Can’t Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/25/2019 Cant Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

    1/8Page 1

    REPORTABLE

    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIACIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

    CIVIL APPEAL Nos.823-854 OF 2016(Arising out of SLP (C ) Nos !"#!#$ !"#"% of &%!!)

    'r* Pu+*i, Sr-i, Co..ission / Ors 0A11**nts

    Vrsus

    T2 Stt Infor.tion Co..ission / Anr 0Rs1on3nts

    WithCIVIL APPEAL NO.855 OF 2016(Arising out of SLP (Ci-i*) No"455 of &%!4)

    Pu+*i, Sr-i, Co..ission UP 0A11**nt

    Vrsus Rg2-n3r Sing2 Rs1on3nt

    ! " # $ E N T$.%. E&BAL' .

    L- grnt3

    & In t2s t6o 11*s t2 s2ort 7ustion 62i,2 n3s

    ,onsi3rtion is s to 62t2r t2 Di-ision 8n,2 of t2

    'r* Hig2 Court +9 i.1ugn3 :u3g.nt 2s rig2t*9 2*3

    t2t t2 rs1on3nts r ntit*3 not on*9 to gt infor.tion

    6it2 rgr3 to t2 s,n ,o1is of t2ir ns6r s2t;

    1

    LatestLaws.com

  • 7/25/2019 Cant Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

    2/8

    LatestLaws.com

    Page 2

    t+u*tion$s2t ,ontining intr-i6 .r

  • 7/25/2019 Cant Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

    3/8

    LatestLaws.com

    Page 3

    Di-ision 8n,2 of t2 Hig2 Court of 'r* t Ern

  • 7/25/2019 Cant Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

    4/8

    LatestLaws.com

    Page 4

    strngt2n t2 ,onfi3n, of t2 ,itinr9 insu,2 institutions T2 PSC is ,onstitution*institution To stn3 +o- +or3; is on of itso6n 1ri. r7uir.nts T2r is not2ing t2ts2ou*3 3tr 3is,*osur of t2 ,ontnts of t2

    .tri*s t2t t2 =.ins 1ro-i3 s 1rt oft2ir 1rfor.n, in t2 ,o.1tition for +ings*,t3 to 1u+*i, sr-i, T2 ,onfi3n, t2t.9 + r1os3 +9 t2 =.ins in t2institution of t2 PSC 3os not ins1ir t2,,1t+i*it9 of fi3u,ir9 r*tions2i1 t2ts2ou*3 s2** no6 =.in t2 n=t ,ontntionof PSC t2t t2r is fi3u,ir9 r*tions2i1+t6n it n3 t2 =.inrs n3 s ,ons7un,; it is *igi+* to ,*i. 1rot,tionfro. 3is,*osur; =,1t 6it2 t2 sn,tion of t2,o.1tnt ut2orit9; s rgr3s t2 i3ntit9 oft2 =.inrs s *so t2 .tri*s t2t 6rsu+:,t3 to t2 =.intion > 2- *r39

    11ro-3 TREESA n3 t2 3iffrnt 1r,3ntsn3 ,o..ntris r*i3 on t2rin s rgr3st2 ,on,1t of fi3u,ir9 r*tions2i1 > r infu** gr.nt 6it2 t2 *6 *i3 +9 t2 Di-ision8n,2 of t2is Court in Cntr of Ert2 S,in,

    4

    LatestLaws.com

  • 7/25/2019 Cant Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

    5/8

    LatestLaws.com

    Page 5

    Stu3is (su1r); t2t SG (!)() 3*s 6it2infor.tion -i*+* 6it2 t2 1rson in 2isfi3u,ir9 r*tions2i1 6it2 not2r t2tinfor.tion un3r t2is 23 is not2ing +utinfor.tion in trust; 62i,2; +ut for t2

    r*tions2i1 6ou*3 not 2- +n ,on-93 or2t is it t2tt2 PSC 2o*3s in trust for t2 =.inrsNot2ing At t2 +st; it ,ou*3 + 1oint3 outt2t t2 i3ntit9 of t2 =.inrs 2s to +insu*t3 fro. 1u+*i, g; 2-ing rgr3 toissus r*t+* to -u*nr+i*it9 n3 =1osur to,orru1tion if t2 i3ntitis of t2 =.inrs r3is,*os3 in 3-n, 8ut; t n9 rt; su,2issus 6ou*3 go to o+*i-ion ftr t2 ,on,*usionof t2 -*ution of t2 ns6r s,ri1ts n3 t2

    1u+*i,tion of t2 rsu*ts T2rfor; it 6ou*3not + in 1u+*i, intrst to 2o*3 t2t t2r ,ou*3+ ,ontinu3 s,r,9 -n s rgr3s t2i3ntit9 of t2 =.inrs A,,ss to su,2infor.tion; in,*u3ing s to t2 i3ntit9 of t2=.inrs; ftr t2 =.intion n3 -*ution1ro,ss r o-r; ,nnot + s2i3 off un3r n9*6 or -o63 1rin,i1* of 1ri-,9

    G > 3o not fin3 n9 su+stn, in t2 rsoning gi-n +9

    t2 'r* Hig2 Court on t2 7ustion of 3is,*osur of

    n.s of t2 =.inrs

    # In t2 1rsnt ,s; t2 PSC 2s t

  • 7/25/2019 Cant Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

    6/8

    LatestLaws.com

    Page 6

    2s ntrust3 t2 ts< of -*uting t2 ns6r 11rs to

    t2 E=.inrs Cons7unt*9; E=.inrs in t2 1osition of

    gnts r +oun3 to -*ut t2 ns6r 11rs s 1r t2

    instru,tions gi-n +9 t2 PSC As rsu*t; fi3u,ir9

    r*tions2i1 is st+*is23 +t6n t2 PSC n3 t2

    E=.inrs T2rfor; n9 infor.tion s2r3 +t6n

    t2. is not *i+* to + 3is,*os3 Furt2r.or; t2

    infor.tion s 6ou*3 *i

  • 7/25/2019 Cant Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

    7/8

    LatestLaws.com

    Page 7

    !% In t2 1rsnt ,s t2 r7ust of t2 infor.tion

    s

  • 7/25/2019 Cant Reveal Names of Exam Paper Checkers Under RTI, Says SC

    8/8

    LatestLaws.com

    Page 8

    t29 6i** not + f,ing n9 unfortunt ,ons7un,s for

    3oing t2ir :o+ 1ro1r*9 If 6 **o6 3is,*osing n. of t2

    =.inrs in -r9 =.; t2 unsu,,ssfu* ,n3i3ts .9

    tr9 to t; t2rfor; **o6 t2s 11*s in 1rt n3

    .o3if9 t2 :u3g.nt on*9 to t2 =tnt t2t t2

    rs1on3nts$11*i,nts r not ntit*3 to t2 3is,*osur of

    n.s of t2 =.inrs s soug2t for +9 t2.

    (((((((((((..)$.%. E*+,

    (((((((((((..)A/ $ish/,

    N6 D*2iF+rur9 4; &%!?

    8

    LatestLaws.com