Living in the Anthropocene : Crash or Crash Through

7/24/2019 Living in the Anthropocene : Crash or Crash Through

1/15

!"#"$% "$ '() *$'(+,-,.)$)/+01( ,+ /+01( 2(+,3%(

4)$$)'( 5.!),6

78+,$ 708 9(":, /0;)

?


2/15

@@@A0%),;'+0$1"'",$A,+%

!"#"$% "$ '() *$'(+,-,.)$)/ 0+12( ,+ 0+12( 3(+,4%(

"#$%&'()* + ,-./ 01221*) 3"41#56 78. 9,. :;. :.?#> @&1>>6 AB2(BC#D6 EFGH


3/15

!"#"$% "$ '() *$'(+,-,.)$)/+01( ,+ /+01( 2(+,3%(

4)$$)'( 5.!),6

*$ 066+)11 ', '() 78+,$ 9(":, /0;)B 6 F#L&"1> #I P#$16 .;];

O)1&1 B&1 ?B2% &1B>#2> *# 51>$B'& #2 *)'>6 *)1 "L>$ #I *)1V2*)$#"121 *&B2>'*'#2H AL* ^'&>*6 C1*U> J1 "C1B& BJ#L* D)B* *)'>*1&? SV2*)$#"121T &1I1&> *#H

V2*)$#"121 '> *)1 *1&? "#'215 J% >"'12*'>*> I#& *)1 "L&&12*(1#C#('"BC 1$#") D)12 )L?B2 B"*'M'*% )B> J1"#?1 *)1 5#?'2B2*I#&"1 #I XB&*) F%>*1? ")B2(1H A% XB&*) F%>*1? D1 ?1B2 *)1'2*1(&B*156 5%2B?'"6 "#?$C1R B25 >1CI[&1(LCB*'2( $)%>'"BC6")1?'"BC B25 J'#C#('"BC $"1>>1> *)B* ?BK1 '* $#>>'JC1 I#& C'I1 *#^C#L&'>) #2 $CB21* XB&*)H

_B?1> 4#M1C#"K $#$LCB&'>15 *)1 "#2"1$* #I *)1 XB&*) F%>*1?D'*) *)1 *1&? `B'B a B ?1*B$)#& >L((1>*'2( *)B* *)1 XB&*)IL2"*'#2> C'K1 B >'2(C1 C'M'2( #&(B2'>?H

b2 *)1 V2*)$#"1216 I#& *)1 ^'&>* *'?1 '2 *)1 1M#CL*'#2 #I C'I1#2 $CB21* XB&*) B >'2(C1 >$1"'1> )B> J1"#?1 ># 2L?1L>6 >#D'51C% 5'>*&'JL*156 ># &B$B"'#L>6 B25 ># L2&1>$#2>'M1 *# 1"#[>%>*1? I115JB"K B> *# >1&'#L>C% 5'>&L$* *)1 J'#>$)1&1U> "&'*'"BCC'I1 >L$$#&* >%>*1?>H

!"#$ &


4/15

9:0$)'0+8 D,3$60+")1

cM1& &1"12* %1B&> B2 '2*1&2B*'#2BC 21*D#&K #I >"'12*'>*> )B>J112 51M1C#$'2( B ?#51C #I $CB21*B&% J#L25B&'1> a *)1 C'?'*>

J1%#25 D)'") D1 "B22#* (# D'*)#L* "BL>'2( >1M1&16L2$&15'"*BJC1 B25 $#>>'JC% "B*B>*$)'" 5'>&L$*'#2 *# *)1 XB&*)F%>*1?H

O)1'& &1>1B&") '25'"B*1> *)B* D1 B&1 B$$B")'2( B25 ?B%BC&1B5% )BM1 1R"11515 I#L& #I *)1 2'21 "&'*'"BC $CB21*B&%J#L25B&'1> *)1% B&1 ?#2'*#&'2(H cI *)1>1 "C'?B*1 ")B2(1 &1"1'M1>*)1 ?#>* B**12*'#2H AL* "C'?B*1 ")B2(1 '> 2#* B 5'>"&1*1 $JC1?*)B* "B2 J1 B55&1>>15 '2 '>#CB*'#2 a *)#L() ?#>* #I *)1 $LJC'"5'>"L>>'#2 D#LC5 C1BM1 %#L D'*) *)1 '?$&1>>'#2 *)B* *)'> '> >#H

!"#$ (


5/15

A1"BL>1 *)1>1 $CB21*B&% J#L25B&'1> B&1 $1&"1'M15 D'*)'2 *)1I&B?1D#&K #I *)1 $)%>'"BC >"'12"1> d $)%>'">6 ")1?'>*&%6 J'#C#(%61*" d D1 *125 *# >11K >#CL*'#2> *# *)1? '2 *)B* >B?1 5#?B'2HO)L> #L& I#"L> '> #2 &121DBJC1 121&(%6 1?'>>'#2> "#2*C6 1"#[>%>*1? &1>*#&B*'#2 B256 B* *)1 1R*&1?16 (1#[12('211&'2(H

AL* b DB2* *# $L* '* *# %#L *)B* *)'> '> B IL25B?12*BC?'>L251&>*B25'2(6 JB>15 #2 BM#'5B2"1 B25 512'BCH V> FD15'>)>")#CB& F*1M12 PB&*?B2 )B> D&'**12Z

3() %+)1' )$#"+,$:)$'1; -+)6".1:)$' ,7 '() )1+;< =>2'.)$'4+< "2

$,' -+":1+";< 1$ ).,;,%".1; .+"2"2? '(,4%( "'2 +1:"@".1'",$2 1+)71+A+)1.("$% 9"'("$ ).,;,%".1; 2 2#* *)B* *)'2(> B&1 (#'2( >1&'#L>C% D(D'*)'2 *)1 XB&*) F%>*1?6 D)'") *)1% B&16 JL* *)B* #L& )L?B2"LC*L&1 )B> J1"#?1 B2*'*)1*'"BC *# *)1 $"1>>1> *)B* >L$$#&* C'I1#2 *)'> $CB21*H

* .+"1"1 ,; .3:'3+)

41* ?1 $BL>1 )1&1 *# 1R$CB'2 *)1 DB% '2 D)'") bU? L>'2( *)1D#&5 S"LC*L&1TH

=LC*L&1 '2 *)'> "#2*1R* &1I1&> *# *)1 $&1MB'C'2( *BK12[I#&[(&B2*15 B>>L?$*'#2> '2 B2% >#"'1*% BJ#L* D)B* '> &1BC6 D)B* '>K2#DBJC16 B25 D)B* )B> MBCL1H =LC*L&1 "#25'*'#2> #L& DB%> #IJ1'2(6 >11'2(6 K2#D'2( B25 5#'2(H =LC*L&1 51*1&?'21> D)B* D1"#2>'51& B$$$&'B*1 B25 &1>$#2>'JC1 B"*'#2 '2 B25 #2 *)1 D#&C5H=LC*L&1 51^'21> *)1 *BK12[I#&[(&B2*15 C'?'*> #I *)1 $#>>'JC1 B25*)1 B""1$*BJC1H

V25 "LC*L&1 '> ># ?L") *)1 M1&% ?15'L? #I #L& 1R'>*12"1 *)B*D1 #I*12 IB'C *# 2#*'"1 '*> I#&?B*'M1 C1 '2 *)1 DB% D1 51^'21 D)#D1 B&1 B25 D)B* D1 B&1 J1"#?'2(H O# L251&C'21 *)'> $#'2*6 '* )B>J112 >B'5 *)B* *)1&1 B&1 *)&11 (&1B* S?%>*1&'1>T '2 *)1 L2'M1&>1ZV'& *# J'&5>H GB*1& *# ^'>)H V25 "LC*L&1 *# )L?B2>H

F# D)B* B&1 *)1 5&'M1&> #I *)'> S"&'>'> #I "LC*L&1Te O)'> '> 2#* B>'?$C1 NL1>*'#2 *# B2>D1&6 *)#L() '* '> "&'*'"BCC% '?$#&*B2* *)B*D1 B**1?$* *# 5# >#H

!"#$ '


6/15

A% ?% &1B5'2( #I #L& (C#JBC $&15'"B?12*6 bU5 >L((1>* *)&11?Bf#& B&1B> #I "LC*L&BC 5%>IL2"*'#2 *)B* B&1 5&'M'2( #L& D#&C5*#DB&5 "B*B>*$)1H

L.,$,G". 1'+)11,+1cL& 5#?'2B2* (C#JBC'>15 1"#2#?% )B> J1"#?1 IL2"*'#2BCC%

51$12512* #2 "#2*'2L#L> (D*) '2 #L*$L* B25 "#2>L?$*'#2 a2#* fL>* B JB5 )BJ'* *# J1 L2C1B&2* a JL* B 511$ >*&L"*L&BC$JC1?H cL& 1"#2#?'"6 >#"'BC B25 $#C'*'"BC >*BJ'C'*% 51$125> #2(D*)H O)1 (C#JBC 1"#2#?% '> B2BC#(#L> *# B $#2W' >")1?1 a 'I(D*) >*#$> 1M1&%#21 (1*> )L&* B25 *)1 D1BK1>* ?#>* #I BCCH

V2#*)1& >%?$*#? #I 1"#2#?'" 5%>IL2"*'#2 '> 1R*&1?1 B25

!"#$ *


7/15

O)1 *)D[BDB% C'I1>*%C1> *)B* (D*) 1"#2#?'1> &1NL'&1(121&B*1 ?#L2*B'2> #I '2*&B"*BJC1 DB>*16 ?L") #I '* 2#M1C *# *)1XB&*)U> 1"#[>%>*1?> B25 *)L> L2BJC1 *# J1 JK12 5#D2 B25BJ>#&J15 J% *)1 2B*L&BC $"1>>1> #I &121DBCH h2I#&*L2B*1C% #2 B^'2'*1 $CB21* *)1&1 '> 2# >L") $CB"1 B> SBDB%TH

Q)G,%+0-(". 1'+)11,+1

@L* >'?$C%6 *)1 1B&*) '> ILCCH PL?B2 $#$LCB*'#2 #2 *)1 $CB21*)B> &1B")15 $CB(L1 $$#&*'#2>H Y? . J'CC'#2 $1#$C1 '2 .].,6 *#

.H/ J'CC'#2 '2 .;.,6 #L& $#$LCB*'#2 )B5 $B>>15 : J'CC'#2 J% ,-.,B25 '> 2#D )1B5'2( I#& .- J'CC'#2H G1 B&1 B >$1"'1> '2 B >DB&?'2(>*B(1 B25 C'K1 B2% #&(B2'>? *)B* (#1> '2*# B $"1>> #I1R$#212*'BC (D*) a J1 '* JB"*1&'B '2 B @1*&' 5'>) #& C#"L>*> L251&IBM#L&BJC1 >1B>#2BC "#25'*'#2> a *)'> (D*) D'CC $1BK D)12 '*1R)BL>*> 12M'?12*BC &1>#L&"1>6 B25 "&B>)H

G)12 5'>"L>>'2( (C#JBC $#$LCB*'#2 D1 L>LBCC% "#2M12'12*C%'(2#&1 *)1 ?B>>'M1 $#$LCB*'#2 #I IB&? B2'?BC> D1 ?B'2*B'2 a BCC:- J'CC'#2 #I *)1?i =B2B5'B2 >")#CB&> )BM1 "BC"LCB*15 *)B* #I *)1*#*BC J'#?B>> #I *1&&1>*&'BC B2'?BC> BC'M1 #2 *)1 XB&*) *#5B%6 6 8:j B&1 IB&? B2'?BC>6 B25 #2C% )L(1 #M1&[$#$LCB*'#2 #I IB&? B2'?BC> '> *)1 ?B'25&'M1& #I 51I#&1>*B*'#26 CB25 B25 DB*1& 51(&B5B*'#26 B25 )BJ'*B*51>*&L"*'#2H

@#$LCB*'#2 $&1>>L&1 B25 &1>LC*'2( 12M'?12*BC 51>$#C'B*'#26"C'?B*1 5'>&L$*'#26 B25 DB& B25 "'M'C >*&'I1 '> 5&'M'2( B25 D'CC"#2*'2L1 *# 5&'M1 ?B>>'M1 B25 '2"&1B>'2( $#$LCB*'#2 ?#M1?12*>H

O)1 '2^CLR #I &1IL(11> '2*# XL$1 *)B* D1 B&1 >11'2( B* *)1?#?12* '> 2#* fL>* *)1 '??15'B*1 "#2>1NL12"1 #I B )L?B2'*B&'B2"&'>'> '2 *)1 3'55C1 XB>*6 E#&*) B25 XB>* VI&'"B B25 =12*&BC V>'BH b*'> B I#&1*B>*1 #I *)1 21D 2#&?BCH

V2#*)1& "#2>1NL12"1 #I #M1&[$#$LCB*'#2 '> *)1 ?L>)#?'2(#I "&'>'> $ ?1(B["'*'1>6 B I1&*'C1 J&115'2( (L25 I#& 21D$B*)#(12>6 J#*) >#"'BC B25 J'#C#('"BC6 *)&1B*12'2( (C#JBC $1B"1B25 &1"L&&'2( $B251?'">H

!"#$ -

(D'2( D1BC*) 5'>$B&'*'1> &1>LC*'2( '2 B 5B2(1L> "#2"12*&B*'#2#I D1BC*) B25 $#D1&H bI )'>*#&% '> B2% (L'516 *)'> D'CC '21M'*BJC%C1B5 *# M'#C12* L$)1BMBC B25 >1M1&1 &1$&1>>'#2H


8/15

9,:"'".0:O1,."0: 1'+)11,+1

cL& 5#?'2B2* $#C'*'"BC6 1R1"L*'M1 B25 B5?'2'>*&B*'M1'2>*'*L*'#2> a J#*) $LJC'" B25 "#&$#&B*1 a B&1 >*&L"*L&BCC%

'2"B$BJC1 #I 51BC'2( D'*) *)1 51(&11 #I "#?$C1R'*%6 $I#L25L2"1&*B'2*% B25 &B$'5 ")B2(1 ")B&B"*1&'>*'" #I *)1 V2*)$#"121Hb2 1M1&% 51M1C#$15 2B*'#2 D1 "B2 >11 *)1 ?#>* '2>*'*L*'#2BCC%>#$)'>*'"B*156 D1CC &1>#L&"15 >*&L"*L&1> #I (#M1&2B2"1 >*&L((C'2(*# "#$1 D'*) *)1 ")BCC12(1> #I B (C#JBC'>15 D#&C5H O)1% B&1 #*15'2 B 2#*'#2 #I >'?$C1 C'21B& "BL>BC'*% *)B* &1251&> *)1? '?$#*12*'2 *)1 IB"1 #I B 512>1C% "#221"*156 5%2B?'"6 2#2[C'21B& &1BC'*%H

O)1 "L&&12* ")B#> '2 *)1 3'55C1 XB>* B25 XB>* VI&'"BI#&1>)B5#D> *)1 *L&?#'C B)1B5 B> &1>#L&"1 "#2^C'"*> 1>"BCB*16 B25

I##56 DB*1& B25 CB25 >)#&*B(1> IL1C '2*1&["#??L2BC B25 >1"*B&'B2>*&'I1H

b* >11?> "C1B& *# ?1 *)B* *)1 L251&C%'2( "BL>1 #I #L&V2*)$#"121 $&15'"B?12* '> *)1 "#&1 MBCL1> B25 J1C'1I> #I #L&(C#JBC'>15 )L?B2 "LC*L&1H G)'C1 *)1&1 B&1 L&(12* *B>K> *)B* ?L>*J1 B""#?$C'>)15 *# >C#D *)1 $B"1 #I 1"#C#('"BC 51>*&L"*'#26 D1?L>* B* *)1 >B?1 *'?1 ?BK1 B >*B&* #2 *)1 BC*#(1*)1& ?#&15'I^'"LC* ")BCC12(1 #I *&B2>I#&?'2( *)1 )1(1?#2'" $CB21*B&%"LC*L&1H

cL& "L&&12* I#"L> #2 "C'?B*1 ")B2(1 '>6 '2 ?% M'1D6 J#*)BJ>#CL*1C% 21"1>>B&% J1"BL>1 #I '*> L&(12"%6 B25 IL25B?12*BCC%?'>C1B5'2(H V> *)1 E#&*) V?1&'"B2 f#L&2BC'>* PH4H312"K12 #2"1#J>1&M15Z SY#& 1M1&% "#?$C1R $JC1? *)1&1 '> B2 B2>D1& *)B* '>"C1B&6 >'?$C16 B25 D(HT

2, D) ;3::8 (3G0$

b2 *)1 "L&&12* '>>L1 #I 3() Q,$'(;"&'J1>

@#$1 Y&B2"'>U &1"12* 12"%"C'"BC6 !1461', J"R6 B> S*)1 ^'&>* D#&K *)B*)B> &'>12 *# *)1 ILCC ")BCC12(1 #I "C'?B*1 ")B2(1TH P1 "#2*&B>*> *)1@#$1U> M'1D D'*) *)B* #I C1B5'2( "C'?B*1 ")B2(1 B"*'M'>*> C'K1 VC`#&1H

SY#& #&1T6 3B221 D&'*1>6 S*)1 IL25B?12*BC> #I *)'> "'M'C'>B*'#2B&1 L2NL1>*'#215H Y#& @#$1 Y&B2"'> *)1 "C'?B*1 "&'>'> '> #2C% *)1?#>* 1R*&1?1 1R$&1>>'#2 #I B 51>*&L"*'M1 *12512"% *)B* )B>J1"#?1 '2"&1B>'2(C% 5#?'2B2* *)L() *)1 "#L&>1 #I

!"#$ .


9/15

'25L>*&'BC'>B*'#2HT 3B221 NL#*1> 12"%"C'"BC '2 *)1 E)9 H,+P C)#")9,7S,,P2Z

3("2 :1+P2 '() @"+2' '":) '(1' 1 -)+2,$ ,7 %+)1' 14'(,+"'< "$ ,4+%;,N1; .4;'4+) (12 74;;< +).,%$"2)6 '() 2.1;) 1$6 6)-'( ,7 ,4+.+"2"2? 1$6 '() .,$2)M4)$' $).)221+< +)'("$P"$% ,7 9(1' "' :)1$2', N) 74;;< (4:1$B

b2 #&51& *# BM#'5 B2% ?'>L251&>*B25'2( #I D)B* b B? >B%'2(6 C1*?1 J1 M1&% "C1B& BJ#L* *)'>H O)1 >)'I* I? 51$12512"1 #2 I#>>'CIL1C> *# &121DBJC1> '> B2 BJ>#CL*1C% 1>>12*'BC "#25'*'#2 I#& *)1"#2*'2L'2( M'BJ'C'*% #I #L& >$1"'1> B25 ?B2% #*)1&> B> D1CCH AL* '*

'> 2#* B >LI^'"'12* "#25'*'#2H O# L>1 B "#?$L*1& B2BC#(%6 &1$CB"'2(I#>>'C IL1C JL&2'2( D'*) &121DBJC1> '> B D#&KBL25 *# BM#'5 B2'??'212* >%>*1? "&B>)H O)1 L251&C%'2( $JC1? '> D'*) *)1#$1&B*'2( >%>*1? a #L& "#&1 "LC*L&BC MBCL1>H

!"#$ /


10/15

O)'> C1B5> ?1 *# *)1 "#2"CL>'#2 *)B* *)1&1 B&1 *)&11 C1M1C> #I&1>$#2>1 *)B* ?L>* J1 B55&1>>15 "#2"L&&12*C%Z

5"'"%0'",$d

9'7%5&:T FQ, $, (0+GH

O)1>1 B&1 *)1 B"*'#2> D1 ?L>* *BK1 *# >C#D B25 >*#$ #L& ?#>*1(&1('#L> BJL>1> #I *)1 J'#>$)1&1 a C'K1 1?'>>'#2> &15L"*'#26"#2M1&>'#2 *# &121DBJC1 121&(% >#L&"1>6 )BC*'2( 51I#&1>*B*'#2B25 CB25 "C1B&'2(6 5&B>*'"BCC% &15L"'2( B2'?BC IB&?'2(6 )BJ'*B*&1>*#&B*'#26 125'2( '25L>*&'BC'>15 ^'>)'2( B25 B(&'"LC*L&16 1*"H

*60-'0'",$d ;03"'&+5&:T F73":6 +)1":")$.)H

V> D1 IB"1 ")B2(1> '2 *)1 J'#>$)1&1 *)B* B&1 BC&1B5% L251&[

DB% B25 D)'") )BM1 B CB( *'?1 &B2('2( I? 51"B51> *# "12*L&'1>6D1 ?L>* ('M1 )'() $&'#&'*% *# >*&12(*)12'2( B25 &151>'(2'2( #L&>#"'BC B25 $)%>'"BC '2I&B>*&L"*L&1 *# D'*)>*B25 L2$&15'"*BJC1>)#"K> B25 ?Bf#& 5'>&L$*'#2H \1C#"BC'>B*'#2 #I I##5 $L"*'#265'>*&'JL*15 121&(% >%>*1?>6 B25 JL'C5'2( >#"'BC "B$'*BC a"#221"*1521>> B25 ?L*LBC B>>'>*B2"1 B* B C#"BC C1M1C a B&11RB?$C1> #I *)1 B5B$*B*'#2 >*&B*1('1> &1NL'&15H

2+0$1;,+G0'",$d '(2 #I #L& *1")2#C#('"BC6 1"#2#?'"6 >#"'BC B25

(#M1&2B2"1 >%>*1?> '2 )B&?#2% D'*) *)1 XB&*)U> C'I1 >L$$#&*>%>*1?>6 L251&$'2215 J% B &B5'"BC &1I&B?'2( #I #L& >)B&15 "#&1"LC*L&BC MBCL1>H b2 *)1 D#&5> #I O)#?B> A1&&%Z

K' "2 ":-,+'1$' ', 4$6)+2'1$6 L '() :1%$"'46) ,7 '() .(1$%)+)M4"+)6 "$ 2(1-"$% 1 #"1N;) :,6) ,7 (4:1$ -+)2)$.) ,$ -;1$)'O1+'( 7,+ '() 74'4+)B *;; ,4+ -+,7)22",$2 1$6 "$2'"'4'",$2 $))6 ',

N) +)"$#)$')6 "$ '("2 $)9 .,$')F'B O#)$'41;;< '("2 ":-;")2+)'("$P"$% L ,4+ +,;) 9"'("$ '() -;1$)'1+< -+,.)22B

VCC *)&11 C1M1C> #I &1>$#2>1 a ?'*'(B*'#26 B5B$*B*'#26 B25*&B2>I#&?B*'#2 a *#(1*)1& "#2>*'*L*1 D)B* b "BCC S*)1V2*)$#"121 *&B2>'*'#2TH

!"#$ ,


11/15

Q))- '"G)

c21 #I *)1 J'((1>* ")BCC12(1> #I *)1 V2*)$#"121 '> I#& L> *#5# '2 $&B"*'"1 D)B* D1 B> B >$1"'1> )BM1 #2C% 1M1& (&B$$C15 D'*)

'2 *)1 &1BC? #I ?%*)#C#(% B25 '?B('2B*'#2 a *# &1"#2"'C1 #L&)L?B2 L251&>*B25'2( #I &1>$#2>'J'C'*% D'*) B $CB21*B&% "#2"1$*#I 511$ *'?1H

Y#& #L& >$1"'1> *'?1 '> ?1B>L&15 '2 ?LC*'$C1> #I )L?B2C'I1*'?1>H O)1 $CB21*U> B(1> B&1 &1"K#215 '2 B1#2>H AL* '2 *)1V2*)$#"121 )L?B2 *'?16 J'#C#('"BC *'?16 B25 (1#C#('"BC *'?1B&1 "#CC'5'2(H V256 B> B "#2>1NL12"16 #L& >$1"'1> '> J1'2( "BCC15 *#B>>L?1 &1>$#2>'J'C'*% I#& "#2>1NL12"1> *)B* B&1 BC?#>* J1%#25#L& K12H

V> QBM'5 V&")1& D*1 '2 )'> J##K 3() !,$% 3(19/ D,9D4:1$2 1+) 0(1$%"$% '() E)F' >GG?GGG H)1+2Z

3() .;":1'". ":-1.'2 ,7 +);)12"$% 7,22"; 74); 0I=', '()1':,2-()+) 9";; ;12' ;,$%)+ '(1$ J',$)()$%)B !,$%)+ '(1$ '":).1-24;)2? ;,$%)+ '(1$ $4.;)1+ 912')? 71+ ;,$%)+ '(1$ '() 1%) ,7(4:1$ ."#";"21'",$ 2, 71+B

V"*'#2 *# ?#51&B*1 "C'?B*1 ")B2(1 '> B *B>K I#& #L& (121&B*'#2

B25 $JBJC% *)1 21R* *D# #& *)&11H AL* 2BM'(B*'2( *)1V2*)$#"121 *&B2>'*'#2 '> B $f1"* I#& ?B2% (121&B*'#2>H \'()*2#D #L& J'((1>* ")BCC12(1 '> *# B&*'"LCB*1 B DB% #I *)'2K'2( B25*BCK'2( BJ#L* '*H

G'*) *)'> '2 ?'25 bUM1 >L((1>*15 B I&B?1D#&K *)B* 5&BD>B**12*'#2 *# I#L& "&L"'BC 5#?B'2> '2 D)'") b J1C'1M1 D1 ?L>* I#"L>#L& 1R$C#&B*'#2> B25 #L& 1II#&*>H Y#CC#D'2( V&'>*#*C1 bUM1 "BCC15*)1>1 I#L& 5#?B'2>Z @>%")16 3%*)#>6 X$'>*g?g6 B25 O1")2gH

!"#$ +


12/15

>A 918.() N 7)"$%O7).,G"$%

O)'> '> *)1 5#?B'2 #I XB&*) "#2>"'#L>21>> #& BDB&121>>6 #I>12>'*'>'2( #L& "LC*L&1 *# 1"#[>%>*1? I115JB"K6 #I #$12'2( #L&)1B&*> *# *)1 "#??L2'*% #I C'I16 #I J1'2( ILCC% $&1>12* *# *)1 XB&*)H

P1&1 *)1 *&B2>'*'#2 D1 ?L>* ?BK1 B> B (C#JBC "LC*L&1 '> I?BC'12B*'#2 *# D)#C121>>H O)1&1 B&1 >*'CC '25'(12#L> "LC*L&1>BL25 *)1 D#&C5 *)B* )BM1 $&1>1&M15 XB&*)["12*&'" "LC*L&BC&1>#L&"1> #I '21>*'?BJC1 MBCL1 *# '2I#&? *)'> *&B2>'*'#2H

'> *)1 5#?B'2 #I >*#&%6 '?B('2B*'#2 B25 "&1B*'M1 $&B"*'"1 a*)1 >$B"1 I? D)'") B&'>1> *)1 "LC*L&BC 2B&&B*'M1> *)B* '2>$'&1

!"#$ &)


13/15

B25 '2I#&? #L& "#CC1"*'M1 ?1B2'2([?BK'2(HP1&1 #L& *&B2>'*'#2D'CC J1 I? '??1&>'#2 '2 B2 #"1B2 #I 5'>'2I#&?B*'#26 5'>*&B"*'#2B25 51?#&BC'>B*'#2 *# #21 *)B* &1BI^'&?> #L& $CB"1 B> &1>$#2>'JC1$B&*'"'$B2*> '2 B2 L2I#C5'2( >*#&% #I "&1B*'#2 #2 XB&*)H

KA L-"1'MGM N 4$,@"$%O!)0+$"$%

O)'> '> *)1 5#?B'2 #I )#C'>*'" >"'12"16 "#CCBJ#&B*'M1 '2NL'&% B25B5B$*'M1 >#"'BC C1B&2'2(HP1&1 #L& *&B2>'*'#2 D'CC J1 I? BI&B(?12*156 &15L"*'#2'>*6 512B*L&15 DB% #I K2#D'2( *)1 D#&C5 *#B ?#&1 '2*1(&B*156 D)#C1 >%>*1?> B25 "#CCBJ#&B*'M1 ?#51H

PA 2).($M N Q,"$%

O)'> '> *)1 5#?B'2 #I '2>*&L?12*BC B"*'#2 '2 *)1 D#&C5 a *)1>$B"1 '2 D)'") D1 &15'>"#M1& C'I1["12*&15 B$$B")1> *#*1")2#C#(%6 1"#2#?'"> B25 (#M1&2B2"1HcL& *&B2>'*'#2 )1&1 '>I? B2 1*)#> #I 5#?'2B*'#2 B25 ?B>*1&% *# #21 #I $B&*'"'$B*'#2B25 "#[#$1&B*'#2H Y? >1CI[51>*&L"*'M1 )LJ&'> *# "#["&1B*'M1&1>$1"*H

Y#& #L& >$1"'1> *)1 1R$1&'12"1 #I *)1 V2*)$#"121 *&B2>'*'#2'> C1>> C'K1C% *# J1 51^'215 '2 *1&?> #I B?1C'#&B*'M1 $#C'*'"BC

>*&B*1('1> B25 $#C'"% ")#'"1> *)B2 J% )#D D1CC D1 &1>$#25 *# B2551BC D'*) >%>*1?'" J&1BK5#D2H V256 *# ?16 *)1&1 "B2 J1 C'**C15#LJ* *)B* J&1BK5#D2 '> D)B* D1 B&1 IB"'2( B25 D'CC "#2*'2L1 *#IB"1 I#& *)1 I#&1>11BJC1 IL*L&1H

R+,G D+)0S6,@$ ', +)$)@0:

F%>*1?'" J&1BK5#D2 5#1> 2#* '?$C% B P#CC%D##5[>*%C1$CB21*B&% B$#"BC%$>1H Y#& $1#$C1 >L&M'M'2( '2 AB()5B5 #&3#(B5'>)L #& O&'$#C' #& 0BJLC #& `BWB #& B2% #I B >"#&1 #I #*)1&

"'*'1> B25 &1('#2> BL25 *)1 D#&C56 >%>*1?'" J&1BK5#D2 '> *)1'&1M1&%5B% C'M15 1R$1&'12"1H O)1 1>*'?B*15 /- ?'CC'#2 5'>$CB"15$1&>#2> '2 *)1 (C#JBC (LCB( #I >NLBC'5 &1IL(11 "B?$> K2#D D)B*>%>*1?'" J&1BK5#D2 '>H V25 I#& "#L2*C1>> >$1"'1> *&1?JC'2( #2*)1 J&'2K #I 1R*'2"*'#26 >%>*1?'" J&1BK5#D2 '> BCC *## &1BC a B25^'2BCH

O)1 "#CCB$>1 ?B2% B&1 1R$1&'12"'2( &'()* 2#D D'CC "#2*'2L1 *#>$&1B5 B25 (B*)1& ?#?12*L? #M1& 51"B51> *# "#?1H b* D'CC J1 B2

!"#$ &&


14/15

B**12LB*15 B25 L21M12 $"1>> *BK'2( 5'II1&12* I#&?> '2 5'II1&12*$CB"1> B* 5'II1&12* *'?1>H Y#& >#?1 '* D'CC J1 1R$1&'12"15 B> DB&B25 M'#C12"1 B25 &1$&1>>'#26 I#& #*)1&> '* D'CC J1 IB?'21 &1>LC*'2(

I? I##5 B25 DB*1& >)#&*B(1>6 I#& >#?1 '* D'CC J1 2B*L&BC5'>B>*1&> B> "C'?B*1 5'>&L$*'#2 *BK1> '*> *#CC6 I#& #*)1&> '* D'CC J11"#2#?'" "&'>'> B25 C#>> #I >BM'2(> B25 C'M1C')##5>6 B25 I#& BCC *##?B2% '* D'CC J1 )BJ'*B* 51>*&L"*'#2 B25 $#'>#215 1"#[>%>*1?>HO)1 ?#>* MLC21&BJC1 &1('#2>6 "#??L2'*'1> B25 >$1"'1> D'CC J1?#>* "B*B>*$)'"BCC% BII1"*156 D)'C1 #*)1&> D'CC JLII1&*)1?>1CM1> B(B'2>* BCC JL* *)1 ?#>* >1M1&1 ?B2'I1>*B*'#2>H

3% $#'2* '> >'?$C% *)B* *)1 V2*)$#"121 '> BC&1B5% L$#2 L>B25 '*> "#2>1NL12"1> B&16 *# MB&%'2( 51(&11>6 BC&1B5% B$$B&12*H

O)1% D'CC >$&1B5 '21R#&BJC% B25 (B*)1& $B"1 B">> *)1 C'I1*'?1>#I BCC "&1B*L&1> "L&&12*C% BC'M1 #2 *)'> $CB21*6 B25 #I *)1'II>$&'2(6 B25 *)1'& #II>$&'2(6 I#& (121&B*'#2> *# "#?1H O)'> '> *)1&1BC'*% #I *)1 V2*)$#"121 *&B2>'*'#2H

V25 I? *)'> J&1BK5#D2 &121DBC D'CC "#?1H

!"#$ &(

X"#C#('>*> >$1BK #I *)1 B5B$*'M1 "%"C1H V $"1>> *)L()D)'") BCC "#?$C1R B5B$*'M1 >%>*1?> "%"C1 I? B""1C1&B*'2((D*) B25 '2"&1B>'2( 5'M1&>'*%6 *# ?B*L&'*%6 '2"&1B>'2( &'('5'*%

Exploitation Phase

RAPID GROWTH

Conservation Phase

LIMITS OF GROWTH

Reorganisation

Phase

RENEWAL

Release Phase

COLLAPSE


15/15

B25 >*B>'> B* *)1 C'?'*> #I (D*)6 I#CC#D15 J% J&1BK5#D2 B255'>'2*1(&B*'#26 I? D)'") B&'>1> B >*B(1 #I &121DBC 5L&'2( D)'")'?$#&*B2* 1M#CL*'#2B&% J&1BK*)L()> I&1NL12*C% #""L&H @#C'*'"BC>"'12*'>* O)#?B> P#?1& Q'R#2 '2 )'> ,--8 J##K 3() 5-2"6) ,78,9$L>1> *)1 *1&? S"B*B(121>'>T *# 51>"&'J1 S*)1 "&1B*'M1&121DBC #I #L& *1")2#C#('1>6 '2>*'*L*'#2>6 B25 >#"'1*'1> '2 *)1BI*1&?B*) #I J&1BK5#D2TH

PL?B2'*%U> ")BCC12(1 '2 *)1 V2*)$#"121 '> *# >1'W1 *)1#$$#&*L2'*'1> '* D'CC #II1& I#& &121DBC6 *# B(B'2 J1"#?1&1>$#2>'JC1 $B&*'"'$B2*> '2 *)1 "#??L2'*% #I C'I16 *# J1 D#&*)%B2"1>*#&> I#& L2K2#D2 (121&B*'#2> *# "#?1H O)1>1 *'?1> "BCC L>*# B"* "#CC1"*'M1C% I? #L& )'()1>* B>$'&B*'#2>6 #L& ?#>* '2>$'&15

"&1B*'M'*%6 B25 #L& 511$1>* "#??'*?12* *# *)1 L2I#C5'2( #I C'I1 #2XB&*)H

!";) :,#)1 :";)A

!"#$ &'

Y#& ?#&1 '2I#&?B*'#2 B25 5'>"L>>'#2 #I *)1

V2*)$#"121 *&B2>'*'#2 M'>'* #L& D1J>'*1Z

DDDHB(1#I*&B2>'*'#2H#&(

Documents

Living in the Anthropocene : Crash or Crash Through