7/21/2019 Param Prasang

1/94

D n w d j t _ w d r u p D s b r d m

V d r m d r t b _ i v d _ d n d e

^ u p u n d e d B d t j d\ d e o b j - ?

H b d r c b d e n

< / 4 : / < 6 4 9

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

2/94

6

vc_h Tnbhcsd nc lruc vcacN3 _ an 3`c rqI`chs ay, ncslX tx` u`bdD ucunesg us lkns tgco isdmk ew/c ks Bchs nQcshs nsjh xqyco nc ,n Twy Bcstc atknc vcc3 Acc an atk jznch nQcshs nsewc ks Bchs h`us nsocgtwe lkns jh lk Twy ncs hSc esusks u nsgy ewc nb h{cc `cs h`b _ oaZnmkks kqxY/c Bcb T_y h`b _D mkb jznch ishs 3`c vcus ks vcjncs ncslX `cau u`bd j qpsxb] oaZnk\kdx vc_h Ccu nc ycBc aiysxcD

3` esSc kchs jbh vc_h Tnbh ki5 x3s an g` ncslX kc/cch.c ldkcu u`bd] ncslX j qpc qvcTnbh _D muycsxcsd us munsjck tcnh n`c & Uvcj kpiqp ncslX ak) jq#c _d! vcl3s] lk uxh isd`iycsx vcjnc Scqcb&Scqcb Kgcxr nhrs _dD*

ozpchb nb eaQ

hcg.c to kbrctb ncs mLcnh ys x3c ro hcipYez tb ncs hcKrs nc jrc pys] lk S3cy kskbrctb us vjus x`us ubps jfAgb jh Tsdn ae3s AcsD to jzBcq ns `cAc isd gs x`us vc, ro mY`csdusy{i.ctb ncs gs x`us aeScc3sD jwEus yxs an N3c rqi lu x`ucsd ncs j`pcurs `cs[

y{i.ctb us tgco ae3c&

uc d tcucai ns3fhd] uc d tcucai nq.MysDuwjqhs \gaBctcucai au\3d jcecaBcgYeucr~DD

vAccXr~ Uns3wh vc_h nq.My] tcs an jh ns Bccx ns vydnch _d] mY sd i_d u`bd j`pcurcD i_dicrc kbrc ns uwjqhcsd ncs tcurc w] N3csdan hcst muns ph.ccsd nb gYeuc nhrs ki3 i_d mY sd esScc nhrcAccD**

,n och kcohirb vcHi isd lk ycsn jh ppcX pybD ocjw rcs cdarnchb Acs `bD gs ocsy mLs &Uy{i.c nc 3` nAcu k`b u`bd yxrcD hcst&hcst kcAc h`nh Bcb kbrc nc iqSc u`bd esScuc] 3` n_kcvc'p3X[* aTh agucsoc ks jwEc & Ulk jh rqI`chc N3c vaBcjzc3 _[*

agucsoc us tgco ae3c & Uy{i.c ozpchb Acs] lkay, kbrc nc iqSc mY`csdus esScc u`bd AccD 3`efaQ vcjncs ucjkde _] lkay, vcj mk gcN3 ncs ucjkde nhrs _dD mk efaQ ks g` ucjkde nhus3csR3 `b _D K=b nc iqSc u`bd esScus nc au3i ozpchb ncs ysuc] lkisd xyrb u`bd _D jhYrq i_d lkgcN3 nc ewkhc vAcX ysrc w an hci] kbrc ns jar] y{i.ctb ks jwErs _dD lknc vAcX _ an hci Bcbvjub j\ub ns x`us j`pcurs u`bd AcsD iryo] jar Bcb j\ub ns x`us u`bd j`pcurc _D auncX 3`

aunyc an kbrc vc_h hci] ecsucsd vuckNr AcsD ecsucsd ,n ewkhs nb vcar nb vcsh u`bd esScrs Acs]

,n&ewkhs ncs oz8j esScrs AcsD jhYrq y{i.c kbrc ns ph.ccsd nb jwtc nhrc Acc] jcecaBcgdeu nhrc Acc]3cau mjckuc ns rc_h jh ph.ccar ncs iwacX ki5nh mjckuc nhrc AccD*lruc kqYeh Bcc3 kqunh ocjw us n`c & Urqi rcs ccK=&gpucsd nc Swco kqYeh opcg nhuc

tcurs `csD 3` Lbn Bcb rcs _D t`c rn kIBcg `cs] ccK=gpucsd nc vVEc vAcX nhuc pca`,D*

jzi nc Kg8j

,n och hcao3c ns jck ,n Tnbh vc3cD hcao3c atk ciXxzdAc ncs j;+ h`b Acb mkisd ks mkus,n jdaNr ncs ncQ ae3cD /ciXxzYAccsd ncs ncslX ncQrc u`bdD mk Tnbh us g` anrco j;+bD j;+us ns oce

mkus hcao3c ks n`c] Uankus rqI`chs /ciXxzYAc ncs uQ nh ae3c[ esSccs] lkisd ,n yclu nQb qlX _Dlks ankus ncQb _[*

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

41/94

>4

hcao3c us n`c] Ui_dus `b ncQb _D* ocr 3` Acb an mk jdaNr isd ayScc qvc Acc an c_rcu ks7cf.cc nhcsD to ks i_dus lk jdaNr ncs j;+c _] i_d iqany isd jM+ x3b wD atk aeu ks ishs iu isdjhic\ic ns jzar jzsi txc _ mk aeu ks ishs Bcbrh ks 7cf.cc agybu `cs x3b _D i_d vxh pc wrcs Bcbankb ks 7cf.cc u`bd nh knrbD vxh c_rcu Bcb ishs kcius ScM+c `cs tc3s rcs Bcb i_d mks jzsi `b nhknrb wD ishs jck ncslX mjc3 u`bd h` x3c _( N3csdan i_d vcjncs 7cf.cc n8] lkns j`ys ishs jck

7cf.cc `csub pca`,D u`bd rcs i_d 7cf.cc n8xb n`c ks vc_h n_ks[ ,n `b e3 isd jzsi vc_h 7cf.cc ,n kcAcn_ks L`h knrs _dD atknc e3 jzsi ks Bch pqnc _ g` akTX jzsi nhuc tcurc _D mks 3` u`bdaeScclX jM+rc an nc_u mks jzsi nhrc _ vc_h nc_u 7cf.ccD jzsi nhuc mknc KgBccg ou tcrc _D mknsay, jzzzsi nhuc `b vcude _D to e3 jzsi ks Bch tc,xc ro g` 7cf.cc nhus isd vkiAcX `cs tc,xcD

vkyb jhi`dk

nccb isd ,n Kgcib agcq)cuYe jhi dk `cs x3s _dD oM+s&oM+s hcts&htgcM+s muns ac3 AcsD gs AcsBcb mVp ncsaQ ns i`cjq#cD ,n och ncibhns i`chctc munc ecXu nhus x3sD ococ vnsys vjus

nihs isd jydx jh aghcticu AcsD munc h`u&k`u jydx&xybps] kcsus&pceb nb gKrq,] oscnbirbncybusd vcae esScnh hctc nc aeicx pNnh Scc x3cD gs ScM+s&ScM+s jh&ubps mu pbtcsd ncs au`chrs h s]rBcb Kgcib tb us 7cdQb otclX vc_h muns ecs psys ScQ~ g`c j qp x3sD mY`csdus ncibh i`chctc ks n`can rqi vBcb tcvcs] ny och` ots vcuc ro rqI`chc jhi dk aiysxcD psycsd us i`chctc ncs Bcst ae3cD

ewkhs aeu koshs Kgcib tb us vjus nihs nc kchc kcicu oc`h i_ecu isd aunygc ae3cD nqynihc Sccyb nh ae3c x3c vc_h Scqe gs ,n ydxcsQb j`us oc`h aib isd o_L x3sD BcNrcsd ncs vcescae3c an gs c`h ks aBcScidxcsd ncs oqyc yc3sdD rqhr g`c k_nM+csd idxrs vc x3sD Kgcib tb us nqykcicu mY sd es ae3sD Lbn och` ots hctc g`c vc3cD ococ us mY` sds aib isd vjus kcAc o_Lus ncs n`cDocsys & Uvcvcs] esSccs LcQ ks vjus jhi dk ncs!*

gs esh rn muks k\kdx nhrs h s rBcb g`c nccb&uhsc vc x3sD gs Bcb Kgcib tb ns BcNr AcsDmY ds g` utchc esScnh _hcub qlXD mY`csdus rqhr vceib Bcstnh octch ks kchs kctcs&kcicu ixgc3sDj`ys nb rh` nihs ncs jydx] ncybu] xybpcsd vcae ks kqka^tr nh ae3c x3c ro mY`csdus Kgcib tbks gK=&/cch.c nhns g`c aghcticu `csus nb agurb nbD

Kgcib tb krs q, ocsys & Uycs! aTh rcs rqius iq5s vjus t_kc hctc ouc `b ae3cD i_dus lkocow ncs aiyus ns ay, gs kchb pbtsd yqQc eb AcbdD nch.c] luns vuqkch jhi dk rcs udxc vc_h eahez

`csrc _D*ncibh ns i`chctc us vjub Bcwy Kgbnch nb vc_h Kgcib tb ks {cic icxbD munb ki5 isdvc x3c an jhi dk ncslX j`ucgc vAcgc h`u&k`u u`bd `csrcD g` rcs agpch vc_h g_hcR3 nb g_kb

pb /cch.cc _ atkns ay, lu pbtcssd nc `cssuc 3c u `csuc ncslX i`g u`bd hScrcD

jdaMr nb jxMb

,n jdaMr vjus akh jh Bcchb jxM+b ocd/cs q, AccD jxM+b nc njM+c pQnbyc AccD mks esScnhankb pcsh nc tb yypc3cD kcspc] lks ys ysus ks nibt&jctcic ko ou tc3sxcD ok N3c Acc] jdaMr

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

42/94

>?

TwQ oMb oyc

ankb 7cus tdxy isd ;sh kb ycs s nb nqZ`caM+3c tibu ks aunybD muncs esScnh nqy jsM+ hcsusyxsD ,n jqhcus jsM+ us jwEc an rqi ko N3csd hcsrs `cs[ mY`csdus n`c an `i konc ncy vc x3c _Dt`c ,n Bcb nqZ`cM+b `csrb _ rcs g` o qr ks jsM+csd ncs ncQ axhcrb _D 3`c rcslrub kchb nqZ`caM+3cauny vc3bd] vo `ichs opus nb nc_u mIibe _ [

ow;+c jsM+ ocsyc] U7coM+cvcs irD luisd vBcb `ichb tcr nc ncslX aiyc u`bd _ vAccXr~ luisd ynM+bnc odsQc vBcb u`bd jM+c _D torn `ichc Bcseb kcAcb luks uc aiysxc rorn lu nqZ`caM+3csd ks `ichcnqE u`bd aoxM+sxcD*

vr% to vcjk nb TwQ `csrb _ rBcb ocr aoxM+rb _D kdxLu itowr `cs rcs uqnkcu nc ncslXScrhc u`bd h`rcD

iacjwtc nc h`K3

Kgcib aggsncuYe tb vygh hc^3 ns ebgcu o`ceqh ns 3`c L`hs q, AcsD i`chct idxy akd

o`ceqh ebgcu kc`o nb Scoh jcnh muns varaAc i`cjdaMr kdY3ckb nc e'cXu nhus jcchsD jz.ccicaenhns mY`csdus Kgcib tb ncs vjus kibj vcku ae3cD gcrcXycj ns i isd mY`csdusjwEc & UKgcib tb]iwacXjwtc isd ishc raun Bcb ag'gck u`bd _D i_dynM+b] j\Ach] aib /ccrq nb oub qlX iwacX3csd nb jwtcnhuc auhc jcxyju ki5rc wD*

Kgcib tb j`ys rcs AccsM+c ks] aTh ebgch jh yQnrs q, i`chctc ns ,n ap= jh munb efa"QjM+bD mY`cs dus mks mrhgc3c vc_h `cAc isd ysnh g`c mjaKAcr ewkhs ycsxcsd ks jwEc & U3` i`chctc kc`onc ap= _ u!* kous `c n`cD ro mk ap= ncs Kgcib tb us T'cX jh /ch ae3c vc_h mk jh ycsxcsd ncs

Acwnus ncs n`cD kBcb agKi3jwgXn Kgcib tb nb vcsh esScrs h sD Kgcib tb }chc g_kc och&och n s tcusns oce muisd ks ,n G3aNr us n`c & Ui`c\iu~] 3` `ichs i`chctc kc`o nc ap= _D `ichs ay, 3`jw 3 _D `i lks jzaraeu jz.cci nhrs _ dD vcj Bcyc ,skb vjicujwgXn ocr `ichs kcius N3csd nh h s _d[*

Kgcib tb us hctc ncs kIocsa/cr nhrs q, n`c an vBcb vcjns ycsxcsd us vcjns ap= jh lkay,u`bd Acwnc an munb efa"Q isd ap= nc vjicu vcjnc vjicu `csxcD gs `b u`bd] vcj Bcb 3ae mk ap=nc vjicu `csrs esScrs rcs vcjncs vg'3 oqhc yxrcD vr% vcj kBcb iwacXjwtn rcs _dD lkb jznch 3aencslX jwtn iwacX vAcgc rKgbh nb jwtc nhrc _ rcs g` ynM+b vAcgc ncxt nb jwtc u`bd nhrc oaZnmkisd vjus Bcxgcu nc Bccg hScnh jwtc nhrc _D

i`chctc Kgcib tb nb ocrcsd ks jzBccagr q,D munb iwacXjwtc ns jzar vucKAcc Sc\i `cs x3bvc_h gs muns H)cyq `cs x3sD

ankb nc aey rcMusksgr rcMuc vVEc

ococ Thbe ,n mVp ncsaQ ns Tnbh `cs x3s _dD vjus oVpcsd ncs kcAc ay3s ,n oqa;+3c tysob ncjzkce ococ ns ay, ys x3bD ococ mk aeu gzr isd AcsD mY`csdus mknb tysob yc_Qc ebD oqa;+3cTwQ&TwQnh hcs jM+bD vjus oVps nc `cAc Accis] tysob ay3s hcsrb&hcsrb g` 7ch yc_Qus yxbD ococ us jwEc& Urqi lruc eqScb N3csd `cs x3b[ i_d vjuc gzr n_ks rcsMw[*

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

44/94

>>

icrc us n`c & Uococ] i_dv\3Yr xhbo wD vct ishs osQs nc tYiaeu _D ishs jck o qrcsdncsaScycusBch ns j_ks u`b d _d] vr% kcspc an vcj t_ks ak) Tnbh ncs aiLclX aScycnh k_nM+csd kcicY3ycsxcsd ncs aiLclX aScycus nc jq.3 k`t isd jzcJr nh ywD anYrq ishb ,skb oeukbob an vct `b vcjncgzr `cs vc3cD 3`b kcspnh i_d vjub SccsQb anKir jh hcs h`b wD*

ococ us 5Q~ mkns `cAc ks tysob ys yb vc_h Scqcb ks Sccus yxsD icrc us n`c & Uvcjus ishs

ay, vjuc gzr N3csd rcsM+ ae3c[*ococ Thbe ocsys & Ug_kc gzr hScnh `b N3c `csxc atkns nch.c ankb nc aey QwQ tc3D aeyQwQus ks gzr QwQuc vVEc _D*

n#.cc

,n och oq)esg n`bd tc h s AcsD hcKrs isd ,n phgc`c vjub BcsM+&onah3csd ns 5q.M ncs ay3s tch`c AccD mkisd ks ,n onhb yxM+cnh py h`b AcbD oq)esg us esScc rcs gs oMs+ eq%Scb q,D mY`csdusphgc`sks jwEc & Urq5s n`c tcuc _[* mkus orc3c an iq5s kciusgcyb j`cM+b jh tcuc _D oq)esg ocsys &

Uvxh i_d lk ydxM+b onhb ncs mLcnh EcsM+ vc rcs rq5s ncslX ,rhct rcs u`bdsD* mkus n`c & Uu`bdD* gsmk ydxM+b onhb ncs mLcnh mk j`cM+b jh EcsM+ vc,D

nf.ccjX.c

ankb vc_hr us vjus incu nc nwM+c 5cM+nh Tsdnrs gNr n`c & Unf".ccjX.cD* mkb gNr uchetb m/ch ks xqth h s AcsD vjus Bcxgcu nc vjicu mY sd k`u u `cs knc vr% mY`csdus mk vc_hr ncs,n ricpc tM+ ae3cD mk vc_hr us AcJjM+ Sccnh Bcb n`c] Unf".ccjX.cD*

to uche tb o_ndqLjqhb j qps rcs N3c esScc an nqy esgrc munb audec nhrs q, n` h s Acs an

uche us oM+c SccsQc nci an3c tcs mk vc_hr ncs pcQc ichcD mknb AcJjM+ nf".c i`chct ncs yxb _Duche tb ns rcs icucs `cs'c mM+ x3sD mY`csdus Hb nf".c tb i`chct ns ph.ccsd isd akh hScnh icTb

icdxbD Bcxgcu ocsys&Uuche] rqius ishc rcs ncslX nkwh an3c u`bdD vxh pcQc ichc rcs mk vc_hr ncsichc] vr% mkb BcaNru ks tcnh {cic icxcsD uche tb mk vc_hr ns jck ec_M+s vc3s vc_h icTb icxusyxsD vc_hr us aTh g`b tgco ae3c & U3` Bcb nf".ccjX.cD* uche tb icTb icxnh jqu% o_nqdL gcjkx3sD g`c esScc an munb icTb nc S3cy vc_h AcJjM+ ichus nc nkwh ecsucsd kcnch `csnh nf".c tb nskcius ScM+s n` h s Acs] Ui`chct! `incs aLncuc orcl3s an `i n`c tc3sdD nf".c tb ocsys & Urqincs

vc_h n`c tx` orc] ecsucsd iq5isd `b kic tcvcsD*ecsucsd kwhrsd mY`bd isd kic x3bdD

kexq# nc k`chc

,n Tnbh nc psyc AccD g` hcKrs isd pyrs gNr to nBcb vjus jbEs iqM+nh esScrc ro mkstibu nb /cwy isd kec ecs vceai3csd nsjeap ~u aeScclX jM+rs AcsD g_kc esScnh g` Mh tcrc AccD mkus,n aeu vjus jbh xq# ks mknc hct tcuuc pc`c an ecs vceai3csd ns jeap ~u N3csd aeScclX jM+rs _dtoan pyrc g` vnsyc `csrc _D

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

45/94

>9

jbh kc`o us n`c & UosQs! rqi t`c n`bd tcrs `cs] i_d jbEs&jbEs rqI sd kIBccyus ns ay, `hgNrkcAc pyrc wD rqI sd nBcb vnsyc&osk`chc u`bd EcsM+rcD ke~xq#] jhic\ic vc_h ic3c] rbucsd tbg ns`hei kcAc h`rs _dD* psyc munb ocr jh oM+c `b `a"cXr vc_h vc'gKr qvcD

,n aeu g` oM+b iqkbor isd Acc] eqScb vc_h `rc'c AccD t_kc an g` j`ys vjus kcAc jbh nsjepcj esScc nhrc Acc] mk aeu mks ,n `b G3aNr nc jeap ~u aeScclX jM+cD ro g` osrh` jhs'ccu

qvcD mkus vjus icayn nb 3ce nb & U3c jbh kc`o! N3c lk iqkbor isd vcjus iq5s vnsyc EcsM+ae3c[* r\{c.c ly`ci qvc] Uu`bd osQs! kcicY3 aeucsd isd rcs i_d rqI`chs kcAc pyrc w anYrq iqkbor nsgNr i_d rqI sd vjub xcse isd mLc ysrc wD mk gNr rcs rqi ishb xcse isd `csrs `csD lkb ks akTX ishc `bje&ap ~u rqI sd uth vcrc _D*

psyc /cY3&/cY3 `csrc qvc ocsy jM+c] U3c icayn! vcj lrus is hocu _d ishs jh tcs iqkborisd iq5s mLc3s ay3s pyrs _d rcan i_d QwQ u tc] `rc'c `csnh Aci u tc!*

icrc&ajrc vjus oVps ncs kb/cs hcKrs jh rcs mdxyb jnM+cnh kcAc ay3s pyrs _d anYrq toueb&ucyc vAcgc nbpM+ ycd7cuc `csrc _ ro gs mks vjub xcse isd mLc ysrs _d vc_h Scqe pynh nbpM+ncs jch nhrs _dD g_ks `b ke~xq# nb nfjc eq%Sc&kqSc `h `cy isd `ichb kIBccy nhrb _] nsgy mujhvQwQ vcKAcc vc_h H)c `csub pca`,D

usnc nskcAc usnb nhc

,n Tnbh khs octch 3` vcgct+ yxc3c nhrc Acc an BcclX hs] usncsd nskcAc usnb nhcs] oecsdnb oeb Scqe muncs roc` nhsxbD

,n hct ehochb oM+c oeub3r Acc atks 3` kqunh kec oqhc yxrc AccD mkus Tnbh ncs it+cpSccus nb kcspb vc_h oce'cc` ks pqxyb nb an viqn Tnbh ycsxcsd ks n`c nhrc _ an oce'cc` nsiq ks oeow vcrb _D

oce'cc` g` kqunh oM+c uchct+ qvc vc_h mks mk Tnbh ncs oqyc ycus nc qNi an3cDpqxySccsh us Tnbh ncs n`yc Bcstc an Tyc hcst mknb oce'cc` ns 3`c ecgr _D mkus mk aeu Sccusisd o qr kb J3ct jngcnh mk Tnbh ncs aScyc3bD Bccstu ns oce Tnbh oce'cc` ns kIiqSc js'c qvcDoce'cc` ks ocrsd nhrs gNr Tnbh us kcspc an mkns iq ks oce'cc` ncs J3ct+ nb oeow yx knrb _lkay, mkus vjus iq ns vcxs vjub `Acsyb hSc ybD pqxySccsh us oce'cc` ncs l'cchs isd n`c anmkns iq ks oeow ns nch.c `b g` `cAc vcxs nhns ocr nh h`c _D

oce'cc` us Tnbh ks t+ocub rcs nqE u jwEc jhYrq ,n Scr mks Acicnh 'c`h ns ncsrgcy nsjck j qpcus ncs n`cD oce'cc` nc 3` au3i Acc an g` atk ankb ncs Scck luci esrc Acc mkncsncsrgcy ns uci Scr ayScnh Bcst esrc AccD pqxySccsh us ki5c an t8h Tnbh ncs oce'cc` us nqEScck luci ae3c _D mkus vcxs o;+nh Tnbh ks g` j= ys ay3c rAcc Scqe ncsrgcy ncs j qpcus pycx3cD ncsrgcy us j= Sccsynh j;+c rcs mkisd ayScc Acc an j=gc`n ncs aouc esh an3s n\y nh esucvc_h mknb Sccy isd Bcwkc Bchgcnh Bcst esucD

ncsrgcy us g_kc `b an3cD pqxySccsh ns ycSc ogcy ipcus jh Bcb mkus nqE u`bd kqucD tomknb Sccy isd Bcwkc Bchgcnh oce'cc` ns jck Bcstc ro oce'cc` jwE jM+c an mkus rcs Tnbh ncs n\ynhus ncs n`c Acc] 3` rcs mZQc `b `cs x3cD Tnbh ncs jwErcE ns ay, oqygc3c x3cD oce'cc` us n`c]

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

46/94

>1

Uiq5s rcs rqI sd n\y nhgcuc Acc( N3csdan rqi n`rs aThrs Acs an ishs iq ks oeow vcrb _ rBcb rcsrqius mk aeu iq5ks ocr nhrs gNr vjub `Acsyb iq ns vcxs nb Acb[*

Tnbh us n`c & Utuco] mk aeu Sccus isd mkus iq5s o qr kb J3ct+ aScyc3b AcbD vcjks ocrnhrs gNr iq5s yxc an ishs iq ks J3ct nb oeow vcjncs vuqapr icywi `csxb lkay, i_dus iq nsvcxs `Acsyb hScnh ocr nb AcbD h`b ocr mk j= nb rcs 3`c ks tcus ns hcKrs isd `b mk vceib us

j= j qpcus ns gcKrs iq5ks icx ay3c AccD*ewkhs ycsxcsd us Bcb oce'cc` ncs 3` ocr orc3b an Tnbh kc`o rcs koks vcgct+ es&esnh n`rspyrs _ d an Uusncsd ns kcAc usnb nhcs] oecsd nb oeb muncs Scqe roc` nhsxbD hctc ncs Tnbh nb ocrnb k\3rc jh oM+b H)c qlXD mkus n`c an kp `b mk pqxySccsh nb oeub3rb us mknb tcu ysybD

xqJr ji

,n hctc ,skc BcNr Acc an aey isd `hgNr icayn ns uci nb 3ce nhrc Acc jhYrq oc`h ks

gfac ,skb ouc hScb Acb an ycsx ki5rs Acs an g` kdkchb vc_h i`cag"c3b _D mknb hcub oM+b BcaNruAcbD mks Bcb hctc ns Bcxgr~&jzsi nb Scoh u`bd AcbD g` `is'cc lk ncsa'c'c isd h`rb Acb an ankb rh`

hctc ns iqSc ks Bcxgcu ns uci nc mVpch.c `csD,n aeu lcTcn ks kcs3s isd hctc ns iqSc ks Bcxgcu nc uci auny x3cD mk aeu hcub nb

Scq'cb nc aLncuc u h`cD mkus uNnchs otgc, vc_h oM+b Scq'cb iuclXD mkns ,skc nhus nc nch.c jwEusjh g` ocsyb an vct hcr vcjns iq ks Bcxgcu nc uci aunyc Acc lkay, `ius 3` Scq'cb iuclX _D hctc us n`c an to iwyjzc.c] BcxgYuci `b 'chbh ks auny x3c rcs aTh 3` `M~Mb&icdk nc

ycsAcM+c ank nci nc _[ ,skc n`nh mkus rqhYr 'chbh \3cx ae3cD oc`h ks kcdkcahn ebScrc qvcBcb Bctu isd mknb pb aKAcar AcbDvYr%nh.c ks jag= vc_h oc`h nb eqau3cd ks vutcuD ,skc vVEc mec`h.c o qr ni `b esScus

ns ay, aiyrc _DatY`csd ncs l'n kcaen _ gcs no Tah3ce nhrs _dD

yocsd js iq hs&Sccics'cb] aeycsd isd 3ce nhrs _dDD

icucjicu ksjh

,n och Hb hcinf".c jhi dk nss opju ns ankb kcAcb us ycsxcsd ks n`c an Uvhs] 3` N3ckc/cq _] i_d mks opju ks tcurc wD akTX ;csdx hpcnh koncs Lxrs pyrc _D pycs] i_d vBcb mkncjcsy Sccsyrc wD* g` muks aiyus x3cD mk ki3 k\kdx `cs h`c AccD g` kons obp isd `b Hbhcinf".c jhi dk ks n`us yxc an Uvhs xcsnypde] N3c ;csdx hpc hScc _] i_d rshc ko pah= tcurc wDycsxcsd ncs Bczairnh vo rw i`c\ic ou o_Lc _[*

Hb jhi dk i`chct ocsys] UBc_3c] rqi Lbn n`rs `cs] jhYrq 5cM+w xYeb vc_h vjag= `csrb qlX Bcbewkhcsd nc 7ch rcs kcT nh `b esrb _D* lk ocr nc mk jh ,skc vkh jM+c an g` Hb hcinf".cjhi dk ns ph.ccsd jh axhnh {cic icxus yxcD Hb jhi dk i`chct tb ncs icu&vjicu nc raunBcb agpch u`bd AccD gs kVps i`cjq#"c AcsD

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

47/94

>0

3cx{cidg`cI3i

,n /ccsob ueb anuchs njM+s /ccsnh kwScus ncs ae, q, AccD ,n i`c\ic hci/cqu nhrs m/ch ksxqth h s AcsD vjub cqu isds gs lk neh i`o Acs an mY sd nqE kw5 u`bd h`c AccD gs /ccsob nsnjM+csd jhp;+nh pys tc h s AcsD /ccsob vjus kcT njM+csd nc uqnkcu esScnh xqKks isd ,n lXdQ nc QqnM+c mLcnhi`c\ic ncs ichus py jM+cD vjus jzsi isd mk neh i`o mk kc/cq nb `cau esScnh Bcxgcu p ysnhichus ec_M+ jM+s] anYrq nqE `b {c.c oce gs yc_Q Bcb x3sD jwEc x3c an jzBcq ec_M+s rcs lk neh Acs icucsankb jh oM+s nqajr `csd anYrq rqhr `b yc_Q N3csd vc3s[

ocsys & Uishc ,n BcNr i`c\ic ishs ucicqu isd osScoh ,n /ccsob ns njM+csd ncs hc_derc qvc pyctc h`c AccD lkb ks i_d mk kc/cq ncs opcus ec_M+ jM+c AccD atks ishs jzsi isd mk neh osScohb `csxb rcsBcyc i_d mknc va`r n_ks `csus ewxcD anYrq g`c N3c esScc an i`c\ic Bcb Bctu nhuc EcsM+nh mk/ccsob nc iqncoyc nhus ns ay, `cAc isd j\Ach rcus ScM+c AccD aTh to g` vjub h{cc isd Scqe `b yxcAcc ro i_d mk obp N3csd jM+rc] vr% i_d yc_Q vc3cD

Bcxgcu nc gcec _ & vuY3capYr3Yrcs icd 3s tuc% j3qXjckrsDrsccd au\3caBc3qcucd 3csx{csid g`cI3`i~DD

vAccXr~ tcs BcNr vuY3 apc ks ishb mjckuc nhrs _d muncs vjzcJr nb jzcaJr nhcrc w vc_hjzcJr nb h{cc i_d Kg3d nhrc wD

kdr nb k`u'cbyrc

`thr iq Iie u`cnh to hcKrs ks xqthrs Acs ro ,n 7ch ns ehgcts jh o_Lb qlX oqa; +3c mY sd

jzaraeu Scwo xcay3c esrb Acb&;csdxb] aunIic] ubp vcae&vcaeD gs mks kqunh k`t Bccg ks krs q,pys tcrs AcsD i`cjq#c lkb ocr nb rcs kccuc an3c nhrs _d an eqtXu vjub eqQrc ks ycSc aMxcucpc sdxs anYrq gs vjus k`t KgBccg ncs u`bd EcsM+sdxs vAcgc mY sd ankb ocr nb jzara3c `csxb `b u`bdD

iq Iie kcc`o us ,n aeu oqa;+3c ncs ehgcts jh o_Lc u`bd esScc ro gs #nnh ewkhcsd ks mknsochs isd jwEus yxsD jrc pyc an oqa;+3c vjus 7ch isd obich jM+b AcbD gs ic! ic! jqnchrs q, 7ch nsvdeh pys x3sD oqa;+3c us rcs kcspc an g` hcst nc oeyc mrchus vc h`c _ anYrq g`c rcs ncslX oeys

nc Bccg Acc `b u`bdD kdr nc cbry iu L`hcD gs var Ecs ks Bchnh oqa;+3c ns aunQ tcnh mkncakh k`ycus yxsD ocsys & Uic! vct rcs iq5s vccbgcXe u`bd aiyc u! vc_h ycsx ;sh&kb rchbTsdnhnsishs iu ncs vjub Bcwycsd ns jzar xcaTy nh esrs _dD rqi to iq5s /cwcX] pcsh] oeicc n`nh kIocsa/crnhrb Acb rBcb rcs i_d vjus vcj isd auhScus yxrc Acc an i_d kpiqp g_kc w rcs u`bdD vr% ic! ishbkVpb a`r_cb rcs rqI`bd `csD rqi tZeb Lbn `cs tcvcsD*

icrc mk e3ciwacX ncs esScnh hcs&hcsnh {cic icxus yxbD iq Iie kc`o vjuc nci&nctEcsM+nh nlX aeucsd rn #nnh mknb ksgc nhrs h sD

Bcxgcu isd vuY3 apc ks yxs q, vc\ichci kdrcsd nb ,skb icuaknrc qvc nhrb _ 3c 3csdn sd an mk /cch.cc ncs j qps q, kdr Scqe Bcxgdr nb xahic jzcJr nh ysrs _dD

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

48/94

>2

k\kdx8jb e;+anyc

xcsjbpde ,n i`c\ic q, _dD munb cceb AccsM+s `b aeu j`ys qlX AcbD vjub ugaggca`rc j\ubvc_h ewkhb aK=3csd ks a7chs gs Kucu nh oM+s jziqaer `cs h s AcsD vjwgX kqdeh Bcb Acs gsD muncs mk hcx&hdx

isd iKr munb icrc us Er ns jh ks esSc ay3cD gs ag/cgc `cs pqnb AcbdD mk kqdeh 3qgn ncs esScnhic ncs mkns ajrc vAccXr~ vjus aegdxr jar 3ce vcus yxsD kcsprb] Ulk yM+ns ns ajrc Bcb lkb nbrh` kqdeh AcsD to `ichb cceb qlX Acb ro `i Bcb muns kcAc lkb rh` bM+c3sd an3c nhrb AcbdD ki3ns kcAc g` tgcub ko aib nb xcX isd pyb x3bD vct 3` yM+nc Bcb lu oc kqSccsd isd osScoh `csh`c _ anYrq vjus ajrc nb rh` 3` Bcb ankb aeu konqE Sccs esxcD* g_kc kcsprb&kcsprb icrc nbvcSccsd ks nqE vHqowe pwnh xcsjbpYe ns oeu jh tc axhsD icrc ncs jh hcsrs esSc xcsjbpYe 5Q~ muns

jck pys x3s vc_h mknb #yclX nc nch.c jwEcD icrc us g` iiXnAcc n` kquclX rAcc 3` Bcb n`c anldkcu lu rqVE kcdkcahn kqSccsd isd vjus tbgu nc y{3 Bcwy o_Lrc _] anYrq esScrs&esScrs3s kcdkcahn,sg3X mkns`cAc ks aEu tcrs _d] m/ch vjustbgu nc /3s3 Bcb u`bd k/c jcrcD ecsucsd xgcnh mks

hcsuc vc_h jErcuc csc h`rc _Dicrc nb ocrcsd ks xcsjbpYe ns cqBc kdKnch tx x3sD ocsys&Uic] kdkch ns kqSc 3ae ugh _dro ccgr N3c _[* icrc us n`c & UBcxgcu nb BcaNrD* ocsys &Uro rqi iq5s BcaNr nc `b mjescnhcsD i_d konqE EcsM+&EcM+nh nsgy g`b n8xcD icrc us mY sd rj nhus ns ay, tdxy tcus nc vcescae3cD kcAc `b 3` mjesc orc3c an Urqi kqSc nb ubde kcsuc] kqKgceq Bccstu nhuc vc_h ef;+ anyc isdh`ucD* xcsjbpde us n`c & U3s rbucsd pbtsd tdxy isd Bcyc n`c kqyBc `csdxb[*

icrc jhi ageqcb Acbd] k\kdxbD ocsybd & UScwo BcwSc yxus jh SccucD ro tcs nqE Bcb 8Scc&kwSccSccvcsxs g`b kqKgceq vc_h KgcKA3nh `csxcD Scwo Hi vc_h AcncgQ ns oce to rst ubde vcus yxs rBcbkcsucD g_kb `cyr isd ran3c vc_h aoEc_uc u Bcb `csxc aTh Bcb oM+&SccoM+ vc_h ndnM+byb Bcwai jh BcbysQus ns kcAc x`hb vc_h kqSce ubde vc tc3sxbD rbkhb a`ec3r 3` an ef;+ anyc isd h`ucD ef;+ anyclXdQ&j\Achcsd ks ous incu ncs u`bd n`rsD lkks rcs Bcc_arn chbh vc_h gKrqvcsd nb a`Tctr `cs jcrb _Dt`c `ichb jag=rc] vcaKrnrc] u_arnrc vc_h ccaiXnrc nb h{cc `cs g` ef; + anyc icuc tc3sxcD g` _k\kdx nc anycD* tcs kc/cq vc_h k^tucsd nb jag= kdxar isd h`rc _ mknb k\3 vc_h /ciXauLckqha{cr h`rb _D atks kc_BccR3gc k\kdx nc anyc kqyBc `cs tcrc _ g`b k`b icus isd kqha{cr ki5ctc3sxcD

aouc x# xr u`b

uciesg ncs o qr opju isd `b agQ~LyucAc ns ecXu `cs x3s AcsD aTh Bcb mY sd kdrcsdnb kBcc isdnVpc kdr nhch ae3c x3cD agQ~LyucAc us mY sd agccsoc khcXT ucin kdr ns jck tcnh eb{cc xz .cnhus nb jzsh.cc ebD ocsys & UvBcb rqi agQ~Ly ns vc_h agQ~Ly rqI`chs & 3` }_r nc Bccg ouc qvc _D3` jecX ro `Qsxc to rqi xq#Ccu jzcJr nhcsxsD*

uciesg muns orc3s vuqkch ,n j`cM+b jh aKAcr kdr agccsoc ns vcHi nb Sccst nhrs pysx3sD g`c N3c esScc] ncslX ow;+c vceib aeu p;+us rn x`hb ubde isd kcs3c qvc Acc vc_h mkus ecsucsd jcg

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

49/94

>:

acgaydx ns jh /chs AcsD uciesg us mks vcgct ebD txrs `b mk ow;+svceib us jwE ae3c & UN3cagQ~Ly ks aiynh vc3s `cs[ a'c"3 ouuc _[ vcvcs o_Lcs] 3`b agccsoc _D*

uciesg ocsys & Uvcjncs esScnh j`ys `b vH)c `cs x3b ro Bcyc vcjncs xq# N3c ouc[kc/cq&kdr rcs ozc iq wcX isd mLnh Bctu&tj nhrs _d vc_h vcj vorn kcs, q, _d[ewkhs] jag= acgagxz jh vcjus vjuc jcg hScc _] 3` Bcb Bcyc N3c kc/cq nc y{c.c _!*

agccsoc ocsys & Uatknc oz kcs3c h`rc _ g` ,ncdr hca= isd txnh mks jqnchrc vc_h txcrc _D i_dus vjuc oz no ncs txc ay3c _ lkay, vchci ks kcs h`c w] lkisd rqI sd N3c jhsccub `csh`b _D aTh ncslX tx` iq5s acg ks Sccyb aeScc3b u`bd jM+rb] 3`c rn an vjuc jcg Bcb acg agxztcu jM+rc _ ro lks n_ks vc_h n`c hScw[rqI sd tcs tx` acg ks Sccyb aeScrb `cs g`c mLcnh ishcjcg hSc ecsD*

uciesg us mu kc/cq ococ nsecsucsd jcg mLcnh acgaydx ks vyx hScuc pc`c anYrq g`c Bcbacgaydx jzxQ `cs x3cD g`b u`bd] mks pchcsd rhT 7cqic Mcyc ro acgaydx Bcb kcAc&kcAc pchcsd vcsh 7cwix3cD mk pi\nch ncs esScnh uciesg muns ph.ccsd isd axh x3s vc_h mY sd xq# icunh id=eb{cc nbjzcAcXuc nhus yxsD ococ us mY sd ac3 8j isd Kgbnch nhrs q, vccbgcXe ae3c an rqI`chb vcdrahnkTclX rcs agQ~LyucAc ns ecXu nhus ns kcAc `b `cs pqnb _D xq# nhus nb ,n vc_jpcahnrc opb h`x3b Acb tcss ishs jcg jnM+rs `b jwhb `cs x3bD g` }_r nc vcgh.c `Q x3c vc_h ro rqi kVps kdr oux3sD

ak)cl aeSccuc jru nc nch.c

,n rjKgb jsM+ ns ubps rjK3c isd o_Lc Acc rBcb ankb nc_, us mkns jh aoQ nh ae3cD ococus xqKks isd ycy `csnh nc_, ncs rcn ae3c vc_h g` BcKi `csnh ubps axh jM+cD ococ ncs yxc an vorcs mY sdjw.cX Ccu `caky `cs x3cD gsc`h nb vcsh vjub ak)clX aeSccus py jM+sD ok] cq# qvciu nc EycgcD atk kdkch ks agiqSc `csnh kc/cuc isd tqQs Acs] kb;+b ns k`chs Bcwry ncs EcsM+ m/gXycsncsdnb vcsh vxzkh q, Acs] iu us jcg aTkyc ae3c vc_h /chccc3b `cs x3sD

nq, jh jcub Bch h`b ,n K=b ncs jcub ajycus ncs ocsysD mkus raun jzrb{cc nhus ncs n`cDkc/cq nb \3cshb p;+ x3b vc_h mks vjuc jahp3 esus ncs mrc8 `cs x3sD g` K=b kVpb jargzrc AcbDaouc Mhs ocsy jM+b & Uococ tb! i_d nc_vc u`bd w atks vcSc aeSccnh tyc vc3s `_dD l/ch nc vcScaeSccuc oM+c i xc jM+sxcD vcj atk iqnci rn j qps _d g`c rcs i_d 7ch isd h`nh jar nb ,nauL

ksgc nhns no ncs j qp pqnb wD anYrq kVpb idaty vBcb o qr vcxs _D vcj Bczair `cs h s _d] vr%tcnh kc/cuc isd yax3sD*ococ ns `csc aLncus vc x3s vc_h gs jwgXgr~ rjK3c isd tc yxsD

kdr nc kdrc c

,n kc/cq ns vcHi isd ,n aeu pcshb `cs x3bD vcHi ns kBcb kcicu pcsh ys x3sD koshs xcgns ycsx lns q,D jqayk Bcb vc x3b] anYrq ococ mkks ,nei jhsccu u AcsD mZQs gs jwgXgr~ kBcbvcxYrqncsd nc `cy&kicpch jwEs tc h s AcsD jqayk us hjQ ayScub pc`bD ococ ocsys & Uvcjncs ankus

n`c an pcsh vc3s Acs[nqE t8hride ycsx vc3s vg3 AcsD gs vjus ay, ko kcicu oQcshus yxsD

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

50/94

96

ishb ubde Scqyb ro i_dus esScc] gs nqE nbirb kcicu vc_h j_ks EcsM+s tc h s AcsD ro i_dus QcPpX nb hcscubisd mu kcicucsd ncs Bcb ys ysus ncs n`cD kp icau3s rcs gs oM+s is hocu ycsx Acs tcs jc nhns ,nydxcsQb EcsM+ x3s ghuc vcjns kcius vBcb udxc `b ScM+c `csuc jM+rcD mu kcicucsd nb rh` 3` ydxcsQbBcb rcs oce `b isd aiyb AcbD ic ns jsQ ks tYic Acc ro rcs 3` Bcb kcAc u AcbD 3`c ks tcrs gNr

lks Bcb ncslX ys ysxcD gs pbtsd pchcsd rhT tic AcbdD Bcys `b raun kqSc vc_h vchci esrb Acbd anYrq

mkks vacn muns hSc&hSccg nb apYrc isd hcr&aeu yxs h`uc jM+rc AccD vo vct ks rcs ncslX apYrch`b u`bd] vr% auadpr `cs `ah&Bctu n8xcD vr% vcj tcl3sD i_d rcs kcicu mLc ys tcusgcycsd ncscY3gce esrc w vc_h mkks Bcb va/cn mk icayn nc /cY3gceb w atY`csdus iq5s lk jznch auadpr

nhcnh vjuc /3cu nhus nc vgkh jzecu an3cD*

lX3cBccg

ankb G3aNr us Scwo j_ks ScpX nhns ,n vcybccu ncsLb ouc3bD xf jzgsc ns aeu oM+c m\kgan3cD c`h ns icaude ycsx Bccst isd chbn q,D mk G3aNr us vjus xq#esg ncs Bcb vcida=r an3c AccD

mk Bcgu isd ,n ks ,n oa;+3c kcicu] ehgcts] QclZk] aotyb&oac3c] xs] xybps vcae yxc3s x3sAcsD mu koncs aeScc&aeSccnh ksL Twys u`bd kic h`c AccD,n kcy oce ococ mkns 7ch x3s ro ksL oM+c `b ic3wk vjus odxys ns oc`h akh jnM+s nqkbX

isd o_Lc AccD ococ us vcgBcxr ns oce mkks jwE ae3c & UajEys kcy incu ns me~7ccQu ns gNr vcjo qr Scqc AcsD vo mkb incu isd o_Lnh lrus xixbu N3csd _d[ incu nc ncslX a`Kkc QwQc&TwQc Bcbrcs u`bd _D* ksL ocsyc&Uococ! iq5s `tch jznch nb apYrc3sd _dD aeicx nci u`bd nhrcD vcjncs N3ckqucD*

ococ ocsys & Uatk incu ncs jcnh kcy Bch j`ys vcjncs os e Scqcb Acb mkb incu ns `csrs q, vcj lrus apdarr N3csd _d[*

ksL us n`c & Uvc_h ko rcs Lbn `b _ anYrq ishs oxygcys us iq5ks pc vc_h oM+c incu oucay3c _D mks esSc&esScnh i_d hcr&aeu apdarr h`rc wD to g` incu nb Er jh p;+nh 7cwwirc _ roishb Ecrb tyus yxrb _D*

ococ ks & UBcys vceib! rqI`chc incu rcs nqE EcsQc `cs u`bd x3c aTh mkns oM+c `csus ksrqI sd N3c jhsccub `cs x3b[*

/ciXBccg ks ha`r `h ldkcu] pc s ncslX o qr j;+c `cs vAcgc vj;+] o qr /cugcu `cs vAcgc aucXu]

i`cu eq%Scb _D kdrcscjwgXn tbus nb nyc kdr akSccrs d_Dnhcicr aeSccuc ucki5b `_

,n v dnchb ococ ewkhs i`c\ic ns kcAc 'ccK=cAcX nhus ns ay, j qpcD atk i`c\ic ks 'ccK=cAcXnhuc pc`rc Acc] g` mks esScrs `b ocsyc] Ui_d ,sks `b `ch icu ysrc wD nch.c] iq5s ncslX 'ccK= u`bdvcrcD* lk jh mk v dnchb kc/cq us vjuc vcku eah3c isd Tsdn ae3cD vcku eah3c isd r_hus yxcD

g` ty jh pyrc qvc mk vcku jh o_Lnh xgXjwgXn ocsyc] Urqi vc tcvcs] 3`bd 'ccK=ccAcX nhsdD*i`c\ic us esScc an lkus rcs vtbo ;csdx nhuc 'cq# nh ae3cD mkns tgco isd ococ us vjus

vcku ncs `gc isd jh y`hc ae3cD vcku jh tcnh vcnc'c isd aQn x3cD ro g` mM+nh mkb

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

51/94

94

vcku jh o_Lnh n`us yxc] Uococ tb] rqI`bd l/ch vc tcvcsD 3`bd o_Lnh ocrsd nhsdD* mk v dnchb ncs`gc isd o_Luc vcrc u`bd AccD n`us yxc] Ui_d g`c n_ks vc[* mk kVps i`c\ic us n`c] Urw jcub isdo_Lus ncs `b vjub aka) icurc _[ i_d Kg3d `gc isd o_L x3c w rcs N3c lkb ks ak) `cs x3c[lkisd ncslX oM+b ocr u`bdD jcub jh o_Lnh rwus vxh ,n iEyb nc nci an3c rcs `gc isd vckuyxcnh i_d ,n apaM+3c ns ohcoh qvcD lkisd ScqeclX nb N3c ocr _[ 3`c Ccu nb rcs ncslX ocr qlX

`b u`bdD* lu nhcicrcsd ncs v/3c\i u`bd ki5uc pca`,D kVps i`cjq#"c nBcb nhcicr u`bd aeSccrsD,n hcb egc jcg Bch oejh`tb

,n vceib ns jsQ isd eeX 'cq# `cs x3cD mkus McPNQh ns jck tcnh egc ybD McPNQh uss 'c`e nskcAc egc Sccus ncs n`cD 7ch vcus jh mkus j\ub ks 'c`e icdxcD 'c`e 7ch isd mjyO/c u AccD mkuskcspc] 'c`e ns kcAc Sccus nc iryo ankb Bcb ibLb pbt ks `csxcD vr% 'c`e ns oeys xqM+ ns kcAcBcb egc Scc3b tc knrb _D mkus jcg Bch xqM+ isd egc yjsQnh Scc ay3cD lkks eeX 7cQus ns otc3

ewuc o;+ x3cD g` hcrBch McPNQh ncs xcay3c esrc h`cD koshc `csrs `b ycLb ysnh McPNQh ns 7ch j qpcD

n`c] Ui_d kchb hcr eeX ks osp_u h`cD rqI sd eeX ewh nhus ns ay, j_kc ae3c Acc 3c o;+cus ns ay,[vBcb ishc j_kc es ecs u`bd rcs Sc_h u`bdD*McPNQh us n`c] UBcclX] j_kc rcs vBcb es esrc wD j`ys 3` rcs orcvcs an egc Scc3b n_ks[* mkus

orc3c] U'c`e ns kcAc rcs Sccus ncs n`c Acc ysanu es cr isd kons 7ch 'c`e n`c `csrc _D 'c`e ibLc`b rcs `csrc _] mkns oeys jcgBch xq+M+ ns kcAc egc Scc ybD* McPNQh us n`c] Uk\3cuc'c nh Mcyc! hcbBch egc vc_h jcg Bch oejh stb] eeX ks ihcsxs u`bd rcs N3c!*

Bcxgcu i5seSc yxs

gfYecgu isd ".c idaeh isd e'cXu ns ay, H)cyqvcsd nb BcbM+ miM+b qlX AcbD yIob nrch isd

ycsx ScM+s AcsD muisd ecsucsdvcSccsdnc vd/cc G3aNr Bcb ScM+c AccD ankb us mks a5M+nrs q, n`c&UBcysvceib] rqI sd vcSc rcs _ u`bd] aTh idaeh is tcnh e'cXu N3c nhcsxs! rqI sd osnch 3`c ScM+c h`us

ks N3c ycBc!*vd/cs vceib us tgco ae3c & UBcclX] atuncs esScus vcj kBcb tc h s _d] i_d u`bd rcs u k`b]

gs rcs iq5s esSc ysdxs an i_d Bcb muns ki{c `cath wD aTh rcs ocr ou `b tc3sxbD

ko i O3cj hci

BcNr nY`clX xq# xcsagYe akd tb nc a'c"3 AccD mks iqkyicucsd ,gd a`Yeqvcsd ns obp `csusgcys

3q) isd 7cc3ycsd ncs jcub ajycus nc nci ae3c x3c AccD 3q) isd Scsr vc3s iqkyicucsd ncs Bcb g` jcubajyc esrc AccD ro kchs iqkyicu jcub jbnh tb mLrs Acs vc_h mjpch ns mjhcYr jqu% yM+clX ns ay,r_3ch `cs tcrs AcsD nY`clX ns mk G3g`ch nb a'cnc3r i`chct rn xlXD i`chct us mks oqycnh jwEc]U,skc N3csd nhrc _[ eq'iucsd ncs jcub ajycus ks N3c iryo[* nY`clX ocsyc] Ui`chct] `i u rcs

a`Yew ncs jcub ajycrs _d u iqkyicu ncsD `i rcs nsgy vcj qtwh ncs jcub ajycrs _dD `isd rcs koisdvcj `b aeScclX jM+rs _dD*

i`chct ki5 x3sD mY`csdus nY`clX ks n`c] Uvo rshc G3g`ch Sc\i qvcD rw vo Bctu nh(

N3csdan vo rw G3g`ch ns ncaoy u`bd h`cD* a'c"3 n`rc _] Uecsucsd tx` rqi `b rqi `cs* vc_h xq#tbn`rs _d] U,n ncs ih tcus ecs] ewkhs ncs opcvcsD* ro N3c xq#tb ks a'c"3 ^3cec Ccub _[ u`bd]

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

52/94

9

pc.cN3 nc mch Acc] Ut`c nc jz/ccuid=b kc/cch.c nqaQ3c isd h`rc _ g`c ns augckb BcG3&Bcgucsdisd augck nhrs _d vc_h atk es'c nc jz/ccuid=b xxupqIob Bcgucsds isd h`rc _ g`c nb turc 5csjaM+3csdisd h`rb _D*

hci hQ nci nh

nc'cb ns rqykb7ccQ jh tcM+s ns aeucsd isd to kBcb KgsQh vc_h ncsQ yxc3s aThrs Acs] ,nKAcwync3 g3csgf) kdr kqo`&kqo` aiyc nhrs AcsD nih isd ,n iciwyb njM+c] g` Bcb 7cqQus ks jhrn `b yjsQs `csrs AcsD munc 'cs"c 'chbh udxc `csrc AccD ncTb `s&ns AcsD ec;+b vc_h ns'c ns ocy,nei kTse AcsD jcg isd ScM+c j`us rAcc `cAc isdd kY3cak3cdss nc jchIjahn e.M /cch.c an3s q, oM+biKrb ks pyrs AcsD

jzcr%ncy xdxc e'cXu vc_h Kucu ns ay, jzaraeu vjus vcHi ks aunynh koshs&koshs xqthrsAcsD KgBccg isd ,nei TNnM+ju AccD uchc yxcnh tcsh&tcsh ks ,n `b Qsn hQrs tcrs&UBcclX hs ! hci

hQ nci nh] nci nh hci hQD hci hQ hs BcclX! hci hQ&hci hQD* hcKrs isd tcs ncslX muns ph.c Ewrc

vAcgc jz.cci nhrc] gs g`b tgco Uhci hQ hci hQ] nci nh* n`rs q, pys tcrs AcsD gs nBcb ankbks ncslX ocr u`bd nhrs AcsD xdxc anuchs j qpnh icrc BccxbhAcb ncs jz.ccinh gs 7ccQ nb kba;3csd jhecsucsd Qcxsd vcxsT_yc3s q, Ld;b tibu jh `b o_L tcrs AcsD g`c vcus&tcusgcys kBcb ec_M+&ec_M+nh ococ nsjcg Ewrs AcsD ro Bcb gs h`&h`nh Uhci hQ hci hQ* n`nh vc'cbgcXe esrs Acs D ycsxcsd nb vcsh raun/3cu u`bd esrsD g`c o_Ls&o_Ls Bcb munb vcScsd jzc3% oYe `b h`rbd vAcgc to nBcb vcScsd Sccsyrs] oM+s

mjhci Bccg ks konb vcsh esScnh Uhci hQ nci nh hs BcclX! nci nh hci hQ* ocsyc nhrs AcsD agucsenhrs q, nBcb&nBcb ankb vceib vAcgc oVVcs&oVpb nb jbLjh Acjnb esnh ocsyrs&Uhci hQ hci hQ]

nci nh hci hQD* /cwj aunyus rn g`c gs 7cdQsBch o_Ls h`rs AcsD nlX&nlX 3qgn ococ ns`cAc&jcghxM+nh ksgc nhrs rcs ncslX mY sd pc3 ycnh ajycrc AccD anYrq gs `hei ic_u `b h`rs Acs vc_hh`&h`nh obp&obp isd ,nic= Uhci hQ* ocsyc nhrs AcsD munb mkb ocsyb isd munc vc'cbgcXe] kuc]itcn nhuc vAcgc mjes'c nhuc konqE aua`r AccD iKrb vc_h Tnbhb rcs ic_u `csrs q, Bcb munshcsi&hcsi ks Qjnrb ebSc jM+rb AcbD

,n nsoey ek

,n och ecs Tnbh 7cwirs&7cwirs hcao3c ns e'cXu ns ay, vc3sD gs BcwScs Acs lkay, vcjk isd ocr

nhus yxs an 3ae nqE Sccus ncs aiy tcrc rcs vVEc AccD hcao3c ns jck akTX ecs hcsaQ3c AcbdD Tnbhcsdns ay, mY sd g` ys vc3bD lrus isd rbkhc Tnbh hcsQb icxus vc x3cD hcao3c us mks ecsucs dhcsaQ3c esebdD 3` esScnh mu ecs Tnbhcsd ncs o qr vc'p3X qvcD 'cb/cz ,n eckb ecs hcsaQ3c ysnh vc3bd vc_hhcao3c ks ocsyb & Uishs icyanu us 3` hcsaQ3c vcjns ay, Bcstb _dD* hcao3c us axunh esScc] vLch`hcsaQ3c AcbdD mk eckb ncs aouc hcsQb ay3s yc_Qc ae3cD eckb us vcnh vjub icyanu ncs kchc `cy n`kquc3cD mkus mu hcsaQ3csd isd ecs hcsaQ3c vc_h aiycnh eckb ncs aTh BcstcD lk och hcao3c us axunhesScc] hcsaQ3c obk AcbdD mY`csdus hcsaQ3c hSc ybd vc_h ecsucsd Tnbhcsd ns vcxs hSc ebdD Bccstu nhrs&nhrsmY`csdus lk ocr nc h`K3 jwEc rcs orc3c & Uvcj ecsucsd BcwScs Acs3` ocr i_dtcu x3b AcbdD ishs jck

ecs hcsaQ3c AcbdD muks vcj ecsucsd nc jsQ u`bd Bchrc lkay, i_dus g` ecs hcsaQ3c mk Tnbh ncs es ebD

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

75/94

09

mk vLch` hcsaQ3csd ncs esScnh i_dus ki5c an esus isd Bcwy qlXD oce isd obk hcsaQ3c vc3bd ro i_dus mksys ay3cD nch.c] Scqec nc gcec _ an tcs jhicAcX isd ,n nc ecu nhrc _ mks i_d oeys i_d ek aeygcesrc wD

au njQ e3

hcao3c `is'cc Scqec ns jzsi isd iKr h`rb AcbD mknb jzar jw.cX va dkn AcbD to g` ocxbps isdjsM+ ns ubps o_Lrb rcs j{cb mM+&mM+nh mkns kibj vc tcrs AcsD gs mY sd vjus `cAccsd ks ecuc aScycrbAcbdD j{cb mkns 'chbh jh Tqenrs h`rs icucs g` munb o qr `b vtbt `csD ,n aeu hcao3c mkb rh`

ja{c3csd ns kcAc Scsy h`b Acbd rBcb gs ,nc,n mM+ x3sD iqM+nh esScc rcs ,n Tnbh vc h s AcsD Tnbh usvcrs `b n`c & UmY sd N3csd mM+c ae3c[ anruc rcs vVEc yx h`c AccD i_d Bcb muns kcAc ScsyrcD*

hcao3c ocsyb & Ui_dus rcs u`bd Bcxc3c] j{cb Scqe `b mM+ x3sD*mkus jwEc & Ulrub esh ks gs rqI`chs kcAc Scsy h s AcsD iq5ks muncs N3c Scrhc Acc tcs mM+

x3s[*hcao3c ocsyb & Ulk kfa"Q ns `h,n jzc.cb ns Bcbrh Scqec okrc _D mY sd jrc _ an nc_u munc

a`r_"cb _ vc_h nc_u eq'iuD vVEc rqi orcvcs] vct N3c Sccnh vc3s `cs [*UhcsQb vc_h oQsh nc icdk*] Tnbh us orc3cD

hcao3c ocsyb & Uro rcs rqi muns eq'iu `csD Bcyc gs rqiks n_ks u`bd MhsdD mY sdjrc _ anhcao3c nBcb kjus isd Bcb munc va`r u`bd nh knrbD lkay, gs lk neh iq5ks apjns h`rs _ dD*

iu nc joc/c

,n aeu Hbhci".cesg nb lVEc jydx jh o_Lnh hs'cib nqhrc j`unh pceb nb xqM+xqM+b ks qNnc jbus nb qlXD r\ncy `b hcub hckia.c us kchb pbtcsd nc ldrtci nh ae3cD gs mu pbtcsd ncsjcnh o qr `b Scq'c q, icucs ankb EcsQs oVps ncs o qr `b vcn"cXn aScyc_uc aiy x3c `csD nqE eshoce gs xIBcbh `csrs q, ocsys & Uhs iu! 3s pbtsd ic ns apYi3 8j ns kcius rcs nqE Bcb u`bd _dD roN3c rw ic nc e'cXu EcsM+nh lY`bd pbtcsd nb nciuc nhsxc! lkb ks rcs htcsxq.c o;+rc _D L`h kcys]vBcb orcrc wD* mY`csdus kchb pbtcsd ncs jck ns ucys isd Mcy ae3cD ,n EM+b ks mY sd nbpM+ isd Mcynh

hc_deus yxs vc_h ocsys & UesSc hs iu] vjub pc`b gKrq nb eqeX'cc esScD*

iu nc kd3i

rjKgb lozca`i aou v/ci j`ys oySc ns oce'cc` Acs jh mY`csdus konqE EcsM+nh Tnbhb ys ybAcbD munc lX'ghcuqhcx vc_h munb G3cnqyrc vuqji AcbD

muns g_hcR3 nb ,n ,skb Bcb vgKAcc qlX to mY sd kcdkcahn ycsxcsd ns obp tcuc vAcgc icxucBcb xgchc u`bd yxus yxcD mY`csdus r3 an3c an N3csd u`bd ankb nb uc_nhb nh yb tc3s atkks

l/ch&m/ch BcQnus ns otc3 ecs twu hcsQb ns ay, ldrtci `cs tc3sD 7cwirs&7cwirs gs ,n hctc ns 3`cx3s vc_h mks vjus ay, nqE nci esus ncs n`cD hctc us mY sd vjus ksg ns ocxbps nb hScgcyb ns

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

76/94

01

ay, uc_nh au3qNr nh ay3cD lozca`i ncs g` nci oM+c vuqnwy yxcD xcg&kict ks ewh gs va/cncd'cki3 locer isd aorc3c nhrs AcsD

mY sd g`c h`rs g"ccsXd `cs x3s ro ,n aeu g`c nc hctc ocxbpc 7cwius x3cD mkns kcAc nsvceai3csd us lozca`i ncs ocxbps ks oa;+3c anKi nc ksg hctc ns kcius js'c nhus ncs n`cD lozca`i

us ksg `cath an3s anYrq g` Scc aunycD mkus ewkhs jsM+ nc ksg eqochc js'c an3c jhYrqq g` Bcb Scc

AccD hctc us mks McQrs q, n`c & Urqi 3`c nslrus jqhcus iqycati `cs] rqI sd 3` jrc u`bd an ankjsM+ nc ksg ibLc _ vAcgc u`bd[*lozca`i us tgco ae3c & Uishb M~3qQb ocxbps nb hScgcyb nb _ u an ksg nb j`pcu nhus

nbD ksg nb anKi nb j`pcu rcs tbBc ncs `csrb _D i_dus vctrn ksg nc ,n QqnM+c Bcb nBcb Scc3cu`bd aTh n_ks tcuw an g` Scc _ 3c ibLcD ishc g_kc nhuc rcs uin`hcib `csxbD*

hctc mknb licuechb jh vc'p3Xpanr qvcD mks jrc Acc an oySc nc oce'cc` lozca`ioce'cc`b \3cxnh Tnbh `cs x3c _D mks raun kdes qvc an g_kc nLcsh vc\ikd3i ankb kciY3lYkcu nc `cs u`bd knrcD vr% mkus jwE ae3c & Uvcj lozca`i rcs u`bd _d[*

lozca`i raun kdnQ isd jM+ x3sD mY`csdus hctc ks t_ks&r_ks ocr oucnh Eqb jclXD mkb hcr gsg` nci EcsM+nh pqjns ks iNnc pys x3sD muns vcus nc kicpch kqunh iNncgcak3csd us munsKgcxr nb r_3cah3c vchIBc nbdD lknb Scoh jcnh lozca`i us G3cjcah3csd ns ,n ncaTys ns kcAc lkjznch iNnc isd jzgs'c an3c an ncslX mY sd j`pcu u kncD ,n iNncaugckb Sccstrc&Sccstrc mkbncaTys isd vc3c vc_h mkus Kg3d lozca`i ks jwEc & Uvcjus `thr lozca`i ncs n`bd esScc[iNncaugckb munc Kgcxr&k\nch nhuc pc`rs _dD* gs ocsys& Uvhs Bccsys iNncaugcak3csd! mk jcSc.Mblozca`i ks rqI sd N3c nciD mkks rqI sd N3c ycBc `csxc[* lruc kqurs `b gs uxhgckb csa/cr `cs mLsD

lozca`i ncs Schb&SccsQb kqucnh mkus n`c & Uucecu] mk i`cjq#"c ncs jcSc.Mb orcusgcyc rw Kg3d ncslXjcSc.Mb aeScrc _D*

U`c BcclX] i_d vg'3 `b jcSc.Mb w*] 'ccdr iu ks mY`csdus mch ae3cD aTh gs vjus iu ncskIocsa/cr nhns ocsys & Uhs eq"Q iu] rqI sd vct Lbn e.M aiyc _D gs Scqec ncs vusn cY3gce esusyxsD munb ,skb iucsgfac esScnh g` ucxahn rcM+ x3c an `cs u `cs] 3`b `thr lozca`i _dD g`hcsnh muns ph.ccsd isd axh jM+c vc_h och&och {cic icxus yxcD jh i`c\ic us mkks knh n`c&UrqiusLbn `b n`c Acc BcclX] i_d Scqe tcurc w an ishc iu anruc jcSc.Mb _D*

icr nb Scoh

Thbeqbu vcch jchk lXhcu augckb AcsD gs l= ospus nb eqncu an3c nhrs AcsD ,n aeu vcchxzc`ncsd ns kcAc G3Kr Acs an ,n ehgs'c us vcnh muks Sc_hcr icxbD vcch us mknb vcsh ncslX /3cuu`bd ae3c icucs ehgs'c ncs esScc u `csD ehgs'c och&och vcgct yxcrc h`c jhYrq vcch `h och vukqubnhrs h sD

ehgs'c us auhc'c `csnh n`c & Uvcch] rq5s esScnh iq5s _hcub `csrb _D rw eqau3c ns nci isdlk jznch Tkc qvc _ an rq5s 3` `cs'c u`bd an rshc vky nci N3c _[ N3c rq5s apYrc u`bd an

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

77/94

00

rshb tcu n_ks aunysxb[* vcch ocsys & UN3c rqI sd jrc _ an rqI`chb tcu n_ks aunysxb[* ehgs'cn`us yxc & Urw kcsp ys an tcs nqE n`c _] Lbn n`c _] kVps aey ks n`c sD*

vcch us n`c & U`c] i_dus tcs nqE n`c _ kcsp&ki5nh n`c _ vc_h kVps aey ks n`c _D*3` kqunh ehgs'c mknb eqncu ns kcius tibu jh ysQ x3sD vc_h mkb ki3 jzc.c \3cx ae3sD vcchg` esScnh _hcu h` x3s an ehgs'c us kpiqp tcu es ebD muns vYeh Tc_hu agpch vc3c an ehgs'c

rcs iq5s atYexb vc_h icsr nc Bcse ki5cus ns ay, vc3c AccD gs kcspus yxs an ehgs'c Lbn `b n`rcAcc an iq5s icayn us Bcstc ank nci ns ay, _ vc_h i_d nh N3c h`c wD N3c i_d eqau3c isd l=ospus ns ay, vc3c w 3c Scqec nb ryc'c nhus[

vcch us vjub eqncu kec ns ay, ode nh eb vc_h ehgs'ccsd nsnjM+s j`u ay3sD jhic\ic nbryc'c isd 7ch ks auny jM+sD munb ryc'c nci3co qlX vc_h gs jw.cX kwTb ehgs'c ou x3s tcs oce isdlXhcu ns i`cu kwTb kdr ousD

tc k` g`b 'c`d'cc`

ankb idaeh ns jck xqyco nc ,n jc_/cc AccD mkns jck `b j\Ach nb ,n pcu Bcb jM+b Acb]atk jh p;+nh ycsx xqyco nc Twy rcsM+rs vc_h esgiaYeh isd iwacX jh p;+crs AcsD Twy ncs 3` vaBcicuAcc an g` kqYeh vc_h Scq'cowech _D g` j\Ach jh G3dR3 nkrc Acc an mknc j\Ach nc tbgu n_kc

mjsa{cr _ atk jh kBcb jcg hScrs _d rAcc Twy ncs esgrc jh p;+crs _dD j\Ach ospchc xqyco nbvjicutun ocrsd kqurc vc_h k`u nhrc AccD

,n aeu ankb a'cZjnch nb uth j\Ach jh jM+bD mkus j\Ach ks ,n kqYeh iwacX ouc3bD iwacXoucrs ki3 Bcb j\Ach ncs pcsQsd k`u nhub jM+bd ysanu g` Scq'cb&Scq'cb ko k`rc h`cD g`c ,n BcG3idaeh ouc3c x3c t`c mk kqYeh iwacX nb KAccjuc nb xlXD

ki3 oeyc] to ycsx xqyco nc Twy rcsM+nh mk iwacX jh p;+cus yxsD xqyco rcs g`b h`cjhYrq kons jcg rys jM+c qvc j\Ach ,n aeu jw 3 iwacX ou x3cD

tcs k`u nhrc _ g`b ,n aeu 'c d'cc` ourc _D uiz G3aNr `b kocs d ns uiu 3csR3 ourc _DkgXHs"L a'cZjnch jhic\ic nb uth mjsa{cr vc_h k`u'cby ycsxcsd jh ,n&u&,n aeu jM+rb `b _Dm/ch vaBcicub G3aNr jzBcq nb jc ks gdapr h`rc _D

n#.ccgcu ocj

pIjch.c nb ocr _D ,n aeu 'cci ncs o qr oM+c tqywk auny h`c AccD `cs&`Zyc `cs h`c AccDxcd/cbtb us kBcb nc3XnrcXvcsd ks jwEc & U3` vcgct nc s nb _[ twywk n_kc[* ncslX nqE ocsy u`bd jch`c AccD g`c rcs oay p;+cus ns ay, onhb nc twywk aunyc AccD i`c\ic tb mLsD twywk isd 'ccaiy `csx,D icyc j`uclX xlXD onhb ns kcAc pyus yxsD

tqywk esgb ns idaeh ns jck vc3cD i`c\ic tb mk onhb ns kcAc AcsD mY`csdus jwEc & Uonhb nbankay, oay p;+clX tc h`b _[*

Ulkay, an esgb jzkYu `csdD*

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

78/94

02

Uonhb ks vceib Hs"L _D iuq"3 nb oay esus ks esgb va/cn jzkYu `csdxbD esSccs] N3c ,skc ncslXvceib r_3ch _[ u`bd rcs i_d r_3ch wD*

kBcb KrO/c ScM+s AcsD ocjw ocsys & Uxwxs tcugh ns Scwu ks `b esgb jzkYu `csrb _d[ 3ae gs jzkYu`csrb `csd rcs vjuc vacn iwZ3gcu hNr ecsD g` N3csd u`bd esrs[ 3` rcs /ccsScc _] v/ciX _D*

Uvcj `isd /ciX ki5cl,D*

Uk\3 jh pycsD jzca.cic= ks jzsi nhcsD g` onhb EcsM+ ecsD vct g` txeIoc vcj ycsxcsd jhatrub jzkYu qlX `cdsxb] mrub lkks j`ys Bcb u qlX `cdsxbD*

ih.c nc vcude iucvc

mk ki3 vcHi EcsQc AccD KAccjuc ncs rbu&pch g"cX `b q, AcsD agucsoc tb] vJjckc`o jQg/cXut_ks rstKgb] /3s3au"L kccn vcHi isd vc x, Acs vc_h ku~ 4:4:nc

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

79/94

0:

xq#&a'c 3 jhIjhc

vdxzstcsd nc ticuc AccD mu aeucsd xcic j`ygcu nc oM+c uci AccD xcic iqkyicu AccD g`kdkch ns kBcb j`ygcucsd ncs jEcM+ pqnc Acc] lkbay, ag'gagt3b n`ycrc AccD ,n och g` oIolXvc3cD mkus ag'gBch ns kBcb j`ygcucsd ncs nq'rb ns ay, yynchcD 3` kicpch kBcb vScochcsd isd Ej

x3cD ro ,-,T-,k- ry3chSccu ucin jchkb j=nch mkns jck j qpcD mkus xcic ks jwEc & Uvcjkdkch ns kBcb j`ygcucsd ncs p_ysdt nh h s _d rcs N3csd u`bd `ibec ks `b yM+ ysrs[ mkb ncs jEcM+ebat, ro `i ki5sdxs an vcj ag'gagt3b _dD*

xcic 3` kqunh vcx `cs x3c vc_h oqhb rh` mk j=nch ncs McQrs q, n`c & U3` kovdxzstb a'c{cc nc vkh _] u`bd rcs ,n Bcchrb3 `csnh vcj ,skc osrqnc kgcy iq5ks u`bd nh knrsAcsD tcurs _d `ibec nc_u _[ g` ishc a'c"3 _] ishc jzc.c _D i_d Kg3d `ibec wD `i ecsucsd xq#&a'c"3

isd ncslX TnX u`bd _D `ibec `b ishb ,nic= niclX _D mkb isd ishb jzar"Lc ,gd kqSc&'ccaYr aua`r _Dto i_dus p_ysdt an3c rcs i_d AccsM+s `b yM+us tcrcD `ibec `b ishb vcsh ks yM+rcD i_d yM+w 3c `ibec] ,n

`b ocr _] N3csdan `i ecsucsd nc aiynh ,n `b G3aNr\g _] ,n `b vcgct _D*ry3chSccu pqjpcj pyc vc3cD g` lruc ki5ech Acc an mkus jwhc gcn3c vScochcsd isdjznca'cr nhc ae3cD

3`b _ Uxq#&a'c"3 kdKarD* kdr&i`c\icvcsd isd 3` kdKnfar toheKr 8j isd esScus ncs aiyrb _D 'cdnhcpc3X ns pchcsd a'c"3 muns anrus J3chs Acs] icucs gs Scqe muisd mrh x3s AcsD hcinf".c jhi dknc uhsYez aggsncuYe ns jzar g_kc `b jzxc;+ jzsi AccD mkb jznch Hb v}_r Kgcib ns J3chs Acs HbKg8j Kgcib atuns n"Q nb ocr kqunh gs hcsus `b yxs AcsD Hb Kg8j Kgcib ncs Bcb jhi i`chct nsjzar o qr J3ch AccD

t3 txr

,n och agucsoctb ncs Knwy ns o qr&ks oVps ScM+s aiysD mY`csdustcshcsd ks Kgcxr isd n`c]Ut3a`YeD*

agucsoc L`h x,D ocsys] U,n ocr orcvcsxsD*UjwaE3sD*UN3c t3a`Ye ns icus ki5rs `cs[*Uvjus es'c nb t3 `cs] mknc Bcyc `csD*Uvc_h ewkhs es'c nc N3c `cs[*

ko pqjD AccsM+b esh oce ,n yM+nc ocsyc] Umknc Bcb Bcyc `csD* ULbn ysanu Ut3a`Ye* isd g`ocr n`c vcrb _[ rqi Ut3a`Ye* n`cs] pbugcys Ut3 pbu* n sd] 8kgcys Ut3 8k n sd] vihbncgcysUt3 vihbnc* n sd rcs vcjk isd jzsi&Bccg n_ks o;+sxc[*

Uu`bd o;+sxcD vjuc&vjuc ycsBc o;+sxc[*Urcs 3` rcs Lbn u`bd _ u[ `isd ,skc id= ocsyuc pca`, atkks kchb eqau3c isd isy&iq Oor

j_ec `csD g` id= _ & Ut3 txr!*

ko ocyncsd us pb vcgct isd n`c] Ut3 txrD*

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

80/94

26

agucsoc us muncs jz.cci an3c vc_h vcxs o;+ x3sD

kVpb locer

vOe iqochn `t nhus ns ay, iNnc nb 3c=c jh AccD icxX isd ,n KAccu jh g` Acnnh kcsx3c vc_h mkus KgJu esScc an g` KgxX isd AccD mkus g`c ecs Tah'rcsd ncs ocrpbr nhrs kqucD j`ysTah'rs us ewkhs ks jwEc & Ulk kcy anrus `t3c=b iNnc vc h s _d [*

UE% ycSc* & ewkhs Tah'rs us tgco ae3cDUvc_h luisd ks anrucsd ncs `t3c=c nc jq.3 aiysxc[*Uankb ncs Bcb u`bdD oxece isd vyb iqTbn ucin ,n icspb _ tcs `t u`bd nh h`c _ aTh

Bcb mks `t nc jq.3 ae3c tc h`c _ vc_h mknb n#.cc ns nch.c 3c=c nhusgcys E% ycSc ycsx BcbAccsM+c&o qr jq.3 nic ysdxsD*

ubde Scqyus jh vOe iqochn kjus ns ochs isd kcspnh vpdaBcr AccD g` vyb iqTbn nb ewncujh x3c vc_h mkus mks vjuc KgJu n` kquc3cD

Uvcjns KgJu ns ochs isd i_d nqE u`bd n` knrcD i_dus rcs oM+b iqa'ny ks `t3c=c ns ay, rbukc_ jpck ebuch tic an3s AcsD ysanu to i_d 3c=c ns ay, auny h`c Acc rBcb i_dus esScc an ishsjM+cskb ecus&ecus ncs rhk h s AcsD i_dus g` kchc cu muisd ocQ ae3cD vo i_d 'cc3e nBcb `t nhusu`bd tc knwxc* & vyb iqTbn us n`cD

xq.c ksG3aNr nb j`pcu

xibX ns aeu AcsD kizcQ agicae\3 vc_h i`cnag ncybeck kd/3c ns ki3 mjgu isd o_Ls AcsDecsucsd vcjk isd gcrcXycj nh h s AcsD kizcQ i`cnag nb ag}cc ks oM+s jzBccagr q,D kizcQ us i`cang

ks n`c] Uvcjnb ag}cc va}ar3 _D vcjnb ohcohb nhus gcyc lk kdkch isd ncslX u`bd _dD lkisd ecsir u`bd] anYrq -------D* ocsyrs&ocsyrs kizcQ pqj `cs x3sD i`cnag ncybeck Bcb panr Acs an i`chctN3csd pqj `cs x3sD ,skc nqE esh pycD rBcb kizcQ ocsyus yxs i`cnag! nc'c! vcj Bcb 8jgcu `csrs rcs---------

i`cnag ncybeck Bccj x3s kizcQ agicae\3 ns vaBcicu ncs] jh mY`csdus ncslX mch u`bd ae3cDxibX Bc3dnh AcbD nqE ki3 ns j'pcr kizcQ agicae\3 ncs J3ck yxbD i`cnag us mY sd kcsus

ns 7cM+s ks ty ajyc3cD kizcQ ncs Kg.cX 7cQ nc ty xiX yxcD g` ocsys] Ui`cnag! 3` rcs xiX tyAcc] LdMc jcub ycvcsD N3c LdMc ty u`bd _[*

Ui`chct! UULdMc ty rcs _ jh Kg.cX7cQ ns otc3 aib ns jc= isd _D 3ae vcCc `csrcs yc[*i`cnag ocsysD i`cnag us 3` ocr G3dR3 isd n`b AcbD

kizcQ ocsys] Uiq5s LdMc ty ajycvcsD lkks N3c an g` aib ns jc= isd _[* i`cnag us aibns jc= nc ty ycnh kizcQ ncs ae3cD jbus ns j'pcr~ kizcQ us n`c] Ukpiqp aib ns jc= nc jcubjbnh iu rfJr qvcD* kizcQ agicae\3 nb J3ck oq5 xlXD

rBcb i`cnag us aguizrc ks n`c] Ui`chct] Kg.cX7cQ vc_h aib ns ocXu isd ,n kc ty Bchc _D jhYrq Kg.cX7cQ nc jcub xiX _ vc_h aib ns jc= nc jcub LdMc _D lkb jznch jcub nb Bccar

i`curc nc 8j nq8j ns kcAc ncslX kIoY/c u`bd _D*

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

81/94

24

G3cg`cahn Ccu

vcpc3X o qHqr ns rbu a'c"3 AcsD rbucsd a'c"3csdnb ageclX nc ki3 vc3cD lk jh vcpc3X us murbucsd nb jhb{cc ysub pc`bD vcpc3X us n`c] Uny jzcr% ishb nqaQ3c isd vcucD* vcpc3X us hca= isdnqaQ3c ns icxX isd ncQs aoScsh ae3sD kqo` rbucsda'c"3 vjus&vjus 7ch ks xq# ns augck nb vcsh pyjM+sD icxX jh ncQs Acs] ysanu a'c"3 Bcb nitcsh u`bd AcsD j`yc a'c"3 ncQc sd nb pqBcu ns ocgtwe nqaQ3crn j qp x3cD ewkhc ncQcsd ks opnh auny vc3c aTh Bcb ,nc/c ncQc pqBc `b x3cD rbkhs a'c"3 usncQs esScs rcs mkus ncQcsd nb Mcay3csd ncs 7ckbQnh ewh Tsdn ae3cD aTh `cAc&iq /ccsnh nqaQ3c rn x3cDvcpc3X o qHqr rbucsd nb xaraga/c3c xc_h ks esSc h s AcsD rbkhc a'c"3 ^3csd b vc3c mY`csdus nqaQ3c ns }ch

Sccsy ae3s vc_h ocsys] Ug\k rqi ishb jhb{cc isd mcb.cX `cs x,D*Ccu g`b _ tcs G3g`ch isd nci vc,D rqI`chc Ccu G3cg`cahn `cs x3c _D rqi kdkch isd h`csxs

rcs rqI sd ncQsd u`bdpqBcsdxsvc_h rqi ewkhcsd ncs Bcb pqBcus u`bd ecsxsD aTh j`ys vc_h ewkhs a'c"3 nb vcshesScnh ocsys] UrqI`chb a'c{cc vBcb v/cwhb _D mcb.cX `csus isd vBcb ki3 yxsxcD*

mechrc

,n ow;+c vceib ic/cgu tb ns oxbps isd akh ubpc an3s /cbhs&/cbhs py h`c AccD gs 'cci nski3 oc`h vjub nqkbX jh o_Lnh nqE j;+ h s AcsD mk ow;+s ncs oqycnh jwEc & UncslX jhs'ccub _ N3ctcs lk rh` /cbhs&/cbhs kIBcynh pyrs `cs[*

ocsyc & Uocow] vcSccsd ks ni aeScclX jM+us yxc _D*ocsys & Uro p'ic yxc ycsD*ocsyc & Uj_ks n`c _d p'is ns ay,[*

ic/cgu tb us vjuc p'ic mks j`uus ncs ae3cD mkus Scq'c `csnh n`c & Ulkks rcs Scwo vVEcebScrc _D*ic/cgu tb us mks p'ic j`us h`us ncs n`cD ocsys & Uys tcvcs] lks yxcnh vjuc nci

pycvcssD*gs ro ks ecs g"ccsXd rn aouc p'is ns j;+clX&ayScclX vcae vjus kBcb nci&nct nhrs h sD ankb

us p'ic oucus ncs n`c Bcb rcs gs Qcy x3sD

kVpc hctc ncu [

,n och i`chctc h.ctbr akd vjus 'cc`b ocx isd 7cqi h s AcsD mkb ocx isd ,n oVpc nqETy jcus ns ay, jsM+csd jh j\Ach Tsdn h`c AccD ,n j\Ach i`chctc h.ctbr akd ncs yx x3cD munskcAc pyusgcys k_auncsd us j\Ach Tsdnusgcycsd nb ryc'c nb vc_h mk oVps ncs jnM+nh i`chct ns kciusys x,D to i`chct us mkks j\Ach Tsdnus nc nch.c jwEc rcs mkus orc3c an g` pch aeucsd ks BcwScc _D mks n`bd Bcb Sccuc u`bd aiyc Acc] lkay, g` j\Ach Tsdnnh Ty Sccnh vjub BcwSc aiQcuc pc`rcAccD

i`chctc h.ctbr akd us vjus k_auncsd ks jwEc] Ulk oVps ncs N3c e.M esuc pca`,[ kBcbk_auncsd us n`c an lks if\3qe.M es ae3c tc,D ysanu i`chctc h.ctbr akd us mks vces'c ae3c anlks jsQ Bch Sccuc aScyc3c tc, vc_h 3` atruc pc s mruc /cu lks es ae3c tc,D ko k_auncsd us

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

82/94

2Hbhci vc_h hcg.c ns obp Bcb"c.c 3q) py h`c AccD hcg.c ns ,n&,n nh kchs gbh 3cs)c ichs

tc h s AcsD ,skb jahaKAcar isd mkus nqIBcn.cX ncs txcus nb vcCc ebD nqIBcn.cX ncs txus jh ydnc isd`cs h s Bcb"c.c 3q) nb tcunchb aiybD mks 3` Bcb jrc pyc an agBcb"c.c ydnc EcsM+nh Hbhci ns j{cisd pys x3s _dD j`ys rcs nqIBcn.cX us vjus vxzt ncs icrc kbrc ncs vjr nh ycus ns ay, o qreq\nchc aTh hcg.c ns n`us jh 3q) Bcwai nb vcsh py jM+cD 3q) Bcwai isd agBcb"c.c ncs esScrs `b mkncxqKkc miM+ jM+c jh mkus vjus vcj ncs kd3r an3cD agBcb"c.c us nqIBcn.cX ncs jz.cci an3c ro

nqIBcn.cX ocsyc & Urq5s N3c vc'cbgcXe ewD aphdtbgb `csus nc ghecu rcs rqI sd ozc es pqns _dD*agBcb"c.c & Uiq5s 3`b vc'cb"c ebat3s an i_d kec /ciX ns icxX jh pywD*nqIBcn.cX & U3` ghecu Bcb rw jc pqnc _D N3c /ciX _ vc_h N3c v/ciX] 3` es'c&ncy ns a`kco

ks vyx&vyx `csrc _D*agBcb"c.c & U/ciX `is'cc ,n `csrc _D*nqIBcn.cX & Utbgu isd ,skc ki3 vcrc _ to /ciX kdnQ isd vc tcrc _D mk ki3

vjus&vjus kdKnch ns iqrcaon tbg vjuc&vjuc /ciX kqaua'pr nhrc _D t_ks i_dus vjus BcclX ns j{cks 3q) nhuc vjuc /ciX ki5c _ vc_h rqius od/cq ns kcAc ag'gck7ccr nhuc vjuc /ciX icucD *

agBcb"c.c & Ui_dus munc \3cx u`bd an3c oaZn i_d rcs mY sd ki5c h`c Acc an jhechc`h.c/ciXkdxr u`bd _D mY sd v/ciX ns icxX ks `Qcuc pc` h`c Acc] lkisd ishc N3c ecs"c _[*

nqIBcn.cX & U3ae 'chbh isd ncslX hcsx `cs tc3s rcs Bcb 'chbh Bcqtc nc \3cx u`bd nhrcD BcclX BcclXnb Bcqtc `csrc _D*

agBcb"c.c & Ueq"niX vc_h eqhcph.c ns ay, vjus oY/cq ncs Bcb e.M esuc vuqapr u`bdD*nqIBcn.cX & Uatks rw /ciX n` h`c _ mkks oM+c v/ciX nqE u`bd `cs knrcD lk nc3X ns ay,

nBcb kIicu nb efa"Q ks u`bd esScc tc3sxc rqI sdD atuks ai=rc nb _ muks a'c{cc yb `csrbD nc'c]

BcclX ns ay, Bchr ns \3cx vc_h y{i.c nb ksgc ncs esScc `csrcD*agBcb"c.c & UBchr vc_h y{i.c ns jeap ~u jh pyus ns ay, Hbhci t_kc BcclX Bcb `csuc pca`,D*nqIBcn.cX & UvVEs ns kcAc rcs kBcb vVEs `csrs _d aTh BcclX

vc_h BcclX nc ah'rc N3cD tc agBcb"c.c tc] vBcb iq5s ichus&ihus ns vycgc nqE u`bd kw5 h`c _Dvjus g'c isd u`bd w i_dD tc ishs BcclX! ishs ai=! ishs 'c=q!*

,skc n`rs&n`rs nqIBcn.cX vc_h agBcb"c.c ecsucsd nb vcScsdxbyb `cs tcrb _ddD agBcb"c.c auhc'c `csnhto yc_Qus yxrs _d rcs nqIBcn.cX vcgct+ esrc _ & UagBcb"c.c!*

7/21/2019 Param Prasang

94/94

agBcb"c.c BcclX nb vcsh iqM+rs _d ro nqIBcn.cX n` jM+rc _&U`i konc lkb rh` ih.c au/ccXahr _ rcs `i ihsdxs `b jh konc 'ccK=csNr aga/c ks a3c niX nh esuc N3csd an `iisd rw `b ,nic= tbagropsxcD*

agBcb"c.c vHqjwahr u3ucsd ks Hbhci nb vcsh py jM+rs _dD9

y{i.c ncs 3q)Bcwai isd is7cuce nc 'caNroc.c yx tcrc _ vc_h gs iwaVEXr `csrs _dD Hbhci nskcAc muns kBcb k`3csxb apdarr `cs tcrs _dD agBcb"c.c kyc` esrs _d an ydnc ns g_| kq"cs.c ncs ankbrh` yc3c tc3s rcs y{i.c t8h Lbn `cs tc3sdxsD kiK3c 3` Acb an g_| kq"cs.c 'c=qj{c ns keK3 nb3`c3rc nhus ncs hctb n_ks `csdxsD `uqicu tb ncs 3` nc3X kc_djc tcrc _D `uqicu tb ydnc tcnh g_|kq"cs.c ncs kchb kiK3c3sd orcrs _d vc_h kcAc pyus ns ay, vcxz nhrs `_dD kq"cs.c hctb u`bd `csrsD l/chki3 aunyrc tc h`c AccD kcspus vc_h iucus nc ki3 u`bd Acc lkay, gbh `uqicu g_| nb vauVEcns ocgtwe muncs 7ch ka`r mLcnh Hbhci ns kcius js'c nh esrs _ dD kq"cs.c n` jM+rs _d & Ui_d 'c=qj{cns ankb Bcb gbh nb apan\kc u`bd nh knrcD 3` ishs hct/ciX ns ag#) _D*

kq"cs.c g_| nb ocrcsd ncs kqunh Hbhci ocsy jM+rs _d & Ug_| nc /ciX konb jbM+c `huc _D g`ankb ,n kiqec3 nc u`bd] kchb icug tcar nc `csrc _D vcjns ay, g_| nc 'cc'gr /ciX `b icY3`csuc pca`,D hct/ciX ks Bcb 3` Hs"L _D*

kq"cs.c & Ui_d g_hb j{c nc w] va`r Bcb nh knrc wD*Hbhci & Ug_| ncs ncslX 'c=q vAcgc ncslX ai= u`bd `csrcD g_|+ vc_h hcsxb ns obp ag'gck nb ,n

vyc_ann Mcsh `csrb _D*aTh g_| us kdtbgub owQb ycus nb ocr n`bD `uqicu tb g` owQb Bcb yc3s vc_h y{i.c Lbn `cs

x3sDhcicuYe kcxh r hcic3 c /cchcgca`n ks kcBcch