24
Rod Sims, Chairman of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission The Mexico Forum 2013 Wednesday 9 January

Driving prosperity through effective competition

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Driving prosperity through effective competition. Rod Sims, C hairman of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission The Mexico Forum 2013 Wednesday 9 January. Two propositions. Competition essentially drives productivity - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: Driving prosperity through effective competition

Rod Sims, Chairman of the Australian Competition and Consumer

CommissionThe Mexico Forum 2013

Wednesday 9 January

Page 2: Driving prosperity through effective competition

• Competition essentially drives productivity

• Competition best way simultaneously to drive growth and reduce income inequality

• Productivity drives national differences in GDP per capita

• Especially when pro competition reform reduces entrenched market power

Page 3: Driving prosperity through effective competition

1. Extend competition to all sectors

2. Strengthen and widen the reach of competition regulation

Page 4: Driving prosperity through effective competition

1. The changes that were made, the role of the National Competition Policy

2. The benefits from these reforms3. Why and how these reforms were

achieved 4. The lessons learnt, some of which I

hope will be useful to you

Page 5: Driving prosperity through effective competition

AUSTRALIA’S RELATIVE DECLINEPer capita GDP (PPP) ranking in OECD

Australia ranked 14th in 1983

Australia ranked 4th in 1950

Page 6: Driving prosperity through effective competition

TOTAL FACTOR PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH, 1980 - 1990%, average annual rate, OECD countries

Australia with poor productivity performance

OECD weighted average

Page 7: Driving prosperity through effective competition

MAJOR NATIONAL COMPETITION POLICY ELEMENTS Policy Element Example 1. Limiting anti-competitive conduct of firms Competition conduct rules

2. Reforming regulations which unjustifiably restrict competition

Deregulation of egg marketing

3. Reforming the structure of public monopolies to facilitate competition

Restructuring of energy utilities

4. Providing third-party access to certain facilities that are essential for competition

Access arrangements for the telecommunications network

5. Restraining monopoly pricing behaviour Prices surveillance

6. Fostering “competitive neutrality” between government & private business

Requirements for government businesses to make tax-equivalent payments

Page 8: Driving prosperity through effective competition

EXAMPLE OF INFRASTRUCTURE CHANGESFROM TO LATE 1980S LATE 1990S (USUALLY)TelecommunicationsGovernment owned Telcom fully vertically integrated, essentially no competition

Pro-competition access regime plus auction of new licences creates many fixed line and mobile competitors

ElectricityEach State owns a vertically integrated monopoly that faces no competition

Many electricity generation companies/retailers compete nationally across an interconnected east coast grid

GasTrading only within State boarders, many barriers to trade

Interstate free gas trade; third party access regime to gas pipelines.

Rail FreightEach State has own rail freight monopoly, which is vertically integrated, and is loss making

Two privately owned competitors operating nationally formed out of previous State entities with separate rail track company

Page 9: Driving prosperity through effective competition

Road FreightDifferent rules means trucks often cannot cross State boarders

National road freight rules and user charging, a national road freight market.

AviationSeparate publically owned domestic and international airlines, the latter strongly protected from competition

Qantas privately owned and flying domestically and internationally in an “open skies” environment

Rural WaterNon tradable virtually free water entitlements create static water usage, particularly to low value activities

World leading water trading regime that separates water property rights from land title and allows temporary and permanent trading

Urban WaterNon cost reflective pricing; in some cases no usage based charges

Largely cost reflective pricing; many cross subsides removed

Page 10: Driving prosperity through effective competition

EXAMPLES OF OTHER REFORMS 1. Deregulation of retail

trading hours6. Removed restrictions on

health professionals

2. Reduced controls on liquor licensing

7. Free up grain export marketing

3. Reduced business licensing ‘red tape’

8. End price and supply restrictions on eggs and poultry

4. Streamlined development assessment processes

9. Remove dairy price and supply controls

5. Removed restrictions on the legal profession

10. Phase out non transferable fishery management licences

Page 11: Driving prosperity through effective competition

1. The changes that were made, the role of the National Competition Policy

2. The benefits from these reforms3. Why and how these reforms were

achieved 4. The lessons learnt, some of which I

hope will be useful to you

Page 12: Driving prosperity through effective competition

FORECAST GROWTH AND REVENUE BENEFITS FROM NCP CHANGES

1995 $

GROWTH Real GDP 5.5% $23 billion pa Real consumption $9 billion pa $1,500 per household Real wages 3% increase Employment 30,000 more jobs

REVENUE Commonwealth $5.9 billion States; Territories, local government State

$3.0 billion

Page 13: Driving prosperity through effective competition

CONTRIBUTION TO GDP GROWTHPercentage points

Total 2.5% increase GDP

Page 14: Driving prosperity through effective competition

INCREASE IN REAL INCOMES FROM NCP REFORMS

% change, 1989-90 to 1999-00

Household Income

Page 15: Driving prosperity through effective competition

EXAMPLE SPECIFIC SECTORAL GAINS

• Electricity prices fall 19% from early 1990s to 2004

• Some coal rail freight rates fall 42% in second half 1990s

• Average telecoms charges fall by 29% for business and 17% for households from 1996-2003

Page 16: Driving prosperity through effective competition

TOTAL FACTOR PRODUCTIVITY GROWTH, 1990-2000 VS. 1980-1990

Percentage Points, difference between average annual growth

OECD weighted average

Strong Australian

performance

Page 17: Driving prosperity through effective competition

REAL GDP GROWTH, AUSTRALIA VS OECDPercentage Points, difference between average annual growth

The National Competition Policy comes into effect

Page 18: Driving prosperity through effective competition

AUSTRALIA’S RELATIVE DECLINE AND RESURGENCEPer capita GDP (PPP) ranking in OECD

Australia ranked 4th in 1950

Australia ranked 14th

in 1983

Australia back to 5th in 2008

Page 19: Driving prosperity through effective competition

1. The changes that were made, the role of the National Competition Policy

2. The benefits from these reforms3. Why and how these reforms were

achieved 4. The lessons learnt, some of which I

hope will be useful to you

Page 20: Driving prosperity through effective competition

Prior to the NCP reforms Australia had experienced a decades-long debate over tariff reform

The Australian economy was performing poorly; challenges set by Treasurer and Prime Minister

With removal of the tariff wall, Australian industries were exposed to international competition, and had to adapt so demanded lower input cost structure

The public had the gains quantified by the respected Industry Commission

There was strong political leadership

Page 21: Driving prosperity through effective competition

The formation of the Council of Australian Governments (COAG) brought together Australia’s Prime Minister and all State and Territory leaders to drive reform

While the main work was usually undertaken by industry experts, central agency people were closely involved

COAG created a new institution, the National Competition Council (NCC), as an independent body to assess the progress of all governments on implementing their agreed reforms

To encourage reform, the Federal Government established National Competition Payments

Formation of ACCC

Page 22: Driving prosperity through effective competition

1. The changes that were made, the role of the National Competition Policy

2. The benefits from these reforms3. Why and how these reforms were

achieved 4. The lessons learnt, some of which I

hope will be useful to you

Page 23: Driving prosperity through effective competition

Ten lessons1.Prepare the ground well

before proceeding with reform

6. Provide generous financial assistance and/or incentives

2. Pursue reform on a board front

7. Get industry structures right

3. Formulate a well structured agenda that is not cluttered

8. Avoid seeking “national champions”

4. Bring high level political drive and constant attention

9. Privatise for competition and efficiency, not for maximum sale proceeds

5. Set a considered, not a frenetic pace

10. Remember that deregulation does not mean no regulation

Page 24: Driving prosperity through effective competition

“ In the life of a country, six years is a short period, but 2191 days are enough for laying the foundations for what now must be our goal: to make Mexico a prosperous country, with new opportunities and greater welfare for all ”