IF Government Pensions Report Definitive - image.guardian.co.uk · IF Government Pensions Report Definitive - image.guardian.co.uk ... 7 | !!!!!

i

!!

!

"#$!%&'$#()$(*!+$(,-&(,!.(/0-#!

1(!*2$!3&4(5$#!%$($#0*-&(6!!!

!

!

"#$%&'(!)*+!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!$10+!/2!%0!%-2)+&3!(24,)-)%&05!%$/!*26!/703!)-0!62-&+1!

),)-/!'*!/0-41!28!/)90:$,!)*+!/70!%0*08'/1!/703!,)3;<!!

"#$%!&'(()*+!,'-*.)#((/!

!

!

"=2-+!>$//2*?1! -0(2440*+)/'2*1!2*!,$%&'(! 10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!7).0! &0+! /2!()&&1! 82-! '*+$1/-')&!

)(/'2*!%3!,$%&'(!10(/2-!$*'2*15!%$/!/70!-0)&'/3!'1!/7)/!7'1!,-2,21)&1!6'&&!1/'&&!&0).0!/704!6'/7!

7$@0&3!@0*0-2$1!,0*1'2*1!/7)/!421/!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-90-1!(2$&+!*0.0-!72,0!/2!)(7'0.0;<!

!

0#.!12(3'445!67$*8(#$!9*4*$'2!#:!;'<'=!

!

!

"A7)/!60B.0!100*!'1!726!.0-3!C$'(9&3!/70!)11$4,/'2*1!67'(7!$*+0-,'**0+!43!)1101140*/1!

28! /70! &2*@:/0-4! 1$1/)'*)%'&'/3! 28! ,$%&'(! 10-.'(0! ,0*1'2*1! 7).0! %00*! 1726*! /2! %0! /22!

2,/'4'1/'(D!E7)/!'1!@2'*@!/2!)880(/!/70!1$1/)'*)%'&'/3!28!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!'*!)!*0@)/'.0!

6)3;<!

"#$%!>#)4!?@((#4A!

!

7&#$8&#9!:;!<9!=&8>$#?!@&A/&4(9$#!

"4*2&#,B!"(54,!=0(*&(?!@&A/&4(9$#?!C0'-9!D-(5)0(?!E$,$0#F2$#!

!

"G#-H!IJKI!!

!L2$!M(*$#5$($#0*-&(0H!7&4(90*-&(?!888N-/N&#5N4>?!@20#-*;!O&B!KKPI!IQJ!

!L2$!M(*$#5$($#0*-&(0H!7&4(90*-&(?!888N-/N&#5N4>?!@20#-*;!O&B!KKPI!IQJ

!

@&(*$(*,!

!

!

!

!

! +05$!

! !

7&#$8&#9!! F!

! !

<R$F4*-'$!S4))0#;! FFF!

! !

T0F>5#&4(9! G!

! !

+4:H-F!S$F*&#!+$(,-&(,!',!+#-'0*$!S$F*&#!+$(,-&(,!! H!

! !

M(9-'-940H!+4:H-F!S$F*&#!+$(,-&(!SF2$)$,B!

!

!

• I>J!#0*1'2*!J(7040! GK!

• L'.'&!J0-.'(0!#0*1'2*!J(7040! GM!

• E0)(70-1B!#0*1'2*!J(7040! GH!

• N-40+!O2-(01!#0*1'2*!J(7040! GP!

! !

S&H4*-&(,! GQ!

! !

@&(FH4,-&(! RG!

!

E$/$#$(F$,! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! RK

L2$!M(*$#5$($#0*-&(0H!7&4(90*-&(?!888N-/N&#5N4>?!@20#-*;!O&B!KKPI!IQJ

7&#$8&#9!

!

S-'/)'*B1!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!131/04!'1!)!4011;!=)-@0&3!$*8$*+0+5!'/!6'&&!(21/!/70!E-0)1$-3!

42-0!/7)*!)!/-'&&'2*!,2$*+1!'*!/70!(24'*@!+0()+01;!T.0-32*05!'/!100415!'1!)*@-3!about that;!

#$%&'(! 10(/2-! 62-90-1! 800&! /70'-! ,0*1'2*1! 7).0! %00*! $*-0)12*)%&3! /)-@0/0+! 82-! ($/1! %3! )!

@2.0-*40*/!,$-1$'*@!8'1()&!)$1/0-'/3;!E703!()*!U$1/'8')%&3!(&)'4!/7)/!/70'-!%2$*/'8$&!,0*1'2*!

)@-0040*/1!60-0!,)-/!)*+!,)-(0&!28!/70'-!04,&2340*/!,)(9)@01!)*+!172$&+!%0!72*2$-0+!)1!

1$(7;!I265!/703!)-0!,2'10+!/2!1/-'90;!

V0)*67'&0! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! 62-90-1! 7).0! )! ,)-/'($&)-! -0)12*! /2! 800&! $*7),,3! )%2$/! /70!

1'/$)/'2*W! /70'-! ,0*1'2*1! )-0! *2/! 2*&3! 4$(7! 42-0! ,)-1'42*'2$15! %$/! 4)*3! X! GK! 4'&&'2*!

,02,&0!'*!8)(/!X!+2!*2/!7).0!2*0!)/!)&&;!#$/!1'4,&35!)!(7)14!7)1!2,0*0+!$,!%0/600*!67)/!

,-'.)/0!10(/2-!)*+!,$%&'(!10(/2-!62-90-1!()*!0Y,0(/!'*!-0/'-040*/;!E70!1'Z0!)*+!+0,/7!28!/7)/!

(7)14!'1!-0.0)&0+!'*!/7'1!,),0-;!

I06!8'@$-01!(24,'&0+!%3!/70!F*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!O2$*+)/'2*!1726!/7)/!42-0!/7)*!Q[5\\\!0Y:

,$%&'(!10(/2-!62-90-1!(2&&0(/!)**$)&!,0*1'2*1!28!]RH5^\\!2-!42-0!X!S-'/)'*B1!).0-)@0!1)&)-3;!

_8! /70105!GR5\\\!-0(0'.0!42-0! /7)*!]H\5\\\!)*+!4)*3!42-0!6'&&! U2'*! /704! '*! /70!(24'*@!

+0()+0;! E2+)3! '*! S-'/)'*5! /70! ).0-)@0! )**$)&! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*! '1! )%2$/! ]Q5\\\5! /70!

,-'.)/0!10(/2-!0C$'.)&0*/!'1!)!&'//&0!42-0!/7)*!7)&8!/7)/W!]K5Q\\;!

!J240!2*!/70!-'@7/!)-@$0!/7)/!/70!1/)/0!7)1!*2!)&/0-*)/'.0!%$/!/2!8'*+!6)31!28!(&21'*@!/7'1!@),!

)*+!4)9'*@!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!42-0!)882-+)%&0!%3!($//'*@!/70!,)32$/1;!N1!)!-01$&/!/70!

@2.0-*40*/!,-2,2101!/2 %-'*@!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!)@0!'*!&'*0!6'/7!/70!1/)/0!,0*1'2*!

)@05!/2!'*(-0)10!04,&2300!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!)*+!/2!/'0!'*8&)/'2*:&'*90+!,0*1'2*!'*(-0)101!/2!/70!

L2*1$40-! #-'(0! F*+0Y! -)/70-! /7)*! /70! 8)1/0-:@-26'*@! `0/)'&! #-'(0! F*+0Y;! E70! a*'2*15!

40)*67'&05! 7).0! +'14'110+! /7010! 42.01! )1! (-0)/'*@! )! -)(0! /2! /70! %2//24! )-@$'*@! /7)/!

,$%&'(!,0*1'2*1!172$&+*B/!8)&&!1'4,&3!%0()$10!/70'-!,-'.)/0!0C$'.)&0*/1!)-0!'*)+0C$)/0;!

A7)/0.0-!32$-!2,'*'2*!2*!/70!4)//0-5!'/!10041!(0-/)'*!/7)/!%2/7!131/041!(2$&+!%0!'*!%0//0-!

17),0;! E7-2$@72$/! /70! G^^\1! ,2&'/'(')*1! 2*! /70! &08/! )*+! /70! -'@7/! +0%)/0+! 726! %01/! /2!

)++-011!/70!'4,&'()/'2*1!28!'*(-0)10+!&2*@0.'/3;!F*!)*!0-)!670*!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!8$*+1!

60-0! %224'*@! /70! 8$/$-0! 10040+!4$(7! %-'@7/0-! /7)*! '/! 7)1! /$-*0+! 2$/! /2! %0;! #-2,21)&1!

60-0!4)+0! /2!,-'.)/'10! /70!,$%&'(! 131/04!)/! /7)/! /'40!)*+!>)*1)-+!%0()40! &'//0-0+!6'/7!

0Y(7)*@01!%0/600*!/70!J2(')&!J0($-'/3!J0(-0/)-3!)*+!7'1!J7)+26!2*!/70!'11$05!/72$@7!&'//&0!

10-'2$1!-082-4!6)1!(24,&0/0+;!N!@2&+0*!2,,2-/$*'/3!6)1!&21/;!

S$/! '*! /70!+0%)/01!X!,)1/!)*+!,-010*/!X!)%2$/!,$%&'(! 10(/2-!,0*1'2*! -082-45! /70-0! '1!2*0!

(2*1/'/$0*(3!672!)-0!/22!28/0*! '@*2-0+! '*! '/!X! 8$/$-0!62-90-1;!N*+!/7)/B1!)!7$@0!,-2%&04!

%0()$10!+0('1'2*1!4)+0!2*!,0*1'2*1!/2+)3!)-0!80&/! '*!8$&&!0880(/!82-!+0()+01;!E703!)-0!/70!

2*01!672!6'&&!,)3;!!

!


!

E7'1! ,),0-! 2880-1! )! -)*@0!28! 1$@@01/'2*1! )%2$/! 726! /70! 131/04!4'@7/! %0//0-! -08&0(/! /70'-!

'*/0-01/1!)*+!%0!4)+0!42-0!-2%$1/;!F!+2!*2/!0*+2-10!)&&!28!'/1!,-2,21)&1!%$/!/70-0!)-0!/62!

/7)/!'/!10041!'4,211'%&0!/2!)-@$0!6'/7W!!

O'-1/&35! '/! '1!7'@7!/'40!/7)/!/[email protected]*40*/!%0(2401!42-0!/-)*1,)-0*/!)%2$/!8$/$-0!,$%&'(!

10(/2-!,0*1'2*!(21/1;!N1!/7'*@1!1/)*+5!/70!8$/$-0!&')%'&'/3!'1!42+0&&0+!$1'*@!)!.0-3!*)--26!10/!

28!,)-)40/0-1!)*+!'/!'1!*2/!42+0&&0+!28/0*!0*2$@7;!E70!,-2U0(/0+!$*8$*+0+!&')%'&'/3!'1!%)10+!

2*!)11$4,/'2*1!)%2$/!/70!1'Z0!28!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!62-982-(0!)*+!)!@-26/7!-)/0!67'(7!)-05!

%3! +08'*'/'2*5! $*(0-/)'*;! F/! 62$&+! %0! -0)12*)%&0! 82-! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*! 1(70401! /2!

,-2+$(0!288'(')&!,-2U0(/'2*1!28!/70'-!8$/$-0!&')%'&'/'01!0.0-3!30)-5!/7)/!'*(2-,2-)/0!)!-)*@0!28!

+'880-0*/!+'1(2$*/!-)/01!)*+!&2*@0.'/3!)11$4,/'2*1;!!

J0(2*+5! '/!10041!-0)12*)%&0!/7)/!)!()/(7:)&&!(&)$10!172$&+!$*+0-,'*!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*5!

1,0*+'*@!)1!7),,0*1!'*!b),)*;!E70!/2/)&!0Y/0*/[email protected]*40*/!0Y,0*+'/$-0!2*!,$%&'(!10(/2-!

,0*1'2*1!(2$&+!%0!(),,0+!)/5!82-!0Y)4,&05!R!,0-!(0*/!28!cd#!1'4,&3!'*!2-+0-!/2!0*1$-0!/7)/!

1,0*+'*@!'1!90,/!6'/7'*!-0)12*)%&0!&'4'/1;!F8!/70!,-2U0(/'2*1!(24,&0/0+!%3!=2-+!>$//2*!:!672!

$*+0-/229! /70! 421/! -0(0*/! ,0*1'2*! -0.'06! 82-! /70! L2)&'/'2*! :! )-0! (2--0(/5! /70! ()/(7:)&&!

62$&+*B/!),,&3!'*!)*3!0.0*/;!>0!1$@@01/1!/7)/!/70!(21/1!62*B/!0.0-!%-0)(7!G;^!,0-!(0*/!'8!7'1!

-082-41!)-0!)+2,/0+;! E7'15! /70-082-05! '1! )*!$*(2*/-2.0-1')&! ,-2,21)&! /7)/!2880-1! )! (2,,0-:

%2//240+!@$)-)*/00!/7)/!/)Y,)30-1!62*B/!@0/!)*3!42-0!*)1/3!1$-,-'101;!

>)440-0+!%3!8)&&'*@!)**$'/3!-)/01!)*+!-'1'*@!'*8&)/'2*5!,0*1'2*0-1!8-24!%2/7!/70!,$%&'(!)*+!

,-'.)/0!10(/2-1!7).0!@22+!-0)12*1!/2!800&!)*@0-;!O2-!/22!&2*@5!S-'/)'*!7)1!%00*!-$*!82-!172-/:

/0-4! )+.)*/)@0! -)/70-! /7)*! &2*@:/0-4! 1/)%'&'/3! )*+! /70! ($4$&)/'.0! 0880(/1! )-0! %0'*@! 80&/!

)(-211!/70!@0*0-)/'2*1;!E70!(7)&&0*@0!'*!/70!(24'*@!+0()+01!6'&&!%0!/2!4)90!2$-!,0*1'2*1!)1!

60&&!)1!/70!-01/!28!2$-!0(2*243!-2%$1/!2*(0!42-0;!

!

<9!=&8>$#!

L2:82$*+0-5!FO!)*+!(2:)$/72-!28!>72(*%!9*4*$'(7#4!

N,-'&!R\GR!

!

!

!

!


<R$F4*-'$!S4))0#;!

!

E70! F*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&! O2$*+)/'2*! eFO;2-@;$9f! '1! )! ,2&'/'()&&3! '*+0,0*+0*/! (7)-'/3! /7)/!

,-242/01! /70! '*/0-01/1! 28! 32$*@0-! )*+! 8$/$-0! @0*0-)/'2*1! '*! S-'/'17! ,2&'(3:4)9'*@;!! FO!

0Y)4'*0+! /70! '*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&! 8)'-*011! 28! ,0*1'2*1! '*! /70! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! e('.'&! 10-.)*/15!

/0)(70-15!/70!)-40+!82-(015!/70!,2&'(0!)*+!I>J!1/)88f!)*+!4)+0!1240!1/)-/&'*@!+'1(2.0-'01W!

g!! E70! /2/)&! &')%'&'/3! 8-24! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*! 1(70401! '1! 0C$'.)&0*/! /2! 2.0-! ]G;R!

! /-'&&'2*! e]G5R\\5\\\5\\\5\\\f5!67'(7! '1!42-0! /7)*!UPV?JJJ!G$#!.D!2&4,$2&H9;!V21/!

! 28!/7010!1(70401!)-0!$*8$*+0+;!I2!42*03!7)1!%00*!,$/!)1'+0!/2!,)3!/704;!

g!! E70! ($--0*/! ,$%&'(! +0%)/0! '1! 2*! 670/70-! /7010! ,0*1'2*1! ()*! %0! )882-+0+;!

! F(*$#5$($#0*-&(0H! /0-#($,,! '1! .'-/$)&&3! '@*2-0+;! E2!4)90! /70! ,0*1'2*1! )882-+)%&0! '*!

! /70! 172-/! /0-45! (244'/40*/1! 7).0! %00*!4)+0!67'(7! )//04,/! /2! /'0! /70! 7)*+1! 28!

! 8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1!28!/)Y,)30-1;!

g!! E70-0!)-0!)&-0)+3!2.0-!WX?JJJ!$RAG4:H-F!,$F*&#!8&#>$#,! #$F$-'-(5!0((40H!G$(,-&(,!

! &/!)&#$!*20(!UIV?YJJN!

g!! _.0-! KI?JJJ! $RAG4:H-F! ,$F*&#!8&#>$#,! F&HH$F*! G$(,-&(,! &/! &'$#! UVJ?JJJ! G$#! ;$0#5!

! )((2-+'*@!/2!O_F!-01,2*101!2%/)'*0+!%3!/70!F*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!O2$*+)/'2*;!

g!! [[h!28!,$%&'(!10(/2-!62-90-1!)-0!($--0*/&3!0*/'/&0+!/2!,0*1'2*1!-0&)/0+!/2!/70'-!8'*)&!

! 1)&)-'015!F&)G0#$9!*&!H$,,!*20(!KJZ!&/!8&#>$#,!-(!*2$!G#-'0*$!,$F*&#;!

g!! #)340*/1!82-!/7010!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!6'&&! &)-@0&3!(240!8-24!,02,&0!672!()*B/!

! 0.0*!)882-+!/2!1).0!82-!)!,0*1'2*!/70410&.01W!!KQ!)-HH-&(!G#-'0*$!,$F*&#!8&#>$#,!8-HH!

! F4##$(*H;!5$*!(&!G$(,-&(,!&*2$#!*20(!*2$!,*0*$!G$(,-&(;!

g!! E70!).0-)@0!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!'1!)%2$/!]Q5\\\!,;);5!F&)G0#$9!*&!0(!0'$#05$!&/!

! UQ?WJJ!0)&(5!#$*-#$9!G#-'0*$!,$F*&#!8&#>$#,!8-*2!G#-'0*$!G$(,-&(,;!

g!! L2$!G$(,-&(,!9$:*?!*&!:$!G0-9!:;!/4*4#$!5$($#0*-&(,?!-,!-(F#$0,-(5!#0G-9H;!%0()$10!

! /[email protected]*40*/!'1!*2/!,$//'*@!)1'+0!)*3/7'*@!/2!400/!'/1!2%&'@)/'2*1!/2!04,&23001;!

! E70!-0,2-/!1$@@01/1!1240!,2&'(3!2,/'2*15!'*(&$+'*@!/)Y'*@!7'@7!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!

! )*+! 0&'4'*)/'*@! ,0*1'2*! %0*08'/1! /7)/! )-0! *2/! (2*/-)(/$)&&3! @$)-)*/00+5! '*(&$+'*@!

! 8-24!8$/$-0!0)-*'*@1;!!

1 | L2$!M(*$#5$($#0*-&(0H!7&4(90*-&(?!888N-/N&#5N4>?!@20#-*;!O&B!KKPI!IQJ

T0F>5#&4(9!!

!

E70! C$)&'/3! 28! ,0*1'2*1! ).)'&)%&0! /2! ,$%&'(! )*+! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! 62-90-1! 7)1! %0(240!

'*(-0)1'*@&3! ,2&)-'10+! '*! -0(0*/! 30)-15! -)'1'*@! /70! ,-21,0(/! 28! )! 10-'2$1! '*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!

'*U$1/'(0;!!

!

E7-2$@7!/70'-!/)Y015!32$*@0-!62-90-1!'*!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!7).0!/2!,)3!82-!$*8$*+0+!,$%&'(!

10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!/7)/!)-0!&'90&3!/2!%0!4$(7!7'@70-!/7)*!)*3/7'*@!/703!6'&&!/70410&.01!-0(0'.0!

'*!/70!(2$-10!28!/70'-!26*!-0/'-040*/1;!!

!

E2!82&&26!726!/7'1!7)1!7),,0*0+5!'/!*00+1!/2!%0!$*+0-1/22+!726!,0*1'2*1!62-9!'*!/70!8'-1/!

,&)(0;!E70-0!)-0!/62!/3,01!28!,0*1'2*W!d08'*0+!S0*08'/!e)&12!-080--0+!/2!)1!"8'*)&!1)&)-3<f!)*+!

d08'*0+!L2*/-'%$/'2*!e)&12!-080--0+!/2!)1!"42*03!,$-(7)10<f;!!

!

C$/-($9!T$($/-*![CT\!&#!]7-(0H!,0H0#;^!,0*1'2*1!$10+!/2!%0!/70!421/!(2442*!/3,0!'*!%2/7!

/70!,$%&'(!)*+!,-'.)/0!10(/2-15!%$/!*26!/70!.)1/!4)U2-'/3!28!/704!)-0!82$*+!'*!/70!&)//0-5!)1!

O'@;!G;!'&&$1/-)/01;!E7010!62-9!%3!)&&26'*@!04,&230-1!/2!+0+$(/!)!(0-/)'*!,0-(0*/)@0!8-24!)*!

04,&2300B1! '*(240! e/70'-! "(2*/-'%$/'2*! -)/0<f!67'(7! /70*! @201! '*/2! /70! ,0*1'2*! 1(7040;!

E7'1!'1!/3,'()&&3!1240670-0!%0/600*!Ph!)*+!GRh!,0-!30)-;!A70*!/703!-0/'-05!*2$;!)-0!,)'+!

)!,0*1'2*! /7-2$@7! /7'1! 1(7040!67'(7! '1!0C$)&! /2!)!,-2,2-/'2*!28! /70'-! 8'*)&! 1)&)-35!$1$)&&3!

0'/70-! /62:/7'-+1! 2-! 7)&8;! V)*3! ,02,&0! )11$40! /7)/! /70'-! (2*/-'%$/'2*1! 7).0! %$'&/! $,! )!

,0-12*)&!",0*1'2*!,2/<!8-24!67'(7!/70'-!,0*1'2*!'1!/70*!,)'+!2$/5! '4,&3'*@!/7)/!/703!7).0!

,)'+!82-!/70!,0*1'2*!/703!-0(0'.0!+'-0(/&3;!F*!)(/$)&!8)(/5!421/!8'*)&!1)&)-3!,0*1'2*!1(70401!

-$*!2*!)*!$*8$*+0+5!2-!",)3:)1:32$:@2<!42+0&5!670-0!/70!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!,)'+!'*!%3!($--0*/!

62-90-1! )-0! '440+')/0&3! ,)'+! 2$/! )@)'*! /2! ,)3! /70!,0*1'2*1! 28! ($--0*/! -0/'-001;!A2-90-1!

672!7).0!%00*!(2*/-'%$/'*@!7).0!*2!,0-12*)&!",0*1'2*!,2/<!/2!8)&&!%)(9!2*!)/!)&&i!)&&! /703!

7).0!'1!)!,-24'10!e1240/'401!0Y,&'('/&3!(2*/-)(/$)&f!/7)/!/703!6'&&!-0(0'.0!)!,0*1'2*!$*+0-!

/70! 1)40! 131/04! 670*! /703! -0/'-0! /70410&.01;! TY)(/&3! 726! &0@)&&3! %'*+'*@! /7'1! ,-24'10!

-0)&&3!'1!7)1!%00*!/70!1$%U0(/!28!&'/'@)/'2*;!

!

E70!903!0&040*/!28! /7'1! '1! /7)/! /70!(2*/-'%$/'2*!-)/0! '1!I_E!)!6)3!28!1).'*@! 82-!32$-!26*!

,0*1'2*5! %$/! '*1/0)+! '1! 42-0! &'90! )! 9'*+! 28! /)Y! %)10+! 2*! 726!4)*3! ,0*1'2*0-1! *00+! /2!

-0(0'.0! )! ,0*1'2*! )/! )*3! 2*0! /'40;! E7'1! 0Y,&)'*1!6735! 82-! 0Y)4,&05!4)*3! ,02,&0! '*! 8'*)&!

1)&)-3! ,0*1'2*! 1(70401! 60-0! @'.0*! -0+$(0+! (2*/-'%$/'2*! -)/01! )*+! 0.0*! "(2*/-'%$/'2*!

72&'+)31<!)1! -0(0*/&3!)1! /70!G^[\1;!E7'1!6)1!%0()$10! '*! /70!G^[\1!S-'/)'*!1/'&&!7)+!)!4$(7!

42-0!8).2$-)%&0!+042@-),7'(!,-28'&0;!E70!*$4%0-!28!62-90-1!6)1!relatively!7'@7!%0()$10!

/70! (7'&+-0*! 28! /70! 0)-&3! G^P\1! %)%3! %224! 60-0! U$1/! 0*/0-'*@! /70! 62-982-(05! 67'&0! )!

(24%'*)/'2*!28!A2-&+!A)-!_*05!/70!J,)*'17!O&$!0,'+04'(!)*+!S-'/)'*B1! &26!80-/'&'/3!+$-'*@!

/70!c-0)/!d0,-011'2*!+0()+01!40)*/!/70-0!60-0!-0&)/'.0&3!806!,02,&0!'*!/70'-!P\1!)*+!Q\1!

672!60-0!-0(0'.'*@!,0*1'2*1;!!

!


!O'@;!G;!d08'*0+!S0*08'/!edSf!,0*1'2*!0*-2&40*/15!*$4%0-!28!)(/'.0!(2*/-'%$/2-15!R\\^M!

!

E70!aj!&)%2$-!82-(0!(2*/)'*1!-2$@7&3!R^!4'&&'2*!)(/'.0!62-90-15!28!6724!P!4'&&'2*!62-9!'*!

/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!)*+!RK!4'&&'2*!62-9!'*!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-;H!O'@$-0!G!'*+'()/01!/7)/![[h!28!

,$%&'(! 10(/2-!62-90-1! )-0! ($--0*/&3! (2*/-'%$/'*@! /2! )! d08'*0+! S0*08'/! edS5! 2-! 8'*)&:1)&)-3f!

,0*1'2*! 1(70405! (24,)-0+! /2! U$1/! 2.0-! G\h! 28! 62-90-1! '*! /70! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-;! N1! 421/!

,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! 04,&230-1! 7).0! (&210+! /70'-! dS! 1(70401! /2! *06! 404%0-15! /7'1! G\h!

-0,-010*/1!/70!2&+0-!,)-/!28!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-982-(0;!V21/!0Y'1/'*@!dS!1(70401!)&12!*2!

&2*@0-! )&&26! ($--0*/! 404%0-1! /2! )((-$0! 8$-/70-! ,0*1'2*! -'@7/15! 67'(7! )@)'*!

+'1,-2,2-/'2*)/0&3!+'1)+.)*/)@01!32$*@0-!62-90-1;!T.0*!/70!8'@$-0!28!R;M!4'&&'2*!62-90-1!'1!

0Y)@@0-)/0+5! )1! /70! /2/)&! 82-! /70! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! '*(2-,2-)/01! ,02,&0! 62-9'*@! 82-!

2-@)*'1)/'2*1! /7)/! )-0! &)-@0&3! @2.0-*40*/:8$*+0+5! '*(&$+'*@! %2/7! /70! `23)&!V)'&! #0*1'2*!

O$*+!)*+!/70!SSL!#0*1'2*!O$*+;!!

!

F*(-0)101! '*! &2*@0.'/3! /7-26! $,! 7$@0! ,-2%&041! 82-! 1$(7! 1(704015! 67'(7! '1! 673! /70! .)1/!

4)U2-'/3!28!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!(24,)*'01!7).0!17$/!+26*!/70'-!8'*)&!1)&)-3!,0*1'2*!1(70401!2-!

(&210+!/704!/2!*06!404%0-1;!!

!

O'@;R;!'1!/)90*!8-24!/70!>$//2*!`0,2-/!'*/2!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!1(70401;!F/!17261!/7)/!/70!

/3,'()&!,0-12*!-0/'-'*@!/2+)3!8-24!)!,-28011'2*)&!2(($,)/'2*!()*!*26!0Y,0(/!/2!&'.0!82-!R[X

K\!30)-1;!E7'1! '1! '*+'()/'.0!28! /70!7$@0! '*(-0)101! '*! &2*@0.'/3!67'(7!60-0!6'/*0110+! '*!/70!

&)//0-!,)-/!28!/70!R\/7!(0*/$-3;!

!

E7'1! 7)1! ,210+! )! 10-'2$1! (7)&&0*@0! 82-! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! 8'*)&! 1)&)-3! ,0*1'2*1! %0()$105! )1!

&2*@0.'/3! '*(-0)1015!42-0! )*+!42-0! ,0*1'2*0-1! )-0! )&'.0! )/! /70! 1)40! /'405!40)*'*@! /70!

)**$)&! %'&&! /7)/! *00+1! /2! %0! ,)'+! %3! /70! (2*/-'%$/'2*1! 8-24! 0Y'1/'*@! 62-90-1! 900,1! 2*!

'*(-0)1'*@;! V)*3! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! 8'*)&! 1)&)-3! ,0*1'2*! 1(70401! 7).0! 0*+0+! $,! 6'/7! &)-@0!

+08'('/1! %0/600*! /70! 2$/@2'*@1! 28! /70'-! 1(70401! )*+! /70! (2*/-'%$/'2*1! /7)/! 7).0! %00*!

(24'*@! '*! /2! ,)3! 82-! /704;! F*! 2-+0-! /2! ).2'+! &0@)&! )(/'2*! 8-24! ,0*1'2*0-1! 672! 7).0*B/!

-0(0'.0+!/70'-!,0*1'2*15!(24,)*'01!7).0!7)+!/2!1/)-/!$1'*@!/70'-!/$-*2.0-!/2!,&$@!/70!@),5!

(21/'*@!%$1'*01101!42*03;!

!

(Final Salary)


!O'@;!R;!#-2U0(/0+!&'80!0Y,0(/)*(3!)/!)@0!P\!82-!404%0-1!28!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!1(70401P!

!

E70! 1)40!,-2(011!7)1!2(($--0+! '*! /70!,$%&'(! 10(/2-5! 0Y(0,/! /70! @2.0-*40*/!$101! @0*0-)&!

/)Y)/'2*!/2!,&$@!/70!@),!%0/600*!/70!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!8-24!32$*@0-!62-90-15!)*+!/70!,0*1'2*1!

+04)*+0+! %3! 2&+0-! 62-90-1;! E7'1! 7)1! (-0)/0+! )*! '*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&! $*8)'-*0115! )1! 6'&&! %0!

0Y,&)'*0+!&)/0-;!!

!

C$/-($9!@&(*#-:4*-&(![C@\!,0*1'2*1!)-0!/70!2*&3!2,/'2*!).)'&)%&0!/2!62-90-1!'*!/70!,-'.)/0!

10(/2-!67210! 04,&230-! 7)1!6'/7+-)6*! /70!2880-! 28! )! 8'*)&! 1)&)-3! 1(7040;! E703!62-9! '*! )!

+'880-0*/!6)3;!_*(0!)@)'*!/70!04,&2300!7)1!/2!4)90!(2*/-'%$/'2*15!%$/!/7'1!/'40!/703!)-0!

1/2-0+! '*!)!,0-12*)&!,0*1'2*!8$*+5!67'(7! '1!$1$)&&3!4)*)@0+!2*!/70'-!%07)&8!%3!)! 8'*)*(')&!

'*1/'/$/'2*! )*+! '*.01/0+! '*! /70! 1/2(9!4)-90/;! E70! '+0)! '1! /7)/! /7-2$@7!70)&/73! '*.01/40*/!

-0/$-*1!)*+!/70!1$%1/)*/')&!%$'&+:$,!28!(2*/-'%$/'2*15!/70!8$*+!@-261!/2!)!%'@!0*2$@7!1'Z0!/2!

,-2.'+0!62-90-1!6'/7! )! +0(0*/! '*(240!670*! /703! -0/'-0;! N/! /7)/! ,2'*/! /703! 7).0! 10.0-)&!

2,/'2*1W!421/!62-90-1!6'/7!/7'1!/3,0!28!,0*1'2*!$10!/70'-!8$*+!/2!,$-(7)10!)*!)**$'/3!8-24!

)*!'*1$-)*(0!(24,)*3!X!)!8'*)*(')&!,-2+$(/!/7)/!6'&&!,)3!/704!)!8'Y0+!'*(240!82-!/70!-01/!28!

/70'-! &'80;! E70! %'@@0-! /70! ,0-12*)&! ,0*1'2*! 8$*+5! /70! &)-@0-! /70! )**$'/3;! >260.0-5! 4)*3!

,02,&0!1/)-/!1).'*@!/22!&)/05!2-!/70'-!,0*1'2*!1(7040!8)'&1!/2!@-26!1'@*'8'()*/&35!)*+!/703!0*+!

$,!6'/7!2*&3!)!14)&&!,0*1'2*!'*(240!'*!-0/'-040*/;!E7'1!'1!)&12!0Y,&)'*0+!'*!10(/'2*!R;!!

!

J240!Q;M!4'&&'2*!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-90-1!7).0!)!9$/-($9!F&(*#-:4*-&(![C@\!,-'.)/0!,0*1'2*5!

)&/72$@7!/70!%0*08'/1!/7010!,)3!2$/!)-0!$1$)&&3!8)-!&011!.)&$)%&0!/7)*!/7210!,-2.'+0+!%3!)!dS!

1(70405!)*+!/70!'*+'.'+$)&!%0)-1!)&&!/70!-'19!6'/7!-0@)-+!/2!726!'*.01/40*/1!,0-82-4;!!

!

E70!-01/!28!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-982-(0!X!GK!4'&&'2*!,02,&0!X!7).0!*2!,-'.)/0!,0*1'2*!)/!)&&5!

40)*'*@! )/! ,-010*/! /703! 6'&&! 7).0! &'//&0! '*(240! '*! -0/'-040*/! %032*+! /70! %)1'(! 1/)/0!

,0*1'2*;!E7'1!'1!+'1,-2,2-/'2*)/0&3!/70!32$*@0-!,)-/!28!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-982-(05!)*+!30/!

)/!/70!1)40!/'40!/70'-!/)Y01!)-0!,)3'*@!82-!/70!42-0!@0*0-2$1!,0*1'2*1!).)'&)%&0!/2!/7210!'*!

/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!X!70*(05!/703!)-0!82-(0+!/2!8$&8'&!)!%)-@)'*!/703!,&)30+!*2!,)-/!'*!(-0)/'*@;!

E7'1!-)'101!C$01/'2*1!28!'*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!'*U$1/'(0;!

!

!


!

L2$!@4##$(*!C$:0*$!!

!

F*!2-+0-!/2!0Y)4'*0!6)31!28!,$//'*@!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!2*!)!42-0!1$1/)'*)%&0!822/'*@5!

/[email protected]*40*/! &)$*(70+!/70! F*+0,0*+0*/!#$%&'(!J0-.'(0!#0*1'2*!L244'11'2*5!(7)'-0+!%3!

=2-+! b27*! >$//2*;! E70'-! 8'*)&! -0,2-/5! ,$%&'170+! '*! V)-(7! R\GG5! 4)+0! )! *$4%0-! 28!

-0(2440*+)/'2*1!82-!-082-4!28!/70!4)U2-!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!1(704015!67'(7!'*(&$+0+W!

!

• L)&($&)/'*@!,0*1'2*1!%)10+!2*!()-00-!).0-)@0!1)&)-35!-)/70-!/7)*!)1!)!,0-(0*/)@0!28!/70!

8'*)&!1)&)-3!

• F*(-0)1'*@!/70!-0/'-040*/!)@0!82-!421/!1/)/0!04,&23001!/2!%-'*@!'/!'*!&'*0!6'/7!/70!%)1'(!

1/)/0!,0*1'2*!)@05!67'(7!'1!($--0*/&3!PH!

• >'@70-!(2*/-'%$/'2*!-)/01!82-!($--0*/!)*+!8$/$-0!62-90-1Q!

!

>'1!-0(2440*+)/'2*1!)&12! '*(&$+0+!)!(244'/40*/!/2!4)'*/)'*'*@!+08'*0+!%0*08'/!,0*1'2*!

1(70401! 82-! 1/)/0! 62-90-1! )*+! 72*2$-'*@! )&&! ,-0.'2$1&3! )((-$0+! ,0*1'2*! -'@7/1! )/! /70'-!

,-010*/!&0.0&;!>0!+'+!*2/!&229!)/!6)31!28!4)9'*@!/704!42-0!)882-+)%&0;!E70!)@0!1/-$(/$-0!28!

/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!62-982-(0!40)*1!/7'1!6'&&!+2!&'//&0!/2!)&&0.')/0!/70!%$-+0*!2*!/70!($--0*/!

32$*@0-!)*+!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1!28!/)Y,)30-1;!!

!

O2&&26'*@!*0@2/')/'2*1!6'/7!,$%&'(!10(/2-!$*'2*15!/[email protected]*40*/!4)3!60&&!%&$*/!/70!'4,)(/!

28! '/1! -082-41! '8! '/! 0*+1!$,!)@-00'*@! /2!)*!)--)*@040*/! /7)/!62$&+! 100!)&&! ,$%&'(!62-90-1!

672!)-0!($--0*/&3!6'/7'*!/0*!30)-1!28!-0/'-040*/!-0/'-0!)/!/70!)@0!/703!,-0.'2$1&3!0Y,0(/0+!

/2!2*!8'*)&!1)&)-3!,0*1'2*1[;!E70!)@0!1/-$(/$-0!28!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!e100!O'@;!Q;f!40)*1!/7)/!

/7'1! 62$&+! 0*)%&0! )! 7$@0! *$4%0-! 28! 62-90-1!672! %0&2*@! /2! /70! ,21/:6)-! @0*0-)/'2*! /2!

-0/'-0! 6'/72$/! /70! @2.0-*40*/! 1).'*@! )*3! 42*035! )! %)-@)'*! /7)/! (3*'()&&3! ,$/1! )! &)-@0-!

%$-+0*! 2*/2! %2/7! /)Y,)30-1! )*+! 32$*@0-! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-!62-90-15! 672!62$&+! 7).0! /2! ,)3!

7'@70-!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!)1!)!-01$&/;!!

!

E7'1!,),0-!)-@$01!/7)/!2$-!($--0*/!*)/'2*)&!+0%)/0!)%2$/!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!7)1*B/!@2*0!

8)-! 0*2$@7! /2! )++-011! )*! '4%)&)*(0W! E70! (21/! 28! 8$*+'*@! @0*0-2$1! ,0*1'2*1! 82-! 62-90-1!

122*!/2!-0/'-0!)-0!%0'*@!,'&0+!$*1$1/)'*)%&3!2*/2!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1!28!/)Y,)30-1!%$/!/7010!

-'(7!%0*08'/1!)-0!&'90&3!/2!0&$+0!/70!32$*@0-!62-90-1!672!6'&&!,)3!/704;!A0!6'&&!)&12!1$@@01/!

)!.)-'0/3!28!,2&'('01!/7)/!(2$&+!(7)*@0!/7'1;!!

!

!


+4:H-F!S$F*&#!+$(,-&(,!',!+#-'0*$!S$F*&#!

+$(,-&(,!

!E70! ).0-)@0! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*! '1! (&)'40+! /2! %0! 1240/7'*@! (&210! /2! ]Q5\\\! ,0-! 30)-5

^!

)&/72$@7! /7'1! '1! )! 4'1&0)+'*@! 8'@$-0! %0()$10! '/! '*(&$+01! /7-00! ()/0@2-'01! 28! ,02,&0! 672!

%0/600*!/704!)-0!-0(0'.'*@!)!&)-@0!*$4%0-!28!.0-3!14)&&!,0*1'2*1W!

!

G; E7210!672!2*&3!62-90+! '*! /70! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! 82-! )! 14)&&! ,)-/! 28! /70'-! ()-00-5!40)*'*@!

/703!2*&3!)((-$0+!)!806!30)-1?!62-/7!28!,0*1'2*!-'@7/1!

R; #)-/:/'40!,$%&'(!10(/2-!04,&23001!!

K; #0*1'2*1! %0'*@! ,)'+! )1! &0@)('01! /2! 6'+261k6'+260-1! )*+5! '*! 1240! ()1015! +0,0*+)*/!

(7'&+-0*!

!

l0/!0.0*! '8! /7'1! 8'@$-0! '1!$10+!)1! /70!).0-)@05! /70!,0*1'2*! '*(240!28!421/!62-90-1! '*! /70!

,-'.)/0!10(/2-!672!7).0!dL!,0*1'2*1!'1!1/'&&!&'90&3!/2!%0!0.0*!&260-5!)1!O'@;!K;!'*+'()/01W!

!

!O'@;!K;!N**$)&!)**$'/3!-)/01!).)'&)%&0!/2!)!4)*!-0/'-'*@!6'/7!)!,0-12*)&!,0*1'2*!,2/!62-/7!]G\\9G\!

!

N1! 0Y,&)'*0+! )%2.05!670*!62-90-1!6'/7! )!dL! ,0*1'2*! -0/'-05! /703! $1$)&&3! $10! /70!42*03!

/703!7).0!%$'&/!$,!'*!/70'-!,0*1'2*!8$*+!/2!,$-(7)10!)*!)**$'/3!8-24!)*!'*1$-)*(0!(24,)*3!

X! )! 8'*)*(')&! ,-2+$(/!67'(7! ,)31! /704! )! 8'Y0+! '*(240! 82-! &'80;! N1! 12!4)*3! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-!

62-90-1! 2*&3! 7).0! ,0-12*)&! dL! ,0*1'2*1! ).)'&)%&0! /2! /7045! /70! ")**$'/3! -)/0<! e/70!

,0-(0*/)@0!28!/70!/2/)&!.)&$0!28!/70'-!,0*1'2*!,2/!/703!6'&&!-0(0'.0!0)(7!30)-f! '1!/70-082-0!

67)/!+0/0-4'*01!/70!1'Z0!28!/70!'*(240!/703!6'&&!-0(0'.0!670*!/703!-0/'-0;!!

!


O'@! K;! +042*1/-)/01! /7)/! )**$'/3! -)/01! '*! -0(0*/! 30)-1! 7).0! %00*! .0-3! &26;! F*! 8)(/5! /70!

7'@701/!-0/'-040*/!'*(240!62-90-1!-0/'-'*@!8-24!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!)/!P\!e/70!)@0!)/!67'(7!

4)*3!,$%&'(! 10(/2-!62-90-1! -0/'-0f!62$&+!%0! )%&0! /2! 2%/)'*!8&4H9!:$! UV?VQV!G$#! ;$0#5! '8!

/703!7)+!4)*)@0+!/2!%$'&+!$,!)!,0*1'2*!,2/!62-/7!]G\\5\\\!+$-'*@!/70'-!()-00-;!!

!

>260.0-5!806!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-90-1!)-0!&'90&3!/2!7).0!1).0+!$,!/7'1!4$(7;!F*!/70!8'-1/!7)&8!

28!R\\^5!/70!).0-)@0!,-'.)/0!,0*1'2*!8$*+!6)1!62-/7!U$1/!]RM5KK\iKK!)*+!/70!).0-)@0!1'*@&0!

,0*1'2*0-!)**$'/3!82-!)!4)&0!6)1!U$1/!]K5P^R!,0-!30)-;GR!A7'&0!)**$'/3!-)/01!)-0!'*8&$0*(0+!

%3!172-/:/0-4!8)(/2-15!67'(7!40)*!/703!@2!$,!)1!60&&!)1!+26*5!O'@;!M;!17261!/7)/!)!1/0)+3!

+0(-0)10!7)1!%00*!/70!+24'*)*/!/-0*+!82-!421/!28!/70!&)1/!/60*/3!30)-1W!

!

!O'@;!M;!N.0-)@0!)**$'/3!-)/015!G^^\:R\\QGK!

!J2402*0!-0/'-'*@!'*!G^^\!(2$&+!0Y,0(/!/2!@0/!2.0-!GPh!28!/70'-!8$*+B1!/2/)&!.)&$0!0)(7!30)-!

)1!-0/'-040*/!'*(2405!%$/!/7)/!7)+!8)&&0*!/2!*0)-&3!Qh!'*!R\\Q5!)*+!/70!1$41!C$2/0+!'*!O'@;!

K;!'*+'()/0!-)/01!)-0!)-2$*+!Hh!)/!,-010*/;!!

!

A'/7! )*! )**$'/3! -)/0! 28! Hh5! -0/'-001! 2*&3! @0/! 2*0:/60*/'0/7! 28! /70! /2/)&! .)&$0! 28! /70!

,0-12*)&!,0*1'2*! 8$*+! e",0*1'2*!,2/<f! /703B.0!%$'&/!$,!+$-'*@! /70'-!62-9'*@! &'80! '*!)**$)&!

,0*1'2*! '*(240;! E7'1! 40)*1! /7)/5! %3! (24,)-'12*5! /70! 8'*)&! 1)&)-3! ,0*1'2*1! 67'(7! )-0!

).)'&)%&0! '*! /70! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-!62$&+! %0! .0-3! 0Y,0*1'.0! 82-! 12402*0! '*! /70! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-!

672!7)1!2*&3!,0-12*)&!+08'*0+!%0*08'/!,0*1'2*1!).)'&)%&0!/2!/704;!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!


!O'@;!H;!d'880-0*/!&0.0&1!28!,0*1'2*!e'*!%&$0f!0Y,-0110+!'*!(24,)-'12*!/2!/70!1'Z0!28!/70!,0-12*)&!!

,0*1'2*!8$*+!67'(7!12402*0!'*!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62$&+!*00+!'*!2-+0-!/2!@0/!/704!e'*!-0+f!!

)11$4'*@!)*!)**$'/3!-)/0!28!Hh5!R\GG!

!

O'@;!H;!17261!/7)/!U$1/!/70!).0-)@0!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!28!]Q5\\\!'1!0C$'.)&0*/!'*!(21/!/2!)!

,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-90-!7).'*@!)(($4$&)/0+!)!,0-12*)&!,0*1'2*!8$*+!62-/7!]GM\5\\\!%3!/70!

/'40!/703!-0/'-0;!l0/!/7'1!62$&+!1/'&&!2*&3!,-2.'+0!)!-0&)/'.0&3!42+01/!'*(240!'*!-0/'-040*/i!

/2!@0/!)!,0*1'2*!67'(7! '1! 0C$'.)&0*/! /2! /70! ($--0*/!*)/'2*)&!4'*'4$4!6)@0! e]GR5PMP!,0-!

30)-f5! /70! -0/'-00! 62$&+! *00+! )! 8$*+! 62-/7! 2.0-! )! C$)-/0-! 28! )! 4'&&'2*! ,2$*+15! 67'&0! )!

,0*1'2*!67'(7!4)/(70+!/70!).0-)@0!)**$)&!1)&)-3!28!]RH5^\\!62$&+!-0C$'-0!)! 8$*+!62-/7!

]HG[5\\\;! F*! 2-+0-! 82-! )! (2$,&0! 672! %2/7! 62-90+! '*! /70! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! /2! -0/'-0! 2*! )!

(24%'*0+! '*(240!28!]M\5\\\5! /70'-! /2/)&! ",0*1'2*!,2/<!62$&+!*00+! /2!7).0!)! .)&$0!28! )/!

&0)1/!][\\5\\\;!E7'1!+042*1/-)/01!726!8)-!2$/!28!-0)(7!/70!/3,0!28!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!

'+0*/'8'0+!'*!O'@;!P;!)-0!82-!421/!62-90-1!'*!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-;!

!

E2!1$44)-'105!421/!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-90-1!)-0!*26!2*!/70'-!26*!670*!'/!(2401!/2!8$*+'*@!

)!,0*1'2*5!6'/7!4'*'4)&!e'8!)*3f!8'*)*(')&!)11'1/)*(0!8-24!/70'-!04,&230-;!l0/!/7-2$@7!/70'-!

/)Y01!/703!)&12!7).0!/2!1$%1'+'10!,0*1'2*1!'*!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-;!

!

!

+4:H-F!S$F*&#!+$(,-&(,!_!L2$!70F*,!!

!

A7'&0!4)*3!'*+'.'+$)&!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!)-0!14)&&5!1240!-0/'-0+!,$%&'(!10(/2-!62-90-1!

%0*08'/!8-24!)*!0Y/-040&3!&)-@0!/-)*180-!28!60)&/7!8-24!32$*@0-!/)Y,)30-1;!

!

E2! '&&$1/-)/0! /70! 1()&0! 28! /70! &)-@01/! '*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&! /-)*180-15! /70! F*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!

O2$*+)/'2*!$10+!O-00+24!28! F*82-4)/'2*!-0C$01/1!/2! '*.01/'@)/0!726!4)*3!82-40-!,$%&'(!

10(/2-!62-90-1!'*!0)(7!28!/70!4)U2-!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!1(70401!)-0!($--0*/&3!-0(0'.'*@W!

!

)f!)!,0*1'2*!62-/7!42-0!/7)*!/70!).0-)@0!)**$)&!1)&)-3!28!]RH5^\\GM!

%f!)!,0*1'2*!62-/7!2.0-!]H\5\\\!!

(f!)!,0*1'2*!62-/7!2.0-!]G\\5\\\GH!

- Average man receiving a single-pensioner annuity

- Average public sector pension

- National minimum wage

- Average annual salary


!

E70!-01$&/1!-0.0)&0+!/7)/W!

!

+$(,-&(!SF2$)$!@0*$5&#;!"B!

UIV?YJJ`!

@0*$5&#;!TB!!

UVJ?JJJ_UKJJ?JJJ!

@0*$5&#;!@B!!

UKJJ?JJJ`!

I>J! KP5Q[Q! [5QGM! ^Q!

L'.'&!J0-.'(0! G[5QP[! ^P^! GR!

E0)(70-1! GR5^MQ! M^Q! [!

N-40+!O2-(01! ^5P[M! KMM! G\!

=2()&!c2.0-*40*/! I2/!F*(&$+0+! G5KQG! R\!

#2&'(0!! I2/!F*(&$+0+! KP[! G!

L&*0H! WX?KXa! KI?IaQ! KPX!

O'@;!P;!I$4%0-!28!($--0*/!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!'*!0)(7!()/0@2-3!

!

E70!-0)&!)42$*/1!28!42*03!'*.2&.0+!'*!/7010!/-)*180-1!)-0!1$%1/)*/')&;!E2!/)90!/70!0Y)4,&0!

28!/70!14)&&01/!@-2$,!X!/7210!-0(0'.'*@!)!,0*1'2*!28!2.0-!]G\\5\\\!,0-!30)-!X!/703!)-0!/70!

%0*08'(')-'01! 28! )! /-)*180-! 8-24! 32$*@0-! /)Y,)30-1! '*! /70! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! /2! -0/'-0+! ,$%&'(!

10(/2-!04,&23001!67'(7! '1!62-/7!)/! &0)1/!UKPNX!)-HH-&(!G$#!;$0#;! E7'1! '1! )! /-)*180-!67'(75!

%0()$10! 28! (7)*@01! /2! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*! )--)*@040*/15! 4)*3! 28! /7010! 62-90-1! )-0!

7).'*@! /2! 8'*)*(0!)/! /70! 1)40! /'40!)1! /703! 8$*+! /70!0*/'-0!%$-+0*!28! /70'-!26*!,0*1'2*1!

/70410&.01;! E70! 1()&0! 28! /7'1! /-)*180-! '1! )&12! 10/! /2! '*(-0)10! -),'+&3! )1! &)-@0! *$4%0-1! 28!

+2(/2-1! )*+! ('.'&! 10-.)*/1!672! %0&2*@! /2! /70! ,21/:6)-! @0*0-)/'2*! )-0! *0)-'*@! -0/'-040*/!

)@0;!

!

O'@;!Q;!+042*1/-)/01!/70!-),'+!)@0'*@!28!/70!('.'&!10-.'(0!62-982-(0!%0/600*!G^^G!)*+!R\GG;!

PQh!28! '/1!404%0-1!)-0!*26!2.0-! /70!)@0!28!M\5! (24,)-0+! /2! U$1/!MMh!/60*/3:2*0!30)-1!

)@2GP;!E7'1!1$@@01/1!&)-@0!*$4%0-1!28!('.'&!10-.)*/1!6'&&!%0!-0/'-'*@!'*!/70!*0)-!8$/$-05!&0).'*@!

%07'*+!-0&)/'.0&3!806!32$*@0-!62-90-1!67210!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!)-0!40)*/!/2!,)3!82-!/70!-0/'-0+!

(272-/B1! %0*08'/1;! F/! )&12! +042*1/-)/01! 726! /70! '4,)(/! 28! =2-+! >$//2*B1! -082-41! 6'&&! %0!

%&$*/0+! '8! /70! @2.0-*40*/! )&&261! 0.0-32*0! 2.0-! /70! )@0! 28! H\! /2!4)'*/)'*! /70'-! 0Y'1/'*@!

%0*08'/15!)1!/7'1!)((2$*/1!82-!42-0!/7)*!)!/7'-+!28!/70!,-010*/!L'.'&!J0-.'(0!62-982-(0;!

!

E70!()10! 82-!,$%&'(! 10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!%0'*@!42-0!@0*0-2$1! /7)*! /7210! '*! /70!,-'.)/0! 10(/2-!

7)1! /-)+'/'2*)&&3! -01/0+! 2*! /70! )-@$40*/! /7)/! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! 62-90-1! 60-0! %0'*@!

(24,0*1)/0+!82-!&260-!1)&)-3!&0.0&1;!>260.0-5!-010)-(7!-0&0)10+!%3!/70!F*1/'/$/0!82-!O'1()&!

J/$+'01! 0)-&'0-! /7'1! 30)-! 17260+! /7)/! '*! 8)(/! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,)3! '1! )(/$)&&3! Q;Hh! 7'@70-5! 2*!

).0-)@05!0.0*!670*!0+$()/'2*5!)@0!)*+!C$)&'8'()/'2*!)-0!8)(/2-0+!'*;GQ!!

!


!O'@;!Q;!L'.'&!J0-.'(0!404%0-17',!%3!)@05!G^^G!)*+!R\GGG[!

!

F*!)++'/'2*!/2!%0'*@!42-0!@0*0-2$1!2*!).0-)@05!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!)&12!7).0!)!-)*@0!28!

2/70-!)+.)*/)@01!2.0-!/70!dL!,0*1'2*1!67'(7!*26!,-0+24'*)/0!'*!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-W!

!

M(9$RAH-(>-(5!X!V21/!28!/70!4)U2-!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!1(70401!)-0!'*+0Y:&'*90+5!40)*'*@!

/70! ,0*1'2*1! /703! ,)3! -'10!6'/7! '*8&)/'2*5!670-0)1! O'@;! K;! 17261! /7)/!dL!,0*1'2*1! $1$)&&3!

+2*B/!7).0!/7'1!)+.)*/)@0!$*&011!/70!%$30-!,)31!82-! '/!%3!)((0,/'*@!)! &260-!)**$)&!1$4!'*!

-0/$-*;! N! *2*! '*+0Y:&'*90+!,0*1'2*! 0880(/'.0&3! @201! +26*! '*! .)&$0! 0)(7! 30)-5! 0-2+'*@! /70!

'*(2401!28!82-40-!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-90-1;!!

!

M('$,*)$(*!#-,>!X!N!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-90-!6'/7!)!dL!1(7040!7)1!/2!%0)-!/70!'*.01/40*/!-'19i!

/7'1! '1! /70! +)*@0-! /7)/5! )1! /70'-! ,0*1'2*! 1).'*@1! )-0! $1$)&&3! '*.01/0+! '*! /70! 1/2(9!4)-90/5!

/70'-!8$*+!6'&&!*2/!,0-82-4!60&&!0*2$@7!82-!/704!/2!7).0!1$88'('0*/!42*03!'*!-0/'-040*/;!F8!

/70!8$*+!$*+0-,0-82-415!/703!@0/!)!&260-!)**$'/3!-)/0!)1!)!-01$&/;!N1!/70!%0*08'/1!28!,02,&0!

'*!dS! 1(70401! )-0! 8'Y0+! -0@)-+&011! 28! 726!4$(7!42*03! /70-0! '1! /2! ,)3! 82-! /7045! ,$%&'(!

10(/2-!62-90-1!+2!*2/!7).0!/2!%0)-!/7'1!-'19;!

!

b&(5$'-*;! #-,>! X! #$%&'(! 10(/2-! 62-90-1! 6'/7! dS! ,0*1'2*1! )-0! @$)-)*/00+! /2! -0(0'.0! /70!

'*(240!/703B.0!%00*!,-24'10+!0.0-3!30)-!82-! &'805!6'/7!/70!1/)/0!%0)-'*@!)&&!/70!)++'/'2*)&!

(21/1! '8! /703! &'.0! &2*@0-! /7)*!0Y,0(/0+;!>260.0-5! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-!62-90-1!6'/7!dL!,0*1'2*!

)--)*@040*/1!7).0!/70!&2*@0.'/3!-'19!/-)*180--0+!/2!/704!'*!/70!82-4!28!&260-!)**$'/3!-)/01i!

'*(-0)1'*@!&2*@0.'/3!7)1!%00*!/70!4)'*!+-'.0-!28!/70!1/0)+3!+0(&'*0!'*!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!)**$'/3!

-)/01!2.0-!/70!&)1/!/60*/3!30)-1;!!

!

@&(*#-:4*-&(,! X! #-'.)/0! 10(/2-! 62-90-1! 672! /)90! 2$/! )! dL! ,-'.)/0! ,0*1'2*! %0()$10! /703!

7).0! *2! 2(($,)/'2*)&! 1(7040! ).)'&)%&0! /2! /704! $1$)&&3! +2*B/! -0(0'.0! )*! 04,&230-!

(2*/-'%$/'2*5!40)*'*@!2*&3!/703!,$/!42*03!'*/2!/70!,0*1'2*!8$*+5!670-0)1!,$%&'(!10(/2-!dS!

,0*1'2*!1(70401!+2!-0(0'.0!04,&230-!(2*/-'%$/'2*1;!!

!!


L2$!+#&:H$)!8-*2!.(/4(9$9!SF2$)$,!

!

E70!421/!'4,2-/)*/!,2'*/!'1!/7)/!7'@70-!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!)-0*B/!*0(011)-'&3!$*8)'-!2*!

/70!32$*@0-!@0*0-)/'2*!'*!/70410&.01i!-)/70-5!/703!)-0!$*8)'-!%0()$10!/703!)-0!4(/4(9$95!

40)*'*@!/70!($--0*/!32$*@0-!@0*0-)/'2*!28!/)Y,)30-1!e)*+!8$-/70-!@0*0-)/'2*1!28!/)Y,)30-1!

1/-0/(7'*@!'*/2!/70!8$/$-0f!6'&&!7).0!/2!,)3!82-!/704!2$/!28!@0*0-)&!/)Y)/'2*;!!

!

#)3!)1!32$!@2!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!)-0!8'*0!$*&011!/70-0!'1!)!,)-/'($&)-!+042@-),7'(!7$4,5!

'*!67'(7!()10!/70!%$-+0*!2*!/)Y,)30-1!-'101!+-)4)/'()&&3!)*+5!2.0-)&&5!/7210!/)Y,)30-1!0*+!

$,!,)3'*@!)!7'@70-!,-2,2-/'2*!28!/70'-! '*(240!/2!/70!(272-/!28!,$%&'(!10(/2-!62-90-1!/7)*!

,-0.'2$1!2-!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1;!E7'1!'1!,-0('10&3!/70!,-2%&04!S-'/)'*!'1!($--0*/&3!8)('*@;!

!

N! 12&$/'2*! 62$&+! *00+! /2! -0+-011! /7'1! '4%)&)*(0! %3! -0+'1/-'%$/'*@! /70! (21/! %0/600*! /70!

@0*0-)/'2*1;!F/!62$&+!7).0!/2!'*.2&.0!0'/70-!/)9'*@!42-0!8-24!0)-&'0-!@0*0-)/'2*1!e)*!2,/'2*!

67'(7! '/! '1! *26! /22! &)/0! /2! ,$-1$0f5! -)'1'*@! /70! (2*/-'%$/'2*1! 28! ($--0*/! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-!

62-90-15! )*+k2-! &260-'*@! /70! ,)32$/1! /2! -0/'-001;! >$//2*B1! -0(2440*+)/'2*1! (2*/)'*0+!

0&040*/1!28!%2/7!28!/7010!&)1/!/62!1/-)/0@'015!)&/72$@7!)1!40*/'2*0+!)%2.05!'8!62-90-1!2.0-!

/70!)@0!28!H\!)-0!)&&260+!/2!-0/'-0!6'/72$/!/70!(7)*@01!(24'*@!'*/2!0880(/!'/!6'&&!+2!&'//&0!/2!

'4,-2.0!/70!2.0-)&&!1'/$)/'2*;!

!

V21/!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!1(70401!)-0!$*8$*+0+5!'*(&$+'*@!/70!2*01!82-!/70!L'.'&!J0-.'(05!

I>J5! #2&'(05! E0)(70-1! )*+!N-40+! O2-(01;! E70! =2()&!c2.0-*40*/! ,0*1'2*! 1(7040! '1!42-0!

(24,&'()/0+!%0()$105!67'&0! '/! '1! 8$*+0+5! '/! '1! $&/'4)/0&3! $*+0-6-'//0*!%3! /70! @2.0-*40*/5!

40)*'*@!'/!1/'&&!'*(-0)101!/70!2.0-)&&!/)Y,)30-!&')%'&'/3;!!

!

L2$!M(*$#5$($#0*-&(0H!@&(,$c4$(F$,!

!

N1!,0*1'2*!&')%'&'/'01!)-0!+080--0+!'*/2!/70!8$/$-05!'/!6'&&!$&/'4)/0&3!%0!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1!28!

/)Y,)30-1!672!822/!421/!28!/70!%'&&!82-!2$-!$*8$*+0+!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!1(70401;!!

!

E7'1!()*!%0!0Y,-0110+! '*! /0-41!28! &')%'&'/'01;!N1!,02,&0! &'.0! &2*@0-5!)*+!$*8$*+0+!1(70401!

*00+!/2!,)3!2$/!42-0!)*+!42-0!42*03!/2!-0/'-0015!/70!,$%&'(! &')%'&'/3!900,!2*! '*(-0)1'*@;!

O'@;! [;! 17261! 726! /70! @2.0-*40*/B1! 01/'4)/01! 28! '/1! $*8$*+0+! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*!

&')%'&'/'01! '*(-0)10+! 8-24! ]K[\! %'&&'2*! '*! R\\R! /2! *0)-&3! ]G! /-'&&'2*! '*! R\G\! )1! '/! 7)+! /2!

-0,0)/0+&3! -0.'10!$,! /70!,-2U0(/0+! &2*@0.'/3!28! /70!,02,&0!672!62$&+!%0! -0(0'.'*@! /704;!

J240!0(2*24'1/1!,$/!/70!&')%'&'/3!)/!*0)-0-!]G;K!/-'&&'2*!e]H\5\\\!,0-!aj!72$1072&+f;!!

!

E7'1! 40)*1! /7)/! /70! %'&&! 82-! /2+)3B1! ,0*1'2*1! ),)-/70'+! '1! %0'*@! 7)*+0+! +26*! /70!

@0*0-)/'2*1! /2! %0! ,)'+! 82-! %3! 2$-! (7'&+-0*! )*+! @-)*+(7'&+-0*;! >260.0-5! /70! &2*@:/0-4!

)882-+)%'&'/3! 28! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*1! '1! )! (2*/-2.0-1')&! )-0)5! 6'/7! /70! _88'(0! 82-! S$+@0/!

`01,2*1'%'&'/3! )-@$'*@! /7)/! /70! (21/! 28! ,)3'*@! 82-! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*1! 6'&&! ,0)9! )1! )!

,0-(0*/)@0!28!cd#!'*!R\GH:GP!)/!Rh!)*+!6'&&!7).0!8)&&0*!/2!G;Mh!%3!R\P\:PG;G^!!

!


!O'@;![;!aj!,$%&'(!10(/2-!2(($,)/'2*)&!,0*1'2*!$*8$*+0+!&')%'&'/'015!V)-(7!R\G\!01/'4)/0

R\!

!

E7'1! '1!40-0&3! )! ,-2U0(/'2*5! )*+! '/! -0&'01! 2*! )! *$4%0-! 28! )11$4,/'2*1!67'(7!40)*! ,$%&'(!

10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!4)3!60&&!0*+!$,!%0'*@!42-0!0Y,0*1'.0!/7)*!/7'1;!F*!2-+0-!/2!%0!-0)&'10+5!'/!

-0&'01!2*!/70!S-'/'17!0(2*243!)(7'0.'*@!)!40)*!cd#!@-26/7!-)/0!28!Rh!)!30)-5!67'(7!6)1!

/70! ).0-)@0! +$-'*@! /70! &)1/! 7)&8! (0*/$-3;RG! E70-0! )-0! 10.0-)&! @22+! -0)12*1! 673! 2$-! cd#!

@-26/7!4)3!*2/!-0/$-*!/2!/7'1!&0.0&W!

Gf! @20(5$,! /#&)! *2$! G0,*! X! F*! )! *$4%0-! 28! 6)315! S-'/)'*! 0*U230+! 7'@7&3! 8).2$-)%&0!

(2*+'/'2*1!82-!@0*0-)/'*@!0(2*24'(!@-26/7!+$-'*@!/70!/60*/'0/7!(0*/$-3!67'(7!)-0!$*&'90&3!

/2!%0!-0,0)/0+!2.0-!/70!*0Y/!H\!30)-1;!

c-26/7!28!Rh!)!30)-!+$-'*@! /7'1!,0-'2+!6)1!)(7'0.0+!/7-2$@7!/70!32$/78$&!0*+0).2$-1!28!

/70!,21/:6)-!@0*0-)/'2*!672!)-0!*26!)@0'*@!)*+!%0'*@!-0,&)(0+!%3!)!14)&&0-!@0*0-)/'2*!28!

32$*@0-!62-90-1i! '/!@)'*0+!)*! '*'/')&!%2)1/!8-24!/70!7$@0!,21/:6)-!-0(2*1/-$(/'2*!,-2U0(/i!

@2.0-*40*/!%2--26'*@!6)1!)%&0! /2! -'10!2.0-! /70! &2*@! /0-45!670-0)1!*26!60!6'&&!7).0! /2!

1/)-/!,)3'*@! '/!%)(95!)*+!I2-/7!J0)!2'&!6)1!)!1/-2*@!12$-(0!28!-0.0*$0!82-!*0)-&3!RH!30)-15!

%$/!60!)-0!*26!)!*0/!'4,2-/0-!28!0*0-@3;!

Rf!@20(5-(5!9-,*#-:4*-&(!&/!5H&:0H!$F&(&)-F!0F*-'-*;!X!E70!1,-0)+!28!@&2%)&'Z)/'2*!7)1!100*!

/70! B+0.0&2,'*@<! 62-&+! @-26! -'(70-5! )*+! )*! 0.0-! &)-@0-! ,-2,2-/'2*! 28! @&2%)&! 0(2*24'(!

)(/'.'/3!/)9'*@!,&)(0!2$/1'+0!/70!/-)+'/'2*)&!B+0.0&2,0+<!62-&+!28!T$-2,05!/70!aJ!)*+!b),)*;!

L24,0/'/'2*!82-! '*.01/40*/! '1! &'90&3!/2!%0(240!4$(7!8'0-(0-5!01,0(')&&3! 8-24!/70!12:()&&0+!

BTQ<! @-2$,! 28! /70! 10.0*! &)-@01/! 040-@'*@!4)-90/1W! L7'*)5! F*+')5! S-)Z'&5! `$11')5! F*+2*01')5!

V0Y'(2!)*+!E$-903;!E70!_TLd!01/'4)/01! /7)/!%3!R\R\! &011! /7)*!7)&8!28!@&2%)&!cd#!6'&&!%0!

@0*0-)/0+! %3! '/1! 404%0-15! )*+! /7'1! 8'@$-0! 6'&&! /70*! +0(&'*0! 0.0*! 8$-/70-! /2! U$1/! MKh! %3!

R\H\;RR!

E70!0(2*24'1/!`'(7)-+!T7-4)*!)-@$0+!'*!7'1!R\\^!%229!C)*!D#+*$!#:!E@3F*$.G!H)I!J@$#K*!

E**%.!(#!9*(!L#@4<*$! /7)/!")1!+0.0&2,'*@!(2$*/-'01!%0(240!42-0!12,7'1/'()/0+!)*+!/70'-!


0+$()/'2*)&! &0.0&1! -'105! 60! ()*! 0Y,0(/! 42-0! m10-.'(0n! U2%1! /2! 82&&26! /70'-! 4)*$8)(/$-'*@!

,-0+0(0112-1!/2!/70!&26:(21/5!8)1/!@-26'*@!0(2*24'01!28!/70!T)1/!)*+!=)/'*!N40-'();!F/!6'&&!

*2/! U$1/!%0!()&&! (0*/-01! /7)/!)-0!10*/!288172-0i!7'@7&3!,)'+!0Y,0-/1! &'90! 128/6)-0!0*@'*00-1!

)*+!8'*)*(')&!)*)&31/1!6'&&!%0!0C$)&&3!.$&*0-)%&0;<!

E70! aj! 7)1! )! 32$*@0-! &)%2$-! 82-(0! /7)*! 421/! +0.0&2,0+! (2$*/-'015! %$/! '1! 1/'&&! 7'@7&3!

.$&*0-)%&0! /2! /70! )@0'*@! )*+! 1&26'*@! 28! /70! (2*/'*0*/)&! 0(2*24'01! %0()$10! /703! )-0! 2$-!

4)U2-!/-)+'*@!,)-/*0-1;!F8!S-'/)'*!1/-$@@&01!/2!8'*+!*06!12$-(01!28!@-26/75!/70!0*/'-0!60&8)-0!

1/)/0!4)3!%0(240!.)1/&3!42-0!+'88'($&/!/2!8$*+;!

T.0*!'8!60!+2!)(7'0.0!/70!)4%'/'2$1!&0.0&1!28!cd#!@-26/7!,-0+'(/0+!%3!/70!_S`5!/7'1!'1!1/'&&!)!

8&)60+!6)3!28!&229'*@!)/!/70!,-2%&04!82-!10.0-)&!-0)12*1W!

!

.(/0-#($,,!X!J)3'*@!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!)-0!)882-+)%&0!'*!/70!&2*@!/0-4!%0()$10!/703!4)3!

-0C$'-0!)!14)&&0-!17)-0!28!cd#!+201!*2/7'*@!/2!)++-011!/70!$*8)'-*011!%0/600*!,$%&'(!)*+!

,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*1!67'(7! '1! ,0-,0/$)/0+! $*+0-! /70! ,-010*/! 131/045! )*+!6'&&! 2*&3! %0!

()--'0+!82-6)-+!'*/2!/70!8$/$-0!$*&011!-082-41!)-0!4)+0;!

!

S2&#*A*$#)-,)!X!N-@$'*@!/7)/!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!)-0!@2'*@!/2!%0!)882-+)%&0!+0()+01!'*/2!

/70!8$/$-0!%0()$10!/703!6'&&!(21/! &011! '*!/0-41!28!cd#!)(/$)&&3!+042*1/-)/01!)!.0-3!172-/:

/0-4! ,0-1,0(/'.0;! F/! 40)*1! /7)/! ,02,&0! '*! /70! 8$/$-0! 6'&&! %0! (244'//0+! /2! ,)3'*@! /7010!

,0*1'2*15!670/70-! /703!()*!)882-+!/2!2-!*2/5!)*+! '/! /-)*180-1!)&&! /70!-'19! /7)/!62$&+!-01$&/!

8-24!S-'/)'*!*2/!)(7'0.'*@!/70!,-0+'(/0+!&0.0&1!28!cd#!@-26/7!2*/2!/70!172$&+0-1!28!8$/$-0!

@0*0-)/'2*1;!!

!

O)'&$-0!/2!)(7'0.0!-082-41!*26!670*!60!7).0!/70!2,,2-/$*'/3!62$&+!%0!)!/0--'%&0!&0@)(3!/2!

&0).0!/2!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1;!S3!)&&26'*@!$*8$*+0+!,0*1'2*!&')%'&'/'01!/2!@2!2*!)((-$'*@5!60!

)-0! /3'*@! /70!*0Y/!@0*0-)/'2*B1!7)*+15! 82-('*@! /704!/2!,)3! 82-!)*!$*8)'-! '*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!

%)-@)'*!67'(7!/703!,&)30+!*2!,)-/!'*!(-0)/'*@;!F8!60!6)*/!)!8'*)*(')&&3!0C$'/)%&0!8$/$-05!60!

7).0!/2!1/2,!10*+'*@!/70!%'&&!82-!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1!/2!/70!"%)*9!28!12*!)*+!+)$@7/0-<;!!

!

E70!8'*)*(')&!('-($41/)*(01!28!0)(7!28!/70!4)'*!(0*/-)&&3:)+4'*'1/0-0+!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!

1(70401!6'&&!*26!%0!0Y,&)'*0+!'*+'.'+$)&&3!'*!J0(/'2*!K;!!

!

!

!

!

!


M(9-'-940H!+4:H-F!S$F*&#!+$(,-&(!SF2$)$,!

!O=S!+$(,-&(!SF2$)$

IQ!

!!

• E70! I>J! #0*1'2*! J(7040! '1! /70! &)-@01/! (0*/-)&&3:)+4'*'1/0-0+! ,$%&'(! 10-.'(0! ,0*1'2*!

1(7040!'*!T$-2,0;!!

• N1!28!KG!V)-(7!R\GGW!

!

N(/'.0!V04%0-1!

e(2*/-'%$/2-1f!

d080--0+!V04%0-1! #0*1'2*1!'*!#)340*/!

G5KR\5MQ^! HP\5KKR! PP^5\^\!

!

• L$--0*/!,0*1'2*0-1!)-0!-0(0'.'*@!]M;^K!%'&&'2*!,0-!30)-!%0/600*!/704!

• _88'(')&!&')%'&'/'01W!UIVWNW!:-HH-&(!

• _88'(')&!8$*+1!/2!,)3!/7'1W!O-H![4(/4(9$9\!

• E70!1(7040?1!288'(')&! &')%'&'/'01!28!]RHQ;Q!%'&&'2*!-0,-010*/!)!8)&&! 8-24!]R[Q;P!%'&&'2*!/70!

30)-! %082-0;! >260.0-5! /7'1! -0,-010*/1! )! 2*0:288! +0(-0)10! 67'(7! '1! 0Y,&)'*0+! %3! /70!

(7)*@0! 8-24!`#F! /2! L#F! 82-! ,0*1'2*! '*+0Y)/'2*;! F*! )*3! ()105! &')%'&'/'01!6'&&! (2*/'*$0! /2!

@-26!'*!/70!(24'*@!30)-15!)*+!)-@$)%&3!(2$&+!%0!0.0*!7'@70-!'8!)!+'1(2$*/!-)/0!28!Gh!6)1!

$10+!-)/70-!/7)*!/70!Kh!67'(7!7)1!*26!%00*!)+2,/0+;!!

• GP5PK\! ,0*1'2*1! (0)10+! +$-'*@! /70! R\G\XGG! 8'*)*(')&! 30)-! %0()$10! 28! ,0*1'2*0-!

42-/)&'/35!%$/!MR5\G\!,02,&0!60-0!*06&3:-0/'-0+;!O'@;!^;!17261!/70!0Y/0*/!/2!67'(7!*06!

-0/'-001!7).0!2$/1/-',,0+!,0*1'2*!(011)/'2*1!'*!0)(7!28!/70!&)1/!82$-!8'*)*(')&!30)-1W!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

O'@;!^;!#0*1'2*!(011)/'2*1!.1!*06!-0/'-040*/1!'*!/70!I>J!,0*1'2*!1(70405!R\\Q:R\GG!

8'*)*(')&!30)-1RM


@-'-H!S$#'-F$!+$(,-&(!SF2$)$IV!

!!

• N1!28!KG!V)-(7!R\G\W!

!

N(/'.0!V04%0-1!

e(2*/-'%$/2-1f!

d080--0+!V04%0-1! #0*1'2*1!'*!#)340*/!

HQM5\\\! KMH5\\\! H^R5\\\!

!

• E70!H^R5\\\!,0*1'2*1!'*!,)340*/!,)'+!2$/!]K;PQ!%'&&'2*!%0/600*!/704!

• E7'1!40)*1! /7)/! '*!R\G\5! 82-!0.0-3!,0-12*!-0(0'.'*@!)!L'.'&!J0-.'(0!,0*1'2*! /70-0!60-0!

2*&3!JNYW!8&#>$#,!,-2.'+'*@!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!/2!,)3!/704!

• E70! 1(7040! 7)+! )! *0/! '*(240! 28! ]K;K[! %'&&'2*! e421/&3! 8-24! (2*/-'%$/'2*1! 4)+0! %3!

($--0*/!04,&23001f!%$/!7)+!*0/!2$/@2'*@1!28!]G\;QR!%'&&'2*!X!(-0)/'*@!)!172-/8)&&!28!]Q;KM!

%'&&'2*!

• _88'(')&!&')%'&'/'01W!UKVQ!:-HH-&(!

• _88'(')&!8$*+1!/2!,)3!/7'1W!O-H![4(/4(9$9\!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!


L$0F2$#,d!+$(,-&(!SF2$)$Ia!

!

!

• N1!28!KG!V)-(7!R\G\W!

!

N(/'.0!V04%0-1!

e(2*/-'%$/2-1f!

d080--0+!V04%0-1! #0*1'2*1!'*!#)340*/!

PH[5KHG! MRP5M^P! H[[5MMG!

!

• E70!H[[5MMG!,0*1'2*1!'*!,)340*/!,)'+!2$/!UaNKV!:-HH-&(!%0/600*!/704!

• E70-0!6)1!)!172-/8)&&!28!UINVQ!:-HH-&(!%0/600*!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!8-24!)(/'.0!404%0-1!)*+!

/70! ,0*1'2*1! '*! ,)340*/5! )*! '*(-0)10! 8-24! ]R;GM! %'&&'2*! +$-'*@! /70! R\\^:G\! 8'*)*(')&!

30)-!

• _88'(')&!&')%'&'/'01W!UKYINP!:-HH-&(!

• _88'(')&!8$*+1!/2!,)3!/7'1W!O-H![4(/4(9$9\!

• E70!1(7040?1!288'(')&! &')%'&'/'01!28!]G^R;M!%'&&'2*!-0,-010*/!)!8)&&! 8-24!]RRK;^!%'&&'2*!/70!

30)-! %082-0;! F*! )*3! ()105! &')%'&'/'01! 6'&&! (2*/'*$0! /2! @-26! '*! /70! (24'*@! 30)-15! )*+!

)-@$)%&3! (2$&+! %0! 0.0*! 7'@70-! '8! )! +'1(2$*/! -)/0! 28! Gh!6)1! $10+! -)/70-! /7)*! /70! Rh!

67'(7!7)1!*26!%00*!)+2,/0+;!!

• E70!903!+042@-),7'(!/-0*+!)42*@!404%0-1!28!/70!1(7040!'1!/7)/!,02,&0!)-0!-0/'-'*@!)/!

)!-)/0!67'(7!'1!4$(7!8)1/0-!/7)*!,0*1'2*0-!42-/)&'/35!&0)+'*@!/2!)!-),'+!'*(-0)10!'*!/70!

*$4%0-!28!,0*1'2*1!%0'*@!,)'+;! F*!/70!R\G\:GG!8'*)*(')&!30)-!GH5\[\!,0*1'2*1!1/2,,0+!

%0'*@!,)'+!%0()$10!28!,0*1'2*0-!42-/)&'/35!%$/!KH5[H\!,-0.'2$1&3!)(/'.0!404%0-1!28!/70!

1(7040!-0/'-0+;!!

• O'@;! G\;! 17261! /7)/! '*! /70! 8'.0:30)-! ,0-'2+!%0/600*!R\\P! )*+!R\GG5! *0)-&3! /7-00!*06!

,0*1'2*1!1/)-/0+!%0'*@!(&)'40+! 82-!0.0-3!1'*@&0!,0*1'2*!67'(7!(0)10+i! '*! /2/)&5!PK5QK\!

,0*1'2*1!1/2,,0+!%0()$10!28!,0*1'2*0-!42-/)&'/35!%$/!GHQ5GKG!404%0-1!28!/70!1(7040!

-0/'-0+;!

!

!O'@;!G\;!I06!-0/'-040*/1!.1!,0*1'2*!(011)/'2*1!,0-!30)-5!R\\P:GG

RQ!

!

!

!

!


"#)$9!7&#F$,!+$(,-&(!SF2$)$IX!

!

!

• N1!28!KG!V)-(7!R\G\W!

!

N(/'.0!V04%0-1!e*2*:

(2*/-'%$/2-3R^f!

d080--0+!V04%0-1! #0*1'2*1!'*!#)340*/!

G^[5\KR! M\H5[PH! K^[5[M\!

!

• _88'(')&!&')%'&'/'01W!UKIJNW!:-HH-&(!!

• _88'(')&!8$*+1!/2!,)3!/7'1W!O-H![4(/4(9$9\!

• F*!/70!R\\^:G\!8'*)*(')&!30)-!G\5H[H!,0*1'2*1!1/2,,0+!%0'*@!,)'+!%0()$10!28!,0*1'2*0-!

42-/)&'/35! 67'&0! GM5\GP! 404%0-1! 28! /70! 1(7040! %0@)*! -0(0'.'*@! /70'-! %0*08'/1i!

7260.0-5!/7'1!1(7040!'1!+'11'4'&)-!/2!/70!2/70-!$*8$*+0+!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!1(70401!

'*! /7'1! -0@)-+! %0()$10!404%0-1! %0@'*! (&)'4'*@! /70'-! %0*08'/1! )/! )! .)-'0/3! 28! +'880-0*/!

)@015!+0,0*+'*@!2*!670*!/703!&0).0!/70!)-43!)*+!670/70-!/703!)-0!'*.)&'+0+!2$/;!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!


S&H4*-&(,!

!F*!2-+0-!/2!)++-011!/70!'*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!'*U$1/'(0!28!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*15!60!*00+!/2!8'*+!

1240!6)3!28!-082-4'*@!/70!131/04!/7-2$@7!67'(7!/703!)-0!8$*+0+;!O2-!1$(7!)!12&$/'2*!/2!%0!

'*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&&3!8)'-5!'/!62$&+!*00+!/2!1)/'183!10.0-)&!903!(-'/0-')W!

!

• O&*! *;-(5! *2$! 20(9,! &/! /4*4#$! 5$($#0*-&(,N! E70! ,-2%&04!6'/7! 2$-! ($--0*/! 131/04! 28!

$*8$*+0+! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*1! '1! /7)/! /703! )&&26! ,02,&0! /2! )((-$0! (244'/40*/1! /2!

-0(0'.0! ,0*1'2*1! 8-24! 8$/$-0! /)Y,)30-1! -0@)-+&011! 28! /70! )%'&'/3! 28! /7210! 8$/$-0!

/)Y,)30-1!/2!,)3;!A0!*00+!)!*06!131/04!'*!67'(7!,02,&0!/)90!4$(7!42-0!28!/70!+'-0(/!

8'*)*(')&! -01,2*1'%'&'/3! 82-! /70'-! 26*! -0/'-040*/1! 12! 60! +2! *2/! %$-+0*! ,02,&0! 6'/7!

,)3'*@!82-!/704!'*!/70!8$/$-0;!

!

• b-)-*-(5!*2$!#-,>N!a*+0-!/70!,-010*/5!$*8$*+0+!131/045!8$/$-0!/)Y,)30-1!%0)-!)&&!/70!-'19!

28!,02,&0!&'.'*@!&2*@0-!/7)*!/703!60-0!0Y,0(/0+!/2!'*!/70'-!-0/'-040*/1;!E70-0!'1!)&12!/70!

'*U$1/'(0! /7)/! 2$-! ($--0*/! 6)3! 28! )11011'*@! ,0*1'2*! )882-+)%'&'/3! $1'*@! ,-2U0(/'2*1! 28!

8$/$-0! cd#! @-26/7! /-)*180-1! )&&! /70! ,-2%&041! 28! $1! *2/! 400/'*@! /7210! /)-@0/1! 2*/2!

,02,&0!'*!/70!8$/$-0;!A0!4$1/!8'*+!)!6)3!28!*2/!,)11'*@!/7010!-'191!2*/2!2$-!(7'&+-0*;!

!

• "FF$G*-(5!)&#$! &/! *2$! #$,G&(,-:-H-*;N! L$--0*/! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! 62-90-1!4$1/!4'--2-! /70!

(7)*@01! '*! ,0*1'2*! 8$*+'*@! /7)/! 7).0!%00*! ),,&'0+! )(-211!421/! 28! /70!,-'.)/0! 10(/2-5!

)*+! /)90! 42-0! 8'*)*(')&! -01,2*1'%'&'/3! 82-! /70'-! 26*! -0/'-040*/15! -)/70-! /7)*! 1'4,&3!

)((-$'*@!0*/'/&040*/1!67'(7!6'&&!60'@7!70).'&3!2*!/70!172$&+0-1!28!8$/$-0!/)Y,)30-1;!

!

E$F&))$(90*-&(,!!

!

E70!F*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!O2$*+)/'2*!,-2,2101!10.0-)&!,211'%&0!(7)*@01!/2!/70!($--0*/!131/04!

28! $*8$*+0+! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*! 1(704015! )&&! 28! 67'(7! 62$&+! 70&,! /2! -0)++-011! /70!

%)&)*(0!'*!8).2$-!28!($--0*/!)*+!8$/$-0!/)Y,)30-1W!

!

KN +20,$!&4*!/-(0H!,0H0#;!G$(,-&(,!-(!*2$!G4:H-F!,$F*&#!!

!

F8!60!)((0,/!/7)/!'/!'1!6-2*@!82-!62-90-1!'*!/70!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!/2!%0!8$*+'*@!42-0:@0*0-2$1!

,0*1'2*1!82-!/7210!'*!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-5!/70*!/70!2%.'2$1!)*160-!'1!82-!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!/2!

4'--2-! /70! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! )*+! @-)+$)&&3! ,7)10! 2$/! 8'*)&! 1)&)-3! ,0*1'2*15! '*! 8).2$-! 28! /70!

+08'*0+! (2*/-'%$/'2*! 42+0&;! E7'1! 62$&+! %0! /70! 8)'-01/! 12&$/'2*! 82-! 32$*@0-! )*+! 8$/$-0!

,-'.)/0!10(/2-!62-90-15!)1!'/!62$&+!40)*!*0)-&3!)&&!62-90-1!/229!8$&&!8'*)*(')&!-01,2*1'%'&'/3!

82-!/70'-!26*!'*(2401!'*!-0/'-040*/5!12!/70!7)*+1!28!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1!62$&+!*2!&2*@0-!%0!

/'0+!%3!'*70-'/0+!,0*1'2*!(244'/40*/1;!!

!

E70!(7)*@01!67'(7!7).0!%00*!4)+0!/2!/70!SSL!,0*1'2*!1(7040!2880-!)!$108$&!%&$0,-'*/!82-!

726!1$(7! -082-41!(2$&+!%0!()--'0+!2$/;!a*/'&!R\G\5! /70!SSL!,0*1'2*! 1(7040!6)1! &'90! /70!

-01/! 28! /7210! '*! /70! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-5! 2880-'*@! $*8$*+0+! 8'*)&! 1)&)-3! ,0*1'2*1;! >260.0-5! /7'1!

(-0)/0+!)!&)-@0!+08'('/!%0/600*!'/1!/2/)&!&')%'&'/'01!)*+!/70!)42$*/!28!42*03!67'(7!6)1!%0'*@!

,-2.'+0+!%3!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!/2!,)3!82-!/704!X!01/'4)/0+!)/!]G;P!%'&&'2*!'*!V)3!R\GG;K\!


!

F*!2-+0-!/2!,&$@!/7'1!@),5!'/!6)1!+0('+0+!/7)/!8-24!G!d0(04%0-!R\G\!/70!8'*)&!1)&)-3!,0*1'2*!

1(7040!62$&+!%0! (&210+! /2! *06!0*/-)*/1;! #02,&0!672!60-0! )&-0)+3!404%0-1!62$&+! 1/'&&!

-0(0'.0!/70'-!%0*08'/1!8-24!/70!8'*)&!1)&)-3!1(70405!%$/!/70'-!,0*1'2*!62$&+!%0!()&($&)/0+!'*!

)!+'880-0*/!6)3;!`)/70-! /7)*!-0(0'.'*@!7)&8!2-! /62:/7'-+1!28! /70!1)&)-3! /703!60-0! -0(0'.'*@!

+$-'*@!/70'-!&)1/!62-9'*@!30)-!)/!/70!SSL!82-!/70!-01/!28!/70'-!&'.015!0Y'1/'*@!404%0-1!62$&+!

'*1/0)+!@0/!/70'-!1)&)-3!)/!/70!/'40!/70!1(7040!6)1!(&210+!/2!*06!404%0-1!,&$1!)!4)Y'4$4!

28!Gh!82-!0)(7!1$%10C$0*/!,)3!-'10;!E7'1!6'&&!+-)4)/'()&&3!&260-!/70!(21/!28!,)3'*@!2$/!4)*3!

28! /70! ,0*1'2*1! 67'(7! 7).0! %00*! ,-24'10+! $*+0-! /70'-! 1(70405! )*+! -0,-010*/1! )*!

'4,2-/)*/! 1/0,! /26)-+1! 4'*'4'1'*@! /70! 0Y,21$-0! 28! 8$/$-0! /)Y,)30-1! /2! /70! (21/! 28!

$*8$*+0+!8'*)&!1)&)-3!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*1;!!

!

#02,&0!672! U2'*0+! /70! SSL! )8/0-! d0(04%0-! R\G\!6'&&! *26! %0! 0*-2&&0+! '*! )! *06! +08'*0+!

(2*/-'%$/'2*! 1(7040! ()&&0+! ='80#&)*5! )+4'*'1/0-0+! %3! O-'0*+1! #-2.'+0*/;!V04%0-1! 28! /7'1!

1(7040!)-0!)&&260+!/2!(2*/-'%$/0!$,!/2!G\h!28!/70'-!1)&)-3!)!30)-5!67'(7!6'&&!%0!4)/(70+!%3!

/70!SSL;!O-'0*+1!#-2.'+0*/!-$*1!)!.)-'0/3!28!'*.01/40*/!8$*+1!'*/2!67'(7!/703!()*!,$/!/70'-!

42*035!6'/7!421/!,02,&0!0Y,0(/0+!/2!,$-(7)10!)*!)**$'/3!670*!/703!-0/'-0;KG!!

!

F*! '*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&! /0-415! /7'1! 7)1! /70! ,2/0*/')&! /2! %0! )! .0-3! 1$((0118$&!42+0&5!6'/7! /70!

%$-+0*!$,2*!8$/$-0!/)Y,)30-1!%0'*@!4'*'4'10+!%3!/70!8)(/!/7)/!/70!1(7040!404%0-1!6'&&!%0!

172$&+0-'*@!421/!28!/70!-'19;!E70-0!10041!/2!%0!1'@*'8'()*/!,2/0*/')&! 82-!-0,&'()/'*@!1'4'&)-!

-082-41!'*!2/70-!%-)*(701!28!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-;!!

!

IN @#$0*$!0!/4(9!*&!2$HG!/4*4#$!5$($#0*-&(,!

!

E70! @2.0-*40*/! '1! )&-0)+3! ,)3'*@! )! &)-@0! )42$*/! /26)-+1! /70! (21/! 28! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-!

,0*1'2*15! %$/! )1! /7010! )-0! ($--0*/&3! $*8$*+0+! /70! )42$*/! '/! ,)31! 2$/! '*! 2*0! 30)-! +201!

*2/7'*@!/2!)11'1/!6'/7!,)3'*@!/70!,0*1'2*1!)@)'*!/70!82&&26'*@!30)-;!

!

F*1/0)+!28!,)11'*@!/7'1!%$-+0*!2*/2!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*15!/[email protected]*40*/!(2$&+!,7)10!'*!/70!

+0.0&2,40*/! 28! )! 8$*+! /2! 70&,! ,)3! '/1! 8$/$-0! ,0*1'2*! &')%'&'/'015! $1'*@! %2/7! '/1! 04,&230-!

(2*/-'%$/'2*! /2! /7010! ,0*1'2*1! )*+! /70! 04,&2300! (2*/-'%$/'2*1! 28! ($--0*/! 62-90-1;! E7'1!

8$*+! (2$&+! %0! '*.01/0+! '*! /70! 1/2(9! 4)-90/! 2-! ,$%&'(! '*8-)1/-$(/$-05! (-0)/'*@! )! .)&$)%&0!

12$-(0!28!8'*)*(0!67'(7!62$&+!70&,!/70!6'+0-!0(2*243;!!

!

QN!+4:H-,2!90*0!&(!G$(,-&(!H-0:-H-*-$,!

!

E70!$*8)'-*011!28!/70!,-010*/!)--)*@040*/1!'1!(24,2$*+0+!%3!/70!8)(/!/7)/!/70!/2/)&!,$%&'(!

10(/2-!,0*1'2*!&')%'&'/'01!)-0!*2/!()&($&)/0+!-0@$&)-&3!0*2$@75!)*+!670*!'/!+201!,$%&'17!/704!

/70! @2.0-*40*/! 28/0*! (722101! /2! $10! )! 7'@7! +'1(2$*/! -)/05! 4)9'*@! /70! &')%'&'/'01! ),,0)-!

14)&&0-!/7)*!/703!-0)&&3!)-0;!!

!

L$--0*/&3!)!+'1(2$*/!-)/0!28!Kh!'1!$10+!%0()$10!/[email protected]*40*/!)11$401!0(2*24'(!@-26/7!

28!Kh!,0-!)**$4!6'&&!%0!)(7'0.0+;!!F/!62$&+!%0!70&,8$&!)&12!/2!()&($&)/0!/70!&')%'&'/3!6'/7!)!

+'1(2$*/!-)/0!28!\h5!Gh5!2-!Rh;!_88'(')&!,-2U0(/'2*1!)&12!-0C$'-0!(0-/)'*!)11$4,/'2*1!)%2$/!

,0*1'2*0-!&2*@0.'/3!67'(7!2*&3!,-2+$(0!2*0!.'06!28!/70!,211'%&0!8$/$-0!1(0*)-'2;!!

!


F*!2-+0-! /2!(-0)/0!)!%0//0-:'*82-40+!+0%)/0!)%2$/! /70! &')%'&'/'01!60!)-0! &0).'*@! 82-! 8$/$-0!

/)Y,)30-15! /70! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*! 1(70401! 172$&+! %0! -0C$'-0+! /2! ,-2+$(0! 288'(')&!

,-2U0(/'2*1! 28! /70'-! 8$/$-0! &')%'&'/'01! 0.0-3! 30)-5! 67'(7! '*(2-,2-)/0! )! -)*@0! 28! +'880-0*/!

+'1(2$*/! -)/01! )*+! &2*@0.'/3! )11$4,/'2*1;! #$%&'17'*@! 1$(7! '*82-4)/'2*! 62$&+! '*($-! &'//&0!

(21/5!)*+!62$&+!0*)%&0!$1!/2!7).0!)!4$(7!42-0!(24,-070*1'.0!+0%)/0!)%2$/!/70!%$-+0*1!

60!6)*/!/2!&0).0!/2!2$-!+01(0*+)*/1;!!

!

PN!M)G&,$!0!G#&5#$,,-'$!*0R!&(!*2$!2-52$,*!G4:H-F!,$F*&#!G$(,-&(,!

!

N1!0Y,&)'*0+!0&10670-0!'*!/7'1!1/$+35!/70-0!'1!)!&)-@0!@),!%0/600*!/70!)42$*/!,$%&'(!10(/2-!

62-90-1!7).0!,)'+!/26)-+1!/70'-!,0*1'2*1!'*!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!)*+!67)/!/703!6'&&!-0(0'.0!2*(0!

/703!7).0!-0/'-0+;!E7'1!'1!421/!1'@*'8'()*/!82-!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!62-90-1!672!7).0!/70!7'@701/!

,0*1'2*1;!

!

_*0!6)3!28!)++-011'*@!/7'1!'4%)&)*(0!6'/72$/!7).'*@!/2!-0:+-)6!0Y'1/'*@!(2*/-)(/1!62$&+!%0!

82-! /70! @2.0-*40*/! /2! &0.3! )! ,-2@-011'.0! /)Y! 2*! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*1! /7)/! )-0! )%2.0! )!

(0-/)'*!/7-0172&+!e82-!0Y)4,&05!]R\5\\\!,0-!30)-f;!E62!(2*10($/'[email protected]*40*/1!7).0!10/!)!

,-0(0+0*/! 82-! 1,0('8'(! /)Y)/'2*! 28! (0-/)'*! /3,01! 28! '*(240! 6'/7! /70'-! /)Y! 2*! %)*90-1?!

%2*$1015!67'(7!6)1!+01'@*0+!,)-/&3!/2!).2'+!7).'*@!/2!-0:+-)6!0Y'1/'*@!(2*/-)(/1;!E2!0*1$-0!

'/!6)1!,-2@-011'.05!/70!/)Y!-)/0!62$&+!7).0!/2!-'10!6'/7!/70!&0.0&!28!,0*1'2*!e12!,02,&0!2*!

7'@70-!,0*1'2*1!,)'+!42-0f;!!

!

VN!<RGH-F-*H;!G#&*$F*!/4*4#$!*0RG0;$#,!

!

#$%&'(! 10(/2-! (2*/-)(/1! (2$&+! %0! -0:6-'//0*! 12! /7)/! /70'-! ,0*1'2*! )--)*@040*/1! 0Y,&'('/&3!

,-2/0(/!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1!28!/)Y,)30-1!8-24!%0'*@!$*8)'-&3!%$-+0*0+!6'/7!(244'/40*/1;!!

!

N! 131/04! (2$&+! %0! +0.'10+! /2! &'4'/! /)Y,)30-! 0Y,21$-05! $*+0-! 67'(7! /70! /2/)&! )42$*/! 28!

@2.0-*40*/! 0Y,0*+'/$-0! 2*! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*1! '1! (),,0+! )/! Hh! 28! /70! @2.0-*40*/B1!

/2/)&!/)Y!/)90!2-!Rh!28!cd#5!67'(70.0-!'1!&260-5!1'4'&)-!/2!/70!1/-)/0@3!67'(7!6)1!)+2,/0+!

10.0-)&!30)-1!)@2!%3!/[email protected]*40*/!28!b),)*;!N!40(7)*'14!62$&+!*00+!/2!%0!+0.'10+!82-!

1()&'*@:+26*!,)340*/1!,-2@-011'.0&3!'*!/70!0.0*/!/7)/!/7'1!(0'&'*@!6)1!%-0)(70+;!!

!

N&/0-*)/'.0&35!/[email protected]*40*/!(2$&+!,$/!)!(),!2*!,0*1'2*!)((-$)&!82-!62-90-1!'*!8'*)&!1)&)-3!

,0*1'2*! 1(70401! 67'(7! 62$&+! &'4'/! /70! 4)Y'4$4! ,0*1'2*! /703! 7)+! /2! ,)3! 2$/! /2! 0)(7!

62-90-!X!/7'1!(2$&+!%0!]M\5\\\!,0-!)**$45!82-!0Y)4,&0;!!

!

_*(0!62-90-1! -0)(7! /7'1! &'4'/5! /703!(2$&+!7).0! /70!2,/'2*!28! 1$,,&040*/'*@! /70'-!,0*1'2*!

'*(240! %3! ,)3'*@! )++'/'2*)&! (2*/-'%$/'2*1! '*/2! )! 62-9,&)(0! +08'*0+! (2*/-'%$/'2*! 1(7040!

e67'(7!/[email protected]*40*/!62$&+!)&12!4)90!04,&230-!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!/26)-+1f5! '8! /703!6)*/0+!

/2!/2,!$,!/70'-!,0*1'2*!'*(240!8$-/70-;!

!

!

!

!

!

!


aN!<,*0:H-,2!0!($8!F&))-,,-&(!&(!G4:H-F!,$F*&#!G$(,-&(,!

!

E70! -0(2440*+)/'2*1! 28! /70! ,-0.'2$1! (244'11'2*! (7)'-0+! %3! =2-+! >$//2*! 7).0! ,-2.0+!

'*)+0C$)/0! '*! /70! 8)(0!28!)! -),'+&3!62-10*'*@!0(2*243! e)1!7'1!C$2/0!2*! /70!(2.0-!28! /7'1!

-0,2-/!'&&$1/-)/01f5!67'&0!10.0-)&!28!/70!)11$4,/'2*1!/703!-0&'0+!$,2*!7).0!,-2.0*!/2!%0!/22!

2,/'4'1/'(5!)*+!/70!(2*(011'2*1!4)+0!%3!/[email protected]*40*/! '*!*0@2/')/'2*!6'/7!,$%&'(!10(/2-!

$*'2*1!7).0!,-2+$(0+!)!10//&040*/!67'(7!'1!1/'&&!$*8)'-!2*!32$*@0-!)*+!8$/$-0!@0*0-)/'2*1;!!

!

N!*06! '*+0,0*+0*/5!%',)-/'1)*! (244'11'2*! 172$&+!%0! (-0)/0+!%3! /[email protected]*40*/! /2!70&,!

)+U$+'()/0! %0/600*! /70! (24,0/'*@! +04)*+1! 28! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! 62-90-1! )*+! /70! @0*0-)&!

/)Y,)30-5! )1! 60&&! )1! /70! *00+1! 28! 8$/$-0! @0*0-)/'2*15! '*! 2-+0-! /2! ,-2+$(0! )! (2*(-0/0!

10//&040*/!67'(7!()*!1/)*+!/70!/01/!28!/'40;!!!

!

!


@&(FH4,-&(!

!`'1'*@! &2*@0.'/3! 40)*1! /7)/! S-'/)'*B1! ,0*1'2*! 131/041! 4$1/! (7)*@0! '*! 2-+0-! /2! -04)'*!

)882-+)%&0;!E7'1!'1!'*0.'/)%&0i!30/!/70-0!'1!)!10-'2$1!+)*@0-!/7)/!/70!32$*@0-!@0*0-)/'2*!6'&&!

0*+! $,! @0//'*@! /70!62-1/! 28! %2/7!62-&+15! 82-(0+! /2! $,72&+! /70! %)-@)'*! /703B.0! '*70-'/0+!

67'(7!@$)-)*/001!@0*0-2$1!,0*1'2*1!/2!/70'-!,)-0*/1!)*+!@-)*+,)-0*/15!2*&3!/2!-0/'-0!6'/7!)!

.0-3!40)@-0!'*(240!/70410&.01;!

!

V'&&'2*1! 28! 32$*@! 62-90-1! '*! /70! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! )-0! 1&00,6)&9'*@! /26)-+1! )! -0/'-040*/!

670-0! )*! )**$'/3! '*(240! 28! ]H5\\\! ,0-! 30)-! 6'&&! 1004! @0*0-2$1;! E70! ).0-)@0! )**$'/3!

'*(240! 82-! )! 4)&0! ,0*1'2*0-! )/! /70! 4240*/! '1! U$1/! ]K5P^R5! )*+! /70! &2*@:/0-4! /-0*+! '1!

+26*6)-+1;!V0)*67'&05!2*0!&$(93!(272-/!28!,21/:6)-!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*0-1!'1!'*1$&)/0+!

8-24!/70!/-2$%&0;!

!

F8! 60! '4)@'*0+5! U$1/! %-'08&35! /7)/! S-'/)'*! 6)1! 1/)-/'*@! 8-24! 1(-)/(7! /242--26i! /7)/! ,$%&'(!

10(/2-! )*+! ,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! 62-90-1! 60-0! %2/7! '*! .$&*0-)%&0! ,21'/'2*1! )*+! /7)/! 60! 7)+!

]G;K/-'&&'2*!28!1,0*+'*@!/2!0*7)*(0!/70'-!-0/'-040*/15!60!)&421/!(0-/)'*&3!62$&+!*2/!(2**'.0!

/2! (-0)/0!)! 131/04!)1! '*'C$'/2$1!)1! /7)/!67'(7! ($--0*/&3! 1/)*+1!X!6'/7!4'&&'2*1!28!,-'.)/0:

10(/2-!,0*1'2*0-1!&08/!2$/!'*!/70!(2&+!67'&0!/70!,$%&'(!10(/2-!-0/'-001!/7-'.0;!

!

F*+00+5! )1! @2.0-*40*/1! )-0! 82-(0+! /2! -)'10! /)Y01! /2! ,)3! 82-! /70! (21/1! 28! 2$-! )@0'*@!

,2,$&)/'2*5! 32$*@0-! 62-90-1! 4)3! 60&&! ,$/! 0.0*! &011! )1'+0! 82-! /70'-! 26*! -0/'-040*/15!

-0'*82-('*@! /70!10.0-'/3!28! /70!7)-+17',! /703!6'&&! 8)(0!670*! /703!0.0*/$)&&3! -0)(7!2&+!)@0!

/70410&.01;!!

!

E7'1!'1!673!'/!-0,-010*/1!)*!$*8)'-!'*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&!/-)*180-!82-!32$*@0-!62-90-1!/2!7).0!/2!

1$,,2-/!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*0-1!2*!,0*1'2*!'*(2401!67'(7!)-0!4$(7!42-0!@0*0-2$1!/7)*!

)*3/7'*@!/703!6'&&!%0!)%&0!/2!)882-+!/70410&.01;!N1!/70!0.'+0*(0! '*!/7'1!-0,2-/!7)1!1726*5!

421/!28!/70!$*8$*+0+!,$%&'(!10(/2-!1(70401!)-0!1$,,2-/0+!%3!/70!@0*0-)&!/)Y,)30-!%0()$10!

28!)!+08'('/!%0/600*!/70'-!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!8-24!)(/'.0!62-90-1!)*+!/70!)42$*/!/703!7).0!/2!

,)3!2$/!'*!,0*1'2*1;!!

!

A7'&1/!/70!-0(2440*+)/'2*1!28!/70!>$//2*!`0,2-/!,-24'10+!/2!'4,-2.0!/7'1!,21'/'2*5!/703!

7).0!%00*!6)/0-0+!+26*!12!/7)/!/70!+'880-0*(01!%0/600*!,$%&'(!)*+!,-'.)/0!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!

,-2.'1'2*!-04)'*!1/)-9;!E70!,-2,210+!(7)*@01!+2!*2/7'*@!)%2$/!/70!8)(/!/7)/!&)-@0!*$4%0-1!

28!,$%&'(! 10(/2-!62-90-1!672!%0&2*@! /2! /70!%)%3!%2240-!@0*0-)/'2*!6'&&! -0/'-0!$*+0-! /70!

,-010*/!X!'*/0-@0*0-)/'2*)&&3!-0@-011'.0!X!131/04;!!

!

E703!)&12!+2!*2/7'*@!)%2$/!/70!8)(/!/7)/!60!)-0!($--0*/&3!7).'*@!/70!6-2*@!+0%)/0!2*!,$%&'(!

10(/2-! ,0*1'2*1;! d'1($11'2*1! 28! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! ,0*1'2*! -082-4! 7).0! 12! 8)-! %00*! .0-3!

(2*(0-*0+!6'/7!)882-+)%'&'/3!X!670/70-!S-'/)'*!6'&&!7).0!0*2$@7!42*03!/2!,)3!82-40-!,$%&'(!

10(/2-!62-90-1!/70!1$%1/)*/')&!,0*1'2*!-'@7/1!/703!7).0!)((-$0+;!!

!

!

!


!

!

l0/! /7'1! /)901! *2! )((2$*/! 28!670/70-! '/! '1! 8)'-! /2! &0/! /704!)((-$0! /7010! -'@7/1! '*! /70! 8'-1/!

,&)(05! 2-! 8)'-! /26)-+1! 32$*@0-! )*+! 8$/$-0! /)Y,)30-1;! F*! )*! )@0! 670*! .'-/$)&&3! )&&! ,-'.)/0!

10(/2-!62-90-1!)-0!7).'*@!/2! 8$*+!/70!0*/'-0/3!28! /70'-!26*!,0*1'2*1!/70410&.015! '1! '/! 1/'&&!

8)'-! 82-! 62-90-1! '*! /70! ,$%&'(! 10(/2-! /2! 0*U23! /70! ,-'.'&0@0! 28! 7).'*@! /70'-1! 1$%1'+'10+! %3!

/)Y,)30-1o!

!

F*+00+5! /70! -0)&!+0%)/0! '1!670/70-!,-'.)/0! 10(/2-! /)Y,)30-1! 172$&+! 1/'&&!%0! 1$%1'+'1'*@! /70!

,0*1'2*1! 28! )*2/70-! @-2$,! 28! 62-90-1! 670*! /7035! 2*! ).0-)@05! 0)-*! 7'@70-! 1)&)-'015! &'.0!

&2*@0-!)*+!7).0!42-0!@0*0-2$1!,0*1'2*1;!TY,-0110+! &'90! /7'15! 1$-0&3! /70!,-010*/!1'/$)/'2*!

-0,-010*/1!)!/2/)&!+0-0&'(/'2*!28!+$/3!/26)-+1!2$-!32$*@0-!)*+!8$/$-0!/)Y,)30-1o!

!

E70!N40-'()*!,-01'+0*/!E724)1!b0880-12*!4)3!60&&!7).0!)@-00+;!N1!70!1)'+! '*!G[GP5!"/70!

,-'*(',&0! 28! 1,0*+'*@!42*03! /2! %0! ,)'+! %3! ,21/0-'/35! $*+0-! /70! *)40! 28! 8$*+'*@5! '1! %$/!

16'*+&'*@!8$/$-'/3!2*!)!&)-@0!1()&0;<!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

!


E$/$#$(F$,!! G!p$2/0+!'*!C)*!9@'$%7'4W!

!7//,Wkk666;@$)-+')*;(2;$9k%$1'*011kR\G\k),-kGGk,-'.)/0:10(/2-:,0*1'2*1:-0/'-040*/:,&)**'*@!R!p$2/0+!'*!C)*!C*2*<$'K)W!

7//,Wkk666;/0&0@-),7;(2;$9k8'*)*(0k,0-12*)&8'*)*(0k,0*1'2*1k[KQKKMQk>$//2*:-0,2-/:,$%&'(:

10(/2-:,0*1'2*1:1/'&&:7$@0&3:@0*0-2$1:(24,)-0+:/2:,-'.)/0:10(/2-;7/4&!K!F*/0-.'06!6'/7!SSL!`)+'2!MB1!H#$2%!C)7.!H**-*4%!8'-1/!%-2)+()1/!2*!\MkGRkR\GG!M!,E;!,88@K'(7#4'2!D*4.7#4!;8)*3*!;@$M*I5!_IJ5!!R\\^!H!_IJ!P!N4%*K*4%*4(!D@F278!;*$M78*!D*4.7#4.!O#337..7#4G!P74'2!0*K#$(5!F#J#L5!R\G\!Q!F%'+;![!"a*'2*1!J009!O$-/70-!#0*1'2*!L2*(011'2*1<5!P74'487'2!C73*.5!\RkGGkGGW!

7//,Wkk666;8/;(24k(41k1k\kP)RK00^):\HHG:GG0G:%[8M:\\GMM80)%+(\;7/4&q)YZZG2V_L_R76!^!L)%'*0/!_88'(0!G\!>)-@-0).01!=)*1+26*5!8'@$-01!(2--0(/!)1!28!J0,/04%0-!RR!R\GGW!

7//,Wkk666;7&;(2;$9k,0*1'2*1k)**$'/'01k)**$'/3:%01/:%$3:-)/01q/0-4'*2&2@3!GG!D*4.7#4!P'8(.!&'I!=Q//5!#0*1'2*1!#2&'(3!F*1/'/$/0!GR!F%'+;!GK!`0/'-040*/!#)-/*0-17',!GM!=Q/Q!144@'2!;@$M*I!#:!?#@$.!'4%!J'$474<.5!_IJ5!R\G\!GH!N&&!*$4%0-1!-080-!/2!@-211!)**$)&!'*(240!8-24!,$%&'(!10(/2-!,0*1'2*!%082-0!/)Y!)*+!2/70-!

+0+$(/'2*1!GP!F%'+;!GQ!D@F278!;*8(#$!D'I!'4%!D*4.7#4.5!FOJ5!R\GG!G[!O7M72!;*$M78*!;('(7.(78.5!>2$10!28!L2442*1!='%-)-35!R\GR!G^!P7.8'2!;@.('74'F727(I!0*K#$(5!_88'(0!82-!S$+@0/!`01,2*1'%'&'/35!b$&3!R\GG!R\!I0'&!`0(2-+5!F*1/'/$/0!28!T(2*24'(!N88)'-1!RG!F%'+;!RR!D*$.K*8(7M*.!#4!92#F'2!6*M*2#K3*4(!=Q/QG!;)7:(74<!H*'2()5!_TLd5!b$*0!R\G\!RK!J/)/'1/'(1!'*!/7'1!10(/'2*!)-0!/)90*!8-24!/70!E?;!D*4.7#4!;8)*3*!'4%!E?;!O#3K*4.'(7#4!:#$!

D$*3'(@$*!0*(7$*3*4(!;8)*3*!188#@4(.!=Q/QR=Q//5!I>J5!R\GG!e$*&011!1/)/0+f!RM!J/)/'1/'(1!'*!/7'1!10(/'2*!)-0!/)90*!8-24!/70!)**$)&!E?;!D*4.7#4!;8)*3*!'4%!E?;!O#3K*4.'(7#4!:#$!

D$*3'(@$*!0*(7$*3*4(!;8)*3*!188#@4(.!82-!-0&0.)*/!30)-1!RH!J/)/'1/'(1!'*!/7'1!10(/'2*!)-0!/)90*!8-24!/70!O'F74*(!,::78*G!O7M72!;@K*$'44@'(7#4!0*.#@$8*!188#@4(.!

=QQSR/Q5!L)%'*0/!_88'(05!R\G\e$*&011!1/)/0+f!RP!J/)/'1/'(1!'*!/7'1!10(/'2*!)-0!/)90*!8-24!/70!C*'8)*$.T!D*4.7#4!;8)*3*!UJ4<2'4%!'4%!H'2*.VG!144@'2!

188#@4(.!=Q/QR//5!d0,)-/40*/!28!T+$()/'2*5!R\GG!RQ!d)/)!12$-(0+!8-24!C*'8)*$.T!D*4.7#4!;8)*3*!U!J4<2'4%!'4%!H'2*.VG!144@'2!188#@4(.!82-!-0&0.)*/!

30)-1!R[!J/)/'1/'(1!'*!/7'1!10(/'2*!)-0!/)90*!8-24!/70!1$3*%!P#$8*.!D*4.7#4!;8)*3*!0*.#@$8*!188#@4(.!

=QQSR/Q5!V'*'1/-3!28!d080*(05!R\G\!R^!V04%0-1!28!/70!)-40+!82-(01!+2!*2/!7).0!/2!,)3!(2*/-'%$/'2*1!/26)-+!/70'-!,0*1'2*1;!K\!"SSL!&'(0*(0!800!,)30-1!4$1/!8'*+!]^\\4!82-!,0*1'2*!8$*+!+08'('/<5!6'72I!C*2*<$'K)5!RMk\KkGGW!

7//,Wkk666;/0&0@-),7;(2;$9k($&/$-0k/.)*+-)+'2k%%(k[M\RKRRkSSL:&'(0*(0:800:,)30-1:4$1/:8'*+:

^\\4:82-:,0*1'2*:8$*+:+08'('/;7/4&!KG!"A7)/!+201!/70!SSL!,-2.'+0o<5!WWO!D*4.7#4.5!G[kGGkG\W!

7//,Wkk666;%%(;(2;$9k43,0*1'2*k1'/01k70&,)+.'(0k,)@01k67)/:+201:/70:%%(:,-2.'+0;17/4&!


Documents

IF Government Pensions Report Definitive - image.guardian.co.uk · IF Government Pensions Report Definitive - image.guardian.co.uk ... 7 | !!!!!