13
This article was downloaded by: [University of New Mexico] On: 22 November 2014, At: 19:47 Publisher: Taylor & Francis Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tnzg20 Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks P. N. Webb a & Guyon Warren a a New Zealand Geological Survey, Department of Scientific and Industrial Research Published online: 09 Feb 2012. To cite this article: P. N. Webb & Guyon Warren (1965) Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks, New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics, 8:2, 221-230, DOI: 10.1080/00288306.1965.10428108 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00288306.1965.10428108 PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content. This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.

Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

  • Upload
    guyon

  • View
    217

  • Download
    4

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

This article was downloaded by: [University of New Mexico]On: 22 November 2014, At: 19:47Publisher: Taylor & FrancisInforma Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

New Zealand Journal of Geology andGeophysicsPublication details, including instructions for authors andsubscription information:http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tnzg20

Isotope dating of Antarctic rocksP. N. Webb a & Guyon Warren aa New Zealand Geological Survey, Department of Scientificand Industrial ResearchPublished online: 09 Feb 2012.

To cite this article: P. N. Webb & Guyon Warren (1965) Isotope dating of Antarcticrocks, New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics, 8:2, 221-230, DOI:10.1080/00288306.1965.10428108

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00288306.1965.10428108

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE

Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information(the “Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor& Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warrantieswhatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of theContent. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions andviews of the authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. Theaccuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and should be independentlyverified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liablefor any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages,and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly inconnection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content.

This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Anysubstantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.

Page 2: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 3: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

1965] 221

ISOTOPE DATING OF ANTARCTIC ROCKS

A SUMMARY-2

P. N. WEBB and GUYON WARREN

New Zealand Geological Survey, Department of Scientific and Industrial Research

(First submitted for publication, 6 May 1963; as finally revised, 29 July 1964)

ABSTRACT

Details of 141 isotope dates obtained from Antarctic rocks and reported in recent literature are listed. Accompanying each date are details of the rock type analysed, the laboratory method used, the locality at which the sample was collected, the country in which the sample was processed, and a reference to the original publica­tion. Revised ages are listed for 90 determinations summarised in an earlier paper.

Details of 141 potassium-argon, strontium-rubidium, and lead-uranium isotope dates obtained from Antarctic rocks are listed in Table 1, and their geographic distribution shown in Fig. 1. Where geographic coordinates are not given in the original publication, the approximate figures have been taken from other scientific literature or gazetteers.

A comprehensive survey of isotope dating is presented in a monograph published by the New York Academy of Sciences in 1961 and entitled "Geochronology of Rock Systems". This publication embraces three main aspects of geochronology: the methodology of the U /Pb, Sr/Rb, and A/K geochronometers, the geological time scale, and the history of the basement rocks of the continents. Only one paper in this monograph (Starik et al., 1961) deals specifically with isotope dating of Antarctic rocks. The in­formation in this Soviet paper was presented earlier in the Reports of the 21st Session of the International Geological Conference (Starik, Krylov, et al., 1960).

Of the 231 dates summarised in this and an earlier paper (Webb, 1962), 137 originate from Soviet laboratories. The great majority of Soviet results were obtained by A/K analysis of whole rocks. In discussing their results, and the methods employed, Starik et at. (1961, p. 577) comment:

"Age determinations by the K-Ar method on whole rocks rather than on individual minerals may raise doubts that are entirely justified .... It has now been established that the most reliable determinations of absolute age by the K-Ar method are obtained from micas. . . . A number of determinations we have made of the age of Antarctic rocks by the K-Ar method, directly on the rocks themselves and on micas taken from them, indicate the agreement of the results is satisfactory, with the qualification that feldspar rocks give a more recent age, as a rule, than other rocks of the same age, or micaceous rocks. Particularly large discrepancies are observed between micas and feldspars from pegmatites."

N.Z. J. Geol. Geophvs. 8 : 221-30

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 4: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

TA

BL

E I

-Deta

ils

of 1

41

Iso

tope

Dat

es o

f A

ntar

ctic

Roc

ks.

Sam

ples

are

arr

ange

d ap

prox

imat

ely

in o

rder

of

incr

easi

ng E

lon

gi tu

de.

Whe

re s

ever

al

date

s ha

ve

been

ob

tain

ed b

y di

ffer

ent

met

hods

:r

om a

sin

gle

sam

ple,

a b

race

is

used

to

link

the

se d

ates

. U

nder

the

col

umn

head

ed M

etho

d, t

r =

tot

al r

ock;

b =

bio

tite

; f

= f

elds

par;

m

=

m

ica;

0

= o

rthi

te;

p =

pyr

oxen

e; z

= z

irco

n. R

efer

ence

s ar

e gi

ven

by n

umbe

r in

the

lis

t at

the

end

of

the

pape

r.

Age

G

p.o

gra

ph

ic

Seria

l (m

illi

on

R

ock

M

ate

rial

Ne

tho

d

Lo

cali

ty

C

oo

rd in

a te 5

Pro

cessed

R

e:f

ere

nces

Nu

mb

er

years

) L

at.

S

Lo

ng

.E

In

91

10

0

Gab

bro

A

,40

/K4

0

p A

n ta

re tic

P

en

insu

la

6J

17

5

7

58W

U

.S.A

. (7

)

92

7

5

Gra

no

dio

ri te

b 63

2

5

58

OJW

9J

J95

B

iot!

tc

gra

ni te

tr

Co

nra

d ~rountains

72

0

0

10

0

0

U.S

.S.R

. (1

7)

94

4

00

S

yen

i te

g

ran

i te

tr

95

4

6)

Dio

ti te

gn

eis

s

tr

96

4

05

G

ran

i te

(v

ein

) tr

Vo

rpo

ste

n

Peak

I

71

20

1

6

00

97

4

6)

Dio

psid

e-p

hlo

go

pi

te

rock

tr

98

4

48

A

mp

hi b

oie

-pla

gio

cla

se

gn

eis

s

tr

Zh

ela

n ~I

t 1

8

00

99

4

49

}

Po

rp

hy

ro

bla

sti

c

gra

n!

te

Sr8

7/R

b8

7

b R

om

no

es:

fjel1

ct,

S

or

Ro

nd

an

e

Htn

s

71

2

7

2J

57

DE

'le

ium

(l

J)

10

0

54

0

Pb

20

7/P

b2

06

z

10

1

'" 1 I

ntr

usiv

e p

orp

hy

rob

lasli

c g

ran

ite

sr8

7/R

b8

7

b (1

1)

Pb

20

7/P

b2

06

1

02

5

40

z

10

J 5

18

P

b2

07

/U2

J5

10

4

51

4

Pb

20

6/u

2J8

sr8

7/R

b8

7

10

5

4J5

}

Gra

ni te

b

G1

.tn

nesi

ad

bre

en

I 7

2

00

2

" 0

0

(13

)

10

6

57

5

l'b

20

7/P

b2

06

z

10

7

'" } I

ntr

usiv

e

gran

ite

sr8

7/R

b8

7

b (1

1 )

10

8

45

3

f

10

9

57

5

Pb

20

7/P

b2

06

z

11

0

52

4

Pb

20

7/U

2J5

11

1

51

2

Pb

20

6/U

2J8

11

2

45

2 }

M

uS

CO

V1

tc-h

io t

i ie

-co

run

du

m

gn

eis

s

sr8

7/R

b8

7

m

Au

5 t

kam

pan

c ,

7

2

00

2

5

00

(1

3)

11

) 4

62

b

N

N

N Z N --0 c:: ~ Z

>

t"'

0 ."

G')

t>1

0 t"'

0 Q

>

Z

0 G')

t>1

0 '" ~ n (J] '§::

>

><

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 5: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

46J

} S

r87

/Rb

R7

......

11

4

Mu

sco

vi te-b

io t

i te

-co

ru

nd

um

g

neis

s

b (1

1)

\0

11

5

47

9

0\

IJI

11

6

'" 1 G

neis

s x

en

oli

th

in

d

iari

te

b N

ord

ta

pp

en

1

10

0,'

1

71

27

2

5

17

11

7

55

0

Pb

20

7/P

b2

06

11

8

55

5

Pb

20

7/U

2J5

~

11

9

55

5

Pb

20

6/u

2J8

tt

l

12

0

4J9

}

Gra

ni t

e

in v

ein

sr8

7/R

b8

7

b N

ord

ta

pp

en

9

50

. "

71

26

(13

) C:

I 2

5

20

C:

I 1

21

4

95

P

b2

07

/Pb

20

6

>

12

2

", 1 G

ra

n! tic

v

ein

in

d

iar!

te

sr8

7/R

b8

7

b (1

1)

Z

Pb

20

7/P

b2

06

t::

l 1

2J

50

0

12

4

508

Pb

20

7/U

23

5

~ 1

25

5

10

P

b2

06

/U2

J8

~

12

6

47

6

Gra

ni te

sr8

7/R

b8

7

b S

ma

ha

u s

an

e,

71

J3

25

25

(l

J)

~

ttl

12

7

48

2

F1

ne_

gra

ined

m

icro

cli

ne

gra

nit

e

tr

S tr

an

dru

df'

j ellet,

71

52

25

4

0

Z

12

8

45

6

) F

ine-g

ra

ined

m

icro

cli

ne g

ra

nit

e

b (1

1 )

I (a

na

tecti

c?

) 0

12

9

"11

f'

>

>-

I lJ

o

47

0

tr

Z

1J1

4

P

eg

rna

ti

te

b G

un

na

r ls

ach

sen

fjel1

e t

I"

72

00

26

0

0

(lJ)

C'l

1J2

4

9"

Mig

ma

tise

d

gn

eis

s

b 0 "l

1JJ

47

5 }

F

ine-g

ra

ined

m

icro

cli

ne

gra

ni te

tr

B

au

ta

en

. S

or

Ro

nd

an

e

Mtn

s 71

5

9

26

0

2

lJ4

4

72

b

:>

Z

lJ5

4

7J}

F

ine_

tra

ined

m

icro

cli

ne

gra

ni

te

b (1

1 )

>-I

(an

ate

cti

c?

)

>

~

1J6

4

48

f'

n >-

I 1

J7

55

5

tr

r; 1

38

5

40

B

ioti te

A

4O/K

4O

b O

yg

ard

en

Isla

nd

s

67

00

5

7

00

TJ

, S.

S.H

. (1

7)

~

lJ9

6

27

B

iot!

tis

ed

p

yro

xen

e-p

lag

iocla

se

tr?

M

aw

son

S

tati

on

67

J6

62

5

J g

neis

s

n ~

14

0

45

8

Mu

sco

vi te

m

L

arse

ma

nn

H

ills

6

9

25

7

6

1J

en

14

1

40

5

Bio

ti te

-ga

rn

e t

g

neis

s

lr

69

28

7

6 lJ

(1

5 )

14

2

40

5

Ch

arn

ock

! te

tr

14

J 1

10

4

Gra

ni te

tr

La

ng

-nes

P

en

insu

la

(Vestf

'old

H

ills

)

68

3

0

78

0

0

(17

) N

N

\j

>

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 6: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

tv

Geo

gra

ph

ic

tv

Age

....

Seria

l (m

illi

on

R

ock

!l

-fa

teria

l M

eth

od

L

oca

li t

y

Co

ord

ina

tes

Pro

cessed

R

efe

ren

ces

Nu

mb

er

yea

rs)

La

t. S

L

on

g.

E

In

14

4

14

18

L

eu c

o-p

lag

iog

ra

ni

te

A4O

/K4

0

tr

La

n{;

nes

P

en

insu

la

(Vestf

old

lI

illE

) 6

8

30

78

0

0

p.

S.

S.

R.

(17

). (

18

)

14

5

14

JJ

Leu

co

cra

tic

pla

gio

gra

ni

te

tr

14

6

14

82

L

ell

co

cra

tic

gra

nit

e

(vein

m

ate

ria

l tr

(15

) Z

in

m

igm

a tf t

e)

N

14

7

)12

60

D

ole

ri te

d

ike

ell tt

ine g

neis

s

tr

Vestf

old

H

ills

(1

8 )

14

8

17

82

}

Ark

osi

c

san

dst

on

e

{fi

ne fr

acti

on

, tr

'-<

0

.1

to 0

.25

mm

} 0 d

14

9

17

92

A

rk

osi

c

san

dst

on

e

(co

arse

fra

cti

on

, tr

~

>0

.25

m

m.)

Z >

15

0

458

Ala

sk

itic

p

orp

Jty

ro

bla

stic

g

ra

nit

e

tr

Pen

gu

in Isla

nd

6

5

45

81

50

(1

7)

t"'"

151

47

7

Peg

ma

I;i

te

in

ch

arn

ock

! te

tr

0

15

2

67

5

68

15

8

6

)0

(15

) "'

l R

ioti

te-p

yro

xen

e

gn

eis

s

tr

rofo

unt

nro

wn

15

J 4

00

R

ock

s o

f ch

arn

ock

ite-m

an

gerit

e

tr

Mo

rajn

e C

liff

66

JJ

93

0

0

(15

). (

8)

C'l

serie

s

t'%l

0 1

54

4

39

G

rey

v

ein

g

ra

ni

te

tr

t"'"

0 1

55

4

24

P

eg

ma

ti t

e

tr

1-l

irn

yy

(1

7)

~

>< 1

56

4

43

B

iotit

e

fro

m

peg

ma

tite

b

>

15

7

41

5

Pe

grn

a t

i te

tr

Ha

sw

ell

Isla

nd

(1

5).

(8

) Z

1

58

J1

8

(;ra

ni

te

po

rp

hy

ry

tr

Da

vj

d Isla

nd

66

2

7

98

42

t:

)

15

9

45

3

Peg

-rna

to

id

gra

ni

te

tr

C'l

t>1

16

0

67

0

Sh

ad

ow

m

igrn

a ti

Le

tr

0

16

1

511

Po

ssessio

n

Cli

f'f'

s 6

6

45

98

51

"d

M

ic-r

ua ti te

tr

~ 1

62

5

8)

Peg

-rn

a ti

te

tr

!oIo

un

t S

tra

thco

na

66

2

7

99

1

0

16

) 6

8 It

A

mp

hib

oli

tic

gra

nit

e

tr

r; Vl

16

4

944

Bio

Li

te

gn

eis

s

tr

Bli

ng

er H

ills

6

6

00

10

1 0

0

(17

)

16

5

968

_11J7

}

Pe

grn

a t

i te

tr

16

6

1JO

O

Pb

20

8/T

h

16

7

15

20

P

b2

06 /

u2

)8

A4O

/K4

0

(15

) ,....

.., 1

68

60

2 S

ha

do

w

mig

ma

tite

tr

s:::

16

9

617

Bio

li

te-p

yro

xen

e

gn

eis

s

tr

>

><

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 7: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

~ 7

0

6'- -,

1

-'

,-70

!,

1-' ,-

10

16

17J

10

41

174

10

94

17

.:)

11

37

17

6

689

17

7

96

)

17R

1

22

5

17

9

51

6

18

0

77

4

1R

l 5

49

IRe

675

18

3

564

18.4

61

2

lR.5

71

8

186

675

18

7

h7:!.

18

8

47

2

189

741

19

0

81

8

19

1

85

2

19

2

86

6

19

3

905

19

4

915

19

5

73

1

19

6

10

55

19

7

15

30

19

8

15

1 '3

P£'l;

lI1a

ti

t e

Feld

sp

a U

d.5

cd

F,

llC'

i~s

Sh

ado

w

nd

gll

la t

il C

'

Sch

is t

Tli

o li te

gn

eis

s

Sch

is t;

Ro

ck

s o

r ch

arn

ock

i le

-man

ccri

te

seri

ps

r.ii

gma li te

Pin

k

po

1y

miF

,lI1

a ti

te

Feld

sp

a t

lii sed

h

io li te

-aarn

et

gn

eis

s

Carn

e t

en

pis

s

Leu

co

cra

tic g

ran

ite

(vein

mate

rial

of'

lI

1igm

a ti

tes)

Ro

ck

s o

f ch

arn

ock

i tc

-man

acri

te

serj

c s

Ap

lile

Sh

ado

w

po

lym

igm

a ti te

Ro

ck

s o

f cll

arn

od

d te-m

an

geri

te

seri

ps

l'ee;

ma ti

te

Feld

sp

a t

his

erl

g

ran

ite

Gn

eis

s

Gra

rd t

e

gn

eis

s

Po

rph

yri

ti

c era

ni·

tc

Gra

ni te

Bio

ti

te g

neis

s

Gra

nit

e

Gn

eis

s

l)eg

mato

id eran

ite

Peg

mati

te v

ein

Gra

ni te

, v

ein

in

r:

neis

s

tr

tr

tr

t1.'

tr

tr

t1.'

Dru

zh

ba

Is1

an

d

tr

tr

tr

'Tli

om

as Is

lall

d

tr

"tr

Sm

cly

kh

Is

lan

d

tr

tr

Ch

arn

ock

itc Is

lan

d

tr

Cach

alo

t Is

lan

d

tr

tr

Harr

is C

liffs

tr

lIig

hju

mp

A

l·ch

ipela

go

tr

tr

Grie

rso

n H

ills

(W

ilic

lmil

l Is

lan

ds

66

~o

11

0

28

tr

tr

tr

tr

tr

tr

are

a)

tr

Po

rpo

ise

Day

Sr8

7./ R

b87

b

Ile M

len

e

b lI

es d

es

ptt

rf'>

ls

66

48

1

28

40

66

37

1

40

01

66

4

0

14

0 0

1

(17

)

(1s)

Fra

nce

(3)

.....

\0

0\

VI ~

~

tl:l

tl:l >

Z

I:) ~ :;d

:;d ~

Z I o ~ Z

C'l o "'1 >

Z ~ r; ~ 8 N

N

V

I

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 8: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

N

N

0\

Age

G

eo

gra

ph

ic

Seria

l C

oo

rd

ina

tes

Pro

cess

ed

N

um

ber

(m

illi

on

R

ock

N

a te

ria

l M

eth

od

L

oca

li ty

L

at.

S

Lo

ng

.E

In

Refe

ren

ces

yea

rs)

,

19

9

46

J R

ose-c

olo

ured

g

ra

n!

te

A4O

/K4

0

tr

Ain

swo

r t

h

Hn

y

67

48

1

46

4

5

U.S

. S

.R.

(17

)

20

0

48

7

Gra

n! te

tr

Z

201

JJ7

G

rey

g

ra

ni te

tr

(15

) N

2

02

7

55

P

ink

g

ra

ni te

tr

20

J 19

1 D

ole

r1

te,

eu t

tin

g

Hea

co

n

Gro

up

tr

lIo

rn

fl

luf'

f 6R

24

1

49

4

8

'-<

20

4

16

9

tr

An

yu

to

C

ap

e 7

0

00

1

62

0

0

8 i>l

20

5

516

Peg

ma

t! te

tr

Eig

er

Isla

nd

s

Z

20

6

59

J R

ock

s o

f'

ch

arn

ock

! tp

-ma

ng

eri te

tr

>

serie

s

t""'

20

7

59

8

Bio

tit

e-g

arn

et

ro

ck

tr

0 ."

20

8

16

2

Ferra

r D

ole

ri te

(in

tru

din

g

Vid

a

f:

Vic

toria

V

all

ey

7

7

20

1

61

0

8

Au

str

ali

a

(4)

C')

Gra

n! te)

ttl

20

9

16

J F

erra

r D

ole

r! te

(i

n

gra

no

dio

ri te

) p

(10

) 0 t""

' 2

10

1

59

f:

7

7

24

16

2

00

0 C

2

11

1

62

7

7

25

1

61

4

5

>< 2

12

1

85

G

ra

no

dio

ri te

(V

ida

G

ra

n!

te)

77

2

J 1

62

0

0

>

21

) 2

22

S

ilic

ic d

ike

intr

ud

ing

g

ra

no

dio

rit

e

f:

Z

t:)

21

4

21

0

Gren

ad

ior!

te

(Vid

a

Gra

ni

te)

h 7

7

2J

16

1

52

C'

) 2

15

21

1 S

ilic

ic d

ike

intr

ud

ing

g

ren

ad

iori te

"

77

2

J 1

62

0

0

ttl

21

6

50

0

Ma

rb

le

fro

m

meta

mo

rp

hic

serie

s

b H

arh

!p

Pa

in t

77

25

1

6J

50

u

.s.

A.

(2)

0 'tl

21

7

49

6

Dio

ri te

(1

2 )

:x: >< 2

18

5

24

B

asic

d

ike

b '" r;

21

9

52

0

La

mp

ro

ph

yre

dik

e

b 7

7

4)

16

J 4

0

'" 2

20

4

25

J

.lo

nzo

nit

ic

gn

eis

s

b N

t..

Xu

ssh

au

m,

Ta

ylo

r V

all

ey

7

7

4J

16

2

40

(2

)

221

45

8

La

mp

rop

hy

re

dik

e

22

2 }

1

50

P

eg

ma

ti tic

d

ole

ri

te

(Ferra

r

Do

lerit

e)

f:

Ste

pa

sid

C'

Sp

ur,

Sk

c!

ton

(~la('ier

78

1

8

16

1

21

Au

str

ali

a

(10

) in

tru

din

g

ba

sem

en

t ro

ck

22

J 1

54

'i: >

><

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 9: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

......

22

4

15

8 }

F

erra

r

Do

lc-r

i le

j

ntr

l1.d

inG

"

Bea

co

n

Esca

lad

e

}'('

ak

, S

kf'

l tO

ll

xrfv

t 7

8

J7

15

9

25

G

rou

p

22

5

15

J p

\0

0\

VI

22

6

15

J F

erra

r D

ole

rit

e

intr

ud

inG

"

Dea

co

n

r H

t :t

-Iar

kh

am,

QH(,(~11

Eli

::ta

hp

th

Ra

ng

e 8

J 04

1

60

1

0

Gro

up

22

7

14

7

} F

erra

r D

ole

rit

e

intr

ud

ing

B

ea

co

n

r B

un

ker

CW

III.

!oil

Mil

lpr,

llro

ard

mo

re

8J

10

1

66

00

G

ro

up

G

lacie

r

22

8

15

5

p

~

tTl ~ ~

22

9

62

0

Qu

artz

ID

on

zon

i te

p

orp

hy

ry

P

h

cI..

~

Aa

ro

ll G

lacie

r,

Th

iel

JI.I

tns

88

1

0

90

JO

W

>

(5 )

Z

2JO

6

J O}

Q

ua

rt?

m

on

:7.o

ni t

e

po

rp

hy

ry

~

Gre

en V

all

ey

, T

hie

l ).

[tn

s 8R

0

5

90

15

W

2J1

5J

O

0 ~

>

~

~

tTl Z I a >

>-i Z

C'l

0 "1 >

Z

>-i ~ t"l

>-i Pi l=d

0 t"l ~

en

IV

IV

-..j

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 10: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

228 NZ. JOURNAL OF GEOLOGY AND GEOPHYSICS [MAY

TABLE 2-Revision of Figures in Earlier Summary (Webb, 1962).

This list repeats, in exact original order, the ages tabulated in the earlier summary of published isotope dates (Webb, 1962), and gives, where necessary, revised figures for each date using the same decay constants for K'o and Rb" as those adopted in this paper. Determinations using Pb isotopes have not been altered. Ages from A/K or Sr/Rb ratios for which the decay constant used in the original calculation is not known are repeated as originally published, followed by an asterisk (*).

A serial number is given to each determination.

The revised figures are incorporated with those of Table 1 1n the locality map (Fig. 1).

---~--------

~ .S --;; ~ .S ~ ~ .s -;;; " ""-~ " ~;i':; " ]fJ5 .0 "

.c " .c " a ~~~ OIl S ~~~ OIl S bIl

" -< " -< " ~~~ -< Z ;":::::::I=l

"" Z :.:~§ ] z ] ~ 0 "

~-o

~ C\'I..c;.::: ·s ] c(I..c:'= :-3 C':I..o;.::: ~-£] '" ~~'§ ·s

'" ~;£:g ·s " " " ~ " " rJl -<~- i>: '" -<~- '" -<~- i>:

,.------

1 176 176 r375 61 760 777 2 199 199 34 470 j458 62 700 713 3 183 183 1468 63 730 747 4 184 184 L485 64 730 747 5 195 195 35 535 516 65 700 708 6 195 195 36 555 535 66 705 723 7 176 176 37 490 476 67 950 950* 8 189 189 38 1070 1147 68 1120 Sl120 • 9 193 193 39 1270 1312 11120*'

10 400 386 40 20 ~20' 69 1075 f1050* 11 420 405 41 468 468* 11100* 12 450 434 42 509 509* 70 780 741 13 460 443 43 450 458 71 1020 1045 14 390 376 44 430 443 72 660 675 15 400 386 45 440 453 73 720 731 16 460 443 46 455 463 74 1020 1044 17 475 458 47 525 540 75 450 461 18 478 454 48 430 443 76 450 458 19 465 442 49 925 949 77 450 458 20 458 435 50 1070 1099 78 485 458 21 457 434 51 515 523 79 445 453 22 476 452 52 %0 560* 80 170 175 23 481 457 53 915 910* 81 450 461 24 493 468 54 915 920* 82 500 512 25 455 432 55 9451 83 460 463 26 483 459 56 945~ 920* 84 425 434 27 506 481 57 945j -970* 85 445 458 28 471 447 r1190 86 315 318 29 474 450 58 1300 j 1215 87' 305 313 30 525 494 11262 8-g 410 420 31 530 498 L1350 89 400 410 32 510 479 59 950 973 90 520 501 33 500 470 60 940 968

NOTES 'Published figure "about 20 m.y.".

'Sr/Rb.

'A/K. 'Coordinates given as 70 0 32' S, 163 0 15' E by Starik et al. be in the Mirnyy Region (93 0 E) by Starik et al. (1961).

(1959); but stated to

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 11: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

~ ~

c< 0 "Q G • oJ" <

"Q ~ ~

~ • § X

0 z .::> ~ 0

0

z • • . + • < ;: Q Z < • • • ;:

• i;::u:~ ~----

~~oe;a~s r----11

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 12: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

1965] WEBB AND WARREN - DATING OF ANTARCTIC ROCKS 229

Picciotto and Coppez (1963) review, in French, 15 papers dealing with age determinations on Antarctic rocks. They recalculate all previous Antarctic A 40 /K4D and Sr87/Rb87 dates, using revised decay constants. This has the effect of reducing slightly most of the earlier-published ages.

The present list (Table 1), as originally compiled by Webb, has been revised by Warren to the same standard constants-i.e., all ages from A/K determinations are based on calculations using AeK1D = 5·85 X 10-11 yr-1 (Aldrich and Wetherill, 1958), and ages from Sr/Rb determina­tions use A,8Rb87 = 1·47 X 10-11 yr-1 (Glendenin, 1961). In most cases the revised figure has been taken directly from Picciotto and Coppez (1963). Ages listed for Pb isotope determinations are those originally published.

Table 2, also prepared by Warren, presents revised figures for the ages given in the earlier summary (Webb, 1962), all dates having been given serial numbers (1-90). All determinations from both Tables of this paper are shown diagrammatically on a map of Antarctica (Fig. 1).

Picciotto and Coppez (1963) note that in the Russian literature the same sample may appear in two publications with slightly different ages. They attribute this to the use of different decay constants or different values of argon content.

In this paper the column showing geological period (see Table 1 of Webb, 1962) has been intentionally omitted, owing to the uncertainty of the relation between numerical ages and period divisions and to the uncertainty in the age figures themselves. Kulp (1961) gives a widely accepted scheme showing the absolute ages of geological periods.

REFERENCES

(1)

ALDRICH, L. T.; WETHERILL, G. W. 1958: Geochronology by Radioactive Decay. Ann. Rev. Nuclear Sci. 8: 257-98.

(2)

ANGINO, E. E.; TURNER, M. D.; ZELLER, E. ]. 1962: Reconnaissance Geology of Lower Taylor Valley, Victoria Land, Antarctica. Bull. Geol. Soc. Amer. 73: 1553-62.

(3) BELLAIR, P.; DELBOS, L. 1962: Age absolu de la derniere granitisation en Terre

Adelie. C.R. Acad. Sci. 254 (8): 1465-6.

(4) EVERNDEN, ]. P.; RICHARDS, ]. R. 1962: Potassium·Argon Ages in Eastern Australia.

]. Geol. Soc. Aust. 9 (1): 1-49.

(5)

FORD, A. B.; HUBBARD, H. A.; STERN, T. W. 1963: Lead-Alpha Ages of Zircon in Quartz Monzonite Porphyry, Thiel Mountains, Antarctica-A Preliminary Report. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Pap. 450-E, Article 208: E 105-8.

(6) GLENDENIN, L. E. 1961: Present Status of the Decay Constants. Ann. New York

Acad. Sci. 91 (2): 166-80.

GeDlogy-6

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014

Page 13: Isotope dating of Antarctic rocks

230 NZ. JOURNAL OF GEOLOGY AND GEOPHYSICS [MAY

(7) HALPERN, M. 1962: Potassium-Argon Dating of Plutonic Bodies in Palmer Peninsula

and Southern Chile. Science 138 (3546): 1261. (See also correction note in Science 139 (3560): 1191, 22 March 1963.)

(8) KRYLOV, A. YA.; SlLlN, Yu. I; ATRAsHENoK, L. YA; LOVTSYUS, A. V. 1961: Absolute

Age of Rocks from Mirnyy District in Antarctica. (In Russian.) Geokhimiya 11: 1034-5.

(9) KuLP,]. L. 1961: Geologic Time Scale. Science 133 (3459): 1105-14.

(10) McDoUGALL, I. 1963: Potassium-Argon Age Measurements on Dolerites from Ant­

arctica and South Africa. J. Geophys. Res. 68 (5): 1535-45.

(11) PASTEELS, P.; DEUTSCH, S. 1963: Age Measurements of Antarctic Rocks (Queen Maud

Land). Nature (Lond.) 199 (4897): 996-7.

(12) PEARN, W. c.; ANGINO, E. E.; STEWART, D. 1963: New Isotope Measurements from

the McMurdo Sound Area, Antarctica. Nature (Lond.) 199 (4894): 685.

(13) PICCIOTTO, E.; COPPEZ, A. 1963: Bibliographie des Mesures d'Ages Absolus en

Antarctique. Ann. Soc. Geol. Be/g. 85 (8): 264-308.

(14) STARIK, I. YE,; KRYLOV, A. YA.;. RAVICH, M. G.; SILlN, Yu. I. 1960: The Age of

East Antarctic Rocks. (In Russian.) DoH 21 Int. Geol. Congr. Prob. 3: 149-57.

(15) STARIK, I. YE.; KRYLOV, A. YA.; RAVICH, M. G.; SILlN, Yu. I. 1961: The Absolute

Ages of East Antarctic Rocks. Ann. New York Acad. Sci. 91: 576-82.

(16) STARIK, I. YE.; RAVICH, M. G.; KRYLOV, A. YA.; SILIN, Yu. 1. 1959: On the Absolute

Age of Rocks of the East Antarctic Platform. (In Russian.) Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 126 (1): 144-6.

(17) STARIK, I. YE.; RAVICH, M. G.; KRYLOV, A. YA.; SILlN, Yu. 1.; ATRASHENOK, L. YA.;

LoVTSYUS, A. V. 1960: New D8ta on the Absolute Age of Rocks in Eastern Antarctica. (In Russian.) DoH. Akad. Nauk SSSR 134 (6): 1421-3.

(18) VORONOV, P. S.; KRYLOV, A YA. 1961: Age of Ancient Rocks of Antarctica. (In

Russian.) Inf. Bull Sov. Antant. Exped. 28: 11-15.

(19) WEBB, P. N. 1962: Isotope Dating of Antarctic Rocks: A Summary-l. N.Z. J. Geol.

Geophys. .5 (5): 790·-6.

Dow

nloa

ded

by [

Uni

vers

ity o

f N

ew M

exic

o] a

t 19:

47 2

2 N

ovem

ber

2014