40
1 Timothy J. Prosser Vice President - Institutional Trust Consulting TIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB Retirement Plan Gifts: Retirement Plan Gifts: Better Now or Later? Better Now or Later? Planned Giving Council of Upstate New York July 27, 2010 Rochester, New York C45802

Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

  • Upload
    rit

  • View
    107

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

 

Citation preview

Page 1: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

1

Timothy J. ProsserVice President - Institutional Trust ConsultingTIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB

Retirement Plan Gifts: Retirement Plan Gifts: Better Now or Later?Better Now or Later?

Planned Giving Council of Upstate New YorkJuly 27, 2010Rochester, New York

C45802

Page 2: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

2

BACKGROUND: ASSETS FUNDING CHARITABLE BACKGROUND: ASSETS FUNDING CHARITABLE GIFTSGIFTS

Donor’s Assets

Pass by will or intestacy

(probate)

Pass as titled

(non-probate)

Pass by agreement or contract

(non-probate)

•Assets held in sole name

•Community property

•Joint tenancy with rights of survivorship

•Transfer or payable on

death

•Retirement Accounts

•Revocable Trust

•Life Insurance

Page 3: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

3

• Recent statistics demonstrate continued growth of U.S. retirement plan assets:

• - in dollars

• - as a percentage of household assets

• IRA assets continue to be a large portion of the retirement market

BACKGROUND: IMPORTANCE OF BACKGROUND: IMPORTANCE OF RETIREMENT ASSETS AS GIFT SOURCERETIREMENT ASSETS AS GIFT SOURCE

Page 4: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

4

BACKGROUND: PLAN STATISTICSBACKGROUND: PLAN STATISTICS$16 Trillion in U.S. Retirement Accounts in $16 Trillion in U.S. Retirement Accounts in 20092009

ICI Research Fundamentals, Vol. 19, No. 3, May 2010

Page 5: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

5

BACKGROUND: PLAN STATISTICSBACKGROUND: PLAN STATISTICSRetirement Assets = 35% of Household Assets in Retirement Assets = 35% of Household Assets in 20092009

ICI Research Fundamentals, Vol. 19, No. 3, May 2010

Page 6: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

6

BACKGROUND: PLAN STATISTICS BACKGROUND: PLAN STATISTICS Assets by Plan Type – Year End 2009Assets by Plan Type – Year End 2009

Plan Type Trillions of Dollars

Annuities 1.4

Defined Contribution 4.1

Private Defined Benefit 2.1

Government Pension Plans 4.2

IRA 4.2

Total 16.0

Investment Company Institute, May 2010

IRA assets = 26% of U.S. retirement assets as of 2009

Page 7: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

7

EGTRRA increases in plan funding limits

Required minimum distribution rules

BACKGROUND: RECENT LEGAL DEVELOPMENTSBACKGROUND: RECENT LEGAL DEVELOPMENTS

Page 8: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

8

EGTRRA INCREASES IN PLAN FUNDING LIMITS EGTRRA INCREASES IN PLAN FUNDING LIMITS Traditional IRAsTraditional IRAs

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Contribution Limit

Page 9: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

9

EGTRRA INCREASES IN PLAN FUNDING LIMITSEGTRRA INCREASES IN PLAN FUNDING LIMITSIRA Catch-up ProvisionsIRA Catch-up Provisions

Available to taxpayers aged 50 and older

Accumulate greater amounts for retirement at an accelerated schedule

Contribute catch-up amounts in addition to the regular IRA contribution limits

• $500 (tax years 2002-2005)

• $1,000 (tax years 2006 and thereafter)

Page 10: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

10

EGTRRA INCREASES IN PLAN FUNDING LIMITSEGTRRA INCREASES IN PLAN FUNDING LIMITS401(k), 403(b), and 457 Plan Limits401(k), 403(b), and 457 Plan Limits

$0

$2,000

$4,000

$6,000

$8,000

$10,000

$12,000

$14,000

$16,000

$18,000

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Contribution Limit

Page 11: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

11

EGTRRA INCREASES IN PLAN FUNDING LIMITSEGTRRA INCREASES IN PLAN FUNDING LIMITS401(k), 403(b), and 457 Catch-Up Limits401(k), 403(b), and 457 Catch-Up Limits

2002…………………$1,000

2003…………………$2,000

2004 ………………...$3,000

2005 ………………...$4,000

2006 & thereafter…$5,000 indexed ($5,500 for 2010)

Available to taxpayers aged 50 and older

Page 12: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

12

REQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION RULESREQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION RULES

IRS regulations under Code §401(a)(9) for distributions from a retirement

plan:Lifetime distributions calculated under one Uniform Table for nearly everyone*

“Designated beneficiary” determined as of September 30 of year following year of death (not RBD)

Charitable gifts of retirement assets at death made easier

*RMD Holiday in 2009

Page 13: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

13

BACKGROUND – TESTAMENTARY vs. LIFETIME BACKGROUND – TESTAMENTARY vs. LIFETIME GIFTSGIFTS

Dichotomy of Testamentary vs. Lifetime Gifts

Testamentary Gifts traditionally seen as:

• Easy

• Flexible

• Tax-effective (income and estate taxes)

Lifetime Gifts traditionally seen as:

• Inconvenient

• Irrevocable

• Tax-ineffective (ordinary income and excise taxes)

Page 14: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

14

BACKGROUND – TESTAMENTARY vs. LIFETIME BACKGROUND – TESTAMENTARY vs. LIFETIME GIFTSGIFTS

Rule of Thumb:

Best charitable bequest gift is a retirement plan

• Carries out taxable income, but charity is tax exempt

• Estate tax charitable deduction

• Easy gift to make (beneficiary designation)

• Flexible for donor (retain control during life)

Best lifetime charitable gift is appreciated stock or appreciated real estate

• Fair market value IT deduction

• Avoid capital gain

Page 15: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

15

BACKGROUND – TESTAMENTARY vs. LIFETIME BACKGROUND – TESTAMENTARY vs. LIFETIME GIFTSGIFTS

Rule of Thumb (pt. 2):

Lifetime gifts of retirement assets are not practical since withdrawal from qualified plan or IRA produces taxable income for the donor

Large gifts exceed AGI limits

Non-itemizers recognize income, but get no deduction

Increased AGI from withdrawals reduces other deductions

No direct transfer from qualified retirement plan to charity possible under current law

Limited directed transfer possible from IRA to charity . . .

Page 16: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

16

TODAY’S DISCUSSIONTODAY’S DISCUSSION

Lifetime gifts of retirement plan assets

• Quick overview of IRA “Charitable Rollover”

Testamentary gifts of retirement plan assets

• Donor ConsiderationsTax aspects of retirement plans and gifts to charityPlan-specific issues

• Planned giving techniques for retirement assets

New “income ordering” regs - a trap for the unwary?

Page 17: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

17

EMERGENCY ECONOMIC STABILIZATION ACT EMERGENCY ECONOMIC STABILIZATION ACT Extended Limited IRA Charitable Rollover thru 2009, Extended Limited IRA Charitable Rollover thru 2009, OnlyOnly

IRA charitable rollover extended through 2009, only; (“Public Good IRA Rollover Act,” S. 864 and H.R. 1250, would extend through 2010)

Highlights:

Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCD) excluded from donor’s taxable income

IRA and Roth IRA accounts, only

Up to $100,000 per year per taxpayer

Account owner age 70½ or older on the date of contribution

Distribution directly from IRA account to charity

Page 18: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

18

EMERGENCY ECONOMIC STABILIZATION ACT EMERGENCY ECONOMIC STABILIZATION ACT Extended Limited IRA Charitable Rollover thru Extended Limited IRA Charitable Rollover thru 2009, Only2009, Only

Qualified charitable distributions (QCD) excluded from donor’s taxable income:

To public charity or conduit foundation (§170(b)(1)(A))

• not to donor-advised fund

• not to private foundation (non-operating)

• not to supporting organization

Outright, fully charitable gift, only

• no split-interest gift/no quid pro quo

• donor must obtain written acknowledgement

QCD counts toward donor’s Required Minimum Distribution from IRA Account

Page 19: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

19

WHAT IS THE REQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION?WHAT IS THE REQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION?

Beginning the calendar year following the year in which the participant reaches 70½, must begin to withdraw required minimum distribution (RMD).

RMD = Account Balance divided by distribution period (life expectancy) associated with account holder’s age

Page 20: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

20

WHAT IS THE REQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION?WHAT IS THE REQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION?

Account Owner’s Age

Distribution Period

Account Owner’s Age

Distribution Period

Account Owner’s Age

Distribution Period

70 27.4 80 18.7 90 11.4

71 26.5 81 17.9 91 10.8

72 25.6 82 17.1 92 10.2

73 24.7 83 16.3 93 9.6

74 23.8 84 15.5 94 9.1

75 22.9 85 14.8 95 8.6

76 22 86 14.1 96 8.1

77 21.2 87 13.4 97 7.6

78 20.3 88 12.7 98 7.1

79 19.5 89 12 99 6.7

Uniform Life Table (excerpt)Applies to all unless sole beneficiary is a spouse who is more than 10 years younger.

Treas. Regs. § 1.401(a)(9)-9 Q&A 2.

Page 21: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

21

WHAT IS THE REQUIRED MINIMUM WHAT IS THE REQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION?DISTRIBUTION?

Example #1:

Maria has $500,000 in her IRA account on December 31, 2007. She will be 80 at the end of 2008. She must receive at least $26,738 ($500,000 divided by 18.7 year distribution period for an 80-year-old) during 2008.

Page 22: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

22

WHAT IS THE REQUIRED MINIMUM WHAT IS THE REQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTION?DISTRIBUTION?

Example #2:

Maria has $300,000 in her IRA account on December 31, 2009. She will be 82 at the end of 2010. She must receive at least $17,543 ($300,000 divided by 17.1 year distribution period for an 82-year-old) during 2010.

Page 23: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

23

WHICH DONORS BENEFIT THE MOSTWHICH DONORS BENEFIT THE MOSTFROM IRA CHARITABLE ROLLOVER?FROM IRA CHARITABLE ROLLOVER?

- Donors who do not itemize

- Donors subject to AGI limitations

- Donors who want to make large gifts and don’t have other assets

- Donors who don’t want / need RMD*

-

*CAVEAT: Reduced account values = reduced RMD

Page 24: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

24

TECHNICAL ISSUES – IRS GUIDANCETECHNICAL ISSUES – IRS GUIDANCE

Notice 2007-7; 2007-5 IRB 1 (January 10, 2007):

Inherited IRAs are eligible for QCD, so long as beneficiary is age 70½

QCD to satisfy outstanding pledge is not a prohibited transaction

QCD is not subject to withholding (QCD request is deemed election not to withhold)

2006 Form 1040 Instructions:

Custodian reports all IRA distributions on 1099 to donor & IRS

Donor reports “QCD” and taxable IRA distributions on Form 1040

Page 25: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

25

PARTNERSHIP FOR PHILANTRHOPIC PLANNINGPARTNERSHIP FOR PHILANTRHOPIC PLANNINGRESOURCES ON THE IRA CHARITABLE ROLLOVERRESOURCES ON THE IRA CHARITABLE ROLLOVER

“Charitable IRA Rollover Resource Center” (www.pppnet.org)

Legislation

IRS publications

Commentary and analysis

Survey of IRA Rollover Gifts to Charity

Page 26: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

26

TESTAMENTARY CHARITABLE GIFTS OF RETIREMENT PLAN ASSETS

Page 27: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

27

TAX ON RETIREMENT PLAN ASSETSTAX ON RETIREMENT PLAN ASSETS

Retirement assets (IRAs, qualified plan accounts, tax-deferred annuities) are “Income in Respect of a Decedent” (IRD)

IRD is taxable income to which the decedent was entitled at death but which was not included in any previous income tax return

(Other IRD: wages, accounts receivable, untaxed interest on bonds, etc.)

Page 28: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

28

Retirement assets and other IRD are:

• Included in the decedent’s taxable estate and

• Subject to income tax in the hands of the recipient

Double taxation can reduce assets to beneficiaries by nearly two-thirds (even greater if GST tax)

TAX ON RETIREMENT PLAN ASSETSTAX ON RETIREMENT PLAN ASSETS

Page 29: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

29

Gift of retirement assets to charity can be a solution to double taxation

• Estate tax charitable deduction is unlimited

• Charity is income tax exempt

• (Uncle Sam pays 66¢ of every dollar to charity)

TAX ON RETIREMENT PLAN ASSETSTAX ON RETIREMENT PLAN ASSETS

Page 30: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

30

OUTRIGHT GIFT TO CHARITY AT DEATHOUTRIGHT GIFT TO CHARITY AT DEATH

Beneficiary Designation Form is mechanism for gift (non-probate)*

EXAMPLE #1:

Primary Beneficiary = 100% Charity• Charity receives immediate benefit

• No estate tax on gifted assets

• Charity pays no income tax on gifted assets

* CAVEAT: Election to annuitize benefits can prevent testamentary gift

Page 31: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

31

BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS MECHANISM FOR GIFTMECHANISM FOR GIFT

EXAMPLE #2:

Primary Beneficiary = 50% Charity / 50% Individual

• Charity must be paid by 9/30 of year following decedent’s death, then Individual can stretch distributions over life expectancy

• No estate tax on portion of assets passing to charity

• Charity pays no income tax on gifted assets

Page 32: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

32

BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS MECHANISM FOR GIFTMECHANISM FOR GIFT

EXAMPLE #3:

Primary Beneficiary = 100% Individual

Contingent Beneficiary = 100% Charity

• If individual survives account owner, charity receives nothing

• Charity takes if individual predeceases account owner (or disclaims)

• No estate tax on portion of assets passing to charity

• Charity pays no income tax on gifted assets

Page 33: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

33

BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS MECHANISM FOR GIFTMECHANISM FOR GIFT

EXAMPLE #4:

Primary Beneficiary = 100% Spouse

Contingent Beneficiary = 100% Charity

• No estate tax on assets passing to spouse (marital deduction)

• Spouse can roll over to his/her own IRA, defer distributions until RBD, name own beneficiary (could be charity)

• Charity takes now if spouse predeceases account owner or disclaims

• No estate tax on portion of assets passing to charity

• Charity pays no income tax on gifted assets

Page 34: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

34

BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS MECHANISM FOR GIFTMECHANISM FOR GIFT

EXAMPLE #5:

Primary Beneficiary = Estate (or Trust) 100%/Estate plan leaves all or part to charity

• Problem: IRA is taxable income to estate tax or trust (compressed rates)

• Question: How to pass IRA to charity and avoid income taxation at estate or trust level?

• Answer: Fiduciary income tax charitable deduction if:(1) pay charitable bequest from “gross income,” and(2) do so “pursuant to terms of governing instrument”IRC §642(c)

Page 35: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

35

BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS MECHANISM FOR GIFTMECHANISM FOR GIFT

EXAMPLE #5 (continued):

Fiduciary income tax charitable deduction if:(1) pay charitable bequest from “gross income,” and (2) do so “pursuant to terms of governing instrument”IRC §642(c)

• Document states that retirement assets pass specifically to charity;

OR

• Document leaves residue (or percentage of residue) to charity and states that:

“to the extent possible, gifts to charitable organizations shall be satisfied by distribution of property constituting income in respect of a decedent as defined under §691(a) of the IRC”

Page 36: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

36

BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS MECHANISM FOR GIFTMECHANISM FOR GIFT

EXAMPLE #5 (continued):

WARNING: New proposed Treasury regulations under §642(c) of the Code state that for such an income-ordering provision under an estate or trust to be effective for tax purposes, it must have “economic effect independent of income tax consequences.”

Page 37: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

37

BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS BENEFICIARY DESIGNATION FORM IS MECHANISM FOR GIFTMECHANISM FOR GIFT

EXAMPLE #6 :

Primary Beneficiary = Charitable Remainder Trust

• Estate tax charitable deduction for remainder value of CRT

• CRT can provide for stream of annuity or unitrust payments to desired individual beneficiaries for life (subject to 10% minimum remainder interest rule)

• CRT payments are based on 100% of CRT value (no diminution for income tax)

• All income tax on assets are deferred until CRT payments are distributed

Page 38: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

38

EXAMPLE OF RETIREMENT ASSETS FUNDING CRTEXAMPLE OF RETIREMENT ASSETS FUNDING CRT

Professor Jones names his CRUT as primary beneficiary of $500,000 of retirement assets at his death. The CRUT provides for payments to his daughter for 10 years of 5% of the CRUT’s market value, with the remainder to his favorite charity.

CRUT$500,000

Prof. Jones’ IRA

Estate TaxCharitableDeduction$302,450

1

2

Prof. Jones’ Estate

Daughter

Annual Payments (5% of Trust) ($25,000)

3

Remainder toFavorite Charity

4

These amounts are calculated using 3.2% as the assumed applicable federal rate for purposes of calculating the value of the remainder interest

Page 39: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

39

RETIREMENT ASSETS TO A CRTRETIREMENT ASSETS TO A CRT

Cautions:• Is planner competent in relevant areas of the law?

(Estate tax, Income tax, ERISA, Retirement distributions, and CRTs)

• No marital deduction if non-spouse income beneficiary• No discretionary access to trust property

(Shouldn’t be sole source of family support)• In large estate subject to estate tax, stretch IRA may produce

better tax result (691(c) deduction)

Page 40: Rochester PGC Upstate NY Retirement Plan Gifts   c45802 - 7 27 10 (2)

40

Retirement Plan Gifts:Retirement Plan Gifts:Better Now or Later?Better Now or Later?

TIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB provides trust services. Investment products are not insured by the FDIC; are not deposits or other obligations of TIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB; are not guaranteed by TIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB; and are subject to investment risks, including possible loss of principal invested. Neither TIAA-CREF nor its affiliates provide legal or tax advice. This presentation is for educational purposes only and addresses a complex topic. Because it does not address many of the nuances of estate and tax law - both federal and state - and because these laws are continually being revised, we urge you to seek the advice of your own attorney, tax advisor, or accountant regarding your particular situation. ©2009 TIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB, One Metropolitan Square, 211 North Broadway, St. Louis, Missouri 63102 C45802

Timothy J. ProsserVice President – Institutional Trust ConsultingTIAA-CREF Trust Company, FSB