1
e120 P21 / British Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 52 (2014) e75–e127 P132 Oral epithelial dysplasia: the role of ATR-Fanconi anaemia pathway in malignant transformation Michael Ho , A. Triantafyllou, J.M. Risk, R.J. Shaw, J.B. Wilson University of Liverpool Background: The Fanconi Anaemia (FA) pathway is responsible for homologous recombination repair of DNA interstrand crosslink damage. This checkpoint in S-phase of the cell cycle is mediated by ATR (Ataxia Telangiecta- sia Rad-3) and BRCA-1. The role of this tumour suppressor pathway in early oncogenesis is evaluated in oral dysplasia (OED) which transformed into oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) by evaluating expression of FANC-D2 protein. Methods: Forty patients with OED (and documented clin- ical outcomes/parameters) were identified from a cohort of patients who were prospectively recruited into a molecular biomarker study (1996-2012). The OED in 23 patients trans- formed into OSCC while the remaining 17 patients were in remission. Archival formalin fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) blocks from the first biopsy confirming the diagnosis of OED, immediately preceding malignant transformation and OSCC blocks, where applicable, were retrieved. 0.4 micron thick- ness sections were stained with FANC-D2, ATR and H2AX (control) antibodies. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) scoring was performed by two clinicians, assessing nuclear and cyto- plasmic staining extent and intensity. Corresponding FFPE cores (0.5 mm diameter) were processed for protein and DNA extraction to validate the IHC findings. Results: Based on the FANC-D2 dysplasia scoring system devised: a score 4 was associated with stable non- transforming OED (16 non-transformers vs. 5 transformers) and a score of 3 was associated with malignant transforma- tion of OED (7 non-transformers vs. 12 transformers) (Fisher exact test p = 0.02). ATR IHC showed staining patterns which correlate with FANC-D2 expression. The findings of IHC were validated with Western blots of protein extracts from the FFPE cores stained with FANC-D2 antibodies. Conclusion: Failure to activate the FA pathway (indicated by poor expression of FANC-D2 protein) due to defective DNA damage detection by ATR has been shown to be related to malignant transformation in OED. FANC-D2 IHC has the potential to influence the management of OED where equipoise exists. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2014.07.234 P133 MD by portfolio or published work in OMFS Barry O’Regan , Rian O’Regan Victoria Hospital, Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland Introduction: The completion of a higher degree in OMFS is difficult and the window of opportunity is nar- row because of dual qualification requirements at an early career stage. Many clinicians remain research motivated but are unable to commit to the timescale and demanding require- ments of a conventional research programme. Some UK Medical Schools1 currently offer an MD by portfolio of pub- lished work of “sufficient quality and academic standard” in peer-reviewed journals 1 . Aims: To compile a portfolio of theme-linked peer reviewed publications. To develop a linking hypothesis and “uniting theme” in personally published material by examining postoperative complication rates for submission as the academic core of an MD thesis to St Andrews University Medical School. Method: Ten personal BJOMS publications in 6-year period (2006-12) relating to two surgical techniques (retro- grade facial nerve dissection in parotidectomy and Le Fort 1 tuberosity osteotomy) were chosen. The complication rates for both techniques were compared against those published for conventional methods of surgical management in the literature. A theme related hypothesis outline entitled “An explo- ration of alternative surgical techniques in salivary gland and facial deformity surgery” was compiled, submitted and provisionally accepted. Results: The thesis construction roadmap and potential pitfalls are explored. Following completion over 2 years (2011-13), an MD thesis by portfolio was successfully sub- mitted for internal and externally chosen specialty expert academic examination. Conclusion: The development of a portfolio of original published work in peer-reviewed journals provides an encour- aging and alternative route to a higher research degree in OMFS. Reference 1. www.st-andrews.ac.uk. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2014.07.235

MD by portfolio or published work in OMFS

  • Upload
    rian

  • View
    225

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: MD by portfolio or published work in OMFS

e120 P21 / British Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 52 (2014) e75–e127

P132

Oral epithelial dysplasia: the role of ATR-Fanconianaemia pathway in malignant transformation

Michael Ho ∗, A. Triantafyllou, J.M. Risk, R.J. Shaw, J.B.Wilson

University of Liverpool

Background: The Fanconi Anaemia (FA) pathway isresponsible for homologous recombination repair of DNAinterstrand crosslink damage. This checkpoint in S-phaseof the cell cycle is mediated by ATR (Ataxia Telangiecta-sia Rad-3) and BRCA-1. The role of this tumour suppressorpathway in early oncogenesis is evaluated in oral dysplasia(OED) which transformed into oral squamous cell carcinoma(OSCC) by evaluating expression of FANC-D2 protein.

Methods: Forty patients with OED (and documented clin-ical outcomes/parameters) were identified from a cohort ofpatients who were prospectively recruited into a molecularbiomarker study (1996-2012). The OED in 23 patients trans-formed into OSCC while the remaining 17 patients were inremission. Archival formalin fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE)blocks from the first biopsy confirming the diagnosis of OED,immediately preceding malignant transformation and OSCCblocks, where applicable, were retrieved. 0.4 micron thick-ness sections were stained with FANC-D2, ATR and H2AX(control) antibodies. Immunohistochemistry (IHC) scoringwas performed by two clinicians, assessing nuclear and cyto-plasmic staining extent and intensity. Corresponding FFPEcores (0.5 mm diameter) were processed for protein and DNAextraction to validate the IHC findings.

Results: Based on the FANC-D2 dysplasia scoringsystem devised: a score ≥4 was associated with stable non-transforming OED (16 non-transformers vs. 5 transformers)and a score of ≤3 was associated with malignant transforma-tion of OED (7 non-transformers vs. 12 transformers) (Fisherexact test p = 0.02). ATR IHC showed staining patterns whichcorrelate with FANC-D2 expression. The findings of IHCwere validated with Western blots of protein extracts fromthe FFPE cores stained with FANC-D2 antibodies.

Conclusion: Failure to activate the FA pathway (indicatedby poor expression of FANC-D2 protein) due to defectiveDNA damage detection by ATR has been shown to be relatedto malignant transformation in OED. FANC-D2 IHC hasthe potential to influence the management of OED whereequipoise exists.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2014.07.234

P133

MD by portfolio or published work in OMFS

Barry O’Regan ∗, Rian O’Regan

Victoria Hospital, Kirkcaldy, Fife, Scotland

Introduction: The completion of a higher degree inOMFS is difficult and the window of opportunity is nar-row because of dual qualification requirements at an earlycareer stage. Many clinicians remain research motivated butare unable to commit to the timescale and demanding require-ments of a conventional research programme. Some UKMedical Schools1 currently offer an MD by portfolio of pub-lished work of “sufficient quality and academic standard” inpeer-reviewed journals1.

Aims: To compile a portfolio of theme-linked peerreviewed publications.

To develop a linking hypothesis and “uniting theme” inpersonally published material by examining postoperativecomplication rates for submission as the academic core ofan MD thesis to St Andrews University Medical School.

Method: Ten personal BJOMS publications in 6-yearperiod (2006-12) relating to two surgical techniques (retro-grade facial nerve dissection in parotidectomy and Le Fort 1tuberosity osteotomy) were chosen.

The complication rates for both techniques were comparedagainst those published for conventional methods of surgicalmanagement in the literature.

A theme related hypothesis outline entitled “An explo-ration of alternative surgical techniques in salivary glandand facial deformity surgery” was compiled, submitted andprovisionally accepted.

Results: The thesis construction roadmap and potentialpitfalls are explored. Following completion over 2 years(2011-13), an MD thesis by portfolio was successfully sub-mitted for internal and externally chosen specialty expertacademic examination.

Conclusion: The development of a portfolio of originalpublished work in peer-reviewed journals provides an encour-aging and alternative route to a higher research degree inOMFS.

Reference

1. www.st-andrews.ac.uk.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2014.07.235