EPGP Batch8 Beas River Tragedy

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/25/2019 EPGP Batch8 Beas River Tragedy

    1/7

    1. INTRODUCTION

    1.1 The IncidentOn 8th June 2014, 48 students and 3 faculty/sta members f !.".# !i$nana

    Jythi Institute f %n$ineerin$ and Technl$y &ere n an educatinal 'isit f(imachal )radesh. On the fateful day, sme f the students &ere standin$ and

    s&immin$ in the *eas ri'er ne+t t andi-anali "atinal (i$h&ay "(-21, 30

    ms d&nstream the ari hydrelectric rect. uddenly, as the d$ates fdam &ere ened, the &ater le'el f the ri'er increased and the students &ere

    &ashed a&ay. The incidents death tll &as 24 i.e. 15 males, 6 female studentsand 1 instructr &ere dr&ned. 7 rescue team f 0 members, includin$ di'ers

    frm "9#:, *, Indian 7rmy, Indian "a'y and thers, searched the 1 mstretch frm ari 9am t )andh 9am and rec'ered the bdies f 24 fatalities 1.

    The eratin f $ates fr the release f ri'er &ater is a nrmal ractice freratin$ a hydr lant. The students i$nred the &arnin$ si$ns ut u near the

    lcatin. The eratin sta f the dam fll&ed a set u rcedure ;as is dne

    since 0 years< fr dam eratin and released the &ater.

    The eratin sta &as held $uilty and &as terminated n char$es f ne$li$ence.They had t face le$al rceedin$s. 7 case f ne$li$ence &as re$istered a$ainst

    the ari (ydrelectric )rect fr causin$ the deaths. :ll&in$ alle$atins &ere

    made= -

    1htt=//&&&.yutube.cm/

    1

    http://www.youtube.com/http://www.youtube.com/
  • 7/25/2019 EPGP Batch8 Beas River Tragedy

    2/7

    u>cient rir &arnin$ &as nt $i'en.

    " hrn &as sunded befre enin$ the $ates.

    ?llusin f rect >cials and lcal sand ma@a- (ydrelectric rect

    >cials ften clluded &ith lcal sand ma@a t arti@cially bst &ater

    releases, ushin$ ut sand &ith the &ater.

    )&er rect team &as ased t reduce the $eneratin f electricity that day.(ence, it had t shut d&n the lant, necessitatin$ that the reser'ir &ater

    be released suddenly d&nstream int the *eas ri'er.

    (Image Source:http://www.frstpost.com/printpage.php?idno=1563341sr!no="#

    (Image Source:http://timesofndia.indiatimes.com/india/$eas%ri&er%traged'power%generating%proects)ar*ati%III%proect/artic+eshow/3645541,.cms#

    (Image Source:http://artic+e.wn.com/&iew/-"13/",/-4/$eas!ri&er!turning!into!dumping!site!or!hote+s!and!others

    /#

    2

    http://www.firstpost.com/printpage.php?idno=1563341&sr_no=0http://www.firstpost.com/printpage.php?idno=1563341&sr_no=0http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Beas-river-tragedypower-generating-projectsParbati-III-project/articleshow/36455419.cmshttp://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Beas-river-tragedypower-generating-projectsParbati-III-project/articleshow/36455419.cmshttp://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Beas-river-tragedypower-generating-projectsParbati-III-project/articleshow/36455419.cmshttp://article.wn.com/view/2013/09/24/Beas_river_turning_into_dumping_site_for_hotels_and_others/http://article.wn.com/view/2013/09/24/Beas_river_turning_into_dumping_site_for_hotels_and_others/http://www.firstpost.com/printpage.php?idno=1563341&sr_no=0http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Beas-river-tragedypower-generating-projectsParbati-III-project/articleshow/36455419.cmshttp://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Beas-river-tragedypower-generating-projectsParbati-III-project/articleshow/36455419.cmshttp://article.wn.com/view/2013/09/24/Beas_river_turning_into_dumping_site_for_hotels_and_others/http://article.wn.com/view/2013/09/24/Beas_river_turning_into_dumping_site_for_hotels_and_others/
  • 7/25/2019 EPGP Batch8 Beas River Tragedy

    3/7

    (Image Source: http://www.+ega+ser&icesindia.com/#

    2 Legal Research and Analysis

    2.1 a& f TrtsThe &rd trt is deri'ed frm the :rench &rd trt, meanin$ A&rn$.A It is ind fharm r inury caused by ne ersn r le$al entity t antherBther thanthru$h breach f cntractBand fr &hich the la& r'ides a remedy. T r'idecmensatin t ele &h $t inured by an actin f thers, eitherintentinally r unintentinally, is the rimary becti'e f the trt la&. It is Cuitessible that a trt and a crime arise frm the same set f facts ;e.$., slain$smene in'l'es bth the trt f battery and the crime f assault< there aresi$ni@cant dierences bet&een the t&. ;%+hibit 4