Conquering Visibility, Conferring Visibility Daniel Dayan

7/27/2019 Conquering Visibility, Conferring Visibility Daniel Dayan

1/17

!"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'("1 2345678 9$,%$ 5615:6 5;6334569?@4443

.(AB%'CD# E 3456 2F&"'$) F&B&"8 G&B&"HG&"'$)3


2/17

56< F&"'$) F&B&" !"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567

!" $%&'()*+ ,-./0%)*+ 1%2%&%0%)*3 4(56 / 7/((/)%8' 59 1%:)%6%;/)%5(%8/)%50&%);%)0)?%1

XD$ "$W '"G'L'G,&) /&KK K$)-O0(//,"'0'(" 2.&K#$))K8 344


8/17

5ee F&"'$) F&B&" !"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567

/&B K$$/ Q,K#'-'$GH !" M(#D 0&K$K8 #D$ "$W L'K'M')'#B $"#%$A%$"$,%K &%$ D(A'"C -(% & G$M$ W'#D #D$

$K#&M)'KD$G /$G'& (" 2&7 #D$ ",%$ (- L'K'M')'#B &"G 2M7 #D$'% (W" $"#'#)$/$"# #( 0("-$%%'"C '#H


9/17

!"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567 .("^,$%'"C b'K'M')'#B8 .("-$%%'"C b'K'M')'#B 5e:

K#'A,)$G #D K,0D %'CD#K KD(,)G be denied to those who, in the name of good faith, challenge the

honor and reputation of information professionals. In other terms, no freedom of expression for those

WD( 0D&))$"C$ #D$ /&Q(% /$G'&H XD$ Q(,%"&)'K#K WD( K'C"$G #D'K A$#'#'(" W$%$ &AA&%$"#)B ,"&W&%$ #D #D$freedom of the press is nothing but an extension of the individual freedoms they wished to curb (ONeill,

344


10/17

5e= F&"'$) F&B&" !"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567

are used to justify it have changed. The felicity of history in deciding what is factual and what is not no

)("C$% G$A$"GK (" D'K /&Qestys wishes or whims but on the criteria of a discipline.

!" & W&B8 '# 'K #D$ K&/$ 'G$& #D JB(#&%G G$L$)(AK WD$" D$ W("G$%K &M(,# #D$ A%(0$KK #D%(,CD

which certain occurrences reach the status of shared facts. Through which mechanisms do they become

recognized, accepted as facts? Reality, writes Lyotard, is a status of the referent that results from the

$--$0#,'(" (- A%(0$G,%$K (- -&0#Oestablishment. Such procedures are defined by agreed protocols, and

#D$'% $--$0#,'(" 'K $"#%,K#$G #( KA$0'-'c institutions. These are factOproducing institutions (Lyotard,

5;


11/17

!"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567 .("^,$%'"C b'K'M')'#B8 .("-$%%'"C b'K'M')'#B 5e1

A('"# #( KD(W'"C K(/$#D'"CH S("K#%'L$ &0#'("K 0&" M$ 0("G,0#$G MB L$%M&) /$&"K8 L'K,&) /$&"K8 (% &

0(/M'"'(" (- M(#DH a$%$ 'K &" $`&/A)$H !# 0("0$%"K & .D()'0 )'#,%CB 0&))$G /("K#%'("H d"$ #&Y$K

A)&0$ $L$%B B$&% '" #D$ U&'"# h,$"#'" M&K')'0& '" "(%#D$%" 9%&"0$H

!" 5330("#$/A#c G$-$%$"0$>0D&))$"C$H XD'K %$KA("K$ 'K $'#D$% G'%$0#)B #D (- #D$

/$G'& #D$/K$)L$K (% #D (- #D'%G A&%#'$K WD(/ #D$ /$G'& ,K$ &K A%(`'$KH

V$%D&AK #D$ /(K# A(W$%-,) G$0'K'(" &L&')&M)$ #( #D$ /$G'& (- %$A%$K$"#'(" 2&K (AA(K$G #( #D$

/$G'& (- 0((%G'"'("7 0("K'K#K '" #D$ K'/A)$ &0# (- KD(W'"C (% "(# KD(W'"CH [B KD(W'"C &" $L$"#8 B(,

A%("(,"0$ #D'K $L$"# #( M$H [B "(# KD(W'"C '#8 B(, K#%'Y$ '# (,# (- $`'K#$"0$H XD$ -&0# (- "(# KD(W'"C

-,"0#'("K &K & K')$"0'"C W&))H !# /,--)$K %$A(%#K &"G A%$L$"#K G'K0,KK'("H N$WK /$G'& (-#$" ,K$ K,0D

K')$"0'"C W&))KH [,# #D$B &)K( %$)B (" /&C"'-B'"C C)&KK$KH

!/&C'"$ & /&A (- #D$ W(%)G '" WD'0D #D$ K'\$ (- 0(,"#%'$K (% 0("#'"$"#K 'K G$#$%/'"$G MB #D$&/(,"# (- /$G'& 0(L$%&C$H XD$ %$K,)# W(,)G M$ #$))'"C 2k&)#,"C T Z,C$8 5;=:7H d- 0(,%K$8 #D$ 0(,"#%'$K

WD(K$ /$G'& &%$ 0("0$%"$G W(,)G %$0$'L$ -,)) A(%#%&B&)KH [,# K(/$ (#D$% 0(,"#%'$K W(,)G M$ %$G,0$G #(

#D$ K'\$ (- A'"D$&GKH X'"B #$%%'#(%'$K W(,)G C%(W '"#( ,"'L$%K$KH gD()$ 0("#'"$"#K W(,)G G'K&AA$&%H @"

&%$& "( )&%C$% #D&" S$`'0( .'#B 2&" &%$& #D #D$ 9%$"0D /$G'& 0&)) V%(0D$Od%'$"#7 W(,)G )((/ )&%C$% #D&"


12/17

5e< F&"'$) F&B&" !"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567

& 0(,A)$ (- 0("#'"$"#KH k('"C -%(/ -&K#'G'(,K G$#&') #( &MK(),#$ '"L'K'M')'#B8 #D'K %&"C$ (- /("K#%'L$

A(KK'M')'#'$K /&"'-$K#K & -(%/ (- K(L$%$'C"&)/(K# G$/',%C'0A(W$%H ! W(,)G 0&)) '# #D$ A'&"(-(%#$

G'/$"K'(" (- /$G'&H @,K#'" W(,)G KA$&Y (- #D$ $`$%0'#'L$ %()$ (- #D$ /$G'&H U,0D $`$%0'#'L$K &%$ D&%G #(0D&))$"C$H @K (AA(K$G #( G'K'"-(%/'("8 WD'0D 0&" $L$"#,&))B M$ 0D&))$"C$G8 ,"'"-(%/'(" A%$$/A#K

G$M$H

R$# $`$%0'#'L$K &%$ "(# #D$ (")B /("K#%'L$ &0#K #D A%$$/A# G$M$H @)) /$G'& /("K#%'("K

0%$$ -&'#K &00(/A)'KH XD$B G( K( MB 257 &KK$%#'"C (% G$"B'"C #D$ $`'K#$"0$ (- C'L$" '"#$%&0#'("Kc 237

'/A(K'"C Q,GC/$"# (" #D$'% A%(#&C("'K#Kc &"G 267 G'KA)&B'"C %$KA$0# (% G'K%$KA$0# #(W&%G #D$/H

! K,CC$K# #D &G(A#'"C & L(0&M,)&%B (- /("K#%'(" %D$% #D&" ("$ (- '"-(%/'(" &))(WK -(% &

M$##$% &"G /(%$ &00,%$ G$K0%'A#'(" (- WD "$WK /$G'& G(H XD'K G($K "(# /$&" C'L'"C ,A (" #D$ %()$ (-

"$WK /$G'& '" A%(L'G'"C '"-(%/'("H [,# #D'K /$&"K #D '"-(%/'(" 'K (")B ("$ $)$/$"# '" & )&%C$%

A'0#,%$c #D "$WK '#$/K 0&""(# /$%$)B M$ G$-'"$G '" #$%/K (- A%(A(K'#'("&) 0("#$"#KH

U,0D 0("#$"#K G( $`'K#8 M,# #D$B &%$ K(/$#'/$K "( /(%$ #D&" A%$#$`#K -(% %$0,%%'"C C$K#,%$KH

XD$ /("K#%'("K (--$%$G #( #D$ A,M)'0 &%$ 0D'/$%&K (- K(%#KH XD$B 0(/M'"$ /$#("B/'0 %$A%$K$"#'("K (-

K'#,'("K W'#D & L&%'$#B (- KA$$0D &0#K #D%(,CD WD'0D K'#,'("K &%$ &KK$%#$G8 &0#'("K Q,GC$G8 &"G #D$'%

A%(#&C("'K#K %$KA("G$G #(H !" (#D$% #$%/K8 #D$ 0("K#'L$ G'/$"K'(" (- /$G'& '/&C$K &)W&BK %$&0D$K ,K

W%&AA$G ,A '" C$K#,%$KH XD'K 'K8 '" & W&B8 WD +,G'#D [,#)$% K&BK '" %$)'(" #( #D$ W(%Y (- U,K&" U("#&C8

WD$" KD$ K#%$KK$K #D '"#$%A%$#'"C & AD(#(C%&AD 'K '"#$%A%$#'"C WD &)%$&GB 0("K#'#,#$K &"

'"#$%A%$#'("H53d%8 #( ^,(#$ Z&G0)'--$O[%(W"8 #D$re is a ritual relationship whenever a society imposes its

members a given attitude towards a given object (Radcliffe O[%(W"8 5;:37H !" #D K$"K$8 /$G'&

0("K#&"#)B A$%-(%/ %'#,&)KH56

53 XD$%$ $`'K#K & "(%/'L$ (MQ$0#'(" #( &G(A#'"C & A$%-(%/'L$ A&%&G'C/H @M&"G("'"C & 0("K#'L$

/(G$) (- /$G'& G'K0(,%K$ W(,)G M$ &" $"G(%K$/$"# (- A(K#/(G$%" %$)'L'K/ &"G %$"G$% A('"#)$KK

^,$K#'("K K,0D &K #D (- /$G'& #%,#D-,)"$KK (% &00,%&0BH !K #D$ L(0&M,)&%B (- A$%-(%/&"0$ %$&))B

'"0(/A'M)$ W'#D #D$ A(KK'M')ity of evaluation? Following Ricoeurs (2006) critique of Hayden White and

D'K $KK&BK (" #D$ &%# (- #D$ #%&"K)(%8 ! M$)'$L$ #D -&% -%(/ A%$L$"#'"C $L&),'(" &"G A%(/(#'"C

%$)'L'K/8 #D$ &G(A#'(" (- & A$%-(%/'L$ A&%&G'C/ #,%"K (,# #( M$ & 0("G'#'(" -(% $L&),'("H J'Y$

$#D"(C%&AD$%K8 %$A$%#(%B #D$$% G'%$0#(%K8 (% A'&"( A)&B$%K8 Q(,%"&)'K#K &%$ 0,)#,%&) #%&"K)(%KH XD$'%

monstrations translate the attitudes, knowledge, and concerns of one speech community into H H H

,"G$%K#&"G&M)$ #$%/K -(% &"(#Der community (Carey, 1997). Fragments of behaviors are recorded and

,K$G &K M,')G'"C M)(0YK -(% #D$ 0("K#%,0#'(" (- &00$A#&M)$ K'/,)&0%&H dML'(,K)B8 #D$ W(%G )((0;%)7*0 'K "(

)$KK $KK$"#'&) D$%$ #D&" #D$ W(%G $#.2*)(')>@00$A#&M)$ /$&"K #D "(# &)) K'/,)&0%& &%$ $^,'L&)$"#H [,#8

'"#$%$K#'"C)B8 &00$A#&M)$ G($K "(# /$&" A$%-$0#H @K Z'0($,% A,#K '#8 "( #%&"K)'(" 'K $L$% A$%-$0#H XD'K 'K

WDB #D$ K&/$ #$`#K Y$$A M$'"C #%&"K)$G &"G #%&"K)$G &C&'"H R$# #D$%$ &%$ #%&"K)'("K #D &%$ M$##$%

(% W(%K$8 %'0D$% (% A((%$%8 /(%$ %$)$L&"# (% )$KK %$)$L&"#8 /(%$ 0(/A%$D$"K'L$ (% )$KK 0(/A%$D$"K'L$HJ'Y$ &)) (#D$% A$%-(%/&"0$K8 /("K#%'L$ A$%-(%/&"0$K 0&" M$ Q,GC$GH56.&" K,0D %'#,&)K M$ %$K'K#$G] U#%$KK'"C #D$ A$%-(%/'L$ A(W$% (- #D$ /$G'& K$$/K #( $"#&') & L'$W (-

/$G'& $--$0#K #D /&Y$K K,0D $--$0#K "(# (")B A(W$%-,) M,# '%%$K'K#'M)$H XD%(,CD #D$'% /("K#%'L$ &0#K8

#D$ /$G'& W(,)G '%%$K'K#'M)B A$%-(%/ (,% #'#,G$K #(W&%G #D$ G'KA)&B$G K'#,'("KH XD'K G($K "(# "$$G #(


13/17

!"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567 .("^,$%'"C b'K'M')'#B8 .("-$%%'"C b'K'M')'#B 5e;

!!!" A< )B' 40/85( 59 CB%2 ,22/*

9%'$"GK WD( %$&G &" $&%)'$% G%&-# (- #D'K $KK&B -$)# #D #D$ -)&L(% (- '#K -'%K# A&%# K,CC$K#$G &

negative attitude toward those who seek visibility. Me, I want to hear from the cheap seats! wrote one

(- /B %$&G$%KH XD'K /$&"K ! "$$G #( 0)&%'-B /B A(K'#'("8 K'"0$ ! W&"# #( D$&% -%(/ #D$ 0D$&A K$K8 #((H

SB G$K0%'A#'(" (- #D$ 0("^,$K# (- L'K'M')'#B '"L()L$G /&"B $`&/A)$K #D W$%$ C%(#$K^,$8

AD()(C'0&)8 (% -%'CD#$"'"CH SB A('"# '" G$K0%'M'"C #D$/ W&K "$'#D$% #( (--$% A'0#,%$K^,$ L'C"$##$K8 "(% #(

G$/$&" #D$ 0("0$%"K (- #D$ L'K'M')'#B K$$Y$%KH X( #D$ 0("#%&%B8 ! /$&"# #( K#%$KK #D$ G$KA$%$ '"#$"K'#B (-

& ^,$K# WD(K$ (#D$%8 /')G$% $`A%$KK'("K &%$ '"0%$&K'"C)B M&"&)8 (%G'"&%B8 W'G$KA%$&GH

XD$ ^,$K# ! D&L$ G$K0%'M$G 0,)/'"$K W'#D #D$ $/$%C$"0$ (- #D(K$ WD( #%B #( C&'" &00$KK #( #D$

%'CD# (- 0("-$%%'"C L'K'M')'#Bc #D(K$ ! 0&)) L'K'M')'#B $"#%$A%$"$,%KH [B #D$'% L$%B $`'K#$"0$8 L'K'M')'#B

entrepreneurs challenge the privileges enjoyed by the major media as factuality producing institutions2JB(#&%G8 5;


14/17

5:4 F&"'$) F&B&" !"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567

testifying takes place but is deprived of authority (Lyotard, 1988, pH :7H XD,K8 0$%#&'" K#$/$"#K 0&" M$

/&G$8 B$# 0&""(# M$ D$&%GH !" & G'--$%$"G8 what suffe%K8 WD 'K $À(K$G #( #D%$K8 'K $À%$KK'(" (%

expressivity itself (F,""8 5;;68 AH 3457H !" (#D$% #$%/K8 #D$ L$%B $`'K#$"0$ (- G'--$%$"GK 'K #D$ KB/A#(/(- & G$/(0%'0 G$-'0'#H

XD'K &%#'0)$ D&K M$$" )&%C$)B '"KA'%$G MB /B &W&%$"$KK (- G'--$%$"GK (AA(K'"C /&Q(% /$G'& #( #D$

)&BA$%K("K ! 0&)) L'K'M')'#B $"#%$A%$"$,%KH !" #D$ )'#'C'(" G'K0,KK$G $&%)'$%8 #D$ )&"C,&C$ (- '"-(%/'("

W&K ,K$G MB #D$ -(%/$% &K & /$&"K (- -(%0'"C #D$ )#$% '"#( K')$"0$H b'K'M')'#B $"#%$A%$"$,%K 0(,)G &)'C"

&%C,/$"#K #D W$%$ K()'G $"(,CD #( D()G '" 0(,%#H R$# #D$ A$#'#'(" #D $"K,$G /$&"# #( G$A%'L$ #D$K$

&%C,/$"#K (- &"B &,#D(%'#BH

Lyotard wrote that philosophy often consists in giving the differend its due, of allowing for the

W%("C #( -'"G &" $À%$KK'("8 -(% #D$ L'0#'/ #( #,%" '"#( &" (%G'"&%B A)&'"#'--H XD'K KD(,)G "(# 0("0$%"

AD')(K(ADB (")BH ! D&L$ M$$" ,K'"C #D$ $`'K#$"0$ (- G'--$%$"GK &K & 0(/A&KK A('"#'"C #( WD &KA$0#K (-

#D$ /$G'& "$$G #( M$ K#,G'$GH gD$%$ #D$B "$$G #( M$ K#,G'$G 'K WD$%$ '# D,%#KH XD,K8 /B K,CC$K#'(" (-/(L'"C -%(/ #D$ )&"C,&C$ (- #+3&'.)%#&+ #( #D$ )&"C,&C$ (- .&+$%')%#&+ 'K &)K( &" #$/A# '"#$%-$%'"C

W'#D & K')$"0'"C A%(0$KKH

XD'K /$&"K #D #D$ #W( "&%%'L$K ! D&L$ A%(A(K$G '" #D'K &%#'0)$ &%$ "(# K'/A)B #W( G'--$%$"#

K#(%'$K #D ! Q,`#&A(K$GH SB #W( "&%%'L$K &%$ A&%# (- #D$ K&/$ K#(%BH gD #D$ )&"C,&C$ (- /("K#%'("

&))(WK 'K &G(A#'"C & G$-'"'#'(" (- & -'$)G '" WD'0D $K#&M)'KD$G A)&B$%K &"G "("$K#&M)'KD$G A)&B$%K

'"K#'#,#'("&) /$G'& &"G K$)-O&AA('"#$G L'K'M')'#B $"#%$A%$"$,%K0&" M$ 0(/A&%$G '"K#$&G (- #D$ K$0("G

C%(,A M$'"C K,//&%')B G'K/'KK$GH5e

XD$ )&"C,&C$ (- '"-(%/'(" $"#%&AA$G #D$ )&B L'K'M')'#B /&Y$%K (" #D$ W%("C K'G$ (- & G'--$%$"GH

How dare you speak of information? said the established media to citizens who protes#$G #D$ /$G'&

displays. Information is something you know very little about and that you are not capable of providing.R(, D&L$ "$'#D$% #D$ Y"(WOhow nor the logistical infrastructure at your disposal. To this, our

0("#$/A(%&%B A&%#$%%$ /$/M$%K8 #D$ ,"'"vited performers of visibility, might reply: Information is what

B(, 0)&'/ B(, &%$ G('"C8 M,# #D'K "(# %$&))B #D$ 0&K$H !" -&0#8 B(, &%$ )'Y$ ,KH gD B(, (--$% &%$

5eXD$ /$G'& -'$)G 0&" M$ -,%#D$% ,"'-'$GH J((Y -'0#'("H @%C,/$"#'L$ &AA%(&0D$K #( -')/ /&%Y$G)B G'--$%

'" -(,% W&BK -%(/ #D(K$ '"-),$"0$G MB :&0%#($P 257 XD$B &%$ "(# $"#%&AA$G '"#( & 0("0$A#'(" (- #D$ W(%Y &K

& KBK#$/'0 WD()$c #D$B /&B &K W$)) -(0,K (" #D$ -%&C/$"#H 237 XD$B &%$ "(# $`0),K'L$)B )((Y'"C -(%

#$`#,&) K'C"'-'0'("K M,# &)K( &GG%$KK &0#,&) K'#,'("K '" #D$ %$&) W(%)GH 267 Z$-$%$"#K &%$ "( )("C$%

(M)'#$%$G (% #,%"$G '"#( #D$ K'C"'-'$GK (- &" &,#("(/(,K G'K0,%K'L$ W(%)GH 2e7 UA$0#(%K &%$ "(#

0("0$'L$G &K C%$-,) M$"$-'0'&%'$K (- & K,' C$"$%'K W(%)G 0%$$G MB & G$/',%C'0 -'C,%$H XD$B &%$ K$$G

K'G$ MB K'G$ W'#D #D$ -')//&Y$%8 -&0'"C #D$ K&/$ K(0'&) %$&)'#'$KH !" (#D$% #$%/K8 #D$ &%C,/$"#'L$ (%%D$#(%'0&) &AA%(&0D &GL(0$G MB k,'))&,/$ U(,)$\ 23455c .D&)L("8 34557 )$&GK #( K,KA$"G'"C #D$ %'C'G

G'K#'"0#'(" M$#W$$" '/&C$K (- %$&)'#B &"G '/&C$K (- -'0#'("H [(#D K$#K (- '/&C$K &%$ K$$" &K -(%/K (-

/("K#%'("H


15/17

!"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567 .("^,$%'"C b'K'M')'#B8 .("-$%%'"C b'K'M')'#B 5:5

/("K#%'("KH U,0D /("K#%'("K /&B (% /&B "(# '"L()L$ '"-(%/'("H R$# #D$B &%$ A%("(,"0'"C

factuality!

XD$ ,"'"L'#$G A$%-(%/$%K &%$ #D,K &KY'"C WD ! M$)'$L$ 'K &" $KK$"#'&) ^,$K#'("P f"G$% WD

0("G'#'("K &%$ /("K#%'("K 0&A&M)$ (- -$)'0'#(,K)B A%("(,"0'"C -&0#,&)'#B] !K '# & /#$% (- WD 'K

A%(L'G$G] d% 'K '#8 (" #D$ 0("#%&%B8 & /#$% (- WD '"K#'#,#'(" 'K A%(L'G'"C '#] !K '# & /#$% (-

&K0$%#&'"'"C %$&)'#B] !K '# & /#$% (- A$%-(%/'L$ A%("(,"0$/$"#] XD$ /&KK'L$ $/$%C$"0$ (- ,"'"L'#$G

L'K'M')'#B $"#%$A%$"$,%K '"L'#$K ,K #( )((Y 0)(K$% #D$ #&,#()(CB &00(%G'"C #( WD'0D '"-(%/'(" 'K WD #D$

'"-(%/'(" /$G'& G(H !# 0&))K -(% & -%$KD #D$(%'\'"C (- WD Q(,%"&)'K/ &K & -&0#OA%(G,0'"C -&0#(%B 'K

&M(,#H


16/17

5:3 F&"'$) F&B&" !"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567

D'9'('K(0'$#$>&%#'0)$>3453>41>4;>0$O^,O&OG'#O/(D&/$GO/$%&DO&,`O

"$C(0'$,%Ko5164;14o633eHD#/)

[%(/M$%C$%8 .H 25;;:7H Le match de football, ethnologie dune passion partisanenXD$ K(00$% /DP

?#D"(C%&ADB (- & A&%#'K&" A&KK'("mH V&%'K8 9%&"0$P SUaH

[i0D$%8 XH 234557H X$0D"'0'#B (- #$"#'("P .("K#%,0#'"C #$"#'(" '" K(0'&) "$#W(%Y'"C K'#$KH V%$K$"#'("

#D$ U$/'"&% 0("G,0#$G MB FH F&B&" #D$ f"'L$%K'#B (- dK)(8 N(%W&BH

.&/A()(8 @H 2UA%'"C8 34557H S("K#$%K '" #D$ A&%YP ?`#%$/'K# -((#M&)) A,M)'0K &"G /$G'& L'K'M')'#BH F0,#)

D#$#7#*#%8H U$/'"&% 0("G,0#$G MB FH F&B&" #D$ N$W U0D(() -(% U(0'&) Z$K$&%0D8 N$W R(%Y8 NRH

.&%$B8 +H 25;


17/17

!"#$%"'("&) +(,%"&) (- .(//,"'0'(" 1 234567 .("^,$%'"C b'K'M')'#B8 .("-$%%'"C b'K'M')'#B 5:6

a(""$#D8 @H 2344:7H Invisibilit: Sur lpistmologie de la reconnaissance [!"L'K'M')'#BP d" #D$

epistemology of %ecognitionmH ZjK$&,`8 KR253;5647H

+$"K$"8 _H [H8 T N$,/&"8 gH ZH 234557H !"#%(G,0#(%B )$0#,%$ #( #D$ Copenhagen symposium Voices from

?,%(A$H University of Copenhagen8 U$A#$/M$% 3455H

JB(#&%G8 +H 9H 25;

Documents

Conquering Visibility, Conferring Visibility Daniel Dayan