Upload
others
View
9
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
International Journal of Science, Technology, Engineering and Management - A VTU Publication
2021; Vol: 3, No:1, pp:15-24
ISSN: 2582-5844(online)
© 2021 VTU Page No. 15
PERFORMANCE OF RECYCLED AGGREGATE CONCRETE ALONG
WITH POLYPROPYLENE FIBERS AT SUSTAINED ELEVATED
TEMPERATURE
Dr. N. Suresh a, Vadiraj Rao N R
*b
aDepartment of Civil Engineering, The National Institute of Engineering, Mysore, India;
b Department of Civil Engineering, The National Institute of Engineering, Mysore, India;
Abstract: The present investigation focus on the utilisation of Recycled Coarse Aggregates (RCA)
along with Fly ash and polypropylene fibers subjected to sustained elevated temperature. The research
describes the studies on Mechanical properties of Recycled Aggregate Concrete (RAC), namely flexural
strength, compressive strength and tensile strength at elevated temperatures. For the study of each
parameter, the specimens are subjected to elevated temperatures of 200, 400 and 600 degrees for 2
hours of duration.
A comparative study was made between the reference mix (with no replacements of RCA and fly ash)
to that of concrete with 20% and 30% fly ash replacements for cement and the corresponding 20%, 30%
& 40% replacements of RCA along with the addition of 0.5% of polypropylene fibers. The result
illustrates that for all combination of mixes, the compressive strength reduces at 200oC and 600oC,
while the compressive strength increases at 400oC. The tensile strength of different mixes reduces
gradually with the increase in temperature whereas an increase in flexural strength is observed at 400oC.
A R T I C L E H I S T O R Y
Received: 12-01-2021
Revised: 14-02-2021
Accepted: 10-03-2021
Keywords: Compressive strength, Recycled Aggregate Concrete (RAC), Flexural strength, Elevated temperature, Split tensile strength
1. INTRODUCTION
One of the primary issues facing our current society is environmental conservation. The reduction of energy consumption and natural resources are some of the key elements in this regard and simultaneous utilization of waste materials being generated. Hence, considerable attention is given on these topics under sustainable development.
Concrete being the most vital and commonly used material
in the construction industry has been used from many
decades, meaning that a tremendous quantity is utilized and
also have to continue using it. The concrete uses up large
quantities of natural resources and creates an impact on
environment because of the debris created by the demolition
waste, which is being generally discarded in landfills. The
primary components of concrete being cement, water, coarse
and fine aggregates with the major fraction being the coarse
aggregates i.e., nearly 65% of the concrete is made up of
coarse aggregates. The production of aggregates that are
naturally occurring resources requires mining from the
quarries resulting in the depletion of resources at a rapid
pace.
The primary attention being on the preservation of
ecosystem and management of natural resources along with
the issue of waste disposal in particular the demolition
rubble has become a major concern for planning engineers
and environmentalists, resulting in attempts to replace
natural materials with the waste generated from demolition
of different structures. Researchers have proposed an
adequate treatment and reuse of concrete as an aggregate of
new construction. In order to make this possible, a
considerable amount of scientific studies were carried out
globally, primarily engaged in the handing of demolished
concrete and its mix design along with mechanical properties
and enhancement of durability aspects.
16 IJESM – VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue. 1, pp. 15- 24 Dr. N. Suresh et. al.
While RCA are increasingly being used to render new
concrete in Western region and some of the far eastern
countries such as Japan and Korea, whereas there is a fairly
little understanding of the prospective use of these
aggregates in India. In addition, next to China India is the
world's largest cement user, implying that India is also one
of the primary consumers of concrete products such as fine
aggregates and coarse aggregates. Since aggregate resources
are not inexhaustible, information on the possible use of
RCA in the concrete manufacturing in India is essential.
The limitations of recycled concrete include higher creep,
larger drying shrinkage and greater chloride ion diffusion in
comparison with traditional concrete. This weakness shall be
negated by adding a definite volume of Fly ash to the
concrete, since Fly ash is expected to reduce the penetration
of concrete thereby reducing the creep, shrinkage and
chloride ion penetration [22].
It is clearly established that fire damage can cause explosive
spalling with the loss of strength due to spalling action of
some concretes under fire inhibits their usage in structures
requiring enhanced fire resistance. As a solution from the
literatures, the use of polypropylene fibres tends to be an
important step in reducing spalling of concrete. In addition,
the melting of polypropylene fibres provides an alternative
route that has been created, thereby releasing the internal
vapour pressure at higher temperatures [23]. The rationale
behind the experimental study is to assess the performance
of various mixes consisting of Recycled aggregates, Fly ash
and polypropylene fibers subjected to sustained higher
temperatures to produce concrete mixes, which comprises
more of sustainable materials without compromising the
performance.
The present investigation is to study the mechanical properties of RAC like flexural strength, compressive and split tensile strengths of mixes for different percentages of RCA, along with fly ash and 0.5% polypropylene fibers at sustained elevated temperatures of 200
0C, 400
0C and 600
0C
for 2 hours of duration.
1.1 LITERATURE REVIEW
Increased proportions of recycled aggregates in concrete can reduce the efficiency of masonry mortars, which cannot be compensated easily, but the majority of recycled aggregate mortars for descriptive applications has shown similar performances to traditional mortars and comply with the guidelines of European standards [1].
The applications of RAC have drawn global attention owing
to its socio, ecological and economic benefits in the future.
Out of several reasons, one important reason for utilizing
RAC in buildings is the resistance to spalling and improved
post-fire residual properties. With the inclusion of steel
fibers, the development of cracks gets postponed and
confines the crack opening in RAC thereby considerably
enhancing the fracture toughness and fracture energy of
RAC at elevated temperatures [2].
The fresh and rheological properties of SCC (Self-Compacting Concrete) with RCA both as fine and coarse aggregates reveals that Self Compacting qualities of concrete improves significantly with the levels of replacement
percentages of recycled coarse and fine aggregates included in the mixes for testing [3]. Also the structural behavior of elements casted using coarse aggregates of crushed recycled concrete from redundant components of the precast concrete industry had little influence on young’s modulus of elasticity [4].
The feasibility and quality of RCA obtained from crushed blocks of concrete obtained from demolished buildings had shown that RCA offers lower resistance to freezing / thawing than natural aggregates, but the degradation measured by Micro-Deval index, water absorption and porosity is less important [5]. Further, the properties of High Performance Concrete declines with the reduction in quality of RCA obtained from lower to higher grades of concrete [6].
RCA can be a potential answer for sustainability
developments since its residual performance was more often
comparable but slightly lower than the reference mixes
considered. In addition, the existence of impurities of non-
cementitious particles speeds up the damages on concrete at
higher temperatures [7].
The Mixed usage of Recycled Aggregates (MRA) as fine or
coarse aggregates fraction and the amount of usage of
cement showed decrease in permeability and strength of
concretes produced from sulphate resistant cement with the
increase in amount of MRA [8].
Studies were carried out on the concrete consisting of RCA
and insulation type of aggregates. A Recycled Aggregate
Thermal Insulation Concrete (RATIC) was created to lessen
the impact on environment with the improvement in
efficiency of the buildings. The study confirmed that beyond
400oC the residual compressive strength of concrete at
elevated temperatures reduces considerably and modulus of
elasticity deteriorates earlier than strength. Based on the
investigation, equations are developed for predicting
ultimate strain, peak strain, elastic modulus and residual
strength of RATIC after the exposure to higher temperatures
along with the compressive stress-strain relationship [9].
The inclusion of RCA in Hot-Mix Asphalt (HMA) can be a
means for encouraging sustainability in construction.
Presently, various investigators have evaluated the utilisation
of RCA in hot-mix asphalt. The results showed that HMA
with Recycled coarse aggregates covered with bitumen
emulsion displayed similar mechanical properties compared
to regular concrete mixes [10].
The Durability aspects of SCC prepared with RCA as full or
partial substitution for Natural Coarse Aggregates (NCA)
along with partial replacement of mineral admixtures for
cement were examined. The results showed that with the
usage of Metakaolin (MK) or Silica Fume (SF) at 10% by
weight of cement compensates for the lowering of durability
properties with 50% replacement of RCA, with Meta Kaolin
being more efficient than Silica Fume. At 100% replacement
of RCA for NCA, the mentioned pozzolans were inefficient
in balancing the loss of durability properties [11].
Shi Cong Kou et al had studied the influence of Fly ash as
Replacement for Cement on the Properties of RAC. The
study deals with the deficiency in the utilisation of recycled
aggregates by scientifically proving the results of including
Performance of recycled aggregate concrete along with polypropyle
Class F Fly ash on concrete properties. The outcome
indicated that the realistic way to develop a greater
percentage of RAC in concrete used for structures is by
including 25–35% Fly ash, so that the drawbacks persuading
with the usage of RA in concrete could be reduced [22].
Salah R et al. investigated on the Residual Mechanical
properties of RAC after subjecting the specimens
temperatures. The authors conducted an investigation where
six types of mixes was developed with combinations for
coarse aggregates produced from crushed limestone
aggregates, Recycled Concrete Aggregates (RCA) and river
gravel. The results indicated that for complete or partial
replacement of RCA for natural aggregates shows better
performance at elevated temperatures and are
to regular concrete. Further, no disintegration of concrete
specimens was observed in RCA concrete at elevated
temperature of nearly 750°C. The residual mechanical
properties show variations among the concrete mixtures with
various percentages of replacement for RCA [24].
1.2. Concrete at Sustained Elevated Temperature
Concrete when subjected to elevated temperature undergo
several transformations. Since aggregate occupies nearly 70
percent of volume in concrete, the behavior
elevated temperatures is largely affected by
aggregates used in concrete. The characteristics of
aggregates such as thermal expansion, thermal conductivity
and chemical stability plays a vital part in studying the
performance of concrete at elevated temperature.
1.3. Materials & Mix Proportions
Cement, Natural Coarse aggregates, Fine aggregates, Fly
ash, Water and Recycled coarse aggregates are used in
casting of specimens.
Cement: The cement used is Ordinary Portland cement
(OPC) of 53 grade which confirms to IS 12269:1987 with
the following properties - Specific gravity
fineness-2%, Standard consistency-27.75%, Initial setting
time and final setting time of 118 minutes and 255 minutes
respectively
Fine aggregates: Zone II Manufactured sand conforming to
IS 383- 1970, having a density of 1612 Kg/ m
gravity of 2.63 is used
Coarse aggregates: Crushed granite which are locally
available conforming to IS 383- 1970, with a Specific
gravity of 2.65 and passing through 20 mm sieve were used
as coarse aggregates.
Mineral admixture: Class F Fly ash is used which conforms
to IS 3812:2003 (part-1) with specific gravity of 2.01 and
18% standard consistency.
Polypropylene Fibers: Recron3S fibers of type CTP 2024
of Reliance make with length of 12 mm, melting point of
160-165OC with Specific gravity 0.90.
Water: Regular tap water that is free from salts and
impurities is used.
Performance of recycled aggregate concrete along with polypropylene fibers at sustained elevated temperature IJESM
on concrete properties. The outcome
indicated that the realistic way to develop a greater
n concrete used for structures is by
, so that the drawbacks persuading
with the usage of RA in concrete could be reduced [22].
Salah R et al. investigated on the Residual Mechanical
properties of RAC after subjecting the specimens to higher
temperatures. The authors conducted an investigation where
six types of mixes was developed with combinations for
coarse aggregates produced from crushed limestone
aggregates, Recycled Concrete Aggregates (RCA) and river
ated that for complete or partial
replacement of RCA for natural aggregates shows better
performance at elevated temperatures and are nearly similar
no disintegration of concrete
specimens was observed in RCA concrete at elevated
temperature of nearly 750°C. The residual mechanical
properties show variations among the concrete mixtures with
various percentages of replacement for RCA [24].
e at Sustained Elevated Temperature
Concrete when subjected to elevated temperature undergo
several transformations. Since aggregate occupies nearly 70
behavior of concrete at
elevated temperatures is largely affected by the type of
aggregates used in concrete. The characteristics of
aggregates such as thermal expansion, thermal conductivity
and chemical stability plays a vital part in studying the
performance of concrete at elevated temperature.
Cement, Natural Coarse aggregates, Fine aggregates, Fly
ash, Water and Recycled coarse aggregates are used in
: The cement used is Ordinary Portland cement
(OPC) of 53 grade which confirms to IS 12269:1987 with
Specific gravity-3.14, percentage
27.75%, Initial setting
time and final setting time of 118 minutes and 255 minutes
: Zone II Manufactured sand conforming to
ing a density of 1612 Kg/ m3 and specific
: Crushed granite which are locally
1970, with a Specific
gravity of 2.65 and passing through 20 mm sieve were used
: Class F Fly ash is used which conforms
1) with specific gravity of 2.01 and
: Recron3S fibers of type CTP 2024
of Reliance make with length of 12 mm, melting point of
water that is free from salts and
Recycled Coarse Aggregates (
a) The waste concrete cubes and
in the laboratory are collected and transported to the
crushing yard.
b) The samples were fed and crushed by mechanical crushers
c) The crushed samples are segregated into the respective
sizes of 4.75mm, 12.5mm, 20mm down etc.
d) The different sizes of aggregates are dumped
and transported
e) Since the crushing machine used for RCA is same as that
of NCA, the RCA obtained will be of similar in size of
that of NCA
IJESM - VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue.1 17
ggregates (RCA)
The waste concrete cubes and cylinders, which were tested
are collected and transported to the
The samples were fed and crushed by mechanical crushers
The crushed samples are segregated into the respective
sizes of 4.75mm, 12.5mm, 20mm down etc.
The different sizes of aggregates are dumped separately
Since the crushing machine used for RCA is same as that
of NCA, the RCA obtained will be of similar in size of
16 IJESM – VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue. 1, pp. 15
Fig1. Different Stages of Production of RCA
*Details of Corresponding Author: AddressDepartment of Civil Engineering, The National Institute of EngineeringMysore; Phone No.-9986590409; E-mail – [email protected]
18 5- 24
Different Stages of Production of RCA
Address:-Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, The National Institute of Engineering,
Table 1: Properties of NA and RCA
Table 2: Mix proportions of different concrete
mixes
Mix identification
RC1 = Regular concrete without any replacements along
with 0.5% PPF
RC2 = Concrete mix with 20%
cement + 20% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
+ addition of 0.5% PPF
RC3 = Concrete mix with 20%
cement + 30% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
+ addition of 0.5% PPF
RC4 = Concrete mix with 20%
cement + 40% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
+ addition of 0.5% PPF
Type of
aggregates
Loose
density
(kg/m3)
Compacted
bulk density
(kg/m3 )
Natural
aggregates
(NA)
1392.5 1604.4
Recycled
Coarse
aggregates
(RCA)
1266.7 1515.5
Material RC1 RC2 RC3
NCA
(kg/m3) 1133 906.5 793
RCA
(kg/m3) ----- 226 340
M-sand
(kg/m3) 657.3 657.3 657.3
Cement
(kg/m3) 394 315.2 315.2
Fly ash
(kg/m3) --------- 78.8 78.8
Water
(lts) 224 228 231
Dr. N. Suresh et. al.
Properties of NA and RCA
Mix proportions of different concrete
mixes
RC1 = Regular concrete without any replacements along
RC2 = Concrete mix with 20% Fly ash as replacement for
cement + 20% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
RC3 = Concrete mix with 20% Fly ash as replacement for
cement + 30% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
th 20% Fly ash as replacement for
cement + 40% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
Specific
gravity
Fineness
modulus
Water
absorpt
ion
2.76 2.2 0.5%
2.54 4.1 3%
RC4 RC5 RC6 RC7
680 906.5 793 680
453 226 340 453
657.3 657.3 657.3 657.3
315.2 275.8 275.8 275.8
78.8 118.2 118.2 118.2
233.7 226.4 229 231.6
Performance of recycled aggregate concrete along with polypropyle
RC5 = Concrete mix with 30% Fly ash
cement + 20% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
+ addition of 0.5% PPF
RC6 = Concrete mix with 30% Fly ash
cement + 30% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
+ addition of 0.5% PPF
RC7 = Concrete mix with 30% Fly ash
cement + 40% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
+ addition of 0.5% PPF
2. EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM
2.1 Mixing and casting of concrete
At first, thorough mixing of coarse and fine aggregates was
done. After getting the homogeneous mixture, cement was
added and further mixing was continued. Meanwhile the
Polypropylene fibers which were soaked in water are added
to the mixer at regular intervals along with water. Finally
concrete was mixed until obtaining a homogeneous and
consistent mix.
2.2 Curing of concrete
The demoulded concrete specimens a
immersed in water for curing.
Fig 2. Curing of specimens
2.3 Heating of specimens
After curing, the specimens were allowed for surface drying
and exposed to 200, 400 and 600°C of sustained elevated
temperatures for 2 hours duration. Post exposure, the
specimens were cooled to room temperature inside the
furnace and later removed for testing.
Performance of recycled aggregate concrete along with polypropylene fibers at sustained elevated temperature IJESM
Fly ash as replacement for
cement + 20% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
Fly ash as replacement for
cement + 30% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
Fly ash as replacement for
cement + 40% RCA as a replacement for natural aggregates
At first, thorough mixing of coarse and fine aggregates was
mixture, cement was
added and further mixing was continued. Meanwhile the
Polypropylene fibers which were soaked in water are added
to the mixer at regular intervals along with water. Finally
concrete was mixed until obtaining a homogeneous and
The demoulded concrete specimens after 24hrs were
were allowed for surface drying
and exposed to 200, 400 and 600°C of sustained elevated
temperatures for 2 hours duration. Post exposure, the
specimens were cooled to room temperature inside the
Fig 3. Specimens kept inside the oven for subjecting it to
elevated temperature
An electric oven with digital control panel, capable of
attaining 1000°C is used to elevate the temperature of the
specimens.
Further, the samples were tested for different properties.
Under each type of sample at a particular temperature, three
specimens of prisms, cylinders and cubes were tested. The
results obtained are tabulated for the average values. The
increase in the temperature was gradual and the rise in
temperature with respect to time is shown in Fig 4.
Fig 4. Graph showing Time v/s Temperature variation
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
In the current study, the results of the mechanical properties
i.e., flexural strength, split tensile strength and compressive
strength for mixes containing natural coarse aggregates
(NCA) and recycled coarse aggregates (RCA) at normal and
elevated temperatures were discussed.
IJESM - VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue.1 17
ept inside the oven for subjecting it to
elevated temperature
An electric oven with digital control panel, capable of
attaining 1000°C is used to elevate the temperature of the
Further, the samples were tested for different properties.
ch type of sample at a particular temperature, three
specimens of prisms, cylinders and cubes were tested. The
tabulated for the average values. The
increase in the temperature was gradual and the rise in
me is shown in Fig 4.
Graph showing Time v/s Temperature variation
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
In the current study, the results of the mechanical properties
i.e., flexural strength, split tensile strength and compressive
containing natural coarse aggregates
(NCA) and recycled coarse aggregates (RCA) at normal and
elevated temperatures were discussed.
19
16 IJESM – VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue. 1, pp. 15
3.1 RESIDUAL COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH
Fig 5. Testing for Compressive strength of concrete
Table 3. Residual comp. strength of various mixes
(in MPa) at different temperatures
Fig 6. Graph showing the variation in residual compressive
strength of the mixes at different temperatures
The following observations are made from the
graph of residual comp. strength at
temperatures.
20 5- 24
RESIDUAL COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH
strength of concrete
of various mixes
(in MPa) at different temperatures
Fig 6. Graph showing the variation in residual compressive
strength of the mixes at different temperatures
The following observations are made from the
graph of residual comp. strength at various
In general, for each mix considered, the
compressive strength drops down at 200
600oC whereas an increase of comp. strength is
noticed at 400oC for most of the mixes.
The maximum compressive strength of
43.75MPa is obtained for
minimum of 28.12 MPa for RC2 at 600
The strength of the reference mix (RC1) is lesser in
comparison with the mixes containing fly ash
(replacement for cement). This shows that cement can
be partially replaced without the loss of streng
After exposure to 4000C, the specimens showed improved
residual comp. strength in comparison to exposure after
2000C. This observation has been made by several
researchers which are reasoned as a outcome of re
of CSH at nearly 3000C, especially when water migrates and
concentrate in the colder areas of concrete [27].
3.2 RESIDUAL SPLIT TENSILE STRENGTH
This indicates the tensile property of the concrete. The
testing procedure is carried out as per IS 516
cylindrical specimens, which were subjected to elevated
temperatures, are tested and the results were tabulated.
Fig 7. Testing for Split tensile strength of concrete
Table 4. Residual split tensile strength (in MPa) for
various mixes at different
Dr. N. Suresh et. al.
In general, for each mix considered, the
compressive strength drops down at 200oC and
C whereas an increase of comp. strength is
C for most of the mixes.
The maximum compressive strength of
43.75MPa is obtained for RC3 at RT, and a
minimum of 28.12 MPa for RC2 at 600oC.
The strength of the reference mix (RC1) is lesser in
comparison with the mixes containing fly ash
(replacement for cement). This shows that cement can
be partially replaced without the loss of strength.
C, the specimens showed improved
residual comp. strength in comparison to exposure after
C. This observation has been made by several
researchers which are reasoned as a outcome of re-hydration
especially when water migrates and
concentrate in the colder areas of concrete [27].
RESIDUAL SPLIT TENSILE STRENGTH
This indicates the tensile property of the concrete. The
testing procedure is carried out as per IS 516-1959. The
, which were subjected to elevated
are tested and the results were tabulated.
Fig 7. Testing for Split tensile strength of concrete
. Residual split tensile strength (in MPa) for
various mixes at different temperatures
Performance of recycled aggregate concrete along with polypropyle
Fig 8. Graph showing the variations in residual split tensile
strength of the mixes at different temperatures
The following observations were made from the graph of
residual split tensile strength at different temperatures
For majority of the mixes the tensile strength decreases
gradually as the temperature increases
There is an increase in strength for most of the mixes at
400oC in comparison with 200
oC, Further a substantial
reduction in tensile strength is observed at 600
The maximum tensile strength is observed for RC3 and
minimum for RC7 mix
The tensile strength of the reference mix (RC1) is
lacking in comparison with the mixes containing fly ash
(replacement for cement)
The tensile behavior is largely associated to
the mixes at interfaces. In comparison to the comp. strength,
the development of tensile strength with increase in
temperature demonstrates higher variations among
conventional concrete and RAC. The decrease in split tensile
strength at higher temperatures can be attributed to higher
no. of interfaces in the RAC, enhancing the progress of
cracks thereby reducing the tensile strength [27].
3.3 RESIDUAL FLEXURAL STRENGTH OF PRISMS
The testing procedure adapted is according to IS 516
Prisms were used for determining the flexural
which were subjected to elevated temperature.
Performance of recycled aggregate concrete along with polypropylene fibers at sustained elevated temperature IJESM
Fig 8. Graph showing the variations in residual split tensile
strength of the mixes at different temperatures
The following observations were made from the graph of
residual split tensile strength at different temperatures
For majority of the mixes the tensile strength decreases
gradually as the temperature increases
There is an increase in strength for most of the mixes at
C, Further a substantial
reduction in tensile strength is observed at 600oC
The maximum tensile strength is observed for RC3 and
The tensile strength of the reference mix (RC1) is
lacking in comparison with the mixes containing fly ash
The tensile behavior is largely associated to the strength of
the mixes at interfaces. In comparison to the comp. strength,
the development of tensile strength with increase in
temperature demonstrates higher variations among
conventional concrete and RAC. The decrease in split tensile
gher temperatures can be attributed to higher
no. of interfaces in the RAC, enhancing the progress of
cracks thereby reducing the tensile strength [27].
RESIDUAL FLEXURAL STRENGTH OF PRISMS
ing to IS 516-1959.
ed for determining the flexural strength,
which were subjected to elevated temperature.
Fig 9. Flexural strength test
Table 5. Residual flexural strength (in MPa) of
various mixes at different temperatures
P
Fig 10. Graph showing the variation in residual flexural
strength of the mixes at different temperatures
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
25 200
Fle
xu
ral
Str
en
gth
(in
Mp
a)
Temperature in
Flexural strength results
IJESM - VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue.1 17
Fig 9. Flexural strength test
. Residual flexural strength (in MPa) of
different temperatures
Fig 10. Graph showing the variation in residual flexural
strength of the mixes at different temperatures
400 600
Temperature in oC
Flexural strength results
RC1
RC2
RC3
RC4
RC5
RC6
RC7
21
16 IJESM – VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue. 1, pp. 15- 24 Dr. N. Suresh et. al.
The following observations are made from the graph
regarding the residual flexural strength at different elevated
temperatures
For most of the mixes, the decrease in flexural strength
was noticed at 200oC and further an increase at 400
oC
For all the mixes at 600oC, the loss in flexural strength is
more than 50%.
Maximum flexural strength of 7.68MPa is observed for
RC6 at room temperature and minimum strength is for
the Reference mix.
The flexural strength of the reference mix (RC1) is
lesser in comparison with the mixes containing fly ash
(replacement for cement). This shows that cement can
be partially replaced without the loss of flexural
strength.
4.0 CONCLUSIONS
From the studies made on the RAC along with replacement
of Fly ash for cement the following important conclusion can
be made
1. For practical considerations, maximum of 0.5 %
polypropylene fibers can be used effectively in the mixes.
Higher percentages of fiber results in the decrease in
workability of concrete
2. At 200oC the residual comp. strength of all the mixes
decreases considerably when compared to room
temperature. Further at 400oC, most of the mixes show
increase in the residual comp. strength
3. The residual split tensile strength of specimens reduces
with increase in temperature i.e., nearly 40% reduction
occurs at 600oC
4. At room temperature, flexural strength of the mixes
increases with the introduction of fibers. Also the
residual flexural strength decreases by more than 50% at
600oC
5. From the results of 7 mixes (i.e., out of 84 cubes, 84
cylinders and 84 prisms), the ideal being RC2 and RC6,
showing better compressive, flexure and tensile
properties
6. The mix RC2 consisting of 20% fly ash (replacement for
cement) + 20% RCA (replacement for natural
aggregates) and RC6 consisting of 30% fly ash
(replacement for cement) + 30% RCA (replacement for
natural aggregates) along with 0.5% PPF provides better
performance which signifies that cement can be replaced
by fly ash between 20 to 30 percent along with same
amount of replacement for RCA for natural aggregates
7. Finally it can be inferred that, the addition of recycled
aggregates (from 20-30%), fly ash, along with
polypropylene fibers improves the concrete properties.
Further, as the mixes consists more of supplementary
materials, it largely helps in sustainable construction
5.0 REFERENCES
1) R.V. Silva, J. de Brito, R.K. Dhir “Performance of
cementitious renderings and masonry mortars
containing recycled aggregates from construction
and demolition wastes” Construction and Building
Materials 105 (2016) 400–415
2) G.M. Chen, H. Yang, C.J. Lin, J.F. Chen, Y.H. He,
H.Z. Zhang ”Fracture behavior of steel fiber
reinforced recycled aggregate concrete after
exposure to elevated temperatures” Construction
and Building Materials 128 (2016) 272–286.
3) Erhan Güneyisi, Mehmet Gesoglu, ZeynepAlgın,
HalitYazıcı “Rheological and fresh properties of
self-compacting concretes containing “coarse and
fine recycled concrete aggregates” Construction and
Building Materials 113 (2016) 622–630.
4) J. Pacheco, J. de Brito, J. Ferreira, D. Soares
“Flexural load tests of full-scale recycled
aggregates concrete structures” Construction and
Building Materials 101 (2015) 65–71.
5) Safiullah Omary, Elhem Ghorbel, George Wardeh
“Relationships between recycled concrete
aggregates characteristics and recycled aggregates
concretes properties” Construction and Building
Materials 108 (2016) 163–174
6) Andreu Gonzalez-Corominas, Miren Etxeberria
“Effects of using recycled concrete aggregates on
the shrinkage of high performance concrete”
Construction and Building Materials 115 (2016)
32–41.
7) Cléo Laneyrie, Anne-LiseBeaucour, Mark F.Green,
Ronan L. Hebert, Béatrice Ledesert, Albert
Noumowe “Influence of recycled coarse aggregates
on normal and high performance concrete subjected
to elevated temperatures” Construction and
Building Materials 111 (2016) 368–378
8) Benito Mas, Antoni Cladera, Jeroni Bestard, Denis
Muntaner, Catalina Elena López, Silvia Piña, Jesús
Prades “Concrete with mixed recycled aggregates:
Influence of the type of cement” Construction and
Building Materials 34 (2012) 430–441
9) Yuanzhen Liu, Wenjing Wanga, Y. Frank Chen,
HaifengJi “Residual stress-strain relationship for
thermal insulation concrete with recycled aggregate
after high temperature exposure” Construction and
Building Materials 129 (2016) 37–47
10) A.R. Pasandín, I. Pérez “Mechanical properties of
hot-mix asphalt made with recycled concrete
aggregates coated with bitumen emulsion”
Construction and Building Materials 55 (2014)
350–358
11) Kanish Kapoor M.E., Research Scholar, S.P. Singh,
Bhupinder Singh “Durability of self-compacting
concrete made with Recycled Concrete Aggregates
22
Performance of recycled aggregate concrete along with polypropylene fibers at sustained elevated temperature IJESM - VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue.1 17
and mineral admixtures” Construction and Building
Materials 128 (2016) 67–76
12) Sumit Arora, S.P. Singh “Analysis of flexural
fatigue failure of concrete made with 100% Coarse
Recycled Concrete Aggregates” Construction and
Building Materials 102 (2016) 782–791
13) Sindy Seara-Paz , Belén González-Fonteboa,
Fernando Martínez-Abell, Iris González-Taboada
“Time-dependent behavior of structural concrete
made with recycled coarse aggregates. Creep and
shrinkage” Construction and Building Materials 122
(2016) 95–109
14) Andreu Gonzalez-Corominas, Miren Etxeberria,
Chi Sun Poon “Influence of steam curing on the
pore structures and mechanical properties of fly-ash
high performance concrete prepared with recycled
aggregates” Cement and Concrete Composites 71
(2016) 77-84
15) Lilia Señas, Carla Priano, SilvinaMarfil “Influence
of recycled aggregates on properties of self-
consolidating Concretes” Construction and Building
Materials 113 (2016) 498–505
16) S. Laserna, J. Montero “Influence of natural
aggregates typology on recycled concrete strength
properties” Construction and Building Materials
115 (2016) 78–86
17) M. Quattrone, B. Cazacliu, S.C. Angulo, E.
Hamard, A. Cothenet “Measuring the water
absorption of recycled aggregates, what is the best
practice for concrete production?”Construction and
Building Materials 123 (2016) 690–703
18) F. Delobel, D. Bulteel, J.M. Mechling, A. Lecomte,
M. Cyr, S. Rémond “Application of ASR tests to
recycled concrete aggregates: Influence of water
absorption” Construction and Building Materials
124 (2016) 714–721
19) YueGeng, Yuyin Wang, Jie Chen “Creep behavior
of concrete using recycled coarse aggregates
obtained from source concrete with different
strengths” Construction and Building Materials 128
(2016) 199–213
20) B. Gómez-Meijide, I. Pérez , G. Airey, N. Thomb
“Stiffness of cold asphalt mixtures with recycled
aggregates from construction and demolition waste”
Construction and Building Materials 77 (2015)
168–178
21) A.R. Pasandín, I. Pérez “Overview of bituminous
mixtures made with recycled concrete aggregates”
Construction and Building Materials 74 (2015)
151–161
22) Shi Cong Kou; Chi Sun Poon; and Dixon Chan
“Influence of Fly Ash as Cement Replacement on
the Properties of Recycled Aggregate Concrete”
Journal of materials in civil engineering., 19(9)
(2007) 709-717
23) K.K. Sideris, P. Manita “Residual mechanical
characteristics and spalling resistance of fiber
reinforced self-compacting concretes exposed to
elevated temperatures” Construction and Building
Materials 41 (2013) 296–302
24) Salah R. Sarhat and Edward. G. Sherwood
“Residual Mechanical Response of Recycled
Aggregate Concrete after Exposure to Elevated
Temperatures” Journal of materials in civil
engineering, 25(11), (2013), 1721-1730
25) Zega, C. J., and Di Maio, A. A.“Recycled concrete
exposed to high temperatures.” Mag. Concrete Res.,
58(10), (2006), 675–682
26) Abou-Zeid, M. N., Shenouda, M. N., McCabe, S.
L., and El-Tawil, F. A. “Reincarnation of concrete.”
Concr. Int., 27(2), (2005), 53–59
27) Cléo Laneyrie, Anne-Lise Beaucour , Mark F.
Green, Ronan L. Hebert, Béatrice Ledesert, Albert
Noumowe “Influence of recycled coarse aggregates
on normal and high performance concrete subjected
to elevated temperatures” Construction and
Building Materials 111 (2016) 368–378
Code Books
28) IS 456:2000-IS (Indian Standard), Plain and
Reinforced Concrete – Code of Practice
29) IS 383:1970 – IS (Indian Standard), Specification
for Coarse and Fine aggregates from natural sources
for concrete
30) IS 516:1959-IS (Indian Standards), Methods of tests
for Strength of Concrete
31) IS 650:1991- IS (Indian Standards), Standard sand
for testing cement-Specification
32) IS 10262:2009-IS (Indian Standard), Indian
Standards Concrete mix proportioning guidelines
23
16 IJESM – VTU, 2021, Vol. 3, Issue. 1, pp. 15- 24 Dr. N. Suresh et. al.
Brief Biodata of authors
a. Dr. N. SURESH
Dr. N. Suresh, currently Professor of Civil
Engineering, and Director of the Building Fire
Research Centre (BFRC) at The National Institute of
Engineering, Mysuru. With a doctorate from Anna
University, Chennai, in Structural Engineering, he
has over 100 papers in journals and conferences. He
is a member of Cement and Concrete (CED-2) and
Fire Fighting (CED-22) committees of Bureau of
Indian Standards. He has been involved in many
projects with national and international universities.
b. VADIRAJ RAO N R
Mr. VADIRAJ RAO N R had completed his B.E &
M. Tech from Visveswaraiah Technological
University (VTU), Belgaum. He had worked as a
structural engineer in various consultancy firms
including L&T constructions. His areas of interest
includes structural engineering, design of RC
structures and concrete subjected to elevated
temperatures. Presently he is working as an assistant
professor in the department of civil engineering, NIE,
Mysore
24