Upload
jacknickelson
View
219
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
FOR USE WITH FINANCIAL PROFESSIONALS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
AFP of Atlanta Education Day --- August 19, 2009
Kevin H. Brown, CIMA
Senior Vice President, Dreyfus Investments
A Division of BNY Mellon Asset Management
Stress in Credit Markets: Implications for Short Term Investing
2 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Outline
I. Credit Crisis: Genesis and Unraveling
1. What is “credit”
2. Cause vs. effect
3. Timeline
II. Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
1. Federal Government
2. Issuers
3. Investors
4. Asset Managers & Securities Dealers
5. Industry Assets
III. What’s Changed: Implications for Short Term Investing
1. Treasury Due Diligence
2. Risk factors Redefined
3. Regulatory Proposals
3 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
I. Credit Crisis: Genesis and Unraveling
4 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Genesis of Credit Crisis
What does “credit” mean?
• Barron’s Financial Guides, 2007 edition:
“At its loftiest, it is defined in Dun & Bradstreet’s motto:
‘Credit: Man’s Confidence in Man’”
• Quantitative vs. Qualitative
• This crisis: significant qualitative factors
5 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Genesis of Credit Crisis
Community Reinvestment Act Credit forcibly extended to wrong obligors
Low Interest Rates Artificial price escalation of leveraged assets, exaggerated purchase capacity, artificial demand
Lowered Consumer Credit Standards
Credit wrongly extended
Borrower Behavior Credit wrongly extended, risk escalation
Lax mortgage issuer regulation Improper issuance & risk calibration
Rating Agency Policies Inaccurate ratings; risks remain unidentified
Securitization Buck-passing of risk
Excessive investment bank leverage
Exaggerated crisis amplitude
Subprime borrower paying habits
Slow-motion collapse, recession
CAUSE EFFECT
6 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Genesis of Credit Crisis
Results:
• Created updraft of ever-escalating house prices
• Housing development & construction rose to meet demand
• Artificial and unsustainable support of both supply and demand
• Many ignored what was to many an obvious bubble in real estate price/demand
And then the bubble started to burst.
7 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Unraveling and Unwinding
8 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
*A Structured Investment Vehicle is a triple A-rated leveraged investment vehicle that seeks to maximize spread income through proactive management of liabilities and assets.
Unraveling and Unwinding
Phase 1: New Century June 2007
Investor flight to quality
Fed begins easing
Quick acceptance of lower yields
Phase 2: Broader Collateralized Debt Obligation (CDO) & Collateralized Mortgage Obligation (CMO) problems (Quantitative vs Qualitative judgments)
Phase 3: Structured Investment Vehicle (SIV) * Commercial Paper issuers with heavy CDO & CMO holdings…October 2007
Phase 4: State Pools, Common Fund
9 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Unraveling and Unwinding
Phase 5: Asset-Backed Commercial Paper: questions arise
sponsor? transparency? LOC?
Phase 6: Municipal securities: bank LOCs
Phase 7: Auction Rate Securities: Failed Auctions Jan 2008
Merrill, UBS, Citi: $18bb, $11bb, $8bb; sand bags relative to market
$330bb market
morphed into classic bank run
Phase 8: Bear Stearns in Mar 2008; broader Repurchase Counterparty Questions
term or overnight?
credit review of counterparty?
10 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Unraveling and Unwinding
Phase 9: Contraction of Commercial Paper issuance
Phase 10: Long list of AAA’s fall to the axe
Phase 11: The crescendo (the latest)
Lehman; September 15, 2008
Obligor to many; Reserve Prime fund broke buck
1.2%; $785mm face value; flood of redemptions; then runs
Public perception of Bruce Bent; rhetoric
Huge fund; many institutional investors affected
Firm size: capital support not an option
11 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Unraveling and Unwinding
CORE ISSUES?
• People didn’t pay their bills
• Violated D & B’s “essence of credit”: Man’s confidence in Man
• Liquidity Problems, Valuation Problems
• Will I get paid?
12 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Unraveling and Unwinding
Phase 12: Era of the marriage of the titans & acronym proliferation;
heightened credit market dysfunction
• Private
B of A & Merrill Lynch
JP Morgan & WaMu
Wells & Wachovia
• Public (selected)
TARP
CPFF
SEC NO Action Letter
TLGP
MMIFF
Spending Stimulus
13 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Unraveling and Unwinding
Phase 13:
• Continued Fed tightening, persistently low yields
• Money Market Fund Reaction: Trading restrictions, Fee waivers
• Dec 2008: Treasurys trading at negative yields
Sample investment opportunity
> You give me $1,000,000
- And 60 days later, I’ll give you $999,833.33
- - $166.67 HPR
- Negative 1 bp return (annualized)
- Treasury fund balances peaked Nov 08 at $720bb; $550bb July 2009
14 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Unraveling and Unwinding
• Issuing credit is a slow process
• Unraveling is a slow process
• Yet Confidence evaporated quickly
• Confidence rebuilding is a slow process
15 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Who Did What?
II. Short Term Investing Participants
16 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
1. Federal Government
2. Issuers
3. Investors
4. Asset Managers, Securities Dealers, Capital Markets
5. Industry Assets
17 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
1. Federal Government
• TARP
• Treasury Guarantee Program for mmfs
• CPFF
• SEC NO Action Letter
• TLGP
• MMIFF
18 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
2. Issuers of Short Term Investments
• Some had to pay more as rates spiked
• Some lost financing altogether (CP contraction from $2.5 to $1.6 trillion in 5 months)
• Bank lines reduced
• Typical short-term financing vehicles became suddenly more expensive
• Cut growth, shed costs
19 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
3. Investors
• From Sept 2008 onward, steep risk retrenchment; abated in 2009
• Treasury rally in 2009
• Due Diligence Process Changes (details to come)
• Piled into money market funds (certain funds; certain families)
20 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
4. Asset Managers, Securities Dealers, Capital Markets
• Winners and losers among firms
• Industry asset explosion
• Despite bank deposit growth & very competitive CD rates
21 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
5196 111 109
323
18
-122 -84
52
444
775
-129
142
1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Q12009
Money Market Funds
Net New Cash Flow – ($ Billions)
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
Source: Investment Company Institute & Crane Data’s “Money Fund Intelligence Reports,” various dates
22 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
516 648 7861,154 1,209 1,115 1,062 1,167 1,349
1,875
2,470 2,388835
9651,059
1,063937 851 874
1,005
1,199
1,360 1,313
1,132
1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Jun-09
Institutional Retail
1,351
2,2712,285
1,8451,613
2,0481913
2,052
3,074
38303,701
2,358
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
Assets in Taxable and Tax-Exempt Money Funds(Year-End; $ Billions)
Source: Imoneynet.com’s “Money Market Insight,” multiple issues from 2009
23 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
U.S. Taxable MMF Assets and Annual Returns
24 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
U.S. Tax-Exempt MMF Assets and Annual Returns
25 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 Q12009
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Source: Federal Reserve’s “Flow of Funds” Tables, Q1 2009
Percentage of Businesses’ cash held in money market funds
26 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007
Bank Deposits 37.2 25 27.1 100 100 100Money Market Funds 31.8 39.4 30.9 78 82 76
Treasury Bills 9.2 8.1 1.9 83 100 100Commercial Paper 3.5 6.7 9.4 55 66 69Agency Securities 3.4 5.3 3.2 56 59 56
Repo 3.1 3.5 6.3 50 55 57Eurodollar Deposits 2.9 6 4.6 37 49 42
Separately Managed Accts 2.1 1.5 3.4 16 17 20Enhanced Cash 1.9 1.6 2.2 14 15 22
Asset-Backed Securities 0.8 0.7 1.1 20 31 33Municipal Securities 0.7 0 1.1 28 36 38
Auction Rate Securities 0.3 0.9 5.1 8 18 33VDRNs 0.2 0 1.5 12 17 25
Other 2.9 1.3 2.2 n/a n/a n/aMean # of Investment Vehicles 2.4 2.4 2.7 3.7 4 6.4
Organizations’ Short-Term Investments
Source: AFP 2009 Liquidity Survey
Allocation Permitted Use
27 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
*Institutional Investor, July/August 2009 issue
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
• Top 80 US asset managers
(any manager < $2bb in cash)
• $7.87 trillion AUM in cash & cash equivalents at 12-31-08*
• Top 10 Assets under Mgmt:
$3,619,522,000,000
• Top 10 Firms’ Market Share: 46%
Rank Firm
Cash & Equiv. AUM ($billion)
1 JP Morgan 612.8
2 Fidelity 592.6
3 State Street 468.5
4 BNY Mellon (Dreyfus)
386.0
5 Federated 356.7
6 BlackRock 338.4
7 Goldman Sachs 285.8
8 Northern Trust 241.0
9 Wells Fargo 227.9
10 Charles Schwab 209.7
28 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
*Imoneynet “Money Fund Analyzer as of 7-31-09
**Excludes offshore money market fund balances, if any
Short Term Investing: Participants’ Reactions
• $3.690 trillion AUM in all domestic money market funds at 7-31-09*
• Top 10 Firms’ AUM:
$2,520,500,000,000
• Top 10 Firms’ Market Share: 68%
Rank Firm MMF AUM**
1 Fidelity 511.5
2 JP Morgan 390.6
3 Federated 294.2
4 Dreyfus (BNY) 246.0
5 BlackRock 240.8
6 Goldman Sachs 216.9
7 Vanguard 192.0
8 Schwab 186.5
9 Wells Fargo 121.7
10 Columbia (B of A)
120.3
29 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
III. What’s Changed? Implications for Short Term Investing
• Treasury Due Diligence Process
• Risk Factors Redefined
• Regulatory Proposals
30 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Treasury Due Diligence Process
People, Process, Philosophy
• People:
Tenure of staff
Professional background
Credit & Sector expertise
Compensation
Reporting structure
31 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Treasury Due Diligence Process
People, Process, Philosophy
• Process:
Risk Management: identify all
Credit Criteria
Concentration rules
Creation of Buy List
Sector Focus
Team Decision Making
Capital Commitments Committee
Limits definitions: issuer, amount, tenor
32 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Treasury Due Diligence Process
People, Process, Philosophy
• Philosophy:
Disciplined investment approach
Emphasis on fundamentals: liquidity, ratings, structure
2a-7 approved list should have large, liquid issuers with multiple dealer support
Risk Budgeting
33 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Treasury Due Diligence Process
Portfolio Construction : What to ask your asset manager
• Hierarchy: capital preservation, liquidity, yield
• Investment strategy: global macro-economic indicators, Federal Reserve policy, current credit markets
• Yield curve, Fed actions: cornerstones of WAM strategy Long and wrong Short and under
• Pre-trade and post-trade compliance
• Stress Tests
• Active management of cash positions
• Consistent sell discipline
• Downgrade policy
34 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Risk Factors Redefined
….For Investors in Money Market Funds & Separate Accounts
35 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Risk Factors Redefined
Investment Manager Analysis
• Performance History
• Security Selection Track Record
• Fund Closings, large trade warnings & acceptance
• Credit Analyst/Portfolio Manager Accessibility
• Holdings Transparency
• Business structure of Sponsor
• Size of asset management in relation to firm
• Length of participation in asset management
Fund Analysis
• WAM strategy & results
• Quality of credit research
• Tolerance for fringe asset classes
• Counterparty evaluation
36 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Risk Factors Redefined
Shareholder Base
• Retail vs institutional client base
• Access vehicle: portals, intermediaries, direct
Systemic Factors
• Participation in government insurance & liquidity programs
• Evolving regulation structure (proposed 2a-7 amendments)
• Investor perception
• Rumors and innuendo
37 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
*Crane Data’s “Money Fund Intelligence,” March 2009
Risk Factors Redefined
Bottom line: How is the Treasury’s process changing?
Implementing Increased Due Diligence
• Limits by fund, fund family, ratings, bank-owned funds
• Scrubbing Holdings
• Holding Aggregation
• Portal Migration ($200bb; 8% of institutional mmf AUM)*
38 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Risk Factors Redefined
Implementing Increased Due Diligence
• Manager Research
Statistics, performance
> Crane Data
> Imoneynet.com
News & Reporting
> Ignites.com
> Fundfire.com
Consultants & Financial Advisors
39 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Regulatory Changes
Investment Company Institute (ICI)
• Report of the Money Market Working Group (MWWG) released March 17, 2009
Obama Administration: June 17, 2009
• Report on Financial Regulatory Reform
SEC on June 24, 2009: proposed 2a-7 amendments
• Goal: “significantly strengthen the regulatory framework for money market funds to increase their resilience to economic stresses and reduce the risks of runs on the funds.”
40 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Investment Company Act of 1940: Rule 2a-7
Sets Standards for:
a. Credit Quality
b. Maturity
c. Diversification
d. Defines Board of Director Responsibilities
Regulatory Changes
41 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Proposed 2a-7 Amendments
Portfolio Risk
• Shorter Average Maturity
• New Weighted Average Life
• Credit Quality Strengthened
• Periodic Stress Tests
Liquidity
• No illiquid
• Retail vs. Institutional
• Daily and Weekly Standards ; General Liquidity Standard
42 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
Proposed 2a-7 Amendments
Holdings Disclosures
Special Operations
• Processing orders at other than $1/share
• Suspension of Redemptions
• Affiliate Purchases
43 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
*Atlanta Business Chronicle, Aug 7-13, 2009, page 29A
Wisdom & Insight: A Dialectic
Wisdom from Tom Bell, former CEO of Cousins Properties*
• July 20, 2009 speech to Rotary Club of Atlanta:
1st priority: get Fed government to stop changing rules
Markets frightened by unpredictable government rule-making
Can’t underwrite risk without rules
No markets without rules
Can’t make investments without rules
Can’t buy or sell without rules
If you can’t trade, there is no market
No market, can’t set a price
No price, nothing sells
Nothing sells, nothing grows
Jobs aren’t created, taxes aren’t paid
So, without free markets, without risk and reward, wealth creation and job creation stops
44 FOR USE WITH INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS ONLY. NOT FOR USE WITH THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
© 2009 MBSC Securities Corporation, Distributor for The Dreyfus Family of Funds.
Dreyfus Cash Investment Services is a division of MBSC Securities Corporation
Not FDIC-insured. Not bank-guaranteed. May lose value.
An investment in any money market fund is not insured or guaranteed by the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation or any other governmental agency. Although a money market fund seeks
to preserve the value of your investment at $1.00 per share, it is possible to lose money by
investing in a money market fund. Yield fluctuates. Past performance is no guarantee of future
results.
Short-term corporate and asset-backed securities, while rated in the highest rating category by
one or more NRSRO (or if an unrated municipal, deemed of comparable quality by Dreyfus),
involve credit and liquidity risks and risk of principal loss.