11
Content Sheet Evaluation Table 2 Color Code 3 Definition of Hazardous wastes 4 ESG reporting guidelines 5 Sheet1

Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

Content SheetEvaluation Table 2Color Code 3Definition of Hazardous wastes 4ESG reporting guidelines 5

Sheet1

Page 2: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

3 3 HK & ChinaGas

(/Towngas)*Equivalent

limits to

Y 2012Sustainability

Report:http://www.towngas.com/sustainabilityRpt/2012/eng/files_en/assets/common/downloads/TownGas_2012

_01a.pdf

Utilities -Utilities(HSIC*)

HKD179,396,776,654

HKD49,867,600,000

HKD6,853,800,000

HKD 0.6517(A)

Y (Health, Safetyand Envt Policy[prologue], 5Rsprinciple - p. 30)

Y (Emission levelsof gas productionplans in HK p. 26)

Y (Greenhousegases [production

equipment] 66)

Y (Wastewater,Chemical waste

generated 66,67)

NI Y (1. CarbonAudit programme2. Heat recoverysystem im Tai PoPlant saved 2400toones of CE 3.

Carbon ReductionProject p.29)

Y (1. Class ofExcellence"

Wastewi$e Labelfor the 11th

consecutive year2. Used Appliance

RecyclingProgramme 3.

mgt of food wastep.33)

Y (5Rs Principlep.30)

Y (Energyconsumpton at

TowngasHeadquarters

p.32)

Y (Totalwastewater output

p.34)

Y (Energy SavingMeasures

Implemented atTowngas

Headquartersp.31)

Y (Reverseosmosis water

treatment facilityinstalled at Tai Po

Plant p.32)

NI (Gasappliancespolyfoampackaging

materials avoidedp.67)

Y (Project mgte.g. EIA studies

p.34)

Y (envt'l mgtsystems p.21)

NI

4 5 HSBC Hldgs Y 2013Sustainability

Reportavailable fordownload:

http://www.hsbc.com/new

s-and-insight/2014/sustainability

-in-2013

Financials -Banks (HSIC*)

HKD1,595,789,364,620

USD181,871,000,000

USD16,204,000,000

USD 0.84 Y (SustainableOperations

Strategy p.17)

1/2 Y (ShowedTotal CO2

emissions p.34)

1/2 Y ((totalnumber of CO2

emissionsequivalent p. 34)

1/2 Y (Total wasteproduced 34)

NI (Noidentification

betweenhazardous & non-hazardous waste

p.34)

Y (ClimateBusiness p.12)

Y (Reduction in21 percent waste

disposed 19)

Y (OperationalSustainability

goals 2012-20 p.17 - 20)

Y (Total energyconsumption in

gigawatt hours p.34)

Y (Total waterconsumption p.

34)

Y (1. Five YearAgreement withJLL on reducing

energyconsumption p.19, 2. Reducedenergy used bydate centres p.

20)

Y (Water SourcingN/A; HSBC Water

Programme asinitiative, 29)

N/A Y (Forest Land &Forest Products

policy that tacklesissues of

deforestation &rights of forestcommunities

[externalassurance fromProforest] p.14)

Y (1. Set arequirement for

forestrycustomers to gain100& certificationby FSC 2. palm oil

customers tobecome membersof RSPO p.14; )

Y (SustainabilityRisk Framework

p.14)

5 6 PowerAssets

Y SustainabilityReport 2013:http://www.powerassets.com/pahweb/SR2013/EN/ebook.html

Utilities -Utilities(HSIC*)

HKD147,904,332,622

HKD69,438,000,000

HKD11,165,000,000

HKD 5.2313 NI NI NI NI NI 1/2 Y (UK PowerNetworks 1.

installed 60 EVcharging stations

2. EV leasingscheme (part of

Low CarbonLondon EV trials)

3. Low CarbonLondon research -studies the habits

of London EVDrivers 4.Dali &

Laoting windfarmsold electricity -->

reduce carbonemissions p.7)

1/2 Y (AVRgenerates energy

through theincineration ofwaste, workingtowards zero-waste energy

generationprocess p.7)

NI NI NI Y (UKPN EVinitiatives p.7)

NI NI NI NI NI

6 11 Hang SengBank

Y CorporateSustainabilityReport 2013:http://www.hangseng.com/cms/ccd/csr/2013/eng_files/pdf/CSR_EN_2013.p

df

Financials -Banks (HSIC*)

HKD247,774,828,586

HKD107,778,000,000

HKD26,678,000,000

HKD13.9541

Y (Hang SengSustainabilityMatrix p.10)

Y (Carbon DioxideEmissions p.45)

Y (GHGemissions in

kilotonnes CO2p.13; Total CO2

emissions inenergy, businesstravel, per FTE,per sq ft p. 45)

Y (Total WasteDisposed toLandfill: IT &Electrical in

tonnes & Wastedisposed per FTE

p. 46)

Y (Total paperconsumption in

tonnes andcompliance p. 45;

General OfficeWaste in tonnes

p. 46)

Y (Hang SengYunnan Biogas

Project incooperation withthe ConservancyAssociation, built

3,000 biogasfacilities provide

free & stableenergy + reduce

CO2 emissions byover 35,000

tonnes)

Y (WasteCollected for

Recycling [data]p.46)

NI Y (Total energyconsumption fromelectricity & otherfuel sources, perFTE, per sq ft in

Gj p.45)

Y (Total waterconsumption &

waterconsumption perFTE in 000m3 &

m3/FTE p.45)

Y (HS GreenFinancing

Scheme - providefunding for HK-

owned factories inthe Pearl River

Delta to buy greenequipment,

enhances EE &reduce pollution p.

28)

1/2 Y (Hang SengPan Pearl River

Delta Envt'lAwards - cutting

electricityconsumption byover 126 millionkilowatt hours p.

45)

NI (*Same asprevious column

p.45)

Y (Suppliersustainability

standards, Ethical& Envt'l Code of

Conduct forSuppliers of

Goods & Servicesp.31)

Y (31) Y (Creditevaluation

process incldesassessment ofany potential

envt'l or sociallysensitive-related

risks, 23,24)

7 12 HendersonLand

Y http://www.hld.com/en/pdf/investor/annual/2013/annualreport/Sustainability%20and%20CSR.pdf

Properties &Construction -

Properties(HSIC*)

HKD145,496,773,683

HKD223,402,000,000

HKD15,948,000,000

HKD 5.426(A)

Y (Envt'l policyp.85)

1/2 Y (GHGemissions of

offices at 2 IFC &AIA Tower

according toelectricity & water

consumptionp.85,88; GHGemissions by

Goodwill p. 86, 89*covers only

energy indirectemissions from

electricityconsumption)

1/2 Y (Refer toprevious column)

NI NI Y (1. ReduceCarbon emissionsfrom air travel by

videoconferencing p.85; 2. Carbon

audit for 2 of theGroup's

commercialproperties )

Y (1. Paperlesscommunication

i.e. iCPM, BQCS,DMS or FSC-certified paper

used on corporatelevel; 2. WasteMgt scheme fordemolition sites

on project level; 3.Recycling

Programmes forthe Group's

commercial &residential

properties 87)

Y (Energyconsumption andefficiency p.86;

Waste Mgt p.86-88; Water Mgt

p.88-89)

1/2 Y (Energyfrom electrivity

consumption forproperties

managed byGoodwill p. 86)

Y (Waterconsumption ofoffices at 2 ifc &AIA Tower p.88,

Waterconsumption for

propertiesmanaged by

Goodwill p.89)

Y (LED, T5lighting & electrictransformers &Energy Label

issued byElectrical &Mechianical

Services Dept oncorporate level,

etc. p.85)

Y (Efficient freshwater supply

devices & Waterefficient irrigationsystems, use ofcertified waterappliances &water saving

sanitary fittings innew buildings;Channels for

temporaryrainwater storageon project levelp.88; Installed

faucets with infra-red sensors,

collectingrainwater forirrigation inGoodwill

Properties p.89)

NI / most likelyN/A

1/2 Y (Surveys todetermine

ecological valueof identified sites

in accordancewith relevant laws,

regulations &guidelines p. 89)

1/2 Y ("Approachthat accomodates

natureconservation

imperatives aspart of the

developmentprocess, whilealso delivering

high qualitylandscaping" --> 5LEED certified, 22BEAM & 3 GBDL

certified p.83)

NI

Order Code ConstituentName

Updated ReferencedReport

IndustryClassification

Market Capitalisation Net Asset Value Net Profit (Loss) Earnings pershare

B1GD B1.1 B1.2 B1.3 B1.4 B1.5 B1.6 B2GD B2.1 B2.2 B2.3 B2.4 B2.5 B3GD B3.1 C1GD (in terms ofenvt'l risk)

1 1 CheungKong

Y 2013 AnnualReport -

Envt'l, Social&

GovernanceReport:

http://www.ckh.com.hk/uploaded_files/news/609_e_content.pdf

(p.86)

Properties &Construction -

Properties(HSIC*)

HKD331,211,500,334

HKD360,681,000,000

HKD35,260,000,000

HKD15.2234

NI NI NI NI NI Y (1. CarbonAudit programme

in 2013 -eco-friendlyinitatives in

properties' dailymgt operations 2.

Power Assetsgets 2nd best

score under CDP3.HK Electric

CarbonCare label86)

Y (waste rebate &recycling

programmes inresidential &commercial

properties by theGroup 87)

Y (Policy forsmart-use of theGroup's vehicles

87)

NI NI Y (Greenpractices in

residential estatesmanaged by the

Grp, e.g.energy-saving

lights, using lesspaper, water &

energy, all electrickitchen 87)

NI (reducing waterconsumption 87)

NI NI NI NI

2 2 CLP Hldgs N CLP 2013Sustainability

Report:https://www.

Utilities -Utilities(HSIC*)

HKD160,808,578,781

HKD87,361,000,000

HKD6,060,000,000

HKD 2.3986 Y (Envt’l Policystatement 84)

Y (Emissions &Wastes, 96)

Y (99) Y (Waste 105) Y ( Waste 105) Y (CC 2050strategy, 99)

Y (Recycling, 105) Y (Resource Use,107)

Y (KPI, 41) Y (108) Y (EE, 58-67) Y (107) N/A Y (84) Y (58) Y

Sheet2

Page 3: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

8 13 Hutchison -several

branches,ESG

reportingunder annual

report

Y http://file.irasia.com/listco/hk/hutchison/annual/2013/

esgr.pdf

Conglomerates-

Conglomerates(HSIC*)

HKD445,522,246,510

HKD426,609,000,000

HKD31,112,000,000

HKD 7.2975 NI NI NI NI NI 1/2 Y (*Many ofthe Group'soperating

companies in theinfrastructure &

energy portfolios,have detailed

metrics to reducepollution &

emissions in theirrespective ESG &

Sustainabilityreports on their

websites* Resultshighlighted:

Europe ContainerTerminals

received the Lean& Green Star for

sustainablebusiness

practices thatreduce more than20% of its carbonemissions p.85)

2/3 Y (1. HuskyEnergy converts

waste gas topower with its

Cadotte facility; 2.Cheung KongInfrastructure

acquired AVR &Enviro Wastewhich imports

garbage &converts it to

energy)

NI (partipated indifferent

programmes withpartners p. 102)

NI NI 1/2 Y (LEDreplacements

which saves 55%energy for Hong

Kong InternationalTerminals p. 101)

NI on sourcingwater, 1/2 Y water

efficiencyinitiatives?(Yantian

InternationalContainerTerminals

recognized bySteering

Committee ofWater-SavingProgramme of

Shenzhen as RoleModel in Water-Saving p.102)

NI - most likelyN/A because

mostly utilities,infrastructure ortransportation

NI 1/2 Y(NorthumbrianWater awarded

the Waste &Recycling -

Impact Winneraward, named

one of the world'smost ethical

companies byEthisphere

Institute; Wales &West Utilities

awarded WalesResponsible

Business Awardfor efforts inenvironment

protection p.103)

1/2 Y (A SWatson's Energy,Supply Chain &Packaging Sub-

committees aim tomake their

operations moreenvironmentally

friendly andreduce their

carbon footprint p.103)

9 14 Hysan Dev(Reports

according toESG)

Y CorporateResponsibilit

y Report2013:

http://www.hysan.com.hk/filemanager/content/corporate_govermance/eCRR2013.pdf

Properties &Construction -

Properties(HSIC*)

HKD 38,932,80,923 HKD63,326,000,000

HKD6,158,000,000

HKD 5.7904 Y (Envt, Hlth &Safety Policy p.3)

Y (Total GHGEmissions forScope 1 & 2 in

CO2e, p.6)

Y (Total GHGEmissions forScope 1 & 2 in

CO2e, p.6)

N/A ( "We believeour business does

not generate amaterial amount

of hazardouswaste" p.23)

N/A (p.23) Y ("Energyefficiency effortscontributed to a

significantreduction in GHG

emissions inrecent years" 1.Lowest energyutilization indexamongst majorshopping malls

p.6)

Y (awarded fullset of "Class of

Excellence"Wastewi$e labels

under thegovernment's HK

Awards forEnvironmental

Excellencescheme for all

buildings exceptHysan Place; Go

PaperlessCampaign for

Hysan's officesp.8)

Y (Hysan'sEnergy

ManagementModel & Energysaving initiatives

in 2013 p.5;Waste

Management,Recycling &

WaterConsumption p.8 -

10)

Y (PurchasedElectricity p.6)

Y (Potable waterused for

properties &landscaping, used

for cooling,wastewter

discharged fromproperties &landscaping)

Y (Mixed modeventilation

operable ventsused by tenants;Installing higherefficiency motorsfor air handlingunits & chilledwater pumps =

compllies with thelatest Code of

Practice forenergy efficiency

of electricalinstallation by HK

governent'sElectrical &Mechanical

ServicesDepartment p.5,Lowest EUI p.6; )

Y (Experimentalartifical wetland in

Hysan Place tohelp recycle greywater generatedin office floors of

the building,anticipating full

operation in 2014p.9)

N/A (p.23) Y (Environment,Hlth & Safety

Policy p.3)

Y (More greenoases in HysanPlace helping

area's biodiversityas pilot for othergreen ideas p.3)

NI ("construction-related health andsafety risks" p.16;

Code of Ethicsp.18)

10 16 Sun HungKai (SHK)

Prop *LOOPParticipant

N SustainabilityReport

2013/13:http://www.shkp.com/Html/CSR/SHK_SR_2013_En

g.pdf

Properties &Construction -

Properties(HSIC*)

HKD312,578,989,963

HKD385,912,000,000

HKD40,329,000,000

HKD15.2757

Y (Envt'l Mgt -Policy,32)

Y (Data tables -Energy Use and

Emissions - CO2eemissions, 44)

Y (Data tables -Energy Use and

Emissions - CO2eemissions, 44)

Y (Data Tables -Materials and

Waste Data forSample

ConstructionSites, 45)

Y (Data Tables -Materials and

Waste Data forSample

ConstructionSites, 45)

Y (1. CarbonReduction

Labelling Systembby HKQAA, 2.

Low-carbon OfficeOperation

Programme byWWF)

Y (36) Y (34) Y (44) N Y (34-36) Y (21,34) N/A Y (34-44) Y (33,38) Y (investing inRE, 34)

11 19 Swire Pacific‘A’

N 2013 AnnualReport:

http://www.swirepacific.com/en/ir/reports/ar13.pdf

Conglomerates-

Conglomerates(HSIC*)

HKD 89,380,597,950 HKD220,297,000,000

HKD13,291,000,000

HKD 8.8334 Y (90-92) Y (93) Y (CO2e,46) NI NI Y (48,92) Y (92) Y (92-95) Y (239) Y (5,11) Y (92-95) Y (N/A onsourcing water,

94,95)

N (Even thoughenergty intensity

of productsaccounted for,

239)

Y (92) Y (90-96) Y (1. CarbonDesk - emissionstrading scheme,94 & Swire sus

fund, 96)

12 54 HopewellHldgs -*LOOP

participant

N SustainabilityReport

2012/13:http://www.hopewellholdings.com/ebook_sustainability_report/cs_report_eng_2013/2012_13_SD_Repor

t_Eng.pdf

Conglomerates-

Conglomerates(HSIC*)

HKD 23,523,890,967 HKD43,243,153,000

HKD12,206,300,000

HKD13.9671

Y (24) Y (CO2e, 48) Y (50) Y (constructionwaste, 48)

Y (commercialwaste, 48)

Y (improve energyefficiency, 24)

Y (Wastewi$e, 26) Y (EV, 20-21;overall

efficiency 24-26)

Y (48-50) Y ( water used bydiff divisions, 48-

50)

Y (LED lights, IAQ24,25)

N N/A Y? (20) Y (22-25) Y (ISO internalauditors, 22 &

envt'lconsiderations

into diff divisions,26,28)

13 66 **MTRCorporation -http://www.mtr.com.hk/eng/sustainability/2013rpt/pe

rf-grii.php

N SustainabilityReport 2013:http://www.mtr.com.hk/eng/sustainability/2013rpt/MTR_SR%202013_24Jun_

Final.pdf

ConsumerServices -

Transportation(HSIC*)

HKD176,138,151,726

HKD152,557,000,000

HKD13,025,000,000

HKD 2.2469 Y (CC policy) Y? (50,53) Y (50,53) Y? (generalwastes fromextension

projects, 50)

Y (50) Y (CDPSubmission)

Y (24) Y (*corporatesustainability mgt

framework

Y (50,53) Y (50,53) Y (carbon lifecycle assessment

23, energyefficiency ratio by

assets)

N (emphasis onelectricity?)

N/A Y (corporatebiodiversity policy

+ 24)

Y (24) Y (Supplier Codeof Practice 25,

Sus competitiveadvantage model

-http://www.mtr.com.hk/eng/sustainability/2013rpt/sust-

mtr.php#risk-mana)

14 83 Sino Land N SustainabilityReview2013:

http://www.sino.com/Sino/media/Sino/ENG/PDF/Publications/Sust

ainability-Report/2013/Sino_Land_SR2013.pdf

Properties &Construction -

Properties(HSIC*)

HKD 78,093,845,928 HKD104,806,214,612

HKD11,687,131,302

HKD 1.9711 N N N N N N Y (Food WiseHong Kong

Campaign, 11)

Y (10-13) N N N Y (13) N/A N Y (Manifesto ofEE in Buildings,

10)

N

15 101 Hang LungProp - *2012Sus Report

N SustainabilityReport 2012:http://www.hanglung.com/Libraries/Do

cument_-_Sustainability/Sustainability_Report_2012.sflb.ashx

Properties &Construction -

Properties(HSIC*)

HKD106,972,202,930

HKD124,534,000,000

HKD7,212,000,000

HKD 1.6105 N N N N N Y (38) Y (36, tenantprograms 37)

Y? (39) Y (39) N N N N/A Y? (futurecommitments 39)

N Y (Sus Risks &Opportunitiescommittee 26)

Order Code ConstituentName

Updated ReferencedReport

IndustryClassification

Market Capitalisation Net Asset Value Net Profit (Loss) Earnings pershare

B1GD B1.1 B1.2 B1.3 B1.4 B1.5 B1.6 B2GD B2.1 B2.2 B2.3 B2.4 B2.5 B3GD B3.1 C1GD (in terms ofenvt'l risk)

Sheet2

Page 4: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

16 293 Cathay PacAir

N SustainabilityDevelopmentReport 2012:http://downloads.cathaypacific.com/cx/aboutus/sd/2012/pdf/CX_SDR12_package_eng.pdf

ConsumerServices -

Transportation(HSIC*)

HKD 57,984,868,991 HKD62,888,000,000

HKD2,620,000,000

HKD 0.666 Y (Sus DvlptPolicy)

Y (Envt'lindicators table,2012 progress

p.3)

Y ( 2012 progressp.3)

Y (2012 progress,p.4)

Y (2012 progressp.4)

Y (CC position~p.110)

Y (Waste mgtfactsheet)

Y (Resource usestrategy ~p.134)

Y (2012 progressp.4)

Y (2012 progressp.4)

Y (Emissions &Fuel efficiency~p.24, CC p.3)

Y (Waste Mgt,Water p. 15)

N N Y (Biodiversityfactsheet)

Y (Sustainablesourcing, ~p.37)

17 316 OOIL N SustainabilityReport 2013:http://www.ooilgroup.com/corporate/environmentalprotection/Documents/OOIL%20Sustainability%20Report%202013.

pdf

Industrials -Industrial

Transportation(HSIC*)

HKD 25,751,394,172 USD 4,470,807,000 USD 47,036,000 USD 0.0752 Y (Sus Strategy12, 15, 17)

Y (Performancedata summary 51)

Y (51) Y (52) Y (51,52) Y (1.Nox controlled

propulsiveengines 17; 2.

Cold ironing/AMPtechnology 17; 3.Low sulphur fuel;4. OOCL carbon

calculator 22)

Y(1.Wastewi$e, 27;2. reduce sludge

by usingspecialised

equipment e.g.homogenisers

p.18)

Y (CorporateSafety, Security &

Envt Policy 10;OOCL Terminals

21)

Y (51) Y (51) Y (EnergyEfficient ships 18;

N? N/A Y (Sustainabilitystrategy 12)

Y (1.onboard wastemgt; 2. ballast

H2O treatment; 3.Ballast H2O mgtprogram p.21)

Y (SustainableProcurement

Policy 11)

18 388 HKEx - HasESG index at

the back

N 2013Corporate

SocialResponsibilit

y Report:http://www.hkex.com.hk/eng/exchange/csr/csr_report/Documents/e140314csr.

pdf

Financials -Other

Financials(HSIC*)

HKD203,427,624,912

HKD20,405,000,000

HKD4,552,000,000

HKD 3.9512 Y (41-48) Y (41-42) *CO2ecounts

Y (41-42) Y (46) Y (47) Y (41-48) Y (46-47) Y (41-48) Y (41-43) Y (46) Y (41-45)(IS26000:2010

43)

Y (46) Y (48) Y (41,43-48) Y (41-48) Y (25,26)

19 494 Li & Fung N AnnualReport 2013- Section on

Sustainability:

http://www.lifung.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/ar2013_09.p

df

ConsumerGoods -Textiles,

Clothing &Personal Care

(HSIC*)

HKD 86,613,726,450 USD 5,036,637,000 USD 725,337,000 USD 0.0868 Y (47) Y (CO2e, 49) Y (49) N/A? Y (49) Y (Energy savinginitiatives 47,Sustainable

design guidelines48)

Y (Wastewi$e 48) Y (sustainabilitystrategy 47)

Y (49) Y ((49) Y (energy savinginitiatives, 47-48)

Y (water-efficientfaucets 48)

N Y? (47) Y? (47) Y (SustainabilityResource Center+ Code of Confuct

for Suppliers &supplier

compliancemanual 50)

20 606 China Agri N 2013 CSRReport:

http://210.6.198.11/videoplayer/201433240433276485744.pdf?ich_u_r_i=e7b205996abca53ce939f2eafe9817a7&ich_s_t_a_r_t=0&ich_e_n_d=0&ich_k_e_y=1445078918750163272475&ich_t_y_p_e=1&ich_d_i_s_k_i_d=7&ich_s_e_q=3229262&ich_u_n_i_t=

1

ConsumerGoods -

AgriculturalProducts(HSIC*)

HKD 17,587,100,640 HKD28,982,703,000

HKD1,521,319,000

HKD 0.2898 Y? (12) N N N N Y (Rewarded foremissions

reduction 29,recycling methane

30)

Y (Recycling ricehusk 31)

Y (29-31) N N Y (renovation ofcoal-fired boiler

31)

Y (recycle wheat-steeping water

31)

N/A Y (29-31) Y (29-31)(Roundtable on

Sustainable PalmOil 31)

Y? (26)

21 688 ChinaOverseas

N 2012 CSRReport:

http://www.cohl.com/csr/pdf/csr_2012_

en.pdf

Properties &Construcion -

Properties(HSIC*)

HKD187,184,039,087

HKD109,970,583,000

HKD23,043,712,000

HKD 2.8196 Y (58) N N N N Y (Videoconferences 55,LEED Buildings

56)

N Y (58,59) N N Y (LED lights, 61) Y (waterconservation mgt?

62)

N/A Y (62) Y (55-62) N

22 700 Tencent - *CSR Reportreleased in2008, no

trace of anypublished

afterwards - *Tencent

Foundation

N N/A InformationTechnology -Software &Services(HSIC*)

HKD1,249,939,233,183

RMB57,945,000,000

RMB15,502,000,000

RMB 1.6924(A)

N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A

Order Code ConstituentName

Updated ReferencedReport

IndustryClassification

Market Capitalisation Net Asset Value Net Profit (Loss) Earnings pershare

B1GD B1.1 B1.2 B1.3 B1.4 B1.5 B1.6 B2GD B2.1 B2.2 B2.3 B2.4 B2.5 B3GD B3.1 C1GD (in terms ofenvt'l risk)

Sheet2

Page 5: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

23 857 PetroChina N 2013Sustainability

Report:http://210.6.198.12/videoplayer/b6f90ee4c4be46e68ddd68ed959eb265.pdf?ich_u_r_i=05a1e74bb47110a04f3c95707a22a643&ich_s_t_a_r_t=0&ich_e_n_d=0&ich_k_e_y=1445078918750163412437&ich_t_y_p_e=1&ich_d_i_s_k_i_d=5&ich_s_e_q=3254973&ich_u_n_i_t=

1

Energy - Oil &Gas (HSIC*)Energy(CSIC**)

HKD213,520,868,000 (H

Shares only)

RMB1,132,735,000,000

RMB129,599,000,000

RMB 0.7081 Y (29) Y (SO2 released65)

N Y (Oil & CODdischarged in

waste water, 65)

Y (65) Y ( 1. emissionsreduction 29; 2.chinese certified

emissionreduction trading

33; 3. CO2flooding? 33; 4.

carbon sink forestdemonstration

project 33)

Y (30) Y (29) Y (*Reportedenergy

conserved,instead of

consumed)

N Y (energyconservationproject, 30)

Y (8, 32) N/A Y (31) Y (31,32) N

24 939 CCB N 2012 AnnualReport:

http://www.asia.ccb.com/hongkong/doc/about_us/hkg2012_financial_annual.

pdf

Financials -Banks (HSIC*)

Financials(CSIC**)

HKD1,416,058,014,093 (H

Shares only)

RMB1,065,951,000,000

RMB214,657,000,000

RMB 0.8586 Y (114-115) Y (114) Y (114) N/A N/A Y (114-118) N/A Y (114) Y (114) Y (114) Y (114-115) Y (water-savingtaps 114)

N/A Y (114-118) Y (Donations toSanjiangyuan

Ecologicalprotection

foundation 115,114-118)

Y (1. green creditstandards as keybasis for projectapproval 112, 2.

invests in RE andother subjects ofcyclic economy

112-113)

25 941 China Mobile N 2013Sustainability

Report:http://www.chinamobileltd.com/en/ir/reports/ar2013/sd2013.pdf?year=2013

Telecommunications -

Telecommunications (HSIC*)

HKD1,744,928,271,805

RMB788,773,000,000

RMB121,692,000,000

RMB 6.054 Y (Green ActionPlan, 36; 50)

Y (50) Y (50) Y (50) Y (50) Y (36-39) Y (Full-cyclepaperless

business process39; 100%recycled

wastewater? 50;waste recycled byqualified 3rd-party

50)

Y ( Green officeinitiatives 39,50;

InspectingApproach for

EnergyConservation &

EmissionsReduction 49)

Y (49) *AlternativeEnergy

consumption

Y (50) Y ( energy savinginitiatives 38,**Integrated

alternative energybase station

combining wind,solar & H2O 38Employee Code

ofConduct for Office

Energy Saving39)

Y (waterconservation

education, raisingawareness aboutwater footprint 50)

N/A Y ( Green ActionPlan, 36, 49-50)

Y (50) Y (Supplier mgtmethod requiringsuppliers to becerficated byISO14001 50)

26 992 LenovoGroup

N 2013Sustainability

Report:http://www.lenovo.com/social_responsibility/us/en/FY2013_Lenovo_Sustainability_Report.

pdf

InformationTechnology -IT Hardware

(HSIC*)

HKD112,193,362,147

USD 3,010,130,000 USD 817,228,000 USD 0.0788 Y (GlobalSustainability

Strategy 20, FYobjectives &

targets 23-25)

Y (17,80-81) Y (17, 83) Y (18) Y (18) Y (1. CC Policy73-74, RE Credits& C offsets 74-75,GHG emissions

objectives &targets 81-82)

Y (Recovery &recycling trends12-13, recycling

data 18, siterecycling 21,

waste mgt target24, 83-84, productend of life mgt 94-

97)

Y (Env'llyconscious

products program86-93; )

Y (79) Y (17,84) Y (Operationalefficiency

summary 74,energy reductionin operations with

data 79)

Y (waterconservationproject 77;

xeriscaping 84)

Y (18) Y (corporatepolicy on envt'l

affairs 63)

Y (85, envt'llyresponsibleproducts 90)

Y ( Globalprocurement 36,

EICCCompliance, etc.

37, risk mgtprogress 75)

27 2388 BOC HongKong

N CSR Report2012:

http://www.bochk.com/images/upload/about_Bochk/20130911E.

pdf (p.24 -28)

Financials -Banks (HSIC*)

HKD255,861,282,437

HKD158,813,000,000

HKD22,252,000,000

HKD 2.1046 Y (Envt'l policy) N N N N Y (25-27) Y (26-27) Y (25-27) N N Y (GreenEquipmentFinancing

Scheme & EnergyEfficiency loanscheme, water-cooled chillers,ISO50001 25)

Y (25) N/A N/A N (HK GeoparkCharity Green

Walk 28)

Y (credit riskpolicy 25, susprocurement

policy

28 3311 China StateCon

N 2012 CSRReport:

http://www.csci.com.hk/csr/pdf/csr_201

2_en.pdf

Properties &Construction -Construction

(HSIC*)

HKD 53,481,561,257 HKD16,180,825,000

HKD2,772,145,000

HKD 0.7129 Y (Low-carbonconstruction 31)

Y (34) Y (34) Y (35,38) Y (38) Y (green buildingdesign standards,

Carbonfootprinting 31)

Y (envt'l mgtstandard

procedure,recyclable

building materials31-32)

Y (31-36) Y (33,38) Y (34,38) Y (biodiesel, Evs33)

Y (waste watertreatment facilitiesfor reuse e.g. on-

site cleaning,cleaning

vehicles34)

N/A Y (31-32) Y (31-32, marinemud treatment for

reclamationprojects 35)

N (Procurementpolicy 46,

Recyclablebuilding materials

31-32)

29 3968 CM Bank(N/A as

reported atthe back oftheir report..

No dataavailable)

N 2012 CSRReport:

http://file.cmbchina.com/CMBIR/201303/047ca5e5-6ca8-459a-

b425-ff4c3debb61

7.pdf

Financials -Banks (HSIC*)

Financials(CSIC**)

HKD 71,801,694,330( H Shares only)

RMB265,465,000,000

RMB51,743,000,000

RMB 2.3009 Y (83-88) N/A N/A N/A N/A Y (green creditloan policy 83,

greenprocurement 88,

green billingproducts 89)

N/A (green office87 but no data forelectricity, wateruse in offices,paper or other

wastes)

Y (83-88) N/A N/A Y (energy saveddue to

conservation &efficiency 83-88)

N/A N/A N/A Y (88) Y (green creditloan policy 86)

Order Code ConstituentName

Updated ReferencedReport

IndustryClassification

Market Capitalisation Net Asset Value Net Profit (Loss) Earnings pershare

B1GD B1.1 B1.2 B1.3 B1.4 B1.5 B1.6 B2GD B2.1 B2.2 B2.3 B2.4 B2.5 B3GD B3.1 C1GD (in terms ofenvt'l risk)

Sheet2

Page 6: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

30 3988 Bank ofChina (2013CSR report

onlyavailable inChinese)

N 2013 CSRReport (InChinese):

http://pic.bankofchina.com/bocappd/report/201403/P02014032663772340186

6.pdf

Financials -Banks (HSIC*)

Financials(CSIC**)

HKD306,893,754,370 ( H

Shares only)

RMB923,916,000,000

RMB156,911,000,000

RMB 0.5621 Y (74-75) Y (75) Y (75) NI NI Y (guidelines forgreen credit 72,green financialproducts 73)

Y (74-75) Y (74-75) Y (75) Y (75) Y (74-75) Y (74-75) N/A N/A N/A NI

Order Code ConstituentName

Updated ReferencedReport

IndustryClassification

Market Capitalisation Net Asset Value Net Profit (Loss) Earnings pershare

B1GD B1.1 B1.2 B1.3 B1.4 B1.5 B1.6 B2GD B2.1 B2.2 B2.3 B2.4 B2.5 B3GD B3.1 C1GD (in terms ofenvt'l risk)

Sheet2

Page 7: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

Red <5 KPIsYellow 6 - 11 KPIsGreen >12 KPIsTotal: 12 KPIs & 4 general disclosure options

Color Code

Sheet3

Page 8: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

UNClass

Code Characteristics

ExplosiveAn explosive substance or waste is a solid or liquidsubstance or waste (or mixture of substances orwastes) which is in itself capable by chemical reactionof producing gas at such a temperature and pressureand at such a speed as to cause damage to

the surroundings.Flammable liquidsThe word “flammable” has the same meaning as“inflammable”. Flammable liquids are liquids, ormixtures of liquids, or liquids containing solids insolution or suspension (for example, paints, varnishes,lacquers, etc., but not including substances or wastesotherwise classified on account of their dangerouscharacteristics) which give off a flammable vapour attemperatures of not more than 60.5ºC, closed-cup test,or not more than 65.6ºC, open-cup test. (Since theresults of open-cup tests and of closed-cup tests are notstrictly comparable and even individual results by thesame test are often variable, regulations varying fromthe above figures to make allowance for suchdifferences would be within the spirit of this definition.)

Flammable SolidsSolids, or waste solids, other than those classed asexplosives, which under conditions encountered intransport are readily combustible, or may cause orcontribute to fire through friction.

Substances or wastes liable to spontaneous combustion

Substances or wastes which are liable to spontaneousheating under normal conditions encountered intransport, or to heating up on contact with air, and beingthen liable to catch fire.

Substances or wastes which, in contact with water emitflammable gasesSubstances or wastes which, by interaction with water,are liable to become spontaneously flammable or togive off flammable gases in dangerous quantities.

Oxidizing

ANNEX IIILIST OF HAZARDOUS CHARACTERISTICS

1H1

3H3

4.1H4.1

4.2H4.2

4.3H4.3

5.1H5.1

Sheet4

Page 9: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

Substances or wastes which, while in themselves notnecessarily combustible, may, generally by yieldingoxygen cause, or contribute to, the combustion of othermaterials.

Organic PeroxidesOrganic substances or wastes which contain thebivalent-o-o-structure are thermally unstable substanceswhich may undergo exothermic self-acceleratingdecomposition

Poisonous (Acute)Substances or wastes liable either to cause death orserious injury or to harm human health if swallowed orinhaled or by skin contact

Infectious substancesSubstances or wastes containing viable microorganisms or their toxins which are known or suspectedto cause disease in animals or humans

CorrosivesSubstances or wastes which, by chemical action, willcause severe damage when in contact with living tissue,or, in the case of leakage, will materially damage, oreven destroy, other goods or the means of transport;they may also cause other hazards

Liberation of toxic gases in contact with air or water

Substances or wastes which, by interaction with air orwater, are liable to give off toxic gases in dangerousquantities

Toxic (Delayed or chronic)Substances or wastes which, if they are inhaled oringested or if they penetrate the skin, may involvedelayed or chronic effects, including carcinogenicity

EcotoxicSubstances or wastes which if released present or maypresent immediate or delayed adverse impacts to theenvironment by means of bioaccumulation and/or toxiceffects upon biotic systems

9H13 Capable, by any means, after disposal, of yieldinganother material, e.g. leachate, which possesses any ofthe characteristics listed above

5.2H5.2

6.1H6.1

6.2H6.2

8H8

9H10

9H11

9H12

TestsThe potential hazards posed by certain types of wastes are not yet fully documented;tests to define quantitatively these hazards do not exist. Further research isnecessary in order to develop means to characerise potential hazards posed to manand/or the environment by these wastes. Standardized tests have been derived withrespect to pure substances and materials. Many countries have developed nationaltests which can apply to mterials listed in Annex I, in order to decide if thesematerials exhibit any of the characteristics listed in this Annex.

Sheet4

Page 10: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

Sheet5

Page 11: Evaluation table 2.41.xls(2)

Sheet5