31
Doing Learning: Investigative Reporting and Service Learning CRAIG FLOURNOY This study examines four classes of college students involved in service learn ing projects. Each class researched and wrote an investigative story that was published. The majority of students said they believe the projects provided them with the skills required for investigative reporting, increased their motiva tion to stud y, and enhanced their desire to make a positive difference in their community. The projects also prompted two foundations to award $150,000 in grant money to support similar work in the future. The study suggests that investigative reporting provides a viable approach for service learning. Service learning, a university organized, hands-on form of study that benefits a community and promotes civic responsibility, is increasingly being incorporated by educators into their curriculum. The National Survey of Student Engagement found that between 2000 and 2005, the percent age of college seniors who participated in service learning rose 22%. 1 Service learning provides many benefits in cluding making teaching more enjoy able and increasing student perform ance in the classroom and interest in society. 2 Some communication programs have made extensive use of service

Doing Learning

  • Upload
    jcfsd

  • View
    15

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Doing Learning

Doing Learning: Investigative Reporting and Service LearningCRAIG FLOURNOY

This study examines four classes of college students involved in service learn ing projects. Each class researched and wrote an investigative story that was published. The majority of students said they believe the projects providedthem with the skills required for investigative reporting, increased their motiva tion to stud y, and enhanced their desire to make a positive difference in their community. The projects also prompted two foundations to award $150,000 in grant money to support similar work in the future. The study suggests that investigative reporting provides a viable approach for service learning.

Service learning, a universityorganized, hands-on form of study that benefits a community and promotes civic responsibility, is increasingly being incorporated by educators into their curriculum. The National Survey of Student Engagement found that between 2000 and 2005, the percent age of college seniors who participated in service learning rose 22%.1 Service learning provides many benefits in cluding making teaching more enjoyable and increasing student perform ance in the classroom and interest in society.2

Some communication programs have made extensive use of service

learning. The majority of journalism and mass communication departments at 190 universities incorporated serv ice learning into the curriculum; pub lic relations and media production and design were the courses most likely to include service learning.3 This study used a different approach: to deter mine if investigative reporting offers a viable approach for service learning, motivating students to become more involved in the classroom and in their community.

Literature ReviewThis study uses an operational

definition of service learning that has

Craig Flournoy (CFWURNO@M AIL.SMU.EDU ) is assistant professor, Division of Journal ism, Meadows School of the Arts, Southern Methodist University.

47 'SPRING '07

Page 2: Doing Learning

been adopted by the American Association of Higher Education. Service learning means a method under which students learn and develop a thoughtfully organized service that is conducted in and meets the needs of a community; is coordinated with an institute of higher education and with the community; helps foster civic responsibility; is integrated into and enhances the curriculum; and includes structured time for the stu dents to reflect on the experience. Thiscase study examines four classes designed to meet this definition.4 Eachincluded an investigative project that addressed a community need, was designed to promote civic responsibili ty, and included structured time for students to assess the service learning experience.

Studies of service learning find nu merous benefits. One examined two undergraduate ethics classes and foundthat the experience increased the stu dents' moral reasoning. 5 Another foundthat the majority of students in an undergraduate class studying organiza tional development said the experience increased their commitment to social service.6 A 2005 study examined a class of high school students who pro duced three public service announce ments and found that they developed the skills to work independently. 7

Other studies have found that serv ice learning was less successful. An examination of eight communication classes found that most students said the service learning component did not increase their motivation to attend class or to study harder.8 A study of220 students enrolled in a mass com

munication introductory course found that fewer than one in three said the service learning aspect taught them

JOURNALISM & MASS COMMUNICATION EDUCATOR 48

more about the subject matter than their other assignments.9

Investigative reporting is original work produced by a reporter using information that others are attempting to keep hidden and that is important tothe public. 10 Scholarly literature exam ining the subject is thin.11 This is particularly true of investigative reporting as service learning.12 Part of the reasonfor this may be that service learning has been executed in a manner that has little in common with investigative reporting. In a traditional service learn ing project, students team with a com munity partner and provide a service such as writing press releases, issuing brochures, or producing public service announcements. In addition, no one is attempting to hide the information.

Nevertheless, an investigative reporting project, properly directed, provides a format that makes it particular ly appropriate for service learning. Each approach attempts to inform the public about a social problem. Each also seeks to prompt authorities to address the problem being highlighted, thus helping the community and fostering the students' sense of civic responsibility. More generally, political theorists, media scholars, and journal ism historians have long stressed that journalism is the linchpin of democracy because it provides citizens with the information needed to make informeddecisions. 13 Investigative reportershave exposed abuses that led to reforms in virtually every area of socie ty.14 In the classic 1956 work Four Theories of the Press, scholars who examined the press in democratic set tings contend that only journalism can provide the check on governmentalabuse essential in a democracy. 15 Morerecently, journalism historian James

Page 3: Doing Learning

Carey argued that the two are insepara ble. In his words, "Without journalism there is no democracy, but without democracy, there is no journalism either."16

Service learning, in turn, offers valuable assistance to investigative reporting as taught in the classroom. In many investigative reporting classes, each student reports and writes several individual stories during a semester. Stories may or may not address a social problem. Resources available to indi vidual students to research each story are severely limited. And there is sel dom time for the students to reflect on the learning experience. However, in the investigative projects examined here, each class would identify a social problem, research and write a story, and reflect on the experience. Having more than a dozen students spend up to a full semester focused on one story meant a more in-depth investigation, an increased chance of publication, and a greater likelihood that change would result. Publishing the story is essential to the service learning aspect because only then will the community be made aware of the problem and possibly take corrective action.

This study's research questionsare:

RQ1: How can investiga tive reporting be used to teach service learning?

RQZ: What are student attitudes toward investigative reporting as service learning?

To explore the first question, serv ice learning was incorporated into four classes: three undergraduate classes at a private university in the Southwest

and one graduate class at a public university. In each class, the students spent part or all of the semester work

ing on an investigative story. To emphasize the service learning aspect, the researcher urged students to inves

tigate a social problem afflicting the conimunity and provided structured time for the students to reflect on the experience. To address the second question, students were asked by the researcher at the conclusion of each project if they believed that combining service learning and investigative

reporting helped them master the skills necessary to do investigative

reporting, increased their motivation to study, and enhanced their desire

to make a positive difference in their community.

Skill mastery means that a student has the knowledge and skills to work independently.17 With this in mind, the researcher provided students with an investigative assignment that chal lenged them to take responsibility for the pro ject. Motivating students to learn means enhancing their desire to gain knowledge. 18 At least one scholar has suggested that students are apt to be motivated when they view their work as meaningful. 19 The researcher selected topics to investigate with all of this in mind. Enhancing the desire of students to make a positive differ ence in the community means promot ing a student's passion to produce social change.20 Also known as civic responsibility or civic engagement, it has been included in the strategic agenda of virtually every national higher education association. 21 A proj ect that enhances civic responsibility promotes the public-service mission of higher education. 22 The topics for investigation also were chosen with this in mind.

49 SPRING '07

Page 4: Doing Learning

Method

Forty-three students were involved in the investigative projects. Nine were working on master's degrees in journal ism; they ranged in age from 22 to 26. Thirty-four undergraduates included twenty seniors and fourteen juniors; twenty-nine of these students were 20 or 21 years of age. More than 80% of the students were female. All were journalism majors.

The students tackled three inves tigative projects. In the spring of 2004, thirteen students in an investigative reporting class examined the largest illegal landfill in Texas. In the fall of 2004, six undergraduate students and nine graduate students investigated violent crime and security at approxi mately 100 college campuses in Texas. In the spring of 2005, fifteen students in an investigative reporting class examined living conditions, crime, and management at the nation's largest pri vate dormitory on a college campus. Many scholars who have researched service learning have devoted relative ly little attention to the details of those projects. Several described what the students did in a few paragraphs. 23

This study examines each assignment in some depth in an attempt to deter mine what went right, what went wrong, and why.

The students were given surveys at the beginning and at the conclusion of each project. In their open-ended com ments at the beginning of the projects, six students said they were worried that no story would result. One gradu ate student asked, "What if we don't uncover anything?" Ten questioned whether they were prepared to do the research and writing required for an

fOURNALISM & MASS COMMUNICATION EDUCATOR 50

enterprise project. Five wondered if they would get their work published. As it turned out, each class uncovered an important story that was published. Two stories led to significant changes in public policy.

In many service learning projects, students partner with a community organization which assigns them a task. Since these projects involved investigative stories, the students partnered with a newspaper and chose a subject that was a community concern. Each class met with an editor and dis cussed possible stories. This provided several benefits. It created a more real world environment and helped get the stories published. In addition, the Texas Freedom of Information Foun dation, a private, non-profit group, agreed to provide free legal assistance in matters regarding requests for public records. Attorneys affiliated with the foundation agreed to advise students preparing requests for records and to help draft responses when agencies denied access to records or charged exorbitant amounts for copies.24

Students began investigating the landfill after a nearby homeowner con tacted the researcher and complained that city officials for years had ignored requests from neighborhood residents, who were African American, to shut down the landfill. Finding something new was not easy. The landfill had been built twenty years ago. Even tually, the students found that city offi cials-who claimed to have fought the landfill-actually contributed to the problem by allowing city demolition crews to dump waste materials there. In March 2004, the students published "Garbage In, Misery Out," a 5,000-word story in an alternative weekly newspa per.25

The story showed that for years,

Page 5: Doing Learning

officials allowed the operators of an illegal landfill to destroy an African American, working-class neighborhood in violation of state and federal law.

For this first project, the re searcher divided the class into teams and assigned areas of responsibility: environmental problems, governmental enforcement, and impact on the neighborhood. The researcher alsb cre ated a master list of assignments and reviewed this with the students week ly. This allowed the students to see what they were doing in relation to the rest of the class. However, assigning tasks to teams rather than individuals may not have been the best approach. It meant some team members did much of the work while others did little. It also made it difficult to hold students accountable. The class put together the landfill story in six weeks.

A new group of students launched their project after a member of the board of directors of the Texas Freedom of Information Foundation suggested that they investigate crime on college campuses in Texas. This second project presented a different set of challenges. First, the subject had received relatively little attention. Second, the project involved the col laboration of two universities-nine graduate students from one university and six undergraduate students from another. Students were divided into teams but tasks were assigned to individuals. The students began by con structing a database of crime statistics for some 100 universities.

Initially, the students thought the story would focus on the campuses with the highest rates of violent crime. However, two students suggested examining campus police performance

in reporting crime to the student body. Federal law requires that universities publish crime logs and issue alerts, warning students of dangerous situa tions. The students obtained this information and compared it with the criminal offense reports for each university. From this, they developed a powerful story: police at many universities often failed to report violent crime to stu dents in violation of federal law. In December 2004, the students published "Insecurity on Campus," a 6,000-word story in an alternative weekly newspaper. 26 It took the stu dents the entire semester to put togeth er this story.

The third project also evolved into something different than what was envisioned initially. A student who worked on the "Insecurity on Campus" story suggested taking a closer look at one public university. A new class learned that four students had recently reported being raped at the Waterview Park Apartments, a privately owned dormitory with 1,200 apartments on that university's campus. The class dis covered that ten rapes had been reported at Waterview over three years but police failed to issue alerts after eight of these. The story appeared to be largely a repeat of the "Insecurity on Campus" story. The students discov ered otherwise.

The students interviewed Water view residents and found many living in abysmal conditions: broken toilets, black mold, and leaking ceilings. University officials refused to turn over Waterview's financial records. However, the developer who built the corriplex agreed to an interview. He said his company had cleared $10 mil lion in profits on Waterview. This pro vided the final piece of the puzzle:

51 SPRING '07

Page 6: Doing Learning

while the students suffered, the devel oper made millions. In April 2005, the students published the "Dorm from Hell," a 5,000-word story in an alterna tive newspaper.27 The story examined the nation's largest private dormitory and revealed that for many students, life was a nightmare of substandard liv ing conditions, poor maintenance, violent crime, and inadequate security. The students spent the full semester working on the story.

The writing portion was challeng ing given the relatively large number of students on each project and the com plexity of the stories. Some instructors have dealt with this by doing their own writing. That is the route chosen by David Protess at Northwestern Univer sity. For years, Protess has had students investigate cases involving persons who may have been wrongfully convicted of crimes. Those stories have helped free eight prisoners. 28 However,Protess's students only do the report ing; they do not write stories for publi cation.29 At other universities, students write or help write the investigative projects. That is the approach at Point Park University and its Innocence Institute. Students' stories, all pub lished in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, have been partially to entirely respon sible for the reversal of ten convictions ranging from armed robbery to capital murder since August 2001. Students learn how to write a sophisticated story, says Bill Moushey, Innocence Institute executive director and Point Park associate professor of journalism and mass communication. "Learning towrite complex stories also helps the students to get jobs," he said.30

The students in these projects (whether called service learning or not, they are) also believed it was important

JOURNALISM & MASS COMMUNICATION EDUCATOR 52

to report and write the stories. On each project, two students from each team wrote. The researcher then met with the writers and helped edit their sec tions and combine the parts into a whole. Each story was sent to the news paper editor who suggested revisions. Each of the twenty-two students who served as writers said this was an indis pensable part of the learning process. "We're journalists and that means we have to write for a living," said one writer of the "Dorm from Hell" story. "Without having to write what we found, we would miss the link between research and the final product."

This comment, like the others, came from surveys completed by the students. The surveys asked for demo graphic information including age, gen der, year in school, and major. The sur veys included the three research ques tions; students were to answer "yes" or "no" to each and to explain why. Other questions were included to allow thestudents to reflect on their work, an essential aspect of service learning. 31

Grading each student's work involved answering several questions. Did the student meet deadlines? What was the quality of the work? Were there errors?Did the student do more than he or she was asked to do?32 In virtually everycase, the answer to this last question was "yes." The best evidence of this was the work by the six undergraduates on the "Insecurity on Campus" story. All were volunteers who got no aca demic credit for their work. Each devoted at least fifty hours to the project during the semester.

Service learning should promote civic engagement. These stories, which focused primarily on social problems, were designed to accomplish this. 1\vo, the "Insecurity on Campus" story and

Page 7: Doing Learning

the "Dorm from Hell" article, led to sig nificant reforms. In their open-ended comments, ten students said these changes represented their most signifi cant accomplishment in college. "Our story forced officials to address hor rible conditions they'd ignored for years," wrote a junior who worked on the "Dorm from Hell" story. "I was amazed to find that I could actually make a difference in people's lives."

Cases Study Results

This study suggests that investiga tive reporting provides a viable approach for service learning. The study also found that the majority of students who participated in these projects said they believe investigative reporting and service learning helped them master the skills necessary for investigative reporting, increased their motivation to study harder, and enhanced their desire to make a posi tive difference in their community.

According to the surveys, all fortythree students who participated said they believe the projects helped them master the skills necessary to do inves tigative reporting. "It takes guts and stamina to deal with sticky situations that people do not want to talk about," said a senior who worked on the "Insecurity on Campus" story. "You cannot learn guts in a classroom lec ture." Approximately two-thirds of the students said they believe the enter prise stories increased their motivation to study. Almost three-quarters of the students said they believe the projects enhanced their desire to make a posi tive difference in their community.

The results are striking given that almost three-quarters of the students said they had never worked on an

enterprise project. In their open-ended comments at the inception and at the conclusion of the projects, students expressed a variety of concerns. At the beginning, nine questioned whether the persons they were to interview would take them seriously. At the conclusion, seven said the researcher did not clearly define their roles. Six said the story required them to spend an inordinate amount of time working outside the classroom. A 21-year-old journalism major said the demands of the landfill story could be overwhelm ing. "In order to do a story like this, you need to be available twelve hours a day," she said.

Nevertheless, all of the students surveyed said they believed the proj ects were an effective way of teaching investigative reporting. A graduate stu dent who worked on the "Insecurity on Campus" story said this was due largely to the nature of the assignment. "I am almost finished with my second journalism degree, and I have never had this kind of hands-on experience," the student said. "I learned about how to actually be a reporter. "33

In their open-ended comments, ten students said the project was their most important learning experience in college. These students said they learned a variety of lessons ranging from challenging officials who refused to turn over records to using a database to make sense of a wealth of statistics. "This class put theory into action," said a 20-year-old senior journalism major who worked on the "Dorm from Hell" story. "Lecture notes get thrown away at the end of the semester. But it's hard to get rid of calluses from our handiwork."

Almost two of every three students surveyed said they believed the enter-

53 SPRING '07

Page 8: Doing Learning

prise stories increased their motivation to study. Of those who answered "no," almost half said their desire to study came from within. But the majority of those who answered "yes" said a chal lenging assignment with real conse quences pushed them to perform at a higher level. "I knew we were in a unique situation that shouldn't be taken for granted," said a graduate stu dent who worked on the "Insecurity on Campus" story. "This assignment made me want to work harder to become a good journalist."

Slightly more than seven of every ten students said they believed the projects enhanced their desire to make a positive difference in their communi ty. The majority of these students said the topic increased their determination to correct the problem. "I like the fact that we are working on something that serves a real purpose in Dallas," said a print journalism senior who worked on the illegal landfill story. "We're uncov ering important information and facts that people otherwise would not know about-and that's gratifying."

Results of these projects suggest that an instructor who plans to use investigative reporting to teach service learning should follow certain steps to enhance the likelihood of success. The most important is to find a public serv ice project that will challenge the stu dents and provide a service to the com munity. Avoid the meat grinder of daily journalism assignments such as covering a meeting or reporting a speech. Instead, focus on more substantive issues. The list of topics is long.34 Also, it is advisable that a teacher work closely with the editor of a newspaper, radio, or television station. This will make the experience more realistic, and it will help ensure the story is pub-

JOURNALISM & MASS COMMUNICATION EDUCATOR 54

lished or broadcast. In addition, an instructor should consider contacting an organization that will assist the stu dents in submitting requests for records and contesting denials by gov ernment agencies. Finally, time must be allotted for students to reflect on the experience.

What students are most appropri ate for a service learning project focus ing on investigative reporting? At a minimum, the students should have strong backgrounds in research and writing. Experience suggests a profes sor work with journalism majors who are graduate students or undergradu ates in their junior or senior year. They will have completed the intro ductory courses needed to prepare students for a more challenging investiga tive assignment.

Discussion

What accounts for the relatively high marks the students gave to these projects? The student surveys and the researcher's experience suggest the hands-on nature of the assignments and the responsibility given to students played key roles in instilling pride in the final product. In the words of a senior journalism major who worked on the "Dorm from Hell" story, "It's amaz ing to see the story come to life, becom ing both a narrative about sexual assaults and the millions of dollars the apartment complex was bringing in."

Students questioned many aspects of the investigative projects. Of the thirteen students who worked on the illegal landfill story, two wondered whether they made a real breakthrough. Of the fifteen students who worked on the "Insecurity on Campus" story, three said it was a mistake to

Page 9: Doing Learning

spend an entire semester working on one story. "I wish that we each had the chance to do some individual report ing and writing and then get class feed back," wrote a 23-year-old graduate student. "That would have taught me a lot more." However, the other twelve students who worked on this project said their work paid off. Indeed, the story prompted a number of universi ties to institute changes to better inform students about crime on campus, and it won several awards.35 A 21-year-old junior journalism ma jor observed, "Not only was it a boost to my resume and to my portfolio, it was a valuable learning experience and a great way to apply the sum total of my journalism education."

This was not the only story that produced change and garnered awards. The "Dorm from Hell" story did like wise.36 The president of the university where the dormitory was located sub sequently hired the university's first housing czar and told the police chief to increase the number of patrol offi cers by 50%. 1\vo students wrote fivestories documenting these and other changes.37 One, a junior journalismmajor, said the experience was eyeopening. "The only real way to learn is by getting your hands dirty and making your own mistakes," she said. "Other wise, you will never know what you are capable of doing."

The stories helped prompt other changes that will benefit future college journalism classes. As a result of the partnership between the investigative reporting classes and the Texas Freedom of Information Foundation, two non-profit groups awarded$150,000 to the foundation in 2006 to continue its work assisting students in their efforts to obtain public records.

The foundation's executive director, Katherine Garner, said her organization will use the money over the next three years to provide students with hands on training using public records to pro duce investigative journalism. Garner said her discussions with students who worked on these stories con vinced her that they provide an effec tive approach for service learning. "We have had a number of these students speak about their experiences at our board retreats," said Garner. "They have told us that they have learned how to do investigative journalismworking on projects that made a differ ence in their community." 38

This study has a number of limita tions. One cannot generalize the results with any degree of confidence because of the small sample size. It also is difficult to determine whether the success of these projects resulted from the satisfaction students often get from hands-on reporting as opposed to the investigative reporting and service learning approach employed here. In addition, some tools that were crucial in bringing these investigative projects to fruition-a newspaper editor willing to work with college students and a foundation willing to help them obtain public records-may not be available. Finally, no guarantee exists that future efforts to use investigative reporting to teach service learning will result in published articles, much less ones that prompt corrective action. An instructor considering this approach should understand that in many cases, inves tigative reporters spend weeks siftingthrough the evidence only to discover that there is no story.39

What lessons can be. learned from these projects? Three stand out. First, help the students find a story they care

55 SPRING '07

Page 10: Doing Learning

about. This may be the teacher's most important task. Experience suggests that a student's willingness to work on a service learning project is in direct proportion to his or her interest in the subject. "I like that our story deals with a topic that affects me first-hand," said a junior journalism major who worked on the "Insecurity on Campus" story. "As a college student, campus safety is an issue I think about every day." Second, spend the full semester on the project or assign it during the latter part of the term. Several students said they felt unprepared for the landfill project, which they worked on during the first six weeks of a semester. Third, allow the students to report and write the story. To do otherwise is to deprive them of a crucial step. In the words of a senior journalism major who worked on the "Dorm from Hell" story, "By both researching and putting the infor mation into story form, I got the whole experience of being an investigative journalist."

Many studies of service learning examine a single semester. This may not be the optimal approach. Instead, a teacher considering service learning should try to incorporate it into more than one course over multiple semes ters. In this case, service learning was incorporated into investigative projects in four classes over eighteen months. There is some evidence that the researcher's performance in the class room improved over time.40 More importantly, the majority of students said they believed that they learned the skills necessary to do investigative reporting on their own, which some consider the real test of learning.41 In the words of a senior journalism major, "Working on this story and having to really dig for the information has boost-

JOURNALISM & MASS COMMUNICATION EDUCATOR 56

ed my confidence in my ability to be a journalist. Baptism by fire was definite ly the best way to go about this story and this class."

Endnotes

1. Personal communication with Robert M. Gonyea, associate director, Indiana University Center for Postsecondary Research, October 13, 2005; and National Survey of Student Engagement, Stud ent Engagement: Pathways to Collegiate S uccess (Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Center for Postsecondary Research, 2004).

2. Judith A. Boss, "The Effect of Community Service Work on the Moral Development of College Ethics Stu dents," Journal of Moral Ed ucation 23 (1994): 183-90; Robert G. Bringle and Julie A. Hatcher, "Implementing Service Learning in Higher Education," The Journal of Higher Ed ucation 67 (March-April 1996): 221-39; Dwight E. Giles Jr. and Janet Eyler, "The Impact of a College Community Service Laboratory on Students' Personal, Social and Cognitive Outcomes," Journal of Adolescence 17 (1994): 327-39; andG.B. Markus, J.P.F. Howard, and D.C. King, "Integrating Community Service and Classroom Instruction Enhances Learning: Results from an Experiment," Ed ucational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 15 (1993): 410-19.

3. Daniel Panici and Kathryn Lasky, "Service Learning's Foothold in Communication Scholarship," Journ alism & Mass Communication Ed uca tor 57 (summer 2002): 113-25.

4. For an excellent overview of the case study as a research strategy, see Robert K. Yin, Case Study Research: Design and Methods (Newbury Park,

Page 11: Doing Learning

CA: Sage Publications, 1984).5. Boss, "The Effect of Community

Service Work on the Moral Develop ment of College Ethics Students," 183. The students attended the University of Rhode Island.

6. Giles and Eyler, "The Impact of a College Community Service Labora tory on Students' Personal, Social and Cognitive Outcomes," 336. The stu dents attended Vanderbilt University.

7. Mark Giese, "An Educator's Journal: Evaluating and Evaluated," Journalism & Mass Communication Ed ucator 60 (autumn 2005): 255. The students attended McClellan High School in Little Rock, Arkansas.

8. Julia B. Corbett and April R. Kendall, "Evaluating Service Learning in the Communication Discipline," Journalism & Mass Communication Ed ucator 48 (winter 1999): 66-76. In that study, the students worked with a community organization, prepared sur veys, or designed public relations cam paigns for local charities.

9. Jeremy Cohen and Dennis F. Kinsey, '"Doing Good' and Scholarship: A Service-Learning Study," Journalism Ed ucator 48 (winter 1994): 4-14. In that study, some students helped teach media literacy in public schools, while others remained on campus and developed brochures for community programs.

10. This definition is found in a number of standard texts on investiga tive reporting including William C. Gaines, Investigative Reporting for Print and Broadcast (Belmont, CA: Thomson, 1998), 1; and Steve Wein berg, The Reporter's Handbook: An Investigator's Guide to Documents and Techniques (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1996), xvi. Civic journalism is akin to investigative reporting in that

both seek. to spotlight community problems. However, where investigative reporters focus on obtaining information that others are attempting to keep hidden, civic journalists concen trate on listening systematically to what citizens have to say. See DavidD. Kurpius, "Sources and Civic Journ alism: Changing Patterns of Reporting?" Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 79 (winter 2002): 853-66; and Paul S. Voakes, "A Brief History of Public Journalism," National Civic Review (fall 2004): 25- 35.

11. Much of it focuses on how to do investigative reporting (see footnote 9) or public opinion of the craft. Regarding the latter, see Lars Willnat and David H. Weaver, "Public Opinion and Investigative Reporting in the 1990s: Has Anything Changed Since the 1980s?" Journalism & Mass Com munication Quarterly 75 (autumn 1998): 449-63; David Weaver and LeAnne Daniels, "Public Opinion on Investigative Reporting in the 1980s," Journalism Quarterly 69 (spring 1992): 146-55; and Virginia Dodge Fields and David H. Weaver, "Public Opinion on Investigative Reporting," Newspa per Research Journal 3 (January 1982): 54-62. There are a handful of important theoretical works. Two scholars attempted to create a theoretical model of the beliefs that guide contemporary American investigative reporters. See James S. Ettema and Theodore L. Glasser, Custodians of Conscience: Investigative Journalism and Public Virtue (New York: Columbia Univer sity Press, 1998). Seven scholars pro vide an historical overview of inves tigative reporting, examine six case studies, and formulate a theory of media agenda building. See David L.

57 SPRING '07

Page 12: Doing Learning

Protess et al., The Journalism of Outrage: Investigative Reporting and Agenda Building in America (New York: Guilford Press, 1991). More recently, two researchers compare the ethical reasoning of investigative reporters with other professionals. See Renita Coleman and Lee Wilkins, "The Moral Development of Journalists: A Comparison with Other Professions and a Model for Predicting High Qua lity Ethical Reasoning," Journalism &

Mass Communication Quarterly 81 (autumn 2004): 511-27.

12. The literature on service learning in journalism and mass communi cation is also relatively small. See Panici and Lasky, "Service Learning's Foothold in Communication Scholar ship," 113.

13. Michael Emery, Edwin Emery, and Nancy L. Roberts, The Press and America: An Interpretative History of the Mass Media (Needham Heights, MA: Allyn and Bacon, 2000), 37-40, 62- 62; Ettema and Glasser, Custodians of Conscience, 85-87; and The Commis sion on Freedom of the Press, A Free and Responsible Press (Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1947), 6-9. Thomas Jefferson famously articulated the importance of journalism to democ racy in a 1787 letter. He wrote, "The basis of our government being the opin ion of the people, the very first object should be to keep that right; and were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter." Jefferson as quoted in Emery, Emery, and Roberts The Press and America, 77.

14. As the publisher Joseph Pulitzer Sr. noted in 1878, "More crime, immor ality and rascality is prevented by the

JOURNALISM & MASS COMMUNICATION EDUCATOR 58

fear of exposure in newspapers than by all the laws, moral and statute, ever devised." Pulitzer as quoted in Judith and William Serrin, Muckraking! The Journalism that Changed America (New York: The New Press, 2002), xx. See also Carl Jensen, ed., Stories That Changed America: M uckrakers of the 20th Century (New York: Seven Stories Press, 2000), 15-23.

15. Fred S. Siebert, Theodore Peterson, and Wilbur Schramm, Four Theories of the Press (Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1956), 50- 57 and 73-77. Siebert makes this case in analyzing the libertarian theory of the press. Peterson echoes this view in his examination of the social responsibility theory of the press, arguing that the framers of the Constitution saw the press as the essential balancing force to government. In Peterson's words, "Government was the chief foe of liberty, they believed, and the press must be free to serve as a guardian against governmental encroachments on individual liberty. If the press were free, men would be free." Siebert, Peterson, and Schramm, Four Theories of the Press, 76.

16. James Carey, "In Defense of Public Journalism," in The Idea of Public Journalism, ed. Theodore L. Glasser (New York: Guilford Press, 1999), 51.

17. Giese, "An Educator's Journal: Evaluating and Evaluated," 252-56. See also Howard R. Muscott, "A Review and Analysis of Service-Learning Programs involving Students with Emotional/Behavioral Disorders," Ed ucation and Treatment of Children 23 (August 2000): 346-68.

18. Shawn M. Glynn, Lori Price Aultman, and Ashley M. Owens, "Motivation to Learn in General

Page 13: Doing Learning

Education Programs," The Journal of General Ed ucation 54 (April 2005):150-70.

19. J.E. Brophy, "On Motivating Students," in Talks to Teachers, ed. D. Berliner and B. Rosenshine (New York: Random House, 1988), 201-45.

20. Kim E. Spiezio, Kerrie Q. Baker and Kathleen Boland, "GeneralEducation and Civic Engagement: An Empirical Analysis of Pedagogical Possibilities," The Journal of General Ed ucation 54 (2005): 273-92.

21. Elizabeth Theiss-Morse and John R. Hibbing, "Citizenship and Civic Engagement," Annual Review of Political Science 8 (2005): 227-49; John Saltmarsh, "The Civic Promise of Service Learning," Liberal Ed ucation 9 (spring 2005): 50-55.

22. Audrey J. Jaeger and CourtneyH. Thornton, "Fulfilling the Public Service Mission in Higher Education: 21st Century Challenges," Phi Kappa Phi Forum 84 (fall 2004): 34-35.

23. See Boss, "The Effect of Community Service Work on the Moral Development of College Ethics Stu dents," 186; Cohen

and Kinsey, '"Doing Good' and Scholarship," 7-8; Corbett and Kendall, "Evaluating Service Learning in the Communi cation Discipline," 70; and Giles and Eyler, "The Impact of a College Community Service Laboratory on Students' Personal, Social and Cogni tive Outcomes," 331. An exception is the work of Mark Giese, who devoted considerable time to detailing his serv ice learning project in which high school students produced three thirty second public service announcements. See Mark Giese, "An Educator's Journ al: Spring and

Summer 2004," Journalism &Mass Communication Ed ucator

59 (winter 2005): 342-46;

Mark Giese, "An Educator's Journal: Fall 2004, Guiding the Course through Pedagogy," Journalism & Mass Communication Ed ucator 60 (spring 2005): 72-75; and Giese, "An Educator's Jour nal: Evaluating and Evaluated," 252- 56.

24. For example, one class asked campus police at several universities to provide copies of offense reports involving violent crime. Most agreed to do so at no charge. But one public university demanded more than $100 for these records. Following an appeal, which the Texas Freedom of Information helped prepare, the university dropped the charge. See Craig Flournoy and Dan Malone, "Student Training," The IRE Journal (May/June 2005): 36-37.

25. A Project of SMU's Investiga tive Reporting Class, "Garbage In, Misery Out," Fort Worth Weekly, February 25, 2004, http://www. fwweekly. com/ content. asp?article= 3660 (May 5, 2006).

26. Megan Connolly, Christine Dao, Farrar Johnson, Pablo Lastra, Jennifer McDowell, Jessica Savage, Shalandys Anderson, Rebecca Ekpe, Jaclyn Gonzales, Christina Jancic, Elizabeth Lee, Lindsay Marshall, Brooke Scoggins, Hannah Seddelmeyer and Taylor Timmins, "Insecurity on Campus," Fort Worth Weekly, Decem ber 1, 2004, http://www.fwweekly. com/content.asp?article=862 (May 5, 2006).

27. Scott Anderson, Genevieve Barr, Alicia Booker, Kelsey Guy, Cecilia Lai, Regan Cumming, Allison Denman, Julie Derham, Hill Fischer, Ariel Hammond, Kristen Mosteller, Teresa Nguyen, Austin Payne, Kristin Weber, and Kindal Wright, "The Dorm from Hell," Dallas Observer, April 28, 2005,

Page 14: Doing Learning

59 SPRING '07

Page 15: Doing Learning

http://www.dallasobserver.com/issues/ 2005-04-28/news/feature.html (May 5,2006).

28. Pam Belluck, "Death Row Lessons and One Professor's Mission," the New York Times, March 6, 1999, sec. A, p. 7; Mark Jurkowitz, "Crusa der's Message Obscured by His Story," Boston Globe, June 17, 1999, sec. C, p. 1; and Ana Medieta, "Prof Awarded$100,000 for Freeing the Innocent,"Chicago Sun-Times, December 4, 2003,p. 28.

29. E-mail from David Protess to author, January 6, 2005.

30. Author's telephone interview with William R. "Bill" Moushey Jr., October 3, 2006.

31. Among the other questions students were asked: What did you dislike about this assignment? What aspect of the project taught you the most? How important was the writing aspect of the project?

32. Students in some classes also were given individual assignments. The students who worked on the land fill story were each asked to profile an investigative reporter, including a per sonal statement comparing their expe rience on the group project with the profile each wrote. After the "Dorm from Hell" article and the landfill story were completed, each student was asked what grade he or she should get and why. Every student suggested a grade that was equal to or less than the grade he or she received. This suggests that by the end of each project, the stu dents had become their own toughest critics. In addition to the group proj ects, students were given quizzes on guest speakers' presentations. Each stu dent also received a participation grade based on class attendance and his or her contribution to class discussions.

/OURNALISM & MASS COMMUNICATION EDUCATOR 60

33. Italics in original.34. On campus, students might

investigate security issues, the avail ability of childcare, the treatment of minority students, or the number of female professors and administrators. Off campus, students could examine the quality of nursing homes, the oversight of mental health clinics, inequities in city services, or the crimi nal records of school bus drivers.

35. Several schools spotlighted in the story subsequently improved their crime notification policy significantly. For example, see Jessica Savage and Kristen Mosteller, "SMU Strengthens Crime Policy," the Daily Campus, April 7, 2005, p. 1. The story received the 2005 Jeanne Clery Campus Safety Award, the top national honor given by Security on Campus, Inc., an authority on campus safety. The story also was awarded first place in the student cate gory of the 2005 First Amendment Awards, a multi-state competition sponsored by the Fort Worth chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists.

36. "The Dorm from Hell" was one of four finalists for the 2006 national collegiate investigative reporting award given by Investigative Reporters and Editors, one of the country's top inves tigative journalism groups. It also was awarded first place in the student cate gory of the 2006 First Amendment Awards, a multi-state competition sponsored by the Fort Worth chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists.

37. The president also vowed to improve lighting, to add emergency call boxes, and to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars to improve living conditions. See Kelsey Guy, "UTD Orders Investigation of Waterview," Dallas Observer, May 5, 2005, p. 19; Kelsey Guy, "More Cops for UTD

Page 16: Doing Learning

Dorm," Dallas Observer, July 14, 2005,p. 16; Cecilia Lai, "Wrist Slap," Dallas Observer, September 8, 2005, p. 15; Kelsey Guy and Cecilia Lai, "Better Homes," Dallas Observer, September 15, 2005, p. 19; and Kelsey Guy and Cecilia Lai, "First Things First," Dallas Observer, December 22, 2005, p. 15.

38. Author's telephone interview with Katherine Garner, September 25, 2006.

39. The author bases this statement on his twenty-two years of experience as an investigative reporter at a major metropolitan newspaper.

40. The author first used service

learning in the spring of 2004 when his investigative reporting class put together the landfill story. At the author's university, students evaluate a professor's performance on a scale of one to five with five being the lowest score and one being the highest; the author's average score in the spring 2004 class was 1.2. In the spring of 2005, the author's investigative report ing class put together the "Dorm from Hell" story, his third project using service learning. The author's average score in that class was 1.06.

41. Giese, "An Educator's Journal: Evaluating and Evaluated," 255.

61 SPRING '07

Page 17: Doing Learning

Copy r ight of Jou rnal ism & Mass Communication Educator is the pro perty of Association for Education i n Jou rnal ism & Mass Communication and i ts content may not be copied or emai led to mul ti ple sites or posted to a l istserv wi thout the copy r ight holder 's express w r i tten permission. However. users may pr i nt. download. or emai l articles for i nd i vidual use.