1
orosity is one of those properties with "kill or cure" effectiveness. In the right hands, in the right product, it confers exquisite performance. In the wrong hands or inappropriate application it can stop the process/product, dead in its tracks! Porosity should be well understood, easily identied, quantiable and controllable. Why is it then, that it can be so easily overlooked or misunderstood? A Porous Overview Porous properties impact/confer on a ceramic, both positive and negative. Porosity is obviously desirable in light-weight products, thermal insulation, catalyst supports, wicking and ltration uses. Negative aspects include friability, loss of strength, undesirable uid absorption etc. The forming of ceramics from powders necessarily generates porosity by xing, in 3-dimensions, positions and relationships of interparticle voids. Low pressure forming methods generate higher porosity and higher pressures produce less. Thermal treatment, be it simultaneous with forming (HIP) or subsequent to it (normal ring) is used to eliminate some, most or all porosity depending on end use. The size of the pores depends on the particle size distribution and shape of the starting powders and various additives (binders, liquids). Of course, the la creates porosity in the initial stages of ring due to their loss or burning out. As sintering is initiated small pores may coalesce into larger ones with e or no loss of overall pore volume. Loss of pore volume (porosity) must be accompanied by shrinkage of the piece. Your Pore Problems Begin Trouble begins by not in place a program of pore volume and size monitoring at all stages of production. From consideration of mass, true density and geometric (envelope) volume one might believe one has all the information needed… just calculate porosity. Maybe even determine it explicitly by water absorption. But not knowing the pore size distribution can lead to serious misunderstandings. You are probably familiar with looking at particle size distributions and making certain deductions. That's OK for loose powders, but even then one cannot deduce how homogeneous the blend is from a size analysis. But when the particles a ain a xed spatial order by pressing, casting, extrusion etc., the resulting pore size distribution plot will reveal the homogeneity of the blend as it exited the forming process. If it's worth proceeding, you will now be able to understand the path along which the sintering process might take. Small pores will be the most thermally "reactive", larger pores less so. Therefore don't be surprised if the nal piece still has porosity - if it started out with predominantly large pores. Remember, the nal porosity is not just a function of initial porosity but also of pore size. Measuring Pore Size Quickly and Reliably The best available measurement method is Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry: rapid (orders of magnitude faster than gas sorption) very wide dynamic range (orders of magnitude larger than gas sorption - unrivaled for pores over 0.25 microns) and yielding network structure (more evident than gas sorption because the uid penetration is sequential or serial in nature). Mercury intrudes from the outside, in, and while there exists a pressure-pore size relationship, it is subject to the arrangement and connectivity of the different pores sizes in the network of internal voids. Therefore, the result not only yields pore size information but also structural or network information. The forced intrusion of non-we mercury into a pore network by applying an external force has been used commercially for the best part of sixty years. So why is it not more widely used? Perhaps it was the lack of automation, the lack of interpretation skills or maybe noise and expense? But that is not now the case. Modern mercury intrusion porosimeters oer high throughput, very wide pore size range, a host of automated features and near-silent operation. Many analyses can be completed in een minutes or less - on two samples at one time. So, when you need pore size information for R&D, process control and quality assurance in all elds of ceramics, consider using the mercury porosimetry method. Mercury porosimetry may reveal porosity where there should be none, identify o-spec green ceramics and allow them to be removed from the remaining processes, and to optimize ring conditions. A all, kilns are not inexpensive to operate. For more information about fuel cells and related measurement instruments, contact Quantachrome Instruments by phone: (561) 731.4999, fax: (561) 732.9888, email: [email protected] or visit www.quantachrome.com. P & Structural Materials Ceramics Pore size is calculated using the Washburn equation: Pore diameter = - (4 γ cos θ )/ P Where γ = surface tension, P = pressure and θ = contact angle. Pore size range is from approximately 1mm down to 3.5nm Pore volume resolution be than 0.1 microlitre. Pressures required as high as 60,000 psi, achieved using specially designed hydraulic pressure generators. Featured in a number of standard test methods including ASTM D4284, ASTM D4404, ASTM D2873, UOP578-02, BS7591-1. Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry Facts Porous Problems: Porous Problems: by: Martin A. Thomas Ph.D., Director of Business Development Quantachrome Instruments ([email protected]) Rid Yourself of Unwanted or Unexplained Porosity In Your Final Product. The PoreMaster GT ® uses the extremely effective rapid mercury intrusion technique. With automatic pore size and pore volume distribution analyzers, you will never have porosity inconsistency in your products again. F o r a n s w e r s t o y o u r p o r o s i t y r e l a t e d q u e s t i o n s a n d t o s p e a k t o a Q u a n t a c h r o m e c o n s u l t a n t , c a l l u s a t 5 6 1 . 7 3 1 . 4 9 9 9 o r e m a i l u s a t Advanced Features: -Automatic air purge -Vapor trap -Extremely quiet Three Operating Modes: -Pressure Scanning -Autospeed -Step-wise PoreMaster GT ® w w w . q u a n t a c h r o m e . c o m © 2004-2010 Quantachrome Corporation [email protected]

PorousPorous Problems:Problems: Ceramics · The forming of ceramics from powders necessarily generates porosity by fixing, in 3-dimensions, positions and relationships of interparticle

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: PorousPorous Problems:Problems: Ceramics · The forming of ceramics from powders necessarily generates porosity by fixing, in 3-dimensions, positions and relationships of interparticle

orosity is one of those properties with "kill orcure" effectiveness. In the right hands, in theright product, it confers exquisite performance.

In the wrong hands or inappropriate application it canstop the process/product, dead in its tracks! Porosityshould be well understood, easily identified,quantifiable and controllable. Why is it then, that itcan be so easily overlooked or misunderstood?

A Porous OverviewPorous properties impact/confer on a ceramic, bothpositive and negative. Porosity is obviously desirablein light-weight products, thermal insulation, catalystsupports, wicking and filtration uses. Negative aspectsinclude friability, loss of strength, undesirable fluidabsorption etc.

The forming of ceramics from powders necessarilygenerates porosity by fixing, in 3-dimensions,positions and relationships of interparticle voids.Low pressure forming methods generate higherporosity and higher pressures produce less. Thermaltreatment, be it simultaneous with forming (HIP) orsubsequent to it (normal firing) is used to eliminatesome, most or all porosity depending on end use.The size of the pores depends on the particle sizedistribution and shape of the starting powders andvarious additives (binders, liquids). Of course, thela creates porosity in the initial stages of firing dueto their loss or burning out. As sintering is initiatedsmall pores may coalesce into larger ones with eor no loss of overall pore volume. Loss of porevolume (porosity) must be accompanied byshrinkage of the piece.

Your Pore Problems BeginTrouble begins by not in place a program ofpore volume and size monitoring at all stages ofproduction. From consideration of mass, true densityand geometric (envelope) volume one might believeone has all the information needed… just calculateporosity. Maybe even determine it explicitly by waterabsorption. But not knowing the pore sizedistribution can lead to serious misunderstandings.You are probably familiar with looking at particle sizedistributions and making certain deductions. That'sOK for loose powders, but even then one cannotdeduce how homogeneous the blend is from a sizeanalysis. But when the particles a ain a fixed spatialorder by pressing, casting, extrusion etc., the resultingpore size distribution plot will reveal the

homogeneity of the blend as it exited the formingprocess. If it's worth proceeding, you will now beable to understand the path along which the sinteringprocess might take. Small pores will be the mostthermally "reactive", larger pores less so. Thereforedon't be surprised if the final piece still has porosity -if it started out with predominantly large pores.Remember, the final porosity is not just a function ofinitial porosity but also of pore size.

Measuring Pore Size Quickly and ReliablyThe best available measurement method is MercuryIntrusion Porosimetry: rapid (orders of magnitudefaster than gas sorption) very wide dynamic range(orders of magnitude larger than gas sorption -unrivaled for pores over 0.25 microns) and yieldingnetwork structure (more evident than gas sorptionbecause the fluid penetration is sequential or serial innature). Mercury intrudes from the outside, in, andwhile there exists a pressure-pore size relationship, itis subject to the arrangement and connectivity of thedifferent pores sizes in the network of internal voids.Therefore, the result not only yields pore sizeinformation but also structural or network information.

The forced intrusion of non-we mercury into apore network by applying an external force has beenused commercially for the best part of sixty years. Sowhy is it not more widely used? Perhaps it was thelack of automation, the lack of interpretation skills ormaybe noise and expense? But that is not now thecase. Modern mercury intrusion porosimeters offerhigh throughput, very wide pore size range, a host ofautomated features and near-silent operation. Manyanalyses can be completed in een minutes or less -on two samples at one time.

So, when you need pore size information for R&D,process control and quality assurance in all fields ofceramics, consider using the mercury porosimetrymethod. Mercury porosimetry may reveal porositywhere there should be none, identify off-spec greenceramics and allow them to be removed from theremaining processes, and to optimize firing conditions.A all, kilns are not inexpensive to operate.

For more information about fuel cells and relatedmeasurement instruments, contact QuantachromeInstruments by phone: (561) 731.4999, fax: (561) 732.9888,email: [email protected] or visitwww.quantachrome.com.

P

&Structural MaterialsCeramics

Pore size is calculated using theWashburn equation:Pore diameter = - (4 γ cos θ )/ PWhere γ = surface tension, P = pressure and θ = contact angle.

Pore size range is from approximately1mm down to 3.5nm

Pore volume resolution be than 0.1 microlitre.

Pressures required as high as 60,000 psi, achieved using specially designed hydraulic pressuregenerators.

Featured in a number of standard testmethods including ASTM D4284,ASTM D4404, ASTM D2873, UOP578-02, BS7591-1.

MercuryIntrusionPorosimetryFacts

Porous Problems:Porous Problems:

by: Martin A. Thomas Ph.D., Director of Business DevelopmentQuantachrome Instruments ([email protected])

Rid Yourself of Unwanted orUnexplained Porosity In YourFinal Product.The PoreMaster GT® uses the extremelyeffective rapid mercury intrusion technique.With automatic pore size and pore volumedistribution analyzers, you will never haveporosity inconsistency in your products again.

For answers to your porosity related questionsand to speak to a Quantachrome consultant,call us at 561.731.4999 or email us at

Advanced Features:-Automatic air purge

-Vapor trap

-Extremely quiet

Three Operating Modes:-Pressure Scanning

-Autospeed

-Step-wise

PoreMaster GT®

www.quantachrome.com

© 2004-2010 Quantachrome Corporation

[email protected]