SCOTUS - Hobby Lobby

8/11/2019 SCOTUS - Hobby Lobby

1/95

"#$%&' ('&)&*)+ (,-(./0 -/012 34"5

$6%%789:

;(-/< =>?@? &A &: B?7:&8%?2 7 :6%%789: #>?7C)*A?+ D&%% 8? @?%?7:?C2 7: &:8?&)E C*)? &) F*))?FA&*) D&A> A>&: F7:?2 7A A>? A&G? A>? *'&)&*) &: &::9?CH->? :6%%789: F*):A&A9A?: )* '7@A *B A>? *'&)&*) *B A>? ,*9@A 89A >7: 8??)'@?'7@?C 86 A>? 0?'*@A?@ *B I?F&:&*): B*@ A>? F*)J?)&?)F? *B A>? @?7C?@H$?? "#$%&' (%)%&*JH+&%,-$% .$/0&, 1 23/0&, 4-56344 KH $H 53"2 55LH

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

$6%%789:

.K0=/MM2 $/,0/-N0O (P Q/NM-Q N;I QK1N;

$/0RS,/$2 /- NMH 7H Q(..O M(..O $-(0/$2 S;,H2

/- NMH

,/0-S(0N0S -( -Q/ K;S-/I $-N-/$ ,(K0- (P NTT/NM$ P(0

-Q/ -/;-Q ,S0,KS-

;*H "5U5VWH N@E9?C 17@F> 3V2 34"WXI?F&C?C Y9)? 542 34"WZ

->? 0?%&E&*9: P@??C*G 0?:A*@7A&*) NFA *B "[[5 #0P0N+ '@*>&8&A: A>?

\]*J?@)G?)A ^B@*G_ :98:A7)A&7%%6 89@C?)^&)E_ 7 '?@:*)`: ?a?@F&:? *B

@?%&E&*) ?J?) &B A>? 89@C?) @?:9%A: B@*G 7 @9%? *B E?)?@7% 7''%&F78&%b

&A6c 9)%?:: A>? ]*J?@)G?)A \C?G*):A@7A?: A>7A 7''%&F7A&*) *B A>?

89@C?) A* A>? '?@:*)X#"+ &: &) B9@A>?@7)F? *B 7 F*G'?%%&)E E*J?@)b

G?)A7% &)A?@?:Ad 7)C #3+ &: A>? %?7:A @?:A@&FA&J? G?7): *B B9@A>?@&)E

A>7A F*G'?%%&)E E*J?@)G?)A7% &)A?@?:AHc W3 KH $H ,H ee344488U"#7+2

#8+H N: 7G?)C?C 86 A>? 0?%&E&*9: M7)C K:? 7)C S):A&A9A&*)7%&f?C

T?@:*): NFA *B 3444 #0MKSTN+2 0P0N F*J?@: \7)6 ?a?@F&:? *B @?%&E&*)2

D>?A>?@ *@ )*A F*G'?%%?C 862 *@ F?)A@7% A*2 7 :6:A?G *B @?%&E&*9: 8?b%&?BHc e3444FFUV#L+#N+H

NA &::9? >?@? 7@? @?E9%7A&*): '@*G9%E7A?C 86 A>? I?'7@AG?)A *B

Q?7%A> 7)C Q9G7) $?@J&F?: #QQ$+ 9)C?@ A>? T7A&?)A T@*A?FA&*) 7)C

NBB*@C78%? ,7@? NFA *B 34"4 #N,N+2 D>&F>2 7: @?%?J7)A >?@?2 @?g9&@?:

:'?F&B&?C ?G'%*6?@:` E@*9' >?7%A> '%7): A* B9@)&:> \'@?J?)A&J? F7@?

7)C :F@??)&)E:c B*@ D*G?) D&A>*9A \7)6 F*:A :>7@&)E @?g9&@?G?)A:2c

W3 KH $H ,H e544EEU"5#7+#W+H ,*)E@?:: C&C )*A :'?F&B6 D>7A A6'?: *B

'@?J?)A&J? F7@? G9:A 8? F*J?@?Cd &A 79A>*@&f?C A>? Q?7%A> 0?:*9@F?:

7)C $?@J&F?: NCG&)&:A@7A&*)2 7 F*G'*)?)A *B QQ$2 A* C?F&C?H 80$'H

;*)?a?G'A ?G'%*6?@: 7@? E?)?@7%%6 @?g9&@?C A* '@*J&C? F*J?@7E? B*@

A>? 34 F*)A@7F?'A&J? G?A>*C: 7''@*J?C 86 A>? P**C 7)C I@9E NCG&)b

XXXXXX

Z-*E?A>?@ D&A> ;*H "5U5Vh2 4-#&*%-9) :--' (;&3,?&==6 (&


2/95

3 .K0=/MM 75Q(..O M(..O $-(0/$2 S;,H

$6%%789:

&:A@7A&*)2 &)F%9C&)E A>? W A>7A G76 >7J? A>? ?BB?FA *B '@?J?)A&)E 7)

7%@?7C6 B?@A&%&f?C ?EE B@*G C?J?%*'&)E 7)6 B9@A>?@ 86 &)>&8&A&)E &A:

7AA7F>G?)A A* A>? 9A?@9:H 0?%&E&*9: ?G'%*6?@:2 :9F> 7: F>9@F>?:2 7@?

?a?G'A B@*G A>&: F*)A@7F?'A&J? G7)C7A?H QQ$ >7: 7%:* ?BB?FA&J?%6

?a?G'A?C @?%&E&*9: )*)'@*B&A *@E7)&f7A&*): D&A> @?%&E&*9: *8i?FA&*):

A* '@*J&C&)E F*J?@7E? B*@ F*)A@7F?'A&J? :?@J&F?:H K)C?@ A>&: 7FF*Gb

G*C7A&*)2 A>? &):9@7)F? &::9?@ G9:A ?aF%9C? F*)A@7F?'A&J? F*J?@7E?

B@*G A>? ?G'%*6?@`: '%7) 7)C '@*J&C? '%7) '7@A&F&'7)A: D&A> :?'7@7A?

'76G?)A: B*@ F*)A@7F?'A&J? :?@J&F?: D&A>*9A &G'*:&)E 7)6 F*:Ab

:>7@&)E @?g9&@?G?)A: *) A>? ?G'%*6?@2 &A: &):9@7)F? '%7)2 *@ &A: ?Gb

'%*6?? 8?)?B&F&7@&?:H

S) A>?:? F7:?:2 A>? *D)?@: *B A>@?? F%*:?%6 >?%C B*@b'@*B&A F*@'*@7b

A&*): >7J? :&)F?@? ,>@&:A&7) 8?%&?B: A>7A %&B? 8?E&): 7A F*)F?'A&*) 7)C

A>7A &A D*9%C J&*%7A? A>?&@ @?%&E&*) A* B7F&%&A7A? 7FF?:: A* F*)A@7F?'A&J?C@9E: *@ C?J&F?: A>7A *'?@7A? 7BA?@ A>7A '*&)AH S) :?'7@7A? 7FA&*):2

A>?6 :9?C QQ$ 7)C *A>?@ B?C?@7% *BB&F&7%: 7)C 7E?)F&?: #F*%%?FA&J?%6

QQ$+ 9)C?@ 0P0N 7)C A>? P@?? /a?@F&:? ,%79:?2 :??j&)E A* ?)i*&)

7''%&F7A&*) *B A>? F*)A@7F?'A&J? G7)C7A? &):*B7@ 7: &A @?g9&@?: A>?G

A* '@*J&C? >?7%A> F*J?@7E? B*@ A>? B*9@ *8i?FA&*)78%? F*)A@7F?'A&J?:H

S) ;*H "5U5Vh2 A>? I&:A@&FA ,*9@A C?)&?C A>? Q7>): 7)C A>?&@ F*G'7b

)6X,*)?:A*E7 =**C $'?F&7%A&?:X7 '@?%&G&)7@6 &)i9)FA&*)H NBB&@Gb

&)E2 A>? ->&@C ,&@F9&A >?%C A>7A 7 B*@b'@*B&A F*@'*@7A&*) F*9%C )*A \?)b

E7E? &) @?%&E&*9: ?a?@F&:?c 9)C?@ 0P0N *@ A>? P&@:A NG?)CG?)A2 7)C

A>7A A>? G7)C7A? &G'*:?C )* @?g9&@?G?)A: *) A>? Q7>): &) A>?&@

'?@:*)7% F7'7F&A6H S) ;*H "5U5VW2 A>? ]@??):2 A>?&@ F>&%C@?)2 7)C

A>?&@ F*G'7)&?:XQ*886 M*886 $A*@?: 7)C 17@C?%XD?@? 7%:* C?)&?C

7 '@?%&G&)7@6 &)i9)FA&*)2 89A A>? -?)A> ,&@F9&A @?J?@:?CH SA >?%C A>7A

A>? ]@??):` 89:&)?::?: 7@? \'?@:*):c 9)C?@ 0P0N2 7)C A>7A A>? F*@b'*@7A&*): >7C ?:A78%&:>?C 7 %&j?%&>**C *B :9FF?:: *) A>?&@ 0P0N F%7&G

8?F79:? A>? F*)A@7F?'A&J? G7)C7A? :98:A7)A&7%%6 89@C?)?C A>?&@ ?ab

?@F&:? *B @?%&E&*) 7)C QQ$ >7C )*A C?G*):A@7A?C 7 F*G'?%%&)E &)A?@b

?:A &) ?)B*@F&)E A>? G7)C7A? 7E7&):A A>?Gd &) A>? 7%A?@)7A&J?2 A>?

F*9@A >?%C A>7A QQ$ >7C )*A '@*J?C A>7A A>? G7)C7A? D7: A>? \%?7:A

@?:A@&FA&J? G?7):c *B B9@A>?@&)E 7 F*G'?%%&)E E*J?@)G?)A7% &)A?@?:AH

B&='< N: 7''%&?C A* F%*:?%6 >?%C F*@'*@7A&*):2 A>? QQ$ @?E9%7A&*): &Gb

'*:&)E A>? F*)A@7F?'A&J? G7)C7A? J&*%7A? 0P0NH T'H "hUW[H

#7+ 0P0N 7''%&?: A* @?E9%7A&*): A>7A E*J?@) A>? 7FA&J&A&?: *B F%*:?%6

>?%C B*@b'@*B&A F*@'*@7A&*): %&j? ,*)?:A*E72 Q*886 M*8862 7)C 17@b

C?%H T'H "hU5"H

#"+ QQ$ 7@E9?: A>7A A>? F*G'7)&?: F7))*A :9? 8?F79:? A>?6 7@?

B*@b'@*B&A F*@'*@7A&*):2 7)C A>7A A>? *D)?@: F7))*A :9? 8?F79:? A>?

@?E9%7A&*): 7''%6 *)%6 A* A>? F*G'7)&?:2 89A A>7A D*9%C %?7J? G?@bF>7)A: D&A> 7 C&BB&F9%A F>*&F?< E&J? 9' A>? @&E>A A* :??j i9C&F&7% '@*A?Fb

A&*) *B A>?&@ @?%&E&*9: %&8?@A6 *@ B*@E* A>? 8?)?B&A: *B *'?@7A&)E 7: F*@b


3/95

5,&A? 7:< VL5 KH $H kkkk #34"W+

$6%%789:

'*@7A&*):H 0P0N`: A?aA :>*D: A>7A ,*)E@?:: C?:&E)?C A>? :A7A9A? A*

'@*J&C? J?@6 8@*7C '@*A?FA&*) B*@ @?%&E&*9: %&8?@A6 7)C C&C )*A &)A?)C

A* '9A G?@F>7)A: A* :9F> 7 F>*&F?H SA ?G'%*6?C A>? B7G&%&7@ %?E7% B&Fb

A&*) *B &)F%9C&)E F*@'*@7A&*): D&A>&) 0P0N`: C?B&)&A&*) *B \'?@:*):2c

89A A>? '9@'*:? *B ?aA?)C&)E @&E>A: A* F*@'*@7A&*): &: A* '@*A?FA A>?

@&E>A: *B '?*'%? 7::*F&7A?C D&A> A>? F*@'*@7A&*)2 &)F%9C&)E :>7@?>*%Cb

?@:2 *BB&F?@:2 7)C ?G'%*6??:H T@*A?FA&)E A>? B@??b?a?@F&:? @&E>A: *B

F%*:?%6 >?%C F*@'*@7A&*): A>9: '@*A?FA: A>? @?%&E&*9: %&8?@A6 *B A>?

>9G7): D>* *D) 7)C F*)A@*% A>?GH T'H "hU"[H

#3+ QQ$ 7)C A>? C&::?)A G7j? :?J?@7% 9)'?@:97:&J? 7@E9G?)A:H

T'H "[U5"H

#&+ ;*A>&)E &) 0P0N :9EE?:A: 7 F*)E@?::&*)7% &)A?)A A* C?'7@A

B@*G A>? I&FA&*)7@6 NFA C?B&)&A&*) *B \'?@:*)2c D>&F> \&)F%9C?^:_ F*@b

'*@7A&*):2 H H H 7: D?%% 7: &)C&J&C97%:Hc " KH $H ,H e"H ->? ,*9@A >7:?)A?@A7&)?C 0P0N 7)C B@??b?a?@F&:? F%7&G: 8@*9E>A 86 )*)'@*B&A F*@b

'*@7A&*):H $??2 &5956 D-#E)=&*JHF 4%,- G*;H,$%) >&A$7A 7 )*)'@*B&A

F*@'*@7A&*) F7) 8? 7 \'?@:*)c 9)C?@ 0P0N ?BB?FA&J?%6 C&:'7AF>?: 7)6

7@E9G?)A A>7A A>? A?@G C*?: )*A @?7F> B*@b'@*B&A F*@'*@7A&*):d )*

F*)F?&J78%? C?B&)&A&*) *B \'?@:*)c &)F%9C?: )7A9@7% '?@:*): 7)C )*)b

'@*B&A F*@'*@7A&*):2 89A )*A B*@b'@*B&A F*@'*@7A&*):H T'H "[U34H

#&&+ QQ$ 7)C A>? C&::?)A )*)?A>?%?:: 7@E9? A>7A 0P0N C*?:

)*A F*J?@ ,*)?:A*E72 Q*886 M*8862 7)C 17@C?% 8?F79:? A>?6 F7))*A

\?a?@F&:? H H H @?%&E&*)Hc ->?6 *BB?@ )* '?@:97:&J? ?a'%7)7A&*) B*@ A>&:

F*)F%9:&*)H ->? F*@'*@7A? B*@G 7%*)? F7))*A ?a'%7&) &A 8?F79:?

0P0N &)C&:'9A78%6 '@*A?FA: )*)'@*B&A F*@'*@7A&*):H N)C A>? '@*B&Ab

G7j&)E *8i?FA&J? *B A>? F*@'*@7A&*): F7))*A ?a'%7&) &A 8?F79:? A>?

,*9@A >7: ?)A?@A7&)?C A>? B@??b?a?@F&:? F%7&G: *B &)C&J&C97%: D>*D?@? 7AA?G'A&)E A* G7j? 7 '@*B&A 7: @?A7&% G?@F>7)A:H >,)3#A&='JH

>,-?#2 5hh KH $H V[[H .9:&)?:: '@7FA&F?: F*G'?%%?C *@ %&G&A?C 86 A>?

A?)?A: *B 7 @?%&E&*9: C*FA@&)? B7%% F*GB*@A78%6 D&A>&) A>? 9)C?@:A7)Cb

&)E *B A>? \?a?@F&:? *B @?%&E&*)c A>7A A>&: ,*9@A :?A *9A &) G/;=-@/%

+$756 +&;%5 -A B3/)# K&*-3,7A B*@b'@*B&A F*@'*@7A&*): 7@? &)F7'78%? *B ?a?@F&:b

&)E @?%&E&*) 8?F79:? A>?&@ '9@'*:? &: :&G'%6 A* G7j? G*)?6 B%&?: &)

A>? B7F? *B G*C?@) F*@'*@7A? %7DH $A7A?:2 &)F%9C&)E A>*:? &) D>&F>

A>? '%7&)A&BB F*@'*@7A&*): D?@? &)F*@'*@7A?C2 79A>*@&f? F*@'*@7A&*):

A* '9@:9? 7)6 %7DB9% '9@'*:? *@ 89:&)?::2 &)F%9C&)E A>? '9@:9&A *B

'@*B&A &) F*)B*@G&A6 D&A> A>? *D)?@: @?%&E&*9: '@&)F&'%?:H T'H 34U3VH

#&&&+ N%:* B%7D?C &: A>? F%7&G A>7A 0P0N *BB?@: )* '@*A?FA&*) 8?b

F79:? &A *)%6 F*C&B&?C '@?b(/$%C P@?? /a?@F&:? ,%79:? '@?F?C?)A:2

)*)? *B D>&F> :g97@?%6 @?F*E)&f?C B@??b?a?@F&:? @&E>A: B*@ B*@b'@*B&A

F*@'*@7A&*):H P&@:A2 )*A>&)E &) 0P0N 7: *@&E&)7%%6 ?)7FA?C :9EE?:A?C

A>7A &A: C?B&)&A&*) *B \?a?@F&:? *B @?%&E&*)c D7: G?7)A A* 8? A&?C A* '@?b


4/95

W .K0=/MM 75Q(..O M(..O $-(0/$2 S;,H

$6%%789:

(/$%C &)A?@'@?A7A&*): *B A>? P&@:A NG?)CG?)AH $?F*)C2 &B 0P0N`:

*@&E&)7% A?aA D?@? )*A F%?7@ ?)*9E>2 A>? 0MKSTN 7G?)CG?)A :9@?%6

C&:'?%: 7)6 C*98A A>7A ,*)E@?:: &)A?)C?C A* :?'7@7A? A>? C?B&)&A&*) *B

A>? '>@7:? B@*G A>7A &) P&@:A NG?)CG?)A F7:? %7DH ->&@C2 A>? '@?b

(/$%CF7:? *B D)==)9C&, JH4,-?# L-*C&, (3;&, M),N&% -A M)**56 8#? Q7>): 7)C ]@??): A* ?)E7E? &) F*)C9FA A>7A:?@&*9:%6 J&*%7A?: A>?&@ :&)F?@? @?%&E&*9: 8?%&?B A>7A %&B? 8?E&): 7A F*)b

F?'A&*)H SB A>?6 7)C A>?&@ F*G'7)&?: @?B9:? A* '@*J&C? F*)A@7F?'A&J?

F*J?@7E?2 A>?6 B7F? :?J?@? ?F*)*G&F F*):?g9?)F?:< 78*9A mWLV G&%%&*)

'?@ 6?7@ B*@ Q*886 M*8862 m55 G&%%&*) '?@ 6?7@ B*@ ,*)?:A*E72 7)C

m"V G&%%&*) '?@ 6?7@ B*@ 17@C?%H N)C &B A>?6 C@*' F*J?@7E? 7%A*E?A>b

?@2 A>?6 F*9%C B7F? '?)7%A&?: *B @*9E>%6 m3h G&%%&*) B*@ Q*886 M*8862

m"Hl G&%%&*) B*@ ,*)?:A*E72 7)C ml442444 B*@ 17@C?%H TH 53H

#3+O/$7A A>? m32444 '?@b?G'%*6??

'?)7%A6 &: %?:: A>7) A>? 7J?@7E? F*:A *B '@*J&C&)E &):9@7)F?2 7)C

A>?@?B*@? A>7A C@*''&)E &):9@7)F? F*J?@7E? ?%&G&)7A?: 7)6 :98:A7)b

A&7% 89@C?) &G'*:?C 86 A>? G7)C7A?H QQ$ >7: )?J?@ 7@E9?C A>&: 7)C

A>? ,*9@A C*?: )*A j)*D &A: '*:&A&*) D&A> @?:'?FA A* A>? 7@E9G?)AH

.9A ?J?) &B A>? ,*9@A @?7F>?C A>? 7@E9G?)A2 &A D*9%C B&)C &A 9)'?@b

:97:&J?< SA &E)*@?: A>? B7FA A>7A A>? '%7&)A&BB: >7J? @?%&E&*9: @?7:*):

B*@ '@*J&C&)E >?7%A>b&):9@7)F? F*J?@7E? B*@ A>?&@ ?G'%*6??:2 7)C &A &:

B7@ B@*G F%?7@ A>7A A>? )?A F*:A A* A>? F*G'7)&?: *B '@*J&C&)E &):9@b


5/95

V,&A? 7:< VL5 KH $H kkkk #34"W+

$6%%789:

7)F? &: G*@? A>7) A>? F*:A *B C@*''&)E A>?&@ &):9@7)F? '%7): 7)C '76b

&)E A>? N,N '?)7%A6H T'H 53U5VH

#5+ QQ$ 7@E9?: A>7A A>? F*))?FA&*) 8?AD??) D>7A A>? *8i?FA&)E

'7@A&?: G9:A C* 7)C A>? ?)C A>7A A>?6 B&)C A* 8? G*@7%%6 D@*)E &: A**

7AA?)97A?C 8?F79:? &A &: A>? ?G'%*6?? D>* D&%% F>**:? A>? F*J?@7E?

7)C F*)A@7F?'A&J? G?A>*C :>? 9:?:H .9A 0P0N`: g9?:A&*) &: D>?A>?@

A>? G7)C7A? &G'*:?: 7 :98:A7)A&7% 89@C?) *) A>? *8i?FA&)E '7@A&?:`

78&%&A6 A* F*)C9FA 89:&)?:: &) 7FF*@C7)F? D&A> %C&$, ,&=$9$-3* 0&=$&A*5

->? 8?%&?B *B A>? Q7>): 7)C ]@??): &G'%&F7A?: 7 C&BB&F9%A 7)C &Gb

'*@A7)A g9?:A&*) *B @?%&E&*) 7)C G*@7% '>&%*:*'>62 )7G?%62 A>? F&@b

F9G:A7)F?: 9)C?@ D>&F> &A &: &GG*@7% B*@ 7 '?@:*) A* '?@B*@G 7) 7FA

A>7A &: &))*F?)A &) &A:?%B 89A A>7A >7: A>? ?BB?FA *B ?)78%&)E *@ B7F&%&b

A7A&)E A>? F*GG&::&*) *B 7) &GG*@7% 7FA 86 7)*A>?@H SA &: )*A B*@ A>?

,*9@A A* :76 A>7A A>? @?%&E&*9: 8?%&?B: *B A>? '%7&)A&BB: 7@? G&:A7j?) *@9)@?7:*)78%?H S) B7FA2 A>&: ,*9@A F*):&C?@?C 7)C @?i?FA?C 7 )?7@%6

&C?)A&F7% 7@E9G?)A &) .C-/)*JH K&7$&? >'5 -A 8#'$)#) G/;=-@/%

(&? ,*9@A`: \)7@@*D B9)FA&*) H H H &: A*

C?A?@G&)?c D>?A>?@ A>? '%7&)A&BB:` 7::?@A?C @?%&E&*9: 8?%&?B @?B%?FA:

\7) >*)?:A F*)J&FA&*)2c $'H2 7A L"h2 7)C A>?@? &: )* C&:'9A? >?@? A>7A &A

C*?:H .$=%-#JH K$? ,*9@A 7::9G?: A>7A A>? &)A?@?:A &) E97@7)A??&)E F*:AbB@??

7FF?:: A* A>? B*9@ F>7%%?)E?C F*)A@7F?'A&J? G?A>*C: &: 7 F*G'?%%&)E

E*J?@)G?)A7% &)A?@?:A2 89A A>? ]*J?@)G?)A >7: B7&%?C A* :>*D A>7A

A>? F*)A@7F?'A&J? G7)C7A? &: A>? %?7:A @?:A@&FA&J? G?7): *B B9@A>?@&)E

A>7A &)A?@?:AH T'H 5lUW[H

#"+ ->? ,*9@A 7::9G?: A>7A A>? &)A?@?:A &) E97@7)A??&)E F*:AbB@??7FF?:: A* A>? B*9@ F>7%%?)E?C F*)A@7F?'A&J? G?A>*C: &: F*G'?%%&)E

D&A>&) A>? G?7)&)E *B 0P0NH T'H 5[UW4H

#3+ ->? ]*J?@)G?)A >7: B7&%?C A* :7A&:B6 0P0N`: %?7:Ab

@?:A@&FA&J?bG?7): :A7)C7@CH QQ$ >7: )*A :>*D) A>7A &A %7Fj: *A>?@

G?7): *B 7F>&?J&)E &A: C?:&@?C E*7% D&A>*9A &G'*:&)E 7 :98:A7)A&7%

89@C?) *) A>? ?a?@F&:? *B @?%&E&*)H ->? ]*J?@)G?)A F*9%C2 &5956 7:b

:9G? A>? F*:A *B '@*J&C&)E A>? B*9@ F*)A@7F?'A&J?: A* D*G?) 9)78%?

A* *8A7&) F*J?@7E? C9? A* A>?&@ ?G'%*6?@:` @?%&E&*9: *8i?FA&*):H (@ &A

F*9%C ?aA?)C A>? 7FF*GG*C7A&*) A>7A QQ$ >7: 7%@?7C6 ?:A78%&:>?C

B*@ @?%&E&*9: )*)'@*B&A *@E7)&f7A&*): A* )*)b'@*B&A ?G'%*6?@: D&A> @?b

%&E&*9: *8i?FA&*): A* A>? F*)A@7F?'A&J? G7)C7A?H ->7A 7FF*GG*C7A&*)

C*?: )*A &G'&)E? *) A>? '%7&)A&BB:` @?%&E&*9: 8?%&?B: A>7A '@*J&C&)E &)b

:9@7)F? F*J?@7E? B*@ A>? F*)A@7F?'A&J?: 7A &::9? >?@? J&*%7A?: A>?&@

@?%&E&*) 7)C &A :A&%% :?@J?: QQ$`: :A7A?C &)A?@?:A:H T'H W4UWVH

#5+ ->&: C?F&:&*) F*)F?@): *)%6 A>? F*)A@7F?'A&J? G7)C7A? 7)C

:>*9%C )*A 8? 9)C?@:A**C A* >*%C A>7A 7%% &):9@7)F?bF*J?@7E? G7)b


6/95

h .K0=/MM 75Q(..O M(..O $-(0/$2 S;,H

$6%%789:

C7A?:2 &5956 B*@ J7FF&)7A&*): *@ 8%**C A@7):B9:&*):2 G9:A )?F?::7@&%6

B7%% &B A>?6 F*)B%&FA D&A> 7) ?G'%*6?@`: @?%&E&*9: 8?%&?B:H ;*@ C*?: &A

'@*J&C? 7 :>&?%C B*@ ?G'%*6?@: D>* G&E>A F%*7j &%%?E7% C&:F@&G&)7A&*)

7: 7 @?%&E&*9: '@7FA&F?H "#$%&' (%)%&*JH 2&&2 WVV KH $H 3V32 D>&F> 9'b

>?%C A>? '76G?)A *B $*F&7% $?F9@&A6 A7a?: C?:'&A? 7) ?G'%*6?@`: @?%&b

E&*9: *8i?FA&*)2 &: )*A 7)7%*E*9:H SA A9@)?C '@&G7@&%6 *) A>? :'?F&7%

'@*8%?G: 7::*F&7A?C D&A> 7 )7A&*)7% :6:A?G *B A7a7A&*)d 7)C &B 2&&

D?@? 7 0P0N F7:?2 A>? B9)C7G?)A7% '*&)A D*9%C :A&%% 8? A>7A A>?@? &:

)* %?:: @?:A@&FA&J? 7%A?@)7A&J? A* A>? F7A?E*@&F7% @?g9&@?G?)A A* '76

A7a?:H Q?@?2 A>?@? &: 7) 7%A?@)7A&J? A* A>? F*)A@7F?'A&J? G7)C7A?H

T'H WVUW[H

;*H "5U5VW2 L35 PH 5C """W2 7BB&@G?Cd ;*H "5U5Vh2 L3W PH 5C 5LL2 @?b

J?@:?C 7)C @?G7)C?CH

NMS-(2 YH2 C?%&J?@?C A>? *'&)&*) *B A>? ,*9@A2 &) D>&F> 0(./0-$2 ,H YH2

7)C $,NMSN2 n/;;/IO2 7)C -Q(1N$2 YYH2 i*&)?CH n/;;/IO2 YH2 B&%?C 7

F*)F9@@&)E *'&)&*)H ]S;$.K0]2 YH2 B&%?C 7 C&::?)A&)E *'&)&*)2 &) D>&F>

$(-(1NO(02 YH2 i*&)?C2 7)C &) D>&F> .0/O/07)C nN]N;2 YYH2 i*&)?C 7:

A* 7%% 89A T7@A SSSU,U"H .0/O/07)C nN]N;2 YYH2 B&%?C 7 C&::?)A&)E *'&)b

&*)H


7/95

"""""""""""""""""

"""""""""""""""""

#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $96?@$A* ?;%) 97%8%98 %) )


8/95

2 W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


9/95

-$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


10/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $9


11/95

+$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


12/95

R W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


13/95

,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


14/95

b W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $93B/ ?;' YJ0V %8

&


15/95

a$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $99/ #-Q-+4M 77/ aQ#3M 8/ 4jRXLVM W%=&; $98&=9F* Z'I%O

D%8') &9 Y'F7 S93B 1D%&%8P 2R

./ 0/ $/ ccR3--1(51-51V51%5M 1%%%55/ @8 %&) \9/ #-Q-+R/ ?;' :'I'=(F

7(=&%') (=' &;' L'7(=&E'8&) 9: YY0M ?='()


16/95

#3 W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


17/95

##$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $99/ #-Q-+4M (& +-j o(%)'= X(E%FH X99=E(8 Y(;8 )&(=&'I ( `99IO`9=e%8P

B


18/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $99/

#-Q-+RM 7/ a4 1D9E7F(%8&5/

V) 'f7F(%8'I %8 $98')&9P(d) B9(=IO(I97&'I k0&(&'E'8&

98 &;' 0(8D&%&H 9: Y


19/95

#-$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


20/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $99/ #-Q-+4M 77/ #-4Q#-+ 1D9E7F(%8&5/

A(D; :(E%FH E'EB'= ;() )%P8'I ( 7F'IP' &9 =


21/95

$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45 #+

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


22/95

#R W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


23/95

#,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


24/95

#b W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9$.3$4 &/&%$,& )4 %=$39 31B30

!3B67. )L1$9& )9 $,-.)/$$&*'f'=D%)' ='F%P%98/ ?;'H I9

89& 7=(HM `9=);%7M 9B)'=G' )(D=(E'8&) 9= &(e' 9&;'=

='F%P%9


25/95

#a$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


26/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $99/ #-Q-+4M (& ,Qb/#a

?;%) D98D'))%98 '::'D&%G'FH I%)7(&D;') (8H (=P'`

Z'f%D9 $9=79=(&%98l5j W=%': :9= X'I'=(F J')798I'8& %8 5)&71170N7>)9M

6/ ?/ 23##M >9/ #3Q++-M 7/ - 1)&(&%8P &;(& &;' 7'&%&%98'= `() (8 k'DDF')%O

()&%D(F D9=79=(&%98l5/23 >9& 98FH I9') &;' \9G'=8E'8& D98D'I' &;(& &;' &'=E k7'=)98)l %8

JXJV %8DF9/ #-Q-+4M (& 2bM 43/
http:///reader/full/corporations.20http:///reader/full/corporations.20http:///reader/full/corporations.20


27/95

2#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


28/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $99/ #-Q-+RM7/ a4/ 0%E%F(=FHM Y9BBH T9BBHd) )&(&'E'8& 9: 7


29/95

2-$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


30/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $9


31/95


32/95

2R W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


33/95

2,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


34/95

2b W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


35/95

2a$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


36/95

-3 W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $99/ #-Q-+4M (& ,QbM `;(& ='()98 %) &;'=' &9 &;%8e &;(&

$98P=')) B'F%'G'I &;(& )79&&%8P %8)%8D'=' DF(%E) `9


37/95

-#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


38/95

-2 W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $99/ #-Q-+4M (& aM 8/ 4M

E(H =')


39/95

--$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


40/95


41/95

-+$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $93B"

hhhhhh

D9E7'8)(&%98 :9= 'E7F9H'')M &;' D9E7(8%') `9


42/95

-R W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


43/95

-,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


44/95

-b W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


45/95

-a$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $99/ #-Q-+4M (& #4Q#+M 4aj

)'' W=%': :9= YY0 %8 >9/ #-Q-+RM (& #3M 4b/ .8I'= 99/ #-Q-+4M (& +3 1%8&'=8(F

K


46/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $9


47/95

4#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


48/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $9


49/95

4-$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


50/95


67%8%98 9: &;' $9


51/95

4+$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


52/95

4R W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


53/95

4,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $93B"j )'' ; C$1%9)M +4R ./ 0/M (& 4-+/

I$$ `() ( :=''O'f'=D%)'M 89& ( JXJVM D()'M B


54/95

4b W.JNATT !"Y6WWS T6WWS 0?6JA0M @>$/

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


55/95

4a$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67%8%98 9: &;' $9


56/95

"""""""""""""""""

"""""""""""""""""

#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

678879:; ?=@AA%?B

SUPREMECOURTOFTHEUNITED STATES

8>)/ #-C-+4 (?D #-C-+E

0:FGHI J.KL7FF; 07$K7MIK: NO P7IFMP

I89 P.QI8 07KGH$70;7M IF/; R7MHMHN87K0

#-C-+4 "#

PNJJ: FNJJ: 0MNK70; H8$/; 7M IF/

N8 LKHM NO $7KMHNKIKH MN MP7 .8HM79 0MIM70 $N.KM

NO IRR7IF0 ONK MP7 M78MP $HK$.HM

I89

$N870MNSI LNN9 0R7$HIFMH70 $NKRNKIMHN8

7M IF/; R7MHMHN87K0

#-C-+E "#

0:FGHI J.KL7FF; 07$K7MIK: NO P7IFMP

I89 P.QI8 07KGH$70;7M IF/

N8 LKHM NO $7KMHNKIKH MN MP7 .8HM79 0MIM70 $N.KM

NO IRR7IF0 ONK MP7 MPHK9 $HK$.HM

TWA%(&'; %? X>%?%?B &Y' $>@A&Z) >W%?[

%>?; &> (DD &Y')' \'] A'V(A^)/ I& &Y' >@&)'& %& )Y>@_D `'

)(%D &Y(& &Y' $>@A&Z) >W%?%>? D>') ?>& Y(a' &Y' `A'(D&Y

(?D )]''W ()=A%`'D &> %& `b &Y' A')W'=&\@_ (?D W>]'A\@_

D%))'?&/ MY' $>@A& (?D &Y' D%))'?& D%)(BA'' >? &Y' WA>W'A

%?&'AWA'&(&%>? >\ &Y' K'_%B%>@) OA''D>V (?D K')&>A(&%>?

I=& >\ #cc- 1KOKI5; `@& D> (BA'' >? &Y' W@AW>)' >\ &Y(&

)&(&@&'/ 42 ./ 0/ $/ d2333`` $% &$'# H& %) &> '?)@A' &Y(&

%?&'A')&) %? A'_%B%>@) \A''D>V (A' WA>&'=&'D/ ()%$; (& +CEe

*+&%; (& fCc 1SH80J.KS; A )&A%a' &> `'_%'a' %? (D%a%?' =A'(&>A (?D ( D%a%?' _(]/ O>A &Y>)' ]Y> =Y>>)' &Y%)


57/95

2 J.KL7FF "#PNJJ: FNJJ: 0MNK70; H8$/

678879:; ?=@AA%?B

=>@A)'; \A'' 'g'A=%)' %) '))'?&%(_ %? WA')'Aa%?B &Y'%A >]?

D%B?%&b (?D %? )&A%a%?B \>A ( )'_\[D'\%?%&%>? )Y(W'D `b &Y'%A

A'_%B%>@) WA'='W&)/ OA'' 'g'A=%)' %? &Y%) )'?)' %VW_%=(&')

V>A' &Y(? X@)& \A''D>V >\ `'_%'\/ 0'' ,-)%.$//a/ ,+))$0%1

203%; -#3 ./ 0/ 2cE; -3- 1#c435/ H& V'(?); &>>; &Y' A%BY&

&> 'gWA')) &Y>)' `'_%'\) (?D &> ')&(`_%)Y >?'Z) A'_%B%>@)

1>A ?>?A'_%B%>@)5 )'_\[D'\%?%&%>? %? &Y' W>_%&%=(_; =%a%=; (?D

'=>?>V%= _%\' >\ >@A _(AB'A =>VV@?%&b/ J@& %? ( =>VW_'g

)>=%'&b (?D (? 'A( >\ W'Aa()%a' B>a'A?V'?&(_ A'B@_(&%>?;

D'\%?%?B &Y' WA>W'A A'(_V \>A \A'' 'g'A=%)' =(? `' D%\\%=@_&/

H? &Y')' =()') &Y' W_(%?&%\\) D''V %& ?'='))(Ab &> 'g'A=%)'

&Y'%A A'_%B%>@) `'_%'\) ]%&Y%? &Y' =>?&'g& >\ &Y'%A >]?=_>)'_b Y'_D; \>A[WA>\%& =>AW>A(&%>?)/ MY'b =_(%V WA>&'=&%>?

@?D'A KOKI; &Y' \'D'A(_ )&(&@&' D%)=@))'D ]%&Y =(A' (?D

%? D'&(%_ %? &Y' $>@A&Z) >W%?%>?/

I) &Y' $>@A& ?>&'); @?D'A >@A WA'='D'?&); KOKI %VW>)')

( h i)&A%?B'?& &')&/Zj ()%$4(& E 1k@>&%?B ,2%5 +6 7+$8)$ a/

9/+8$&; +2# ./ 0/ +3,; +-- 1#cc,55/ MY' S>a'A?V'?& V@)&

D'V>?)&A(&' &Y(& &Y' (WW_%=(&%>? >\ ( )@`)&(?&%(_ `@AD'?

&> ( W'A)>?Z) 'g'A=%)' >\ A'_%B%>? h1#5 %) %? \@A&Y'A(?=' >\ (

=>VW'__%?B B>a'A?V'?&(_ %?&'A')&e (?D 125 %) &Y' _'()&

A')&A%=&%a' V'(?) >\ \@A&Y'A%?B &Y(& =>VW'__%?B B>a'A?[

V'?&(_ %?&'A')&/j d2333``C#1`5/I) &> KOKIZ) \%A)& A'k@%A'V'?&; &Y' 9'W(A&V'?& >\

P'(_&Y (?D P@V(? 0'Aa%=') 1PP05 V(^') &Y' =()' &Y(&

&Y' V(?D(&' )'Aa') &Y' S>a'A?V'?&Z) =>VW'__%?B %?&'A')&

%? WA>a%D%?B %?)@A(?=' =>a'A(B' &Y(& %) ?'='))(Ab &> WA>[

&'=& &Y' Y'(_&Y >\ \'V(_' 'VW_>b''); =>a'A(B' &Y(& %) )%B[

?%\%=(?&_b V>A' =>)&_b &Y(? \>A ( V(_' 'VW_>b''/ ()%$; (&

-ce )''; $#:/; JA%'\ \>A PP0 %? 8>/ #-C-+4; WW/ #4C#+/

MY'A' (A' V(?b V'D%=(_ =>?D%&%>?) \>A ]Y%=Y WA'B?(?=b %)

=>?&A(%?D%=(&'D/ 0''; $#:#; 2;/; (& 4,/ H& %) %VW>A&(?& &>

=>?\%AV &Y(& ( WA'V%)' >\ &Y' $>@A&Z) >W%?%>? %) %&) ()[

)@VW&%>? &Y(& &Y' PP0 A'B@_(&%>? Y'A' (& %))@' \@A&Y'A) (

_'B%&%V(&' (?D =>VW'__%?B %?&'A')& %? &Y' Y'(_&Y >\ \'V(_''VW_>b'')/ ()%$; (& 43/


58/95

-$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

678879:; ?=@AA%?B

J@& &Y' S>a'A?V'?& Y() ?>& V(D' &Y' )'=>?D )Y>]%?B

A'k@%A'D `b KOKI; &Y(& &Y' V'(?) %& @)') &> A'B@_(&' %)

&Y' _'()& A')&A%=&%a' ](b &> \@A&Y'A %&) %?&'A')&/ I) &Y'

$>@A&Z) >W%?%>? 'gW_(%?); &Y' A'=>AD %? &Y')' =()')

)Y>]) &Y(& &Y'A' %) (? 'g%)&%?B; A'=>B?%l'D; ]>A^(`_'; (?D

(_A'(Db[%VW_'V'?&'D \A(V']>A^ &> WA>a%D' =>a'A(B'/ MY(&

\A(V']>A^ %) >?' &Y(& PP0 Y() %&)'_\ D'a%)'D; &Y(& &Y'

W_(%?&%\\) Y(a' ?>& =A%&%=%l'D ]%&Y ( )W'=%\%= >`X'=&%>? &Y(&

Y() `''? =>?)%D'A'D %? D'&(%_ `b &Y' =>@A&) %? &Y%) _%&%B([

&%>?; (?D &Y(& %) _')) A')&A%=&%a' &Y(? &Y' V'(?) =Y(__'?B'D

`b &Y' W_(%?&%\\) %? &Y')' =()')/ ()%$4(& cC#3; (?D ?/ c;

4-C44/MY' V'(?) &Y' S>a'A?V'?& =Y>)' %) &Y' %VW>)%&%>? >\ (

D%A'=& V(?D(&' >? &Y' 'VW_>b'A) %? &Y')' =()')/ ()%$4(&

fCc/ J@& %? >&Y'A %?)&(?=') &Y' S>a'A?V'?& Y() (__>]'D

&Y' )(V' =>?&A(='W&%>? =>a'A(B' %? %))@' Y'A' &> `' WA>[

a%D'D &> 'VW_>b'') >\ ?>?WA>\%& A'_%B%>@) >AB(?%l(&%>?); ()

(? (==>VV>D(&%>? &> &Y' A'_%B%>@) >`X'=&%>?) >\ &Y>)'

'?&%&%')/ 0'' -)%$4 (& cC#3; (?D ?/ c; 4-C44/ MY' (==>V[

V>D(&%>? ]>A^) `b A'k@%A%?B %?)@A(?=' =>VW(?%') &>

=>a'A; ]%&Y>@& =>)& )Y(A%?B; =>?&A(='W&%>? =>a'A(B' \>A

\'V(_' 'VW_>b'') ]Y> ]%)Y %&/ MY(& (==>VV>D(&%>?

'k@(__b \@A&Y'A) &Y' S>a'A?V'?&Z) %?&'A')& `@& D>') ?>&%VW%?B' >? &Y' W_(%?&%\\)Z A'_%B%>@) `'_%'\)/ 0'' -)%$4(& 44/

N? &Y%) A'=>AD (?D () 'gW_(%?'D `b &Y' $>@A&; &Y' S>a[

'A?V'?& Y() ?>& V'& %&) `@AD'? >\ )Y>]%?B &Y(& %& =(??>&

(==>VV>D(&' &Y' W_(%?&%\\)Z )%V%_(A A'_%B%>@) >`X'=&%>?)

@?D'A &Y%) ')&(`_%)Y'D \A(V']>A^/ KOKI %) %?=>?)%)[

&'?& ]%&Y &Y' %?)%)&'?=' >\ (? (B'?=b )@=Y () PP0 >?

D%)&%?B@%)Y%?B `'&]''? D%\\'A'?& A'_%B%>@) `'_%'a'A)m`@A[

D'?%?B >?' ]Y%_' (==>VV>D(&%?B &Y' >&Y'Am]Y'? %&

V(b &A'(& `>&Y 'k@(__b `b >\\'A%?B `>&Y >\ &Y'V &Y' )(V'

(==>VV>D(&%>?/

MY' W(A&%') ]Y> ]'A' &Y' W_(%?&%\\) %? &Y' 9%)&A%=&

$>@A&) (AB@' &Y(& &Y' S>a'A?V'?& =>@_D W(b \>A &Y'V'&Y>D) &Y(& (A' \>@?D >`X'=&%>?(`_'/ JA%'\ \>A K')W>?D[


59/95

4 J.KL7FF "#PNJJ: FNJJ: 0MNK70; H8$/

678879:; ?=@AA%?B

'?&) %? 8>/ #-C-+4; W/ +f/ H? D%)=@))%?B &Y%) (_&'A?(&%a';

&Y' $>@A& D>') ?>& (DDA')) ]Y'&Y'A &Y' WA>W'A A')W>?)' &>

( _'B%&%V(&' =_(%V \>A \A''D>V %? &Y' Y'(_&Y =(A' (A'?( %)

\>A &Y' S>a'A?V'?& &> =A'(&' (? (DD%&%>?(_ WA>BA(V/

()%$4 (& 4#C4-/ MY' $>@A& WA>W'A_b D>') ?>& A')>_a'

]Y'&Y'A >?' \A''D>V )Y>@_D `' WA>&'=&'D `b =A'(&%?B

%?='?&%a') \>A (DD%&%>?(_ B>a'A?V'?& =>?)&A(%?&)/ H? &Y')'

=()'); %& %) &Y' $>@A&Z) @?D'A)&(?D%?B &Y(& (? (==>VV>D([

&%>? V(b `' V(D' &> &Y' 'VW_>b'A) ]%&Y>@& %VW>)%&%>? >\ (

]Y>_' ?'] WA>BA(V >A `@AD'? >? &Y' S>a'A?V'?&/ I) &Y'

$>@A& V(^') =_'(A; &Y%) %) ?>& ( =()' ]Y'A' %& =(? `' ')&(`[

_%)Y'D &Y(& %& %) D%\\%=@_& &> (==>VV>D(&' &Y' B>a'A?V'?&Z)%?&'A')&; (?D %? \(=& &Y' V'=Y(?%)V \>A D>%?B )> %) (_A'(Db

%? W_(='/ ()%$4(& 4-C44/

hTMUY' IV'A%=(? =>VV@?%&b %) &>D(b; () %& _>?B Y()

`''?; ( A%=Y V>)(%= >\ A'_%B%>@) \(%&Y)/j >W'?; )> &>_'A(?&; (?D )> \A'' %) &Y(& ?> W'A)>? V(b `'

A')&A%=&'D >A D'V'(?'D `b B>a'A?V'?& %? 'g'A=%)%?B Y%) >A

Y'A A'_%B%>?/ :'& ?'%&Y'A V(b &Y(& )(V' 'g'A=%)' @?D@_b

A')&A%=& >&Y'A W'A)>?); )@=Y () 'VW_>b''); %? WA>&'=&%?B

&Y'%A >]? %?&'A')&); %?&'A')&) &Y' _(] D''V) =>VW'__%?B/H? &Y')' =()') &Y' V'(?) &> A'=>?=%_' &Y>)' &]> WA%>A%&%')

(A' (& Y(?D %? &Y' 'g%)&%?B (==>VV>D(&%>? &Y' S>a'A?[

V'?& Y() D')%B?'D; %D'?&%\%'D; (?D @)'D \>A =%A=@V)&(?=')

=_>)'_b W(A(__'_ &> &Y>)' WA')'?&'D Y'A'/ KOKI A'k@%A')

&Y' S>a'A?V'?& &> @)' &Y%) _')) A')&A%=&%a' V'(?)/ I) &Y'

$>@A& 'gW_(%?); &Y%) 'g%)&%?B V>D'_; D')%B?'D WA'=%)'_b \>A

&Y%) WA>`_'V; V%BY& ]'__ )@\\%=' &> D%)&%?B@%)Y &Y' %?)&(?&

=()') \A>V V(?b >&Y'A) %? ]Y%=Y %& %) V>A' D%\\%=@_& (?D

'gW'?)%a' &> (==>VV>D(&' ( B>a'A?V'?&(_ WA>BA(V &>

=>@?&_')) A'_%B%>@) =_(%V) `()'D >? (? (__'B'D )&(&@&>Ab

A%BY& >\ \A'' 'g'A=%)'/ ()%$4(& 4+C4E/

O>A &Y')' A'()>?) (?D >&Y'A) W@& \>A&Y `b &Y' $>@A&; HX>%? %&) >W%?%>?/


60/95

"""""""""""""""""

"""""""""""""""""

#$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67809.:6; @\ )&(Z&X%>? YZ'(=&T; &T' $@QZ& T@X=) &T(&

[@UU'Z[%(X '>&'Z]Z%)'); %>[XQ=%>? [@Z]@Z(&%@>); (X@>? S%&T

](Z&>'Z)T%]) (>= )@X' ]Z@]Z%'&@Z)T%]); [(> @]& @Q& @\ (>^

X(S 1)(_%>? @>X^ &(` X(S)5 &T'^ VQ=?' %>[@U](&%YX' S%&T

&T'%Z )%>['Z'X^ T'X= Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\)/ 0'' $%&'( (& #BA4a/

$@U]'XX%>? ?@_'Z>U'>&(X %>&'Z')&) %> Q>%\@ZU [@U]X%(>['

S%&T &T' X(S; (>= =%)(=_(>&(?') &T(& Z'X%?%@>bY()'= @]&b

@Q&) %U]@)' @> @&T'Z); T@X= >@ )S(^; &T' $@QZ& ='[%='); (&

X'()& ST'> &T'Z' %) ( cX')) Z')&Z%[&%_' (X&'Z>(&%_'/d F>=

)Q[T (> (X&'Z>(&%_'; &T' $@QZ& )Q??')&); &T'Z' (XS(^) S%XXY' ST'>'_'Z; %> X%'Q @\ &@XX%>? (> '>&'Z]Z%)' [X(%U%>? (


61/95

2 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; bY()'= '`'U]&%@>; &T' ?@_'Z>U'>&; )"'"(&T' ?'>'Z(X

]QYX%[; [(> ]%[e Q] &T' &(Y/ 0'' $%&'; (& 4#A4-/#

IT' $@QZ& =@') >@& ]Z'&'>= &T(& &T' K%Z)& FU'>=U'>&f)

KZ'' H`'Z[%)' $X(Q)' ='U(>=) Z'X%?%@>bY()'= ([[@UU@=(b

&%@>) )@ '`&Z'U'; \@Z @QZ ='[%)%@>) X'(_' >@ =@QY& @> &T(&

)[@Z'/ 0'' )%*+$; (& BAg/ 7>)&'(=; &T' $@QZ& T@X=) &T(&

$@>?Z')); %> &T' :'X%?%@Q) KZ''=@U :')&@Z(&%@> F[& @\

#aa- 1:K:F5; 42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333YY '& ,'-"; =%[&(&'= &T'

'`&Z(@Z=%>(Z^ Z'X%?%@>bY()'= '`'U]&%@>) &@=(^f) ='[%)%@>

'>=@Z)')/ 7> &T' $@QZ&f) _%'S; :K:F ='U(>=) ([[@UU@b

=(&%@> @\ ( \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>f) Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) >@

U(&&'Z &T' %U]([& &T(& ([[@UU@=(&%@> U(^ T(_' @> &T%Z=](Z&%') ST@ =@ >@& )T(Z' &T' [@Z]@Z(&%@> @S>'Z)f Z'X%?%@Q)

\(%&Ti%> &T')' [()'); &T@Q)(>=) @\ S@U'> 'U]X@^'= Y^

L@YY^ D@YY^ (>= $@>')&@?( @Z =']'>='>&) @\ ]'Z)@>)

&T@)' [@Z]@Z(&%@>) 'U]X@^/ O'Z)Q(='= &T(& $@>?Z'))

'>([&'= :K:F &@ )'Z_' ( \(Z X')) Z(=%[(X ]QZ]@)'; (>=

U%>=\QX @\ &T' T(_@[ &T' $@QZ&f) VQ=?U'>& [(> %>&Z@=Q['; 7

=%))'>&/

7

cIT' (Y%X%&^ @\ S@U'> &@ ](Z&%[%](&' 'jQ(XX^ %> &T'

'[@>@U%[ (>= )@[%(X X%\' @\ &T' 8(&%@> T() Y''> \([%X%&(&'=

Y^ &T'%Z (Y%X%&^ &@ [@>&Z@X &T'%Z Z']Z@=Q[&%_' X%_')/d

./$%%'0 .$+'%&1220 2* 324&1'$,&'+% .$" _/ 5$,'6; +3+

./ 0/ g--; g+B 1#aa25/ $@>?Z')) ([&'= @> &T(& Q>='Z)&(>=b

iiiiii

# IT' $@QZ& %>)%)&) %& T() T'X= >@>' @\ &T')' &T%>?); \@Z (>@&T'Z X'))

Z')&Z%[&%_' (X&'Z>(&%_' %) (& T(>=* '`&'>=%>? (> '`%)&%>? ([[@UU@=(b

&%@>; [QZZ'>&X^ X%U%&'= &@ Z'X%?%@Q) >@>]Z@\%& @Z?(>%k(&%@>); &@ '>[@Ub

]()) [@UU'Z[%(X '>&'Z]Z%)')/ 0'' $%&'( (& -A4/ G%&T &T(& ([[@UU@=(b

&%@> '`&'>='=; &T' $@QZ& ())'Z&); cS@U'> S@QX= )&%XX Y' '>&%&X'= &@ (XX

PK@@= (>= MZQ? F=U%>%)&Z(&%@>Rb(]]Z@_'= [@>&Z([']&%_') S%&T@Q& [@)&

)T(Z%>?/d 7%&'( (& 4/ 7> &T' '>=; T@S'_'Z; &T' $@QZ& %) >@& )@ )QZ'/ 7>

)&(Ze [@>&Z()& &@ &T' $@QZ&f) %>%&%(X 'U]T()%) @> &T%) ([[@UU@=(&%@>; %&

QX&%U(&'X^ ='[X%>') &@ ='[%=' ST'&T'Z &T' T%?TX%?T&'= ([[@UU@=(&%@> %)'_'> X(S\QX/ 0'' $%&'( (& 44 1cG' =@ >@& ='[%=' &@=(^ ST'&T'Z (>

(]]Z@([T @\ &T%) &^]' [@U]X%') S%&T :K:F / / / /d5/


62/95

-$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67809.:6; ; () ](Z& @\ ( >(&%@>S%=' %>)QZ(>[' ]Z@?Z(U

%>&'>='= &@ Y' [@U]Z'T'>)%_'; %& [(XX'= \@Z [@_'Z(?' @\

]Z'_'>&%_' [(Z' Z')]@>)%_' &@ S@U'>f) >''=)/ $(ZZ^%>?

@Q& $@>?Z'))f =%Z'[&%@>; &T' M'](Z&U'>& @\ L'(X&T (>=

LQU(> 0'Z_%[') 1LL05; %> [@>)QX&(&%@> S%&T ]QYX%[ T'(X&T

'`]'Z&); ]Z@UQX?(&'= Z'?QX(&%@>) Z'jQ%Z%>? ?Z@Q] T'(X&T

]X(>) &@ [@_'Z (XX \@ZU) @\ [@>&Z([']&%@> (]]Z@_'= Y^ &T'

K@@= (>= MZQ? F=U%>%)&Z(&%@> 1KMF5/ IT' ?'>')%) @\ &T%)

[@_'Z(?' )T@QX= '>X%?T&'> &T' $@QZ&f) Z')@XQ&%@> @\ &T')'

[()')/

FIT' F\\@Z=(YX' $(Z' F[& 1F$F5; %> %&) %>%&%(X \@ZU; )]'[%b

\%'= &TZ'' [(&'?@Z%') @\ ]Z'_'>&%_' [(Z' &T(& T'(X&T ]X(>)

UQ)& [@_'Z (& >@ (=='= [@)& &@ &T' ]X(> ](Z&%[%](>& @Z

Y'>'\%[%(Z^/2 O(Z&%[QX(Z )'Z_%[') S'Z' &@ Y' Z'[@UU'>='=

Y^ &T' ./ 0/ OZ'_'>&%_' 0'Z_%[') I()e K@Z['; (> %>=']'>=b

'>& ](>'X @\ '`]'Z&)/ IT' )[T'U' T(= ( X(Z?' ?(]; T@Sb

'_'Zl %& X'\& @Q& ]Z'_'>&%_' )'Z_%[') &T(& cU(>^ S@U'>f)

T'(X&T (=_@[(&') (>= U'=%[(X ]Z@\'))%@>(X) Y'X%'_' (Z'

[Z%&%[(XX^ %U]@Z&(>&/d #++ $@>?/ :'[/ 2gg4# 1233a5 1)&(&'b

U'>& @\ 0'>/ 9@`'Z5/ I@ [@ZZ'[& &T%) @_'Z)%?T&; 0'>(&@Z

9(ZY(Z( N%eQX)e% %>&Z@=Q['= &T' G@U'>f) L'(X&T

FU'>=U'>&; ST%[T (=='= &@ &T' F$Ff) U%>%UQU [@_'Z(?'

Z'jQ%Z'U'>&) ( >'S [(&'?@Z^ @\ ]Z'_'>&%_' )'Z_%[') )]'[%\%[

&@ S@U'>f) T'(X&T/

G@U'> ](%= )%?>%\%[(>&X^ U@Z' &T(> U'> \@Z ]Z'_'>&%_'

[(Z'; &T' (U'>=U'>&f) ]Z@]@>'>&) >@&'=l %> \([&; [@)&

iiiiii

2 0'' 42 ./ 0/ $/ h-33??A#-1(51#5A1-5 1?Z@Q] T'(X&T ]X(>) UQ)& ]Z@b

_%=' [@_'Z(?'; S%&T@Q& [@)& )T(Z%>?; \@Z 1#5 ['Z&(%> c'_%='>['bY()'=

%&'U) @Z )'Z_%[')d Z'[@UU'>='= Y^ &T' ./ 0/ OZ'_'>&%_' 0'Z_%[') I()e

K@Z['l 125 %UUQ>%k(&%@>) Z'[@UU'>='= Y^ (> (=_%)@Z^ [@UU%&&'' @\ &T'

$'>&'Z) \@Z M%)'()' $@>&Z@X (>= OZ'_'>&%@>l (>= 1-5 cS%&T Z')]'[& &@

%>\(>&); [T%X=Z'>; (>= (=@X')['>&); '_%='>['b%>\@ZU'= ]Z'_'>&%_' [(Z'(>= )[Z''>%>?) ]Z@_%='= \@Z %> &T' [@U]Z'T'>)%_' ?Q%='X%>') )Q]]@Z&'=

Y^ &T' L'(X&T :')@QZ[') (>= 0'Z_%[') F=U%>%)&Z(&%@>d5/


63/95

4 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; ^ S@U'> \Z@U @Y&(%>%>?

>''='= [(Z' (& (XX/ 0''; '"8"( )0"( (& 2a3,3 1)&(&'U'>& @\

0'>/ K'%>)&'%>5 1cG@U'> @\ [T%X=Y'(Z%>? (?' )]'>= Bg

]'Z['>& U@Z' %> @Q&b@\b]@[e'& T'(X&T [(Z' [@)&) &T(>

U'>/d5l )0"( (& 2a-32 1)&(&'U'>& @\ 0'>/ N%eQX)e%5 1c[@b

](^U'>&) (Z' P@\&'>R )@ T%?T &T(& PS@U'>R (_@%= ?'&&%>?

P]Z'_'>&%_' (>= )[Z''>%>? )'Z_%[')R %> &T' \%Z)& ]X(['d5/

F>= %>[Z'()'= ([[')) &@ [@>&Z([']&%_' )'Z_%['); &T' )]@>b

)@Z) [@U]Z'T'>='=; S@QX= ^%'X= %U]@Z&(>& ]QYX%[ T'(X&T

?(%>)/ 0''; '"8"( )0"((& 2a,Bg 1)&(&'U'>& @\ 0'>/ MQZY%>5

1cIT%) Y%XX S%XX '`](>= T'(X&T %>)QZ(>[' [@_'Z(?' &@ &T'

_()& U(V@Z%&^ @\ P&T' #, U%XX%@> S@U'> @\ Z']Z@=Q[&%_' (?'%> &T' .>%&'= 0&(&') ST@ (Z' Q>%>)QZ'=R / / / / IT%) '`b

](>='= ([[')) S%XX Z'=Q[' Q>%>&'>='= ]Z'?>(>[%')/d5/

F) (X&'Z'= Y^ &T' G@U'>f) L'(X&T FU'>=U'>&f) ]()b

)(?'; &T' F$F Z'jQ%Z') >'S %>)QZ(>[' ]X(>) &@ %>[XQ='

[@_'Z(?' S%&T@Q& [@)& )T(Z%>? @\ c)Q[T (==%&%@>(X ]Z'_'>b

&%_' [(Z' (>= )[Z''>%>?) / / / () ]Z@_%='= \@Z %> [@U]Z'T'>b

)%_' ?Q%='X%>') )Q]]@Z&'= Y^ &T' L'(X&T :')@QZ[') (>=

0'Z_%[') F=U%>%)&Z(&%@> P1L:0F5R;d ( Q>%& @\ LL0/ 42

./ 0/ $/ h-33??A#-1(5145/ ITQ) [T(Z?'=; &T' L:0F ='_'Xb

@]'= Z'[@UU'>=(&%@>) %> [@>)QX&(&%@> S%&T &T' 7>)&%&Q&'

@\ N'=%[%>' 17JN5/ 0'' ,, K'=/ :'?/ g,2+Ag,2B 123#25/-

IT' 7JN [@>_'>'= ( ?Z@Q] @\ %>=']'>='>& '`]'Z&); %>[XQ=b

%>? c)]'[%(X%)&) %> =%)'()' ]Z'_'>&%@> P(>=R S@U'>f)

T'(X&Tdl &T@)' '`]'Z&) ]Z'](Z'= ( Z']@Z& '_(XQ(&%>? &T'

'\\%[([^ @\ ( >QUY'Z @\ ]Z'_'>&%_' )'Z_%[')/ 7JN; $X%>%[(X

OZ'_'>&%@> 0'Z_%[') \@Z G@U'>* $X@)%>? &T' 6(]) 2 123##5

1T'Z'%>(\&'Z 7JN :']@Z&5/ $@>)%)&'>& S%&T &T' \%>=%>?) @\

cP>RQU'Z@Q) T'(X&T ]Z@\'))%@>(X ())@[%(&%@>)d (>= @&T'Z

@Z?(>%k(&%@>); &T' 7JN '`]'Z&) ='&'ZU%>'= &T(& ]Z'_'>b

iiiiii

- IT' 7JN %) (> (ZU @\ &T' 8(&%@>(X F[(='U^ @\ 0[%'>['); (> @Z?(>%b

k(&%@> $@>?Z')) ')&(YX%)T'= c\@Z &T' '`]X%[%& ]QZ]@)' @\ \QZ>%)T%>?(=_%[' &@ &T' 6@_'Z>U'>&/d .49/): 5)&);'% _/ (X jQ@&(&%@> U(Ze) @U%&&'=5/


64/95

+$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67809.:6; [XQ=' &T' c\QXX Z(>?'d @\ KMFb

(]]Z@_'= [@>&Z([']&%_' U'&T@=)/ @0"((& #3/ 0'' (X)@ )0"(

(& #32A##3/

7> U(e%>? &T(& Z'[@UU'>=(&%@>; &T' 7JNf) Z']@Z&

'`]Z'))'= [@>['Z>) )%U%X(Z &@ &T@)' _@%['= Y^ [@>?Z')b

)%@>(X ]Z@]@>'>&) @\ &T' G@U'>f) L'(X&T FU'>=U'>&/ IT'

Z']@Z& >@&'= &T' =%)]Z@]@Z&%@>(&' YQZ='> S@U'> [(ZZ%'=

\@Z [@U]Z'T'>)%_' T'(X&T )'Z_%[') (>= &T' (=_'Z)' T'(X&T

[@>)'jQ'>[') @\ '`[XQ=%>? [@>&Z([']&%@> \Z@U ]Z'_'>&%_'

[(Z' (_(%X(YX' &@ 'U]X@^'') S%&T@Q& [@)& )T(Z%>?/ 0'';

'"8"( )0"((& #a 1cPGR@U'> (Z' [@>)%)&'>&X^ U@Z' X%e'X^ &T(>

U'> &@ Z']@Z& ( S%=' Z(>?' @\ [@)&bZ'X(&'= Y(ZZ%'Z) &@Z'['%_%>? / / / U'=%[(X &')&) (>= &Z'(&U'>&) (>= &@ \%XX%>?

]Z')[Z%]&%@>) \@Z &T'U)'X_') (>= &T'%Z \(U%X%')/d5l )0"( (&

#3-A#34; #3, 1]Z'?>(>[^ U(^ Y' [@>&Z(%>=%[(&'= \@Z

S@U'> S%&T ['Z&(%> U'=%[(X [@>=%&%@>); \@Z '`(U]X'; )@U'

[@>?'>%&(X T'(Z& =%)'()'); ]QXU@>(Z^ T^]'Z&'>)%@>; (>=

N(Z\(> )^>=Z@U'; (>= [@>&Z([']&%_') U(^ Y' Q)'= &@

Z'=Q[' Z%)e @\ '>=@U'&Z%(X [(>['Z; (U@>? @&T'Z )'Z%@Q)

U'=%[(X [@>=%&%@>)5l )0/; (& #3- 1S@U'> S%&T Q>%>&'>='=

]Z'?>(>[%') (Z' U@Z' X%e'X^ &@ '`]'Z%'>[' =']Z'))%@> (>=

(>`%'&^; (>= &T'%Z [T%X=Z'> \([' c%>[Z'()'= @==) @\ ]Z'&'ZU

Y%Z&T (>= X@S Y%Z&T S'%?T&d5/7> X%>' S%&T &T' 7JNf) )Q??')&%@>); &T' L:0F (=@]&'=

?Q%='X%>') Z'[@UU'>=%>? [@_'Z(?' @\ cP(RXX PKMFbR

(]]Z@_'= [@>&Z([']&%_' U'&T@=); )&'Z%X%k(&%@> ]Z@['=QZ');

(>= ](&%'>& '=Q[(&%@> (>= [@Q>)'X%>? \@Z (XX S@U'> S%&T

Z']Z@=Q[&%_' [(]([%&^/d4 IT'Z'(\&'Z; LL0; &T' M'](Z&b

U'>& @\ D(Y@Z; (>= &T' M'](Z&U'>& @\ IZ'()QZ^ ]Z@UQXb

?(&'= Z'?QX(&%@>) Z'jQ%Z%>? ?Z@Q] T'(X&T ]X(>) &@ %>[XQ='

[@_'Z(?' @\ &T' [@>&Z([']&%_' )'Z_%[') Z'[@UU'>='= %> &T'

iiiiii

4 L:0F; LL0; G@U'>f) OZ'_'>&%_' 0'Z_%[') 6Q%='X%>'); (_(%X(YX' (&

T&&]*mmSSS/TZ)(/?@_mS@U'>)?Q%='X%>') m 1(XX 7>&'Z>'& U(&'Z%(X) ()

_%)%&'= ' 2,; 23#4; (>= (_(%X(YX' %> $X'Ze @\ $@QZ&f) [()' \%X'5;Z']Z%>&'= %> F]]/ &@ 9Z%'\ \@Z O'&%&%@>'Z) %> 8@/ #-A-+4; ]]/ 4-A44(/

0'' (X)@ ,, K'=/ :'?/ g,2+Ag,2B 123#25/
http://www.hrsa.gov/womensguidelineshttp://www.hrsa.gov/womensguidelines


65/95

B 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; '); )QYV'[& &@ ['Z&(%> '`[']&%@>); =')[Z%Y'=

)%*+$; (& 2+A2,/+ IT%) @]%>%@> Z'\'Z) &@ &T')' Z'?QX(&%@>)

() &T' [@>&Z([']&%_' [@_'Z(?' Z'jQ%Z'U'>&/

9

GT%X' &T' G@U'>f) L'(X&T FU'>=U'>& )Q[[''='=; (

[@Q>&'ZU@_' ]Z@_'= Q>(_(%X%>?/ IT' 0'>(&' _@&'= =@S>

&T' )@b[(XX'= c[@>)[%'>[' (U'>=U'>&;d ST%[T S@QX= T(_'

'>(YX'= (>^ 'U]X@^'Z @Z %>)QZ(>[' ]Z@_%='Z &@ ='>^ [@_b

'Z(?' Y()'= @> %&) ())'Z&'= cZ'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) @Z U@Z(X

[@>_%[&%@>)/d #+g $@>?/ :'[/ 0+-a 1K'Y/ a; 23#25l )'' )0"(

(& 0##B2A0##,- 1N(Z/ #; 23#25 1='Y(&' (>= _@&'5/B IT(&(U'>=U'>&; 0'>(&@Z N%eQX)e% @Y)'Z_'=; S@QX= T(_' c]QP&R

&T' ]'Z)@>(X @]%>%@> @\ 'U]X@^'Z) (>= %>)QZ'Z) @_'Z &T'

]Z([&%[' @\ U'=%[%>'/d @0"( (& 0##2, 1K'Y/ 2a; 23#25/ :'b

V'[&%>? &T' c[@>)[%'>[' (U'>=U'>&;d $@>?Z')) X'\& T'(X&T

[(Z' ='[%)%@>)i%>[XQ=%>? &T' [T@%[' (U@>? [@>&Z([']&%_'

U'&T@=)i%> &T' T(>=) @\ S@U'>; S%&T &T' (%= @\ &T'%Z

T'(X&T [(Z' ]Z@_%='Z)/

77

F>^ K%Z)& FU'>=U'>& KZ'' H`'Z[%)' $X(Q)' [X(%U L@YY^

D@YY^ @Z $@>')&@?(, U%?T& ())'Z& %) \@Z'[X@)'= Y^ &T%)

$@QZ&f) ='[%)%@> %> A>=/26>'%& $%C',24+:', 2* D+'"_/ 3>)&1; 4a4 ./ 0/ g,2 1#aa35/ 7> 3>)&1;

&S@ U'UY'Z) @\ &T' 8(&%_' FU'Z%[(> $TQZ[T S'Z' =%)biiiiii

+ 4+ $K: h#4,/#-31(51#51%_5 123#-5 1LL05l 2a $K: h2+a3/,#+A

2,#-1(51#51%_5 123#-5 1D(Y@Z5l 2B $K: h+4/ag#+A2,#-1(51#51%_5 123#-5

1IZ'()QZ^5/B 0'](Z(&%>? U@Z(X [@>_%[&%@>) \Z@U Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) S@QX= Y' @\ jQ')b

&%@>(YX' X'?%&%U([^/ 0'' E'/,1_/ F%)&'0 3&$&',; -ag ./ 0/ ---; -+,A-+g

1#a,35 1L(ZX(>; [QZZ%>? %> Z')QX&5/,F) &T' $@QZ& '`]X(%>); )'' $%&'( (& ##A#B; &T')' [()') (Z%)' \Z@U &S@

)'](Z(&' X(S)Q%&); @>' \%X'= Y^ L@YY^ D@YY^; %&) (\\%X%(&'= YQ)%>'))

1N(Z='X5; (>= &T' $U%X^ &T(& @]'Z(&') &T')' YQ)%>'))') 1&T' 6Z''>)5l

&T' @&T'Z \%X'= Y^ $@>')&@?( (>= &T' \(U%X^ &T(& @S>) (>= [@>&Z@X) &T(&YQ)%>')) 1&T' L(T>)5/ .>X')) @&T'ZS%)' )]'[%\%'=; &T%) @]%>%@> Z'\'Z) &@

&T' Z')]'[&%_' ?Z@Q]) @\ ]X(%>&%\$ () L@YY^ D@YY^ (>= $@>')&@?(/


66/95

,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67809.:6; %'= Q>'U]X@^U'>& Y'>'\%&)

Y'[(Q)' &T'^ %>?')&'= ]'^@&' (&; (>= () (> '))'>&%(X 'X'b

U'>& @\; ( Z'X%?%@Q) ['Z'U@>^/ JZ'?@> X(S \@ZY(=' &T'

[@>)QU]&%@> @\ ]'^@&'; (>= &T%) $@QZ&; Z'X^%>? @> &T(&

]Z@T%Y%&%@>; Z'V'[&'= &T' 'U]X@^'')f [X(%U &T(& &T' ='>%(X

@\ Q>'U]X@^U'>& Y'>'\%&) _%@X(&'= &T'%Z \Z'' '`'Z[%)'

Z%?T&)/ IT' K%Z)& FU'>=U'>& %) >@& @\\'>='=; 3>)&1 T'X=;

ST'> c]Z@T%Y%&%>? &T' '`'Z[%)' @\ Z'X%?%@> / / / %) >@& &T'

@YV'[& @\ P?@_'Z>U'>&(X Z'?QX(&%@>R YQ& U'Z'X^ &T' %>[%b

='>&(X '\\'[& @\ ( ?'>'Z(XX^ (]]X%[(YX' (>= @&T'ZS%)' _(X%=

]Z@_%)%@>/d @0"( (& g,gl )'' )0"( (& g,gAg,a 1c(> %>=%_%=b

Q(Xf) Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) P=@ >@&R '`[Q)' T%U \Z@U [@U]X%(>['S%&T (> @&T'ZS%)' _(X%= X(S ]Z@T%Y%&%>? [@>=Q[& &T(& &T'

0&(&' %) \Z'' &@ Z'?QX(&'d5/ IT' F$Ff) [@>&Z([']&%_' [@_'Zb

(?' Z'jQ%Z'U'>& (]]X%') ?'>'Z(XX^; %& %) c@&T'ZS%)' _(X%=;d

%& &Z(%>) @> S@U'>f) S'XX Y'%>?; >@& @> &T' '`'Z[%)'

@\ Z'X%?%@>; (>= (>^ '\\'[& %& T() @> )Q[T '`'Z[%)' %)

%>[%='>&(X/

H_'> %\ 3>)&1=%= >@& [@>&Z@X; &T' KZ'' H`'Z[%)' $X(Q)'

S@QX= >@& Z'jQ%Z' &T' '`'U]&%@> L@YY^ D@YY^ (>= $@>')b

&@?( )''e/ F[[@UU@=(&%@>) &@ Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) @Z @Y)'Zb

_(>['); &T' $@QZ& T() [X(Z%\%'=; UQ)& >@& )%?>%\%[(>&X^

%U]%>?' @> &T' %>&'Z')&) @\ &T%Z= ](Z&%')/g

iiiiii

g 0'' E),:2%,)% _/ G20'+; 43B ./ 0/ 23+; 2-3 1#a,25 1cIT%) [()'; @\

[@QZ)'; %) >@& @>' %> ST%[T (>^ T(ZU &@ &T' ]T^)%[(X @Z U'>&(X T'(X&T @\

&T' [T%X= @Z &@ &T' ]QYX%[ )(\'&^; ]'(['; @Z='Z; @Z S'X\(Z' T() Y''>

='U@>)&Z(&'= @Z U(^ Y' ]Z@]'ZX^ %>\'ZZ'=/d5l A,&$&' 2* H12+%&2% _/

5$/02+( @%:"; 4,2 ./ 0/ ,3- 1#ag+5 1%>_(X%=(&%>? )&(&' )&(&Q&' Z'jQ%Z%>?

'U]X@^'Z) &@ ([[@UU@=(&' (> 'U]X@^''f) 0(YY(&T @Y)'Z_(>[' ST'Z'

&T(& )&(&Q&' \(%X'= &@ &(e' %>&@ ([[@Q>& &T' YQZ='> )Q[T (> ([[@UU@=(b

&%@> S@QX= %U]@)' @> &T' 'U]X@^'Z @Z @&T'Z 'U]X@^'')5/ 8@&(YX^; %>

[@>)&ZQ%>? &T' :'X%?%@Q) D(>= .)' (>= 7>)&%&Q&%@>(X%k'= O'Z)@>) F[& @\

2333 1:D.7OF5; 42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333[[ '& ,'-"( &T' $@QZ& T() [(Q&%@>'=

&T(& c(='jQ(&' ([[@Q>&d UQ)& Y' &(e'> @\ c&T' YQZ='>) ( Z'jQ')&'=

([[@UU@=(&%@> U(^ %U]@)' @> >@>Y'>'\%[%(Z%')/d 54&&'+_/ E)/I)%,2%;+44 ./ 0/ ,3a; ,23 1233+5l )'' )0"((& ,22 1c(> ([[@UU@=(&%@> UQ)& Y'

U'()QZ'= )@ &T(& %& =@') >@& @_'ZZ%=' @&T'Z )%?>%\%[(>& %>&'Z')&)d5/ F


67/95

g 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; )@Q?T& Y^ L@YY^ D@YY^ (>= $@>')&@?(

S@QX= @_'ZZ%=' )%?>%\%[(>& %>&'Z')&) @\ &T' [@Z]@Z(&%@>)f

'U]X@^'') (>= [@_'Z'= =']'>='>&)/ 7& S@QX= ='>^ X'?%@>)

@\ S@U'> ST@ =@ >@& T@X= &T'%Z 'U]X@^'Z)f Y'X%'\) ([['))

&@ [@>&Z([']&%_' [@_'Z(?' &T(& &T' F$F S@QX= @&T'ZS%)'

)'[QZ'/ 0'' 5$&12/): 51$+)&)', 2* 3$:+$>'%&2( @%:" _/

34='+)2+ 524+&; -2 $(X/ 4&T +2,; +B+; g+ O/ -= B,; a-

123345 1cG' (Z' Q>(S(Z' @\ (>^ ='[%)%@> %> ST%[T / / / P&T'

./ 0/ 0Q]Z'U' $@QZ&R T() '`'U]&'= ( Z'X%?%@Q) @YV'[&@Z

\Z@U &T' @]'Z(&%@> @\ ( >'Q&Z(X; ?'>'Z(XX^ (]]X%[(YX' X(S

=')]%&' &T' Z'[@?>%&%@> &T(& &T' Z'jQ')&'= '`'U]&%@>

S@QX= ='&Z%U'>&(XX^ (\\'[& &T' Z%?T&) @\ &T%Z= ](Z&%')/d5/ 7>)QU; S%&T Z')]'[& &@ \Z'' '`'Z[%)' [X(%U) >@ X')) &T(> \Z''

)]''[T [X(%U); cnP^R@QZ Z%?T& &@ )S%>? ^@QZ (ZU) '>=) VQ)&

ST'Z' &T' @&T'Z U(>f) >@)' Y'?%>)/fd $T(\''; KZ''=@U @\

0]''[T %> G(Z I%U'; -2 L(Z_/ D/ :'_/ a-2; a+, 1#a#a5/

777

F

D([e%>? ( &'>(YX' [X(%U Q>='Z &T' KZ'' H`'Z[%)' $X(Q)';

L@YY^ D@YY^ (>= $@>')&@?( Z'X^ @> :K:F; ( )&(&Q&'

%>)&ZQ[&%>? &T(& cP?R@_'Z>U'>& )T(XX >@& )QY)&(>&%(XX^

YQZ='> ( ]'Z)@>f) '`'Z[%)' @\ Z'X%?%@> '_'> %\ &T' YQZ='>

Z')QX&) \Z@U ( ZQX' @\ ?'>'Z(X (]]X%[(Y%X%&^d Q>X')) &T'

?@_'Z>U'>& )T@S) &T(& (]]X%[(&%@> @\ &T' YQZ='> %) c&T'

X'()& Z')&Z%[&%_' U'(>)d &@ \QZ&T'Z ( c[@U]'XX%>? ?@_'Z>b

U'>&(X %>&'Z')&/d 42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333YYA#1(5; 1Y5125/ 7>

:K:F; $@>?Z')) c(=@]&P'=R ( )&(&Q&@Z^ ZQX' [@U](Z(YX' &@

&T' [@>)&%&Q&%@>(X ZQX' Z'V'[&'= %> 3>)&1/d J2%;$/',_/ D

5'%&+2 A,=K+)&$ L'%'*):'%&' F%)M2 02 N'8'&$/; +4B ./ 0/

4#g; 424 1233B5/

:K:Ff) ]QZ]@)' %) )]'[%\%[ (>= SZ%&&'> %>&@ &T' )&(&Q&'

%&)'X\/ IT' F[& S() [Z(\&'= &@ cZ')&@Z' &T' [@U]'XX%>?iiiiii

Y(X(>['= (]]Z@([T %) (XX &T' U@Z' %> @Z='Z ST'> &T' KZ'' H`'Z[%)'$X(Q)' %&)'X\ %) (& )&(e'; >@& ( )&(&Q&' =')%?>'= &@ ]Z@U@&' ([[@UU@=(b

&%@> &@ Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) (>= ]Z([&%[')/


68/95

a$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67809.:6; = &@ ?Q(Z(>&'' %&) (]]X%[(&%@> %> (XX [()') ST'Z'

\Z'' '`'Z[%)' @\ Z'X%?%@> %) )QY)&(>&%(XX^ YQZ='>'=/d

h2333YY1Y51#5/a 0'' (X)@ h2333YY1(51+5 1cPIRT' [@U]'XX%>?

%>&'Z')& &')& () )'& \@Z&T %> ]Z%@Z K'='Z(X [@QZ& ZQX%>?) %)

( S@Ze(YX' &')& \@Z )&Z%e%>? )'>)%YX' Y(X(>[') Y'&S''>

Z'X%?%@Q) X%Y'Z&^ (>= [@U]'&%>? ]Z%@Z ?@_'Z>U'>&(X %>b

&'Z')&)/d5l $%&'((& 4g 1(?Z''%>? &T(& &T' ]Z'b3>)&1 [@U]'Xb

X%>? %>&'Z')& &')& %) cS@Ze(YX'd (>= c)&Z%e'P)R )'>)%YX'

Y(X(>[')d5/

IT' X'?%)X(&%_' T%)&@Z^ %) [@ZZ')]@>=%>?X^ 'U]T(&%[ @>:K:Ff) (%U/ 0''; '"8"(0/ :']/ 8@/ #3-A###; ]/ #2 1#aa-5

1T'Z'%>(\&'Z 0'>(&' :']@Z&5 1:K:Ff) ]QZ]@)' S() c@>X^ &@

@_'Z&QZ> &T' 0Q]Z'U' $@QZ&f) ='[%)%@> %> 3>)&1;d >@& &@

cQ>)'&&X' @&T'Z (Z'() @\ &T' X(S/d5l #-a $@>?/ :'[/ 2B#,g

1#aa-5 1)&(&'U'>& @\ 0'>/ W'>>'=^5 1:K:F S() c=')%?>'=

&@ Z')&@Z' &T' [@U]'XX%>? %>&'Z')& &')& \@Z ='[%=%>? \Z''

'`'Z[%)' [X(%U)/d5/ 7> X%>' S%&T &T%) Z')&@Z(&%_' ]QZ]@)';

$@>?Z')) '`]'[&'= [@QZ&) [@>)%='Z%>? :K:F [X(%U) &@

cX@@e &@ \Z'' '`'Z[%)' [()') ='[%='= ]Z%@Z &@ 3>)&1 \@Z

?Q%=(>['/d 0'>(&' :']@Z& g/ 0'' (X)@ L/ :/ :']/ 8@/ #3-A

gg; ]]/ BA, 1#aa-5 1T'Z'%>(\&'Z L@Q)' :']@Z&5 1)(U'5/ 7>)T@Z&; &T' F[& Z'%>)&(&') &T' X(S () %& S() ]Z%@Z &@ 3>)&1;

S%&T@Q& c[Z'(&P%>?R / / / >'S Z%?T&) \@Z (>^ Z'X%?%@Q) ]Z([b

&%[' @Z \@Z (>^ ]@&'>&%(X X%&%?(>&/d #-a $@>?/ :'[/ 2B#,g

1)&(&'U'>& @\ 0'>/ W'>>'=^5/ 6%_'> &T' F[&f) U@='Z(&'

]QZ]@)'; %& %) T(Z=X^ )QZ]Z%)%>? &T(& :K:Ff) '>([&U'>& %>

#aa- ]Z@_@e'= X%&&X' [@>&Z@_'Z)^/ 0'' 9Z%'\ \@Z 0'>(&@Z

NQZZ(^ '& (X/ () 7>):) 54+)$' g 1T'Z'%>(\&'Z 0'>(&@Z)

iiiiii

a .>='Z 31'+9'+& (>= G20'+; &T' $@QZ& cZ'jQ%ZP'=R &T' ?@_'Z>U'>& &@

VQ)&%\^ (>^ )QY)&(>&%(X YQZ='> @> Z'X%?%@Q)X^ U@&%_(&'= [@>=Q[& Y^ (

[@U]'XX%>? )&(&' %>&'Z')& (>= Y^ U'(>) >(ZZ@SX^ &(%X@Z'= &@ ([T%'_'

&T(& %>&'Z')&/d A>=/26>'%& $% C',24+:', 2* D+'"_/3>)&1; 4a4 ./ 0/ g,2; ga4 1#aa35 1Jf$@>>@Z; [QZZ%>? %>

VQ=?U'>&5/


69/95

#3 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; &T' 0'>(&'

(>= ( _@%[' _@&' %> &T' L@Q)' @\ :']Z')'>&(&%_')5/

9

M')]%&' &T')' (Q&T@Z%&(&%_' %>=%[(&%@>); &T' $@QZ& )'')

:K:F () ( Y@X= %>%&%(&%_' ='](Z&%>? \Z@U; Z(&T'Z &T(>

Z')&@Z%>?; ]Z'b3>)&1VQZ%)]ZQ='>['/ 0'' $%&'( (& B; >/ -; ,;

#,; 2+A2,/ I@ )Q]]@Z& %&) [@>[']&%@> @\ :K:F () ( U'()b

QZ' ='&([T'= \Z@U &T%) $@QZ&f) ='[%)%@>); @>' &T(& )'&) (

>'S [@QZ)'; &T' $@QZ& ]@%>&) \%Z)& &@ &T' :'X%?%@Q) D(>=

.)' (>= 7>)&%&Q&%@>(X%k'= O'Z)@>) F[& @\ 2333 1:D.7OF5;

42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333[[ '& ,'-"( ST%[T (X&'Z'= :K:Ff) ='\%>%b&%@> @\ &T' &'ZU c'`'Z[%)' @\ Z'X%?%@>/d :K:F; () @Z%?%>(XX^

'>([&'=; ='\%>'= &T(& &'ZU &@ U'(> c&T' '`'Z[%)' @\ Z'X%b

?%@> Q>='Z &T' K%Z)& FU'>=U'>& &@ &T' $@>)&%&Q&%@>/d

h2333YYA2145 1#aa4 '=/5/ 0'' $%&'( (& BA,/ F) (U'>='= Y^

:D.7OF; :K:Ff) ='\%>%&%@> >@S %>[XQ=') c(>^ '`'Z[%)' @\

Z'X%?%@>; ST'&T'Z @Z >@& [@U]'XX'= Y^; @Z ['>&Z(X &@; (

)^)&'U @\ Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\/d h2333YYA2145 123#2 '=/5 1[Z@))b

Z'\'Z'>[%>? h2333[[A+5/ IT(& ='\%>%&%@>(X [T(>?'; ([[@Z=b

%>? &@ &T' $@QZ&; Z'\X'[&) c(> @Y_%@Q) '\\@Z& &@ '\\'[& (

[@U]X'&' )'](Z(&%@> \Z@U K%Z)& FU'>=U'>& [()' X(S/d

7%&'( (& ,/

IT' $@QZ&f) Z'(=%>? %) >@& ]X(Q)%YX'/ :D.7OFf) (X&'Z(b

&%@> [X(Z%\%') &T(& [@QZ&) )T@QX= >@& jQ')&%@> &T' ['>&Z(X%&^

@\ ( ](Z&%[QX(Z Z'X%?%@Q) '`'Z[%)'/ 9Q& &T' (U'>=U'>& %>

>@ S(^ )Q??')&) &T(& $@>?Z')) U'(>& &@ '`](>= &T' [X())

@\ '>&%&%') jQ(X%\%'= &@ U@Q>& Z'X%?%@Q) ([[@UU@=(&%@>

[X(%U); >@Z =@') %& Z'X%'_' [@QZ&) @\ &T' @YX%?(&%@> &@ %>b

jQ%Z' ST'&T'Z ( ?@_'Z>U'>& ([&%@> )QY)&(>&%(XX^ YQZ='>)

( Z'X%?%@Q) '`'Z[%)'/ 0'' C$,4/ _/ O6'+,; +B- K/ -= +2,;

+-+ 1$FM$ 233a5 19Z@S>; [QZZ%>?5 1cIT'Z' %) >@

=@QY& &T(& :D.7OFf) =Z(\&'Z); %> [T(>?%>? &T' ='\%>%&%@>

@\ n'`'Z[%)' @\ Z'X%?%@>;f S(>&'= &@ YZ@(='> &T' )[@]' @\ &T'

e%>=) @\ ]Z([&%[') ]Z@&'[&'= Y^ :K:F; >@& %>[Z'()' &T'Q>%_'Z)' @\ %>=%_%=Q(X) ]Z@&'[&'= Y^ :K:F/d5l L/ :/ :']/


70/95


71/95

#2 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; ? ?@_'Z>U'>&(X %>&'Z')&/d5/ F>= &T' _%'S &T(&

&T' ]Z'b3>)&1 &')& %>[XQ='= ( cX'()& Z')&Z%[&%_' U'(>)d

Z'jQ%Z'U'>& T(= Y''> (%Z'= %> &')&%U@>^ Y'\@Z' &T' 0'>b

(&' Z'X%?%@Q) \Z''=@U/

0''; '"8"(L'(Z%>? @> 0/ 2aBa Y'\@Z' &T' 0'>(&' $@UU%&&''

@> &T' ?/; 2= 0'))/; ,gA,a 1#aa-5

1)&(&'U'>& @\ OZ@\/ M@Q?X() D(^[@[e5/

JQZ ='[%)%@> %> 5)&6 2* L2'+%'; %& %) &ZQ'; )&(&') &T(& &T'

X'()& Z')&Z%[&%_' U'(>) Z'jQ%Z'U'>& cS() >@& Q)'= %> &T'

]Z'b3>)&1 VQZ%)]ZQ='>[' :K:F ]QZ]@Z&'= &@ [@=%\^/d 0''

$%&'((& B; >/ -; #,; >/ #g/ F) VQ)& %>=%[(&'=; T@S'_'Z; &T(&)&(&'U'>& =@') >@& ([[QZ(&'X^ [@>_'^ &T' $@QZ&f) ]Z'b

3>)&1VQZ%)]ZQ='>['/ 0'' 31'+9'+&; -,4 ./ 0/; (& 43, 1cP7R&

S@QX= ]X(%>X^ Y' %>[QUY'>& Q]@> &T' P?@_'Z>U'>&R &@

='U@>)&Z(&' &T(& >@ (X&'Z>(&%_' \@ZU) @\ Z'?QX(&%@> S@QX=

[@UY(& P&T' ]Z@YX'UR S%&T@Q& %>\Z%>?%>? K%Z)& FU'>=U'>&

Z%?T&)/d5l H12>$, _/ C'!)'R L0" 2* @%0)$%$ A>=/26>'%&

3':4+)&6


72/95

#-$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67809.:6; )&(>& X(S)Q%&)/ IT(& &()e; %>

_%'S @\ &T' ]@)%&%@>) &(e'> Y^ &T' $@QZ&; Z'jQ%Z') [@>)%=b

'Z(&%@> @\ )'_'Z(X jQ')&%@>); '([T ]@&'>&%(XX^ =%)]@)%&%_' @\

L@YY^ D@YY^f) (>= $@>')&@?(f) [X(%U)* M@ \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@b

Z(&%@>) Z(>e (U@>? c]'Z)@>P)Rd ST@ c'`'Z[%)' / / / Z'X%b

?%@>do F))QU%>? &T(& &T'^ =@; =@') &T' [@>&Z([']&%_'

[@_'Z(?' Z'jQ%Z'U'>& c)QY)&(>&%(XX^ YQZ='>d &T'%Z Z'X%b

?%@Q) '`'Z[%)'o 7\ )@; %) &T' Z'jQ%Z'U'>& c%> \QZ&T'Z(>[' @\

( [@U]'XX%>? ?@_'Z>U'>& %>&'Z')&do F>= X()&; =@') &T'

Z'jQ%Z'U'>& Z']Z')'>& &T' X'()& Z')&Z%[&%_' U'(>) \@Z

\QZ&T'Z%>? &T(& %>&'Z')&o

N%)?Q%='= Y^ %&) 'ZZ(>& ]Z'U%)' &T(& :K:F U@_'=Y'^@>= &T' ]Z'b3>)&1 [()' X(S; &T' $@QZ& \(X&'Z) (& '([T

)&'] @\ %&) (>(X^)%)/

#

:K:Ff) [@U]'XX%>? %>&'Z')& &')&; () >@&'=; )'' ,4=+$((&

g; (]]X%') &@ ?@_'Z>U'>& ([&%@>) &T(& c)QY)&(>&%(XX^ YQZb

='> $ ='+,2%S, 'T'+:),' 2* +'/)8)2%/d 42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333YYA

#1(5 1'U]T()%) (=='=5/ IT%) Z'\'Z'>['; &T' $@QZ& )QYU%&);

%>[@Z]@Z(&') &T' ='\%>%&%@> @\ c]'Z)@>d \@Q>= %> &T' M%[b

&%@>(Z^ F[&; # ./ 0/ $/ h#; ST%[T '`&'>=) &@ c[@Z]@Z(&%@>);

[@U](>%'); ())@[%(&%@>); \%ZU); ](Z&>'Z)T%]); )@[%'&%'); (>=

V@%>& )&@[e [@U](>%'); () S'XX () %>=%_%=Q(X)/d 0'' $%&'( (&

#aA23" IT' M%[&%@>(Z^ F[&f) ='\%>%&%@>; T@S'_'Z; [@>&Z@X)

@>X^ ST'Z' c[@>&'`&d =@') >@& c%>=%[(&P'R @&T'ZS%)'/d h#/

L'Z'; [@>&'`& =@') )@ %>=%[(&'/ :K:F )]'(e) @\ c( ]'Z)@>f)

'T'+:),' 2* +'/)8)2%/d 42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333YYA#1(5 1'U]T()%)

(=='=5/ 0'' (X)@ hh2333YYA2145; 2333[[A+1,51(5/#2 GT'&T'Z

iiiiii

#2F) '(ZX%'Z '`]X(%>'=; )'' ,4=+$((& #3A##; :D.7OFf) (U'>=U'>& @\

&T' ='\%>%&%@> @\ c'`'Z[%)' @\ Z'X%?%@>d =@') >@& Y'(Z &T' S'%?T& &T'

$@QZ& ]X([') @> %&/ N@Z'@_'Z; %& %) ]())%>? )&Z(>?' &@ (&&Z%YQ&' &@

:D.7OF (>^ ]QZ]@)' &@ [@_'Z '>&%&%') @&T'Z &T(> cZ'X%?%@Q) ()b

)'UYXP%')R @Z %>)&%&Q&%@>P)R/d 42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333[[1(51#5/ 9Q& [\/ $%&'( (&2B/ IT(& X(S (]]X%') &@ X(>=bQ)' Z'?QX(&%@>/ h2333[[1(51#5/ I@ ]'ZU%&

[@UU'Z[%(X '>&'Z]Z%)') &@ [T(XX'>?' k@>%>? (>= @&T'Z X(>=bQ)' Z'?QX(b


73/95

#4 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; ? Z'X%?%@> %) (> %>jQ%Z^ @>' [(>>@& (>)S'Z S%&T@Q& Z'\'Zb

'>[' &@ &T' c\QXX Y@=^d @\ ]Z'b3>)&1 c\Z''b'`'Z[%)' [()'X(S/d

J)/$+0); ,-- K/ -=; (& #2#2/ IT'Z' %) %> &T(& [()' X(S >@

)Q]]@Z& \@Z &T' >@&%@> &T(& \Z'' '`'Z[%)' Z%?T&) ]'Z&(%> &@

\@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>)/

.>&%X &T%) X%&%?(&%@>; >@ ='[%)%@> @\ &T%) $@QZ& Z'[@?>%k'=

( \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>f) jQ(X%\%[(&%@> \@Z ( Z'X%?%@Q) '`b

'U]&%@> \Z@U ( ?'>'Z(XX^ (]]X%[(YX' X(S; ST'&T'Z Q>='Z

&T' KZ'' H`'Z[%)' $X(Q)' @Z :K:F/#- IT' (Y)'>[' @\ )Q[T

]Z'['='>& %) VQ)& ST(& @>' S@QX= '`]'[&; \@Z &T' '`'Z[%)' @\

Z'X%?%@> %) [T(Z([&'Z%)&%[ @\ >(&QZ(X ]'Z)@>); >@& (Z&%\%[%(XX'?(X '>&%&%')/ F) $T%'\ %) c(> (Z&%\%[%(X Y'%>?;

%>_%)%YX'; %>&(>?%YX'; (>= '`%)&%>? @>X^ %> [@>&'U]X(&%@> @\

X(S/d H+4,&'', 2* 24&1 52//'8' _/ E220R$+0; 4

GT'(&/ +#g; B-B 1#g#a5/ $@Z]@Z(&%@>); &X^ Z'U%>='=; cT(_' >@ [@>)[%'>['); >@ Y'X%'\);

>@ \''X%>?); >@ &T@Q?T&); >@ =')%Z')/d 5)&);'%, F%)&'0 _/

Q'0'+$/ A/':&)2% 52>>S%; ++g ./ 0/ -#3; 4BB 123#35 1@]%>b

%@> [@>[QZZ%>? %> ](Z& (>= =%))'>&%>? %> ](Z&5/

IT' K%Z)& FU'>=U'>&f) \Z'' '`'Z[%)' ]Z@&'[&%@>); &T'

iiiiii

&%@>) Q>='Z :D.7OF S@QX= c=Z(U(&%[(XX^ '`](>= &T' )&(&Q&'f) Z'([Td

(>= ='']X^ %>&ZQ=' @> X@[(X ]Z'Z@?(&%_'); [@>&Z(Z^ &@ $@>?Z'))f %>&'>&/

9Z%'\ \@Z 8(&%@>(X D'(?Q' @\ $%&%') '& (X/ ()7>):) 54+)$' 2B/#- IT' $@QZ& Z'?(Z=) J$//$81'+ _/ 5+2R% P2,1'+ 34='+ O$+I'& 2*

O$,,"( @%:"; -BB ./ 0/ B#, 1#aB#5; () c)Q??')&P%>?R / / / &T(& \@Zb]Z@\%&

[@Z]@Z(&%@>) ]@))')) P\Z''b'`'Z[%)'R Z%?T&)/d 7%&'( (& 2BA2,/ 0'' (X)@

$%&'((& 2#; >/ 2#/ IT' )Q??')&%@> %) Y(Z'X^ &T'Z'/ IZQ'; @>' @\ &T' \%_'

[T(XX'>?'Z) &@ &T' 0Q>=(^ [X@)%>? X(S ())(%X'= %> J$//$81'+ S() (

[@Z]@Z(&%@> @S>'= Y^ \@QZ JZ&T@=@` ?'Z) S'Z'

TQU(> %>=%_%=Q(X); >@& (Z&%\%[%(X; X(Sb[Z'(&'= '>&%&%'); )@ &T'Z' S() >@

>''= &@ ='&'ZU%>' ST'&T'Z &T' [@Z]@Z(&%@> [@QX= %>)&%&Q&' &T' X%&%?(b

&%@>/ F[[@Z=%>?X^; &T' ]XQZ(X%&^ )&(&'= %& [@QX= ]Z'&'ZU%& &T' jQ')&%@>

cST'&T'Z (]]'XX'') T(P=R )&(>=%>?d Y'[(Q)' L+$4%*'/0 _/ L+2R%; -BB./ 0/ +aa 1#aB#5; ST%[T Q]T'X= ( )%U%X(Z [X@)%>? X(S; S() \(&(X &@ &T'%Z

[X(%U @> &T' U'Z%&)/ -BB ./ 0/; (& B-#/


74/95

#+$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67809.:6; %k'=; )T'X&'Z [TQZ[T') (>= @&T'Z

>@>]Z@\%& Z'X%?%@>bY()'= @Z?(>%k(&%@>)/#4 cK@Z U(>^ %>=%b

_%=Q(X); Z'X%?%@Q) ([&%_%&^ ='Z%_') U'(>%>? %> X(Z?' U'()b

QZ' \Z@U ](Z&%[%](&%@> %> ( X(Z?'Z Z'X%?%@Q) [@UUQ>%&^;d

(>= c\QZ&T'Z(>[' @\ &T' (Q&@>@U^ @\ Z'X%?%@Q) @Z?(>%k(b

&%@>) @\&'> \QZ&T'Z) %>=%_%=Q(X Z'X%?%@Q) \Z''=@U () S'XX/d

52+=2+$&)2% 2* .+',)0)%8 L),12= 2* 514+:1 2* ?',4, 51+),&

2* U$&&'+V0$6 3$)%&, _/ 7>2,; 4g- ./ 0/ -2,; -42 1#ag,5

19Z'>>(>; [QZZ%>? %> VQ=?U'>&5/ IT' $@QZ&f) c)]'b

[%(X )@X%[%&Q=' &@ &T' Z%?T&) @\ Z'X%?%@Q) @Z?(>%k(&%@>);d

B2,$%%$VH$92+ A!$%8'/):$/ U4&1'+$% 514+:1 $%0 3:122/

_/ AAD5; +B+ ./ 0/ """; """ 123#25 1)X%] @]/; (& #45; T@Sb'_'Z; %) VQ)& &T(&/ 8@ )Q[T )@X%[%&Q=' %) &Z(=%&%@>(X \@Z [@Ub

U'Z[%(X @Z?(>%k(&%@>)/#+ 7>=''=; Q>&%X &@=(^; Z'X%?%@Q)

iiiiii

#4 0''; '"8"( B2,$%%$VH$92+ A!$%8'/):$/ U4&1'+$% 514+:1 $%0 3:122/

_/ AAD5; +B+ ./ 0/ """ 123#25l J2%;$/', _/ D 5'%&+2 A,=K+)&$ L'%'*)V

:'%&' F%)M2 02 N'8'&$/; +4B ./ 0/ 4#g 1233B5l 514+:1 2* U4I4>) L$9$/4

76'( @%:"_/ B)$/'$1; +3g ./ 0/ +23 1#aa-5l ?)>>6 3R$88$+& O)%),&+)',

_/L2$+0 2* A-4$/);$&)2% 2* 5$/"; 4a- ./ 0/ -,g 1#aa35/#+ I^]%[(XX^; $@>?Z')) T() ([[@Z='= &@ @Z?(>%k(&%@>) Z'X%?%@Q) %> [T(Zb

([&'Z Z'X%?%@>bY()'= '`'U]&%@>) \Z@U )&(&Q&') @\ ?'>'Z(X (]]X%[(&%@>/

A"8"( 42 ./ 0/ $/ h2333'A#1(5 1I%&X' E77 '`'U]&%@> \Z@U ]Z@T%Y%&%@>

(?(%>)& 'U]X@^U'>& =%)[Z%U%>(&%@> Y()'= @> Z'X%?%@> \@Z c( Z'X%?%@Q)[@Z]@Z(&%@>; ())@[%(&%@>; '=Q[(&%@>(X %>)&%&Q&%@>; @Z )@[%'&^ S%&T Z')]'[&

&@ &T' 'U]X@^U'>& @\ %>=%_%=Q(X) @\ ( ](Z&%[QX(Z Z'X%?%@> &@ ]'Z\@ZU

S@Ze [@>>'[&'= S%&T &T' [(ZZ^%>? @> / / / @\ %&) ([&%_%&%')d5l 42 ./ 0/ $/

h#2##-1=51#5 1](Z(XX'X '`'U]&%@> %> FU'Z%[(>) G%&T M%)(Y%X%&%') F[& @\

#aa35/ 7& [(> )[(Z['X^ Y' U(%>&(%>'= &T(& :K:F '>X(Z?') &T')' ' 'U]b

&%@>) &@ (XX@S L@YY^ D@YY^ (>= $@>')&@?( &@ T%Z' @>X^ ]'Z)@>) ST@

)T(Z' &T' Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) @\ &T' 6Z''>) @Z L(T>)/ 8@Z =@') &T' $@QZ&

)Q??')& @&T'ZS%)'/ $\/ $%&'((& 2g/

IT' $@QZ& =@') %='>&%\^ &S@ )&(&Q&@Z^ '`'U]&%@>) %& Z'(=) &@ [@_'Z

\@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>); 42 ./ 0/ $/ hh-33(A,1Y5125 (>= 2-g>1(5; (>=

%>\'Z) \Z@U &T'U &T(& c$@>?Z')) )]'(e) S%&T )]'[%\%[%&^ ST'> %& %>&'>=)

( Z'X%?%@Q) ([[@UU@=(&%@> >@& &@ '`&'>= &@ \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>);d

$%&'( (& 2g/ IT' $@QZ&f) %>\'Z'>[' %) Q>S(ZZ(>&'=/ IT' '`'U]&%@>) &T'

$@QZ& [%&') [@_'Z ['Z&(%> U'=%[(X ]'Z)@>>'X ST@ @YV'[& &@ ]'Z\@ZU%>? @Z())%)&%>? S%&T (Y@Z&%@>)/ $\/ $%&'( (& 2g; >/ 2, 1c&T' ]Z@&'[&%@> ]Z@_%='=

Y^ h2-g>1(5 =%\\'Z) )%?>%\%[(>&X^ \Z@U &T' ]Z@&'[&%@> ]Z@_%='= Y^
http:///reader/full/organizations.14http:///reader/full/organizations.14http:///reader/full/organizations.15http:///reader/full/organizations.15http:///reader/full/organizations.14http:///reader/full/organizations.15


75/95

#B 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; ^ '>&%&^ @]'Z(&b

%>? %> c&T' [@UU'Z[%(X; ]Z@\%&bU(e%>? S@ZX=/d 7>2,; 4g-

./ 0/; (& --,/#B

IT' Z'()@> ST^ %) T(Z=X^ @Y)[QZ'/ :'X%?%@Q) @Z?(>%k(b

&%@>) '`%)& &@ \@)&'Z &T' %>&'Z')&) @\ ]'Z)@>) )QY)[Z%Y%>? &@

&T' )(U' Z'X%?%@Q) \(%&T/ 8@& )@ @\ \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>)/

G@Ze'Z) ST@ )Q)&(%> &T' @]'Z(&%@>) @\ &T@)' [@Z]@Z(&%@>)

[@UU@>X^ (Z' >@& =Z(S> \Z@U @>' Z'X%?%@Q) [@UUQ>%&^/

7>=''=; Y^ X(S; >@ Z'X%?%@>bY()'= [Z%&'Z%@> [(> Z')&Z%[& &T'

iiiiii

:K:Fd5/ 8@&(YX^; &T' $@QZ& =@') >@& ())'Z& &T(& &T')' '`'U]&%@>) T(_'%> \([& Y''> (\\@Z='= &@ \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>)/ 0'' h2-g>1[5 1cT'(X&T

[(Z' '>&%&^d [@_'Z'= Y^ '`'U]&%@> %) ( &'ZU ='\%>'= &@ %>[XQ=' c(>

%>=%_%=Q(X ]T^)%[%(>; ( ]@)&?Z(=Q(&' ]T^)%[%(> &Z(%>%>? ]Z@?Z(U; (>= (

](Z&%[%](>& %> ( ]Z@?Z(U @\ &Z(%>%>? %> &T' T'(X&T ]Z@\'))%@>)d5l I@kk%;

GT%&T'Z KZ'' H`'Z[%)'* A>=/26>'%& )&1 (>= &T' :'Y%Z&T

@\ 0&(&' $@>)&%&Q&%@>(X KZ'' H`'Z[%)' $X(Q)' );

YQ& >@& >'['))(Z%X^ T@)]%&(X); / / / U(^ Y' (YX' &@ %>_@e' Ph2-g>1(5R

/ / / /d5l [\/ 0/ #-,; ##-&T $@>?/; #)& 0'))/ 123#-5 1() %>&Z@=Q['=5 1FY@Z&%@>

8@>bM%)[Z%U%>(&%@> F[& @\ 23#-; ST%[T S@QX= (U'>= &T' ='\%>%&%@> @\

cT'(X&T [(Z' '>&%&^d %> h2-g> &@ %>[XQ=' cT@)]%&(XP)R;d cT'(X&T %>)QZ(>['

]X(>P)R;d (>= @&T'Z T'(X&T [(Z' $[%X%&%')5/ IT')' ]Z@_%)%@>) (Z' Z'_'(Xb

%>? %> ( S(^ &T(& ='&Z([&) \Z@U @>' @\ &T' $@QZ&f) U(%> (Z?QU'>&)/

IT'^ )T@S &T(& $@>?Z')) %) >@& [@>&'>& &@ Z')& @> &T' M%[&%@>(Z^ F[&ST'> %& S%)T') &@ '>)QZ' &T(& ](Z&%[QX(Z '>&%&%') (Z' (U@>? &T@)'

'X%?%YX' \@Z ( Z'X%?%@Q) ([[@UU@=(&%@>/

N@Z'@_'Z; &T' '`'U]&%@> [@=%\%'= %> h2-g>1(5 S() >@& '>([&'= Q>&%X

&TZ'' ^'(Z) (\&'Z :K:Ff) ]())(?'/ 0'' JU>%YQ) $@>)@X%=(&'= :')[%)b

)%@>) (>= F]]Z@]Z%(&%@>) F[& @\ #aaB; h+#+; ##3 0&(&/ #-2#A24+/ 7\; ()

&T' $@QZ& Y'X%'_'); :K:F @]'>'= (XX )&(&Q&@Z^ )[T'U') &@ Z'X%?%@>b

Y()'= [T(XX'>?') Y^ \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>); &T'Z' S@QX= Y' >@ >''= \@Z (

)&(&Q&'b)]'[%\%[; ]@)&b:K:F '`'U]&%@> @\ &T%) )@Z&/#B IT(& %) >@& &@ )(^ &T(& ( [(&'?@Z^ @\ ]X(%>&%\$; )Q[T () Z')%='>&

(X%'>); U(^ YZ%>? :K:F [X(%U) @>X^ %\ &T%) $@QZ& '`]Z'))X^ c(==Z'))'=

&T'%Z P\Z''b'`'Z[%)'R Z%?T&) Y'\@Z' 3>)&1/d 7%&'( (& 2,/ $@>&%>Q%>? S%&T

&T' $@QZ&f) '`(U]X'; Z')%='>& (X%'>); Q>X%e' [@Z]@Z(&%@>); (Z' \X')Tb(>=b

YX@@= %>=%_%=Q(X) ST@ ]X(%>X^ [@Q>& () ]'Z)@>) )T'X&'Z'= Y^ &T' K%Z)&

FU'>=U'>&; )'' F%)&'0 3&$&',_/ N'+0482VF+-4)0';; 4a4 ./ 0/ 2+a; 2,#1#aa35 1[%&%>? L+)08', _/ E)T2%; -2B ./ 0/ #-+; #4g 1#a4+55; (>=

$ *2+&)2+); :K:F/


76/95

#,$%&' ()* +,- ./ 0/ """" 123#45

67809.:6; )/ 0'' 42 ./ 0/ $/

hh2333'1Y5; 2333'A#1(5; 2333'A21(5l [\/ H+$%, E2+/0 7)+V

/)%',( @%:" _/ B$+0),2%; 4-2 ./ 0/ B-; g3Ag# 1#a,,5 1I%&X'

E77 Z'jQ%Z') Z'()@>(YX' ([[@UU@=(&%@> @\ (> 'U]X@^''f)

Z'X%?%@Q) '`'Z[%)'; YQ& )Q[T ([[@UU@=(&%@> UQ)& >@& [@U'

c(& &T' '`]'>)' @\ @&T'ZP 'U]X@^'')Rd5/ IT' =%)&%>[&%@>

Y'&S''> ( [@UUQ>%&^ U(=' Q] @\ Y'X%'_'Z) %> &T' )(U'

Z'X%?%@> (>= @>' 'UYZ([%>? ]'Z)@>) @\ =%_'Z)' Y'X%'\); [X'(Z

() %& %); [@>)&(>&X^ ')[(]') &T' $@QZ&f) (&&'>&%@>/#, J>'

[(> @>X^ S@>='Z ST^ &T' $@QZ& )TQ&) &T%) e'^ =%\\'Z'>['

\Z@U )%?T&/

:'(=%>? :K:F; () &T' $@QZ& =@'); &@ Z'jQ%Z' '`&'>)%@>@\ Z'X%?%@>bY()'= '`'U]&%@>) &@ \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>)

)QZ'X^ %) >@& ?Z@Q>='= %> &T' ]Z'b3>)&1 ]Z'['='>& $@>b

?Z')) )@Q?T& &@ ]Z')'Z_'/ L(= $@>?Z')) %>&'>='= :K:F &@

%>%&%(&' ( [T(>?' )@ TQ?'; ( [X(Z%@> )&(&'U'>& &@ &T(&

'\\'[& X%e'X^ S@QX= T(_' Y''> U(=' %> &T' X'?%)X(&%@>/ 0''

E1)&>$%_/7>'+):$% H+4:I)%8 7,,%,"( @%:"; +-# ./ 0/ 4+,;

4Bg 1233#5 1$@>?Z')) =@') >@& cT%=' 'X']T(>&) %> U@Q)'b

T@X')d5/ IT' &'`& @\ :K:F U(e') >@ )Q[T )&(&'U'>& (>=

&T' X'?%)X(&%_' T%)&@Z^ =@') >@& )@ UQ[T () U'>&%@> \@Zb

]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>)/ 0'' B2996 U2996 3&2+',( @%:" _/ 3'9'V

/)4,; ,2- K/ -= ###4; ##Ba 1$F#3 23#-5 19Z%)[@'; $/ [QZZ%>? %> ](Z& (>= =%))'>&%>? %> ](Z&5 1X'?%)X(&%_'

Z'[@Z= X([e) c(>^ )Q??')&%@> &T(& $@>?Z')) \@Z')(S; X'&

(X@>' %>&'>='= &T(&; :K:F S@QX= [@_'Z \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(b

&%@>)d5/ 0'' (X)@ 0'>(&@Z) 9Z%'\ #3A#- 1>@>' @\ &T'iiiiii

#, 7 ](Z& S(^) S%&T &T' [@>&'`& Z'X'_(>& T'Z'/

L' )'') %& () &T' 'U]X@^'Z)f c'`'Z[%)' P@\R &T'%Z Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'\) S%&T%>

&T' [@>&'`& @\ &T'%Z @S> [X@)'X^ T'X=; \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>)/d 7%&'((& 2

1[@>[QZZ%>? @]%>%@>5/ 0'' (X)@ $%&'( (& 4+A4B 1@]%>%@> @\ &T' $@QZ&5

1)%U%X(ZX^ [@>['>&Z(&%>? @> Z'X%?%@Q) $%&T @\ 'U]X@^'Z) S%&T@Q& Z'\'Zb

'>[' &@ &T' =%\\'Z'>& Y'X%'$ (>= X%Y'Z&^ %>&'Z')&) @\ 'U]X@^'')5/ 7 )'' ()

&T' Z'X'_(>& [@>&'`& &T' 'U]X@^'Z)f ())'Z&'= Z%?T& &@ '`'Z[%)' Z'X%?%@>

S%&T%> ( >(&%@>S%=' ]Z@?Z(U =')%?>'= &@ ]Z@&'[& (?(%>)& T'(X&T T(kb(Z=) 'U]X@^'') ST@ =@ >@& )QY)[Z%Y' &@ &T'%Z 'U]X@^'Z)f Z'X%?%@Q)

Y'X%'\)/
http:///reader/full/attention.17http:///reader/full/attention.17http:///reader/full/attention.17


77/95

#g 9.:GHDD !"LJ99C DJ99C 0IJ:H0; 78$/

67809.:6; &%@>'= =QZ%>? \X@@Z

)]''[T'); Z'[@?>%k'= &T' \Z'' '`'Z[%)' Z%?T&) @\ \@Zb]Z@\%&

[@Z]@Z(&%@>)5/

IT' $@QZ& >@&') &T(& \@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>) U(^ )Q]b

]@Z& [T(Z%&(YX' [(Q)') (>= Q)' &T'%Z \Q>=) \@Z Z'X%?%@Q)

'>=); (>= &T'Z'\@Z' jQ')&%@>) &T' =%)&%>[&%@> Y'&S''> )Q[T

[@Z]@Z(&%@>) (>= Z'X%?%@Q) >@>]Z@\%& @Z?(>%k(&%@>)/ 0''

$%&'((& 23A2+/ 0'' (X)@ $%&'((& - 1WH88HMC; [QZb

Z%>?5 1[Z%&%[%k%>? &T' 6@_'Z>U'>& \@Z c=%)&%>?Q%)T%>? Y'b

&S''> =%\\'Z'>& Z'X%?%@Q) Y'X%'_'Z)iYQZ='>%>? @>' ST%X'

([[@UU@=(&%>? &T' @&T'ZiST'> %& U(^ &Z'(& Y@&T 'jQ(XX^Y^ @\\'Z%>? Y@&T @\ &T'U &T' )(U' ([[@UU@=(&%@>d5/#g

F?(%>; &T' $@QZ& \@Z?'&) &T(& Z'X%?%@Q) @Z?(>%k(&%@>) '`%)&

&@ )'Z_' ( [@UUQ>%&^ @\ Y'X%'_'Z)/ K@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>)

=@ >@& \%& &T(& Y%XX/ N@Z'@_'Z; T%)&@Z^ %) >@& @> &T' $@QZ&f)

)%='/ :'[@?>%&%@> @\ &T' =%)[Z'&' [T(Z([&'Z) @\ c'[[X')%()&%b

[(X (>= X(^d [@Z]@Z(&%@>) =(&') Y([e &@ 9X([e)&@>'; )'' #

G/ 9X([e)&@>'; $@UU'>&(Z%') @> &T' D(S) @\ H>?X(>= 4+g

1#,B+5; (>= S() Z'%&'Z(&'= Y^ &T%) $@QZ& ['>&QZ%') Y'\@Z'

&T' '>([&U'>& @\ &T' 7>&'Z>(X :'_'>Q' $@='/ 0'' H'++'&&

_/ H$6/2+; a $Z(>[T 4-; 4a 1#g#+5 1=')[Z%Y%>? Z'X%?%@Q)

[@Z]@Z(&%@>)5l H+4,&'', 2* 24&1 52//'8'; 4 GT'(&/; (&B4+ 1=%)[Q))%>? c'X''U@)^>(Z^d [@Z]@Z(&%@>); %>[XQ=%>?

&T@)' c[Z'(&'= \@Z &T' ]Z@U@&%@> @\ Z'X%?%@>d5/ I@ Z'%&'Z(&';

c\@Zb]Z@\%& [@Z]@Z(&%@>) (Z' =%\\'Z'>& \Z@U Z'X%?%@Q) >@>b

iiiiii

#gF[[@Z=%>? &@ &T' $@QZ&; &T' 6@_'Z>U'>& c[@>['=')d &T(& c>@>]Z@\%&

[@Z]@Z(&%@>P)Rd (Z' ]Z@&'[&'= Y^ :K:F/ 7%&'( (& #a/ 0'' (X)@ $%&'( (&

23; 24; -3/ IT(& %) >@& (> ([[QZ(&' =')[Z%]&%@> @\ &T' 6@_'Z>U'>&f)

]@)%&%@>; ST%[T '>[@U]())') @>X^ c[TQZ[T');d c+'/)8)24, %>)&%&Q&%@>);d

(>= c+'/)8)24, >@>b]Z@\%&)/d 9Z%'\ \@Z :')]@>='>&) %> 8@/ #-A-+B; ]/ 2g

1'U]T()%) (=='=5/ 0'' (X)@ :']X^ 9Z%'\ %> 8@/ #-A-+4; ]/ g 1c:K:F

%>[@Z]@Z(&') &T' X@>?)&(>=%>? (>= [@UU@>b)'>)' =%)&%>[&%@> Y'&S''>

Z'X%?%@Q) @Z?(>%k(&%@>); ST%[T )@U'&

Documents

SCOTUS - Hobby Lobby