Canguilhem Vital Rationalist Selections

  • View
    394

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Georges Canguilhem is one of France’s leading philosophers and historians of science. Trained as both a medical doctor and a philosopher, Canguilhem overlapped these practices to demonstrate that there could be no epistemology without concrete study of the actual development of the sciences and no worthwhile history of science without a philosophical understanding of the conceptual basis of all knowledge.A Vital Rationalist brings together for the first time some of Canguilhem’s most important writings, including excerpts from previously unpublished manuscripts. Organized around the major themes and problems that have preoccupied Canguilhem throughout his intellectual career, this collection allows readers both familiar and unfamiliar with Canguilhem’s work access to a vast array of conceptual and concrete meditations on epistemology, methodology, science, and history. Although Canguilhem is a demanding writer, Delaporte succeeds in identifying the main lines of his thought with unrivaled clarity and maps out the complex and crucial place this thinker holds in the history of twentieth-century French thought.

Text of Canguilhem Vital Rationalist Selections

A Vi ta l Se l e cte d Ge o r g .t

R a ti o n a l i st Wr i ti n g s yn g u i l h e m f rom

Edit cd Tr anslat cd

b, v Fr ango is l) e lapo r t e bv Ar t hur G oldham nr er

l vit h an int r oduct icr n a c r it ical

bv Paul R. r binor v and Lim oge s

bib li ogr aphv bv Cam ille

ZON E

BOOKS

N E\v1994

YOR K

O 1 9 9 4L I r T o n e ,In c. Z O N EB O O K S 6 r r B r o a d r v r y ,S u itc 6 0 8 N e * Y o r k , N Y to o tz A l l r i g h t s r c s c rve d .

,

i\I

(tContents

,^t \

rr

['

N o p a r t o l t h i s b o o k m a y b e r e p r o d u ce d , sto r e d in a r e t r i c v a l s y s t e m ,o r tr a n sm itte d in a n y lb r m o r b y a ny m e r n s , i n c l u d in g e lcctr o n ic, m e ch a n ica l,p h o to co pl i n g , m i c r o l i l m in g , r cco r d in g , o r o th e r u ' ise ( e xce p t f o r t h a t c o p y i ng p e r m ittcd b y Se ctio n s r o 7 a n d r o 8 of t h e U . S . C o p y r ig h t L a t| a n d e xce p t b y r e vie we r slo r t h e p u b l i c p r e ss) with o u t wr itte n p e r m issio n fio m the Publisher. S o u r c e sf o r t h e cxce r p ts a r e liste d o n p p . 4 8 0 - 8 1 .

Delaporte e Editor's Notc b.vFranqois Rat ionalist lnt r oduct ion: A Vit al by PaulRabinow 1r P,qnr ONr M Er oDor ocY lhe Hr st or r ol 5cr ( n( e 25

P r i n t e d i n t h e U n ite d Sta te so fAm e r ica . D i s t r i b u t e d b y l h e M l l- Pr e ss, C a m b r i d g c , M assa ch u se tts, n d L o n d o n . En g la n d a Da L i b r a r y o f C o n g r e ssCa ta lo g in g - in - Pu b lica tio n ta C a n g u i l h e m . Ge o r g e s,r e o a A v i t a l r a t io n a list: se le cte dr vr itin g s lio m Ge o r ges C a n g u i l h e m . r ed ite d b v F r a n q o isDe la p o n e ; tr a n sla ted b v A r t h u r C o l dh a m r n e r with a n in tr o d u ctio n b r : Pa ul R a b i n o s a n d r cr itica l b ib lio g r a p h vb y Cim illc L im o gcs. p cm. I n c l u d e s b i b lio g r a p h ica lr e fe r e n ce s. r s B No - 9 4 )?9 9 - 7 2 - 8 r . S c i e n c e - l Iisto r v. z. Scie n ce - Ph ilo so p h y. t . D e l a p o r t e , f ra n q o is, r 9 .1 r Qr) t.cl4 '991 9 l- 86rI lr . T itlc.

I II III PARrT\\'() IV

The VariousModels ar The Historl of the Histor,vof Science Epr s:l, t t o I olainthe neuromtrscular r t ' gulat io n so f m. e mc n t - i rJ D )e l \'L he movcmcnt of exci sed , th e h e a rt, l l th t' l > r' ai n d not causesP i ri tsto di or gans , s p c c i ,rl l \ c llou into thesc organs,rrh.rt c.rused th('D)to contract?Dcscartes from thc body' did not ha v cto c o n l i o n t th i s rl te s ti o rt,R cntoveclIn .1

it rhc heart r et ainecl s heat , anr l t r aceslr f blor r t l r et r ainit lg in it it uut coul (l vap or ir er nd c. r usc t o er par r r J. lN f ol t hosc *ho held dif h ear t wasa r nusclc.it bec. r m c f ic( r lt t o. r r g( r ct hat t he that thc m()vcmcnts. centr.ll controller ol .rll crrgan brain was the cssential necessarv look to pl.rccrother than thc brain, to l-hus, it became i 1 not l or t he causet hen at lcast lir r lact or s go! er ning cer t ain du rnovements. lFormation rillctc, p.5)l Thomos Willis DeservesCredit for the Reflex Concept \ [69] W hat dist inguishedWillis f iom [ ) escar t es \ 'er e his conm ot ion of t he hcar t an( l t he cir culat ion of t he ccpti ons of t he blood, rvhich hc took *'holesalc fiom \\iilliam Ilarvev; namelv, l ri s conce pt ionsol t he nat ur c of anim al spir it s and t heir m ov( of ment through t he ner ves; t hc st r uct ur eol ner 'es; anclof m usru l ar con t r act lon. ;\ccor ding t o Willis ( and Har vcr ') ,t hc hear t is a nr uscleind it r D ()thi D g r or c.I f ir is t hc pr im um m ovcl-ol t he ot her t nusclcs, r) it rc i s srronl v bv vir t ue ol t he r hvt hm of it s lut r cli Lri l di ng at a or . i I th e ,vs tu d i e d rh c p l o l ' l c n r o f - 11iv en, l all, s , r lv e. Thc nraterialcmboclimcnt ficedom; in t of ofthcse dcgr ees lr eedom consist s gui