74

DWDM and OTN Fundamentalsd2zmdbbm9feqrf.cloudfront.net/2015/usa/pdf/BRKOPT-2106.pdf · DWDM and OTN Fundamentals Rodger Nutt ... Intro to OTN ... (P mW /1mW) dB and dBm are additive,

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

DWDM and OTN Fundamentals

Rodger Nutt

Service Provider Optical Architecture Team

Technical Solutions Architect

BRKOPT-2106

Introduction – What is DWDM?

Optical Fiber

Linear/Non-linear Effects and Solutions

DWDM Components

DWDM Software

Intro to OTN

Increasing Capacity, Flexibility and Reach in DWDM

Agenda

What is DWDM?

Wavelength Division Multiplexing

• DWDM systems use optical devices to combine the output of several optical transmitters

Optical

fiber pair

TX

Optical

transmittersOptical

receivers

TX

TX

TX

RX

RX

RX

RX

Transmission

DWDM devices

ITU-T Grid

Frequency

(THz)

Wavelength

(nm)

1528.77 nm 1578.23 nm

0.4 nm spacing

1552.52 nm

(Center channel)

196.2 THz 190.1 THz193.1 THz

(Center channel)

50 GHz spacing

ITU wavelengths = lambdas = channels center around 1550 nm (193 THz)

Dense vs. Coarse (CWDM vs. DWDM)

DWDM CWDMApplication Long Haul Metro

Amplifiers Typically EDFAs Almost Never

# Channels Up to 80 Up to 8

Channel Spacing 0.4 nm 20nm

Distance Up to 3000km Up to 80km

Spectrum 1530nm to 1560nm 1270nm to 1610nm

Filter Technology Intelligent Passive

Optical Fiber

Fiber Geometry and Dimensions

• The core carries the light signals

• The refractive index difference between core & cladding confines the light to the core

• The coating protects the glass

Coating

250 microns

Cladding

125 microns

Core

SMF 8 microns

Communication Wavelengths in the InfraRed

850 nm Multimode 1310 nm Singlemode C-band:1550 nm Singlemode L-band: 1625 nm Singlemode

UltraViolet InfraRed

850 nm 1310 nm 1550 nm 1625 nm

l

Wavelength: l (nanometers)

Frequency: (terahertz)

C = x l

Visible

Optical Spectrum

Good for TDM at 1310 nm

OK for TDM at 1550 nm

OK for DWDM (With Dispersion Mgmt.

Good for CWDM (>8 wavelengths)

Extended Band

(G.652.C)

(suppressed attenuation in the

traditional water peak region)

OK for TDM at 1310 nm

Good for TDM at 1550 nm

Good for DWDM (C + L Bands)

NZDSF

(G.655)

OK for TDM at 1310 nm

Good for TDM at 1550 nm

Bad for DWDM (C-Band)

DSF

(G.653)

Good for TDM at 1310 nm

OK for TDM at 1550

OK for DWDM (With Dispersion Mgmt.)

SMF

(G.652)

Applications for the Different Fiber Types

Linear Effects

Transmission Impairments

• Attenuation• Loss of Signal Strength

• Chromatic Dispersion (CD)• Distortion of pulses

• Optical Signal to Noise Ratio (OSNR)• Effect of Noise in Transmission

800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600

Wavelength (nm)

0.2

0.5

2.0

Loss (dB/km)

L-ba

nd:1

565–

1625

nm

C-b

and:

1530–1

565n

m

S-b

and:

1460–1

530n

m

800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600

Wavelength (nm)

0.2

0.5

2.0

Loss (dB/km)

L-ba

nd:1

565–

1625

nm

C-b

and:

1530–1

565n

m

S-b

and:

1460–1

530n

m

Time Slot

10Gb/s

2.5Gb/s Fiber

Fiber

Time Slot

10Gb/s

2.5Gb/s Fiber

Fiber

S+N

N

S+N

N

Attenuation

• With enough attenuation, a light pulse may not be detected by an optical receiver

Insertion loss (dB)

Attenuation (dB)

Distance (km)

Optical device

Fiber Attenuation (Loss) Characteristic

800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600

OH- Absorption Peaks in

Actual Fiber Attenuation Curve

Wavelength in Nanometers (nm)

0.2 dB/Km

0.5 dB/Km

2.0 dB/Km

Loss(dB)/km vs. Wavelength

S-band:1460–1530nm

L-band:1565–1625nm

C-band:1530–1565nmOH: Hydroxyl ion absorption is the absorption in optical fibers of electromagnetic waves,

due to the presence of trapped hydroxyl ions remaining from water as a contaminant.

Laser Output Power and Receiver Sensitivity and dBm

• Fiber loss expressed in dB but transmitter/receiver power is expressed in dBm

• This is why both the transmitter output power and the receiver sensitivity is expressed in dBm:

PowerdBm=10log(PmW/1mW)

dB and dBm are additive, hence the simplification

Example:

• Powerdbm = 10log(2mW/1mW)=3dBm

• Powerdbm = 10log(1mW/1mW)=0dBm

Gain expressed by ratio: Pout/Pin

Gain measured conveniently in dB: 10 log10 Pout/Pin

If the power is doubled by an amplifier, this is +3 dB

AmpPinPout

Gain and Decibels (dB)

Attenuation: Optical Budget

Optical Budget is affected by:• Fiber attenuation

• Splices

• Patch Panels/Connectors

• Optical components (filters, amplifiers, etc.)

• Bends in fiber

• Contamination (dirt/oil on connectors)

Basic Optical Budget = Tx Output Power – Rx Input Sensitivity

Pout = +6 dBm R = -30 dBm

Budget = 36 dB

Signal

Input

980 or 1480 nm

Pump Laser

Erbium

Doped

Fiber

Amplified

Signal

Output

Isolator

WDM Coupler for

pump and signal

Isolator

Basic EDFA

configuration

Attenuation Solution: EDFA

• Erbium doped fiber amplifies optical signals through stimulated emission using 980nm and 1480nm pump lasers

Chromatic Dispersion (CD)

• Total dispersion is a function of the length of fiber and it’s dispersion factor

• Limits transmission distance for 10G and above wavelengths

• Can be compensated by using negative dispersion fiber or electronically through modulation schemes

Bit 1 Bit 2 Bit 1 Bit 2Bit 1 Bit 2Bit 1 Bit 2 Bit 1 Bit 2

The Optical Pulse tends to Spread as it propagates down the fiber

generating Inter-Symbol-Interference (ISI)

DCUs use fiber with chromatic dispersion of opposite sign/slope and of suitable length to bring the average dispersion of the link close to zero.

Solution: Dispersion Compensating Unit

Optical Signal-to-Noise Ratio (OSNR)

• OSNR is a measure of the ratio of signal level to the level of system noise

• As OSNR decreases, possible errors increase

• OSNR is measured in decibels (dB)

• EDFAs are the source of noise

Signal level dBm)

Noise level (dBm)

Signal level

OSNR = -----------------

Noise level

Optical Signal Detection

• Across a fiber span, optical signals encounter attenuation, dispersion and increased noise levels at amplifiers.

• Each of these factors causes bit detection errors at the receiver.

Distance (km)Transmitting

end

Receiving

end

Low attenuation

Low dispersion

High OSNR

High attenuation

High dispersion

Low OSNR

Example: Link Design with Line Amplifiers10G Xenpak spec: Tx: +3 to -1dBm, Rx min: -21dBm (0ps/nm)

CD tolerance: +1600ps/nm @ 2dB penalty

OSNR min: 16dB (0.5nm resolution)

-1dBm +2dBm

0ps/nm

Time

Domain

Wavelength

Domain

OSNR: 18dB Rx:

-9dBm

Meets receiver minimum

OSNR and power

requirement

+2dBm/ch

TX RX

Tx: -1dBm minM

ux

Dem

ux

DCU

-1600

ps/nm25dB 25dB

DCU

-1600

ps/nm

+2dBm/ch-23dBm/ch -23dBm/ch

OSNR= 21dB

Noise

OSNR= 18dB

Noise

OSNR= 35dB

Noise

-23dBm

1600ps/nm

+2dBm

0ps/nm

-23dBm

1600ps/nm

+2dBm

0ps/nm

OSNR Solution #1Raman Amplifier

• Stimulated Raman Scattering creates the Gain

• Reduces the effective span loss and increases noise performance

• Gain is highly dependent on quality of fiber

• Gain Spectrum ~ 40nm with a single pump

Lo

g

(BE

R)

4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15–15

–14

–13

–12

–11

–10

–9

–8

–7

–6

–5

–4

–3

–2

–1

0

S/N (dB)

Uncoded

No FEC

G.709

RS(255,239)

Raw Channel BER=1.5e-3

EFEC=8.4 dBFEC=6.2 dB

OSNR Solution #2: Forward Error Correction• FEC extends reach and design

flexibility, at “silicon cost”

• G.709 (G.709 Annex A) standard improves OSNR tolerance by 6.2 dB (at 10–15

BER)

• Offers intrinsic performance monitoring (error statistics)

• Higher gains (8.4dB) possible by enhanced FEC (with same G.709 overhead – G.975.1 I.4)

• New SD-FEC provides 2dB more coding gain

Benefit: FEC/EFEC Extends Reach and Offers 10–15 BER

Non-linear Effects

Non Linear Effects

• Polarization Mode Dispersion (PMD)• Caused by Non Linearity Of

Fiber Geometry

• Effective for Higher Bit rates (10G)

• Four Wave Mixing (FWM)• Effects multi-channel systems

• Effects higher bit rates

• Self/Cross Phase Modulation (SPM, XPM)• Caused by high channel power

• Caused by channel interaction

Wavelength (nm)

-5

-10

-15

-20

-25

-30

-35

-40

1542 1543 1544 1545 1546 1547 1548

Pow

er (d

Bm

)

Wavelength (nm)

-5

-10

-15

-20

-25

-30

-35

-40

1542 1543 1544 1545 1546 1547 1548

Wavelength (nm)

-5

-10

-15

-20

-25

-30

-35

-40

1542 1543 1544 1545 1546 1547 1548

Pow

er (d

Bm

)

nx

nyEx

Ey

Pulse As it Enters the Fiber

Spreaded Pulse As

it Leaves the Fiber

nx

nyEx

Ey

Pulse As it Enters the Fiber

Spreaded Pulse As

it Leaves the Fiber

Power SP

M D

isto

rtio

n

Power SP

M D

isto

rtio

n

Polarization Mode Dispersion (PMD)

• It is Relevant at Bit Rates of 10Gb/s or More

• Pulse broadens as it travels down fiber

• Mainly a manufacturing/install issue with concentricity of fiber

• Mitigation

• Increasing system robustness with FEC

• Leverage MLSE

• Use PMD Compensation (PMDC)

• Deploy PMD-optimized fibers

• Advanced Modulation Schemes

nx

nyEx

Ey

Pulse as It Enters the Fiber Spreaded Pulse as It Leaves the Fiber

DWDM Components

Typical Components of DWDM Systems

• Optical transmitters and receivers

• DWDM mux/demux filters

• Optical add/drop multiplexers (OADMs)

• Reconfigurable OADM (ROADM)

• Optical amplifiers

• Transponders/Muxponders

Optical Transmitter Block Diagram

Detects pulses of

electrical charge

• Power measured in watts (W)

• Amplitude measured in

volts (V)

Creates pulses of light

• Power measured in

decibel-milliwatts (dBm)

• Relative amplitude

measured in decibels (dB)

Electrical conductor

E-O

Optical fiber

1 11 01 11 0

Electrical-to-optical

(E-O)

conversion+

-

dB

+

-

V+ -

Optical Receiver Block Diagram

Detects pulses of light

• Power measured in

decibel-milliwatt (dBm)

• Relative amplitude

measured in decibels (dB)

Creates pulses of electrical charge

• Power measured in watts (W)

• Amplitude measured in volts (V)

Electrical conductor

O-E

Optical fiber

+ -

Optical-to-electrical (O-

E)

conversion1 11 0+

-

dB

1 11 0+

-

V

DWDM Mux and Demux Filters Block Diagram

1

2

3

N

DWDM

fiber

N light pulses of different wavelengths

From N

transmittersTo N

receivers

1

2

3

N

Composite

signal

Multiplexer Demultiplexer

1, 2, ….N

OADM Block Diagram

New data stream,

same wavelength

Signsl 1 drop

OADM

one signal

Pass through pathOriginal

composite signal

New composite

signal

Drop path Add path

DWDM

fiber

Signal 2 add

ROADM Architecture

Add

WavelengthsDrop

Wavelengths

Pass-Through WavelengthsSplitter

Add

WavelengthsSoftware

Controlled

32 Ch. DeMux

Pass-Through WavelengthsSplitter

l1Network

Elementl3

Network

Element

Software Controlled Selectors – 32 Ch.

(Pass-through/Add/Block)

DWDM

Signal

Transponder

Module

West

East

DWDM

Signal

Drop

Wavelengthsdrop block blockdrop

dropblock block drop

Software

Controlled

32 Ch. DeMux

Add

Pass

Add

Pass

Network

Element

Network

Element

Transponder

Module

Pass

Pass

Add

Add

Software Controlled Selectors – 32 Ch.

(Pass-through/Add/Block)

l1l3

Optical Amplifer Block Diagram

• Unidirectional operation

• Extends the reach of a DWDM span

OA

DWDM

fiber

Attenuated input

composite signal

Amplified output

composite signal

Powerin Powerout

Transponder Block Diagram

Optical fiber

Non-ITU-T

compliant wavelength

ITU-T

compliant wavelength

O-E-O

wavelength conversion

850, 1310, 1550 nm 15xx.xx nm

Transponder

Tx

RxG.709 Enabled

Muxponder Block Diagram

Optical fibers

Multiple Non-ITU-T

Compliant Clients

ITU-T

compliant wavelengthMultiplexing and O-E-O

wavelength conversion

850, 1310, 1550 nm15xx.xx nmTx

Rx

Muxponder

G.709 Enabled

Pluggable Optics

10G

XENPAK, X2, XFP

and SFP+

Below 10G

GBIC and SFP

40G/100G

CFP,CXP and

CPAK

DWDM System

OEOTxRx

TxRx

OADM OAOA

Rx Tx

Transponder interface

OEOTxRx

TxRx

Direct interface

To client devices

ClientClient

Mux and

demuxMux and

demux

DWDM Software

Intelligent DWDM

• Modern systems compensate real-time for variations in the network

• Gain Equalization

• Amplifier Control

• Automatic Node Setup

• Automatic Power Control

• WSON Restoration

• Allows for less truck rolls and maintenance windows

Why Per-Channel Optical Power Equalization

• For amplifiers to operate correctly, all channels must be equalized in power.

• If channel powers are not equal, more gain will go to the higher powered channels.

• Channel power is inherently unequal due to different insertion losses, different

paths (add path vs. express/pass-through), etc.

• Controlling the optical power of each channel in an optical network is required.

AMP

AMP

Optical Power Equalized Channels

Channels with Unequal Optical Power

OADM Without Power Equalization

Express Path

Add/Drop

Path

Why Per Channel Equalization

Constant Power Mode

AMP

Initial condition – 2 channels

Total Output Power +2dBm

Per Channel

Power -1dBm

AMP

Adding 2 channels Amp set to Constant Power Mode

Total Output Power +2dBm

Per Channel

Power -4dBm

Add Channels Example

AMP

Initial condition – Gain 14dB

Total Output Power +2dBm

Per Channel

Power -1dBm

Per Channel

Power -15dBm

AMP

Initial condition – Gain 16dB

Total Output Power +2dBm

Per Channel

Power -1dBm

Per Channel

Power -17dBm

Span Loss Increase Example

Per Channel

Power -15dBm

Per Channel

Power -15dBm

Constant Gain Mode

AMP

Initial condition – Gain 14dB

Total Output Power +2dBm

Per Channel

Power -1dBm

AMP

Gain Stays Constant – Gain 14dB

Total Output Power +5dBm

Per Channel

Power -1dBm

Add Channels Example

AMP

Initial condition – Gain 14dB

Total Output Power +2dBm

Per Channel

Power -1dBm

Per Channel

Power -15dBm

AMP

Gain stays the Same – Gain 14dB

Total Output Power -1dBm

Per Channel

Power -4dBm

Per Channel

Power -18dBm

Per Channel

Power -15dBm

Span Loss Increase Example

Per Channel

Power -15dBm

Automatic Power Control

• Automatically corrects amplifier power/gain for capacity change, ageing effects, operating conditions

• Keep traffic working after network failires

• Prevent BER due to network degrade

• Keep constant either power or gain on each amplifier

• No truck rolls

• No troubleshooting required

• No operation complexity

APC

No Human Intervention Required

Intro to OTN Switching

Aggregation Technology

OTN Drivers

• Sub-Lambda Aggregation/Switching• Adapt to DWDM

• Switch/Router IntfcMismatch to DWDM

• Transparency• Timing

• Protocols (i.e. OSPF vsISIS)

• Sub-Lambda Protection

• Unnecessary when client interface = DWDM Trunk

Source: Infonetics

OTN Only Packet

Aggregation OTN OTN / Packet

Optimized

Private Line

Private Line

Private Line

Private Line

Not yet needed

Money saved

λ2 λ1 λ2 λ1 λ2

deferred λ1

Private Line

Private Line

Private Line

Private Line

Private Line

Private Line

Private Line

Private Line

OTN – A Quick refresher

OPU

ODU

OTU OTU OTU

How Does OTN Relate to DWDM? O

TN

DW

DM

OCh

OMS

OTS OTS OTS

Three Architectural Options for OTN

Switched

G.709

(Digital OTN)

Static WDM

(Analog OTN)

Flexible

WDM

(Analog OTN)

Switched

G.709

(Digital OTN)

Dynamic

WDM

(Analog OTN)

Framed G.709

(Digital OTN)

A B C

G.709 provides all dynamic capabilities

WDM for capacity only

G.709 provides dynamic switching

WDM with reconfigurable connections

G.709 provides framing only

WDM for all dynamic capabilities

OTU4Clients and Mappings

• ITU simultaneously defined an ODU0 at 1.25 Gbps to carry GigE

• Supplants ODU1 (2.5 Gb/s) as the fundamental TS size

• ODU4 is divided into 80, 1.25 Gb/s Time Slots

• ITU defined the ODUflex container, ODU2e is the first

Increasing Capacity and Reach

100G and Beyond – Coherent DetectionDirect Detection

• Must correct for impairments in the physical domain (insert DCU’s)

• Forced to live with non-correctable impairments via network design (limit distance, regenerate, adjust channel spacing)

• Dumb detection (OOK), no Digital Signal Processing, only FEC

Coherent Detection

• Moves impairment correction from the optical domain into the digital domain

• Allows for digital correction of impairments (powerful DSP) vs. physical correction of impairments (DCU’s). Adds advanced FEC.

• Massive performance improvements over Direct Detection.

DD

CD

DD

DCU DCU DCU

Regen

Flexible Modulation – Reach vs. Capacity

BPSK 28 GBaud 56 Gbps 50 Gbps 10,000 km

QPSK 32 GBaud 112 Gbps 100 Gbps 6,800 km

16-QAM 35 GBaud 224 Gbps 200 Gbps 1,200 km

Modulation Baud Rate Line Rate Payload Rate Distance

Traditionally DWDM capacity is limited by the

channel spacing imposed by the 50GHz ITU grid.

Rigid Spacing

Wasted Spectrum

Superchannel with Minimal Spacing

Efficient Spectrum Use

Tightly spaced Superchannels deliver ~30% increase in capacity

50 GHz ITU Grid “Gridless”

Adding Flexibility

ROADM brought flexibility to DWDM networks.

Any wavelength. Anywhere.

But it was static flexibility.

Moves and changes required a truck roll.

… because ROADM ports were

colored and directional.

Colored Add/Drop

Fixed port frequency assignment

One unique frequency per port

Directional Add/Drop

Physical add/drop port is tied to a

ROADM “degree”

Due to these restrictions, a change in direction or frequency of an optical circuit

required a physical change (move interface to different port) at the endpoints.

Colorless Add/Drop

No port-frequency assignment

Any frequency, any port

With Colorless plus Omni-Directional, the frequency and direction of the signal

can be changed, without requiring a change of ROADM add/drop port, therefore

no truckrolls, and hence…programmability!

Omni-Directional Add/Drop

Add/Drop ports can be routed

to/from any ROADM degree

Colorless and Omni-directional add/drop bring

touchless flexibility, and hence programmability, to

ROADM networks.

Directional Add/Drop ROADMs

form a Contentionless node by

definition.

With Contentionless, N instances of a given wavelength (where N = the number

of line degrees in the ROADM node) can be add/dropped from a single device,

eliminating any restrictions on dynamic wavelength provisioning.

Contentionless add/drop allows

multiple instances of the same

frequency to A/D from one unit.

But…Colorless and Omni-directional introduce

wavelength contention at the add/drop stage. Need

a Contentionless architecture.

Transmitter can tune its laser’s

frequency to any channel in the

ITU grid.

Tunable lasers work with colorless add/drop to enable touchless changes in the

frequency of an optical signal. Coherent receivers simplify the construction of

colorless and omni-directional ROADM nodes, by eliminating the need to de-

multiplex a signal down to the individual wavelength.

Receiver can select any channel

from of a composite (unfiltered)

signal.

Tunable lasers and coherent receivers are also key

enablers of the touchless programmable optical layer.

But this touchless capability is of limited use without

intelligence.

Intelligence to find an optically feasible

route through the network.

The WSON Control Plane combines

GMPLS signaling with knowledge of

optical interface requirements and

channel impairments.

WSON

Embedded Optical

Intelligence

WSON enables automated, constraint-

based zero-planning wavelength setup,

which in turn enables advanced optical

layer features such as Optical Restoration.

Dynamic Optical Restoration

Client

Colorless, Omni-Directional ROADM switches the pathService is brought back up with the same Client and Optical interfaces, zero touches

Embedded WSON intelligence locates and verifies a new path and wavelengthTransponders re-tune to available wavelength

Fiber Cut!

animated slide

Client

ROADM Network

Transponder

Shelf

Transponder

Shelf

Adding a User Network Interface (GMPLS-UNI) to

WSON turns a touchless ROADM into a

programmable optical layer.

• GMPLS UNI enables multi-layer circuit provisioning by signaling exchanges between UNI

Client (typically routers) and UNI Network (typically optical) nodes.

• Provides the ability to share and leverage information across layers

• Facilitates scale while maintaining organizational segmentation and distinct operational

expertise among layers

UNI-C

UNI-N

GMPLS

UNI

Key Takeaways

• Dramatic increase in Bandwidth has led to the use of DWDM

• Fiber type effects the quality of transmission

• Linear Effects are predictable and can be compensated

• Non-Linear Effects are known but somewhat unpredictable

• OTN Switching is an emerging transport technology

• Modern DWDM systems are intelligent and simple to operate

• Good reference is: http://www.cisco.com/en/US/products/hw/optical/ps2011/products_technical_reference_chapter09186a00802342dd.html

Introduction – What is DWDM?

Optical Fiber

Linear/Non-linear Effects and Solutions

DWDM Components

DWDM Software

Intro to OTN

Increasing Capacity, Flexibility and Reach in DWDM

Conclusion

Complete Your Online Session Evaluation

Don’t forget: Cisco Live sessions will be available for viewing on-demand after the event at CiscoLive.com/Online

• Give us your feedback to be entered into a Daily Survey Drawing. A daily winner will receive a $750 Amazon gift card.

• Complete your session surveys though the Cisco Live mobile app or your computer on Cisco Live Connect.

Continue Your Education

• Demos in the Cisco Campus

• Walk-in Self-Paced Labs

• Table Topics

• Meet the Engineer 1:1 meetings

Thank you

Glossary Arrayed Waveguide (AWG)

Automatic Node Setup (ANS)

Automatic Power Control (APC)

Chromatic Dispersion (CD)

Cross Phase Modulation (XPM)

Decibels (dB)

Decibels-milliwatt (dBm)

Dense Wavelength Division Multiplexing (DWDM)

Dispersion Compensation Unit (DCU)

Dispersion Shifted Fiber (DSF)

Erbium Doped Fiber Amplifier (EDFA)

Four-Wave Mixing (FWM)

GlossaryInternational Telecommunications Union (ITU)

Non-Zero Dispersion Shifted Fiber (NZ-DSF)

Optical Add Drop Multiplexer (OADM)

Optical Signal to Noise Ratio (OSNR)

Optical Supervisory Channel (OSC)

Optical Supervisory Channel Module (OSCM)

Polarization Mode Dispersion (PMD)

Reconfigurable Optical Add Drop Multiplexer (ROADM)

Self Phase Modulation (SPM)

Single Mode Fiber (SMF)

Variable Optical Attenuator (VOA)