Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
MATEFL is an organisation run on a volunteer basis by teachers for teachers of English as a foreign language. It is dedicated to the professional development of its members by facilitating the sharing and exchanging of ideas and keeping abreast of new developments in the EFL world.
June 2015
Malta Association of Teachers of English as a Foreign Language
NEWSLETTER
2 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
Jean Theuma
Jean is a freelance Teacher Trainer. Her main interests are helping teachers to get—and stay—involved in their own development. Jean is also fascinated by the role of technology in the classroom. Apart from that, Jean loves the theatre and mak-ing theatre costumes. Follow Jean on Twitter at @jean_theuma
Matt Done
Matt has 10 years of general English and exam preparation experience. He has been training on TEFL cert courses for the past two years and is closing in on becoming a CELTA tutor.
Natasha Fabri
Natasha has been an online/offline ELT trainer for well over a decade. She spent seven years freelancing in beautiful Lisbon, Portugal before returning to Malta in 2012. She is passionate about technology in the classroom and giving teacher train-ing workshops. She loves writing, trekking and photography. Find her on her public page dedicated to all things TEFLon facebook: NatashaFabriTEFL
In this issue your contributors are (alphabetically):
We’d love you to get involved
Are you a teacher or an EFL professional who enjoys writing?
Would you like to have your ideas published in the newsletter?
Contact us by emailing Jean Theuma at [email protected]
Daniel Xerri Daniel is a teacher of English at the University of Malta Junior College. He also teaches on the university’s MA in TESOL. He holds postgraduate degrees in Eng-lish and Applied Linguistics, and is currently completing a PhD in Education at the University of York. His main research interest is teacher education and de-velopment in English Language Teaching. More information about his talks and publications can be found here: www.danielxerri.com
Marjorie Rosenberg Marjorie is a lecturer at the University of Graz, trains teachers and works with corporate clients. She has published extensively in business English and is the author of 'Spotlight on Learning Styles’ (Delta). She is currently the IATEFL President.
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 3
Hello TEFLers,
What a busy summer this is turning out to be! I meet people
everyday who complain because they do not seem to be able to
stop and take a breath. Well...I hope you can make time to sit
down, relax and read the latest issue of the MATEFL newsletter.
In this issue Marjorie Rosenberg carries on where her fantastic
Spring workshop left off. Marjorie clarifies the definition of
learner styles and elaborates on different types of styles that
you might be able to pick out in your students or even yourself.
Daniel Xerri discusses what being a ‘creative practitioner’
means. His article gives us food for thought as he challenges us
to leave our comfort zones in the name of creativity. I offer an
article which looks into one of the greatest tools in the teachers’
arsenal—the skill of asking questions. Natasha Fabri explores
Personal Learning Networks in Teacher 2.0 while Matt Done
puts 2 course books through their paces in Course Book face-Off
(Outcomes vs New English File).
Please get in touch if you have something to say. Contact me –
Jean Theuma at [email protected]
Enjoy! Jean
The MATEFL committee are: Alan Marsh (President) Larissa Jonk (Secretary) Caroline Camp-bell (Treasurer) Jean Theuma (IATEFL representative/Editor) Julia Pearson (Website manager/Membership secretary) Ian Scerri (Facebook page) Natasha Fabri (Assistant editor) Matt Done (Newsletter contributor)
MATEFL can be contacted at: PO Box 2 Gzira, Malta www.matefl.org
[email protected] @MATEFLmalta MATEFL (Malta)
Spotlight on Learner Styles Marjorie Rosenberg
4
On Teachers’ Creativity
Daniel Xerri 11
7 Ways we use Questions in Class Jean Theuma
24
Materials Swop Shop
10
Teacher 2.0: a survival guide to
Technology in the Classroom
Natasha Fabri explores PLNs
14
Course Book Face – off Outcomes vs New English File Matt Done
17
Out and About in EFL Jean Theuma takes us teacher training in Peru
19
Fun Pages 21
EFL in a Nutshell 27
The MATEFL Spring Workshop in pictures
28
Inside this issue:
Articles:
Regular Features:
Get noticed by EFL professionals in
Malta
To advertise in the MATEFL newsletter, please contact Jean Theuma at
[email protected] for information and advertising rates.
4 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
How my journey began It is always interesting when discussing the concept of
learning styles with educators. Although research has
been carried out over the last fifty years or so it is still
considered by some to be controversial. Those who
feel that learning styles do not exist or have a place in
the classroom can point to a wide variety of websites
and scholarly articles while proponents of learning
styles can also find a large number of journal articles
and research results attesting to the validity of the
theories. My interest in this field began in the early
1990s in a course on ‘superlearning’ techniques where
I heard about visual, auditory
and kinaesthetic learners for
the first time. It was as if a door
had opened for me and I finally
understood why my years of
trying to learn French through
the audio-lingual method had
been so resoundingly
unsuccessful. As a visual and
kinaesthetic learner, being told
‘not to picture the words in my
head’ was the wrong way for
me to first be confronted with a
language. Just listening to the
sounds and finding automatic responses or sitting in a
language lab with nothing to look at did not help me
at all. Years later, when I learned German, I wrote
words down myself, carried a dictionary around to
look words up and made use of a number of visual
aids. This method was certainly more rewarding for
me and suddenly finding out what the difference was
in the two experiences began my journey into this
fascinating area. As a language teacher I became very
interested in finding out how I could help my learners
to have positive experiences both inside and outside
the classroom and discovering and development
different possibilities of doing this became a mission.
Definitions As one of the first questions which comes up refers to
the definition of styles, it seems best to quote some of
the experts in the field. For example :
Guild and Garger (1998:) say ‘The way we
perceive the world governs how
we think, make judgments and
form values about experiences
and people. This unique aspect
of our humanness is what we
call “style”’.
Keefe (1979) contends
that styles are ‘characteristic
cognitive, affective and
psychological behaviours that
serve as relatively stable
indicators of how learners
perceive, interact with and
respond to the learning environment’
Kinsella (1995) comments that ‘learning style
refers to an individual’s natural, habitual and
preferred ways of absorbing, processing and
retaining new information and skills which
persists regardless of teaching methods of
content area’.
Spotlight on Learning Styles
Following her recent workshop in Malta, Marjorie Rosenberg discusses how learners need to find ways of learning which they are comfortable with.
As a language teacher I
became very interested in
finding out how I could help
my learners to have positive
experiences both inside and
outside the classroom
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 5
Dunn and Dunn (1992, 1993) and Dunn, Dunn,
and Perrin (1994) say that ‘learning style is the
way each person begins to concentrate on,
process, internalize and retain new and difficult
academic information.’ They go on to suggest
that ‘More than three-fifths of learning style is
biological; less than one-fifth is developmental.’
Importance in learning Moving on to the importance or use in learning is a
subject which inspires debate from all corners of the
globe and from people involved in a variety of
educational situations. An argument is often made
that it is not possible to change instruction to suit
every learner and even in cases where this is done, it
has no particular effect on the success of the learning
outcome. While this may be true, it is only one part of
the equation. However, ‘it is possible to strive for
uniform outcomes but to intentionally diversify the
means for achieving them’ (Guild and Garger 1998).
Jeremy Harmer addresses this issue as well when he
says :
‘The moment we realise that a class is composed
of individuals (rather than being some kind of
unified whole) we have to start thinking about
how to respond to those students individually so
that while we may frequently teach the group as
a whole, we will also, in different ways, pay
attention to the different identities we are faced
with.’
This is not to say that we need to constantly change
our instruction to make sure that we reach each and
every learner all of the time. But a mix of methods can
provide learners with new possibilities and resources
for them to explore outside the classroom including
those which are new and different for them. In
addition, encouraging learners to try out new methods
for themselves can encourage them to become more
independent and autonomous learners, another goal
of helping them to discover their styles.
As Andrew Cohen says:
‘Indeed we learn in different ways and what suits
one learner may be inadequate for another. While
learning styles seem to be relatively stable,
teachers can modify the learning tasks they use in
their classes in a way that may bring the best out of
particular leaners with particular learning style
preferences. It is also possible that learners over
time can be encouraged to engage in ‘style-
stretching’ so as to incorporate approaches to
learning they were resisting in the past’.
Myths and misconceptions As there are a number of misconceptions about
learning styles, this is an important area to cover in
any discussion of the topic. For one thing, learning
styles are not an excuse. Finding out about one’s
strengths and weaknesses does not mean that one is
allowed to simply give up because he or she is not
particularly good at something. The goal instead is to
create a mindset in which the person is made
cognizant of their particular situation and to expand
on it and grow. In any discussion with learners about
their styles, the option of falling back on a weakness
as a reason not to do something is simply not on the
table. It would also be a misconception to assume that
learners cannot stretch out of their styles. Although
the style can be seen as a foundation, most learners
have incorporated methods ascribed to other styles to
learn and acquire knowledge. Being aware of the wide
range of possibilities in learning does not mean that a
learner will not make use of them if necessary to
achieve a particular goal or when learning a particular
subject. And if the learner is successful with this,
motivation may improve resulting in a positive self-
fulfilling prophesy.
6 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
Another misconception is that teachers tend to label
or pigeon-hole learners once they know their styles.
This is most certainly not the aim of those of us
working in this field. It is interesting to observe
students and to be aware of their styles as it makes
giving advice to particular questions easier but it does
not mean that a teacher should assume a learner
cannot grow or change. Teachers can reassure leaners
that ANY strength or strategy which will help them
achieve a goal is fine, there is no need to only use ones
most commonly employed by the style. However, they
also need to have the self-confidence to use strategies
comfortable for them, even if they have been told in
the past that these strategies will not help them to
learn.
In addition, styles are not ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ - they are
valueless. No style is ‘better’ than another style; one
may be more suited to learning a particular skill than
another but each of the styles has their strong and
weak points. Style and competence should not be
confused. In a language class it is certainly possible
that two people with very similar learning style profiles
are at completely different levels of language. So many
other factors must be considered that simply basing
all conclusions about learners on style would be a
mistake. It could also be that a learner is enrolled in a
programme which is not the right one for him or her.
Discoveries about style could lead to making a change
but it may also simply lead to finding new ways to
learn material.
Implementation There are a variety of ways in which learning styles can
be implemented into the foreign language classroom.
In Spotlight on Learning Styles teachers are provided
with checklists which they can go through with their
students and discuss. Particular characteristics of styles
are given as well as tips and strategies. The styles of
both the teacher and the students are looked at and
suggestions are made as to how to expand a teacher’s
repertoire in the classroom. As many of us teach in the
way we prefer to learn, we may overlook learners’
needs whose styles are very different from our own.
Spotlight on Learning Styles has been written to remind
teachers about the types of students in our classrooms
and provide tips, hints and ideas to ensure that
teachers can reach as many of their students as
possible and find both satisfaction and joy in doing so.
Style types As there are a large number of learning styles and
surveys to determine them used by researchers and
practitioners, it was necessary to decide which ones to
focus on in Spotlight on Learning Styles. For this reason
the choice was made to choose three particular areas.
This logical sequence of gathering information led to
the choice of three distinct areas to cover, beginning
with visual, auditory and kinaesthetic modalities
(sensory channels of perception), global / analytic
thought processes (cognitive processing) and Mind
Organisation (behaviour based on perception and
organization of information). By adding on to the
knowledge provided by one style, a more composite
picture of a learner can be made. After doing all three
surveys the individuality of each of the learners
becomes more apparent, the uniqueness of each
learner can be appreciated, and suggestions for
strategies can be tailored to the particular learner and
situation.
According to Cohen:
‘Although numerous distinctions are emerging from
the literature, three categories of style preferences
are considered particularly relevant and useful to
understanding the process of language learning:
sensory/perceptual, cognitive and personality-
related preferences’ (Reid 1995 and Weaver 1996)
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 7
VAK Learners The standard model of VAK generally includes visual,
auditory and kinaesthetic learners. These were
researched early on by Walter Barbe and Raymond
Swassing (1979) who defined what they called
modalities as ‘any of the sensory channels through
which an individual receives and retains information.’
However, after working in adult education and teacher
training for some thirty years, it seems that adults tend
to be either kinaesthetic motoric (tactile) learners or
kinaesthetic emotional ones. The exact age as to when
this split takes place has not been determined but it
seems to show up in the later years of high school and
is certainly apparent by the
time learners reach tertiary
level education or take on a
job. For this reason Spotlight
on Styles looks at these two
areas separately and provides
ideas for working with both
types.
Visual learners generally
remember best when they can
see something or write it
down. Examples of activities
for them include noticing
things about them, using colours, drawing or creating
pictures in their minds, recognizing shapes, and
describing items or people in writing.
Auditory learners remember what they hear or say.
Therefore the activities for them include passing on
sentences to each other orally, telling stories or putting
them in the correct order through listening, describing
people aloud, asking questions, and matching
beginnings and endings of jokes they hear.
Kinaesthetic emotional learners need to feel
comfortable with others and want to have the feeling
of belonging. Therefore, they are given the chance to
work together in groups to plan joint events, tell each
others’ horoscopes or fortunes, find positive adjectives
to describe classmates, or tell others how they feel
about a particular topic within a safe setting.
The kineasthetic motoric leaners need to move about
and learn best when they can try things out for
themselves. They are given the opportunity to walk
around and mingle to gather information, create the
moving parts of a machine in a group, pass on a word
by writing on someone’s back, or act words for others
to guess.
The last section has mixed
activities which are designed
to appeal to all learner types
such as describing, drawing or
‘becoming’ pictures, playing
memory games in groups,
remembering and repeating
unusual definitions, as well as
kinaesthetic bingo and gap
texts. Students are also
encouraged to contribute to
the activities and if some are
more successful than others,
they can be asked to help
fellow students or give personalised tips on how to
remember things better.
Global / Analytic Learners Moving onto cognitive processing, we take a look at the
global / analytic learning style. One of the first
researchers to look into these styles was Herman
Witkin (1981) who worked with fighter pilots to
discover what influenced their decisions while piloting
planes. He came up with his theory of field-dependent
(global) learners and field-independent (analytic)
No style is ‘better’ than
another style; one may be
more suited to learning a
particular skill than another
but each of the styles has
their strong and weak
points.
8 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
learners based on this research and went on to develop
the ‘Group Embedded Figures Test’, still used today to
determine cognitive learner styles.
Global learners tend to process information holistically
and by remembering the entire experience rather than
just details. They are also relationship-oriented and may
be more emotional than analytic learners. The activities
designed to appeal to them include a group drawing
exercise to create a person, writing stories about others
in the class, coming up with an idea for a class excursion
and playing games like ‘You-Robot’.
Analytic learners, on the
other hand, like details and
structure. They may prefer to
work alone as they prefer not
to be distracted. They are
generally self-motivated and
may be quite goal-oriented.
The activities created for
them include finding
mistakes, solving logical
puzzles, figuring out a
detective story, and creating
rules for specific activities.
Mind Organisation The last of the styles looks at behaviour and is created
by putting together the idea of perception as concrete
(using the senses) or abstract (using ideas and feelings)
and the element of organisation (either systematically
or non-systematically). This gives us four distinct styles
which were created by April Bowie (1997) who began
her research working with adolescents. She devised a
learning style survey called ‘Mind Organisation’ and
used it as a basis for counselling high school students
and helping them to learn. Her four styles include:
Flexible Friends who perceive abstractly through
ideas or feelings and organise non-systematically.
Expert Investigators who perceive abstractly
through ideas or feelings and organise
systematically.
Power planners who perceive concretely using their
senses and organise systematically.
Radical Reformers who perceive concretely through
their senses but organise non-systematically.
Flexible Friends like to work in groups, especially those
in which they like the other people. They are creative
and intuitive and value
personalised learning
experiences. They are also
enthusiastic and express their
empathy for others. Language
activities which appeal to
them include setting personal
goals, writing down sentences
which are true for them in a
dictation exercise, learning to
use vocabulary of emotions
and feelings, completing
sentences about their
partner, and finding things in
common with others.
Expert Investigators are logical and systematic learners.
They tend to be perfectionists so prefer to work at their
own speed. In dealing with others they are generally
logical and rational. They especially like to do research
and to know where they can get information from. The
language activities designed for them include working
with facts and informative materials, finding errors and
doing research for a class excursion followed by a
report on how it went.
Power Planners like to be organised and are generally
detail- and task-oriented. In groups they may take on a
Moving on to personal
research or professional
development, stretching
outside your own comfort
zone, or helping students to
realise their true potential are
only some of the places these
ideas can take you.
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 9
natural role as a leader and enjoy hands-on activities.
The language tasks designed for them include putting
processes in order and explaining them to others,
finding explanations and rules for difficult grammar
points, using linking words correctly to create plans and
setting priorities.
Radical Reformers are risk-takers and are often curious
about a number of different fields of study. They
generally rely on their intuition to solve problems but
pride themselves on finding unique ones. They tend to
‘think outside the box’ and value creativity and
ingenuity. In groups, they may inspire others and value
real-life experiences. The activities for them include
realistic role plays, creating and acting out a scenario
based on a true story, buying and selling everyday items
to each other by finding unusual uses for them, creating
statements about themselves which the others guess
are true or false.
Moving on The information presented here is the start; the end of
the journey is up to the readers and users of the book.
As learning styles and the discoveries which occur when
people become aware of them is a never-ending story,
the goal of this article and the book itself is to open up a
perspective on learning which perhaps had not been
considered before. Moving on to personal research or
professional development, stretching outside your own
comfort zone, or helping students to realise their true
potential are only some of the places these ideas can
take you. The excitement of discovery remains to those
who use the information to delve into themselves and
their teaching as well as their students and their
learning in whichever way they choose. The impetus is
here, the joy of further discovery is up to you.
Bibliography Barbe, W B and Swassing, R H Teaching through
modality strengths: Concepts and practices Zaner-
Bloser Inc. 1979
Bowie, A Mind Organisation, The Learning Styles
Institute 1997
Bowie, A Adolescent Self Perceptions of Learning
Styles: A Qualitative Study, Master’s Thesis, Antioch
University, Seattle 1998
Dunn, R and Dunn, K The Complete Guide to the
Learning Styles Inservice System Allyn and Bacon
1999
Guild, P B and Garger, S Marching to Different
Drummers Association for Supervision and
Curriculum Development (ASCD) 1998
Harmer, J The Practice of English Language Teaching
Longman 2007
Keefe, J W ‘Learning styles: an overview’ in Keefe, J S
(Ed): Student learning styles: diagnosing and
prescribing problems Reston. National Association
of Secondary School Principles 1979
König, M E Theory of Learning Styles and Practical
Applications Grin-Verlag für akademische Texte
2005
Reid, J Learning Styles in the ESL/EFL Classroom
Heinle and Heinle Boston Publishers 1995
Roche, T Investigating Learning Style in the Foreign
Language Classroom Langenscheidt 2006
Schmitt, N (Ed) An Introduction to Applied Linguistics
Hodder Education 2002
Witkin, H A and Goodenough, D R Cognitive Styles:
Essence and Origins International Universities Press
1981
Let us know if you attended Marjorie Rosenberg’s workshop? Did you enjoy it? What do you feel about Learner styles? Are there activities and things you do in class that take into account different
learner styles?
10 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
Material Swop Shop
Ideas for lessons that really work!
If you have lesson activities that really work, please share them.
Email Jean Theuma at [email protected] with a brief description of what you do and why it works.
Share your ideas with others!
“ Murder mystery Game.
This game can be used to practice indirect questions
with an Intermediate class. Students are put into
pairs (student A & student B). The teacher tells the
students some basic information about the crime
e.g. a teacher from the school was murdered yester-
day. Students are told that they are suspects but
yesterday they and their partner were at the cinema
at the time of the murder. Students invent details
about what they did at the cinema without taking
notes. While this is happening, 2 Students are given
the role of policemen. They must go outside the
class and create questions for the suspects. Divide
all the As and Bs into two groups and allocate a po-
liceman to each group. The policeman ask his/her Qs
taking detailed notes about the answers from each
student. The teacher monitors the groups and notes
down common errors. When they are finished the
teacher asks the students to go back into their pairs
and discuss the answers they had given. The police-
men compare their answers. The policemen reveal
the pair that had the most discrepancies and they
are the murderers. The teacher gives delayed error
correction on the board. ”
(Adrian—teaches general English to adults)
“ I think the key to working with one-to-one stu-
dents is flexibility. Ask the student what he/she
wants to do on a daily basis. Their attitude to how
they work and what material they want to cover will
change as the course progresses—and maybe they
are tired or stressed and want to do things different-
ly sometimes. ” (Liz—teaches adults)
“ I often find that my students love talking about
health and fitness, especially if they come from Eu-
ropean countries. Doing tasks related to fitness ex-
ercises helps to introduce or revise verbs that the
students are either not familiar with or don’t know
the exact meaning of. This topic is very versatile be-
cause at beginner level you can teach easy verbs
such as walk, run, sit, stand; mid-levels get tricky
words like kneel, crouch, and crawl; and higher lev-
els get to talk about the difference between lift and
pick up, grab and catch, grasp and cling! The food
aspect of fitness is also good to exploit, leading to
beginner level lessons on basic food stuffs, middle
level lessons about cooking techniques and higher
level lessons discussing the nutritional and energy
values of certain foods. Health and fitness as a topic
can also lead to discussions on work/life balance
and whether we get enough time to peruse a
healthy lifestyle. ” (Joe—teaches adults in summer)
“ Improvisation works a treat with all classes as a
fluency exercise. Give each student a number. Call a
number and give a scenario where the student
needs help—their car breaks down, they are on a
desert Island, they are locked out of their house, …
The student should start the scene looking wor-
ried—Call other numbers and those students must
come into the scene and offer help. They can leave
the scene whenever they want to but can only enter
when you call their number. This can be done with
one large group in the middle of the class or with
several smaller groups working simultaneous-
ly.” (Jean—teaches adults and teens)
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 11
Introduction
It seems symptomatic of the social media era that
most people’s diet of inspirational quotes is nowadays
supplied by social networking sites, awash as they are
with the pithy quips and maxims of a host of
enlightened writers, artists and celebrities. What was
once the job of The Oxford Dictionary of Quotations is
now being done by Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest
among others. The original source of these quotes is
rarely cited and almost never given any importance. It
seems as if we have all read Albert Einstein, William
Shakespeare and Mahatma Gandhi, we have all
listened to Steve Jobs’s (2005)
Stanford University
commencement speech, and we
have all watched Dead Poets
Society, Forrest Gump, Rocky
Balboa and The Pursuit of
Happyness. In the process of ultra
skimming through countless posts
and tweets, with some luck such
inspirational quotes are read and
shared. However, if they are not
properly digested the words would not be worthy of
being termed ‘inspirational’. In this article I reflect on
the significance, with respect to teachers’ creative
identity, of a quote I came across recently.
A school in Nicaragua used Instagram to post the
following quote by the American author Joseph
Chilton Pearce: “To live a creative life, we must lose
our fear of being wrong.” This quote was meant to
encourage its students not to be afraid of making
mistakes in their struggle to master the English
language. Pearce wrote a number of books about child
development and this particular quote is perhaps one
of the most famous pronouncements on creativity.
Beyond the school’s use of the quote as a means of
goading students to experiment with the target
language, this sentence should also resonate with
teachers in their endeavour to be creative
practitioners.
Creative Practitioners
Some teachers’ misconceptions about what
constitutes creativity impede them from positioning
themselves as creative practitioners (Xerri, 2013). The
myth that creativity is only about
creating works of art or enabling
learners to be artistic is detrimental
to teachers’ efforts to be creative.
As language speakers we are all
creative individuals. It takes a lot of
creativity for a child to acquire a
language, for a learner to use the
language we teach them. However,
as language teachers we can be
even more creative when we think
of new possibilities for language teaching and
learning. Being creative does not just mean using arts
and crafts, poetry or film in language lessons. While
lessons incorporating activities based on those media
and genres have the potential to act as creative
impulses for learners, the essence of creativity for
teachers goes beyond classroom activities.
Being creative means daring to do things differently,
thus expanding the boundaries of what you know
about teaching and learning in order to discover new
On Teachers’ Creative Life
Daniel Xerri discusses creativity in the classroom ahead of this year’s EFL Monitoring Board
conference on the same theme.
Being creative does not
just mean using arts
and crafts, poetry or
film in language
lessons.
12 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
worlds within the confines of your classroom. In fact,
Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (1996) defines the creative
individual as “someone whose thoughts or actions
change a domain, or establish a new domain” (p. 28).
Being creative means you do not just do what trainers
and other experts tell you you should be doing, but
rather trusting your intuitions as educators to break
new ground, research your practices, experiment with
new pedagogies, and try out new activities or spin-offs
of things you are used to doing. Being creative means
you are not just followers but leaders, not just
consumers but creators, not just an audience but
sharers. Being creative means you do not hermetically
seal your knowledge and experience inside your head,
but rather expressing the willingness to share with
others. A community of creative educators is made up
of professionals who are constantly learning from
each other.
Most teachers are all too willing to sit back and learn
from others, fearing that they cannot teach anything
to their peers or to themselves, fearing that they have
nothing new to say, that they are incapable of being
creative. They do what they are instructed to do on a
teacher training course, at a conference, or in a
methodology book. However, possessing all that
knowledge should not hinder teachers from doing
things differently, finding out for themselves what
works and what is unlikely to be effective. There is no
recipe for the perfect lesson; there is no manual that
will ensure success in every single activity with every
single student. Being creative means having faith in
your expertise as a teacher, as someone
knowledgeable about your context, your learners, the
language, and the repertoire of methods and
approaches at your disposal. Being creative means you
do not let the dictums of others straightjacket you, but
rather demonstrating the willingness to question
everything and to apply multiple perspectives to every
issue and problem you encounter.
Creative teachers are not just born creative. Creativity
is a state of mind. It is a boundary that you need to
cross in order to discover your potential to do things
differently and be an inspiration for others. According
to Alan Alda (2007), you need to
Have the nerve to go into unexplored
territory. Be brave enough to live creatively.
The creative is the place where no one else
has ever been. It is not the previously known.
You have to leave the city of your comfort
and go into the wilderness of your intuition.
You can’t go there by bus, only by hard work
and risk and by not quite knowing what
you’re doing, but what you’ll discover will be
wonderful. What you’ll discover will be
yourself. (pp. 21-22)
Most teachers are not creative because they allow
fear to dominate them. They prefer living in the
comfort zone rather than exploring the unknown.
Whilst there are practically no more places on Earth
for anyone to discover for the first time ever, there is
a lot that can still be discovered about teaching and
learning. However, the number of teachers willing to
act as explorers is far too little. Education requires as
many teachers as possible determined to explore new
frontiers.
Being creative means you are not afraid to fail,
especially since failure is a fundamental part of the
teaching and learning experience. Which teacher has
not tasted the bitterness of failure at least once over
the course of their career? The most brilliant
educators are the ones who have failed many times in
their quest to achieve success, whether this be an
amazing lesson, wonderful feedback, or a learner’s
attainment of seemingly impossible aims. Being
creative means you are willing to transcend your fears
in order to discover that you can be right sometimes
besides being wrong at other times.
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 13
As Edward de Bono (1990) points out,
The need to be right all the time is the
biggest bar to new ideas. It is better to have
enough ideas for some of them to be wrong
than to be always right by having no ideas at
all. (p. 108)
The need to be right all the time is the essence of
vertical thinking, which is a problem solving and
decision-making approach that entails being selective,
analytical and sequential as a means of avoiding
failure. According to de Bono (1990), an “Exclusive
emphasis on the need to be right all the time
completely shuts out creativity and progress” (p. 108).
This is why it is important to use lateral thinking, which
consists of both the willingness to perceive things in
divergent ways and a series of thinking methods that
can be learnt (de Bono, 1982).
Conclusion
Teachers need to lead a creative life rather than just
experience creative moments interspersed among non
-creative lesson activities. Being creative is not
something you do temporarily. It should be a
permanent fixture of your professional life. You do not
stop being a teacher when the lesson ends. Teaching is
an intrinsic part of your identity. Similarly, creativity
should be a constant feature of your teaching and your
professional inquiry as an educator within and outside
the classroom. However, for that to happen you need
to overcome your fear of being wrong. As Ken
Robinson (2006) maintains, “if you’re not prepared to
be wrong, you’ll never come up with anything original”.
I dare you to lose your fear of being wrong. I dare you
to be wrong sometimes. That is how you can be right
at other times. That is how you can be creative.
The theme of the 4th ELT Malta Conference is Creativity
in ELT. The conference will take place on 22-25 October
2015.
References
Alda, A. (2007). Things I overheard while talking to
myself. New York: Random House.
Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1996). Creativity: Flow and the
psychology of discovery and invention. New York:
HarperPerennial.
de Bono, E. (1982). Thinking course: Powerful tools to
transform your thinking. Harlow: BBC Active.
de Bono, E. (1990). Lateral thinking: Creativity step by
step. New York: HarperPerennial.
Jobs, S. (2005, June). How to live before you die
[Online video]. TED. Retrieved May 14, 2015
from http://www.ted.com/talks/
steve_jobs_how_to_live_before_you_die
Robinson, K. (2006, February). How schools kill
creativity [Online video]. TED. Retrieved May 14,
2015 from https://www.ted.com/talks/
ken_robinson_says_schools_kill_creativity
Xerri, D. (2013, Autumn). The value of creativity:
Language teachers as creative practitioners.
Teaching English, 3, 23-25.
You do not stop being a
teacher when the
lesson ends.
14 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
PLNs – building your professional support system.
Even the most enthusiastic of teachers, armed with
the best stock of course books, can go through a
phase of “been there, done that (for the umpteenth
time)”. There’s a whole plethora of online resources at
our fingertips, if only we knew where to start! I admit I
have passed through this kind of phase at times
myself, especially before joining
MATEFL a few years ago.
However, sometimes, it isn’t
just about finding yet another
handout about the Present
Perfect or a cool new video to
use with your long-term
students. It’s about making
connections with other
teachers and professionals in
our field and discussing what
drives us and worries us. In
short, we want to talk about things which matter to
us.
Last month, I was lucky enough to meet our MATEFL
Spring Seminar guest speaker Marjorie Rosenberg, the
current President of IATEFL. We realised we had
several mutual friends on Facebook and she quickly
suggested some more people I should follow. She
reminded me that we always need to nurture our own
PLN and eagerly told me about her own.
For those who are unfamiliar with the term, a PLN
(Personal Learning Network) is basically an informal
learning support system of individuals whose aim is to
share ideas and knowledge through interaction. A PLN
is intrinsically a social process and is supported by
social learning theories (Bandura) and
connectivism (Siemens & Downes).
So, what does a PLN for ELT look like exactly? How
does one go about joining one?
Here is a short, non-exhaustive list of PLNs I’ve
participated in, and enjoyed, recently:
ELTChat
http://eltchat.org/wordpress/
ELT chat is a self-professed ELT “social
network” offering mutual support and
opportunities for Continuous
Professional Development to ELT
professionals around the world. Online
discussions about a chosen topic are
held every Wednesday at 10pm CET for
one hour through Twitter. If you cannot
join in real time, you’ll be happy to
know that full summaries of the chats
are then posted on the site http://eltchat.org/
wordpress/eltchat-summaries-index/. It is especially
useful if you’re not a twitter user. A poll is posted
every Sunday to vote for the next topic to be
discussed, so issues are kept current. It is a really good
community of regulars, with the likes of Marjorie and
other IATEFL personalities, regularly contributing to
the discussions.
EDchat
http://edchat.pbworks.com/
Similarly, even though it is not exclusively focussed on
ELT, #Edchat conversations are hosted twice every
Teacher 2.0: a Survival Guide to Technology in the classroom
Natasha Fabri explores 21st century teaching.
a PLN (Personal
Learning Network) is
basically an informal
learning support system
of individuals whose
aim is to share ideas
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 15
Tuesday, at 6pm and 1am
CET. Conversations range from
“current teaching trends, how
to integrate technology,
transform their teaching, and
connect with inspiring
educators worldwide” to
“education policy and reform”.
Shelly Sanchez Terrell, a co-
founder of Edchat also hosts
her own free, 30 minute
weekly webinars every Friday at 10pm
CET.
Joining is simple, log on as a guest
on: Americantesol.adobeconnect.com/terrell. The
sessions are always lively and useful in content and
Shelly interacts with participants from all over the
world in real time. After each webinar, she also offers
free resources and a Certificate of Attendance if you
fill in a form:
Shellyterrell.com/amtesolcertificate.
ELT Pics
https://www.facebook.com/groups/eltpics/
and http://www.eltpics.com/
ELTPics is a community of ELT professionals who take/
share their own photos on a given theme to pool into
a resource bank of images which can be used freely
for teaching purposes. A new theme is posted every
two weeks on both Facebook and Twitter (#eltpics),
Join IATEFL!
Membership with IATEFL offers you:
Contact with EFL teachers around the world
An annual conference and exhibition at membership rates
An opportunity to join any of the 15 Special Interest Groups (SIGS)
Discounted periodicals
IATEFL Voices newsletter 6 times a year
MATEFL is an Associate Member of IATEFL and as such is able to offer
all its members the opportunity to become an IATEFL member for only €35.00 and €23.00 for each SIG.
Ask for an application form, fill it in and send it to Caroline Campbell, c/o 257, Upper St. Albert Street, Gzira,
GZR 1153 along with your cheque for €35.00 (plus €23.00 for each SIG you choose). Details of available SIGs
are found on the application form and on the IATEFL web-site—www.iatefl.org.
Please note that this offer is only available for MATEFL members.
For any further information please contact Caroline Campbell, Alan Marsh or Jean Theuma at [email protected]
ELTpics is a huge resource of free pictures which are legal for teachers to download and use in class.
16 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
so it is easy to keep up to date. A number of curators
tag and upload images to the relevant sets to make
them searchable on albums on:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/eltpics/albums.
The website www.eltpics.com also gives useful tips on
how to use these images in the classroom. Most of us
have a smartphone by now, so it’s easy to see how this
is quite popular!
Map of the Urban Linguistic Landscape
(MULL)
https://www.facebook.com/groups/MUrbanLL/
MULL can be seen as a more recent variation of
ELTPics. However, it is more focussed on the mapping
of variations of English around the world. Contributors
post pictures of street signs and other public notices,
commenting on idiosyncrasies of the region and how
English becomes intertwined with the local languages
with some quite interesting results.
English Club
https://www.englishclub.com/
Having a PLN is also great for our language learners
outside of the classroom. A great place to start from is
Englishclub. It caters for both learners and teachers of
English and includes a forum for teachers:
https://www.englishclub.com/esl-forums/.
While the PLN is not a new concept, I feel it is a great
way for all teachers, from the newbies or seasonal
teachers to the “veterans” among us, to be reminded
that we operate within a larger community of teachers
worldwide. By connecting to these PLNs, we get to
meet other people who are passionate about what
they do. It’s a great way to get inspired by their
experiences, to fuel our own enthusiasm for teaching
by trying new things and to also build connections and
friendships with our peers abroad. The great thing is
that we also realise that we too have much to
contribute to the community beyond our shores.
ELTchat is a good place to start.
If you are not a twitter user, you can read the summaries of the chat which are archived on the site.
If you do use twitter, you can join the chat every Wednesday at 10pm CET.
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 17
Course book face off
Matt Done pits two course-book giants against each other.
For this edition of the good old course book ‘face-off’, I’ve chosen two very different titles that are nonethe-less both personal favourites. That’s right - the legend-ary ‘New English File’ takes on the formidable ‘Outcomes’. Outcomes – Published by Heinle-Cengage, Written by Hugh Dellar and Andrew Walkley What kind of book is it? Outcomes is very much a unique product in the com-petitive world of EFL materials. Aside from its slightly older cousin ‘Innovations’, which is also co-authored by Hugh Dellar, it is essentially the only leading course book designed with the somewhat controversial ‘lexical approach’ in mind. For those of you who are unfamiliar, the crux of it is that lexis lies at the heart of language acquisition. We don’t simply slot words into the gaps of pre-learned grammatical structures, it ar-gues. Rather, any progress we make as language learn-ers comes off the back of acquiring layer upon layer of lexis. And this belief is certainly reflected in the book, which is bursting with all kinds of words and expres-sions. You won’t see units in this book arranged around discreet grammar items like the present per-fect. What’s good about it? A lot. The thing that leaps out at you most, perhaps, is its emphasis on developing conversations. The ra-tionale is that conversations, at least at the start, de-velop rather predictably, and that we can prepare stu-
dents for this by feeding them a language diet rich in lexical chunks and fixed expressions. Students learn useful things such as ‘What are you doing later?’, and ‘How’re things at work?’ then put them to practice immediately in the several role-play and mini dialogue activities. You really do get a sense that you are help-ing your learners develop their fluency and have real-istic conversations – something which certainly can’t be said for other books. Could anything be better? Well, nothing is perfect in life, but I really did have to scratch my head to find a glaring deficiency in this one. Perhaps for certain students, outcomes may be a shock to the system in that few of the gap-fill activities are really ‘grammar’ exercises. Although there are still notes on rules at the back, your typical grammar-checklist bearing student might not get his fix here. Another potential issue is that, since the series is so content heavy and input focused, it does place a slightly heavier load on the teacher, who might be subjected to a wider range of less predictable ques-tions. This book may, therefore, be better suited to more experienced teachers who are happy to stand in the firing line. Finally, and I’m being nit-picky here, there are one or two expressions taught in the book which might sound odd coming from a student, like ‘Are you taking the mickey out of me?’ or ‘He’s a right pain’. Having said that, for students preparing to live or already living in the UK, these will have high surren-der value, especially receptively.
VS
Heinle-Cengage Oxford University Press
18 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
Overall impressions I came across this book for the first time when I was running out of material to use with an advanced class. I was sick and tired of flicking unsuccessfully through higher-level course books, desperate to find some-thing to teach that didn’t sound daft or obscure. I mean, how often do we really say or hear ‘Never be-fore had I held him so tightly’? Outcomes promptly came to the rescue and has been a firm favourite ever since. The thing I love most about it is that I get a very strong sense that I’m actually teaching something of value, which is, after all, what we’re being paid to do. If you haven’t used this book yet, stop whatever you’re doing and buy it at once. New English File – Published by Oxford University Press, Written by Clive Oxenden and Christina Latham-Koenig What kind of book is it? Few things in life make me cringe as much as a bad cliché, but you have to say that New English File is a book which ‘needs no introduction’. We’ve all used it, we’ve all got photocopies of our favourite bits, and some of us can probably teach some of its units back-wards and with our eyes closed. It’s the book you see under students’ arms as they cross the road while you wait at the lights, and the book you see on café tables as one-to-one lessons take to the streets. New English File is everywhere, and with good reason. Once you look inside, it’s a fairly typical course book. Most units are written around discreet grammar items, and most also conform to the safe and sturdy ‘PPP’ (present, practice, produce) model. There is a healthy dose of what you’d expect – grammar, vocab-ulary, listening, reading, and writing, but also a very strong focus on pronunciation. It’s definitely a meaty book with plenty for teachers and students to sink their teeth into. What’s good about it? Quite a lot. The biggest strength of New English File, as far as I’m concerned at least, is the choice of topics. Most units in the book feature relevant and up-to-date issues which really do get students talking and engaged. There’s also a good amount of humour and light-heartedness, which does wonders for classroom dynamics and of course makes the material itself more memorable. Another plus point is the considerable attention paid to pronunciation. While other books treat it superfi-
cially if at all, English File features very regular pronun-ciation slots, which raise both students’ and teachers’ awareness of how crucial an aspect of language learn-ing it is. The teacher’s book is also an absolute goldmine, brimming with extra activities for practice tests, grammar homework and further communicative practice Finally, unlike with outcomes, perhaps, there’s absolutely no reason why a novice teacher couldn’t pick this up and teach from it – a definite ‘A+’ for being user-friendly. Could anything be better? Well, yes, but again I’m going to have to be quite nit-picky. You could argue that the lesson structure of most of the book, PPP, has been largely discredited. Everything is fairy linear and logical, in that language is first presented, then practiced a bit in a controlled manner, and then used in a ‘freer’ sort of context. However, this doesn’t really match up to what is known about language acquisition, which is more of a messy ‘one step forward, two steps back’ kind of pro-cess. Still, you could level this accusation at the vast majority of books on the market - it’s just how most of them continue to be written. You could, of course, defend the PPP approach in books. After all, it offers students a sense of progress, it makes the language accessible, and it’s easy for teachers to pick up and teach. But this is a debate for another day... Another criticism I have is related to a pet-hate of mine – songs. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not totally against them. I just think that most of them offer pretty unrealistic models of language, in spite of the ‘fun and motivation’ factor. New English File is packed with them, although, to be fair, they tend to be op-tional add-ons rather than central features of the les-son. Overall Impressions My frail attempt at a critique is testament to the fact
that I’m a big English File fan. If they made t-shirts, I’d
wear one with pride. It’s a motivating, fun, and lively
book that has language content to match. It’s little
wonder that it rules the roost when it comes to course
books.
Matt Done
If you’d like to compare 2 course books for our next Course Book Face-off, please contact Jean Theuma at [email protected]
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 19
Out and About in EFL
Jean Theuma has just come back from Teacher training in LIMA, PERU
Teacher Training is not always an easy job. Teaching teachers can be hard and Department Heads even more so. So when I was asked to go to Lima in Peru for a week to train a group of University English Department Coordinators I did not know what to expect. Add to this the fact that the first time I was to meet my co-trainer was in Amsterdam when getting on the plane to Lima and I am sure you can understand my ap-prehension. On the flight we did not have seats next to each other, so the first time we had to actually sit down and talk to each other was in the taxi whizzing towards the hotel. Well...I say ‘talk to each other’, but it was mainly both of us looking out the window and taking sharp breaths every time the taxi weaved in and out of hellish traffic. It would seem that taxi drivers in Peru have not grasped the simple fact that they have
a brake and that it is not a sign of weakness to use it! Brian, for that is the name of the co-trainer, and I got out at our beautiful hotel and, all at once, everything seemed fine. My worries evaporated and my excitement at a new adventure kicked in. The training took place at the hotel, and the par-ticipants were also housed in the hotel. This meant that we did not have any travel time to and from the training venue. At the end of each training day, we went to our room, put on our comfortable shoes and within minutes were out the door exploring the city. And what a wonderful city Lima is! Our hotel was in the Miraflores district; obviously the more affluent part of town with clean streets, fancy shopping malls,
The view from the top of the hotel , looking out on to the Pacific Ocean.
20 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
tourist trap ‘artisan’ markets and beautiful parks at the end of every road. This was quite a contrast to the streets we saw as we were driving in from the airport. The taxi ride took us past dull, dingy shops which seemed to built into garages, children playing bare-foot in dust-heaps and greasy smelling fast-food joints on every corner. The taxi driver warned us to keep the windows rolled up as motorcyclists have been known to ride by the windows, pluck the handbag off your lap and make their escape through the gridlocked traffic. One of the highlights of the trip was a publisher visit. The publisher, while wooing the University, took the participants and us trainers out to the best restaurant in town. This is The Huaca Pucllana , a Peruvian speci-ality restaurant built on the site of a pre-Inca temple in the middle of the city. Before you wonder whether I have taken leave of my senses, let me explain...Lima is a poor city with very limited resources. When the Pe-ruvian Government found that the strange mound in the middle of the city was an ancient ruin, they looked into how to fund its restoration. The restaurant own-ers were given permission to use some of the grounds to built an elevated deck, put tables and chairs out and serve wonderful Peruvian cuisine. In return for this, the restaurant have pledged to preserve, restore and fund excavations on the site. In fact, last year, 2 preserved mummies were discovered inside the mound and were handed over to the Peruvian Gov-ernment Museums department. Another highlight was a visit to the Larco museum. Another hair-raising taxi ride away from the hotel and
20 minutes later we were walking through one of the best laid out museums I have ever been to. All the exhibits are clearly marked and gathered into sections depicting different aspects of Inca life: cooking, farm-ing, textiles, and, of course, what they are best known for, human sacrifice. And housed away from the main exhibits, the museum also boasts one of the largest collections of pre-Colombian erotic art; a slightly em-barrassing find considering I had only just met my col-league on the flight over! The University Coordinators turned out to be a dream to train. They were eager, enthusiastic and keen to discuss new methods. Like most administrators, they felt as if they were snowed under and had trouble di-viding their time up between the day to day running of their department and the forward planning which would make their lives easier. The group were good English speakers and were well-able to express them-selves on a variety of topics. The course focussed on teacher observations, developing and supporting teachers and working towards meeting standards im-posed by the University on their departments. The week flew past and before I knew it I was back on the plane making a gruelling 48 hour journey home. I left the hotel in Lima on Saturday just after midday and got home on Monday just before midday. I trav-elled trough Amsterdam and Rome before collapsing gratefully into my own bed. But I would do it all again in a shot!
Please let us share your experience of teaching abroad. If you’d like to contribute to the next Out and About in EFL, please email Jean Theuma at [email protected]
A textile sample found at the Larco Museum dating from 1AD
Statue of a bright red bull in Parque Kennedy, also known as Cat Park because it is full of stray cats.
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 21
Words in this puzzle appear horizontal, vertical, diagonal as well as backwards!
ASYNCHRONOUS
AUDIO BLOG
BLENDED LEARNING
CALL
CONCORDANCER
COURSE CASTING
DIGITAL DIVIDE
DISCUSSION GROUP
E-LEARNING
E-PORTFOLIO
IWB
KEYPAL
M-LEARNING
MULTIMEDIA
MUVE
NETMEETING
PBWIKI
PEER-TO-PEER
SECOND LIFE
SKYPE
SYNCHRONOUS
VIDEO CONFERENCE
VLE
VLOG
WEBQUEST
WIKI
How well do you know your EFL jargon?
All the words below are related to teaching with the Internet:
E R E C N A D R O C N O C P E
V C S U O N O R H C N Y S U P
G L N S E C O N D L I F E O Y
A D E E P O R T F O L I O R K
G N I N R A E L M E V U M G S
B L E N D E D L E A R N I N G
P B W I K I F L A P Y E K O T
E L E A R N I N G V L O G I S
R A S Y N C H R O N O U S S E
G O L B O I D U A C A L L S U
M U L T I M E D I A O M C U Q
G N I T E E M T E N V E P C B
E D I V I D L A T I G I D S E
C O U R S E C A S T I N G I W
R E E P O T R E E P T O Y D V
22 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
The Ultimate Synonym Crossword
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 23
Across
1. passage
6. re-run
8. acute
9. warily
10. creditable
12. defrost
14. independent
18. immature
19. youthful
20. payment
22. ascend
24. cable
26. below
28. gilt
30. two
31. yell
32. yearly
36. gorge
37. microscopic
38. answer
Down
2. exceptional
3. precisely
4. dispatch
5. swap
7. roughly
11. battle
13. cat
15. same
16. circulate
17. great
18. cutthroat
21. spotless
23. abruptly
25. purchase
27. authentic
29. commence
30. active
33. haul
34. group
35. housecoat Created using Puzzlemaker at
DiscoveryEducation.com
Answers on page 26
Signs in “English” from China
Source: www.telegraph.co.uk
24 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
7 ways we use questions in class
Asking questions is one of the most powerful tools we have as teachers. According to a popular learning pyramid diagram available on the internet, only 5% of what students hear when teachers are in lecture mode is actually remembered, whereas 50% of discus-sion driven information is retained. Although the pyramid has been proven to be a gross simplification of what actually happens, it seems true that being more participatory will aid learning more than ‘just’ listening or reading activities. So when teachers ask questions, even if they are rhetorical, something sparks in the students’ brains and they become more involved; they become part of what is going on, rather than merely onlookers. In Critical Thinking: Basic Theory and Instructional structures, the au-thors propose that all thinking is driven by questions. Asking questions opens up discussion, whereas answering questions clos-es it down. Here are 7 ways in which teachers can use questions in class:
1. To engage students Teachers use questions at the beginning of a lesson or at the beginning of a particular part of a lesson, to create interest in the topic or content. We ask stu-dents to predict or reflect on topic, asking what they know or linking the topic to their own experiences. This has two benefits:
A) For students, it activates background sche-mata – in other words, it helps the process by which the learners combine their own background knowledge with the information we give them about the topic in order to understand the lesson. Students find this very engaging.
B) As teachers, we can find out what our stu-dents already know or feel about the topic, making sure that the lesson is well-received by the students. We can move on swiftly if we detect that the students already know all about it, or are bored by the topic. Equally, we can linger if the students are enthusiastic
and want to develop the discussion.
2. To ask students to personalise the language Scott Thornbury defines personalisation in language teaching as ‘when you use it [language] to talk about your knowledge, experience and feelings’. Many teachers consider this stage very important for learn-ing as it gives the students an emotional connection with the content of the lesson. In course books, the personalisation task is often the final stage of a lesson giving the opportunity for creative practice, letting the students off of the leash, so to speak! Personalising
the language also allows the student the opportunity to explore the ways in which an item of language might be useful to them personally and how it can be incorporated to their active language library.
3. Concept check questions As teachers, we sometimes need to be sure that what we think we have taught correlates to what the students have learnt. What I mean to say is, we might go into a detailed explanation of, say, a grammar point only to find
that, no matter how clearly we think we have taught the point, the students still find it confusing. Concept check questions are those quite tricky questions that we all cover when we are learning how to teach, and for the most part, never really put into practice once we get our own classes. Some teachers might rely in-stead on watching the students flounder in the first practice exercise and then go back to the beginning to clarify and pick up the pieces. Concept check ques-tions should be precisely what is written on the tin – a series of questions which clarify the concepts that we are trying to teach to avoid confusion later on in the lesson.
4. Instruction check questions In my experience as a teacher observer, these type of questions are also often overlooked and forgotten. Instruction check questions allow us those few mo-ments to check that all the students know what they are supposed to be doing and how long the activity is expected to last. I think we should sometimes remind ourselves that our students have not done the exer-
Jean Theuma explores how using question techniques can increase the learning in our classes
Asking questions
opens up
discussion, whereas
answering
questions closes it
down.
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 25
cise in the book the 12 million times that we have! They are coming to the task for (possibly) the first time and can easily be confused by the instructions. This is especially clear in older students who have not been to school for many years and those keen stu-dents who want to get it right.
5. To check for comprehension during a recep-tive skills part of a lesson After a reading or listening (the receptive skills), the best way we teachers can find out if the students have actually understood the text is by making them an-swer comprehension questions. In fact, these some-times seem to benefit the teacher more than the stu-dents. Teachers can also use com-prehension questions to direct the students’ attention to certain parts of the reading or listening activity that contain important or inter-esting language. But with regard to students, Mario Rinvolucri sug-gests that they should be encour-aged to gauge their own compre-hension of a text. He recommends activities such as asking the stu-dents to write comprehension questions for each other in order to find the answers. He also pro-poses that teachers’ questions about he texts should focus on the students elaboration or reaction to the text rather than just a regurgitation of it.
6. As prompts during a productive skills part of a lesson Most of us find it quite difficult when asked to speak or write about something on the spot, with little prep-aration. Learners of the language have the added hur-dle of having to organise, not only their thoughts on the topic, but also the very language that they will need to use to express themselves. By providing prompt questions and giving speaking preparation time or time to write a mind-map or speaking notes, the students can better organise their thoughts and their language. Prompt questions can provide a frame-work on which the student can structure their speak-ing or writing and this in itself is an important skill to learn in a foreign language as much of it is culture based and varies from country to country.
7. To create genuine rapport with the students Arguably, the best condition for learners to engage and learn what we teach them in class is when they are relaxed. Stephen Krashen calls this ‘lowering the students’ affective filter’ and he extols the benefits of lowering personal and classroom anxiety. One good way to relax the students is to create a sense of rap-port with them by being genuinely interested in the students as people. Asking them about their day, their health and happiness when they come to lessons is one way. Finding out about their motivation to learn English and how they are comfortable learning is an-other. In the positive atmosphere created by good rapport, student confidence can also be built which, in
turn, is related to progress and learning.
These were just 7 ways that using questions in class can greatly ben-efit our students. I wonder, can you think of any more?
References and further reading:
Benjes-Small, C. Tales of the un-dead...Learning theory, the learning pyramid - available: http://acrlog.org/2014/01/13/tales-of-the-undead-learning-theories-the-learning
-pyramid/
Crangle, T. Building rapport and confidence in ELT classes – A summary - available: http://eltchat.org/wordpress/summary/building-rapport-and-confidence-with-students-in-elt-classes-a-summary Krashen, S. (1982) Principles and practice in second lan-guage acquisition, Pergamon Press Inc. Paul, R.W & Elder, L. (2000) Critical Thinking: Basic Theory and Instructional Structures, Foundation for Critical Thinking Stott, N. Helping ESL students become better readers: Sche-ma theory applications and Limitations - available: http://iteslj.org/Articles/Stott-Schema.html Thornbury, S. (2006) An A-Z of ELT, Macmillan Rinvolucri, M. How useful are comprehension questions available: https://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/article/how-useful-are-comprehension-questions
Learners of the language have the
added hurdle of having to organise,
not only their thoughts on the topic,
but also the very language that they will need to use to
express themselves.
26 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
Answers to the MATEFL newsletter crossword:
Across
1. pass
6. repeat
8. pointed
9. carefully
10. valid
12. thaw
14. separate
18. childish
19. young
20. fee
22. rise
24. rope
26. under
28. gold
30. both
31. shout
32. annual
36. valley
37. tiny
38. response
Down
2. special
3. exactly
4. send
5. switch
7. approximately
11. clash
13. feline
15. alike
16. distribute
17. super
18. competitive
21. clean
23. suddenly
25. buy
27. real
29. start
30. busy
33. load
34. gang
35. robe
Language is funny like that....
1. There is no egg in eggplant or ham in hamburger 2. There are no apples or pines in pineapple. 3. Is cheese the plural of choose? 4. If teachers taught, did preachers praught? 5. People recite at a play and play at a recital. 6. People have noses that run and feet that smell 7. The weather can be as hot as hell and as cold as hell. 8. How come writers write, but fingers don’t fing and grocers don’t groce. 9. When a house burns up, it burns down. 10. When the stars are out they are visible, but when the lights are out they are invisible. 11. How come a slim chance and a fat chance as the same? 12. How come a wise guy and a wise man are opposites? 13. How come an alarm clock goes off by going on? 14. If the plural of tooth is teeth, then the plural of booth is beeth, right?
Source: https://www.englishforums.com ______________________________________________________
Pun fun
What’s the worst thing about having a party in space? You have to planet!
Yesterday a clown held open a door for me. I thought it was a nice jester.
How do you make an anti freeze? Steal her blanket!
It was an emotional wedding. Even the cake was in tiers.
What does a house wear? A dress
There was an explosion in a cheese factory in France. De-brie everywhere!
It’s hard to explain puns to a kleptomaniac. They always take things literally.
Two aerials were on a roof. They fell in love and got married. The service wasn’t great, but the reception was excellent.
I asked a Frenchman if he played video games. He said Wii http://www.buzzfeed/jessicamisener
M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4 P a g e | 27
Facts and figures about EFL students coming to Malta in 2014
The EFL Industry in a nutshell
Source: https://eflmalta.gov.mt/en/Pages/Industry-Statistics.aspx
EFL Students visiting in 2014
Male Female NA* Total
January 1156 1454 1 2611
February 1462 1704 0 3166
March 2700 3805 0 6505
April 2722 3535 1 6258
May 2407 2883 3 5293
June 4172 6228 11 10411
July 6800 10403 4 17207
August 5155 7102 4 12261
September 2317 3357 2 5676
October 2011 2582 1 4594
November 1177 1460 2 2639
December 493 436 0 929
Totals 32572 44949 29 77550
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
18000
20000
Ital
y
Ger
man
y
Ru
ssia
Fran
ce
Oth
er
cou
ntr
ies
Au
stri
a
Sp
ain
Sw
itze
rlan
d
Lib
ya
Po
lan
d
Turk
ey
Bra
zil
Jap
an
Cze
ch R
ep
Ne
the
rla
nd
s
Sw
ed
en
Be
lgiu
m
Slo
vaki
a
Sou
th k
ore
a
Co
lom
bia
Fin
lan
d
26113166
6505
6258
5293
10411
17207
12261
5676
45942639 929
EFL Students visiting in 2014 total
January February March April
May June July August
September October November December
EFL students’ countries
Italy 18572
Germany 10505
Russia 9429
France 7388
Other countries 5484
Austria 4276
Spain 3601
Switzerland 2370
Libya 2052
Poland 2045
EFL students’ countries
Turkey 1947
Brazil 1513
Japan 1499
Czech Rep 1458
Netherlands 1216
Sweden 976
Belgium 793
Slovakia 686
South Korea 610
Colombia 600
Finland 530
In 2014, the majority of students visiting Malta were Italian, German, Russian and French. In fact, 23% of EFL stu-dents hailed from our neighbouring country Italy. The students overwhelmingly flocked to our shores in June, July and August, with more students coming in July than any other month. Throughout the year, 16% more female students graced the islands than male students and they made up 60% of all students coming in July. The poorest month for the EFL industry was December with just under 1000 students coming to learn English.
* No information is available
28 | P a g e M A T E F L N e w s l e t t e r — M a y 2 0 1 4
The MATEFL Spring Workshop
Jean Theuma meets some of the teachers who attended Marjorie Rosenberg’s session in May 2015