15

Click here to load reader

Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2212

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life inLatinAmericaOsocialismo,lutassociaisenovomododevidanaAméricaLatina

RicardoAntunes UNICAMP,Campinas,SãoPaulo,Brazil.E-mail:[email protected]ção:ClarissedeAlmeida:PontifíciaUniversidadeCatólicadeSãoPaulo,SãoPaulo,SP,Brasil.

Articlesubmittedin29/06/2017andacceptedin31/08/2017.

Page 2: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2213

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

Resumo

Oobjetivodestetextoérefletirsobreaexperiênciarecentedosocialismocomo

olhar voltado para a América Latina. Se ao longo do século XX, a tese do

“socialismoemumsópaís”sofreuumaderrotaprofunda,mesmoemseuespaço

ampliadode incidência,qualpoderáseropapel (econômico,socialepolítico)de

paísescomooBrasil,México,Argentina,Venezuela,BolíviaeColômbia,Cubaetc,

nas lutas pelo socialismo, tanto no espaço latinoamericano, quanto mundial?

Nestaerademundializaçãodocapital,comoserápossívelpensarosocialismoem

umespaçosimultaneamentenacionaletambémglobal/universal?Equaissãoos

polos sociais capazes de lutar por estas transformações, quando se toma o

exemplodaAméricaLatina?Sãoestesalgunsdospontostratadosnesteartigo

Palavras-chave: Socialismo e América Latina; Classe trabalhadora e socialismo;

revoluçãonacionaleinternacional.

Abstract

The intent of this text is to reflect on the recent experience of socialismwith a

view towards Latin America. If, in the course of the 20th century, the thesis of

"socialism in one country" has suffered a profound defeat, even in its broader

space of incidence, what can be the role (economical, social and political) of

countries such as Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Venezuela, Bolivia and Colombia,

Cuba, etc., in the struggles for socialism,both in LatinAmerica spaceand in the

world? In this ageof globalizationof capital, how canwe thinkof socialism in a

space both national and also global / universal? And what are the social poles

capable of fighting for these transformations,when taking the example of Latin

America?Thesearesomeofthequestionesdealtwithinthispresentarticle.

Keywords:SocialismandLatinAmerica;Workingclassandsocialism;nationaland

internationalrevolution.

Page 3: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2214

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

Aninitialnote1

Atthethresholdofthetwenty-firstcentury,thesearchforanewsocialistproject

isintoday'sagendaoncemore.Nowadayswehavetheconditionstotakeamore

conclusiveaccountoftheexperiencelivedinthetwentiethcentury:consideringits

mostimportantexperiencesdefeated,withtheUSSRattheforefront,itispossible

to certify that these projects were not able to defeat the system of social

metabolismofcapital.

Thissystem,constitutedbythetripodofcapital,labourandstate,cannot

be overcome without eliminating all elements which comprise it. As István

Mészáros2says, it is not enough to eliminate one or even two of its poles. The

challenge is to overcome the tripod, including the hierarchical social division of

labourwhichsubordinatesworktocapital.

Bynothavingadvanced in thisdirection,post-capitalist countries, ledby

theUSSR,were incapableofbreaking the logicofcapital.Asimilarphenomenon

occurs todaywithChina,whichoscillatesbetweenabroadopening to theworld

market under the command of capital and the strengthening of rigid political

controlexercisedbythestateandtheChineseCommunistParty.Ibelievethatthe

reflectiononthispointisafirstanddecisivechallenge.

Let’sfocusonasecondpoint:theexperienceof“socialisminonecountry”

oreveninalimitedsetofcountrieswasalsoadefeatedenterpriseinthecentury

whichhaspassed.AsMarxsays,socialismmustbeconceivedasaworld-historical

processuality;politicalrevolutionsmayinitiallyassumeamorelimitedandpartial

national conformation. But social revolutions have an intrinsic universalizing3

meaning.

1ThistextresumesideaspresentedattheCEMAXInternationalSeminarandwaspartlypublishedinthebookTheContinentofLabor(Boitempo,2011).2IstvánMészáros,BeyondCapital,SãoPaulo,Boitempo,2002.3KarlMarx,CritiqueofHegel'sPhilosophyofRight/Introduction,SãoPaulo,Boitempo,2005eMarxandEngels,TheGermanIdeology,SãoPaulo,Boitempo,2007.

Page 4: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2215

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

In the phase of globalized capital, marked by a globally unequal capital

system – in the characterization of François Chesnais4, socialism can only be

conceivedasaglobal/universalenterprise.Itseffectivenessinthenationalspace

willdepend,decisively,on itsdevelopment inothernationalspaces,whichtends

togive itahistorical-worldprocess. Inthismovement,themore itcanreachthe

heartofcapital (theUnitedStates,UnifiedEuropeandJapan in the foreground),

thegreaterwillbeitseffectivepossibilities.

Likewise, the preservation of market elements during the socialist

transition of the twentieth century proved to be a condign path for the capital

system to be reinstated. Thus, the constitution of a free association ofworkers,

creating a new system of social metabolism based on autonomous and self-

determinedwork,isincompatiblewiththegearsofthemarket.Theapologeticand

justifying “concepts”of the “socialistmarket economy”or “socialistmarket” are

euphemismsusedtocoverupthereturnandcommandofthecapitalsysteminits

restorationprocess.

The cases of China and the former USSR are too strong.Many believed

thatSovieteconomicopenness,alongsidewithitspoliticalopenness,wasgoingto

bea condition for thepreservationofwhatwasalsomistakenly termedas “real

socialism”.ThecollapseoftheSovietsystemisalreadypartofourrecenthistory,

andonly a lot of naivety could imagine that “Chinese socialism” can control the

systemofcapital thatspreads intensely throughoutChina,whosedegradationof

labourhasbecomethestandardusedbythesystemcapital to furtherdilapidate

theworkforceonaglobalscale.

Themajordifference,whenwecomparetheChinesecaseandtheSoviet

one, is that the first one made a monumental economic opening to capital,

hypertrophying thepolitical apparatusof the stateand its controlover the class

societywhichexiststodayinChina.Withthatinmind,theeconomicopeningwas

materialized, maintaining ultra-centralized control of the state through the

CommunistPartyandtheArmy.Anexampleofthesechangesandtheadvanceof4FrançoisChesnais,Theglobalizationofcapital,SãoPaulo,Xamã,1996.

Page 5: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2216

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

the capital system is the fact that the Chinese Communist Party already allows,

amongitsmembers,businessmenaffiliation.Itisnotdifficulttoimaginewhatwill

resultfromthispictureinthecomingyearsanddecades.

Disregarding this processuality, when one thinks of socialism of the

twenty-first century,would be the same as disregarding history. And the critical

historyofthesocialistexperimentofthetwentiethcenturyisfundamentaltothe

effectiveexerciseofsocialisminthetwenty-firstcentury.

In this context, the possibilities of socialism in Latin America must be

thoughtofaspartofaprocessualitythat isnotdepletedinitsnationalspace.As

wesawearlier,throughoutthetwentiethcentury,thethesisof“socialisminone

country”hadatragicresult.Themajorchallenge,therefore,istoseektherupture

withthelogicofcapitalonanational,continentalandglobalscalesimultaneously.

CountriessuchasBrazil,Mexico,Argentina,Venezuela,BoliviaandColombiamay

playsignificantrolesinthisscenario,sincethat,ononehand,theyareimportant

polesoftheglobalstructuringofcapitaland,ontheother,theyhaveasignificant

numberofsocialandpoliticalforcesofworkandstrugglesandsocialmovements

ofextremeimportance.

Economically,severalofthesecountrieshaveasignificantproductivebase,

suchasBrazilandMexico;othershavestrategicpoliticalimportance,asinthecase

of Venezuela, which, together with Bolivia and, to less extent, Ecuador, seeks

alternativesthatarecontrarytothedominantneoliberallogic.

AlongwiththeoutbreakofstrugglesandpopularuprisingsinIndia,Russia,

KoreaandinIndonesia,amongothercountriesthatarenotdirectlyatthecenter

ofthecapitalistworld,theyallconstitutearangeofpopularsocialandworkforces

capableofpropelaprojectwhichhasasitshorizonasocialistsocietalorganization

of a new type, renewed and radical, quite different from the revolutionary

undertakingsattemptedinthetwentiethcentury.

Page 6: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2217

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

Thecentralitiesofsocialstrugglesandthenewmorphologyofwork

Inthistimeofhistory, thedevelopmentofsocialandpoliticalmovementsofthe

leftandofthemasses,capableoffacingsomeofthemostacutechallengesofthis

century,isalsopresent.Fromthesocialandpoliticalmovementofthezapatistas,

inMexico, in1994,againstNorth-Americanimperialdomination,passingthrough

theOaxacacommunethatunsettledtheoligarchicpower,inMexico,recently,or

yetthroughtheadventoftheMovementofRuralWorkersWithoutLand(MST),in

Brazil,fortheresumptionofworkandunionstrugglesinLatinAmericaandforthe

socialexplosionsofunemployedworkersinsomanyotherpartsoftheworld.Not

tomentionthestruggleofthepiqueterosinArgentinaandthesocialstrugglesof

indigenous and popular communities for vital issues, such as battles against

privatization and the “commodification” of water, gas and oil, as has been

happening in Bolivia, Venezuela, In Uruguay and in other countries of our

continent.

These struggles increasingly take the form of movements against the

complete commodification of the world, against the totalizing (and totalitarian)

“commodification" of everything that is produced, and are increasingly being

intensified, in order to strike capital in a more persistent way in its own

materiality. Itsgreateststrength lies in indicatingthecentralityof itsstruggles in

the very own spaceof capital andof its system, andhence, extra-parliamentary

andextra-institutionalcentralstruggles.

As Mészáros teaches us, since capital is a system of social metabolism

whichisessentiallyextra-parliamentary,anyattempttoovercomeitthatislimited

to the institutional andparliamentary spherewill be impossible to carryout the

difficulttaskofdestroyingcapitalsystemanditssupportpillars.Thegreatestmerit

of these new social and politicalmovementsmentioned above flourishes in the

centrality that they confer on social struggles of essentially (or predominantly)

extra-parliamentaryprofile.

Page 7: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2218

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

The greatest challenge in the world of work and left-wing social

movements is to create and inventnew formsof autonomous action capableof

articulatingandgivingcentralitytoclassactionsagainstcapitalanditsdestructive

logic.Thisisatastagewherecapitalhasneverbeensodestructiveiwork,nature

andtheenvironment,inshort,tohumanity.

The refusal of the separation, introduced by the capital, between

economic action – carried out by the unions and by the political-parliamentary

actionoftheparties–betweensocialandpoliticalstrugglesconceivedseparately

–itisabsolutelyimperativeandevenindispensablewhenitisintendedtodefeat

thepowerfulsystemofsocialmetabolismstructureofthecapital,structuredfrom

thetripodstate,capitalandwagelabour5.Actionagainstthedominionofcapital

in search of socialismmust articulate social struggle and political struggle in an

inseparablecomplex.

The world of work and class social struggles, in their complex relations

withthestrugglesofecology,gender,ethnic,generational,forsubstantialequality

(Mészáros), have increasingly a globalized conformation.With the expansion of

capitalonaglobalscaleandthenewformassumedbytheinternationaldivisionof

labour,theresponsesoftheworkers'movementassumeagrowinguniversalizing

sense. Increasingly,national-levelstrugglesmustbearticulatedwithastruggleof

internationalscope.

The transnationalization of capital and its productive system forces the

workingclassandpopularstrugglesevenmoretofighttheprivatizationsofwater,

oilandgasandtofightfortherighttowork,forreducingtheirtimeandtheirwork

days, for the expansion of social rights, and finally, for vital issues. For this it is

imperative a strong international articulation in actions and struggles, both for

solidarity and for strengthening forms of confrontation. To the globalization of

capital corresponds, therefore, a globalization of social and labor struggles is

increasinglyanduntransferably.

5Idem.

Page 8: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2219

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

This is because theworking class in the contemporaryworld, in its new

morphology,ismorecomplexandheterogeneousthantheoneexistingduringthe

periodof fordistexpansion.TherescueofwhatAlainBihrcalledasenseofclass

belonging, against the numerous objective and subjective fractures imposed by

capital, is one of his most prompt6challenges. Yet, wemust have an expanded

conceptionofworkthatdoesnot leadustotheequivocalandEurocentricthesis

ofthemythoftheendofwork7.

Preventing precarious workers from being marginalized from forms of

class social and political organization is an imperative challenge in the

contemporary world. The understanding of the complex connections between

class and gender, between “stable” and precarious workers, between nationals

and immigrants, betweenworkers of different ethnic groups, between qualified

and unqualified, between young and old, between employees and unemployed,

ultimately,amongsomanyfractureswhichcapitalimposesontheworkingclass,it

becomesfundamentaltorespondthroughasocialandpoliticalmovementofmale

and femaleworkers in the search for andeffective realizationof a new socialist

projectinthis21stcentury.

Once again the redeeming sense of class belonging (which implies

understanding the conformations of the working class today and its new

morphology)isacrucialissueatthisturnofthecentury.

Twoexamplesmayhelpustobetterunderstandthisnewmorphologyof

work and social struggles. In Argentina, we witnessed the organization of

unemployedworkers,knownaspiqueteros,who,togetherwiththepauperization

ofthe8middleclasses,deposedtheDeLaRúagovernmentinDecember2001and

6Alain Bihr, From the big night to the alternative: the Europeanworkers'movement in crisis, SãoPaulo,Boitempo,1998.7Thisproblematicwasdeveloped inGoodbyetowork? (SãoPaulo,Cortez)andThesensesof labor(SãoPaulo,Boitempo).8Notadatradutora:Aacepçãonastraduçõesnaobramarxianaemportuguêsde“pauperizaçãodaclasse trabalhadora” equivalem ao inglês “immiseration of the working class”. Contudo, o termo“immiserated”nãomeparececorrente,por issoopteipor “impoverished”,masquepodeconotarumasimplicidadealheiaàconstruçãodacategoria.Pelorigorvocabularemetodológico,épossívelumareconstruçãodasentençapara“immiserationofthemiddleclasses”.

Page 9: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2220

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

severalalleged“presidents”inthe“daysthatunsettledArgentina”.Wehavealso

seentheexpansionofanimportantprocessoffactoryoccupationbytheworkers

(the “recovered factories”), struggling to preserve their jobs and wages, in a

country whose neoliberal governments have reached the maximum of servility

towardstheIMFanditsdestructivepolicy.

We can also recall the expressive zapatista resistance in Mexico, which

played a decisive role in the anti-neo-liberal social and political struggles of the

early 1990s,whenmany believed that history had ended its cycle; and also the

recent commune of Oaxaca, in 2005, which denudated the destruction of the

publicgoodtokenplaceinMexico.

Thus, despite theheterogenization, complexity and fragmentationof the

LatinAmericanworkingclassanditssocialstruggles,weadvocatethethesisthat

the possibilities of an effective human and social emancipation, through the

conquestofthesocialistalternative,canfindconcretenessandsocialviabilityfrom

the revolts and rebellions that originated centrally (and not exclusively) in the

worldofwork;aprocessofsimultaneousemancipationfromwork,atworkandfor

work.

This formulation does not exclude or suppress other important forms of

rebellion and contestation. But, living in a society that produces commodities,

exchange-values, whose logic is focused on the valorization of capital and its

perverse cycle, labour revolts end up having a statue of centrality in the direct

fightagainstcapital.

Thewholerangeofwageworkerscomprisingtheservicesector,plusthe

“outsourced” workers, the ones from the informalmarket, “domestic workers",

unemployed,theunderemployedandtheunemployed,theyallsumdecisivelyto

thedirectlyproductiveworkers,configuringthemselves inthesocialandpolitical

poleendowedwithgreaterpotentialityandanti-capitalistradicalism.

In the same way, ecological struggle, feminist movements, ethnic

(indigenous,black,immigrant)movements,LGBTs,etc.,amongothers,findgreater

Page 10: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2221

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

vigor and vitality when they manage to articulate their singular and authentic

claimsagainstthemultipleoppressionsofthecapitalsystem.

Inthecaseofecologicalandenvironmentalmovements, theaxisof their

strugglesmustbeagainstthedestructivelogicofcapital(whichdestroysnatureon

aglobalscale)and,inthecaseofwomen'sstruggle,theiractionsmustturnagainst

thefetishizedcharacter,outlandish,“desoralizing"andvirulentformofpatriarchal

domination which subordinates them in their double space, family and

professional, preventing their struggle in search of an effective substantive

equality.Thesamecanbesaidinrelationtothestruggleofvariouspeople,ethnic

groupsandculturesfortheruptureofthedeconstructionscarriedoutbycapitalto

preventtheattainmentofasubstantialequality.

Strikesandsocialexplosionsarealsoimportantexamplesofthenewforms

ofsocialconfrontationagainstcapital,giventhenewmorphologyoflaborandits

multifaceted character. Theymerge elements of these poles differentiated from

whatIhavebeencallingtheclass-which-lives-from-workandconstituteimportant

examplesof thesenewconfrontationsagainst thedestructive logic thatpresides

contemporary(dis)sociabilitythatthe21stcenturyhaswitnessedinintensityand

abundance. These struggles ultimately lead us to debate some important points

whenthinkingabout thedesignofasocialist societalproject in thiscentury that

begins.

Foranewwayoflife

Socialist enterprise can not effect another way of life if it does not grant labor

something radically different both from structural subordination to capital and

from its heteronomous sense, subordinated to a system of command and

hierarchy,asoccurredduringthevalidityoftheSovietsystemandinthecountries

of the so-called “socialist bloc” or “real socialism”, euphemism for hiding the

Page 11: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2222

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

affrontswhichimpededtheautonomyoflaboroutsidethegearsofcapitalandits

systemofcommand.

Thisbringsustoanothercrucialpointwhenitcomestounderstandingthe

truemeaningof labor in socialismand its profounddifference in relation to the

social formofworkunderthecapitalsystem.Aswehavedeveloped inthebook

“TheSensesofWork”,ameaningful lifeoutsideworksupposesameaningful life

withinwork.Itisnotpossibletoreconcilesalaried,fetishizedandoutlandishwork

withtrulyfreetime.Ameaninglesslifeatworkisincompatiblewithameaningful

lifeoutsidework.Tosomeextent,thesphereoutsideworkwillbetaintedbythe

ineffectivenesswhichhappenswithinlaborlife.

Astheglobalsystemofcapital,inourpresentday,alsointensivelycovers

thespheresoflifeoutsidework,thede-fetishisationofsocietyofconsumptionhas

as essential corollary the de-fetishisation in the means of production of things.

Whatmakesitsconquestmuchmoredifficultifonedoesnotdecisivelyinterrelate

action for free timewith thestruggleagainst the logicof capitaland thevalidity

oftheuseofabstractlabour.

If thefoundationofcollectiveaction is radically turnedagainst theforms

of (de)socialization of the commodity world, the immediate struggle to reduce

workingdaysorhoursbecomes importantand fullycompatiblewith theright to

work(lessworkinghourswithoutreductionofsalary).Inthisway,theimmediate

contemporary struggle to reduce working days or hours and the struggle for

employment, instead of being excluding, necessarily becomes complementary.

And societal enterprise formeaningfulwork and for authentic life outsidework,

for a time available forwork and for a truly free and autonomous time outside

work–both,therefore,outsidetheoppressivecontrolandcommandofcapital–

convertintoessentialelementsintheconstructionofasocialistsocietynolonger

regulated by the system of social metabolism of capital and its mechanisms of

subordination.

Thesocietalinventionofanewlife,authenticandendowedwithmeaning,

thus reinstates,at thebeginningof the21stcentury, the imperativenecessityof

Page 12: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2223

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

buildinganewsystemofsocialmetabolism,ofnewmeansofproductionbasedon

self-determined activity. Time-based available activity to produce socially

necessaryvaluesofuse,intheaccomplishmentofthesociallynecessaryworkand

against the heterodetermined production,which characterized capitalism, based

onthesurplus-timefortheexclusiveproductionofexchangevaluesforthemarket

andforthereproductionofthecapital.

The central constitutive principles, which must be present since the

construction of 21st century socialism, should be guided by the following

foundations:

1) the essential meaning of production and societal life will be directed

exclusivelytowardsreachingactualhumanandsocialneeds;

2) The exercise ofwork should always be synonymouswith self-activity,

free activity, basedon available time, in away that is deeply articulated

withthepreviousprinciple,basedonhuman-socialneeds.

Duringtheperiodofcapitalism(and,morebroadly,of thecapitalsystem

itself),theuse-valueofsociallynecessarygoodswassubordinatedtoitsexchange-

value,whichbegantogovernthelogicofthesystemofproductionofcapital.The

basicproductive functions,aswell as thecontrolof theirprocess,were radically

separatedbetweenthosewhoproduce(theworkers)andthosewhocontrol(the

capitalists and their managers). As Marx says, capital operated the separation

betweenworkersandthemeansofproduction,between“thesnailanditsshell”9,

deepeningtheseparationbetweenproductiongearedtothefulfillmentofhuman-

socialneedsandtotheneedsofself-reproductionofthecapital.

Sinceitwasthefirstsmeansofproductiontocreatealogicthatdoesnot

primarilytake intoaccountrealsocietalneeds,andwhichthereforealsodiffered

radically fromallpreviouslyexisting social control systemsofmetabolism (which

theyproducedinordertogiveprioritytotheneedsofhumanself-reproduction),

capitalhasestablishedasystemaimedatself-valorization,whichisindependentof

therealself-reproductiveneedsofhumanity.9KarlMarx,Capital(RiodeJaneiro,CivilizaçãoBrasileira,1971).

Page 13: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2224

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

The second essential societal principle is, as Marx teaches, to conceive

workasa vital activity, free, self-activity,basedon theavailable time.What this

meansissayingthatthenewsocialistsocietalstructuringmustrefusetooperate

on the basis of the dichotomous separation between working time needed for

socialreproductionandsurplus-labourtimeforthereproductionofcapital.Thisis

because the time available will be that expenditure of self-determined labour

activity, directed “towards autonomous activities, external to the money-

commodity relationship”10, deniers of the totalizing relationship given by the

commodity-formandthuscontrarytothecommodity-producingsociety.

Asaconclusion:alifefullofmeaninginallspheresofsocialbeing,givenby

social happiness and humanomnilaterality, can only be effected by demolishing

the barriers between working time and nonworking time, so that, from a vital

activity full of meaning, self-determined, beyond the hierarchical division that

subordinates work to current capital 11 and, therefore, under entirely new

foundations, a new sociability can be developed. Woven, as we present in our

book “The Senses of Work”, by socially and freely social associated individuals

(men and women), where ethics, art, philosophy, truly free time and otium, in

accordance with the most authentic aspirations, aroused within daily life, open

ways to the conditions for the realizationof the identitybetween individual and

human genre, in its multilateral dimension. A life with entirely new forms of

sociability,wherefreedomandnecessityaremutuallyfulfilling.12

Theexerciseofautonomouslabour,eliminatingtheexpenditureofexcess

time for the production of commodities, also eliminating the destructive and

superfluous time of production (spheres which are controlled by capital), will

enable the real rescue of the structuring meaning of living labour, against the

meaningof(de)structuringofabstractlabourforcapital.Thisisbecausethework

which structures capitaldeconstructs the socialbeing, that is, salariedwork that

gives meaning to capital generates an inauthentic subjectivity, alienated /10RobertKurz,Thecollapseofmodernity(SãoPaulo,PazeTerra,1992).11IstvánMészáros,op.cit.12RicardoAntunes,Thesensesofwork,op.cit.

Page 14: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2225

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

outlandishintheworkitself.Inaformofauthenticallysocialistsociability,labour,

byrestructuringhumanandsocialsenseofproduction,willdisruptcapitalandits

marketsystem.Andthissameself-determinedworkwhichwill rendercapitalno

meaningwillgeneratethesocialconditionsforthefloweringofanauthenticand

emancipatedsubjectivity,givinganewmeaningtowork.

If work becomes endowedwithmeaning, it will also (and decisively) be

through art, poetry, painting, literature,music, free time, otium, that the social

beingcanbehumanizedandemancipatedinitsdeepestsense.Whatwouldbea

ravishingattemptof21stcenturysocialism.

References

ANTUNES,Ricardo.Adeusaotrabalho?(SãoPaulo,Cortez)

________.Ossentidosdotrabalho(SãoPaulo,Boitempo).

BIHR, Alain. Da grande noite à alternativa: o movimento operário europeu em

crise,SãoPaulo,Boitempo,1998.

CHESNAIS,François.Amundializaçãodocapital,SãoPaulo,Xamã,1996.

KURZ,Robert.Ocolapsodamodernização(SãoPaulo,PazeTerra,1992).

MARX,Karl.CríticadaFilosofiadoDireito/Introdução,SãoPaulo,Boitempo,2005e

MARX,Karl;ENGELS.AIdeologiaAlemã,SãoPaulo,Boitempo,2007.

MARX,Karl.Ocapital(RiodeJaneiro,CivilizaçãoBrasileira,1971).

Page 15: Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in ... · Socialism, social struggles and the new way of life in Latin America O socialismo, lutas sociais e novo modo de vida

2226

Rev.DireitoePráx.,RiodeJaneiro,Vol.08,N.3,2017,p.2212-2226.RicardoAntunesDOI:10.1590/2179-8966/2017/29906|ISSN:2179-8966

MÉSZÁROS,István.Paraalémdocapital,SãoPaulo,Boitempo,2002.

AbouttheauthorRicardoAntunesProfessorofLabourSociologyatUNICAMP.Author,amongotherbooks,ofTheSensesofWork (Boitempo, also published in Italy, England / Holland, USA, Portugal, India andArgentina); Goodbye to Work? (Ed. Cortez, also published in Italy, Spain, Argentina,ColombiaandVenezuela)andWealthandMiseryofLaborinBrazil(organizer,Boitempo),Vol. I, II and II. Coordinates the World Work Collections, by Boitempo and Work andEmancipation, by Popular Expression publisher. In the first half of 2017 he was VisitingProfessoratCa'FoscariUniversityinVenice(Italy).E-mail:rlcantunes53@gmail.com.Theauthoristheonlyresponsibleforwritingthisarticle.