26
Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory Large Scale Computing and Storage Requirements for Nuclear Physics (NP): Target 2017 April 2014 1 Monday, April 28, 2014

Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Nuclear Forces from LatticeQuantum Chromodynamics

Martin J. SavageInstitute for Nuclear Theory

Large Scale Computing and Storage Requirements for Nuclear Physics (NP):

Target 2017April 2014 1

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 2: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Solve QCD

From QCD to Nuclei

2

FRIB

Lattice QCDMonday, April 28, 2014

Page 3: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Core-Collapse Supernova

Black-Hole orNeutron Star ?

SN1987a

(Mezzacappa et al)

Y nnK

Nuclear EoS

n

nn

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 4: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Spin-pairing Shell-structure Vibrational and rotational

excitations

ΛQCD

mu

ΛQCD

md

ΛQCD

ms

ΛQCD

αe

Small number of input parameters responsible for all of strongly interacting matter

Quarks and

GluonsProton

Nucleus

The Structure and Interactions of Matter from QCD

4

Quantum Chromodynamics

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 5: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Refining Nuclear Forces and Multi-Nucleon Interactions:

Enhanced Predictive Capabilities

QCD to constrain coefficientsi) Verification and/or better experiment (?)ii) Inaccessible to experiment, e.g. nnn, nnnn

iii) Number of coefficients for required level of precisioniii) and/or direct calculation of desired quantity 5

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 6: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

l Nuclear physics exhibits fine-tuningsl Why ??l Range of fundamantal parameters to produce sufficient carbon ?l Solving QCD is the only way to provide precise constraints.

The ONLY way to understand Fine-Tunings of our Universe

Parameter/Gauge Landscape

6

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 7: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

NSAC Milestone

By 2017 : calculations at mpi ~ 220 MeV (140 MeV ?) will provide first direct connection to nuclear forces in nature.

[ assumed Moore’s Law increases ]

2008

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 8: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Lattice QCD

�θ̂� ∼�

DUµ θ̂[Uµ] det[κ[Uµ]] e−SY M

Monte-Carlo Evaluation of QCD Path Integral

Lattice Spacing :

1/Λχa << mπL >> 2πLattice Volume :

Effective Field Theory gives form of extrapolation a = 0 and L =∞

→ 1N

N�

gluon cfgs

θ̂ [Uµ]Gauge ConfigurationsPropagators

(Nearly Continuum) (Nearly Infinite Volume)

Not Quite QCD !

Systematically Extrapolate

8

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 9: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

SciDAC-3 NP/HEP

9

capacity hardwareJLab effort is critical for NPLQCD

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 10: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

mπ ~ 800 MeV

Nuclei

10

d nn 3He 4He n� �3 H �

3 He �3He �

4 He H�dib n� ��4 He

1�0�

12

0�

1�

12

32

12

32

0�

0�

0�

1�

0�

0�

s�0 s��1 s��2

2�Body 3�Body 4�Body

�160

�140

�120

�100

�80

�60

�40

�20

0

�E�MeV

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 11: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Deuteron and Helium

11

prelim

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 12: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

LQCD to EFT to Nuclei

LQCD Nuclei for 800 MeV pions• Fit 2-body and 3-body LQCD bindings• Predict 4-body, c/w LQCD prediction• Predict A>>4, beyond present LQCD capabilities

Barnea, Conressi, Gazit, Pederiva and van Kolck

arXiv:1311.4966

``First Contact`` LQCD

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 13: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Desired Resources2014-2017

13

From QCD to Nuclei

2018!

Moore’s Law from 2011

Moore’s Law + possible Algorithm Development2014

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 14: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Roadblocks of the Present

14

> 1 year behindschedule

Does NOT include shared configuration productionMonday, April 28, 2014

Page 15: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

USQCD Proposed Production2014-2019

15

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 16: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Workflow

• Transitioning from sequential to integrated production • Includes GPUs for propagators• Still need to reduce disk footprint - being done

Emmanuel ChangSciDAC-3 Postdoc

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 17: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Workflow (2)

Emmanuel ChangSciDAC-3 Postdoc

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 18: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Data Projections

• Physics ``Noise’’ in nuclear correlation functions • variance dictated by pion mass : lighter = noisier

• Remains a petascale problem, as estimated in 2005, 2009, 2011Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 19: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Data Projections (2)

2012-2014 production

243x64, 323x64, 483x96 lattices , ~ 104

500K, 200K, 130K sets

e.g., 323x64

cfg : 1.7 GB2 prop : 13 GB2 blocks : 4.4 GBcorrelators : 4.2 MBSaved ~ 17 TB + 1.5 TB<I/O> ~ 0.14 GB/s

2 props/set

USQCD : 41 M CPUand 220K GPU

NERSC : 30 MXSEDE : 20 M

• Checkpointing• implicit in workflow• manuel restart at present

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 20: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Data Projections (3)

2014-2017 production

643x128 lattices , ~ 5 103

6M sets

963x192 lattices , ~ 5 103

6M sets

cfg : 27 GB2 prop : 208 GB2 blocks : 8.8 GBcorrelators : 8.4 MBSave ~ 135 TB + 50 TB<I/O> ~ 43 GB/s

cfg : 137 GB2 prop : 1 TB2 blocks : 13.2 GBcorrelators : 12.6 MBSave ~ 685 TB + 76 TB<I/O> ~ 195 GB/s

writing everything = Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 21: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Compute

NERSC is ~50% of Nuclear Forces measurement resources

Current NERSC

>16K cores36 hr run times80 runs/yrchroma, usqcd stack, apprec

86 TB reads and 2 TB out64 GB/node and 50TB global

200 TB storageMonday, April 28, 2014

Page 22: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Compute (2)

•The highlighted production in the USQCD plan requires 2.8 Bn core-hrs before 2017• propagators• blocks• contractions

• requires ~ 900M core-hrs/year • partial co-production with other cold projects• < 500 K cores, wallclock limited, as many as needed• I/O will be integrated database(s), SQL, hdf5

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 23: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Compute (3)

• Chroma exploits GPU• development is ongoing• no openCL• OpenMP in chroma• will use soon

• Porting to MIC • not yet, will happen

• USQCD/JLab spearheading porting (project non-specific)• SciDAC-3

0 512 1024 1536 2048 2560 3072 3584 4096 4608Titan Nodes (GPUs)

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

TFLO

PS

BiCGStab: 723x256DD+GCR: 723x256BiCGStab: 963x256DD+GCR: 963x256

Strong Scaling, QUDA+Chroma+QDP-JIT(PTX)

B. Joo, F. Winter (JLab), M. Clark (NVIDIA)

JLab Groupsee Robert Edwards presentation

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 24: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Compute (4)Things to do ?

• NERSC• People on-site [ university ] to help port

• DOE+ASCR• Local development clusters• People on-site [ university ] to help port• Full SciDAC-3 support, more postdocs and students

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 25: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

Closing Remarks

Lattice QCD, combined with chiral EFT and nuclear many-body techniques, will provide first principles predictive capabilities for Nuclear Physics

25

Continuing and increasing large scale NERSC resources are critical to refining nuclear forces

Monday, April 28, 2014

Page 26: Nuclear Forces from Lattice Martin J. Savage Quantum ... · Nuclear Forces from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics Martin J. Savage Institute for Nuclear Theory ... Pederiva and van Kolck

THE END

26

Monday, April 28, 2014