53
Wrijving en slijtage van kunststofproducten Jan Spoormaker Spoormaker-Consultancy in Reliability and Liability of Plastic Products Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren

Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

  • Upload
    vophuc

  • View
    222

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Wrijving en slijtage van kunststofproducten

Jan Spoormaker

Spoormaker-Consultancy in

Reliability and Liability of

Plastic Products

Society of Plastics Engineers Europe

Tribologie/polymeren

Page 2: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Friction and wear of plastic products

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 tekst

Friction

Friction is a force that resist relative movements between two surfaces in contact.

Wear

Wear is a process in which interaction of surface(s) or bounding face(s) of a solid with

the working environment results in the dimensional loss of the solid, with loss of

material.

Friction and wear are system properties

Tribology

Science about friction, lubrication and wear

Tribotechnology

Engineering application of tribology

Page 3: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Tribological System according to Czichos

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Relative movement

Gliding, rolling

Load Fn

Velocity v

Ambient temperature

Friction force Fw

Friction coefficient f, μ

Wear h

Friction temperature

Noise

Loads &

environment

Loads &

environment

Tribological

quantities

Surface parameters

Roughness

Macro geometry

1. Body

2. Body

3. Substance

4. Environment

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.1

Page 4: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

- polymerisatie

- ketenopbouw en ketenlengte

- fysische eigenschappen

- kristallisatie

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO-2040-20081201

Polymeren

Plastics are fantastic, they can fail in many

unexpected ways

Page 5: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Polymeriseren en ketenlengte

additiepolymerisatie

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO-2040-20081201

Page 6: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Polymeriseren van etheen C2H4 PE

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO2070-20100215

Page 7: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Polymeriseren van etheen C2H4 PE

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO2070-20100215

onvertakt

vertakt

Page 8: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Ketenlengte

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.1

Page 9: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Ketenlengte

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.1

Page 10: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Ketenlengte van PE

Paraffine (500 g/mol ) lijmtube (105 g/mol) UHMW-PE (5.106 g/mol)

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO2070-20100215

Page 11: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Molecuulmassa - sterkte en viscositeit

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO2070-20100215

Page 12: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Amorf en semi-kristallijn

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO2070-20100215

tie-molecule

Page 13: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Kristallisatiesnelheid

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO2070-20100215parison

Page 14: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

wrijving

slijtage

contactoppervlak

vervorming

cohesie en adhesie

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO-2040-20081201

Pwrijving en slijtage bij kunststoffen

Page 15: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Normal force, drag force and friction force

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Material combination μ, f

PA6 - PA6 (no lubrication)

1.20

PA6 – POM (no lubrication)

0.60

PA6 – PTFE (no lubrication)

0.10

POM – POM (no lubrication)

0.55Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.3

Page 16: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Wear

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Material combination wear factor k

POM – steel (Ra = 0.1 μm) 2 10-15 m2/N

POM – steel (Ra = 0.6 μm) 80 10-15 m2/N

h k p v t

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.4

Page 17: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Micro contact surface

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.5

Page 18: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Deformation

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.6

Page 19: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Physical processes cohesion and adhesion

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Bonding forces

Cohesion

Adhesion ----------

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.9

Page 20: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

ruwheid

snelheid

stick-slip effect

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO-2040-20081201

Wrijving bij kunststoffen

Page 21: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Friction coeeficient as a function of roughness

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

High yield strength Low yield strength

Surface roughness Surface roughness

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.10

Page 22: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Friction coefficient as a function of roughness for

POM and HDPE

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Roughness Ra (μm) Roughness Ra (μm)

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.11

Page 23: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Friction coefficient as a function of speed

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Speed

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.12

Page 24: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Mass-spring model

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.13

Page 25: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Stick-slip effect

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

time

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.14

Page 26: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

deformatie

adhesieve slijtage

abrasieve slijtage

pitting

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO-2040-20081201

slijtage bij kunststoffen

Page 27: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Boundary and deformation zone

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

• Boundary zone

• Deformation zone

Hard roughness

asperity top

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.15

Page 28: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Adhesive wear

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.16

Page 29: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Abrasive wear

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.17

Page 30: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Shear stress for rolling contact

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.18

Page 31: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Pitching as a result of fatigue

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Fatigue cracks Pitting

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.19

Page 32: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Knieprothese

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Page 33: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Knieprothese

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Page 34: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Putvorming in UHMPE

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Page 35: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

slijtage – ruwheid

meten van slijtage

vlaktedruk – pv waarde

warmte-ontwikkeling

PTFE

Hardheid

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO-2040-20081201

Lagers

Page 36: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Wear as a function of roughness for POM and HDPE

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.20

Page 37: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Wear as a function of roughness and pressure for PA6.6

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.21

Page 38: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Wear as a function of pressure

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.22

Page 39: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Different wear tests

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.23

Page 40: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Pin on disk

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.24

Page 41: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Calculation of average bearing pressure and wear

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

p 43MPa

h k p v t

FT D

p

Extra

Page 42: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Heat flux and Average Bearing Pressure

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

2(W/m )h f p v

- heat flux

f – friction coeficient

p – average bearing presure

v - velocity

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 tekst

Page 43: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Critical pv-values

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 Fig. 3.25

Page 44: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Prediction of wear

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

h k p v t

k – wear factor

p – average bearing presure

v – velocity

t - time

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 tekst

Page 45: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Coefficients of friction and wear rates

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

1 1h k p v t 2 2h k p v t

Extra

Page 46: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Effect of PTFE content on wear

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Extra

Page 47: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

PTFE & silicone to reduce friction and wear

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Extra LNP Lubricomp

Page 48: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Effect of hardness on wear

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Extra LNP Lubricomp

Page 49: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Effect of shaft finish on wear (micro-inches!)

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Extra LNP Lubricomp

Page 50: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

warmte-ontwikkeling

vermoeiing

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

IO-2040-20081201

Tandwielen

Page 51: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Failure analysis

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Extra

Page 52: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Failure analysis

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

Extra

Page 53: Society of Plastics Engineers Europe - VeMet · Society of Plastics Engineers Europe Tribologie/polymeren. Friction and wear of plastic products Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability

Guidelines for plastic bearings

Spoormaker Consultancy in Reliability & Liability of Plastic Products

• Metal bearing surfaces must be smooth (< 1 μm), hard and corrosion

resistant.

• Wear particles must be collected in grooves.

• Bearing clearance must account for high thermal expansion and absorption

of water (PA)

• The average bearing pressure should preferably be not higher than 1 N/mm2

and at most 5 N/mm2.

• The out-of-roundness of bearings should be as small as possible and film

gates are preferred.

• Bearing plastics with PTFE are preferred especially for applications without

lubrication.

• Boundary lubrication is must better than running dry.

• Grease or oil can affect plastic bearings (swelling & ESC)

Dictaat Hfdst. 3 tekst