Disclaimer This Expert Choice consultation

and presentation content is proprietary. Because of this, I can show only select slides from this participation.

Mistakes to avoid when synthesizing Avoid showing so many things

at once that it causes confusion Ensure information is properly

labeled “Forest for the trees” problem Reiteration may be needed

Avoid renaming things in a way that corrupts the result

Investigate when the result doesn’t feel right

Uncover bias Uncover disagreement and

haze

Area Validation Exercise Shows the accuracy of pairwise comparison.Determine the relative sizes of the shapes below. Ex: Is the circle 80% of the aggregate area and the triangle 5%?

Diagonals and redundancy

Scales

Alternatives

Speed Max. Range

Safety Cost Reliability

Maneuverability

Mustang 2 1500 Excellent

8.5 Average Outstanding

BF109 2.5 2700 Good 6.5 Low Good

Warbird 1.8 2000 Poor 5.5 High Very Good

Mosquito 2.2 1800 Very Good

7.0 Average Moderate

Which is the best warplane?