaØa qñaM197438. kñúgcMeNamGñkEdlrt;rYcBIesckþIsøab;manenAEtmñak;EdrKW ys; e):a.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg80

Page 91: Brother enemy

eRkaymk samin nig e):a )ankøayCaemdwknaMrNsirS EdlKaMRTedayRkúghaNUynigdwknaMclnaenH

RbqaMg b:ul Bt vij.

kic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIs enAqñaM1973 k¾kMNt;pgEdrnUvkarcab;epþImeFVIkarvayRbharrbs;

ExµrRkhmRbqaMgnwgkEnøgsþúkGavuF mnÞIreBTü nigCMrMe)aHT½Bnanarbs;evotNamenAelITwkdIkm<úCa Edl

Rkúm b:ul Bt RbwgERbgbgðaj[eXIjP½sþútagedayecaTRbkan;BIkarminyl;nigPaBKµanvin½yrbs;Gñk

RbtibtþiCakUnTahansamBaØKµanzannþrs½kþi. GñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manBIrnak;énTIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam

)anRtÚvsmøab;«edaykarP½nþRcLM» enAeBlEdlBYkeKeTAelgextþkMBg;camkñúgExtula. enAExkumÖ³

qñaM1975 Rkúmsil,³mYyTaMgmUlénrNsirSrMedaHCatiEdlmkBI mI f (My Tho) )anRtÚvsmøab;rgÁal

kñúgkarBYnsÞak;mYyeBlkMBugqøgkat;TwkdIkm<úCa enAeBlEdlRkúmenH eFVIdMeNIreTAkan;tMbn;rMedaH

TaMgLayrbs;extþtaynijvij. edayeqøIytbeTAnwgkaresñI[mankarBnül;bBaðaenHBIsMNak;BYk

emdwknaMevotkug km<úCa)anGHGagfa ]bTÞvehtuKYr[esaksþayenH KWCaGMeBIrbs;RkúmCnEdleK

minGacRtÜtRta)an. tam Rtan; faj;s‘n; GnuRbFanTIPñak;garB½t’manevotNamfa enAqñaM1973

y:agehacKµanGñkTTYlxusRtÚvNamñak;Edlmanzan³esµIKat;eCOfa karsmøab;rgÁalRbCaCnevotNam

TaMgenHCakarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaeLIy. Kat;niyayfa «eyIgcat;TukerOgTaMgenH

CakarxUcxatmYyEdlminGacecosputenAeBlmans®gÁam». k¾b:uEnþvaBi)akTTYlRsbEdrfa kariya-

l½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamBuM)anTTYlB½t’manBitR)akdBIerOgenHeT. b:uEnþ RkúghaNUy

eFVIhak;dUcCaRBmTTYlnUvkarBnül;rbs;ExµrRkhmenH eRBaHmincg;eFVI[manCemøaHCamYy b:ul Bt

kñúgeBlEdlTICRmkTaMgLaykñúgTwkdIkm<úCaenAEtcaM)ac;sRmab;xøÜnenAeLIy. mü:ageTot evotNam

eCOfa TIbMput «maK’ad¾RtwmRtÚv»mYymuxCapuseLIgenAkm<úCaRbqaMgnwglT§iCatiniymceg¥ótcg¥l;rbs;

b:ul Bt minxan. Parkic©sMxan;rbs;RkúghaNUy KWrMedaHPaKxagt,ÚgedayminCMruj[karvivaT

EdlxøÜnkMBugRbQmmuxnwgsm<½n§mitþmancitþmineTogeLIgdl;kRmitx<s;mYyeLIy. dUecñHebITukCaman

PaBtantwgEdlkan;EtrIkFMeLIg²rvagRbeTsTaMgBIrk¾eday k¾evotNamenAEtbnþ«eKarBkarRBm

eRBógKña»teTAeTotEdr. edayeqøIytbeTAnwgsMeNImYyrbs;ExµrRkhm evotNam)anseRmcbBa¢Ún

kgÉkPaB visVkmµ nigkgkaMePøIgFMCaeRcIneTAkan;km<úCaedIm,ICYyRc)ac;-k RkúgPñMeBj[søab;enATwk

pþac;RB½Rt.

b:ul Bt pÞal;k¾RbwgERbgEfTaM«lkçN³manEtsMbkeRkA» [enAdEdlEdr. enAéf¶TI3 Extula

qñaM1974 kñúglixitEføgGMNrKuNmYycMeBaHbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam Kat;)ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa «C½y

dgáÚvnag nigkNþúr 81

Page 92: Brother enemy

CmñHTaMgLayEdlkgT½BevotNamdeNþIm)anKWCasñaédénsamKÁIPaB nigkarCYy]btßmÖKñaeTAvijeTA

mkrvagbkS nigRbCaCnénRbeTseyIgTaMgBIr». smþITaMgGs;enHRtÚv)anGHGagbnÞab;BIkarbeNþj

CnCatievotNamrab;Ban;nak;ecjBIkm<úCa bnÞab;BIkarsmøab;BYkkmµaPi)alEdlbNþúHbNþalenARkúg

haNUy nigbnÞab;BIkarvayRbharmUldæanT½Bnanarbs;evotNam kñúgTwkdIkm<úCarYcmk. kñúgEpñkénkar

eqøIyqøgKñatamsMbuRtEdlsresredayeRbIsBaØasm¶at;enH eKGacTajehtuCasMGagCaBisskar

snüay:ag»Larikrbs; b:ul Bt cMeBaH eL DwkfU nUvXøafa «edaykareKarBy:agesµaHs½µRKnigGs;BI

dYgcitþ»EdlKat;enAEteKarBedayx¢ab;x¢ÜncMeBaHmaKa’ «samKÁIPaBd¾CitsñiT§ nigmitþPaBCabgb¥Ún nig

bdivtþrvagRbeTskm<úCanigevotNam»Canic©39. TaMgsßirPaBEpñkkmøaMgkñúgépÞbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa

TaMgsßankarN_CatinigGnþrCatienABuMTan;eFVI[mankarRbQmmuxmYyedaypÞal;CamYyevotNamenA

eLIyeT. eKetagEtrg;caMbIqñaMEfmeTot.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg82

Page 93: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI3mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH

RBwtþikarN_mYyEdlhak;dUcCarnÞH)aj;kNþaléf¶Ecs)anmkdl; eGog sarI ]bnaykrdæm®nþI

km<úCaRbCaFibetyü enAéf¶TI13 Extula qñaM976. kñúgdMeNIrRtLb;BIRkúgjÚvy:kmkvij bnÞab;BIkar

ehaHehIrmYyEdleFVI[Gs;kmøaMg eGog sarI EdleTIbmkdl;nievsndæanrbs;Kat;enATIRkúgEbl®háad

(Belgrade) esÞIrEtminTan;RsYlbYlpg Rsab;Etelak Duysan háas):arI RbFannaykdæanGasuIénTIsþI

karRksYgkarbreTsyUehÁasøavI EdlCaGñkTak;TgsMxan;bMputrbs;Kat;enATIRkúgEbl®hÁad )anedIrcUl

mkkñúgbnÞb;TTYlePJóvedaybeBa©jTwkmuxKYr[xøac. háas):arI )anR)ab;dMNwgfa «Ék]tþm¡ ´)anTTYl

karENnaM[pþl;B½t’manR)ab;elakGMBIkarvivtþénsßankarN_cugeRkayenHenARbeTscin. rdæm®nþIkar

breTscineTIbnwgGHGagBIkarcab;xøÜnelakRsIcag Qij/ hSagCunCIv/ y:avviunyn; nig v:aghugevn BI

bTeFVIskmµPaBRbqaMgbkSnigrdæ». eRkaymk háas):arI )anerobrab;fa eBlenaHQam)anRcal

RkhmeBjépÞmuxEdlRsLaMgkaMgrbs; sarI mYyrMeBc ³ «eT¡ vaBuMGaceTACadUecñHeT GñkTaMgenaHsuT§Et

CasmasPaBd¾l¥. sarI eBalrGU‘tic²edaysMeLgmYyEdleKsþab;swgEtminB¤»1.

taMgBIsrTrdUvqñaM1971 CakalbriecäTEdlKat;sßitenARkúgeb:kaMgkñúgzan³CatMNagbkSkumµúy

nIsþkm<úCaGmbkSkumµúynIsþcin sarI )ancgmitþPaBCamYyBYkr:aDIkal;CaeRcInnak;. BYkyuvCn nigGñk

EdlrIkrayxøaMg)ankøayeTACamnusSsMxan;enAsm½ybdivtþn_vb,Fm’d¾RcbUkRcbl;kñúgeBlEdl em:A

CMruj[BYkqµaMRkhm«bM)ak;muxBYkvrCn»rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþcin nige)assm¥atKuNvibtþiepSg²énlT§i

esIerIniym. CaBiess y:av vuinyn; EdlCamitþd¾CitsñiT§bMputrbs; sarI. y:av CaGñkTietonxagGkSr

sa®sþénRkúgs‘agéhEdleKminsUvsÁal; )ankøayeTACasmaCikkariyal½yneya)ay enAqñaM1964.

Kat;manKMnitmincUlcitþ ¬s¥b;edaymindwgerOgGVI¦ cMeBaH semþc sIhnu dUcemdwknaMExµrRkhmEdr eday

BYkenHcat;TuksemþcCamnusS«RbtikiriyataMgBIeCIgrhUtdl;k,al»2. cMeBaH sarI mitþPaBenHman

sarsMxan;EmnETn BIeRBaHedayBit y:av manmuxnaTI dwknaMKN³kmµaFikarkic©karbreTsénKN³

mCÄimbkSkumµúynIsþcin. BYkemdwknaMExµrRkhmdwgfa TisedAeqVgRCúlrbs;xøÜnRtÚv)anFanaGHGag

edaykarKaMRTrbs;cin lÁwkNa y:av nigbkSBYkEdlmanKMnitdUcKña nwgenAEtsßitkñúgmuxtMENg.

GaRs½yehtuenH eTIbeRkayBIenaHbnþic sarI etagEtesuIb[dwgBIerOgcab;xøÜnbNþamitþPkþid¾

CitsñiT§ nigyuT§ikCnrbs;Kat;EdlekIteLIgBIréf¶eRkaykarecjdMeNIrrbs;Kat;BIRkúgeb:kaMgeTARkúg

83

Page 94: Brother enemy

jÚvy:k CaTIEdlKat;RtÚvEføgkarN_kñúg»kasmhasnñi)atRbcaMqñaMrbs;GgÁkarshRbCaCati. kñúg

raRtIéf¶TI6 Extula qñaM1976 KWbIs)aþh_eRkaymrNPaBrbs;RbFan em:A kgÉkPaBeyaFaBiess

elx2341 EdldwknaMedayGtItGgÁrkSrbs; em:A KW v:agdugsuIg )aneFVIkarsRmúkcUlrh½sdUc

epøkbenÞaredIm,Icab;xøÜnRbBn§emm:ayrbs; em:A nig GñkCitsñiT§TaMgbIrbs;Kat;. eQµaHrbs;GñkTaMgenH

)anRtÚvdak;bBa©ÚledaybRgÜmEtmYykñúgsnÞanuRkmneya)ayrbs;cineRkamkarehAfa «bn4nak;».

naykrdæm®nþIsþITI hVa KUehVg nigrdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTsesnaRbmux ey CanyIgEdlsuT§EtCaeCIgcas;

énbdivtþn_ )anerobcMRbtibtþikarmYyCamYy v:ag nigRtÜtBinitüedayxøÜnKat;pÞal; y:agehackarcat;

karrbs;Kat;eTAelIkarpþac;crnþGKÁisnIsRmab;sßanIy_TUrTsSn_Edr.

b:uEnþTaMgkñúg»kasénkarQb;sMctbIéf¶enATIRkúgeb:kaMg TaMgkñúgkarCYbBiPakSaenAGgÁkarsh

RbCaCatiCamYysmPaKIrbs;Kat;KW Cav hánhVa sarI BuMmankarsgS½ybnþicesaHeLIy nUvkarXubXit

k,t;enAeb:kaMg. BIréf¶munKat;cakecjBIRkúgjÚvy:keTAkan;TIRkúgEbl®háad Kat;RtÚv)anGeBa¢IjCa

ePJóvkitþiyscUlrYmBiFICb;elogmYyEdlerobcMeLIgeday Cav b:uEnþfVId,itEt Cav manTMnak;TMngd¾

CitsñiT§CamYyBYkr:aDIkal;k¾eday k¾Kat;KµaneRbIBakübBaäitbeBaäógBIerOgenaHEdr. PøamenaHdIenAeRkam

eCIg sarI hak;dUcCaRsutcuH.

enAkñúg»kasénkarsñak;GaRs½ycugeRkayrbs;Kat;enARbeTscin sarI BitCadwgtamry³

cagQIg fa BYkr:aDIkal;ElgmanP½BVsMNageTotehIy fVIebIBYkeKCamnusSCitsñiT§bMputnwg em:A Edl

eBlenaHCitsøab;eTAehIyk¾eday. bnÞab;BImrNPaBrbs;elaknaykrdæm®nþI CU eGnLay enAEx

mkra qñaM1976 BYkeK)anRbwgERbgEsVgrkkarKaMRTBI em:A edIm,Ikm©at;kareLIgsñgtMENgrbs;

mnusSEdl CU KaMBarKWGñkRbtibtþiniym etg s‘avBIg. b:uEnþ R)akdNas; elakRbFan em:A mincg;[

cagQij nigRkúmrbs;nageLIgmkCMnYseLIy. KWehtuenHehIy)anCaKat;eRCIserIsm®nþIbkSmñak;

eQµaH hVa KUehVg EdleKsÁal;c,as;BIsmancitþeqVgniymrbs;Kat;[eFVICanaykrdæm®nþIsþITICaCagyk

hSag CunCav EdlCaGñkRTwsþIeqñImCageKrbs;BYkr:aDIkal;. rhUtmkdl;eBlenH hVa manmuxtMENg

Cardæm®nþIsnþisuxsaFarN³3. bnÞab;BImrNPaBrbs; em:A Kat;)aneLIgzan³BIrRkWteTot ehIy)an

køayeTACaRbFanbkS. ExµrRkhm nig b:ul Bt CaBiess eGog sarI )antamBinitüemIldMeNIr

mantKñahUrEhénRBwtþikarN_TaMgLayenARbeTscinTaMgcitþRBÜy)armÖedayxøacERkgBYkenHmanTMenar

eTArkBYksþaMniym. munnwgcakecjBIPñMeBjeTAkan;RkúgjÚvy:kenAéf¶TI30 ExkBaØa sarI )anCYyRBag

eFVIlixitGbGrsaTrmYyepJICUnnaykrdæm®nþIsþITI hVa KUehVg kñúg»kasbuNüCatirbs;cinEdr. GVIEdl

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg84

Page 95: Brother enemy

manlkçN³sMxan;bMputKW sarlixitenH)anEføgsresIrbdivtþvb,Fm’nigrebobEdlbkSkumµúynIsþcin

seRmc)aneCaKC½ykñúgkarkemÞc «esnaFikarRbqaMgsgÁmniym nigRbqaMgbdivtþrbs; lIv cavCI nig

etg s‘avBIg». tamkarGHGagrebobminc,as;fa bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCanwgsVaKmn_ hVa edayeBjcitþ

kñúgkrNIEdlKat;edIrtambnÞat;neya)ayrbs;RkúmbdivtþeqVgniym.

k¾b:uEnþvac,as;Nas;fa rdæRbharenARkúgeb:kaMgEdleFVI)anseRmcedayKµanbgðÚrQam)an

bNþal[mankarKitsµanTukCamunnUvkarbþÚrTismYyeTArksþaMniymvij ehIyRbEhlCamankarvil

RtLb;mkvijrbs; etg pgEdr EdlFøab;rgeRKaHBIkare)assm¥atcMnYnBIrdgrYcmkehIy. \riyabf

cEmøkxusBIFmµtarbs; sarI kñúgGMLúgCaeRcIns)þah_bnþbnÞab;mkeTot )anbgðaj[eXIjR)akdNas;

nUvkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;Kat;cMeBaHmuxkarrIkraldalénsßankarN_enARbeTscin. tamTIPñak;garB½t’man

rbs; rUm:anI nigcin)an[dwgfa eRkayBIkarQb;sMcty:agxøIenARbeTsrUm:anI nigyUehÁasøavI emdwknaM

ExµrRkhm)ancakecjBITIRkúgbu‘ykaer:s ¬rdæFanIRbeTsrUm:anI¦ enAéf¶TI16 Extula qñaM1976.

tmkeTot Rsab;Et)at;muxElgeXIj Tal;Et25éf¶eRkaymkeTot eTIbelcmuxKat;CafµIenARkúg

PñMeBj. tamFmµta Kat;RtÚvCiHynþehaHmYyeRKÓgrbs;Rkúmh‘un Tarom rbs;rUm:anI eq<aHmkRkúgeb:kaMg

sinCakEnøgEdlKat;RtÚvrg;caMeCIgynþehaHrbs;cin Edlr:ab;rgkarehaHehIrmkRkúgPñMeBj2eCIgkñúg

mYyEx. RKb;karQb;sMctenARbeTscin sarI EtgEtRtÚv)anTTYlenAGakasyandæanedayGnurdæm®nþI

karbreTsmñak;tamTmøab;dUcsBVdgCanic©. RbsinebIkarqøgkat;manry³eBlelIsBImYyéf¶ mansma

Cikkariyal½yneya)aymñak;CaGñkerobcMBiFICb;elogCakitþiysCUnKat;. karsEmþgnUvPaBrak;

Tak;TaMgenH suT§EtRtÚv)anRbkaspSayCasaFarN³ edayTIPñak;garB½t’mancinfµI. EtfaelIkenH TaMg

sarB½t’mancin TaMgsarB½t’mankm<úCa BuMmanelIkykmkniyayBITIkEnøgEdl sarI sßitenAeLIytaMgBI

karecjdMeNIrrbs;Kat;BITIRkúgb‘uykaer:s mk. enATIbMputviTüúRkúgPñMeBj)anRbkaspSayenA

éf¶TI12 Exvicäika qñaM1976fa Kat;eTIbnwg)anTTYlsartaMgBIÉkGKÁrdæTUtbreTsbInak;. esckþI

bBa¢ak;EdleFVIeLIgCapøÚvkarkñúgkarEtgtaMgrdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTs sun esn [eFVICardæm®nþIkarbreTssþI

TIrhUtdl;éf¶TI8 Exvicäika enaH sbBa¢ak;[eXIjfa sarI BuM)ancUlkan;tMENgrbs;Kat;vijeTmunkal

briecäTenH4.

etIKat;enAÉNa? CasMNYrEdl´sYrPriya eGog sarI KW eGog FIriT§ CaeRcInqñaMeRkaymk

eTot. yuvCnTaMgBIrnak;enH)anCYbKñaenAeBlEdlBYkeKsikSaenATIRkúg):arIs. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH

b:ul Bt )ancab;citþRsLaj;bgRsIrbs; FIriT§ KW exov bu:NÑarI EdlCanisSitenA):arIsEdr. minyUr

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 85

Page 96: Brother enemy

b:unµan bgb¥ÚnRsITaMgBIrRBmTaMgsVamIrbs;BYkeK)ankøayeTACaKUsVamIPriyad¾manGMNacbMput rbs;

RbeTsdUcEdl semþc sIhnu )anmanbnÞÚlfa «bn4nak;énkm<úCa»Edr. cemøIyd¾esaHkeRkaHrbs;

FIriT§ cMeBaHsMNYrrbs;´ mansPaBhak;dUcCanagKµandwgGVIbnþicesaH. nagniyayfa «elakeXIj

ehIyfa BYkeyIgmñak;²rs;enAedayELkBIKña». B½t’manTaMgGs;EdleyIgmanbBa¢ak;[eXIjfa sarI

)ansñak;enARbeTsciny:agehacNas;k¾bIs)aþh_Edr. karenAes¶óms¶at;rbs;sarB½t’mancin Gac

RtwmEtbkRsayfa enHCakarsñak;GaRs½ytaMgBIedImmkrbs;Kat;. eBjry³eBlenaH emdwknaMExµr

RkhmrUbenHTMngCap©itp©g;vaytémøsßankarN_ bnÞab;BImankarPan;ERbEpñkneya)ayEdleTIbnwgeFVI[

regÁaHregÁIRbeTscin nigcaMTTYlBIBYkemdwknaMfµIrbs;cinnUvkarFanaGHGagfa mrNPaBrbs; em:A nigkar

e)assm¥atBYkr:aDIkal; nwgmineFVI[karKaMRTrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgcMeBaHkm<úCaecaTCabBaðaeLIgvijeLIy.

karRBÜy)armÖrbs; sarI EdlsMGagelIehtuplmenaKmviC¢aKWBitCaRtwmRtÚvtamehtupl.

kñúgGMLúgry³eBl-RbEhldb;qñaM-Edlkt;smÁal;edaybdivtþn_vb,Fm’ kartsU‘edayGavuFenAkm<úCa

nigkarpusecjExµrRkhmenaH KWEpñkmenaKmviC¢amanPaBRbesIrelIseKTaMgGs;. etIRbeTskm<úCa

GacsgÇwmelIkarKaMRTrbs;RbeTscinmYy EdlGMNwHteTAkMBuglem¥ógeTAsþaMtaMgBImankarTat;ecal

édKUEpñkmenaKmviC¢arbs; sarI EdreT?. BYkemdwknaMExµrRkhmRtÚvEtbgðaj[eXIjedayqab;rh½s

fa cMeBaHerOgenH ³ plRbeyaCn_Cati)anTTYlrgplGaRkk;bnþicbnþÜcBIEpñkmenaKmviC¢a ehIyfa

bMNgRbqaMgrbs;cincMeBaHectnaepSg²rbs;evotNamnigkarerobcMTb;Tl;nwgBYksUevotmanTm¶n;

mYyy:agsem,ImCagxdak;lkçxNÐepSg²rbs;emdwknaMcinfµImkelIkm<úCarbs; b:ul Bt eTAeTot. mun

mYyqñaM mitþPaBcin-km<úCanwgRtÚvbBa¢ak;GHGagCafµI ehIyenATIbMput b:ul Bt EdlecjBIPaBGnamik

nwgerobcMCMhandMbUgelIqakGnþrCatirbs;Kat;enATIRkúgeb:kaMg.

karRBÜy)armÖenARkúgPñMeBj

kñúgdMeNIrRtLb;mkvijrbs;Kat; bNþashkarIrbs; sarI Edldk;Cab;edaykþIkgVl;)anRbjab;

Rbjal;epJIsarlixitGbGrsaTrmYycMeBaH hVa kñúg»kasénkarEtgtaMgrUbKat;CaRbFanbkSkumµúy

nIsþcin. PaKeRcInénbNþabkSCabgb¥ÚnenATUTaMgBiPBelakcUlcitþecosvagminbgðaj[eXIjesckþI

lem¥ógrbs;xøÜnkñúgCemøaHépÞkñúgrbs;cineT. BYkeK)anEføgsresIr hVa edayminelIkniyayBIBYk

r:aDIkal;EdlRtÚvdkhUtGMNaceLIy. b:uEnþ sRmab;bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCavij GVIEdlkm<úCaRtÚvkarkar

KaMRTrbs;cin KWBitCamansarsMxan;esµIGayuCIvitkñúgry³eBlEdlGñkTaMgenH beNþay[karsgS½y

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg86

Page 97: Brother enemy

tictYcRKbdNþb;elIPkþIPaBrbs;eKcMeBaHBYkemdwknaMRkúgeb:kaMg. GaRs½yehtuenH sarlixitrbs;

emdwknaMkm<úCaBuMrYjranwgelIksresIry:agkk;ekþAcMeBaHRbFanbkScin Edl)anseRmceCaKC½y

kñúgkar«kemÞcRkúmRbqaMgbkS nigRbqaMgbdivtþn_énbn4nak;»eLIy. enHCakarbþÚrKMnitPøam²d¾KYr[

cEmøkedayehtufa munenHmindl;mYyExpg sarlixitdMbUgmYyrbs;RkúgPñMeBj )anGHGagnUvkarKaMRT

rbs;xøÜncMeBaH«BYkmnusSTaMgenaH» EdlcinsnµtfaCaGñkRbqaMgbdivtþn_>>>.

edayRbwgERbgeFVI[Rkúgeb:kaMgkk;ekþAkñúgcitþGMBIkarpþac;sm<n§PaBCasßaBrrbs;BYkemdwknaM

km<úCaCamYy«bn4nak;»rYcehIy b:ul Bt yl;eXIjy:agc,as;cMeBaHdMNwgcugeRkayepSg² Edl

manRbPBmkBIRbeTscinfa RbkbedayeRKaHfñak;xøaMgNas; enAeBlEdleFVIkarpSBVpSaykñúgRbeTs

eTaHCaKYrdl;kalk¾eday. KµanbBaðaRBman[dwgBIKMnitminsmehtuplTaMgLaycMeBaHGñkenAkñúgbkS

Edlvaytémøfa b:ul Bt nig eGog sarI eFVIGVI²RCúlhYskñúgRbB½n§neya)aymUlvivdþniym (Radicalisme)

eLIy. sarlixitEdlepJICUn hVa KUehVg BuMRtÚv)anpSBVpSaytamviTüú PñMeBjEdlCaRbPBpþl;B½t’man

EtmYyKt;sRmab;RbCaCnkm<úCaEdlrs;enAray):aytamCMrMRbmUlpþúMeFVIkargarnananigenAdac;q¶ayKña

BImYyeTAmYypgeT. ticCagmYys)aþh_munkarmkdl;rbs;KN³RbtiPUkaEstcinmYyRkúm eTIbviTüú

PñMeBj)anpSayenAéf¶TI2 ExFñÚ qñaM1976 [Gñksþab;rbs;xøÜndwgBIkarEtgtaMg hVa kñúgmuxtMENg

nigkarcab;xøÜn«bn4nak;». dMNwgRtÚv)anpSay edayKµaneFVIkarbBa¢ak;GMBIGtþsBaØaNénbNþa

smaCikrbs;«bn»enHbnþicesaHeLIy TaMgminniyay[dwgBIRbePTénbT]Rkidærbs;GñkTaMgenaHpg.

edayKab;CYn KN³RbtiPUesdækic©nigBaNiC¢kmµmYyrbs;km<úCa)ansñak;GaRs½yenARbeTs

cinEdr kñúgeBlEdlmankarruHerIfñak;dwknaMrbs;cind¾KYr[cg;dwgenH. KN³RbtiPUkm<úCa)anTTYlBIm©as;

pÞHnUvkarGHGagfa «Rkúgeb:kaMgnwgenAEtCamitþd¾Tukcitþmñak;rbs;rdæaPi)al nigRbCaCnkm<úCaRbCaFib

etyüCanic©kal»5. k¾b:uEnþ lT§plGviC¢manEdleKminGacRbmaNdwgmunkñúgkar«bt;eTAsþaM» Edl

cab;epþImedayRbeTscinmkelIkRmiténCMnYyrbs;xøÜnmk[km<úCa ehIyelIsBIenHeTot mkelIpøÚvcitþ

rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa )aneFVI[ b:ul Bt RBÜy)armÖy:agCak;c,as;. GMNwHteTAenARKb;kal³eTs³

km<úCaEtgEteRkInrMB£k[RbeTscindwgfa smiT§plrbs;bdivtþn_vb,Fm’niyaymü:ageTotKWviFankar

eqVgRCúlhYsehtuTaMgb:unµan EdlcinRbkan;ykenAcenøaHqñaM1966 nig1971 RtÚvEtkarBar[)an

nigBRgIkEfmeTot ehIyfa kartsU‘vNѳ)anbgábegáItCa«kgRcvak;mYy EdlnaMeTArklT§plcug

eRkay»kñúgkarksagRbeTspgEdr. enAéf¶TI10 ExFñÚ qñaM1976 kñúg»kasCb;elogmYyCakitþiys

dl;KN³RbtiPUénTIPñak;garB½t’mancinfµIenARkúgPñMeBj h‘U nwm rdæm®nþIRksYgB½t’man)anEføgsresIr

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 87

Page 98: Brother enemy

cMeBaHkarbMpøaj[sabsUnünUv«bn4nak;» b:uEnþKat;)anniyayTukCamunfa RbCaCncin«nwgminbeNþay

[lT§iesIrIniym b¤vNѳmUlFnniymegIbk,aleLIgvij)aneLIy». enHCaRbeyaKsEmþg[eXIj

EfmeTotnUvkarRBÜy)armÖmYyCagkareCOCak;BitR)akdmYy.

karraErkrbs;cin

tamkarBit etIKN³dwknaMcinyl;eXIjBIExµrRkhmy:agdUcemþcxøH?. ebIvinicä½yerOgenH tam

ry³esckþIEføgkarN_epSg²rbs;KN³RbtiPUcinEdlmkeFVITsSnkic©CapøÚvkarenARkúgPñMeBj kñúgExFñÚ

KWkarKaMRTrbs;cinmanlkçN³eBjeljelIkElgEtkares¶IcsresIredayeFVImindwgy:agKYrsmnUv

karniyaybBaäitbeBaäógrbs;km<úCacMeBaHkarbnþCacaM)ac;nUvkartsU‘vNѳenARbeTscin. mü:ageTot

KN³RbtiPUcink¾BuM)anGHGagnUvkarKaMRTrbs;xøÜncMeBaH «kartsU‘rbs;km<úCa edIm,IkarBarÉkraCü nig

bUrNPaBTwkdIrbs;xøÜn»Edr ebIniyaytamrebobminsUveGonxµasKWcinminKaMRT «kartsU‘rbs;km<úCa

RbqaMgnwgevotNam»eLIy. karraErkcitþenH EdlCMruj[mankarCECkxusRtÚvmYyxagmenaKmviCa¢

nigpþl;nUvkarKaMRTmYy eTaHCalYclak;k¾eday k¾mYycMENkRbEhlGac[eKkat;yl;faenHCakar

TUnµanmYykuM[eRCótERCkneya)ayépÞkñúgrbs;cinEdr. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday enAeBlRtLb;mkBI

RbeTskm<úCavij rdæm®nþIRksYgTMnak;TMngesdækic©CamYybreTsrbs;cineQµaH hVagyI )anniyay

R)ab;ÉkGKÁrdæTUtrUm:anIRbcaMRkúgeb:kaMgnUvkarminGbGrrbs;Kat;Casm¶at;fa «BYkeK¬ExµrRkhm¦)an

RbRBwtþRCúlhYsehtukñúgkarEsVgrkkar]btßmÖxøÜnedayxøÜnÉg¬ÉkraCüm©as;kar¦». enACMnan;CamYyKña

enaH edayniyayeTAkan;bNþaGñkkarTUtbs©imRbeTs ÉkGKÁrdæTUtcinRbcaMhaNUyBuM)anlak;elom

nUvkarPJak;ep¥Ilrbs;Kat;cMeBaHkarRbwgERbgy:agxøaMgrbs;ExµrRkhmBImun edIm,IEsVgrkrebobrbb

esdækic©mYy Edlcg;rs;enAedayePaKplrbs;xøÜnÉgeLIy. Kat;)anR)ab;ÉkGKÁrdæTUtGWr:ubmñak;[

dwgfa km<úCa)anRcanecalCMnYyes,ógGahar -témøesµInwg20landuløarGaemrik- Edlpþl;[eday

RbeTscinenAqñaM1976EfmeTot6.

karTietoneRkApøÚvkarTaMgenHrbs;BYkemdwknaMcin naniTaXrdUvqñaM1977 EdlEføgedIm,IbeRmI

eKalbMNgGgÁTUtnigsarB½t’manenaH )anqøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjy:agc,as;nUvkarERbRbÜld¾RCaleRCAEdl

ekItmanedayécdnüenARbeTscin taMgBImankarbeNþjBYkr:aDIkal;ecjBItMENgmk. enAqñaM1974

kñúgeBlEdlrasIrbs;BYkeqVgniymRCúlhYsehturbs;cinsßitenAkMBUlenAeLIyenaH manÉksarépÞkñúg

mYyrbs;bkS)anvaytémøBYkkumµúynIsþkm<úCafa CaGñkKaMRTKMnit em:A esTug d¾rwgmaMbMputenAbreTs.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg88

Page 99: Brother enemy

b:uEnþcab;taMgBIqñaM1975 karsmøab;rgÁalnigGMeBIsahaveXareXAEdlRbRBwtþedayExµrRkhm)an

køayeTACaerOgEdleKdwgB¤RKb;KñaTUTaMgsklelak edaysarcemøIyCasakSIrbs;GñkePosxøÜn

km<úCa. enAbs©imRbeTs tamkarvaytémøepSg²EdlecjBIRbPBrdæaPi)al )anGHGagBItYelxGñk

søab;enACMnan;enaHfa mancMnYnCagmYylannak;taMgBIkareLIgkan;GMNacrbs;ExµrRkhm. RbEhlenA

cugqñaM1976 vamankarlM)akbnþicsRmab;BYkemdwknaMcinkñúgkarbgðajmuxmat;ExµrRkhmCaGñkKaMBar

EpñkmenaKmviC¢arbs;xøÜn[ecjmuxenAbreTsNas; kñúgeBlEdlsarB½t’manrbs;cin)anbriharCa

erogral;éf¶ nUvkarrMelaPbMBaneRcInrab;minGs; EdlRbRBwtþeday«bnbYnnak;»kñúgkardwknaMb®gáab

y:agsahavrbs;xøÜnRbqaMgnwgRbCaCncinenaH. enAedImqñaM1977 niBn§naykkaEstkumµúynIsþcin

mYyenAhugkug)anniyayR)ab;´fa ³ «eyIgBuMGacTietonExµrRkhmCacMh)aneT BIeRBaHenH BuMEmn

Caneya)ayrbs;cinEdlRtÚveRCótERCkkic©karépÞkñúgrbs;bNþaRbeTsdéT. b:uEnþeyIgmankarcab;

GarmµN_fa BYkeK)anRbRBwtþRCúlhYsehtubnþic kñúgrebobGnuvtþsmPaBniymnigneya)ayÉkraCü

m©as;kar». KUsnÞnarbs;´)anTmøak;kMhus CaBiess cMeBaHkarseRmccitþrbs;ExµrRkhmEdllub

bM)at;R)ak;kas CMnYjtUctac nigkmµsiT§iÉkCn. Kat;min[témøEfmeTotcMeBaHkarbdiesFrbs;Exµr

Rkhm EdlminTTYlsÁal;GtßiPaBénbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa nigminedIrtamKMrUedIménmaK’a m:akSelnIn kñúg

kareFVIbdivtþsgÁmniymtamdMNak;kalnImYy². \sSrCnpøÚvkarmñak;eTotrbs;cin )ansarPaBR)ab;

´CaÉkCnBIkareTIsTal;rbs;cin EdlRtÚvbgçM[xøÜneFVIKeFVIføg;cMeBaHkarGgVrkrrbs;BYkGaNikCncin

Edlrt;eKcxøÜnBIRbeTskm<úCa edayesñIsuM[CYyeFVIGnþraKmn_edIm,IbBaÄb;karsmøab;rgÁalTaMgenaH

pg. Kat;)anbkRsayfa b:uEnþRbeTscinBuMGaceRCótERCkkic©karépÞkñúgrbs;km<úCa)aneLIy. eTaH

Cay:agNak¾eday dMeNIrhUrEhénRBwtþikarN_epSg²kñúgkarKaMRTrbs;cincMeBaHExµrRkhmTMngCabgðaj

[eXIjfa «neya)ayCak;Esþgniym» (La real-politik) manehtuplrbs;vaEdlminTTYlsÁal;TaMgkar

minyl;RsbxagpøÚvcitþTaMgkarminRtÚvKñaxagmenaKmviC¢a.

enAeBlEdl b:ul Bt erobcMRbvtþisa®sþCafµIeLIgvij

tamPaBdUcKñad¾cEmøkmYy enAeRkayéf¶énmrNPaBrbs; em:A nigkarcab;xøÜn«bn4nak;»kartsU‘

RbqaMgnwgBYkr:aDIkal;)anekIneLIgy:agxøaMgkñúgépÞbkSkumµúynIsþcin ninñakarlem¥ógmkkm<úCa KWxusEbøk

BImuny:agCak;c,as;. enAcugExsIha qñaM1976 KN³elxamCÄimbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaEdlRbmUlpþú¿

enACuMvij b:ul Bt )anCYbRbCuMKñaGs;ry³eBlbIéf¶. enAkñúgkmµviFIRbCuMKWsmUhPavUbnIykmµxag

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 89

Page 100: Brother enemy

ksikmµ nig]sSahkmµTaMgRsug nigkarbegáItpÞH)ayrYmkñúgTUTaMgRbeTs. sRmab; b:ul Bt yl;fa

RtÚvEtbegáInel,ÓnkñúgkarksaglT§ikumµúynIsþniym edIm,IttaMgnwgevotNamRbkbedayeCaKC½y

d¾RbesIr. TsSnavdþIsm¶at;bMputrbs;bkSeQµaH «Tg;bdivtþ» )anbkRsayedayKµamlak;elomenA

Exmifuna qñaM1976fa «eyIgcg;ksaglT§isgÁmniym[)anqab;rh½sbMput eyIgcg;eFVI[RbeTs

rbs;eyIgpøas;bþÚrsPaBRTg;RTay nigcg;[RbCaCneyIgkarBar)annUvPaBrugerOgrbs;xøÜneday

qab;rh½sbMput. Cabzm RbkarTaMgenHKWsRmab;raraMgsRtÚvmin[bMpøicbMpøajeyIg)an»7. pøÚveq<aH

eTArk«PaBfáúMefáIgrugerOg» KWRkaleTAedayQamnigTwkEPñkrbs;RbCaCnRbúsRsIrab;ryBan;nak; Edl

RtÚvbgçM[eFVIERsdUcstVFatuCamYynwgmðÚbGahard¾Gtþxat; nigesckþIsøab;cMeBaHGñkNaEdlh‘an

t¥ÚjEt¥r. rbbenHmanlkçN³twgruwg edayELkcMeBaH«RbCaCnfµI»CaGtItGñkTIRkúgEdlRtÚvvinicä½yfa

BukrlYyesµakeRKakedaymenaKmviC¢avNѳKhbtI. karlublagkMhusrbs;buKÁlmñak;² KWTNÐkmµeFVI

karhtßkmµmYyEdllM)akenOyht;y:agxøaMg. cMENkGñkTn;exSayEdleFVIkar)anplTabCagkar

kMNt;KWBYkeKElgmanplRbeyaCn_NamYysRmab;km<úCabdivtþeTotehIy dUcRbeyaKRbCaRbiy

mYyelIkeLIgfa «Tukk¾mincMeNjdkecjk¾minxat». sRmab;GñkTaMgLayEdlBYkeK[rs; b¤[søab;

KWBYkkmµaPi)alExµrRkhmeRbIEtRbeyaKenHb:ueNÑaHEdleFVI[mñak;²RBWq¥wgxñg.

mü:ageTot tamkarKn;KUrrbs; b:ul Bt fa kalNabdivtþn_kan;Etdac;xat Kat;kan;Etman

sPaBgayRsYlkñúgkarkm©at;bkSBYkRbqaMgnwgmaK’adwknaMrbs;Kat;kñúgépÞbkSEdr. ÉksarépÞkñúgmYy

)anbBa¢ak;dUecñHfa «BYkemeraKEdlrukranbkSCasm¶at;nwgRtÚvpÞj;pÞal;[bgðajxøÜneLIg tamry³kar

latRtdagBIlkçN³Bitrbs;bdivtþsgÁmniym»8. ebIGñkNaRbqaMgCMTas; b¤RKan;EtsaksYrBIbBaða

enHnwgRtÚveKecaTRbkan;faCaBYkcRkBtþi b¤Pñak;garrbs;evotNamEdlcg;bMpøaj neya)aymha

elatepøaHrbs;km<úCa. RbEhlenABak;kNþalrdUvekþAqñaM1976 karb:unb:geFVIXatCaeRcInelIkeTA

elIrUb b:ul Bt )anpþl;CaelsbEnßmmYyeTotdl;karEsVgrkbkSBYkRbqaMg EdlminTan;ecjmuxCak;

Esþg.

y:agehacNas; karebotebonmYykñúgcMeNamkarebotebonRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt EdlcuHpSay

kñúgesovePAexµArbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyü KWTTYl)ankarGHGagbEnßmBImat;rbs;kgT½BExµrRkhmrt;

ecalCYrmñak;EdlePosxøÜneTAkan;RbeTséf ehIyEdl)anniyayGaf’kM)aMgR)ab;BYkm®nþIpøÚvkarrbs;

GaemrikenATIenaHfa enABak;kNþalqñaM1976 karrYmKMnitk,t;mYykñúgeKalbMNgbMBul b:ul Bt )an

TTYlbraC½y BIeRBaHGgÁrkSmñak;kñúgcMeNamGgÁrkSCaeRcInrbs;Kat;)anPøkSedayminRby½tñnUvmðÚb

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg90

Page 101: Brother enemy

Gaharmandak;fñaMBulEdleKTukbRmúgsRmab; b:ul Bt ehIyRtÚvsøab;PøammYyrMeBc. tamsmþIrbs;

kgT½BExµrRkhmrt;ecalCYrdEdlrUbenHfa vIrPaBrbs;GñkrYmKMnitk,t;-embBa¢akarExµrRkhmmñak;

eQµaH can; cRkI nigGñksmKMnitrbs;Kat;-)anRtÚvENnaM[eFVIkic©karenH edaysarkaremIleXIj

TsSnIyPaBén«TukçevTna» EdleKdak;mkelIRbCaCnkm<úCaenHÉg9. vak¾Gacfa GñkrYmKMnitk,t;

suT§EtCaGñkCMTas;nwgneya)ayRbqaMgevotNamrbs; b:ul Bt pgEdr b:uEnþBuMmanP½sþútagNamYy

CabEg¥kdl;kareBalGHGagepSg² EdlmanbBa©ÚlTaMgevotNamdUckñúgesovePAexµAelIkeLIgTal;

EtesaH.

enAExkBaØa qñaM1976 rlkénkare)assm¥attamrebobCak,ÜnelIkdMbUgsMedAeTAelIbNþa

smaCikbkSKWmanTak;TgedaypÞal;nwgbBaðaénTMnak;TMngrvagbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa nigevotNam y:ag

R)akd. kalbriecäTEdleKTTYlsÁal;CaTUeTA nUvéf¶begáItbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCarhUtmkdl;eBl

enHKWéf¶TI30 ExkBaØa qñaM1951 CaRbkarGacbegáItExSry³Tak;TgedaypÞal;rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ

km<úCaCamYybkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinEdlbegáIteLIgenAqñaM1930eday hU CImij. kñúgGMLúgeBj

firevlaénkarRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgBYk)araMg ¬qñaM1946-1954¦ evotNam Lav nigExµr )anrYm

shkarKñay:agCitsñiT§ ehIykñúgTIbMputCnCatikm<úCaCaeRcInk¾vaytémøBIkic©shRbtibtþikarenHEdr.

yuT§ikCnkumµúynIsþeCIgcas;mñak;rbs;km<úCaeQµaH Ekv mas manmuxkñúgcMeNamemdwknaMCaeRcIn

EdlykcitþTukdak;sgát;bBa¢ak;EfmeTotBIedImkMeNItbkSEdlecjBIevotNam tamry³karR)arB§

buNüxYbkMeNItelIkTI25rbs;xøÜny:agmehaLarik. mü:ageTot tamKat;yl;neya)ayépÞkñúgrbs;

evotNamKWmanlMnaMRsbKñanwglT§im:ak;suIs Rbkan;tamRTwsþI (Marxisme Orthodoxe) CagmaK’aeqVgRCúl

rbs;km<úCa. mas RbEhlCadwgxøÜnfa Kat;RtÚvEtRbjab;cUleFVIskmµPaBCabnÞan;. edayBit enA

ExsIha bnÞab;BIlixitsEmþgmrNTukçrbs; b:ul Bt cMeBaHsBRbFan em:A EdlRbkasBIkarsßitenA

kñúg»vaTlT§iem:AniymenaH Kat;)an[dMNwgmunBIKeRmagkarfµI²CaeRcIn. edvId eqnd_l½r RbvtþiviTUEdl

sresrBIRbvtþiRbeTskm<úCa)ansnñidæanfa PaBFUrRsalCamYyevotNamEdleKGacemIleXIj

c,as;enAedImrdUvekþAqñaM1976 RBmTaMgPaBminR)akdRbCaEpñkneya)ayenARbeTscineRkay

mrNPaBrbs; em:A pg GacCMruj[ Ekv mas ekobsgát;edIm,I[eKR)arB§buNüxYbkMeNItelIkTI25

rbs;bkSenAcugExkBaØa qñaM197610.

edaypÞúymkvij b:ul Bt )anseRmccitþlubbM)at;KMnitEdlfa bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaenAEtman

RbPBedImepSg²ecjBIevotNam. Kat;)anseRmcedayGMNacfa karbegáItbkSBuMEmnmankal

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 91

Page 102: Brother enemy

briecäT enAqñaM1951eT b:uEnþKWmancab;BImhasnñi)atbkSenAqñaM1960 Edl)aneRCIstaMgKat;Ca

GKÁelxarg. dUecñHRbvtþisa®sþEdlEkERbeLIgvij GacbkRsay)anfa bkS)ancab;epþImskmµPaB

«d¾RtcHRtcg;»rbs;xøÜneRkamkardwknaMrbs; b:ul Bt edaybM)at;ecalry³eBl9qñaMénkarrYbrYmKñad¾

CitsñiT§CamYyevotNam eRBaHeKmincg;niyayBIPaBsßitenAeRkambgÁab;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam Edl

kñúgry³eBlenaHemdwknaMExµrRkhmbc©úb,nñBuMEdlsEmþgtYnaTIsMxan;NamYyeLIy. TsSnavdþITg;bdivtþ

elxBiessmYyRbcaMExkBaØa-tula )anelIkbgðaj[eXIjP½sþútagTaMgRsugsþIBIkarEkERbkal

briecäTénéf¶kMeNItbkSenH. GtßbTmYyEdlRbEhlCasresredayrUb b:ul Bt pÞal;)anbBa¢ak;

bMPøWBIerOgenHfa «eyIgRtÚvEtEksRmÜlRbvtþisa®sþbkS edIm,I[smRsbeTAnwgneya)ayÉkraCü

nigGFibetyürbs;eyIg»11.

db;éf¶munkalbriecäTEdl)aneRKagTuksRmab;karR)arB§xYbkMeNItbkS b:ul Bt )anecjbBa¢a

[p¥akkarerobcMbRmúgepSg²nig[cab;xøÜn Ekv mas RBmTaMgemdwknaMCan;x<s;mñak;eTotKW éN sar:an;

¬Føab;beRgónenAviTüal½yÉkCnmYyeQµaHceRmInviC¢a¦. GñkTaMgBIrRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚneTAkan;mNÐlsYr

cemøIyrbs;EpñksnþisuxCatienARkúgPñMeBj EdlTIenaHCaGtItGnuviTüal½yTYlEsøgedayGKarsikSa

TaMgGs;RtÚv)anERbkøay[eTACaKuk nigkEnøgsYrcemøIyeRkameQµaHsm¶at;fa s-21(S-21)vij.

bnÞab;BIkareFVITaruNkmµGs;ry³eBlmYyExnig«kareqøIysarPaB»CabnþbnÞab;minecHcb; GñkTaMgBIr)an

RtÚvykeTAsmøab;ecaledayKµanGaNitGasUr. kñúgGMLúgBIrqñaMCabnþbnÞab;mkeTot kmµaPi)al

sMxan;²rbs;bkSRbEhlCa20>000nak; rYmTaMgRkúmRKÜsarrbs;BYkeK)anTTYlrgnUveCaKvasna

dUcKña bnÞab;BIkarCab;XMumYyry³kñúgmNÐld¾l,Il,ajenH12.

eqnd_l½r )ankt;smÁal;fa «edayminRBmTTYlsÁal;karBitTaMgGs;sþIBIcMNgTak;TgCaRbvtþisa®sþ

CamYyevotNam «b:ul Bt EdlTMngCaeRKagkartaMgBIeBld¾Cak;lak;mYyGacRbkan;yksßanPaBxag

pøÚvneya)aykñúgCemøaHd¾manTMhMFMeFgmYyCamYyevotNamCaeRscnigkñúgkmµviFIsmUhPavUbnIykmµ

dac;xatmYyenAkñúgRbeTsEdlElgyktamKMrU b¤BaküENnaMrbs;evotNameTotehIy»13.

GtßbTrbs;TsSnavdþITg;bdivtþBuMmanbnSl;karsgS½yNamYysþIBIGtßiPaBéncMNgTak;TgCa

buBVehtumYyrvagkareFVIvisuT§kmµnigkarRbqaMgCMTas;cMeBaHneya)ayeqVgRCúlhYsehturbs; b:ul Bt

eLIy. Kat;)ankt;smÁal;fa mnusSxøHkñúgépÞbkSpÞal;)ancat;TukkarCemøósRbCaCnBITIRkúgnana kar

lubbM)at;RkdasR)ak;nigkmµsiT§iÉkCnfaCa «neya)ayeqVgRCúl» munnwgGHGagbEnßmfa «eyIgman

ehtuplrbs;eyIg ehIykarpøas;bþÚrkñúgsmUhPaB)anbgðaj[eXIjfa eyIgvinicä½yRtwmRtÚvEmn.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg92

Page 103: Brother enemy

eqVgb¤mineqVgetImanGVICasMxan;eTA? ³ eyIgRtÚvEtsßitenAedayRsuHcitþRsuHKMnitKñaCamYykarpøas;bþÚr

kñúgsmUhPaB». GñkniBn§GtßbT)anecaTRbkan;smaCikbkSxøHfa «eFVIxøÜnRbqaMgnwgkarpøas;bþÚrkñúg

smUhPaBnigk,t;karbdivtþn_»14.

enAéf¶TI27 ExkBaØa qñaM1976 viTüúRkúgPñMeBj)anRbkasCasaFarN³fa mYys)þah_mun ¬éf¶

Edlmankarcab;xøÜn Ekv mas¦ KN³kmµaFikarkNþalénsPatMNagRbCaCn)anGnuBaØatc,ab;[ b:ul

Bt «Qb;sRmakCabeNþaHGasnñmYy edaymUlehtusuxPaB bnÞab;BIKat;manCMgWtaMgBIb:unµanExmk

ehIy». nYn Ca )anRtÚvEtgtaMgCanaykrdæm®nþIsþITI. GñksegátkarN_CaeRcIn )ansnñidæanBIerOgenH

fa b:ul Bt )anTTYlrgeRKaHBIkare)assm¥atmYy. tamkarBit «karQb;sRmakedaymUlehtuCMgW»

RKan;EtCaelsmYyb:ueNÑaH ehIyeKaledArbs;emdwknaMExµrRkhmKW eFVI[Kat;manesrIPaBeBjTIkñúg

karBüa)al«dMe)ArlYy»rbs;bkSEdlCasmasPaBbkSBYk RbqaMg. k¾b:uEnþ exn XVIn eCOfa b:ul Bt

GacRtÚvbgçMcitþ«enAEtkñúgbnÞb;»bnÞab;BImankarb:unb:geFVIXatmYyEdlekIteLIgkalBIedImrdUvekþA

qñaM1976.

karRsavRCavTaMgLayrbs; XVIn )annaMeTAdl;karsnñidæanfa b:ul Bt GaceKcxøÜneTArs;enAkñúg

CRmksm¶at;mYy nigmankic©karBary:agmaMTaMbMputBIkarvayRbharCayfaehtufµI²eTot. BITIlak;xøÜn

eTA Kat;GacdwknaMeFVIkarkm©at;ecalTaMgGs;nUvBYkemKMniténkarrYmKMnitk,t;sMedAsmøab;Kat;eTotpg.

cemøIyCasakSIrbs;GñkePosxøÜn nigGñkenArs;ranmanCIvitBIkare)assm¥atTaMgLayEdlrt;eTAdl;

RbeTséfy:ageRcIneBjry³eBlénqñaM1977enaH )anbgðaj[eXIjBIkarsmøab;rgÁalnUv«BYk

GtIt»kmµaPi)alExµrRkhmkñúgTMhMmYyy:agFM-RbEhlmanGñkEdlmansmancitþnwgevotNamEdr

eTaHCay:agNaGñkTaMgenHcUlcitþeFVIneya)ayépÞkñúgmYyEdlminRbkan;twg ehIyEdlRbqaMgnwg b:ul

Bt rYmTaMg«BYkRbtikiriya»TaMgGs;EdlRKan;Etsnµtpg. enACMnan;enaHEdr RkúmesuIbkarN_sm¶at;

rbs;GaemrikaMgenARbeTséf)anTTYlnUvB½t’mand¾Cak;lak;CaeRcIn EdllatRtdagfa b:ul Bt )an

dwknaMeFVIkarkm©at;«GñkEdlKat;cat;TukCasRtÚv»enAPaKBay½BüRbeTsedaypÞal;xøÜnEtmþg15.

enAkñúgGMLúgR)aMmYyEx cugeRkayénqñaM1976 RbEhlKµanGVIKYr[PJak;ep¥IleLIyenAeBlEdl

kare)assm¥atepSg²kMBugRbRBwtþeTAy:ageBjTMhwgeTAehIyenaH k¾km<úCaxMRbwgEfrkSaPaBmanEt

sMbkeRkAmYy kñúgTMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTsevotNamEdr. kñúgeBlEdlrbb b:ul Bt xMRbwg

«e)assm¥at» CYrkmµaPi)alxøÜnpÞal;nigdak;[GnuvtþnUvkmµviFIeqVgRCúlrbs;xøÜn rbbenHcUlcitþmineFVI[

b:HBal;dl;smancitþd¾l¥rbs;evotNam EdlmanmkelIxøÜnCag. enAExsIha qñaM976 KN³RbtiPU

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 93

Page 104: Brother enemy

smaKmnarIrbs;km<úCamYyRkúm)aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;RkúghaNUy. TnÞwmnwgenaH b:ul Bt minrYjranwg

eFVIbdisNæarkic©ÉkGKÁrdæTUt paM v:an;)a edIm,IEføgGbGrsresIrKat;kñúg»kasbuNüxYbelIkTIsamsibmYy

rbs;saFarNrdæsgÁmniymevotNameLIy. enAéf¶TI21 ExkBaØa qñaM1976 KWCaéf¶ebIksem<aFkar

Tak;TgKñatampøÚvGakasrvagTIRkúghUCImijnigPñMeBj Edlr:ab;rgedayRkúmhu‘nEG‘revotNam (Air

Vietnam). BiFIsem<aFmYy)anR)arB§eFVIkñúg»kasenaH enAcMNtGakasyandæaneBaFicintug. munenH

mYyéf¶ evotNamRbEhlCaBuMdwgfa mitþExµrmñak;kñúgcMeNammitþExµrd¾kRmrbs;xøÜnKW Ekv mas )anRtÚv

ExµrRkhmcab;dak;KukenATYlEsøgpgeT.

kñúgsunÞrkfarbs;Kat;EdlEføgenAGgÁkarshRbCaCatienAExtula qñaM1976 eGog sarI BuMlak;

elomnUvkarkt;smÁal;d¾CUrct;CaeRcIncMeBaHRbeTsevotNam edayminbeBa©jeQµaHeLIy EdlGac

raMgramin[RbeTsenHesñIsuMcUlCasmaCikGgÁkarGnþrCati)an. eKdwgfa karcUlCasmaCikGgÁkar

shRbCaCatirbs;evotNam)anRtÚvraMgxÞb;edaykare)aHeqñatev:tU (Veto) rbs;GaemrikaMg [ev:tU Ca

BaküLataMgmann½yfa ´CMTas;. CasiT§i b¤GMNacBiessEdlpþl;[smaCikGcié®nþy_ énRkúmRbwkSa

snþisuxGgÁkarshRbCaCatiR)aMRbeTsKW Gaemrik )araMg Gg;eKøs rusSúI nigcin EdlGnuBaØat[

smaCiknImYy²CMTas;RKb;bBaðaTaMgGs;. kñúgcMeNamsmaCikTaMgR)aM ebImansmaCikNamYyCMTas;

KWbBaðamYyenaHRtÚveKcat;TukCaemaX³-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb]. éf¶TI28 Extula qñaM1976 eday

sarI Gvtþman rdæm®nþITI1sþITI sun esn )anTTYlCYbÉkGKÁrdæTUt )a kñúgry³eBlCagBIrem:ag.

xøwmsarénkarCYbsnÞnaKñaenAEtsßitkñúgPaBsm¶at; b:uEnþbriyakasénkarCYbKñaRtÚv)anvaytémø

edayviTüúPñMeBjfa «mansPaBrak;Tak;nigsñiT§sñal»16.

bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa manesckþIkøahankñúgkarbBa¢ÚnKN³RbtiPUGñksarB½t’manmYyRkúmmanKña

7nak; eTAcUlrYmmhasnñi)atbkSelIkTI4rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNamEdlebIkeFVIenABak;kNþalExFñÚ

qñaM1976. RbtiPU)anBaMnaMnUvsarlixitGbGrsaTrmYyrbs;GgÁkarbdivtþn_ ¬eQµaHEdleRbIR)as;

edayGgÁkarbdivtþkm<úCa rhUtdl;karecjmuxCabkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaEtmþg¦ ehIykarepJIlixitenH KW

kñúgbMNgEfrkSarUbPaBeRkAénTMnak;TMngCaRbRktIrvagbkSTaMgBIr. cMeBaH«karGbGrsaTrd¾kk;ekþA

bMput» EdlRkúgPñMeBjepJICUnbkSkumµúynIsþevotNammanbEnßmnUvkarrMB£kBIGtßiPaBén«samKÁIPaBbdivtþ

mYy nigmitþPaBCabgb¥ÚnsßitesßryUrGEgVgmYyEdlbkSTaMgBIrFøab;lt;dMkñúgePøIgénkarts‘Ubdivtþn_»17

pg. GtßbTénsarlixitenH )anRtÚve)aHBum<pSayedayRkúghaNUy b:uEnþ viTüúPñMeBj)anseRmcmin

pSaysarlixitenHeLIy. enAeBlEdlGñkmansmancitþnwgevotNam RtÚv)antamdanRbkit²eday

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg94

Page 105: Brother enemy

BYkPñak;garsnþisux b:ul Bt vamuxCanwgeFVI[ekItmankarRcbUkRcbl;kñúgCYrrbs;xøÜnminxan.

«mtiENnaMrbs;KN³870»

evotNamcab;epþImmnÞilsgS½ynUverOgr:avxøHEdlekItmankñúgépÞbkSkumµúynIsþrbs;km<úCaeday

mindwgCaerOgGVIBitR)akdeLIy. rdæm®nþITI1 paM v:an;dug Edl)anCYbsnÞnaCaÉkCnCamYyePJóvCatiéf

mñak;enAcugqñaM1976 )anCRmab[dwgnUvkarRBÜy)armÖy:agxøaMgcMeBaHeCaKvasna EdleRtómbRmúg

sRmab;«bNþamitþPkþikm<úCa»xøHrbs;Kat;. GtItGñkkarTUtkm<úCamYycMnYntUc EdlCasmaCikrdæaPi)al

tsU‘dwknaMeday semþc sIhnu )anepJIsMbuRtCaeRcInmk[mitþPkþiTaMgLayenARkúghaNUymunnwgeLIg

ynþehaHeFVIdMeNIrBIRkúgeb:kaMgmkkan;RkúgPñMeBj. taMgBIenaHmk KµanGñkNamñak;)anTTYldMNwgBI

GñkTaMgenaHesaH18.

etIRkúghaNUyvaytémøTMhMénkare)assm¥atenAkm<úCaedayc,as;las;EdreT? Bi)aknwg

niyayNas;. b:uEnþvaR)akdNas;fa evotNamBitCaRtÚvpþl;B½t’man[dwgBICemøaHepSg² EdleFVI[

bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaEbk)ak;Kña. enAedImExmIna qñaM1977 GñkkarTUtevotNammñak;RbcaMenARkúg

evogc½nÞ¬rdæFanIRbeTsLav¦ )anrMB£kR)ab;enAmux´BI«karRbQmmuxy:agF¶n;F¶r»rvagRkúmmnusSEdl

Kat;ehAfa «BYksñiT§ em:A-b:ul Bt cMtY100PaKry»nigGñkRbkan;«maK’aRtwmRtÚv». maK’aRtwmRtÚvEp¥k

elIkarTamTar[manmitþPaBCamYyevotNam. Kat;emIleXIjfa «enATIbBa©b;maK’aRtwmRtÚvnwgelc

ecjRbkbedayC½yCmñH» BIkarvivaTenaH. KWRkúmRbkan;maKa’RtwmRtÚvenHehIyEdl dug Kitdl;enA

eBlEdlKat;TmøayR)ab;ePJóvCatiéfBIesckþIsgÇwmrbs;Kat;EdleXIjelceLIgnUv«GñkbdivtþBit²»

enAkm<úCa. RtÚvelIkTwkcitþedayesckþIsgÇwmenH RkúghaNUy)anbeBa©jb£kEkøgCaGñkCitxagl¥

edayxMRbwgRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt y:agxøaMg. RbEhlCanwk)armÖcMeBaHkarrIkraldalénneya)ayépÞ

kñúgrbs;km<úCaenaHehIy )anCaevotNamxMRbwgy:agGs;BIcitþBIeføIm edIm,IeFVI[RsbnwgcMNg;cMNUl

citþrbs;emdwknaMExµrRkhm. CaBiessevotNamseRmccitþminbegáItelsbEnßmepSg²cMeBaHkar

Føak;cuHénTMnak;TMngCa]PetaPaKInigPaBÉekaénbNþamitþRkúghaNUy ¬ExµrmkBIevotNamxageCIg¦

kñúgépÞbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaeLIy. edIm,ICaskçIkmµénsamKÁIPaB KN³RbtiPU®sþIevotNammYyRkúm

)anRtÚvbBa¢ÚnmkRkúgPñMeBjenAedImExkumÖ³ qñaM1977. éf¶TI15 ExdEdlGnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs h½g

v:an;L k¾eFVIdMeNIrmkkan;rdæFanIExµredIm,IeFVITsSnkic©BIréf¶Edr EtBuMmankarRbkaspSayCasaFarN³

eT. Kat;manebskkmµy:agsMxan;bMput KWbBa©úHbBa©Úlkm<úCa[cUlrYmsnñisITkMBUl\NÐÚcinmYyenAeBl

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 95

Page 106: Brother enemy

xagmux. edIm,IeFVI[briyakasmansgÇwmeLIgvij L )anesñI[manshRbtibtþikarCafµIedayKµan

lkçxNÐkñúgkarbBa¢ÚneTARbeTsCativijnUvRbCaCnkm<úCaTaMgGs;Edl)anePosxøÜneTARbeTsevotNam

kalBIb:unµanExcugeRkayfµI²enH19. kñúgkrNICaeRcIn RbtibtþikarenHEbrCamanlT§pl edaykarKitKUr

rksuIxagpøÚvCMnYjy:agKYr[Gam:as;eTAvij. GaRs½yehtuenH enAedImqñaM1977 BYkGaCJaFrtam

bNþaextþrbs;evotNam )anGnuBaØat[ExµrRkhmeFVIkaredaHdUrGñkePosxøÜnEssibR)aMbYnnak;BICMrM

m:ukv:a edaybþÚrnwgstVeKaCaeRcInk,al elImUldæaneKamYyk,aldUrmnusSmñak;20.

km<úCa)anRcanecalKMnitsþIBIsnñisITkMBUlTaMgGs;. sMeNIenHelceLIghak;dUcCakarsEmþg

bEnßmmYyénectnarbs;evotNam EdlenAEtcg;dak;\NÐÚcin[sßitenAeRkamGaNaBüa)alrbs;xøÜn.

enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1976 RkúgPñMeBj)anbeBa©jRbtikmµedayRby½tñRbEygenAeBlEdlRkúghaNUy

elIkykmkniyayBI«TMnak;TMngBiess» EdlkMBugcgP¢ab;RbeTsevotNam nigLav. enAExFñÚ qñaM

1976 karRby½tñRbEygenH)anERbkøayeTACakarRBÜy)armÖvijenAeBlEdlvabgðajfa eKaledA

yUrGEgVgrbs;evotNamKWbegáIt[mancMNgTak;Tgd¾CitsñiT§nigCaGcié®nþy_CamYyRbeTskm<úCa.

esckþIseRmccitþcugeRkayrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam)ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa RbeTsevotNamR)afña

«karBarnigBRgIkTMnak;TMngBiessrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbCaCnLav nigkm<úCaCabgb¥Ún BRgwgyuT§samKÁIPaB

kareCOTukcitþeTAvijeTAmk shRbtibtþikaryUrGEgVgnigkarCYy]btßmÖKñaeTAvijeTAmkelIRKb;

vis½y>>> edIm,InwgeFVI[RbCaCnTaMgbIEdlkalBIedImFøab;rYbrYmKñakñúgkartsU‘rMedaHCati manlT§PaBcab;BI

eBlenHeTAkñúgkarsßabnanigkarkarBarRbeTserog²xøÜnCanic©nirnþr_ CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;ÉkraCüPaB

nigPaBfáúMefáIgrugerOgrbs;RbeTsnImYy²EfmeTot»21.

db;ExeRkaymkkare)assm¥atCabnþbnÞab;Edlcab;epþImeFVIenAExkBaØa 1976 )anbNþal[

mankarkemÞckmµaPi)albdivtþn_CaeRcInrynak; ehIyCaBiess)anBRgwgkarRtÜtRtarbs; b:ul Bt

elIk,alm:asuIndwknaMbkSEfmeTot. RbEhlenAcugExmIna qñaM1977 cab;epþImelceLIgnUvrbob

bkRsayrbs;km<úCaGMBI«karseRmccitþpþac;RBR½t» edIm,IttaMgnwgkarKMramkMEhgrbs;evotNam.

tamRbEhl b:ul Bt )anseRmcbBa©b;bBaðaenHCamYynwgkarRbDiteLIgnUvTMnak;TMngCaGñkCitxagl¥

CamYyevotNam. mYyEpñkKWdl;eBlevlaEdlRtÚvcat;karedIm,Ikm©at;GaNikCnevotNamenAkm<úCa

TaMgRsug ehIymYyEpñkeTotKWeFVIkarvaylukRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNamEtmþg.

rs; saerOn ynþkarImñak;EdlenArs;ranCIvitBIbNþaqñaMd¾exµAggwténrbb b:ul Bt enAnwkeXIj

y:agc,as;BIéf¶mYyenaHnaedImExemsa qñaM1977 enA]dugÁextþkMBg;s<W. eBlenaHKat;enAQrkñúgmnÞIr

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg96

Page 107: Brother enemy

rbs;RbFanRsukExµrRkhmedayrg;caMkarmkdl;rbs;Kat;edIm,Idak;CUnbBa¢IrfynþEdlxUc[Kat;Binitü.

saerOn )aneXIjenAelItueFVIkarnUvlixitmYymancuHkalbriecäTéf¶TI1 Exemsa qñaM1977 Edlman

sresrcarfa ³ «mtiENnaMrbs;KN³870». enACMnan;enaH saerOn Kµandwgfa elx«870»Caelx

sm¶at;rbs;KN³mCÄimbkSd¾manGMNacbMputKWGgÁkard¾Gaf’kM)aMgenaHeT. b:uEnþ esckþIkñúgsMbuRtenaH

manlkçN³KYr[P½yrn§t;bMput ³ CnCatievotNamTaMgGs;kñúgtMbn;RBmTaMgCnCatiExµr Edlniyay

PasaevotNam b¤EdlmanmitþPkþiCaevotNamRtÚvEtcab;bBa¢ÚnxøÜneTA[Epñksnþisuxrbs;rdæ. saerOn

enAEtQresÞIrEtrwgxøÜnkñúgTIenaH. CakUnkMRBa Kat;RtÚv)anciBa©wmbI)ac;edaym©as;yandæanCatievotNam

mñak;enARkúgPñMeBj. mü:ageTot Kat;ecHniyayPasaevotNamnig)anerobkarCamYy®sþIevotNam

mñak;pg. sMNagl¥ kñúgshkrN_EdlGñkTaMgBIrrs;enAKµanGñkNamñak;)andwgBIsavtarrbs;Kat;

eLIy. saerOn CYsCulLanhSúIb (Jeep) rbs;KN³Rsuk rYck¾Rbjab;Rbjal;RtLb;mkpÞHvij

PøamedIm,IR)ab;dMNwg[RbBn§Kat;dwg. b:uEnþnag)andwgerOgenHrYceTAehIy. ®sþIevotNammñak;kñúgPUmi

eTIbEtRtÚvsmøab;edayExµrRkhmvaynwgdMbg ehIyykeTAkb;enAxageRkAPUmiy:agRtwmRtÚv. éf¶mun

bþIrbs;®sþIenaH)anRtÚvExµrRkhmbBa¢Ún[eTAkab;eQIenAkñúgéRB. CaeRcInéf¶eRkaymk eBlKat;RtLb;

mkvijeXIjpÞHenATeTs¥at. GñkCitxagEdlRtÚveFVI[)ak;s,at)anbiTmat;enAes¶óm ehIyxMeKcBI

Kat;EfmeTot. edayEsVgrkRbBn§enATICitxagCuMvijPUmi Kat;)anrkeXIjGMeBIsahavéRBépSenH KW

Kat;eXIjédmçagelcecjBIpñÚrmYyEdleKeTIbnwgkaylubfµI². Kat;sÁal;PinPaKédenH edayKµan

lM)ak. enAsl;EtsMNYrmYyEdlKµancemøIyfa ³ ehtuGVI?22. cab;taMgBIExmIna kñúgeKaledAeRtóm

Tb;Tl;nwgkarb:HTgÁicedayGavuFCamYyevotNam kgÉkPaBT½BCaeRcInrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’a )anRtÚv[

Qb;bMeBjParkic©bgábegáInpl edIm,IerobcMxøÜneTAsmrPUmivij. kñúgraRtIéf¶TI30 Exemsa qñaM1977

ExµrRkhm)ancab;epþImvayqµk;CabnþbnÞab;eTAelIPUmi nigXuMnanarbs;extþGany:agkñúgEdndIsNþTenø

emKgÁeday)aj;smøab;GñkPUmi nigdutpÞHsEm,gGs;y:ageRcIn. karvayRbhareTAelIXuMTijebon

EtmYy )aneFVI[RbCaCnsuIvilrgeRKaHRbEhl100nak;. mYyqñaMeRkaymk eK)anGnuBaØat[

´¬GñkniBn§¦eFVId¿eNIreTAkan;Tijebon EdlBIeBlenHeTA)anERbkøayCaTIRkúgexµaceTAehIy CakEnøg

Edl´Gacsþab;nUverOgniTanepSg²rbs;GñkEdlrYcputBIeRKaHP½yénraRtIéf¶TI30 Exemsa Edl

bNþal[manvinaskmµy:agexøacpSaenaH. tamkarBit km<úCa)ancab;epþImeFVIkarvayqµk;dMbUg²rbs;

xøÜntaMgBIExmkra qñaM1977emø:H. b:uEnþkarvayqµk;rbs;ExµrRkhmenAéf¶TI30 Exemsa d¾vinashin

ehacenH KWBYkeKcg;eRCIserIsykéf¶ExCanimitþrUbmYy. éf¶enaHKWCaéf¶énkarR)arB§BiFIbuNüxYbqñaM

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 97

Page 108: Brother enemy

TIBIrén«karrMedaHevotNamxagt,Úg» ¬30 emsa 1975¦ nigmYyéf¶mun éf¶buNüTI1 ]sPa EdlCa

TivaGnþrCatiénsamKÁIPaBrvagBlkrTUTaMgBiPBelak.

haNUysgÇwmelIeCaKC½yrbs; etg

enAeBlEdlm:asuInTUrGgÁúlIelx (Téléscripteur) KWm:asIunGgÁúlIelxsRmab;kt;GkSrEdleKbBa¢Ún

mkBIcm¶ay énTIsþIkarRksYgkarbreTslan;sñÚreLIg edIm,IpSay[dwgCasaFarN³BImrNPaBrbs;

em:A RkúghaNUy)anEckrMElkesµIKñarvagkarrg;caM nigkarsb,ayrIkray. taMgBIeRcInExmkehIy²

edayBittaMgBImrNPaBrbs; CU eGnLay enAExmkra qñaM1976 B½t’manepSg²EdlelcecjmkBI

Rkúgeb:kaMg)an[dwgBIkarekIneLIgnUvkartsU‘edIm,IGMNac nigkarceRmIneTAmuxénBYkr:aDIkal;Edl

RbQmmuxdak;Kña RbsinCamankartTl;KñaEmnETn. mrNPaBrbs; em:A CasñÚrCYgmrN³sRmab;BYk

eqVgniymEmnb¤? eTaHCay:agNak¾eday k¾RkúghaNUymansgÇwmBIerOgenHEdr. edIm,IkuM[»kas

mYyknøgeTAedayxVHPaBesµaHsµ½RKkñúgTMnak;TMngEdlmansPaBtantwgbMput rvagRbeTsTaMgBIr

evotNam)anbBa¢ÚnkRmgpáarYmmrNTukçy:ageRcIn eTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMgtamynþehaHBiessmYy

eRKÓg. kariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamTaMgmUl b¤swgEtTaMgGs;)anNat;CYbKña

kñúgGKarmYy Edlmanrcnab½TµrebobCaRBHvihar EdlbeRmICasßanTUtrbs;cinRbcaMRkúghaNUy

edIm,IcuHhtßelxakñúgesovePAcUlrYmsmanTukç.

enAéf¶TI12 Extula qñaM1976 BYkemdwknaMevotNamesÞIrEtminGacTb;karsb,ayrIkray

y:agxøaMgrbs;xøÜn)aneLIy enAeBlEdlBYkeK)andwgBIkarcab;xøÜn «bn4nak;». GñkdwknaMevotNam

mñak;EdleBareBjeTAedayTwkcitþekøóvkøa)anRbkasR)ab;GñkqøgeqøIyB½t’mankaEstluym:anIet

(l’Humanité) fa «elakRbEhlCaeTARkúgeb:kaMgenAqñaMxagmux edIm,IbMbiTbM)aMgRBwtþikarN_enaH»23.

karTayTukCamunenH manlkçN³minsUvGs©arüb:unµaneT enAsm½ymYyEdlbNþasmaCikbkSkumµúynIsþ

)araMgsñiT§sUevot suT§EtCamnusSEdleKmincg;eXIjmuxenARbeTscin. G‘ÍcwgehIy)anCaevotNam

manesckþIsgÇwmfa bnÞab;BIkarkm©at; «bn4nak;» RbeTscinc,as;CarkeXIjmaK’aRtwmRtÚveLIgvij

ehIyRbkan;\riyabfmYyEdlminsUvceg¥ótcg¥l; ¬RsLaj;CatixøÜnÉgRCúlhYsehtu¦ nigeTarTn;eTA

rklT§iRbtibtþiniymcMeBaHRbeTsrbs;xøÜneRcInCagmun. ebIsinekItmanedayécdnüfa maK’aniympøÚv

kNþalrbs;sB CU eGnLay nig etg s‘avBIg EdleBlenHrasIkMBugFøak;cuH cab;epþImmaneRbób

eLIgvijenARbeTscinenaHneya)ayÉkraCürbs;RkúghaNUy RbEhlGacsgÇwmniyaysþab;Kña

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg98

Page 109: Brother enemy

)anRbesIrCagmunminxan.

Ca]TahrN_ÉkGKÁrdæTUtrbs;evotNamRbcaMenARbeTscin egVón RTúgvij k¾manesckþIsgÇwm

Edr. Kat;)anRBlyBakü[shesvikrbs;Kat;xøHdwgfa ebIsinCa etg )ankan;GMNaceLIgvij

CemøaHcin-evotNamsþIBIekaHTaMgLaykñúgsmuRTcinPaKxagt,Úg GacnwgrkeXIjdMeNaHRsaymYy.

vij )ankt;smÁal;BI etg fa kñúg»kasénkarCYbCamYy eL yn; GKÁelxabkSkumúµynIsþevotNam

enAExkBaØa qñaM1975 etg )anTTYlsÁal;BIGtßiPaBénCemøaHmYy ehIy)an[dwgBIbMNgrbs;Kat;

Edlnwgpþl;nUvdMeNaHRsaymYyenAeBleRkay. b:uEnþtaMgBIedImdMbUgén yuT§nakarRbqaMgnwg etg enA

cugqñaM1975 Rkúgeb:kaMg)anbnþwgCMhrrbs;xøÜnehIyRbkasfa ekaHTaMgLayCa«TwkdId¾Bisidærbs;

matuPUmiCaTIRsLaj;»rbs;eyIg edayehtuenH KWBuMGaccrca)aneLIy. evotNamFøab;sgÇwmfa kar

eRCIstaMg etg [kan;GMNaceLIgvij GacnwgeFVI[mankarxitcUlCitKñaPøam²mYy CageTarTn;eTArk

ehtukarN_Cak;EsþgsþIBIbBaðaenH24.

kalebIdMNwgsþIBIkarpøas;bþÚrepSg²EdlekItmanenARkúgeb:kaMgrlay)at;eTA evotNamk¾kMBug

erobcMEpnkarR)aMqñaMTIBIrrbs;xøÜnEdr. taMgBImYyqñaMmkehIy BYkemdwknaMevotNam)aneFVIdMeNIreTA

RbeTssgÁmniymnanaedIm,IEsVgrkmUlniFiEdlcaM)ac;sRmab;karksagRbeTseLIgvij. mhaRbeTs

sgÁmniymEtmYyKt;EdlbdiesFmincUlrYmCYykñúgry³eBlEvgKWRbeTscin. karkm©at;ecalBYk

r:aDIkal;Gacmann½yfa Cakarpøas;bþÚr\riyabfmYy. enAéf¶TI15 Extula KWbIéf¶bnÞab;BIkarRbkas

pSay[dwgRBwtþikarN_enaH RkúghaNUyEdlcg;bBa¢ak;[rwtEtc,as;)anesñIsuMCMnYyesdækic©eTATIRkúg

eb:kaMgtamry³sMbuRtmYy. b:uEnþ enAeBlEdlRkúghaNUyR)arB§ebIkmhasnñi)atbkSenAExFñÚkñúg

sal)aDij RbkbeTAedaykarsb,ayrIkraybMputenaH kareqøIytb)aneTACaerOgEdlemdwknaMevot

NamTnÞwgrg;caMCanic©. KµanmuxRbtiPUcinNamñak;kñúgcMeNamGñktMNagbkSkumµúynIsþCabgb¥ÚncMnYn

émÖR)aMbYn Edl)anmkcUlrYmtamkarGeBa¢Ijrbs;evotNameLIy. enHCaRbPBénkarrYjracitþmYy

kñúgesckþIraykarN_xagneya)ayrbs;evotNam. bnÞat;neya)ayrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam

elIqakGnþrCatiKWtRmg;CaBiesseTArkbøúkRbeTsmincUlbkSsm<½n§nigttiyelak. bnÞat;neya)ay

enH)anTukmYyGenøInUvbBaðaCasarvnþEdl)aneFVI[Rkúgeb:kaMgnigmUsÁÚEbk)ak;Kña. evotNam)anEjk

[Rkúgeb:kaMgeXIjnUvPaBxusKñakñúgbBaðaenH edaykMNt;cRkBtþiniymGaemrikfa CaGñkKMramkMEhgFM

bMputRbqaMgnwgsnþiPaBBiPBelak b:uEnþenAykcitþTukdak;sresIrRBmKñacMeBaHshPaBsUevot nig

RbeTscinEdl)anseRmceCaKC½ykñúgkarksaglT§isgÁmniymEdr. evotNamBuM)anbBa¢ak;BIRbkar

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 99

Page 110: Brother enemy

enH[c,as;R)akdeLIy ehIyk¾mineCOKMrUCasklmYysþIBIkarbdivtþn_Edr ³ RbeTsnImYy²RtÚvEteFVI

[yuT§sa®sþmYy nigyuT§viFImYyrIkceRmInsmRsbeTAtamsßanPaBRbeTspÞal;rbs;xøÜn.

etIRbeTscinbeBa©jRbtikmµEbbNacMeBaHkarmincUlbkSsm<½n§rbs;evotNam?. ry³eBl

rg;caMRtÚvbBa©b;kñúgbNþaéf¶cugeRkayénExkumÖ³ enAeBlEdlcemøIyBIeb:kaMgeqøIytbnwgsMbuRtmYy

kalBIExtulamun)anmkdl;evotNam. tamBitenHCakarl,gBiesaFn_Rbtikmµrbs;cin eRkay em:A

TTYlmrNPaB BuMEmncg;suMCMnYyEpñkesdækic©mYyenaHeT. enHKWCakarbdiesFtamrebobKYrsmmYy.

eK)anbkRsayR)ab;Gnurdæm®nþIevotNammñak;EdleFVIdMeNIrqøgkat;Rkúgeb:kaMgfa RbeTscinBuMGac

eqøIytbtamsMeNIrbs;evotNam)aneT BIeRBaHesdækic©rbs;xøÜnpÞal;eTIbnwgegIbBIkarxUcxatEdl

bgáeLIgedayBYk«bn4nak;»nwgkarrBa¢ÜydIy:agF¶n;F¶rmYy25.

enHBuMEmnCaelssamBaØmYyeT eTaHbICaBuMEmnk¾eday k¾vaCakarbgðajPsþútagKYr[eBjcitþ

kñúgkarbdiesFrbs;cinEdr. bnÞab;BIry³eBlEdlekItmankarrMeCIbrMCYlnigs®gÁamsuIvilesÞIrEt

db;qñaMnigbnþedaykarrBa¢ÜydI enAextþehbuI (Hebei) EdlCamhnþrayd¾FM enAExkkáda qñaM1976 eday

eFVI[manGñkrgeRKaH70muWnnak; nigbnSl;TukGñkKµanCRmkCagmYylannak;enaH esdækic©rbs;cin)an

TTYlrgplb:HBal;y:agF¶n;F¶r. b:uEnþRbkarTaMgenHBuM)anraraMgmin[Rkúgeb:kaMgbBa¢Ún hVagyI CaRbjab;

mkkan;RkúgPñMeBjenAExFñÚ qñaM1976eLIy edIm,IcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógpþl;CMnYyesdækic©mYy

sRmab;km<úCaedayeRKageFVIkarRbKl;«eRKÓgsmÖarbrikçarepSg²»Camun. ehtuplBitR)akdénkar

bdiesFrbs;cin KWRbEhlCacg;EsVgrkkñúgGsßirPaBneya)aynUvGVIEdlmanGtßRbeyaCn_eBlenaH

enARkúgeb:kaMgehIyemIleTA. ry³eBlbYnEx edIm,IeqøIytbnwgsMbuRtrbs;RbeTsevotNamEdl

caM)ac;xanmin)an KWCasBaØabgðaj[eXIjfa karCECkEvkEjkrkxusRtÚvmYy)anRbRBwtþeTAsþIBI

eKalkarN_EdlRtÚvRbkan;yk. eKRbEhlCaminEdldwgBIxøwmsarénkarCECkBiPakSaenaHesaH

eLIy. esckþIsgÇwmEdlevotNamEp¥keTAelIrUbbuKÁl etg nigmaK’aniymkNþalfµIrbs;Kat;enaH

eXIjfa mindwgCasMGageTAelIGVIEdr. eKRtÚvEtrg;caMrhUtdl;cugqñaM1978 edIm,I)andwgnUvGVIEdl

ekItmanBitR)akdkñúgerOgenH. PaBmineTogTat;énsßankarN_GnþrCatienAeBlenaH)aneFIV[ etg

EdltaMgxøÜneLIgenAkñúgcenøaHeBlenaHCamnusSxøaMgrbs;RbeTscinKWCasRtÚvdac;xatbMputrbs;evot

Nam. b:uEnþ enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1977 TaMgBYkem:AniymEdlRbmUlpþú MCafµICu Mvij hVa KUehVg

TaMgBYkRbtibtþiniymEdldwknaMeday etg enAminTan;TukcitþxøÜnÉgb:unµaneT edIm,IepþImKMnitmuneK

xagvis½yneya)aybreTs CaBiesseTAeTot vapÞúynwgneya)ayEdl)anGnuvtþtaMgBIqñaM1975

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg100

Page 111: Brother enemy

mk. srubesckþIeTAkaresIerIBinitüeLIgvijmYy GMBITMnak;TMngepSg²rvagcin-evotNamnwgminGac

maneTAÉg²eLIyedayehtufa PaBCUrct;EdlbnSl;TukedayCemøaHTwkdI kareRbIGakb,kiriyaminl¥

EdleRtómbRmúgedayRkúghaNUycMeBaHGaNikCncinenAkñúgRbeTsevotNam nigKMnitpþÜcepþImTaMg

Layrbs;xøÜnedIm,IBRgwgPaBx<g;x<s;CageKbMputrbs;evotNamenA\NÐÚcin. vacaM)ac;Nas;sRmab;

emdwknaMcinEdlRtÚvEteFVI[manPaBryalbnþic PaBl¥itl¥n;nigeBareBjedayPaBkøahanxagneya

)ay edIm,ICMrujRbeTsevotNamedayskmµ kñúgkarEsVgrkÉkraCüneya)aynigeFVI[karRBÜy)armÖ

GMBIerOgsnþisuxrbs;xøÜnFUrRsal. Rtg;kEnøgEdlRtÚvbkRsayBIkarRbwgERbgEdlsEmþg[eXIj

edayRkúghaNUykñúgeKalbMNgEklm¥TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYybs©imRbeTseRbobdUckmøaMg

Tb;d¾manRbeyaCn_mYyTl;nwg\T§iBlRkúgmUsÁÚenaH BYkemdwknaMcinEdlenAEtminTukcitþ)anRtÚveFVI[

Gak;Gn;citþnwgerOgTaMgenHy:agxøaMg. kñúgTIbMput Tm¶n;énRbvtþisa®sþmYyEdlpÞúkeTAedayvibriyakas

¬dMeNIrERbRtLb;¦ nigesckþIP½yxøaccMeBaHkarrYmKMnitKñaCasm¶at;rvagsUevot-evotNam )aneFVI[

karseRmccitþelceLIg ³ eRbIRBng; RbesIrCagemImkar:ut. edayeRCIserIsrvaglT§PaBepSg²

edIm,I[mankarxitCitKñaCaRbéBNImYy nigtamviFIneya)ayEdlpþl;eRKaHfñak;ticCagRbeTscin)an

cMNay\T§iBlEdlxøÜnGacenAmanenAeLIyeTAelIevotNamTaMgGs;.

enAeBlEdlcemøIyrbs;RbeTscinbMpøaj[sabsUnünUvesckþIsgÇwmTaMgGs;énkarxitCitKña

TsSnvis½yénTisdwknaMfµImYyrbs;cinedayecosvagPaBsñiT§sñalhYsRbmaNCamYyExµrRkhm Edl

RkúghaNUycg;)any:agxøaMgkøaenaH hak;dUcCarwtEtXøatq¶ayeTA². Rkúgeb:kaMg)anykcitþTukdak;

CafµIcMeBaHtMbn;enH TukNaCardæFanIcinEdlrMeCIbrMCYleBjTMhwgkalBIR)aMExmun )ansEmþg[eXIjnUv

PaBmineGIeBImYycMeBaHerOgr:avepSg²enAGasuIGaeKñy_EdlERbRbÜlxusBImun. RbeTscinmanbMNg

bgðaj[eXIjedayrebobminGacbdiesF)annUvkarkat;pþac;rbs;xøÜnCamYykarGnuvtþeKalkarN_

eqVgRCúlkalBICMnan;mun. kñúgeKaledAenHelakCMTav etg yinCav RbBn§emm:ayrbs;sB CU

eGnLay )anRtÚvbBa¢ÚneTAkan;RbeTsPUmasRmab;ebskkmµkarTUtCan;x<s;CaelIkdMbUg enAkñúgRbeTs

enHtaMgBIeRcInqñaMmkehIy. bnÞab;mk elakCMTav)aneTAeFVITsSnkic©enARbeTs):aKIsßan nigRsIlgáa

eTot. TnÞwmnwgenaH edayTmøay\riyabfenAs¶at;es¶ómkñúgb:unµanExcugeRkayrbs;Kat; eGog sarI

)aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMgCafµIEdlRtÚv)anm®nþICan;x<s;cinTTYlbdisNæarkic©y:agGFikGFmbMput.

RkúghaNUy)ankt;smÁal;edaykarRBÜy)armÖcMeBaHvtþmanrbs;]tþmesnIy_ v:ag sagr:ug GKÁesna

FikarrgkgT½Bcin kñúgBiFICb;elogmYyEdlpþl;kitþiyssRmab; sarI eday]bnaykrdæm®nþI lI

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 101

Page 112: Brother enemy

s‘annan enAéf¶TI31 ExmIna enARkúgeb:kaMgpgEdr. vtþmanrbs; v:ag mann½yedayKµan[sgS½yfa

shRbtibtþikarEpñkeyaFaCamYykm<úCaBitCamankñúgrebobvar³énkarCYbCuMKñaenaHehIy.

RbeTscin)ancab;epþImnaMykRbeTskm<úCa[ecjputBIPaBÉekaniym ¬neya)aybreTsénrdæ

mYyEdlniymminTak;Tgnwgkic©karGnþrCatib¤RbeTseRkA¦ EdleFVI[km<úCaeRtkGrCaxøaMg nigRbqaMg

Tl;nwg«karvaysRmúkRbelamesñh_rbs;evotNam» CamYybNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþkñúgtMbn;

pg. bNþajpSBVpSayB½t’manrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg Edl)anXøaMemIledayes¶óms¶at;mYycMeBaHdMeNIrd¾

KYr[kt;smÁal;bMput -CadMeNIrelIkdMbUgtaMgBIs®gÁamcb;- rbs;Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam pan;

ehon kñúgbNþaRbeTsGas‘an enAExkkáda qñaM1976enaH )anlak;)aMgerOgenH edaykares¶IcsresIr

BIdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs; sarI vij. emdwknaMExµrRkhm)aneFVIdMeNIreTARbeTsm:aeLsuI sigðburI nigPUma

edayeFVICaGñkBaMnaMsarmYyEdlFanaGHGagfa «\NÐÚcinRkhm» EdlrYbrYmeRkamkarRtÜtRtarbs;Rkúg

haNUyBuMmanGtßiPaBeT. sarI )anEføgR)ab;]bnaykrdæm®nþIsigðburI suInNafaMb‘I r:ahSar:atNaM fa

«RbCaCnkm<úCaBuMmanCMenOcMeBaHshB½n§\NÐÚcinmYyeT edayKat;)anR)ab;[dwgTaMgGs;BICemøaH

TwkdIEdlkMBugeFVI[km<úCaRbQmmuxnwgevotNameTotpg. edayRbEhlCaeFVIpÞúynwgTsSn³Éeka

niymCaRbéBNIrbs;km<úCa sarI )anKUsbBa¢ak;fa km<úCaRbCaFibetyüR)afñabegáItTMnak;TMngCa

GñkCitxagl¥CamYysigðburI nigCYyeFVI[karpøas;bþÚrxagvis½yBaNiC¢kmµkan;EtrIklUtlas;eTAGnaKt

EfmeTot26.

emdwknaMExµrRkhm)anbnþdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;xøÜnkñúgtMbn;teTAeTot. cMENkRbeTscin bnÞab;BI

minmat;minkCaeRcInExsþIBIbBaðaenH )aneFVIkarTamTarrbs;xøÜnCasaFarN³mþgeToteTAelIekaHTaMg

LayEdlsßitenAsmuRTcinPaKxagt,Úg. GtßbTEdlecjpSaykñúgkaEstmYyrbs;cin cuHéf¶TI14

ExmIna qñaM1977 )aneRkInrMB£kevotNamnUvkarseRmccitþrbs;RbeTscinkñúgkarcUlkan;kab;RbCuM

ekaHRs<atlI EdlminTan;mannrNab:HBal;CafµI27. esckþIEføgkarN_CaeRcIn EdlRtÚvpSBVpSay

CasaFarN³kñúg»kasbuNüxYbelIkTIBIrénC½yCmñHrbs;ExµrRkhm )anbnSl;TuknUvkarsgS½yxøH²

GMBIectnarbs;km<úCaEdleFVI[PaBtantwgCamYyevotNamekInrwtEtxøaMg nigGMBIkarsnüarbs;RbeTs

cinEGbmkxag b:ul Btpg. kñúg»kasénBiFICb;elogmYyEdlerobcMeLIgenAPñMeBj sarI )aneqøIy

sarPaBEdlesÞIrEtKµanlak;elomBIkare)assm¥atCaeRcInRbqaMgCnCatievotNam EdlepþImeFVIkñúg

TUTaMgRbeTs. enARkúgeb:kaMg rdæm®nþIkarbreTscin hYg hY )annaMykeTAniyaybnþeTotedayEføg

sresIrkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü EdlecHeFVI[«GMeBIviecäTkmµEdlbgáeLIgedayBYksRtÚvrbs;xøÜn eTaHCa

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg102

Page 113: Brother enemy

enAxagkñúg b¤mkBIxageRkARtÚvbraC½yTaMgGs;». elakrdæm®nþI)an[RbeTskm<úCadwgfa GMBIvis½y

neya)aykarbreTs maK’arbs; em:A BuMmanecaTCabBaðaeLIgvijeT. dUecñHRbeTscinmine)aHbg;sm<½n§

PaBrbs;xøÜnCamYybNþaRbeTstUctacRbqaMgTl;nwgkareRbI])ayklsm¶at;EdlnaM[manPaBvwkvr

kareRCótERCk b¤kareRbImeFüa)aybMPitbMP½yBIsMNak;BYkmhaGMNaceLIy. hYg niyayfa «eyIg

eCOCak;y:agR)akdfa RbCaCncinnigkm<úCateTAGnaKt nwgrYbrYmKñakan;EtCitsñiT§EfmeTot eyIgnwg

vayRbyuT§RbekoksµaKña nigeFVIdMeNIreTAmuxTaMgGs;KñatampøÚvénkarRbyuT§tsU‘rYmrbs;eyIg»28.

karelIkTwkcitþTaMgenH hak;dUcCakar[tRmúydUecñHEdr. esÞIrEtmindl;BIrs)þah_eRkaymkpg

ExµrRkhm)ancab;eFVIkarvayRbharkñúglkçN³CaRTg;RTayFMCaelIkdMbUgrbs;xøÜnRbqaMgnwgevotNam

Pøam. karvayRbharenHRtÚv)antbtmkvijedaykarTmøak;RKab;EbktampøÚvGakasy:ageRcIn.

ynþehaHRbedjTmøak;RKab;EbkFun «Dragonfly A-37» Edle)aHbg;ecaledayshrdæGaemrik)ancab;

eFVIskmµPaBeLIgvijenAkñúg»kasenH. b:uEnþkñúgcMeNamRbeTsTaMgBIr KµanRbeTsNamYyeFVIesckþI

raykarN_sþIBI]bTÞvehtuenAtamRBMEdnrbs;xøÜneLIy. karRBmanCaelIkdMbUgrbs;evotNamcMeBaH

km<úCa eRkamTRmg;CakMNt;karTUtsm¶at;mYycuHkalbriecäTéf¶TI7 Exmifuna qñaM1967 RtÚv)aneFVImYy

éf¶mundMeNIreTAdl;Rkúgeb:kaMgrbs; paM v:an;dug. rdæm®nþIkarbreTsrbs;evotNam)anbBa¢ÚnlixitmYy

eTA[ suk Xag ÉkGKÁrdæTUtkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüRbcaMRkúghaNUy EdlkñúgenaHKat;)anpþl;eyabl;

[mankarebIkkic©crcakRmitx<s;mYy edIm,IedaHRsaybBaðaRBMEdn nigbBa©b;«]bTÞvehtuRbLak;eTA

edayQam» EdlekItmanknøgmk. enHCakarniyayeyagy:agc,as;RkELtBIkarvayRbharrbs;

ExµrRkhmeTAelITIRbCuMCn Tijebon nigextþGany:ag. evotNam)anecaTRbkan;BYkemdwknaMRkúg

PñMeBjedaycM²CaelIkdMbUgbMputfa «kardak;[cUlRbyuT§nUvcMnYnTahand¾sn§wksn§ab;kñúgRbtibtþikar

CaeRcInelIkdMNalKña eTAelItMbn;d¾FMlVwgelVIymYyBuMGacekItmanBIKMnitpþÜcepþImrbs;Gñkkan;GMNac

km<úCaenAtammUldæanTaMgenaHeT. bT]Rkidæd¾sem,ImTaMgenH BitCaRbRBwtþeLIgedaymnusSmYyEpñktUc

KWmnusSmYyRkúm Edlmanectnaminl¥ kñúgeKalbMNgecaT[manPaBkkrl¥k;eLIgvijdl;samKÁIPaB

CaRbéBNI nigmitþPaBCabgb¥Ún Edl)annigkMBugbRgÜbbRgÜmbkS nigRbCaCnTaMgBIrrbs;eyIg»29.

enAéf¶bnÞab; Tinanub,vtþirbs;kgT½BevotNam Kn;dUy júinhSin )aneRbIBakübBaäitbeBaäógCa

elIkdMbUgGMBIGtßiPaBénbBaðaRBMEdnmYyedayGMBavnav[kgT½BRbúgRbyt½ñCab;Canic© edIm,IrujRcaneTA

vijnUvkarvayRbharNamYymin[dwgxøÜnmunBIsMNak;sRtÚv. etIsRtÚvCaGñkNa ehIyRBMEdnenA

Rtg;Na? RbCaCnRtÚvEtrg;caMdl;qñaM1978 eTIbRtÚvR)ab;[dwgBIerOgenH.

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 103

Page 114: Brother enemy

edayeqøIytbeTAnwgsMeNIrbs;evotNam enAéf¶TI18 Exmifuna rdæaPi)alrbs;km<úCa)anR)ab;

[dwgfa karRbCuMedIm,IcrcaKñaTMngdUcCaBuMGaceFVI)aneLIy munkareFVI[sßankarN_manRbRktIPaBsin

EdlnwgRtÚvseRmcRbkan;ykenA«eBlevlad¾Cak;lak;»NamYy30. mYys)aþh_eRkaymk rdæaPi)al

km<úCa)aneRbIsmþIbBaäitbeBäaógCasaFarN³ nigc,as;las;CaelIkdMbUgbMputcMeBaHkarTas;ETgKña

CamYyevotNam edayEføgsresIrbNþakmµaPi)alnigyuT§CnenAextþkMBt EdlmanRBMEdnCab;

RbeTsevotNamcMeBaH «Blikmµrbs;BYkeKkñúgkic©karBarRBMEdnekaHTaMgLay nigEdnTwkrbs;km<úCa

EdlminGacb:HBal;)an»31.

Rkúgeb:kaMgbeBa©jGakb,kiriyaCasRtÚv

cMeBlEdlmankarFøak;cuHy:agc,as;kñúgTMnak;TMngepSg²CamYyRbeTskm<úCa rdæm®nþIkarBar

RbeTsevotNam ]tþmesnIy_ v: egVógy:ab kMBugsßitenAkñúgdMeNIreTAkan;shPaBsUevot nigGWr:ub

xagekIt. b:uEnþ dUcsBVdg BYkemdwknaMevotNamEdlRbúgRby½tñnigEdlhYgEhgBIkareFVIskmµPaB

edayÉkraCürbs;xøÜnenaH)anecosvagminsEmþg[eXIjfa xøÜnCasm<½n§mitþd¾CitsñiT§bMputrbs;BYk

sUevotenAmuxRkEsEPñkRkúgeb:kaMgeLIy. ebITukCakarlem¥ógEpñkneya)ay nigesckþIRtÚvkarEpñk

esdækic©rbs;xøÜnRbTajeTArkkarxitcUlCitKñanigRkúgmUsÁÚk¾eday k¾BYkeKdwgc,as;Nas;BIGMNacrbs;

RbeTscinenAeBlEdlh‘aneFVI[RbeTsenHTas;citþ. enAExmifuna minyUrb:unµan bnÞab;BIkarvilRtLb;

rbs;Kat;BIRTIkúgmUsÁÚ ]tþmesnIy_ y:ab )anecjdMeNIreTAeFVI«TsSnkic©CapøÚvkar nigCamitþPaB»enA

RbeTscineTotkñúgzan³CaemdwknaMKN³RbtiPUeyaFad¾sem,ImmYy. PaBFMduMénKN³RbtiPUenH RtÚv

)anKitKUry:agQøasévbMputedayrkSaTuksmasPaBdEdl dUcKñanwgcMnYnsmaCikKN³RbtiPUEdlKat;

Føab;dwknaMeTAshPaBsUevotkalBImunEdr. dMeNIrTsSnkic©enH)anRbRBwtþeTABuM)anTTYlpll¥

RbesIreLIy. smPaKIrbs; y:ab KWesnaRbmux ey CanyIg BuM)aneTATTYlsVaKmn_Kat;enA

Gakasyandæan ehIyk¾BuMmankarCb;elogCakitiþysEdr. kñúgkic©snÞnasMxan;²CaeRcIn KUsnÞnarbs;

y:ab suT§EtCa\sSrCnfñak;bnÞab;. evotNam)anRtÚveFVI[Gak;Gn;RsBn;citþy:agxøaMg. eK)an

niyayfa y:ab )aneFVI[«m©as;pÞH»¬cin¦P½nþPaMgRsLaMgkaMg edayKat;R)ab;erOgs¶at;kM)aMg[dwgfa

«TIRbwkSacinCaeRcInnak;rbs;ExµrRkhmRtÚv)ancab;CaeQøIyswkenAEx]sPa kñúg»kasénkarvay

RbharmYyRbqaMgnwgevotNam»32.

bdisNæarkic©EdleKeRtómbRmúgsRmab; y:ab )aneFVI[Kat;nwkxwgminticeT. edIm,IbgðajnUv

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg104

Page 115: Brother enemy

karminsb,aycitþrbs;xøÜn evotNam)ancuHpSayenATMB½rTImYyénkaEstkgT½BnUvGtßbTmYy Edl

TuksRmab;sarmnÞIrhaNUy nigsRmab;smuc©½y ¬karRbmUlTukvtßúTaMgLayEdlRsedogKñab¤dUcKña¦

Cab;nwgr)aykarN_sþIBIdMeNIrrbs; y:ab enARbeTscinEdlbgðaj[eXIjBIkartsU‘ edIm,IÉkraCü

ry³eBlmYyBan;qñaMrbs;evotNamRbqaMgnwgRbeTscin.

enAéf¶bnÞab;BIkarecjdMeNIrrbs; y:ab enAéf¶TI8 Exmifuna rdæm®nþITI1 paM v:an;dug )anRtLb;BI

RkúgmUsÁÚmkdl;RbeTsvij edayQb;sMctmYyry³xøIenARkúgeb:kaMg. kalmun kñúg»kasénkarQb;

sMctmYyry³xøIkñúgrdæFanIcinenAExemsa tampøÚveq<aHeTARkúg):arIsenaH dug )an[eyabl;sþIBIkarCYb

RbCuMKñamYyedIm,IBiPakSaedaHRsaybBaðaepSg². karCYbRbCuMKñaenH RtÚv)anKat;erobcMCamunfaeFVIenA

éf¶TI8 Exmifuna. edayehtuenH Kat;)aneRtómxøÜnsRmab;karsnÞnaedayesµaHRtg;mYyCamYy ]b

naykrdæm®nþI lI s‘annan Edldwgc,as;R)akdBIsMNuMÉksarTak;TgnwgCMnYymk[RbeTsevotNam

kñúgzan³Kat;CaGtItédsþaMrbs; CU eGnLay TTYlbnÞúkvis½yesdækic©. b:uEnþelIkenH BuMEmnsnÞnaBI

bBaðaBaküsuMCMnYyrbs;evotNameT. lI )an RbKl;[ dug nUvGnusSarN³mYyEdlCabNþwgsarTukç

BitR)akdRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNamEtmþg. lI )anecaTRbkan;evotNamfa )andwknaMneya)ay

RbqaMgcinTaMgxagBaküsmþIk¾dUcskmµPaB. enAqñaM1975 RbeTscinFøab;)aneFVIsMeNI[mankarebIk

kic©crcaKñaGMBIbBaðaRBMEdnEdr. lI )ansþIbenÞas dug fa «b:uEnþ edayelakRbwgERbgBnüareBlkñúgkar

crcanana elakBuMEdlbBaÄb;karlukluyedayxusc,ab; mkkñúgTwkdIrbs;cineLIy edayelIkmUlehtu

fa cMENkdIRtg;enHb¤Rtg;enaHRtÚv)anmkevotNam. evotNamk¾bgá[mankarRbyuT§reb:Hre):aHnig

begáInGMeBIéRBépSRKb;Ebby:ageTotpg»33.

Kat;)anecaTRbkan;fa cMnYn]bTÞvehtutamRBMEdn)anekIneLIgBI100 elIkenAkñúgqñaM1974

dl;900elIkenAqñaM1976. RbeTsevotNamEdlkalBIedImnigkñúgGMLúgeBlrab;qñaMmkehIy

Føab;)anTTYlsÁal;GFibetyürbs;cinelIRbCMuekaH):ar:aEsl nigRs<atlI enaH )ancUllukluyRbCuM

ekaHTaMgenH enAqñaM1975 edaybegáIt[manPaBtantwgmYyFMCageKbMput. lI k¾benÞasRkúg

haNUypgEdr cMeBaHkarmineKarBBaküsnüarbs;xøÜn edayeRbIkarbgçitbgçMRbqaMgnwgCnCaticin Edl

kMBugsñak;enAevotNamEfmeTot. RkúghaNUyminEdlbeBa©j[dwgnUvGVIEdlCaRbtikmµrbs; dug

esaHeLIy b:uEnþtamBYkcinfa Kat;)ansakl,gniyayedaHsaBIkarbþÚrKMnitPøam²rbs;evotNam

edaysarkarbgçMEdltRmÚvedays®gÁam ³ edayCab;édRbyuT§nwgBYkGaemrikaMgxøaMgeBk nigedayBwgEp¥k

xøaMgelICMnYyrbs;cin RbeTsevotNamBuMmaneBlevlaRKb;RKan;edIm,IKitKUrBIbBaðaekaHTaMgenaHeT.

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 105

Page 116: Brother enemy

karCYbKñaEdleBareBjedayPaBlVIgCUrct;rvagsmmitþkalBIeBlknøgmkfµI²kñúgmhasal

RbCaCnenARkúgeb:kaMg )ankMNt;nUvrbt;CasßaBrmYy. sm½ykalénesckþIKYrsmxøaMg karniyay

bBaäitbeBaäóg nigkarriHKn;epSg²EdlxVHPaBc,as;las;KWElgmanteTAeTotehIy. cab;BIeBlenHeTA

eKRBlHKñaedayeRbIBaküsmþIF¶n;²dak;KñacMmuxEtmþg eKKMramkMEhgKñaCacMh\tlak;elom. kar

Tas;ETgKñaenAminTan;elcecjCasaFarN³Emn b:uEnþeKejjeFµjdak;KñarYceRsceTAehIy.

b:ul Bt begáIterOgeFVI[xVl;citþ

karQøanBand¾bgðÚrQamrbs;ExµrRkhmRbqaMgnigPUminanarbs;evotNam ehIymYyExeRkaymk

KWenAExmifuna dMeNIreTAkan;RbeTscinEdleFVI[keRkIkbnþicbnþÜcrbs;]tþmesnIy_ y:ab nigkarCYbKñad¾

rMeCIbrMCYlrvag paM v:an;dug nig lI s‘annan )aneFVI[RkúghaNUyeCOR)akdkñúgkar)amÖrbs;xøÜnEdl

RtÚvBRgwgsnþisuxpÞal;[rwtEtxøaMgeLIgeTot. evotNamFøab;manCMenOs‘b;dk; Cab;enAkñúgcitþfa snþisux

RbeTsrbs;xøÜnKWTak;Tgy:agCitsñiT§nwgsnþisuxrbs;RbeTsLav nigkm<úCa. RBwtþikarN_epSg²kñúg

ry³eBlBIrExEdlknøgputeTA )annaMmknUvP½sþútagy:ageRcInsRmab;bEnßm[karRBÜy)armÖrbs;xøÜn

rwtEtc,as;eLIg. tammtiGñkyuT§sa®sþevotNamfa ebIsinCaedayKab;CYnmanmhaGMNacCa

sRtÚvmYybegáItcMNgTak;Tgd¾CitsñiT§CamYyRbeTsNamYykñúgcMeNamRbeTsTaMgBIrenaH snþisux

rbs;evotNamnwgeBIbRbTHnUvkarKMramkMEhgy:agF¶n;F¶rminxan. minyUrb:unµaneRkaykarvilRtLb;

rbs;Kat;mkBIRbeTscinvij dug )ancab;eFVIdMeNIrCafµI. elIkenH eKaledArbs;Kat;KWRbeTsLav

CakEnøgEdlKat;)ancuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógmitþPaBmYy. enHCaExSbnÞat;karBarTImYyRbqaMg

nwgkareFVIGnþraKmn_Cayfaehturbs;cinenA\NÐÚcin.

enARkúgevogc½nÞnaRBwkéf¶TI15 ExkkádaenH \sSrCnCan;x<s;mYycMnYnkñúgKN³RbtiPUrbs;evot

Nam)anpþl;nUvshRbtibtþikard¾TUlMTUlayEdleRKagKitedayRbeTsTaMgBIr. eRkABIGKÁelxabkS eL

yn; (Le Duan) nigrdæm®nþITImYy paM v:an;dug mansmaCikkariyal½yneya)ayBIrrUb smaCikKN³kmµa

FikarmCÄimbkSBIrrUb nigm®nþIpøÚvkarCaeRcInrUbeTotk¾)aneFVIdMeNIreTARbeTsepSg²Edr. enHKWCaelIk

dMbUgehIyEdlRbeTsLav)anTTYlsVaKmn_ -ehIyEdlRbeTsevotNambBa¢ÚneTA- nUvKN³RbtiPU

Can;x<s;mYyEbbenH. KN³rdæm®nþILavesÞIrEtTaMgGs;)aneTATTYlsVaKmn_evotNamdl;cMNtGakas

yandæan. kñúgcMeNamenaHk¾man«RBHGgÁm©as;Rkhm»EdlmanBukmat;¬RbFanaFibtI sUpanuvgS¦ nayk

rdæm®nþI éksn PUmivihan rhUtdl;rdæelxaFikar Edlmanzan³tUcTabCageKeTotpg. enAéf¶bnÞab;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg106

Page 117: Brother enemy

karRbCuMhVÚgmhaCny:agFMmYy)anRtÚverobcMeLIgenACitvtþfatlYg CavtþRBHBuT§sasnamYy sRmab;

eFVIkarsVaKmn_cMeBaHePJóvCasaFarN³. b:uEnþkñúghVÚgmhaCnEdlRbmUlpþú¿edaybkSenATIenaH etIGñk

NamYyEdlyl;BitR)akdBIGtßn½yénBaküsmþIEdlEføgedaynaykrdæm®nþI?. éksn PUmivihan

)anrMB£kBIkareFVI[braC½ynUv«RKb;Epnkark,t;nigRbkbedayl,ickl RBmTaMgGMeBIviecäTkmµepSg²

EdlGuCGaledayBYkcRkBtþi nigBYkbrivarrbs;vanigBYkRbtikiriya ehIy)ansgát;bBa¢ak;BIPaB

caM)ac;xanmin)anedIm,IeFVIGVI²RKb;y:agsMedABRgwgÉkPaBd¾RCaleRCACamYyevotNamsgÁmniym[

rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgeTot»34.

naykrdæm®nþI éksn )anniyayedomdamedaymincMeBaHdl; «EpnkarRbkbedayBisBul»

rbs;RbeTscin nigExµrRkhmEdlmaneKaledAbMpøajTMnak;TMngBiessrbs;evotNamCamYybNþa

RbeTsCitxagenA\NÐÚcin. kartbvijPøam²rYmKñacMeBaH «EpnkarTaMgenaH» RtÚv)anbgðaj[dwgenA

RBwkéf¶TI18 Exkkáda. munnwgcakecjeTARkúghaNUyvij evotNam)ancuHhtßelxaCamYyRbeTs

LavelIsn§isBaØamitþPaBnigshRbtibtþikarmYy. RbeTsTaMgBIrRtÚvEt «rYbrYmKñaCanic©kñúgkarksag

nigkarkarBarRbCaCatirbs;xøÜn».

maRta1énsn§isBaØaenH EdlseRmcsRmab;eBl25qñaM )anbgÁab;edaydac;xat[PaKITaMgBIr

RtÚv «eFVI[RbCaCnnigbkSerog²xøÜnyl;BItémøEdlRBmeRBógKñaedayykcitþTukdak;cMeBaHTMnak;TMng

RbkbedayÉksiT§irvagRbeTsevotNamnigRbeTsLav edaykarKaMBarnigkarCYyCMrujTMnak;TMngenH

edIm,IEfrkSakMu[manmnÞilnigKµan]bsKÁmkraraMgCaerogrhUt». xsMxan;enH maneKalbMNgCmñH[

)annUvkarmincUlcitþ ¬edaymindwgerOgGVI¦ rbs;RbCaCnLavcMeBaHevotNam nigbgáarkarelceLIg

nUvKMnitceg¥ótcg¥l;niymmYy ¬karkan;eCIgCatimatuPUmiRCúlhYsehtu¦ nigKMnitminTukcitþeKÉgmYy

dUcEdlvaRtÚveFVI[BuHke®Ba¢alxøaMgenARbeTskm<úCarYcmkehIy. fVIt,itEtbBaðakarBarRbeTsenAEt

CakarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;rdænImYy²k¾eday k¾maRta2 Ecgfa RbeTsTaMgBIr«KaMRTnigCYyKñaeTAvijeTA

mkeday\tlkçxNл nig «shkard¾CitsñiT§ edIm,IbegáInsmtßPaBkarBar nigKaMBarrkSaÉkraCüPaB

GFibetyüPaB nigbUrNPaBEdndIrbs;xøÜn nigkemÞcral;EpnkarnigskmµPaBbMpøicbMpøajEdlGnuvtþ

edayBYkcRkBtþinigkmøaMgRbtikiriyaTaMgGs;enARbeTseRkA»35.

sn§isBaØamitþPaB nigkic©RBmeRBógbnÞab;bnSMCaeRcInEdlcuHhtßelxaCabnþbnÞab;mkeTot )an

begáItCamUldæaneBjlkçN³c,ab;kñúgkarshkarEpñkneya)ayd¾CitsñiT§mYynigGnuBaØat[mankar

BwgEp¥krbs;RbeTsLavcMeBaHRbeTsevotNamGMBIvis½ysnþisuxpg. GVI²TaMgGs;)anmanGtßiPaB

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 107

Page 118: Brother enemy

eTAtamRBwtþin½y ¬tamdMeNIrkarEdlmanrYcmkehIy¦ taMgBIkarbegáItsaFarNrdæLavemø:H. sn§isBaØa

enH)anrMB£kRbeTscin nigkm<úCa[dwgCamunfa RkúghaNUyseRmccitþrkSa]tþmPaBrbs;xøÜnenA

\NÐÚcinehIy fVIebImankarRbqaMgCMTas;nwgxøÜnk¾eday. tamBit eRkaykarvayRbharCaeRcInelIk

rbs;km<úCa karEsVgrkTMnak;TMngEdlmanÉksiT§iCamYyRbeTsLav nigkm<úCa )ankøayeTACabBaða

GaTiPaBmYy ehIyk¾BuMEmnCaTsSnvis½yRbeyalmYyEdr.

sRmab; b:ul Bt sn§isBaØaevotNam-Lav )aneFVI[GVI²EdlGaRkk;bMputeTACac,as;las;

eLIg. RbeTsevotNam)anseRmccitþbnÞab;BIraErky:agyUrnig)ancab;epþImGnuvtþKMnitRsemIRsém

BIshB½n§d¾cas;KMrwlrbs;xøÜn. eKKµansgS½yeLIyfa mhicätarbs;evotNamKW «deNþImykRbeTs

km<úCaTaMgmUledaykmøaMg nigbBa©ÚleTAkñúgshB½n§mYyrbs;\NÐÚcin ehIykñúgeKaledAenH k¾edIm,I

CYysRmÜlkareFVIGenþaRbevsn_rbs;CnCatievotNamrab;ryBan;nak;EfmTaMgrab;lannak;Caerogral;

qñaMmkkan;km<úCapg». b:ul Bt )anniyayR)ab;GñksarB½t’manyUehÁasøavIenAExmIna qñaM1978

Casm¶at;fa ebIsinCaRkúghaNUyseRmceKalbMNgrbs;xøÜnEmnenaH «RbCaCnkm<úCanwgkøayeTA

CaCnCatiPaKticFmµtamYyminxan»36. sn§isBaØaenHCasBaØaR)ab;[dwgfa RbeTsevotNam)an

seRmccitþP¢ab;RbeTskm<úCaCarNbrbs;xøÜnrYcCaeRsc37.

saFarNCnKµandwgTal;EtesaHBIkarERkrEGgxusTMng Edlsn§isBaØaenHjúaMg[ b:ul Bt cg;

ykKMnittam. kñúgbTykkarN_xøImYysRmab;TsSnkic©rbs;evotNamenARbeTsLav viTüúRkúgPñMeBj

RKan;EtniyaybBaäitbeBaäógminc,as;las; cMeBaHkaremIlgay\tjejItjejIm EdljúaMg[

RbeTsevotNam pusKMniteKarBGFibetyüPaBRbeTsCitxagxøÜn edaykMNt;karRBmeRBógRtwmEt

fñak;kugs‘ulb:ueNÑaH GaRs½yedayGMNacénm®nþIpøÚvkarrbs;Lav nigevotNam Edl«nwgRtÚvGnuBaØat

[qøgkat;RBMEdnedaymincaM)ac;manTidæakar»38.

kareRsIbRsalcitþrbs;GñkQñH

enAéf¶TI17 Exkkáda qñaM1977 Caéf¶EdlBYkemdwknaMevotNamcuHhtßelxaenAxageRkamsn§i

sBaØaRsbeTAtamTsSnkic©rbs;xøÜnenARkúgevogc½nÞenaH BYkkmµaPi)alCan;x<s;énk,alm:asuIndwknaMbkS

sRmab;PaKbUB’akm<úCa)anCYbRbCuMKñaCasm¶at; edIm,IkMNt;yuT§sa®sþrbs;xøÜnRbqaMgnwgevotNam.

enHCakarKab;CYnmYyKYr[q¶l;. esckþIseRmccitþEdlRbkan;ykkñúg»kasénkarRbCuMenaH minRtÚv

)anpSBVpSay[dwgCasaFarN³eLIyTal;EtCaeRcInExeRkaymkeTot eTIbsMeNAedIménkMNt;ehtu

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg108

Page 119: Brother enemy

RbCuM)anFøak;kñúgkNþab;édevotNam kñúgGMLúgénRbtibtþikare)assm¥atmYyenARbeTskm<úCa. BYk

kmµaPi)alExµrRkhmRbEhlCadwgfa RbeTsevotNamenAEtciBa©wm«mhicätaexµAggwtkñúgkarvay

deNþImykTwkdIrbs;eyIg nigkemÞcBUCsasn_Exµr[sabsUnüCanic©». edayehtuenH TMnas;rvagrdæ

«BuMGacedaHRsaytampøÚvneya)ay)aneLIy». edayniyayedomdamRtg;²cMeBaHkmµaPi)alTaMg

LayEdlrgeRKaHBIkare)assm¥atCaeRcIn eRBaHEtbdiesFminedIrtammaK’aRbqaMgevotNamrbs;

xøÜnenaH karedaHRsaybBaða)anecaTCasMNYrfa «etIeyIgeCOfa GacedaHRsay [TMnas;CamYy

evotNam] edayGnuvtþtammaK’arbs;bkSeyIg b¤yktRmab;tamPaBkMsakrbs;Rkúmk,t;Edllut

CgÁg;enAmuxBYkyYn ehIydak;xøÜnCa´kBa¢Hva? eyIgRtÚvEtlt;dMxøÜn[rwgbuwgnigminRtÚvERbkøayxøÜneTACa

´kBa¢HyYndac;xat».

GtßbTénkMNt;ehtuRbCuM )anCMruj[yuT§CnTaMgGs;eRtómxøÜnkemÞcevotNamCanic© kñúgkrNI

EdlmankarQøanBancUlkm<úCa. «ebIsinCaevotNamRbfuypSgeRBgcUlmkkñúgTwkdIrbs;eyIg

eyIgminRtwmEtRtÚvbBaÄb;nigsmøab;BYkvab:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþeyIgRtÚvEtcat;kar[)anmun ehIyqøgkat;

RBMEdn edIm,IkemÞcBYkvaenAkñúgTwkdIpÞal;rbs;vakñúgeKaledAeFVI[PaBkøahanrbs;vacuHexSaynigbegáIn

karP½yxøacEdlvamandUcEteyIgEdr. minyUrb:unµaneRkaykarvayRbhar BYkvanwgElgh‘ancUllukluy

RbeTseyIg ehIydl;eBlEdlvaRtÚvkarBarTb;Tl;vijmþg»39.

esckþIseRmccitþBuM)anpþl;nUvPaBCak;lak;NamYycMeBaHGVIEdlnwgkøayeTACaeKaledArbs;

ExµrRkhm EdlevotNamFøab;vaybM)ak;[enARtwmEtkarkarBarTb;Tl;mþgmkehIyeT. b:uEnþcab;BIedIm

qñaM1977 smaCikxøHkñúgcMeNamGñkenACuMvij b:ul Bt EdlrkSaKMnithYsehturYcmkehIykñúgkar

c,aMgdeNþImykkm<úCaeRkam ¬RbeTskm<úCaPaKxageRkamsBVéf¶KWEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁ¦nigéRBnKr40

mkkan;kab;vij )anelIkkmøaMgcitþkgT½Brbs;xøÜn[eFVIkarts‘URbqaMgnwgevotNam.

etI b:ul Bt Kitfa yuT§Cnekµg²rbs;xøÜnEdlRbdab;edaysmÖarswkminRKb;RKan;Gacman

smtßPaBykC½yCmñHelIRbeTsevotNamR)akdEmnb¤? Kat;manCMenOdUc em:A Edr GMBI]tþmPaB

rbs;mnusSCageTAelIrfeRkaH-rfBasEdknigGavuF. RbkarenHRtÚv)anbEnßmedaylT§iCatiniym

ceg¥ótcg¥l;d¾RkGWtRkeGagrbs;ExµrRkhm EdlpÞúkeTAedayCMenOmingayregÁaHregÁImYycMeBaH

RbCaCati vIrPaBd¾emaHmutnigsmtßPaBepSg²rbs;xøÜnpg. b:ul Bt )anEføgRbkasenAExkBaØa qñaM

1977fa «ebIRbCaCneyIgmansmtßPaBsßabnaR)asaTGgÁrvtþ)an Kat;k¾GaceFVIGVI²RKb;y:ag)an

Edr». Kat;)anseRmceCaKC½ykñúgkarjúaMg[eKeCOfa ExµrRkhm)anvayQñHshrdæGaemrikTaMg

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 109

Page 120: Brother enemy

Rsug ehIyFøab;CYyevotNam[deNþIm)anC½yCmñHpÞal;rbs;xøÜnEfmeTot. GVI²GaceFVI)anTaMgGs;

bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHmYyEdleFVI[esJIbrMePIbdUecñH. tamTsSn³ b:ul Bt fa BYkkgT½Brbs;RbeTsevotNam

vatTI nwgminmansmtßPaBdUckgT½Brbs;km<úCa EdlsuxcitþbUCaxøÜncMeBaHbuBVehtud¾RtwmRtÚvmYyrbs;

CatiesaHeLIy. kmøaMgrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüsßitenARtg;PaBbrisuT§xagmenaKmviC¢arbs;kgT½B

nigGgÁkarmUldæanTaMgLayrbs;xøÜn. kñúgsm½yRbCuMmYyrbs;bkS Kat;)anbBa¢ak;dUecñHfa «ebIsinCa

eyIgerobcMtRmwmtRmg;kgT½B[)anl¥RtwmRtÚv ´eCOfa eyIgGacykC½yCmñHelIGaNÑam¬RbeTs

evotNam¦)an BIeRBaHsgÁmeyIgCasgÁmsmUhniymmYy enAeBlEdlsgÁmrbs;evotNameFVImin

)anseRmcdUceyIg ehIyc,as;CaGnþrayedaykarRcbUkRcbl; nigkarKµansNþab;Fñab;EdlbgáeLIg

edaysarrbbkmµsiT§iÉkCn»41.

RbEhledaysar«eCaKC½y»Edl)anmkedayyuT§Cnrbs;xøÜntaMgBIExemsa qñaM1977 KWkar

kemÞcbMpøajPUmiCaeRcInrbs;evotNam nigkarsmøab;rgÁalRbCaCnsuIvil kñúg»kasénkarvayqµk;CaeRcIn

elIkedaymin[dwgxøÜnmun RBmTaMgkarKµanRbtikmµrbs;evotNamenaHehIyEdlCMruj[ b:ul Bt man

CMenOTukcitþmYyEbbenH. RkúghaNUyRtÚvRbQmmuxnwgkarxVHxates,ógGahard¾F¶n;F¶rmYy vibtþisgÁm

d¾RCaleRCAmYyenAPaKxagt,Úg nigkartsU‘edayGavuFénRkúmepSg² EdlkñúgenaHy:agehacman

clnamYyKW «rNsirSrYbrYmedIm,Ikarts‘Urbs;BUCsasn_EdleKCiHCan;» eyIgFøab;B¤eKehABYkenHfa

BYkhVúlr:U² [tamGkSkat;CaPasa)araMgfa F.U.L.R.O. (Front Uni pour la Lutte des Races Opprimées)]

EdlTTYlKuNRbeyaCn_BIkarCYyKaMRTrbs;ExµrRkhmEdr ehIykarlM)akTaMgenH RbEhlCaeFVI[

RbeTskm<úCamancitþemaHmutKµanekatjejItdUecñH.

eKGHGagfarbb b:ul Bt )anQandl;eFVIesckþIseRmcfa dMeNaHRsayedaykarcrcamYy

sþIBICemøaHTwkdICamYyRbeTsevotNam KWBuMGaceFVI)aneLIy. edIm,IFanaÉkraCüPaB nigbUrNPaBTwkdI

rbs;RbeTs b:ul Bt minRBmriHrkmeFüa)ayNaepSgeRkAEtBIkarbgðajkmøaMgT½BenAtambeNþay

RBMEdnnigkareBalGHGagCasaFarN³nUvkarTamTarrbs;xøÜnGMBIRBMEdnsmuRTeLIy. kñúg»kasénkic©

crcabBaðaRBMEdnenAEx]sPa qñaM1976 GñkcrcaevotNam pan; ehon minRBmTTYlsÁal;ExSbnÞat;

eRbvIeysRmab;eFVICaeKalvinicä½yedIm,IkMNt;RBMEdnsmuRTeT. edayelIkeTAéf¶eRkay kic©crcasþIBI

erOgenHminEdl)anebIkeFVIeLIgvijTal;EtesaH. enAéf¶TI12 Ex]sPa qñaM1977 RkúghaNUy )an

niyay[dwgfa tMbn;esdækic©rbs;xøÜnlatsn§wgBIeqñreTAlMhsmuRTrhUtdl;200ém:l_ ¬RbEhl

320KILÚEm:Rt¦42.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg110

Page 121: Brother enemy

ebITukCaevotNamRbkaseRtómxøÜn «EsVgrkdMeNaHRsaytamkic©crcaCamYyRbeTsBak;B½n§

TaMgGs;sþIBIbBaðaepSg²Tak;TgeTAnwgtMbn;smuRTnigtMbn;x<g;rab)atsmuRT edayQrelImUldæanén

kareKarBÉkraCüPaB nigGFibetyüPaBeTAvijeTAmk nigeTAtamc,ab;GnþrCati»k¾eday k¾RbeTskm<úCa

mineCOBIerOgenHEdr. TsSnavdþI«km<úCaRbCaFibetyüQaneTAmux»RbcaMExsIha qñaM1977 Edl

CaTsSnavdþId¾RbNItsRmab;kareXasnaenAbreTsenaH )ane)aHBum<EpnTIRbeTskm<úCamYy. cMNuc

EtmYyEdlKYrkt;smÁal;CageKKW ExSbnÞat;cuc²mYy ¬ExSbnÞat;eRbvIey¦ enAelIEpnTIEdleKKUskat;

QUgsmuRTéf KWsRmab;smÁal;faenHCaRBMEdnsmuRTrbs;km<úCa. enHKWCacemøIyrbs;RkúgPñMeBj

cMeBaHkarcg;)anEdnsmuRTrbs;evotNam.

enAéf¶TI30 Exkkáda GñkeFVIGtßaFib,aymñak;énviTüúRkúgPñMeBj)anrMB£kfa kalBIeBlknøgmk BYk

«bnk,t;kan;GMNac» enAkm<úCaBuMecHRbqaMgtbtcMeBaHkarrMelaPbMBanCaeRcInelIkmkelIEdnsmuRT

rbs;xøÜneLIyedaysgát;bBa¢ak;fa vaBuMdUcKñaeTkñúg«dMNak;kalbdivtþn_bc©úb,nñ EdlecHkarBarnig

ksagRbeTs». edayerobrab;eQµaHekaHTaMgLayEdlRtÜtRtaedaykgT½Bbdivtþn_km<úCa bTGtßa

Fib,ay)anRBman[dwgBIkarebþCJacitþ RbqaMg«RKb;karQøanBanTaMgGs;mkelIbNþaekaH nigRKb;kar

eRCótcUlEdnTwkrbs;xøÜn EdlecjmkBIsRtÚvmYycMnYnTaMgq¶ayTaMgCiteTaHCasRtÚvNak¾eday43.

eBlevladl;ehIy edIm,Ipþl;karRBmand¾xÞrxÞarmYycMeBaHRkúghaNUy».

karGHGagbEnßmenARkúgeb:kaMg

enAéf¶TI28 ExkBaØa qñaM1977 KMnitsuTidæiniymd¾Cak;lak;mYy)ansßitmanenAmYyry³enARkúg

eb:kaMg. enHCaelIkdMbUgbMputtaMgBIyUrmkehIy EdlTIRkúgenHCakEnøgmanR)arB§BiFIFM²dUecñH.

qñaM1976 )anepþImeLIgedaymrNPaBrbs; CU eGnLay. bnÞab;mkmanRBwtþikarN_CabnþbnÞab;Kña KW

claclEpñkneya)ay karrBa¢ÜydIEdlbNþal[mnusSsøab;y:ageRcIn mrNPaBrbs; em:A esTug nig

karpøas;bþÚr\sSrCnneya)ayCafµId¾KYr[PJak;ep¥IlmYy. RbeTscinEdlRtÚveFVI[KaMgclnaBak;kNþal

)andkdegðImFMbn§ÚrPaBtantwgkñúgcitþ edaykardYlrlMrbs;BYkr:aDIkal; b:uEnþtamkarBit cinmanehtupl

epSg²eTotkñúgkarsEmþgTwkcitþrIkraytictYcEdr. enAéf¶TI1 Extula qñaM1977 manR)arB§BiFIbuNü

xYbelIkTI28 énkMeNItsaFarNrdæRbCamanitciny:agGFikGFm. enHsuT§EtCabNþaBiFIbuNüFM²Ca

pøÚvkarelIkdMbUgkñúgRbeTscineRkaysm½y em:A ehIyenHk¾Ca»kasEdleKmin)anrg;caMmunnUvkar

elcmuxCaGnþrCatielIkdMbUgrbs;emdwknaMkm<úCamñak; EdleKminFøab;EdleXIjmuxesaHrhUtmkTl;nwg

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 111

Page 122: Brother enemy

eBlenH ehIyk¾CakarGHGagbEnßmBIsm<½n§PaBcin-km<úCa CasaFarN³pgEdr. minRtwmEtedIm,IrMB£k

buNüCatirbs;cinb:ueNÑaHeT eRBaHenAelIevTika eKeXIjmanTg;CatiBN’RkhmelOgrbs;km<úCa

RbCaFibetyübk;rvic²kNþalTg;CaticinCaeRcIn. cegáógeKamCaeRcInenAtamrukçvifIqagGan Edl

enAbeNþayviman La Porte de la Paix Céleste RBmnwgGMBUlePøIgFM²BN’smanragpáaQUkk¾manedatTg;

Catirbs;sm<n§miRtGasuITaMgBIrEdr. kUnsisSrab;rynak;EdlCaGñkkan;b:g;kat manlabBN’cRmúHenA

QrpþúMKñaTaMgsgxagTVarcUl. tamkar[sBaØa BYkkUnsisSTaMgenH)anelIkRKvIb:g;katputBIk,al Edl

mansresrGkSrcin nigExµrfa «sVaKmn_». BlrdæRkúgeb:kaMgcMnYndb;muWnnak; )anRtÚveKekNÐRbmUl

edIm,I[eTAERskCyeXasGbGrsaTrbNþaePJóvBiessrbs;xøÜn BlrdæTaMgenaH)anQrCarbgy:ag

EvgminecHputmYy enAxagmuxGakasyandæannigtambeNþayrukçvifIqagGan. b:uEnþ eTaHCaPaKeRcInén

hVÚgmnusSrayrgEdlRbmUlpþúMKñaenATIenaH BuMKitBIGtþsBaØaNBYkePJóvEdlxøÜnRtÚvpþl;kitþiysbnþic

esaHk¾eday k¾karerobcMTaMgenHlµmRKb;RKan;bBa¢ak;[eXIjfa ePJóvTaMgenaHsuT§EtCamhamitþrbs;

RbeTscinehIy.

RBwkenaH enAeBlEdlCnCatiExµrmñak;RbkbedayTwkmuxjjwmBRBay kat;sk;RCg nigesøók

Bak;exaGavBN’etñatcas;rebob em:A elcmuxecjBIynþehaHb‘UGuIg-707 mYyeRKÓgrbs;cin Gaf’

kM)aMgmYyRCúgEdlruMB½T§CuMvijBYkemdwknaMExµrRkhm RtÚv)anebIkecjmYyEpñk. eRBaHfa mnusSmñak;

enHEdlCaemdwknaMkMBUlrbs;bdivtþn_km<úCa ehIyEdlKµanGñkNamYyFøab;)aneXIjmuxCasaFarN³

esaHenaHmaneQµaHfa b:ul Bt. enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1976 eBlEdlviTüúPñMeBj)anRbkaspSayCa

saFarN³fa naykrdæm®nþIkm<úCaRbCaFibetyümaneQµaHfa b:ul Bt enaH karsikSaRsavRCavGMBIGtþ

sBaØaNBitR)akdrbs;mnusSEdleKminsÁal;TaMgRsugenH )anRbRBwtþeTAy:agqab;rh½s. bYnEx

bnÞab;BIkarEtgtaMgrUbKat; Gaf’kM)aMgERbeTACakan;EtggwteLIg²EfmeTot enAeBlEdleKdwgfa Kat;

)andkxøÜnfyCabeNþaHGasnñedaysarmUlehtusuxPaB. eKElgB¤GñkNamñak;niyayBIKat;eTot

ehIy rhUtTal;EtKat;edIrCan;elIkRmalRBMRkhmenAGakasyandæanRkúgeb:kaMg. enATIbMput mnusS

EdlKµanGñkNasÁal;)anelcmuxTaMgsac;TaMgq¥wgEtmþg eRkamkarykcitþTukdak;BImtisaFarN³

GnþrCatiy:ageRcIn. edaybeBa©jsñamjjwmy:agRss;mYyeBlcuHBIelIynþehaH b:ul Bt )ancab;

rlak;édKñaeTAvijeTAmkCamYynaykrdæm®nþI nigRbFanbkSrbs;cin hVa KUehVg y:agkk;ekþAbMput.

emdwknaMCan;x<s;R)aMbInak;RbEhlmYyPaKbIénsmaCikkariyal½yneya)ayd¾man\T§iBlxøaMgbMputkñúg

cMeNamenaHman etg s‘avBIg Edl)anpþl;siT§iGMNaceLIgvijkalBIeBlfµI²)aneTACYbCuMKñaenA

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg112

Page 123: Brother enemy

Gakasyandæan edIm,IsEmþg[eXIjnUvmitþPaBd¾RCaleRCAEdlkMBugbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTscinnigkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyü. enAeBlEdl b:ul Bt nig hVa QrEk,rKñaelIrfynþebIkdMbUlmYyeRKÓg eFVIdMeNIr

tamrukçvifIqagGan hVÚgRbCaCn)anvayKgeXµaHlan;rMBg RKvITg;CatiRkdasénkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

nigRBElgbuWte):agrab;ry[ehaHeTAkñúgGakas. karTHédGbGrsaTr)anlan;B¤RThwgGWgkgGm

tamdMeNIrqøgkat;énk,ÜndEgðCakitþiys.

kñúg»kasénsnñisITkaEstmYyenARkúgeb:kaMg CamYybNþajGñksarB½t’mancin b:ul Bt )aneFVI

esckþIsegçbxøImYysþIBICIvitbdivtþn_rbs;Kat; b:uEnþ KµaneBlNamYyEdlKat;niyayfa Kat;CaGñkNa

eLIy. edayeRbóbeFobrUbftCaeRcIn nigesckþIerobrab;xøH²BICIvRbvtþirbs;Kat; GñkÉkeTsCaeRcIn

)anseRmceFVIkarsnñidæanfa b:ul Bt nigemdwknaMkumµúynIsþeQµaH saLút s Edl)at;muxBIPñMeBj enA

qñaM1963 KWCamnusSEtmYy. eRkABImitþcin kUer:xageCIgnigGñkÉkeTsbreTsmYykþab;tUc KµanGñkNa

mñak;dwgfa b:ul Bt enArg;caMbBa©b;kare)assm¥atRbLak;eTAedayQamEdl)andwknaMeFVIeBjfirevla

mYyqñaMRbqaMgnwgsRtÚvrbs;Kat;EdlBitR)akd b¤EdlRKan;EtsgS½ykñúgépÞbkS[cb;sin eTIbKat;

ecjBITIggwteT. eBlenHKat;dwgfa mansnþisuxRKb;RKan;ehIy edIm,Ibgðaj[BiPBelakdwgB¤BIGtßiPaB

énbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaEdllak;muxtaMgBIyUryarNas;mkehIy eRkamr)aMgGnamikfa «GgÁkar» nig

edIm,IepþImeFVIdMeNIreTAbreTsCaelIkdMbUgrbs;Kat;kñúgzan³CaGKÁelxabkSnigCanaykrdæm®nþIpg.

kñúgBiFIbuNüd¾G‘åkGFwkepSg²Edlpþl;CUnkñúg»kasbuNüCatirbs;cin enAevlal¶acéf¶TI1 Extula

b:ul Bt CaePJóvkitþiys )aneFVIb£kBaCaGñkFMedayQrenAEk,rRbFanbkS hVa KUehVg elIevTikakitþiys

ehIy)anEføgsresIrBIkaMRCÜcEdleK)aj;eTotpg. kñúgcMeNamePJóvbreTsdéT²eTotEdlman

vtþmanenAl¶acenaH eKsegáteXIjman hYg v:an;h‘n; Edr. fVId,itEtKat;RtÚvbeNþjecjBIKN³kmµa

FikarmCÄimbkSk¾eday k¾Kat;enAEtCaGnuRbFansPaCatievotNamdEdl. mindwgfaetIKat; ¬h‘n;¦

man»kas)anCYbBiPakSaedayKµansakSICamYy b:ul Bt edIm,IEsVgyl;munbg¥s;GMBIkarTietond¾

CUrct;rbs;km<úCaEdrb¤k¾Gt;eT pÞúyeTAvij edIm,ICRmab b:ul Bt GMBIrebobvinicä½yrbs;BYkemdwknaM

evotNampg b:uEnþKMnitenHmanlkçN³Tak;Tajcitþy:agxøaMg edayehtufa BIrqñaMeRkaymk h‘n; )aneFVI

[BiPBelakPJak;ep¥IlRsLaMgkaMg eRBaHKat;)ankøayeTACaemdwknaMCan;x<s;evotNamdMbUgbMput Edl

cuHcUlnwgRbeTscin ehIy)anefáaleTasneya)ayrbs;RkúghaNUycMeBaHRbeTskm<úCaEfmeTot.

kñúgsunÞrkfaepSg²Kña EdlKat;EføgenARkúgeb:kaMg kñúg»kasBiFICb;elogb¤snñisITkaEst b:ul

Bt EtgniyaybBaäitbeBaäógeTArkkarc,aMgdeNþImykTwkdIkm<úCaxøHkalBIGtItedayBYkéfnigevot

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 113

Page 124: Brother enemy

NamEdlCaGñkCitxag. R)akdNas;fa eQµaHevotNamEtgpuseLIgkñúgKMnitKat;Canic©enAeBlEdl

Kat;Rbkasfa «eyIgnwgminGt;»n[karQøanBan karbgáehtu kareRCótERCk kareFVIviT§gSna b¤skmµ

PaBQøbykkarN_NamYyRbqaMgnwgkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü nigRbCaCneyIgeLIy eTaHCaecjBIRbPB

Nak¾eday». Kat;)anbEnßmeTotfa «rbbbdivtþn_km<úCamankrNIykic©karBarRBMEdnrbs;xøÜn

ehIyeFVIy:agNa[Tal;EtRBMEdnTaMgenHminRtÚv)anesIerIeLIgvijCadac;xat»44.

kñúgeBleFVIkarpøas;bþÚreyabl;KñaCasm¶at;CamYybNþaemdwknaMcin b:ul Bt )anrMB£kR)ab;GMBI

skmµPaBvaylukRbqaMgRbeTsevotNamCayfaehtuEfmeTot KWminRtwmEtkarBarxøÜnb:ueNÑaHeT.

Kat;)anniyayR)ab; hVa nigemdwknaMcindéTeTotCasm¶at;fa tamKat;yl; Twkcitþrbs;kgT½BevotNam

enAmankRmitTabNas; ehIyTahanrbs;evotNammansPaBhak;dUcCaBuMGacRTaMRTnwgkarxVHxat

eLIy. Kat;)anniyayfa «kñúgsßanPaBTaMgenH RKan;Etclnabdivtþn_enAGasuIGaeKñy_ begáInkarvay

Rbharrbs;xøÜnEtbnþic sßankarN_muxCavivtþpþl;PaBGnueRKaHminxan ehIyenAeBlenaH eyIgnwgGac

edaHRsaybBaðaepSg²rbs;eyIg)an». Kat;)anbMPøWR)ab;BYkcinfa «bkSrbs;km<úCa)anpøas;bÚþr

TsSn³Kñay:ageRcInGMBIbBaðaenHCamYybNþabkSrbs;éf \NÐÚensuI m:aeLsuI nig PUma ehIybkSTaMg

enaHsuT§EtsEmþgmtiyl;RsbCamYyKat;Edr. b:ul Bt snñidæanfa «eTaHCaenAmanbBaðaCaeRcInEdl

RtÚvCmñHBuHBar[)anmunnwgQaneTAdl;eKaledArbs;eyIgk¾eday k¾eyIgGacsMGagelIkarKaMRTrbs;

mitþcinenAPaKxageCIg ehIyenAGasuI-GaeKñy_eyIgGaceFVI[manmtiÉkPaBEtmYysRmab;Capl

RbeyaCn_rbs;eyIg. karERbRbÜlCayuT§sa®sþenHKWCakarelIkkmøaMgcitþd¾FMeFgcMeBaHeyIg»45.

Éksarsm¶at;epSg²Edllak;)aMgmin[dwgenARkúgeb:kaMg)anbgðaj[eXIjeRkaymkeTotfa

b:ul Bt minEdl[témøhYsehtuBITMhMénkarKaMRTrbs;cinesaHeLIy. edayBit kñúgr)aykarN_sm¶at;

mYysþIBIsßankarN_GnþrCatiEdl hYg hY EføgenAmuxKN³kmµaFikarmYyrbs;bkSenAéf¶TI30 Exkkáda

qñaM1977 )anedAbBa¢ak;fa karkm©at;BYkPñak;gareRCótcUlénlT§iesIerIniymsUevotEdlepþImeFVIeday

b:ul Bt KWCaviFankarRtwmRtÚvmYy BIeRBaHva«)aneFVI[kgT½Brbs;Kat;s¥atbrisuT§R)ascakPaBBukrlYy

nigCYyBRgwgsmtßPaBRbyuT§rbs;kgT½BEfmeTot». hY )ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa kare)assm¥atTaMgenH

rYmnwgkarbdiesFrbs;km<úCaminTTYlykGaNaBüa)alrbs;evotNam nigCemøaHEpñkmenaKmviC¢a

rvagRbeTsTaMgBIr)annaMeTAdl;karbgá[manPaBCasRtÚvnwgKñaBitR)akd. ebITukCa hYg hY niyay

erobrab;bBa©ÚlBIkareRCótERCkmYyrbs;sUevotk¾eday k¾Kat;nwkKitEfmeTotBIRbeTsevotNam

edayrMB£kBIyfaPaBéns®gÁammYyrvagRbeTskm<úCanigBYkesIerIniym. Kat;)aneBalGHGagfa «CYn

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg114

Page 125: Brother enemy

kals®gÁamRtwmRtÚvmYyGacebIk»kas[mankarBRgwg]tþmPaBmçag² ehIys®gÁampþac;RB½RtmYy KW

CameFüa)ayGacedaHRsaybBaðaTaMgGs;». témøEdlRtÚvbg;KWF¶n;F¶rCaTIbMput b:uEnþlT§plEdl)an

mkk¾esµInwgkarRbwgERbgenaHEdr. tammtiKat;fa RbeTscinBuMGacsßitenAes¶ómedayminbeBa©j

RbtikmµnigGt;»ncMeBaHkarecaT[manbBaðaeLIgvijedayBYkesIerIniymsUevotGMBIGFibetyüPaB

rbs;km<úCaeLIy ³ «eyIgKaMRTy:agmuWgm:at;nUvkarseRmcrbs;RbCaCati nigRbCaCnkm<úCakñúgkartsU‘

Tl;nwglT§isgÁmcRkBtþiniym (Social-impérialisme) ehIyeyIgnwgpþl;CMnYyRKb;Ebby:agtamEdleyIg

manlT§PaBpþl;[»46.

vaBi)akbMPøW[c,as;faetIkarsnüaEdleFVI[PJak;ep¥IlenH CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;«s®gÁamRtwmRtÚv»

mYy qøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjBICMhrCaÉkcä½nÞrbs;RkúmemdwknaMcinb¤mYyfa etIenHCalkçN³sBaØaénGtß

RbeyaCn_EdlRbkan;ykedayBYkem:Aniymkñúgkarts‘UEdlbnþeFVI[BYkenHRbqaMgnwgBYkRbtibtþiniym

Nas;. KµanÉksarNamYyrbs;cin EdlmanmkenAeBleRkayeTotrMlwkedayc,as;las;BIesckþI

RbkasenHeLIy ehIyb:unµanExeRkaymk emdwknaMcinniymkNþalmñak;)anRbwgERbgrm¶ab;neya)ay

pSgeRBgRbqaMgevotNamrbs;ExµrRkhmEdr. dUecñH GVI²TaMgGs;)aneFVI[eKKitfa enAniTaXrdUvqñaM

1977 karKaMRTcMeBaH b:ul Bt KWCaTegVIrbs;bkSBYkeqVgniymy:agBitR)akd.

b:uEnþenAbreTsKµanmnusSNamñak;dwgBI\T§iBlénkareRbIl,ic nig])aykledaycMeBaHénneya

)ayenAkñúgRbeTscin sþIBIbBaðaénkarKaMRTcMeBaHRbeTskm<úCaTal;EtesaH. sRmab;BiPBxageRkA

xøwmsarenHKWmann½yc,as;las;bMput karlatRtdagrbs;kaEstbs©imRbeTs karsmøab;rgÁal Edl

RbRBwtþeLIgenAkm<úCaKµanGVITak;TajbnþicesaH edayRbeTscinenAEtesµaHRtg;cMeBaHbNþasm<½n§mitþ

rbs;xøÜndEdl. hY )anRbkaskñúgBiFICb;elogmYyfa «vIrRbCaCnkm<úCaminRtwmEtseRmceCaKC½y

kñúgkarkemÞcsgÁmcas;b:ueNÑaHeT Etk¾bgðaj[eXIjfa xøÜnk¾ecHksagsgÁmfµImYypgEdr». rwtEt

c,as;las;CagenH TukNaCaPasaEdlKat;eRbIkñúgmCÄdæanedayELkEdlBnül;minekItk¾eday k¾Kat;

)anEføgsresIrcMeBaHkare)assm¥atepSg² nigkarQøanBanRbqaMgevotNamCaeRcInelIk Edl

epþImeFVIeday b:ul Bt Edr.Kat;)ansEmþgesckþIGbGrsaTrcMeBaHeCaKC½yEdlTTYl)ankñúgkic©

karBarbUrNPaBEdndIrbs;km<úCa niyayedayELk KWkñúgs®gÁamRBMEdnCamYyevotNam nigkarkemÞc

[sabsUnünUv «])ayklbMpøicbMpøaj nigbgáehturbs;sRtÚvépÞkñúgnigxageRkA». hY niyayR)ab;

b:ul Bt EdlesIcjjwmBRBayfa ³ «bgb¥ÚnrYmGavuF cinmanesckþIrIkrayy:agelIslb;cMeBaHmux

C½yCmñHd¾RtcHRtcg;rbs;Gs;elak»47.

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 115

Page 126: Brother enemy

dMeNIreBareBjedayeCaKC½yrbs; b:ul Bt enARbeTscin KµanGVIeRkABIkm©at;PaBsgS½y nig

PaBGacERbRbÜlEdleFVI[xUcdl;TMnak;TMngcinkm<úCataMgBIsrTrdUvqñaM1976eLIy. vak¾)anCYy

BRgwgCMhrpÞal;rbs;Kat;kñúgépÞbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa[rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgEdr. vaCaP½sþútagfa Cabzmmitþ

PaBrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgKWsMGagelIlkçxNÐxagRbvtþisa®sþnigPUmisa®sþ-yuT§sa®sþ (Géostratégique)

ehIyGVIEdlsMxan;KWfaRbeTskm<úCaGacRbqaMgtTl;nwgRbeTsevotNamEdlCaKURbECgd¾cm,gbMput

rbs;RbeTscinenAkñúgtMbn;pg.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg116

Page 127: Brother enemy

semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu ³ cakecjBIqakneya)ay

karcakecjBIGakasFatuRtCak; nigG½BÞRkas;EbkEpSgénTIRkúgeb:kaMg KWCaPaBFUres,Iy

RBHT½ymYysRmab; semþc sIhnu. éf¶nImYy²enARkúgPñMeBjkñúgExFñÚ mansPaBRsTn; nigeBareBj

eTAedayBnøWRBHGaTitü. valM)akxøH²CamYyPaBesImbnþic²EdleFVI[xVayxVl;enArdUvePøógFøak;.

ehIykalebIKµanBnøWéf¶EcgcaMgEdlElgeFVI[TenøemKgÁqøúHrsµIepøk²enaH vaGacnwgmanxül;CMenar

RtCak;bk;mkbe)asGEg¥lxøÜnR)aNGñkmþgmáalEdr. vadl;eBllµmEdlRBHGgÁyagRtLb;mkvij

bnÞab;BIkarnireTsRBHkayR)aMqñaM. b:uEnþsRmab;RBHGgÁ éf¶TaMgLayhak;dUcCaesaHkeRkaHdUckñúgry³

eBlénkarKg;enAedaybgç¿citþenATIRkúgeb:kaMgEdr. semþcFøab;manRBHraCbMNgERbRBHkayeTACa

ÉkGKÁraCTUteKacrénkm<úCafµI edayyagRtac;creTARKb;TisTIkñúgBiPBelak edIm,IEsVgrksmancitþkar

KaMRTnigCMnYysRmab;karksagRbeTsrbs;RBHGgÁ EdlRtÚvbMpøicbMpøajedays®gÁameLIgvij. b:uEnþ

ExµrRkhm)anCMTas;nwgerOgenH. BYkeK)anbdiesFminpþl;CMenOTukcitþcMeBaHkSRt¬skþiPUmi¦mYyGgÁ

edIm,IbgðajCafµInUvninñakarbdivtþn_rbs;RTg;enAbreTsCamYynwgkarxMxñHExñg ebImindUecñaHeTCamYynwg

karRsLaj;eBjcitþ. tamBit sRmab;eBlenHExµrRkhmBuMRtÚvkar[mankarpSBVpSay[eKdwgB¤Ca

saFarN³eT. edaycab;epþImEkERbsgÁmy:agsuICeRmACafµI BYkeKKµanR)afñaGVIeRkAEtBIdak;«kar

BiesaFn_»rbs;xøÜn[sßitenAdac;q¶ayBIeKÉgb:ueNÑaH. tamry³vtþmanrbs;RBHGgÁCaemdwknaMRbeTs

KWvaRKb;RKan;ehIyEdlsemþc sIhnu pþl;[BiPBelakeXIjnUvrUbPaBkm<úCa KYr[TukcitþmYykñúgeBl

EdlkarBiesaFn_rbs;ExµrRkhm )anbnþeFVI[RbeTskm<úCargTukçevTnateTAeTot.

enAqñaM1975 munkardYlrlMénRkúgPñMeBj semþc)anmanbnÞÚlR)ab;RbFan em:A Casm¶at;fa

bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHrbs;ExµrRkhm RBHGgÁR)afñadkRBHkayecjBIqakneya)ayehIy. kareFVIsh

RbtibtþikarCamYyBYkeK KWvahYsBIsmtßPaBrbs;RBHGgÁeTAehIy. em:A )anCMTas;BIbBaðaenHy:ag

muWgm:at;. Kat;)anBitTUlsemþcfa «RBHGgÁRtÚvEtCYyExµrRkhm. GFikrN_rbs;RBHGgÁ CamYy

BYkeKmanminelIsBI20PaKryeT ehIyTsSn³EdledAeTArkeKalbMNgEtmYyKWmandl;eTA80

PaKryÉeNaH sUmsemþcbMePøc20PaKryenaHecaleTA». semþcmanbnÞÚltbPøamfa «elak

RbFan¡ erOgenHminGaceFVIeTArYceT». b:uEnþ semþcBuMGacCECksMeNHsMNalCamYy em:A )anyUreT

eRBaHKat;kMBugQWcab;kñúgkay. enATIbMput semþc sIhnu )anvilRtLb;mkkm<úCavij EdlminyUrb:unµan

RBHGgÁdwgRBHkayfa GFikrN_cMnYn20PaKryenaH)anERbeTACa100PaKryeBjEtmþg.

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 117

Page 128: Brother enemy

]bTÞvehtumYy)anekIteLIgedayécdnükñúgeBlTTYlbdisNæarkic©EdlerobcMeLIgkñúgnievsn

dæanrbs;RBHGgÁkñúg»kasbuNüCatiRbeTsKuy)a enaHKWCaP½sþútagelIkdMbUgEdlRBHGgÁRTg;RCabBI

sarCatiBitR)akdrbs;ExµrRkhm KWCaRkúmbnmYyEdls¥b;exI<mCnbreTsbMput. dUctamTmøab; semþc

sIhnu RtÚvGansgákfaRbsiT§BrCaPasaExµrbnÞab;mkRtÚvQb;mYyEPøtedIm,Irg;caMkarbkERb b:uEnþs¶at;

sUnü. KµanemdwknaMExµrRkhmNamñak;kñúgcMeNamenaHehIbmat;eLIy eTaHCaecHPasa)araMgfñwk

k¾eday. eKGacemIleXIj exov sMpn Cam©as;sBaØab½Rtfñak;bNÐit Edlecjedaysalas½re)an

ykEkgédbukGñkGgÁúyCitKat;mñak;KW sYg suIeKOn CabBaØvnþmñak;eTot EdlecHniyayPasa)araMg nig

CaGtItnaykTIPñak;garB½t’manExµr. karrg;caMecHEtBnüareTA enATIbMput semþc sIhnu k¾bkERbsgáfa

rbs;RBHGgÁeTACaPasa)araMgedaypÞal;. kñúgRbeTskm<úCarbs; b:ul Bt karecHdwgPasabreTsmYy

mann½yfa CakarsEmþg[eXIjPaBrNbmYyEdleKminKYrsEmJg[dwgeLIy.

kñúg»kasd¾kRmCaeRcInEdlRBHGgÁCYbBiPakSaCamYy exov sMpn rdæm®nþIkarbreTs eGog sarI

b¤CamYyrdæm®nþIeXasnakar h‘U nwm KWkarpþl;mtiENnaMTaMgb:unµanrbs;RBHGgÁEtgRtÚvRcanecaleday

karKYrsmCanic© ebITukCaerOgEdlminsUvsMxan;k¾eday dUcCa «ehtuGVI)anCamin[shkrN_nana)an

Qb;sRmakenAéf¶GaTitü?CaedIm. eKeqøIyfa eyIgminGacbBaÄb;karxMRbwgERbgrbs;RbCaCn Edl

manTwkcitþbMeBjParkic©tamTisedAbgábegáInplrbs;Kat;)aneLIy». RtÚveFVI[xUcRBHT½y semþc)an

seRmcbegáInkarcMGkbBaÄWcitþ nigkarkt;smÁal;d¾CUrct;EfmeTot enHCameFüa)ayEtmYyKt;Edl

RBHGgÁenAesssl;.

BIr-bIs)þah_eRkaydMeNIryagnivtþn_mkRkúgPñMeBjvij semþc sIhnu )anGeBa¢IjÉkGKÁrdæTUt

evotNam paM v:an;)a EdleTIbmkBIPaKxagt,ÚgfµI² cUlrYmBisarGaharéf¶Rtg;CamYyRBHGgÁ. kar

GeBa¢IjedayxøÜnRBHGgÁpÞal;enHmanlkçN³KYr[rIkrayNas;. kñúgeBlEdl )a edIrtYCaPñak;garsm¶at;

rbs;kumµúynIsþedIm,IplRbeyaCn_evotNamenARkúgPñMeBjkalBImunenaH ÉkGKÁrdæTUtrUbenH Føab;RtÚv

b:Ulisrbs; semþc sIhnu tamdans¥itNas;Edr. b:unµanqñaMeRkaymk Kat;)anRtÚvrdæaPi)alyk

mkeRbIvijeday[eFVICatMNagrdæaPi)albdivtþbeNþaHGasnñ evotNamxagt,Úg RbcaMTIRkúg):arIs.

h‘U nwm k¾)ancUlrYmkñúgkarBisarGaharéf¶Rtg;enaHEdr kñúgzan³Cardæm®nþIeXasnakarénraCrdæaPi)al

rYbrYmCatikm<úCa. )a )anTUlsemþcBIkarlM)akTaMgLay EdlevotNamxagt,ÚgeTIbnwgrMedaHfµI²RtÚv

RbQmmuxedaHRsay. semþc)ankat;smþI )a fa «b:uEnþkm<úCak¾mankarlM)akdUcKña». bnÞÚlenH)an

eFVI[ hU‘ nwm minsUvsb,aycitþeLIy. )a )anbMPøWR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦ eRkaymkeTotfa Kat;xMRbwg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg118

Page 129: Brother enemy

niyaybEgVgkarbgáehtutambnÞÚlrbs;semþcEdr. Kat;)anniyayfa «RbeTseyIgTaMgBIrsuT§Et

TTYlrgeRKaHBIkarQøanBanedaycRkBtþiGaemrikdUcKña. eBlenHCaeBlEdlRtÚvBüa)al[sHCa

ehIy». edayminTuk[xUcTwkcitþsemþc)anmanbnÞÚlsgmkvijfa «KWBitCaG‘IcwgEmn b:uEnþBYkemdwknaM

enATIenH¬km<úCaRbCaFibetyü¦)aneRbI»sfs½kþisiT§imYyb:uEnþBi)akelbNas;». PaBes¶óms¶at;d¾

tujtuHmYy)ansNæitmaneLIg. )a RkeLkemIl hU‘ nwm edayknÞúyEPñkmYyqVac; eXIjKat;eQ¶ak

smøwgemIleRkam1. mYyqñaMeRkaymk emdwknaMExµrRkhmrUbenH RtÚv)anykeTARbharCIviteRkamkar

ecaTRbkan;BIbTeFVIcarkic©CaKuNRbeyaCn_sRmab;es>GuI>Ga>.

enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1976> RkúmGñkkarTUtdMbUgmYymanKñacMnYnR)aMBIrrUb mkBIRbeTsGWr:ub Ga®hVik

nigbNþaRbeTsGar:ab; ehIyEdlkMBugsñak;enARkúgeb:kaMg RtÚv)anGeBa¢Ij[mkkan;RkúgPñMeBj edIm,I

CUnlixitsartaMgrbs;xøÜn. BiFIelogsayePaCn_eBll¶acEdlpþl;CakitþiyscMeBaHGñkTaMgenaH)an

pþl;[ semþc sIhnu man»kasfµImYyedIm,IsEmþg[dwgBIsßanPaBénTwkRBHT½yrbs;RBHGgÁnigeRbI

karkMEbøgs¶ÜtedIm,IbBaÄWcitþy:agkMral. ÉkGKÁrdæTUtmñak;kñ úgcMeNamenaH)ansaksYredaymin

R)akdxøÜnÉgfa edaymeFüa)ayEbbNaeTAEdlGacsþarRbeTskm<úCaeLIgvij )anebIeKbBa¢ÚnBYk

bBaØvnþTaMgGs;eTACnbTehIyenaH? semþc)anmanbnÞÚltbrebobkacfa «enATIenH eyIgminxVHbBaØvnþ

eT dUcCa exov sMpn GñkmansBaØab½Rtfñak;bNÐitesdækic© CYn eCOn bNÐitEpñkevC¢sa®sþ eGog sarI

bBaØvnþmñak;EdlFøab;bMeBjkarsikSarbs;xøÜnenARkúg):arIs>>>». RBHGgÁ)anbgðÚrRBHbnÞÚlBnül;Evk

EjkhUrEheTAtamdMeNIrénRBwtþikarN_TaMgLayrebobRtab;tamkarcMGkmYy. ePJóvTaMgGs;EdlRtÚv

eFVI[eTIsTal;kñúgcitþ)anrkSakares¶óms¶at;KµanB¤mat;k. BYkeK)aneXIjBIcm¶ayrYceTAehIynUvTIRkúg

exµacmYy esdækic©KµanrUbiyvtßúdak;[eRbIR)as; FnaKarkNþalrlM)ak;Ebk nigRkdasR)ak;ebuIgrsat;

tamxül; Føak;raytampøÚvfñl;nana. RbkarTaMgenH BuMGacrYcputBIkaremIleXIjrbs;BYkeK)aneLIy.

»kasd¾kRmepSg²Edl semþc sIhnu mansiT§iedIm,I)anCYbCamYyBYkbreTsdUcCakñúgBiFI

Cb;elognana )anRtÚveKlubecaly:agqab;rh½s. tamBit sßanPaBrbs;RBHGgÁ)ancab;epþImman

sPaBrwtEtGaRkk;eLIg²eRkaydMeNIryagRtLb;rbs;RBHGgÁ)anRbEhlmYys)þah_b:ueNÑaH.

enAéf¶TI5 Exmkra qñaM1976 RBHGgÁ)anLayRBHhsþelxaelIrdæFmµnuBaØfµIrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyü

EdlRtÚvCMnYsrdæFmµnuBaØrbs;RBHraCaNacRkkm<úCavij. cab;BIenaHmk km<úCa)anERbkøayy:ag

RbtükSfa «rdæRbCaCn» fµIElgmanGVICasarsMxan;sRmab;RBHGgÁeTotehIy. enAéf¶TI8 Exmkra qñaM

1976 mitþnigCaGñkFøab;KaMBarRBHGgÁKW CU eGnLay )anTTYlmrNPaB. mYys)aþh_eRkaymk

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 119

Page 130: Brother enemy

yuT§nakareXasnamYytamsarB½t’manenARbeTscin )anepþImRbqaMgnwgGñksñgtMENgKat;Edl)an

eRCIserIsTukCamunKW etg s‘avBIg. clnaenH)anedA[eXIjnUvkarvilRtLb;d¾FMrbs;BYkr:aDIkal;

EdlCabgb¥ÚnxagKMnitniymRCúldUcExµrRkhmEdr. KµanGVIKYr[PJak;ep¥IlesaHeLIy cMeBaHsMeNIEdl

semþc sIhnu suMyageTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMg edIm,IsEmþgKarvkic©cugeRkaycMeBaH CU ehIyEdlRtÚveK

bdiesFenaH. ExµrRkhmkMBugRbúgeRbóbEtgtaMg[manrdæaPi)alfµImYy semþcRTg;RBHtRmiHfa eK

R)afñacg;[RBHGgÁsßitenATIenHEdr. ExµrRkhmBuMEmnrg;caM[eKGgVr edIm,IRBmTTYlnUvkarsuMlaElgBI

tMENgrbs;RBHGgÁeLIy.

b:uEnþ karGnuBaØat[RBHGgÁcUlruWERttedayKµanGnþraKmn_NamYydUecñH GacbegáIt[mansMNYr

y:ageRcInenAbreTs. sRmab;CaelIkdMbUgehIytaMgBIkaryagRtLb;mkvijrbs;semþc EdlRBHGgÁ

RtÚv)anGnuBaØat[manbnÞÚltamviTüúCatienaH. eRkayeBlEdlesckIþRBagsunÞrkfarbs;RBHGgÁTTYl

)ankaryl;RBmBI«GgÁkar»ehIy m®nþImñak;)anmkftRBHsUresogdak;ExSGat;enARBHraCdMNak;

RBHGgÁpÞal;. semþc sIhnu )anTtsarCRmablaRbCaCatirbs;RBHGgÁEdlpSayenAéf¶TI2 Exemsa

qñaM1976 edayRBHsUresogGYlGak;rebobrMeCIbrMCYlkñúgRBHT½yfa ³

«bnÞab;BIrdæRbharrbs; ln; nl; nigbnrbs;vanaéf¶TI18 ExmIna qñaM1970 enARkúgPñMeBj ´

)aneFVIsm,fcMeBaHxøÜn´pÞal; nigcMeBaHRbCaCnkm<úCafa ´nwgdkxøÜnTaMgRsugnigCaerogrhUtBIqak

neya)ay edayehtufa ´)anrYmdMeNIrCamYyCnrYmCati´rhUtTTYl)anC½yCmñHCasßaBrelIcRkBtþi

GaemrikaMgnigbnk,t;ehIy ehIyeBlenHCaeBlcab;epþImskraCfµIrbs;bdivtþ tYnaTIrbs;´nwgRtÚv

dl;eBlbBa©b;ehIyEdr>>>. kñúgry³eBlesssl;énCIvitrbs;´ ´enAEtdwgKuNcMeBaHRbCaCnkm<úCa

vIrbursnigvIrnarIénRbeTskm<úCa nigcMeBaHGgÁkarbdivtþn_km<úCaEdl)anlublagekrþ×eQµaH ´BIerOg

esAhµgTaMgGs;enAcMeBaHmuxBiPBelaknigRbvtþisa®sþ. edaysarmenaseBa©tnaenH edayCMenO

eCOCak;EdlRbCaCn nigGgÁkarbdivtþn_rbs;eyIgcat;Tuk´kñúgzan³CasmaCikrbs;xøÜnmñak;dUceKEdr

enaH eTIbéf¶enH´)anesñIsuMnUvkarGnuBaØatdkxøÜnfyElgrvIrvl;nwgkic©karsaFarN³eTot».

BIréf¶eRkaymk viTüúPñMeBj)anRbkaspSayCasaFarN³fa rdæaPi)al)anTTYlyl;RBmnUvkar

suMlaElgBItMENgrbs; semþc sIhnu edayesaksþaybMputehIy)anpþl;zan³RBHGgÁCa«mhaburs

esñhaCati»eTotpg. rdæaPi)al)anesñIksagvimanmYyedIm,ICakitþiysfVayRBHGgÁ nig)anbric©aK

R)ak;esaFncMnYn8>000duløarkñúgmYyqñaMsRmab;RBHGgÁpgEdr. eRkaymkminEdlmannrNamñak;

niyayBIbBaðaksagvimanenHesaHeLIy. CaeRcInqñaMeRkaymkeTot´¬GñkniBn§¦ )anTUlsYrsemþc

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg120

Page 131: Brother enemy

sIhnu fa etIRBHGgÁ)aneFVIGVIxøHCamYyR)ak;TaMgenHkñúgRbeTsmYyEdlKµanrUbiyvtßúenaH?. semþc

)aneqøIytbedaybeBa©jRBHbsSas³bn§ÚrRBH»rafa «eT¡´minEdleXIjBN’RkdasR)ak;mYyduløar

pg kuMfaeLIyRsemalR)ak;duløarTImYyenaH». tamBitRBHGgÁ)anRTg; lixiteTA«GgÁkar» eday

bdiesFminTTYlR)ak;esaFnenHeT. viTüúPñMeBj)anpSay[dwgfa semþc sIhnu «cg;eqøót»kasBIkar

cUlruWERttrbs;RBHGgÁedIm,IcMNayeBlevlasRmab;RKÜsarRBHGgÁ eRkayBI)anbMeBjskmµPaBxag

neya)ayGs;ry³eBlsamsibR)aMqñaMmk». viPaKTanmYykñúgcMeNamviPaKTandMbUg²rbs;Exµr

RkhmcMeBaHCIvPaBrs;enAénRkúmRKÜsarsemþc KWkardeNþImykbuRtIBIrGgÁkñúgcMeNambuRtICaeRcIn

rbs;RBHGgÁ sVamIrbs;GñkTaMgBIr nigRBHraCntþadb;GgÁkñúgcMeNamRBHraCntþaTaMgGs;rbs;RBHGgÁ

edIm,IbgçMGñkTaMgenaH[eTAeFVIERs. sVamIrbs;buRtIRBHGgÁRBHnambTumbu)aö EdlRBHGgÁRsLaj;cUl

citþCageK KWCaGakasyanikénkgGakascrkm<úCa. buRtRbsaenHehIyEdl)anebIkynþehaH

Rbedjet-28eTATmøak;RKab;EbkelIvimanRbFanaFibtI ln; nl; enAkñúgExmIna qñaM1972 munnwg

rt;ePosxøÜneTAkan;tMbn;EdlRtÜtRtaedayExµrRkhm. semþcminEdl)aneXIjGñkTaMgenaHCafµImþg

eTotesaHeLIy. edayRbKl;nUvBaküsuMlaElgBItMENgrbs;RBHGgÁ semþcKµandwgfaenHCakar

cab;epþImrgTTYleTasTNÐmYy KWRtÚvkMNt;[Kg;enAEtkñúgR)asaTexmrinÞb:ueNÑaH ehIyerOgenHExµr

RkhmminEdlRbkas[dwgB¤Tal;EtesaH.

mnusSmñak;eQµaH b:ul Bt EdleKminEdlsÁal;esaH 121

Page 132: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg122

Page 133: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI4karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ

bNþasmaCikénKN³RbtiPUrbs; b:ul Bt )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMgtamynþehaHRbtikmµ

mYyeRKÓg nig)aneRbIR)as;rfynþm:ak hugKI ¬Tg;Rkhm¦ CaCageRbIreTHEdlTwmedayesH sRmab;

kareFVIdMeNIrcuHeLIgrbs;BYkeKkñúgrdæFanIcin. GñkTaMgenaH)anseRmccitþeTAeKarBviBaØaNkçn§bNþaRBH

ecAGFiraCcinenAkñúgvimantmál;sBRbFan em:A CaCageTAeFVIemIlvimanRBHecAGFiraC. b:uEnþTsSnkic©

rbs; b:ul Bt )anRtwmEtsgát;bBa¢ak;BIRbvtþicas;mYyeLIgvijb:ueNÑaH. m®nþICan;x<s;mñak;énRksYgkar

breTscin )aneFVIdMeNIrmkkan;RkúgPñMeBj edIm,IGmdMeNIrBYkePJóvkm<úCaCakic©KYrsmtamynþehaH

cinmYyeRKÓgrhUtdl;rdæFanIeb:kaMg rebobdUcKñanwgBYkm®nþIénRBHraCvaMgcinCUndMeNIrBYkesþcRtaj;

cMNuHEdlnaMsYysarGakrmkfVayRBHecAGFiraCkalBIsm½yedImy:agGFikGFmtaMgBIRBMEdnrhUt

dl;raCFanIEdr. b:uEnþ PaBdUcKñaKWEp¥kelIkarvinicä½yEpñkneya)ay nigyuT§sa®sþ EdlmannaTIBiess

kñúgTMnak;TMngrbs;RbeTscinCamYybNþaRbeTsCitxagxøÜnenAGasuIGaeKñy_.

cab;taMgBIstvtSr_TI3 nigrhUtdl;cugstvtSr_TI15 bNþaRBHmhakSRténRBHraCaNacRknana

¬h‘VÚNn/ ecnLa/ cm,:a nig km<úCa¦ EdlelceLIgenAelIEdndIénRbeTskm<úCa nigevotNamxagt,Úg

sBVéf¶ )anTTYlsÁal;siT§iGFiraCrbs;cinelIRbeTscMNuH y:agehacEbbCanimitþrUbEdr edaybg;sYy

sarGakrticb¤eRcIny:ageTogTat;eTA[RBHecAGFiraCcin. tamkarBit ebskkmµTaMgLayEdlerobcM

[mandMeNIr edIm,InaMsYysarGakreTAdl;eKaledAKWsuT§EtCaRbtibtþikarxagBaNiC¢kmµEkøgbnøMTaMg

Gs;. RbtibtþikarxagBaNiC¢kmµenH k¾Gacr:ab;rgdl;karkarBarRbeTscinEdr. bNþaRBHraCaNacRk

enAGasuIGaeKñy_BitCavaytémøfa karRBmanmYyBIRBHecAGFiraCd¾manGMNaclµmRKb;RKan;eFVI[rsay

citþnUvkarQøanBanCayfaehtuBIsMNak;bNþaRbeTsCitxagrbs;xøÜn1.

rebobRKb;RKgmandMeNIreTAy:agl¥ drabNacRkPBcinmanlkçN³xøaMgbgÁÜr edIm,Idak;karKMramrbs;

xøÜnedaykmøaMgeyaFa[Rbtibtþitam nigdrabNaKµankic©karbnÞan;EdlRtÚvedaHRsay. enAqñaM1407

RBHecAGFiraC mij y:uglI )anbBa¢ÚnkgT½BmYymankmøaMg200>000nak;eTAdak;TNÐkmµRbeTsevot

NamcMeBaHbT]Rkidæd¾sem,Imrbs;RbeTsenH CaBiess karQøanBanRbqaMgnwgnKrcm,:a. evotNam

Edlcaj;karRbyuT§)anRtÚvbgçM[RbKl;EdndIEdlBYkeKeTIbnwgP¢ab;CarNbeTA[cinvij2. b:uEnþ enAqñaM

1414 RBHmhakSRtrbs;km<úCaminsUvmansMNagb:unµaneT. RBHGgÁ)ancat;bBa¢Únm®nþImñak;eTARkúg

123

Page 134: Brother enemy

eb:kaMgy:agrh½s edIm,IsuMkarKaMRTrbs;cinRbqaMgnwgnKrcm,:a Edl[T½BcUllukluyRbeTsrbs;

RBHGgÁedaybþÚrnwgkarbg;sYysarGakrmYy. b:uEnþ RBHecAGFiraC y:uglI EdlCab;rvl;vayRbyuT§

nwgBYkm:ugehÁaly:agxøaMgenAPaKxageCIgenaH RKan;Et[ebskCnrbs;ExµrRtLb;mkvijRbkbeday

kitþiysesµInwgzan³RBHGgÁ nigGHGagfa nKrcm,:ak¾cMNuHRbeTscinEdr. ebskCn EdlRBHGgÁbBa¢Ún

eTAnKrcm,:a)anbBa¢ay:agdac;xat[RBHraCa¬nKrcm,:a¦ «dkkgT½BRBHGgÁecjBIkm<úCa nigTuk[RbeTs

enHsßitkñúgsnþiPaB». b:uEnþ lixitpøÚvkar¬rbs;RBHecAGFiraCcin¦BuMmankardak;TNÐkmµ RBmTaMgkarKMram

NamYyeLIy. dUecñH lixitenHenAEtKµan)anpl eRBaHRkúmmnusSRbdab;GavuF EdlmkBInKrcm,:a

enAEtbnþlYcbøn;RbeTskm<úCadEdl. kñúgsm½ykaltmkeTot enAeBlEdlRBHraCaNacRkExµrcuH

exSay nigkøayeTACacMNIénkarRsk;Twkmat;cg;)anrbs;evotNam nigesom CaRbeTsCitxagxøÜn

RbeTscin)ane)aHbg;km<úCaeTAtameRBgsMNagrbs;xøÜnEtmþg. tamkaryl;eXIjrbs;Exµrfa eTaH

CamanGVIekIteLIgk¾eday k¾KMnitCaRbéBNIéntYnaTICaGavuFhtßEdlRbeTscin RtÚvEtsEmþgenAkñúg

tMbn;c,as;CabnþGnuelameTAtamKMnitCayuT§sa®sþrbs;eKdEdl. RBHmhakSRtdMbUgénRbeTskm<úCa

sm½yfµIKW semþcRBH neratþm sIhnu )anRbwgEsVgrkeLIgvijy:agemaHmutkñúgkarcgmitþPaBCamYy

RbeTscinkumµúynIsþ kñúgesckþIsgÇwmbnøacbNþasRtÚv ¬EdlminTan;ecjCak;Esþg¦rbs;RbeTsRBHGgÁ.

enAqñaM1966 RBHGgÁQanrhUtRbkasfa mitþPaBenHKW «mann½y ÉkraCüPaB snþiPaB nigbUrNPaB

EdndI» sRmab;PaBKg;vgSénRbeTskm<úCaEfmeTot. RBHGgÁ )anRbkasedaybBaäitbeBaäógeTArk

RbeTsevotNam nigRbeTséfkñúgn½yCak;lak;fa ³ «ebIsinCaeyIggakecjBIRbeTscin eyIgnwg

RtÚvxaMEhksuI edayhVÚgtµatEdlCaGñkCEBa¢gTwkdIExµrCanic©nirnþr_miinxaneLIy»3.

taMgBIedImrhUtdl;cugRbvtþisa®sþrbs;xøÜnmunsm½yTMenIb RbeTscinRKan;EtCaGñkKaMBar d¾

sb,úrsmYynigCaédKUBaNiC¢kmµmYysRmab;RbeTskm<úCab:ueNÑaH. cMENkEbbEpnénTMnak;TMng

epSg²EdlRbeTsevotNamrkSaCamYyRbeTsCitxagxøÜnenAPaKxageCIg KWmanlkçN³xusKñaRsLH.

enAeBlEdlraCrdæaPi)alcinpþl;nUvkarkarBarcMeBaHRbeTscMNuHepSgeTotrbs;xøÜn cin)anRbwgERbg

edayKµanQb;QredIm,Idak;RbeTsevotNam[sßitenAeRkamGMNacxøÜnEdr. cMENkRbeTsevot

Nam )anRbwgERbgbgðaj[eXIjnUvkarcg;QñHd¾éføfñÚrrbs;xøÜndUcKña edayelIkxøÜnÉg CaGaNacRk

kNþaltUcmYy (mini-Empire du Milieu) tammeFüa)ayrbs;xøÜnedaymincMNuHkarekobsgát;rbs;BYk

cineLIy. kñúgTMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTskm<úCanigRbeTsLav RbeTsevotNamkumµúynIsþ)an

dak;CMnYsTMnak;TMngrebobenAkñúg»vaT ¬xagneya)ay¦ énsnþtivgS egVón eTACaRbB½n§sm<n§PaBmYy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg124

Page 135: Brother enemy

sMedAerobcMsnþisux nigkarRtÜtRtarbs;xøÜnxagEpñkesdækic©. dUcenAsm½yedImEdr ectnarbs;evot

Nam edIm,ItaMg]tþmPaBrbs;xøÜnenARBMEdnPaKxagt,ÚgRbeTscin)anbgá[mankarRbqaMgEdlminGac

sRmúHsRmÜl)anBIsMNak;BYkemdwknaMrbs;xøÜnEdlsuT§EtkøayeTACaCnkumµúynIsþ.

RmameCIgmYyEdlnaM[QWcab;

GñkRbvtþiviTUminTan;RtÚvr:UvKñasþIBIedImkMeNItRbeTsevotNameT. tamkarbkRsaymYyfa

RbCaCnevotNammanTIkMeNItCaRbvtþisa®sþrbs;xøÜnenAkñúgtMbn;mYyénextþhagdugrbs;cin ehIy

tamkarbkRsaymYyeTotfa enAkñúgGagTenøRkhm. RBHraCaNacRkdMbUgrbs;evotNam EdlesovePA

vsSikRbvtþi ¬esovePAEdlmancuHRBwtþikarN_RKb;qñaM¦rbs;cinniyayKWmaneQµaHfa Namevot ¬Pasa

cin ehA Nan Yueh¦ EdlRtÚvbegáIteLIgedayesþcRtaj;s®gÁamlHbg;sasnamñak;eQµaH RTW da enAqñaM

208munRKisþskraC. RTW da )anerobkarCamYy®sþIevotNammñak; edayRbkan;ykTMenomTmøab;

evotNam ehIysmøab;rgÁalCnCaticinTaMgGs;EdlenAmansVamIPkþicMeBaHRBHecAGFiraCrbs;eK.

bnÞab;BImansV½yPaBmYystvtSr_ RbeTsevotNam)anRtÚvelbRt)ak;edaysnþtivgSfµIKW snþtivgS

han EdleFVI[tMbn;enaHeTACaextþBIrrbs;cinKW extþ):anyU¬tMbn;kg;tug¦nigextþy:avCI-dIsNþTenø

Rkhm. kñúgry³eBlmYyBan;qñaMénkarkan;kab;rbs;cin evotNam)anRtÚveFVI[RCÜtRCabnUvTRmg;

epSg²énkarerobcMsgÁm nigneya)ayrbs;nayecAhVayBYkeKpgEdr. BYkeK)anTTYlykbec©k

eTsksikmµTMenIbsRmab;CMnan;enH nigeFVI[lUtlas;nUvRbB½n§GkSrmYy EdlkøaymkBIGkSrcin. enA

sm½ykalenH eKeXIjmankarcab;kMeNItnUvRkúmGñkecHdwgeRCARCHcin-evotNammYy EdlRCÜt

RCabeTAedayvb,Fm’cinnigTsSn³BiPBelakEbbxugCWniym. kareKarBrbs;evotNamcMeBaHvb,Fm’

cinKWmanlkçN³RCaleRCACagRbéBNIrbs;GaNÑam [GaNÑam mann½yfa «PaKxagt,ÚgEdleFVI[man

snþiPaB» b¤«PaBsuxsanþ». BYkcin)andak;eQµaHRbeTsevotNamdUecñHsRmab;CaelIkdMbUgenAqñaM

679]. RBHmhakSRtevotNammYyRBHGgÁenAstvtSr_ TI15)anGHGagtamry³GtßbTenHfa ³

BIrebobTaMgLayEdleFVI[manGarüFm’rbs;xøÜn PaKxagt,ÚgEdlmansnþiPaB ¬GaNÑam¦

)anbeBa©jb£kRkGWt.

RBHmhakSRt nigGaNaRbCanura®sþrbs;xøÜn KµaneKarBc,ab;NaeRkABIc,ab;rbs;snþtivgS

han eLIy.

mYk nig Gavpay eyIgeKarBeFVItamc,ab;rbs;snþtivgS fag4.

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 125

Page 136: Brother enemy

cMeBlEdlkmøaMgCatiniymkMBugmansnÞúHxøaMgkøakñúgRbeTsenAedImstvtSr_enH GñkecHdwg

evotNam)anykmkGYtCanic©BIkarecHsil,³xagkarsresrl¥ nigGkSrburaNcin. PaKeRcInsuT§Et

CaGñkdwknaMkumµúynIsþenAevotNam edaycab;epþImBI hU CImij eTAEdlRCÜtRCabeTAedayvb,Fm’

rbs;cin.

edaypÞúynwgmtiFmµta kareFVI[RCÜtRCabnUvvb,Fm’rbs;cinenH)anpþl;[evotNamnUv]bkrN_

neya)ay nigreboberobcMEpñkesdækic©EdlBYkeKRtÚvkar edIm,IbgáehtunwgGaNacRkénGaTieTB Empire

Céleste ¬enHCaeQµaHBIedImrbs;RbeTscin eRBaHRBHecAGFiraCRbeTsenH RtÚveK[eQµaHfa kUnrbs;

GaTieTB¦. dUcEdlRbvtþiviTUmñak;)ankt;RtaBIerOgenHfa «RbeTscin)anbegáIt RbCaCatifµImYyeday

Gectna EdlecHRbkan;ykrebobRKb;RKgrbs;cin edIm,IerobcMÉkraCüPaBpÞal;rbs;xøÜn»5. eday

RtÚveFVI[rgTukçkñúgry³eBl900qñaMeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;cin RbCaCatienH )anTmøab;xøÜnRTaMRT

karlM)akkñúgry³eBlmYyBan;qñaMfµIeTot kñúgkarts‘UTl;nwgRbeTscin.

edayeqøót»kasénsm½ykalRCÜlRcbl;mYyenARbeTscin emdwknaMrbs;evotNammñak;

eQµaH g:U ekVón )anbeNþjkgT½BRbcaMbnÞayTIRkúg nigGñkeFVIkarkñúgkariyal½yrbs;cinTaMgGs;ecjBI

TIRkúg ehIybegáItsnþtivgSÉkraCümYy. kar)at;bg;enH BuMEmnTTYlykedayKµanBicarNaeday

RBHecAGFiraC sug ehIyBuMEmnedayBYkm:ugehÁalKWRBHecAGFiraC mij nig CIg CaGñkTTYltMENg

bnþmkeToteLIy. enAeBlEdlsNþab;Fñab;RtÚverobcMeLIgvijenAPaKxagt,ÚgRbeTscin RBHecA

GFiraC sug )anbBa¢ÚnkgT½BmYyeTAvaydeNþImykextþy:avCImkvij KW40qñaMbnÞab;BIkareFVIGbKmn_

rbs;evotNam. sarlixitmYyEdlbBa¢Úneday éthSúg KWRBHecAGFiraC sug eTA[RBHmhakSRtenA

RbeTsevotNam munkarbBa¢ÚnT½BeTARbeTsenH )anqøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjKMnitrbs;ciny:agc,as; ³

«TMnak;TMngrbs;RbeTscinCamYyBYkmnusSéRBKµanGarüFm’enAPaKxagt,Úg KWdUcKñanwgrcnasm<½n§

énxøÜnR)aNmnusSEdr ³ ebHdUgCaGñkbBa¢akark®nþak;rbs;édnigeCIgTaMgBIr. dUecñHebHdUgCaecAhVay

nigCam©as;. ebIsinmanGVIekIteLIgedayKab;CYnkñúgédmçagb¤eCIgmçag srésQamRtÚveFVI[sÞH b¤fa

srésRbsaTeFVI[GñkQWcab;xøaMg viC¢aeBTümYyGacEkbM)at;eraKenH)an. kñúgkrNIpÞúyBIenH eKGnuvtþ

karBüa)aledaykarcak;m¢úl ¬bc©úb,nñehAm¢úlviTüasa®sþ¦ rhUtdl;suxPaBmandUcedImeLIgvij».

bnÞab;BIBüa)al«eCIgnigéd»rYcehIy niyayedayELkKWCnCatiPaKticenAPaKxagt,ÚgRbeTscin

RBHecAGFiraC)anRbmUlpþúMkarykRBHT½yTukdak;eTAelIRbeTsevotNam EdlRBHGgÁeRbóbRbdUcnwg

RmameCIgmYy. «mnusSmanKtibNÐitGacmindwgBIRmameCIgEdlnaM[QWcab;tictYcEmnb¤?. ebIsin

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg126

Page 137: Brother enemy

CaRBHGgÁRtÚvdwknaMRbeTs RBHGgÁnwgbeNþay[manesrIPaBRKb;Ebby:ageTAtamGMeBImindwgxusRtÚv

rbs;GñkEdlnwgminnaM[xUcdl;PaBbrisuT§rbs;eyIg».

sarlixit)ansUm[evotNamdak;xøÜnsþab;bgÁab;raCrdæaPi)al sug edIm,IsuxPaBl¥dl;xøÜn

R)aNrbs;RbeTscin. kñúgkrNIEdlminRBm ³ «eyIgnwgbBa¢a[kat;saksBrbs;GñkCaduM² Garq¥wg

rbs;GñknigeFVI[dIrbs;GñkeTACaRKab;l¥it²dUcCaRKab;FBaØCati>>>. RKab;KC;énsmuRTrbs;Gñk eyIgnwg

e)aHecaleTAkñúgTenø masénPñMTaMgLayrbs;Gñk eyIgnwgRKEvgecaleTAkñúgFUlIdI. eyIgminRsk;Twk

mat;cg;)anrtnsm,tþirbs;GñkeT. GñkTaMgGs;KñaehaHehIrnigelatepøaHy:agelOndUcstVsahav enA

eBlEdlreTHrbs;eyIgTajedaystVesH. GñkTaMgGs;KñapwktamRcmuH eyIgmanGgárnigRsa. cUl

rYmKñapøas;bþÚrEbbbTrbs;GñkeTA¡. GñkTaMgGs;Kñakat;sk;xøI eyIgBak;mYk. smþIGñkeRbóbdUcsMeLgyM

rbs;bkSI eyIgmanesovePAnigkarRbLg. sUmTuk[eyIgbgðat;beRgónGñkBIc,ab;Bit²¡. etIGñkcg;

eKcputBIkarrs;enACarebobmnusSéRBenAcugkat;mat;jk ehIysmøwgeTArkmNÐlénGarüFm’eT? etI

Gñkcg;e)aHbg;ecalsemøókbMBak;eFVIBIsøwkeQInigesµArbs;Gñk ehIyesøókBak;GavpayEdlmanpáa

edrdas):ak;rUbPñMnigrUbnaKEdreT? etIGñkyl;ehIyb¤enA? kuMbiTTVaredaykMhwg GñknwgeFVI[mankMhus

mYyEdlnaM[vinas. eyIgnwgRbmUlpþúMrfeRkaH esH nigkgT½BRbqaMgnwgGñk>>>»6.

RBHmhakSRtevotNam eL h½n minRBWRBÜcnwgkarKMramkMEhgenHeLIy. enAqñaM981 kgT½B

raCvgS sug )anTTYlrgbraC½yd¾EsnGam:as;mYyenARbeTsevotNam. kñúgry³mYyBan;qñaMEdl

manCabnþbnÞab;mkeTot evotNam)anvayrujRcankarlukluyCagémÖ)aøyelIkEdlecjmkBIPaK

xageCIg.

GñkÉkeTssþIBITMnak;TMngCaRbéBNIrbs;RbeTscinCamYybNþaRbeTsCitxagxøÜn )anmUl

mat;KñaTTYlsÁal;CaTUeTAfa menaseBa©tnaEdlBYkcinFøab;manGMBIPaBx<g;x<s;elIseKrbs;xøÜn taMgBI

sm½yRKb;RKgrebobnaMsYysarGakrmkfVay KWmanlkçN³vb,Fm’eRcInCagneya)ay. lkçnþik³

EdlRtÚvbg;sYysarGakr BuMEmnpþl;[RbeTsmYyeT b:uEnþ cMeBaHRBHmhakSRtmYyGgÁ [Et

mhakSRtenaHTTYlsÁal;PaBRbesIrx<g;x<s;elIseKrbs;RbeTscin nigGgVrsuMkarTTYl[xøÜncUlkñúg

«GaNacRkkNþal»¬RbeTscin¦ edIm,InwgeFVI[«xøÜnERbRbÜlrIkceRmIn». edayBicarNatamrebob

GrUbI vamansarsMxan;tictYcNas;cMeBaHRBHecAGFiraCcin EdlmnusSéRBKµanGarüFm’mñak;TTYlsÁal;

PaBx<g;x<s;CageKbMputrbs;xøÜnenaH. b:uEnþ kñúgRBwtþikarN_epSg² RbeTscin)anxMRbwgCaerOy² edIm,I

ykQñHnigRtÜtRtaedaypÞal;nUvBYkmnusSéRBKµanGarüFm’EdlkMBugrs;enAbrievNxageRkAénGaNa

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 127

Page 138: Brother enemy

cRkrbs;xøÜn. kñúgkrNIRbeTsevotNam ]bsKÁénsßanPaBdI nigkarts‘Ud¾rwgrUsrbs;GñkRsuk )an

eFVI[karedaHRsaybBaðaenHmankarBi)akxøaMgnigminGaceFVIekIt. karTak;TgtamEbbEpnnaMsYysar

GakreTAfVay KWCaEbbEpnEtmYyKt; EdlmaneKalbMNg. mü:ageTot rebobRKb;RKgEdlrdæmYy

RtÚvnaMsYysarGakreTACUnrdæ mYyeTotTukCakarcMNuH edayEp¥kelIbNþaeKalkarN_xugCWniym )an

Tuk[RbeTscinmanesrIPaBmYylµmRKb;RKan; edIm,IeFVIGnþraKmn_enAeBlEdlGVI²Gac[eFVI)an.

eTaHbICabNþaRBHmhakSRtrbs;evotNam minEdlQb;TTYlsÁal;GFibetyürbs;cink¾eday

k¾RBHecAGFiraCEdleLIgRKgraCübnþbnÞab;Kña ehIyerogral;elIkEdlRBHGgÁeQVgyl;fa kmøaMgT½B

rbs;RBHGgÁxøaMgbgÁÜrehIy RBHGgÁEtgEteFVIGnþraKmn_kñúgRbeTsCitxagrbs;xøÜnCanic© edIm,IeFVI[man

sßirPaBnigerobcMrebobrbbsgÁmtamlT§ixugCWniym. ]TahrN_ muncab;epþImeFVIkarlukluyenAqñaM

1407 EdltaMg[maneLIgvijnUvkarRtÜtRtarbs;cinBIrTsvtSr_elIRbeTsevotNam RBHecAGFiraC

y:uglI )anykRBHT½yTukdak;erobrab;nUv«bT]Rkidæ»FM²cMnYnémÖEdlRBHGgÁTmøak;eTaseTAelIRBH

mhakSRtevotNam. bT]RkidæsMxan;bMputcMnYnR)aMbIsuT§EtCakarbMBanxagsIlFm’nigmenaKmviC¢a ³

kardeNþImGMNacedayeRbI])aykl ¬bnþedaykareFVIXatRBHmhakSRteBjc,ab;¦ kareFVI)abeTA

elIRbCaCn kareCrRbmafcMeBaHRBHecAGFiraCmij. bnÞab;mkeTotKW«bT]Rkidæ»cMnYnR)aMEdlTak;Tg

eTAnwgsnþisuxRbeTscin. RBHecAGFiraC)anecaTRbkan;RbeTsevotNamCaBiessfa )anjúHjg;[

mankarvwkvrkñúgcMeNamBYkkulsm<½n§enAtamRBMEdn nigCMruj[mankarbHe)arRbqaMgnwgRBHecA

GFiraC. GMeBIQøanBanepSg²rbs;RbeTsevotNamRbqaMgnwgnKrcm,:a)anbgá[mankarecaTRbkan;

cm,g²cMnYnR)aMCabnþbnÞab;. enATIbMput kñúgkrNIBIrcugeRkayRbeTsevotNammin)aneKarBcMeBaH

rUbRBHecAGFiraCeLIy. RbvtþiviTU v:ag háúgvU )anKUsbBa¢ak;edayyutþiFm’fa bBa¢IkMhusenH «bgðaj

[eXIjBIkarcg;)anrbs;RbeTscin GMBIsiT§iGFiraCelIRbeTscMNuH edaydkhUtBIbNþardæcMNuHnUv

esrIPaB nigÉkraCüPaBkñúgkareFVIskmµPaBrbs;eK» ehIyCaBiessrdæmYyEdlenAEtCaPaKIrYm

bBa©Úl¬EdlbMeBj[mUl[sBVRKb; dUcCaédeCIgEdlb®gÁb;ragkayEdr¦ éncRkPBcintaMgBIyUrmk

ehIy7. edayBit RbeTsevotNam BuMEmnCaRBHraCaNacRkenAeRkamcMNuHdUcRBHraCaNacRk

déT²eT. CaGtItextþrbs;RBHecAGFiraC kalBIedImevotNamFøab;)aneRkbCBa¢k;KuNRbeyaCn_

epSg²BIGarüFm’rbs;cinCaeRcIn. edIm,IbgðajP½sþútagBITNÐkmµEdlRBHGgÁdak;elIRbeTsevotNam

enAqñaM1407 RBHecAGFiraC y:uglI )aneFVIGtßaFib,ayfa RbeTsenHCaRbeTsman«sm<½n§jatiy:ag

CitsñiT§»nwgRbeTscin. enHKWCaBaküsMxan;mYy. edaycg¥úlP½sþútagBIcMNgsac;jatirvagRbeTs

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg128

Page 139: Brother enemy

TaMgBIr RbeTscin)anpþl;dl;RbeTsevotNamnUvBnøWGarüFm’rbs;xøÜny:ageRcIn. «bT]Rkidæ»TaMgLay

rbs;bNþakSRtevotNamRKan;EteFVI[kSRtTaMgenHGak;Gn;RBHT½yy:agxøaMgb:ueNÑaH.

«RbyuT§edIm,IrkSask;Evg>>>»

kñúgry³eBlBIrTsvtSr_EdlmanbnÞab;BIkarlukluyenAqñaM1407 karRKb;RKgrbs;evotNam

enAEtsßitenAkñúgédBYkm®nþICan;x<s;EdlmkBIRbeTscindEdl. skçIPaBEdlbgðaj[eXIjBIvb,Fm’

rbs;evotNam)anRtÚvbMpøicbMpøaj xøHRtÚvnaMeTARbeTscin ehIyPaKeRcInRtÚv)at;bg;-enHCakar

vinasd¾KYr[QWcab;sRmab;GñkGkSrsa®sþevotNamrab;stvtSr_xagmuxeTot. c,ab;sareBIBn§rbs;

raCvgSmij )anRtÚvbBa©ÚlmkkñúgRbeTs ehIyeK)anksagsalaeronCaeRcInedIm,Ibgðat;beRgón

GkSrsa®sþburaNrbs;cin. TMenomTmøab; RbéBNI karkat; b¤kartubEtgsk; nigTMenomrbs;cin)an

RtÚvcab;bgçM[evotNamTTYlyk. c,ab;fµImYy)anhamkarRbtibtþiTmøab;CaRbéBNIxøH²rbs;evotNam

dUcCaTmøab;sak;xøÜn labeFµj¬[exµA¦ b¤TMBasøamøÚ. dUcy:agkñúgry³eBldMbUgénkarkan;kab; BYkcin)an

eRbIRbCaCnevotNam[eFVIkarTaMgbgçMedIm,IeFVIGaCIvkmµ Er:mas R)ak; s<an; nig Edk b:uEnþk¾eRbIkñúgkar

br)aj;dMrI edIm,IykPøúkbr)aj;rmasedIm,Iykkuy nigkarmuCrkRKab;KC;eTotpg8.

yuT§nakarcm,aMgT½BéRBd¾yUrmYyEdldwknaMedayemT½Brbs;evotNammñak;eQµaH eL Ly )an

bBa©b;karRtÜtRtarbs;cinenAqñaM1427. rhUtmkdl;kareFVIsBa¢½yrbs;)araMgry³eBl4stvtSr_

knøHeRkaymkeTot RbeTsevotNamecHkarBarxøÜnBIkarlUkédcUlTaMgGs;rbs;breTs. manEtkar

KMramkMEhgd¾F¶n;F¶rmYyb:ueNÑaH KWenAqñaM1788 snþtivgS Cij )anbBa¢ÚnGgÁkgT½BmYy edIm,Isakl,g

bgçM[evotNamTTYlGaNaBüa)alrbs;xøÜnCafµImþgeTot. GñkyuT§sa®sþevotNamd¾cMNanmñak;eQµaH

egVón h‘uy )aneFVI[RbtibtþikarswkenHbraC½y. Kat;ecHTajykRbeyaCn_d¾RbesIrBImenaseBa©tna

Catiniymd¾xøaMgkøarbs;RbCaCnEdlrIkduHdaledaysarkarmincUlcitþcMNuHeKCaeRcInstvtSr_ dUc

EdlbTbnÞrénceRmóg«dMeNIrkgT½B»rbs; egVóg h‘uy bgðajCaP½sþútagRsab; ³

RbyuT§edIm,IrkSask;Evg

RbyuT§edIm,IrkSaeFµjexµA

RbyuT§edIm,IbMpøajreTH ¬kg;4¦ TaMgGs;rbs;sRtÚv

RbyuT§edIm,Ikm©at;eRKÓgkarBarTaMgGs;rbs;vaenARKb;kEnøg

RbyuT§edIm,I[vadwgfa RbeTsPaKxagt,Úgd¾xøaMgBUEkKWCaecAhVaypÞal;rbs;va9.

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 129

Page 140: Brother enemy

RbeyaKCaeKalKMnitCatiniymrbs;evotNam karRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgkarRtÜtRtarbs;cin)an

RtÚvelIktemáIgesÞIrEtesµInwgsasnaEdr. kñúgGMLúgénkareFVIs®gÁameBjTMhwgTl;nwgshrdæGaemrik

TukNaCakarKaMRTrbs;cinmansarsMxan;y:agxøaMgmYysRmab;karKg;vgSrbs;RbCaCnevotNamk¾eday

k¾CMenOenHRtÚv)anRbtibtþiedaysm¶at;Canic©. kñúgGMLúgénkarsñak;GaRs½ymYyenAevotNamxageCIg

naExtula qñaM1972 GñkRsavRCavGaemrikaMg hSk kahIn )annwk)armÖBIkRmiténesrIPaBxagsasna.

kñúgRBHviharRKisþsasnaenARkúghaNUy Kat;)aneTAemIlkñúgBiFIsURtFm’éf¶GaTitümYyEdlman

sasniky:ageRcIncUlrYm. bnÞab;BIcb;BiFIsURtFm’ mKÁúeTÞsk_evotNamrbs;Kat;)ansYrKat;fa ³ «etI

elakcg;sÁal;sasnarbs;eyIgeT?». kahIn )anyl;RBmtamkarGeBa¢IjPøam. eK)annaMKat;qøgkat;

s<anmYy EdlnaMeTAkan;ekaHmYyénbwgh½neKom enATIRkúghaNUy. kñúgRBHviharmYyelIekaHenaH man

Gasn³bIsRmab;dak;eRKÓgskáar³. Gasn³TImYysRmab;]TÞiscMeBaHRBHBuT§ Gasn³TIBIrcMeBaHRBHGa-

TieTBdInigTwk ehIyGasn³TIbIEdlenAcMkNþalKWsRmab;]TÞiscMeBaH Rtan; h‘ugdav Ca]tþmesnIy_Edl

vayQñHkgT½Bcin-m:ugehÁalenAstvtSr_TI13. edaysVHEsVgcg;dwgelIsBIenHeTot kahIn )anrk

eXIjfa enARkúghaNUymanbUCnIydæanR)aMmYykEnøgepSgeTot EdlevotNamsagsg;eLIgCa

kitþiysdl;bNþavIrburs nigvIrnarIkñúgkarts‘URbqaMgnwgGñklukluycindUcCa eLLy b¤bgb¥ÚnRtkUl

RTúg CaedIm10.

dMNalKñanwgkarRbyuT§enAeRkamkar]btßmÖrbs;cinedIm,IÉkraCüPaBrbs;xøÜn RbeTsevotNam

)anbMBak;[xøÜnÉgnUvEbbbTneya)ayedImmYyEdllaybBa©ÚleTAedayPaBmuWgm:at; nigPaBTn;Pøn;.

PaBmuWgm:at;kñúgkarkarBarGtþsBaØaNnigÉkraCüPaBrbs;xøÜn. PaBTn;Pøn;kñúgkarEsVgrkedayx¢ab;x¢Ün

nUvkarsRmúHsRmÜledayGt;»n[KñaeTAvijeTAmkmYy (Modus Vivendi) CamYyRbeTscin. edayBit

karxitcUlCitKñaEdlmanEtmYyenH )anqøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjmenaseBa©tnarbs;evotNamcMeBaH

RbeTscinEdlmanlkçN³pÞúyBIKña KWkarRsLaj;cUlcitþ nigkars¥b;ex<Im menaseBa©tnanwkfa tUcTab

CageK nigGPimanH esckþIkøahanRbkbedayvIrPaB nigRbtibtþiniym (Pragmatisme). bMNgrbs;

evotNamkñúgkareFVICam©as;enARbeTsrbs;xøÜn EtgEtRtÚvbg¥n;edaystism,CBaسc,as;las;mYy

EdlBYkeKsEmþg[eXIjcMeBaHGanuPaBrbs;RbeTscin nigedaysarkaresI¶csresIrBitR)akdmYy

cMeBaHGVI²TaMgGs;EdlmkBIRbeTscin. taMgBIdMbUg²énÉkraCüPaB bNþaRBHmhakSRtevotNam )an

yl;dwgy:agrh½sfa meFüa)ayEdl[seRmclT§pleRcInRbkarEdlBYkeKman-vIrPaBénRbCaCn

GtßRbeyaCn_énsßanPaBdI nigviTüasa®sþEpñkyuT§sa®sþrbs;eK-lµmRKb;RKan;nwgeFVI[braC½ynUvkar

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg130

Page 141: Brother enemy

b:unb:gratt,atTaMgGs; b:uEnþfa RbeTscinmanRbCaCneRcInNas; ehIyRbPBFnFank¾mansn§wk

sn§ab; EdlBYkeKGacsgÇwmykQñHcin)ankñúgkarRbyuT§ry³eBly:agyUrmYy. siT§iGFiraCrbs;cin

elIRbeTscMNuHmanKuNvibtþitictYcbMput ³ CaeKalkarN_siT§ienH)anbdiesFnUvkareRCótERCkpÞal;

mYy. RbvtþiviTUrbs;evotNam)ansgát;bBa¢ak;BIerOgenHfa ³ «vaCaplRbeyaCn_sRmab;bNþaRBH

mhakSRtevotNam EdlRtÚvlHbg;GFibetyürbs;xøÜnmYyEpñkCafñÚrnwgkarKaMBarrbs;cinkñúgkrNI

EdlmankarbHe)ar nigeFVI[R)akdfa RbeTsCatinwgminTTYlrgeRKaHfñak;NamYyEdlxøÜnCacMNuH b¤

RKb;RKgedaypÞal;edayRbeTscineLIy»11. bnÞab;BITTYlC½yCmñHelIkgT½Blukluycinmþg²RBH

mhakSRtrbs;evotNamEtgcat;bBa¢ÚnCaRbjab;nUvm®nþITUtmñak;edIm,IsuMkarGt;»neTasBIRBHecAGFiraC

cin nigbg;sYysarGakr[RBHGgÁCanic©. karGt;»neTasenH EtgEtyl;RBmpþl;[Cadrab.

sil,³énkarerobcMRbugeRbóbCaeRsc

bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHelIkgT½BraCvgS mij enAqñaM1427 mYyEpñkénRbCaCnnigkgT½B manbMNg

bdiesFsnþiPaBEdleKpþl;[ ehIycg;sgswkedaykarsmøab;rgÁalGñkCab;Kukcinvij. b:uEnþshkarI

d¾CitsñiT§bMputrbs;emT½BevotNam eL Ly KWGñkyuT§sa®sþnigkvI egVón Rtay )anRbqaMgnwg

bBaðaenH. Kat;)anCECktv:afa ³ «kñúgkal³eTs³bc©úb,nñKµanGVIgayRsYlCagvayRbharxµaMgsRtÚv

nigbg¥n;seRmkrbs;eyIgCamYyQamrbs;vaeLIy. b:uEnþ bnÞab;mkeTot>>>? ´xøacERkgfa kareFVI

dUecñHnwgbNþal[manKMnuMy:agsVitsVajBIraCvgS mij. BYkeKnwgsVHEsVgsgswkvij eRBaHfakitþis½BÞ

énmhaGaNacRkmYy)anRtÚveFVI[b:HBal;. BYkeKnwgbBa¢ÚnT½BfµImYyeTot. dUecñH etIeBlNaEdl

esckþIQWcab;edaysars®gÁamnwgRtÚvbBaÄb;?. edIm,IsarRbeyaCn_rbs;RbCaCatieyIgTaMgBIr vaCa

karRbesIrEdlRtÚveqøót»kasEdlsRtÚvlutCgÁg; edIm,IbegáItsnþiPaBCamYyva»12. eL Ly )an

eFVItamkar[eyabl;rbs; Rtay. CagenHeTAeTot eL Ly )anRbKl;eTA[kgT½Bcin Edlcaj;nUv

TUkcMnYn500eRKÓg esHCaeRcInBan;k,al niges,ógGaharmYycMnYnFM edIm,IGac[kgT½BenaHRtLb;

eTARbeTsvij.

edaydwgy:agc,as;GMBIkarqáÜtnwgbuNüskþirbs;RBHecAGFiraCcin nigkitüanuPaBEdl[RBHGgÁ

mankitþiysEtsMbkeRkA evotNammankarbuinRbsb;CaxøaMgkñúgsil,³TTYl)anBIRBHGgÁedaykar

beBa©IcbeBa©I nigkarsþab;»vaTreboblak;elomnUvGVIEdlBYkeKminGacTTYl)anedaykmøaMgT½B. enA

edImstvtSr_TI18 evotNam)anmanbMNgdac;xatkñúgkarTamTartMbn;RBMEdnmYycm¶ay40lI-

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 131

Page 142: Brother enemy

rgVas;cinburaNRbEvgRbEhl20KILÚEm:Rt-xagkñúgEdndIrbs;cin. RBHecAGFiraCcinRTg;BieraFy:ag

xøaMg. enAeBlenaH RBHmhakSRtevotNam)anrevosrév sEmþgnUvkaresaksþayrbs;RBHGgÁeday

BaküsmþIcuHj:meBjeljmYy. edayRtÚveFVI[FUrRsal RBHecAGFiraC)aneFVIsm,Taneday\tyk

kéRmnigrhUtteTAnUvEdndIEdltv:aedayRbeTsevotNam13. enAqñaM1788 vIrbursevotNam

egVón h‘uy )anvayrujRcankarlukluymYyrbs;raCvgS Cij. bnÞab;BIkarvayrujRcan Kat;)an

bBa¢ÚneTA[RBHecAGFiraCcinnUvlixitsuMdak;xøÜneRkambgÁab;nigkarsuMeTasmYy. Kat;)anBnül;eday

rabsafa karvayRbharrbs;kgT½BKat;KWCa]bTÞvehtumYy. b:uEnþ GMeBIEdleFVI[b:HBal;dl;GgÁ

GFiraCRtÚvEtBüa)al. dUecñH edIm,IlublagkMhus egVón h‘uy )ansnüaeFVIdMeNIredaypÞal;eTAkan;

Rkúgeb:kaMg kñúg»kasbuNüxYbEb:tsibRBHvsSarbs;RBHecAGFiraC. tamkarBit Kat;)anbBa¢ÚnkµÜy

Rbúsmñak;EdlmanrUbragniglkçN³dUcKñaebHbiT[eTACMnYsKat;. etIRBHecAGFiraCrkeXIjkare)akbnøM

enHeT? eKmindwg. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday egVón h‘uy Ekøgkøay)anTTYlkareFVIBiFIbdisNæarkic©

d¾»LarikmYys½kþismCaePJóvRBHecAGFiraCmYyGgÁEdlkMBugmanvib,disarI14.

cab;BIstvtSr_TI10 neya)ayrbs;evotNamcMeBaHbNþaRbeTsCitxagxøÜn-cm,:a km<úCa éf

nigEdndItUc²EdlmankSRtRKgraCüenARbeTsLav-)anERbpøas;eTACaElgcMNuHRbeTscin. b:uEnþ

kñúgkrNICaeRcIn evotNam)anRbúgeRbóbCaeRscedIm,ITUlRBHecAGFiraC[dwgBImUlehtu b¤els

epSg² nigskmµPaBnanaEdlepþImeFVIRbqaMgnwgrdæcMNuHxøHkñúgcMeNamrdæcMNuHCaeRcIneTot rbs;

RBHGgÁ. enAqñaM1044 RBHmhakSRtevotNam lI éftug EdlxMRbwgbgðajP½sþútagBIkarcUlluk

luyrbs;RBHGgÁkñúgnKrcm,:a )anGeBa¢IjGñkniBn§esovePAlT§ixugCW[mkCYyxøÜn edIm,Ibgðajfa

RbeTsenHxVHkareKarBcMeBaHRBHGgÁ. KMrUénesckþIeqøIyedaHsadUcKñaenH GacrkeXIjkarGnueRKaH

BIRBHraCvaMgcinpgEdr. enAqñaM1446 evotNam)anbþwgraCrdæaPi)alraCvgS mij GMBIkarbøn;bMpøaj

EdlRbRBwtþedayBYkcamenAtamRBMEdnEfmeTot. edayehtuenH RBHecAGFiraCcin)anTUnµanRBH

mhakSRtcamy:agmuWgm:at;[Qb;rMelaPRBMEdnrbs;evotNam. émÖbIqñaMeRkaymkenAeBlEdl

RBHGgÁeRtómRBHkayeFVIkarvayRbhary:agF¶n;F¶rbMput kñúgRbvtþisa®sþrbs;xøÜneTAelInKrcm,:a

RBHecAGFiraCevotNam faj; tug )ancat;bBa¢ÚnebskCnmñak;eTACYbraCrdæaPi)alraCvgS mij edIm,I

raykarN_BImUlehtuepSg²énKeRmagkarlukluyrbs;xøÜn kñúgeKalbMNgkuM[BYkcinmankMhwg15.

RBHmhakSRtTaMgLayrbs;evotNam)anRbwgERbgbegáIttamKMrUrbs;cinnUvRbB½n§RtÚvbg;sYy

sarGakrpÞal;rbs;xøÜn. BYkkSRtTaMgenH)anEtgtaMgxøÜnEtxøÜnÉgeRkamBakü Vuong ¬RBHmhakSRt¦

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg132

Page 143: Brother enemy

enAcMeBaHmuxBYkcin b:uEnþ eRkamBaküfa Hoang ¬RBHecAGFiraC¦enAeBlEdlBYkeKmankarTak;TgCamYy

GaNaRbCara®sþpÞal;rbs;eKb¤CamYyRBHmhakSRtepSg²eTotenAGasuI-GaeKñy_. kñúgeKalbMNg

eFVIRtab;tam¬edayKµanBicarNa¦RbeTscin BYkkSRtTaMgenHQanrhUtdl;ehARbeTsrbs;xøÜnfa «Ga

NacRkkNþal»eTotpg. PaBdUcKñaénvimanGFiraCEdlBYkeKsßabnaenAelITIRkúgev: KWmanlkçN³

dUcKña ebHbiTnwgburIhamXat; (Cité interdite) enATIRkúgeb:kaMg taMgBIRbLayTwkrhUtdl;TVar. enAedIm

stvtSr_TI11 RBHraCvaMgRkúgev: )anfVayRBHmhakSRtRbeTskm<úCa EdlxøÜneFVIb£kCacat;TukdUc

RbeTscMNuHmYynUvRtaBN’masviciRteTAedayrUbstVGUdæelcRkeLatmYy EdlCaKMrUedImBitR)akd

énRtaEdlxøÜnFøab;)anTTYlBITIRkúgeb:kaMgCaskçIPaBénkarTTYlsÁal;. «PaBcEmøk»énstVEdlqøak;enA

elIRta)anbgá[mankarcg;dwgxøH²enATIRkúgPñMeBj EdlenATIbMputeK)ankMNt;stVenHeRkamkarehAfa

etacin16.

elak GaLichSg;D½r vUdésd_ )ankt;Rtafa sVamIPkþirbs;RBHecAGFiraCevotNamnigrebob

cat;karrdærbs;RBHGgÁcMeBaHRbB½n§énkarcat;Ecgneya)aycin )anCMruj[BYkcineCOfa «BYkeKrYmbgá

Cab:UlRsUbTajEpñkvb,Fm’énsgÁmxøÜnÉgmYyEdlB½T§CuMvij eday«BYkGnarüCnEdl)anEtxagbgá[

manPaBvwkvr»17. bMNgEpñkvb,Fm’rbs;raCrdæaPi)alevotNamminGaceRbób)annwgvb,Fm’rbs;

RbeTscin b:uEnþ TIéTBIvb,Fm’rbs;cinKWRbeTsevotNamB½T§CuMvijeTAedayRbeTsEdlmanvb,Fm’

sm,ÚN_EbbeTot. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday k¾BYkevotNamxøÜnÉgminEdlmanesckþITukcitþmYyEdl

GaceRbóbeFob)annwgvb,Fm’rbs;BYkcineLIy. enHehIyCaRbPBénGsßirPaBnigCemøaH Edlbgðaj

[eXIjBIkarsakl,gEdlnaM[vinasGnþrayrbs;RBHecAGFiraC mij m:ag kñúgkareFVI[RbeTskm<úCa

manlkçN³CaevotNamRbEhlenAqñaM1830 .

edIm,IbgðajPsþútagBIkarBRgIkGaNaBüa)alPaBrbs;xøÜnenARbeTskm<úCa nigbNþardætUc²

¬EdlmankSRtRKgraCü¦ enARbeTsLav evotNam)anTajykRbeyaCn_BItRmÚvkarEpñksnþisuxEfm

eTot eRkABIGMnYtek¥gk¥agEpñkvb,Fm’rbs;eK. egVón RTI Pug Cam®nþIenARBHraCvaMgRkúgev: )anbeBa©j

eyabl;enAqñaM1835fa ³ «sßanPaBPUmisa®sþrbs;RbeTsevotNamCasßanPaBEdlmaneRKaHfñak;

xøaMgNas;. RbeTsevotNammanlkçN³Tl;xñgnwgRbeTsd¾FMlVwgelVIymYyKWRbeTscin ehIyEdl

KMnitcUlcitþcm,aMgrbs;eK)anCMruj[BRgIkTwkdICab;CaRbcaMmkkan;RbeTsCitxagxøÜnEdlcincat;TukCa

RbeTsKµanGarüFm’. enAPaKxaglic nigxagt,ÚgmanCatisasn_CaeRcIncUlcitþvatTwkdIEdr Edlkar

lukluyepSg²mkelITwkdIeyIgElgmansarsMxan;eTotehIy>>>. edIm,IFananUvsnþisuxnigvibulPaB

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 133

Page 144: Brother enemy

BYkeK[evotNam]RtÚvEtRbqaMgedayKµanQb;p¥akcMeBaHkarQøanBanTaMgGs;rbs;RbCaCnnigkulsm<n§

TaMgenaH. RbeTskm<úCamanlkçN³Tn;exSay karbHe)arenAkñúgRbeTsmanlkçN³RtaMERtg EdleFVI

[RbCaCnP½yRCÜlRcbl; dUcCakarlukluyénkgT½BesomCaedIm. CaeRcInelIkeRcInsakm<úCa)an

TTUcsuMCMnYyrbs;eyIg edIm,IeFVI[mansnþisuxnigerobcM[manreboberobrykñúgRbeTsrbs;eKeLIg

vij»18. ehtuenH RBHraCvaMg ev: )anerobcMkarRtÜtRtarbs;xøÜnelIRbeTskm<úCaeRkamelsfa

karBarRbeTsenHTl;nwgkareFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;esom. enAqñaM1827 evotNamRtÚvEtCYyRBHGgÁ

m©as;LavmYyGgÁ EdlenAeRkamcMNuHxøÜn edIm,IrujRcankarKMramkMEhgrbs;esomdUcKña. RbeTs

evotNam)aneqøót»kasenH kan;kab;EdndId¾FMlVwgelVIyenAPaKxageCIgnigPaKkNþalRbeTsLav

CaBiess samenO CatMbn;mYy Edl125qñaMeRkaymk)ankøayeTACamUldæand¾rwgmaMrbs;clnats‘U

):aeftLav edaymankarKaMRTrbs;evotNampg. enAcugstvtSr_TI19 edaydeNþImykRbeTsLav

km<úCa nigevotNam RbeTs)araMg)anRtwmEtbBa©b;GFibetyümYyBan;qñaMrbs;cinmkelIRbeTsenH

b:ueNÑaH. RbeTs)araMg)anbegáIt[manneya)aynigyuT§sa®sþEtmYy ¬\NÐÚcinrbs;)araMg¦ Edl

bNþaRBHecAGFiraC RtkUl egVón hak;dUcCakMBugeFVI[seRmcBitR)akdsRmab;plRbeyaCn_pÞal;

rbs;RBHGgÁehIy.

rYbrYmKñab:uEnþminesµIKña

mYyPaKbYnénstvtSr_eRkayBIkarEbk)ak;\NÐÚcinrbs;)araMg nigkarkekItrdæLav km<úCa nig

evotNamEdlÉkraCü KMnitcg;[man«bøúk\NÐÚcin»mYyEdlRKb;RKgedayRkúghaNUy)anelceLIg

mþgeTot. etIevotNammanbMNgTTYlmrtkExSbnÞat;RBMEdnrbs;GaNaniKmedIm,I«bMeBjeKaledA

xagvb,Fm’nigneya)ayrbs;buBVbursénRbeTsevotNam»Emnb¤?»19. sBaØaNén«shB½n§\NÐÚ

cin» EdlGMBavnavedayBYkkumµúynIsþevotNamkñúgGMLúgTsvtSr_30 BuMEmnCarebobbkRsaytam

rebobfµIéncRkPBsnþtivgS egVón eTb¤?. ebIBinitü[ditdl;eTAkarvivtþénneya)ayrbs;evotNam

enA\NÐÚcinkñúgry³eBlhasibqñaMcugeRkayenH )anedA[eXIjBIkarbnþyuT§sa®sþrbs;eK ehIybT

BiesaFn_fµI²k¾RtÚv)anBRgwgeLIgEfmeTot. k¾b:uEnþ karvaytémød¾QøasévbMputrbs;eKGMBIkmøaMgCati

niymepSg²nigsßirPaBPUmisa®sþneya)aykñúgtMbn; )anXaXaMgmin[RkúghaNUyerobcMneya)ay

bc©úb,nñmYyRsbKñanwgneya)ayevotNamsm½yRBHecAGFiraC)aneLIy.

erOgRbvtþisa®sþniyayt²KñamYyGHGagfa hUCImij Føab;rkSabMNgy:agx¢ab;x¢ÜnGMBI«shBn§½

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg134

Page 145: Brother enemy

\NÐÚcin»mYyeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;evotNamehIybMNgenHKWCaRbPBedIménkarbegáItbkSkumµúy

nIsþ\NÐÚcinenaHÉg. tamBit KMnitén]tþmanuPaB¬PaBsMxan;d¾elIslb;¦rbs;evotNam enA\NÐÚcin

enH)anRtÚvdak;bgçMeTAtamqnÞ³rbs;GgÁkarkUminETneTAvijeT. [kUminETn CaGgÁkarkumµúynIsþGnþrCati

TIbIbegáItedayelnInenAExmIna qñaM1919 RtÚv)anrMlayecalenAqñaM1943. BaküenHCaGkSrkat;

énPasarusSIú BaküeBjeljKW (Kommounistitcheski Internatsional)-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb]. karRsav

RCavkñúgeBlfµI²enHbgðaj[eXIjfa kñúgGMLúgTsvtSr_30 BYkkumµúynIsþevotNam)anykcitþTukdak;

y:agxøaMgedIm,ICYyeFVI[karbdivtþn_enALavnigkm<úCarIklUtlas;pgEdr. enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1930 Cn

kumµúynIsþCaeRcInRkúm)anRbmUlpþúMKñaenARkúghugkug edIm,IbegáItbkSmYyfµIEdlBYkeK[eQµaHfa bkS

kumµúynIsþevotNam. karseRmccitþenaHnaM[mankarsþIbenÞasy:agxøaMgBIsMNak;GgÁkarkUminETn

edayTietonBIKMnitCatiniymceg¥ótcg¥l;nigkarmindwgBIlT§iGnþrCatiniymvNѳGFnrbs;eK. tam

bBa¢arbs;GgÁkarkUminETn eQµaHbkS)anRtÚvpøas;eTACabkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinvij. GgÁkarkumµúynIsþ

GnþrCati)anGHGagfa karkan;kab;RtÜtRtarbs;GaNaniKm)araMgKWCasRtÚvEtmYyKt;rbs;RbCaCn

\NÐÚcin dUecñHedIm,IvayRbyuT§nwgkarkan;kab;enaH RtÚvRBmeRBógKñabegáItCaGgÁkarÉkPaBmYy.

TsSnavdþImYyrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcincuHkalbriecäTqñaM1932 )aneFVIGtßaFib,ayfa «fVId,it

RbeTsTaMgbI ¬Lav km<úCa nig evotNam¦ CaBUCsasn_bIxusKñaCamYyPasa RbéBNI nigGakb,kiriya

b£kBaxusKñak¾eday k¾BYkeK)anbegáItCaRbeTsEtmYynigdUcKañ>>>. eKBuMGaceFVIbdivtþedayrebobdac;

edayELkenAevotNam km<úCa nigenALav)aneT. edIm,IRbQmmuxttaMgnwgsRtÚvRbqaMgbdivtþn_ Edl

kmøaMgTaMgGs;RbmUlpþúMeRkambBa¢akarÉkPaBkñúgTUTaMg\NÐÚcinenaH bkSkumµúynIsþRtÚvEtRbmUlpþúMkmøaMg

vNѳGFnenA\NÐÚcinbegáItCarNsirSrYbrYmmYy eRkamkardwknaMrbs;vNѳGFn\NÐÚcin ¬EdltMNag

edaybkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcin¦»20.

ebIeTaHCamankarENnaMTaMgenHk¾eday k¾karxitxMRbwgERbgTaMgLayrbs;evotNamedIm,IRbmUl

«vNѳGFnenA\NÐÚcin» b¤eRCIserIsGñksuMcUlbkSCaCnCatiLav b¤CnCatiExµrminsUv)anlT§pleLIy

eRBaHtamRbeTsTaMgenaHesÞIrEtKµanmnusSEdleKRtÚvkarpg. skþanuBl¬kmøaMgEdlGaceRbI)an¦

bdivtþEdllak;xøÜntamPUmitUc²enARbeTsLav nigkm<úCaBMuTan;elcecjc,as;las;enAeLIy. mü:ageTot

evotNamk¾manTsSn³sMKiHmYycMeBaHRbeTsTaMgBIrEdr. srubeTAbkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcin KWCabkSmYy

rbs;evotNam. enARbeTsLavnigenARbeTskm<úCapÞal; Rkúmts‘UEpñkneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþ

\NÐÚcin mansmasPaBPaKeRcInsuT§EtCaCnGenþaRbevsn_evotNam. eKalkarN_GnþrCatiniymén

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 135

Page 146: Brother enemy

GgÁkarkUminETn nigCMenOrbs;xøÜnGMBIrdæshB½n§mYytamEbbEpnsUevotenaH y:agehacNas;)an

bNþal[bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinGnum½tkarseRmccitþmYyenAkñúg»kasénsmaCelIkdMbUgrbs;xøÜn na

ExmIna 1935 edayrMB£kBIyfaPaBénkarbegáItshB½n§mYy. GtßbTenH)anedAbBa¢ak;fa «enAeBl

EdlBYkcRkBtþi)araMgRtÚv)anbeNþjecjBI\NÐÚcin RbCaCatinImYy²nwg)anTTYlsiT§isV½yseRmc

¬karseRmckic©karGVI²edayxøÜnÉg¦. siT§isV½yseRmcenHGaccUlrYmkñúgshB½n§k¾)an b¤begáItrdæ

mYydac;edayELkk¾)an. RbCaCatinImYy²nwgmanesrIPaBcUlrYm b¤dkxøÜnBIshB½n§. siT§ienHGac

rYbrYmnigRbB½n§NamYyk¾)antamkareRCIserIsrbs;xøÜn».21 enAedImTsvtSr_40 BYkevotNam)an

yl;dwgBI]tþmKtiCatiénRbCaCnLav nigkm<úCaEfmeTot CaBiesskarykcitþTukdak;rbs;RbCaCneTA

elIclnaExµr\sSr³Edlkan;EtrIkFMeLIg². enAqñaM1941 esckþIseRmccitþmYyrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ

\NÐÚcin )anKUsbBa¢ak;BIPaBcaM)ac;kñúgkar«eRbIR)as;neya)aysmRsbmYysþIBIsiT§isV½yseRmcCati»

eRkayBIkarcakecjrbs;BYk)araMg. GtßbT)anbnþfa «enHCasiT§irbs;RbCaCnenA\NÐÚcin kñúgkar

seRmccitþrbs;xøÜn ebIsinCaBYkeKR)afñarYmKñabegáIteTACashPaBénsaFarNrdæRbCaFibetyü b¤

pÞúyeTAvijcg;sßitenACardædac;edayELkk¾)an»22. db;qñaMeRkaymk sBaØaNénshB½n§xagneya

)ayEdlminR)akdRbCaenH)anRtÚveKe)aHbg;ecal. bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcin RtÚvEbgEckeTACabIbkS

tamCatinImYy² eFVIy:agNakMu[BYk)araMg man»kasbeBaäHmenaseBa©tnaRbqaMgevotNamBIsMNak;

RbCaCnLav nigExµr)an. eTaHCaKMnitGMBIshB½n§min)anseRmck¾eday k¾KMnitmYyeTot)anepþImcak;

b£sEdr Edltamry³enaH karcat;EcgdwknaMEpñkmenaKmviC¢a nigkarRbyuT§edIm,IÉkraCüPaBenA\NÐÚcin

RtÚvFøak;eTAelIevotNamdEdl. karRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgBYk)araMg)anbMeBjKMnitenHEfmeTot.

kñúgeBlCamYyKña EdlevotNamcab;epþImecosvagkareFVI[maneRKaHfñak; edayeRbóbeFob

nwgKMnitshB½n§EdlENnaMedayGgÁkarkUminETn edayBit kardwknaMeFVIRbtibtþikareyaFa )anRbTaj

BYkeKeTArkTispÞúyKñay:agCak;c,as;. \NÐÚcin)anelceLIgCaerogral;éf¶eFVI[evotNamemIleXIj

fa CasmrPUmiCayuT§sa®sþEtmYyKt;. evotNamecHeFVI[RbéBNIEpñkeyaFarbs;xøÜnTMenIbeLIg

edayGnuelameTAtambTBiesaFn_énkarts‘Urbs;dUntaxøÜnTl;nwgRbeTscin EdleFVIs®gÁamRbCaCn

tamKMnit em:A. b:uEnþ xusEbøkBIBYkkumµúynIsþcin evotNamBuMmankEnøgsRmab;karBarEdndId¾FMlVwgelVIy

edIm,IerobcMT½Brbs;BYkeKeLIgvijmunnwgecjeTAsakl,gnwg]tþmPaBrbs;sRtÚveLIy. BYkeKBuMGac

eFVIsm,TanedIm,IBnüareBleT. cMNucexSayenH)ankøayeTACaCak;Esþg enAeBlEdlRbeTs)araMg

eRbIR)as;TMhMEdndITaMgmUlrbs;\NÐÚcin. enAqñaM1947 BYk)araMg)ancab;epþImeFVIkarvaylukkñúg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg136

Page 147: Brother enemy

visalPaBy:agFMRbqaMgnwgkEnøgkarBarmaMTaMnanarbs;evotmij cab;BIRbeTsLav nigRbeTskm<úCa.

RbvtþiviTUxagkgT½B vIløIyuaM FWrlI )ankt;smÁal;fa «bTBiesaFn_enH )anbgçM[evotNamRbemIlemIl

karbdivtþn_enARbeTsLavnigkm<úCafa CameFüa)aysRmab;vayRbharBYk)araMgBIcMehog nigeFVI[

kgT½B)araMgmYyEpñkElgeFVIskmµPaBekIt»23.

enAqñaM1950 enAeBlEdlevotmijerobcMkarvaybkrbs;xøÜnRbqaMgTl;nwgBYk)araMg ]tþm

esnIy_ y:ab EdlCaGñkbBa¢aRbtibtþikarswkTaMgGs;)anEtgniBn§esovePAesþIgmYyEdlCaXaøMg

B½t’manBitR)akdsþIBIyuT§sa®sþrbs;evotNamenAkñúgtMbn;enH. Kat;)ansresrfa «\NÐÚcin KWCa

TItaMgyuT§sa®sþnigCasmrPUmirYmEtmYyKt;. edaymUlehtuenHehIyEdlvaKµanRbeyaCn_Tal;Et

esaHkñúgkarrMB£kBIÉkraCüPaBrbs;RbeTsevotNam drabNaRbeTskm<úCa nigLavenAEtsßitenA

eRkamkarRtÜtRtarbs;cRkBtþiniymenaH ehIyeyIgk¾BuMGacéllk[RbeTskm<úCamYynigRbeTs

LavmYyÉkraCü)anEdr drabNaevotNamenAEtRtÚvRtÜtRtaedayBYkcRkBtþi. BYkGaNaniKmsuT§Et

Føab;eRbIR)as;RbeTskm<úCaedIm,IvayRbharmkelIRbeTsevotNam. RbeTsLavnigkm<úCa )ankøay

eTACamUldæaneRkayCabeNaþHGasnñEdlsRtÚvEtgEtrYcputBIkarvayRbharCanic© kñúgeBldMNalKña

EdlsmrPUmienA\NÐÚcinCakEnøgEdlgayrgeRKaHxøaMgeTAvij. edayehtuenH eyIgRtÚvEtebIk

rNsirSRbyuT§enALav-km<úCaedayemaHmut nigedaykmøaMgT½BTaMgGs;rbs;eyIg»24.

edayP¢ab;TegVInigsmþI evotmij)anvayRbharCabnþbnÞab;enAPaKxageCIg PaKkNþal nigPaK

xagt,ÚgRbeTsLav RBmTaMgPaKkNþalevotNampgEdr munnwgekogBYk)araMg[Føak;eTAkñúgGnÞak;enA

eDonebonPUy:agRby½tñRbEygbMput. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH kgT½BevotNammYycMnYntUc)anrYbrYm

nwgExµr\sSr³ehIyeFVITukçbukemñjrMxanBYk)araMgEdlenAkm<úCa. edayelIkTg;C½yssuMcuHcaj; bnÞay

eDonebonPU)anpþl;CasBaØaénkarcakecjrbs;BYk)araMg BuMRtwmEtBIevotNamb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþBI

\NÐÚcinTaMgmUl.

sRtÚvrYmrbs;GñkCatiniym KWRbeTs)araMgEdlBIeBlenHeTARtÚv)anbeNþjecjBIsmrPUmi

\NÐÚcinGs;ehIy. k¾b:uEnþkñúgbNþaqñaMeRkay²mkeTot RBwtþikarN_epSg²énkarRbyuT§Kñarbs;evot

Nam edIm,IbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTsrbs;xøÜneLIgvij hak;dUcCaGHGagbEnßmnUvsuBlPaBniekçbbTrbs;

y:ab [rwtEtCak;c,as;eLIgeTot. BYkKUsRtÚvnwgkarbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTsevotNameLIgvij EtgEt

RtÚvkarEdndIkm<úCanigLavCaRbeTsCitxagxøÜnCanic© kúñgkarTb;sáat;karrulmkmuxrbs;kumµúynIsþk¾dUc

RkúghaNUyEdr edIm,IeFVI[kic©xitxMRbwgERbgTaMgLayrbs;xøÜnseRmceCaKC½y. dUcEdlelak FWrlI

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 137

Page 148: Brother enemy

)ankt;smÁal;KW munnwgbgá[mans®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTI2 shrdæGaemrikEdlsmKMnitnwgRbeTséf

)aneqøótTajGtßRbeyaCn_BIGsßirPaBneya)ayenARbeTsLav edayerobcMQreCIgenAtMbn;val

rabdEdl CaTIEdlBYk)araMgFøab;vayevotmijkalBImun. tamrebobdUcKñaenH karEbgEckRbeTs

evotNamtambeNþayExSRsbTI17CabeNþaHGasnñ EdlseRmcedaysnñisITRkúghSWENv )an

bgçM[bkSBlkrevotNamEdlkan;GMNacenAPaKxageCIgeRbIR)as;pøÚvrebogCaeRcInrbs;RbeTsLav

edIm,IrkSakarTak;TgCamYyGgÁkarcat;taMgrbs;xøÜnenAPaKxagt,Úg. enAevotNamxagt,ÚgEtmþg CaTI

Edls®gÁamT½BéRBeCOnelOneTAmux eKsmÁal;eXIjmanExSbNþajpøÚvlMmYyBuHkat;taméRBPñMeq<aH

mktMbn;PaK|sanRbeTskm<úCaqøgkat;tambriB½T§PUmism,ÚreTAedayPñMénRbeTsLavpgenHKWCapøÚvlM

hUCImijd¾l,Il,aj CaRbB½n§pøÚvd¾saMjúaMmYyEdlGacebIkrfynþ)an manbeNþayTaMgGs;RbEvg

RbEhl13>000KILÚEm:Rt. kñúglMdab;EdlpøÚvlMenHkøayCaExSry³Tak;Tgd¾sMxan;esµIGayuCIvit

rbs;BYkkumµúynIsþeq<aHmkPaKxagt,ÚgenaH shrdæGaemrikk¾begáIns®gÁamrbs;xøÜnEdlminRbkasecj

muxRbqaMgnwgevotNamkan;EtxøaMgeLIg²Edr. GaemrikaMg)anpÁt;pÁg;smÖarswkmYyEpñksRmab;kgT½B

PUminÞLav ehIymYyEpñkeTotsRmab;GñksuIQñÜlc,aMgEdleKeRCIserIsBIkñúgbNþakulsm<½n§enAtam

mUldæanenaH. eRKaHfñak;cab;manrUbragc,as;las;enAPaKxagt,Úg evotkug)ancab;epþImerobcMbNþa

TICRmknigTItaMge)aHT½BbeNaþHGasnñenAmçagRBMEdnrbs;xøÜnKWkm<úCaEdltameKalkarN_CaRbeTs

GBüaRkwtmYy.

rdæRbharenAExmIna qñaM1970RbqaMgnwgsemþc sIhnu nigkarlukluyRbeTskm<úCaEdlman

bnþbnÞab;Kñamindac;edayBYkGaemrikaMg )aneFVI[RBMEdncugeRkayRtÚvrlMrlay. \NÐÚcinTaMgmUl)an

køayeTACasmrPUmiCayuT§sa®sþEtmYynigdUcBImuneLIgvij ³ karc,aMgKñaedIm,IbRgÜbbRgÜmevotNam

CafµI )anRbRBwtþeTAkñúgéRBs,atrbs;RbeTskm<úCanigtMbn;éRBPñMenARbeTsLav. edayeFVI[braC½y

enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1971 cMeBaHkarvaybky:agsem,ImGs©arümYyrbs;BYkGaemrikaMg nigevotNamxag

t,Úg kñúgeKaledAyayIRbeTsLavnigkat;pþac;pøÚvlMhUCImijehIyedayvaybM)ak;RbtibtþikarswkFM²

EdlepþImeFVIeday ln; nl; kñúgqñaMdEdlenaH evotNamxageCIg)anRtÜtRtaTItaMgmYyxagkmøaMgT½BenA

\NÐÚcineday\tRbEkk)an. kic©RbwgERbgd¾sem,ImkñúgkarCYybNþúHbNþalnigkarCYy]btßmÖrbs;

evotNamdl;BYk):aeftLavnigExµrRkhmBitCaCMnYymYyEdlBYkeKRtÚvkarbMput. enAeBlenaH

smrPUmiRbyuT§)anRtÚverobcMCaeRscedIm,IvayRbyuT§pþac;RB½RtenAniTaXrdUvqñaM1975. niekçbbT

rbs; y:ab EdlEtgniBn§kalBIémÖR)aMqñaMmun ehIyEdlbgðajfa \NÐÚcinCa«smrPUmiRbyuT§EtmYy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg138

Page 149: Brother enemy

Kt;»enaH BitCaRtwmRtÚvdUcKat;KitTukEmn. EtR)aMExeRkaymkb:ueNÑaH clnabdivtþTaMgGs;)anTTYl

eCaKC½yenAkñúgRbeTsTaMgbI.

snþiPaB)anekItman RbeTsevotNam)anxMRbwgbgábegáIt[manExSbNþajsm<½n§PaBmYy

eRkamelsTMnak;TMngBiess BitehIyKWsMedAFanasnþisuxpÞal;rbs;xøÜn b:uEnþk¾elIktemáIgkic©sh-

RbtibtþikarEpñkesdækic©mYykñúgry³eBlEvgCamYykm<úCanigLavEdr edayQrelImUldæanénPaBdUcKña

xagmenaKmviC¢a. bnþicmþg² RkúghaNUy)andwgBIKMnitCatiniymy:agemaHmutrbs;BYkExµrRkhm BI

GriPaBkan;EtrIkFMeLIg²rbs;eKcMeBaHevotNamkñúgbNþaqñaMcugeRkayéns®gÁam nigBIKMniteqVgRCúl

hYsehturbs;BYkeKeTotpg.

rhUtmkdl;eBlenH ktþaCayuT§sa®sþ)anQñHelIkarviPaKrbs;evotNamGMBIsßankarN_enA

\NÐÚcin. ebIG‘Ícwg evotNamKWCaGñkbnþRTwsþIEpñkeyaFarbs;snþtivgS egVón edayrebobd¾Cak;lak;

mYy. b:uEnþ kñúgdMNak;kalénkarksagnigkarBRgwgRbeTseLIgvijbnÞab;BIs®gÁam bBaðaxagmenaKm

viC¢anigesdækic©)ancab;mansarsMxan;CafµI. ebIsinCakm<úCapþac;s<anemRtICamYyRbeTsevotNam

ehIyGnuBaØat[BYksRtÚvrbs;evotName)aHTItaMgenAelITwkdIrbs;xøÜn enAeBlenaH karKMramkMEhg

EdlFøab;eFVI[ egVón RTIPug nig v:egVóny:ab RBÜy)armÖxøaMgbMputenaH)anelcecjCafµI. mü:agvijeTot

karGnum½tRbkan;ykedayRbeTskm<úCanUvyuT§sa®sþGPivDÆn_eqVgRCúlhYsehtumYy GaceFVI[

KeRmagkarrbs;evotNamkñúgshRbtibtþikarEpñkesdækic©nigkareRbIR)as;rYmKñanUvRbPBFnFanrbs;

RbeTsTaMgBIrenaH ERbRtLb;Gs;.

b:uEnþCadMbUg evotNamcUlcitþsgát;F¶n;eTAelIPaBCabgb¥ÚnEdllt;dMkñúgkarts‘UrYmCaCageTA

elIkarRBÜy)armÖxagEpñkesdækic© b¤bBaðasnþisuxrbs;xøÜn. «bMNulQam»mYy )ancgP¢ab;BYkLav

nigkm<úCaeTAnwgevotNam bnÞab;BIkareFVIBlIkmµy:ageRcInEdllHbg;edayevotNam enAelIsmrPUmi

RbyuT§én\NÐÚcin. v: dugy:ag Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam)anniyayR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa ³ «eyIg

TTUc[manTMnak;TMngBiessy:agxøaMg BIeRBaHRbvtþisa®sþBiPBelakKWKµanKMrU sþIBITMnak;TMngdUcRbePTenH

eT ³ RbCaCnbIRbeTs)anRbLÚkkñúgkarRbyuT§ts‘UrYmKñamYy edayrMElk RsUv Ggár GMbil nigRKab;

rMesv CYyKñaeTAvijeTAmk». tamKat;yl; karsßabna nigkarkarBarrbs;RbeTsTaMgbI RtÚvEtman

CacaM)ac;edIm,Ibnþkic©shRbtibtþikard¾CitsñiT§enH.

evotNamBuMEdlniyayrMB£kCacMhGMBIKMnitsþIBIkardak;eRbIrYmKñanUvRbPBFnFanenA\NÐÚcin

esaHeLIy. evotNamRKan;Etpþl;KMnitsþIBIshRbtibtþikarmYyedIm,IeFVIGaCIvkmµelITenøemKgÁ

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 139

Page 150: Brother enemy

b:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþtamTsSn³xagesdækic© GñkeFVIEpnkarenARkúghaNUynwgerobcM\NÐÚcinCa«kEnøgrs;»

(Espace Vital) rbs;eK. CamYyBlrdæRbEhl60lannak; rs;enARbmUlpþúMelIceRmókdItUcceg¥ótmYy

EdlmYyPaKFMCatMbn;éRBPñM ¬srubTaMgGs;dIEdldaMduH)anman6lanhikta¦ RbeTsevotNamman

épÞdIksikmµsRmab;RbCaCnmñak;²ticCageKbMputkñúgcMeNamRbeTsEdlmandIticCageKenAGasuI

GaeKñy_. enAqñaM2000RbeTsenHnwgmanBlrdædl;eTA90lannak;. sRmab;RkúghaNUy kareFVI

shRbtibtþikarCamYybNþaRbeTsCitxagenA\NÐÚcinEdlmanRbCaBlrdætic b:uEnþmansm,tþiFmµCati

eRcIn KWCaPaBcaM)ac;mYy.

edayniyayrebobminc,as;las;GMBIkareFVIEpnkarmYysRmab;\NÐÚcin m®nþIEpnkarCan;x<s;

mñak;rbs;evotNam ec evottan; )anbeBa©jKMniteyabl;enAedImqñaM1980fa ³ «elImUldæanénsßan

PaBCayuT§sa®sþ EdlBwgBak;KñaeTAvijeTAmkrvagRbeTsevotNam/ RbeTsLavnigkm<úCa vacaM)ac;

RtÚvP¢ab;bNþatMbn;EdlmanlkçN³yuT§sa®sþsMxan;CamYynwgbNþatMbn;EdlmanlkçN³esdækic©xøaMg/

erobcMBRgaynigEbgEckkmøaMgkargarnigRbCaCn[esµIKña edayrebobbBa©ÚltMbn;TaMgLayEdl

plitRsUv/ tMbn;]sSahkmµ/ ehdæarcnasm<n§nanapg>>>»25.

KWTal;EteRkayBIkarelceFøaeLIgy:agc,as;nUvPaBtantwgrvagcin-evotNam eTIbRkúg

haNUycab;epþImsMGagelITLðIkrN_epSg²EdlmanlkçN³yuT§sa®sþ CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;TMnak;TMng

Biessrbs;xøÜn. kaEstRbcaMéf¶rbs;kgT½BevotNam «Kn;dUyjinhSin» )anRbkasenAExemsa

1979 dUcenHfa «taMgBICagmYystvtSr_mkehIy Rbvtþisa®sþrvagevotNam Lav nigkm<úCa

EtgEtlayLMeTAedayeCaKvasnaCamYyKñaCanic©. enAeBlEdlRbeTsmYykñúgcMeNamRbeTs

TaMgbIRtÚveKlukluy b¤P¢ab;CarNb ÉkraCüPaBb¤esrIPaBrbs;RbeTsBIrepSgeTot k¾RtÚvrgkarKMram

kMEhgdUcKña ehIysnþiPaBk¾BuMGacekItmanRKb;RbeTs)anEdr. edayehtuenH sRtÚvrbs;RbeTs

NamYy KWCasRtÚvrbs;RbeTsTaMgbIedayecosminrYc. karEfrkSaÉkPaB sm<½n§PaBkñúgkarRbyuT§

suT§EtCalkçxNÐcaM)ac;rbs;bdivtþkñúgRbeTsTaMgbI». edayCMrujRTwsþIenHeTAmuxeTot evotNam

)anGHGagy:agrh½sfa BIbTBiesaFn_CaRbvtþisa®sþenH muxCaelcecj«c,ab;»mYy EdlBYksRtÚv

mansRmab;bgáehtuenA\NÐÚcin edayehtufa ÉkPaBenHFanadl;ÉkraCürbs;RbeTsTaMgbI TnÞwmnwg

enH BYkmhaGMNacxageRkAk¾xMRbwgERbgerobcMkarRtÜtRtaTaMgmUlrbs;xøÜnEdr edayenAeBldMbUg

eKeFVI[RbeTsTaMgenHTas;ETgEbk)ak;Kña tmkeTotcUlkan;kab;RbeTsTaMgbImþgmYy². ]tþmesnIy_

evotNammñak;)anRbkas[dwgenAqñaM1984fa «kñúgkarXubXitedIm,IP¢ab;\NÐÚcinCarNbnigBRgIk

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg140

Page 151: Brother enemy

\T§iBlrbs;BYkeKenAGasIu-GaeKñy_ BYkRbtikiriyaeb:kaMgmineRbIviFIGVIepSgBIenHeLIy»26.

GñkkarBarRbcaM]bTVIb\NÐÚcin

karbegáIt «c,ab;» TaMgenHkñúgRbvtþisa®sþrbs;\NÐÚcin KWRbEhlCamanlkçN³Rbkan;bkSBYk

xøH. k¾b:uEnþ GVIEdlEbøkenaHKWRbvtþisa®sþnigPUmisa®sþneya)ay ¬karsikSaBI\T§iBlénbNþaktþaxag

PUmisa®sþeTAelIneya)ayGnþrCati¦ )anbgðaj[eXIjfa karRbqaMgCMTas;rbs;cin cMeBaHcMNg;RKb

sgát;elIeKrbs;evotNamenA\NÐÚcin manlkçN³minERbRbÜleLIy. lkçN³cm,geKkñúgRbvtþién

TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;RbeTscinCamYycMENkénEdndIeKakGasuIGaeKñy_ KWkareTarTn;eTArkkartaMg

xøÜnCaGñkkarBarsNþab;Fñab;nigsßirPaBminlMeGogenAkñúgtMbn;. BitehIyfa elIkElgEtkarlukluy

RbeTsevotNamedayraCvgS mij enAqñaM1407 nigkarbBa¢Únkgnavarbs;cinmkkñúgEdnsmuRT

GasuIGaeKñy_enAedImstvtSTI15 RbeTscinBuM)aneRbIkmøaMgT½B edIm,IedIrtYnaTICaGñkkarBareLIy.

tamFmµta yUr²mþg RBHraCaNacRkmYyb¤mYyeTot kñúgcMeNamRBHraCaNacRkEdlcMNuHenAkñúg

tMbn; )anGMBavnavcMeBaHRbeTscinedIm,IrMgab;eKalbMNgcg;QøanBanrbs;bNþaRbeTsCitxag ehIy

edayehtuenH RBHecAGFiraCminEdlxkxansþIRbedARbeTscMNuH EdlRtÚvecaTRbkan;esaHeLIy.

kñúgkarsþIRbedArebob«BukRbedAkUnnigmanlkçN³EbbxugCW RBHecAGFiraC y:uglI )anbBa¢ÚneTA

[RBHmhakSRtRbeTséf nUvBaküecaTRbkan;epSg²rbs;nKrcm,:a m:aLaka nig s‘Um:aRta Edlbþwg

briharBIkarQøanBanrbs;éf. RBHecAGFiraC)anbgÁab;bBa¢afa ³ «cab;BI\LÚvenHeTARtÚveFVItamc,ab;/

RtÚvedIrtambNþaeKalkarN_d¾RtwmRtÚv/ karBarRBMEdnrbs;Gñk/ RtÚvmanesckþIéføfñÚrCamYybNþa

RbeTsCitxagrbs;Gñk edayrebobeFVIy:agNa edIm,IeRtkRtGalnUvKuNRbeyaCn_ énsnþiPaBd¾

FMeFgCaerogrhUt»27.

BIeRkaytYnaTICaRBHecAGFiraCminlMeGog manbiT)aMgnUvbMNgrbs;cinkñúgkarEfTaMPaBs¶b;s¶at;

enAPaKxagt,Úg nigseRmceFVI[mantulüPaBkmøaMgmYyrvagrdætUc²kñúgtMbn; EdlFøab;karBarsßirPaB

pÞal;rbs;xøÜn. ka®sþIbenÞasrbs;RBHecAGFiraC BuMGacraraMgmin[evotNam P¢ab;TwkdInKrcm,:a nigmin

[BYkéfvayRbharm:aLaka)aneLIy b:uEnþ karvatTITwkdIrbs;bNþaRbeTscMNuHenAPaKxagt,Úg BuM)an

eFVI[eRKaHfñak;dl;snþisuxrbs;RbeTscin ehIyk¾mineFVI[b:HBal;dl;PaBRbesIrx<g;x<s;CageKrbs;

xøÜnEdr. eTaHbICaRbeTscMNuHnanaTmøab;eFVIG‘Ícwgk¾eday k¾RbeTsTaMgenaH)aneFVI[«cRkPBkNþal»

Elgxwgsm,aEdr edaysEmþgnUvkarsuMeTaseTAtampøÚvc,ab; nigedaybBa¢ÚnsYysarGakreTAfVay.

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 141

Page 152: Brother enemy

enAkñúgGtItkal manehtuplsMxan;mYyEdlXaXaMgmin[RbeTscineFVIGnþraKmn_edaykmøaMg

eyaFaenAPaKxagt,Úg ³ CaerOy² RbeTscinEtgEtRbmUlpþúMkarykcitþTukdak;rbs;xøÜneTAelIPaK

Bay½BüCanic©. kñúgry³eBlCaeRcInstvtSmkehIy BYkcrkCn ¬Cnrsat;GENþt\tmanlMenAR)akd

RbCa¦ enAGasuIkNþal-m:ugehÁal/ XItg; (Khitan) ehIyeRkaymk rusSI)aneFVIkarKMramkMEhgy:ag

F¶n;mkelIxøÜn. RBHecAGFiraC hugvU EdlbegáItsnþtivgS mij bnÞab;BIbraC½yrbs;BYkm:ugehÁal )an

bgÁab;edaydac;xatmin[BYkkSRtsñgtMENgBIRBHGgÁ cUllukluybNþardætUc²EdlKµanGarüFm’

TaMgeTAhYsBImhasmuRTnanaTaMgkñúgtMbn;éRBPñMrbs;rdæTaMgenaH edayKµanehtuplEdlKYrykCakar

)aneLIy. RBHGgÁ)anGHGagenAqñaM1371fa «ebIsinrdæTaMgenaHmineFVI[rMxandl;RbeTscineT vamin

manbBaðaRtÚvvayRbharRbeTsTaMgenaHeLIy. b:uEnþ cMeBaHBYkGnarüCnenAPaKBay½BüEdlrYmbgáCa

karKMramkMEhgmYycMeBaHRbeTscinCaeRcInCMnan;mkehIy eyIgRtÚvEteRtómxøÜneFVIGnþraKmn_RbqaMg

nwgBYkeKCadac;xat»28.

karsakl,gmYyGMBIkarbgÁab;bBa¢aenH )anelceLIg[eXIjenAcugstvtSTI19 enAeBlEdl

RBHecAGFiraCcinmYyGgÁRtÚvseRmccitþRbQmmuxnwgeRKaHfñak;NamYykñúgcMeNameRKaHfñak;CaeRcIn

EdlKMramkMEhgRbeTsCatikñúgeBldMNalKña enAPaKxageCIgnigPaKxagt,Úg. enAqñaM1882

ÉksarmYyrbs;cin)anBN’naBIRbeTsevotNamfaCa«r)aMgmYysRmab;GaNacRkkNþal» TukRKan;

karBarRbeTscinPaKxagt,Úg. ebITukCavasßitenAeRkAraCaNacRkeyIgk¾eday k¾«eyIgBuMGace)aHbg;

ecalEdr». k¾b:uEnþBIrqñaMeRkaymk eRkamkarekobsgát;rbs;)araMgenAPaKxagt,Úgcab;BIevotNameTA

nigkarKMramkMEhgBIs®gÁammYyrvagrusSIú-Cb:unenAPaKxageCIg snþtivgS CIg EdlfmfykmøaMg)an

bdiesFkatBVkic©EbbxugCWniymrbs;xøÜnEdlRtÚvkarBarRBHmhakSRtrbs;evotNamEdlCaesþc

cMNuHxøÜn. m®nþImñak;rbs;raCvgS CIg )anR)ab;[dwgfa «kñúgCemøaHbc©úb,nñ [rvagRbeTscinnig)araMg

BIerOgRbeTsevotNam] karKaMBarRbeTscMNuHmYyKWCabBaðatUctac cMENkkarBRgwgkic©karBar

GaNacRkrbs;xøÜnKWCabBaðasMxan;Cag».29 enACMnan;enaH eday)armÖnwgsnþisuxpÞal;rbs;xøÜn

RbeTscinEdlRBWxøacBIkarvayRbharrbs;rusSúI-Cb:unenAPaKxageCIg )ancuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØa

eTonsuIn enAqñaM1885 CamYyRbeTs)araMgehIye)aHbg;ecalGFibetyüPaBrbs;xøÜnelIRbeTs

evotNam.

enAqñaM1949 saFarNrdæRbCamanitcin)anerobcMxøÜnQancUlkñúgBiPBelaksm½yTMenIbxag

vis½yTMnak;TMngedayesµIPaBKñarvagrdænana. kñúgzan³Cardæm:akSsuIsniym RbeTscinRtÚvTTYlbnÞúk

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg142

Page 153: Brother enemy

eRbIsBaØaN «GnþrCatiniymvNѳGFn»edayxanmin)an. tamBit GVIEdlTak;Tgnwgneya)aybreTs

énRbvtþuisa®sþnigkgVl;Edlmanrab;stvtSr_mkehIykñúgkarr:ab;rgsnþisuxrbs;xøÜn )anman\T§iBl

CagmenaKmviC¢am:akSsuIsEdlfµIbMput ehIymü:ageTotRtÚvnaMcUlmkBIelakxaglicpg. PaBdUcKñaEpñk

menaKmviC¢arvagcinkumµúynIsþ nigevotNamxageCIgKWmantémøEtkñúgrebobcat;karCak;EsþgEdl

RbeTsTaMgBIrcuHsRmúgKñaCamYyplRbeyaCn_Catierog²xøÜnb:ueNÑaH.

taMgBIkarkekItclnakumµúynIsþenAevotNam hUCImijnigbNþasmmitþrbs;Kat;)anEfrkSa

cMNgTak;Tgy:agCitsñiT§CamYybkSkumµúynIsþcin. BYkemdwknaMevotNammYuycMnYnFM)anTTYlkarbNþúH

bNþalEpñkneya)aynigeyaFaenARbeTscin nigeFVIkmµsikSakñúgkgT½BrMedaHrbs; em:A EfmeTot.

minyUrb:unµan eRkaykarbegáItsaFarNrdæRbCamanitcin Rkúgeb:kaMg)anTTYlsÁal;rdæaPi)alrbs; hU

EdleBlenaHsßitenAkñúgéRBenAeLIy kñúgzan³CasaFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüevotNam. sRmab;Ca

elIkTIBIrehIykñúgRbvtþisa®sþ-elIkTImYyKWkareFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;RkúmTg;exµA (Pavillons Noirs) RbqaMg

BYk)araMg RbEhlenAqñaM1880-EdleRKÓgsa®sþavuFnigTahanrbs;cin)anqøgkat;RBMEdnmkCYy

RbeTsevotNamRbyuT§Tl;nwgsRtÚvbreTsmYy. [Tg;exµAKWRkúmTahanminerobry¬KµanÉksNæan

dUcTahanFmµta¦rbs;cinEdlRbyuT§nwgBYk)araMgenAtugkwg CaBiessenAqñaM1883-1885 -kMNt;

rbs;GñkbkERb]. karpÁt;pÁg;smÖarswkd¾sem,Imrbs;cin)anCYy[ y:ab TTYlC½yCmñHCaRbvtþisa®sþ

rbs;Kat;elIBYk)araMgenAeDonebonPUkñúgqñaM1954. eRkaymk Rkúgeb:kaMg)anGYtxøÜnfa TIRbwkSaCan;

x<s;cinCaeRcInnak;CaBiess]tþmesnIy_ ecn kag )anERbkøayxøÜnCaGñkyuT§sa®sþmñak;kñúgcMeNamGñk

yuT§sa®sþBitR)akdTaMgLay. enHCaGMnYtek¥gk¥agEdleFVI[evotNamGs;sMeNIc. GVIxøHeTAGacCa

tYnaTIBitR)akdrbs;cinkñúgcm,aMgenH? RBwtþikarN_epSg²EdlmanmkxageRkay²eTot)anbgðajfa

karcUlRbLÚkrbs;cin manehtupltRmÚv[eFVIdUecñH edaysarkarRBÜy)armÖEdlxøÜnRtÚvl,g[dwg

edIm,IsnþisuxpÞal;rbs;RbeTsxøÜnenAtamRBMEdnPaKxagt,ÚgdUcKñanwgmenaseBa©tnarbs;xøÜnEdlman

cMNgEpñkmenaKmviC¢aCamYyevotmijEdr.

bnÞab;BIkarecjpSayÉksarsm¶at;xøH²rbs;snñisITRkúghSWENvsþIBI\NÐÚcin ¬qñaM1954¦

karelcmuxrbs;RbeTscinsm½y em:A CaelIkdMbUgelIqakGnþrCati-\LÚvenH eK)anføwgEføgcMNucGVI

xøH EdlRbeTscinxitmkrkbBaða\NÐÚciny:agKYr[q¶l; eRBaHtaMgBIedIm vaminEdlG‘ÍcwgesaH. elak

b:UlmUs GñkÉkeTsd¾l,Il,ajxagbBaðaevotNam CaGtItTIRbwkSasñgkarCan;x<s;rbs;)araMgenA

\NÐÚcin)aneBalGHGagenAqñaM1965fa enARkúghSWENvRbeTscin)aneFVIsm,Tany:ageRcIn[BYk

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 143

Page 154: Brother enemy

)araMgkñúgeKalbMNgbM)at;min[evotNameFVIm©as;elI\NÐÚcinTaMgRsug. db;bYnqñaMeRkaymk RbvtþiviTU

®hVg;s½rhSÚy:U kñúgkarsikSaCaelIkdMbUgnUvÉksarTaMgLaykñúgbNÑsardæanrbs;)araMg Edlniyay

BItYnaTIrbs;RbeTscinenARkúghSWENvenaH k¾)anseRmceFVIesckþIsnñidæanmYydUcKñaebHbiT.

GñkxugCWniymmñak;enAhSWENv

KMnitpþÜcepþImmYyrbs;BYkcin)anGnuBaØat[snñisITecjrYcBIPaBT½lRckdMbUgmYykñúgcMeNam

PaBT½lRckCaeRcIn. rdæaPi)altsU‘ExµrnigLavEdlRbeTsevotNamFøab;CYyRTRTg;)anTamTar[xøÜn

)ancUlrYmsm½yRbCuMenAhSWENvEdr. Rkúgeb:kaMg)aneFVIkarekobsgát;eTAelIRbeTsevotNamedIm,I

[Qb;KaMRTkarTamTarenH. RbFanKN³RbtiPUcin CU eGnLay BuMyl;RsbtamTsSn³rbs;evotNam

eT EdlfardæaPi)altsU‘TaMgBIrenHCatMNagBitR)akdrbs;RbCaCnLavnigExµrenaH. Kat;k¾)anraraMg

min[RkúghaNUyebIkkarvayRbyuT§enAkm<úCa edIm,ICYyBRgwgsßanPaBrbs;clnatsU‘ExµrEdr30.

kgVl;d¾FMbMputrbs; CU KWbeBa©óskareFVIGnþraKmn_mYyrbs;GaemrikaMgenA\NÐÚcin EdlGacRbTaj

RbeTscin[Føak;eTAkñúgCemøaHmYyrwtEtFMeLIgeTot. enAeBlEdleRKaHfñak;enH hak;dUcCaeTAq¶ay

ehIy neya)aykarTUtrbs;cink¾RbwgykcitþTukdak;raraMgmin[BYkGaemrikaMgQreCIgkñúgtMbn;enH

Edr. CU eGnLay )anR)ab;[BYk)araMgdwgCaÉkCnBIkarTTYlsÁal;edayRbeTscinnUv«rdæaPi)alsñiT§

bs©imRbeTs»mYyEdlmanenARbeTsenaHRsab;. CU )anEføgR)ab;GñkkarTUt)araMgfa «ebIsinCarbb

raCaFibetyübc©úb,nñenALavnigkm<úCaTTYl)ankaryl;RBmBIRbCaCnehIy ´minyl;fa ehtuGVIk¾eK

minrkSaTuk[enAdEdleTA». Kat;)anbBa¢ak;fa RbeTscinR)afñacg;[RBHraCaNacRkTaMgBIrkøayeTA

CaRbeTsmansnþiPaBnigmanRbCaFibetyütamKMrURbeTs\NÐÚensuI PUma nig\NÐaEdr. Kat;k¾minyl;

Tas;kñúgkarEdlRbeTsTaMgBIreTArYbrYmnwgshPaB)araMgvijeT b:uEnþKat;)anRBmanfa «eyIgnwgmin

eBjcitþ[RbeTsLav nigkm<úCakøayCamUldæanT½Brbs;GaemrikaMgeLIy>>>. erOgenHnwgkøayeTACakar

KMramkMEhgmYuysRmab;snþisuxrbs;RbeTscinEdleyIgTaMgGs;KñaElgrvl;KitKUreTAehIy»31.

k¾b:uEnþ enHBuMEmnCabMNgrujBYkGaemrikaMg[q¶ayBIRBMEdncinnUvvtþmand¾maneRKaHfñak;Etmü:ag

b:ueNÑaHeT EdlCMruj[ CU TTYlsÁal;RBHraCaNacRkLavnigkm<úCa nigCYyCMruj[mankardkfykgT½B

evotmijecjBIRbeTsTaMgBIrenH. kic©RBmeRBógRkúghSWENvminyl;RBmpþl;ÉkraCüPaBTaMgRsug[

evotmijeT BIeRBaHkic©RBmeRBóg)aneRKagKitnUvkarEbgEckRbeTsevotNamCabeNþaHGasnñkñúgkar

rg;caMkare)aHeqñatTUTaMgRbeTs. b:uEnþ CU )anbBa¢ak;bMPøWR)ab;BYk)araMgCaKUsnÞnarbs;Kat;fa RbeTs

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg144

Page 155: Brother enemy

cinGnueRKaHcMeBaHGtßiPaBRbeTsevotNamBIr nigcMeBaHkarbegáItrdæeRcInenAtamRBMEdnrbs;xøÜn. kñúg

kayvikarmYyEdlcEmøkxusFmµta CU )anGeBa¢Ij paM v:an;dug rdæm®nþITImYyénsaFarNrdæRbCa

FibetyüevotNamCamYynwgKN³RbtiPU\NÐÚcinepSg²eTotEdlkñúgenaHmanTaMgtMNagrbb)avday

[GFiraCRbeTsevotNamBIqñaM1932-1945 EdlRtÚvbgçitbgçM[dak;raCüedayevotmijenAqñaM

1945 nigCaRbmuxrdærbs;evotNamBIqñaM1945-1955-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb] EdlRTRTg;

edayBYkGaemrikaMgnig)araMgpg cUlrYmbriePaKGahareBll¶acmYy. kñúgeBlbriePaK)ay CU

)anQanrhUtdl;esñI[KN³RbtiPUevotNamxagt,ÚgbegáItsßantMNagmYyenARkúgeb:kaMgEfmeTot.

dug manGakar³PJak;ep¥IlEmnETn Edl CU )anbkRsayfa «R)akdehIy paM v:an;dug CaGñkCitsñiT§

CageKrbs;eyIgxagEpñkmenaKmviC¢a b:uEnþRbkarenHBMuEmnhammin[mantMNagPaKxagt,Úgmñak;enaH

eLIy. srubeTA etIGñkTaMgBIrBuMEmnCaCnCatievotNameTb¤? ehIyeyIgTaMgGs;suT§EtCaCnCati

GasuIdUcEtKñaEmneT?».

kñúgry³eBlémÖqñaM EdlmanbnÞab;BIkic©RBmeRBógRkúghSWENv RbeTscin)anxMRbwgCab;CaRbcaM

kñúgkarEfTuk\NÐÚcinmYy[enAdac;Cakg;² mincMNuHbNþamhaGMNacFM²tammeFüa)ayRKb;Ebby:ag

EdlxøÜnman. meFüa)ayTaMgenaHnwgepþImBIneya)aykarTUtsm¶at;eTArkkarekobsgát;Epñkesdækic©

edayqøgkat;tamkarBwgEp¥kelIkmøaMgT½B. rhUtmkdl;karcab;epþImkareFVIGnþraKmn_ edaypÞal;BI

sMNak;BYkGaemrikaMgenARbeTsLavenAqñaM1963 eTIbRkúgeb:kaMgRbwgERbgCYybNþasmmitþ):aeftLav

rbs;xøÜnEtmineRcIndUckalCYyrdæaPi)alGBüaRkwtcRmúHmYy EdlGacbgáeTACardæRTnab;mYyenAPaK

xagt,ÚgxøÜneT. BYkcink¾dUcsUevotminsUvCacUlcitþeRbIR)as;kartsU‘edayGavuF edIm,Ipþl;snÞúHdl;

karbRgÜbbRgÜmPaKxageCIgnigxagt,ÚgevotNameLIy32.

karKaMRTEpñkeyaFarbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgcMeBaHkarRbwgERbgeFVIs®gÁamEdlepþImeLIgedayRkúg

haNUyenARbeTsLavnigkm<úCa)anrIkceRmIneLIgsRmab;eKaledAdMbUg KWedIm,ITb;BYkGaemrikaMg[enA

q¶ayBI\NÐÚcin ehIyeKaledATIBIrKW edIm,IRbECgCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚkñúgkarTak;TajcitþKMnitBYkkumµúynIsþ

\NÐÚcin CaGaT×KWBYkkumµúynIsþevotNam. RbeTscinkMBugeFVIxøÜnCaeCIgÉkxagkartsU‘rMedaHCatiRbqaMg

nwgcRkBtþiniymnig´kBa¢Hrbs;va dUecñHkrNIykic©rbs;xøÜn)anbgÁab;[KaMRTkarRbyuT§tsU‘rbs;evot

NamEdr. CamYykarTmøak;RKab;EbkdMbUg²rbs;GaemrikenAqñaM1964 nigbNþaqñaMCabnþbnÞab;mk

eTot karbegáItbNþajmUldæanT½BGaemrikaMgmYy nigkarbBa¢ÚnTahanGaemrikaMgcMnYn500>000nak;

mkevotNamxagt,Úg )aneFVI[mUlehtusMxan;mYykñúgcMeNammUlehtusMxan;²én\riyabfniym

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 145

Page 156: Brother enemy

kNþalEdlRbkan;ykedayRbeTscinenAhSWENvenaHRtÚv)at;bg;sarsMxan;TaMgGs;. enAcMeBaHmux

karKMramkMEhgeFVIkarvaylukevotNamxageCIgtampøÚveKakBIsMNak;BYkGaemrikaMg nigkarTmøak;RKab;

EbktampøÚvGakasenACit²RBMEdnrbs;xøÜn )aneFVI[Rkúgeb:kaMgeRtómeFVIBlikmµy:agFMeFgedIm,IRTRTg;

saFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüevotNam nigGt;Fµt;TukbeNaþy[RkúghaNUysEmþgtYnaTId¾manGMNac

elIslb;CageKenA\NÐÚcinpg.

CamYynwgkarbegáIns®gÁamenAevotNam[rwtEtxøaMgeLIg EdlseRmcedayRkúgv:asIunetan kñúg

karb:unb:gTb;sáat; «lT§ivatTIniymrbs;cin» enAGasuI-GaeKñy_ eRKaHfñak;énkarvayRbharedaypÞal;

mYyRbqaMgnwgcinElgGacbeBa©ós)anehIycab;BIeBlenHeTA. hYsBIkrNIykic©GnþrCatiniym

Fmµta CMnYyrbs;cincMeBaHkarRbyuT§rbs;BYkkumµúynIsþevotNam)ankøayeTACa«GaCJabBa¢a»mYy

edayeFVI[b:HBal;dl;snþisuxrbs;RbeTs. cagQij RbBn§rbs; em:A )anniyayR)ab;Gñksresr

CIvRbvtþirbs;Kat;sBa¢atiGaemrikaMgCasm¶at;fa «ebIsinCaevotNamxageCIgminvayRbyuT§eT eBl

enaHKµanGVIGacbeBa©ósmin[sRtÚvvayRbharBYkcineLIy»33.

«FIv enAq¶ayBIGMe)asrbs;GñkNas;/ smmitþ>>>»

b:uEnþ vadUcCaminTMngEdlRbeTscinvaytémø CYyRkúghaNUyedIm,IeFVI[QamTahanGaemrikaMg

hUrrhacfa CameFüa)ayd¾s½kþisiTi§kñúgkareFVI[sRtÚvCacRkBtþicuHexSayenaH. tamBit cinhak;dUcCa

«sVaKmn_» edaykarFUres,IykñúgcitþGMBIvtþmanrbs;kgT½BGaemrikaMgenAEk,rRBMEdnrbs;xøÜnEdr eRBaH

Cakic©FanaTl;nwgkarvayRbharedayGavuFbrmaNUCayfaehtumYy. enAExmifuna qñaM1965 enA

TIRkúgEKr¬rdæFanIRbeTseGhSIúb¦ rdæm®nþITI1 CU eGnLay )anniyayR)ab;elak NaEsSr ¬søab;enA

qñaM1970¦ RbFanaFibtIeGhSIúbCasm¶at;fa «eyIgxøacNas; EdlGñkneya)ayniymeRbIFm’ekþA

rbs;GaemrikaMgxøH CMruj[mankarvayRbharedayGavuFbrmaNURbqaMgnwgcin ehIyeyIgcat;Tukkar

Cab;édRbyuT§rbs;BYkGaemrikaMgenA\NÐÚcinfa CakarFanar:ab;rgmYyTb;Tl;nwgeRKaHfñak;enH BIeRBaH

sac;Qamrbs;eKsßitenACitbegáIynwgRkjúaMrbs;eyIg. ebIshrdæGaemrikbBa¢ÚnT½BmkevotNam

eRcIneLIgkalNa eyIgrwtEteBjcitþkalenaHEdr t,iteyIgdwgfa BYkeKsßitenAkñúgkNaþb;édeyIg

ehIyeyIgGaceFVI[QamBYkeKhUreTAtamcMNg;rbs;eyIg»34.

enAcenøaHqñaM1965 nig1968 BYkcin)anbBa¢ÚnTahan kmµkr nigGñkbec©keTssrubTaMgGs;

RbEhl320>000nak; edIm,Ir:ab;rgtP¢ab;pøÚvrfePøIgmYyrvagRbeTscinnigevotNam erobcMRbB½n§

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg146

Page 157: Brother enemy

karBarEdnGakas nigbMeBjebskkmµmYycMnYnxagCMnYybec©keTs[xanEt)andac;xat. vtþman

rbs;eKKWCayuT§viFImYyEdlerobcMy:agbuinRbsb;edIm,IraraMgshrdæGaemrik[e)aHbg;KMnitcUllukluy

evotNamxageCIgb¤KMramRbeTscinPaKxagt,Úg. Rkúgeb:kaMgk¾Fanar:ab;rgkardwkCBa¢ÚnbNþabkçCn nig

TIRbwkSaeyaFarbs;evotNameTARbeTsLav edayqøgkat;tamRbeTscinEdr. cin)anpþl;Lan

kamIjú:gcMnYn30>000eRKÓgeTA[evotNam ehIyedaysarLanTaMgenaH eRKÓgsmÖarswkrbs;cin

rab;Ban;etan)anRtÚvdwktRmg;eTAkan;eKaledAtampøÚvlMhUCImij. BYkcink¾RBmeRBógKñaCamYysemþc

sIhnu edIm,IdwkGavuFniges,ógGaharqøgkat;tamRbeTskm<úCaykeTA[evotkugenAPaKxagekIt

RbeTskm<úCaEdr.

enAExemsa qñaM1980 ´¬GñkniBn§¦)aneFVIdMeNIreTARkúgeb:kaMgedIm,IeFVIsmÖasn_ han nanLúg

Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTscinEdlCaédsþaMrbs;sBrdæm®nþITI1 CU eGnLay nigCaGñkepþImKMnitmñak;kñúg

cMeNamGñkepþImKMnitCaeRcIn sþIBIneya)ay\NÐÚcinrbs;RbeTscin. ´sYrKat;fa kñúgsm½ys®gÁam

bnÞab;BIKaMRTvtþmanrbs;evotNamenARbeTsLavnigkm<úCa ehtuGVIk¾cinEbrCaCMTas;RbqaMgenAeBlenH

eTAvij? CamnusSqab;xwgRceLat han )aneqøIyR)ab;´fa eKminGaceRbóbeFobsßanPaBEdlQñHBI

mSilCamYysßanPaBbc©úb,nñeT «enACMnan;enaH evotNamsuT§EtRtÚvbgçMcitþ[pøas;bþÚrTImkxagkñúgEdndI

rbs;RbeTsLavnigkm<úCa edaysarPaBcaM)ac;xanmin)ankñúgkarRbyuT§tsU‘Tl;nwgcRkBtþiniym

GaemrikaMg. BitehIy eBlenaHeyIg)anKaMRTBYkeK>>> b:uEnþ eyIgmineBjcitþ[RbeTsmYyEdl

kalBIedImFøab;RtÚvCiHCan;edaymhaGMNaccRkBtþimYy cab;epþImCiHCan;bNþaRbeTsCabgb¥ÚnepSg

eTotbnÞab;BITTYl)anC½yCmñHpþac;RB½RtenaHeT».

han )anbBa¢ak;GHGagR)ab;´pÞúynwgGVI²EdlTMngCakarBitfa BYkcin «minEdlB¤ hU CImij

rMB£kBIKMnitbegáItshB½n§\NÐÚcinmYy»Tal;EtesaH. edIm,Ibgðaj[c,as;BIcMNucNaEdlfñak;dwknaM

evotNambc©úb,nñ«k,t;»maKa’m:akSsuIsBitR)akdrbs;hUCImijenaH Rkúgeb:kaMg)ankMNt;kalbriecäT

CapøÚvkar KWcab;BIqñaM1975mk EdleKaledAGnutþrPaBrbs;evotNammkelI\NÐÚcin)anelcrUbrag

BitR)akdKWBuMEmnmunkalbriecäTenHeT. b:uEnþCaÉkCn bNþaemdwknaMcin CaBiess v:ag Kn;muI Priya

emm:ayrbs; lIv cavCI )anriHKn;nUvkarsnüarbs; hU CaKuNRbeyaCn_sRmab;shB½n§\NÐÚcin

mYy35.

enAExmIna qñaM1982 GñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;mYyrUbénTIPñak;garB½t’mancinfµI ehIyCamYyKat;

´)anrMB£kR)ab;BImhicäta\NÐÚcind¾cas;KMrwlrbs;evotNamenaH )anniyayerobrab;R)ab;´nUvvaküx½NÐ

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 147

Page 158: Brother enemy

mYyénkmµviFIneya)ayrbs;bkSBlkrevotNamenAqñaM1951 Tak;TgeTAnwgkarbegáItshB½n§

\NÐÚcinmYyfa «ebIeTaHCakñúgeBlmans®gÁamRbqaMgTl;nwgshrdæGaemrikk¾eday k¾evotNam [Edl

eBlenaHdwknaMeday hU CImij] minEdle)aHbg;KMnitenHesaHeLIy. karerobcM[manshB½n§mYy

rbs;\NÐÚcinKWCaeKaledAEdlBYkeKminEdlePøcTal;EtesaH. eRkamelskarBarpøÚvlM hUCImij

BYkeK)anbBa¢ÚnT½By:ageRcIneTAkan;PaKxageRkamRbeTsLavnigRbeTskm<úCa. enATIbBa©b;éns®gÁam

BYkeKminRtwmEtmindkkgT½Brbs;xøÜneTAvijeT pÞúyeTAvijBYkeKEfmTaMg)anbBa¢ÚnT½BfµI²cUleTAkñúg

tMbn;nana CaBiessenARbeTsLavPaKxagelIEfmeTot».

TsSn³rbs;cinGMBItYnaTIrbs;evotNamenA\NÐÚcinenH BuMEmnCakarsresrsRmÜlRbvtþisa®sþ

CafµIFmµtaenaHeT. RbeTscinRbEhlBuM)anbgáarCamunnUvkarb:unb:gRtÜtRtaCacMhmYyBIsMNak;evot

Nam dUcEdlraCvgS han Føab;GHGagBIerOgenHeLIy. b:uEnþeRkaymkmanktþaCaeRcIn EdleFVI[eK

Kitfa edayenAEtbnþCYyRbeTsenHy:agsþúksþmÖkñúgeBls®gÁam Rkúgeb:kaMgnwkRBÜy)armÖeRsceTA

ehIyBItYnaTIrbs;RbeTsevotNamEdlnwgeTACaGñknaMmuxeKenA\NÐÚcin. cab;taMgBIBak;kNþal

TsvtSr_60 RbeTscin)ansßabnapøÚvyuT§sa®sþmYyEdlP¢ab;BIextþyunNanmkPaKxageCIgRbeTs

Lav. TahanCagrbs;cinRbEhl20>000nak; )anmke)aHTItaMgenARbeTsLav eRkamkarKaMBarBI

kgkaMePøIgFMRbqaMgynþehaHCaeRcInedIm. tYnaTIrbs;BYkenHminkMNt;RtwmEtkarBarCYrmuxrbs;cin

b:ueNÑaHeT Etk¾RtÚveFVI[mantulüPaBxagkmøaMgCamYyvtþmanrbs;evotNamEdr kñúgkarRbemIlemIl

GnaKténkarvayRbharCayfaehtumYyBIsMNak;BYkGaemrikaMg. bnÞab;BI)anCYbBiPakSaCamYy CU

eGnLay enAqñaM1974 sþIBIbMNgedIrtamKnøgenHrYcmk hg;rI KIsSIúgh½Ár )anseRmcedayesckþI

eBjcitþy:agc,as;mYyfa vtþmanrbs;BYkcinenARbeTsLavGac[eKkarBarsßanPaBmYy «BIcMehog

evotNamEdlGaceFIVCa]bsKÁcMeBaHkarRtÜtRtaCayfaehtuénsm<n§½mitþ EdlRKan;Etsnµt [rbs;eK]

kñúg\NÐÚcinTaMgmUl»36.

enAcugTsvtSr_60 nigenAedImTsvtSr_70 kic©RbwgERbgTaMgLayrbs;BYkcin edIm,IbMEbk

smasPaBxøHrbs;):aeftLavecjBIPaBenAeRkamGMNacrbs;evotNamenaH )aneFVI[mankar

Ebk)ak;Kñay:agxøaMg ³ y:agehac CnCatiLavsñiT§cinmñak;)anRtÚveKlYcsmøab; 37. emdwknaMbkS

kumµúynIsþkm<úCa b:ul Bt )aneFVIdMeNIreTARbeTscinenAcugqñaM1965 ehIy)anTTYlkarKaMRTBI em:A

cMeBaHneya)ayÉkraCümincMNuHRkúghaNUyrbs;Kat;eTotpg. b:uEnþrdæRbharenARkúgPñMeBjkñúg

ExmIna qñaM1970 )anbegáIt[mansßanPaBfµImYy KWshRbtibtþikarrvagbkSTaMgbIrbs;\NÐÚcin)an

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg148

Page 159: Brother enemy

køayeTACalkçN³caM)ac;mYy.

enAedImdMbUg tamRBHraCtRmiHpþÜcepþImrbs; semþc sIhnu EdleTIbRtÚvTmøak;BItMENgfµI²

snñisITkMBUlrbs;RbCaCn\NÐÚcinmYy)anebIkeFVIenAkg;tug naExemsa qñaM1970 EdleBlenaH

smasPaBcUlrYmeRkABI semþc sIhnu KWman paM v:an;dug RBHGgÁm©as; sUpanuvgS én):aeftLav nig

egVógh‘uyfU énrNsirSCatirMedaHevotNamxagt,ÚgpgEdr. snñisIT)anecjesckþIEføgkarN_mYy

EdlrYmmankarRBmanmYyRbqaMgnwgGMNacRKbsgát;rbs;PaKImYykñúgcMeNamPaKITaMgGs;mkelIPaKI

epSgeTot. esckþIEføgkarN_)anEcglkçxNÐc,as;fa «epþImecjBIeKalkarN_Edlfa karrMedaH nig

karkarBarRbeTsnImYy²CaParkic©rbs;RbCaCnxøÜn PaKITaMgGs;EdlRbQmmuxdak;KñaRtÚvRbkan;Bakü

snüaeFVInUvGVI²RKb;Ebby:agEdlCasiT§iGMNacrbs;xøÜnedIm,Ipþl;nUvkarKaMRTKñaeTAvijeTAmk Rsbtam

bMNgrbs;PaKIEdlBak;B½n§ nigQrelImUldæanénkareKarBKñaeTAvijeTAmk». cMNucmYyeTot)an

sgát;bBa¢ak;fa shRbtibtþikareTAéf¶muxedIm,IksagRbeTsnImYy²eLIgvij RtÚvEt«GnuelameTAtam

kareRCIserIsrbs;RbeTsnImYy²enaH». ebITukCamaneRbIBaküeBcn_ RbúgRby½tñTaMgenHEdlCaKMnit

pþÜcepþImrbs;BYkcinnigExµrRkhmk¾eday k¾KMniténkarelIk[eTACaFmµnuBaØPaBnUvshRbtibtþikarrvag

RbCaCn\NÐÚcinKWmin)anseRmclT§pleLIy. kñúg»kasénkic©smÖasn_mYyenAExemsa qñaM1979

semþc sIhnu )anmanbnÞÚlR)ab;´fa édKUrbs;´KWBYkExµrRkhmrYmnwgBYkcinpg )anTietony:agxøaMgnUv

karpþl;eyabl;rbs;´EdlsuM[mankarebIkRbCuMsnñisITkMBUlrbs;RbCaCn\NÐÚcinelIkTI2enARkúg

haNUy enAqñaM1971. karRbCuMenaHnwgRtÚvbBa©ÚleTAkñúgRkbx½NÐénkarBieRKaHeyabl;Kñaeday

eTogTat;sMedArwtcMNg samKÁIPaBrvagsm<½n§mitþnana. karsÞak;esÞIrrbs;cin )anbgðaj[eXIjedIm

ehtu CaBiesstamry³eKalbMNgrbs;xøÜn Edlcinmincg;eFVI[raMgsÞHdl;PaBFUrRsal EdlxøÜn

cab;epþImCamYyRkúgv:asIunetaneLIy. b:uEnþ ebIBinitü[eRCACagenH karEdlcinbeBa©ósmin[man

snñisITfµImYyenaHKW xøacvaCYyBRgwgsßanPaBKnøwHEpñkeyaFarbs;RkúghaNUyenA\NÐÚcin[rwtEtrwgmaM

eLIgenaHÉg.

enAExFñÚ qñaM1971 naTIRkúgeb:kaMg semþc sIhnu )anmanbnÞÚlCasm¶at;CamYyGtItnaykrdæ

m®nþI)araMg EBür m:geds RhVg; fa RBHGgÁdUcCamincg;e)aHbg;\NÐÚcin[sßitenAeRkamkarRtÜtRtaBI

«GMNac»EtmYyKWRkúghaNUyenaHeT eRBaHfa karKµansßirPaBEdlmanCabnþmknwgbNþal[xUc

RbeyaCn_sRmab;BiPBelakTaMgmUl. «´Føab;manbnÞÚlBIerOgenH CamYy CU eGnLay EdlmanTsSn³

dUc´Edrfa bNþaRbeTsenA\NÐÚcinRtÚvEt[sßitenACaGBüaRkwtTaMgRsugdEdl. RbeTscinnwgman

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 149

Page 160: Brother enemy

RbeTsTaMgenaHCabEg¥k»38.

GtItnaykrdæm®nþI)araMg)anecaTsYrbBaðaenHedaypÞal;cMeBaH CU eGnLay EdlCaGtItKU

snÞnarbs;Kat;enAsnñisITRkúghSWENvnigGñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;cinCaeRcInnak;eTotEdr. esckþI

snñidæanrbs;Kat;KW «vac,as;Nas;Edlfa RbeTscinR)afñabeBa©ósmin[GanuPaBmYyEdlRtÜtRta

edayevotNamxageCIgBRgIkkarRtÜtRtarbs;eKmkelI\NÐÚcinTaMgmUleLIy. BYkcin)anniyay

BIÉkraCüPaBénlkçN³neya)ayrbs;RbeTsnImYy² Lav km<úCa nigevotNamxagt,ÚgEdr»39.

sRmab;BYkcinyl;fa kic©RBmeRBogsnþiPaBRkúg):arIsenAExmkra qñaM1973 )anrYmbgáCakic©

FanamYyRbqaMgTl;nwgGnutþrPaBrbs;evotNam. enAedImqñaM1973 CU )anKUsbBa¢ak;R)ab;ÉkGKÁrdæ

TUt)araMg eGTIEyn m:aNak; fa RbeTscinykcitþTukdak;xøaMgbMputeTAelImaRtaTI20énkic©RBmeRBóg

EdleRKagTuknUv «kardkkgT½Brbs;breTsTaMgGs;» ecjBIRbeTskm<úCanigLav. Kat;niyayfa

«eyIgnwgmineTA[km<úCa]eT b:uEnþeyIgk¾BuMGacyl;RBm[GñkNaepSgeToteTATIenaHEdr»40.

enAqñaM1972 shrdæGaemrikk¾RtÚvjúaMg[eCOCak;Edrfa Rkúgeb:kaMgcg;[man«karbMEbk

\NÐÚcinCabIRbeTs». edayRkúgv:asuInetanmanTsSn³dUcKña karbn§ÚrPaBtantwgrvagcin-GaemrikaMg

nwgCYysRmÜldl;erOgenaH41.

bnÞab;BIkarbeBaäHGriPaBCacMhrvagcinnigevotNamrYcmk enARkúghaNUyeK)anpSayerOg

niTancMGn;neya)ayxøI²fa em:A Føab;)anniyayTUnµan paM v:an;dug [edaHRsaybBaðarbs;xøÜn Edlman

sBVéf¶dac;edayELkBIevotNamxagt,Úg. erOgenHekItmaneLIgenAExvicäika qñaM1972. em:A )an

RbkasR)ab; dug fa «eKminGace)assMramEdlenAq¶ay)aneT ebIsinCadgGMe)asxøIeBk. RbeTs

étv:an;sßitenAq¶ayeBkBIGMe)asrbs;eyIg ehIy FIv EdlenAevotNamxagt,Úgk¾enAq¶ayxøaMgBI

GMe)asrbs;elakEdr smmitþ¡ eyIgTaMgGs;KñaRtÚvsuxcitþTTYlehtukarN_enH». eKGHGagfa dug

)anr:ab;rgnwgRbFan em:A fa GMe)asrbs;evotNammandgEvgNas;42. edayminbdiesFerOgniTan

cMGkneya)ayenH enAqñaM1973 Rkúgeb:kaMg)anbBa¢ak;bMPøWeRkaymkfa tameyabl;rbs;xøÜn Rkúg

haNUyRtÚvEtGt;Fµt;bnþic munnwgepþImkartsU‘edIm,IbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTseLIgvij. RbkarenHnwgeFVI[

sµúKsµajdl;GnþraKmn_rbs;GaemrikaMgmYyfµIEfmeTot.

CaBiessKµanevotNamEdlbRgÜbbRgÜmEtmYyeT

GVIEdlCaCMhrrbs;cinsþIBIbBaðaénkarbRgÜbbRgÜmevotNameLIgvij KWRkúgeb:kaMg)anRbwgERbg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg150

Page 161: Brother enemy

rkSaTMnak;TMngedayÉkraCüy:agCak;R)akdCamYyrNsirSrMedaHCatiEdlenAPaKxagt,Úg. kareRtóm

bRmúgepSg²EdlepþImedayBYkcinedIm,InaMeRKÓgsa®sþavuF es,ógGahar nigRkdasR)ak;eTApþl;[

rNsirSrMedaHCatiedayqøgkat;tamRbeTskm<úCaBuMEmnedaysarEtehtuplsnþisuxb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþ

RbEhlCaedayectnarbs;cinkñúgkarrkSaTMnak;TMngedaypÞal;mYyCamYyGñkbdivtþn_evotNamxagt,Úg

pgEdr. bnÞab;BIbdivtþvb,Fm’ enAqñaM1966-67RkúghaNUy)anerobcMeRKÓgTb;mYycMeBaHkar

sayPayénkareXasnarbs;cinenAPaKxageCIgRbeTs b:uEnþ\T§iBlrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg)anbnþmanmk

elIBYkkumµúynIsþmYyEpñkenAxagt,ÚgeTottamry³ExSbNþajsm¶at;CaeRcIn.

GñkCMnajkarGaemrikaMgmñak;)ankt;smÁal;fa tamBit enAeBlEdls®gÁamvivtþQaneTArk

lkçN³KYr[eBjcitþsRmab;RkúghaNUy nigeBlEdlBYkGaemrikaMgcab;eFVIkardkfykgÉkPaB

RbyuT§rbs;xøÜnedaysMGagelIRTwsþInicsunenaH RbeTscin)anbegáInkarRbwgERbgrbs;xøÜneTVeLIgeTot

edIm,IerobcM[mankarTak;TgKñaedaypÞal;CamYyRbeTsLavnigkm<úCa b:uEnþk¾CamYyGñkbdivtþn_enAPaK

xagt,ÚgevotNampgEdr43.

eRTÓg jÚtag GtItrdæm®nþIRksYgyutþiFm’énrdæaPi)albdivtþn_beNþaHGasnñevotNamxagt,Úg

Edlrt;ePosxøÜnecjBIRbeTsenAqñaM1979 )anGHGagbBa¢ak;cMeBaHmux´¬GñkniBn§¦fa RbeTscin

)anrkSaTMnak;TMngepSg²«y:agCitsñiT§bMput»CamYyrdæaPi)albdivtþn_beNþaHGasnñ. tamkarerobrab;

rbs;Kat;fa «BYkcinhak;dUcCadwgxøÜnmuntaMgBIdMbUgfa PaKxageCIgmanlT§PaBRKb;y:agkñúgkar

dak;bgçM[manEbbEpnTsSn³rbs;xøÜnenAPaKxagt,Úg. edayehtuenHehIy eTIbBYkcinKaMRTrdæaPi)al

bdivtþn_beNþaHGasnñ. KWBYkcinenHEdr EdlTTUc[dak;bBa©ÚlsiT§isV½yseRmcrbs;PaKxagt,Úgkñúgkic©

RBmeRBógTIRkúg):arIsenaH»44.

tag )anelIk]TahrN_mYyGMBIkareKarBrbs;cincMeBaHGtþsBaØaNGñkPaKxagt,ÚgR)ab;´Edr.

Kat;Føab;)aneFVIdMeNIrmYyeTARkúgeb:kaMgenAExkumÖ³ qñaM1975 kñúgzan³CaemdwknaMKN³RbtiPUmYyén

rdæaPi)albdivtþn_beNþaHGasnñ. Gñkbdivtþn_PaKxagt,ÚgBMu)ansñak;enAkñúgnievsndæanCamYynwgKN³

RbtiPUrbs;saFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüevotNameT. BYkcin)anerobBiFIbdisNæarkic©BIrdac;eday

ELkBIKña ehIyGVIEdlminsUvRtcHRtcg; KWBuMEmnbdisNæarkic©Edlpþl;[rdæaPi)albdivtþn_beNþaH

GasnñeLIy. karviPaKEdlGHGageday tag BICMhrrbs;cin-Edl\LÚvenHvamandMeNIrRtÚvKñaeBj

elj-)anbBa¢ak;bEnßmkñúgkrNIxøHnUvGVIEdlnaMmkniyayeday elak RhVg;s½r mIsUhV CaebskCn

Biessrbs;rdæm®nþIkarbreTs)araMg. bnÞab;BIdMeNIrmYyeTARkúgeb:kaMg enAedImqñaM1976 EdlenA

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 151

Page 162: Brother enemy

eBlenaHKat;)anCYbeFVIkarsnÞnaCamYym®nþIx<s;² mIsUhV )anRbkas[dwgdUecñHfa «BYkcinniyayfa

vaminsMxan;b:unµaneTEdlmanevotNamBIr b¤bIenaH. cMNucsMxan;KWKµanevotNamrYmKñaEtmYy

eLIy»45.

bYnqñaMeRkaymk evotNam)anGHGagfa enAExemsa 1975 Rkúgeb:kaMg)ansuMkuM[xøÜneFVIkar

vaylukpþac;RB½RteTAelIRkúgéRBnKr enHCakareXasnaRbEhldUcTLðIkrN_epSg²CaeRcIneTotrbs;

evotNamEdr taMgBIkarkat;pþac;edaycMhrbs;eKCamYyRbeTscin. b:uEnþelak hVIlIB rIQ½r Edl

eFVICaÉkGKÁrdæTUt)araMgRbcaMRkúghaNUy enAcenøaHqñaM1973 nig1975 )anbBa¢ak;R)akdNas;fa

enAéf¶TI20 Exemsa qñaM1975 KWR)aMbYnéf¶munkardYlrlMénRkúgéRBnKr Rkúgeb:kaMg)anRBmanRkúg

haNUyBIeRKaHfñak;Edlnwgmankñúgkar«rujGMe)aseTAq¶ayeBk»EdlenHCakarelIkeLIgvijnUvBakü

eRbóbeFobEdlFøab;eRbIeday em:A kalBIqñaM1972Edr46.

\riyabfrbs;evotNam )anpøas;bþÚrdUcKñaenAbNþaqñaMCabnþbnÞab;mkeTot. fVIebIKat;bMeBj

muxgarbeRmIplRbeyaCn_Catirbs;evotNamk¾eday k¾ hU CImij EtgykcitþTukdak;EfrkSay:ag

ehacnUvTRmg;énTMnak;TMngCaRbéBNIrbs;RbeTsKat;CamYyRbeTscinenARKb;kal³eTs³Canic©. Kat;

)ansresrlixitEføgGMNrKuNedayédKat;pÞal;CaeRcInc,ab;epJIeTA[ em:A ehIykñúgesckþIEføgkarN_

CasaFarN³TaMgLayrbs;xøÜn bNþaemdwknaMevotNamEtgsEmþgkareKarBCanic©cMeBaHRbeTscin.

evotNamEdlRbEhlCadwgxøÜnCagBYkcinenaH )anrkSataMgBIyUryarmkehIynUvKMrUmYyénTMnak;TMng

epSg² EdlxøÜnRBm[RbeTscinmantYnaTICa«bgFM»enaH. RhVg;s½r hSÚy:U )ankt;smÁal;fa enAedIm

TsvtSr_60BYkemdwknaMevotNam )aneRbIR)as;lkçN³eKarBcMeBaH em:A dUcKñanwgbNþaRBHmhakSRt

rbs;evotNamyksYysarGakreTAfVayRBHecAGFiraCRbeTscinkalBIedImEdr. edayGnuvtþtam

karnaMsYysarGakreTAfVayRBHecAGFiraCcinBIedIm hU Etg)ancat;bBa¢Únm®nþIraCkarCan;x<s;CaeRcIn

nak;eTAkan;RBMEdnPøamedIm,IGmkarBarrdæm®nþInanarbs;cin EdleFVIdMeNIrmkRbeTsevotNamCanic©.

edaycat;Tukfa RbeTscinRbkan;\riyabfCaGFiraCmYyEdlmanlkçN³kan;eCIgmçag²cMeBaHRbeTs

evotNamenaH elak hSÚy:U yl;fa «GVI²EdlkRmeXIjenH KWvasµúKsµajlM)akyl;Nas;. tamBit

eKGacrkeXIjsMNl;énerOgr:avmYykMPø ÚsFMEdlBYkemdwknaMevotNamRbRBwtþxø ÜnedayÉkÉg

Ca«esþccMNuHeK»47. edaykarkarBarplRbeyaCn_Catirbs;xøÜnKµanQb;Qr EdlnwgCMruj[BYkeK

bMBanRbeTscinenaH evotNamenAEteKarBtamTRmg;epSg²EdlTTYldMENlBIGtItkalmk.

k¾b:uEnþ kareKarBEdlmanEtsMbkeRkAenH enATIbMput)anrlubrlaybnþicmþg² Cabzm eday

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg152

Page 163: Brother enemy

PaBF¶n;F¶rénCemøaHcin-sUevot tmkehIyCaBiess bnÞab;BIdMeNIrCaRbvtþisa®sþrbs;RbFanaFibtI

nicsun eTAkan;RbeTscin EdlevotNamRbdUceTAnwgkarpøas;bþÚreTArkPaBCasRtÚvnwgKñamYy.

RbeTscinnigshPaBsUevotEdlRkúghaNUyRbkasenAqñaM1972edayminbeB©ajeQµaH suT§Et«RtÚv

ruj[kb;Pk;KYr[GaNitenAelIpøÚvénkarsRmbsRmÜlKñaEdl\t[eBjcitþ nigefakTab»48.

bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHd¾KYr[PJak;ep¥Ilrbs;xøÜnnaqñaM1975 RbeTsevotNamEdlxøaMgBUEk nigEdl

eCOCak;elIxøÜnÉgxagkmøaMgT½BenaHmingayeFVI[GnþraynUvGVIEdlxøÜncat;TukCaplRbeyaCn_Cati edIm,I

bMeBjcitþRbeTscineLIy. mü:ageTot evotNamk¾seRmccitþeFVI[TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜn CamYy

RbeTscinmanlkçN³fµIEdr. P½sþútagénkareKarBcMeBaH«mhaykS»xageCIg ebIeTaHCamanEtTRmg;

eRkAk¾eday k¾ElgRtÚvkal³eTs³eTotehIy. edaykøayeTACaRbeTs«eBjlkçN³»evotNam)an

RbúgeRbóbxøÜnTTYlr:ab;rgkarcat;EcgdwknaMkarbdivtþn_kñúgGasuIGaeKñy_rYcCaeRsc.

b:uEnþ KWmanEtenAqñaM1975b:ueNÑaHEdlelxabkS eL yn; sEmþg[eXIjedayrebobCak;

EsþgnUvPaBRkGWtRkeGagrbs;evotNam edayecosvagminGeBa¢IjbNþaePJóvrbs;Kat;eTAcUlrYmBiFI

Cb;eloglaKñaeLIy. BYkemdwknaMkumµúynIsþcin RbEhlCaminsgÇwmrkSaTukCamYyRbeTsevotNam

nUvTMnak;TMngepSg²rebobCaRbeTscMNuHeToteTemIleTA. mü:ageTot karrMCYlcitþd¾xøaMgkøaEdlGuC

Gal[ekItCaTMnas;enARbeTscin eday«PaBRkGWtRkTmEbbemIlgay» nig«citþexµArmilKuN»rbs;

evotNamtaMgBIkarcab;epþIménCemøaH )aneFVI[nwkeXIjKMrUmYyénTMnak;TMngepSg²enAstvtSr_mYy

epSgeTot. karrMCYlcitþenH manGtßn½ysMxan;mYyKW karxkcitþrbs;BYkcin cMeBaHkarbHe)arénRbeTs

tUcCitxagxøÜnk¾dUc«GMeBIGaRkk;»rbs;BYkevotNam. RbeTsevotNamenAEtRtÚvsnµtfaCa«sac;jati

CitsñiT§bMput»nwgRbeTscin dUcEdlRBHecAGFiraC y:uglI )ankt;smÁal;kalBI500qñaMmuneTotb¤?.

enATIbBa©b; RkúghaNUy)anCmñHnwgRbeTscin edIm,IEsVgrkcgmitþPaBnwgshPaBsUevot

ehIyRtg;enHÉgKWCamUlehtusMxan;mYykñúgcMeNammUlehtusMxan;²énkarRbqaMgCMTas;rbs;cinRKb;

karb:unb:gdak;GnutþrPaBTaMgRsugrbs;evotNamenA\NÐÚcin-EdlmanlkçN³xøaMgkøa niglkçN³Cakar

QøanBanCageBlNa²TaMgGs;. karbegáItTMnak;TMngneya)ayEdltamsMbkeRkAmanlkçN³

CitsñiT§rvagRbeTsTaMgBIr PaBBwgEp¥kEpñkesdækic©nigeyaFarbs;RbeTsevotNamcMeBaHRkúgmUsÁÚ

)anrYmbgáCakarKMrammYy EdlRbeTscinBuMEdlRbQmmuxtaMgBIqñaM1949mk. RBHecAGFiraC hugvU

)anTUnµanbNþaGñksñgtMENgBIRBHGgÁkuM[lukluyrdæKµanGarüFm’mYyenAPaKxagt,Úg edayKµan

mUlehtusmehtusmpl BIeRBaHsRmab;RbeTscin karKMramkMEhgsMxan;bMput KWmkBIPaKxageCIg

karpøas;bþÚrTisedAedayRbvtþisa®sþ 153

Page 164: Brother enemy

Canic©. b:uEnþ bnÞab;BIkardkfyTaMgRbjab;Rbjal;rbs;mhaGMNacGaemrikaMg enAeRkayeBl

s®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTIBIrputrlt;enAqñaM1975 RbeTscinRbEhlCaRbQmmuxnwgeRKaHfñak;fµImYy

TaMgRsug. eRkABIT½BefµIreCIghasibkgBlFMrbs;sUevot nigkardak;BRgaymIsuIl nigkgGakascrd¾

sem,ImenAPaKxageCIg \LÚvenH RbeTscinRtÚvQmmuxtTl;nwgTsSnvis½yénsm<n§PaBsUevot-

evotNammYy cMeBaHdMeNIrrbs;BYksUevotmkRBMEdnPaKxagt,Úgrbs;xøÜnEfmeTot. CaeRcInqñaM

eRkaymk emdwknaMevotNammñak;QanrhUtdl;bkRsayfa sm<n§PaBrbs;RbeTsxøÜnCamYy

RkúgmUsÁÚKWCakarkarBarbMRmúgTukCamunEtmYyKt;RbqaMgnwgRbeTscin. Kat;)anGHGagfa ³ «kñúgRbvtþi

sa®sþTaMgmUl eyIgFøab;rYcputBIeRKaHfñak;rbs;cinEtBIrkrNIb:ueNÑaH ³ RbeTscinmYyEdlTn;exSay

nigEbk)ak; b¤RbeTscinmYyEdlKMramkMEhgedayBYkGanarüCnmkBIPaKxageCIg. sBVéf¶enH rusSI

KWCaBYkGnarüCnrbs;eyIg»49.

karbegáItTMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMgenAqñaM1972 TIbMput)anruj«Eqácck» KWcRkBtþiniymGaemrik

[Xøatq¶ayBImat;TVarrbs;RbeTscin. b:uEnþ enAPaKxageCIg «xøa»sUevotenAEtbnþERskRKhwmCanic©.

tamcin[dwgfa taMgBIqñaM1978 sUevotbRmúgEtnwgBRgwgCRmkfµImYyenAPaKxagt,ÚgeTAehIy. kñúg

bribTCayuT§sa®sþmYyEbbenaH etIGFiraCcinGgÁNanwgeFVIKeFVIføg;cMeBaHkarGMBavnav[CYyBIGñk

esµaHRtg;PaKxagt,ÚgmYy EdlRtÚvRbQmmuxnwgkarKMramkMEhgdUcGaNacRkkNþalEdrenaH?.

BitehIy eTaHbICamanPaBdUcKñaEpñkmenaKmviC¢arbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTscinrbs; em:A k¾eday k¾km<úCa

RbCaFibetyüEdlecHEtreGIlbMputenaH BuMEmnCaRbeTscMNuHmYyeT. b:uEnþ bTBiesaFn_knøgmk

rbs;RbeTscin k¾dUckarP½y)armÖbc©úb,nñrbs;xøÜn )antRmÚv[cinRtab;tamTaMgggwtggl; nUvkar

RbRBwtþmYyénbNþaGtItRBHecAGFiraCrbs;xøÜncMeBaHRbeTsevotNamnigkm<úCaEdlmanrab;stvtSr_

mkehIy.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg154

Page 165: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI5CMenarxül;BITisxaglic

éf¶TI16 ExmIna qñaM1977 ynþehaHRbtikmµ Starlifter BN’TwkR)ak;nigexovénkgGakascr

GaemrikaMg)anep¥ógsøabepþImeFVIkarcuHctrbs;xø ÜnenAelIdIragRcmuHRCÚkEdllycUleTAkñúgTenø

Rkhm. enAelIynþehaH ÉkGKÁrdæTUt eLGUNard_ vUdxUk )ansmøwgemIlvalERsTaMgLayEdlkat;

xVat;ExVgCaRkLacRtgÁedayTMnb; nigRbLayTwktambg¥ÜcynþehaH. emdwknaMshCIB vUdxUk minEdl

dak;eCIgCan;RbeTsevotNamTal;EtesaH TaMgPaKxageCIg TaMgPaKxagt,Úg. b:uEnþ Kat;minEmnmin

dwgfa RbePTbwgmUlFM²EdleFVI[eTsPaBemIleTAmansñamrTuH²CareNþARKab;EbkeLIy. ePøógFøak;

ex¢ak²mYyemy:agFM)anbMeBjreNþAFM²TaMgenH EdlbnSl;TukedaykgGakascrGaemrikaMg. enA

mansñamrbYsCaeRcIneTotEdlRtÚvBüa)al nigcMNgTak;TgepSg²EdleFVI[xUcTwkcitþ k¾RtÚvcgP¢ab;

eLIgvijmuneBlEdlCMBUkénRbvtþisaRsrbs;GaemrikaMgEdlmaneCaKC½ytictYcenHRtÚvbiT.

vUdxUk pÞal;EdlCaRbFanshCIB]sSahkmµrfynþshrdæGaemrik (United Auto Workers Union)

)anRtÚvGmdMeNIreday\sSrCnGaemrikaMgbYnnak;eTot. Kat;manebskkmµedIm,Icab;epþImebIkTMB½r

mYyfµI. elakRbFanaFibtI CImI xaF½r EdleTIbCab;eqñatkñúgeBlfµI²)anRbKl;esckþITukcitþ[elak

vUdxUk dwknaMKN³RbtiPUdMbUgmYyeFVIdMeNIreTAkan;RkúghaNUy nigRkúgevogc½nÞ edIm,Isakl,gEsVgrk

dMeNaHRsaymYyGMBIbBaðaTahanGaemrikaMgEdlcat;Tukfa )at;xøÜnenA\NÐÚcinbnÞab;BIs®gÁamputrlt;

eTA. enAeBlEdlynþehaHcab;epþImeTACitdl;Gakasyandæan y:a LaM edayehaHehIrBIelIEpndImYy

EdlesÞIrEtERbkøayeTACadIexSaHCICati nigedrdaseTAedayxÞmsøwkrexkrxak nigedImb£sSIs‘ubRTúb

elak vUdxUk )andNþwgsYrkñúgcitþfa karTTYlsVaKmn_rbs;rdæFanI«CasRtÚv»nwgeRtómbRmúgcMeBaHKN³

RbtiPUrbs;Kat;edayrebobNaeTA. KUsnÞnarbs;Kat;kñúgRKb;sm½yRbCuMkargarnigCaGñkkarTUtevot

NamkñúgcMeNamGñkkarTUtevotNamEdleCakCaMkñúgcm,aMgCageK KWGnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs pan; ehon.

b:uEnþ etIGñkNaEdlnwgmkTTYlsVaKmn_Kat;enAcMNtGakasyan? BYkemdwknaMlMdab;TIBIrb¤?.

xül;ekþAnigesImbnþic² )anbk;pat;mkb:HmuxKat;kalebIKat;dak;eCIgCan;elIk,alCeNþIrynþehaH

Pøam. TIbMput Gakasyanik)anBnøt;m:asuInRbtikmµ. PaBes¶óms¶at;mYy EdleFVI[huwgRtecok)an

ekItmaneLIgenATIenaH. eBlenHKat;kMBugsßitenATIRkúghaNUyehIy. mindl;R)aMqñaMmunpg TIenHKW

Casßannrk. enAeBlbuNüNUEGlqñaM1972 hVÚg ynþehaHeb-52 EdlbBa¢ÚnedayelakRbFana

155

Page 166: Brother enemy

FibtI nicsun )ansmøab;RbCaCnsuIvilrab;Ban;nak; edaykemÞcmnÞIreBTüFMCageKenATIRkúghaNUy[

)ak;EbkexÞcxÞI1 kñúgkarvayRbhary:agxøaMgkøax<s;dl;kRmitCaelIkcugeRkaymYyeTaHbICakgkmøaMg

kaMePøIgFM)aj;ynþehaHrbs;evotNam RBÜsRKab;kaMePøIgsMedAynþehaHTmøak;RKab;EbkykSTaMgenaH

EdlehaHkb;BBkemIlmineXIjkñúgkm<s;CaeRcInKILÚEm:Rtk¾eday. éf¶enH enAeCIgCeNþIrynþehaH

Kat;emIleXIjcMeBaHmuxKat;EtGakasyandæand¾tUcmYynighVÚgmnusSmYyRkúmtUcCamYy)ac;páa

b:ueNÑaH. kic©karrbs;Kat;KWeFVICMerOnTahanEdl)at;xøÜn[)anBitR)akdbMput tamEdlGaceFVIeTA)an

rYmTaMgRkúmyanikénynþehaHeb-52 EdlRtÚv)aj;Føak;enABIelIRbeTsevotNampg. enAnwgtucrca

RbFanshCIB]sSahkmµrfynþGaemrikaMg elak vUdxUk manTmøab;eTACYbbNþamnusSEdlmanGMNac

edIm,IcrcaTl;muxKña. b:uEnþ GñkEdlKat;nwgRtÚvCYbedIm,Il,gcrcaBIkic©RBmeRBógshRbtibtþikarmYy

BuMEmnmanGMNacseRmcdUcrgVg;emdwknaMRkúmh‘un General Motors b¤ Chrysler eLIy. BYkenaHsuT§EtCa

smmitþrYmGavuFrbs; hU CImij. BYkeKFøab;)anvayRbyuT§edayKµanQb;Qrkñúgry³eBlsamsib

qñaM edIm,IseRmceKaledArbs;BYkeK. etIKat;mansmtßPaBRKb;RKan;eT? etIKat;nwgseRmcebIkTMB½r

mYyfµI nigerobcMsßanPaBsRmab;karTak;TgRbkbedaysnþiPaBCamYyKUsRtÚvBImSilb¤eT?.

enAeBlKat;cuHBIynþehaH vUdxUk )aneXIjBIcm¶aynUvmnusSEdlRtÚvlUkédmkcab;édKat; KW

BuMEmnCaGñkkan;muxgarrayrgénRksYgkarbreTseT b:uEnþKWBitCa pan; ehon pÞal;xøÜnÉgEtmþg Edl

esIcjjwmy:agRss;. manrUbragtUcl¥it ehon KWCatYy:agm®nþIeBjlkçN³EdlKYrsmrak;Tak;nig

TukcitþxøÜnÉg. bnÞab;BIBiFITTYlsVaKmn_y:agxøImYy vUdxUk nig bNþashkarIrbs;Kat; KWRBwT§smaCik ém:

m:an;ehVól/ ÉkGKÁrdæTUt sðal y:Us/ smaCik sunnI m:ugháÚem:rI nigGñkRsIsmaCikénGgÁkarsiT§imnusS

m:arIy:an GuIEdlm:an rYmTaMgGñkkaEstmYyRkúmtUcpg)aneLIgrfynþ ehIyk,ÜndEgðCakitþiys)aneFVI

dMeNIrtampøÚvkat;eq<aHmkkan;TIRkúghaNUy. enHCacm¶aypøÚvmYyEdlenATIbMputmancm¶ayEvgCagkar

KitTukCamunbnþic. bnÞab;BIebIkERCkhVÚgGñkefµIreCIgk,ÜndEgð)aneTAdl;s<an Lúg ebon d¾l,Il,aj.

cracrN_d¾mmajwkénhVÚgreTHeKa LankamIj:úgnigGñkCiHkg;eRcIn\tKNna )aneFVI[sÞHpøÚvenAeBleTA

Citdl;mhasMNg;enH. sRmab;ehtuplepSg²EdlRbEhlCacEmøkKYr[q¶l; KWc,ab;cracrRbkan;

sþaMRtÚvpøas;bþÚrenAkEnøgenH. edIm,Iqøgkat;s<an yanynþTaMgGs;RtÚvEteTAtampøÚvvagmYymunnwgcUl

mkkñúgCYrxageqVg. enHCalkçN³EdlesÞIrEt putsm½yeTAehIy. ehon )anerobrab;R)ab; vUdxUk fa

s<anenHEdlksagqøgkat;elITenøRkhm edayBYk)araMgFøab;RtÚvrgkarTmøak;RKab;EbkkñúgeBls®gÁam

ehIyvaBuMTan;)anCYsCulenAeLIyeT. Kat;min)ac;enOyht;nwgBnül;fa yanynþRKb;RbePTEdl

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg156

Page 167: Brother enemy

RtÚvbgçM[pøas;bþÚrCYrEbbenHKWbNþalmkBIplvi)akéns®gÁamEdr.

enAeBlkMBugc,aMgKñaeBjTMhwg kMBg;EpéhhVúg enAPaKxagekItRkúghaNUy KWCamCÄmNÐl

KmnaKmn_d¾sMxan;esµIGayuCIvit. eRKÓgsmÖarswkniges,ógGaharrab;Ban;etan )anerIdak;cuHenATIenH

munnwgRtÚvdwkeTAkan;RkúghaNUynigPaKxagt,Úg. k,ÜnrfynþdwkCBa¢ÚnKµanpøÚvNaepSgeRkABIqøgkat;

s<anLúgebon Edlkñúgry³eBlCaeRcInqñaM)ancab;epþImRsutxagEpñkEdleRbIR)as;edayrfynþkaMmIj:úg

pÞúksmÖareBj²CaeRcIneRKÓgebIkmkBIéhhVúgeLIy. pøÚvKmnaKmn_CayuT§sa®sþTaMgGs;suT§EtRtÚv

RTúDeRTam. BYkvisVkrcinnigrusSI )anxMRbwgERbgTl;RTmhasMNg;enHedayKµaneCaKC½y. evotNam

xøÜnÉg)anrkeXIjdMeNaHRsaymYymanlkçN³samBaØbMput. ksikrEdlErkbEnøepSg²enAxagcug

dgErkb£sSImYy )anpøas;bþÚrsµaenAeBlEdlsµamçagcab;epþImcukeray. evotNamRKan;Etpøas;bþÚr

c,ab;énkareFVIcracrenAelIs<anb:ueNÑaHCakareRsc ³ rfynþkaMmIj:úgTaMgLayEdlpÞúksmÖareBj²

mkBIéhhVúgRtÚvEtRbkan;CYrxageqVg EdlBImunRtÚveRbIR)as;edayrfynþkaMmIj:úgTaMgLayEdlKµan

dwkGVImkBIRkúghaNUy. rebobcat;karsamBaØenH )anbgðaj[eXIjlT§pldUcbMNg.

eTaHbICamankar)at;bg;CIvitmnusS karbMpøicbMpøajnigkarQWcab;edaysars®gÁamk¾eday k¾enA

tamdgpøÚvnana hVÚgmnusSminsEmþg[eXIjkars¥b;ex<ImNamYy EdlGacemIleXIjRbqaMgnwgBYk

GaemrikaMgeLIy. GñkTTYlxusRtÚvevotNam EdlGmCUndMeNIr vUdxUk nigKN³RbtiPUKat;rhUtdl;

nievsndæanEdldak;[Kat;eRbIR)as;edayrdæaPi)al hak;dUcCaRBman[BYkKat;cab;GarmµN_fa vanwg

maneRKaHfñak;Nas;EdlecjedIredayKµanGñkGmkarBar. RbCaCnenAEtman«kMhwgy:agxøaMg» RbqaMg

nwgBYkGaemrikaMgenAeLIy. b:uEnþ bnÞab;BIkarcakecjrbs;GñkCUndMeNIrbNþasmaCikénKN³RbtiPU

)anecjeTAeRkAedaylYclak;. edayedIrkMsanþtamdgpøÚvnana BYkeK)anRtÚveFVI[egOgq¶l; Edl

RbTHeXIjmnusSmñamanlkçN³rYsrayrak;Tak; nigKYr[cUlcitþ. enARBwkéf¶bnÞab; vUdxUk nigRBwT§

smaCik ém: m:an;ehVól )anedIrRkLwgCuMvijbwg h½n eKom-mann½yfa davEdlrkeXIjvij-EdlenA

cMBIeRkaynievsndæanrbs;Kat;. vUdxUk )ancab;GarmµN_nwgerOgeRBgniTanrbs;evotNamTak;Tgnwg

bwg¬nigdavTiBVrbs;bwg¦enHNas; EdlnaM[nwkeXIjdl;erOgeRBgniTanrbs;RBHmhakSRt GaeFor

Edr. kñúgrebobniTanrbs;evotNam)anerobrab;fa dav mYy)anpusecjBIbwg EdlGac[vIrbursmñak;

vayQñHBYkQøanBancin. bnÞab;BIC½yCmñH dav )anGENþteLIgeTAelIemX edaybeBa©jBnøWrsµIén

mhiT§ib£T§id¾mhas©arürbs;xøÜneLIgcaMgEPñkmunnwgFøak;cuHmkvij ehIynaMykeTAeRkamTwkbwgeday

GeNþIkmYyk,al.

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 157

Page 168: Brother enemy

manePøógFøak;y:agxøaMgkalBIyb;mun edImeQITaMgLayenAmat;bwgmçageTot manTwksenSImdk;

Cab;søwkeLIgsk,ús. BYkRbCaCnevotNam)anykkEnøgenaHedIm,Ihat;R)aNenAeBlRBwktamk,ac;

KuNétCi (T'ai Chi). RbCaCndéTeTot GgÁúyenAelIekAGIEvg² smøwgemIlépÞTwkbwg. vUdxUk )an

eXIjekµgRsIBIrnak;BIcm¶ayEdlkMBugGgÁúyRcehagBinitüemIlrbs;cEmøkkñúgføúkmYy. ekµgRsImñak;

kñúgcMeNamekµgTaMgBIr)ansmÁal;eXIjBYkbreTsPøam ehIy)anERskep¥IleKep¥IlÉg. BYknag)an

egIbQreLIgkñúgclnaRBmKña. vUdxUk EtgEtniyayerobrab;eRkaymkfa RsICMTg;mñak;kñúgcMeNam

RsICMTg;CaeRcIn )angakxøÜnEbrmkrkKat;. enAeBlenaHKat;emIleXIjfa muxekµgRsId¾Rss;s¥atenH

mansmøakmYyKYr[xøac. Kat;)anniyayedayeRkómRkMfa «enAeBlenHnagenAminTan;RtÚveFVI[xUc

muxmat;eT b:uEnþ R)akdNas; nagnwgmanmuxmat;s¥ateLIgvijenAéf¶eRkay».

GgÁúyTl;mux pan; ehon enAtumYy vUdxUk nwkeXIjBI]bTÞvehtu enAeBlEdlKat;RbwgERbgbBa©b;

CMBUkEdleFVI[Bi)akcitþenH. kalBIyb;mSil Kat;mankarCYbKñaEdlmin)anKitTukCamunmYyCamYy

rdæm®nþIkarbreTs egVón DuyRTij. elakrdæm®nþI)aneFVIdMeNIrmkdl;exOnxagelIénnievsndæanrbs;

Kat;edIm,IsEmþgkarsVaKmn_cMeBaHKN³RbtiPUKat;. erOgEdlnaMmknUvkarsakBiesaFmYymanlkçN³

pÞal;xøÜnbnþiccMeBaHkarcab;epþImBiPakSaenH edayKat;manKMnitRbsiT§Brdl;buNüxYbkMeNItd¾sb,ay

rIkraymYydl;elakRBwT§smaCik ém: m:an;ehVól pgEdr. vUdxUk )anbBa¢ak;R)ab; RTij fa «´sgÇwmfa

enAcugbBa©b;énkarsñak;GaRs½yrbs;eyIg eyIgnwgbegáIt[manRKwHénkarxitcUlCitKñamYyrvag

RbeTseyIgTaMgBIr». b:uEnþ elakrdæm®nþIkarbreTsEdlCamnusSmaDtUc bbUrmat;esþIgdUcbbUrmat;RtI

nigrebobemIlmutCaTIbMputmanlkçN³CamnusSmuWgm:at; nwgkic©karNas;. Kat;)aneqøIytbnwg vUdxUk

y:agxøIfa ³ «Kµanluy KWKµanbBa¢IGñk)at;xøÜnGVITaMgGs;». tamBaküeBcn_énkic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIs BYk

GaemrikaMgRtÚvyl;RBmsgkarxUcxatedaysars®gÁam muneBlEdlevotNamcab;epþImKitKUrBIkar

snüapÞal;rbs;BYkeK nigEsVgrkTahanGaemrikaMgEdl)at;xøÜn2.

vUdxUk k¾CamnusSmineTarTn;dUcKat;Edr. Kat;eBalGagfa GMNwHteTAkic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIs

manlkçN³hYssm½yeTAehIy bBaðaGacedaHRsay)anedayQrelImUldæanmnusSFm’Etb:ueNÑaH.

vUdxUk )anRbkascMeBaHelak RTij fa ³ «eyIgminEmnmkBIcugmçageToténBiPBelakedIm,IeFVIs®gÁam

BaküsmþIKµan)anRbeyaCn_enaHeT». karCYbKña)anbBa©b;eTAedaykarmincuHsRmúgKñamYy.

karBiPakSaCapøÚvkarrbs;KN³RbtiPUGaemrikaMgCamYyelak pan; ehon minTMngCacab;epþIm

edayRbpñÚll¥eLIy. vUdxUk )anGanesckþIEføgkarN_EdlKat;)anerobcMTak;TgeTAnwgesckþIseRmc

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg158

Page 169: Brother enemy

EpñkmnusSFm’mYyGMBIbBaðaTahan)at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§ (M.I.A.: Missing in Action). cMENkxagelak

ehon vijmine)aHbg;sMeNIrbs;Kat;kñúgkarCYsCulkarxUcxatedaysars®gÁameLIy. kñúgkarQb;

sRmakmYyEPøtCu¿vitu vUdxUk )anesñIKUsnÞnarbs;Kat;Pøam edIm,IsuMCYbeRkApøÚvkarmYyttYEtBIrnak;

CamYyGñkbkERbevotNammñak;CasakSI. edayBit elak vUdxUk nig m:an;ehVól eTIbnwgRbkan;yk

karseRmccitþrbs;Kat;GM)aj;mijenHÉg ³ ebIcg;eFVI[ElgrEGgcitþKña KWmanEtCYbcrcattYEtBIrnak;

edayesckþIesµaHRtg;eTAvijeTAmkb:ueNÑaH. karCYbKñanwgenAEteRkApøÚvkarCanic©. vUdxUk )anBnül;

R)ab;GñkbkERbfa ³ «ebIKµanGVIecjrYceT eyIgRtÚveFVIhak;dUcCakarCYbKñaenHminEdlekItmanesaH».

edayCYbKñattYCamYy pan; ehon elak vUdxUk )ancab;niyayRtg;²Etmþg. Kat;)anbBa¢ak;fa KN³

RbtiPUEdlbBa¢ÚnmkedayelakRbFanaFibtI xaF½r enH )anrYmbgásRmab;RbeTsevotNamnUvsMNag

mYyEdleKKµansgÇwmTuk edIm,ICMrujdMeNIrénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBmYy ³ «elaknwgminCYbCafµInUv

KN³RbtiPUmYy EdlRbkbedaysmasPaBCaTIeBjcitþdUcCaeBlenHeT». RbFanKN³RbtiPU

GaemrikaMg)anrMlwkR)ab; pan; ehon Casm¶at;fa ³ «elakFøab;dwgCMhrrbs;´kñúgeBls®gÁamehIy.

elakk¾dwgBICMhrrbs; sðal y:Us nig m:arIy:an GuIEdlm:an Edr. mnusSEtmñak;Kt; [kñúgcMeNam

KñaeyIg] Edlman\riyabfxusBIeKÉgKWsmaCiksPa sunnI m:ugháÚem:rI b:uEnþ y:agehacNas; elak

k¾dwgy:agBitR)akdfa elakRtÚvseRmcEbbNakñúgerOgenHehIy. ebIeyIgenAEtbraC½y elakGac

niyayBakülacakKñaedayKYrsmcMeBaHkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBsRmab;db;b¤émÖqñaMxagmuxeTot». Kat;

)anbEnßmfa enAeBlenaH vaCa»kasRbesIrmYyedIm,IlubbM)at;esaknadkmµTaMgLayEdleTIbman

fµI². enARBwkenaH vUdxUk )anniyayR)ab; ehon BIkarrMCYlcitþ rbs;Kat; BIsmøakelIépÞmuxrbs;ekµg

RsItUcmñak; EdlenHCasmøakmYyTMngCabgáeLIgedayRKab;EbkGaemrikaMgehIy. «eyIgRtÚvseRmc

citþenARBwkenH ebIsinCaRbePTénerOgr:avenHGacekItmanmþgeTot». enAeBlkMBugniyay vUdxUk )an

eXIjTwkEPñkhUrkat;Epnf<al;rbs;GñkbkERbEdleFVI[Kat;mankaregOgq¶l;Edr. ehon RKan;Et

niyayb:ueNÑaHfa «elakmanlkçN³esµaHRtg;Nas;. etIRtÚveFVI GVIeTot? RtLb;eTAtucrca?».

vUdxUk EdleBareBjedayesckþIsgÇwm)aneqøIytbfa KWbBaðaenHÉgEdleyIgsßitenATIenH3.

eBlRtLb;mktucrcaEdlRkaledayRkNat;esþIgmansac;m:dæBN’ébtg ehon )an rg;caM

[eKnaMykv:alistUcmYyBIRksYgkarbreTsmkRbKl;[Kat;. Kat;dkecjsMNuMÉksarcMnYnbIBI

v:alis ³ «l¥¡ manbBaðabIEdlRtÚvRBmeRBógKña ³ bBaðaTahan)at;xøÜn kareFVI[manRbRktIPaB nigkar

CYsCulEpñkesdækic©. enHCabBaðadac;edayELkBIKña b:uEnþ vaCab;Tak;TgKñay:agCitsñiT§». enH

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 159

Page 170: Brother enemy

ehIyCacMNucénkarBicarNaEdl vUdxUk bRmúgxøÜnTTYlyl;RsbTaMgGs;. ehon )anRbkasfa

KN³RbtiPUGacnaMeTAmatuPUmivijnUvsaksBTahan)at;xøÜnmYyQutdMbUg cMnYndb;BIrnak;EdlrkeXIj

GtþsBaØaNedayevotNam. ehon k¾R)ab;B½t’man vUdxUk fa kariyal½yBiessmYy)anRtÚvbegáIt

eLIgedIm,IRbmUlB½t’manepSg²sþIBITahan)at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§ nigRbmUlGdæiFatuGñkTaMgenaHCayfa

ehtu. ehon )anbBa¢ak;EfmeTotfa ³ «karebIGVI²GaceFVI)an RbeTsevotNamnwgpþl;dMNwgdl;

shrdæGaemriknUvB½t’manepSg²EdlGaceRbIR)as;)an nigRbKl;[vijnUvsaksBTaMgLayEdl

rkeXIjenAeBleRkay. b:uEnþ edayehtufa kareFVIshRbtibtþikarrbs;evotNamsþIBIbBaðaTahan

)at;xøÜnRtÚvEtBinitüemIleRkamTsSn³mnusSFm’enaH ehon )ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa vaCakarRtwmRtÚv

EdlshrdæGaemrikRtÚvbgðaj[eXIjlkçN³mnusSFm’dUcKñaEdr edayCYsCulkarbMpøicbMpøajxøH²

EdlekIteLIgkñúgry³eBlmans®gÁam. edayKiteTAdl;PaBmaneTAmanmk Rkúgv:asuInetanRtÚvEt

eFVIGVImuneKbnþicbnþÜcCadrab. vUdxUk )anniyaynwg ehon fa elakRbEhlCacat;TukCMnYyEdlelak

esñIsuMeyIgCa«karCMBak;KuNmYy EdlelakRtÚvEtbMeBjeTAtammnsikarnigstiénkarTTYlxusRtÚv

rbs;elakehIyemIleTA». cMeBaHlkçN³epSg²EdlGacTTYl)anCMnYyenH ehon )anbBa¢ak;R)ab;

vUdxUk fa RbeTsevotNamebIkcMhcMeBaHsMeNITaMgGs;4.

vUdxUk vaytémøfa enHKWCaCMhrminhYsehtumYy. karCYsCulkarxUcxatedaysars®gÁam

ElgRtÚvcgP¢ab;nwgxTaMgLayEdlmanEcgkñúgkic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIseTotehIy. GñkcrcaGaemrikaMg

)anRbkasfa ³ «eyIgmanbMNgCMruj[BYkeKeFVIshRbtibtþikarsRmab;ehtupl EpñkmnusSFm’

ehIykñúgehtuplRbePTdUcKñaenH EdltRmÚv[eyIgCYyRbCaCnevotNam sþarRbeTsCatirbs;xøÜn

eLIgvij».

BIrExeRkaymk pan; ehon )anGHGagbEnßmR)ab;´ ¬GñkniBn§¦ fa vUdxUk )anyl;RBmCECk

BiPakSaBIyfaPaBénCMnYymnusSFm’GaemrikaMgmYycMeBaHRbeTsevotNam. tameKGHGagdUcEdl

elak vUdxUk bBa¢ak;BIerOgenHEdrfa eTaHbICaCMnYyedaypÞal;TaMgGs;RtÚvbdiesFk¾eday k¾elak

RbFanaFibtIEdlmanGMNacd¾TUlMTUlay GacCYyRbeTsevotNam)anrYceTIbsMukarGnum½tyl;RBm

BIsPaCan;TabCaeRkay.

ehon )anbBa¢ak;fa TnÞwmnwgenH RbeTsevotNammanbMNgerobcM[manTMnak;TMngkarTUteLIg

vijCamYyshrdæGaemrikEdr b:uEnþ karRbwgERbgrbs;Kat;kñúgn½yenH KWseRmcenARtg;qnÞ³rbs;GaemrikaMg

EdlRtÚv«e)aHbg;ecalkMhusEpñkneya)ayknøgmk» nigCaBiessdkbRmamEpñkBaNiC¢kmµ nig

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg160

Page 171: Brother enemy

eqñatev:tUrbs;xøÜnmin[RbeTsevotNamcUlGgÁkarshRbCaCati.

KN³RbtiPUrbs;GaemrikaMg etagEteTAcUlrYmsEmþgkarKYrsmnwgnaykrdæm®nþI paM v:an;dug

EfmeTot EdlCakatBVkic©CapøÚvkarcugeRkaymYymunkarecjdMeNIrrbs;Kat;. enAeBlEdl

KN³RbtiPUQaneCIgcUlkñúgbrievNvimanRbFanaFibtI paM v:an;dug EdlCa«cas;TuMrbs;bdivtþn_»)anenA

rg;caMKN³RbtiPUeRkameragEfvTTwgexøagTVarmYy. f¶asTUlay sk;l,ayGacm_xøasiteTAeRkay bbUr

mat;esþIgehIyRkbYc nigGavBN’RbepHrbs;Kat; )aneFVI[Kat;manb£kBaCa mnusSéføfñÚrnigRsKt;RsKM

mñak;. b:uEnþ enARBwkenH sñamjjwmmYy)aneFVI[karsmøwgemIlrbs;Kat;manBnøWRss;føa.

bnÞab;BIkarcab;rlak;édd¾rak;Tak; dug )anGeBa¢IjePJóvrbs;Kat;cUlkñúgbnÞb;TTYlePJóv. eRkam

karsmøwgemIlBIrUbsMNakBak;kNþalxøÜnrbs;sBRbFan hU CImij EdlelceFøaeLIg kñúgbnÞb; vUdxUk

)anGgÁúyelIekAGIEvgmYyEk,r dug Ca«sRtÚv»kalBIeBlknøgmkfµI². GñkTaMgBIr)anesIcjjwmBI

muxEkvm:asuInftCaeRcInrbs;GñkkaEst. sRmab;evotNamTIbMputenH KWem:agénC½yCmñH. ebskCn

rbs;mhaGMNacsRtÚvEdlcaj;s®gÁam )anmkTTUcsuMerobcMTMnak;TMngrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrCafµI. sh

rdæGaemriknwgkøayeTACasRtÚvdUcRbeTs)araMgEdlcaj; dUcKña kalBIeBlknøgmkminyUrb:unµanenH

eTACaédKUEdlmanÉksiT§iEmnb¤?. RkúghaNUy)anbeNþayxøÜn[lukluyedaymenaseBa©tna

sb,ayGENþtGNþÚgmYy EdlBi)akTb;. dug )anniyayeTAkan; vUdxUk fa ³ «´eCOfa bMNg

rbs;elakRbFanaFibtI xaF½r ¬KW¦ epþImCECkBiPakSaBIkarTas;ETgKñarbs;eyIgCamYylkçN³citþKMnit

fµImYy. ebIsinCaG‘ÍcwgEmneyIgRtÚvEtCmñH[)an». vUdxUk )anbgðajP½sþútagBIlkçN³éncitþKMnit

fµIenHedayEføgsresIrBI «esckþIéføfñÚr nigesckþIkøahan»rbs;RbCaCnevotNam. Kat;)anEføgfa

«taMgBIyUryarNas;mkehIy RBwtþikarN_RbkbedayTukçesakTaMgLay)aneFVI[RbeTseyIgTaMgBIr

XøatecjBIKña»5. kñúg»kassnñisITkaEstmYy EdlKat;)aneFVIbnþiceRkaymkenATIRkúghaNUy Kat;

)anbBa¢ak;fa karsnÞnaRbkbedaylkçN³viC¢mannigsßabnaenH )anrYmbgáCa«PaBcab;epþIméndMeNIr

mYysMedAeFVI[eTACaBitnUvTsSnvis½yénkareFVI[TMnak;TMngGaemrik-evotNammanRbRktIPaBeLIg

vij».

briyakaskñúgry³BIréf¶enHmanlkçN³RbkbedaymitþPaBEmnETn Edlelak vUdxUk eCOfa

GacsuMBIBYkm©as;pÞHrbs;Kat;nUvkareyaKyl;mYyEdlmanlkçN³samBaØbnþic. enAeBlEdlKN³

RbtiPUGaemrikaMgcUlrYmkñúgkarelIkmQUsEdkmanpÞúkGdæiFatuTahanGaemrikdak;kñúgynþehaHmYy

vUdxUk )anTaj pan; ehon eTAq¶ayBIeK ehIy)anbgðajnUvBaküsuMmYykñúgnaménsmaCikmñak;rbs;

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 161

Page 172: Brother enemy

KN³RbtiPUKat; KWelakvresnIy_Ék b:Ul m:aF½r (Paul Mather) eRBaHfaKat;)andwgtamry³GgÁrkS

rbs; exnXVIn fa RsIKUdNþwgevotNamrbs; m:aF½r BuMGaccakecjBIRkúgéRBnKr enAqñaM1975eT.

etIeKGaceFVI[GñkTaMgBIrCYbCuMKña)aneT?. ehon )ankt;TukehIyniyayfa Kat;nwgBinitüemIlnUvGVI

EdlKat;GacnwgeFVI)an. BIr-bIExeRkaymk nagRkmuMevotNam)ancakecjBIRbeTsevotNam

ehIy)anerobkarnwg m:aF½r. ebITukCamankarsb,ayGENþtGNþÚgEdlbgáeLIgedayTsSnvis½yén

karxitcUlCitKñamYyrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrk¾eday k¾karCYbCuMrbs; m:aF½r nigRsIKUdNþwgKat;EdlGs;

sgÇwmeTAehIy nigkarbBa¢ÚnmkmatuPUmivijnUvGdæiFatuTahanGaemrikaMg)at;xøÜndb;BIrnak; KWRbEhl

CalT§plsßitesßryUrGEgVgEtmYyKt;éndMeNIrrbs; vUdxUk kñúgTIbMputehIyemIleTA.

rg;caMePøógduløar

enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1975 TUrTsSn_rbs;GaemrikaMg)ancak;pSaynUvrUbPaBsþIBIkarrt;eKcxøÜn d¾

ekalahlénhVÚgGñkePosxøÜn nigBYkbuKÁlikGaemrikaMgenAmuxkarrulcUlrbs;kgT½BkumµúynIsþmkkan;

RkúgéRBnKr. minyUrb:unµaneRkaymk Rkúgv:asuInetanhak;dUcCaRtÚveFVI[PøwkPøaMgsµartIPøam²cMeBaH

GVI²TaMgGs;EdlTak;Tgnwg\NÐÚcin. karxÞb;luycMnYn150landuløarEdlevotNammanenAshrdæ

Gaemrik karhamXat;Epñkesdækic©y:agKMhukEdlbBaØtieTAelIRbeTskm<úCa nigevotNam karrMeCIb

rMCYlmYyry³xøIedaysarerOgr:avnavam:ay:aehÁenAEx]sPa bnÞab;BIenaHmk KWElgmanerOgGVITaMgGs; ³

\NÐÚcineTIbnwgliclg;y:ageRCAenAeRkamPaBmineGIeBIrbs;BYkGaemrikaMg6.

kareFVI[FujRTan;nigPaBminmanplRbeyaCn_rbs;shrdæGaemrik esÞIrEtmanTMhMpÞúynwgkar

GnÞHGEnÞgrbs;evotNamkñúgkarerobcMTMnak;TMngeLIgvijCamYyKUsRtÚvkalBImSilrbs;eK. taMgBImun

karbBa©b;éns®gÁam RkúghaNUyeCOCak;fa karBRgwgTMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜnCamYyelakxaglic CaBiess

CamYyshrdæGaemrik KWCakic©karEdlRtÚveFVImuneKedayxanmin)ansRmab;karsþarRbeTseLIgvij.

b:unµanéf¶bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHrbs;kumµúynIsþenATIRkúgéRBnKr ´¬GñkniBn§¦)ansYrkgT½Bmñak;EdlkMBug

yaml,atenAxagmuxsßanTUtGaemrikaMgfa ³ ehtuGVI)anCamineXIjTg;C½yrbs;«rNsirSrMedaHCati»

(F.N.L) bgðÚteLIgenAelIGKardUcenAelIsßanTUtelakxaglicÉeTot²Edl«rMedaH»)anG‘Ícwg? «eKmin

GnuBaØati[eyIgbgðÚteLIgeT». enHBuMEmnCakarePøcmYyrbs;GñkeFVIkarkñúgkariyal½yeLIy. RbeTs

evotNamsb,ayelatkeBaägEdl)anQñHs®gÁam b:uEnþ eKcg;)anCaBiesssnþiPaBeTot. enAEx

kkáda qñaM1975 naTIRkúghaNUy ´)ansaksYrelak v:ag Tug niBn§naykkaEstjinhSinCakaEst

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg162

Page 173: Brother enemy

RbcaMéf¶rbs;bkS enAeBlEdlKat;Kitcg;cuHpSay«ÉksarRkúgéRBnKr». enHCabrimaNÉksar

sm¶at;rbs;GaemrikaMgd¾sem,ImEdlrwbGUs)ankñúgrdæFanIevotNamxagt,Úg kñúgcMeNamenaHman

Éksarftcmøgdak;ExSGat; karerobrab;BIRbtibtþikarTaMgGs;rbs;es>GuI>Ga>enARbeTsevotNam

pg. ÉksarTaMgenHRtÚve)aHbg;ecaledayRkúmmnusSénkariyal½y C.I.O. (Central Intelligence Office)

rbs;evotNamEdlmanlkçN³dUcKñanwg C.I.A. Edr. Tug CamnusSR)akdRbCaNas; ³ RbeTs

evotNamminmanectnariHKn;GMBIGtItkal nigrBwsédykEdkeTArukdMe)Arbs;GaemrikaMgeLIy.

evotNamenAcgcaMeTIs\LÚvnUvsmþIsnÞnarbs; hU CImij kalBIqñaM1954. bnÞab;BIbraC½yrbs;

)araMgenA eDon ebon PU (Dien Bien Phu) hU )anbgÁab;bBa¢akuM[niBn§naykkaEstRbcaMéf¶rbs;bkS

cuHpSayGVIEdlbgðaj[eXIjCMenOeCOCak;hYsehtucMeBaH C½yCmñHEdlTTYl)an. hU )anBnül;fa

«kñúgdMNak;kalfµIEdlepþImeLIgenAeBlxagmux eyIgRtÚvkarmitþPaBnigshRbtibtþikarrbs;RbeTs

)araMg».

enAeBlenaH Tug )anTuk[´enAEtmindwgBImUlehtuR)akdRbCaEdlmanPaBCaedImehtuénPaB

rwgt¥wgrbs;evotNamkñúgkarbegáItTMnak;TMngedayesµaHRtg;CamYyshrdæGaemrik KWesckþIsgÇwmTTYl

)ankarbric©aKR)ak;cMnYn4>700landuløar ¬eRkamTRmg;CaCMnYyesdækic©¦ EdlsnüaCasm¶at;eday

elakRbFanaFibtI nicsun kñúg»kasénkarcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIseLIy. TRmaMEt

rdæaPi)alGaemrikmanqnÞ³eKarBkarsnüarbs;xøÜn RbeTsevotNam)ancab;epþImEccg;bNþaFnaKarik

nigGñkCMnYjrbs;shrdæGaemrikeRsceTAehIy. mindl;BIrExeRkaykardYlrlMénTIRkúgéRBnKrpg

bNþaGñktMNagrbs;FnaKarGaemrik (Bank of America) nigFnaKar First National City Bank )anRtÚv

GeBa¢Ijmkkan;RbeTsevotNam edIm,IsikSaBImeFüa)ayepSg²kñúgkarerobcMTMnak;TMngEpñkBaNiC¢kmµ

nighirBaØvtßúeLIgvij. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH evotNam)anR)ab;[bNþaRkúmh‘uneRbg EdlkalBI

GtItkalFøab;rukrkeRbgenAkñúgEdnTwkrbs;xøÜndwgfa evotNamnwgsVaKmn_Rkúmh‘unTaMgenaHCafµI.

enAéf¶TI3 Exmifuna KWmYyExEtb:ueNÑaHbnÞab;BIkardYlrlMénTIRkúgéRBnKr paM v:an;dug )aneLIg

niyayenAevTikardæsPaCatiedIm,ICMrujCa]Larik[shrdæGaemrikeFVI[TMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜn CamYy

RbeTsevotNammanRbRktIPaBeLIgvij nigpþl;nUvCMnYymYysRmab;karsßabnaRbeTsrbs;Kat;CafµI

dUcEdlshrdæGaemrikFøab;)ansnüaenATIRkúg):arIs. karGMBavnavenH RtÚv)anRcanecaledayRkúg

v:asuInetan. v:ag Tug )anRbkasR)ab;ePJóvGaemrikaMgmYyRkúmenAExvicäika qñaM1975fa ³ «enA

RbeTsevotNamvaCaRbéBNIeTAehIy kñúg»kasénBiFIbuNüepSg² EdleKerobcMkarRbkYte)ak

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 163

Page 174: Brother enemy

cM)ab; ehIyenAeRkaycb;karRbkYtKWKURbqaMgTaMgBIr)ancab;»bKña. RbeTsevotNam)anRbúgeRbób

eFVIdUcKñaenHEdr EtRbFanaFibtI hV½rd_ minRBm».

enAExdEdl elak hg;rI KIsSúIghÁ½r )anbgðajnUvkayvikarmYyEdlbNþal[manesckþIsgÇwm

xøH². eqøIytbeTAnwgkaredaHElgedayRkúghaNUynUvCnCatiGaemrikaMgR)aMbYnnak;Edlcab;)an

enAevotNamxagt,ÚgkalBIExmIna rdæm®nþIkarbreTsGaemrikaMg)anGnuBaØat[GgÁkarsasnanig

mnusSFm’CaeRcInbBa¢ÚnCMnYymkRbeTsevotNam. enAéf¶TI24 Exvicäika elak hg;rI KIsSúghÁ½r )an

Rbkasfa TMnak;TMngrbs;shrdæGaemrikCamYyRbeTsevotNam «nwgBuMenAEteRkamcMNuHGtItkal

eT». shrdæGaemrik)anRbkasxøÜneRtómeqøIytbeTAnwgkarsEmþg[eXIjsuqnÞ³TaMgGs;«ebIsinCa

bNþardæaPi)alenA\NÐÚcinbgðaj[eXIjlkçN³«eyaKyl;»cMeBaHkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;BYkGaemrikaMgni

gbNþaRbeTsCitxagxøÜnenAGasuI ehIyebIsinCaevotNamRbkan;yk\riyabf«sßabna»mYysþIBI

bBaðaeFVICMerOnTahanGaemrikaMg)at;xøÜncMnYn832nak; nigkareFVImatuPUminivtþn_nUvGdæiFaturbs;BYkeK

shrdæGaemrikk¾eRtómxøÜneFVIdUcKñaeTAvijeTAmkEdr».

vicarNkfamYyrbs;kaEstjÚvy:kEfm )anvaytémøedayxøÜnÉgfa ³ «enHehIyKWkarcab;epþIm

Rbkan;yk\riyabfd¾Tn;Pøn;mYyKYr[sresIry:agxøaMgcMeBaHbNþarbbkumµúynIsþenA\NÐÚcin b:uEnþ vaBit

CaenAsl;pøÚvEdlRtÚvedIrteTAeTot»7. GtßbT)an[eyabl;fa shrdæGaemrikRtÚve)aHbg;El,g

e)aHeqñatev:tUrbs;xøÜndUcEdlxøÜnFøab;eFVIenAExsIha edIm,IhamXat;karTTYlRbeTsevotNam[cUl

GgÁkarshRbCaCatieTA.

b:uEnþ Rkúgv:asuInetanmanbMNgbMePøcRbeTsevotNamecal EfmTaMgminGP½yeTas[eTot.

kare)aHeqñateRCIserIsRbFanaFibtIxitkan;EtCitmkdl;. sRmab;kare)aHeqñaterIsebkçPaBdMbUg elak

ehSr:al; hV½rd_ RtÚvtTl;nwgKURbECgniymsþaMKWelak r:UNal; rIehÁn. karKitBIesckþIsgÇwmEdlcg;

[TTYlyknUvGVI²EdlCaGaTiPaBrbs;evotNam Tak;TgeTAnwgkarraMgxÞb;Epñkesdækic©rbs;GaemrikaMg

KWesÞIrEtKµanTaMgRsug. enABak;kNþalkareRCIserIsebkçPaBsRmab;tMENgRbFanaFibtI KIsSúIghÁ½r

)anBRgwgCMhrrbs;GaemrikaMgeRkayBI)anBicarNarYcCaeRsc. Kat;)an[dwgfa karbBa¢ÚnmkmatuPUmi

vijnUvGdæiFatuTahan)at;xøÜn k¾dUckareFVICMerOnTahan)at;xøÜnEdlrkmineXIjdan «KWCaGVI²EdlRtÚv

eFVImuneKdac;xat ebIminG‘ÍcwgeT shrdæGaemrikminGacRbemIlemIlkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBmYy

eLIy». KIsSúIghÁ½r )anRbkasCaÉkCnpgEdrenAmuxKN³kmµkarTTYlbnÞúkbBaðamnusS)at;xøÜnenA

GasuIGaeKñy_fa vaBi)aknwgbgçM[RkúghaNUye)aHbg;sMeNIsuMCMnYyrbs;xøÜnNas; drabNabBaðasþIBI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg164

Page 175: Brother enemy

Tahan)at;xøÜnenAEtedaHRsayminTan;eRsc)ac;enaH. Kat;)anedAfa ³ «ebIsinCaBuMmanTahan)at;xøÜn

eT BYkeKnwgRtÚvbgçM[yl;RsbtamCMhrrbs;eyIg. b:uEnþeBlNaeyIgbgðajkarRcas;Rcal;rbs;

eyIgcMeBaHerOgrbs;eK eBlenaHBYkeKeTACakan;EtrwgrUseLIg»8.

b:uEnþ RkúghaNUy minEdle)aHbg;esckþIsgÇwmTTYl)anduløarkñúglMGanénkareFVI[manRbRktI

PaBEpñkkarTUteLIy. edaybBa¢ak;GHGagfa BYkeKBuMGaceKarBmaRtaénkic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIs

Tak;TgnwgkareFVICMerOnTahanGaemrikaMg)at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§eT drabNashrdæGaemrikminRbkan;Bakü

snüarbs;xøÜnkñúgkarpþl;CMnYyEpñkesdækic©mYy b:uEnþ enAExFñÚ qñaM1975 BYkevotNam)anGnuBaØat

[mankarRbKl;saksBTahanGaemrikaMgbInak;. BYkeKk¾)anRbKl;pgEdrnUvsaksBTahanm:arIn

cugeRkayBIrnak;EdlRtÚvsmøab;enAPaKxagt,Úg nigRbKl;eQµaHTahan)at;xøÜndb;BIrnak;EfmeTot.

karKn;KUrrbs;RkúghaNUyEdlmansPaBsuTidæiniymbnþicKWfa Rkúgv:asuInetanRtÚvtbsñgmkvij[

dUcKñanigdkecjnUvkarRbqaMgCMTas;rbs;xøÜncMeBaHkarpþl;CMnYyEpñkesdækic©mYymk[evotNam. b:uEnþ

BuMTan;manGVImYyTTYl)anplRbeyaCn_esaH. edIm,IebIkTVarRbeTsGaemrik RbeTsevotNam)an

eRbIR)as;l,icklmYyeTotedayKµanTTYleCaKC½yFMduMeLIy. evotNam)anbgðajedIm,ITak;citþBI

yfaPaBénkarcuHhtßelxaelIkugRtaCIkxYgGNþÚgeRbgkñúgEdnsmuRTrbs;xøÜn. munkardYlrlMénRkúg

éRBnKr eKvaytémøfacMnYnTwkR)ak;EdleFVIvinieyaKmanRbEhl100landuløar edayRkúmh‘un

GaemrikaMgCitémÖkñúgkareFVIGaCIvkmµ GNþÚgeRbgenARbeTsevotNam. Rkúmh‘unm:Ub‘Íl nig Esðl )an

eFVI[eRbg)aj;ecjBIkñúgdImkehIy. kardYlrlMrbs;evotNamxagt,Úg)anekIteLIgedaymindwgxøÜn

muneBlEdlRkúmh‘unTaMgenaH GacniyayedaykareCOCak;fa karrkeXIjrbs;BYkeKGaceFVIGaCIvkmµ

tampøÚvCMnYj)an. cab;BIExkkáda qñaM1975 GñktMNagénRkúmh‘uneRbgGaemrikaMgnana )anCYbGñk

TTYlxusRtÚvevotNam Casm¶at;enATIRkúg):arIskñúgeKalbMNgeFVIkarxYgGNþÚgeRbgeLIgvij. enAEx

kumÖ³ qñaM1976 GñktMNagxøHkñúgcMeNamenaH RtÚv)anGeBa¢Ij[eTAkan;RkúghaNUy edIm,Idak;CUnBinitü

nUvsMeNIrbs;xøÜn9. kareFVIRbtibtþikarxYgeRbg)ancab;epþImPøamedayKµanEGGg; rdæaPi)al hV½rd_ )an

bdiesFmindkkarraMgxÞb;Epñkesdækic©eLIy eTaHbICamankarekobsgát;rbs;mCÄdæanGñkrksuIeRbgk¾eday

drabNaevotNamminTan;cat;Ecg[mankareFVICMerOnTahanGaemrik)at;xøÜnedayeBjelj.

enAsrTrdUvqñaM1976 RbeTskm<úCasßitenAkñúgsßanPaBRCÜlRcbl;xøaMgedaykareFVIvisuT§kmµ

¬kare)assm¥at¦ y:ageXareXA ehIyRbeTscinkMBugsßitkñúgsm½yGnþrkal. kñúgry³eBlenaH

rebobeXasnaeRCIserIsRbFanaFibtIenAshrdæGaemrikmansPaBkan;EtxøaMgkøa. ebkçCnKNbkS

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 165

Page 176: Brother enemy

RbCaFibetyü hSImmI xaF½r )anbenÞasRbFanaFibtI ehS r:al;hV½rd_ fa minykcitþTukdak;bBa¢Ún

KN³kmµkarmYyeTAGegátBITahanGaemrik)at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§ nigminepþImeFVIkarcrcaCamYyRkúg

haNUy. tamsmþIelak xaF½r fa enHCakarminykcitþTukdak;mYyEdlKYr[esaksþayéRkElg.

edayCak;Esþg karykcitþTukdak;rbs; xaF½r cMeBaHTahan)at;xøÜn KWmanlkçN³skþismCaGñk

neya)ayy:agxøaMg.

edImehtuepSg²énkaryl;RcLMmYy

xaF½r )anEtgtaMg suIrus v:an;s_ [eFVICardæm®nþIkarbreTs nig rIqad hUlRb‘Úk CaGnurdæm®nþI

karbreTsTTYlbnÞúkkic©karGasuInig):asuIhVik. GñkTaMgBIr)ancUlrYmRKb;karsakl,gTaMgGs; sMedA

pþl;snÞúHdl;karEsVgrkdMeNaHRsaysnþiPaBenARbeTsevotNam. edaysMGagelIbTBiesaFn_BI

bBaðaevotNamrbs;Kat; v:an;s_ )anvaytémøfa kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBkñúgTMnak;TMngepSg²CamYy

RkúghaNUy nwgCYy[mankarbnßyPaBBwgEp¥krbs;RbeTsevotNamcMeBaH RkúgmUsÁÚ nigRkúg

eb:kaMg. mü:agvijeTot hUlRb‘Úk hak;dUcCamanRbpñÚlfa kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBenH nwgsEmþgtYnaTI

d¾sMxan;kñúgkarbegáItnUvTMnak;TMngsßabnamYyrvagRbeTsevotNam nigsmaKmGas‘anEfmeTot.

edayrMB£kBIehtuplepSg²énplRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜnsRmab;kic©karenAGasuI CamYyelakRbFanaFibtI

xaF½r hUlRb‘Úk )anEføgR)ab;Kat;fa ³ «KWenAGasuIcugbUBa’EdlshrdæGaemrik)aneBIbRbTHnwgbBaða

eRcInCageK kñúgGMLúg30qñaMcugeRkayenH. s®gÁamcugeRkayTaMgbIrbs;eyIg)ancab;epþImenATIenaH

ehIybBaðaénkarTTYlxusRtÚvkñúgkar)at;bg;RbeTscin/ RbeTskUer:/ RbeTsevotNam nigRbeTs

km<úCa )aneTACacMNucsMxan;énkarCECkBiPakSaxagneya)ayd¾ekþAKKukrbs;eyIg. ´Kitfa

rdæaPi)alrbs;elakGacnwgeFVI[eXIjrbt;mYy. eyIgGacnwgerobcMneya)ayRbTak;KñamYy Edl

nwgbBa©b;sßanPaBenH ehIyRbkan;yk\riyabfmYycMeBaHGasuI»10.

kñúgzan³CaGPi)alrdæ ehSG½rhSúI (Géorgie) elak xaF½r minEdlRbkan;CMhsþIBIs®gÁamenA

evotNameT. Kat;RtÚveFVIcab;GarmµN_tictYcBIRTwsþIeqñIm²TaMgenaH Edlb:unb:gbegáItrebobrbbfµImYy

enAGasuI. hUlRb‘Úk )anniyayR)ab;´fa «´minKitfa elak xaF½r minsUvmanTsSn³eTAelIbBaðaenH

eT ³ erOgEtmYyKt; EdleFVI[Kat;Cab;citþkñúgRbeTsevotNam KWGMNacCanimitþrUbrbs;Kat; BIeRBaH

Kat;)anRtÚveRCIstaMg[eFVICaRbFanaFibtIeRkaysm½ys®gÁam. Kat;ykcitþTukdak;y:agxøaMgcMeBaH

kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNamEbbCanimitþrUbmYy ehIyKat;k¾ykcitþTukdak;xøaMgkñúg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg166

Page 177: Brother enemy

kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscinnigKuy)apgEdr. Kat;cg;eFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYymnusS

TaMgGs;». kñúgzan³CaRbFanaFibtITImYybnÞab;BIsm½ys®gÁam Kat;cab;epþImRbmUlpþúMRbCaCnkñúg

RbeTseLIgvij nigeFVI[shrdæGaemrikmankitþis½BÞCafµIenAbreTs. dUecñH Kat;RtÚvEteFVI[eKbMePøc

RbeTsevotNamBIGarmµN_ ehIykñúgn½yenHkayvikardMbUgrbs;Kat;KWelIkElgeTasTaMgRsugcMeBaH

GñkminsuxcitþcuHj:mTaMgGs;. meFüa)aymYyeTot edIm,IbMePøcGtItkalKYr[QWcab;enH KWsßitenA

Rtg;TTYl[)annUvB½t’manTaMgGs;sþIBITahan2>500nak;Edlsøab;enA\NÐÚcin kñúgcMeNamenaHman

800nak;RtÚvcat;Tukfa )at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§11.

karTamTaredayTTUcrbs;rdæaPi)al hV½rd_ edIm,ItRmÚv[mankareFVICMerOnTahan)at;xøÜneBj

eljmYymunkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBTaMgRsugKWxVHlkçN³R)akdniymbnþic. tamkarBit bBaðaenH

Føab;)at;skmµPaBmþgeTAehIy. kñúgry³eBlénkareXasnae)aHeqñat elakRbFanaFibtI hV½rd_

)anbeBa©jb£kx<g;x<s;nigéføfñÚrkñúg\riyabfminbn§ÚrédmYy edIm,IRbqaMgnwgkarecaTRbkan;epSg²Edl

manlkçN³PøIePøIKµandwgxusRtÚv. kic©karcaM)ac;rbs; xaF½r RtÚv)anCYysRmÜledayr)aykarN_mYy

rbs;KN³kmµkarTTYlbnÞúkbBaðaCn)at;xøÜnenAGasuIGaeKñy_ EdldwknaMedaysmaCiksPasaFarNrdæ

sunnI m:ugháÚem:rI edaysnñidæanfa BuMmanCnCatiGaemrikaMgNamñak; ehIyk¾KµanGñkeTasNamñak;rs;ran

manCIvitenA\NÐÚcin b¤enATIdéTEdr. r)aykarN_)anbEnßmfa ³ «kareFVICMerOneBjeljmYyKWmin

GaceFVI)aneLIy dUecñH minRtÚvsgÇwmelIbNþardæaPi)alenA\NÐÚcineT»12.

karcab;RbtibtþikmµviFIneya)aykarbreTsrbs;rdæaPi)alfµI hak;dUcCaBuMmanecaTeLIgnUv

]bsKÁFMduMeT eTaHCay:agNak¾edayk¾enAmancMNucmYyeTotKW karbiTCMBUks®gÁamenAevotNam.

shrdæGaemrik)ane)aHbg;nUvesckþIsgÇwmTaMgRsugcMeBaHkareFVICMerOneBjeljénTahan)at;xøÜnkñúg

karRbyuT§. vaElgCakareFVICMerOnmYyEdl«eBjeljk¾dUcGacTTYlyk)an»eTotehIy. dUecñH

shrdæGaemrikKitfa RkúghaNUynwgsEmþg[eXIjlkçN³shkar edayehtufa eK)anbnþe)ak

ykCMnYymnusSFm’edayl,icd¾buinRbsb;. kñúgGnusSrN³mYyEdleFVIeLIgsRmab;KeRmagkar

epSg²rbs;RbFanaFibtIfµIxagvis½yneya)aykarbreTs v:an;s_ )anCMruj[bBa¢ÚnKN³RbtiPUmYy

tMNagRbFanaFibtIeTAkan;\NÐÚcinenAExtula qñaM1976 edIm,IBiPakSaBIbBaðaTahan)at;xøÜn. enATIRkúg

haNUy eRbsittMNagRbFanaFibtInwgRtÚvRbKl;GMNac[Rbkas-kñúgnaménv:an;s_-fa «shrdæ

Gaemrik)anRbúgeRbóbCaeRscedIm,Idak;CUnsPaCan;TabBinitünUvkmµviFICMnYymnusSFm’mYykñúgvis½y

sagsg;lMenAdæannigsuxaPi)alkalebIeyIgTTYl)ankareFVICMerOnmYysþIBITahan)at;xøÜnPøam»13.

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 167

Page 178: Brother enemy

RbkarenHRbEhlCakarepþImKMnitxagneya)aykarbreTselIkdMbUgrbs;elak xaF½r. bIEx

bnÞab;BIkarRbkascUlkan;muxtMENg KN³ebskkmµrbs;RbFanaFibtIEdldwknaMedayelak eLGUNard_

vUdxUk )aneLIgynþehaHmkkan;RkúghaNUy. m®nþIenARksYgkarbreTsmñak;)anTTYlsÁal;fa ³ «kar

cab;GarmµN_EtmYyKt;kñúgkarbBa¢ÚnKN³ebskkmµrbs; vUdxUk KWbBa¢ak;[dwgCak;EsþgBImrNPaBrbs;

Tahan)at;xøÜnTaMgGs;». bBaðaBuMEmnmanEtEpñkmnusSFm’b:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþ manEpñkhirBaØvtßúpgEdr.

dUecñH mnÞIrbBa©ekaN )ancat;EcgepÞrR)ak;bMNac;rbs;BYkeKeTA[Gñk)at;xøÜnCaeRsckñúgeBlEdlkar

søab;rbs;GñkTaMgenaH enAminTan;bgðajP½sþútagCapøÚvkarenAeLIy.

elak xaF½r eBjcitþnwglT§plCaeRcIn. edaysgÇwmelIeCaKC½yEpñkneya)aykarbreTs

elIkdMbUgmYy xaF½r )ancat;TukRbtikmµrbs;evotNamcMeBaHKN³ebskkmµrbs; vUdxUk famanlkçN³

«GMeNayply:agxøaMg» nig)ansEmþg[eXIjnUvkareBjcitþrbs;Kat;cMeBaHGVI²TaMgGs;Edlevot

NamFøab;)anpþl;[rYcmkehIysþIBIbBaðaTahan)at;xøÜn. Kat;)ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa ³ «´eCOfa GVI²TaMg

Gs;KWRbEhlCaevotNamGacpþl;[ ´KµanmeFüa)ayNamYybgðaj[eXIjfa evotNam)aneFVI

CMerOnTahan)at;xøÜnTaMgGs; EdlBYkeKmanB½t’manepSg²sþIBIBYkenaHeT b:uEnþ ´Gacniyayfa BYkeK

mansuqnÞ³»14.

qnÞ³kñúgkareFVIshRbtibtþikarBitR)akdrbs;evotNam)aneFVI[elceLIgnUvlT§plCaeRcIn

pÞúyKñanwgExµrRkhmEdleFVI[ xaF½r TTYlrgnUvkarepÁInbM)ak;muxBitR)akdmYy. KN³RbtiPUrbs; vUdxUk

BuM)anTTYlkareqøIytbNamYyeTAnwgsMeNIsuMGnuBaØateFVIdMeNIreTAkan;RkúgPñMeBjrbs;xøÜneLIy.

taMgBIRkúgevogc½nÞ rdæFanIrbs;RbeTsLavCaTIEdlKN³RbtiPUsñak;enAmYyry³eBlRtLb;mkBI

RbeTsevotNam vUdxUk )anepþImeFVIesckþIesñIkarCacugeRkaymYy. m®nþImñak;énRksYgkarbreTs

EdleTACamYyKN³RbtiPU )aneTAkan;sßanTUtkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüedIm,IriHrkpøÚv[)anTTYlkar

GnuBaØateTATsSnkic©RbeTsenH. b:uEnþ dUcKñanwgRbeTskm<úCapÞal;rbs;eKEdr sßanTUtenHenAEtbiTTVar

Citsøúg. eRkayBIm®nþIrUbenHeKaHTVarkñúgry³eBlknøHem:ag Priyarbs;ÉkGKÁrdæTUtExµrRkhmEdl

k¾CaelxaTImYyrbs;bþIKat; )anebIkTVaredIm,ITTYlB½t’manEdlsresredayelak vUdxUk. «elakÉk

GKÁrdæTUtminenAeT» nagniyayeTAkan;ebskCnGaemrik tamcenøaHTVarEdlbegðIbbnþicmunnwgbiTTVar

lan;RKaMgesÞIrb:HRcmuHKat;. kareqøIytbrbs;RkúgPñMeBjRtÚv)anpSBVpSaytamviTüúCati ³ «kMhwgvNѳ

rbs;RbCaCnkm<úCa enAEtRbqaMgnwgBYkcRkBtþiGaemrikaMgnigBYkEqábMerIvadl;TIbMput. RbCaCnkm<úCa

RsLaj;ÉkraCüPaB GFibetyüPaB nigesrIPaBrbs;xøÜnCaTIbMput. BYkeyIgminGacTTYlyl;RBm

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg168

Page 179: Brother enemy

tamBaküsuMrbs;BYkcRkBtþiGaemrikkñúgkarbBa¢ÚnKN³RbtiPUmYy edIm,ImkeFVITsSnkic©enAkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyü)aneLIy. BYkeyIgminGacéllkCYbKN³RbtiPUenH)aneT eTaHCaenAkEnøgNa

k¾eday».

elak xaF½r mancitþrIkrayKYrsmcMeBaHkarbn§ÚrbnßyfµIEdlsEmþg[eXIjedayBYkevotNam.

Kat;)ankt;smÁal;fa kalBIeBlknøgmk evotNamFøab;Rbkasfa BYkeKnwgmincrca ehIynwgmin

pþl;B½t’manbEnßmtictYcNamYysþIBITahan)at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§eLIy drabNashrdæGaemrikenAEt

bdiesFminsgkarxUcxatedaysars®gÁam. b:uEnþ\LÚvenH BYkeK)anpþl;KMnit[mankarerobcMkic©

RbCuMCafµIenATIRkúg):arIs edayKµankRmitlkçxNÐGVICamun. tamkar[dwgrbs;elak xaF½r KWevot

Nam)anR)ab;elakfa ³ «eyIgkuMeFVI[karRsuHRsÜlKñanigkarminRtÚvKñakalBIGtItkalKaMgenA

dEdl. cUreyIgEbreq<aHeTArkGnaKtvij». eday\tERkgrEGgTaMgRsugcMeBaHectnaepSg²rbs;

evotNam Kat;)ansnñidæanBIerOgenHfa RkúghaNUy)aneRtómlHbg;ecalkarTamTarrbs;xøÜnBI

yUrmkehIy-karpþl;CMnYymYyrbs;shrdæGaemrikkñúgkarsßabnaRbeTseLIgvij. b:uEnþ esckþIray

karN_rbs; vUdxUk manlkçN³c,as;las;Kµan[mnÞil ³ edayminniyaycMfa CMnYyenHCabBaðaGaTiPaB

kñúgkareFVI[TMnak;TMngkarTUtmanRbRktIPaBeLIgvij evotNam)anedAbBa¢ak;y:agc,as;fa bBaðaTaMg

BIrenHKWCab;Tak;TgnwgKña.

karRbEkkrbs;RkúghaNUy manry³eBlBuMyUreLIy. bIéf¶eRkaymk kñúgbTsmÖasn_mYy

CamYyTIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam pan; ehon )aneqøIybdiesFedaymincMeBaHeTAnwgkarbkRsay

rbs;elak xaF½r. Kat;)anEføgR)ab;KN³ebskkmµrbs; vUdxUk fa RbeTsevotNamR)afñaebIk

TMB½rCafµIkñúgTMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜnCamYyshrdæGaemrik b:uEnþKat;)anbBa¢ak;y:agc,as;fa eTaHbIy:agNa

«vaBi)akbdiesFeTAelIGtItkalEtmü:ag)aneT. enAtampøÚvénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB enAman]bsKÁ

CaeRcIneTotEdlRtÚvBuHBar15.

eTaHCakarPan;RcLMkñúgkarvinicä½yenHminRKb;RKan;k¾eday k¾elak xaF½r )anbEnßmcMeBaHPaBmin

c,as;las;enHedayBaküsmþIEdlmann½yminCak;lak;EfmeTot. edayelIkykmkCECkrkkarBit

fa shrdæGaemrikmankatBVkic©RtÚvCYyRbeTsevotNamEdrb¤eTenaH elak xaF½r minEvkEjkeday

Cak;lak;BIyfaPaBenHeLIy. RbFanaFibtIGaemrikaMg)anR)ab;[dwgfa ³ «´nwgeFVIRbtikmµedaykar

eyaKyl; ebIsinCavaekItmanedayKab;cYnkñúgPaBbnþKñaénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeLIgvijnUvTMnak;

TMngEpñkBaNiC¢kmµ nig TRmg;énCMnYyEpñkesdækic©xøH²EdlRtÚvcab;epþImCafµI».

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 169

Page 180: Brother enemy

etICMnYyrbs;GaemrikaMgCasarsMxan;mYy b¤pÞúyeTAvijCaEpñkEdlcUlmkbMeBjb®gÁb;mYy

kñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeLIgvij?. xaF½r BuM)anRbkan;CMhredayPaBc,as;las;eBjelj

CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;dMeNaHRsayTImYyeT. BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUy )anRtÚvCMrujedaysmehtu

smpl[eFVIkarekobsgát; edIm,IbgçM[edaHRsaybBaðaTIBIr. C½yCmñHrbs;elak xaF½r nigeGKIb

rbs;Kat;EdlsuT§EtCasmasPaBniymkNþal ehIyEdll,Il,ajedaysarkarRbqaMgnwgs®gÁam

rbs;BYkeK )aneFVI[esckþIsgÇwmrbs;RkúghaNUyelceLIg. KN³ebskkmµrbs; vUdxUk EdlrYm

mansmasPaBniymkNþal)aneFVI[evotNamrwtEteCOEfmeTotkñúgKMnitfa shrdæGaemrikRtÚvEt

lublagbT]Rkidærbs;xøÜn16. eRkaykarcUlkan;muxtMENgrbs;Kat;bnþic xaF½r )anrevosrévcat;

bBa¢ÚnKN³RbtiPUmYyy:agrh½s nigBRgwgPaBR)akdkñúgcitþrbs;Kat;fa RbeTsevotNamenAEtCa

cMNuckNþalénneya)ayrbs;GaemrikaMgCanic© ehIyfaRkúgv:asuInetan)anRbúgeRbóbbg;témøénkar

eFVI[manRbRktIPaBCaeRsc. CaGñkm:akSsuIsniymRtwmRtÚv BYkemdwknaMevotNam)anrkSaCab;kñúg

citþCanic©nUvGVIEdlBYkeKvaytémø BIktþakMNt;Epñkesdækic©EdlenABIeRkamkareFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;cRkBtþi

nigeCOCak;fa skþanuBlEpñkesdækic©rbs;RbeTsevotNam ¬RbPBFnFanFmµCati nightßBlikEdl

manKuNsm,tþi¦ lµmRKb;RKan;nwgeFVI[BYkmUlFnikGaemrikaMgRtLb;mkvij. karpþl;CMnYymYyeTA[

RbeTsevotNamnwgpþl;KuNRbeyaCn_cMeBaH]sSahkmµrbs;GaemrikEfmeTot. kalBIqñaM1973

KN³kmµkaresdækic©cRmúHGaemrikaMg-evotNammYy )anseRmcQandl;KeRmagkic©RBmeRBógmYy

Edltamry³enH shrdæGaemrik)ansnüaeRbIR)as;nUvkmµviFICMnYymYyEdlmanTwkR)ak;srub1>500

landuløar ehIyRbeTsevotNamRtÚveRbIR)as;85PaKryénTwkR)ak;enHsRmab;Tij plitplrbs;

GaemrikaMgvij. eRkABIkareRskXøanplkéRmrbs;BYkmUlFnik RkúghaNUyk¾yl;eXIjfa Gac

TukcitþelIcitþsb,úrsEdlmanBIkMeNItrbs;BYkGaemrikaMg nigKMnitGaRkk;rbs;eKcMeBaHRbeTs

evotNamEdr. GñkedIredIm,IsnþiPaBrab;Ban;nak; Gñkmanekrþ×eQµaHl,Il,ajRbmaNdb;nak;énsPa

Can;TabGaemrik EdlkalBIeBlfµI²Føab;Rbkan;CMhrRbqaMgs®gÁamnwgCMruj[mankareFVI[TMnak;TMng

epSg²manPaBRbRktIedayCak;lak; nigkarElgxÞb;CMnYymYysRmab;karsßabnaRbeTsevotNam

eLIgvijehIy.

GVI²TaMgGs;bgðaj[eXIjfa rdæaPi)al xaF½r RbEhlCaminyl;BICMhrrbs;evotNambnþic

esaH. eTaHCaevotNamRbkan;esckþIsgÇwmTTYl)anCMnYyGaemrikaMgd¾sem,ImmYyk¾eday k¾BuMR)akd

fa BYkeKvaytémøskþismnwgTTYlrgVan;mYysRmab;shRbtibtþikarrbs;eKsþIBIbBaðaTahan)at;xøÜn

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg170

Page 181: Brother enemy

EdreT b:uEnþ BIeRBaHtamkaryl;eXIjrbs;BYkeKfa enHCabMNulEpñksIlFm’mYyrbs;shrdæGaemrik

eTAvij.

Cak;c,as;Nas;EdlminmanGñkNamñak;enARkúgv:asuInetanFøab;Kitsµanfa evotNam)ansMGag

ykEtEmnETnelIGMeNayd¾sb,úrsrbs;GaemrikaMg -enHCarebobbkRsayrbs;Cn\NÐÚcinGMBI

Epnkar m:arsðal (Plan Marshall)- edIm,IsßabnaRbeTsrbs;xøÜn EdlbMpøicbMpøajedays®gÁameLIg

vij. k¾b:uEnþ>>> m®nþICan;x<s;mñak;rbs;evotNam)anbBa¢ak;R)ab;´kñúgeBlerobcMeFVIEpnkaresdækic©

TImYyeRkaysm½ys®gÁamfa bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHrbs; xaF½r Pøam evotNam)andak;bBa©ÚlkñúgkarKit

TukCamunrbs;xøÜnCaeRscnUvCMnYymYyEdlmanTwkR)ak;4>700landuløar Edlsnüapþl;[kalBIqñaM

1973. tamm®nþICan;x<s;evotNammñak;eTotfa «KWkaretOnbgçMCabnÞan;rbs;BYkGñkTTYlxusRtÚveFVI

Epnkaresdækic© CaBiess eL faj;gI eTIbevotNamseRmccitþbgðajnUvcMNucminGacpøas;bþÚr)anenH

kñúgPaBcaM)ac;xanmin)anénCMnYymYy sRmab;karsþarRbeTseLIgvij edaycat;Tukfa CabBaðaEdl

RtÚvCECkBiPakSamuneKkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyshrdæGaemrik»17.

CaeRcInqñaMeRkaymk rIqad hUlRb‘Úk Edl´R)ab;[dwgBIEpnkarrbs;evotNam edIm,ITajyk

luyEdlsnüaedayRbFanaFibtI nicsun )anlan;mat;fa ³ «BYkeKRbEhlCaLb;sµartIGs;ehIy».

hUlRb‘Úk EdlCamnusSd¾Gs©arüsRmab;neya)aykarbreTsrbs;GaemrikaMg KWCaCnmñak;kñúg

cMeNamCnTaMgLayEdlFøab;qøgemeraKevotNam. bIqñaMenARbeTsevotNamsRmab;muxtMENgdMbUg

rbs;Kat;enAbreTs ³ bTBiesaFn_enH)anGenÞaltamKat;Gs;mYyCIvit.

RtÚvEtgtaMgedayelak xaF½r nig suIrus v:an;s_ CaGnurdæm®nþIkarbreTsTTYlbnÞúkkic©karGasuI

xagekIt hUlRb‘Úk )anyl;eXIjfa enHCa»kasedIm,IkMNt;neya)ayGasuImYyedaylkçN³R)akd

niymehIy18. kñúgKMnitrbs;Kat; kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNam nigRbeTscin

RtÚvEterobcMeLIgCadMNak;kaldMbUg ehIykñúgdMNak;kaldMbUgenH kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBkñúgTMnak;

TMngCamYyRbeTsevotNamKWCaGaTiPaBdac;xat. shkarImñak;kñúgcMeNamshkarIrbs;Kat;enARksYg

karbreTs)anniyayfa ³ «Dick CamnusSEdlRtÚveFVI[xVl;citþedaysarRbeTsevotNam. Kat;cg;

mancMENkkñúgRbvtþisa®sþEdr kñúgzan³CaGñknaMGaT×karpSHpSaCamYyRbeTsenH BIeRBaHkarpSHpSaenH

nwgbBa©b;CasßaBrnUvCMBUkd¾KYr[QWcab;mYyénneya)aykarbreTsrbs;GaemrikaMg».

rdæaPi)alelak xaF½r k¾manmUlehtuepSg²kñúgkareFVI[TMnak;TMngCamYyRbeTsevotNamman

RbRktIPaBeLIgvijEdr. enA»kasmYy elakRbFanaFibtIpÞal;)anelIkykmkniyayBIRbPBFn

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 171

Page 182: Brother enemy

FanFmµCatid¾sMxan;rbs;evotNamEfmeTot CaBiesseRbgkat. TnÞwmnwgenaH edaymincg;beNþay

[BYkGWr:ubnigCb:undeNþImkEnøgxøÜnenARbeTsevotNam BYkFnaKarik GñkCMnYj nigBYk]sSahkreRbg

rbs;GaemrikaMg)aneFVIkarekobsgát; edIm,I[rdæaPi)aldkr)aMgBaNiC¢kmµecj. enAéf¶TI18 Exemsa

qñaM1977 RkúghaNUy)anecjpSayCasaFarN³nUvc,ab;vinieyaKÉkCnmYy sRmab;CnbreTs

EdlmanlkçN³esrIKYr[PJak;ep¥IlEdlkalBI BIr-bIExmun BYkFnaKarikGaemrikaMgxøHGacdwgesckþI

RBagc,ab;enHrYceTAehIy.

TsSn³Epñkesdækic©GMBIbBaðaenH KWminGackat;pþac;)anBIkarBicarNaEpñkkarTUt EdlmanlkçN³

TUlMTUlayCageLIy. v:an;s_ nig hUlRb‘Úk eCOfa edayCMBak;citþnwgÉkraCüPaBrbs;xøÜnxøaMgeBk

RbeTsevotNamcUlcitþRbkan;ykneya)aytulüPaBmYyrvagmhaGMNacnanaCagedaysarsßanPaB

BwgEp¥krbs;eKTaMgRsugmYycMeBaHBYksUevot. GñkTaMgBIryl;eXIjfaGvtþmanénGñktMNagkarTUt

rbs;GaemrikaMgenARbeTsevotNam )anbg¥ak;BYkeKmin[mankmøaMgTb;mYyTl;nwg\T§iBlrbs;sUevot

enAtMbn;GasuIGaeKñy_. kñúgsarNarbs;Kat; v:an;s_ )ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa «´Føab;manGarmµN_fa kar

begáItTMnak;TMngkarTUtCaFmµtaCamYyRbeTsevotNam EdlbNþaRbeTsCamitþrbs;eyIgenAGasuI

suT§Etcg;)any:agxøaMgenaH nwgebIk»kas[eyIgbegáIn\T§iBlrbs;eyIgeTAelIRbeTsenH nigpþl;nUv

meFüa)aymYysRmab;CYy[RbeTsevotNamedaHxøÜnputBIPaBenAkñúgcMNuHxagneya)aynigeyaFa

hYsRbmaNBIshPaBsUevot b¤RbeTscin»19. manEt b‘ÍkjÚ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI TIRbwkSasnþisuxmñak;b:ueNÑaH

Edlbgðaj[eXIjPaBmineGIeBIcMeBaHGVIEdlKat;ehAfa «CabBaðabnÞab;bnSMdUcbBaðaevotNamG‘Ícwg».

karExVgKMnitKña kñúgkarvaytémøenHnwgpÞúkeTAedayplvi)aky:ageRcIn20.

TIbBa©b;énkaryl;RcLM

mYyExbnÞab;BIelak vUdxUk RtLb;BIevotNammkvij evotNamnigBYkGaemrikaMg )ancab;epþIm

crcaCafµIenATIRkúg):arIs. elIkenH rgVg;énbBaðaepSg²EdlelIkykmkCECkBiPakSaedaysRtÚv

TaMgBIr KWmanlkçN³TUlMTUlayCagmuneRcIn. karcrcak¾rYmbBa©ÚlbBaðaeFVI[manRbRktIPaBEdr.

Ex]sPa CaExEdlGVI²manlkçN³GFikGFm ehIyTsSnvis½yGMBIeCaKC½y k¾KYrCaTIsgÇwmbMput.

eTaHbICamanr)aMgBaNiC¢kmµEdlenACaFrmank¾eday k¾rdæaPi)alelak xaF½r )anGnuBaØat[dwkCMnYy

mnusSFm’mYyCaÉkCneTARbeTsevotNam EdlmantémøCaTwkR)ak;5landuløar. enAExmkra

edayRbkan;KMnitpÞúyBIneya)ayrbs;rdæaPi)al hV½rd_ elak xaF½r min)anCMTas;nwgkarpþl;R)ak;km©I

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg172

Page 183: Brother enemy

mYyedayGgÁkarshRbCaCati edIm,IeFVIhirBaØb,Tandl;KeRmagGPivDÆn_mYyeLIy. kñúgkareFVI

smÖasn_mYymunkarecjdMeNIrrbs;Kat;BITIRkúgv:asuInetaneTAkan;Rkúg):arIs elak hUlRb‘Úk BuM)an

bdiesFfa shrdæGaemrik)anpþl;edaymincMeBaHnUvCMnYymYydl;RbeTsevotNameLIy. bNþa

TsSnkic©enATIRkúghaNUyénGñktMNagGgÁkarmUlniFirUbiyvtßúGnþrCati (F.M.I.) enAExFñÚ qñaM1976

bnÞab;mk TsSnkic©rbs;GñktMNagFnaKarBiPBelak enAExmkra qñaM1977 )aneFVI[evotNam

sgÇwmfa CMnYyrbs;GaemrikaMgnwgqøgkat;tamsßab½nTaMgBIrenH EdlRtÜtRtay:agditdl;edayshrdæ

Gaemrik. r)aykarN_sm¶at;rbs;FnaKarBiPBelak Edltak;EtgbnÞab;BIkarvilRtLb;énbNþaGñk

CMnajkarrbs;xøÜnnwgmandMeNIrl¥eTAtamn½yenH ³ edayelIksresIrBIkarxMRbwgERbgrbs;rdæaPi)al

evotNamedIm,IebIk[eRbIR)as;nUvRbPBFnFanFmµCati nigTajykplRbeyaCn_BIskþanuBld¾

TUlMTUlayrbs;xøÜn eyIgsuMkuM[GñkCMhrpþl;R)ak;raMgxÞb;«CMnYyFMduMmYy» tamlkçxNÐEdlmankMNt;.

kñúgry³eBlénkarsßabnaRbeTseLIgvijbnÞab;BIs®gÁamd¾EvgGnøaymYy RbeTsevotNamRtÚvkar

eBlryalmYyry³ edIm,ItRmg;Tisesdækic©rbs;xøÜneLIgvij tamkarERbRbÜlénbNþaeKaledAfµIkñúg

eBlRbeTsmansnþiPaB»21.

enAéf¶TI27 Exemsa ÉkGKÁraCTUtshrdæGaemrikRbcaMRbeTséf)anvayTUrelxeTARkúgv:asuInetan

edIm,ICUnB½t’mandl;bNþaecAhVaynayrbs;xøÜnGMBIesckþIsgÇwmrbs;RkúghaNUy. edayRsg;smþI

ÉkGKÁrdæTUtRbeTsEblhSúikRbcaMrdæFanIrbs;evotNammkniyayCasMGag Kat;)anraykarN_fa

evotNam)ayvaytémøy:agmutmaMGMBIkarpþl;CMnYymYyrbs;GaemrikaMg bnÞab;BIkareFVI[manRbRktI

PaB ehIyfakñúgTsSnvis½yenH BYkeKTnÞwgrg;caMedayGnÞHsanUvkarebIkKN³ebskkmµkarTUtrbs;

shrdæGaemriktUcmYyenATIRkúghaNUy nacugqñaM197722. kñúgsMbuRteqøIyqøgmYyeTot m®nþI

sßanTUt)anerobrab;bBa©ÚlnUvsmþIsnÞnarbs;Gñk[karN_mñak;Edlfa «naykrdæm®nþI paM v:an;dug )ansEmþg

[eXIjTwkcitþesamnSrIkrayy:agxøaMg»cMeBaHGnaKténTMnak;TMngrvagGaemriknigevotNam.

lT§plénkarcrcaEdlRbRBwtþeTABIéf¶TI3 dl;TI4 Ex]sPa kñúgGKarmYyénGtItKN³ebsk

kmµevotkugenARkúg):arIs hak;dUcCaeFVI[mankarxkcitþy:agesaHkeRkaHmYy. pan; ehon )anrMB£kBI

lixitEdlelak nicsun epJImk[naykrdæm®nþI paM v:an;dug EdlkñúgenaH RbFanaFibtIGaemrikaMg)an

snüabg;R)ak;dl;RbeTsevotNamcMnYn3>250landuløar edayKitCaCMnYysRmab;karsþarRbeTs

eLIgvij bUkbEnßmnwgkarpþl;vtßúFatuedImeTot EdlKitCaTwkR)ak;mancMnYndl;eTA1>250landuløar.

rdæaPi)alelak xaF½r )an[dwgfa xøÜnBuMGaceFVItamkic©snüaenH)aneT. hUlRb‘Úk )anniyayR)ab;´

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 173

Page 184: Brother enemy

¬GñkniBn§¦Casm¶at;fa ³ «Kat;)anTTYlkarENnaM[esñIBYkevotNamTTYlsÁal;eTAvijeTAmk edaymin

KitfaGVIEdlRtÚvCECkmun b¤CECkeRkayeT nigsEmþg[dwgnUvbMNgrbs;eyIgEdlcg;eXIjRbeTs

evotNameFVIsmahr½NTaMgRsugkñúgtMbn;GasuIGaeKñy_mYy EdlRbkbedaysßirPaBnigsnþiPaB».

GñkcrcaGaemrikaMg)anniyayR)ab; ehon BIsmancitþTaMgmUlrbs;Kat;cMeBaHsßanPaBRbkbeday

eRKaHfñak;EdlRbeTsevotNam RtÚvrgTTYlbnÞab;BIkarbMpøicbMpøajedaysars®gÁam b:uEnþbdiesFmin

eFVIkarsnüacMeBaHkarpþl;CMnYyCayfaehtumYyrbs;GaemrikaMgeLIy. Kat;)anbMPøWfa CMnYymYyEbb

enaHGacnwgeRKagKit bnÞab;BIkarbegáItTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUtrYc b:uEnþR)akdNas;KWBuMEmnmuneT.

karFanafa shrdæGaemriknwgElge)aHeqñatev:tUrbs;xøÜnkñúgkarcUlCasmaCikGgÁkarshRbCaCati

rbs;evotNam BuMEmnCakarPJak;ep¥IlEdleFVI[sb,aymunsRmab;KUsnÞnarbs;Kat;eT BIeRBaHRkúg

haNUy)anrkSaTukehtukarN_enHkñúgcitþsRmab;CakarBiesaFn_taMgBI\LÚvenHeTAehIy.

exnXVIn EdlenACMnan;enaHCaTIRbwkSaBiessrbs; hUlRb‘Úk enAnwkeXIjfa kñúgGMLúgénkarcrca

Rsab;EtecAhVaynayrbs;Kat;EdlQreQ¶akelItu)anRbkasfa «elakrdæm®nþI¡ eyIgTukerOgEdl

eFVI[eyIgminRtÚvKñamYyduM. eyIgecjBIRbCuM ehIyRbkasR)ab;GñksarB½t’manrYmKñafa eyIg)an

seRmccitþeFVI[TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;eyIgmanRbRktIPaBehIy». ehon )anbdiesF. Kat;)an

eRkInrMB£kfa shrdæGaemrikRtÚvEtCYybiTsñamrbYsedaysars®gÁameLIgvij. tamkar[dwgrbs;

XVIn KWevotNamKitfaTTYl)anC½yCmñHEpñksIlFm’mYy ehIyRbkarenHÉgEdlelceLIgCa

mUlehtuénkarcecsrbs;eK. C½yCmñHenAqñaM1975 BitCaskmµPaBRsbc,ab;rbs;bkSeKtaMgBI

40qñaMknøgmk. RbCaCatiepSg²eTotEdlcaj;s®gÁam CaBiess RbeTsCb:un nigRbeTs)araMg

suT§EtTTYlsÁal;edayyl;RBmbg;témøsRmab;CYsCulkarxUcxat edaysars®gÁameLIgvij.

C½yCmñHEpñksIlFm’enHnwgBuMeBjeljeT RbsinebIBYkGaemrikaMgRtLb;mkRbeTsevotNamvij

edayBuM)ansgéføkarxUcxatbNþalmkBIs®gÁam.

erOgr:av)anERbeTACaGaRkk;enAmuneBlbBa©b;TwkTImYyénkarcrcaenATIRkúg):arIs. karlat

RtdagedayevotNam GMBIkarsnüaCasm¶at;rbs;RbFanaFibtI nicsun nigkarniyaybBaäitbeBaäóg

EdleTIbmanfµI²kñúgkarpþl;CMnYyedaymincMeBaHmYydl;RbeTsevotNam hak;dUcCakarTHkMepøóg

sPaCan;TabGaemrikmYyédG‘Ícwg. cMNg;cg;)anCMnYyy:agxøaMgEdlBi)akbg¥n;)anRtÚveFVI[keRmIk

eLIgvijPøam EdlTaMg v:an;s_ TaMg hUlRb‘Úk BuM)aneRKagKitCamuneLIy. eTaHbICaelak xaF½r ykcitþ

Tukdak;BieRKaHCamYysPaCan;Tab munnwgbBa¢Únelak hUlRb‘Úk eTATIRkúg):arIsk¾eday k¾RkúmRbqaMg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg174

Page 185: Brother enemy

GPirkSniym)anke®Ba¢aleLIgRbqaMgnwgKMnitpþÜcepþImTaMgGs; CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;kareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBmYy. enAéf¶TI4 Ex]sPa sPaCan;x<s;kMBugBiPakSa BIesckþIRBagc,ab;sþIBICMnYyEpñk

esdækic©eTA[breTs enAeBlEdlBaküsmþIEdl ehon niyay kñúgGMLúgénkareFVIsnñisITkaEstrbs;

Kat;enARkúg):arIs )anRtÚvkt;Rtaedaym:asuInTUrGgÁúlIelx. tamsmþIKat;fa shrdæGaemrikRtÚvman

katBVkic©CYyRbeTsevotNam. enAeBlenaH eKeXIj elak vIløIyuaM GasRb‘Úk CaGñktMNagra®sþ

KNbkSsaFarNrdæelIkRKvIesckþIcmøgénesckþIRbkasenH nigERskLÚLaTamTareFVIkare)aHeqñat

mYy edaybgçM[RksYgkarbreTse)aHbg;KeRmagkarenHeTAvij. karesñIEkc,ab; ¬viesaFnkmµ¦ rbs;

Kat; edayhamXat;min[rdæaPi)alGaemrikaMg «crcaBIkarpþl;CMnYyesdækic©mYy karsgkarxUcxat

edaysars®gÁam b¤TRmg;viPaKTanEpñkhirBaØvtßúmYycMnYn eTaHCaTRmg;EbbNak¾eday» CamYy

RbeTsevotNam)anRtÚvGnum½tenAéf¶enaH edaykare)aHeqñatyl;RBm266sMeLgRbqaMg131

sMeLg. v:an;s_ )aneKarBeFVItam. Kat;)anRbkasfa «eyIg)aneFVI[evotNamdwgy:agc,as;fa

eyIgnwgminbg;R)ak;Casah‘uy CYsCulkarxUcxatedays®gÁameLIy»23.

enAéf¶TI2 Exmifuna eBlEdl ehon eFVIdMeNIreTAkan;sßanTUtGaemriksßitenAtamrukçvifI

háaRb‘ÍEyl kñúgTIRkúg):arIssRmab;dMNak;kalTIBIrénkarcrcaCamYy hUlRb‘Úk Kat;ElgsßitenAkñúg

sßanPaBcitþKMnitdUcmuneTotehIy. R)akdNas; enHCaelIkdMbUgehIyEdlemdwknaMRkúghaNUymñak;

RtÚvebIk[cUlkñúgsßanTUtGaemrikaMgmYy b:uEnþ evotNam)anvinicä½yBIkarlYgcitþenHragsþÜcesþIgbnþic.

GVIEdlsMxan;sRmab;evotNam KWesckþIsgÇwmBICMnYyrbs;GaemrikaMgd¾sem,ImmYy. enAéf¶TI19 Ex

]sPa RkúghaNUy)anpSBVpSaylixitsm¶at;rbs;RbFanaFibtI nicsun cuHéf¶TI1 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1973

EdlepJImk[elak paM v:an;dug edaymanesckþIfa «rdæaPi)alshrdæGaemriknwgCYyksagRbeTs

evotNamxageCIgeLIgvijbnÞab;BIs®gÁam edayKµanlkçxNÐxagneya)ayeLIy». nicsun bBa¢ak;fa

karrYmviPaKTanrbs;GaemrikaMg«nwgmanEk,r²3>250landuløar sRmab;ry³eBl5qñaM». sRmab;

RkúghaNUy lixitenHmanPaBhak;dUcCasnøwkeboFMCageKmYy. b:uEnþ kñúgeBlfµI²enH GñkEdleFVI

)atukmµenAmuxmnÞIrbBa©ekaNedIm,ITamTarsnþiPaBElgmanenATIenaHeTotehIy \LÚvenHKWCaerOgtRmÚv

[pþl;CMnYymYysRmab;RbeTsevotNameTAvij. GaRkk;CagenHeTAeTot karkan;kab;PaKxagt,Úg

edaykmøaMgT½B karCn;eCarénhVÚgCnePosxøÜnEdlkMBugrt;ecjBIRbeTsnigB½t’manepSg²Tak;Tgnwg

karcab;Gñkneya)ayRbqaMgrab;Ban;nak;dak;XuMXaMg)aneFVI[sPaCan;TabGn;citþ. karsnüasm¶at;

rbs;RbFanaFibtI)at;ekrþ×eQµaHmñak; EdleFVIeLIgmunkardYlrlMénRkúgéRBnKrKWKµantémønigmin)ankar.

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 175

Page 186: Brother enemy

enAeBlEdl hUlRb‘Úk cUltuGgÁúyTl;mux pan; ehon reNþAénkarsgS½ymYyEdlemIlmin

eXIj nigKMnuM mansPaBeTACaRkhUgy:agxøaMg. elak RhVg; suIv½rt_ TTYlbnÞúkbBaðaTahan)at;xøÜnenA

RksYgkarbreTsGaemrikaMg ehIyEdlRtÚvGeBa¢IjeTAcUlrYmkñúgkarcrcaenAEx]sPa nigmifuna )an

RtÚveFVI[PJak;ep¥IlGMBIlkçxNÐnigkarniyayedayRby½tñRbEygrbs; hUlRb‘Úk elIkenH Edltam

Tmøab;Kat;CamnusSrak;Tak;CageK. suIv½rt_ niyayfa «´dNþwgsYrkñúgcitþfa etI Dick ¬CaeQµaHehAeRkA

rbs; hUlRb‘Úk¦ )anTTYlesckþIbgÁab;y:agmuWgm:at;BIerOgenHEmnb¤. Tal;EtenAeBleRkaymkeTIb´

dwgnUvGVI EdleFVI[Kat;Gn;citþ». enAmunkarecjdMeNIrrbs;Kat;eTARkúg):arIs hUlRb‘Úk )anRtÚv[

B½t’maneday eGhV>b‘Í>Gay>(F.B.I.)fa carbursmñak;kñúgépÞrdæaPi)al ehIyRbEhlkñúgépÞRksYg

karbreTsEdr )anbBa¢ÚneTA[evotNamnUvsarTUrelxsm¶at;TaMgLay EdleRtómTuksRmab;BYk

GaemrikaMg. exnXVIn nwkeXIjfa eyIgmin)andwgB½t’manGVIEdlevotNamdwgeT b:uEnþ eyIgminGac

eKcecjBIkarcab;GarmµN_d¾cEmøkrbs;evotNamenAGgÁúyTl;muxeyIg EdlRbEhlCaRtÚvpþl;

B½t’manRKb;RKan;dUceyIgEdr cMeBaHkarENnaMEdleyIg)anTTYlsRmab;karcrcaEdlkMBugEtRbRBwtþ

eTAenH». b:uEnþ ebIBinitü[eRCARCHeTAkarrkeXIjerOgcarkmµenH BuM)aneFVI[dMeNIrkarcrcapøas;bþÚrFMduM

eLIy evorElgEtGakb,kiriyarbs; hUlRb‘Úk. BYkGaemrikaMg)ansnñidæanBIerOgenHfa ebIsin

evotNamdwgBIkarENnaMrbs;eyIg BYkeKmuxCadwgfa eyIgk¾KµanGVInwgpþl;[dUcEdl Dick Føab;)an

RbkasCasaFarN³[dwgrYcmkehIyEdr.

GVIEdl hUlRb‘Úk pþl;[-y:ageRcInRtwmEtkarsnüapþl;CMnYyminR)akdRbCamYyedaymin

cMeBaHb:ueNÑaH bnÞab;BIkareFVI[TMnak;TMngmanRbRktIPaB-BuMEmnCarbs;Edl ehon cg;)aneT.

evotNam EdleTIbnwgpþl;[dMNwgfµI²sþIBITahan)at;xøÜnémÖnak;eTot manbMNgcg;[GaemrikaMgtbKuN

mkvij. ehon )ant¥ÚjEt¥rdak; hUlRb‘Úk fa «etI[RtLb;eTARkúghaNUyvij edayédTeTy:ag

em:c? eRBaHkariyal½yRsavRCavEdlbBa¢Únmk[´ ¬pan; ehon¦ nUvB½t’mansþIBITahanGaemrik)at;

xøÜnnwgsYr´fa etI´man)anTTYlGVICafñÚrmkvijeT. hUlRb‘Úk k¾t¥ÚjEt¥reTAvijfa rdæaPi)alrbs;´rk

eFVIGVIBuMekItedaysPaCan;TabEdr. TLðIkrN_enHBuMman\T§iBleTAelI ehon eLIy. ehon )ans‘ksmþI

mkvijfa «etIelakeFVIy:agNa ebIsinCardæsPaCatirbs;evotName)aHeqñatGnum½tc,ab;mYyeday

hamXat;min[mankarEsVgrkTahanGaemrik)at;xøÜn?». BYkevotNam)ansEmþg[eXIjkarRbúg

eRbóbsRmúHsRmÜlKñaGMBIcMnYnTwkR)ak; nigrebobbg;R)ak;CaeRsc ³ «sRmab;eyIgmYyduløarKWmYy

duløar eyIgminKitfavaecjmkBIkEnøgNaeT». hUlRb‘Úk )aneqøIytbvijfa ³ «eyIgnwgCYyelak

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg176

Page 187: Brother enemy

tamry³GgÁkarGnþrCatiepSg²». ehon )anR)ab;´Casm¶at;fa ³ «b:uEnþ enAeBlEdl´sYrKat;BIcMnYn

TwkR)ak;énCMnYyenH Kat;ecosvagmineqøIytbnwg´eLIy»TukNaCaeyIgniyaybUr)ac;edayELkenA

eRkayeBlcb;kic©RbCuMsnñisITk¾eday. enAeBlenHEtmþg karxkcitþnigPaBeRkómRkM)anelceLIgenA

elIépÞmuxrbs;Kat; fVIt,itEtKat;manGakar³es¶óms¶at;nigesIcjjwmk¾eday. hUlRb‘Úk )ansakl,g

eFVI[ ehon eCOCak;elIKat;edaybMPøWfa sPaCan;TabCaerOgmYy ehIyestvimanCaerOgmYyeTot.

tamKat;fa eKminKYrTajesckþIsnñidæanCasßaBrBIkare)aHeqñatrbs;GñktMNagra®sþeLIy. ehon )an

niyayR)ab;´fa «)aT¡´yl;RBm. GVIEdleFVI[Tas;citþKWRksYgkarbreTsBuMmanesckþIkøahan

[dMNwgdl;sPaCan;TabnigTsSn³CaCMhrpÞal;rbs;RksYgsþIBIbBaðaCMnYydl;RbeTsevotNamenH

Ég»24.

braC½yenH rYmTaMgkarrMeCIbrMCYlEdlpuspuleLIgkñúgCYrBYkGPirkSniympg KWCasBaØa[dwgBI

TIbBa©b;énKMnitpþÜcepþImneya)aykarbreTselIkdMbUgrbs;RbFanaFibtI xaF½r. tamkarBit vUdxUk )an

TTYlsÁal;erOgenHeRkaymkfa rdæaPi)alBuM)anvas;sÞg;TMhMénkarRbqaMgCMTas;rbs;BYkemexøagén

sPaCan;TabnigbNþamCÄdæanGñkesñhaesrIPaBGMBIkarpþl;CMnYymYyeTA[RbeTsevotNameLIy.

enAExmifuna rdæsPaCati)anGnum½tedaysMeLgelIslb;nUvviesaFnkmµ KeRmagc,ab;mYysþIBIkarpþl;

CMnYyEpñkesdækic©eTA[breTs. GtßbTc,ab;enHEdlbgðajCUnedayelak eLsÞ½r v:Ul GñktMNag

ra®sþxagKNbkSRbCaFibetyü )anbdiesFedayCak;lak;minTTYldwgB¤nUvBaküsmþIrbs;RbFana

FibtI nicsun fa ³ TwkR)ak;cMnYn3>250landuløarEdlsnüapþl;[evotNamnwgminRtÚvpþl;[eT.

eBlebIkeFVIkarBiPakSa elakRbFanaFibtI xaF½r )anbBa¢ÚnlixitmYyeTA[RbFansPa edIm,IsuM[Kat;eFVI

y:agNakuM[esrIPaBEdlbNþaFnaKarGnþrCatimankñúgkarpþl;TwkR)ak;km©IRtÚvkRmitkMNt;edaykareFVI

viesaFnkmµ¬esckþIesñIEkc,ab;¦mYyenaH. b:uEnþ Cakar\tRbeyaCn_. edayminrvl;nwgGnusasn_

rbs;RbFanaFibtI GñktMNagra®sþ)anGnum½t viesaFnkmµc,ab;mYyedaysMeLgPaKeRcInelIslb;

hamR)ammin[mUlFnrbs;GaemrikaMgqøgkat;«edaypÞal;b¤edayRbeyal»RBMEdnRbeTsevotNam-

k¾dUcRBMEdnRbeTskm<úCa Lav nigRbeTsG‘Uhág;daEdr.

eTaHbICaelak hUlRb‘Úk nig v:an;s_ enAEtCaskmµCnénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBmYyCamYy

RbeTsevotNamk¾eday k¾GñkTaMgBIrminmankmøaMgRKb;RKan;edIm,IepþImeFVIkarRbyuT§CamYyvimankaBItUl

¬vimanEdlCaTIsñak;karrbs;KNbkSRbCaFibetyü nigKNbkSsaFarNrdæniym¦Edr rYmTaMgkarpþl;

CMnYymYyRtwmEtmnusSFm’k¾min)anpg. edayElgP½yxøacGVITaMgGs; enAExsIha elak xaF½r )an

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 177

Page 188: Brother enemy

cuHhtßelxaCamYyRbeTs):aNam:anUvsn§isBaØad¾cRmÚgcRmasmYysþIBIbBaðaERBkCIk ¬):aNam:a¦.

ehtuGVI)anCaKat;RbfuyeRKaHfñak;edayykGñkxøHEdlmanPkþIPaBcMeBaHsn§isBaØaCasRtÚveTAvij

ehIyRbkan;CMhrmYyGMBIbBaðaevotNamEdlminCaTIeBjcitþrbs;RbCaBlrdæPøam²EbbenH?.

eTaHCaelak hUlRb‘Úk nigeGKIbrbs;Kat;)anCYb pan; ehon CafµIenAéf¶TI19 ExFñÚ qñaM1977 kþI

esckþIsgÇwmkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBenAEteFVI[xVl;KMnitdEdl. kic©karrbs;carbursevotNam

k¾mancMENkkñúgerOgenHEdr.

edayBit cab;BImandMNwgsm¶at;mYyEdlpþl;eday XVIn kñúgGMLúgsrTrdUv RkúmeGhV>b‘Í>Gay>

)anrkeXIjGtþsBaØaNm®nþIrdækarGaemrikaMgEdlsgS½yfaCaGñk[karN_eTAevotNam ehIy)an

tamdanedaykarlYcsþab;karsnÞnatamTUrs½BÞ. sRmab;CaelIkdMbUgbg¥s; enAeBlEdlKat;eXIj

sMeNAftcmøgénsarTUrelxsm¶at;CaeRcInEdleGhV>b‘Í>Gay>RbKl;[ hUlRb‘Úk enAExmifuna XVIn

)annwkBiPal;Pøamfa GñkRbRBwtþelµIsRbEhlCamansac;jatinigcMNgmenaseBa©tnaenARbeTsevot

NamehIyemIleTA nigTMngCaGñkrgeRKaHBIkarKMramEhkekrþ×mYypgk¾mindwg. Kat;KiteTAdl;elak

r:UNal; h‘umRhVI EdlCanieyaCikmñak;enAmCÄmNÐlRbtibtþikarénTIPñak;garB½t’manshrdæGaemrik

(United States Information Agency) EdlmkCYbKat;enAExmIna edIm,IesñI[Kat;CYyeFVI[mitþnarIrbs;Kat;enA

RbeTsevotNam)ancakecjBIRbeTsenH. enAeBlenaH XVIn )aneRtómxøÜnecjdMeNIreTARkúg

haNUyCamYynwg vUdxUk Edr. xusEbøkBI vUdxUk EdlniyayR)ab;evotNamedaypÞal;BIbBaðaKUdNþwg

rbs;vresnIy_Ék m:aF½r/ XVIn )aneTACYbm®nþIsßanTUts‘uyEGd edIm,I[CYyCMrujsMNuMÉksar

GenþaRbevsn_rbs;mitþRsI h‘umRhVI eCOneTAmux.

kartamXøaMemIlEdlbMeBjedayeGhV>b‘Í>Gay )anTTYlEpøpáa. h‘umRhVI EdlmindwgeKtamdan

)aneTACYb XVIn mþgmáal edIm,IniyayBIerOgekµgRsIR)ab;Kat; nigesuIbsYrBIvDÆnPaBénkareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNam. XVIn )andMNalfa ³ «enAeBlenaH ´Bi)akGt;RTaMeFVIhak;dUcCa

\tmanerOgehtuGVIekIteLIgNas;». h‘umRhVI Edl\tsgS½yGVITal;EtesaH )anbnþcmøgeLIgvijnUv

sarTUrelxsm¶at;TaMgGs;rbs;RksYgkarbreTsEdlFøak;kñúgédKat; munnwgRbKl;eTA[ edvId eRTÓg.

eRTÓg CayuT§ikCnsnþiPaBniymmñak; nigCakUnRbúsrbs;GtItebkçCnRbFanaFibtI Rtan; Dij hS‘Ú Edl

eBlenaHRtÚvcab;dak;KukeTAehIy. tYnaTIrbs;Kat;KW bBa¢ÚnÉksarTaMgenH[eTAdl;KN³RbtiPUrbs;

evotNamenAGgÁkarshRbCaCati b¤sßanTUtevotNamenATIRkúg):arIs.

TIbMput enAExFñÚ qñaM1977 evotNam)anlHbg;KMnitminTTYlR)ak;kasNamYyBIBYkGaemrikaMg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg178

Page 189: Brother enemy

eLIy munkareFVITMnak;TMngkarTUtmanRbRktIPaBeLIgvij. b:uEnþ edaymindwgfa karb:unb:gesuIbkarN_

rbs;evotNamRtÚveGhV>b‘Í>Gay>dwgB¤ BYkeKenAEtTamTarfa shrdæGaemrikRtÚvEtsnüaCYyBYkeK

Canic©. Ca]TahrN_ enAeBlEdl ehon cUleTAGgÁúyenAtucrcaTl;muxnwg hUlRb‘Úk CaelIkTIbI

Kat;enAEtniyayedayKµanR)akdkñúgcitþBIsMeNIsuMCMnYyrbs;Kat;mþgeTot. kñúgry³eBlénkarQb;

sRmakxøImYy Kat;sgÇwmfa «»kasedIm,IniyaytTl;KñaEtBIrnak;CamYyGñkcrcaGaemrikaMgmkdl;

ehIy. edayniyayCaPasa)araMgKµancaM)ac;rkGñkbkERb nigKµansresrRkdas ehon )ansYreTA

hUlRb‘Úk faetI elakenAcaMdMNak;kal k nig x énkic©RBmeRBógEdlRBagedayGñkcrcaGaemrikaMgnig

evotNamkalBIqñaM1966eT?. dMNak;kal k KWrYmmankarbBaÄb;karTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;GaemrikaMg

enARbeTsevotNam. cMENkdMNak;kal x KWsRmab;eRbICaRkbx½NÐénkardak;[eRbIR)as;edayPaKI

TaMgBIrnUvkarRbúgeRbóbmYycMnYntUcEdlRtÚvrkSaCakarsm¶at;. ehon )an[eyabl;GMBIkarbnþeLIg

vijnUvskmµPaBmYyRbePTdUcKñaenH. enAkñúgry³kaldMbUg RbeTsTaMgBIrnwgeFVI[TMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜn

manRbRktIPaBeLIgvij ehIykñúgry³kalTIBIr KWbnÞab;BIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB shrdæGaemriknwg

RbkasCaÉketaPaKInUvkarpþl;CMnYymYyCaTRmg;GVIk¾edayeTA[RbeTsevotNam. evotNamR)afña

fa BYkGaemrikaMgRtÚvRbkan;karsnüamYytamrebobeRkApøÚvkarcMeBaHerOgenHenAdMNak;kal x. ehon

)anGgVrkrfa ³ «RKan;EtxSwbdak;Rtecok´BItYelxEdlelakesñICUnKW)anehIy». hUlRb‘Úk nwkeXIj

eqøIytbfa ³ «´esaksþayNas; ´BuMRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[eFVIdUecñHeLIy. Kat;k¾RcanecalBIkar[dk

r)aMgEpñkBaNiC¢kmµEdlnwgrYmbgáCaCMhandMbUgmYyeq<aHeTArkkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeLIgvijEdr.

RkúghaNUyEdleTIbnwgecjpSayCasaFarN³nUvc,ab;vinieyaKTunrbs;xøÜn Kµancg;)anGVIeRkABI

bBa©ÚlbNþaRkúmh‘unrbs;GaemrikaMgkñúgkarGPivDÆn_Epñkesdækic©rbs;RbeTseLIy. tamm®nþIpøÚvkar

GaemrikaMgmñak; EdlcUlrYmkñúgsm½yRbCuMfa ³ «evotNamhak;dUcCaPJak;ep¥IlenAeBlEdl hUlRb‘Úk

eqøIytbeTAeKvijfa minGaceTArYceT».25

k¾b:uEnþ hUlRb‘Úk )an[eyabl;-mü:ageTot enHKWCasMeNIfµIEtmYyrbs;Kat;-fa RbeTsTaMgBIr

RtÚvbegáIt[manKN³ebskkmµTMnak;TMngkñúgrdæFanIpÞal;erog²xøÜn. enHCarUbmnþGnþrkaledIm,Irg;caMkar

begáItTMnak;TMngkarTUteBjelj bnÞab;BIkaredaHRsaybBaðaEdlenAmancb;sBVRKb;. edayKiteTA

dl;karebIkKN³ebskkmµTMnak;TMngenARkúgeb:kaMgnigRkúgv:asuInetankalBI ExkumÖ³ qñaM1973 ehon

)aneqøIytbfa «eyIgmincg;eFVIdUcBYkcineT». bYnqñaMeRkaymk karN_EdlfakareFVI[manRbRktIPaB

eBjeljnUvTMnak;TMngepSg²rvagRbeTsTaMgBIrEdlenABuMTan;)anseRmcKWBuMEmnCakarelIkTwkcitþ

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 179

Page 190: Brother enemy

mYysRmab;evotNameT. RkúghaNUyRbEhlCaesaksþayy:agQWcab;nUvkarbdiesFenH enAeBl

EdldMeNIrénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBrvagcin-GaemrikaMg)ancab;epþImedayBitR)akdenAqñaMdEdlenaH.

edayCak;Esþg evotNamBuMyl;BIcMNucrGak;rGYlxøHénerOgr:av ¬v½rFWehÁt¦-EdlBIdMbUgCa

RBwtþikarN_l¥mYyekItmancMeBl-EdlnwgbMpøajplRbeyaCn_rbs;BYkeKcab;BIéf¶enHeTAeLIy. enA

shrdæGaemrik karsuMlaElgBItMENgrbs;RbFanaFibtI nicsun )anbgá[manclaclxagneya)ay

mYyPøam EdllT§plc,as;CageKKWkareFVI[tMENgRbFanaFibtIcuHexSay. enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1975

BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUy)anc,amCab;»kasGs;sgÇwmenH ehIycab;epþImkarRbyuT§dUcepøkbenÞarrbs;

xøÜnenAPaKxagt,ÚgPøam. enAeBlenH karcuHexSayéntMENgRbFanaFibtI KWCa]bsKÁFMbMputkñúgkarbgçM

[dkbMramCMnYyGaemrikaMg BIeRBaHvaeFVI[sPaCan;TabmanGMNacrwtEtxøaMgeLIg. elak nicsun )an

bMBansaFarN³mtitamGMNaccitþxøÜn edaybBa¢ÚnynþehaHeb-52 eTATmøak;RKab;EbkelITIRkúg

haNUy edaysnüapþl;CMnYyeTA[KUsRtÚvrbs;xøÜnCasm¶at; ehIyevotNamsgÇwmfa xaF½r nwgeTACa

nicsun mñak;EdlRsLaj;snþiPaB. b:uEnþ evotNamminyl;fa bnÞab;BIerOgr:avv½rFWehÁt nigbraC½y

EpñkeyaFaenA\NÐÚcin kartéføKñaCasm¶at;tamrebob nicsun-KIsSúIghÁ½r ElgRtÚvkal³eTs³eTot

ehIyenAshrdæGaemrik. minyUrb:unµan BYkeK)ansmÁal;eXIjedayRsLaMgkaMgfa RbeTsrbs;eK

ElgmanCMhrxøaMgehIyenAelIqakneya)ayGaemrikaMg ehIyfa edayRbQmmuxnwgkarRbqaMgrbs;

sPaCan;Tab xaF½r )ancuHcaj;RBmKñanwgkardak;[BinitüeLIgvijnUvkarsnüaEdleFVIeLIgtamry³

vUdxUk kñúgkarpþl;CMnYymnusSFm’mYypg. sRmab;RbeTsevotNamGMNwHteTA kareRCIserIsrvag

lT§PaBBIrKWCaerOgFmµtamYykñúgcMeNamerOgFmµtaCaeRcIn ³ b¤mYye)aHbg;KMnitElgbgçM[eKeFVItam

lkçxNÐrbs;xøÜn b¤lHbg;ecalesckþIsgÇwmTaMgGs;edIm,ITajKuNRbeyaCn_BIR)ak;duløar nigbec©kviC¢a

rbs;GaemrikaMg ehIyEbreTArkRkúgmUsÁÚvij.

braC½ykñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyshrdæGaemriknigGlT§PaBkñúgkarbegáItTMnak;TMng

EpñkBaNiC¢kmµ )anrYmbgáCakarxkcitþd¾sem,ImsRmab;RbeTsevotNam. kñúgenaHk¾manbraC½y én

neya)ayebIkTVar[mUlFnbreTscUlEdr EdllT§plCak;Esþg KWR)ak;km©ImYycMnYn35landuløarBI

GgÁkarmUlniFirUbiyvtßúGnþrCati nigR)ak;km©ImYycMnYn49landuløarBIGgÁkarshRbCaCatiTuksRmab;

eFVIhirBaØb,Tandl;KeRmagGPivDÆn_mYy.

FnaKarikGaemrikaMgmñak;EdlkMBugeFVITsSnkic©enARkúghaNUy )anniyayR)ab;´Casm¶at;fa ³

«Kat;RtÚveFVI[egOgq¶l; BIPaBecH»nlMeTantamkal³eTs³nigkarniymsac;kar» EdlsEmþg[eXIj

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg180

Page 191: Brother enemy

edayBYkGñkcrcarbs;evotNamkñúgTMnak;TMngrbs;eKCamYyGñkrksuIelakxaglic. k¾b:uEnþ eTaHbICa

mankarniymsac;kar niglkçN³esrIniymxøaMgénc,ab;vinieyaKrbs;evotNamenHk¾eday k¾BYk

vinieyaKinbreTsminbgçMmkkan;RkúghaNUyEdr. GñkEdlsakl,geFVIkarBiesaFn_ )anRtÚveFVI[)ak;

Twkcitþy:agqab;rh½s edaysarEbbbTkariyaFibetyürbs;evotNam nigbriyakassgS½yEdl

rkSa[sßitesßredayEpñksnþisux. esckþIsgÇwmrbs;evotNamcg;eXIjkarkekIteLIgnUvcMNg

Tak;TgmitþPaBnigshRbtibtþikarCamYyGWr:ubxaglic )anRtÚvraraMgedayPaBmineGIeBInigmineyaKyl;

mYy.

edIm,Ibgðaj[eXIjc,as;nUvqnÞ³rbs;RbeTsxøÜnkñúgkarebIkTVareq<aHeTArkbs©imRbeTs naykrdæ

m®nþIevotNam)aneRCIserIsRbeTs)araMgsRmab;dMeNIrCaelIkdMbUgrbs;Kat;eTAbreTs enAeRkay

eBlbBa©b;mhasnñi)atbkS. Kat;cg;bBa©ÚlrdæFanIepSg²eTotenAGWr: ubxaglickñúgdMeNIreKacr

rbs;Kat;CuMvijTVIbenaHEdr edIm,IbegáInEfmeTotnUvsarsMxan;énsuqnÞ³rbs;Kat;. b:uEnþ edayxøacERkg

mankarCMTas;xagkñúgRbeTs nigedaycg;Tuk[GaemrikCaGñkpþÜcepþImKMnit PaKeRcInénbNþaRbeTsenA

GWr:ubxaglic elIkElgEtRbeTsdaNWm:ak n½rEv:s nig hVaMgLg; )anbdiesFedayKYrsmminTTYl

sVaKmn_ dug enAeBlKt;bBa©b;TsSnkic©enARbeTs)araMgeLIy. cemøIyrbs;TIPñak;gardaNWm:akedIm,I

GPivDÆn_ EdlerobcMCYydl;RbeTsevotNam«kñúgRBMEdnkMNt;mYy»enaHKWmanlkçN³RKan;EtCa

tMNagb:ueNÑaH26.

dMeNIrCaRbvtþisa®sþrbs; dug eTAkan;RbeTs)araMg k¾RtÚvkt;smÁal;edaynimitþrUbepSg² nig

edaykarCYbKñaCafµId¾rMCYlcitþ Cagedaykarsnüapþl;hirBaØvtßúCak;lak;. elakRbFanaFibtI v:aeLrI

hSúIsáard_ edsþaMg )anerobcMCUnGtItGñkbdivtþn_nUvBiFIbdisNæarkic©d¾rugerOgmYyenAviman eGlIehS.

kic©RBmeRBógminsMxan;cMnYnBIrEpñkshRbtibtþikaresdækic©nigvb,Fm’)anRtÚvcuHhtßelxa. GMeNay

rbs;elakxaglic EdlRkúghaNUysgÇwmy:agxøaMgenABuMTan;mkdl;eT. GñkkarTUt)araMgmñak;)an

GHGagBIerOgenHenAeBleRkaymkfa ³ evotNam)anRtLb;eTAvijTaMgeRkómRkM ehIykarxkcitþ

rbs;eK manTMhMesµInwgesckþIsgÇwmrbs;eKEdr»27.

enARbeTsevotNam esckþIsgÇwmnigkarxkcitþRsab;EtekItmanedaymin)anRbúgmunenAkñúgépÞ

RbeTscMkal³eTs³mYysMxan;bMput edaysarkarekItmanRBmKñanUvvibtþiesdækic© nigkarRbQmmux

y:agxøaMgkøarvagGñkRbkan;tammenaKmviC¢anigGñkniymsac;kar. qñaM1977KWCaqñaMGBmgÁlmYy.

GVI²hak;dUcCaRtÚveFVI[ERbRtLb;TaMgGs;. enAExkumÖ³ pldMNaMenAPaKxageCIg)anTTYlrgkarxUcxat

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 181

Page 192: Brother enemy

y:agsem,Im edaysarGakasFatuRtCak;d¾xøaMgmYy. tmkeTot RbeTsenH )anTTYlrgnUvPaB

raMgs¶Ütd¾F¶n;F¶rCaeRcInExbnþedayeRKaHTwkCMnn;mYyEdlbNþal[mankarvinasd¾FM ehIyenATIbMput

karxVHes,ógGahard¾sem,ImmYy. enAExmInaqñaMdEdl RbeTsevotNam)anesñIsuMCMnYyBIGgÁkarsh

RbCaCatinigbNþaRbeTsCamitþ b:uEnþ minsUvCa)aneCaKC½yFMduMeLIy. cMENkEpñk]sSahkmµrbs;xøÜn

k¾)anrgTTYlkarxVHxateRbg\n§n³nigeRKÓgbnøas;pgEdr.

eKRbEhlCaenAEtmindwgBIPaKl¥itl¥n;énkarCECkBiPakSarbs;kariyal½yneya)ayén

KNbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamTak;TgeTAnwgkarseRmcsMxan;²xagEpñkneya)ayeRkARbeTs nigkúñg

RbeTspgeT. b:uEnþ enATIRkúghaNUy GñksegátkarN_EdlykcitþTukdak;xøaMgCageK minePøcnwgeFVI[

elceLIgnUvsBaØaénkarEbk)ak;KñakñúgépÞénRkúmemdwknaMeLIy28.

R)akdehIy KNbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamRtÚvEbk)ak;CaBIr. karBiPakSaxagneya)ay)an

RbRBwtþeTAy:agvk;vIrvagGñkEdledIrtamKURbECgTaMgsgxag. GñkniymkNþalEdlmannaykrdæm®nþI

paM v:an;dug Caemexøag )anGYtsresIrBIkareFVIshRbtibtþikard¾CitsñiT§mYy CamYybNþaRbeTselak

xaglic Edlman]sSahkmµeCOnelOnnigkarpøas;RTg;RTayevotNamxagt,ÚgCalMdab;lMeday

CamYyeKaledATajykplRbeyaCn_RbesIrelIseKBImUlFnnigPaBbuinRbsb;kñúgkarcat;karRKb;

RKgkic©karrbs;RbeTsTaMgenaH. GñkepSgeTot Edlman eRTÓg Cij enACYrTImYynigCaGñknaMBakü

rbs;RkúmenH )anniyayBIeKaledAdMbUgKWkarksagsgÁmniym karrkSaPaBs¥atbrisuT§EpñkmenaKm

viC¢a nigkarRbyuT§RbqaMgnwg«kareRCótcUlnigkarbMpøajsgÁmEdldwknaMedayxµaMgsRtÚv». BYkenH

)anCMTas;cMeBaHesrIkmµEpñkesdækic© ¬kareFVI[manesrIPaBCagmun¦ nigkarebIkTVareTArkbs©imRbeTs

nigTietonBIPaByWty:avkñúgkarpøas;bþÚrRTg;RTaylT§isgÁmniymenAPaKxagt,ÚgevotNamEdleTIb

rMedaHfµI² eRBaHCakEnøgbgáeraK bgáGMeBIBukrlYynigPaBGab;»n EdlenAeBlenH PaKxageCIgk¾RtÚv

qøgeraKenHEdr. edayeqøótTajykRbeyaCn_ BIdMeNIreTAGWr:ubrbs;naykrdæm®nþI paM v:an;dug eRTÓg

Cij )anepþImeFVIkarvayRbhard¾xøaMgkøamYy RbqaMgnwgkardwknaMRbkbedayeRKaHfñak;énCYrGñkkariya

Fibetyüniym ehIyGMBavnav[BRgwgvin½yxøaMgEfmeTot kñúgcMeNamGgÁkarrbs;rdæaPi)al. b:uEnþ

BYkRkúmGñkRbkan;twg)anRtÚveFVI[eCOs‘b;kñúgKMnitfa bs©imRbeTsCasRtÚvnwgRbeTsevotNam

taMgBIkMeNIt. shrdæGaemrik)anbdiesFedaycecsminTTYlsÁal;karTTYlxusRtÚvEpñksIlFm’

rbs;xøÜn ehIyRbeTsCb:unnigRbeTs)araMg k¾mancMENkkñúgKNeyüminéføfñÚmYyénR)ak;bMNulcas;

nigR)ak;bdiPaKtictYcEdr. enATIbMput rebobniyaycak;edatkñúgkarsnÞnaTaMgLayrbs; paM v:an;dug

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg182

Page 193: Brother enemy

enATIRkúgeb:kaMg naedImExmifuna )anbMpøajesckþIsgÇwmepSg² EdlTukdak;edayBYkevotNamkñúg

liT§Rbtibtþiniymrbs;BYkemdwknaMcinfµI nigkñúgTsSnvis½yénkareFVI[TMnak;TMngCamYyRkúgeb:kaMgman

skmµPaBeLIgvij.

GñksegátkarN_)araMgmñak;enATIRkúghaNUy)aneFVI[eKkt;smÁal;BIerOgenHfa ³ «enABak;

kNþalqñaM1977 CYrGñkneya)ayfµImYy)anpusecjeLIg. enARbeTsevotNam karpøas;bþÚr)an

ekIteLIgkñúgsPaBs¶b;es¶ómdUcsBVdg edayKµankarRbkasxÞrxÞar nigKµankarefáaleTasBYkGñkcaj;

CasaFarN³eLIy. maKa’neya)ayfµI )ansEmþgecjtamry³karBRgwgneya)ayépÞkñúgmYy. ebI

niyayBIneya)ayeRkARbeTsvij KWva)anqøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjnUvPaBmineGIeBImYykan;EtrIkFMeLIg²

cMeBaHbs©imRbeTs nigkarrwtbnþwgcMNgTak;TgmYyCamYybøúksgÁmniymkñúgRKb;vis½yTaMgGs;»29.

enAcugExmifuna qñaM1977 KN³kmµaFikarmCÄimbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam EdlrYmRbCuMeBjGgÁ

)anGnum½tkmµviFIsmUhPavUbnIykmµdIFøI nigseRmcbegáInkic©karEpñkmenaKmviC¢a[rwtEtxøaMgeLIg30.

kmµviFIenH)ankMNt;enAedImTsvtSr_80faCakarbBa©b;TaMgRsugnUvkareFVI[vis½yksikmµ enAPaKxag

t,ÚgmanlkçN³sgÁmniym. viFankarsMxan;²epSgeTotnwgmantameRkay sMedAeFVIkarlubbM)at;

BaNiC¢kmµnig]sSahkmµEbbmUlFnniym. karbegðIbbnþic[xül;elakxagliccUl hak;dUcCabiT

edayxøÜnÉgvij.

CMenarxül;BITisxaglic 183

Page 194: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg184

¬elak¦ etg s‘avBIg EføgsunÞrkfaenAsYnc,arestvimanCamYynwgGñkbkERbrbs;elak nig xatF½r RbFanaFibtIshrdæ

Gaemrik naéf¶TI28 Exmkra qñaM1979. etg s‘agBIg CRmabelakRbFanaFibtI xaF½r [dwgGMBIEpnkarlukluy

RbeTsevotNamrbs;elak

emdwknaMsUevot GaLicsuI kusSúIhÁIn CamYy

elaknayrdæm®nþIevotNam paM v:an;dug

Page 195: Brother enemy

185

yuT§narIevotNamkMBugP¢g;kaMePøIgbeNþIrTahancin

EdlRtÚvcab;)anCaeQøIyswk

karQWcab;kñ úgsm½y ln; nl; qñaM1972

Page 196: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg186

ehg sMrin

h‘un Esn

ehg sMék

Page 197: Brother enemy

187

smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayevotNam

h½g v:an;hn enATIRkúgeb:kaMgbnÞab;BIkar

pþac;xøÜncuHcUlnwgRbeTscin

rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam egVón kUfac;

naykrdæm®nþIevotNam paM v:an;dug elak]tþmesnI Rtan; v:an;Rta embBa¢akarrg

énkgT½BkumµúynIsþenAevotNamxagt,Úg

Page 198: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg188

v:ag Tug niBn§naykkaEstRbcaMéf¶rbs;bkS

evotNam

eL yn; GKÁelxabkSkumµúynIsþevotNam

sUpa vgS RbFanaFibtIsaFarNrdæ

RbCaFibetyüRbCamanitLav

g:U eDon

JimGerrand

Photo

JimGerrand

Photo

JimGerrand

Photo

Page 199: Brother enemy

189

CnrgeRKaHenAkñúgKukTYlEsøgd¾l,Il,aj

KMnrcemøIysarPaBrbs;GñkeTasenAmnÞIrXuMXaMg

TYlEsøg

PRKInformationServicephoto

Photocourtesy

RichardHolbrooke

llad¾k,alteRmóbCaCYrenAkñúgreNþAsaksB

JimGerrand

Photo

Page 200: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg190

Gñkmñag mUnik sIhnu

semþcRBH neratþm sIhnu CYbCamYyGñkniBn§enATIRkúgBüúgy:agnaExkumÖ³ qñaM1981

niTaXrdUv qñaM1980 TidæPaBQµÜjExµrkMBugeFVI

dMeNIreTAkan;RbeTséf. TahanevotNam

QryamkarBars<an

Photocourtesy

RichardHolbrooke

Page 201: Brother enemy

191

eKhdæanenAtampøÚvmYyxageqogxagt,ÚgpSarGUrb£sSImanpÞúksuT§Etm:asuInedr

niTaXrdUv qñaM1978 TidæPaBsmøab;rgÁalrbs;

ExµrRkhmenAkñúgextþhaeTog rbs;evotNam

Page 202: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg192

Page 203: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI6xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag

karsg;sNæaKarmYyenAmat;bwgmYy nigvimantmál;sBmYyeFVIBIeføImfµBN’RbepHnigfµRkanItenA

TIRkúghaNUy nigkarTUTat;R)ak;sRmab;karksagsmiT§plepSg²EdlmansarsMxan;kñúgqñaMbnÞab;BI

s®gÁamcb; tamBitKWbnÞab;BIkarcakecjrbs;BYk)araMgenaHRtÚv)ansßabnaeRsc)ac;y:agqab;rh½s.

BitNas; vimantmál;sB hU CImij manlkçN³FMRtEdtRtdwm. vimanenHelceFøaeLIgelITIlan

)aDij EdlmanlkçN³dUcTIlanRkhmenAeb:kaMgEdr. enAeBl hU søab; BYksUevot)anENnaM[epÞr

sBrbs;Kat;mkTIRkúgmUsÁÚsin edIm,IGb;saksBnigrkSaTuk[putBIkarTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;GaemrikaMg.

evotNam)anRbEkkfa RbCaCatibreTsmYy eTaHCaRtÚvCMrujedaybMNgl¥k¾eday k¾minRtÚveFVICa

GñkTTYlrkSaTuksaksBemdwknaMCaTIskáar³rbs;xøÜnEdr. CMnYsRbkarenH GñkGb;sBrbs;sUevot

)anRtÚvcat;bBa¢Únmkkan;RkúghaNUyCabnÞan;. bnÞab;mk saksBRtÚv)anepÞreTAdak;kñúgrUgmYyy:ag

eRCAEdlCIkxageRkamkUnPñMmYy edayrg;caM[ynþehaHTmøak;RKab;EbkTaMgLayrbs;GaemrikaMg RBm

ehaHehIreTAkan;TIdéTeTotsin. edaymanCMnYyrbs;rusSI vimantmál;sB)anksagrYcral;Tan;eBl

sRmab;karR)arB§BiFIbuNüC½yCmñH enAqñaM1975. taMgBIeBlenaHmk vimanenHKWCakEnøgmYyEdl

GñkeTscreTATsSnaeRcInCageKbMput.

niyayedayxøIeTA vimantmál;sB hU CImij )ankMNt;nUvTIbBa©b;énsm½ymYy. k¾b:uEnþ

sNæaKarfaMgL mann½yfa sNæaKarC½yCmñHEdlksagedayBYkKuy)a RtÚv)ancat;TukfaCakarpþl;

smÞúHdl;]sSahkmµEpñksNæaKarrbs;evotNamEdlkMBugerobcM[manlkçN³TMenIbTan;sm½y.

va)anCMnYssNæaKarem:RtÚb:Ulcas; Edldak;eQµaHfµIfa fugjit CaGtItmhasNæaKarrbs;Rkúg

haNUy EdlmanmktaMgBICMnan;GaNaniKmem:øH. sNæaKarfaMgLCamYynwgbnÞb;ragbYnRCúgRTEvg

rbs;xøÜn EdlbMBak;eTAedaym:asuInRtCak; eRKÓgsgðarimTMenIb RckTVarbg¥ÜcénsalbriePaK rkbwg

dak;suT§EtkBa©k;enaH GMNwHteTAKWCaTIkEnøgd¾l¥eqItqayCageKrbs;rdæFanI. sNæaKarenH)anTTYl

erobcMeFVICakEnøgbdisNæarkic©Edlpþl;edaym®nþIsßanTUtsUevotkñúg»kasénBiFIbuNüxYbbdivtþn_

Extulamþg².

edIm,Isakl,gEsVgyl;BITwkcitþrbs;evotNamlMeGogeTAxagNa²enaH GñkkarTUtEdlbMeBj

muxgarenARkúghaNUy minePøcnwgsegátemIlBiFITTYlbdisNæarkic©Edlpþl;edaybNþam®nþIénsßanTUt

193

Page 204: Brother enemy

cinnigsUevoteLIy. G‘ÍcwgehIy)anCaRbeTsTaMgBIrRbECgKñasEmþg[eXIjmitþPaBnigPkþIPaBrbs;

xøÜn ehIyevotNam)anRbwgERbgTb;xøÜnminlMeGogeTAxagNaTaMgGs;. GñkkarTUt)anføwgEføg eday

ykcitþTukdak;cMeBaHGtßbTepSg²kñúgsarB½t’manRbcaMéf¶rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam Edlsresr

sRmab;RbeTscinnigshPaBsUevot ehIyRbwgERbgkMNt;GñkNamYy Edl)anTTYlKuNRbeyaCn_

BIkare)aHBum<pSayGtßbTenH. BYkeK)aneRbóbeFobsMeNAedIménesckþIraykarN_rbs;sUevot nig

cin eTAtamrebobbkRsay EdlRsg;ykeTAcuHpSaykñúgkaEstrbs;evotNam edIm,Isakl,g

bgðajBIPaBxusKñaEpñkmenaKmviC¢aEdlGacekIteLIg)an. ]TahrN_ enAExkBaØa qñaM1975 eBl

Edl]tþmesnIy_ ecn suIelon smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþcin briharBI«Gnutþr

PaBniym» enAeBlkMBugeFVITsSnkic©enATIRkúghaNUy kaEstTaMgLayrbs;evotNamminniyayBI

BaküenHeLIy. GñkkarTUt)anTajesckþIsnñidæanBIerOgenHEdlkøayeTACakatBVkic©eTAehIy ehIy

)anbBa¢ÚndMNwgenHCaTUrelxeTAkan;rdæFanIerog²xøÜn.

edayrebobdUcKña kareFVIbdisNæarkic©rbs;sUevotnigcinenARkúghaNUy Ca»kasd¾mantémø

sRmab;sÞabsÞg;BIkRmiténTMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;evotNamCamYybNþaRbeTssgÁmniymCabgb¥Ún

nig):an;RbmaNBIdMeNIrERbRbÜlCayfaehturbs;va. kñúg»kasBiFIbdisNæarkic©TaMgenH GñkkarTUt

minRKan;Etkt;smÁal;BYkePJóvrbs;evotNamtamzananuRkmb:ueNÑaHeT BYkeK)anTukEPñkmçagsmøwgemIl

naLikarbs;eKCanic© edIm,IepÞógBIeBlevlaEdlBYkeKmkkan;TIenH. dUecñH tameKalkarN_Edl

erobcMKWfaBYkemdwknaMevotNam)anRtÚvbgçM[cMNayeBlevlaeTAcUlrYmkñúgeBlCamYyKña kñúgBiFI

bdisNæarkic©rbs;cinpgnigsUevotpg. mñak;²EdlbMBaneKalkarN_enHnwgyl;xøÜnÉg.

b:uEnþ kñúgraRtIéf¶TI6 Exvicäika qñaM1976 eKmincaM)ac;eRbIbec©keTsepÞógeBlevlaeLIy. kalBI

Extulamun edIm,ICakayvikarkan;mrNTukçbnÞab;BImrNPaBrbs; em:A esTug m®nþIsßanTUtcin )anlubecal

karR)arB§BiFIbuNüCati. cab;taMgBIeBlenaHmk vaeTACaKµanRbeyaCn_kñúgkarRbmaNBIeBlevlaEdl

eRbIedayBYkm®nþIevotNam edIm,IcUlrYmkñúgBiFIbdisNæarkic©rbs;sUevoteLIy edayxVHcMNucsRmab;

eRbóbeFob. eTaHCay:agNa GñksegátkarN_xagkarTUt minebomkarxkcitþrbs;eKyUreLIy eRBaHfa

kñúg»kasd¾Cak;lak;enHehIyEdlnaykrdæm®nþI paM v:an;dug CaePJóvkitþiyskñúgBiFIbdisNæarkic©RtÚv

seRmccitþedIm,IefáaleTasRkúgmUsÁÚ CasaFarN³edaysmþIKMeraHKMerIymYyenAmuxGgÁTUtCaeRcIn.

karelIkEkvRbsiT§iBrcMeBaHC½yCmñHbdivtþn_Extula esÞIrEtminTan;cb;RsYlbYlpg elak paM v:an;dug

)anedIrecjBItu. tamry³shkarImñak;kñúgcMeNamshkarIrbs;Kat; Kat;)ansuMCYbÉkGKÁrdæTUt)araMg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg194

Page 205: Brother enemy

sðal m:aLÚ edIm,IeFVIkarsnÞnaCaÉkCnmYykñúgbnÞb;Cab;KñaenaH. dug nig m:aLÚ )ansßitenAkñúgbnÞb;

biTTVarCitGs;ry³eBl20naTI. eBjry³eBlenaH ePJóvrbs;Kat;KWelakÉkGKÁrdæTUtsðaBøIn enAEt

eFVIeCIy EPñksmøwgEkvRsasM):ajrbs;Kat;mindk. «elaknaykrdæm®nþI)anniyayR)ab;´fa Kat;

mancitþsb,ayrIkrayNas; cMeBaHKMniteFVIdMeNIreTARbeTs)araMgenAeBlqab;²xagmux» enHCasmþI

rbs; m:aLÚ EdlniyayR)ab;shkarImñak;kñúgcMeNamshkarIrbs;Kat;enAeBleRkaymk. tamelak

ÉkGKÁrdæTUt)araMgfa Kµankic©karGVIF¶n;F¶rb¤Rbjab;Rbjal;RtÚv)anrMB£kkñúg»kasénkarsnÞnaenHeT.

kareFVIdMeNIrrbs; dug eTAkan;RbeTs)araMg RKan;EteRKagTukCamunkñúgry³eBlCaeRcInExb:ueNÑaH.

edayCak;EsþgmUlehtuénkarlwb)at;d¾yUrlg;rbs;naykrdæm®nþIevotNam KWKat;manbMNgepSg

eTot. m:aLÚ )ankt;smÁal;rebobelgesIc fa dug hak;dUcCaminRbjab;Rbjal;bBa©b;kic©sMeNH

sMNalnigeTACYbm©as;pÞH sUevotenAtuGaharvijeLIy. enATIbMput kalebIcb;karsnÞnaehIy elak

naykrdæm®nþI)anelIkéd CasBaØamitþPaBeTAkan;sðaBøIn ehIyk¾laecjeTA.

tammtirbs;GñkkarTUtTaMgGs;fa kayvikarEbøkBIFmµtaenH BitCaKitTukCamunedaykariyal½y

neya)ayCarebobbBa¢ÚnsarEdlRbeTsevotNamykcitþTukdak;cMeBaHTMnak;TMngrbs;xøÜnCamYy

RbeTs)araMg ehIyRbEhlCamYybs©imRbeTsTaMgmUleRcInCagCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ. mYyry³bnÞab;

dMNwgEdlniyayt²Kña)anelcB¤sussaykñúgmCÄdæanGñkkarTUtfa Gakb,kiriyaEbøkBIFmµtarbs;

dug enAl¶acenaH KWCakareqøIytbrbs;evotNameTAnwgkarekobsgát;Edlmanesñótl,ickly:ag

Rbsb;rbs;rusSIpgEdr. RbeTsevotNamCamitþmYyrbs;shPaBsUevot b:uEnþBuMEmnCaRbeTsenA

eRkambgÁab;mYyEdleKeFVI)abeT1.

vKÁénehtukarN_bnÞab;bnSMenAsNæaKarfaMgLenH )aneFVI[eXIjCak;EsþgnUvkarpøas;bþÚr Edl

)anekIteLIgedaymin)anRbúgmunkñúgTMnak;TMngrbs;evotNamCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚtaMgBIcugTsvtSr_50.

enACMnan;enaH KWevotNamesÞIrEtminTan;elIksÞÜytemáIgshPaBsUevotfaCaGñkbMPøWpøÚvbøúksgÁmniym

pgeT. BYkeK)an)at;bg;CMenOBIkMeNItrbs;xøÜncMeBaHeromc,gsgÁmniymCabgb¥Ún. CagenHeTAeTot

kþIsgÇwmkñúgkarbRgÜbbRgÜmCatieLIgvij kMBugeFVI[ekItmanrUbrag ehIyTsSnvis½ykñúgkarBRgIk

mUldæanTaMgLayénneya)aykarbreTsrbs;eKk¾kMBugpþl;nUvsarsMxan;Edr EdleFVI[evotNamElg

rYjranwgbgðajPaBR)akdkñúgcitþrbs;xøÜncMeBaHRkúgmUsÁÚeTotehIy. karcab;GarmµN_GMBIesrIPaBfµI²

enH )anbBa©b;y:agqab;rh½s. bBaðaepSg²CamYyRbeTscinnigRbeTskm<úCa PaBkan;EtF¶n;F¶rén

vibtþiEpñkesdækic© dMeNIrRsutcuHénkarebIkTVareq<aHeTArkbs©imRbeTs ³ TaMgGs;enH)annaM[cuHfy

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 195

Page 206: Brother enemy

RbkbedayeRKaHfñak;nUvlT§PaBkñúgkareFVIskmµPaB edIm,IeTAdl;eKaledAGVImYyrbs;RbeTsevot

Nam. evotNamcaM)ac;RtÚvEtelbPaBRkGWtRkeGagrbs;xøÜnmkvij. eBlevlaKWkarCYbKñaCafµI

CamYyRkúgmUsÁÚeTot.

«enaHehIyCamaK’arMedaHCatirbs;eyIg¡»

kardak;esñh_rbs;RbeTsevotNamcMeBaHshPaBsUevot manb£sKl;taMgBIedImstvtSr_TI

20. GñkCatiniymevotNamsuT§EtCaGñkCMBak;KuNrdæaPi)alGaNaniKm)araMgedaymincMeBaH Edl

)anBRgIkTsSnvis½ysRmab;GnaKtrbs;eK. edaysarGaNaniKmenHehIyEdlevotNam)anB¤eK

niyayBIbdivtþn_buleqvicCaelIkdMbUg. rhUtmkTl;nwgkarmkdl;rbs;BYk)araMg BiPBEdlBYkbBaØvnþ

evotNamEtgmémKitKWRbeTscin. GñkGkSrsa®sþcin)anpþl;[evotNamnUvRkbx½NÐsRmab;RbwkSa

KMnitTsSnviC¢a neya)ay nigsgÁm. BYk)araMg)aneFVI[TidæPaBepSg² minRKan;EtsMedAeTArkGWr:ub

b:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþ sMedAeTArkBiPBelakpgEdr. KWenAqñaM1920 Edl hU CImij )anbgðaj[dwgBIlT§i

kumµúynIsþedaykaremIlesovePArbs; elnIn kñúgElVgbnÞb;d¾tUcrbs;Kat;enATIRkúg):arIs. hU )an

sresr EssibqñaMeRkaymkfa «vaeFVI[´RCÜlRcbl;kñúgcitþesI¶csresIr nigmanesckþIsgÇwmy:ag

c,as;. ´rMePIbcitþnwgerOgenHrhUtRsk;TwkEPñk». eTaHCaenAEtmñak;ÉgkñúgbnÞb;rbs;´k¾eday k¾´

niyayB¤² ehIybeBa©jkayvikarhak;dUcCaQrenABImuxhVÚgmnusSy:ageRcInmYy ³ «bNþaCnrYmCati

EdlrgTukçevTnaCaTIesñha eyIgRtÚvkarrbs;enH ehIyenHKWCamaK’aénkarrMedaHCatirbs;eyIg¡»2.

bYnqñaMeRkaymk hU )ansßitenATIRkúgmUsÁÚ. edaykøayeTACayuT§Cnrbs;bdivtþn_GnþrCati

Kat;xkxanmin)anCYbvIrbursrbs;Kat; KW elnIn Edlsøab;BIrbIem:agmunkareTAdl;rbs;Kat;bnþic.

Kat;)ansikSa bnÞab;mkbeRgónenAsaklviTüal½ybUBa’RbeTs enATIRkúgmUsÁÚ ehIy)anCYbsÁal; hSÚ

ehSBsþalIn nig\sSrCnsMxan;²rbs;bkSCaeRcIneTot CaBiess r:adik, hSúINUvIey:v nig DImIRtÚhV.

enATIenaH mnusSCaeRcIn)anbegáIt[mancMNgTak;TgepSg²CamYybkSkumµúynIsþshPaBsUevot nig

karbdivtþn_rbs;sUevot Edlnwgbgðaj[eXIjsarsMxan;d¾FMminRtwmEtcMeBaHGaNaniKm)araMgenA

\NÐÚcinb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþ cMeBaHshPaBsUevotpÞal;EfmeTot. enAcugqñaM1924 hU )ancakecjBI

TIRkúgmUsÁÚeTAkg;tugCaTIEdlKat;TTYlbnÞúkeFVI[Kb;ePøIgbdivtþn_rIksayeTAeTot kñúgzan³Kat;CatMNag

GgÁkarGnþrCatikumµúynIsþsRmab;cugbUBa’RbeTs. R)aMmYyqñaMeRkaymk Kat;)anbegáItbkSkumµúynIsþ

\NÐÚcin (P.C.I.). GVIEdlenAsl;KWCacMENkmYyénRbvtþisa®sþ3.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg196

Page 207: Brother enemy

tamPUmisa®sþ eTaHbICacm¶ayd¾FMeFgmYyxNÐEckPaKxagt,ÚgRbeTscinnigRbeTsevotNam

CaTIEdlbkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcineFVIRbtibtþikaredaylYclak;émÖqñaMbnÞab;BIkarsñak;enArbs; hU CaelIk

dMbUgenATIRkúgmUsÁÚk¾eday k¾shPaBsUevotenAEtCaGñkbMPøWpøÚvsRmab;Gñkbdivtþn_evotNamCanic©.

karKaMRTrbs;Gñkbdivtþn_evotNamcMeBaHneya)aykarbreTsrbs;rusSI)anRbRBwtþeTAedayKµanlkç

xNÐ BIeRBaHshPaBsUevotCa«kMEBgkarBar[bdivtþn_BiPBelakGacrIkFMFat;» dUcEdlÉksarmYy

rbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcin cuHkalbriecäTqñaM1935 )anGHGagbEnßmBIerOgenHEdr ehIyEdlkar

bMpøajedayBYkcRkBtþi «nwgrujRcanclnaBiPBelak[fyeRkayGs;rab;sibqñaM».

PaBesµaHRtg;rbs;BYkkumµúynIsþevotNam )anRtÚveFVI[regÁaHregÁIsRmab;CaelIkdMbUgenAqñaM

1945. karKaMRTrbs;FanIbdivtþn_BiPBelak ¬RkúgmUsÁÚ¦ cMeBaHevotNammanminRKb;RKan;eT kñúg

kal³eTs³d¾sMxan;naeBlenaH. enAExsIha qñaM1945 edayeqøót»kasénkar)ak;T½Brbs;)araMg

enAmuxkarrulcUlmk\NÐÚcinrbs;Cb:un BYkkumµúynIsþevotNam)andeNþImGMNacenARkúghaNUy

ehIybegáItsaFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüevotNam. mü:ageTot sþalIn k¾dUcRbFanaFibtIGaemrik harI

RTÚm:an; )aneFVICamindwgminB¤cMeBaHkarGMBavnavrbs; hU CImij eLIy. Kat;)anecosvagminTTYlsÁal;

rdæfµInigbdiesFminpþl;nUvkarKaMRTcMeBaH hU EfmeTot. eCaKC½yrbs;bdivtþn_evotNamRKan;EtCa

dMeNIrpøas;bþÚrRBwtþikarN_bnÞab;bnSMb:ueNÑaHsRmab;RkúgmUsÁÚ. tamkaryl;eXIjrbs;xøÜn Gasn³

CaeRcInEdlBYkkumµúynIsþ)araMgTTYl)anenAsPa KWmansarsMxan;mYyepSgeTot edayminniyayBIkar

BRgwg\T§iBlrbs;xøÜnenAGWr:ub eRkaysm½ys®gÁam[rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgpgeT4. rhUtmkdl;eBlEdl

bkSkumµúynIsþ)araMg)at;bg;esckþIsgÇwmTaMgGs;kñúgkareLIgkan;GMNac ehIykñúglMGanenH eBlEdl

bkSkumµúynIsþevotNamcab;epþImbriharBIs®gÁamrbs;«cRkBtþi» eTIbRkúgmUsÁÚEbrmkykcitþTukdak;

cMeBaHkarRbyuT§ts‘Urbs;evotNamnigpþl;nUvkarKaMRT. b:uEnþ enAeBlenaHshPaBsUevotminTan;

bgðaj[eXIjnUvkarrevosrévhYsRbmaNmYy edIm,ITTYlsÁal;saFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüevotNam

eT. enAExmkra qñaM1950 edayyktRmab;tamsaFarNrdæRbCamanitcinEdleTIbbegáItfµI enATIbMput

RkúgmUsÁÚ)anTTYlsÁal;rdæaPi)alrbs; hU EdleBlenaHkMBugsßitenAkñúgéRBm:aKITaMgminsb,aycitþ5.

b:uEnþ karTTYlsÁal;enH RbEhlBuMEmnCakarbMPan;eLIy. RkúgmUsÁÚ nigRkúgeb:kaMgRtÚv)aneFVI

[xVl;xVayteTAeTot edIm,IEsVgrkkarsRmbsRmÜlmYyCamYyBYk)araMgCagKaMRTRbeTsevotNam

rhUtdl;C½yCmñHpþac;RB½Rt. TLðIkrN_rbs;eKKWfa BYkeKBuMGacFanakarKaMRTcMeBaH hU CImij eT kñúg

krNIEdlmanGnþraKmn_rbs;GaemrikaMgenA\NÐÚcin. tamkarBit sþalIn )ancuHkic©snüamYyCamYy

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 197

Page 208: Brother enemy

RbeTs)araMg edayRkúgmUsÁÚnwgCYysRmÜldl;dMeNaHRsaymYyGMBIs®gÁamenA\NÐÚcin EdlnaM[xUc

RbeyaCn_BYkkumµúynIsþevotNam ehIyCafñÚrmkvij BYk)araMgnwgCMTas;cMeBaHshKmn_GWr:ubEdlTTYl

bnÞúkxagkic©karBar. enAkñúg»kasénsnñisIThSWENvqñaM1954 karekobsgát;EdleFVIeTAelIbNþa

sm<n§miRtrbs;evotNamedayBYkcin nigsUevotmandUcCa BYkevotNamRtÚvEte)aHbg;kardeNþImkan;

kab;TwkdIrbs;kgT½Bevotmij ehIybNþasmmitþLav nigExµrrbs;xøÜn )anRtÚvbgçM[TTYlsÁal;PaBRtwm

RtÚvtamc,ab;énbNþarbbRbqaMgkumµúynIsþenARbeTsLav nigkm<úCaEdr. mü:ageTot evotNamRtÚvEt

[sc©ab½ndl;karEbgEckRbeTsrbs;xøÜnCabeNþaHGasnñ edayykExSRsbTI17 CabnÞat;RBMEdn

Edlnwgmanry³eBlémÖmYyqñaM6. enAqñaM1980 ´)ankat;smþIÉkGKÁrdæTUtRbeTsevotNam Edl

t¥ÚjEt¥renAcMeBaHmux´GMBIPaBminesµaHRtg;EdlBYkcinsEmþg[eXIjenATIRkúghSWENv ³ etIshPaB

sUevotmancMENkTTYlxusRtÚvmYydUcKñaEdreT?. Kat;)aneqøIymk´vij edayeFVIsBaØabgðaj´

rebobCanimitþrUbnUvfttubiTCitmYyfa ³ «G+a¡GVI²TaMgGs;sßitenAkñúgenH. eyIgnwgniyayBIerOgenH

enAeBl»kasmkdl;». BiPBelaketagEtrg;caMMémÖR)aMqñaM edIm,I)andwgnUvGVIEdlevotNamtiHedol

BI\riyabfrbs;RbeTscin enAqñaM1954naTIRkúghSWENv.

cab;taMgBIkalbriecäTenH-1954-smþIeRbIedayELksRmab;Pasabdivtþn_cab;BIéf¶enHeTA KW

Elglak;elomeTotehIy eTaHCatictYck¾Kµanpg eRBaHvaEsþgeBk ³ tamkarBit RkúgmUsÁÚ ykcitþTuk

dak;nwgRbeTsevotNamtictYcEmnETn y:agehacGVIEdlekItmaneLIgmineFVI[b:HBal;CMhrrbs;

sUevotenAGWr:ub b¤TMnak;TMngrbs;sUevotCamYyshrdæGaemriknigRbeTscin. rusSI )ancab;epþImpþl;[

eTARbeTsevotNamnUvCMnYyd¾t,itet,ótmYy xagEpñkesdækic©nigeyaFa. b:uEnþ rusSIminrvl;eFVIGVI

TaMgGs; edIm,IGnuBaØat[mankarGnuvtþn_maRtaénkic©RBmeRBóghSWENv EdltRmÚv[bNþaRbeTshtß

elxIerobcMkare)aHeqñatenAqñaM1956 kñúgeKalbMNgeFVIkarbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTseLIgvij. KMniténkar

epþImeFVIkarts‘UedayGavuFenAPaKxagt,Úg )aneFVI[BYksUevotTIeTIry:agxøaMg. nIKIta RKÚteqv )anvay

témøfa karpSgeRBgmYyEbbenaH EdldwknaMRbqaMgnwgsm<n§mitþmYyrbs;BYkGaemrikaMg KWecaT[man

bBaðaeLIgvijdl;PaBFUrRsalCamYyshrdæGaemrikEdlKat;RbwgERbgelIksÞÜyeLIg. Kat;niyay

fa ³ «lT§pléns®gÁamT½BéRB muxCabgá[mankarPan;ERbxøaMgmYy kñúgBiPBelakminxan».

erOgenH)aneFVI[ evotNamPJak;ep¥IlRsLaMgkaMg7.

minyUrb:unµan evotNam)anbnßybnþicmþg²nUvkarykcitþTukdak;cMeBaHGnusasn_rbs; RKÚteqv

Tak;TgnwgPaBcaM)ac;kñúg«dMNak;kalqøgkat;edaysnþiviFI»eq<aHeTArklT§isgÁmniymnigkarbRgÜbbRgÜm

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg198

Page 209: Brother enemy

Cati. enAcMeBaHmuxkarekobsgát;d¾muWgm:at;EdlepþImedayRbFanaFibtI g:U Dijeyom BYkkumµúynIsþenA

PaKxagt,ÚgevotNam)anepþImkarts‘UedayGavuFedayÉkÉg. enAqñaM1960 s®gÁamT½BéRB)an

raldalkñúgTMhMeRcInKYrsmCamYynigkarRbsiT§iBrrbs;KN³kmµaFikarmCÄimbkSkumµúynIsþenATIRkúg

haNUy EdlCaehtueFVI[xUcRbeyaCn_dl;RkúgmUsÁÚpg. kñúgRkbx½NÐénkic©RBmeRBóghSWENv

fµIenAqñaM1963 evotNam)anRtÚveFVI[ekþARkhaymin)at; cMeBaHRbkarEdlBYksUevotcab;epþImham

Xat;CaÉketaPaKInUvkareRbIR)as;RbeTsLavCatMbn;qøgkat;eq<aHeTAevotNamxagt,Úg. b:uEnþkarCab;

édRbyuT§minTan;dl;eBlevlaeT kñúgeBlEdlRkúghaNUyeRbIR)as;pøÚvlMhUCImijkan;EteRcIneLIg²

edIm,IRTRTg;PaKxagt,Úg. RBmCamYyKña kñúgehtukarN_TaMgenaHEdleRbIviFIkan;EtxøaMgRtÚv)ankt;

smÁal;edaykarTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;kgGakascrGaemrikaMgenAPaKxageCIg nigkareLIgeKakrbs;

kgT½BGaemrikaMgenAPaKxagt,ÚgnaqñaM1965 )anCMruj[RkúgmUsÁÚBRgwgkarKaMRTrbs;xøÜncMeBaHRkúg

haNUyrwtEtxøaMgeLIg. karekIneLIgnUvkarvivaTCamYyRbeTscin k¾CYy[mankarKaMRTenHEdr. rhUt

mkdl;karFøak;BIGMNacrbs; RKÚteqv enAqñaM1964 nigcritlkçN³énGñksñgtMENgKat; KWBuMmanGñk

Namñak;CYycat;EcgnaMpøÚvsUevot[cab;epþImKitKUrGMBIbBaðaevotNamCafµIeLIy.

edIm,IeqøIytbnwgkarecaTRbkan;rbs;cinBIlT§iesIerIniymnigkarXubXitCamYyshrdæGaemrik

BYkemdwknaMfµIenAvimanRkwmLaMg etagEtsEmþg[eXIjnUvsuqnÞ³sgÁmniymrbs;xøÜn edayCYy]btßmÖ

KaMRTRbeTsevotNam eTaHbICaeRKÓgsBVavuFEdlpþl;edayBYksUevotbRmúgTuksRmab;karBarevot

NamxageCIgRbqaMgnwgkarvayluktampøÚvGakasrbs;GaemrikaMgk¾eday k¾dUcCaCYykñúgkarBRgwg

s®gÁamT½BéRBenAPaKxagt,ÚgEdr. eBjry³eBléns®gÁam RkúgmUsÁÚenAEtRbúgRby½tñbgáarCamunnUv

lT§PaBénkarraldalCemøaHmYyCanic©. bnÞúkEdlpþl;[xøÜnnUvtYnaTICaGñkpÁt;pÁg;eRKÓgGavuF )aneFVI[

BYksUevotsakl,geRbIR)as;tYnaTIenHedIm,IeFVI[PaBFUrRsalCamYyGaemrikelOneTAmux nigbgðaj[

eXIj]tþmPaBrbs;xøÜnTl;nwgRkúgeb:kaMgpg. ebIniyayxagEpñkhirBaØvtßú 75PaKryénsmÖarswk

FunF¶n;EdleRbIR)as;edayevotNamKW)anmkBIRkúgmUsÁÚ b:uEnþrusSI)anykcitþTukdak;minpþl;eRKÓg

sBVavuFRKb;RbePTenAkñúgkNþab;édxøÜn EdlFVI[karc,aMgKñarIkraldaleLIy. ]tþmesnIy_evotNam

xageCIgmñak;EdlRtÚvcab;CaeQøIyswk )anbenÞasBYksUevotfa )anpþl;mIsuIlsmuRT-smuRTeTA[

«NaEsSr ¬RbFanaFibtIeGhSúIb¦ nig ebn EblLa ¬RbFanaFibtIGal;ehSrI¦ enAeBlEdlBYkeK

EtgEtbdiesFCanic©minpþl;mIsuIlenHmk[xøÜn edIm,IRbyuT§tTl;nwgnava Yankee Station nig Dixie Station

¬Cakgnavacm,aMgrbs;GaemrikaMg¦ enAlMhsmuRTrbs;evotNameLIy»8. evotNam)annaMmk

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 199

Page 210: Brother enemy

niyayR)ab;´CajwkjyRbkbedayesckþIeBjcitþpg nUverOgniTanxøI²EbbcMGkmYyEdl´sUm

sarPaBfa minGacBinitübBa¢ak;[dwgxusRtÚv Emnb¤minEmneLIy. Gñkbec©keTsenAhaNUynwg

seRmceCaKC½y edaykarBüayamkñúgkarEkERbRbB½n§tRmg;)aj;rbs;mIsuIlTaMgLayEdlpþl;[

edayBYksUevot nigbBa©b;nUvPaB)aj;minRtÚvénhVÚgynþehaHeb-52rbs;GaemrikaMg. rusSIhak;dUc

CaRtÚveFVI[RsLaMgkaMgedaylT§plénbec©keTsenH ³ munbg¥s;BYksUevot)anRbKl;eTA[evotNam

edayectnanUvGavuFepSg²EdlminGac)aj;eTAdl;ynþehaHTmøak;RKab;EbkFM²eT eday)armÖxøacbgá

ehtunwgBYkGaemrikaMg.

dUNal; hSaháÚrIy:a CaGñkÉkeTsxagbBaðasUevotd¾eqñImmñak;)anBiBN’naBICMhrrbs;RkúgmUsÁÚ

elIbBaðaevotNamenABak;kNþalTsvtSr_60fa «shPaBsUevot)ancat;Tuks®gÁamenHBuMEmndUc

erOg Armageddon ¬s®gÁamGvkas?¦mYyeT b:uEnþCakarepþImKMnitmYyEdlxuskal³eTs³ nigEdl

GacmanplGaRkk;eTAéf¶mux ehIy)anRtwmEteFVI[sµúKsµajdl;neya)aykarbreTsrbs;xøÜn nig

begáIt[manbBaðaBi)akedaHRsayfµImYyb:ueNÑaH. cMeBaHerOgenH eKaledArbs;vaBuMEmnecjmkBI

mhicätapÞal;rbs;sUevoteT edayrebobmü:agKWvaRtÚvbgçM[TTYledayKUsRtÚvTaMgBIrKW RbeTscin nig

shrdæGaemrik. RbeTsrusSImincg;[cinnigshrdæGaemrikTTYl)anC½yCmñHmYyeLIy eRBaHfa

C½yCmñHrbs;RbeTsTaMgBIrnwgbMpøajkitüanuPaBrbs;xøÜn. sRmab;rusSI Rckecjd¾RbesIrCageK nwg

manlkçN³CakarRbkYt\tQñHcaj;mYy»9.

enAeBlEdlevotNam xMRbwgbBa©úHbBa©ÚlRkúgmUsÁÚ[beBa©jPaBemaHmutCagmuncMeBaHRkúg

v:asuInetan edayelIkBIbMNgdwknaMbøúksgÁmniymrbs;BYksUevotenaH CemøaHEdlkan;EtraldalxøaMg

eLIgrvagshPaBsUevotnigRbeTscin)anecaTCabBaðaF¶n;F¶rmYycMeBaHRkúghaNUy. ebITukCaman

karTas;ETgKña EdlekItmantamkal³eTs³CamYyRkúgmUsÁÚnigeb:kaMgkþI k¾fñak;dwknaMrbs;evotNamenA

Etsnñidæanedayx¢ab;x¢ÜnBIPaBcaM)ac;énsamKÁIPaBkñúgCYrsgÁmniymEdr. evotNamP½yxøacfa karTas;ETg

Kña)anRtwmEtpþl;RbeyaCn_[«BYkcRkBtþiniym»nigeFVI[xUcxatdl;karts‘Urbs;RbCaCnevotNam

b:ueNÑaH. kñúgGtItkal hU CImij Føab;eFVIkarsakl,gCaeRcInedIm,IpSHpSamhaykSTaMgBIr b:uEnþenA

qñaM1966 evotNamhak;dUcCabeNþayeTAtamkmµvasnacMeBaHkarEbk)ak;énbøúksgÁmniym.

BYkeK)anseRmccitþedayectna edIm,ITajykRbeyaCn_BIkarRbkYtRbECgrvagcinnigsUevot.

CMhrkNþalrbs;eKEdlmankRmitesµIKñarvagRkúgmUsÁÚnigRkúgeb:kaMg)anGnuBaØat[evotNam TTYl

)anGtßRbeyaCn_CaGtibrmamYyTaMgsgxag.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg200

Page 211: Brother enemy

témøénÉkraCüPaB

hU CImij )anRtÚvTak;TajcitþedaylT§im:akS-elnInnigshPaBsUevot BIeRBaHrbs;TaMgGs;

enHCaPaBKYr[sgÇwmmYysRmab;ÉkraCüRbeTsrbs;Kat;. karKitmémdUcKñaenH GMBIkarbRgÜbbRgÜm

RbeTseLIgvijbnÞab;BIsnñisIThSWENv )ankMNt;edayc,as;las;nUv\riyabfrbs;RbeTsevotNam

eRkamkardwknaMrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþcMeBaHbNþaRbeTssgÁmniymCabgb¥Ún. eTaHbICaenAkñúgépÞbkS

rbs;xøÜnmanninñakarxagmenaKmviC¢aminRsbKñak¾eday k¾bkSkumµúynIsþrbs;evotNamminEdlman

GñksñiT§sUevot GñksñiT§cineLIy b:uEnþ KWmanEtGñksñiT§evotNamd¾emaHmutb:ueNÑaH. erOgr:av h½g

mijCij KWCakrNIedayELkmYy ³ bNþasmaCikénKN³dwknaMbkSRtÚv)anbeNþjecj eRBaHEtman

TMnak;TMngy:agCitsñiT§nwgbreTs. enAqñaM1967 Cij EdleBlenaH CaRbFansalaneya)aybkS

nigm®nþImYycMnYnRtÚv)ancab;xøÜnedaysarkareFVIcarkic©[shPaBsUevot. karkm©at;GñkEdleK

snµtfaCaBYksmasPaBsñiT§cinrbs;bkS )anekItmaneLIgenAeRkayqñaM1975.

neya)ayrbs;RkúghaNUyBuMEmnRKan;EtedIrtampøÚvkNþalmYyb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþCaneya)ay

mincUlbkSsm<n§pgEdr edaysMGagelIkarseRmcmYytaMgBIdMbUg. bBaðaTaMgGs;sRmab;evotNam

KWRtÚvkMNt;fa etIRkúgmUsÁÚ b¤ Rkúgeb:kaMg EdlmansßanPaBRbesIrCageK edIm,ICYyeFVI[seRmceKal

edAx<s;bMputrbs;xøÜnedayBitR)akd. karraErkrbs;evotNamenAcenøaHTaMgsgxag KWBuMGacbkRsay

edayrebobepSgBIenHeLIy10. enAqñaM1963 eBlEdl RKÚt eqv RbqaMgnwgs®gÁamrMedaHCati eday

ykelsfa vamuxCabgá[maneRKaHfñak;dl;snþiPaBBiPBelak RbeTsevotNam)anbgçitxøÜncUlEGb

RbeTscin edIm,IbriharCasaFarN³BIPaBFUrRsal nigkic©RBmeRBógminrIksayGavuFnuyekøEG‘r.

b:uEnþ enAqñaM1972 eBlEdlelak rIqad nicsun eFVIdMeNIreTARkúgmUsÁÚnigRkúgeb:kaMg edaymin

e)aHbg;karTmøak;RKab;EbkenAPaKxageCIgevotNamenaH RkúghaNUy)anefáaleTasCasaFarN³BI

«kalanuvtþniym»¬karniymedIrRsbtamkal³eTs³¦rbs;RbeTssgÁmniymTaMgLay. kñúgkal³eTs³

enH RkúghaNUynwksþayeRkayfa karkarBarplRbeyaCn_EdlKitftxøÜnnigTak;TgnwgplRbeyaCn_

Cati)anedIrmunlT§i«GnþrCatiniymvNѳGFn» KWmunkarKaMRTdl;karRbyuT§ts‘UenAevotNam edIm,Ikar

bRgÜbbRgÜmCatirbs;xøÜn.

munbg¥s; RkúgmUsÁÚEdlcg;karBarPaBFUrRsalCamYyRkúgv:asuInetan nigedayP½yxøacfa kar

pSgeRBgrbs;evotNammuxCaRbTajxøÜn[Føak;kñúgCemøaHmYyrIkkan;EtFMeday sVaKmn_CamYynwglkç

xNÐc,as;las;mYycMeBaHkarvaylukEdlepþImedayRkúghaNUyRbqaMgnwgPaKxagt,ÚgenAniTaXrdUv

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 201

Page 212: Brother enemy

qñaM1975. rusSImindwgfa etIBYkeKsb,aycitþnwgTsSnvis½yepSg²EdlesñI[mankarbRgÜbbRgÜm

RbeTsevotNameLIgvij b¤k¾P½yxøacplvi)akepSg²EdlGacekItmanBIyuT§nakareyaFamYyb¤k¾

y:agNa. CaBiess rusSImincg;[kgT½BGaemrikaMgvilRtLb;mkRbeTsevotNamvijeT eRBaHvanwg

eFVI[BYkeKsßitenAkñúgCMhrBi)akedaHRsaymYyEdlRtÚveRCIserIsrvagkarcuHcaj;nigkareFVIs®gÁam

edayeRbIviFIkan;EtxøaMg. enAeBlEdlRkúgv:asuInetanepþImTak;TgCamYyBYksUevot edIm,IesñI[Tb;

skmµPaBrbs;evotNam BYkeK)ansuxcitþeFVItamTaMgeTIsTal; b:uEnþ )aneqøót»kasenH edIm,IbBa¢ak;

R)ab;BYkGaemrikaMgBIkarenACakNþalrbs;xøÜnEdr. kñúgsarlixitsm¶at;mYyEdlepJICUnRbFanaFibtI

hV½rd_ mYys)aþh_munkardYlrlMénTIRkúgéRBnKr RkúgmUsÁÚ)ansgát;bBa¢ak;GMBIehtukarN_fa «eKal

bMNgrbs;evotNam BuMEmneFVI[RsGab;rUbPaBshrdæGaemrikeT»11. eKminGacniyayeday

BitR)akdfa evotNamRbkan;tamBakü snüaenHEdrb¤k¾Gt;eT. edayvayRbharmUldæanGakas tan;

sWnjwk BYkeK)aneFVI[karbnþCemøósbuKÁlikecjtamynþehaHdwknaMFM²minGacRbRBwtþeTA)an nig

)anbgçM[BYkGaemrikaMgeFVIkardkfymYytam]T§mÖaKcRkTaMgRbjab;Rbjal;nigxUcmuxmat;cab;BIelI

dMbUlGKarTaMgLayenATIRkúgéRBnKr. esckþIraykarN_kñúgsarB½t’manrbs;sUevotGMBIRBwtþikarN_enH

enAEtføwgEføgCanic©. mü:ageTot kñúglixitsEmþgkarGbGrsaTrEdlRkúgmUsÁÚbBa¢ÚneTARkúghaNUy

KWBYksUevotRby½tñminerobrab;bBa©ÚleQµaHshrdæGaemrikenAkñúgenaHeLIy edIm,IecosvagykEdkeTA

rukdMe)AGaemrikaMg12.

k¾b:uEnþ eTaHbICamankarRbúgRby½tñTaMgRsugrbs;xøÜnk¾eday k¾RkúgmUsÁÚGacdwgfa RbeTsevotNam

EdlCab;CMBak;nwgCemøaHmYyBan;qñaMrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTscinCanic©enaH enAeBlenH ehgs‘y Gac

pøas;bþÚrcitþmkcUlxagxøÜnk¾fa)an. RkúghaNUyGackøayeTACasm<n§miRtminGacvaytémø)anmYy

edIm,ITb;RbeTscinnigbeRmICaQñan;sRmab;\T§iBlrbs;sUevotenAGasuIGaeKñy_. rdæaPi)alrbs;

sUevotGaceBjcitþnwgkarebIk[eRbIR)as;EdleRKagTukCamunnUvkMBg;Epnanarbs;evotNam ehIy

TMngCa»kasBRgIkEmkFagrbs;xøÜnpg. b:unµanéf¶bnÞab;BIkardYlrlMénTIRkúgéRBnKr GñkRtÜtBinitü

sUevot)ancab;epþImmkdl;RkúghaNUyy:ageRcIn edIm,IbBa¢ak;BIkarKaMRTrbs;BYkeKcMeBaHevotNam

nigedIm,ITamTarcMENkénkarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;eKkñúglT§plseRmcRbkbedayC½yCmñHenH. bnÞab;BI

karraErknigkarKaMRTd¾Rby½tñRbEygkñúgry³eBlCaeRcInqñaM GMNwHteTARkúgmUsÁÚ)ane)aHBYyeTACYb

GñkQñHy:agelOn ehIyhak;dUcCaeRtómbRmúgbg;témørbs;Edl)at;ehIyrkeXIjvij CaeRsc

eTaHbIvaCaeFVIeLIgTaMgeTIsTal;k¾eday. m®nþIpø ÚvkarsUevotmñak;)anniyayrG‘UrTaMR)ab;rdæm®nþI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg202

Page 213: Brother enemy

karbreTsrbs;Kat;KWelak Gg;eRd RháÚmIkU enAExkBaØa qñaM1975fa karFujRTan;rbs;eyIgKWeyIg

ElgsmÁal;eXIjGVI[)anRbesIreRkAEtBIeqøIyeTAeK¬evotNam¦vijfa eTb:ueNÑaH. mnusSminsUvdwg

xusRtÚvTaMgenaH )ancab;epþImRbkan;Gakb,kiriyaeFVIGVI²TaMgGs;Etmñak;Ég ehIyenAeBlenH BYkeK

)ansuMBIeyIgnUvrbs;EdleyIg[minekIteTot»13.

enAéf¶TI4 Ex]sPa KWEtbYnéf¶b:ueNÑaHbnÞab;BIkarsRmúkcUld¾xÞrxÞarénhVÚgrfeRkaH T.54 rbs;

sUevoteTAkñúgvimanRbFanaFibtIenATIRkúgéRBnKr navapÞúkTMnijrbs;sUevoteQµaH nINa saháaydas

nignavadwkeRbg\n§n³eQµaH kumsUm:UeLt RBIm:UrIy:a )ancUlctenAkMBg;EpdaNag enAevotNamxag

t,Úg. BIrs)aþh_eTot navafµI²rbs;sUevotnwgebIkcUlmkctenAkMBg;EpRkúgéRBnKr edaypÞúksuT§Et

es,ógGahar nigeRbg\n§n³. «kayvikarRbkbedaymnusSFm’»enH maneKaledAEtmYyKt;KW edIm,I

TTYl)ankardwgKuNrbs;evotNam. BYksUevotb:unb:gbegáItTmøab;mYynigebIkpøÚveq<aHeTArkkareRbI

R)as;kMBg;EpnanaenAPaKxagt,Úg[kan;EteTogTat; ehIyCaBiessxagEpñkeyaFa. b:uEnþ edayvay

témøBICMnYyEpñkesdækic©nigbec©keTsrbs;BYksUevot/ RkúghaNUymanbMNgbnþdwknaMvis½yneya-

)aykarbreTsrbs;RbeTseTAtamcMNg;rbs;xøÜn. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaEdlevotNambdiesFmin[

eRbIR)as;kMBg;Eprbs;xøÜn BYkeKk¾)anRcanecalkaresñI[xøÜncuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógmitþPaBmYy

CamYyBYksUevotpgEdr14. BitehIy BYkevotNamdwgfa xøÜnmanPaBCitsñiT§nwgRkúgmUsÁÚCagRkúg

eb:kaMgxagEpñkmenaKmviC¢a b:uEnþ esckþIlMeGogenH muxCaCMruj[BYkeKlHbg;PaBGBüaRkwtEdlBYkeK

Føab;sEmþg[eXIjkñúgCemøaHrvagcin-sUevotminxan. karseRmccgsm<n§PaBmYytampøÚvc,ab;

CamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ eTaHCaminniyayGMBIkarGnuBaØat[sUevoteRbIR)as;nUvkMBg;Epnanarbs;xøÜnk¾eday

k¾va)anrYmCakarbgáehtumYycMeBaHRbeTscinEdr ehIyRbkarenHminmankñúgbMNgTaMgLayrbs;

evotNameLIy.

mindwgfa BYkcinRtÚv)anb¤minRtÚv)anpþl;dMNwg[dwgBIkarbdiesFenHeT ehIyenAbnþkarsgS½y

BIectnaepSg²rbs;BYkesIerIniymevotNamcMeBaHBYksUevotteTAeTot. tameKniyayfa CaeRcIn

s)aþh_bnÞab;BIRkúgéRBnKrdYlrlM elakRbFan em:A )anrMB£kenAmuxelak KURKit R)aemaCJ naykrdæm®nþI

éfEdlsßitenAmYyry³xøIkñúgrdæFanIrbs;cinGMBIKeRmageFVIsBa¢½yxøH² enAkñúgtMbn;EdlKat;Føab;)an

CYyeRCamERCgevotNam. tameyabl;rbs;Kat;fa evotNam«Cab:usþiCYrmuxrbs;cRkBtþiniym

sUevotenAGasuI»15.

ebIsinCaeKeFVIniTsSn_fa enHBitCasmþIrbs; em:A Emn vanwgBi)aksnñidæanBIectnaepSg²rbs;

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 203

Page 214: Brother enemy

evotNamNas;. kardeNþImkan;kab;TIRkúgéRBnKrKWCakar)anseRmcbMNgd¾x¢ab;x¢ÜnmYy. bMNgd¾

x¢ab;x¢ÜnenHKW hU CImij nigbNþasmmitþrbs;Kat;)anEsVgrktamry³bTBiesaFn_nigkartUccitþCaeRcIn

EdlBuMFøab;manBImunmk. cab;BIeBlenHeTA bkSkumµúynIsþevotNamdwgfa xøÜnmanesrIPaBCageBlNa²

TaMgGs; kñúgkarRbkan;ykpøÚvEdlxøÜneRCIserIs. KµanGñkNaecHniyayBIemaTnPaBrbs;RbeTsevot

NamCagelak v:ag Tug niBn§naykkaEstjinhSineLIy. rYmCamYy hU CImij Tug Føab;)anRTaMRTkñúg

karts‘Urbs;clnaevotmijedIm,IÉkraCüPaB/ cm,aMgenAeDonebonPU nigbNþaqñaMd¾yUrlg; nigP½yxøac

kñúgkarvayRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgBYkGaemrikaMg. enAExkkáda qñaM1975 ´)aneTAelgKat;enAkñúgbnÞb;

kariyal½yd¾tUcEdlmanTItaMgenAkñúgGKaréneKhdæancMNas;mYynaTIRkúghaNUy. BImat;bg¥ÜceTA

nigtamsøwkeQIRtsuMRtsay eKemIleXIjbwgh½neKomBIcm¶ayCabwgEdlmandavTiBVrbs;vIrburs

evotNammñak;EdleFVIkarRbyuT§ edIm,IÉkraCüPaBkb;enAkñúgenaH. Tug EdlmanEs,kmuxRCIvRCÜj

edaysareBlevla hak;dUcCaeLIgpñt;PøamenAeBlEdlKat;niyaymkkan;´kñúgsñamjjwmmYyfa ³

«sBVéf¶ eyIg´TaMgGs;KñamanesrIPaBnigGMNacCagmun EdleyIgminEdlmandUceBlenHeT». kar

putrlt;éns®gÁam)aneFVI[)at;TaMgRsugnUvkarbgçitbgçMPaKeRcInEdlrwtt,itsV½yPaBneya)ayrbs;

evotNam. Tug minlak;elomeLIyBIkarN_Edlfa C½yCmñHpþac;RB½Rt)anmaneLIg eTaHbICamankar

ekobsgát;BIRkúgmUsÁÚ nigRkúgeb:kaMgEdlykcitþTukdak;mineFVI[shrdæGaemrikTal;Rckk¾eday. Tug

)anR)ab;´fa RkúghaNUy)anQñHs®gÁamRbqaMgnwgkgT½BEdlmankmøaMgelIslb;KWkgT½BCasRtÚv

rbs;xøÜn b:uEnþk¾QñHkgT½BCabNþamitþxøÜnEdr16. CaÉkCn BYkemdwknaMepSg²eTot )ansEmþg[eK

eXIjlkçN³qab;eCOTukcitþeK niglkçN³Rtg;Kµanl,ickl EdleFVIb£kRkGWtRkeGagnwgkarEdl

RbeTsevotNamerobcMeFVIkarvaylukpþac;RB½Rtrbs;xøÜnenAPaKxagt,Úg edayminR)ab;erOgenHTaMg

Rsúg[bNþasm<n§miRtsgÁmniymrbs;BYkeKdwgeLIy. enAb:unµanéf¶cugeRkayénExemsa qñaM1975

RkúghaNUyBuM)anykcitþTukdak;nwgkarRBmanEdlbeBa©j[dwgdac;edayELkedayBYkcin nigBYk

sUevotpgeT eRBaHRbeTsTaMgBIrenHP½yxøacfa karvaydeNþImRkúgéRBnKredaykmøaMgT½B muxCabgá[

manGnþraKmn_fµImYyrbs;GaemrikaMgCaminxan.

Tug )anelIk]TahrN_CaeRcInmkR)ab;´GMBIesrIPaBeTIbTTYlfµI²enH EdlRkúghaNUyGac

beBa©jmtirbs;xøÜnedayeBjelj. ]TahrN_ «eyIgKaMRTrdæaPi)al\NÐaRbqaMgnwgkarrYmKMnitk,t;

rbs;BYkcRkBtþiniym eTaHbICaRbeTscinBuMsb,aycitþk¾eday. eyIgKaMRTKNbkSkumµúynIsþ

B½rTuyháal;RbqaMgnwgkareRbIkll,icrbs;KNbkSsgÁmniym eTaHbICaKNbkSkumµúynIsþepSgeTot

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg204

Page 215: Brother enemy

CaeRcInriHKn;cMeBaHxøÜnk¾eday». RkúghaNUy)anniyaybBaäitbeBaäógcMeBaHkarRbqaMgCMTas;rbs;

Rkúgeb:kaMgBIkarRbkasdak;RbeTskñúgPaBGasnñenA\NÐakalBIExmifunamun nigkarTietonrbs;cin

RbqaMgnwgKNbkSkumµúynIsþB½rTuyháal;EdlRtÚvcat;TukCa]bkrN_mYyrbs;sUevot. m®nþIevotNam

epSg²eTot )anniyayR)ab;´Casm¶at;fa BYkeKBuMGbGrnwgPaB\teGonxµasénneya)aysRmb

sRmÜlEdlRbkan;ykedayRkúgmUsÁÚkñúgTMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYyshrdæGaemrikeT ehIy

elIsBIenHKWkarGMBavnavrbs;sUevotCaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;karbegáItRbB½n§snþisuxrYmmYyenAGasuI

EdlerOgenHBYkeKKµaneXIjGVIeRkAEtBIkarb:unb:geFVIsm<n§PaBmYyRbqaMgcineLIy. enAqñaM1969

BYksUevotFøab;)anbeBa©jKMnitRbmUlpþú MRbeTsenAGasuITaMgGs;[cUlrYmkñúgsm<n§PaBmYysMedA

RbqaMgRbeTscin. mYyqñaMeRkaymk kñúgry³eBlénkareFVIsmÖasn_mYyCaelIkTIBIr v:ag Tug )anEjk

erOgenHedayBaküKYr[cgcaMBIrXøa ehIyniyayR)ab;´fa ³ «vamanPaBTIéTBIKñaFM²rvagRbeTsnana

enAGasuI. etIRtÚvKitKUrrMlayRbeTsTaMgenH[eTACavtßúEtmYyedayreboby:agdUcemþc? etIKitcg;

rYmkmøaMgCa s‘UhartU ¬\NÐÚensuI¦ nig esnIR)aemaCJ¬enARbeTséf¦edaymeFüa)ayNa?».

R)akdNas; RkúghaNUyBuM)aneRtómxøÜnElgKaMRTkarts‘Ubdivtþn_enAkñúgRbeTsGasuIepSg²

edIm,IebIk»kas[BYksUevotTak;TajbNþarbb«Rbtikiriya»kñúgtMbn;kñúgKeRmagmYyeLamB½T§RbeTscin

eLIy. GñkkaEstevotNammñak;)anlan;mat;enAmux´kalBIExemsa qñaM1977fa «BYksUevotElg

manGVIEdlBYkeKmaneTotehIy». «BYkeKcg;[manPaBFUrRsalCamYyshrdæGaemrik edIm,IGaceRbI

R)as;PaBbuinRbsb;TaMgGs;rbs;xøÜnkñúgkarplitrfynþ nigm:asuInRtCak;sRmab;TIpSarkñúgRbeTsrbs;

eK. BYkeKBuMmanplRbeyaCn_NamYy edIm,IKaMRTkarRbyuT§ts‘UkñúgkarrMedaHRbeTsttiyelakeLIy

elIkElgEtedIm,IbegáItCa]bsKÁdl;RbeTscinb:ueNÑaH».

bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHEdleFVI[RsLaMgkaMgrbs;xøÜn RkúghaNUy)andl;kþIsb,ayrIkrayéRkElg.

GVI²GaceFVI)anTaMgGs;sRmab;GñkEdl)anb®gáabrdæd¾manGMNacbMputénBiPBelak. edaysm,Úr

htßBlkrEdlmanCMnaj/ ksikmµrIkRtkuMRtkal/ FnFaneRkamdIsþúksþmÖ-RbEhlmaneRbgkatpg-

Twksm,ÚrRtI RbeTsevotNamGacksagesdækic©d¾rwgmaMmYyelImUldæanTaMgenH eTaHbIeKGacRbyuT§

ts‘UnwgbisacGaemrikaMgQñHehIykþI. karsuxkaysb,aycitþenH )anrlay)at;y:agqab;rh½s kñúg

lMdab;EdltfPaBEpñkesdækic©)anelceLIg[eXIjkan;Etc,as;eLIg². edIm,IksagRbeTsEdlRtÚv

hinehacedaysars®gÁameLIgvij eKRtÚvEtxMRbwg[)anseRmcnUvCMnYyEpñkesdækic©nigbec©keTs

mYy. karRKb;RKgRbCaCatimYyEdlrYbrYmeLIgvij KWCabnÞúkbEnßmmYyeTot. ebIniyay[xøIeTA

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 205

Page 216: Brother enemy

ÉkraCü EdlTTYl)anfµI²enARbeTsevotNamKWCakarsakl,gd¾twgEtgmYy. enATIRkúghaNUy eK

hammin[niyayTietonCaÉkCnGMBITRmg;xøH²énneya)ayrbs;sUevoteLIy b:uEnþ CasaFarN³vij

eKsEmþg[eXIjkarRBmeRBógTaMgRsugmYyCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ. xusEbøkBIdMeNIrrbs;Kat;eTATIRkúg

eb:kaMg enAExkBaØa qñaM1975 TsSnkic©rbs; eL yn; enARkúgmUsÁÚnaExtulaqñaMdEdl )anebIk»kas[

mankartak;EtgesckþIEføgkarN_rYmmYy EdlRbeTsevotNamGHGagnwgshPaBsUevotBIkarKaMRT

rbs;xøÜncMeBaHneya)aykarbreTsrbs;sUevot niglatRtdagsþIBIPaBcaM)ac;edIm,I«eFVI[manPaB

FUrRsaltamdMeNIrmYyEdlminGacERbRtLb;)an». sRmab;Rkúgeb:kaMg Bakü«PaBFUrRsal» KWCa

BaküesÞIrEtRbmafCacMhmYy. evotNampÞal;)anbriharenAExtula qñaM1974 BIkarrYmKMnitk,t;

rbs;GaemrikaMg sMedAbMEbkbM)ak;RbeTskumµúynIsþnana niglak;KMnitfa eKaledABitR)akdrbs;

shrdæGaemrikKW «karkemÞcclnarMedaHCatiTaMgGs;»17. CaeRcInExeRkaymk emdwknaMevotNam

mñak;)anniyayedaHsaBIkarERbRtLb;enHenAcMeBaHmuxGñkmansmancitþmñak;KWelak PIF½r lImkWkU

niBn§naykkaEst Journal of Contemporary Asia EdlkMBugeFVITsSnkic©enARbeTsevotNamfa ³

«ÉkraCüPaBmantémøéføNas;. erogral;eBlEdleyIgsEmþg[eXIjÉkraCü eyIgRtÚv)at;esckþI

RtÚvkarmYyEfmeTot. kalNaCMhrrbs;eyIgERbRbÜleTACaGaRkk; kalenaHTMhMénCMnYyrbs;bNþa

RbeTs«Cabgb¥Ún»k¾cuHfyEdr»18.

mYyExbnÞab;BIkarvilRtLb;rbs; eL yn; BITIRkúgmUsÁÚ kaEstrbs;evotNammYy)anrMB£k

edayeRbIBakücMGkbBaÄWcitþfa C½yCmñHmann½yfa TIbBa©b;énGMeNayrbs;bNþaRbeTsCamitþ. «enA

eBlmans®gÁam eyIg)anTTYlCMnYymYyEdleK[eday\tKitéfø. b:uEnþ GNwHteTA TMnak;TMngrbs;

eyIgCamYybNþaRbeTsCamitþnigCabgb¥Ún sßitenARtg;kareRbIBaküeBcn_dUecñH ³ sgbMNulvij nUvGVI

EdlGñk)anx©I eFVI[edImTunrbs;GñkmanEpøpáa TijedIm,ICYj. RbkarTaMgGs;enH KWeFVIeLIgkñúgnamén

CMnYy nigplRbeyaCn_eTAvijeTAmk»19.

karsþarRbeTsevotNameRkaysm½ys®gÁameLIgvij RtÚvkarCacaM)ac;nUvCMnYyd¾sem,Im

mYyBIRbeTseRkA. rdæaPi)alRkúghaNUycUlcitþesñIsuMCMnYyBIbNþaRbeTselakxaglicCaCagBIbøúk

sgÁmniym edaysarEtRbeTsTaMgenaHmanbec©kviC¢aeCOnelOnCag. b:uEnþ clnamincUlbkSsm<n§

RtÚvkar[rkSasmtamYyEdllM)aktRmÚvcitþbMput. evotNam)anbMPøWdUecñHcMeBaH elak hVIlIB rIQ½r

ÉkGKÁrdæTUt)araMgRbcaMRkúghaNUyfa GVIEdlmanEtkñúgKMnitedIm,IBRgwgÉkraCüneya)ayrbs;eyIg

KWrebobcat;EcgmYy«EdlmanbYnPaKI» bøúksUevotnigRbeTscinpÁt;pÁg;Bak;kNþalénCMnYyGWr:ubxaglic

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg206

Page 217: Brother enemy

shrdæGaemrik RbeTsCb:un nigkaNada pÁt;pÁg;Bak;kNþaleTot20. BImunmkRkúghaNUycUlcitþ

rkSasmtamYykñúgTMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚnigRkúgeb:kaMgCag. k¾b:uEnþ ebIcg;)anTTYl

CMnYy haNUyRtÚvEtEkERb\riyabfrbs;xøÜn ehIyebIKit[sBV²eTAKYrEtlMeGogeTAxagRkúgmUsÁÚ

RbesIrCag. mundMbUg BIeRBaHshPaBsUevotCaRbeTsmanePaKsm,tþinigGanuPaBCagRbeTscin

ehIyCaBiessbnÞab;mk BIeRBaHplRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜnKWfa RbeTsevotNamRtÚvEtkøayeTACardæxøaMg

mYy. dUcEdleKnwksµan RbeTscin)anbdiesFminsnüapþl;CMnYykñúgry³eBlEvgeLIy. pÞúyeTA

vij RkúgmUsÁÚ)ansnüapþl;CMnYydl;kareFVI[)anseRmcnUvEpnkarR)aMqñaM1976-1980rbs;

evotNamtamkic©snüapþl;hirBaØvtßúEdlkMNt;CaeRsc. enAExtula qñaM1975 kic©RBmeRBógpþl;

CMnYymYyCaelIkdMbUgsRmab;karsþarRbeTseLIgvijRtÚv)ancuHhtßelxa. RkúgmUsÁÚ)ansnüapþl;

hirBaØvtßúcMnYn60PaKryRtÚvCa 2>100landuløarkñúgkarcMNayEdlrab;bBa¢ÚlkñúgEpnkarsRmab;

ry³kalqñaM1976-8021.

c,as;Nas; enHCaGMeNayEdlKitEtRbeyaCn_xøÜn. CafñÚreTAvij RbeTsevotNam RtÚvEt

pþl;nUvkarKaMRTrbs;xøÜncMeBaHneya)ayeRkARbeTssUevot-GaemrikaMg. k¾b:uEnþ BYkemdwknaMviman

RkwmLaMg)anvaytémøy:agkNþalfa RkúghaNUy)anxñHExñgBRgIkPaBFUrRsalenH edayERbpøas;

TMnak;TMngpÞal;rbs;xøÜnCamYybreTsEdr. edayyl;BIsµartIÉkraCürbs;RbeTsevotNam Rkúg

mUsÁÚP½yxøacy:agxøaMgBIkar)at;bg;EpñkmYyén\T§iBlrbs;xøÜn. taMgBIedImrhUtdl;cugqñaM1976 BYk

sUevot)anXøaMemIlCamYykarRBÜy)armÖBIkarxMRbwgrbs;RkúghaNUykñúgeKalbMNgbegáItTMnak;TMng

EpñkkarTUtnigesdækic©CamYybs©imRbeTs nigeTAcUlrYmCamYyclnamincUlbkSsm<n§. bnÞab;BIkar

cuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógpþl;CMnYyEpñkesdækic©EtBIr-bIExb:ueNÑaH karsb,ayrIkrayxøaMgrbs;

sUevotcMeBaHRbeTsevotNamEdlCa «b:usþiCYrmuxénlT§isgÁmniym»)ancab;epþImERbCaesaHGegÁIy.

RkúghaNUymanPaBdUcKñaEpñkmenaKmviC¢aEfmeTotCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ k¾dUcCamYyRkúgeb:kaMg b:uEnþ

plRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜnR)akdCamin[LÚkLMnwgCemøaHrbs;RbeTsTaMgBIreT. dUcr)aykarN_sm¶at;

mYyrbs;sUevot EdlTuksRmab;EtkarsnÞnakMBUlrvagsUevot-evotNam enAExtula qñaM1975

)ansgát;bBa¢ak;BIerOgenHfa sRmab;»kasenH «evotNamyl;eXIjfa minTan;dl;kalevlaEdl

RtÚvkan;eCIgxagNa²kñúgCemøaH» EdleFVI[RbeTscinRbQmmuxnwgshPaBsUevoteT22. BYk

emdwknaMevotNammankar)armÖedayELkminbeNþay[PaKxagt,Úg EdleTIbrMedaH)anfµI²køayeTACa

rbs;EdlxøÜnGacxatbg;kñúgkarRbECgKñarvagcin nigsUevoteLIy. enAPaKxagt,Úg BYkemdwknaM

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 207

Page 218: Brother enemy

evotNam)anRbKl;kareFVI[seRmcxagEpñkesdækic©xøH² eTA[bNþaRbeTsepSg²dUcCaRbeTs

)araMg/ n½rEv:s/ \NÐa nigRbeTsCb:unCaedIm. cMENkrusSI nigBYkcin)anRtÚvFIbecaldac;Ghgáar.

edayeFVI[ekþARkhaycMeBaHkarbdiesFrbs;evotNam minGnuBaØat[ebIksßankugs‘ulmYyenATIRkúg

hU CImij BYksUevot)anKMramcab;bgçM[navaTaMgLayrbs;xøÜneFVIBhikarmincUlctenAkMBg;EprdæFanI

PaKxagt,ÚgEdr. b:uEnþ evotNam)anedaHRsaybBaðaenHdUcKñanwgBYkcin-enHCakarsEmþg[eXIjPaB

minlMeGogy:agl¥. evotNam)anhamXat;min[RbeTsTaMgBIrebIksßankugs‘ulenAPaKxagt,Úg

dUcKña enAeBlEdlBYk)araMg)anRtÚvGnuBaØat[rkSasßankugs‘ulrbs;eKdEdl ehIyGñkkarTUtnig

GñkkaEstelakxaglic)aneFVIdMeNIreTAPaKxagt,ÚgswgEtedayesrI23.

enAEx]sPa qñaM1975 GñkeqøIyqøgénTIPñak;garB½t’mantasS (TASS) enATIRkúghaNUy Edl

eTIbnwgedIremIlRbeTsenHrYmCamYyshPatr³¬GñkmanviC¢aCIv³dUcKña¦ kumµúynIsþCaeRcInnak;)ant¥Új

Et¥ry:aglVIgCUrct;BI «PaBGyutþiFm’» EdlevotNamGnuBaØat[EtbNþaGgÁkarsarB½t’mancRkBtþi

dUcCaTIPñak;garB½t’man)araMg/ eGPI/ r:yF½r nig yU>PI>Gay> eFVIkarenARkúghUCImij enAeBlEdlevot

NambdiesFmin[xøÜnebIkkariyal½ymYyenATIenaHeLIy. enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1976 GñkkarTUt\NÐa

mñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenARkúghaNUy)anniyayR)ab;´Casm¶at;fa «EbbEpnEdlGñkkarTUtsUevot

yayIrMxanbNþashPatr³rbs;BYkeKEdlRtÚvbeNþjecjBIRkúgéRBnKr edIm,IEsVgrkB½t’manepSg²

KWBitCaKYr[GaNitEmnETn».

eL yn; )aneFVI[rusSIekþARkhayy:agxøaMgkñúg»kasénmhasnñi)atbkSkumµúynIsþshPaB

sUevotelIkTI25 enAExmIna qñaM1976 edayKat;BüayamsYrBIRbFanbTÉkraCüPaB. enAéf¶bnÞab;

KWCaéf¶EdlGñkmenaKmviC¢aénbkSkumµúynIsþsUevot mIxaGuIl s‘UsøÚv briharBIkarniyayRbkan;tam

RTwsþItictYceBkrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ)araMgehIyhak;dUcCaKab;CYn eRBaH eL yn; )ancUlrYmbriePaK

)ayéf¶Rtg;CamYyelak hSk m:areq-GKÁelxabkSkumµúynIsþ)araMg-Edr. kñúgsnÞrkfarbs;Kat; eL

yn; )anKUsbBa¢ak;fa bkSkumµúynIsþnanaKWbegáIteLIgedIm,IEsVgrk «EbbEpn/ TRmg; nigrebobRbqaMg

epSg² tRmÚveTAtamsßanPaBénRbeTserog²xøÜnrbs;BYkeK»24.

enAExsIha qñaM1976 paM v:an;dug )aneFVICatMNagRbeTsevotNamrYmKñaEtmYyeTAcUlrYm

snñisITkMBUlénbNþaRbeTsmincUlbkSsm<n§enATIRkúgkULúMbU. evotNammankareBjcitþy:agxøaMg

cMeBaHesckþIrab;GanEdlRbeTsCaeRcInénBiPBttiyelaksEmþg[eXIj enAeBlEdlBYkeK)anCYb

RbeTsTaMgenaHCaelIkdMbUgbg¥s; k¾b:uEnþ EbrCaRtÚveFVI[PJak;ep¥IledaykarmincUlcitþrbs;shPaB

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg208

Page 219: Brother enemy

sUevoteTAvij. enAeBlRtLb;BIkULúMbUmkvij g:U eDon )anniyayGaf’kM)aMgR)ab;CnkumµúynIsþGuItalI

mñak;fa ³ «BYksUevotnwgRtÚveFVIGVI²CaeRcIneTot edIm,IEklMGrUbPaBCanimitþrUbrbs;xøÜn»25.

enAExkBaØa qñaM1976 RkúghaNUyRtÚv)anTTYl[cUlCasmaCikGgÁkarrUbiyvtßúGnþrCati

ehIyenAExmkra qñaM1977 )anTTYl\NTanmYycMnYn36landuløar. RbeTsevotNamCardæsgÁm

niymdMbUgeKEdl)ancUlCasmaCikGgÁkarrUbiyvtßúGnþrCati EdltamRkúgmUsÁÚfaCa«]bkrN_sMxan;

bMputrbs;cRkBtþiniymsRmab;eFVIGaCIvkmµelIbNþaRbeTsEdlkMBugrIklUtlas;»26.

tamkarBit RkúgmUsÁÚ Rkúgeb:kaMgnigRbeTssgÁmniymÉeTot²EdlsßitenAedayELkBIGgÁkar

rUbiyvtßúGnþrCati KWsRmab;ehtuplmYyepSgeTot. bNþardæCasmaCik RtÚvbgðajGgÁkarrUbiyvtßú

GnþrCatiBIsmtulüéntulükarEpñkesdækic©nigcMnYnTwkR)ak;énrUbiyb½NÑbRmúgrbs;xøÜn KWdUcbgðaj[

sRtÚvdwgBIkarsm¶at;rbs;rdæG‘Ícwg¡. dUcEdleKKitTukCamun BYksUevotminePøcnwgriHKn;karcUlCa

smaCikenHeLIy. b:uEnþ enAeBlEdlBYkeKdwgBIbTbBaØtiTaMgLayénkarvinieyaKrbs;breTsEdl

eRKagkaredayRkúghaNUy ehIyedaykarTTUc[BYkvinieyaKinelakxagliccUlmkrksuI BYksUevot

)ancab;epþImminTukcitþBIkartRmg;TisEpñkmenaKmviC¢arbs;evotNamPøam. GñkkarTUtsUevotenA

RkúghaNUyminniyayGVITaMgGs; edIm,IbiT)aMgkareXñIscitþrbs;eK edayvinicä½yCamunBIbraC½yén

karsakl,gksaglT§isgÁmniymCamYyR)ak;rbs;bNþaRbeTselakxaglicenH. GñkkarTUtsUevot

mñak;)ankt;smÁal;R)ab;shPatr³\NÐamñak;enATIRkúghaNUyCamYykarcMGkrEdlElgRcLMfa ³

«eyIgFøab;dwgehIy GVIEdlBYkyUehÁasøavIBwgelIkarvinieyaKrbs;bs©imRbeTs»27.

karGak;Gn;citþrbs;BYksUevot)anekIneLIgEfmeTotenAeBlEdlRbeTsevotNamRbkasBI

karbdiesFrbs;xøÜnmincUlCasmaCikRkúmRbwkSasgÁhesdækic©b¤GgÁkarkUem:kug (COMECON : Council for

Mutual Economic Assiatance). enAedImqñaM1977 GñkkarTUtevotNammñak;)anR)ab;erOgs¶at;kM)aMg[

´dwgfa ³ «BYksUevot)anekobsgát;[RbeTssgÁmniymTaMgGs;cUlCasmaCikGgÁkarkUem:kug. b:uEnþ

eRkABIRbeTsKuy)a KµanRbeTsminEmnGWr:ubNamYycUlrYmeLIy ehIyeyIgk¾minmanbMNgcUl

dUcKña. eyIgnwgeFVI[BYkcinGak;Gn;citþ»28.

enArdUvekþAqñaM1976 BYksUevothak;dUcCae)aHbg;ecalminksageragcRksøEdkEfbmYy

bBa©ÚlCamYyKñanwgeragcRkplitkaMePøIgFMenARbeTsevotNameLIy. edayKµankakFüÚgfµnigKµanEr:

EdkRKb;RKan;-vtßúTaMgGs;enHEdlRbeTsevotNamxVH-PøamenaH BYksUevotR)ab;fa sMeNIenHBuMsm

RsbeT. karpÁt;pÁg;eRKÓgbnøas;sRmab;kgT½BmansPaByWty:av ehIykardæanksagTMnb;varIGKÁisnI

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 209

Page 220: Brother enemy

EdlebIksem<aFedaysUevotelITenøda enAevotNamxageCIg tamkarBitKWKµanskmµPaBeFVIGVITaMg

Gs;. edIm,Ibgðaj[eXIjkarekþARkhayrbs;xøÜn RkúghaNUy)anGnum½tmaRtamYyénKeRmagenH

edayminbBa©ÚlBYksUevotpgeT. evotNam)ancab;epþImeRKagKitBIlT§PaBebIkkardæansagsg;TMnb;

varIGKÁisnItamKeRmagrbs;xøÜn. kñúgeKaledAenHBYkeK)anepþImsÞabsÞg;eyabl;FnaKarGPivDÆn_

GasuInigbNþaRbeTselakxaglicedays¶at;kM)aMgedIm,Isakl,gbBa¢ak;BIkarCYyeRCamERCgEpñk

hirBaØvtßúEdlRtÚvkarxanmin)an. KN³ebskkmµesdækic©rbs;GU®sþalI Edlsñak;GaRs½ymYyry³

enARbeTsevotNamnadMNac;qñaM1976)anPJak;ep¥IlkñúgcitþBIPaBc,as;las;énbBaðaepSg²rbs;

KUsnÞnaxÜønGMBItémøénkarsßabnaTMnb;varIGKÁisnImYyRbePTdUcTMnb;varIGKÁisnIEdlkMBugmanskmµPaBenA

RbeTsGU®sþalIEdr. evotNamBuMmanniyayBIerOgenHEfmeToteT b:uEnþ Cak;c,as;Nas;fa BYkeK

kMBugEsVgrkGñkCMhrecjR)ak;fµImñak;eTot. rwtEtecjmuxCagenHeTot BYkeK)anRbwgERbgEsVgrk

karpþl;hirBaØvtßúmYypgEdr sRmab;CMnYsKeRmagsagsg;eragcRksøEdkEfbEdle)aHbg;ecal

edayBYksUevot. CasaFarN³ BYkeKecosvagmineFVIGtßaFib,ayTaMgGs;sþIBIkare)aHbg;KñaÉgrbs;

rusSI b:uEnþ BYkeK)anbgÁab;[eFVIkarsikSamYyEdlGaceFVI)anenARkWhSÚt_-L½r (Creusot-Loire)29.

RbeTsevotNam)anrMB£kBYksUevotfa xøÜnRtÚvkarCMnYymYyPøam²munnwgepþImshRbtibtþikar

eBjeljCamYybøúksgÁmniymnigbMeBjtRmÚvkarepSg²edaybegáInkarnaMecjrbs;xøÜneTAkan;

shPaBsUevot eTaHbICaenAExkkáda qñaM1976 GñkTTYlxusRtÚvxagEpnkarrbs;evotNam eL faj;gI

EdlRtLb;BIdMeNIrd¾yUrmYyenARkúgmUsÁÚ nig Eb‘rLaMgxagekItKµan)anTTYlGVIbnþicesaHk¾eday30.

RtÚveFVI[mYem:AedaykarxVHes,ógGaharnigvtßúFatuedIm eRBaHEtkarnaMecjy:agsem,ImeTAkan;

shPaBsUevotsRmab;RTRTg;karnaMcUlrbs;xøÜn evotNam)anbgðaj[eXIjCaerOy²nUvkarmin

sb,aycitþrbs;eKcMeBaHRkúgmUsÁÚ tamry³karRBmanrbs;GñkTTYlxusRtÚvenAeRkam»vaTxøÜn. enAEx

kBaØa qñaM1976 TsSnavdþIEpñkRTwsþIrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNameQµaH Hoc Tap )anCMruj[«KitKUrBI

karpøas;bþÚrepSg²EdlekItmanedayécdnükñúgkareFVIshRbtibtþikarCaGnþrCati ehIyelImUldæanenH

RtÚvykcitþTukdak;EfmeTotGMBIneya)ayxøÜn]btßmÖxøÜnedayxøÜnÉg nigkarbegáInplitplsRmab;naM

ecj»31. CaCMnYskartbvijPøam² evotNam)ankat;bnßyTIRbwkSaeyaFasUevotmYycMnYn.

bnÞab;BImhasnñi)atbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamenAExFñÚ qñaM1976 cMnYnenH)anfycuHBI80mk40nak;

bnÞab;mkenAExemsa qñaM1977 sl;Et25nak;b:ueNÑaH. cMnYnTwkR)ak;RbcaMqñaMénCMnYyeyaFarbs;

sUevotmk[evotNam)anFøak;cuHedayeLIgminelIsBI 20landuløareLIy. TMnak;TMngepSg²rvag

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg210

Page 221: Brother enemy

sUevot-evotNam)anfmfy kñúgeBlEdlGñkkarTUtsUevotEdlbMeBjmuxgarenARkúghaNUy

cab;epþImsEmþgPaBeTamnsSCacMhBI«PaBrmilKuNrbs;evotNam». enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1977

GñkkarTUtGasuImñak;)anRtÚveFVI[PJak;ep¥Il EdlsmÁal;eXIjBYksUevotP½yxøacNas;ERkgRbeTs

evotNamcUlxagbøúkmUlFnniym. CaBiessRbeTsCb:un k¾eFVI[BYksUevotRBWxøacEdr. BYksUevot

ERkgrEGgfa RbeTsevotNam -CamYyvtßúFatuedImnigTIpSarkñúgRbeTsrbs;xøÜn- muxCaCYyeFVI[

RbeTsCb:unrwgmaMEfmeTot EdlCaKURbECgminEmnkumµúynIsþsMxan;bMputrbs;eKenAGasuIxagekIt.

mü:ageTot karsHCanwgKñarvagRbeTsTaMgBIrk¾bNþal[mankarP½yxøacfa RbeTsevotNamEdl

Gt;RTaMBuM)annwgkarTak;TajmUlFn nigbec©kviC¢arbs;bs©imRbeTsmuxCaminEbrmkrksm<n§mitþsgÁm

niymrbs;xøÜnvijeLIy32.

enAcugqñaM1976 evotNam)anbM)at;\riyabfEdleFVI[BYksUevotxkcitþ edayykcitþTukdak;

beBa©jTsSnvis½yd¾rugerOgrbs;elakxaglic[eXIjvij. karcrcaepSg²)anbnþsþIBIyfaPaBén

karpþl;CMnYyEpñkesdækic©mYyrbs;Cb:un. enATIRkúghaNUy nigTIRkúg):arIs karerobcMRbúgeRbób

epSg²éndMeNIrTsSnkic©CapøÚvkarrbs; paM v:an;dug eTAkan;RbeTs)araMgkMBugRbRBwtþeTAy:agmmajwk.

enAExkkáda qñaM1976 pan; ehon Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam )aneFVIdMeNIrRbkbedayEpøpáamYy

tambNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþenAGasuIPaKGaeKñy_. enAExtula shrdæGaemrik)anesñIcab;epþIm

eFVIkarRbCuMedIm,IcrcaCamYyRbeTsevotNam. enATIbMput C½yCmñHrbs;elak hSImmI xaF½r kñúgkar

eRCIserIsRbFanaFibtI)anbegáIt[manbriyakasTukcitþnigesckþIsgÇwmfµImYyenATIRkúghaNUy. KWkñúg

bribTGnueRKaHenHehIy EdlbNþal[ paM v:an;dug eFVIepÁInbM)ak;muxÉkGKÁrdæTUtsUevot CasaFarN³

kñúg»kasénkareFVIbdisNæarkic©kñúgBiFIbuNürMlwkxYbbdivtþn_ExtulaenaH.

s‘UsøÚv ecjdMeNIr

GFikrN_CamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ)anERbeTACarwtEtCak;EsþgEfmeTotenAkñúg»kasmhasnñi)atbkS

BlkrevotNamelIkTI4 naExFñÚ qñaM1976 EdlRtÚvRbsiT§namfµIenAeBlenaHfa bkSkumµúynIsþevot

Nam. db;R)aMmYyqñaM)anknøgeTAtaMgBImhasnñi)atcugeRkay. edayrYmRbCuMedIm,IkMNt;edayc,as;

las;nUvmaKa’neya)ayCapøÚvkarénRbCaCatimYy EdlGMNwHteTArYbrYmKñaEtmYy mhasnñi)atenH

)anbgðajCafµInUvrbt;d¾sMxan;mYykñúgCIvPaBneya)ayrbs;RbeTs nigbeBa©j[eXIjbuBVehtuén

karcg;)anÉkraCürbs;xøÜny:agxøaMg. eTaHbICamankarekobsgát;rbs;RkúgmUsÁÚmþgehIymþgeTot

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 211

Page 222: Brother enemy

k¾eday k¾evotNambdiesFminGeBa¢Ij«RkúmsiT§sUevot»mYyKWclnakumµúynIsþ\NÐa EdleBlenaH

kMBugEbk)ak;KñaEdr. BYkeKeBjcitþGeBa¢IjRkúmmincUlbkSsm<½n§ mYyeRkameQµaHfa bkSkumµúynIsþ

\NÐa¬m:akSniym¦Cag eRBaHRkúmenHriHKn; TaMgRkúgmUsÁÚTaMgRkúgeb:kaMg. BYkeK)anRBmeRBógKña

GeBa¢IjbkSkumµúynIsþcinEdr b:uEnþtaMgBImanbdivtþn_vb,Fm’ BYkcin)ankMNt;TukdUcCaeKalkarN_min

eTAcUlrYmkñúgmhasnñi)atbkSkumµúynIsþbreTsnanaeLIy. vtþmanrbs;BYksUevotBuMecaTCabBaðaeT.

b:uEnþ KN³RbtiPUrbs;sUevotEdldwknaMedayelak mIxaGuIl s‘UsøÚv GñkmenaKmviC¢arbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ

shPaBsUevotnwgRtÚvGnueRKaH[GgÁúyenAEb:kxagmuxevTika. dUcKN³RbtiPUsUevotEdr BYkkumµúynIsþ

)araMgnigGuItalIk¾RtÚvpþl;siT§iBiesseday[sñak;enAPUmiRKwHdac;edayELkBIeK eTaHbICaRkúgmUsÁÚecaT

faCakarniymlT§ikumµúynIsþGWr:ub pÞúyBIlT§iEdleKniymTUeTAk¾eday.

briyakaseTACamansPaBtantwgPøam. s‘UsøÚv )ansakl,gbBa©úHbBa©Úl eL yn; cMnYnbIdg[eFVI

smahr½NRbeTsevotNameTAkñúgbøúksUevot b:uEnþ\t)anpl. edayeRbIkarekobsgát;CasaFarN³

kñúgsnÞrkfamYyEdlEføgenAcMeBaHmuxmhasnñi)at s‘UsøÚv )anesñI[evotNamcUlCasmaCikGgÁkar

kUem:kugedayminbeBa©jeQµaHcMeLIy. Kat;GHGagfa «vamanlT§PaBfµI²CaeRcIn EdlKYrBicarNa

kñúgkareFVI[shRbtibtþiEpñkesdækic©rvagbNþaRbeTssgÁmniym[rwtEtsuICeRmAeLIg»33. bNþa

KN³RbtiPUGaløWm:g;xagekIt b:ULÚj nig eqkUsøÚv:aKI )anGHGagRtg;²Etmþg ³ «kñúgkarbBa©b;karksag

lT§isgÁmniym karcUlCasmaCikGgÁkarkUem:kug nigkareFVIsm½<n§PaBEdlminGacsabsUnüCamYy

shPaBsUevot KWCameFüa)ayEdlminGacCMnYs)an».

eKmin)anseRmcQandl;karsRmbsRmÜlNamYyeT. edIm,IbgðajBIkarGak;Gn;citþrbs;xøÜn

s‘UsøÚv )anbMRBÜjkarsñak;enA ehIyvilRtLb;eTARkúgmUsÁÚvijtamynþehaHpÞal;xøÜnrbs;Kat; munkarbiT

mhasnñi)ateTAeTot. kñúgry³eBlR)aMmYyExbnÞab;mk RbeTsevotNam)anTTYlrgPaBCUrct;BI

kMhwgrbs;sUevotcMeBaHkarsakl,grbs;xøÜnenH. CMnYyEdlsnüapþl;[enAqñaM1975 manry³eBl

yUrxusEbøkBIFmµta eTIb)anmkdl;RbeTsevotNam. enHCaPaBKab;CYnd¾cEmøk eRBaHenAExemsa

qñaM1977 kñúgeBlEdl paM v:an;dug eRtómxøÜncab;epþImdMeNIrelIkdMbUgrbs;Kat;eTAkan;GWr:ubxaglic

BYksUevot)anbBaÄb;ElgRbKl;mk[RbeTsevotNamnUvkarpÁt;pÁg;vtßúcaM)ac;epSg² EdlRbeTs

CatiRtÚvkarCaxøaMg. ]sSahkmµFunkNþalrbs;xøÜn )anTTYlrgkarxVHeRKÓgpÁt;pÁg;BIrmuxmYyKWeRbg

\n§n³ EdlshPaBsUevotCaGñkpþl;[d¾sMxan; ehIyBIrKW eRKÓgbnøas;epSg².

GñkkarTUtsUevotmñak; EdlbMeBjkargarenARkúghaNUy)anniyaycMGkLkLWyedaykar

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg212

Page 223: Brother enemy

sb,ayrIkrayenAmuxsmPaKI\NÐamñak;fa «evotNamqab;Gn;citþNas;cMeBaHerOgEdleKkMBugniyay

GMBIÉkraCürbs;xøÜn RbeTsenHmuxCaecosminputBIbraC½yeLIy. esdækic©rbs;eKRsutcuH. val¥

Nas;EdlniyayBIÉkraCü b:uEnþsRmab;´ ´nwgeFVIGVImYyvijvaRbesIrCag»34. vibtþiesdækic©man

sPaBrwtEtdundabeTA² bBaðaepSg²xagneya)aykarbreTsekIneLIgkan;EteRcInehIyBYksUevot

hak;dUcCaseRmccitþ «TukRbeTsevotNam[sßitenAkñúgsßanPaBBi)ak»Etmñak;Ég.

kñúgGMLúgeBleFVIs®gÁam GgárRtÚv)anpþl;[edayRbeTscinedayminKitluy ¬rhUtdl;25mWun

etan¦ EdlGnuBaØat[evotNamecosputBIkarxVHes,ógGahar. cMENkevotNamxagt,Úgk¾TTYl

CMnYyGaemrikaMgrebobdUcKñaEdr. RbeTsevotNamEdlmincMNuHGñkNa BuMTTYl)ankarCYyeRCam

ERCgdUecñHeT. RbeTscin)anbBaÄb;karpþl;CMnYyrbs;xøÜnenAqñaM1975. enAeBlEdlevotNam

RtLb;EbreTArkRkúgmUsÁÚ sUevot)anGHGagnwgevotNamfa «CMnYyxages,ógGahar» nwggayTTYl

)anRsYlCagmun ebIsinRbeTsevotNamcUlCasmaCikGgÁkarkUem:kug.

snþisuxpÞal;rbs;xøÜncab;epþImeFVI[RbeTsevotNamRBÜy)armÖpgEdr cab;taMgBIedImqñaM1977.

TMnak;TMngepSg²CamYyRbeTskm<úCa)anTTYlrgnUvkarFøak;cuHminQb;Qr. enAExkumÖ³ h½g v:an;L

Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs)aneFVIdMeNIrCasm¶at;mkkan;RkúgPñMeBj edIm,IesñIeFVIkarRbCuMkMBUlmYyrvag

RbeTs\NÐÚcin b:uEnþ\t)ankar. enARbeTskm<úCa karkm©at;CnCatiPaKticevotNam nigkarsmøab;

smasPaBCnTaMgLayEdlsgS½yfamansmancitþnwgRkúghaNUy)ancab;epþImenAExemsa EdlenH

CasBaØadMbUgénkarvayRbharedayRTg;RTayFMrbs;ExµrRkhmenAtamRBMEdnevotNam. enARbeTs

Lav manRkúmRbqaMgkumµúynIsþCaeRcIn)anXubXitKñaRbqaMgnwgrdæaPi)al):aeftLavCasm<n§miRtrbs;

evotNam enAeBlEdlRbeTséfenArkSaTukkarraMgxÞb;Epñkesdækic©mYyRbqaMgnwgRbeTsenHEdl

CaRbeTsKµanpøÚvecjeTAsmuRT. enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1977 esckþIsgÇwmkñúgkarpSHpSaCamYyRbeTs

cinrwtEtfycuHEfmeTot. enAExkumÖ³ Rkúgeb:kaMg)aneqøIytbedaykarbdiesFsMeNIsuMCMnYyrbs;

RkúghaNUy nigesñI[BiPakSaeLIgvijBIkRmgekaHnanaenAsmuRTcinxagt,Úg edayGHGagCaCa

saFarN³BIkarTamTarTwkdIrbs;xøÜnnigbdiesFkarcrca. karrvaMgRby½tñ)anbgçM[evotNameRtóm

xøÜnTb;Tl;edaykmøaMgeyaFaCaeRsc.

bnÞab;BIbraC½yrbs;xøÜn kgT½Brbs;RbFanaFibtI FIv )anTukCamrtk[RbeTsevotNamnUv

brimaNeRKÓgsBVavuFGaemrikaMgd¾sn§wksn§ab;. edayKµaneRKÓgbnøas; nigedayKµanbuKÁlikEdlman

smtßPaBEfTaM eRKÓgGavuFTaMgGs;nwgxUcxatElgeRbIkar)any:agqab;rh½s. edaycitþesµaHb¤eday

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 213

Page 224: Brother enemy

ehtupl evotNamKitfa shPaBsUevotCaRbeTsEtmYyKt; EdlxøÜnRtÚvEbreTArk edIm,ITTYl)an

smÖarswkFunF¶n; nigkarbNþúHbNþalxagkgT½B.

RbwgERbgEklMGTMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYybs©imRbeTs[)anRbesIrCagmun KWCaerOg

mYy b:uEnþ RbeTsevotNamRtÚvEtTTYlsÁal;fa xøÜnElgGacbeNþay[TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜn

CamYyRkúgmUsÁÚFøak;cuHeTotehIy. tfPaBxagPUmisa®sþ PaBcaM)ac;xagesdækic©nigeyaFa EdlsMxan;

esµIGayuCIvit )anCMrujeTArkkarpSHpSaCananwgKñaeLIgvij. b:uEnþ RkúgmUsÁÚBuMEmnCaGñkcuHj:menAmux

KUsRtÚv ehIyevotNamk¾minmanbMNgnwgGgVrsUmeTasrusSIEdr. eTaHCay:agNa karpþÜcepþImKMnit

kñúgkarpSHpSaedayrebob\tex©aHnigeBjeljenH EbrCaFøak;mkelI dug rebobbBaÄWeTAvijEdl

kalBIR)aMExmun KWKat;enHÉgEdl)aneFVIkarbBaÄWcitþÉkGKÁrdæTUtsUevotCasaFarN³.

BYksUevot)andak;karekobsgát; edIm,InwgeFVI[karsñak;GaRs½yrbs; dug enARbeTs)araMgRtÚv

kat;bnßymkRtwmbIéf¶ EdltamkareRKagTukBIdMbUgKWbIs)þah_ 35. edayehtuenH dMbUgKat;)anQb;

enARkúgmUsÁÚkñúgry³eBlR)aMéf¶ eTIbbnþdMeNIreq<aHeTAkan;Rkúg):arIs bnÞab;mk vilRtLb;mksñak;enA

shPaBsUevotmYyExeTot EdlnwgelceLIg[eXIjrbt;CaRbvtþisa®sþmYyénRbeTsevotNam

sm½yfµI. dUecñH munnwgeFVIdMeNIreTAkan;TIRkúg):arIs dug )anCYbCamYyelak GaLicsuI kusSIúhÁIn Edl

)anBiPakSaKñaBI «bBaðaplRbeyaCn_rYm». karTTYlbdisNæarkic©KWmanlkçN³xVHPaBkk;ekþA.

zannþrskþimFüménm®nþITaMgLayEdlCUndMeNIr dug eTAGakasyandæaneBlKat;ecjdMeNIreTARkúg

):arIsenAéf¶TI25 Exemsa CasBaØabgðaj[dwgBIkarminsb,aycitþrbs;shPaBsUevotehIy.

«enAeBleKpwkTwk eKminRtÚvePøcRbPBeT»

enAedImEx]sPa qñaM1977 dug )anRtLb;mkshPaBsUevotvij. karsñak;GaRs½yd¾yUr

rbs;Kat;enATIenaH enAEtruMB½T§edayGaf’kM)aMgCanic©. enAeBlEdlKat;elcmuxCafµI enAéf¶TI6 Exmifuna

edIm,ICYb eLGUnIt eRbseNv GVI²EdlbiT)aMgmin[eXIj )aneFVI[karsgS½yrlayGs;. RbeTs

evotNamnigshPaBsUevot hak;dUcCabgðaj[eXIjnUvkarRsuHRsYlKñaCafµI. eK)andwgBIsßanPaB

TaMgLay nigtémøénkarCananwgKña EtenAeBlEdlmñak;²eFVIkarbkRsayBIehtukarN_epSg²rbs;xøÜn

b:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþ tamB½t’manbnþicbnþÜcEdleKmanrYcmkehIy vac,as;Nas;fa PaBkan;EtF¶n;F¶rénvibtþi

esdækic© nigbraC½yénneya)aysMueFVIkarcrcarbs;xøÜnenHehIy EdlrujRbeTsevotNam[Føak;eTA

kñúgédRkúgmUsÁÚenaH36.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg214

Page 225: Brother enemy

edaytamdantaMgBIRkúgmUsÁÚ cMeBaHkarRbRBwtþeTAénkarcrcaKñaenARkúg):arIssþIBIkareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBrvag pan; ehon nig rIqad hUlRb‘Úk ¬éf¶TI3 nig TI4 Ex]sPa¦ ehIyTTYlbraC½y)aneFVI[ dug

q¶l;RsLaMgkaMg. rdæaPi)alelak xaF½r )aneFVI[esckþIsgÇwmTaMgb:unµanrbs;evotNamrlayGs;.

enAéf¶TI5 Ex]sPa sPaCan;Tabrbs;Gaemrik)ane)aHeqñateFVIviesaFnkmµc,ab; EdlhamXat;kar

BiPakSaTaMgGs;CamYyRbeTsevotNam dUcCa«karsgkarxUtxatedaysars®gÁam CMnYyb¤TRmg;xøH²

énviPaKTanxaghirBaØvtßúeTaHCaTRmg;EbbNak¾eday». dMNwgminl¥epSg²)aneTAdl;RkúghaNUy

y:ageRcIn. kñúgraRtIéf¶TI30 Exemsa ExµrRkhm)anebIkeFVIkarvayRbhary:agFMmYyRbqaMgnwgPUmi

nanarbs;evotNamenACab;RBMEdnkm<úCa. eL DwkfU GñkÉkeTsneya)aykarbreTsd¾eqñIménkari-

yal½yneya)aybkSkumµúynIsþevotNam)aneFVIdMeNIreTATIRkúgmUsÁÚCasm¶at;. Kat;nwgcUlrYm

CamYy dug kñúgkarBiPakSad¾sMxan;sRmab;GnaKténTMnak;TMngrbs;RbeTsTaMgBIr. GñkkarTUténbNþa

RbeTsGWr:ubxagekItEdlbMeBjmuxgarenARkúghaNUy enATIbMputk¾Tmøay[dwgB½t’manepSg²sþIBI

TsSnkic©sm¶at;enHrbs; fU nigkarsnÞnad¾yUrenATIRkúgmUsÁÚEdr. R)aMmYyqñaMeRkaymk m®nþICan;x<s;

sUevotmñak;)anniyayGaf’kM)aMgR)ab;´fa ³ «karCYbKñad¾muWgm:at;CahUrEhmYy BitCaekItmanenARkúg

mUsÁÚ kñúgEx]sPanigmifunaEmn ehIykarCYbKñaenH )anebIk»kas[mankarxitcUlCitKñamYy rvag

RbeTsevotNam nigshPaBsUevot. k¾b:uEnþ Kat;bdiesFminsnµtfa karERbRtLb;rbs;evotNam

enHCakarTTYledayKMeraHKMerIyrbs;GaemrikaMgeT. ebItameKniyayfa KWRbeTscin nigkarKMram

kMEhgrbs;km<úCaeT EdleFVI[evotNamseRmccitþEbbenaH. t,itGIbBaðaenHenABuMTan;edaHRsay

rYcral;eT ³ etICMhrrbs;evotNamcMeBaHRbeTskm<úCanwgmanEbbNa?. enAeBlEdl´sYrKat;fa

enAeBlenaHebIemdwknaMrbs;evotNamesñI[BYksUevotBinitüBIKMniténkareFVIsn§isBaØaCamYyRbeTsLav

Kat;)anpþl;cemøIyEdlmanbgáb;Gaf’kM)aMgenHmk´vijfa ³ «vaBitCaFmµtaEdlRbeTsevotNamRtÚv

BieRKaHCamYyshPaBsUevotsþIBIbBaðamYyEdlmansarsMxan;EbbenH».

eTaHCaxøwmsarénkarsnÞnaenARkúgmUsÁÚmanGVIxøHk¾eday/ k¾karxitcUlCitKñarvagRbeTsevot

Nam nigbøúksUevot )anecjCalT§plc,as;las;bMput. enAcugEx]sPa RbeTsevotNam )an

køayeTACasmaCikrbs;FnaKarGnþrCatiEpñkshRbtibtþikaresdækic© nigFnaKarGnþrCatiEpñkvinieyaK

Edl]btßmÖedayshPaBsUevot bnÞab;BIxøÜn)ancUlCasmaCikGgÁkarkUem:kugCaelIkdMbUg. enAéf¶TI6

Exmifuna KWbYnéf¶bnÞab;BIbraC½yénkarcrcarvagGaemrik-evotNamvKÁTIBIrenATIRkúg):arIs paM v:an;dug

)anCYb eRbseNv tampøÚvkar. tamsarB½t’manrbs;sUevot)an[dwgfa PaKITaMgBIr)ankt;smÁal;

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 215

Page 226: Brother enemy

«edaykareBjcitþEdlneya)ayGnþrCatiniymrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþTaMgBIr )anrYmviPaKTanCYyBRgwg

mitþPaBrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr[rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgEfmeTot». cab;BIéf¶enHeTARkúgmUsÁÚElgniyayBI

RbeTsevotNamCamYyPaBRceLateTotehIy edayrMB£kBI«sarsMxan;esµIGayuCIviténshRbti

btþikarRKb;Ebby:agrvagshPaBsUevotnigRbeTsevotNam»vij. dUcCanimµit bMBg;bgðÚreRbgEdl

rIgsܶt)ancab;epþImhUreLIgvij. enAcugExmifuna KWmYyExbnÞab;BIkarsnÞnadMbUg² enATIRkúgmUsÁÚ eL

faj;gI )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;rdæFanIrbs;sUevotCafµI. rusSI)ansnüapþl;[Kat; nUv«\NTansMxan;²

Edlpþl;nUvPaBgayRsYldl;karsgbMNul»vij edIm,IpÁt;pÁg;hirBaØvtßúcMeBaHkardæanEssibkEnøg

EdlRkúgmUsÁÚyl;RBmsßabnaenARbeTsevotNam. BYksUevot)anRbkas[dwgBIkarseRmccitþ

«begáInel,Ónkñúgkarpþl;TMnij]sSahkmµrbs;xøÜn»pgEdr. gI Edlsb,ayrIkrayxøaMg)anRbkasfa

karcrcaenARkúgmUsÁÚ )anTTYlEpøpáaRbkbeday«eCaKC½yy:agFMeFgmYy» ehIyfa kic©RBmeRBóg

EdlcuHhtßelxaseRmc KWCa«P½sþútagCak;EsþgénsamKÁIPaB mitþPaBnigshRbtibtþikarCabgb¥Ún»

rvagRbeTsTaMgBIr37.

KµanGVImanPaBCanimitþrUbd¾KYr[cab;GarmµN_énkarEbrRtLb;CayuT§sa®sþrbs;evotNamRbesIr

CagkarGeBa¢IjkgT½BsUevoteTATsSnkic©enAPaKxagt,ÚgeLIy. taMgBImYyqñaMknøHmkehIy evotNam

)anCMTas;minRBmTTYlkaresñIsuMebIksßankugs‘ulTaMgGs;rbs;sUevotnigcin enATIRkúghUCImij. k¾b:uEnþ

enAcugExkkáda KN³RbtiPUsUevotmYyEdlmansmaCikémÖmYynak; )aneTAdl;TIRkúgdaNagCasm¶at;

RbEhlenHCaplénkarsnÞnakalBIEx]sPa-mifunaenARkúgmUsÁÚehIyemIleTA. eTaHy:agNa

k¾eday k¾kareFVIdMeNIrenHRtÚvruMB½T§edayPaBGaf’kM)aMgbMput. ynþehaHFunGuIlIyUQIn62 CaeRcIn

eRKÓg)anehaHeTAcuHctenAdaNagedaypÞal; edIm,IecosBIRkúghaNUy nigkarsmøwgemIlrebobcg;

dwgerOgeKrbs;GñkkarTUt. b:uEnþ BYksUevotmancitþsb,ayrIkrayy:agxøaMgcMeBaHesckþIBüayam

rbs;xøÜn EdldMNwgenH)anelcB¤sussayy:agqab;rh½skñúgmCÄdæanGñkkarTUtenATIRkúghaNUy.

TsSnkic©eRkApøÚvkarenH)ankMNt;nUvkarcab;epþImTMnak;TMngCafµI EdlBIrqñaMeRkaymk)annaMeTAdl;kareFVI

sm<n§PaBEpñkeyaFamYyeTAtampøÚvc,ab;eTot. KN³RbtiPUEdlkñúgenaHmantMNagkgT½BTaMgbIRbePT

)anedIrBinitüemIlenAdaNag qksmuRTkaMraj; j:aRtag nigkEnøgEdlmanplRbeyaCn_xag

yuT§sa®sþCaeRcInkEnøgeTotenAPaKxagt,Úg. KN³RbtiPURbEhlCa)anvaytémøBIesckþIRtÚvkar

EpñkeyaFarbs;RbeTsevotNamsRmab;ry³eBldb;qñaMxagmuxpgEdr. BYksUevot)ancMNayeBl

evlakñúgkarRsavRCavCaelIkdMbUgmYynUv]bkrN_eyaFarbs;GaemrikaMg EdlrwbGUs)aneday

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg216

Page 227: Brother enemy

evotNamRbEhlRKan;EtedIm,Ivaytémø BIskþanuBlEpñkBaNiC¢kmµrbs;GavuFTaMgenaHb:ueNÑaH.

cab;BIExtula RbeTsevotNam)ancab;epþImRbKl;rfynþm:akGaemrikaMgsRmab;dwkCBa¢ÚnT½BCaeRcIn

eRKÓgeTA[RbeTseGtüÚBI EdlCam:UyGavuFfµIrbs;RkúgmUsÁÚ tamkarpþÜcepþImKMnitrbs;RkúghaNUy

b¤karsRmbsRmÜlCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ. bnÞab;BITsSnkic©rbs;KN³RbtiPUeyaFasUevot RkúgmUsÁÚ)an

yl;RBmpþl;[RbeTsevotNamnUvnavamuCTwkFunCMnMBIreRKÓg navaBiXatBIreRKÓg naval,atCaeRcIn

eRKÓg nigynþehaHRbedjTmøak;RKab;Ebkmic-21bYnkg. cMnYnTIRbwkSaeyaFarbs;sUevotenA

RbeTsevotNam Edlkat;bnßyKµanERbRbÜltaMgBIqñaM1976)anekIneLIgCafµI kñúgeKalbMNg

bNþúHbNþalevotNam[ecHeRbIeRKÓgsBVavuFnigynþehaHTaMgLayEdlBYkeKeTIbnwgTTYl. enAcug

qñaM1978 eKdwgfa cMnYnTIRbwkSaeyaFasUevotenARbeTsevotNamman600nak;. cMnYnTwkR)ak;én

CMnYyeyaFarbs;sUevot)aneLIgdl;75landuløar38.

minyUrb:unµan RkúghaNUy)anepþImeFVIyuT§nakarsÞabsÞg;cemøIykñúgcMeNamRbCaCnxøÜn mü:ag

eTotk¾dUckñúgcMeNamsRtÚvrbs;xøÜnEdr sþIBIGtßn½yénkarBRgwgcMNgTak;TgmitþPaBrbs;xøÜnCamYy

RkúgmUsÁÚ. BiFIbuNüxYbelIkTI60énbdivtþn_buleqvic )anpþl;[RkúghaNUynUv»kasl¥\tex©aH kñúg

karepþIm «ExmitþPaBmYyrvagevotNam-sUevot». sarB½t’mannigTUrTsSn_)anniyaynigEføgsresIr

BIshPaBsUevotnigCMnYyd¾sb,úrsEdlRbeTsenHpþl;[RbeTsevotNam. kñúgry³eBlEtmYyEx

munBiFIbuNüxYb KN³RbtiPUrbs;sUevotR)aMbIRkúm -taMgBIfñak;]tþmesnIy_rhUtdl;smiTi§krPaBynþ-

)anmkkan;RbeTsevotNamCabnþbnÞab;. smaCikKN³kmµaFikarmCÄimbkSkumµúynIsþshPaBsUevot

mñak;)aneFVIsnñisITenATUTaMgRbeTssþIBIRbFanbTd¾sMxan;énbdivtþn_ buleqvic. edaye)aHbg;nUvkar

RbúgRby½tñEdlCaTmøab;rbs;xøÜncMeBaHRkúgeb:kaMg RkúghaNUy)anlatRtdag[dwgBITsSnkic©énKN³

RbtiPUeyaFasUevotd¾FMmYyEdldwknaMeday]tþmesnIy_ ey:BIesðv RbFankariyal½yneya)ay

kgT½Bnigkgm:arInsUevot. b:uEnþ BYk evotNamBuMniyay[dwgTaMgGs;eT ³ smaCikKN³RbtiPUbYnrUb-

GñkCMnajénkgT½Bm:arIn-)anRtÚvGnuBaØat[eTABinitü qksmuRTkaMr:aj; nigkMBg;Epj:aRtag kñúglkçN³

sm¶at;bMput. BYksUevotmanbMNgBinitüemIl TItaMgnavacrnanaEdlbnSl;TukedayBYkGaemrikaMg[

)anditdl;. BitehIyevotNamenAminTan;beNþay[RkúgmUsÁÚeRbIR)as;TItaMgnavacrTaMgenHeT b:uEnþ

karEdlGnuBaØat[manTsSnkic©enH s[eXIjfa evotNam)anBicarNaBIGtßRbeyaCn_epSg²

EdlBYkeKnwg)anTTYlkñúgkareFVITMenIbkmµRbeTsrbs;xøÜnedayBYksUevoteRsceTAehIy.

enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1977 sarB½t’manrbs;evotNamEdlBuMEdlniyaymYym:at;BIKeRmagCMnYy

xül;TisxagekItmaneRbóbCag 217

Page 228: Brother enemy

epSg²rbs;sUevotesaHenaH enAeBlenH)anKaMRTRkúgmUsÁÚedaykarekatsresIrCaeRcIn. eL yn;

)anEføg[dwgCa]Larikfa «enAeBleKpwkTwk eKminRtÚvePøcRbPBeT». RbPBEdlKat;Eføg[dwgenH KW

shPaBsUevot. kñúgnaménkarKaMRTd¾FMeFgnigminGacvaytémø)an Kat;)ansEmþg[dwgBI «mena

seBa©tnadwgKuNd¾RCaleRCAnigBitR)akd»rbs;Kat;EfmeTot. edayGnuelameTAtamExénkarR)arB§

BiFIenH eL yn; GKÁelxabkSEdlGmdMeNIreday eRTÓg Cij mnusSTIBIrnigCaGñkRTwsþIénkariyal½y

neya)ay)aneLIgynþehaHeq<aHeTAkan;RkúgmUsÁÚ edIm,IcUlrYmBiFIbuNürMlwkxYbGnusSavrIy_bdivtþn_

Extula. mYyqñaMbnÞab;BIBiFIbdisNæarkic©d¾eRkómRkMkñúgcitþenAsNæaKarfaMgL naTIRkúghaNUy TMnak;

TMngepSg²rvagsUevot-evotNam)anvilRtLb;rkcMNucecjdMeNIredayBitR)akd. Baküesøak

mYykñúgcMeNamBaküesøakCaTIsMNBVrbs; em:A esTug KW ³ «xül;xagekItmaneRbóbelIxül;xaglic»

b:uEnþ Rkúgeb:kaMgrkBuMeXIjmUlehtuNamYy[sb,aycitþeT enAeBlEdlTMnayenHelcecj

rUbrageLIgBitR)akdenARbeTsevotNamenaH.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg218

Page 229: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI7PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH

enHCaRKacugeRkaybMputEdl´manbMNgCYbniyaynwgelak sg;d½r hÁIy:UrI CaGñkeqøIyqøgén

TIPñak;garB½t’man M.T.I. rbs;hugRKIenATIRkúghaNUy. b:uEnþ ´Føab;)anCYbburshugRKIrUbenHEdlman

dMeNIrbu½geBoc nigsÁmkMRBwgmþgrYcmkehIy KWenAmunkarrMedaHTIRkúgéRBnKr. enAeBlenaH Kat;CaGñk

karTUt CasmaCikmñak;énKN³RbtiPUhugRKIRbcaMKN³kmµkarGnþrCatixagkarXøaMemIl nigkarRtÜtBinitü

CaGgÁkarctuPaKIEdlbegáIteLIgedayhtßelxIénkic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIs edIm,IBinitüemIlkarGnuvtþn_

bTQb;)aj;Kña. vtþmanrbs; hÁIy:UrI nigGñkkarTUtdéTeToténbøúksUevotenAkNþalebHdUgRkúgéRBnKr

EdlenAeBlenaHRtÚvrujpÞb;[Tal;RckkñúgkarRbyuT§søab;rs;mYyTl;nwglT§ikumµúynIsþ)anrYmbgáCaPaB

cEmøkmYykñúgcMeNamPaBcEmøkCaeRcInrbs;s®gÁam dUcvtþmanrbs;KN³RbtiPUevotNamxageCIgnig

evotkugenAkñúgbrievNB½T§lYsbnøaénmUldæanGakascrtan;sWnjwkCaedIm. KN³RbtiPUenH man

cMENkmYyenAkñúgKN³kmµkareyaFacRmúHEdlbegáIteLIgedaykic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIsEdr. xus

EbøkBIN³RbtiPUevotNamkumµúynIsþ EdlRtÚvbgçaMgkñúgsMNg;beNþaHGasnñ Rbk;s½gásI nigkarBar

edaykgT½B smaCikTaMgLayénKN³RbtiPUhugRKInigb:ULÚjRtÚv)anerobcM[sñak;enAkñúgPUmiRKwHnana

EdlRbkbedaypasukbMput. hÁIy:UrI sñak;enAsNæaKar Gas½Þr sßitenAtampøÚvTuydU cMkNþalTIRkúg

EdlCasgáat;mYymanPaBG‘UGrCageKénTIRkúgéRBnKr. Kat;)aneFVIkarTak;TgCamYyGñkkaEstxøH²

b:uEnþ k¾)ancgmitþPaBCamYybNþasmaCikénKN³RbtiPUevotNamenAtan;sWnjwkpgEdr ehIyBiess

bMput CamYyvresnIy_RtI ¬skþibYn¦ PYg NaM CamnusSFat;duHeBaHnigBak;Ev:nta EdlTTYlbnÞúkTMnak;

TMngCamYyGñkkaEst. CaGñkmanedImkMeNItenAEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁ NaM CamnusSmanlkçN³

rYsrayrak;Tak;nigcUlcitþelgesIc.

b:uEnþ enAéf¶EdleFVI[Qøk;fb;degðImnaExkBaØa qñaM1977enH NaM manlkçN³twgcitþ nigRcas;

Rcal;. kargarrbs;Kat;BuMmanpøas;bþÚreT. Kat;enAEtCasmaCikEpñkB½t’manrbs;kgT½BdEdl. b:uEnþ

cab;BIéf¶enHeTA nayecAhVayrbs;Kat;KWrdæaPi)alEdlbRgÜmEtmYyénRbeTsevotNamenARkúg

hUCImij. kñúgGMLúgeBls®gÁam Kat;Føab;)anqøgkat;karlM)akCaeRcInqñaMenATIRkúghaNUy nigrt;eKc

xøÜnkñúgTIRkúgenHTaMgjab;j½rrn§t;. bnÞab;BIcm,aMgputrlt;Kat;)anseRmccitþmkrs;enAeRkamépÞemX

senþasRbNIénRkúgéRBnKrvij. karTTYlbnÞúkGñkkaEstbreTs KWCacMENkmYykñúgmuxkarrbs;Kat;

219

Page 230: Brother enemy

ehIy NaM RtÚv)anRbKl;ebskkmµemIlEfkarBarGñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manfµIsBa¢atihugRKI EdleTIbeLIg

ynþehaHenATIRkúghaNUykalBIeBlfµI²enHEfmeTot. enAeBlCYbKñadMbUgeFVI[Kat;eBjcitþrYmCUn

dMeNIrmitþcas;nigrMB£kBIGnusSavrIy_l¥² enAmuxdbb‘ÍEyrtUc²Etmþg.

enARBwkéf¶TI26 ExkBaØa kmµviFI)anpøas;bþÚrPøam² NaM )anRtÚvekaHehAeday]tþmesnIy_ Rtan;

v:an;Rta embBa¢akareyaFPUmiPaKTI7EdlrYmmanRkúghUCImij nigbNþaextþPaKxaglicCab;RBMRbTl;nwg

RbeTskm<úCa. elak]tþmesnIy_Føab;dwknaMeFVIkarvaydeNþImkan;kab;RkúgéRBnKredaypÞal; kalBIEx

emsa qñaM1975 Kat;CavIrbursenAPaKxagt,ÚgEdleKsÁal;RKb;Kña. enARBwkenaH Kat;BitCamankMhwg

y:agxøaMg. BIryb;mun kgT½BExµrRkhm)aneLamB½T§vayRbhar extþtaynij edaysmøab;CnsuIvil

Gs;RbmaNmYyrynak;. enHCaelIkTIBIrehIyEdlBYkExµrRkhmebIkkarqµk;vayRbharEdlbNþal

[mnusSsøab;eRcInenARbeTsevotNam edayeRCIserIsvayqµk;Etyb;éf¶esAr_erogral;elIkcMeBl

EdlGñkTTYlxusRtÚvxageyaFaenAtammUldæanTaMgenaHRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[sRmakBIkargar edIm,IeTA

saksYrsuxTukçRKÜsarrbs;BYkeKenATIRkúghUCImij. elIkenH]tþmesnIy_ Rta )anbBa¢a[kgT½Bmñak;²

sßitenAtambu:sþ×rbs;xøÜnnigcab;epþIm[eRtómsmÖarswknigP½sþúParCaeRsc edIm,ITb;Tl;nwgkarqµk;vay

Rbharedaymin[dwgxøÜnmunrbs;ExµrRkhm. Kat;)aneTABinitüemIlPUminanaEdlRtÚvExµrRkhmluk

luybMpøicbMpøajedayxøÜnÉg ehIyEdleFVI[Kat;RBWrn§t;cMeBaHGMeBIéRBépSEdlKat;)aneXIj.

BiPBelakTaMgmUlnwgRtÚvCUndMNwg[dwgBIerOgenH. elak]tþmesnIy_)anesñI[ NaM GmkarBarGñk

kaEsthugRKIrUbenHeTAkan;TIkEnøgepSg²Edlmankarsmøab;Rbhar\tGasUr.

enAresoléf¶c½nÞenH hÁIy:UrI )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;viharkatUlikmYyenAbrievNxageRkATIRkúg

edIm,IeFVIsmÖasbBVCitevotNamEdlniymEkTRmg;mñak;eQµaH can; Tin CaGñkEdlKat;sÁal;rab;Gan

taMgBImunkarrMedaHem:øH. NaM EdlmanGakar³RsBab;RseBan)anedIrcUleTAkñúgPøam edaykat;pþac;kar

eFVIsmÖasn_rbs;Kat; Kat;)ansMuGgVr[ hÁIy:UrI RtLb;eTAsNæaKarKat;vij. hÁIy:UrI nwkq¶l;Etmñak;Égfa

etIsMNYrTaMgLayEdlKat;ecaTsYr can; Tin manlkçN³riHKn;cMeBaHrbbkumµúynIsþRtg;²eBkeTdwg?

enAeBlRtLb;mkdl;sNæaKarvij NaM Edllak;esckþIxøHmin[dwg RKan;EteFVIkarbBa¢ak;y:agxøIfa ³

«sUmelakerobcMGIv:an;sRmab;dMeNIrmYyEdlmanry³eBlBIréf¶».

TsSnkic©mindwgxøÜnmunenH EdlKat;)andwgenARBwkéf¶bnÞab;eBlKat;ecjdMeNIrBIsNæaKar KW)an

naMKat;eTAdl;PUmimYyenAextþtaynij. taMgBIsamsibqñaMmkehIy EdlKat;edIrtamkarbdivtþn_ PYg

NaM manTmøab;nwgTsSnIyPaBmnusSsøab;nigQutqaksahaveXareXAeLIgsuaMeTAehIy. cMENk

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg220

Page 231: Brother enemy

hÁIy:UrI k¾dUcKñaEdr kñúgRkbx½NÐénskmµPaBepSg²rbs;Kat;sRmab;KN³kmµkarGnþrCatixagkarXøaM

emIlnigkarRtÜtBinitü. b:uEnþ mñak;²manKMnitcg;eXIjnUvGVIEdlBYkeKnwgRtÚvemIlenAéf¶enH. kñúgpÞH

nImYy² eBareBjeTAedaysaksBEdlkMBugs¥úyrlYyrayedrdaselIdI saksBburs-®sþI nig

kUnekµgenAlayLMKña xøHRtÚvkat;k,al xøHeTotRtÚvvHeBaH kat;éd-eCIg nigxVHEPñk. mYyqñaMeRkaymk

enAeBlnwkeXIjTsSnIyPaBenH NaM enArkklcg;k¥ÜtenAeLIy. edaykan;m:asuInftCab;éd hÁIy:UrI

)anftBIRKb;RCúgeRCayTaMgGs;y:agCk;citþ. hVIlftrbs;Kat; EdlTijTuk)anRtÚvKat;eRbIesÞIrEt

Gs;. Kat;Kitfa rUbftTaMgenHnwgeFVI[BiPBelakTaMgmUlrMCYljab;j½rkñúgcitþminxan. mü:ageTot Kat;

)aneTACaGñkkaEstbreTsdMbUgEdl)anCYbBYkGtItkmµaPi)alExµrRkhm EdlePosxøÜneTARbeTs

evotNam. kñúgry³eBlénkarsnÞnaPøam² \tRBagTukCamun EdlKat;)aneFVICamYyExµrRkhmxøHkñúg

cMeNamenaHenAtamtMbn;RBMEdn Kat;)ansaksYrykB½t’manBIkarsmøab;mnusSTaMghVÚg²EdleBlenH

kMBugekItmanenARbeTskm<úCapgEdr. eRkaymkKat;)anTTYlsÁal;fa «rhUtmkdl;eBlenH ´

jejItjejImkñúgkarTTYlsÁal;BItfPaBénkarbgðÚrQam BIeRBaHbBaðaenHCabBaðaBisidæ¬b:HBal;min

)an¦rbs;RkúghaNUy. CapøÚvkar TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;RbeTsTaMgBIrmanlkçN³Rss;Rsay nig

RbkbedayPatrPaB». enAeBlenH shesvikevotNamTaMgBYgrbs;Kat;)anetOn[Kat;«pþl;

B½t’manR)ab;saFarNmtiBiPBelak)andwgedayqab;rh½sbMput».

Kat;enABuMTan;Gs;karegOgq¶l;rbs;Kat;eT. eTIbEtRtLb;mkdl;sNæaKarvijminTan;RsYlbYl

pg bnÞab;BIkarbMeBjkargarmYyéf¶d¾mmajwk-FUlIdI kemþAéf¶ nigCab;køins¥úy-Rsab;EtmanGñkTTYl

xusRtÚvEpñksnþisuxmñak;mkrkCYbKat;. eK)andkhUthVIlftrUbnigkMNt;ehtuxøI²rbs;Kat;edayTTUc

«sUm»kuM[Kat;niyayR)ab;mnusSNamñak;eTotnUvGVIEdlKat;)aneXIj eTaHCaGñkkaEsthugRKIdUcKat;

EdlkMBugsñak;enAkñúgsNæaKarCamYyKñak¾eday. TUrs½BÞRtÚvkat;pþac; Kat;RbEhlCaRtÚvkMNt;[enAEt

kñúgsNæaKary:agR)akd. BIréf¶eRkaymk hÁIy:UrI EdleFVI[Bi)akcitþedaysarkarsakl,genH )an

eFVIdMeNIrtamynþehaHRtLb;eTARkúghaNUyvij1.

PYg NaM )anTTYlkarsþIbenÞasy:agF¶n;. Gñkkan;GMNacBuMcUlcitþkareFVIdMeNIrrbs;Kat;rYmCamYy

GñkkaEstbreTsmñak;eT. edIm,IeFVIdMeNIreTAkan;tMbn;«resIb»mYy karGnuBaØatrbs;RksYgkarbreTs

KWCaerOgcaM)ac;. tamBit hÁIy:UrI nig NaM )andwgPøamfakariyal½yneya)ayBuMyl;RsbtamKMnit

pþÜcepþImrbs;]tþmesnIy_ Rta eT ehIykariyal½yneya)ay)anseRmceFVIkarRtÜtBinitüB½t’manTaMg

Gs;EdlTak;TgnwgkarvayRbharrbs;ExµrRkhm. Rta )anTTYlkarbgÁab;bBa¢a[p¥akkarRbúgeRbób

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 221

Page 232: Brother enemy

erobcMeFVIkarvaysgswkrbs;Kat;. s®gÁamCamYyRbeTskm<úCaKWCakic©karmYyF¶n;F¶rEmnETn eRBaH

EtRbKl;erOgenHeTA[kgT½Bmñak;EdleFVIGVI²eTAtamEtsnÞúHcitþ. mü:ageTotkm<úCa BuMEmnCaRbeTs

mYyEdlecaTCabBaðaeT. RsemalKMramkMEhgrbs;RbeTscin )anbgðajRTg;RTayeLIgBIEpñkxag

eRkayrbs;evotNam. dUecñHGVI²EdlCab;Bak;B½n§TaMgGs;-eyaFaesdækic©nigkarTUt-kñúgCemøaH

edayGavuFCayfaehtumYyCamYyRbeTskm<úCaRtÚvEtføwgEføgedayhµt;ct;. b:unµans)aþh_eRkaymk

Rta )anRtÚv«dMeLIgskþi»CaGnurdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTs CamuxgarRsNukmYyEdlbgðajBIGtßRbeyaCn_

[Kat;enAEtkñúgkariyal½ymYy. GñkTTYlxusRtÚvevotNammñak;)anbkRsayBIerOgenHCaÉkCnfa ³

«enARbeTsevotNameKminbBa©úHskþinigbM)ak;muxGñkNamñak;eT. ebIsinCaGñkmineFIVkargarGIVGñkenaH

nwgRtÚvrujeTAkñúgzananuRkmCamYynwgR)ak;bMNac;dUcesþc nigzan³x<g;x<s;mYy¡». Rta BMumanP½BV

sMNagdUcenHeT. enAqñaMbnÞab; Kat;RtÚv)aneKdkhUtgarecjedayRsÜlEtmþg.

enAéf¶TI31 ExFñÚ qñaM1977 g:U eDon )anekaHehA hÁIy:UrI eTARksYgkarbeTsedIm,IRbKl;hVIl

rUbft kaEsSt nigkMNt;xøI²rbs;Kat;mk[Kat;vij. enAéf¶dEdlenaH caM)ac;RtÚvGHGagfa ExµrRkhm

)ancab;epþImbriharBI«karQøanBan»rbs;evotNamEdr. CMnYs[karsMueTas eDon )anRbKl;eTA[

GñkkaEstnUvRbtikmµpøÚvkarelIkdMbUgrbs;RbeTsevotNam cMeBaHRBwtþikarN_EdlekItmanfµI²enH.

GMNwHteTA karsmøab;rgÁalenAtaynij KWCanaTIrbs;Rbvtþisa®sþ. tamkarBit karvayRbharEdl

bgáeLIgPøam²enAmundMeNIrCapøÚvkarelIkdMbUgrbs; b:ul Bt eTARbeTscin KWKµanbMNgGIVeRkABIbgðaj

[BYkcindwgBIkarebþCJadac;xatRbqaMgevotNamrbs;kgT½Bkm<úCaeLIy. esþehVn hIuD½r )aneFIVsmÖas

kmµaPi)al nigkgT½BExµrRkhmmYycMnYnFM eRcInCagGñkÉkeTsxagbBaðakm<úCaxøHeTot. tammtirbs;

Kat;fa karvayRbharenAéf¶TI24 ExkBaØa eTAelIextþtaynij EdlbgáeLIgedaykgBlFMelx3nig

elx4énPUmiPaKbUBa’rbs;km<úCa KWCasBaØabgðaj[eXIjPaBenAeRkam»vaTBIry:ag. m:üagKWskmµ-

PaBekItecjBICMenOemaHmutEdlsEmþgeLIgedayBYkembBa¢akarkgT½BkñúgkarRbl½yCIvitevotNam

ehIyenHCaskçIPaBmYyénsVamIPkþirbs;eKcMeBaH b:ul Bt enAeBlEdlkarEsVgrkGñkEdlmansman

citþnwgevotNam kMBugEtmanskmµPaBBuHeBary:agxøaMgkñúgTUTaMgRbeTsehIy m:üageTot enHCa«CMnUn»

mYyEdlBYkExµrRkhmbgç¿[RbeTscineFVIskmµPaBGVImYy2.

s®gÁammYyEdlminecjmux

enAsrTrdUvqñaM1977 erOgr:avd¾KYr[RBWxøacbMputCaeRcIn)ancab;epþImelcB¤sussayenATIRkúg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg222

Page 233: Brother enemy

hUCImij ¬GtItRkúgéRBnKr¦. erOgniTanepSg²rbs;Gñkrs;ranmanCIvitBIkarsmøab;rgÁal EdlRbRBwtþ

eLIgenAkm<úCa)anraldalBImat;mYyeTAmat;mYy. kñúgeBldMNalKñaenaH GñkePosxøÜnevotNam

ÉeTot²)anrt;eKcxøÜnrYceTAdl;RbeTsm:aeLsuInigéf. GñkTaMgenHk¾)anerobrab;BIPaBsahavéRBépS

kñúgkarvayqµk;rbs;ExµrRkhmenAtamRBMEdndUcKña. b:uEnþ BiPBxageRkAKµan)andwgBIerOgenHTal;

EtesaH. CapøÚvkareKRKan;EtniyaybeBaäóg²BI]bTÞvehtuCaeRcIn EdlmanlkçN³Fmµta²b:ueNÑaH.

karRtÜtRtarbs;rdæaPi)aleTAelIRbB½n§pSBVpSay KWdUcKñanwgkarhamXat;[enAes¶óms¶at;Edlcab;

bgçM[BYkbreTseKarBtamdUckrNIelak sg;d½r hÁIy:UrI EdlCaGñkKaMRTG‘Ícwg rhUtdl;karRbDitBITMnak;

TMngCaFmµtarvagRbeTsTaMgBIrGacRtÚvEfrkSa[sßitenAkñúgsßanPaBdEdlpg. kñúgGMLúgeBlenaH

kariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam )anerobcMeFVIkarsgswkrbs;xøÜnvijkñúgsPaBs¶b;

s¶at;bMput. bYnéf¶eRkaykarvayRbharrbs;ExµrRkhm viTüúRkúghaNUy)anpSBVpSaylixitsresIr

mYyCUn b:ul Bt y:agesaHkeRkaHkñúg»kasénkarRtLb;mkRKb;RKgRbeTseLIgvijRbkb eday

eCaKC½yrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa.

evotNam)anKitKUrBIkarvaybkmkvijkñúgry³eBlCaeRcInEx. y:ab )aneFVIdMeNIreTABinitü

smrPUmiedayxøÜnÉgedIm,IvaytémøsßankarN_enATIenaH. enATIbMput kñúgExtula qñaM1977 kgT½B

evotNam)ancab;eFVIRbtibtþikareyaFaCaelIkdMbUgrbs;xøÜnedaysm¶at;. rfeRkaHmYyExS)aneRCót

cUlCeRmA24KILÚEm:RtmkkñúgTwkdIkm<úCaenAextþsVayerog bnÞab;mkeFVIhak;dUcCadkfyeTAvij.

kgT½BefµIreCIgExµrRkhmmYykgvresnatUc )anedjtamehIyqøgkat;RBMEdncUleTAkñúgTwkdIevotNam.

ExST½BTIBIrrbs;evotNamenArg;caMBYkenHrYcCaeRsc. edayRtÚvvayRbharkñúgeBldMNalKñaBImux

pg nigBIcMehogpg kgT½Brbs;km<úCa)anRtÚveLamB½T§Cab;kñúgGnÞak;enH. kgT½BExµrRkhmCagmYyry

nak;)anRtÚvevotNamcab;xøÜn. b:uEnþkarxatbg;kñúg»kasenH hak;dUcCaBuM)anbg¥n;nUvPaBBuHke®Ba¢al

rbs;ExµrRkhmEdlcUlcitþcm,aMgeLIy 3.

KYr[q¶l;Edr «esovePAexµA» Edle)aHBum<pSayedayrbb b:ul Bt enAExkBaØa qñaM1978

BuMmansresrbBa©ÚlkarQøanBanenHkñúgkarerobrab;d¾EvgKYr[FujRTan;énbNþwgsaTukçrbs;xøÚnRbqaMg

nwgevotNameLIy. eKetagEtsnñidæanfa karvaybkEpñkeyaFaenHBitCaeFVI[evotNamraErk

EmnETn. edayrebobdUcKña esovePAexµAk¾BuMmanniyay[dwgCasaFarN³BIkarb:unb:geFVIrdæRbhar

sñiT§evotNamsRmab;ry³eBleBjmYyqñaM1977Edr. b:uEnþevotNamFøab;RtÚveKecaTRbkan;fa

CaRbPBedIménkarb:unb:glYcsmøab; b:ul Bt CaeRcInelIkenAcenøaHqñaM1975nig1976. enA

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 223

Page 234: Brother enemy

edImrdUvekþAqñaM1977 ExµrRkhmRKan;EtbþwgbriharBIkarerobcMnUv«Epnkarvaylukd¾FMeFg»mYy

b:ueNÑaH4 b:uEnþBuM)anpþl;PaBCak;lak;epSg²eToteRkABIenHeLIy. tamkarBit tamkaryl;dwgrbs;

evotNamfa elIkenHkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbeFVIrdæRbharR)akdRbCaEdlminEdlsakl,gRbqaMgnwg

b:ul Bt )ancab;epþImmanenAExvicäika qñaM1977. rdæRbharenHmanrYmbBa©ÚlBYkkmµaPi)alExµrRkhm

EdlEbk)ak;bkSBYkrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’apg. kEnøglak;Tukes,ógGaharCaeRcInRtÚv)anerobcMenAkñúg

éRBeRCAkñúgeKalbMNgeFVIkarbHe)armYyEdlminTan;dl;»kas5.

etIRkúghaNUymanedIrtYnaTINamYykñúgkarerobcMrdæRbharenHeT? tamrebobKiteTAmü:agfa

eKc,as;CaeqøIyedayPaBviC¢man bu:EnþKµanGñkNamñak;GacbBa¢ak;BIerOgenH[)anBitR)akdeLIy.

GñkviPaKénRkúmesIubkarN_sm¶at; nigGñkÉkeTsbs©imRbeTs)ansaksYrExµrRkhmrab;rynak;Edl

nwksþayeRkaynigBYkkumµúynIsþevotNamEdlrt;cUlxagsRtÚvpgEdr. BYkeK)anBinitüemIleday

hµt;ct;nUvcemøIysarPaBd¾eRcInsn§wksn§ab;rbs;GñkeTasCatiExµrenATYlEsøgCaeQµaHsalad¾l,IenA

RkúgPñMeBjEdlExµrRkhmERbkøayeTACaKukvij b:uEnþKµan)anplGVITaMgGs;. ebIsinevotNam)an

seRmceCaKC½ykñúgkarbMpøajKeRmagkarBYkcarbursExµrRkhmBitEmn ebIsinCaBYkeKBuHBar]bsKÁ

EdlkMBugbgçaMgRbeTskm<úCaehIycUlTak;TgCamYyGñkrYmKMnitk,t;enAxagkñúg)an k¾bc©úb,nñsñaédenH

enAEtKµannrNadwgenAeLIy. pÞúyeTAvijvaR)akdNas;fa cab;BIqñaM1977 RkúghaNUy)ancab;epþIm

begáItmUldæansRmab;clnaRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt enARbeTsevotNampÞal;eRsceTAehIy.

karsmøab;rgÁalCaeRcInelIkenAtaynij nigkarKitTukCamunEdlBYkeKsµanxus)anrYmbgáCa

rbt;mYykñúgTMnak;TMngrvagExµr-evotNam k¾dUckñúgdMeNIrCIvitrbs;kmµaPi)alExµrRkhmCaeRcInnak;

EdlqøgcUleTARbeTsevotNamkñúg»kasenaH Edlman h‘un Esn mñak;enAkñúgcMeNamenaHEdr. Kat;

CaembBa¢akarkgvresnaFMmYyEdle)aHTItaMgenAtMbn;cenøaHRBMEdnextþRkecH nigextþkMBg;cam.

enAedImqñaM1977 Kat;)anTTYlbTbBa¢aBIesnaFikarkgT½B[erobcMkgÉkPaBrbs;xøÜn edIm,Ivay

RbharcUlkñúgextþtaynijCeRmA15KILÚEm:Rt. karvayRbhartampøÚveKak EdleRKagTukenA

éf¶TI30 Ex]sPa RtÚv)anRbKl;Parkic©[kgÉkPaBrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’aCaeRcInkg edaymankarRTRTg;

BIkgkaMePøIgFMrbs;kgBlFMelx4pg. b:uEnþ embBa¢akarCaeRcInnak;EdldwknaMbBa¢akgvresnaFM nig

kgvresnatUc)anbdiesFmineFVItambBa¢aenaHeLIy. BYkeK)anRtÚvcab;xøÜnnigykeTAsmøab;ecal

TaMgGs;. hu‘n Esn CaemT½Bmanv½yekµgCageKkñúgcMeNamembBa¢akarT½Brbs;PUmiPaKmankareCOCak;

BitR)akdcMeBaHesnaFikarEdlRbKl;Par³[Kat;dwknaMRbtibtþikarTaMgenH. karerobrab;EdlKat;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg224

Page 235: Brother enemy

GHGagR)ab;GñkkaEst esþehVn hIud½r enAeBleRkaymkminEmnGt;RbeyaCn_enaHeT «´yl;dwgqab;

rh½sfa ´BuMGaceFVIGMeBImYyEbbenaH)aneT. dUecñH´BuMmankareRCIserIsNaepSgeToteRkABIrt;

cUléRBCamYyyuT§CnmYyPaKrbs;´eLIy KWenAéf¶TI20 Exmifuna qñaM1977»6. eRkayenaHbnþic

Kat;)anqøgkat;RBMEdneTAenARbeTsevotNam.

enATIbMput Epnkar)anRtÚvseRmcGnuvtþenAéf¶TI24 ExkBaØa. «eCaKC½y»rbs;RbtibtþikarenH

)annaMeTAdl;karEtgtaMgembBa¢akarmñak;eQµaH ehg sMrin [kan;tMENgdwknaM EdlnwgkøayeTACa

sm<½n§mitþd¾sMxan;rbs;evotNamenAkm<úCa. manmaDl¥it sm,úrEs,kRsKaM kñúgGayu43qñaM sMrin

beBa©j[eXIjlkçN³RsKt;RsKM EdlKat;kRme)aHbg;critb£kBaenHNas;. bgKat;nigKat;suT§Et

CasmaCikénk,alm:asuInKN³kmµaFikarbkSRbcaMPUmiPaKbUB’a. etIKat;manmuxnaTIGVIeTAEdl)an

cUlrYmedaypÞal;kñúgkarQøanBand¾eXareXArbs;ExµrRkhmeTAelIRbeTsevotNamenaH? eKmin)an

dwgBIerOgenaHeT. b:uEnþeKdwgfa Kat;RtÚv)aneRCIstaMgPøam²CaRbFan«smrPUmipøÚvCatielx7» enA

RBMEdnRbeTsevotNam. edayehtuenH Kat;k¾køayeTACamnusSTI2énzananuRkmkgT½BRbcaMPUmiPaK

enaH. «rbs;GVIk¾edaysuT§EtmancMENkGaRkk;rbs;va». b:unµanExeRkaymk karTTYlxusRtÚvelI

smrPUmienH)aneFVI[ b:ul Bt xwgdac;k,aldac;knÞúy enAeBlEdlkgT½Brbs;Kat;bgðaj[eXIjfa

KµansmtßPaBRbyuT§tTl;nwgevotNam. dUecñH edIm,Ise®gÁaHCIvitxøÜnpg Kat;RtÚvEtrt;ePosxøÜneTA

RbeTsevotNam7.

bBaðarbs;km<úCa)ankøayeTACacMNucsMxan;kñúgkarCYbBiPakSaKñaCasm¶at;enARkúgmUsÁÚ rvagBYk

emdwknaMevotNam nigbNþasmPaKIsUevotrbs;BYkeKkñúgGMLúgrdUvekþAqñaM1977. BYksUevot

manB½t’manepSg²pÞal;xøÜnrbs;BYkeKsþIBI])aykleFVIviT§gSnaepSg²rbs;evotNam ³ enAEx vicäika

qñaM1977 GñkkarTUtmñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenARkúghaNUy)anniyayR)ab;shesvik\NÐamñak;[

dwgfa clnatsU‘Tl;nwgExµrRkhmkMBugcat;EcgerobcM[mandMeNIreLIgehIy. k,alm:asuIndwknaM

clnaenHKWRkúmmYymanmnusSBIdb;nak;eTAdb;R)aMnak;ehIykñúgcMeNamenaH y:agehacNas;manbInak;

CaGtItsmaCikbkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinEdlkalBImunbegáIteLIgedayevotNam8. GñkkarTUtrUbenH

BuM)anbBa¢ak;fa clnatsU‘enHeFVIRbtibtþikarmkxagkñúgRbeTskm<úCa b¤skmµPaBepSg²rbs;xøÜnkMNt;

RtwmEtkñúgRbeTsevotNamb¤k¾y:agNaeT.

enAsrTrdUvqñaM1977 ExµrRkhmEdle)aHbg;bkSBYkmYyRkúm kñúgcMeNamenaHman hu‘n Esn/

Ehm samin nig bU‘ fg-EdlGñkTaMgGs;enHnwgsEmþgtYnaTIsMxan;elIslb;CageKmYykñúgkarRbyuT§

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 225

Page 236: Brother enemy

RbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt-)anerobcMclnarbs;xøÜnenARbeTsevotNam. erOgr:avenA taynij enATIbMput

)aneFVI[evotNamrMCYlcitþ. taMgBIEx]sPa qñaM1977 GñkTaMgenHRKan;EtvaytbvijTl;nwg

karTmøak;RKab;EbktampøÚvGakas b¤kar)aj;RKab;kaMePøIgFMepøagdak;xøH²b:ueNÑaH ehIyedaylak;karN_

sm¶at;eTot. rebobeFVIskmµPaBepSg²eTot manlkçN³CaPaBcaM)ac;mYycab;taMgBIéf¶enHeTA.

ExµrRkhmEdle)aHbg;ecalCYr BuMEmnCaPñak;garbgáehtueT. evotNamraErkkñúgcitþy:agyUr

munnwgeCOelIGñkTaMgenaH bnÞab;BIkarsYrcemøIynigkarsegátBinitüCaeRcInEx. vamanP½sþútagfa GñkxøH

kñúgcMeNamExµrRkhme)aHbg;ecalCYrTaMgenaH CaBiess h‘un Esn )an[dMNwgdl;evotNamCamunBI

EpnkarlMGiténkarvayRbhareTAelItaynijpgEdr EdlenHCaskçIPaBénsuqnÞ³rbs;eK 9. Pøam²

B½t’manTaMgenaHRbEhlCaBuMTan;eFVI[evotNameCOR)akdRbCaeTelIkElgEtB½t’manenaHminTan;

)anbBa¢ÚneTA[bBa¢akarkgT½Brbs;PUmiPaK. b:uEnþ kñúg»kasénkarcab;epþImeFVIskmµPaBvayRbhar BYk

RbCaCnsuIvilevotNamRtÚv)anTukecalTaMgRsugedayKµankarkarBareLIy. minyUrb:unµaneRkaymk

evotNam)anRtÚveFVI[nwkeXIjeTArkCYbGñke)aHbg;bkSBYkR)aMbInak;Edlrt;mkkalBIeBlfµI² edIm,I

BiPakSaBIGnaKtneya)ayrbs;RbeTskm<úCa10.

GñkePosxøÜnkm<úCamanbMNgEtmü:agb:ueNÑaH KWRtLb;eTAkm<úCavijedIm,IvayRbyuT§. RkúghaNUy

yl;c,as;R)akdfa enHehIyCa«P½BVsMNagbEnßmmYy»kñúgGnþraKmn_rbs;xøÜnEdlGac[seRmclT§pl

eRcInRbkar. kñúgGtItkalfµI² evotNamFøab;eFVIGnþraKmn_BIrdgrYcmkehIy edIm,ICYypþÜlrMlMrbbkan;

GMNacmYyenARkúgPñMeBjkñúgGMLúgTsvtSr_40-50 RbqaMgnwgBYk)araMg nigkñúgGMLúgqñaM1970

RbqaMgnwg ln; nl;. b:uEnþmunnwgseRmccitþCafµImþgeTot evotNam)anerobcMkarsakl,gCaelIk

cugeRkaymYy edIm,IbMEbkRbeTscin[XøatecjBIRbeTskm<úCasin. sarlixitEdlBYkeKepJIeTA[

Rkúgeb:kaMgelIkenHKWCaesckþIGMBavnavmYy nigCakarRBmanrbobeFVIeBImYysRmab;karBarplvi)ak

epSg²EdlekItmanedaysarkarbnþkic©KaMRTrbs;cincMeBaHRbeTskm<úCa.

eL yn; sÞg;citþcin

karKaMRTenHnwgmanrhUtdl;eBlNaeTA? BYkemdwknaMevotNam)anTTYlsÁal;edayrIkrayfa

BYkeKBuMTan;GacbeBa©jTsSn³CasßaBrmYy)aneTmunsrTrdUvqñaM1977. v:ag Tug )aneFVIkarsnñidæan

CamuneRscnUvPaBesaHGegÁIyénTMnak;TMngrvagcin-km<úCa bnÞab;BIkardYlrlMén«bnbYnnak;». tam

eyabl;Kat;fa RTwsþIRbtibtþiniymrbs; etg s‘avBIg> nigRTwsþIeqVgRCúlhYsehturbs;ExµrRkhm BuMGac

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg226

Page 237: Brother enemy

«cuHsRmúgKña»)aneLIy. R)akdNas; taMgBImankarbdiesFy:agCak;lak; edayRbeTscinkñúgqñaM

1977cMeBaHkaresñIsuMrbs;evotNamedIm,IbEnßmCMnYyesdækic©[xøÜnenaH )aneFVI[KMnityl;RcLM

epSg²rsat;)at;Gs;. RkúghaNUyyl;kan;Etc,as;CalMdab;fa xøÜnRtÚvEte)aHbg;esckþIsgÇwmkñúg

karsRmbsRmÜlTMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnTaMgGs;CamYyRkúgeb:kaMg. b:uEnþenAsl;RbeTskm<úCa

eTot. bBaðaTaMgGs;KWcg;dwgfa etIkarcgKMnuMRbqaMgevotNamrbs;BYkcin vaCaerOgEdlCMruj[BYkeK

eqøIytbnwgkarbgáehturbs;ExµrRkhmb¤mYyy:agNa. ecjBITsSn³enH karTTYly:agG‘åkGFwk Edl

Rkúgeb:kaMgerobcMTTYl b:ul Bt enAsrTrdUvqñaM1977 KWCaRbpñÚlminl¥mYy. elIsBIenHeTot kar

riHKn;epSg²EdlesÞIrEtKµanlak;elomRbqaMgnwgevotNam k¾ebIk»kas[emdwknaMExµrRkhmh‘an

RbRBwtþGVI²tamGMeBIcitþxøÜnEdr. enAéf¶TI3 Extula qñaM1977 munkarecjdMeNIrrbs; b:ul Bt Gñk

crcad¾eqñImCageKrbs;evotNameQµaH pan; ehon )aneFVIdMeNIrCasm¶at;eTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMg edIm,IesñI

[BYkemdwknaMcinCYyerobcM[mankarCYbKñamYyrvagKat; nigkm<úCa. tamBitenHKWCal,icmYysRmab;

sakl,grk[eXIjnUvCMhrrbs;cin kñúgCemøaHEdlkMBugekItmanrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrpg. RbeTscin

)anTTYlyl;RBm b:uEnþ karCYbKñaBIrelIkrvag ehon nigGñktMNagkm<úCaenATIRkúgeb:kaMg )anRbRBwtþ

eTAminCaRbesIreLIy. eKRbECgKñaniyayEtBIPaBCUrct;nigerOgKµanxøwmsarb:ueNÑaH. km<úCa)an

riHKn;y:agxøaMgkøanUvGMeBIQøanBan kareFVIviT§gSna nigviecäTkmµEdlRbRBwtþeLIgCabnþbnÞab;eday

RbeTsevotNam. c,as;CagenHeTAeTot km<úCa)anecaTRbkan;RkúghaNUyfa)anbBa©úHbBa©Úl[man

rdæRbharmin)anseRmcCaeRcInelIkRbqaMgnwgrbb b:ul Bt. CakareqøIytb ehon )anefáal

eTascMeBaHkarcUllukluyd¾kMeraléRBépSrbs;km<úCacUlkñúgTwkdIevotNamEdr b:uEnþkñúgeBlCamYy

KñaenaH )anesñI[mankarebIkkic©crcaEfmeTotedIm,Ikat;bnßyPaBtantwgenAtamRBMEdn. km<úCa)an

s‘ksmþIvijPøamfa KµankarcrcaNamYyGacelIkykmkBinitüeLIy drabNaevotNamBuMRBme)aHbg;

])aykl viT§gSna nigskmµPaBviecäTkmµrbs;xøÜnenaH. sRmab;evotNamenHCasMeNIEdlBuMGac

TTYlyk)an eRBaHvaeRbóbdUcCaTTYlsÁal;BiruT§PaBrbs;xøÜnmunkarcab;epþIménkarBiPakSaG‘Ícwg 11.

ehon EdlCamnusSKYr[GaNit k¾TTYlbraC½ykñúgkaredaHRsaybBaðaRBMEdnCamYyRbeTscin

Edr. enAéf¶TI7 Extula mankarCYbBiPakSaKñad¾yUrCaelIkdMbUgmYyenATIRkúgeb:kaMg kñúgcMeNamkarCYb

eTVPaKICahUrEhmYykñúgeKalbMNgkMNt;RBMEdneKak¬srub1>275KILÚEm:Rt¦ nigRBMEdnsmuRT¬QUg

smuRTtugkwg¦[ehIyeRscCasßaBrrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr. karRbCuMcrca)anbnþkñúgry³eBldb;Ex

CamYynwgkarp¥akCaeRcInelIkrhUtTal;Etcab;epþImpÞúHeLIgnUvkarRbTUsr:ayKña eTIbkarCYbsnÞnaKñaRtÚv

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 227

Page 238: Brother enemy

bBaÄb;TaMgRsúg12.

enAExtula KWmYys)þah_eRkaykarecjdMeNIrrbs; ehon RkúghaNUy)anRbkasCasaFa

rN³BIvtþmanrbs;KN³RbtiPUeyaFasUevotmYyRkúmenAelITwkdIrbs;xøÜn. enHCakarRBmanmYyEdl

bgáb;eTAedayGaf’kM)aMg ³ karbegáInkic©KaMRTRKb;Ebby:agrbs;cincMeBaHkm<úCanwgbNþal[mankar

BRgwgshRbtibtþikarsUevot-evotNamkan;EtxøaMgeLIgEdr13.

b:uEnþRbeTscin)aneFVIskmµPaBmunrYcCaeRsc. munenHbnþic cin)ansnüacUlrYmBRgwgskþanuBl

kgT½Brbs;sm<½n§mitþExµrRkhmrbs;xøÜny:agmWugm:at;bMput. eKsakl,gdNþwgsYrkñúgcitþfa etIRkúg

eb:kaMgminerobcMmitþPkþiTaMgLay[mansßanPaBGnueRKaHmYy ¬eKnwkKiteTAdl; h½g v:an;hn CaGñkrt;

ecalbkSBYkcUlxagsRtÚvenAéf¶xagmux¦ EdlCaGñkFøab;ykcitþTukdak;pþl;B½t’man[dwgBIkarERbRbÜl

Edlmin)anKitTukCamunénkarxitcUlCitKñarvagRbeTsevotNamnigshPaBsUevoteTb¤14.

eTaHCay:agNak¾eday xN³EdlmanehtukarN_sMxan;²énRbvtþisa®sþrbs;xøÜn RbeTscin

EtgEtbgðaj[eXIjrebobBiPal;mYyCanic©Tak;TgeTAnwgRbeTsevotNam. enAéf¶TI5 Extula KWBIr

éf¶bnÞab;BIkarmkdl;Rkúgeb:kaMgrbs; ehon nigR)aMéf¶munkarmkdl;RkúghaNUyrbs; ey: BIesðv

esnanuBn§eyaFaRbcaMsßanTUtcinenARkúgPñMeBj)ancuHhtßelxakñúgnamGKÁesnaFikarénRksYgkarBar

RbeTscinnUvBiFIsarmYykñúgkarpÁt;pÁg;eRKÓgsBaVvuFmk[km<úCa EdlCakareFVI[eTACaBitnUvkic©

RBmeRBógCabzmkñúgkarpþl;CMnYyeyaFa\tsMNg EdlcuHhtßelxaedayPaKITaMgBIrkalBIExkumÖ³

qñaM1976. kic©karTaMgGs;suT§EtRtÚvruMB½T§eTAedaylak;karN_sm¶at;bMput. smÖarCMnYymantaMgBI

viTüúpSaynigcab;sMeLgtUc²rhUtdl;ynþehaHRbedj>>>. BiFIsarenaHk¾maneRKagnUvkarpÁt;pÁg;

smÖarcaM)ac;RKb;Ebby:agkñúgkarbegáItkgT½BTaMgbIEpñkrbs;km<úCapgEdrKWsRmab;kgT½BeCIgeKak

eCIgTwk nigeCIgGakas15.

pÞúyeTAvij RbeTscin)ankat;bnßyy:agsn§wksn§ab; nUvcMnYnénkarTak;TgtampøÚvGakasCa

eTogTat;rbs;xøÜn CamYyRkúghaNUy. karTak;TgtampøÚvGakasrvagRkúghaNUynigRkúgkg;tugeday

ynþehaHRTIdg; (Trident) énRkúmh‘unGakascrN_suIvilcinRBmnwgkarTak;TgtampøÚvrfePøIgrhUtdl;

Rkúghugkug )anrYmbgáCapøÚvecjd¾sMxan;eTArkBiPBeRkAsRmab;CnbreTsEdlrs;enAkñúgrdæFanIrbs;

evotNam. CaerOy² kEnøgGgÁúyTaMgGs;RtÚvkk;TukmunCaeRcIns)aþh_. R)akdNas;plvi)ak

epSg²xagBaNiC¢kmµEdlelcecjBIkarseRmccitþenH sRmab;BYkcin)ankøayCaerOgbnÞab;bnSMeTA

vij. GVIEdlRtÚvvaytémøKWkarsEmþg[eXIjkarmYhµgrbs;xøÜn. eRkamelsd¾minTMngmYy Rkúmhu‘n

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg228

Page 239: Brother enemy

GakascrN_cin)ankat;bnßyeCIgehaHehIrBIBIrdgeTAmYydgvij kñúgcMnYneCIgehaHehIrRbcaMs)þah_

rbs;xøÜn Kitcab;taMgBIéf¶TI1 Exvicäika qñaM1977teTA.

mçag)anbg¥g;el,ÓnTak;TgKña mçageTotEbrCabegáInel,ÓneTAvij. enARkúgPñMeBj Gñkbec©keTs

cin)anerobcMbegáItmCÄmNÐlTUrKmnaKmn_mYytaMgBIExtula qñaM1977em:øH. ExSTUrelxedaypÞal;

mYynigExSTak;TgtamviTüúCaeRcInExS)anRtÚvebIksem<aFy:agGFikGFmenAéf¶TI10 Exvicäika qñaM

1977. rhUtmkdl;éf¶ExenH karTak;TgtamviTüúrbs;sßanTUtcinCamYyRkúgeb:kaMg KWCaExSTak;Tg

EtmYyKt;rbs;RkúgPñMeBjCamYyBiPBxageRkA 16.

GKÁelxabkSkmµúynIsþevotNam eL yn; EdleTIbEtRtLb;BITIRkúgmUsÁÚminTan;RsYlbYlpg

)anecjdMeNIreTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMgeTot eTAtamTmøab;føwg[esµIKñaxagEpñkkarTUtrbs;evotNam. b:uEnþ

elIkenH Kat;BuMEmnCaGñkeFVI[CBa¢IgesµIKñaeT. GñkkarTUtevotNammñak;)anBnül;R)ab;´fa «smmitþ

eL yn; )aneTArkerOgsRtÚvdl;sMbukrbs;vaEtmþg tamKMrUvIrburs lI eFOgeKot (Ly Thuong Kiet)

rbs;eyIg». vIrbursEdlKat;niyayenH KWRBHmhakSRtmYyGgÁrbs;evotNamenAstvtSr_TI11

EdldwknaMRbkbedayeCaKC½ynUvkareFVIs®gÁamkarBarCamunmYyenAelITwkdIrbs;cin edIm,Iyk

eRbóbelIkarlukluymYyEdlhak;dUcCaecosminput.

kñúg»kasénkarCYbsnÞnaKña emdwknaMevotNam)ancab;epþImniyaybeBa©IcbeBa©IBIemaTnPaBCati

rbs;cin. Kat;)anEføgedaylkçN³rmüTmKYr[q¶l;cMeBaHRbFanbkSkumµúynIsþcin hVa KUehVg fa

«eyIgCab¥ÚneBArbs;smmitþ eyIgsßitenAEb:kxagsmmitþCanic© ehIyeyIgnwgminpøas;bþÚrCMhresaH

eLIy eTaHCamanGVIekIteLIgk¾eday»17.

b:uEnþ eLyn; )aneFVI[kt;smÁal;fa ebITukCamanGFikrN_CamYyRbeTscinsþIBIbBaðaCayuT§sa®sþ

sMxan;²k¾eday k¾RbeTsevotNamecosvagRKb;karriHKn;CasaFarN³Edr KWxusEbøkBIBYksUevot Ca

]TahrN_ ehIyKat;egOgq¶l;fa BYkcinhak;dUcCamindwgKuNKat;BIerOgenHesaH. GVIEdlminesµaHRtg;

nwgKña Kat;minePøcrMB£kfa karKaMRTdl;karksaglT§isgÁmniymenARbeTsevotNam KWCakatBVkic©

GnþrCatimYykñúgcMeNam «katBVkic©GnþrCatiCaeRcIn» rbs;RbeTscinkñúgnaménsBnaykrdæm®nþI CU

eGnLay. bnÞab;BI)ansEmþgkaresaksþaycMeBaHmrNPaBrbs; em:A esTug/ CU eGnLay nig CUti

rYcmk yn; )aneqøót»kasenHedIm,ICRmabCUnnUvkarRtiHriHBicarNarbs;Kat;GMBIneya)aykñúgRbeTs

rbs;cin EdlCaRbkareFVI[b:HBal;esI²dl;karxVHesckþIKYrsmy:agCak;c,as;. eKKµansgS½yeLIy

fa BYkemdwknaMfµIrbs;cin«nwgminGnuBaØat[vNѳekgRbv½Ba©mYycMnYntUcegIbk,aleLIgvij)aneT eTaHCa

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 229

Page 240: Brother enemy

manGVIekIteLIgk¾eday ehIyBYkeKnwgrvaMgRby½tñedIm,IeFVI[RbeTscinfµIenAEt¬Rkhm¦Canic©»18.

eL yn; )anTTYlbraC½y. Kat;BuMGacbBa©úHbBa©Úl[BYkcinbnßykarKaMRTrbs;eKcMeBaHBYk

ExµrRkhm)aneLIy. pÞúyeTAvij Rkúgeb:kaMg)anecaTRbkan;RbeTsevotNamfa)aneFVITukçbukemñj

RbeTsCitxagxøÜnEdlTn;exSay ehIyb:unb:gdak;nwmRtÜtRtaelIRbeTsenaHedayRCkeRkampøak

begáIt«TMnak;TMngBiess»TaMgbgçMrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrEfmeTot. eBlenaH hVa ehobnwgbBa¢ak;GHGag

nUvkarKaMRTrbs;RbeTscincMeBaHkm<úCaCasaFarN³RbqaMgnwgevotNameTAehIy. edayEføgkñúgBiFI

Cb;elogmYyEdlerobcMCakitþiyscMeBaH eL yn;/ hVa )anKUsbBa¢ak;fa RbeTsrbs;Kat;)antaMgcitþ

«cgsm<½n§PaBCamYyRbeTsTaMgGs;EdlrgeRKaHBIkarQøanBanrbs;BYkcRkBtþi nigBYksgÁm-cRkBtþi

(social-imperialiste) nigCamYyRbeTsTaMgGs;EdlsßitenAeRkamkareFVIviT§gSna kareRCótERCk karRKb

sgát; nigkarrMelaPCiHCan;rbs;breTs». RbeTscincUlrYmCYysRmÜldl;«karbegáItrNsirSTUlM

TUlaymYyRbqaMgnwgGnutþrPaBniyménmhaGMNacFM²» pgEdr.

karrkerOgrbs;cinmanlkçN³c,as;las;Nas;. eL yn; )aneqøIytbnwgerOgenHeday

RbkasCasaFarN³fa RbeTsevotNamnwgminGnuBaØat[ «mhaGMNaccRkBtþib¤RbtikiriyaNamYy

eTaHCamhaGMNacNak¾eday ekobsgát;ÉkraCüPaBnigesrIPaBrbs;evotNameLIy»19. «Gnutþr

PaBniym» «mhaGMNacRbtikiriya» suT§EtCakarniyayedomdameTAvijeTAmkEdleKGacemIlFøúH

dl;eRKÓgkñúg.

kñúgkarCYbsnÞnaKñamun² BYkemdwknaMevotNamFøab;man»kasRcanecaledayesckþIKYrsmnUv

karesñIsuM[xøÜncUlrYmCamYyRbeTscinkñúgsm<½n§PaBRbqaMgsUevotmYy. BYkemdwknaMevotNamEtgEt

ykcitþTukdak;EføgGMNrKuNRBmKñacMeBaHRbeTscin nig«bNþaRbeTssgÁmniymCabgb¥Ún»epSgeTot

¬ehAmü:ageTotKWbøúksUevotEdleRcInEtCabNþaRbeTssgÁmniymenAGWr:ubxagekIt bc©úb,nñRtÚvrlM

rlayGs;ehIy¦ cMeBaHCMnYyEdlRbeTsTaMgGs;enaHpþl;[RbeTsxøÜn»20Canic©. b:uEnþelIkenH eL

yn; )aneFVIerOgmYyRCúlhYsehtubnþic. Kat;)anEføgsresIrsUevotedayecjeQµaHCacMheFIV[BYk

m©as;pÞHGak;Gn;RsBn;citþxøaMgEmnETn. taMgBIyUryarNas;mkehIy PaBKYrsmEtsMbkeRkAEdl

biT)aMgkarBiténPaBtantwgrvagcin-evotNam enAeBlenH)aneRbHFøayRbkbedayeRKaHfñak;

bMput. FatupSMepSg²énCemøaHEdlnwgmkdl;naeBlxagmux )ansßitenAtamTIkEnøgrbs;vacab;eBl

enHeTAehIy.

karsnüarbs;BYkcinkñúgkarKaMRTRbeTskm<úCaKWmanenAkñúgkarsnÞnad¾BuHke®Ba¢alCamYy eL yn;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg230

Page 241: Brother enemy

EdlmanmkeRkay²eTot. kñúgkarRsavRCavCasm¶at;mYyGMBIneya)ay\NÐÚcinrbs;RbeTscin

ecg Bav GKÁelxaKN³kmµaFikareyaFarbs;bkSkumµúynIsþcin)ansmÁal;fa ³ cab;BI Exvicäika qñaM

1977 «karExVgKMnitKñarvagRbeTsevotNamnigkm<úCa)ankøayeTACaerOgFM Tal;EtElgtRmÚv[

eyIgbiT)aMgerOgenHyUrteTAeTot. kic©RbwgERbgTaMgb:unµanrbs;eyIgtaMgBIkarrMedaHRbeTskm<úCaenA

qñaM1975 edIm,IraraMgkuM[bdibkçPaBenHpÞúHeLIg enATIbMput eXIjfaKµan)anRbeyaCn_GVITaMgGs;.

sRmab;mUlehtuenHehIy)anCaenAExFñÚ KN³kmµaFikarmCÄimbkS)anseRmccitþmUlmtiKña pþl;nUv

karKaMRTeBjTMhwgcMeBaHkm<úCanigGnuBaØat[km<úCaBRgwgxøÜneLIgEfmeTot edIm,IRbQmmuxTl;nwg

sßankarN_fµI EdlTMngCaecjmkGMBIbraC½yénkarcrcaKñaehIyemIl_eTA»21.

hYsGMBIsmancitþEdlxøÜnrgTTYledIm,IRbeTskm<úCa ehIyedayminbdiesFBIRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜn

kñúgnaTICa]bkrN_rbs;RkúmGñkts‘UTl;nwgGnutþrPaBrbs;evotNam RkúmemdwknaMcincUlcitþeFVIkarcrca

kñúgry³eBlyUrCaCagkarRbQmmuxdak;Kña. BitehIy vamanPsþútagCaeRcInEdlbRBa©asKña dUcCa

karelIkTwkcitþCYyedayKµanKitcMeBaH b:ul Bt enAqñaM1977CaedIm EdlRbEhlcaM)ac;eFVI[eK

bkRsayEbbCakarqøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjBIkarts‘UdeNþIm\T§iBlKña EdlbnþGRgÜnbkSkumµúynIsþcinenA

CMnan;enaH. d,itGI tamBIeRkay etg s‘avBIg BYkemdwknaMxagExSRbtibtþiniym)anvaytémøBYkExµr

RkhmfaCa Procuste fµI [kñúgerOgeRBgniTanRkic Procuste KWemecarbøn;enA Attique EdlRtÚvsmøab;eday

Thésée ¬esþcRbeTsRkic¦. vacUlcitþcgsn§wgBYkCnrgeRKaHenAelIERKmYy. ebIsinCaCnrgeRKaH

manmaDFMeBk vaeFVI[xøIedaykat;eCIgTaMgBIrecj ebImaDtUceBkvacab;EhkEtmþg-kMNt;rbs;Gñkbk

ERb] ehIyemdwknaMTaMgenaHraErkedIm,IKaMRT karbgáehtuRbqaMgevotNamrbs;BYkeKyUrteTAeTot22.

karKaMRTmYyEdlminsUvmuWgm:at;

etIeKegOgq¶l;y:agNaeTA kalebImnusSEdlRtÚvcat;taMgedIm,ImksEmþgkarKaMRTrbs;cin

cMeBaHkm<úCa eRkayBIbraC½yénkic©crcaepSg²CamYy eL yn; CamnusSdac;xatmñak;EdleKsÁal;

CaTUeTAenaH?. ecn y:ughSI ]bnaykrdæm®nþInigCasmaCikkariyal½yneya)ay KWCamnusSedIr

RsbtamsßankarN_. sñaédd¾l,Il,ajrbs;Kat;kñúgkardwknaMRbCashKmn_ «tacay» CaTIEdlKat;

xñHExñgerobcMdak;[GnuvtþdMbUnµanrbs; em:A sþIBI «PaBÉkraCüm©as;karxagvis½yksikmµ»enaH )anruj

RcanKat; [QaneLIgdl;kMBUlénzananuRkmbkSy:agqab;rh½s. «edIrtamKMrUshkrN_ tacay» KWCa

BaküesøakEdlTTYl)aneCaKC½yy:agRtcHRtcg;Pøam²edaysar em:A. xagneya)ay ecn

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 231

Page 242: Brother enemy

RbEhlBuMEmnCa«mnusSsMxan;»mñak;eT b:uEnþ Kat;man«rebobniyay»dUcExµrRkhmEdr dUecñHKat;man

P½BVvasnaTaMgRsugkñúgkareFVI[ b:ul Bt yl;citþKña.

enAéf¶TI3 ExFñÚ qñaM1977 ecn )aneLIgynþehaHeq<aHmkRkúgPñMeBj. karsñak;GaRs½yd¾kRm

rbs;Kat;manfirevladb;éf¶. edIm,IbnÞrRBwtþikarN_enH TIPñak;garB½t’mancinfµI)ancuHpSaybTGtßaFib,ay

mYymancMNgeCIgfa ³ «mitþPaBkm<úCa-cin )ancak;b£sy:ageRCAnigrIklUtlas;RtkuMRtkal» Edl

rMB£keLIgvijBIGtßiPaBéncMNgTak;TgCaRbvtþisa®sþrvagcin-km<úCa nigniyayBIkarKaMRTrbs;cincMeBaH

b:ul Bt mþgeTot. ecn )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;tMbn;RBMEdnCaTIEdlkarvayRbyuT§KñakMBugRbRBwtþeTA.

kareFVIdMeNIrenHRtÚv)anRbkas[dwgCasaFarN³edaykm<úCa RbEhledIm,IeFVI[RbeTsevotNam

cab;GarmµN_ehIyemIleTA b:uEnþkñúgsunÞrkfaTaMgb:unµanrbs;Kat; ecn ecosvagminniyayedaycM²BIkar

vayRbyuT§KñaenHeT. eKmindwgfaetI ecn mansßitenAkEnøgenaHeT enAéf¶TI5 ExFñÚ qñaM1977 kñúgeBl

EdlmankarvayRbharrbs;evotNamkñúgtMbn;mYy EdleKehAfa«cMBuHesk»enaH?. b:uEnþR)akdNas;

fa Kat;)ansEmþgkarKaMRTrbs;cincMeBaHkm<úCa edayBaküeBcn_minsUvlHfa23 «KµanGñkNamñak;Gac

enABaMgBImuxrvageyIgTaMgBIr)aneT. RbeTscin nigkm<úCaCabgb¥ÚnnwgKñaGs;kalCaerogrhUt»24.

karniyayrebobsÞak;esÞIrrbs;cinenH RbEhlCaeFVI[km<úCaTas;citþxøaMgEdlnwgbkRsay[

dwgfa ]bnaykrdæm®nþI vn ev:t -GnaKtCaGñkrgeRKaHedaykare)assm¥atrbs; b:ul Bt- man

krNIykic©RtÚvEtBnül;[)anc,as;las;nigCak;lak;edIm,IecosvagkarPn½þRcLMepSg² ³ «RbeTs

km<úCanwgminbeNþay[eKeFVI[ERbkøayCafµImþgeToteTACarNbRbeTsNamYyCadac;xat. km<úCanwg

minGt;»ncMeBaHkarrMelaPbMBanNamYymkelIEdndIb¤EdnTwkrbs;xøÜneToteLIy. smmitþcinrbs;

eyIgGacsmÁal;eXIjnUvkarebþCJacitþrbs;kgT½Bbdivtþn_km<úCaehIy EdlseRmccitþeFVI[bMNgR)afña

d¾Bisidærbs;xøÜnTTYl)aneCaKC½yBitR)akdrhUtdl;TIbMput». TMngCaG‘ÍcwgEmn. eTaHCay:agNa

k¾eday k¾esckþIEføgkarN_CasaFarN³rbs; ecn GMBIerOgenHmanlkçN³lak;elomKYr[kt;smÁal;.

PkþIPaB nigvIrPaBrbs;kgT½Bkm<úCaKµaneBlNamYyEdlminRtÚvrMB£kenaHeLIy.

pÞúyeTAvij ecn )anGbGrsresIry:agkk;ekþAnUveKalKMniténdMeNIrTaMgbgçMmYyeq<aHeTAkan;lT§i

kumµúynIsþEdlmantémøbMputsRmab; b:ul Bt. shkrN_ksikmµ? tammtirbs; ecn shkrN_

TaMgenaH)anedIrtYnaTId¾sMxan;mYykñúg«kareFVI[skmµPaBviT§gSnaepSg²rbs;sRtÚvbraC½ynigkarBRgwg

GMNacpþac;karvNѳGFn»EfmeTot. enHKWCaneya)ayépÞkñúgrbs;ExµrRkhm?. tameyabl; ecn

dEdlfa vaCaneya)aymanlkçN³«RtwmRtÚvbMput».25

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg232

Page 243: Brother enemy

GnþraKmn_edIm,IsRmúHsRmÜlkarvivaT

xusKñaEtBIréf¶b:ueNÑaH ecn yu:ghSI GacCYbKñanwgRbFanaFibtILav KWRBHGgÁm©as; sUpanuvgS

enAGakasyandæaneBaFicintugminxan. TsSnkic©rbs;RBHGgÁ KWBitCamksRmúHsRmÜlkarvivaTrvag

km<úCa-evotNamy:agR)akd. Casm½<n§mitþrbs;evotNamsRmab;ehtuplpSg²Edlkt;smÁal;

edayneya)ayCak;Esþg nigsm,CBaسEdlrYmbBa©ÚlTaMgplRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜnpg RkúmemdwknaMLav

)ansegátBinitüRbkbkarRBÜy)armÖtictYcBIPaBtantwgEdlecHEtekIneLIgrvagbNþaRbeTsCitxag

xøÜn. enAqñaM1974 exov sMpn nig eGog sarI Føab;)aneTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtMbn;samenOEdlrMedaH)an

eday):aeftLavEdr. dUecñHBYkeKBuMGacbdiesFminTTYlRbmuxrdærbs;Lav)aneLIy enAeBlEdl

«lixitesñIsuM»)anRtÚvdak;CUntamry³sßanTUtrbs;xøÜnRbcaMRkúgevogc½nÞenaH.

RBHGgÁm©as;)anyagmkdl;PñMeBjenAéf¶TI17 ExFñÚ qñaM1977. BiFITTYlbdisNæarkic©d¾

]LarikmYyRtÚv)anerobcMeLIgenAGakasyandæan b:uEnþkarCYbKñarbs;RTg;CamYy b:ul Bt )anRtwmEt

Tuk[manesckþIsgS½yxøHb:ueNÑaH ³ karpþac;mitþPaB KWBitCaeCosminput. dMNwgsþIBIkarCYbKñaenH

BuMRtÚv)anpSBVpSayCasaFarN³eTtamkaresñIsuMrbs;km<úCa. kñúgnievsndæansRmab;bNþaRbmuxrdæ

breTssßitenAtammat;Tenøsab briyakasmansPaBtwgEtgy:agxøaMg. sUpanuvgS )ansakl,g

bBa©úHbBa©Úl b:ul Bt kuM[kat;pþac;ÉkPaBrvagRbeTsTaMgbIenA\NÐÚcin EdlFøab;rgTukçevTnarab;sibqñaM

kñúgkarRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgsRtÚvrYm. b:uEnþtamkarniyayrbs;GñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;Lavmñak;fa ³ «b:ul

Bt Kµancg;dwgcg;B¤GVITaMgGs;. Kat;niyayRTeKaHe)aHe)akRbqaMgnwgevotNamKµanQb;». cMENk

emdwknaMExµrRkhmk¾BuMGacjúaMg[ sUpanuvgS eCOBIPaBcaM)ac;kñúgkarrkSakarBarÉkraCüPaBrbs;

RbeTsLav cMeBaHmuxRbeTsevotNam)anEdr. niyayedayxøI karCYbBiPakSaKñaenH)anERbRtLb;

eTACakarniyayKñasþab;Elg)anEtmþg.

k¾b:uEnþ «esþcRkhm» EdlGaCIBCaGñkbdivtþn_rbs;RBHGgÁCab;Tak;Tgy:agCitsñiT§nwgbkSkumµúy

nIsþ\NÐÚcinrbs;hUCImijenaH BuMcg;cakecjBIPñMeBj edayminTan;eFVI[TsSn³rbs;RBHGgÁRtÚveKdwg

B¤CasaFarN³eT. »kasRtÚv)anpþl;[RBHGgÁkñúgBiFIbdisNæarkic©mYyCakitiþysdl;RTg;. eday

cab;manbnÞÚlRBHGgÁRbkasenAcMeBaHmuxePJóvnigm©as;pÞHfa KNbkSkumµúynIsþLav«seRmcbnþParkic©

d¾CajC½yrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinteTAeTot ehIyvayRbyuT§RbekoksµaKñaCamYybNþaRbCaCn

km<úCanigevotNamCabgb¥ÚnCanic©». RBHGgÁk¾eqøIytbedaybBaäitbeBaäógcMeBaHkarriHKn;rbs;km<úCa

Tak;TgeTAnwgRbePT«TMnak;TMngGnþrrdæ» EdlbegáIteLIgedaykic©RBmeRBógevotNam-LavpgEdr.

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 233

Page 244: Brother enemy

tameyabl;RBHGgÁfa enHKWCa«KMrUénneya)aymitþPaBnigCaGñkCitxagl¥mYy EdltMNag[eKal

karN_rbs;eyIgTaMgRsugkñúgTMnak;TMngepSg²CaGnþrCati». PaBs¶b;s¶at;EdlnaM[tujtuHkñúgcitþ)an

ekItmankñúgTIRbCuMGñksþab;TaMgmUl. GñkkarTUtnigBYkm®nþIExµreLIgEbkejIseCakf¶as. eKetagEtrMB£k

fa éf¶enaHmansPaBekþAs¥úHs¥ab;cEmøkxusBIFmµtasRmab;ExFñÚ EdlCaExRtCak;bMput. dl;evnEdl

exov sMpn eLIgEføgsunÞrkfamþg Kat;)anTietonRbeTsLavedaymincMeBaHGMBIsm<n§½PaBrbs;xøÜn

CamYyRbeTsevotNam nigkarGnuBaØat[kgT½BevotNammke)aHTItaMgelITwkdIrbs;xøÜn. karrMB£k

rbs;Kat;manlkçN³c,as;las;Nas;. TMnak;TMngrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrmansgÇwmGacrIklUtlas;

eTA)anTal;EtBYkeKeCosvagmineRCótERCkkic©karépÞkñúgrbs;pgxøÜneTAvijeTAmk. CaBiessRbeTs

nImYy²RtÚvEtkarBarkMu[TwkdIrbs;xøÜnGacRtÚveRbICamUldæansRmab;kareFVIGnþraKmn_mYyRbqaMgnwg

RbeTsCitxagxøÜn.

eTaHCamanPaBtantwgEdlminTan;ecjmkc,as;k¾eday k¾KUsnÞnaTaMgBIrBMulHbg;PaBrak;Tak;nwg

KñaEdlmanEtsMbkeRkAEdr. eGog sarI RtÚv)anRTg; sUpanuvgS GeBa¢IjeTAbriePaK)ayl¶acmYyenA

sßanTUtLav. cMENkRBHGgÁ)anyageTARkúgesomrabdUcEdleRKagTukCamun tamynþehaH edes-3

kBa©as;mYyeRKÓg EdlrYcputBIeRKaHfñak;kalBIsm½ys®gÁamelakelIkTI2 edIm,IeFVITsSnkic©enA

R)asaTGgÁrvtþd¾l,Il,aj. kareFVIdMeNIrenHminGacbMePøc)aneLIy CaBiessedaysarGñkebIkynþ

ehaHrbs;km<úCaCayuvCnekµg²EdleTIbnwgmkBIeFVIkmµsikSafµI²enARbeTscin. GñkkarTUtmñak;Edl

EhhmRTg; sUpanuvgS )anrMB£kfa «eBlehaHeLIg nigeBlcuHsk;k,alBYkeyIgeLIgbHRcÚg. Tal;Et

cuHmkdl;dIvijeTIbeyIg)anFUrRsalkñúgcitþ»26.

éf¶TI26 ExFñÚ KWbYnéf¶bnÞab;BIRBHGgÁRtLb;mkRbeTsvij rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam egVón

DuyRTij )anecjdMeNIreTARbeTs\NÐÚensuI edayQb;sMctry³eBlxøIenARkúgevogcnÞ½. sUpanuvgS

)anR)ab; RTij [dwgBIkarlM)akepSg²kñúgkarsnÞnaKñaEdlRTg;eTIbnwgeFVICamYy b:ul Bt. RTij

)ansþab;B½t’manenHedayykcitþTukdak; edayminniyay[ sUpanuvgS dwgfa kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH

kgT½Brbs;evotNamCaeRcInExS )ansRmúkcUleTAkñúgRbeTskm<úCa tamBIeRkayhVÚgrfeRkaHeLIy.

edaymin[RbBn§½eXasnaBiPBelakTaMgmUldwg s®gÁam\NÐÚcinTIbIEdlemdwknaMLavR)afñaeCosvag

bMputenaH )ancab;epþImrYceRsceTAehIy.

evotNam)anbeBa©jeRbIkñúgRbtibtþikarnUvcMnYnTahanefµIreCIgd¾sem,ImmYy kñúgenaHmankg

ÉkPaBeqñImmYy KWkgBlFMelx9-EdlKaMRTedaykgkaMePøIgFMCaeRcInedIm. karvayRbhareday

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg234

Page 245: Brother enemy

RsuHKña)ancab;epþImecjBIcMNucenAtambeNþayRBMEdncMnYnR)aMmYykEnøgedayEckecjCaBIrmuxRBÜj

sMedAmkrkrdæFanIEtmþg. BImuxT½BrfeRkaHet-54 nigGuwm-113 CaeRcIneRKÓg )anRtaypøÚvtampøÚv

Catielx1nigelx7 eq<aHmkkan;RkúgPñMeBj. eKaledArbs;evotNam dUcEdl v:ag Tug R)ab;´[

dwgenAeBleRkaymkKW «TI1 ³ edjkm©at;ExµrRkhm[ecjputBITwkdIrbs;eyIgTI2 ³ vaybM)ak;BYkeK

[)ak;s,atmþg edIm,I[ExµrRkhmyl;fa karmintbtrbs;eyIgRKan;EtCasMbkeRkAb:ueNÑaH ehIyfa

pøÚvEtmYyEdlGacmanKWpøÚvénkarcrcaKña»27.

eKaledATImYYykñúgcMeNameKaledATaMgenaH)anTTYleCaKC½yswgEtKµanCYbkarlM)ak. kgT½B

rbs;evotNamEdlKaMRTedaykar)aj;kaMePøIgFMeRsacdUcePøóg )anT®nÞancUlkm<úCadUchVÚgRsemac.

kgT½BExµrRkhmCagmYyrynak;)anRtÚvsmøab; b¤rbYskñúgRbtibtþikare)assm¥atCaeRcInkEnøg. kñúg

cMeNamkgT½BEdlRtÚvrbYs GñkEdlmanP½BVvasna)anRtÚvbBa¢ÚnmkRkúgPñMeBjtamGRgwgEsg. b:uEnþ

mnÞIreBTüCaeRcInBuMmanERKBMuRKb;RKan;sRmab;TTYlGñkrbYsTaMgenaHeT. Qamk¾xVHxatsRmab;bBa©Úl[

GñkrbYs. karérGgÁasQammYy)anerobcMeLIgCabnÞan;BIRkúmemdwknaMmYykþab;tUc nigRkúmRKÜsar

rbs;BYkeKEdlrs;enARbmUlpþMúKñaenAtamCayrdæFanI. PaBcaM)ac;EdlRtÚvEteFVICabnÞan;kñúgsßanPaB

mYyEbbenH )anbgðaj[eXIjnUvkarP½nþRcLMy:agFMrbs;karbdivtþn_ExµrRkhm. RKÚeBTüCavNѳnay

Tunrab;rynak;)anRtÚvbBa¢Ún[eTAeFIVkarTaMgbgçMenACnbT. kñúgenaHRKÚeBTümYycMnYnFMRtÚv)ansmøab;

ecal. enAeBlenH mnÞIreBTüTaMgGs;suT§EtRtÚvkan;kab;edaybuKÁlikeBTüekµg²CakUnRbCaksikr

Edl)aneronsURtEpñkevC¢sa®sþbnþicbnþÜcb:ueNÑaH k¾køayCa«eBTübdivtþn_»Etmþg. karsakl,g

bBa©ÚlQam[GñkrbYsrbs;BYkeBTüTaMgenaH )anTTYllT§pledayPynþraymYy28.

karTb;Tl;Edl\tsNþab;Fñab;énkgT½BPUmiPaKrbs;ExµrRkhm min)anseRmceCaKC½yeLIy

ehIyRtÚv)ankemÞcedaykgrfeRkaHnigkar)aj;sn§ab;y:agsem,ImBIsMNak;sRtÚv. tamTissMedA

mkRkúgPñMeBj tMbn;CuMvijRkúgkMBg;camEdlCaTIRkúgd¾sMxan;sßittamdgTenøemKgÁRtÚvvaydeNþIm)an

edaymincaM)ac;RbyuT§. kgT½BevotNammYyExSeTot)anmkdl;mat;TVarextþsVayerogEdr. ExS

karBarCaeRcInkEnøgsuT§EtRtÚvevotNamvayTmøúHTmøayTaMgGs;. BitNas; bNþakgÉkPaBrbs;

PUmiPaKbUB’a RBmTaMgkgBlelx4¬enAeRkam»vaTmCÄim¦ EdlbBa¢aeday ehg sMrin )an)ak;T½Brt;

EbkExJkKñaenAmuxkarrulcUlrbs;kgBlevotNamCaeRcInkg.

bNþaemdwknaMRkúgPñMeBj EdlRtÚveFVI[RsLaMgkaMgedaykarvaylukd¾sem,ImxusEbøkBIFmµta

rbs;evotNam nigEdlRtÚveFVI[Lb;sµartIedaykar)ak;T½Brt;r):at;r):ayrbs;kgT½BPUmiPaKbUB’a BMu)an

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 235

Page 246: Brother enemy

sakl,gGgVrrksnþiPaBdUcEdlevotNamFøab;nwksgÇwmeLIy. enAéf¶TI25 ExFñÚ sm½yRbCMuvisamBaØ

mYyrbs;KN³dwknaMExµrRkhm)anebIkeFVIenARkúgPñMeBj. eK)anseRmccitþbBa¢ÚnT½BCMnYyeTAkan;

rNsirSbUB’a ehIyCaBiesseqøIytbnwgkarvaylukEpñkeyaFa edaykarbegáInkarvaylukEpñk

neya)aykan;EtxøaMgeLIg. b:ul Bt nigRkúmrbs;Kat;snñidæanfa GaceFVIeTA)anedIm,Idak;RbeTs

evotNam[enARtwmkarTb;Tl;b:ueNÑaH edaybriharcMeBaHmuxBiPBelak BIkarkan;kab;PaKxagekIt

RbeTskm<úCa. R)akdehIyTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUtc,as;CaRtÚvkat;pþac;. RKb;y:ageq<aHeTAkarerobcM

«vayRbhar»xagkarTUt EdlExµrRkhmhak;dUcCaminxVayxVl;hYsehtuBIkarvaybkrbs;xøÜneLIy.

ExµrRkhmeCOCak;fa «eyIgGacTb;Tl;BYkevotNam)an. enAeBlRbkaspSaydMNwgenHCasaFarN³

BiPBelakTaMgmUlnwgbeBa©jRbtikmµminxan»29.

karpþac;mitþPaB

KW mij elxaFikarTImYyénsßanTUtevotNamRbcaMRbeTskm<úCa )ancab;epþImkargartamTmøab;

RbcaMéf¶rbs;Kat;edaysþab;viTüúRkúgPñMeBj EdlCameFüa)ayEtmYyKt; Kat;GacTTYl)anB½t’man

epSg²sþIBICMhrrbs;rbb b:ul Bt. erogral;éf¶resol esckþIcmøgCaPasa)araMgmYyBIkarpSay

tamviTüúenAeBlRBwkRtÚv)anEck[RKb;sßanTUtTaMgGs;. b:uEnþ mij EdlecHniyayPasaExµr\tex©aH

enaH cUlcitþsþab;dMNwgepSg²tamviTüúvijCaCagrg;caMesckþIbkERbEdleKEck[. RBwkéf¶TI31 ExFñÚ

qñaM1977enH ekItmanerOgcEmøkmYyxusBIsBVdg. CMnYskarcak;pSaybTePøgbdivtþn_mYycMnYn

nigB½t’manepSg²tamTmøab; viTüú)ancab;epþImkarpSayrbs;xøÜnenAevlaem:ag 6RBwkedayesckþI

RbkasBiessmYy EdlkMNt;nUvkarepþImkareXasnay:agxÞrxÞarmYyRbqaMgnwgevotNam Edlmin

EdlB¤esaHkñúgkarTMnak;TMngepSg² rvagbNþaRbeTssgÁmniym«Cabgb¥Ún» ³

«edaycat;TukkarQøanBand¾eXareXA nigéRBépSEdleTIbnwgRbRBwtþeLIgedayRbeTsevotNam

RbqaMgnwgkm<úCaRbCaFibetyünigRbCaCnsøÚtRtg;rbs;eyIg edaycat;TukGakb,kiriya Gmitþ nig

bMNgGaRkk;rbs;rdæaPi)alsaFarNrdæsgÁmniymevotNam>>>rdæaPi)alkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü)an

seRmccitþkat;pþac;ral;TMnak;TMngkarTUtTaMgGs;CamYysaFarNrdæsgÁmniymevotNamCabeNþaH

Gasnñ cab;BIéf¶TI31 ExFñÚ qñaM1977 enHteTArhUtTal;EtkgT½BQøanBanevotNamdkfyBITwkdId¾Bisidæ

rbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyünigbriyakasmitþPaBmYyrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrRtÚv)anEklm¥eLIgvij»30.

bYnem:ageRkaymk GñknaMsarmñak;EdlmanTwkmuxmuWgm:at;kñúgnamrdæm®nþIkarbreTsrbs;km<úCa

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg236

Page 247: Brother enemy

)anmkdl;sßanTUt EdlkñúgsarenaHmann½yCaesckþIRbkasbeNþjecjEtmþg ³ buKÁliksßanTUt

rbs;evotNam)anRtÚvsMu[cakecjBIRkúgPñMeBjkñúgs)aþh_enH. enAéf¶TI3 Exmkra qñaM1978 KW

mij nigshkarIrbs;Kat; )aneFVIdMeNIreTARkúghUCImij tamynþehaHBiessmYyeRKÓgEdleK

CYlmk. Gvtþmanrbs;Kat; RbEhlCamanry³eBlxøIbMput eRBaHmYyqñaMeRkaymkKat;)anvilRtLb;

mkRkúgPñMeBj «EdlRtÚv)anrMedaH»vijtamk,ÜnrfeRkaHrbs;kgT½BevotNam. ÉkGKÁrdæTUtkm<úCa

RbcaMRkúghaNUy sux Xag mansMNagticCag mij eTAeTot. kñúg»kasénkarecjdMeNIrrbs; Xag

Kat;)an»befIblaKña CamYymitþevotNammñak; enHCaerOgeFVsRbEhsmYyEdleKcminputBIExSEPñk

GñkkarTUtcin EdlmanvtþmanenAGakasyandæaneLIy. mindwgfa etIehtukarN_enH vaCamUlehtuén

P½BVGaRkk;rbs;Kat; b¤y:agNaeT eRBaHKat;)anRtÚvsmøab;eRkayBIRtLb;mkRkúgPñMeBjvij )anEt

cMnYnbIExb:ueNÑaH31.

ExµrRkhmsuT§Etmanehtupl. karRbkaspSayEdleFVIeLIgedayviTüúPñMeBj BitCaeFVI[

BiPBelakTaMgmUlPJak;ep¥IlRsLaMgkaMgEmn. mindl;bIqñaMpg eRkayBIkarbBa©b;CemøaH\NÐÚcin s®gÁam

)ancab;keRmIkCafµImþgeTot. RbeTskumµúynIsþBIrEdlCaGtItsm<n§½mitþ)anvayRbyuT§KñaCacMheday

bBa©b;y:agKMhuknUvkarniyayedomdam nigkarKMramEhkekrþ×Kñarab;ExmkehIysþIBIGFikrN_ Edl

sµan²rbs;RbeTseKTaMgBIr. Pøam²enaH tulüPaBkmøaMgkñúgGasuIPaKGaeKñy_)anRtÚveFVI[Pan;ERb.

»kasEdleRCIserIsedayExµrRkhmGacBuMRbesIreT. karpþac;TMnak;TMngCasaFarN³rbs;eK

)aneFVI[RkúghaNUyxVayxVl;citþxøaMgEmnETn edaysarrdæm®nþIkarbreTsrbs;xøÜneTIbnwgcab;epþIm

dMeNIrTsSnkic©mYyenAtambNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþkñúgGasuIGaeKñy_ edIm,Isakl,gerobcM[

manTMnak;TMngCaGñkCitxagl¥CamYyRbeTsTaMgenaH. vaTMngfa evotNammin)anbgáarCamuncMeBaH

Rbtikmµqab;rh½srbs;km<úCaeLIy. mþgenH karykcitþTukdak;rbs;saFarNCnBiPBelak )anepþat

eTAelI«s®gÁamrvagsmmitþnigsmmitþ»ehIy. eKetagEteFVIRbtikmµtbtvij. RkúmGñkeFVIkarxag

kareXasnaCapøÚvkarnwgGacsb,ayrIkrayxøaMg. RkúghaNUy)ancab;epþImpSBVpSayCasaFarN³

edayBaküeBcn_c,as;las;nUvB½t’many:ageRcIn Tak;TgeTAnwgkarrMelaPbMBanrbs;ExµrRkhm CaBiess

karvayRbharpÞÜn²RbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNam.

etIRkúgPñMeBjmanBieRKaHCamYyRkúgeb:kaMgeT munnwgRbRBwtþkMhusEdlEkminekItenH? etI

BYkcinRtÚv)anpþl;B½t’man[Etb:uNÑwgeTb¤? karraErkcitþrbs; ecn y:ughSI kalBIdb;éf¶munkñúgkar

Rbkan;CMhrCacMhsþIBICemøaHRBMEdnhak;dUcCas[eXIjfa vaKµan)ankarGVIeT ehIyfakarpþac;TMnak;

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 237

Page 248: Brother enemy

TMngkarTUtRtÚv)anseRmcedayRkúgPñMeBj edIm,IbgçM[RbeTscineFVIGVImYypÞúynwgqnÞ³rbs;xøÜn32.

smasPaBepSgeTotk¾CYyKaMRTkñúgn½yenHEdr. ]TahrN_ ehtuGVI)anCaBYkemdwknaM km<úCaBMu

kt;smÁal;fa CMnYyeyaFaEdlRbeTscinsnüapþl;[EbrCaRtÚvBnüareTAvij? ¬tamkarBit RbeTs

cinRtÚvkareBlevlamYyqñaMknøH edIm,IRbkan;tamBaküsnüarbs;xøÜnkalBIExkumÖ³ qñaM1976¦?.

ehtuGVI)anCaBYkemdwknaMExµrRkhmBMuPJak;ep¥IlnwgkarrvaMgRby½tñrbs;etg?. enAExtula qñaM1976

etg EdlRtÚvsaksYredayGñkkaEstmñak;sþIBICemøaHenH )anRbkasfa «bBaðaTaMgGs;nwgseRmcCa

lT§pledayxøÜnÉg. eyIgyl;RsbcMeBaHkarebIk[mankarcrcaKñaBitR)akd. eyIgecosvagmin

vinicä½ycMeBaHGVIEdlmanlkçN³RtwmRtÚvnigGVIEdlminmaneLIy»33. kalBImYyqñaMmun b:ul Bt )an

ecaTRbkan;emdwknaMciny:agRBegIyfa eFVIxøÜnCa«GñkRbqaMgbdivtþn_mñak;». etg kMBugBRgwgCMhrrbs;

Kat;kñúgépÞbkSkumµúynIsþcin BYkExµrRkhmGacRtÚvkardak;bNþasm<n§½mitþrbs;xøÜnBImuxsßanPaBmYy

EdleKminGacERbRkLas;)an34.

edIm,Ibgðaj[eXIjsamKÁIPaBCamYykm<úCa GñkkarTUtcinEdlbMeBjmuxgarenARkúghaNUy min

GaceFVIGVIekIteRkAEtBIGmCUndMeNIrGñkkarTUtExµreTAkan;GakasyandæankñúgdMeNIrRtLb;mkRkúgPñMeBj

vijb:ueNÑaH edayqøgkat;tamTIRkúgeb:kaMg. b:uEnþ RbeTscinminsb,ayTal;EtesaH cMeBaHkarekIn

eLIgy:agxøaMgénCemøaHrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrnigkarpþac;TMnak;TMngkarTUtrbs;BYkeK. TIPñak;garB½t’mancin

fµI)anRsg;ykmkcuHpSayTaMgRsugnUvkarecaTRbkan;epSg²rbs;km<úCa b:uEnþk¾manerobrab;bBa©ÚlnUv

kareBalGHGagrbs;evotNamy:agxøIpgEdr. vaKµansgS½yeLIyfa BYkcinmancitþlem¥ógmkelI

km<úCa edayRKan;EtminniyayCacMhb:ueNÑaH b:uEnþ lMnaMEdlkaEstrbs;eKEvkEjkBICemøaH hak;dUc

Capþl;nUvGaTiPaBénkarcrcaCaCagkarbegáIns®gÁam. Rkúgeb:kaMgBMu)anbgðajkarekobsgát;eday

pÞal;eTAelIRkúghaNUyenAeLIyeT. P½sþútagKWfaenAéf¶TI10 Exmkra qñaM1978 BYkcin)anbnþkic©

RBmeRBógpþl;CMnYyhirBaØvtßúRbcaMqñaMeTA[evotNameTotedaymincaM)ac;BiPakSaKñaeT. enACMnan;enaH

ehtukarN_enHminrbUtputBIGñkCMnajkarxøHénrdæaPi)alGaemrikaMgeLIy Edlkt;smÁal;fa «BYkcin

GacBnüarkarcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBóg ebIsinCaBYkcincg;sEmþg[eXIjnUvkarRbqaMgrbs;eK

cMeBaHRkúghaNUy»35. Rkúgeb:kaMg)anyl;RBmsRmbsRmÜl[mankarCYbKñafµImYyrvagkm<úCanig

evotNamEfmeTotEdleXIjfa \t)anpldUckalBIRbCMuelIkmunEdr36.

CafµImþgeTot GñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;mñak;EtgEteFVIdMeNIry:agRbjab;mkkan;RkúgPñMeBj

edaynaMsMbuRtmYyBIfñak;dwknaMcinmkpg. elIkenHKWelakRsI etg yIgCav CaGñkneya)ayniym

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg238

Page 249: Brother enemy

kNþalmñak;. BitehIyRbeTscinxVayxVl;Nas;BIsnþisuxrbs;km<úCaEdlRbQmmuxnwg]tþmPaB

eyaFad¾elIslb;rbs;evotNam nigeRKaHfñak;epSg²EdlbNþalmkBIneya)aybgáehturbs;xøÜn

pg. b:uEnþmUlehtuénkarRBÜy)armÖcm,grbs;cinKWepSgBIenH. edayBit ebIsinCacinbeNþayxøÜn[

RbTajeTArkkareFVIGnþraKmn_edayeyaFaenAkm<úCa xøÜnc,as;CaTTYlrgeRKaHfñak;BIkarrIkraldalén

CemøaHenHminxan ehIyTMngCaGaceFVI[cMNgTak;TgrvagevotNamnigsUevotrwtEtrwgmaMeLIgEfmeTot.

R)akdNas; plRbeyaCn_rbs;cinBMuEmnbeNþay[CemøaHrbs;\NÐÚcinrbUtputBIkarRtÜtRtaTaMgRsug

eLIy. cMENkelakRsI etg k¾minsUvdak;esckþIsgÇwmelIRkúgPñMeBjb:unµanEdr. elakRsICamnusS

manKuNvibtþiedaysarKat;CaPriyaemm:ayénsBrdæm®nþITI1 CU eGnLay Edlkarsøab;rbs;Kat;)an

eFVI[ExµrRkhmmYycMnYnFMrIkraysb,aykñúgcitþ. mü:ageTot elakRsIk¾CamitþCitsñiT§nwgsemþc sIhnu

Edr EdleBlenaH RBHGgÁRtÚvExµrRkhmdak;kMhit[sßitenAEtkñúgnievsndæanrbs;RTg;enAkñúgrdæFanI

b:ueNÑaH37.

«enAeBlEdlknÞúybk;Eqá»

enAéf¶TI18 Exmkra qñaM1978 elakRsI etg )anmkdl;PñMeBjGmdMeNIredayshkarI

CaeRcInrUb kñúgenaHmanGnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs han nanLúg nigGñkÉkeTsxagbBaðaGasuIGaeKñy_CaeRcIn

rUbeTot. karsEmJg[eXIjBiFIeFVIbdisNæarkic©d¾GFikGFmEdleRtómbRmúgsRmab;elakRsI

RbEhlBMuEmnerobcMrebobbMPan;EPñkenaHeT. enA»kasenH RbeTscin)anTTYlrgbraC½ymYyy:ag

R)akd. tamkarBit taMgBIsrTrdUvqñaM1977 Rkúgeb:kaMg)anekobsgát;ExµrRkhm[BRgIkmUldæan

neya)ayrbs;xøÜn nigGnuBaØat[semþc sIhnu vilmkkan;GMNacvij. bu:EnþelakRsI etg BMuGac

eTACYbsemþc sIhnu )aneT eRBaH b:ul Bt )anCMTas;nwgerOgenH. elakRsI)anRbKl;[ExµrRkhm

nUvsarlixitmYyEdlepJIfVaysemþc sIhnu edayRBHraCbuRtImYyGgÁkñúgcMeNamRBHraCbuRtIrbs;

RBHGgÁKWRBHGgÁm©as;kSRtI bu)öaeTvI nadkar)aMenARkúg):arIs. ExµrRkhmminEdlyksarlixitenHeTA

fVayRBHGgÁesaHeLIy. enAeBlEdlelakRsICUneyabl;fa km<úCaRtÚvxñHExñgedaHRsaybBaða

epSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYyevotNamedaykarcrcaKñaenaH elakRsI)aneBIbRbTHnwgkarbdiesFmYyCafµI

mþgeTot. kñúgsgáfaCasaFarN³mYy etg yIgCav )anGHGagCafµInUvkarKaMRTrbs;RbeTscin cMeBaH

eKalkarN_TaMgR)aMénneya)aysnþishviC¢manEdltameyabl;elakRsIfa «RbeTsTaMgGs;kñúg

BiPBelakrYmTaMgbNþaRbeTssgÁmniympg RtÚvEtRbtibtþitameKalkarN_enH edIm,Isakl,g

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 239

Page 250: Brother enemy

edaHRsayTMnas;epSg²rbs;xøÜntamkarcrca»38.

RbFansPatMNagRbCaCn nYn Ca )aneqøIytbnwgelakRsI etg vijfa «RbCaCnkm<úCasuT§Et

CaGñkesñhaCatimatuPUmid¾emaHmut b:uEnþRbkbeTAedayvicarNBaØaN. BYkeKminEdlbgáerOgnwgGñk

Namñak;eLIy ehIyk¾minEdlmanbMNgnwgbgáEdr». b:uEnþ «RbCaCnkm<úCanwgvayRbyuT§dac;xat

RbqaMgnwgGMeBIviT§gSnanigviecäTkmµEdlRbRBwtþeLIgenAkñúgépÞRbeTs edIm,IpþÜlrMlMkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

RbqaMgnwgkarRbbicRbe)acTwkdIenAtamtMbn;RBMEdn RbqaMgRKb;karQøanBannigeKalbMNgvatTIBI

xageRkA»TaMgGs; 39.

eTaHCakareqøIybdiesFedayRbeyalenHenAminTan;RKb;RKan;k¾eday k¾RkúgPñMeBj)ansgát;

bBa¢ak;y:agxøaMgeTAelIcMNucmYy ³ tamry³viTüúrbs;xøÜn)anpSayEdleKR)akdCakMNt;fa karriHKn;mYy

EdlesÞIrEtKµanlak;elom sþIBICMhrrbs;cinmuneBlBYkePJóvcinerobcakecjBIRbeTseTAvij eday

ehtufaBYkeKkMBugsßitenAGgÁrenAeLIynaeBlresoléf¶TI20 Exmkra qñaM1978 enaH. bTGtßaFib,ay

EdlpSaytamviTüúmanlkçN³CabMNgmYyeRsceTAehIy ³ «RbCaCnkm<úCaeKarBedaymuWgm:at;cMeBaH

eKalkarN_ÉkraCüPaB GFibetyüPaB nigPaBm©as;kar ehIyEbgEckdac;RsLHrvagmitþnigsRtÚv

enAkñúgBiPBelakTaMgmUl>>>. RbeTskm<úCaCaRbeTsmYytUc RbPBFnFanrbs;xøÜnk¾xSt;exSaynigman

RbCaCntic>>>. b:uEnþ eRkamkardwknaMrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaRbCaCnrbs;eyIgmanlkçN³Gg;Gac

køahanbMput». CMnYyrbs;cin?. km<úCa«manTMnukcitþelIkmøaMgrbs;xøÜnÉgpÞal;». BitehIy¡ cMeBaH

muxkarQøanBan nigkarb:unb:gP¢ab;TwkdIrbs;evotNam RbeTskm<úCaBMuGacminRtÚvkarCMnYyKaMRTBIbNþa

mitþPkþirbs;xøÜneLIy b:uEnþkñúglkçxNÐfa RbeTsTaMgenaHRtÚvcat;Tukkm<úCaedayesµIPaBKña. enAeBl

enaH viTüúExµrRkhm)anniyaybBaäitbeBaäógminc,as;las;mYy cMeBaHkarb:unb:gsmøútKMramxøH Edlnwg

eFVI[mhaGMNacCamitþmYykøayCaGñkKYrbenÞaseTAvij ³ «eyIgecHEbgEckrvagmitþBitR)akd nigmitþ

Ekøgkøayc,as;las;. mitþBitR)akdeKarBeyIgnigRsLaj;eyIg BIeRBaHBYkeKminbgáGVI[b:HBal;

ÉkraCüPaB GFibetyüPaB nigbUrNPaBEdndIeyIgCafµIeLIy. CakarBitNas; mitþrbs;eyIgBuMEmn

CamitþEdlnaMmkpþl;[eyIgnUvCMnYyCasm<armYyeT b:uEnþ ecHpþl;nUvsarsMxan;xøHcMeBaHeyIg. kar

samKÁIKñaBitR)akd KWkareKarBKñaeTAvijeTAmkrbs;RbeTsnImYy²eTaHFMkþItUckþI. vaminEmn[RbeTs

mYy CMTas;nwgsiT§iekþabkþab;GnaKtpÞal;rbs;xøÜneT>>>»40.

PaBrbwgrwgrUsrbs; b:ul Bt )anbnßylT§PaBkñúgkareFVIskmµPaBrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg. eBjfir-

evlaénrdUvrgaqñaM1977 RbeTscink¾RBÜy)armÖGMBIneya)ay«eFVI[manPaBFUrRsal» cMeBaHmux

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg240

Page 251: Brother enemy

RkúgmUsÁÚrbs;rdæaPi)al xaF½r ¬Carter RbFanaFibtIGaemrikBIqñaM1977 dl; qñaM1981¦pgEdr Edl

tamkaremIleXIjrbs;xøÜnfa enHRKan;EtCakarbgðaj[eXIjBIPaBTn;exSayb:ueNÑaH. pÞúyeTAvij

RbeTscinBMucg;bgáerOgeday\tRbeyaCn_nwgRkúgmUsÁÚ edayKaMRTkm<úCaCacMhRbqaMgnwgevotNam

eLIy. karepþImBiPakSad¾RbúgRby½tñenH)anKMrameFVI[cin)at;bg;mitþPaBCamYysm<½n§mitþd¾RbesIrCag

eKenAGasuIGaeKñy_-Rbtikmµrbs;km<úCa )anbgðaj[eXIjy:agc,as;rYcmkehIy. dUecñH cinRtÚvEt

eFVIkareRCIserIsmYy. Rkúgeb:kaMg)ane)aHbg;yuT§viFI edIm,IeRbIyuT§sa®sþvij. vaTMngfa RkúmGñk

Rbkan;neya)ayeqVgkñúgépÞRkúmemdwknaMcinekItmankarCinNaynwgeFVIkarekobsgát;eTAelIsm<n§miRt

bdivtþn_mYy edIm,IbBaðayuT§viFIsamBaØmYyNas;. b:uEnþ mUlehtuepSg²eTot GacCMruj[Rkúgeb:kaMg

e)aHbg;GBüaRkwtPaBmindac;xatrbs;xøÜn. PaBrIkminrYcénkic©shkarsUevot-evotNamKWmanlkçN³

rebobenHÉg dUcKñanwgkareXasnavaylukRbqaMgcinEdlbgáeLIgPøam² edayBYksUevot b¤PaBkan;

EtF¶n;F¶rénbNþaCnCaticinenARbeTsevotNamEdr. enABak;kNþalExkumÖ³ qñaM1978 ®hÁIháÚrI

r:Um:aNUv smaCikkariyal½yneya)aybkSkumµúynIsþsUevot )aneFVIdMeNIreday\tRBagTukCamun

mYyeTAkan;RkúghaNUynigRkúghUCImij. enAéf¶TI21 ExkumÖ³ evotNam)anecjpSayCasaFarN³

nUvesckþIEføgkarN_mYyEdlminxusBIkarefáaleTasRbeTscintampøÚvkareLIy. tamBit viTüúhaNUy

)anpSay[dwgfa mhaGMNacbreTsmYy)aneRbIR)as;TwkdIkm<úCaedIm,IQøanBanRbeTsevotNam.

«BYkcRkBtþiniymnigBYkRbtikiriyaGnþrCati )anCYy]btßmÖkm<úCa[begáIt nigbMBak;GavuF[kgT½BcMnYn

db;BIrkgBlFM manTaMgkaNugFM)aj;)anry³q¶aynigynþehaHRbyuT§CaeRcIneRKÓg EdlBImunenHbnþic

kgT½Bkm<úCaminEdlmaneRbIR)as;eLIy»41.

RbeTscin)anbBa©b;y:agqab;rh½snUvkarRbwgERbgTaMgb:unµanrbs;xøÜn edIm,IeFVI[seRmcdMeNaH

RsaymYyedaykic©crca eTaHCacincuHcaj;karKMramEhkekrþ×rbs; b:ul Bt eTaH CacindwgPøam²BITMhM

éneKaledAxageyaFarbs;evotNamk¾eday. edayehtuenH GBüaRkwtPaB¬PaBCaGñkkNþal¦rbs;

xøÜntamEdleKsmÁal;eXIjKWRtÚvcb;. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH k):al;cinCaeRcIneRKÓg)ancab;epþImerI

eRKÓgsmÖarswkdak;cuHenAkMBg;EpkMBg;esammankaNug130mIløIEm:Rt Edl)aj;)anry³q¶ay

kaMePøIgRbqaMgrfeRkaHTMhMFM rfeRkaHflClik¬cuHTwkk¾)anelIeKakk¾)an¦mYycMnYnFM42. enAéf¶TI26

ExkumÖ³ qñaM1978 rdæm®nþITI1 hVa KUehVg )ane)aHbg;CapøÚvkarminepþImclnaeFVI[rIkceRmIndl;

dMeNaHRsaymYyelImUldæanéneKalkarN_snþishviC¢manTaMgR)aMeLIy. Kat;Eføgfa «KµanRbeTs

NamYymansiT§isVHEsVgbegáItGnutþrPaBrbs;xøÜnkñúgtMbn;mYyénBiPBelak)aneLIy ehIyk¾Kµan

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 241

Page 252: Brother enemy

siT§ibgçM[RbeTsNamYyepSgeToteFVItamqnÞ³rbs;xøÜnEdr ¬KWsMedAeTAelIevotNamy:agc,as;¦.

tameyabl;eyIgKWRtg;enHehIyCalkçN³vinicä½yd¾sMxan;EdlGacbgðajfa etIRbeTsmYy)an

RbtibtþieTAtameKalkarN_snþishviC¢manEdrb¤k¾Gt;»43.

enAedImExmkra qñaM1978 eBlEdls®gÁamtamrlkFatuGakasrvagRkúgPñMeBjnigRkúg

haNUykMBugBuHke®Ba¢alxøaMg kgÉkPaBCaeRcInrbs;km<úCaEdldkykmYyPaKBIbNþakgBlFMén

PUmiPaKkNþal)aneFVIclnaeq<aHmkPaKxagekIt. kgBlFMTaMgenaH)anRtÚvdwknaMbBa¢aedaymnusS

sMxan;bInak;rbs;rbbenH KWrdæm®nþIRksYgkarBarRbeTs sun esn embBa¢akarPUmiPaKkNþal Ek Bk

nig PUmiPaKnirtI tam:uk. b:uEnþkgT½Brbs;RkúghaNUy)anvayRbyuT§dkfynigvileTAkan;mUldæannana

rbs;xøÜnvij edaymincg;[mankarb:HTgÁicKñaeLIy.

kñúgeKalbMNgbiT)aMgbraC½yRKadMbUgrbs;xøÜn eBlenaHExµrRkhm)ancab;epþImeRbIyuT§nakar

y:agxøaMgkøabEnßmeTotedIm,Ibgðaj[eXIjfa «kardkfyRbkbedaysucänÞ³rbs;evotNam» KWCa

«mhaC½yCmñHCaRbvtþisa®sþ»mYy. éf¶TI6 Exmkra qñaM1978 KWRtÚvcarwkCaGkSrmaskñúgtaragéf¶

ExqñaMénRbvtþisa®sþ TukdUcCaéf¶KYr[cgcaMEdlExµr)anvaykm©at;km©aykgT½BQøanBand¾xøaMgBUEkrbs;

evotNam. edIm,IGbGrC½yCmñH«)aymYycan»eTot)anRtÚvGgÁkarbEnßm[enAtamerag)aynana

EdlbRmúgTuksRmab;BYkkmµaPi)alénrbb. erOgr:avEdlminKYr[eCOTaMgenH )ancab;epþImpSBVpSay

[dwgB¤enAkñúg»kassmiTÞIgepSg²nigkEnøgCaeRcIneTot. ]TahrN_ eKniyayfa BYkyuT§Cnd¾Gg;Gac

køahannigd¾xøaMgBUEkGs©arürbs;eyIg)ankemÞcrfeRkaHrbs;evotNamCagdb;eRKÓg ehIyfa BYkeK

)anykrfeRkaHTaMgGs;eTArMlayEkécñeFVICacan)aycansmøCaedIm.

minyUrb:unµan kareFVIBiFId¾G‘åkGFwkenH RtÚv)anCMnYsedayrlkfµImYyénkarsmøab;rgÁal. ebIsin

evotNamseRmceCaKC½yvaycUleRCAkñúgTwkdIkm<úCaCeRmA33KILÚEm:Rt ehIyRbCaCnExµrrab;Ban;nak;

)aneqøót»kasenaHrt;eTARCkekanenAkñúgTwkdIevotNamKWminGacfaGñkTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’a

suT§EtCaRkúmmnusSk,t;eLIy. y:agehac enHKWCakaredjrkehtuplrbs;KN³mCÄimbkS. minyUr

b:unµaneRkaymk embBa¢akarkgBlelx4)anRtÚvsmøab;edaysnþisuxmñak;EdlesµaHRtg;nwg b:ul Bt

)aj;mYyRKab;cMk,al44.

kñúglMnaMpSaydUcsBVdgrbs;xøÜn viTüúRkúgPñMeBj)anRbkasrebobbeBaäógfa Parkic©fµIEdlCa

katBVkic©sRmab;RbeTsCati KWcab;BIéf¶enHteTARtÚvkarBar «mnÞIrRksYgnanaedaykemÞcBYksRtÚv

EdlykkEnøgTaMgenaHeFVICaCRmkrbs;va xµaMgmYycMnYntUc)anlak;xøÜnenATIenaHtaMgBIyUrmkehIy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg242

Page 253: Brother enemy

xøHeTotkMBugeRCótcUlkalBIeBlfµI²enH». RbCaCnkm<úCaTaMgGs;RtÚvEtCRmúHecjBIstiGarmµN_

rbs;xøÜnCadac;xatnUvkMEGlsgÁmcRkBtþiniym mUlFnniymnigRbtikiriya>>>nigkemÞcvNѳekgRbv½Ba©

TaMgGs;>>>km©at;ecalKMnitbuKÁlniym sYntYniym nigksagRbeTsedayel,ÓnelOnrh½sCa

TIbMput»45. kardak;[Gnuvtþneya)ayenH manrYmbBa©ÚlkarbEnßmeBlem:ageFVIkar karbnßyrbb

Gahar karbegáIny:agxøaMgkøakñúgkarEsVgrknigkarkemÞcGñkEdlmanKMnitminl¥. bNþaextþEdlRtÚv

evotNamlukluy )anTTYlrgnUvkare)assm¥atnigsmøab;xøaMgCageK.

GñkrgeRKaHEdlmanmuxmuneK KWBYkkmµaPi)alExµrRkhmnigRKÜsarTaMgmUlrbs;BYkeK. cab;epþIm

enAExmkra qñaM1978 rlkénkare)assm¥atfµIEdlmanlkçN³sahavéRBépSCaBiessenaH )an

eLIgdl;kRmitx<s;bMputenAEx]sPa CamYykarsmøab;rgÁaly:ageRcInEdlmanCabnþbnÞab;BIkarb:unb:g

egIbbHe)armin)anseRmcmYy. GñkTTYlxusRtÚvsMxan;CageKkñúgyuT§nakarkab;smøab;enH KWédsþaM

rbs; b:ul Bt eQµaH tam:uk CabkçCnkumµúynIsþeCIgcas;mñak;Edldak;esckþITukcitþeTAelIemdwknaMkMBUl

rbs;xøÜnTaMgRsúg. enHCaeKaRtnamEtmYyKt;rbs;ksikrrUbenH EdlmanragkaysÁmkMRBwg/ k,al

eLIgRtegal nigEPñkmut EdlRKb;RKan;júaMg[Kat;begáItsb,diP½y)an. kgT½Brbs;Kat;Edlman

RbPBedImenAPUmiPaKnirtI manlkçN³elceFøaCageK edaysarPaBeXareXAdac;ELkmYyTaMgRsug.

eRkamkarbgÁab;bBa¢arbs;Kat; kgT½BTaMgenH)anRbRBwtþGMeBIkab;smøab;y:aghYsRbmaN CaBiess

enAPaKxagekItRbeTs. ehIyenHRKan;EtCakarsak[dwgCabzmb:ueNÑaH. kñúglMdab;Edlkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyüERbkøayRbeTsxøÜn[eTACaCMrMXMuXaMgmYyenaH karsmøab;mnusSTaMghVÚg)anraldal

y:agqab;rh½sBaseBjépÞRbeTs46.

enAeBlEdlrbb b:ul Bt erobcMxøÜny:agecjmuxedIm,Isakl,g[dwgkmøaMg edaye)assm¥at

CYrT½Brbs;xøÜnpÞal; edayBRgwgbEnßmcMnYnmnusSnigeRKÓgyueT§abkrN_[kgT½Brbs;xøÜnenaH evotNam

EbrCacUlcitþerobcMGVI²edays¶at;kM)aMgCag.

RkúghaNUyerobcMEpnkarepSg²sRmab;RbeTskm<úCa

taMgBIkarbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTseLIgvij erogral;rdUvrga BYkemdwknaMCan;x<s;rbs;evotNam )an

cakecjBIPaBRtCak;nigkarcuHG½BÞenARkúghaNUy edIm,ImkrkBnøWRBHGaTitüenAPaKxagt,Úgvij KWenA

CMnan;cUlqñaMfµIrbs;evotNam. R)akdNas; enHCa»kasd¾RbesIredIm,IedIrTsSnkic©tameragcRk/

shkrN_nigbnÞayTahanTaMgLay nigeFVI)azkfaCasaFarN³GbGrcMeBaH «karcab;epþImksaglT§i

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 243

Page 254: Brother enemy

sgÁmniymd¾CajC½y». b:uEnþ kñúgcenøaHTsSnkic©BIr PaBRtCak;RsYlénFatuGakas )anCMruj[man

kareFVIvisSmkalCaFmµta. b:uEnþ qñaMenHKWElgdUcmuneTotehIy. enAPaKxagt,Úg )anekItmanRBwtþi-

karN_FM²CaeRcIn EdlBuMmankarTak;TgNamYynwgkareFVIeTscrN_eT. enAdMNac;Exmkra qñaM1978

bNþasmaCikkariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam)anmkCYbKñay:ags¶at;kM)aMgCafµIenA

RkúghUCImijsRmab;karCYbRbCuMCahUrEhmYy edIm,IGnum½tKeRmagkarepSg². karkat;pþac;cMNgTak;

TgkarTUtedayExµrRkhm)aneFVI[evotNamTas;citþy:agxøaMg. CemøaHEdlevotNamykcitþTukdak;

rkSaTukCakarsm¶at;enaH enAeBlenH)anelceLIgenAelI«TMB½rTImYy»énkaEstnanakñúgBiPBelakTaMg

mUl. GaRkk;CagenHeTAeTot evotNamRtÚv)anecaTRbkan;CafµInigRtÚvsgS½yfa manbMNg«elb

Rt)ak;» RbeTsCitxagxøÜnEdlTn;exSayCag. vIrbursénkarRbyuT§ts‘URbqaMgnwgcRkBtþiBImSil enA

eBlenH)anRtLb;mkedIrtYCacRkBtþitUcmYyvij.

kariyal½yneya)ayrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam)anRbwgERbgerobcMtulükarénkarcUl

lukluy kalBIExFñÚ qñaM1977. ExµrRkhmFøab;RtÚvevotNamEktRmg;pøÚvkuM[edIrxusEdr b:uEnþ BYkeK

BMuEdlbgðaj[eXIjfa manbMNgEkERbeLIy. braC½yEpñkeyaFarbs;ExµrRkhmBMubgá[man

rdæRbharEdlsgÇwmedayevotNam TaMgk¾BMueFVI[rdæGMNacrbs;eKvinasGnþrayEdr. manEtCnCati

Exµr60>000nak;b:ueNÑaH Edl)anseRmccakecjBIRbeTstamBIeRkaykgT½BevotNam. taMgBI

qñaM1975 manRbCaCnkm<úCa evotNam nigcin srubTaMgGs; 300>000nak; )anrt;eKcecjBI

rbb b:ul Bt eTArs;enAmçageToténRBMEdnRbeTs. RkúghaNUyKµanEdlniyaymYym:at; b:uEnþ

eBlenHCaeBlEdlRtÚvbgðajR)ab;BiPBelak[dwgBIkarcakecalRsukTaMghVÚgTaMghVayenHehIy.

vabgáCaP½sþútagCak;EsþgénesckþIs¥b;ex<Im EdlbMpuseLIgedayRbeTskm<úCarbs; b:ul Bt. Rkúg

haNUyk¾TTUcsMuGnþraKmn_BI]tþmsñgkarGgÁkarshRbCaCatiTTYlbnÞúkCnePosxøÜnpgEdr.

enAExmIna qñaM1978 ´¬GñkniBn§¦man»kas)aneTATsSnaenACMrMebnsaj; CakEnøgEdlBBak;

BBUneTAedayGñkePosxøÜnExµr EdlmkeTIrenARtwmextþtaynijrbs;evotNamenH. «CMrM»enHKµanGVI

eRkAEtCadIvals¶ÜthYtEhg nigRkaledayFUlId¾FMlVwgelVIy nigCaTIEdlRbmUlpþúMeTAedaykUnxÞmeFVIBI

b£sSInigRbk;cMebIg[Et)an²b:ueNÑaH. ´GacsnÞnaKñaedayesrICamYyGñkePosxøÜnTaMgenaH Edltam

karBit CatYmnusSmanlkçN³BiessCagmun. karcab;GarmµN_y:agc,as;las;bMputrbs;´ KWfakar

TTYl[sñak;GaRs½yrbs;evotNam KWmanehtuplmYyepSgeToteRkABIehtuplsb,úrsFm’. ´)an

CYbsYryuvnarIsa®sþacarümñak;EdlevotNamcat;[TTYlbnÞúkniyaylatRtdagR)ab;GñksarB½t’manBI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg244

Page 255: Brother enemy

PaBsahaveXareXArbs;ExµrRkhmfa ³ «etIGñkRtLb;eTAkm<úCavijeT?». nag)aneqøIyCaPasa

)araMgTaMgminR)akdkñúgxøÜnfa «ca+¡enAeBlEdlRbeTsTaMgmUlRtÚv)anrMedaH». rMedaHedayGñkNa?

vaCasßanPaBlM)aky:agCak;Esþg sRmab;GñkTTYlxusRtÚvevotNamenATIenaH enAeBlEdlnageqøIy

fa «R)akdNas;edaykgT½BevotNam». vaTMngfaKUsnÞnarbs;́ )anTTYlkarbgÁab;bBa¢adac;xatmin[

elIkniyayBIGtßiPaBénclnats‘UmYyEdlkMBugEteRCIserIsmnusS[eFVIT½BenAevotNamenaHeLIy.

GñkePosxøÜnÉeTot²)anniyayR)ab;´CaÉkCnfa kñúgCMrMtaynijEtmYyKt; manmnusSRbúsRsI

RbEhl2Ban;nak;RtÚv)aneRCIserIs[cUleFVIT½BedIm,IvayRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgrbbb:ulBt. dUecñH

kñúgeBlEdl]tþmsñgkarTTYlbnÞúkCnePosxøÜncab;epþImr:ab;rgnUvkarpÁt;pÁg;es,ógGahardl;GñkenArs;

kñúgCMrMenH evotNamk¾TTYlbnÞúkpÁt;pÁg;ExµrEdlbRmúgsRmab;karRbyuT§eTAtamEbbbTrbs;xøÜnEdr.

etImankarrIklUtlas;dUcemþcxøHtaMgBI em:A esTug nigRTwsþIs®gÁamRbCaCnrbs;Kat;EdlsMGagelI

karKaMRTrbs;RbCaCn nigkardak;xøÜn[sßitenAkñúgcMeNamGñkTaMgenaH«dUcRtIenAkñúgTwk».

kñúg»kasénsm½yRbCMurbs;kariyal½yneya)ayenAExmkra eL DwkfU Ca«eCIgcas;xagbBaða

km<úCa» )anepþImeFVIkarBiPakSasþIBIkRmiténkarRbQmmuxKñaenAeBlxagmuxqab;²enH. egVón kUfac;

rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam)anbBa¢ak;GHGagR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa ³ «karCYbBiPakSad¾twgEtgEdl eL

yn; )aneFVIenARkúgeb:kaMgkalBIExvicäika qñaM1977enaH )anjúaMg[Kat;eCOfa BYkemdwknaMcinBMurYjra

nwg«eRbIR)as;b:ulBtRbqaMgnwgeyIg»eLIy. mü:ageTot eRkayBITsSnkic©rbs;smaCikkariyal½y

neya)aybkSkumµúynIsþcinmñak;enAkm<úCaEtBIrs)aþh_b:ueNÑaH karkat;pþac;TMnak;TMngkarTUtenH )anbgçM

[evotNameRKagKitBIkareFVIGnþraKmn_kñúgTMhMy:agFMmYyenAkm<úCa. tammtirbs; fac; dEdlfa ³ «va

kan;Etc,as;ehIyfa RbeTscin)anerobcMeFVIs®gÁam ehIyeyIgRtÚvEtelIkykkareRCIserIsrbs;

eyIgmkBicarNaCafµIEdr». niyaymü:ageTotfa eyIgRtÚvEtbegáInkarRbúgeRbóberobcMEpñkeyaFa

nigsakl,geFVI[mankarxitcUlCitKñaEpñkkarTUtCamYyshrdæGaemrik nigbNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþ

enAGasuIGaeKñy_eTot. eBlevlaEdlRtÚvpÁúMkarekobsgát;EpñkeyaFanigkarGMBavnavCacMh[mankar

egIbbHe)armYyRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt )anmkdl;ehIy. dUecñH mYyEpñk KWRtÚvbegáItkgT½Brbs;clna

ts‘UExµrmYy ehIymYyEpñkeTot KWsakl,geFVIkarpþÜcepþImKMnitxagvis½ykarTUteLIgvij.

enAéf¶TI5 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1978 viTüúRkúghaNUy)anpSBVpSayCasaFarN³nUvEpnkardMbUgmYy

sþIBIkarEsVgrkdMeNaHRsaybBaðakm<úCamanbIcMNuc ³ kardkkgT½BEdlRbQmmuxKñacMnYn5KILÚEm:Rt

BIRBMEdnerogxøÜn karcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØaminQøanBanKñamYy nigkarRtÜtBinitüRBMEdnCaGnþrCati.

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 245

Page 256: Brother enemy

GñkTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;evotNammñak; )anTTYlsÁal;cMeBaHmux´¬GñkniBn§¦fa ³ «eyIgdwgfa ExµrRkhmnwg

minyl;RBmtamsMeNITaMgenHeLIy b:uEnþy:agehacNas;PaBTTYlxusRtÚvkñúgkarbdiesFenHnwgFøak;

eTAelIBYkeK». erOgr:avenH)anebIk»kas[mankareXasnaRCúlhYsehtumYytamRbB½n§pSBVpSay

B½t’man. bNþaRbeTskñúgbøúksUevot)anyl;RsbtamEpnkarrbs;evotNamEdlBYkeKvinicä½yfa

«smehtusmpl». dUckarTayTukCamun RkúgPñMeBj)anRcanecalEpnkarenHrebobeBbRCay

edaykt;smÁal;fa enHRKan;EtCameFüa)ayKMrammYybUkpSMnwgkarb:unb:gbMP½nþsaFarNmtiGnþrCati

b:ueNÑaH.

enAcugExmkra qñaM1978 ]tþmesnIy_ ®hÁIháÚrIGWvic ):aLÚvsÁI GKÁembBa¢akarkgT½BeCIgeKakrusSIú

)aneFVIdMeNIrmkkan;RbeTsLavtamynþehaHBiesspÞal;rbs;Kat; edIm,IeFVI«TsSnkic©CamitþPaB»

mYy. enAevogésPaKxageCIgRbeTs Kat;)anCYbCamYyrdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTsevotNam v: egVógy:ab

Casm¶at;edIm,IBiPakSaKñaBIbBaðasßankarN_enAkm<úCa. tamGñkmat;rGilxøHfa kar[eyabl;rbs;

):aLÚvsÁI cMeBaHevotNamKW «erobcMBlRbharRkúgR)aKCafµI»*. ]tþmesnIy_ ):aLÚvsÁI yl;eXIj

c,as;Nas;fa BYkcinKµanlT§PaBmkCYysm<n§½mitþExµrrbs;xøÜneT. dUecñH vaGac[evotNamebIk

rfeRkaHrbs;xøÜnrhUtmkdl;PñMeBj nigTmøak; b:ul Bt BItMENg)andUcTmøak; GaLicsg;d½r Dubsic

enAqñaM1968Edr. b:uEnþ y:ab minRBmsþab;karENnaMenHeLIy. Kat;)aneqøIytbvijfa CnCati

evotNamnwgedaHRsaybBaðaenH«tamrebob»rbs;xøÜn.

kgT½BmYyEdlecjBIPaBminc,as;las;

enABak;kNþalExkumÖ³ qñaM1978 kariyal½yneya)ayevotNam)anrYmRbCMuKñaCafµIenACay

RkúghUCImij. sm½yRbCMu)anRbRBwtþeTAkñúgGtItsalabNþúHbNþalb:Ulisrbs; FIv ¬bc©úb,nñeKehA

sala FUDwk¦ EdlsßitenAq¶ayBITIRbCMuCn. BYkemdwknaMevotNam)ansikSaKeRmagkarmYycb;cug

cb;edImkñúgkarbegáItbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCafµImYy nigkarerobcMcat;taMgclnats‘UmYy. kñúgcenøaHeBl

enaH eL yn; nig eL DwkfU )anCYbeFVIkarBiPakSaKñaCabnþbnÞab; dMbUgCamYykmµaPi)albkSkumµúynIsþ

km<úCa EdlnireTsxøÜneTAevotNamxageCIgtaMgBIqñaM1954 bnÞab;mkCamYyGñkEdlrYcrs;CIvitxøH BI

kare)assMGatrbs; b:ul Bt47.

kñúgcMeNamGaNikCnExµrRbEhl1>000nak; Edlkic©RBmeRBógRkúghSWENvqñaM1954

eRKagTuk[eTAtaMgenARkúghaNUyenaH KWmantictYcNas;EdldMGk;enAevotNamxageCIg. PaKeRcIn

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg246

Page 257: Brother enemy

)anRtLb;mkRbeTskm<úCavij edIm,IcUlrYmkñúgkarts‘URbqaMgGaemrikaMg. manEtmYycMnYntUcb:ueNÑaH

EdlenArs;ranCIvitBI\T§iBléns®gÁampg nigkare)assm¥atrbs;BYk b:ul Bt pg. dUecñH GñksUm

cUlxÜnkñúgKN³dwknaMbkSfµI)anRtwmbgáCaRkúmy:agtUcmYyEdlxVl;xVayCabzm KWeFVIy:agNa[EtxøÜn

)anrs;sinb:ueNÑaH. kñúgcMeNamenaHman Eb:n suvNÑ Gayu40qñaMFøab;sßitenAevotNamtaMgBIqñaM

1954 nigRtÚv)anbNþúHbNþalkñúgsalabkSnigsalaeyaFaCaeRcInkEnøg ehIyCaembBa¢akarmñak;

kñúgkgT½Brbs;evotNam. can;suI nig xag sarin nigeyaFaCaeRcInnak;eTot EdlmanzannþrskþiesµI

Kña. taMg sarwm RbFanbuKÁlikenAGNþÚgEr:FüÚgfµhugég:. Ekv cinþa GñkniyayB½t’manCaPasaExµrtam

viTüúhaNUy. Ca suT§ GñkniBn§enATIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam. kñúgcMeNamGñkrt;eKcxøÜnfµI²k¾KYrerob

rab;bBa©ÚlkmµaPi)alneya)ayxøHdUcCa Ehm samin/ ys; e):a/ h‘un Esn nig b‘U fg pgEdr.

RtÚvbeBa©jPøam²BIkEnøgeFVIkard¾etaky:aknigCMrMCnePosxøÜn CaTIEdlBYkeKFujfb;kñúgkarrg;caM

mnusSTaMgenH)anRtÚveKnaMeTAbgðajxøÜnenAcMeBaHmuxBYkemdwknaMevotNamsMxan;² EdlrhUtmkTl;nwg

eBlenH BYkeKFøab;sÁal;Ettamry³rUbftb:ueNÑaH. tamkarERbRbÜledayécdnümYy BYkeKRtÚv)an

ehA[cUlxøÜnmkTTYleFVICaemdwknaMfµImYyrbs;km<úCa EdlsßitkñúgPaBminc,as;las;énRbvtþisa®sþenA

eLIy. eL DwkfU )anR)ab;B½t’man[BYkeKdwgfa eBlevla)anmkdl;ehIy edIm,IrwtcMNgshRbtibtþi

karepSg²eLIgvij sRmab;CnkumµúynIsþTaMgGs;énRbeTsTaMgBIr. mñak;²RtÚvykcitþTukdak;BRgIk

rcnasm<n§½xageyaFa nigneya)aysRmab;GnaKtclnats‘UmYy[kan;EtrIkFMFat;eLIg.

edayCYbemdwknaMkm<úCamñak; kñúgcMeNamemdwknaMTaMgenaHkñúg»kasénTsSnkic©rbs;´ ¬GñkniBn§¦

enACMrMebnsaj; ´BMudwgBItYnaTIEdlKat;RtÚvsEmþgkñúgyuT§sa®sþrbs;evotNamPøam²)aneT. enAéf¶

enaH eGKIbTUrTsSn_mYyRkúmk¾sßitenATIenaHEdr. enAmuxkaemr:aCaeRcIn ®sþImñak;)anerobrab;BICIvPaB

RbcaMéf¶enAkm<úCa eRkamrbb b:ul Bt. GñkePosxøÜnmYyhVÚg)aneTAecameramCMuvijnagy:agENn.

´)aneqøót»kasenaHedIm,IeKcxøÜnecjq¶aybnþicBIeK ehIyedayrYcputBImKÁúeTÞsk_naMpøÚvrbs;´ ´)an

epþImeFVIkarsnÞnaCamYymnusSCaeRcIntamEtRbTH. dUecñH´man»kas)anCYbniyayCamYyCnmñak;

eQµaH fug ):ak; CaGtItbuKÁlikrdækarénrbb ln; nl; EdlxSwbdak;Rtecok´fa erogral;yb;GñkePos

xøÜn)anRtÚvbgçM[RbCMueronsURtneya)ayedIm,IerobcMkarRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgExµrRkhm. PøamenaH Kat;

)ancg¥úlR)ab;´[eXIjmnusSTabkenþÓmñak;Bak;mYkkgT½BevotNamCMnan;GaNaniKm ehIyERskfa

«nuH+¡ elak Duk KWKat;enHehIy EdlCaGñkebIkkarRbCMueronsURt¡».

GavsWmIBN’sédxøI exakaKIeCIgEvg nigEs,keCIgsERgkekAs‘U enHÉgKWCaÉksNæanrbs;

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 247

Page 258: Brother enemy

«elakDuk». muxmUlrbs;Kat;manlkçN³pÞúynwgkarminTukcitþmYyd¾Cak;lak; enAeBlEdl´sakl,g

[Kat;erobrab;BIRbvtþirbs;Kat;. Kat;mindwgerOgeRcInnUvGVIEdlKat;GacdMNalR)ab;CnbreTsmñak;

eT. eTaHbICarhsSnamrbs;Kat; nigrebobesøókBak;manEbbEpnCaevotNamk¾eday k¾Kat;KWCaExµr

BUCl¥mñak;Edr. dUcsmaCikbkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_km<úCarab;Ban;nak;epSgeTot Duk )ansßitenARkúg

haNUytaMgBIqñaM1954 tamkic©RBmeRBógRkúghSWENvtRmÚv. enAqñaM1971 Kat;)anmkcUlrYmkñúg

clnatsU‘RbqaMg ln; nl; b:uEnþbIqñaMeRkaymk Kat;RtÚvRtLb;eTARbeTsevotNamvij TaMgRbjab;

Rbjal;edIm,IeKcBIkarb®gáabrbs;ExµrRkhm. Kat;)anrs;enAbIqñaMbnÞab;eRkaymkeTot kñúgPUmimYy

enAEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁkñúgzan³Cakmµkrksikmµmñak;. bnÞab;BIenaH Kat;)ancUlxøÜnCafµI tamkarGMBavnav

rbs;bdivtþn_. GMNwHteTA Kat;)anRtÚvcat;[TTYlbnÞúkeRCIserIsnigbgðat;beRgónGnaKtkmµaPi)al

rbs;clnatsU‘kñúgépÞénshKmn_CnePosxøÜnExµrenATIenaH. bIqñaMeRkaymkeTot ´¬GñkniBn§¦)aneFVI

dMeNIreTAkan;RkúgPñMeBjehIy)anesuIbdwgfa elak Duk nigelak ys; e):a emdwknaMrNsirSse®gÁaH

Catikm<úCaKWCamnusSEtmYy. edayKµanR)afñanwgeTAeFVIERscmáarenAEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁ Kat;EbrCa

eTArs;enARkúghaNUybIqñaM munnwgmkeFVICaGñkcat;EcgkargarenACMrMCnePosxøÜnenH.

ebn saj; BMuEmnCakrNImYydac;edayELkBIeKeT. enAPaKxagt,ÚgevotNam taMgBImankar

kat;pþac;cMNgkarTUtmk CMrMEdlmanRbePTdUcKñaCaeRcIn)anrIkduHdalesÞIrEtRKb;kEnøg fVIebIsßitkñúg

lkçN³sm¶at;bMputk¾eday. BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUy)ancab;epþImpþl;lkçN³sm,tþiedayELksRmab;

GñkTaMgenaH KWkarbegáItkgT½BéRBmYy. vahak;dUcCaeFVI[sb,ayEdlkt;smÁal;fa edIm,IeFVI[seRmc

nUv«karrMedaH»RbeTskm<úCaCaelIkTIBIr BYkeKEbrCaeRbIGVI²TaMgGs;EdlbNþaKUsRtÚvkalBIeBlfµI²

rbs;eK-shrdæGaemriknigrbbrbs; FIv-e)aHbg;ecaleTAvij. Ca]TahrN_ kñúgtMbn;CayRkúghUCI

mij GtItmCÄmNÐlbNþúHbNþalb:Ulisrbs;rbb FIv eQµaH FU Dwk EdlB½T§CMuvijedayrbglYsbnøa

x<s;²)anRtÚvbkSkumµúynIsþExµrEdleTIbbegáItfµI²ykeTAeRbIkar ehIyEdlGtßiPaBsßitkñúgPaBsm¶at;

enAeLIy. GtItmUldæanGaemrikaMgenA s‘n; Lúk nig Lúg y:av Ek,rTIRkúghUCImij RBmTaMgvalcMNt

]T§mÖaKcRkeyaFaenA vI faj; kñúgEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁ RtÚv)aneKbBa©ÚleTAkñúgkareRtómbRmúgepSg²

sRmab;eRbIedaylYclak;edIm,IRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt48. éf¶TI22 Exemsa qñaM1978 kgBltUcTI1

EdlCakgT½BExµrEbkecjBIbkçBYk RtÚv)anRbsiT§inamCapøÚvkarkñúg»kasénBiFIbuNümYy Edlhammin

[GñkeRkAcUl49. enAcugqñaMenaH kgBltUcCaeRcInepSgeTot -EdlkmøaMgBitR)akdesµInwgmYykgvr

esnatUc- suT§EteRtómlkçN³rYcCaeRsckñúgkarcUlrYmvaylukrbs;evotNamenARbeTskm<úCa.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg248

Page 259: Brother enemy

karRbyuT§EdlminBit/ karsmøab;rgÁalEdlBitR)akd

kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH kareXasna)ancab;epþImmansnÞúHy:agxøaMgkøa. kaEstnana nigviTüú)an

pSBVpSaynUvbTykB½t’many:ageRcInsþIBIGMeBIsahavyg;Xñgrbs;ExµrRkhm. TVarecjcUlrbs;

RbeTs)anebIksRmab;GñkkaEstbreTs. kñúgGMLúgBIrqñaMknøgeTA KWtaMgBIkarcakecjrbs;´BITIRkúg

éRBnKr ´RtÚv)anGnuBaØat[eFVIdMeNIreTARbeTsevotNamminelIsBIBIrdgeLIy. b:uEnþ enHBuMEmnmk

BI´minsakl,genaHeT. ´)anRtÚvevotNamGeBa¢IjCafµI TukNaCadMeNIrcugeRkayrbs;´mantaMgBIbI

Exmunk¾eday. ´)aneTAdl;TIRkúghaNUyenAéf¶TI4 ExmIna qñaM1978. GñkTTYlxusRtÚvevotNam

)aneFVI[´dwgy:agrh½sfa dMeNIrrbs;´nwgminmaneKaledAGVIepSgeRkABI[´raykarN_BIbBaðarbs;

km<úCaenaHeT. BuMmankarCYbGñkTTYlxusRtÚvénKN³kmµkarEpnkar nigeTATsSnashkrN_mYyenAEdndI

sNþTenøRkhmdUcEdl´manbMNgeT. paM v:an;KYg CaGñkmanebskkmµnaMpøÚvGñkkaEstEdleFVIdMeNIr

mkevotNamry³eBlxøI )anniyayR)ab;´fa ³ «elaketagEtyl;[)anc,as;BIedImehtuénkarTas;

ETgKñarbs;eyIg CamYyRbeTskm<úCa».

kñúgs®gÁameXasnaBitR)akdenH GñkGuCkaMRCÜcEdlTTYlbnÞúkbBa¢a)aj;[RsuHKñaKWGnurdæm®nþI

karbreTs v: dugy:ag xøÜnÉgpÞal;. enAéf¶TI5 ExmIna shPatr³ ¬GñkmanviC¢aCIv³dUcKña¦ GWr:ubBIrrUb-

r:ULg; EBür):aruaMgháÚ énkaEstLWm:ug nig kaEr:l v:an; v:ulhVWern énkaEst NRC Handelsblad nigrUb´pÞal;

RtÚv)anGeBa¢IjCaÉkCn[eTAcUlrYmBisaGahareBll¶acmYyRBmTaMgpþl;B½t’manepSg²pg. erOgenH

)aneFVI[´nwkeXIjGnusSavrIy_d¾Cak;lak;mYy ³ dMeNIrkmSanþrbs;´naevlaRBwkéf¶esAr_enAexmedvIs

kñúgmUldæanGakastan;sWnjwknaTIRkúgéRBnKr kalBIqñaM1974-75. ´)ancUlrYmminEdlxankñúg

snñisITkaEstCaeRcInelIk EdlerobcMedayvresnIy_ÉkkñúgsemøókbMBak;BN’ébtgmñak; enAkñúg

GKarrbs;KN³RbtiPUevotkugEdlmankaryamkarBary:aghµt;ct;. BitehIy enHCarUbPaBeRkA

beBaäatmYy ³ eKminGacGHGagfa KN³RbtiPUénrdæaPi)albdivtþn_beNþaHGasnñ ¬evotkug¦ )aneRCam

ERCgy:agxøaMgdl;karkarBarbTQb;)aj;Kña dUcEdlkic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIstRmÚv[xøÜneKarBeLIy.

y:agehac karCYbKñaenHenAmuxEBgkaehVmYyb¤ePsC¢³fµIGac[GñksarB½t’manrkSakarTak;TgCamYy

EpñkmçageTotEdr. enAeBlenaHeK)anbeRmIeyIgnUvRsa Lua moi CaRsaxøaMgrbs;evotNameFVIBIGgár

EdlelakvresnIy_Ék y:ag KUsnÞnarbs;eyIghak;dUcCacUlcitþNas;. enAyb;enaHelak y:ag

dEdlenHnwgeFVIxøÜnCaePJóvrbs;´kñúgkarbriePaKGahareBll¶acmþg.

rUbragrbs; y:ag hak;dUcCaBuMERbRbÜlesaH. f<al;rbs;Kat;enAEtpt EPñkmUltUc² nigPøW

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 249

Page 260: Brother enemy

ciBa©acdEdl. xøÜnR)aNragesþIgCagmunbnþic RbEhlmkBIKat;Bak;GavsédxøIehIyemIleTA nigman

Gakar³s¶b;es¶ómCagmun. Kat;ecHniyayPasa)araMg/ Gg;eKøs nigeGs,:aj:úly:agsÞat; eRBaH

kalBIedImKat;Føab;)aneFVICaÉkGKÁrdæTUtrbs;rdæaPi)albdivtþn_beNþaHGasnñRbcaMRbeTsKuy)a.

ebITukCarUbsRms;Kat;minGacRbEkk)ank¾eday k¾Kat;CaCnbdivtþn_EdlmanGMNacmñak;. R)akd

Nas;fa eKalbMNgrbs;Kat;KWKµanGVIeRkAEtBIjúaMg[«bNþamitþcas;sm½yenA tan; sWnjwk» eCOBI

PaBRtwmRtÚvénbuBVehturbs;evotNambu:eNÑaH. karniyaymñak;Égrbs;Kat;manfirevlabIem:ag

EdlesÞIrEtKµankat;CaGenøIedaykarkt;smÁal;epSg² EdleFVI[xVl;citþsþIBIkarRbyuT§rvagbgb¥ÚnÉg

nigkarcMGkbBaÄWcitþxøaMg²cMeBaH b:ul Bt nigBYkyuT§ikCnrbs;Kat; ¬b:ul Bt¦ enAbreTseLIy. kar

bkRsayrbs; y:ag BIkarRbyuT§KñaeBareBjeTAedaykarTmøayR)ab;erOgs¶at;kM)aMgCaeRcIn.

vaCaehtukarN_minFøab;manBImun EdldMeNIrrbs;eyIgminsßitenAeRkamkarkMhitNamYy.

eyIgmanesrIPaBeFVIGVItamcitþ. b‘Yy h‘uyj:an CaGñkTTYlxusRtÚvTMnak;TMngCamYyGñkkaEstbreTs

)anbBa¢ak;R)ab;eyIgfa «elakGaceFVIdMeNIreTATINaeRscEtcitþelakenAtambeNþayRBMEdnkm<úCa

rhUtdl;GVIEdlCakaryl;eXIjrbs;elakRtÚv)anbMeBjtamesckþIRtÚvkar». karpþl;nUvesrIPaB

mYydUecñH KWGacmanedaysarEtTTYl)ankarGnuBaØatbNþaGgÁkarfñak;elIrbs;rbbenHb:ueNÑaH. eK

RtÚvEtdeNþImykQñHelIkarminRBmeCOGVI²TaMgGs;rbs;GñkkaEst ³ enAelIsmrPUmi karBitnwg

bgðajfaevotNamBuMmanGVIEdlRtÚvlak;)aMgTal;EtesaH eRBaHBYkeKCaGñkrgeRKaHBIkarQøanBan

rbs;ExµrRkhm ehIyfaeKalbMNgvatTIniymrbs;BYkeKRKan;EtCaerOgniTanEdlRbDiteLIgeday

b:ul Bt b:ueNÑaH.

BitNas; taynij KWCacMNucekþAmYy. TIrYmextþmanCIkreNþAy:ageRcIndUcrn§)ayxuM. enARKb;

TIkEnøgmansuT§EtCRmkeRkamdI ³ eRkamcieBa©Imfñl;/ Ek,rGKarTaMgLayrbs;rdæaPi)al nigkñúgsYnc,ar

PUmiRKwHnana. enAPaKxageCIgTIRkúgcm¶ayBIrbIKILÚEm:RtEdlCaRBMEdnrbs;km<úCaKWCaPUmi tan; Lab

(Tan Lap) ³ xÞmsøwkBIrCYr eFVIBIPk;hals¶Üt tambeNþaypøÚvrdibrdubmYy. kalBIR)aMmYyExmun

ExµrRkhm)anbnSl;TukenATIenHRtwmEteKhdæan)ak;EbkmYyKMnrb:ueNÑaH. KWenAkñúgPUmienHehIyEdl

hÁIy:UrI Føab;)anftrUbsþIBIkarsmøab;rgÁald¾l,Il,ajrbs;Kat; munnwgRtÚveKdkhUtyk. cMENkeyIg

vij eyIgKµanlM)akbnþicesaHkñúgkarCYbsMeNHsMNalCamYyGñkenArs;ranmanCIvitmñak;kñúgcMeNam

GñkenArs;ranmanCIvitd¾kRmCaeRcInKW®sþIv½yekµgmñak;eQµaH egVón FIKU. nagyMGNþWtGNþkbeNþIr

erobrab;R)ab;eyIgBIkarsmøab;Rbhar\tGasUrbeNþIr. b¥ÚnRbúsnag nignagEdlrs;ranmanCIvitenH

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg250

Page 261: Brother enemy

KWedaysarEteFVIButCasøab;eRkamsaksBmYyKMnrb:ueNÑaH.

PUminanaRtÚvbMpøicbMpøaj/ ERsTaMgLayRtÚve)aHbg;ecal/ pñÚrexµacmanrab;ry ³ TsSnIyPaB

rebobdUcKñaenH )anekItmanmþgehIymþgeTotenAtambeNþayRBMEdn. eyIgGacsþab;B¤BImat;BYkGñk

enArs;ranmanCIvitpÞal;nUvkarniTanBIGMeBIsahavyg;XñgepSg² EdlRbRBwtþedayÉkÉg rebobdUc

sm½yyuKkNþalGIcwg. karsgS½yRbEhlElgmaneTotehIy cMeBaHtfPaBénkarRbyuT§KñaKµan

GaNitGasUrenH EdlbiT)aMgEPñkBiPBelakyUryarmkehIy. P½sþútagepSg²EdleFVI[GMBl;KWenA

TIenaH.

b:uEnþ KµanGVIGac[snñidæanBIkarvayRbharfµI²rbs;km<úCadUcKñanwgkarvayRbharkalBIqñaMmun

eLIy. tamkarsnñidæanrbs;´KWfa evotNam)anpþÜcepþImKMniteLIgvijmuneK. etIRtÚvBnül;epSgBIenH

fa eKGaceFVIdMeNIredaygayRsYleTAkan;tMbn;RBMEdnedayrebobNa?. ´)ansmÁal;eXIjsøak

sñamqøgkat;c,as;RkELtrbs;rfeRkaHmYyExSelIpøÚvhuyRTelammYyenAcenøaHtaynijnigRBMEdn

RBmTaMgsñamrfynþeyaFamYyeRKÓgpÞúkeBjeTAedayés< Edltam´sµanKW ykeTApÁt;pÁg;[kgT½B.

R)akdNas; enATIenaHEdlsßanPaBPUmisa®sþGnuBaØat kgT½Brbs;evotNam )anrujRcankmøaMgT½B Ca

ExSRkvat;karBarrbs;xøÜneTAkñúgRbeTskm<úCa. evotNamdwgxøÜnfa RtÚvEteFVICam©as;elIsßankarN_

eyaFa ehIyBYkeKminrYjrakñúgkarnaMGñkkaEstbreTsEdlRBÜy)armÖBIsnþisuxrbs;eKpÞal; eTAkan;

tMbn;RBMEdn edIm,IbgðajR)ab;BIsøaksñaménkarbMpøicbMpøajEdlbgáeLIgedayExµrRkhmeLIy.

minyUrb:unµan ´)anTTYlkarGHGagbBa¢ak;BIeKalbMNgepSg²rbs;evotNam kñúg»kasén

TsSnkic©rbs;eyIgenAPUmiGanPU Ek,rcUvduk. enATIenaHmanP½sþútag Cak;EsþgCaeRcInEdlCaGMeBIvay

Rbharrbs;kgT½BefµIreCIgnigkgkaMePøIgFMExµrRkhmkalBIeBlfµI². KMnrpÞH)ak;EbkenAhuyEpSgenA

eLIy. GñkPUmikMBugRbjab;Rbjal;RbmUlRTBüsm,tþirbs;BYkeKTukmYyduM munnwgdwkCBa¢ÚneTAdak;kñúg

TICRmknanatamEtRbTH. k¾b:uEnþ eKdwgy:agc,as;fa GñkkaEsténsarB½t’manrbs;vNѳKhbtI

EtgEtXøaMemIlGVIEdlnaM[cab;GarmµN_xøaMgCanic©. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday GñkxøHkñúgcMeNamKñaeyIg

TMngCamineCOdac;xatfa RKab;kaMePøIgFMEdleyIgB¤sUrqVacBIelIk,alrbs;eyIgRtÚv)aj;ecjmkBI

TItaMgrbs;ExµrRkhmeT. bnÞab;BImYyry³xøI GñkbkERbrbs;´ h‘uy v:an;taM )an[eyabl;fa ³ «etaH

eyIgecjeTAxageRkAPUmivij Gs;elakRbEhlCaGacemIleXIjkarRbyuT§KñaBIcm¶ay». eK)anpþl;

[eyIgnUvEkvyitmYyEdlENnaM[eyIgemIleTAkEnøgedImeQImYyedImenAmçageToténvalERsEdl

kMNt;RBMEdnCamYyRbeTskm<úCa. kgT½BevotNammñak;énRkúmGñkGmkarBarrbs;eyIg)anQrenA

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 251

Page 262: Brother enemy

Ek,rb£sSImYyKum<. Kat;mans<ayviTüúTak;TgmYyenAelIxñgpg. edaycab;kan;k,almIRkÚ Kat;ERsk

LÚLamindwgerOgGVIxøHeT eRBaHeyIgsþab;BuMyl;. enAEk,reyIg nayTahanmñak;)anERskcMTalfa ³

«Rbjab;cUlelNdæanPøam¡». BIrbIvinaTIeRkay sMeLgénkar)aj;epøagRKab;kaMePøIgFMmYy)an

lan;B¤mkdl;PUmiEdlsßitenABIeRkayeyIgGmeTAedaysMeLglan;sUrqVac. RKab;kaMePøIg)anpÞúHenAkúñg

sMNuMedImeQIEdleyIgkMBugEtsegátBinitü. nayTahanEdlmansMeLgelVIyrhitréh )anRbkas

edayrt;rkCRmkxøÜnÉgfa ³ «ExµrRkhmvayRbharehIy¡». eyIgB¤kar)aj;kaMePøIgt,al;xøH nigkar

)aj;R)av²énGavuFsV½yRbvtþiy:ageRcIn. CafµImþgeTot eK)ansuM[eyIgcUlTICRmk. RKab;kaMePøIgFM

mYyRKab;eTot)anehaHlan;sUrqVacxagelIk,alrbs;eyIg ehIypÞúHenApþúMedImeQITaMgenaH.

etImanGVIEdlRtÚvesIc BitNas;KWkargarrbs;GñkEdlcUlcitþxøaMgnwgGVImYy. GñkTTYlxusRtÚv

EdlCUndMeNIreyIgtaMgBITIRkúghUCImij)aneFVITwkmuxRkjÚv. CakarKYr[esaksþayNas;Edl b:ul

Bt BuMEmnCamnusScUlcitþerobcMkarvayRbharBitR)akdmYy edIm,IbMeBjbMNgrbs;eyIgenaH¡.

eyIg)anRtÚvcMGk[rh½sbMput ³ mindl;160KILÚEm:RtBITIenaHpg karRbyuT§KñaEmnETn)an

RbRBwtþeTAy:agxøaMgkøaenAcMNucmYyeToténRBMEdn. evotNam)anxMRbwgvayrujRcanBYkGñklukluy

ExµrRkhmy:agsVitsVaj. bIéf¶eRkaymk eK)anmkdas;´EdledkkñúgbnÞb;sNæaKarmYyenARkúg

hUCImij edIm,IRbKl;[´nUvesckþIENnaMmYyxusEbøkBIFmµta. taM )an[dMNwg´fa GñkkaEstTaMgGs;

RtÚveTACYbCuMKñamYyem:ageRkayenAGakasyandæantan;sWnjwk. eKalbMNgBuMmanbBa¢ak;[dwg.

enAeBlem:agEdlmt;Kña KWenAcMNtGakasyantan;sWnjwk mnusSesÞIrEtmktan;tab;eTA

ehIy. eRkABIGñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manelakxaglic enATIenaHk¾manRkúmGñkkan;m:asuInftPaBynþKuy)a

nigb:ULÚj nigGñkftrUbRBmTaMgGñkftPaBynþrbs;evotNammYyhVÚgEdr EdlehobnwgecjdMeNIreTA

haeTog TaMgGs;Kña. ebHdUgrbs;´jab;j½rCaxøaMg enAeBlEdl´eXIjynþehaHrbs;eyIgBIcm¶ay.

dMbUg ´sµanEtstVsm½ybuerRbvtþisa®sþ. b:uEnþBuMEmneT enHBitCa]T§mÖaKcRkm:ak Chinook mYyeRKÓg

EdlrUbragERbeTACakMBIkkMBkmUl² ehIyBN’fñaMEdllab-BIedImBN’ébtg-RKan;EtCaGnusSavrIy_

minc,as;b:ueNÑaH. enHCaexµacesHkBa©as;d¾l¥mYyrbs;kgT½BGaemrikaMgenARbeTsevotNam. KMnUr

smÁal;EtmYyKt;EdleFVI[GarmµN_minsUvrIkraykñúgTsSnIyPaBKYr[RsgakcitþenH KWrUbsBaØapáay

BN’elOgnigépÞBN’RkhménkgT½BGakasrbs;evotNamenAelItYynþehaH. bg¥ÜcBIrkñúgcMeNam

bg¥ÜcTaMgGs;rbs;ynþehaH RKan;EtCaRbehagRchFøúgb:ueNÑaH. karRbTak;qVak;KñamYyénExSePøIg

CaeRcInEdlFøak;rENgreNagenAkñúgbnÞb;GñkCiH emIleTAmansPaBKYr[RsegHRsegacNas;. pÞúy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg252

Page 263: Brother enemy

nwgesckþIsgÇwmTaMgGs; m:asuInynþehaH)ancab;epþImbeBaäHehIyehaHnaMeyIgecjeTA. edayRbfuy

RkeLkemIleTAeRkA ´smøwgKyKn;mYysnÞúHnUveRKÓgRTRTg;tYynþehaHTaMgmUlEdlemIleTATn;lVt

dUc\tq¥wgnigRbLak;exµA² EdlCamrtkmYyrbs; Oncle Sam b¤ Uncle Sam [CaBaküGg;eKøsEdleRbICa

karehAshrdæGaemrikrebobcMGk ehIyBaküenHTajecjmkBIBakü U.S.Am (United States of América)]

Tuk[RbeTsevotNamsgÁmniym.

eyIg)anehaHBIelItMbn;valkk;y:agqab;rh½s EdlmanBaseBjeTAedaymat;reNþARKab;Ebk

nigRKab;kaMePøIgFM bnÞab;mkEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁ EdlmanvisalPaBFMlVwgelVIyeLIgébtgRsgat;

nigkat;xVat;ExVgeTAedayRbLayTwkBN’daMEdgCaeRcIn. kMsYlxül;RtCak;mYy)anbk;cUlmkb:HeyIg

tambg¥ÜcEbkTaMgBIr. bnÞab;BIkarcuHctmYyry³xøI edIm,Icak;eRbgbEnßmenAkg;fW FanIénEdndIsNþ

]T§mÖaKcRk Chinook )anehaHeLIgCafµIeq<aHeTAhaeTogEtmþg.

edaysmøwgemIlmUldæanGakaskg;fW EdlCamUldæanmYykñúgcMeNammUldæanFM²ksagenA

RbeTsevotNamedayBYkGaemrikaMg nigsþab;sMeLgynþehaH A.37 Caplitplrbs;GaemrikkMBugeraT×

m:asuInenAelIpøÚvehaHehIr edaymanP¢ab;RKab;EbkenAeRkamsøabTaMgsgxagrbs;vapg )anehaHeLIg

tamTMngsMedAeTARbeTskm<úCa ´k¾esIcjwm². kalBIbIqñaMmun enAeBlEdlshrdæGaemrikenAkMBug

vayRbyuT§nwg«km<úCaGñkKaMRTRkúghaNUy» enAeLIy hg;rI KIsSúIghÁ½r bdiesFminTTYlsÁal;fa evot

NamKµansmtßPaBjúaMgExµrRkhm[luHkñúgGMNacrbs;xøÜn dUcEdl eL DwkfU GHGagR)ab;Kat;eLIy50.

ebIKit[hµt;ct;eTA lT§ikumµúynIsþrbs;km<úCa minEmnCakarbegáItmYyrbs;evotNameTb¤?.

karRbCuMpþl;B½t’manEdlBYkeyIg)ancUlrYmkñúgry³eBlénkareFVIdMeNIrrhUtdl;cMNtGakasyan

haeTog KWRtÚv)aneFVIeLIgedaymanEpnTIepSg²rbs;esnaFikarGaemrikaMgCaCMnYypg. b:uEnþ Gñk

beRgóneyIgniyayBuMmansMenogrebobGñkticsas; (Texas) esaH ehIyTItaMgTaMgLayrbs;sRtÚv

EdlKUsedayexµAédenAelIEpnTI BuMEmnsresr[eXIjc,as;CaGkSr «V.C» ¬evotkug¦ b¤K.C ¬Exµr

kumµúynIsþ EdlCakarehACapøÚvkarrbs;GaemrikaMgkñúgry³eBls®gÁam¦eLIy. t,itGI cab;BIéf¶enHeTA

sRtÚvKWkm<úCaRbCaFibetyürbs; b:ul Bt s®gÁamenHerobcMeLIg edaysm<arswkfµICamYysmÖarswk

cas;>>>.

GakasyandæanhaeTog mansPaBesÞIrEts¶at;sUnü. enAÉnayq¶ay eKeXIjkMsYlEpSg

BN’shuyecjBIeragcRksuIm:g;t_mYy EdlminyUrb:unµanRtÚvxül;bk;naMykeTAlMhGakas Edlman

BN’exovRss;føa. enAcugpøÚv ePsC¢³RtCak;²nignMb‘ÍsÁI)anRtÚverobbRmugCaeRscenAelIkRmaltu

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 253

Page 264: Brother enemy

BN’smYy edIm,IbeRmIbMNgeyIg. enHCaTmøab;EbøkKYr[cg;dwgenARbeTsevotNamkumµúynIsþ eRBaH

kñúgRbeTsenH KµanerOgGVIGacmaneLIgeday\tmanKN³kmµaFikarNamYycUlLÚkLMerobcMBiFIbdi-

sNæarkic©mYyeLIy. eRkamkemþARBHGaTitüKµanRbNIemtþaenH dbsUdaCaeRcInEdlekþA]Nð² lay

RkÚceBaFisat;k¾TTYlsVaKmn_ePJóv eTaHCaePJóvNamkdl;k¾eday.

bnÞab;BIkarRbmUlpþúMB½t’mancugeRkaymYy EdleFVIeLIgedayvresnIy_RtI v:ag cUv EdlcUlcitþ

QWq¥alCYyeK eyIg)anecjdMeNIreTAkan;haeTog. TIRkúgEdlkñúgeBlfµI²enHmanmnusSticCag

30>000nak; enAéf¶enHmansPaBesÞIrEtGs;mnusSrlIg ehIyhaglk;TMnijnigpÞHsEm,gsuT§Et

biTTVar. GMEbgRKab;kaMePøIgFMenArayBaseBjelIdI. enAcMNtkMBg;Ep GñkvegVgmindwgeTANa enAQr

rg;caMedaymank®nþk/ )avRkecA b¤kanC½rcgBüÜrxagcugeQIEvgmYylIelIsµa b¤dak;KrKñaelIkg; nigreTH

rujpg. k,Ünrfynþrbs;eyIg)anQb;enAeBlecjputBITIRkúg. enAhYsq¶ayBITIenaH KWdIERsrbs;XuM

mIDuk Edllatsn§wgrhUtdl;PñMtUc²enAEk,rRBMEdnrbs;RbeTskm<úCa. eyIg)anqøgkat;valERseday

efµIreCIg EdleFVI[dIhuyeLIgsMeBagRKbBIelIk,alrbs;eyIg. kñúgxN³EdleyIgedIrcUleTACitdl;

xÞmtUc²Rbk;s,ÚvenACab;eCIgPñM køins¥úyGesacmYyEdleFVI[Qøk;degðIm enAEtvilvl;enATIenaH ³ enH

CakøinmnusSsøab;R)akdNas;. enAkNþalKMnr)ak;EbkéneKhdæannana elNdæanmYyRtÚv)aneKelIk

ykrbs;eTIsETgecj. mnusSRbmaNdb;BIrnak; kMBugCIkreNþAkb;saksBenARtg;enaHkñúgsPaB

s¶b;s¶at; edayEbkejIsb:un²RKab;eBat. enAEk,rpÞHmYyEdlcMhFøúgeK)ankb;saksBdb;R)aMnak;

manRbús RsI nigkUnekµg. minq¶ayb:unµanBITIenaH dMbg RBng; EdlTMngCaExµrRkhmeRbIsmøab;mnusS

enAray):ayelIdIenAeLIy. kñúgenaHmandMbgmYyRtÚveKbukTmøúHRbdab;ePTRsImñak;EdlRtÚvcgkEn§k

édeCIgTaMgxøÜnR)aNnnlKk. kUnTaMgBIrrbs;nagRtÚveKkat;CakMNat;². saksBxøHRtÚvkat;k,al

)at;. saksBxøHeTot EdlFøayeBaHevonecjmkeRkARtÚv)aMg)at;eRkamkarecameraménhVÚgruy

k,alexov. edayrkklcg;k¥Üt ´etagEtsRmakmYysnÞúHenAeRkamedImeQImYyedImmunnwgbnþedIr

emIleTot. eKhdæanTaMgGs;edayKµanelIkElg)anpþl;nUvTsSnIyPaBeFVI[P½yxøacdUckaryl;

sbþiGaRkk;. cMENkstVTaMgLayk¾ExµrRkhmsmøab;KµanRtaRbNIEdr. exµaceKa nigEqágab;sþÚksþwgenA

kñúgreNþAEk,rmat;pøÚv. enACithaeTog xageRkayTYlx<s;mYyEdlExµrRkhmRCkBYnkñúgry³eBlén

karvayRbharrbs;evotNam ´emIleXIjsaksBkgT½BExµrRkhmBIrnak;. Exµrrt;eKcxøÜnenH)an

bnSl;TukEk,rxøÜnnUvGavuFmYyKMnr ³ kaMePøIgGaka-47/ RKab;eb-40 nigkaMePøIg)aj;minFak;fyplit

enARbeTscin.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg254

Page 265: Brother enemy

egVón v:an;h½n Gayu25qñaM nigRbBn§rbs;Kat;)anRtÚvdas;[PJak;BIdMeNkenAeBleTobPøWéf¶ TI14

ExmIna edaysERmkCaPasaExµrfa ³ «cUl¡ cUl¡» nigedaysMeLgERskfÚ¶rrbs;GñkPUmi. kñúgPaB

ggwt GñkTaMgBIr)anrt;eKcxøÜneTAkan;kUnPñMmYyEdlmanéRBeQIBaseBjenACitenaH CakEnøgEdl

BYkeKlak;xøÜnkñúgry³eBlBIréf¶. enARBwkéf¶bnÞab; BIkEnøgsegátemIlrbs;Kat;enAelIPñM h½n GacemIl

eXIjExµrRkhmdwk)avRsUv nigRTBüsm,tiþkMbuikkMb:ukTaMgGs;rbs;RbCaCnkñúgPUmitamreTHykecj

eTA. ´xMRbwgsmøwgemIlxÞmtUc²TaMgenH EdleFVIBIPk;smܶtnigb£sSIeday\tGMeBI ´Bi)akeCOfa xÞm

TaMgenHGacmanGVIEdlbgðaj[eXIjP½sþútagsRmab;karlYcbøn;Nas;. etImanGVIEdlGacCaedImehtu

bNþal[manRkúmGñksmøab;mnusS? P½sþútagKYrTTYlyk)anEtmYyKt; Edl´GacelIkmkbgðaj

KWBaküesøakCaPasaExµrmYyEdlykFüÚgsresrRkevmRkvamenAelITVarmYyfa «TIenHRsukeyIg».

karrMB£k[eXIjnUvGVI²EdlknøgyUrmkehIy KWRbEhlCa300qñaMmun EdndIsNþTenøemKgÁTaMgmUl

rYmTaMghaeTogpgKWCaTwkdIrbs;km<úCa. dUecñH PaKeRcInénRbCaCnenAXuMmIDuk nigGñkrgeRKaH KWsuT§Et

manedImkMeNItExµr.

erOgTaMgGs;enH )anrYmbgáCacMeNaTbiTmuxmYysRmab;´. edayEsVgrkb£sKl;mYyénkar

smøab;Rbhar\tGasUrenH ´enAEtmindwgdUcmnusSesÞIrEtRKb;KñaBIGVIEdlekItmanenARbeTskm<úCa

bnÞab;BIkarvayluyrbs;evotNamenAExFñÚEdr. ´mindwgTal;EtesaHBIkarcg;eFVIGVI²[FMGs©arüEdl

sNæitkñúgcitþKMnitExµrRkhmbnÞab;BIC½yCmñHCaRbvtþisa®sþEdlminR)akdenAéf¶TI6 Exmkra qñaM

1978eLIy. eRkaymk eGog sarI )anbMPøWR)ab;GñkkaEstbreTsfa edayeqøIytbcMeBaHkar

lukluyrbs;evotNam «eyIgRtÚvEtcab;epþImeFVIkarvaylukeLIgvij ehIyrujRcanevotNam[cUl

y:ageRCAeTAxagkñúgRBMEdnpÞal;rbs;BYkeK»51.

eyIg)anRtLb;mkkan;RkúghUCImijvij. skçIPaBdMbUgmYy-EdlnaM[exøacpSakñúgcitþ-eTIbnwg

eFVI[eyIgdwgBIkarBiténs®gÁam EdleFVI[«smmitþ»Cabgb¥ÚnenA\NÐÚcinRbyuT§tTl;Kña. eRkayenaH

minyUrb:unµan ´)andMNwgfa karseRmcbBa¢ÚnGñkkaEsteTAhaeTogtam]T§mÖaKcRkmuneBlEdl

saksBTaMgLayRtÚvbBa©úH )anRtÚvseRmceday eL DwkfU pÞal; EdlGMNwHteTA enARkúghaNUy

karcat;EcgBIbBaðaneya)ayrbs;km<úCaRtÚvFøak;mkelIKat;. b:ul Bt )anpþl;lT§PaB[Kat;ecjBI

y:ageRcIn ehIyKat;minTuk[»kaskñúgkareXasnad¾l¥RbesIrmYyknøgputeLIy. kñúgry³eBlenaH

RbeTskm<úCa)anRbwgERbgdUcKña edIm,ITTYl)ankarKaMRTBIbreTs. enAéf¶EtmYyEdlBYkeyIgeTA

TsSnahaeTog b:ul Bt )anTTYlCYbGñkkaEstyUehÁasøavImYyRkúmenAkñúgnievsndæanmYy sßitenA

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 255

Page 266: Brother enemy

tammat;TenøsabnaTIRkúgPñMeBjEdr. enHCaRkúmGñkkaEstdMbUgbg¥s;EdlRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[cUl

RbeTskm<úCataMgBIC½yCmñHrbs;ExµrRkhm. b:ul Bt )anbMPøWfa RbeTskm<úCasakl,gedaHRsay

CemøaHrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTsevotNam «edayKiteTAtamsßanPaBCak;Esþg». «ebIsinCaRbeTs

evotNamRbkan;\riyabfmitþPaBmYycMeBaHeyIgenaH KµanehtuplNamYyEdlfa bBaðaenHminRtÚv

)anedaHRsayedayqab;rh½seLIy»52.

v: dugy:ag )anbgðajBIrebobéllkrbs;Kat;kñúgkarbegáItTMnak;TMngRbkbedaymitþPaBrvag

RbeTsTaMgBIrR)ab;eyIgedayRtg;²fa ³ «manEtdMeNaHRsayBIrb:ueNÑaH EdlGacmanlT§PaBeFVI

eTArYccMeBaHkarb:HTgÁicKñaenH. b¤mYyrbbrbs;km<úCaRtÚvpøas;bþÚrneya)ay b¤mYyRbCaCnkm<úCaTTYl

r:ab;rgpøas;bþÚrrbbedayxøÜnÉg».

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg256

Page 267: Brother enemy

semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu ³ kñúgKukExµrRkhm

sRmab;CaelIkdMbUgehIykñúgCIvitrbs;RBHGgÁEdlsemþc sIhnu RtÚv)ankm©at;ecjBImuxgar

saFarN³ ehIyRKan;EtCabuKÁlsamBaØmñak;b:ueNÑaH EdlenACMuvijRBHGgÁKWPaBs¶at;RCgM. nievsndæan

rbs;RBHGgÁenAkñúgRBHbrmraCvaMg Edlh‘umB½T§edayrbgx<s;²eRbóbdUcCaRTúgmasmYyEdlyam

karBaredayyuvksikrekµg²esøókBak;exaGavBN’exµA nigEdleKsÁal;eRBaHEtPaBminEdljjwmenH

Ég. GtItRBHRbmuxrdæBMuGaccakecjBICRmkrbs;RBHGgÁedayKµankarGnuBaØatBIGgÁkareLIy.

vaR)akdehIyEdlRBHGgÁBMuEdlmanRBHT½ycg;ecjeTAeRkAeTaHCaTINak¾eday. kgVl;BIkarTTYl

es,ógGaharBIGgÁkar k¾RBHGgÁmineFøay[dwgEdr. erogral;RBwk yuT§Cnmñak;EtgCiHkg;ykrbb

es,ógGaharRbcaMéf¶CaRtICabEnømkfVayRBHGgÁCanic©. GtItnaykrdæm®nþIrbs;RBHGgÁKWelak Eb:n

nut rYmTaMgelxaFikarpÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁ KWGñkRsI esA sar:ut RtÚv)anyl;RBm[rYmcMENkkñúgkarCab;XMu

rbs;RBHGgÁEdr. b:uEnþBYkeK)anRtÚvcat;Ecg[rs;enAnievsndæandac;edayELkBIKñaenAkñúgRkúgPñMeBj.

taMgBIeBlEdlbuRtICaeRcInGgÁrbs;RBHGgÁ nigRkúmRKÜsarrbs;GñkTaMgenaHRtÚvbeNþjecjBInievsndæan

mk«BiPBrs;enA»rbs;semþc sIhnu )anrYmtUceTA²y:agcEmøk. kñúgRBHbrmraCvaMgmanEtGñkmñag

m:Unik nigbuRtaTaMgBIrrbs;RBHGgÁ KWRBHGgÁm©as; sIhmunI nig nri®nÞBgS b:ueNÑaH.

Gñkmñag m:Unik )anmanbnÞÚlerobrab;R)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa «cab;taMgBIkarsMulaElgBItMENgrbs;

semþc ¬enAExemsa qñaM1976¦ BYkeyIgElg)aneXIjGVIEdlmanCIviteTotehIy. eTaHbICaGñk

beRmIk¾RtÚveKdkykecjGs;Edr». CaelIkdMbUgehIykñúgCIvitrbs;Gñkmñag m:Unik EdlmankrNIykic©

RtÚvdNþaMsømðÚbGaharCaerogral;éf¶edIm,IciBa©wmbI)ac;RKÜsar. kñúgGMLúgénkarKg;Rbfab;nireTsRBHkay

ry³eBlR)aMqñaMenARkúgeb:kaMg CU eGnLay EdlFøab;sÁal;c,as;BIcMNUlesaymðÚbq¶aj;²rbs;semþc

)anerobcMdak;cugePAmñak;kñúgcMeNamcugePAcMNan²RbcaMRkúgeb:kaMg EdlmanÉkeTsxageFVImðÚb)araMg

[eTAenAbeRmIRBHGgÁtamsBVRBHT½y. b:uEnþ \LÚvenH KWGñkmñag m:Unik CaGñkbMeBjkic©karpÞHsBVsareBI

taMgBIkardaMsø nigdaMbEnøbnþicbnþÜcedaymanbuRtrbs;RBHGgÁ sIhmunI CYyxøH²pg. GñkmñagnigRBHraC

buRtk¾mandaMeckxøHEdr.

eBlevlahak;dUcCaenAnwgfál;. s¶at;sUnüBMumanB¤sUrsMeLgGVImYyeLIy. semþc sIhnu RTaM

Gt;sgát;RBHhb£T½yedays¶at;es¶óm. RBHviharRBHEkvmrktd¾Rss;s¥at EdlenAEk,rRBHbrmraCvaMg

RtÚve)aHbg;ecal. PaBs¶b;s¶at;dUcenAvalkb;exµacmYy)ansNæitenATIenaH ehIyRtÚveFVI[rMxanmþg

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 257

Page 268: Brother enemy

máaledaysarsMeLgTTHsøabehIrrbs;hVÚgstVRBabb:ueNÑaH. semþc)ankat;RBHT½y eFVIy:agNamin

beNþay[RBHraCsuxPaBxagpøÚvcitþcuHexSayeLIy. edayP½BVl¥ RBHGgÁenAmankmµsiT§iviTüúFMmYy

eRKÓgm:ak ®hánDik (Grundig) EdlCaGMeNayrbs; exov sMpn Edr. enHCa«bg¥Üc»rbs;RBHGgÁebIk

eTArkBiPBelak CameFüa)ayTMlayPaBdEdl²d¾KYr[RBWxøacEtmYyKt; EdlmanTaMgyb;TaMgéf¶

minecHcb;. erogral;RBwknigerogral;yb; RBHGgÁxMRbwgravcab;bu:sþ×viTüúTUTaMgBiPBelakGs;ry³eBl

CaeRcInem:agdUcCaviTüú b‘Íb‘ÍsuI sMeLgshrdæGaemrik viTüúGU®sþalI viTüúRhVg;GaMETr viTüúGinhas;karbs;

Cb:un nigviTüúhaNUyCaedIm. edaymanRbdab;sþab;sMeLgBak;elIRBHeks RBHGgÁRTg;sNþab;B½t’man

TaMgGs;enARbeTskm<úCa b:uEnþk¾sNþab;B½t’manrbs;tMbn;nigBiPBelakpgEdr.

semþcRTg;RBHsNþab;CamYyTwkRBHT½yrIkraylayLMeTAedayrebobkmSanþmYy GMBIB½t’man

epSg²Tak;TgnwgRBHGgÁ. BiPBelakBMuTan;ePøcrUbRBHGgÁeT. GñkykB½t’manmñak;)anGHGagfa RtÚveFVI

[Gak;Gn;RBHT½y edaysarGVIEdlRBHGgÁTteXIj RBHGgÁk¾)at;mat;ElgecjRBHvacaEtmþg. Gñk

ykB½t’manmñak;eTotEdlniyaysMGagtamsmþIrbs; eGog sarI )anbBa¢ak;fa semþc )anKg;Rbfab;

edaysuxRsYlbMputkñúgRBHraCdMNak;RBHGgÁ ehIyfaRBHGgÁ)anRTg;lixit«sarNa»¬RbvtþierOgedIm¦

rbs;RBHGgÁeTotpg. b:uEnþ sarI k¾manesckþIeqøIyedaHsaepSg²eTotsRmab;eRtómedayELkEdr.

enAniTaXrdUv qñaM1977 eGog sarI )anniyayenARbeTsm:aeLsuIsþIBIerOgGaf’kM)aMgTak;Tgnwgsemþc

sIhnu manbnÞÚl. semþcFøab;)anRbkasfa ³ «ebIsinCa´)anCYbBYkbreTs ´nwgmankmøaMgbnþeFVI

neya)ayteTAeTot».

lixitTUrelxTaMgLayrbs;GñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manEdlbBa¢ÚnmktaMgBIRBMEdnéf-km<úCa b¤BIrdæFanI

ÉeTotenAGasuI)anbgðaj[eXIjnUvkarcab;GarmµrN_EfmeTot. b:uEnþtamry³TUrelxTaMgenH GVIEdl

bgðajBIsßankarN_enAkm<úCatamry³lixitsarTUrelxTaMgenaH)anRtwmEteFVI[RBHGgÁRBÜyRBHT½ynig

fb;)armÖb:ueNÑaH. edayÉkÉg RBHGgÁRTg;RCabfa erOgniTanepSg²sþIBIesckþIQWcab; karkab;smøab;

kardak;eTasedaybgçM[eFVIkarCaTm¶n;EdlnaMmkniyayedayBYkGñkePosxøÜnExµrR)ab;eK R)ab;ÉgenaH

suT§EtCakarBit. Ca]TahrN_RBHGgÁRTg;RCabtamry³GñkyamRBHGgÁfa kRmiténkareRbIGMeBIreXar

eXA nigkarsb,ayedayeFVI[GñkÉeTotQWcab;evTnarbs;Gñkgb;nwgRTwsþIkumµúynIsþ ekµg²GacekIt

eLIgEmn.

enACMnan;enaH eKminEdlRbúgRby½tñxøaMgdUecñHeLIyenARkúgPñMeBj. edayehtuenHehIy )anCa

erogral;RBwk semþc sIhnu EtgykRBHT½yTukdak;sNþab;esckþIraykarN_rebobeXasnarbs;viTüú

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg258

Page 269: Brother enemy

ExµrRkhmedayebIksMeLgviTüúxøaMg²nigebIkbg¥ÚccMhTaMgGs;. eBlEdlRBHGgÁeFVIrebobenHedIm,I[

GñkyamdwgB¤rYcehIy RBHGgÁykRbdab;sþab;sMeLgmkBak;nwgRBHeksPøam edIm,IsNþab;B½t’manepSg²

CMuvijBiPBelakmþg. RBHGgÁ)anftcmøgTuknUvesckþIGtßaFib,aymYycMnYntamry³m:aej:mYyeRKÓg

kñúgeKalbMNgsRmab;RTg;RBHsNþab;eLIgvij nigviPaKdMNwgTaMgenaHedayl¥itl¥n;.

Tmøab;enHBMuEmnKµaneRKaHfñak;enaHeT. éf¶mYyenAcugqñaM1976RBHGgÁdwgfa exov sMpn man

bMNgnaMRBHGgÁyageTAeFVITsSnkic©mYyenAtamextþCamYyKat;. dUecñH RBHGgÁRtÚvEtTukecal

«kaEsSt» ftsMeLgEdlnwgnaM[mankarsgS½yenAkñúgRBHraCdMNak;rbs;RBHGgÁ. semþc sIhnu

)anrMB£kfa «semþc)ancMNayeBleBjmYyyb;edIm,IGat;bTceRmógTaMgGs;EdlRBHGgÁGaccab;

)antamviTüúTaMgrhn;kñúgeKalbMNglubecalB½t’manepSg²EdlRBHGgÁ)anftTukkalBIéf¶mun».

dMeNIrTsSnkic©CamYy exov sMpn enAtamextþmYycMnYn)anebIk»kas[RBHGgÁTteXIjc,as;

nUvlkçN³d¾FMeFgén «neya)aymhaelatepøaH» EdlepþImeFVIedayExµrRkhm. RBHGgÁ)anTteXIj

kardæanFMEdlmanBlkrRbús-RsIrab;Ban;nak;xMRbwgCIkRbLayTwky:agEvgrab;KILÚEm:Rt kñúgsPaBs¶b;

s¶at;KYr[GaNit. TidæPaBenHmanlkçN³dUcTIlany:agFMmYymansuT§EtmnusSesøókBak;exµAeFVIkar

BBak;BBUndUchVÚgRsemac. etIGñkTaMgenaHemIlsÁal;RBHGgÁBIcm¶ayeT? ebIsinCaBYkeKemIlsÁal;

semþc sIhnu Emn k¾BYkeKmankarxøacrn§t;Nas;kñúgkarmkeKarBRBHGgÁdUckalBIedIm. manEtmþgKt;

EdlhVÚgRbCaCnQrenAtamcieBa©Imfñl;CatiemIlsÁal;RBHGgÁ enAeBlEdlrfynþEmrsWedsBN’s

rbs;semþcQb;g:k;. mnusSmYycMnYn)anemIleXIjRBHP½®kþRBHGgÁtamkBa©k;rfynþ. BYkeKnaMKña

ERskeLIgfa «semþc«¡ semþc«» ehIyk¾sÞúHrt;tRmg;eTArkRBHGgÁPøam. semþc sIhnu EdlRtÚveFVI

[rMePIbjab;j½rRBHT½y)anmanbnÞÚlxSwbdak;Gñkmñag m:Unik fa «buNÑwgRKb;RKan;ehIy¡ ´eTAsMeNH

sMNalCamYyBYkeKsin» ehIyRBHGgÁbRmúgebIkTVarcuHBIrfynþ. exov sMpn EdlenAGgÁúyEk,r

GñkebIkbr)anbeBa©jTwkmuxdUcbisacmñak; nigniyayeTAkan;semþcfa «sUmRBHGgÁrm¶ab;GarmµN_ nig

sUmyagmkKg;kñúgrfynþvij». cMENkGñkmñag m:Unik )anGgVrkr[RBHGgÁKg;enAes¶óm kMuCMTas;nwg

bBa¢arbs;eK. eRkaymkGñkmñag)anmanbnÞÚlR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa ³ tameyabl;rbs;´¬Gñkmñag¦kar

Edl exov sMpn eFVIdUecñHKWedIm,IplRbeyaCn_ rbs;semþcEtb:ueNÑaH. exov sMpn BMucg;eFVI[RBHGgÁ

RbQYn eRBaHEthVÚgRbCaCnTaMgenaHeT TaMgmincg;[RBHGgÁRbfuyeRKaHfñak;nwgkarbHe)armYyrbs;

RbCara®sþpg. semþc sIhnu sBVRBHT½yeFVItamGñkmñagnigyagRtLb;mkkan;rfynþvij EdlbeBaäH

m:asuInecjdMeNIreTAy:agrh½sdUce)aHBYy. Gñkmñag m:Unik RkeLkeRkayeXIjRbCaCnTaMgenaHlut

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 259

Page 270: Brother enemy

CgÁg;cuHnigsÞabGEg¥ldIEdlsemþceTIbnwgdak;RBH)aTGm,aj;mijenH.

sRmab;semþck¾dUcCasRmab;RbCaCnExµrrab;lannak; karEfrkSaCIvitrbs;xøÜn[Kg;vgSKWCakþI

kgVl;mYyRKb;eBlevla. semþcRtÚvEtelbemaTnPaBrbs;RBHGgÁTukkñúgRBHT½y nigRtÚvEtyl;RBm

bnÞabRBHkaytameKÉg. enHCatémøEdlRtÚvbg;. eRkaymkRBHGgÁ)anmanbnÞÚlR)ab;erOgGaf’kM)aMg

mYyfa maneBlmYyenaH RBHGgÁmanRBHT½ysakl,gerIbRmHEdr. b:uEnþkan;EttsU‘RbqaMgnwgBYkeK

xøaMgeLIgkalNa eKkan;EtrwtbnþwgelIsmuneTAeTot. BYkeK)andkbuKÁlikeFVIkarrbs;RBHGgÁecjTaMg

Gs; ehIykat;pþac;karTak;TgRKb;Ebby:agCamYyRBHGgÁeTot. eBjmYyqñaM1977 RBHGgÁminEdl

eXIj exov sMpn cUlmkKal;Tal;EtesaH. enATIbMput eRkayBImanCemøaHd¾yUrnigy:agxøaMgCamYy

Gñkmñag m:Unik sþIBIbBaðaénkarminRBmcMNuHeKrYcmk semþc sIhnu )anRBmcuHcaj;edIm,IesckþIsuxkñúg

RKÜsarnigjativgSrbs;RBHGgÁ. tambnÞÚlpÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁfa RBHGgÁ)anyl;RBmelIksresIrExµr

Rkhm. RBHGgÁ)anmanbnÞÚlenAeBleRkaymkfa «sßanPaBrbs;eyIgRtÚv)anEklm¥RbesIrCagmun

bnþic b:uEnþkarbeBa¢arrkplRbeyaCn_TaMgenHEdl´BMuEdlnwkKitmþgNaesaH suT§EtCaGMeBIEdleFVI[

Gab;kitþiys. ´minEdlRtÚveKbM)ak;muxdUecñHTal;EtesaHkñúgmYyCIvit´». GVIEdlCakarlYgelam

citþEtmYyKt;KW«esñót»enHRbEhlCa)anCYyeRsacRsg;semþc nigRkúmRKÜsarrbs;RBHGgÁ[putBI

eRKaHfñak;dl;CIvitpgEdr.

BitNas; PaBkan;EtF¶n;F¶rénCemøaHCamYyevotNam y:agehack¾CacMENkCYyse®gÁaH

«sßanPaBGaRkk;» rbs;RBHGgÁxøHEdr. ExµrRkhm)anepþImeFVIyuT§nakarsmøab;rgÁalrbs;xøÜntam

rebobCak,ÜnnUvCnCatiExµredImkMeNItCaevotNam b¤CnEdlRtÚvsgS½yfamansmancitþcMeBaH

RbeTsevotNameday\t)anpþl;B½t’man[semþc sIhnu dwgeLIy. enAExemsa qñaM1977

ekItmankarvayqµk;dMbUg²eTAelIPUmievotNamTaMgLayenAtamRBMEdnBIsMNak;ExµrRkhm. bNþa

emdwknaMcinxøH)an):an;RbmaNy:agRtwmRtÚvGMBIeRKaHfñak;epSg²EdlelcecjBIneya)aypSgeRBg

rbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyücMeBlmYyEdlRbeTsrbs;xøÜnsßitenAÉekaTaMgRsúgelIqakGnþrCati. KWkñúg

ehtuplenHehIyEdlBYkemdwknaMcin)anENnaM b:ul Bt kñúg»kasénkarsñak;GaRs½yrbs;Kat;enA

Rkúgeb:kaMgkalBIExkBaØa-tula qñaM1977fa RtÚvGnuBaØat[semþc sIhnu yagcUlRsukvij

ehIyeRbIR)as;RBHkitþis½BÞ nigRbCaRbiyPaBrbs;RBHGgÁedIm,IEklm¥rUbPaBkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüenA

ÉbreTsCafµI. edIm,Ibgðaj[eXIjnUvkarykcitþTukdak;cMeBaHeCaKvasnarbs;mitþKat; elakRbFan

KIm GuIls‘ug )anepJI «Epøe):am» mYyk®nþkmkfVaysemþctamry³ b:ul Bt Edr.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg260

Page 271: Brother enemy

enHKWCaCMnUnd¾KYrCaTIrIkraymYyEdlmindwgxøÜnCamun. TegVIEtmYyKt;Edl b:ul Bt RBmbMeBj

muxkarenHbgðaj[eXIjc,as;fa Kat;Bi)aknwgeCosvagBIsemþc sIhnu Nas;. edaytRmÚv[ b:ul

Bt RBmTTYlykCMnUneTAfVaysemþc s[eXIjfa KIm GuIls‘ug BitCaykcitþTukdak;y:agxøaMgkñúgkar

bgðajmitþPaBrbs;Kat;. RbkarenHk¾CakmøaMgelIkTwkcitþmYyEdr. semþc sIhnu BMubeNþay[knøgeTA

nUv»kasTmøayPaBrs;enAÉekaTaMgRsúg EdlkñúgenaHRBHGgÁ)anRtÚvbgçaMg[enAEtkñúgvaMgtaMgBIedIm

qñaM1977eT. semþc)ansresrcuthµayCaelIkdMbUgepJIeTA[ b:ul Bt edIm,IsEmþgnUv«kardwgKuN

d¾RCaleRCA»rbs;RBHGgÁ. elIkTIBIr kñúg»kas«buNüxYbkMeNItbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCad¾CajC½y» nig

elIkTIbI edIm,IGbGrsresIr b:ul Bt cMeBaH«eCaKC½ykñúgdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;Kat;enARbeTscin

nigkUer:xageCIg». sarlixitTaMgenH)anRtÚvpSBVpSaytamviTüúPñMeBjy:agqab;rh½s. semþc sIhnu

)ankt;smÁal;rebobelgesIcfa GtßbTénsarlixitrbs;RBHGgÁ)anRtÚvEkERbn½yrebobeFVIy:ag

Na[Tal;Et«CMnUnd¾sb,úrs»enaH RtLb;eTACarbs; b:ul Bt pÞal;eTAvij. rebobbkRsaypSay

tamviTüúk¾dUcKñaEdr )aneFVI[semþcdwgfa RBHGgÁrMePIbRBHT½yb:unNanwg«menaseBa©tnamitþPaBnigkar

RsLaj;fñak;fñmd¾kk;ekþA EdlbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCaKitKUrcMeBaHRBHGgÁ». GnusSavrIy_EtmYyenH

)aneFVI[RBHGgÁenAEtcg;pÞúHsMeNIc. tamBitkarEdlviTüúPñMeBjerobrab;bBa©ÚlRBHnamRBHGgÁkñúg

bTGtßaFib,ayrbs;xøÜn KWCaRbpñÚlmYyEdleFVI[RBHGgÁsb,ayRBHT½yCag«Epøe):am»rbs; KIm

GuIls‘ug eTAeTot. enHKWCakaMrsµImYykñúgPaBggwtEdlB½T§CuMvijRBHGgÁ.

PaBs¶b;s¶at;munxül;BüúH 261

Page 272: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg262

Page 273: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI8karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM

éf¶TI24 ExmIna qñaM1978 KWCaéf¶fµImYyEdlRbEhlCaKµanerOgGaRkk;ekIteLIgenATIRkúg

hUCImijeLIy. bnþicmþg² RBHGaTitü)anrHeLIgecalkaMrsµImkelIkEnøgsagsg;navaEdlsßitkñúgsPaB

s¶b;s¶at;enAeLIy nigelIcugeQInanaEdlenAeRtIymçageToténTenøhUrkat;RkúgéRBnKr. enAtammat;

RcaMgTenø CnCaticin nigevotNamy:ageRcIn EdlesøókBak;exaGavPIhSam:anigGavkak;kMBughat;R)aN

tamk,ac;Kun étCi. tammhavifIegVógh‘uy nigenACMuvijpSarFM Gñkrs;enAtamcieBa©Imfñl; GñkGt;TICRmk

kMBugEtedklk;enAeLIyedaysNþÚkxøÜnpÞal;dI. Gñkrt;éqEkvkMBugrMkilyanyWt²tampøÚvRkalekAs‘U

edIm,IEsVgrkm:UydMbUgrbs;xøÜn. enAkac;RCúgpøÚveLfaj;tug ®sþIcMNas;lk;mImñak;)ancab;epþImerobcM

tuekAGIrbs;xøÜn. KµanGñkNamñak;bgðaj[eXIjnUvkarykcitþTukdak;sþab;bTcRmógbdivtþn_nigkar

eXasnaEdllan;B¤BIRbdab;bMBgsMeLgEdleKerobcMenATIlanLamsug enAkNþalTIRkúgbnþicesaH

eLIy. kñúgBnøWd¾RsTn;éneBlRBwkRBham bNþaCnkñúgTIRkúghak;dUcCanwkRsémeTAdl;eBlevlamYy

EdlxøÜnFøab;ehA«TIRkúgéRBnKr»enAeLIy.

dMeNIrcab;manskmµPaBeLIgvijrbs;TIRkúgenAeBlRBwkenaH mansPaBeFVI[eKPJak;ep¥IlbMput.

rfynþeyaFaCaeRcIneRKÓg)anelceFøaeLIgPøam²edaymindwgCaecjBIkEnøgNamk. BYkb:Ulis

EdlmanÉksNæanBN’RbepHRkemA TahanénkgT½Berobry nigBYknisSitrab;Ban;nak;Edlman):anéd

BN’Rkhm)anelatcuHRBwb²BIrfynþTaMgenaH ehIycab;epþImrayKñaCaRkLacRkRtgÁB½T§CuMvijTIRkúg

Pøam. Rbtiþbtþikard¾FMbMputmanrebobCaeyaFaEdlGnuvtþedayrbbkumµúynIsþcab;taMgBIkarputrlt;

eTAéns®gÁam )ancab;epþImehIy. sRtÚvrbs;eKeBlenHKW RkúmGñkCMnYjCaKhbtIEdlesckþIseRmc

GMBIeCaKvasnarbs;xøÜneTIbnwgRtÚvRbkastamesckþICUndMNwgmYy EdlpSBVpSayedayviTüúrbs;rdæa

Pi)al. BYkb:UlisEdlRbdab;GavuFRKb;édenAQrRbúgeCIgkarBImuxhagTMnijnanakNþalTIRkúg

b:uEnþmYyEpñkFMénkgT½B)aneFVIclnaeq<aHeTARcWLWg CaTIRkúgePøaHmYyrbs;TIRkúghUCImij Edlman

CnCaticinrs;enAPaKeRcInbMput. RtÚvdas;[PJak;BIdMeNkTaMgesuIgmemIgedaysarPaBj½rkeRkIkenH

GaNikCncinrab;Ban;nak;EdlminsUvkk;ekþAkñúgcitþ)anemIleXIjb:Ulisy:ageRcInkan;GavuFP¢g;mkmux

enARKb;TIkEnøg cMENkTahans½µRKcitþenAQrrayKñaB½T§CMuvijsgáat;tamrebobCak,Ün. mnusSPaKeRcIn

eCOfa enHRKan;EtCakarbgðajkmøaMgFmµtamYyrbs;BYkGaCJaFrbu:eNÑaH. eKKitfa kmøaMgTaMgenHnwg

263

Page 274: Brother enemy

eFVIkarcab;xøÜnmnusSmYycMnYn CakarsgswkeTAnwgkarRcÜlRcbl;EdleFVI[TIRkúgvwkvrkalBIbYnéf¶mun.

edayBit kalBIéf¶TI20 ExmIna qñaM1978 RcWLWgEdlCamCÄmNÐlBaNiC¢kmµrbs;rdæFanIPaK

xagt,ÚgKWCakEnøgEdlekItmanRBwtþikarN_mYyEbøkxusBIFmµta. karcab;xøÜnyuvCncinmñak;EdlrwgTTwg

kñúgeBlEdlkgT½BkMBugekNÐGñkEdlmanGayuRtÚveFVITahan )anbNþal[mankarRbmUlpþMúKñaBBak;BBUn

ehIy)anERbkøayy:agqab;rh½seTACa)atukmµmYyEdlekIteLIgÉg²RbqaMgnwgrbbdwknaMRbeTs.

rUbftmYysnøwkrbs; em:A esTug RtÚv)an)atukrelIkRKvIeLIgelI. mnusSRbmaN200nak;PaKeRcIn

CaGaNikCncin )anedIrdEgðCak,ÜnenAtampøÚvnanaénRkúgRcWLWgedayERskbnÞrBaküesøakdEdl².

BYk)atukr)anTamTar[bBa¢ÚnBYkeKeTAmatuRbeTsvij edaybdiesFkarnireTseTAkan;«tMbn;esdækic©

fµI» EdlBi)akkñúgkarrs;enAnigkareRCIserIsyuvCnekµg²bBa©ÚleTAkñúgkgT½BevotNamedaybgçM.

TsSnvis½yénkrNIykic©beRmICaTahanKµanzannþrskþi EdleKeRbI[søab;kñúgCemøaHRBMEdnCamYy

RbeTskm<úCaEdlkan;EtRsÜcRsal;eLIg²enaH KµanGVIeFVI[BYkeKmanTwkcitþesaH. BYkb:Ulis)anvay

sRmúkbMEbkhVÚg)atukredayeRbIdMbg ehIy)ancab;mnusSRbEhldb;BIrnak;.

vaelcrUbragy:agqab;rh½s ³ karBRgaykmøaMgb:UlisenAéf¶TI24 ExmIna enHKWtRmg;eTArk

eKaledAFMepSgmYyeTot. TIRkúgRcWLWgnwgRtÚvRbharcMebHdUgEtmþg. mnusSRbdab;GavuFTaMgenH )an

QrRbúgeCIgkartamdgpøÚvCab;Canic© xN³EdlTahans½µRKcitþekµg²cUlEqkeqrrebobCak,ÜntampÞH

nighaglk;TMnijTaMgLayedIm,IEsVgrkmasnigrUbiyb½NÑepSg²EdlRtÚvykeTAtmál;TukkñúgXøaMg.

BYkeKk¾eFVIbBa¢IsareBIP½NÐkt;RtaRTBüsm,tþiTaMgGs;EdlrdæaPi)almanbMNgrwbGUseFVICaRTBüsm,tþi

rdæEdr. karrukerItMbn;enH)anebIk»kas[eKrkeXIjbrimaNdMumasnigluyduløarmYycMnYnFM Edl

RtÚveKdwkCBa¢ÚnykeTATukenAkEnøgsuvtßiPaBy:agrh½s. bRmammYy RtÚv)anRbkaseLIgsRmab;Gñk

CMnYjTaMgGs; edayhammin[lk;dUrRTBüsm,tþiTaMgLayEdl)ancuHbBa¢IsareBIP½NÐnigEdlRbkasfa

Carbs;CatirYcehIyeT. RbCaCnevotNamsamBaØEdlminsb,aynwgeXIjkarrlMdYlénGaNtþi

rbs;TIRkúgRcWLWg )anedIrniyaybriharfa ³ rdæaPi)al)anrwbGUsmasrhUtdl;R)aMBIretanÉeNaH.

tamkareqøIy[karN_rbs;GñkeTscrbreTsmñak; kñúgcMeNamGñkeTscrbreTsd¾kRmman Edlman

vtþmanpÞal;nwgkEnøg)anniyayfa «TIRkúghUCImij hak;dUcCaRtÚveFVI[q¶l;RsLaMgkaMg. edayT½lR)aCJ

mindwgKity:agNa mnusSCaeRcIn)anrt;eqøqøacuHeLIgeRbóbdUckNþúrCab;RTúgkñúgPaBGs;sgÇwmhYs

kRmit». GaNikCncindb;R)aMbInak;)aneFVIGtþXatenAeRkayéf¶d¾Rcbl;vwkvrenaH.

rdæaPi)alevotNamminEdllak;)aMgeKalbMNgrbs;xøÜnkñúgkarbegáIt[manlT§isgÁmniym enA

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg264

Page 275: Brother enemy

PaKxagt,ÚgtamkalbriecäTEdlxøÜnkMNt;enAqñaM1980eLIy. b:uEnþ dMeNIrekIteLIgPøam² nigRbti-

btþikard¾manRTg;RTayFMeFgenH)aneFVI[BiPBelakP½nþPaMgRsLaMgkaMg. taMgBIqñaM1975 rdæaPi)al

fµIrbs;kumµúynIsþ)andak;[mankarEkTRmg;xagrUbiyvtßúmYy EdlbNþal[RbCaCnevotNam enAPaK

xagt,ÚgrlayhinehacRTBüsm,tþiGs;. taMgBIenaHmk rdæ)anxñHExñgCaeRcInelIkeRcInsaedIm,IbegáIn

karRtÜtRtarbs;xøÜneTAelIshRKasÉkCnnananigdak;bgçM[bg;Bn§kan;EtF¶n;eLIg². b:uEnþ kñúgkarrwt

bnþwgenH vahak;dUcCamancenøaHRbehagmYyEdlGñkCMnYjcincitþsøúyGacecjrYcCanic©. elIkenH

BYkeKRtÚvvaypÞb;eFVI[ElgkeRmIkekItEtmþg. Tahans½µRKcitþekµg²rab;Ban;nak;Edl)anhVwkhat;

CaBiessenAkEnøgepSg²q¶aydac;BIeKÉg )anmkCYyBYkkmµaPi)albkSnigPñak;garrbs;rdæEdr. kar

cUleTAEqkeqrkñúgshRKasTaMgLaykan;EtekIneRcIneLIg² GVI²EdlsMxan;suT§EtRtÚvRtÜtBinitüelIk

ElgEtePaCnIydæanecj. EtmYyEPøtesaH RKÜsarcMnYn30>000)anRtÚveKdeNþImykRTBüsm,tþi

Gs;rlIgBIxøÜn nigdkhUtmeFüa)ayciBa©wmCIvitEfmeTot. éf¶TI3 Ex]sPa RkdasR)ak;rbs;evotNam

xagt,ÚgRtÚvlubbM)at;ecal. GñkrkSaTukluyeRcIn²)an)at;bg;GVI²TaMgRsug b¤esÞIrEtTaMgGs;.

tamk,Ünc,ab;eKGacbþÚrRkdasR)ak;EdlGs;témøCamYynwgRkdasR)ak;fµI)an b:uEnþcMnYnRkdasR)ak;

EdlrdæbeBa©j[eFVIcracrmantictYcbMput1.

karpøas;RTg;RTayPaKxagt,Úg[eTACarbbsgÁmniymEdleKRbkas[dwgtaMgBIyUrmkehIy

enaH enATIbMput)ancab;epþIm. karvayRbharcM²RbqaMgnwgrbbmUlFnniym)anekItmanRBmKñaCamYy

nwgkarcab;epþImGMeBIRbTUsr:ayedayecjmuxrvagRbeTsevotNamnigRbeTscinsgÁmniymEdr.

d,itrhUtmkdl;kalbriecäTenH karvayRbharedayBaküsmþIrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrmansPaB

dUcCadavenAkúñgeRsamenAeLIy. cab;BIeBlenHeTA erOgenaHKµanGITak;TgnwgCemøaHCacMhrvagevot-

Namnigkm<úCaeT. RkúghaNUyRKan;EtniyaybriharCasaFarN³BI«BYkRbtikiriyaGnþrCati» EdlpÁt;

pÁg;GavuF[ExµrRkhmb:ueNÑaH cMENkRkúgeb:kaMgvij)anvayRbharcMeBaH«Gñkecjmuxkan;eCIgKMnit

GnutþrPaBniym»>>>edayecosvagminbeBa©jeQµaHGñkTaMgenaHpgeT. b:uEnþkarvayRbhareTAelIRkúg

RcWLWg nigkarcakecalRsukTaMghVÚg²CabnþbnÞab;Kña rbs;CnCaticinenAevotNam)anpøas;bþÚrGVI²TaMg

Rsúg. RbeTscin)anefáaleTasCapøÚvkarcMeBaHRbtibtþikarrbs;evotNamenH. kñúgeBlCamYyKña

enaH enARbeTskm<úCa braC½yénkaregIbbHe)armYyRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt RbEhlCanwgnaM[manGnþra-

Kmn_mYyrbs;evotNamRbqaMgnwgRbeTsenHedayecosminput. mü:ageTot karCab;édrbs;evot-

NamkñúgCemøaHCacMhmYyCamYyRbeTscin )aneFVI[shRbtibtþikarrvagevotNamnigshPaBsUevot

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 265

Page 276: Brother enemy

manel,Ónkan;EtelOneTAmuxswgEtedaysV½yRbvtþi. GVI²TaMgGs;sßitenAtamkEnøgeRsc edIm,Inwg

ebIkpøÚveTArkCemøaHmYyEdlnwgehorhYsBIRBMEdnevotNam nigkm<úCaeTAeTot.

karcUllukluyrbs;BYkkumµúynIsþevotNamRbqaMgnwgRkúgRcWLWgEdlCamCÄmNÐlmUlFn

niymd¾sMxan; BMuEmnekIteLIgeday\tRBagTukCamunenaHeT. BitehIy eKGacebIkeFVIyuT§nakarenH

eRkayBIkarecjdMeNIrrbs;GñkkaEstbreTsTaMgGs;EdlmkesuIbGegátGMBIkarbgáehturbs;Exµr

RkhmenAtamRBMEdnénRbeTsTaMgBIrEtb:ueNÑaH. cMENk´¬GñkniBn§¦ ´)ansßitenATIRkúghUCImij rhUt

dl;éf¶TI20 ExmIna. ´)aneFVIdMeNIreTAsYrsuxTukçmitþPkþicas;²enAkñúgTIRkúgRcWLWg nigbriePaK)ayCa

mYyBYkeKy:agsb,ayrIkraykñúgePaCnIydæancinnanaEdlmanmnusSsuIpwkceg¥ótENn. PaBpÞúyKña

rvagpSarRcWLWgEdlmanmnusSkuHkr nigeBareBjeTAedayTMnijnaMcUledayeKcBn§ b¤plitkñúgRsúk

nigtutaMgTMnijenApSarTIRkúghaNUyEdlKµanTMnijdak;eRBaHRtÚvdkhUtKµansl;y:agKYr[GaNit )an

eFVI[´RsLaMgkaMg. GñkGmdMeNIr´suT§EtCaevotNamxageCIgEdlmkBIRksYgkarbreTs)anQr

smøwgemIlTMnijsmÖareRbIR)as;RKb;mux kñúgTUkBa©k;TaMgPøwkPøaMg edaysarBYkeKeTIbEt)aneXIjCaelIk

dMbUgbMput b:uEnþ)andkfymkvij enAeBlEdleXIjb½NÑtémørbs;va. ´)anB¤RbCaCnrG‘UrTaMBIGa-

kb,kiriyaBYkkmµaPi)alRkúghaNUytaMgBIeBlenaHemø:H EdlRtÚvecaTRbkan;fa )andeNþImPaKxag

t,Úg ehIy´dNþwgsYrkñúgcitþfa etIPaKxageCIgEdlmanrebobrbbrs;enAtwgruwgRtÚvkareBlevlab:unµan

edIm,ITb;Tl;nwg«mnþesñh_»rbs;TIRkúgRcWLWg)an? eL kVagcan; GnuRbFanKN³kmµaFikarRbCaCn

bdivtþn_énGtItrdæFanIPaKxagt,Úg )anniyayR)ab;´fa «Parkic©rbs;eyIgKWRtÚveFVI[TIRkúgmYyTaMgmUl

eq<aHeTArkkarbegáInplitpl]bePaK-briePaK TIRkúgmYyEdleRbIR)as;eBlevlaTaMgGs;sRmab;

karplit edIm,I[skþismnwgeQµaHhUCImij». KUsnÞnarbs;´enAEtminR)akdesaHkñúgkarerobrab;GMBI

dMeNIrpøas;bþÚrsgÁmTaMgRsugenH.

´)anvilRtLb;eTARkúghaNUyvijenAéf¶23 ExmIna dUcEdleRKagTukCamun. karecjdMeNIr

rbs;´BIRbeTsevotNamRtÚv)ankMNt;CamunsRmab;éf¶Es¥kRBwk. b:uEnþ´maneBlevlarkeXIjmUl

ehtuepSg²énkarTamTaredayTTUcrbs;evotNamEdlkat;bnßykarsñak;GaRs½yrbs;eyIg.

kñúg»kaselogsayePaCn_EdlerobcMeLIgsRmab;eyIgedayKN³kmµaFikarTMnak;TMngvb,Fm’CamYy

breTs ´)anCYbsMeNHsMNalCamYy hug ha GñkTTYlxusRtÚvGtßbTEpñkesdækic©rbs;kaEst

jinhSin GMBIbBaðaCaeRcInsþIBIkarksaglT§isgÁmniymenAevotNamxagt,Úg. bIqñaMeRkay karrMedaH

fVIebImankarEkTRmg;xagrUbiyvtßúEdlmanlkçN³RbqaMgnayTunk¾eday k¾esdækic©enAPaKxagt,ÚgenAEt

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg266

Page 277: Brother enemy

BwgEp¥kCasMxan;elIkarepþImKMnitrbs;ÉkCnCanic©. esÞIrEtRKb;vis½yxagEpñk]sSahkmµ nigBaNiC¢kmµ

xagRsUvGgár EdlCaEpñkyuT§sa®sþsMxan;bMputenaH suT§EtRtÚvRtÜtRtaedayBYkshRKinÉkCncinTaMg

Gs;. tamkarvaytémøxøHfa RcWLWgCaTIRkúgEtmYyKt;EdlRkesabRTBüFnCarUbiyvtßúPaKxagt,Úgdl;

eTABak;kNþal ehIyPaKeRcInénTunCamasnigrUbiyb½NÑkMBugkøayeTACarbs;mYyEdlRbqaMg\T§iBl

Epñkesdækic©d¾manskþanuBl2. RcWLWg Ca«ebHdUgmUlFnniymmYyEdlkMBugelatkñúgxøÜnR)aNsgÁm

niymevotNam». tammtirbs; hug ha fa RbkarenHCasBaØaR)ab;[dwgnUvkarGt;Xøan pSarggwt

nigGtiprNaEdleFVI[manGnþraydl;PaKxagt,ÚgCasaFarN³. ´sYrfa etIelakeRKagedaHRsay

bBaðaenHedayrebobNaeTA? hug )aneqøIytbmk´vijCamYykarjjwmrebobcMGkelgfa «eyIg

)anKitKUrBIerOgenHehIy». éf¶Es¥keLIg kmµaPi)albkSnigsmaCikénkmøaMgsnþisuxrab;Ban;nak;)an

cab;epþImeFVI«karvHkat;ebHdUg»mYyy:agFMsem,Im.

eRkaymk´)andwgfa karerobcMRbúgeRbóbeFVIkarvayRbharRbqaMgnwgmUlFnniymnig\T§iBl

esdækic©rbs;CnCaticinenAPaKxagt,Úg )anmaneLIgRBmKñanwgkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbmYyTak;Tgnwg

km<úCapgEdr. kñúgclnaRBmKñaEtmYy kariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamEdlrYmRbCMu

enABak;kNþalExkumÖ³ qñaM1978)anseRmccitþbegáIt[manclnatsU‘mYyRbqaMg b:ul Bt nigedIm,I

snþisuxRbeTs)anBinitüBic½yBIplvi)akTaMgLay EdlelcecjBIkarRtÜtRtaEpñkesdækic©edayBYk

CnCaticinenAPaKxagt,ÚgeTotpg. eKsßitenAkñúgsßanPaBCitdl;karRbQmmuxmYyfµInigF¶n;F¶rCamYy

km<úCa EdlCasm<n§½mitþrbs;RbeTscinehIy. karmnÞilrbs;evotNamRbqaMgnwgshKmn_cind¾man

GMNac)anRtÚvBRgwgEfmeTotenAExmkra tamry³neya)ayfµIEdlepþImeLIgedayRkúgeb:kaMgcMeBaH

CnCaticinenAbreTsEdlGMBavnav[GñkTaMgenaHrYbrYmKña KaMRTkartsU‘«RbqaMgGnutþrPaB»cab;BIéf¶enH

teTA. enABak;kNþalExmIna qñaM1978 kariyal½yneya)ayevotNam)anrYmRbCMuKñaCafµIenATIRkúg

hUCImijkñúglkçN³sm¶at;bMput edIm,IerobcMbBa©b;Epnkarl¥itl¥n;cugeRkayrbs;xøÜnkñúgkarvayluk

RbqaMgTIRkúgRcWLWg. karseRmccitþEdlhak;dUcCavasnatRmÚvenH nwgbNþal[mankarcakecal

RsukTaMghVÚg²mYy kñúgcMeNamkarcakecalRsukTaMghVÚgTaMghVayd¾FMsem,ImeRkaysm½ys®gÁam.

karseRmccitþenHnwgbEnßmTMhMénkarerIseGIgCatisasn_fµImYyeTAkñúgCemøaHepSg²EdlkMBugeFVI[Gñk

CatiniymenAGasuIRbQmmuxdak;KñapgEdr.

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 267

Page 278: Brother enemy

bNÐit ehSxIl (Jekyll) nigelak éhd_ (Hyde) enAsgáat;cin**

PaBtantwgrvagcin-evotNamenArdUvekþAqñaM1978 RKan;EtCavKÁmYyénRbvtþisa®sþd¾yUrlg;

mYyb:ueNÑaHEdledImkMeNItrbs;vak¾RcLMbl;nwgedImkMeNItrbs;RbCaCatievotNamEdr ticb¤eRcIn

EtgEtbgá[manCemøaHmYyrvagKñanwgKñaCanic©. kareFVIGenþaRbevsn_elIkdMbUgrbs;CnCaticincUlmk

rs;enAkñúgRbeTsevotNammanb£sKl;taMgBIstvtSr_TIbImunRKisþskraCem:øH. kñúgry³eBlBIrBan;qñaM

CabnþbnÞab;mkeTot-ehIyCaBiesskñúgfirevla900qñaMénkarRtÜtRtarbs;cinelIPaKxageCIg

evotNam-rlkénkareFVIGenþaRbevsn_rbs;CnCaticin manTaMgTahanrMsay GñkraCkar GñkFøab;Cab;

Kuk nigBYkrt;ecalCYr )ancUlmkrs;enAevotNambnþKñabNþak;dUcxüg. RbQmmuxnwgkarcUlmky:ag

kuHkr \riyabfrbs;bNþaemdwknaMRbeTsevotNamEdlÉkraCü EtgEtbgðaj[eXIjlkçN³BIr

y:agpÞúyKñaCanic© ³ BYkeKRBmTTYledayrIkraynUvkarrYmkmøaMgrbs;CnCaticin edIm,IBRgwgrbbrbs;xøÜn

b:uEnþk¾RBWxøacBYkcinTaMgenaHbgáCa]bsKÁepSg² enAéf¶NamYyEdr. BYkGenþaRbevsn_cin)anrYbrYmCa

shKmn_mYyEdlsuT§swgCaGñkRsLaj;kargar nigeKarBvin½yEdlGacrYmviPaKTankñúgkarkab;qáarran

dIfµI/ kartaMgCaGaNaniKmelIdIfµI² karGPivDÆn_EpñkBaNiC¢kmµnigkarlatsn§wgénGFibetyüPaBrbs;

evotNamEfmeTot. enAstvtSr_TI17 Gñkkan;eCIgsnþtivgSmij (Ming) rab;ryBan;nak;EdleK

dkhUtsiT§i ehIyEdlkMBugrt;eKcBIGñkQøanBanm:an;CU (Mandchou) )anmkdl;RkúgéRBnKr cMENk

emdwknaMExµrEdlRKan;EtmaneQµaHfa CaGñkRKb;RKgenaH BMudwgRbkan;yk\riyabfEbbNaeLIy

cMeBaHniKmCnRbdab;GavuFTaMgenH. ehtuenHehIy)anCaemdwknaMExµr)anesñIsMu[RbmuxénsnþtivgS

egVón rbs;evotNamCYyRBHGgÁpg. edayminbg¥g;yUr emdwknaMsnþtivgS egVón )anbgçM[GñkTaMg

enaHeKarBtamxøÜnnigykeTAdak;[rs;enAkEnøgmYyminq¶ayBIéRBnKrb:unµaneLIy TIenaHKWsßitenARtg;

pSarRcWLWgbc©úb,nñenH. edIm,ICafñÚrTIRkúgéRBnKr)anTTYlsÁal;siT§iGFiraCelIRbeTscMNuHrbs;

snþtivgS egVón. k¾b:uEnþ TahancinmYyRkúmepSgeTotEdldwknaMedaym:ak;KU (Mac Cu) )anmktaMgenA

tMbn; haeTog (Ha Tien) EdlenAeBlenaHCadIrbs;km<úCaenAeLIy. m:ak;KU EdlRbkasxøÜnÉgCa

«RBHraCaenAhaeTog»)anerobcM EdndIrbs;xøÜneTACakEnøgBaNiC¢kmµd¾rIklUtlas;mYynigBRgIkkar

RtÜtRtarbs;xøÜneTAelIbNþaextþCitxageTot. RBHGgÁ)anseRmcdak;xøÜnenAkñúg»vaT¬xagneya)ay¦

RBHecAGFiraC egVón edayehtuenH RBHGgÁ)anBRgIkEdndIrbs;evotNamrhUtmkdl;RBMEdnPaK

xagt,Úgbc©úb,nñrbs;xøÜn 3.

b:uEnþedayeRbIR)as;BYkniKmCncinTaMgenH BYkemdwknaMevotNamBMuEdleFVsRbEhsnwgBYkGñk

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg268

Page 279: Brother enemy

TaMgenaHeLIy. BYkenHsuT§EtmanedImkMeNItenARbeTsd¾FMlVwgelVIymYyEdlFøab;manmhicätayk

RbeTsevotNamdak;CacMNuH ehIyRbkarenHÉgEdlRKb;RKan;eFVI[BYkeKRtÚvCab;sgS½yminecHcb;.

kñúgry³eBlénkarbHe)arrbs;bgb¥ÚnRtkUl étsun bInak;Edl)andwknaMkarbHe)armYyRbqaMgnwg

RBHecAGFiraCevotNamenAstvtSr_TI18enaH CnCaticinenARcWLWgmYymuWnnak;)anRtÚvBYkbHe)ar

smøab;y:agrgÁal. kñúgGMLúgeBlEdlmansPaBFUrRsÜlxøH BYkCnCaticinrs;enAmanesrIPaBbribUrN’

nigrksuIeFVImaneFVI)an b:uEnþenAEtrs;enAdac;edayELkBIRbCaCnevotNamCanic©. enAqñaM1840

GFiraC mij m:ag énsnþtivgS egVón EdlegOgq¶l;edaysmÁal;eXIjm®nþICan;x<s; GmRBHraCaesom

GnuBaØat[BYkCnCaticinrs;enArYmKñaCamYyRbCaCnkñúgRsukenaH )anniyayTukCamunfa kareFVs

RbEhsminbMEbkCnCatiTaMgenaH[rs;enAdac;edayELkBIKña nwgnaMeTAdl;kardYlrlMRbeTsesommin

xan4.

GñkÉkeTsCb:unmñak;xagbBaðaTaMgenH)ankt;smÁal;edayRtwmRtÚvbMputfa «CnCaticinenAevotNam

KWxusKñatictYcBIerOgRbelamelakmancMNgeCIgfa bNÐit ehSxIl nigelak éhd_ ³ BYkeKsuT§EtCa

mnusSRbkbedayeRKaHfñak;EdlRtÚvEtXøaMemIl[ditdl;Canic© nigCashKmn_mYyEdleKGaceRbI

R)as;CaRbeyaCn_y:agGs;BIcitþpg>>>. bNþaGFiraCénsnþtivgS egVón EdlCaGñkpþl;esckþIGnueRKaH

dl;shKmn_cin k¾RBÜy)armÖGMBITMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;BYkenHCamYyRbeTskMeNItrbs;eKEdr eday

eRbIR)as;BYkenHedIm,I[ykkarN_GMBIsßankarN_enARbeTscin kñúgeKalbMNgEklm¥TMnak;TMngrvag

RbeTsTaMgBIr[rwtEtRbesIreLIg»5.

fVIebIbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamhak;dUcCaTTYldMENlEdlmanPinPaKBIrpÞúyKñad¾sMxan;k¾eday

k¾\riyabfrbs;xøÜncMeBaHcinmanlkçN³Cak;lak;Nas; edaysarPaBdUcKñaEpñkmenaKmviC¢arvagRkúg

eb:kaMg nighaNUykñúgTsvtSr_50nig60 nigedaysarevotNamRtÚvkarkic©KaMRTEpñksmÖarswkkñúg

kartsU‘edIm,IkarbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTsrbs;xøÜneLIgvij. tamkarBitshKmn_cinenAPaKxageCIgman

cMnYntictYcb:ueNÑaH ¬15PaKrykñúgcMnYnCnCaticinTaMgGs;Edlrs;enAevotNam¦ ehIyPaKeRcInman

muxrbrCakmµkr GñkeFVIkarkñúgGNþÚgEr: nigGñkensaT dUecñHkardak;BYkeK[manRkbx½NÐedaybkSBMu

bgðaj[eXIjnUvkarlM)akFMdMueT. lkçnþik³rbs;BYkGaNikCnRbmaNdb;muWnnak;enH kñúgRbeTssgÁm

niymCabgb¥ÚnmYyBuMmanTak;Tgnwgc,ab;epSg²rbs;RbeTsCatieT b:uEnþmanRtwmEtkarRBmeRBógKña

mYyrvagbkSnigbkSb:ueNÑaH. kic©RBmeRBógmYyRtÚv)ancuHhtßelxaenAqñaM1955 Edlmanxøwmsar

fa «dak;BYkGaNikCncin[sßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;bkSBlkrevotNam» nigmintRmÚv[eRCIs

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 269

Page 280: Brother enemy

erIsPøam²nUvsBa¢atiNamYyxusBICnrYmCatirbs;xøÜnEdltaMglMenAkñúgbNþaRbeTsGasuIGaeKñy_epSg

eTotEdleTIbnwg)anÉkraCüfµI²eLIy. BYkeKGacrs;enARbeTsevotNam nigrkSasBa¢aticin)an

luHNaEtenATIbMputkøayeTACaBlrdæevotNamEdr.

kñúgGMLúgeBl23qñaM EdlmanbnþbnÞab;BIkic©RBmeRBógEdleFVIeLIgedayBaküsmþIenH Rkúg

haNUyBMuEdleFVIGVImYyedIm,IbgçitbgçMBlrdæcinrbs;xøÜn[cUlsBa¢atievotNameLIy. b:uEnþenAqñaM

1961 RbeTscin)anRBmtamsMeNImYyrbs;evotNamEdlERbCa[BYkcinenAevotNamxageCIg

TaMgGs;cUlsBa¢ati edayRKan;Etsnüapþl;TidæakarEpñkeTscrN_[CnCaticinenAevotNam EdlsuMeTA

sYrsuxTukçRKÜsarrbs;xøÜnenARbeTscinb:ueNÑaH7.

sßanPaBBiessenH)aneFVI[CIvPaBrs;enARbcaMéf¶rbs;BYkGaNikCncinmanPaBgayRsÜl nig

pþl;[BYkeKnUvzan³CaCnCatiPaKticmYyEdlmanÉksiT§i. ek s‘n; CaCnCaticinnigCaGtItGñktaMg

lMenAeRkARsukenARkúghaNUy)anniyayrMB£kfa «BYkeyIg)anTTYlnUvPaBl¥RbesIrCageK BITaMg

sgxag. enAPaKxageCIg BYkCnCati v:a ¬CnCatievotNamedImkMeNItcin¦ )aneRkbCBa¢k;Gtß

RbeyaCn_RKb;Ebby:agBIsBa¢atievotNamedayKµanTTYlplBi)akNamYyeLIy. RbEhlCaenAqñaM

1970 evotNam)ansakl,g[BYkeyIgcUlsBa¢ati b:uEnþ PaKeRcInbMputkñúgcMeNamBYkeyIgemIl

BuMeXIjmanGIVEdlcMeNjBIbBaðaenHeT. eyIgmansiTi§rhUtdl;eTAe)aHeqñateTotpg. eKcat;TukBYk

eyIgCaCnCatievotNameBjlkçN³ elIkElgEtBYkeyIgrwgrUskñúgkarRsg;eQµaH edIm,IcUleFIV

Tahanb:ueNÑaH»8.

ÉksiT§ieRkayenH CaÉksiT§iEdlmantémøelIslb;kñúgRbeTsmYyEdlRKÜsarnImYy²EtgEt

)at;bg;smaCikmñak;kñúgcMeNamsmaCikRKÜsarrbs;xøÜnEdlecjeTAeFIVs®gÁamrMedaHCati. dUcédKU

rbs;xøÜnenARbeTscinEdr GñkCMnYjcinenAevotNamxageCIgk¾RTaMRTnwgplvi)akepSg²BIkarEkTRmg;

sgÁmniymdUcKña b:uEnþBMuTTYlrgkarQWcab;edaysarkarRbkan;BUCsasn_NamYyeLIy. tamBit

manm®nþIrdækarmYycMnYnFMEdlecjGMBICnCatiPaKticcin)ankan;kab;muxtMENgsMxan;²enAkñúgépÞbkS

nigrdæaPi)aleTotpg. eRkamrbbRbqaMgkumµúynIsþénsaFarNrdæevotNamxagt,Úg shRKasTaMg

LayEdlRKb;RKgedayBYkcinsuT§EtrksuIman)an b:uEnþ BYkefAEk²)anRtÚvbgçitbgçMeday g:UDij

eyom [CaGñkneya)ayevotNamxagt,Úg¬1901-1963¦. Kat;)aneFVICardæm®nþITI1enA

evotNamxagt,ÚgkñúgqñaM1954 ehIy)anRbkasRbeTsenHCasaFarNrdæenAqñaM1955. Ca

RbFanaFibtIEdlRTRTg;edayshrdæGaemrik ¬1956-1963¦ Kat;)anerobcMbegáItCarbb

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg270

Page 281: Brother enemy

pþac;karmYy. Kat;)anRtÚveKsmøab;kñúg»kasénkareFVIrdæRbharmYy-kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb] [Rbkan;

yksBa¢atievotNameRkamkarKMrambBaÄb;skmµPaBTaMgGs;rbs;BYkeK. Rkúgeb:kaMg)antv:aRbqaMg

nwgkarerIseGIgCatisasn_enH edaymankarKaMRTBIrNsirSrMedaHCatievotNamxagt,Úgpg. RtÜtRta

edayRkúghaNUy rNsirSCatirMedaHevotNamxagt,Úg)ansnüa[BYkcinenAPaKxagt,ÚgeRCIserIs

sBa¢atirbs;xøÜnedayesrIbnÞab;BIkarrMedaHRbeTsCatirYc.

k¾b:uEnþ \riyabfrbs;BYkkumµúynIsþevotNam)ancab;epþImpøas;bþÚrenAcugstvtSr_60 enAeBl

EdlkarRcbl;vwkvrénbdivtþn_vb,Fm’)ansayPaymkdl;shKmn_cinenAevotNamxageCIg.

enAeBlEdlBYkqµaMRkhmenARbeTscinefáaleTasRkúghaNUy nigb:unb:gbBaÄb;karpÁt;pÁg;smÖarswk

rbs;cin BYkem:AniymkñúgshKmn_cinenAevotNamxageCIg)anbnþkarbdivtþvb,Fm’pÞal;rbs;xøÜneday

ecaTbkSkumµúynIsþevotNamfamanKMnitesIerIniym9.

naKeRkakBIdMeNk

dUcGñkTTYlxusRtÚvevotNamTTYlsÁal;erOgenHEdrfa KWcab;taMgBImanbdivtþn_vb,Fm’ ehIy

CaBiesscab;taMgBIdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;RbFanaFibtI nicsun enARbeTscinkñúgqñaM1972 EdlemdwknaM

fñak;kMBUlénzananuRkmbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam)ancab;epþImKitfa eKetagEtQb;TukcitþBYkm®nþIrdækar

EdlecjmkBICnCatiPaKticcin. cMNgEdlbegáItedaykarsnüaEpñkmenaKmviC¢a rYmKñasRmab;

shKmn_TaMgBIr)ancab;epþImrlaxSak. bnÞab;BIdMeNIrrbs; nicsun ebIRkúgeb:kaMgElgKYr[Tukcitþ

ehIy ehtuGVI)anCaBYkm®nþIrdækaredImkMeNItcinenAmanmuxtMENgeTot eTaHbICaBYkenH CamnusSCMnan;

TIBIrk¾eday?. TMnak;TMngepSg²rvagrdænigrdækMBugFøak;kñúgsßanPaBGaRkk; karminTukcitþeKÉg nig

KMnitRbqaMgcinrbs;evotNamEdlmankñúgcitþtaMgBI2000qñaMénRbvtþisa®sþ)anpuseLIgCafµI. BYk

m®nþIrdækar«cin» EfmTaMgRtÚveKRbKl;Parkic©fµI²[kan;kab;edays¶at;kM)aMgeTotpg. GMNwHteTA

BYkeKElgmanmeFüa)ayTTYl)anB½t’manc,as;las;eTotehIy.

enAqñaM1975 BYkemdwknaMevotNammanCMenOR)akdkñúgcitþy:agCak;lak;fa ³ Rkúgeb:kaMgBMu

sb,aycitþnwgeXIjkarelceLIgnUvRbeTsevotNammYyEdlrYmKñaeLIgvij nigxøaMgBUEkeLIy.

evotNamminEdlePøcesaHeLIyBIeRKaHfñak;emIlmineXIj EdlbgðajeLIgedayRbeTscin eTaHCa

sßitkñúgGarmµN_sb,ayrIkrayenAeBlmanC½yCmñHk¾eday. eKdMNalfa enAEx]sPa qñaM1975

GKÁelxabkS eL yn; eBlmkdl;mUldæanGakas tan; sWnjwk enARkúgéRBnKrPøam)aneBalGHGag

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 271

Page 282: Brother enemy

fa ³ «eRKaHKMramkMEhgFM²BIrKWeRKaHGt;Xøan nigBYkRbtikiriyacin»suT§EtCamUlehtucm,génkar

lM)akepSg²rbs;RbeTsCati. tamkar[dwgrbs;smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayevotNammñak; fa

karEdlKat;BMuniyayedomdamedayRtg;²BIkarQøanBanCayfaehtumYyrbs;cin KWBIeRBaHfa

«bBaðaenHBuMTan;ecaTeLIgeTenAsm½yenaH» b:uEnþ «edayELk eyIgRtÚvEtRbúgRby½tñCab;Canic©»10.

CMnYyrbs;cincMeBaHRbeTsevotNamRtÚv)ankat;bnßycab;BIGMLúgqñaM1976-77 ehIy

TMnak;TMngrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrk¾Føak;cuHbnþicEdr. dUecñHRkúghaNUy)ankat;bnßylkçN³sRmúHsRmÜl

bnþicmþg²cMeBaHshKmn_cinkñúgRbeTsrbs;xøÜnEdlmancMnYndl;eTAmYylannak;ehIy Edl«esckþI

esµaHRtg;»rbs;BYkenH hak;dUcCaeFVI[xøÜnmnÞilsgS½ytaMgBIeRkaykarrMedaHRbeTsrYcem:øH. pÞúyeTA

vij evotNamyl;eXIjfa caM)ac;RtÚvEtBRgwgkarRtÜtRtarbs;xøÜn[kan;EtrwgmaMeLIgEfmeTot.

CaBiess bkSkumµúynIsþevotNamBMueBjcitþTal;EtesaH EdlBYkcinenARkúgRcWgLWgh‘anelIkTg;Cati

saFarNrdæRbCamanitcinnigRKvIrUbft em:A esTug enAéf¶bnÞab;BIkarrMedaH. sRmab;BYknayTuncin enA

RkúgRcWLWg -kñúgGtItkalCaGñksßitenAeRkamkar]btßmÖKaMBarrbs;rbbRbqaMgkumµúynIsþd¾xøaMgbMputrbs;

étv:an;- enHTMngCa)atukmµmYyEdlRbRBwtþeLIgRsbtamkal³eTs³suT§saFkñúgeKalbMNgbgðaj[

BYkemdwknaMfµI¬cin¦eXIjfa eTaHCamanGVIekIteLIgk¾eday k¾BYkeKmanTwkcitþniymeqVgEdr. evorElg

EtBYkeKmincg;bgðajfa BYkeKmanRkúgeb:kaMgCaGñkKaMRTd¾manGMNacmYyb:ueNÑaH. mYyEPøtenaH

BYkeK¬cinenARkúgRcWLWg¦BuMnwksgS½yfa kayvikarrbs;eKGaceFVI[BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUyGak;Gn;citþ

eLIy BIeRBaHBYkeKmindwgfa eTaHCamankarGHGagBImitþPaBCapøÚvkark¾eday k¾ehtuénkarGnþraymYy

mansPaBkan;EteRCAeTA²rvagRbeTsTaMgBIrEdr. eK)andkhUtykTg;CatiecjTaMgGs;.

rdæaPi)alevotNamxageCIgBMumanectnaRbkan;tamBaküsnüaEdlseRmcCamYyBYkcin eday

rNsirSrMedaHCatievotNamxagt,ÚgTal;EtesaH. vaBuMEmnbBaðaEdlRtÚvGnuBaØat[BYkTaMgenaH

eRCIserIssBa¢atirbs;eKeT. CaeRcInqñaMeRkaymk enAeBlEdl´rMB£ksYrBIBaküsnüaenHcMeBaH

ÉkGKÁrdæTUtevotNammñak;enATIRkúgeb:kaMg cemøIyrbs;Kat;eqøIymkvijKWmanlkçN³c,as;las;bMput

«eyIg)anTTYlykkarBitmYy ³ CnCaticinesÞIrEtTaMgGs;enARbeTsevotNamsuT§EtmansBa¢ati

evotNam. sRmab;eyIgvahak;dUcCaKµanRbeyaCn_GVInwgeFVI[sßanPaBenHRcbUkRcbl;eT. y:agem:c

k¾eday k¾esckþIEføgkarN_epSg²KWCaerOgmYy ehIykarBitKWCaerOgmYyeTot»11.

karBitenARbeTsevotNamqñaM1975 EdlbRgÜbbRgÜmeLIgvijnigeCOCak;elIkmøaMgrbs;xøÜn

dUecñHElgmanGVITak;TgCamYybNþaqñaMdMbUg²énGtßiPaBRbeTsevotNamxageCIg EdleBlenaHman

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg272

Page 283: Brother enemy

lkçN³CitsñiT§nigkMBugBwgEp¥kRbeTsciny:agxøaMgeTotehIy. etImanplRbeyaCn_GVIeTAEdlRkúg

haNUyebIkRbfuybgá[mankarvinasd¾FMenH?. karEdlRkúgeb:kaMgTTYlsÁal;BIsiT§ikarBarGaNikCn

rbs;xøÜn )aneFVI[eKnwkeXIjdl;meFüa)ayeFVIGnþraKmn_d¾xøaMgmYyenAPaKxagt,Úg. enAedImqñaM1976

BlrdæTaMgGs;enAPaKxagt,ÚgEdlmanedImkMeNItcin RtÚv)anbgçitbgçM[cUlsBa¢atievotNam.

RbeTscinBMu)antv:aRbqaMgtampøÚvkareLIy. b:uEnþenAéf¶TI10 Exmifuna qñaM1977 kñúg»kasénkar

snÞnamYyCamYy paM v:an;dug elak]bnaykrdæm®nþIcin lI s‘annan )anecaTRbkan;evotNamfa)an

k,t;nwgBaküsnüaepSg²rbs;xøÜn12. mü:ageTot PaKxagt,ÚgElgCakmµvtßúénkarBiPakSaeTotehIy.

enAniTaXrdUvqñaM1977 RbeTsevotNam)ancab;epþImeFVI[c,as;R)akdnUvsßanPaBénGñkrs;enAtam

RBMEdnrbs;xøÜnKWCnCatiedImkMeNItcin b¤smaCikénbNþaCnCatiPaKtic. GñkRsukéntMbn;sm,ÚreTA

edayPñMenH CaTUeTAsuT§EtmanRKÜsarsßitenATaMgsgxagRBMEdn. BYkeKRtac;crBIRbeTsmYyeTARbeTs

mYy)anedayesrIehIyEfmTaMgRsbc,ab;TaMgGs;edIm,IrksuICYjdUrb¤mUlehtuRKÜsar. edayP½yxøac

\T§iBl EdlRbeTscinGaceRbImkelIBYkenH CaBiessedaysarGanuPaBxagesdækic©rbs;cinpg

RkúghaNUy)ancab;epþImedjecjBIRsuknUvCnTaMgLayNaEdleRCIsyksBa¢aticin edaymin[

elcB¤x©rx©ayeLIy13.

kñúgry³eBlyUryarmkehIy PaBmnÞilrbs;evotNamRbqaMgcinmanedImehtuCasMxan;Bak;B½n§

eTAnwgsnþisuxRbeTsenHÉg. b:uEnþ\T§iBlénmCÄdæanGñkCMnYjrbs;cin)anbEnßm[mankarRBÜy)armÖ

y:agxøaMgkñúgvis½yesdækic©EfmeTot. enArdUvekþAqñaM1977 karGnum½tkmµviFIeFVIsmUhPavUbnIykmµ

mYyeTAelIkmµsiT§idIFøIenAPaKxagt,ÚgedaybkSkumµúynIsþevotNam )aneFVI[karksaglT§isgÁmniym

enATIenaHkan;EtmansnÞúHQaneLIg. KN³kmµaFikarmYy)anRtÚvbegáIteLIg edIm,IGnuBaØat[Epñk

]sSahkmµ nigmCÄdæanGñkCMnYjÉkCnbgðajnUvsMeNIepSg²kñúgTisedAraMgxÞb;skmµPaBBYkenH[sßit

kñúgRBMEdnmYyy:agceg¥ót. enAqñaM1977 plitples,óg)anFøak;cuHy:agKMhukEdlGacpþl;nUv

eRKaHmhnþraynigbgá[mankarsþúkTukTMnijes,ógedIm,Ilk;temøIgéfø nigkarrIklUtlas;nUvTIpSarggwt

eTotpg. sRmab;rdæaPi)alKWCaeBlEdlRtÚvrYsran;BRgwgkarRtÜtRtarbs;xøÜneTAelITIpSar. enAeBl

snþisuxRbeTsRtÚvKMramkMEhgedaykarvayRbharkan;EtxøaMgeLIg²BIsMNak;ExµrRkhm nigeday

clnatsU‘rbs;rNsirSrYbrYmedIm,IkarrMedaHBUCsasn_EdlRtÚvCiHCan;(F.U.L.R.O)RBmTaMgRkúmRbqaMg

kumµúynIsþepSgeTotenaH eKBMuGacGt;»n[manPaBRcbUkRcbl;Epñkesdækic© EdlCaRbPBedIméncla

clkñúgsgÁmenAkñúgrdæFanIPaKxagt,ÚgdUecñH)aneT14.

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 273

Page 284: Brother enemy

sm½yRbCMunaExkumÖ³ qñaM1978 rbs;kariyal½yneya)ay)anebIk»kas[mankarBicarNa

d¾suICeRmAmYy sþIBIplvi)akecosminputEdlGacekItmanBIviFankarfµI²EdlRbkaspSayCasaFarN³

edayRbeTscinTak;TgeTAnwgGaNikCnrbs;xøÜnEdlrs;enAÉnaysmuRT. kñúgGMLúgeBlbdivtþn_

vb,Fm’ KN³kmµaFikarsRmab;kic©karCnCaticinenAÉnaysmuRTBMusUvman»kasbeBa©jskmµPaB

rbs;xøÜneT. tamkarBitneya)ayrbs;cinxagvis½yenHmanPaBkMBugeBjeTAedaykarRcbUkRcbl;.

b:uEnþcab;BIqñaM1977 KWcMeBlEdlevotNamcab;epþIm«sm¥at»RBMEdnrbs;xøÜnCamYycin Rkúgeb:kaMg

)ancab;epþImykcitþTukdak;CalMdab;cMeBaHsmtßPaBnigedImTunrbs;BYkcinEdlrs;enAÉbreTs. enAéf¶

TI4 Exmkra qñaM1978 GtßbTmYyrbs; lIg ecghSIú ecjpSayenAkñúg«Tinanub,vtþiRbCaCn»)anGtßa

Fib,ayy:agl¥itl¥n;sþIGMBICMhrfµIrbs;RbeTscinkñúgbBaðaenH. BIeBlenHeTA«CnCaticinEdlrs;enA

ÉnaysmuRTKWCacMENkmYyénRbCaCaticin ehIyGnaKtrbs;eKk¾RtÚv)ancgP¢ab;nwgRbeTscinpg

Edr». RbFanKN³kmµaFikarsRmab;kic©karCnCaticinenAÉnaysmuRT)anbgÁab;y:agc,as;las;[Cn

rYmCatixøÜnTaMgenaHbgábegáItCa«rNsirSbRgÜbbRgÜmGñkesñhaCatimatuPUmid¾TUlMTUlaymYy» RbqaMgnwg

«GnutþrPaBniym». mü:ageToteRkABICnCaticinenAÉnaysmuRT Kat;)anniyayeTAkan;«mitþTaMgGs;

CabreTs Edl¬smÁal;xøÜnÉg¦CaGñkmanedImkMeNItcinEdr». RbFanKN³kmµaFikarenH)anGHGagfa

RbeTscinnwgminRKan;EtFanakarKaMBarbNþaGaNikCnrbs;xøÜnenAÉnaysmuRTb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþ RbeTs

cinnwgeRtómbRmúgTTYlsVaKmn_GñkTaMgenaHCaeRsc nigcat;viFankarRKb;Ebby:agsRmab;«GñkTaMgLay

NaEdlR)afñavilRtLb;mkRbeTscinvij edIm,IrYmcMENkkñúgkarksagmatuPUmirbs;xøÜn b¤RKan;Etmk

rs;enACaBlrdæFmµtak¾)an». cMeBaHGñkTaMgLayEdleRCIserIscUlsBa¢atiRbeTsEdlTTYlxøÜn[

sñak;enAKWenAEtCa«bgb¥Únnigmitþrbs;eyIg»Canic©15.

k¾b:uEnþ esckþIRbkasEdlminsUveFVI[RsLaMgkaMgenHmann½yfa smaCikTaMgGs;énCnCaticin

Edlrs;enAray):ayBaseBjBiPBelakeTaHCamansBa¢atiGVIk¾eday suT§EtRtÚvGMBavnav[rYbrYmKña

kñúgkarRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgRkúgmUsÁÚnigGñkKaMRTrbs;eK ehIyfaBYkcinTaMgenaHRtÚv)anFananUvkarKaMRTBI

sMNak;Rkúgeb:kaMgEfmeTot. cab;BIedImqñaM1978 sßanTUtcinenARkúghaNUy )ancab;epþImbMPøWBI

neya)ayrbs;xøÜncMeBaHshKmn_cinenAevotNamEdr. lixitqøgEdnCaeRcIn)anRtÚvRbKl;eday

s¶at;kM)aMgeTA[Gñkman²cinxøH EdlmaneKalbMNgcg;vilRtLb;eTARbeTskMeNItvij edaybiThag

lk;TMnij nigePaCnIydæanrbs;xøÜnecal. karbegáInnUvsBaØaKitrkEtplRbeyaCn_TaMgenH)anRtÚv

vinicä½yy:agmuWgm:at;bMputenATIRkúghaNUyedayehtufa kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH Rkúgeb:kaMg)anRbkan;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg274

Page 285: Brother enemy

yksßanPaBxagpøÚvneya)aymYyCamYyRbeTskm<úCakan;EtCitsñiT§eLIg². eBlevlaedIm,IeFVI

karseRmccitþCasßaBrmYy)anmkdl;ehIy. eKRtÚvEtbM)at;bBaðaTaMgGs;CamYyTIRkúgRcWLWg16.

evotNamhak;dUcCaBMu)ankarBarCamuncMeBaHGVIEdlRbeTscin)anefáaleTasCasaFarN³GMBI

neya)ayGriPaBrbs;xøÜneLIy. enAcugExmIna GñkkarTUtevotNammñak;)anniyayR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦

Casm¶at;fa «RbeTscinnwgminRbfuyRbfaneFVI[xUckitüanuPaBGnþrCatirbs;xøÜnedayeFVIkarvayRbhar

mkelIeyIgeT». Kat;)anbEnßmfa «eyIgnwgeqøIyTTYlsarPaBTaMgGs;. BMumanGVIeRkABIenHeT»17.

evotNam)ankMNt;CaeKalnUvRBwtþikarN_Edlfa kñúgeBlfµI²enH BYkcin)ancab;epIþmeFVIkarvay

lukRbelamesñh_mYysMedAeTArkbNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþenAGasIuGaeKñy_. edayykcitþTuk

dak;xøaMgnwgbuBVehtuCnCaticinenAÉnaysmuRTy:agecjmux evotNammuxCabenÞasBIerOgEdlenAEt

manCanic©enAkñúgtMbn; KWkgTIR)aMrbs;cin [CaeQµaHkgGasasµ½RK EdlKUsRtÚvbnøMbgáb;xøÜnenAkñúgkgT½B

eTAvijeTAmk. RbeyaKenHcab;epþImmanenAeBlEdl]tþmesnIy_ ®hVg;kU eLamB½T§TIRkúgm:aRDIk

¬1936-1939¦ edayeRbIT½BbYnkgCameFüa)ay ehIyenAkñúgTIRkúgenaH KWGñkmansmancitþnwg

Kat;EdlrYmbgáCakmøaMgTIR)aM-kMN;trbs;GñkbkERb] ehIyEdlRtÚvbMpøaj[Gs;. mü:ageTot kar

vaylukRbqaMgnwgTIRkúgRcWLWgminKWsMedARbqaMgnwglT§imUlFnniymmunGVITaMgGs;eTb¤? evotNam

sgÇwmfa BYkcinnwgykerOgenHeTABicarNaminxan. xøwmsarpÞal;énmtiENnaMrbs;rdæaPi)alcuHéf¶TI

24 ExmIna hak;dUcCaedA[eXIjnUvectnabgáarCamunmYynUvkarriHKn;TaMgGs;BIsMNak;Rkúgeb:kaMg ³

«karseRmccitþbBa©b;skmµPaBepSg²rbs;GñkCMnYjÉkCnnwgRtÚvdak;[GnuvtþedayKµanpøas;bþÚrenA

RKb;RkúgnigextþTaMgGs;enAPaKxagt,Úg edayminKitGMBIsBa¢atinigsasnaeLIy». k¾b:uEnþedIm,I

beBa©ósRKb;ehtukarN_EdlekItmanedaymin)andwgCamun RbCaCnRtÚv)anENnaM[«RbúgRby½tñ

cMeBaHkarrYmKMnitk,t;rbs;BYkRbtikiriyaTaMgGs;-n½yEdleKmin)ac;sEmþg[cM KWRkúgebkaMg-sMedA

eFVI[xUcneya)ay nigbMEbkbM)ak;GñkeFVIkarrbs;eyIg»18.

enHCakarKn;KUrmYyEdlP½nþRcLMFMNas;. RbeTscinyl;faRBwtþikarN_epSg²enARkúgRcWLWgKW

CakarbgáehtuCacMhmYyRbqaMgnwgneya)ayrbs;xøÜncMeBaHGaNikCncinTUeTAEdlrs;enAbreTs

ehIyeTAhYsBIenaHKWkarRbqaMgnwgtYnaTICamhaGMNacRbcaMtMbn;rbs;xøÜnpg. kitüanuPaBrbs;xøÜn

cMeBaHRkEsEPñkCnCaticin15lannak;enAGasuI-GaeKñy_ KWCakmµvtßúénkarBiPakSaxagneya)ay

mYy. ebITukCakarRbkan;CMhrkalBIeBlfµI²rbs;xøÜnmanPaBmWugm:at;k¾eday k¾vabgðaj[eXIjfa xøÜn

minGacFanakarBarshKmn_cinenARbeTsevotNam edayCak;lak;)aneLIy. mü:ageTot \riyabf

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 275

Page 286: Brother enemy

es¶óms¶at;rbs;cincMeBaHbBaðaenH )anCYyCMruj[KURbqaMgTaMgGs;rbs;xøÜnkñúgtMbn;xMRbwgeFVIRtab;tam

\riyabfrbs;eKeday\tel¥óg sþIBIlT§iesñhaCatiRCúlhYsehturbs;evotNamEdr.

Rkúgeb:kaMg)anerobcMeFVIRbtikmµtbteBjmYyEx. b:uEnþPaBes¶óms¶at;enH RbEhlCaminbMPan;

eT ³ PaBtantwg)anekIneLIg. GaNikCncinrab;Ban;nak;EdlkMBugrt;eKcecjBIevotNamxageCIg)an

cab;epþImEsVgrkTIsñak;GaRs½yenAmçageToténRBMEdn. enAPaKxagt,Úg BYkBaNiC¢krcineRcInCagenH

eTotEdleKdkhUtRTBüsm,tþiGs;rlIgBIxøÜn RtÚv)anbBa¢ÚneTA«tMbn;esdækic©fµI». RbeTscin)aneRCIs

erIséf¶R)arB§BiFIbuNüxYbelIkTIbIénkarbBa©b;s®gÁamenAevotNamCanimitþrUb edIm,IbeBa©jkareCr

RbmafCaelIkdMbUgrbs;xøÜn nigcab;epþImbgðajPaBCasRtÚvnwgKña. enAéf¶TI30 Exemsa qñaM1978

kñúg»kasTTYlePJóvcinmYycMnYntUcEdlrs;enAÉnaysmuRT lIv ecghSúI )anRbkas[dwgfa CnCati

cinEdlrs;enAevotNammYycMnYnFM)an «vilRtLb;mkRbeTscinvijTaMgrhn;». edayminbMepøIsTMhM

RBwtþikarN_ Kat;)anelIkeLIgGMBIkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;GaCJaFrcin Edl)antamdan«karvivtþn_énsßan

karN_enaHedayykcitþTukdak;y:agditdl;bMput» ³ ebIsinRbeTscinCMruj[BYkcinenAÉnaysmuRT

Rbkan;yksBa¢atirbs;RbeTsEdlBYkeKsñak;enA xøÜnBMuGacGt;»ncMeBaH«karb:unb:gNamYysMedAbgçit

bgçMBYkcin Edlrs;enAtamRbeTsTaMgenaHeLIy»19.

db;BIréf¶eRkaymk Rkúgeb:kaMg)anbegáInkarekobsgát;mYykRmitEfmeTot edayRBmanRkúg

haNUys¶at;²BIkarbBaÄb;kargarenAkardæancMnYnémÖmYykEnøg Edlpþl;hirBaØvtßúedayBYkcin enAeBl

xagmuxqab;². cMENksmÖarbrikçarRBmTaMgmUlniFinwg «RtÚvepÞrmkmatuRbeTsvij sRmab;eRbIR)as;

kñúgkarpþl;kargar nigkarTTYl[sñak;enArbs;bgb¥ÚncinEdlRtÚvbeNþjecjBIevotNamvij». Rbvtþi

sa®sþ)anekItmanRcMEdl² b:uEnþedaylMnaMEbøkBIFmµta. enAqñaM1960 edIm,IbgðajnUvkarGak;Gn;

citþcMeBaHRkúgeb:kaMg BYksUevotk¾Føab;bBaÄb;CMnYyesdækic©rbs;xøÜneTA[ciny:agKMhukEdr. karseRmc

citþenHEdlbrihay:agxøaMgedayRbeTscin)aneFVI[karkarpþac;mitþPaBkan;EtelOndl;TIbBa©b;. b:uEnþ

Rkúgeb:kaMgrg;caM[dMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;elak b‘IkjÚ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI EdlCaGñkRbqaMgsUevotxøaMgkøabMputnig

CaTIRbwkSasnþisuxCatiGaemrikbBa©b;eTAsin eTIbcab;dMeNIrkarvayRbharedayBaküsmþICaelIkdMbUg

mYyeTAtameKalkarN_. kñúgesckþIEføgkarN_mYyEdlpSBVpSayCasaFarN³enAéf¶TI24 Ex]sPa

kariyal½yTTYlbnÞúkkic©karCnCaticinenAÉnaysmuRT )anbriharBI«kareFVITukçbukemñjmkelIBYk

GaNikCncinenAevotNam EdlCaGñkrgeRKaHBIkarbeNþjecjminsmehtuplmYy» edayefáal

eTascMeBaH «karbeNþjecjnigkarvilRtLb;TaMgbgçMmkRbeTscinvijnUvCnCaticinmYycMnYny:agFM

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg276

Page 287: Brother enemy

kñúgcMeNamGñkEdlrs;enATIenaH»pg. esckþIEføgkarN_)anKUsbBa¢ak;fa PaKeRcInénGñkEdlRtÚv

beNþjecj)anRtÚveKRbmaf eFVI)ab qk; bøn; nigvaydM «enAeBlmkdl;TwkdIcinBYkeKenAsl;Et

GIv:an;Edls<ayenAelIxñgb:ueNÑaH». evotNamk¾RtÚvecaTRbkan;fa «)ancat;EcgeFVIkarcab;xøÜnmnusS

y:ageRcIn eRbIGMeBIeXareXAnigkarkab;smøab;eTAelIrUbkayGaNikCncin» enARkúghUCImijEfm

eTot. Rkúgeb:kaMg)anRBmanRkúghaNUyfa evotNamRtÚvEtTTYlxusRtÚvcMeBaHplvi)akepSg²

énGMeBI«pþac;kar sahavéRBépS nigrMelaPelIc,ab;GnþrCatiTaMgenH»20.

kñúgcenøaHeBlenaH CnCaticin70>000nak; )ancakecjBIRbeTsevotNamrYcCaeRsceTA

ehIy. eKnwgRbEhlBMudwgfa karcakecalRsukeTsTaMghVÚg²enH cab;epþImedayrebobEbbNa

eLIy. ehtuGVI)anCaRbeTscinyl;RBmebIkRBMEdnrbs;xøÜn?. ehtuGVI)anCacinEGGg;yUremø:H mun

nwgRbkasR)ab;[saFarNmtiGnþrCatidwg?. erOgr:avTaMgGs;enHmanpÞúkeTAedayesckþIeRkveRkaF

hYsehtu ehIyBi)aksesaHkMu[RcLMbl;KñanUvsMNMuénkarecaTRbkan; nigRbqaMgkarecaTRbkan;eTAvij

eTAmkrbs;GñknaMGaT×Nas;KW BYkGtItbgb¥ÚnrYmGavuFEdlkøayeTACasRtÚvminGacsRmúHsRmÜlKña

)an. BYkcin)anecaTRbkan;evotNamfa )aneFVITukçbukemñjCnrYmCatixøÜnehIy)aneRbIR)as;kmøaMg

T½BCUndMeNIreTAdl;RBMEdnEfmeTot. evotNam)anecaTRbkan;BYkcinfa CaGñkGuCGal[mankar

elIkKñacakecalRsukTaMghVÚg²nigbMepøagBaküccamGar:ambeg¥IlbMP½yepSg²edIm,IeFVI[esdækic©rbs;

xøÜn)at;sßirPaB nigb:unb:geFVI[neya)ayevotNamep¥ógeTArkcinEfmeTot. karbMPøWTaMgenHKµan

ehtuplNamYyEdljúaMg[eCOCak;eBjeljeT ehIyk¾KµanGVImYybMPøW[dwgBITMhMénehtukarN_

EdlekIteLIgenHEdr. enABak;kNþalExmifuna qñaM1978 cMnYnénGñkePosxøÜn)anekIndl;db;bImuWn

bIBan;nak;. mü:ageTot karcakecalRsukTaMghVÚg² BMuEmnmanPaBdUcKñaenARKb;TIkEnøgeT eTaHbICa

skmµPaBrbs;vaTaMgenAPaKxageCIg nigenAPaKxagt,Úg )anRbRBwtþeTAkñúgeBlCamYyKñak¾eday.

enAPaKxageCIg erOgenHBMumanBak;Bn§½edaypÞal;eTAnwgkarRbúgeRbóbEdlRbkan;ykRbqaMgnwgBYk

nayTuncinenATIRkúgRcWLWgeT. BitehIy vamanTak;TgeTAnwgGñkCMnYjFM²Emn b:uEnþyUreTAeTotmuxCa

Tak;TgnwgBYkkmµkr GñkeFVIkarkñúgGNþÚgEr: nigGñkensaTRtIminxan. eKGacKitfa RkúghaNUycUlcitþ

eFVIdUcCaKµanerOgGVIekIteLIgesaHG‘Ícwg. karEdlfakMBg;EpéhhVúg Camat;RcksMxan;bMputrbs;evot

NamxageCIgeq<aHeTArkBiPBeRkA rYmTaMgbNþaGNþÚgEr:FüÚgfµ nigkEnøgensaTCaeRcInnwgeBIbRbTHkar

KaMgdMeNIrTaMgRsugedaysarEtkarcakecjy:agRbjab;Rbjal;rbs;GñkeFVIkarcinenHÉgEdlnwgRtÚv

CECkkarBar CaCagyl;RBmnwgerOgenH. b:uEnþ pÞúyeTAvij GñkensaTRtIRkIRk nigkmµkrxVHsmtßPaB

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 277

Page 288: Brother enemy

TaMgenHEdlmancMnYnrab;Ban;nak;BMuEmnCamnusSEdlRkúgeb:kaMgelIkTwkcitþ[RtLb;mkRbeTskMeNItvij

edIm,ICYyeFVI«TMenIbPavUbnIykmµTaMgbYn»enaHeT. tamkarBit eKalsMxan;EdleyIgerobbRmúg vaelc

ecjfa edayKµanTak;TgnwgkarjúHjg;rbs;RkúghaNUy nigRkúgeb:kaMg karcakecalRsukTaMghVÚgTaMg

hVayenH)anRbRBwtþeTAtamsgVak;edayELkmYy ehIyBMubeRmIplRbeyaCn_TaMgRbeTsevotNam

TaMgRbeTscin. eKenAcaMfa GVI²TaMgGs;cab;epþImeLIgeday karseRmccitþrbs;evotNam kñúgkar

beNþjBYkGaNikCncinTaMgGs;enAtamtMbn;RBMEdnPaKxageCIg edIm,IFanasnþisuxRbeTsrbs;xøÜn.

tmkeTot mankarrwtbnþwgnayTunenARkúgRcWLWg bnÞab;mkkareFVITukçbukemñjBYkQµÜjtUctac nigm©as;

ePaCnIydæanenARkúghaNUyEdlRtÚveFVI)abedaysar«ePaKRTBüEdl)anmkminRtwmRtÚv» nigPaB

yWty:avkñúgkarbg;Bn§rbs;BYkeK. cab;taMgBIExkumÖ³ edIm,IbEnßm[RKb; buNüxYbfµIBIr)anRtÚvR)arB§

eLIgedIm,IrMB£kC½yCmñHEdlTTYl)anedayvIrbursCati eL Ly nig Rtan; h‘ugdav eTAelIGñkQøan

Bancin. BiFIbuNüTaMgBIrenHminsUveFVI[BYkcinenARbeTsevotNamkk;ekþAkñúgcitþb:unµaneT.

Rkúmh‘undwkCBa¢ÚnmðÚbkMb:ugcas;²tamsmuRT

enAedImqñaM1978 ÉkGKÁrdæTUtRbeTscinRbcaMRkúghaNUy)ancab;epþImecjlixitqøgEdn

y:ageRcIn[GaNikCncinmYycMnYn. b:uEnþ mUlehtucm,génkarcakecjTaMghVÚgenHKWBaküccamGar:am

EdlelcB¤sussaykñúgshKmn_CnCaticinGMBIs®gÁammYyrvagRbeTscinnigevotNam Edlc,as;

Camkdl;kñúgeBlqab;². enAeBlyb; xitþb½NÐCaeRcInEdlBMuGacdwgecjBIRbPBNa )anRtÚveKyk

eTAs‘ktamTVarpÞHnana edayCMruj[CnCaticincakecjnigcUlrYmkñúgkarsßabnaRbeTsCatirbs;xøÜn.

karcecsrwgrUsEdlGacekItmansuT§EtRtÚvKMramkMEhgedaykarsgswk. BIeRkayyuT§nakareFVI[

manBaküccamGar:amenH RkúghaNUyeCOfaKW«smasPaBCnGaRkk;kñúgépÞshKmn_CnCativ:a».

TnÞwmnwgenaH Rkúgeb:kaMgk¾ecaTRbkan;kariyal½ysnþisuxsaFarN³rbs;evotNamEdr. eKaledAén

yuT§nakarenHBMumanlkçN³c,as;las;eLIy. sðalbWN½rt_GaceFVIsmÖasCamYyCnePosxøÜnCaeRcIn

nak;enAPaKxageCIg edaysarkarecHPasacinnigPasaevotNamrbs;Kat;. Kat;snñidæanfa «mUlehtu

rbs;GñkEdlseRmccitþrt;ePosxøÜnBIPaKxageCIgmaneRcInNas;. mundMbUgKWmankarP½yxøacnUvGVIEdl

BYkeKGacRtÚvrgeRKaHenAkñúgkarvaysµan¬eTAelIGVImYyEdleKTukfanwgman¦GMBIs®gÁammYyrvagRbeTs

cinnigRbeTsevotNam EdlTMngCaBitxøaMgeLIg². bnÞab;mkKWkarCMBak;citþcMeBaHsBa¢atirbs;eK

EdlerOgenaHBYkeKBMumanbMNge)aHbg;ecalTal;EtesaH. enATIbMputKWkarRBÜy)armÖxøH²Tak;Tgnwg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg278

Page 289: Brother enemy

karFøak;cuHEpñkCIvPaBrs;enArbs;eK ehIyCaTUeTAKWmenaseBa©tnaEdlkan;EtrIkFMeLIg²edaysarkar

ercrwlnUvbuBVsiTi§epSg² EdlBYkeKmankñúgzan³CaCnbreTstaMgenAeRkARsukCaGcié®nþy_»21.

eTaHbICamankarsnñidæanGMBIedImehtuénBaküccamGar:amTaMgenaHk¾eday k¾vaR)akdfaevotNam

BMu)anykcitþTukdak;[muWgm:at;edIm,IraraMgkarcakecalRsukkMeNItTaMghVÚgenHeLIy. edayKitGMBI

cm¶aypøÚv BIPaBxSt;exSayxagmeFüa)aydwkCBa¢Ún ehIyCaBiesslkçxNÐ EdltRmÚv[eFVItameday

sarviFankarEpñksnþisuxkñúgkarpøas;bþÚrTIkEnøgrs;enArbs;mnusS eKBi)akvinicä½yedaymeFüa)ay

rebobNa EdlhVÚgGñkePosxøÜnmYyeRcInEbbenaHGaceFVIdMeNIreTAdl;RBMEdn edayKµankars‘umRKluMBI

rdæGMNacenaH?. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday karvaysµaneday\tmanGVIsMGagEdlrkSaTukkñúgKMnitBYk

emdwknaMRkúghaNUymanminelIsBIbIExeLIy. karvaysµanenH)anRtÚvkm©at;ecjtaMgBIeBlEdl

RbeTscincab;epþImefáaleTasRbeTsevotNamCasaFarN³. enAéf¶TI30 Ex]sPa Rkúgeb:kaMg )an

lubecalKeRmagCMnYyfµIcMnYnhasibmYyKeRmagEdlRtÚvpþl;[RbeTsevotNam srubeTA karlub

ecalKeRmagTaMgenH)aneLIgdl;cMnYncitsibBIrehIy. karseRmccitþenH eFVIeLIgpÞúynwgeKalkarN_

rbs;xøÜnEdlpSBVpSay[eKdwgB¤RKb;EteBledayRbeTscinxøÜnÉgfa minRtÚveRbIR)as;CMnYyesdækic©

eFVICameFüa)ayekobsgát;xagEpñkneya)ayeLIy. kan;EtF¶n;F¶rCagenHeTAeTot RbkarenHman

n½yfa EtmYyExeRkayb:ueNÑaHmeFüa)ayepSg²Edllem¥ógeTArkkarRsuHRsYlKña)anrlay)at;

Gs;EtmYyExeRkaymkb:ueNÑaHBICemøaHRtÚv)aneFVI[eKdwgB¤CasaFarN³22.

karlubecalCMnYyrbs;cinnwgeFVI[b:HBal;y:agxøaMgdl;esdækic©rbs;evotNam EdlrkklEt

rlMdYleTAehIyenaH. b:uEnþ vanwgCYybM)at;karsÞak;esÞIrcitþcugeRkayrbs;evotNam edIm,IEbreTA

cUlrYmCamYyGgÁkarkUemkugvij [COMECON GkSreBjKW Council for Mutual Economic Assistance.

)araMgehAfa C.A.E.M ExµrehARkúmRbwkSasgÁhesdækic©begáIteLIgkñúgqñaM1949 enARkúgmUsÁÚshPaB

sUevot. CMnan;enaHmansmaCikdb;RbeTs suT§Etkan;lT§isgÁmniymKW b‘ulhÁarI/ hugRKÍ/ b:ULÚj/

r:Um:anI/ eqkUsøÚv:aKI/ shPaBsUevot¬smaCiksßabnik¦/ saFarNrdæRbCaFibetyü GaløWm:g; ¬kalenaH

minTan;rYbrYmKña¦/ m:ugehÁalI/ KU)a nigevotNam. cMENkÉRbeTsGal;)anI EdlCasmaCiksßabnik

mYyEdrenaH)andkxøÜnecjenAqñaM1961. GgÁkarenHmanTIsñak;karenARkúgmUsÁÚ b:uEnþ bnÞab;BIs®gÁam

RtCak;bBa©b;eTAGgÁkarenHk¾rlt;rlayeTAtamenaHEdr -kMNt;rbs;GñkbkERb]. taMgBIkarCYbRbCMu

kMBUlEdlRbRBwtþeTACasm¶at;enARkúgmUsÁÚ kñúgGMLúgrdUvekþAqñaM1977 esckþIseRmcmYyRtÚv)an

erobcMsRmab;TisedAenHrYcCaeRsc. RkúghaNUy)anpþl;nUvkaryl;RBmrbs;xøÜncMeBaHeKalkarN_

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 279

Page 290: Brother enemy

sMucUlCasmaCikrbs;GgÁkarenHEdlRtÚvEtekItman«eTAtamkalevla». kareRtómbRmúgenH KWman

Cab;Bak;B½n§nwgkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;evotNamEdlminTMnas;nwgRbeTscinedaykarsMucUlCasmaCikGgÁkar

mYyEdlRKb;RKgedayBYksUevoteLIy y:agehac drabNakareFVI[manRbRktIPaBEtsMbkeRkAmYy

nwgGacrkSa)ankñúgTMnak;TMngrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr23. BIeBlenHeTARkúghaNUyGaceFVIGVI²)aneday

KµaneTIsTal;eLIy. RbeTsevotNam)ancUlCasmaCikGgÁkarkUemkugCapøÚvkarenAéf¶TI28 Exmifuna

¬1978¦. eBlenaHKWRkúgmUsÁÚCaGñkQñHenATwkTImYykñúgkarRbkYtrvagcin-evotNam>>>.

CemøaHEdleRbIviFIkan;EtxøaMgecHEtmanCabnþmkeTot. enAéf¶TI26 Ex]sPa qñaM1978 Rkúg

eb:kaMg)anRbkas[dwgBIeKalbMNgrbs;xøÜn kñúgkarbBa¢ÚnnavaBIreRKÓgeTAevotNam edIm,I«dwkCBa¢Ún

CnCaticinEdlrgeRKaHBIkareFVITukçbukemñjRtLb;mkRbeTsvij». sRmab;RkúghaNUyyl;fa kar

seRmccitþCaÉketaPaKIenH )anbgðaj[eXIjBI«neya)aykarTUteRbInava»mþg. GñkeFVIGtßaFib,ay

pøÚvkarmñak;rbs;evotNam)ansEmþgkareRkaFxwgfa «enHCab£kBaRkGWtRkGagemIlgayeKÉgkRmit

x<s;bMput. smuRTcinxagt,ÚgBMuEmnCaEdnsmuRTmYyrbs;cineT. éhhVúgnigRkúghUCImij k¾BuMEmnCa

kMBg;EpEdlbNþanavarbs;cinGacecjcUleRscEtcitþEdr»24.

sRmab;RbCaCnevotNamyl;fa enHCa»kasl¥Nas;edIm,ITajykGtßRbeyaCn_mYyeday

briharCasaFarN³BIPaBpÞúyKñaénneya)ayrbs;cin. etIBYkGaNikCncinEdlrs;enARbeTskm<úCa

RtÚveKeFVI)abdUcKñaEdrb¤eT? etIerOgenbNþal[manbBaðadl;karKaMRTrbs;cincMeBaHExµrRkhmEdr

eT? GñkeFVIGtßaFib,ayviTüúRkúghaNUy)anniyaycMGkLkLWyeTotfa «ebIRbeTscincg;CYy

se®gÁaHGaNikCnxøÜnEdlrgeRKaHBIkarrMelaPeFVI)abEmn KWenAkm<úCaÉeNaHeTEdlcinRtÚvbBa¢Ún

navarbs;xøÜneTAy:agelOnbMput»enaH25.

RbtibtþikarCYyse®gÁaHBYkcinenAevotNam)anCMrujeTArkbraC½ymunCaeRsc. karTTUcrbs;

cinEdlRKan;Etcg;dwkCBa¢Ún«BYkcinEdlCaGñkrgeRKaHedaykarrMelaPeFVI)ab»RtLb;eTAmatuRbeTs

vij EdlmaneKalbMNgedayeRbIkll,ic[eKTTYlsÁal;CapøÚvkarnUvKMnitEdlfa man«kareFVI)ab»

BitR)akdenaHKWCaerOgEdlRkúghaNUyBMuTTYlsÁal;eLIy. mü:ageTot BYkevotNamk¾minTTYlsÁal;BI

karsßitman«CnCaticinenAevotNam»Edr b:uEnþfamanEtCnCativ:a ¬CnCatievotNamedImkMeNIt

cin¦b:ueNÑaH. minRKan;EtefáaleTaskarpþÜcepþImKMnitrbs;cinb:ueNÑaHeT RkúghaNUy)anRbwgERbg

eRbIR)as;erOgenHCaKuNRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜnEfmeTot edaybegáIt[mansßankarN_mYyEdlsaMjúaM

Bi)akedaHRsaybMput KWesñI[RbeTscinTTYlykCnCativ:aTaMgGs;Edlcg;cakecjBIRbeTs

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg280

Page 291: Brother enemy

evotNam eRkayBIkarBinitüsMNMuÉksarrbs;BYkeKrYcral; ehIyRbKl;[mnusSTaMgGs;nUvTidæakar

mYymñak;². vaBitCaBi)akNas;sRmab;RbeTscin EdlRtÚvTTYlbnÞúkykGñkePosxøÜncMnYn mYylan

BIrEsnnak;eday\tRBagTukCamunEbbenH. mü:ageTot ebIxøÜnsuxcitþRBmTTYlykCnCatievotNam

edImkMeNItcin TaMgenaH hak;dUcCadak;xøÜnrgTTYlkarecaTRbkan;epSg²BIbTeRCótERCkkic©karépÞkñúg

rbs;evotNamminxan.

RbeTscinRbEhlCaminEdleCOesaHfa RkúghaNUynwgbNþal[eKeFVIdUecñH ehIykñúgeBl

dEdlenaH k¾TTYlsÁal;BIkareFVITukçbukemñjRbCaCncinEdltaMgTIlMenAeRkARsukrbs;xøÜnEdr. k):al;

BIreRKÓgEdlcin esñIbBa¢ÚneTAenaH GacdwkykGñkePosxøÜn)anEt2>200nak;b:ueNÑaH. RbeTscin

TMngCaKµaneKaledANaepSgeRkAEtBIeFVI[RbeTsevotNamsßitkñúgsßanPaBlM)akCasaFarN³ nig

bgðaj[BYkcinEdlrs;enAÉnaysmuRTeXIjfa xøÜnEtgRBÜy)armÖBIeCaKvasnarbs;BYkCanic©enaH

eLIy.

karRbCMucrcaKñasþIBIerOgenH)ansuIeBlGs;R)aMmYys)aþh_ edayepþatCasMxan;eTAelITRmg;

EbbbTénkarvilRtLb;rbs;GñkePosxøÜn nigPaBlm¥iténkarcUlctrbs;navaTaMgBIreRKÓg. karRbCMu

crcarenH)anebIk»kas[manyuT§nakareXasnad¾GWgkgmYyeTAvijeTAmk. enATIbMput KeRmagkar

enH )anRtÚveKe)aHbg;ecalenAExkkáda qñaM1978. GñkkarTUtcinmYyRkúmEdlbBa¢ÚnmkedIm,IerobcM

karebIksßankugs‘ulrbs;RbeTscinenARkúghUCImij RtÚvrg;caMedayGt;Fµt;cMnYnbIExenARkúghaNUy

munnwgRtLb;eTARkúgeb:kaMgvijedayKµan)anTTYllT§plGVInaMeTACamYypgeT. tampøÚvkareKBMuGac

GnuBaØat[RkúmenHeFVIdMeNIreTAkan;PaKxagt,Úg)aneLIy edaysarehtuplsnþisux. tamkar[dwg

rbs;RkúghaNUyfa karebIksßankugs‘ulnwgGacRbRBwtþeTA)anenARtImasTIbIénqñaM1978 dUecñHKW

BitCaeRkaykalbriecäTEdlkMNt;sRmab;karCemøósGñkEdldak;BaküsMueRtómecjdMeNIrCaR)akd

. edayGnuelamtamkarkMNt;R)aMmYys)aþh_ kñúgkarrg;caMkNþalsmuRTEk,reqñrRbeTsevotNam

navacinTaMgBIreRKÓg)ancakecjeTAvijedays¶at;kM)aMgeq<aHeTAkMBg;Eprbs;xøÜneQµaHhaMgBuy enA

PaKxagt,ÚgRbeTscin. enAelInavarbs;eKmankmµkrQWmYycMnYn/ eRKÓgcanqñaMg)ak;Ebk ehIy

GsµimanH)anRtÚveFVI[fñaMgfñak;. karCn;eCarKµandac;énCnePosxøÜnTaMghVÚg EdlelIkTwkcitþCacMh

edayRkúghaNUytaMgBIEx]sPa ecHEtmanbnþKµanFUrRsak tampøÚveKakEfmeTot ehIy)aneLIgdl;

kRmitmYyrhUtTal;EtBYkrdæGMNaccinRtÚvEtdkbda«sVaKmn_karRtLb;mkRbeTsvij» Edldak;enA

tamb:usþ×TaMgLayCab;RBMEdnKµansl;. RKb;cMNucTVarcUlTaMgGs;suT§EtRtÚvbiTTVarcak;esay:agRby½tñ

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 281

Page 292: Brother enemy

RbEyg.

Kit[sBV²eTA vKÁénerOgnavaeTAykCnePosxøÜn)anelceLIgCa erOgEdleFVI[xVl;y:agxøaMg

sRmab;Rkúgeb:kaMg ehIypÞúyeTAvij )anrYmbgáCaGtßRbeyaCn_minsgÇwmTukmYysRmab;kareXasna

rbs;RkúghaNUyEfmeTot. kñúgkarpSaymYyEdlpSayedayviTüúRkúghaNUytRmg;eTArktMbn;GasIu

GaeKñy_ GñkeFVIGtßaFib,aymñak;)anRBmanCa]TahrN_fa «karbþÚrKMnitPøam²rbs;cincMeBaHRbeTs

evotNamKWCaerOgRKb;RKan;nwgeFVI[rdæaPi)alnanaenAkñúgtMbn;RBÜy)armÖehIy. ebIsinCardæaPi)al

TaMgenaHminbegáInkarRbúgRby½tñ[rwtEtxøaMgEfmeToteT KWc,as;CaRtÚv)at;bg;GVI²TaMgGs;minxan»26.

tamkarBit RbeTscinRtÚveFVI[xVl;xVayxøaMgEmnETnrhUtTal;EtxøÜnvaytémøfaRtÚvEtbgðajnUvPaB

FUrRsalxøH² cMeBaHbNþaÉkGKÁrdæTUténRbeTsCasmaCikGas‘anenATIRkúgeb:kaMg. karbeBa©j

RbtikmµcMeBaHkarrMelaPbMBanrbs;evotNamRbqaMgnwgGaNikCnrbs;xøÜnKWCa«krNIedayELk»mYy

BIeRBaHkareFVIRbtibtþikarEdlbgáedayRkúghaNUymancMENkénkarrYmKMnitd¾FMmYyEdlerobcMRbTak;

RkLaedayBYksUevotEdr.

RbtikmµEbbRCÜlRcbl;kñúgcitþnigEdl\tBicarNarbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg)anRtwmEteFVI[CnCaticin

enARbeTsevotNamrgeRKaHEfmeTotb:ueNÑaH. esckþIEføgkarN_EdltemøIgTwkcitþtamrebob

«bgb¥ÚneyIgenARbeTsevotNamrg;caMtaMgBIyUryarmkehIynUvéf¶EdleyIgnwgnaMBYkeKRtLb;mk

matuRbeTsvij»27)anCMruj[manesckþIsgÇwmminR)akd. esckþIEføgkarN_enH)anRbTajCnCati

cinrab;Ban;nak;enAPaKxageCIg[ecjdMeNIreTAkan;RBMEdn nigCnCaticinrab;ryBan;nak;eTot enATIRkúg

RcWLWgesñIsMu[bBaöÚnBYkeKeTAmatuRbeTsvijCapøÚvkar. naExmifuna enATIRkúghUCImij RkúmGñkeFVIkar

TTYlbnÞúkcuHbBa¢IGñkR)afñaecjdMeNIr mankargareFVIy:ageRcInedaykñúgmYys)aþh_manmnusSdak;

BaküsMucMnYnsamsibBan;nak; 28.

tamkarBit PaKeRcInénBYkcinEdleRCIsykkarbBa¢ÚneTAmatuRbeTsvij)anyl;eXIjkñúg

erOgenHnUvmeFüa)aymYy edIm,IeFVInirRbevsn_eTAenARbeTsmYyepSgeTotkñúg»kasNamYyCaelIk

TIBIr. b:uEnþsRmab;evotNamyl;fa BYkenaH)anrYmplRbeyaCn_EtmYyCamYysRtÚvrbs;xøÜn.

bMNgEdlsEmþg[eXIjedayshKmn_cinedIm,IvilRtLb;eTARbeTscinkumúµynIsþvij )anBRgwg[

karKitmémBitR)akdrbs;evotNam EdlminTukcitþeKÉgGMBIkmøaMgTIR)aMrbs;cin rwtEtmaMeLIgEfm

eTot. CaCagbgçitbgçMGñkCMnYjenARkúgRcWLWg [bþÚrKMniteTAeFVIERscmáaredaybBa¢ÚnBYkeKeTAdak;

enAkñúgtMbn;esdækic©fµItamrebobGñkGt;kargareFVIedImkMeNItevotNam KWrdæaPi)alRKan;Etcg;yk

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg282

Page 293: Brother enemy

BYkenHecj[)at;BImuxBImat;b:ueNÑaH. mü:ageTot rdæaPi)alk¾)anTTYlplkéRmmYy«dak;ehae):A»

enAeBlqøgkat;Edr. neya)aynirRbevsn_EdlerobcMeLIgedayRkúghaNUy KWCaPaBGt;eGonxµas

y:ageBjeljmYy. GñkCMnYjmñak;enATIRkúgRcWLWg)anbMPøWfa «edayehtufa eyIgminmannisS½yxag

kargarERscmáar eyIg)anbdiesFmineTACnbTeT ehIyeTaHCay:agNak¾eday yUrb¤qab;eyIg

TaMgGs;KñanwgRtÚvePosxøÜnecj. cMENkÉrdæaPi)alyl;faRtwmRtÚvNas;EdldkhUtmasrbs;eyIg

nigbeNþay[eyIgecjdMeNIreTATINak¾)an»29.

eBjfirevlaénrdUvekþAqñaM1978 kariyal½yEpñksnþisuxsaFarN³rbs;evotNam)anebIk

RkúmkargarCaeRcInenAkñúgbNþaTIRkúgsßitenAtameqñrsmuRTPaKxagt,Úg nig[eKeFVITUkk):al;y:ageRcIn

sRmab;dwkCBa¢ÚnCnCaticin ¬b¤evotNamEdleFVIxøÜnCacin¦edayTarCamunnUvéføQñÜlRCúlhYsehtuCa

masnigCaduløarEtmþg30. RbtibtþikarEdlGñkkarTUtbs©imRbeTsdak;smµtinam[fa «Rkúmh‘undwk

CBa¢ÚnmðÚbkMb:ugcas;²tamsmuRT»enaH enATIbMput)anTTYllT§plKWkñúgry³eBlBIrqñaMmanmnusSRbEhl

25muWnnak;rt;ecjtamTUk EdlkñúgenaHmnusSBIsamsibeTAEssibBan;nak; )an)at;bg;CIvitenAkñúg

smuRT31.

enAPUmiPaKbUBa’ ³ kare)assm¥atmYycab;epþIm

karRbyuT§d¾sahavrbs;«emnaK»RbqaMgnwg«kUnnaK»)anTak;TajnUvkarykcitþTukdak;BIBiPBelak

TaMgmUlmYyry³xøIEdr. b:uEnþkñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH RbeTskm<úCak¾TTYlrgnUvkarkab;smøab;x<s;dl;

kRmitmYyEdlmanlkçN³FMeFgNas; eRbóbbIdUcCabgçM[kareFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;evotNamrwtEtqab;

mkdl;. mü:ageTot GñkÉkeTscMNan²EdlcaMXøaMemIlP½sþútagTaMgLaysþIBIRbeTsEdlkat;pþac;BI

BiPBelakenH edaykarykcitþTukdak;sþab;karpSayrbs;viTüúPñMeBj nigesckþIGHGagrbs;GñkePos

xøÜnkm<úCaEdleTIbmkdl;fµI² GacsgS½yBITMhMénesaknadkmµEdlbgáclacltamRsukERsnigcmáar

ekAs‘Urbs;km<úCaenAPaKxagekIt. enAéf¶TI24 Ex]sPa qñaM1978 RbeTscin)ancab;epþImtµHtiHedol

RbqaMgRbeTsevotNamy:agcas;éd RBmeBlmanTsSnkic©RbkbedayEpøpáarbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI enA

TIRkúgeb:kaMg. enAéf¶BuF TI24 Ex]sPadEdl kñúgcm¶ayBITIenaHRbmaN3>000KILÚEm:Rt karvay

RbharEdlmanTRmg;xusEbøkBImunTaMgRsugmYy)anepþImeLIg enAkñúgRbCMuCntUcmYyrbs;km<úCaeQµaHfa

sYg. b:ul Bt )anbBa¢ÚnkgBlFMCaeRcInrbs;PUmiPaKkNþal eTAeLamB½T§mnÞIresnaFikarrbs;bkS

PUmiPaKbUB’a munnwgcat;EcgeFVIkarcab;xøÜn«BYkk,t;» eBalKWBYkemdwknaMKN³kmµaFikarbkSEdlRtÚv

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 283

Page 294: Brother enemy

sgS½yBIbTXubXitCamYyRbeTsevotNam. emdwknaMmYycMnYntUc)anRtÚvcab;xøÜneFVITaruNkmµekob

ykcemøIysarPaB bnÞab;mkykeTAsmøab;ecal. esa Pwm elxabkSPUmiPaKbUB’a nigCaGtItédsþaM

rbs; b:ul Bt )aneFVIGtþXat. GñkTaMgLayEdlRbwgERbgTb;Tl;nwgkgT½Brbs; b:ul Bt )anrt;

ePosxøÜneTARbeTsevotNam dUcCaeFVI[kmøaMgénclnatsU‘ExµrenATIenaHkan;EtrIkFMeLIgEfmeTot.

karsmøab;BYkkmµaPi)al nigkgT½Brbs;PUmiPaKbUB’ay:agrgÁalrgÁM )aneFVI[esckþIsgÇwmcugeRkaybMput

GMBIkareFVIrdæRbharRbqaMgnwgRkúmemdwknaMExµrRkhmRtÚvrlaysabsUnü. BMumankaredaHRsayNa

epSgeTot eRkABIBwgEp¥kelIkmøaMgRbyuT§rbs;evotNameLIy.

enAéf¶TI25 Exmifuna edayeFVI[mankarPJak;ep¥IlRsLaMgkaMgCaTUeTAmYy viTüúPñMeBj)anRbkas

CasaFarN³fa karb:unb:geFVIrdæRbharmYyEdlerobcMCasm¶at;edayRbeTsevotNam nigRkúm

es>GuI>Ga> eTIbnwgRtÚveyIgkemÞcecal. kareRbIkmøaMgpÁÜbKñaEdlerobcMedayGñkEdltaMgxøÜn CaemKMnit

enaHKWminTMngCaBitTaMgRsúgeT. b:uEnþ kareXasnarbs;evotNam)anniyayGMBIkarbHe)arenA

RbeTskm<úCadMNalKñanwgGñkGegÁtkarN_)ansnñidæanGMBIerOgenHfa enATIenaH ekItmanRBwtþikarN_F¶n;F¶r

edayELkEmn. b:uEnþeKetagEtrg;caMBIrqñaM edIm,I)andwgBIRBwtþikarN_BitR)akd nigGtßn½yeBjelj

rbs;va. b:uEnþplénkarbHe)arrbs;PUmiPaKbUBa’ nigkarb®gáabCab;bnþKñahUrEhGMBIdMeNIrénRBwtþikarN_

epSg²enA\NÐÚcinKWmaneRcInGenk. RBwtþikarN_TaMgenaH pþl;nUv»kas[eKbBa©b;enAeBlenHEtmþg.

CamYynwgkare)assm¥atenAPUmiPaKbUB’a yuT§nakarRbLak;eTAedayQamEdlepþImeLIg eday

b:ul Bt enAkñúgPUmiPaKepSg²eTot edIm,IeFVI[maK’aneya)ayrbs;Kat;maneRbóbCageKenaH

)ansÁal;nUv PaBxøaMgdl;kRmitmYy. km<úCaRbCaFibetyüRtÚv)anEbgEckCaPUmiPaKrdæ)alcMnYn7KW ³

]tþr bUB’a |san nirtI bs©im Bay½Bü nigPUmiPaKkNþal. tMbn;rdæ)alCaeRcIneTotEdlmanlkçN³

Rbhak;RbEhlKña Føab;RtÚvGnum½trYcmkehIyedaybkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCakñúgGMLúgeBleFVIskmµPaB

lYclak; nigkñúgry³eBlR)aMqñaMénkarRbyuT§tsU‘edayGavuF¬1970-1975¦. kgÉkPaBRbcaM

PUmiPaKCaeRcInkg EdlenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgedaypÞal;BImCÄimbkSFøab;mansV½yPaBd¾Cak;lak;mYy

RbEhlmkBIPaBlM)akkñúgkarTak;TgKñaeRcInCagmUlehtusnþisux. kñúgry³eBlbYnqñaMdMbUgénrbbenH

KN³mCÄimbkS)anRbwgERbgdak;bgçM[manrebobdwgnaMtamlMdab;lMedaymYyecjBIfñak;elIRtg;eTA

bNþaemdwknaMPUmiPaKEtmþg edayrkSaTukr)aMgmYyy:agtwgruwgrvagPUmiPaKnanamin[Tak;TgKña)an

eLIy. edayBwgEp¥kelIPUmiPaKkNþalnignirtI enAqñaM1976-77 b:ul Bt )ancab;epþImkm©at;ecal

emdwknaMPUmiPaK]tþrnigBay½BüPøam. karExVgKMnitKñaCaeRcIn EdlepþatCasMxan;enAelIsgVak;énkar

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg284

Page 295: Brother enemy

eFVIbdivtþn_nigrebobGnuvtþepSg². GñkRbqaMg)anTietonmaK’aeqVgRCúlhYsehtunigpSgeRBgniym

rbs; b:ul Bt faBYkeKKµanCMenOBIdMeNIreq<aHeTArklT§ikumµúynIsþkñúgry³eBlmYyy:agxøIeT ehIyk¾

minyl;RBmcMeBaHkarRbRBwtþKµanGaNitGasUrEdleRtómbRmúgsRmab;RbCaCnTIRkúgEdr.

BYkeK)anTietonneya)aypSgeRBgniymrbs; b:ul Bt cMeBaHRbeTsevotNamEfmeTot-enHCa

GMeBIk,t;Edlsmnwgsøab;. PaKeRcInénGñkrgeRKaHBIkareFVIvisuT§kmµepSg²suT§EteCOfamankarKMram

kMEhgrbs;evotNamEmn ³ tammtiBYkeKfa caM)ac;RtÚvEtEkERbkarP½nþRcLMkñúgkardwknaMRbeTs

KWedIm,IFanaeCaKC½yrbs;bdivtþn_km<úCa nigpþl;[RbeTsCatinUvmeFüa)ayepSg²sRmab;karBarxøÜn

edayxøÜnÉg. karvinicä½ysßankarN_mYyKWCasBaØaEdl[dwgehtumun>>>. sRmab; b:ul Bt nigRkúmman

PkþImYykþab;tUcrbs;Kat; karecaTRbkan;BIGMeBIk,t;ebItameyabl;elak hIuD½r KWCameFüa)aygayRsYl

mYy edIm,IeKcecjBI«karBiPakSatTl;KñaxagEpñkneya)ay EdlkñúgenaHBYkeKminR)akdCaman

eRbóbelIKat;eLIy ehIymü:ageTotmuxCanwgbgá[manPaB)ak;EbkKñakñúgbkS»32eTotpg.

karRbqaMgTaMgGs;Tl;nwg b:ul Bt dUcCakarRbqaMgrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’aKWmanlkçN³xøaMgkøaCag

eK. taMgBIkarcab;kMeNItrbs;clnaExµr\sSr³RbqaMg)araMgkñúgGMLúgTsvtSr_40 PUmiPaKenH)an

shkary:agCitsñiT§CamYyBYkkumµúynIsþevotNam. PaBenAekokRBMEdnCamYyRbeTsevotNam

nigvtþmanénBYkkmµkrevotNamkñúgcmáarekAs‘Unanarbs;km<úCa )aneFIV[karTak;TgKñamanPaBgay

RsYlbMput. kñúgGMLúgeBldMbUg²énkarRbyuT§tsU‘Tl;nwg ln; nl; KWkñúgPUmiPaKenHehIyEdlBYkevot

Nam)anCYyerobcMnigbgðat;beRgónk,ÜnyuT§sa®sþkgT½BExµrRkhm. shRbtibtþikard¾yUrlg;enH

hak;dUcCaedA[eXIjTRmg;neya)ayrbs;BYkkumµúynIsþExµr EdlCaGñkkarBarTsSn³énkarxiteTACit

lT§im:akSsIusCaRbéBNImYykñúgkarpøas;RTg;RTaylT§isgÁmniym. edayeFVI«tamKMrUrbs;evotNam»

BYkeK)ansgát;bBa¢ak;GMBIPaBcaM)ac;kñúgkareRbIR)as;RbPBFnFanepSg²EdlGaceRbIR)as;)an-

rbs;BYkKhbtIb¤GñkdéTeTot-edIm,IbegáInkarplit. karlubbM)at;vNѳepSg²BMuEmnCaGaTiPaBeT.

RkúmEdldwknaMeday b:ul Bt BitCaRtÚvjúaMg[luHkñúg\T§iBlem:A nigKMnitrbs;Kat;sþIBIkartsU‘vNѳ

smPaBkñúgsgÁm nigkarbnþts‘Ueday\tQb;Qr33.

eKmindwgfa etIkarExVgKMnitKñaTaMgenHRtÚv)anBiPakSatTl;KñakúñgépÞbkS b¤faetIBYkkumµúynIsþrbs;

PUmiPaKbUB’aRbfuyts‘UtampøÚvneya)aynwg b:ul Bt b¤k¾y:agNaeT. eTaHbICay:agNak¾eday vahak;

dUcCaGñkTaMgenaHminRBmGnuvtþn_ral;viFankareqVgRCúl nigéRBépShYsehtu EdlseRmceLIgeday

mCÄimeT. kñúgry³eBlbIqñaMdMbUgénkarkan;GMNacrbs;ExµrRkhm PUmiPaKbUB’a)anpÁt;pÁg;es,ógGahar

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 285

Page 296: Brother enemy

[RbCaCn)anRbesIrCageK ehIykarrs;enArbs;«GñkfµI» -RbCaBlrdæTIRkúgEdleKbMEbkmin[enA

púþMKña- k¾minsUvlM)aklMbindUcenAkEnøgdéTeTotEdr34.

k¾b:uEnþ vaCakarBitfa PUmiPaKbUB’ak¾mancMENkkñúgkarsmøab;rgÁalEdr. Ca]TahrN_ CnCaticam

CagR)aMmYymuWnnak;PaKeRcInmanedImkMeNItenAextþkMBg;cam RtÚv)anExµrRkhmRbharCIvit eRBaHEt

CMenOsasnaGuIsøamrbs;xøÜn. kgT½Brbs;PUmiPaKbUB’axøH)aneFVI[eKsmÁal;xøÜnedaysarkarRbRBwtþ

GMeBIsahavyg;XñgEbøkBIFmµtaeTAelIRbCaCnsuIvilevotNamedaymankar«[éd»rbs;mCÄimpg.

b:uEnþ plvi)akénkarmincuHsRmúgKñaxagEpñkneya)ayb¤CMgWminTukcitþeKÉg )annaMeTAdl;karniyay

edaHsaEterogxøÜn. PUmiPaKbUBa’CaRbPBpþl;kmµaPi)aly:ageRcInsem,ImEdlmanRkúmGñkEbkbkS

BYk b¤GñkEdlRtÚvsmøab;muneBlEdlminGacb:unb:geFVIGVITaMgGs; 35.

«k,alyYn xøÜnExµr»

Rbvtþirbs;PUmiPaKbUBa’KWCab;Tak;TgnwgRbvtþirbs; esa Pwm edayminGackat;pþac;BIKña)an. esa

Pwm manedImkMeNItCaksikrEdlmanrUbragFat;k®nÞl duHk,aleBaH muxmUldUcRBHc½nÞKWCamnusSFøab;

)andwknaMclnakumµúynIsþenAPUmiPaKenHrbs;RbeTskm<úCa kñúgGMLúgeBlmYyPaKbYnénstvtSr_mk

ehIy. enAqañM1954 Kat;k¾manmuxenAkñúgcMeNamCnkumµúynIsþExµrrab;Ban;nak;EdlRtÚvRbmUlpþúMKñaCafµI

enATIRkúghaNUy b:uEnþKat;)anlYcvilRtLb;mkkm<úCavij edIm,IerobcMksagbkSCafµI. enAqñaM1963

Kat;)aneLIgzan³cUlkñúgKN³kmµaFikarGcié®nþy_bkS¬esµInwgkariyal½yneya)ayEdr¦. KN³

Gcié®nþy_enHEdlmansmaCikR)aMrUb KWRKb;RKgedayBYkbBaØvnþRbqaMgevotNamrbs; b:ul Bt ehIy

manEtKat;¬esa Pwm¦mñak;b:ueNÑaH EdlmanedImkMeNItCaksikr. kñúgGMLúgbNþaqñaMeFVIs®gÁamT½BéRB

RbqaMgrbb ln; nl; Kat;)ankøayeTACanayGKÁesnaFikarrgénkgT½Brbs;ExµrRkhm. kñúgGMLúg

TsvtSr_60nig70 Kat;)ancUlrYmshkary:agCitsñiT§CamYyBYkkumµúynIsþevotNam ebITukCaman

karregáóscitþKñamþgmáalk¾eday. \T§iBlrbs;Kat;kñúgPUmiPaKeRkayqñaM1975manrwtEtxøaMgeLIg

EfmeTot enAeBlEdlKat;)ankan;kab;muxtMENgBIrEtmñak;ÉgKWsmaCikKN³Gcié®nþy_pg nigCaelxa

bkSPUmiPaKpg. mnusSCaeRcInvaytémøfa PUmiPaKbUBa’RtÚvCMBak;KuNKat;cMeBaHPaBsm,ÚrN_sb,ay

EdlmineTogrbs;PUmiPaKenH b:uEnþ GñkÉkeTsenAEtBicarNaenAeLIy GMBItYnaTIrbs;Kat;enAkñúgkar

smøab;rgÁalenATwkpþac;RBR½t.

eKnwkeXIjfa karKµansmtßPaBrbs;kgT½BPUmiPaKbUB’akñúgkarTb;Tl;RbqaMgnwgkarlukluy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg286

Page 297: Brother enemy

rbs;evotNamenAExFñÚ qñaM1977 RtÚv)anGHGagbEnßmedayrlkénkare)assm¥atmYyfµIeTot.

kñúgPaBRcbUkRcbl;EdlekItmanbnÞab;BIkardkfyrbs;kgT½BRkúghaNUy kgÉkPaBT½BmYycMnYn

rbs;PUmiPaKbUB’a )an)aj;kaMePøIgtTl;KñaCamYykmøaMgT½BCMnYyrbs;mCÄimEdleTIbnwgmkdl;BIPUmiPaK

kNþal. edaykgÉkPaBTaMgenH)ak;T½Brt;x©at;x©ayenAcMeBaHmuxkarrulmkmuxrbs;evotNamkalBI

mun enAeBlenHkgT½BTaMgenaHRtÚvCab;sgS½yy:agxøaMgBIkarXubXitCamYysRtÚv. mþgmYy²

kmµaPi)alT½BTaMgGs;EdlmannaTICanirsarrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’a RBmTaMgbNþaembBa¢akarkgBlFMrbs;

PUmiPaKkNþalEdlcUlrYmkñúgkarRbyuT§enH RtÚv)anekaHehAmkRkúgPñMeBjedIm,I«RbCMu» ehIyRtÚv)at;

xøÜnedayKµaneXIjvilRtLb;eTAvijCaerogrhUt. ÉksarCaeRcInenAKukTYlEsøg)anbgðajfa rhUt

mkdl;éf¶TI19 Exemsa qñaM1978 cMnYnGñkeTasEdlmkBIPUmiPaKbUB’aman409nak; KWeRcInelIsBI

cMnYnGñkeTasmkBIPUmiPaKBay½BürhUtdl;eTAdb;dg. enAéf¶bnÞab; mnusScMnYnémÖR)aMbInak;eTotRtÚvExµr

Rkhmykmkdak;KukenATYlEsøgEdlsuT§EtmkBIPUmiPaKbUB’aTaMgGs;. embBa¢akarkgBlFMTaMg

BIrrbs;PUmiPaKkNþalEdle)aHTItaMgRbcaMenAPUmiPaKbUB’a k¾RtÚv)ancab;xøÜnpgEdr. embBa¢akarmñak;

kñúgcMeNamBIrnak;EdldwknaMbBa¢akgBlFMelx290 maneQµaHfa ehg tal; EdlRKb;RKgbBa¢aelI

kgBlFMelx290. Kat;KWCabgb¥ÚnbegáItrbs; ehg sMrin 36.

enAéf¶TI10 Ex]sPa qñaM1978 viTüúRkúgPñMeBj)anpSBVpSaysard¾cEmøkmYyedayGMBavnav

[eFVIkarkab;smøab;BUCsasn_evotNam nig«kare)assm¥at»kñúgCYrkgT½Brbs;km<úCaxøÜnÉgpÞal; ³

GVI²TaMgGs;RKan;EtCatYelxb:ueNÑaH. yuT§mñak;kñúgCYrrbs;eyIgRtÚvEtsmøab;evotNam[)ansamsib

nak;. >>>niyaymü:ageTot karxUcxaterogxøÜnnwgsßitenAkñúgpleFobKWmYyTl;nwgsamsib EdltRmÚv

[eyIgmin)ac;bBa¢ÚnmnusSR)aMbIlannak;¬RbCaCnEdl):an;sµanenARbeTskm<úCa¦[cUlRbyuT§eT.

dUecñHeyIgRtÚvkarmnusSEtBIrlannak;b:ueNÑaH sRmab;kemÞcevotNamcMnYnhasiblannak; ehIy

eyIgnwgenAsl;RbCaCnR)aMmYylannak;eTot». karcab;epþImeFVImYyEdlRbkbedaymhicätakúñgkar

TamTar[mankarcUlRbyuT§TaMgRsugBIsMNak;kgT½B bkS nigRbCaCnTaMgmUl «eyIgRtÚvEte)assm¥at

CYrT½BnigbkSrbs;eyIg[s¥atbrisuT§ ehIyk¾RtÚve)assm¥atkñúgCYrmhaCn[dUcKñaEdr kñúgeKalbMNg

bnþkarvayRbyuT§ edIm,IkarBarTwkdIrbs;eyIgnigBUCsasn_Exµr»37.

kñúgzan³Cafñak;dwknaMmñak;etI esa Pwm manBak;Bn§½nwgneya)aycEmøkxuseKenHEdrb¤eT? etIKat;

manpþl;esckþIyl;RBmkñúgkare)assm¥atepSg²rbs;mCÄimbkSEdreT? GñkRsavRCavsBa¢ati

GU®sþalImñak;KWelak Eb‘n eXornin EdlecHniyayPasaExµrsÞat;CMnaj nigEdl)ancMNayeBl

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 287

Page 298: Brother enemy

evlay:ageRcInedIm,IsikSaBIRbvtþisa®sþfµI²rbs;km<úCaeCOfa esÞIrEteBjry³eBlénkare)as

sm¥at esa Pwm manCMgWenAedkBüa)alxøÜnenAeLIy ehIyk¾BMumanGñkNapþl;dMNwgBIerOgenH[Kat;dwg

Edr. TIbMput enAeBlEdlKat;)andwgBIkarcab;xøÜnembBa¢akarkgBlFMTaMgBIrrbs;PUmiPaKkNþal Edl

e)aHT½BRbcaMkarenAPUmiPaKbUB’a¬kgBlFMelx280 nig290¦ Kat;cab;epþImxwgsm,ay:agxøaMg b:uEnþ

dMbUnµansþÜcesþIgrbs;Kat;KWRtÚvCMruj«[mñak;²ykcitþTukdak;tamdansPaBkarN_ nigeFVIkarRbúgRby½tñ

x<s;edayxøÜnÉg». tammtielak Eb‘n eXornin fa esa Pwm )anRtÚvjúaMgmin[eFVIGVImYyekIteLIy

edaysarstism,CBaسeKarBvin½ybkSrbs;Kat; nigPaBR)akdkñúgcitþrbs;Kat;fa karcab;xøÜnmnusS

y:ageRcInnigkarsmøab;mnusSy:agrgÁalenH BMuGacqøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjBIsarCatiBitR)akdrbs;bdivtþn_

eLIy. enAeBlEdlkare)assm¥atrIkraldalkan;EtxøaMgeLIg² ehIyEdlKµanGVIGacbBaÄb;)anenaH

Kat;hak;dUcCaRtÚveFVI[Pan;PaMgRsLaMgkaMgElgeFVIGVIekIt. pÞúyeTAvijtameyabl;elak sÞIvehVn

hIuD½r fa bnÞab;BIkarvaybukTmøúHrbs;evotNamenAExFñÚ esa Pwm )anRtÚvr:UvKñaCamYy b:ul Bt edIm,I

km©at;smaCikénbBa¢akardæankgT½Brbs;xøÜnCaeRcInnak;. sRmab;emdwknaMmñak;rbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyü

rebobEtmYyKt;kñúgkarykrYcxøÜncMeBaHbraC½ymYy KWmanEtTmøak;karTTYlxusRtÚvcMeBaHGMeBIk,t;eTA

elIGñkenAeRkambgÁab;xøÜnb:ueNÑaH. cMeBaH huID½r yl;fa «vaBitR)akdNas;nUvGVIEdl esa Pwm )andwknaM

enAeBlRbwgERbgRTRTg;vibulPaBminR)akdmYykñúgPUmiPaKbUB’a nigsakl,gcat;EcgerobcMkgT½BTaMg

tMbn; k¾dUcCamUldæan b:uEnþKat;BMu)andwgfa xøÜnKat;pÞal;CamnusSEdlRtÚvsgS½yEdreT»38.

ebIBinitü[eRCARCHeTA etI)ankarGVIebI esa Pwm EdlCaemdwknaMRbkbedayectnaRtwmRtÚvmñak;

b:uEnþCamnusSKµanBiesaFn_ Rtg;Kµanl,icklb¤CaeBCÄXatmñak;Edls‘umRKlMunwg b:ul Bt RtÚv)at;bg;

esckþITukcitþeTAehIyenaH? GVIEdlRtÚvKitKWfa karBüayamTaMgGs;sgÇwmrbs;Kat; edIm,IerIbRmHecj

BIdegáóbEdlrYbrwtmkelIKat; muxCabeBaäH[mans®gÁamsuIvilmYyEdlkan;EtsahavéRBépSeLIg²

rhUtdl;mankarcUleFVIGnþraKmn_saCafµIrbs;evotNam EdlelIkenHmanTMhMFMeFgbMput.

enAcugEx]sPa qñaM1978 Ek Bk emdwknaMPUmiPaKkNþalEdl b:ul Bt cat;[TTYlParkic©dwknaM

eFVIkare)assm¥atepSg²)anepJIeTA[ esa Pwm nUv«sMbuRtGeBa¢IjRbCMu»mYy. Pwm )andwgR)akdBIGVI

EdlKat;RtÚvRbkan;Gakb,kiriyay:agNa²ehIykñúgerOgenH. edayévqøatKat;)anbBa¢ÚnnirsarbInak;

EdlkñúgenaHmanfñak;dwknaMbkSCan;x<s;mñak;pg[eTAesuIbsYrBIkmµvtßúénkarRbCMuenH b:uEnþKµaneXIjGñk

Namñak;vilRtLb;mkvijesaH.

enAéf¶TI24 Ex]sPa kgT½Brbs;PUmiPaKkNþalEdlRtÚvCYyBRgwgkmøaMgbEnßmkalBIeBlfµI²

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg288

Page 299: Brother enemy

edayrfeRkaHmYykg )anh‘umB½T§mnÞIrbkSPUmiPaKbUB’aenAsYg Edlmancm¶ayRbmaN30KILÚEm:Rt

BIRBMEdnevotNam. emdwknaMPUmiPaKmYycMnYnFM)anRtÚvcab;xøÜnnigsmøab;ecal. b:uEnþ Pwm )anrt;eKc

ecjq¶ayeTAehIy EdlGmdMeNIredayRbBn§ kUn² nigGgÁrkSCaeRcInnak;rbs;Kat;edayePosxøÜntam

LanhSIúbmYyeRKÓgkñúgbMNgeTA[dl;RkúgPñMeBj. tamelak Eb‘n eXornin [dwgfa Kat;Føab;)an

RbkasR)ab;bNþashkarIrbs;Kat;fa Ek Bk nigrdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTs sun esn EdldwknaMeFVIkar

vayRbharenH suT§EtCamnusSk,t;ehIyKat;sgÇwmfa nwg)anTTYllixitcab;xøÜnKat;BIKN³mCÄimbkS

eTotpg. tameyabl; huID½r fa «Pwm eCOfakgT½Brbs;PUmiPaKkNþal)anRbRBwtþhYsBIbTbBa¢arbs;

mCÄim. edayehtuenH Kat;bBa¢a[kUnecArbs;Kat;RbyuT§tTl;eTAvij rhUtTal;EteFVIy:agNa[ b:ul

Bt seRmccitþbBaÄb;karvayRbyuT§enH. dUecñHvaTMngCaBitEdlKat;KµandwgxøÜnfa Kat;)ankøayeTACa

eKaledAEdlRtÚvvayRbharBIsMNak;KN³dwknaMmCÄimbkSeLIy enAeBlEdl b:ul Bt RtÚvjúaMg[

eCOCak;taMgBIEx]sPa qñaM1978mkfa Kat;¬esa Pwm¦CaemdwknaM«bkSBlkrkm<úCa»lYclak;mYy

EdlbegáIteLIgedayevotNam nig es>GuI>Ga> edIm,IdeNþImGMNacenAkm<úCa»39.

esa Pwm )ane)aHTItaMgrbs;Kat;enAtammat;TenøemKgÁminq¶ayBITIRkúgPñMeBjb:unµaneLIy eday

sgÇwmfa b:ul Bt nwgmansuPvinicä½ykñúgerOgenHCaminxan. munnwgRbfuycUleTAkñúgrdæFanI Kat;)an

bBa¢Únnirsarmñak;[erobcMkarTak;TgKñaCadMbUgmYy. enAéf¶TI2 Exmifuna qñaM1978 «KN³kmµaFikar

TTYlbdisNæarkic©» mYy)aneFVIdMeNIrmkCYbKat;eRkamTRmg;Cak):al;BIreRKÓgEdlpÞúkENneTAeday

kmøaMgT½B. Pwm cab;nwksgS½ycMeBaHGVI²EdlenArg;caMKat;CaeRsc. Kat;)andkkaMePøIgxøIrbs;Kat;

)aj;cMkNþaledImRTÚgsøab;)at;bg;CIvitPøammYyrMeBc40.

Rbtibtþikaréf¶TI24 Ex]sPa qñaM1978 KWCakarepþImnUvvKÁcugeRkayénRbvtþisa®sþ EdlRbLak;

eTAedayQamrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyü. minyUrb:unµan eKnwgQaneTAdl;TICeRmA énPaBKYr[rn§t;

\t]bma. karcRmaj;enAB§d¾épÞkñúgbkSrhUtmkdl;eBlenH enAEtB½T§CuMvijedaykarlak;karN_sm¶at;

Canic©. GñkrgeRKaHsuT§EtRtÚvTak;Taj[ecjBIPUmidæanrbs;BYkeK eRkamelsCa«karGeBa¢IjmYy» -

eTAtamlT§PaBeRCIserIs³«karBieRKaHeyabl;tamTmøab;mYy» «karcUlrYmRbCMueronsURt» «karRbCMu

bnÞan;mYy» -b¤«karTTYlParkic©fµI» EdleKcg;RbKl;[«GñkTaMgenaH»bMeBj. karGeBa¢IjTaMgGs;enA

eBlenaH suT§EtRtÚvRbKl;[EpñksnþisuxCaGñkGnuvtþ. kñúgry³eBlbYnqñaM«GñkEdlRtÚvGeBa¢Ij»

RbmaNémÖBan;nak; RtÚv)aneFVITaruNkmµkñúgeKalbMNgKabykcemøIysarPaBepSg² bnÞab;mkRtÚv

smøab;ecalTaMgGs;enAmNÐlXMuXaMgTYlEsøg. b:uEnþGaf’kM)aMgEdlnaMmuxskmµPaBepSg²rbs;bkS

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 289

Page 300: Brother enemy

enAEtRkas;XµwkdEdl ehIymeFüa)aysRmab;Tak;TgKñarvagPUmiPaKCaeRcInKWKµanEtmþg. dUecñH

BMumankarP½yeqøqøacuHeLIgeLIy. BitehIy viFIepSg²rbs;bkSKWCMruj[mankarP½yxøacnwgkarmnÞil

sgS½y b:uEnþk¾KµanGVIelIsBIhñwgeTotEdr. pÞúyeTAvij edaybBa¢ÚnrfeRkaHCaeRcIneRKÓgeTAvay

deNþImykTIsñak;karbkSPUmiPaKenAsYg KWdUcCa b:ul Bt seRmccitþbgðajmuxcuHEdr. GñkEdlrYcrs;

CIvitBIeRKaHfñak;enH)an)at;bg;karyl;RcLMcugeRkayrbs;xøÜn. enAéf¶bnÞab;BIkarvayRbharKW éf¶TI25

Ex]sPa bNþaembBa¢akar nigyuT§CnTaMgGs;énkgBlFMelx4nigelx5 ¬embBa¢akarkgvresnatUc

nigkgvresnaFMCaeRcIn¦ RtÚv)anekaHGeBa¢Ij[eTAcUlrYmsm½yRbCMumYy. enAeBleTAdl;Pøam Gñk

TaMgGs;enaH)anRtÚveK[edaHexaGavecjrYccgsøabesk nigcab;dak;elIrfynþkamIj:úgCaeRcIn

eRKÓg. enAeBleTAdl;tMbn;dIvalKµanmøb; BYkenH)anRtÚveKRcanTmøak;mkdI ehIyykkaMePøIgynþ)aj;

rHsmøab;ecalEtmþg. mñak;kñúgcMeNamenaH)anrYcputBIeRKaHfñak;enAmanCIvity:agcEmøkKYr[q¶l;.

Kat;)anrt;ePosxøÜneTAdl;evotNam CaTIEdlKat;mankrNIykic©eFVICaksiNsakSIEfmeTot41.

ehg sMrin EdlCaembBa¢akarkgBlFMelx4)andwgfa b¥ÚnRbúsrbs;Kat;)an)at;xøÜn. Kat;min

bEg¥bg¥g;yUreLIy ³ CamYyyuT§CnRbmaNmYyBan;nak;EdlenAesµaHRtg;CamYyKat;)annaMKñaeKcxøÜnrt;

cUléRBPøam. Ta sab‘un kmµaPi)altMbn;mñak;EdlCaRbFankgQøbmUldæan)ancab;epþImbøn;deNþImyk

XøaMgGavuFrbs;PUmiPaK edIm,IrkkaMePøIgnigRKab;r:uEkátRbqaMgrfeRKaH. BYkkgQøb)anRbyuT§tTl;nwg

kgT½Brbs;PUmiPaKkNþalkñúgGMLúgeBlRbEhlbIs)þah_ munnwgdkfycUleTAkñúgéRB. bNþaemdwknaM

epSgeTotrbs;tMbn;CaBiess Ca suIm/ m:at; lI/ Em:n qn/ G‘uk b‘uneQOn nig suIm ka )anrt;cUléRB

CamYykmøaMg3>000nak;edaymanGavuFkan;RKb;éd nigRbCaCnsuIvilmancMnYneRcInCagdb;dg. rhUt

mkdl;dMNac;Exkkáda kñúgextþcMnYnbIrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’a ¬kMBg;cam sVayerog nig éRBEvg¦ kgT½Brbs;

PUmiPaKkNþal)anTTYlrgyayIkarrMxanCab;CaRbcaM. edayeqøót»kaseBlEdlExµrRkhmrt;

ePosxøÜnecj GñkPUmimYycMnYny:agFM)annaMKñavaykemÞcpÞH)ayrYm nigEbkEckeKaRkbIRTBüsm,tþi

EdleKRbmUldak;rYm.

cab;taMgBIExmifuna edayQmmuxnwgGanuPaBéneRKÓgsa®sþavuFEdlplitenARbeTscin kg

rfeRkaH RBmTaMgkgT½Bd¾es,Imrbs;PUmiPaKnirtIEdldwknaMeday tam:uk karRbyuT§tsU‘EdlRbRBwtþ

eTAÉg²rbs;kgQøb EdlbegáIteLIgTaMgRbjab;Rbjal;enaH BMuGacykeRbóbelIBYknirtI)an

eLIy. enAExkkáda kRmiténkarvayRbyuT§Kña)anfycuHbnþicmþg². karsgswk)ancab;epþImehIy.

karkab;smøab;y:agsahav\tGaNitGasUr )anRbRBwtþeTACaExSsgVak;mYyxusEbøkBImun EdlPUmiPaK

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg290

Page 301: Brother enemy

bUB’aminFøab;TTYlrgkalBIeBlknøgmk. tamkaryl;eXIjrbs; b:ul Bt nigbNþasmaCikrbs;Kat;

fa RbCaCnExµrenAPUmiPaKbUB’aTaMgGs;)anbgðajlkçN³BitR)akdrbs;xøÜnehIy KWCaBYk«k,alyYnxøÜn

Exµr» EdlRtÚvEtkemÞcecal[Gs; 42. Cak;EsþgeK)ankab;smøab;GñkbHe)ar Edlcab;)annigRkúm

RKÜsarrbs;GñkTaMgenaH ehIyk¾kemÞcPUmiTaMgmUlEdlFøab;pþl;CRmkdl;BYkenaHpgEdr. GñkEdlman

P½BVvasnaGaRkk;TaMgenaHRtÚv)andwkCBa¢Úneq<aHeTArkesckþIsøab;tamrfynþkamIj:úgTaMgGs;. BIrqñaM

eRkaymk ´¬GñkniBn§¦RtÚv)aneKCUndMeNIreTAemIlKMnrq¥wgexµacmYy kñúgcMeNamKMnrq¥wgexµacCaeRcIn

kEnøgenAextþkMBg;cam Edltamkar):an;sµanfamanmnusSRbEhl 50>000nak;RtÚv)anykmk

smøab;enATIenaH. enAeRkammøb;edImsVayCaeRcInedIm eKRbTHeXIjEtq¥wgEq¥gllad_k,almnusS

RbúsRsInigkUnekµgRKb;v½ysßitenARcbUkRcbl;Kñahak;dUcCakRmalmYy EdlemIleTAKYr[eRkómRkM

kñúgcitþGYlENnkñúgedImRTÚg>>>.

kñúgPUmiPaKTaMgmUl karb®gáabd¾KYr[tk;søútenH TMngCaeFVI[manmnusSsøab;cMnYnCag100>000

nak;. mYyPaKbIénRbCaCn-GñkEdleKsgS½yehIyEdlRtÚvEtkm©at;ecal-RtÚv)anCemøós[eTA

rs;enAkñúgtMbn;RKúncaj;nanaenAPUmiPaKxaglicRbeTskm<úCa. edayminTan;smøab;pgcMnYn Bak;kNþal

énGñkEdlRtÚvCemøós)an)at;bg;CIviteTAehIyedaysarkarGt;Xøanb¤CMgWtmáat;epSg².

edIm,Irt;eKcBIkarkm©at;d¾sahavyg;XñgenH BBYkemdwknaMkarbHe)arnigRbCaCnsuIvilRtÚvEt

EsVgrkTIlak;xøÜnenAkñúgéRBTTwkeCakxøÜnR)aNeRkamtMNk;TwkePøógrlwmCab;énrdUvmUsug. edayxVH

es,ógGahar fñaMeBTü exaGav nigRKab;rMesv )aneFVI[karebþCJacitþrbs;BYkeKfmfycuH. dUecñHkar

eRCIserIsKWsamBaØ ³ cuHcUl-dUcKñanwgeFVIGtþXatEdr- b¤sakl,gpSgsMNagrbs;xøÜnCamYynwg

evotNam. kareRCIserIspøÚvTIBIrBMuEmnfaGt;eRKaHfñak;enaHeT. edayBitGñkrt;ecalCYry:ageRcInBI

bNþakgBlFMrbs;PUmiPaKkNþal k¾mancMENkBak;B½n§enAkñúgkarvayqµk;CaeRcInelIkRbqaMgeTAelIPUmi

nanarbs;evotNamenAtamRBMEdnEdr. karpøas;bþÚrCMhrPøam² sRmab;BYkkmµaPi)al EdlRTRTg;kñúg

citþnUvkareXasnaRbqaMgevotNamtaMgBIeRcInqñaMmkehIy BMuEmngayRsÜleT. Exµr\sSr³mYycMnYn

tUcEdlenArs;ranmanCIvit ehIyEdlkalBIedIm Føab;manTMnak;TMngy:agCitsñiT§CamYyevotNam RtÚv

)ancat;[eTAeFVICaGñknaMpøÚv. cab;taMgBIdMNac;Exmifuna viTüúRkúghaNUy)ancab;epþImpSayCaPasaExµr

edayGMBavnav[RbCaCnegIbbHe)areLIg. kmµaPi)alExµrCaeRcInnak;EdlRbCaCnFøab;sÁal; ehIy

EdlmnusSTaMgGs;eCOfasøab;)at;eTAehIyenaH )anniyayeTAkan;CnrYmCatirbs;xøÜntamry³viTüúenH

edIm,IsMu[CYycUlrYmkñúgbuBVehtuenHpg. ehg sMék bgbg¥s;rbs; ehg sMrin )anedIrtYnaTICaPñak;gar

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 291

Page 302: Brother enemy

TMnak;TMngkñúgerOgenH. CaGtItGñkdwknaMrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’a¬dUcbgb¥Únrbs;Kat;Edr¦ Kat;)anePosxøÜneTA

RbeTsevotNamkalBIeBlmunenHbnþic. ehg sMék )anniyayerOgsm¶at;pÞal;xøÜnrbs;Kat;R)ab;´

¬GñkniBn§¦fa «TIbMputeyIgTaMgGs;Kñadwgfa eyIgBMuGacmanlT§PaBpþÜlrMlM b:ul Bt edaymeFüa)ay

pÞal;rbs;eyIg)aneT. eyIgmanEteTAsMukarCYy]btßmÖBIevotNamb:ueNÑaH». kalBIeBlknøgmkmin

yUrb:unµan Kat;k¾mancMENkkñúgnaTICaGKÁbBa¢akarRkúmPñak;garTMnak;TMngrbs;PUmiPaKbUB’a edIm,IrkSakar

Tak;TgCamYyGgÁPaBepSg²rbs;bkS nigCamYyRbeTsevotNamEfmeTot. dUecñH Kat;sÁal; nigrab;

GanCamYyevotNamc,as;Nas;. enAExmkra qñaM1978 enAeBlKat;ePosxøÜnecjBIRbeTs ehIy

eTAdl;RBMEdnevotNam Kat;)anRtÚvdwktam]T§mÖaKcRknaMeTAkan;RkúgéRBnKrPøam. bnþiceRkaymk

Kat;)anCYbnwgExµrRkhmmanKMnitRbqaMgdéTeTotCaeRcInenAGtItsalab:UlismYyeQµaHFUDwk.

KNbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam)anRbwgERbgerobcMclnatsU‘ExµrmYy[dMeNIrkartaMgBIeBlenaH

mkem:øH. karbgðat;k,ÜneyaFasRmab;yuT§CndMbUg²)ancab;epþIm. BIeRBaHeKElgsgÇwmelIkarKaMRT

CayfaehtumYyBIsMNak;RbCaCnExµrenARbeTskm<úCaPaKxagekIteTotehIy edaysarGgÁkarbkSenA

TIenaHeTIbnwgRtÚvb®gáabesÞIrrMlaysUnü. kþIsgÇwmkñúgkareFVI[mankarpøas;bþÚrmYykñúgépÞbkS -bnÞab;BI

rdæRbharmYy-)anrlayxSúl ehIyk¾lM)akkñúgkarykExµrEdlhVwkhVWnenARbeTsevotNam[

eRCótcUleTAkñúgRbeTs edIm,IerobcMkaregIbbHe)armYyrYmCamYynwgGñkmanKMnitRbqaMgEdlsßitenA

pÞal;TIenaHpgEdr.

evotNam)ancab;eFVIkarTak;TgCamYyRkúmGñkBYnkñúgéRBedIm,Its‘UCaeRcInRkúmeTot. enAedIm

ExkBaØa BYkeK)aneFVIkarvaylukfµImYyedaykgrfeRkaHcUlmképÞkñúgRbeTskm<úCa. eKaledArbs;

BYkeKelIkenHKWkarTak;TgCamYy ehg sMrin nigGñkmanCMenOelIKat; EdldkfycUleTAkñúgéRB ehIy

GmkarBardMeNIrGñkTaMgGs;enHrhUthYsRBMEdnExµrcUleTARbeTsevotNam. edayehtuenHehIyEdl

ehg sMrin/ Ca suIm nigExµrRkhmEdlenAKg;vgSCIvitGaceTAdl;RbeTsevotNamedaysuvtßiPaB

enaH. GnaKtrdæaPi)alkm<úCasñiT§evotNamGacerobcMeLIg)anehIy43.

eL DwkfU )ancakecjBIRkúghaNUytamynþehaHeq<aHmkTIRkúghUCImij. GmdMeNIredayGñk

CMnajkarbkSCaeRcInrUbEdlmanÉkeTsxagbBaðakm<úCa Kat;)anCYbR)aRs½yCamYyExµrRkhmEdl

manKMnitRbqaMgRBmTaMgGñknireTsxøÜntaMgBIyUrmkehIyxøHeTot CaBiess Eb:n suvNÑ nig Ca suT§

enAFUDwk Gs;ry³eBlBIréf¶ ¬21-22 ExkBaØa qñaM1978¦. tamkic©RBmeRBógrYmmYy eK)an

seRmcfa skmµPaBeyaFapþac;RBR½tmYynwgRtÚvdMeNIrkarenAExFñÚ qñaM1978 kñúgGMLúgrdUvR)aMgKWmun

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg292

Page 303: Brother enemy

cab;epþImrdUvRcÚtkat;. eK)aneFVIkary:agmmajwkedIm,IbgáIt«rNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCati»mYyEdlkñúg

namclnaenH karRbyuT§tsU‘RtÚvEtcab;epþImdMeNIrkarBIeBlenaHeTA44.

RbeTscinmémKitBIkarrYmKMnitk,t;mYy

enArdUvekþAqñaM1978sßankarN_mansPaBRcbUkRcbl;y:agxøaMg eTaHCaGñksegátbreTsk¾min

dwgBIerOgenHEdr. karegIbbHe)arnigkarb®gáaby:ageXareXAenAPaKbUBa’RbeTskm<úCa/ CnCaticin

rab;Ban;nak;EdlR)afñaqøgeTARbeTsxøÜn)anrs;enABBak;BBUnkñúgTIRkúgLagsug CaTIRkúgenACab;RBMEdn

cin-evotNam ehIyTIbMput karbegáItsmyuT§eyaFarbs;sUevotenAtamRBMRbTl;rbs;cin ³ kmøaMgnig

]bkrN_caM)ac;TaMgGs;sRmab;CemøaHkñúgTMhMFMmYy RtÚv)anerobcMbRmúgeRsc)ac;Gs;ehIy. sRmab;

Rkúgeb:kaMgyl;fa karRbRBwtþminl¥mkelIBYkGaNikCncinBuMEmnCaPaBcaM)ac;dac;xatmYykñúgkarpøas;

RTg;RTaylT§isgÁmniymenARbeTsevotNameT ehIyk¾BuMEmnCaGMeBIerIseGIgCatisasn_Edr b:uEnþ

R)akdNas; enHCaFatupSMmYyénneya)ayrbs;sUevot sMedAeLamB½T§RbeTscinEtmþg. CemøaH

rvagevotNam-km<úCak¾mancMENkkñúgkarvaylukmYyrbs;RkúgmUsÁÚ RbqaMgnwg]tþmPaBRbcaMtMbn;

rbs;cinEdr. kñúgerOgenH RbeTsevotNamEdlCa«kmøaMgGnutþrPaBCYrTIBIr» RKan;EtCa]bkrN_mYy

rbs;RkúgmUsÁÚb:ueNÑaH. pÞúyeTAvij tamkaryl;eXIjrbs;RkúghaNUyfa karcUlcitþbgðÚrQamenA

RbeTskm<úCa nigkarvayRbharrbs;ExµrRkhmmkelIEdndIrbs;xøÜn KWCaEpñkbMeBjb®gÁb;énEpnkard¾

TUlMTUlaymYy EdlerobcMy:agbuinRbsb;edayRbeTscin edIm,IkemÞcRbeTsevotNam[sabsUnü.

CaBiess RkúgmUsÁÚRBÜy)armÖnwgkarelceLIgnUvkarrYmCasm<½n§mYyrvageb:kaMgnigRkúgv:asIunetan.

kñúgkal³eTs³enH karBRgwgshRbtibtþikarrbs;xøÜnCamYyRkúghaNUyEdlxøÜnb:gR)afñataMgBIyUrmk

ehIy enAEtCaerOgsMxan;esµIGayuCIvit. enAestviman CaTIEdlTsSn³RbqaMgsUevotrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI

man\T§iBlxøaMg eKKµansmÁal;eXIjkñúgCemøaHrvagExµr-evotNameRkAEtBIfa enHCas®gÁamRbeyal

mYlrvag RkúgmUsÁÚ nigRkúgeb:kaMgeLIy. dUecñHshrdæGaemrikRtÚvEtpþl;nUvkarRTRTg;CayuT§sa®sþ

rbs;xøÜncMeBaHRbeTscin.

sRmab;RkúgmUsÁÚ enHCaeBlevlad¾l¥ b:uEnþk¾maneRKaHfñak;pgEdr. smþIniyaybBaÄWcitþnig

RTeKaHe)aHe)akEdleqøIyqøgKñaCasaFarN³rvagRbeTscinnigRbeTsevotNam KWCalaPBitR)akd

mYyEdleKKµansgÇwmTuk. rusSIemIleXIjPøamnUv»kasEdlxøÜnrg;caMCayUrmkehIy edIm,ITak;Taj

RkúghaNUy[mkcUlxagxøÜn. erOgr:avCnCaticinenARbeTsevotNam)anebIk»kas[sUevotelIk

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 293

Page 304: Brother enemy

ykRbFanbTeXasnaBImunmYymkniyayeLIgvij nigbriharEtBIsEtBasBIGMeBIsm¶at;Rbkbeday

kll,icénkmøaMgTIR)aM EdlmansmancitþnwgcinenAGasuIGaeKñy_. dUecñHBYkeK)anedA[eXIjnUvcMNuc

epSg² EdlTukCamantémøéRkElg. edayERbRtLb;BaküeBalsresIr RkúgmUsÁÚ )anbrihareday

karTamTaredayTTUcBI«GnutþrPaBniyménmhaGMNac» nigkareRCótERCkkñúgkic©karépÞkñúgrbs;evot

NamEdlRbeTscinCaGñkRbRBwtþelµIs.

b:uEnþ dMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI enARbeTscinkñúEx]sPa qñaM1978 nigBaküsmþIEdlKat;

niyayKWmanlkçN³EdlnaM[eKep¥IlP½yRBÜy edayehtufa karepÞrbec©kviC¢aeyaFanigkarpþl;GavuF

rbs;GaemrikaMgeTA[RbeTscinRtÚv)anelIkykmkCECkBiPakSaKña. enAéf¶TI25 Exmifuna GKÁelxa

bkSkumµúynIsþsUevot eLGUnIt eRbseNv)anbgðajrUbragenAmuxeKedaypÞal;xøÜnÉg. karriHKn;rbs;

Kat;GMBIneya)aycincMeBaHshrdæGaemrik manlkçN³xøaMgkøamYyminFøab;manBImunmk. tamKat;fa

GñkenAshrdæGaemrikEdlelg«snøwkebocin» )anbnþeFVIneya)ay«RbkbedayeRKaHfñak;mYynig

emIlmineXIjEvgq¶aynwgesaksþayy:agQWcab;BIerOgenHenAéf¶NamYyminxan»45.

shPaBsUevot )anBRgwgrwtEtxøaMgnUvshRbtibtþikarrbs;xøÜnedaysm¶at;CamYyRkúghaNUy.

cMENkÉkariyal½yneya)ayrbs;evotNam EdlrYmRbCuMenABak;kNþalExkumÖ³)anRbkan;yk

esckþIseRmccitþsMxan;²mYycMnYnTak;TgcMeBaHRbeTskm<úCa nigRbeTscin. edayGnuelameTAtam

karEdlRtÚveFVIrbs;xøÜn esckþIseRmcKWfa kardak;kgT½BevotNam[RbyuT§enAkm<úCa RbEhlCabgá[

mankarvaytbPøam²mYyrbs;cinminxan. edIm,IRbQmnwgkarKMramenH RkúghaNUyRtÚvkarkarBar

EpñkxageRkayrbs;xøÜnsin. GñkTTYlxusRtÚvevotNammñak;)anniyayR)ab;ÉkGKÁrdæTUt\NÐaRbcaM

enARkúghaNUyCasm¶at;naéf¶mYyfa «eyIgyktRmab;tamRbeTsrbs;elak». enAqñaM1969

shPaBsUevot)anbBa©úHbBa©Úl[RbeTs\NÐacuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógmitþPaBnigshRbtibtþikar

mYy. kic©RBmeRBógenHmanxsMxan;mYyEdlGHGagBIeKalkarN_énkarKaMRTxagEpñkeyaFarbs;

sUevot. \NÐaenArg;caMemIlsMeNIGs;ry³eBlBIrqñaM. b:uEnþ eTogminQñHTal; ³ karb:HTgÁic eday

GavuFEdlc,as;Camkdl;kñúgeBlqab;²CamYyRbeTs):aKIsßannigeRKaHfñak;énkarsnüamYyrbs;cin

CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;RbeTsenH enATIbMput)annaM[RbeTs\NÐacuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBóg nigdak;

xøÜnenAeRkamkarKaMBarrbs;rusSIKW\NÐaRtÚvEtrkGñkFanaCamhaGMNacputelxmYy. bIExeRkaymk

kgT½Brbs;\NÐa)anvayQñHRbeTs):aKIsßan-CaC½yCmñHEdlnaMeTAdl;karbegáItRbeTsbg;køaeds

ÉkraCümYy.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg294

Page 305: Brother enemy

enATIbMput RkúghaNUyk¾esIerIBinitüeLIgvijnUvKeRmagsn§isBaØamYyEdlesñIedayBYksUevot

taMgBIqñaM1975 KWbnÞab;BIC½yCmñHenAPaKxagt,ÚgPøam. enAedImExmifuna ]tþmesnIy_ y:ab )aneFVI

dMeNIrCasm¶at;eTAkan;RkúgmUsÁÚ edIm,Idak;CUnBYkemdwknaMsUevotBinitünUvBRgagsn§isBaØadMbUgmYy.

Kat;)aneqøót»kasenH edIm,IbgðajBIlkçN³énesckþIRtÚvkarEpñkeyaFarbs;RbeTsKat;pgEdr.

enAtampøÚveq<aHeTARkúgmUsÁÚ ynþehaHrbs; y:ab EtgEtcuHctenARkúgjÚvEdløI¬edIm,Icak;saMg b¤dak;

GñkdMeNIr¦kñúglkçN³Gaf’kM)aMgbMput. Kat;)anCYbrdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTsnigrdæm®nþIkarbreTsrbs;

\NÐaenAcMNtGakasyan ehIy)anesñI[CYyRbeTsKat;sRmab;karbegáIteragcRkplitGavuFmYy

edIm,IeFVIGavuFFunRsal. edaydwgBIlkçN³EdlecosminrYcénkarRbyuT§rbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTskm<úCa

nigRbeTscin RbeTsevotNammincg;BwgEp¥kEteTAelIBYksUevotmYyeTsRmab;karpþl;GavuF[xøÜn.

BIrqñaMeRkaymk GñkTTYlxusRtÚvfñak;x<s;mñak;rbs;\NÐa)anniyayerOgGaf’kM)aMgR)ab;´fa karesñIsuM

rbs; y:ab RtÚv)anRcanecaly:agKYrsmedayGHGagfa \NÐaBuMmanRbPBFnFanRKb;RKan;. Kat;

GacseRmcBIerOgenHedayrebobepSgeTotCamYyelakRsInaykrdæm®nþI \®nÞa Kn§I EdlCaqµbbegáIt

rdæbg;køaeds. b:uEnþrdæaPi)alEdlTTYltMENgbnþBIKat;KWelak m:Ur:ahSúIdWés CaRbmuxrdæaPi)alniym

sþaMelIkdMbUg mincg;cUlBak;B½n§nwgsm<½n§mitþmYyrbs;sUevotkñúgkarpSgeRBgmYyEdlemIleXIjCak;

EsþgRbqaMgnwgRbeTscineLIy.

RkúgmUsÁÚ GacRtwmEteRtkGrnwgdMeNIrmanmkvijénplRbeyaCn_EdlsEmþg[eXIjeday

RkúghaNUy edIm,IeFVIkarseRmccuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØamitþPaBmYyb:ueNÑaH. enAdMNac;Exmifuna

nIkUéL hVIruyb‘In Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTssUevot)anTTYlr:ab;rgbM)at;]bsKÁsMxan;²EdlmanenAkñúg

KeRmagsn§isBaØa. vaCaeBlEdlrdæaPi)alevotNamRtÚveRCIserIs»kasEdl[RbeyaCn_bMput

sRmab;karcuHhtßelxa. vaBuMEmnCabBaðabeg¥IlRkúgeb:kaMg edaykarpSay[dwgB¤Gaf’kM)aMgmYyEdl

beB©ajmuneBlevlaeLIy b:uEnþpÞúyeTAvij eKRtÚvEtR)ab;[dwgkñúgkald¾KYr ebIsinCaeKcg;raraMgRkúg

eb:kaMg[e)aHbg;ecaldMeNaHRsaymYyedaykmøaMgeyaFa. kariyal½yneya)ay k¾mincg;eFVI[

esAhµgdl;TsSnvis½yénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBmYyCamYyshrdæGaemrikedaybgçMel,ÓnRBwtþi-

karN_epSg²Edr46.

rhUtmkdl;eBlenH karerobcMRbúgeRbóbEpñkP½sþúParnigkardak;BRgayT½BsRmab;karRbyuT§Kña

Edlnwgmkdl;enAeBlxagmux)anRbRBwtþeTAy:agqab;rh½s. enAExsIha s<anGakasmYy)anRtÚv

erobcM[maneLIgrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrtamkaresñIsuMrbs;evotNam enAeBlEdlkarpþl;sBVavuFtampøÚv

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 295

Page 306: Brother enemy

smuRT)aneLIgdl;kRmitmYyEdlminFøab;manBImunmk. enAdaNag ynþehaHGg;tUNUv-12 (Antonov-

12) FM²CaeRcIneRKÓg )anerIsmÖar³ecjCab;rhUtmankaNug)aj;)anq¶ay mIsuIl r:ada nigRKab;

rMesvsRmab;BRgwgkarkarBarrbs;evotNam[rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgEfmeTot. ynþehaHRbedjTmøak;

RKab;Ebkmic-21CaeRcIneRKÓg EdlerIecjBInavaenAkMBg;EpdaNag nigdak;pÁúMenAnwgkEnøg )an

ehaHeq<aHeTAPaKxageCIg ehIycuHctenACitRBMEdnrbs;cin.

enATIRkúgmUsÁÚk¾dUcenAeb:kaMg s®gÁameXasna)aneLIgdl;kRmitx<s;bMput-mçagRbqaMgcin mçag

eTot RbqaMgsUevot. bIs)aþh_eRkayeBlEdlRbeTscincab;epþImbriharBI«karkat;kal;Elgrab;rk/

kareFVITukçbukemñj nigkarbeNþjecj» EdlBYkGaNikCncinenARbeTsevotNamCaGñkrgeRKaH

dMNak;kalfµImYyeTotRtÚv)anqøgkat; ³ evotNamRKan;EtCarNbrbs;BYksUevotb:ueNÑaH KWCa«BYk

Kuy)aenAGasuI». niyaymü:ageTot «sgÁm-cRkBtþiniymsUevot» KWCa«GñkjúHjg;nigCaGñkKaMRT

sMxan;bMput» dl;viFankarepSg²RbqaMgcinEdlRbkan;ykedayRbeTsevotNam47.

karvaylukedayBaküsmþI)anbnþekInrwtEtxøaMg. minyUrb:unµan Rkúgeb:kaMg)anseRmcKaMRT

RbeTskm<úCaRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNamCacMh. cab;BIBak;kNþalExmifuna edaymankaryl;RsbBI

ExµrRkhmpg BYkcin)ancab;epþImbriharBIeKalbMNgvatTIniymrbs;evotNamRbqaMgnwgbNþaRbeTs

CitxagxøÜn. ebItambTvicarNkfamYyrbs;Tinanub,vtþiRbCaCnecj Exkkáda )ansresrfa BYkeK

«vayb£kLWt» bnÞab;BIC½yCmñHrbs;eKelIshrdæGaemrik nigkarRbmUl)anbrimaNeRKÓgsBVavuF

GaemrikaMgy:ageRcIn. teTAeTot «BYkeKc,as;CaGnþrayedaykarelaPln; cg;)anrbs;eKhYsehtu

minxan». BYkeKKµanKiteXIjGVIeRkAEtBIbegáIt«GFiraC»rbs;eKeTA elIPUmiPaKGasuIPaKGaeKñy_ b:ueNÑaH

ehIykñúgTsSnvis½yenH BYkeK)anRbwgERbg«begáItshB½n§\NÐÚcinmYy»enAeRkamkarRKb;

RKgrbs;eKEfmeTot.

sRmab;BYkcin eTAhYsq¶ayBIlkçN³tMbn;niymdac;muxrbs;xøÜn CemøaHrvagExµr-evotNam )annaM

eTAdl;Gtßn½yTak;TgeTAnwgBiPBelakmYyy:agqab;rh½s. tamkaremIleXIjrbs;cinfa neya)ay

vatTIniymrbs;evotNam nigbMNgR)afñarbs;BYksUevotsMedAeTArkPaBx<g;x<s;CageKbMputelIBiPBelak

RKan;EtCaRTg;RTayBIrén)atuPaBEtmYyb:ueNÑaH. bBaðaRbeTskm<úCa nigGaNikCncinenAbreTs

ElgmanenAkñúgGFikrN_rvagRbeTssgÁmniymTaMgBIreTotehIy EdlkarcrcaepSg²lµmRKb;RKan;

GaclubbM)at;)an. tamBaküsmþIrbs;GñkeFVIGtßaFib,aycinmñak;fa ³ «vamankarrYmKMnitk,t;mYy

RbqaMgnwgRbeTscin. GFikrN_rvagRbeTskm<úCanigevotNam nigkl])ayRbqaMgcinrbs;Gñkkan;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg296

Page 307: Brother enemy

GMNacevotNam )anelceLIg[eXIjc,as;kñúgerOgenH-ehIyCaBiess kareFVITukçbukemñjnigkar

beNþjBYkGaNikCncinnigkareRbIR)as;bBaðabNþaCnCaticinenAbreTs edIm,IeFVI[ekItmankarEbk

)ak;KñarvagRbeTscinnigRbCaCatinanaenAGasuIGaeKñy_. mhaGMNacputelxsUevotCamYynwg

eKaledAGnutþrPaBpÞal;rbs;xøÜn )anbeRmICaGñkFana nigGñkKaMRTKYr[TukcitþcMeBaHneya)ayGnutþr

PaBRbcaMtMbn;rbs;evotNam EdlCa«kUnGuk»rbs;xøÜn48.

TwkeBjeRBóbEkv

rlkénBaküsmþIRTeKaHe)aHe)aksMedAeTArkRbeTsevotNamnigshPaBsUevotenaH )anqøúH

bBa©aMg[eXIjkarpøas;bþÚrneya)ay EdlekItmanedayCYnenARbeTscin naedImrdUvekþAqñaM1978.

exµacRbFan em:A Føab;RtÚvjúaMg[eCOCak;BIlkçN³EdlecosminrYcénkarRbQmmuxdak;KñarvagRbeTs

cin nigcRkBtþiniymBiPBelak. kñúgTsSn³vis½yenH em:A )anCMruj[RbCaCnKat;BRgwgEpñkmenaKm-

viC¢a erobcMsþúkRKab;FBaØCati nigCIkelNdæaneRkamdICaeRcIn. b:uEnþcab;taMgBIKat;søab; -k¾dUctaMgBI

kardYlrlMénBYkr:aDIkal;Edr- RkúmemdwknaMfµIrbs;cin)anseRmccitþedayjejItjejImkñúgkarRbkan;

CMhrmYyEdlmanlkçN³suTidæiniymbMput. GMNwHteTA vahak;dUcCamaneyabl;xusKñaGMBIrNsisS

rYbrYmmYyedayTTYlKuNRbeyaCn_BIkarKaMRTCaGnþrCatid¾TUlMTUlaymYyRbqaMgnwgsRtÚvsMxan;bMput

rbs;xøÜnKWRkúgmUsÁÚ. bnÞab;BIkarRbkas[dwgenAExmIna qñaM1978 nUvEpnkardb;qñaMkñúgkareFVITMenIbkmµ

Rbkbedaymhicätad¾FMeFgmYy RbeTscinRtÚvkarsnþiPaBry³eBlEvgmYyedIm,IerobcMxøÜnsRmab;

s®gÁamBiPBelak. RbeTscinsnñidæanfa GacBnüareBl)anedayraraMgEpnkarepSg²rbs;sRtÚv

kñúgeBlminTan;epþImEtmþg. GñkTTYlxusRtÚvcin)anRbkasR)ab;GñkÉkeTsshrdæGaemrikTTYlbnÞúk

bBaðakarBarCati ém:xWlPIls,ÚrI enAEx]sPa qñaM1978fa «bs©imRbeTsRtÚvEteFVI[manclacldl;

CayuT§sa®sþrbs;BYksUevot». «sRmab;RbkarenH eKRtÚvEteFVIkarRbkYtRbECgnwg\T§iBlrbs;BYk

sUevotenAkñúgbNþaRbeTsttiyelakxøH EdlmanlkçN³yuT§sa®sþsMxan;mYyedayÉekaRbeTs

TaMgenaHxagEpñkkarTUt ehIyminRtÚvePøcBIPaBkemSayénreboberobcMxagsgÁmkic©nigesdækic©rbs;

shPaBsUevot nigPaBpuyRsYyénsßirPaBxagCatisasn_rbs;sUevotpgeT»49. kñúgcMeNambNþa

RbeTsttiyelakEdlman«sarsMxan;CayuT§sa®sþd¾FM»R)akdNas; RbeTscink¾cat;RbeTsevot

NamcUleTAkñúgcMeNamenaHEdr. vaKYr[cab;GarmµN_Nas; EdlsmÁal;eXIjfa karpøas;bþÚrTsSn³

neya)ayrbs;cinRbEhlmaneLIgRBmKñaCamYynwgTsSnkic©rbs; Rb‘IhSInsÁI enATIRkúgeb:kaMg. tam

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 297

Page 308: Brother enemy

elak mIEsðlGUkesnbWk GñkÉkeTsbBaðaRbeTscinenARkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati EdlrYmdMeNIrCamYy

Rb‘IhSInsÁI eTARbeTscin)anniyayfa «PaBrmuaMgrem:akEdlBYkcinbriharCasaFarN³BIGMeBIevoc

k,t;rbs;evotNam )anbgáCaTsSn³Edlmin)anRbúgTukCamunkñúgkarsnÞnaepSg²»50.

B½t’manmYyEdllatRtdagedayBYkCb:un ehIyEdlRtÚvGHGagbBa¢ak;eRkaymkeTot)an

cg¥úlPsþútagfa enAqñaM1978 kñúg»kasénsm½yRbCMumYyrbs;kariyal½yneya)ayEdlBYkcin

)anseRmccitþ«eqøIytbcMeBaHGMeBIbgáehtuepSg²rbs;evotNam»nig«minrafyenAmuxkarsakl,g

eRbIkmøaMgeLIy ebIsinCaevotNamepþImeFVIkarpSgeRBgmYyxageyaFa»51. EpnkarCabnÞan;mYy

TMngCaRtÚverobcMCaeRscenACMnan;enaH Edlry³eBlrbs;vaRtÚv)anbBa¢ak;BIrExeRkaymkeTot.

BYkemdwknaMcin )anXøaMemIledayykcitþTukdak;cMeBaHsßankarN_eyaFaenAkm<úCa ehIyk¾RBÜy)armÖBI

plGaRkk;énkardYlrlMEdlGacekItmanrbs;ExµrRkhmEdr. GñkTTYlxusRtÚveyaFaxøH)anEføgBI

ectnarbs;xøÜnkñúgkarbBa¢ÚnGñksµR½Kcitþrbs;cinmkkm<úCa edayGHGagfa ebImineFVIGnþraKmn_eT RbeTs

cinmuxCa)at;bg;Epñkd¾sMxan;mYykñúgtMbn;enHminxan. b:uEnþKMnitenH)an RtÚvRcanecalCabnÞan;sRmab;

mUlehtuepSg²xagneya)aynigesdækic©k¾dUcxageyaFa. «kMuGagelIGñkdéT[eFVIcugePACMnYsxøÜn» ³

suPasitcinenHRbEhlCabkRsay[dwgBI\riyabfrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgehIy. éf¶mYy GñkTTYlxusRtÚv

cinmñak;)anbMPøWR)ab;´fa «ebIKit[hµt;ct;eTA eKalkarN_rbs; em:A KWfakarkarBarÉkraCüPaB nig

GFibetyüPaBrbs;RbeTsmYy CasMxan;RtÚvEtCasñaédrbs;RbCaCnRbeTsenaHpÞal;». eyabl;

epSg²eTot EdlmanKuNRbeyaCn_CageK k¾RtÚv)aneKelIkykmkBinitüBiPakSaEdr. TImYyKWPaB

sßitenAq¶ayxagEpñkPUmisa®sþrbs;RbeTskm<úCa nig]bsKÁkñúgkarpÁt;pÁg;dwkCBa¢ÚnPsþúParnigsmÖar

brikçarkgT½B. TIBIr KWRKaHfñak;EdlbgáeLIgedaykarcUlRbyuT§mYyedaypÞal;rbs;BYksUevotrYmKña

nwgevotNam. enATIbMput RbeTscinGacERkgrEGgfa kareFVIGnþraKmn_xageyaFamYyenAkm<úCaGac

eFVI[bNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþenAGasuIGaeKñy_ P½yxøacGaceFVI[bs©imRbeTsminsb,aycitþ

ehIyGaceFVI[EpnkarTMenIbPavUbnIykmµrbs;xøÜnPan;ERbGs;. Rkúgeb:kaMg)anyl;RBmbegáInel,Ón

kñúgkarRbKl;smÖarswk begáIncMnYnTIRbwkSaeyaFarbs;xøÜn b:uEnþenATIbMput)anseRmcTuk[RbeTskm<úCa

rbs; b:ul Bt «edaHkunEtmñak;ÉgeTAvij».

k¾b:uEnþeTaHCay:agNak¾eday k¾RbeTscinminGacbeNþay[RbeTsevotNamKMramkMEhg

sm<n§½mitþEtmYyrbs;xøÜnenAGasuIGaeKñy_ nigbeNþjGaNikCnrbs;xøÜnedayKµannrNadak;eTas ehIy

k¾mineFVIsøÚtbUtnwgsRtÚvcecsmanHrbs;xøÜnEdr. bNþaemdwknaMkumµúynIsþcin Edlman etg s‘avBIg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg298

Page 309: Brother enemy

CaGñkdwkmux )anseRmccitþeFVInUvGVIEdlbNþaRBHecAGFiraCcinCMnan;munGnuvtþknøgmk enAeBlEdl

RBHGgÁsmÁal;faRbeTsevotNambgðaj[eXIj«PaBRkGWtRkTm» KWRBHGgÁEtgEtdak;TNÐkmµmYy

eTAelIRbeTsenHCanic©. ebIeTaHCaCMnYyEdlpþl;[edayRbeTscinkñúgsm½ys®gÁam maneRcInsn§wk

sn§ab;y:agNak¾eday -Rkúgeb:kaMg)anvaytémøCMnYyenHfa mancMnYnTwkR)ak;dl;eTA émÖekadiduløar-

k¾evotNamGYtfa)anRbeTcRbeTscinEdlxøÜnElgxøacEdr. enAExsIha qñaM1978 GñkTTYlxusRtÚv

cinmñak;EdlesaksþaycMeBaH«karrmilKuN»rbs;evotNam)anniyayedImy:agQWcab;fa «evot

NamsuT§EtCamnusScitþexµA».

lkçN³RbqaMgrbs;cincMeBaHevotNam R)akdCaBuMmanlkçN³RbkbedayvicarNBaØaNTaMgRsug

eT. menaseBa©tnaepSg²k¾mancMENkrbs;vaenAkñúgenaHEdr. enAkñúgépÞRkúmemdwknaMrbs;cin GñkEdl

bgðaj[eXIjnUvkars¥b;ex<ImevotNamxøaMgkøaCageKKW etg s‘avBIg EdlmanlkçN³EbøkbgÁÜr enAeBl

EdleKnwkeXIjBIesckþIsgÇwmepSg²rbs;RkúghaNUuyEdlcab;epþImmanenAeBlEdl etg RtLb;mk

kan;GMNacvij. BaküsnüapÞal;xøÜnrbs; etg kñúgkarykcitþTukdak;KaMRTRbeTsevotNamkñúgGMLúg

eBlmans®gÁam RbEhlelceLIg[eXIjBITMhMFMeFgénkarxkcitþrbs;Kat;enAmuxkarGnþrayén

sm<½n§PaBmYy. GñkkarTUtéfmñak;EdlCYbTak;Tgnwg etg kñúg»kasCaeRcInenAnwkeXIjfa «Twkmuxrbs;

Kat;Etgpøas;bþÚrminEdlxan kalebIniyaydl;bBaðaevotNammþg². sm¥b;rbs;Kat;manlkçN³

ecjmkBIxagkñúgEtmþg». enAeBleKrMB£kBIBYkevotNamenAcMeBaHmuxKat;²EtgCHsmþITaMgkMhwg

edaycat;TukBYkenaHsuT§EtCa«Eqá»eBj²mat;. kñúgeBleFVIsnñisITkaEstmYyenAExvicäika qñaM1978

Kat;)anEføgfa evotNamCa«BYkyUkUg enATisxagekIt»EfmeTot. kareTIsTal;citþrbs;naykrdæm®nþI

éf eRKógsak; qUm:aNnþ EdlenAGgÁúyEk,r etg manlkçN³Gac[eKemIleXIjc,as;nwgEPñk. eday

ehtuenH enAExsIha qñaM1978 menaseBa©tnarbs;RbeTscinKWmanlkçN³c,as;las;Nas;Edlva

mindUceKalbMNgrbs;xøÜneT.

bIqñaMeRkaymk ´¬GñkniBn§¦)andwgtamry³GñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinmñak;fa enAedImExkkáda qñaM1978

kñúg»kassm½yRbCMuRbcaMs)aþh_mYykñúgcMeNamsm½yRbCMus)aþh_rbs;xøÜn kariyal½yneya)ayén

bkSkumµúynIsþcin)anseRmc «pþl;emeronmYy[evotNam» edIm,Idak;eTascMeBaH«Gakb,kiriyaeBar

eBjedayPaBrmilKuNnigPaBRkGWtRkeGag»rbs;eK. edayBiPakSaKñakñúgsPaBsm¶at;bMputenaH

karGnum½tesckþIseRmccitþenHBMumankaryl;RBmCaÉkcä½nÞeT b:uEnþenATIbMput etg )anGHGagRbkb

edayeCaKC½yfaRbtibtþikareyaFaEdlmankMNt;mYyRbqaMgnwgevotNam nwgeFVI[RkúgmUsÁÚyl;fa

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 299

Page 310: Brother enemy

RbeTscinnwgminbeNþay[eKsmøútKMram)aneLIy. cin)anvinicä½ykñúgbBaðaenHTukCamunfa ebIsinCa

BYksUevotBMueTACYyevotNameT BYkenHnwgTmøak;karsgS½yeTAelIsm½<n§mitþrbs;xøÜn ehIynwgGaceFVI[

CMhrrbs;sUevotkñúgBiPBttiyelakcuHTn;exSayminxan. tamRbPBB½t’mandEdl)an[dwgfa edIm,I

[manRbsiT§PaB etg s‘avBIg )ansgát;bBa¢ak;y:agyUrGMBIRbtibtþikareyaFarbs;cinEdlminRtÚv

bgðajfaCaCemøaHmYyedIm,IplRbeyaCn_CatiBitR)akdeT b:uEnþRtÚveFVI[eXIjfa enHCaEpñkényuT§-

sa®sþmYyRbqaMgGnutþrPaBBiPBelakvij. kariyal½yneya)ay)anseRmccitþBnüarkarRbtibtþi

ehIy)anbegáInkic©RbwgERbgeTVeLIgEfmeTot kñúgeKalbMNgsRmbsRmÜl[mankarxitcUlCitKña

mYyCamYyshrdæGaemrik RbeTsGasuIminEmnkumµúynIsþnigbs©imRbeTsrYcral;sin52.

enAcugExkkáda qñaM1978 rdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTskm<úCaRbCaFibetyü sun esn )aneFVIdMeNIr

eTATIRkúgeb:kaMg edIm,ITTUcsMuBIRbeTscinnUvkic©snüaEpñkeyaFamYyRbqaMgnwgevotNam. eKeFVI[Kat;

FujRTan;edayniyayRcMEdl²R)ab;Kat;BIKuNsm,tþién «PaBÉkraCüm©as;kar» RKb;Et»kas. etg

s‘avBIg -kalBImunRtÚvExµrRkhmemIlgayTukdUcCaGñkRbqaMgbdivtþn_- )ansEmþg[eXIjGakb,kiriya

twgrwugy:agcEmøk edays‘ksmþIeTA sun esn vijTaMgKMeraHKMerIyfa CMnYyrbs;cinnwgkøayeTACaGt;

RbeyaCn_ ebIsinCaBYkemdwknaMkm<úCamine)aHbg;ecalneya)ay«ceg¥ótcg¥l;niym»rbs;xøÜn nigmin

RBmbgábegáItrNsirSrYbrYmd¾TUlMTUlaymYyRbqaMgnwgsRtÚvevotNam. BYkcin)anbgÁab;bBa¢adac;xat

[ExµrRkhmyag semþc sIhnu eTAeFVICaemdwknaMrdæaPi)alvij ehIyxitxMEklm¥rUbPaBRbeTsrbs;xøÜn

enAeRkARbeTs[kan;EtRbesIrCagmunpg. BYkcink¾TUnµan[ sun esn eRtómxøÜnsRmab;s®gÁamT½BéRB

yUrGEgVgmYyedayCIkelNdæan erobcMkEnøglak;TukGavuFnigekNÐRbmUlmhaCnpgEdr. dUecñH kñúg

krNIEdlmankarQøanBanCafµIrbs;evotNam rebobRbyuT§enHhak;dUcCa[plRbeyaCn_Cagkar

RbyuT§ts‘UmYycMBImux. TIbMput RbeTscin)ansnüafa nwgeFVIkarKabsgát;eTAelIRbeTsevotNam

edayKµankarbBa¢ak;c,as;las;epSgBIenHeLIy53.

xøÜn]btßmÖxøÜnedayxøÜnÉgb¤ebIeFVImin)an eKetagEtQan[dl;cMNucmYyedIm,IviPaKBIRBwtþikarN_

epSg²edayR)akdRbCa. s<anGakasmYyEdlminFøab;manBImunmkRtÚv)anbegáIteLIgedIm,IdwkCBa¢Ún

eRKÓgsa®sþavuFnigRKab;rMesveq<aHmkkm<úCa. edaybUkbEnßmCamYykarehaHehIrcMnYnBIreCIgRbcaM

s)aþh_tamRbeTsLav RkúmynþehaHmYyEdlmanynþehaHb‘UGuIg707cMnYnR)aMeRKÓg)anr:ab;rgP¢ab;

karTak;Tgrvagextþkg;tugnigRkúgPñMeBjtamsmuRTcinxagt,ÚgedayeTogTat;. eRkABIeRKÓgGavuF

RbeTscin)anbBa¢ÚnTIRbwkSaeyaFarab;rynak;EfmeTot. tamkarsnñidæanrbs;BYkPñak;garsm¶at;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg300

Page 311: Brother enemy

Gaemrikfa enAcugqñaM1978 cMnYnTIRbwkSacinmandl;eTA5>000nak;ÉeNaH.

cMENkkarerobcMRbúgeRbobepSg²sRmab;karvaylukpÞal;rbs;xøÜnvij RbeTscin)anseRmc

cab;epþImvaylukelIsmrPUmikarTUtmun. sn§isBaØasnþiPaB nigmitþPaBEdlxøÜncrcataMgBIyUryarmk

ehIyCamYyRbeTsCb:un enATIbMputRtÚv)ancuHhtßelxaenAExsIha qñaM1978 edaymankarKaMRTCa

sm¶at;BIsMNak; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI pg. xsMxan;mYyEdlRtÚvCECkKñaénsn§isBaØaenHEcgfa PaKITaMgBIrsUm

sEmþgnUvkarRbqaMgCMTas;rbs;xøÜnRKb;rUbPaBGnutþrPaBniym. enHCakarvaylukEpñkkarTUtelIk

dMbUgEdlseRmc)anedayRkúgeb:kaMg ehIyEdlnaM[Gnþraydl;plRbeyaCn_RkúgmUsÁÚeTotpg.

dMNak;kalfµImYyéndMeNIreFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyshrdæGaemrik)ancab;epþImCamYykarEtgtaMg

elak eLGUNard_ vUdxUk nig cay ehSmin [eFVICaemdwknaMKN³ebskkmµTMnak;TMngKñay:agecjmux.

RsbeBlCamYyKñaenaH RbB½n§pSBVpSayrbs;cin)ancab;dMeNIrkar«Rbelamesñh_» eTAkan;RbeTs

nanaenAGasuIGaeKñy_Edr -EdlminTukcitþyUrmkehIycMeBaHbdivtþn_rbs;RbeTscin- edIm,IbeRmIkic©

erobcMdMeNIrTsSnkic©pSHpSaKñad¾FMEdl etg s‘avBIg nwgRtÚveFVIenAeBlqab;² edaycab;epþImkñúgbNþa

RbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþkñúgtMbn;\NÐÚcineTA.

rdUvekþAqñaM1978 )anQandl;TIbBa©b;. BYkcinnigevotNam)anerobcMEpnkarcm,aMgrbs;xøÜn

edaysm¶at;. b:uEnþmunnwgcab;epþImc,aMgKñaeK RtÚvkareBlevlaedIm,IRbmUlkarKaMRTmYycMnYnsin. kñúg

karrt;RbNaMgel,ÓnEdlepþImeFVIedayRkúghaNUynigRkúgeb:kaMg mitþPaBnigkarKaMRTrbs;shrdæ

GaemrikEdlfµI²enH RBmeRBógKñaenAeRkAmat;TVarGasIu KWCakarRbfuyxatEdlnaMeTArklT§pl

cugeRkaymYy.

karGuCGal[rwtEtmanerOgFM 301

Page 312: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg302

Page 313: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI9Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡

elak rIqad hUlRb‘Úk )ancab;epþImBIeKalkarN_fa KWenAcMkNþalghVÚgmnusSEdlkarsm¶at;

mYyRtÚv)ankarBarCitl¥bMput. enAéf¶TI27 ExkBaØa qñaM1978 Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs)anrYmRbCuMRkúm

Gñkcrcad¾tUcrbs;Kat;enAkñúgkEnøgmYyénsßanebskkmµGaemrikaMg RbcaMGgÁkarshRbCaCatisRmab;

CaelIkTIBIrkñúgry³eBlmYys)aþh_. eKkMBugsßitenAkNþalsm½yRbCuMeBjGgÁénmhasnñi)at

GgÁkarshRbCaCati ehIydUcsBVdg karRcbUkRcbl;KWmankRmitx<s;bMput. enAtamrukçvifIelx1 kar

eFVIcracrtampøÚv)anRbRBwtþeTAsnSwm²edaysarclnarfynþkñúgRsuk nigyanynþeTscrN_. k,Ün

rfynþpøÚvkarCaeRcIneRKÓg )anRtaypøÚvmYyeq<aHeTATIsñak;karGgÁkarshRbCaCatiTaMgBi)ak. bNþa

RbFanaFibtI naykrdæm®nþI nigrdæm®nþIkarbreTsénBiPBelakTaMgmUlsrubeTA140RbeTs)aneTA

kan;TINat;CYbenAsgáat;emnhatan; edayRbúgeRbóbxøÜnbnÞab;²KñaedIm,IeFVICavaKµin enAkñúgmhasnñi)at

nigcUlrYmkñúgBiFICb;elog/ BiFIbdisNæarkic© nigsm½yRbCuMRKb;RbePT. hUlRb‘Úk )anrkeXIjm®nþI

CatYy:ag edIm,IsnÞnaedays¶at;kM)aMgCamYyevotNamsþIBIkarbegáItTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUtrvagRbeTs

TaMgBIr. taMgBIkarbeNþjGñktMNagrbs;evotNamecjBIGgÁkarshRbCaCatienAExkumÖ³qñaMdEdl

eRBaHEterOgr:avcarkmµminc,as;las;mYy KMniténkarxitcUlCitKñamYyCamYyRbeTsevotNamBuMman

GVIEdleFVI[saFarNmtiGaemrikaMgcab;GarmµN_eLIy. dUecñH karRbkasEdleFVImuneBlevlasþIBI

karCYbKñaTaMgenHmuxCanwgeFVI[RbFanaFibtI xatF½r CYbkarlM)akminxan.

GVI²)anmaneLIg dUcEdleRKagTukCamun. sarB½t’manBuMdwgdMNwgsþIBIkarCYbrbs; hUlRb‘Úk

kalBIR)aMéf¶munCamYyGnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs egVón kUfac; eLIy. dUecñHenAresoléf¶TI27 ExkBaØa enH

hUlRb‘Úk/ RhVg;vIsn½r mIEsðl GUesnbWk CanayTahanenAkñúgRkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati nigshkarIBIrrUb

enARksYgkarbreTs)annaMKñaeLIgCiHrfynþtak;suIBIreRKÓgedayKµanGñkNamñak;cab;PøwkBYkeKeLIy.

BYkeK)aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;kEnøgNat;CYbKñaCamYyevotNamedaysm¶at;CaelIkTIBIr. bnÞb;TaMgLay

énGKarKN³ebskkmµd¾tUcrbs;evotNamEdlemIlmineXIj eRBaHkb;)at;enAkñúgmhaRKwHmYyksag

GMBI\dænigkBa©k;km<s;35Can;enAtampøÚv Waterside Plaza BuMmanRkbx½NÐGVIEdlsmnwgTTYlRBwtþikarN_Ca

Rbvtþisa®sþmYyEbbenHTal;EtesaH. hUlRb‘Úk RbEhlCaeCOCak;fa karRbCuMCamYy fac; CafµIenH

nwgebIk»kas[mankarecjdMeNIrfµImYy. bnÞab;BIkic©RBmeRBóg exm edvId (Camp David) EdlcuH

303

Page 314: Brother enemy

htßelxakalBImYys)aþh_munrvagelak em:Naehm ebhÁIn (Menaham Begin) naykrdæm®nþIGuI®sþaEGl

nigelak GanUGar_ Gal;sadat (Anouar al-Sadate) RbFanaFibtIeGhSúIb kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYy

RkúghaNUynwgCaeCaKC½ymYyEfmeTotkñúg«fg;yam»rbs;elak xaF½r.

k¾b:uEnþ elak hUlRb‘Úk )anRtÚveFVI[RsLaMgkaMgenAkñúg»kasénkarCYbKñaelIkdMbUgnaéf¶TI22

ExkBaØa cMeBaHkarRbkan;KMnitx¢ab;x¢Ünrbs;evotNam EdlcecssMGagelIkarbg;R)ak;sRmab;CYsCul

karxUcxatedaysars®gÁamCafñÚrnwgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBdEdl. fac; )annaMmkCamYyKat;nUv

ÉksarmYysMNuMFMEdlmanpÞúkesckþIEføgkarN_TaMgGs; TaMgpøÚvkarb¤minpøÚvkar EdlenAkñúgenaH BYkeK

)anEføgBIbMNgrbs;xøÜnCaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBmYy edayKµanlkçxNÐtaMgBIEx

kkáda qñaM1978mkem:øH. enHCakarxatbg;kmøaMg\tRbeyaCn_. CafµImþgeTot fac; Edldak;bgÁúymin

Tan;RsYlbYlpg )ancab;epþImeRcógceRmógdEdl²sþIBIkatBVkic©xagsIlFm’rbs;GaemrikaMgcMeBaH

RbeTsevotNam edayelIkeLIgvijnUvTLðIkrN_\t)ankardUcBImun EdlnaMeTAdl;braC½ykalBIqñaM

1977. Kat;)anraykarN_R)ab;nayecAhVayKat;KW rdæm®nþIkarbreTs elak suIrus v:an;s_ fa ³

«Gs©arüNas;elak¡ BYkeK¬evotNam¦enAEtTamTarluyBIeyIgCanic©».

b:uEnþ enAeBlRbCuMelIkTIBIr hUlRb‘Úk EdlsÁal;kll,icénkarcrcarbs;evotNammankar

R)akdkñúgcitþfa fac; muxCae)aHbg;karTamTarrbs;xøÜnminxan. dUecñH etIRtÚvBnül;rebobEbbNa Edl

GñkcrcaevotNamminRBmbBaÄb;karcrcaCasßaBrenAeBl hUlRb‘Úk RbkasenAéf¶TI22 ExkBaØaenaHfa

tamKat;yl; vaKµanRbeyaCn_nwgbnþniyayKñakñúgn½ydEdl²G‘ÍcwgeT. elakGnurdæm®nþITukcitþxøaMgEmn

ETncMeBaHGMeBIrbs;Kat; EdlKat;)ansuM[GUesnbWkcUlrYmGgÁúyEk,rKat;enAkñúgRKb;karRbCuMcrca.

b‘ÍkjÚ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anvinicä½yedaymineBjBIkarbegáItTMnak;TMngeLIgvijCamYyRbeTsevotNam Edl

Kat;cat;TukCa«rNb»FmµtamYyrbs;BYksUevot ehIyGaRkk;CagenHeTAeTot KWRkúghaNUyCasRtÚv

ecjmuxrbs;RbeTscinEdlKat;yl;fa CaGnaKtsm<½n§mitþCayuT§sa®sþrbs;Gaemrikpg. hUlRb‘Úk

)anniyaysµanEtxøÜnÉgfa [EtevotName)aHbg;karTamTarrbs;BYkeKenAcMeBaHmux GUesnb‘Wk Edl

CaGñkÉkeTsxagbBaðaGasuIGmelak Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI vanwgBi)akeFVI[RkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCatiraraMgKat;min

[eFVIGVIekItNas;.

lMnaMBaküeBcn_EdlniyayecjenAkñúgeBlRbCuM BuMEmnCaTmøab;EdleKFøab;eRbIeLIy. fac;

EdlesøókBak;semøókbMBak;BN’exov )anTTYlsVaKmn_BYkGaemrikaMg enAeBlGñkTaMgenHmkdl;sßan

KN³ebskkmµ. bnÞab;BIkarcab;rlak;édKñamYysnÞúHmk GñkTaMgGs;)ancUlGgÁúyCuMvijtukRmal

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg304

Page 315: Brother enemy

ébtgRtg;RCúgbnÞb;mYy EdleTIberobcMdak;tuTUtaMgsRmab;BiFITTYlePJóvdUctamTmøab;. GñkTaMgGs;

)anRtÚveFVI[PJak;ep¥IlnwgdMeNIrrh½srhYndUcmnusSmanv½yenAekµgrbs; fac; Edly:agehaceTIbEt

manGayuhasibbIqñaMb:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþ mnusSEdljjwmrIkrayCab;enH Føab;manbTBiesaFn_Epñk

s®gÁamnigEpñkkarTUtCaeRcInqñaMmkehIy. edayeqøót»kaskñúgeBlsRmakxøImYyCuMvijEBgEt fac;

)anniyayR)ab;erOgGaf’kM)aMgrbs;Kat;xøH². CavresnIy_eTakñúgkgT½Bevotmij Kat;)ancUlrYmenA

kñúgkareLamB½T§bnÞayrbs;)araMgCaRbvtþisa®sþenAeDonebonPU. BIrqñaMeRkaymk fac; )ancab;epþIm

GaCIBCaGñkkarTUtrbs;Kat;kñúgzan³CaGKÁkugs‘ulRbcaMRkúgjÚvEdløI. KWenACMnan;enaH ehIyEdlKat;

eronBIEbbbTl¥²rbs;GWr:ubtammeFüa)aypÞal;rbs;Kat;. edayecHniyayPasa)araMgsÞat;eTA

ehIy Kat;k¾eronecHPasaGg;eKøsy:agqab;rh½s. karecHPasaGg;eKøsnigbTBiesaFn_EpñkkarTUt

rbs;Kat;nwgeXIjfa manRbeyaCn_EmnETnkñúgTsvtSr_70 eBlEdlKat;eFVIkarcrcad¾EvgGnøay

CamYyelak hg;rI KIsSúIghÁ½r enATIRkúg):arIs EdlenAeBlenaHKat;eFVICashkarIrbs; eL DwkfU.

\LÚvenH Kat;KWCanayecAhVaymþg. Kat;)ancab;epþImeFVIesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;Kat;CaPasaevotNam

ehIyvac,as;Nas;fa Kat;Kµanpøas;bþÚrCMhrTal;EtesaH. Kat;niyaymþgehIymþgeTotfa shrdæ

GaemriknwgmineTARkúghaNUyedayédTeTeT. dUecñHelak hUlRb‘Úk RtÚvEterobrab;BIehtuplepSg²

eLIgvij Edlhammin[shrdæGaemrikeFVIkic©snüaNamYyGMBIerOgenHeLIy. ry³eBlmYyem:ag

knøHkñúgkarniyayeqøIyqøgKñaEdl\t)ankar Kat;)anRbmUlÉksarepSg² ehIyerobTukdak;enAkñúg

kabUbTukÉksarrbs;Kat;. karsnÞna)anbBa©b;y:agKMhuk. «elak fac; eyIg)aneFVIGVI²tamEtGac

eFVI)an. ebIeTaH CaGVI²TaMgGs;EdlelakniyayR)ab;eyIgRtÚvbBa©b;karCECkBiPakSak¾eday».

elak fac; )antbmkvijfa cuHebIeyIgnaMKñapwkEtsin?.

BYkeKnaMKñaegIbecjBItuTaMgGs;Kña. enAcugmçageToténbnÞb; TwkEt kaehV nMeRkóm² nignMeRkób

eFVIBIGgárEdlsuT§EtenAfµI RtÚv)anerobcMbRmúgCaeRsc edIm,IbeRmIeKalbMNgePJóv. enAmçageTotén

East River ¬CaERBksßitenAcenøaHsgáat;enARkúgjÚvy:kKWsgáat;emnhatg; nig Rb‘ÚkXøIn¦ épÞemXBN’

exov)anERbBN’snSwm² eTACasVayRBEltvij. GUesnbWk )anbeBa©jGakar³eFVImuxRkjÚvminRBm

niyaysþIeBjmYyresol. erOgTaMgGs;enH )anbNþal[Kat;ecHEtsgS½yminGs;minehIy.

Kat;mineCOfa evotNammanbMNgcrcaGMBIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBkñúgry³eBlxøIeLIy EdltamKat;

yl; erOgenHnwgeFVI[elak hUlRb‘Úk sßitenAkñúgsßanPaBCaGñkedImecaTvijmþg. fac; dwgfaGñkNaCa

GUesnbWk ehIy²Kat;R)akdCadwgxøÜnBIkarxan)ancMeNjplRbeyaCn_rbs;Kat;eTotpg. fac;

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 305

Page 316: Brother enemy

ecHcab;epþImCamYy GUesnbWk nUvkarsnÞnaminsUvsMxan;mYyCamYyKat;kñúgzan³Cam®nþICan;x<s;.

GUesnbWk eFVIhak;dUcCaminB¤. Kat;bnþsmøwgemIleTAdMbUlGKarTaMgLayénsgáat;]sSahkmµ XVIn

EdlelcrUbrageLIgkñúgpÞaMgkBa©k;énbg¥Üc. GUesnbWk )andMNaleRkaymkfa «KµanGVIRtÚvniyay

TaMgGs; ´seRmcminniyaymYym:at;eTAkan;GñkNamñak;eLIy. enHCaelIkdMbUgehIy Edl´CYb

CnCatievotNammñak;». edayTmøayPaBes¶óms¶at;EdlBi)akRTaMmYy hUlRb‘Úk )anRbjab;eFVI[

karsnÞnamansnÞúHeLIgvij.

bnÞab;BIbriePaK¬[mankmøaMgeLIgvij¦rYc Kat;)anesñIenAeBlehobnwgsuMlafa «eyIgniyayKña

bnþicEfmeTot». eBlRtLb;mkkan;tuvij fac; )anERbeTACamnusSmñak;eTotPøam. «yl;RBm ´nwg

niyayR)ab;elakBIGVIEdlelakcUlcitþ. eyIgyl;RBm edIm,IelIkTukeTAeBleRkaynUvkarBinitü

emIlbBaðaepSg²eTot. CadMbUg eyIgeFVI[TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;eyIgmanRbRktIPaBsin edayKµan

lkçxNÐCamuneLIy». hUlRb‘Úk )anrMB£kfa ³ «Gs©arüNas;¡ EtmYyrMeBcesaH GVI²)anERbkøay

eTACagayRsYlTaMgGs;. enaHKWkic©RBmeRBógmYyEdlBuMGacseRmc)ankñúgry³eBlBIrqñaM EbrCa

RtÚvcuHhtßelxakñúgry³eBlEtdb;naTIeTAvij». fac; )anesñI[ hUlRb‘Úk cuHhtßelxaelIBiFIsar

RBmeRBógmYy. «eyIgmanm:asuInGgÁúlIelxmYyenAxageRkamshkarITaMgLayrbs;eyIgGacKitKUr

tak;EtgxøwmsarBiFIsarenHehIy kñúgeBlEdleyIgGgÁúypwkEtGs;mYyEBg». hUlRb‘Úk Edl

sb,ayswgehaH)aneqøIytbfa «enHCakarrIkceRmInmYyRbkbedayn½ysßabnabMput nigCakare)aH

CMhaneTAmuxmYyd¾sMxan;». b:uEnþ Kat;)anRcanecalminyl;RBmtamGtßbTEdlEtgPøam²KµanRBag

TukCamun eTaHCaGtßbTGVIk¾eday dUcEdl fac; esñIKat;eLIy. «´nwgbBa¢ÚnsMeNIrbs;elakeTARbFana

FibtI´. eyIgnwgBinitüemIlsMeNIenHedaykarykcitþTukdak;bMput ehIyeyIgnwgR)ab;elak[dwg

CamunkalebIeyIgyl;fa vaGace)aHCMhaneTAmuxehIy». eTaHCay:agNak¾eday fac; cg;)anfa

kic©RBmeRBógGacRtÚvcuHhtßelxaenAkñúgs)aþh_TImYyénExtula kñúgry³eBlénkarsñak;GaRs½y

enARkúgjÚvy:krbs;rdæm®nþIkarbreTs egVón DuyRTij. b:uEnþtam hUlRb‘Úk yl;fa vaminR)akdfa

cemøIymYyrbs;GaemrikaMgGacseRmcTan;kñúgry³eBlenHeT.

fac; niyayfa «´nwgsßitenATIRkúgjÚvy:krhUtdl;éf¶TI20 Extula». edaymin)andwgmun

briyakasénkarRbCuMEdl[RbpñÚlGaRkk;rhUtmkdl;eBlenH)anpøas;bþÚrTaMgRsug. eK)anrMB£kBIkar

ebIksßanTUtGaemrikaMgmYyenATIRkúghaNUykñúgGKarepSg² Edlkan;kab;edayGtItsßankugs‘ul

GaemrikaMgkalBIsm½yGaNaniKm)araMg. GtItsßanTUtRbeTsevotNamxagt,ÚgenATIRkúgv:asuInetan

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg306

Page 317: Brother enemy

EdlenATMenrRtÚv)an hUlRb‘Úk RbKl;[ fac; TaMgTwkmuxRss;jjwm. fac; )anBiPakSaeRsceTA

ehIyBIcMnYnbuKÁlikénsßanTUtnImYy² bTbBaØtiþepSg²EdlRtÚvRbkan;yksRmab;karTak;TgKña nig

hibGñkkarTUt. niyayedayxøI eKeFVIGVI²edayhµt;ct;bMput.

enAeBlEdl hUlRb‘Úk EdlmanTwkmuxRss;RsaysuMla fac; EdlbeBa©jsñamjjwmRss;

RsayEdrenaH RsemalraRtIkal)anFøak;RKbmkelIRkúgjÚvy:kTaMgmUl. b:uEnþ raRtIenHhak;dUcCa

estaruN ¬BnøWsbMRBagEdlelceLIgenAeCIgemXmunRBHGaTitürH¦ fµImYysRmab;TMnak;TMngrvag

Gaemrik-evotNam.

ElgmanGVImYyraraMgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeTotehIy. neya)aykarbreTsrbs;GaemrikaMg

enAGasuI )anmkdl;pøÚvEbkCabYnehIy. rhUtmkdl;eBlenH suIrus v:an; nig b‘ÍkjÚ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI Gacbnþ

yuT§sa®sþpÞúyKñacMeBaHRbeTscinnigGasuIPaKGaeKñy_ eday\t[PaBminRsbKñapÞúHeLIgCasaFarN³

eLIy. \LÚvenH eKRtÚvEtseRmcedaymuWgm:at;. mçagKWRbeTsevotNamnigRbeTscin ehIymçag

eTotKW RbeTskm<úCanigRbeTsevotNam EdlsuT§EtsßitenAelIpøÚvénkarRbQmmuxdak;KñaedayGavuF

mYyCak;Caminxan EdlkñúgenaHshPaBsUevotTMngCanwgcUlBak;B½n§Edr. kñúgnaménkarRbqaMgtTl;nwg

BYksUevot eKcaM)ac;RtÚvkan;eCIgRbeTscin nigsm<½n§mitþExµrRkhmrbs;cinEdleKmincUlcitþesBKb;

dUcEdl Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI TUnµan[GnuvtþtamEdrb¤? b¤mYyenHCaTsSn³rbs; v:an;s_ nig hUlRb‘Úk dak;xøÜn[

q¶ayBI CemøaHmYyEdlBnøicb£sKl;TaMgGs;rbs;vaeTAkñúgRbvtþisa®sþCatiénbNþaRbeTsGñknaMGaT×?

ÉNaeTACaplRbeyaCn_rbs;shrdæGaemrikenAGasuI? kñúgkarbegáItrYmKñanUvTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUt

CamYyRbeTsevotNamnigRbeTscin? b¤kñúgkarbdiesFminebIkeFVIkarcrcaCamYyevotNam edIm,I

TTYl)anplRbeyaCn_BIRkúgeb:kaMg?. mhaGMNackumµúynIsþsMxan;bMputTaMgBIrenAGasuI)ancab;epþIm

eFVIkarTak;TgnwgshrdæGaemrikehIy. mhaGMNacTaMgBIr R)afñacg;edIrtYnaTIsMxan;mYyenAGasuIpg

Edr. enHCaeBlEdl hSImI xaF½r RtÚvseRmcBItYnaTIenHfa vanwgmanlkçN³EbbNa CakmøaMgeFVI[

mantulüPaB b¤Casm½<n§mitþrbs;PaKImYykñúgcMeNamPaKICemøaHTaMgGs;.

evotNamsuMBwgshrdæGaemrik

TMnak;TMngGaemrik-evotNam)ansÁal;nUvPaBesaHkeRkaHxøaMgEmnETnmYy kñúgry³eBldb;Ex

cugeRkay EdlmanmunkarCYbKñaCafµIenAqñaM1978. kñúg»kasénsm½yRbCuMcrcaelIkcugeRkayrvag

hUlRb‘Úk nig pan; ehon kalBIedImExFñÚ qñaM1977 evotNam)ane)aHbg;minykCMnYyEpñkesdækic©

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 307

Page 318: Brother enemy

rbs;GaemrikaMgeFVICaGaTiPaBkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeT. b:uEnþ ehon )anniyayTTUc edIm,I[

shrdæGaemrikeFVIkarsnüaCYyRbeTsevotNamedaymat;TeT bnÞab;BIkarbegáItTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUt

eLIgvij. karRbCuM)anTTYllT§plenATwkbegðIyedaybraC½ymYy.

BIrExeRkaymk RBwtþikarN_GaRkk;)anekItmanCafµICamYykarecaTRbkan;buKÁlikmñak;énTIPñak;gar

esuIbkarN_rbs;GaemrikaMgeQµaH r:UNal; h‘umRhVI nigGñksmKMnitsBa¢atiGaemrikaMg-evotNammñak;

rbs;Kat;eQµaH edvId eRTÓg fa )aneFVIcarkic©CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;RbeTsevotNam. eQµaHÉkGKÁ

rdæTUtevotNamenAGgÁkarshRbCaCati Dij )aFI Føab;RtÚvbeBa©j[dwgfaCaemKMnitmñak;kñúgcMeNam

emKMnitTaMgLayénRbtibtþikarenH. karBaredayGP½yÉksiT§ikarTUt Kat;)anRtÚvbeNþjecj.

tamkarBit erOgr:avcarkic©enHebIeRbóbeFobeTAminEmnCaerOgsMxan;eT. BitehIykñúgcMeNam

ÉksarEdleKlYcdk manÉksarxøHRtÚvcat;fñak;«sm¶at;»k¾BitEmn b:uEnþeTaHCay:agNak¾vamineFVI[

b:HBal;dl;snþisuxrbs;shrdæGaemrikEdr. ÉksarxøHeTot BuMmanbgðaj[eXIjlkçN³Gaf’kM)aMg

bnþicesaHeLIy. ]TahrN_ ÉksarmYykñúgcMeNamÉksarTaMgenaH)anraykarN_BIkarRbkan;CMhrd¾

Cak;lak;rbs;GñkkarTUt\NÐa nigyUehÁasøavI EdlbMeBjmuxgarenATIRkúghaNUy. ÉksarmYyeTot

manniyayBIesckþIsnñidæanrbs;KN³ebskkmµ vUdxUk eTAelIkarpSHpSaCamYyRbeTsevotNam

ehIyÉksarmYyeTot fVIt,itEtcat;fñak;fa «sm¶at;» KWmanerobrab;l¥itl¥n;EtBIeCIgehaHehIrén

ynþehaHEG‘rRhVg;enAeBlecjdMeNIr nigeBlmkdl;TIRkúg hUCImijkñúgry³eBlmYyExb:ueNÑaH.

niyayedayxøI Kµan«esñót»NamYyrbs;RkúmesuIbkarN_sm¶at;rbs;evotNam EdlGacKMramkMEhg

dl;snþisuxrbs;shrdæGaemrikaMgeLIy. b:uEnþ KWRtwmRtÚvNas; edaysarEtÉksarepSg²EdllYc

ykminmansarsMxan;eTIb eGhV>b‘Í>Gay (F.B.I.) minbþwgerOgenHeTAtulakar. BiesselIkElgEtkar

bþwgbþl;eTAtulakarBIerOgcarkic© enaHnwgminlatRtdagkarsm¶at;rbs;rdæ[eKdwgenAkEnøgsaFarN³.

mü:ageTot karRbjab;Rbjal;erobcM[Rbkasfa ÉkGKÁrdæTUtevotNamCaCnEdleKminKab;citþ

muxCaeFVI[Cnmñak;kñúgcMeNamCneRcInnak;PJak;ep¥Il CaBiessenARksYgkarbreTs. etIkarRbjab;

Rbjal;enH bgðaj[eXIjhak;dUcCabMNgeFVIkarsgswkmYydUcEdlevotNamGHGagEmnb¤eT?

r:UbWt GUklI CaGnuRbFanrbs; hUlRb‘Úk sRmab;kic©karGasuIGaeKñy_)anGHGagfa RkúghaNUymin

Edlyl;BIRbtikmµrbs;GaemrikaMgesaHeLIy. Kat;)anbEnßmfa «b:uEnþ c,ab;nigtfPaBénneya)ay

xagkñúgRbeTsrbs;eyIgmanGtßiPaBenAeLIy ehIyeyIgBuMmankareRCIserIseT»1.

erOgr:avenHnwgmins½kþismsresrkt;RtaTukenATMB½rxageRkam kñúgRbvtþisa®sþénkareFVIcarkmµ

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg308

Page 319: Brother enemy

rvagxagekItnigxagliceLIy ebIvaminb:HBal;dl;TMnak;TMngrvagGaemrikaMg-evotNamyUrGEgVgeT.

GUklI )ansmÁal;fa «cab;BIeBlenHeTA karrIkceRmInCabeNþaHGasnñTaMgGs;kñúgkarcrca)anRtÚv

bBaÄb;. Rkúgv:asuInetanenAminTan;yl;BIkarseRmccitþbeNþjGñktMNagevotNam EdlekIteLIg

cMeBlEdlRkúghaNUykMBugEtBinitüemIledayl¥itl¥n;nUvneya)aykarbreTsrbs;xøÜneLIy».

kñúg»kasénkarRbCuMrbs;xøÜnenAExmkra qñaM1978 kariyal½yneya)aybkSkumµúynIsþ

evotNam )anseRmceFVI[karCYbRbCuMCamYyRkúgv:asuIetanmansmÞúHCafµIsþIBIbBaðaénkareFVI[man

RbRktIPaB nigepþImclnaeFVIkarpSHpSamYyCamYyBiPBminEmnkumµúynIsþ eTaHCabg;xatCMnYyEpñkesdækic©

mYyrbs;GaemrikaMgk¾eday. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH kariyal½yneya)ayrbs;evotNamk¾)an

seRmccab;epþImeFVIkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbxageyaFaRbqaMgnwgRbeTscinnigRbeTskm<úCapgEdr2.

enHCakarlHbg;EdlnaM[QWcab;xagpøÚvcitþ. mundMbUg BIeRBaHRbeTsevotNamRtÚvkarR)ak;

xøaMgEmnETn. bnÞab;mk BIeRBaHkarlHbg;enHCakarTTYlsarPaBénbraC½yEpñkkarTUtmYy. fVIebI

TTYl)anC½yCmñHeyaFad¾sem,ImmYyk¾eday k¾RkúghaNUyminGaccab;bgçM[Gñkcaj;eFVIkarsgR)ak;

CYsCulkarxUcxatedaysars®gÁam CafñÚrnwgkarbegáItTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUteLIgvijEdr. b:uEnþ kar

ykcitþTukdak;dl;snþisuxrbs;RbeTs )anQñHelIkarykcitþTukdak;epSg²eTot. taMgBIcugqñaMmun

RBwtþikarN_epSg²)anelcTRmg;eLIgminCal¥eLIy. evotNamminGaceRKagKiteFVIkarttaMgTaMg

RbeTscinpg RbeTskm<úCapgenAkñúgeBlEtmYy edayKµankarbEnßmCMnYyxageyaFarbs;sUevot)an

eT. bMNgénPaBmincMNuHGñkdéTrbs;eKnwgRtÚvb:HBal;edaysarerOgenaHCak;Caminxan. karebIk

sßanTUtGaemrikmYyenATIRkúghaNUy nwgmanlkçN³CakmøaMgTb;mYycMeBaH\T§iBlrbs;sUevot.

mü:ageTot karebIksßanTUtenHnwgCameFüa)ayRbqaMgnwgkll,icepSg²rbs;cinsMedAÉekaRbeTs

evotNamxagkarTUtpg.

erOgGaRsUvénkarbeNþjÉkGKÁrdæTUtevotNamenAGgÁkarshRbCaCati)aneFVI[sñamrbYs

EdlBi)aksHCaQWcab;eLIgvij. TMnak;TMngeTVPaKI)ancab;epþIm«etaHetIy»CafµI. sm½yRbCuMelIkTI

bYnénkarcrcarvag rIqad hUlRb‘Úk nig pan; ehon EdleRKageFVIenAExkumÖ³nwgRtÚvlubecal.

RkúghaNUyerobcMkarcab;epþImTak;Tgmun

b:uEnþ RkúghaNUy ElgRbkan;CMhrkickukyUreTotehIy. dMeNIrrbs;Rb‘ÍhSInsÁIeTAkan;RbeTs

cinKWCaerOgEdlKYr[RBÜy)armÖ ehIyCagenHeTAeTot esckþIEføgkarN_rbs;Kat;EdlkMBugKaMRTRkúg

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 309

Page 320: Brother enemy

eb:kaMgRbqaMgnwg«GñkkarBarGnutþrPaBniymRbcaMtMbn;» EdlCakarniyaybBaäitbeBaäógeTArkRbeTs

evotNam k¾eFVI[evotNamnwk)armÖEdr. PaBtantwgCamYyRbeTscin)anekIneLIg RKb;KñakMBugerobcM

xøÜneFVIkarRbQmmuxKñaenAelIrNrgÁ¬TIcm,aMg¦rbs;km<úCa. kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRkúgv:asuInetan

KWCaerOgbnÞan;bMput. tamelak eRhVd eR)an (Fred Brown) m®nþIenARksYgkarbreTsfa «evotNam

manbMNgeFVI[manRbRktIPaBenAmunéf¶buNükargar[sUmbBa¢ak;fa enAshrdæGaemrik nigkaNada «Tiva

buNükargar»)anR)arB§eFVIenAéf¶c½nÞ TI1 énExkBaØa] b¤y:agyUrenAéf¶buNü«GrKuNRBHCam©as;»

[Thanksgiving day ³ CabuNüEdlR)arB§enAshrdæGaemrikenAéf¶RBhs,t×TI4 énExvicäika ¬kMNt;Gñk

bkERb¦]. eTaHbIy:agNak¾eday kñúgkarrg;caMkarCYbKñafµImYyCamYyBYkGaemrikaMg pan; ehon )an

RbkasCaBiessenAkñúgsnñisITkaEstmYyEdlRbRBwtþeTAenATIRkúgtUküÚnaExkkádafa RkúghaNUy

e)aHbg;minykbBaðaCMnYyGaemrikaMg mkeFVICaGaTiPaBkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeLIy ³ «enHCa\riya

bffµImYy edaytaMgcitþEbreq<aHeTArkGnaKt[EdlbeBa©[eXIj]BIxagevotNamvij». GMNwHteTA

GaemrikaMgnwgRtÚv)ansVaKmn_enARbeTsevotNam ebIsinCaBYkeKbgðaj[eXIjkarRbúgeRbób

epSg² RbkbedaymitþPaB nigsµartIshRbtibtþikarBitR)akdmYy. b:uEnþ ehon )anbBa¢ak;fa «ebI

sinBYkeKmkedayédTeT enaHkarTTYlsVaKmn_RKan;EtminsUvrak;Tak;b:ueNÑaH»3.

bnÞab;BIRkúgtUküÚ ehon )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;TIRkúgkg;Eb‘r:a-RbeTsGU®sþalI-eTot CaTIEdlKat;

GHGagbEnßmnUvesckþIRbkasBImunrbs;Kat; kñúgGMLúgénkarCYbsnÞnaCamYynaykrdæm®nþIGU®sþalI

m:al;xUm eRhVhS½r nigrdæm®nþIkarbreTs Gan;RDÚ PIxuk. elak PIxuk )anniyayR)ab;´fa «munkarmk

dl;rbs; ehon ´¬PIxuk¦)anCYbsnÞnatamTUrs½BÞcMnYnBIrdg ebIminG‘ÍcwgeTKWbIdgCamYy DIk ¬eQµaH

ehAeRkArbs; hUlRb‘Úk¦ GMBIbBaða\riyabffµIrbs;evotNam. ´)anrMB£kR)ab;Kat;Edr bnÞab;BIkar

snÞnarbs;eyIg. hUlRb‘Úk manlkçN³suTidæiniymNas;enAeBlbnÞab;mkeTot»4.

TIbMput enAeBlEdlevotNamseRmccitþRbkasBIdMNwgenHedaypÞal;enAExkkáda cMeBaHGñk

TTYlxusRtÚvGaemrikaMgmñak; esckþIrMePIbjab;j½rrbs; hUlRb‘Úk )anekIneLIgeTV. RkúghaNUy)an

bBa¢ÚnKN³RbtiPUmYyeTAkan;RkúghUNUlUlU CakareqøIytbnwgkarGeBa¢IjBImunmYyrbs;GaemrikaMg

[eTATsSnkic©enAmCÄmNÐlshRbtibtþikarekaslüvic½ysaksBGtItTahan)at;xøÜn (Joint Casualty

Resolution Center) nigbNþabec©kviC¢ad¾Gs©arürbs;mCÄmNÐlenH CaTIEdlGñkbec©keTsénviC¢asßan

ekaslüvic½y )anEksRmÜlbegðIynUvviFIsa®sþnanaEdlGnuBaØat[eKrkeXIjGtþsBaØaNbuKÁlmñak;

edaycab;epþImBIq¥wgmYyduMb¤sk;mYykBa©úMeTA. dUecñHshrdæGaemriksgÇwmbBa©úHbBa©Úl[evotNamEsVgrk

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg310

Page 321: Brother enemy

kgT½BGaemrikaMgEdl)at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§kan;EtskmµEfmeTot. karCYbKñamanlkçN³rak;Tak;nigmitþPaB

d¾kRmman. vUh½g Cam®nþImñak;rbs;rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam)ansEmþg[eXIjlkçN³rYsray

xøaMgNas; EdlenHKWCadMeNIrelIkdMbUgrbs;Kat;eTAkan;shrdæGaemrik. Kat;)anniyayR)ab;elak

RhVg; suIv½r enARksYgkarbreTsTTYlbnÞúkbBaðaTahanGaemrik)at;xøÜnCasm¶at;fa «´minEdledklk;

RsYldUecñHeTkñúgmYyCIvit´». bnÞab;BITsSnkic©enAmCÄmNÐlshRbtibtþikarekaslüvic½yGtIt

Tahan)at;xøÜn KN³RbtiPUTaMgBIr)anniyayBIshRbtibtþikarrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrmþg. edIm,IbBa©b; eRhVd

eR)an )annaM h½g eTAkEnøgciBa©wmstVTwk. enAeBlsmøwgemIlclnarbs;RtI dUhVaMgenaHehIyEdl h½g

beBa©j[dwgnUvBakümYyXøaedayes¶óms¶at;fa RbeTsevotNamnwgElgniyayBIkarpþl;CMnYymYy

rbs;GaemrikaMg eFVICaGaTiPaBkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeTotehIy. enATIbMput enHCakarRbkasd¾

c,as;las;nigKµan[mnÞilmYyEdlecjBIbbUrmat;rbs;evotNam. eR)an Edlsb,ayrIkrayxøaMg

)anedIrsMedAeTAkab‘ÍnTUrs½BÞmYyedIm,IehAeTA hUlRb‘Úk enATIRkúgv:asuInetan. hUlRb‘Úk )anEføgfa

enHCadMNwgd¾l¥edaybBa¢ak;fa Kat;Rbjab;cg;B¤BaküenHecjBImat;evotNampÞal;.

hUlRb‘Úk KµaneFVI[elcecjesckþITukcitþrbs;Kat; Edlrk)anmkvijbnþicesaHeT. BitehIy

enARksYgkarbreTs m®nþImñak;²rIkraykñúgcitþNas;BIlT§PaBmantMENgmYyenATIRkúghaNUy b:uEnþ

RksYgkarbreTsenAEtBuMTan;TTYldMNwgsþIBIkarpøas;bþÚrCMhrmYyrbs;evotNamtampøÚvkareT. tam

karBit KµankarCYbKñaNamYyRtÚveRKagTukkñúgtaragkalviPaKeLIy ehtudUcenHehIy)anCaRkúghaNUy

BuMmanehtuplNamYybBa¢ÚneTA[BYkGaemrikaMgnUvdMNwgCapøÚvkarmYyenaH. hUlRb‘Úk Edlcg;ecos

vagBIcMNab;GarmµN_rbs;saFarNCneTAelIRBwtþikarN_fµI² BuM)anbnþniyayBIsMeNIrbs;evotNam

edIm,IepþImkarsnÞnamYyQutfµIenATIRkúg):arIsnaExsIhapgeT. dUcEdleyIg)andwgmkehIyfa

Kat;cUlcitþCYbGnurdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNamCagkñúg»kasénkareTAcUlrYmRbCuMmhasnñi)atGgÁkar

shRbCaCatirbs;Kat;enAExkBaØa. tamTsSn³mYyEpñkkarTUt vamanRbeyaCn_CagEdlminRtÚvlat

RtdagBIkarcab;epþImkarcrcaeLIgvijCamYyRkúghaNUyenAeBlEdleRKaHfñak;éns®gÁammYyrvagcin-

evotNamelcRTg;RTayeLIgkan;Etc,as;enaH. cMENkevotNamvijyl;fa BuMmanplRbeyaCn_

NamYyEdlRtÚvbgðajedayCak;lak;xøaMgnUvsnøwkeborbs;eK munkarcab;epþImeLIgvijnUvkarRbCuM

BiPakSaCamYyBYkGaemrikaMgeLIy. dUecñH BYkeKrwtt,itedayxøÜnÉgnUvkarniyaybBaäitbeBaäógCa

saFarN³ nigkarbBa¢ak;bEnßmCaÉkCnkñúgry³eBlCaeRcInEx. kñúg»kassñak;GaRs½yrbs;Kat;enA

TIRkúghaNUyCamYyKN³RbtiPUmYyrbs;sPaCan;x<s; elak hSn PI> mWfa BitCasakl,geFVI[)an

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 311

Page 322: Brother enemy

TTYlkarbMPøWGVI²EdlminTan;c,as;[kan;Etc,as;EfmeTot. Kat;)ansYrTaMgKMeraHKMerIyfa RbeTs

evotNam BitCae)aHbg;GVI²EdlCaGaTiPaBrbs;xøÜnEmnb¤?. cemøIyrbs; ehon manlkçN³Bi)ak

yl;bnþic ³ «eyIg)anbgðajPaBTn;Pøn;ehIy». edayetOn[bBa¢ak; ehon )ancMGn; mWfa fa «eNðIy¡

erOgenHTuk[GñkcrcaniyayKñavij» nigTuk[ rIqad hUlRb‘Úk bMeBjkic©karrbs;Kat;cuH»5.

b:uEnþ edayminsb,aycitþBIkarelIkeBlkarCYbKñaCamYy hUlRb‘Úk evotNamBitCa sgÇwm

seRmc)ankic©RBmeRBógmYyenAExkBaØanaTIRkúgjÚvy:kminxan. TsSnkic©CabnþbnÞab;rbs;smaCik

sPaGaemrikaMgCaeRcInrUbkñúgGMLúgrdUvekþA )anbegáInkarrMePIbjab;j½rxøaMgEdlekInecjBIkarsnÞna

kñúgeBlfµI²EfmeTot. KN³RbtiPUsPaCan;x<s;EdldwknaMedayelak sunnI m:ughÁÚem:rI R)akdCaBuM

GeBa¢Ij paM v:an;dug nig pan; ehon [eFVIdMeNIrmkkan;shrdæGaemrikeTemIleTA?. CafñÚrmkvij

evotNamBuM)anRbKl;GidæFatuTahanGaemrik)at;xøÜndb;R)aMrUbmk[KN³RbtiPUeLIy.

enAeBlRtLb;mkdl;Rkúgv:asuIetanvij m:ughÁÚem:rI )ansuM[rdæaPi)albnþkarsnÞnaKñaCafµI kuMbg¥g;

yUr edIm,IbegáItTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUtnigBaNiC¢kmµTaMgRsugeLIgvijCamYyRbeTsevotNam. mWfa )an

GHGagbEnßmfa ³ «epþImkarcrcaeLIgvijb¤? b:uEnþ evotNamRKan;EtsYrBIerOgenHb:ueNÑaH» CaBiess

BIeRBaH«BYkeKxøacRbeTscin»6. smaCiksPamYyRkúmeTotEdlbBa¢ÚneTARkúghaNUytamkarepþIm

KMnitrbs;RBwT§smaCik eGdvWd ekNÑWDI enAeBlRtLb;mkvijk¾bgðajesckþIsnñidæandUcKñaEdr. r)ay

karN_GMBIebskkmµrbs;Kat;EdlEføgenAmuxKN³kmµkarnItikmµRBwT§sPa)ansnñidæany:agc,as;fa

«R)akdehIy eyIg)anQanmkdl;cMNucminGacRtLb;eRkaymYy. eyIgRtÚvEteFVIkarseRmccitþ

CaRbvtþisa®sþmYyGMBIerOgneya)aykarbreTs>>>. GMNwHteTA eyIgmanlT§PaBbMeBjedaysnþiviFI

nUvGVIEdleyIgFøab;xMRbwgeFVItaMgBIyUryarmkehIy edaykmøaMgeyaFaedIm,IkarBarplRbeyaCn_

rbs;GaemrikaMgenAkñúgPUmiPaKGasIuGaeKñy_ edaykarBarÉkraCüPaBrbs;evotNamBIkarRKbsgát;BI

xageRkATaMgGs;»7. GñkKUrrUbkMEbøgsܶtmñak;)ankt;smÁal;fa paM v:an;dug GacnwgbBa¢ak;eLIgvijBI

esckþIraykarN_ rbs;GtItrdæm®nþIkarbreTsGaemrik eDon rWs Edlfa «vtþmanrbs;Gaemrik [man

lkçN³]caM)ac;xanmin)ankñúgkarkarBarsnþiPaB nigsßirPaBenAGasuIGaeKñy_»8.

evotNam)antamXøaMemIlCamYykarRBÜy)armÖnUvkarEbreTAsñiT§cinrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI b:uEnþBYkeK

eCOfa Rkúgv:asuInetannwgminyl;RBmP¢ab;TMnak;TMngCamYycinvijeT BitehIyedaysar)armÖBIpl

RbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜnEdleKyl;dwg)an. enAeBlenaH vadl;eBlehIyEdlRtÚve)aHCMhaneTAmuxeTot

nigcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØamitþPaBmYyCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ. karFanaTaMgBIrenHTl;nwgkarekobsgát;nig

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg312

Page 323: Brother enemy

kll,icepSg²rbs;cin nigebIk»kas[evotNamepþImeFVIkarvaylukxageyaFamYyRbqaMgnwgrbb

rbs; b:ul Bt edayeBjédeBjeCIg. RkúghaNUyBuMdwgxøÜnfa ehtukarN_epSg²enARkúgv:asuInetan

)anERbRbÜlehIyeT. edaymin[mnusSRKb;KñadwgeRkAEtBIshkarICitsñiT§mYykþab;tUcrbs;elak

RbFanaFibtI EpnkarmYyRtÚv)anerobcMenAdMNac;Exmifuna. EpnkarenaH)aneRKageFVIkarbegáItTMnak;

TMngxagkarTUteBjeljeLIgvijCamYyRbeTscin enAmunExFñÚ qñaM19789.

kñúgGnusSrN³mYycuHkalbriecäTéf¶TI7 Exkkáda qñaM1977 Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anrMB£k xaF½r fa esckþI

seRmccitþsMxan;²EdlKat;Rbkan;yk KWTak;TgnwgRbeTscinBuMEmnRbeTsevotNameT. Kat;)an

beBa©jeyabl;fa «karceRmInlUtlas;énTMnak;TMngepSg²rvagRbeTseyIgTaMgBIr[shrdæGaemrik

nigRbeTscin] nwgeFVI[tulüPaBénkmøaMgTaMgGs;enAkñúgBiPBelakERbRbÜly:agdac;xat». b:uEnþfa

«karbegáItTMnak;TMngeLIgvijCamYyRbeTsevotNam )anRtwmEtraMgrakarrIklUtlas;enHb:ueNÑaH»10.

enAéf¶TI5 Exkkáda KWR)aMmYyéf¶muneBlEdl ehon pSBVpSayCasaFarN³BICMhrfµIrbs;evot

NamenATIRkúgtUküÚ karCYbRbCuMedIm,Icrcarvagcin-GaemrikaMgsþIBIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB)ancab;epþIm

enATIRkúgeb:kaMg. edayBnüarkarcrcaCamYyRkúghaNUy hUlRb‘Úk EdlKµanBiPal;BIerOgenH)an

GHGagnUvkarCYyeRCamERCgcMeBaHRbeTscin kúñgkarrt;RbNaMgEdlRbeTsenH)anepþImCamYy

RbeTsevotNam sRmab;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRkúgv:asuInetan. bc©½yEdlCaedImehtu

RbqaMgcin edayecjmuxxøaMgrbs;RbeTsevotNam KWc,as;Cabgá[mankarsÞak;esÞIrxøH²edayecos

minrYc ehIyEdleFVI[xøÜnxatbg;nUvesckþITukcitþ. pÞúymkvij Gaf’kM)aMgTaMgmUlEdlkMBugB½T§CuMvijkar

RbCuMedIm,Icrcarvagcin-GaemrikaMg )anRTRTg;karcrca[putBIkarriHKn;TaMgGs;.

karRtLb;mkvijrbs; etg

bnÞab;BIkarcab;epþImd¾huwkh‘ak;mYy TMnak;TMngrvagRbeTscinnigshrdæGaemrik)anRtÚvbBaÄb;kñúg

ry³eBly:agyUr. TsSnkic©Casm¶at;rbs; hg;rI KIsSIghÁ½r enATIRkúgeb:kaMgkalBIqñaM1971)an

ebIk[manTsSnkic©CaRbvtþisa®sþrbs;RbFanaFibtI nicsun enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1972. em:A Edlman

KMnitmémBIkarKMramrbs;sUevot )aneFVIGVI²TaMgGs;edIm,IsRmÜl[mankarxitcUlCitKñamYyrvagRbeTs

TaMgBIr edaydak;[GnuvtþnUvRTwsþI«rNsirSrYbrYm»d¾eqñImrbs;Kat; ³ «cgsm<n§PaBCamYysRtÚvrayrg

edIm,ItTl;nwgsRtÚvFM». enAedImqñaM1973 sßanebskkmµsRmab;TMnak;TMngKña)anebIkenATIRkúg

v:asuInetan nigRkúgeb:kaMg. b:uEnþ karepþImkarTak;TgEpñkesdækic©nigvb,Fm’enHBuM)ansßitesßryUreLIy

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 313

Page 324: Brother enemy

mü:agedaysarerOgGaRsUv Watergate [lubecjCaGKareRcInCan;mYyenATIRkúgv:asuInetan nigCa

TIsñak;karrbs;KNbkSRbCaFibetyü enAqñaM1972. enAéf¶TI17 Exmifuna bursR)aMnak;RtÚvb:Ulis

cab;xøÜn enAeBlkMBugerobcMbgáb;mIRkÚhVÚnenATIenaH. GñkkaEstbgðajfa mIRkÚhVÚnTaMgenaHKWsRmab;

RbFanaFibtIeRbIlYcsþab;karBiPakSaKñarbs;KNbkSRbCaFibetyü kñúgeBlEdlKat;QreQµaH

e)aHeqñatenAqñaM1972mþgeTot. edayRtÚveRCIstaMgCafµI RbFanaFibtI nicsun )anxMsakl,gedaH

xøÜnBIerOgenH bnÞab;mk)ansuMlaElgBImuxtMENgenAExsIha qñaM1974¬kMNt;GñkbkERb¦] nigmü:ag

eTot edaysarkarekIneLIgy:agxøaMgkñúgkarts‘UedIm,IGMNacenARbeTscinpg. Rkúgeb:kaMg)ansmÁal;

eXIjedayRkEsEPñky:agGaRkk;nUvkarRbwgERbgTaMgLay EdlsEmþg[eXIjedayrdæaPi)al

GaemrikaMg edIm,IeFVI[manPaBFUrRsalCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ. mü:ageTotBYkcin)anRtÚveFVI[xVl;xVaykñúgcitþ

BIkarRsUtrUtbnþic EdlRbFanaFibtI hV½rd_ sEmþg[dwgkñúgkarbnþneya)ayrbs;elak nicsun sMedA

lHbg;étv:an; edIm,IeFVI[TMnak;TMngepSg²CamYyRbeTscinmanRbRktIPaBeBjelj.

b:uEnþ enAedImqñaM1978 sßankarN_enARbeTscin)anERbRtLb;TaMgRsugCafµImþgeTotEdl

CaehtunaM[PaBcaM)ac;énkareFVIsm<n§PaBCamYyGaemrikaMgekItmanCafµI. taMgBIkarcab;xøÜn«bnbYnnak;»

enAcugqñaM1976 BYkemdwknaMRbtibtþiniymnigniympøÚvkNþalEdlRbmUlpþúMCuMvij etg s‘avBIg )an

cab;epþImpþl;nUvsarsMxan;dl;kareFVITMenIbkmµxagEpñkesdækic©. etg EdleFVI[mannItism,TaeLIgvij

enAExkkáda qñaM1977 )anRbkan;yksßanPaBxagpøÚvneya)ayPøamkñúgkarecaTCabT]RkidæTaMgRsug

GMBIkareFVIneya)ayrbs;BYkr:aDIkal;enAkñúgRbeTsk¾dUcenAeRkARbeTs. tam etg fa neya)aykar

breTsrbs;cinEdlEp¥kelIkarts‘UvNѳmanlkçN³twgruwgxøaMgeBk11.

Kat;)anrujtamrebobCak,ÜnnUv«kUnGuk»CaeRcInrbs;Kat;cUlkñúgbkS rdæaPi)al nigkgT½B ehIy

karFøak;cuHénTMnak;TMngCamYyshPaBsUevotnigRbeTsevotNam )anpþl;karGnueRKaHy:ageRcIn dl;

etg BIeRBaHvanaM[mankarxitcUlCitKñamYyCamYybs©imRbeTsedayecosminrYc. BitehIy b‘ÍkjÚ

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )aneFVI[seRmcnUvKMnitbegáItrNsirSrYbrYmmYyRbqaMgRkúgmUsÁÚnigsm½<n§mitþevot

Namrbs;eK. R)akdNas;ehIy bc©½yEdlCaedImehturbs;BYkGaemrikaMgnigBYkcinmanlkçN³epSg

BIKña ³ sRmab;TIRbwkSarbs; xaF½r sarsMxan;KWkarCRmúleTAmuxrbs;sUevotenATVIbGaRhVik EdlKat;)an

XøaMemIlCamYymenaseBa©tnarkeFVIGVIminekItlayLMeTAedaykMhwg ehIysRmab; etg vijyl;fa

GVIEdlsMxan;KWerOgrbs;evotNam. b:uEnþ erOgTaMgGs;enH vatRmg;eTArkeKaledAEtmYydUcKña.

mnusSTaMgBIrrUbenH manGVI²TaMgGs;EdlRtÚvKña ehIykarmanplRbeyaCn_rYmKñaenH )anraraMgshrdæ

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg314

Page 325: Brother enemy

Gaemrikmin[lem¥ógeTAxagNa)aneLIyrvagmhaGMNackumµúynIsþTaMgBIrEdlRbECgKñaenAGasuI.

eTaHbICaRbRktIPaBéCamYyRbeTscin nigRbeTsevotNam KWCaeKaledAmYykñúgcMeNam

eKaledACaGaTiPaBénneya)aykarbreTsfµIrbs;GaemrikaMgk¾eday k¾karrIklUtlas;minsUvmanGVIKYr

[cab;GarmµN_Edr bnÞab;BIkarcUlkan;GMNacmYyqñaMrbs; xaF½r. tamkarBit bBaðaBuMEmnekItmaneday

BitR)akdkñúgTIbMputdUcKñaeT. taMgBIdMbUg vabgðaj[eXIjkarTas;ETgKñaEfmeTotCamYyRbeTscin.

CamYyevotNam erOgr:avTaMgenaH ebIeRbóbeFobKñaeTAKWmanlkçN³gayRsYlCag ³ evotNamRKan;Et

yl;RBmshkarkñúgkarEsVgrkTahanGaemrik)at;xøÜnnige)aHbg;CamunnUvkarTamTarsMNgxUcxateday

sars®gÁamb:ueNÑaH. pÞúyeTAvij karERbkøaysßanebskkmµTMnak;TMngEdltaMgenARkúgeb:kaMg nigRkúg

v:asuInetaneTACasßanTUteBjlkçN³)antRmÚv[BYkGaemrikaMgeFVIsm,TanCacaM)ac;. dUecñH BYkcin)an

bdiesFminsnüae)aHCMhaneTAmuxeToteT kñúgpøÚvénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeLIgvij drabNashrdæ

GaemrikBuMTan;kat;pþac;TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜnCamYyétv:an; nigrMlaysn§isBaØapþl;CMnYyEpñkeyaFa

EdlcgP¢ab;RbeTsTaMgBIreTenaH. enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1977 RbFankariyal½yTMnak;TMngrbs;cinenATIRkúg

v:asuInetanKW ]tþmesnIy_ h½g hSin )anRcanecalTaMgKMeraHKMerIynUvsMeNIrbs;GaemrikaMgEdlsuM[

mandMeNIrmYymkkan;shrdæGaemrikrbs;emdwknaMCan;x<s;cinmñak;. CadMbUg Kat;)anTamTar[shrdæ

GaemrikbiTsßanTUtrbs;étv:an;sin. elak xaF½r )anxwgRceLat. kñúgsarNarbs;Kat; GtItRbFana

FibtIrUbenH)ankt;Rtafa «RbeTscinRbEhlCaenAEtcat;xøÜnÉgCaGaNacRkkNþalEdlsgÇwmfa

PaKesssl;énBiPBelakmuxCaTTYlsÁal;PaBRtwmRtÚvénCMhrepSg²CaeKalkarN_rbs;xøÜnehIy

emIleTA»12.

RksYgkarbreTsTl;nwgRkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati

GVI²)anbgá[mankarElgGt;RTaMteTAeTot b:uEnþ elak xaF½r nwgRtÚvvaytémøBI«bBaðaCaeKal

karN_»TaMgenaH. enAedImrdUvekþAqñaM1977 xaF½r )anseRmccitþbMeBjtamkarTamTarrbs;Rkúg

eb:kaMgeRkamlkçxNÐfa shrdæGaemrikGacrkSaTMnak;TMngeRkApøÚvkarrbs;xøÜnCamYyétv:an;teTAeTot

ehIyfashrdæGaemrik)aneFVI[seRmcnUvkarFanakñúgkaredaHRsayRbkbedaysnþiviFImYynUv

CemøaHrvagRbeTscinTaMgBIr. eKaledArbs;Kat;KWCMrujRkúgeb:kaMg[ykcitþTukdak;kan;EtekIneLIg

CalMdab;BIkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;GaemrikaMg. enAExsIha KWmYyExbnÞab;BIkarEtgtaMgeLGUNard_ vUdxUk

[eFVICaRbFankariyal½yTMnak;TMngrbs;GaemrikaMg elak suIrus v:an;s_ )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;RbeTscin

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 315

Page 326: Brother enemy

edIm,IbM)at;karExVgKMnitKñaxøH². Kat;)anesñITTYlsÁal;saFarNrdæRbCamanitcinfa CardæaPi)alRsb

c,ab;EtmYyKt; ehIyminbnþsn§isBaØapþl;CMnYyEpñkeyaFaCamYyétv:an;eLIgvijeLIy. b:uEnþ v:an;s_

)anR)ab;rdæm®nþIkarbreTscin hYghY [dwgfa Kat;cg;)ankaryl;RBmrebobsm¶at;BIRbeTscinpgEdr

edIm,Inwg[buKÁlikkarTUtrbs;GaemrikaMgsßitenAétv:an; 13.

hV½rd_ nig KIsSIghÁ½r RbEhlCaeTAq¶ayCagenH. sMeNIrbs; v:an;s_ )anedA[eXIjdMeNIr

fyeRkaymYy eRBaHvabnþEp¥kelIGaTiPaBénRbeTscinBIrnigenAEtrkSaRkúmGñktMNagkarTUtmYyenA

étv:an; EdlKat;minh‘anniyayBIeQµaHrbs;vaeLIy. b:uEnþ BYkcinBuMRcanecalsMeNIenHPøam²eT.

TnÞwmnwgenaH v:an;s_ )anbnøúyBaküy:agc,as;fa CMhrrbs;GaemrikaMgGacvivtþEfmeTot b:uEnþBuMTan;

sEmþg[eXIjenAeBl\LÚvenHeT. edayehtufa BYkcinRtÚvkarkarBnüareBlmYymunnwgedaHRsay

kareFVI[manRbRktIPaB dUecñHminRtÚvRbjab;Rbjal;eBkeT. enAEtRbB½n§pSBVpSayb:ueNÑaHEdlman

skmµPaB. Rkúgeb:kaMgmincg;[karCYbKñaenHTTYlbraC½yeLIy. tamelak vIløIyuaM køIsFIn Gñk

ÉkeTsd¾l,Il,ajxagbBaðacinenARksYgkarbreTs)an[dwgfa BYkemdwknaMcin)anepþatkarykcitþ

Tukdak;bMput cMeBaHkartak;EtgesckþIEføgkarN_bBa©b;sRmab;GñksarB½t’man. B½t’manmYyEdlecjBI

Rkúgv:asuInetan)anmkbMpøajGVI²[xUckarmunkMNt;eBlTaMgGs;. B½t’manenHbBa¢ak;fa Gñkcrcacin

)anbgðaj[eXIjlkçN³minrwgrUseRcInCagkarEdleRKagTuk. etg EdlxwgRceLatetattUg)aneFVI

RbtikmµedaysmþIKMeraHKMerIy. Kat;)anRbkasR)ab;niBn§naykkaEstGaemrikaMgmYyRkúmfa ebsk-

kmµrbs; v:an;s_ )anTTYllT§plRtwmEteFVI[mankarxVHPaBkk;ekþAmYykñúgTMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMg

b:ueNÑaH. ]bTÞvehtuenHEdlxusEbøkxøaMgBIFmµta )ankMNt;nUvkarbBaÄb;mYykñúgdMeNIrlUtlas;én

kareFVI[manRbRktIPaB. rwtEtF¶n;F¶rCagenHeTAeTotenaHKWedImdMbUgRbEhlbNþalBICemøaHF¶n;F¶r

mYyrvag b‘ÍkjÚ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI nigRksYgkarbreTssþIBI\riyabfEdlRtÚvRbkan;ykcMeBaHRbeTscin

EdlnwgmanplRbtiXatd¾FMeFgenAGasuIehIyemIleTA.

etIkarelcFøayerOgenHecjmkBIRbPBNa mUlehtumkBIkMhwgrbs; etg s‘avBIg? b:uEnþ

suIrus v:an;s_ EdlEtgEtRby½tñRbEygnigKYrsm minrYjranwgvinicä½ykñúgerOgenHfa Cakarb:unb:g

bMpøajneya)ayrbs;Kat;edayectna ehIyBuMEmnedayKµankarrMCYlcitþeTEdlKat;)anrMB£kcMeBaH

mux´nUv«dMeNIrmin)anseRmcpl» rbs;Kat;enARbeTscinfa «eyIg)anCYbeFVIkarsnÞnaRbkbeday

EpøpáaxøaMgNas; b:uEnþCaGkusl Rsab;EtmnusSsMxan;mñak;)anpSBVpSayerOgenH[dwgCasaFarN³-

mnusS sMxan;mñak;kñúgcMeNamCaeRcInnak;enAestviman. ´manvibtþipøÚvcitþBIbBaðaenH. karRbkYtCamYy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg316

Page 327: Brother enemy

etg s‘avBIg )anRtÚvrwtbnþwgnigTamTar[mankarecHlak;Gaf’kM)aMgbMput elIkElgEtvaminbraC½yTaMg

Rsug. ehIyerOg)anekItmaneLIg»14. enAcMeBaHmux´ Rb‘IhSInsÁI )anbdiesFedayCak;lak; BIkar

TTYlxusRtÚvTaMgGs;rbs;RkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCatikñúgerOgr:avenH. tamKat;[dwgfa BYkcin)aneFVI

RbtikmµCaGviC¢mancMeBaHsMeNIepSg²rbs; v:an;s_ BIeRBaHfa «BYkeKBuMTan;)anRbúgeRbóbxøÜn nig

yl;fa dMeNIrénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBelOnCagcMNg;rbs;eKxøaMgeBk ehIyfashrdæGaemrikxVH

PaBmuWgm:at;cMeBaHsUevotpg»15.

tamkarBit karelcFøayerOgsm¶at;RbEhlBuMGacbkRsayBIPaBKMeraHKMerIyénRbtikmµrbs;

etg s‘avBIg Etmçag)aneT. eKGacsnñidæanfa BYkcinyl;fa Rkúgv:asuInetanpþl;sarsMxan;dl;kar

bn§ÚrbnßyPaBtantwgCamYyshPaBsUevot nigkarbBa©b;kic©RBmeRBógmYysþIBIkarkRmitkMNt;kar

rt;RbNaMgxagsBVavuF CagkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBxagkarTUtCamYyRbeTscin. enAkñúgRbeTs etg

BuMmanesrIPaBRKb;RKan;edIm,Icat;kareT ehIykareFVI[mannItism,Tavijrbs;Kat;manlkçN³enAfµI²

Nas;. Kat;RtÚvEtrYbrYmCamYyBYkem:AniymbrisuT§nigRbkan;twg CaBiessRbFanbkShVaKUehVg.

dUecñH Kat;GacnwgRtÚvCMruj[pþl;nUvskçIPaBénkarrwgrUs nigkarRsLaj;CatimatuPUmirbs;Kat;sþIBIbBaða

étv:an; edIm,ItRmÚvcitþBYkniymeqVgsin.

cab;BIcugqñaM1977 Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anbegáInkarekobsgát;rbs;Kat;rwtEtxøaMg. tamKat;yl;kar

eFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscin )anbgáCameFüa)ayRbqaMgnwglT§ivatTIniymrbs;sUevotenA

GaRhVikCageBlNa²TaMgGs;. RsbKñaenaH Kat;)anRbwgERbgCMTas;nwgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBEpñk

karTUtCamYyRbeTsevotNam Edlb:gR)afñay:agxøaMgeday v:an;s_ nig hUlRb‘Úk pgEdr. sRmab;

Kat;bBaðaenHman«sarsMxan;bnÞab;bnSM»b:ueNÑaH16. Kat;)anbMPøWR)ab; xaF½r enABak;kNþalExvicäikafa

ebIsinCasaFarNmtisgS½yBIPaBmuWgm:at;énneya)aykarbreTsrbs;shrdæGaemrikKWCasMxan;

bNþalmkBIbBaðaRbeTsKuy)a evotNam karcrcasþIBIkarkRmit GavuFyuT§sa®sþ (S.A.L.T. GkSr

eBj Strategic Arms Limitation Talks) nigRbeTskUer:enHÉg17.

etIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscin manlkçN³rMxandl;karcrcasþIBIkarkRmitGavuF

yuT§sa®sþEmnb¤?. edaypÞúyBI v:an;s_/ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI mineCOdUecñaHeT. Kat;yl;eXIjfa ehtuGVI)an

CashrdæGaemrikRtÚvEteyaKyl;dl;PaBqab;Rbkan;rbs;RkúgmUsÁÚ enAeBlEdlkarcrcaEdlkMBug

RbRBwtþeTA BuMCMruj[BYksUevotbnßyKMnitvatTId¾xøaMgkøarbs;BYkeKBImçageTAmçagBiPBelakenaH?. kic©

shkarrvagcin-GaemrikaMg EdlepþImKMniteLIgedayrUbKat; KWCa«kartbvijPøam²CayuT§sa®sþ»mYy

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 317

Page 328: Brother enemy

edIm,IbgçM[BYksUevotQb;«eRbIR)as;PaBFUrRsalCameFüa)ayeFVI[bNþaTItaMgEpñkPUmisa®sþ-neya

)aynigyuT§sa®sþrbs;BYkeK» enAmCÄimbUBa’nigkñúgtMbn;ragEsñgRkbIén TVIbGaRhVikrwtEtviesseLIg.

KMniteRbIR)as;«snøwkebocin»)ancab;epþImbeBa©j[eKdwgB¤ehIy.

tamry³elak mIEsðl GUesnbWk elak Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )an[Rkúgeb:kaMgdwgfa Kat;RbúgeRbóbxøÜn

CaeRscnwgeFVIdMeNIreTARbeTscin ebIeTaHCaeKGeBa¢Ijcugmat;cug-kk¾eday. GUesnbWk )anbBa¢ak;

fa BYkcinnwgseRmccitþ «RbfuyeRbIkarRbECgKñarvagbuKÁlikénRkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati nigbuKÁlik

RksYgkarbreTs EdlBYkeKRtÚv)anR)ab;[dwgBIerOgenHedayelak hg;rI KIsSIúghÁ½r» ehIyfa BYkeK

«nwgEbreTABYkemdwknaMGaemrikaMgNaEdlmanTsSn³CayuT§sa®sþRsbeTAtamTsSn³rbs;BYkeK»18.

enAedImExvicäika Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anTTYlkarGeBa¢IjmYy[eTAkan;RbeTscin. PøamenaH v:an;s_

)anxMRbwgBnül;elak xaF½r [RbqaMgnwgkareFVIdMeNIrenH EdlmuxCanwgraraMgdl;karcrcaEdlepþImeFVI

edayRksYgkarbreTsminxan. PaBtantwgrvagmnusSTaMgBIrEdlminbgðajlkçN³mkeRkA )anpÞúH

eLIgCacMh. b:uEnþ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI maneRbóbCagmYyKWmuxtMENgrbs;Kat; )aneFVI[Kat;enAekokkitnwg

elakRbFanaFibtICanic©. Kat;ecHeqøót»kasedIm,IGHGagBIbuBVehturbs;Kat; Edlrdæm®nþIkarBar

RbeTs har:UleR)an k¾KaMRTKat;Edr. TIbMput enABak;kNþalExmIna xaF½r )aneTarTn;eTArk Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI

ehIyminrvl;nwgkar[eyabl;pÞúyrbs; v:an;s_ eLIy.

karseRmcrbs;RbFanaFibtIKWpÞúkeTAedayplvi)akCaeRcIn. karseRmcenH)anGnuBaØat[

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI begáIt[manCamYyRkúgeb:kaMgnUvkarsnÞnaBIyuT§sa®sþrYmmYy ehIykñúgTsSn³enHRtÚv

CMrujkareFVI[RbRktIPaBénTMnak;TMngcin-Gaemrikkan;EteCOneTAmuxeTot. b:uEnþ hYsGMBIenaH varYmbgá

CakarminTTYlsÁal;mYycMeBaHneya)aytulüPaBEdlbnþeFVIeday v:an;s_ pgEdr. t,itGI v:an;s_

minTan;manbMNgkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB -EdlKat;KWCaGñkesñIdMbUgmñak;kñúgcMeNamGñkesñIdMbUg²-

CamYyRbeTscineT munnwgRtÚvbBa©ÚleTAkñúgyuT§sa®sþRbqaMgsUevotrYmKñamYy. pÞúyeTAvij tam

Kat;yl;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBenHKWCaerOgEdlminGacbMEbkecjBIkarcrcad¾l¥itl¥n;sþIBIkarkRmit

GavuFyuT§sa®sþEdlkMBugRbRBwtþeTAeLIy. enAéf¶TI10 Ex]sPa qñaM1978 Kat;)anBüayamesñIeTA

kan;RbFanaFibtIfa kic©karTaMgBIrRtÚvdwknaMeFVI[)anl¥RbesIrenAmundMNac;qñaM. kareFVI[manRbRktI

PaBCamYyRbeTscin BitCanwgCYysRmÜldl;kar[sc©ab½nelIkic©RBmeRBógsþIBIkarkRmitGavuF

yuT§sa®sþ edayCMruj[sPaCan;TabeFVIGVImYyCaRbeyaCn_dl;rdæaPi)alpg. v:an;s_ )ankt;Rtakñúg

stirbs;Kat;fa «´EtgEtmanKMnitniyayRKb;eBlBI«karelgsnøwkebocin»fa vaCayuT§viFIRbkb

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg318

Page 329: Brother enemy

edayeRKaHfñak;Nas; ehIyelIsBIenHeTot enAeBlEdleCaKC½y b¤braC½yénkarcrcasþIBIkarkRmit

GavuFyuT§sa®sþmindwgCay:agNapgenaH»19.

b:uEnþedaymin[ v:an;s_ dwg Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anepþImeFVIkarvaylukTak;TajmYyeTAkan;BYkemdwknaM

cin. cab;BIExkumÖ³ qñaM1978 Kat;)anCYbsnÞnaCasm¶at;CamYy hans‘U RbFankariyal½yTMnak;

TMngsþITIrbs;cinenATIRkúgv:asuInetan EdlenAkñúgeBlenaH Kat;man»kaslatRtdagBICMhrepSg²

Tak;TgnwgshPaBsUevotEfmeTotEdlxusKñay:agxøaMgBICMhrrbs; v:an;s_ 20.

munnwgeLIgynþehaHeTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMg Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anTTYlkarpþaMepJIBI xaF½r faKat;)ancuH

htßelxaxageRkammtiENnaMmYyEdltak;EtgedayxøÜnKat;pÞal; CamYynwgkarCYyrbs; GUesnbWk

nigEdlkMNt;BICMhrGaemrikaMgedayCak;c,as;. mtiENnaMenH enATIbMputnwgeFVI[CemøaHrvagcinnig

evotNammanlkçN³CaGnþrCati ehIyCMruj[shrdæGaemrikxiteTAxagRkúgeb:kaMgkan;Etekok.

TMnak;TMngepSg²CamYyRbeTscin)anrYmbgáCa «lkçN³sMxan;mYyénneya)ayBiPBelakrbs;

shrdæGaemrik». RbeTsTaMgBIrmankgVl;xagEpñkyuT§sa®sþkñúgry³eBlEvgdUcKña ehIyCabzm

KW«karCMTas;rYmKñacMeBaHKMnitbegáItGnutþrPaBTaMgGs; TaMgkñúgBiPBelakb¤kñúgtMbn;». n½yd¾FMKWeKGac

emIlFøúH ³ Rkúgv:asuInetankan;eCIgRbeTscinRbqaMgshPaBsUevot nigRbeTsevotNamEdlRkúg

eb:kaMgecaTRbkan;CaerOy²fa manbMNgtRmÚv[eFVItam«GnutþrPaBRbcaMtMbn;»rbs;xøÜn. mü:ageTot

shrdæGaemrik)anRbkas[dwgBIkarRbqaMgrbs;xøÜn cMeBaHKeRmagkarrbs;sUevotEdl«eRbIR)as;

RbeTsevotNam¬ehIyRbEhlCaéf¶NamYyétv:an;Edr¦ edIm,Ih‘umB½T§RbeTscin»21.

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI enAelI«mhakMEBgcin»

BIrs)aþh_eRkayeBlEdlRkúgeb:kaMgR)ab;[dwgCasaFarN³BIkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;xøÜnTak;TgeTA

nwgkarcakecalRsukTaMghVÚg²rbs;CnCaticinBIRbeTsevotNam enAéf¶TI19 Ex]sPa Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI

rYmCamYyGñkTTYlxusRtÚvmYycMnYntUcénRkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati RksYgkarbreTsnigmnÞIrbBa©ekaN

)aneLIgynþehaHeFVIdMeNIreTAkan;RbeTscintamynþehaHbUGuIg707mYyeRKÓgénkgGakascrshrdæ

Gaemrik. TsSnkic©nwgERbeTACaTsSnkic©rbs;TIRbwkSasnþisuxEtmñak;Égvij dUcEdl hUlRb‘Úk bgðaj

[dwgBIerOgenHPøamfa Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI manbMNgbdiesFkarsnÞnakRmitx<s;enATIRkúgeb:kaMg. eRkABIKat;

GnuRbFanrbs; suIrus v:an;s_ )ansakl,geRbIlkl,icTaMgGs;sgÇwmmYy edIm,I[eKraykarN_BIkar

seRmccitþenH. Kat;)anvayTUrelxeTA vUdxUk enAkariyal½yTMnak;TMngrbs;GaemrikaMgRbcaMrdæFanI

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 319

Page 330: Brother enemy

cin [Rbjab;Rbjal;eTAkan;TIRkúgtUküÚCaTIEdlRkúmrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI RtÚvcuHct¬edIm,Icak;saMg¦

24em:ageRkay. edayRtÚveFVI[RsLaMgkaMg GñkkarTUtGaemrikaMg)aneCOkñúgry³mYyEPøtenaH BIkar

pøas;bþÚrTisneya)aymYyenAnaTIcugeRkay. minyUrb:unµanBYkeKyl;fa enHRKan;EtCavKÁcugeRkay

énCemøaHrvag v:an;s_ nig Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI b:ueNÑaH. hUlRb‘Úk manbMNgcg;[ vUdxUk CYysuMeTasRbFana

FibtI xaF½r kñúgnamrUbKat; edIm,I[Kat;TTYl)ankarGnuBaØateTAcUlrYmkarRbCuMedIm,Icrcapg. vUdxUk )an

bdiesFedayKYrsmfa Kat;mineFVIGnþraKmn_kñúgerOgenHeT. GarmµN_rbs; hUlRb‘Úk )anERbeTACa

mYem:AxøaMgNas;. tamsakSIGaemrikaMgmñak;fa karsñak;GaRs½yrbs;Kat;enATIRkúgeb:kaMg RKan;EtCakar

g:k;grmYyb:ueNÑaH. eRkaymkshkarImñak;rbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )ansnµtfakarbdiesFenHCa«kgVHxat

karRBmeRBógKñarvagmnusSTaMgBIr». cMENkÉ vIløIyuaM køIsFIn EdlCaGñkrgeRKaHpÞal;BIkarkat;kal;

Elgrab;rkenH cUlcitþbkRsayerOgenHfa Cakarbgðaj[eXIjPaBRcENnxagviC¢aCIv³Cag.

hUlRb‘Úk nig Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )ancMNaykmøaMgrbs;xøÜn edayminKitGVITaMgGs;enAkñúgry³eBlénkar

eXasnae)aHeqñatrbs;elak xaF½r EdlBYkeK)anpþl;CakmøaMgy:agxøaMgkñúgcMeNamGñkÉeTot²

dl;RkúmGñkCMnajkarxagneya)aykarbreTs. GñkTaMgBIrmaneKaledAy:agx<s; b:uEnþenATIbMput

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anmaneRbóbCag. b:uEnþ hUlRb‘Úk )anmansiT§icUleFVIkarenAestviman nigminrYjra

eqøótykRbeyaCn_GMBImuxtMENgKat;eLIy ehIyKURbECgrbs;Kat;enAEtcgKMnuMnwgKat;Canic©.

dUcEdl køIFIn GHGagBIerOgenHfa Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )ancat;Tuk hUlRb‘Úk Ca«GñkmanfµImñak;EdleBareBj

edayGMnYt» ehIyKat;mincg;EckrMElkeCaKC½yéndMeNIreTARkúgeb:kaMgrbs;Kat;CamYy hUlRb‘Úk eLIy.

eTaHCay:agNak¾eday BYkcinTMngCabnþbkRsay]bTÞvehtuenHfa CasBaØaénkarminTukcitþmYy

RbqaMgnwgshkarImñak;rbs; v:an;s_ ehIyBYkeK)aneqøótTajykplRbeyaCn_BIkareRbHqa Edlelc

eLIg[eXIjBIkñúgrdæaPi)al xaF½r RBmKñaTaMgpÞal;xøÜnpg TaMgxagmenaKmviC¢apg.

karKitKUrrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI KWfa Kat;RtÚvEtBnül;BYkcin[eCOBitR)akdBIkarseRmccitþRbqaMg

sUevotrbs;rdæaPi)al xaF½r edIm,IbnÞn;citþBYkeKsþIGMBIbBaðaTMnak;TMngeRkApøÚvkarrvagshrdæGaemrik

nigétv:an;. ehIyebIsinCaBYkeKenAEttwgEtgGMBIcMNucenH eKGacsgÇwmfa TsSnvis½yénsh

RbtibtþikarmYyxagvis½ykarBarCati nwgnaMBYkeKeTArkkarxitcUlCitKñamYyCamYyshrdæGaemrik

edaymanb¤KµankarbegáItTMnak;TMngEpñkkarTUt. Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anCRmab etg s‘avBIg fa shrdæGaemrik

TTYlyl;RBmtamlkçxNÐepSg²rbs;cin sþIBIkarkat;pþac;TMnak;TMngCapøÚvkarCamYyétv:an; Cakar

eRCIserIsrvaglT§PaBBIrEdlenAExsIha qñaM1977 v:an;s_ Føab;karBarenAcMeBaHmuxKat;. Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg320

Page 331: Brother enemy

bBa¢ak;fa karseRmccitþKWecjGMBIRbFanaFibtI xaF½r. edIm,Ibgðaj[eXIjBIbMNgCak;lak;rbs;

GaemrikaMg Kat;)annaMeTACamYyKat;nUv«CMnUn»y:ageRcIn EdlsRmab;eFVI[mankarKab;GarmµN_xøaMg.

samuyEGl han;FIgfun smaCikRkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati nigCaGtItshkarIénrdæaPi)al

RbFanaFibtI hSnsun EdlCaGñkÉkeTsxagkarRbyuT§RbqaMgkarbHe)arenARbeTsevotNam RtÚv

)anRbKl;Parkic©[bBa¢ÚneTA[BYkcinnUv«GnusSrN³rbs;RbFanaFibtIelx10» CaÉksarsm¶at;

bMputpÞúkeTAedaykarviPaKmYysþIBIsßankarN_BiPBelak EdlRbemIlemIlsßanPaBkmøaMgeyaFarbs;

sUevot. kic©karenHsMedAjúaMg[RbeTscineCOfa Rkúgv:asuInetan)ancat;TukcinCasm<n§miRtmin

lMeGogmYy CaPaKIEdlBak;B½n§edaypÞal;kñúgkarrYmkmøaMgKñaeRkApøÚvkarmYyedIm,IRbqaMgRkúgmUsÁÚ.

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anRbkas[dwgfa bTbBa¢aTaMgLayrbs;GaemrikaMgTak;Tgnwgkarlk;eTA[RbeTscinnUv

bec©kviC¢aeyaFanwgRtÚvsRmbsRmÜlKña. mü:ageTot GMNwHteTAbNþaRbeTssm<n§miRtrbs;Gaemrik

nwgmanesrIPaBlk;GavuFeTA[Rkúgeb:kaMgtambMNg. edIm,IbEnßmTm¶n;eTAelIkarseRmcpÞal;xøÜnrbs;

Kat; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )andak;GñkÉkeTsxagbBaðaenHBIrrUbenAGmCab;Kat;KWelak ebnhSamIn G‘uybWm:an;

TIRbwkSaTIsþIkarRbFanaFibtITTYlbnÞúkEpñkviTüasa®sþnigbec©kviC¢anigelak m½rtun GaR)am:UvIt Gnurdæ

elxaFikarenARksYgkarBarRbeTsTTYlbnÞúkbBaðaepSg²Tak;TgnwgsnþisuxGnþrCati.

GaR)am:UvIt EdlecHniyayPasacin )anRtÚvRbKl;Parkic©CaBiessedaymnÞIrbBa©ekaN[eFVI

karGegátdMbUg²sþIBIkarbBa©ÚlCayuT§sa®sþnUvkareFVIshRbtibtþikarxageyaFaCayfaehtumYy

CamYyRbeTscin22. Kat;Cam®nþIénRksYgkarBarRbeTsGaemrikaMgTImYyEdleFVIdMeNIreTAkan;RbeTs

cin ehIyKat;)aneqøót»kasenaH edIm,ICYbsmPaKIcinmñak;edays¶at;kM)aMgkñúgcMeNamsmPaKIcin

rbs;Kat;. tamkarGHGagrbs;sakSImñak;Edl)ancUlrYmkñúgkarsnÞnaKñafa «enaHKWCakarniyaymñak;

Égd¾yUrmYy. kñúgry³eBlCagmYyem:ag GaR)am:UvIt )anpþl;dMNwgdl;bNþaKUsnÞnarbs;Kat;nUv

B½t’manepSg²Edlsm¶at;bMputsþIBIkardak;BRgaykgT½Brbs;sUevotenAtambeNþayRBMEdncin». enH

RbEhlCaelIkdMbUgehIyEdlRbeTsTaMgBIrshkarKñakRmitx<s;bMput kñúgvis½yB½t’man¬sm¶at;¦.

CaBiess GaR)am:UvIt )anR)ab;BYkcin[dwgnUvB½t’manepSg²sþIBIGavuFyuT§sa®sþrbs;sUevotEfm

eTot. Kat;)andkecjBIkabUbyYrrbs;Kat;nUvrUbftCaeRcInsnøwkEdlftBIGakasKW zbnP½NÐeyaFa

nigkgrfeRkaHEdlRbmUlpþúMKñay:ageRcInenARBMEdnrbs;cinEdleFVI[KUsnÞnarbs;Kat;PJak;ep¥Ilpgnig

rIkraypg. cMENkelak ebnhSamIn G‘uybWm:an; )anCYbeFVIkarsnÞnadac;edayELkCamYyBYkcin

Tak;TgeTAnwgshRbtibtþikarCayfaehtumYyrvagcin nigGaemrikaMgxagvis½yviTüasa®sþ nigbec©kviC¢a

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 321

Page 332: Brother enemy

ehIyCaBiesskñúgvis½yénkarRbmUlB½t’mantamRbB½n§eGLicRtÚnikGMBIshPaBsUevot. karCECk

BiPakSaTMngCaRbkbedayEpøpáa eRBaHmYyqñaMeRkaymkva)anseRmcplnaM[mankartaMgsßanIy

lYcsþab;mYyrbs;GaemrikaMgenAelIEdndIcinsRmab;tamXøaMemIlkarsakl,gGavuFmIsuIlrbs;BYk

sUevot23.

b:uEnþ edayRby½tñy:agxøaMgsþIBIshRbtibtþikarCamYyRbeTscinxagvis½ykarBar v:an;s_ pÞal;

BuM)anCMTas;nwgKeRmagbegáItsßanIylYcsþab;eLIy. enHCameFüa)ayd¾RbesIredIm,IBinitüemIl

karGnuvtþn_kic©RBmeRBógkat;bnßyGavuFyuT§sa®sþrbs;BYksUevot ehIysPaCan;TabmuxCanwgRtÚveFVI

[cab;GarmµN_BIerOgenHkñúgeBlpþl;sc©anum½tminxan.

karbgðajedImehtuTaMgLayrbs; Rb‘IhSInsÁI manlkçN³xusKñaTaMgRsug. smaCikmñak;énRkúm

rbs;Kat;)anniyay[dwgfa «b‘Ik xMRbwgykcitþykeføImBYkcin edays‘kesotsmþIfa B½t’manepSg²

EdleyIgeTIbnwgpþl;[ GacRKan;EtCakarPøk;[dwgCamunmYyb:ueNÑaH». enAeBlRtLb;mkTIRkúg

v:asuInetanvij vIløIyuaM køIFIn )antak;EtgGnusSrN³mYyRbkbedaysmþICUrct;bMput EdlkñúgenaH

Kat;)anecaTRbkan; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI fa )ansEmJgCaeRKÓgTak;citþBYkcin[mansgÇwmBICMnYyGaemrikaMgmYy

enAkñúgvis½yxøH² EdlminEdlCECkBiPakSakñúglMdab;fñak;dwknaMCan;x<s;esaH ehIyEdlenAminTan;

yl;RBmenAeLIy. v:an;s_ )anGbGrsresIrkarviPaKenHy:agekøóvkøa. Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI eFVIhak;dUcCa\t

manerOgehtuGVIekIteLIgTaMgGs;.

enATIRkúgeb:kaMg TIRbwkSasnþisuxCati)andutbeBaäHkarxVHGMNt;rbs;cin edaysgát;bBa¢ak;enA

cMeBaHmux h½g nig etg s‘avBIg BIPaBcaM)ac;BRgwgshRbtibtþikareTAelI«bBaðaepSg²EfmeTot dUcCa

bBaðaGahVháanIsßan karpþl;CMnYyeTA[RbeTs):aKIsßan nigkarCYytMbn;GasuIGaeKñy_CaedIm EdlCakar

eqøIytbeTAnwgkarRTRTg;rbs;sUevotcMeBaHKMnitvatTIniymrbs;evotNam»24. esckþIRbkasenH

esÞIrEtyl;RBmcMeBaHsm<½n§PaBrbs;RbeTscinCamYyExµrRkhmEdr edayehtufa kñúgtMbn;GasuI

GaeKñy_TaMgmUl km<úCaRbCaFibetyürbs; b:ul Bt CaRbeTsEtmYyKt;Edlts‘UTb;Tl;nwg«lT§ivatTI

niymrbs;evotNam». sakSIdEdl)ankt;smÁal;CaÉkCnfa «b‘Ík )aneCOedayKµanRBWesáóbbnþuic

nUvkarviPaKrbs;cin sþIBIkarKMramkMEhgrbs;sUevot nigBItYnaTIrbs;BYkevotNamEdlRKan;EtrNb

rbs;rusSIb:ueNÑaH. Kat;yl;eXIjfal¥EfmeTot enAeBlBYkcinBnül;R)ab;Kat;fa meFüa)ayEtmYy

Kt;edIm,IbeNþjrusSIecjBItMbn;KWCYysRmÜl[mankarxitcUlCitKñamYyrvagsUevot-evotNam

EdltamBYkcinfa nwgnaMeTArkkarb:HTgÁicrvagsm<n§miRtnana edayecosminput»25. edayrebob

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg322

Page 333: Brother enemy

mü:ag Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )aneFVI[eTACapøÚvkarnUvCMhrfµIrbs;GaemrikaMg edayGbGrsresIrCasaFarN³kñúg

»kasBiFICb;elogmYy nUvkarRbqaMgrbs;cincMeBaH«GnutþrPaBBiPBelaknigtMbn;». enAeBlEdl

dMNwgdwgmkdl;Kat; v:an;s_ EdlBuM)anpþl;nUvkaryl;RBmrbs;Kat;)anxwgRceLatetattUg. Kat;

)ankt;smÁal;edayKµanGt;GFüaRs½yfa «enHCasmþIl¶Iel¶ImYysuT§saF. sunÞrkfarbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI

nigsmþIsnÞnarbs;Kat;enAmhakMEBgKWeFVI[BYkcinRtÚvcitþR)akdNas; b:uEnþBYkeKnwgBuM)anseRmc

lT§plc,as;las;GVITaMgGs;»26.

enAeCIgmhakMEBgEtmþg Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anbeBa©jsmþIeTAkan;GñkbkERbcinrbs;Kat; Nan;suI tag

nUvkarbgáehtu¬edayemIlgayfa KURbqaMgKµansmtßPaBnwgeFVIGVIekIt¦y:agesaHkeRkaHmYyfa «Gñk

TImYyEdlQrelIkMBUl[rbs;mhakMEBg]nwgeTARbyuT§nwgBYkrusSIenARbeTseGtüÚBI». Kat;maneRbób

elIyuT§karenARbeTscinrbs;Kat;edayKµanBi)akeFVI[RsLaMgkaMgRKb;Kña. enAeBlcuHmkvij BYkeK

)anCYbKñanwgsisSnayTahanrbs;kgm:arInCaeRcInnak; EdlkMBugQrftrUbCaRkúm. edaykMesokxøÜn

y:agRbsb;cUleTAkNþalcMeNamBYkenaH Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )ansYrfa «enAeBlenH etIkmøaMgGVIEdleFVI[

GñkTaMgGs;KñaftrUbCamYyGñkriHKn;sUevotxøaMgCageKenAelIBiPBelak?». BYksisSnayTahan

kgm:arInenAEtQrmigmaMgedayegOgq¶l;. BYkeKnwkmineXIjbnþicesaHeLIyBIGtþsBaØaNrbs;

«bisacRcmuHEvg»enH.

eTaHbICakareFVIRtab;edayqÁgKYr[Gs;sMeNIcTaMgenHbNþal[ v:an;s_ ekþARkhayk¾eday

k¾eKRtÚvEtTTYlsÁal;fa dMeNIrrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI eTARbeTscin)anpþl;nUvsmÞúHfµImYydl;GPiRkménkar

eFVI[manRbRktIPaBEdr. mü:ageTot karKaMRTnigkareyaKyl;EdlTIRbwkSaGaemrikaMgbgðaj[eXIj

)anrYmbgásRmab; etg s‘avBIg nUvsnøwkeboFMCageKmYy ¬EdlGac[seRmclT§pleRcInRbkar¦

ehIyedaysarRbkarenH etg GaceFVI[TsSn³TaMgLayrbs;Kat;maneRbóbCagenAkñúgsm½yRbCuM

pþac;RB½Rténkariyal½yneya)ayrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþcinenAExkkáda qñaM1978 Edl)anseRmccitþ

«pþl;emeronmYycMeBaHRbeTsevotNam».

mYyExbnÞab;BIkarvilRtLb;mkvijrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI PaBRsuHRsYlKñaEtsm,keRkAmYyhak;dUcCa

RtÚveFVI[maneLIgvij rvagbNþaTIRbwkSaneya)ayrbs; xaF½r. v:an;s_ har:UleR)an Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI nig

hamIltun hSkdg; )anseRmcedaymankaryl;RBmBIRbFanaFibtIpgfa kareFVI[manRbRktIPaB

CamYyRbeTscinnwgmaneLIgenABak;kNþalExFñÚ. enAedImExkkádanaTIRkúgeb:kaMg vUdxUk )anRbKl;[

BYkcinnUvr)aykarN_BisþardMbUgmYykñúgcMeNamr)aykarN_BisþarbnþbnÞab;KñamYysþIBIkaredaHRsay

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 323

Page 334: Brother enemy

CemøaHepSg²Tak;TgeTAnwgekaHétv:an;. eRkaymk suIrus v:an;s_ )anlatRtdagfa ³ «hUlRb‘Úk nig ´

manKMniteRbIR)as;rlkFatuGakasEdlbRmúgTuksRmab;estviman¬eRkameQµaHsm¶at;fa«Voyager»¦

edIm,ITak;TgKñaCamYyvUdxUk» kñúgeKalbMNgrwtt,iteRKaHfñak;énkarelcFøayerOgsm¶at; 27. karelg

l,icrbs;Kat;)anLgmkelIxøÜnÉgvijehIy Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI nwgTajTLðIkrN_BIerOgenH edIm,Ipþac;RksYg

karbreTsecjenAeBlEdlRtÚvRbkan;ykkarseRmccitþsMxan;²bMput.

KeRmagkarepSg²kñúgkarebIksßanTUtenARkúghaNUy

bnÞab;BIkarRbCuMenAéf¶TI27 ExkBaØanaTIRkúgjÚvy:k EpñkEdlTTYlbnÞúkkic©karevotNam enA

RksYgkarbreTs)anbegáItRkúmkargarmYy edIm,IkMNt;BIPaKl¥itl¥n;énkarGnuvtþn_kñúgkarebIksßanTUt

GaemrikaMgenATIRkúghaNUy. RtÚvR)ab;[dwgBI]bsKÁepSg²EdlRtÚvRbQmmuxedaysarkar

yl;RBmrh½seBk bNþasßanTUtbs©imRbeTsxøH-sßanTUtGU®sþalI GaløWm:g;xaglic-nigCaBiess

hUlRb‘Úk manbMNgeFVI[mankarRBmeRBógCamYynwgevotNamCamunsin. m®nþIBIrrUbénRksYgkar

breTsKWelakr:UbWtGUklInigsÞIvlIn)anRtÚvcat;[CYyp©úgepþIm edIm,IeFVI[)anseRmcerOgenH GñkTaMg

BIr)anCYbshkarImñak;rbs; fac; KW Rtan; kVagkU CaeRcInelIkenATIRkúgjÚvy:k. bBaðaepSg²

EdlenAminTan;dac;eRscmanrYmbBa©ÚlpgEdrnUvcMnYnGñkkarTUtEdlcat;taMg[bMeBjmuxgarenAsßanTUt

rebobdwkCBa¢ÚnhibkarTUt b¤karGnuBaØat[cuHctenAGakasyandæanRkúghaNUyEdlcaM)ac;RtÚveRbI

ynþehaHRbePT C-5A Galaxy mYyeRKÓgsRmab;eFVIkardwkCBa¢ÚnsmÖar³epSg²rbs;sßanTUt.

enARksYgkarbreTs eKcab;epþImBicarNaBIsmasPaBbuKÁliksRmab;sßanTUtEdlRtÚvebIkenA

eBlxagmux. sRmab;ehtuplepSg²EpñksnþisuxEdl[mnÞilsgS½y exnXVIn )anENnaM hUlRb‘Úk

ecAhVaynayrbs;Kat; kuM[ykGñkkarTUtNamYyEdlerobkarnwg®sþIevotNam. DUkkøas PIk GtIt

Pñak;garsnþisuxmñak;rbs;shrdæGaemrik Føab;)anrs;enACaeRcInqñaMenATIRkúgéRBnKr CaTIEdlKat;TTYl

bnÞúkviPaKÉksarepSg²EdlrwbGUs)anBIevotkug nigr)aykarN_sYrcemøIyTaMgLay. tambNþaj

sm¶at;rbs;Kat;enAmnÞIrbBa©ekaN Kat;)andwgdMNwgsþIBIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB Edlc,as;Camkdl;

kñúgeBlqab;² ehIyKat;)andak;ebkçPaBnwgeK. b:uEnþ tamFmµtaGñksµ½RKcitþminmaneRcInKñaeT. Rkúg

haNUyk¾minniyayBIerOgluykak;Edr. shkarImñak;rbs;elak sÞIv lIn )anGgVrKat;enARtg;kEnøg

bt;énrebogpøÚvmYyenATIsþIkarRksYgkarbreTs «´B¤eKniyayfa elakkMBugEsVgrkmnusSeTAeFVIkar

enARkúghaNUy. sÞIv ´sUmGgVrsUmelakeFVIhak;dUcCaminEdlB¤eKniyayBI´eTAcuH».

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg324

Page 335: Brother enemy

\LÚvenH vaenAEteFVI[saFarNmtinigsPaCan;Tabyl;RBmcMeBaHkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB

CamYyRbeTsevotNamb:ueNÑaH. karsÞabsÞg;mti)ansEmþg[eXIjnUvkareBjcitþeRcInKYrsm.

enAéf¶TI29 ExkBaØa qñaM1978 KWBIréf¶eRkayeBlEdl fac; bdiesFminniyayBICMnYyEpñkesdækic©

CamunkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB hUdDIg xaF½r Gnurdæm®nþIRksYgkic©karsaFarN³)anbBa¢ÚneTA[

hUlRb‘Úk nUvesckþIsnñidæanénkareFVIGegátmtisaFarNCnmYyEdlseRmceFVIeLIgedaybNþaj

TUrTsSn_ N.B.C. News ³ «mtiPaKeRcInmYyCaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;karTTYlsÁal;[RbeTsevotNam]

GacnwgfmfyeTAvij luHRtaEt«kareFVI[manRbRktIPaB»enHminrYmbBa©Úlkarpþl;CMnYyhirBaØvtßúd¾

eRcInmYy. b:uEnþ RBMEdnénCMnYyenH)anRtÚvbBa¢ak;edayCak;lak; ehIymü:ageTot saFarNCnyl;

eXIjfa evotNam)aneFVIkarRbwgERbgy:agxøaMgedIm,Ipþl;nUvkarbMPøWGMBITahanGaemrikEdl)at;xøÜnkñúg

karRbyuT§».

munnwgttaMgnwgsmaCikl,I²énsPaCan;Tab hUlRb‘Úk )an[RkúmkargarkñúgRksYgrbs;Kat;

erobcMr)aykarN_mYy EdlBnül;EvkEjky:agCak;lak;BIkalanuvtþPaB¬PaBKYrdl;kal¦énkareFVI[

manRbRktIPaB. ÉksarenHmancMNgeCIgfa karbegáItTMnak;TMngkarTUteLIgvijCamYyRbeTs

evotNam ³ GaTiPaBmYyEdlRtÚveFVImuneK )anKUsbBa¢ak;fa RbeTsenHmuxCakøayeTACarNrgÁén

karRbyuT§mYyrvagshPaBsUevotnigRbeTscin BYksUevot)anbegáInvtþmanrbs;eKenATIenaHnig)an

BRgwgkarKaMRTrbs;eKcMeBaHevotNamenAkñúgCemøaHCamYykm<úCa. «vtþmanmYyrbs;GaemrikaMgenA

RkúghaNUy Gac[eyIgdwgB½t’mankan;EtRbesIrBIkarvivtþn_énkarRbkYtRbECgrvagcin-sUevot nig

pþl;dl;BYkemdwknaMevotNamnUvkareRCIserIsd¾Cak;lak;mYy edIm,IQrkñúgCYrmhaGMNackumµúynIsþ

mYyb¤mYyeTot». drabNaminTan;)anbegáItTMnak;TMngkarTUtCamYyRbeTsevotNam «shrdæ

GaemriknwgminbegáIt[manGMNacNamYyenAkñúgRbeTsenHeT ehIynwgTTYlB½t’manminl¥BIGVIEdl

ekItman b¤muxCanwgekItman». kardak;sßanTUtmYyenARkúghaNUy«nwgmanPaBkan;EtgayRsYl

[edIm,ITTYlB½t’manepSg²sþIBITahanGaemrik)at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§] CagkarTak;TgbnÞab;bnSM dUcBYkeK

)anTTYlbc©úb,nñenATIRkúg)agkk b¤enARkúg):arIs b¤karCYbKñaedaykal³eTs³dUcEdlGñkTTYlxusRtÚv

xøHénrdæaPi)al b¤smaCikxøHénsPaCan;TabGaceFVI)an». enATIbMput RkúmGñkeFVIkarenAsßanTUt nwgGac

CYyshRKasTaMgLayrbs;GaemrikaMg[RbQmmuxTl;nwgkarRbkYtRbECgrbs;Rkúmh‘unbreTs

epSg²eTot.

kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH RkúmkargarEdlTTYlbnÞúkBinitüTRmg;GnuvtþTaMgLayénRbtibtþikar

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 325

Page 336: Brother enemy

)aneBIbRbTHnwg]bsKÁCaeRcIn. GñkxøHRKan;EtdwgfaGVIeTAEdldUcGtItsßankugs‘ulGaemrikenA

RkúghaNUy? vresnIy_Ék ém:xWl GIeLn énkariyal½ykic©karneya)ayeyaFaenARksYg

karbreTs )anman»kasftGKarenaHkalBIBIrExmuneBlEdlKat;rYmdMeNIrCamYyKN³RbtiPUmYy

énsPaCan;TabeTAeFVITsSnkic©enATIRkúghaNUy. Kat;minBi)akbnþicesaHeLIykñúgkarrkTItaMgsßan

kugs‘ul EdlsßitenAtamdgvifIhay)aRTúg cMkNþalTIRkúg. «KWCaGKarBN’ébtgEtmYyKt;KW

BN’ébtgdUcR)ak;duløarGI‘cwg». bBaðaEtmYyKWenAeBlEdlKat;RbúgeRbóbftvimanRbvtþisa®sþenH

EdleTIbEtlabBN’eLIgvijfµI² edIm,IbeRmIeKalbMNgGñkkan;kab;enAeBlxagmux Rsab;Et

kgT½BevotNammñak;)anmkQrBaMgBImuxRtg;cenøaHkNþal. dUecñH hVIlrUbftmanlkçN³RBilmin

c,as; b:uEnþenHCarUbftEtmYyKt;EdlRksYgkarbreTsman. kñúgsßanPaBenH vaBi)annwgeFVIKeRmag

karepSg²kñúgkarerobcMNas;. edayP½BVl¥ manm®nþImñak;)anerIrkeXIjbøg;GKarenaHEdleKkb;ecal

yUrmkehIy. mIEsðl GUesnbWk )andMNalfa «éf¶mYyEdl´eTAkan;RksYgkarbreTs ´)an

RtÚveFVI[PJak;ep¥IlEdlrkeXIjÉksarKYr[cab;citþd¾Rkas;mYydMu EdlBYkeK)anerobcMsþIBIEbbbT

GnuvtþTaMgLaykñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB bBaðap¥akskmµPaBepSg²rbs;evotNamenAshrdæ

Gaemrik/ karkMNt;TItaMgsßanTUt/ karR)aRs½yTak;TgKña nigbBaðaesssl;»28.

RksYgkarbreTs)anseRmc[ dWnIs haF½r EdlCashkarImñak;rbs; GIeLn enAkariyal½y

kic©karneya)ay EdlecHniyayPasaevotNamdUcKat;Edr[eFVIdMeNIreTARkúghaNUyenAExFñÚ

edIm,Icab;epþImBinitüemIlTItaMgsRmab;sagsg;sßanTUtnigEpnkarerobcMmYy.

b:uEnþCadMbUg haF½r )aneTABinitüBic½yGKarepSg²énGtItsßanTUtevotNamxagt,ÚgenA

TIRkúgv:asuInetansin munnwgRbKl;[RkúghaNUyeRbIR)as;. enHKWkarRsavRCavtaMgBIedImmkvij.

kRmalRBMsuT§EtduHpSit ehIyrUbKMnUrEdlBüÜrnwgCBa¢aMgeLIgeRbHEbkRska b:uEnþebIBinitü[l¥itl¥n;

GVI²TaMgGs;BuMmanpøas;bþÚreT taMgBIkarcakecjrbs;GñkkarTUtevotNamxagt,ÚgkalBIExmIna qñaM

1975. TsSnavdþIEfm nigjÚvsVic cas;²Edlerobrab;BIRBwtþikarN_énkardYlrlMrbs;RkúgéRBnKr

enArat;rayelItuCamYycanKRKicCaeRcIn EdlbBa¢ak;[dwgBIkarbriePaKGaharcugeRkaymYy. kariya

l½yTTYlbnÞúkemIlxusRtÚvGKarepSg²rbs;breTs (Bâtiments étrangers) )anbdiesFminTTYlbnÞúkeFVI

karCYsCulEdlcaM)ac;xanmin)aneT ebITukCamankarsnüaEdleFVICamYykariyal½yenHBIkarsgR)ak;

enAeBlxagmuxk¾eday. rYcmkehIyEdlkarcMNaysRmab;GsgðarimkmµrfynþepSg²rbs;GtIt

sßanTUtRtÚvFøak;mkelIkariyal½yenH¡.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg326

Page 337: Brother enemy

GVI²TaMgenHKµan)anRbeyaCn_esaHeLIy. edaymin[RksYgkarbreTsdwg estvimankMBug

EttRmÚv[RBwtþikarN_epSg²RbRBwtþeTAtamdMeNIrmYyxusKñaTaMgRsug.

Rkúgv:asuInetanbgðajBIeKalbMNgepSg²rbs;cin

enAeRkayeBlcb;karsnÞnaCamYy fac; naevlayb;éf¶TI27 ExkBaØa hUlRb‘Úk nigeGKIb rbs;

Kat;)ancakecjBIsßanKN³ebskkmµrbs;evotNam ehIykarebIksßanTUtmYyrbs;GaemrikaMgTMng

CaBit. b:uEnþ GñkxøHenAEtsgS½yminGs;minehIy. mIEsðl GUesnbWk nwkeXIjsmþIEdlniyayeTA

kan; hUlRb‘Úk fa «DIk ¬CaeQµaHehAeRkArbs; hUlRb‘Úk¦ evotNam)ane)akbeBaäatelakKWBYkeK

cMGk[elak». hUlRb‘Úk )anRtÚveFVI[PJak;ep¥IlBIPaBsVitsVajrbs; fac; EdlxaMRkajnwgkarTamTar

CMnYyEpñkesdækic©rbs;Kat; ³ «Tal;Etdl;naTIcugeRkay eTIbKat;e)aHbg;karTamTarCaGaTiPaBenH

eRkamkarqaeqArMxanrbs;hUlRb‘Úk. bnÞab;BIenaHeTA fac; manbMNgfaRtÚverobcM[manBiFIsar

RBmeRBógKñamYy eTaHbICaKat;dwgfaenHBuMEmnCaTMenomTmøab;karTUtk¾eday». GUesnbWk )anRtÚvjúaMg

[eCOCak;fa evotNamRKan;EtbeBaäatBiPBelakb:ueNÑaH ehIycg;bgðajxøÜnfaCaemKMniténkareFVI[

manRbRktIPaB b:uEnþKµanbMNgeFVI[ecjCalT§plBitR)akdeT. tamKat;yl; PaBbnþKñaénRBwtþikarN_

epSg²enAsrTrdUvqñaM1978)anTajRbeTsTaMgBIreTArkTispÞúyKña. «édTaMgBIrlUkeTArkKña b:uEnþ

R)akdNas;favanwgmineQagdl;Kña)aneT»29.

GUesnbWk manbMNgbkRsayerOgr:aveLIgvij bnÞab;BIkarb:HTgÁicKñamYykþarEmnb¤?

b¤mYykardwgehtumunrbs;Kat;TMngCaEp¥keTAelIkardwgfa Kat;manGriPaBnwg Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI cMeBaHkareFVI[

manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNameTdwg? BIeRBaHenATIbMput Kat;KµansgS½yesaHeLIyfa enA

eBlenaH RkúghaNUy)aneRtómeFVIBlIkmµy:ageRcInedIm,IQaneTAdl;kic©RBmeRBógmYy. karraErk

rbs; fac; dUcEdl hUlRb‘Úk yl;FøúHBIerOgenHKWRKan;EtCal,icklmYynigCakarsakl,gcugeRkay

mYy edIm,IeFVI[TTYl)anBIshrdæGaemriknUvkarsnüapþl;EpñkhirBaØvtßúmYyb:ueNÑaH. evotNamyl;

eXIjfa BYkeKminGacRbTHeRKaHfñak;FMduMeT ebIRKan;EtPan;RcLMbnþicbnþÜcenaH ehIyBYkeKeCOfa kic©

RBmeRBógnwgseRmcecjCarUbrageLIgPøambnÞab;BIkare)aHbg;minniyayBIGaTiPaBénkarpþl;CMnYyCa

munrbs;xøÜn.

hUlRb‘Úk KµanKMnitTuTidæiniymdUc GUesnbWk Tal;EtesaH. Kat;minbgðaj[eXIjfa ]bsKÁ

epSg²minsUvsMxan;eT b:uEnþ Kat;k¾mineCOfa ]bsKÁTaMgenaHminGacBuHBar)anEdr. TsSn³rbs;

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 327

Page 338: Brother enemy

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI minEmnfa Kat;mindwgenaHeT. k¾b:uEnþ Kat;RBÜy)armÖBIkarcUlBak;B½n§Cayfaehtukñúgs®gÁam

RBMEdnmYy rvagevotNamnigkm<úCaeRBaHEtmhaGMNacnana. munbnþicénkarCYbrbs;Kat;CamYy fac;

ynþehaHQøbykkarN_mYyrbs;GaemrikaMg EdlkMBugehaHehIrEk,reqñrsmuRTPaKkNþalRbeTs

evotNam)ancab;)ankarTak;TgKñatamviTüúEdlbgðaj[dwgfa kgT½BeqñImrbs;evotNammYykgBl

FMkMBugEtraybNþak;KñaenAtamRBMEdnrbs;km<úCa. kareFVIclnarbs;kgT½BRtÚv)anRbkas[dwgCa

saFarN³fa enATIenHnigTIenaH. r:ahVaEGl yunháWric CaGñkÉkeTsd¾eqñImelIseKxagbBaða\NÐÚcin

enAkñúgEpñkesuIbkarN_sm¶at;énRksYgkarbreTs)anniyayTukCamun enAExsIhafa evotNamnwgmin

RtÚvkareBlevlaR)aMmYyExedIm,IpþÜlrMlMrbb b:ul Bt eT30.

karxitcUlCitKñac,as;las;bMputrvagsUevot-evotNam EdlCaP½sþútagénkarcUlCasmaCik

GgÁkarkUemkugkñúgeBlfµI² )anrYmbgáCamUlehtuRBÜy)armÖmYyeTot. hUlRb‘Úk )anbegðIberOgenH

R)ab; fac; Edr. fac; )aneqøIyR)ab;Kat;vijfa «ectnarbs;eyIgcMeBaHRbeTskm<úCamanlkçN³Ca

karkarBarxøÜnsuT§saF. enHCaerOgmYyEdlKYrTTYlyk)an ehIyBYkGaemrikaMgRtÚv)anR)ab;[dwg

BIkarqµk;vayRbharrbs;ExµrRkhm EdleTIbmanfµI²enAmçageToténRBMEdn. yunháWric )anniyay

R)ab;´Casm¶at;fa «tamkarBit hUlRb‘Úk nigeyIg TaMgGs;Kña)ankan;eCIgBYkevotNamGMBIbBaðaenH

rhUtdl;cugqñaM1978/ faG‘ÍcwgeTAcuH. evotNam)anRtÚvExµrRkhmrMelaPbMBaneTAelITwkdIpÞal;

rbs;eK k¾dUcrMelaPBYkéfEdrebI»kashuc[. sRmab;eyIg b:ul Bt KWCaEqáqáÜtmYyk,al CamnusS

EdleKmincUlcitþRKb;KñaenAkñúgtMbn; nigCaKMrUePrvCnpg»31.

v:an;s_ nig hUlRb‘Úk Kitfa vtþmanrbs;GaemrikaMgenAkñúgtMbn;d¾vwkvrenHnwgedIrtYnaTIeFVI[FUr

RsalmYy. KWeRkamTsSn³enHehIyEdlGñkTaMgBIrmanbMNgeFVI[manRbRktIPaBEpñkkarTUtCamYy

RbeTscinnigRbeTsevotNam. d,itGI ebIsinCaCemøaHépÞkñúglT§ikumµúynIsþrYmbgáCakarKMramkMEhg

mYycMeBaHsßirPaBtMbn; vaGacCa»kaseFVI[\T§iBlrbs;GaemrikaMgenAGasuIkeRmIkeLIgvijEdr.

rdæm®nþIkarbreTsGU®sþalI elak eGnRDÚ PIxUk )anyl;RsbnwgTsSn³enHTaMgRsug. karRbkas[

dwgCasaFarN³nUvkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBrvagGaemrikaMg-evotNam )aneFVI[Kat;eBareBjeTAeday

karsb,ayrIkrayy:agxøaMg ebIeTaHbICaKat;eCOfa GacenAmandMeNIrEvgq¶ayeTAmuxeTotk¾eday.

PIxUk )anniyayR)ab;eKÉgfa «enAeBlEdlRBwtþikarN_epSg²ekItmaneLIg dUecñH´yl;fa vaKYrdl;

eBlevlaEdlbNþaRbeTsxøH-RbeTsGU®sþalICa]TahrN_ b:uEnþ RbeTskaNada nig nUEv:lehSLg;

Edr-RtÚvcab;epþImbnþkarsnÞnaEpñkkarTUteLIgvijCamYyRbeTskm<úCaehIy edaykuMePøcR)ab;[

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg328

Page 339: Brother enemy

RbeTscindwgBIKMnitpþÜcepþImTaMgGs;EdlnwgRtÚvRbkan;ykeTAtamTisenHpg. ´)anpþl;KMnitdl;

v:an;s_ nig hUlRb‘Úk GMBIerOgenH eRBaHfakñúgenaH ´emIleXIjmeFüa)aybgáarTukCamunnUvplGviC¢man

EdlGacekItmanCayfaehtuBIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBrvagGaemrikaMg-evotNameTAelITMnak;TMng

epSg²rvagRbeTscin nigshrdæGaemrik»32. hUlRb‘Úk KµanrkSaTukGnusSavrIy_NamYykñúgkar

CECkBiPakSaenHeT «´mincaMGVIeTKWmanEtb:uNÑwg. b:uEnþ ´BuMmanehtuplNamYyeFVI[sgS½ynUvGVIEdl

eGnRDÚ )anGHGageLIy»33.

enAéf¶TI27 ExkBaØa karsegçbxøI²nUvRBwtþikarN_GnþrCatiTaMgLay EdlerobcMerogral;éf¶

edayRksYgkarbreTs edIm,IbeRmIeKalbMNgelakRbFanaFibtI BitCa)anbBa©Úlr)aykarN_

mYysþIBIkarCYbKñarvag hUlRb‘Úk nig fac; Edr. r)aykarN_enaH manGmeTAedaykMNt;xøImYy rbs;

v:an;s_ pg EdlENnaMedayTTUckñúgkareFVI[nUvTMnak;TMngEpñk karTUtCamYyRbeTsevotNamman

RbRktIPaBqab;rh½s. vaTMngfa elak xaF½r )aneCOtamKMnitenHrYceTAehIyedayehtufa enAedImEx

Kat;)anpþl;karbgÁab;bBa¢a[ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI eRbIRKb;lT§PaBTaMgGs;edIm,IQaneTAdl;«karTTYlsÁal;

RbeTscinnigRbeTsevotNamdMNalKña»34.

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anbgðaj[eXIjkarExVgeyabl;rbs;Kat;CamYy v:an;s_ nig hUlRb‘Úk. Kat;)an

CMTas;nwgKeRmag«bBa©ÚlRbeTsevotNameTAkñúgGPiRkmén[kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBcinnigGaemrikaMg]».

kñúgyuT§sa®sþRbqaMgsUevotrYmrbs;xøÜn bBaðaepSg²kñúgtMbn;)anedIrtYnaTIbnÞab;bnSMmYyb:ueNÑaH. kar

s¥b;QñanIsEdlmanrab;stvtSmkehIyrvagevotNamnigcin RbEhlCakgVl;cugeRkayrbs;Kat;.

Kat;vaytémøxusBIkarP½yxøacEdlRbeTscinjúaMg[bNþaRbeTsCitxagrbs;xøÜnykKMniteFVItamnig

bdiesFfa evotNamRBWxøacNas;cMeBaHkarrulmkmuxmYyrbs;cinsMedAmkTisxagt,Úg ³ «KµanGVIGac

GHGagBIKMnitenHeLIy TaMgtamRbvtþisa®sþ TaMgtamyuT§sa®sþ». tamKat;yl;RbeTsevotNam

RKan;EtCa«GñkTTYlplRbeyaCn_epSg²BIshPaBsUevot»b:ueNÑaH ehIyKat;yl;RsbnwgkarP½y

xøacrbs;RbeTscinEdleXIjRbeTsevotNamERbkøayeTACamUldæanmYyrbs;sUevot. Kat;kt;

smÁal;fa ³ «v:an;s_ nig hUlRb‘Úk )aneFVIyuT§nakarCaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYy

RbeTsevotNam Edltam´yl;enHCakarPan;RcLMmYysuT§saF EdleFVI[maneRKaHfñak;dl;karxit

cUlCitKñaCamYyRbeTscin CaBiessxagEpñkyuT§sa®sþ». Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI cg;R)aRs½ykargarnwg hUlRb‘Úk

Edr. «´RtÚveFVI[eCO Cak;fa hUlRb‘Úk [kñúg»kasénkarCYbKñaenAExkBaØa qñaM1978 naTIRkúgj:Úvy:k]

KµaneKalbMNgGVIeRkAEtBIjúaMg[evotName)aHbg;ecalsMeNIsuMCMnYyEpñkesdækic©rbs;eKb:ueNÑaH

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 329

Page 340: Brother enemy

edIm,IsRmÜldl;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaB ehIy´riHKn;meFüa)ayTaMgGs;rbs;Kat;y:agxøaMg»35.

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI nwgBiPakSaCamYyRbFanaFibtIBIPaBb:HTgÁicEdlecosminput kñúgkarseRmccitþmYy

EbbenaH ehIy xaF½r Edlyl;Rsbtameyabl;rbs;Kat;)anelIkkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYy

evotNameTAeBleRkayvij. karbkRsayrbs;Kat;BIRBwtþikarN_epSg²manmktaMgBIqñaM1981.

enAkalbriecäTenH RbeTsevotNamesÞIrEtRtÚvefáaleTasCasaFarN³BIbBaðamnusSFm’eTAehIy.

karkan;kab;RbeTskm<úCaKWCaGMeBIEdl)aneFVIRCúleTAehIymYy. RbCaCnePosxøÜntamTUkrab;Ban;nak;

)ansakl,grt;ecjBIRbeTs. tamsmþIKat;EdlGYtxøÜnfa KWKat;Etmñak;ÉgKt;EdleFVI[braC½ydl;

kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRkúghaNUy. Kat;RbEhlCaeCOBIGMNacrbs;Kat;Cardæbursmñak;Bit

Emn. b:uEnþkñúglMdab;TsSn³enH \sSrCnmñak; eTotk¾manzan³GacGYtxøÜn)anEdrKW eLGUNard_ vUdxUk.

vUdxUk enHÉgEdlCaGñkepþImdMeNIrkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBedaydwknaMKN³ebskkmµmYyrbs;

RbFanaFibtIeTARkúghaNUyenAniTaXrdUvqñaM1977.

kñúgzan³CaRbFankariyal½yTMnak;TMngrbs;GaemrikaMgRbcaMRkúgeb:kaMg Kat;manebskkmµcrca

EsVgrkkic©RBmeRBógmYykñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscin. dUecñH eKnwkEtkñúgcitþfa

kRmiténkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;Kat; RbEhlCapøas;bþÚry:ageRcIn taMgBIkareFVIdMeNIrrbs;Kat;eTATIRkúg

haNUy. karcrcaCamYyBYkcin Edlcab;epþImCasm¶at;enAExkkáda naTIRkúgeb:kaMg eBlenaHKWsßitenA

kñúgdMNak;kalRbkbedayeRKaHfñak;mYy. vUdxUk GaclubbM)at;]bsKÁepSg²EdlenAsl; ehIy

EdlRtÚvBuHBar[)anenAkñúgBiFIbriePaK)aymYyEdlpþl;CUnedayrdæm®nþIkarbreTscin hYg hY enAéf¶

TI3 Extula qñaM1978 naTIRkúgjÚvy:k. kñúg»kasenaH v:an;s_ hUlRb‘Úk nig GUesnbWk )anrYmdMeNIr

CamYyKat;Edr. enAyb;dEdlenaH elak hSk XInFIn )anerobcMenA Central Park ekoknwgsßan

ebskkmµcin nUvkardutkaMRCÜcEbøkxuseKmYykñúgcMeNamkardutkaMRCÜcEbøkxuseKrbs;Kat;. sñÚrénkar

pÞúH)anlan;B¤RThwg eFVI[bg¥ÜcGKarnanaj½rrNþM. briyakasEdlmanlaykarkMEbøgnigP½yRBÜyenH

KWvaRtÚveTAtamkal³eTs³ ³ karCYbKña)anRbRBwtþeTARbkbedaylkçN³d¾rMeCIbrMCYl. hYghY )anriHKn;

edayRtg;²Kµanlak;elom. Kat;)antiHedol v:an;s_ y:agxøaMgBIkarcecsrbs;shrdæGaemrikEdl

rkSaTMnak;TMngkarTUtCamYy étv:an; niglk;eRKÓgsBVavuFeTA[eTot. enAem:ag10yb; eKetagEtnwk

KiteTAdl;GahareBll¶ac. edayerobcMy:agsRmaMgenAelItumðÚbGaharrbs;cin)aneLIgRtCak;

Gs;. hUlRb‘Úk )anrMB£kenAnwgmux´BIPaBesakesAénkarbriePaKGahareBll¶acEdleLIgRtCak;min

ecHcb;enH. «G‘ÍcwgehIy )anCaeyIgBuMmanlT§PaBegIbeTAemIlkaMRCÜc. ehIyl,icTaMgenH)aneFVI[

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg330

Page 341: Brother enemy

B¤sUrsMeLgKYr[xøacy:agxøaMgdUckar)aj;kaMePøIgt,al;Edr. eKnwgsnñidæandUcenARkúgéRBnKrkñúg

ry³eBlmans®gÁamG‘Icwg».

vUdxUk )anRtÚveFVI[Gs;sgÇwmKYrsm. b:uEnþ BnøWénesckþIsgÇwmtUcmYy)anelceLIgeRBaH

shkarImñak;rbs; hYg )anmkCYbKat;Casm¶at; edIm,IesuIbsYrBIkareFVIdMeNIrrbs;Kat;eTATIRkúgeb:kaMg

vij. elIkenH Kat;R)afñafa mþgenHeKRtÚvRBmeRBógKñaedayKµanBnüareBlGMBIeKalkarN_énkar

snÞnaCahUrEhfµImYyenAkñúgrdæFanIcin. enHRbEhlCakar[sBaØamYyehIyemIleTA. edayBi)ak

niyayKñaCamYy v:an;s_ BYkcinRbEhlCasEmþg[eXIjPaBqab;RsuHRsYlCamYy vUdxUk CagEdl

BYkeKdwgfa Kat;eFVIkarkñúgRkúmshkarId¾CitsñiT§CamYy xaF½r nig Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI Edr.

enAéf¶TI11 Extula qñaM1978 eBlEdl xaF½r sYrKat;enAcMeBaHmux Rb‘ÍhSInsÁIkñúgkariyal½y

BgRkeBIénestvimanfa etIKat;eBjcitþbnþkarRbCuMedIm,IcrcaCamYyRbeTsevotNamb¤eT cemøIy

rbs;Kat;KWeTdac;xat. vUdxUk )anBnül;R)ab;RbFanaFibtIfa kñúgkal³eTs³bc©úb,nñ BYkeK ¬v:an;s_ nig

hUlRb‘Úk¦ manTwkcitþeFVI[braC½ydl;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscinEtmþg. BitehIy

karbgðajedImehtupÞal;xøÜnrbs;Kat;manlkçN³c,as;las; ³ Kat;mincg;RbfuyeFVI[manGnþraydl;

ebskkmµEdleKRbKl;[Kat;bMeBjenARkúgeb:kaMgeLIy. b:uEnþ etIBYkcinRbkasedayCak;lak;fa xøÜn

RbqaMgnwgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBrvagGaemrikaMg-evotNamEdreT?. vUdxUk )ansarPaBR)ab;´fa

Kat;minEdlsÞabsÞg;BYkcinBIcMNucenHeLIy edayTuk[BYkePJóvGaemrikaMgxøHsYrBIerOgenHcuH. CYn

kalePJóvmñak;kñúgcMeNameRcInnak;)ansYrBYkcinfa ³ «etIelaknwgmanRbtikmµEbbNakñúglT§PaBEdl

eyIgnwgeFVI[TMnak;TMngrbs;eyIgCamYyRbeTsevotNammanRbRktIPaBeLIgvij? tamFmµtacemøIy

KWEtgEtRby½tñRbEygCanic© b:uEnþ KµanemdwknaMcinNamñak; sEmþg[eXIjkarRbqaMgdac;GhgáareLIy».

tamkarBitebI vUdxUk P½yxøacRbtikmµGviC¢manmYyenaHKWRKan;EtfabBaðaminTan;)anedaHRsayeday

Cak;lak;b:ueNÑaH. «karcrcaCamYyRkúgeb:kaMg)anepþImenAExkkáda ehIykarsnÞnarbs;´CamYy

elakRbFanaFibtI)anekItmanenAExtula. kñúgry³eBlbIExenH edayKµaneBlniyayBIRbeTsevot

NamCamYyBYkcinTal;EtesaH ´GacvaytémøerOgenHbnþicbnþÜcenAeBlbc©úb,nñEdleyIgQandl;

eKaledAehIy eRBaHmincg;begáIt[mankarmnÞilsgS½ymkelIsuqnÞ³rbs;eyIg»36.

karbkRsayBIrEdlpÞúyKñaRsLHGMBI\riyabfrbs;cin )aneFVI[rdæaPi)alGaemrikaMg Ebk)ak;

CaBIrEdr ³ mçagKWkarbkRsayrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI-vUdxUk ehIymçageTotKWkarbkRsayrbs; hUlRb‘Úk.

hUlRb‘Úk )anerobrab;R)ab;´fa ³ «´enAnwkeXIjedayeBjeljnUvsmþIsnÞnarbs;BYkcinkñúg»kas

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 331

Page 342: Brother enemy

mhasnñi)atGgÁkarshRbCaCatienAqñaM1978 ³ «kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBrvagGaemrikaMg-evotNam

minTak;TgnwgeyIgeT sUmelakbegáItTMnak;TMngkarTUtCamYyRbeTsNa Edlelakcg;cuH». mnusS

RKb;Kñayl;fa evotNamBuMEmneRtkGreT b:uEnþ BYkeKsuxcitþxaMmat;sgát;citþ ¬eRBaHecosminrYc¦»37.

elak xaF½r yl;Rsbtameyabl;rbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI nig vUdxUk. Kat;yl;eXIjfa «bBaðacinman

sarsMxan;Casarvnþ» ehIyKat;)anseRmcfa kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNamnwg

ekItmanbnÞab;BIkarcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógCamYyRbeTscinrYcehIy38.

esckþIseRmcrbs;RbFanaFibtIenAéf¶TI11 ExtulaenH sßitenACaerOgsm¶at;bMput. enARksYg

karbreTs kRmmanGñkEdlRtÚvdwgBIerOgsm¶at;enHNas; eBlEdleKcab;epþImeFVIkarerobcMRbúg

eRbóbebIksßanTUtGaemrikaMgenATIRkúghaNUy. hUlRb‘Úk nigbNþashkarICitsñiT§rbs;Kat;pÞal;

k¾minRtÚv)anR)ab;[dwgBImUlehtuBitR)akdénkarelIkeBlenHEdr RbEhledIm,IecosvagkarRbQm

muxfµImYyrvag v:an;s_ nig Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI ehIyemIleTA. eK)ansakl,geFVI[Kat;eCOfa KWkarBinitüBic½y

GMBIneya)aykúñgRbeTsEtmü:agb:ueNÑaH GacR)ab;ehtuplBIkarseRmccitþenH ³ mYyExmunkare)aH

eqñat karsEmþgnUvsmancitþxøaMgeBkcMeBaHRbeTsevotNammuxCanwgbNþal[xUcxatdl;kare)aH

eqñateRCIserIssmaCiksPaCan;TabmYycMnYnFMeLIgvij. GñkCitditnwg hUlRb‘Úk mñak;)ankt;smÁal;

fa ³ «cab;taMgBIéf¶TI27 ExkBaØa karbgÁab;bBa¢aepSg²rbs;estviman)anERbeTACac,as;las;TaMg

Rsug ³ KµankareFVI[manRbRktIPaBmunkare)aHeqñateT»39.

hUlRb‘Úk karBartMENgrbs;Kat;

enAkariyal½yTTYlbnÞúkkic©karGasuIxagekIt BaküccamGar:am)ancab;epþImelcB¤sussay

eTaHbICamankarRbúgRby½tñmin[Føayecjk¾eday k¾kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNam

sßitkñúgsßanPaBF¶n;F¶renAeLIy. PaBtantwg)anekIneLIgrvagEpñkTTYlbnÞúkkic©karxagevotNamnig

xagcin ehIyEpñkxagcinkMBugsRmbtamCMhrPaKeRcInrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI. b:uEnþ eKRtÚvkar[mankUnxül;

BüúHmYypÞúHeLIg-bnÞab;BImanesckþIseRmcxøH²EdlkMNt;[ hUlRb‘Úk kñúg»kasénkarsñak;GaRs½y

mYyenATIRkúg)agkk-edIm,Inwg[karseRmccitþrbs;estviman RtÚv)andwgB¤eTAdl;mnusSRKb;Kña.

karcab;epþImdMeNIrkarkic©karenH)anmaneLIgRBmKñaCamYykarbBa¢ÚnCasm¶at;eTA[evotNamnUvGVIEdl

eKehAfa GaTiPaBfµIkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBy:agKYr[q¶l; eRBaHelIkenH GaemrikaMgCaGñkdak;

lkçxNÐmþg.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg332

Page 343: Brother enemy

r:UbWt GUklI )aneFVIdMeNIreTARkúgj:ÚvykBIrelIk edIm,IBiPakSaCamYyevotNam. Rkúmkargar

EdlbegáIteLIgsRmab;BinitüemIledayl¥itl¥n;nUvbBaðaepSg² EdlecaTeLIgedaykarebIksßanTUt

)aneFVIkary:agskmµ. kñúg»kasénkarCYbKñaelIkcugeRkayrbs;Kat;enAéf¶TI17 Extula GUklI )an

smÁal;eXIj egVón kUfac; GnÞHGEnÞgy:agxøaMg. fac; rMGukKat;fa «Rbjab;eLIg¡ eyIgcg;edaHRsay

bBaðaenHPøamEtmþg». GUklI )anBnüareBledayykelsfa CabzmKat;RtÚvkarBinitüPaKl¥itl¥n;

TaMgGs;[eRscCamunsin.

b:uEnþ enAéf¶TI30 Extula karyl;Tas;epSg²nigesckþIesñIEdlKat;RtÚvTTYlPar³bgðajCUndl;

Rtan; kVagkU KWmanPaBxusKñaTaMgRsug. munnwgcab;epþImcrcaeTAmuxeTot BYkGaemrikaMg)antRmÚv

enAeBlenHfa evotNamRtÚvBinitüeLIgvijnUvCMhrrbs;xøÜnelIbIcMNuc ³ bBaðaRbeTskm<úCa bBaðaTMnak;

TMngsUevot-evotNam nigbBaðaCnePosxøÜntamTUk. BIr-bIqñaMeRkaymk paM b‘íj GñkkarTUtCan;x<s;

evotNammñak;)aneFVIeBICasYrfa «ehtuGVI)anCamanlkçxNÐfµITaMgenH?. BIeRBaHfa taMgBIEx]sPa

qñaM1978 [CakalbriecäTénTsSnkic©rbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI enARkúgeb:kaMg] BYkcin)anseRmccitþRbkan;

neya)ayGmitþmYycMeBaHRbeTsevotNam ehIyfaBYkGaemrikaMg)ancUlédxagcineTotpg»40.

GVIEdl b‘íj min)anniyayKWfa karXubXitrvagsUevot-evotNam manPaBdUcKñanwgkar

XubXitrvagGaemrikaMg-cinEdr. enARBwkéf¶TI30 Extula ¬RtÚvnwgéf¶TI29 l¶acenARkúgv:asuInetan¦

ynþehaH GIulIyUQIn62 mYyeRKÓgrbs;sUevot)anehaHeLIgBIGakasyandæan Ny éb enARkúg

haNUy edaymanpÞúkemdwknaMCan;x<s;evotNamCaeRcInrUb41.

emdwknaMTaMgenaH R)akdCasmaCikkariyal½yneya)aycMnYnBak;kNþalEdlGmdMeNIr

GKÁelxabkS eL yn; eq<aHeTARkúgmUsÁÚ CaTIEdlKat;nwgcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØamitþPaBmYysMedA

bgáarRbtikmµmYyrbs;cin EdlTMngCaBitkñúgeBlEdlevotNameFVIkarvayRbharRbeTskm<úCa.

enATIRkúgjÚvy:k fac; )anrg;caMedayGt;Fµt;fa enATIbMput BYkGaemrikaMgmuxCaseRmccitþcuHhtßelxa

elIkic©RBmeRBógeFVI[manRbRktIPaBminxan. kñúgry³eBlmYyEx fac; EdlRtÚveFVI[enOyNay)an

eLIgynþehaHeTAkan;RkúgmUsÁÚmþgeTot edayqøgkat;tamTIRkúg):arIs. kñúgrdæFanIrbs;sUevot enAéf¶TI3

Exvicäika Kat;)ancUlrYmBiFImYyEdlerobcMeLIgkñúg»kasénkarcuHhtßelxasn§isBaØasUevot-evotNam.

RkúghaNUyBuMGacseRmcTTYl)ankarTTYlsÁal;EpñkkarTUtmYyrbs;GaemrikaMg EdlRtÚveFVICaGaT×mun

kareFVIshRbtibtþixageyaFaCamYyBYksUevoteLIy.

eKGacdNþwgsYrfa etIkarbþÚrKMnitPøam²rbs;BYkGaemrikaMgCaplénkarrkeXIjrbs;eKGMBI

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 333

Page 344: Brother enemy

karRbúgeRbóbcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØarvagsUevot-evotNamEmnb¤? BitehIy enAéf¶TI27 Extula

RkúghaNUy)anRbkasCasaFarN³fa eL yn; nig paM v:an;dug nwgeFVIdMeNIreTATsSnkic©CapøÚvkarenA

TIRkúgmUsÁÚkñúg«GnaKtqab;²xagmux». b:uEnþeKyl;FøúHfaenAeBlenaHBYkeKnwgcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØa

mYy ehIyenAmanmYyCMhaneTotEdlRbEhlKµanGñkNamñak;GacseRmc)aneT.

BitehIy RksYgkarbreTs)anRbwgERbgbgðajPsþútagGMBIbraC½yénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB

CamYyRbeTsevotNamkñúgkalxageRkaymkeTot. tameKeCOfa karbegáItTMnak;TMngkarTUt GaceFVI

eTA)anbnÞab;BIkarcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØasUevot-evotNam karlukluyRbeTskm<úCa nigkar

bgðaj[dwgBIerOgCnePosxøÜntamTUk. karbkRsayenH BuMKitdl;GVIeLIyebIeRbóbeFobnwgkalb,vtþi

eLIy. ehtukarN_sMxan;dMbUgBIr BitCaekItmaneRkayéf¶TI11 Extula CakalbriecäTEdl xaF½r

Rbkan;ykkarseRmccitþrbs;Kat;. cMENkkarcakecalRsukTaMghVÚg²énCnePosxøÜntamTUk)ansßit

kñúgsßanPaBRbkbedayeRKaHfñak;xøaMgBitR)akd Etkñúgry³eBlénrdUvekþAqñaM1979b:ueNÑaH42.

kñúgkareFVIsmÖasn_CabnþbnÞab;EdlKat;GnuBaØat[´CYb hUlRb‘Úk )anGHGagCaeRcInelIk

eRcInsafa KµaneBlNamYyEdlKat;seRmccitþBnüareBlkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBedayCak;lak;

eLIy. karGHGagenH mansPaBpÞúyKñay:agBitR)akdnwgskçIkmµrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI rbs; vUdxUk ehIy

ebIniyay[cMKWrbs;elak xaF½r pÞal;. tamKat;fa RbeTscinBuMmanTMnak;TMngNamYykñúgerOgenHeT ³

«mnusSeRcInNas;eCOfa kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNam )anRtÚvlHbg;edIm,ICa

KuNRbeyaCn_dl;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscin. tamkarBitKW evotNampÞal; EdlbegáIt

[mansßanPaBmYyEbbenH rhUtTal;EtBYkeKElgmanlT§PaBcUlrYmteTAmuxeTot». dUecñH karBnüar

eBlnwgRtÚvbkRsayedayehtuplbIy:ag ³ «TImYy erOgCnePosxøÜntamTUk/ TIBIr B½t’manepSg²

EdleyIgmansþIBIkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbeFVIkarlukluyRbeTskm<úCa nigTIbI kare)aHeqñateRCIserIs

sPaCan;Tab»43.

tamkarBit PaBCYnKñaénkare)aHeqñatnigkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNam -bBaða

EdlRtÚvCECkKñakñúgkRmitx<s;bMput- KWCaerOgEdleFVI[twgcitþ. b:uEnþerOgenH Føab;)anbkRsayfa

RKan;EtCakaryWty:avbnþicbnþÜcb:ueNÑaH BuMEmnCakarkat;pþac;eT. dUecñH hUlRb‘Úk )anGHGagnUv

TLðIkrN_BIreTot. rdæaPi)alnwgRtÚveFVI[RBÜy)armÖBIRbtikmµepSg²rbs;saFarNCn kñúgkarebIk

sßanTUtmYyenATIRkúghaNUy cMeBlEdlsßanIy_TUrTsSn_nanapSBVpSayBaseBjRbeTsnUvrUbPaB

CnePosxøÜntamTUkEdlkMBugrt;ecjBIRbeTsevotNam. rdæaPi)alP½yxøacERkgmankarpÞúHecjnUv

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg334

Page 345: Brother enemy

kartv:aRbqaMgmYy. bEnßmBIerOgenH KWGtßiPaBénr)aykarN_sm¶at;mYysþIBIkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbeFVI

s®gÁamRbqaMgnwgRbeTskm<úCa. b:uEnþ TLðIkrN_TaMgGs;enH nwgrwtEteFVI[eCOCak;edayminGacRbEkk

)an ebIsinCa hUlRb‘Úk nigbNþashkarIKat;enARksYgkarbreTsbnþeFVIkargareBjry³eBlén

Extula edayeFVIhak;dUcCaKµanGVIekIteLIgesaH sþIBIkarebIksßanTUtGaemrikaMgenATIRkúghaNUy.

enAsrTrdUvqñaM1978 ÉksarmYyEdleRbIsRmab;Bnül;GMBICMhrrbs;RksYgkarbreTs )an

pþl;nUvkarbkRsaymYyxusKñaTaMgRsugsþIBIkarkat;pþac;karBiPakSaCamYyRbeTsevotNam. cMENk

GUklI vij ehobnwgTTYlsÁal;enAcMeBaHmux´eTAehIyfa lkçxNÐfµI²Edldak;[evotNamBinitüenA

éf¶TI 30 Extula RKan;EtCaelsmYysMedAbiT)aMgkarpøas;bþÚrKMnitPøam²rbs;GaemrikaMgb:ueNÑaH.

enAExkBaØa hUlRb‘Úk Føab;)anBiPakSaerOgTaMgbIenHCamYy fac; Edr edaymineFVI[man]bsKÁNamYy

dl;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeT. dUecñH GñkNamYyEdlpþl;bBa¢abgá[mankaryl;Tas;fµI²eTot?.

edIm,IkarBarxøÜnBIerOgenH GUklI )anRbEkkfa ³ «BuMmankarbgÁab;bBa¢arbs;estvimaneT. Pøam²enaH

GUesnbWk k¾rkBuMeXIjGVI²Edl)anekIteLIg ehIy)anbBa©úHbBa©ÚlRbFanaFibtI[pþl;eTA v:an;s_ nUv

esckþIbgÁab;fµI²eTot». tamkarsnñidæan enHehIyCaKMnitrbs;Kat;nigKMnitrbs; hUlRb‘Úk. «eyIg

manbMNgR)ab;evotNam[dwgBImUlehtuepSg² EdlnaMeTAdl;braC½yénkarcrcaEdr»44.

´)ansYr hUlRb‘Úk fa enAeBlNaEdlKat;R)ab;[evotNamdwgBIkarseRmccitþrbs; xaF½r?.

b:uEnþvaTMngCaBitEdlfa kñúg»kasénkareFVIdMeNIrrbs;Kat;enAGasuIGaeKñy_ Kat;)anlatRtdagfa

erOgr:avxøHmandMeNIrminl¥eT. enAéf¶TI31 Extula TIPñak;garB½t’man yU>PI>Gay nigkaEst Nasüúg

enARkúg)agkk )annaMmkniyaynUvsmþIsnÞnaxøH²EdleKsnµtfaCarbs;Kat; EdlfakareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBrvagGaemrikaMg-evotNamGacekItmanmunry³eBlBIrEx. kartv:aCabnþbnÞab;tamTUrs½BÞ

EdlehAmkKat;BITIRkúgv:asuInetan KWCaRbpñÚlminl¥mYy. hUlRb‘Úk )anRbEkky:agxøaMgkøa b:uEnþ

lkçN³xageRkAénerOgr:avKWsuT§EtpÞúynwgKMnitKat; ³ B½t’man)ancab;epþImelcB¤sussaybnÞab;BIkar

CYbrbs;Kat;CamYynaykrdæm®nþIéf eRKógsak; qUm:aNnþ mYys)aþh_. dUecñH karvinicä½y)anelc

ecjCaBiessBIkñúgcMeNamshkarIKat;enARksYgkarbreTsfa Kat;TMngCa)anniyayKYr[mnÞilEmn

ehIyfa mü:ageTotKat;GacCaGñkminecHlak;Gaf’kM)aMgtaMgBIdMbUgmkpg.

eRkaymk ´man»kas)aneFVIsmÖassakSICaeRcInnak; TaMgGaemrikaMg TaMgéf. vabgðajfa

hUlRb‘Úk BuM)ankMNt;kalbriecäTNamYycMeBaHkarbegáItTMnak;TMngkarTUtCamYyRbeTsevotNam

eLIy. CamYynwg GaR)am:UvIt EdlCMnan;enaHCaÉkGKÁrdæTUtenARbeTséf Kat;)anCRmab eRKógsak;

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 335

Page 346: Brother enemy

[dwgBIxøwmsarénkarsnÞnarbs;Kat;CamYy fac; kalBIExkBaØa edayminePøcerobrab;R)ab;BIkare)aHbg;

rbs;evotNam Edlcg;[sgkarxUcxatedaysars®gÁamCamunsinmunnwgP¢ab;TMnak;TMngkarTUteLIg

vijpg. BYkemdwknaMéf )ansnñidæanBIerOgenHedaysmehtuplfa karbegáItTMnak;TMngkarTUtrvag

RbeTsTaMgBIr KWc,as;CaekItmankñúgeBlqab;². b:uEnþ RbeTséfk¾dUcRbeTsTaMgGs;énsmaKm

Gas‘anP½yxøacERkgfa kñúgkarRbjab;Rbjal;rbs;Kat; edIm,IeFVI[TMnak;TMngGaemrikaMg-evotNam

manRbRktIPaB hUlRb‘Úk muxCaePøcKitbNþamitþcas;²rbs;Kat;enAGasuIminxan. dUecñH BYkemdwknaM

RbeTsTaMgenH)anpþÜcepþImKMnitpSBVpSay[dwgB¤tamsarB½t’mannUvsmþIsnÞnarbs; hUlRb‘Úk eday

bEnßmbnßytictYckñúgkþIsgÇwmraMgrakarRbRBwtþeTAénRbtibtþikarrbs;Kat;. kñúgGtßbTrbs;kaEst

Nasüúg )anniyayesI²EbbCa]TahrN_ BitNas;edIm,IbeRmIeKalbMNgRbeTscinfa kareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBGaemrikaMg-evotNam «TMngCanwgekItmanmun» karbegáItTMnak;TMngkarTUtrvagRbeTscin

nigshrdæGaemrik. karelcFøayerOgsm¶at;)anbNþal[manlT§plEdleKTukcitþelI. karniyay

bdiesFrbs;estvimannigRksYgkarbreTs)anekItmanBIrb¤bIem:ageRkaymk. edayeFVI[ hUlRb‘Úk

Gn;citþbnþicbnþÜc GñknaMBakürbs;RksYgkarbreTs hUDIg xaF½r )anRbkasfa «KµansmaCikNamñak;

rbs;rdæaPi)alGaemrikaMgGacGHGagbBa¢ak;BIerOgmYyEbbenaHeT». Kat;)anbBa¢ak;«RbkbedayPaB

muWgm:at;cugeRkay»fa ³ «rdæaPi)alGaemrikaMgminTan;Qandl;karseRmccitþNamYyGMBIkalbriecäTén

kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCayfaehtumYyeLIy. rdæaPi)alBuMTan;Qandl;kic©RBmeRBógNamYyTaMg

karRtÚvr:UvNamYyCamYyevotNameT». enHBuMEmnCakarBiteT b:uEnþ xøwmsarRtÚvTTYl)any:agc,as;

las;bMput. Rkúgeb:kaMgRtÚv)aneFVI[)at;P½yRBÜy ehIybNþasm<½n§mitþenAGasuIGaeKñy_k¾G‘ÍcwgEdr.

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anxwgdac;k,aldac;knÞúy enAeBlEdlKat;dwgBIBaküccamGar:amepSg²manRbPB

mkBIRkúg)agkk EdltamKat;yl;KWbMpuseLIgeday hUlRb‘Úk. b:uEnþ Kat;enAminTan;Gs;karegOgq¶l;

rbs;Kat;enAeLIyeT. sßanIylYcsþab;rbs;es>GuI>Ga> EdlmanbnÞúkeFVIcarkic©elIkarTak;TgKñatam

TUrs½BÞenAxagkñúg]bTVIb\NÐÚcin)ancab;)ansarmYyenAéf¶TI31 Extula EdlmanlkçN³esÞIrEteFVI[

GaCIBrbs; hUlRb‘Úk vinasGnþrayeTAehIy. GUesnbWk manGakar³migmaMgeBjry³eBlénkar

GanesckþIcmøgRbcaMéf¶Edlft)anedayPñak;garesuIbkarN_rbs;Kat;. enaHKWCaGtßbTbBa¢ÚnmkBI

cm¶aymYyCaPasaevotNam EdlGñkeqøIyqøgénTIPñak;garB½t’manevotNamenATIRkúgevogc½nÞ bBa¢Ún

eTAkariyal½yrbs;xøÜnenATIRkúghaNUy. GñkkaEstrUbenaH)anTajehtusMGagtam«\sSrCn

GaemrikaMgmñak;»fa bnÞab;BIkare)aHeqñatExvicäika «rdæaPi)al xaF½r RbEhlCaGaceFVI[TMnak;TMngrbs;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg336

Page 347: Brother enemy

xøÜnmanRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNamdMNalKñanwgRbeTscinEdr ehIyecosvagfa kareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscinmineFVI[KaMgdl;kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNameLIy».

b:uEnþ lixitTUrelx)anbBa¢ak;BI«karekobsgát;Edl Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI eFVIeTAelIGñkTTYlxusRtÚvenARksYg

karbreTs edIm,IjúaMg[BYkenaHbnþeFVIkarTak;TajcitþRbeTscinteTAeTot ehIyBwgEp¥kerOgTaMgGs;

enaH edIm,IRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNam». lixitTUrelxenaHmanbMNgedIm,IbBa©b;«karTTYlsVaKmn_

y:agkk;ekþA» EdleRtómeday hUlRb‘Úk sRmab;GñktMNagmñak;rbs;RbeTsevotNamkñúg»kasén

BiFITTYlbdisNæarkic©mYyenATIRkúgevogc½nÞEdr. GñkkarTUtGaemrikaMg«)anR)ab;KUsnÞnarbs;Kat;

CamYykarsb,ayrIkrayelcecjmkeRkAfa Kat;eTIbnwg)anCYbeFVIkarsnÞnaCamYy egVón kUfac;

ehIyfa shkarImñak;kñúgcMeNamshkarICaeRcInnak;rbs;Kat;enATIRkúgjÚvy:k )aneFVIkarR)aRs½y

Tak;TgCab;CaRbcaMCamYy fac; dEdlenH». Kat;)ansEmþg[eXIj«suTidæiniymy:agxøaMgcMeBaHTsSn

vis½yepSg²kñúgkareFVI[TMnak;TMngrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrmanRbRktIPaBeLIgvij». GñkeqøIyqøgén

TIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam)anbkRsaysmþIsnÞnarbs; hUlRb‘Úk fa CasarmYynigCa«kayvikar

RbkbedaymitþPaB»mYy EdlbBa¢ÚneTAkan;RbeTsevotNam. kñúgTwkmuxesøksøaMg GUesnbWk )andak;

GtßbTenHenAelItueFVIkarrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI ehIyesñI[elak xaF½r beNþj hUlRb‘Úk ecjBIkargar.

enAeBlEdlkarxkcitþjaMjIKat; hUlRb‘Úk RtÚveKeXIjenAkñúgTIRkúgLasSÚ (Lashio) sßitenAtam

pøÚv Burma Road [CapøÚvCatid¾sMxan;enARbeTsPUmaP¢ab;TIRkúgr:g;hÁÚneTARbeTscin] EdlCaRsukmYyman

eTsPaBRss;Rtkal b:uEnþenAdac;q¶ayBIeK ehIyCamYyTIRkúgenH RksYgkarbreTs)anrkSakar

Tak;TgepSg²edayeTogTat;. sßanTUtGaemrikaMgenATIRkúgr:g;hÁÚn)anvayTUrelxeTA[Kat;CabnÞan;

edIm,IR)ab;dMNwgepSg²EdlecjmkBIRkúg)agkk nigkarbdiesFrbs;Rkúgv:asuInetan. mü:ageTot

v:an;s_ )ansaksYreTAkan; hUlRb‘Úk GMBIxøwmsarBitR)akdénesckþIRbkasrbs;Kat;Edr. R)akdEmn

hUlRb‘Úk )anbdiesFkarTTYlxusRtÚvTaMgGs;. eRkaymk Kat;man»kasbkRsayBIerOgenHfa «enA

CMnan;enaH vamanPaBtantwgy:agxøaMgrvagRksYgkarbreTs nigestviman. eK)ansakl,geFVI[´

TTYlrgkarTTYlxusRtÚvTaMgGs;GMBIbraC½ymYy. kñúgerOgr:avTImYyKW GaR)am:UvIt )anRbEkkdac;

GhgáarBIesckþIseRmccitþepSg² EdlKat;cat;TukfaCarbs;´. v:an;s_ )anCYykarBar´eTAkan;elak

xaF½r ehIyGVI²RtÚv)anRBmeRBógKña. kñúgerOgr:avTIBIrRkúmes>GuI>Ga> )aneFVIGegátehIy)ansnñidæanBI

RbtibtþikarpSBVpSayB½t’manPUtkuhkmYy EdlTMngCarbs;sUevot»45. tamkarBit hUlRb‘Úk )an

RtÚv[rYcBiruT§edayGtßbTrbs;GñkkaEstBIrrUbKWelak rUvLg; GuIv:an nig rUbWt NUv:ak; EdlBnül;Evk

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 337

Page 348: Brother enemy

Ejky:agc,as;fa r)aykarN_épÞkñúgrbs;TIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam KWCa])aymYyrbs;sUevot

sMedAeFVI[TMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMg KaMgdMeNIr nigeFVI[ekItmankarEbk)ak;KñakñúgrdæaPi)al xaF½r46.

tam hUlRb‘Úk fa karRbsBVKñaénehtukarN_TaMgBIrenHKW ehtukarN_enATIRkúg)agkknigehtu

karN_enATIRkúgevogc½nÞ manlkçN³CakarXubXitKñabRmúgbMpøajnrNamñak;. Kat;niyayfa «enaHKW

hak;dUcCanrNamñak; )anepþImeFVI[´vinastamrebobCak,Ün». tamkarBit ebIsinCaekItmankar

XubXitEmn KWBuMEmnCasñaédrbs;emKMnitEtmñak;eT. karelcFøayerOgsm¶at;enARkúg)agkkebItam

hUlRb‘Úk faCa«esckþIdkRsg;EdlP½nþRcLM»kñúgeKalbMNgeFVI[Gnþraydl;karcrcarvagGaemrikaMg-

evotNam EdlCaerOgbeRmIplRbeyaCn_rbs;RbeTséf nigRbeTscinenAmunkare)aHeqñateRCIs

erIssPaCan;TabGaemrikaMg. k¾b:uEnþ lixitTUrelxrbs;TIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam KWmanlkçN³bMpus

bMpulRbqaMgcin. mü:ageTot TUrelxminEdlpSay[dwgTal;EtesaHnUvGVIEdlGac[eKKitfa lixitTUr

elxenHRKan;EtbBa¢Únecj edIm,I[BYkGaemrikaMg b¤BYkcinsáat;cab;)anb:ueNÑaH. GVIEdlmansarsMxan;

kñúgerOgenH KWkarbMéPølkçN³BiténB½t’manepSg²EdlbBa¢Ún edayTIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam.

vaCak;R)akdNas;Edlfa hUlRb‘Úk )anCYbParFarIrbs;evotNamenATIRkúgevogc½nÞ kñúg»kasénBiFI

bdisNæarkic©mYyEdlpþl;edaysmPaKIGaemrikaMgrbs;Kat;. hUlRb‘Úk dMNalfa «´niyayBakü

sYsþIeTAkan;Kat; b:uEnþ ´R)afñafacg;«elIkédCasBaØamitþPaBd¾kk;ekþA»eTArkKat;eTot EdlenHKWCakar

bgçÚcRTg;RTayénkarBitmYy». hUlRb‘Úk )ankarBarxøÜny:agxøaMgkøa Edl)anriHKn;buKÁlb¤neya)ay

sñiT§cinrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI rebobdUcEdlKat;RtÚvrdæaPi)alsþIbenÞasedaymincMeBaHEdr.

vaminTMngTal;EtesaHEdlfa hUlRb‘Úk )anniyayEbbenHeTAkan;GñkkarTUtevotNammñak;

eTaHbICamenaseBa©tnapÞal;xøÜnrbs;Kat;k¾eday. b:uEnþ lixitTUrelxrbs;TIPñak;garB½t’manevotNamBuM

)anbBa¢ak;BI«\sSrCnfñak;x<s;rbs;GaemrikaMg» EdleRCIserIsKUsnÞnaevotNammñak; edIm,Iniyay

R)ab;erOglak;kM)aMgrbs;xøÜneLIy. vaRKan;EtCabBaðaén «karsnÞnaKñaCasm¶at;»mYyb:ueNÑaH.

GñkeqøIyqøgénTIPñak;garB½t’manevotNamenATIRkúgevogc½nÞ dageKon man»kas)anCYbCECkKñaCamYy

BYkGaemrikaMg KWsmaCikshKmn_sasnaRbÚetsþg; EdlkMBugsñak;enAkñúgrdæFanIevogc½nÞCajwkjy

rYmTaMgCamYyGñkkaEstelakxaglic EdleFVIdMeNIrqøgkat;tamTIenaHmþgmáalpg. Kat;GacEsVg

yl;BIBYkeK-elIkElgEtvaBuMEmnCaRbPBkarTUt-nUvRbvtþiénkarEbk)ak;Kñarvag Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI nig

hUlRb‘Úk. mü:ageTot evotNammanehtuplxøH² EdleFVI[rIkraykñúgcitþGMBI karN_Edlfa Gñkkar

TUtmñak;kñúgcMeNamGñkkarTUtrbs;BYkeK RtÚv)anGeBa¢Ij[eTAnievsndæanrbs;ParFarIGaemrikaMgEdl

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg338

Page 349: Brother enemy

nwgGacBnül;nUvesckþIraykarN_eBareBjeTAedaykarsb,aycitþbnþicbnþÜccMeBaHRBwtþikarN_enaH

Edlpþl;edayGñkeqøIyqøgénTIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam. enATIbMput vaGacfa elak hUlRb‘Úk-enA

TIRkúgevogc½nÞ k¾dUcenATIRkúg)agkkBImun-Føab;)anrMB£kRbkbedayKMnitsuTidæiniymd¾Cak;lak;mYy GMBI

TsSnvis½yénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBrvagGaemrikaMg-evotNampgEdr. dUecñHkar):an;sµanmunmYy

GMBIl,icklrbs;sUevotminGacFIbecjTaMgRsugeT eRBaHvaTMngxøaMgNas;Edlfa lixitTUrelxenH

BitCalixitTUrelxrbs;GñkeqøIyqøgB½t’mankñúgRsukmñak; EdlkMBugbBa¢ÚndMNwgeTA[BYkecAhVaynay

rbs;Kat;. ebIKit[hµt;ct;eTA lixitTUrelxRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚnenAéf¶bnÞab;BIkarecjdMeNIrrbs; hUlRb‘Úk

eTAkan;RbeTsPUma. etImanGVIFmµtaCagenH?. b:uEnþ ebIBinitü[eRCARCHeTAcMNucsMxan;BuMEmnenARtg;

enaHeT. hYsBIkaredaHRsaytampøÚvKMnit GMBIkarXubXitbRmúgk,t;CayfaehtumYy erOgr:avenARkúg

)agkknigRkúgevogc½nÞbgðaj[eXIj CaBiessfa rhUtmkdl;eBlenH hUlRb‘Úk mindwgGVITaMgGs;GMBI

karbnßyskmµPaBkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNam.

hUlRb‘Úk )anrYcxøÜnBIkarP½yTaMgRbputRbepIy. mhnþraypÞal;xøÜnRtÚv)anecosvagTaMgBi)ak.

k¾b:uEnþ karRbLÚkb:Uk):akrbs;Kat;CamYy Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI nig GUesnbWk )anbnSl;danepSg² EdlminGac

lub)an. karTak;TgKñarbs;GñkTaMgenaH minEdle)aHbg;ecalGakb,kiriyaeRbIsmþItwgEtgdak;Kña

Tal;EtesaH. karxMRbwgERbgTaMgGs;rbs;Kat;taMgBIBIrqñaMmkehIy edIm,IP¢ab;TMnak;TMngeLIgvijCamYy

RbeTsevotNam)anRtÚveFVI[rlaysUnü. enAeBlEdl hUlRb‘Úk RtLb;cUlmkRkúgv:asuInetanvij

naedImExvicäika TsSnvis½yénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNam minEdlRtÚvTat;ecal

dUceBlenHeT. edaybBa©Úlvasnarbs;xøÜnCamYyvasnarbs;RbeTscin shrdæGaemrik)anseRmc

citþbdiesFtYnaTInaMmuxeK EdlRtÚv)anmkxøÜnvijenAGasuI. enAGasuICaTIEdls®gÁamsßitenAekokxøÜn

bMput.

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 339

Page 350: Brother enemy

semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu ³ rYcputBIeRKaHfñak;

enATIRkúgPñMeBjevlaRBwkéf¶TI1 Exmkra qñaM1978 xül;GakasmansPaBRtCak;KYrsm.

semþc sIhnu cab;ebIkviTüúm:ak RhánDik rbs;RBHGgÁ edIm,IsNþab;B½t’manepSg²EdlpSayecjBIviTüú

PñMeBj. tamTmøab;dUcsBVdg RBHGgÁeRcInmYlebIksMeLg[B¤xøaMg²kñúgeKalbMNgmin[BYkGñkyam

l,atdwgBIskmµPaBepSg²rbs;RBHGgÁenAkñúgRBHraCdMNak; ehIyenHKWCakareFVI[GñkyamTaMgenaH

eCOBIKMnitesñhaCatimatuPUmirbs;RBHGgÁ eRcInCagsþab;dMNwgedayBitR)akd. KYr[PJak;ep¥IlEmn¡.

éf¶enH kmµviFIpSayRtÚv)anEkERb. CMnYskarcak;pSayceRmógbdivtþn_sþIBI vIrPaBkmµkr ksikr nig

kgT½Bd¾CajC½yrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyü karBiBN’naminQb;QrsþIBIlT§plénkarRcÚtkat;b¤kar

ksagkm<úCafµI viTüúEbrCapSaynUvdMNwgmYyEdleFVI[RsLaMgkaMgeTAvij. rdæaPi)alkm<úCaeTIbnwgkat;

pþac;TMnak;TMngepSg²xagkarTUtCamYyRbeTsevotNam Edl)anRbRBwtþelµIseday«karQøanBan

minsmehtupl nigEdlmanlkçN³FMeFgmYy» RbqaMgnwgkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. semþc sIhnu Føab;

dwgcitþBYkevotNamc,as;las;Nas; BitEmnEteBlenHRBHGgÁmindwgRbkan;RBH\riyabfEbbNakñúg

erOgenHk¾eday ³ kic©karrbs; b:ul Bt Bi)aknwg[RBHGgÁcUlrYmNas;.

enAExmIna qñaM1973 kñúg»kasénRBHraCdMeNIrtamtMbn;rMedaHnana PaBtantwgEdlminTan;

ecjCak;EsþgrvagExµrRkhm nig«smmitþ»evotNameKcBMuputBIRkEsRBHenRtrbs;RBHGgÁeLIy.

taMgBIeBlenaHmk RBHGgÁRtÚvcaMXøaMemIlGFikrN_rvagBYkenHsin. enAExkBaØa qñaM1975 kñúg»kas

eFVIRBHraCTsSnkic©mYyenATIRkúghaNUy paM v:an;dug )anTUlR)ab;RBHGgÁenAcMeBaHmux exov sMpn fa

RbeTsevotNammanesckþITukcitþEtelIRBHGgÁpÞal;b:ueNÑaH. BIrb¤bIs)aþh_eRkaymk eBlRtLb;mk

RkúgPñMeBjvij exov sMpn nig sun esn )anTUlR)ab;RBHGgÁnUvTsSn³rbs;xøÜnsþIBIevotNameday

KµansMécmat;fa CaGñkKMramkMEhgGtßiPaBRbeTskm<úCapÞal;. tameyabl;GñkTaMgBIrfa karKMram

kMEhgenHminRtwmEteFVI[eyIgebþCJabeNþjCnCatievotNamTaMgGs;ecjBIRbeTsbu:eNÑaHeT Efm

TaMgpþl;CameFüa)aysRmab;eyIgcab;bgçMedaykmøaMgT½B[RkúghaNUyTTYlsÁal;RBMEdnsmuRTnigEdn

eKak«RbkbedayyutþiFm’»CagmuneTotpg.

ebItamkareXasnarbs;viTüúPñMeBjfa enAedImqñaM1978 RtÚv)ankt;smÁal;edayeCaKC½yd¾

Gs©arüCabnþbnÞab;KñamYyeTAelIBYkQøanBanevotNam. R)akdehIy KµanGñkNamñak;KaMRTkareBal

GagTaMgenHEdleKpSBVpSaytamviTüúeLIy. semþc sIhnu dwgc,as;BIeRKaHfñak;y:agem:c²ehIy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg340

Page 351: Brother enemy

cMeBaHkarttaMgnwgkgT½BevotNamEdleCaKCaMkúñgcm,aMgeTAehIyenaH. b:uEnþ RBHGgÁ)anrkSaTukkar

fb;)armÖenHEtkñúgRBHhb£T½yb:ueNÑaH. kñúgsarlixitmYyepJIeTA[ b:ul Bt RBHGgÁ)anesñI[eRbIkitþis½BÞ

rbs;RBHGgÁedIm,IbeRmICatimatuPUmiEdr. b:uEnþ\t)ankar. semþc)anmanRBHraCbnÞÚlfa «ExµrRkhm

minRBmTTYlkaresñIrbs;´kñúgkarbeRmICatieT BIeRBaHBYkeKfa esckþIseRmccitþ)anRbkan;ykeRsc

eTAehIy ³ C½yCmñHrbs;eKnwgmanTMhMelIsBIC½yCmñH enAéf¶17 Exemsa qñaM1975eTAeTot [Caéf¶

EdlRkúgPñMeBjFøak;kñúgkNþab;édBYkeK]». enAeBlEdlRBHGgÁRTg;RCabtamviTüúBIkarGeBa¢Ijmkdl;

RkúgPñMeBjrbs;elakCMTavemm:ay CU eGnLay KWGñkRsI etg yIgCav enaH semþc)annwksgÇwmfa

RBHGgÁnwgRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[CYbsnÞnaCamYyKat;minxan. elakRsI etg )anRtÚvCUnB½t’man[dwgfa

semþc sIhnu BMucg;CYbR)aRs½yCamYyGñkNamñak;eT. CaCMnYselakRsI)anRtÚv exov b:uNÑarI Priya

emdwknaMExµrRkhm ¬b:ul Bt¦ GeBa¢IjcUlrYmkñúgkarRss;RsUbGahareBll¶acmYy rYmCamYybNþa

PriyaénemdwknaMExµrRkhmCaeRcInnak;eTot. Bakücak;edatbBaÄWcitþRbqaMgevotNamnigsmþIek¥gk¥ag

BIerOgcm,aMgEdlpSayecjral;éf¶BIviTüúPñMeBj )anjúaMg[semþceCOfa b:ul Bt enAEtminRBmemIl

karBit[cMBImuxeLIy.

dMeNaHRsaypþac;RB½RtGMBIbBaðaevotNam dUcEdl b:ul Bt eRKagKitmin)aneFVI[semþc

egOgq¶l;eLIy. eK)anrMB£ktamk,ÜnnBVnþd¾KYr[RBWxøactamviTüúRkúgPñMeBjfa CnCatiExµrmñak;²Gac

smøab;CnCatievotNamsamsibnak; dUecñHeyIgmanmnusSlµmRKb;RKan;edIm,IkemÞcRbCaBlrdæ

hasiblannak;EdleKeFVICMerOnenARbeTsevotNam1.

Rtg;kEnøgenH vamanerOgr:avEdlRtÚvesIck¾dUcRtÚveFVI[ekþARkhayEdr. k¾b:uEnþGVIEdlR)akd

RbCaEmnETn KWkarGMBavnav[mankaregIbbHe)armYyRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt EdlpSayecjBIviTüúRkúg

haNUyÉeNaH. dUecñH rbbEdlKYr[xøacrn§t;)ancab;epþImregÁaHregÁIRKwHxøÜnÉg. semþc sIhnu Edl

)andwgerOgenHenAExkBaØa qñaM1978 k¾P½yxøacEdr enAeBlEdlRBHGgÁsmÁal;eXIjCafµInUvkmµvtßúén

kareR)asRbNIrbs;ExµrRkhmenH. exov sMpn )anyagRBHGgÁeTAeFVITsSnacrfµImYyenAtamextþ.

elIkenH eKaledAKWeFVI[semþc)anCYbTak;TgnwgRbCara®sþrbs;RBHGgÁ nigeFVI[GñkTaMgenaHeCOfa

semþcpþl;nUvkarKaMRTmYymkelIrbbenHTaMgRsug. enAkMBg;EpkMBg;esamnigenA)at;dMbg RBHGgÁ

GacyagcUleTACitBYkkmµkrEdlTTYlsVaKmn_RBHGgÁedaykarTHédGbGrsaTr.

sRmab;eBlenH GVI²k¾l¥RbesIrsRmab;TTYlykEdr. enAeBlRtLb;mkdl;PñMeBjvij semþc

sIhnu )anRtÚvGeBa¢Ij[cUlrYmkñúgBiFImYyEdl exov sMpn ehAfa «karCb;elogd¾sñiT§sñalmYy

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 341

Page 352: Brother enemy

Cakitþiysdl;GñkesñhaCatimatuPUmi» enAkñúgnievsndæanrbs;rdæaPi)al¬xagekItvtþPñM¦ EdleKeRtóm

TuksRmab;EtTTYlePJóvCan;x<s;rbs;rdæbu:eNÑaH. kñúg»kasCb;elogd¾sm,ÚrmðÚbeBarBas RBHGgÁ

sgÇwmfa nwgCYbRbTHGtItGñkrYmKMnitnwgRBHGgÁKW Eb:n nut Caminxan. k¾b:uEnþ«vtþmanshkarId¾CitsñiT§

rbs;RBHGgÁBIrrUbKWGtItrdæm®nþIkarbreTs sarin qak nigGtItrdæm®nþIpÁt;pÁg;sBVavuF dYg sMGul )aneFVI

[RBHGgÁPJak;ep¥IlCageK. GñkTaMgBIrmanGakar³dUcQWcukcab;kñúgxøÜny:agxøaMgrhUtesÞIrEtminh‘an

emIlmkRBHGgÁ». semþc sIhnu TtesÞIrEtminsÁal;nUvrUbragsÁmkMRBwgniggk;egIk²rbs; sarin qak

EdlCabNÐitc,ab;d¾eqñImmñak;ERbeTACay:agdUecñHesaH EdlniekçbTbNÐitrbs;Kat;sþIBIRBMEdnExµr-evot

NamenHehIyEdlpþl;[ b:ul Bt eFVICaTLðIkrN_ sRmab;bEnßmeTAelIkarTamTarTwkdIrbs;Kat;- enH

CakarcMGkbBaÄWcitþd¾CUrct;bMput. sarin qak EdlsßitenATIenHmanTwkmuxesøksøaMgdUcmuxexµac bnÞab;BI

)aneFVIkarCaTm¶n; nigsuIGt;suIXøanGs;CaeRcInqñaM ehIyk¾CakmµvtßúénkarykcitþTukdak;dUcsemþcEdr.

kñúgeBlbriePaK)ay eGog sarI nig eGog FIriT§ EdlFøab;bBa¢ÚnGñksIhnuniym nigGñkts‘UmYycMnYn

edaypÞal;[eTArkesckþIsøab;enaH k¾xMRbECgnwgkarykcitþTukdak;enHdUcKña. R)akdehIy Gñkkan;

m:asuInftmñak;)aneRtómxøÜnft RBwtþikarN_enHTuk[sßitenACaGmt³. BIr-bIs)aþh_eRkaymk kñúg

»kasénkareFVIdMeNIreTAkan; RkúgjÚvy:kedIm,IcUlrYmmhasnñi)atGgÁkarshRbCaCati eGog sarI

minePøcEckrUbft BiFICb;elogenH[GñkkarTUtnigGñkkaEsteLIy. rUbftmYysnøwkGacPUtkuhk

)anEmneT? GaRs½yehtuenHehIy eTaHbICamanBaküccamGar:ambMPitbMP½yEbbNak¾eday

k¾rUbftenH bgðaj[eXIjfa semþcBitCaenAmanRBHCnµEmn ehIyfa RBHGgÁKg;enARbeTskm<úCadUc

bNþaGtItshkarIrbs;RBHGgÁEdr RBHGgÁenAEtCardæbursd¾sMxan;KYr[eKarBmñak;dEdl.

y:agehac dMeNIryagRtLb;edaykareyaKyl;rbs;semþc sIhnu mkkm<úCavij )anbNþal

[manplGaRkk;mYyEdlmin)anKitTukCamun. ExµrRkhmhak;dUcCaxVl;xVaynwgsnþisuxrbs;RBHGgÁ

Pøam²Etmþg. RBHraCdMNak;rbs;RBHGgÁkñúgRBHbrmraCvaMgElgmansuvtßiPaBRKb;RKan;eTotehIy.

BYkeKnwkKitCamYynwgkarERkgrEGgfasYnc,arRBHraCvaMgmansPaBlðelðv\tmanGVIkarBarBIkarvay

qµk;rbs;hVÚg]T§mÖaKcRksRtÚvesaH. semþc sIhnu BMuEmnCamnusSEdleKgaye)akbeBaäatenaHeT.

karP½yxøacBitR)akdrbs;RBHGgÁKWxøacevotNammkcab;BRgt;RBHGgÁ ehIybM)at;GVI²EdlGacnaM[

seRmclT§pleRcInRbkarrbs;RBHGgÁenAelIqakGnþrCatiÉeNaH. semþc)anRtÚvepÞr[eTAKg;Rbfab;

enAkñúgnievsndæanmYyB½T§CMuvijedayrbgsuIm:g;t_x<s;²niglYsbnøa ehIymanTMhMtUcCagmuneTAeTot.

karRbúgRby½tñTaMgenHBMuEmn\tRbeyaCn_eLIy. rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam egVón kUfac; )anniyay

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg342

Page 353: Brother enemy

R)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦CaeRcIn qñaMeRkaymkeTotfa evotNamBitCa)anerobcMKeRmagkarcab;BRgt;semþc

sIhnu Emn muneBlEdlRBHGgÁminTan;epÞrecjBIRBHbrmraCvaMgeTAeTot.

enAelIdMbUlGKarx<s;mYyEdlenACitenaH ExµrRkhm)andak;taMgeRKÓgbMPøWy:ageRcIn tRmg;eTA

rknievsndæanfµIrbs;RBHGgÁCaerogral;yb;. sMNMuBnøW)anqøgkat;rnaMgsøabRBil ¬EdlrUt)an¦ BImçag

eTAmçag)acsacrsµIeBjbnÞb; eFVI[semþc sIhnu nigGñkmñag m:Unik Bi)akpÞMbMput. enAkñúgbnÞb;enaHemIl

eTAPøWdUceBléf¶G‘IcwgxN³Edlsemþc sIhnu dNþwgsYrkñúgRBHT½yfa etIGñkyamrbs;RBHGgÁmanlYc

segátBinitüemIlskmµPaBRBHGgÁnigmehsItamEkvyitEdreT?.

eRkABIkarCab;rvl;sNþab;B½t’mantamviTüú semþc)ancMNayeBlevlaTtesovePAnigeron

PasaeGs,aj:úlEfmeTot. kareFVImðÚbGaharKWCakarkmSanþEtmYyKt;rbs;RBHGgÁkñúgbNþaéf¶d¾Gab;GY

nigtwgEtgTaMgenaH. enHKWCacMNg;cMNUlRBHT½yEdlmantaMgBIedImmkrbs;RBHGgÁ. k,ÜneFVImðÚbGahar

EdlRBHGgÁecHpSMeRKÓgeRKA KWCakarbBa©ÚlKñamYyrvagrsCatiExµrnigrsCati)araMg EdlRBHGgÁman

karecHdwgy:ageRCARCH. enAyb;éf¶TI24 ExFñÚ qñaM1978 RBHGgÁ)anRbjab;Rbjal;begIðykic©kar

c®gáan)ayPøam²enAeBlEdlGñkmñag m:Unik ERskehARBHGgÁ[mksNþab;B½t’mantamviTüú. kñúg

RBwtþibRtB½t’manrbs;xøÜn viTüúpSaysMeLgshrdæGaemrik)anRbkas[dwgfa elak m:al;xUm xadEv:l

GñkÉkeTssBa¢atiGg;eKøsxagbBaðaGasuI EdlkMBugeFVITsSnkic©enAkm<úCaRbCaFibetyürYmCamYyGñk

kaEstelakxaglicBIrnak;eTot RtÚv)aneKlYcsmøab;enAkñúgnievsndæanrbs;Kat;enAPñMeBj. BYkrdæ

GMNackm<úCa)anTmøak;kMhuseTAelIevotNamBIGMeBImnusSXatedayectnaenH. semþc sIhnu

RTg;RBHtRmiHfa erOgenHdUcCaminTMngTal;EtesaH.

semþcRTg;RCabc,as;Nas;fa kñúgkm<úCaRbCaFibetyürbs; b:ul Bt eKminGacCnøelgCamYy

nwgsnþisuxrbs;GñkNamñak;eLIy. xadEv:l nigGñkkaEstGaemrikaMgBIrnak;BitCa)anRtÚveKkarBar

y:agmFü½t. edayrebobNaeTA Edlkumµ:g;dUmYyRkúmGacqøgkat;r)aMgkarBarrbs;TahanExµrRkhm

EdleKerobdak;Cab;²Kñaedaymin[BYkenHemIleXIjeTotenaH?. ehtuGVI)anCaBYkkum:g;dUsÁal;

xadEv:l nigdwgBIbnÞb;EdlKat;edk?. semþc)anKitsµanEtRBHGgÁÉgfa ³ ebIsinCaevotNamGac

beBa©jsñaédmYyEbbenHEmnenaH snþisuxrbs; b:ul Bt k¾sßitkñúgeRKaHfñak;dUcKñaEdr. TMngCaBit

CagenHeTAeTotKW b:ul Bt xøÜnÉgEtmþgEdlCaemKMnitkñúgkarlbeFVIXatenH. GVIEdlsa®sþacarü

saklviTüal½yGg;eKøsEdlCaGñkFøab;ekatsresIrExµrRkhmy:agxøaMgkøaRtÚvrgTTYlenaH KWmanEt

RBHCam©as;eTEdlGacR)ab;Gaf’kM)aMgBIerOgenH)an. RBwtþikarN_enH)aneFVI[RBHGgÁnwkeXIjdl;

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 343

Page 354: Brother enemy

CIvitpuyRsÜyrbs;RBHGgÁpÞal;Edr.

erOgr:avepSg²)anvivtþeTAkan;EtelOn. bNþasßanIyviTüúrbs;breTs)anGHGagbEnßmfa

RbeTsevotNam)anepþImyuT§nakarvayRbharkñúgTMhMFMmYyRbqaMgnwgRbeTskm<úCaehIy ehIy)an

niyayerobrab;BIkarRbyuT§suIsac;hutQamKñaCaeRcInkEnøgeTotpg. edayFøab;sÁal;evotNam

c,as;las; nigCaBiesssÁal;]tþmesnIy_ v: egVógy:ab EdlCaemT½Bl,Il,ajxøaMgbMputenaH RBHGgÁ

BMumankarPJak;ep¥IleLIy b:uEnþ)andNþwgsYrkñúgRBHT½yBITIbBa©b;eTAvij. kñúgeBlresoléf¶TI2 Exmkra

qñaM1979 kmµaPi)alExµrRkhmmñak;)anmkTUlsemþcnigmehsIfa ³ RBHGgÁmaneBl15naTIedIm,I

erobcMGIv:an;sRmab;karyageTAkan;TisedAkMNt;TukmYyEdleKminTan;dwg. semþc)anmanbnÞÚleTAkan;

Gñkmñag mU:nik fa «eBlevlarbs;eyIgmkdl;ehIy». RBHGgÁerobcMRBHkayeq<aHeTArkesckþIsøab;

eTdwg¡. tamkarbBa¢ak;P½sþútagCaeRcInrbs;GñkePosxøÜnExµr EdlpSBVpSayedayviTüúTaMgLayrbs;

breTssemþc sIhnu RTg;eQVgyl;y:agc,as;BIEbbEpnEdlExµrRkhmcat;EcgkñúgerOgenHCaeRsc.

eRkamelsd¾samBaØmYy BYkCnrgeRKaH)anRtÚvTak;Taj[cakecjBIpÞHrbs;xøÜn ehIyRtÚv)at;mux

CaerogrhUt. eBlenHKWdl;evnrbs;RBHGgÁmþg. RBHGgÁFøab;)anseRmcRBHT½yeFVIGtþXatEdr

CaCagbeNþayRBHkay[ExµrRkhmdwkykeTAsmøab;dUceKdwkkUnecomykeTAkan;TIstþXat¬kEnøg

smøab;stV¦. b:uEnþ ebskCnExµrRkhm)anRtLb;mkmþgeTot edayTUlesñI[RBHGgÁnaMykmðÚbGahar

eRkómEdlRBHGgÁmanTaMgb:unµaneTACamYypg. semþcRTg;dkdegðImFMbn§ÚrRBH]ra. semþcRTg;

RBHtRmiHfa etIcaM)ac;RtÚvykes,ógGahareTAeFVIGVI ebIeKnaMeTArkesckþIsøab;eTAehIyenaH?.

enAl¶acéf¶dEdl exov sMpn )ancUlmkKal;suMlasemþc nigRBHjativgS RBHGgÁmuneBl

EbkKña eRBaHRBHGgÁRtÚvyageq<aHeTAkan;extþ)at;dMbgPaKxageCIgRbeTs. exov sMpn )anbBa¢ak;fa

BYkQøanBanevotNam)anbnþdMeNIrrulmkmuxrbs;eK ehIyfa semþc sIhnu nigRBHjativgSRBHGgÁ

nwgmansnþisuxbeNþaHGasnñ ebIsinCasßitenAeRkArdæFanI. Kat;)ansnüanwg semþc sIhnu fa nwgeTA

sYrsuxTukçRBHGgÁenA)at;dMbgkñúgeBlqab;²xagmuxenH. enAeBlsiT§iRbkas¬eBlRBlb;eRkayeBl

RBHGaTitülic¦ k,ÜndEgðedayrfynþCaeRcIneRKÓg)anecjdMeNIrlan;keRkIkdI. esÞIrEtminTan;ecj

putBIPñMeBjpg GñkCiHkñúgrfynþ)anB¤sUrsMeLgRKab;kaMePøIgFMEdl)aj;mkBITisxagekItpÞúHlan;k¥il²

enAÉnayq¶ays®gÁamCitmkdl;EmnETnehIy.

exov sMpn BMu)anTUlerOgr:avTaMgGs;R)ab;RBHGgÁeT. enAéf¶TI2 Exmkra qñaM1979dEdlenaH

muneBlRBwkRBlwm kumµ:g;dU dat;kug evotNamBIrRkúm )ansakl,geRCótcUlkñúgRkúgPñMeBj edIm,Iqµk;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg344

Page 355: Brother enemy

cab;ykrUbsemþcpÞal; b:uEnþRtÚvTTYlbraC½y. GñkEdlRtÚvvayluk)anCiHkaNUtekAs‘UCaeRcIneRKÓg

qøgkat;édTenøsab ehIyebIkEGbmkrkRcaMgEk,rRBHbrmraCvaMg. PaKeRcInénGñkGs;enaH)anRtÚv

smøab;. GñkenArs;CIvitmñak;kñúgcMeNamGñkrs;ranmanCIvitCaeRcInnak;)anrt;eKcxøÜnrhUteTAdl;

RbeTséf CakEnøgEdlCnenaHniyayebIkkkayBIkarb:unb:gmin)anseRmcR)ab;GñkesuIbkarN_

elakxaglicexÞcxÞI. eRkaymkeTIb semþc sIhnu RTg;RCabBIerOgenH KWenAeBlEdlRBHGgÁ)ankøay

eTACamnusSmanesrIPaBmñak;. eKaledArbs;evotNamkñúgRbtibtþikarenH KWcg;[semþcTTYlParkic©

eFVICaemdwknaMclnatsU‘mYyRbqaMgrdæaPi)al b:ul Bt.

kareFVIdMeNIrtampøÚvCatielx5 EdlmansPaBRkehgRkhUgrhUtenaH )aneFVI[mankarenOyht;

Gs;kmøaMgy:agxøaMg. semþc sIhnu )anKg;Rbfab;enAsuIsUpunEk,rRBMEdnRbeTséftaMgBIBIréf¶mk

ehIy enAeBlEdl exov sMpn mkTUlRBHGgÁ[dwgmunfa RBHGgÁGacyagRtLb;cUlPñMeBj)an.

sRtÚv)anRtÚvvayrujRcan[fyeTAvijehIy. k¾b:uEnþkareFVIdMeNIreTAnigmkenH bgðaj[eXIjfa

sRmab;eBlenHExµrRkhmBuMmanbMNgeFVIXatRBHGgÁeLIy. b:uEnþ teTAeTot etIerOgenHnwgeTACay:ag

NacMeBaHdMeNIrrulmkmuxbnþ²Kñarbs;evotNamenaH?. edaypÞúynwgkareBalGHGagrbs; exov

sMpn sRtÚvBuMRtÚv)anvayrujRcaneTAeRkayvijeT. sMeLgrNþMk¥il²énRKab;kaMePøIgFM)aneFVI[kBa©k;

nievsndæanrbs;semþceLIgj½rrBa¢Üy ehIyhak;dUcCakan;EtxitCitmksnSwm².

enAl¶acéf¶TI5 Exmkra qñaM1979 semþc sIhnu RtÚv)anTTYl[CYbsvnakareday«bgTImYy»

KWemdwknaMkMBUlrbs;ExµrRkhmedaypÞal;. eK)anmkdwksemþcehIyCUnRBHraCdMeNIrrhUtdl;GKard¾

sáwmésámYykm<s;BIrCan; EdlmanTItaMgsßitenAmat;TenøsabcMxagekItvtþPñM. KWCaGtItnievsndæanrbs;

eTsaPi)al)araMg EdlksageLIgtamrcnab½TµEbbGaNaniKm. kalBIedIm semþc sIhnu Føab;yk

kEnøgenHeFVICaTIsMNak;enAsRmab;EtePJóvrdæaPi)alb:ueNÑaH. semþcBuMEdl)anCYbTl;muxKñanwg b:ul

Bt taMgEtBIqñaM1973emø:H. kñúg»kaséndMeNIryagTsSnkic©tamtMbn; rMedaHnanaenAkm<úCa kalBI

ExmInaqñaMenaH RBHGgÁ)anCYbnwgmnusSmñak;EdlenAEtmaneQµaHfa saLút s b:ueNÑaH. GñkRTwsþIkumµúy

nIsþEdlFøab;eronsURtenAsgáat;LataMg¬Rkúg):arIs¦ )anbgðaj[semþceXIjfa Kat;CamnusSman

lkçN³mwH²nigsuPaBrabsamñak;minsUvykcitþTukdak;beBa©jmuxmat;b:unµaneT ehIyeRcInbeNþay

[GñkdéTeTotniyayCMnYsKat;eTAvij.

buKÁl b:ul Bt EdlRby½tñkñúgkarniyaysþInigRkGWtRkTmenHElgmaneTotehIy. enAéf¶TI5

Exmkra qñaM1979 kñúgry³eBl4em:ag Gakb,kiriya¬b¤b£kBacriya¦rbs;Kat;manlkçN³CaemdwknaM

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 345

Page 356: Brother enemy

mñak; ehIyebIKit[sBVRKb;eTA KWmanlkçN³ecHKYrsmnigKYr[RsLaj;cab;citþbMput. éf¶mYy semþc

sIhnu )anrMBJkBIbriyakasnal¶acenaHfa «b:ul Bt CamnusSkMeralmñak; b:uEnþKat;hak;dUcCaKµancMNuc

NamYysEmþgnUvkars¥b;ex<ImmkelI´esaH. Kat;ecHdak;xøÜny:agsuPaBEdleFVI[eKTn;citþRsLaj;».

semþck¾RtÚveFVI[egOgq¶l;edaykarecHeRbIBaküraCs½BÞy:ag\tex©aHrbs;Kat; niglkçN³Biesskñúg

kareKarB»nlMeTancMeBaHRBHmhakSRt eRbóbdUcCaeKarBRbNib½tn_RBHsgÇBuT§sasnaEdr. «eGog

sarI bdiesFmineRbIR)as;BaküraCs½BÞenHCamYy´eT. sRmab;Kat; ´KWCaRbCaBlrdæmñak;dUcBlrdæ

déT²eTotEdr». cMENk exov sMpn )anRbRBwtþedayrebobepSgBIKña. fVId,itEtKat;Rbkan;RTwsþI

smPaBk¾eday k¾ exov sMpn niyayeTAkan;semþcCaBaküraCs½BÞEdr. eRkaymksemþc)anerob

rab;fa «l¶acenaH ´BitCaRtÚveFVI[PJak;ep¥IlRsLaMgkaMg. b:ul Bt niyayrebobdUcKñanwg exov sMpn

Edr. enHKWCaerOgKYr[Gs©arüNas;¡ minKYr[eCOTal;EtesaH¡».

b:ul Bt )anniyaymkkan;´fa «RBHkruNaCaGm©as; TUlbgÁMsUmGP½yeTas Edl´Tmøab;[

exov sMpn eFVICatMNagcUlKal;RBHGgÁ». Kat;»neKarB´edayédRbNmüCab; nig)aneRbIR)as;

Bakü«´»EtmYydgKt; b:uEnþeRcIneRbIBaküfa ´RBHkruNa²dUcKñaenARBHraCvaMgGg;eKøs. eTaHCa

y:agNak¾eday k¾eFVI[´PJak;ep¥IlEdr».

b:ul Bt )anTTUcy:agxøaMgkñúgeKalbMNgsUm[semþcyl;RBmeFVICatMNagRbeTskm<úCaenA

GgÁkarshRbCaCati. CamYymitþPaBCaeRcInEdlRBHGgÁmanenAbreTs RBHGgÁGaceFVIRBHkay[

eTACaGñkCYyse®gÁaHmYyGgÁy:agsMxan;. semþc)anmanbnÞÚltbfa RBHGgÁenAEtRsLaj;RbeTs

Cati nigefáaleTaskarQøanBanrbs;evotNamCanic©. semþc)ansnüanwgxitxM[Gs;BIsmtßPaB

edIm,IFanakm<úCa[)anTTYlkarKaMRTBIRkúmRbwkSasnþisuxénGgÁkarshRbCaCati. eGog sarI )ankat;

smþIedÍm,IbBa¢ak;R)ab;RBHGgÁfa manEtmehsIRBHGgÁmñak;b:ueNÑaHEdlrYmdMeNIrCamYyRBHGgÁ)an

edaysarmUlehtuxVHkEnøgGgÁúyenAkñúgynþehaH. semþc sIhnu )anesñIeTA b:ul Bt fa «Ék]tþm¡

sUmGnuBaØat[bNþasmaCikraCvgS nigshkarIrbs;´)anecjeTACamYy´pg». b:ul Bt smøwgemIl

eGog sarI EdlGgÁúyenAEk,rsemþc ehIyniyayfa «sUmelakCYysRmÜledIm,I[GñkTaMgGs;)an

eLIgCiHynþehaHRKb;²Kña». PøamenaH semþc sIhnu rMePIbRBHT½yeLIgRsalRBHkayxJak. RBHGgÁ

P½nþPaMgsµartIedayEføgGMNrKuNy:ageRcIn eTaHCa)andwgc,as;BIGVIEdlbiT)aMgBIeRkaykarsenþas

RbNIenHk¾eday ³ b:ul Bt Tal;RckehIy. emdwknaMExµrRkhm)anniyayrMB£ky:agyUrBIRbtibtþikar

TaMgLayrbs;kgT½BRbkbedayKMnitsuTidæiniymmYy EdlRbEhlCaminrMePIbnwgGVITal;EtesaHfa

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg346

Page 357: Brother enemy

«kñúgry³eBlBIrEx eyIgnwge)assm¥atevotNam[Gs;». semþc sIhnu manbnÞÚleqøIytbfa sUm

sEmþgkarGbGrsresIrelakRbFan¡. b:ul Bt )anbnþfa «cab;BIeBlenHeTA semþcGacyageTA

RbeTscinjwkjab;)antamEtRBHGgÁsBVRBHT½y. semþcmanesrIPaBeFVIGVI²tamRBHT½y)anehIy

eyIgnwgcaMTTYlsVaKmn_edayrIkraycMeBaHdMeNIryagnivtþn_mkkan;matuRbeTsvijrbs;RBHGgÁ.

ebIsinCaRBHGgÁsBVRBHT½yKg;enACamYyBYkeyIg´b:unµanéf¶k¾eday k¾eyIg´rIkraysVaKmn_Canic©».

eGog sarI )an[eyabl;edaykargk;k,alkñúgTwkmuxy:agmaMCasBaØafayl;RBm. semþc sIhnu

EdleFVIRBH»sæcMhFøúg)anmanbnÞÚleLIgEdrfa «BitEmnb¤Ék]tþm¡ ´sUmGrKuNCaGenkb,kar».

esrIPaBEdlCitmkdl;kalBImSil hak;dUcCarsat;eTAq¶ayy:agrh½senARBwkéf¶TI6 Exmkra

qñaM1979. kaMePøIgFMrbs;evotNam RbEhlBuMEmnsßitenAq¶ayBITIRkúgPñMeBjb:unµaneLIy. etI

ynþehaHbU‘GuIg707rbs;cinGacmkdl;eKaledA ehIycuHctenAGakasyandæaneBaFicintug)aneT?

bnÞab;mkynþehaHRtÚvehaHecjeTAvij edayminTTYlrgRKab;kaMePøIgrbs;evotNamEdrb¤eT?.

eGog sarI )anpþaMepJIsemþcfa kñúgkrNIEdlynþehaHcinmin)anmk sUmRBHGgÁcakecjBIPñMeBj ehIy

ePosxøÜnrt;cUléRBvij. semþc)anmanbnÞÚlrMB£kfa «´)anerobcMv:alisBIr. kñúgv:alismYy´)an

erobdak;semøókbMBak;sRmab;eTARkúgjÚvy:k. kñúgv:alismYyeTot ´erobeRKÓgmðÚbkMb:ug GavkaKI

exaGavBIhSam:a RkmamYynigEs,keCIghUCImij ¬CaEs,keCIgeFVIBIkg;Lancas;²CatYy:agmYyEdl

manEtBYkT½BéRBenA\NÐÚcinb:ueNÑaHeRbIR)as;¦». dUecñH etIRBHGgÁRtÚvrt;cUléRBrYmdMeNIrCamYyExµr

RkhmTaMgenH EdlRBHGgÁFøab;emIlgayEmnb¤?. cemøIyKWbiT)aMgkñúgépÞemXRsGab;ÉeNaH Edl

erkarsmøwgemIledayminecHFujRTan;mkelIBYkGñkdMeNIrCaticinnigkm<úCa EdlkMBugehobnwgcakecj

eq<aHeTAeKaledAmYy. mñak;²epÞógRtecoksþab;edayxMRbwgEjk[dac;nUv«sñÚrm:asuInEdlmkCYy

se®gÁaH» CamYysMeLgrNþMénkar)aj;kaMePøIgFMtKña. ynþehaHmik-19plitenARbeTscin Edlman

KUrTg;Catikm<úCaRbCaFibetyüenActteRmóbKñaCaCYrenAcugpøÚvehaHehIr edayminGaceFVIGVIekIteRBaH

KµanGñkebIkynþehaH. enAxagelIGakasyandæaneBaFicintugRBHGaTitücab;epþImrHx<s;Nas;eTA

ehIy. xül;GakasmansPaBs¶b;s¶at;nwgfál;. semþc sIhnu kMBugTnÞwgrg;caM«bkSIesrIPaB»mk

TTYlykRBHGgTaMgGnÞHsa.

Yankee RtLb;mkvijmk¡ 347

Page 358: Brother enemy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg348

Page 359: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI10NUEGlRkhm

sRmab;ÉkGKÁrdæTUtLav xaMpan vILaCit nigsRmab;shkarITaMgR)aMmYyrUbrbs;Kat; raRtIéf¶TI6

Exmkra qñaM1979enaH KWCaraRtImYyEdlBYkeKmin)anedkBYnTal;EtesaH. s®gÁamEdlRbkb

eTAedayeRKaHfñak;xøaMgkan;EtmkekokNas;eTAehIy. PaBs¶b;s¶at;dUcenAvalkb;exµacmYy )an

RKbdNþb;mkelIrdæFanI EdlRtÚvrMxanmþgmáaledaysñÚrsn§wkénkar)aj;kaMePøIgFMtTl;Kñay:agxøaMg.

bg¥ÜckBa©k;rbs;sßanTUteLIgj½rrBa¢Üy. ebITukCaKat;PJak;ep¥IlnwgPaBekIteLIgPøam²enHk¾eday k¾

xaMpan rg;caMRBwtþikarN_EdlmkbBa©b;Edr.

Kat;)ansakl,geFVI[shkarITaMgGs;rbs;Kat;s¶b;kñúgcitþ edaybBa©úHbBa©Úl[naMKñasURtFm’

bn;Rsn;RBHBuT§Cam©as;. BYkeKsuT§Etsßitkñúgv½yCayuvCnrs;enAkñúgsßanTUtdac;ELkBIeKTaMgRsug nig

Xøatq¶ayBIRkúmRKÜsarrbs;xøÜnEfmeTot edayehtuenHBYkeKeRcInRtsulrkKñaesÞIrEtdUckUnekµg eBl

EdlCYbehtukarN_P½yxøacGVImYy. taMgBIéf¶TI2 Exmkra qñaM1979emø:H GñkenAsßanTUtLav hak;dUcCa

rs;enAelIekaHmYyEdls¶at;RCgM Gs;sgÇwmnigdac;RsyalBIeKÉgkñúgTIRkúgmYyEdleFVI[xVl;citþ

kñúgsPaBrg;caMEtkarbegðIy[vinasGnþrayb:ueNÑaH. RBHBuT§Cam©as;)aneRbónRbedA[mnusSEsVgrk

pøÚveTAniBaVn edIm,IedaHxøÜn[putBIvalvdþsgSar ehIykñúgeBlCYbkarlM)akenH BYkeK)anEbreTArk

RBHBuT§edayÉkÉg.

CaerOgcEmøkmYyEdl\sSrCnmñak;Ebb xaMpan seRmccitþmkeFIVCatMNagRbeTsLav sgÁm

niymRbcaMRbeTsmYyEdlniymeqVgRCúlénBiPBelakenH. tamkarBit mnusSEdlmanmaDFM

f¶asTUlay karjjwmreboblwblnigmwH²enHBMuEmnrdæaPi)almincg;rkSaTukkñúgRbeTs edaysar

KuNsm,tiþbdivtþrbs;Kat;enaHeT bu:EnþKWedaysarKat;ecHniyayPasaExµrsÞat; ehIyTsSn³rbs;

Kat;kñúgCIvPaBrs;enA k¾manlkçN³cUlcitþPaBs¶b;s¶at;mYyEdlenHCaKuNsm,tþicaM)ac;kñúgkm<úCarbs;

b:ul Bt. yuvkmµaPi)albdivtþn_EdlFøab;QñHrUbenHmansPaBesIÞrEtLb;sµartIGs;ehIy bnÞab;BIkar

rs;enAdac;BIeKTaMgRsugGs;ry³mYyqñaMmkehIyenaH. Kat;RtÚvEtCemøósbuKÁlikecjCabnÞan; eRBaH

erogral;Ex karTak;TgtampøÚvGakasrvagRkúgevogc½nÞnigRkúgPñMeBj manEtmYyKt; nigkarehaHehIr

manEtmYyeCIgb:ueNÑaH. enATIbMput eK)anbBa¢ÚnKat;[RtLb;eTARbeTsvijtamkaNUt ehIykarebIk

eLIgtamTenøemKgÁeTAPaKxageCIgmanry³eBldl;eTACagmYys)aþh_ÉeNaH.

349

Page 360: Brother enemy

RbEhlEssibqñaMmun xaMpan Føab;)ansñak;GaRs½yenARbeTskm<úCaEdr. CayuvbBVCitmñak;

Kat;)aneronsURtykcMeNHviC¢aenAviTüasßanBuT§sasnbNÐitüenARkúgPñMeBj. kñúgry³eBlmYyPaKFM

énCIvitrbs;Kat; Kat;Føab;)aneFIVCam®nþIrdæ)alnigGPi)alRkúghøÜgR)a)ag EdlCaraCFanIbrmburaN

mYy ehIymü:ageTot TIenaHk¾CamCÄmNÐlRsavRCavxagvis½yRBHBuT§sasnad¾sMxan;CageKbMputrbs;

RbeTsCatipg. Kat;minEdlnwksµanfa kñúgeBlNamYyKat;GackøayxøÜneTACaGñkTUtTal;EtesaH

ehIyR)akdNas;BMuEmnkñúgRbeTsmYyEdlRbqaMgnwgsasnaeT. eTaHy:agNak¾eday k¾ xaMpan min

GacRcalecalkarGMBavnavrbs;bkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_LavEdlEtgEtbgðajnUvkarGt;»nEbøkBIFmµta

mYycMeBaHRBHBuT§sasnaEdr.

Kat;)anRtLb;mkRbeTskm<úCamþgeTot bnÞab;BIGvtþmancMnYnR)aMbIqñaM. RbeTsenHmanlkçN³

eFIV[Kat;esIÞrEtemIlminsÁal;. raCFanIEdlkalBIedImCaTIRkúgmanesaP½NPaBl¥\tTas;CamYy

briyakasrebobextþ)araMgmYyenaHKWGs;pøÚvEkehIy. vtþGaramTaMgGs;elIkElgEtvtþmYyKt;

EdlenAEk,rRBHbrmraCvaMg suT§EtRtÚve)aHbg;ecalKµankarEfTaM eTaHbICaminRtÚveKERbkøayeTACa

CRgúkdak;RsUv b¤kEnøgeFIVTwkRtIk¾eday. RBHsgÇTaMgLayEdlcaksikçabTRtÚv)anykeTAsmøab; b¤

dak;eTas[eFIVkarCaTm¶n;. ExµrRkhm)anbgðajedayemaTnPaB[ xaMpan emIlExSPaBynþeXasna

mYy EdleKeXIjGtItRBHsgÇCaeRcInGgÁRtÚvykeTATwm[GUsreTHdUcstVeKa.

CIvitmnusSRbúsmñak;BuMmantémøeTenAkm<úCa ehIyenARBwkéf¶TI7 Exmkra qñaM1979 CIvithak;

dUcCaTwkmYytMNk;elIsøwkQUk. sßanIyviTüúbreTsCaeRcIn)anpþl;dMNwg[dwgBIkarrulmkmuxrbs;

evotNamcUlmkkñúgTwkdIkm<úCaEdr. \LÚvenHsñÚréns®gÁamkan;EtmkekokEmnETnehIy CaP½súþútag

fa sßankarN_mansPaBrwtEtF¶n;F¶rCagkarniyayrbs;viTüúeTAeTot. sRmab;BYkLav eRKaHfñak;KWman

BitR)akd ³ eRBaHBYkeKCaGñkkarTUtcugeRkayEdlsßitenATIRkúgPñMeBj. PaBmineTogTat;kñúgkarTak;

TgKñatamviTüúTUrelxm½rS (morse) CamYyRkúgevogc½nÞ)anRtÚvpþac;Gs;ry³R)aMmYyéf¶mkehIy. kñúg

TUrelxcugeRkayrbs;Kat;EdlbBa¢ÚnenAeBlbuNücUlqñaMskl xaMpan )anCUndMNwgR)ab;emekay

rbs;Kat;BIGsnþisuxEdlkan;EtrIkFMeLIg²enAkñúgrdæFanIPñMeBj. edayeqøIytbmkvij rdæm®nþIkar

breTsLav)anTUnµankuM[Kat;søn;esøa nig[sßitenAEtkñúgsßanTUt. TukCay:agNak¾eday k¾Kat;Kµan

CeRmIsNaepSgeTotEdr. TIRkúg)anRtÚvkat;pþac;BIBiPBelakTaMgRsug. eRkaymkeTIb xaMpan

rkeXIjBImUlehtuénkardac;TMnak;TMngKñarbs;Rkúgevogc½nÞKWenAeBlEdlsßankarN_BuHkeRBa¢alxøaMg

enARkúgPñMeBj karIEtmYyKt;Edlkan;xagTUrelxenATIsþIkarRksYgkarbreTsLavkMBugQWedkCab;nwg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg350

Page 361: Brother enemy

ERKedaysareraKrakmYl.

enAyb;éf¶TI2 Exmkra qñaM1979 xaMpan RtÚvdas;[PJak;BIdMeNkedayshkarImñak;kñúgcMeNam

shkarITaMgGs;rbs;Kat;EdlniyayTaMgP½yj½rR)ab;Kat;fa «ExµrRkhmkMBugerobcMCemøósbuKÁlik

eFVIkarRKb;sßanTUtTaMgGs; b:uEnþRbEhlCaKµanBYkeyIgeT». BIbg¥Ücrbs;Kat;eTA xaMpan Gacsegát

eXIjPaBRcvat;RcEvgénhVÚgmnusSEdlmanenAelIpøÚvfñl;Ek,renaH. GñkTaMgenaHsßitenAkñúgbriB½T§PUmi

mYy¬TIkEnøgEdlenAkNþalkEnøgdéTeTot¦mansuT§EtsßanTUt. sßanTUtTaMgGs;suT§EtenATIenH eday

RbmUldak;mYyduMcm¶ayBIKñaRbEhlmYyryEm:Rtb:ueNÑaH. BYkkgT½Brbs;km<úCaCaGñkelIkRbdab;

Rbdarbs;buKÁliksßanTUtdak;elIrfynþkamIj:úgCaeRcIneRKÓgkñúgeBlEdlGñkkarTUterobcMrfynþrbs;

xøÜnpÞal;. buKÁlikTUtLavmñak;)ansYreTAkgT½BEdlenAQrmuxTVarcUlCaPasaExµrfa «etImanerOgGVIekIt

eLIg¡smmitþ?». «sRmab;ehtuplxagsnþisuxGgÁTUtTaMgGs;nwgRtÚvepÞrbBa¢ÚneTAextþ)at;dMbgsin

b:uEnþKµankarENnaMNamYysRmab;BYkLaveT» kgT½BenaH)aneqøIytbmkvij. KWc,as;las;Nas; b:ul

Bt RtÚvkarcMNab;xµaMg ehIyBYkLavEdlCasm<½n§mitþrbs;evotNamCamuxsBaØaEdlRtÚveRCIserIs

TukCamunrYceRsc.

ÉkGKÁrdæTUtyUehÁasøavI mIéhLÚ Lúm):a eFVImuxmigmaMgedaynwkq¶l;kñúgcitþy:agxøaMg. éf¶TI2

Exmkra qñaM1979 enAevlaRBwkKat;)aneTACYb b:ul Bt edIm,InaMykfñaMeBTürbs;kak)aTRkhm

yUehÁasøavImYycMnYneTARbKl;CUn. Kat;emIleTAemdwknaMExµrRkhmhak;dUcCaTukcitþxøÜnÉgxøaMgNas; ³

b:ul Bt eBalR)ab;fa karQøanBanrbs;evotNamEdlepþImyuT§nakarenA ExFñÚ nwgRtÚveyIgvay[

)ak;T½Brt;x©at;x©ayy:agqab;rh½s. l¶acenaH enAeBlEdlGñkTTYlxusRtÚvmñak;énRksYgkarbeTs

mkR)ab;dMNwgedaysmþImYyEdlKµanR)akdkñúgxøÜnfa Kat;RtÚvEt«cakecjCabeNþaHGasnñ»BIrdæFanI

dMbUgKat;sµanfaCakarhat;eronkarBarxøÜnmYyb:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþenAeBlEdlGñkTTYlxusRtÚvenaHbEnßmfa

«smmitþRtÚvEtcakecjkñúgry³mYyem:ageTot» Rsab;EtKat;ebIkEPñkRkLg;nigmanTwkmuxRsLaMgkaMg

eTAvij. etIenHCaTIbBa©b;rbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüb¤? b:unµanem:ageRkaymkk,ÜnrfynþtUc nigrfynþ

kamIj:úgCaeRcIneRKÓgEdlpÞúkeBjeTAedayBYkbuKÁliksßanTUtbreTsTaMgGs; elIkElgEtsßanTUt

mYy )anebIkbreq<aHeTAkan;extþ)at;dMbg. ÉkGKÁrdæTUt Lúm):a )anRbTHeXIjsmPaKIcinrbs;Kat;

su‘n hav enATIenaHEdr EdltamFmµtaKat;CamnusSsb,ayrIkrayNas; b:uEnþeBlenH Kat;Tal;KMnit

mindwgCaKity:agNaeLIy. tamRbEhlTMngCaKat;Bi)akRTaMRTnwgkarcakecjenHehIy.

bnÞab;BIsñak;enA)at;dMbgmYyyb; buKÁlikrbs;sßanTUtyUehÁasøavInigcinRtÚvcab;epþImeFVIdMeNIr

NUEGlRkhm 351

Page 362: Brother enemy

EdlenOyesÞIr)ak;cegáHRtLb;mkPñMeBjvij edIm,ICiHynþehaHeq<aHeTARkúgeb:kaMgdUcEdl)aneRKag

TukCamun. ehtuenHenARBwkéf¶TI6 Exmkra qñaM1979 manCnCatiExµrnigcinrab;rynak; enAQrrg;caM

kñúgGakasyandæaneBaFicintug eRkamkar)aj;kaMePøIgFMepøagdak;KñaeTAvíjeTAmk. elIkElgEt b:ul

Bt KN³dwknaMExµrRkhmesÞIrEtTaMgGs;suT§EtmanmuxsßitenATIenaH. Lúm):a yl;c,as;BImUlehtuén

karpøas;bþÚrkareFVIdMeNIrenHPøam enAeBlEdlKat;RkeLkeXIjRBHP®½kþ semþc sIhnu EdlKat;minEdl

)anCYbesaHtaMgBIyUrmkehIyk¾sßitenAkñúgcMeNamenaHEdr. «BYkGñkFøab;yamXøaMemIl» RBHGgÁ)an

mksEmþgkareKarBCRmablasemþcTaMgeTIsTal;. karsuMGnuBaØatCYbsnÞnaCamYysemþcEdl Lúm):a

esñIsuMkalBIqñaMmunkñúgnammitþPkþicas;rbs;semþcKW elakesnaRbmux hSÚhSIúbRbÚsTItU )anRtÚvbdiesF

y:agKYrsm. dUecñH eBlenHPaBCab;XuMrbs;RBHGgÁ)anputrlt;ehIy. eGog sarI edIrcUlmkCit

ÉkGKÁrdæTUtyUehÁasøavIedayniyaysMueTaspg. sarI )anR)ab;[Kat;dwgfa mnusSeRcInkuHkrdUecñH

KN³RbtiPUrbs;elakGacmanRtwmEtbYnekAGIb:ueNÑaHkñúgynþehaH. ÉkGKÁrdæTUtcinnigyUehÁasøavI

)anseRmcsßitenATIenHedayTukekAGIrbs;xøÜn[BYkbuKÁlikenAeRkambgÁab;Kat;vij.

enAevlaéf¶Rtg; ynþehaHbU‘GuIg707BN’TwkR)ak;nigexovénGakascrN_suIvilcin)anbnÞabxøÜn

cuHctenAeBaFicintug. semþc sIhnu manRBHT½ysb,ayrIkrayrhUtRsk;RBHClenRt. CafµImþg

eTot semþcEdlsb,ayRBHT½ynwgesrIPaB)ancakecjBIRbeTsrbs;RBHGgÁ. semþccab;»b

ÉkGKÁrdæTUtyUehÁasøavInigmanbnÞÚlTaMgGYlGak;fa «sUmelakBaMnaMkareKarBRsLaj;rbs;´CRmab

elakRbFanaFibtI TItU pg ehIysUmR)ab;elakfa RbCaCneyIgnwgmincuHcaj;dac;xat». ynþehaH

)anehaHeLIgputBIdI ehIyk¾BuMmankarecjdMeNIrtamynþehaHNaepSgeTotEdr. ÉkGKÁrdæTUtTaMgBIr

)ancab;eFVIdMeNIrRtLb;mk)at;dMbgCafµImþgeTot.

enAeBlRBwkRBhaméf¶TI7 Exmkra qñaM1979 karRcbUkRcbl;EdlminGacBN’na)an²ekItman

enACuMvijsßanIyrfePøIgRkúgPñMeBj. mnusSCaeRcInBan;nak;TaMgRsITaMgRbúsTaMgekµgkµag )ancakecj

y:agkuHkrtamrfynþkaMmIj:úg m:UtU kg; eTARKb;TisTIrYmTaMgkmµaPi)alExµrRkhm nigRkúmRKÜsarrbs;eK

pg. BYkeKrt;ecjBIkEnøgsñak;enAeTAkan;tMbn;CayRkúg. edayCak;Esþg mnusSBuM)ancakecjBI

TIRkúgTaMgGs;eT. rfePøIgBIrExSenAÉsßanIy)anpÞúkeBjeTAedayBYkyuT§CnrbYsnigRbCaCnsuIvil

EdlP½ysøn;esøaeRsceTAehIy. eGog sarI nigbNþashkarIrbs;Kat;énRksYgkarbreTs)anxitxM

raMgxÞb;hVÚgmnusSmin[RbeRCóteLIgCiHrfePøIgeT edIm,ITukkEnøgsRmab;GñkrbYsEdlecHEtbnþmkdl;

KµanQb;. RBHGaTitü)aneFVI[TUrfePøIgTaMgGs;ERbkøaybnþicmþg²eTACabnÞb;sRmab;q<úgEdleFVI[Gñk

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg352

Page 363: Brother enemy

CiHeLIgEbkejIssRsak;. em:ag9Cagbnþic Rsab;Etelcmuxnirsarmñak;mindwgmkBIkEnøgNaR)ab;fa

kgT½Brbs;evotNamsßitenAq¶ayBITIRkúgEtR)aMKILÚEm:Rtb:ueNÑaH. sarI ecjbBa¢a[ecjdMeNIrPøam.

tamTUrfePøIg hVÚgmnusS)annaMKñaelateLIgetagmat;TVarb¤cRmwg nigeLIgTMeBjelIdMbUlEfmeTot.

k,ÜnrfePøIgTaMgBIrcab;keRmIkxøÜnd¾F¶n;Bab; ehIyebIkeq<aHeTA)at;dMbgedayKµanbg¥g;.

BIelIdMbUlrabesµIénsßanTUt xaMpan )antamsegátemIlRBwtþikarN_enHy:agykcitþTukdak;. etI

erOgTaMgGs;enHnwgRtÚvbBa©b;edayrebobNaeTA?. taMgBIeBlRBwkRBham sñÚrpÞúHénRKab;kaMePøIgsV½y

Rbvtþi)anlan;B¤eLIgP¢ab;CamYynwgkarpÞúHénRKab;kaMePøIgFMCaeRcInkEnøg. eBlenaHem:agCitdb;ehIy

rfynþhSúIbmYyeRKÓg)anebIkcUlmkkñúgbriB½T§PUmiGñkkarTUtedIm,ICemøósBYkyuT§Cnekµg²EdlcaMkar

BarenATIenaH. munnwgeLIgCiHrfynþ yuT§Cnmñak;kñúgcMeNamenaH)anelIkkaMePøIgGaka47rbs;xøÜn

ehIy)aj;rHy:agKeXøInmkelIEpñkxagmuxénsßanTUtLav b:uEnþKµanGñkNamñak;RtÚvrbYseLIy. RKab;

kaMePøIgmYyRKab;)anrt;mkb:HrUbftrdæm®nþITI1 éksnPUmivihan EdlRCúHFøak;mkdIEbkx©ay.

dMeNIrvk;vIBitR)akdmYyhak;dUcratt,ateBjkñúgTIRkúgenH EdleKeCOfaElgmanGVIkeRmIk

eTAehIy. yUr²mþgrfynþkaMmIj:úgCaeRcIneRKÓgEdlplitenARbeTscinnigEdlmanpÞúkmnusS

eBj²)anebIkbry:agGs;el,ÓntammhavifIRBHmunIvgS. ]T§mÖaKcRkCaeRcIneRKÓgBN’ébtg )an

bgðajrUbrageLIgenAkñúglMhemXd¾EsnekþAnaRBwkenaH. sñÚrkgrMBgEdlKYr[RBWxøacenH)anlb;elI

sMeLgkaMePøIgFMmYyEPøt²Edr. BiPBmYyhak;dUcCarlMrlayeRkamRkEsEPñkrbs; xaMpan Edlnwk

Kits¶at;²faetI b:ul Bt mansßitenAkñúg]T§mÖaKcRkmYykñúgcMeNam]T§mÖaKcRkTaMgenaHEdreT?.

RbEhlenAevlaresol Kat;)ansþab;B¤c,as;KµanRcLMnUvsñÚrkg;Rcvak;lan;RThwgmYy. edayeQ¶ak

tambg¥Üc Kat;GacemIleXIjBIcm¶aytamcenøaHpÞHfµBIrCYrnUvcMENkmYyénmhavifIRBHmunIvgS Edl

CapøÚvFMCagbg¥s;kñúgTIRkúg. rfeRkaHmYyeRKÓgEdlmanedatTg;CatiBN’RkhmnigelOg)anelc

eLIgkñúgBBkEpSgBN’exov bnÞab;mkrfeRkaHmYyehIymYyeTot ecHEtelcecjCabnþKña. xaMpan

ERskfa «enaHn+rfeRkaHeRcInNas;» bnÞab;mkedIm,ICakitþiysdl;GñkTaMgenaH Kat;k¾ERsk[buKÁlik

rbs;Kat;«elIkTg;CatieLIg¡».

mYyem:ageRkaymk elxaTIBIrénsßanTUt)anl,gRbfuyecjeTAxageRkA. edaykayvikar

cEmøk Kat;)anTak;TajnUvkarykcitþTukdak;BITahanl,atevotNammYyRkúmtUcEdledIrcuHtammha

vifId¾s¶at;RCgMenH. edayPJak;ep¥Il evotNam)anP¢g;kaMePøIgtRmg;mkrkKat;enAeBlEdlKat;ykéd

TaMgBIrdak;elIk,al. kalebIBYkenaHedIrmkCit Kat;k¾ykédcg¥úlbgðajsßanTUtrbs;xøÜnehIyR)ab;

NUEGlRkhm 353

Page 364: Brother enemy

eQµaHnigmuxgarrbs;Kat;eTAkgT½BExµrmñak;EdleXIjmanEtmñak;Kt;kñúgRkúmenH. enAyb;enaH Tahan

evotNamdb;BIrnak;)anmkCYyyamkamsßanTUtLav. subinGaRkk;)anbBa©b;. xaMpan Edlsb,ay

esÞIrqáÜtenaH)anerobBiFICb;elogy:agFMmYycMeBaH«GñkrMedaH»TaMgenH1.

GñkNaEdlRtÚvkarsn§isBaØamitþPaBmYy?

kñúgeBlEdlRkúmGñkkarTUtLav R)arB§BiFIC½yCmñHenARkúgPñMeBjrYmCamYyGñkKaMBarfµIrbs;BYkeK

mnusSTaMgGs;minTan;)at;egOgq¶l;nwgerOgenHenAeLIy. GVIEdlPJak;ep¥IlCagenHeTAeTotKWfa mindl;

BIrs)aþh_pg RbeTsevotNamGacseRmceCaKC½yvaybM)ak;RbeTssgÁmniymCitxagxøÜn nigkm©at;

ecjBIGMNacnUvsm<½n§mitþEtmYyKt;rbs;RbeTscinenAGasuIGaeKñy_. tamkarBit s®gÁamepøkbenÞar

enH)anRtÚvseRmcCaeRcInExmkehIy edaykarerobcMRbúgeRbóby:agsem,ImTaMgEpñkkarTUt nig

eyaFaenARbeTsevotNamk¾dUcenARbeTscin. sn§isBaØasUevot-evotNamRtÚv)anbnþedaykar

erobcM[manTMnak;TMngkarTUtrvagcin-GaemrikaMgeLIgvij. karcUllukluyRbeTskm<úCaeday

RbeTsevotNam )anekItmanmunkarQøanBanRbeTsevotNam edayRbeTscinbnþic. kñúgry³eBl

bIEx RBMEdnneya)ayenAGasuInwgRtÚveFVI[Pan;ERbTaMgGs;.

bnÞab;BIkarbeNþjCnCaticinBIRbeTsevotNam kñúgGMLúgrdUvekþAqñaM1978 RkúghaNUy)an

RbwgERbgbgðaj[eXIjfa RbeTscinCaGñkKMramkMEhgmYysRmab;sßirPaBenAGasuIPaKGaeKñy_TaMgmUl

edaysakl,geFVI[mankarxitcUlCitKñamYyCamYybNþaRbeTsénsmaKmGas‘anpg ³ evotNam

RtÚvEtkarBarGBüaRkwtPaBrbs;xøÜnkñúgkarvivaTEdlnwgmkdl;enAeBlxagmux. enHCakarpøas;bþÚr

KMnitPøam²KYr[kt;smÁal;KWkñúgry³eBlCaeRcInqñaMmkehIy EdlevotNamFøab;EtbeBa©jGakar³

emIlgaycMeBaHGgÁkarGas‘anenHEdlbegáIteLIgkñúgqñaM1967eBlEdls®gÁamevotNamkMBugpÞúH

eBjTMhwgehIyfa enHRKan;EtCa«plmYyénneya)ayGnþraKmn_ nigQøanBanrbs;cRkBtþiniym

GaemrikaMgb:ueNÑaH»2.

b:uEnþ enAedImrdUvekþAqñaM1976 edayecosvagPaBsñiT§sñalrbs;xøÜny:agRby½tñRbEygenaH

RkúghaNUyEbrCayl;RBmtamsMeNIrbs;smaKmGas‘ankñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBTMnak;TMngkarTUt

nigBRgIkshRbtibtþikarCa]PetaPaKIEfmeTot.

kñúglMdab;EdlkarvivaTCamYyRbeTscinmansPaBKMramkMEhgkan;EtxøaMgeLIg² evotNam Gac

nwge)aHbg;xdak;lkçxNÐepSg²EdlBYkeKGacTTYlrgplGaRkk;cMeBaHkardwknaMsñiT§bs©imRbeTsCa

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg354

Page 365: Brother enemy

cMhrbs;smaKmGas‘anEdr. minyUrb:unµanbBaðaTaMgGs;Gac[dwgfa RkúghaNUyb¤Rkúgeb:kaMgnwgTTYl

)aneCaKC½ykñúgkarTak;Taj«citþnigKMnit» bNþaRbeTsRbqaMgkumµúynIsþy:agxøaMgkøaEk,rxagxøÜn. enA

Exmifuna qñaM1978 evotNam)anebIkyuT§nakarTmøak;RKab;EbkelIRbeTskm<úCakñúglkçN³sm¶at;

bMput rhUtdl;ecjTmøak;samsibdgkñúgmYyéf¶k¾man. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH evotNam)ansEmþg

[dwgBIkareRtómCECkBiPakSaKñaedaypÞal;CamYysmaKmGas‘an nigCamYyRbeTssmaCiknImYy²

dac;edayELkBIKñapgEdr EdlrhUtmkdl;eBlenaHsuT§EtbdiesFmincrcaCamYy edaykarminTukcitþ.

enAExkkáda pan; ehon )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;RbeTsm:aeLsuI. enATIenaH Kat;)ancab;epþImbgðajxøÜn

CaGñkerobcMeFVI[tMbn;enHeTACatMbn;snþiPaB nigGBüaRkwtPaBmYy CamYyeKCamYyÉg.

«yuT§nakarRbelamesñh_» )anbnþeTAeTotCamYydMeNIrCaRbvtþisa®sþenAExkBaØa rbs;rdæm®nþI

TImYy paM v:an;dug. enATIRkúgkULalMBYr dug )andak;kRmgpáaenAvimanrMB£kviBaØaNkçn§Tahanm:aeLsuI

Edlsøab;edaykarvayRbyuT§kñúgs®gÁamsuIvilmYy. CaÉkCn Kat;QanrhUtdl;suMGP½yeTas

cMeBaH«m©as;pÞH»GMBICMnYyEdlRkúghaNUyFøab;)anpþl;[BYk]TÞamm:aeLsuIEfmeTot. enATIRkúg)agkk

dug )ansnüacMeBaHBYkéfnUvkarminKaMRTrbs;xøÜndl;KNbkSkumµúynIsþéfEdlxusc,ab;eLIy. tamkar

Bit eKaledArbs;Kat;KWeFVIy:agem:cseRmc[)ansn§isBaØamitþPaB nigshRbtibtþikarmYyCamYy

bNþaRbeTsénsmaKmGas‘anEdlnwgeFVI[karxitcUlCitKñaCafµIrbs;evotNamGMBITMnak;TMngepSg²

kñúgtMbn;eTACapøÚvkareLIg. TnÞwmnwgenaH smaKmGas‘ank¾minTan;seRmccitþPøam²Edr dUcenHehIy

)anCakaresñIrbs; dug )anRtÚvRcanecaledayesckþIKYrsm. k¾b:uEnþ smaKmGas‘an)anyl;RBm

ecjpSayesckþIEføgkarN_mYyEdlRKan;Et[l¥emIlb:ueNÑaH edayKUsbBa¢ak;BImitþPaBEdlkMBug

bRgÜbbRgÜmPaKITaMgBIr.

RbeTsevotNamBuM)anseRmceCaKC½ykñúgkarTak;TajRbeTséf[cUlkñúgsm<½n§PaBmYy

RbqaMgcineT Etk¾minbeBa©jBakü[c,as;las;Edr. esckþIEføgkarN_)anRtÚvpSBVpSayCasaFarN³

eday dug ehIy eRKógsak; naykrdæm®nþIéf)anhamXat;min[RbeTsTaMgBIr «RbRBwtþGMeBI viT§gSna

edaycMeBaH b¤edayRbeyalRbqaMgnwgRbeTsmYy b¤mYyeToteLIy» nighameRbIR)as;kñúgTMnak;TMng

rbs;BYkeKnUv«karGagkmøaMgT½Bb¤karKMramkMEhg»pgEdr. BYkéf)anRbqaMgCMTas;nwgkardak;bBa©Úl

kñúgGtßbTénesckþIEføgkarN_ nUvvaküxNÐmYyEdlhamXat;kareRbIR)as;TwkdI«RbeTsTIbI»NamYy

kñúgeKaledAbgá[manGriPaBnwgKña. BaküniyaybBaäitbeBaäógeTArkRbeTscin nigkm<úCaenH man

lkçN³Gac[eKyl;n½y)an.

NUEGlRkhm 355

Page 366: Brother enemy

KeRmagkarTaMgLayrbs;evotNamsßitkñúgsßanPaBRtÚveFVI[Pan;ERbGs;. karcuHhtßelxa

elIsn§isBaØamYyCamYysmaKmGas‘annwgbgá)anCaExlkarTUtmYyRbePT EdlRCkeRkamExl

enHevotNamGaccab;epþImeFVIkarpSgeRBgrbs;xøÜnkñúgkm<úCaminxan. edayPaBeqatl¶g;KYr[PJak;ep¥Il

mYy evotNamsgÇwmfa karebIkeFVIkic©crcaxagkarTUtnwglubbM)at;esckþIP½yxøacepSg²EdlRbeTs

xøÜnman ehIyvanwgbgðaj[eXIjBIRbúgeRbóbRbkbedaymitþPaBrbs;BYkeKcMeBaHsmaKmGas‘an enA

eBlEdlBYkeKcUleFVIGnþraKmn_edayeyaFaenARbeTskm<úCa. BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUyKitfa kar

seRmckic©RBmeRBógCa]PetaPaKI CabnþbnÞab;CamYybNþaRbeTsCitxagxøÜnenAPaKxagt,Úg nigkic©

RBmeRBógeFVI[manRbRktIPaBmYyCamYyshrdæGaemriknwgCYysRmalkarRbqaMgsn§isBaØamYy

EdlBYkeK)anseRmccitþcuHhtßelxaCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚEdr.

edayBit dMeNIrRbwgERbgEpñkkarTUtEdlGnuvtþedayevotNamenAsrTrdUvKW Esþgecjy:ag

c,as;sRmab;eKaledAEpñkeyaFaeRcInCag. RkúghaNUy)anerobcMkalviPaKmYyTukCaeRsceTA

ehIy. enAcugrdUvekþAqñaM1978 bNþaRbeTsénsmaKmGas‘anmankaregOgq¶l;xøH²Edr BIkarTTUc

rbs;evotNamkñúgeKalbMNgeFVIy:agNa[dMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs; paMv v:an;dug )anRbRBwtþeTAenAExtula

qñaM1978 y:agyUrbMput. GñkkarTUtmYycMnYnFM)aneFVIkarsnñidæanfa RkúghaNUycg;eFVI[)anmun etg

s‘avBIg EdldMeNIrTsSnkic©enARbeTséf sigðburI rbs;Kat;RtÚv)aneRKagTukenAkñúgExvicäikaqñaMenaH.

b:uEnþminRtwmEtb:uNÑwgeT RkúghaNUyEfmTaMg)aneFVIkarekobsgát;y:agxøaMgeTAelIbNþaRbeTsxøHén

smaKmGas‘an edIm,IbgçitbgçMRbeTsTaMgenaH[bgðajqnÞ³rbs;xøÜn¬Rbkan;ykxagNa²¦CaKuN

RbeyaCn_dl;kic©RBmeRBógmitþPaBmYyeTotpg. ]TahrN_ GñkkarTUtm:aeLsuI EdlmanmuxtMENg

RbcaMenArdæFanIrbs;evotNam-taMgBIÉkGKÁrdæTUtrhUtdl;elxaTIBIr-suT§EtRtÚvdak;[sßitenAeRkam

karqaeqArMxanmYyedayBitR)akd. KUsnÞnarbs;BYkeK eRcInecalsmþIy:agc,as;fa RkúghaNUyGac

nwgesIerIBinitüeLIgvijnUvneya)aymitþPaBrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTsm:aeLsuI ebIsinCaTsSnkic©rbs; paM

v:an;dug BuM)anTTYleCaKC½ymYyeTenaH3. tamRbEhl«eCaKC½y»KWmann½yfa karcuHhtßelxaelI

sn§isBaØaEdlesñIeLIgedayevotNam. RBmCamYyKñaenaH enAcugmçageToténBiPBelakKWenATIRkúg

jÚvy:k rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam egVón kUfac; k¾ekobsgát;rdæaPi)alGaemrikaMg[cuHhtßelxaelI

GtßbTmYy EdlkMNt;y:agc,as;BIeKalkarN_énkarerobcMTMnak;TMngkarTUtCa]PetaPaKImYyeLIg

vijEdr.

evotNam)anerobcMkmµviFIeFVIkarQøanBanrbs;xøÜnmkelIRbeTskm<úCa enAkñúgExFñÚ eRBaHCardUv

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg356

Page 367: Brother enemy

R)aMgEdlgayRsÜl[rfeRkaHebIkbr ehIyk¾cMrdUvRcÚtkat;Edr enHCacMNucsMxan;bMputsRmab;Fana

karpÁt;pÁg;es,ógdl;clnatsU‘Exµr Edl)anhVwkhat;enARbeTsevotNamtaMgBIedImqñaM1978mk.

evotNammincg;[éf¶ExEdleKkMNt;TukekokKñaxøaMgeBkeTAnwgéf¶cuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØamitþPaB

CamYyRkúgmUsÁÚeT BIeRBaHPaBekokKñaenHGacbNþal[eKeCOfa enHCa\T§iBlrbs;BYksUevoteday

pÞal;kñúgkarcab;epþImkarRbyuT§KñaenH. evotNamnwkKit\tQb;Qrfa sn§isBaØaRtÚvcuHhtßelxa[

)anmunsrTrdUv KWrebobdUcBYkeKeFVIkarekobsgát;esÞIrEtkñúgeBlCamYyKñaeTAelIshrdæGaemrik nig

bNþaRbeTsénsmaKmGas‘anEdr. evotNamxMRbwgEsVgrkkarKaMBarBIBYksUevot b:uEnþBuMEmnRtÚvbg;

témøGVIk¾edayenaHeT ehIyk¾minRtÚveFVI[sm<½n§PaBenHbiTRKb;RckTVarsRmab;bs©imRbeTs TaMgk¾min

RtÚveFVI[CemøaHrbs;xøÜnCamYyRbeTscinnigkm<úCanaMeq<aHeTAPaBÉekaTaMgRsugmYyEdr. kñúgRKb;

krNIBiessTaMgGs; neya)aykarTUtd¾skmµmYynwgeFVI[evotNammansßanPaBl¥RbesIrCagmun

sRmab;CECkrkxusRtÚvCamYyBYkrusSúI.

RkúgmUsÁÚpþl;nUvkarFanarbs;xøÜn

eTaHCay:agNak¾eday bnÞab;BIdMeNIrB½T§CMuvijGasIuGaeKñy_rbs; paMv:an;dug enABak;kNþal

Extula qñaM1978 KeRmagkarepSg²rbs;evotNamhak;dUcCargplb:HBal;y:agxøaMg. dug BMu)an

seRmceFVI[karmnÞilsgS½yrbs;smaKmGas‘anfycuHeLIy edayehtuenH Kat;RtÚvEte)aHbg;

ecalPøamnUvKMnitTaMgGs;GMBIerOgsn§isBaØa. enAExsIhanigkBaØa ePøóg)anbg¥úry:agxøaMgEdlminFøab;

manBImunmkenARbeTsevotNam-BüúHsgÇranigTwkCMnn;-enAEdndITenøRkhm TenøemKgÁ nigPaKkNþal

RbeTs. plitplksikmµRbmaN1/5lanetanRtÚv)anbMpøaj ehIystVciBa©wmcMnYn 20PaKry

k¾RtÚvvinasGnþray. »nPaBEpñkplitplksikmµEdlCaehtuénkarGnþrayBitR)akd)anekIneLIgkñúg

smamaRtd¾sem,Im. tamkarvaytémøenAeBlenaHKW3lanetan4.

eyaFPUmiPaKTI9EdlmanbnÞúkeFVIRbtibtþikarenARbeTskm<úCa RtÚv)anbMpøajedayTwkCMnn;

TenøemKgÁrYmTaMgPaKxagekItRbeTskm<úCapg. RbkarenHdUcCa[dMNwgdl;rfeRkaHTaMgLayrbs;

evotNamGMBIsßanPaBdIEdlEbkPk;b:biucb:)ac;Edr ykl¥KWTal;EteRkayrdUvePøóg. GVIEdleFVI[

rwtEtRBÜy)armÖEfmeTot KWeKKµanTTYl)andMNwgGVIesaHBIshrdæGaemrik. rIqad hUlRb‘Úk )ancab;

epþImdMeNIrTsSnacrmYyenAGasIukñúgeBlEdl fac; Fujfb;edaykarrg;caMyUrenATIRkúgjÚvy:k.

enAdMNac;Extula qñaM1978 kariyal½yneya)ayrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam)aneFVIkar

NUEGlRkhm 357

Page 368: Brother enemy

seRmccitþfa eTaHbICasßanPaBdIminGMeNaypl ¬karTTYlrgeRKaHedaymhnþrayTwkCMnn;TenøemKgÁ¦

y:agNak¾eday k¾karcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØaCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚBuMGacBnüareBl[yUrteTAeTot)an

eT. bnÞab;BIkarp¥akBIrelIk Gñkcrca)anecjdMeNIreq<aHeTATIRkúgmUsÁÚmþgeTot. fac; )anTTYlbBa¢a[

cakecjBIjÚvy:keTACYbKñaenATIenaHEdr.

enATIRkúgmUsÁÚnaéf¶TI1 Exvicäika qñaM1978 ynþehaHGIulIyUQIn62mYyeRKÓgEdleK)anCYl

CaBiessBIRkúmhu‘nGakascrN_ AEOFLOT rbs;sUevot)ancuHctenAcMNtGakasyandæannuykUv:U

eRkamsMeLgTHédGbGry:agxøaMgBIGñkmkTTYl. smaCikkariyal½yneya)aycMnYnR)aMrUb smaCik

KN³kmµaFikarmCÄimbkSR)aMbYnrUb nigGñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;Cagdb;rUbeTot)anmkRbmUlpþúMKñaenATI

enH. BiFIeFVIbdisNæarkic©manlkçN³rak;Tak;EbøkBIFmµta. eRkamkarftrUbPaBrbs;kaemr:aTUrTsSn_

CaeRcIneRKÓg eLGUnId eRbseNv [CaGKÁelxabkSkumµúynIsþsUevotBIqñaM1977 dl;qñaM1982]

)ancab;»brwtKñay:agyUrCamYysmPaKIevotNamrbs;Kat; eL yn;. bnÞab;BIkareKarBePøgCatiTaMg

BIrrYc eL yn; nig paM v:an;dug )anedIrRtÜtkgkitþiys bnÞab;mkKN³RbtiPUTaMgmUl)anecjdMeNIreTA

kan;nievsndæansRmab;ePJóvbreTssñak;enA. tambeNþaypøÚvEdlRtÚveFVIdMeNIreKeXIjTg;Catievot

Nam nigsUevotrlas;rvic²laycRmúHKñay:ages¥ksáH edaymancgbdakat;TTwgfñl;RbsiT§iBry:ag

eRcIn EdlmanxøwmsarCaGaT×fa «sVaKmn_dMeNIrmkdl;rbs;mitþevotNam» nig «Ceya¡ saFarNrdæ

sgÁmniymevotNamEdlCakMEBgCYrmuxénlT§isgÁmniymenAGasuIGaeKñy_».

enATIbMput bMNgd¾x¢ab;x¢Ünrbs;BYksUevotEdlrkSaTuktaMgBIyUryarmkehIy kñúgkarbBa©Úl

RbeTsevotNamkñúgsm<½n§PaBmYyRbqaMgRbeTscinRtÚv)anseRmcenAeBlenH. enAéf¶TI3 Exvicäika

qñaM1978 BYkemdwknaMénRbeTsTaMgBIr )anCYbCuMKñakñúgmhasalénvimanRkwmLaMg edIm,IcuHhtßelxa

elIsn§isBaØamitþPaB nigshRbtibtþikarmYyEdlkMNt;sRmab;ry³eBl25qñaM. maRtaTI6énGtßbT

kic©RBmeRBógenH)anbgðajBIkarFanafa RbeTsevotNamsVHEsVgrk[)ankarKaMRTmYyRbqaMgnwg

karvayRbharCayfaehturbs;cin ³ «ebIsinPaKINamYykñúgcMeNamPaKITaMgBIrRtÚvvayRbhar b¤

rgTTYlkarKMramkMEhgBIkarvayRbharNamYy RbeTshtßelxITaMgBIrRtÚvcUlrYmbþwgbriharcMeBaH

erOgenHCabnÞan; edIm,Ikm©at;ecalkarKMramkMEhgenH nigcab;epþImGnuvtþviFankarsmRsbkñúgkarKaMBar

snþiPaB nigsnþisuxrbs;RbeTsTaMgBIr»5.

eRbseNv EdlRtÚveFVI[sb,ayrIkrayy:agxøaMgnwgesckþIBüayamrbs;Kat;)anKUsbBa¢ak;fa

sn§isBaØaenHnwgeFVI[GñkTaMgLayEdlKµanplRbeyaCn_NamYykñúgmitþPaBrvagRbeTsevotNamnig

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg358

Page 369: Brother enemy

shPaBsUevot GñkTaMgLayEdlekgykRbeyaCn_BIelIkarEbk)ak;rbs;bøúksgÁmniym nigkareLIg

dl;kRmiténPaBtantwgB§d¾épÞkñúgrbs;xøÜnminsb,aycitþeLIy. Kat;)anbEnßmfa «cab;BIeBlenHeTA

sn§isBaØaenHKWCatfPaBneya)aymYy ehIyfaRtÚvEtykcitþTukdak;nwgerOgenHeTaHCaeBjcitþb¤min

eBjcitþk¾eday»6.

BitehIy tfPaBneya)ay b:uEnþk¾mantfPaBeyaFaEdr dUcEdleKnwgrkeXIjerOgenHy:ag

qab;rh½s. «viFankarsmRsb» EdlrMB£kedaymaRtaTI6énsn§isBaØa k¾mandak;bBa©ÚlnUvkarGnuBaØat

[BYksUevoterobcMdak;mUldæannavacrN_nigGakascrN_enAelITwkdIrbs;evotNamEdr. sRmab;

RbeTsevotNam enHCatémøEdlRtÚvbg;edIm,ITTYl)ankarKaMBarBIsUevotRbqaMgnwgRbeTscin kar

pÁt;pÁg;brimaNGavuFyuT§PNÐ nigsmÖarbrikçarepSg²y:agsn§wksn§ab;mYyRBmTaMgkic©snüapþl;CMnYy

esdækic©mYyEfmeTot CaBiesskarpþl;RKab;FBaØCaticMnYn1/5lanetan. b:uEnþ enAExsIha qñaM

1978 enAeBlEdlral;esckþIsgÇwmkñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyshrdæGaemrikenAminTan;

)at;bg;enaH paM v:an;dug )anbBa¢ak;fa RbeTsrbs;Kat;mincg;BwgEp¥kelIRbeTsmYykñúgkic©karrbs;xøÜn

eT. Kat;niyayfa «taMgBI4000qñaMmkehIy erogral;elIkEdlRbeTsrbs;eyIgbENþtbeNþay

BwgEp¥kEtGñk]btßmÖKaMBarmñak;lT§plKWkarvinashinehacmYy»7. bIExeRkaymk sßanPaBRbeTs

evotNammanrebobdUcenaHÉg.

bnÞab;BIcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØarYcmk kñúg»kasCb;elogmYyenAvimanRkwmLaMg eL yn; )an

Rbkasfa cab;BIeBlenHeTA RbeTsevotNammanmeFüa)ayRKb;RKan;edIm,I«bMeBjRbkbeday

kitþiysnUvebskkmµd¾BisidæsRmab;Catirbs;xøÜn» RBmTaMg«katBVkic©d¾x<g;x<s;CaGnþrCati»rbs;xøÜnpg KW

karBarxøÜnRbqaMgTl;nwgRbeTscin nigeFVIGnþraKmn_enARbeTskm<úCa. kardwgKuNrbs;evotNam

cMeBaHBYksUevot tammtiGñksegátkarN_breTsxøHfa KWFMNas;eTArhUtTal;EteFVI[evotNamman

GarmµN_fa dUc)anTTYl«GMeNaysRmab;CIvit»G‘Icwg. eL yn; bnÞn;xøÜneKarB«m©as;pÞH»BIrdgmunnwg

eLIgelIynþehaHRtLb;mkRbeTsvij. eBlenaHKWéf¶9 Exvicäika qñaM1978.

karerobcMRbúgeRbóbeFVIs®gÁamenARBMEdnrbs;cin

kñúgGMLúgénkarsñak;GaRs½yenATIRkúgmUsÁÚrbs;KN³RbtiPUevotNam BYkcink¾minenAeFVIRBegIy

Edr BYkeK)anerobcMbegðIyCasm¶at;kñúgkardwknaMbBa¢a bBa¢ÚnP½sþúPar nigsmÖarswkrYcCaeRscsRmab;

karvaylukrbs;xøÜnRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNam. taMgBIExsIha qñaM1978 EpñkesuIbkarN_sm¶at;

NUEGlRkhm 359

Page 370: Brother enemy

rbs;GaemrikaMg)anrkeXIjsBaØaepSg²énkarbegáInskmµPaBd¾xøaMgkøamYyenAkñúgeyaFPUmiPaK

háagh‘SÚ Cab;nwgRBMEdnRbeTsevotNam. bNþasßanIypáayrNbcarkmµEdlkMBugRtÚveRbICaP½sþútag

bEnßmeTAelIcemIøyCasakSIrbs;GñkdMeNIrGaemrikaMgenAPaKxagt,ÚgRbeTscinenaH )anbgðaj[dwg

fakgynþehaHmic-19 nigmic-21 mYycMnYnFMrbs;kgGakascrN_eyaFacin)anerIpøas;kEnøgmk

kan;GakasyandæannanaEdlenAekokRBMEdnevotNamCageKbMput CaBiessenANan;nIg [TIrYmextþ

háagsuI] nigKn;mIg [TIrYmextþyunNan]. kgrfeRkaHnigkaMePøIgFunF¶n;k¾RtÚvdwkCBa¢ÚnsMedAmkPaKxagt,Úg

Edr. enAedImExvicäika karerobcMbRmúgTaMgenH)ancb;sBVRKb;. karRbmUlpþúMkgT½BrfeRkaH nigkaMePøIgFM

d¾eRcIn)ansßitenAtamTItaMgEk,rbegáIynwgRBMEdn. kEnøgsþúkeRbg\n§n³FM²k¾)anksagrYcCaeRsc.

enABak;kNþalExvicäika BYkGaemrikaMg)anesuIbdwgBIkarerobcMtaMgsßanIybNþak;mYysRmab;eqøIyqøg

tamTUrs½BÞ edayeRbIrlkFatuGakasxøIenAelIkMBUlPñMtUcmYykñúgextþháagsuI. sßanIyenHGnuBaØat[

GKÁesnaFikarkgT½B nigKN³kmµaFikarkic©kareyaFarbs;bkSkumµúynIsþcin manlT§PaBTak;TgKñaeday

pÞal;CamYybBa¢akardæannanarbs;kgT½BrMedaHRbCaCnEdlsßitenAPaKxagt,Úg8.

cMeBaHkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbeFVIs®gÁamrbs;cin eK)anBwgBak;elIB½t’manepSg²EdlGñkrt;ecal

CYrmñak;énkgT½BrMedaHRbCaCncin)anniyayR)ab;RkúmesuIbkarN_sm¶at;GaemrikaMg enHBitCakMNb;

dMNwgmYyy:agsMxan;. Gñkrt;ecalCYrenHmanzan³CaGnuesnIy_RtIEdlbMeBjmuxgarenAeyaFPUmiPaK

háagsuI ehIyEdlRtÚv)ancab;xøÜnedayb:UlishugkugkñúgeBlEdlKat;b:unb:geRCótcUlmkkñúgTwkdI

GaNaniKmGg;eKøsedayxusc,ab;. b:Ulis)anRbKl;rUbKat;eTA[EpñksYrykkarN_xageyaFarbs;

Gg;eKøsnigGaemrikaMgenATIenaH ehIyKat;)anlatRtdagfa enAcugExvicäika qñaM1978 embBa¢akarén

kgÉkPaBrbs;Kat;)anEføgsunÞrkfamYy edayrMBJkBIlT§PaBEdlGacmans®gÁammYyRbqaMgevotNam

enAeBlxagmuxqab;². minyUrb:unµaneRkaymkKWenAéf¶TI11 ExFñÚ qñaM1978 ]tþmesnIy_ év háÚCIg

RbFankic©karneya)ayénkgT½BrMedaHRbCaCn)anRbkaskñúgsm½yRbCuMmYyenANan;nIgkñúgBiFIbuNü

xYbelIkTI20énkarbegáItPUmiPaKsVy½t hSag kñúgextþháagsuIfa RbeTsevotNam)anbgáGMeBIRbTUs

r:ayy:ageRcIn ehIyfa RbeTscinmaneKalbMNg«pþl;emeronmYy» cMeBaHRbeTsenH. év Gayu

72qñaM CaemdwknaMCnCatiPaKtic hSag enAPUmiPaKenHKWCamnusSmñak; EdlRtÚvrab;bBa©ÚlkñúgcMeNam

GñkmanninñakarniympøÚvkNþalrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþcin ehIyxagEpñkeyaFaKat;KWCasm<½n§mitþd¾sMxan;

rbs; etg s‘avBIg EdlCaCnxøaMgfµImñak;rbs;RbeTseTotpg. sunÞrkfarbs;Kat;)an[sBaØadl;kar

erobcMRbúgeRbóbenAdMNak;kalcugeRkaysRmab;eFVIkarlukluyy:agBitR)akd.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg360

Page 371: Brother enemy

RbCaCnénPUmiPaKsVy½t hSag énextþháagsuI Edlrs;enACab;RBMEdnRbeTsevotNam KW

RbmUlpþMúCasMxan;nUvCnCatiPaKticEdleKRbTHeXIjenAmçageToténRBMEdnEdr. vasmehtusmpl

Nas;Edl év Føab;manmuxCYyxñHExñgedaypÞal;kñúgkarpþl;CMnYyeyaFarbs;cineTA[BYkkumµúynIsþ

evotNam. Kat;Føab;eFVICaTIRbwkSaeyaFaGmbBa¢akardæanrbs;evotNamenAeBlEdlmankareLam

B½T§eDonebonPUenAqñaM1954. enAeBlEdlbdivtþn_vb,Fm’kMBugmankMsYleBjTMhwg Kat;)ankøayeTA

CaeKaledAvayRbharrbs;BYkqµaMRkhmEdr BIeRBaHedaysarKat;karBarsgVak;kñúgkarpþl;eRKÓg

sBVavuF eTA[evotNamEdlnaMqøgkat;tamtMbn;rbs;Kat;RKb;RKg. db;BIrqñaMeRkaymk KWmnusSdEdl

enHÉgEdlmankrNIykic©RbkasR)ab;kgT½BrMedaHRbCaCnfa xøÜnRtÚvTTYlParkic©dak;TNÐkmµRbeTs

evotNamedaysar«karrmilKuN»rbs;eK. enAéf¶bnÞab;BIsunÞrkfa rbs;Kat;esnaFikarrbs;eyaF

PUmiPaK háagsuI RtÚv)anepÞrmkPaKxagt,Úgkan;Etq¶ayEfmeTot kñúgeBlEdlkgBlFMelx1rbs;Gñk

rt;ecalCYrEdlRtÚvcab;xøÜn)anenAhugkug )anerobcMe)aHTItaMgenAcm¶ayBIrKILÚEm:RtBIRBMEdn ehIy

cab;epþImhVwkhVWnnigRbCMueronsURtkUnTahanrbs;xøÜny:agskmµ9. enABak;kNþalExFñÚ esovePAesþIg

mYyEdle)aHBum<rMelcedayrUbPaBBN’RtÚv)anEckcay[bNþakgÉkPaBT½Bnana Edle)aHTItaMg

enAtambeNþayRBMEdn. esovePAenHBiBN’naGMBIÉksNæanniglkçN³smÁal;eRKÓgGavuFepSg²Kña

rbs;kgT½BevotNam.

enAeBlEdlRbeTscinkMBugeFVIkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbEpñkeyaFaeBjTMhwgenaH etg s‘avBIg

)ancab;epþImeFVIdMeNIrTsSnkic©mYyeTAkan;bNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþenAGasuIGaeKñy_Edr. dMeNIr

bnþbnÞab;Kñarbs;Kat;eTAkan;RbeTséf m:aeLsuI nig sigðburI manry³eBlR)aMbYnéf¶. ebskkmµrbs;

Kat;sßitenARtg;eFVI[bNþaKUsnÞnarbs;Kat;)at;P½yRBÜy ³ RbeTscincg;eFVIxøÜnCaGñkFana snþisuxRbcaM

tMbn;. edayehtuenH etg sgÇwmrk[eXIjkarKaMRTkat;kñúgCemøaHCamYyRbeTsevotNam. ebITukCa

RbeTscine)aHbg;ecaltaMgBIedImTsvtSr_70minsEmþg[eXIjPaBRbTUsr:ayNamYycMeBaHbNþa

RbeTsenAGasuIGaeKñy_ ehIycab;epþImerobcMTMnak;TMngkarTUteLIgvijCamYybNþaRbeTsCasmaCik

smaKmGas‘an ¬elIkElgEtRbeTsmYy¦ cab;BIqñaM1975k¾eday k¾briyakaskñúgkic©CYbsnÞnaTaMg

LaymanlkçN³fµIsnøagTaMgRsúg. R)akdehIy kñúgry³eBld¾Cak;lak;mYyTMnak;TMngEpñkBaNiC¢kmµ

nigvb,Fm’)anrIklUtlas;KYrCaTIeBjcitþ b:uEnþkarKaMRTEdlRbeTscinbnþpþl;[BYk]TÞamkumµúynIsþéf

nigm:aeLsuI )annaM[esAhµgdl;TMnak;TMngCa]PetaPaKIy:agxøaMg. enATIRkúgeb:kaMg eKFøab;Tajehtu

plfaTMnak;TMngrvagrdæ nigrdæKµanTak;TgnwgTMnak;TMngCabgb¥Ún EdlbkSkumµúynIsþcinEfrkSaCamYy

NUEGlRkhm 361

Page 372: Brother enemy

bNþaKNbkSxøHenaHeT KµanGñkNamñak;dwgfaRtÚveFVIy:agem:ceLIy. ebITukCamankarRbEkkrbs;cin

k¾eday k¾bNþardæaPi)alénsmaKmGas‘andwgy:agc,as;fa karpSayrbs;viTüúBYkkumµúynIsþéfnig

m:aeLsuIEdlGMBavnav[eFVIkartsU‘edayGavuF suT§EtRtÚvpSayecjBIb:usþ×pSaysMeLgrbs;cinenA

yunNan ehIyfaeRKÓgsBVavuF nigluykak;EdlBYk]TÞammansRmab;eRbIR)as;KWecjmkBIRkúg

eb:kaMgEdr. kalBIBIr-bIs)aþh_mun paM v:an;dug )anGHGagnwgbNþaRbeTsénsmaKmGas‘anCa

saFarN³fa RbeTsevotNamminKaMRTGMeBIviT§gSnaeT. GaRs½yehtuenH RbeTscinRtÚvdak;[

sßitenAkñúgsßanPaBmYyEdlBi)ak edaHRsaybMput ³ b¤mYycinRtÚvyktRmab;tamRbeTsevotNam

edayminrvl;dl;eKalkarN_TaMgLayrbs;xøÜn b¤mYyRtÚvRbkan;CMhrrbs;xøÜndEdl ehIyRbfuy

Rbfandak;xøÜn[RkúghaNUy eFVIkareXasnasþIBI«karKMramkMEhg»rbs;cin?.

etg )anedaHRsay«PaBraErkKMnit»enH edayseRmceFVIkarvaylukEpñkkarTUtEtmþg. kñúg

»kaseFVIsnñisITkaEstmYyenARkúg)agkk edayeqøIytbeTAnwgsMNYrmYysþIBIcMNgTak;Tgrbs;

RbeTscinCamYyBYkkumµúynIsþéf etg )aneqøIyfa «´minPUtkuhkdUc paM v:an;dug eT». «smþIesµaHRtg;

KWCalkçxNÐcaM)ac;xanmin)ankñúgkarerobcM[manTMnak;TMngl¥RbesIrrvagrdænigrdæ»10. etg )an

Rbkan;CMhrCaeKalkarN_rbs;Kat;BIerOgenHtampøÚvkarfa RbeTscinnwgbnþpþl;nUvkarKaMRTmYyxag

pøÚvcitþcMeBaHbkSkumµúynIsþCabgb¥ÚnTaMgGs;. b:uEnþCaÉkCn Kat;)ansnüaCamYy eRKógsak; nayk

rdæm®nþIéffa Qb;KaMRTKNbkSkumµúynIsþéfehIy. kare)aHbg;ElgKaMRTenHRbEhlCaenAEtCaerOg

Gaf’kM)aMg eRBaHfa kñúgkrNIpÞúy BYksUevotnwgqk;»kassRmúkcUleFVIkar vayRbharminxan ehIy

enHBuMEmn)at;bg;plRbeyaCn_EtRbeTscineT smaKmGas‘an k¾RtÚv)at;bg;Edr.

etg kan;cgáÚt

edaybdiesFCasaFarN³mineRbIGMeBIviT§gSna evotNam)anTTYlGtßRbeyaCn_mYy sRmab;

RbqaMgnwgRbeTscinCaeRsc. b:uEnþGtßRbeyaCn_enHRtÚvTukCaemaX³ edaykarRbkas[dwgGMBIkar

cuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØasUevot-evotNamBIréf¶munkareLIgkan;GMNacrbs; etg. tamkaremIl

eXIjrbs;smaKmGas‘anyl;fa qnÞ³cg;)anÉkraCüPaBnigkarmincUlbkSsm<½n§EdlRbkaseday

RkúghaNUy)aneFVI[)at;bg;lkçN³EdlnaM[eCOTaMgGs;. esckþIesñIrbs; etg sþIBI«GnutþrPaBniym

BIr» KWsUevotnigevotNamTTYl)ankarKaMRTCabEnßmeTot.

enAéf¶TI6 Exvicäika kñúg»kasCYbtTl;KñaEtBIrnak; etg )aneFVI[ eRKógsak; PJak;ep¥IlRBmKña

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg362

Page 373: Brother enemy

edayPaBesµaHRtg; nigkarminGt;GFüaRs½yrbs;Kat;. Kat;)anniyayR)ab; eRKógsak; fa «va

RbEhlCaR)akdEmnEdlRkúgPñMeBjRtÚvdYlrlM b:uEnþeTaHCay:agNa s®gÁamnwgBuMcb;eT vaeTIbnwg

cab;epþImEtb:ueNÑaH»11.

RbeTscinBuMyl;Rsbnwgneya)ayrbs; b:ul Bt eLIy b:uEnþcink¾BuMGace)aHbg;tMbn;mYy Edl

manlkçN³sMxan;xagyuT§sa®sþEbbenHeTA[evotNamEdr. etg )an[dMNwgmunfa «RbeTscinnwg

minenAes¶ómedayminerobcMGVIenaHeT eyIgnwgcat;viFankarepSg²EdlnwgtRmÚv[eyIgeFVI». emdwknaM

cin)anbnøúysmþI[dwgedaykarTTUcfa viFankarTaMgenHGacmanTRmg;CakareFVIGnþraKmn_xageyaFa

mYy. b:unµanéf¶eRkaymk etg man»kaslatRtdagBaküsMGagdEdlenH enAmuxBYkemdwknaMRbeTs

sigðburIEfmeTot. ]bnaykrdæm®nþIsigðburI suINafaMb‘Í r:ahSar:at;NaM )ankt;smÁal;fa «BYkcinBuMman

Tmøab;e)aHbg;sµartIrwgrbs;eKeLIy. b:uEnþ enAeBlEdlnaykrdæm®nþITI1 lI kVan;yU sYr etg BIerOg

evotNam ´eXIjEPñkrbs;Kat;CHecjnUvkarekþARkhayy:agxøaMg ehIyKat;BuMEmneFVIButeT». Kat;

eqøIyfa karrmilKuNTaMgenaHRtÚvEtpþnÞaeTas eday)anbEnßmfa «eyIgElgeyaKyl;BYkeKeTot

ehIy TaMgluykak;TaMgejIsQamrbs;cin». etg )ans‘ksmþIrebobminc,as;fa «sUmelakemIl

lT§plcuH. etInwgRtÚvpþnÞaeTasedayrebobNa? eyIg)aneRCIserIsrYcehIy». enAExkkáda

qñaM1978 eBlEdlkarseRmccitþ«pþl;emeronmYy»[RkúghaNUyRtÚv)anRbkan;ykenaH KWva

RKan;EteqøIytbeTAnwgkarrMelaPbMBanepSg² EdlRbRBwtþeLIgRbqaMgnwgshKmn_cinenARbeTs

evotNamb:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþ enAeBlenH etg )anbgðajRBwtþikarN_epSg²eRkamTsSn³mYyxusKñay:ag

xøaMg. tam etg niyayeKaledArbs;Kat;KWkarBarsnþisuxnigsßirPaB enAGasuIGaeKñy_ ehIyCaGaT×

enARbeTséf. dMeNIrmantKñahUrEhénRBwtþikarN_sMxan;²EdlRtÚvedaHRsaydUcEdlraykarN_[dwg

edayemdwknaMcin -karlukluyrbs;kgT½BevotNamd¾eRcInsem,Imbnþedays®gÁamts‘Ud¾yUrGEgVg

mYyrbs;km<úCa- manlkçN³dUcTMnayy:agcEmøk. RbQmmuxnwgkarvatTIrbs;evotNam Kat;)an

eFVI[eXIjBIPaBcaM)ac;kñúgkarshkarKñad¾CitsñiT§mYyrvagRbeTséfnigRbeTscin. b:uEnþ eRKógsak;

EdlCaGñkcUlcitþneya)aytulüPaBCaRbéBNIrbs;éf )anbgðaj[eXIjnUvkarraErkcitþxøH²Edl

rYmbBa©ÚlRbeTsrbs;Kat;[cUlvak;vinkñúgCemøaHépÞkñúgmYyénlT§ikumµúynIsþ. pÞúyeTAvij Kat;)an

snüaeFVIGnþraKmn_ b:uEnþebIsinCasßankarN_tRmÚv[Kat;eFVIb:ueNÑaH12.

enAeBlEdlRkúgeb:kaMgbegáInkarRbKl;smÖarbrikçary:agsn§wksn§ab; nigkarbBa¢ÚnTIRbwkSa

CaeRcInnak;rbs;xøÜneTARbeTskm<úCaEdlRtÚvkgT½BsRtÚveLamB½T§RbeTscinKitfa vamansarsMxan;

NUEGlRkhm 363

Page 374: Brother enemy

xøaMgNas; EdlynþehaHrbs;xøÜnGacehaHehIrBIelIEdnGakasrbs;éfeq<aHeTAkan;RkúgPñMeBj eday

ehtufa pøÚvehaHehIrCaRbéBNIkat;tamRbeTsLavCasm<½n§mitþrbs;evotNamElgpþl;nUvkarFanaxag

snþisuxRKb;RKan;eTotehIy. eRKógsak; )anyl;RBmtamsMeNIrbs;BYkcin.

kñúgeBlEdl etg bnþdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;Kat;enAGasuIGaeKñy_ KN³RbtiPUmYyEdldwknaMeday

v:ag dugsuIg (Wang Dong Xing) smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþcink¾mkdl;rdæFanIrbs;

km<úCaEdr. tamTMng v:ag RbEhlCamkGHGageLIgvijedayc,as;las;nUvkarKaMRTrbs;cincMeBaH

RbeTskm<úCa TukNaCaGVI²bgðaj[eXIjBIPaBCitmkdl;énkarvaylukrbs;evotNamkñúgTMhMy:agFM

mYyk¾eday. tamkarBit erOgr:avTaMgenaHminsUvCaFmµtab:unµaneT. v:ag GtItGgÁrkSkarBar em:A

edaypÞal;KWCaKURbECgxagneya)aymñak;rbs; etg s‘avBIg. Kat;RtÚv)ancat;[eTAniyayR)ab;

bNþaemdwknaMniymeqVgrbs;Kat;enATIRkúgPñMeBjnUvsarmYyEdlminCaTIeBjcitþ-edayniyayEtBI

erOgsMxan; ³ karKaMRTCasaFarN³cMeBaH «kartsU‘d¾RtwmRtÚvedIm,IkarBarÉkraCüPaB GFibetyüPaB

nigbUrNPaBTwkdI»rbs;RbeTskm<úCa b:uEnþ BuMmankarsnüaNamYyGMBIkarcUlrYmRbyuT§xageyaFa

eLIy. RkúmemdwknaMcin)anbnøúyBaküfa BYkGñkQøanBan «RbEhlBuMGacTb;[enAnwgkEnøg)aneTenA

eBldMbUg» b:uEnþkñúgTIbMputBYkeKnwgRtÚvbraC½yminxan. tameyabl;rbs;cinfa ykl¥RtÚverobcMxøÜneFVI

s®gÁamyUrGEgVgmYytamEbbEpnT½BéRBvijRbesIrCagkareFVIcm,aMgrebobepøkbenÞarmYyEdlKaMRT

edaybreTs13.

tamkarBit karbgðajkmøaMgrbs;evotNamenAsrTrdUvqñaM1978 enATIbMput)aneFVI[ b:ul Bt

cab;GarmµN_ehIyk¾eFVI[CMenOTukcitþBIPaBminecHcaj;rbs;km<úCaregÁaHregÁIEdr. ehtudUecñHehIy )an

CaKat;esñIsuM v:ag dugsuIg nUvTahansµ½RKcitþrbs;cin edIm,ImkvayRbyuT§RbqaMgevotNamenAkm<úCa

enaH. ®sþIyuT§ikCn)araMgmñak;EdltsU‘edIm,IC½yCmñHénKMnitmYyeQµaH LÚr:g; Bic (Laurence Picq) )an

pþl;nUvP½sþútagd¾sMxan;mYysþIBIkarPJak;ep¥Ilrbs;ExµrRkhmcMeBaHkarbdiesFrbs;cinBIerOgenaH. Bic

EdlerobkarCamYyGñkTTYlxusRtÚvExµrRkhmd¾sMxan;mñak;eFVIkarenARksYgkarbreTs KWCaGñkbeRmI

kargarenARkúgPñMeBjkñúgzan³CaGñkbkERbnigvayGgÁúlIelx. nagmanParkic©bkERbsunÞrkfaEdl

RtÚvEføgkñúg»kaseFIVBiFIbdisNæarkic©mYyCakitiþysdl; v:ag. enAevlacugeRkay sVamIrbs;nagEdl

edIrmkTaMgdgðk;xøaMg)ansMu[naglubkfaxNÐmYyecal nigvaysunÞrkfaenHeLIgvij. kfaxNÐEdl

lubecalenaHbBa¢ak;fa «rdæaPi)alkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü nigbkSkumµúynIsþdwgc,as;fa kñúgkrNIEdl

manesckþIRtÚvkarBYkeKGacsgÇwmelICMnYyrbs;kgT½BcinCabgb¥Ún»14. bNþasmaCikénKNbkS

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg364

Page 375: Brother enemy

RbtiPUcin)annaMmkEføgenARbeTskm<úCanUveKalkarN_sMxan;²EdlpÞúyKñaCaeRcIn. v:ag dugsIug )an

[dMNwgGMBIesckIþGMBavnavrkT½BCMnYyEdlRbkasedayBYkemdwknaMRbeTs b:uEnþTnÞwmnwgenaH h‘U

y:av)ag nig yU CUlI EdlCasm<½n§mitþneya)ayrbs; etg s‘avBIg )anbgðajnUvB½t’mandMbUg²

sIþGMBIneya)aymUlvivdþniym(radicalisme)epþspþasrbs;ExµrRkhm nigdMeNIrRcbUkRcbl;rbs;sgÁm

km<úCapg. RbkarTaMgGs;enHnwgCYyRTRTg;dl;karBiPakSaKñaxagEpñkneya)ayd¾sIuCeRmAmYy sIþGMBI

tYnaTIrbs;RbeTscinenA\NÐÚcinminxan.

eRkaybniþcBIkarvilRtLb;rbs; v:ag nig etg mkkan;Rkúgeb:kaMgvij kariyal½yneya)ay

énbkSkumµúúynIsþcin)anRBmeRBógKñaebIksm½yRbCMud¾TUlMTUlaymYyEdlmanrebobvar³dUcteTA ³

neya)ayépÞkñúgrbs;cin b:uEnþk¾manrebobvar³sIþBIkarTak;TgCamYyshrdæGaemriknig\NÐÚcinEdr.

sm½yRbCMud¾EvgGnøayenH ¬BIéf¶TI11 Exvicäika dl;éf¶TI15 ExFñÚ qñaM1978¦ )anedA[eXIjkarERb

RbÜld¾sMxan;mYyénneya)ayrbs;cin. sm½yRbCMu)an[sc©ab½ncMeBaHkarRtÜtRtaRbeTseday

etg s‘avBIg dUcEdlGñkR)aCJxagPasaRbvtiþsa®sþnigvb,Fm’rbs;cin hSWehán dUm [eQµaHfa «TU

sRmab;bBa¢arbs;KN³kmµaFikarmCiÄmbkS (Tableau de Commande)» niyaymü:ageTot KWCab:usþibBa¢akar

d¾sMxan;énGMNacépÞkñúgKN³kmµaFikarmCÄimbkS15. etg )anruj«kUnGukTaMgLay»rbs;Kat;eTAmux

edayPaBQøasévbMput. Kat;)aneFIVyuT§nakaredaybiunRbsb;tamry³bNþaRbB½n§pSBVpSayB½t’man

pøÚvkar miTIÞgnananigkarbiTb½NÑRbkasedIm,IbgçM[mankarEtgtaMgbkçBYkrbs;Kat;kñúgKN³kmµaFikar

mCÄimbkS nigedIm,Ibgá[mankarpøas;bþÚrmYynUvsmasPaBénkariyal½yneya)ayEfmeTot. kñúg

cMeNammitþPkiþneya)ayrbs;Kat;bYnnak;EdlkñúgenaHmanelakRsI etg yIgCav Edr RtÚv)aneRCIs

taMg[eFIVCasmaCikkariyal½yneya)ayy:agqab;rh½s ehIyshkarId¾CitsiñT§bMputrbs;Kat;KW

hSav hSIúy:ag RtÚv)anEtgtaMgCaGKÁelxaKN³kmµaFikarmCÄim. emdwknaMCaeRcInnak;EdlsuT§EtRtÚv

dMeLIgbuNüskiþkñúgGMLúgbdivtþvb,Fm’ )anRbqaMgCMTas;y:agxøaMgeTAnwgkardwknaMEbbRbtibtiþniymxag

vis½yneya)ayesdækic©rbs;Kat;. kñúgcMeNamenaHKWmanRbFanbkS hVa KUehVg RbFansniþsuxCati

v:ag dugsIug nigecAhVayRkúgeb:kaMg vU ti (Wu De) pg. edayRtÚvbgçM[eFIVsV½yTietonBYkTaMgenH

RbEhlCayl;RBm[mankarkat;bnßynUvGMNacEdlmanBit²rbs;eKminxan16.

EpñkxageRkayrbs;Kat;RtÚv)anFana etg GaceFVI[eKcab;GarmµN_eFVItamTsSn³epSg²rbs;

Kat;sIþGMBIbBaðaneya)aybreTs EdlkñúgeBlfIµ²erOgenHEtgEtmankarCECkrk¬xusRtÚv¦enAeLIy.

]TahrN_dUcCabBaðakm<úCaCaedIm. bNþaemdwknaMEdlsþab;tambgÁab;BYkeqVgniym ehIyEdlman

NUEGlRkhm 365

Page 376: Brother enemy

CaeRcInnak;Føab;mkeFIVTsSnkic©enARbeTskm<úCasuT§EtniyaykarBarBYkExµrRkhmy:agsiVtsVaj.

dMeNIrlwb)at;mYyEPøtrbs;Kat; )aneFVI[CMhrrbs; etg rwtEtxøaMgeLIgeTot EdlbdiesFkarTak;Tg

TaMgGs;CamYyBYkenaHxagEpñkmenaKmviC¢a. edIm,IRbqaMgTl;nwgkmøaMgRcanrbs;evotNam eKaledA

rbs;Kat;KWerobcM[mankarBYtédKñad¾TUlMTUlaymYyedayRbmUlpþúMeRkABIRbeTscinnUvbNþaRbeTsmin

EmnkumµúynIsþPaKeRcInkñúgtMbn;. eyabl;rbs;RbvtiþviTU XIg ecn KWfacMNucsMxan;énkarCECkBiPakSa

KñasIþBIneya)aykarbreTsrbs;kariyal½yneya)ay)anRkLwgCMuvijbBaðasIþBIkareFIVGnþraKmn_Epñk

eyaFaCayfaehtumYyenARbeTskm<úCaEtb:ueNÑaH. tameKGHGagfa v:ag dugsIug manbMNgfa

eyIgRtÚveqøIytbedayGnueRKaHcMeBaHkarGMBavnavsuMCMnYyrbs; b:ul Bt. kñúgn½ydUcKñaenH sñgkar

neya)ayTI1rbs;kgnavacrN_cin s‘U ehSnhY )anCMruj[eFVIkarbBa¢ÚnnavamYykgeTAsmuRTxagekIt

edIm,ICYyRbeTskm<úCa karBarEdnsmuTÞrbs;RbeTsenaH. cMENkÉembBa¢akareyaFPUmiPaKhÁagsIu

eQµaH s‘U sIuyU vijEdlCaGñkmanbTBiesaFn_mñak;)anRbkasfa Kat;eRtómxøÜndwknaMkgT½Brbs;Kat;

vaylukRbeTsevotNameRscehIy17.

b:uEnþ etg nigbkçBYkrbs;Kat;)anRbqaMgCMTas;y:agmWugm:at;cMeBaHkareFIVGnþraKmn_mYyeday

pÞal; sRmab;ehtuplepSg²EdleRKagTukCamunnigmineFVIGnþraydl;kic©RbwgERbgeFIVTMenIbPavUb

nIykmµrbs;RbeTsCatipg. CaBiess ecg )a‘v smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayTTYlbnÞúkkic©kar

GnþrCati)anRbkasfa ³ «etIbNþaRbeTsenAGasIuGaeKñy_ nigRbeTsdéTeToténBiPBelakbeB©aj

RbtikmµEbbNaeTA ebIsinCaeyIgbBa¢ÚnTahanrbs;eyIgeTARbeTskm<úCa?». «esckIþsgÇwmTaMgGs;

kñúgkarbegIátrNsirSrYbrYmmYyRbqaMgGnutþrPaBnwgRtÚvGnþrayminGacbgáar)an. eyIgnwgelceLIg

CamhaGMNacGnutþrPaBniymmYyvijmþg. tam ecg )a‘v fa shPaBsUevotmincg;[manGnþraKmn_

mYyrbs;cinenAkm<úCaeT eRBaHfa GnþraKmn_enHGacnwgRbmUlsaFarN³mtiBiPBelakRbqaMgnwg

RbeTscin ehIyGacbg¥ak;kareFIVTMenIbPavUbnIykmµrbs;xøÜnEfmeTot»18.

TukCaKat;CMTas;cMeBaHkarbBa¢ÚnTahansµ½RKcitþeTARbeTskm<úCak¾eday k¾ etg minsUveFVIxøÜnCa

GñkkarBarkardak;TNÐkmµmYyeTAelIRbeTsevotNamEdr. Kat;ecHeFIV[bkSyl;RBmtamTsSn³

epSg²rbs;Kat;. «karvayRbharmYyRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNambgðaj[eXIjfaCaGMeBIkarBarxøÜn

Rsbc,ab;mYy» manPaBehgs‘ytictYcNas;Edlbgá[mankarRbqaMgtbtPøam²mYyBIsUevotkñúg

TMhMy:agFMenaH. Ep¥kelIB½t’manepSg²EdlbBa¢ÚnmkedayRkúmesIubkarN_GaemrikaMg Kat;snñidæanfa

kgT½BsUevotEdlRbmUlpþMúy:ageRcInsem,ImenAtamRBMEdnrbs;cin BMuGaceFIVRbtibtiþkarvaylukTmøúH

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg366

Page 377: Brother enemy

y:agelOnsMedAmkRkúgeb:kaMg)aneT ehIyRbeTscinGacRbQmmuxnwgkarvaylukEdlmankMNt;

mYy. tameyabl; etg fa mü:ageTotkareFIVGnþraKmn_bgáarCamunmYyRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNam

nwgBMubgá[mankarRbqaMgBIshKmn_GnþrCatieLIy. enATIbMput kareFVIGnþraKmn_BMumanGVIbg¥ak;TMenIbkmµ

TaMgbYnrbs;eyIgeT ehIyRbEhlCararaMgRbeTsevotNam[e)aHbg;ecalKMniteFVI[Gak;dMeNIrkar

eFVITMenIbkmµenHEfmeTot. eTaHbICaRbeTscinseRmcQandl;eKaledARtwmEt70PaKryénbNþa

eKaledAeyaFarbs;xøÜnk¾eday k¾kareFVIRbtibtþikarlµmEtsakl,gEdr. karmin)aneCaKC½ynwgrYm

bgáCakarR)ab;[dwgd¾mantémøGMBIPaBTn;exSayénkgT½BrMedaHRbCaCnnigCaeRKÓgelIkTwkcitþsRmab;

kareFVITMenIbkmµrbs;xøÜn. sMxan;CagenHeTAeTot vanwgbgðaj[shPaBsUevotnigRbeTsevotNam

dwgBIsmtßPaBrbs;RbeTscin kñúgkarRbqaMgral;karb:unb:gh‘umB½T§rbs;BYkeKpg. etg s‘avBIg )an

snñidæanfa yuT§sa®sþrbs;sUevotnwgTTYlrgbraC½ymYyenAGasIuminxan19.

kariyal½yneya)aybkSkumµúynIsþcin )an[esckþIyl;RBmcMeBaHkardwknaMTisenHEfmeTot.

kariyal½yneya)ayk¾pþl;nUvkarFanarbs;xøÜnkñúgkarBYkédKñaCamYyshrdæGaemrik edayTukbBaða

étv:an;eTAmçagsin. cMeBaHelak mIEsðl GUkesnbWk yl;fa yfaPaBénskmµPaBeyaFamYyRbqaMg

RbeTsevotNam «muxCaRtÚvBiPakSaKñaBIGVIEdlTak;citþeRcInCagmunEfmeTot cMeBaHkarbBa©b;dMeNIr

énkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyshrdæGaemrik. eKGacKitdUcKñafa vaCYyBRgwgsßanPaBrbs; etg

[rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgkñúgkarRbQmmuxTl;nwgGñkdwknaMTaMgGs;enARbeTscin Edlyl;eXIjtémøénkareFVI

[manRbRktIPaBx<s;xøaMgeBk»20.

enAExFñÚ qñaM1978 etg s‘avBIg )ansMEdg[eXIjc,as;eday\tRbEkk)ankñúgzan³Ca

«mnusSxøaMg»rbs;bkSedaymeFüa)ayykQñHsMxan;bMputbIy:agrbs;Kat; ³ karrYbrYmrlaysac;

mYy edayneya)ayRbtibtþiniymEpñkesdækic© \riyabfcMeBaHRbeTsevotNamnigbMNgeFIV[man

RbRktIPaBeBjeljrbs;Kat;kñúgTMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMg. eKeXIjfa karp¥akTuksinnUvneya)ay

\NÐÚcinrbs; etg )anekItmaneLIgRBmKñaCamYyKeRmagkarepSg²ry³eBlxøIrbs;elak hSImIxaF½r

Edr. enAéf¶TI2 Exviciäka enAeBlEdlRbFanaFibtIGaemrikaMgepIJeTA[ etg nUvsMeNIcugeRkayrbs;

GaemriksIþBIkareFIV[manRbRktIPaB etg )an[eyabl;faGIV²nwgRtÚvedaHRsayenAExmkra.

GUkesnbWk )ankt;smÁal;fa RbFanaFibtI xaF½r (Carter) «)aneFVI[mankarsb,ayrIkraymYyEdl

RbkasR)ab;RbCaBlrdæGaemrikaMg[dwgnUveCaKC½yFM²bIsRmab;buNüNUEGl ³ karseRmc)ankic©

RBmeRBóg exm davId kareFIV[manRbRktIPaB[CamYyRbeTscin] nigsni§sBaØakat;bnßyGavuF

NUEGlRkhm 367

Page 378: Brother enemy

yuT§sa®sþTIBIr (S.A.L.T.II)»21.

RbeTscinRbmUlTunrbs;GaemrikaMg

GVI²TaMgGs;)anRtÚvseRmcedaygayRsYlEtkñúgrvagBIrb¤bIéf¶b:ueNÑaH. éf¶TI2 Exvicäika ³ kar

bBa¢ÚneTARbeTscinnUvsMeNIcugeRkayTaMgLayrbs;GaemrikaMg. éf¶TI3 Exvicäika ³ karcuHhtßelxaelI

sn§isBaØasm½<n§PaBeyaFarvagsUevot-evotNam. éf¶TI6 Exvicäika ³ karcab;epþImdMeNIrTsSnkic©

rbs; etg s‘avBIg enAGasuIGaeKñy_. PaBehgs‘yénneya)aykñúgRbeTsrbs;GaemrikaMgnigcin-

eCaKC½yén])ayEbbkariyaFibetyürbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI RbqaMg v:an;s_ nig hUlRb‘Úk. karerobcM

rbs;RkúmniymeqVgénbkSkumµúynIsþcineday etg s‘avBIg-nigkarvivtþn_énsßanPaBCayuT§sa®sþ

hak;dUcCatRmg;eTArkeKaledAEtmYydUcKña ³ karbegáItedayqab;rh½snUvsm½<n§PaBmYyrvagcin-

GaemrikaMgedayEp¥kelIkarKMramkMEhgeFVIs®gÁam. BIrqñaMeRkaymk GñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinmñak;)an

niyayerOgGaf’kM)aMgR)ab;´fa «rhUtmkdl;sm½yRbCuMrbs;kariyal½yneya)ayenAExvicäika-FñÚ

hVa KUehVg )ansEmþgecjkarRbqaMgCMTas;cMeBaHkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRkúgv:asuInetan ebI

y:agehacNas; kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBRtÚvEtrYmbBa©ÚlkarrkSaTMnak;TMngeRkApøÚvkarrvagshrdæ

Gaemriknigétv:an;pg». etg CaGñkEdlcat;TukkarKMramrbs;sUevot-evotNamCaerOgsMxan;Bit

R)akd TaMgcMeBaHRbeTscink¾dUcsm½<n§mitþkm<úCarbs;xøÜn ehIyCaGñkcUlcitþRbkan;\riyabfqab;RsuH

RsYlCagmunmYysþIBIbBaðaétv:an;. kardak;eRbIshRbtibtþikarBhusNæanCamYyshrdæGaemrik

KWCakarxatbg;edIm,I)anGVImYy.

enAéf¶TI4 ExFñÚ qñaM1978 BYkcin)anbnøúyBakü[dwgCaelIkdMbUgfa BYkeKGacyl;RBmeFVIkar

sRmbsRmÜlmYyGMBIbBaðaekaHétv:an;. kalBIBIréf¶mun RkúghaNUy)anRbkasCasaFarN³BIkar

begáItrNsirSmYyEdlmansuT§EtGñkRbqaMgnwgrbb b:ul Bt KWrNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa.

naéf¶enaH enAeBlEdlÉkGKÁrdæTUt vUdxUk CYbrdæm®nþIkarbreTssþITIrbs;cin han nanLúg edIm,I

BiPakSaBIsMeNIfµI²rbs;GaemrikaMg Kat;)ansmÁal;eXIjPøam²nUvmnusSfµI²CaeRcIn EdlenAGm

CuMvijKUsnÞnarbs;Kat;. shkarIBIrnak;rbs;elakrdæm®nþI-EdleKBinitüeXIjfa CaGñkniymeqVgbMput

ehIyEdlFøab;cUlrYmRKb;karcrcaTaMgGs;-BuMmanmuxenATIenaHeT ³ v:ag éhru:g CakµÜyRsIrbs; em:A nig

Nan;suI tag GñkbkERbPasaEdlmaneQµaHl,I. BYkeKRtÚv)anCMnYsedayGñkkarTUtGaCIBBIrrUb

vij. han nanLúg pÞal;k¾pøas;bþÚrrebobniyayEdr. rhUtmkdl;eBlenH RbeTscinminRBm

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg368

Page 379: Brother enemy

e)aHbg;ecalkareRbIkmøaMgRbqaMgnwgétv:an;eLIy ehIyk¾RbqaMgpgEdrcMeBaHGVIEdlshrdæGaemrik

elIkykmkniyayCaÉketaPaKIBIbMNgQaneTAdl;karedaHRsayedaysnþiviFImYy. b:uEnþ enAéf¶TI4

ExFñÚ han )anR)ab;[ vUdxUk dwgfa RbeTscinnwg«minRbEkkCasaFarN³»eLIy ebIsinCaRkúg

v:asuInetanecjpSayCasaFarN³nUvesckþIEføgkarN_mYyeTAtamn½yenH. mü:ageTot ]bnayk

rdæm®nþI etg s‘avBIg R)afñaCYbÉkGKÁrdæTUtGaemrikaMgenAeBlqab;²xagmuxenHEdr.

enAéf¶TI13 ExFñÚ eBlEdl vUdxUk QaneCIgcUlkñúgvimanRbCaCnd¾FMsáwmésá naTIRkúgeb:kaMg

Kat;mindwgfa etg s‘avBIg EdlKat;nwgCYbCaelIkdMbUgenH )anseRmceFVI[BYkemdwknaMCan;x<s;bMput

rbs;bkSKaMRTKat;kñúgKeRmagkardak;TNÐkmµrbs;Kat;cMeBaHRbeTsevotNameLIy. emdwknaMcinman

sgÇwmy:agxøaMgfa karbegáItTMnak;TMngkarTUtCamYyRkúgv:asuInetannigkareFVIdMeNIrrbs;Kat;eTAshrdæ

GaemrikenAeBlqab;²xagmux-elak xaF½r )anbBa¢ÚnsMbuRtGeBa¢IjeTAKat;kalBIBIréf¶mun-nwgeFVI[

Kat;mankarKaMBarRbkbedayRbsiT§PaBCasßaBrteTARbqaMgTl;nwgkartbtCayfaehtumYyrbs;Rkúg

mUsÁÚ. Kat;manbMNgbegáItrNsirSrYmcin-GaemrikaMgd¾rwgmaMmYymunnwgl,gRbfuysMNagcugeRkay

rbs;Kat;enARbeTsevotNam. vUdxUk )andwgnUvr)aykarN_epSg²rbs;RkúmesuIbkarN_sm¶at;

GaemrikaMg EdlniyayGMBIkarcl½tT½BenAEk,rRBMEdnrbs;evotNamtaMgBIExvicäika qñaM1978mk.

b:uEnþ Kat;enAEt«minRBmeCOGVI²TaMgGs;»cMeBaHyfaPaBmYyénkarvayRbharrbs;cin22.

eTaHCay:agNak¾eday eK)anGHGagfa GñkTTYlxusRtÚvGaemrikaMgEdlcab;epþImeFVIkñúgkarcrca

edaysm¶at;bMputCamYyRkúgeb:kaMg)ansmøwgemIledayEPñkmçag EdlbgðajlkçN³GnueRKaHdl;kar

erobcMRbúgeRbóbEpñkeyaFarbs;cin ehIyRBÜy)armÖy:agxøaMgcMeBaHkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbEpñkeyaFa

rbs;evotNam. shrdæGaemrikminsYrnaMGVITaMgGs;eRkABIrYbrYmCamYyRbeTscinRbqaMgsUevot. b:uEnþ

KMnitenHhak;dUcCaminRtÚvBinitüesI²eLIy EdlfaRkúgeb:kaMgGaceRbIR)as;RbRktIPaBcin-GaemrikaMg

edIm,IeFVI[seRmcnUveKaledAEpñkeyaFaTaMgGs;rbs;xøÜn enAGasuI-GaeKñy_. evorElgEtRbeTscin

mincUlcitþxagNaCagxagNa. b:uEnþvaBitfa ebIBYkGaemrikaMgvaytémøRbesIrCagmunBItémøEdlyk

citþTukdak;xøaMgedayRkúgeb:kaMgcMeBaHkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBenaH BYkeKnwgGaceKcevHBIkareFVIsm,Tan

xøH²GMBIbBaðaétv:an;minxan.

kñúgPaBeFVImindwgEdlenHCabMNgepSg²rbs;cin vUdxUk )anRtÚveFVI[PJak;ep¥IlTaMgrYsray.

etg )anniyayR)ab;Kat;fa «eyIgyl;Rsbtameyabl;rbs;elak. ´yl;RBmtamkarGeBa¢Ij

rbs;elakRbFanaFibtI xaF½r eTAeFVITsSnkic©RbeTsrbs;elak». GnuRbFanaFibtIcinhak;dUcCa

NUEGlRkhm 369

Page 380: Brother enemy

bgçM[qab;Edr. Kat;niyayR)ab; vUdxUk Casm¶at;fa Kat;R)afñaeTAkan;shrdæGaemrikenAExmkra

qñaM1979 KWmYyExbnÞab;BIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB 23. erOgTaMgenH manlkçN³EbøkKYr[q¶l;xøaMg

dUcKña. etg )anyl;RBmCamYykarykcitþTukdak;nUvGVIEdlKat;)anbdiesFkalBImindl;mYyqñaMknøH

mun. edayBit sMeNIrbs; xaF½r )aneFVIbnþeLIgvijnUvsMeNIrbs; v:an;s_ kalBIExsIha qñaM1977.

RbFanaFibtIGaemrikaMgmanbMNgBnüarkic©RBmeRBógkarBarCamYyétv:an;mYyqñaMeTot nigbnþlk;GavuF

EdlmankareRCIserIseTA[RbeTsenH bnÞab;BIkarputkMNt;énkic©RBmeRBógenH. cMENkRbeTscin

vij RtÚvEttmmineFVIRbtikmµcMeBaHkarsgát;bBa¢ak;CafµIBIbMNgrbs;GaemrikaMg edIm,IQaneTAdl;kar

EsVgrkdMeNaHRsayedaysnþiviFImYyGMBIbBaðaenHEdr24.

xaF½r RtÚveFVI[sb,ayrIkrayy:agxøaMgcMeBaHRbtikmµrbs; etg s‘avBIg. mUldæanénkic©RBm

eRBógeFVI[manRbRktIPaBRtÚv)aneFVI[ekItman. b:uEnþ edIm,Iecosvagfa karelcFøayerOgsm¶at;

Cayfaehtubgá[mankarRbqaMgBIBYkEdleFVIGVI²CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;étv:an;enAsPaCan;Tab elak

xaF½r )anseRmccitþKMhukerOgenaHEtmþg. CaCagrg;caMéf¶TI1 Exmkra dUcEdleRKagTukCamun elak

xaF½r )anRbkasBIdMNwgenHPøam. Kat;cMGkLkLWyfa «dl;evnEdl´RtÚveFVI[ etg PJak;ep¥Ilmþg

ehIy». vUdxUk )anTTYlkarbgÁab;bBa¢a[esñIsuMCYb etg enARBwkéf¶TI14 ExFñÚ nigesñI[Kat;RbkasBI

kic©RBmeRBógCasaFarN³enAéf¶bnÞab;. karsresresckþIEføgkarN_rYmenABuMTan;)anRbúgeRbóbenA

eLIy. dUecñH sMeNIrbs;Kat;)anERbRtLb;eTACaRbkaskic©RBmeRBógmuneBlEdlvaminTan;seRmc

CapøÚvkareTAvij¡ b:uEnþ etg EdlRtÚveFVI[RsLaMgkaMg)anyl;RBm.

karpøas;bþÚreRKagkarenH BuMmanTak;Tgnwg suIrus v:an;s_ eT. karRbQmmuxeday Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI GMBI

kardwknaMneya)ayrbs;cin )anERbeTACakarcaj;eRbóbeKCasßaBrsRmab;Kat;. vaElgmanbBaða

rkSalMnwgmYykñúgTMnak;TMngepSg²CamYyRbeTscin nigevotNam dUcEdlKat;niyayENnaM[eFVItam

eTotehIy ³ kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBEpñkkarTUtCamYyRkúghaNUyRtÚv)anp¥akTaMgRsug kñúgGMLúgeBl

énkarcrcaCamYyRkúmeb:kaMg. ehIyerOgenaH elakRbFanaFibtIElgTukCasMxan;eTotehIynUv

eyabl;[RbúgRby½tñrbs;Kat;kñúgkareRbI«snøwkebo»cin nigkarRBÜy)armÖrbs;Kat;BIkareFVI[Gnþray

dl;TMnak;TMngsUevot-GaemrikaMg. v:an;s_ )anpþl;nUvkaryl;RBmrbs;Kat;edIm,Inwg[kareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscin RtÚv)anRbkasCasaFarN³enAéf¶TI1 Exmkra qñaM1979 b:uEnþ Kµan

krNINamYyRtÚv)anRbkasmuneT. eKGacRbmaNdwgCamunfa dMNwgenHnwgeFVI[rdæm®nþIkarbreTs

sUevot Gg;eRd RháÚmIkU Gn;citþEdlKat;RtÚvCYbKñakñúgrvagExFñÚ ehIyfadMeNIrmantKñahUrEhénkarcrca

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg370

Page 381: Brother enemy

sþIBIkarkRmitGavuFyuT§sa®sþ (S.A.L.T) EdlminecHcb;nwgRtÚvrgplb:HBal;BIerOgenH. k¾b:uEnþ enAéf¶

TI14 ExFñÚ elak xaF½r )anTUrs½BÞBITIRkúgehSrUssaeLm edIm,IR)ab;Kat;[dwgfa kareFVI[manRbRktI

PaBCamYyRbeTscin KWRtÚvrujeTAéf¶TI15 ExFñÚvij eBalKWmunkarCYbrbs;Kat;CamYy RháÚmIkU. v:an;s_

)anniyayRtÜs²kñúgniekçbbTrbs;Kat;fa «dMNwgenHKWCakareFVI[Tas;citþBitR)akdmYy. enAcMeBl

EdlmanGasnñ ehIykñúgry³eBlRbEhlR)aMmYyem:ag Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anseRmceCaKC½ykñúgkarbMEbk

Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs v:er:n RKItUhVhVW nigrdæelxaFikar rIqad hUlRb‘Úk ecjBIsßab½nEdlmanGMNac

eFVIkarseRmccitþ. GñkTaMgBIrBuMGacpþl;dMNwg[´BIGVIEdl)anekIteLIgeT»25.

enAeBlEdl v:an;s_ eRtómxøÜnRtLb;mkTIRkúgv:asuInetanvij-vaGacfaKat;minsßitenATIenaHeT enA

éf¶EdlekItmanRBwtþikarN_sMxan;-xaF½r EdlrhUtmkdl;eBlenHmancitþrIkrayy:agxøaMg nig Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI

pÞal;)aneqøót»kaseRbIkarsgS½ymYy. etIkarRbjab;Rbjal;rbs;cinR)ab;[dwgGVIeTA?. etI etg

s‘avBIg mineBbRCayGMBICMhrrbs;Rkúgv:asuInetanTak;TgnwgekaHétv:an;eTb¤?. BYkeKR)akdCamindwg

fa karbegáIndMeNIrcrca[elOneTAmuxCYyeFVI[gayRsYldl;KeRmagkarepSg²xagEpñkeyaFarbs;

cineLIy. vUdxUk )anrMB£kehIy xaF½r )anepJImk[Kat;enAevlaRBwkéf¶TI15 ExFñÚ ¬RtÚvnwgéf¶TI14l¶ac

em:agenARkúgv:asuInetan¦nUvsarlixitbnÞan;mYy edIm,IsuM[Kat;bBa¢ak;fa GVI²TaMgGs;BitCac,as;las;

ehIykñúgcitþrbs;emdwknaMcin. Kat;)anepÞógpÞat;eTAtamTmøab;nUvesckþIcmøgkarsnÞnarbs;Kat;kalBI

éf¶munCamYy etg b:uEnþ \tmaneT ³ Kµankarsþab;KñaBuM)anNamYyGacmaneLIy. xaF½r TTUcfa Kat;RtÚv

EtCYb etg mþgeTotCadac;xat. eKRBmeRBógKñaeFVIkarNat;CYbKñafµImYy-elIkTIbIkñúgrvag24em:ag-

CamYyPaBrh½srhYnmYyxusEbøkBIFmµtaTaMgRsug. mYyem:ageRkaymk vUdxUk EdlrYmdMeNIrCamYy

GnuRbFanrbs;Kat; esþpWlfun r:y (Stapleton Roy) )anCYb etg enAvimanRbCaCn.

CadMbUg etg minlak;elomPaBGl;EGkrbs;Kat;eLIy b:uEnþ eRkayeBlEdl vUdxUk niyay

eLIgvijGMBICMhrrbs;GaemrikaMgkñúgkarbnþlk;GavuFeTA[étv:an; etg )ansEmþgkMhwgPøamfa ³ «ehtuGVI

)anCaelIkbBaðaenHmkniyayeTot?». vUdxUk pÞal;BuMGacbBa©úHbBa©Úl etg BIGtßRbeyaCn_énkar

CYbKñaenH)aneT b:uEnþ Kat;xMRbwgERbgBnül;fa tamkaremIleXIjrbs;RbCaCnGaemrikaMg karpþl;

GavuFsRmab;karBar[étv:an;KWCakarFanasßirPaBrbs;RbeTsenH. vUdxUk )andMNalR)ab;´ eRbób

dUcCaKat;eFVI[sac;erOgenaHelceLIgCafµIG‘Ícwg ³ «enAeBlenH etg )ansþIbenÞas[Kat;edayKµan

eyaKyl;nUvGVIEdlKat;mankñúgcitþTaMgb:unµan. kartUccitþrbs;Kat;CaPaBEdleKGacemIleXIjc,as;

edayEPñkTeT. eday\tekatERkg etg )anniyayeLIgvijBICMhrRbeTsrbs;Kat; ³ étv:an; KWCa

NUEGlRkhm 371

Page 382: Brother enemy

extþmYyrbs;cin nigBuMmansiT§iNamYyshkarCamYyshrdæGaemrikxagvis½ysBVavuF enAeRkayeBl

k¾dUcmuneBleFVI[manRbRktIPaBEdr. Kat;)anniyayedaymuWgm:at;fa ³ «eyIgnwgminsuxcitþCadac;

xat». vUdxUk )anBnül;Kat;fa Kat;minEsVgrkkarRBmeRBógrbs;RbeTscinsþIBIbBaðaenHeT. GVIEdl

Kat;ykcitþTukdak;CasMxan; KWRbRktIPaB. vUdxUk )aneRkInrMlwkfa «TMnak;TMngrvagRbeTscindIeKaknig

ekaHétv:an; )ancab;epþImERbRbÜl ehIyTMnak;TMngrbs;eyIgCamYyétv:an;k¾pøas;bþÚrdUcKñaEdr. sBVéf¶

enH ]bsKÁepSg²EdlBuMGacBuHBar)annwgRtÚvbM)at;edaygayRsYlCamYynwgeBlevla»26.

etg )at;RceLatbnþicehIy)ansYrfa «etIRtÚvy:agdUcemþc?». vUdxUk )aneqøIyfa «´sUm

[eyabl;edayTTUcbgçMfa eyIgRtÚvbBa©b;nUvGVIEdleyIg)ancab;epþImehIy. emdwknaMcin)antb

Pøam²fa «yl;RBm¡» EdleFVI[KUsnÞnarbs;Kat;FUres,Iykñúgcitþy:agxøaMg. bBaðaEdlTukminTan;

edaHRsay KWkarlk;GavuFeTA[étv:an; EdlnwgeFVI[lM)akdl;TMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikenAeBleRkay.

sRmab;eBlenH etg s‘avBIg EdlCabursxøaMgfµIrbs;RbeTscin)anTTYleCaKC½y. Kat;maneRbób

elIRbeTsevotNamkñúgkarRbkYtEdlepþImedaylYclak; edIm,IdeNþImykmitþPaBrbs;GaemrikaMg.

karerobcMRbúgeRbobcugeRkay

ebIsinkarerobcMRbúgeRbobxagEpñkeyaFaenAPaKxagt,ÚgRbeTscinmineFVI[shrdæGaemrik

RBÜy)armÖhYsRbmaNenaH k¾vaKµanGVIRtÚvRBÜy)armÖBIkarRbmUlpþúMT½By:ageRcInenAtamRBMEdnrbs;

km<úCaEdr. enAéf¶TI12 Extula qñaM1978 kgBlFMCaeRcInkgrbs;evotNamEdlkñúgenaH mankg

ÉkPaBeqñIm²mYycMnYnFM)anRtÚvdak;BRgayenAtambNþaextþdUcCa dak;Lat; taynij nig Gany:ag

EdlsuT§EtCaextþmanRBMRbTl;Cab;km<úCa. RbQmmuxnwgbBaðaxVHxateRKÓgeRKAm:asuInynþehaH

RbedjTmøak;RKab;EbkFun A-37 nig F-5 ¬cab;)anBITahanGaemrikaMg¦ EdlBYkeKFøab;eRbIR)as;RbqaMg

nwgExµrRkhmkalBIExmifuna evotNamRtÚvbgçMcitþEkERbrebobRbyuT§rbs;xøÜnCafµI. ynþehaHmic-19

nigmic-21 CaeRcIneRKÓgEdleFVIenAshPaBsUevot)anRtÚvepÞrBIPaKxageCIgmkkan;mUldæan CU

Lay/ ebon v:a nig kg; fW enAPaKxagt,Úgvij.

karecjbBa¢asRmab;karBarTaMgenHBuMEmnCakaremIlgayenaHeT eRBaHTIRkúghUCImijman

cm¶ayehaHehIrmindl;knøHem:agpgBITIRkúgPñMeBj. m®nþIGgÁkarshRbCaCatimñak;Edlmuxgarrbs;

Kat;tRmÚv[eTAPaKxagt,ÚgCajwkjab; )anemIleXIjBIcm¶ayCamYynwgkarPJak;ep¥Ilfa enAtamtMbn;

CuMvijrdæFanIPaKxagt,ÚgmanerobcMtemøIgkaMePøIg)aj;ynþehaH nigRbdab;)aj;kaMRCÜcmIsuIltRmg;eTA

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg372

Page 383: Brother enemy

PaKxaglicRcÚgRcag. enATICitxagTItaMgsMxan;²rbs;TIRkúgeXIjmanCIkelNdæan nigTICRmksRmab;

karBarBIkarTmøak;RKab;EbktampøÚvGakasEfmeTot. enHRbEhlCakarerobcMeFVI[RbCaBlrdædwgxøÜn

Camun cMeBaHkarepþImeFVIRbtibtþikarRbqaMgnwgRbeTskm<úCaehIy. b:uEnþGñkyuT§sa®sþevotNam

k¾eRKagKitCacaM)ac;nUvkarKMramkMEhgBIkarvayRbharTaMgsgxagRBmKña BIsMNak;ExµrRkhmEdl

KaMRTedayBYkcin enAtambNþaRBMEdnPaKnirtInigBIsMNak;BYkcinpÞal;enARBMEdnPaKxageCIgrbs;xøÜn

pgEdr. karP½y)armÖenHKWEp¥kelIB½t’manepSg²EdlRbmUl)anedayRkúmesuIbkarN_sm¶at;taMgBI

niTaXrdUv qñaM1978emø:H Edlbgðaj[dwgtamry³karbegáInrwtEteRcInnUvkarRbKl;rfeRkaH rfBas

Edk nigynþehaHRbedjmic19rbs;cinmk[RbeTskm<úCa nigkarbgçMksagRBlanynþehaHeyaFa

fµImYyd¾FMenAkMBg;qñaMgEfmeTot. evotNam)anvaytémøfa cMnYnkgT½B TIRbwkSanigGñkbec©keTscin

EdlTTYlParkic©erobcMkgT½Brbs;km<úCa[eFVIkarvaylukmYyRbqaMgevotNamxagt,ÚgmancMnYn

RbEhl10>000nak; 27.

sßanPaBneya)ay nigkarTUtBiPBelak)anERbRbÜly:agqab;rh½s. evotNamcaM)ac;RtÚvEt

bBaÄb;CabnÞan;bMputtamEdlGaceFVIeTA)an nUvRbtiTinénRbtibtþikareyaFaTaMgLayrbs;xøÜn. eday

ELkBYkeKk¾RtÚveFVI[xVl;RBÜyedaysarkarb:unb:grbs;ExµrRkhmEdlcg;rMedaHxøÜnBIsßanPaBÉeka nig

sm¥b;CnbreTsrbs;eKEdr. enAsrTrdUvqñaM1978 tamkarbBa©úHbBa©Úlrbs;cin ExµrRkhm)anepþIm

eFVIyuT§nakarmYyedIm,IEklm¥rUbPaB CaBiessrUbPaBEdlcUlcitþbgðÚrQamrbs;eK[)anRbesIrCag

mun. taMgBIedImrdUvekþArhUtdl;cugrdUvsøwkeQIRCúH kareFVITsSnkic©CamitþPaB)anRbRBwtþeTACabnþ

bnÞab;KñaenARbeTskm<úCa. CaBiesseKGackt;smÁal;eXIjRkúmtUc²Edl niymlT§im:akS-elnIn

rbs;GaemrikaMg Rkúmem:Aniymrbs;EblhSik RkúmsgÁmniymrbs;Cb:un. enAeBlRtLb;mkRbeTs

vij GñkxøHkñúgcMeNamGñkeTAeFVITsSnkic©TaMgenaH )anraykarN_[dwgBI«vDÆnPaB»d¾KYr[sJb;EsJg

EdlseRmceFVI)anenARbeTskm<úCa. kñúgkaEstjÚvy:kEfms_ smaCikmñak;kñúgcMeNamGñkeTAeFVI

TsSnkic©TaMgenaH)anTTYlsÁal;fa PaBRCúlhYsehtuGac RtÚvRbRBwtþenATIenaH b:uEnþKat;)anCMTas;

edayCak;lak;BI«erOgminBiténkarsmøab;RbCaCnGs;CaeRcInnak;EdleKRbDitenARkúg)agkk». tam

mtiKat;fa enARbeTséfmanGñkxøHBuMrYjranwg«bg;R)ak;50duløareTA[GñkePosxøÜnmYycMnYneLIy edIm,I

[BYkeKerobrab;BIerOgBiessd¾KYr[RBWxøacTaMgenaHR)ab;BYkbreTs»28.

]bnaykrdæm®nþIrbs;km<úCa eGog sarI )ancab;epþImdMeNIrTsSnkic©mYykñúgPUmiPaKGasuI

GaeKñy_edIm,Isakl,geFVI[mankarxitcUlCitKñamYyCamYybNþaRbeTsxøH CaBiessCamYyRbeTs

NUEGlRkhm 373

Page 384: Brother enemy

éf. rdæm®nþIkarbreTsm:aeLsuI nigéfk¾)aneFVIdMeNIrmkRbeTskm<úCaEdr. eGog sarI )anepþImeFVIkar

naMsRmúHsRmÜlenHedayxøÜnÉg kñúg»kasénsnñisITkaEstmYyenARkúgjÚvy:kGMBIRbFanbT«eyIg

cg;[Gs;elakemIleXIjedaypÞal;EPñkfaetIkm<úCarMelaPsiT§imnusSEmnb¤Gt;?». y:agehacNas;

KeRmagkarenH)aneFVI[TMnak;TMngepSg²RtÚv)ankat;pþac;CamYyGtItkalEdr ³ cab;BIeBlenHteTA

ExµrRkhmcab;KitKUrxøaMgBIkarTietonrbs;saFarNmtiGnþrCati. BYkeK)anRbKl;lixitGeBa¢IjmYy

CUnelakGKÁelxaFikarGgÁkarshRbCaCati xWt v:al;Edm edaysuM[Kat;eFVIdMeNIrmkkan;RbeTskm<úCa

edIm,IvaytémøBIsßanPaBsiT§imnusSenATIenaHpÞal;. kalbriecäTmYyRtÚv)ankMNt;rYcCaeRscKWExkumÖ³

qñaM1979. enAExvicäika RkúgPñMeBj)anyl;RBmGnuBaØat[TIPñak;gareTscrN_mYyrbs;éfEdlCa

kmµsiT§irbs;elak qatéq Qunhav:an; GtItrdæm®nþIkarbreTséfnigCamhamitþmñak;rbs;RbeTscin

erobcM[mandMeNIrkmSanþcMnYnmYyéf¶enAGgÁrvtþcab;BIExmkrateTA. k¾b:uEnþGñkeTscrEdlmkBIevot

Nam GuIRsaEGl kUer:xagt,Úg étv:an; nigGaRhVikxagt,Úg BuMGaccUlrYm)aneT29. qatéq )anniyay

R)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa «KWBuMEmnplkéRmeT EdlelIkTwkcitþ´[eFVIdUecñH. ´manbMNgEtmü:agb:ueNÑaH

KWcg;[RbeTskm<úCaebIkcMhTVar ehIyBYkcink¾manbMNgdUcenHEdr»30.

karEsVgrkkic©FanamYysRmab;semþc

kareFVI[ semþc sIhnu mannItism,TaEpñkneya)ayeLIgvijedayExµrRkhmTMngCaeFVI

[evotNamRBÜy)armÖy:agxøaMgEdrcab;BIéf¶enHeTA. eKnwkeXIjfa kñúgGMLúgéndMeNIrmYyeTA

GgÁkarshRbCaCatienAExtula eGog sarI )anEckcayrUbftsemþcCaeRcInsnøwkEdl)anftkñúg

eBlman«BiFICb;elogd¾sñiT§sñalmYyCakitþiysdl;GñkesñhaCatimatuPUmi»kalBIExmun 31.

BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUyP½yxøacfa karerobcM semþc sIhnu [kan;tMENgvij GacGnuBaØat[

ExµrRkhmrMedaHxøÜnecjedayminGaRkk;eBkBI«bBa¢IBYkmnusSEdleKmincUlcitþ» enAeBlEdlBYkeK

ElgmanGñkNarab;GaneTAehIyenaH. edayehtuenH BYkemdwknaMRkúghaNUymanKeRmagkarpÞal;xøÜn

CaeRcInedIm,ICaRbeyaCn_dl;semþc ³ BYkeKnwgeRbIR)as;RBHnamRBHGgÁedayrIkray edIm,ITak;Taj

karKaMRTcMeBaHclnatsU‘RbqaMg b:ul Bt TaMgxagkñúgk¾dUcCaxageRkARbeTs. enAedImExtula qñaM

1978 smaCikmYyrUbrbs;KN³RbtiPUevotNamenAGgÁkarGu‘yeNsáÚ (U.N.E.S.C.O) )aneFVIdMeNIr

edays¶at;²eTAkan;PaKxagt,ÚgRbeTs)araMg edIm,ICYbCamYyRBHraCbuRtmYyGgÁkñúgcMeNambuRt

CaeRcInGgÁrbs; semþc sIhnu KWRBHGgÁm©as; neratþm rNb£T§i. CamYyRBHeksmUl/ RBHenRtFM²

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg374

Page 385: Brother enemy

jak;RBic² nigRBHsitakarminpøas;bþÚrrbs;RBHGgÁ. RBHGgÁm©as; rNb£T§i manrUbragnigdMeNIrdUcRBH

bitaRBHGgÁebHbiT. enATIenaH RBHGgÁeFVICaRKÚbeRgónEpñkc,ab;enAsaklviTüal½yeGsGg;RbÚv:g;.

ePJóvrbs;RBHGgÁKWGñkBaMnaMsMbuRtmYyBImitþevotNammñak;EdleKsÁal;RKb;KñamkCYbRBHGgÁpÞal;

ehIy)anbgðajxøÜnkñúgzan³CaeRbsitEdlbBa¢ÚnmkedayrdæaPi)alenARkúghaNUypg. Kat;)anEføg

sresIr semþc sIhnu BItYnaTIrbs;RBHGgÁCaGñkksagRbeTskm<úCaTMenIb. Kat;)anTUlCRmabdMNwg

dl;buRtrbs;semþcfa evotNamsgÇwm«rMedaH»semþc)anBIExµrRkhm kñúgeKalbMNgGac[RBHGgÁ

sEmþgtYnaTICaemdwknaMmñak;rbs;clna. eRbsitrbs;evotNam)anTUlRBHGgÁm©as; rNb£T§i fa «eyIg

manbMNgy:agxøaMgkøasUm[RBHGgÁ¬rNb£T§i¦cUlrYmCamYyclnatsU‘fµIrbs;km<úCakñúgzan³CatMNag

semþc sIhnu». rNb£T§i )anEføgGMNrKuNy:agkk;ekþAcMeBaHePJóvBIkarxVayxVl;EdlRbeTs

evotNamKitKUrdl;RBHbitaRBHGgÁ b:uEnþsRmab;RBHGgÁpÞal;RBHGgÁ)anbdiesFmincUlrYmeLIy.

RBHGgÁm©as; rNb£T§i )anmanbnÞÚlR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦Casm¶at;fa «´KµandwgBImUlehtuénkarCab;XuMXaMg

rbs;RBHbita´Tal;EtesaH TaMgmindwgfaevotNammanKMniteFVIy:agem:cpgeT». ebskCnrbs;evot

Nam)anTUldMNwgR)ab;RBHGgÁeRcInCagmunbnþic kñúg»kaséndMeNIrrbs;Kat;mkCYbRBHGgÁCaelIkTIBIr

enABak;kNþalExFñÚ ³ «KWenAmunbuNüNUEGl mYyb¤BIrs)aþh_ ´eTIbnwgerobcMtubEtglm¥edImsa)auMg

(Sapin) nigpáaPJÍepSg²eTotrYcral;. elIkenH evotNam)anesñI[´RBmTTYltYnaTICaGñktMNagBiess

rbs;rNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa EdlkarbegáItclnaenHeTIbnwgRtÚv)anRbkasCasaFarN³.

´)anbdiesFCafµIeTot»32 GsmtßPaBrbs;evotNamedIm,IFana[)ankarCYyeRCamERCgBIsmaCik

mYyGgÁénBUCBgSrbs; semþc sIhnu b¤y:agehacNas;\sSrCnExµrminEmnkumµúynIsþl,IeQµaHmñak;

EdleKsÁal;RKb;Kña )aneFVI[BYkeKxVl;KMnity:agxøaMg. braC½yenHBMu)anCYyBRgwgdl;PaBKYr[eKarB

rbs;clnatsU‘ EdlBYkeKCaGñk]btßmÖKaMBareLIy TaMgk¾min)anbegáInskmµPaBedIm,IseRmceKaledA

GVImYyEdleFVI[cuHfyeRsceTAehIy edaykarvaylukxagTMnak;TMngsaFarN³EdlepþImeLIgeday

ExµrRkhmEdr. bnþiceTotvanwgElgmaneBlsgÇwmfa karcUleFVIGnþraKmn_enARbeTskm<úCa GacTTYl

)anKuNRbeyaCn_BIkarKaMRTb¤karcUlédBIsMNak;GnþrCatieTotehIy. mancMNucviC¢manEtmYy

b:ueNÑaH KWenATIbMput v:al;Edm )anRcanecalmineFVIdMeNIrmkkan;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüeLIy. sRmab;

GVIEdlenAsl;KWkarEklm¥rUbPaBCamuxmat;rbs;km<úCa bnÞab;BIkarebIkTVarbs;xøÜn-BitehIyEdl

RtÚvXøaMemIly:agtwgrwug-eq<aHeTABiPBelakxageRkAEdleFVI[sµúKsµaj RbkbedayeRKaHfñak;dl;

EpnkarTaMgLayrbs;evotNamEfmeTot. enHKWCa»kaseFVIskmµPaBmYyRtÚvkal³eTs³bMput.

NUEGlRkhm 375

Page 386: Brother enemy

sm<½n§PaBeyaFaCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ)anseRmcedaykic©RBmeRBógmYy meFüa)ayepSg²xag

karTUt)anbBa©b; evotNamGacRbmUlpþú¿karykcitþTukdak;TaMgGs;rbs;xøÜneTAelIkarerobcMRbúgeRbób

cugeRkay kñúgkarcUleFVIGnþraKmn_enAkm<úCavij. RkúmemdwknaMRkúghaNUy)ansißtkñúgsßanPaBminsUv

cab;bgçMedayRBwtþikarN_epSg²eLIy. R)akdNas; GtItkmµaPi)alExµrRkhmnigGñknireTsxøÜnkm<úCa

Edlhat;hVwkhVWnenAPaKxagt,ÚgevotNamRbEhl200nak;)anseRmccitþvayRbyuT§ b:uEnþBYkeKenA

BuMTan;bM)at;)ankarTas;ETgKñaxagneya)ayrbs;xøÜnenAeLIy. dUecñH BYkeKenABuMTan;GacbegáItbkS

kumµúynIsþfµImYyrbs;km<úCaEdlGacdwknaMkarRbyuT§)anEdr ehIyeBlevla)anbgçMeFVIkic©karenH[)an

qab;. dUecñH evotNamBuMGacrg;caM[maneBlTMenrkñúgkar ebIksmaCmYyrbs;bkS nigkare)aHeqñat

eRCIstaMgKN³dwknaMmYyeT. karbegáItrNsirSrMedaHkm<úCamYyedayRbmUlpþúMGñkEdlmanninñakar

epSg²Kña KWCaviFankarbeNþaHGasnñmYyEdlgayRsYlCag. edaysarrebobenH nwgGacGnuBaØat

[kgT½Brbs;evotNameFVIskmµPaB)anehIy.

karbBa©úHbBa©ÚlRTwsþIneya)ay nigkarbgðat;beRgónk,ÜneyaFadl;kgT½BExµrEdlcab;epþImtaMgBI

edImqñaM1978 )anbegáInskmµPaBrwtEtxøaMgeLIgEfmeTot. karRcas;Rcal;mansPaBeLIgdl;kRmit

x<s;bMput. b:uEnþ]bsKÁxagPasa)anbgá[mankarlM)aky:ageRcIn ehIyk¾eFVI[dMeNIrRbRBwtþeTAén

RbtibtþikarxageyaFaRtÚvrGak;rGYlxøH². GaRs½yehtuenH evotNametagEtGMBavnavrkCnCati

PaKticExµreRkamenAEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁmkCYykñúgKeRmagkarenH. CaGñkRtÚvCab;sgS½yxagpøÚv

neya)ayyUryarmkehIy edaysarEtkarecHniyayBIrPasarbs;xøÜn BYkeKGacbgðaj[eXIj

CaGñkCMnYykard¾mantémøsRmab;kgT½Brbs;evotNamEdlRtÚvcUlmkkm<úCaenAkñúgkal³eTs³enH.

embBa¢akareQµaH say ):ak; (Say Pak) CnkumµúynIsþkm<úCaEdlFøab;rs;enARkúghaNUytaMgBIqñaM1954

RtÚv)anevotNamRbKl;Parkic©[eRCIserIsyuvCnExµreRkamcUleFVIkgT½BenAextþ)ak;lIv kñúgEdndI

sNþ. Kat;)anerobcMebIksm½yRbCuMCasaFarN³CaeRcInelIk edIm,IbBa©úHbBa©ÚlyuvCn[cUlrYmkñúg

clnarMedaHRbeTskm<úCa ehIyminkMNaj;nwgkarsnüaepSg²eLIy ³ bnÞab;BIkarrMedaHRbeTseBj

elj Gñksµ½RKcitþnwg)anTTYl«muxtMENgTTYlxusRtÚvepSg²kñúgrdæaPi)al»edayKµanBi)ak. eRkay

BIeFVIBiFIbBa©ÚlmYy yuvCn500nak;)anRtÚvbBa¢ÚneTA kaem:A (Ca Mau) edIm,ITTYlkarbNþúHbNþalxag

eyaFa. enAExmkra qñaM1979 RkúmenHnwgRtÚvcUl rYmCamYykgÉkPaBrbs;evotNamCaeRcIneTot

kñúg»kasénkarvaylukrbs;evotNammkelIextþtaEkvenARbeTskm<úCa.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg376

Page 387: Brother enemy

karerobcMBiFIsem<aF

Dij kan CaGtItnayTahanEpñkvisVkmµénkgT½Brbs;evotNam)anCYyeRCamERCgd¾sMxan;GMBI

Gaf’kM)aMgkñúgkarerobcMRbúgeRbobenH. kan manvasnaRtLb;eTApÞHvij y:ag LWt BIkarrs;enAmYy

ry³enACMrMGb;rMEkERbCafµImYyEdleRtómsRmab;EtBYknayTahanrbs;rbbcas;b:ueNÑaH. smtßPaB

CavisVkrrbs;Kat;EdlbNþúHbNþaledayBYkGaemrikaMg)anTak;TajkarykcitþTukdak;mkelIrUbKat;.

eKRtÚvkarCMnYyrbs;Kat; edIm,IsßabnapøÚvfñl;nigs<any:ageRcInenAkñúgextþdak;Lat;/ sugeb nig taynij

EdlmanRBMEdnCab;RbeTskm<úCa. cab;BIrdUvekþAqñaM1978mk eKminBi)akkat;sµanBIehtukarN_

cEmøk²EdlkMBugEtRtÚverobcMCasm¶at;eLIy ³ rdæaPi)alevotNam )an[kgT½BerobcMcat;EcgCYs

CulpøÚvTaMgGs;EdlCapøÚveq<aHmkkan;RbeTskm<úCa. taMgBIExtula kgÉkPaBevotNamCaeRcIn)an

kan;kab;ceRmókdIxøH²rbs;km<úCaenAtambeNþayRBMEdn. enABak;kNþalExviciäka kgT½Brbs;

evotNam)aneFVIRbtibtþikary:agsMxan;mYy mkkñúgextþRkecHtambeNþaypøÚvCatielx13. kar

RbyuT§suIsac;hutQam)aneFVI[kgBlFMmYyrbs;ExµrRkhmesÞIrEtrlaysabsUnü. PUmiPaKenaH

RtÚv)anRbkasfaCa«tMbn;rMedaH» b:uEnþ «GñkdwknaMkargarenH»enAEteFVI[ kan nwkKitminyl;Canic©rhUt

mkdl;éf¶mYykñúgExvicäika eTIbKat;eXIj]T§mÖaKcRkmYyeRKÓg)anehaHmkcuHctenAxagmuxkariyal½y

eFVIkarrbs;Kat;EdlenACitRBMEdn. enAkñúg]T§mÖaKcRkKat;eXIj eL DwkfU nig]tþmesnIy_ dug v:an;kug

embBa¢akarrgeyaFPUmiPaKTI7 )anGeBa¢IjmkedaypÞal; edIm,IRtÜtBinitükarerobcMsem<aFCapøÚvkarnUv

karbegáItclnatsU‘rbs;km<úCa nigkarerobcMTIbBa¢akarCYrmuxrbs;kgT½BevotNampg.

TIkEnøgEdlseRmcykedIm,IRbkasBIkarbegáItrNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCatikm<úCaCapøÚvkarsßitenA

cm¶aybIKILÚEm:RtBIRBMEdnevotNamkñúgTwkdIkm<úCa. TIenaHCaéRBre)aHtUcmYycMkNþalcmáarekAsU‘mYy

naTisxagekItTIRbCuMCnsñÜl. kan )annaMbu‘ldUEhSrmYyeRKÓgrbs;kgT½BeTATIenaH edIm,IBRgabdI[

esµIl¥. RkúmTahanénkgBlFMelx476)anerobcMdMeLIgevTikamYy nigRbdab;bMBgsMeLgpg. enA

RBwkéf¶TI2 ExFñÚ qñaM1978 RbCaCnExµrCaeRcInBan;nak;)anmkRbmUlpþúMKñaenATIenaH eRkamBnøWRBHGaTitü

d¾PøWciBa©ac. PaKeRcInénGñkTaMgenaHRtÚv)andwkCBa¢ÚnmktamLankamIj:úg CaeRcIneRKÓgtaMgBICMrMGñk

ePosxøÜnTaMgLayenARbeTsevotNam. kgT½BCaeRcInrynak; -CaExµrRkhmrt;ecalCYr b¤CayuT§Cn

erIsfµIEdlhat;hVwkhVWnenARbeTsevotNam-)anesøókBak;bg¥ÜtÉksNæanfµIETg nigmYkBN’ébtg

rbs;xøÜny:agExgEr:g. bTePøgCatifµImYyEdleRcógCaRkúm)anlan;B¤eLIg enAeBlEdlxül;rMePIy²

bk;Tg;CatiRbmaNdb;EdlmanBN’Rkhm nigBN’elOg CanimitþrUbrbs;rNsirSeTIbbegáItfµIrlas;

NUEGlRkhm 377

Page 388: Brother enemy

rvic².

smaCikKN³kmµaFikarTaMgdb;bYnrUb )aneLIgQrbgðajxøÜncMeBaHmuxhVÚgRbCaCnmþgmYy²

eRkamkarTHédGbGrsaTry:agkgrMBg. )ac;páaEdleKnaMBIRbeTsevotNammk RtÚv)aneKCUncMeBaH

smaCikmñak;². ehg sMrin CaRbFanrNsirS)aneLIgGankmµviFIney)ay enAeBlEdlhVÚgRbCaCn

)anERskCyeXassEmþgkarKaMRTedaye)aHkNþab;eTAelI. eRkayBIenaH Kat;)anedIrsMedAeTAmux

edIm,IEføgGMNrKuN eL DwkfU EdlenAQrsegátemIlBiFIenHBIcm¶ayhak;dUcCaemman;mYysb,aycitþ

nwgkUn²rbs;vaG‘Icwg. eL DwkfU niyaymkkan; ehg sMrin edayrIkmuxRss;b:Rbimfa «´minnwksµanfa

smmitþerobcMBiFI)anl¥dUecñHesaH»33.

bnÞab;BIeFIVmiTÞIgrYc bNþakgÉkPaBrbs;clnats‘UnigGñkdwknaMrNsirS)anedIrBinitüemIlPUmi

CaeRcInenACab;RBMEdnEdlExµrRkhmdkfyecjeTAvij)at;Gs;. emdwknaMTaMgenaH)anBnül;RbCaCn

BIkmµviFI11cMNucrbs;xøÜn edIm,IdeNIþmykeCaKC½yelIrbb b:ul Bt nigerobcMCIvPaBRKÜsaresdækic©

TIpSar R)ak;kas sasna eLIgvijnigbB©ab;s®gÁamRBMEdnCamYyRbeTsevotNam34. sßanIyviTüú

mYyenARkúghUCImijEdldak;namsRmab;»kasenaHfa «sMeLgrbs;RbCaCnkm<úCa» )ancab;epþImpSBV

pSaykmµviFIrbs;rNsirSsamKIþse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa nigraykarN_BIdMeNIrRbRBwtþeTAénkarRbyuT§

epSg². xitþb½NÑrab;Ban;snøwkEdlGMBavnav[mankaregIbbHe)arRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt RtÚv)aneK)ac

BIelIynþehaHtambNþaextþnanaEdlenACitRBMEdn.

kalBIémÖR)aMbIqñaMmun evotNamFøab;)anCYy]btßmÖkñúgkarbegIátclnarMedaHCatiCaelIkdMbUg

rbs;km<úCaKWrNsirSÉkPaB\sSr³ edImI,vayRbyuT§Tl;nwgkarkan;kab;rbs;)araMg. R)aMbIqñaMmun evot

NamFøab;)anP¢ab;vasnarbs;BYkeKCamYyrNsirSrYbrYmCatikm<úCaRbqaMgnwgGaemrikaMgEdr. dUecñH

enHCaelIkTIbIehIyEdlevotNamerobcM«clnatsU‘rMdaH»mYyenAelITwkdIRbeTsCitxagxøÜn 35. eL

DwkfU k¾CamnusSEdleKsÁal;rab;GanyUrmkehIy Kat;Føab;)anCYybegáItrNsirSÉkPaB\sSr³taMg

BIeBlmunmk ehIycab;taMgBIqñaM1966 Kat;KWCaGñkTTYlxusRtÚvxagbBaðakm<úCaenAkariyal½yneya

)aybkSkumµúynIsþevotNam36. manPaBxusKñaEtmYyb:ueNÑaH elIkenH sRtÚvBMuEmnCaGaNaniKm

niym)araMgb¤cRkBtiþniymGaemrikaMgeT b:uEnþCaGtItsm½n§mitþkumµúynIsþmYyeTAvij. Tg;CatifµIrbs;

clnaenH KWCanimitþrUbénkarRtLb;eTArkRbéBNIcas;énshRbtibtþikarExµr-evotNamedayeBj

elj ³ rUbR)asaTkMBUlR)aMBN’elOgelIépÞBN’Rkhm. nimitþrUbenHEdleRbIR)as;CaelIkdMbUg

edayExµr\sSr³kñúgTsvtSr_50 )anRtÚve)aHbg;ecaledayRkúmrbs; b:ul Bt enAqñaM1975 ehIy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg378

Page 389: Brother enemy

km<úCaRbCaFibetyü)anGnum½tTg;CatiBN’Rkhm R)asaTBN’elOg kMBUlbIvij.

b:uEnþnimitþrUbniymenH )anrbUtputBIPaKeRcInénsmaCikfIµénrNsirSsamKIÁse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa

Edlbc©½yCaedImehtusMxan;KWkarrs;ranmanCIviténRkúmRKÜsar b¤bNþamitþPkiþrbs;BYkeKEdlsßitenA

eRkamkarekþabkþab;rbs;ExµrRkhm. enHCakars¥b;ex<ImrYmmYycMeBaHrbb b:ul Bt EdlRbmUlpþMú

eRkamkardwknaMrbs;evotNamnUvGñkEdlrYcputBIkarsmøab;rgÁalCaeRcInKW GñkePosxøÜn EdlecjBI

vNѳmFüm/ Gñkrt;ecalCYr nigGñkEbkbkSBYkBIExµrRkhm. PaKeRcInénsmaCikKN³dwknaMb¤GñkcUl

rYmFmµta suT§Etdk;Cab;nUvkarmineCOTukcitþcMeBaHectnad¾RCaleRCArbs;BYkevotNam. b:uEnþBYkeK

KµaneXIjCeRmIsNaepSgeRkABIseRmccitþeFVIdUecñH edIm,Ise®gÁaHkm<úCaeLIy. smaCikPaBKN³kmµa

FikarkNþalrbs;rNsirSsamKIÁse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa )anqøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjnUvPaBlaycRmúHmYyEdl

minsßitesßr ³ GtItExµrRkhmR)aMmYynak;Edlman ehg sMrin CaRbFan BYkkumµúynIsþRbkan;tam

RTwsIþEdlsiñT§evotNam¬Exµr\sSr³¦bYnnak; bBaØvnþTIRkúgbInak; nigRBHsgÇmYyGgÁ 37.

eBjry³eBlénkareFIVmiTIÞg kgT½Berobryrbs;evotNamCaeRcIn)anBRgwgsßanPaBkarBar

CMuvijTIenaH. Gñkkan;kaMePøIg)aj;ynþehaH)anrMéBemIleTAelIemXKµanQb;QrTaMgnwk)armÖkñúgcitþ.

Dij kan nigKIñKñarbs;Kat;)anTTYlbBa¢a[kab;éRBeQIkñúgtMbn;mYysißtenAcm¶ayRbEhlBIrKILÚEm:Rt

enAkñúgTwkdIénextþRkecHrbs;km<úCa EdlRtÚverobcMeFIVCabBa¢akardæanCYrmuxrbs;kgT½BevotNam.

eK)andwkCBa¢ÚnkugtWn½rGaluymIjÚ:mCaeRcInEdlRbmUlykBImUldæannanarbs;GaemrikaMgmkkan;TIenH

Edr. eK)ansagsg;pÞHdMbUlRbk;s,ÚvnigelNdæanFM²y:ageRcIn. enAeRkamedImeQIeKerobcMdak;

m:asIunePøIg nigsmÖarbrikçarviTüúTak;Tg. bBa¢akardæanenHEdlRbsiT§namfa eTon pug «bu:s×þCYrmux»nwg

bgá[manBüúHsgÇramkelIRbeTskm<úCaenAeBlxagmuxqab;².

eKaledAKWRkúgPñMeBj

karpþl;sBaØacab;epIþmkarvaylukedayeyaFa RtÚv)ankMNt;eFVIkñúgsgáat;mYyénextþ )aemFYt

sßitenAelItMbn;x<g;rab. kardeNþImykTIRkúgenHbnÞab;BIkarRbyuT§edaymin[dwgxøÜnmunmYynaExmIna

qñaM1975 )ankMNt;nUvkarcab;epIþmebIk«yuT§nakarhUCImij»EdlRtÚvbBa©b;CamYykardYlrlMénTIRkúg

éRBnKr. enABak;kNþalGRFaRtéf¶TI24 ExFñÚ CYgrbs;RBHviharRKisþsasna )anbnøWeLIgenAeBl

Edl]tþmesnIy_ CU h‘uym:an; GKÁsñgkarneya)ayénkgT½BRbCaCnevotNam)anelIkkaMePøIgxøI)aj;

eLIgeTAelImYyRKab;CasBaØa[ebIkkarvaylukCapøÚvkarEdldwknaMeday]tþmesnIy_ hYg kaM. Gñk

NUEGlRkhm 379

Page 390: Brother enemy

TTYlxusRtÚvevotNammñak;)anerobrab;R)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa «]tþmesnIy_ kaM sÁal;RbeTskm<úCaPaK

xagekItdUcsÁal;ehae):Arbs;Kat; Kat;Føab;)andwknaMRbtibtþieyaFasMxan;²CaeRcInRbqaMgnwg ln; nl;

kñúgGMLúgTsvtSr_70».

eRkamépÞemXEdledrdas;eTAedayBnøWpáayepøk² sñÚrsnw§kénExSrfeRkaH et54 nigLan

kamIjú:gCaeRcIneRKÓgEdlpÞúkeBjeTAedayTahan )ancab;epIþmecjdMeNIrtampøÚvCatielx14Edl

naMeq<aHmkkan;RbeTskm<úCaeRkamGakasFatuRtCak;eRsg. R)aMéf¶eRkaymk BYkeK)anvay

RbharbnÞayExµrRkhmenATIRkúgRkecH[)ak;T½Brt;r):at;r):ayGs; 38.

RkecHCaTIRkúgmYyEdlevotNamsÁal;c,as;dUcRkey:AédeRkayeBl«rMedaH»)anBIkgT½Brbs;

ln; nl; enAqñaM1970. enATIenaHevotNam)anbegáItmNÐlhat;hwVkhWVnmYysRmab;bNþúHbNþal

ExµrRkhmCaeRcInrynak;[ecHRbyuT§tamEbbkumµ:g;dU. R)aMbYnqñaMeRkaymk BYkeK)anvaypþac;yk

TIRkúgenHBIkNþab;éd«GtItsisS»rbs;eKmkvijedIm,IRbKl;eTA[sm<½n§mitþExµrfIµrbs;xøÜnvijmþg.

enAéf¶TI1 Exmkra qñaM1979 kgT½Brbs;evotNamEdlcuHmkBIRbeTsLavtamTenøemKgÁ)an

deNþImkan;kab;FanIénextþsÞwgERtg. tamBit kardYlrlMtMbn;d¾sMxan;bMputTaMgBIr EdlsßitenAtamdg

TenøemKgÁenaH)ankat;pþac;extþcMnYnbYnenAPUmiPaK|sanrYcCaeRsc. tMbn;PñMsm,ÚreTAedayéRBeQI

énPUmiPaK|sanEdlmanGñkRsukPñMrs;enAtictYc suT§EtCaTICRmks¶at;kM)aMgrbs;clnaRbqaMgnwg

ln; nl; kalBIGMLúgTsvtSr_70. kEnøgTaMgenaH)anERbkøayeTACa«tMbn;rMedaH»sRmab;rNsirSfIµ

rbs;km<úCaCafIµmþgeTot.

kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH kgT½Brbs;eyaFPUmiPaKTI7 nigTI9 eRkamGKÁbBa¢akar]tþmesnIy_ eL

DwkGaj; (Le Duc Anh) EdlmankgrfeRkaHnaMmux )anebIkkarvayluky:agFMmYytampøÚvCatielx1nig

elx7EdlnaMtRmg;mkrkTenøemKgÁdUcKña. munepþImeFIVkarvaylukenH kgT½BGakasrbs;evotNam

)anTmøak;RKab;Ebky:agsn§wksn§ab;eTAelITItaMgTaMgLayrbs;ExµrRkhmesÞIEteBjmYys)aþh_eTA

ehIy. b:ul Bt )anRbRBwtþnUvkMhusy:agF¶n;mYyeRBaHKat;RbmUlpþúMT½BRbEhl 30>000nak; KWRtÚv

CaBak;kNþaléncMnYnkgT½Berobryrbs;ExµrRkhm dak;BRgayragekagdUcFñÚsn§wgtambeNþaytMbn;

cMBuHesk¬extþsVayerog¦ nigtMbn;EpøsnÞÚc ¬Rsukemmt; extþkMBg;cam¦ minq¶ayBIRBMEdnevotNam

b:unµaneLIy. bnÞab;BIkarsÞg;rkTItaMgtamGakasCamunrYcmk kgT½BTaMgenaH)an RtÚvsmøab;y:agrgÁal

edaykarvayRbharpÁÜbKñarvagkgkaMePøIgFM nigkarTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;evotNam. kgT½Brbs; b:ul

Bt )anbeB©aj[eXIjkartsU‘reb:Hre):aHy:agKYr[q¶l;. kgT½BEdlmanedImkMeNItCaRbCaksikr

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg380

Page 391: Brother enemy

TaMgenHecHsmøab;mnusSEtnwgkaMbitExVv pÁak; b:ueNÑaH b:uEnþBYkeKBMumaneBlevlaeronebIkbrynþehaH

Rbedj b¤eRbIkaMePøIgynþ)aj;ynþehaHeLIy. PaKeRcInénTIRbwkSa nigRKÚbgðat;cin )anCemøósxøÜn

ecjtamsmuRTedayKµanEGGg; edayTuk[ExµrRkhmEdlKµanbTBiesaFn_edaHkunEtmñak;Ég. enA

eBlEdlevotNamcUldl;TIRkúgPñMeBjdeNþIm)anCyPNÐ BYkeK)anRbTHeXIjynþehaHmic-19

manKUrTg;Catikm<úCaRbCaFibetyüfIµsnøagenAteRmóbCaCYrkñúgcMNtGakasyandæaneBaFicintugTaMg

Gs; ehIymanynþehaHxøHeTIbnwgykecjBIeksfIµ²pg.

ebITukCamankarKaMBartampøÚvGakask¾eday k¾karruleTAmuxrbs;kgT½BevotNamtampøÚveKak

BMuEmngayRsYlenaHeT. vresnIy_Ék b‘YyTin Edl)anftrUbBIelI]T§mÖaKcRkrbs;Kat;nUvkarvay

RbyuT§KñaepSg²)anniyayR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa karc,aMgKñaEdlsahaveXareXACageK kñúgyuT§nakar

enHmunkardeNIþm)anTIRkúgPñMeBj KW)anekIteLIgenAkñúgtMbn;EpøsnÞÚc. karRbyuT§Kñadac;k,aldac;

knÞúy)anRbRBwtþeTAkñúgry³eBlBIréf¶. evotNam)ansakl,gqøgkat;brievNExSkarBarmYyEdl

erobcMeLIgedaykarCIkRbLayTwk nigcmáarmIneFVICar)aMg. kalebIqøgkat;]bsKÁenHrYcehIy kgT½B

)anRbjab;Rbjal;eLIgtamTenøemKgÁeTAelIrhUthYsBIFanIénextþkMBg;cameTAeTot. karvayRbyuT§

KñaFM²BIreTot)anekItmanenAGñkelOg pøÚvCatielx1 EdlCakMBg;cmøgcugeRkaytamdgTenøemKgÁmun

nwgeTAdl;PñMeBj nigenAtanI¬extþkMBt¦ tampøÚvCatielx3 eq<aHeTArktMbn;eqñrsmuRT39. kgÉkPaB

kumµ:g;dUmYyRkúm)anseRmceCaKC½yeTAdl;mat;RcaMgTenøsabTl;muxnwgRkúgPñMeBj. enAmuneBlRBwk

éf¶TI2 Exmkra qñaM1979 BYkeK)ansakl,gqøgkat;TenøsabedIm,IeTA«rMedaH»semþc sIhnu. kar

b:unb:genH)anRtÚvbraC½y. semþc sIhnu )anmanRBHraCbnÞÚlR)ab;Gaf’kM)aMgCamYy´¬GñkniBn§¦

edaykaresaksþayfa «BYkeK)anqøgkat;édTenøsabedIm,Icab;BRgt;´ ehIyBYkeK)anRtÚvsmøab;

esIÞrEtTaMgGs;. Pøam²enaH ´)andNwþgsYrkñúgRBHT½yfa ehtuGIV)anCa exov sMpn mkTUl´fa ´man

eBldb;R)aMnaTIedImI,erobcMecjdMeNIr? bnÞab;mk eK)annaM´eTAkan;extþ)at;dMbgnigsIusUpuneTA»40.

enAéf¶TI4 Exmkra evotNam)anRtÜtRtaeRtIyxagekItTenøemKgÁTaMgGs; srubeTAmanR)aMBIr

extþ b:uEnþBYkeKElgGacsgÇwmyk semþc sIhnu [eFIVCaGñkdwknaMrNsirSRKb;RKg«tMbn;rMedaH» d¾lVwg

elVIyeTotehIy.

bnÞab;BIkarQb;p¥akmYyéf¶ kñúgraRtIéf¶4 Exmkra kariyal½yneya)ayénbkSkumµúynIsþevot

Nam)andak;bTbBa¢apþac;RB½RtmYyEdlRtÚvseRmc[)andac;xat«eKaledA ³ RkúgPñMeBj». enAéf¶TI6

Exmkra qñaM1979 kgT½Brbs;evotNam)anqøgkat;TenøemKgÁenAGñkelOgnigenAxageCIgkMBg;cam.

NUEGlRkhm 381

Page 392: Brother enemy

s<anbENþtTwkEdlplitenAsUevotnigkaNUtcmøgFM²rbs;GaemrikEdlnaMmkBIRbeTsevotNam)an

GnuBaØat[rfeRkaH rfynþ nigkgT½BqøgmkeRtIyxaglic)anedaygayRsÜl. kgBlR)aMbYnkñúg

cMeNamkgBlFMTaMgdb;BIrrbs;evotNam EdlKaMRTedaykgT½BrNsirSbIkgvresnaFMeTot )anh‘um

B½T§TIRkúgPñMeBjBITisGaeKñy_nigTisxageCIg. enAeBlRBwkéf¶TI7 Exmkra qñaM1979 kgkmøaMgFMrbs;

evotNam )ancab;epIþm)aj;epøagdak;tMbn;CayRkúgrbs;rdæFanIy:agsem,Im. bnÞab;mk mat;RckcUl

TIRkúgd¾sMxan;CageKBIr KWpøÚvCatielx1 nigpøÚvCatielx7)ansißtenAkñúgsßanPaBRtÚvXaMgxÞb;edaykar

rulmkmuxrbs;CYrT½BevotNamEdlsRmúkcUlmkTaMghVÚg².

PaBsb,ayrIkrayRtÚvbBa©b;

ebItamP½sþútagepSg²EdlRtÚvKñasIþBIéf¶cugeRkayrbs;RkúgPñMeBjenaHGacnwg[eKykeTAtak;

EtgCasac;erOgmYykñúgExSPaBynþrbs; EhVllInI ¬Fellini - smiTi§krPaBynþsBa¢atiGIutalI¦)an.

mnIÞreBTüEtmYyKt;rbs;TIRkúgEdlenAbMeBjkargar eXIjmanhUrehoreTAedaykgT½BRtÚvrbYsy:ag

eRcInEdldwkmkBIsmrPUmi. GñkrbYsRbmaNmYyrynak;edksþÚksþwgenAelITIFøa nigtampøÚvfñl;xagmux

mnIÞreBTüEdlRKbdNþb;eTAedayQamnigstVruy ehIyERskf¶ÚredaykarQWcab;nwgmuxrbYs. enA

kEnøgdéTeTotkñúgRkúgPñMeBj KWCaeBlevlaénkarsb,ayrIkraynigkarerobcMBiFIepSg². tam

RbéBNI karebIkrdUvensaT)anRbRBwtþeTAenAcugExFñÚnigedImExmkra. enARBwkéf¶TI6 Exmkra qñaM

1979 LankamIjú:gBIreRKÓg)andwkRtIykmk[CMrM«b>30» EdlCaCMrMkmµaPi)albdivtþn_tUctac nig

RkúmRKÜsarrbs;BYkeKrs;enA. sRmab;GñkEdlsIuGt;sIuXøantaMgBIeRcInExmkehIyenaH kareXIj«RtI»

enAeBlenHKWCarbs;EdlelIkkmøaMgcitþy:agBitR)akd. PøamenaH briyakas)anERbeTACakarsb,ay

rIkrayxusBIsBVdg. mnusSTaMgGs;kñúgCMrM)anRbjab;Rbjal;eFVIRtImuneBlEdlvas¥úy ehIy)an

briePaK)ayéf¶Rtg;y:agsáb;sál; bnÞab;mk BYkeKcab;epIþmerobcMRtIEdlenAsl;sRmab;GahareBl

l¶ac nigRbLak;TuksRmab;ExxagmuxeTot. b:uEnþ karsb,ayrIkrayenHmanry³eBlxøIbMput. bTbBa¢a

RtÚv)ankMNt;[erobcMxøÜncakecjCabnÞan;. ®sþImñak;EdlmineCO)ansYrfa «cakecj\LÚvenHb¤?

ehIycuHRtIrbs;eyIgeFIVy:agem:ceTA? karP½ysøn;esøamYy)anraldaleBjCMrMTaMgmUl41.

minq¶ayBITIenHb:unµan enAeragcRktm,ajRkúgPñMeBjk¾manerOgdUcKñaenHEdr. ExµrRkhm)an

GnuBaØat[kmµkrsmøab;stVRCÚknigman; edIm,IerobcMBiFICb;elogmYyCakitiþysdl;buNüxYbelIkTI1én

«C½yCmñHCaRbvtiþsa®sþ»elIRbeTsevotNam. karerobcMRbúgeRbóbesIÞrEtcb;sBVRKb;eTAehIy

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg382

Page 393: Brother enemy

Rsab;EtkmµkrTaMgGs;)anTTYlbTbBa¢a[eFIVdMeNIrCabnÞan;eTAcMNtrfePøIg edIm,IeRtómcakecjtam

pøÚvEdk42.

evotNam )ankMNt;eFIVkarp¥akmYykñúgkarvaylukrbs;xøÜntaMgBIyb;éf¶TI3 Exmkraemø:H ehIy

RkúgPñMeBjnwksµanTaMgxusfa mansniþsuxvijehIy. enAyb;éf¶TI5 Exmkra b:ul Bt EdleCOCak;elI

xøÜnÉgR)akdenaH)anTUl semþc sIhnu TukCamunfa kgT½Brbs;Kat;c,as;Cae)assm¥atevotNam

[Gs;munry³eBlBIrExminxan. tamkar[eyabl;rbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg ExµrRkhm)anksagkEnøglak;

GavuFy:agrwgmaMCaeRcInenACYrPñMRkvaj sRmab;krNIEdlBYkeKRtÚve)aHbg;rdæFanITaMgRbjab;Rbjal;

ehIykñúgbTsmÖasn_mYyEdlpþl;dl;TIPñak;garB½t’mancinfIµ enAéf¶TI11 ExFñÚ b:ul Bt )anRbkasfa

rdæaPi)alrbs;Kat;erobcM«s®gÁammYyEdlRtÚveRbIry³eBlyUrnigkarRbwgERbgy:agxøaMg»CamYyevot

NamrYceRscehIy. k¾b:uEnþ km<úCaBMu)ansµanTukCamunBIkardYlrlMy:agTan;hn;mYydUecñHesaHeLIy.

enAeBlEdl b:ul Bt dwgxøÜnfa C½yCmñHElgmanehIyenaH KWvahYseBleTAehIy. mindl;émÖbYn

em:agpg rdæFanIRtÚvbeB©ajmnusSeTAeRkATaMgGs;. Gñkrs;enAkñúgrdæFanITaMgb:unµan RtÚve)aHbg;eBl

)ayminTan;ehIyrbs;xøÜnnigRtIrab;etanEdlTuk[s¥úyrlYyecal b:uEnþk¾e)aHbg;eRKÓgsa®sþavuF

RKab;rMesvy:ageRcIn nigÉksarTaMgLayrbs;KukTYlEsøgEdlnaM[eRKaHfñak;eTotpg. «Duc» Edl

CaRbFanKuknigCamnusSmñak;kñúgcMeNammnusSEdleKEsVgrkCageKbMputrbs;rbbenaH viHEtnwgRtÚv

eKTukecalenAnwgkEnøg b:uEnþenATIbMput Duc )anecjputBIPñMeBjedaysuvtßiPaB eRkaykarmkdl;rbs;

BYkevotNambniþc. ÉkGKÁrdæTUtcinnigTIRbwkSaCaeRcInrynak;GaccakecjTan;eBlevla b:uEnþ eday

TukecalGIV²TaMgGs;EdlBYkeKman. evotNammancitþrIkrayy:agxøaMg enAeBlEdlrkeXIjbnÞb;

eRkamdImYyrbs;sßanTUtEdlpÞúkeBjeTAedayRsakUj:ak;rbs;)araMg.

etIBYkeKegOgq¶l;nwgkardYlrlMelOnrh½srbs;RkúgPñMeBjEmnEdrb¤eT?. eTaHCamkdl;

sBVéf¶ k¾eKlM)aknwgeqøIy[)anc,as;BIerOgenHNas;. kñúgkRmgGnusSavrIy_rbs;]tþmesnIy_BIrrUb

EdlmanTak;TgnwgerOgenH43)anerobrab;fa ³ edaypÞúynwg«yuT§nakarhUCImij» edIm,IdeNþImTIRkúg

éRBnKr KµanGIVEdlRtÚvsresrenAéf¶enHsþIBIkareFIVGnþraKmn_rbs;evotNamenAkm<úCaeLIy.

eK)andwgkñúgkarbriyayBIyuT§nakarenAkñúgqñaM1975fa enAExFñÚ qñaM1974 kariyal½yneya

)ayrbs;evotNam)anGnum½tCaGaT×nUvEpnkarskmµPaBmYy edayeRKagTukCamunnUvkarbegáInrwtEt

xøaMgmYykñúgkartsU‘neya)ay nigeyaFarbs;kgT½BRbCaCnevotNamenArvagqñaM1975-76

«kñúgeKalbMNgRbmUlpþúMlkçN³sm,tiþepSg²sRmab;karvaylukCaTUeTAmYy nigkaregIbbHe)armYy>>>

NUEGlRkhm 383

Page 394: Brother enemy

edIm,IrMedaHPaKxagt,Úg»44.

bnÞab;BIkarvaylukCaelIkdMbUgenAExmIna qñaM1975 eTAelItMbn;x<g;rabrYcmk rbbrbs;evot

Namxagt,Úg)anRtÚvvinasy:agqab;rh½s EdleFVI[kariyal½yneya)ayrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevot

NamseRmccitþqk;yk»kasCayuT§sa®sþenH edIm,IeFIVkar«rMedaHTIRkúgéRBnKr[)anenAmunrdUvePøóg

Føak;». kardeNIþmykRkúgPñMeBjenAqñaM1979 etIkariyal½yneya)ayrbs;evotNam)anqk;

»kasCafµIdUckarvayykTIRkúgéRBnKrkalBIbYnqñaMmunEmnb¤? b¤mYyevotNammaneKalbMNgtaMg

EtBIedImmkedIm,Ikan;kab;TUTaMgRbeTs nigelIkbnþúbrbbGay:gmYyenAnwgkEnøg?. ebIvinicä½yerOgenH

eTAtamel,ÓnEdlevotNamvaydeNþImykTIRkúgPñMeBjnigerobcMrdæaPi)alfIµmYyenATIenaH PaKeRcIn

énGñksegátkarN_)ansniñdæanfa enHCaeKaledArbs;evotNamEmn».

tamkarBit \LÚvenHeKmanB½t’many:agRKb;RKan;edIm,IbBa¢ak;GHGagfa evotNamRKan;Eteqøót

»kasEdlhuc[BYkeK dUcenAkñúgéRBnKrkalBIqñaM1975Edr. bTsmÖasn_rbs;emdwknaMrNsirS

samKÁIse®gÁaHCatiBIrrUb )aneTACaeKalbEg¥kénsmµtikmµd¾mansarsMxan;bMputenH. Ca suT§ smaCik

sßabnikmñak;kñúgcMeNamsmaCiksßabnikrbs;rNsirS nigCasmaCikkariyal½yneya)ayénbkS

RbCaCnbdivtþkm<úCa )anTTYlsÁal;enAkñúg»kassnÞnaKñamYyCamYy sÞIehVn hIuD½r enAqñaM1981 fa

enAeBlcab;epIþmdMbUg²rNsirSBMusgÇwmdeNþImykRbeTsTaMgmUl)aneT. «eyIgsgÇwmkan;kab;

RbeTsRtwmEtBak;kNþalb:ueNÑaH KWeRtIyTenøemKgÁmçagehIycMENkEdlenAsl;Tuk[ b:ul Bt».

enHCaeCaKC½yxageyaFadMbUg² rbs;evotNamEdlbNþal[mankarpøas;bþÚrkmµviFImYy. enAeBl

enaHevotNam)anseRmcvayykTIRkúgPñMeBjEtmþgTan;GaceFIVeTA)an ehIycUlRbLÚkkñúgs®gÁam

mYyEdlRtÚveRbIry³eBlyUr nigkarRbwgERbgy:agxøaMg. «eyIgminsgÇwmfa GacdeNþImykRbeTs

TaMgmUl)anPøam²eLIy. eyIg)anebIkkarvaylukrbs;eyIg ehIyeyIgBMuRbTHnwgkarTb;Tl;Na

mYyTal;EtesaH. BYkkgT½Brbs; b:ul Bt ecHEtdkfy eyIgecHEtruleTAmuxq¶ayeTA²>>>enAeBl

EdleyIgdwgBIsßankarN_EdlRkúgPñMeBjCemøósmnusSGs; eyIgk¾bukcUleTAkñúgebHdUgrdæFanI

Etmþg. eyIgBMuGacbeNþay[TIRkúgTeTs¥atKµanmnusSenA)aneLIy»45.

smaCikKN³kmµaFikarmCÄiménbkSRbCaCnbdivtþkm<úCamñak;eToteQµaH Ehm samin )anniyay

erOgsm¶at;R)ab; sIÞehVn hIuD½r kñúgeBleFIVsmÖasn_mYyepSgeTotrebobdUcKñaEdrfa ³ KeRmagkardMbUg

KWvayRbharnig «deNþImkan;kab;EteRtIyTenøemKgÁmçagb:ueNÑaH». «b:uEnþ enAeBlEdleyIgepIþmebIk

karvayluknigsegáteXIjfadUcCaRsYleyIgk¾cab;bnþruleTAmuxeToteTA»46.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg384

Page 395: Brother enemy

ehtukarN_xøH²EdlekIteLIgRtÚv)aneRbIsRmab;bBa¢ak;BIcemIøyCasakSITaMgenaH. eKGacrk

eXIjsBaØaepSg²énkarRbjab;Rbjal;kñúgcMeNamemdwknaMrNsirS enAcMeBaHmuxdMeNIrénRBwtiþkarN_

TaMgGs;EdlelceLIg[eXIj. karvayluk)ancab;epIþmenAcugExFñÚ b:uEnþTal;Etdl;éf¶TI6 Exmkra

qñaM1979 eTIbrNsirSpSBVpSaytamviTüúnUvkmµviFI«bnÞan;» mYymanR)aMbIcMNucEdlRtÚvGnuvtþkñúg

«tMbn;rMedaHnana»enAkm<úCa. kmµviFIenHRtÚv)anGnum½tenAéf¶TI5 Exmkra. eRkayBIkarp¥akGs;

CaeRcInelIk mhasniñ)atmYy)anR)arB§eFIVenAemmt;kñúgextþkMBg;camedIm,IerobcMbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCa

eLIgvij. mhasnñi)at)aneRtómerobcMe)aHeqñateRCIserIsKN³dwknaMfIµmYynigGnum½tkmµviFImYyfIµ

eTAehIy Rsab;EtenAeBléf¶Rtg;éf¶TI7 Exmkra qñaM1979 viTüú)anpSaydMNwgd¾KYr[rMePIbfa ³ Rkúg

PñMeBjRtÚv)anrMedaHehIy¡. bkSEdleTIbbegIátfIµRtÚv)ancat;EcgRbtiPUcUlrYmmhasniñ)atcMnYn66

rUb[TTYlemIlxusRtÚvkic©karepSg²PøamEtmþg47.

enAéf¶TI8 Exmkra BYkemdwknaMrNsirS)anrg;caMkarGnuBaØatrbs;kgT½BevotNam edImI,eFIVdMeNIr

mkkan;TIRkúgPñMeBj enAeBlEdlviTüú)anRbkasCasaFarN³fa bnÞab;BIkarrMedaHrdæFanIeday«kgT½B

bdivtþnigRbCaCnkm<úCa» RkúmRbwkSabdivtþn_mYyEdlmansmaCikR)aMbIrUb)anRtÚvbegIáteLIgeRkamkar

dwknaMrbs; ehg sMrin. GtItembBa¢akarkgBlFMExµrRkhmEdleTIbnwgePosxøÜneTARbeTsevotNam

esÞIrEtmindl;bYnExmunpg )ansßitenAkñúgsßanPaBRtÚvtemáIg[eFVICaemdwknaMRbeTsPøammYyrMeBc.

ehtukarN_mYyepSgeTot maneKalbMNgbgðaj[eXIjfa evotNam)anRbRBwtþhYsBIectna

dMbUg²rbs;xøÜneTAeTotKW karN_EdlRkúghaNUyRbjab;Rbjal;ekNÐRbmUlRkúmGñkeFVIkarsIuvil

evotNam -Gñkbec©keTsnigbuKÁlik- mkekþabkþab;kargarenARbeTskm<úCaEtmþg. eKBi)akeCOfa

enHCakMhusFmµtamYykñúgkarcat;EcgNas;. RkúmPñak;garsm¶at;GaemrikaMg)anBinitüeXIjfa

rfeRkaHrbs;evotNamCaeRcIneRKÓg)anxUcenAtampøÚvCatielx6muneTAdl;kMBg;FM. ExµrRkhmEdl

)ak;T½B)anbMpøajrfeRkaHCaeRcIneRKÓg. eKRtÚveRbIry³eBlmYys)aþh_ edIm,IpÁt;pÁg;ExSrfeRkaH

rbs;evotNam dUcCakarcak;eRbg pþl;RKab;rMesv es,ógGahar edIm,I)aneTAdl;Rkúg)at;dMbg

eTot48.

taMgBIs)aþh_TIbIénExmkra qñaM1979 kgT½Brbs;evotNam)ankan;kab; «ebHdUgCayuT§sa®sþ»

rbs;km<úCa TIRkúgnigpøÚvCatisMxan;²TaMgGs; b:uEnþRtÚvrg;caMrhUtdl;Exemsa qñaM1979 nigkarmkdl;

énT½BCMnYy eTIbevotNamcab;eFIVkare)assm¥atmUldæantasaj; EdlbegáIteLIgedayExµrRkhm

Edlrt;eKcxøÜneTAenAEk,rRBMEdnéf.

NUEGlRkhm 385

Page 396: Brother enemy

taMgBImankarehaHeLIgénynþehaHcugeRkayBIGakasyandæaneBaFicintug enAéf¶TI6 Exmkra

nigkarecjdMeNIrénrfePøIgcugeRkay BIcMNtGysµ½yyanRkúgPñMeBjenARBwkéf¶TI7 ExmkraEdlman

eGog sarI CiHenAelIenaHEdr RBMEdnrbs;éfKWCameFüa)ayEtmYyKt;edIm,IcakecjBIRbeTs. GñkkarTUt

mYyRkúmFMEdlBImunbMeBjmuxgarenAPñMeBjkñúgsßanTUtcin yUehÁasøavI nigRbeTsepSg²eTot nig

TIRbwkSanigGñkbec©keTscinrab;rynak; )anEsVgrkTIBMnak;enARbeTséf. m®nIþmñak;enARksYgkar

breTséf)anniyayfa «sRmab;RbeTscin enHCakarGam:as;muxmYyBMuFøab;manBImunmk». rwtEtmin

EdlesaHeTAeTot KWGñktMNagmñak;én«GaNacRkkNþal¬RbeTscin¦RtÚv)anbgçM[rt;eKcBIRbeTs

mYyEdlsißteRkamGMNacrbs;xøÜnkñúgmUlehtuepSg² EdleFIV[xUckitiþysdUecñHeLIy. BitNas;

BYkéf)aneRtómbRmúgTTYleFIVbdisNæarkic© Gñkrt;eKcxøÜnTaMgenHy:agRbesIrbMput. eK)anseRmckic©

RBmeRBógsm¶at;CaeRcInedayGnuBaØat[ynþehaH bU‘GIug 707 rbs;cincuHctenAGtItmUldæan

GaemrikaMgenAG‘Uta):av edIm,IdwkBYkcinEdlCemøósxøÜnecjBIkm<úCaRtLb;eTARbeTsvij. muneBlenH

minyUrb:unµan Rkúgeb:kaMgFøab;)anbriharriHKn;mUldæanTaMgenHy:agxøaMgkøabMput edayecaTRbkan;fa

CamUldæanCYrmuxsRmab;beRmI«karQøanBanrbs;cRkBtiþGaemrikaMg».

enAéf¶TI11 Exmkra qñaM1979 eGog sarI Edlehvht;esIÞrsøab;nigEdleRskXøan)aneTA

dl;RBMEdnrbs;éf. kñúgsPaBGU‘GrénhVÚgmnusS Kat;)anRCúH)at;Es,keCIgTaMgGs;. GñkkarTUtcin

enARkúg)agkk )annaMykEs,keCIgnigexaGavfIµ²eTA[Kat;enATIenaH. ]T§mÖaKcRkmYyeRKÓgénkg

GakascrN_éf)aneTAdwkykKat;nigshkarITaMgb:unµanrbs;Kat; EdlkñúgenaHmanTaMgGñksarB½t’man

rbs;viTüúRkúgPñMeBjpg mkkan;Gakasyandæan dUn emOg enARkúg)agkky:ags¶at;kM)aMgbMput. BITIenH

BYkeK)anCiHynþehaHmYyrbs;Rkúmh‘unéfGnþrCatisMedAeTARkúghugkug EdlCakEnøgQb;sMctdMbUg

mYymuneTAkan;RbeTscineTot.

ebskmµsm¶at;enAGU‘ta):av

kñúgcMeNamÉksaTaMgLayEdlkgT½BevotNamrwbGUs)anenAmUldæantasaj; eKeXIjman

esckIþcmøgCaeRcInsIþBIkarsnÞnarvag eGog sarI nigBYkemdwknaMcincMnYnbYnQut. enAéf¶TI13 Exmkra

qñaM1979 etg s‘avBIg )ansIþbenÞas sarI cMeBaH«yuT§nakare)assm¥at¬EdlKat;)andwknaM¦fa man

lkçN³RCúlhYsehtubniþc nigmanTMhMFMeFgeBk». Kat;)anniyaynwg sarI edayRtg;²fa kareFVI

visuT§kmµrbs;ExµrRkhmeFIV[mankMhusdl;RbeTscinnigeFIV[man«plGviC¢many:ageRcIn». Kat;)an

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg386

Page 397: Brother enemy

rMB£kfa RbeTscinFøab;)anpþl;KMrUsþIBIrNsirSrYmKñaCamYy«sRtÚvrayrg»rYcehIy CaBiessCamYy

Cag kayecok kñúgry³eBleFIVs®gÁamTl;nwgRbeTsCb:un ehIy)anniyayENnaMy:agxøaMgkøa[ eGog

sarI seRmceFIVtamKMrUsm<½n§PaBenHCamYy semþc sIhnu Edr. «karminseRmccgsm<½n§PaBrvagBYk

eyIgnwgRBHGgÁ KWCabraC½ymYyy:agF¶n;enAeBleRkay. dUecñH ebIdl;kalevlakñúgGnaKtmYyqab;²

enH ´sUmesIñeRtómTukmuxtMENgRbmuxrdæCUnsemþc sIhnu vij. smmitþ b:ul Bt nwgkøayeTACardæ

m®nIþTI1 TTYlxusRtÚvRksYgkarBarRbeTsnigCaGKÁembBa¢akarkMBUl». etg )andak;kic©snüaeday\t

jejItfa ebIsinbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCayl;RBmeFIVtamkarENnaMenH BYkcinnwg«CYyeRCamERCgkm<úCa[

Gs;BIédBIeCIg». Kat;k¾)anTUnµan[ sarI EkERbrebobeXasnarbs;ExµrRkhmpgEdr. «sRmab;eBl

enH elakminRtÚvelIkniyayBIbkSkumµúynIsþeToteT sUmelakbMpusBIkarRsLaj;CatimatuPUmiBIKMnit

Catiniym niglTi§RbCaFibetyüvijRbesIrCag».

etg )anR)ab; sarI [dwgfa Rkúgeb:kaMg)anTukdak;[km<úCaeRbIR)as;nUvfvikamYymanTwkR)ak;

cMnYnR)aMlanduløarGaemrik EdlGacpþl;[eTotkalebIGs;. etg )ansYrfa «etIelakcg;[eyIg

pþl;luytamry³Na? tamRkúg)agkk? tamelak eRKógsak; b¤tamry³FnaKarRbeTséf? sarI

)an[eyabl;edayRbúgRby½tñfa ³ «sUmelaktmál;luyenAsßanTUtcinRbcaMRkúg )agkkRbesIr

Cag»49.

enAéf¶TI13 Exmkra qñaM1979 BIrbIem:ageRkayBI)ancUlrYmkñúgkarCYbKñarvag etg nig sarI

GñkyuT§sa®sþd¾eqñImrbs;cinBIrrUbKW ecg )a‘v CasmaCikkariyal½yneya)ay nigGnurdæm®nIþkarbreTs

han nanLúg )aneLIgCiHynþehaHmYyeRKÓgrbs;Rkúmh‘unGakascrN_Cati edIm,IbMeBjebskkmµ

sm¶at;mYy. eCIgehaHehIrEdlCYledayRbjab;Rbjal;sRmab; ecg nig han RBmTaMgGñkTTYlxus

RtÚvCan;x<s;CaeRcInrUbeTotrbs;esnaFikarkgT½BRbCaCn)antRmg;mkkan; GU‘ta ):av. naykrdæm®nIþ

eRKógsak; )aneFIVdMeNIrtamynþehaHeTAmUldæanGakascrN_enaHedIm,ITTYlsVaKmn_KN³RbtiPUcin.

enAéf¶TI14 Exmkra BYkeK)anBiPakSaKñaeBjmYyéf¶. eK)anBiPakSaKñaBITRmg;EbbbTepSg²sIþBI

shRbtibtiþkarcin-éfkñúgs®gÁamenARbeTskm<úCa. Kat;)anhucéd[edaysm¶at;taMgBIeBlEdl

etg elIkeLIgBIyfaPaBénshRbtibtþikarmYyedIm,IKaMRTExµrRkhm. edayminlHbg;GBüaRkwtPaB

rbs;xøÜn eBlenH eRKógsak; )ancat;EcgseRmceFVIsm<½n§PaBmYyCamYyRkúgeb:kaMgehIy. CaeRcIn

qñaMeRkaymk GñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;mñak;rbs;éf )anniyayR)ab;´edays¶at;kM)aMgfa KWkñúg»kas

énsm½yRbCMusm¶at;enHehIyEdlekItmankarseRmccitþeFIVshRbtibtiþkarmYyrvagRbeTscinnig

NUEGlRkhm 387

Page 398: Brother enemy

RbeTséf 50. enAeRkayeBlCYbsnÞnaKñaenH BYkemdwknaMcin)aneLIgynþehaHRtLb;eTARkúgeb:kaMg

vijCamYy s‘un hav ÉkGKÁrdæTUtcinEdlCemøósxøÜnecjBIRkúgPñMeBj ehIyenAkñúgkarbUbrbs;BYkeK

KWkic©RBmeRBógmYyEdlmansarsMxan;CaTIbMput. eRKógsak; )anGnuBaØat[cineRbIR)as;TwkdIrbs;éf

edIm,IpÁt;pÁg;eRKÓgsmÖarcaM)ac; niges,ógdl;ExµrRkhm. Kat;)anyl;RBmpþl;nUvmeFüa)ayepSg²

kñúgkardwkCBa¢ÚnnigkarsRmÜldl;dMeNIrqøgkat;rbs;buKÁlikeyaFa nigsmÖarbrikçarrbs;km<úCa ehIy

k¾)anRBmeRBógCYysRmÜlnUvkareFIVdMeNIreTAbreTsrbs;BYkemdwknaMExµrRkhm eday[qøgkat;

tamRbeTséfpgEdr51. enHKWCacMNuccab;epþIménkareFIVshRbtibtþikarCayuT§sa®sþd¾mansar

sMxan;bMput EdlRbeTscin)anBRgIkenAGasIuGaeKñy_taMgBIs®gÁamevotNamcb;eTA.

navarbs;cinBIreRKÓgEdleFVIdMeNIreq<aHmkRbeTskm<úCaCamYysmÖarswkrbs;xøÜn cMeBlEdl

mankardYlrlMénRkúgPñMeBj )anTTYlbBa¢a[Qb;sMctenAkMBg;EpmYyrbs;éfEk,rRBMEdnsmuRTrbs;

km<úCa. karcat;EcgpÁt;pÁg;CabnÞan;mYyRtÚv)aneFIVeLIgCasm¶at;edayynþehaHrbs;cinCaeRcIneRKÓg

rhUtdl;GtItmUldæanT½BGakasrbs;GaemrikaMgenA taXøI.

enAéf¶TI16 Exmkra qñaM1979 KWbIéf¶bnÞab;BIkarCYbKñaCasm¶at;rvagcin-éf viTüúrbs;km<úCa

RbCaFibetyü Edls¶at;ElgB¤taMgBIéf¶7 Exmkra )ancab;epIþmeFIVkarpSayrbs;xøÜneLIgvij. Gñk

niyayviTüúBImun )ancab;epþImvayRbharRbqaMgBYkQøanBanevotNam\tQb;QrdUcsBVmYydg.

b:uEnþ BYkPñak;garsm¶at;rbs;GaemrikaMg)ansmÁal;eXIjnUvPaBxusKñaEdlKYr[cab;GarmµN_mYy ³

elIkenHb:us×þpSayKWsißtenARbeTscinvij.

bNþalmUldæansRmab;KaMRTkardwknaM nigbBa¢ÚneRKÓgRbdab;RbdaeyaFaeTA[clnaT½BéRBEdl

RbqaMgevotNamKWtaMgenARbeTséf. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH RbeTscin)ancat;EcgeFIVkarcl½tkgT½B

rfeRkaHnigynþehaHy:agsem,ImmYyeTAkan;RBMEdnrbs;evotNam dUcEdl etg Føab;RBly[dwgkñúg

»kaséndMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;Kat;enARkúg)agkkkalBIBIrExmunEdr. kñúg»kasénTsSnkic©rbs;Kat;

enATIRkúg)agkk ecg )a‘v )anxMRbwgeFIV[ eRKógsak; )at;P½yRBÜyBIplvi)akepSg²EdlGacekIt

ecjBIsm<½n§PaBfIµrbs;Kat;CamYyExµrRkhm edayelIkykmkniyayBIkardak;TNÐkmµRbeTs

evotNamenAeBlxagmuxpg. Kat;)anniyayR)ab;emdwknaMéffa «enHBMuEmnCaeKaledAsmøútbMP½y

EtmYymuxeT EdlRbeTscinbBa¢ÚnkgT½BeTAkan; K½gtug nig yun Nan ³ eyIg)anRbúgeRbóbTb;Tl;

nwgRbtikmµEdlGacekItmanTaMgGs;»52.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg388

Page 399: Brother enemy

Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI TTYl)anGtßRbeyaCn_fµImYy

bnÞab;BIkareFIV[manRbRktIPaBEpñkkarTUtCamYyshrdæGaemrik nigkarbn§ÚrcMNgepSg²rvag

étv:an;nigRkúgv:asIunetan RbeTscinGacepÞrkgBlFMTaMgb:unµanrbs;xøÜnEdlsißtenAtamextþCab;eqñr

smuRTTl;muxnwgRbeTsétv:an;mkkan;RBMEdnsUevotnigevotNamvij. enAcugExmkra qñaM1979

kgT½BerobrycMnYndb;R)aMBIrkgBlFMEdlmancMnYnRbmaN225>000nak;RtÚv)andak;RbmUlpþúMenA

tamRBMEdnrbs;evotNam. ynþehaHRbedjTmøak;RKab;EbkCag700eRKÓg RtÚvCamYyPaKR)aMén

kgGakascrN_rbs;cin maneKeXIjsMctenAtamcMNtynþehaHnanaEk,rRBMEdnevotNamEdr.

RkúmesIubkarN_sm¶at;rbs;shrdæGaemrik)an[sBaØaGasnñCafIµsIþBIkarRbmUlpþM úT½Brbs;cinkñúg

GnusSrN³mYycuHéf¶TI19 Exmkra qñaM1979 nigTuksRmab;CRmabGñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;rbs;

GaemrikaMg[)andwgBIerOgenH. enAkñúgcMeNamGñkTaMgenaH CaBiessGñkenAkñúgRksYgkarbreTs

manGñkxøHRBÜy)armÖBIkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbTaMgenHEdlvaCaRbpñÚlfac,as;CamankarvayRbharmYy

R)akdNas;enAmundMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs; etg enAshrdæGaemrik. m®nIþmñak;)anniyayCasm¶at;R)ab;

elak dunGUbWd½rhVW CaGñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manEpñkkarTUtrbs;kaEstv:asIunetanb:us×þfa «eyIgBMudwgnUvGIVEdl

[etg] eRbI])ayklsm¶at;eLIy». Kat;RbEhlnaMBYkeyIg[Cab;édkñúgkarvayRbharrbs;Kat;pgk¾

mindwg b¤y:agehack¾TTYl)ankarsmKMnitEtsm,keRkAmYyEdr»53. rIqad hUlRb‘Úk Gnurdæm®nIþkar

breTsGaemrikTTYlbnÞúkkic©karGasIuxagekItnig):asIuhiVk )anekaHGeB¢aIjÉkGKÁrdæTUtcincMnYnBIrelIk

kñúgs)þah_munkarmkdl;rbs; etg edIm,IR)ab;Kat;[dwgmunfa karvayRbharmYyRbqaMgRbeTs

evotNamkñúgry³eBléndMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs; etg nwgeFIV[shrdæGaemrikeTIsTal;kñúgcitþy:ag

sem,Im»54.

RbsinebIBYkcinbgðajxøÜneLIgCaGñkcUlcitþykGasaeK KWBMuEmntamry³esckþIrab;GancMeBaH

Rkúgv:asIunetanenaHeT b:uEnþBIeRBaHkarvayRbharenH)anRtÚverobcMkmµviFIsRmab;kalbriecäTmYy enA

eBlxagmuxeTot. m®nIþpøÚvkarcinmñak;)anlatRtdagGaf’kM)aMgR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦ enAExmIna qñaM1979

fa «enAeBlEdlGnuRbFanbkSkumµúynIsþcin etg s‘avBIg ecjdMeNIreq<aHeTARkúgv:asIunetan eyIg

)ankMNt;éf¶ExeFIVkarvayRbharrYceRsceTAehIy. Kat;BMuEmneTAshrdæGaemrikedIm,ITTYl)ankar

yl;RBmBIBYkGaemrikaMgeT b:uEnþ karKaMRTxagpøÚvcitþcMeBaHKat;Etb:uNÑwgKWRKb;RKan;Nas;eTAehIy.

BYkcin)anTTYleRcInelIsBIhñwgeTAeTot ehIy)ancab;epIþmeFIVs®gÁamRbqaMgevotNam edayman

kar[édCasm¶at;BIshrdæGaemrikpg». dMeNIrERbRtLb;mkvijnUverOgr:avepSg²EdlKYr[Gs;

NUEGlRkhm 389

Page 400: Brother enemy

sMeNIcminsUvmanGñkNakt;smÁal;eT ³ xMRbwgTb;«lTi§vatTIniymrbs;cin» KWCamUlehtucm,g mYy

kñúgcMeNammUlehtucm,g²énkareFIVGnþraKmn_rbs;GaemrikaMgenARbeTsevotNam. nimitþsBaØarbs;

TIbBa¢akarpþl;CMnYyeyaFaenARbeTsevotNam¬GkSrkat;M.C.A.V¦ KWrUbdavmYyrbs;GaemrikaMg

kMBugcak;TmøúHmhakMEBgEdlCanimitþrUbRbeTscinBImçageTAmçag.

etg )anRbkasedayc,as;las;BIeKaledAepSg² éndMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;Kat;elIkenH.

Kat;mkedIm,IEsVgrkkarKaMRT nigkareyaKyl;rbs;BYkGaemrikaMgcMeBaHEpnkarcUllukluyRbeTs

evotNamrbs;Kat;. Kat;RtÚvEtpþl;karRBmanmYycMeBaHRkúghaNUy nigRkúgmUsÁÚRBmTaMgeFIV[BYk

EdlminRBmeCOGIVTaMgGs;kñúgbkSkumµúynIsþcinekatEsJgpgEdr. enAl¶acénéf¶eTAdl;Rkúgv:asIunetan

rbs;Kat;KWéf¶TI28 Exmkra Kat;)anniyaynwg Rb‘IhSInsIÁ faKat;manbMNgeFVIkarCYbKñattY¬EtBIrnak;¦

mYy CamYyRbFanaFibtI xaF½r edIm,IBiPakSaKñaBIbBaðaRbeTsevotNam. enAéf¶bnÞab; eBlcab;epþIm

ebIkkic©crcaenAestviman Kat;)anrMB£kR)ab;RbFanaFibtIGaemrikaMgfa «shrdæGaemriknigRbeTscin

Føab;)ansÁal;ry³kalénkarRbQmmuxd¾yUr nigd¾lM)akCamYyevotNam». enAeBlyb;KW eBlerobcM

xøÜnedIm,ITTYlTanGahareBll¶ac etg )anesIñelak xaF½r edayTTUc[mankarCYbKñaCaKN³kmµaFikar

tUcmYy edIm,IBiPakSaGMBIbBaðaGaf’kM)aMgepSg². xaF½r )andkxøÜncUleTAkan;kariyal½yragBgRkeBI

CamYyelak m:unedl/ v:an;s_ rdæm®nIþRksYgkarbreTs/ har:Ul eR)an nig Rb‘IhSInsIÁ edIm,Isþab; etg

raykarN_BIEpnkarvayRbharRbeTsevotNamrbs;Kat;. edaybeB©ajEpSg)arIm:akb:g;daBImat;

etg )anRbkasedayKµanRBwmfa RbeTscinmankatBVkic©eFIV[søak;dMeNIrkarKn;KUr EpñkyuT§sa®sþ

rbs;shPaBsUevot. «vaCakarcaM)ac;Nas;EdleyIgRtÚvxMRbwgTb;bg¥n;mhicätahYsRbmaNrbs;

evotNamnigpþl;emerontUcmYyEdlBYkeKsmnwgTTYl». Kat;)anFanaGHGagfa karvayRbharnwg

eFIVeLIgkñúgTMhMtUclµmnigmankMNt;. GIVEdlKat;RtÚvkarKW «karKaMRTxagpøÚvcitþ» rbs;shrdæGaemrikelI

qakGnþrCatib:ueNÑaH55.

edayesIñ[shrdæGaemrikseRmceFIVsm<½n§PaBmYyRbqaMgnwgRkúgmUsÁÚ nigsMu[KaMRTdl;karepþIm

KeRmagkarrbs;Kat;Tl;nwgevotNam etg )anqøgputdMNak;kalfIµmYyénCemøaHrvag v:an;s_ Rb‘IhSInsÁI.

mYyéf¶mundMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;etg v:an;s_ )anRbkasfa neya)ayrbs;shrdæGaemrikcMeBaHRkúg

mUsÁÚ nigRkúgeb:kaMg«nwgenAEtél[esIµKñaehIynwgmin[ep¥ógeTAmçag²eLIy»56.

RksYgkarbreTs)aneFIVGIV²RKb;y:agedIm,IeCosvagkarecjpSayesckIþEføgkarN_pøÚvkarmYy

edaymincg;[eKfa Gaemrik)anP¢ab;karRBmanrbs;xøÜneTAnwgkarRBmanrbs;RbeTscin edIm,IRbqaMg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg390

Page 401: Brother enemy

«GnutþrPaBniym»eLIy. b:uEnþCafIµmþgeTot Rb‘IhSInsÁI )anTTYlC½yCmñHelI v:an;s_. xaF½r BMuykcitþ

Tukdak;nwgkarpþl;eyabl;rbs;rdæm®nIþkarbreTsKat;eLIy. RtÚvCMrujeday Rb‘IhSInsIÁ xaF½r )an

seRmclubecalvaküx½NÐmYykñúgesckIþEføgkarN_rYm EdlmankñúgesckIþEføgkarN_cin-GaemrikaMg

elIkmunBIr. kñúgkar)armÖeFIV[mansmtaxagneya)aymYy Kat;)anbBa¢ak;edayELkkñúgerOgenHfa

TMnak;TMngepSg²rvagshrdæGaemriknigRbeTscinBMuEmn «sMedARbqaMgnwgrdædéT²eToteLIy». mun

karCYbKñarvag etg nig xaF½r Rb‘IhSInsIÁ )anl,gsRmÜlkarExVgeyabl;KñaEdlGacmanrbs;RbFana

FibtICamYynwgKeRmagdak;TNÐkmµcinEdr. «´P½yxøacfa v:an;s_ )anbB©úaHbBa©ÚlRbFanaFibtI[eFIVkar

Kabsgát;eTAelIBYkcinedIm,IkMu[BYkeKeRbIkmøaMg)ay. bBaðaenH )anRtwmEtjúaMg[BYkcineCOfa sh

rdæGaemrikCa«xøaRkdas»mYyb:ueNÑaH»57. b:uEnþ enHBMuEmnCabBaðaRtÚvniyaybgðajBIsmtßPaBeFVIGVI

)anEtb:uNÑwgeT. Rb‘IhSInsIÁ )anniyayedayxøÜnÉgR)ab;elakRbFanaFibtIfa edaysarmitþPkþixøH

kñúgcMeNammitþPkþirbs;Kat;dUcelakCaedIm)an«cUlLÚkLM y:ageRCAkñúgkarBiPakSaepSg² Edlmanmun

karseRmccitþpþl;«emeron»mYydl;RbeTsevotNamrbs;cin>>>Kat;k¾vaytémønUvGVIEdl[cMeNj

pgEdr»58.

cMeBaHeyIgCacin>>>

ebIvinicä½ytamkardMNalrbs; xaF½r nig Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI emdwknaMmaDl¥itrbs;cinEdlBi)akniyay

Kña[sþab;)an )aneFVI[eKPJak;ep¥IlCaxøaMg. ecjmkBIRbeTssRtÚvmYyminCayUrb:unµan Kat;)an

niyayedayGMNacedIm,IRKb;RKg«karpþl;emeron»epSg²59. tamsMGagrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI fa esckþI

raykarN_edayelak etg GMBIKeRmagkarvayRbharRbeTsevotNamrbs;Kat; KWCa«karbgðaj

neya)ayeRbIkmøaMgsrubEtmñak;Égnigd¾sem,ImGs©arü» EdlKat;minEdldwgminEdlB¤esaHkñúgGMLúg

bYnqñaMEdlKat;enAestviman. Kat;)anGHGagfa «´b:gCasm¶at;fa rebobEdl etg maneyabl;BIkar

BwgEp¥kelIkareRbIkmøaMg Gacman\T§iBleTAelIbNþaGñkTTYlxusRtÚvGaemrikaMgxøHEdlkMBugkan;kab;mux

tMENgsMxan;²»60. edayminPan;RcLM eKGacbBa¢ak;fa Kat;manbMNgniyaysMedAelak v:an;s_

CaBiess. v:an;s_ EdlmineBjcitþnwgerOgminyl;RBmBwgEp¥k«karpþl;emeron» k¾P½yxøacERkgfa kar

TTYlsVaKmn_EdleRtómbRmúgsRmab; etg edayestvimanGacCMruj[RkúgmUsÁÚsnñidæanfa vaman

karRBmeRBógKñaCasm¶at;mYy ¬edIm,IbMpøajnrNamñak;¦rvagRbeTscinnigshrdæGaemrikpgEdr61.

xaF½r BuMykcitþTukdak;BIerOgenHeLIy. Kat;eCOfa v:an;s_ «hak;dUcCacg;sEmþgkaresaksþayrbs;

NUEGlRkhm 391

Page 402: Brother enemy

xøÜn» cMeBaHTMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMg62.

niyaymü:ageTot etg )anTTYlGVI²EdlKat;RtÚvkaresÞIrEtTaMgGs;. Kat;)anefáaleTas

shPaBsUevotCasaFarN³ EdlecaT[manbBaðaeLIgvijBIkic©RBmeRBógkRmitGavuFyuT§sa®sþTI2

EdlshrdæGaemrik)anerobcMedayGMNt;bMputCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ nig)anbnøWBaküKMramkMEhgepSg²

RbqaMgRbeTsevotNampg edayKat;eBalBaküTaMgenHenAcMeBaHmuxRbFanaFibtI xaF½r mñak;Edl

RtÚveFVI[RsLaMgkaMgEdlkñúgnamKat;Cam©as;pÞHmankarKYrsm Kat;KµanniyayGVITaMgGs;eTaHCaniyay

RbqaMg b¤xøÜndkxøÜnBICMhrepSg²rbs;cink¾eday. enAéf¶TI29 Exmkra kñúg»kasénkarCYbCamYy

KN³kmµaFikartUcrbs;Kat;CamYyGnuRbFanaFibtIcin xaF½r )ansakl,gbBa©úHbBa©ÚlKat;TaMgxøaccitþ

b:uEnþ eTaHCay:agNak¾eday k¾Kat;min[eyabl;fa KeRmagkarepSg²rbs;cinGaceFVI[Gnþraydl;

TMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMgeLIy. TLðIkrN_rbs; xaF½r KWfa evotNamkMBugsßitenAkñúgsßanPaBkan;Et

ÉekaeLIg²enAkñúgBiPBelak edaysarEtkarkan;kab;RbeTskm<úCa ehIyebIcinvayRbharBYkevot

NamenaHmuxCanwgeFVI[keRmIkeLIgnUvsmancitþepSg²CaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;evotNamminxan. kar

ebþCJacitþdak;TNÐkmµRbeTsevotNamrbs; etg enAEtrwgmaMKµanregÁaHregÁI ehIy xaF½r GacRtwmEtesñI

eFVIkarCYbKñaCafµImYyb:ueNÑaH. karCYbKñaCafµI)anRbRBwtþeTAenARBwkéf¶bnÞab;kñúgkariyal½yBgRkeBI

¬énestviman¦ enAcMeBaHmuxGñkbkERbPasaEtmñak;Kt;. enAeBlenaH elak xaF½r )aneRbIviFImYy

xusEbøkBIFmµta. Kat;)anGanedaysMeLgxøaMg²nUvlixitsresrédmYy EdlsegçbTLðIkrN_epSg²

rbs;Kat;RbqaMgnwgkarlukluymYyenARbeTsevotNammunnwgRbKl;CUnePJóvrbs;Kat;. eKGHGagfa

eKaledArbs;Kat; KWkarsEmþg[eXIjkarRbqaMgCapøÚvkarrbs;Kat; edayR)afñaGs;BIeBaHBIBugfa etg

minykcitþTukdak;nwgerOgenHeLIy. xaF½r )anGHGagfa «´manGarmµN_fa karseRmccitþRtÚv)an

Rbkan;ykeRsceTAehIy. RbeTsevotNamnwgRtÚvdak;TNÐkmµ»63.

xøwmsarxagkñúglixitenAEtCaGaf’kM)aMgdEdl. Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anEføgeRkaymkeTotfa KMnitpþÜc

epþImrbs; xaF½r KWCaerOgEtmYyKt;EdlRtÚvniyay ehIyKat;nwgbEnßmRbkbedayPaBesµaHRtg;Kµan

lak;elomEdleFVI[Tas;KMnitfa «eyIgBuMGaceFVIsm<½n§PaBtampøÚvkarCamYynwgBYkcin nig]btßmÖKaMBar

cMeBaHGVIEdlRKan;EtCakarQøanBanedaykmøaMgT½B EdlKitTukCamuneRsc)aneLIy. kñúgeBlCamYy

KñaenaH karsnüaBuM)anpÞj;pÞal;eyIg[RtÚvEtefáaleTasRbeTscinenAGgÁkarshRbCaCatienAeBl

eRkayeLIy».

edayP½yxøacfa BYkcinRbkan;ykkarGHGagTaMgenHEmnETn Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anRbkasR)ab;rdæm®nþI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg392

Page 403: Brother enemy

karbreTscin hYghY kñúgGMLúgénkarsnÞnaCaÉkCnmYyenAéf¶dEdlfa mUlehtuénkarRBÜy)armÖBit

R)akdEtmYyKt;rbs;GaemrikaMg KWRbtikmµCayfaehturbs;BYksUevot. Kat;)ansakl,g «elIkTwk

citþBYkcin[kMNt;eBlevlaeFVIkarvaylukqab;rh½smYy CaCagRbLÚkkñúgCemøaHyUrGEgVgmYy»/ enH

CaBaküEdl etg )ansnüanwg xaF½r taMgBIeBlenaHemø:H. Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )ansresrkñúgkRmgGnusSav

rIy_rbs;Kat;fa «edIm,ICasBaØamitþPaB ´)aneTAkan;dMbUlrabsRmab;karehaHehIrén]T§mÖaKcRkenA

Ek,rvimanRkúgv:asuInetanedIm,ICRmabla etg. ´manbMNgeFVI[Kat;dwgfa Kat;TTYl)ankarKaMRTrbs;

estviman/ ´eCOfa Kat;sb,aycitþy:agxøaMgnwgerOgenH». ebIsinCa xaF½r ykcitþTukdak;bBa©úHbBa©Úl

RbeTscin[vayRbharRbeTsevotNamEmn kayvikarCanimitþrUbrbs; Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI minsUveRCamERCg

Kat;¬xaF½r¦kñúgerOgenaHb:unµaneT. tamkarBit xaF½r EdlRtÚveFVI[RcbUkRcbl;citþrvagsnþiniym ¬kar

edaHRsayGFikrN_edaysnþiviFI¦tamEbbRKisþsasnarbs;Kat; nigPaBcaM)ac;eFVIxøÜnCaRbFanaFibtI

xøaMgmñak;hak;dUcCaeRCIsykpøÚvén PaBgayRsYlCag ³ karRbqaMgCMTas;EdlRKan;EtmanTRmg;eRkA

mYy nigkars‘umRKluMrebobjak;EPñkdak;KñamYy. enAeBlEdlkarlukluyrbs;cinEdleKrg;caMyUr

mkehIy)ancab;epþIm16éf¶ eRkaymk Rkúgv:asuInetan)anxitxMeFVIy:agNa[Rkúgeb:kaMgrYcputBIkar

sgswkrbs;sUevot edayCMruj[RkúgmUsÁÚRbkan;neya)ayniymkNþalmYy. karcuHhtßelxaelI

kic©RBmeRBógkMNt;GavuFyuT§sa®sþTI2 EdlTak;TajkarykcitþTukdak;rbs;BYkGaemrikaMg KWEp¥kelI

kardwknaMl¥rbs;shPaBsUevot64.

ebIelak xaF½r nig Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI eFVIhak;dUcCaminsUvRbqaMgnwgkarvayRbharRbeTsevotNam

edayRbeTscink¾eday k¾bNþasmaCikd¾eqñImxøHénsPaCan;Tab)anKaMRT etg edayecjmuxEtmþg.

RbFansPa TIb GUenol (Tip O'Neill) )aneFVIkarsnÞnamYyCamYyGnuRbFanaFibtIcinenAvimankaBItUl

ehIyKat;)anRbkasR)ab;elakGnuRbFanaFibtIcinfa ebIBuMmanGVIbBaÄb;KMnitpSgeRBgniymrbs;

evotNameT eKmuxCaRbTHeRKaHfñak;éns®gÁamelakelIkTIbImYyminxan ³ enAeBlEdlkgT½BCb:un

kan;kab;EdndIm:an;CUrI enAqñaM1931 KµannrNamñak;eFVIGnþraKmn_eT ehIyBiPBelakkMBugsßitenAkñúg

s®gÁamelakeBjTMhwg. edayPJak;ep¥IlbnþicbnþÜcBIkarxitcUlCitKñaEdlminsmRsbtamkal³eTs³

etg )aneqøIytbnwg GUenol fa eTaHCakrNIRbeTsevotNamBuMEmndUcsuT§saFnwgkrNIdéTk¾eday

k¾Kat;caM)ac;RtÚvEt«pþl;emeronmYy»65[evotNamEdr.

enAeRkayeBlcb;karsnÞnarbs;Kat;CamYyrdæaPi)alnigBYkemdwknaMsPaCan;Tab etg )an

erobcMeFVIsnñisITkaEstmYyenATIRkúgv:asuInetan EdlKat;)anRbkasfa ³ «sRmab;eyIg eyIgyl;fa

NUEGlRkhm 393

Page 404: Brother enemy

evotNamCaBYkKuy)aenAbUBa’. ebIsinCaeKminpþl;emeron[eT karbgáehtunwgmanrwtEtxøaMg>>>. ´

GacbBa¢ak;R)ab;Gs;elaknUverOgBIr ³ cMeBaHeyIgCacin eyIgKitnUvGVIEdl eyIgniyayehIymineFVI

edayKµanBicarNaeT»66.

c,ab;k,Ünéns®gÁam

etg manlkçN³CamnusSRceLatKµandwgxusRtÚv b:uEnþesµaHRtg;. kareFIV[manRbRktIPaBTaMg

Rbjab;Rbjal;CamYyRkúgv:asIunetan karCYbsnÞnaCaÉkCn nigesckIþEføgkarN_CasaFarN³ suT§Et

)anRtiHriHedayp©itp©g;kñúgEpnkarvayRbharRbeTsevotNamtamKMnitrbs;Kat;. edaypÞúynwg

KeRmagkarrbs;evotNamEdlEsVgrklT§plBIkarPJak;ep¥Il edaybdiesFnUvbMNgT®nÞancUlRbeTs

km<úCaenaH yuT§sa®sþrbs;BYkcineRcInBwgEp¥keTAelIkarRbqaMgnwgkarbriharepSg²Cag. edayyk

citþTukdak;pþl;B½t’mandl;GñkEdlQWq¥alGMBIbMNgepSg²rbs;xøÜn Rkúgeb:kaMgR)afñabegáItbriyakas

eyaKyl;KñamYy EfmTaMgkarRsuHcitþKMnitKñamYypgCMuvij«s®gÁamtamk,Ünc,ab;»rbs;xøÜn. eBl

RtLb;mkBIshrdæGaemrikvij etg )anQb;sMctmYyry³xøIenARkúgtUküÚ edIm,IraykarN_R)ab;BYk

emdwknaMCb:unBIeKaledAFM² énEpnkarvayRbharRbeTsevotNamrbs;Kat;. Kat;)anbEnßmfa Kat;

)anR)ab;dMNwgenHdl;RbFanaFibtI xaF½r rYcehIy67. karlatRtdagenH nigkarminmanRbtikmµ

CapøÚvkarrbs;Rkúgv:asIunetan )aneFVI[Cb:unsißtenAkñúgPaBmniÞlsgS½yrbs;xøÜnCanic© ³ BitCamankar

RBmeRBógKñasm¶at;rvagcin-GaemrikaMgCak;CaR)akd. KeRmagkarrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgminsUveFIV[BYk

Cb:unrIkrayb:unµaneT b:uEnþedaysareKarBcMeBaHshrdæGaemrik BYkCb:unRKan;EtsEmþgnUvkarminyl;

Rsbrbs;eKedayeRbIBaküsmþIfwøgEføgCaTIbMputb:ueNÑaH68.

enAéf¶TI9 ExkumÖ³ KWmYyéf¶bnÞab;BIkarvilRtLb;mkvijrbs;Kat; KN³kmµkareyaFarbs;KN³

kmµaFikarmCÄimbkSkumµúynIsþcin )anebIksm½yRbCMumYykñúgry³eBlbIéf¶eRkamGFibtIPaBrbs; etg

s‘avBIg edIm,IRbkan;ykkarseRmccitþCasßaBrmYy. etg )anraykarN_R)ab;KN³kmµkarBIkarTTYl

sVaKmn_edayrak;Tak; EdleRtómbRmúgsRmab;Kat;enAbNþaRbeTselakxaglicnigsmaKmGas‘an.

enAsl;EtbBaðaRtÚvBinitüemIledayl¥itl¥n;GMBIRbtikmµepSg²EdlGacekItmanBIshPaBsUevot

b:ueNÑaH. tameyabl;rbs;Kat;fa erOgenHmankrNIBiessbI ³ b¤mYyBYksUevot RKan;EteFIVkarefáal

eTastamBaküsmIþmYyEtb:uNÑwg b¤mYyBYkeKeRbIkarqµk;cUlvayRbharrebobdak;TNÐkmµedayman

kRmitmYyBImçageToténRBMEdn b¤mYyBYkeKerobcMeFVIkarlukluymYykñúgRTg;RTayFM. tamKat;sµan

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg394

Page 405: Brother enemy

yfaPaBTIbIKWKµansgÇwmfa nwgmaneT. Kat;lem¥ógeTArkyfaPaBTImYyCag. cMENkyfaPaBTIBIrKW

RbeTscinnwgeRtómeFIVkarRbQmmuxnwgerOgenHrYcehIy69.

karEdl etg eCOCak;GMBIkarKµanRbtikmµrbs;sUevot KWedaysarEtsni§sBaØakRmitGavuF

yuT§sa®sþTIBIr EdlKat;efáaleTasedayCak;lak;. Kat;snñidæanfa RkúgmUsÁÚ)anRtÚveFIV[xVl;KMnit

EmnETn edaysarsni§sBaØakRmitGavuFyuT§sa®sþedIm,IRbLÚkkñúgCemøaHmYy. Kat;sgÇwmEdrfa

shrdæGaemriknwgKabsgát;eTAelIBYksUevot edIm,IkMu[BYkeKeFIV[Gnþraydl;sni§sBaØakñúgkarseRmc

citþeFIVskmµPaBeyaFamYyRbqaMgnwgRbeTscin. etg Føab;niyayR)ab;BYkGaemrikaMg nigBYkCb:unfa

karvaylukrbs;xøÜnmanlkçN³kRmitkMNt;mYy nigmanry³eBlminelIsBIémÖéf¶eLIy. tamemIl

eTAKat;RbEhlsgÇwmfa sarenHnwgeTAdl;vimanRkwmLaMgEdrehIyemIleTA70.

b:uEnþ Rkúgeb:kaMgminTukcitþelIBYkCb:unnigBYkGaemrikaMg edIm,I[CYybBa¢ÚndMNwgenHeLIy. enA

éf¶TI12 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979 yuvGñkkarTUt)araMgmñak;EdlmanmuxtMENgenARkúgm:anIlRbeTsh‘IVlIBIn

mankaregOgq¶l;Edl)anTTYlkarehAtamTUrs½BÞmYyBI s‘avéhV (Xiao Fei) CasmPaKIcinmñak;EdlKat;

Føab;CYbenAkñúgBiFIbdisNæarkic©epSg² ehIyEdlmanbMNgCYbKat;CabnÞan;. Kat;)anRbkasy:ag

»LarikfaRbeTscin)anRTaMGt;Fµt;dl;TIbMput ehIy)aneRtómxøÜndak;TNÐkmµRbeTsevotNamCa

eRsc. Kat;)anGHGagfa ³ «dUckarvayRbharkñúgbMNgdak;TNÐkmµRbqaMgnwg\NÐakalBIqñaM1962

Edr enHCaRbtibtiþkarmankMNt;mYy». GñkkarTUt)araMg)ansYrfa ³ etIRkúgmUsÁÚnwgeFIVy:agem:c?.

s‘av )aneqøIytbedayKµanrYjrafa «BYksUevot)anpþl;nUvkarFanaGHGagfa sUevotnwgmincUleFIV

GnþraKmn_eLIy». dUecñHs®gÁammYyc,as;Camkdl;kñúgeBlqab;². GñkkarTUt)araMgEdlRtÚveFIV[

T½lKMnitedaysarkarlatRtdagxusBIFmµtaenH )anRbjab;Rbjal;epJIsarTUrelxmYyeTARksYg

karbreTsPøam. GaRs½yedaydMeNIrrGak;rGYlEpñkkariyaFibetyü lixitTUrelxrbs;Kat;cuH

éf¶TI12 ExkumÖ³ EdlR)ab;dMNwgBIkarlukluyrbs;cinBMuRtÚv)aneKvayecjeTAeT b:uEnþ)aneTAdl;tam

hibGñkkarTUteTAvij. TUrelxenH)aneTAdl;TIRkúg):arIs bnÞab;BImankarcab;epþImpþl;«emeron»BIréf¶

eTAehIy71.

dUecñH Rkúg):arIsBMumaneBlRKb;RKan;pþl;B½t’man[RkúghaNUydwg TaMgBMumaneBlsÞabsÞg;

eyabl;RkúgmUsÁÚsIþGMBIPaBRtwmRtÚvtamkarBiténTLðIkrN_epSg²rbs;BYkcinEdr. b:uEnþ eKGacbBa¢ak;

edayminxøacP½nþRcLMfa RkúgmUsÁÚ)anTTYlnUvkarFanaGHGagGMBIlkçN³mankMNt;énkareFIVRbtibtiþ

enHrYcehIy muneBlEdlkaMePøIgFMrbs;cinrab;ryedImcab;)aj;pþk;eRsacdUcePøógenARBwkéf¶TI17

NUEGlRkhm 395

Page 406: Brother enemy

ExkumÖ³ EdleFVI[manmhnþrayy:agsem,ImenAtambeNþayRBMEdnrbs;evotNam.

enAevlaRBwkéf¶TI16 ExkumÖ³ ¬em:agenATIRkúgv:asIunetan¦ R)aMmYyem:agKt;munebIkyuT§nakar

vayRbhar cay ehSmin (Chai Zemin) ÉkGKÁrdæTUtRbeTscinRbcaMshrdæGaemrik)annaMsarlixit

mYyeTAkan;estviman EdlRbkas[dwgBIkarcab;epþIm«viFankarkarBarxøÜn»RbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNam.

Rkúgeb:kaMg)aneRCIserIsem:ageBlrbs;xøÜnl¥Nas;. rdæm®nIþkarbreTsrbs;\NÐa Gatal; b‘IharI

v:as;):ayI )ansißtenARbeTscin TukNaCaTMnak;TMngepSg²rvagcin-\NÐaRtÚveFVI[kksÞHkñúgry³eBl

db;R)aMBIrqñaM bnÞab;BIs®gÁamenAqñaM1962k¾eday. KµannrNamñak; ehIyR)akdCaminEmnevotNam

eT GacKiteTAelIGIVEdlRkúgeb:kaMgRbfuyRbfaneFIV[Gnþraydl;PaBFUrRsalEdleTIbnwgekItman

fIµ²enH edayepþImeFVIkarvayRbharRbqaMgnwgRbeTsCamitþmYyrbs;\NÐa cMeBlevlad¾Cak;lak;enH

Nas;. tamBitRkúghaNUymansgÇwmy:agxøaMgfa enAéf¶TI16 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979 enaHnaykrdæm®nIþ

paMv:an;dug EdlGmdMeNIredaynayesnaFikar v:an; eTon yug nigemdwknaMCan;x<s;CaeRcInrUbeTotRtÚv

ecjdMeNIrmkkan;RkúgPñMeBjpg. BYkeKRtÚvsßitenAkm<úCa bYnéf¶ edIm,IBRgwgcMNgTak;TgepSg²

CamYyrbbfIµ 72.

éf¶esAr_ TI17 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979 muneBlRBHGaTitürHbniþcG½BÞd¾Rkas;mYy)anRKbdNþb;CYrPñM

tUc²sm,ÚreTAedayéRBeQIenAtamRBMEdncin-evotNamenAeLIy. enHKWCaeBlevlaEdlkgT½B

rbs;cin)aneRCIserIsedIm,IbeB©ajkMhwgeRkveRkaFrbs;xøÜn. vamanPaBdUcKñamYynwgkarvayluk

cugeRkay enAeBlEdl Can LúgCa RBHecAGFiraC m:an;CU bBa¢ÚnkgT½BesHnigkgT½BefµIeCIgmYy enA

qñaM1788 edIm,Idak;esþcmYyGgÁ[esayraCüenARkúghaNUytamkareRCIserIsrbs;xøÜnEdr. kmøaMg

pÞúHGavuFd¾sem,Imrbs;BYkcin-kaMePøIgFM)aj;)anry³q¶ayTMhM130miløIEm:Rt nig120milIøEm:Rt nig

kaMePøIg)aj;RKab;ru:EkátTMhM140milIøEm:Rtrab;ryedIm-)anFøak;eRsacmkelIRbeTsevotNamtam

sgVak;RbEhlmYyRKab;kñúgmYyvinaTI. GñkykB½t’manGaemrikaMgmñak;EdlsißtenApÞal;nwgTIkEnøg)an

sresrfa «sMeLgRKab;kaMePøIgEdl)aj;ecjmansPaBeLIgENn ebIeKsþab;BIcm¶aylan;B¤sñÚrhak;

dUcCakarvayRbharmYyBIsMNak;ynþehaHeb-52G‘Ícwg». Kat;)anbEnßmfa y:agehackñúgmYyelIk²

kar)aj;epøagmanfirevlaémÖnaTICab;KñarhUttag[kar)aj;eRcInbMputkñúgmYynaTIeTAtamviFanénkar

Tmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;GaemrikaMg73.

tmkeTot TahancinRbEhl85>000nak; EdlKaMRTedayrfeRkaHCaeRcIneRKÓg)ansRmúk

cUlRsdUcTwk)ak;TMnb;mkelIRbeTsevotNamtamcMNucRBMEdnémÖR)aMmYykEnøgxus²Kña. cMNuc

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg396

Page 407: Brother enemy

sMxan;bMputénkarvayluk)anRbmUlpþúMy:agqab;rh½smkelIpøÚvcMnYnR)aM EdlnaMeq<aHeTArkFanIrbs;extþ

epSg²edaye)assm¥atGIV²TaMgGs;enAtamtMbn;TaMgenaH edIm,IbMpøajb:us×þCYrmuxrbs;evotNam.

tamyuT§viFId¾l,Il,ajmYyKW «kar[kgT½BsRmúkcUlTaMghVÚg» EdlkgT½BRbCaCnCaticin Føab;)aneRbI

mkehIykñúgs®gÁamenAkUer: kgT½Brab;Ban;nak;)anRbwgERbgkm©at;kgQøb nigqµaMRBMEdnrbs;evotNam

[xÞatecjBICRmknanay:agxøaMgkøabMput. yuT§viFIenH KWCabraC½yEkElgekItmYyEdlRkúgeb:kaMg

)anTTYlsÁal;BIerOgenHenAeBleRkaymkeTot. BYkcinFøab;KitfaKµanGnÞak;EdlerobcMdak;eday

evotNam nigKµanpøÚvxVat;ExVgeFVI[vegVgkñúgrUgCIklugeRkamdInigelNdæanFM² EdlBYkeK)anCIkenAtam

tMbn;RBMEdneLIy. bIéf¶dMbUgkñúgkarvayRbyuT§)aneFIV[kgT½Bcinsøab;y:agrgÁal ³ enAeBleFVIkarvay

sRmúkTItaMgnana Tahanrab;Ban;nak;RtÚv)ansmøab;edaysarkar )aj;rHBIkaMePøIgynþ Can;RKab;mIn b¤

RtÚv)at;bg;Gv³yv³edaysarGnÞak;RKab;kaMePøIgFMrbs;BYkevotNam.

edayEtgtaMg]tþmesnIy_ y:ag edhSIú [eFVICaGñkdwknaMkgT½BlukluyCMnYs]tþmesnIy_

s‘UsIuyU Rkúgeb:kaMg)anniyaysarPaBBIbraC½yrbs;xøÜnedayrebobminc,as;las;. y:ag edhSIú

Edlmanv½yenAekµgenAeLIyRtÚv)an[eQµaHeRkAfa ³ «]tþmesnIy_ c,aMgminecHcaj;»taMgBIKat;man

tYnaTIkñúgs®gÁamenAkUer:emø:H. Kat;)anepIþmeFIVkarpøas;bþÚrrebobRbyuT§mYyCabnÞan; nigdak;ecjbTbBa¢a

[eFIVkarvayRbhartamrebobeRCIserIsmYy edaymankarKaMRTBIkgePøIgFM nighVÚgrfeRkaHpg. kñúg

rvagdb;éf¶ kgT½BrMedaHRbCaCn)anruleTAmuxyWt²EdlnaMmuxedaykgrfeRkaHrbs;xøÜnrhUtdl;CeRmA

samsibeTAEssibKILÚEm:RtBIRBMEdn. bnÞab;BIkarRbyuT§Kñay:agsVitsVaj kgT½Brbs;cin )anseRmc

eCaKC½yvaykan;kab;FanIrbs;extþcMnYnbYnKW LaycUv/ Lavék/ hay:ag nigkav)ag. enAéf¶TI27

ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979 bnÞab;BIkarcat;Ecg)aj;kaMePøIgFMy:agsem,Im karvayRbharTmøúHcUledayhVÚg

rfeRkaH)aneRCótcUldl; Lagsug CaFanIextþcugeRkayenAtMbn;RBMEdnEdlFøak;kñúgkNþab;édBYkcin.

RbtibtiþkarTaMgenH)anbNþal[manmnusSsøab;eRcInCageKkñúgbNþakarc,aMgKñaTaMgGs;. TIRkúgEdl

ksagedayBYk)araMgenHmanTMngCaRtÚveFVI[FUrRsak. b:uEnþ bnÞab;BI)ankan;kab;TYlPñMTaMgLay kgT½B

cinRtÚvRbyuT§KñaBIpÞHmYyeTApÞHmYytamelNdæanFM²EfmeTot edIm,Ikm©at;GñkenAkarBar. TIbMput enA

evlaem:ag2³40naTI éf¶TI5 ExmIna qñaM1979 BYkcin)andeNþImkan;kab; Lagsug dUcCaebIkmat;

Rckeq<aHeTAkan;EdndIsNþTenøRkhmEdr. TIRkúgrbs;extþLagsug RKan;EtCaCnbTmYyEdlrgkarhin

ehacb:ueNÑaHnigmanedrdaseTAedaysaksBsmmitþfµI² ehIyeBlenHCasRtÚvnwgKñavij. BIr-bI

em:ageRkaymk Rkúgeb:kaMg)anRbkasCasaFarN³fa kgT½Brbs;xøÜn)aneTAdl;eKaledArbs;eK

NUEGlRkhm 397

Page 408: Brother enemy

ehIy. enAéf¶dEdlenaH kgT½Brbs;cin)ancab;epIþmdkfyeTAkan;TwkdIcinvij.

«s®gÁamtamc,ab;k,Ün»ry³eBldb;R)aMmYyéf¶enH )anbMpøajRBMEdncin-evotNam[xUcxat

y:agdMNM. BYkcin)anseRmceCaKC½ykñúgkarbgðinbegðactMbn;mYyEdlrYcputBIkarTmøak;RKab;Ebk

rbs;GaemrikaMg. edayxøaceFIV[b:HBal;dl;TwkdIrbs;cin BYkGaemrikaMgBMu)anTmøak;RKab;EbkelITIRkúg

nanatamtMbn;RBMEdnEdlenAKg;vgSCamYynwgTIRkúghaNUy EdlGKarepSg²eFVIBI\dæenAminTan;xUcxat

enAeLIy. b:uEnþ kgT½Brbs;cin)ankemÞcrabdl;dIKµansl;enAtampøÚveFIVdMeNIrrbs;eK. TIRkúgLagsug

TTYlrgkarvinasGnþraykñúgeBlmankarRbyuT§Kña b:uEnþPaKeRcInénTIRkúgepSg²eTotEdlkan;kab;

edayBYkcin k¾CakmµvtßúénkarbMpøicbMpøajmYyedayectnay:agCak;c,as;. b:unµanExbnÞab;BIkar

QøanBan ´¬GñkniBn§¦)aneFIVdMeNIreTA kav)ag ehIyRsLaMgkaMgedaysegáteXIjfa RkúmTahan

visVkmµrbs;cin)andak;)øasIÞkbMpøajGIV²EdlminTan;xUcxatenAeLIy ³ RKwHsßannanarbs;TIRkúgkari-

yal½yéRbsNIy_ salaeron nigmnIÞreBTü. PñMtUc²EdlkalBIedIm hUCImij Føab;erobcMkarbdivtþn_

CamYybNþasmmitþcinrbs;Kat; suT§EtCasakSIenAes¶óms¶at;cMeBaHkarbMpiøcbMpøajenH. bgág;/ éd

rENgEdkEfbénpSarkNþal)anelceLIgy:agc,as;dUcCa eRKagq¥wgmYyegIbeTArkemXd¾lðelðvenA

eBlEdldMbUlRbk;ek,Ógrbs;vaRtÚvebIug)at;Gs;edaykarpÞúH. Rbdab;rm¶ab;emeraKeBocb:c/ bMENk

éndbGuksIuEsnCaeRcIndMu nigdMumUltUc²éneCIgERK EdlelcecjBIkemÞc)ak;EbkGac[dwgfa TIenH

CamnÞIreBTümYy. minq¶ayb:unµanBITIRkúg s<anEdkEfbmYy)an)ak;Føak;eTAkñúgTwkemIleTAhak;dUcCa

lutCgÁg;. KµansBaØaNamYybBa¢ak;fa mankarRbyuT§KñaRbRBwtþeTAenAkñúgTIRkúgeLIy. vresnIy_Ék

evotNammñak; )aneFIVkarcab;GarmµN_bBa¢ak;R)ab;´fa karkemÞcbMpøajTIRkúgkav)ag )anekItmaneLIg

enAéf¶TI10 ExmIna KWR)aMéf¶eRkaykarRbkasdkkgT½Brbs;cinCasaFarN³. ehtuEdlBYkcinBMu)an

eFIVkarbMpøicbMpøajtaMgBIdMNak;kaldMbUgénkarQøanBan KWBIeRBaHcincg;eRbIR)as;TwkdIEdlkan;kab;

edIm,IcrcaKñaBIkardkkgT½BevotNamecjBI km<úCa.

karmicEPñkrbs;Rkúgv:asIunetan

etIRkúgeb:kaMgRtÚvkarGIVR)akdkñúgkarEdlxøÜncUllukluyRbeTsevotNam? vaTMngfa eKaledA

epSg²)anERbRbÜltaMgBIExkkáda qñaM1978 CakalbriecäTEdlkariyal½yneya)ay)aneRKagKit

CaelIkdMbUgedIm,I«pþl;emeronmYy[evotNam». CasMxan; RbeTscinenAEtmanbMNgdak;TNÐkmµ

«sm<½n§mitþmYyEdlrmilKuN»nig«kUnsisSmñak;EdlrwgrUs»Canic©. edayvayRbhary:agcas;éd

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg398

Page 409: Brother enemy

RbeTscinmanbMNgbgçitbgçMRbeTsevotNam[BinitüCeRmIsneya)ayrbs;xøÜneLIgvij b:uEnþkar

vivtþénsßankarN_GnþrCati)anpþl;[evotNammanehtuplepSg² kñúgkareFIVGnþraKmn_bEnßmeTot.

sni§sBaØamitþPaBevotNam-sUevot nigkarcUllukluyRbeTskm<úCaKWCakarbgáehtucMeBaHPaBx<g;x<s;

CageKbMputRbcaMtMbn;rbs;RbeTscin. kardYlrlMénrbb b:ul Bt )aneFIV[cin)ak;mux)ak;mat;ehIy

RkúgmUsÁÚKMrameLamB½T§RbeTsxøÜnEfmeTot. b:uEnþ RbeTscin)antbteTAvijedaykmøaMgT½B. kar

RBElgkgT½BcMnYnémÖR)aMmWunnak;[eFIVkarvaylukRbeTsevotNamedIm,I«kemÞcPaBminecHcaj;rbs;

evotNam»dUc etg GHGag KWminEmnsMedARtwmEtbM)ak;muxevotNamnigRbKl;PaBKYr[eCOCak;mk

RbeTscinvijb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþk¾sMedAbgçM[RkúghaNUy[dkkgÉkPaBT½Brbs;xøÜnxøH²ecjBIkm<úCa

pgEdr. cinRtÚvkarbgðaj[eXIjdUcKñafa ³ RbtibtiþkarenHCaemeronmYysRmab;RbeTselakxag

licTaMgGs;EdlRtÚvjúaMg[ElgeFIVGIVekItenAcMeBaHmuxninñakarpSgeRBgniymrbs;sUevot. etg )an

RbkasR)ab;GñkkaEstenAeBlEdlkgT½Brbs;Kat;kMBugvayRbyuT§enARbeTsevotNamfa ³ «eyIg

minGacbeNþay[BYkKuy)a eFIVGMeBIGaRkk;enAGaRhVik mCÄimbUB’a nigenATIdéTeTotedayKµanRbTHnwg

karRbqaMgtTl;eLIy. mü:ageTot eyIgk¾minGacbeNþay[BYkKuy)aTisxagekIt¬evotNam¦eFIV

GMBIGaRkk;enARbeTsLav km<úCa EfmTaMgenAtamRBMEdnrbs;cineTotpg». «RbeTsxøHkñúgBiPBelak

P½yxøacERkgeFVI[BYkevotNamGn;citþeTaHbICaRbeTsTaMgenaHGaceFVI)ank¾eday. BYkeKnwgminh‘an

l,gRbqaMgnwgBYkevotNamesaHeLIy»74.

Tinanub,vtþikgT½BrMedaH)ansresrrwtEtcM²CagenHeTAeTot ³ «karvaybkeTAvijedIm,IkarBarxøÜn

KWCa»sfEdlCYyRTRTg;kitiþysmYyrbs;GñkTaMgLayEdlQWcab;nwg«CMgWs¥b;sUevot». C½yCmñH

CakarelIkTwkcitþd¾éføføamYysRmab;RbCaCnenAGasIuGaeKñy_ nigsRmab;BiPBelakTaMgmUlkñúgkar

RbyuT§rbs;xøÜnRbqaMgnwgGnutþrPaBniym»75.

ebIsinneya)ayeFIV[mankarFUrRsalEdlGYtGaghYsehtuedayelakxagliceFVI[ etg

mankMhwgeRkveRkaFmYyEbbenaH KWfaneya)ayenaHbgáCakarminTTYlsÁal;mYycMeBaHmaKa’neya)ay

rwgt¥wgrbs;cin. edaysarelak Rb‘IhSInsÁI shrdæGaemrik)anelIkRmamédBIryl;RBmCacMhcMeBaH

s®gÁamenH ehIyKµanRbeTselakxaglicNamYyepSgeToteFIVtameT. edaycat;Tukkarlukluy

RbeTskm<úCaCa«karKMramRbqaMgnwgsnþiPaB nigsßirPaBtMbn;EdlGacCamUlehtuénCemøaHmYyrwtEtFM

Cagmun» Rkúgv:asIunetan)anniyayedaHsaBIskmµPaBrbs;cinedayBaküsmþIminc,as;las;esaH.

RbFanaFibtI xaF½r )anRbkasfa ³ «kñúgbNþas)aþh_fIµ²enH eyIg)andwgBIkarlukluyRbeTskm<úCa

NUEGlRkhm 399

Page 410: Brother enemy

edayRbeTsevotNam nigkareRCótcUlrbs;cinenAtamRBMEdnrbs;RbeTsevotNam». edayehtu

enH GñknaMBakürbs;shrdæGaemrik)anesñI[mankardknUvkgT½Brbs;evotNamBIRbeTskm<úCa nig

kgT½Brbs;cinenARbeTsevotNamCabnÞan;. enACMnan;enaH RbeTsxøH)ansniñdæanBIerOgenHfa Rkúg

v:asIunetannwgminCMTas;BIkarrkSakgT½Brbs;cinenARbeTsevotNameT lÁwkNaevotNamenAEtrkSa

T½BBIRbeTskm<úCaenaH76.

rdæm®nIþkarbreTsshrdæGaemrik v:an;s_ R)afñalubecalTsSnkic©rbs;rdæm®nIþrtnaKar ém:eXIl

bøÚ‘em:nfl EdlCasBaØaénkartv:aRbqaMgnwgkarvayRbharrbs;cin. Rb‘IhSInsIÁ )anCMTas;nwgerOgenH

y:agdac;xat. Rb‘IhSInsIÁ )anGHGagfa «edaysarPaBmWugm:at;rbs; xaF½r nigedayminniyay[cM

KWsmþIrbs;Kat;pÞal; TMnak;TMngfIµrvagcin-GaemrikaMg )anTTYleCaKC½ytaMgEtBIcab;epþImdMbUg»77.

s®gÁamcin-evotNam hak;dUcCa)aneqøótTajykKuNRbeyaCn_BIshRbtibtiþkarrvagRkúg

eb:kaMg nigRkúgv:asIunetanxagvis½ysniþsuxEdlekIteLIgBIdMeNIrrbs; Rb‘IhSInsÁI enAEx]sPa qñaM

1978. CaeRcInqñaMeRkaymk GñkTTYlxusRtÚvGaemrikaMgCaeRcInnak; )anniyayR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦

CaÉkCnnUvPaKli¥tl¥n;xøH² sIþGMBIshRbtibtiþkarenH. kñúgs)aþh_dMbUgénkarRbyuT§Kña edaysarman

dMuBBky:agRkas;RKbdNþb;BIelItMbn;RBMRbTl;cin-evotNamenaH )anraraMgmin[páayrNbcarkmµ

rbs;GaemrikaMgXøaMemIlkardak;BRgaykgT½Brbs;evotNam)aneLIy b:uEnþ Rkúgv:asIunetan)anCYy

RbeTscin edaypþl;Casm¶at;nUvB½t’mansIþBIkardak;BRgaykgT½Brbs;sUevot enAtambeNþayRBMEdn

cinEdlTTYl)anBIpáayrNbEdr ehIy)anR)ab;[dwgBIkarRbkasdak;kgT½BsUevotenAtMbn;sIuebrI

[sßitkñúgPaBGasnñpg eRkayBIkarcUllukluyRbeTsevotNam78.

emeronmYysRmab;BiPBelakTaMgmUl

lkçN³TUlMTUlayénkarvaylukrbs;cin karxUcxatnigkarbMpøicbMpøajEdlcindak;eTaseTAelI

RbeTsevotNamnigkarmineXIjmankartbtrbs;sUevot)anbEnßmPaBKYr[Tukcitþrbs;RbeTscin

y:agR)akd. elIsBIkareRbImeFüa)ayKMramxøH²enAtambeNþayRBMEdncin BYksUevotKitEtcg;

begáInel,ÓnkñúgkarRbKl;smÖarswk[RbeTsevotNamb:ueNÑaH ³ tamkareXasnarbs;cin RbkarenH

mann½yesµInwgkarvaytémøfaxøÜnCa«xøaXµúMRkdasenAGekçasanxageCIg»dUecñaH. RbeTscineBjcitþnwg

C½yCmñHrbs;xøÜnNas; b:uEnþ eTaHbIy:agNak¾manbBaðaxøHenAminTan;[eBjcitþTaMgRsugEdr enAeBl

EdlBYkcinRbkasnUvkarcakecjrbs;xøÜn kgT½Berobryrbs;evotNamcMnYnbIkgBlFMkMBugeFIVdMeNIr

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg400

Page 411: Brother enemy

sMedAmk Lagsug ehIyRkúgmUsÁÚeTIbnwgecjkarRBmany:agmWugm:at;mYyedayKabsgát;[Rkúgeb:kaMg

bBa©b;karQøanBanrbs;xøÜn«munvaminTan;hYseBl». ebIKit[sBVeTA dUcGñkCMnajkarsiñT§cinmñak;)an

segçbesckIþy:agRtwmRtÚvfa eCaKC½yd¾FMrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMg KW)anRtwmEtbMpøajehdæarcnasm<½n§

eyaFa pøÚvKmnaKmn_ nigsmÖarbrikçarsgÁmenAevotNamxageCIg[exÞcxÞIb:uueNÑaH79.

]bsKÁepSg²xagEpñkesdækic©rbs;RbeTsmansPaBkan;EtdundabEfmeTot ehIyevotNam

RtÚvEtkarBarRBMEdnxageCIgrbs;xøÜn RbqaMgTl;nwgkarvayRbharrbs;BYkcinenAéf¶muxeTot. kar

RbqaMgnwgRkúgeb:kaMgmuxCamantémøkan;EtéføCagkalBImuneTAeTot. enARtg;enHÉg KWCaplcMeNj

srubEdlBYkcinTTYl)anBIRbtibtiþkarrbs;xøÜnmkvijenaH. evotNamenARtÚvcMNayTaMgCIvitmnusS

nigeyaFaCaeRcInnak;EfmeTot tamkarvaytémørbs;cinfa mancMnYn20>000nak; 80.

eTaHCaRbeTscinsnñidæanfa karsøab;rbs;mnusSmYycMnYnFMnigkarbMpøicbMpøajepSg²nwgeFIV[

evotNam«Gn;cg;»k¾eday k¾RbeTscinRtÚveFIV[tUccitþy:agxøaMgEdr ³ enAmunkardkfykgT½Brbs;cin

RkúghaNUy)anseRmceFIVkMENnCaTUeTAmYy edaybBaØtþierobcMRbCaCatiTaMgmUl[manTRmg;RtwmRtÚv

mYyedIm,IeFIVkarvayRbyuT§. RkúghaNUy)anRbkasy:agRkGWtfa «enHKWCakarcab;epþIms®gÁamts‘U

mYyRbqaMgnwgBYkQøanBanrbs;RbeTscinRbtikiriya».

edayCak;Esþg RbeTsevotNamBMu)anTTYlykemeronrbs;cineT ehIyk¾BMumanGIVpøas;bþÚrEdr

enARbeTskm<úCa. paM v:an;dug )anbnþTsSnkic©rbs;Kat;enARkúgPñMeBj hak;dUcCaKµanerOgGIVekIteLIg

Tal;EtesaH. Kat;)ancuHhtßelxaCamYy ehg sMrin nUvsni§sBaØasniþPaBnigshRbtibtiþkarmYy

sRmab;firevlaémÖR)aMqñaM EdlCaPsþútagbgðaj[eXIjBIvtþmanrbs;kgT½BevotNamCaeRcInkgBlFM

enARbeTskm<úCaBitEmn. CaCagdkT½BecjBIsmrPUmikm<úCa RkúghaNUyEdlmankarévqøat)an

beNþay[kgesnaCnnigkgT½BtMbn;Tb;Tl;nwgkarvaylukrbs;cin ehIyEfmTaMgmineRbIkgT½Berobry

CaeRcInkgBlFMepSgeTotpg. evotNam)an)at;bg;RbCaCnsIuvilnigeyaFaRbEhl10>000

nak;81 KWBitCasn§wksn§ab;Emn b:uEnþedayminRBm[kgT½BerobrycUlRbyuT§ k¾RkúghaNUyminTuk[

Rkúgeb:kaMgmansMNagNamYydeNþIm)anC½yCmñHCasßaBrEdr*.

RbEhlCaBYkcinpÞal;xøÜnÉg EdldkRsg;bTBiesaFn_BIkareFIVRbtibtiþkarswkrbs;xøÜn. tam

r)aykarN_sm¶at;mYyEdlecjBIRkúgeb:kaMg)an[dwgfa karxUcxatrbs;cinnigevotNammancMnYn

«esµIKñaeRcInKYrsm» ehIykgT½BrMedaHRbCaCnminecH«dwknaMeFIVs®gÁamTMenIbmYy»eLIy. edayeXIj

karxUcxaty:agF¶n;F¶rEdlxøÜn)anrgTTYlnigbraC½ykñúgkareRbIR)as;GavuF nigyuT§viFIEdleRbIR)as;

NUEGlRkhm 401

Page 412: Brother enemy

RbeTscin)anseRmcfa RtÚvEteFIVTMenIbnIykmµkgT½Brbs;xøÜnedayqab;rh½sbMput82.

eTaHCay:agNak¾eday k¾s®gÁamBMuEdlmanGñkQñHEdr. enAeBlEdl´eFIVdMeNIreTAkav)ag

enAExkkáda qñaM1979 ´eXIjRbCaCnmñak;EdlRkIRkrehmrhamkMBugsakl,geFIVpÞHelIKMnr)ak;Ebk

eLIgvijTaMgTwkmuxeRkómRkMCamYybMENkeKhdæanEdlrk)anBIkñúgKMnr)ak;EbkCaeRcIn. enAExbnÞab;

´)aneFVIdMeNIrqøgkat;tamextþBIrrbs;cinKW háagsIu nigyunNan. ´RtÚveFIV[PJak;ep¥Ily:agxøaMg eday

cMnYnTahanBikarrbs;kgT½BrMedaHRbCaCnmancMnYnmYyminKYr[eCO EdlkMBugedIrexJIc²lIeQIq<amrbs;

xøÜn nigkarRBegIykenþIyTaMgRsugrbs;RbCaCn eTaHbICamantaMgBiB½rN_enA KunmIg sIþBIeCaKC½yén

«karvaybkkarBarxøÜnRtwmRtÚvtamc,ab;»k¾eday. ´)anrYmdMeNIrCamYyGñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinmñak;eTA

TsSnaTsSnIyPaBceRmógnigr)aMmYy EdlsEmþgedayCnCatiPaKticepSg²rbs;extþ háagsIu. enA

TIenaH´man»kasvas;sÞg;BIRbCaRbiyPaBéns®gÁamtamc,ab;k,ÜnenH)anRbesIrbMput. saFarNCn

y:ageRcIn)anTHédlan;B¤kgrMBgenAeBlcb;karRbKMePøgmYybTb¤r)aMmYyQut nigkarelgBnøWePøIgnig

ePøIgBN’. tmkeTot eKcab;epIþmelgqakmYyeRkamcMNgeCIgfa vIrPaBrbs;kgT½BrMedaHRbCaCn

dak;eTasBYk]TÞamevotNam. enAelIqak eKeXIjmnusSBIrnak; bgðajrUbrageLIgkñúgsemøókbMBak;

BN’ébtgnigBak;mYkEbbGaNaniKmevotNam. BYkeKsµÚmsMues,ógGahar/ vayRbtb;KñadeNþIm

sMNl;mðÚbGahar/ ejIssMe)ar nigykédmkCUtexarbs;xøÜn. eKFøab;niyayBITahanGaemrikaMg BIr

nak;kñúgelçanbdivtþn_mYykalsm½ybdivtþn_vb,Fm’. tmk vIrburskgT½BrMedaHRbCaCnmñak;esøókBak;

sTaMgGs;)anhk;cUlmkkñúgqakPøam. edaysEmþg rebobelatepøaHRkLab;páab;p¶arlaycRmúHeTA

edayk,ac;r)aMnighSúydU (Judo) GñkesøókBak;senH )ankemÞcBYk]TÞamevotNamEtmYyb:RBicEPñk

b:ueNÑaH. enAeBlEdlvaMgnnFøak;cuH manPaBs¶b;s¶at;KYr[rMxanmYyenAkñúgcMeNamGñkemIlTaMgGs;.

GñkmkCamYy´smøwgemIlBitaneragelçanKµandak;EPñk. KµannrNamñak;dwgfa manmQUsb:unµanBan;Edl

dwkmkBIevotNamCagRbCaCnenANanIgeT.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg402

Page 413: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI11\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB?

GIV²)ancab;epIþmenAl¶acéf¶esAr_TI13 Exmkra qñaM1979 edaykarcab;rlak;édCamitþPaBmYy

reboblak;elomCamYyPñak;garmñak;énRkúmesIubkarN_sm¶at;GaemrikaMg. bnÞab;BIcb;karRbCMucugeRkay

rbs;RkúmRbwkSasniþsuxénGgÁkarshRbCaCati semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu )anyagRtLb;mkkan;

sNæaKarv:al;d½rGas;fUrIy:a enARkúgjÚvy:kvijrYmCamYynwgExµrRkhmCaeRcInnak;kñúgsemøókbMBak;

BN’RkemA nigPñak;garsm¶at;mYycMnYntUc. kRmmanGñkNasmÁal;eXIjRBHGakar³twgEtgrbs;

semþc sIhnu Nas; EdlbMPan;GñkdéTedaysarRBHsitakarEdlminERbRbÜl/ karKYrsmrebobdak;

RBHkay nigRBHraCkayvikarelIkRBHhsþbnþicrbs;RBHGgÁ. CeNþIrynþrbs;sNæaKarEdlman

mnusScUleBj)anlan;sMeLgB¤Rbwb² semþc sIhnu )aneqøót»kasenHcab;kBaäk;édPñak;garsm¶at;

mñak;y:agxøaMgkñúgcMeNamPñak;garsm¶at;CaeRcInnak;. edaynwksµanfa semþccg;bgçMKat;[TTYlyk

R)ak;Pñak;garenH)ancab;epIþmrG‘UrTaMrebobtv:amYy b:uEnþenAcMeBaHmuxkarsmøwgemIlrebobGgVrkrrbs;

semþc sIhnu nigsBaØagk;RBHeksrbs;RBHGgÁ Kat;k¾yk«kUnsMbuRt»mYy dak;cUlkñúgehae):ATaMg

jejItjejIm>>>.

taMgBIdMeNIryageTAdl;TIRkúgjÚvy:kenAéf¶TI9 Exmkra semþc sIhnu )aneRbIeBlevla

TaMgGs;rbs;RBHGgÁkñúgkarcUlrYmsniñ)at sniñsITkaEst karCYbsmÖasn_nigkarEføgsunÞrkfaepSg²

ehIyRBHGgÁRTg;pÞM)anEtbniþcbnþÜcb:ueNÑaH. edayxVHxatB½t’manmkBIRbPBedImsIþBIsßankarN_enAkñúg

RbeTskm<úCa RbB½n§pSBVpSaynana)anrMxanRBHGgÁedaykarecaTsYrCasMNYrepSg²sþIBI«karsmøab;

rgÁal»enAkm<úCa nigkarsIþbenÞasBIerOgEdlRBHGgÁRBmTTYleFVICatMNagrbbmYyEdlRbLak;eTA

edayQam. RBHGgÁ)anbeNþayRBHkayeTAtamRBHT½yBieraFrbs;RBHGgÁRbqaMgnwgGñklukluy

evotNam b:uEnþ)aneRtómBaküeBcn_EdleFIV[QWcab;bMputedayELk sRmab;rbbEdlRBHGgÁsnµt

faRtÚvkarBar. semþc)anRbkasR)ab;GñkkaEstmñak;fa «b:ul Bt RbEhlCaGñkRsLaj;Catimatu

PUmimñak; b:uEnþk¾CamnusSkMNacyg;Xñgmñak;Edr. Kat;)ancat;TukRbCaCnkm<úCa dUcstVBahn³EdlRtÚv

bgçM[eFIVCaTm¶n;dUcstVRCÚkEdleKykeTAsmøab;enATIstþXatEdr»1.

edaymanRBHraCbnÞÚlkñúgsm½yRbCMuvisamBaØmYyrbs;RkúmRbwkSasniþsux semþc sIhnu )anTTUc

sMuedayRBHsUresogmYyeBareBjedaykarrMCYlRBHT½y[shKmn_GnþrCatiCYybeNþjevotNam

403

Page 414: Brother enemy

ecjBIkm<úCa. sunÞrkfarbs;RBHGgÁ)aneFVI[eKcab;GarmµN_xøaMg ehIyRbCaRbiyPaBrbs;RBHGgÁkñúg

bNþaRbeTsttiyelak lµmEteFIV[RBHGgÁTTYl)ansmancitþ nigkarKaMRTCaTUeTA b:uEnþeqñatev:tUrbs;

sUevotEdlminGacecosrYc )anraraMgkarriHKn;CaÉkcä½nÞmYycMeBaHRbeTsevotNam. karRsLaj;

CatimatuPUmi esckIþeTogRtg; nigesckIþkøahanrbs;semþc sIhnu )aneFIV [eKePøcKitBIrbbEdl

RBHGgÁeFIVCatMNagbnþicbnþÜcEdr. enAGgÁkarshRbCaCati RBHGgÁ)anCYbmitþPkiþcas;²mYycMnYn

ehIy)aneFVI[RBHGgÁxVl;xVayRBHT½yCafIµ. RBHGgÁ[témøy:agsem,ImcMeBaHÉkGKÁrdæTUtGaemrikaMg

RbcaMGgÁkarshRbCaCati Gan;RDÚy:g; (Andrew Young) EdlCaGñkkarBarsiTi§mnusSy:agxøaMgkøakñúgBiPB

elakTaMgmUl ehIysmancitþenHKWmaneTAvijeTAmk. y:g; smÁal;eXIjfa semþcCa«KMrUbuKÁld¾

Gs©arümYyGgÁ». tamPaBxageRkA RBHGgÁsRmbRBHkay edIm,IrYcrs;CIvitBITukçlM)akevTnaTaMgLay

edaymineFVI[b:HBal;dl;RBHkitþinampÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁeLIy2.

y:g; BMudwgfa karekatsresIrrbs;Kat;cMeBaHsemþcnwgeFIV[RBHGgÁRtÚvsißtenAkñúg«karsak

BiesaFn_»BIsMNak;ExµrRkhmy:agqab;rh½spgeT. enAéf¶Edleqñatev:tUrbs;sUevotbBa©b;sm½yRbCMu

RkúmRbwkSasniþsux semþc sIhnu )anRbkan;ykkarseRmcRBT½yd¾RtwmRtÚvmYyeRsceTAehIy

Tak;TgeTAnwgGnaKtrbs;RBHGgÁCa«GñktMNagCan;x<s;»rbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyü edaymin[mnusS

TaMgGs;dwgeRkAGMBImehsIrbs;RBHGgÁeLIy. sRmab;semþcRTg;RCabc,as;Nas; EdlbuRtCaeRcIn

GgÁrbs;RBHGgÁRtÚv)at;RBHkay RBHGnuCéfø¬b¤RBHeroméfø¦nigsVamIrbs;GñkTaMgenaH RtÚv)ansmøab;

edayExµrRkhm. karsnÞnaTaMgLayrbs;RBHGgÁCamYyGñkkarTUt GñkkaEst nigbNþaCnrYmCatiExµr

)anCYy[RBHGgÁRCabkan;Etc,as;EfmeTotGMBIlkçN³FMeFgénerOgr:avEdlekItmanenARbeTskm<úCa.

karKµanrMBwgpÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁ nigkarbriharriHKn;epSg² EdlkñúgenaHRBHGgÁRtÚvrgTTYlkñúgzan³CaGñk

tMNagrbb b:ul Bt enaH)aneFIV[TukçRBÜyedaysarkarRBat;R)asbuKÁlCaTIRsLaj;pÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁ

EdlExµrRkhmeFIVTukçeTasmkelIRBHGgÁkan;EtF¶n;F¶reLIg. KµanGVIeTotEdlRtÚverobcMTaMgGs;/ TaMg

kitþiys/ TaMgkarykcitþTukdak;EdlRkúmGñktMNagRbeTscinRbcaMGgÁkarshRbCaCati bMeBjRBHraC

bMNgRBHGgÁ-«TUlbgÁMsUm[RBHGgÁkMuKitBIkarcMNay»/ ÉkGKÁrdæTUtRbeTscin)anTUlR)ab;RBHGgÁ

y:agc,as;edaydak;RBHGgÁ[Kg;enAbnÞb;sNæaKard¾RbNItmYy-TaMgmin[RBHGgÁTak;TgCamYy

GñkkarEstpg ³ semþc sIhnu enAEtCaGñkeTasCanic©. kmµaPi)alExµrRkhmbInak;EdlGmdMeNIr

RBHGgÁtaMgBIRkúgPñMeBjminsb,aycitþnwgedIrtamRBHGgÁdUcRsemalGenÞaltamR)aN RKb;Etkar

bgðajRBHP®½kþCasaFarN³ edayEckKñaedIrCamYyRBHGgÁnigmehsIRBmTaMgRkúmGñkEhhmrbs;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg404

Page 415: Brother enemy

RBHGgÁenAsNæaKar v:as;d½rGas; fUrIy:a pg. BIrbIs)aþh_eRkaymksemþcRtÚveKR)ab;[dwgfa enA

eBl eGog sarI eFIVdMeNIrmkdl;RBHGgÁnwgRtÚvbBa©úHzan³CaGnuRbFanKN³RbtiPUrbs;km<úCaRbCaFib

etyüenAGgÁkarshRbCaCativij. semþc sIhnu )anmanRBHraCbnÞÚlenAeBleRkaymkeTotfa Twk

eBjeRbóbEkvehIy. semþc)anseRmcRBHT½yfa enHCaeBlevlad¾RbesIrmYy edIm,IdeNþImyk

esrIPaBRBHGgÁmkvij.

enAyb;éf¶esAr_enaH kUnsMbuRtEdl semþc sIhnu epJItamBYkPñak;garsm¶at;)aneFVI[ Gan;RDÚy:g;

)at;mat;)at;k. semþc sIhnu )ansresrexVókedayexµAédelIbMENkRkdasxJúkxJÚvmYynUvBaküdUc

teTA ³ «elakGFikar ´sUmTTUcsMuCMnYyBIRkúmrbs;elakedIm,I[´rYcputBIBYkExµrRkhm EdleBlenH

kMBugsñak;enAsNæaKar v:al;d½r Gas;fUrIy:a CamYy´Edr. yb;enH evlaem:agBIrKt; ´nwgcakecj

edaysm¶at;BIRkúmGñkEhhm´EtmYyGgÁÉgCamYyv:alismYy. sUmelakemtþanaMykrUb´tam

rfynþeq<aHRtg;eTAb‘uyr:Urbs;elak Gan;RDÚy:g; ÉkGKÁrdæTUtGcié®nþy_rbs;shrdæGaemrikRbcaMGgÁkar

shRbCaCatiEtmþg. sUmEføgGMNrKuNelakCaGenkb,kar. RBHhsþelxa «sIhnu». y:g;

)anR)ab;[ v:an;s_ nig rIqad hUlRbÚ‘k dwgPøam² Edl)anekaH GeBa¢IjGñkTTYlxusRtÚvénRkúmesIub

karN_sm¶at; nigEpñksniþsuxCatiCaeRcInrUbmkeFVIkarRbCMumYyCabnÞan;. hUlRb‘Úk )anniyayenAeBl

eRkaymkfa enABak;kNþalGRFaRteyIg)anerobcMnUvKeRmagsac;erOgmYydUcExSPaBynþG‘ÍcwgEdl

niyayBIvIrbursmancitþTUlMTUlaymñak;. RkúmPñak;garsm¶at;CaeRcInnak;enArg;caMsemþctameBlem:ag

kMNt;enAmat;TVarkEnøgsñak;enArbs;RkúmGñkEhhmRBHGgÁ. hUlRbÚ‘k )aneLIgeTAkan;bnÞb;erobcMkar

eFVIRbtibtþikarenACan;TIR)aMBIrénGKarRksYgkarbreTs CaTIEdlKat;GactamdankarvivtþsßankarN_enH

enAeBlEdl v:an;s_ sißtenAEk,rTUrs½BÞÉpÞHrbs;Kat;. eRkaymk hUlRbÚ‘k )anniyay[dwgfa «KWCa

karRbfuyeRKaHfñak;mYyFMNas;. eyIgP½yxøacEtRBHGgÁRtÚveKsmøab;b:ueNÑaH. eTaHCay:agNa

k¾edayRBHGgÁenAEtCaGñkeTasmñak;rbs;ExµrRkhmdEdl».

enAkñúgElVgbnÞb;rbs;RBHGgÁ semþc sIhnu enAKg;rg;caMeBlem:agEdl)ansnµtTaMgRcas;

Rcal;kñúgRBHT½y. tamFmµtaBYkqµaMExµrRkhmeRcInEtedkenAeBlBak;kNþalGRFaRt b:uEnþenAyb;enH

BYkenaHhak;dUcCamingguyedkesaH. enAem:agdb;BIrnigsamsibnaTIGRFaRt RBHGgÁRTg;enAsNþab;B¤

sMeLgbiukb:k;²énm:asIunGgÁúlIelxmYyenAkñúgbnÞb;Ek,rxageTot. k¾b:uEnþenAevlaem:agBIreTobPøW GIV²

)ansßitenAkñúgsPaBs¶b;s¶at;TaMgRsug. RBHGgÁmanbnÞÚllaGñkmñag m:Unic EdlmanRBHP®½kþeRkóm

RkMehIycakecjeTAedaylYclak;. GaemrikaMgbYnnak;enAGgÁúyrg;caMRBHGgÁedayKµanniyaysIþmYy

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 405

Page 416: Brother enemy

m:at;. munnwgyagcakecj RBHGgÁ)anbgÁab;dac;xat[Gñkmñag m:Unic R)ab;ExµrRkhmnigBYkcin)andwg

GMBIkarseRmcRBHT½yeKcecjrbs;RBHGgÁenHpg. semþck¾)anesñI[GñkmñagsgR)ak;cMnYn20>000

duløareTA[ExµrRkhmEdl)anpþl;[RBHGgÁ enAeBlRBHGgÁyagecjBIRkúgPñMeBjvijpg. Gm

sgxagedayBYkPñak;garGaemrikaMg semþc)ane)aHCMhany:agrh½ssMedACeNþIrynþmYy. enAxag

cugpøÚvrebogxVat;ExVgmYyEdlnaM[vegVg RBHGgÁ)anrkeXIjpøÚvmkdl;xageRkACaTIEdlrfynþmYy

eRKÓgenArg;caMCaeRsc edIm,IebIkCUnsemþcrhUtdl;kariyal½yrbs; y:g;. semþc sIhnu manRBHraC

bnÞÚleRkaymkfa rUbRBHGgÁdUcCasißt enAkñúgExSPaBynþEpñkcarkmµmYyG‘Icwg¡».

RBwtþikarN_Edlmin)anKitTukTaMgenH )aneFIV[EpnkarepSg²rbs; y:g; EdlRtÚveFIVdMeNIreTA

TIRkúgGaLinta(Atlanta)enAéf¶TI14 Exmkra edIm,IcUlrYmBiFIbuNürMB£kxYbkMeNItelIkTI50rbs;elak

m:artaMg lUF½r XIg ERbRtLb;Gs;. RbFanaFibtIxaF½rRtÚvTTYlParkic©niyayBnül;R)ab;GñkkaEst

BIGvtþmanrbs;Kat;enH. Kat;niyayfa y:g; RtÚvehA[mkkan;RksYgkarbreTsenAem:ag2³30naTI

RBwk eRBaHEt«ebskmµBiessmYy». TIbMput enAeBlEdl y:g; mkdl;edayyWteBlenAéf¶enaH

Kat;)anRbkasR)ab;sarB½t’manfa Kat;eRtómCYbBiPakSaCamYyGñktMNagrbs;cin edIm,I«sakl,g

lubbM)at;karlM)akxøH²EdlTak;TgnwgRbeTskm<úCa»3.

kalenaHGIVEdlKat;BMuGacniyay[dwgKWfa enAmuneBlRBwkRBlwmKat;)aneTACYbsemþc sIhnu

EdlkMBugRsyutRsyg;RBHT½y bnÞab;mkCYbCamYyBYkcin edIm,IBiPakSaBIRBHraCbMNgcg;cakecjBI

ExµrRkhmrbs;semþc. ÉkGKÁrdæTUtcinRbcaMGgÁkarshRbCaCati)anRtÚvekaH GeBa¢Ij[eTAkan;b‘uyr:U

rbs; y:g; PøamCakEnøgEdl semþc sIhnu )anmanbnÞÚlR)ab;ÉkGKÁrdæTUtcin edaypÞal;BIbMNgesIñsMu

siTi§RCkekanxagneya)ayCabeNþaHGasnñenAshrdæGaemrik. semþc)anmanRBHraCbnÞÚlR)ab;

Kat;fa ³ «éf¶NamYy ´nwgRtLb;eTAKg;Rbfab;enARbeTscinvij b:uEnþ´)anrgkarb:HTgÁicxagpøÚvRBHT½y

y:agxøaMg. vacaM)ac;Edl´RtÚvEteTAkan;mnIÞreBTümYyenARkúgjÚvy:kCabnÞan; edIm,IsRmakBüa)al[

manRBHkayBleLIgvij».

semþc sIhnu )aneFIV[RksYgkarbreTsGaemrikT½lKMnity:agxøaMg. bTBiesaFn_EdlRBHGgÁ

Føab;qøgkat;enARbeTskm<úCa )aneFIV[RBHGgÁTak;Taj)ansmancitþCaTUeTA. b:uEnþ v:an;s_ nig hUlRbÚ‘k

P½yxøacfa kare)aHbg;ecalbkçBYkrbs;RBHGgÁGaceFIV[qakneya)ayrbs;km<úCa)at;bg;emdwknaM

EdlmansmtßPaBmYyGgÁ nigCanimitþrUbmYyénÉkPaBCati. GIVEdlkan;EteFIV[RBÜy)armÖEfmeTot

enaH KWeRKaHfñak;eFVI[TMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMgEdleTIberobcM[manfIµ²cuHGn;exSay ebIsinCaeKyl;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg406

Page 417: Brother enemy

RBmpþl;siTi§RCkekan[RBHGgÁEmnenaH. edaysarKMnitpþÜcepIþmrbs;RbeTscin CasMxan;nigkarRbwg

ERbgTaMgRsugrbs;xøÜn eTIb semþc sIhnu GacyagcakecjBIRkúgPñMeBjmunkarcUlmkdl;rbs;

evotNam ehIyRbeTscinpgEdrEdl)anbBa¢ÚnRBHGgÁeTAkan;RkúgjÚvy:k[eFVICatMNagrbs; b:ul Bt

enaH. edayCak;Esþg Rkúgeb:kaMgmaneKalbMNgeRbIR)as;kitþisBÞ½CaGnþrCatirbs;semþc edIm,I

RbmUlsaFarN³mtiRbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNam. ]bnaykrdæm®nþI etg s‘avBIg )anBnüareBlenA

shrdæGaemrikBIrs)aþh_eRkaymkeTot. »kasEdlRtÚvseRmccitþyl;RBmpþl;siT§iRCkekanEpñk

neya)ay[ semþc sIhnu mansPaBminl¥eLIy. rU:ehS s‘ullIv:an; ]bkarIrbs;elak hUlRb‘Úk

TTYlbnÞúkkic©karRbeTscinRtÚv)andas;[PJak;BIdMeNkenABak;kNþalGRFaRtnigsMu[GeBa¢Ijmkkan;

RksYgkarbreTs. KWrUbKat;enHehIyEdlTTYlbnÞúkR)ab;dMNwgenHdl;BYkcin. enAem:ag4RBwk Kat;

)anehA han; s‘U RbFankariyal½yTMnak;TMngrbs; cinenARkúgv:asuInetantamTUrs½BÞ edIm,IR)ab;[Kat;

dwgfa semþc sIhnu EdlGs;RBHkayy:agxøaMg )ancUlsRmakBüa)alenAmnÞIreBTüehIy. mundMbUg

hans‘U manGakar³egOgq¶l; b:uEnþKat;)anBRgwgsµartIeLIgvijy:agqab;rh½s. s‘U )aneqøIytby:ag

xøIfa ³ «l¥Nas; ebIRBHGgÁsBVRBHT½yEmneyIgyl;RBm»4.

BnøWRBHGaTitüsRBag²)anrHeLIgcaMgmkelITenø East River enAeBlEdl semþc sIhnu RtÚv)an

eKCUndMeNIryageTAkan;mnÞIreBTü lINUshuIl (Lenox Hill) enAtamdgvifI Park Avenue. enAevlaRBwkéf¶

bnÞab; RBHGgÁm©as;kSRtI m:Unic )anyagmkKg;enACamYyRBHGgÁEdrkñúgbnÞb;naCan;TI9énmnÞIreBTü CaTI

EdlRBHGgÁTaMgBIrnwgRtÚv)anbgçaMgedayxusc,ab;esÞIrEtTaMgRsug. RksYgkarbreTsyl;eXIjfa

KYrEtdak;semþc[enAdac;BIeKÉgsinedIm,Ipþl;eBlevla[RBHGgÁeFVIkarRtiHriHBicarNaCaCagpþl;siT§i

RCkekan[RBHGgÁedayRbjab;Rbjal;eBk. esckþICUndMNwgmYy)anRbkas[dwgBIkaryagcUl

mnÞIreBTürbs;semþcbnÞab;BIman «sPaBtantwgy:agF¶n;F¶rmYyEpñksrésRbsaTnigkarGs;RBHkay

Bly:agxøaMgmYy». RhVg;taTU m®nþIenARksYgkarbreTsEdlecHniyayPasa)araMg nigEdlFøab;

rs;enARbeTskm<úCaGs;CaeRcInqñaMRtÚv)ancat;[eTAsaksYrsuxTukç semþc edIm,IbBa¢ak;fa RBHGgÁ

BMuEmnCaGñkeTaseT ³ viFankarepSg²Epñksnþisux KWRKan;EtkarBarRBHGgÁ nigTuk[RBHGgÁmaneBl

RKb;RKan;edIm,IRTg;RBHtRmiHb:ueNÑaH. elak y:g; k¾GeBa¢IjeTACYbsemþcEdr. c,as;Nas; eyabl;

rbs;GaemrikaMgmandUcteTA ³ «RBHGgÁGacKg;enACamYyeyIgebIsinCaRBHGgÁsBVRBHT½y b:uEnþehtuGVI

)anCaRBHGgÁminBicarNaEfmeTotBIerOgenH? enAeBlEdleKcUlxagKURbqaMgBYkeKmuxCa)at;bg;

GtþsBaØaNrbs;xøÜn ehIyElgmanRbeyaCn_GVITaMgGs; kñúgzan³CaemdwknaMneya)ay». hUlRbÚ‘k

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 407

Page 418: Brother enemy

)andMNalfa ³ «eyIg)anTUlsYrRBHGgÁfa GñkNaEdlRBHGgÁnwgRtÚvBwgEp¥k? GñkNaEdle)aHbg;

RBHGgÁecal? ExµrRkhm?. mnusSTaMgGs;dwgfa RBHGgÁ)anpþac;TMnak;TMngCamYyExµrRkhmehIy.

etIsemþccg;e)aHbg;RbeTsmYyEdleTaHCay:agNak¾eday k¾RBHGgÁBMuGacyagRtLb;eTAvijenAeBl

enHEmnb¤?». enAéf¶TI18 Exmkra qñaM1979 v:an;s_ )aneFVIdMeNIredaypÞal;eTAkan;mnÞIreBTü. Kat;

)anTUl semþc sIhnu fa RBHGgáKWCaePJóvrbs;rdæaPi)alGaemrikaMg ehIyfaRBHGgÁGacKg;enAshrdæ

Gaemrikkñúgry³eBlyUrtamEtRBHGgÁsBVRBHT½y. v:an;s_ BMumanniyayBIsiT§iRCkekanEpñkneya

)aymYym:at;Tal;EtesaH5.

semþcmanRBHT½yeRtkGrCaBnøwkEdlRBHGgÁ)anedaHRBHkayecjBIRkjaMExµrRkhm nigkøay

CamnusSmñak;manesrIPaBeLIgvij. b:uEnþGVI²BMuEmnsuT§Etl¥enaHeT ³ xusEbøkBIbNþaemdwknaMRbeTs

ttiyelakPaKeRcIn GtItRBHmhakSRtGgÁenHBMumanelxKNnINamYycuHkñúgFnaKarnanaenAbreTs

eLIy. GñkRKb;RKgmnÞIreBTülINUshuIsRtÚveFVI[RsLaMgkaMg enAeBlEdldwgfa GñkCMgWRbkbeday

kitþinamrbs;xøÜnBMumankarFanar:ab;rgxagEpñksuxPaBmYyenaH. mnÞIreBTüKµanKitGVIeRkABITamTar[

«GaNaBüa)al»TaMgBIrrbs;RBHGgÁ KWExµrRkhm nigBYkcin[bg;éføeBTüeLIy. b:uEnþKWrdæaPi)al

GaemrikaMgCaGñkecjR)ak;bg;éføeBTücMnYn 15>000duløareTAvij. b:uEnþ bnÞab;BIkareTAsYrsuxTukç

rbs; v:an;s_ semþc sIhnu RTg;RCabfa shrdæGaemriknwgBMuyl;RBmpþl;siT§RCkekanEpñkneya)ay

[RBHGgÁeLIy. edayRtÚveFVI[xUcRBHT½ysemþc)anRbjab;eFVIkarTak;TgCamYyÉkGKÁrdæTUt)araMg

RbcaMGgÁkarshRbCaCatiPøam kñúgeKalbMNgsMu[Kat;bBa¢ÚneTAkan;Rkúg):arIsnUvBaküesñIsMulixit

qøgEdn)araMgsRmab;RBHGgÁ nigGñkmñag m:Unik. RBHGgÁk¾)anesñIsMukarGnuBaØatKg;enAkñúgPUmiRKwHtUc

mYyEdlCakmµsiT§irbs;RBHmataRBHGgÁenAmUhSIn pgEdr. semþceCOCak;nwgTegVIrbs;RBHGgÁNas;

eTIbRBHGgÁRTg;lixiteTARksYgkarbreTsedImI,R)ab;[dwgfaRBHGgÁnwgeTArs;enARbeTs)araMgvij.

b:uEnþ BYk)araMgsuxcitþyl;RBmpþl;siT§iRCkekan[RBHGgÁkñúglkçxNÐdac;Nat;fa semþc sIhnu RtÚvEt

ecosvagskmµPaBneya)ayTaMgGs;nigkareFVIsmÖasn_epSg²EdlmanlkçN³neya)aypg.

Gñkmñag m:Unik EdlmankMeNItBI«BukCaCnCati)araMgGacTTYl)anlixitqøgEdn)araMgmYy cMENkÉ

semþcKWBMuGaceT. sRmab;semþc sIhnu kareRCIsenAeBlenHmanlkçN³lM)akCaTIbMput ³ b¤mYy

RtÚvrs;enACaGñknireTsxøÜnedayKµanRTBüsm,tþinigKµanmatuPUmi b¤mYyyl;RBmeFVICatMNagfñak;fñm

edayrbbmYy Edlkab;smøab;mnusSGs;y:ageRcInedayectna?. lT§PaBTIbI)anelceLIgPøamEt

minsUvTak;citþb:unµaneLIy. tamkarCYyxñHExñgrbs;ÉkGKÁrdæTUténRbeTsmincUlbkSsm<½n§mYy Rkúg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg408

Page 419: Brother enemy

haNUy)anTUl[semþcdwgfa ebIsinRBHGgÁcg;yagRtLb;mkRkúgPñMeBjvijedIm,IeFVICaemdwknaM

rbbmYy EdlerobcMeLIgedayevotNamRBHGgÁnwgRtÚv)anTTYlsVaKmn_.

enATIbMputKW etg s‘avBIg EdlRtÚvseRmccitþBIerOgRBHGgÁ. etg nwkRBÜy)armÖy:agxøaMg eday

karRbkasy:agxÞrxÞarrbs; semþc sIhnu RbqaMgnwgExµrRkhm nigRBHraCbMNgcg;Kg;Rbfab;enAbs©im

RbeTsrbs;RBHGgÁ. kalviPaKrbs;Kat;Edlmanrebobvar³eRcInhYsRtÚv)anEkERb edIm,IGacebIk

»kas[Kat;)anCYbsemþcenAéf¶TI31 Exmkra qñaM1979 edaymanshRbtibtþikarBIBYkGaemrikaMg

pg. GmkarBaredayPñak;garsnþisuxrbs;RksYgkarbreTsbYnrUb semþc sIhnu nigmehsI)anyag

tamrfynþBIjÚvy:keTAEbø‘rhav (Blair House) Canievsndæanrbs; etg edImI,cUlrYmelogsayePaCn_

eBll¶acCalkçN³ÉkCnmYy.

enAmuxmðÚbGaharcind¾sm,ÚreBarBas etg )anRbkasfa ³ «semþc sIhnu¡ RBHGgÁCaGñkesñha

Catid¾eqñImmYyGgÁ RBHGgÁminRtÚve)aHbg;matuPUmirbs;RBHGgÁKWkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüeLIy». semþc

sIhnu )anmanbnÞÚltbvijy:agrh½sfa ³ «matuPUmiEtmYyKt;rbs;´ KWkm<úCaBMuEmnkm<úCaRbCaFib-

etyüeT. ´k¾BMuEmnCaGñkRbCaFibetyüxøaMgkøaEdr ´CaesþcskþiPUmimYyGgÁ». etg )anRbEkktwg

sMeLgfa semþcCaGñkRbCaFibetyüBitR)akdmYyGgÁ¡. Kat;)anbEnßmfa ³ «´KYrEtsarPaBfa

cMeBaHeyIgCacinBMusUvcUlcitþlkçN³neya)ayxøH²rbs; b:ul Bt eT eRBaHKat;CamnusStwgEtg

eBk». RbeTscin)ansakl,gbnÞn;RBHT½ysemþc. semþcEdlmineCO)ansYrfa «BitEmnb¤? etI

elakeCOR)akdfa eKGaceFVI[stVxøaERbkøayeTACastVsøÚtbUt)aneT?». etg )anTTYlsÁal;fa

RbeTscinBMumanGMNacenHeT b:uEnþ Kat;)anrMB£kTUlR)ab;semþcBIkarRbwgERbgepSg²EdlRbeTs

rbs;Kat;)aneFVIedIm,IrMedaHsemþcBIExµrRkhmEdr. edayeFVICaykkardwgKuNd¾RCaleRCArbs;semþc

cMeBaHRbeTscinCasMGag etg )anTUlsemþcfa KWRBHGgÁCaGñkmanbnÞÚlRBmKñafa RbeTscinCamitþ

cas;mYypgnigCamatuPUmiTIBIrpg taMgBImankarpþÜlrMlMRBHGgÁenAqñaM1970em:øH. vanwgCakarcMGk

cMeBaHRbeTscinEdl semþc sIhnu bdiesFminyagRtLb;eTArs;enARkúgeb:kaMgvij. etg )anpþl;

nUvkarFanaGHGagnwgsemþcfa kartaMgRBHT½yminshkarCamYyExµrRkhmnwgRtÚv)aneKarBeFVItam

ehIyfaKµankarKabsgát;NamYynwgRtÚveFVIeTAelIrUb RBHGgÁedIm,IbgçMRBHGgÁBIerOgenHeLIy. mü:ag

eTot eKnwgmintRmÚv[RBHGgÁyageTAkan;TINaEdlpÞúynwgRBHT½yRBHGgÁpgeT. etg )ansnüaeRbI

lT§PaBTaMgGs;rbs;Kat;CamYyExµrRkhm edIm,I[CYyEsVgrkRBHraCbuRta-buRtI RBHraCntþa¬ecA¦ nig

bNþajativgSdéTeTotrbs;semþc sIhnu Edl)at;xøÜnEfmeTot. karGeBa¢Ijd¾CaTIkk;ekþArbs; etg

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 409

Page 420: Brother enemy

nigkic©Fana[manesrIPaBTaMgRsúg)anbBa©b;karsÞak;esÞIrRBHT½ycMnYnBIrs)aþh_rbs;semþc sIhnu

RtwmenH. RBHGgÁnwgyageTAKg;Rbfab;enATIRkúgeb:kaMgCafµIedayesckþIsgÇwmfa sßanPaBneya)ay

d¾RbesIrmYymuxCaGnuBaØat[RBHGgÁyagRtLb;eTAkan;RbeTskm<úCaEdlÉkraCümYYyvijminxan6.

semþc sIhnu )anyl;RcLMEdlsEmþgecjnUvKMnitsuTidæiniymdUcenH ehIynwksµanfa eKnwg

beNþay[RBHGgÁKg;enAs¶b;s¶at;enARbeTscinenaH. BitCaqab;rh½sEmn¡ karKabsgát; karlYgelam

karbeBa¢ar nigkarTak;TajcitþRKb;Ebby:ag)anbgçM[RBHGgÁcUlrYmeFVIkarts‘UCafµI EdlCMrujedaykar

kan;kab;rbs;evotNam. kitþis½BÞCaGnþrCatinigRbCaRbiyPaBd¾FMeFgrbs;RBHGgÁenAkm<úCa)anpþl;[

RBHGgÁnUvtYnaTIKnøwHmYyCafµIkñúgesaknadkmµrbs;km<úCa. enAqñaM1970 semþc sIhnu RBHRbmuxrdæ

EdleKTmøak;BItMENg )ancgP¢ab;eCaKvasnarbs;RBHGgÁCamYyBYkExµrRkhmnigsm<n§½mitþevotNam

nigcinrbs;BYkeK. enAqñaM1979 karcab;epþImRbkYtRbECgKñaenAxageRkA)anekIneLIgy:agxøaMg.

karkan;kab;RbeTskm<úCaedayevotNam minRKan;Etbgðaj[eXIjkarbgáehtumYycMeBaHRbeTscin

b:ueNÑaHeT Etk¾eFVI[smaKmGas‘anRBÜy)armÖy:agxøaMgEdr. CagenHeTAeTot karkan;kab;enH)aneFVI[

RbeTséf)at;bg;«RTnab;»mYy Edlx½NÐEckRbeTsBIKURbECgevotNamEdlmanrab;stvtSr_mk

ehIy. enAedImdMbUg enHCaCemøaHFmµtamYyrvagRbeTsevotNammçag ehIymçageTotKWRbeTscin

nigRbeTsenAkñúgkar]btßmÖrbs;xøÜnKWkm<úCa EdlenAeBlenH)anRtÚvr:UvKñaedaysarCemøaHCaRbvtþi

sa®sþmYyepSgeTot EdlkMBugeFVI[RbeTsevotNam nigRbeTséfRbQmmuxdak;Kña edIm,IdeNþIm

karRtÜtRtavalTMnabTenøemKgÁ. s®gÁamfµIenH)anpþl;[BYksUevotnUv»kasebIkpøÚvmYymkkan;smuRT

):asuIhVikEdlBMuFøab;manBImunmk. bNþasm<½n§mitþkñúgtMbn;rbs;RbeTséf nigbNþaRbeTsCamitþenA

bs©imRbeTs )anRtÚvGUsTaj[cUlkñúgCemøaHmþgeTot. RbeTskm<úCa)ankøayeTACacMNucekþAfµImYy

kñúgkarRbQmmuxdak;KñarvagxagekItnigxaglic. karvivaTCaRbvtþisa®sþRtÚv)andutbeBaäHCafµI mitþnig

sm<½n§mitþTaMgLayEdlCaGñknaMGaT×)aneRbIl,icklepSg² edIm,ITTYl)anGtßRbeyaCn_CayuT§sa®sþ

mYykñúgeBlEdlKµanRbeTsNamYyxVl;xVayBIeCaKvasnarbs;RbCaCatiExµr.

TIbBa©b;énsubinGaRkk;

karkan;kab;TIRkúgPñMeBjedayevotNam nigkaredjtamExµrRkhmrhUtdl;RBMEdnéf )anbgá[

mankarPJak;ep¥IlRsLaMgkaMgenARkúg)agkk. etIBYkenHeFVIdMeNIreTAdl;NaeTot?. eBlenH«CnCati

RBÚsSGasuI» (Les Prussiens d'Asie) KWevotNamnwgedjtamGñkedIrtamrbb b:ul Bt cugeRkayrhUtdl;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg410

Page 421: Brother enemy

TwkdIéfEmnb¤? BYkeKnwgbBa¢Únk,ÜnrfeRkaHrbs;xøÜnrhUtdl;Rkúg)agkkeToteTdwg?.

karmkdl;rbs;evotNam RtÚv)anTTYlsVaKmn_edayTwkcitþrIkrayenAtambNþaPUmirab;ry

rbs;km<úCa. RbCaCnminnwksµanfamanerOgG‘IcwgeLIy ³ BYkkmµaPi)alExµrRkhmnigkgQøbTIbMput

)ancakecjBIRsukPUmiGs;. RbCaCnmñak;²manesrIPaBCafµIkñúgkarrs;enACYbCMuRKÜsar ehIyGaceTA

edkBYnenATINak¾)an edayKµanP½yxøacBIéf¶Es¥keLIy. eRkamkarbgçitbgçMRbCaCnCit30>000nak;

énbNþaextþPaKxaglicnigRkúgPñMeBjRtÚvekoreTAtamExµrRkhmcUleTAkñúgéRBeTot. b:uEnþ sRmab;

tMbn;déTeToténRbeTs enHKWCadMeNIrrYcputBIeRKaHfñak;mYy. GñkPUmi)annaMKñaerIkkayCRgúkRsUv

rbs;GgÁkar nigsmøab;RCÚk man; Ta edIm,IerobcMkarbriePaKCaelIkdMbUgrbs;eKy:agEq¥tsáb;sál;

eRBaHBYkeKminEdlsÁal;GVIEdlfa «Eq¥t» taMgBIbYnqñaMmkehIy. RbCaCnkm<úCarab;ryBan;nak;)an

cab;epþImecjdMeNIr edIm,IvilRtLb;eTARsukkMeNItrbs;eKvij. RbCaCnRbúsRsIEdlmansemøók

bMBak;BN’exµArEhkréy: kMBugdwkCB¢ÚanGIv:an;d¾tictYcrbs;BYkeK tamreTHrujedayédEdleFVI[Et)an²

nigedIrRcvat;RcEvgeTAmkBaseBjRbeTs emIleTAhak;dUcCahVÚgRsemacedIrCaCYrEdr. R)aMmYyEx

bnÞab;BIkarQøanBan enAeBlEdl´¬GñkniBn§¦eFVIdMeNIreTAkm<úCaCafµImanRbCaCnxøHenAEteFVIdMeNIr

tampøÚvenAeLIy. bnÞab;BIkareFVIdMeNIrGs;rab;ry em:agTaMgGs;kmøaMgnigeRskXøan BYkeKenAEtbnþ

edIrTaMgRtdabRtdYsrhUtdl;eKaledAcugeRkayrbs;eK. «ebIsinCaevotNamminmkeT eyIgTaMgGs;

KñanwgRtÚvsøab;» enHCaBaküEdlGñkrYcputBIeRKaHfñak;TenÞjminQb;. b:uEnþ RbeyaKsEmþgkardwgKuN

enHBMumanKitRBÜy)armÖBIkarmkdl;énRBwtþikarN_GaRkk;eLIy ³ RbeTsevotNamEdlCasRtÚvKµan

TIbMputnwgminP¢ab;RbeTskm<úCaCarNbrbs;xøÜnEmnb¤? GtItRKÚbeRgónmñak;)anxSwbdak;Rtecok´

enAtampøÚvEdlnaMKat;mkpÞHvijfa ³ «´P½yxøac faBYkeK¬evotNam¦seRmccitþsßitenATIenH edIm,I

suIGgárrbs;eyIg».

evotNamBMu)aneFVIGVIedIm,I[skþismeTAnwgCMenOTukcitþrbs;RbCaCnkm<úCaeLIy. kñúgry³bIEx

bnÞab;BIkarmkdl;rbs;xøÜn evotNam)anrukerIbMpøajeTAtam«Tmøab;»enAkñúgrdæFanI. k,ÜnrfynþkamIj:úg

CaeRcIneRKÓgEdlpÞúkeBjeTAedayTUTwkkk m:asuInRtCak; eRKÓgsmÖarGKÁisnI eRKÓgsgðarim m:asuIn

RKb;RbePT nigrUbcmøak;d¾mantémøy:ageRcIn)anebIktRmg;eq<aHeTATIRkúghUCImij. vtßúEdlRbmUlsnSM

TaMgGs;enHRtÚv)ane)aHbg;ecalenAqñaM1975 edayRbCaBlrdæTIRkúgPñMeBj enAeBlEdlBYkeKRtÚv

beNþjecjy:ageXareXA ehIyExµrRkhmEdleBareBjeTAedaykaremIlgaycMeBaHnimitþrUbén

karcuHGab;»nrbs;vNѳKhbtI )anTukecaledayKµanGñkNab:HBal;eLIy. eTaHCa«CyPNлTaMgenH

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 411

Page 422: Brother enemy

EdlnaMykBIRkúgPñMeBjCYybMeBjXøaMgRBTüsm,tþirbs;RkúghaNUy)anmYycMnYntUck¾eday k¾BYkeK

)anbnSl;TuknUvsøaksñamy:ageRCAkñúgcitþKMnitrbs;RbCaCnExµr ehIyeFVI[buernicä½y¬KMnitEdleK

Rbkan;ykCaeRscedayKµanRtiHriHBicarNa¦ EdlbgðajnUvPaBCasRtÚvrbs;RbCaCnExµrcMeBaHBYk

yYnmanrwtEtxøaMgeLIgEfmeTot. TnÞwmnwgenaH evotNam)ankøayeTACa«GñkEdlRbCaCnElgsUvman

CMenO»kñúgtYnaTICa«GñkrMedaH»RbeTskm<úCaEdr.

enAeBlEdl´¬GñkniBn§¦mkdl;TIRkúgPñMeBjenAExkkáda qñaM1979 ´)aneXIjTIRkúgexµacmYy

EdlpøÚvcUlTIRkúgRtÚvbiTmin[mnusSecjcUleLIy elIkElgEtGñkkøahanCaGtItGñkFøab;rs;enA

TIRkúgEdlrg;caMkñúgCMrMTaMgLayEdlbegáIteLIgedayKµanRBagTukCamun enAtambrievNxageRkArdæFanI

b:ueNÑaHeTIbh‘aneFVIdMeNIrcUl. GñkTaMgLayEdllYceRCótcUleTAdl;kñúgRkúgPñMeBj )anedIrRkEvl

cuHRkEvleLIg edIm,IEsVgrkvtßúmYycMnYnEdleKGacykmkeRbIeLIgvij)an. edayeFVIdMeNIrcuHtam

mhavifIRBHmunIvgS ´Gacsþab;B¤sMeLgxÞrKYr[xøacénCMhaneCIgpÞal;rbs;´. sgáat;CMnYjrbs;cin

EdlkalBIedImmansPaBrs;revIkenaHhak;dUcCaRtÚvrgeRKaHBImhavinaskmµmYy. eKhdæannighag

lk;TMnijnana)anRtÚverIbMpøajexÞcxÞIKµansl;. ERK tu TU ekAGI Edl)ak;EbknigsMNl;eRKÓgeRbIR)as;

kñúgc®gÁan)ayenArayedrdastamRTÚgfñl;RKbeBjeTAedaysMLIKesIm² EdlFøayecjmkBIBUk

nigexñIyedaysareKvHrkmas nigeRKÓgGlgáarmantémø. enHCasBaØafa BYkecarlYc)ancUlrukerI

RKb;pÞHTaMgGs;.

evotNamBMuTukcitþelIkardYlrlMd¾KMhukmYyrbs;clnats‘UExµrRkhmeT. BYkeKminR)afña

karBarCamunnUvGVIEdlBYkeKrkeXIjenAxagkñúgRbeTseLIy. karCMTas;R)akdRbCarbs;GnþrCati

EdlBYkeKRtÚvRbQmmuxhak;dUcCaCYykan;eCIgBYkeKedaymindwgxøÜn. km<úCaRbCaFibetyüBMuRtwmEt

CaRbeTsmYyEdlKµanR)ak;kas KµanTIpSar KµanRbBn§½éRbsNIy_ Kµansalaeronb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþKW

CakEnøgmYyEdlmanKMnrq¥wgexµacnigreNþAsaksBy:agsem,Im. karGt;Xøan)anKMramkMEhgGñkEdl

rs;ranmanCIvity:agxøaMg ehIyeRkABIGbGry:agekøóvkøaenAeBl)anedjkm©at;rbbmYyEdlBiPBelak

TaMgmUlefáaleTasCaskl RbeTsevotNamk¾RtÚvrgTTYlkarTieton nigkarbenÞasBIsMNak;Gnþr

CatipgEdr.

bkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_km<úCaEdlerobcMeLIgTaMgRbjab;Rbjal;kñúgGMLúgeBléndMeNIreq<aHmk

RkúgPñMeBjrbs;kgT½BevotNam tamRTwsþIRtÚvEtr:ab;rgbegáItrdæaPi)alrbs;RbeTsCatiEfmeTot.

b:uEnþsmaCik200nak;rbs;bkSnigBYknireTsxøÜnmYykþab;tUcRBmTaMgGñkEbkKMnitRbqaMgExµrRkhm

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg412

Page 423: Brother enemy

EdlKµanbTBiesaFn_ ehIyEdlrYmbegáItCaRkúmRbwkSabdivtþn_enaHBMumansmtßPaBRKb;RKan;nwgbMeBj

Parkic©Edlrg;caMBYkeKeT ³ eFVI[RbCaCatirs;eLIgvij nigpþl;[RbCaCnEdlegIbBIsubinGaRkk;nUv

CIvPaBmYyRbhak;RbEhlBImun. mü:ageTot BYkeKBMuGacsgÇwmkarBarrbbfµIEtmñak;ÉgRbqaMg

Tl;nwgkgT½Brbs;ExµrRkhm)aneLIy. karbM)at;bNþasmaCikGñkmanviC¢aCIv³esrI nigkarraErkmin

beRmIrbbkumµúynIsþmYyeTotrbs;GñkEdlrYcputBIeRKaHfñak; )aneFVI[karsþarRbeTseLIgvijCYbkar

lM)akrwtEtxøaMgeLIg.

m®nþIrdækarnigGñkbec©keTsevotNamrab;Ban;nak; RtÚv)anekNÐRbmUledIm,IerobcMsþarRbB½n§Twk

nigGKÁisnI CYsCulpøÚvreTHePøIg[mandMeNIrkareLIgvij nigebIk»sfal½yCaeRcInkEnøg Edlman

RKÚeBTünigKilanubdæakevotNamCaeRcInnak;enAeFVIkarCamYyRKÚeBTüExµrmYykþab;tUc. eK)anbegáIt

TIsþIkarRksYgnanaedaymansuT§EtTIRbwkSaevotNamCaGñkcaMjak;ExSBIxageRkayqak. CnCatiExµr

rab;rynak;RtÚv)anbBa¢ÚneTAkan;RbeTsevotNam edIm,IbnþkarbNþúHbNþalEfmeTotxagEpñkevC¢sa®sþ

sikSaFikar FnaKar BaNiC¢kmµGnþrCatinigsnþisux.

R)ak;kasRtÚv)andak;[eRbICafµIenAkm<úCakñúgqñaM1980 bnÞab;BIry³kalmYyEdlCMnYjtUctac

RbRBwtþeTAelImUldæanénkaredaHdUrKñarvagGgárnigmas. edaysarkarrt;Bn§mYyEdlmanlkçN³

FMeFgenAtamRBMEdnéf TIpSarnanarbs;km<úCaRtÚv)anbMeBjedayeRKÓgsmÖar³caM)ac;CaeRKÓg

]bePaK-briePaKCafµI. CMnYyGnþrCatid¾sn§wksn§ab;)anbeBa©óseRKaHTurÖikS. kumarakumarIkm<úCa)an

eFVIdMeNIrcUlsalaeroneLIgvij. eKk¾eXIjmanfñaMeBTüCaeRcInmuxenAtammnÞIreBTünana. dMeNIrrs;

eLIgvijenAkm<úCa dUcEdl´¬GñkniBn§¦)ansmÁal;eXIjkñúgry³eBlR)aMmYyqñaMKWTukfaCaGBÖÚtehtu

mYy. enHeRbóbdUcCastVehVnic¬phénix¦-bkSImü:agkñúgerOgeRBgEdleKdutrMlayehIyGacrs;eLIg

vij)an- km<úCa)anrs;eLIgvijBIepHpg;rbs;xøÜn. evotNam)anpþl;[km<úCanUvehdæarcnasm<½n§

caM)ac;mYy ehIy)anTTYlKuNRbeyaCn_BICMnYyGnþrCatid¾sb,úrsmYyEfmeTot b:uEnþ munGVI²TaMgGs;

KWkmøaMgpøÚvcitþnigPaBsVitsVajkñúgkargarrbs;CnCatiExµrEdlRtÚvEteFVI[RbeTsCatixøÜnrs;eLIgvij.

vagayRsYlNas;edIm,IeFVI[RbeTskm<úCars;eLIgvij CagnaMmknUvdMeNaHRsaymYycMeBaH

bBaðaGnaKtneya)ayrbs;xøÜn. kñúgeBlEdlRbCaCnkm<úCaCab;rvl;nwgkic©karrbs;xøÜn edayxMRbwg

erobcMkarrs;enAeLIgvij RkúghaNUyk¾RbmUlpþMúkic©RbwgERbgTaMgGs;rbs;eKkñúgkarBRgwgkarRtÜtRta

rbs;xøÜnelIRbeTskm<úCatamry³rdæfµIrbs;Exµr rdæaPi)al nigbNþasßab½nbkSrbs;rbbenHEdr.

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 413

Page 424: Brother enemy

«ebIPñMeBjrlM éRBnKrk¾nwgrlayEdr>>>»

rdæFmµnuBaØfµImYyRtÚv)anGnum½tenAniTaXrdUvqñaM1981. bnÞab;mkKWkare)aHeqñateRCIserIs

smaCikrdæsPaCaticMnYn117rUb kñúgcMeNamebkçCn148rUb. ebkçCnQreQµaHTaMgenaHKW GtIt

ExµrRkhmb¤Exµr\sSr³ b:uEnþ k¾manbBaØvnþrYcputBIeRKaHfñak;énrbbEdlRtÚvedjecjBIGMNacpg )an

begáItkarRbmUlpþMúKñay:agKYr[q¶l;mYyehIykarrYbrYmKñaenHKWedaysarEtBYkeKmanKMnitRbqaMgnwgrbb

b:ul Bt dUcKñab:ueNÑaH. dUcEdlelak h‘un Esn rdæm®nþIRksYgkarbreTs)anbkRsayfa kare)aH

eqñatenH KWmaneKaledA«eRCIserIsmnusSBMuEmneRCIserIsmaK’aneya)aymYyeT. maK’aneya)ay

eyIg)aneRCIserIsrYcehIyedaybgðÚrQamrbs;eyIg»7. BitehIy GñkKaMRTrbbfµI)anTTYlsMeLg

eqñatKaMRTTaMgGs;Cag99PaKry.

bnÞab;BIkare)aHeqñat mhasnñi)atbkSmYy)anR)arB§eFVIeLIgkñúgExmkra qñaM1979 enAemmt;

Edlbgðaj[eXIjBIkarerobcMGgÁkarrbs;xøÜnCafµI. bkSfµIEdlRbsiT§nameLIgvijfa bkSRbCaCn

bdivtþn_km<úCanigmansmaCik800nak; tamBitKWCaRkúmfµImYyénEpñksñiT§evotNamrbs;bkSkumµúy

nIsþkm<úCaEdlRtÚvkm©at;esÞIrEtTaMgRsugeday b:ul Bt8. emdwknaMbkSenHCamnusSmuWgm:at;nigsÁm

kMRBwgmñak;eQµaH Eb:n suvNÑ CaExµr\sSr³nireTsxøÜnEdleTIbRtLb;BIRkúghaNUymkvij. bkSfµI

)annaMmkvijnUvÉkPaBRbCaCn\NÐÚcinEdl b:ul Bt manbMNgbMEbkbM)ak;. edaypÞúyBI b:ul Bt

EdlminTTYlsÁal;«cMNgCabgb¥Ún»nwgevotNam Eb:n suvNÑ )anTTYlsÁal;fa bkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_

km<úCanwgeFVI[RbéBNId¾éføføarbs;bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcinEdlbegáIteLIg eday hUCImij sßitesßrcIrkal

teTA. kic©RbwgERbgsMxan;bMputmYykñúgcMeNamkic©RbwgERbgsMxan;²rbs;evotNamenAkm<úCa sßitenA

Rtg;karBarbkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_km<úCa-ehIyCaBiesskarBarsmaCikfµI²rbs;bkSenH-RbqaMgnwg

eRKaHfñak;epSg²EdlBYkeKehAfa «Catiniymceg¥ótcg¥l;» nigkarb:unb:gedaHxøÜnBIsamKÁIPaBrbs;

\NÐÚcin. edIm,Ir:ab;rgBIPaBbrisuT§EpñkmenaKmviC¢arbs;bkSfµI TIRbwkSaevotNamCaeRcInnak;)anBinitü

BaküesñIsMucUlbkSenAfñak;PUmiPaK ehIyGñksMukEnøgeFVIkarsuT§EtRtÚvbBa¢ÚnCabnÞab;eTARbeTsevot

Nam edIm,IbMeBjkarsikSaxagEpñkneya)ay9.

karRtÜtRtaRbeTskm<úCaxagEpñkeyaFa KWCabnÞúkénGgÁPaBT½Belx4rbs;evotNamEdltam

FmµtaTTYlbnÞúkemIlxusRtÚvenAtambNþaextþénEdndIsNþTenøemKgÁRbeTsevotNamÉeNaH. TIsþIkar

RksYgkarBarRbeTsmYyRtÚv)anbegáIteLIg. kgBlFMrbs;ExµrcMnYnbI)aneRCIserIsmnusS[cUl

eFVIkgT½B10 ehIy)andak;BRgaycab;taMgBIqñaM1983 kñúgzan³CaT½BCMnYy. b:uEnþKWkgT½Brbs;

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg414

Page 425: Brother enemy

evotNamnigTahancMnYn180>000nak;rbs;]tþmesnIy_ eL DwkGaj; CaembBa¢akarGgÁPaBT½B

elx4 EdlCaGñkr:ab;rgkarkarBarrbbfµITaMgRsug.

kñúgsPaBlak;karN_ KWGgÁPaBbIrbs;evotNamCaGñkkþab;sPaBkarN_rbs;sarFarNrdæRbCa

manitkm<úCa-enHCaeQµaHrbs;rdæfµI. enAfñak;elIbMputKWRkúmGa-40(A-40) rYmmansmasPaBsuT§Et

GñkCMnajkarénKN³kmµaFikarmCÄimrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam sRmab;r:ab;rgTMnak;TMngrvagbkS

TaMgBIrnigpþl;karENnaMelIbBaðaFM²TaMgGs;. bnÞab;mkKWRkúmeb-68 (B-68) dwknaMeday Rtan; s‘n;)ac;

CasmaCikelxaFikardæanbkSkumµúynIsþevotNam nigrYmmansmasPaBsuT§EtGñkCMnajkarevotNam

fñak;GnþrkarI RtÚv)ancat;[eTAcUlrYmeFVIkargarGmRksYgnanarbs;km<úCaedayshkarKñaseRmceTA

elIbBaðaepSg²RbcaMéf¶. RkúmTIbIEdlmansuT§EtTIRbwkSaKWRkúmGa-50(A-50) CaGñkCYyxagEpñkrdæ

)alenARKb;extþ11.

enAfñak;extþnigtMbn;CnbTTaMgLay KWRtÚvRKb;RKgmYycMENkedayBYkTIRbwkSasuIvilEdlmkBI

bNþaextþCa«bgb¥Ún»enARbeTsevotNam. enAfñak;mUldæanKWRkúmBiessEdlecjmkBIkgT½Bevot

Nam nigEdldwknaMbBa¢aedayBYkGnuesnIy_ÉkCaGñkr:ab;rgmuxgarCaTIRbwkSa12.

cab;taMgBImankarQøanBannigkarkan;kab;RbeTskm<úCa evotNam)anriHrkmUlehtuRbesIr²

edayxøÜnÉgminQb; edIm,IbegáItsm<n§½PaB\NÐÚcinmYy. evotNam)anbegáItc,ab;mYyRbePTEdlmin

ecHERbpøas; tRmÚveTAtamPUmisa®sþ nigRbvtþisa®sþ. eKGacyl;FøúHnUvGtßbTd¾sMxan;mYyrbs;]tþm

esnIy_ eL DwkGaj; Edlniyayfa «kñúgGMLúgeBlCaeRcInstvtSr_mkehIy RbeTsTaMgbI Lav km<úCa

evotNam )anrYmsuxTukçkñúgsßanPaBmYydUcKña ³ sßanPaBCaGñkrgeRKaHBIGMeBIQøanBanrbs;kgT½Bskþi

PUmicin cRkBtþiniym nigkmøaMgRbtikiriyaGnþrCati». bMEbkbM)ak;RbeTsTaMgbIenHedayeRbIR)as;

RbeTsmYyCaQñan; edIm,IP¢ab;RbeTsmYyeTotCarNb ehIyenATIbMput P¢ab;RbeTsTaMgbICarNbEt

mþg «enHehIyCaeKalkarN_éns®gÁamQøanBanTaMgGs; EdlRbRBwtþeLIgedaykmøaMgxageRkARbqaMg

nwg]bTVIb\NÐÚcin». edayehtuenH karbegáIt«sm<½n§CayuT§sa®sþmYyrvagRbeTs\NÐÚcinTaMgbI

CaerOgcaM)ac;xanmin)ansRmab;karKg;vgS nigkarrIklUtlas;rbs;RbeTsnImYy² nig\NÐÚcinTaMg

mUl»13.

eK)anbgðajBITahanevotNamEdlkMBugsøab;eedaysarCMgWRKúncaj;enARbeTskm<úCa rbYs

nigdac;éddac;eCIgkñúgkarBYnsÞak;vayRbharrbs;ExµrRkhm nigrebobbkRsaylm¥itmYyGMBI«c,ab;»

enH. BYknayTahanrbs;eK)anbMPøWBImUlehtuénvtþmanrbs;xøÜnenARbeTsevotNamdUecñHfa «ebI

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 415

Page 426: Brother enemy

PñMeBjrlMéRBnKrk¾nwgrlayEdr. ebIeyIgRtÚvsøab;kñúgkarRbyuT§ KWsøab;enATIenH RbesIrCagsøab;

enARbeTsevotNam»14.

C½yCmñHEpñkeyaFa braC½yEpñkkarTUt

dMNak;kalCapøÚvkardMbUgkñúgkarcat;taMgsm<n§½PaB\NÐÚcinenH )anekItmanenAExmkra qñaM

1980. bNþardæm®nþIkarbreTsénRbeTsTaMgbIEdlrYmRbCMuenARkúgPñMeBj)anRbkasCasaFarN³

nUvPaBdUcKñaxagTsSn³sþIBIbBaðarbs;km<úCa nigbBaðaGnþrCatiepSg²eTot. taMgBIenaHmk EbbEpnén

sm½yRbCMuenH)anRbRBwtþeFVIeLIgvijBIrdgkñúgmYyqñaM ral;karRbCMumYyelIk²KWCa»kasbgðaj[

eXIjBIkarRbkan;ykCMhrcugeRkayrbs;RkúghaNUyEdlhak;dUcCaecjmkBIRkúm\NÐÚcinTaMgmUl.

dUecñH RkúghaNUy)aneFVI[tYnaTICaemdwknaMrbs;xøÜnenA\NÐÚcineTACapøÚvkarBRgwgPaBRsbc,ab;dl;rbb

rNbRkúgPñMeBj[rwtEtrwgmaMeLIg nigeFVI[mankarcab;GarmµN_fa sm½<n§fµIenHminGacERbRkLas;)an

eLIy. enAqñaM1980 RkúghaNUy)ancab;epþImBRgIkTsSn³bøúkBIrenAGasuIGaeKñy_ KW\NÐÚcinnigsma

KmGas‘anedaybM)at;KMnitEdlfa evotNamGacmannaTImYykñúgkarerobcMenHkñúgnaménkm<úCaCardæ

RTnab;mYy. egVón kUfac; rdæm®nþIRksYgkarbreTsevotNam)anEføgR)ab;elak siT§I saev:t suILa Ca

smPaKIéfrbs;Kat;fa «´BMuRtÚvkarfa RbeTsmYyénsmaKmGas‘ankøayeTACardæRTnab;mYyeLIy».

dUecñH «manEtelakcg;[RbeTsmYykñúgcMeNamRbeTsTaMgbIenA\NÐÚcineTACaRbeTsEtmYy?»15.

RkúghaNUyminRtwmEtEsVgrksnþisuxsRmab;bøúkneya)aymYyb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþk¾EsVgrkkar

eFVIsmahrNkmµxagEpñkesdækic©pgEdr kñúgeKalbMNg«EbgEckhtßBlkredayesµIPaBKña nigeRbI

R)as;RbPBFnFanmnusS nigFnFanFmµCatirbs;RbeTsTaMgbI[Gs;lT§PaB»16. cMeBaHRbeTsevot

NamEdlmanépÞdIdaMduHR)aMmYylanhiktasRmab;RbCaCn60lannak;enAqñaM1985 RbeTskm<úCa

EdlmanRbCaCnCit¬7lannak;¦ CamYyépÞdIdaMduHmYylanhiktaknøH nigtMbn;ensaT Edlsm,ÚreTA

edayRtIeRcInbMputenaH )ancab;epþImRbemIlemIlGnaKtEdlminGacminykcitþTukdak;)aneLIy17.

kñúgExSbnÞat;neya)ayEdlcab;epþImCamYykarcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØaLav-evotNam enAqñaM

1977 bNþaextþrbs;RbeTsLavnigkm<úCa)anRtÚveKkMNt;[eFVIsm<n§½emRtICamYy «bNþaextþCa

bgb¥Ún» enARbeTsevotNam. edayGnuelameTAtamkareFVIsm<½n§emRtIPaBenH BYkTIRbwkSa BYkCMnaj

karbec©keTs nigBYkRKÚeBTürbs;evotNam)anmkkan;bNþaextþCabgb¥ÚnenAkm<úCa nigenARbeTsLav

y:ageRcIn edImI,shkarkñúgKeRmagkartUc²edaycUlrYmkñúgkarbegáIt[manTMnak;TMngBiessrvag

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg416

Page 427: Brother enemy

RbeTsTaMgbIenA\NÐÚcin.

KN³kmµaFikaresdækic©rYmmYyrvagevotNam Lav km<úCa )anRtÚverobcMbegáItkñúgsnñisITkMBUl

mYyrvagRbeTsTaMgbIenA\NÐÚcinnaTIRkúgevogcnÞ½kñúgExkumÖ³ qñaM1983. KN³kmµaFikarenH Edlman

suT§Etrdæm®nþIesdækic© nigEpnkarRtÚvrYmRbCMuBIrdgkñúgmYyqñaM «edImI,begáInel,ÓnshRbtibtþikarEpñk

esdækic©nigkarsRmbsRmÜlEpnkarGPivDÆn_Cati»18. kñúgRbeTsnImYy²KN³kmµaFikarCatisRmab;

shRbtibtþikarEpñkvb,Fm’nigesdækic©RtÚvbegáIteLIg EdlBIdMbUgRtÚvmantYnaTIsRmab;BieRKaHb¤[

eyabl;b:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþRkúghaNUy)anbBa¢ak;[dwgPøamfa «eKalbMNgyUrGEgVgrbs;xøÜn KWbRgÜb

bRgÜmRbeTsTaMgbI nigeFVI[seRmcBitR)akdnUvsmahrNkmµxagEpñkesdækic©rbs;eK»19.

munrdæRbharqñaM1970 enARbeTskm<úCamanGaNikCnevotNamrs;enAcMnYn50muWnnak; ehIy

RtÚvsmøab;y:agrgÁalkñúgclnabM)at;Catisasn_evotNamedayrbb ln; nl; nigeRkaymkrbb b:ul

Bt b¤RtÚvbeNþjecjBIRbeTskm<úCaEtmþg. evotNam)anTajykTLðIkrN_enH edIm,Ibgðaj[

eXIjfa karvilRtLb;rbs;xøÜnBitCaRtwmRtÚv. kñúgzan³CaniKmCnfµI evotNamGacsEmþgtYnaTIKnøwH

mYytamkalkMNt;kñúgkareFVIsmahrNkmµEpñkesdækic©Edl)aneRKagrYcmkehIy. saracrmYyrbs;

RkúmRbwkSardæm®nþIcuHkalbriecäTEx]sPa qñaM1982 )anEcgc,as;fa RbCaCnevotNamEdlmkdl;

RbeTskm<úCataMgBIqñaM1979 ehIy«kMBugRbkbmuxrbrepSg²EdlrYmviPaKTanCYydl;kareFVI[man

nItism,TaeLIgvij nigdl;karGPivDÆn_Epñkesdækic© CaBiesskñúgvis½yksikmµ ensaT karplitGMbil

nigsib,kmµ» nwgRtÚvGnuBaØat[sßitenATIenHedIm,IbMeBjkargar20. ebITukCadwgfa karhUrCn;eCarKµan

GñkNaRtÜtRtarbs;evotNammkkñúgRbeTskm<úCaGacbgá[mansm¥b;CaRbéBNIrbs;RbCaCnExµr

RbqaMgRbeTsCitxagxøÜn nigbgá[manPaBtantwgxøH²k¾eday k¾evotNamBMuePøcfa mYyEpñkénRbCaCn

xøÜn)aneTACaGñksIuQñÜlenARbeTskm<úCa nigkan;kab;tMENgsMxan;kñúgesdækic©rbs;RbeTsenH EdlrYm

bgáCaGtßRbeyaCn_mYyminGacrMlg)an. Gñkbg¥ab;KuNUbkar³rbs;RkúghaNUy)anecaTRbkan;fa

)anGnuvtþneya)ay EdlKitTukCamunmYykñúgkardak;bBa©ÚlRbCaCnevotNam[mkrs;enAkm<úCa.

vaGacfaenHCadMeNIrmaneLIgvijnUvrUbPaBCaRbvtþisa®sþmYyEdleKdwgCayUrmkehIy ³ karEsVg

taMgTIenARbeTsepSgedayxøÜnÉgrbs;RbCaCnevotNameq<aHeTAakan;tMbn;epSg²EdlmanRbCaCn

tic. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday lT§plEdl)anmkKWkarBRgwgkarkan;kab;rbs;evotNamelIRbeTs

km<úCa[rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgeTot. enAqñaM1985 tamkarvaytémørbs;GñkRbCasa®sþelakxaglic

d¾eqñImmñak;)an[dwgfa manRbCaCnsIuvilevotNamcMnYnCag175>000nak;)anmktaMglMenAenA

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 417

Page 428: Brother enemy

RbeTskm<úCa ³ kñúgcMeNamenaHmanGtItGñkFøab;rs;enAkalBIedImBYkniKmCnfµIEdlKµandIFøI¬enA

evotNam¦ BYkGñkCMnYj nigTahanEdlrMsay[mkkan;CIvPaBCasuIvilvij21. karvaytémøepSg²

eTot QanrhUtdl;eTAGHGagfa man600>000nak;ÉeNaH22.

kñúgeBlEdlkgT½B nigBYkTIRbwkSasuIvilRbwgERbgBRgwgrbbfµIrbs;km<úCa RkúghaNUy)an

eRbIR)as;\T§iBlEpñkkarTUtTaMgGs;rbs;xøÜn edIm,IeFVI[mankarTTYlsÁal;CaGnþrCaticMeBaHsaFarNrdæ

RbCamanitkm<úCaEdr. karefáaleTasCaÉkcä½nÞcMeBaHkarcUleFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;evotNamnig kardak;

TNÐkmµEdlbgáeLIgedaykareFVIGnþraKmn_enH )aneFVI[karTTYlsÁal;PaBRsbc,ab;énrbbfµIkøayeTA

CaGaTiPaBdac;xatmYyénneya)aybreTsrbs;evotNam. kñúgeKaledAenH RkúghaNUycUlcitþ

epþatkarecaTRbkan;xagpøÚvsIlFm’nigRsbc,ab; RbqaMgnwgkm<úCaRbCaFibetyürbs; b:ul Bt CaCag

elIkeLIgBIKuNsm,tþirbs;rdæaPi)alEdlxøÜn)anelIkbnþúbeLIg.

bNþaRbeTsdMbUg²EdlTTYlsÁal;saFarNrdæRbCamanitkm<úCaCapøÚvkar KWsßitkñúgbøúksUevot

cMnYndb;mYyRbeTs nigGgÁkarsiñT§sUevotCaeRcInkñúgcMeNam88GgÁkarEdlmankñúgclnamincUlbkS

sm½<n§. bNþamitþPkþirbs;RkúghaNUyBMu)anseRmceCaKC½ykñúgkarbeNþjkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

ecjBIclnaenH)aneT b:uEnþ enATIbMputRbeTsevotNam)anseRmcbMbiTmat;ExµrRkhmmin[niyay

)anenAkñúgsnñisITmYy edaykareRbImeFüa)aykarTUty:agxøaMgkøa. kariyal½ysRmbsRmÜlrbs;

clnamincUlbkSsm½<n§ EdlrYmRbCMuenATIRkúgkULMúbU¬rdæFanIRbeTsRsIlgáa¦ naExmifuna qñaM1979 )an

bdiesFminyl;RBmtamBaküesñIsMurbs;evotNameLIy ³ dUecñHBMuEmn h‘un Esn rdæm®nþIkarbreTs

v½yekµgrbs;saFarNrdæRbCamanitkm<úCaeT EdlnwgRtÚvGgÁúyekAGIenaH b:uEnþKW eGog sarI CasmPaKI

rbs;Kat;énkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. b:uEnþ h‘un Esn TTYl)anlkçxNÐmYy KWKat;GacsßitenAkñúgsalRbCMu

)anEtBMumansiT§ieLIgniyayenAelIevTikaeLIy. elak hVIEdl ka®sþÚ emdwknaMfµIrbs;clnaenHKWCaGñk

bBa©b;erOg«ekAGI»km<úCaenAkñúgsm½yRbCMukMBUlénbNþaRbeTsmincUlbkSsm½<n§enATIRkúgLahav:an

naExkBaØa qñaM1979. exov sMpn RbFanrdæaPi)al EdlRtÚvedjecjBIGMNac )anTTYlTidæakar[

cUlRbeTsKuy)aCaFmµta b:uEnþ KN³RbtiPUrbs;Kat;RtÚv)aneKdak;[sRmakenAsNæaKarmYyman

cm¶ay30KILÚEm:RtBIvimansRmab;eFVIsnñisITedayKµanmeFüa)aydwkCBa¢ÚnsRmab;Tuk[KN³RbtiPU

Kat;eRbIR)as;eLIy. mü:ageTot eKBMupþl;b½NÑsmÁal; sRmab;Bak;Cab;nwgGavEdlRtÚvEtmanCacaM)ac;

xanmin)an edIm,ImansiT§icUleTAkñúgsalRbCMupgeT. ebIeTaHCamankarRbqaMgCMTas;BIbNþaKN³RbtiPU

énsmaKmGas‘ank¾eday k¾ekAGIrbs;km<úCa)anRtÚvRbkasdak;[enATMenrsin. exov sMpn enAEt

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg418

Page 429: Brother enemy

sßitenATIenaHCanic©.

enAGgÁkarshRbCaCati eKminGaceRbIR)as;kl])aydUcenaH)aneT ehIysiT§iev:tUmYyrbs;

sUevot k¾BMuRKb;RKan;raraMgkarTTYlsÁal;rdæNamYyedayGgÁkarGnþrCatienHEdr. kñúgsm½yRbCuMén

mhasnñi)atGgÁkarshRbCaCatienAExkBaØa qñaM1979 evotNam)anxMRbwgeFVI[mankarbeNþj

km<úCaRbCaFibetyüecjBIGgÁkarenHEdr b:uEnþKµan)aneCaKC½y. edayman 6 sMeLg-Edlman

sMeLgshrdæGaemrikEdr-Tl;nwg3 KN³kmµaFikarBinitüsartaMgrbs;GgÁkarshRbCaCati)an

seRmcrkSaTukekAGI[km<úCaRbCaFibetyüdEdl. dUecñH shrdæGaemrik)ane)aHeqñatCaKuN

RbeyaCn_dl;rbbmYy EdlkalBImunRtÚvelakRbFanaFibtI xaF½r [eQµaHfa «rbbEdlrMelaPsiT§i

mnusSFMCageKbMput» enAelIBiPBelakeTAvij. enHCakarseRmccitþEdleFVI[QWcab;mYysRmab;

v:an;s_. e)aHeqñatedIm,Ipþl;Gasn³[ b:ul Bt nwgminEmnsEmþg[eXIjnUvkarKaMRTmYycMeBaHrbb

enHeTb¤? ehIye)aHeqñatRbqaMgkm<úCaRbCaFibetyümann½yfa RbqaMgCMTas;cMeBaHRbeTscinnig

smaKmGas‘an ehIyeFVI[karQøanBanrbs;evotNameTACaRsbc,ab;eTAvij. eRkaymk GñkTTYl

xusRtÚvCan;x<s;GaemrikaMgmñak;)anTTYlsÁal;fa ³ «kareRCIserIssRmab;eyIgKW sMGagelIeKalkaN_

sIlFm’ nigc,ab;GnþrCati. karseRmccitþRtÚvlMeGogeTArkc,ab; BIeRBaHenHk¾CaplRbeyaCn_

sRmab;snþisuxeyIgEdr». b:uEnþtamry³kare)aHeqñatEdlRBhµlixittRmÚvenH KWshrdæGaemrik)an

KaMRTXatkrmYyRkúmEdlBYkm®nþIrdækarGaemrikaMgBMumansiT§icab;rlak;édBYkenHpgeT23.

enAéf¶TI21 ExkBaØa qñaM1979 mhasnñi)aténGgÁkarshRbCaCati)ane)aHeqñatGnum½t

r)aykarN_rbs;KN³kmµaFikarBinitüsartaMgeday 71sMeLgyl;RBm 35sMeLgRbqaMg nig34

sMeLgGnubvaT. enAelIkRmalBN’ébtgnigBN’masénTIsñak;karGgÁkarshRbCaCati Edlkarvay

lukxageyaFarbs;RbeTsevotNamRbqaMgkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü RbEhlCabraC½yenATIbMput. rbb

b:ul Bt RbEhlenAmanEtRkúmkgT½BtUc²EdlRTaMRTlM)akenAkñúgéRBb:ueNÑaH ³ ehIyk¾RbEhlCa

ElgRtÚv)aneRCIstaMgCatMNagRsbc,ab;rbs;RbCaCnkm<úCaeTotEdr. taMgBIkare)aHeqñatenHmk

karts‘UedIm,IRtÜtRtaRbeTskm<úCa )anecjBIéRBs,atenAtamRBMEdnExµr-éfmksMEdgenAeRkamBitan

d¾l¥eqIténmhasnñi)atGgÁkarshRbCaCatienATIRkúgjÚvy:k sgáat; m:an;hatan; kñúgry³eBlBIr-bI

s)þah_ erogral;srTrdUv.

karCECktTl;KñaenAGgÁkarshRbCaCati edIm,I[mankardkT½Brbs;evotNamnigedIm,Ipþl;

siT§isV½yseRmc[RbCaCnExµr )anbgá[mankarBYtédKñad¾cEmøkmYy ³ RbCaCatiCagmYyryRbeTs

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 419

Page 430: Brother enemy

)anGHGagnUvkarKaMRTrbs;xøÜncMeBaHExµrRkhmCanic© EdlRbeTsCaeRcInenAkñúgcMeNamenaH enAEt

efáaleTas nigbnþefáaleTasdEdl. karN_EdlfaGgÁkarshRbCaCaticecsTTYlsÁal;km<úCaRbCa

Fibetyü bNþal[EpñkkarTUtrbs;evotNamÉekaBIeK. briyakasmanlkçN³GnueRKaHdl;kardak;

TNÐkmµelIRbeTsevotNam nigkarvaysRmúktbtedayeyaFarbs;cin.

karKn;KUrrbs;cin«emeron »EpñkeyaFaEdlRbeTscinpþl;[RbeTsevotNamenAExkumÖ³ qñaM1979 BMueFVI[

b:HBal;dl;karebþCJacitþkñúgkarsßitenARbeTskm<úCarbs;RkúghaNUyeLIy. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday

k¾Rkúgeb:kaMgeCOR)akdkñúgcitþfa edayeFVIkarKabsgát;EpñkeyaFaeBjTMhwg¬enAtamRBMEdncin-evot

NamnigenARbeTskm<úCa¦ kareFVI[EpñkkarTUtÉekanigkardak;TNÐkmµEpñkesdækic©BIGnþrCati enATIbMput

RkúghaNUyc,as;CaRtÚvkarsnþiPaBminxan. eKaledArbs;RbeTscinKWelIksm<½n§mitþ ExµrRkhmrbs;

xøÜn[kan;GMNacvij ebITukCaBYkenHElgmanGVIEdlBYkeKRtÚvmanTaMgRsugk¾eday. eKaledARbEhl

manlkçN³R)akdniymtictYckñúgry³eBlxøI b:uEnþKMniténkarRbyuT§mYytamry³karRbKl;siT§iRbqaMg

nwgRbeTsevotNam BitCaTak;TgKñaCamYynwgeKaledAepSg²ry³eBlmFüménneya)aykarbreTs

rbs;cin. karcUlQøanBanRbeTsGahVhÁanIsßan (Afghanistan) edayBYksUevotenAExFñÚ qñaM1979

)aneFVI[karRbqaMgsUevotrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgekInrwtEteTVeLIg. cab;BIeBlenaHeTA RbeTscinGacRbkan;

yktYnaTI¬EdlxøÜnminRtÚvman¦CaeCIgÉkénÉkraCüPaBnigGFibetyüPaBsRmab;RbeTstUcTaMgBIr

nigCaGñkriHKn;dl;GnutþrPaBrbs;sUevotniglT§ivatTIniymrbs;evotNampg. edaymanmUlehtu

RtwmRtÚv RbeTscinsgÇwmeTAelIkarKaMRTrbs;elakxagliccMeBaHkmµviFI TMenIbPavUbnIykmµrbs;xøÜn

minxan.

edayminbBa¢ak;BIerOgenH RbeTscinP½yxøacy:agxøaMgGMBIerOgEdlfa dMeNaHRsayqab;rh½s

énbBaðakm<úCanwgpþl;plcMeNjelIslb;dl;RkúghaNUy dUecñHehIy cineBjcitþTuk[erOgenH

bnøayeBlteTAeTot. kareFVI[rdæaPi)alsiñT§evotNammYyenARkúgPñMeBjmanlkçN³Rsbc,ab; nig

karBRgwgbøúk\NÐÚcineRkamkardwknaMrbs;RkúghaNUy )anbNþal[Rkúgeb:kaMg)at;bg;\T§iBlrbs;

xøÜnkñúgtMbn;. karedaHRsayCemøaH nigkarbegáItTMnak;TMngd¾l¥RbesIrrvagRkúghaNUynigsmaKm

Gas‘an k¾nwgeFVI[TMnak;TMngd¾lM)akEdlRkúgeb:kaMg)ancab;epþImeFVICamYysmaKmenHRtÚvGnþray

pgEdr ³ \T§iBlEdlevotNamerobcM[maneLIgy:agl¥enA\NÐÚcin RbEhlnwgbNþal[RbeTséf

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg420

Page 431: Brother enemy

minsUvsEmþg[eXIjlkçN³shRbtibtiþkarb:unµaneLIy. bNþaRbeTsepSgeToténsmaKm Gas‘an

CaBiessRbeTs\NÐÚensuInigm:aeLsuIEdlkMBugBicarNacMeBaHGaNikCncinkñúgRbeTsrbs;xøÜnCamYy

karminTukcitþnigkMBugRBWxøaclT§ivatTIniymrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgenaH nwgeFVIkarCamYyRbeTscinedayRbúg

Rby½tñbMput. pÞúyeTAvij kareFVI[CemøaHmYyenAsßitesßryUrGEgVgEdlRbeTsevotNamnigshPaB

sUevotRtÚvRbQmmuxnwgRbeTsepSg²énBiPBelak bgðaj[eXIjGtßRbeyaCn_mYyEdlminGac

kat;éfø[RtÚv)an eRBaHvaeFVI[RbPBFnFanrbs;shPaBsUevotxUcxatGnþraynigeFVI[RbeTsevot

NamexSaHrIgér. CasaFarN³ RbeTscintRmÚv[RbeTsevotNamdkkgT½Brbs;xøÜnecjBIkmú<Ca

b:uEnþkñúgkarcrcad¾esµaHRtg;xusEbøkBIFmµtamYy etg s‘avBIg )ansþIbenÞaselak m:asay:UQI GUhuIr:a

naykrdæm®nþICb:unBIkarxVHGMNt;rbs;RbeTselak RBmTaMgRbeTselakxaglicdéTeTotEdlTamTar

[mankardkkgT½BevotNamqab;rh½sBIkm<úCa. etg )anR)ab;erOgGaf’kM)aMg[ GUhuIr:a dwgfa «RbeTs

cinmanplRbeyaCn_TaMgRsugkñúgkarxMRbwgERbgeFVI[evotNamsßitenARbeTskm<úCateTAeTot. kar

lM)akepSg²rbs;BYkeKnwgekIneLIg ehIyBYkeKnwgElgmanbMNgKMramkMEhgeTAelIRbeTséf

m:aeLsuI nigsigðburIeTotpg»24.

kñúg»kasénkareFVIsmÖasn_mYy EdlKat;)anGnuBaØat[´¬GñkniBn§¦cUlCYbnaExemsa qñaM

1980 han nanLúg Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs nigCaGñkbegáItyuT§sa®sþ\NÐÚcind¾cm,grbs;RbeTscin

)anBRgIkkarsMGagehtupledayBaküeBcn_epSg²eTAvij. karesñI[evotNamdkkgT½Brbs;xøÜn

ecjBIRbeTskm<úCa KWminsUvmanlkçN³R)akdniymb:unµaneT. «eKGacKitKUrBIdMeNaHRsayneya

)aymYy)anEtenAeBlEdlBYksUevotElgGacKaMRTevotNamb:ueNÑaH». sRmab;eBlenH eyIgmin

RtÚveFIVGIVEdlGac«sRmalbnÞúkd¾F¶n;rbs;BYksUevoteLIy». «eyIgRtÚvEteFVI[sUevotyl;fa BYkeK

nwgBMuGacbnþRTaMRTrebobenHyUreTAeTot)aneT ehIyeyIgxMRbmUlsaFarNmtiBiPBelak[cUlrYmkñúg

n½yenHEdr. vasMxan;Nas;EdlRtÚveFVI[sUevotsßitkñúgsßanPaBenAdac;BIeKÉgTaMgRsug»25.

karvivaTcinnigevotNam)ankeRmIkeLIgvijCafµIeBjry³eBlénrdUvekþAqñaM1979. enAeBl

enaH RbeTscin)ancab;epþImerobcMclnats‘UmYyRbqaMgevotNam edayRbmUlpþMúEtGñkExVgmti nigGñk

EbkbkSBYkenA\NÐÚcinb:ueNÑaH. m®nþIfñak;kNþalrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam nigLav RbmaNCag

db;nak;)aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMg. edaymanCMnYyBIRbeTséf GñkePosxøÜn EdlmankMeNItBI

bNþakulsm<½n§enARbeTsLav RtÚv)anepÞrbBa¢ÚneTARbeTscinvijtamynþehaH. kñúgeBlCamYyKña

enaH h½n v:an;hn bgb¥ÚnrYmGavuFrbs;hUCImij nigCaGtItsmaCikkariyal½yneya)ay)aneFIV

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 421

Page 432: Brother enemy

dMeNIreTARbeTscinEdr EdleFVI[eKcab;GarmµN_y:agxøaMg. enAExkkáda Kat;RtÚveFVIdMeNIreTATIRkúg

Eb‘rLaMgxagekIteTot [kalenaHCardæFanIrbs;saFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüGaløWm:g;. bc©úb,nñCardæFanI

rbs;shB½n§GaløWm:g; eRkayBI)anbRgÜbbRgÜmCaRbeTsEtmYy] edaysarmUlehtusuxPaB nig)an

Qb;sMctmYyry³xøIenATIRkúgkar:aCI RbeTs):aKIsßan. enATIenaHburscMNas;Gayu76qñaMrUbenH

t¥ÚjEt¥rfa QWedImRTÚg. BYkbuKÁlikbeRmIkargar):aKIsßan)anykKat;ecjBIbnÞb;rg;caMCabnÞan; edIm,I

ykeTAmnÞIreBTüBinitüsuxPaB. munkarehaHeLIgrbs;ynþehaH GgÁrkSrbs; h½n EdlCaGñkman

ninñakarneya)aydUcKñaEdrenaH )ansmÁal; eXIjfabuKÁlikRbcaMGakasyandæanmindwgfa h½n

sßitenAkEnøgNaeLIy. mYyExeRkaymk Kat;)anelcmuxCafµIenATIRkúgeb:kaMg ehIy)anecaTRbkan;

«eL yn; nigbnrbs;Kat;»falk;RbeTsevotNameTA[RkúgmUsÁÚ. h½n TamTar[man«karbdivtþn_TIBIr»

mYykñúgRbeTsKat;EfmeTot. RsbeBlCamYyKñaenaH BYkcin)anbegáItmCÄmNÐlhVwkhat;CaeRcIn

kEnøgsRmab;Gñk EbkbkSBYksBa¢atievotNamnigLav RBmTaMgCnCatiPaKticnanapg. BYkeKcab;epþIm

KaMRTbNþaclnakgT½BéRBRbqaMgkumµúynIsþEdlvayRbyuT§Tl;nwgbNþardæaPi)alenA\NÐÚcin EdlkMBug

kan;GMNacpg 26.

GñkÉkeTsmñak;xagbBaðacinenARksYgkarbreTsGaemrikaMg)ankt;smÁal;fa «BYkcinminRKan;Et

pþl;emeronmYyb¤BIr[evotNamb:ueNÑaHeT KWBYkeKpþl;karbeRgónTaMgmUlmYyEtmþg» edayeRbIkar

Kabsgát;\tQb;QreTAelIRbeTsLavnigkm<úCa nigraraMgGñkEdlpþl;mUlniFimin[CYyevotNam

nigbgçM[evotNamerobcMesdækic©rbs;xøÜnCarebobeyaFaEfmeTot. tameyabl;GñkÉkeTsenaHfa

«karbeRgón»nwgmanry³eBlBIbIeTAR)aMqñaM b:uEnþ «eKmindwgBIRbePTénBiFIRbKl;rgVan;EdleRKagTuk

CamunedayBYkcineT»27.

EbbbTénRBwtþikarN_epSg²enARbeTskm<úCa )aneFVI[sm<n§½PaBepSg²kñúgtMbn;ERbRbÜl.

sRmab;Rkúg)agkkyl;fa eRKaHGaRkk;énkarcUlkan;kab;RbeTskm<úCa KWCarebobsEmþgsm½yfµIén

liT§ivatTIniymrbs;snþtivgS egVón enAedImstvtSr_TI19. karmkdl;\NÐÚcinrbs;BYk)araMg)an

bBa©b;CabeNþaHGasnñnUvkarRbkYtRbECgKñarvagRbeTséfnigevotNam edIm,IdeNþImkarRtÜtRtaelI

]bTVIbenH. karRbkYtRbECgenH)anEsþg[eXIjCaBiesscab;BIstvtSr_TI17mk enAeBlEdl

RbeTsTaMgBIr¬éfnigevotNam¦ sakl,grkSakarRKb;RKgelIRBHraCaNacRkRTnab;TaMgBIr Lavnig

km<úCa nigeFVI[Tn;exSayeTAvijeTAmk. eRkayBImankic©RBmeRBógRkúghSWENv RbeTséf)aneFVIGVI²

TaMgGs; edIm,IbMpøajRbeTsevotNamkumµúynIsþ ³ RbeTséf)ancUlrYmkñúg«s®gÁamsm¶at;»Edl

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg422

Page 433: Brother enemy

erobcMedayRkúmes>GuI>Ga>enARbeTsLav KaMRTclnaExµresrIRbqaMgkumµúynIsþenARbeTskm<úCa nig

bBa¢ÚnkgT½BeTACYyc,aMgenAevotNamxagt,Úg. CafñÚrmkvij RkúghaNUy)anKaMRTBYk]TÞamkumµúynIsþ

rbs;éfEdr. karRbwgERbgTaMgGs;enHKµan)anplRbeyaCn_GVITaMgGs;. C½yCmñHrbs;BYkkumµúynIsþ

enARbeTsLavkñúgqñaM1975 kgT½BRbEhl50>000nak;rbs;evotNam)ane)aHT½BCaRbcaMenA

TIenaH ehIyTIbMput karcUllukluyRbeTskm<úCa)anbM)at;ecal«EdndIRKb;RKan;sRmab;ciBa© wm

RbCaCn ¬Espace Vital¦» rbs;xøÜnEdlRbeTséfxMRbyuT§taMgBIstvtSr_TI17em:øH. Rkúg)agkkBMueRtóm

TTYlxøÜne)aHbg;eLIy. kalBImun RbeTséfFøab;)aneFVIRbtikmµedaybBa¢ÚnkgT½Brbs;xøÜneTAvay

RbyuT§nwgevotNamenARbeTskm<úCa. karedaHRsayrebobenHElgykmkeRbI)aneTotehIy. enA

kñúgGMLúgeBlénkarBiPakSaGMBIyuT§sa®sþd¾BuHkeRBa¢almYyenAedImqñaM1979 naykrdæm®nþIéf eRKóg

sak; )anRbqaMgCMTas;nwgkarcUleFVIGnþraKmn_edaypÞal;TaMgGs;. Kat;sYrfa ³ «kñúgnamGñkNa? kñúg

namExµrRkhmb¤?». b:uEnþ karrwgTTwgy:agcecsrbs;ExµrRkhm nigkarebþCJacitþrbs;RbeTscin

RbqaMgnwgRbeTsevotNam)anbgðaj[RbeTséfeXIjfa cinenAEtCakmøaMgd¾manGMNacdEdl

edImI,eFVI[]tþmPaBrbs;evotNamRtÚvbraC½y. GñkyuT§sa®sþcinGHGagfa edaymineFVIGVITaMgGs;

vanwgeFVI[smta kmøaMgkñúgPUmiPaKGasuIGaeKñy_EdneKakpøas;bþÚrTaMgRsug. RbeTsevotNamnwg

mkdl;mat;TVarRbeTséf karbMpøicbMpøajGacnwgeFVI)antamcitþ ehIyenATIbMputevotNamGacdak;

RbeTsenH[sßitenAeRkamGMNacrbs;xøÜneTot. tameyabl;rbs;GñkyuT§sa®sþéfmñak;fa RbeTs

km<úCaElgCardæRTnab;mYyehIy CakarRbesIrGVIEdlRtÚveFVIKWKaMRTkarts‘Urbs;ExµrminEmnkumµúynIsþ

EdlbgáCaRTnab;mYyedayxøÜnÉgpÞal; 28.

Rkúgv:asuInetane)aHbg;smaKmGas‘an

edayBit sm½<n§PaBrvagrdæaPi)alRkúgeb:kaMgnigRkúg)agkk )annaMeTAdl;karebIk[man«kar

cab;epþImmYysRmab; etg s‘avBIg» enARbeTséf edaydak;bBa©Úlkarcab;epþImenHCacMNucsMxan;énkar

eRtómbRmúgCayuT§sa®sþrbs;cinpg. GaRs½yedaykarerobcMCasm¶at;epSg² navarbs;cinCaeRcIn

eRKÓg)anerIdak;enAkMBg;Ep sat;tahuIb nigxøgéy: nUvsBVavuFRKb;RbePT RBmTaMgRKab;rMesvCaeRcIn

etan EdlkgT½Brbs;éfRtÚvdwkCBa¢ÚnrhUtdl;CMrMnanarbs;ExµrRkhm ehIyeRkaymk rhUtdl;clna

ts‘UminEmnkumµúynIsþCaeRcInRkúmenAtambeNþayRBMEdnExµr-éfpgEdr. sßanTUtcinRbcaMRkúg)agkk

EdlCYyeRCamERCgedayGñkCMnYjcinkat;éf nigedaykgT½BPUminÞéf)anTTYlr:ab;rgeFVICaGñkpÁt;pÁg;

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 423

Page 434: Brother enemy

es,ógGahar fñaMeBTü nigeRKÓgeRbIR)as;caM)ac;EpñksIuvileTA[kgT½BExµrRkhmeTot. Rkúgeb:kaMg

)anbg;Bn§sRmab;siT§iqøgkat;mYyeTA[kgT½Brbs;éf ehIymü:ageTot k¾beNþay[kgT½Béfdk

sBVavuFTaMgenHmYyEpñkEdr. edayGnuelamtamkic©RBmeRBógmYyepSgeTot RbeTscin)anpþl;

bec©kviC¢acaM)ac;mYycMnYnsRmab;karplitGavuFRbqaMgrfeRkaHrYmKñakñúgeragcRkplitGavuFmYyrbs;

éfkñúglkçxNÐfa mYyEpñkénplitplenHRtÚvbRmúgTuksRmab;ExµrRkhmpg.

karerobcMCasm¶at;TaMgenH bgðaj[eXIjnUvPaBécdnüd¾l¥sRmab;Rkúmh‘undwkCBa¢Únrbs;éf

EdlRKb;RKgedaykgT½BrkcMNUl)any:ageRcIneRBaHfa Rkúmh‘unenH)ancuHdundabtaMgBImankarbiT

mUldæannanarbs;GaemrikaMgEdlmanenAelITwkdIéfemø:H. enHk¾Ca»kasrkkéRmxusc,ab;Edr sRmab;

nayTahanxøHrbs;éfedaysar «c,ab;» tRmÚv[sRmab;karRbKl;sBVavuFrbs;cin29.

taMgBIcugqñaM1979 kgT½Brbs; b:ul Bt EdlRtÚveFVI[køayeTACaRkúmmnusSetaky:ak ehIy

EdlkMBugQWcab;edayCMgWRKúncaj;nigkarxVHes,ógGahar)anrkeXIjfamBlfµImYyeLIgvij eday

sarCMnYysb,úrsrbs;BYkcin. bnÞab;BIkarlukluyrbs;evotNam kgT½BExµrRkhmmanenAsl;

RbmaNdb;BIrkgBlFMb:ueNÑaHEdlenArat;rayBaseBjRbeTs edayKµankarTak;TgrvagKñanwgKña

ehIyCajwkjyKµankarTak;TgCamYynwgbBa¢akardæanpÞal;rbs;xøÜnpgeT. ExµrRkhm)anrs;eLIgvij

edaysarCMnYyrbs;GnþrCati nigkarbMBak;yuT§abkrN_CafµIedaykarpÁt;pÁg;GavuFrbs;cin. enAcugqñaM

1980 eK)anvaytémøfa cMnYnT½Brbs;ExµrRkhm)aneLIgBI2muWnrhUtdl;4mWunnak;30.

esnaFikardæanrbs;ExµrRkhmmanTItaMgsßitenAEtBIrb¤bIKILÚEm:Rtb:ueNÑaHBIRBMEdnéf b:uEnþ kg

kumµ:g;dUCaeRcInRkúmmanKñaBIdb;eTAdb;BIrnak;RtÚv)anbBa¢ÚncUlmképÞkñúgRbeTs edIm,IeFVIkarBYnsÞak;vay

Rbhar dak;mIntampøÚvfñl;nigbMpøicbMpøajs<an. enAcugqñaM1981 s®gÁamT½BéRBenAkm<úCamansPaB

rwtEtxøaMgeLIg² EdlbNþal[maneRKaHfñak;dl;tMbn;mYyPaKy:agFMrbs;RbeTs.

b:uEnþkarrYbrYmkmøaMgKñaRbqaMgRkúghaNUyEdleTIbnwgcab;kMeNIt hak;dUcCaminsUvmanesckþI

sgÇwmb:unµaneTenAelIqakGnþrCati. R)akdNas; edaysarkic©RbwgERbgrYmKñarbs;shrdæGaemrik

smaKmGas‘annigRbeTscin ExµrRkhmenArkSa)anGasn³rbs;xøÜnenAGgÁkarshRbCaCatidEdl

b:uEnþkarKaMRTrbs;GnþrCati)anfycuHKYr[)armÖ. enAqñaM1980 evotNam)anebIkTVarRbeTskm<úCa

y:agFMsRmab;RbBn§½pSBVpSayB½t’manelakxaglicnana. taMgBIeBlenaHmk RkúmGñkykB½t’man nig

RkúmGñkftTUrTsSn_CaeRcInGaceFVIdMeNIrcuHeLIgedayesrIenAkñúgRbeTs GacniyayCamYyGñkEdl

enArs;ranmanCIvitBIvalBiXat GaceTATsSnareNþAq¥wgexµac nigKukTYlEsøgd¾l,Il,ajenARkúgPñMeBj

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg424

Page 435: Brother enemy

EdlenAkñúgKukenHcemøIysarPaBrab;Ban;TMB½rEdlKabcRmaj;ykBIGñkeTaseRkamkareFVITaruNkmµ

y:ageXareXAbMput nigrUbftCnrgeRKaHCaeRcIn )anbgðaj[eXIjBI«RbsiT§PaB»énm:asuInsmøab;

mnusSenAkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüBIqñaM1975dl;qñaM1978. bTykB½t’mannigExSPaBynþepSg²

EdlnaMeTAbgðajR)ab;eKÉgedayGñkkaEst )anbgá[mankars¥b;ex<ImTUTaMgBiPBelak ehIy)an

CMruj[RbeTsGg;eKøs nigGU®sþalI ElgTTYlsÁal;rbb b:ul Bt 31teTAeTot.

enAqñaM1980 rdæm®nþIRksYgkarbreTsfµIrbs;GaemrikaMgKWelak eGdm:un mWsÁI EdledIrtam

Gnusasn_rbs;Gñkkan;tMENgmunKat;KWelak v:an;s_ GMBIcMNucenH)aneBalGHGagfa RbeTsrbs;Kat;

mineRbIsiT§rbs;xøÜnkñúgkare)aHeqñat edIm,IeFVI[ b:ul Bt mannItism,TaeLIgvijenAGgÁkarshRbCa

CatieLIy. Kat;k¾rgTTYlnUvkarKabsgát;xøH²BIsMNak;RbeTscin nigBIbNþaÉkGKÁrdæTUtGaemrikaMg

RbcaMRbeTsnanaénsmaKmGas‘anpgEdr ehIyR)akdNas;BI Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI pÞal; EdlenATIbMput )an

seRmccitþGnuBaØat[Kat;e)aHeqñatCaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;km<úCaRbCaFibetyümþgeTot. BYkExµrRkhm

enAkan;kab;Gasn³rbs;xøÜndEdl. karbBa©úHbBa©ÚlEdleFVIeLIgedayshrdæGaemrik RbeTscin nig

smaKmGas‘an)anTTYlkarKaMRT97sMeLg cMeBaHesckþIseRmccitþrbs;xøÜnEdlTamTar[mankardk

kgT½Brbs;evotNamecjBIkm<úCa. ebITukCaTTYl)aneCaKC½yenHk¾eday k¾bNþaRbeTsénsmaKm

Gas‘andwgc,as;fa edIm,IkarBarGasn³km<úCaRbCaFibetyüenAGgÁkarshRbCaCati eKminRtwmEt

Eklm¥rUbPaBCa«pøaksBaØa»ExµrRkhm[)anRbesIrCagmunb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþCaBiessRtÚvBRgIkmUldæan

rbs;clnats‘URbqaMgevotNamEfmeTot. enAsrTrdUvqñaM1980 elak lI kVan;yU rdæm®nþITI1sigðburI

)anTTYlsÁal;CasaFarN³fa «edIm,IRbmUlnigrkSakarKaMRTBIBiPBminEmnkumµúynIsþ eKetagEtdak;

emdwknaMkm<úCamñak;EdlmankitüanuPaBCaGnþrCati[RKb;RKgkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü muneBlmhasnñi)at

rbs;GgÁkarshRbCaCatiebIkRbCMuenAqñaM1981»32.

eKetagEteRKagKitBIkarseRmccitþpøas;bþÚrmYyEfmeTot edayedjExµrRkhmecjEdl

Gas‘anminGacKaMRTteTAeTot. GñkkarTUtCan;x<s;mñak;rbs;éf)anniyayBIerOgenHeRkaymkfa ³

«caM)ac;GIeTAGenÞalGenÞakedIm,I[TTYl)andMeNaHRsayneya)aymYy ebIsmaKmGas‘anBMuman

dMeNaHRsaysRmab;CMnYspþl;[pgenaH?». enHehIyCaRbPBénKMnitkñúgkarbegáIt[mankarrYm

kmøaMgKñamYyrbs;ExµrRbqaMgkumµúynIsþenaH. muneBlEdlKMnitenHelcecjCarUbragbNþaGñk]btßm

KaMRTrbs;BYkeKetagEteFVIdMeNIrxVat;ExVgrab;Ban;KILÚEm:Rt nigerobcM[mankarCYbKñad¾keRkIkjab;j½r

rab;minGs;CamYybNþa\sSrCnExµrnigcinCaeRcInrUb.

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 425

Page 436: Brother enemy

Rkúgeb:kaMg)ansEmþg[eXIjnUvkarsb,ayrIkraybnþicbnþÜcb:ueNÑaH cMeBaHkarRbwgERbgTaMg

Layrbs;smaKmGas‘anEdlb:unb:gerobcMsnñisITGnþrCatimYyeRkamkar]btßmÖrbs;GgÁkarshRbCa

CatikñúgeKaledAEsVgrkdMeNaHRsayneya)aymYy. GVIEdlRbeTscincg;)anKWkarBarkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyü[enAmanlkçN³dEdl edaybegáItrNsirSrYbrYmRsbKñamYyQrelImUldæany:agTUlM

TUlaymYy edIm,Ibnþkarts‘UedayGavuFteTAeTot. RbeTscinnwk)armÖfa karbegáItrdæaPi)alcRmúH

mYyrbs;ExµrCamYy\sSrCnepSg²dUcCa semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu nigGtItnaykrdæm®nþIrbs;RBHGgÁ

sWn san EdlelIkeLIgedaysmaKmGas‘anenaHGaceFVI[\T§iBlrbs;ExµrRkhmrYmtUceTA². taMgBI

karyagRtLb;rbs;RBHGgÁeTARkúgeb:kaMgvijenAExkumÖ³ qñaM1979 TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs; semþc

sIhnu CamYyBYkm©as;pÞHrbs;RBHGgÁmansPaBsuxdumrmnanwgKñaNas;. BYkcin)anerobcM[RBHGgÁ

Kg;enAkñúgvimanmYyy:agFMCamYyGagEhlTwkxñatGULaMBik nigbnÞb;bBa©aMgExSPaBynþkñúgRKÜsarmYy

EdlmanTItaMgsßitenAcMkNþalebHdUgRkúgeb:kaMg. b:uEnþ etg BMuRbkan;BaküsnüaEdlKat;)anniyay

enARkúgv:asuInetaneT ehIyminyUrb:unµan semþc)anRtÚvTTUcsMu[eFVICaemdwknaMrNsirSrYbrYmmYyeRkam

kar]btßmÖKaMBarrbs;cinmþgeTot. edayCMTas;RbqaMgnwgkarbdiesFy:agcecsmYytamBaküesñIsMu

rbs;cin semþc)anTamTar[mankarbeNþjkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüecjBIGgÁkarshRbCaCati TRmaM

karbegáIt)anrdæaPi)altMNagmYy edIm,Ikan;kab;Gasn³EdlTuk[TMenrenAGgÁkarshRbCaCatieLIg

vij33. fVIebIRbeTscin)anbMeBaksmÖarRbNIt²y:ageRcIn nigpþl;nUvkitþiysy:agNak¾eday k¾

semþc sIhnu enAEtRbkan;CMhry:agmuWgm:at;kñúgkarbriharExµrRkhmy:agxøaMgkøa nigkarTieton

neya)ayrbs;BYkcinEdlRBHGgÁecaTfa «cg;vayRbyuT§Tl;nwgRbeTsevotNamrhUtdl;Exµr

cugeRkaybg¥s;». tamRBHGgÁeQVgyl;RckecjmanEtmYyKt; KWsnñisIThSWENvfµImYyEdlFana

snþisuxRbeTsevotNampg nigRbKl;ÉkraCü[RbeTskm<úCavijpg. RBHGgÁsmÁal;eXIjeday

hYsRBHT½yEdlBYkcinnwksgÇwmfa RbeTsevotNamc,as;CacuHj:meRkamkarKabsgát;minxan.

BIkarriHKn;epSg²EbbenaH EdlsemþcbnøW[dwgenARkúgeb:kaMgnigkarRbkasCasaFarN³enAedImqñaM

1980fa RBHGgÁR)afñayagRtLb;mkRbeTskm<úCavijenaH mann½yfa semþc sIhnu GacRbEhl

RtÚvBYkcinEdlRtÚveFVIekþARkhayxøaMgTat;ecalminxan. enAExkkáda qñaM1980 BYkcin)anRcanecal

nUvkarsMuGnuBaØatrbs;rdæm®nþIkarbreTséfmin[CYbKal;semþceLIy34. edayxusRBHraCbMNgnig

tUcRBHT½yxøÜnÉg semþc)anyagRtLb;mkBIRkúgBüúgy:agvijedayectnaeRBaHEtkarCYbKñaenH

edayRbkasR)ab;GñksarB½t’manfa RBHGgÁnwgdkRBHkayecjBICIvPaBneya)ay. erOgdUcKñaenH

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg426

Page 437: Brother enemy

Føab;ekItmanrYcmþgmkehIykalBIExsIha qñaM1979 ³ kaleNaH BYkcin)anraraMgmin[mankarCYbKña

mYyEdleRKagTukCamun CamYyGnuRbFanaFibtIGaemrikaMgelak vl;F½r m:unEdl pgEdr. sRmab;

semþc sIhnu vaCaerOgKYr[Eq¥tRBHT½yNas; 35.

smaKmGas‘an)anbnþeFVIkarKabsgát;eTAelIRbeTscinteTAeTot. kñúg»kasénkareFVIdMeNIr

CabnþbnÞab;KñamYyeTAkan;Rkúgeb:kaMgnasrTrdUvqñaM1980 rdæm®nþITI1sigðburI lI kVan;yU nigsmPaKIéf

rbs;Kat; eRBm TinsU‘LaNun )anKabsgát;cin[eFVIkarpøas;bþÚremdwknaMkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü KWem

ExµrRkhmd¾l,Il,ajbInak; b:ul Bt/ eGog sarI/ exov sMpn ecjedaydak; semþc sIhnu nig sWn

san CMnYsvij. etg s‘avBIg )aneqøIytbedayRtg;²eTAvijPøamfa kardkemdwknaMTaMgbInwgeFVI[

BYkyuT§CnExµrRkhmEdleyIgFøab;eRbICaRTnab;rvagTahanevotNamnigRbeTséfFøak;Twkcitþ. k¾b:uEnþ

etg )anyl;RsbnwgKMnitkñúgkarBYtkmøaMgKñamYyedayRbmUlpþMúExµrRkhm semþc sIhnu nig sWn san

ebIsinCa«GñkTaMgBIrminmanbMNgbMpøajkarts‘URbqaMgnwgBYkevotNameTenaH»36.

RbeTscinmanehtuplRtwmRtÚvEdlminTukcitþ semþc sIhnu nigGtItnaykrdæm®nþI sWn san

rbs;RBHGgÁ. mnusSesþIgx<s; suxPaBminmaMTaM nigsmþIéb:LaMenH ecHeFVI[eKeKarBekatxøacBIsMNak;

mnusSRbEhl6>000nak;énrNsirSCatirMedaHRbCaBlrdæExµr EdldwknaMbBa¢aeday]tþmesnIy_

eDon Edl (Dien Del) enAtamRBMEdnExµr-éf )anbdiesFminshkarCamYyExµrRkhmeLIy drabNa

emdwknaMEdll,IeQµaHy:agGaRkk;enAEtkan;muxdMENgdEdlenaH. Kat;k¾)anTamTareRKÓgsa®sþavuF

sRmab;mnusSrbs;Kat;pgEdrmunnwgyl;RBmCYbKña. Kat;EtgniyayRcMEdl²minecHFujRTan;fa

«edIm,IcUleTAkñúgRTúgxøa ´RtÚvEtkan;RBng;FMmYy».

etg )anpþl;karsnüaR)ab; lI fa RbeTscinnwgminTTUcedIm,I[ExµrRkhmeLIgkan;GMNacvij

eT. kñúgeBle)aHeqñatedayesrIEdlerobcMeLIgeRkaykardkfyrbs;evotNam ebIsinCaExµr

Rkhmcaj; RbeTscinnwgeKarBtam. kñúgkarcrcaRbkbedayesckþIsb,ayrIkrayy:agxøaMgmYy

edIm,IlT§iRbCaFibetyüEbbKhbtI etg )ansYreTA lI fa «etIelakyl;RBmeT ebIsinCakare)aH

eqñatpþl;GMNaceTA[ExµrRkhmvijenaH?». lI eqøIyfa «BitCayl;RBm»TaMgbBaú©HbBa©Úlfa enHKWCa

smµtikmµd¾RtwmRtÚvmYy37. lI )anRtLb;BIRbeTscinmkvijedaymankareBjcitþCaxøaMg enATIbMput

Rkúgeb:kaMg)anpþl;nUvkarRBmeRBógrbs;xøÜncMeBaHkarebIk[mansnñisITGnþrCatimYysþIBIkm<úCa nigsþIBI

dMeNaHRsayneya)aymYytamry³kare)aHeqñatedayesrI.

GVI²manRKb;sBVehIy. smaKmGas‘anGaccab;epþImkarvaylukxagkarTUtrbs;xøÜnCaRbeyaCn_

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 427

Page 438: Brother enemy

dl;karbegáItrdæaPi)alcRmúHmYyrbs;km<úCamunkarebIkRbCMurbs;snñisIT. enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1981

ebskCnBiessrbs;smaKmGas‘anKWGñkkarTUtmñak;rbs;\NÐÚensuIeQµaH Gan;v:a sanI )aneFVIdMeNIr

eTATIRkúgBüúgy:agedIm,ICYbKal; semþc sIhnu nigGgVrRBHGgÁkñúgnamsmaKmGas‘an[eFVICaemdwknaM

rdæaPi)alcRmúHmYy. tmkeTot semþc)anTTYlCYbÉkGKÁrdæTUtRbeTscin nigkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

RbcaMTIRkúgBüúgy:agEdlGgVrkrRBHGgÁ[cUlrYmkñúgkarBYtkmøaMgKñaenHEdr.

enAsrTrdUvqñaM1979 semþc)anRbmUlpþMúyuT§ik³rbs;RBHGgÁCafµIkñúgbkçsm<n§ExµrGñkCatiniym

mYynigesñIcrcaCamYyevotNam edIm,I«erobcMÉkraCüPaB nigGBüaRkwtPaB»rbs;km<úCaeLIgvij.

cuthµaycMnYnbIEdlsemþcRTg;lixitepJIeTAGtItmitþPkþiRBHGgÁKW paM v:an;dug suT§EtKµancemøIyeqøIytb

mkvijTaMgGs;. RkúgPñMeBjk¾)anRcanecalkaresñIrbs;RBHGgÁkñúgkaryagRtLb;mkkm<úCarbs;

ehg sMrin vijkñúgzan³CaRbCaBlrdæsamBaØ38. TVarrbs;RbeTsevotNam hak; dUcCabiTsRmab;

RBHGgÁEdr. bs©imRbeTs)anbgðaj[eXIjGMNrsaTrbnþicbnþÜcb:ueNÑaH enAeBlEdlRBHGgÁ

sakl,gbegáItCeRmIsmYyrvaglT§PaBBIr sRmab;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüedaybegáItrdæaPi)alnireTs

pÞal;rbs;RBHGgÁ. dUecñH semþc sIhnu RtÚvsßitkñúgsßanPaBRbQmmuxnwgkareRCIserIsEdlminCaTI

eBjRBHT½ymYy ³ b¤mYydkRBHkayTaMgRsugnigKµanlkçxNÐecjBICIvPaBneya)ay b¤mYyrYbrYm

CamYybNþaGtItédKUEdlRBHGgÁs¥b;ex<Im?. RBHGgÁ)anRtÚveFVI[Gak;Gn;RBHT½yedaykarriHKn;

rbs;CnrYmCatixøH²Edlrs;enAeRkARbeTs edaysþIbenÞasBIGtþTtßPaB nigkarminykRBHT½y

Tukdak;rbs;RBHGgÁkñúgkarRbyuT§rbs;km<úCaedIm,IÉkraCüPaB. mü:ageTot semþcelIktemáIgRBHGgÁÉg

x<s;xøaMgeBkkñúgzan³CaRBHbitaRbeTskm<úCasm½yTMenIb nigmankaryl;dwgBIRbvtþisa®sþhYsehtu

eTaHCae)aHbg;CIvPaBneya)ayk¾eday. semþc)anseRmclubbM)at;PaBraErkRBHT½yrbs;RBHGgÁ

edayRbkaseRtómRBHkaycUlrYmCamYyExµrRkhmkñúgmUlehtuepSg²EdleFVI[sm½<n§PaBmYyEbb

enaHminGacekIteLIg)an.

eRkayBIRbkasR)ab;BiPBelakBIRBHraCbMNgshkarCamYyExµrRkhmd¾KYr[PJak;ep¥Ilrbs;

RBHGgÁbnþic semþc sIhnu )anyl;RBm[´¬GñkniBn§¦CYbeFVIkarsnÞnamYy. taMgBIkarnireTsxøÜnelIk

dMbUgrbs;RBHGgÁenATIRkúgeb:kaMgkalBIqñaM1970 RBHGgÁEtgyageTAKg;enARkúgBüúgy:ag edayeTog

Tat;kñúgmYyqñaM²Gs;ry³eBlCaeRcInEx. GtItmitþPkþirbs;RBHGgÁ KIm GuIls‘ug RbFanaFibtIkUer: xag

eCIg)ansßabnavimand¾FMsáwmésámYyman40bnÞb;fVayRBHGgÁ EdlsßitenAmat;RckecjBIrdæFanI.

edayTTYl)anTidæakarmYyEdlsemþc)anesñIRbFanaFibtI KIm sRmab;´ ´)aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;rdæFanI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg428

Page 439: Brother enemy

d¾sem,Imnigd¾RtCak;eRsgrbs;kUer:xageCIgCabnÞan;. semþc sIhnu )anTTYlsVaKmn_ ´kñúgvimanpÞal;

rbs;RBHGgÁEdlEbrmuxeTArkPñMTab²RKbeTAedayhim³nigbwgkkrwgmYy. enAeBleFVIkarsnÞna)an

Bak;kNþal RBHGgÁ)ancg¥úleTAtumYy ehIymanbnÞÚlCamYysñamjjwmbnþicfa «KWRtg;hñwgÉgehIy

Edl´nwgRtÚvcrcaCamYy exov sMpn ehIyeyIgnwgminRBmeRBógGVITaMgGs;». CamYyesckþIesµaHRtg;

EdlmantaMgBIyUrmkehIyrbs;RBHGgÁ semþc)anmanRBHraCbnÞÚlbEnßmfa «´KµanbMNgeFVIkarRBm

eRBógCamYyExµrRkhmeLIy TaMgbc©úb,nñ TaMgéf¶Es¥k TaMgenAExvicäika ¬CakalbriecäTEdlRBHGgÁ)an

kMNt;sRmab;karBiPakSaCaelIkTIBIrCamYy exov sMpn¦ ³ ´cg;elgesIcbnþicCamYyBYkcin».

dUcEdl)aneRKagTukCamun karCYbKñaenAExmInarvag exov sMpn nig semþc sIhnu )anTTYl

lT§plbraC½ymYyedaysarkarTamTarepSg²rbs;semþcCaedImehtu. semþc sIhnu )andak;

lkçxNÐCaGaTiPaBcMnYnR)aMbYn kñúgkarcUlrYmCamYyExµrRkhmkñúgépÞrNsirSrYbrYmmYy. xsMxan;Edl

lM)akCageKsRmab;karcrcaKWmanTak;Tgnwgéf¶GnaKt39. eRkayBImandMeNaHRsayneya)ay

mYy nigkardak;CMnYskgT½BevotNamedaykgT½BEfrkSasnþiPaBGnþrCati semþc sIhnu )anTamTar[

mankardkGavuFBIExµrRkhm nigsmasPaBepSg²eTotrbs;clnatsU‘. exov sMpn )anRcanecal

sMeNIenH. Rtg;kEnøgenH semþc)aneFVI[ykcitþTukdak;dl;cMNucresIbmYy ³ mYyEpñkKWPaBminRsb

KñaxagplRbeyaCn_rvagRbeTscinnigsm<½n§mitþExµrRkhmrbs;eK ehIymYyEpñkeTotKWplRbeyaCn_

rvagRbeTscinnigtMbn;GasuIGaeKñy_minEmnkumµúynIsþ.

bNþaRbeTsénsmaKmGas‘an suT§Etvaytémøminl¥BIPaBrwgrUsrbs;BYkemdwknaMExµrRkhm

EdlRcanecaldMeNaHRsayTaMgGs;rYmmankardkGavuFBIyuT§Cn nigkardkfypÞal;rbs;BYkeK.

RbeTsTaMgenaHmanTwkcitþrIkrayy:agxøaMg enAeBlEdlRbeTscin)anyl;RBmcUlrYmkñúgsnñisIT

GnþrCatimYysþIBIRbeTskm<úCa. RkúgmUsÁÚ nigRkúghaNUy)an[dwgfa BYkeKnwgmincUlrYmkñúgsinñisIT

enHeT. RbeTscin)anRbkasfa xøÜnnwgminsVHEsVgeFVI[man\T§iBlrbs;xøÜnelIRbeTskm<úCatamry³

ExµrRkhmeLIgvijeLIy edayehtuenHsmaKmGas‘an)anseRmccitþRbjab;erobcMsnñisITenHeLIg.

vaTMngfa EpnkarsnþiPaBd¾smehtusmplmYyEdlKiteTAdl;plRbeyaCn_epSg²sRmab;sniþsux

RbeTsevotNam ehIyEdlKaMRTedaymhaGMNacFM² CaBiessshrdæGaemrik nigRbeTscin

RbEhlCaTak;TajcitþRkúghaNUy)an ebIeTaHCaevotNambdiesFmincUlrYm edIm,IrkSamuxmat;xøÜn

k¾eday. smaKmGas‘an nigCaBiessRbeTssigðburI)aneRtómxøÜnnwgehtukarN_EdlminCaTIeBjcitþ

CaeRsc.

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 429

Page 440: Brother enemy

karRBagesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;smaKmGas‘an sRmab;snñisITGnþrCatisþIBIbBaðakm<úCaenA

Exkkáda qñaM1981 RtÚv)antak;EtgeLIgCaBiesstamKMnitpþÜcepþImrbs; lI kVan;yU Edlbgðaj[

eXIjnUvPaBsRmúHsRmÜlmYycMeBaHRbeTsevotNamy:agKYr[q¶l;. va)anqøúHbBa©aMg[eXIjnUvkar

RBmeRBógKñamYykñúgcMeNamRbeTsGas‘anTaMgGs;EdlminsmÁal;eXIjplRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜn kñúg

yuT§sa®sþrbs;cinEdlmaneKaledAeFVI[evotNamexSaHrIgéreLIy. karfmfykmøaMgrbs;evotNam

nigkarvilRtLb;mkkan;GMNacvijrbs;ExµrRkhmsñiT§cinnwgeFVI[smtakmøaMgkñúgtMbn;ERbRbÜlRkLab;

cak;y:agFMeFg. k¾b:uEnþ karkm©at;ExµrRkhmecjtamry³kare)aHeqñat ehIydak;CMnYseday

rdæaPi)almYyEdlÉkraCünigmincUlbkSsm<½n§ nwgeFVI[RbeTséfnigRbeTsevotNamElgP½yRBÜy

ehIybM)at;min[RbeTscinmanelsedIm,IeFVIGnþraKmn_enAtMbn;GasuIGaeKñy_EdneKakEfmeTot.

KeRmagénesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;Gas‘an)anTTYlsÁal;nUv «karRBÜy)armÖd¾RtwmRtÚvrbs;bNþa

RbeTsCitxagkm<úCa-niyayedayELkRbeTsevotNam-fa RbeTsenHBuMGackøayeTACakarKMram

kMEhgmYycMeBaHRbeTsCitxagTaMgenaH ehIyk¾minRtÚv)aneRbIR)as;edayrdæNamYysRmab;RbRBwtþ

GMeBIviT§gSna b¤karQøanBanedaykmøaMgeyaFaEdr». GtßbTenH)anRcanecaledayKµanEcgc,as;las;

nUvkarTTYlxusRtÚvmYyEpñkénkareFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;evotNamcMeBaHneya)aypSgeRBgrbs;ExµrRkhm

nigvtþmaneyaFarbs;cinenARbeTskm<úCapgEdr. GtßbT)anGYtsresIrfa RbeTsevotNamnwg)an

TTYlCMnYyGnþrCatimYykñúgkarsþarRbeTsCatieLIgvij edIm,ICYsCulkarxUcxatEdlTTYlrgkarbMpøic

bMpøajedaysars®gÁam bnÞab;BIkaredaHRsaybBa©b;bBaðakm<úCa. TisedArbs;Gas‘an dMbUgKWeFVI[

TTYl)annUvkardkkgT½BevotNamecjBIkm<úCa bnÞab;mk kardkhUtGavuFBIExµrRkhmnigkarbegáItrdæa

Pi)albeNþaHGasnñmYy edIm,IerobcMkare)aHeqñatedayesrI.

snñisITenH)ancab;epþImeFVIenAGgÁkarshRbCaCatienAéf¶TI13 Exkkáda. minTan;)anGIpg BYkcin

nigExµrRkhm)ansEmþgnUvkarminyl;RBmnwgKeRmagrbs;Gas‘any:agmWugmat;. KMnitGeBa¢IjbkS

RbCaCnbdivtþExµrsñiT§evotNam[cUlrYmsnñisIT)anRtÚvRcanecal. vaküx½NÐénesckþIEføgkarN_

Tak;TgnwgkarRBÜy)armÖd¾RtwmRtÚvrbs;bNþaRbeTsCitxagkm<úCa k¾RtÚv)ansRmalEdr. smaKm

Gas‘anenAEtminrafycMeBaHkardkhUtGavuFBIRkúmbHe)arRbqaMgCaeRcInrbs;Exµr nigkarbegáItrdæa

Pi)albeNþaHGasnñmYy. edayRtÚveFVI[q¶l;RsLaMgkaMg GñkkarTUtrbs;sigðbUrI)anemIleXIjfa

karFanar:ab;rgepSg²EdlGHGageday etg CamYy lI kVan;yU Tak;TgnwgkareKarBesckþIseRmc

tamry³hibeqñat RbEhlCaminKYr[TukcitþeLIy. enAéf¶TI15 Exkkáda kñúg»kasénkarRbCuMkargar

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg430

Page 441: Brother enemy

mYyEdlmanGñksegátkarN_40rUb kñúgcMeNamenaHmanGñkkarTUtGaemrikaMgEdr )anenATIenaHeBl

manTas;smþIKñay:agxøaMgrvag fmmI kUs ÉkGKÁrdæTUtsigðbUrIRbcaMGgÁkarshRbCaCati nigCatMNag

smaKmGas‘anCamYynwg lIn CIg CaÉkGKÁrdæTUtrbs;RbeTscin. edayeFVI[RsekorRtecoknwg

sþab; lIn )anelIkykc,ab;GnþrCatimkeFVICasMGag edIm,ICYykarBarExµrRkhm. cMENk kUs Edl

CaGtItRBwT§bursmhaviTüal½ynItisa®sþénsaklviTüal½ysigðbUrI)anERskPøat;mat;fa ³ «y:agehac

Nas; ´ecHdwgBIc,ab;GnþrCatiCagelakÉkGKÁrdæTUteTAeTot b:uEnþ c,ab;BMuEmneFVIeLIgsRmab;karBar

RkúmmnusSsahavyg;XñgenHeT». tmkeTot Kat;)ancab;eFVIkarr:ayr:ab;y:agl¥itl¥n;nUvPaBKYr[

rn§t;jab;j½rEdlRbRBwtþeLIgeday b:ul Bt nigédeCIgrbs;Kat;kñúgGMLúgeBlénkarkan;GMNacbYnqñaM.

CnCatiExµrxøHEdlmanvtþmankñúgsalRbCuMEdr enaH)annaMKñaRTehayMPøam40.

kñúg»kasénkarCYbRbCuMmYyepSgeTotCamYybNþardæm®nþIkarbreTsGas‘an han nanLúg Gnurdæ

m®nþIkarbreTscin)anykkNþab;édeKaHtulan;pUg CasBaØaR)ab;[dwgnUvkarekþARkhayrbs;Kat;

cMeBaHkarTietonKµanQb;QrRbqaMgnwgExµrRkhm. «ebIKµankarts‘Uy:agsVitsVajrbs;km<úCaRbCaFib

etyüeT k¾éf¶enHBYkeyIgminenATIenH edIm,IBiPakSaBIbBaðaRbeTskm<úCaEdr b:uEnþ c,as;CaBiPakSaKñaBI

bBaðaRbeTséfminxan»41. han )aneRkInrMB£kfa kardkhUtGavuFBIBYkExµrRkhmminRKan;EteFVI[

yuT§CnTaMgLayFøak;Twkcitþb:ueNÑaHeT EfmTaMgeFVI[b:HBal;y:agxøaMgdl;PaBRtwmRtÚvtamc,ab;rbs;

km<úCaRbCaFibetyüeTotpg. han )ansYrTaMgxwgRceLateTAkan;bNþaKUsnÞnarbs;Kat;fa ³ «ehtuGVI

)anCaesñIsuM[smaCikRsbc,ab;mYyrbs;GgÁkarshRbCaCatidak;GavuFcuH? ehtuGIV)anCabgçM[man

rdæaPi)albeNþaHGasnñcMeBaHrdæCasmaCikmYyrbs;GgÁkarshRbCaCatiEdlrgeRKaHBIkarQøanBan

mYyeTAvij?. Kat;)anbnþfa ³ bnÞab;BIkardkfyrbs;kgT½BevotNam bnÞúkerobcMRbeTsnwgRtÚvFøak;

elIrdæaPi)alRsbc,ab;rbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyü ehIymanEtrdæaPi)alenHmYyKt;EdlRtÚverobcM

kare)aHeqñat».

CMhrrbs;cinenAkñúgsnñisIT)aneFVI[smaKmGas‘anxwgcitþy:agxøaMg b:uEnþtYnaTIEdlsEmþg eday

shrdæGaemrikkñúgsnñisITenaH eTIbCakareFVI[Tas;citþxøaMgmYyy:agBitR)akd. enAqñaM1980 kñúg

»kasénkareXasnae)aHeqñatrbs;xøÜn RbFanaFibtI r:UNal; rIehÁn Føab;bgá[manerOgehtuCamYy

BYkcinmþgehIy edayKat;)ansnüaerobcM[manTMnak;TMngpøÚvkarCamYyRbeTsétv:an;eLIgvij. enA

eBlenH rdæm®nþIkarbreTsrbs;Kat;elak GaLicsg;d½r ehk )anRbwgERbgy:agGs;BIcitþBIeføImedIm,I

eFVI[cineBjcitþKat;vij edayelIkehtuplfa «RbeTscinRbEhlCaRbeTsd¾mansarsMxan;CageK

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 431

Page 442: Brother enemy

énBiPBelaksRmab;shrdæGaemrik» ebIsmøwgemIlplRbeyaCn_CayuT§sa®sþepSg²rbs;RbeTs

TaMgBIr42.

enAkñúgsnñisIT ehk )anbnþpÁab;citþcinrhUtdl;kan;eCIgRkúgeb:kaMgRbqaMgnwgbNþasm<½n§mitþnig

mitþPkþiminEmnkumµúynIsþrbs;shrdæGaemrikEfmeTot. GñkkarTUtGas‘and¾eqñImmñak;)anrMB£kBIerOgenH

CamYykartUccitþfa ³ «ehk nig]bkarIrbs;Kat;KWelak hUlRDIdhS_ )anedIrecjBImhasnñi)atGgÁkar

shRbCaCatienAeBlEdl eGog sarI egIbQredIm,IeLIgniyay. GMeBId¾Gs©arüenH)anRtÚvcuHkñúg

TMB½rTImYyénkaEstjÚvy:kEfms_ b:uEnþkñúgTIkM)aMgvij mnusSBIrnak;enH ehk nig hUl RDIdhS_ )aneFVI

karKabsgát;mkelIeyIg edIm,I[BYkeyIgsRmbxøÜneTAtamCMhrrbs;cin»43.

hUlRDIdhS_ nigGnuRbFanrbs;Kat;TTYlbnÞúkkic©karGasuIGaeKñy_eQµaH hSn eNRháÚb:ug )aneFVI

dMeNIrbMeBjebskkmµmþgmñak;enAtambNþaRbeTsGas‘an edayKabsgát;rdæm®nþIkarbreTsCaeRcIn

rUbkuM[pÞj;pÞal;kareFVIsm,TanepSg²rbs;RbeTscin edIm,IsRmbsRmÜlKñacMeBlEdlGñkRbtibtþi

niym etg s‘avBIg riHKn;eTAelIRkúmniymeqVgrbs;Kat;. elak m:uktar KUsUm:aGatm:adüa rdæm®nþIkar

breTs\NÐÚensIu)anxwgRceLatfa ³ «ebIsinCa etg BuMmanesrIPaBnwgeFVIGVIekItenaH KWCaerOgrbs;

Kat;. BYkeyIgBuMEmnCaemedaHrbs;Kat;eT»44.

enAcMeBaHmuxkarminyl;RBmrbs;elak s‘ubBIy:as; daNa)aLan; rdæm®nþIkarbreTssigðbUrI

[dkecjxsMxan;² EdlRbeTscinmankarExVgeyabl;EdrenaH elak hUlRDIdhS_ )anKMramfanwg

ykerOgenHeTAbþwgelak lIkVan;yU. daNa)aLan; )anpÞúHsmþITaMgkMhwgfa «sUmGeBa¢IjedayesrI¡ ebI

sinCaelakcg;» munnwgcakecjBIsm½yRbCuMTaMgdMeNIrxwgttUgttag. lI TMngCaminGt;»nnUvkar

RbQmmuxnwg ehk nig hUlRDIdhS_ enHeLIy45.

ÉkGKÁrdæTUtshrdæGaemrikRbcaMRkúgm:anIl ¬rdæFanIRbeTsh‘VIlIBIn¦ nigRbcaMRkúg)agkk )an

TTYlbBa¢aBIelak ehk [cUlCYbR)aRs½yGMBIbBaðaenHCamYyRbFanaFibtI m:arkUs nignaykrdæm®nþI

eRBmTinsU‘LaNun edIm,IbBa©úHbBa©Úl[rwtbnþwgrdæm®nþIkarbreTsrbs;pgxøÜnEdleFVIkarenATIRkúgjÚvy:k

pg. smaKmGas‘anenAEtbnþecaTshrdæGaemrikfa )ancUlédCamYysRtÚv b:uEnþ edayTb;Tl;min

)annwgkarKabsgát;rbs;cinnigGaemrikaMg Gas‘ank¾yl;RBmniyayBIkarsRmbsRmÜlKñavij Edl

Cakare)aHbg;ecalnUvcMNucKnøwHBIrkñúgEpnkarrbs;xøÜn.

eK)anecjrYcBIPaBT½lRck enAéf¶EdlGas‘ane)aHbg;ElgTamTar[mankardkGavuFBIRkúmExµr

c,aMgKñaTaMgLay edayRKan;Etpþl;nUvkarFanaminc,as;las;fa «viFankarsmRsbepSg²nwgRtÚv

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg432

Page 443: Brother enemy

Rbkan;ykedIm,IbeBa©ósmin[bkSBn§RbqaMgrbs;km<úCararaMgb¤GukLúk» kare)aHeqñat. Elgmankar

niyayENnaMBIrdæ)albeNþaHGasnñmYyeTotehIy b:uEnþ «viFankarepSg²RtÚvdak;bgçM[TTYledIm,Ikar

BarPaBsuxsanþrbs;Blrdæ». enATIbMputrUbmnþsRmúHsRmÜlKñaenH)anCYyse®gÁaHsnñisIT[RbRBwtþ

eTA)an. karRbQmmuxd¾rMeCIbrMCYlrbs;RbeTscin nigsmaKmGas‘an )aneFVI[eXIjy:agCak;c,as;

nUveRCaHd¾eRCAmYyEdlx½NÐEckPaKITaMgBIr ebIeTaHCaBYkeKeFVIkarCMTas;rYmKñaRbqaMgnwgkarkan;kab;

RbeTskm<úCaedayevotNamk¾eday ehIyRtÚvvinicä½yeday fmmIkUs fa «vaCaerOgEdleFVI[Bi)ak

citþbMput Edl´minFøab;)anCYbRbTHkñúgGMLúgeBl13qñaMénkarbMeBjmuxgarenAGgÁkarshRbCaCati».

sRmab;RbeTsTaMgLayénsmaKmGas‘an enHCa»kasrkeXIjpgEdrnUvGVIEdlCabnÞúkrbs;RbeTs

tUc²RbQmmuxTl;nwgmhaGMNacnana46.

sm<½n§PaBmYyEdlxusRbRktI

semþc sIhnu )anbdiesFmincUlrYmsnñisITenHeT EdltamRBHGgÁmanRBHraCtRmiHfaenaH

Ca«tulakar»samBaØmYysRmab;vinicä½yRbeTsevotNamb:ueNÑaH enAeBlEdleKRtÚvEsVgrkdMeNaH

RsaymYyCabnÞan;. b:uEnþenArdUvekþA qñaM1981 RBHGgÁhak;dUcCaminsUvCMTas;nwgKMnitcg;[mankar

rYmkmøaMgKñamYyb:unµaneLIy. enAExsIha RBHGgÁ)anCYb sWn san CaelIkdMbUgbg¥s;taMgBIkarcakecj

rbs;GtItnaykrdæm®nþIrbs;RBHGgÁeTATIRkúg):arIs. CaesdæviTUEdlmankarbNþúHbNþalRtwmRtÚv mun

dMbUgKat; KWeKCaGñkTTYlbnÞúkbeRgónsemþc]byuvraC neratþm sIhnu tmkeTot Kat;)ankøayeTACa

FnaKarikTImYy Cardæm®nþIRksYghirBaØvtßú nignaykrdæm®nþIrbs;RBHGgÁ. fVIebImankic©shkard¾yUrlg;

nigCitsñiT§nwgKñak¾eday k¾enATIbMputTMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;GñkTaMgBIr)anfmfycuHy:agxøaMgenAcug

rC¢kalrbs; semþc sIhnu ehIyBYkeKk¾ElgniyayBIKñataMgBIeRcInqñaMmkehIy. smaKmGas‘anKWCa

GñkGenÞalGenÞak[mankarrYbrYmKña edayminrvl;dl;karGak;Gn;citþrvagKñanwgKñarbs;GñkTaMgBIr

eLIy. rdæm®nþIkarbreTséf siT§I saev:tsuILa )anCYbeFVIkarsnÞnaeRkApøÚvkarmYyCamYy semþc sIhnu

enAsßanTUtéfRbcaMTIRkúg):arIs. Kat;KWCaGñkkarTUtéfdMbUgbg¥s;Edl)anCYbsemþctaMgBICag15qñaM

mkehIy. KWKat;enHEdrEdlesñIsemþc[bMePøcGtItkalehIydwknaMrdæaPi)alcRmúHmYyenaH.

sRmab;RbeTséf karcgsm<½n§emRtICamYy semþc sIhnu ebIemIltamRbvtþisa®sþrbs;xøÜn KW

CakarERbRbÜlPaøm²mYy EdleFVI[eKcab;GarmµN_y:agxøaMg. enAqñaM1962 semþcFøab;)anbþwgeTA

tulakarGnþrCatienARkúgLaeG [CMnuMCRmHBIerOgR)asaTRBHvihar EdlRbeTséf)andeNþImeTAeFVICa

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 433

Page 444: Brother enemy

kmµsiT§irbs;xøÜn ehIyRBHGgÁ)anQñHkñúgerOgkþIenHnigTTYl)anR)asaTRBHviharmkvij. kñúgry³eBl

15qñaMénrC¢kalRBHGgÁminEdle)aHbg;»kaskñúgkarbriharBIlT§ivatTIniymrbs;éf nigmhicätarbs;

bNþaemT½BRbeTsenHeLIy. b:uEnþedayKitdl;plRbeyaCn_snþisuxRbeTs nigbBa©b;s®gÁamBakü

smþId¾eRKatRKatsþIBIPaBKYrdl;kalénkareFVIsm<½n§PaBmYyCamYysemþc sIhnu enaH RBHraCvaMgRkúg

)agkk)anR)ab;kgT½BPUminÞéffa cab;BIeBlenHeTAkarpSHpSaCamYysemþc KWCakmµvtßúénkarCECk

BiPakSaKñakñúgrdæsPa47.

smaKmGas‘annigshrdæGaemrik)anQandl;eKaledArbs;BYkeK ³ enAExkBaØa qñaM1981

semþc sIhnu nig sWn san )anyagnigeFVIdMeNIreTAsigðbUrIedIm,IcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógmYy

EdlnaMeTAdl;karbegáIt[manrdæaPi)alcRmúHmYy.

vamankarRBmeRBógeRcInKña(Consensus)mYykñúgépÞsmaKmGas‘an sþIBIPaBcaM)ac;énkarbegáIt

rdæaPi)alcRmúHmYy edIm,IrkSakarKaMRTBIGnþrCaticMeBaHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü b:uEnþ BuMEmnsþIBItYnaTI

rbs;rdæaPi)alenHeT. BYkm:aeLsuI nig\NÐÚensuI yl;eXIjfa vanwgeTACaRkbx½NÐEdll¥\tex©aH

sRmab;BRgIk«kmøaMgTIbI»mYy edayRbmUlpþúMPaKeRcInénRbCaCnkm<úCaEdlBuMEmnCayuT§ik³rbs;Exµr

Rkhm TaMgk¾BuMEmnCayuT§ik³rbs;evotNam. enHCaesñótd¾l¥mYy edIm,IerobcMdak;BYkemdwknaMminEmn

kumµúynIsþ[kan;GMNac nigseRmc)ankic©RBmeRBógmYyCamYyevotNameRkayBIrlas;ecalExµr

Rkhm. rdæm®nþIkarbreTsm:aeLsIu tan;RsIu háahSalI sðahVI )anbMPøWR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦fa «BYkcinBuMcg;

[mankardkGavuFBIExµrRkhmeT eyIgRtÚvEterobcMkmøaMgRbqaMgminEmnkumµúynIsþmYy». karerobcM

rdæaPi)alcRmúHmYynwgebIk»kasbMBak;GavuF[kmøaMgminEmnkumµúynIsþ)an. kmøaMgT½BTIbIenH «BuMEmn

bRmúgTuksRmab;vayRbyuT§nwgevotNameT b:uEnþsRmab;begáIt[manPaBesµIKñamYyrvagédKUTaMgLay

rbs;rdæaPi)alcRmúH nigeFVI[kmøaMgminEmnkumµúynIsþeTACaKUsnÞnad¾KYr[TukcitþmYysRmab;karcrca

epSg²CamYyevotNam»48.

karrkSakarKabsgát;EpñkeyaFaeTAelIevotNamtamry³karCYbTak;TgnwgExµrRkhm KWCaGaTi-

PaBEdlRbeTséfRtÚveFVImuneK. rdæaPi)alcRmúHminbeRmIGVIeRkAEtBIr:ab;rg[mankarKaMRTBIshKmn_

GnþrCatib:ueNÑaH. RbeTssigðbUrI)anyl;RBmnwgTsSn³epSg²rbs;Rkúg)agkkEteKalFM² b:uEnþ

mü:ageTot k¾manbMNg[RbúgRby½tñmin[ExµrRkhmeqøótTajykplRbeyaCn_NamYyxagEpñkneya

)ayBIrdæaPi)alcRmúHenHEdr. bnÞab;BI)anseRmckic©RBmeRBógCaeKalkarN_mYyenAExkBaØarYcmk

PaKITaMgbIEbrCaCab;KaMgkñúgkareQøaHRbEkkKñaKµanTIbBa©b;sþIBIkarRbKl;tMENgrdæm®nþIepSg² nigsþIBI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg434

Page 445: Brother enemy

karcat;EcgdwknaMEdlRbmUlpþúMmkenAeRkamGMNacEtmYy. edIm,IbBa©b;bBaðaenH RbeTssigðbUrI )an

dak;esñIKeRmag«rdæaPi)alcRmúHgaydwknaM»mYyedayRbKl;sV½yPaBrbs;eK[édKUepSg² nigeday

bM)at;RKb;lT§PaBTaMgGs;min[ExµrRkhmRKb;RKgrdæaPi)alenH)aneLIy. bnÞab;BIBüayameFVIkar

crcad¾lM)akGs;firevlaR)aMbIEx enATIbMput rUbmnþEdlGacTTYlyk)anmYyRtÚv)anerobcM[man

eLIg. edIm,IbegáInel,Ónkic©karTaMgenaH smaKmGas‘anetagEteRbIkarKMramkMEhgepSg²CacaM)ac; ³

mYyEpñkKWkat;pþac;es,ógGaharsRmab;rNsirSCatirMedaHRbCaBlrdæExµr ehIymYyEpñkeTotQb;

TTYlsÁal;km<úCaRbCaFibetyü.

]bsKÁcugeRkayTak;TgeTAnwgkarRbKl;tMENgsMxan;²cMnYnBIrkñúgrdæaPi)al)anRtÚvdkecjenA

Ex]sPa qñaM1982. enAeBlenaH suIFI )aneFVIdMeNIreTATIRkúgeb:kaMgedIm,ICYbsemþc sIhnu elIkenH

edaymankareRCamERCgBIsMNak;BYkcinpg. semþc sIhnu nwgkan;muxtMENgCaRbFanrdæaPi)alcRmúH

sWn san Canaykrdæm®nþI ehIy exov sMpn nwgkan;muxtMENgCardæm®nþIkarbreTsnigmanzan³CaGnu

RbFanrbs;semþc. semþc sIhnu )anmanRBHraCbnÞÚlR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦Casm¶at;fa «bnÞab;BI)an

sakl,geFVIskmµPaBedayKµanCMnYyBIGñkdéT eyIg)anRtÚvbgçM[e)aHbg;mti». smaKmGas‘annig

shrdæGaemrik)aneFVI[RBHGgÁ nig sWn san dwgy:agc,as;fa BYkeKnwgyl;RBmpþl;CMnYyrbs;xøÜn

eTA[EtrdæaPi)alRsbc,ab;mYydUcrdæaPi)alkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüb:ueNÑaH KWBuMEmnCaclnakgT½BéRB

mYyeLIy. TIbMput enAéf¶TI22 Exmifuna qñaM1982 emdwknaMTaMgbI)anCYbCuMKñaCafµIenATIRkúgkULalMBYr

sRmab;BiFImYyEdlkMNt;nUvkarcab;kMeNIténrdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüCapøÚvkar. ebIKit

[sBVeTA BaküfardæaPi)alcRmúHhak;dUcCaGnueRKaHsRmab;ExµrRkhmeRcInCag. édKUTaMgGs;rbs;

rdæaPi)alenH)anyl;RsbnwglkçxNÐbYnrbs;BYkeK ³ rcnasm<½n§RtIPaKI karminmanPaBelIslb;

CageKrbs;PaKINamYykñúgcMeNamPaKITaMgbI ¬)ann½yfaKµanGñkNaelIsGñkNaeT¦ rebobRbkan;

ykkarseRmccitþCaÉkc½änÞ nigkarGnum½tiykTg;CatinigbTePøgCatikm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. ebIsinCa

BYkeK¬PaKIBIr¦cakecjBIrdæaPi)alcRmúH ExµrRkhmnwgGacrkSaTukkarehAkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüdEdl.

BitehIyvamansgÇwmtictYcNas;Edlfa ExµrRkhmseRmccitþcakecjBIrdæaPi)alcRmúHenaH b:uEnþ

cMNuccugeRkayenH )anbBa©b;esckþIsgÇwmepSg²Edlfa éf¶NamYyBYkminEmnkumµúynIsþc,as;Caqk;

»kasykPaBRsbc,ab;rbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüeTAeRbIminxan. mü:ageTot ExµrRkhm)anseRmc

eCaKC½yeFVI[neya)aybreTseTACanaTIdac;muxrbs;eK. m®nþIkarTUtrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüEdl

RbcaMkarenAbreTsnwgRtÚvKaMRT[kan;muxtMENgrbs;xøÜndEdl.

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 435

Page 446: Brother enemy

RbeTsevotNamhak;dUcCaminsUvcab;GarmµN_nwgrdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüb:unµan

eLIy fVIebIkarbegáItrbs;xøÜn)anpþl;CaTm¶n;dl;smaKmGas‘ansRmab;tTl;KñaenAelIqakGnþrCati nig

eFVI[mankarEkERbfµIkñúgclnats‘Uk¾eday. cab;BIqñaM1982 RbeTsevotNamk¾ElgCMTas;nwgPaBCa

tMNagrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüenAGgÁkarshRbCaCatieTotEdr. cMnYnRbeTsEdle)aHeqñatKaMRT

karseRmccitþrbs;Gas‘anRbqaMgnwgevotNam)anQaneLIgBI91sMeLgenAqñaM1979 rhUtdl;

cMnYnCaÉtTKÁ³114sMeLgenAqñaM1985. smaKmGas‘annigshrdæGaemrik)anerobcM[mankmµviFI

pþl;CMnYyesdækic© nigeyaFamYyRBmTaMgkarbNþúHbNþalsRmab;BYksmasPaBminEmnkumµúynIsþén

rdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüEfmeTot. cMENkRbeTscinEdlFøab;CYyExµrRkhmy:agsn§wk

sn§ab;rYcmkehIy RBmTaMgRbeTskUer:xageCIgpg)anesIñpþl;CMnYymk[rdæaPi)alcRmúHenHEdr. eday

sarCMnYyes,ógGaharnigmnusSFm’Edlpþl;edaybNþaGgÁkarGnþrCaticMeBaHRbCaBlrdæExµrEdlkMBug

rs;enAtamCMrMnanaenAtambeNþayRBMEdnrbs;éf nigedaysarsmÖareyaFaEdlpþl;edayRbeTscin

nigsmaKmGas‘anenaH cMnYnGñkRbyuT§minEmnkumµúynIsþ)aneLIgdl;cMnYnRbEhl30>000nak;.

smaKmGas‘an)anbMBak;GavuF[BYkminEmnkumµúynIsþedIm,IeFVI[GñkTaMgenaHeTACaKUsnÞna Edl

GacTTYlyk)anCamYynwgRbeTsevotNam edayenArkSakarKabsgát;EpñkkarTUteTAelIRkúghaNUy

dEdl edIm,IeFVI[seRmcdMeNaHRsaymYytamkarcrca. edayBaküeBcn_RsedogKñanwgesckþIEføg

karN_rbs;Gas‘anenAsnñisITGnþrCatisþIBIbBaðakm<úCa bNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþ)ansakl,gCag

db;BIrelIk edIm,IxMRbwgeFVI[RbeTsevotNamdkkgT½Brbs;xøÜnecjBIRbeTskm<úCa nigGnuBaØat[RbCa

CnExµrmansiT§isV½yseRmceRkamkarRtÜtRtarbs;GnþrCati. b:uEnþvamankarÉkPaBmYyEtsMbkeRkA

b:ueNÑaHenAkñúgépÞsmaKmGas‘an. RbeTs\NÐÚensuI nigm:aeLsuI EdlRBÜy)armÖCageKBIkarKMram

kMEhgry³eBlyUrEdlRbeTscinedIrtYCafµIkñúgtMbn;enH )anxMRbwgsEmþg[eXIjPaBqab;RsuHRsYl

EtxagxøÜnEdr. elak]tþmesnIy_ ebnnI mWdanI EdleBlenaHCaRbmuxEpñkesIubkarN_sm¶at;rbs;

\NÐÚensuI )aneFVIdMeNIrCapøÚvkarcMnYnBIrelIkeTAkan;RkúghaNUyenAqñaM1980mþg nigqñaM1982mþg

edIm,Isakl,gEsVgrkrUbmnþsRmúHsRmÜlmYy. RkúghSakataBuMmanCMenOTukcitþNamYyeTAelI

RbeTscinEdlRtÚvsgS½yfa )ansEmþgtYnaTImYykñúgkarb:unb:geFVIrdæRbharrbs;kumµúynIsþ¬min)an

seRmc¦enAqñaM1965eLIy. \NÐÚensuI)anbgðajnUvsmancitþcMeBaHkarRbyuT§rMedaHCatienARbeTs

evotNam nigkarbgáehturbs;xøÜncMeBaHRkúgeb:kaMg. ebnnI )anEføgRbkasCaBiessfa RbeTsrbs;

Kat;cat;TukkareFVIGnþraKmn_enARbeTskm<úCaCaTegVIkarBarxøÜnRtwmRtÚvtamc,ab;mYy. b:uEnþenAcMeBaHmux

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg436

Page 447: Brother enemy

karRbqaMgCMTas;y:agxøaMgkøaBIsMNak;RbeTséf nig sigðbUrI ebnnI RtÚvEtlHbg;KMnitEsVgrkdMeNaH

Rsayrbs;Kat;EdlsMGagelIsßankarN_Cak;Esþg EdlkMBugmaneRbóbCagenAkm<úCa. enAedImqñaM

1983 RbeTsm:aeLsuI)anRbwgERbgbgá[mankarsnÞnaKñamYyrvagGas‘annigRbeTsBIrenA\NÐÚcin

KWRbeTsLavnigevotNam. RbeTséfnigRbeTscin)aneFVI[karb:unb:genHbraC½yedaysMGagels

fa enHCakarGnum½tyl;RBmpþl;sBaØaNénbøúk\NÐÚcin. kñúgsMeNImYyepSgeTotenAqñaM1985

RbeTsm:aeLsuI)anpþl;eyabl;[erobcMkarcrcaedaymin cMeBaHrvagrdæaPi)al ehg sMrin nigrdæa

Pi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. sMeNIenH)aneBIbRbTHnwgkarRbqaMgCMTas;CafµIBIsMNak;RbeTséf

RbeTscin nigExµrRkhm ³ eKminRtÚvCYykarBarrbbGay:gmYyeLIy. sMeNImYyeTotEdlmþgenH

ecjmkBIRbeTs\NÐÚensuI)anesñI[mankareFVI[manRbRktIPaBEpñkkarTUtCamYyshrdæGaemriksin

edIm,ICMrujevotNam[cakecjBIRbeTskm<úCa b:uEnþ RtÚv)anRcanecaledayRbeTséf nigsigðbUrI

eTot.

smaKmGas‘anecHTajykplcMeNjBIkarekrþ×eQµaHrbs;shKmn_GnþrCati cMeBaHtYnaTIrbs;

xøÜnkñúgbBaðarbs;km<úCa. \LÚvenHGas‘anRtÚvEtkarBarÉkPaBrbs;xøÜn[)anCadac;xat eKaledAenA

eBlenHmansarsMxan;sRmab;xøÜndUcKñanwgkaredaHRsaybBaðakm<úCaEdr. edayeKarBcMeBaHmuxkar

TamTarrbs;RbeTséf-EdlsßitenACYrmuxTl;nwgevotNam-enHehIy EdlkarÉkPaBenHRtÚv)an

karBar. karRbqaMgCMTas;edayKµanlak;elomrbs;RbeTséf )anbgá[mankarGak;Gn;citþxøH²enA

RbeTs\NÐÚensuI Edlhak;dUcCamanGarmµN_fa beNþay«[Rkúg)agkkdwknaM» eRscnwgk,alcitþ

edayyl;fa RbeTsrbs;xøÜnCaRbeTsmYyEdlmanépÞdIFMlVwgelVIynigmanRbCaBlrdæeRcInCageK

enAPUmiPaKGasuIGaeKñy_enH. RkúghSakartayl;eXIjfa CemøaHmYyEdlecHEtbnþ[Evgq¶ayenA

RbeTskm<úCac,as;CaKMramkMEhgdl;ÉkPaBrbs;tMbn; nigebIkpøÚv[mankarcUleFVIGnþraKmn_kan;Et

xøaMgeLIgBImhaGMNacFM²Cak;CaR)akd. dUecñH eKRtÚvEtnaMRbeTsevotNam[eFVIshRbtibtþikar

kñúgépÞshKmn_GasIuGaeKñy_ ehIyerob«eRKÓgkarBar»CMuvijshKmn_enH edIm,IbeBa©ósmhaGMNac

epSg²[ecjq¶ayrYmTaMgRbeTscinpg49.

b:uEnþmanTsSn³xøH² EdlRtÚvRbjab;Rbjal;rkSa[manPaBrYbrYmKñakñúgrdæaPi)alcRmúHmYy

EdlminTan;suIExSKñaenAeLIy k¾dUcrkSaÉkPaBrbs;Gas‘anEdr. minRtwmEtKµankarsRmúHsRmÜl

NamYyrvagédKUnanarbs;rdæaPi)alcRmúHb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþBYkeKBuMsMécnwgvayRbharKñaCasaFarN³

eLIy. ExµrRkhmnigBYkminEmnkumµúynIsþ)anRbQmmuxdak;KñaedayeyaFamþgmáalEdr. kar

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 437

Page 448: Brother enemy

RbwgERbgTaMgLayEdleFVIedaybNþaRbeTsxøHrbs;smaKmGas‘an edIm,IbM)at;min[mankarrYbrYm

kmøaMgBIExµrRkhmmYycMnYntUcEdlmanRbvtþiGaRkk;CageK )aneFVI[manbriyakasmnÞilsgS½ymYy

rvagrdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü nigbNþaRbeTs]btßmÖKaMRTrbs;xøÜn. enAExkBaØa qñaM1983

kñúg»kasénBiFIelogsayePaCn_mYyEdlerobcMedaysmaKmGas‘anCakitþiysdl; semþc sIhnu

enAsNaæaKar v:al;d½r Gas;fUrIy:a enATIRkúgjÚvy:k rdæm®nþIkarbreTsm:aeLsuI háahSalI )anepþIm

BiPakSaBIbBaðamYyedayRby½tñRbEygbMputenAmux exov sMpn fa «´sUmeTas etIelakGacesñI[

b:ul Bt/ eGog sarI nig tam:uk dkxøÜnfyedIm,ICaKuNRbeyaCn_x<g;x<s;dl;RbeTskm<úCab¤eT?».

semþc sIhnu EdlcUlrYmCamYyKñaEdrenaH)anelIkeLIgnUvsMeNId¾éføfñÚrmYyfa «ebIsinÉk]tþm b:ul

Bt» manbMNgRbKl;Parkic©dwknaMkgT½BeTA[ exov sMpn. sIhnu nwgsBVRBHT½ydak;vimanenATIRkúg

Büúgy:agnigPUmiRKwHtUcmYyenATIRkúgmUhSInrbs;RBHGgÁenARbeTs)araMgsRmab;[eRbIR)as;tamRtÚv

kar. RtÚveFVI[ekøóvkøaedayTsSn³vis½yenH semþcQanrhUtdl;bBa¢ak;fa vimanenATIRkúgBüúg

y:agmanGagEhlTwkmYy salbBa©aMgPaBynþmYy taragvaysInigtarag)al;THeTotpg. «Gs;

elakGacbriePaKmðÚbGahartamEtGs;elakcUlcitþmantaMgBImðÚb)araMg/ Exµr nigcin. Gs;elakc,as;

CaTTYl)ankarrs;enAmYyd¾s¶b;s¶at;bMputkñúgTIenaH». exov sMpn eFVImuxRkjÚv ehIyeqøIytbeday

smþImWugm:at;mYyfa ³ «rbs;TaMgGs;enaHBuMmansarsMxan;eT. GVIEdlsMxan;KWÉkPaB. eyIgRtÚvrYbrYm

KñaCanic© ehIyeyIgnwgenAEtrYbrYmKñadEdl. KµanGñkNamYyGacbMEbkeyIg[XøatBIKña)aneLIy».

bnÞab;BIsßitkñúgsPaBes¶óms¶at;KYr[Fujfb;mYyry³ rdæm®nþITaMgGs;)ancab;epþImbriePaKGahar50.

kñúg»kasénsm½yRbCuMKN³rdæm®nþImYynaExkkáda qñaM1984 etg s‘avBIg Edldwgfa

smaKmGas‘an)anCECkBiPakSaKñaCafµIGMBIkardkfyrbs;emExµrRkhml,IeQµaHGaRkk;mYycMnYnenaH

)anecjnUvkarRBmanmYyedayRtg;²cMeBaHrdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüEtmþg. enAExtula

Kat;)anTTYlCYbrYmKñaTaMgsemþc sIhnu/ sWn san nig exov sMpn enATIRkúgeb:kaMgehIy)anKMram

fanwgkat;pþac;CMnYyrbs;cinTaMgRsug ebIsinCaédKUNamYykñúgrdæaPi)alcRmúHRtÚveKkm©at;ecj.

etgmanGakar³xwgRceLaty:agxøaMg. Kat;)anniyayedaysmþIF¶n;²fa ³ «´minyl;esaHfa ehtu

GVI)anCamanGñkxøHcg;rlas; b:ul Bt ecal? BitEmnEtfa Kat;)anRbRBwtþxusxøHEmnkalBIGtIt

kalb:uEnþsBVéf¶ KWKat;enHehIyEdldwknaMkarRbyuT§RbqaMgnwgBYkQøanBanevotNamenaH»51.

PaBtantwgEdlenAdk;Cab;kñúgépÞrdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyümansPaBrwtEtF¶n;F¶r

eLIg²edaysarkarKMramsuMlaElgBItMENgrbs; semþc sIhnu mþgeTot. semþc)anmanRBHraC

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg438

Page 449: Brother enemy

bnÞÚlCasm¶at;R)ab;shkarImñak;TaMgtUcRBHT½yfa ³ «munRbeTskm<úCaTTYl)anÉkraCüPaB ´man

ecAhVayEtmYyKt;KWRbeTs)araMg. bnÞab;BI)at;bg;ÉkraCüPaB´manecAhVaydl;eTAR)aMbIÉeNaH».

ecAhVayTaMgR)aMbI KWRbeTsR)aMmYyénsmaKmGas‘an RbeTscin nigshrdæGaemrik.

enAExvicäika qñaM1984 semþc)anesñIsuMlaElgBItMENgykEtEmnETn. RBHGgÁ)anyageTA

eFVITsSnkic©enARbeTs)araMg ehIyBaküccamGar:amepSg²)anelcB¤sussayminRBm)at;sþIBIkar

CYbKñarbs;RBHGgÁCamYy h‘un Esn rdæm®nþIkarbreTsrbs;rdæaPi)al ehg sMrin EdleBlenaH kMBug

eFVITsSnkic©CaÉkCnenArdæFanIRbeTs)araMgEdr. enAéf¶TI22 Exvicäika qñaM1984 GaruN panuBgS

ÉkGKÁraCTUtRbeTséfRbcaMRbeTs)araMg)ancUlrYmkñúgsnñisITmYyrbs;GgÁkarG‘uyeNsáÚ nig)an

eRtómxøÜneLIgEføgsunÞrkfamYyCaeRscenAeBlEdlKat;)anTTYlTUrelxmYyBIemekayrbs;Kat;KW

siT§I saev:tsuILa EdlesñI[Kat;sVHEsVgeFVIy:agNa[mankarNat;CYbKñamYyCabnÞan;rvag semþc

sIhnu nigrUbKat;¬siT§I¦. eBlenaH siT§I )aneLIgCiHynþehaHmYyeRKÓgrbs;Rkúmhu‘néf GnþrCati

eRsceTAehIykñúgdMeNIreq<aHeTATIRkúg):arIs edIm,Isakl,gXat;XaMgsemþckuM[laElgBItMENg.

GaruN )ancakecjy:agRbjab;Rbjal;BIsnñisIT edayBuM)anEføgsunÞrkfarbs;Kat;pgeT.

enAeBlEdl GaruN eTACYbsemþc Kat;)anTUlsYrfa etIBitEmneTEdlfa RBHGgÁ)andak;

BaküsuMlaElgBItMENgCUneTA exov sMpn CafµIenaH?. GaruN )anerobrab;enAeBleRkaymkfa ³

«RBHGgÁ)anbeBa©jRBHBieraFPøamEtmþg». «´FujRTan;nwgerOgenHNas;. ´Elgcg;eFVIGVITaMgGs;

CamYyrdæaPi)alcRmúHenHehIy». PaBRceLattUgtagrbs;semþc)anbnþedayRBHbnÞÚlcMGkepSg²

EdlRBHGgÁFøab;rgTTYlBIsMNak;BYk)atukrsñiT§ sWn san kalBIdb;BIréf¶munenATIRkúgmInna pUlIs kñúg

rdæmIeNsUta shrdæGaemrik. kalebIrsaykMhwgehIy RBHGgÁ)anseRmcRBHT½y sUmGeBa¢Ij siT§I

[mkcUlrYmbriePaKGaharenAsNæaKarrbs;RBHGgÁKg;Rbfab;enAtMbn;CayRkúg):arIsEdr. GaruN

)anPa¢b;karTak;Tgnwg siT§I EdlkMBugsßitenAkñúgynþehaHrbs;Kat; edaymeFüa)ayviTüúrbs;Rkúmh‘unéf

GnþrCatiCabnÞan;. enAeBlmkdl;cMNtGakasyandæansðaldWehÁalminTan;)anRsYlbYlpg GaruN

)annaM siT§I mkbriePaKGaharenAsNæaKar semþc sIhnu edayKµanEGGg;eLIy. edayeqøót»kas

kñúgeBlbriePaKGaharEdlmanmðÚbcMnYndb;BIrmux siT§I )anEføgefáaleTaskarnaMbgáehtuénBYkyuT§ikCn

rbs; sWn san ehIy)anbBa©úHbBa©Úlsemþc[sßitenACaemdwknaMrdæaPi)alcRmúHteTAeTot. enAyb;

éf¶dEdlenaH siT§I )ank¥Ütceg¥areBjkñúgLanEdlkMBugdwkKat; edayeBjel,Óneq<aHmkTIRkúg):arIs

vij. rfynþEmrsWedsmYyeRKÓgRtÚveFVI[RbLak;Gs; ³ etIenHCatémøEdlRtÚvbg;y:agéføbMput

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 439

Page 450: Brother enemy

sRmab;PaBKg;vgSénrdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüb¤?52.

bYnExeRkaymk semþc sIhnu )aneFVIkarKMramsuMlaElgBItMENgCafµI edayelIkenH RBHGgÁ

sMGagelImUlehtusuxPaB. tamBitkarseRmccitþrbs;RBHGgÁmanRbPBCaedImehtuKW edaysarkar

bdiesFrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgminsnÞnaCamYyRkúghaNUy. bNþardæm®nþIkarbreTsénsmaKmGas‘an

)anrYmRbCMuKñaCabnÞan;enATIRkúg)an;Dug¬RbeTs\NÐÚensuI¦ ehIy)antak;EtgesckþIGMBavnavrYmKñamYy

cMeBaHsemþc kñúgeKalbMNgsUm[RBHGgÁesIerIkarseRmcRBHT½yrbs;RBHGgÁeLIgvij. semþc)an

yl;RBm b:uEnþenAExkkáda qñaM1985 RBHGgÁ)anecaTRbkan;CasaFarN³fa édKUrbs;RBHGgÁKWExµr

Rkhm)ansmøab;yuT§ik³rbs;RTg;Gs;cMnYn38nak;. CagenHeTAeTot RBHGgÁ)anRbkasfa «kar

seRmcRBHT½ycakecjBIrdæaPi)alcRmúHnwgBMuGacERbRkLas;)aneLIy». rdæaPi)alcRmúHkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyümanCIvitKg;enAminCal¥ minCaGaRkk;¬Fmµta¦ eTaHCamanvibtþiépÞkñúgrbs;xøÜnk¾eday.

eBjfirevlaénrdUvR)aMgqañM1984-1985 EdlkarvayRbyuT§Kñad¾twgEtgbMput)anb:HBal;dl;

PaBKYr[Tukcitþrbs;RBHGgÁ. karvayluky:agxøaMgkøamYykñúgry³eBlR)aMEx edayeRbIR)as;kaMePøIg

FMnigrfeRkaH edIm,IvayRbharbNþaCMrMsIuvilnigmUldæankgT½BnanaenAtamRBMEdnExµr-éf evotNam

)aneFVI[EdndIEdlKµanPaBR)akdrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyürgkarxUcxaty:agF¶n;F¶r. evotNam)an

deNþImykBIExµrRkhmCaBiessmUldæanpÁt;pÁg;sMxan;²CaeRcIn nigFanIEdleKminGacykCakareQµaH

PUmifµIEdlksageLIgkñúgéRBs,atEk,rRBMEdnrbs;éf ehIyCakEnøgmYyEdlsemþc sIhnu TTYllixit

sartaMgrbs;ÉkGKÁrdæTUtnanarbs;breTsedaykareRkbRsasaM):ajpg. bnÞab;BIkarvayluk

rbs;evotNam clnats‘UmanenAsl;EtmUldæanmYyb:ueNÑaHenAelITwkdIrbs;km<úCa. ExµrRkhm)an

bgçMcitþbMEbkkgT½Brbs;xøÜn CakgÉkPaBtUc²nigBRgaycUlmképÞkñúgRbeTsvij. RbCaCnsuIvilcMnYn

46>000nak; EdlsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;xøÜn)anEsVgrkTICRmkenARbeTséf. BYkyuT§ikCn

rbs;semþc nig sWn san RBmTaMgCnePosxøÜncMnYn250>000nak; EdlRtÚvTTYl[sñak;enAtam

CMrMnanaEdlRtÜtRta edayclnats‘UenAEk,rRBMEdnéfenaHRbEhlCadkfyeTARBMEdnmçageTot.

braC½yEpñkeyaFaenHbgðaj[eXIjc,as;nUvPaBTn;exSayEpñkmenaKmviC¢a nigkarxVHkarerobcM

nigkarhVwkhat;rbs;RkúmminEmnkumµúynIsþTaMgLay CaBiessrNsirSCatirMedaHRbCaBlrdæExµr.

CaRkúmminsUvbþÚrpþac;kñúgCMenOhYsehtuNamYydUcExµrRkhm TahanénRkúmminEmnkumµúynIsþTaMgenaH

mincg;e)aHbg;RKÜsarrbs;xøÜn edIm,ImkeFVIs®gÁamT½BéRBxagkñúgRbeTseLIy. GñkRbyuT§sIhnuniym

)andwknaMkmøaMgeFVIkarlukluykñúgEdndIsRtÚvdac;²BIKña kñúgeKalbMNgeFVIkareXasnab:ueNÑaH b:uEnþ

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg440

Page 451: Brother enemy

enARKaEdl)at;bg;CMrMGs; yuT§Cn14>000nak;rbs;rNsirSCatirMedaHRbCaBlrdæExµr)anRtÚveFVI[

Føak;kñúgsßanPaBElgrIklUtlas;Tal;EtesaH. nayTahanCaeRcInnak;rbs;rNsirSCatirMedaHRbCa

BlrdæExµr minsUvcUlcitþrebobdwknaM«pþac;kar»rbs; sWn san b:unµaneLIy ehIyk¾mincUlcitþkar

eRCótERCkrbs;Kat;kñúgkic©kareyaFa nigkarbdiesFrbs;Kat; minshkarCamYysemþc sIhnu Edr.

enATIbMput kMhwgEdlminbgðajlkçN³mkxageRkA)anERbkøayeTACakarbHe)arCacMhenAExFñÚ qñaM

1985. smaKmGas‘an)aneFVIGnþraKmn_edIm,Irm¶ab;GFikrN_enH ehIykarcat;EcgdwknaMTahanrbs;

rNsirSCatirMedaHRbCaBlrdæExµrRtÚvFøak;eTAelIédTahanéfvij.

xøaXµúM dak;eCIgmkTisxagt,Úg

edIm,IRTRTg;clnats‘UnigrdæaPi)alcRmúHEdleXøgeXøag[enAKg;vgSdEdlenaH smaKmGas‘an

)anpøas;bþÚreKaledArbs;xøÜnCafµI ³ beBa©ósmhaGMNacFM²[putBIGasuIGaeKñy_. kñúgry³eBl6qñaM

EdlmanbnÞab;BIkarcUllukluyRbeTskm<úCa eKeXIjmankarBRgwgkmøaMgd¾sem,ImGs©arümYyén

vtþmaneyaFarbs;sUevotkñúgmhasmuRT):asuIhVik EdlyktRmab;tamedayshrdæGaemrikEdr.

edayeqøótTajykKuNRbeyaCn_BIPaBÉekarbs;evotNamnigsßanPaBesdækic©RbkbedayeRKaHfñak;

nigkarKMramkMEhgrbs;cin RkúgmUsÁÚ)aneFVIxøÜneTACaGñkkarBarRbeTsevotNamd¾sMxan;bMput. CafñÚr

mkvij BYksUevotRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[taMgmUldæaneyaFaCaeRcInkEnøg EdlRkúghaNUyFøab;cecs

bdiesFtaMgBI4qñaMmkehIy. kñúgry³eBl2qñaMEdlmanCabnþbnÞab;BIkarQøanBanrbs;cin RkúgmUsÁÚ

)anpÁt;pÁg;sBaVvuFeTARkúghaNUymantémørhUtdl;2ekadiduløar ¬2>000landuløar¦ KWeRcInCag

qñaM1978cMnYndb;dg. tmkeTot karRbKl;smÖarswk)anRtÚvfycuH b:uEnþTMhMCamFüménCMnYy

eyaFarbs;sUevotenAEtmancMnYnRbEhl750landuløarkñúgmYyqñaM²Edr. RkúghaNUy)anTTYl

CaBiessnUvsmÖarcas;²EdlbNþaRbeTsénktikasBaØa v:asUvI ¬bc©úb,nñrlay)at;Rsemal¦ nig

sm<½n§mitþdéT²eTotrbs;sUevotTukecalElgeRbIeTAehIy b:uEnþevotNamRtÚvEtbgðajnUvkardwg

KuNxøH²dUceKdUcÉgEdr. cab;BIéf¶enHeTATVarTaMgGs;rbs;RbeTs)anebIkcMhy:agFMsRmab;buKÁlik

eFVIkarrbs;sUevot. enAqñaM1986 eKeXIjmanTIRbwkSasUevotRbcaMkarenAevotNamRbEhl

2>000nak;Tl;nwg25nak;b:ueNÑaHkalBIedImqñaM1977. mü:ageTot xagEpñkCMnYybec©keTsman

CMnajkarsUevotRbEhl3>000nak;)aneFVIkarenAtamkardæanepSg²eRcInkEnøg CaBiesskEnøg

rukrkeRbgkatenAlMhsmuRTEk,reqñrevotNam. tamRkúmesIubkarN_sm¶at;GaemrikaMg)an[dwgfa

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 441

Page 452: Brother enemy

taMgBIqñaM1979 TMhMénCMnYyEpñkesdækic©rbs;sUevot)aneLIgdl;1>000landuløarkñúgmYyqñaM 53.

kñúgeBlCamYuyKñaenaH shPaBsUevot)anbegáItCMnYyesdækic©nigeyaFarbs;xøÜneTARbeTsLavnig

km<úCapgEdr nigBRgwgvtþmanrbs;xøÜnenARbeTsTaMgBIrrwtEtxøaMgeLIgEfmeTot.

evotNam)anbg;bMNulrbs;BYkeK[BYksUevotbnþicmþg²Caerogral;Ex>>>. db;mYyéf¶ bnÞab;BI

karcab;epþImcUlQøanBanrbs;cin paM v:an;dug )aneFVIdMeNIredaysm¶at;eTAkan;TIRkúgmUsÁÚ. enAExmIna

qñaM1979 eRkaydMeNIrvilRtLb;rbs;Kat;bnþic navaKaMRTCaeRcIneRKÓgénkgnavaesIubkarN_

sUevotenAsmuRTcinxagt,Úg )ane)aHyufáasMctenAkMBg;Ep daNag54. R)akdNas; karGnuBaØatenH

BitCapþl;ePøIgébtgeday dug kñúg»kasénkarsnÞnaepSg²EdlKat;)aneFVIenATIRkúgmUsÁÚ. tamGñk

CMnajkarGaemrikaMgfa karBRgwgvtþmaneyaFarbs;sUevotrwtEteRcIneLIgenARbeTsevotNam KWCa

lT§plénkic©RBmeRBógedayELk Edl)anseRmckñúgGMLúgeBlmankarCYbKñaedayeTogTat;rvagGñk

TTYlxusRtÚvénRbeTsTaMgBIr BuMEmnCakic©snüamYyEdlmanry³eBlminkMNt; b¤karCYlmankMNt;

nUvTItaMgnanarbs;evotNameT. maRtaTI6énsiTi§sBaØasUevot-evotNam)anEcgkarBarCamunfa

RtÚvCYbeFVIkarBieRKaHKñakñúgkrNIEdlmankarKMramkMEhgdl;snþisuxrbs;PaKIhtßelxI nigkarRbkan;

ykviFankarsmRsbedIm,IRbQmmuxTl;nwgkarKMramkMEhgenaH.

kan;Etmann½yCak;lak;eTAeTot enAéf¶TI27 ExmIna qñaM1979 kgnavaeCIgTwktUcmYyrYmman

naval,atebIkmuxk,ÜnmYyeRKÓg navaRbedjel,ÓnelOnmYyeRKÓg nignavaRsg;mInmYyeRKÓg)an

e)aHyufáaQb;sMctenAqksmuRTkaMr:aj; CaTIkEnøgEdlnavasUevoteRcIneRKÓgFøab;mke)aHyufáa Ca

elIkdMbUgbMputtaMgBIéf¶TI12 Exemsa qñaM1905em:øH. enAéf¶enaHnavamYykgFMmancMnYn42eRKÓg

EdldwknaMeday]tþmnavIniymesþctSar eQµaH suINUvI r:Uedsv:gsÁI )aneRCótcUlmkkñúgqksmuRT

enH. PaBxusKñaEtmYyKt;KWkalBI qñaM1905 enATIenaHmanEtkEnøgykFüÚgfµmYyb:ueNÑaH EdlBi)ak

sñak;GaRs½yenApgnigEdlkan;kab;edayBYk)araMgpg. BYkenH)anbBa¢a[kgnavarbs;sUevotcak

ecjBITIenaH edIm,IkarBarGBüaRkwtPaBrbs;RbeTskñúgs®gÁamrvagsUevot-Cb:un. 74qñaMeRkay BYk

GaemrikaMg)anbnSl;TukBIeRkayBYkeKnUvmUldæanGakascr nigmUldæannavacrmYyEdlmansarsMxan;

xøaMgCageKbMput. enATIbMput mUldæanenHk¾køayeTACamUldæannavacry:agFMrbs;BYksUevotvij nig

CakMBg;EpQb;sMctd¾sMxan;rbs;eKenAeRkAshPaBsUevot ehIyk¾Ca«mUldæan »sRmab;karvatTIén

kgnavacrrbs;xøÜn enAsmuRTcinPaKxagt,Úg nigmhasmuRT\NÐaEdr.

GaRs½yedaykarseRmctaMgBIdMbUgmYy BYksUevotminksagmUldæanT½BNamYyenATwkdI

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg442

Page 453: Brother enemy

RbeTseRkAEdlGacRtÚve)aHbg;ecalvijeLIy elIkElgEtmUldæankaMr:aj;enAevotNammYy

b:ueNÑaH. enATIenaHmansßanIyQøbcaMsþab;mYysRmab;kt;RtaTuknUvclnakgnavacrrbs;GaemrikaMg nigcin

enAkñúgsmuRTcinxagt,Úg. k¾b:uEnþ BYksUevot)anbegáIncMnYnnavaFM²nigynþehaHrbs;xøÜn EdltaMg

mUldæanenAqksmuRTkaMr:ajmþgbnþic² b:uEnþedayKµanP½ynwgGnþray. navaEdlbBa¢ÚnmkenAqñaM

1979manBI5eTA10eRKÓg nigBI25eTA35eRKÓgenAqñaM1985. cMENkynþehaHeK)anbBa¢Ún

mkCamFüm mYyéf¶BI10eTA15eRKÓgenAqñaM1979 nigBI35eTA40eRKÓgenAry³eBl6qñaMeRkay

mkeTot. CamYyynþehaHTmøak;RKab;EbksRmab;vayRbhartamsmuRTcMnYn16eRKÓg m:ak Badger

ynþehaHMIG-23mYykg EdlGaceFVIGnþraKmn_RKb;eBleTaHCasßanPaB]tuniymEbbNak¾eday

bUkbEnßmnwgynþehaHdwkCBa¢Ún nigynþehaHesuIbkarN_CaeRcInEdlsuT§EtsMctenAevotNamTaMgGs;

)aneFVI[smtßPaBeFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;shPaBsUevotenAPUmiPaKGasuIGaeKñy_elOnhYsBIbMNgd¾x¢ab;x¢Ün

minsmehtuplrbs;xøÜnmunqñaM1978eTAeTot. enAedImqñaM1986 shPaBsUevot)ankøayeTACa

mhaGMNaceCIgTwkmYykñúgcMeNammhaGMNaceCIgTwkdMbUg²enAGasuI 55 ³ navaFM²rbs;sUevotBI20

eTA25eRKÓg rYmTaMgnavamuCTwkmYycMnYnpg )anebIkbrl,atRcvat;RcEvgenAsmuRTcinPaKxagt,Úg

edayerobcMbRmúgqksmuRTkaMr:aj;[eTACakEnøgsRmab;pÁt;pÁg;es,ógGahar eRbg\n§n³ RKab;rMesv

nigG‘UsRmab;CYsCulk):al;pg. edayehtuenH RkúgmUsÁÚGacBRgaykmøaMgrbs;xøÜnkñúgmhasmuRT

\NÐacMnYnBIrdgxøaMgCagkalBIGtItkal. ebIRkeLkemIleTAeRkayvij kareRCIserIsrbs;Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI

kñúgkarKaMRTRbeTscinedIm,IvayRbharlT§ivatTIniymrbs;sUevotGacmanpøÚvG‘utehIy.

RckpøÚvEdlnaMeTArkkarcab;epþIm)anRtÚvbiT

enARbeTskm<úCa s®gÁamT½BéRB)ankeRBa¢aleLIgy:agxøaMgkñúgbribTénkarBRgwgkmøaMgeyaFar

bs;sUevotenA\NÐÚcin. k¾b:uEnþ bnÞab;BIry³eBlBIrqñaMéndMeNIrTsSkic©CaRbvtþisa®sþrbs; etg enA

Rkúgv:asuInetan PaBcaM)ac;CayuT§sa®sþEdlFøab;eFVI[BYkGaemrikaMgelgsnøwkebocinElgdUcmuneTot

ehIy. sm<½n§PaBCayuT§sa®sþrvagcin-GaemrikEdl Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI ts‘Uy:agsVitsVajeFVI[)an

seRmcenAqñaM1978)ancab;epþImCYbkarlM)akCamYykareRCIstaMgelak rU:Nal; rIEhÁn 56 Ca

RbFanaFibtIEdl)ansnüakñúgGMLúgeBleFVIkareXasnarksMeLgeqñatfa Kat;nwgEklm¥TMnak;TMng

epSg²rvagshrdæGaemriknigétv:an;[)anl¥RbesIrCagmun. rhUtmkdl;qñaM1980 eTIbsm<½n§PaB

enH)anTTYlEpøpáa ¬bnÞab;BIkarlukluyRbeTsGahVháanIsßanedayBYksUevot¦eRkamTRmg;Cash-

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 443

Page 454: Brother enemy

RbtibtþikarmYyxagsnþisuxTak;Tgnwgvis½yCaeRcIn. kñúgeBlCamYyKñaenaH RbeTscin )ancab;epþIm

BinitüeLIgvijkñúgkarsRmbEpñkyuT§sa®sþrbs;xøÜntamshrdæGaemrik sRmab;mUlehtuepSg²xag

neya)aykñúgRbeTs. kalebIkarTas;ETgKñarbs;xøÜn CamYyRkúgv:asuInetan sþIBIbBaðalk;GavuF

eTA[étv:an;køayCac,as;las;ehIyenaH-CabBaðaEdlTukminTan;seRmckñúgkic©RBmeRBógrYmmYyenA

ExFñÚ qñaM1978 edIm,IRbjab;cg;eXIjkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBecjCalT§plsin-neya)aybreTs

rbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgk¾pøas;bþÚrTisEdr. BIesckþIGMBavnav[mankarcat;taMgrNsirSrYbrYmmYyRbqaMgnwg

RkúgmUsÁÚEdlGYteday etg s‘avBIg RbeTscin)anEbreTAcgsamKÁIPaBCamYybNþaRbeTsttiy

elakvij nigEsVgrkkareFVIshRbtibtþikarxagesdækic©CaCagkarRbQmmuxdak;Kña. kartRmg;TisfµI

enHmanRbeyaCn_sRmab;RbeTsTaMgGs;rYmTaMgshPaBsUevot nigGWr:ubxagekItpg b:uEnþelIkElgEt

RbeTsevotNammYyb:ueNÑaH. enAcugqñaM1981 lI s‘annan ]bnaykrdæm®nþIcin)anRbkasfa

RbeTsrbs;Kat;R)afñabnþdMeNIreFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚeLIgvij Edl)anp¥aktaMgBIman

karlukluyRbeTsGahVháanIsßanmk.

edayeqøótTajykRbeyaCn_BIPaBtantwgrvagRkúgv:asIunetannigRkúgeb:kaMg shPaBsUevot

)aneFV IRbtikmµedayGnueRKaHcMeBaHkarkeRmIkCafµ InUvykcitþTukdak;BIsMNak;RbeTscinenH.

enAéf¶TI24 ExmIna qñaM1982 eLGUnId eRbseNv GKÁelxabkSkumµúynIsþsUevot)ansEmþg[dwgCa

saFarN³nUvbMNgEklm¥TMnak;TMngepSg²rvagRbeTsTaMgBIreLIgvij. edayrMlwkTaMgRbúgRby½tñfa

RkúgmUsÁÚminEdlyl;RsbnwgniekçbbTRbeTscinBIreLIy Kat;ecosvagminecaTBYkcinfa «Cnk,t;nwg

lT§im:akS-elnIn»dUckalBIedImeT ³ «eyIgminEdlCMTas; ehIy\LÚvenHeyIgminCMTas;BIGtßiPaBén

RbB½n§sgÁmniymmYyenARbeTscineT»57. Rkúgeb:kaMg)ansgsmþIeTAvijPøam² edaybgçM[Rkúg

mUsÁÚdkecalnUv]bsKÁcMnYnbIkñúgkareFVI[manRbRttIPaBrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr EdlRbeTscin cat;Tukfa

CakarKMramkMEhgdl;snþisuxrbs;xøÜn ³

1¦ karKaMRTrbs;sUevotcMeBaHkarkan;kab;RbeTskm<úCaedayevotNam.

2¦ karkan;kab;RbeTsGahVhÁanIsßan edayBYksUevot.

3¦ karBRgayT½By:agsem,ImenAtamRBMEdncin.

R)aMBIrExeRkaymk karCYbcrcaKñasþIBIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaB)ancab;epþImCafµI.

ebITukCamankarFanaEdlGHGagCasaFarN³eday eRbseNv fakarxitcUlCitKñaCamYy

RbeTscinnwgmineFVI[«xUcRbeyaCn_dl;RbeTsTIbI»k¾eday k¾RkúghaNUyRtÚveFVI[Gak;Gn;kñúgcitþ

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg444

Page 455: Brother enemy

edaykarebIkkic©crcaenHrYcCaeRsc. enHBuMEmnCaelIkTImYyeT EdlmhaGMNacCamitþmñak;)an

lHbg;plRbeyaCn_rbs;evotNamsRmab;GtßRbeyaCn_CayuT§sa®sþpÞal;rbs;xøÜnenaH. b:uEnþ kar

CYbKñaCabnþbnÞab;cMnYnR)aMBIrelIk rvagcinnigsUevotEdlRbRBwtþeTAcab;BIsrTrdUvqñaM1982 hak;dUc

CaBuMnaMeTAdl;PaBFUrRsalNamYysþIBIkarKaMRTrbs;sUevoteLIy. edayCak;Esþg RkúgmUsÁÚ k¾mineFVI

[maneRKaHfñak;dl;eKaledACayuT§sa®sþrbs;xøÜnenARbeTsevotNam edIm,IbMeBjcitþcinEdr. fVIebI

man«]bsKÁ»CaeRcInEdlRtÚvedaHRsayCabnÞan;k¾eday k¾TMnak;TMngEpñkesdækic©BaNiC¢kmµ nigvb,Fm’

rvagRbeTscinnigshPaBsUevot)anrIklUtlas;KYr[kt;smÁal;. ]TahrN_enAqñaM1985 mankar

pøas;bþÚrKN³RbtiPUeTAvijeTAmkrvagRbeTsTaMgBIrelIsBIR)aMBIrelIk. bnÞab;BITsSnkic©CaelIkdMbUg

enARbeTscinnaExFñÚ qñaM1984 rbs;GñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;sUevotmñak; KW]bnaykrdæm®nþI GIuv:an;

GaXIb:Uv nigTsSnkic©rbs;]bnaykrdæm®nþIcin y:av yIlIn enAshPaBsUevotkñúgExkkáda qñaM1985

RkúgmUsÁÚ)anyl;RBmsnüapþl;hirBaØvtßúsRmab;kareFVITMenIbkmµxagEpñk]sSahkmµcMnYndb;R)aMBIrkEnøg

nigsßabnaeragcRkfµIcMnYnR)aMBIreTot. kic©RBmeRBógmYyEdlcuHhtßelxaenAqñaM1985)anEcgfa

BaNiC¢kmµ Ca]PetaPaKInwgRtÚvbegáIncMnYnmYyKuNnwgdb;BIrdg kñúgry³eBlR)aMqñaM. Rkúgeb:kaMg)an

bnþTamTarfa TMnak;TMngCak;lak;xagneya)aynwgGacEklMG[)anRbesIrelIsmunEtdrabNa«]bsKÁ»

epSg² CaBiess]bsKÁsþIBIRbeTskm<úCanwgRtÚv)andkecjedayRkúgmUsÁÚ. b:uEnþkarTak;TgKña

CaeRcIneTotecHEtmanCahUrEhkñúgkRmitshCIBnigGgÁkaryuvCn ehIyrdæm®nþIkarbreTsénRbeTs

TaMgBIr)aneRKageFVIdMeNIrTsSnkic©eTAvijeTAmkEfmeTotenAqñaM1986.

b:uEnþRkúgeb:kaMgenAEtminTukcitþTal;EtesaHcMeBaHRkúgmUsÁÚEdlbgðaj[eXIjkarKMramkMEhg

yUrGEgVgmYycMeBaHRbeTscindEdl. b:uEnþ edaymanTMnak;TMngCitsñiT§nwgsUevot KWvaGacpþl;KuN

RbeyaCn_xagEpñkesdækic© ehIynwgpþl;CameFüa)aymYy[RkúgmUsÁÚeFVIkarekobsgát;xagcitþsa®sþ

eTAelIRbeTsevotNam EdlGacCMruj[RbeTsenHEsVgrkkarsRmbsRmÜlmYyCamYyRbeTscin.

CakarCak;c,as;Nas; edaymaneKaledAsabeRBaHnUvPaBmnÞilsgS½yrvagRkúgmUsÁÚ nigRkúghaNUy

etg s‘avBIg )anRbkasR)ab;emdwknaMGWr:ubmñak;enAedImqñaM1985fa RbeTscin nwgminCMTas;kartaMg

mUldæanT½BmYyrbs;sUevotenAqksmuRTkaMr:aj;eLIy ebIsinCaevotNamcakecjBIRbeTskm<úCa

enaH58. enHRbEhlCasmþIRbkbedayl,icklsuT§saF b:uEnþvaKYr[rIkraypgEdr EdlsmÁal;

eXIjfa etg )aneFVIbRBa©aseTAnwgeKalCMhrrbs;cinkalBIBak;kNþalTsvtSr_70 EdlenAeBl

enaHRkúgeb:kaMg)anRBmanBiPBelakTaMgmUlminQb;Qr[RbqaMgnwgBYkGnutþrPaBsUevot nigKeRmag

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 445

Page 456: Brother enemy

karbegáItmUldæanmYyrbs;eKenAqksmuRTkaMr:aj;. enAedImqñaM1986 edayGs;sgÇwmnwgkar)at;

mineXIjkaresñIeFVIkic©crcaBIsMNak;shPaBsUevotsþIBIbBaðaTaMgLayEdlelIkeLIgedayRbeTscin

Rkúgeb:kaMg)anbegáInkareXasnavaylukrbs;xøÜn RbqaMgnwgRkúgmUsÁÚCafµI. CMhrrbs;xøÜnTak;Tgnwg

RbeTskm<úCaBMumanERbRbÜleLIy ehIyedIm,IeFVI[shrdæGaemriknigRbeTséfeCOCak; nigbgðajBIkar

seRmccitþ ¬bnÞab;BIkarraErkd¾yUr¦rbs;xøÜn[RkúgmUsÁÚeXIj RbeTscin)anbegáInnUvkarTmøak;RKab;

EbkdMNalKñanwgkarqµk;vayRbharedayTahanefµIreCIgeTAelIRbeTsevotNamrwtEtxøaMgeLIgEdr.

CamYykareLIgkan;GMNacrbs; mIxaGuIlhÁ½r)aqUv RkúgmUsÁÚ)anbnþpþl;CMnYyesdækic©nigeyaFa

mYyeTA[RbeTsevotNameTot b:uEnþ)antRmÚv[begáInkarnaMecjksiplrbs;evotNam nigkar

RKb;RKgd¾muWgm:at;mYyeTAelICMnYyEdl)anpþl;[. cMENkkarKaMRTrbs;sUevotkñúgerOgr:avrbs;km<úCa

k¾RtÚv)anGHGagCapøÚvkarEdr. kñúg»kasénkareFVIGnþraKmn_CaelIkdMbUgrbs;Kat;sþIBIbBaðaPUmiPaK

GasuIGaeKñy_ Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTssUevot mIxaGuIlkaBItsa )anvaytémøfa sßankarN_enARbeTs

km<úCa«minGacERbRkLas;)aneLIy» nig)anniyayTukCamunfa «]bsKÁTaMgbI» Edlerobrab;eday

RbeTscin enATIbMputnwgrlay)at;CamYyeBlevlaminxan. CaÉkCn BYkemdwknaMsUevot)ansEmþg

[eXIjlkçN³minsUvmansuTidæiniymb:unµaneT. BYkeK)ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa karbnþCemøaHteTAeTotnwg

pþl;«GtßRbeyaCn_TaMgRsugsRmab;BYkGaemrikaMgenAGasuIGaeKñy_» eFVI[sµúKsµajdl;TMnak;TMngepSg²

rvagGas‘annigshPaBsUevot nigkRmitRBMEdnvtþmanrbs;sUevotkñúgtMbn;d¾manfamBlmYy kñúg

cMeNamtMbn;d¾manfamBlTaMgLayénBiPBelak. QmmuxnwgkarpuseLIgnUvclnaGñkCatiniymExµr

vaRbEhlCaRbesIrNas;sRmab;RbeTsevotNamedIm,IdkxøÜnfyBIRbeTskm<úCa. enAExFñÚ qñaM

1985 GñkÉkeTssUevotxagbBaðaGasuId¾eqñImmñak;)anniyayR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦edayRtg;²fa ³

«RbeTsevotNamKYrEtEsVgrkkarsRmbsRmÜlmYyCamYyRbeTscinehIy. evotNamBMuGac

GnuBaØat[manRbeTscinmYyEdlCasRtÚvenACab;nwgRBMEdnrbs;xøÜnCanic©nirnþr_enaHeLIy»59.

enAqñaM1985 RckEdlnaMecjeTArkkarcab;epþImRtÚv)anbiT. db;qñaMeRkayeBlEdl

]T§mÖaKcRkcugeRkayrbs;GaemrikaMgcakecjBIRkúgéRBnKr bNþardæm®nþIkarbreTsrbs;\NÐÚcin

)aneFVIkarGMBavnavmYycMeBaHshrdæGaemrik edayesñI[sEmþgCafµInUvtYnaTIsßabnamYykñúgtMbn;enH.

karcab;epþImeFVI[manPaBFURsalrvagcin-sUevot RtÚvrab;bBa©Úlkñúgkarpøas;bþÚrKMnitPøam²enHEdr

ehIyCemøaHEdleFVI[rdæ)alrIehÁnRbQmmuxnwgRkúgeb:kaMgBIbBaðaétv:an;enaH)anCYyCMruj[Rkúg

haNUyEbrRtLb;eTArksRtÚvkalBIeBlfµI²rbs;xøÜnvij.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg446

Page 457: Brother enemy

enAqñaM1982 enAeBlEdlelak hSk s‘Ul eLIgkan;tMENgCMnYs GaLic hSg;D½r ehk enAkñúg

zan³CaemdwknaMneya)aykarbreTsrbs;GaemrikaMg shrdæGaemrik)ancab;epþImsgS½yBIpl

RbeyaCn_CayuT§sa®sþ EdlRbeTscinGacsEmþgCMnYsxøÜn. R)akdNas; Rkúgeb:kaMgenAEtCatYÉk

d¾sMxan;mYykñúgtMbn;EdlCaTIpSard¾manskþanuBly:agsem,ImmYysRmab;BaNiC¢kmµnigBYkvinieyaKin

GaemrikaMg ehIybgáCakmøaMgTb;d¾elIslubmYyTl;nwg\T§iBlrbs;sUevotenAGasuI. k¾b:uEnþ RbeTscin

ElgCacMNucsMxan;sRmab;yuT§sa®sþrbs;GaemrikaMgeTotehIy. Rkúgv:asuInetan emIlBMueXIjpl

vi)akcMeBaHGVIEdlRkúgeb:kaMgeFVIkarKabsgát;eTAelIRbeTsevotNameT b:uEnþeKaledATaMgLayrbs;

GaemrikaMgcMeBaHRbeTskm<úCamanlkçN³xusKñaedayCak;Esþg. edayeFVI[xUcRbeyaCn_dl;RbeTs

cin rdækarrIehÁn)anRbkasnUvkarCMTas;rbs;xøÜnCaerOy²cMeBaHkarvilRtLb;rbs;ExµrRkhmmkkan;

GMNacvij. shrdæGaemrikminsUvefáaleTas[)anxøaMgkøadUcRbeTscineLIycMeBaHkarkan;kab;rbs;

evotNamelIRbeTskm<úCa b:uEnþkareFVIdUecñHKWedaysarGaemrik)armÖBIsßirPaBnigkarrYbrYmKñarbs;

Gas‘an nigedIm,IkarBarsnþisuxRbeTséfnigBMuEmneFVItRmÚvcitþBYkcineT. Rkúgv:asuInetan )anecosvag

KMnitpþÜcepþImCaÉktþCnTaMgGs;sþIBIbBaðakm<úCa b:uEnþenABIeRkayqakvij shrdæGaemrik)anCYyeRCam

ERCgGas‘an[begáItrdæaPi)alcRmúHmYysRmab;RbeTskm<úCa nigFanaEsVgrkC½yCmñH[rdæaPi)al

enHenAGgÁkarshRbCaCatiEfmeTot. enAqñaM1982 shrdæGaemrik)anepþImkmµviFIpþl;CMnYyeday

mincMeBaHmYy EdlmancMnYnTwkR)ak;15landuløarkñúgmYyqñaM sRmab;pþl;[édKUTaMgLayminEmnkumµúy

nIsþkñúgrdæaPi)alcRmúHtamry³RbeTsepSg²énsmaKmGas‘an. edayGnuelameTAtamninñakar

neya)ayfµIrbs;GaemrikaMgkñúgkarKaMRT «GñkRbyuT§edIm,IesrIPaB » RbqaMgkumµúynIsþkñúgTUTaMgBiPBelak

sPaCan;Tabrbs;GaemrikaMg)anseRmcenAqñaM1985GnuBaØat[pþl;CMnYyesdækic© b¤eyaFadl;clna

ts‘Urbs;km<úCaCapøÚvkarkñúgTwkR)ak;rhUtdl;eTA5landuløar.

enARkúghaNUy mansBaØafaeBlevlapøas;bþÚr eKminRBÜy)armÖedayhYsehtueBkeTBIkar

seRmccitþenH EdlrYmCakarCab;Bak;B½n§edaypÞal;elIkdMbUgrbs;shrdæGaemrikenA\NÐÚcin taMgBIqñaM

1975mk. eKBitCadwgBIlkçN³CanimitþrUbénerOgenHehIy CaBiesseKdwgNas;BIkarBRgIksßan

karN_CayuT§sa®sþEdlekItmanPøam²enAGasIuxagekIt. karKn;KUrrbs;evotNameFVI[eKnwkeXIj

dl;karKn;KUrkalBIqñaM1978Edr. munkarcuHhtßelxaelIsn§isBaØaCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ nigkareFVIGnþraKmn_

enARbeTskm<úCa RbeTsevotNam)anxMRbwgERbgTaMgGs;sgÇwm edIm,I[eFVITMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;xøÜn

CamYyRkúgv:asuInetanmanRbRktIPaB. bnÞab;BIry³eBlR)aMBIrqñaMkñúgkarBRgwg\T§iBlrbs;xøÜnenA

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 447

Page 458: Brother enemy

km<úCaknøgputeTARbeTsevotNam)anRbwgERbgP¢ab;cMNgTak;TgCafµICamYyshrdæGaemrik nig

begáInskmµPaBeTArkeKaledAGVImYyrbs;xøÜncMeBaHmuxRkúgmUsÁÚEfmeTot. ebITukCaeRKÓgsa®sþavuF

rbs;sUevot)anCYy[mankarpþÜlrlM b:ul Bt k¾eday k¾RbeTsevotNamkan;Etsb,aycitþeLIg²

fa TIbMputplRbeyaCn_Epñksnþisuxrbs;xøÜnenA\NÐÚcinGacnwgRtÚvFana)anEttamry³dMeNaHRsay

CaGnþrCatimYyb:ueNÑaH EdlkñúgenaH shrdæGaemriketagEtsEmþgtYnaTIKnøwHmYy. enARkúgv:asuInetan

\LÚvenHeKqøgputsm½yeRkay Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI ehIy ³ sm<½n§PaBCamYyRbeTscin)aneTACaerOgbnÞab;

bnSM pÞúyeTAvijeKyl;fa fVIebIsm<½n§PaBrbs;xøÜnCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚmansPaBCitsñiT§y:agNak¾eday

k¾RbeTsevotNamRKan;EtCaGay:gFmµtamYyb:ueNÑaH. Gnurdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTsGaemrikaMg rIqad

GarmIefc )anniyayR)ab;´¬GñkniBn§¦Casm¶at;fa «shPaBsUevot nigevotNam BMu)anerobkarenA

muxGacarüeT». Kat;eCOCak;fa sm<½n§PaBenHnwgedaHédecjBIKña enAeBlEdlPaKITaMgBIrElgrk)an

plRbeyaCn_rbs;xøÜnteTAeTot. eTaHbICashrdæGaemrikBMuTan;)aneRtómxøÜnRtLb;mksEmþgtYnaTId¾

skmµmYykñúgtMbn;dUcEdlRbCaCn\NÐÚcinRtÚvkark¾eday k¾rdækar rIehÁn )anbgðaj[evotNamdwgBI

meFüa)ayekobsgát;mYy edIm,IbgçM[shrdæGaemrikepþImeFVIkarsnÞnaeLIgvij edayniyayBIkar

edaHRsaybBaðaTahanGaemrikaMg)at;xøÜnenA\NÐÚcin cMnYn2>500nak;KWCa«GaTiPaBCatid¾sMxan;mYy».

edayeCOelIsBaØaelIkTwkcitþepSg²kñúgcMeNamCnCatievotNam enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1982 rIqat

GarmIefc )aneFVIdMeNIreTARkúghaNUy edIm,IBiPakSaBIbBaðaTahan)at;xøÜnkñúgs®gÁam. b:uEnþ dMeNIr

CaelIkdMbUgeTARkúghaNUyrbs;GñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;GaemrikaMgmñak;cab;taMgBIqñaM1977 fVId,itEt

)anTTYllT§plCak;lak;sþÜcesþIgk¾eday b:uEnþva)aneFVI[evotNamecjputBIPaBÉeka ehIyeFVI[

Rkúgeb:kaMg nigrdæFanIxøH²rbs;Gas‘anRBÜy)armÖdUcKña. edayGnuelameTAtamTisneya)ayfµIEdl

Rbkan;ykenAedImrdUvekþA qñaM1982 Rkúgv:asuInetanminTan;seRmccitþTTUcBIerOgenHeTAkan;Rkúg

haNUyenAeLIyeT eTaHbICasßankarN_rbs;km<úCaminpøas;bþÚrbnþicbnþÜck¾eday. bnÞab;BIkarCYbKña

kRmitx<s;CaeRcInelIk nigkareFVIdMeNIrd¾Cak;lak;mYycMnYn GdæiFatuTahanGaemrikaMgRbEhlmYyry

nak;)anRtÚvdwkykeTARsukvij. enAqñaM1985 RkúghaNUy QanrhUtdl;GnuBaØat[kgT½B

GaemrikaMgmYyRkúmeFVIkarrukrkGdæiFatuenAtamkEnøgFøak;ynþehaHEfmeTot. evotNamk¾)ansnüa

eFVIRKb;lT§PaBTaMgGs;rbs;xøÜn edIm,IedaHRsayBIbBaðaTahan)at;xøÜnkñúgs®gÁamkñúgry³eBlBIrqñaM.

enAedImqñaM1986 GarmIefc EdlGmdMeNIredayelak b:Ul v:UlhVÚvIt Gnurdæm®nþIkarbreTssRmab;

GasuIxagekIt nig ):asuIhVik )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan;RbeTsevotNam kñúgzan³CaemdwknaMKN³RbtiPU

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg448

Page 459: Brother enemy

GaemrikaMgmYyRkúm EdlCaKN³RbtiPUfñak;x<s;elIkdMbUg taMgBIebskkmµrbs;elak eLGUNard_ vUdxUk

mk. GarmIefc )anvilRtLb;mkRbeTsvijCamYykarFanaeFVIshRbtibtþimYyy:ageBjelj

BIsMNak;RbeTsevotNam EdlKµandak;lkçxNÐGVICabzmeLIy.

edaybnþnUvkarvaylukRbelamesñh_rbs;xøÜn RkúghaNUy)anbgðaj[eXIjnUvlT§PaBkRmit

kMNt;kñúgkarecjcUlrbs;BYksUevoteTAqksmuRTkaMr:aj;rbs;xøÜn. enAqñaM1985RkúghaNUy )an

cab;epþImbnøúyBakü[dwgenARkúgv:asuInetanfa qksmuRTkaMr:aj;enAEtsßitenAeRkamkarRtÜtRtarbs;

evotNamCanic© ehIykñúgkrNIEdlmandMeNaHRsayBICemøaHrbs;km<úCa vtþmaneyaFarbs;sUevot

enATIenaHGacnwgRtÚvkat;bnßy. erOgTaMgGs;enHBitCaKYr[Tak;TajcitþEmn b:uEnþBYkGaemrikaMgsÁal;

c,as;Nas;BI«l,ic»rbs;evotNam eRBaHEtminTukcitþ. eTaHbICay:agNak¾eday k¾BYkGaemrikaMgmin

cg;beNþayxøÜn[GUsTajcUleTAkñúgkic©crcaepSg²EdlGacnwgeFVI[xUcRbeyaCn_dl;karrYbrYmKña

rbs;Gas‘an nigeFVI[maneRKaHfñak;dl;yuT§sa®sþrbs;Rkúg)agkksþIBIbBaðakm<úCaeLIy.

Rkúgv:asuInetan)anTTYlykedayGnueRKaHnUvsMeNIeFVIshRbtibtþikarEpñk«mnusSFm’»rbs;

RbeTsevotNam Edltamry³shRbtibtþikarGacerobcM[manRbRktIPaBEpñkkarTUtCayfaehtu

mYy b:uEnþ)anbnþTamTar[mankardkfykgT½Brbs;evotNamecjBIRbeTskm<úCa TukCalkçxNÐdMbUg

sRmab;karpSHpSaTaMgGs;. cMENkevotNam)anGHGagfashRbtibtþikarrbs;eKsþIBIbBaðaTahan

)at;xøÜnkñúgs®gÁam )annaMmkpþl;[eKnUvKuNRbeyaCn_mYycMnYnminxan. BYkevotNamsgÇwmfa briya

kas manlkçN³minsUvRbqaMgb:unµaneT Rkúgv:asuInetannwgbnÞn;CMhrrbs;xøÜnsþIBIbBaðakm<úCa nigjúaMg[

RbeTscinbgðajlkçN³sRmbsRmÜleRcInCagmun ehIynwgjúaMg[RbeTséfluHkñúgGMNacxøÜndUc

Kña. y:agehacNas; k¾BYkeKmanKMnitkarBareRKaHfñak;TukCaeRscGMBIyuT§nakarRbqaMgevotNam Edl

kMBugduHdalenAshrdæGaemriksþIBIerOgGñkeTasEdltameKGHGagfa RtÚvXMuXaMgedayRkúghaNUy.

BYkemdwknaMevotNamk¾sgÇwmpgEdrfa karKaMRTrbs;GaemrikaMgcMeBaHclnats‘Ukm<úCaEdlbgðajedIm

ehtu edaykardwknaMEpñkmenaKmviC¢arbs;rdækarIehÁnnwgfmfycuHminxan.

témøEdlRtÚvbg;

taMgBIkarcUllukluyRbeTskm<úCa evotNamnigKUsRtÚvTaMgLayrbs;xøÜnKitfa eBlevla nig

siT§isßitenACamYyBYkeK. RkúghaNUysgÇwmfa erogral;qñaMEdlknøgputeTAnwgeFVI[CMhrrbs;rbb

ehg sMrin rwtEtrwgmaMeLIgkñúgkm<úCamYyEdlrs;eLIgvij ehIyfa enATIbMput BiPBelakk¾TTYlsÁal;

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 449

Page 460: Brother enemy

GMeBIEdl)anCaeFVIRCúleRsceTAehIy eRBaHeKFujRTan;nwgKaMRTs®gÁamts‘UmYy EdlKµansgÇwmnwg

QñH. TnÞwmnwgenaHRkúgeb:kaMgKitfa evotNamEdllg;RTenskñúgs®gÁamT½BéRBmYyEdlKµanRck

ecj nigedayemIleXIjesdækic©nigsnþisuxrbs;xøÜnRtÚvKMramkMEhgy:agF¶n;F¶r bnÞab;mkkardak;

TNÐkmµesdækic©nigkarKabsgát;xageyaFa enATIbMputc,as;CadkkgT½BfyBIkm<úCaminxan. b:uEnþ

s®gÁamenARbeTskm<úCa)anQancUldl;qñaMTIR)aMBIrehIy ehIyKµankarRbmaNTukCamunNamYy TMng

CaeFVI[seRmcelcCarUbrageLIy.

s®gÁamBeRgcBRgilEdlRbeTscinbegáIteLIg )aneFVI[RbeTsevotNamcuHexSayy:agxøaMg.

karbdiesFrbs;bs©imRbeTsminpþl;CMnYyesdækic©nighirBaØvtßúmYymk[evotNam)aneFVI[esdækic©

rbs;xøÜnkan;EtmansPaBF¶n;F¶reLIg². taMgBIs®gÁam)anbBa©b; RbCaCnevotNamCagmYylannak;

)anrt;ecjBImatuRbeTs EdlmanmYycMnYnFM)anrt;ecjenAeRkayqñaM1979. RbeTsevotNam

EdlkalBIedImCa davID [David CaRBHmhakSRtTIBIrrbs;CnCatieGRbW (Hébreu) RbEhlqñaM1010-

970munRKisþskraC] nigCaGñkvayQñHháÚlIy:at GaemrikaMg [Goliath Gñkcm,aMg CnCatihVIlIsþaMg

(Philistin) )anvaycaj; davId kñúgkarRbyuT§mYy] )ankøayeTACaRbeTsEdlshKmn_GnþrCatimin

rab;rk nigeFVI[GgÁkarshRbCaCatiemIlgayEdlCaGñke)aHeqñatseRmcpþl;nUvCMnYyd¾sMxan;mYy

kñúgkarsþarRbeTseLIgvijkalBIb:unµanqñaMmun. enAedImqñaM1986 bMNulxageRkArbs;evotNam)an

eLIgdl;6/7ekadiduløar. edaysarmUlehtuminsgbMNul GgÁkarTaMgGs;Edl[R)ak;x©IenAelak

xaglic)anbdiesFElg[x©IteTAeTot. karEkTRmg;esdækic©EbbTIpSaresrI EdlepþImeLIgtaMgBIqñaM

1980 )aneFVI[plitplEpñkes,ógGaharrbs;xøÜnekIncMnYneLIgy:agCak;c,as; ehIy)anCYy[

RbeTsCaticakputBIvibtþiesdækic©d¾GaRkk;énRbvtþisa®sþrbs;xøÜnEfmeTot. k¾b:uEnþ GnaKtRbeTs

evotNamEdlbM)at;min[manmUlFn enAEtsßitkñúgsPaBKYr[RBÜy)armÖy:agxøaMg. karRKb;RKg

RbkbedaymhnþraymYy KWBMuEmnbegáIteLIgedIm,IerobcMbBaðaepSg²[mansPaBdUcedImeLIgvijeT ³

GñkmenaKmviC¢aEdlEkmineLIgxøHkñúgépÞbkS )anRbqaMgCMTas;nwgkarEkTRmg;TaMgGs;. karsakl,g

EdlBYkenaHcg;[kat;bnßykareRbIR)as;edayGnuvtþkarpøas;bþÚrRkdasR)ak; enAExkBaØa qñaM1985

eXIjfanaM[vinasGnþrayeTAvij. eRkamTm¶n;énGtiprNacMnYn500PaKry EdlmanCabnþbnÞab;mk

eTot RbCaCnenAPaKxageCIgfVIt,itEtmanPkþIPaBmYyCanic©k¾eday )ancab;epþImTamTar[mankarpøas;

bþÚrmYykñúgk,alm:asuIndwknaMRbeTs. eBjfirevlaénrdUvekþAqñaM1986 kñúgkic©RbwgERbgmYyedIm,I

sþarCMenOTukcitþrbs;RbCaCneLIgvij GKÁelxabkSkumµúynIsþevotNam eLyn; EdleBlenaHkMBug

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg450

Page 461: Brother enemy

manCMgW)anlHbg;GMNacesÞIrEtTaMgGs;. karerIruHKN³rdæm®nþIy:agFMmYy)anekItmaneLIg edayman

karbBa©ÚlGñkEkTRmg;sMxan;²mYycMnYnmkkñúgrdæaPi)alpg. tameKsnñidæan mhasnñi)atbkSkumµúy

nIsþevotNamelIkTI6EdleRKageFVIenAcugqñaM1986nwgpøas;bþÚrGñkdwnaMmanv½ycas;mYyPaKecj

edaydak;BYkemdwknaMv½yekµgEdlmanKMniteCOnelOnCMnYsvij. b:uEnþ KµanGVImYybgðaj[eXIjfa

emdwknaMEdlmanv½yekµgTaMgenaHnwgmanCMhrmYyxusKñaBICMhremdwknaMeromc,grbs;BYkeKsþIBIbBaða

km<úCa b¤k¾y:agNaeLIy.

karxUcTwkcitþ)anraldaly:agrh½skñúgcMeNamédKUTaMgLayrbs;smaKmGas‘an eTaHbICa

RbeTséfnigRbeTscinEdlCatYÉkBIrd¾sMxan;hak;dUcCaBMueRtómcuHj:mk¾eday. RbeTsevotNam

)anP½nþRcLMy:agF¶n;edaynwksµanfa ExµrRkhmnwgRtÚvvay[cuHcaj;edayqab;rh½s ehIyfa BiPBelak

nwgePøcBIkm<úCakñúgeBld¾xøI. BImYyqñaMeTAmYyqñaM karkan;kab;xusc,ab;rbs;evotNammkelIRbeTs

km<úCa)anRtÚvBRgwgrwtEtrwgmaMeLIg b:uEnþ enAGgÁkarshRbCaCatik¾mankarRbqaMgCMTas;cMeBaHkar

kan;kab;enHEdr. ExµrRkhmEdlRtÚvRbCaCns¥b;ex<ImnigP½yxøacCanic©enaH)anseRmceCaKC½yvil

RtLb;mk«xagmuxqak»vij edaymankarKaMRTrbs;RbeTscinnigRbeTséfpg. fVIebITTYlrgbraC½y

kñúgGMLúgrdUvR)aMgqñaM1985k¾eday k¾s®gÁamT½BéRBenAépÞkñúgRbeTsenAEtmanskmµPaBxøaMgkøa

Canic©. bnÞab;BIkarkan;kab;km<úCaGs;ry³eBlCagR)aMmYyqñaM sm¥b;d¾yUrlg;rbs;RbCaCnExµrRbqaMg

nwgevotNam)anelceLIgCafµI. eKcab;epþImdwgnUvsBaØaénkarrvatcitþCaeRcInkñúgCYrkgT½Brbs; ehg

sMrin ehIysaFarNrdæRbCamanitkm<úCaElgsßitenAeRkamGMNacRkúghaNUyeTotehIy.

enAedImqñaM1986evotNamdwgxøÜnfa eBlevlaRbEhlCaBMupþl;karGnueRKaH[xøÜneLIy ebIBYkeK

enARtÜtRtaRbeTskm<úCaeTotenaH. ebIsinCaQñHkarRbyuT§enARbeTskm<úCa k¾RbeTsevotNam

muxCanwgcaj;karRbyuT§edIm,IsnþiPaBnigvibulPaBEdr. enARbeTscin kareFVITMenIbPavUbnIykmµ)anrIk

lUtlas;y:agelOn rIÉPaKeRcInénbNþaRbeTsminEmnkumúµynIsþenAGasuIPaKGaeKñy_suT§EtrIk

duHdaldUcpáaRtÚvTwksenSIm ³ manEt\NÐÚcinmYyb:ueNÑaHEdlhak;dUcCaCMrujeTArkPaBcuHdundab. eTaH

CadUecñHk¾eday k¾RkúghaNUyBMumanEkERbCMhrrbs;xøÜnsþIBIbBaðakm<úCabnþicNaesaHedayenAEtcat;Tuk

fakm<úCaCamUldæanpþl;snþisuxdl;RbeTsxøÜn ehIymanHRbwgkm©at;ecalclnats‘UEfmeTot b:uEnþ)an

cab;epþImeRKagKitBIdMeNaHRsayxagkarTUtmYyCaCageRKagKitBIrdæaPi)alcRmúHmYyEdldwknaMeday

semþc sIhnu nigEdlRTRTg;edaykarFanar:ab;rgepSg²rbs;GnþrCati. dMeNaHRsayenHRbEhl

eBIbRbTHnwgkarRbqaMgCMTas;BIKUsRtÚvTaMgLayrbs;xøÜn EdlsgÇwmfab:unµanqñaMeTAmuxeTot RbeTs

\NÐÚcin ³ enAeBlNaeTIbmansniþPaB? 451

Page 462: Brother enemy

evotNamnwgyl;c,as;minxan. b:uEnþ CamYynwgRkúmemdwknaMfµImYy RkúghaNUyBMu)aneRtómdak;GavuF

cuHeLIy ebITukxøÜnRtÚvbg;xatkñúgerOgenHy:agNak¾eday.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg452

Page 463: Brother enemy

Gvsankfa

s®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTIbIBitCaminGacecosrYcEmnb¤?. edayRkeLkemIleTAGtItkal eKGac

eqøIyRBmKñafa ³ GacecosrYcnigminGacecosrYc. R)akdehIy PaBtantwgd¾Cak;lak;mYyenAEtman.

Rbvtþisa®sþ)anbnSl;nUvsøaksñamy:ageRCAkñúgpñt;KMnitKUTMnas;epSg² mYyEpñkKW evotNamnigExµr

ehIymYyEpñkeTotKWevotNamnigcin EdlEtgminTukcitþKñaeTAvijeTAmky:agxøaMg. dMeNIrpuseLIg

vijnUvclnaGñkCatiniym edIm,ITamTarTwkdInigkarts‘UedIm,IkarRtÜtRtaRbPBFnFanepSg² EdleFVI[

exSaHGs;taMgBIyUrmkehIyedaykarkan;kab;rbs;GaNaniKmnigkareFVIGnþraKmn_rbs;breTs KWsuT§Et

CaerOgEdlmanCaFmµtakñúgviFankard¾Cak;lak;mYy. b:uEnþ kñúgeBlenaHKµanGñkNamñak;e)aHbg;s®gÁam

mYyedayBitR)akdenaHeT.

sRmab;evotNamyl;fa \NÐÚcinKWCakEnøgEtmYyKt;EdlFanasnþisuxdl;RbeTsrbs;xøÜn nig

Ca«kEnøgrs;» EdlcaM)ac;sRmab;esdækic©rbs;xøÜnEdr ehIyRbkarTaMgenHGacCaRbPBénkarb:HTgÁicKña

CamYyExµrRkhmCatiniymRCúlminxan. k¾b:uEnþenAeBlEdls®gÁamcb; karBRgwgGMNacrbs;bkS

kumµúynIsþelIRbeTsTaMgmUl nigkarsþaresdækic©eLIgvijKWCaGaTiPaBBIrrbs;RbeTsevotNamEdl

RtÚveFVImuneK. enHBMuEmnkarbegáItcRkPB\NÐÚcinmYyeT. evotNam BitCaRBÜy)armÖBIkarEbkbkS

BYkrbs;ExµrRkhm b:uEnþevotNamBMubgçMeFVI[GñkTaMgenaH pøas;bþÚrmaK’aneya)ayeLIy. b:ul Bt nig

bkSBYkkþirbs;Kat;suT§EtykeRbóbelIeBlevla. BYkeKetagEteFVIGVImYy[qab;bMput edIm,IbegáItrdæ

GMNacbdivtþmYyrbs;km<úCanig«bnSúT§» RbCaCatiecjBIBYkmnusSGKti nigGaRkk;TaMgGs;EdlsIuQñÜl

beRmI[RbeTsevotNamenAmunkarRbyuT§søab;rs;EdlecosminputCamYy«BYkvatTIevotNam». RtÚv

eFVI[mancitþemaHmut edaysarsßanPaBdundabxagEpñkesdækic©nigkarlM)aképÞkñúgrbs;RbeTsevot

Nam ExµrRkhmeCOfa GacQñHelIGVIEdlBYkeKcat;TukCakarvayRbharmYyEdlminGacecosrYc

edaydwknaMkarvayRbyuT§enAelITwkdIpÞal;rbs;evotNamEtmþg. karbgáehtuepSg²rbs;ExµrRkhm

)anbgçM[RkúghaNUyEkERbkmµviFI nigRbmUlpþMúkarykcitþTukdak;TaMgRsugeTAelIsnþisuxrbs;xøÜnenA

\NÐÚcinminxan. taMgBIyUryarmkehIy RbeTscinEtgmnÞilsgS½yBImhicätarbs;RbeTsevotNam

Canic©. cinFøab;)aneRbIR)as;siT§iGMNacrbs;xøÜnnigmeFüa)ayepSg²EpñkkarTUt edIm,IraraMgGnutþr

PaBrbs;RkúghaNUyenA\NÐÚcin ebITukCakmµviFIrbs;xøÜnCa]bsKÁdl;KMnitpþÜcepþImrbs;BYkExµrRkhm

k¾eday. bnÞab;BIkarraErkcitþmYyry³RbeTscinRtÚvEtKaMRTRbeTskm<úCay:ageBjbnÞúkkñúgs®gÁam

453

Page 464: Brother enemy

mYyEdlExµrRkhmxøÜnÉgCaGñkbgáeLIg.

PaBKab;CYnmYyénsßankarN_d¾céRgenAelIqakGnþrCati)annaM[sßankarN_enA\NÐÚcinmanPaB

rwtEtF¶n;F¶reLIgEdr. kñúgry³eBlRbEhlbIqñaM RbeTscin)anRtÚveFVI[Cab;rvl;y:agxøaMgkñúgkarts‘U

épÞkñúgrbs;xøÜnrhUtmkTl;cugqñaM1978 eRBaHEterobcMkarBiPakSaCafµImYysþIBIbBaðaenA\NÐÚcin.

naménneya)ay RbeTscinKitEtGMBIkarRbqaMgCaGkmµmYyEdleFVI[nwkeXIjdl;Tmøab;CaRbéBNI

nigkarGnuvtþdUcm:asuInnUveKalkarN_sMxan;²énlT§iem:Aniym. evotNamrkSakþIsgÇwmnwgeFVI[BYk

GaemrikaMgRtLb;mkkñúgtMbn;vij edIm,IeFVICaGñkFanafµIdl;smtakmøaMgenATIenH. esckþIsgÇwmenHRtÚv

)aneFVI[xkcitþedaykarRBegIykenþIyrbs;shrdæGaemrikcMeBaHGasuI eRkaysm½ys®gÁamevot

Nam nigedaykarRbqaMgCMTas;y:agmuWgm:at;BIshsPaGaemrikaMg. fVIebI suIrus v:an;s_ nig rIqad

hUlRb‘Úk yl;c,as;BI»kasEdlCemøaHenA\NÐÚcinbgðajxøÜnCafµIcMeBaHRkúgv:asuInetank¾eday k¾Gñk

TaMgBIr)ancaj;karRbyuT§xagkariyaFibetyüCaKuNRbeyaCn_dl;GñkRbqaMgsUevotd¾xøaMgkøamñak;KW

b‘ÍkjÚv Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI Edr.

etImanbRmúgTukenAeBlxagmux? ebIvinicä½yerOgenHtamRbvtþisa®sþfµI² bNþaqñaMEdlmkdl;

enAeBlbnÞab; muxCanwgCYbRbTHkarQWcab;nigRbEhlCabgðÚrQameRcInCagmunpg. RbeTscin)an

seRmccitþbM)ak;RbeTsevotNam ehIyGHGagBI]tþmPaBpÞal;rbs;xøÜnenAGasuIGaeKñy_EfmeTot.

RbeTscinRKan;EtKaMRTedayGenøI²kñúgkardak;[GnuvtþnUvKeRmagkarenHedaysmaKmGas‘annigbs©im

RbeTsb:ueNÑaH. RbeTsevotNam)anseRmccitþrkSaGtßRbeyaCn_EdldeNþIm)anedaykmøaMg

GavuF nigedayesckþIRtÚvkarEdldak;bgçMmkelIRbCaCnpÞal;rbs;xøÜn. ebIRkúgeb:kaMg nigRkúghaNUy

minTb;mhicätaepSg²rbs;xøÜneT \NÐÚcinBitCamin)ansÁal;snþiPaBeLIy.

fVIebIRbeTscinmanvisalPaBFMlVwgelVIy nigmanRbPBFnFanmnusSminecHrIgsܶtk¾eday k¾

RbeTscinBMuGaceFVI[RbeTsevotNamluHkñúgGMNacrbs;xøÜnEdr. RbeTsevotNam edaymankar

KaMRTBIRkúgmUsÁÚpg enAEtCamhaGMNaceyaFad¾KYr[RBWxøacmYydEdl. b:uEnþedImI,BRgwg]tþmPaBrbs;

xøÜnenA\NÐÚcin evotNamRtÚvEtBuHBarykQñHclnaCatiniymExµrnigPaBCasRtÚvEdlminGacsRmúH

sRmÜl)anénKURbECgGs;ry³eBleRcInstvtSr_mkehIy KWRbeTséfEfmeToteRkABIkarlM)ak

epSg²Epñkesdækic© nigsgÁmkic©pÞal;rbs;xøÜn.

k¾b:uEnþ ebIRbvtþisa®sþbeRgón[GñknaMGaT×TaMgGs;ecHEtsgS½yKñaeTAvijeTAmkdUecñH k¾vabeRgón

[GñkTaMgenaHdwgfa snþiPaBCaerOgEdlGaceFVI)an. CemøaHd¾sVitsVajEdlkñúgenaH RbeTscin nig

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg454

Page 465: Brother enemy

RbeTsevotNam)ancUlrYm BMuGacXat;XaMgRbeTsTaMgBIrEdlFøab;sÁal;KñayUrmk ehIymin[eQøaH

KñaenaHeT. kalBIGtItkalenAkñúgcenøaHsm½ykals®gÁam vamansm½ykalsnþiPaByUrGEgVgEdr

enAeBlEdlRbeTscinTTYlsÁal;fa Bi)aknwgdak;RbeTsevotNam[sißtenAeRkamGMNacxøÜnNas;

fVIebIRbeTsevotNamTTYlsÁal;]tþmPaBrbs;«GaNacRkkNþal»k¾eday. edIm,Inwg[snþiPaBGac

RtÚveKykcitþTukdak; RbeTscinTTYlRsbfa karRBÜy)armÖEdlRbeTsevotNammancMeBaHsnþisux

rbs;xøÜn)annaMeTAdl;karykcitþTukdak;cMeBaHsßankarN_enARbeTskm<úCa rebobdUcKñanwgerOgEdl

RbeTscinesñI[RkúghaNUyRbúgRby½tñnwgsnþisuxrbs;xøÜnEdr. edayRkGWtRkeGaghYsehtu«BYk

emdwknaM»RbeTsevotNamsBVéf¶ RbEhlCaBMueRtómxøÜneFIVtamKMrUrbs; egVón h‘uy vIrbursénclna

ts‘URbqaMgcin EdlbnÞab;BIC½yCmñHxageyaFarbs;Kat; RbqaMgnwgGaNacRkkNþalehIyEbrCanaM

yksYysarGakreTAfVayRBHecAGFiraCenARkúgeb:kaMgeTemIleTA. pÞúyeTAvij BYkemdwknaMevotNam

BMuGaceFVImindwgfa RbeTscinCamhaGMNacd¾sMxan;mYyRbcaMtMbn;. braC½ykñúgkarb:unb:gc,aMgdeNþIm

ykRbeTskm<úCaenAstvtSr_TI19 nigbTBiesaFn_kalBIeBlfIµ²RbEhlCaeFIV[RkúghaNUyRtiHriH

BicarNaCafµI.

kñúgRbvtiþTMnak;TMngTaMgGs;rvagRbeTséfnigRbeTsevotNam eKRbTHeXIjEtsm½ykalmYy

b:ueNÑaH-edImstvtSr_TI19- EdlRbeTskm<úCaElgCaedImehtuénkarTas;ETgKñarvagRkúg)agkk nig

Rkúgev:eTotehIy. enAeBlenaH evotNam)aneRbIGMNacBitR)akdmYymkelIRbeTskm<úCa b:uEnþ

RBHraCvaMgenARkúgev:)anRsuHRsYlKñafa RbeTséfk¾manplRbeyaCn_dUcKñaenAkñúgRbeTsenHEdr.

Xøarbs;eTsaPi)alevotNameQµaH eL v:an;eyot enAEtl,Il,ajdEdl Edlmanxwømsarfa ³

«RbeTskm<úCaKWCakUnekµgmñak;EdlmanRbeTséfCa«BuknigRbeTsevotNamCamþay». RbCaCnExµr

minsUvcUlcitþ[eKeRbóbeFobRbeTsrbs;xøÜneTAnwgkUnekµgmñak;EdlKµanGIVkarBarenaHeT. b:uEnþbnÞab;BI

s®gÁamnigkar)at;bg;mnusSy:ageRcInkñúgry³eBldb;qñaMEdlRKb;RKgeday b:ul Bt RbeTskm<úCa

BitCacuHexSayxøaMgNas;eRBaHEtCaRbeTsmYyEdlRKan;EtCaRTnab;b:ueNÑaH. km<úCaRtÚvEteronsURt

eLIgvij edIm,IeFVIxøÜn[eTACaRbCaCatieBjeljmYyeRkamkarkarBarBIGnþrCati KWBMuEmneRkamsh

viCitrdæ(Condominium)-[EdndIEdldeNþIm)anedaykarc,aMgrYmKña]rbs;evotNamnigéfeLIy.

km<úCanwgRtÚveFVI[mankarKaMBarBIGnþrCatiRbqaMgnwgkarvilRtLb;mkvijrbs;ExµrRkhm niglT§iRCúl

hYsehtuRbLak;eTAedayQamrbs;BYkenH ehIyRbqaMgnwgGnþraKmn_TaMgGs;rbs;breTs. manEt

karFanaBIsMNak;mhaGMNacFM²b:ueNÑaH EdlGaceFVI[RbCaBlrdæExµrkk;ekþAkñúgcitþlubbM)at;karmin

Gvsankfa 455

Page 466: Brother enemy

TukcitþKñaeTAvijeTAmkrvagRbeTsevotNamnigRbeTséf ehIyGacbeRmIy:ageBjsmtßPaBsRmab;

snþisuxpÞal;xøÜnrbs;RbeTsnImYy²pg.

b:uEnþkarFanaBIGnþrCatienHnwgGacekItman ebIsinCaRkúgmUsÁÚTTYlsÁal;favanwg[KuNRbeyaCn_

dl;xøÜneRcInCageK edaye)aHbg;kareRbICemøaHEpñkeyaFaKµaneGonxµas ehIyTTYlRsbfa vanwgpþl;

KuNRbeyaCn_Cag TaMgxagTsSn³yl;eXIjBI\T§iBlneya)ayrbs;xøÜn k¾dUcTsSn³mYymanlkçN³

BaNiC¢kmµy:agRtwmRtÚvEdr EdlminRtÚvcecsEsVgrk[xagEt)annUv]tþmPaBenAGasuIGaeKñy_eLIy.

cMENkxagBYkGaemrikaMg karTTYlxusRtÚvy:agF¶n;F¶rmYy)anFøak;mkelIxøÜnEdlsßitenAkñúg

sßanPaBGs;sgÇwmmYyEdr. bnÞab;BIkg;Rbvtiþsa®sþvilRKb;mYyCMuBYkGaemrikaMgRtÚv)anelIk[kan;

muxgarCaGaCJakNþalmþgeTot. KWBYkGaemrikaMgenHehIyEdlmanlkçN³RbesIrCageK edIm,IFana[

mansmtakmøaMgCafµImYyenAGasIuGaeKñy_/ r:ab;rgsnþisuxRbeTséfTl;nwgRbeTsevotNam nigrMedaH

RkúghaNUyBIkarP½yxøacrbs;xøÜnBIGnutþrPaBcin edayrMgab;karminTukcitþEdlRkúgmUsÁÚmaneTAelI

Rkúgeb:kaMg. b:uEnþedIm,IerobcMerOgenH Rkúgv:asuInetanetagEtp¥akGMBIkareFVICMerOncMnYnTahan)at;xøÜn

kñúgs®gÁam ehIyTIbMputRtÚvEtTTYlyl;RBmsEmþgtYnaTId¾skmµCagmunmYyenA\NÐÚcin. shrdæ

GaemrikGacTTYlmkvijnUvkitüanuPaBnigGMNacEdl)an)at;bg;kalBImunkñúgkarpSgeRBgxageyaFa

Edlxuskal³eTs³rbs;xøÜn. luHRtaEteRbIR)as;edayRtwmRtÚvnUvGMNacxagesdækic© nigkarTUt

rbs;xøÜn CaBiessedaymanxdak;lkçxNÐCYyRbeTskm<úCa[rs;ranmanCIviteLIgvijpg.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg456

Page 467: Brother enemy

kalb,vtþisMxan;²

qqññaaMM11997755

17emsa kardeNþIm)anTIRkúgPñMeBjedayExµrRkhm.

30emsa kardeNþIm)anTIRkúgéRBnKredayBYkkumµúynIsþevotNam.

04]sPa karvayRbharrbs;ExµrRkhmenAelIekaHnanarbs;evotNam.

12]sPa karsÞak;cab;)annavadwkTMnijGaemrikaMgmYyeRKÓgeQµaH ém:y:aehÁ edayBYk

ExµrRkhm.

12mifuna karkan;kab;ekaHmYyrbs;km<úCaedayRbeTsevotNam. TsSnkic©Casm¶at;

rbs; b:ul Bt enARkúghaNUy.

21mifuna karCYbKñaCasm¶at;rvag em:A esTug nig b:ul Bt enARkúgeb:kaMg.

18 sIha karsnüarbs;cinkñúgkarpþl;CMnYyesdækic©y:agsn§wksn§ab;mk[RbeTskm<úCa.

25kBaØa karbBa©b;TsSnkic©rbs; eL yn; enARkúgeb:kaMg KµankarRBmeRBógKñaNamYy

RtÚv)anseRmceLIy.

30tula karsnüarbs;sUevotcMeBaHRbeTsevotNamkñúgkarpþl;CMnYyesdækic©ry³eBl

yUrkñúgGMLúgeBlénkarsñak;GaRs½yrbs; eL yn; enATIRkúgmUsÁÚ.

21vicäika karRbkaspSayCasaFarN³nUvkarbRgÜbbRgÜmPaKxageCIg nigPaKxagt,Úg

evotNamEdlc,as;CaekItmankñúgeBlqab;².

qqññaaMM11997766

06kumÖ³ karcuHhtßelxaelIkic©RBmeRBógpþl;CMnYyeyaFaCasm¶at;rvagRbeTscin nig

km<úCa.

02emsa karlaElgrbs; semþc RBHneratþm sIhnu BImuxtMENgCaRbmuxrdærbs;

km<úCa.

14emsa karRbkasBIrdæaPi)alfµIrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüEdldwknaMeday b:ul Bt.

20kkáda karTTYlCYbKN³RbtiPUGñkkaEstevotNammYyRkúmeday b:ul Bt.

09kBaØa mrNPaBrbs;RbFan em:A.

457

Page 468: Brother enemy

06tula karcab;xøÜnbNþasmaCikrbs; «bn4nak;».

14FñÚ karebIkmhasnñi)atrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþevotNam.

qqññaaMM11997777

24kumÖ³ karRbkasCasaFarN³nUvkarminbnþpþl;CMnYyrbs;cineTA[RbeTsevotNam.

16mIna karepþImsñak;GaRs½yenARkúghaNUyrbs;KN³RbtiPUtMNagRbFanaFibtI

GaemrikaMgmYyRkúmEdldwknaMedayelak eLGUNard_ vUdxUk.

25emsa karepþImTsSnkic©rbs; paM v:an;dug enAGWr:ubxaglic.

30emsa karvayRbharrbs;ExµrRkhmeTAelIPUminanarbs;evotNamenAtamRBMEdn.

03]sPa karebIkkic©snÞnakñúgkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBrvagGaemrikaMgnigevotNamenA

TIRkúg):arIs.

07mifuna karCYbKñarvag paM v:an;dug nig eLGUnIdeRbseNv enATIRkúgmUsÁÚ.

10mifuna karCYbKñarvag paM v:an;dug nig lI s‘annan enARkúgeb:kaMg.

17kkáda karcuHhtßelxasn§isBaØamitþPaBmYyEdlmanry³eBl25qñaMrvagRbeTs

evotNam nigRbeTsLav.

24kBaØa karvayRbhareTAelIPUmirbs;evotNammYyedayExµrRkhm bNþal[Cn

suIvilsøab;Gs;RbmaN100nak;.

28kBaØa karcab;epþImeFVITsSnkic©RbkbedayeCaKC½yrbs; b:ul Bt enARbeTscin.

10tula karmkdl;RbeTsevotNamnUvKN³RbtiPUeyaFasUevotCan;x<s;mYyRkúm.

21vicäika TsSnkic©rbs; eL yn; enARkúgeb:kaMg. kñúgeBlenaHmankarb:unb:gbMEbk

BYkcin[XøatecjBIExµrRkhm.

03FñÚ TsSnkic©rbs;]bnaykrdæm®nþIcin ecn y:ughSIú enARbeTskm<úCa.

25FñÚ karvayRbharrbs;evotNamRbqaMgnwgRbeTskm<úCa.

31FñÚ karpþac;TMnak;TMngkarTUtrvagRbeTskm<úCanigevotNam.

qqññaaMM11997788

18mkra karsñak;GaRs½yenARbeTskm<úCarbs;elakCMTav etg yIgCav PriyasB

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg458

Page 469: Brother enemy

elak CU eGnLay EdlmkeFVITsSnkic©edIm,IbBa©úHbBa©ÚlExµrRkhm[Rbkan;

ykneya)ayniympøÚvkNþal.

05kumÖ³ sMeNIrbs;evotNamGMBIbTQb;)aj;Kña nigkarebIkkic©crcaCamYyRbeTs

km<úCa.

22kumÖ³ dMeNIrCasm¶at;eTARkúgeb:kaMgrbs;GñkcrcaevotNammñak;.

24mIna karcab;epþImeFVIkarb®gáabeTAelIGaNikCncinenARbeTsevotNam.

22emsa karbegáItkgBltUcTI1rbs;ExµrenARbeTsevotNamedIm,IRbqaMgrbb b:ul

Bt.

12]sPa karlubecalEpñkxøHénCMnYyrbs;cineTA[RbeTsevotNam.

20]sPa karmkdl;Rkúgeb:kaMgrbs;elak b‘ÍkjÚ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI.

24]sPa enARbeTskm<úCaPaKxagekIt b:ul Bt )anepþImkarvayRbharrbs;xøÜnTl;nwg

GñkRbqaMgkñúgépÞbkS. karbþwgbriharedayRkúgeb:kaMgGMBIeCaKvasnaEdl

bRmúgTuksRmab;GaNikCncinenARbeTsevotNam.

28mifuna karcUlCasmaCikGgÁkarsgÁhesdækic©(COMECON)rbs;RbeTsevotNam.

05kkáda enARkúgeb:kaMg karepþImkic©crcaCasm¶at;rvagGaemrikaMg-cin sþIBIkareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBeLIgvij.

11kkáda karlHbg;lkçxNÐCaGaTiPaBCapøÚvkaredayRbeTsevotNamkñúgkareFVI[man

RbRktIPaBCamYyRkúgv:asuInetan.

10kBaØa karcab;epþImeFVITsSnkic©rbs; paM v:an;dug kñúgbNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþenA

GasuIGaeKñy_.

27kBaØa karCYbsnÞnaKñaCasm¶at;rvagGaemrikaMg-evotNam EdlmanvDÆnPaBy:ag

qab;rh½sGMBIGPiRkménkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBeLIgvijrvagRbeTsTaMgBIr.

11tula karp¥akdMeNIrénkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNamedayelak

RbFanaFibtIGaemrik xaF½r rhUtdl;karbegáIt[manTMnak;TMngCamYyRkúgeb:kaMg

sin.

03vicäika karcuHhtßelxasn§isBaØamitþPaBmYyrvagsUevot-evotNam Edlmanfirevla

25qñaM.

kalb,vtþisMxan;² 459

Page 470: Brother enemy

05vicäika etg s‘avBIg cab;epþImeFVITsSnkic©mYyenAbNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþenA

GasuIGaeKñy_. KN³RbtiPUrbs;cinmYyeTot)aneFVIdMeNIrmkkan;RbeTs

km<úCa.

11vicäika karebIksm½yRbCMuvisamBaØmYyrbs;RkúmemdwknaMbkSkumµúynIsþcin ³ etg

s‘avBIg cab;epþImBRgwg]tþmPaBrbs;Kat;.

02FñÚ karRbkasCasaFarN³edayRkúghaNUysþIBIkarbegáItrNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaH

Catikm<úCaEdlRbqaMgnwg b:ul Bt.

15FñÚ karRbkasCasaFarN³sþIBIkareFVI[manRbRktIPaBEpñkkarTUtrvagRkúgeb:kaMg

nigRkúgv:asuInetan.

25FñÚ karcab;epþImkarcUllukluyRbeTskm<úCaedayRbeTsevotNam.

qqññaaMM11997799

07mkra karvaydeNþIm)anRkúgPñMeBjedayevotNam.

14mkra karCYbKñaCasm¶at;rvagcinnigéf ³ karKaMRTs®gÁamT½BéRBRbqaMgevotNamenA

RbeTskm<úCa.

28mkra dMeNIreTAdl;Rkúgv:asuInetanrbs; etg s‘avBIg. enATIenaHKat;)anEføg[dwgBI

KeRmagkarrbs;Kat;kñúgkarpþl;«emeron »mYy[RbeTsevotNam.

17kumÖ³ RbeTscin)ancUllukluyRbeTsevotNam.

27mIna navacm,aMgsUevotmYykg)ane)aHyufáasMctenAqksmuRTkaMr:aj;rbs;evot

Nam.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg460

Page 471: Brother enemy

GkSrkat;EdleRbIR)as;kñúgRbPBÉksarsMGag

A.C.N. Agence Chine Nouvelle ¬TIPñak;garB½t’mancinfµI¦

A.F.P. Agence France-Presse ¬TIPñak;garB½t’man)araMg¦

A.V.I Agence Vietnamienne d' Information ¬TIPñak;garB½t’manevotNam¦

B.P Bangkok Post ¬kaEst)agkkb:usþצ

C.V. Le Courrier du Vietnam

F.E.E.R. Far Eastern Economic Review ¬TsSnavdþIesdækic©cugbUBa’¦

F.B.I.S.-P.R.C. Foreign Broadcast Information Service-People's Republic of China.

F.B.I.S.-A.P.A. Foreign Broadcast Information Service-Asia Pacific

N.D. Nhan Dan

N.Y.T. The New York Times ¬kaEstjÚvy:kEfms_¦

P.I. Pékin Information

Q.D.N.D. Quan Doi Nhan Dan

R.R. Renmin Ribao

S.W.B. Summary of World Broadcast (BBC)

W.P. Washington Post ¬kaEstv:asuInetanb:usþצ

461

Page 472: Brother enemy

RbPBÉksarsMGag

CMBUkTI1

1 Roy Rowan, The Four Days of Mayaguez, New York, Norton, 1975; pp. 38-48.

2 The Vietnamese Air Force, 1951-1975: An Analysis of its Role in Combat and Fourteen Hours at Koh

Tang, Southeast Asia Monograph Series, Vol.3, Washington, D.C., VSAF, 1981, p. 106.

3 Roy Rowan, ibidem, p. 123.

4 karR)aRs½yTak;TgKñapÞal;xøÜnrbs;m®nþImñak;énRksYgkarbreTsGU®sþalI eRkaykarsnÞnarbs;

Kat;CamYytUt (Tot) enARbeTsm:aeLsuI/ éf¶TI5 Exemsa qñaM1979.

5 Michael Chinoy, «A Close Look at the Mayaguez», F.E.E.R, éf¶TI30 Ex]sPa qñaM1975, p. 18.

6- R.M.Smith, Cambodia Foreign Policy, Ithaca, N.Y., Cornell University Press, 1965, p. 159.

7 Ben Kiernan, «man;éRB/ man;Rsuk nigEk¥kTwk ³ PUmiPaKbUBa’eRkamrbb b:ul Bt » kñúgkarniBn§l,g

TI8 «bdivtþn_nigplvi)akkñúgRbeTskm<úCa» David Chandler and Ben Kiernan éd., Monograph Series

Nº25, New Haven, Conn. Yale University Southeast Asia Studies, 1983, p. 178. karbkERbeTACa

Pasa)araMgkñúg Camille Scalabrino nig Marie-Claire Orieux: Cambodge: Rbvtþisa®sþ nigRkya

tMNaMg/ 1945-1985, Asie-Débat 2, l’Harmattan, 1985, pp. 159-160.

8 Dossier Kampuchéa, Vol. 1, C.V., Hanoi, 1978, p. 128.

9 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy paM v:an;)a GtItÉkGKÁrdæTUtrbs;evotNamRbcaMkm<úCaRbCaFib

etyü/ TIRkúghUCImij/ éf¶TI27 Exmkra qñaM1981.

10 S.W.B., 5 août 1975.

11 Dossier Kampuchéa, p. 127.

12 Kenneth M. Quinn, The Origin and Development of Radical Cambodia Communism, niekçbbTfñak;

bNÐit/ University of Maryland, 1982, p. 187.

13 Ibid.

14 kMNt;ehtuGUsr:UeNGU sþIBIkarsnÞnarvag v:ag sðagr:ug-sun esn enAéf¶TI6 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1976

Edlbgðaj[dwgkñúgeBlkat;kþI b:ul Bt-eGog sarI edaykM)aMgmux. sMeNAedImRtÚv)at;bg;

b:uEnþkarerobrab;y:agl¥itl¥n;CaeRcIn)annaM[nwkeXIjBIlkçN³BiténkarbkERbCaPasa)araMg

462

Page 473: Brother enemy

enH. CaBiess Tak;TgeTAnwgPaBsþÜcesþIgénCMnYyrbs;cin EdlpÞúynwgkarbBa¢ak;GHGagrbs;

Gñkkan;GMNacevotNam.

15 F.B.I.S.-P.R.C., éf¶TI16 Exemsa qñaM1976/ A-7.

16 The Straits Times, éf¶TI13 Exvicäika qñaM1974.

17 hg;rI KIsSIúghÁ½r/ The White House Years, Boston, Little, Brown, 1979, p. 1114. esovePAbkERbCa

Pasa)araMg ³ GMBIestviman ³ 1968-1973, Paris, Fayard, 1979.

18 Kiessing’s Contemporary Archives, janvier 1974, p. 26488.

19 esckþIraykarN_segçbsþIBIkarsnÞnarbs;]bnaykrdæm®nþI lI s‘annan CamYy paM v:an;dug enA

éf¶TI10 Exmifuna qñaM1977, A.C.N., éf¶TI22 ExmIna qñaM1979.

20 S.W.B., éf¶TI1 Ex]sPa qñaM1975.

21 S.W.B., éf¶TI29 Ex]sPa qñaM1975.

22 S.W.B., éf¶TI22 Ex]sPa qñaM1975.

23 «Fighting a New Kind of War", F.E.E.R, éf¶TI26 ExkBaØa qñaM1975/ p. 10.

24 F.B.I.S.-P.R.C., éf¶TI23 ExkBaØa qñaM1975/ A-16.

25 Ibid., A-18-19.

26 tameyabl;m®nþIcinmñak;fa karTamTaredayTTUcrbs; eL faj;gI edIm,IsuMCMnYyrbs;cin kñúg

GMLúgénkareFVIdMeNIrKµanQb;Qrrbs;Kat;)aneFVI[Kat;maneQµaHehAeRkAfa «sµÚmyack».

27 P.I., éf¶TI16 Exmifuna qñaM1978/ pp. 12-16. GtßbTBuMmanbBa¢ak;TaMgkalbriecäTénkarsnÞna

enH TaMgeQµaHemdwknaMrbs;evotNameT b:uEnþ karniyaybBaäitbeBaäógBI «CMgWd¾F¶n;F¶r»rbs; CU

nigkarniyayeyagBI«sm½ys®gÁam»eFVI[eKKitfa Kat;enaHCa eL faj;gI ³ enAExsIha

qñaM1975 RbB½n§pSBVpSayB½t’manrbs;cin )anelIkykmkniyayBIkarCYbKñamYyrbs; gI

CamYy CU EdlenAeBlenaHcUlBüa)aleraKkñúgmnÞIreBTü.

28 elIkykmkniyayCasMGageday A.C.N., éf¶TI19 Exmifuna qñaM1981.

29 GMBIGFibetyüPaBrbs;evotNamelIRbCuMekaH h½gsa nig eRTÓgsa/ RkúghaNUy/ RksYg

karbreTs/ 1979/ p. 60. karbkRsayrbs;evotNam)anRtÚvGHGagbBa¢ak;eday A.C.N.,

éf¶TI14 ExsIha qñaM1979.

30 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYynaykrgmCÄmNÐlRbvtþisa®sþsm½ybc©úb,nñrbs;cin/ Rkúg

RbPBÉksarsMGag 463

Page 474: Brother enemy

eb:kaMg/ éf¶TI8 ExmIna qñaM1982.

31 S.W.B., éf¶TI6 Exmifuna qñaM1978.

32 S.W.B., éf¶TI2 Ex]sPa qñaM1975.

33 Carlyle A. Thayer nig David G. Marr, Vietnam Since 1975, Center for the Study of Australian-Asian

Relations, Research Paper Nº20, Brisbane, Griffith University, 1980, p. 7.

34 Ta Kung Pao, hugkug/ éf¶TI27 Exvicäika qñaM1975.

35 Gareth Porter, «neya)ayevotNamnigvibtþienA\NÐÚcin» kñúgs®gÁam\NÐÚcinelIkTI3/ David W.P.

Elliott éd., Boulder, Colo., Westview Press, 1981, p. 80.

36 S.W.B., éf¶TI26 Exemsa qñaM1976.

37 karsnÞnarbs; eGog sarI CamYyelak Patrice de Beer, GñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manénkaEst LWm:ug

sRmab;PUmiPaKGasuIGaeKñy_/ )agkk/ Extula qñaM1975. ´sUmGKuNelak Beer Edl)an

bBa¢ÚnkMNt;RtaxøI²rbs;elakmk[´.

38 sarin qak/ «RBMEdnRbeTskm<úCa», Paris, Dalloz, 1966, pp. 207-208; sUmGanpgEdrnUv esovePA

km<úCa-evotNam/ International Boundary Study Nº155, RksYgkarbreTsGaemrikaMg/ kariya-

l½yesuIbkarN_ nigRsavRCav/ Washington, D.C., 1976, pp. 11-12.

39 esckþIcmøgénkarsnÞnarbs; v:ag Tug CamYyelak James Burnet, haNUy/ éf¶TI12 Exmkra

qñaM1986. B½t’manpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak James Burnet.

40 S.W.B., éf¶TI6 Exkkáda qñaM1976.

41 S.W.B., éf¶TI18 ExsIha qñaM1976.

42 «esckþIraykarN_segçbsþIBIkarsnÞnarbs;]bnaykrdæm®nþI lI s‘annan CamYynaykrdæm®nþI

paM v:an;dug enAéf¶TI10 Exmifuna qñaM1977», A.C.N., éf¶TI22 ExmIna qñaM1979.

43 Jurgen Domes, RbeTscineRkaysm½ybdivtþn_vb,Fm’/ London, Hurst, 1976, pp. 247-251.

44 Michel Oksenberg, «mYyTsvtSn_énTMnak;TMngcin-Gaemrik», karbreTs/ srTrdUv 1982, pp. 180-

181.

vKÁ ³ «neratþm sIhnu ³ em:agénC½yCmñH»

1 Henry Kissinger, bNþaqñaMEdlclaclxøaMg Little, Brown, 1982, p. 59. karbkERbCaPasa)araMg ³

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg464

Page 475: Brother enemy

«bNþaqñaMd¾rMeCIbrMCYl», Paris, fayard, 1982.

2 GuI pan;dara/ «karRtLb;mkPñMeBjvij», Paris, A.M. Métailié, 1982, p. 37.

CMBUkTI2

1 Paul Mus, evotNam ³ sgÁmsa®sþéns®gÁammYy/ Paris, Editions du Seuil, 1952, p. 17.

2 Michael G. Cotter, «Towards a Social History of Vietnamese Southward Movement», Journal of Southeast

Asia History, Vol. IX, Nº1, mars 1968, p. 14.

3 Georges Maspero, «RBHraCaNacRkcm,:a», Paris, Van Houst, 1928, p. 26. cMeBaHtYelxEdlfµI

bMput sUmGansßitiCMerOnRbCaCnenAqñaM1976 rbs;saFarNrdæsgÁmniymevotNam.

4 Alexander Barton Woodside, evotNam nigKMrUrbs;cin/ Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1971,

p. 247.

5 David Chandler, km<úCamunsm½y)araMg ³ Politics in a Tributary Kingdom. 1794-1848, Ann Arbor,

Mich., University Microfilms, 1973, p. 108.

6 David Chandler, «An Anti-Vietnamese Rebellion in Early Nineteenth Century Cambodia: Pre-Colonial

Imperialism and a Pre-Nationalist Response», Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, Vol. VI, Nº1, mars

1975, pp. 16-24.

7 B½t’manpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak David Chandler, éf¶TI15 Extula qñaM1982; aussi, David Chandler, op.

cit., p. 154; David Chandler, «Kampuchea-Vietnam-The Roots of Strife», in The Vietnam-Kampuchea-

China Conflict, Malcolm Salmon éd., Working paper Nº1 Canberra, Department of Political and Social

Change, Research School of Pacific Studies, Australian National University, 1979, pp. 4-5.

8 erOgxøI²kñúgRbvtþisa®sþenH )anpþl;CaRbeyaKEdleKTenÞjminQb;mYykñúgkareXasnarbs;

ExµrRkhm. cMeBaHkarbkRsayrbs;GñkrYcputBIeRKaHfñak;mñak;CaCnCatikm<úCa sUmGan

esovePA «karvilRtLb;mkPñMeBjvij» rbs;elak GuI pan;dara/ Paris, Métailié, 1982, p. 129

RBmTaMg esovePArbs;elak A. Pannetier, kMNt;ehtuxøI²GMBIkm<úCa ³ enAkNþalRbeTsExµr/

Paris, Payot, 1921; Paris, Cedoreck, 1983, pp. 15-16 pg.

9 Chandler, op. cit., p.153.

10 esckþIRbkasB½t’man/ km<úCaRbCaFibetyü/ KN³ebskkmµGcié®nþy_enAGgÁkarshRbCaCati/

RbPBÉksarsMGag 465

Page 476: Brother enemy

éf¶TI11 ExFñÚ qñaM1978. tamkarBit erOgenHmanBitR)akdKWcab;BIqñaM1977mk.

11 sarin qak/ «RBMEdnRbeTskm<úCa»/ Paris, Dalloz, 1966, tome 1, p. 179.

12 Michael Leifer, Cambodia: The Search for Security, London, Pall Mall, 1967, p. 95; Roger M. Smith,

Cambodia’s foreign Policy, Ithaca, N.Y., Cornell University Press, 1965, pp. 158-159. karTTUcedIm,I

[mankareRbIGakb,kiriyaRby½tñ ¬xagpøÚvkay b¤vaca¦ edayELkmYycMeBaHCnCatiPaKticExµr

eRkamenAPaKxagt,ÚgevotNam KWCamUlehtuénbraC½ykñúgkarcrcaenAExtula qñaM1964

rvagrNsirSrMedaHCatievotNam¬evotkug¦ nigkm<úCa. kMNt;ehtuénkarRbCuMrbs;KN³RbtiPU

énrNsirSrMedaHCatievotNamxagt,ÚgenAvimanTTYlePJóvnaTIRkúgeb:kaMg/ éf¶TI1 Extula qñaM

1964 evlaem:ag4l¶ac/ ÉksarpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak sðal émy½r.

13 Alain Forest, «km<úCanigkartaMgGaNaniKmrbs;)araMg»/ Paris, l’ Harmattan, 1980, p. 452.

14 elIkmkniyayCasMGagedayelak Gareth Porter, «evotNamnigkm<úCa», CemøaH\NÐÚcinelIk

TI3/ David Elliott éd., Boulder, Colo, Westview, 1981, p.124, note 101.

15 RksYgkarbreTs/ TUrelxNº749-S.D.C.S Extula qñaM1952/ manRbPBmkBITIRkúgéRBnKr.

tammtiENnaMdEdlfa bkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcin)anRbKl;GMNac[bkSkumµúynIsþevotNamedIm,I

«erobcMnigdak;[manRkbx½NÐnUvsmaCikrbs;xøÜn EdlmanedImkMeNItCacin ehIyEdlkMBugsñak;

GaRs½yenARbeTsevotNam/ km<úCanigRbeTsLav».

16 GñkÉkeTsxagbBaðaRbeTskm<úCa min)anRBmeRBógKñaGMBIGtßn½yénmhasnñi)atqñaM1960

EdlCakalbriecäTénkarbegáItbkS dUcEdl b:ul Bt )anGHGagb¤mhasnñi)atelIkTIBIrénbkS

RbCaCnbdivtþn_km<úCa EdlekItmkBIbkSkumµúynIsþ\NÐÚcineT. karbBa¢ak;GHGagTaMgBIrRbEhl

CamankarBit¬enAkñúgenaH¦tamcMENknImYy².

17 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Charles Meyer, Rkúg):arIséf¶TI18 Exmifuna qñaM1977.

18 neratþm sIhnu/ esovePA «GñkeTasExµrRkhm»/ Hachette, 1986, p. 416.

19 Harald Munthe-Kaas, «smÖasn_CamYysemþcRBH neratþm sIhnu»/ F.E.E.R. éf¶TI9 Extula qñaM

1965.

20 Stephen Header, «Kampuchea’s Armed Struggle: The Origin of an Independent Revolution», Bulletin of

Concerned Asian Scholars, Vol. 11, Nº1, 1979, p.7.

21 Timothy Carney, «Cambodia: The Unexpected Victory», GtßbTmin)ane)aHBum<pSay/ ExkumÖ³

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg466

Page 477: Brother enemy

qñaM1979/ p.10.

22 Heder, «Kampuchea’s Armed Struggle», p.14.

23 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak sðal émy½r/ ):arIs éf¶TI18 Exmifuna qñaM1977.

24 Kissinger, The White House Years, p. 250; William Shawcross, ehtukarN_bnÞab;bnSM/ KIsSúIghÁ½r/

nicsun nigkarbMpøajRbeTskm<úCa/ New York, Simon and Schuster, 1979, p. 70.

25 elIkmkniyaysMGagedayelak sðavRkÚs op.cit.p. 123. kñúgn½ydEdlelak sðavRkÚs k¾

elIksmþIrbs;elak William Colby GtItnayk C.I.A. mksMGagpgEdr.

26 Sihanouk, op.cit.

27 Heder, «Kampuchea’s Armed Struggle», p. 14. enAqñaM1968 semþc sIhnu )anGYtGagfa )an[

eKsmøab;GñkRbqaMgCaCnkumµúynIsþ1500nak;taMgBIqñaM1956mk.

28 Ibid.

29 Shawcross, op. cit., p. 250.

30 esovePAexµA/ ehtukarN_nigP½sþútagénGMeBIQøanBannigkarP¢ab;TwkdIrbs;RbeTsevotNam

RbqaMgnwgkm<úCa/ PñMeBj ³ RksYgkarbreTskm<úCaRbCaFibetyü/ qñaM1978/ p. 86.

31 Kissinger, Years of Upheaval, Boston, Little, Brown, 1981, p. 353.

32 Ibid., p. 341.

33 Ibid., p. 36.

34 Shawcross, op. cit., pp. 335-343.

35 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYysemþcRBH neratþm sIhnu enATIRkúgeb:kaMg éf¶TI5 Exemsa qñaM

1980.

36 Donald Kirk, «Revolution and Political Violence in Cambodia, 1970-74», dans Communism in Indochina,

Joseph Zasloff and Paul Brown éd., Toronto, Lexington, 1975, p. 218.

37 TUrelxEdlerobrab;bBa©Úledayelak Ben Kiernan «man;éRB/ man;Rsuk nigEk¥kTwk ³ PUmiPaKbUB’a

rbs;km<úCaeRkamrbb b:ul Bt »/kñúgkarniBn§l,gTI8sþIBIbdivtþn_nigplvi)akenAkm<úCa/ David

Chandler and Ben Kiernan éd., Monograph Series Nº25, New Haven, Conn., Yale University Southeast

Asia Studies, 1983, p. 176.

38 Ibid., p. 159.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 467

Page 478: Brother enemy

39 sMNuMerOgkm<úCa/ pp. 9-10.

CMBUkTI3

1 Rbtikmµrbs; eGog sarI cMeBaHkarcab;xøÜnBYkr:aDIkal; RtÚv)anerobrab;R)ab;´ edayshkarI

CitsñiT§mñak;rbs;elak háas):arI enATIRkúg)agkk. BIqñaM1979dl;qñaM1982 háas):arI CaÉk

GKÁrdæTUtRbeTsyUehÁasøavIRbcaMRbeTséf.

2 J.B. Armstrong, Revolutionary Diplomacy: Chinese Foreign Policy and the United Front Doctrine,

Berkeley, University of California Press, 1977, pp. 180-181.

3 cMeBaHkarbriyaymYyGMBIRBwtþikarN_Extula qñaM1976 enARbeTscin sUmGanesovePArbs;

elak Roger Garside, Coming Alive: China after Mao, New York, Mentor, 1981, pp. 101-154; Andres

D. Onate, «hVaKUehVg nigkarcab;xøÜnbn4nak;», China Quarterly, ExkBaØa qñaM1978/ pp. 540-565.

4 tamviTüúRkúgPñMeBjfa enAéf¶TI13 Extula ÉkGKÁrdæTUténRbeTsm:alInigtg;hSanIEdlGeBa¢Ij

mkCUnlixitsartaMgRtÚv)anTTYleday sun esn rdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTs EdlbMeBjParkic©kñúg

zan³Cardæm®nþIkarbreTs/ S.W.B., éf¶TI1 Exvicäika qñaM1976.

5 sunÞrkfarbs;elak lI Cag (Li Qiang) rdæm®nþIBaNiC¢kmµeRkARbeTsrbs;cinEføgkñúg»kasBiFI

Cb;elogmYyenAéf¶TI28 Extula qñaM1976/ F.B.I.S.-A.P.A., éf¶TI29 Extula 1976.

6 sgáat;¬GtßbT¦enH sMGagelIkarsnÞnarbs;´CamYyGñkkarTUtEdlbMeBjmuxgarenATIRkúg

haNUynigeb:kaMg naBak;kNþalqñaM1977. enAcugqñaM1976 km<úCaRbCaFibetyü)anTij

TMnijBIRkúghugkugRtwmEt1landuløarb:ueNÑaH. sUmGanGtßbTrbs;elak Nay:an; can;da ³

«Phnom Penh Undercover Men»kñúgTsSnavdþIesdækic©cugbUBa’ (F.E.E.R) ecjéf¶TI10 ExFñÚ qñaM

1976.

7 Ben Kiernan and Chanthou Boua, ksikr nigneya)ayenAkm<úCa/ London, Zed, 1982, p. 291.

8 David P. Chandler, «A Revolution and Full Spate: Communist Party Policy in Democratic Kampuchea,

ExFñÚ qñaM1976», GtßbTmin)ane)aHBum<pSay/ p. 7.

9 Kenneth M. Quinn, The Origin and Development of Radical Cambodian Communism, niekçbbT

fñak;bNÐit/ University of Maryland, 1982, pp. 136-137.

10 David P. Chandler, «Revising the Past in Democratic Kampuchea: When Was the Birthday of the

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg468

Page 479: Brother enemy

Party?», Pacific Affairs, été 1983, pp. 297-299; Ben Kiernan and Chanthou Boua, ksikr nig

neya)ayenAkm<úCa/ London, Zed, 1982, p. 291.

11 Chandler, ibid., p. 297.

12 Chanthou Boua and Ben Kiernan, «kariyaFibetyüénesckþIsøab;», New Statesman, éf¶TI2 Ex

]sPa qñaM1980; David Hawk, «mCÄmNÐlRbl½yBUCsasn_TYlEsøg», Index on Censorship,

Exmkra qñaM1986, pp. 25-31.

13 Chandler, op. cit., p. 298.

14 karbkERbGtßbTBITsSnavdþITg;bdivtþedayelak Timothy Carney nig Kem Sos Edlmankñúg

esovePAmYyCitecjpSay e)aHBum<pSayeday Karl Jackson.

15 B½t’manpþl;eday Timothy Carney, CaGñkÉkeTsxagbBaðakm<úCaenAsßanTUtGaemrikaMgRbcaMRkúg

)agkk. sUmGanesovePA «Cambodia’s Communist regime begins to purge its own ranks while

continuing a crack-down», Wall Street Journal, éf¶TI19 Extula qñaM1977.

16 S.W.B., éf¶TI1 Exvicäika qñaM1976.

17 A.V.I., éf¶TI21 ExFñÚ qñaM1976.

18 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYysa®sþacarü R)aemaCJ Naxnfab (Pramoj Nakhonthap) GtItRKÚ

beRgónmuxviC¢aviTüasa®sþneya)ay enAsaklviTüal½yFmµsatRkúg)agkk naTIRkúgevogc½nÞ

éf¶TI4 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1982.

19 B½t’manpþl;[enAEx]sPa qñaM1977 edayGñkkarTUtGasuImñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenARkúg

haNUy.

20 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy xaMKuN m®nþIénKN³kmµaFikarRbCaCnextþsVayerog/ sVayerog

éf¶TI14 Exmkra qñaM1981.

21 bkSkumµúynIsþenAevotNam ³ mhasnñi)atCatielIkTIIV. ÉksarRkúghaNUy/ kare)aHBum<

pSayCaPasabreTs/ 1977, pp. 161-162.

22 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak rs; saerOn enAéf¶TI14 Exmkra qñaM1981 naTIRkúg

PñMeBj.

23 B½t’manpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak Michel Strulovici GñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manrbs;kaEstG‘uym:anIet

¬l’Humanité) RbcaMTIRkúghaNUy/ Exvicäika qñaM1977.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 469

Page 480: Brother enemy

24 karsnÞnaCamYyGñkkarTUt\NÐamñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenATIRkúgeb:kaMg enAéf¶TI27 Extula

qñaM1977/ hugkug.

25 «esckþIraykarN_segçbsþIBIkarsnÞnarbs;]bnaykrdæm®nþI lI s‘annan CamYy paM v:an;dug enA

éf¶TI10 Exmifuna qñaM1977»/ A.C.N., 22 ExmIna qñaM1979.

26 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak suInNafmb‘Í r:ahSar:atNam rdæm®nþIkarbreTssigðburI/ éf¶

TI19 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1982/ sigðburI.

27 A.C.N., éf¶TI14 ExmIna qñaM1977.

28 S.W.B., éf¶TI19 Exemsa qñaM1977.

29 S.W.B., éf¶TI9 Exmkra qñaM1978.

30 sMMNuMerOgkm<úCa/ p. 133.

31 S.W.B., éf¶TI28 Exmifuna qñaM1977.

32 tamkaEst Sankei Shimbun, elIkykmkniyayCasMGagkñúg Issues and Studies, ExmIna qñaM

1978. enAExvicäika qñaM1977 tamRbPBB½t’manmYyrbs;evotNamfa TIRbwkSaciny:ag

eRcInRtÚvcab;CaeQøIyswkkñúg»kasénkarvaybkmYyenAkñúgEdndIrbs;km<úCa.

33 «esckþIraykarN_segçbsþIBIkarsnÞnarbs;]bnaykrdæm®nþI lI s‘annan CamYy paM v:an;dug

enAéf¶TI10 Exmifuna qñaM1977»/ A.C.N., éf¶TI22 ExmIna qñaM1979.

34 S.W.B., éf¶TI19 Exkkáda qñaM1977.

35 S.W.B., éf¶TI20 Exkkáda qñaM1977. bEnßmBIelIÉksarenH mankarcuHhtßelxaelI ³ sn§i

sBaØakMNt;RBMEdnmYyrvagevotNam-Lav/ kic©RBmeRBógpþl;CMnYyesdækic©mYysRmab;

ry³eBl3qñaMedaymin)ac;sgvij nigpþl;nUvR)ak;km©ImYyedayKµanykkarR)ak; nigkic©RBm

eRBógmYy edIm,Ipþl;TidæakarsRmab;GñkkarTUtnigm®nþIbuKÁlikrdækarRbeTsTaMgBIr. tamÉkGKÁ

rdæTUtrbs;evotNamRbcaMRbeTsLav egVón s‘n; (Nguyen Xuan) fa GVIEdlsMxan;KWCMnYyesdækic©

RtÚvEteRbIR)as;sRmab;karpÁt;pÁg;kgT½BevotNamEdlsMctenARbeTsLav.

36 bTsmÖasn_rbs;smmitþ b:ul Bt CamYyKN³RbtiPUGñkkaEstyUehÁasøavI EdlmkeFVITsSnkic©

enAkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü/ PñMeBj/ km<úCaRbCaFibetyü ExmIna qñaM1978.

37 sunÞrkfarbs; b:ul Bt enAmuxKN³kmµaFikarGcié®nþy_bkSnaéf¶TI2 ExsIha qñaM1978 Edl

ykmkbgðajenAcMeBaHmuxtulakarbdivtþn_RkúgPñMeBjenAéf¶TI2 ExsIha qñaM1979 eRkamelx

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg470

Page 481: Brother enemy

eyag 2>5>11. tulakarenH)ankat;eTas b:ul Bt nig eGog sarI kM)aMgmux edayRbhar

CIvitbg;.

38 elIkykmkniyayCasMGagedayelak Nay:an; can;da ³ «Lav/ evotNam ³ mitþCitsñiT§Cag

eK»/ TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R., éf¶TI29 Exkkáda qñaM1977.

39 elIkykmkniyayCasMGagedayelak háaer:t B½rT½r ³ , «neya)ayrbs;evotNam nigvibtþi

enA\NÐÚcin», p. 97.

40 Kiernan and Boua, Peasants, p. 170.

41 ÉksarNº2.5.11, kñúgkMNt;CasMGagenARtg;elxerog37.

42 S.W.B., éf¶TI14 Ex]sPa qñaM1977.

43 S.W.B., éf¶TI22 Extula qñaM1977.

44 P.I, éf¶TI7 Extula qñaM1977/ pp. 20-30.

45 kMNt;ehtusþIBIkarCYbrbs; b:ul Bt CamYyBYkemdwknaMcin/ éf¶TI29 ExkBaØa qñaM1977 RtÚv

rwbGUs)anenATIRkúgPñMeBj ÉksarenHRtÚv)anbgðajenAcMeBaHmuxtulakarbdivtþn_ naExsIha

qñaM1979 eRkamelxeyag 2>5>28.

46 esckþIraykarN_)anFøak;kñúgédRkúmPñak;garsm¶at;enAétv:an; ehIy)ane)aHBum<pSaykñúg Issues

and Studies, ExFñÚ qñaM1977/ pp. 77-79. esckþIraykarN_enH )ane)aHBum<pSaymYyExmun

karepþIms®gÁamrvagkm<úCanigevotNam Edlvabgðaj[eXIjR)akdEmn.

47 P.I., éf¶TI7 Extula qñaM1977, pp. 20-30.

vKÁ«neratþm sIhnu ³ kSRtEdlcakecjBIqakneya)ay»

1 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy paM v:an;)a/ GtItÉkGKÁrdæTUtrbs;evotNamRbcaMkm<úCaRbCaFib

etyü RkúghUCImij éf¶TI27 Exmkra qñaM1981.

CMBUkTI4

1 Wang Gungwa, shKmn_nigRbCaCati ³ karniBn§l,gGMBIGasuIGaeKñy_ nigRbeTscin/ Singapore,

Heinemann, 1981, p. 53.

2 Georges Maspero, «RBHraCaNacRkcm,:a», Paris, Van Houst, 1928, p. 224.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 471

Page 482: Brother enemy

3 kaEst Réalités Cambodgiennes, elxecjéf¶TI24 Exmifuna qñaM1965.

4 Huynh Sanh Thong, éd. et trad., The Heritage of Vietnamese Poetry, New Haven, Conn., Yale University

Press, 1979, p. 3.

5 Henri Maspero, dkRsg;CasMGagedayelak M. Coughlin, «evotNamkñúgRsemalrbs;cin »,

Journal of Southeast Asian History, kBaØa qñaM1967/ p. 242.

6 dkRsg;mkniyayCasMGagedayelak Keith W. Taylor, «The rise of Dai Viet and the establishment

of Thang Long» dans Kenneth R. Hall and John K. Whitmore éd., Explorations in Early Southeast Asian

History: The Origins of Southeast Asian Statecraft, Michigan Papers on South and Southeast Asia, Nº11,

Ann Arbor, 1976, pp 165-166, bkERbBIPasaevotNamedayelakétl½r. sMeNAedImCaPasa

cinRtÚv)at;bg;. RbvtþiviTU Wang Gungwu Kitfa lixitenHTMngCa)anbBa¢Ún edayBitR)akd

eRBaH)armÖeFVI[rMCYldl;menaseBa©tnaCatiniym b:uEnþmankarEkbEnßm[kan;Etl¥elIsmunxøHBI

sMNak;Gñksresrkalb,vtþirbs;evotNam.

7 Gungwu, op. cit., p. 64.

8 Thomas Hodgkin, Vietnam: the Revolutionary Path, New York, St. Martin’s Press, p. 56.

9 Hodgkin, ibid., p. 89.

10 sa®sþacarü George Mct. Kahin, B½t’manpÞal;xøÜn/ éf¶TI19 Exkkáda qñaM1984.

11 Trung Buu Lam, «Intervention versus Tribute in Sino-Vietnamese Relations, 1788 -1790», kñúg The

Chinese World Order, John K. Fairbank éd., Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1968, p. 178.

12 Le Thanh Khoi, Histoire du Vietnam des origines à 1858, Paris, Sudestasie, 1981, p. 214.

13 Lloyd Eastman, Throne and Mandarins: China’s Search for a Policy during the Sino-French Controversy

1880-1885, Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1967, p. 43.

14 Trung Buu Lam, ibidem, 174-175.

15 John K. Whitmore, The Development of Le Government in Fifteenth Century Vietnam, niekçbbTfñak;

bNÐit/ Cornell University, 1968, p. 208 nigesovePA «RBHraCaNacRkcm,:a» p. 231 rbs;elak

Maspero pgEdr.

16 Chandler, Cambodia Before the French, p. 63.

17 niekçbbTrbs; vUdés EdlRtÚv)ankarBary:agRtcHRtcg;kñúgesovePArbs;Kat; mancMNgeCIg

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg472

Page 483: Brother enemy

fa evotNam nigKMrUcin/ Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1971, pp. 253-254.

18 Dao Vang Vy, Nguyen Tri Phuong, Saigon, Nha Van Hoa, Ba Van Hoa, Giao Duc Va Than Nien,

1974, p. 53. ´sUmGKuNelak Michael Eiland Edl)anTak;TajkarykcitþTukdak;rbs;´eTAelI

sgáat;GtßbTRtg;enH ehIyEdl)anbkERb[´EfmeTot.

19 John T. McAlister, Jr., «PaBGacnwgekItmansRmab;kargarTUtenAGasuIGaeKñy_», World Politics, Vol.

XIX, Nº2, Exmkra qñaM1976/ p. 273.

20 dkRsg;ykmkniyayCasMGagedayelak Huynh Kim Khanh, lT§ikumµúynIsþevoNam/ Ithaca,

N.Y., Cornell University Press, 1982, p. 129.

21 Dossier Kampuchéa, p. 95.

22 Ibid.

23 William Turley, «Vietnam’s View of Regional Order», karTak;TgKñaenAsnñi)atRbcaMqñaMelIkTI26én

smaKmsikSaBIbBaðaGnþrCati/ Washington D.C., 8 mai 1985, p.6.

24 Ibid.

25 GtßbTrbs; Che Viet Tan «Redistribute the work force in order to build and defend the fatherland»,

Tap Chi Cong San, ExsIha qñaM1979 RtÚv)anbkERbcuHpSaykñúgesckþIraykarN_rbs;RbeTs

evotNam/ Nº2148, Washington, D.C., National Technical Information Service, 1979, Washington

D.C., 1979, p. 21.

26 F.B.I.S.-A.P.A., éf¶TI4 Exmkra qñaM1985/ K.G.

27 elIkmkniyayCasMGageday Suebsaeng Promboon, Sino-Siamese Tributary Relations, 1282-1853,

niekçbbTfñak;bNÐit/ University of Wisconsin, 1971, p. 173.

28 elIkykmkniyayCasMGageday Gungwu, op. cit., pp. 46-47.

29 elIkykmkniyayCasMGageday Eastman, op. cit., p. 39.

30 Ben Kiernan, esovePA «etI b:ul Bt cUlkan;GMNacEbbNa?»/ London, Verso, 1985, p. 140.

31 esckþIraykarN_EdltamsegátemIltYnaTIrbs;RbeTscinenAsnñisITRkúghSWENv KWsMGagCa

sMxan;elIesovePArbs;elak François Joyaux, «RbeTscin nig karedaHRsayCemøaH\NÐÚcin

TImYy»/ hSWENv qñaM1954/ ):arIs/ kare)aHBum<pSayrbs; Sorbonne, 1979, pp. 231-323.

32 cMeBaHkarviPaKl¥itl¥n;mYyGMBI\riyabfrbs;RbeTscin cMeBaHkarbRgÜbbRgÜmRbeTsevotNam

RbPBÉksarsMGag 473

Page 484: Brother enemy

EtmYy sUmGanesovePA CemøaHcin-evotNam rbs;elak Eugène K. Lawson, New York,

Praeger, 1984, pp. 52-69.

33 Roxane Witke, smmitþnarI cag Qij/ Little, Brown, 1977, p. 271.

34 Mohamed Heikal, Nasser: ÉksarRkúgEKr/ London, New English Library, 1973, p. 269.

35 esckþIsarPaBrbs;elakCMTav Wang Guangmei cMeBaHelak David G. Marr, eb:kaMg/ éf¶TI7 ExkBaØa

qñaM1980. GKuNcMeBaHelak David G. Marr EdlbBa¢Únmk[´nUvkMNt;xøI²rbs;elak.

36 Kissinger, Years of Upheaval, pp. 58-59.

37 RtÚvsaksYredayGñkniBn§enATIRkúgevogc½nÞ enAéf¶TI26 Ex]sPa qñaM1978 nayTahanevot

Nammñak;)anRbkasR)ab;´fa ³ «CnCatiLavkat;cinmñak;KW ]tþmesnIy_ PUm:a RtÚv)ansmøab;

kñúgkarRbyuT§enAqñaM1971 b:uEnþeK)anbMepøIsfa Kat;RtÚvkMcat;edayevotNam» edayeFVI[eK

eCOfa BaküccamGar:amRbEhlCamUlehtumYyehIyemIleTA.

38 Pierre Mendès France, Tl;muxKñaCamYynwgGasuI/ New York, Liveright, 174, pp. 107-108. kare)aHBum<

pSaytamsMeNAedIm/ Pierre Mendès France, karsnÞnaCamYynwgGasuIéf¶enH/ esovePAkMNt;

ehtuénkareFVIdMeNIr/ Paris, Gallimard, 1972.

39 Pierre Mendès France, op. cit., p.189.

40 Etienne M. Mana’ch, RbeTsmYyEdlqøgkat;edaybNþaGanuPaBminGacTb;Tl;)an ³ cin-\NÐÚcin

qñaM1972-1973 Paris Fayard, 1982, p. 575.

41 Porter, «evotNamnigvibtþi\NÐÚcin», pp. 74-75.

42 TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R., éf¶TI15 Exmifuna qñaM1979, p. 39.

43 Lawson, op. cit., pp. 193-194.

44 karkt;smÁal;rbs; tag ¬Tang¦ RtÚv)anGHGagbBa¢ak;edaym®nþICan;x<s;mñak;enARkúghaNUy

nigdkRsg;ykmkniyayCasMGagedayelak Stanley Karnow kñúgesovePA evotNam/ GMBI

Rbvitþsa®sþmYy/ N.Y., Viking, 1983, p. 638.. bYnExmunkareFVIdMeNIrrbs;RbFanaFibtI nicsun

eTAkan;RbeTscin ¬ExkumÖ³ qñaM1972¦ RbeTscin)anTUnµan[RbeTsevotNamTukbBaðaRbFana

FibtI FIv mYyduMsin ehIyseRmc[xagEt)annUvkic©RBmeRBógmYysMedA[mankardkkgT½B

GaemrikcugeRkayecjBIRbeTsevotNam.

45 François Missoffe, karRbyuT§ttYrvagRkúmneya)ayxageqVg/ Paris, Ramsay, 1977, p. 128.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg474

Page 485: Brother enemy

46 Thanh Nam, «eb:kaMgse®gÁaHRkúgéRBnKr » ¬ebkaMgCYyRkúgéRBnKr¦/ Tinanub,vtþievotNam/ Ex

mifuna qñaM1979; Philippe Richer, El,gelgbYnnak;enAGasuIGaeKñy_/ Paris, Presses Universitaires

de France, 1982, p. 49.

47 Joyaux, la Chine, p. 355.

48 Lawson, op. cit., p. 242.

49 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtevotNammñak;enAéf¶TI14 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1983 naTIRkúg

)agkk.

CMBUkTI5

1 Seymour Hersh, The Price of Power: Kissinger in the Nixon White House, New York, Summit Books,

1983, pp. 623-625.

2 tamkic©RBmeRBógRkúg):arIs RbeTsevotNam)ansnüa «CYysRmÜldl;karbBa¢ÚneTAmatu

RbeTsvijnUvsaksBTahanTaMgLayEdl)at;kñúgxøÜnkarRbyuT§»ehIyshrdæGaemriksnüa

«CYypSHmuxrbYss®gÁam».

3 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak eLGUNad_ vUdxUk enAéf¶TI17 ExsIha qñaM1984naTIRkúg

v:asuInetan.

4 kariyal½yGnuB½n§B½t’manrbs;estviman/ Presidential Commission on Americans Missing and

Unaccounted for in Southeast Asia: A Report on Trip to Vietnam and Laos March 16-20, 1977,

Washington, D.C., éf¶TI23 ExmIna 1977/ p. 11.

5 W.P., éf¶TI18 ExmIna qñaM1977.

6 fVIebImtiPaKeRcInelIslubmYyénrdæaPi)alshrdæGaemrik bgðajPaBGmitþcMeBaHRbeTsevot

NamenAqñaM1975k¾eday k¾manGñkxøHlMeGogeTArkkarpSHpSaKñaEdr. elakvresnIy_RtIy_

ém:xWl GILin EdlRbLÚkyUrmkehIykñúgkarRbwgERbgeFVIs®gÁamrbs;GaemrikaMgenA\NÐÚcin

)ansresrGnusSrN³mYyeTAGnurdæm®nþIkarBarRbeTsenAéf¶TI5 Exmifuna edayENnaMBIkareFVI

[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRkúghaNUy eTaHbICaTRmg;d¾Cak;lak;mYyénCMnYyEpñkesdækic©RtÚvbg;

Catémøk¾eday. sRmab;Kat;yl;fa karraMgxÞb;Epñkesdækic© «KWCaTegVIrMelaPbMBanmYyEfmTaMg

CaTegVIRceLatetattUgmYypg EdlminsmrmüTaMgRsugkñúgneya)ayGnþrCatirbs;RbCaCati

RbPBÉksarsMGag 475

Page 486: Brother enemy

eCOnelOnmYy». edaypÞúyeTAvij GILin )anpþl;CaGnusasn_[Rbkan;ykviFankarl¥itl¥n;

nigemaHmutepSg²Tl;nwgtfPaBénRbeTsevotNamfµI.

7 N.Y.T., éf¶TI19 Exvicäika qñaM1975.

8 dkRsg;mkniyayCasMGagedayelak Murray Hiebert, «Playing Politics with the MIAs»,

Southeast Asia Chronicle, Nº85, éf¶TI12 ExsIha qñaM1982.

9 N.Y.T., éf¶TI25 Exemsa qñaM1976.

10 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak rIqad hUlRb‘Úk enAéf¶TI5 Exmifuna naTIRkúgeb:kaMg.

11 tamkar[dwgrbs;RksYgkarBarRbeTsfa kñúgcMnYnsrubmnusS)at;xøÜnenA\NÐÚcin2>546nak;

man753nak;)anRtÚvcat;Tukfa)at;xøÜnkñúgkarRbyuT§/ 33nak;RtÚvcab;CaeQøIys®gÁam/ 647

nak; TMngCasøab; ehIy1>113)anRtÚvsmøab;kñúgeBlRbyuT§ edayeKminGacnaMsaksBmk

)an. sUmGacesovePArbs;elak Bill Herod, «The Unfinished Business of America’s MIAs»,

Indochina Issues, Nº17/ mifuna qñaM1981/ rYmTaMg «America’s Missing: A Look behind the Numbers»,

Indochina Issues, Nº54/ ExkumÖ³ qñaM1985pg.

12 W.P., éf¶TI17 ExFñÚ qñaM1976.

13 Cyrus Vance, Hard Choices: Critical Years in American Foreign Policy, New York, Simon and Schuster,

1983, 450.

14 snñisITkaEstrbs;RbFanaFibtI xaF½r enAéf¶TI24 ExmIna qñaM1977/ Rkúgv:asuInetan.

15 S.W.B., éf¶TI29 ExmIna qñaM1977.

16 kñúgkarsnÞnamYyenATIRkúghugkug naéf¶TI3 ExmIna qñaM1983elak mIEsðl GUkesnbWk Gñk

ÉkeTsxagbBaðaGasuIenARkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati )anniyayR)ab;´Ca]TahrN_fa ³ «ebskkmµ

rbs; vUdxUk RbRBwtþeTAmin)anl¥eLIy. tamkarBit GñkxøH)anxMRbwgeFVIdMeNIrmYysRmab;Et

erOgTahanGaemrik)at;xøÜnsuT§saF/ »kasénkare)aHtRmúydMbUg²sRmab;kareFVI[manRbRktI

PaBmYyCamYyRbeTsevotNamkMBugnaM[evotNamyl;RcLM. enAcMeBaHmux vUdxUk evotNam

)anbgðajlkçN³Tn;Pøn;GMBIbBaðaCYsCulkarxUcxatedaysars®gÁam. rhUtTal;EteRkaymk

eTIbevotNamElgbnÞn;CMhr ehIyxaMRkajcMeBaHsMeNIsuMCMnYyesdækic©rbs;eK».

17 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy egVón LaM RbFanKN³kmµaFikarEpnkarrbs;evotNamenAéf¶TI31

Exmkra qñaM1981naTIRkúghaNUy. TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R, éf¶TI28 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1981.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg476

Page 487: Brother enemy

18 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy rIqad hUlRb‘Úk enAéf¶TI5 Exmifuna qñaM1983 naTIRkúgeb:kaMg.

19 C.Vance, op. cit., p. 122.. xaF½r )ansEmþg[dwgBITwkcitþrbs;Kat;fa «eRtómRbkYtRbECgnwgBYk

sUevotkñúgtMbn;CayuT§sa®sþTaMgLay CaBiessenARbeTsevotNam». N.Y.T., éf¶TI12 Ex

mifuna qñaM1977.

20 Zbigniew Brzezinski, GMNacnigeKalkarN_ ³ kMNt;RbvtþiGMBIRkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati (1977-1981),

New York, Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 1983,p. 197.

21 saFardæsgÁmniymevotNamr)aykarN_esdækic©mYy/ FnaKarBiPBelak/ Washington, D.C.,

August 1977, p. 66.

22 TUrelxrbs;ÉkGKÁrdæTUtshrdæGaemrikRbcaMRkúg)agkk Charles Whitehouse, Nº09191-2717442,

éf¶TI27 Exemsa qñaM1977.

23 Asian Wall Street Journal, éf¶TI5 Ex]sPa qñaM1977.

24 karerobrab;l¥itl¥n;enHKW)anmkBIkarsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGnurdæm®nþIkarbreTs pan; ehon

enATIRkúg):arIs naéf¶TI21 Exmifuna qñaM1977 nigCamYyGtItGnurdæm®nþI rIqad hUlRb‘Úk/

Rkúgv:asuInetan>DI>suI>/ éf¶TI24 Exkkáda qñaM1981.

25 F.B.I.S-A.P.A., éf¶TI7 Exmifuna qñaM1977, K-5.

26 Arkady N. Shevchenko, Ebk)ak;CamYynwgRkúgmUsÁÚ/ New York; Knopf, 1985, p. 265. kare)aHBum<

pSay CaPasa)araMg ³ «karpþac;mitþPaBCamYyRkúgmUsÁÚ» (Rupture avec Moscou), Paris, Payot,

1985.

27 Marc Menguy, haNUyRbqaMgnwgeb:kaMg/ mCÄmNÐlsRmab;kic©karGnþrCati/ Harvard University,

1979, p. 36.

28 Ibid., 40.

29 Ibid., 41.

30 Information-Documents, Nº3, éf¶TI1 Exemsa qñaM1982/ e)aHBum<pSayeday C.V., RkúghaNUy,

p. 11.

CMBUkTI6

1 karerobrab;GMBI]bTÞvehtuenAsNæaKarfaMgLenH KWsMGagelIkarsnÞnaCamYyGñkkarTUtCaeRcIn

RbPBÉksarsMGag 477

Page 488: Brother enemy

EdlmanmuxenAkñúgBiFIbdisNæarkic©. ]bTÞvehtu)anRtÚvelIkykmkniyayedayelak Marc

Menguy GñkkarTUt)araMg EdleBlenaHbMeBjmuxgarenATIRkúghaNUy ³ haNUyRbqaMgnwg

eb:kaMg/ mCÄmNÐlsRmab;kic©karGnþrCati/ 1979, p. 33.

2 hU CImij ³ «ehtuGVI´eRCIserIslT§ieLnInniym»/ skmµPaBnigkarbdivtþn_ ¬Action et Révolution

1920-1967,¦ GtßbTCeRmIs nigerobcMedayelak Colette Capitan -Peter-Paris, shPaBTUeTAén

kare)aHBum<pSay/ coll. 10/18, 1968, p.18.

3 GMBIdMeNIrCIvitrbs; hU CImij sUmGanesovePArbs;elak Jean Lacouture: Ho Chi Minh, Paris,

éditions du Seuil, 1977. GMBIclnakumµúynIsþevotNam sUmGanesovePAmYykñúgcMeNamesovePA

nanaEdll¥CageKKW lT§ikumµúynIsþevotNam 1925-45 rbs;elak Huynh Kim Khanh,

Ithaca, New York, Cornell University Press, 1982.

4 Gareth Porter, «Vietnam and the Socialist Camp: Center or Periphery», Vietnamese Communism in

Comparative Perspective, William Turley éd., Boulder, Colo., Westview Press, 1980, pp. 228-231.

5 Bernard Fall, esovePA ³ evotmij ³ saFarNrdæRbCaFibetyüevotNam 1945-60, Paris, Presses

de la Fondation nationale des sciences politiques, 1960, p. 116-119.

6 Jean Lacouture nig Philippe Devillers, End of a War: Indochina 1954, New York, Praeger, 1969, pp.

291-293. kare)aHBum<c,ab;edIm ³ TIbBa©b;éns®gÁammYy/ \NÐÚcin qñaM1954, Paris, éditions du

Seuil, 1960.

7 Porter, op. cit., p. 247.

8 elIkykmkniyayCasMGagedayelak Douglas Pike: «\T§iBlénCemøaHcin-sUevotcMeBaHGasuI

GaeKñy_», CemøaHrvagcin-sUevot/ Herbert Ellison éd., Scattle, University of Washington Press, 1982,

p. 196.

9 Donald S. Zagoria, Vietnam Triangle: Moscow, Peking, Hanoi, New York, Pegasus, 1967, p. 127.

10 sRmab;karviPaKsuICeRmAmYyGMBIneya)ayrbs;evotNamcMeBaHshPaBsUevot nigRbeTs

cin sUmGanesovePArbs;elak W.R. Smyser, PaBminBwgEp¥krbs;evotNam ³ lT§ikumµúynIsþ

evotNamenAcenøaH rusSI nigcin/ 1956-69, Papers on International Studies, Southeast Asia Series,

Nº55, Athens, Ohio, Ohio University Center for International Studies, 1980.

11 David Butler, kardYlrlMrbs;RkúgéRBnKr/ New York, Simon and Schuster, 1985, p. 299.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg478

Page 489: Brother enemy

12 Daniel S Papp., evotNam ³ mtimkBIRkúgmUsÁÚ/ eb:kaMg/ v:asuInetan/ Jefferson, N.C., Mc Farland,

1981, p. 195.

13 Shevchenko, Ebk)ak;CamYynwgRkúgmUsÁÚ/ pp. 262-263.

14 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþImñak;énRksYgkarbreTsrbs;evotNamenAéf¶TI24 Exmkra

qñaM1981 naTIRkúghaNUy.

15 Joseph Alsop, «Showdown Over Southeast Asia», TsSnavdþI Reader’s Digest, elxecjExFñÚ qñaM

1975/ TMB½r128.

16 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy v:ag Tug enAéf¶TI25 Exkkáda qñaM1975 naTIRkúghaNUy.

karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþICan;x<s;mñak;énRksYgkarbreTsevotNam enATIRkúghaNUy

naéf¶TI26 Exkkáda qñaM1975.

17 Q.D.N.D., éf¶TI7 Extula qñaM1974/ dkRsg;mkniyayCasMGagkñúg Asian Analyst, éf¶TI4

Exvicäika qñaM1975/ p. 4.

18 B½t’manpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak Peter Limqueco, éf¶TI11 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1976.

19 vicarNkfarbs;kaEst Giaiphong éf¶TI28 Exvicäika qñaM1975 dkRsg;mkniyayCasMGag

eday Le Thi Tuyet, evotNam ³ sgÁmniymkñúgkarEsVgrkmUlFn/ Washington, D.C., Center of

Strategic and International Studies, 1976, p. 9.

20 Nayan Chanda, «Hanoi Opts For a Broad Approach», TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R, éf¶TI25 ExkumÖ³ qñaM

1977.

21 kareqøIy[karN_rbs;elak Evelyn Colbert GtItGnurdæelxaFikarTTYlbnÞúkkic©karGasuIxagekIt

nig):asuIhVik enAcMeBaHmuxGnuKN³kmµkarsPaTTYlbnÞúkkic©karGasuInig):asuIhVik/ éf¶TI26 Ex

kkáda qñaM1983/ muxgarrbs;sUevotenAGasuI/ Washington, D.C., U.S. Government Printing

Office, 1983, p. 193.

22 Sevchenko, op. cit., p. 263.

23 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtGWr:ubmñak;enAéf¶TI25 Exvicäika naTIRkúghaNUy. kar

snÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþICan;x<s;mñak;énGgÁTUtrbs;sUevot enATIRkúgeb:kaMgnaéf¶TI6

Exmifuna qñaM1983.

24 GñkeqøIyqøgB½t’manGnamik/ «Le Duan backs the loners», TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R., éf¶TI19 ExmIna

RbPBÉksarsMGag 479

Page 490: Brother enemy

qñaM1976.

25 B½t’manpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak Massimo Loche, GñkeqøIyqøgB½t’mankaEst l’Unità enATIRkúghaNUy/

ExFñÚ qñaM1976.

26 «I.M.F., I.B.R.D., Tools of Imperialist Exploitation», TIPñak;garB½t’man Tass, éf¶TI6 Exemsa qñaM

1983/ F.B.I.S., U.S.S.R., éf¶TI8 Exemsa qñaM1983/ C.C.2.

27 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUt\NÐamñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenARkúghaNUy naéf¶TI2

Exmkra qñaM1977 enATIRkúghugkug.

28 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtevotNammñak;enATIRkúgevogc½nÞ naéf¶TI9 ExmIna qñaM

1977.

29 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkaTUtGasuImñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenATIRkúghaNUy naéf¶TI4 Ex

vicäika qñaM1976 enATIRkúghugkug. karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþImñak;énRksYgBaNiC¢kmµ

GU®sþalIenATIRkúghugkugnaéf¶TI4 Ex]sPa qñaM1977. sUmGanGtßbTrbs;elak Nayan

Chanda, «Hanoi Opts For Broad Approach» cuHpSaykñúgTsSnavdþI F.E.E.R. elxecjpSay

éf¶TI25 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1977 pg.

30 Robert Ross, Chana’s Vietnam Policy, 1975-1979; The Politic of Alliance Termination,

niekçbbTfñak;bNÐit/ Colombia University, 1984, p. 140.

31 Nayan Chanda, «Vietnam’s Economy: New Priorities», F.E.E.R., éf¶TI19 Exvicäika qñaM1976.

32 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtGasuImñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenATIRkúghaNUy naéf¶TI5

Ex]sPa qñaM1977enATIRkúghugkug.

33 S.W.B., éf¶TI17 ExFñÚ qñaM1976.

34 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUt\NÐamñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenATIRkúghaNUy naéf¶TI19

ExsIha qñaM1977 enATIRkúghugkug.

35 karsnÞnaCamYyelak Philippe Richer GtItÉkGKÁrdæTUt)araMgRbcaMTIRkúghaNUy enAéf¶TI13

Exmifuna qñaM1982 enATIRkúg):arIs.

36 esckþIraykarN_GMBIkarcrcasUevot-evotNamenH KWsMGagelIkarsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§Ca

mYyGñkkarTUtCaeRcInrUb TaMgxagbs©imRbeTsk¾dUcxagbøúkkumµúynIsþ rYmTaMgCamYyGñkkaEst

GWr:ubxagekItenATIRkúghaNUy naExvicäika qñaM1977pg. karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñk

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg480

Page 491: Brother enemy

TTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;EpñkkarTUtrbs;sUevotenAéf¶TI6 Exmifuna qñaM1983 naTIRkúgeb:kaMg.

37 Ross, op., cit., 211.

38 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtsUevot nig GWr:ubxagekIt enATIRkúghaNUy naExvicäika

qñaM1977. karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUt\NÐamñak; eFVIkarGmBYksUevotenA

éf¶TI17 Exmkra qñaM1986 naTIRkúgv:asuInetanDI>suI>.

CMBUkTI7

1 B½t’manpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak Sandor Gyori, éf¶TI12 Extula qñaM1985.

2 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Stephen Heder enATIRkúg)agkk naéf¶TI30 Exmifuna qñaM

1983.

3 karBiBN’naenHsMGagelIkarsnÞnaCaÉkCnmYyCamYyGñkTTYlxusRtÚvevotNambIrUbkñúgenaH

manmñak;CavresnIy_Ék rYmTaMgCamYyGñkkarTUténbNþaRbeTsminEmnkumµúynIsþ enATIRkúg

haNUy naExmIna qñaM1978pg.

4 esovePAexµA ³ ehtukarN_nigP½sþútagepSg²énGMeBIQøanBannigkarP¢ab;TwkdIrbs;evotNam

RbqaMgnwgkm<úCa/ PñMeBj/ RksYgkarbreTs/ qñaM1978/ TMB½r99.

5 sMNuMerOgkm<úCa/ Vol. 2. C.V., Hanoi, 1979, pp. 63-65.

6 karsnÞnarbs;elak Stephen Heder CamYyelak h‘un Esn/ PñMeBj/ Exkkáda qñaM1981.

7 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Stephen Heder enATIRkúg)agkk naéf¶TI30 Exmifuna qñaM

1983.

8 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUt\NÐamñak;EdlbMeBjmuxgarenATIRkúghaNUy naExsIha

qñaM1978 enATIRkúghugkug.

9 karbkRsayRsbKña RtÚv)anpþl;dl;elak Stephen Heder edayelak h‘un Esn nig ehg sMrin

kñúg»kasénkarsnÞnadac;edayELkBIKñaenAExkkáda qñaM1981.

10 tamelak ehg sMrin Edlkan;muxtMENgsMxan;²enAkñúgépÞrNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa

enAqñaM1979 nigEdlkøayeTACaRbFanRkúmRbwkSaRbCaCnbdivtþn_extþkNþal)an[dwgfa Rkúm

GñkbegáItrNsirSenHdMbUgKWmanR)aMbInak; ³ Kat;/ elak h‘un Esn/ nut fn/ jwk hYn/ mas RkÚc/

mas hYn/ G‘ug pn nig eb:g ):at; ¬karsnÞnaCamYyelak Heder, éf¶TI8 Exkkáda qñaM1981

RbPBÉksarsMGag 481

Page 492: Brother enemy

enARkúgPñMeBj¦.

11 karsnÞnaCamYyGñkkarTUtevotNamnigGasuIenARkúghaNUy naExmIna qñaM1978.

12 CemøaHRBMEdnrvagcin-evotNam manlkçN³CanimitþehtumYyeRcInCagCabuBVehtumYyén

CemøaHEdlmanenAeBlxagmux. CemøaHenH)ancab;epþImenAedImTsvtSr_1970 enAeBlEdl

plRbeyaCn_ CatinigCayuT§sa®sþrbs;RbeTsTaMgBIrcab;epþImExVgKña. cMeBaHkarbkRsay

rbs;evotNam sUmGanGnusSrN³rbs;RksYgkarbreTsénsaFarNrdæsgÁmniymevotNam

Tak;TgeTAnwgkarbgáehtu nigkarrMelaPRBMEdnrab;minGs; EdlBYkGaCJaFrcinenAtambeNþay

RBMEdncin-evotNam CaGñkTTYlxusRtÚv/ haNUy/ RksYgkarbreTs/ qñaM1979/ pp. 17-22.

sRmab;PaB c,as;las;epSg²Tak;TgnwgRBMEdnEdneKakenH sUmGanGtßbT China-Vietnam

Boundary, International Boundary Studies, Nº38, Bureau of Intelligence and Research, U.S. Department

of State, Washington, D.C., éf¶TI29 Extula qñaM1964. tamGtßbTenHfa «KµankarvivaTEdndI

NamYyB¤mkdl;eyIgeT ».

13 A.V.I., éf¶TI10 Extula qñaM1977.

14 h½g v:an;hn )ancuHcUlnwgBYkcinenAExkkáda qñaM1979 b:uEnþ TMnak;TMngd¾CitsñiT§rbs;Kat;Ca

mYyBYkcin RtÚveKdwgB¤CasaFarN³taMgBImunkalbriecäTenHemø:H. vaGacfa RkúghaNUyxMRbwg

eRbIR)as;TMnak;TMngepSg²rbs;Kat;CamYyBYkemdwknaMcin edIm,ITTYl)ankarKaMRTBIRkúgeb:kaMg

cMeBaHeKalbMNgrbs;xøÜnEdr. BYkcinRbEhlCa)anTTYlBIKat;nUvB½t’mand¾mantémøCaeRcInsþIBI

CMhrrbs; evotNameTAelIbBaðasMxan;². eTaHbICaKat;pÞal;RtÚvTuk[manmuxtMENgCapøÚvkar

¬manEtsMbkeRkA¦ k¾eday k¾kUnrbs;Kat;)ankan;kab;TItaMgd¾sMxan;mYykñúgbkSkumµúynIsþ

evotNamEdr ehIyGacesuIb ykkarN_tamry³mitþPkþinigGñkmansmancitþCaeRcInrbs;Kat;

EfmeTot.

15 sMeNAénkic©RBmeRBóg )anRtÚvRbmUl)anedaykgT½Brbs;evotNamenARkúgPñMeBj enA

Exmkra qñaM1979.

16 S.W.B., éf¶TI14 Exvicäika qñaM1977.

17 esckþIseRmccitþEdlsnµtfaCarbs;elak eL yn; RtÚv)annaMmkniyayedayTIPñak;gar

B½t’mancinfµI(A.C.N.)enAéf¶TI23 Exvicäika qñaM1979bnÞab;BIkarcab;epþImGriPaBrvagcin-

evotNam enAqñaM1978 kñúgeKalbMNgbriharBIkarbþÚrKMnitPøam²rbs;evotNam. k¾b:uEnþ

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg482

Page 493: Brother enemy

vaTMngCasMedARbqaMgnwgesckþIesµaHRtg;rbs;evotNamcMeBaHRbeTscineTAPaBminesµaHRtg;

rbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgcMeBaHRbeTsevotNampgEdr.

18 S.W.B., éf¶TI22 Exvicäika qñaM1977.

19 S.W.B., éf¶TI22 Exvicäika qñaM1977.

20 F.B.I.S.-P.R.C., éf¶TI22 Exvicäika qñaM1975/ A-18-19.

21 «Keng Piao’s r)aykarN_GMBIsßankarN_enA]bTVIb\NÐÚcin» Issue and Studies, étbui/ Exmkra

qñaM1981/ p. 85. m®nþIcinfñak;x<s;mñak;)anbBa¢ak;R)ab;´BIlkçN³BiténÉksarenH.

22 GñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinCaeRcInrUb EdlRtÚvsaksYrenATIRkúgeb:kaMg nigTIRkúghugkug kalBIqñaM

1979)anniyayGMBIPaBExVgKMnitKñaEdlenAmanbnþkñúgépÞfñak;dwknaMcin rhUtmkdl;cugqñaM

1978 sþIBIbBaðaRbeTskm<úCa. enAkalbriecäTenH CemøaHrvagkm<úCa-evotNam)aneLIgdl;

kRmitminGacRtLb;eRkaymYy edayKMramkMEhgdl;TItaMgCayuT§sa®sþTaMgLayrbs;RbeTs

cin enAGasuIGaeKñy_ ehIy etg s‘avBIg RtÚv)anCMruj[begáInkarKaMRTrbs;cindl;RbeTskm<úCa

TaMgeTIsTal;.

23 N.Y.T., éf¶TI23 ExFñÚ qñaM1977/ p.5.

24 edayelIkyksmþIsnÞnaTaMgenHmkniyaysMGag RbB½n§pSBVpSayrbs;evotNam)ankt;

smÁal;fa «vagayyl;Nas;fa GñkNaEdleRbIsmþIbBaäitbeBaäógEdlmaneKalbMNgTaMg

enH»/ CemøaHevotNam-km<úCa ³ ÉksarmYy/ haNUy/ GKare)aHBum<pSayCaPasabreTs/

1979, p. 23.

25 F.B.I.S.-A.P.A, éf¶TI16 ExFñÚ qñaM1977/ H-3.

26 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak can;epg sIupaPMu Cam®nþICan;x<s;enARksYgkarbreTsLav/

éf¶TI28 Exkkáda qñaM1983 enATIRkúgevogc½nÞ.

27 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy v:ag Tug enAéf¶TI22 ExmIna qñaM1978 naTIRkúghaNUy.

28 briyakasEdlkMBugRKbdNþb;RkúgPñMeBjnaeBlenaH KWRtÚv)anBiBN’naedayCnbreTsCaGñk

taMglMenAeRkARsukmñak; kñúgcMeNamCnbreTsd¾kRmmanbMput KWGñkRsI LÚr:g;Bic CaPriyarbs;

kmµaPi)alfñak;dwknaMExµrRkhmmñak; EdlGñkRsI)anrs;enARbeTskm<úCacab;BIqñaM1975 dl;

1979 munnwgcakecjBIsVamInigRbeTsEdlTTYlsÁal;Kat;TukdUcCakUn. sUmGanesovePA ³

«q¶ayhYs eCIgemX ³ R)aMqñaMCamYyExµrRkhm»/ Paris, Barrault, 1984, p. 116.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 483

Page 494: Brother enemy

29 Ibid., p. 115.

30 F.B.I.S.-A.P.A., éf¶TI1 Exmkra qñaM1978.

31 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy Kieu Ming enAéf¶TI16 Exmkra qñaM1981 naTIRkúgPñMeBj.

32 kñúg»kasénsnñisITmYy ¬enATIRkúgeb:kaMg éf¶TI31 ExFñÚ¦ ÉkGKÁrdæTUtkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü biuc

Cag )anRbkasfa ³ «kareRCIserIsEtmYyKt;rvaglT§PaBBIrrbs;eyIgKWvayRbyuT§ edIm,ITak;

TajkarykcitþTukdak;BIbNþamitþrbs;eyIgTaMgCitTaMgq¶ayelITVIbTaMgR)aM edIm,IdeNþImkarKaMRTBI

saFarN³mtiGnþrCati». elIkykmkniyayCasMGagedayelak Douglas Pick kñúgGtßbTCemøaH

evotNam-km<úCa/ r)aykarN_EdleFVIsRmab;GnuKN³kmµkarGMBIGasuI nigkic©kar):asuIhVik/

Committee on International Relations, Washington, D.C., U.S. Congress, éf¶TI4 Extula qñaM1978/

p. 11.

33 TIPñak;garB½t’man A.F.P., éf¶21 Extula qñaM1977.

34 enAsm½yRbCuMeBjGgÁrbs;bkSkumµúynIsþcinnaExkkáda qñaM1977 etg s‘avBIg )anEføg

sunÞrkfamYyEdlriHKn;edayRtg;²bMputcMeBaHneya)ayeRkARbeTsrbs;cinedayecaTRbkan;

fa Ep¥keTAelIkarts‘UvNѳxøaMgeBk (Issues and Studies, Taipei, mai 1979, p. 55). mYyExeRkaymk

cMnYnsmaCikBak;kNþalénKN³kmµaFikarmCÄim suT§EtCamnusSCitditnwg etg EdlBImunFøab;

RtÚveFVIvisuT§ kmµcMeBaH«PaBlMeGogeTArksþaMniym»rbs;xøÜn ehIyRtÚveFVI[mannItism,Tavij

sRmab;kal³eTs³enH. enAcugqñaM1977 kare)assm¥atTUeTAmYy)ancab;epþImsMedARbqaMg

nwgsøabniymeqVgrbs;bkS. sUmGanesovePA naK nig xøaXµúM/ London, Pall Mall, 1982, pp. 226-

229 rbs;elak Philip Short. eKGacsnñidæanedaysmehtuplfa sßanTUtrbs;km<úCaenATIRkúg

eb:kaMg)antamsegátemIledayykcitþTukdak;nUvkar»nfykitþisBÞénRkúmeqVgniymenARbeTs

cinenH.

35 F.B.I.S., «Trend in Communist Media», éf¶TI11 Exmkra qñaM1978, pp. 10-11, elIkykmk

niyayCasMGagedayelak Ross, «China’s Vietnam Policy», p. 286.

36 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtmñak;énRbeTsttiyelakmYyenAéf¶TI4 ExmIna qñaM

1978 naTIRkúghaNUy.

37 Laurence Picq, Au-delà du ciel, p. 52.

38 S.W.B., éf¶TI21 Exmkra qñaM1978.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg484

Page 495: Brother enemy

39 S.W.B., éf¶TI20 Exmkra qñaM1978.

40 F.B.I.S-A.P.A., éf¶TI20 Exmkra qñaM1978/ H-2.

41 S.W.B., éf¶TI23 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1978.

42 tamRkúmesuIbkarN_sm¶at;elakxaglicfa karpÁt;pÁg;kaMePøIgFMnigGavuFRbqaMgrfeRkaHrbs;cin

)ancab;epþImmkdl;édkm<úCaenAcugExmkra-edImExkumÖ³. sUmGanesovePArbs;elak Evelyn

Colbert, «Issues of Power, Balance and Security in Indochina», eyabl;enAsnñisITsþIBIsnþisux

enAGasuInigkñúgmhasaKr):asuIhVik EdlRbRBwtþeTAenA Palm Springs 8-10 Exmkra qñaM1982,

p. 14 nigesovePA «\T§iBlénCemøaHcin-sUevot», p. 11 rbs;elak Douglas Pick.

43 sunÞrkfarbs;elak v:a KUehVg enAkñúgmhasnñi)atCatielIkTIV EdldkRsg;mkniyayCasMGag

edayelak Ross kñúgesovePA China’s Vietnam Policy, 1975-1979, p. 290.

44 Ben Kiernan, «Khmer Bodies with Vietnam Mind’s: Kampuchea Eastern Zone, 1975-1978», p. 31.

45 S.W.B., éf¶TI7 Exmkra qñaM1978.

46 karerobrab;BIRBwtþikarN_epSg²enAPUmiPaKbUBa’KWsMGagelIkarsnÞnaCamYymnusSCaeRcIn enA

kñúgextþkMBg;camnigéRBEvg naExmIna qñaM1980 nigExmkra qñaM1981.

47 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§ ¬Exmkra qñaM1981¦ CamYym®nþIevotNamfñak;x<s;mñak; Edledaysar

Kat;enHehIy Edl´)andwgPaKeRcInénPaKl¥itl¥n;Tak;TgeTAnwgkarerobcMRbúgeRbóbeFVIGnþraKmn_

rbs;evotNamenARbeTskm<úCa. sRmab;ehtuplEdl[mnÞilsgS½y m®nþIrUbenHRtÚvkarrkSa

GnamikPaBrbs;xøÜnmin[eKdwgeLIy.

48 B½t’manTaMgenHEdlTak;TgnwgCMrMhVwkhVWnnanarbs;clnats‘Ukm<úCa KW)anmkBIkareFVIsmÖasn_

m®nþIRbmaNCadb;R)aMnak;énrbbelak ehg sMrin enAPñMeBj kMBg;cam sVayerog nig kMBg;FMenA

ExmIna qñaM1980.

49 éf¶ExqñaMénkarbegáItkgBltUcdMbUgenH RtÚv)anniyay[dwgkñúg»kasénkarR)arB§xYbkMeNIt

elIkTIbIrbs;kgBltUcenHenAExemsa qñaM1981/ F.B.I.S-A.P.A., éf¶TI29 Exemsa qñaM

1981, H-4.

50 Kissinger, The White House Years, p. 1414.

51 Richard Dudman, «km<úCaTl;nwgstVRkeBI», Asian Wall Street Journal, éf¶27 ExFñÚ qñaM1978.

52 F.B.I.S.-A.P.A., éf¶TI20 ExmIna qñaM1978/ H-2.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 485

Page 496: Brother enemy

CMBUkTI8

1 S.W.B., éf¶3 Ex]sPa qñaM1978.

2 Roland-Pierre Paringaux, kaEstLWm:ug éf¶TI20 Exemsa qñaM1978.

3 Tsai Maw-kuey, esovePA «CnCaticinenAevotNamxagt,Úg» (Les Chinois au Sud-Vietnam), Paris,

bNÑal½yCati/ 1968 pp. 23-29. sUmGanniekçbbTrbs;elak Michael Eiland EdlCitecjpSay

pgEdr(Cornell University) sþIBITMnak;TMngepSg²rvagevotNam-éfenAstvtSr_TI18.

4 elIkykmkniyayCasMGagedayelak Alexander Woodside, evotNam nigKMrUrbs;cin

Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1971, p. 244.

5 Fujiwara Riichiro, «Vietnamese Dynastie’s Policies Toward Chinese Immigrants», Acta Asiatica, Nº18,

mars 1970, pp. 68-69.

6 Hoa in Vietnam Dossier, Hanoi: Foreign Language Publishing House, 1978, p. 24. m®nþImñak;énKN³

kmµkarsRmab;kic©karCnCaticinenAÉnaysmuRT )anniyayR)ab;´fa karbkERbCaevotNam

nUvkarRBmeRBógedaymat;TeTenH )anePøcniyayBaküsMxan;mYy ³ «edaysµ½RKcitþ». eday

´saksYrBIerOgenH Nguyen Trong Vinh, ÉkGKÁrdæTUtrbs;evotNamenARkúgeb:kaMg)anGHGag

nwg´fa KWRbeTscinEdlCaGñkeFVI[kic©RBmeRBógERbcakBIsPaBedIm. sUmGanesovePArbs;

elak Nayan Chanda, «Southeast Asia Comes into Focus», TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R. éf¶TI7 Exkkáda qñaM

1978.

7 Pao-min Chang, Beijing, Hanoi and the Overseas Chinese, Berkeley Institute of East Asian Studies,

University of California, 1982, p. 11.

8 dkRsg;mkniyayCasMGagedayelak Charles Benoit, kñúgesovePA «GñkePosxøÜntamTUkrbs;

evotNam», kñúgCemøaH\NÐÚcinelIkTI3/ David W.P. Elliott éd. Boulder, Colo, Westview Press, 1981,

p. 144.

9 Gareth Porter, «Vietnam Policy and the Indochina Crisis» kñúgCemøaH\NÐÚcinelIkTI3/ David W.P.

Elliott, éd. Boulder, Colo, Westview Press, 1981, p. 74.

10 sunÞrkfarbs; To Huu enAsalaRkbx½NÐkmµaPi)al Nguyen Ai Quoc, Giao Duc Ly Luan (traduit),

J.P.R.S. Southeast Asia, 1 ExmIna qñaM1985.

11 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Nguyen Trong Vinh, ÉkGKÁrdæTUtevotNamRbcaMRkúgeb:kaMg/

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg486

Page 497: Brother enemy

eb:kaMg Exmifuna qñaM1978.

12 «esckþIraykarN_segçbsþIBIkarsnÞnarbs;]bnaykrdæm®nþI lI s‘annan CamYy paM v:an;dug

enAéf¶TI10 Exmifuna qñaM1977»/ A.C.N., éf¶TI22 ExmIna qñaM1979.

13 P.I., éf¶TI18 ExsIha qñaM1978/ p. 28. Ibid. éf¶TI16 Exmifuna qñaM1978/ p. 15.

14 cMeBaHesckþIraykarN_mYyGMBIkarBi)akEpñkesdækic©enARbeTsevotNamnaedImqñaM1978

sUmGanGtßbTrbs;elak Nay:an; can;da «Hanoi Takes the Campaign behind the Lines» kñúg

TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R. éf¶TI3 ExmIna qñaM1978 nigGtßbT «Hanoi Takes a Grip on the South»,

kñúgTsSnavdþI F.E.E.R. éf¶TI26 Ex]sPa qñaM1978.

15 F.B.I.S., éf¶TI5 Exmkra qñaM1978/ E-11-21.

16 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþIevotNammñak;enATIRkúghUCImij naExkkáda qñaM1979.

17 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtevotNammñak;enAéf¶TI2 ExmIna qñaM1978 naTIRkúg

evogc½nÞ.

18 S.W.B., éf¶TI28 ExmIna qñaM1978.

19 Nayan Chanda, «Peking Says It Out Loud to Hanoi», F.E.E.R., 12 mai 1978.

20 GMBIRbeTsevotNameFVIkarbeNþjGaNikCncinecj/ eb:kaMg/ GKare)aHBum<pSayesovePA

CaPasabreTs/ 1978, pp. 2-6.

21 Benoit, kñúgCemøaH\NÐÚcinelIkTI3/ p. 151.

22 sRmab;PaBCak;EsþgsþIBIkardkCMnYyrbs;cin sUmGanesckþIEføgkarN_rbs;RksYgkarbreTs

evotNamcuHéf¶TI17 Exmifuna/ S.W.B., éf¶TI18 mifuna qñaM1978.

23 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtevotNamenATIRkúgevogc½nÞnaéf¶TI2 ExmIna qñaM1978.

24 F.B.I.S.-A.P.N., éf¶TI6 Exmifuna qñaM1978/ K1-7.

25 S.W.B., éf¶TI27 Exmifuna qñaM1978. karRsavRCavmYyrbs;es>GuI>Ga> )anvaytémøeRkay

mkfa CnCaticinRbEhl200>000nak; )anRtÚvsmøab;enARbeTskm<úCaeRkamrbb b:ul

Bt. A Demographic Catastrophe, Washington, D.C., C.I.A., 1980, p. 14.

26 S.W.B., éf¶TI7 Exkkáda qñaM1978.

27 Michael Godley, «A Summer Cruise to Nowhere: China and the Vietnamese Chinese in Perspective», The

Australian Journal of Chinese affairs, Nº4, July 1980, p. 41.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 487

Page 498: Brother enemy

28 Pao-Min Chang, Beijing, Hanoi and the Overseas Chinese, p. 40.

29 Benoit, op. cit., p. 153.

30 esckþIraykarN_l¥CageKGMBIRbtibtþikarxaghirBaØvtßúKWesckþIraykarN_rbs;elak Barry Wain,

The Refused: The Agony of Indochina Refugees, Hong-Kong, Dow Jones, 1981, pp. 85-106.

31 The Boat People: An «Age» Investigation, introduction de Bruce Grants, Victoria, Australia, Penguin,

1979, pp. 80-81.

32 Stephen Heder, BI b:ul Bt eTA Eb:n suvNÑ/ Bangkok, Chulalongkorn University, 1980, p. 16.

33 tamsakSImñak;EdldkRsg;smþImkniyayCasMGagedayelak Michael Vickery: esa Pwm

Føab;)anRbkasfa eKaledAénkareFVIbdivtþn_ KWelIkkm<s;CIvPaBrs;enA BuMEmneFVI[fyb¤bgçM[

mnusSmñaeTArkPaBevTnaetaky:akkñúgeKalbMNgEtmYyKt; edIm,IeFVI[GñkTaMgenaHsÁal;fa GVI

eTACaPaBRkIRkeLIy ¬EdlenHCaneya)ayrbs; b:ul Bt¦. Michael Vickery, Cambodia, 1975-

1982, Boston, South End Press, 1984, p. 137.

34 sRmab;karviPaKKYr[cab;GarmµN_mYyGMBIPaBTIéTBIKñaénPUmiPaKenARbeTskm<úCa sUmGan

esovePA Cambodia rbs;elak Vickery TMB½r65-188 CaBiess TMB½r131-138. cMeBaH

skçIPaBmYysþIBIdMeNIrrs;enAkñúgPUmiPaKbUBa’ sUmGanesovePA «man;éRB>>>» pp. 136-196

rbs;elak Ben Kiernan pg.

35 tamRbEhl karb:unb:glYcsmøab;mYykñúgcMeNamkarb:unb:glYcsmøab;dMbUg²eTAelIbuKÁl b:ul

Bt KWkarb:unb:glYcsmøab;rbs; can; cRkI CaGñkTTYlxusRtÚvd¾manRbCaRbiymñak;enAPUmiPaK

bUBa’. bnÞab;BIbraC½y Kat;RtÚv)ancab;xøÜnnigsmøab;enAéf¶TI19 Ex]sPa qñaM1976. bBa¢I

eQµaH BYkemdwknaMEdlRtÚvsmøab;KWmanenAkñúg «EpnkarrYmcugeRkay», esckþIraykarN_Rbticar

kmµrbs; km<úCaEdlrkeXIjCafµIenAmNÐlsYrcemøIyTYlEsøg. ´sUmGrKuNelak Murray

Hiebert Edl )anpþl;GtßbTbkERbCaPasaGg;eKøsmYymk[´.

36 Kiernan, « man;éRB>>>», p. 187.

37 S.W.B., éf¶15 Ex]sPa qñaM1978.

38 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy Stephen Heder enATIRkúgjÚvy:kéf¶TI20 ExkBaØa qñaM1980.

Heder )ansMGagelIkareqøIysarPaBrbs;bNþashkarIxøHrbs; esa Pwm man PYg CaedIm

nigkar snÞnaCamYyemdwknaMExµrRkhmCaeRcInrUbEdlsÁal;Kat;c,as;.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg488

Page 499: Brother enemy

39 esovePAexµA/ TMB½r101-104. ÉksarxøHEdlrkeXIjeRkaymkenAkñúgKukTYlEsøgbgðaj

farbb b:ul Bt eCOBIGtßiPaBénkarYmKMnitk,t;minBitCaeRcIn EdlBak;B½n§minRtwmEtRkúmesuIb

karN_sm¶at;evotNamb:ueNÑaHeT b:uEnþshPaBsUevot GaløWm:g;xagekIt shrdæGaemriknig

étv:an;pgEdr.

40 karerobrab;GMBIkarsøab;rbs; esa Pwm KWsMGagelIesovePArbs; Kiernan, op. cit. TMB½r168-

172/ elIkarRsavRCavrbs; Heder nigelIkarsnÞnapÞal;xøÜnrbs;´CamYykmµaPi)al CaeRcIn

rUbrbs;PUmiPaKbUBa’ enAkMBg;cam nigsVayerog enAExmIna qñaM1980 nigExmkra qñaM1981.

cemøIyCasakSITaMgGs;)anniyayRtÚvKñaGMBIkarN_fa esa Pwm )aneFVIdMeNIreTAkan; RkúgPñMeBj

b:uEnþ PaBExVgKMnitKñaxøHenAEtmanGMBITIkEnøgd¾Cak;lak;nigkal³eTs³énkarsøab;rbs;Kat;.

GñkxøHGHGagfa Kat;)anRtÚvsmøab;edaykgT½Brbs; b:ul Bt b:uEnþ eKTTYlRsbCaTUeTAfa Kat;

søab;edaykareFVIGtþXad.

41 karniTanrbs; Run Dun embBa¢akarkgvresnatUc/ A.V.I., éf¶TI21 Exmifuna qñaM1978.

42 rUbmnþenHmanmktaMgBIqñaM1971 enAeBlEdlcab;epþImkareFVIvisuT§kmµBYkkmµaPi)al EdlRtLb;

mkBIRkúghaNUyvijCasm¶at;. karsnÞnarbs; Heder CamYyelak ehg sMrin enAéf¶TI8 Ex

kkáda qñaM1981.

43 enAExmkra qñaM1979 enAeBlEdlKN³kmµaFikarmCÄimbkSkumµúynIsþkm<úCafµImYyRtÚvbegáIt

eLIg KWkñúgcMeNamsmaCik20rUb man16rUbCaGñkmanedImkMeNItBIbNþaextþrbs;km<úCa Edl

manRBMEdnCab;CamYyevotNam ehIykñúgcMeNamextþTaMgenHPaKeRcInKWenAPUmiPaKbUBa’.

44 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak ehg sMék enAsVayerognaéf¶TI15 Exmkra qñaM1981.

PaKl¥itl¥n;énsm½yRbCuMEdlnaMeTAlT§plcugeRkayenH RtÚv)anpþl;mk[´edaym®nþIrbs;

evotNamfñak;x<s;mñak;.

45 elIkykmkniyayCasMGageday Branning Garrett, «The China Card» and Its origins: U.S.

Bureaucratic Policies and the Strategic Triangle», niekçbbTfñak;bNÐit Brandeis University, 1983, p.

132.

46 B½t’manepSg²sþIBIbNþakarCYbKñaCasm¶at;rvagevotNamnigsUevot RtÚv)anpþl;mk[´eday

m®nþIevotNamfñak;x<s;mñak;enAExmkra qñaM1981/ «edaykareKarBcMeBaHRbvtþisa®sþ» ehIy

fVId,itEtkarlatRtdagTaMgenH BuM[cMeNjdl;buBVehturbs;RbeTsevotNamEfmTaMgcMeBaH

RbPBÉksarsMGag 489

Page 500: Brother enemy

GaCIBpÞal;rbs;Kat;k¾eday.

47 «Who is the Instigator?», R.R., e)aHBum<pSayCafµIkñúg On Vietnam’s Expulsion of Chinese Residents,

Pékin, 1978, p. 131.

48 S.W.B., éf¶TI12 Exkkáda qñaM1978.

49 Michael Pillsbury, «Strategic Acupuncture», Foreign Policy, Nº41, hiver 1980-81, p. 56. enAqñaM1975

Pillsbury CaGñkÉkeTsTImYyrbs;GaemrikaMgxagvis½ykarBarRbeTsEdlniyayENnaMCa

saFarN³BIkarRbKl;eRKÓgsBVavuF[RbeTscin. sUmGanesovePA ³ «U.S.-Chinese Military

Ties?» rbs;GñkniBn§dEdl/ Foreign Policy, automne 1975.

50 Michel Oksenberg, «mYyTsvtSr_énTMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMg», foreign Affairs, automne 1982, p.

185.

51 Jiji Press, TajehtusMGagBIRbPBmYyenAhugkug/ éf¶TI26 Exkkáda qñaM1978. dkRsg;mk

niyayCasMGagmþgeTotedayelak Masa hi Nishihara, «The Sino-Vietnamese War of 1979: Only

the First Round?», GtßbT)ane)aHBum<pSay.

52 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy\sSrCnpøÚvkarrbs;cinmñak;enAéf¶TI12 Ex]sPa qñaM1980

naTIRkúghugkug. cMeBaHkarviPaKd¾l¥itl¥n;mYyGMBICMhrrbs;cincMeBaHRbeTsevotNamenACMnan;

enaH sUmGanesovePArbs;elak Robert G. Sutter, «China’s Strategy Towards Vietnam and Its

Implications for the United States», David W.P. Elliott éd. The Third Indochina Conflict, Boulder, Colo,

Westview Press, 1981, pp. 175-190.

53 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinmñak;enAéf¶TI10 Exemsa qñaM1979 naTIRkúg

hugkug. kñúgsunÞrkfamYyEdlmanlkçN³enAEtsm¶at; EføgenAéf¶TI16 Exmkra qñaM1979

ecn )‘av smaCikkariyal½yneya)ayrbs;cin )anniyayGMBIkarRbwgERbgrbs;cinedIm,I

«elIksemþc sIhnu [esayraCüeLIgvij». sUmGanesovePA «Keng Piao’s r)aykarN_GMBI

sßankarN_]bTVIb\NÐÚcin», Issues and Studies, Taipei, Exmkra qñaM1981/ p. 83.

CMBUkTI9

1 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak r:UbWt GUklI bc©úb,nñCardæelxaFikarTTYlbnÞúkRbqaMg

ePrvkmµ/ éf¶TI19 ExFñÚ qñaM1984/ v:asuInetanDI>suI>.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg490

Page 501: Brother enemy

2 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy\sSrCnpøÚvkar\NÐamñak;enAéf¶TI22 ExmIna qñaM1978 naTIRkúg

haNUy.

3 esckþIcmøgénsnñisITkaEstEdlpþl;eday pan; ehon enAéf¶TI10 Exkkáda qñaM1978.

TUrelxrbs;RksYgkarbreTs manRbPBmkBIRkúgtUküÚ/ éf¶TI14 Exkkáda qñaM1978.

4 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Gan;RDÚ PIxUk enATIRkúgkg;Eb‘r:a naéf¶TI26 Exvicäika qñaM

1982.

5 esckþIcmøgmYyénkarsnÞnarvagelak hSI>PI>mWrfa nig pan; ehon enHRtÚv)anpþl;[´ eday

GñkcUlrYmGaemrikaMgmñak;énbNþaGñkcUlrYmrbs;GaemrikaMgkñúgkarCYbKña.

6 Congressional Record Times, éf¶TI22 ExsIha qñaM1978.

7 kaEst Los Angeles Times, éf¶TI23 ExsIha qñaM1978.

8 Daniel Southerland, «US Wary Over Vietnam’s Overtures», Christian Science Monitor, éf¶TI29

ExsIha qñaM1978.

9 Zbignew Brzezinski, Power and Principle, p. 224.

10 Ibid., p. 562.

11 «Teng Hsiao-ping’s speech on Foreign Policy at the Third Plenum, July 20 1977», Issue and Studies,

Taipei, mai 1979, p. 55.

12 Jimmy Carter, Keeping Faith, Memoirs of a President, London, Collins, 1982, p. 189.

13 Cyrus Vance, Hard Choice: Cristal Years in American Foreign Policy, New York, Simon and Schuster,

1983, p.81.

14 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak sIurus v:an;s_ enATIRkúgjÚvy:k naéf¶TI15 ExsIha qñaM

1980.

15 William Gleysteen EdleKsgS½ybnþicbnþÜcBIkarpÁab;citþelak Rb‘ÍhSúInsÁI yl;eXIjfa karelc

erOgsm¶at;KWCaplén «karsb,ayrIkrayxøaMgmYyEdlxuskal³eTs³CaCagKitfa CakarXub

XitKñaedaysm¶at;mYysMedAeFVI[braC½y»karRbCuMcrcaEdldwknaMeFVIeday v:an;s_. karsnÞna

rbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak William Gleysteen enATIRkúgv:asuInetan DI>suI> naéf¶TI27 Ex]sPa

qñaM1985.

16 Brzezinski, op. cit. p. 197.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 491

Page 502: Brother enemy

17 Ibid. p. 560.

18 Oksenberg, «mYyTsvtSr_énTMnak;TMngcin-GaemrikaMg», p. 183.

19 Vance, op. cit., p. 116.

20 Jonathan D. Pollack, The Lessons of Coalition Politics: Sino-American Security Relations, Santa Monica,

Rand, 1984, p. 29.

21 Brzezinski, op. cit., annexe 1, pp. 1-3.

22 Garrett, «The «China Card» and Its Origins», p. 46.

23 kñúg»kasénkarsnÞnamYyCamYyGñkniBn§ smaCikmñak;rbs;KN³RbtiPUelak Rb‘IhSInsÁI )an

niyayR)ab;´edaybdiesFminpþl;B½t’manepSg²sþIBIkarsnÞnaKñaenaHfa ³ «esckþIsnñidæanTaMg

Layrbs;elak minpÞúynwgGVIEdl´)andwgeT». tam Electronic Warfare/Defense Electronics,

ExsIha qñaM1978/ p. 23-24 fa Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI )anpþl;eTA[BYkcinnUv «EPñknigRtecokrbs;elak

xaglic». GtßbTe)aHBum<dEdlenH ¬Exmkra qñaM1979¦ manB½t’manmYyEdlRbEhlCaeFVI

[PJak;ep¥Il y:agBitR)akd ³ shrdæGaemrik)anerobcMnigdak;[dMeNIrkarnUvsßanIysegátBinitü

(S.I.G.I.N.T.) CaeRcInenAtambeNþayRBMEdnsUevot-cin. erOgenHRtÚv)anGHGagbEnßmenA

qñaM1981.

24 Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI, Power and Principle, p. 212.

25 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak sIurus v:an;s_ enATIRkúgjÚvy:k naéf¶TI15 ExsIha qñaM

1980.

26 Vance, op. cit. p. 117.

27 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGtItsmaCikmñak;énRkúmRbwkSasnþisuxCati enAéf¶TI19 Exvicäika

qñaM1981 naTIRkúghugkug.

28 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Michel Oksenberg enAéf¶TI3 ExmIna qñaM1983 enARkúghugkug.

29 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Michel Oksenberg enATIRkúghugkug naéf¶TI3 ExmIna qñaM

1983.

30 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Raphael Iungerich enAéf¶TI22 ExFñÚ qñaM1984 naTIRkúg

v:asuInetan DI>suI>.

31 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Raphael Iungerich enATIRkúgv:asuInetan DI>suI> naéf¶TI22 ExFñÚ

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg492

Page 503: Brother enemy

qñaM1984.

32 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Andrew Peacock enAéf¶TI26 Exvicäika qñaM1982 naTIRkúg

kg;Eb‘r:a.

33 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak rIqad hUlRb‘Úk, enAéf¶TI11 Exkkáda qñaM1985 na

TIRkúgv:asuInetan DI>suI>.

34 Brzezinski, op. cit., p. 228.

35 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak b‘ÍkjÚ Rb‘ÍhSInsÁI enAéf¶TI27 Exkkáda qñaM1981.

36 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak eLGUNad_ vUdxUk enAéf¶TI4 Extula qñaM1984 naTIRkúg

v:asuInetan DI>suI>.

37 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak rIqad hUlRb‘Úk enAéf¶TI11 Exkkáda qñaM1985naTIRkúg

v:asuInetan DI>suI>. eyabl;Edlfa kareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTscinKWminRtÚveFVIRsb

KñaCamYykareFVI[manRbRktIPaBCamYyRbeTsevotNam )aneBIbRbTHnwgkarRbqaMgy:agxøaMg

køamYyBIsMNak;bNþam®nþIxøHénRksYgkarbreTsGaemrikenATIRkúgeb:kaMg nigv:asuInetan. kar

KitmémGMBIRbtikmµrbs;RbeTscin KWeRcInEtCaGMeBIrbs;GñkTaMgLay dUcCaelak GUesnbWk

nig elak r:UehS s‘UlIv:an; CaedIm EdlbM)at;nigBnøat;smþIsnÞnatictYcrbs;cinrhUtdl;eFVI[

Kat;GHGagfa karxitcUlCitKñaCamYyRbeTsevotNameFVI[rMxandl;karxitcUlCitKñaCamYy

RbeTscin.

38 J. Carter, op. cit., p. 195. R)aMBIrqñaMeRkaymk bnÞab;BITsSnkic©mYyenACMrMCnePosxøÜnExµr tam

RBMEdnkm<úCa-éf xaF½r )anRbkasR)ab;GñkkaEstfa ³ «shrdæGaemrikRtÚvEtEfrkSaTMnak;

TMngepSg²CamYyRbeTsevotNam. enHCabBaðaRKwHmYy. eTaHCakarExVgKMnitKña sßitenAman

k¾eday k¾vamanRbeyaCn_Cag EdleyIgenArkSakarTak;TgKña»/ Philadelphia Inquirer, 5 mifuna

qñaM1985.

39 B½t’manpþl;edaym®nþImñak;énRksYgkarbreTsGaemrikaMg. karlak;erOgtUctacTaMgenHrbs;

estvimanenAEtCabBaðaresIbmYy. R)aMmYyqñaMeRkaymk m®nþIrUbenH)anTTUcfa kuM[erobrab;

eQµaHrbs;Kat;bBa©ÚleTAkñúgGVIEdlTak;TgeTAnwgesckþIbgÁab;bBa¢aTaMgenaHrbs;estviman.

40 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy paM b‘íj (Pham Binh) RbFannaykdæanRsavRCavGnþrCati én

RksYgkarbreTsevotNam enAéf¶TI28 Exmkra qñaM1981 naTIRkúghaNUy.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 493

Page 504: Brother enemy

41 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUt\NÐamñak;enAéf¶TI17 Exkkáda qñaM1979. taMgBIedIm

qñaM1978 evotNam)aneRbIkan;EteRcIneLIgnUvExSehaHehIrmYyrbs;\NÐa edIm,IeFVIdMeNIreTA

kan;RkúgmUsÁÚ. sMeNIsuMkarGnuBaØateFVIkarehaHehIr )anpþl;dl;BYk\NÐanUvP½sþútagd¾mantémø

mYykñúgkarvivtþn_énTMnak;TMngepSg²rvagsUevot-evotNam.

42 eRkABIehtukarN_Edlfa eKrkyl;mineXIjfa ehtudUcemþc)anCasn§isBaØaeTVPaKImYyCamYy

RbeTsttiyelakmYy KYrEtman\T§iBleTAelIkarseRmccitþTTYlsÁal;RbeTsevotNamrbs;

GaemrikaMgenaH eKRKan;Etkt;smÁal;fa sn§isBaØasUevot-evotNamRtÚv)ancuHhtßelxaenAéf¶

TI3 Exvicäika qñaM1978. karlukluyRbeTskm<úCaedayevotNamcab;epþImenAéf¶TI25 ExFñÚ

qñaM1978 KWvaRKb;RKan;ehIy.

43 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak rIqad hUlRb‘Úk enATIRkúgv:asuInetan DI>suI> naéf¶TI11 Ex

kkáda qñaM1985.

44 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak r:UbWt GUklI enAéf¶TI19 ExFñÚ qñaM1984 naTIRkúgv:asuInetan

DI>suI>.

45 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak rIqad hUlRb‘Úk enAéf¶TI11 Exkkáda qñaM1985naTIRkúg

v:asuInetan DI>suI>.

46 Rowland Evans and Robert Novak, «A Case of Soviet «Disinformation»», W.P., éf¶TI13 Exvicäika

qñaM1978.

vKÁ«neratþm sIhnu ³ rYcputBIeRKaHfñak;»

1 S.W.B., éf¶TI15 Ex]sPa qñaM1978.

CMBUkTI10

1 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy ³

Ék]tþmÉkGKÁrdæTUt xaMpan vILaCit (Khamphan Vilachit) enAéf¶TI9 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1983

naTIRkúgevogc½nÞ.

GñkkarTUtLavbMeBjmuxgarenARkúgPñMeBjmñak; enAéf¶TI7 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1983 naTIRkúg

evogc½nÞ.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg494

Page 505: Brother enemy

\sSrCnpøÚvkarrbs;yUehÁasøavImñak;enAéf¶TI22 Exmkra qñaM1979.

vresnIy_Ék b‘Yy Tin (Bui Tin) enATIRkúghaNUynaéf¶TI28 Exmkra qñaM1981.

BYkkmµkrrbs;Rkúmh‘unsuraKarenAPñMeBjéf¶TI23 Exmkra qñaM1981.

semþcRBH neratþm sIhnu enAéf¶TI5 Exemsa qñaM1980naTIRkúgeb:kaMg. sUmGanesovePA

«karvilRtLb;mkPñMeBjvij» rbs;elak GuI pan;dara/ Métailié, 1982/ pp. 183-186.

2 N.D., éf¶TI1 ExFñÚ qñaM1971.

3 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtm:aeLsuImñak;enATIRkúghugkug naéf¶TI12 Extula

qñaM1978.

4 «Vietnam-Economic Situation», Washington, D.C., World Bank, 1979, p. 3.

5 TsSnkic©enAshPaBsUevotrbs;KN³RbtiPUbkSnigrdæaPi)alénsaFarNrdæsgÁmniym

evotNam/ mUsÁÚ/ TIPñak;garB½t’manNUvUsÞI (Novosti), 1978, p. 17.

6 Ibid.

7 Gareth Porter, «Vietnam’s Soviet Alliance: A Challenge to US Policy» Indochina Issues, Nº6, ]sPa

1980/ p. 4.

8 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkÉkeTsGaemrikaMgmñak; enAkñúgrdæFanIGasuImYy naéf¶TI13 Ex

kkáda qñaM1983. Don Oberdorfer, «Reds vs. Reds In Indochina: A New, Confusing Kind of War»,

W.P., éf¶TI1 emsa qñaM1979.

9 esckþIsegçbénkarsYrcemøIymYy mankalbriecäTéf¶TI30 Exemsa qñaM1982 RtÚv)anpþl;

mk[´edayGñkÉkeTselakxaglicmñak; EdlsMNUmBrrkSaGnamikPaB. karykcitþTukdak;

rbs;´eTAelItYnaTIrbs; Wei enARbeTsevotNamRtÚv)anTak;TajcitþedaynayTahancinmñak;

kñúgkarsnÞnamYyenAéf¶TI25 ExsIha qñaM1979.

10 TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R., éf¶TI17 Exvicäika qñaM1978.

11 karsnÞnarbs; Michael Chinoy CamYy\sSrCnpøÚvkarfñak;elImñak;enATIRkúg)agkk naéf¶TI11

Exvicäika qñaM1978. ´sUmGKuNelak Chinoy EdlbBa¢Únmk[´nUvkMNt;xøI²rbs;elak. etg

)anrMB£kCasaFarN³pgEdr BIyfaPaBmYyénkardYlrlMrbs;RkúgPñMeBj eTaHbICaKat;RbEhl

mincg;fadUecñHk¾eday. munTsSnkic©rbs;Kat;eTAkan;RbeTséf Kat;)anRbkasR)ab;Gñk

kaEst éfmYyRkúmfa ³ «ebIsinCakar):an;sµanTukCamunrbs;´RtwmRtÚv RbeTskm<úCanwgRtÚv

RbPBÉksarsMGag 495

Page 506: Brother enemy

bMpøaj[sabsUnüTaMgRsug. RbkarenHnwgbgðaj[BiPBelakeXIjBIsarCatiBitR)akdénrbb

rbs;evotNam. enAeBlenaH vanwgCa»kassRmab;Gas‘anEdlRtÚvsEmþgtYnaTId¾sMxan;mYy

kñúgkaredaHRsaybBaðaehIy». Nayan Chanda, «Cambodia: Waiting for the Inevitable», TsSnavdþI

F.E.E.R., éf¶24 Exvicäika qñaM1978.

12 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþImñak;énRksYgkarbreTséf Edl)ancUlrYmy:agCitsñiT§

kñúgkarsnÞnarvageRKógsak;-etg. karsnÞnarbs;´KWmaneLIgenAéf¶TI21 ExFñÚ qñaM1981naTI

Rkúghugkug.

13 Chanda, «Cambodia: Waiting for the Inevitable».

14 tamÉksarsm¶at;mYyrbs;cinfa rdæaPi)alkm<úCa)anbeBa©j[dwgsMeNIenH. sUmGan «Keng

Piao’ s Report on the situation of the Indochinese Peninsula», Issues and Studies, Tapei, January 1981,

p. 85. karGHGagbEnßmBIerOgenHRtÚv)anbgðajkñúgesovePA «q¶ayhYseCIgemX>>>» TMB½r141

rbs;GñkRsI LÚr:g; Bic.

15 Jurgen Domes, The Government and Politics of the P.R.C.: A time of Transition, Boulder, Colo. Westview

Press, p. 163.

16 Parris Chang, Elite Conflict in the Post Mao China, Baltimore, University of Maryland, Occasional

Papers/Reprint Series in Contemporary Asian Studies, Nº2, 1983, pp. 10-11.

17 King C. Chen, Politics and Process of Peiping’s Decision to Attack Vietnam, Taipei, Institute of

Internation Relations, 1983, p. 81. sUmGanesovePA «Keng-Piao’s Report on the Situation of the

Indochinese Peninsula», pp. 85-86.

18 «Keng Piao’s Report», op. cit., pp. 88-89.

19 Chen, Politics and Process, pp. 86-87.

20 Oksenberg, «A Decade of Sino-American Relation», p. 187.

21 Ibid.

22 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelakÉkGKÁrdæTUt eLGUNad_ vUdxUk enATIRkúghugkug naéf¶TI8

Extula qñaM1980.

23 Carter, Keeping faith, pp. 198-199.

24 Ibid., p. 197.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg496

Page 507: Brother enemy

25 Vance, Hard Choices, p. 118-119.

26 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelakÉkGKÁrdæTUt eLGUNad_ vUdxUk enATIRkúghugkug éf¶TI8 Extula

qñaM1980 nigenATIRkúgv:asuInetanDI>suI> éf¶TI4 Extula qñaM1984.

27 karminTukcitþeKÉg b¤karPan;RcLMénRkúmPñak;garesuIbkarN_sm¶at;rbs;evotNamhak; dUcCa)an

RbmaNhYsBIvtþmanrbs;CnCaticinenARbeTskm<úCa. PaKeRcInénGñkÉkeTsEdlTTYl)an

B½t’manRtwmRtÚvKitfa cMnYnBitR)akdmanminelIsBI5>000nak;eLIy. eRkaymk vresnIy_

Ékmñak;énkgT½Brbs;evotNam )anGHGagR)ab;´fa QrelImUldæanénGVIEdlKat;segáteXIj

enAPñMeBj TIRbwkSacinKWmancMnYn8>000nak;. karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyvresnIy_Ék b‘Yy

Tin enAéf¶TI28 Exmkra qñaM1981naTIRkúghaNUy.

28 Daniel Burstein, «On Cambodia: But, Yet», N.Y.T., éf¶TI21 Exvicäika qñaM1978.

29 B.P., éf¶TI9 ExFñÚ qñaM1978.

30 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak qatéq Qunhav:an (Chatchai Choonhavan),éf¶TI14 ExFñÚ

qñaM1984 naTIRkúg)agkk.

31 S.W.B., éf¶TI2 Extula qñaM1978.

32 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyRBHGgÁm©as; neratþm rNb£T§i/ éf¶TI26 Extula qñaM1982

enATIRkúgkg;Eb‘r:a.

33 cemøIyCasakSIrbs; Dij kan sþIBIsm½yRbCuMEdlbegáItrNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa

RtÚv)anTTYledaym®nþIGU®sþalImñak; naExvicäika qñaM1979 eRkayeBlEdl kan ePosxøÜneTA

RbeTsm:aeLsuI. ´sUmGKuNm®nþIrUbenH Edl)anbBa¢Únmk[´nUvkMNt;xøI²rbs;Kat;. PaKeRcIn

énkarniyayR)ab;erOgGaf’kM)aMgrbs; kan )anRtÚvGHGagbEnßmR)ab;´edaykmµaPi)alExµr

CaeRcInrUbEdl)ancUlrYmkñúgkarRbCuMenH.

34 rNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa/ RkúmB½t’manénrNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCatikm<úCa/ qñaM1979/

31ff., TIkEnøge)aHBum<pSayBuMmanbBa¢ak;.

35 rNsirSÉkPaB\sSr³RtÚv)anbegáIteLIgbnÞab;BImhasnñi)atCatiTI1rbs;clnats‘UExµréf¶TI

17 Exemsa qñaM1950. enAqñaM1952 ÉksarExµrmYy)ansnµteCaKC½yrbs;clnats‘Ufa

mkBI\T§iBlnigkarKaMRTrbs;RbCaCnevotNam.

36 Timothy Carney, «Heng Samrin’s Armed forces and a Military Balance in Cambodia». karbBa¢Ún

RbPBÉksarsMGag 497

Page 508: Brother enemy

B½t’maneTA[snñisITenA Princeton sþIBIkm<úCa/ éf¶TI12-14 Exvicäika qñaM1982, p. 4.

37 smaCikdb;bYnrUbénrNsirSsamKÁIse®gÁaHCatikm<úCaKW ehg sMrin ¬GtItExµrRkhm b¤ExµrRkhm¦/

Ca suIm ¬ExµrRkhm¦/ rs; sm½y ¬Exµr\sSr³¦/ m:at; lI ¬ExµrRkhm¦/ b‘un mI ¬ExµRkhm¦/ h‘un

Esn ¬ExµrRkhm¦/ elakRsI man sMGan ¬ExµrRkhm¦/ mas sMNag ¬ExµrRkhm¦/ enA sam:un

¬Exµr\sSr³¦/ m:ug LúgsuIm/ Ehm samin ¬Exµr\sSr³¦/ elakRsI C½y kBaØa/ can; Ev:n nig R)aCJ

s‘un.

38 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy\sSrCnpøÚvkarevotNammñak;/ éf¶TI29 Exmkra qñaM1981

enATIRkúghaNUy.

39 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyvresnIy_Ék b‘Yy Tin/ éf¶TI28 Exmkra qñaM1981 enATIRkúg

haNUy.

40 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYysemþc RBHneratþm sIhnu enATIRkúgeb:kaMg naéf¶TI5 Exemsa

qñaM1980.

41 esovePA «karRtLb;mkPñMeBjvij» rbs;elak GuI pan;dara/ TMB½r180.

42 B½t’manpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak Ben Kiernan, éf¶TI30 ExkBaØa qñaM1982/ RkúgEm:lb‘n.

43 Van Tien Dung, Our Great Spring Victory, New York, Monthly Review Press, 1977, kare)aHpSay

CaPasa)araMgedayelak Camille Scalabrino nig Nguyen Ngoc Giao, Et nous primes Saigon. Le

Sycomore, 1979. Tran Van Tra, Vietnam: history of the Bulwark B-2 Theatre, Vol.5. Concluding the 30

Years War, Washington, D.C., Joint Publication Research Service, 1983. GtßbTRsg;CaPasa

)araMgmYyEdlbkERbedayelak Georges Boudarel KWmanenAkñúgesovePA «kariyaFibetyü

enARbeTsevotNam» ¬kariyal½yenAevotNam¦/ Asie-Débat 1, L’ Harmattan, 1983.

44 Dung, op. cit., p. 25.

45 karsnÞnarbs;elak Stephen Heder CamYyelak Ca suT§ enARkúgPñMeBj naéf¶TI6 Exkkáda

qñaM1981 ¬esckþIcmøg¦.

46 karsnÞnarbs;elak Stephen Heder CamYyelak Ehm samin/ éf¶TI8 Exkkáda qñaM1981

enATIRkúgPñMeBj¬esckþIcmøg¦.

47 Stephen Heder, GtßbTminTan;e)aHBum<pSay. tam Heder fa mhasnñi)at)aneRCIstaMgKN³

kmµaFikarGcié®nþy_mYymansmaCikR)aMBIrrUbdwknaMeday Eb:n suvNÑ. smaCikdéTeTotKW h‘un

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg498

Page 509: Brother enemy

Esn/ b‘U fg/ can; KirI/ v:an; sun/ ehg sMrin/ nig Ca suT§. kñúgcMeNamenaH mansmaCikEtBIrrUb

b:ueNÑaH h‘un Esn nig ehg sMrin-EdlCaGtItExµrRkhm cMENksmaCikdéTeTotsuT§EtExµr

\sSr³.

48 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkÉkeTsmñak;xagbBaða]bTVIb\NÐÚcin enAsßanTUtGaemrikaMg

RbcaMRkúg)agkk naéf¶TI11 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1983.

49 esckþIdkRsg;énkMNt;ehtuenH manenAkñúg «Record of a conversation between Deng Xiaoping and

Ieng Sary, le 13 Janvier», C.V., octobre 1979. sgáat;GtßbTmþúM²EdlxVHRtÚv)ane)aHBum<pSayenA

eBleRkaykñúg The Chinese Ruler’s Crimes Against Kampuchea, 1984. P½sþútagsm,ÚreBarBas

manenAkñúgGtßbTedIménkarsnÞnaKñaTaMgRsug. mü:ageTot lkçN³BiténkMNt;ehtuenH minEdl

RtÚvCMTas;edayRkúgeb:kaMgesaHeLIy.

50 The Chinese Ruler’s Crimes Against Kampuchea, p. 111.

51 GtßbTdkRsg;énsm½yRbCuMenHKWmanenAkñúgesovePA The Chinese Ruler’s Crimes Against

Kampuchea, p. 112.

52 Ibid.

53 Don Oberdorfer, «Reds vs. Reds», W.P., éf¶TI1 Exemsa qñaM1979.

54 Newsweek, éf¶TI5 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979.

55 Brzezinski, Power and Principle, p. 409.

56 U.S. State Department Bulletin, kumÖ³ qñaM1979/ pp. 7-11.

57 Brzezinski, op. cit., p. 409.

58 Zbigniew Brzezinski, «East Asia and Global Security: Implications for Japan» The Journal of International

Affairs, Vol. 37, Nº1, été 1983, p. 8.

59 elak xaF½r niyayfa TsSnkic©rbs; etg )anrYmbgáCa «»kasEdlnaM[rIkraybMputmYy

kñúgcMeNam»kasEdlnaM[rIkraybMputénGaNtþiCaRbFanaFibtIrbs;´. ´rIkrayxøaMgNas;

ehIyemdwknaMcink¾dUecñHEdr» Keeping faith, p. 202.

60 Brzezinski, Power and Principle, p. 408.

61 Vance, Hard Choices, p. 122.

62 Brzezinski, Power and Principle, p. 408.enAéf¶TI2 ExkumÖ³ v:an;s_ )andak;[ xaF½r BinitüesckþIEføg

RbPBÉksarsMGag 499

Page 510: Brother enemy

karN_mYyEdlRtÚvpSayenAkñúgry³eBlénTsSnkic©rbs; etg. tamesckþIEføgkarN_enaHfa

TMnak;TMngrvagcin-GaemrikaMgKWCalkçxNÐd¾sMxan;énsnþiPaByUrGEgVgmYy dUckareFVI[kan;Et

RbesIrCagmunnUvTMnak;TMngepSg²CamYyshPaBsUevotEdr. munnwgGanesckþIEføgkarN_

xaF½r )anrG‘UrTaMfa «mankarsuMeTasEfmeTotpgb¤?». Rb‘IhSInsÁI )anbBa©úHbBa©ÚlKat;fa

RbePTénesckþIEføgkarN_enH )anpþl;[shrdæGaemriknUvrUbPaBmindac;eRsc nigminR)akd

mYy. seRmcsRmÜceTA KWBuMmanesckþIEføgkarN_NamYyeLIy.

63 Carter, op. cit., p. 209.

64 Brzezinski, Power and Principle, p. 412. muneBlmankarvaylukrbs;cin ÉkGKÁrdæTUtGaemrikaMg

enARkúgmUsÁÚ Malcolm Toon )an[elak ®háÚmIkU dwgBIesckþIsgÇwmrbs;Kat;GMBIkarminRbRBwtþGVI[

hYsehturbs;sUevot enAeBlEdlkarvaylukenHekItman. Christian Science Monitor, éf¶TI26

ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979.

65 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak eLGUNad_ vUdxUk/ éf¶TI8 Extula qñaM1980enARkúghugkug.

66 P.I., éf¶TI9 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979/ pp. 13-14.

67 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþICan;x<s;mñak;énRksYgkarbreTsCb:un/ éf¶TI31 Ex]sPa

enATIRkúgtUküÚ.

68 kñúg»kasénkarRbCuMedayELkmYyCamYyelak hYg hY elak s‘UNaGU sUNUda rdæm®nþIkarbreTs

Cb:un )anRbkasR)ab;Kat;fa ³ «RbeTscinminRtÚvBwgelIkareRbIkmøaMgkñúgCemøaHRBMEdnrbs;xøÜn

CamYyRbeTsevotNameLIy>>>. kñúgnaménRbeTseyIg RbeTscinRtÚvEteFVIGVImYy eday

Rby½tñRbEyg». kaEst Mainichi Daily News, éf¶TI8 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979.

69 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinmñak;enATIRkúghugkug naéf¶TI7 ExmIna qñaM1979.

70 Brzezinski, Power and Principle, p. 140. karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþICan;x<s;mñak;énRksYg

karbreTsCb:unenATIRkúgtUküÚ naéf¶TI31 Ex]sPa qñaM1983.

71 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUt)araMgmñak;enATIRkúg):arIs/ éf¶TI3ExkumÖ³qñaM1985.

72 enAeBldwgBIkarvayRbharrbs;cin v:a):ayI ¬naykrdæm®nþI\NÐa¦)anbMRBÜjdMeNIrTsSnkic©

rbs;Kat;ehIyRtLb;mkRbeTs\NÐavij. paM v:an;dug )anbnþdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;Kat;.

73 N.Y.T., éf¶TI25 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1979.

74 Time, éf¶TI12 ExmIna qñaM1979.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg500

Page 511: Brother enemy

75 Daniel Tretiak, «China’s Vietnam War and Its Consequences», karbBa©ÚnB½t’maneTAkan;sikçasala

mYysþIBIRbeTscin/ saklviTüal½yrbs;cinenAhugkug/ éf¶TI5-7 ExFñÚ qñaM1979/ p.7.

76 Garrett, «The «China Card» and «Its Origins»», p. 156.

77 Brzezinski, Power and Principle, p. 414.

78 kñúgB½t’manmYymancMNgeCIgfa «Major Power Interest in the Asia Pacific Region» enAkñúgkar

RbCuMsnÞnarvagGñkneya)ay\NÐÚcin-GU®sþalI EdlRbRBwtþeTAenAekaH)alI naéf¶TI5-8 ExFñÚ

qñaM1982-karpSayCasaFarN³EtmYyKt;EdlniyayBICMnYysm¶at;enH-T.B. Miller )an

elIkykmkniyayBI«CMnYybec©keTsEdlRbEhlCapþl;[edayshrdæGaemrikeRkamTRmg;

CarUbftepSg²Edlft)anedaypáayrNb». sa®sþacarü Miller naykmCÄmNÐlénkar

RsavRCavEpñkyuT§sa®sþnigkarBarrbs;GU®sþalI )anseRmcyk)anB½t’mansm¶at;CaeRcIn.

Kat;)anEføgR)ab;´ ¬enATIRkúgkg;Eb‘r:a naéf¶TI17 ExFñÚ qñaM1982¦fa tam«RbPBB½t’man

epSg² EdlminGacbdiesF)an»fa shrdæGaemrik)anpþl;eTA[BYkcinnUvB½t’manCaeRcInTak;Tg

eTAnwgkareFVIclnarbs;kgT½BsUevot.

79 Li Man Kin, Sino Vietnamese War, Hong Kong, Kingsway International Publications, 1981, p. 61.

80 Ibid, 60.

81 karvaytémørbs;cin. KµantYelxNamYyRtÚv)anpþl;[edayevotNameLIy. F.B.I.S.-A.P.A.,

éf¶TI22 mIna qñaM1979/ L1.

82 cMeBaHkarviPaKGMBItémøEdlRbeTscinRtÚvbg;eTAelIEpnkarkñúgRbeTssUmGanesovePArbs;

elak Daniel Tretiak, op. cit.. Gñkrt;cUlxagsRtÚvmñak;Edlmanzan³x<s;énkgT½BRbCaCnrMedaH

)anRbkaseRkaymkcMeBaHGñkTTYlxusRtÚvmñak;énRkúmesuIbkarN_sm¶at;bs©imRbeTsfa ³

«kareFVIRbtibtþikarRbqaMgevotNam)anbNþal[manmhnþrayy:agFM». kñúgcMeNamkgT½B

300nak;énkgvresnatUcrbs;Kat;man45nak;RtÚvsøab;nigrbYs95nak; KWkar)at;bg;man

RbEhlCit50PaKry.

CMBUkTI11

1 kaEst Le Matin, éf¶TI19 Exmkra qñaM1979.

2 Elizabeth Becker, «Sihanouk Center Stage», W.P., éf¶TI15 Exmkra qñaM1979.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 501

Page 512: Brother enemy

3 kaEst N.Y.T., éf¶TI15 Exmkra qñaM1979.

4 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy r:UehS s‘UlIv:an; , éf¶TI17 Exkkáda qñaM1985enARkúgv:asuInetan

DI>suI>.

5 kñúgesovePA «GñkeTasExµrRkhm»/ TMB½r365 semþc sIhnu )anGHGagfa ³ «enAcMeBaHmux

PaBes¶óms¶at; [rbs; v:an;s_] enH mehsI´ )anpþl;eyabl;[´eFVIkarTak;TgCamYyRbeTs

)araMgkuMbg¥g; edIm,IsuM[RbeTs)araMgyl;RBmpþl;nUvsiT§iRCkekanxagneya)aydl;eyIg

eRBaHfa shrdæGaemrikhak;dUcCabdiesFsMeNIrbs;eyIgeTAehIy».

6 karbriyayBIkarCYbKñatamkarNat;rbs;semþc sIhnu CamYy etg s‘avBIg KWsMGagelIkar

CYbsnÞnaBIrelIkCamYysemþcenAéf¶TI5 Exemsa qñaM1979 naTIRkúgeb:kaMg nigExsIha

qñaM1979 ¬karsnÞnatamTUrs½BÞBITIRkúgBüúgy:ag¦.

7 Nayan Chanda, «The Ballot-box Response», F.E.E.R., éf¶TI8 Ex]sPa qñaM1981.

8 80PaKryénKN³kmµaFikarmCÄimbkSRbCaCnbdivtþn_km<úCasuT§EtCaGtItyuT§Cn kñúgkar

RbyuT§RbqaMg-)araMg ¬Exµr\sSr³¦ nigFøab;eFVIsm<n§miRtCamYyevotNam ehIy20PaKry

CaGtItExµrRkhm. Stephen Heder, B½t’manEdlmancMNgeCIgfa «The Elite of the People Republic

of Kampuchea» eTA Cornell University, éf¶TI12 Exvicäika qñaM1981. Heder )ansgát;bBa¢ak;fa

80PaKryénsmaCikKN³kmµaFikarmCÄimmanedImkMeNItBIextþnanaEdlmanRBMEdnCab;nwg

evotNam ehIyfa 60PaKryFøab;rs;enA20qñaMb¤elIsBIenH enARbeTsevotNam.

9 Timothy Cerney, «Kampuchea in 1982: Political and Military Escalation», Asian Survey, mkra

qñaM1983, p. 82.

10 Ibid., p. 79.

11 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtmñak;énRbeTssgÁmniymmYy/ éf¶TI2 ExmIna qñaM1980

enATIRkúgPñMeBj. sUmGanGtßbTrbs;elak John McBeth, «Bureaucrats from B68»cuHpSay

kñúgTsSnavdþI F.E.E.R. éf¶TI15 Extula qñaM1982pg.

12 Ibid., p. 82.

13 F.B.I.S.-A.P.A., éf¶TI4 Exmkra qñaM1985/ K-6.

14 Paul Quinn-Judge, «View From the Front», TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R, éf¶9 Exemsa qñaM1982.

15 Nayan Chanda, «Making of a Bloc», TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R., éf¶TI30 Ex]sPa qñaM1980.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg502

Page 513: Brother enemy

16 v: v:an;eKot/ enAsnñisITelIkTImYyénkarerobcMeFVIEpnkarsRmab;\NÐÚcin enAExkumÖ³ qñaM1984

Edlerobrab;bBa©ÚlGtßbTmYyKµancuHhtßelxa ³ «The Vietnamisation of Kampuchea: A New Model

of Colonialism», Indochina Report, Extula qñaM1984/ RbeTssigðburI.

17 épÞdIksikmµEdleRbIR)as;enARbeTsevotNamGaceLIgBI 0/09hikta enAqñaM1985 dl;

0/13hiktasRmab;RbCaCnmñak;²enAqñaM2000 luHNaEtRtÚvbegáInépÞdIksikmµEdleRbI

R)as;enH85PaKry nigdMeLIgva[dl;10lanhikta. enAeBlenH RbCaCnevotNam

RbEhlCaeLIgdl;75lannak;y:agTabbMput. Stewart E. Fraser, «Vietnam Struggles with

Exploding Population», Indochina Issues, Nº57, Ex]sPa qñaM1985/ p. 5.

18 F.B.I.S-A.P.A., éf¶TI25 ExkumÖ³ qñaM1983, p. I.6.

19 kaEføgrbs;GñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;evotNammñak;cMeBaHelak W.S.Turley kñúg»kasénkar

snÞnamYyenATIRkúghaNUy naéf¶TI31 ExmIna qñaM1983. B½t’manpÞal;xøÜnrbs;elak Turley.

20 Policy of the People’s Republic of the Kampuchea with Regard to Vietnamese Residents, PñMeBj ExkBaØa

qñaM1983/ p. 12. enAExmifuna qñaM1983 egVón kUfac; rdæm®nþIkarbreTsevotNam )an

RbkasR)ab;smPaKIGU®sþalI b‘Íl éhedn fa niKmCnevotNamenARbeTskm<úCamanminelIs

BI500>000nak;eT edaybBa¢ak;fa bnÞab;BIkarsøab;rbs;evotNamEdlmanedImkMeNItenATI

enaH sBVéf¶enHmanmitþPkþib¤bgb¥Únsac;jatixøHrbs;BYkeK)ancUleTAtaMgenACMnYs. karsnÞna

rbs;Gñk niBn§CamYyelak b‘Íl éhedn (Bill Hayden) enAéf¶TI27 Exmifuna qñaM1983 naTIRkúg

hugkug.

21 Fraser, op. cit., 6.

22 Marie-Alexandrine Martin, «nItiRkmevotNamUbnIykmµenAkm<úCa»/ neya)ayGnþCati/ niTaXrdUv

qñaM1984/ p. 184.

23 enAqñaM1981 saracrmYyrbs;RksYgkarbreTs )anhammin[GñkTTYlxusRtÚv GaemrikaMg

cab;édnwgExµrRkhmeLIy. kñúg»kasénBiFIbdisNæarkic©mYyenAGgÁkarshRbCaCati naEx

mifuna qñaM1981 rdæm®nþIkarbreTsGaemrikaMg GaLichSg;d½r ehk (Alexander Haig) )ancab;

édGñkkarTUtEdlrevosrévmñak;y:agENn edaymindwgfa GñkenaHCa eGog sarI eLIy.

24 GñkTTYlxusRtÚvmñak;énRksYgkarbreTsrbs;Cb:unenATIRkúgtUküÚ )anbBa¢Únmk[´nUvesckþI

cmøgkarsnÞnarvag GUhuIr:a-etg enH ¬tUküÚ éf¶TI10 ExFñÚ qñaM1979¦. sUmGanGtßbTrbs;

RbPBÉksarsMGag 503

Page 514: Brother enemy

elak Nayan Chanda, «Japan’s Kampuchea Diplomacy» kñúgTsSnavdþI F.E.E.R. elxecjpSay

éf¶TI10 Exemsa qñaM1980.

25 «vasnacugeRkaysRmab;ExµrRkhm», TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R., ecjéf¶TI18 Exemsa qñaM1980.

26 Gñkrt;ecalCYrLavmñak; )anbBa¢ak;R)ab;´BIGtßiPaBénCMrMhVwkhat;mYyrbs;clnats‘URbqaMg

evotNamenARbeTsLavfa KWsßitenARbeTscinPaKxagt,Úg. karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYy

sa®sþacarü xaMesgEkv esgsaFIt(Khamsengkeo Sengsathit)enATIRkúgeb:kaMgnaExkumÖ³ qñaM

1982. sa®sþacarüsaklviTüal½yGaemrikaMgmYyRkúm)anCYbCnCatiéfCaeRcInnak; Edl

kMBugbgðat;beRgónGñkts‘ULav enAkñúgtMbn;mYyénextþyunNan (Yunnan). edIm,I[rwtEtCak;

c,as;sþIBIkarKaMRTrbs;Rkúgeb:kaMgcMeBaHs®gÁamqµk;RbqaMgkumµúynIsþsUmGanGtßbT «Fancy

meeting you here» rbs;elak Nay:an; can;da kñúgTsSnavdþI F.E.E.R. elxecjpSayéf¶TI24

Exkkáda qñaM1981/ TMB½r14-15.

27 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYym®nþImñak;énRksYgkarbreTsGaemrikaMg enAéf¶TI20 ExsIha qñaM

1980 naTIRkúgv:asuInetanDI>sIu>.

28 ]tþmesnIy_ Saiyud Kerdphol embBa¢akarCan;x<s;énkgT½BPUminÞéf/ dkRsg;mkniyayCa

sMGagkñúg The Nation Review, éf¶TI19 Exkkáda qñaM1982.

29 ´Føab;B¤niyayBI«siT§i»enHBImat;rbs;GñkCUndMeNIrCaExµrRkhm k¾dUcBImat;BYkem²énclna

ts‘UExµrminEmnkumµúynIsþEdr.

30 Stephen Heder, «Democratic Kampuchea: The Regime’s postmortem», Indochina Issues, Nº13, Janvier

1981, p. 5.

31 RbeTsGU®sþalI)anQb;TTYlsÁal;km<úCaRbCaFibetyüCapøÚvkarenAéf¶TI14 Extula qñaM1980.

sUmGanGtßbTrbs;elak Frank Frost, «The Conflict over Cambodia: Implications of the Khmer

Coalition Agreement», Canberra, Department of the Parliamentary Library, 1982, Basic Paper Nº14.

32 lI xVan; yU/ Rsg;mkniyayCasMGagkñúgTsSnavdþI F.E.E.R., éf¶TI26 ExkBaØa qñaM1980.

33 eqøIytbnwglixitmYyrbs; exov sMpn cuHéf¶TI21 ExsIha qñaM1979 EdlesñI[RBHGgÁTTYl

tMENgCaRbFanrNsirS semþc sIhnu )anbeBa©jRBHraCeyabl;fa ³ «rNsirSfµIk¾dUckmµviFI

neya)ayfµI EdlbgðajedayExµrRkhm Cak;Esþg KWCakarlak;ButfµImYyEdlnwgTak;Tajcitþ

)anEtBYkmnusSPøIePøInigeqatl¶g;b:ueNÑaH».

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg504

Page 515: Brother enemy

34 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtCan;x<s;rbs;éfmñak; enAéf¶TI14 Exmkra qñaM1986

naTIRkúgv:asuInetan DI>suI>.

35 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtCan;x<s;mñak;rbs;shrdæGaemrik EdlGmdMeNIrelak

Mondale eTATIRkúgeb:kaMg/ éf¶TI23 Exkkáda qñaM1985 enATIRkúgv:asuInetanDI>suI>.

36 karerobrab;BIdMeNIrrbs;elak eRBm eTARbeTscin KWsMGagelIbNþakarsnÞnarbs;´CamYy

GñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinmñak; enAéf¶TI15 Exvicäika qñaM1980 nigCamYyGñkTTYlxusRtÚvmñak;én

RksYgkarbreTséf enAéf¶TI29 Exvicäika qñaM1980 naTIRkúg)agkk.

37 karerobrab;BIdMeNIrrbs;elak lI xVan;yU enATIRkúgeb:kaMg KWEp¥kelIkarsnÞnamYyCamYy

GñkTTYlxusRtÚvcinmñak; enAéf¶TI3 ExFñÚ qñaM1980 naTIRkúghugkug nig CamYym®nþImñak;énRksYg

karbreTssigðburIenAéf¶TI5 ExFñÚ qñaM1980. kñúg»kasénkarsnÞnamYyenAExkumÖ³ qñaM1983

naTIRkúg)agkk elakrdæm®nþIkarbreTssigðburI s‘UBIy:as; daNa)aLan; )anGHGagR)ab;´fa

)anTTYlkarFanaBIBYkcinfa BYkeKnwgRbtibtþitamkarvinicä½ymYyrbs;RbCara®sþ edaye)aHbg;

BYkExµrRkhmecal.

38 kñúg»kasénkarsnÞnamYy enAéf¶TI5 Exemsa qñaM1980 naTIRkúgeb:kaMg semþc sIhnu )an

manRBHraCbnÞÚlR)ab;´fa ³ «´CaCnCatiExµrnigCaGñkesñhaCatimñak;. ´mincg;eFVIxøÜnCa sIhnu

Edlsøab;enAelITwkdIbreTsmYyeLIy. ´cg;cUlTivgÁtenAkñúgRbeTsrbs;dUntanigRbCaCn´.

´RsLaj;RbeTscinnigkUer:xageCIg b:uEnþRbeTsTaMgenaHBuMEmnCamatuPUmi¬RsukkMeNIt¦rbs;´

eT. matuPUmirbs;´ KWRbeTskm<úCa ehIymanEtmYyKt;>>>. ebIniyay[esµaHRtg;eTAmunnwg

cUlTivgÁt ´R)afñacg;mancMENkkñúgRbvtþisa®sþkñúgzan³CaGñkksagRbeTskm<úCa CaBiess

kñúgvis½ysgÁmkic©nigvb,Fm’. RbCara®sþtUctacCaGñkRkIRk/ RbCaCnsamBaØEtgEtCamnusS

sRmab;´Canic©. munnwgcUlTivgÁt ´RtÚvEteFVIGVIEdlmanplRbeyaCn_dl;GñkTaMgenaH. evot

Nam nigelak ehg sMrin RbEhldwgfa BYkeKnwgeqøótTajKuNRbeyaCn_y:ageRcInBIkar

yagRtLb;eTAvijrbs;´. GVI²nwgRtÚvcb; ³ s®gÁamRbqaMgExµrRkhmnwgRtÚvQñH».

39 lkçxNÐTaMgR)aMbYnKWmandUcxageRkam ³

kk>> karseRmccUlrYbrYmnwgExµrRkhmkñúgrNsirSrYbrYmmYynigkñúgrdæaPi)albRgÜbbRgÜmCati

mYy KWRtÚvmanlkçxNÐ. ebIsinCalkçxNÐNamYykñúgcMeNamlkçxNÐTaMgenHRtÚvRcanecal

edayExµrRkhmb¤RbeTscin semþc sIhnu nwgminGacshkar)aneLIy.

RbPBÉksarsMGag 505

Page 516: Brother enemy

xx>> km<úCaRbCaFibetyüRtÚvEtERbkøayCaRbeTskm<úCadUcBImun. Tg;CatinigbTePøgCatimunqñaM

1970 nwgRtÚverobcM[dUcedImvij.

KK>> kgT½BsIhnuniymnwgRtÚvbMBak;GavuFedayRbeTscin[esµIKñanwgkgT½BExµrRkhmEdr ehIy

nwgenAEtsßitenAeRkamGMNacbBa¢akarÉkraCüdEdl.

XX>> edayTTYlbnÞúkmuxtMENgCaRbFanrNsirS semþc sIhnu nwgminTTYlxusRtÚvelIrdæaPi)al

rbs;RBHGgÁeLIy.

gg>> RBHGgÁnwgRtÚvGnuBaØat[eFVIkargarnigyageFVIdMeNIrCamYynwgGñktMNagsMxan;²rbs;rdæa-

Pi)al.

cc>> RBHGgÁnwgmansiT§ibeBa©jmtidUcGñkkaEstnigGñkniBn§Edr.

qq>> karbBa¢ak;[dwgnwgRtÚvpþl;[sþIBIeCaKvasnarbs;RBHjativgSnigshkarIrbs;RBHGgÁEdl

)at;xøÜneRkamrbbExµrRkhm.

CC>> bnÞab;BIkardkfyrbs;evotNam RbeTskm<úCaRtÚvEtRbkasxøÜnCaRbeTsGBüaRkwt ehIy

kgT½BTaMgGs;rbs;xøÜnRtÚvdkhUtGavuF. munkardkfyenH kgT½BGnþrCatirkSasnþiPaB

mYynwgRtÚvdak;BRgay.

QQ>> kare)aHeqñatsklnwgRtÚverobcMeLIg. kgT½BrkSasnþiPaBnwgRtÚvCMnYsedayKN³kmµkar

RtÜtBinitüGnþrCatimYy.

40 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtmñak;énRbeTsmYyCasmaCiksmaKmGas‘an Edl

manmuxenAsm½yRbCuMnaTIRkúgjÚvy:k/ éf¶TI15 Exkkáda qñaM1981.

41 han nanLúg )anrMB£kR)ab;´BIkarkt;smÁal;enHedaypÞal;kñúgGMLúgénkarsnÞnamYyEdlKat;

)anyl;RBm[´CYbBIrbIExeRkaymk ³ «Han Fire a Warning Volley», TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R. elx

ecjpSayéf¶TI12 ExmIna qñaM1982.

42 Alexander M. Haig, Caveat: Realism, Reagan, and foreign Policy, New York, Mcmillan, 1984, p. 194.

43 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkTTYlxusRtÚvCan;x<s;mñak;énsmaKmGas‘an enAéf¶TI20

Ex]sPa qñaM1985 naTIRkúgv:asuInetan.

44 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak m:ukta KUs‘Um:aGatm:adüa enATIRkúgjÚvy:k naéf¶TI17

Exkkáda qñaM1981.

45 Ibid.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg506

Page 517: Brother enemy

46 edayerobrab;BIehtukarN_bnÞab;bnSMenH GñkkarTUtmñak;énRbeTsmYyCasmaCiksmaKm

Gas‘an )anniyayR)ab;´fa ³ «y:agehac snñisITenH)aneFVI[eyIgdwgerOgr:avmYycMnYn

tUcEdr. enAeBlRbkan;ykesckþIseRmccitþ RbeTstUc²ElgmanmitþeTotehIy».

PaKeRcInénbNþaRbeTselakxaglic)anbdiesFmincUlrYmCamYysmaKmGas‘ankñúgkar

RbQmmuxCamYynwgRbeTscineLIy.

47 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkkarTUtCan;x<s;mñak;rbs;éf enAéf¶TI11 Exvicäika qñaM1985

naTIRkúgv:asuInetanDI>suI>.

48 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak tan;RsIuháahSalI enATIRkúghugkug naéf¶TI25 ExFñÚ

qñaM1981.

49 Sabam Siagian, «Potentials of Conflict and Potentials of Peace in Southeast Asia», B½t’manTak;Tgnwg

karRbCuMelITI3rvag\NÐÚensuI-saFarNrdæshBn§GaløWm:g;/ Hambourg, 15-17 Avril 1985.

50 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYysemþcRBH neratþm sIhnu enATIRkúgjÚvy:knaéf¶TI14 Extula

qñaM1984.

51 Nayan Chanda, «Sihanouk Stonewalled», TsSnavdþI F.E.E.R., elxecjpSayéf¶TI1 Exvicäika

qñaM1984.

52 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak Garun panuBgS enATIRkúg):arIsnaéf¶TI31 Exmkra

qñaM1985.

53 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyGñkÉkeTsxagB½t’manrbs;GaemrikaMg enAéf¶TI17 Exmkra

qñaM1986 naTIRkúgv:asuInetanDI>suI>. The U.S.S.R. in Indochina, Report Nº334, Bureau of

Intelligence and Research, Department of State, Washington, D.C., mars 1982.

54 W.P., 10 mars 1979.

55 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYyelak rIqad GarmIefc Gnurdæm®nþIRksYgkarBarCati TTYl

bnÞúkEpñksnþisuxGnþrCatienAéf¶TI28 ExFñÚ qñaM1985 naTIRkúgv:asuInetanDI>suI>.

56 cMeBaHkarBinitüemIld¾RbesIrmYyGMBIshRbtibtþikarrvagcin-GaemrikaMgxagvis½ysnþisux

enAqñaM1979-80 sUmGanesovePArbs;elak Jonathan D. Pollack, The Lesson of Coalition

Politics: Sino-American Security Relations, Santa Monica, Rand Corporation, 1984, pp. 39-72.

57 Banning N. Garrett and Bonnie S. Glaser, War and Peace: The view from Moscow and Beijing, Policy

RbPBÉksarsMGag 507

Page 518: Brother enemy

Papers in International Affairs Nº20, Institute of International Studies, Berkeley, University of California

Press, 1984, pp. 48-49.

58 Richard Nations, «Great Leap Sideways», F.E.E.R., 30 mai 1985.

59 karsnÞnarbs;GñkniBn§CamYysa®sþacarüsaklviTüal½yd¾eqñ Immñak;rbs;sUevotCaGñk

ÉkeTsxagbBaðaGasuIPaKGaeKñy_enA Bellagio naéf¶TI7 ExFñÚ qñaM1985.

sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg508

Page 519: Brother enemy

esckþIEføgGMNrKuNBIGñkERbsRmÜl

Cabzm ´sUmEføgGMNrKuNCaBnøwkcMeBaHelak Nay:an; can;da Edl)anpþl;siT§i[´ERbsRmÜl

esovePArbs;elakeRkamcMNgeCIgfa «sRtÚvbgb¥ÚnÉg» tamry³elak qaMg yu naykmCÄmNÐl

Éksarkm<úCa. esovePAenH ´Føab;)anERbsRmÜlcuHpSaykñúgkarEstrsµIkm<úCamþgrYc mkehIykal

BIcugqñaM1997. b:uEnþ enAeBlEdlmCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCaTTYl)ansiT§iERbsRmÜlBIGñkniBn§ nig

seRmc[e)aHBum<sñaédenH ´k¾cab;epþImBinitü nigEksRmÜleXøagXøaeLIgvijedayl¥itl¥n; edIm,IeFVI[

xøwmsaresovePAenHmanlkçN³kan;EtsuRkwteLIg. eTaHCay:agNak¾eday karERbsRmÜlBIPasa

breTsmkCaPasaExµrBitCamankarlM)aknigkarxVHxatxøH²minxan. GaRs½yehtuenH ´)aTsUm

GFüaRs½ycMeBaHkarxVHcenøaHmYycMnYnEdlBitCamanenAkñúgesovePAenH.

´)aTsUmEføgGMNrKuNCaGenkb,karcMeBaHelak qaMg yu naykmCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

Edl)anxitxMxñHExñgRKb;Ebby:agrhUtdl;esovePAenHseRmcecjCarUbrageLIg. ´)aTk¾sUmEføg

GMNrKuNpgEdrcMeBaHelak s‘um man GtItTIRbwkSanaykrdæm®nþIh‘unEsn elak pøúg qMu naykRKb;RKg

nigelak Eb:n smiT§i niBn§naykkaEstrsµIkm<úCaEdl)anCYyeRCamERCg nigKaMBar´rhUtdl;´man

éf¶enH. elIsBIenH ´)aTsUmEføgGMNrKuNcMeBaHmitþrYmkargarTaMgGs;enAmCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

EdlxitxMbMeBjkargarCaFøúgmYyeFVI[seRmc)aneCaKC½yFM²CabnþbnÞab;.

´sUmEføgGMNrKuNpgEdrcMeBaHmitþGñkGanEdlFøab;)anpþl;kmøaMgcitþ nigelIksresIr´eday

pÞal;kþIb¤minpÞal;kþI RBmTaMgGñkniymkarGanesovePARKb;rUb sUmTTYl)anesckþIsux nigeCaKC½yRKb;

RbkarkñúgkarbMeBjParkic©edIm,IsuPmgÁrbs;xøÜnerogeTA.

CIEh/ éf¶TI9 Exmkra qñaM2006

eTB em:gXan ehA TIXayu

509

Page 520: Brother enemy

RbvtþiGñkbkERb

eTB em:gXan ekItenAExkumÖ³ qñaM1947 enAPUmiCIEh XuMBamRbeFñaH RsukekaHsUTin

extþkMBg;cam. elak)anCab;sBaØab½RtmFümsikSaTutiyPUmi enAqñaM1967 enATIRkúgPñMeBj. enAqñaM

1968 elak)anTTYlsBaØab½RtKruekaslüBImhaviTüal½yKruekaslüRkúgPñMeBj. BIqñaM1997

dl;qñaM2002 elakeFVIkarCabuKÁlikbkERbPasa)araMgenAkaEstrsµIkm<úCa bc©úb,nñelakKWCaGñk

bkERbPasa)araMgenAmCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa.

esckþI]TÞis´sUm]TÞissñaédenHCUncMeBaHelak«Buk eTB xVg nigGñkmþay Cam TI nigb¥ÚnRbús-RsIrbs;´

bYnnak; RBmTaMgRbCaCnkm<úCasøÚtRtg;RbmaN2lannak;Edl)ansøab;)at;bg;CIvitTaMgminGs;citþ

eRkamkarkab;smøab;y:agsahavéRBépSkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüBIqñaM1975 dl; qñaM1979.

510