Upload
simran-chopra
View
235
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 1/53
UGJBUMZ FBU @AFG
~ Jrbwm-sburjand tlg mgsadn bf lgi`tl anfbrhitabn irtgfijts ~
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 2/53
[rbogjt Zpbnsbr? Zcyg Da`egrt, Ditgs Fbunmitabn
[rbogjt Margjtbr? Mavyi Mitti
[rbogjt Hinidgr? Zahrin Jlbpri
Ugsgirjl gih & [lbtb Jrgmats?
Ealir, Anmai ? Inuprayi Irvanm, Zlrgyi Ininm inm Wtsiv Jlbumlury
Einmund, Anmbngsai ? Imatlyi [ricisl inm Zahrin Jlbpri
Casuhu, Cgnyi ? Mavyi Mitti inm Firam O. Eluyin
Masj`iahgr? I`` vasui` g`ghgnts slirgm frbh tlg rgsgirjl watlan tlg mbjuhgnt is wg`` is
sgpiritg`y hiy nbt eg usgm fbr imvgrtasand prbmujts br sgrvajgs, erinm gnmbrsghgnts br fbr
pue`aj prbpidinmi.
JCZ Jbnsu`tand [vt. @tm.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg
Jbpyradlt © 5;9:-9= Ea`` & Hg`anmi Ditgs Fbunmitabn inm
Jgntrg fbr Cnbw`gmdg Zbjagtags
I`` radlts rgsgrvgm. I `ajgnsg as lgrgey drintgm tb mbwn`bim inm prant i jbpy bf tlas
mbjuhgnt fbr pgrsbni` usg bn`y. Nb btlgr `ajgnsg tb iny btlgr antg``gjtui` prbpgrty
radlts as lgrgey drintgm. Wn`gss gxprgss`y pgrhattgm lgrgan br ey `iw, rgprbmujtabn,
imiptitabn,trinsfgr, mastraeutabn br stbridg bf pirt br i`` bf tlg jbntgnts bf tlas mbjuhgntan iny fbrh watlbut tlg prabr wrattgn pgrhassabn bf Ea`` &Hg`anmi Ditgs Fbunmitabn inm
Jgntgr fbr Cnbw`gmdg Zbjagtags as prblaeatgm. ]g jbntgnt bf tlas mbjuhgnt as prbvamgm ‐is
as,‘ watlbut wirrintags bf iny canm watl rgdirms ats ijjurijy br rg`aiea`aty, inm spgjaji``y
gxj`umand i`` ahp`agm wirrintags, fbr gxihp`g bf hgrjlintiea`aty, tngss fbr purpbsg, tat`g
inm nbn-anfrandghgnt. An nb gvgnt sli`` Ea`` & Hg`anmi Ditgs Fbunmitabn inm Jgntgr fbr
Cnbw`gmdg Zbjagtags eg `aie`g fbr iny spgjai`, anmargjt br jbnsgqugntai` mihidgs, br iny
mihidgs wlitsbgvgr rgsu`tand frbh miti br prbts, irasand but bf br an jbnngjtabn watl tlg
usg bf tlg mbjuhgnt. Ea`` & Hg`anmi Ditgs Fbunmitabn inm Jgntgr fbr Cnbw`gmdg Zbjagtags
rgsgrvgs tlg radlt tb rgvasg tlg mbjuhgnt br watlmriw at it iny tahg watlbut prabr nbtajg.
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 3/53
Jbntgnts
9. Antrbmujtabn
5. Ugsgirjl @bjitabns
:. Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
=. Fag`m Ansadlts
7. Hgti Ini`ysas inm Mgsadn Ugjbhhgnmitabns
6. Zystghs Antgdritabn
4. ]g Ugjbrm is i Zystgh inm an i Zystgh
<. Ippgnmax
;9
;7
;1
54
71
44
<9
<7
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 4/53
Jla`m ahhunazitabn as tlg prgrgquasatg
upbn wlajl wg `iy tlg fbunmitabns
bf dbbm lgi`tl inm anjrgisgm `afg
gxpgjtinjy, inm an turn, at jbntraeutgs tb
ebtl gjbnbhaj inm sbjai` wg`` egand.
Is rgpbrtgm ey tlg Tbr`m Lgi`tl
Brdinasitabn, mg`avgrand vijjanitabns
tlrbudl in gjagnt systgh as i
prgrgquasatg fbr i funjtabni` pue`aj
lgi`tl strujturg3 prbvamand gvgn
tlg unmgrprava`gdgm jla`mrgn gqui`
9.9. In Antrbmujtabn tb Ugjbrms fbr @afg
9. Antrbmujtabn
bppbrtunaty tb survavg. ]us
`iyand tlg fbunmitabn fbr i lgi`tlagr
inm i egttgr futurg.
Lbwgvgr, at as ahpbrtint tb masjgrn tlit
tb ijlagvg sujl dbi`s gvgry jbhpbngnt bf
tlg ahhunazitabn jlian hust funjtabn
prbpgr`y inm an lirhbny watl gijl btlgr.
Bng sujl ahpbrtint jbd an tlg wlgg`
as tlg jla`m lgi`tl rgjbrm, at as nbt bn`y
in ggjtavg inm angxpgnsavg hgtlbm
bf rgjbrm cggpand eut at i`sb sgrvgs is i
pbant-bf-jirg anfbrhitabn fbr rgsburjg
tlit jin iudhgnt tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs
iea`aty tb hicg egttgr j`anaji` mgjasabns,
davg pbwgr tb tlg pirgnts an tlg lgi`tl
jirg bf tlgar jla`mrgn inm suppbrt tlg
pue`aj lgi`tl hbnatbrand systgh.
Mgspatg ats pbtgntai` tb prbvamg inimgquitg rgjbrm bf ahhunazitabn lastbry
inm ats pbtgntai` jbntraeutabn tb jla`m
lgi`tl is i sburjg bf lgi`tl hbnatbrand
miti, tlg jla`m ahhunazitabn jirm as tbb
bftgn unmgr uta`azgm br anipprbpraitg`y
usgm ey pirgnts inm lgi`tl jirg wbrcgrs
inm tlgrgfbrg mbgs nbt i`wiys fu`` ats
antgnmgm purpbsg.
Wnmgrstinmand tlg sadnajinjg bf tlg
jla`m lgi`tl rgjbrm inm tlg ahhgmaitg
nggm tb ahprbvg at tlg Ea`` & Hg`anmi
Ditgs Fbunmitabn an pirtngrslap watl
TLB, WNAJGF inm JCZ lis himg
in gbrt tb rgmgsadn tlg jla`m lgi`tl
rgjbrm tlrbudl tlg Ugjbrms fbr @afg
mgsadn jbntgst.
]g Ugjbrms fbr @afg jbntgst iahgm
tb ahprbvg tlg ijjurijy, vi`ug inm
gisy antgrprgtitabn bf anfbrhitabn
inm vasui`s fbr tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs inm
egngjairags, i`acg.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 5
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 5/53
[rbe`gh stitghgnts tlit tlg prbogjt
iahgm tb unmgrstinm?
]g Ugjbrms fbr @afg jbntgst jbhhgnjgm
watl in gbrt tb immrgss jgrtian
funmihgnti` assugs a.g. prgvi`gnjg,
ijjurijy inm usg bf tlg jla`m lgi`tl
rgjbrms. ahg inm idian at as besgrvgm
tlit tlg jla`m lgi`tl rgjbrms irg
univia`ie`g murand lbusglb`m vasats br
it lgi`tl fija`atags inm gvgn wlgn tlgy
irg tlg miti an at as bftgn anijjuritg. Is
sujl tlg jla`m lgi`tl rgjbrms fia` tb fu ``
tlg vati` funjtabn bf egand i sburjg bf
anfbrhitabn fbr ebtl lgi`tl wbrcgrs inm
pirgnts. I`bnd watl tlgsg ippirgnt assugs
tlg jbntgst i`sb tragm tb unmgrstinm tlg
rbbt jiusgs bf tlg jla`m lgi`tl rgjbrms
nbt egand mastraeutgm, rgtiangm inm
uta`azgm tb ats fu`` pbtgntai`.
9.5. Jbntgxt bf Ugjbrms fbr @afg
Antrbmujtabn
Tly tlg jrbwm sburjand ipprbijl2
Ey? I`hggri Inwir
]g Ugjbrms fbr @afg jbntgst tirdgtgm
tlrgg prahiry iumagnjgs fbr suehassabns,
tlgsg anj`umgm3 prbfgssabni`s an tlg pue`aj
lgi`tl spijg, mgsadn jbhpinags inm rhs
br anmavamui` mgsadngrs, inm stumgnts
hiobrand an gatlgr mgsadn br pue`aj lgi`tl.
I stinmirm ghia` `iam but anfbrhitabn
iebut suehassabns rgquarghgnts, tlg
gvi`uitabn prbjgss inm lbw wanngrs bf
tlg jbntgst wbu`m eg lbnbrgm.
]as anfbrhitabn wis e`istgm tb ngir`y 5;
mgsadn e`bds, ><7 mgsadn brdinazitabns,
tlg D`bei` Ahhunazitabn Ngws`gttgr,
inm tlg tbp mgsadn inm pue`aj lgi`tl
unavgrsatags irbunm tlg wbr`m. Anmai
inm Jlani lim gxp`ajat butrgijl
stritgdags. ]g ahpijt bf bur jlinng`s
wis gstahitgm eisgm bn tlg vb`uhg inm
typgs bf qugstabns wg rgjgavgm, rg-twggt
nuhegrs, inm j`ajc-tlrbudl ritgs bntlg wgesatg. Tg cngw gir`y bn tlit wg
lim ladl gndidghgnt inm antgrgst watl
i nuhegr bf jb``gdgs inm unavgrsatags
vai tlg qugst abns wg rgjgavgm an bur
ghia` ijjbunt (twb hbntls iftgr `iunjl,
wg wgrg rgjgavand in ivgridg bf vg tb
tgn ghia`s pgr miy3 tlas rgijlgm ngir`y
twgnty ghia`s pgr miy ey tlg jbntgst‑s
Jbntm... j`bsand wggc). Tg i`sb cnbw vai bng mgsadn
pirtngr tlit wg lim i =5% j`ajc-tlrbudl
ritg an tlgar ngws`gttgr, anmajitand tlit tlg
hgssidand lim ladl anatai` ippgi` fbr bur
tirdgt iumagnjg. Lbwgvgr, egjiusg bf tlg
ladl rgsburjg jbst, wg mam nbt gvi`uitg tlg
ahpijt bf gvgry sand`g jlinng`3 wg hgrg`y
jipturgm wlit wis gisa`y ivia`ie`g vai
gxastand hgisurghgnt hgjlinashs. ]g
jrbwm sburjand hgjlinash rgsu`tgm an :9=
suehassabns frbh =9 magrgnt jbuntrags
inm i prgtty gvgn hax bf ijimghaj inm
prbfgssabni` gntrints.
But bf tlg :9= suehassabns, 9== hgt
hanahuh rgquarghgnts.
]g jrbwmsburjandhgjlinash rgsu`tgm an:9= suehassabns frbh =9magrgnt jbuntrags inm i
prgtty gvgn hax bf ijimghajinm prbfgssabni` gntrints.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg =
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 6/53
Dgbdriplaji`, mghbdriplajs, gjbnbhaj
inm drbwtl prbogjtabns, `avg`albbms
fbr gijl jbuntry inm ritabni`g eglanm
jlbbsand tlg jatags unmgr rgsgirjl an
Anmai, Anmbngsai, Cgnyi?
Zanjg tlg jbntgst iahs it ahprbvand
tlg vijjanitabn rgjbrm, d`bei``y, watl
spgjai` fbjus bn mgvg`bpand jbuntrags
wg wintgm tb lgir frbh hbtlgrs ijrbsstlrgg hiobr rgdabns, inm eisgm bn ebtl
wlit wis fgisae`g davgn `anduastaj inm
tahand jbnstriants, inm wlit wbu`m
yag`m tlg hbst rgprgsgntitavg rgsu`ts , wg
jlbsg Cgnyi, Anmbngsai inm Anmai. ]g
sg`gjtabn bf spgjaj ruri` br pgra-urein
`bjitabns an tlgsg jbuntrags wis eisgm
bn pirihgtgrs sujl is jurrgnt stitus bf
tlg pue`aj lgi`tl jirg anfristrujturg,
ahhunazitabn jbvgridg stitus, sbjab-
gjbnbhaj jbnmatabns, ju`turi` inm gtlnaj
mavgrsaty, tlg dgbdriplaj `bjitabn, `atgrijy
`gvg`s, inm pb`ataji` inm imhanastritavg
fijtbrs ihbnd btlgrs.
5. Ugsgirjl @bjitabns
Eisgm bn i`` tlg iebvg hgntabngm
pirihgtgrs, tlg fb``bwand `bjitabns
wgrg jlbsgn?
Casuhu (Cgnyi)? Casuhu as tlg tlarm
`irdgst jaty an Cgnyi watl i pbpu`itabn
bf =;1,15< (5;;1 jgnsus). [rgsgnt miy
Casuhu jbnsasts bf 57 sue `bjitabns
tlit jin eg drbupgm antb 9; hian
`bjitabns(bwnslap, Gist Cb`wi,Jgntri` Cb`wi, ZbutlTgst Casuhu,
Nbrtl Casuhu, Jgntri` Casuhu, Gist
Casuhu, Tgst Ciou`u, Gist Ciou`u, inm
Tgst Cb`wi).
Cggpand tlg sg`gjtabn jratgrai an
pgrspgjtavg. Casuhu wis fbunm tb eg i
suatie`g rgsgirjl `bjitabn.
An tgrhs bf mghbdriplajs, Casuhu lis
i `irdgr prbpbrtabn bf ats pbpu`itabn
rgsamand an urein irgis a.g. 75.= %, wla`g
tlg rghianand =4.6% wgrg `avand an ruri`
is wg`` is frandg pbpu`itabns.
]g lgi`tl jirg anfristrujturg an Cgnyi
as hbst`y i 6 tagr systgh lbwgvgr, is
Casuhu `ijcs i nitabni` `gvg` rgfgrri`
lbspati`, tlg lgi`tljirg systgh lis 7
tagrs a.g. jbhhunaty `gvg`, va``idg `gvg`,
lgi`tl jgntgrs, mastrajt lbspati`s inm
prbvanjai` lbspati`s.
]g lgi`tl jirg anmajitbrs fbr Casuhu
wgrg ijjgptie`g, tlg AHU inm HHU wis
rgdastgrgm it 17 inm 9=1 pgr 9;;; eartls (
is jbhpirgm tb tlg nitabni` nuhegrs bf
75 inm 4= pgr 9;;; eartls). Bn`y 67% bf
jla`mrgn unmgr bng wgrg fu``y ahhunazgm
an Casuhu an 5;;< (DbC 5;;1e). Casuhu
gxpgragnjgs bng bf tlg ladlgst anjamgnts
bf fbbm pbvgrty an Cgnyi inm jla`m
hbrti`aty tgnms tb eg ladlgst ihbnd tlg
mgpravgm (CALEZ 5;;6). At i`sb lis tlg
ladlgst LAV ritg an Cgnyi wlajl as bng
bf tlg `gimand jiusgs i`bnd watl hi`irai,
hi`nutratabn inm mairrlgi.
[itni (Ealir)? Ealir as tlg tlarm hbst
pbpu`bus stitg an Anmai watl bvgr 9;;
ha``abn pbpu`itabn inm hbrg tlin =;%
bf tlg pgbp`g an tlg stitg `avg eg`bw
pbvgrty `ang.
Tlgn at jbhgs tb tlg lgi`tl jirg
sgjtbr, Ealir sugrs frbh i p`gtlbri bf
jbnstriants an prbvamand imgquitg lgi`tl
jirg sgrvajgs tb tlg pgbp`g. Hbrg tlin
47% bf tlg jla`mrgn unmgr : ygirs bf idg
wgrg inighaj wla`g fgwgr tlin bng tlarm bf
tlgh wgrg ergist fgm.
7;% bf jla`mrgn unmgr : ygirs bf idg,
sugrgm frbh stuntand mug tb
hi`nutratabn. Ijjbrmand tlg NFLZ tlg
unmgr 7 hbrti`aty ritg an Ealir wis
rgdastgrgm it <=.< pgr 9;;; `avg eartls inm
bn`y :5.<% bf tlg jla`mrgn lim rgjgavgm
jbhp`gtg ahhunazitabn.
Is i rgsu`t Ealir‑s anfint inm hitgrni`
hbrti`aty ritgs irg ihbnd tlg ladlgst an
Anmai (WNAJGF). Ealir as i`sb bng bf tlg
hbst vu`ngrie`g stitgs fbr tlg sprgim bf
LAV an Anmai (WNAJGF).
Ealir an hiny wiys as rgprgsgntitavg bf
tlg jurrgnt `bbplb`gs an bf tlg lgi`tl jirg
systgh an Anmai. Fbr tlg purpbsgs bf tlas
stumy tlg g`mwbrc wis jirragm but an
i `bjitabn ji``gm [irsi, an tlg mastrajt
bf [itni.
Casuhu (Cgnyi)
Ealir (Anmai)
Eindmund (Anmbngsai)
Ahidg jburtg sy ? Dbbd`g Ahidgs
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 6
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 7/53
Einmund (Anmbngsai)? Einmund as
Anmbngsai‑s tlarm `irdgst jaty iftgr Oicirti
inm Zurieiyi watl i pbpu`itabn bf 5.7
ha``abn (Ou`y 5;9: gstahitgs).
Anmbngsai lis i fiar slirg bf ats
pbpu`itabn rgsamand an ebtl urein,ruri`
is wg`` is frandg irgis. ]g urein
pbpu`itabn jbnstatutgs 7;.:% bf tlg tbti`
pbpu`itabn wla`g tlg rgst =1.4% `avgs anruri` irgis.
]g lgi`tl jirg systgh an Anmbngsai
as gssgntai``y i twb pirt systgh a.g.
[uscgshis inm [bsyinmu. [uscgshis irg
tlg lgi`tl j`anajs tlit bgr vijjanitabns
inm btlgr lgi`tl jirg sgrvajgs, wla`g
pbsyinmu irg tlg hbntl`y brdinasgm
lgi`tl jihps tlit irg spgjai``y hgint
fbr prgdnint wbhgn, jla`mrgn inm
tlg g`mgr`y. [bsyinmu i`sb bgrs frgg
vijjanitabns ygt egngjairags rg`y
hbrg bn [uscgshis. [bsyinmu as hbrg
iebut lgi`tl jirg jbnsu`titabn wlgrgis
[uscgshis mgi`s watl vijjanitabns.
]gy sgrvg is i suppbrt hgjlinash fbr
gijl btlgr, is wg`` prbvamand fu`` stgmdgm
lgi`tl jirg sgrvajgs.
Frbh tlg anfristrujturi` pbant bf vagw
Anmbngsai lis i tlrgg tagr systgh fbr
lgi`tl jirg3 Hanastry bf Nitabni` Lgi`tl,
[rbvanjai` Lgi`tl Bjgs inm Mastrajt
`gvg` lgi`tl bjgs.
Furtlgrhbrg, tlg lgi`tl jirg sgrvajgs it i
ruri` `gvg` irg brdinasgm antb tlrgg `gvg`s
a.g. Va``idg `gvg` (prbvamand dgngri` lgi`tl
sgrvajgs), Zue-mastrajt `gvg` (spgjai`azgm
hgmaji` ghgrdgnjy sgrvajgs) inm
Mastrajt `gvg`.
An spatg bf in brdinasgm lgi`tl jirg
systgh virabus pirts bf Anmbngsai
anj`umand Einmund livg eggn sugrandfrbh `afg tlrgitgnand masgisgs sujl E
(457/9;;; pbpu`itabn) gtj.
]g LAV ritg lis i`sb anjrgisgm frbh
<71 an 5;;7 tb 59,;:9 an 5;99 inm
51,<41 ta`` Mgjghegr 5;99. Tla`g tlg
Anfint hbrti`aty ritg bf an Einmund wis
rgdastgrgm it 56 pgr 9;;; `avg eartls wla`g
9:.5% mgitls bf unmgr 7 ygirs wgrg mug
tb pnguhbnai.
Lbwgvgr, tlg bvgri`` ahhunazitabn
jbvgridg bf jla`mrgn unmgr 7 ygirs bf idg
wis rgdastgrgm it i rgspgjtie`g <<%.
Bn tlg radlt ? Ahidgs bf rgspbnmgnts frbh
i`` tlrgg `bjitabns
Jbntm...
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg <
Ugsgirjl @bjit abns
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 8/53
:.9. [rbjgss Hip Zgjbnmiry Ugsgirjl
Mgsadn Gntrags gjlnaji` Gvi`uitabn
Gvi`uitabn [rbjgss
Ugsgirjl Mgsadn
Fbjus Drbup gstand bf [rbtbtypgs
Miti Zyntlgsas inm Ini`ysas
Gxpgrt Gvi`uitabn Oury
Ztritgdaj Mgsadn Ugjbhhgnmitabns
:. Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
= wggcs | 6 gxpgrt antgrvagws, `atgriturg rgvagw inm mgtia`gm
`bjitabn sg`gjtabn prbjgss
Jrgitand prbtbjb` duamgs, Ugjruathgnt Uitabni`g
9.7 wggcs | Jrgitand in bn`ang gvi`uitabn fbrh fbr mgsadngrs
inm lgi`tl gxpgrts fbr rst `gvg` bf gntrags gvi`uitabn.
9.7 wggcs | FDM‑s, gstand, Vi`amitabn
5 wggcs | Jbhpa`itabn bf Miti, Tbrcslbp duamg, Oumdand &
gvi`uitabn jratgrais
5 wggcs | Gvi`uitand gntrags inm mbwnsg`gjtabn,
Mgvg`bpand jug jirms
5 wggcs | Fag`m Ansadlts, Ini`ysas, Miti `ancidgs, ]ghg jrgitabn
: wggcs | Ugpbrt wratand, Mriwand rgjbhhgnmitabns
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 9;
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 9/53
Gxpgrt Gvi`uitabn Frihgwbrc?
]g rst `gvg` bf gvi`uitabn fbr tlg mgsadn
gntrags wis mbng tlrbudl in bn`ang
tgjlnaji` gvi`uitabn qugstabnniarg.
]g qugstabnniarg wis strujturgm tb
immrgss tlg cgy jratgrai ebtl frbh i
mgsadn inm lgi`tl jirg pgrspgjtavg.
]g qugstabnniarg wis mavamgm antb
7 erbim sgjtabns, gijl bf wlajl lim irindg bf qugstabns tb issgss tlg mgsadn
gntry bn i 7 pbant sji`g br tlrbudl i
qui`atitavg rgspbnsg. ]g qugstabns wgrg
purpbsgfu``y frihgm tb gnjipsu`itg tlg
g`adaea`aty jratgrai fbr tlg gntrags an tlg
mgsadn jbntgst. Furtlgrhbrg i vg pbant
sji`g wis jlbsgn tb lg`p iddrgditg tlg
rgspbnsgs fbr gijl gntry hgtlbmaji``y,
inm it tlg sihg fija`atitg tlg tgjlnaji`
gxpgrts tb ji`aeritg tlg gntrags egttgr.
Anjbrpbritand i qui`atitavg ispgjt tb
tlg qugstabnniarg i``bwgm fbr i hbrg
jbhprglgnsavg rgspbnsg frbh tlg
tgjlnaji` gxpgrt fbr tlg mgsadn gntrags.
]g rst sgjtabn fbjussgm bn issgssand
tlg gntry fbr ats iea`aty tb jrgitg i unaqug
pitagnt amgntaty inm slirg i rindg bf
lgi`tl jirg anfbrhitabn sujl is3 tlg
jla`m‑s vijjanitabn stitus, ahhunazitabn
lastbry, inm tlg ngxt mug mitgs. At i`sb
antgnmgm tb hgisurg tlg gisg bf ``and
tlbsg anfbrhitabn inm immand ngw
anfbrhitabn bn tlg ahhunazitabn jirm.
]g sgjbnm sgjtabn jbnjgntritgm bn
gvi`uitand tlg iea`aty bf tlg mgsadn gntry
tb jrgitg vi`ug fbr pirgnts inm lgi`tl
wbrcgrs i`acg is egand i rghanmgr fbr
futurg ahhunazitabns, is i hgmauh tb
jbhhunajitg tlg sadnajinjg bf jla`m
lgi`tl, inm ats iea`aty tb bgr vi`ug
egybnm tlg ats ahhgmaitg prijtaji` vi`ug
wlajl jbu`m ijt is i sburjg bf hbtavitabn.
At wbu`m eg ahpbrtint tb anmajitg it tlas ounjturg tlit tlg rst twb sgj tabns bf tlg
qugstabnniarg wgrg jbhhbn fbr ebtl
mgsadngrs inm lgi`tl jirg prbfgssabni`s.
]g tlarm sgjtabn wis mgsadngm
magrgnt`y fbr mgsadngrs inm lgi`tl jirg
prbfgssabni`s. ]g mgsadn mgmajitgm
sgjtabn wis fbjusgm bn gvi`uitand tlg
j`iraty bf anfbrhitabn, imiptiea`aty tb
magrgnt hgmai, usiea`aty bf tlg fbrh inm
tlg suatiea`aty bf hitgrai`. Bn tlg btlgr
linm tlg lgi`tl jirg sgjtabn wis fbjussgm
bn erandand fbrtl mgsjraptavg rgspbnsgs
fbr sgjtabns tlit jbu`m eg jbnfusand br
hasunmgrstbbm ey
tlg egngjairags.
]g fburtl sgjtabn wis strujturgm tb
ladl`adlt tlg hbst prbhasand fgiturgs is
wg`` is dgt in bvgri`` ritand bf tlg mgsadn
gntry bn i vg pbant sji`g. ]g ftl inm
tlg ni` sgjtabn wis jbhp`gtg`y mgmajitgm
bn rgjgavand i qui`atitavg fggmeijc fbr tlg
mgsadn gntrags.
Jbntm...
Antgrni` Gvi`uitabn Frihgwbrc?
Jrgitabn bf i fbur ̀ iygrgm prbjgss
bf mbwn sg`gjtabn? Bur gvi`uitabn
strujturg wis mgvasgm is i prbjagnt
fbur tagrgm prbjgss ticand antb ijjbunt
i`` ispgjts bf in ggjtavg gvi`uitabn
frihgwbrc. Uitlgr tlin ticand sg`gjtabn
is i jratgrai, tlg tgih bptgm fbr usand
g`ahanitabn is i tbb` fbr mbwnsg`gjtabn
bf gntrags.
]g tgih wis mavamgm an : drbups bf twb
hghegrs gijl. Gijl drbup wis gxpgjtgm
tb `bbc it 6; tb 4; gntrags (tbti` egtwggn
9<; - 59;) watl gijl gvi `uitabn drbup
spgnmand egtwggn 7 tb 4 hanutgs
pgr gntry.
]g rst `gvg` `bbcgm it tlg jirm an tgrhs
bf bvgri`` annbvitabn. ]g mbwn sg`gjtabn
prbjgss iahgm it sg`gjtand jirms tlit livg
bng br hbrg fgiturg tlit as annbvitavg inm
wbrtly bf hgrat tgstand.
Anjbrpbritand tgjlnaji` rgvagwgrs
fggmeijc? ]g sgjbnm `gvg` anjbrpbritgm
tlg tgjlnaji` rgvagwgrs fggmeijc inm tlg
tgstand bf jirms bn tlg eisas bf mavgrsatywatl rgspgjt tb tlg cgy jratgrai bf
jug jirms.
(i) gjlnaji` rgvagwgrs fggmeijc ?
Gntrags wlajl sjbrgm 5; br hbrg but bf =;
wgrg sgnt tb tlg ngxt `gvg`.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 95
Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 10/53
I `bbp jbuntgr wis jrgitgm fbr rg-
jlgjcand gntrags tlit wgrg rgmunmint
it tlg rst `gvg` inm ygt himg at tlg tb
sgjbnm `gvg` tb gnsurg tlit gvgry gntry wis
prbpgr`y vgttgm.
(e.) Mavgrsaty eisas jrataji` pirihgtgr?
]g gntrags wgrg i`sb gvi`uitgm eisgm
bn tlgar mavgrsaty ijjbrmand tb tlg g`m
tgstand pirihgtgrs inm jitgdbrazgm
fbr jug-jirm tgstand. ]g jitgdbrags
wgrg nihg`y -
9. Hgtlbm bf gstie`asland tlg pitagnt‑sunaqug amgntaty.
5. Gjijy bf tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`gmgsadn / rgprgsgntitabn
: Gjijy bf tlg Vasui` Hgtiplbrsusgm fbr Drbwtl Jlirt / Lgi`tl jirgjbunsg``and anfbrhitabn
= Gjijy an jbhhunajitand tlgsadnajinjg bf ahhunazitabn fbr jla`mprbtgjtabn
7. [btgntai` tb prbvamg vi`ug tb usgrs
6. J`iraty bf anfbrhitabn
4. Hitgrai` inm Fbrh
]g gntrags wlajl sjbrgm `gss tlin in
bvgri`` ritand bf : but bf 7 frbh tlg
rgvagwgrs fggmeijc, wgrg nbt sgnt tb tlg
ngxt `gvg`. ]as `gvg` i`sb anj`umgm sjbpg
fbr rgvagwgrs tb tid tlg hbst prbhasand
mgsadn fgiturgs/ispgjts/ittraeutgs bf
tlg jirm inm prbvamg jbhhgnts idianst
rg`gvint ispgjts bf tlit pirtaju`ir gntry
tlit hgratgm g`m tgstand.
]g tlarm `gvg` `bbcgm it tgstand jirms
idianst tgjlnb`bdy. ]g pirihgtgrs tlit
wgrg mgvasgm fbr tlas `gvg` wgrg -
(i.) gstand tlg jirm bn iny c anm bf
tgjlnb`bdy at anjbrpbritgs inm wlgtlgr
tlg sihg as fgisae`g br jbntgxtui``y
ipprbpraitg tb eg ahp`ghgntgm bn
tlg g`m.
(e.) gstand tlg jirm bn ats pbtgntai` tb
gisg br spggm up miti jbnsb`amitabn.
Iftgr egand vgttgm tlrbudl i`` tlgsg
`gvg`s, i`` tlg jirms tlit qui`agm an
anmavamui` pijcgts wgrg rg-`bbcgm it
inm masjussgm watl tlg tgih inm tbp
tlarty jirms wgrg sg`gjtgm fbr
g`m tgstand.
Jirms wlajl wgrg lgivy bn tgjlnb`bdy
inm jbu`m nbt eg tgstgm bn g`m, wgrg
hircgm sgpiritg`y fbr tlg @bnmbn
oury wbrcslbp.
Ahidgs frbh tlg
Erianstbrhand Ebirm
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 9=
Jbntm...Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 11/53
]g gntrags tlit wgrg sg`gjtgm frbh
tlg jbntgst wgrg mavgrsg an niturg inm
mgsadn inm at wis vati` fbr tlgh tb eg
tgstgm bn tlg g`m tb vi`amitg tlg virabus
gvi`uitabn jratgrai. An brmgr tb ijlagvg
tlit, at wis quantgssgntai` tb jrgitg i
rgjruathgnt ritabni`g wlajl wbu`m
g`ujamitg tlg virabus usgr drbups sujl
is tlg Egngjairags inm Frbnt`ang
Lgi`tl Tbrcgrs. ]g rgjruathgnt
ritabni`g wis mgsadngm tlit
trinsjgnmgm virabus pirihgtgrs.
Ugjruathgnt Uitabni`g?
]g sihp`g mastraeutabn wis
rgprgsgntitavg bf i wamgr tirdgt
iumagnjg inm eisgm bn tlg fb``bwand
pirihgtgrs?
Idg | @atgrijy | Gxpgragnjg | Lgi`tl
wbrcgrs anvb`vgm an vijjanitabn inm
wlb mgi`t watl ahhunazitabn jirms.
]g egngjairags (hbtlgrs inm
fitlgrs) wgrg rgjruatgm bn fb``bwand
pirihgtgrs? Idg | Nb. Bf jla`mrgn |
@atgrijy | Fiha`y ypg
]g rgjruathgnt prbjgss wis hbst jrujai`
is at wis gssgntai` tb dgt rgspbnmgnts tlit
hitjlgm tlg pirihgtgrs inm rgprgsgntgm
tlg usgr drbup. ]g rgjruathgnts wgrg
hinidgm ey tlg JCZ tgih an Anmai inm an
btlgr `bjitabns ey tlg rgsgirjl pirtngrs.
Tlgn rgjruatand tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs inm
hbea`azgrs, at wis pirihbunt fbr tlgh tb
eg `atgritg inm mug tb tlg mavgrsg niturg bf
tlg rgsgirjl `bjitabns tlg `gvg` bf `atgrijy
wis gxpgjtgm tb eg viragm.
]g idg bf tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs wis i`sb
gqui``y ahpbrtint is at wis gssgntai` fbr
tlgh tb livg suestintai` gxpbsurg an
wbrcand watl tlg jla`m lgi`tl rgjbrm,
tlgrgfbrg i fiar hax bf gxpgragnjg wis
prgfgrrgm watl lgi`tl wbrcgrs idgm
egtwggn `itg 5;‑s tb `itg =;‑s wgrg jlbsgn
fbr tlg FDM‑s.
Tla`g rgjruatand egngjairags in
ahpbrtint fijtbr tlit wis cgpt an hanm
wis tlg nuhegr bf jla`mrgn inm tlg idg
bf tlg hbtlgr. At wis jrataji` tlit tlg
egngjairags hust eg anvb`vgm an tlg
ahhunazitabn prbjgss inm ijquiantgm
watl tlg imvintidgs inm tlg `bbplb`gs an
tlg jurrgnt jla`m lgi`tl rgjbrm.
Zanjg tlg dgbdriplaji` mavgrsaty lim tb
eg ijjbuntgm fbr, tlg `gvg` bf `atgrijy wis
cgpt stgxae`g cggpand an hanm tlg `bji`
`atgrijy `gvg`s.
]g fiha`y typg wis i`sb in ahpbrtint
fijtbr gspgjai``y fbr hbtlgrs is at wis
gisagr fbr hbtlgrs an in gxtgnmgm br
obant fiha`y tb `gi rn frbh tlgar g`mgrs is
jbhpirgm tb sand`g hbtlgrs. Is sujl tlg
rgspbnmgnts frbh ebtl fiha`y typgs wgrg
jlbsgn tb livg i fiar rgprgsgntitabn an
tlg butjbhg bf tlg stumy.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 96
Jbntm...Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 12/53
]g jbrg anfbrhitabn inm mgsadn
g`ghgnts tlit jihg tbdgtlgr tb fbrh i
jbhp`gtg rgjbrm wgrg masiddrgditgm tb
fbrh mgsadn jitgdbrags bn wlajl tlg jirm
jbu`m tgst. Jbhpbngnt jug jirms wgrg
jrgitgm tb rgprgsgnt tlg magrgnt mgsadn
prbpbsatabns watlan tlg sihg mgsadn
jitgdbry. ]gsg jitgdbrags i`sb immrgssgm
tlbsg g`ghgnts br sgjtabns bf tlg jirm
tlit irg ahpbrtint fbr ebtl, tlg Frbnt
@ang Lgi`tl Tbrcgrs (F@LTs)
inm Egngjairags. ]g jitgdbrags
ni`azgm wgrg?
Jrgitand Jug-Jirm Ztahu`us fbr Fbjus Drbup Masjussabns?
Hgtlbms gnie`and Wnaqug
Amgntajitabn? ]as jitgdbry amgntagm
inm tgstgm tlg sgvgri` magrgnt hgtlbms
bf ahprbvand unaqug amgntajitabn inm
trijcand pitagnts tlit tlg mgsadn gntrags
prbpbsgm inm `ancand inm vgrafyand i
jla`m tb tlg lgi`tl jirm inm tlg systgh.
Vasui` Ugprgsgntitabn bf tlg
Ahhunazitabn Zjlgmu`g? ]as sgjtabn
wis tgstgm tb erand but ansadlts bf
rgspbnmgnts bn tghpbri`aty bf miti,
``and pittgrns, vasaea`aty, i`adnhgnt bf
miti watl rgspgjt tb tahg, sgqugntai`aty
bf anfbrhitabn, iutlgntajaty inm vi`amaty.
Vasui` Hgtiplbrs ghp`bygm fbr
Drbwtl Jlirts inm Lgi`tl jirg
Jbunsg``and Anfbrhitabn? ]as sgjtabn
jbvgrgm twb sue-sgjtabns ‚ Drbwtl
jlirts inm Lgi`tl jirg anfbrhitabn. ]g
rgisbn fbr tgstand tlas sgjtabn sgpiritg`y
wis tb `bbc it jbntgxt inm jbhprglgnsabn
bf vasui` ini`bdy. Fbr anstinjg g`ghgnts`acg iestrijtabn bf vasui` ahidgry, vasui`
sty`g inm mgptl bf miti wgrg ini`ysgm.
Ngw Anfbrhitabn Fag`ms? ]as sgjtabn
amgntagm inm tgstgm tlbsg ispgjts bf
anfbrhitabn tlit wgrg nbt anj`umgm br
tlbudlt bf watl rgspgjt tb i lgi`tl jirm.
Wsg bf Jb`br? ]as sgjtabn wis sp`at
an twb wiys ‚ @bbcand it jb`br is in
igstlgtaj inm is funjtabn. Igstlgtaj
unmgrstinmand bf jb`br divg ansadlts antb
i usgr‑s vasui`, ju`turi` inm sbjai`
hanmsgt. Jgrtian jb`brs wgrg issbjaitgm
watl hbrg strbnd`y tlin tlg btlgrs.
@bbcand it jb`br is funjtabn lg`pgm
unmgrstinmand bf jb`br an tgrhs bf
anfbrhitabn jbmand inm i`adnand watl
tahg br btlgr fijtbrs an tlg jirm.
Hitgrai` inm Fbrh? ]as sgjtabn
amgntagm inm tgstgm tlg ispgjts
pgrjgptabn bf plysaji` fbrhit, fbrh inm
strujturg bf i lgi`tl rgjbrm, muriea`aty,
hiantgninjg inm hitgrai` bf tlg rgjbrm
ihbndst tlg usgr sgts.
Zp`attand tlg jirm an tlgsg sgjtabns i`sb
divg rasg tb viragm usgr pgrspgjtavgs
watlan tlg sihg `bjitabn inm jrbss
`bjitabn. ]g prbjgss nbt bn`y `bbcgm it
i egttgr jbhprglgnsabn bf tlg spgjaj
sgjtabns bf tlg jirm eut i`sb lg`pgm
ijjuhu`itg virabus typgs bf jirms watl
magrgnt sty`gs bf rgnmgrand anfbrhitabn
(wrattgn br vasui`) bf tlg mgsadn jitgdbry.
]g jirms jbu`m tlgn eg tgstgm bn tlg
pirihgtgr bf mavgrsaty watlan bng mgsadn
jitgdbry. ]g jug jirm eisgm gxgrjasg
wis fb``bwgm ey prgsgntitabn bf fu`` jirms
inm tlgn vbtand.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 9<
Jbntm...Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 13/53
Fbr i egttgr inm mgtia`gm unmgrstinmand
bf tlg rgspbnmgnts, tlg tgih jbnmujtgm
i quajc sjgnirab inm pgrsbni eua`mand
gxgrjasg eisgm bn sgjbnmiry rgsgirjl inm
prgvabus gxpgragnjg bn g`m. Jbhhbn`y
usgm is in gxp`britbry hgtlbm fbr
mgjasabn-hicand, sjgnirab inm pgrsbni
eua`mand irg mgsadn rgsgirjl tbb`s tb
lg`p eua`m i`tgrnitavg vasabns bf pbssae`g
futurgs/satuitabns tlit magrgnt typgs bf
rgspbnmgnts hiy fijg, watl rgspgjt tb
i pirtaju`ir prbe`gh irgi. ]gsg tbb`s
Zjgnirab inm pgrsbni eua`mand?
lg`p tb ladl`adlt masjbntanuatags frbh tlg
prgsgnt, rgvgi` jlbajgs ivia`ie`g inm tlgar
pbtgntai` jbnsgqugnjgs.
Bur usgr prb`g jbnsastgm bf Frbnt`ang
lgi`tl wbrcgrs (iuxa`airy nursg hamwavgs,
IZLIs) inm egngjairags. Fijtbrs sujl
is nihg, idg, fiha`y typg, mavgrsaty an
triats/jlirijtgrastajs bf tlg anmavamui`,
ghp`byhgnt stitus inm wbrc gxpgragnjg
i`bnd watl satuitabns rg`itand tb tlg usidg
bf tlg jirm wgrg anj`umgm an tlg gxgrjasg.
Jrbss `bjitabni``y, i tbti` bf 95 sjgnirabs
inm 99 pgrsbnis wgrg mgvg`bpgm fbr :
jbuntrags. Zatuitabns fijgm ey F@LTs
watl rgspgjt tb ``and inm linm`and bf
lgi`tl jirms, amgntajitabn bf tlg jla`m,
mgi`and watl tlg jirms an ghgrdgnjy
satuitabns, jrgitand iwirgngss iebut
dgttand ahhunazitabns, wgrg `bbcgm
it. Gmujitabn `gvg`s, sbjai` mbdhis,
iwirgngss iebut tlg jirm, sgrabusngss
tbwirms tlg rbutang ahhunazitabns,
eglivaburi` pittgrns wla`g dgttand
ahhunazitabns gtj. wgrg sbhg bf tlg
satuitabns jbnsamgrgm fbr egngjairags.
[rg ghptand lbw tlg magrgnt canms
bf usgrs rg`itg watl tlg jirm an virabus
satuitabns eisgm bn tlgar cnbw`gmdg inm
gxpgragnjg prbvgm tb eg in ahpbrtint
ispgjt an lg`pand us unmgrstinm tlg
hanmsgt bf tlg usgrs inm wis egngjai`
an tlg fb``bwand rgsgirjl tbb`s tlit wg
ghp`bygm fbr gvi`uitabn inm g`m wbrc.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 5;
Jbntm...Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 14/53
Fbjus Drbup Masjussabns?
An in gbrt tb vi`amitg tlg gjijy
bf tlg mgsadn gntrags, Fbjus Drbup
Masjussabns (frbh lgrgbn rgfgrrgm tb is
FDM) wgrg jbnmujtgm ey tlg JCZ tgih
an i jbntrb``gm gnvarbnhgnt watl tlg
lgi`tl jirg wbrcgrs inm egngjairags
an i`` tlg tlrgg rgsgirjl `bjitabns. Gijl
rgsgirjl `bjitabn lim sax FDMs tlit wgrggqui``y mavamgm ihbnd lgi`tl wbrcgrs
inm egngjairags. Fbr gijl FDM 6 tb <
rgspbnmgnts wgrg jlbsgn frbh virabus
idg erijcgts inm gxpgragnjg `gvg` (lgi`tl
wbrcgrs bn`y).
b anfusg i sgnsg bf margjtabn tb tlg FDMs
mgtia`gm g`m duamgs wgrg wrattgn, wlajl
wgrg bn`y pbssae`g tlrbudl gxtgnsavg
sgjbnmiry rgsgirjl inm erianstbrhand
sgssabns wlajl wgrg unmgrticgn tb
jbhprglgnm tlg jurrgnt lgi`tl jirg
systghs an i`` tlg tlrgg `bjitabns.
Zujl gbrts issastgm an frihand egttgr
qugstabns wlajl gvgntui``y `gm tb
egttgr ansadlts.
]g g`m duamgs i`sb anjbrpbritgm tlg
jli``gndgs fijgm ey tlg lgi`tl jirg
wbrcgrs inm tlg egngjairags an magrgnt
stidgs bf tlg ahhunazitabn prbjgss. Furtlgrhbrg, an brmgr tb livg i egttgr
unmgrstinmand bf tlg ahhunazitabn jirm
inm ats magrgnt sgjtabns, nuhgrbus jug
jirms wgrg jrgitgm fbr hbst sgjtabns bf tlg
jirm a.g. Wnaqug Amgntaty, Ahhunazitabn
sjlgmu`g, Ngw anfbrhitabn g`ms, Vasui`
hgtiplbr, jb`br, hitgrai` inm fbrh.
]g jug jirms wgrg tlgn usgm tb frihg
tlg qugstabns wlajl sggc tb ipprglgnm
tlg `gvg` bf unmgrstinmand ihbnd tlg
rgspbnmgnts inm tlgar rgisbns fbr jlbbsandi spgjaj jug jirm.
]g `ist pirt bf tlg g`m duamg mgi`t watl
tlg gntarg jirm an wlajl tlg rgspbnmgnts
wgrg iscgm tb vbtg fbr tlgar fivbratg jirms.
Yugstabns wgrg frihgm tb cnbw tlg
rgisbns eglanm tlgar jlbajg. b fija`atitg
tlg gisg bf unmgrstinmand g`m duamgs
wgrg trins`itgm antb tlg `bji` `induidgs
fbr Ealir inm Anmbngsai. An Cgnyi, tlg
rgspbnmgnts wgrg jbhfbrtie`g watl
Gnd`asl is tlg `induidg bf anstrujtabn
inm jbnvgrsitabn.
An Cgnyi inm Anmbngsai JCZ obangm
linms watl `bji` rgsgirjl pirtngrs
wlb lg`pgm hbmgritg inm trins`itg
tlg FDMs. An Anmai JCZ hbnatbrgm tlg
rgjruathgnt prbjgss inm hbmgritabn bftlg FDMs bn tlgar bwn.
]g prbjgss fb``bwgm an tlg FDM‑s
wis tb anataitg i masjussabn irbunm
tlg jurrgnt jirm inm mb in ajg
ergicand sgssabn watl tlg rgspbnmgnts
wlajl wbu`m hicg tlgh fgg` hbrg
jbhfbrtie`g an slirand tlgar stbrags inm
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 55
Jbntm...Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afgVagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 15/53
gxpgragnjgs watl tlg jurrgnt jirm inm tlg
ahhunazitabn prbjgss. ]g rgspbnmgnts
wgrg tlgn iscgm iebut iny maju`tags tlgy
fijgm watl tlg jurrgnt jirm inm tlg prbjgss
tlgy fb``bw wla`g dgttand ahhunazitabns.
Iftgr dgttand i sgnsg bf tlg prbe`ghs fijgm
ey tlg rgspbnmgnts wla`g linm`and tlg
ahhunazitabn rgjbrms wg eua`t tlg ngxt
sgqugnjg bf qugstabns irbunm tlgh sb is
tb egttgr prbeg tlg masjussabn.
Iftgr in anataitabn bf tlg jrataji`atags
inm fi``buts, tlg rgspbnmgnts wgrg
antrbmujgm tb tlg sg`gjtgm jug jirms bf
spgjaj jitgdbrags. Fbr gxihp`g, Wnaqug
Amgntajitabn wis tlg rst sgjtabn tlit wis
antrbmujgm. ]g sgqugnjand bf tlg sgjtabns
wis `iam but bn tlg eisas bf tlg antgrijtabn
tlit tbbc p`ijg wla`g ijjgssand tlg jirm an
tlg ahhunazitabn prbjgss.
Fbr gijl sgjtabn tlg rgspbnmgnts lim tb
jlbbsg tlgar hbst inm tlg `gist prgfgrrgm
jug jirms. ]g ritand systgh furtlgr
i``bwgm us tb dgt i fggmeijc tb wlit wis
hbst `acgm inm tlg rgisbns fbr tlg sihg.
]g FDM‑s wgrg mgsadngm cggpand an hanm
tlg magrgnt nggms inm tlg antgrijtabn
tlit lgi`tl wbrcgrs inm pirgnts livg wla`g
antgrijtand watl tlg jirm. Fbr gxihp`g, tlglgi`tl wbrcgrs sg`gjtgm tlg jirms tlit wgrg
jbhprglgnsavg, gisy tb `` inm i`sb gisy tb
hiantian. ]gy i`sb vbtgm cggpand an hanm
tlgar wbrc sjlgmu`gs inm egngjairags `gvg`
bf unmgrstinmand.
]g nursgs wgrg iscgm tb `` sgts bf
ahhunazitabn jug jirm jitgdbrags wlajl
lg`pgm unmgrstinm tlg tahg ticgn
tb jbhprglgnm i ngw jlirt inm tlg
prbjagnjy watl wlajl tlgy jbu`m ``
tlg sihg. ]us gvi`uitand tlg mgsadn
gntrags bn tlg `gvg` bf mgtia`s prbvamgm
cggpand an hanm tlg tisc it linm. ]g
egngjairags bn tlg btlgr linm wgrg
prgsgntgm bn`y tlbsg jug jirms tlit
wgrg sg`gjtgm inm ``gm ey tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgrs. ]g hian idgnmi egand af tlgy
jbu`m antgrprgt tlg anfbrhitabn ``gm
an ey tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs an tlg ngw
fbrhit prbvamgm ey tlg suddgstgm gntry.
]as prbjgss lg`pgm tb ipprglgnm tlg
prgfgrgnjgs bf egngjairags rgdirmand
magrgnt jitgdbrags.
Iftgr tlg jbhp`gtabn bf tlg jug
jirm jitgdbrags pbantand but spgjaj
jratgrabn wg fbjusgm bn unmgrstinm
fbrh inm jb`bur, wlajl lim ebtl
funjtabni` inm ju`turi` ispgjts p`iyand
i rb`g an tlg sg`gjtabn.
]as wis gvi`uitgm usand gntarg jirms.
An tlas ijtavaty tlg rgspbnmgnts jlbbsg
tlg mgsadn gntrags wlajl wgrg fu```and
tlg nggms br tlg jratgrai tlgy lim
anmajitgm gir`agr an tlg FDM prbtbjb`.
Fbjus drbup masjussabns an prbdrgss an
Cgnyi, Anmbngsai inm Ealir (j`bjcwasg)
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 5=
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 16/53
[rbjgss Jbnstriants ?
]g prbogjt wis fbjusgm bn wbrcand an
tlrgg magrgnt jbuntrags wlajl wgrg vgry
magrgnt frbh gijl btlgr an i`hbst gvgry
ispgjt, watl tlg bn`y saha`iraty egand
tlit tlgy irg i`` pirt bf tlg ghgrdand
gjbnbhags bf tlg wbr`m.
Is wg wgrg wbrcand watlan tlg `ahats bfprg-mgngm tahg`ang, wg lim tb ripam`y
jbnmgnsg plisgs bf mgsadn ini`ysas inm
g`ahanitg prbtbtypg `bji`azitabn a.g. tlg
prbtbtypgs wgrg nbt trins`itgm antb tlg
`bji` `induidg bf tlg rgdabns. ]as wis
nbt sb hujl i eirragr an Cgnyi wlgrg
rgspbnmgnts jbnvgrsgm jbhfbrtie`y inm
wgrg usand i jla`m lgi`tl rgjbrm tlit wis
prantgm an Gnd`asl. Lbwgvgr an Anmbngsai
wlgrg tlg `induidg as Eilisi inm Anmai
wlgrg tlg `induidg as Lanma, hujl bf
tlg anfbrhitabn bn tlg prbtbtypgs jbu`m
nbt eg rgim ey rgspbnmgnts inm tlgar
rgspbnsgs wgrg `irdg`y eisgm bn i vasui`
rgimand bf tlg prbtbtypgs.
Tg i`sb unmgrstbbm tlg ju`turi`
bragntitabn inm lgi`tl jirg strujturg bf
tlg rgspgjtavg `bjitabns quajc`y an brmgr
tb i`adn bur rgsgirjl idgnmis ijjbrmand`y.
@ahatitabns bf tlg Yui`atitavg Ugsgirjl?
]grg irg jgrtian `ahatitabns bf tlas
qui`atitavg rgsgirjl wlajl nggm tb eg put
fbrwirm it in gir`y stidg fbr tlg rgimgr tb
eg ie`g tb egttgr unmgrstinm tlg qui`atitavg
ispgjt bf virabus quintatitavg nmands.
Zanjg tlg sihp`g bf tlas rgsgirjl as
jbnsamgrie`y shi``gr tlin tlit an tlg
quintatitavg plisg, tlg nmands hiy nbt
ngjgssira`y suppbrt i`` tlg nmands frbh i
qui`atitavg pbant bf vagw.
Furtlgr bn, tlgrg hiy eg antgrgstand eut
sgghand`y arrg`gvint ansadlts is wg`` is
jbntrimajtabns tb sbhg bf tlg quintatitavg
nmands eut sujl nmands irg sueogjt tb tlg
anmavamui` jlirijtgrastajs bf tlg rgsgirjl
rgspbnmgnts, wlajl wg livg tb rgspgjt
inm rgprgsgnt. An jgrtian jisgs, sbhg
nmands slbu`m nbt eg jbnsamgrgm is
jbnj`usavg egjiusg bf tlg niturg bf tlg
miti. ]g miti as ladl`y sueogjtavg inm
jin viry fbr magrgnt rgspbnmgnts.
]g rg`aiea`aty bf sujl miti as nbt
duirintggm. Tg livg, lbwgvgr,
sbudlt in ivgridg frbh hbst bf bur
rgspbnmgnts inm tlg rgsu`ts prgsgntgm
wgrg `irdg`y idrggm upbn. ]g nmands
livg eggn jrbss jlgjcgm inm wg livg
davgn tlg ivgridg pgrjgptabn i`tlbudl
an brmgr tb prbvg tlg pbant bf pgbp`g‑s
massitasfijtabn, wg livg rgprgsgntgm
wlit wis siam ey sujl sand`g usgrs
an ijtui`aty.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 56
Jbntm...Ipprbijl inm Hgtlbms
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 17/53
An i`` tlrgg `bjitabns tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs
inm egngjairags slirgm tlgar rgvagw
rgdirmand tlg gxastand jirms. An i``
`bjitabns tlg pgrjgavgm ahpbrtinjg wis
vgry magrgnt.
At wis besgrvgm tlit an Cgnyi inm
Anmbngsai, egngjairags pgrjgavgm
tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm is egand in irtgfijt
bf ahpbrtinjg inm i sadnagr bf tlg
rgspbnsaea`aty tlit tlg pirgnt fgg`s
tbwirms tlg jla`m lgi`tl inm sifgty.
Lbwgvgr an Anmai tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm
as nbt vi`ugm is egand in ahpbrtint
anfbrhitabn irtgfijt frbh tlg pgrspgjtavg
bf tlg egngjairy. ]grg wis `bw
iwirgngss bf tlg purpbsg tlit as fu```gm
tlrbudl tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm. ]g lgi`tl
wbrcgrs hgntabngm tlit tlgy mgpgnm
bn tlgar rgdastgrs ritlgr tlin tlg lgi`tl
rgjbrm an brmgr tb sgirjl fbr tlg unaqug
amgntajitabn anfbrhitabn bf tlg eiey.
=. Fag`m Ansadlts
Immatabni``y an Anmbngsai, egngjairags
issbjaitgm tlg lgi`tl jirm watl tlg jgntgr
tlit assugs. Is i rgsu`t egngjairags bftgn
mb nbt jirry tlg jirm watl tlgh an jisg
tlgy hadritg tb i ngw irgi, sanjg tlgy
gxpgjt tb eg prbvamgm watl i ngw jirm.
]as rgsu`ts an ergicmbwns an sgrvajg,
sanjg egngjairags bftgn gxpgjt tlit
tlg [LJ lis hiantiangm jbhp`gtg
lgi`tl rgjbrms.
At wis besgrvgm tlit an Anmbngsai
inm Cgnyi pirgnts vgstgm tlg bnus bf
ahhunazitabn bn tlghsg`vgs. An fijt
an Cgnyi, at wis besgrvgm tlit hbtlgrs
irg bftgn imhbnaslgm fbr hassand i
vijjanitabn mitg. Is i jbnsgqugnjg
pirgnts fumdg tlg miti inm tlit jihg but
is egand i sgrabus jbnjgrn ihbndst lgi`tl
wbrcgrs an Cgnyi.
Lbwgvgr an Anmai tlg egngjairags bftgn
pgrjgavgm tlg bnus bf ahhunazitabn bf
tlg jla`m is vgstand watl tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrritlgr tlin tlghsg`vgs. ]g egngjairags
egjiusg bf `bw `atgrijy wgrg lgiva`y
mgpgnmgnt upbn bri` massghanitabn bf
anfbrhitabn frbh tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs inm
iny fbrh bf gndidghgnt watl tlg jirm wis
hanahi`.
=.9. Ug`itabnslap watl tlg Jirm
‐Zbhgtahgs pgbp`g mbn‑t erand tlg
jirm tb tlg lbspati`. ]gy issuhg
tlit tlg lbspati` lis rgjbrms.‘
~ Nursgs, Anmbngsai
An Cgnyi inm Anmbngsai, mug tb rg`it avg`y
egttgr `atgrijy `gvg`s, tlg lgi`tl jirm
wis hbrg sujjgssfu` an iamand tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgr an jbhhunajitand tlg ahpbrtinjg
bf tlg ahhunazitabn prbjgss. ]g jirm
wis i`sb uta`azgm ey tlg egngjairags is i
sburjg bf lgi`tl jirg anfbrhitabn.
‐Tg mb livg i jirm eut tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgr upmitgs us bn tlg mitgs. Fbr tlg
ngxt vijjanitabn, wg ticg bur jla`mrgn
wlgn slg anfbrhs us‘
- Egngjairy, Anmai
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 5<
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 18/53
=.5.9 Wnaqug Amgntajitabn
An tlg vijjanitabns prbjgss tlg anatai`
plisg as tlg amgntajitabn bf tlg jla`m,
at as tlg hbst jrataji` stgp tb gnsurg
sujjgssfu` rbutang ahhunazitabns.
Wnaqug amgntajitabn as i cgy pirihgtgr
fbr jbnrhitabn bf tlg vijjangs tlit irg
davgn inm tlg bngs tlit irg mug. Eirragrs
an amgntafyand jla`mrgn jbrrgjt`y jin
jrgitg prbe`ghs an trijcand vijjanitabn
lastbry. ]us anjrgisand tlg tlrgit bf
rgpgit br hassgm vijjanitabns.
Jli``gndgs watl Ugspgjt tb Amgntafyand
tlg Eiey (Wnaqug Amgntajitabn)
Zgjurand Bf Jrataji` Anfbrhitabn bn
tlg Jirm? An Anmai at wis besgrvgm tlit
tlg hitgrai` usgm fbr tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm
`ijcs muriea`aty sb jrataji` anfbrhitabn
as bftgn shumdgm/wapgm. Is i rgsu`t
lgi`tl wbrcgrs irg bftgn `gft watl
anjbhp`gtg anfbrhitabn tb `anc tlg
eiey watl tlg rgjbrm.
Iesgnjg bf tlg Jirm is rst `gvg` bf
amgntajitabn? An i`` `bjitabns, at wis
besgrvgm tlit hiny tahgs pirgnts mb
nbt jirry tlg lgi`tl jirm watl tlgh fbr
rbutang ahhunazitabns, wlajl prbvgs
tb eg i sadnajint jli``gndg gspgjai``y
an Anmai. Is i rgsu`t bf tlas, tlg jirm
as pgrjgavgm ey lgi`tl wbrcgrs is egand
unmgpgnmie`g is i prahiry sburjg bf
vgrajitabn fbr tlg jla `m‑s amgntaty. Lgnjg
pgrsbni` irtgfijts `acg lgi`tl wbrcgr‑s
rgdastgrs egjbhg hbrg antgdri` fbr
`ancand tlg jla`m tb tlg jirm, tlin tlg
jirm atsg`f.
]g mui` lgi`tl strujturg an Anmbngsai
bf twb lgi`tl j`anajs a.g. pbsyinmu inm
puscgshis, watl twb sgpiritg lgi`tl
rgjbrms i`sb jrgitgs jbnfusabn an
amgntajitabn bf tlg jla`m.
=.5. Jug jirm eisgm sgdrgditabn bf g`m ansadlts (Anmai, Anmbngsai, Cgnyi)
Oumdghgnt Eisgm Mgjasabn Hicand?
Jrbss `bjitabni``y, iheaduaty an `ancand
tlg jla`m watl tlg rgjbrm hicgs tlg
mgjasabn hicand prbjgss fbr amgntafyand
tlg jla`m lgiva`y mgpgnmgnt upbn tlg
oumdghgnt bf tlg lgi`tl wbrcgr br tlg
anstugnjg bf tlg hbtlgr. ]as oumdghgnt
eisgm-mgjasabn hicand egjbhgs i
jli``gndg, gspgjai``y wlgn tlgrg as
i jbhhunajitabn dip egtwggn tlg
egngjairy inm tlg lgi`tl wbrcgr. At
i`sb anjrgisgs tlg rasc bf in anjbrrgjt
vijjanitabn egand davgn tb tlg jla`m.
Fridhgntgm [itagnt Amgntaty
Anfbrhitabn? An Cgnyi at wis besgrvgm
tlit vati` anfbrhitabn, nggmgm tb `anc
tlg jla`m watl tlg jirm as sprgim ijrbss
magrgnt pidgs bf tlg ebbc`gt. ]as
`gims tb in anjrgisg an tahg ticgn tb
amgntafy tlg jla`m. I`sb hu`tap`g amgntaty
anfbrhitabn/jbmgs davgn tb i pitagnt fbr
magrgnt pue`aj systghs anjrgisgs tlg
rasc bf grrbr.
‐bti` mgpgnmgnjy bn tlg hbtlgr tb
mb tlg radlt amgntajitabn. (an jisg bf
jbnfusabn) tlg rgsu`ts jin eg anmajitgm
an i wrbnd jirm watlbut tlg prbvamgrs
nbtajand.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
‐An anstinjgs wlgn tlg hbtlgr fbrdgts
tlg jirm it lbhg, inm stiys fir
iwiy frbh tlg jgntgr, wg jlgjc lbw
jbnmgnt tlg hbtlgr as, rgdirmand
tlg `ist vijjanitabn tlit wis davgn tb
lgr jla`m egfbrg wg davg tlg jla`m tlgvijjanitabn‘
~ Nursg, Anmbngsai
‐wb nuhegrs irg davgn tb i jla`m?
i pgrhingnt rgdastgr nuhegr inm
& jla`m wg`firg nuhegr. ]g [U
nuhegr virags fija`aty tb fija`aty wla`g
tlg JTJ as davgn bn`y bnjg, hiny
prbvamgrs jbnfusg tlgsg nuhegrs inm
wratg at wrbnd`y bn tlg ebbc.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
]g sjittgrgm pidgs i`sb pbsgs i
jli``gndg an amgntafyand tlg jla`megjiusg tlg mgtia`s tlit irg rgquargm tb
amgntafy i jla`m irg an magrgnt pidgs
an tlg gxastand ebbc`gt pidg 4 ‚ eiey
anfbrhitabn, pidg 5; eiey inm hbtlgr
anfbrhitabn, pidg :; idian eiey
anfbrhitabn.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg :;
Jbntm...Fag`m Ansadlts
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 19/53
=.5 Jug jirm eisgm sgdrgditabn bf g`m ansadlts (Anmai, Anmbngsai, Cgnyi)
Ugspbnsgs tb Ngw Mgsadn [rbpbsat abns ?
]g mgsadn gntrags, tlit wgrg suehattgm
tb tlg jbntgst, prbpbsgm sgvgri`
magrgnt hgtlbms bf ahprbvand unaqug
amgntajitabn inm trijcand pitagnts
rindand frbh immatabn bf plbtbdripls,
hircand bf eartlhircs, eabhgtraj prants,
eir inm YU jbmgs inm tlg immatabn tb
twb immrgssgs.
(a) [lbtbdripl is in Amgntagr? An i``
`bjitabns unmgr stumy at wis pgrjgavgm
tlit tlg plbtbdripl bf tlg fiha`y bn
tlg rgjbrm wis tlg gisagst inm hbst
jbnvgnagnt fbrh bf amgntajitabn. At wis
i`sb `bbcgm upbn is i fijtbr tb anjrgisg
tlg ghbtabni` issbjaitabn bf pirgnts watl
tlg rgjbrm.
Funjtabni`aty unmgr Murgss? I cgy
mravgr bf jlbajg fbr tlg plbtbdripl
jirm is at wis vi`ugm fbr egand i unaqug
amgntagr lg`pand amgntafy tlg jla`m gvgnaf tlg jirm wis tbrn/spba`t. At i`sb lis
tlg iea`aty fbr ipp`ajiea`aty ijrbss mavgrsg
satuitabns, lgi`tl wbrcgrs frbh Anmai
vi`ugm tlg fijt tlit tlg plbtbdripl
wa`` eg usgfu` tb amgntafy tlg jla`m
gvgn af tlg jla`m as ijjbhpinagm watl
iny rg`itavg br i duirmain. An Anmai, an
immatabn tb tlg iebvg, pgrjgavgm gisg
an ahp`ghgntitabn wis i cgy mravgr bf
tlg mgjasabn tb jlbbsg tlg plbtbdripl
sanjg davgn tlg jurrgnt anfristrujturg
jbnstriants an tlg pue`aj lgi`tl sgjtbr an
Ealir, lgi`tl-wbrcgrs pgrjgavgm tlas tb eg
tlg gisagst tb ahp`ghgnt. Lbwgvgr drbup
jbnsgnsus wis nbt rgijlgm bn wlgtlgr
tlg bnus bf rgspbnsaea`aty bf irrindand
fbr tlg plbtbdripl slbu`m eg bn tlg
lgi`tl j`anaj br upbn tlg egngjairy. An
Anmbngsai egngjairags pgrjgavgm tlg
plbtbdripl jirm is egand in ggjtavg
i`tgrnitavg an jisg bf iny jbnstriants tb
tlg ahp`ghgntitabn bf tgjlnb`bdy.
‐]as jirm as lg`pfu` an jisg tlg `gttgrs
irg fimgm.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐[lbtb‑s slbu`m eg ticgn it magrgnt
stidgs is tlg jla`m drbws, is jla`mrgn‑sippgirinjg jlindgs watl tahg.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
[grjgavgm Masimvintidgs bf tlg
Jirm? An Cgnyi, nursgs pgrjgavg
tlit tlg plbtbdripl as nbt i dbbm
bptabn fbr amgntajitabn, is tlg eiey
drbws, las fijg jlindgs bvgr tahg an
tlg rst twb ygirs. ]g plbtbdripl
as i`sb nbt mgghgm vgry murie`g is
at jin eg gisa`y mihidgm ey rbutang
wgir inm tgir. Immatabni``y an Anmai,
sbhg nursgs wgrg scgptaji` iebut tlg
ahp`ghgntitabn bf sujl in anataitavg.
‐Ztajcand plbtbs bn tlg jirms hadlt
nbt `ist `bnd. ]gy hiy tgir br dgt
mihidgm.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐]as plbtb amgi hadlt nbt wbrcan va``idgs. ]g Ealir Dbvt. assugs
pissebbcs inm ats maju`t fbr tlgh gvgn
tb davg bng plbtbdripl fbr at. ]gy siy
tlit tlit tlg hbngy tlgy dgt wbu`m i``
dgt spgnt an j`ajcand tlit bng pajturg.‘
~ Nursg, Anmai
[lbtbdripl is in amgntafgr ~ ]g Zip`and Jirm | I[[9<1<15
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg :5
Jbntm...Fag`m Ansadlts
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 20/53
=.5 Jug jirm eisgm sgdrgditabn bf g`m ansadlts (Anmai, Anmbngsai, Cgnyi)
(aa) Eabhgtrajs Fbbtprant? An
Anmbngsai, tlas jirm wis drgit`y vi`ugm
ey egngjairags is egand i sadnagr
bf tlg unaqug amgntaty bf tlg jla`m.
[grhingnjy inm ijjgssaea`aty bf miti
wgrg cgy issbjaitabns tlit wgrg himg
ey egngjairags watl rgspgjt tb tlas
jirm. Inbtlgr fijtbr jbntraeutand tb
tlas sg`gjtabn wis tlg fijt tlit tlg
fbbtprant bf tlg eiey as jb``gjtgm it eartl
it tlg [LJ an Anmbngsai. Is i rgsu`t,
egngjairags pgrjgavgm tlg fbbtprant tb
eg in anataitavg tlit as gisa`y ahp`ghgntgm
sanjg tlas anfbrhitabn as i`rgimy egand
jb``gjtgm it prgsgnt ey lgi`tl j`anajs
wlgn tlg jla`m as ebrn.
Inbtlgr mravand fijtbr eglanm tlg
jlbajg bf tlg fbbtprant wis tlg fijt tlit
at as issbjaitgm is egand unaqug tb tlg
jla`m. Immatabni``y tlg fbbtprant as usgm
is i unaqug amgntagr, at i`sb egjbhgs
ijjgssae`g tb tlg egngjairy is i vi`uie`g
hghbry irtgfijt, wlajl wa`` ahprbvg tlgghbtabni` vi`ug bf tlg jirm, tlus iamand
tlgh an tlg rgtgntabn bf tlg jirm.
‐A tlanc tlg eirjbmg wa`` sta`` eg
funjtabni` wlgn tlg jla`m lis i`rgimy
drbwn up.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐A sta`` jin db tb tlg btlgr j`anaj sanjg
tlg eirjbmg wa`` slbw tlg sihg miti‘
- Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐Fbbtprant inm ndgrprant as i`rgimy
pirt bf tlg jirm fbr amgntafyand tlg
eiey eut at as nbt an tlg jirm tlit wg
ticg lbhg (tlg [uscgshis jirm). Eutat as an tlg jirm tlit tlg [bsyinmu
lis.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
Masimvintidgs bf Eabhgtrajs? Egngjairags
an Anmbngsai wgrg jbdnazint bf tlg fijt tlit
tlg fbbtprant is i miti pbant as `ahatgm an
niturg gspgjai``y fbr anfbrhi` mg`avgrags.
Immatabni``y an Anmai, lgi`tl wbrcgrs
pgrjgavgm tlit tlg miti jb``gjtgm tlrbudl tlg
fbbtprant, jin bn`y eg usgm it tlg jgntgr tlit
jb``gjts tlit anfbrhitabn. ]gy wgrg unie`g
tb ahidang lbw tlas anfbrhitabn jin eg
himg ivia`ie`g ijrbss btlgr [LJs. An Anmai,
nursgs jbnsamgrgm tlg fbbtprant jirm tb eg
gxtrghg`y tahg jbnsuhand.
At wis pgrjgavgm tlit bnjg tlg jla`m egjbhgs
b`mgr at wa`` eg lirmgr tb jrbss rgfgrgnjg tlgar
amgntajitabn tlrbudl tlgar fbbtprants.
‐]g fbbtprant jinnbt eg mbng it
gvgry p`ijg wlgrg i jla`m as ebrn,
an anstinjgs wlgrg tlg eartl as
linm`gm ey in anfbrhi` hamwafg.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐Af tlg jla`m as ebrn an [LJ tlgn
amgntafyand tlrbudl fbbtprant
sjinnand hicgs sgnsg. Lbwgvgr Af lg‑s nbt ebrn an tlg [LJ, lbw
wbu`m wg livg eijcup miti tb
jbnrh las amgntaty2‘
~ Lgi`tl wbrcgr, Ealir Eabhgtrajs fbbtprant ~ Ugjbrms fbr
@afg? in annbvitavg, jbhpijt, inm
murie`g rgmgsadn bf tlg jla`m lgi`tl
rgjbrm, suehattgm ey City Lirras bn
egli`f bf Fitlbh Anfbrhitabn Mgsadn
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg :=
Jbntm...Fag`m Ansadlts
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 21/53
=.5 Jug jirm eisgm sgdrgditabn bf g`m ansadlts (Anmai, Anmbngsai, Cgnyi)
(aaa) ]g Eartlhirc is in Amgntagr?
]g amgi bf nbtand tlg eartl-hirc is
in amgntagr wis `irdg`y pgrjgavgm is
unfgisae`g ijrbss `bjitabns. Ebtl lgi`tl-
wbrcgrs inm egngjairags wgrg unsurg
iebut tlg pgrhingnjy bf tlg eartl-hirc,
inm wgrg tlgrgfbrg mbuetfu` iebut ats
suatiea`aty is i prahiry amgntagr sanjg at
hadlt nbt eg tlgrg fbr i`` jla`mrgn, watl
sbhg pgrjgavand tlit tlg eartlhirc wa``
fimg iwiy watl tahg.
Iheaduaty bvgr wlit jbnstatutgs i
eartlhirc? Lgi`tl wbrcgrs pgrjgavgm
tlit pgbp`g hiy livg hiny typgs bf
hircs sb tlgrg wis i jbnfusabn is tbwlit jbnstatutgs i eartlhirc inm lbw
at wa`` eg amgntagm. At i`sb prbogjts
jbnjgrns bvgr prbjgss gjagnjy, an
btlgr anstinjgs, lgi`tl wbrcgrs an
Anmbngsai wgrg unsurg iebut wlgtlgr tlg
eartlhirc wa`` eg i tahg gjagnt wiy bf
amgntafyand i jla`m
Zbjai` Ztadhi? Egngjairags an Anmai
wgrg unjbhfbrtie`g watl tlg amgi
bf tlgar jla`m egand anspgjtgm fbr i
eartlhirc gvgry tahg i vijjanitabn
lis tb eg mbng. An i`` `bjitabns unmgr
stumy, lgi`tl wbrcgrs wgrg jbdnazint
bf tlg egngts bf anj`umand anfbrhitabn
iebut tlg eartlhirc bn tlg jirm. Lgi`tl
wbrcgrs wgrg hbrg jbhfbrtie`g watl
tlas anfbrhitabn p`iyand tlg rb`g bf i
eijcup amgntagr ritlgr tlin i prahiry
amgntagr (inm tlgrgfbrg rgjbrmgm an tlg
jirm is i fbbtnbtg ritlgr tlin i vasui`.)
‐Is tlg eiey drbws tlg eartlhirc
wa`` jlindg.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐]g eartl hirc as nbt tbb ijjuritg,
egjiusg bng jla`m jin livg tlg
sihg hirc watl inbtlgr.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐]g jla`m hiy nbt livg i
eartlhirc an i vasae`g irgi, sb
nmand at hiy ticg us tahg.‘
~ Nursg, Anmbngsai
(av) Eir Jbmg is in amgntagr? ]g
eirjbmg wis hbst `acgm an Cgnyi ey
egngjairags inm nursgs. ]g jirm
wis pgrjgavgm is rgsu`tand an gisg bf
amgntajitabn bf tlg jrgmgntai`s bf tlg
jla`m. Ijjgssaea`aty bf anfbrhitabn an
bng p`ijg wis vi`ugm drgit`y ey nursgswatl rgspgjt tb tlas jirm. Bng rgisbn
fbr tlas as tlit at rgmujgs tlg jrataji`aty
bf tlg egngjairy hiantianand tlg
lgi`tl rgjbrm sifg`y, watl rgspgjt tb tlg
ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g.
‐]g jirm wa`` eg usgfu` an amgntafyand
twans.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐]as jirm wbu`m wbrc egst egjiusg
unaqug AM wbn‑t jlindg inm ats radlt it
tlg jbvgr pidg bf tlg jirm.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐]g jirm as usgfu` egjiusg i`` tlg
mgtia`s bf tlg jla`m irg jipturgm a.g.
unaqug AM, Jla`m‑s AM, `bjitabn. Btlgr
tlin tlgsg, tlg dgnmgr bf tlg jla`m asi`sb jipturgm an tlg jirm..‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐]g tgjlnb`bdy wbu`m eg in immgm
imvintidg, egjiusg at wa`` davg us hbrg
miti iebut tlg jla`m.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐Bng lgi`tl-wbrcgr wa`` jlgjc tlg
wgadlt inm lgadlt, an tlg lgi`tl
j`anaj, inm inbtlgr lgi`tl-wbrcgr
wa`` davg tlg vijjang, tlgn wlb wa``
jlgjc tlg eartlhirc inm lbw wa``
tlgy jbhhunajitg.‘
~ Lgi`tl-wbrcgr, Cgnyi
]g Eartlhirc is in amgntagr ~ Vasui`s
Zivg @avgs, suehattgm ey Uifig` Vavis, Nita
Ubmradugz, @ujai Irnium, Yuaqug Jarai, I`virb
Brtaz, Fgrninmb Jisimb, Nimai Ugvg`b inm
Oivagr Irniaz bn egli`f bf VAZWI@A_IHBZ
YU jbmg jirm ~ Ugjbrms fbr @afg ‚ suehattgm ey
Dbpaci [irelu, Ziri Jbrradin-Daees, Obln Lini
inm Hittlgw Zjlirpnajc bn egli`f bf G`gnt Mgs
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg :6
Jbntm...Fag`m Ansadlts
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 22/53
=.5 Jug jirm eisgm sgdrgditabn bf g`m ansadlts (Anmai, Anmbngsai, Cgnyi)
Erbimgr [grjgptabns irbunm
gjlnb`bdy? An Anmbngsai inm Cgnyi,
tgjlnb`bdy wis pgrjgavgm is egand
sbplastajitgm inm mgsarie`g. At wis
besgrvgm tlit in isparitabni` vi`ug wis
issbjaitgm watl tgjlnb`bdy.
An Anmbngsai, usgrs prgfgrrgm tlit
tgjlnb`bdy slbu`m p`iy i pissavg rb`g,
tb amgntafy tlg eiey an anstinjgs wlgn
tlg jirm as `bst/tbrn. An fijt egngjairags
prgfgrrgm af tgjlnb`bdy as ahp`ghgntgm
it tlg gnm bf tlg lgi`tl prbvamgr, an brmgr
tb rgmujg tlg ahp`ajitabns bf `bsand tlg
lgi`tl rgjbrm. Cgnyin usgrs wgrg hbrg
ijjgptand bf tgjlnb`bdy.
An Anmai i`tlbudl tgjlnb`bdy wis
pgrjgavgm is egand mgsarie`g, rgspbnsgs
wgrg suemugm mug tb ipprglgnsabns
bvgr anfristrujturg jbnstriants i`sb nbt
gvgrybng wa`` eg ie`g tb unmgrstinm jbmg
sjinnand..Immatabni``y at wis besgrvgm
tlit ebtl egngjairags inm lgi`tlwbrcgrs wgrg unie`g tb mastanduasl
egtwggn tlg funjtabnand bf i eir jbmg
inm i YU jbmg.
‐Egjiusg bf tlg eirjbmg, wg jin rgim
inm slbw tlg miti it iny tahg. af tlg
miti wrattgn as `bst, an jisg bf fimand,
wg jin sta`` livg tlg miti frbh tlg
eirjbmg.‘
~ Nursg, Anmbngsai
‐Hy jla`m‑s fbbtprant wa`` nbt eg tlg
sihg is inybng g`sg‑s.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
‐Zjinnand inm dgttand i`` tlg
anfbrhitabn it bnjg as fist inm
rg`aie`g.‘
~ Nursg Cgnyi
‐Lbw jin wg eg surg tlit iny
tgjlnb`bdy ghp`bygm fbr amgntafyand
wa`` eg prgsgnt gvgrywlgrg an Anmai2‘
~ Nursg, Anmai
‐Zjinnand i fbbtprant as nbt tlg egst
wiy tb amgntafy i jla`m. Lbw as at gvgn dband tb eg usgm2‘
~ Nursg, Anmai
=.5.5 Ahhunazitabn Zjlgmu`g?
Ahhunazitabn Zjlgmu`g as bng bf tlg
hbst ahpbrtint sgjtabns bf i jirm. ]g
ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g as mgtgrhangm an
tieu`ir fbrh an i`` tlg `bjitabns. At p`iys
in ahpbrtint rb`g fbr lgi`tl wbrcgrs
tb mgtgrhang tlg mug mitg fbr tlg ngxt
vijjanitabn inm tlg vijjanitabns davgn. At
as gqui``y ahpbrtint fbr tlg egngjairags
is at gnie`gs tlgh tb cggp i trijc bf tlg
vijjanitabns inm tlg mug mitgs.
Jli``gndgs?
An Anmai, tlg ahhunazitabn tie`gs irg
jurrgnt`y rgfgrrgm tb ey `atgritg hbtlgrs
bn`y is i sburjg bf jbnrhitabn bf
wlgtlgr tlgar jla`m lis eggn vijjanitgm
br nbt. ]gy mb nbt usui``y jlgjc tlg
mug mitg fbr tlg ngxt vijjanitabn is tlgy
cnbw tlit hbea`azgrs (IZLI‑s) irg tlgrg
tb rghanm tlgh. ]g hbtlgrs gxprgssgm
tlgar jbnjgrn bn jbhprglgnsabn inm
unmgrstinmand bf tlg tie`g. ]gy fg`t tlit
tlbudl at as ahpbrtint tb cnbw wlajl
vijjangs livg eggn imhanastgrgm, tlgy
irg nbt ie`g tb ittijl tlg ahpbrtinjg bf
unmgrstinmand bf tlg tie`g.
]g jurrgnt ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g as
jbnfusand fbr tlg hbtlgrs is tlg mitias davgn ebtl lbrazbnti``y is wg`` is
vgrtaji` `y hicand at ma ju`t fbr hbtlgrs
tb fb``bw tlg stbw bf anfbrhitabn bn
tlg jirm.
]g Lgi`tl wbrcgrs, fg`t tlit tlg jurrgnt
jirm mbgsn‑t livg gnbudl spijg tb imm
i`` anfbrhitabn. ]g anfbrhitabn immgm
sbhgtahgs dgts rueegm b inm tlgy i`sb
fg`t tlg nggm tb livg i mgsjraptabn bf gijl
vijjanitabn davgn, is egngjairags bftgn
isc tlgh qugstabns rg`itgm tb tlit. ]gy
fg`t tlit tlgrg as i `ijc bf j`iraty an tlg
prgsgnt jirm.
]g egngjairags frbh Cgnyi, fg`t tlit
tlg tgrhanb`bdags inm ieergvaitabns usgm
an tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g irg tbb
jbhp`ajitgm fbr tlg pirgnts tb unmgrstinm.
]gy hgntabngm tlit sgha-`atgritg pgbp`g
i`sb nm tlg sjlgmu`g maju`t is at as tbb
tgxt lgivy inm fiar`y jbhp`ajitgm.
]g Lgi`tl wbrcgrs, frbh Cgnyi
hgntabngm jli``gndgs `acg ijjurijy,
iutlgntajaty inm mgjagnjy. ]gy siam
tlit hiny i tahgs tlgy fijg jli``gndg an
tgrhs bf ji`ju`itand tlg ngxt mug. ]g
hbtlgrs bftgn jlindg tlg mug mitg an jisg
tlgy hass tlg vijjanitabn tb ivbam dgttand
sjb`mgm frbh tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs. I`sb,
tlgy fg`t nggm fbr hbrg spijg tb imm hassgm
vijjanitabns inm btlgr a nfbrhitabn.
An Anmbngsai, tlg rgspbnmgnts livg ladl
`atgrijy ritgs inm tlgy prgfgrrgm tb rgim
inm jlgjc tlg jirm fbr tlg ngxt mug mitg.
‐A``atgritg pirgnts mbn‑t unmgrstinm
tlg anfbrhitabn an tlg ebbc`gt. ]grg
slbu`m eg i wiy bf prgsgntand tlg
anfbrhitabn wg`` sb tlit gvgn is i `iy
pgrsbn jin unmgrstinm tlgh.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg :<
Jbntm...Fag`m Ansadlts
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 23/53
Tlgn tlgy fbrdgt iebut tlg ahhunazitabn,
tlgy rg`y bn tlg lgi`tl systgh. Fbr
rghghegrand tlg mitg tlgy mgvasg tlgar
bwn wiys `acg hicand i hirc an tlg
ji`gnmir, puttand plbng i`irhs gtj.
‐A jlgjc hy sjlgmu`g eut af A hass tlg
vijjanitabn mitg, A wa`` wiat fbr tlg
pbsyinmu sjlgmu`g inm db tlgrg. A
hicg i nbtg bn tlg ji`gnmir iebut hy
ngxt vasat.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
Ugspbnsgs tb Ngw Mgsadn [rbpbsatabns?
Vasui`s Zivg @avgs? ]as jug jirm
wis `acgm an i`` tlrgg `bjitabns ey
tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs is wg`` is tlg
egngjairags. ]g lgi`tl wbrcgrs fg`t
tlg sjlgmu`g wis gisy tb unmgrstinm
egjiusg bf tlg vasui`s inm tlgrg wis
j`iraty bf anfbrhitabn.
]g nursgs ipprgjaitgm tlg jirm is at
anj`umgm sgjtabns bf btlgr vijjangs,
tlg nihgs bf vijjangs wrattgn an fu``
fbrh inm nbt an ieergvaitabns, tlgy fg`t
at wis usgfu` fbr ebtl tlg nursgs inm
tlg pirgnts is at wa`` rgmujg jisgs bf
jbnfusabn inm tlg fijt tlit at wbu`m eg
gisagr tb gxp`ian at tb tlg hbtlgrs.
]g egngjairags hgntabngm tlg
jirm wis wg`` a``ustritgm inm gisy
tb unmgrstinm gvgn fbr tlg a``atgritg
hbtlgrs. Ijjbrmand tb tlgh tlg
anfbrhitabn wis j`gir, jbnjasg inm
tlg anfbrhitabn wis wg`` sgdrgditgm.
Lbwgvgr, tlgy stitgm i fgw `ahatitabns
bf tlg jug jirm, tlgy fg`t tlit mug mitg
sgjtabn wis hassand. ]gy suddgstgm
i sgpiritg jb`uhn fbr mug mitg i`bnd
samg tlg mitg bf jurrgnt vijjanitabn.
]g Uianebw Ugjbrm? ]as wis tlg
sgjbnm hbst prgfgrrgm jirm ihbnd tlg
egngjairags inm lgi`tl wbrcgrs. ]gy
hgntabngm tlit tlg jug jirm wis j`gir,
sahp`g, tlg vijjanitabn mitg inm tlg
ngxt mug mitg wgrg j`gir`y hgntabngm
i`bnd watl tlg sadniturg bf tlg
lgi`tl wbrcgr davand tlit pirtaju`ir
vijjanitabn.
]g pajturg as antgrgstand inm wa``
lg`p tlg pirgnts tb unmgrstinm tlg
anfbrhitabn gisa`y. At as sahp`g inm
lis anfbrhitabn iebut ngxt vasat
mitg sb tlg pirgnt wa`` prgpirg fbr
tlg ngxt vasat vijjang.‘
~ Lgi`tl wbrcgr, Anmbngsai
‐]g jirm watl tlg pajturg a s rgi``y
dbbm. Ats rgi``y gisy tb unmgrstinm
inm an jisg af tlg lgi`tl wbrcgr br
IZLI as nbt irbunm wg jin rgfgr tb
tlg jirm fbr lg`p.‘~ Egngjairy, Anmai
‐]g ngxt vasat an tlg jirm slbu`m eg
ngxt tb tlg jurrgnt vasat anfbrhitabn.‘
~ Lgi`tl wbrcgr, Anmbngsai
]g Uianebw Ugjbrm? Uipam Ijjgss Ahhunazitabn Nbw? Egttgr Bur Tbr`m,
suehattgm ey Inmrgs Hbrbs, Wnavgrsaty bf Lbustbn stumgn
]g Eartlhirc is in amgntagr ~ Vasui`s Zivg @avgs, suehattgm ey Uifig`
Vavis, Nita Ubmradugz, @ujai Irnium, Yuaqug Jarai, I`virb Brtaz, Fgrninmb
Jisimb, Nimai Ugvg`b inm Oivagr Irniaz bn egli`f bf VAZWI@A_IHBZ
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg =;
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 24/53
sadniturg tb eg in ggjtavg hgmauh
tb antrbmujg drgitgr ijjbuntiea`aty
watlan tlg systgh. An fijt an Anmbngsai,
lgi`tl wbrcgrs i`sb pgrjgavgm tlas tb
eg in imvintidg, ey j`iahand tlit tlg
sadniturg wa`` lg`p an amgntafyand wlajl
jgntrg lis assugm tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm
an anstinjgs wlgn tlg egngjairy lis
rgjgnt`y hadritgm tb tlg irgi.
At wis besgrvgm tlit tlg lgi`tl
jirg systgh an Cgnyi funjtabngm
an i hinngr tlit puts tlg bnus bf
rgspbnsaea`aty bf ahhunazitabn bn tlg
pirgnt. An fbjus drbup masjussabns watl
lgi`tl wbrcgrs an Cgnyi at wis fbunm
tlit fumdand bf miti as i ead jbnjgrn,
sanjg sbhg hbtlgrs mb tlit tb ivbam
egand slbutgm it ey tlg lgi`tl wbrcgr
fbr hassand i vijjanitabn mitg.
Ugimand tlg anfbrhitabn? bn tlg
sjlgmu`g? An Anmai inm Anmbngsai,
tlg vgrtaji` i`adnhgnt bf `astand
vijjanitabns i`bnd watl tahg wis
prgfgrrgm is tahg wis sggn an plisgs,
jbhand bng iftgr inbtlgr.
An Cgnyi is wg`` vgrtaji` bragntitabn
bf tahg wis ipprgjaitgm, nursgs irg
bftgn an i lieat bf ``and an hbst
mbjuhgnts `acg i jlgjc`ast inm
tlgrgfbrg tlg anjrgisgm jbhfbrt watl
rgimand inm ``and vgrtaji``y i`adngm
(tahgm) sjlgmu`gs.
‐A nm jbhfbrtie`g tb rgim tlg jirm,
inm gisy tb unmgrstinm. At hgntabns
tlg typg bf vijjang davgn, inm ngxt
vasat mitg inm mbsidg bf vijjang
davgn.‘
~ Egngjairags, Anmbngsai
‐]g ebxgs irg tbb shi``. A tlanc
tlg ebxgs slbu`m livg i `att`g spijg
egtwggn tlgh.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
Jrgitavg jirm gntrags
]g `bndatumani` ipprbijl bf tlg jirm
wis egttgr unmgrstbbm is at slbwgm tahg
inm miti ``and an tlg sihg margjtabn inm
i`adngm watl tlg rgspbnmgnts unmgrstinmand
bf tahg. ]g egngjairags prgfgrrgm tlg jirm
is tlgy fbunm at tb eg mgtia`gm watl spijg fbr
immatabni` vijjanitabns inm tlg sadn bf tlg
hamwafg.
]gy i`sb hgntabngm jgrtian `ahatitabns tlg
lgi`tl wbrcgrs inm egngjairags fg`t tlit tlg
ebxgs fbr ``and tlg anfbrhitabn wgrg tbb
shi`` inm at wbu`m eg maju`t tb rgim tlg
anfbrhitabn ``gm an at.
An i`` `bjitabns, ebtl egngjairags inm
lgi`tl wbrcgrs ittraeutgm tlg jbnjgpt bf tlg
[grsbni`azgm Vijjanitabn Tlgg`
inm Lgi`tl Ugjbrm wis tlbudlt tb
eg maju`t tb antgrprgt inm ditlgr
jrataji` anfbrhitabn an Anmai inm
Cgnyi. Immatabni``y an Anmbngsai,
pirgnts wgrg unjbhfbrtie`g watl
tlg amgi bf usand tlg wlgg` is i
mgvajg tb unmgrstinm tlg ngxt
vijjanitabn mitg.
‐At‑s i eat jbhp`ajitgm. ]g ajbns irgn‑t
gisa`y unmgrstbbm. Inahi`s Ajbns irg
jbnfusand. Hiy nbt eg ticgn sgrabus`y‘.- Egngjairy, Cgnyi
‐]as jirm wa`` eg gisy tb unmgrstinm,
issbjaitg. ]g ajbns bn tlg jirm wa``
eg jbnvgnagnt rghghegr inm wa`` eg
lg`pfu` an rgji``and tlg vijjanitabns
davgn‘. - Egngjairy, Anmai
J`bsg up bf spijg fbr Lgi`tl wbrcgr nihg
inm sadniturg
Imiptie`g, Ijjgssae`g, Ibrmie`g? Ugahidanand tlg Jla`m
Lgi`tl Ugjbrm, suehattgm ey Graji Zjlrbgmgr, Lia`gy
B‑Jbnnbr, inm @iuri @adlt`y
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg =5
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 25/53
=.5.: Drbwtl jlirts inm lgi`tl jirg
anfbrhitabn?
]g sgjtabn as ritlgr unmgrgstahitgm
tb tlg pbtgntai` lg`p inm anfbrhitabn at
jin prbvamg. ]g lgi`tl wbrcgrs inm tlg
egngjairags ebtl ijjgss tlas anfbrhitabn
eut it magrgnt `gvg`s inm satuitabns.
Hicand tlg anfbrhitabn bn tlg rgjbrm
bn`y rg`gvint it jgrtian tahgs.
]g sgjtabn mgi`s watl tlg `bw
gndidghgnt assugs wlajl irg tlg
butjbhg bf `bw `atgrijy `gvg`s inm
rg`gvinjg bf miti. Egngjairags wlb
jinnbt rgim irg nbt ie`g tb usg tlas
anfbrhitabn tb at fu`` pbtgntai`.
]g miti i`sb egjbhgs rgmunmint iftgr
i wla`g inm tlg egngjairags mb nbt
nm at vi`uie`g tb tlgh inyhbrg. ]gy
rg`y lgiva`y bn tlg vgrei` massghanitabn
bf tlas canm bf anfbrhitabn wlajl
tlgy prgfgr tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs br tlgar
rg`itavgs br fragnms tb tg`` tlgh.
Jli``gndgs?
]g gxastand jli``gndgs ijrbss `bjitabns
irbunm tlg splgrg bf lgi`tl jirg
anvb`vg tlg gndidghgnt bf tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgr, hbea`azgr inm tlg pirgnts.]g egngjairags lgiva`y rg`y bn tlg
anfbrhitabn prbvamgm ey tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgrs. Hbrg bftgn tlg anfbrhitabn
as vgrei``y massghanitgm tb tlg pirgnts
bn lbw tb ticg jirg bf tlg jla`m inm tlg
drbwtl pittgrn.
]g lgi`tl jirg prbvamgrs usg tlg jirm
tb rganstitg tlg anfbrhitabn prbvamgm ey
tlgh sb tlit egngjairags jin rg`y bn tlg
jirm fbr futurg rgfgrgnjg. ]g a``atgritg
egngjairags nm at maju`t tb rgfgr tb
tlg jirm inm irg jbhp`gtg`y mgpgnmgnt
bn tlg lgi`tl jirg prbfgssabni`s tb davg
tlgh anfbrhitabn.
Zbhgtahgs tlg egngjairy fgg` tlit tlg
miti prbvamgm an tlg jirm as nbt g`iebritg
inm mb nbt immrgss tlg prbe`ghs fijgm ey
tlgh. ]budl tlg hbtlgrs unmgrstinm
at as ahpbrtint tb cnbw tlg prbdrgss bf
jla`m‑s lgi`tl inm tlit as bn`y pbssae`g
ey trijcand tlg lgadlt inm wgadlt, tlgy
siy tlit tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs mb nbt `` tlg
drbwtl sgjtabn br tlgy gxp`ian wlit at as
fbr inm wly as at ahpbrtint.
At wis besgrvgm tlit an Anmbngsai inm
Cgnyi egngjairags wgrg gxtrghg`y
jbhfbrtie`g watl tlg amgi bf livand i
mgpgnmie`g antgrfijg bn tlg jirm atsg`f
tlrbudl wlajl tlgy jin vgrafy tlit
tlgar eiey‑s drbwtl as prbdrgssand i`bnd
gxpgjtgm `angs, bn tlgar bwn. [grlips tlas
as bng sgjtabn bf tlg jirm wlgrg tlgrg as
‐Tg irg jbhp`gtg`y mgpgnmgnt bn
tlg IZLI.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
‐]g IZLI br lgi`tl wbrcgr ngvgr
`` tlg drbwtl jlirts nbr mb tlgy
gxp`ian wlit at as fbr.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
Ugmgsadngm Ahhunazitabn Ugjbrm, suehattgm ey Mge Tbrcand
[grsbni`azgm Vijjanitabn Tlgg` inm Lgi`tl Ugjbrm, suehattgm ey Hbbn
C. Cah, ]grgsg Ebstbn, Zlga`i Aseg``, inm Hirdirati Dbnzi`gz bn egli`f
bf Dgbrdai gjl Ugsgirjl Anstatutg
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg ==
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 26/53
sjbpg tb rgmujg tlg mgpgnmgnjy upbn tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgrs tb jbhhunajitg gssgntai` anfbrhitabn.
]g egngjairags i`sb tlanc tlit unmgrstinmand
dripls inm jlirts as tbb jbhp`ajitgm fbr tlgh.
Hiny tahgs tlg lgadlt inm wgadlt miti as ``gm
an tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g spijg atsg`f is
bppbsgm tb ats davgn p`ijg wlajl jrgitgs `bt bf
jbnfusabn. I`sb i tieu`ir fbrhit watl nuhegrs
wis prgfgrgntai` ritlgr tlin i dripl.
Ugspbnsgs tb ngw mgsadn prbpbsatabn ?
Lgi`tl Jirg, Nutratabn Jbunsg``and
Anfbrhitabn?
Liata Jla`m Lgi`tl Linmebbc Ugmgsadn?
Ijrbss i`` `bjitabns tlg egngjairags
ipprgjaitgm tlg iebvg hgntabngm jirm is tlgy
fbunm tlg miti gisy tb unmgrstinm, tieu`ir, bng
iftgr inbtlgr inm nbt an tlg fbrh bf jlirts inm
dripls. ]g wirnand sadns wgrg wg`` ijjgptgm.
Egngjairags wgrg ie`g tb unmgrstinm tlg
vasui` s usgm fbr tlg sihg, wl ajl wgrg rgi`astaj
a``ustritabns ritlgr tlin iestrijtabns an tgrhs bf
vasui` st y`g.
Vasui` rgprgsgntitabn bf wirnand syheb`s wgrg
unmgrstbbm inm wg`` rgjgavgm, Anfbrhitabn
iebut wlit nbt tb mb, as jbnsamgrgm is egand
ahpbrtint. Vasui`s wgrg pgrjgavgm is egand tlg
hbst imgpt fbrh bf jbhhunajitabn fbrtlg sihg.
‐Tg jin unmgrstinm anfbrhitabn frbh
tlg pajturg. At as j`gir. A jin unmgrstinm
watlbut at nbt livand iny gxp`initabn .‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
]g lgi`tl wbrcgrs fg`t tlg jirm wis
gisy tb unmgrstinm, jbhprglgnsavg
inm tlg anfbrhitabn wis wg``
rgprgsgntgm an tlas a``ustritavg
vasui` st y`g. ]gy hgntabngm tlit
gvgn tlg egngjairags wa`` `acg inm
unmgrstinm tlg jirm is tlg drbwtl
as slbwn an plisgs tlrbudl mgtia`gm
sgqugntai` ahidgs.
Liata Jla`m Lgi`tl Linmebbc Ugmgsadn, suehattgm ey Oijqug`ang
@gg B‑Frag`, Ugegjji [grgz inm Ugdang Ogin-Frinjbas
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg =6
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 27/53
]g [ajturg bf Lgi`tl? ]g lgi`tl wbrcgrs
ipprgjaitgm strbnd vasui` `induidg.
]g egngjairags fg`t mindgr Zadns wgrg
ahpbrtint is at i`grts tlgh iebut tlgar
jla`mrgn‑s lgi`tl inm anfbrhs tlgh wlgn
tlgy hust ticg tlgar jla`m tb tlg lbspati`.
I driplaj as usgm tb slbw tlg drbwtl, wg
jin sgg (amgntafy) tlg wgadlt bf tlg eiey,
at as prgsgntgm an i driplaj fbrh. ]g
qugstabns prbvamgm irg usgfu` fbr ebtl tlg
pirgnt is wg`` is tlg hamwafg. At rghanms
tlg hamwafg bf wlit slbu`m eg tb`m tbtlg pirgnts, tlas jin wbrc is i prbjgss bf
jbunsg``and.‘
~ Lgi`tl wbrcgr, Anmbngsai
‐Gisy tb unmgrstinm egjiusg an immatabn
watl pajturgs tlg anfbrhitabn as jbhp`gtg.
Gvgn fbr inybng wlb jinnbt rgim, at as
ittrijtavg fbr hg tb rgim at.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
Dripl Nbn-@atgrijy ? ]g dripls irg
nbt unmgrstbbm ey hbst bf tlg pirgnts is
prgvi`gnt vasui` jbdnatabn as nbt strbnd
gnbudl tb antgrprgt tlas canm bf driplaji`anfbrhitabn. ]gy irg jbhfbrtie`g an rgimand
nuhegrs ritlgr tlin antgrprgtand i p`bttgm
dripl `ang. ]as satuitabn wis quatg bppbsatg
an Anmbngsai wlgrg pgbp`g wgrg bpgn tb
rgimand inm antgrprgtand dripl miti is tlgy
sgghgm tb unmgrstinm tlg anfbrhitabn.
Trattgn nuhegrs an i tieu`ir fbrhit sgghgm
`acg in inswgr tb tlg satuitabn wlajl jin
eg rgim watlbut iny antgrprgtitabn br
issastinjg. An Cgnyi tlg ijjurijy bf
tlg hircands mbng ey tlg nursg bn tlg
drbwtl jlirt wis i jiusg fbr jbnjgrn
ihbndst egngjairags. An Anmai is wg``,
hiny tahgs tlg lgadlt inm wgadlt miti
as ``gm an tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g
spijg atsg`f wlajl jrgitgs jbnfusabn.
‐Hiny tahgs tlg lgadlt inm wgadlt
miti as ``gm an tlg ahhunazitabn
sjlgmu`g spijg atsg`f is bppbsgm tb
ats davgn p`ijg wlajl jrgitgs `bt bf
jbnfusabn.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
‐Dripl jlirts irg lirm tb antgrprgt.
Af tlg wgadlts jbu`m eg anmajitgm an
wratand anstgim bf usand tlg dripls
at wa`` eg gisagr fbr pirgnts tb
unmgrstinm.‘
Mindgr Zadns - Ladl`y vi`ugm
Anfbrhitabn ? An Anmbngsai inm
Cgnyi vasui` rgprgsgntitabn bf
wirnand syheb`s wis unmgrstbbm
inm wg`` rgjgavgm. Anfbrhitabn iebut
wlit nbt tb mb, as jbnsamgrgm is egand
ahpbrtint. An Anmai, egngjairags
wg`jbhgm tlg amgi bf immand mindgr
sadns an tlg jirm egjiusg tlg prgsgnt
HJL jirm hassgs tlas anfbrhitabn.
Cgy anfbrhitabn sgjtabn? An Cgnyi
inm Anmbngsai usgrs `acgm tlg lgim
jarjuhfgrgnjg is bng bf tlg drbwtl
anmajitbrs, is ats trijcand jbu`m
rgvgi` spgjaj masgisgs. I`sb tlgy
tlbudlt tlit tlg drbwtl anfbrhitabn
wbu`m eg hbrg jbhp`gtg af tlas
sgjtabn wis immgm.
‐Lgim jarjuhfgrgnjg, `gndtl & wgadlt
irg sgpiritg`y hgisurgm lgnjg gisy tb
antgrprgt tlg pirihgtgrs.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐A `acg tlas egjiusg wg jin sgg eiey lgimjarjuhfgrgnjg tb jlgjc af tlg jla`m lis
lymrbjgpli`us br nbt.‘
~ Nursg, Anmbngsai
‐]g p`bttand as nbt gisy tb unmgrstinm.
Nursgs mbn‑t i`wiys hirc bn in
antgrsgjtabn br i `ang tlgy hiy hirc an i
squirg spijg. Qbu wbn‑t cnbw tlg gxijt
wgadlt br lgadlt frbh tlg p`bttand.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
]g [ajturg bf Lgi`tl, suehattgm ey rap B‑Mg``
inm Whegrtb Fusjb
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg =<
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 28/53
Lgi`tl wbrcgr jirm prgfgrgnjgs? ]g lgi`tl jirg
jbunsg``and anfb eba`s mbwn tb tlg fijt tlit tlg
lgi`tl wbrcgrs mb nbt livg tlg tahg tb gxp`ian
gvgrytland tb tlg egngjairags sb tlgy wbu`m wint
i hgjlinash tlit jbu`m sujg tlg nggm.
At jin eg mbng tlrbudl sg`f gxp`initbry vasui`s is
suddgstgm ey i fgw mgsadn gntrags. An Anmai, lgi`tl
wbrcgrs irg unie`g tb prbvamg mgtia`gm lgi`tl jirg
jbunsg``and is tlg ahhunazitabn prbjgss as `gndtly
inm tlgrg irg `irdg egngjairy jrbwms.
An Anmbngsai is wg`` tlg egngjairags tlanc tlit tlg
u`tahitg sburjg bf anfbrhitabn fbr lgi`tl jirg anfb
irg tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs, gvgn af tlgy jin rgim tlg
anfbrhitabn tlghsg`vgs tlgy `acg tb jrbss jlgjc tlg
sihg watl tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs.
]g Lgi`tl wbrcgrs prgfgrrgm jbnjasg anfbrhitabn
inm sg`f gxp`initbry vasui` `induidg. Bn tlg btlgr
linm, egngjairags prgfgrrgm jbhprglgnsavg,
gxp`initbry vasui`s sb gvgn an iesgnjg bf lgi`tl
wbrcgr tlgy jin dgt rg`gvint anfbrhitabn.
.‘At as (lis) dbbm anfbrhitabn tlit tlg
pirgnt slbu`m livg. At i`sb davgs ghgrdgnjy
trgithgnt tb tlg eiey wlgn i prbe`gh as
fijgm ey tlg pirgnts watlbut iny hgmaji`
lg`p irbunm tlgh.‘
~ Nursg, Anmbngsai
‐At prbvamgs ygs br nb qugstabns tb tlg
pirgnts an brmgr tb eg ie`g tb jlgjc tlg
drbwtl bf tlg eiey. At i`sb slbws tlg sji`g
inm drbwtl bf tlg eiey.‘
~ Nursg, Anmbngsai
=.5.= Ngw Miti Fag`ms ?
An tlg ngw miti g`m sgjtabn tlg jbnjgpts
tlit wgrg sg`gjtgm tb eg tgstgm bn tlg g`m
wgrg eisgm bn tlg prijtaji`aty inm tlg
bvgri`` ggjtavgngss bf tlg mgsadn. ]g
gntrags tlit himg tlg sg`gjtabn anj`umgm
jbnjgpts sujl is plbtbdripls bf tlg
jla`m tb mgpajt ats drbwtl inm prbdrgss,
jgrtajitg watl i p`gmdg fbr hbtlgrs,
unaqug lgi`tl anfbrhitabn sujl is i``grdagsbf tlg jla`m, in ghgrdgnjy lg`p`ang nuhegr
inm plbng nuhegrs bf `bji` lgi`tl jgntrgs
inm nursgs inm i fgw nbvg` ygt annbvitavg
jbnjgpts sujl is rbtitand mai`s wlajl jbu`m
wbrc is in ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g.
Ugspbnsgs tb ngw mgsadn prbpbsatabn?
I Ugjbrm fbr @afg? Lbwgvgr, tlg
jbnjgpts tlit ghgrdgm strbnd`y ijrbss
`bjitabns wgrg tlit bf tlg jla`m‑s
plbtbdripl inm tlg lg`p`ang nuhegrs
fbr hbtlgrs.
]g lgi`tl wbrcgrs fg`t tlit tlrbudl
tlg plbtbdripls tlg hbtlgrs wbu`meg ie`g tb sgg lbw wg`` tlgar jla`m lis
mgvg`bpgm inm an gssgnjg ansta`` i sgnsg
bf ijjbhp`aslhgnt an tlg pirgnts.
Immatabni``y, tlg egfbrg inm iftgr
nirritavg bf tlg jbnjgpt wbu`m lg`p
jbhhunajitg tlg egngts mgravgm frbh
tlg vijjanitabns. Zbhg pirgnts i`sb
I Ugjbrm fbr @afg, suehattgm ey Ihinmi Eujc, Zi``y
Hiagr, Jlgn Qu inm Nitg Du``gmdg bn egli`f bf Hiry`inm
Anstatutg Jb``gdg bf Irt
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 7;
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 29/53
fg`t tlit tlg jbnjgpt bf egfbrg inm iftgr wbu`m
hbtavitg tlgh inm hicg tlgh hbrg rgspbnsae`g
tbwirms jbhp`gtand tlg ahhunazitabn prbjgss inm
gvgntui``y `gim tb egttgr up cggpand bf tlg jirm.
‐A wa`` ngvgr fbrdgt tlas canm bf jirm egjiusg
bf tlg pajturgs is wg`` is tlg fijt tlit i`` tlg
mitgs bf tlg vijjangs irg jbhp`gtg. Tlgngvgr
tlg ahhunazitabn as jbhp`gtg, sb wg jin sgg
tlg lgi`tly jla`m plbtb, sb A wa`` cggp tlg jirm
is i hghbrie`g stu.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐]g plbtb jin eg pramg bf tlg hbtlgr fbr tlg
jla`m it i `itgr mitg.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
@avg ta`` 7? ]g sgjbnm hbst ipprgjaitgm jbnjgpt
wis tlit bf in ghgrdgnjy lg`p`ang nuhegr jbup`gm
up watl tlg plbng nuhegrs bf tlg lgi`tl jgntrg
inm tlg `bji` nursg. ]g pirgnts fg`t tlit tlg
plbng nuhegr wbu`m ijt is i eramdg egtwggn
tlg pirgnts inm tlg lgi`tl jgntrg. Hbrgbvgr, tlg
pirgnts stitgm tlit livand i jbntijt nuhegr it
tlgar maspbsi` wbu`m gnie`g tlgh tb rgijl but tb
tlg lgi`tl jgntrg br tlg `bji` nursg murand tahgs bf
ghgrdgnjy. ]g jbnjgpt bf in ghgrdgnjy lg`p`angnuhegr wis gspgjai``y ipprgjaitgm ey hbtlgrs
wlb fg`t tlit tlgy irg bvgr`y mgpgnmgnt bn tlg `bji`
nursgs fbr gvgn tlg hbst eisaj anfbrhitabn, inm
lgnjg livand i lg`p`ang nuhegr wbu`m hicg `afg
gisagr fbr tlgh.
‐Af plbng nuhegr bf tlg [LJ as tlgrg ,
tlgn wg jin ji`` up inm nm but mitgs fbr
vijjanitabn, nbw wg livg tb jbntijt inm
wiat fbr IZLI.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
‐]g plbng nuhegr as lg`pfu`. Oust an jisg
hy jla`mrgn livg in i``grdaj rgijtabn .‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
Immatabni` Anfbrhitabn? Furtlgrhbrg, tlg amgibf livand unaqug hgmaji` anfbrhitabn bf tlg jla`m
bn tlg jirm wis wg`` rgjgavgm ey pirgnts inm
lgi`tl wbrcgrs.
]g pirgnts fg`t tlit livand in immatabni` spijg
fbr vati` anfbrhitabn `acg i``grdags wbu`m nbt bn`y
hicg tlg lgi`tl anfbrhitabn bn tlg jirm hbrg
jbhprglgnsavg eut i`sb issast tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs
inm mbjtbrs tb imhanastgr tlg radlt canm bf
hgmajitabn tb tlgar jla`m.
I fgw hbtlgrs i`sb stitgm tlit hbrg bftgn
tlin nbt tlgy irg jbhp`gtg`y uniwirg iebut
tlg i``grdags bf tlgar jla`m inm lgnjg sujl
anfbrhitabn wbu`m eg rgi``y usgfu` fbr tlgh.
‐]grg slbu`m eg spijg fbr gxtri anfbrhitabn
`acg i``grdags gtj. ]as anfbrhitabn as
ahpbrtint.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
@avg ta`` 7, suehattgm ey
Mayi Mge
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 75
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 30/53
=.5.7 Hitgrai` inm fbrh inm jb`bur
Hitgrai`? In ahpbrtint assug irbunm tlg
hitgrai` bf tlg jurrgnt jirms wis maju`ty
an hiantgninjg mug tb frida`aty bf tlg jirm.
]g jirms wgrg sueogjt tb spba`idg ey rit
eatgs, ba` hircs, stians, witgr sp`islgs
gtj. Wsgrs gxprgssgm tlg nggm fbr p`istaj
jbitgm jirms br jirms watl shbbtl jbvgrgm
surfijgs wlajl wbu`m gnsurg muriea`aty,
prbtgjt anfbrhitabn an tlg jirm, lg`p an
gisy upcggp bf tlg rgjbrm inm prbtgjt frbh
iny plysaji` mihidg.
Fbrh? Fbrh as tlg rgprgsgntitabni` ispgjt
bf tlg jirm. At as tlg ni` plysaji` fbrhit
tlit eanms anfbrhitabn inm vasui`s an i
tijta`g fbrhit.
]g Ebbc`gt fbrh? Jrbss `bjitabni``y,
tlg ebbc`gt fbrhit jihg but is tlg
strbndgst plysaji` fbrh bf tlg jirm. At
wis ipprgjaitgm i`` usgr sgts is at wis
jbhpijt, hinidgie`g, pbrtie`g, linmy
inm usgr fragnm`y. An Anmai tlg fbrh bf i
ebbc gvbcgm rgspgjt mug tb tlg rgfgrgnjg
issbjaitgm watl gmujitabn. An Cgnyi inm
Anmbngsai, tlas jirm wis ladl`y vi`ugm mug
tb fiha`airaty bf tlg fbrhit is tlgar prgsgnt
jirms irg an i ebbc`gt fbrhit. At gpatbhasgm
i ladlgr stinmirm bf lgi`tljirg an Anmaiinm Anmbngsai is at wis issbjaitgm watl
lgi`tl jirg rgjbrms bf pravitg lbspati`s.
]g Ea-Fb`m fbrh? Hiny rgspbnmgnts
ijrbss i`` `bjitabns i`sb jlbsg shi``gr
jbhpijt sazgs bvgr ead sazgs lgnjg tlg
Ea-Fb`m jirm wis i hiobr prgfgrgnjg fbr
usgr sgts prahira`y fbr ats muriea`aty inm
gisg an hinidand.
‐I sand`g fb`m as tlg egst egjiusg at
hicgs tlg jirm jbhpijt inm gisy tb
usg, oust `acg i sahp`g tie`g hgnu.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
Jbhpijt strujturgs? An Anmai, fitlgrs
gxprgssgm jbhfbrt watl jirms wlajl
wgrg jbhpijt gnbudl tb t an tlgar
wi``gts. Wsgrs `acgm `gssgr nuhegr
bf fb`ms tb gnsurg tlg jirm as gisy tb
linm`g inm mbgs nbt tgir it tlg fb`ms.
Fbrhs inm strujturgs wlajl wgrg
p`iyfu` inm nbt sgrabus an niturg wgrg
nbt gnjburidgm. Fbrhs `acg egims,
huds, einms wgrg rgogjtgm ey tlg
pirgnts bn tlg prghasg tlit tlgy wbu`m
nbt eg ticgn sgrabus`y inm wbu`m eg
hasusgm ey jla`mrgn.
]g Ebbc`gt fbrh
Jbhpijt strujturg
]g EA-Fb`m fbrh
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 7=
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 31/53
Jb`bur? Bur FMDs `bbcgm it jb`brs an
twb ispgjts, is in igstlgtaj inm is i
funjtabn an tgrhs bf jbmand
Issbjaitabn, Ug`itabn inm
Amgntajitabn? Ijrbss i`` `bjitabns, tlg
sbjai` jbntgxt jihg but is i strbnd mravgr
fbr rgspbnmgnts an hicand jlbajgs br
suddgstabns iebut jb`br prgfgrgnjgs.
Lgi`tl wbrcgrs suddgstgm yg``bw inm
drggn fbr tlg gntarg jirm prahira`y
egjiusg tlgy irg eradlt inm wbu`m eg
vasui` `y hbrg ippgi`and inm gisy tb
mastanduasl frbh tlg rgst. ]g lgi`tl
wbrcgrs fg`t tlit drggn wis gisy tb
issbjaitg watl lgi`tl, is at as bftgn sggn
an tlg lbspati`s.
Drggn i`sb sadnags drbwtl inm niturg.
Bng bf anstinjg an Anmai wis wlgn i
lgi`tl wbrcgr‑s rgisbn fbr jlbbsand drggn
wis tlit prgdnint hbtlgrs irg bftgn
iscgm tb jbnsuhg drggn vgdgtie`gs an
tlgar magt, wlajl an turn rganfbrjgs tlg
jbnjgpt bf lgi`tl issbjaitgm watl tlg
jb`bur drggn.
An Anmbngsai i prgfgrgnjg tbwirms
drggn wis i`sb besgrvgm is tlg jb`bur as
ju`turi``y rg`gvint tb tlg jbntgxt. ]gy
wgrg i`sb bpgn tb usand btlgr eradlt
jb`burs fbr tlg purpbsg bf amgntajitabn
inm rghanmgr jrgitabn.
An Cgnyi, eradlt jb`brs irg hbst`y
issbjaitgm watl lgi`tl. Zanjg tlg jb`br bf
tlg gxastand vijjanitabn jirm as purp`g, at
as i`sb prgfgrrgm ey hiny lgi`tl wbrcgrs.
Tlatg jb`br watl rgm jrbss as i`sb
issbjaitgm watl lgi`tl. Hiny usgrs i`sb
`bbcgm it tlg igstlgtajs bf jb`bur an tgrhs
bf ats funjtabni`aty. ]gy gxprgssgm tlg
nggm fbr `adltgr jb`burs an tlg jirm‑s
eijcdrbunm sb tlit anfbrhitabn jbu`m eg
gisa`y wrattgn br rgim.
‐]g gxastand jb`br “purp`g‑ as dbbm.‘
~ Lgi`tl wbrcgr, Cgnyi
‐Eradlt jb`brs irg dbbm egjiusg
anfbrhitabn jin eg sggn it i d`injg.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
Qg``bw is i jirm jb`bur
Ugm is i jirm jb`bur Drggn is i jirm jb`bur
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 76
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 32/53
Funjtabni`aty bf jb`bur?
Jb`bur I`adngm watl ahg ? Nursgs
besgrvgm tlit hbtlgrs wbu`m nm at
gisy tb issbjaitg jb`burs watl tahg br
hbrg spgjaji``y plisgs bf i jla`m‑s
mgvg`bphgnt. Jb`bur jbmand tlg
prbdrgssand idg bf tlg jla`m i`adngm
watl tlg vijjanitabns bf tlit plisg,
wis prgfgrrgm bvgr issadnand jb`burs
tb vijjangs.
Hbtlgrs eg`agvgm tlgy wbu`m cnbw wlit
plisg bf tlg vijjanitabn jyj`g las/lgr
jla`m wis an eisas las idg jbu`m rgpbrt
tlg sihg tb nursgs, wlb jbu`m stap eijc
lgr rgdastgr tb tlit tahg-pgrabm watlbut
wistand tahg.
An Anmbngsai, jb`br jbmand an tlg jirm wis
vgry wg`` rgjgavgm ey usgrs is tlg jbuntry
usgs jb`bur jbmand systghs fbr magrgnt
purpbsgs. ]gy livg pue`aj trinspbrt
systgh jb`br jbmgm eisgm bn `bjitabns, sb
tlg jb`bur jbmand systgh as i`rgimy wg``
andriangm an tlgh ju`turi``y.
An Cgnyi, tlg nggm bf amgntafyand
anfbrhitabn it i d`injg wis i strbnd
mravgr tb prgfgr jb`br jbmand. An jirms
wlgrg jb`bur jbmand wis mbng ijjbrmand
tb vijjang, nursgs hgntabngm tlit stirc`y
jbntristand jb`burs slbu`m eg usgm ritlgr
tlin slimgs tlit jin eg jbnfusgm.
‐At (jb`bur jbmand is pgr
idg bf tlg jla`m) as gisy tb
rghghegr , egjiusg wg
tgnm tb rghghegr tlg idg bf
jla`m egttgr tlin tlg vijjang
davgn.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐Imoust jb`bur tb idg. T lgn
pirgnts jbhg tb tlg j`anaj
wlgn wg isc iebut tlg idg bf
tlg eiey tlgn wg wa`` cnbw at
as an tlas jb`bur einm .‘~ Nursg, Anmbngsai
Ug`itand vijjangs tb tahg
(idg) as dbbm egjiusg gvgn
a``atgritg pgbp`g jin gisa`y
unmgrstinm af gxp`iangm
ijjbrmand tb jb`bur.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
‐]g jirm slbws j`gir`y
wlajl vijjangs irg tb eg
davgn bvgr wlit pgrabm bf
tahg.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
‐At wbu`m eg gisagr fbr
hbtlgrs tb sgg tlg vijjangs
murand lgi`tl ti`cs .‘
~ Lgi`tl wbrcgr, Cgnyi
‐]g prbvamgr jin gisa`y
gxp`ian tlg jb`burs /
vijjangs.‘
~ Lgi`tl wbrcgr, Cgnyi
Jb`br i`adngm watl tahg
Jb`br i`adngm watl vijjanitabns
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 7<
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.
ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 33/53
]g rgjbrm as i pgrsbni` irtgfijt tlit
massghanitgs anfbrhitabn is wg`` is
ijts is i einc fbr jb``gjtand inm stbrand
anfbrhitabn bf tlg jla`m fbr tlg futurg.
]g pbtgntai` vi`ug bf tlg rgjbrm as hujl
hbrg vist tlin wlit at as ijtui``y usgm
fbr radlt nbw inm at jin eg lirngssgm
tlrbudl immatabn bf virabus miti g`ms.
]g anfbrhitabn mgsadn bf tlg rgjbrm as
in ispgjt wlajl lis tb eg linm`gm it twb
`gvg`s wlajl as tlrbudl unmgrstinmand
bf nggms inm tlg wiy pgbp`g ijjgss
tlg anfbrhitabn.
7.9.9. Wnhgt-Anfbrhitabn Nggms?
]g jurrgnt lgi`tl rgjbrm as nbt ie`g
tb immrgss i`` tlg nggms bf tlg
egngjairags. ]g egngjairags sggc
irriy bf immatabni` anfbrhitabn iebut
ahhunazitabns inm tlg prbjgss tlrbudl
tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs. ]g rgjbrm jin eg
gnlinjgm watl sg`f gxp`initbry miti sb
tlit tlg egngjairags wa`` egjbhg sg`frg`aint inm dgt ijjuritg anfbrhitabn.
An Anmai, wla`g hiny egngjairags
jbnsamgr tlg jirm tb eg nbt ahpbrtint,
tlg nursgs rg`y lgiva`y bn tlgar rgdastgrs
tb cggp i trijc bf ahhunazitabns.
]us hicand tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm is in
anfbrhitabn irtgfijt `bbsg ats pbtgntai` tb
7. Hgti Ini`ysas inm Mgsadn Ugjbhhgnmitabns
7.9. Anfbrhitabn Mgsadn
‐]grg slbu`m eg spijg fbr gxtri
anfbrhitabn `acg i``grdags gtj. ]as
anfbrhitabn as ahpbrtint.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
‐Tlit as an at fbr us2 Tg mb nbt
unmgrstinm tlg virabus sgjtabns bf tlg
jirm.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmai
rg`iy anfbrhitabn an i rgspbnsavg hinngr.
@bw `atgrijy `gvg`s3 Ladl mgpgnmgnjy
bn vgrei` anfbrhitabn inm rghanmgrs
(IZLIs)3 @bw lgi`tl jirg iwirgngss3
Hastrust bn pue`aj lgi`tl systgh i`sb
jbntraeutg tb `bw vi`ug bf tlg jirm.
]g rgjbrm slbu`m immrgss tlg nggm bf
tlg egngjairags wlb irg `bbcand fbr
immatabni` anfbrhitabn g`ms sujl is
mindgr sadn, hassgm vijjanitabns, i``grdy
anfbrhitabn gtj. Zujl anfbrhitabn wa``
hicg tlg pirgnts rg`y bn tlg rgjbrm fbr
hbrg g`iebritg anfbrhitabn.
]g rgjbrm slbu`m i`sb i``bw fbr
`bji`asitabn. I mgmajitgm spijg slbu`m eg
i``bttgm an tlg rgjbrm tb immgm iny canm
bf anfbrhitabn wlajl tlg pirgnts tlanc as
ahpbrtint tb anfbrh tlgh bf tlg lgi`tl bf
tlgar jla`m. Fbr gxihp`g tlgrg slbu`m eg
i spijg fbr hassgm vijjang br wratand iny
canm bf gxtri anfbrhitabn an tlg rgjbrm
tb anjbrpbritg i sgnsg bf eg`bndand inm
rgspbnsaea`aty tbwirms tlg rgjbrm.
]g jurrgnt jirm lis nb spijg fbr
immatabni` anfbrhitabn. ]g hbtlgrs
irg bftgn uniwirg bf i``grdags br btlgr
vijjanitabns tlit i jla`m nggms.
Livand in immatabni` spijg fbr vati`
anfbrhitabn `acg i``grdags inm plbng
nuhegrs davgs hbtlgrs i rgfgrgnjg pbant
inm i`sb mbgs nbt imm jbnfusabn tb tlg
gxastand miti.
Zbhg canm bf ngditavg rganfbrjghgnt
wbu`m i`sb lg`p an dgttand tlg pirgnts
ticg jbnsamgritabn tb tlg fijt tlit tlgrg
jin eg eim ggjts tb tlg jla`m‑s lgi`tl af
tlgy irg nbt davgn vijjanitabns bn tahg.
Is besgrvgm bn g`m pirgnts wint i
hgisurg bf tlg lgadlt inm wgadlt bf tlg
jla`m tb cggp i trijc bf tlg jla`m‑s lgi`tl.
]g pirgnts wbu`m wint in anmajitbr
bf stinmirm drbwtl jurvg inm jbhpirg
at watl tlg ijtui` drbwtl bf tlgar bwn
jla`m. ]as hgjlinash wbu`m hicg tlgh
sg`f mgpgnmgnt an hbnatbrand tlg drbwtl
bf tlgar jla`m.
]g rgjbrm slbu`m i`sb livg tlg pbtgntai`
tb inswgr magrgnt qugstabns watl
rgspgjt tb tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g.
Immrgssand qugstabns rgdirmand tlg
virabus vijjan itabns, tlgar mgtia` s inm
tlgar egngts. Tlit as egand davgn2 Tlit
as at prbtgjtand frbh2 Tlit as tlg vijjang
fu`` fbrh inm tlg samg ggjts2
Tatl rgspgjt tb tlg ahhunazitabnsjlgmu`g, jrataji` irgis bf anfbrhitabn an
tlg rgjbrm slbu`m i`sb eg `ancgm, tlgsg
anj`umg mug mitg, anfbrhitabn bn vijjang
inm lgadlt/wgadlt bf tlg jla`m. ]grg
jbu`m eg i wiy tb inswgr tlg qugrags
pirgnts hadlt livg wlajl ticgs jirg
bf tlg ghgrdgnjy nggms is an wlgn tlg
jla`m fi``s sajc inm tlg tlgy wbu`m nggm
duaminjg an ticand jirg bf tlg jla`m.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 6;
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 34/53
7.9.5. Ju`turgs? Jb``bquai` @induidg, Hgmai
inm Fbrhit
Ju`turgs, Hgmai inm Fbrhit? Magrgnt
ju`turgs livg magrgnt wiys an wlajl tlgy
jbhhunajitg, jbhprglgnm, rgdastgr br gvgn
trust anfbrhitabn. ]as hiyeg mgpgnmgnt
bn wlb as davand tlgh anfbrhitabn (sburjg),
wlit hgmai inm fbrhit as at egand jbhhu-
najitgm at (fijg tb fijg, hbea`g, iumab, tgxt,
vasui` inm sb bn), wlit as tlg hinngr br tbng
bf jbhhunajitabn (anstrujtabni`, pbsatavg
hbtavitabni`, rgvgrsg psyjlb`bdy inm sb bn)
inm tlg tgjlnaqugs usgm tb rganfbrjg tlit
sihg anfbrhitabn. Tg irg hbst `acg`y tb
ahprbvg anfbrhitabn stbw inm miti hin-
idghgnt af wg `gvgridg bn tlg cnbw`gmdg
bf tlgsg `bji` ju`turgs bf anfbrhitabn inm
jbhhunajitabn inm ijjbunt fbr tlgh wla`g
mgsadnand i ngw systgh. Fbr anstinjg, tlg
eg`bw a``uhanitgs ?
Amgntafyand tlg jla`m
]g nursg wbu`m
gnquarg iebut tlg
nihg bf tlg jla`m.
]g hbtlgr wa`` rghghegr
tlg eartl brmgr bf tlg jla`m
a.g. wlgtlgr tlg jla`m as lgr
9st ebrn, 5nm ebrn, :rm ebrn
Amgntafyand tlg `ist vijjanitabn davgn
]g nursg wbu`m
gnquarg iebut tlgnihg bf tlg `ist
vijjanitabn davgn.
Lbwgvgr tlg hbtlgr wbu`m
bn`y rghghegr tlg satgbn tlg ebmy wlgrg tlg
vijjanitabn lim eggn davgn.
Amgntafyand wlgrg
tlg jla`m as an tlg
ahhunazitabn jyj`g
]g nursg wbu`m
gnquarg iebut tlg
nihg bf tlg `ist
vijjanitabn davgn.
Lbwgvgr, tlg hbtlgr wbu`m
rghghegr tlg nuhegr bf
vasats tlg hbtlgr lis himg.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 65
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 35/53
Hgmai inm Fbrhits - Mgpgnmgnj y bn
vgrei` v/s wrattgn anfbrhitabn? Ju`turgs,
Hgmai inm Fbrhit? Jurrgnt`y tlg anfbrhi-
tabn massghanitabn fbr tlg jirm as frid-
hgntgm egtwggn anfbrhitabn wrattgn ey
Lgi`tl jirg wbrcgrs spgjaji``y Nursgs inm
vgrei` anfbrhitabn fbr lgi`tl jirg anfbrhi-
tabn egand davgn IZLIs. Egngjairags livg
nb rb`g bf miti gndidghgnt watl rgspgjt tb
tlg jirm fbr wrattgn anfbrhitabn wlajl `ancs
eijc tb tlg jli``gndg bf usgr jbnngjt inm
gndidghgnt inm anj`usabn bf i justbhazgm
spijg fbr usgrs tb wratg an tlg jirm. Lgnjg,
vgrei` anfbrhitabn, (wlajl as i pbbr sburjg
fbr iutlgntajitabn inm rgjb``gjtabn bf miti)
egjbhgs i prahiry sburjg bf anfbrhitabn
rg`ainjg fbr tlgh.
@bw `atgrijy `gvg`s davg rasg tb prbe`ghs
rgvb`vand irbunm unmgrstinmand anfbrhitabn
an jurrgnt prant eisgm fbrhits.
Fag`ms ansadlts slbw i jrujai` nggm fbr
ivia`iea`aty bf viragm hgmai inm fbrhits fbr
i ladlgr mgdrgg bf usgr anvb`vghgnt, j`iraty
inm miti rganfbrjghgnt.
Tg irg `acg`y tb immrgss tlas assug watl jirms
mgsadngm tb eramdg tlas dip ey suppbrtand
wrattgn miti tlrbudl iumab hgssidgs is i
rghanmgr bf tlg anfbrhitabn davgn ey nursgbr vasui`s bn wi``s br p`ijgs tlit frgqugnt`y
anlieatgm ey tlg usgrs.
I`sb massghanitabn bf anfbrhitabn frbh
i pgbp`g bf ahpbrtinjg `acg mbjtbrs,
ahpbrtint durgs anvb`vgm an tlg lgi`tl
jirg inm pb`ajy hicand prbjgss br `bbcand
it i egttgr p`itfbrh fbr jrgitand i jatazgn
gndidghgnt fbruh.
Mgspatg viryand ansadlts irbunm
tgjlnb`bdy, bur suddgstabn as tlit at
jin eg uta`asgm is in imvintidgbus
hgmauh af `ancgm tb tlg jbntgxt bf
ju`turg. Ju`turg inm tgjlnb`bdy db
linm an linm irg mgtgrhanint bf gijl
btlgr‑s gxastgnjg. ]g hbst vaie`g wiy
bf tgjlnb`bdy egand jbnsamgrgm is i
ngw hgmauh tb eg antgdritgm watl tlg
ju`turi` jbntgxt bf tlg `bjitabn.
7.9.:. Jbntgxt an wlajl anfbrhitabn as rgim
]g ha`agu bf tlg rgjbrm jlindgs gvgry
tahg tlg usgrs gndidg watl tlg rgjbrm. ]g
magrgnt usgr inm magrgnt antgrijtabn
sjgnirab `gims tb jrgitabn bf mavgrsg
satuitabns wlajl jin eg `gvgridgm tb jrgitg
jbntgxt. ]g rgjbrm is in anfbrhitabn
irtafijt lis jgrtian mriweijcs wlajl irg
jiusgm ey ijjgssand bf miti it magrgnt
tahgs inm jbntgxts. ]g rg`gvinjg bf tlg
anfbrhitabn cggps jlindand is tlg rgjbrmgm
anfbrhitabn egjbhgs b`m inm arrg`gvint
iftgr i pgrabm bf tahg. I`sb tlg stitaj
anfbrhitabn prbvamgm an tlg rgjbrm
lis i tahg ebunm sadnajinjg fbr
tlg usgrs inm tlas issbjaitabn bf usgr
anfbrhitabn bvgr mug jbursg bf tahg
egjbhgs rgmunmint, `gimand tb viragm
`gvg`s bf gndidghgnt egtwggn tlg usgr,
anfbrhitabn prbvamgm inm tlg rgjbrm is
i wlb`g.
Fbr anjrgisand tlg gjagnjy bf tlg
anfbrhitabn inm tlg rgjbrm at as
gssgntai` tb ergic mbwn tlg nggms
inm tlg antgrijtabns. At jin ticg p`ijg
watl rgdirm tb tlg usgrs. Zp`attand tlg
rgjbrm antb twb sgjtabns as in ipprbijl
wlajl jin lg`p us ijlagvg tlg nggmfu`.
Tatl tlg rst pirt bf tlg rgjbrm egand
andriangm an sbhgtland tlit tlg
egngjairags usg gvgry miy inm jin eg
pirt bf tlgar mia`y `afg an i nbn-antrusavg
wiy. ]as pbrtabn bf tlg jirm jin wbrc
is i rghanmgr hgjlinash wlajl jin eg
rgim ey usgrs wla`g mband tlgar mia`y
ijtavatags. ]g irtafijt jin livg tlg
iea`aty tb hgrdg antb gvgrymiy beogjts
inm bn`y dgt nbtajgm eijc wlgn gvgr
nggmgm. Mia`y antgrijtabns watl tlg
irtafijt jin rganstitg tlg hgssidg an i
hbrg irhitavg wiy. I`sb pirtaju`ir
antgrijtabns jin lg`p eua`m i rghanmgrhgjlinash fbr tlg sihg.
]g rghanmgr hgjlinash jin eg
trins`itgm antb i mug mitg ji`gnmir
br i wi`` j`bjc wlajl jin tg`` tlg
egngjairags iebut tlg ngxt mitg bf
vijjanitabn br tlg wiys wlajl jin
mgsjraeg lbw tlgy jin ticg jirg bf
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 6=
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 36/53
tlg jla`m. At jin i`sb eua`m bn ghgrdgnjy
jisgs wlajl jin eg `gvgridgm is i lg`p
hgjlinash it tlg tahg bf jrasas.
]g btlgr pbrtabn bf tlg rgjbrm jin
jirry ahpbrtint anfbrhitabn iebut
tlg ahhunazitabns tlit irg gntgrgm ey
tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs. ]as as gssgntai` an
hiantianand tlg hgmaji` lastbry bf tlg
jla`m wlajl jin eg ijjgssgm wlgngvgr tlg
nggm as pirihbunt. At jin eg cgpt iwiy
watl jirg inm ijjgssgm bn tlg ngxt mug
mitg bf tlg ahhunazitabn. ]as sgdhgnt bf
tlg rgjbrm wbu`m prbvamg anfbrhitabn tb
eg rgim it i d`injg inm wbu`m nbt anvb`vg`bndgr gndidghgnt.
Tg suddgst tlit imbptand tlas hgtlbm bf
sgpiritabn bf tlg rgjbrm antb pbrtabns bf
ipp`ajitabn anj`anitabn jin mriw egngjai`
butjbhgs is tlgy sujg tlg rgquarghgnts
bf tlg magrgnt usgrs.
7.9.=. Ugprgsgntitabn inm Vasui` Jbdnatabn
Vasui` jbdnatabn as i vati` ispgjt bf
miti inm pajturg antgr rg`itabn inm ats
antgrprgtitabn an tlg jirm. At mgpgnms
bn jlindand rgprgsgntitabns bf vasui`
anfbrhitabn a.g. slipgs, fbrh, jb`br, sty`g,
a``ustritabns gtj.
Jurrgnt`y tlg lgi`tl jirms ghp`by i ritlgr
fridhgntgm inm rgstrajtavg ipprbijl tb
miti vasui`asitabn wlajl as pgrjgavgm tb
eg jbnfusand inm nbn anfbrhitavg tb tlg
gatlgr usgr sgts.
Vasui` `atgrijy - Wnmgrstinmand tie`gs
v/s Dripls v/s Nuhegrs? @bbcand it
tlg mavgrsaty an tlg usgr mghbdriplaj, i
strbnd prbe`gh amgntagm bn g`m wis
rgimand inm jbhprglgnsabn bf dripls
fbr drbwtl jlirts. Jgrtian ansadlts
rgvgi`gm nursgs tb eg jbhfbrtie`g watl
dripls wla`g tlg btlgrs prgfgrrgm gatlgr
i nuhegr eisgm prbdrgssabn br i tieu`ir
fbrhit.
Irgis watl vgry `bw vasui` `atgrijy
prgfgrrgm miti an tie`gs is bppbsgm tb
dripls br nuhegrs is jrbss rgfgrgnjand
wis i jbhp`ajitabn.
‐Nbt i`` pirgnts jin unmgrstinm lbw
tb antgrprgt tlg dripl. Trattgn an
ca`bs wa`` eg gisagr tb antgrprgt… af hy
jla`m‑s wgadlt lis anjrgisgm frbh 6.7
tb 4 CDZ, A wa`` cnbw tlit lg as bn tlg
radlt trijc.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
Iestrijtabn v/s rgi`ash - A``ustritabns
br ajbnbdriply? Iny eirg ebng vasui`s,
ajbnbdriply, `ang-mriwands, iestrijtabn
br sahp`ajitabn bf vasui` ahidgry wis
nbt unmgrstbbm. ]as idian `ancs eijc tb
usgrs nbt prgfgrrand miti an dripls, is
driplaji` vasui`azitabn as i vgry iestrijt
fbrhit bf vasui` rgprgsgntitabn.
‐Zihg rgm jb`bur fbr fbbm inm witgr,
mbgs nbt wbrc, tlas as nbt rgi`astaj.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 66
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 37/53
Jrbss `bjitabni` ansadlts slbwjisgm i ladl
mgdrgg bf prgfgrgnjg fbr mgtia` inm rgi`ash
an a``ustritabn sty`gs. I rgi`astaj ipprbijl
tb vasui` ahidgry wis hbrg vi`uie`g inm
wg`` rgjgavgm ey i`` usgrs. ]as i`sb prbvgm
tb eg egngjai` fbr usgrs watl `bw `atgrijy
`gvg`s br p`ijgs wlgrg vgrei` anfbrhitabn
as prahiry is rganfbrjghgnt bf anfbrhitabn
tlrbudl stgp ey stgp atgritabns hicgs
unmgrstinmand egttgr inm sahp`gr.
‐Gvgn fbr inybng wlb jinnbt rgim, at
as ittrijtavg fbr hg tb rgim at.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐Af tlgy hass iny anfbrhitabn ‚ tlgy
wa`` sgg tlg vasui`s inm rghghegr at.
At wa`` rgdastgr idian inm idian.‘
Bur ini`ysas suddgsts i rgi`astaj ygt sahp`g
ipprbijl tb miti br vasui` rgprgsgntitabn.
Vasui` sty`gs bf i rg`itie`g niturg watl
luhin fbrhs inm mia`y beogjts mriwn is
tlg usgrs ijtui``y sgg an tlgar gvgrymiy `avgs
wbu`m eg hbst vi`ugm inm unmgrstbbm.
7.9.7. F`bw inm Zgqugnjand?
F`bw inm sgqugntai`aty irg ahpbrtint
mravand fijtbrs fbr ladlgr rgimiea`aty
inm rgji`` bf anfbrhitabn is anfbrhitabn
p`ijghgnt br sgqugnjand an tlg jirm lis
i margjt rg`itabn watl wlgtlgr at wa`` eg
nbtajgm, rgim, inm rgpgitgm`y rganfbrjgm
ey egngjairags br nbt. ]g ahhunazitabn
tie`g as tlg hbst ahpbrtint anfbrhitabn
pagjg an tlg mgsadn bf tlg rgjbrm inm
ats p`ijghgnt wa`` mgng tlg wiy pgbp`g
nivaditg. Zb at‑s p`ijghgnt as sadnajint
tb tlg anticg bf anfbrhitabn tlit
pgbp`g jin livg wla`g dband tlrbudl
tlg rgjbrms
Tlgrg stbw bf anfbrhitabn `bbcs it i
`bdaji` i stgp ey stgp miti sgdrgditabn
hgtlbm, fijtbrand bn tlg tahg frihg
tlit tlg usgrs dgt tb antgrijt watl tlg
jirm an, sgqugnjand `bbcs it i hbrg
fbjussgm ipprbijl bf miti jluncand bf
bn`y tlbsg jrataji` anfbrhitabn g`ms
wlajl irg hbst rg`itavg tb tlg usgrs.
Mgspatg egand sgpiritg gntatags an
tlghsg`vgs, ebtl nggm tb eg strbnd`y
`ancgm watl gijl btlgr tb lg`p immrgss
tlg prbe`gh bf rgspbnmgnts nbt rgimand
tlg gntarg jirm inm nbt egand ie`g tb
hicg `ancs egtwggn tlg anfbrhitabn an
virabus sgjtabns.
Tlgrg as tlg mug mitg2? Ansadlts frbh
tlg g`m ini`ysas rgvgi`gm nursgs inm
egngjairags livand jbntristand vagws
bn wlgrg tlg ngxt mug-mitg slbu`m eg
p`ijgm an tlg jirm mug tb magrgnjg an
tlgar rg`itabn watl tlas anfbrhitabn.
Frbh tlg nursgs‑ pgrspgjtavg wis tlgar
prgfgrgnjg bf tlg mitg tb eg p`ijgm
an tinmgh watl tlg ahhunazitabn
sjlgmu`g fbr twb rgisbns - ]gy
wbu`m eg ie`g tb ji`ju`itg tlg mug
mitg watl gisg sggand tlg `ist mitg bf
ahhunazitabn davgn, at wbu`m eg tlg
`ist tland tlit tlgy sgg wla`g ``and
tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g inm
tlgrgfbrg tlgy wbu`m nbt fbrdgt at inm
sgjbnm`y, tlgy fg`t tlit tlg mug mitg
egand hgntabngm inywlgrg egfbrg tlg
ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g wbu`m massuimg
hbtlgrs frbh dband tlrbudl tlg gntarg
jirm. Vasaea`aty inm rgjb``gjtabn bf tlg
ngxt mug mitg inm ats stritgdaj p`ijghgnt
an tlg jirm btlgr tlin tlg ahhunazitabn
sjlgmu`g wis fbunm tb eg hbrg lg`pfu`
fbr egngjairags.
[rbhangnjy bf tlg anfbrhitabn tlit as
sbudlt ey tlg egngjairy, `acg tlg ngxt
vasat miti, jin lg`p an rgan stitand tlg
ahpbrtinjg tb eg issbjaitgm watl tlg
lgi`tl rgjbrm. Tg irg `acg`y tb jrgitg i
hbrg gjagnt systgh watl bf “ngxt-mug
mitg‑ rganfbrjghgnt af wg jin sujjgssfu``y
rgjbnja`g tlg nggms bf tlgsg twb usgr
sgts a.g. Nursgs inm egngjairags tlrbudl
egttgr mgsadn. Fbr anstinjg, i jirm watl i
sgpiritg sgjtabn j`gir`y hircand tlg ngxt
mug mitg an tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g
i`bnd watl ats rganfbrjghgnt is i stajcgr br
i e`ure prgfgrie`y tbwirms tlg gnm bf tlg
jirm wbu`m immrgss ebtl anfbrhitabn stbw
inm sgqugnjand watlbut jbhprbhasand bn
tlg ijjgss inm gisg bf miti rgimand, ``andbr jbhprglgnsabn.
‐rianand tlg hbtlgrs bn oust sggand
tlg rst pidg fbr tlg mug mitg, hiy
gnjburidg tlg hbtlgrs nbt tb db
tlrbudl tlg nbtgs an tlg ebbc.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 6<
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 38/53
Jbntanuaty bf Miti? Jbntanuaty bf
miti as in ahpbrtint mravgr fbr stbw inm
sgqugnjand bf anfbrhitabn fbr rgimand
inm jbnngjtand virabus sgjtabns bf
anfbrhitabn an tlg jirm ey tlg usgrs,
prahira`y egngjairags. ]g g`m ansadlts
slbwgm tlit `ancand tlg idg bf tlg jla`m
inm lgi`tl jirg anfbrhitabn i`bnd watl
tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g strgndtlgns
tlg amgi bf drbwtl inm prbdrgss gsp.
ihbndst tlg egngjairags.
At as bur lypbtlgsas tlit ergicand tlg jirm
antb sgpiritg sgjtabns fbr ahhunazitabn
sjlgmu`g, drbwtl jlirts inm lgi`tl jirg
anfbrhitabn watl i saha`ir tahg`ang tgnms
tb scgw tlg amgi bf lgi`tl jirg an tlg
egngjairags‑ hanms.
At wbu`m egst sgrvg tlg jirm af tlg
ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g wis `ancgm
tb btlgr jrataji` anfbrhitabn g`ms
`acg anfbrhitabn bn tlg vijjanitabn,
ats ahpbrtinjg inm prbtgjtabn vi`ug3
tlg lgadlt/wgadlt bf tlg jla`m watl
prbdrgssand idg inm ahpbrtint lgi`tl
jirg anfbrhitabn tlit jbrrgspbnms watl
gijl plisg an tlg vijjanitabn sjlgmu`g.
An tlas wiy tlg hgtiplbr tlit tlg jirm
usgs fbr jbrrg`itand lgi`tl inm prbdrgss bftlg jla`m watl rbutang ahhunazitabns inm
ipprbpraitg lgi`tl jirg as strbndgr an tlg
hanms bf tlg egngjairags.
‐Drbwtl hbnatbrand jlirt slbu`m eg
put ngxt tb ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g
fbr gisg bf jbntanuaty bf tlg pirgnt
tb cggp bn erandand tlg jla`m tb tlg
j`anaj.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
7.9.6. Magrgnt Wsgrs, Magrgnt Anfbrhitabn Nggms, Magrgnt
Gxpgjtitabns
]g jirm lis i jrataji` rb`g tb
p`iy an ahprbvand antgrijtabn inm
anfbrhitabn stbw egtwggn tlg lgi`tl
prbvamgrs inm egngjairags. ]as
antgrijtabn as mgpgnmgnt bn tlg
fijt tlit tlg rgjbrm as ijjgssgm it
magrgnt pgrabms bf tahg ey magrgnt
pgbp`g egand tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs br
tlg egngjairags.
Magrgnt Wsgrs? ]grg irg prahiry,
sgjbnmiry inm tgrtairy usgrs anvb`vgm
an tlg antgrijtabns watl tlg rgjbrm.
]g prahiry egand tlg egngjairags
wlb gndidg watl tlg rgjbrm tlg hbst
inm uta`azg jrataji` anfbrhitabn frbh
at. ]g sgjbnmiry egand tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgrs wlajl irg tlg nursgs inm tlg
hbea`azgrs wlb `` tlg jirm, antgrprgt
tlg anfbrhitabn inm massghanitg at tb
tlg egngjairags anvb`vgm. ]g tgrtairy
irg tlg pgbp`g tlit ijjgss tlg jirm
hbhgntira`y fbr gxihp`g tgijlgrs,
rg`itavgs gtj.
]g nggm bf tlg gijl usgr as vgry
magrgnt inm tlg jirm lis tb eg ininswgr tb hbst bf tlg qugstabns
anvb`vgm. Nursgs fgg` tlit tlg
anfbrhitabn an tlg rgjbrm hust gjlb
wlit tlgy tg`` hbtlgrs, tlas wa``
gnie`g egttgr rgji`` inm ahprbvg tlg
`gvg` bf trust hbtlgrs livg bn tlg
nursgs inm tlg anfbrhitabn atsg`f.
]g magrgnjg bf ngjgssatags as i`sb
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 4;
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 39/53
ladl`adltgm an tlg jbuntrags bf tlg FDM.
Lgi`tl wbrcgrs an Anmbngsai fg`t jirms
slbu`m livg sg`f gxp`initbry anfbrhitabn,
nbt ‐tbb hujl anfbrhitabn‘ wlajl hiy
gnjburidg i `bt bf qugstabns frbh pirgnts.
An Cgnyi inm Anmai, Nursgs fg`t tlgrg wis i
nggm fbr tlg jirm tb eg i rgfgrgnjg tb gnie`g
tlgh tb mb egttgr lgi`tl jirg jbunsg``and.
Tlb wratgs bn tlg jirm2? ]g ijt bf
wratand bn tlg jirm as i`wiys `ahatgm tb tlg
lgi`tl wbrcgrs davand tlg ahhunazitabn.
]as antgrijtabn as rg`gvint tb tlg
egngjairags is wg``, af tlgy wbu`m wint
tb dgngritg sbhg anfbrhitabn br usg tlg
rgjbrm is i rghanmgr hgjlinash fbr
tlghsg`vgs. Eut tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs pgrjgavg
at is i tlrgit tb tlg rgjbrm is tlgy tlanc at
jin lihpgr tlg anfbrhitabn.
Ugimand tlg Anfbrhitabn? Nursgs
wbu`m `acg tb eg ie`g tb trijc tlg jla`m‑s
ahhunazitabn stitus inm hassgm
bppbrtunatags, inm tlg drbwtl triogjtbry
it i d`injg, gndidand an quajc ``and bf tlg
anfbrhitabn an tlg rgjbrm. Hbtlgrs wbu`m
`acg anfbrhitabn bn ngxt mug mitg, wlit tlg
vijjanitabn prbtgjts idi anst, mgtia `gm jla`m
rgirand, drbwtl inm mindgr sadns inm rb`g
bf tlg fitlgr sb at anvb`vgs rgimand it gisg.
bb Hujl Anfbrhitabn? ]g egngjairags
`bbc fbr sg`f gxp`initbry vasui`s, watl
mgtia`gm anfbrhitabn sb tlit tlgy jin
antgrprgt tlg anfbrhitabn tlghsg`vgs.
Nursgs tlanc tlas wa`` gnjburidg hbrg
qugstabns wlajl tlgy wbu`m `acg tb ivbam
an vagw bf `ahatgm tahg it linm. I`sb tlg
egngjairags pgrjgavg drbwtl is anjrgisg an
wgadlt inm tlgrgfbrg oust `bbc fbr tlit
pagjg bf anfbrhitabn prbdrgssand bvgr
hbntls, nursgs jlirt lgadlt, wgadlt inm
lgim jarjuhfgrgnjg.
7.9.4. [lysaji` Fbrh
]g plysaji` fbrh bf tlg rgjbrm slbu`m livg
tlg qui`aty bf egand funjtabni` unmgr murgss.
]grg as i prgfgrgnjg sggn tbwirms fiha`air
inm gxastand fbrhs bf tlg rgjbrms is tlg fbrh
sg`gjtgm nggms tb jbnvgy sgrabusngss, bwngrslap
inm stitg rgjbdnatabn fbr gxihp`g i ea-fb`m br
i ebbc`gt fbrh as prgfgrrgm ey hbst pgbp`g.
]as eglivabur slbws tlit tlg egngjairags
irg `bbcand fbr tlg qui`aty bf tlg rgjbrm egand
jbhpijt watl `gss nuhegr bf fb`ms wlajl i`sb
immrgssgs tlg jbst ggjtavgngss ispgjt.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 45
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 40/53
7.5. Ahprbvgm Antgrijtabn inm Gndidghgnt
Gndidghgnt watl tlg rgjbrm jin eg gnlinjgm
tlrbudl anjrgisand inm andrianand tlg
antgrijtabns watl tlg jirm. ]g sihg jin eg mbng
tlrbudl virabus hgtlbms ghp`bygm watlan tlg
systgh inm tlg mgsadn bf tlg rgjbrm atsg`f.
7.5.9 Anjrgisgm Vi`amitabn, Ijjbuntiea`aty,
Jbhhathgnt? I jli``gndg tlit tlg lgi`tl jirms
irg jurrgnt`y fijand as vi`amitabn inm ijjbunt-
iea`aty bf miti. Bur g`m rgsgirjl slbws tlit tlg
bng bf tlg prahiry fia`urgs bf tlg jirm as tlg egn-
gjairags‑ `ijc bf hbtavitabn/ansparitabn tb rgtian
br rgfgr tb tlg jirm is tlgy irg nbt ie`g tb gatlgr
rg`itg tb br mgpgnm bn tlg jirm ghbtabni``y br
funjtabni``y. Uganfbrjghgnt bf miti frbh ladlgr
iutlbratags gsp. fbr egngjairags as inbtlgr fijtbr
tlit tlg jirm fia`s tb ijjbhp`asl.
Lgi`tl wbrcgrs fijand miti fumdand/
hinapu`itabn, trijcand hassgm vijjanitabns inm
vi`amitand tlg sihg watl egngjairags irg irgis
wlajl livg ygt tb eg immrgssgm an tlg jirm wlajl
i`sb `gims tb ergicmbwns an tlg jirm wbrcand is
systgh ritlgr tlin oust in irtgfijt.
Zpgjaji``y an Anmai, hadritabn bf hbtlgrs tb
mg`avgr tlgar eieags an tlgar nitavg va``idg rgsu`ts
an jrgitand jbhp`ajitabns fbr hbtlgrs an cggpand
i trijc bf tlg jla`m‑s lgi`tl triogjtbry watlrgspgjt tb tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs anvb`vgm an las/lgr
ahhunazitabn jyj`g.
Ansadlts rgvgi`gm tlg nggm bf tlg Lgi`tl wbrcgrs
sadnand inm `` tlgar nihgs an tlg ahhunazitabn
sjlgmu`g wlajl lg`m tlgh ijjbuntie`g ey
hbtlgrs an jisg bf mbuets inm qugstabns br
sbhgtland dband wrbnd.
‐Hbtlgrs jin eg trajcy
sbhgtahgs, af tlgy irg `itg
fbr tlgar fija`aty vasat tlgy jin
jlindg mitgs br gvgn hirc i
vijjanitabn is davgn.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐Af hbtlgr wints tb i`tgr ‚at
wbn‑t eg pbssae`g is tlg nbtgsinm sadniturg (wrattgn ey tlg
lgi`tl wbrcgr) irg tlgrg .‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
Bur lypbtlgsas as tlit watlbut
rganfbrjghgnt bf vi`amitabn br
ijjbuntiea`aty fbr gatlgr usgr
sgts, hbtavitabn br jbhhathgnt
tb nbt oust prgsgrvg tlg jirm eut
tbwirms jbhp`gtabn bf i rbutang
ahhunazitabn jyj`g as i jli``gndg.
Jirms watl sadniturgs, stihps
inm stajcgrs bf tlg nursg davand
i pirtaju`ir vijjanitabn irg
hbrg `acg`y tb immrgss assugs
irbunm gnsurand vi`amitabn br
ijjbuntiea`aty. At i`sb tijc`gs
tlg jli``gndg bf anfbrhitabn
egand vi`amitgm frbh i ladlgr
iutlbraty fbr tlg egngjairags.
Jirms watl p`gmdgs, plbtbdripls
br anfbrhitabn bn vijjang
egngts irg `acg`y tb dgngritg hbrg
jbhhathgnt, i sgnsg bf ijjbhp`aslhgnt
inm hbtavitabn fbr prgsgrvitabn fbr
egngjairags inm ijt is i strbnd mravgr fbr
tlgh tb unmgrstinm tlgar rgspbnsaea`aty
tbwirms rbutang ahhunazitabns.
‐Af hbtlgr wints tb i`tgr ‚at
wbn‑t eg pbssae`g is tlg nbtgs inm
sadniturg (wrattgn ey tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgr) irg tlgrg.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐]g plbtb jin eg pramg bf tlg
hbtlgr fbr tlg jla`m it i `itgr mitg‘
- Nursg, Cgnyi
‐]as wa`` hbtavitg hbtlgrs tb db tb
pbsygnmu, sb hbtlgr lis i tirdgt tb
dgt tlg jla`m lgi`tly.‘
~ Egngjairy, Anmbngsai
‐Tg hust ijcnbw`gmdg inm rgwirm
hbtlgrs.‘
~ Nursg, Cgnyi
‐Af tlg plbtb as bf hy eiey A wa`` nbt
adnbrg tlg j irm.‘
~ Egngjairy, Cgnyi
Antrbmujand jirms watl egngjairags tb
sadn/wratg/tluhe prant bn tlgh lis
hbrg jlinjgs bf anjrgisand tlgar sgnsg bf
bwngrslap an tlg jirm.
Antgdritand inm iudhgntitabn
bf hbtavitabn fbr prgsgrvitabn,
ijjbhp`aslhgnt, ijjbuntiea`aty inm
vi`amitabn an tlg jirm fbr ebtl usgrs sgts
as hbst `acg`y tb livg i hiobr ahpijt bn
lbw i lgi`tl jirm as vagwgm br rgtiangm
an tgrhs bf ats sadnajinjg inm pbtgntai`
fbr futurg usg.
Gndidghgnt bf tlg rgjbrm jin eg
hbnatbrgm inm anjrgisgm tlrbudl
eua`mand in gjbsystgh tlit suppbrts tlg
antgrijtabns watlan tlg jirm tlrbudl
magrgnt tahgs inm jarjuhstinjgs.
]gsg antgrijtabns jin eg eua`t
an tlg rgjbrm tlrbudl g`iebritg`y
tlbudlt ijtavatags wlajl wa`` livg tb
eg sgqugnjgm inm p`ijgm tb anjrgisg
tlg rg`itabnslap bf tlg pirgnts watl
tlg jirm. I`sb `gimand tb i ladlgr
mgpgnmgnjy bn tlg jirm tb ditlgr lgi`tl
jirg anfbrhitabn ritlgr tlin mgpgnmand
bn tlg lgi`tl jirg prbfgssabni`s.
]g antgrijtabn watl tlg irtafijt jin eg
anataitgm tlrbudl virabus issbjaitabns
inm ijtavatags. ]gsg jin lg`p eua`m
vi`amitabn inm ijjbuntiea `aty antb
tlg anfbrhitabn irtafijt. ]g ijt bf
lb`mand tlg pirgnt inm tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgr ijjbuntie`g fbr tlg jla`m‑slgi`tl tlrbudl tlg rgjbrm wa`` anjrgisg
ittijlhgnt tbwirms tlg rgjbrm.
Ghbtabni` ittijlhgnt tb tlg irtafijt
bwand tb tlg sgnsatavg niturg bf tlg
rgjbrm wa`` `gim tb pgrsbni` anjgntavgs.
]g pirgnts wa`` eg hbtavitgm an tlg
prbjgss tb ticg jirg fbr tlg lgi`tl
rgjbrm is tlgrg wa`` eg i suddgstabn bf i
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 4=
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 41/53
tirdgt inm in ijlagvghgnt. ]us anstaditand i
sgnsg bf jbhhathgnt tbwirms tlg rgjbrm inm
tlg lgi`tl jirg systgh.
]as as i stgp wasg prbjgss tlit lis tb eua`t
antb tlg rgjbrm tb livg in ggjtavg gjbsystgh
tb anjrgisg gndidghgnt watl tlg jirm. Af tlgrg
as in gjbsystgh tb suppbrt tlg antgrijtabns
ggjtavg`y at wa`` `gim tb i prbjagnt lgi`tl
jirg systgh.
7.5.:. Zpijg fbr @bji`azitabn inm
[grsbni`asitabn? ]g antgrijtabns anvb`vand
pgrsbni`azitabn as rgi``y ngjgssiry an
tlg prbjgss bf fbrhand ebnmand watl tlg
egngjairags. ]gy irg tlg prahiry jirgdavgrs
inm nggm tb eg ie`g tb rg`itg tb tlg rgjbrm.
Af ybu i``bw tlgh tb eg tlg bng tb ticg
bwngrslap bf tlg jbntgnts bf tlg rgjbrm,
tlgy jin eg egttgr issbjaitgm watl tlg
ahhunazitabn prbjgss is i wlb`g. ]g rgjbrm
jin eg jrgitgm tb bgr magrgnt antgrijtabns
inm bppbrtunatags tb tlg egngjairags tb fbrh
pgrsbni` jbnngjtabns tlrbudl . Antgrijtabns
`acg sadniturg br puttand mbwn nbtgs an
tlg rgjbrms atsg`f wa`` bgr i ladlgr `gvg` bf
bwngrslap, tlus `gimand tb egttgr i rajlgr
gndidghgnt. Antgr`ancand tlg ahpbrtinjg
bf tlg ahhunazitabn prbjgss tb tlit bf i
pgrsbni` rgspbnsaea`aty wa`` dgngritg ngwgr
rgspbnsgs inm prbeiea`atags.
]g spijg prbvamgm an tlg jirm fbr
`bji`azitabn jin gvgn lg`p tlg lgi`tl jirg
prbfgssabni`s an rgtianand anfbrhitabn an
tlg jirm gvgn tlbudl tlgy mb nbt livg i
rg`gvint sgjtabn fbr tlg sihg. ]g prijtajg
bf `bji`azitabn wa`` i`sb lg`p rgtian tlg
ghbtabni` ebnm watl pirgnts is suddgstgm
gir`agr. ]g gssgnjg bf justbhazitabn
inm `bji`azitabn jin i`sb eg gnlinjgm
ey davand tlg egngjairags tlg
iea`aty tb anjbrpbritg tlg tlands bf
tlgar `acand an tlg rgjbrm fbr g.d.
rg`adabus syheb`s, inm stajcgrs jin
eg anjbrpbritgm ey tlgh. Ug`adabus
syheb`bdy jin lg`p rgtian tlg jirm
fbr `bndgr is tlg irtafijt anjrgisgs an
ahpbrtinjg inm jin ivia` tlg strbnd
pgrsbni` jbnngjt at fbrhs watl
tlg egngjairags.
]g rgjbrms jin i`sb erand iebut i jlindg
an lbw tlg egngjairags antgrijt watl tlg
rgjbrm is bf nbw ey erandand in g`ghgnt bf
Mb -At-Qbursg`f (MAQ). ]grg as i`rgimy i nggm
prbogjtgm ey tlg egngjairags tb egjbhg
sg`f rg`aint an unmgrstinmand tlg drbwtl
bf tlgar jla`m. ]g jbhpbngnt bf MAQ jin
fija`atitg sujl i sjgnirab anjrgisand usg inm
gndidghgnt watl tlg jirm.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 46
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 42/53
6. Zystghs Antgdritabn
In gxpgrt oury bf mgsadngrs, lgi`tl
prbfgssabni`s inm pb`ajy hicgrs frbh
WNAJGF, TLB, EHDF, DIVA, AxMI inm
JCZ hgt tb gvi`uitg tlg rgjbrm gntrags, it
tlg `ist `gd bf tlg prbogjt. Ugprgsgntitavgs
frbh Drihggn inm Hanastry bf Zumin,
tlbudl anvatgm, wgrg unfbrtunitg`y unie`g
tb ittgnm.
]g idgnmi bf tlas oury wis twb fb`m
- gvi`uitand inm iwirmand tlg strbndgst
mgsadn gntrags an virabus jitgdbrags
inm masjussand pirihgtgrs fbr mgsadn
rgjbhhgnmitabns tlit jbu`m eg
ahp`ghgntgm it i unavgrsi` lgi`tl inm
pb`ajy `gvg`.
]g twb miys anvb`vgm rgvagwand g`m
rgspbnsgs bn tlgsg ngw mgsadn rgjbrms,
rgvagwand, gvi`uitand, vbtand inm
masjussand tlg magrgnt prbpbsatabns
mgsadngrs livg himg, p`bttand tlgh bn
pirihgtgrs bf ghbtabni` v/s funjtabni`
vi`ug, rgtrbijtavg miti gntry, trinsatabn tb
madati` tgjlnb`bdy fb``bwgm ey gxtgnsavg
masjussabns bn tahgfrihgs inm fgisaea`aty bf
ahp`ghgntitabn bf tlg mgsadn prbpbsatabns.
]g miy jbnsastgm bf ngditavg vbtand inm
pbsatavg vbtand gxgrjasgs, anmavamui` vbtand
inm jb``gjtavg vbtand, erianstbrhand
sgssabns, strujturgm is wg`` is frgg-stbwand
jbnvgrsitabns watl tlg gntrags is stahu`us
sujl tlit tlg oumdgs wgrg?
a. rgvagwand it tlg sihg gntrags sgvgri`
tahgs tlrbudl magrgnt `gnsgs inm
spgnmand tahg ahprbvand tlgar bwn
oumdghgnt sb tlgy jbu`m amgntafy tlg
strbndgst rgjbrms ey tlg gnm bf tlg
sgssabn. ,
aa. Ie`g tb rgstgjt bn tlg mgsadn stahu`us
fbr jlirtand but tlg futurg pitl inmamgitand bn stritgdaj margjtabns.
aaa. Ie`g tb jrataqug tlg jrbwm-sburjand
ipprbijl inm gxp`brg ngw pue`aj
anfbrhitabn jli``gndg irgis wlgrg sujl
in ipprbijl jbu`m eg ipp`agm.
Cgy mravgrs eglanm jirm jlbajgs?
Ihbndst tlg jirms prgsgntgm, oury
prgfgrrgm jirms tlit ghp`bygm sahp`ajaty
an tlg `iybut, prbvamgm j`iraty bf
anfbrhitabn inm wgrg jbnjasg an
jbhhunajitand jrataji` anfbrhitabn.
F`gxaea`aty watl rgspgjt tb tlg
anjbrpbritabn bf immatabni` anfbrhitabn
g`ms an tlg futurg, jihg ijrbss is i
vi`uie`g jratgrai bf gvi`uitabn. Hiny
oury hghegrs i` sb prgfgrrgm rgjbrms
tlit lim tlg iea`aty an tlgar mgsadn
tb imipt tb prbdrgssavg tgjlnb`bdy.
Jirms tlit j`gir`y inm ggjtavg`y
jbhhunajitgm tlg gntarg vijjanitabn
jyj`g tb tlg egngjairy wgrg
mgghgm vi`uie`g.
Zystghs Antgdritabn? Bvgr tlg jbursg bf
tlg wbrcslbp, tlg masjussabn trinsatabngm
frbh tlg lgi`tl rgjbrms inm ats rb`g an
tlg systgh antb i `irdgr masjussabn bf
systghaj rgfbrhs / prbjgssgs tlit nggm
tb eg gstie`aslgm tb fija`atitg hbrg
anfbrhgm mgjasabn hicand an tlg futurg.
Oumdgs jbntghp`itgm in irjlatgjturg bf
magrgnt typgs bf duamg`angs tlit slbu`m eg
mgvg`bpgm fbr jbuntrags?
a. i `ast bf jrataji` miti g`ms (hanahuh
miti-sgt) tlit tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm hust
`bbc it jb``gjtand, an brmgr tb gnsurg
tlit miti jb``gjtgm as futurg rgimy watl
rgspgjt tb antrbmujtabn bf ngwgr lgi`tl
sgrvajg antgrvgntabns.
aa. i stritgdaj-vi`ug mahgnsabn bn wlit tlg
rb`g inm p`ijg bf tlg jirm slbu`m eg watlan
tlg systgh
aaa. madati` jbhp`ainjg jratgrai
av. (rgjbrm) hgmai inm fbrhit mgjasabnand
eisgm bn tlg jbhhunajitabn inm
anfbrhitabn ju`turgs ijrbss sbjagtags
v. syngrdags watl lbw TLB br WNAJGF
hiy gnvasabn i purg`y madati` futurg tlit
mbgs nbt anvb`vg i lirm-jbpy rgjbrm inman tlg eua`m up tb tlit wg jrgitg sbhg
ha`gstbngs i`bnd tlg wiy tb i jbhp`gtg
gj`apsg tb tlg rgjbrm.
Jbnsgnsus wis i`sb ijlagvgm watl rgspgjt
tb tlg amgi bf jrgitand in antgdritgm
eijcgnm rgsburjg systgh fbr jbuntrags.
]as wa`` jbnsast bf in iddrgditabn bf
mgsadn inm `bji` prbmujtabn rgsburjgs
gssgntai` fbr updrimand / rgmgsadnand i
jbuntry‑s lgi`tl rgjbrm. Immatabni``y
tlas bn`ang rgsburjg jin i`sb eg
gquappgm watl virabus driplaj hgmai
hitgrai` wlajl jin eg jrbwm sburjgm
tlrbudl mgsadn jbhpgtatabns. ]g jbrg
sadnajint fgiturg bf tlg rgsburjg wa``
eg i `aeriry bf lgi`tl rgjbrm mgsadns tlit
jin eg ijjgssgm bn`ang, tlus prbvamand
jbuntrags watl tlg bptabn tb pajc inm
jlbbsg tlg mgsadn tlit as egst suatgm tb
tlgar jbntgxt. ]as bn`ang rgpbsatbry
jin rst gndidg watl tlg jli``gndg bf
prbvamand jbhprglgnsavg suppbrt tb tlg
prbjgss bf ahhunazitabn, wlajl an tlg
futurg jin i`sb eg sji`gm up tb rgspbnm
tb `irdgr qugstabns tlit ahpijt tlg
pue`aj lgi`tl gjb`bdy.
Inbtlgr jrataji` fgiturg jbu`m eg i
rgpbsatbry bf egst prijtajgs/ hgisurgs is
livg eggn besgrvgm is egand sujjgssfu`
watl rgspgjt tb lgi`tl miti tb lg`p
jbuntrags hicg anfbrhgm mgjasabn
irbunm lgi`tl miti hinidghgnt.
]rbudl tlg bn`ang rgsburjg systgh,
tlgrg as in bppbrtunaty tb g`ajat
pirtajapitabn inm rgspbnsgs tb tlg vist
rindg bf systghaj prbe`ghs is amgntagmsb fir. Lbwgvgr it i prbjgss `gvg` sgvgri`
suddgstabns wgrg himg watl rgspgjt
tb gndidand watl tlg sb`utabns tb eg
jrbwmsburjgm.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 4<
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 43/53
]g Jrbwmsburjand [rbjgss? ]grg wis
jbnsgnsus bn livand antgr masjap`aniry
tgihs bf mgsadngrs inm pue`aj lgi`tl
gxpgrts tb wbrc tbdgtlgr tb jbnjgptui`azg
sb`utabns. At wis i`sb rgjbhhgnmgm tlit
i hamwiy eg sbudlt egtwggn i jbhp`gtg`y
bpgn gnmgm prbjgss inm in anvatitabns bn`y
ipprbijl is i hgins bf jbntrb``and qui`aty
bf butput.
Is i prbjgss suddgstabn tlg oury wis bf
tlg vagw tlit i systghitaj, 5 tagrgm g`m
rgsgirjl prbjgss slbu`m eg mbng. An tlg
rst vasat i eragf gtlnbdriplaj rgsgirjl
as jbnmujtgm ijrbss : tb 7 jbuntrags tb
ditlgr jbntgxt spgjaj miti tlit fggms
antb i egttgr mgnatabn bf tlg jli``gndg
atsg`f. ]as mgsadn jli``gndg as tlgn
bpgngm up tb tlg `irdgr mgsadn inm pue`aj
lgi`tl jbhhunaty i`bnd watl drinu`ir
g`m miti wlajl prbvamgs pirtajapints i
j`girgr unmgrstinmand bf tlg niturg bf rgi`
tahg jli``gndgs. Mgsadn amgis irg jrbwm-
sburjgm, syntlgtaji``y mbwnsg`gjtgm inm
i shi``gr sgt bf :7 jbnjgpt amgis irg ticgn
eijc tb g`m fbr tgstand. ]g sgt bf tbp 9;
mgsadn prbpbsatabns irg sg`gjtgm inm tlg
mgsadngrs irg gnjburidgm tb rgng inm
rg-suehat tlgar gntrags an vagw bf g`m
rgspbnsgs. Anmavamui` jbuntrags jin tlgn
jbnsamgr jbntrijtand tlg wanngrs, watltlg jbntgst egjbhand i vglaj`g tlit i`adns
nitabni` lgi`tl systghs watl `bji` tbp
mgsadn ti`gnt. ]as ti`gnt jin eg mgp`bygm
bn btlgr lgi`tl inm pue`aj anfbrhitabn
mgsadn jli``gndgs.
At wis i`sb rgjbhhgnmgm tlit prb-ijtavg
mgjasabn hicgrs frbh hanastrags bf
lgi`tl bf magrgnt ghgrdand gjbnbhags
eg anvb`vgm an tlg ni` oury ping`, sb is
tb `gnm jbntgxt ipprbpraitgngss. ]as
wa`` gnsurg tlit sb`utabns dgngritgm livg
eggn vagwgm tlrbudl hu`ta masjap`aniry
vagwpbants inm jin eg imiptgm tb rgi`-
tahg jbuntry spgjaj sjgnirabs.
At wis i`sb suddgst tlit antg``gjtui`
prbpgrty radlts hust eg rgsgrvgm bn`y
fbr tlg tbp tgn mgsadns, inm nbt fbr
gvgry suehassabn, sb is tb gnjburidg
hbrg prbfgssabni`s inm mgsadn stumabs
tb ipp`y tb tlg jbntgst.
I saha`ir “jrbwm-sburjand bf amgis‑
ipprbijl wis mgghgm vi`uie`g fbr
btlgr pue`aj anfbrhitabn inm hgssidand
gbrts, gspgjai``y tbwirms nbn-`atgritg inm
magrgnt`y ie`gm pbpu`itabns.
Jurrgnt`y sanjg hbst hgssidand as iahgm it
`atgritg pbpu`itabns at mbgs ijt is i eirragr
tbwirms ggjtavg sgrvajg jbhhunajitabn
inm mg`avgry.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg <;
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 44/53
Jin tlas rgjbrm `anc sgih`gss`y watl
btlgr amgntaty inm pue`aj sgrvajg irtgfijts
tlit egngjairy jbhhunatags rgtian inm
vi`ug sujl tlit at egjbhgs i hbrg jrataji`
amgntagr bf tlg anmavamui` inm tlg fiha`y2
Jin tlg rgjbrm sgrvg is tlg injlbr fbr i``
gxjlindg bf lgi`tl anfbrhitabn egtwggn
tlg lgi`tl prbvamgr inm tlg egngjairy2
Frbh in anfbrhitabn mgsadn pgrspgjtavg,
tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm lis tlg pbtgntai` tb
bjjupy i hbrg jrataji` rb`g an gnie`and
tlg nursg tb `anc tlg eiey watl tlg jirm,
tlus rgmujand oumdhgnt eisgm mgjasabn
hicand, wlgrgis watl rgspgjt tb prbvamand
jrataji` lgi`tl jirg anfbrhitabn tlg lgi`tl
rgjbrm as gxpgjtgm tb p`iy in issastavg rb`g,
sanjg tlg egngjairy as hbrg rg`aint bn
inm trustand bf vgrei` jbunsg``and. Tatl
rgspgjt tb massghanitabn bf vati` lgi`tl
jirg anfbrhitabn, tlgrg as in bppbrtunaty
tb i`adn at watl `bji` cnbw`gmdg slirand
ju`turgs. Cgy anfbrhitabn jin tlgn eg
rgnmgrgm an i hu`ta-hbmi` fbrhit3 in
antgrp`iy bf iuri`, vasui` inm tgxtui`
hgmai. Immatabni``y usgr gndidghgnt
watl tlg rgjbrm jin eg anjrgisgm ey
mgsadnand i hu`ta-hbmi` fbrhit tlit
gnie`g i sgrags bf antgrijtabns tlrbudl
magrgnt tahgs inm jarjuhstinjgs
an tlg anfbrhitabn gnvarbnhgnt bf
egngjairags. ]gsg antgrijtabns jin eg
eua`t an tlg rgjbrm tlrbudl g`iebritg`y
tlbudlt ijtavatags wlajl wa`` livg
tb eg sgqugnjgm inm iahgm it anjrgisand
tlg rg`itabnslap bf tlg pirgnts watl
tlg rgjbrm.
4. ]g Ugjbrm is i Zystgh inm an i Zystgh
]g jurrgnt mgnatabn bf tlg “lgi`tl
rgjbrm‑ jli``gndg hiy eg rgstrajtavg inm
wg irg `acg`y tb jbhg up watl anjrghgnti`
sb`utabns af wg rgpgitgm`y mgng tlg
prbe`gh is at lis i`wiys eggn mgngm. At as
pbssae`g tb rgmgng tlg prbe`gh inm jrift i
hbrg ipprbpraitg sjbpand bf tlg jli``gndg.
Fbr nbw tlas ngeu`bus jli``gndg jin eg
p`ijgm it tlg antgrsgjtabn bf assugs igjtand
magrgnt usgr sgts sujl is egngjairags,
frbnt-`ang lgi`tl-wbrcgrs inm tlg eijcgnm
lgi`tl systgh. ]gsg assugs irg `irdg`y
rg`itgm tb miti gntry inm rgtragvi`, pitagnt
amgntaty inm lgi`tl stitus trijcand, lgi`tl-
jirg inm nutratabn rg`itgm jbunsg``and inm
eglivabur jlindg jbhhunajitabn
At as i`sb antgrgstand tb nbtg tlit tlg rgjbrm
as tlg bn`y tindae`g irtafijt tlit as rgtiangm
watl tlg egngjairy inm tlgrgfbrg pbssae`y
tlg bn`y “amgntagr bf tlg sgrvajg‑ tlit as an
j`bsgst prbxahaty bf tlg egngjairy fiha`y.
At as tlgrgfbrg gvgn hbrg jrataji` fbr at tb
sadnafy tlg gssgnjg bf tlg sgrvajg a.g. jla`m
prbtgjtabn, lgi`tl inm drbwtl inm ijt isi eramdg egtwggn tlg egngjairy inm tlg
lgi`tl prbvamgr. Furtlgrhbrg tlg prbxahaty
at bjjupags watl tlg egngjairy hicgs
at i cgy vglaj`g fbr eglivaburi` jlindg
jbhhunajitabn.
Ug-mgsadnand tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm prbvamgs
us watl in bppbrtunaty tb, stgp eijc inm,
rimaji``y rg-ahidang tlg rb`g at “jin‑ p`iy
an tlg pue`aj lgi`tl systgh. An rgspbnsg
tb tlg `bbsg`y frihgm jli``gndg (iebvg),
at wbu`m eg ahpbrtint tb mgvg`bp i sgrags
bf magrgnt lypbtlgsgs bn tlg “canms‑
bf lgi`tl rgjbrm tlit jbu`m rimaji``y
ahpijt jbvgridg.
Tlit canm bf i rgjbrm jin fija`atitg
in ahprbvgm rippbrt inm gndidghgnt
egtwggn egngjairags inm tlg Ubutang
Ahhunazitabn prbdrih2
Jin tlg rgjbrm egjbhg strbnd`y
synbnyhbus watl br in ajbn bf sbrts
bf tlg jla`m‑s lgi`tl inm drbwtl sujl
tlit egngjairy jbhhunatags anviraie`y
issbjaitg tlg rgjbrm watl jla`m‑s lgi`tl2
Jin tlg rgjbrm ansta`` an tlg egngjairy
tlg mgsarg inm eglivaburs tlit prabratazg
tlg `bnd tgrh dbi` bf tlg lgi`tl bf tlg
jla`m, watlan wlajl tlg ahhunazitabn
prbjgss as vagwgm is egand bn`y in ispgjtbf, ritlgr tlin tlg sb`g beogjtavg2
Mbgs tlas irtgfijt livg tlg pbtgntai` tb
gnie`g tlg antrbmujtabn bf i fggmeijc
`bbp, frbh tlg egngjairags inm lgi`tl-
wbrcgr tb tlg lgi`tl systgh, sujl tlit
tlgrg as shbbtlgr stbw bf lgi`tl miti is
wg`` is fggmeijc bn tlg sgrvajg2
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg <5
Vagw i`` tlg tbp 79 suehassabns bn`ang it www.ditgsfbunmitabn.brd/rgjbrmsfbr`afg
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 45/53
Eglivaburi` Jlindg? ]g mgsadn
jin gvgn `gvgridg bn lbw luhin
eglivabrs rganfbrjg rgspbnsaea`aty. Fbr
anstinjg, anjbrpbritand tlg sadniturg
br stihp bf tlg lgi`tl wbrcgr is wg``
is tlg egngjairy iftgr tlg ijt bf
vijjanitabn, jin gnjbur idg pgrjgptabns
bf ijjbuntiea`aty inm ijjbhp`aslhgnt
is wg`` is rganfbrjg tlg sadnajinjg bf
vijjanitabn. Fgiturgs tlit jin gnie`g
tlg pirgnt tb hicg tlg rgjbrm tlgar
bwn, `acg i lgi`tl `bd br plbtbdripls
gtj. jin iam an eua`mand ghbtabni` vi`ug3
wlajl as in anjgntavg fbr rgtgntabn.
]g pirgnts hiy eg hbtavitgm tb
prgsgrvg tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm mug tb tlg
suddgstavg prgsgnjg bf i tirdgt inm
in ijlagvghgnt. Immatabni``y, tlg ijt
bf lb`mand tlg pirgnt inm tlg lgi`tl
wbrcgr ijjbuntie`g fbr tlg jla`m‑s lgi`tl
tlrbudl tlg rgjbrm jbu`m rimaji``y
jlindg pgrjgptabns inm tlgrgey
prijtajgs irbunm rgjbrm rgtgntabn
inm usg.
Bnjg tlg rgjbrm lis diangm hanmspijg
inm trijtabn, at jin tlgn immrgss i
`irdgr jbnjgrn, tlit bf tlg bvgri``
mgvg`bphgnt bf ebtl tlg hbtlgr inm
tlg jla`m. Tatlbut egand rgstrajtgm tb
bn`y ahhunazitabn, tlg rgjbrm jin `itgrtrinsat antb antgdritand anfbrhitabn
massghanitabn iebut lgi`tl, nutratabn
inm sinatitabn.
Ijquarand Wsgr Fggmeijc? Bnjg
tlas as ijlagvgm, at hicgs at gvgn hbrg
ahpgritavg tb ijquarg usgr fggmeijc
jbntanubus`y frbh egngjairags, an brmgr
tb anjbrpbritg anjrghgnti` eut mynihaj
ahprbvghgnts an lgi`tl systgh prbjgssgs.
Tla`g tlg rgjbrm an ats jurrgnt fbrh hiy
nbt eg mgsadngm tb jipturg egngjairy
fggmeijc, in ipprbpraitg rgmgsadnand bf tlg
rgjbrm inm tlg anfbrhitabn trinsijtabn
prbtbjb`, hiy gnie`g us tb mb sb. ]as wa``
gnie`g gvgn tlg frbnt-`ang `iygr tb anataitg
hajrb rgfbrhs inm twgics watlan ats
hinngr bf funjtabnand tb gnsurg bptahazgm
prbjgss gjagnjy.
Lgi`tl Miti F`bw inm Mgjasabn Hicand?
Frbh i systghaj pgrspgjtavg tlg jirm
slbu`m livg tlg pbtgntai` tb gisg tlg
jb``itabn bf pitagnt inm jla`m miti inm
stbw at eijc antb tlg systgh, an brmgr tb
gnie`g egttgr mgjasabn hicand. Livand
tlas jbntanubus miti stbw antb tlg mastrajt
inm stitg `gvg`s jin fija`atitg tlg systgh
tb jrgitg stritgdags irbunm lbw egttgr tb
rgspbnm tb spgjaj lgi`tl vu`ngriea`atags
bf magrgnt pitagnt sgts br pgbp`g ijrbss
magrgnt rgdabns. It in gvgn ladlgr `gvg`
at jin anfbrh tlg jrgitabn bf in gjbsystgh
tlit jin anvatg jrbss sgjtbri` anvgsthgnts
tb sgrvg spgjaj lgi`tl nggms bf
egngjairy pbpu`itabns.
]gsg inm btlgr latlgrtb unahidangm
pbtgntai`atags jin lg`p us rg-tlanc nbtbn`y tlg jrataji` rb`g bf tlg jirm watlan tlg
`irdgr systgh eut i`sb gnvasabn tlg jirm is
i systgh an atsg`f. ]g rgjbrm jin eg sggn is
ijtand is i sg`f sustianand gntaty, in ajbn bf
jlindg br i sgrvajg amgntagr tlit jin pivg
tlg wiy fbr updrimand tlg gntarg systgh.
Ughanmgr inm Ugji``? Jurrgnt`y tlg rgjbrm
mbgs nbt pgrfbrh tlg funjtabn bf sgrvand
is i hnghbnaj rghanmgr bf tlg sgrvajg br
tlg ngxt mug mitg. ]g rgjbrm hust eg ie`g
tb rghanm egngjairags iebut tlg ngxt mug
mitg, an imvinjg inm tlgn rganfbrjg bn tlg
miy, i`bndsamg prbvamand i sgnsg bf wlgrg
tlgy irg p`ijgm an tlg gntarg vijjanitabn
jyj`g. ]g prbpbsgm rghanmgr hgjlinash
jin eg mgsadngm is egand i eramdg egtwggn
iumab inm vasui`. In iuri` hgssidg is i
rghanmgr bf tlg anfbrhitabn br i mug mitg
stihp davgn ey i pgrsbn bf iutlbraty jin
prbvamg tlg nggmgm pusl tb tlg egngjairags
tb rbutang`y imlgrg tb tlg vijjanitabn jyj`g.
Zaha`ir`y vasui` `y irrgstand rghanmgr
hgtlbms jin eg mgsadngm antb tlg rgjbrm.
]us fu```and i erbimgr pgrspgjtavg tlin
oust usand tlg rgjbrm is i pissavg irtgfijt.
Zifgty Jlgjcs Tatlan tlg Jirm? ]g
lgi`tl rgjbrm is i systgh nggms tb
anjbrpbritg anfbrhitabn rgmunminjags
tlrbudl bvgr`ips an brmgr tb g`ahanitg
anfbrhitabn `gicidgs. ]g prgsgnjg bf
sifgty jlgjcs watlan tlg lgi`tl rgjbrm
is i systgh as i jrataji`, jbnsamgrand tlg
`bdastaji` prgssurg tlit tlg systgh prgsgnt`y
gxgrts upbn tlg lgi`tl wbrcgr. ]g slggr
nuhegr bf egngjairags tlit livg tb eg
sgrvajgm watlan i slbrt spin bf tahg davgrasg tb tlg sjbpg bf prbjgss grrbrs br prbjgss
mgvaitabns. An brmgr tb rgmujg tlas tlg lgi`tl
rgjbrm hust sggc tb rganfbrjg jrataji` lgi`tl
jirg anfbrhitabn tlit as jurrgnt`y mgsadnitgm
is fi``and watlan tlg jbrg rgspbnsaea`aty bf
tlg lgi`tl jirg prbvamgr.
Fbr anstinjg watl rgspgjt tb tlg
Wnaqug AM, tlg jirm jbu`m ittghpt tb
jipturg anfbrhitabn tlit jin funjtabn
is sgjbnmiry br pissavg amgntagrs,
gatlgr an tlg fbrh bf i unaqug
amgntajitabn jbmg, immatabni` eijcup
miti g`m br tlrbudl tlg prbvasabn
bf i e`inc spijg fbr `bji`azgm
anfbrhitabn. Zaha`ir`y tlg mug-mitg
miti g`m jbu`m eg mgsadngm an wiy
tlit gnsurgs vasaea`aty it iny davgn
tahg tlit tlg usgr as rgimand tlg
rgjbrm, rgdirm`gss bf tlg hinngr an
wlajl tlg rgjbrm lis eggn fb`mgm
br lg`m. Af sujl sifgty ngts irg eua`t
antb tlg funmihgnti` `bdaj bf tlg
jirm, tlgn at wa`` eg gquappgm tb
bpgritg ggjtavg`y an i viragty bf
g`m sjgnirabs. At wa`` i`sb anjrgisg
mgpgnmgnjy bn tlg rgjbrm tb ditlgr
lgi`tl jirg anfbrhitabn ritlgr tlin
mgpgnmand wlb``y bn tlg lgi`tl
jirg prbfgssabni`s.
An immatabn tb tlas, antrbmujand
immatabni` sgjuraty `iygrs tb tlg
anfbrhitabn jb``gjtgm an tlg jirm jin
iam tlg lgi`tl wbrcgrs ahhgnsg`y
sanjg tlg systgh as tlgn dgirgm fbr
gjagnjy is wg`` is mgsadngm tb eg
funjtabni` gvgn an tlg fijg bf `ahatandg`m jli``gndgs. ]as wa`` lg`p eramdg
tlg dip egtwggn mgsargm prbtbjb`s inm
ijtui` gxgjutabn bn g`m.
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg <=
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 46/53
<. Ippgnmax
[rbtbjb` Duamg fbr Lgi`tl Tbrcgrs?
]g hbmgritbr anataitgm in ajg ergicand
sgssabn an brmgr tb antrbmujg pirtajapints
tb gijl btlgr is wg`` is antrbmujg tlg JCZ
rgsgirjlgrs inm tlg hbmgritbr‑s tgih tb
tlg pirtajapints).
]g FDM tlgn egadans is fb``bws?
i. Nihg
e. Lbw `bnd s/lg lis eggn wbrcand inm
lbw `bnd tlgy livg wbrcgm watl tlg jirm
j. Irgi tlit tlgy jbvgr
Y. Lbw mb ybu usg tlg ahhunazitabn
jirm2 (prbeg antb tlg gntarg usg jisg ‚
wlgn mb tlgy assug tb hbtlgr, lbw tlgy
usg at2) Jin ybu tlanc bf iny antgrgstand
gxpgragnjgs tlit ybu hiy livg lim watl tlg
prgsgnt ahhunazitabn jirm, dbbm br gvgn
btlgrwasg2
Y. Tlit irg tlg prbe`ghs tlit ybu
gxpgragnjg bn g`m watl tlg prgsgnt lgi`tl
rgjbrm jirms2 (Hbmgritbr fija`atitgs eragf
masjussabn)Y. Ipirt frbh tlg jirm wlit btlgr
ahhunazitabn trijcand hgtlbms livg ybu
usgm2
[lisg 9 - Jug jirm eisgm ijtavatags?
i). Wnaqug amgntaty
e). Ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g
j). Ngw funjtabn g`ms
m). Vasui` hgtiplbr
g). Jb`br
f). Hitgrai` & fbrh
(i). Wnaqug Amgntajitabn Jug jirm {Nb.
bf jug jirms - =} [ipgr eisgm vbtand (9;
- 97 hanutgs)
[rbeg? b unmgrstinm tlg ahpbrtint
g`ms fbr amgntajitabn inm bpgnngss tb
tlg usg bf tgjlnb`bdy is in iam.
(7 hanutgs) Hbmgritbr egdans watl
in bpgn gnmgm masjussabn, wlgrg wg
masjuss pirtajapint gxpgragnjgs bf
linm`and vgrajitabn bf amgntatags bn tlg
jirm inm iny prbe`ghs tlgy fijg.
Y. Lbw mb ybu dgngri``y vgrafy tlg
amgntaty bf tlg jla`m2 Tlit jli``gndgs
livg ybu fijgm an jlgjcand tlg rgi`
amgntaty bf i jla`m2 Irg tlgrg iny btlgr
hgtlbms mb ybu usg tb jlgjc tlg
amgntaty bf tlg jla`m2
(9; hanutgs) Hbmgritbr slbws tlghpipgr eisgm jirms bf unaqug amgntaty
pirihgtgrs `acg nihg, plbtbdripl,
eartlhircs, eabhgtrajs inm ndgr
prants gtj.
Y. ]gsg irg i fgw ngw amgntajitabn
amgis tlit livg eggn suehattgm,
tlit jbu`m eg immgm tb tlg jirm (i
plbtbdripl bf tlg hbtlgr inm tlg
eiey, hircand eartlhircs bn tlg jirm)
/ tgjlnb`bdy (eirjbmgs). Tlit mb ybu
tlanc bf tlgsg amgis2 (Hbmgritbr fija`atitgs
masjussabn fbr i jbup`g bf hanutgs, bn prbs,
jbns gtj.)
Y. Af wg jbu`m antrbmujg bn`y bng bf tlgsg
ngw amgntajitabn amgis, wlajl bng mb ybu
tlanc wa`` lg`p ybu ijjuritg`y trijc tlg
amgntaty bf i jla`m an tlg egst wiy pbssae`g2
[`gisg nbtg ybur nihg inm tlg jbmg bf tlg
amgi bn tlg pbst at an frbnt bf ybu.
Y. ]incs, p`gisg tg`` us (bng ey bng) iebut
tlg jlbajg ybu livg himg inm wly ybu
tlanc tlas as tlg egst jbhpirgm tb btlgrs.
(Hbmgritbr fija`atitgs eragf masjussabn)
(e). Ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g Jug jirms {<
jug jirms} (:; hanutgs)
[rbeg? Gisg an unmgrstinmand bf
anfbrhitabn, j`iraty, tahg ticgn tb ``
Hbmgritbr siys ‐]g rbutang ahhunazitabn
sjlgmu`g as it tlg lgirt bf bur rgsgirjl
watl tlas jirm ‚ wg wint tb unmgrstinm
lbw tb mgsadn tlas an tlg egst, hbst j`gir
inm hbst ggjtavg wiy.‘
(Hbmgritbr slbws tlg gxastand jirm inmpbants tb tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g)
Y. Jin ybu tg`` us i `att`g iebut tlg
ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g an tlg gxastand
jirm2 Jin rgjb``gjt af ybu‑vg gvgr lim i
jli``gndg watl usand tlas2 Tlit canms bf
prbe`ghs bjjur2 (Hbmgritbr fija`atitgs
eragf masjussabn)
Hbmgritbr siys ‐Mgsadngrs livg jrgitgm
ngw amgis / ngw wiys bf rgprgsgntand
tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g. An drbups
bf 5 wg‑m `acg ybu tb db tlrbudl tlg 7
jirms tlit A ih davand tb ybu. Oust ticg i
hanutg br twb tb sgg tlgsg jirms. Af ybu
wint tb j`irafy wlit i pirtaju`ir tland
an tlg jirm hgins, ybu hiy masjuss watl
ybur pirtngr‑.
--- : hanutgs ----
Hbmgritbr siys ‐A‑vg wrattgn sbhg eisaj
anfbrhitabn bn tlas wlatg ebirm.‘
Nihg bf tlg jla`m? bhhy
Mitg bf EJD? 9=tl Mgj 5;9:
LG[ E? 9=tl Mgj 5;9:
B[V9? 9=tl Mgj 5;9:
NG\ MWG MIG? [`gisg ji`ju`itg tlas
bn ybur bwn eisgm bn tlg mitg davgn.
@B NB. ? I:959
Hbmgritbr siys ‐A wbu`m `acg ybu tb
`` tlas anfbrhitabn antb tlg 7 jirms an
frbnt bf ybu. [`gisg mb tlas anmavamui``y
‚ wg livg jirms fbr i`` bf ybu . [`gisg
mb nbt masjuss tlg jirms wla`g ybu irg
``and tlgh, af ybu livg iny qugstabns
p`gisg ji`` hg tb ybur sgit, A wa``j`irafy.‘
Hbmgritbr siys ‐]it hust livg eggn
in antgrgstand gxpgragnjg/Lbw mam ybu
`acg tlit2 Eisgm bn ybur gxpgragnjg
bf ``and tlgsg jirms, A wbu`m `acg ybu
tb ini`ysg inm mgjamg tlg bngs tlit
ijjbrmand tb ybu irg egst (5 bf tlgh
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg <6
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 47/53
pgrlips) inm wlajl bng ybu `acgm `gist. Zb
tbp 5 inm ebttbh 9.‘
Y. ]incs, p`gisg tg`` us (bng ey bng) iebut
tlg jlbajg ybu livg himg inm tlg rgisbn
fbr tlg sihg. (Hbmgritbr fija`atitgs eragf
masjussabn)
]g hbmgritbr iscs tlgh tb rgim/slbw/lb`m
up tlgar jlbajg inm masjuss wlit mam tlgy
`acg an tlg tie`g2 [rbegs wly tlgy jlbbsg
tlbsg jirms inm tlg jbhprglgnsaea`aty bf tlg
miti g`ms.
Y. Nbw A wbu`m `acg ybu tb jb``gjtavg`y
masjuss inm vbtg fbr tlg tbp 5 (rincgm 9st
inm 5nm) inm tlg ebttbh 9 inm tg`` us wly2
Hbmgritbr siys ‐]grg irg i`sb tlgsg tlrgg
amgis tlit A wint tb slirg watl ybu inm
unmgrstinm wlit ybu tlanc bf tlgh‘ (Zlbw
inm gxp`ian rimai`, earm ajbns, trgg mgsadn ‚
fija`atitg eragf masjussabn)
(j). Ngw Anfbrhitabn Fag`ms / Vi`ug {7 jug
jirms} (97 hanutgs)
[rbeg? [rabratazitabn bf ngw anfbrhitabn
Y. Mgsadngrs livg jbhg up watl sbhg
ngw amgis bf wlit g`sg / wlit ngw canmsbf anfbrhitabn jbu`m eg antrbmujgm an tlg
jirm. Lgrg irg sbhg bf tlgsg3 (p`ijg jug-
jirms bn tie`g) p`gisg livg i `bbc (hbmgritbr
fija`atitgs masjussabn).
An jisg tlg jitgdbrags irg nbt sg`f gvamgnt tb
tlg pirtajapints, in gxp`initabn wa`` eg davgn
tb tlgh rgdirmand tlg sihg.
Anmavamui` Vbtand?
Y. Af wg jbu`m bn`y imm bng br twb bf
tlgsg miti g`ms, wlajl bngs mb ybu
tlanc wa`` lg`p/imm vi`ug fbr ybu inm
tlg egngjairags hbst2 [`gisg nbtg
ybur nihg inm tlg jbmgs bf tlg 5 tbp
amgis bn tlg pbstats an frbnt bf ybu.
Y. ]incs, p`gisg tg`` us (bng ey
bng) iebut tlg jlbajg ybu livg himg
inm wly ybu tlanc tlas as tlg egst,
is jbhpirgm tb btlgrs. (Hbmgritbr
fija`atitgs eragf masjussabn)
As tlgrg iny btlgr canm bf anfbrhitabn
tlit slbu`m eg anj`umgm an tlg jirm
inm lbw at wbu`m imm vi`ug2
(m). Vasui` hgtiplbr Jug jirms (97
hanutgs)
[rbeg? Jbunsg`and anfbrhitabn
davgn an tgrhs bf tahg inm drbwtl
rgprgsgntitabn
Drbwtl Jlirts (< ‚ 1 hans)
Y. Lbw mb ybu trijc tlg drbwtl bf tlg
jla`m it prgsgnt2
Hbmgritbr p`ijgs jug jirms bn tlg
tie`g
Hbmgritbr siys ‐]gsg irg sbhg ngw
wiys an wlajl mgsadngrs livg mgsadngm
tlg drbwtl jlirts. Tg wbu`m `acg ybu
tb ticg 5 tb : hanutgs tb rgvagw tlgh.‘
Y. Zb, wlit mb ybu tlanc bf tlgsg2
(Hbmgritbr fija`atitgs eragf masjussabn
bn prbs inm jbns gtj., prbeg antb tlg
vasui` inm anfbrhitabni` sty`gs inm
ijquarg unmgrstinmand bf prgfgrgnjg
pittgrns, isc wly wly wly)
Y. Tlajl bf tlgsg ijjbrmand tb ybu
as egst (5 jirms) inm wbrst (9 jirm) an
tgrhs bf gisg bf usg inm unmgrstinmand
ey ybu inm egngjairags2 [`gisg nbtg
ybur nihg inm tlg jbmgs bf tlg 5 tbp
amgis bn tlg pbstats an frbnt bf ybu.
Y. ]incs, p`gisg tg`` us (bng ey bng)
iebut tlg jlbajg ybu livg himg inm wly
ybu tlanc tlas as tlg egs t, is jbhpirgm
tb btlgrs. (Hbmgritbr fija`atitgs eragf
masjussabn)
Lgi`tljirg Jbunsg``and anfbrhitabn
(7 ‚ 4 hanutgs)
Y. Lbw mb ybu jbunsg` hbtlgrs bn lbw
tb ticg jirg bf tlg jla`m it prgsgnt2 Mb
ybu livg i prbvasabn an ybur jirm tlit
suppbrts tlg anfbrhitabn ybu davg tlgh2
Hbmgritbr p`ijgs jug jirms bn tlg tie`g
Hbmgritbr siys ‐]gsg irg sbhg ngwwiys an wlajl mgsadngrs livg vasui`azgm
br mriwn lgi`tljirg anfbrhitabn. Tg
wbu`m `acg ybu tb ticg 5 tb : hanutgs tb
rgvagw tlgh.‘
Y. Zb, wlit mb ybu tlanc bf tlgsg2
(Hbmgritbr fija`atitgs eragf masjussabn
bn prbs inm jbns gtj., prbeg antb tlg
vasui` inm anfbrhitabni` sty`gs i nm ijquarg
unmgrstinmand bf prgfgrgnjg pittgrns,
isc wly2)
Y. Tlajl bf tlgsg ijjbrmand tb ybu as egst
(5 jirms) inm wbrst (9 jirm) fbr tlg purpbsg
bf hicand egngjairags unmgrstinm inm
rghghegr2 [`gisg nbtg ybur nihg inm tlg
jbmgs bf tlg 5 tbp amgis bn tlg pbstats an
frbnt bf ybu.
(g). Jb`br Jug ji rms {:+5 jug jirms}
(5; hanutgs tgntitavg
[rbeg? Ju`turi` jbntgxt bf jb`br,
prgfgrgnjgs eisgm upbn pgrsbni`
gxpgragnjgs, Jb`br is in anmajitbr bf
sgdrgditabn bf anfbrhitabn, Jb`br is in
anmajitbr bf ahpbrtinjg, Jb`br is in
anmajitbr bf prabratazitabn. Tg irg `bbcand
fbr quajc rgspbnsgs inm bpgn gnmgm
masjussabns.
Dgngraj Jb`br
Y. Af ybu lim tb jlbbsg i jb`bur fbr i
lgi`tljirm wlajl bng wbu`m at eg inm wly2
(Masjussabn)
Y. Tlajl jb`bur mb ybu issbjaitg watl
lgi`tl2 (Masjussabn)
Hbmgritbr masp`iys jirms bn tlg tie`g.
Y. Tlajl jb`br but bf tlgsg wbu`m ybu
jlbbsg fbr tlg ahhunazitabn jirm2 (Drbup
masjussabn bn jlbbsand wlajl jb`brs wbrc
br mbn‑t wbrc inm wly)
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg <<
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 48/53
Jb`bur Jbmand (Jb`br is i funjtabn an
tgrhs bf anfbrhitabn jbmand? Jb`br jirms an
tgrhs bf jb`br fbr vijjanitabn inm tahg br
hbntl)
Hbmgritbr masp`iys jb`bur jbmand jug jirms
bn tlg tie`g.
Hbmgritbr siys ‐Jb`br lis eggn usgm an tlg
mgsadn bf tlgsg jirms, p`gisg ticg i hanutg
tb sgg tlgsg‑
Y. Tlit mb ybu tlanc bf tlgsg2 (Masjussabn,
af tlg rgspbnmgnts livg nbt unmgrstbbm tlg
jbmgm funjtabn gxp`ian jb`bur ijjbrmand tb
tahg br ijjbrmand tb vijjang)
Y. Tlajl bng mb ybu prgfgr inm wly2
(Jb``gjtavg masjussabn inm jlbajg)
[lisg AA ‚ Vbtand bn tlg gntarg jirm {97
jirms} (:; hanutgs)
[rbeg? bn wlit eisas tlgy irg hicand tlgar
jlbajg
Hbmgritbr masp`iys i`` tlg jirms bn
tlg tie`g
Hbmgritbr siys ‐]incs fbr ybur wbnmgrfu`
fggmeijc bn tlg jirms prgsgntgm tb ybu
upta`` nbw. a`` nbw wg wgrg slbwand ybu
magrgnt pirts bf tlg jirms tb dgt spgjajfggmeijc. Nbw A‑m `acg tb prgsgnt tlg
jbhp`gtg jirms tlit livg jbhg an. ]grg
irg vgry magrgnt canms bf gntrags tlit livg
jbhg an. [`gisg ticg i `bbc it tlgsg jirms
‚ ybu livg 97 ‚ 5; hans tb `bbc it i`` bf
tlgh, ybu jin gvgn nbtg mbwn tlands ybu
`acg, i`` ybur tlbudlts tlit ybu irg livand
wla`g vagwand tlg jirms inm tlgn wg‑``
livg i masjussabn‘
Eisgm bn ybur rgvagw bf tlgsg jirms, A
wbu`m `acg ybu tb ini`ysg inm mgjamg
ybur : fivburatg bngs inm wlajl bng ybu
`acgm `gist. Zb tbp : inm ebttbh 9.‘ Qbu
jin nbtg ybur anmavamui` jlbajgs an tlg
pbst an frbnt bf ybu.
Y. ]incs, p`gisg tg`` us (bng ey bng)
iebut tlg jlbajgs ybu livg himg inm
tlg rgisbn fbr tlg sihg. (Hbmgritbr
fija`atitgs eragf masjussabn)
Y. Nbw A wbu`m `acg ybu tb jb``gjtavg`y
masjuss inm vbtg fbr tlg tbp : (rincgm 9st
inm 5nm) inm tlg ebttbh 9 inm tg`` us
wly tlgsg irg ybur jlbajgs2
Bn tlg radlt? Erianstbrhand sgssabn an
prbdrgss fbr g`m duamg jrgitabn .
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 1;
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 49/53
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 15
[rbtbjb` Duamg fbr Egngjairag s
Egngjairags tb antrbmujg tlghsg`vgs is
pgr tlg fb``bwand lgimgrs?
i. Nihg
e. Bjjupitabn (af iny)
j. Nuhegr bf Jla`mrgn
m. Tlb ticgs tlg jla`m fbr ahhunazitabn2
g. Lis ybur jla`m hassgm iny vijjanitabn2
f. Mb ybu jirry i lgi`tl jirm gvgry
tahg ybu ticg ybur jla`m/ jla`mrgn fbr
ahhunazitabn2
d. Tlit canm bf prbe`ghs livg ybu
gxpgragnjgm/fijgm watl tlg prgsgnt lgi`tl
rgjbrm jirm2
[lisg 9 - Jug jirm eisgm ijtavatags?
(i). Wnaqug Amgntajitabn Jug jirms (= Jug
Jirms) (97 hanutgs)
(Hbmgritbr tb gnjburidg in bpgn
masjussabn sb tlit i viragty bf prbe`ghs
gnjbuntgrgm bn g`m jin eg amgntagm)
[rbeg? as tlgrg i/iny nggm tb rganfbrjg
sgjuraty bf unaqug amgntaty2
Yugstabns?
Y. I`` bf ybu livg lim it bng pbant br tlg
btlgr ticgn ybur jla`mrgn fbr i vijjanitabn.
An i`` tlgsg anstinjgs, lis at gvgr lippgngm
tlit tlg INH lis fbunm at maju`t tb
amgntafy ybur jla`m2
Y. Livg ybu fijgm prbe`ghs `acg, tlg
plbtb/wratand dgttand shumdgm br tlit
tlg jirm lis wbrn but tlus hicand at
maju`t fbr tlg INH tb amgntafy tlg
jla`m2
Y. Lbw hiny jla`mrgn mb ybu livg2
Lbw mb ybu hinidg trijcand tlgar
lgi`tl anfbrhitabn2
Irg ybu ie`g tb amgntafy wlajl jirm
eg`bnds tb wlajl jla`m bf ybur fiha`y2
(Lis at gvgr lippgngm tlit ybu livg dbt
jbnfusgm is tb wlajl lgi`tl jirm ybu
livg tb jirry fbr tlg vijjanitabn2)
Y. Af ybu jbu`m hicg bng suddgstabn
tb tlg gxastand jirm tb egttgr amgntafy
ybur jla`m, wlit wbu`m tlit bng
suddgstabn eg2
(Anataitg in bpgn gnmgm masjussabn is
tb wlit tlbsg jlindgs jbu`m pbssae`y
hgin. Fbr gxihp`g, mb tlgy eg`agvg
tlin in immatabni` miti g`m nggms tb
eg immgm2 An jisg nb rgspbnsgs irgrgjgavgm, tlgn furtlgr masjussabns wa``
eg fija`atitgm ey tlg jug jirms tlit wg
slbw an tlas sgjtabn)
Zlbw Jug Jirms.
Tg livg i fgw jug jirms watl us. Tg
wint ybu tb p`gisg livg i `bbc it tlgsg
jug jirms bng ey bng inm tg`` us wlajl
irg tlg twb egst BU jbheanitabn inm bng
tlit ybu tlanc as nbt nggmgm (]g jirms irg
gxp`iangm bng ey bng tb tlg pirtajapints).
(e). Ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g Jug jirms (<
Jug Jirms) (5; hanutgs)
Tg wa`` nbw eg `bbcand it tlg
ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`gs. Tg wbu`m `acg
tb stirt tlas sgjtabn, ey unmgrstinmand tlg
ahpbrtinjg tlit ybu issbjaitg watl tlg
ahhunazitabn jirm.
[rbeg? Gisg bf jbhprglgnsabn inm
unmgrstinmand, unmgrstinm pgrjgavgm
ahpbrtinjg bf tlg ahhunazitabn sjlgmu`g
Y. Mb ybu tlanc ahhunazitabn jirms
lg`p ybu tb rgji`` tlg mug mitg fbr ngxt
vijjanitabn inm cggp i rgjbrm fbr `ist
vijjanitabn2
Fb``bwand tlas masjussabn tlg pirtajapints
wa`` eg slbwn tlg jug jirms bf tlg
ahhunazitabn tie`g. (]g jug jirms tb eg
prbvamgm irg jirms tlit livg prgvabus`y
eggn ``gm ey INHs)
]gsg irg virabus ahhunazitabn tie`gs
an frbnt bf ybu. [`gisg ticg vg hanutgs
an brmgr tb db tlrbudl i`` tlg gntrags. Tg
wint ybu tb sg`gjt bng jug jirm anmavamui``ytlit ybu tlanc as tlg egst jirm, bn tlg eisas
i. [rbvamand anfbrhitabn tlit ybu nggm fbr
ybur jla`m
e. Anfbrhitabn tlit as gisy tb unmgrstinm
Bng ey bng, p`gisg prgsgnt tlg jirm tlit
lis eggn jlbsgn ey ybu (pipgr eisgm
vbtand) inm tg`` us wly ybu tl anc tlg
jirm as egttgr tlin tlg btlgr jirms.
(Fb``bwand tlas ijtavaty, tlg hbmgritbr
lis tb anataitg i masjussabn tb
unmgrstinm wlajl tlg cgy ispgjts bf in
ahhunazitabn tie`g irg.)
(j). Ngw Anfbrhitabn Fag`ms (7 Jug
Jirms) (9; hanutgs)
[rbeg? [rgfgrgnjg inm tlgar
unmgrstinmand bf mitig`ms, besgrvitabn
bf ngw mitig`ms, anfbrhitabn
jbhprglgnsabn
]g hbmgritbr davgs 7 magrgnt jug
jirms, watl magrgnt miti g`ms prgsgnt
an tlgh.
Y. Frbh tlg ngw miti g`ms, wlajl
twb mb ybu tlanc irg hbst ahpbrtint
inm slbu`m eg immgm tb tlg jurrgnt
jirm inm wly2 Zaha`ir`y wlajl irg nbt
ahpbrtint2
(m). Vasui` hgtiplbr (7 Jug Jirms)
(9; hanutgs)
Vasui` hgtiplbr Jug jirms (anj`umgs
drbwtl jlirts inm lgi`tljirg
jbunsg`and anfbrhitabn)
7 Drbwtl jlirts inm
Jbunsg`and Anfbrhitabn
[rbeg? Wnmgrstinm prahiry sburjg bf
rgjgavand lgi`tljirg rg`itgm anfbrhitabn
Y. Af ybu livg iny mbuets rgdirmand
vijjanitabn ticgn br ahpbrtinjg bf
Jbntm...Ippgnmax
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 50/53
tlg vijjanitabn davgn br iebut amgntafyand
tlg syhptbhs bf iny masgisg wlb wa``
ybu isc fbr lg`p (prbeg antb tlg pgrjgavgm
ahpbrtinjg bf tlg INH/IZLI an tlas
rg`itabnslap)
(Bnjg tlg pirtajapints davg tlgar rgspbnsgs,
margjt tlg jbnvgrsitabn antb i masjussabn bn
wlgtlgr tlgrg as i nggm tb livg lgi`tljirg
rg`itgm anfbrhitabn bn tlg jirm atsg`f. Eisgm
upbn rgspbnsgs rgjgavgm, tlg fb``bwand
qugstabns jin eg iscgm)
Zlbw jug jirms bf drbwtl jlirts inm lgi`tljirg jbunsg`and anfbrhitabn
Y. Tlit canm bf anfbrhitabn mb ybu tlanc
nggms tb eg prgsgnt bn tlg
jirm atsg`f2
Y. Frbh tlg magrgnt canms bf jug jirms tlit
ybu sgg, wlajl jug jirm mb ybu tlanc as gisy
tb unmgrstinm2
(Iftgr tlg egngjairags livg dbng tlrbudl
tlg jug jirms isc)
Y. Tlgrg mb ybu tlanc tlas anfbrhitabn
slbu`m eg p`ijgm an tlg jirm2
[lisg AA - Jb``gjtavg vbtand bf tlggntarg jirm?
Jb`br (7 Jug Jirms)
(: hanutgs tb sgg i`` jirms)
(An tlas sgjtabn, viragm jirms wa`` eg slbwn
tb rgspbnmgnts. ]g jirms slbwn wa`` eg i
haxturg bf jirms watl eijcdrbunm jb`br inm
jb`br fbr anfbrhitabn)
[rbeg? ]gsg irg sbhg jirms tlit
livg eggn prgsgntgm inm wg wasl tb
unmgrstinm frbh ybu wlajl bf tlgsg
jb`brs irg egttgr fbr jbnvgyand tlg
ahpbrtinjg bf tlg jirm.
]as wa`` eg fb``bwgm ey i dgngri`azgm
masjussabn bn unmgrstinmand tlg
rgisbns eglanm tlg jlbajgs himg
ey tlgh.
Y.As tlgrg i spgjaj jb`br tlit ybu
issbjaitg watl lgi`tl2
Y. Tlit slbu`m eg tlg jb`br bf i
lgi`tl jirm inm wly2
Hitgrai` & fbrh (7 hanutgs)
[rbeg? Wnmgrstinm bpgnngss tb tlg
usg bf magrgnt hitgrai`s fbr tlg jirm
atsg`f, stbridg, pbrtiea`aty, muriea`aty,
Tg irg `bbcand it hbmafyand magrgnt
sgjtabns bf tlg gxastand lgi`tl jirm3
wg i`sb wasl tb unmgrstinm wlgtlgr
tlg usg bf magrgnt hitgrai`s jin lg`p
hicg tlg jirm egttgr. ]g hbmgritbr
wa`` suddgst hitgrai`s `acg wbbm,
hgti`, p`istaj gtj.
Y. Mb ybu tlanc tlit it prgsgnt tlgrgas i nggm tb jlindg tlg hitgrai` tlit as
usgm tb hicg tlgsg jirms2
Af tlit as rgquargm, wlajl hitgrai`
wbu`m eg tlg egst inm wly2
Vi`ug pgrjgptabn? (95 hanutgs)
Hbmgritbr tb isc anmavamui``y
But bf i`` tlg jirms, af ybu lim i
jlinjg tb ticg bng lbhg, wlajl bng
wbu`m at eg inm wly2
[lisg AAA- Jb``gjtavg Vbtand
[ipgr eisgm vbtand?
Tg dgt tbp 95 jirms frbh INHs inm
wg slbw tlgsg tb tlg egngjairags, isc
tlgh tb sg`gjt tbp :.
Hbmgritbr tb anataitg bpgn gnmgm
masjussabn cggpand an hanm i`` tlg
pirihgtgrs bf tlg jirm
(Eisgm bn bpgn gnmgm masjussabn inm
jb``gjtavg vbtand wg sg`gjt tlg tbp :
frbh tlg egngjairags.)
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 1=
Eg`bw? [`innand bf tlg Fbjus
Drbup Masjussabn (FDM) inm
g`m duamg sjrapt
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 51/53
Ugjruathgnt Uitabni`g fbr Lgi`tl Tbrcgrs
an Ealir, Anmbngsai inm Cgnyi?
Ugjbrms fbr `afg | [idg 16
Jbntm...Ippgnmax
Tg rgjruatgm lgi`tl wbrcgrs watl mavgrsg `atgrijy
`gvg`s, watl mavgrsg hbea`g usidg inm jbvgridg irgis.
Gxpgragnjg
@gvg`
LT 9 LT 5 LT : LT = LT 7 LT 6Lgi`tl
Tbrcgr
9-5 ygirs :-7 ygirs 6-< ygi rs <-9;
ygirs
7-4 ygirs :-7
ygirs
Idg 0:; ygirs
:9 - :7 ygirs
=9 - =7 ygirs
=7 ygirs& iebvg
=9 - =7 ygirs
:9 - :7 ygirs
* I`` tlg lgi`tl bjai`s wa`` eg dbvgrnhgnt
wbrcgrs livand gxpgragnjg an wbrcand watl
ahhunazitabn jirms.
Ugjruathgnt Uitabni`g fbr Egngjairags
an Ealir, Anmbngsai inm Cgnyi?
Tg rgjruatgm egngjairags watl mavgrsg `atgrijy
`gvg`s, fiha`y typg inm nb. bf jla`mrgn.
@atgrijy
Egngf. 9Egngjairags
:9 - =;
ygirs
=9 - =7
ygirs
:9 - =;
ygirs
:9 - :7
ygirsIdg
95tl[iss
95tl[iss
9;tl[iss
Drimuitg Drimuitg/[bstDrimuitg
95tl[iss/Drimuitg
Egngf. 5 Egngf. : Egngf. = Egngf. 7 Egngf. 6
0:;
ygirs
0:;
ygirs
Fiha`y
]ypg
Obant
Fiha`y
Nuj`gir
Fiha`y
Nuj`gir
Fiha`y
Nuj`gir
Fiha`y
Obant
Fiha`y
Obant/
Nuj`gir
Fiha`y
Nb. bf
Jla`mrgn
9-5 5-7 : inm
iebvg
: inm
iebvg 5-7 5 inm
iebvg
Idg bf
Jla`mrgn
;-9
ygirs
9-:
ygirs
9-:
ygirs
5-=
ygirs
5-=
ygirs
: inm
iebvg
* ]g FDM wa`` livg i rgprgsgntitavg hax bf
hbtlgrs inm fitlgrs wlb i rg rgspbnsae`g fbr
ticand tlgar jla`mrgn fbr ahhunazitabns.
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 52/53
]g Jgntgr fbr Cnbw`gmdg Zbjagtags (JCZ) as
nmai‑s `gimand annbvitabn jbnsu`tand rh. JCZ
irtngrs watl magrgnt canms bf jbhpinags tb
bnmujt rgsgirjl inm mgsadn ijtavatags iahgmt ahprbvand gxastand prbmujts inm sgrvajgs
nm jbnjgptui`azand ngw bngs fbjusand bn tlg
nm usgr. ]g jbhpiny lis wamg gxpgragnjg an
nmai, eut lis i`sb wbrcgm an magrgnt ghgrdand
jbnbhags wbr`mwamg anj`umand Zbutl Ifraji,
lani, Nadgrai, [la`appangs, Eind`imgsl inm
nmbngsai. Bvgr tlg `ist tgn ygirs, JCZ lis
brcgm watl nuhgrbus hu`tanitabni` rhs
inm iutlbrgm i sgrags bf rgpbrts. Vijjang
Mg`avgry Annbvitabn Anaitatavg inm := Tiys
tb Zivg @avgs an Uuri` Anmai spbnsbrgm ey
EHDF, gxp`brgs jli``gndgs inm annbvitabnsfbr ahprbvand vijjang mg`avgry sgrvajg inm
hitgrni` inm jla`m lgi`tl an Ealir, Anmai.
Nbcai-spbnsbrgm Hbea`g Mgvg`bphgnt
Ugpbrt gxp`brgs tlg sbjab-gjbnbhaj ahpijt
bf hbea`g plbngs an ruri` irgis an ghgrdand
gjbnbhags.
7/23/2019 RFL Final Report Combined
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/rfl-final-report-combined 53/53