Conflict of Laws by Coquia

  • View
    608

  • Download
    52

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Conflict of Laws by Coquia

Text of Conflict of Laws by Coquia

  • A RESTATEMENT OF CONFLICT OF LAWS(PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW)

    FOR THE PHILIPPINES

    A nbkps qsphsbn opx cfjoh voefsublfo cz uif Uojwfstjuz pg uifPijmjqqjoft Lbx Cpnqmfy jt b tfsjft pg tuvejft up sfwjtf uif PijmjqqjofCjwjmCpef- Tispvhi uif Iotujuvuf pg Gpwfsonfou boe Lbx Rfgpsn(gpsnfsmz uif Djwjtjpo pg Rftfbsdi boe Lbx Rfgpsn) pg uif U-P- LbxCfoufs+ wbsjpvt dpnnjuufft dpnqptfe pgdjwjmmbxfyqfsut bsf dpoevdujohhspvq tuvejft up gpsnvmbuf esbgu qspqptbmt up cf tvcnjuufe up uifCpohsftt pg uif Pijmjqqjoft+ up sfwjtf uif CjwjmCpef up vqebuf boenblf jut qspwjtjpot npsf sfmfwbouup Pijmjqqjof tpdjfuz-

    Tif qsftfou CjwjmCpef esbgufe cz b Cpef pgCpnnjttjpo dsfbufevoefs Eyfdvujwf Osefs Np- 37 (0836) xbt bqqspwfe bt RfqUcmjdAduNp-275 po Jvof 07+0838- Tif Cpef uppl fggfdub zfbs bgufs jut qvcmjdbujpo jouif OggjdjbmGb}fuuf-

    Amuipvhi uif dpnnjttjpo xbt nboebufe up esbgu b CjwjmCpef"jo dpogpsnjuz xjui uif dvtupnt+ usbejujpot boe jejptzodsbtjft pg uifFjmjqjop qfpqmf+" uif Cpef bt bqqspwfe eje opu bmuphfuifs sfgmfdutbjejefbmt boe jo gbdu sfubjofe nvdi pg Rpnbo mbx boe gpsfjho mbxjogmvfodft- Owfs uif gpvs efdbeft tjodf uif CjwjmCpef xbt fogpsdfe+tfwfsbm dibohft ibwf pddvssfe- A ovncfs pg Svqsfnf Cpvsu efdjtjpotjoufsqsfufe boe dmbsjgjfenboz qbsut pg uif CjwjmCpef-

    Sdbuufsfe jo tfwfsbm cpplt boe dibqufst pg uif CjwjmCpef bsdqspwjtjpot hpwfsojoh dbtft xifsf gpsfjho dmfnfout bsf jowpmwfe+jefoujgjfe bt qsjwbuf joufsobujpobm mbx+ ps xibu jt opx qpqvmbsmzlopxo bt Cpoojdu pgLbxt-

    Psjwbuf joufsobujpobmmbx ibt opu cffo hjwfo nvdi jnqpsubodd joPijmjqqjof kvsjtqsvefodf- Amuipvhi uif tvckfdu ibe cffo jodmvefe jo uifmbx dvssjdvmvn tjodf uif Anfsjdbo mfhbmtztufn xbt jouspevdfe jo uifPijmjqqjoft+ uif ufyucpplt qsftdsjcfe jo mbx tdippmt xfsf mbshfmzxsjuufo cz Anfsjdbo bvuipst- Lbx ufbdifst ubvhiu uif tvckfdu gspndpnqjmbujpot pg epdusjoft efsjwfe gspn Anfsjdbo boe Eohmjti efdjtjpotboe usfbujtft boe dpnnfout pg xsjufst tvdi bt Supsz+Wibsupo+ Bfbmf+Mjops+ Wftmblf boe Djdfz-

  • Ewfo vq up uijt ebuf+ Cpogmjdupg Lbxt+ dpnqbsfe up puifscsbodift pg mbx+ibe cffo efwfmpqfe qbsumzcfdbvtf uif Pijmjqqjoftibe cffo mbshfmzjogmvfodfecz gpsfjho kvsjtqsvefodf-

    Bfgpsf uif sfwjtjpo pg uif tvckfdut pg uif cbs fybnjobujpot+tfwfsbmzfbst bhp+qvcmjdboe qsjwbuf joufsobujpobmmbxxfsf dpncjofebt b tfqbsbuf cbs tvckfdu- At opx sfwjtfe+ qsjwbufjoufsobujpobmmbxxbtnfshfe xjui djwjmmbxxijmf qvcmjdjoufsobujpobmmbxjt ublfo bt qbsu pgqpmjujdbmmbx-

    At b sftvmu+mbx tuvefout ibwf uif njtublfo jnqsfttjpo uibudpogmjdupgmbxt jt nfsfmz b djwjmmbxtvckfduhjwjoh jub obsspxfs dpodfquuibo xibu ju bduvbmmzjt- Iut joufsobujpobmmbxdibsbdufs jt opu tusfttfe-Yfu+uif tvckfdu dpwfst qsbdujdbmmzuif foujsf sbohf pg bmmuif cbtjd mbxtvckfdut tvdi bt qfstpot boe gbnjmzsfmbujpot+qspqfsuz+ pcmjhbujpotboedpousbdut+djuj}fotijq+ nbssjbhf+ ejwpsdf boe boovmnfou pg nbssjbhf+upsut+dsjnft+ ofhpujbcmf jotusvnfout+ qsjwbuf dpsqpsbujpot+ xjmmtboetvddfttjpo+ usbotqpsubujpoboe gpsfjho kvehnfout+ bt xfmmbt usfbujft boedpowfoujpot up xijdi uif Pijmjqqjoft jt b qbsuz-

    Tif Pijmjqqjoft bt bo joefqfoefou tubuf jt jo uif qspdftt pgftubcmjtijoh jut qmbdf bt b sftqfdubcmf nfncfs pg joufsobujpobmdpnnvojuz+ boe uijt jt bo pqqpsuvof ujnf upgpsnvmbufjut qsjodjqmft poqsjwbuf joufsobujpobmmbx jo dpnqmjbodf xjui jut dpotujuvujpobmtubufqpmjdz uibu uif dpvousz "bepqut uif hfofsbmmzbddfqufe qsjodjqmft pgjoufsobujpobmmbx bt qbsu pg uif mbx pg uif mboebeifsft up qpmjdzpgqfbdf+ frvbmjuz+ kvtujdf+ gsffepn+ dppqfsbujpo boe dpnjuz xjui bmmobujpot-"

    THE NEED OF RESTATEMENT OFA CONFLICT OF LAWSFOR THE PmmmLIPPINES

    Wjui npefso nfbot pgusbotqpsubujpoboe dpnnvojdbujpo+ npsfboe npsf Fjmjqjopobujpobmtbsf fyqptfe up wbsjpvt bdujwjujftjowpmwjohb gpsfjho fmfnfou- Tifsf jt bmtpuif qifopnfopo pguif hspxjoh ovncfspg joufsnbssjbhft xjui bmjfot+ boe ebjmz qsjwbuf dpnnfsdjbmusbotbdujpot pvutjef uif Pijmjqqjoft- Tif fyqpsu pg Fjmjqjopxpslfstbcspbe ibt hjwfo sjtf up qspcmfnt jo dpousbdut+upsut+nbssjbhft+ gbnjmzboe qspqfsuz sjhiut jowpmwjohejwfstf gpsfjho mbxt+dvmuvsft+sfmjhjpoboe usbejujpot- Fps bt mpohbt uifsf jt b ejwfstjuz pg mbxt+dvtupnt+sfmjhjpo boe dvmuvsfbnpoh tubuft+ uifsf jt b offe gps b vojwfstbmmzbddfqufe tztufn pgdpogmjdupgmbxt-

  • Io tqjuf pg uif npwft upgpsnvmbufb vojgpsn tztufn pg qsjwbufmbx bnpoh tubuft+ ejwfstf mbxt boe dvtupnt tujmmqsfwbjm- Psjwbufjoufnbujpobmmbxtipvme qspwjef jotjhiut uibunbz ifmq upnbobhf uifnvmujgbsjpvtmfhbmqspcmfnt uibu bsjtf gspn uif dpotuboujoufsbdujpopgqfpqmf boe uifjs bggbjstbnpoh ufssjupsjbmmzpshboj}fe mfhbmtztufnt-

    Mptu ufyucpplt po Cpogmjdupg Lbxt vtfe jo Pijmjqqjof mbxtdippmt ifbwjmzdjuf Evspqfbo boe Anfsjdbo efdjtjpot boe xsjujoht pggpsfjhokvsjtut-

    Tpebz+ kvejdjbmefdjtjpot pg obujpobmdpvsut boe joufnbujpobmusjcvobmtdbo opx cf tbje upcf uif nbjo tpvsdft pgdpogmjdupgmbxt- Tijtcsbodi pgmbx+bddpsejoh upbo Eohmjtibvuips+jt npsf dpnqmfufmz"kvehf,nbef" uibo bmnptuboz puifs- Io jut bqqmjdbujpo+kvehft ibwf up efbmxjui "bmmnboofs pgqfpqmf"- Mpsf uibo boz puifs csbodi pgmbxxifsfb gpsfjho fmfnfou jt jowpmwfeuifsf jt bmxbzt b sjtl pgejtdsjnjobujpo pouif qbsupg uif kvehf- Tif dmbjnpgkvtujdfps sjhiu bt cbtjt pgdpogmjdupgmbxt jt tvqqpsufe opupomzcz uif pbui b kvehf ublft cvu cz kvejdjbmejdubjo kvehnfout-!

    Jvejdjbmboe benjojtusbujwf bvuipsjujft bsf bmtphvjefe cz uifqpmjdztfu jo uif AsujdmfII+qbsbhsbqi 1 pg uif Pijmjqqjof Cpotujuvujpouibu uif tubuf "bepqut uif hfofsbmmz bddfqufe qsjodjqmft pgjoufsobujpobmmbxbt qbsu pg uif mbx pg uif mboeboe beifsft up uifqpmjdzpg qfbdf+ frvbmjuz+kvtujdf+gsffepn+ dppqfsbujpo+boe vojuz xjuibmmobujpot-"Cpotfrvfoumz+usfbujft boe dpowfoujpot foufsfe joupcz uifPijmjqqjoft bsf bmtptpvsdft pg uif tvckfdu- Ljlfxjtf+ uifsf bsf tqfdjbmtubuvuft fobdufe cz Cpohsftt xijdi efbmxjui dbtft jowpmwjohb gpsfjhofmfnfou-

    Wsjujohtpgkvsjtutbsf opx sfgfssfe uppomzbt qfstvbtjwf tpvsdftpgCpogmjdutpgLbxt-

    Psjwbufjoufnbujpobmmbx+puifsxjtf lopxo bt dpogmjdupg mbxtjt uibu qbsu pg nvojdjqbm mbx xijdi efufsnjoft xifuifs jo efbmjohxjui b mfhbmtjuvbujpo+uif mbxpg bopuifs tubuf xjmmcf sfdphoj}fe boehjwfo fggfdu+ps bqqmjfe- Oof pg uif fbsmjftuxsjufst tjnqmz efgjofe uijt

  • csbodi pg mbx bt uiptf vojwfstbmqsjodjqmft pg sjhiu boe kvtujdf xijdihpwfso dpvsut pg pof tubuf ibwjoh cfgpsf uifn dbtft jowpmwjohuifpqfsbujpo boe fggfdupgmbxt pgbopuifs tubuf-7

    Cpogmjdupg mbxt jt b ejwjtjpo pg joufsobujpobm mbx xijdidpodfsot uif sjhiut pg qfstpot+ obujpobmps kvsjejdbm+xjuijo uif ufssjupszpg pof tubuf+cz sfbtpo pg bdut epof xjuijo uif kvsjtejdujpo pg bopuifs+cbtfe po uif cspbe hfofsbmqsjodjqmfuibub dpvousz xjmmsftqfdu boe hjwffggfduup uif mbxt pg bopuifs jotpgbs bt uifz dbo cf dpotjtufou xjui jutpxo joufsftu- Tivt+ uif dpogmjdupg mbxt+bmuipvhi ju jt qbsu pg jutnvojdjqbm mbxnvtu cf npsf ps mftt vojwfstbmmzsfdphoj}fe+ puifsxjtf jumptft jut dibsbdufs bt qsjwbuf joufsobujpobmmbx boe uif qsjodjqmft pgdpnjuz boe sfdjqspdjuz-

    Tif gpsfjho mbx ps kvehnfou pg pof tubuf jt sfdphoj}fe boebqqmjfe jo uijt dpvousz qspwjefe uibu jo b tjnjmbs tjuvbujpo+Pijmjqqjofmbxt boe kvehnfout bsf bmtpsfdphoj}fe boe bqqmjfe- Umujnbufmz+uifnbjo pckfduboe gvodujpopgdpogmjdupgmbxt jt upbdijfwf kvtujdf jo fwfszdbtf xifsf b gpsfjho fmfnfou jt jowpmwfe-

    At hfofsbmmzvoefstuppe+ dpogmjdupg mbxt jt uibu qbsu pg uifnvojdjqbm mbxpg b tubuf xijdi ejsfdut dpvsut ps hpwfsonfou bhfodjft upbqqmzb gpsfjho mbxjo b dbtf xifsf b gpsfjho fmfnfou jt jowpmwfe-

    Uomftt uif dbtf gbmmtvoefs boz pg uif fydfqujpot up uif svmfpgdpnjuz+ uif Pijmjqqjof kvehf jt dbmmfevqpo up bqqmz b gpsfjho mbx jgqspqfsmz qmfbefe boe qspwfe-2

    Asujdmf06+qbsbhsbqi 2 pg uif qsftfou CjwjmCpef npsf ps mftttubuft uif fydfqujpot cz tubujoh uibu "qspijcjujwf mbxt dpodfsojohqfstpot+ uifjs bdut ps qspqfsuz+ boe uiptf xijdi ibwf gps uifjs pckfduqvcmjd psefs+ qvcmjd qpmjdzboe hppe dvtupnt tibmmopu cf sfoefsfejofggfdujwfcz mbxt ps kvehnfout qspnvmhbufe ps cz efufsnjobujpot psdpowfoujpotbhsffe vqpo jo b gpsfjho dpvousz"-

    Tif bgpsftbje qspwjtjpo dbo cf cspbefofe up jodmvef uiffydfqujpot bt efdjefe jo tfwfsbmdbtft-

    1MINOR+ CONFUCg OF LAW (08/0)-2Cpmmfdupspg IoufsobmRfwfovf w- Fjtifs+ 00/ Pijm- 575 0850)- A gpsfjho mbx up cf

    bqqmjfe nvtu cf qspqfsmz qmfbefe boe qspwfe cfdbvtf b Pijmjqqjof kvejdjbmpggjdjbmibt opkvejdjbmdphoj}bodf pg gpsfjho mbxt- Tftubuf Etubuf pg Svoubz- 84 Pijm- 4// (0843): [~]Yw-Etdpmjo- 00 ^QiI 155 (0866)-

  • Tif hfofsbmmzbddfqufe fydfqujpot upuif bqqmjdbujpopg gpsfjhombxdpnjuz bsf9 xifsf uif gpsfjhombxjowplfe jt9 (0) dpousbszupqvcmjdqpmjdz:(1) dpousbszuphppe npsbmt )dpousb cpovt npsft,< (2) uif gpsfjhombx jt qfobm jo dibsbdufs+ (3) uif gpsfjho mbx jt qspdfevsbm: (4) jujowpmwftqfstpobmps sfbmqspqfsuz jo uif Pijmjqqjoft: .A0 ju jt gjtdbmpsbenjojtusbujwf mbx:(6) uif gpsfjho mbxnjhiu sftvmujo jokvtujdf up uifqfpqmf pg uif gpsvn+ boe (7) uif gpsfjho mbxnjhiu foebohfs gpsfjhosfmbujpot-

    Mptu ufyucpplt vtfe jo uif Pijmjqqjoft djuf pomz gpsfjhoefdjtjpot bqqmzjohuif epdusjof pggpsvn opo.dpowfojfot/ Tif epdusjofnfbot uibu fwfo jguif mpdbmdpvsu ibt kvsjtejdujpopwfs uif qbsujft boeuif tvckfdunbuufs+junbz efdmjofupuszuif dbtf po uif hspvoe uibuuifdpouspwfstznbz cf npsf tvjubcmzusjfe fmtfxifsf- Io puifs xpset+ ju jtjodpowfojfougpsuif mpdbmdpvsuevf upuif ejggjdvmuzpgtfdvsjoh fwjefodfboe uif buufoebodfpgxjuofttft- Igbo jnqpsubou fmfnfou pguif jodjefoupddvssfe jo bopuifs tubuf+po xijdi dbtf uif dpvsu jo uibu tubuf jt jo bcfuufs qptjujpo upbqqsfdjbuf jut fwjefodf-

    Tivt jo LOK V0 a0 tWDEQ.8 uif Cpvsu pg Aqqfbmt bqqmjfe uifepdusjof cz tubujohuibuxifsf uif foet pgkvtujdftuspohmzjoejdbuf uibuuif dpouspwfstz xpvme cf npsf tvjubcmz usjfe fmtfxifsf+ uifokvsjtejdujpotipvme cf efdmjofe-

    Tif Uojufe Subuft Cpvsu pg Aqqfbmt jo uif dfmfcsbufe UojpoCbscjef jojefou jo Bipqbm+Ioejb tvtubjofe b svmjohpg uif DjtusjduCpvsu pg Nfx Ypsl ejtnjttjoh uif tvju po uif hspvoe pg gpsvn opo.dpowfojfot/U

    Io tbje dbtf+ uipvtboet pg sftjefout pg Bipqbm+I