Upload
joseph-v
View
212
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
short-term intensive therapy forfamilies or individuals. The authorsets out to bring some clarity to thefield.
Part I of the book consists ofeight chapters, each of which focuses on a different aspect of crisisintervention. After an introquctorychapter, the author gives an excellent review of the basis of crisistheory, incl~ding the pioneeringwork of Caplan and Lindemann.The third chapter delineates thegeneral principles of crisis intervention psychotherapy. These haveto do with availability and brevityof treatment, activity of the therapist, and the focus on present problems. The fourth and fifth chaptersdescribe programs that utilize crisisintervention, the author giving special attention to three programsthat represent what he sees as thethree most common uses of crisisintervention: child and familytreatment, marital therapy, andprograms designed to avoid orshorten psychiatric hospitalization.The sixth chapter gives an excellentreview and critique of evaluationstudies on crisis intervention psychotherapy, followed by a chapterthat discusses the selection of appropriate clients for this type oftreatment. The author considersfacets such as severity of the problem, diagnosis, motivation fortreatment, and socioeconomicstatus. The final chapter focuses onthe future ofcrisis intervention, andhere the author is optimistic, primarily because of the cost-effectiveness of this type of treatment.
Part II consists ofa single chapterthat describes a working model forthe practice of crisis intervention.Its six essential stages are ex-
APRIL 1979· VOL 20 • NO 4
plained: delineating the problemfocus, evaluation of client, contracting, intervening, termination,and follow-up.
The author successfully distinguishes between crisis-interventiontherapy and long-term psychotherapy. It would have been helpful ifhe ~ad also addressed the differences between crisis-intervention therapy and other short-termtherapies.
Written in a generally ~iear, concise style, the book is highly readable, and represents a valuable addition to the crisis-interventionliterature.
Renee Binder, M.D.University of CaliforniaSa,! Francisco
Drug Abuse: Clinicaland Basic AspectsEdited by Sachindra N. Pradhail. 598 pp.$24.50. Sl. Louis. CV Mosby. 1977.
• A book on drug abuse immediately conjures up the thought ofhow seldom, if ever, one sees orattempts to treat a narcotic addict-and then the ,book is bypassed. With this bo~k, such a reaction would be a great mistake,since chapter after chapter pointsup the prevalence of many problems directly attributable to theabuse of legal drugs obtained byprescription or by a trip to the localliquor outlet.
The stated objective is to provide"digested but authoritative andcomprehensive technical information on clinical and basic aspectsthat will be useful for managementand prevention of drug abuse."This objective has been achieved.There is something for everyone.
Each area of particular interest canbe explored here, be it pharmacology, epidemiology, or clinical management. Alcohol and prescriptiondrug abuse receive excellent coverage; but it is unfortunate that moreis not included on the recent epidemic of phencyclidine abuse.
The book's coverage of generalaspects of drug abuse is mostly upto date. The discussion of clinicalaspects gives specific attention todrug groups, chemicals, usage patterns, types of individuals involved,and complications requiring discovery and intervention. The section on socio-educational aspectshas merit for those not specializedin this area. The final section, ondrug abuse research, is followed byuseful appendices, tables, references, and a glossary of drug users'argot.
This book can be of value notonly to those who specialize intreating addiction but also to thosewho are called upon to recognizeand intervene in the myriad medical and psychiatric problems presented by a drug-taking society.
Leonard W. Cobbs, M.D.Xenia. Ohio
Psychophannacology forPrimary Care PhysiciansBy Charles L. Bowden and Martin B. Giffen. 91 pp. $8.95 paperback. Baltimore. Williams & Wilkins. 1978.
• The authors' purpose, to publisha "h~ndbook intended for physicians and students who will haveprimary care responsibilities," isadmirably accomplished in thissmall volume. The text encompasses the core content of psychopharmacology in a pragmatic and
289
BOOK REVIEWSlucid manner. Chapters devoted toaffective disorders, insomnia, psychosis, psychopharmacology forchildren, and drug interactionsoffer practical guidelines for the useof psychopharmacologic agents.The chapter on the cost of thesemedications and the saving to thepatient that can result from attention to prescription practices ishelpful, too.
This reviewer can fault the authors in only one respect: they subscribe to the myth that primary carephysicians rely solely on psychotropic drugs to treat anxiety anddepression, without offering counseling, support, and advice. Thisbeliefno longer has a foundation ofcredibility, and has been invalidated by well-documented surveysamong primary care physicians.
Can this text be recommendedfor primary care physicians? Definitely yes. In convenient pocketsize, it contains the essential psychopharmacologic knowledgeneeded by the primary care physician to use these agents with a feeling of competence and to understand limitations of their use.Joseph V. Fisher, M.D.Medical University of South Carolina
Neuroses: A Comprehensiveand Critical ViewBy Melvin Gray. 341 pp. $15.95. New York.Van Nostrand Reinhold. 1978.
• The dynamic evaluation of psychiatric thought serves as thespringboard from which Dr. Grayexplores the vast and complex areaof the neuroses. In order to give thereader a perspective in this constantly developing field, he furnishes historical informationthroughout the book, drawing fromthe disciplines of philosophy, the-
APRIL 1979 • VOL 20 • NO 4
ology, and sociology, as well asfrom medicine and psychiatry.
Dr. Gray makes the emphaticpoint that while great strides havebeen made in the study of mentalhealth and mental illness, there isstill much to be learned and organized in areas such as the development of a comprehensive, consistent psychiatric nosology and in theinfant field of neurochemistry.
The initial chapter of the booktraces beliefs and attitudes towardabnormal human behavior fromthe dawn of history to the modernera. This chapter is remarkable inthe amount of research that musthave been done and the amount ofinformation furnished. It is repletewith quotes, from Homer to Freud.
The second chapter deals withclassification. Dr. Gray takes nothing for granted as he discusses thereasons for and requirements of aneffective system of classification, aswell as the many difficulties encountered in the development ofsuch a system. Once again, a historical perspective is included.
A chapter on etiology discussesvarious concepts of disease and themultiple factors that affect the individual's thinking, feeling, andbehavior.
The next eight chapters comprisethe bulk of the book. Each is concerned with one of the eight neurotic disorders as defined in DSMII. Each includes a well-researchedsection tracing the history of thedisorder and a section on etiology,in which varying theoretical pointsof view, including genetic, neurophysiologic, and psychological, arediscussed. Diagnosis is viewed froma historical point of view, with emphasis on DSM II; a discussion ofthe soon-to-be-published DSM IIIis also included. Brief sections ineach chapter summarize differen-
tial diagnosis, source, prognosis,and treatment. These sections ineach chapter are fairly conventional in their approach to theneuroses. The chapter on anxietyneurosis includes a concise, informative overview of current thinking on the biologic basis for emotion, with particular regard tostress.
The chapter on depression dealswith difficulties in classification andthe attempts of DSM III to resolvesome of these difficulties. In thischapter, biogellic amine theory isdiscussed, along with early loss andgenetic and environmental factors.
The final chapter deals withtreatment. Here, Dr. Gray againdiscusses history and then furnishesbrief descriptions of current treatment methods. He advocates careful treatment planning and recommends a broad approach in thehandling of the complexities ofmental illness.
All in all, the book presents abroad overview with a richness ofhistorical and current information.Of necessity, few topics are explored in great depth, but the extensive bibliography at the end ofeach chapter can be a stimulus forthe interested reader to pursuetopics further. One criticism is thatthe book contains many errors ingrammar and spelling for such ascholarly text. This can be distracting at times. I would hope thatfuture printings will be more carefully edited and proofread.
In summary, I would recommend the book to the reader interested in the broad sweep of psychiatric thought. Its discussion ofrecent neurophysiologic developments and its inclusion of the DSMIII make it a most timely text.
Michael C. Coplon. M.D.Merion Station. Pa.