Creating & Managingdesirable online

communitiesJessamyn West - MetaFilter

<librarian.net/talks/mixmedias>

@jessamyn

numbers

purpose

"Have a very clear picture of

what you want to get out of

the community before you

design it. Not every site needs

comment sections, not every

product needs a forum."

•Support for products/services?

•Brand identity?

•Clicks/Eyeballs?

•Customers for other products?

•Value-add for existing customers?

What are you doing?

staffing

"You can't just add a comment

section, nominate a moderator,

and have an instant community...

An insufficiently-staffed

comment section is worse than

nothing."

Specifically

•Real humans, round the clock

•Dedicated to moderation/facilitation

•With tools and social skills

•Deputized to actually fix things

•And Pay Them

personality

"Every community will have

unreasonable people in it, but the

folks in charge of keeping things in

check need to not stir things up

instead. Hire peacekeepers, not

warriors."

moderator manifesto

•Mods are users, not just mods.

•Never score points at the expense of a user.

•Never lose your cool.

•Have each other's backs but don't "thin blue line" it.

•Be consistent but acknowledge mistakes.

policies

"Rules need to be consistent

and explicable, not

necessarily

detailed. Put legal/policy

issues

in specific terms and

behavioral issues in general

ones."

levels of problematic

•Illegal (in your jurisdiction?)

•Immoral/ethically dubious (porn, warez, hacking)

•Will get you banned (or banned4lyfe)

•Will get you the night off (drunks)

•"Hey man not cool" (allowed, not totally ok)

•"We really don't have a problem with that"

specific concerns•Suicidal people/deaths

•Ironic "I was just kidding" racist/sexist/homophobic commenters

•Threats against the site or members

•NSFW/triggers/spoilers/blinking?

•Unpopular opinions

•Trolling/stunts

tech

"Custom tools that streamline our

process have saved us heaps of

time and allows us to moderate a

large site with a small staff."

deleted

who is flagging and why

user

details

"Often users can handle some

level of moderation as long as

they feel it's fair and they are

being understood."

track publicly

•Usernames = accountability

•User activity/contributions

•Who is in charge

•Methods of redress

track privately

•IP addresses

•Name changes, if allowed

•History of user actions

•History of moderator actions

•History of moderator actions by user

homegrown

solutions

merci * thank

you<librarian.net/talks/mixmedias>