3
SARMIENTO III VS MISON AND CARAGUE Posted by kaye lee on 11:13 PM 15 SCRA 5!" G#R# No# $""$! De%e&be' 1$ 1"($ )A**o+nt+n, Po-e'. /ACTS: M+son -as a**o+nted as t0e Co&&+ss+one' o t0e 2'ea o Csto&s and Ca'a,e as t0e Se%'eta'y o t0e De*a't&ent o 2d,et4 -+t0ot t0e %on'&at+ on o t0e Co&&+ss+on on A**o+nt&ents# Sa'&+ento assa+led t0e a**o+nt&ents as n%onst+tt+onal by 'eason o +ts not 0a6+n, been %on'&ed by CoA# ISSUE: 70et0e' o' not t0e a**o+nt&ent +s 6al+d# RU8ING:  9 es# T0e P' es+dent a%ted -+t0+n 0e' %onst+tt+onal at0o'+ty and * o-e' +n a** o+nt+n, Sal6ado' M+son4 -+t0ot sb&+tt+ n, 0+s no&+nat+on to t0e CoA o' %on'&at+on# e +s t0s ent+tled to e;e'%+se t0e ll at0o'+ty and n%t+ons o t0e o<%e and to 'e%e+6e all t0e sala'+es and e&ol&ents *e'ta+n+n, t0e'eto# Unde' Se% 1 A't# VII o t0e 1"($ Const+tt+on4 t0e'e a'e ! ,'o*s o o<%e's -0o& t0e P'es+dent s0all a**o+nt: 1st4 a**o+nt&ent o e;e%t+6e de*a't&ents and b'eas 0eads4 a&bassado's4 ot0e' *bl+% &+n+ste's4 %onsls4 o<%e's o t0e a'&ed o'%es 'o& t0e 'ank o %olonel o' na6al %a*ta+n4 and ot0e' o<%e's -+t0 t0e %onsent and %on'&at+on o t0e CoA# =nd4 all ot0e' Go6e'n&ent o<%e's -0ose a**o+nt&ents a'e not ot0e'-+se *'o6+ded by la-> 3'd t0ose -0o& t0e P'es+dent &ay be at0o'+?ed by t0e la- to a**o+nt> !t04 lo-@'ank+n, o<%e's -0ose a**o+nt &ents t0e Con,'ess &ay by la- 6est +n t0e P'es+dent alone# /+'st ,'o* o o<%e's +s %lea'ly a**o+nted -+t0 t0e %onsent o t0e Co&&+ss+on on A**o+nt&ents # A**o+nt&ents o s%0 o<%e's a'e +n+t+ated by no&+nat+on and4 + t0e no&+nat+on +s %on'&ed by t0e Co&&+ss+on on A**o+nt&ents4 t0e P'es+dent a**o+nts#

I Need Scribid Shit 11

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

8/16/2019 I Need Scribid Shit 11

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/i-need-scribid-shit-11 1/3

8/16/2019 I Need Scribid Shit 11

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/i-need-scribid-shit-11 2/3

=nd4 3'd and !t0 ,'o* o o<%e's a'e t0e *'esent bone o %ontent+on# 2y ollo-+n,

t0e a%%e*ted 'le +n %onst+tt+onal and statto'y %onst'%t+on t0at an e;*'ess

en&e'at+on o sbe%ts e;%ldes ot0e's not en&e'ated4 +t -old ollo- t0at only

t0ose a**o+nt&ents to *os+t+ons e;*'essly stated +n t0e 'st ,'o* 'eB+'e t0e

%onsent %on'&at+on o t0e Co&&+ss+on on A**o+nt&ents#

It +s e6+dent t0at t0e *os+t+on o Co&&+ss+one' o t0e 2'ea o Csto&s a b'ea

0ead +s not one o t0ose -+t0+n t0e 'st ,'o* o a**o+nt&ents -0e'e t0e %onsent

o t0e Co&&+ss+on on A**o+nt&ents +s 'eB+'ed# T0e 1"($ Const+tt+on del+be'ately

e;%lded t0e *os+t+on o 0eads o b'eas 'o& a**o+nt&ents t0at need t0e

%onsent %on'&at+on o t0e Co&&+ss+on on A**o+nt&ents#

8e,o 6s CSC4 1!3 SCRA 3=$

Posted by P+s Mo'ados on No6e&be' $4 =F11

Pbl+% O<%e'4 A**o+nt&ents4 CSC

/a%ts: Pet+t+one' -as a**o+nted Ad&+n O<%e' II4 O<%e o t0e C+ty Mayo'4 Ceb C+ty4

by Mayo' Solon# T0e a**o+nt&ent -as des%'+bed as *e'&anentH bt t0e CSC

a**'o6ed +t as te&*o'a'y4H sbe%t to t0e nal a%t+on taken +n t0e *'otest led by

t0e *'+6ate 'es*ondent and anot0e' e&*loyee#

SbseBently4 t0e CSC ond t0e *'+6ate 'es*ondent bette' Bal+ed t0an t0e

*et+t+one' o' t0e %ontested *os+t+on and4 a%%o'd+n,ly d+'e%ted t0at t0e latte' be

a**o+nted to sa+d *os+t+on +n *la%e o t0e *et+t+one' -0ose a**o+nt&ent +s 'e6oked#

en%e4 t0e *'+6ate 'es*ondent -as so a**o+nted to t0e *os+t+on by Mayo' Dte'te4

t0e ne- &ayo'#

 T0e *et+t+one'4 +n6ok+n, 0+s ea'l+e' *e'&anent a**o+nt&ent4 Best+ons t0e o'de' and

t0e 6al+d+ty o t0e 'es*ondents a**o+nt&ent#

Isse: 7ON t0e CSC +s at0o'+?ed to d+sa**'o6e a *e'&anent a**o+nt&ent on t0e

,'ond t0at anot0e' *e'son +s bette' Bal+ed t0an t0e a**o+ntee and4 on t0e bas+s

o t0+s nd+n,4 o'de' 0+s 'e*la%e&ent#

eld: No# T0e a**o+nt&ent o t0e *et+t+one' -as not te&*o'a'y bt *e'&anent and

-as t0e'eo'e *'ote%ted by Const+tt+on# T0e a**o+nt+n, at0o'+ty +nd+%ated t0at +t

8/16/2019 I Need Scribid Shit 11

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/i-need-scribid-shit-11 3/3

-as *e'&anent4 as 0e 0ad t0e '+,0t to do so4 and +t -as not o' t0e 'es*ondent CSC

to 'e6e'se 0+& and %all +t te&*o'a'y#

Se%t+on "04 A't V o t0e C+6+l Se'6+%e De%'ee *'o6+des t0at t0e Co&&+ss+on s0all

0a6e +nte' al+a t0e *o-e' to Ja**'o6e all a**o+nt&ents4 -0et0e' o'+,+nal o'*'o&ot+onal4 to *os+t+ons +n t0e %+6+l se'6+%eJ J#and d+sa**'o6e t0ose -0e'e t0e

a**o+ntees do not *ossess a**'o*'+ate el+,+b+l+ty o' 'eB+'ed Bal+%at+ons#H

 T0e CSC +s not e&*o-e'ed to dete'&+ne t0e k+nd o' nat'e o t0e a**o+nt&ent

e;tended by t0e a**o+nt+n, o<%e'4 +ts at0o'+ty be+n, l+&+ted to a**'o6+n, o'

'e6+e-+n, t0e a**o+nt&ent +n t0e l+,0t o t0e 'eB+'e&ents o t0e CSC 8a-# 70en

t0e a**o+ntee +s Bal+ed and all t0e ot0e' le,al 'eB+'e&ents a'e sat+sed4 t0e

Co&&+ss+on 0as no %0o+%e bt to attest to t0e a**o+nt&ent +n a%%o'dan%e -+t0 t0e

CSC 8a-s#

CSC +s -+t0ot at0o'+ty to 'e6oke an a**o+nt&ent be%ase o +ts bel+e t0at anot0e'

*e'son -as bette' Bal+ed4 -0+%0 +s an en%'oa%0&ent on t0e d+s%'et+on 6ested

solely +n t0e %+ty &ayo'#