68
Terminations Type MVTI Application Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Voltage Class 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV Application Range (24kV) 25 - 1000mm² 25 - 1000mm² 25 - 1000mm² 25 - 1000mm² 25 - 300mm² Termination Type Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Slide-On Slide-On Heat Shrink Heat Shrink Slide-On Material Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone EPDM EPDM Silicone Instruction Drawing Data sheet Indoor Outdoor MVTI BOM & Cost analyse No.of components Our calculated UC TC: 32.95€ TC: 27€ Tender Price Distribution Price 76,3 - 100 Installation advantage disadvantage Seal with Scotch 70 can flag when tape gets dirty Less installation steps Silicon grease is transferred to the human skin while pulling out the core Build-In sealing compound Supplier QT III M-Seal Push-On M-Seal Heat Shrink 3M M-Seal Heat Shrink QT II

MV Termination Competition Overview

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Terminations

Type MVTI

Application Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor

Voltage Class 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV

Application Range (24kV) 25 - 1000mm² 25 - 1000mm² 25 - 1000mm² 25 - 1000mm² 25 - 300mm²

Termination Type Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Slide-On Slide-On Heat Shrink Heat Shrink Slide-On

Material Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone EPDM EPDM Silicone

Instruction Drawing

Data sheet Indoor Outdoor MVTI

BOM & Cost analyse

No.of components

Our calculated UC TC: 32.95€ TC: 27€

Tender Price

Distribution Price 76,3 - 100

Installation

advantage

disadvantage

Seal with

Scotch 70 can

flag when tape

gets dirty

Less

installation

steps

Silicon grease

is transferred to

the human skin

while pulling out

the core

Build-In sealing

compound

Supplier

QT III M-Seal Push-On M-Seal Heat Shrink

3M

M-Seal Heat Shrink

QT II

Tyco

Quicker than

heatshrink

Less chanche

to get

contamination

inside the

termination

Clear instruction

Clear

instruction

quality to

heavily reliant

onto the

installer skills easy to store

Customer

MVTO IXSU OXSU TFTI TFTO SEI SEF CHE-I CHE-F CAE-I

Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor

12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV

25 - 300mm² 25 - 1200mm² 25 - 1200mm² 25 - 630mm² 25 - 630mm² 25 - 630mm² 10 - 1000mm² 10 - 1000mm² 10 - 630 mm²

Slide-On Heat Shink Heat Shink Slide-On Slide-On Slide On Hybrid Hybrid Slide-OnSilicone Silicone Elastomer Silicone Silicone

MVTO-5131 IXSU 5131 OXSU-F5131 TFTO-5131 SEI 24 SEF

CHE-F 24kV 70-

240

MVTO IXSU OXSU TFTI TFTO SEI SEF CHE-I CHE-F CAE-I

BOM BOM BOM BOM BOM BOM

26 19 25 24 35

29.9 € 6.4 € 31.5 € 20.4 € 18.0 € 32.4 € 33.0 €

35 - 45€129 € 133 € 75 € 69 € 72 €

Need a flame

lots of

components

Mastic tape

pushed out of

position during

body installation

high application

range coverage

difficult to install

(but easier than

NKT )

complicate

instruction ( less

pictures / more

text )

Suedkabel (ABB)Tyco Cellpack

easy installation

Clearer

instruction (

cmpared to NKT

)

easier to push

the body onto

the cable(

compared to

other slide on

term.)

quality to heavily

reliant onto the

installer skills

Cleaning tissue

delivered with kit

quality to heavily

reliant onto the

installer skills

Difficult to shrink

in termination

boxes

no good feeling

during body

installation ( fear

to wrap off the

stress control

mastic )

installation of lug

sealing tube to

difficult

separate skirts

red sealing

mastic is thin and

tears easily

E.ON

CAE-F AIN AFN ITK OTK TI TO IAEM FAEM STI

Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Indoor

12/24kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36, 42kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV

35 - 630 mm² 35 - 630 mm² 25 - 800 mm² 50 - 630 mm² 25 - 500mm² 25 - 500mm² 25 - 300mm² 25 - 300mm² 35 - 630mm²

Slide-On Slide-On Slide-On Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Slide-On Slide-On Slide-On Slide-On Slide-OnSilicone Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone Silicone

CAE-F 24kV 70-

240

OTK 24 DD 150-

240 TO 24

CAE-F AIN AFN ITK OTK TI TO IAEM FAEM STI

BOM BOM BOM

24 14 9 + lugs

22.8 € 21.6 €

35 - 45€ 35 - 45€117 € 57 € 132 € 210 € 120 €

MISLEADING

INSTRUCTION

Many

installation steps short termination

easier to push

the body onto

the cable(

compared to

other slide on

term.)

Build-In sealing

compound

one pcs

termination body

Lovink PrysmianNKTNexans (Euromold)Cellpack

useable with all

cable lugs

Measurements

can lead to

installation

mistakes

requires

experience

many installation

steps ( tricky)

longer

termination

installation force

depending on

cross section of

cable and lug

palm width

REQUIRES

TOOLS FOR

INSTALLATION no heat/no flame

instruction not

very clear

short termination

Manufacturing /

Installation

traceability

compared to CS

more space for

installation is

required

LOT OF

GREASE

REQUIRED

more waste

material

possible to

transfer

contaminants

into the

termination

quality to heavily

reliant onto the

installer skills

limited

application

range

quality to heavily

reliant onto the

installer skills

grease under the

skirts ( need to

clean )

quality to heavily

reliant onto the

installer skills

STE CIT COT CT HIT TIS TES

Outdoor Indoor Outdoor Outdoor Indoor Indoor Outdoor

12, 24, 36kV 11 kV 11kV 33kV 11kV 12, 24, 36kV 12, 24, 36kV

35 - 630mm² 50 - 400mm² 50 - 400mm² 50 - 630² 16 - 400mm² 35 - 630mm² 35 - 630mm²

Slide-On Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Cold Shrink Heat Shrink Heat Shrink Heat ShrinkSilicone Silicone Silicone Silicone

TES

STE CIT COT CT HIT TIS TES

23.76 €

32 €

ElconPrysmian

Nexans OTK 24 DD 150 - 240

Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3

Termination body

Lower part

2 3

Termination body

Upper part

3 1 Mastic

4 1 Installation hook

5 2 Lubricant

6 3 cleaning tissue

7 1 Installation instruction (D)

10 3

11 1

Packaging Carton

Kitting

Details Cost est.

0.20 €

0.10 €

0.80 €

0.03 €

Installation instruction (D) 0.10 €

1.00 €

1.00 €

3.23 €

Cellpack CAE-F 24kV 70 - 240

Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3 Termination body

2 6 Sealing tape

3 3 Lubricant

4 1 Applicator AH2

5 1 Applicator MH2

6 3 Plastic collar

7 1 Insulation tape

8 2 gloves

9 1 abrasive cloth

10 3 cleaning tissue

11 1 intallation instruction

Packaging

Kitting

Details Cost est.

Molded termination body

with Refractive SC

element: 207g 14.74 €

6 x 250mm x 25mm x 0,8 1.20 €

3 x 8g 2.50 €

16 g 0.86 €

10 g 0.84 €

0.10 €

19m x 15mm 0.10 €

0.01 €

0.10 €

0.30 €

4 DIN A4 instructions: DE,

GB, ES, FR 0.30 €

420 x 200 x 100mm 1.00 €

0.75 €

22.80221

Pirelli ELTImb Indoor 35-240mm²Home

Picture Pos QTY Description Details

1 3 Termination body Silicon (?) 103g

2 3 Skirts Silicon (?) 23g

3 3 Applicator Caps 17g

4 Sealing mastic 300 x 25

5 1 Lubricant 50 ml

6 3 Gloves

7 1 intallation instruction

Packaging 310 x 220 x 110

Kitting

Cost est.

12.82 €

2.73 €

1.72 €

1.60 €

3.00 €

0.03 €

0.10 €

1.00 €

0.75 €

23.76 €

Cellpack Hybrid CHE-F 24kV 70-240 mm²Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3 Termination body

2 9 Silikon Skirts

3 1 Applicator AH3

4 3 Stress Control

6 1 Lubricant GM1

7 1 Insulation tape

8 9 Sealing tape

9 1 abrasive cloth

10 3 cleaning tissue

11 1 intallation instruction

Packaging

Kitting

Details Cost est.

Heatshrink termination

body 147 g 3.70 €

27 g 18.15 €

0.86 €

Moulded SC to push on 26

g 5.05 €

8g 0.85 €

19m x 15mm 0.10 €

150mm x 25mm x 3 1.80 €

25 x 300 0.10 €

0.30 €

4 DIN A4 instructions: DE,

GB, ES, FR 0.30 €

720 x 150 x 130mm 1.00 €

0.75 €

32.96203

Cellpack Hybrid CHE-F 36kV 500 - 800 mm²Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3 Termination body

2 9 Silikon Skirts

3 1 Applicator AH3

4 3 Stress Control

6 1 Lubricant GM1

7 1 Insulation tape

8 9 Sealing tape

9 1 abrasive cloth

10 3 cleaning tissue

11 1 intallation instruction

Packaging

Kitting

converted to 24kV

Details Cost est.

Heatshrink termination

body 200g 2.07 €

55g 20.43 €

0.87 €

Moulded SC to push on

120g 9.84 €

8g 0.85 €

19m x 15mm 0.10 €

150mm x 25mm x 3 1.80 €

25 x 300 0.10 €

0.30 €

4 DIN A4 instructions: DE,

GB, ES, FR 0.30 €

720 x 150 x 130mm 1.00 €

0.75 €

38.4065

NKT TO 24 150² 20kV Outdoor

Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3 Termination body

2 1 Sealing mastic

3 1 Lubricant

4 3 Polybag

5 3 Earthing cable lug

6 3 Cable lug

1 intallation instruction

Packaging Plastic bag with 2 chambers

Kitting 1,5 * 30€/h

Details Cost est.

Geometric stress controll.

Weight 253g 18.14 €

20g 0.20 €

40 g 2.00 €

0.15 €

0.10 €

Plastic bag with 2 chambers 0.20 €

0.80 €

21.59 €

Tyco TFTO-5131 70 - 150mm²

Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3 Termination body

2 6

Sealing mastic 310 x

30mm

3 3

Sealing mastic 160 x

110

3 3 Lubricant

4 3 Polybag

5 3 Cleaning pads

6 3 Gloves

1 intallation instruction

Packaging Carton 400 / 170 / 130

Kitting 2,5min x 30€/h

Details Cost est.

176g Elastomer push on

bodies without stress

controll 15.02 €

1.50 €

1.00 €

0.60 €

0.15 €

0.30 €

0.03 €

0.10 €

Carton 400 / 170 / 130 0.40 €

1.25 €

20.35 €

Tyco OXSU-5131 70 - 150mm²

Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3 HS-Tubes

2 9 Skirts

3 3 Yellow taps

4 3 Red tape

5 1 intallation instruction

Packaging Carton 600 / 170 / 130

Kitting 4min x 30€/h

Details Cost est.

HS-Tube 440mm 50/16

Dual layer 3.94 €

23.62 €

0.90 €

0.50 €

German 0.15 €

Carton 600 / 170 / 130 0.40 €

2.00 €

31.51435

Tyco IXSU F5131 70-240 mm²Home

Picture Pos QTY Description Details

1 3 HS-Tubes

HS-Tube 660 mm 50/16

Dual layer, 180 g

3 3 Yellow taps

4 3 Red tape

5 1 intallation instruction German

Packaging Carton 390 / 130 / 110

Kitting

Cost est.

3.14 €

0.90 €

0.50 €

0.15 €

1.00 €

0.75 €

6.436622

Südkabel SEI 12kV indoor 70-150 mm²Home

Picture Pos QTY Description Details

1 3 Termination body

Silicone push on bodies

with stress controll, 121g,

210 mm lenght

2 3 Silicone Tubes

3 x size 4 50g

3 2 Silicone Grease 2 x 15g

4 1 Vinyl Tape

6 2 Cleaning tissues

7 1 abrasive cloth

8 1 Intallation instruction

Packaging Carton 300 / 230 / 85 (high quality)

Cost est.

12.83 €

1.50 €

1.50 €

0.10 €

0.10 €

0.10 €

0.10 €

1.00 €

0.75 €

17.98467

Südkabel SEF 24 95 - 240mm²

Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3 Termination body

2 9 Silicone Tubes

3 3 Hose Clip

3 2 Silicone Grease

4 1 Vinyl Tape

5 1 Mastic tape

6 3 Cleaning tissues

7 1 abrasive cloth

8 1 Intallation instruction

Packaging Carton 340 / 300 / 130 (high quality)

5min x 30€/h

Details Cost est.

Silicone push on bodies

with stress controll, 214g,

Refractive SC 21.98 €

3 x size 3 36g

3 x size 4 50g

3 x size 5 70g 4.00 €

0.30 €

2 x 15g 1.50 €

0.10 €

0.20 €

0.10 €

0.10 €

0.10 €

Carton 340 / 300 / 130 (high quality) 1.50 €

2.50 €

32.38065

Tyco MVTO-5131 95 - 300mm²

Home

Picture Pos QTY Description

1 3 Termination body

2 6

Sealing mastic 310 x

30mm

3 1 Binding wire 2,5m

3 6 Lubricant

4 3 Polybag

5 3 Cleaning pads

6 3 Gloves

1 intallation instruction

Packaging Carton 400 / 170 / 130

Kitting 2,5min x 30€/h

Measured dimensions of 5131

Dimensions: Appliction range expansion rate

Inner diameter mm

19 21 11%

37 95%

Wall thickness

- Stress Controll 5.0

- Insulation on SC 3.7

- Insulation (skirt area) 3

Details Cost est.

Geometric stress controll.

Weight 290g 24.44 €

1.50 €

0.50 €

1.20 €

0.15 €

0.30 €

0.03 €

0.10 €

Carton 400 / 170 / 130 0.40 €

1.25 €

29.87 €

Home

Picture Pos QTY Description Details Cost est.

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

Packaging

Kitting

0