THUAT CHIEU HON.pdf

7/17/2019 THUAT CHIEU HON.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/thuat-chieu-honpdf 1/97

';:*.

l-r

I

Ttr

vi

tt'grl ddi : Nti mang

lil

()Nc

ouot

NHqN

i

]'t'r

vi

dArl

se;

ilruc

h[nh

\

Di0n

c*rrr.tarn

ilff

Ngq,.

hap chdrrh l0rrg

I

{,1

i\[n-r' tlrhrr

trrmrif

"

gdnc

unlt

(lhitrn

tinh hr;c

thqtc hhnlt

Tidng

11dri ct"rn6|$n

lny

Bi

mdt

lrong }[n

tay

o

s,.j.

e6,ru{r

.,.

€} i,

'Roi

dich

rlAn

giti4[*

DQu

giap

tuq"-eidflJ

rufN

triu

{fi

I(hbng_

I\linh

thhn

todn-

thidt

tlrr

J

,

'

Bdt rlu{i

thnr

nguy$p

,

s

(iia

Cat

hinr

tibn

thhr($',tbdri

V{n

han

hAng

nirm ('I'\i0n

ftuan

tu

ph0c)

.

IRiN

}AI

rJNH

n:,:

,

t(hbng

r\lirrli

thhn

'torin

HuYIN

Go

(

..,',*,

vi

chlnh b;,in,

,",i"

,

Bi

tl fANo

lli

qrrydt

boi

bhi

'

GPKD

36

2tl3

ETTIPHNT

nsdu

tr0-E-72,

:

*j

'ti

.

t'

'l*tl

".r"$

,-;q1'

rt

t6

,

ffi



1;.

i

rr

'

a

-'

,.

r.

':.:t

.t

,.,'

'

.

),, .'

.ol

l

i:,i'.'

THf,N

IJNH

Hgc'i:'"

*

rHU{r

CHIEU

t/-1

4&'-r""-o.^,

j

l



'.

:-,1'..:,

,

..

i..,.,,

,

i

'

"",t

l

NGUVEW

KHOA

HAiN

x

LINII

IISC

-^\

fiHltl|

il0t{

,,

t*i-

'ffi

rri-

r'.il

ffi

,

,;l

tr'f

.ir1

t

t,:

T

)'\

T'HAN

A

Ht|AT



,l

l:j$

,.;l

r(

.

;tl

,.::

r,

,.,i

,"t

.

,:,

I

''

i

,'i

'

N/rfrn.g

ltiCn

YiQt-Nam

md

cdn

)Idt

sd

itdnq

Sau

iIAg

id.

Lrong

ldc,

ph&nt

Tt/A

ttqng

uE

dbng bdttg

khdng

phdi

chi

cd

&

.

:

rdg'ra

&

nhibu

nuhc

khde.

tr\n

Ih6.

gtoi.

bdo

& ViAt-Nam

theo <

nghb

dbng

b6ng.

>

i

j

m|t

dogn

ud.n

cfia Ltong

Erlc Thi|p

ui6t

(

{d-ftff

ViQt-Nam

n

(trang

323-3251 :

<

Nhring ngadi

thb

thd.nh

Htng-Eqo

(Thdnh Trdnl

ud

thdnh

Li6,u-Ilqnh

(Thdnh Phit-Ebng, Thdnh Eln

Sdng)

ca

tl6n

,,20

thdng

tdnt ta ngdg Lrtg I'hd.nh'Trkn

vd

ngdg

I

thdnr)

ba

ld.

ngdg

uia

mdu

tsi

dEn

Ki6p-Bqc

(H&i-daong)

dEn

B&o-Ldc,

d4n

Trftc-Mgc

(Nam-E-inft) ud ilbn

Phfi-Dky

(Thanh-IIda'S ldm 16.

ud

ld,n

ilbng

ttb

trft

td,

trir

tQt binh.

N/rftnE

ngudi

lhd'

Dac,l'hdnh

Trdn ud

Thdnh

Mdu

Qi6u-

Ilutth)

ctlng

thd

chr

ui thad,ng

g7,i

Id

Ebng

c6i

ldng

Ebng,

bd

DbnE)

ildn

bd,

con

gdi,

con

trai

n6.u

tem

bdi

thdg'ph&i

s6

tha

tn

itln

cdc

ph&,

cdc

dbn.

Idm

lA

ddi

bdt

nhang ilb

ciiu bfn ldm con

cdng

dA tri'.

Ngudf

bi

'cdc

ui

Cdng-chua

(corr

Nsoc

lladng) bd.t

ldm

con

$bng

thl

goi

Id

dbng

Duc

Ms.,

Ldn d.dng

cfia

cd.c

6ng

Hdang ffr

tht

gpi

Id

ilbng

E(c

}ng,', Cdn

ilbng c6,

ddnq

cdu

Id can

ilbng

cfia cdc

uong

hbn

tt nh6

chtt

nhdm

qid

thi6ng. 7'4i

ftOt

Phrt

Dkg

ud

tb'n

Song

cdc

bll

tlbng

thadng

thi

nhau udo

gieo

dm

dvong

xudt

b&n:

-_

NGUOI

i

(in liin

uruc

"'mQr

rAc

olA

HUNG

(dich

Aus

eiqener

Kraft'

c&a

2)

Wilhelmine

Yon

Hillern

-

RU

-

NHirNCl

xudt

t&

-l-

NnBu

-

SIIIU

H

LUar

gue

vu

HQc

NH1P

MoN

Gi6

I]6n

Phaong'nuilt

t&n

19671

HIBN

TU,Q,'N0

SIEU

t{iNIT

(Nftd rudt

bdn

Phsnt-udn-Taoi1957)



th

I

cfr

nguti

trfing

tug'en

ldm bd'

tlbng

quan'

Trong

khi IEn

ilbng

hag

rahc

.

gid

6ng

ilbng

ud

bd

rtbng

cing

iIbngl

c6,

itbngij

cdu

illu

,n'd',

do

chtt

khd'n

tanh

itd

sdc

sd'

N/rilng

dng dbng

tdn

cd

tdc

'ji6n

linft

'sdLt

udo

c'6

udo

md'

hodc

thdt c'6 o&rtg

a&

I{a,

khta

ladi

b&ng

tlao

il"i

tr,tt

tir.

horic

ldg

md.u

uE

btia,

bho con

bQnh

u6ng

(m6i

klti

hrinh

til).

trong

khi

rnrta

I6,n

iaOng

(c6

cr? ntrrrc)

c6

tuc

nh&g

nrrta'

hd hit,

qudt

lhdo

hodc

hdt

rad:ng,

l

,Eqo

phu

thrtg

iad

ilbnq

c6t

rdt

thlnh

hdnh

ttong

ddtt

gicn.

Ntrit

nE

ngrti

,

c6

bdnh

thtdng

iI6n

thdg

phn

thfig

uE

tri b6nh

ua

ftlru

tri:ic

td.

l'a

/roric

ttrinh

rlbng

thi6,p tu6ng

thd:m

tb fiAn

dudi

drn

Phfi.

.,,Ngodi

cae

rqr

]stng

bdi

phb

thdnq

trt'n

ildg crta

dso

qida

cdn

cd

phep

1hlt

co

(phu

Ebng

ti6nl udcdch''ggi

d'i'

Dil.ng

m6t

nqadi

cti,

khi6n

ri€ng

ldm

trung

gian itb,

h6i

han

y

kif.n

qui

thdn

ud:, cdc

uong

hbn... >

Tdc

gt&

Aa

khdch

quan

ghi lqi

tin n.qlr.Fng

crta

mlt

s6

t6ng-bdo

vi{t-Nam

thco

quan

ttib.m cfia

k6

ui6,t

uE

lchoa

rii-[rii

ltgc.

I

rin

thdnh

I

Chfing

t6i trich ra.

itd'g

cfing

rrhrnE chung

tdi

cdn

c6

g khdc

Ia

rlr)ng

b6ng

Id

nt6t

tln

ngud'ng

c6

oar

t6

a

ngli kh6.ch

quan

rd,ng

ttn ngtdng

ub

noi

ngadi

Viff-Narn.

Tronq

c6ng

cuQic

ndng cao

dd'n

tri,

gifra

ud'n-ilb'

ch6ng

nte

fin

di

iloan

ud

I

t\n

trqng

try-do

ttn

ngat)ng

chftng

la

phin cdn

nhdic

kgi,Iudng.

Chfing

tdi

ta&ng

t&ng

chi cdn

trtnh-bdg

nhrtng

tai

hgi

cfia

il6ng

bdnq

&

dranr

ndo ud

nhiin,g

nghi.

udnuE.

udn

ill

linlvirng

cd.ng

itaqc drtt

|a

cho

nhilng

ai

thien

u)

plrdn

tdrn

linft

dd

hug4n-bt

dttgc

tho&-mdn,

Ilitn

kh&o

mQt

td.c phhm

ri€ng

ub,

dbng

b6ng

vi(t-Nam

theo

Ithia

csnh khoa-hgc,

itii

h6l chrtng fti

rdt nhibu

tht

git

ud

c6ng

kh6

kh6ng

phdi

chi iIftng,

ub,

mdt

ph6ng

s{r

tli4u

tra

db

k:e

lgi',

ntd

cdn

cdn

dilng

cdc

ti6u

chudn

khoa

hoc

ilb

klfio

sdt

hhe-binh

ptui.n

tich

hiQn

ttqngl

nhdt

H

chn

thdi

qian, cdc

idi

IiQu

cg

thb.,

cdcb&ng

eo

gbm

c&

nhdn

chftng.

Odng uiQc

dg ddi

hii

ntQt

sg nghi€n-cuu

ldu

ddi

cd tchi

chi

theo

d\i

ntQt

con itbng

trong

udi

mroi

bubi

len

dbng

ud

ph&i

c6

sg

pfu1

td.

cfia

m6t

s6

cdc

nhd

khoa-hgc

hodc

'gioi

khdcnfur b6.c-si,tdm

linhhgc gia,tdm

lg hoc gia,cdc

nhd

chirc trdch hdnh

chdnh

ud tv phdp

tia

fhtong

noi r&g

ra

li.(n tuqng,

cilnq ldm

uiQc

phung

ubi ttt

cdch m t

rtg-ban

nghi€n-cttu,

cd cdc bifln

b&.n

k&

thrtc

uilc

ililu-tra,

C6ng

uiQc ndg

&

nahc

ta

kh6ng

cd,

trdi

lqi

i.

cdc

rurd:c lihr

b0

iIfr

c6.

Chrtng fti

tg

nghi

c6

thb

ldm

c6ng

uiQc thu

hai

Id

bitn kh&o

mdt

tdp

sdch nhd

ndi

uE Ebng

b6ng

& ngosi

qu6c

ud

nhfrng

cing uiQc

dd

ldm

& nrhc

ngodi.

Vdn-iIE

ilbng

b6ng

&

n:a.bc ngod.i

dd

Id" ild.u

iL

cho

nlidu

cudc

tranh-Iu[n.

M\t

h7c

thagdt

phdt

sanh ra

tt

ilbngl

bdng Id

'Ihdn

linh

hgc

'hog

Thflng-Iinh

thug6,t

(Spiritisme)

ch& traong

r&no

ngadi

s6ng

cd

thb giao

thiQp

uhi kE

ch\t.

IIgc

thug6,t

ndg bdnh-trubng

6'

Au-Mfi

ud

cdc

phai

c6ng

kich hag bdnh-ugc

hgc

thug6,t

nag

cfing

rdt

nhi4u.

Vt

tE

d6

tdc phlm ndg

phdn

I|n

chfi

trgng

trtnh-bdg

hoc thuytt

tlrdn

linh,

cd.c

cttQc

khdo-ctru

cfia hgc gid

phdi

ndg,

cd.c

cuQc

tranh

IuQn

gifta tradng

.

Thd.n

linh

hgc

od.

cdc hgc

Ilwg6t

mdn

phdi khdc tit

kll.r,a

hugbn-bi-hgc

cho it6.n

khoa

hgc

thryc-nghtQm

cfing nh:r

g

ki6n

crta

cdc

thn-gido.

ud.

tri4t-gia

il6i ubi

v6n-il?

ndy,



iii,,ll

Nhang

cdc

con

tbng

tr Au-Mfi

dd.

c6

&nh

hatrnq

gt

it6,n

rF

li6n-trftn

ub.

tu-tt&ng

con ngtdi

?

Ngodi

uiQc

ph,dt

snnft

ra thug6t

k

Thdn

linh

hgc >

n6

cdn

ldm

cho

cdc

nlzir

nghi4n-cttu

uE

ldm-Iinh

m&

ra

mgt

trnbnq

mOi

ld

khou

Si6u

td,m.

Ig (Pgrapsgchologie)

md

trgng

tdm

crta

n6

ngrig

nag

tdm

ttdo

danh-ttt

SiAu

ft,m

linh

(M6tapsgchique).

fl

ffig

quu tu

ui(c

nglitLn-cftu

cdc,

ndng

lvc

bi

hn

cdn

tilm

tnng

nei

con

ngatl

trit

hiQn

taqng

thdn

nhdn

it6n

I6i

thhn

giao

cdch

cdm.

.i

sqr rudt

hign

cfia'

cdc

a.

con

ttbng

>

dd

td'r

crrc khoa-hoc

bdt

ddu

chrt

(En m|t

dia-hst

trilrc

kia

cdc

nhd

bdc

hge

It

.mudn

Abi

g

A n, mQt

tlia

hgt

<<

cdm

>,

nt6t

dia_hgt

mA

iln

di

'iloan

chl itdng

cho

bon s

dL"n

ngu ,>

tin_Iutittg

nfi

kl'l.

ndi

i16.4

ngwdi

ta

kh6ng

thb

ktftng

pht

cadi

hng

biu

mdt

lti

ui

khirth-bi.

Dd

Id

mptlsq

il6.n-bd

ltn

khi

klrca

hgc

trrufun

clrug.in

hu&nq

uo,o

tdnh-uqc

hugbn

bt, tdm-linh,

phgm-ui

crta khaa

tinh

Thhn

hoc.l

T'hdl uQg,

Nu

khi

khoa

tdnul

utl

tt6p tlrco

lrhoa

tim

phdn

hgc itd

glfip

cho uiQc

khdtn

phd

phdn

ndo

rrdi

titrt

con ngadi,

mdti

linh

ugc

mii it

ai

chrt

y.

KIrca

siitt

td.nt

Iinh

cd nhfrng

iquan-tibm

khdc

u(ti

hgc thug\t

iltd.n-linh,

sd

bb

trtc

url

soi'

sdng

khta

cgnh

klfil

crta

ufuvitE.

iBian-klfio

idch

ndg

chrt4g

kJi

chi.

mong

g6'p

nt6t

it

tdi-Iitu

cn

dali

tag

db

trtnh-bdg

udn

ilb ilbng

b6ng

uni

t(c-gi&

Vi(t-Nam

ua

hQu

qud

cfia

sF

phdt

sanh

ra

phong

trdo

dbng

b6ng trAn

tht

gi6i.

lGlita

Mc

6

cac

hi/an-tornol

f

ViQt-Nam

clpfing

ta

cho

Id,

mA

ftn

di

doun

:

ilbng

bdno |"a khdrro ri ni ohin nnhilrn.

i0n-,taqng;

ilbng

bdng

ina

khirtg

c6 ai

chiu

nghitn_

I

rl

l

aau,

chrtng Ldi

thdg

cd

bbn phQn

trtnh

bdy

ty

hihu

,bi6t

hs.p

hdi

crta

chrtng

fti

d6i

u6i

odn-itE

ggi

ld g6p pftdn

udo

cdng

ui(c

ndng

cao

dd.n

tri.

chdns

/gr

su mt

tin

crg-doan

c&a

ddn

ertfing

Id

titu

rhrtng

tdi

qugdt

rdnt

ilco

tlubi

song

phdi

chi

16

eh6

nao

ld

ht

chd

nrlo

ld thryc,

phdn

biet

ilaqc

gi(t

ud.

chdn ,,d

klfinq

ldnt

hcti

d6.n qugbn

tg-do

tin

nguhng

cfia

h9.

Chung

t6i

cfingy

lg.i

uftng

tin

r&.nq

phdn

tdm

linh

crtrt

,ton

ngndi

nfit

nqdg,

kia

sE

dagc

hibu

16

hon

kh6ng

phdi

t'hi

bdng

khoa

hoc

uQt

chdt

ud

khoa

hgc

thtpc-nglitm

mcl

crdrilt

b&'ng

khoa

hgc

tinh-thdn,

phdn

md

cdc ilgo-tt

ud

hugbn-bt

hoc

hibu

rd

hon

Id

cdc

nhd

bdc

hgc

c&a

khoa*hpc

hitn

kint,

phdn

chi

do

bdn

thdn

chdn

tdtn

kinh

nghi(m

khtrm

phd

allr/r

kh|ng

phfri.

do

ktnh

ph|rtg

tqi

cfia

nhd

ui

trt)ng

hgc

hug

con

dao

cfia nhd

uiiii

phdu

md

tim

ra

ttuqc

ui

kh6ng

th|

'ding

khi

cu udt

clfit.

'l

unq

nlrd

khdo'cau

uE

tdm

phdn

hgc

sau

khi

ili

tt6.tt

tdt

ctung1 ud

klrca

tdnt

phd"n

hoc

ild

tu thu

trti.

,b

u6.i.

rdn

htLn

si4uJinh,

Brtg

gid'

chi

con

udn-t|

bao

giu

khoa

hgc

trt,ji

cltiu

'bd

dla

hqt

<

udt

chdt

>

tlt,

sang

dia

hqt

< trnft-lftdrr

r

ftdrr

.klfim-phd

b&n

thh.

con

ngadi

oa'

m6i

liin;quan

r:fra

rfi

voi

Vii-Tru.

Chi

cO m{t phuong-phdp

tbng

hop

nt6t

con

ttudng

trrcti,

:nto'i

soi

sdnq

daqc

n:r/,t

odn-d|

Idm

tlfic

rtrlLc

nhr.irn

loni

lir

ldu,

I

{l

il,

tl

lt

ff

il

ll

I



'l

Sp

ktraf

sfn&

mAt

:buhc

iId.u.

Vi6t-Na/ir

ta

I€

trgng

nhu

thd

hag

ldnr

linh

I'

I

i

,dl

h|i

l

I

\tdo

'khdng

chu

pao

?

l

i\

i

I

IrAn

thf

gihi

Id

{

d4n

mdt

ud,n

tIE quan

Hud

G-19b8

'

Sti-gdn

1i-r-9

l95B

.Nha-trang

10-lgtitt

Tfc

gil

: Nguydn

Khoa

HuAn

Iryc

I

l

.i

chuong

t.-

ouAN

urlrn

vE sU

air

rfr

c0a

tlNH

'

I

mdn

ouA

cAc

rncrl

EAt' 16r

alAo

YA

'

oiu

TQc.

Cfc

dfin

tQc

qua

cAc

thdi-dqi

dbu

tin-tu&ng

rfing

ngudi

ta

vdn

c0n s6ng

sau

khi

chdt

(1). Kh0ng

nhfrng

th6, cic

lOn

giflo phln dOng cfiirg

nhln

nh{n

rfrng sau

khi

qu{

vIng

con

ngu<ri

dang

cdn

c6

mQt

cdl

gi

(2)

NIA

vln hlo

PhAp

Georges

Barbarin

trong tlc

pbhm

<

L'apr0s mort

I

(Le grqnd

probldnne

de

I'au-dell)

Librairie

Astra,

df;

dtrng

tron

mQt

phtn

tllu

ii& nghi0n-criu cdc

clnh

gi&i

cira

con ngudi sau

khi chdt

ttr

clc

tin

ngudng

cira [Iy-Lqp

qua

T0y-'tqng

rldn

Thi0n-chta-giAo,

Hbi-6iAo,

PhAt

gifo

vl

clc

m0n

phAi

cfin

huybn

bi hqc.

CAc srg

dfin

ch&ng

fiy

clrting

tOl tu&ng

kh6i

phii

trlnh

biyi

ra

tlf,y

vA

dQc

gil

nio

mudn

bi6t

xin

ilgc

c{c

sAch

thetn

kh*o dd

k0

ra

trong chuong

nAy.

tham

khto

s6

53.

tham khlo

sd

54.

(l)

Xem

(2)

Xbm

tAi liQu

tli

liQu



(huons

n,-

NGubN

o6c

vA

rlcn-rnlnn

rlfn

rntEx

'lat^

CUA CHIEU HON

THUAT.

I

Nhu

chrtng

tf

dil

rd

'sau

khi

Gon

ngudi cb6t

thi

'phhn

xAe thAn

laq rff

song

phhn

tinh

anlr vdn

cdn.

ltAy

giu

th& h6i

'ngudi

tlog co

thb

nio

ti6p

xdc

vdi

ngucri

chdt

noi

phln lintr anh

6y kh0ng?

rl(hoa chi0u

hbn thu{t

dd,p

rXng

c6

thA.,

'

Einh

rghia daqh

tu

chi0u hbn

thutt

dich d chii Spiri-

tisme

tfra

ti6ug PhAp.

froug

cu6n

trl

rliSn

Vocatrulaire

'technigue

et critifiue

de

la

philosophie

sfia Andrd

l,alande

co

gifri

thlch <

4

hqc

thu56t theo

d6

tinh

thhrr cfia

uhting

ngudi cbdt crlu tgog

sau khi chdt.

Phhn

v{t

chdt

cr;c ki'

mong

manh ndy

irlrung

thudng

lA khOng

th8

do

urht thu&ng

lhdy

duoc

c6 thb

.

ti6p

irlc

v{ri

ngu0i sdng

nh} &

vili

lrudng

hgp,

thudng

tA

do hAnh

dQng

c{ra

cdc

dbng

tfr

(mddiums)

>.

i

Nhung

trutrc

ktri khoa

chi4u

hbn

dtroc Allan

Knrdec

(H.

Itivail)

&

l'hCp

l{p

thAnh

hoc

thuydt

ggi

lA

'th}n

Linh-

hqc

(1353)

troDg

itec

pnhm

Le

livre des

Bsprits

(tsAo

'l'rinh

Nh{t

de

di:h

th[nh

Thhn-Ti0ri Kinh)

chtng

ta

chn bi6t

qua

di6n ti6n

cirl

ptrong trAo

I

nAy

tei c*c nu0c

Au

Mi.

THUAT cUTEu Ubu

c6

nhiEu tidng

dQng

mqnh

vl

nhiEu

cAnh

cfra

sb

bi

m&

i

ra'

rl6ng

vio,

lAm rung chuy8n

db dqc

vl

mbn

ra bi

l4t'

tung. Nhibu bin tay

lquh

vA

cring d6n

sd vAo

cAc

c6

Fox.

Nh&

cd

cich

gd

tr0n vAch

mi nh&ng

ti6ng

gd

lAm

thAnh

nhiing chfl

(nhu

ki0u buu diQn

tlf,

dtng

chfr morse)

bbn

ma cho

bi6t

t6n

c0

ta

tru0c kia

lt

Charles

Rosna,

cho

bidt

rii nghb

nghi$p

nbibu

chi

ti&

vb

cdi

chdt

thlm

hgi

ctra

cd

ta bi

chdn

.&

d6 sau khi

bi

Am

s{t.

Sau

tl6

do nhiing

dibu

ndy ngu&i

ta dio

duoc

xtrcrng c&a

mQt

ngudi

chdt

trong

khu

nhA

nCry

drlng

nhu

ch6

chi

ddn

(l).

ChnyQn

nAy

lAm cho

rlAn chring

trong

vilng

keo

d6n noi

dy

rdt'

r{Ong

clB

xem. Gia

atinh

tror

phli tim

cdch

ddi

ctr6

&. Sau

d6

hbn

kE

ctrdt'

vfin blm

theo

vi

cOng

chrlng

ti6p

tlrc

dusc

xem

ciic

hi$n tugng

tlbng

b6ng

dY.

Con

tqi

ngOi

nhl

&

Hydesville

kh6ng

nhfrng

chi

c6'

ml4h

Charles

Rosna

hiQn lOn

mil

cdn

c6

nh&nq

hbn

kh{c

cl6n

du. EiEu

nAy khidn

ngudi

ta

thAnh

Hp

nhibn

nh6m

d6 choi

vdi ma,

ban

dhu

lim

kiEu

biln

xay

rbi

sau

ddn

hidm tirng mlnh

96

dhy

cho

ch4v (nhu

hlnh

con

co

bOn

ta).

Nhfrng

biQn

tugng vb

chiOu

hbn

niry

lan

truyBn

kh8p

Hoa-Kj.

D&n

chring

trong

nu&c

ciria

lAm

hai

phe,

ngu&i

tin

kA kh0ng

tin

cii

nhau

klch

liQt

nhdt

ll

tr0n mlt

b{o

clri.

Te

id6

nhiBu

nhA

trt-thuc

danh-tidng

dB tlm nghi0n

cuu

c6c hi$n-tugng

ney.

Chring

tOi

xin

kA

scr linh

muc

(1f Mu6n

16

Enrme

Hardinge

rom

:

Elstory

of

modern

amorican

rpirituelism

cfiar

(trang 294).

v.

'; rP

ttir

tai

Tai

IIoa-Ki1.1Sg truybn

bA khoa

mQt

hi$n

tufng nhA

bi

ma

phA

Mi.

Nhl

"ill

iq

striGu hbn

bAt dhn

1B4S & Hydesville

&,

Sd 1A

d0m

d0rn

tr

ll

ti

I

gia

iinu

lhg

Fo*

i

.i



TEAN

-rNE

EQC

tsrittein,

blc

si

Hallock,

Iintr

mBG

Briswold'

gi{o

su

Robert

Hare

&

dqi hgc

dulng

llavard,

Ong

chAnh

ln

Edmonds'

thugng

nghi

si

lTaltmadge,

nhi

ngogi

giao

R'

lDale

owen'

fft

cfr

aUu

ili tlfo

kdt

luin

c6

sq

cen

thi$p c&a c6i

v0

hinh.

(l).

Nlm

1852

c6i

ghn

15000

chfr

kJ

cfra

thrrdng

dAn

IlIf

l

y€u

clu

I

thuqng

nghi

viQn

[Ioa

Ki'

dflt

&y-ban

khoa

boc

ig

oghiOn-ctiu

vb

cAc

vdn-dE'

a

Chi0u

hbn

thu{t

I vl

nlm

isso

"hou"rt

Harel

trinh

bly

cib

c0ng

cuQc

1{ien

cuu

c'&a

OnS

tlodg

tfc

Pfhm

nhan

db

1r

Expdrim:"ill

to"t:tigations

of

tbe

Spirit

Manileslation

r.

Robert

f)ale

Owen

trong

t{c

phhm

(Floot

fatls

bn

tbe

Boundary

of

anolher

world

(Sur

h-

ii-ir"

d'un

autre lmonde) ltt77

duoc

hoan-ngbCnh

nhiet

li0t'

Sso

lao

ll

gilo-su

James

hyslop

dqy

khoa

tAm

lJ

hoc

tsi

.l+i

hoc

ttudn-gicolumbia

d

Nfw

york

nghion-cfu

vcri

dbng

iir Piptt'r

vt

rriirh-bey

cAc

st

khlo-erlu

cira

Ong

trong

phric

trtirh

cira

hQi

tAm-llnh

(2)'

Tai

,lnft._ThAnh

hp

hQi

lrrghi0n-cu'n

di}

ti0u.dliQt

cAc

hiQn-ruong

do

trl

tu&ng-lughg

sinh

ra'

Sau

18

thlng

nghi6n-

cuu

hQi

nAy

gbm

co

33

nhl

trl

thri'c

lqi

cOng

nhfn

tnong

bln

phtc-trlnh

li

cAc

hiQn

tugog

{y

c6

th{t

vS'

khOng

'dam

phfi nh{n.

i

I

:ong

rfc

MOt

trong

33

ngudi

ily

lA

A'

Russel

Wallace

tr

phhm

<

Miracles

L"oJ

Moa"o

Spiritdalism

> lAm

chiln

dQng

d'u luln

Anh-qudc

vb

cflc

hiQn-tugng

chi0u

hdn'

Wallece

(1,

XG-

. SplrituClismo

r

(J'

W'

BDMONDS

'Ncw

Yorl

1854')

(2)

XGm

l'roceefllngs

S'

P'

R'

T'

XVI'

THUAr

cHlfu

rrbN

sinh

1B2J

mdt

1{)13

lA

chfr tich

hOi

Anthropologie

Anh,

nhln

vi0n lloyal

Society.

K6

d6 ln

Srainton

Moses

(hav

Oron)

gilo-su

tgi d+i

hgc

dudrng

OXITORD

vi6r

lu0n

hai tle

phiim

nhen-dE

r<

Psy.:hography

)

n6i

vE

tdi

chfr truc

ti6p cira

itbng tii,

(6iriture

directe)

vl lAc phhm

c

Spirit

Identity

r.

Oliver

Lodge

(1851-1943)

giCq

su vgt lJ hgc

vl

vi€n

tru6',rg

Dqi-hoc

dudng

tsirmingham

nhAn-vi€n

ViQn Bptng-

gia

lfe

giii

nhibu

cdng

trinh

vb

quang-hgci

v6

tuy6n drgn,

v.v...

A,

de

I\{organ

chfr rich

hqi

toln hgc &

Luin-d0n

tAc

girl

<

l,-rom

malter

ol'

spirit

d"

cfing bCnh vqc

stf

c6

th{t

cic

hiQn-tuong

r0m

linh.

(iiAo

srr

v{t-l1i hgc

dai-hoc

'

do}og

Dublin,

William

lJarrett

(18{4-11125)

hqi

vjOn

hQi

Holng-gia chfr

truang

d{t n}n

rn6n6

cho

hQi

nghiCn-cuu

tlm linb

Anh qudc

1{JB2 (Society

frl

psychical

Ilesearch

'vldt

tit

le S. [r.

R.).

t.qi

phii

kA

William

Grookes

(t8BZ-1919)

h6a

hoc

gia

vA v{t-lj

gia,

nhin-vi0n

viQn

HoAng gia

Anh

qudc

mi

su

tirn ra tinh

trgng

thu

4

cira

v{t

chdt

(quatridme

6tat

de

la, matidre)

m& dhu

cho khoa

quang

tuy6n vi

nguy0n-

t&

trong

clc

tdc-phhm

dE

rlugc dich sang

ph6p

vXn nhan-

rlb

<

Iledherches

sur

les

phdnomdnes

du

spiritualisme

n,

vt

q

l)rscours

sur

les

Recherches psychiquer

r

df,

chung

minh

dugc cfic triQn

tuong

tAm linh.

Nhung chrlng

t0i ciing

kh0ng

thD

quOn

Frdddric

W.

H.

Mvers

(184.3-1901),

gi[o-su

hhoa

t0m-lj

hgc dgi-hgc

dudng

CAMBIIIDGI1

nbi ti6ng

vb

nghi0n-crtu

bln

th& cfia

con ngu&i

de

so4n

,tAc-phhm

vi-dqi

nhibu

tAi-liQu

phong-phrl

nhan



'l

,l'.1.

r

.

i

I

l.iiri

rl

|Lr,lr

l.

I

'$:l:

r

.l

]''i

l6

db

r

Hnman

personnality

dn

hdnh 1903.

l

THAN

LINH

HOG

and

itri survivel

of

bodilv

dealh

r

TGi f.

-

C0ng

viSc nghi0n-cftu chiOu

hbn

thuit

do

giAo

su

Ercole

Cdaiaia

&

Naples

vdi

Clbng

tr?

Iiusapiir Palatlino

song c6ng

cuQc

1

'nAy

r[1

cdng*kich

kich lidt.

Chaiaia

phli

m&i mQt

sd

trl*thr?c rt6n

tl6

rn&

cdc cuQc

thl

nghif

m 18"91

tsi

nhA

gido-su p6rar

Lombroso

(1835-1909)

mQt nhA y

si vb

thln-kinh,

mOt

hinh

lu{t

gia,

ivA

gi6o-su

t4i Eai

hgc

ilu}ng

Turin (f).

Lonrliroso

c6 nhibu

giAo-su khfc dbng

dr

d[

c0ng

b6

k6t

qufi nhftng

hiQn

tuqng

6y

dtng

voi

sr1

th4t.

Td bdo

t

il.:itutin

det

Popolo ngAy

1S-11-1892

d[ng

tii

cAc biO,r

bln

cira 17 bubi

ttri-ngtrigm

+i

nhA

Irinzi

voi

dbng-tr?.

Eusafia Paladino vA

cd t0n

cfia

nhiEu

nhi

tri-thric

vA

bAc-hgc

qudc-t6

trong

tlo

cri

Giovauni

Schiaparelli

(1835-1910)

thiOn

vdn

hgc

gia

chtr d*i illiLan, nguoi

d5

tlm ra hlnh tinh

Hesperic

vd

cac dudng

v{n

tri

tr6n

l\lars,,

G.

Iriuzi

ti6n-si

vAt

lf

hqc,

bAc-si

Duc Carl

du

Prel &

lllnnich,

iAksakot

qudc-vu-khanh

Ngu,

v.

v...

-.Tsi

P/rdp.*

Q61g

viQc

nghi$n-cr?u

chigu

hbn

thu4t

do

Allan Kardeb b{c

ri

Y-khoa

sinh

3-10-180f & Lyon

m{t

3l-3-1869

&

Bal0

l6c

giA

nhiEu

s{ch

vb chiou hbn

thu{t

trong

sd d6

c6

hai cudn

cdn

bln << Le

livre

des

Esprits

>

vA

(

Le

livre

des

m€diums

>

xudt

bln

tep

cbi

Revue spirite

),

lvi

d{t

mQt

h9

th6ng

giAo

If

cho

khoa

chi*u

hbn bAy gid

dusc mQntr danh

lA Thhn

linh

hgc. (Spiritisme).

Cfing

nCn

fB

Paul

Gibier hgc

trO

cira Pasteur

pho

SiAm

d6c

vign

Lich-sr?

tu nhi6n

(0lusdum

d'histoire

naturelle)

bi

ngu&i

ta

c0Fg

klch

dE' dQi

vb cAc

cOng

cuQc tht

nghiQm

i

'.i ;o

.t,i

a.

l7

IIUAT

CHIBU

HON

ir0n rlia'lr4t

<

cdm

r

vb cAc hi$n

tugng

phi

thudng

nty

nOn

phli

sang

Hoa

Kj'

thdnb

t{p viQn chdng

b$nh

ch6

dqi

& New-York.

Oug

vi6t hai

tAc-phiim

cbinh

nhan-db

<

Le

spiritisme

gu faki-

lisme

oc:idental

r

vA

< Analyse des choses

r.

M$t

hQi ngbi0n

cfnr

tirm

linh (Soci6te de recherches

psychiques) thAntr ltp &

Uale

do gilo

srr

{lharles

Richet

(1850-t935)

gido sr

d4i

hoc <luong

I3alt,

nbfln

viEn

viQn

FIln

ldrrr Y-kbod

vi

d+i

tA Albert

de

llochas

gitirn'<iii.:

trrr<rng [JAch.Khoa (1837-19t4)

vA

xnfit

bln

tqp

chi

Annnles

des sciences

psychirlues

nhim,

mrtc

dich

nghiOn

crku

cd.i:

hi{n lucrng

lAm linh.

CAc c0ng

viQc rrghitn

cri'n

cua

(laruille

Flaryrmarion

(tS4l'1925) thi0n

v[r

hgc

f{ia,

,\rnaucl

de

Grammont

nhAn vr0n

hQi

hAn

lf,m khor

hoc,

nrOt

lrolrg, sf,og

l{p

vi0n cfia

lnstitut

M6raprvchique

inler-

nationai

(ViQu

Si€u

t{m

linh

& tsal0)

uri

sau n&y bric

si

(itrlev

vA

Osty

lln

luot

chir

tich

bQi n\r

dn hucrng

tl5n

crirg

viQc

srru

t$m

c{c

hisn turnrg tAm

linh vdo

rnQt

linh

vtrp

khoa hoc thoAt hfrn hg

th6ng

giAo lf

nhu

trudng

r\llarr

l(ardec

chit lrurrrr;g.'

,

, Vb

plrhn

m6n

phAi

thhn

.tilfr

hgc

edng

viQc

nghi0n

cftu duoc

li6p

tuc

do L6on

Deuis,

Gabriel

Delanne,

An<lr6

I)umes,

Henri

llegnauit, cric

mdn

itb cira

Allan

Kardec

lflnh tu

phAi

chi6n hbn thu{t &

PhAp.

,

ViQn

Si0u

TAm

Linh

&

Ilat6

89

du&ng

Avenue

Niel

l)aris

17e

do

ll6c

si Ir.

Montier

(tru&ng

ph0ng

thl nghiQm

cira

Eqi

hqc ttudng Y

khoa tsal€,

lAm

chi

tich bfrt

dtru

irott' rlQng

*au th6

gicri

chi6n

tranh

thu

.hai.

a

aa



, I

PIrAN

II

.

€huons

r.

-

aAc sU

THi-NcHtEm

cOn rnoA

cHliu

nbnr

A)

Chi6u hhn

c5

nhlbu

hinh

rh&c.

1) Xdg bdn(la

typtologie)

Hinh

thuc nAy

Ii

trinn

tn*c

th6

so

nh{t

i

ci"ra

khoa

cbi€u

hbn. Nhfrng

ngu}i chi€u

hbn

ngbi

vi il{t

ltay

lOn

cAi bAn vA tr}y theo

ti6ng

gd

ctia

hAn

mi

ghdp

chfr.

M6i

chfr

c{i

sE

duqc

qny,

dinh

bffng

bao, nhi6ri

li6ng

gd,

v.v...

ghn

gi6ng thu &

buu',

tliQn ngudi

la

dirng chfr

morse v{y.

'l'rong

hlnh

thric'

ney

te

phAi

lo4r

ra uhirng

nguy€n

nhAn

vAt chiit

nh&ng

cri

d0ng

v0

i'

thri'c

cfra

nguiri

\chi0u

lrbu,

tu

luc

cfia cAc

nguli

dq cu$c,

su

truybn

J',

Ndu sau khi

tI[

loqi

duoc nhilng

giA thuydt

{y

lf

rnsi ndn

xem

nh&ng

hiQn-tucrng

chi0u hbn

lA

cS

thar.

2)

Ldi

cltfr

ta

d|ng (dcriture

automatique).

Hinp

thruc

nAy

do

dbng

tir'

(mddium).

Ngbi chm

btt

vA

vidt

.&

ta

hi0n

tugng co htt

tliuOc

logi niy. Phln

nhibu

vdi

clch

thftc

nly ngudi

ta

al6

cho 1&

su

truybn

.J

cia

phhn vd

thdrc

(Suggestion

ineonseiente)

gAy

ndn.

'

Nhu

ch&ng ta dff bi6t tu-tu&ng

c6''

dO

,tbng

tft

c6

th8

nhsn

duoc

tu

tu&ng

th8

ph6ng rR

do

cfra

nhtng

ngu,ci

l

i

{

l

t

{

,'i

i

I

1

I

TAAN LINH

EOC

E

,,1.t

I

.

'

T+i

cdc

nudc

kbfc cOng

viQc

nghiOn

ciru

cfing duoc

cAcr

nhA

trl thtc

dd

f

nhu

&

Bric c6

bdc

si,

tdn si

khoa

hgc Eans

Driesh

gi{o

su

tri6t hcic

dqi

hoc

rludng

Leipzig

b6c

sI

Albert Von

fchrenck

Nolzing

& Munich.

Tqi A

cdn

.tlnh

cd

gi6o

su Vat

ly

hgc

d+i

hgc

dudng

.

Buenos

Aires

ld

Jose S.

Irernanflez.

T4i Thuy

si cd

jRaoul

Monlandon chir

tich

bQi

ngtri0n,

cuu

tlm linh

&

GenCvo,

v.v...

l.t

Tqi

I'buy-Di6n

jc6

giAg

srr Sydney

Albrotz

(mdt

1925,

gido

su

tf,m

,

lI'thrfc nghiQm

dgi

h.oc

iluirng

Usapala).

Trong

vipc

nghi,0n cuu

cAc lri$n tuong tAm linb

chn

pb0n

biet

quau

rli€m cfra

hai

phAi

trOn th6

gioi.

Phdi

chlOu

hbn

]ttru4t

&

Phed

:

lhi0n

vb ly

thuydt,

mu6n

dtt loOt

hQ

h6ng

giAo lj'

ldo

Allan

Kardec

hucrng

dAn

vd

tin

vAo lf thuydt lu{n hiii

cbfrng

hqn.

L

PhAi

chi0u

hdn

thu[t

&

Anh I\l

mn6n

dtrng

su

tbi

nghiQm

qhulng

j

ninhi sr1

*bfit

tfr

eila

con

ngudi

chu khdng

mudn

atrt

t[enn

trt{t

nq

th6ng

diAo

lJ'

nhu

& t]hdp

nhu

Drrglas

tfode

-Ot

hboe

tfr rnug{

phAi

chi€u

hbn

Anh

l{_t

cdng

I

kich

rthuy6f

lufln

hbi crid trudng Ptr6p.

(1}

Dir

rhd lrndc

ldn

tai

hOi

ngtii

qudc 16

chi6u

hbn

thust

hqp

&

Bale

1$00 dfl ahdp

thu{n

2 nguy6ri rfrc chinlr

:

-

srf

I

bdt

tfr

cfiA con

ngu&i qau

khi ch6t.

il

-

su

li0n

lqc

girfra

ngu&i sdng vd ngudi chdt.

=-.-L

(l)

Xem tli

lt0u

tnatir tn6o sd 17 treng 21,7.

ll

L

,Jl

ii

I

t,

:'l



i

.)n

ctrI

rrgii

cAe

rhl

dbng

tft

ndi,

tbi

ta

khOng

tir

tqo n€n,

G.:

0'

len t"

nhfin

xdc.

a

tqo

rr0n

hiQn

j

l'ftx,N

UNH ilOC

tu-trrrg theo

Idi

chuy$ri di tu-

tu

lhbh

da

trlrddg

0,

i

boqg

&

lt.,roog

lrep

mA dbng tri

vi6t nb&ng thu

mA chidh

y

hhOng

bl6t

,tray

cf, cfr toa (cAc

ngoqi

chfrng

(+n)

dbu khong bi6t

vA c6 nlrfrng chi

tiCt,

mhu

ehuydn

mi cfc ngudi ugbl dO

kh0ng

bi6t rl6n

lAm

sao

blo do

tibrn

thuc

hav

su

truvEn

{' tao

ra ?

3) NhQp

cd,c (incorporaticn).

Voi

hiQn

tugng,

n*y ta d{t

gii

thuydt ti6

"ttgt

rlf;

t{c dQng

vdo

phln

via

pbdclr cdra

dbng

tfr'

db

pruqrn

thAn

x{c eira

ngurii

ndv mA

ndi chuy0n.

frong trang lth{i ,ndy

phhn

vO

thuc

cfia

dbn4

tfr

ddog

rnQt

vai

trd

quan-trong.

Nhiiug k$'ni$m,

rrlng

khi6u, tu-tu&ng,

trinh

finh

cira

kf

uc

dff

in sfru

vriro

phhn

v0 thuc

cd

th6

nbi

dAy trong hic dbng

tfr

&. tlong

trqng

thnl

tu

mQng

du.

m6t

trang th{i h6n

m0.

Song

ndu trong'trqug

tliii

ridy

cfr

dQng

c6

nhfrng diQu b0

gidng

ngtrdi

clrdt

tht

blo d6 li do

phhn

vo

ihuc cira

tliing

cic

con

dbng dbu nfun

troug

truong

hqp

Sf hiQn

hbn

(rnatericlisation).

Sqr

hi4n h6n chn

,

duo-c

ki€m

so{t ch{t

chE.

vi phhq

nhibu

Fi$n

tuong

pb{t

xndt

duoi

6nh

<tdn dd

hai trong

h<ing tdi.

Mudn

clr6og

lai

su

bip

bgm ngu&i

fa de ki6rn soAt uhu

thd

udo

?

tto{c dirug

bln

c&n

c6

{*t

mAy

ghi

nh&n

(balances

munies

d'appareils

(r)

Xem tai

lieu

thanr khlo

sd

35.

'I'HITAT

CIIIE|I

H.)N

enregistreurs)

rl8

cAn dbng lfr cho bidt

rthq

nlng trong

cdc

.cuQc

tht-nghiQrn

theo

Amstrong

vC

Relmers,

hry

theo

cdch

c[ra Wiltiam

Grnokes

vA

K]

su Varlery d{t

mQt

he thdng

chuOng

diQn

(batteries

6lectriques)

vt dbng

tfi l)i

tr6i

buoc

l4i

116

hi6rn

soAt.

'frudc

khi

m&

cuQc

thi-nghi0m

hi6rn

soht

6o

t1utrn

dting

tt},

gian

phdng

thi

,nghiQm,

v,v"..

nrhrr

c*c vi€n Si0n

'l'fim

l;inh di

lAm,

,

.**

B| {rrdng

rhuSt

nrQr rd

cdc

cuQc

rhi

nghtQm.

Hlin

cira.

i\naslasie l'drdlyguine

mdt d nhi

thuong Tambou

(Nga)

thing

I

t-lti87 dff

rlng

,

vrio bAn

x0y

ngAy

h6m sau

y

ch6t

trong nhrl

ci-ra

l\1.',NartzelT

cho

m0t s6 cAc dbng tfr

chu

hbrr

dn

drruc kiOm

soAr

lA

c6 ftat

(l),

Abiaharn

l.lorentine

linlr

trong b0

dQi Floa-t(j

mfit

ir-8-1871

t}

Ilroocklyn

(FIoa

Kj)

ring

hbn

& Stranklyn dlo

lViglrt

(&

Arrh)

cirng

.tlrring

dv

cho

bi6t

tubi, kB

rd nhilng

chr ti6l

ciia

rlai

y.

Sau ktri

m&

cuoc

dibu

tra

nhfrng" tin

?Iy

tlbu rlring su

lh0t.

(Xem

Cnrnpte r.entlu

du

congrds

spirite et

spiritualiste

rle

1900)

(trang

10,{

-

109).

,

tt'

C)

€ric

hi$n rugng

v&

phbn

ki6m

codt,

,

f,ogi

c&ir rtbng

t#

(dcritrrre

mddiarrirnique). Ldi ch&

nA,v

do

t16r'g lti

clim

vi6t

dB vi6t

iluclson

'I'sttle.

& t4i

Ctevelatrtl

(Obio)

ilt ,

hic

llt tubi

lA

mQt dua b6

chln

bo

ktrdng

hu&ng

duoc su

giAo-rlqc

uio

chi

chuy8n

Io

vigc

dbng

bd .

Thd

(l)

Xern

t.{i liQrr tharn

ktr,io sd

lrti

trang

4:t7

-

l{0

(c6

trlch

;cac

bi0o

bln

li0n tltr:rn

..ilCn

srr

chung minh

nty.)

i -i

-i

h

,'t

.

-E*

'

"$

.,6

,-l

.t,

'tt

2t



s6ch

nhan

d$ <

Arcanes

de

la

Nature

)

trong

fiy c6 nhibu

lu

tu&ng'tg

lttog

vuot

qua-cec

su

hi&u

bi6t

cira

khoa hgc

hi{,n

thdi.

Yt

cbi

c6

sich, thu

viQn

gl

ci vi

nhA

cha

mg

nghdo.

(SAch

dn

htnh 1860). LiEn

d6

in

&

1Uy

tei bAn

ba

lln, tAi b[r{ nhibu

lln

&

Anh v}r sau dO

tlugc bAc

sI

Aschenbrefrner

& Euc

dich

vA xu?[t bin

t4i L.eipzick.

llAe

si

fliichndr lilnh

tu

ph{i

dni-r'vlt & Eric

dgc

t:ic

phhm

tudng

do

mf

t nte hhoa.

hoc

nio

vi6t

ra

n0rr

rtfl

trlch

r?i

nhilu

pfhn lrong

s{ch 6ng

dA vi6t ndn

t{c pirhm

<

niot,ge

et

mdtidre

r.

(Luc

tvi

v{t

chdt),

,

llAc

si

tsfichner

sau

'khi

,uog

My

dAn thuydt

mcri tinr

d6n

Clevelanp

d8

mridn

B{U lludson

'futt{e

nguoi

tld

giup

dng

mQt

.

p'rhu

l6n trong

viQ;

bidu so+n tdc

plrh

n

nt

i

trOn.l

Song

dfn

kbi

g{p

Hudson

"fqttle

thi b{c

si rniri

b&t

ngr?a

ra

me

lthily

ifing

do

chi

lA

mQt

ngudi

ddt ndt

(1).

i:ir

i . ,:'

1

NeAy

29-1t'1,391

mqt

hfl giA.

chdt

nhAp

vAo tlbng

tfr

Stairiton

Mosir muc

su cfia

liglise anglicane

vi

cbo

'bidt

dia

cbi

cb6

f

ngAy

cdn

nhd cira

bh to, tubi

ilA,

ngAy

ch-6t.

,22

mi m6i

t6i

iy

vi6t...

cho

ddn

lric

Sau

,khi

ki$ui

soft

fqi d,i4g

voi

su

th{t.

(2)

tl

"l

il

l'

L

I |

.

_l

I

0ng

Des$oulins thu{t

I

nhfrng butii

vd hlnh

cfia

6nE

trbng

tr+ng

jtnai

dbng rfii. Nrrfrng

blnh

{rrh

udy

phhn

tlr

(r)

Xem trii tieu

them

khig

sd

5ti-

trang

lt25 vi

cuiin

r

Der

spiritirmus

r

Cfrl

du

Prel

trang'

44.

(r)

i"- nfseigneineots spi

Staintin

I\{oses.

i

I

'il

ritualistos

trang

57

section lV

cira

I

THAN LINTI

HOC

hoin

ttrdnh

mQt cu6n

TIJUAT

CTIIEU

EbN

nhibu

le nh&ng

-bA

con thf,n

tbuQc

cfra

nhfrng

ngu0i

ttdn

dq

ur&

chlnh Ong

,khdng

hE

quen

bi6t.

(l)

LogJ

chtr

trtc

ti6p (6criture

directe

hay

psychographio).

Lnqi

nAy

c6

thb

,thuo

hiQn

du6i lnh

ddn sAlg vi

d6'

ki6m so{i. Bbng

tir

vAn

binh

tinh nhu thrdng.

Nhtng

to

gifiy

d{t

trong

hr}p

.hay

trong nr

In t& cd kb6a

.

hay

trong

ntr&ug tflinr

blng deu

bXug

dl,

cOt

vi khfin lqi

kbi

ru&

ra

th{y

c6 nh&ug hiug

chil

vi6t cfi,

nhfrng

ctr& ky

ciia nhiing

nguoi dA chdt.

Nrqhi0n

cuu

vb loai

hi6n tucrng

nAy

c6 nlribu

iroc-giJ,

dic

b:Qr

Ii

l){

tur.yi:

Guklenstuble

voi

lfrc

pbhm

< [,n

rdalil6

des

csprirs et le

phdnomene

rle

leur

6crilure

directe

I

(l,evmaire'

1857)

vi Stainron i\loses

tronpJ

tAc

plrhq

<

Psjchography

).

C{c

cuQc thi

nghi$m

cira

brt

tuoc

Guldenstuble

tiruc

hiQn 6

cdc nu<yc nhr

Anh,

Btlc,

PhAp,

tai

diQn Louvre,

tda

lAu

el*i

Versailles,

& ntri.

trl

Sainr

Denis,

diQn

West-

minsler

vfi

Bristish

Musdum

cirrig

& cip

lAu

dAi t6i

cb

kh[,c.

Nhibu

nhd trt thu':

tldn

chung

ki6n.

't{c

ptrhm

gbrn

co

30 bin

in

cAc

td

gi{y

dfl

viSt

theo

s

ldi

CIFS hiQn

r

ndl' hla

chon

trong sii

200

tdm

,tbu0c

20

thu

ti6ng

ktris nhau

Stainton

Moses

sau

lU

nIar

thi

nghiQrn dd

t{p

trung

rilt

nhibu

tdi hdu

trong

tdc

pbiim

tr€n

e,,f'a Ong.

Nh&ng

hi$n

tuong

niy

ciing

c6

tl rd

trong

<

Recherche

sur le

spirilualisne

r (trang

158

cira

Witliem

Grookes)

sau

dAy

tn

nnQt

dogn

trich dfln

:

i

liQu

tharn

khio

s6

57,

trang

169.





--::,1:*-



I'

TNI,N

LINH

TIOC

29t

"ar

-

;iuioot

tuyrorl"

{ong

h:"

.

*tr

i

hig"

'

hlnh

tluoc

cd

dqng

lai ttrl

c${ng

ta

ito

rht

chup

finh

duoc

vA

cu6i

cirng

cA

c*

toai

dBu

tr{ng

thf,Y'

I

0oo

nl"lrel*

,a,rrn

lq,,o"

Russell

]wett"tu

thi

nqbiQm

rsi

nhJ

on$

ilai

crrurr

1T:'o

,,lu'l

:-'..t:.1 T:,-::

::t-[:

l;";

"il

Hi

lil

I

'i

rnst

br'g

'chtrng

cu

tht'

n

Hbng

ti'r

thfi-v

p

tl

rd

srf

hi0n

hbn

nAy

lrroc

khi

chup

iun

nla

aiEu

ln{v

nlne

lvui

birc

antr

ilul

chup

ra'

(t)

I

,ru.

bnc

lsi

l

'rnoorpsirn,

tlloroni

n{

Beattie

tht

ngtriQrrt

yh

,

sau

ltn

inlo

|rt"

rf

chrrp

drsc

lph

mQt

hbn

rna'

(2)

I

Mo*1",

ptri6p

I

aon

igiu

chuv6n

nqhiQp

rtfi

c,6up

tlroc

I

Mo*1",

nlri6p

I

aon

igiu

chuy6n

nqhiQp

rtfi

c,6up

tlroc

&nh

nhiEu

ftbo

i

-th

pndil Ngrrdi

ta

hiQtt

ong

vi

cho

lit

Oio

bcm

song

lcudi

ctr'.ff

One

tbftng

Fien'

l?

ngrrdi

lam

chin',g

c0ng

nh&n

trongl

cetc

truc

tntridy

cb

trbn

kE

thSn

quvfir,

cfra

mlnh.

Han

ttfa

Ong

chAnh

frn

Ednrourls

cdng

nh: n

nhilrrg

r

nSu&i

c,hdt

dO

&nh

chrlP

rlttgc'

trong

luc

sintr

ti€n hhong

co

cbuil

frnh,

nhu

v4y

8i'{

ttrrrydt

sal}g

lgi

rir

lnh

cff

ki

Ong dlrfip

nhAn

dttoc'

Ltlorr

Denit

1t:t1-

.r

'

i

.

,

'r

mrr

nh4f,

Cdi

khi

chi

ilpng

ti'r

th6y

tA

tA

(loqi

dbng

nt:

n

t)*nu

l'invjsible,

1t''ntt[

19t)

c6ng

nh{n

c6

<luirc

nh0ng

;;;

;'it

cfrn

6ns

vclpf

giam

d6c

b$o

vessiilo

&

La

rnii

cbup

cfc

giai

d<rqn

cfi{

sg

bi0n

hb1

.\

Khi

rnA

slr

hi$n

hbn

ddn

mOt

giai

tloqn'kh[

rii

rdng

rhi

ktr0ng

nhfrng

'og,,'-di

ta

clruP

Ase

rluqc

mA'cfr

tqa

cfingtronglhfY.

i

i

',

('.)

Xeur

A.

xussefl

{vallace

t ['os

mlrasle*

et

lo

tlrttdorre

\

rt

'-s--

spiritrrallsmo

I

trang

251-t'

i

I

1.r

(12)

Xern

tAi

litu

tham

hblo

sd

l-'6

trang

7'l'

i-

.1

:

,'ll

T.IIUAT

cHIEU

II6NI

D6 ln

trudng

hgp,

c&a

Kating King'm6t

hbn'dAn

bA

rlii

iriQn

lOn

trong

nhibu

nHna

trong

cic,

cuQc

thi nghigm

cirr

trha trac

hqc

Antr

w.

crookes.

({eor

Recherches sur"

ie

spiritualisme

cria

tAc

gil).

'frong

mQl hni

di6n

vdn

.tqc

rqi hQi

qehi

ri6n

tri6u

lcdc

khoa

troc

& Bristol

1Bg8

mA W.

Crookes

h

chri

lirtr,

ong

d[ l&p

lzli

qual]

di6m bflt

di d.iclr

vE

'lp

liu.'ing

t0m linh

hoc

thuc

.nghiQm

cira dng

: r

lla

,

ruusi

nfuu

dd qua

k& tu

ngdy,

t6i

c0ng

h6

c$c

phric

'tr'inh

jvb

cac

cong

cu0c

thi

ngtiiQur

muc

.lich

de

chu'g

'ri.lr

I

rffng

ngoal

nh&qg

sLi

hi8u bi.it cira

chrlng

la

dfii

vai

hhoa

hgc

ngdy

nny,,

cdn c6

niQt

lqc, vfi

rlo

n:Qt ugubn

gdc

th0ng rnintr

kh*c

voi ta t:c

alQng

.-

l0i

liirOrrg

cCr

gi

dA

sfra

cb&a

-

tOi

vfrn

gifr

l,

ngnJ€n

rrhiing

.qu

nhfrn

xOt cira,tOi

da

c0ng

b6. ('t'rente

ans

se sont

6coul6s

dt'puis

q'e

j'ai

publid

les

eomptes

.

renclus cl'exp6ri,.nees

lctrdant

:i

d6montrer

Qttc,

en detlors

de

'os

connaissonces

scierrtil'iqnes,

il

exisle

une

force,

mise en ceuvre

par

une

inteiligence

qni

drffdre

de

I'intelli$ence

conomune

i tour

les

rnorlels

je

n'ai

rien

A

retracter

je

maintien rnes

con-

tastritions

ddjA

pnblides

(Dans

l,invisible

p.

19b).

r

I'tr6ng

5-1919

trong

t+p c{t

c

Revue, scierrtlfique

er

nnorale

du

spiritisme

>

W. Croohes

ISp

lAi

quan di8m

cria,

Ong

:

o

Theo tdi

nhflug

hiQn

'tugng

{y

cAng lrlm

s{ng

16

j

'

ki6n

cfra

nhibu

.dbng

nghiQp

vi

t

gn

hfru

cria

t6i

rrong

r

hQi

nghi€n

cuu

tf,m

linh

p

dA

nh{n

thuc

<luoc

trong

cAc

mhu

chuyQn

ily

bfing

chrtng

cfin mQt cuQc s6ng

tbeo,

lb

ldi

kh{e

ti6p

theo

cu6c s6ng

cfia

con ngu&i

mi trong

I

J

i





.l

q',

duoc

thfip

tel.

Anh

tru&ng

{y

lim

cho

chiu.

Chi

troirg

m$t

giAy

'dbng

hb

Katie

,

nrQt

cii

hinhj

sdp

chly

ra'

trong

rnQt

lb

lfr

nhiiug

ndit trOn

gltorrg

I

m6t'

CAc

con

rbi

dO" c*i

jmni

vi

ciri,

trAn'

,CAi

Ao

thi

ddt

triru

tnqt

eii

nha

stlp

db'

Duiri

inh

agn

,hhi,

,ch6frg

t6i

nhln rchS

Katie

dirng

bQng,

nAng

tan

dhn.

.,

r

i

)Irg

nAng

tau

d[n.

.

n

lli

iir,

I rt

'ill

:

ttot

truirrrg

ho.'p

rluoc

thi€u

ha

b:in

Utl

tU

,t:"111

ti;

lung

ir{C

si

FrankHn

1

't:F'u

khi0n'

liro] .iro

liferirore,'

ch6t

i

f,l+,,

l0rr

cho

chiiog

li

ong

;t;.it;at"

ctri,

nhi

ngai'

lr'a"q

t'

Nii'u-Utvc

tu

186t-186{i

11

I

t{o,ig s88

llb

rhi

nghiQrrr

]vn

do

hQt

lhn

<}

cdi

vf

hinh

i90tl

*ot

talp

roi"

v['

't'b

biQn

tuong

'(

ma

hi$n

trb'

r

trri

nghiprn

iughv

trong

tii,o"e

ttrl

nghi$m

"t

Oi-*

ta'

Cdc

cuoc'iirt

n{rtG-

ndy thr'rrc

hilnh

lot

ttbng

tfr

bi

Salrnon'

Ngny

lO-i-l,tUS

Abng

ttr

Snlur'-rn

dilt

trong

mot

ph0ng

thi

r,Jt,ig*

tay

I

chAn

cQ'.

tqi

tr€n

qot

clridc

gh6'

MOt

cfii

Ut

nr

"noarig

vAo

cb abng;

rt't

vi

c{r

'

nhibu srri

dAy

c0.t

kcr.l ra

it6rf

ch6

cfr

loa.

,

t1

jf,,{c-si

Paul

Gibier,

gi6m

.ldc

viOrr

Pasteur

&

Niru-'

t)'ott

co

trirjn

bay

trree

[0i

ngbi

tanr

ly

&

rla-L0

nlm

1 . :

-

i-h .ro--

'

..-,d^r1

|

^

te hiAn hhn r

I

Ntri€ru

fln6.

ray,

'mdt

hi$n

l6n'.

Nhibu

hluh-

ma

kttdc

nhau,

ton

be.

Co

itnt

c&a

mQt

ngu&i

rlAn

bh

mlnh

khinh'

trdi

lAi

bli

Salmon

dbng

tfr

thi

to

ldn'

,

srr

li

rufit

di)

iQn

dgi

nhu

sau

:

lJan

dhu

ngudi

ta

lTTf,N

LINII

IIOC,

Katie

r{t

kh6

b

6n

<lln

nhu

1?a,

Ban

,llu

mfit

thut

rlln

lrrt lhn

xu6ng

cfia

ba

n89n

vi

rhf,Y

hln ';'

THUAT

cHIEU IIdN

tlrdy

mQt diDm

md

nod

sr{ng

vA l}n

Ii6

lA

hintr

mQt

nguai

dAn

bl

hign

gu'ong

m{t

cira

mQt

c0 g{i.

y6u

digu

l+i.

IJfng

ngudi

nAy

di

khtp

trong

nly,

n6i

chuyQn

vfi

k6

kh6c.

33

vog

rbi

dAi

thn.

lOn.

Cudi ctrng

lt

nbi'lCn rbi

c0 tllc

ph0ng,

ch&o

,

ngudi

llde

si

Gibier b{t

ddn,

vA

kiSm sorit.

Ebqg

tfr

vfrn

ufinr trorrg

phdng

thi

ugbigm

vd

cAc

-

d0y

c$t

lvdn

ch6c

ch[''

:co

nlriEu

hiin

ma

l6ri

choi

dau.

sr1

biQn

hii'

theo

lli

cAc lriiir

Lnft

n6i

la

nh&

mOt

phhn

rut

& sinh

hlc

ciia dling

tir

& trong

traug

ttr6i phan

h6a

(d6n{at6rialisa-

tion).

lSintr

luc rl$.y

ll

thA pi:r{ch

(doublo

6th6rique)

cfia

dilng

tri'

nr)i

fireo danh

tir

cfia

nh6m Th0ng

thiOn

hr2c

(thrlusoPhie).

*

,t*,

0 i-aqi-Lcri

tu

.1901

d6n

1902

nhiEu

cn0c

thi

nghigrn

v6i dbng tri.

Ilusapia

Paladino

tqi'G0nes

do

c6c nhA

tri thuc

rrhrr

Lomtrroso

Norselli

vA

l)arro

chm

dhu.

C€sar

Lombroso

co

t:i

rd

trong l{c

phhm

r<

Hypno-

tisme

,et

spiritisrue

r

cira

6ng.

IIOI cnQc

chiOu

hbrr

&

Be

Unh

lg0l do

6ng Larsen

li

trong

td

bdo

I'huy-Di6n

Eko.

Ong

tl

lai

hbn

bA

Arrna

mdt

24-3-1899

hifn l6n

trong phong

rht

nghiQm. Eiy tt

mQt

rloqn

trlch

:

(.

.

.

NIln

k6o rt

d

lO

Egt

quang

clnh la

ky.

Cht'urg tdi

thfiy

mQt

ngu&i dAn

bi

y6u

diQu

m{c 6o cu6i

vA

dhu lrirm

mQt

kbhn

cholng

tring dAi

phrl

ddn

chfin.

lp,



o",

i

r

i

I I

TEANUNHHoc

t;

3:.r lb_n"

chotnglndy

If

tfing,ltm

sao

htnh

nhu

l&

der

b&i

nh&n

duOngj

dnh

stng

htryln

diQu.

TOi

cdn

nhd

guong'm{t

cy.

Mhei

hei

ndm

vE tru6c

t6i

dn

dem

ncng

ddn

btn

tUo

hOni

16

ltc

ntng

con

sanh

.tibnl

*;";

vfin

cOn

ttep

vdi

tilp;

mfn

choAng

tr€n

t6c

den.

T6i

nghe

rung

qurnh

tOi

cQ

nhfrng

tr6ngr

khen

th6t

ra

mQt

giong

nggc

nhi6n.

j

Tdi

vfin

chilm,

chrt

nhln

binh

d6ng

yOu

ki$u

dy

d6n

khi

tilm

mln

k6o

ru6ng.

MQt

doqn

sau,

ning

tai

bucrc

i.a

vdn

nhu

khi

c'n

sdng.

Tdc

den

mu0t cfia

ntng

phfi

xu6ng

gbong

mit

dgp.

Thlln

lrlnh

ning

phir

mQr

cii

{o tlAi

rrfing

nhu

tuy6r.

Ntng

nhln

t0i

ufi

c{p

mfit

,len

rroug

s{pg

;

tOt

ttrfiy

ci,r

:li

nn-ng

vfin

c6

1v6

y8u

cluang

:

d6

tA

vo

t6i

Su

xufit

hi$n

cia

unng

c6

lmQt vE

tlgp vA

ri6t

rliQu

lq

lirng,

mgt

hinh

ding

mA

con

ngudt

cfrr

i

thd

gian

khdng

"0.

TOi

doc

thhm

t6n

cfia

nAng.

MQr

ugubn

hgnh pbrit

l6n

lao

d6n

xam

chi6m

itii.

.Neog

budd

vao

phong

rbi

man

kco

lqi.

Gian phr)ng

-ivfiu

's{ng,

cri

tga

y€n

l{ng

vA

trang

nghiOm,

ra

cd

thQ

thdy

dbrig

trri

vdn

ngbi

trong gh6

bAnh

sudt

trong

th&i

4iien

hign

ruqng

phlt

sanh.

Larsen

c6

xini

cfit

.

mEt

m 6ng

hh[n.

yoan

(voile)

vi

dog

ta

cdn

gi&

lgi

sau

khl

vli

Ong bi6n

milt.

Chdt

atrng

dD

ttm

ra

khdn

voan mQt phitn

lfiy &

ngubn

sinh

h.rc

cria

ilbng,

trir

(radtationr

du

cgrps

bumain).

\

ThEt

li

chuyQn

li0u-trai

&, thd

kg

vdn

minh

khoa

i

ti

boe

niy

(1).

u

I

i

I

I

I

et

1)

Xenl

llevue

trrng

072).

$clentiflque

mora

i

i

le

du

spirltlsme

mat

19(il

'\

TIIUAT

CHIBU

ITbITI

IJlc

si Guslave

Geley,

giAm ddc

viQn

si0u tlm

llnh

(Metapsyclrique) qudc

t6

c6 m&

nhilu

'cuQc

tbt

nghiQq

vdi ddng tir

Dva

Carlidre

hay

l3eraud

Marthe.

Cic

cuQc tbt

nghiQm

nly

&

phdng

tht-nghiQm

ViQn

tir

l2-l9l?

tl6n

ttrfrng 3-1918.

C0ng vi$c'ki6m

so{t

dugc

thgc-

hAnh mOt

cAch

chAu

ddo.

\

,

al KilOm

sodt

phdng

thi-nghiQm.-

Khda

cfra

itugc

xem x6t

hy

m6i

lln tru&c khi tbl-nghiQm

.vi

sau

khi

thl-nghi$m.

Ebng tr? ngbi trong

nQt

ghd

,binq

& sau mln

dugc ehlnh

rte-gi&

lA

tsAc-si

Geley vl

bA Bisson nim

tay.

MAn

duoc

v6n

l6n

su6t thdi

gian

biQn-tugng

phit

xu{t

.IA

l6i

(ldri

ldc-gil)

c6

tbd

chlnh milr iUCy

hiQn

tugng mQt

clch

rd-rlng.

t'irdng

dbng

tfr

ngbi

tlgac

ki8m

soit

tru0c

vl

sau

efc

cnQc

thi-nghiQm.

'J(

bl Kil6m

sodt

dbnq

t&.*

Eva

bi cbi

trln

ra

trong

mQt

gian ph0ng

bOn

cgnh, dlogn in{c

mQt

cAi

do l6t

mAu den.

'l'6c,

cudng hgng,

16

mfii

dEu tluqc

xe4 xdl.

Cl

ll,q

em

dqo, ciing drqc

qgudi

ta khAm

x6t (Le

toucher

vaginal

6tait

pratiqud',

non constammenl mais I

deux

L trois

reprires).

Q

Anlt ittn.--

Cdc

bubi

thl-nghiQm

dlbu

thuc

hign dntvi

dnh

ddn

,sing

(lumi6re

blanche)

"Cri

tga c6

thE

xem

chfr

hoi

lsrr duoi

Anh

rldn

niyl

vl

nhln

dbng

hb

{b

bi6t

gid.

Kbi

nio ngr&i ia

mudn

chup

lnh

rbi

ngu&i

ta

dtrng

d€n d6

(lumidre

rouge) v6i

mQt

lOoS

diQn

lt

30

tt6n

60

n6n.

Bubi

tht

nghidnt

ngdg 72-2-1918.

< liva rdt

ducc

kh6e

{?nh.

TOi

ghi

vio

sb

nh&ng ldi

<r

Evr n6i :

,l

l

i

'I

$5

I't



<

rmQt

ngud

tlen

fl

mudn

hiQn

l0n.

c&e

tAc

phhm

nly.

I

TI-IAN LINS

HQC

i:;a...Ttl

24

g\b nify

t6i

o6

cflm.

(u&ng

Shn

bon'

toi

c6

hinh

<tmQt

nguAt

ttan

lt mu6n

hiQn

l0n.

i

."'

<'Lrlc

Eva

ngir

tniep

thi

;A

t* &

troog

trang thci

xf,m

<.nhiPgiaotidpv{ic6ivohinh](elleestprise),

'

(

IJe ta rOn

ta

$Ua

lAu

vd

kOu

lOn

nhfrng

ti6ng

nhu' mQt

< nguli

ilAn

bl l6c1

'shp

sluh con.

]tu6

rbi im

b[t.

.

Tdi

tu&ng

r<

rlng

hiQn

tugng

s€

kh0ng

luilt,

nign.

Nhung

bA

Bisson

< dtirng c94h t6i

lqilla len:

lx"oi

kla noi

bu'c mAn.

r

'

<

Th4t

th6

tr0n

lono

abrg

tr?

hfnh

cAi

dlu

cfia mQtrngu&i

r

din

bA

tr&

u€n rii'

rAng.

Su

xuilt

hiQn

m{t

ngudi

dAn

bA

u

nAy,rflt

p6..E6 lir{ mgt,

Uhn0rl'rp{f

lrung binh

c6

[n

mHt

u

dhy

yinlnii

,v,n

npQt mdu

da

mft

p6,

guong

m{t

dpp

uOn

til..

<

cri.'itq+

4ghn mf,l vA

thi

thhml

trao,

dbi

cfim

tu&nq

cho

*

nnn;;jrji

,oim

dpng

lqur

nen

fn6n,b4t

den

I

'

(

H[$nl

tutlng

n[y

rfit

ugtn ch'f

dQ

1Ai

giAy nOn

tOi ktr0ng

(

dfi

thl

gid

dB

chup lnh.

'

,

11/

'I

o

sdnl

d0 15

flno1

r"o cei

{tt

nahg

l+i

hi$h

ra

.c6

khi

<r

lo khi

"nO

nhung

lfc nlo

cfing

rd

rAng. Sau

bung

cAi

<

dlu

dnqs

|I6n

v{

nhia

n}qc

d(Ia;

TOi bdn

den. Sau

kbi

<

il€n

db

ioi

thfiy

lcAi

dlu,

& trOjn dlu

gdi

cfia

Eva.

Trong

<

bobi

fhil,ngblQm

nily

toi

mongl

thdy

chdt 6t-t0-bd-I[t-mlt

):'u...Trl

24

girb

n{f

t6i

o6

cim

tu6ng

ghn bOn

<

(subithnce

ectoplasmiqoe

originelle)

nguyOn

fry vA

ciing

<

kh6ng

thf,y,

sqr

thCnh

htnh

c&a,

c{i

itlu

qua

nhibu

Siai

rlogn-

<

lilien tugng

ney

pnat

sinh mQt

le{ch

thinn

llnh.

(1)

.l

.

r'I

.

I I

r.

.

+

(1)

sE

silt

thtch

dalnh

iri vl

hiQn

ug:o8,

niy

&

phln

IV,

chuorng

I

,'

.frong

tic

phhm

tr'Tout

,l'ocgultispe

,d6voild.

r

Tosque .ghi

lqi

dbng

t&

Eva

ducyc

b{c

sj

schrenck

Notzing

nghicn-cuu

va

c[

bl

Bissou

:

'focquet

xem

cugc

thl-nghi$m'

cf,a

Nolzing

'

khong'

co

gia

tri.

0og

cho

rhng

dbng

tri Eva

d[ nudt

olc

bu'c

inh

(?)

rbi nhl

(?)

ra?

Song

dbng

tri

Eva

khOng

hE

bi

'bit

co

gian l{n

trong

c{c

cuQc

tht-nghiQrn

tqi

Society

for

plychicat

resea'rch

vd

tgi

Sorbonne

(40

bubi tht-nghiQnfi)'

'focquet

irhri

nbsn

khOng

hi6u

B'iir

cO

tili;ludng

8+t

ra

sao'

Rd

lA'Tocquet

da

nghi

quA

dQ1 vA

Ong kCt

lu$n rfing Eva

c6

khi

lpa

bip mi

cfrng

c6-hic.

c6

nhfrng,,higl

1ttd118

rdc

NhAt

I

-

:'

,'''i','

Ilubi

tlfi

nghiQm

ngdg'26-2-1918.

'

Ki6rlr'so{t

tdt

k}

nhu

lhudng

lg.

Eva;bi

xlag,;'ph{p

I

,dr

nhtnb.

MQt

guong

mit

hi$n'lOnghn

tlbng

trl'

Guong,

mat

nAl

cfing

gi6ng nhq

guong:m{t

mA

tdi ell c6

dip chup

inh

tro4g

bubi

thi-nghiQn

lhn

trudcr

'

'

'l'Oi

lnh{n

thdy

su

xu{t

hiQn

nAy

c6

f

diqh

Ilm

cho

tdi

nh$n

tbf,y

qua c{c

giai doqn

hieq

hlnf

:

THUAT

CITIEU HON

1)

Guong.m{t

xudt

hiSn

&

vA

gidng vdi

khuOn

m$t

ctra

'hiQn

quA

nhanh'ch6ng

nOn

tdl

3)

MQt

ddng

10ns'dd

? l6ns

'

.cia

Erri

vB

phia

I

\

2) dhu0n

.m{t hiQu

lOn

nhd

mQt

tdm

mAn

bao

phfi

ghn

c4nh

ddng

tr}.

Sq

rd

rAng

izing

dhn

rbi

gi$m dln'

dau

min

mQt cAch

thtnh

llnh

i

nguoi

thulng

song

sqr

xuilt

ktrOng

lh6

chup

&nhiduqc.

i

tinh

ch{t

(substadce)

tir

4iQng

Flva

nhl

ra

tay.

CAi'dly''nAy;ihong

xudng

du6i

cfrm

bOn

trAi

mQt tl.

CI6i

dAv

nAv

phinh

o

rl

..i.,_,rl,]

',

'':,,-

, 1't'-

t

lt"

'rl



.II{UAT

CTITBU

nbr.r

Tu

19tg

tl6n 1920, hQi

nghi0n

lh['

dO

Varsovie

df, nghidn crlu

dufi

.

su

diEu khi€n

F&"

rtgi th

nghiQm

dbu dugc

l{p

bi€n

bln.

I

Bubi

thi

ngliQm

30-8-1919.

Sau

khi

tflt

dOn vd chi

cOn

da

(lampe

rou

oe)

'cr?

tqa

nhln thily nhiEu

tlrinh

mBt

guong

m{t

c6 rIn

s[ng

;.

\

'lt

ctu

tAm

linh Balan &

itbng

t&

Franck

Kluski

Okolowicz.

C[c

Uobi tnt

I

mQt nggn ddn d6

lnh

sAng

tu

l4i

vir

nhu

diCm

sinh.

Sau

vli

phrlt

dqi

chd

cfr toa thfiy

nhiEu di$m inh

s{ng

xung

quanh dbng

tfr vt

dbng th}i

,

ngu&i

ta r:ghe

cb

nlribu

ti6ng

g0

vA

nhibn ti6ng

nhu

nhii'ng bucr;

clrdn

cfia

ngudi

di.

Ngu&i

tn

thfiy

su higrr

trtnh cfra nhibu ngudi

ban tlfiu

-

lA

mfi

ngrrd'i

lan, lOng

rflt

nhibu,

t6c

dii

vA bg

rf,n rdi

rim.

F.Ilnh

d,ing

nguli

nAy

nr?a

ngndi,

nfre

n$gm,

gidng

rnQt ngnd'i

hbi

thugng

cb

thdi

rlgi. Y ndi

ti6ng

ngbd

rang

ring

nghidn

rdng

vi

ctr$t

lu6'1,

Khi

nguoi ta

ggi

y thl

y

lgi

ghn

vd

rd

cfr

to4

lfiy lay

m6 vdo cfr

toq

nhunpg

mong tay

y nhgn

nhu nhfrng cAi

gflu

chrr

ktrOng

phii

nr6ng

tny.

Ebug

tfr

ra lQnh

cho y

'kb,

tt6n

hbn mQt kE

t1r

xung

le

Charles

l6n clio

rXng

dd

chdt

13

ndno

song.kh6ng

mudn

clro

ai

chup

{nh

vi

ld

rlbng

trl bfio y

n6i

16o"

Kd

d6 ln

sn

xr.rfit

hi$n,

cira Lrai

ngu0i il&n bi.

flgupi

nhAn

ra

np,utri

'dAn

bA

lhu

nh?it

IiRFIERI

rn0t ngu&i

dAn bn

An-dO

&

Caleuttn

rnA rrgurii'ta

thiiy

tr"org

c{c

cuQc

thl

nghiQm

trudc.

Cfr to4

c6 chup nhiEn buc

inh.

,

Bubi thi nghiLm

3-9-1919.

gdg

r,i

I

|

.,

,

,

I I 'L

s8

I

I I

I

IHANLINITHoG

nhr

mQtl

cii

nu

ihoe

m&

dhn.'

TOi thdy

cdc

n6t

rd

rdng

oh

ntoU

lci

mgt

lhriOn

m[t.

TOi bflt

tlOn.

Du&i

Antr

ddn

hiQn

tuqng

vdn tbn

tgi.

Cudi

dong dAy khu0n

m{t

tidn

lOn

phla

ben

rtrAi

c{i

dhu

cira

iEva hay

trong

kholng

2r

phin

ghn

'cqnh

{bng

tr? eao hsn

tai

y.

tlfly

gid grung

m{t

lgi

hiQn

ra

i0

rAng. Tdi

plrup

mQt

bric

lnh

thu

hai"

,i

Bubi

tttt

nghiQm ngdg

S-3-1P18.

I

i

Sau

khi chd

Fqi

d0

mQt

gi&

Evri

rdn

ri vd

tidng

r'€n

cAng

ngAy

cung

tp.

MQt .1t

trfir:g

rudt

'hi$n

noi

vai rlbng

tft

ltra.

V{t

trfing

'Ay

to

dhn

lbi

chung

tOi

thdy &

gifra

v[t tr&ng

dy

fuoilg

mflt

ctra

u$t

nguoi.

Cdi

gtrorrg

mdt

nAy bi6n

rbi

hiQn

.c6 khi noi

riguc

liva

c6 khi troi

vai,

cd

hhi

duoi

cil{,

c6

khi

trOn'

rl}u

gdi,

c6

khi} trong

hai

bd,n

ta-v,

c6 khi

n6

vAo

trong

miQng

Llva. Su6t

hubi

tlri

nghiSrn

{oi

1fin

cp

th0

thdy Era.

Eva vfin

irn lhn

vd

n6m

,trong

chi6c

ghd bAnh.

,

Bubi tllj nghi4-lt nsdg 11-3-19 8.

Su6t

cnQc

tht nghiQm

nAy, min

h6o

l6n ndn

tOi

vdn

cd

ih6

thdy tlbng tfr

Bsa

vfi

gutt

sat

hiQn'

tuong.

Sau m$t

(bdi

I

fiian

rIQ

45

pbrit

trAng th{i lOu

dBng

(trnnse)

bht

rlhu.

I

'tninn

linh

toi thdy

-qt

dfm mf,y md

to

bfing trAi ' caru

xudt

hi$n hdn

canh,

dbng

tfr,

'EAm mfly

nAy

&

ngrlc Eva

vi

cudi

crlng

hi$n

l6n

m$t

cAi

rlhu

n11udi.

rtr--L

' I

rdt l&n,

rbi

phqy

vdo'

mi$ng

dbng tri".'

rnn

n8y

qrra

r4l

B6ng Eva

keu

l0n. (1)

ata

h

il

i

i

ll

i1

i

tl

l1

il

t

ii

t

li

(1)

Xem

tli

llQu

thau

kbio

s6 59 trang

208.



.:.

,il

'l

1

'I

'

^t'

I

,l

j

40

Con

ngudi

4tqrn

lhn

lrudc

'hiQ,n

lidm mqi

ngudii IIA

Grelak

c6

dem

Ngudi ngqm

nAf

ctng

r16n

rd

con

THAN

LTNH

ROC

ra

rbi

cl6n

the

IuOi

mQt

con

ch6

lheo,

chd

vA

con ch6

rfi,r.

1l

TIUAT

(IHIEU

H6N

Dbng

tr?

(iuzik

&

trong

mQt

ph0ng

c6

cdn lu&i tu

phia

1

Itai

tay

elbrrg tir

do bAc si

Getey vA

Ong

.lelski

eXm

hai

btn.

tl6ng

t$i.

Odi

'ltubng

luoi

nAy

chi

cd rnot

c*i

cri'a

ngang.

Q6

mOt

cfii

ghd

nfing

bfrng da

vA

r:Ach

c{i

bubng

1

thrrcrc

50

IA

cAi

bin.

Guzik

uim m€

(ehi

nlm

phut

lA

y

ngfi). Ct?

tqa

cd

cirn

tu6'ng

cA mQt

sg

xufit

triQn

14

cqnh

illlng

tfr.

NhiBu

ti6ng

nhu

brrac chAn

tli

vA

rrlriEr.r

tia s{ng

hiQn

l6n'

Hai

Anh

sAng

ch6o

nban

nhu hai

eon

qlorn

ddtu

d6n

6hn

Jeiski.

I6i

tbfly

binh

rnQt

khuon m[t,

lrinb

rnOt

thatrlr

ni0n,

hinh

hai

tra

hi'a. ti6n

gbu lqi

phio

y

vA

,tiign

ra

mQt

ngtroi,

€{p

mlt rdt tinh anh.

tuI$t

cAi

gi nbu

kbirn

chodns

dhu

vd chm

cirl

klrudn

rrr{l

nAy,

Su

xu{t

hiQn

vAo hhofing

lr

gi0y.

TOi

e6

c{rn

tiidrog

rluqc Om

rbi rd

nhiEg..-cfiu

n6i

tidng

llalan

rnA

ldi

khdng

hiAu

tlusc'

K6'' vd

hinh-

tl6n ro hai

va i

tdi.

Ti)i

r$t

tb6a

nrsn

vE

hipn

tuong nAy

vl

10i fl'iiyctrFc

chfln

rhng

tlhng

tfr ktr0ng

th6

nAo

lira

gSt

iray

g;ian

tl'ii

duo-c.

I(6

ql6

kB

vd hinh

ndi

rfrLrg

:

y sd

rlern

cAi

ghd

ra

ngoAij

'toi

nghe ti6ng

cfra nr&

rhi t0i

co cAsr

iur'rng

c6i

ghd

rtuo't

l€n

dlu

ninh

rbi

dfis d$i

tr€n

c6i

hin. KA

d'i cdt

rnQt

luhng sing

hay

&

trtln

9h6...

Elhng

tfr

tirrh

dAy...

Thip

dOn

I

Nguoi

ta th6y chi6c

ghd

dn

d[t

f

t'0n b[n.

'l'rong

tlrrli

gian

hiQn

tilrryng

c*i

f;hd

chuybn

di

dbng

tir

.vfin

n*.m v{

tay

tdi

rfia nim cb{t tay

r^rbng

Hbn

ngudi

fiAn

bh .{n-CQ

llheri

cfrng

hiQn

l€n.

NhiEu

alb

dgc

bi

qulng

vut. Ngudi rta

np,he

ntribu

tiOng lAch cdrch

vi

nhibu ti6ng

chAn

bucc di.

.r

.

tl

Ntrrn

1920

dpng-tfr

Kluski

dCln

tqi

vi$n

si0s

tAm-linh

qudc 16

&

Phipi

vi

cdc

cnQc

thi

nghiQm

d{t

dnrri

quybi

cira h[e

si

Gelef,

vdi sr.r cQng

t6c

cfia Ctr.

flichet

vi

A'

de

Grammont^

l

llAc

si Gelel dfi

di

d6n

tr*6t luan

:

q

Clrirng

tdi d;i

thily

su

hiQn-

hbn : nhiBn ch0n

tny ngtrdi,

do

viQc

chlnh

n:fit

mlnh

trbug thdyi sq

Tnd...

L

*

Vb

[huOn

nl{t

ngu}i

: thhirnp4

thucrng

Eu xu{t hiQn

In

nhfing hinh

liAn

then

(clri

c0 th$ntrOn hay

tbfin

tlutri).

C*c khnQn nnft d, sau

itting

tft hay

&t

bdn

c4nh

dbng

ti'r.

Cfc

guong

.

m{t fiy,

rfit sdng.

Cdi

nhin r{t.

linh dong,

ch[nr

chrl

pg6

nffrng ngudi rlpng

rn&

cnQc

thi nghiQm.

Gucrn

fr[t

rdt

frhm

tinh

vA

yOn

l{ng

cd

v6

dghi€m trang.

Nhiing

hinh

ndy

nbu

bi6t

su

quan

tnrng

vai;tro

cira

hq. (t)

I

il.'..l

ubi

thi

n,Ihi|,n

1/t,g.1g2g.i

.

\

l'

0

Varsorie

llalan

t+i

"bi|

hoAng thAn

{-obomirski,

I

thl

tir.

al

l)

Tei U€u

th{m khlo

s6 59 tpang

225

-

280.

'i



rguAr csrEu

udx

Cic

ndt

tren

da

nrilt

rilt

lt

m&,

t6c khdng c6. Thln

htnh

miu

,xfinc,

oOn

guon*'m{t

thi

mAu

xrnh l4 cAy"

Hei,musi

giAy

clbng

hb

de

qua.

I\{Qt

ngudi

trong

bqn thdt

la

l0n.

Con

ura

nhdo

rudng

Bhd

vA

nhu

mQt

tr6.i

bong

bong

hiingl

cao

sn

bi6n

mfrt.

Bn

Silbert

thuc

d{y.

)D

15-12-lg\t;

M$t

con

ma

hiQn

l0n,

nninh

m{0

mQt

cfi

do trfrng

dAi

th{u

ddt: Mdu

da con

m&

tr8ng

nhgt

nhqt.

Coir ru&

n*y

hi$n vd

bi6n

nhibo

lhn.

Ngudi

te h6i song

nd

kh6ngi

rri

ldi.

Su

bi6n

m$t

cfing

dA

thily.

.idrrrg

nra

nh6 dhn, lrgp

dhn, rbi hl6n

mfft.

ttA

Silbert

ttruc

d&y.

Ua

ta

hhu rrhrt kiQt

trfc

vA

tflm thlm

m6

m$1.

'frong

khi

con

rna

ney

Lign

b{c

si

Auer c6 thb tbiiy

{ry6r4

qua hinh con

ma

nh&ng db

ilgc

&

s&u

n6.

t-:6

khi

rlbng

tfr Silbert dung

dfly vA

ngucri

ta thil.y

con

ma

di

c4uh dbng

lfr

song

chAu

tay

thl m& kh6ng

dugc t'6.

Kbi

Jrnh

sfing

bflt l6n

ngrr&i

ta

lhdy con

ma niy

c6

nrQt

cdi khhn

rhoAng

fp

lOn

rlhu. cilp mlt n6 nhHm

lai,

tay

to,

miQng

rgug,'

mOi

diy.

Guon6

mtt nhu

lh

tqe &

trong

tucrng d{

chm

thqeh. Ngu}i

ta

cd

th6

thdy

mfii

vA

mit,

Ktri

ma

bi6n, n6

db mQt

chf,t

gl gtn

ilbng

tfr vd

chidtr

sling.

(

l)

"ta

Nhibu euQc

thl-nghi$m

v&i

dbng

tfr

c6 Ada-Bessinet

tai

OFlt0

&

M .

l3i6n

bln

lrubi

tht

nghiQm

22.5.1922:

(l)

Bic si

Albert

dd

Schrenck

pbysiques

de

ia

m6diuulnlt6

r

trang

Notzing trong

r

Les

phdnomdnes

230.

4$

t"

42

i

\

I

I

rHi,N

LINH

HQC

ll

Bubi

thi.

'nghiQrn

29-9-1921,

Tqi

farsorie

itbng tr? vfin

bi kiEm

solt

vA

nim

tay,

nlo4

m&

mf

hiQn

l6n n&m

cfiy vi$t

chi &

trOn bin.

tOii

tlidy

clly

vi6t

chl

blt

<thu

vidt

l6n

gidy.

(1)

*

i'ii'

BAc

bI Auer

tlf, nghien-eurt

tru&ng

hqp

r:ira

tlbng tft

Mariti Silbert

tt

1921, rldn 192'2 :

/

2g'i/t-1921.

An| sir:g milu

ag.

nlibu hinh

bAn ta

tu

g tfr

thbdt

rd vi

bign lOn nhdt

lA

hCIn

pbia

tay

mirt.

I

Nhibu

dAm

rrlAy m& liiQn

l6n theo

tlu&ng thfing vA

I8r

vA

bA

rlbu

hi{n

lhinh

hinh

lnhfrng

bAn

tay,

.'

&-5-7'921.

Ann

]*eog

trong

ptrong

t,o.'

oay

miu vAng

khbng

bXng

Anh

pfng

'mAu

d6.

Sq hi$n

hinh k6m

hcrn.

HiQn tttgng:'xtlc

niao,

(phdnorudne

de contact)

su

hiQn

hlnlr

it

rd vfi

phln nhibn

nhri

hi

bao bgc

b&i nhiing

ilAm

mfly.

5-8-1921.

tsh

lvlarle

Silberl

tfrud'ng

trong cAe

cuQc

thi

ngtri$m

khAc

vdn 6 trong trqrtq

thf;i iinh

b6ng

& vlo

trgng-th6.i

l*u dbns

(transe). Nira

6id

snu

mQi cii

cllu

hign l0n. Con

da

n&y

dri'ntr1

d$y.

Ilb

cao c{ta

y dq

t

thud*c

20,

Con

ina

k6o

gh6,vs ngbi.

Anh

s{ng

ydu

o't

hhi6n

ta kh6

nhAn 16.

BAc si

Auer vi6t

:

<

Con

mr

ngbi

vA ch[m chfi nhin

ttSi

bfing

rnQt

cfi

nhln mOng

lung'

'

(l)

Xou

tii

liQul tham

khio

sd tt

-

chuoug

II

vb

Ma:

T4i

phdng

thi nghlQm

hbn

mf ae

vidt

cilng

nhu ciu

chuyQn

'

ma

illi

ditng.

phfin

vi6t

t0n

biog tlen

2

olu

tha.

\l

l

'l



it

Arthur

Conan

l[oyle du.

b6ng

hinh

nnQt

guong

ur{t

ddn

bA

hign

l0rr. I-ub fly

cO

dbng f

t? IJessinet

bfit

tthu

& troug

trqng

tbAi

lOn rlbng.

Ttr trong

miQng tlbng

tfr

lfessinet

thdt l6u ltli

cfrai n6uoi

Aq

de

tllack.

Otoud

mQr k6

v0 hinl:

kr6m

soiit

vA

rti$u

khi6n

bubi

pbieu

hbn.

Hai khuon

mfir bign

'Lrong

lubi

ltrt

nghigm

nAy

c6 nhir

v[u

hio' Antr

Sir

rur

Conan

l[oyle du.

b6ng

hinh

nnQt

guong

ur{t

ddn

hign l0rr. I-ub fly

cO

dbng f

t? IJessinet

bht

rthu

&

troug

'

rlr

i

i

l

Ban

tllu dbpg

tfr

Ressivet

v5n

lhuc

tinh

vthiSu

la

bluh

lusn

c{c

hiQn

tuong (nhu

uhibu Anh

sAng

trong

phOng

tht

nghiQm

vA

hay

ch$p

chtrn

tro{c

c6

nhqc durre

nhfrng

kA

v0

llluh

dAnh

l0n).

r&

I

1922

-44

THtr,NILINH

[Ioc

c6

1

lin

bAn

l0n.

Conan l.)oyle

thfiy

dr5

ld'hlnh

ngudi

con

vil

cii6u

Ong

On.

Conan l.)oyle

thfiy

dr5

ld'htnh

ngudi

con

vil

cii6u

Ong

la

vl

sau

dd

tfr

hinh

ngud,i

,mg

cfia

Arthur

Connn

l)oyle.

'l'r'orrg

truhi

]thi-nehi€m

.nAv Katie Kinp

(mot

hlin

hav

l'r'orrg

buhi

]thi-nghi€m.nAy

Katie King

(mQt

hbn

ha3,

biQn l6n

cho

V1.

Crookes

hhio

cuu)

ciing

hign

tCIn,

Nhtbu

't

il{.

C

Stannleseu

&

fluenrest

thfi

Dd

le

vif

c

cho hif n

hiln

mOr

c0

*1,

le"

,tu

llad;leine"

-lffif,-il-nevue

Mdtapsychiq'e

'tlaog:

z

^

"t::i

dovtc

''|""*

'

""

,*"':J'"

vitar r

rlbng

ti

trang

26 vh

bi6t.

hiQn

nhibu

.|HUAT

CBIEU

TT6N

IIiQn

tuo.ng nly

xu{t

hiQn &

Mantes

{']hri

p

vAo

1920.

45".

m0t thAnh-phd

Ky

str

Stanutescu

dfl dlch

thfrn

ki8m

soAt

gian

phong

thi

nghigm

vd

hign

rugug

df,

x&y

ra

nhu

sau.

gxq

dAy

lA loi

cfia

Ong

vi6t

:

,,

... Srf

xufit

hiQn

,th{t Ie

t6

,'nhi

vd, c6

v6

tho

rogng.

Ii{adeleine

hiQn

lCn lily

mQt

Ei6

hoa

.

vi

il6n

t{ng

chrlng

tOi.

Dudi dnh

cfia

ba

nggn

,

ddn

tt6

rri4u,:i

ta

{hdy

nAng nrQt

cAch rd

rAug.

Ddr ld.

ruQt

ngtrtri

con gAi

uy6a

chuy6n

gi6ng

cAi

hinh

luc

cdn sdng,

vi l0n

hon dbng

tir.

Nhibn

d'h

rld'

dring

hlrrh

ph0ug

(6cran)

sAng

(116

ld

nhiing

ffim

gif,y

tria

ciing c6

chdt

xut,r

ph{t da

dantr

sfrng

vA

khi nio

ddn ma-nh€

di

urn

chilp

6ntr

bAt

lOn ta

rgi

vio

moi

xiy

ra

hi$n

tucrng.)

Vcvi

cfc tfrm

plr0ng

nAy

ngudi ta

df,

'roi

dusc

hinh

cira

dbng

tfr

l6n bbng

ma ld

hai

hlnh

khic nhatr.

Ilbn

nra

Madeleine

ddn ugbi

noi dhn rlucrng

clnr dA

dArrir dAn.

'

Itbi r16n

hlin

cd Josepbine ddn ghn

b0n

dbug

tri

Om

Ong

ta

vi dfin 6ng

ta dang ngAi

ngir

rldn

cfr

tga.

.

[I6n

tna

t\ladeleine

cfing

ddn

ddn

dbng

tfr

lJlaise

ra

chd

cfr

to*

xem

l\dadeleine

m{c {o kh{c cdn

dhng tfr

tslaise

thl

m{c

6o

ktt*c.

Madeleine dQi

mff b0

r0

trlng vi cholng

mqt

cdi 6o tring

phtr

d[i,

tay

cut.

TSt

eA

viflc

kh&o-sAt

cia t0i dA

f,i

ddn kdt lu{n ring

c6

su

gil

tgo,

r>

Nlantes

khOng



'il

{6

xu{t

hi$n

hbn

ma

thAn

{6n

hhlo

EAt

hi$n-tugng

nh&n

br1

roCt

hiQn

,,

hbn

ma

nhu

c6

th$u

Ong

vi6t:

rHuAr

cruEu

HdN

MOt

hbn

ma hifn

'l0n

m{c.

db

trlng

dl

qua,

di

tqi,

vA

choi

tldn

ducng

chm

(cAy

dAn

ducrng

clm,

nAy

dty

nip

rn&i

lg

cbu

?

iru

piano

fernr6).

Hbn

ma

nAy

dlch

thtn

ddn

rn&

cfra

sb

rt8

cho.

cri toa

duqc

thfiy

rd

t'tng

hon.

Tr€n trAn

uAng

c6

.

nhibu

{nh

sAng

mlu

luc vl

vlng.

at,

I

6' Y

trong

hO;

nghi0n

cuu

<

Fiat

Lux

n

c6

tb

chrle

nhiEu

cuQc

rhi

nghidm

vdi

dbug

rt?

bA

H. Gel.

Sau df,y

lA

mOt

doan

trlch

trong

t{c pbhm

r

Snr

la terre,

la

vie

de

l'au

delA

D 1925

cfia

chtnh

t{c, gil

le

H

et E

Gal vi6t,:

...

<

Babr'

thi

nghiQnt

tO.Z,.tgdS.

Squ

b6n gid

y€n

tdn${

hi$n

luong

phAt sinh.

NhiQu

ti6ng

gd nhg

tr€n bAn vi

lr6n

cdc vAch

tui'rg.

Ohring

rOi

tit

etdn.

NhiEu

ngu&i

trong

ben

chring

lOi

c6 clm'tu&ng

c6.

nhfrng

lobng

tinh

kht

lgbh

chay xurrg

quanh

cAc bin

tay.

Do

dfiu

biQu

cfie

ha

v0

binh,

chtng t0i

btt

dOn

116

chcrp lnh.

ts6ng

nhi6n

c6

mQt b6

hoa

roi

xudng

tr6n

bln

tay

,chung

t0i.

Sau

khi

rrla

finh,

.chring

t0i

thdy

htdh bln rhAn

cfirr

mot

ngudi ddrn.

bt ml

cAc

ndl tr€n

guong

milt

r{t

rd rAng.

Elu

choilng mQt

cAi khdn

voan

c6.nhfrng

du&ng

x6p

thring

phfr

xudng.

NgtI"

deo mQt

cii

kibng

chq.m

hat

ngec

v*

minh,

phfi

mQt

tdm

vfii

tring.

(

xunS

t6i c6

huybn

.," Bubi

lhi

nghidm

28.3,792r.

MOt

hbn

hiQn

t6n

tu

lA

Emily

miit

nim

1865.

Sau

khi

chup

lnh

chring

hlnh

mQt thi6u

nii.

Ce;

nCt

c6 :vE

thanh lich,

vi

lo

lfuir.

cho

ta

,c6

clm tr&ng

nhg nhlng.

.

i'

TTII,N

LINU

HOC

17

I

HiCn

i

tuong

hey

cfrng

ditgc

viOn

ki

su

lestouuann

&j-su

Lo"-t

9"

.Oog

nhfrn

6ng

Albert

Fourid

d6n

nghiOn-

.tio

sg

biQn

hlnh

nit

vl

cfrng

tli

ddn

kdt

lufln

c6

\ h$t)

sg

Madoleine.

ftierre

Emile

Cornillier

dlcb

'

rri0n-ruonql

vi

22'5-1926

6ng

rlf;

c0ng

e

TOi

thf;y

rd

i

ring

trong

srp

thlt

khuOn

m{l

cfra

mQt

agudi

i

a{n

ff,

kfrOng

c0

kh[n

1

voanr

kh6ng

c6

hda

tran61

vl

khong

rlu.

|

'

]

TOi

lflX tna

b

ngilm

vA

]uc

sodt

theo

i

tOi'

Kdt

loqo

"

Sf

hiQn

nbn

r{

nhftng

sF

that

hh0ng

phfii

,{a

tr',

[o

rnuflt.f

fliln

na

kh[c'

voi

rtb'g

rfr.

Ilflr

chic

'cbln

laol

u

motlnguoi

dln

bl'

D

(1)

.'

HiQn

tugng

b

M*ottt

lgi

drgc

nhAn

clrung

thri

tu

li

ky

Bu

Henri

Azam

nghiOn

cuu

trong

trlm

bubi

tht

nghiQm

n[or

fin

vt

ai

I

aen

t6t

lugn

dbng

tfr

Blaise hhong

hE

Itra

bip.

(tudn6

ltnoA,

trong

iqp

cht

Psychia

15-8-1928)'

''I

I

r

'.i

Tqp

eht

bA

Frondoni

ilbng

lfr

le

,i

t,

I

Psybhia

ngfiy

Laiombe

c6

bt illu

tu&c

btt

cfia

1923

vdi.

tt

*a

15-8-1923

duOi

ng0i

kE

cugc

thi-nghiQm

nlnt

Pouza.

(l);-

met6rialisatio-ns

6talent

bien ttes

ttres

livantr'

uon

des

c

Cdntribution

I

l'6tude

a.ionostteg

ellcr

{t"i.ot

diff6rontos

drr.

m6.t'm..,

st hrne

d'olles

cn

toute

ccrtitude

ilioe

leune

femme.

(troDg

c

cdntribution

I

l'6tude

.

'-^-

i^ rtr--r--

-

Dra*a limita Carnillier 1S29 treng

1l),

'9q tvrtv

,des

ph6oomdncs

del

uantes

r

pierre

Emile

cornillicr,

1929

traEg

1l).



4E

TIIAN

LINH

HOG.

rrla

iuh

chung

d6nh

rdi

llm

thdi

vAo

kholng

til

rg

hi$n

hbn

tr0n

chidc

tlo

bAc

si

thuYbrr

tru&ng

ctriOu

hbn

nirS'.

i

tdi

c6

cho

ta

tlrd

ki

Mqt

chuy$n

thcr

mQng

nhltt

tdu

thtry

<

ltonla

Cie

Fabre

>

tir

Ong

Chaix

diEu

kbibn

cuQc

I

Nhibu

hlnh

ray

in

dilu

tron

l']ot'

Nhfi'ng

hlnh

tay

nAy

riit

niiec

vOi

fri[rn.

tay

cfc

nguoi

tr&n

tiu'

MQt

chidc

duong

chm

&

trCn

tau,

kh6n6r

co

nguo[

duoc

drlnh

l€n'

Chfng

i.i

U,

On"

rred

tiu.

ti6ng

rilri*n

cfic

trnh

tldn

stbu

t't

h6t

rbi

qhfng

leri

thdy

cdch

xa

dO

d0

mu'oi

thu6'c

mQt

i

bong

xAm

dans]

xoal

tr0n

xung

quintr

minh

hhof;c

mOt

chi6c

6o

cholng

trfing'

MQt

nguoi

'trong

bon

bfll

ddn

bfim

vB

phta

y'

'fa

thf,v

d6

ii

-Oi

ngoai

con

,g{i m[c

quhri'

min

xanh

l{

cAy

vrl

lo

tnhi

lung

<tairg

mria'

Tr0n

dhu

ngutii

tlAn

b&

ndy

cd

dQi

mQt

cdi

k[r[n'

Vff

ttiQu

cira

ngudi

din

bi

mun

theo

d0ng

phqong

vi

gi6ng nhu

l6i mfa

cira

nhftng

ngu&i

dAn

bil An

dO.

Uiqn

ttrqog

lfiu

tr6n

20

phrit

rbi

ngudi

.t

niy

bidn

mdt.

j(1)

\

.*

l*

Dbnq

ti

Jeah

Jozik

ttdn

viQn

Si€u

tAm

linh

qudc

16

rir

nX-

192b

ve

dudi

sg

dibu

khi}n

cfir

bAc si

Eugdne

--6

iti

,uoni

tnu{t

ttiug

trong

bAo

a

fle vue

scientifique

et

-r'F;lo"'

"nirii*'e

r

trrans

2-lef5

trans

4:i

r[uar

cilrEu

EoN

()sty

etii

hqlp

rAc

md

4t

cuQc

tht

nghiQm

ttt

Trong

_cAc

fubi

rnt

nghiQm

c6

nhfrng

bubi

kdt

qufr

khl

quan

mi

cfiug

c6

nhilng

bubi

d6n

h6t

qufr

nhu

f.

C{c

.bi€n.

b&n

.n"

p{c

dA

dua

d6n

nhfrng

nh{n

x6t

gl

?

19

26-3

iil6n

18-5.

c6

giA

tri

c6

khdng

dua

bic ri

O$ty

'i

i

ll

.i

il

|

,iil

: i1

r{i

f

f

I

'

ii

li

'

1l

;l

'i

l

I

'i,r I

'

.1

:l

]I

:'r I

-rI

I

ti

:t

;I

iI

{l

j

I

:'

t;

tl

tl

,i

t

'l

',]

I

,l

jj

ii

l

r1

,1

,:i

ti

0og

quir

quy6t

cAc

hiQn'tugng

xly

ra

, trong phdrng

thi nghi$rn

clf,

dugc

quan

sAt

trong

tinh

,tr$ng

h6t

suc

blnh

tinh

vA

khOng

phAi

do

su

tAn

loqn

tinh

thhn

hay

vqng

tmtirtri.

Cd

nhr€n

inh

sAug

nhu

ma

dudc (en

l.eux

follets).

l3ly

khu.rr.

rn{t

hi6n

I6n

cho

t.i

thdy

trong

hai bubt

thr'gtrigm

T^

hhone

16

urQt

guon*

*:,

Tlo

gi6rf

Guzik.

(t)

'Iirudr

g

hqp

c&a

dbng

,1,

,rnu*"r,

ob,

ri6ng

trtn

rh6

gitri

vts

rrlrfrug

nb'g

luc

dbng

cdt,

vo

cria bac

si

CRANDoN

dv

IlosLon

nhfln

viO'

hQi

nghi€n

ctu

tam

rinh

Ms duoc

quarl

sfrt

n6m

lgZZ,

''Irudng

hop

crja

duoc

bAi

'si

llrwin

Trong

mQt

bubi

lOn

va

clm

dng

dign

khfc

&

ngoAi

tbAnh

c6

lh0t.

(t)

Bin

tudrig

trinh

tthy

d&

I'institut

m6lapsychique

de

paris

r

ehique

thAng,

1l

vi

t2:1928.

(2)

Xem

Dr

Edwin

lJowers

:

phenomena

of

ttie

Seance

ttoom

tlbng

t*

Frank

Decker

& lfy

cting

I3owecs

nghi0n

ctta.

(2)

tht

nghiQm

mQt

hbn

tOn

lA

pasry

hifn

tho4i

d6

n6i

chuyQn

v&i

mQt

nguo.i

ph6.

'Su

li0n

lgc

bfing

tliQn

thogi

nty

,

ata

'

trong

:

c

Le

m6dium

J. Guzik

i

(Dr

Eug,

Osty).

Revue m6tapsy-

<

Spiritualism's

Cha[cnge.

The

r

New York

1936.

/



I

I

I

i

60

Henry

S. Olqott

'sfng

lflP

vi0n

qudc

t6

trong

'lt6c

Phhm

:

<

PeoPle

*-

''

.^ t,

r,'h--

cO

tbufit

lqi

su

xu{t

hi$n

c&a

hbn

crl

tog.

l

vAo

Nhibu

tidngi

tfr vin &

trong

TEAN.LINH

TIOC

hOi

'lhting

Thi6n

hgc

from

the

other

worltl

>

ma

Katie

llrink ml

;dbng

trl

lt

bA

iCompton

dugc

ki8m

so6t

ki'

BAa

ri

L

Th.

Charerain

trgng

tdc-phhm

<

I\IaLdrialisalious

Deu

connues

>

thu$t

lai

4bng ttt

l&

bA

Bablin

bi

sQt

lrong

-

.;

-N---^.^

r-l-

^l-l

jUe

,n*,,n

quiln

nhiEn

dAy

vf

cAc'

rniri

tllroc

trfm chl.

inf

irop

*o

qT hn

,cfie

bh

tal

tr1 nbi6n

hi

lQt

ra

vi

v{t

'rr{uar

cHrEu

HdN

ki6m

soit,

L.i,r

ffy

cAc hif

n

tugng

c<

n6i

I vi

sArg

n

<lEu

xuilt

hiQn

trong phdng

tht

nghigm.

ma lriQn

l6n,

rd6i

khnQu

rn{r

kh6c

nhau. (l)

Cirng trong

chuong

Sy

c{r

thb

chqp

&nh

vi

c{c

hif n

tucrng$

xly

ra

,51

r

clc

:inh

Mudi

hbn

1

nAj

chrlng

ta rIfl

thfiy

cAc

bi6n

tuo..rrg

cAc

hiQn

tuoog

ndy

cflng

rfit

gi6ng

nhrr

.ngoAi

dli,

khdng

phfli

&

trong phong

I

,l

rl

.t

,i

I

.t

.,

I

I

t

**

a*a

UAc

sT

Euril

Servadio

tb

chrtc

nhiBu

cuQc

ilrl-nghifur

& La m[

vdi ciiing

tt?

Pasq:rale

Erto.

Diirrg

{ri'

c'lemau c&ng

duoa

ki6m

so{t

trong

cfrc'hi6u-rurrnq.

Ll:lc

harig

pbtc

trlnh

niy

c6 ghi

rd

troug

t6c-pbhm

r<

I.here

is

no

dedth

r

oria lrlor

ence

l\Iarryal

Ii6t

lu{n

:

Cic

sg

,rr,

"**ero

vl

hhoa

chiOu

hhn

do

nhibu'',hir

rri

thr?c

vi b{a

hgc

&

nhitru

nu&c

tr6n

rh€-

gi&i

lrghid' efu

vdri .hi€u

rlbng

tfr.

q6

khi

mQt

rl6ng.tfr

drtoc nhiEu

rrhA ngghi€n

cuu

lhn

luot

thi-nghiQm.

(2)

Cic

biOn

b,ln dfi

chung

mintr

hiOrr two,ng

sO

dnAt.

'I'uy

nhi0n

cd

mQt

sd

rtiirrg ti'r

lua bip lr

bit

qui

tnng.

Do

d6 r:hG*g

tliirrg

trlr nay

4ii

ldru

cho

khoa

chi0u-

hbn

b

mang

ti6riq

1A

nlrilng

tr$ liip-bonr

c6

tinh,,cAch

xio

thu$t.

nfq[

cnQc

t|rr

ngtriQm

cfir

.6septr

tte

Wyckoff

&

Niru

uf

c

i

trinS

phirrjg

khso ciru

f'*c,

tti4tt

111r.IuS

tt\m

linh'

Db[,g

rfr?

pdank

Decker

.q

tr.rg

t,ot

tr4n{

thAi

h6'

me

rfi

ntr

rudjt

tnoi

gian

hi1fln-,".:"u,

xutrft

ot:'1'

Ngty

S-12-lpfZ

ong

fAYLOtt

& Nftu

Udc

ki

lr0t

nlt0n

vi6n

r:fra

hQi

lio

thuflt i\If

(sqci6t6

arndricnine

des magiciens)

dilrr

t+i

ritty

'IF

ki6m

sodt

dbng tir

l)ec1er,

[uc

soirt

ky

lud.ng

vh

crrdi

ctrng

5eu

clu

rlbrrg

tfr vtr0

ngbi

trcrrg

m$t

c{i

bao

(sac) do

Ong

simvi6ng

kh'of

l4i

bii'g

cic

tl khofr

cira

6n5;

dern

rheo.

Sau

id6

Patsy

(nrgt

hbil

noa)

len

ti6ng

li

ndu

hqr

m&

duqc

cil

b[o

drlng

rtbng

tr?

I)ecker

dtrcrc

thl

sao

?

iTaylor

til

ldi

le

Ong'

ta

sE

cho

luOn

cAi

bao.

fiy'

Sau

d6

20

phrit tu

nlien

cU

bao

hi

ldt

ra

vi

vilt

vAo

dlu

gdi

cus

ctr

tot

i

vgng

I

clQi- trong

ldc

.

d6

thl

tlbug

thdi

hdn me

(lranse)

vd

viln

dqoc

thi

nghtQm

vb'

crie

'dn

dE

ma hi$ir

hbn

v.v.

Gusrave

Le Bo'

(I)

Xem b6r

<

L'aslrosophier

vol

VIII,

s6

6

(21-2-lg:13)

tra'g

:lixf"

Joseph

rle

Wyvekoffs.

biQt gii

vA chin

(2)

SE

tr&

lei

v{n:dl

nAy.

trong

phln

,

lV

phin

trong

tlc

phlm qly.

I

v6

tay

lrqng





THi,N

LINH HOC.

Song

vdl

n{iing

cuQc

nghiOn-cuu

cira

cflc

nbi

bAc

hgc

qurdc-td

'nl

:nh4ng

cuQc ki6m

rgAt rfit

ch[t

chE khOng

lhe bio rflng

i*c

ngudi

nfiy dA bi

dbng

tfr

lta

ddi.

Chfng

ta"bi6t

r{ng

cd khi

mQt dbng

tfr

duoc

nhilu

nhl

nghi0n-criu

khlo

j

rAt

chu

kh0ng

phii

chi

mot

nhA nghiOn-

'crtu

mi th0i. I

'

,

i

Nhu v{y

nhfing

chung

nhfln

cira

nrQt

s6

ddng

ngu]i

hhdng

thB

xem

h

kh0ng

giA

tri

ituqc

tru phi

ngud'i

ta

cci tlnh

;

nhri

rh1n.

'I

Nhdng

phu{ng-tiQn

dUng

ltl8

ki0nr

so6.t

'

cirn

niot

sS

nhd

nghiOn-ciro

nhtr

Witlirm

Qrookes

vi

Crourrvell

Yarley'

rl6i

vdi

dbng

tr?

bir

Fay kh0{g th0

b6o ld

co

thB bi lus.

viQc

]dy

nhu saf :

$6nr

Anh

c{

be

Fay

nbi

ltitlng

vb

phep

c6 th6 xirflt

bi{n

i&

lmgt

;rci

khAc

trong

khi

chintr lbin.xdc

.bA

&

mQt

noi.

[iith6

nlrt]

btc hoc.'W.

lClroohes

vir

Ong

Varley kY-

str aignj

vt atul

ln

nh&n

vi0n

HQi

lliin

LArn

Arltr

nrcri

qoyi;t

tlinh

m&

,cugc

thi-nghiQm

;,;l

fiq,ban

dE bAlrav

vdo

mft

girn

plr0rrg

dtii

l<i6nr soAt

kV ltrd'hg

chic

]chfin

khdng

cir

,m{it

ai

c{r

thB

nrip

l6n

vd

(tXt

rnfit be thdng

chfing

chil

c{.c

thr.'t dril tlS

eQt

bA

tB

Iti

tl"ong

chi6c

:qh6

bAnh

vA

]clro

cliQn

chly clnrng

quauh,

Nlr"r

viv

trln

l*

Iray

cfr.dQdg

tl gl

r]Frr

c4 ni6y

glri

':i

vS-

klr.irrrq

ttrb rlAo lua

bip

.

ai

.r-lrroc.

.i

Ong CSx

rrrOt

vi

quan

toa chilng

ki6n

curl,c thi-ngtri{rn

fi3

eio ha-v OnS

Crqohes

vd

icAc

ban

cfin

6ng thfiy

hirltr

rlnng

rd

r$t

nf

j

faf,

trf bi dCc,

c.o h.ra xnnh,

crirrh

tr:ry

TIIUAT CHIEU

HON

trhn vA deo

dbng

hb

dCn

trao

cho

6ng

Crookes

mQt

cudn

sach.

Ttr ch6

Ohg

Crookes.

ngbi

,rtdn

ch6 bA

Fey

ngbi

(sau

cAi

mln

che)

rilt

xa dE

c6 th8

ngd

r&ng bt

df,

kidm

cAch

di ra

dua

srich hay

v6'i

ra,

VA

tqi

dong

diQn

,

vfin

ch?y

md

khdng

gbi

nhftn

6u99

srp

xd diqh

n]o c[

vi

chAn

lay

tlbu

bi

tr$i

cl

thl

lAur

sao

mA

di.

Troug lfc

thi

nghiQrn' mQi nguoi rlEu

thdy

hiQn-tuo.ng

nAy song kh0ng

ai

chiu

hd

mOi

cho ai bi6t c&

nhu

v{y t|l

hh0ng

phli

lA

ldi

vong

tu&ng,

cbung (hallur:ination

eollective). Ndu

lt

vgng tu6ng chung

thi

cfi bqn

ctrng

phli

cho nhau

bi6t

rd ringitcilng mQt luc khi

hiQn

tuong xly

,ra

(uhung dAy

lt

trud'ng

bqp

xudt

hbn cfia

.

dbng

tri'),

YiQc

thu hai

ld

bAs

si Gibier

m&

cuQc

thi

nghi$m

'vdi

dbng'tft

Salmon.

l|il

Salmon bi

nbdt

lrqog

nhiing

lbng

luo'i.

Nhftng

cuQc

tht-nghigm

cfra

Ong

v&i

dbng tft'Slide

trong

li3 bnbi

(ilbng

t& niy df,

.tlqoc

nhi

thiOn

r[n

hgc

Zoellner

]gido

su & r4i dai

hgc

duln 1

Leipzig

(Euc)

nghi0n

cun

cirrrg vo'i mOt sfi I&n

cAc

gifo

su

dqi-hqc khAe)

vfi

(ilhier

clff hdt luAn

rfing :

u i[

Slu,l" khOng

ci

rtiSm

nilo

c6

thB

brho

ld

bio

bom

>,

Ong

vi6t

:

r<'l'rong

circ

cuQc tbi

<<

nghi$m, chlnlr clrting tdi dff

dlch

thAn kiDm

soAt

giar:

<r

phong

rili b[.t

v

cdi

giiry,

sb

so4ng

lse srr6t

tron€

Ao

<<

q':Rn

1.

tlilr

gio

ehrtng

tOi

xin l6i

y

rJf,

ph,

i kb.{m

ret

<r rr,trn v$y

ni5u

rnudn hi$n tuong

diro'c xfrc

th{t

r.

2)

Cftc

cttdc

cltiiu hdn

rtilu

do

sp

finh

c,J

(lmsard)

hug

trimg lrc.t'c

coinr,itlenct.)

IIiQn

tucrng

nCy kh0ng clrtng

nhfit

le hhi

hign

inorrg rlrrcrc

ki6nr

soAt f

ti.

Vt

drr

nr0t hbn

t€n,:ho

bi6t

sinh &

ttAu..md.t

&

' Su,

cuili ctug

hi'8rn

soAt lgi

dtng nhu

vSy.

Vi{c

hiEm sr:ft

lJ

r.ill,,.'.|..,'.'i...''..,':l.j

...'

tib$

'

:

:'.'.3

.

.r#



I

)

Jrulng

Uqirlhbn

bdctsi

Khpx nhd

nh{p,xic

dbng

tfr

vi6t'

drgc

vf

,b0t

tu gi6ng

hlc

cdn

sinb

ribn,

icrrdng

hqp

thi6u tuong

Korff

,cb6t

vi

ntiip

.vAo:dbng

rri

cE

chi

b&n

'di

chrtc,

tru0c

kfi

lAm

cbung

Oirg

{y

qu0n

l4i

cho

gia

dtnh vA

,sau

d6

[tm

ra,

viQc

flilliam

Stead

rn0t

nhA

t&nn

linh.

hoc c6 ti6ng

dE

dAnh

cuQc

vcyi

anli lf,

.futia

dA

luc

Ongrniyi chdt di,

nh6p

x{c

rtbng

tfr

l0n.

chi

rd

ch6

da

brlc

thu, vA mi6ng

'ngdi

bA

d6i

nhu

lA bfrng

c6 hic

cdn

&

duong

.

th6,

vCQc

hbn

con nhil

.vat

lf

hoc

Oliver Lotlge

nh{F

vito

Abng

h& cho bi{t

tung

ttch

mqt

bric

{ntr

cii

cria y,

viQo

Vincent Reggio

ch6nh

An toA

'Ihu'qng

'Ihhm

G0nes

1i;

nn6p

qio

rAc

tlbng

lk6

rnQt chuyQn

mi

Ong

.te

trdi

f

lqi v0i

I'hdmas

Reggio

tlnh

muO & Y

.;lA

anh

mQt

ml

.cbi

riOng

dng

ndy bidt

mi th6i.

dEu

c6 thb

xem

nhu

nhiing

c0n

chuyQF

dn

ggt

b&

pa

ngoAi

gi&

thuy0t

trtng

hgp. j

,.

,'

llcacUubi

cArcu

ftbh dlu

ad ,lgng ta&ng

(haltuciiwtion),

drn

thi

(suggestton)

hag

tq

kg dm,

tlg

(autosuggestion).

Thd

nto

goi

i

ll

:ygqg

tu&ng

?

Vgng

ru&ng

lA'

tuqng

tu&ng

rtdn

.mQt

cfli

gt,

mgt

diBu

gt

qt

rh{r

ra

hh6ng

c6.

:l'l-.--

i

-

.t,--l'.

-r-

:---d

---i-a

\

'.ili

nof

l

yig":{eh

lqi

dhiBu

thich

rh6,

ddi h6i

+hiEu.rhdi

r{ sn1v1

c0ng

n{u,

chfrng,

kenlS

diBu

tra

ngudi

s6ng.

..t

I

'

I

r.

ViQd

hbn

cfiq Oscard

Wildb

hiQn

l0n

vi6r kich

vt

gigng

{ir,

l'I '.i.',','"-L

,iiiou'jci1

kE

ou{f

ct

auig hbolre

(tdenrificetion

der

esprits)

vrn

rfiq

gidng

f,ic saoil

ribn

ivd cho

bi6r

nhibu

oni

riei

nh6

rnh{t

vb

il{i

tu

cira

:

Ongl mt,sau

d6 ki0m

soAt

I+i

dtng,

hp6ng

niif

tdi

ch& cfia

j

<lbng

ifr

vi6t

dem

so

s{nh

rdi

btt

.

tr;

"pfu

bng ta

ltc-

con

sdng

ifir

gittng

.

nbau.

;

\

i,"-:

- --,r.,

ll

'rHuAtlcurEUHbN o

'

,',

;

'

i

57

'

TrQng

ldi

vong tb&ng

nly cd

c&i

do,lai,

do mll,

do

'mfii

hly-t6rn

lqt do

ngfi

quancira

thln

rtc.

Khi"mQt

ngudi

vgng

tu&ng

phln

nhiEf

:

hQ

tq

Am

lnh

'If,y,

gqi

lA

'vqng

tu&ng

cA

nhAn.

,Khi

mQt

s6

ngu&i

vQng

lu&ng

thi

ggi

ln

vqng

tu&ug

chung

,

hay t{p

thD

(hallucination

collective).

Vi

ldu

:

ni0t

ngudi

thdy

mQt

ltu lA chudi

'{dnh

sQt

so4t

tlrrbi

Anh

trhug

blo

tI6

lt

ma

thl nh&ng

ngucri

di

v&i

y vi

sg'hfii,

vl

bi

ngrli

kblc Am

'

thi

kh6u

goi

sanh

ra

ldi

tF hi

Am

tlri,

rti

ctqg

cho

,

dd

lt

hbn. ma'

Nhu

v*y

lt

dn

vong

tu&ng.

Nhung 8rf

vong

tu&ng

nhu

'thd

phhn

nhilu

tlbui,do u.Qt.

clm

xrlc

dE"dQi

g0y

nCn'

(1)

Cfim

x*c

ilv

ttAnh

mgnh

.iAo

gitc

quaq

cira

tg vir

.khidn

ta

c6 mot

{n-tt:ong

hay,

mot binh:

lnh

hh0ng

cd

th&t' Vl

lai-

*

nnudn

bi

vong

tu&ng'ngu&i

ta'

thulpg q.trqng

th{t

kh6ng

,,rlnloc

blih'thuong.

Khi

cfe

nhi

nghi0n

'ctiu

&

trong

phdng

lht-nglriQru

{hl

kh0ng

th8 bl.o

I

hg

.vgng

,

tu&ng

t{l cA'

'frfi

ldi ctro

l4p

lu{n.

dQ,

Rlchet

c6

vi6t

:

I

Cho

riing

',yqng

tu&ng

lt

chuyQn >

ti6t suc

con

nit, 0

dia

bat

siou

hlntr

cfrng

nhu

,&

rlia

h4t khoa"hgc

'khAc

khong

nen rtdi

,

.d6n'

vong

tu&ng;

t(hi

ruQt

'gudi

nhln.

trdn

htn

thfr bi6u

3B'5

ln 38'5.

Ndu

tro

th$y Anh

sfng

lA

thily' nghe

ti6ng

dQug

ll nghe...

r

,

GiA

thu;dt

vQng

tu&ng

nty

c6'

phln

thlngfikbi

nti

d6n

mQt

sd

biQn

tuoog

tlbng'.

b6ng

&

ben

ta'

(l) X€E

r l'An

lj,

KhAng

dich.

quln

ch{ng

r

cira.

Goltare

Ie

Bon,

Nguy6n vin

-

îlti

,;l

-,'.{.1

.;it

:t:.S

,

j::f

':::1h

. ,:i;.

'

j

.'ili

'

'

"i:l

.1,].ll

,:-in

;

:.,1 |

):

.',i,

::l

.-'.:-,

,..til,

,i'q

,.'l.

,,Jl

.

r""f

. .l

i

",]l

I

'rl

.,



TlluaT cnrEo sdN

Edy

li

quan

diEm

cfia

Morton

Prince

(trong < Subscon-

ciousi

phdnom6na

D

treog

87) .c Tdi

th{y

ngudi

la

d[

qu6'

quan

t0m vb

viQc

chrtng

tr c6

hi6u

hay

khdng

c{c

dtdn

trinh

c6

j

thuc.

Thf,t

1a,

chring

ta

dang

dring

trndc

clc

hiQn

iuong

holn

toin

gi6ng

nhnu

du'di

mqi

khta

caub

vdi

phhn

thua

trtr

lA cd

khi chfng

ta

hiEn

cAc

hiQn

tucrng

ftQt

cAch

cO

J

thrlc

vA

c6

kqi

kh0n8.

>

,

Nhu thd

bAc si

Morton

Prince

chf,p

thuf;n

su c6

tha

c6

'rQt

{, thuc

C6

th$

nfi

lA v0

f

lhuc(N,iorton

l)rince tflrnel

dgnc la

p6ssibilitc

d'ttne

conscience

pour

ainsi

dire incotrscienl).

Di;i

v<ri

tOi

d6

ll

mQt

quan

uiQm

kh6

khln

vi

rrhu

tlr6

chn

phti

gdp rirt

dinh

nghia

phhn

f

thuc

ld

thd

nAo

?

I)di

vdi

t6ii.

tdi

hhdng

c0ng

nh0n mQt

j'

thud ini vO

thiLc

(P<lur

ma

part

jene

cclngois

pasla

possibilit6

d'une

conseience

ineonsiente)

(trich trong

r<

Analyse

de

t'esprit

>

IJerlraird

Ilussel

lrang

32,

Payot

xu{t

b[n;.

Binet mQt

lAm

lf

hgc

gia

Pbfp

n6i

ddn

mQt

v0 sd

j

thuc

(une pluralit6

de

conscience)

hay

grQt

h4

J

thrlc

&

ngodi

phhn

Ef

thue

chtnh

(une ious-tonscience

en

dehors

de la

conscience

PrinciPale).

cic

lu{n

di$u

cia

cAc

nbA

tAm

kdt

luin

u

l$t

khb

gili

quy6t

vCrr

t6i chn

n6n

giF clc

khla

canh

lil

60

I i

,i

i i

rELNLrNHEoc

dbng

rfr

vi6t

vfin &

trong

trang

thii

t

rhLrc

vA khOng

bi6r

pfiog

bAn tat

cira

minh

dang vi6t.

Ebng

tfr lt

nh&bg

:ngudi

bO

tUE

ilf cho

v0

y

th;uc

tr;

do

host

ilQng.

(l)

, Edi

vdi

Chevreuil

tiEm

thrlc

lA

phhn

mt

j

rhuc

kh0ng

ki0d

Colt' drrod.

D0

lt

mQt

ldanlr

tu

c6

lE

c6 lctr

cho

,cnc

hoh

(tb

cfih

]cAc

ly

thby{t

khirc

nhau dfrng

'de

giii

thtchi

hien

tuqng vi

kh0ng

c6 danh

tir nAo

ri6ng

biCt,

song

ln

mQt

dafrli

tu

tqm

thdi

c6

th8

mdr

di

\hi

ngudi

ta

tlm, ra

nhn{rg ngubn gdc

th{t

cfia

su

hoqt dQng

vA

cira

tu tu&ng

fn

phln

tibm

thue biEu

lE

ra.

,

Ddi v0i

Heirri

Azam

r

dairh

tir tibm

rhuc

chi

hinh dunSg

mqt cdi

trii tuqng

trung

mI

khoa

hgc

nghdo

,nAn

cfia

ta

biQn

nay ddn

dui

gdi

-&

{Idy.

Dd

lA

ruQt

danh

r{r

hay

song

tl$

chi

t6

$ni

ngg

dOt

vi

cAi

bfit

luc

rrong.oAch

llf

giAi.

>

(t.e

Subconscientj

est

un

cul

de

qac

syrnbqtirlue

oir vien

s'age-

nouiller

notre

pduvre

science

c'est un

mot

l'ameux

qui

cache

I'ignorance et

l'iripuissance de lir. rldmonsl,rntion

r Le

houbeur

parlait

) psge

1110.

Henri llegnaull). NIQI

vAi

hoc

gifi

htr6r:

nhrr

i\Iyr:rs dirng

danh

tit

<

Conscience

suhliminaler

(hay

-'t

situ

f

thtlp) cilirg

c6 nghia li

subcousuient.

Irlournoy,

gido

su lAm

lf

hqc

dqi

hec

ducrn$

Geudve

cho

riiug

nhFng

hi€n

tuorrg vA

diirr

lrlnh

(processus)

mA nguli

ta,

xerlt

nhrr

lii

cO

y

thric m{c dhu ngu&i

dy

khOng

hl6t

vi

n6 di0n

ra

du0i

muc

cha

phhn

trt

tbrJrc

thucing,,.

Bertrand Rusrel.pQt

hgc

gil

anh

ph€

biub

rhuydt

tiBm

thuc

khi

dtrng tt6

gili

,rhtch

ctc

hiQn

tutrng

vE

ldi

chfr tu

dong

nhu

sau:

:

(l),xem

tai

tidul tham

khlo

sd

46

lcollectir.rn

Que

sais

je).

I

I

I

l

t

I

;

t

I

I

I

I

I

I'-illoux

tli0n

dhu

vi

lj'

hgc

nOn

Ong

di

d6n

db niy

vl

theo

J

chung

miu

thudn'

{y.,

.

Chring

ta

nh{n

thdY

c(r

nhftng

sg

bfit

dbng

trqng

lhAi

cfia

tAm

hbn'

ngay

trong

phdi

ldm

lf

hqc

citng

f

ki6n vb

vCn

dE

giti

thich

clc

con

ngudi.

xung

quanh tiOq

chuhn

.,'



63

HUAT

CNIfU

HT}N

dff

ghi trong

phiro

trinh song lt lAu

seu Ong

tt

ngqc

nhi0n

ttr6n

ctro tAc

glft

hay

chlnh lA

mot

dta

con

trai

(l).

VAy

rht

khOng

th6 bio ld do

v6.

thuc

hay

liBm thu'c

mil.

ilbng

tfr

bigt

,rnQt,chuyQn

yikh0ng

rd.

SrI

n$.ry hi6m

Ii

nhiEu

nhi

l&,m ly

.

hqc

c6

tidng

song

hh0rrg

bao

gio

khfio-cuu'

vi[ tbi-nghigru

vE

chi€u'

lrbn

llrnAt

nit

l4i cd

gatr

tuy0p bd

nhii'ng

diBo

khi6n cho

ngucri tn

rtgrr

riing

ho li

k6

kh6og c6

ti

hi6n

thitc

gi

vb viln

db

hg dang,

phO

irlrrh.

Eb l*

dibu chrlug

ta nhfln

lhdy icri

Philippe

Girardet

khi

Ong

db

cfp

ddn

vfin-db

chidn

hbn

thu{t trong

l{c phhm

,c

tl'i6t

rrguoi

l (Ph4m

carr

-l.'irug

.<l;cb).

(i)

Cttc

'

bnhi

rltt\u Ifin rlo

ilbng

t[r

trudt

hi)tt

1go

ro.

Dd

li

,lhng?:t

silrft

,lcfti

(thtorie

de l'animisme).

Nilrr,rri

t,t cr

tlr6

ruilt

via,

xufit

bhn.

Do tri

mQt.

diErl

chEc

chiin

(2).

Song

hfio

rftng diSng

tfr xufit

h8n

vd

hiOn

ra

(I'1

gi&

r,grrdi

rrrry kE nq,

thl

khd*g <lring

vi?ng"

V,{

j4i

er5 klri irrii

tra

hhn rlra

hiQn ldn

mQt lin

trong

plibrrg

tlti ng\i$r*r, N6n blo

do

dilng tfr thi d6'g t&

cd th.

nri*

Lirm ptrrlp

phfrn

tirfiru dB

hi{n

ra thAnh

hai

ba

ngulri tlusc

'1

I{hu

stll

lA

rudt

tlibu phi

ly.

Iludng nfra ddi r,6i cllc

hiQn

tugn61

l6n

cho bi6t.

tung tlch,

lf

lich,

thi

vi$o

dl5ng

tfr

r.u{t hbn

i18

l+o

ndn hrQn

tugng

khdrng th0 nAo

cOng

nhAn

rltfgc

{fruirng

hqp

Oscard

\Yilde vi6t

hich),

(l)

Xern

tai

liQu

them

khio

(2)

Xdm

r

Nhfrng hi6n

tugng

sd

5l

trang

51

-

58.

si6u hinh

r Cbu<rng :*rr{t hbn

-

6?

i

'

,

f

THANLTNHHQC

g

thric

vA

vO

thrlc

thl

cOn

mong

gl

hg co th8

dting ly

gidi

cfra

hq,

.t8

dp

dung

vlg

vigc

giai

thictr

leii

chft

,

t+

'dQng?

'

1

i

,l

'fa

c6

th8 chfip

nh{n

m6t

ptrf,n

nAo

nh{n x6t

dy

ddi

y0i

cA:

nubi

chi4u

'hbn

vd

gifi

iri rni

dbng

tir

ehi

vidt

hay

noi

l0n

nhfrpg

cliEu

kh0ng

dAu,

v0

bb

vA

nh&'ng

iti$u

niy

khdng

ttr&

ki8m

soA

thAt hu. Edi

vtri nrot

sd

lo'n

c{c

hi€n

trlrrng

dbng

b6ng

&

Viet

,Nam

chrlng ta sd

tha

xem

ldi

gifii

rhtch

cira

phdl

tAm

lj'

hqc

c6

phln

xAc rlAng

vl cAe

hign

tuqn$ dbng

b6ng

r

nudc

la

ktrOng

cd ai

db

t0m

nghi€n

ciru

flh&n

tAch

vA

ki6m

soirt

nhrr

vfln

olb

diing

horrg

i.r

ngogi

qridc

dir

du:nc nhiEu

hoc

Siit

dcvn

ctrqc

lray

lirni4

rrht'm

hofic

hi$p trQi

qu6ct te

khfio

rrghiQm.

\

,i

Song

l.)i

giii

thlch

{t'

.

hofrn toArr khCrng tfti'ng

vflrng

n6n'r[p

dlrng vAo

cfc

mAu

chnqgn

chung

tOi

dn,

lrlrh

idfrn.

Ilenri

ttegnaulf

drra

lru&ng

hgp cfra rn$t ngrd'i

tdn

Jean

l\{eqlirr

nhflp,l vdo

xdc

tltin$ln

cdlldldne

'D

ngAy

tr4-4-

1920 ciro

I

niat A1* chi

sS nhA

p

ttr*nn

ph{i

hlarsei}le

vA

bflo

lfi ctrdt

vt

ty

tfr

sau

khi

cffi

vff

r6'i

rnol

ngurri

hang

lOrh,

dn

b[F

bf,

,ta

vA

tu&ng

hA

niy

ctrdt

non

mdi

tr& lni t

sdt.

{.6t

qun

?

'

sau

Lktri

gtti

thu cho

t}A

gtia

phu

Jian

Merlin, t{c

gil

nb*n

dusc tho

trfr

l]i

cho rirng

hl

ta

chinh,lA

vr7

pfiaJean

Merli .'Irong

mOt bubi

chi0u

hbn

khAc

c6

,

vi6n tufng

Z rhl

vA

trong

hic

h6i

chuy$n tfin

thlm

kich,

Jein

plerlin cho h{l

vl

cfii

v[ vo'i

nhi hing

x6m

vi

hA nty ,lc6 mQt d&A

con

lrai cdn

nh6. Snu

khi

kE ch$yf

V

kh{ng

c0ng

nh{t

vA

blo le

g6i

vl

Ong

ta

'\

tAc

gii

:

Nguy6n

khoe

Iluin.

,,1

l*

,]

I



I

6t

I

ZY Cac

bubi

chiiu

Ifin

to

tttb gt&t thich

tlteo

tradng

',

hq{

IF

fQng

(.u

(soyambulfsrpe)

hag

ngadi

itdi

(personnalitis

--,---J--\

|

secondes).

,

I

i

,

Elntr

nghil

ttr

mQng

du

nhu

thd

nio ? ESy

lA

trutrng

hqp

elic

ngrrof

dirng

til

didn

(rnagn6tiseur')

c6

frnh

hudng

d6nL

c{c c"o

fbog

mir

nq lht nghiQm.

:

trpng

trqnp

th{i ndy

kE

]cn*

tri

di8n cd thb

ttibn khi6n

dbn[

jt'r]

aE bpo hs

lAm

thpd

y

mndn.

Nhfrng

hqc

gil

cira

phei

n:iy

lntru

.lanet vd

llinet

gili

thicb

l6i

c,hri tqr

ira

ph{i

n:iy

jntru'

Janet

vi

l}inet

gi&i

thicb

l6i

c,hti

tql

tlgng

phng

gii

thuy6t rrily.

rj

,

Song chring ta

n0n hi€u

rifng

hi0n

tu'ung

,tu.mQng

du

xly

rC

drfi

itl

dieo

khi6n cria Janet,

c0n trong

hi$n

tusng

chiOu

hdn

thl

dbng

tit

vi6t

rnA

khOng

bi

kE

khAc

tlibu

khi8n

bildg

tu tu&ng.

'[rong

trqng thf,i

bdt

dOng

(elat

cataleptique)

vt

trgng thAi md muQi

(6trdt

l6thargique),

nguoi

tg m0ni1

du

bi

kA thOi

mi4n

hay h6

chA

tit

di&n

guoi

tg

mon[

du

bi

kA thOi

mien

hay h6

chA

tir

di&n

sai

khidn

hhu

llcm

theo

f

nnudn cfia

ho.

HiQn

tuong

rlbng

t{r'

vidt

trong cbi6u

hbn thu$t

cilng

lA

hign

tuqng

I

oey.

E6

lA

y

hi6n

cfra

trlc

si

Alerar,drie

Lestchinski

(l)

I

, ;l

tlgng

nhng

gin

thuJ6.t rrily.

tulng .nri,rf

ta

n0n hi€u

riing

hiQn

tu'ong

.tu-mQng

du

TTIUAT

CHIEU

HbN

trfong

rlbng

boug

lA

rnQt

hintr

thuc

cira

tu

mQng

du vo'i

trqng

ttt*i a-

thi

vil

ttr

kf

Am

thf.

TAc

gil

dil

nhln

dbrrg

bdi:as

d*6'i

khia

cgnh

ci,a

nhA thOi

mi6n

mi

t[0i

vd

cllo

rfing hg

lOn

ttreo

ldi

-(

thOi

mi6n

tu.

tlQng >

(Auto-

trlprrntisrner).

Lriri

gi&i

thtnh

dy

c6

phhn

dring

cho

mOt

sd

lrvn

r:hc

hi(:n

tu<rng

dting

b0ng

ri nuirc

ta

sorig

kh0ng

tlr0

: p

tlqrr;4

l6,i

nh{n

x6t

nAy

cho

tofin

th6

cAc

cuQc

hh&o

tcuu

vts

tlilng

b{ng

6'

tr'0n

thd

gi<ri'

(lrrrrrr

nrf

nr

lrhrr

lbd chi

dhhtg

mQt

phirn

nir".r

111q

t rrti.

'I'r:1r1;r

fi,li

trI

rn0irg

drr

bi

thOi

miOn

d{t

ta

lrpilc

t'tQt

.r.[n

rlii:

rrguui

llrt)i

uli0rr

v&

ir6

bi

th6i

rni0n"

{-it.rtt

[rrtr:g

ttr{i

cira

<I(ing

tfr

tlong

luc

lOn

rt6ng

hny

hi

rr}r{p

xdc

rlting

rJ:)t

ta truirc

mQt

v?in

ti6 khdc

hiitr.

1-1'

tl&y

khtrng

ctr

*rqlt

nguiri

rrAo tldtn$

ra thoi

iui6n

vd

rl6ug

tii

bi

.thOi

nri€n'

D$y

chi

c6 rn$t

cir to4

riit

ttdng

mA

tu

lu&ng,

y

nghi

ctra

ho

r{t hhfic

nhau,

rdt

ptruc

t,gp,

thi

& tIAy

ai

li

chfi df,ng

chi huy vAo

<liing

tir ru[

khi6n

y vi6t

hay

ndi

theo

f

cfra

rnQt

ngu':ri

? t{6u

ln

tiur

thi tht

lfiilt

stsl

brit

buQc

y

vi6t

cho

tlung

rtr$t

chft

trong

khi

10

ngtrrli

cd

thi)

nghi

10

ch&

hh{c

nhru ?

(Xem

thuflt

th,ir

rniOn cfra

[)hqm

hgc

Tin)'

Ntrii'ng

tai

li{u

ci'r chii'vi6t

vA

c&

chir'kf

cria

ngrroi

chdt

gi$ng

nhau

hic

cou

sdng

ld

nhiiug

bXng cd

il6 chi

rii

khor:6

rhf

b&o

lA tu

ruQng

du

dugc'

NIm

IOrt

orrg Cumming

Walters

cd

clto

hay

llteo

,l6i

etril,

tu

tlQng

Ong

cd

vi6t

bAi

hAt

cfia

Irrank

Collint

'

(urQt k6

que

vf,ngl

"a

6ng

ndy

qud

mQt

ch&n'

San

khi

nglri0n

cuu

hb

sc/

cira

hQr

,vi

cic

hQi

vi0n

thAm

ni0n

ngrdi

ta

qul

di tim

ra drrqc

mQt

ngucri

cd

ton

la

Frank

corlifis

lA

mQt

l&i

t&

hAt

hay

vi

qud

mQt

chin'

DO

Yi

quan

ni{m

nhu

thd ndn mQt

tAc

gil

khAc

&

Vigt

Nam

nghiOn

criu

vb

hhoa

th6i

mi6n

itl

.ph0

blnh

hiQtt

l.r

(l)

Xem tli li€u

tham kblo

sd

50

r

Psychologte

des

Etats

nerveux

)

(Collection

Actlon

let

Pous6e)

vA clc tAc

phhm

khAc

nhuloia

Piorre

Janet

r L'automatisme

psychologique

r,

JA.Blnet

c Les alteratlons

de

la

personnalitd

r,

Th.

Flourroy

e Dtis

Indes i

la

plandto

Mars

l,

'faine

q

De I'intelligeuco

1.

Ribot

,<"Les

matadies

de

Ia

personnalitd

r.

,]

tl

t



I

I

I

I

l

I

I

l

I

I

I

..:

i

'

,8)

Cfd

,thug6t

hbi

ta&n9.:--

Mot sd hoc gil cho

rfing

;i,o6

trudng

hqp

nhfrng

kJ

ric'. {y

hn tAng

trong

v0

.thric,

rk

'

'11

khi

ivfdt

dqPg

tfr chl

-hbi

]trr&ns

lai

md

,

thoi.

E6

le

I.hiQn;

tugng cry$temndsie

hay

lA rsvivilcence

,

tqm

ggi

li

,

hi$n

tugqg

bbi

tu&pg.

,

,'

tuong cr5rplemndsie

bay IA

rsvivircence

.

tSm

ggi

li

ll'hioo

chta

dA

cbrln6

minb

rXng:.khong

phli

'qui

trong

c*,i

hi$n

,tuqng

chi0u

hbl

'

,

'

drrcrc.

^

'

.i

Vidn

ttiidu

tA

,

barget

,co

eho

Fil

ig"ot

^

l"

co

th6

chup

lrinir

tu

ttr&ng.

te

chi

chn

nghl

ddn

mQt

ngutri

ml

khons

clu,

sq

co

mtt

ctra

y'

Dibu

'nny

dfr

suo

-t4o

nOn

m0t

hith

tu

tu&ng

mA

ooo

mlt ia

khdng

thdy

'drroc

,rsong

ddg

kinh

ctra-may

lnh

c6

thb

gbi

nh$n

itlugc'

C6

;S""t

.llng

,lanh

tu

chrlp

inh

bhng

nhiing

rung

dQng'l&a

lh0

vla

(cliche

.

astral).

L$pl

lu$n

niy

ttring

'trong

nhiEu

tiudng

hgp

song

co

lq

Gi& ,thug6.t

thb,

nil

ta

ta6ng'

(iddopt'astie'1'

Trong

gil

thuyft

cAc

hign

tuqng

do

llbng

tri

t4o

:

ra"

dE

tlhh

bily'

,&

diBm

6,

cdn

mQt lufln

cr

khfc

cho rilng

lnh

cfia

hbn

nna

ohup

tluo'c

ctng

chi

ld

lnh oira

dbng

''

tr?'

:

IlAc

si

Vori

t{ar'fman

gi&i

thtch

]cAc

diQu

{y

chi

dung

klri

chi

tnav

*gt

hinh

6nh

cfra

Abng

rfr

nhung

nhu

chung

ta-

dfl

bj6t

*r"

.OnO

inh

'ra

kh6ng

nhfrng

iigud'i

^tp

:

tndy

lnh

tlbng

to*afrrrlr'cimOthbnkhfcv&ittbtigt&nhutrongtrrr&ng

*U--Unttn

ltr,llglinloo

d'E

$uqc

nh$ bAc

hQc

Nga

Aksakof

.iop

a"rt'ugsy

20-i-1886

&.'tr.rg0n

ddn'

Trong

bftc

&ntr

nlv

c6

c[

hbn

rnQt

ctr

gil

hiQn

l6n

bOn

'csnh

'i

inn

dbng

tfr

Eglinton.

Lci

c6

trr'iOng

hgp

nhibu

hbn hi$u

lOn

eht?

hh6ng

*ofil

la

mQt

hbn

thl

'J'oi')rlrBu

ngurli

cho'

rXng'c{c

iuh

chup

rluoc

trQng

phOng

thi.{nghiQm

phi0u

nbn

thu$t'

'chi

'

li

,<

th6

hiQn

tu"

t1r&ngtr

ldicn

thm

danh,

tri

id.oplastibf

nghia

li

vl

tu

tu&ng-

cira.

ta

nghi

d6n

10t lt1h

lnh

'

,rio

ndn

i:lnh

&ntr

ney

ni€'n

fen

1A

miy

&nh

cb

th-8

chup

THUAT,CHIEO

HON

. cri

toq kh0ng

ai

hay.,bidt

song k6 theo

tluydt

ndy

cho

rnng

dbng frri'

rlff

dgc

ttc

cdn nhd

hay

truoc

116

vlio

qQt

thdi

:

lt i

gian

ndo

dS

tbdntr

bA/,

gicr.mdi

nho il$

vi6r

lai.

Song

i.hhi

kiBmr

so6t,t i,

ngpOirta tii6t r.fing

hiri ilio

dy tric

sinir

Bnl

sreml

so6t

,lFr

ngFditta

biOt

r6ng

biri ilro

ily

hic

sinir

liBu

nhi'vdn

h,io

Osear

Wilde

'chua

co lim

vi

khong

phii

IA

mQt brti

cii

mA

df,y

ld

rnQt

vO

kictr

urui

mi

6{igng

v{n

rdt

gidng

vi cl

.btt

tu

nti,a.

'

"

l

:;

"

'

'

Gil

thuydr

oFy.n6u

ndan

ldinh,.cho,

ky, rht

'cfing

chi

lA

gifinthn5'dt

fbl

tibm

thriql

n$u

dd

rrinh

b&y

&

tti$m

5.

.9)Cd'cbu6inhieu/rbn,ilbu,,ttontaqufi'tao.1g,

'

Gi6o hQi

Latm5

(Ihi0n

chria

gt{p)

ctro

r*ng

Tir0rig

linh

thuydt

,kp6nlg

c6

gid

rri rvl.

cAc

hiQn

tuqng

dbp

do

.ms

quf.

Chdng

t6i s6

tr&

Iai

vdn

dB

nAy & phln

lit

vU

qusn

diBryr

cria' TOn

gi{o,

triCt

If,

khoa

hoc

vd

huybu

bi

hgc

vB

r:lri€u

hbn

thu{t.

r,

I ..

tt

'l

" rl I " l' : ' I'r.'

Quan

di6o

jf,y

g,fng

ndu pa

kibm

soAt lqi

hiQu

tuong.

Vt

du

:

Mqt

tf$ni

lt,1

troog

{rqng

that

ldn

tlbng

viCr

tii

;phfrng

biirtha

{fra

v$n

hAo

Oscar Witde rn{c tlhu:hlc

dy

,'

Allan

Kardec

lfinh

tu

chi6u

hbn

rhu4t

&

phAp

trong

t{p

ThIn

titn'kinh

(Le

tivre

des

Esprils)

de

trtnh

b$y

lhtnh

L

mQt

hg rh6ng

gi{o

tj (Docrrine)

rroirg'116

0n}

hdn

ghtqgl

n frng

lOiL

,ruyOn

b6

cfrp

cAc

v

Thtnh

I

b0n

d+o



THUAT

CIIIET]

TIdN

'l'6m

lqL mQt [ri$n tuong

cfia

'chi6u

hbn thufit

mn6n

,drruc

r:hrlng

rninh d6 ll

hbn

,cfra

kB

ch6t

dn

li6n

lac

viyi

ngrrr)'i

siing

thl

cdn

phfii

c6 nhtrng

ti6u

chuhn

nhu

Sillt:

l)

SU

hi€rn

soAt

rlUug

tri,

phli chu

rliro,

'I'a

kh0ng

ih8

ngor

d,5

trn

{bng

rfr

dii lita

bip

ta.

Sr.r

kiEm so{t cfr

tqa cirnfi rfit'chn tl8

trAnh

su

gian

l4n.

2)

I)irns

ph6p

loai

suy

cAe

gil

thuydt

dA chung

lri

ri"rrrg

lri,{ln tryonl{

dy

khrirrg

th6

gifii

thtch

brii

ctc lj

lE

:

trirrrg

lro-y;^

tinh

co rltay rfri, vgng

tr&ng,

*m

thi

hey

tr-r

dru

f

lri., liiSrn

llruc. Lrlli

trr&ng

r:fia ph6i

lAm lf

hqc ho{c trulbn

j,

lrsy

rliiirg

tri,doe

etru.crt

j'nghi

cira

cri'loa, linh

tnf.

,,Itii

';ri'i

lrtcn

fr:rrug

,

iic

togi

ehfr

tu

dOng,

ho{c lra:tg,

tlrrii

tr,r

rririnr;

rlrr

cila

plr*i

thdl

miSn

thuat

vil

khoa

trr

rlii rr lrtitrr:

kirrhr;4 tlt6

gi6.i

thich

do su

xuf,t

lriirr

.

r:irn eii]r'fl

tfr

tlri:r'

i1rii

si'rh

hhi

r:hir

ngitla r'I6i

voi

eAc

hi$n

lu'orrg

hiOn

hiilr

Trra

l;orrfl

phdng

tbi nghidm

ha{c

khr}ng

llrb

girii

l ri,:h

iiiiufi

l"i'

tJrul6t

ihi hi6n tu tuinrg

ddi roi lrii:rr

Itl-liir11

r'111111

tllr uc

i-rbll nla

3)

li;$ru s'r,*t Iqi

lrien

t.ul.rnfl

bXu,g

efich ur6

cngc dtil'r

ra. \ii tlrr fuiln

X k6 ehi

tidt

vE

cnQe

doi

y"

Ta

sE

r5.n

ci.'

r'ro

r:ri("

chi ii?it

dfi

ghi

trong bubi hc.rp

b*na hiCIrr lr','r

r10

riiilr"r

t;l

reirr

e6

theit

co

t$n

X,..

klr0ng

?

I

6E'

]

I

rHhN

r,lNu rroc

nhiBu

hiQn

tudng

chrrp

nhiing hiirr

ura

rn;r

trong cfr

t.o+

khOng

ai

nghi: d6n

vi

tl6

lA

mQt

kE

lq

m$t

nhu

trrirng

trn'p bi

diin"g

ffr

Espdrance

ngdy

3-4-1ti1]0

,&

tai

nhri nrgt

trr

gia

&

Ttrqy Di0n

co mflt

lrong

inh

ctr:g

mot

hlc vr-r'i

hijn

ma

Svcntromberg

vi c4

truong

lrcrp

cira

ttbng

ti'r

llronsQn

Burraf

vi-lrtin

bi IJonner hign

u:dt lhn trnng

$nh.

111

Gifi ttutqtt

nhdn ttitn.

I

CAc

hE thtfo

phfii

rrhfin

idi0n

(megnetisnrc)

giii

tbicl:

rfle

.

h {nl tro

ilrg

bin

x&y

tldng

cdt

birng

nhAn

rii{n

cua diing

ti'r'vr\

c/rc ngrr&i

{rf

llrlntr. l)ilirr rrA)' rlring

rn0t

ptrSn

fttrr

vl lri0n

tuong

co

nl.rt'r'

nhffrr

rliirr

tlrii

:rontr1

lrIc

rfing

klrOng

cd kA

v0

l-rinh ttri

hlrOrrc

tlfrr;,.

I,illc

si

Carnilie

tle.

Sa.toiti cr

+6i

.l$n

nhdri tliQn

khi

ngtridn cuu

(on

nguli

va

chol

rhng

khi

ngrrdi

ta

ch6t

tlri

phiin

dtQu

Iuc

ndy

dang

con

(trong

Ondeset

rnrlistions

bnmnincs

lr

ang

lt,t),

i

I

l{arcef

Cosfart

cho rffng

nhirng

nhip

rung

dQog

cila.

trr'

iu&'ng

cO t$6 lern

cho

dbng

tfr

thAu

nhg.n tlrroc

vA

rlng

ta

cOng nli{n

rfiug

co

tbl liOn

l+c voi

li6

chdt

theb

thul'[1

nh0n d[9n

cfia

6og

(xein

l,e

rnagndtisrne hun:r-aiu

I)ar

Marcel

Cossart)

+

t'

I

li6.t

IuQn

:

Sau

khi

dungl tft

c& cAc gii

rtruydt

kB

rr0n

o

rh:

tlduh db

rrrQt

hiQn

tuo'ng

chidu lrbrr ttrtr[t

n6u

hhdng

cb kdt

qn[, l4r

dy chirng

ta sE

tin

rffug hiQq tuo'ng

chi0u hbn

Cy

mdi

thdt

li

c6

gil

tri.

l

'

|

'

r.

i



pniv

ilr

Giruong

l.-

r6n

olAo

o6l

v6t

ruoa

cnlGu

nbrnr.

Chring

ta

c6

th8 tOr:u

tfit

hai

quan

dt6m :

quan

diEm

q0ng

[ich

vA

qnan di8m

b$nh

vuc khoa chi€u

hbn thuAt.

Song trong

srp

c6ng kich

khoa

'chi0u

bbn, m6i rrgutri

ditng

& trong

lf,nh

vr.lc

cfra mlnh

rt8

c0ng ktch

mQt cAch

khic

nbau

tiry

theo

minh nhin

vfin

dE

theo

khla

cgnh

niio.

Chung ta

ldn lil:ot

kh&o sdt:

Il

Thftn

chfia

gid.o.

Nhibu

sdc[

cfia

dqo Thidn

Chfa

c6ng

kith

kich

li$t

khon Chi0u

hbn. Ly

do

ld

toA thdnh

La

rnf,

ctro ildr hl

ruilt l6i

giao

thOng

vdi

quf

tric

lt (Satnn-D6mon).

llmile

Clrris?ophe

trong t{c

phhm

<

Mensouge et l)anger

rltl

Spiritisrne

D

df,

lOn tidng

h&n

hqc

ddi

v&i

Th0ng linh

thuldt Urnile

Ciriistophe

chn rXng

su

chu

hbn ugudi

chdt

d0 tinr hi6t h$n

hia

cdi

tfr

cd

rrhfrng

gi lA

rtQt tljlu

r;flnn

ct-tr:g

nhu IrrQt

rrfiudi

dAn

phgm

lugt

v$y,

lir

g'a

bho

rti.rg

'l

hi0ir

chrla

gi6o

kh0ug cOug

kiclr klrr,a

he: rA ly

tri

sr:ng ndu

Llhon

hgc vd

lf

trl

ctri {p

dung

?r{lng

dln

hr.rt

cfia

ho

rn*

thdi.

Cdn mudn

giii

thtch cie

djbu

trong

lbtlnb.

kinh

thi

clri

cdl

Oh{a cho

phdp

ngbia

tr\

do

tf,.nh

vrle cirsr,

duc

tiu,

ql)

,

(l)

Mrrrs

la rdv6lal.ion

blbliquo

I)ieu

n'est

accessible

qu'A

i

la

Foi

khlo

s6

15

tlang

73),

r

l

de

pac

la

volont6

gxprisse

de

(sAch

trich dis

tAl li6u

tham



TIIUAT

CHIEU HE)N

Nhrrnq

d. Plrdp

'trong

khi

nghidn

eun

klch

thOng

linh

thuydt

chring

ra

khdng

th8

ddn nr0t

trcc

gi&

c6

tidng tlen6

Gu6non.

TTIi,N

LINH

IIOC

vE vise

odng

khdng

.nb

c+p

'I'{c

gii

cdng kictr

thdng

linh

ttrnydt

vt

ldru

ebo

dbng

tfr bi

hdnh eubng

vong

bi

im

lnh vS

diOn

khfrng.

l,

r",

,

MOI

tdc

gil

ktrAc

Francis

de

Mirclair

c6ng

kich

kich

liQl,

Thdng

linh

lttruydt

(1)

san khi di{

cho

,

rfrng cile

hlgn tuong,

vB

dbng

bbng

r{bu

do dbri6

tir

l8n

Sil

ml1o

lqi

ca

tsng

Th0{g

linh

thuydtl &'Chrrang II cfra

tAe

phhm

nhu

mQt

phuonf

,phAp

lAm

thon

diu

cfc n6i

tlau

khb

cha

ngu&i

diri

v{

chl

cOng

kiCh nhiing

su

thur:

hAnh

(Cr:

qne

je

critiquc

c

sont

les

pratiqnef.

je

dirai

,;,,e

.u

rtootrine

spirite es

drninemment

humsiue

et

cernsolRnl.e

trang

89).'

..\

I,'ranpis dtr

Mirclair

lqi

dE

ei.rp

tl$n rrrQt

t6c

ilhhm

khic

nban

dE

<

Les

$orrtreurs

d'eslritr

>

do

Georges

'N{eumier

vi0t

ll'ori1;

.16

lfb

gii

lgt tihnlhhiing

rnirntr lcli

Lrip

bo',rt

cira.

prot

sd

diind

lfr,

Dogn

cqrii

cirnq

Ir.

de Mii

clain

c0vrE1

klch

t[riinry

tny

'I'[rdng'

linlt

thuyCIt

lrilrrg rngt

tlnngt

danh lit'.

Clrir,rg

ini ltrtch

]

ngnyCIn

rin

clo:rn

pirflp

\rIn ily

rrhw

san:

I

,

i

n

f,e

demon

tpirite

inluse

sonrnoisenretrt

tlrr.e

doelrine

d'Cillr'6lnpntb

arrss[

nCfaste

l]ouf

I'eslrrit,-1ue

g}ouf

l'&rne.

Iispritl

dlrlrlenrs

]"t

de tdndbre$.

peidition

et de

l.'dqrrilillvg

islelleFlu[l et

.dc

ltl

snnl6

spiln(uelle*noco-psinlrique

dre

tle

d€liri:,

I

nl{rn

<le

d'ah[r"rhtio

ns,

da

ng{ r moi;

rl

iel,

vr

lus

:rniirclf

gi

cux

Dc:'trine

infollne masquant

et

6iouffnnt

i'idie

,lc

)ir:rr,

,1,

qn'e le if

rrore

vofontairement

pour

s'v sntrstitner,

currfreption.

qni

rtite{e

l'dquillibre

dont

ont]

v6cu

jusrln'iei

dr.s

urilliers

de gdheratians,nl

,

Dogn

n&y

lail

tu rhAu

thuilh

v8i dn4n

lr0rr cho

rf;ng

Th0ng

linh

thuyd

cd thb

thoa

diu dru ktrb

cira rrgur)'i

tltri.

(r)

Tit

ll6u

ttfam khio sd

t6.

q

l,

,.]

i i

.j

i

,i

rd

ll"rc

(iu6rron'trong

trie phhm

c

I-.err.eur

spirite

r

mot

tdc

pbiirr

'iflt

lihfi cl:iy

df; c6nq

krch

'I"u0ns,Iinh

thurdt

r{t

nh'ilr;" Soiig

rl:bu

dAng

ctru

y

1A

Ong kh$ng phri

nhg.n

cric

[mrrg

lhii

r:iirn

116'6

rri'

lfi

iira

h;p

song

6ng chdrrg

lai

ldi

gifii ihicli

cfin

pti6i

't'irtirrg

l.inh

ttruy6t,

0og

rri6t

: <<

Noug

ne

ctinleslons

nullement

la

rtlslit6

des

fncultds

dires

ricdium_

niqrres

el, nnt"re

crilique

ne

porle

que

sur

l,ilrtertrrr'dtat;on

{Jr-r

clr

dulrirl:nt

les

spirites.'r,

iy

.li,1i.*

,i,1.:,elrilrr6

tn

thly

ttend

(iir6*on

li;r

la,in

nn0t

i;iiri:

tt0,rf;

'riii

vA chfr

(luBir

rd

If 16

Ong

drrn

ra

l--l[t

lrhi

,\"

khi

0rrg

lxlo

riirrg

nhiing

ou,)c

kh,fi.r

s{t

cira

cl:

rrl:.i

lkhrio

rri'n

vl$

liah

i'gc

n;iy

khong

cdr

g'a

tri

lirrr

nhl:

rf,rr.

r

iri

r:rr

lv

lrran

*ng

ih

c6

frh8

IJ6

flfi-v

ir6t

rneli

,;1r,_,al

tlri-uritri4rrr

iit

Willianr

(,yor;kss

rlrc) ,rlfi'r

t)eirl,

riilrier.

".

v.y"

1'11

ri:rg

lri

lliv

lllm

nqaq

ntri*ir

thh3,

ru0t .qii

, irit

lrAc

hol

nilr

(

rrnille'

liiainrriarrlonciing

tin

tu&ug

Th0ng

lirtb ihr.rr.6t.

Dny

it

urrlt_

eiu phc

blnh

efra

tirrg

:

s

..,

Nlain

rlous

l)ourorls

dire

fu:ut

rJe

suile que,

eD

raisr.

r

cle

leur

sp6i.lalisntion

la

ec:rr c',errce

rh

cos sayjtnts

sg

tfouye

liruitdil

n nn

rlo;nnint

restreint

ct le

hors

de

ee

rlomnirr'e,

leur

erp nion

n-a ph:s

rle

valeur

qne

belle

du

pr,enni,rr

\,( nu l).

{1.

d{ty

Ren6

dtterrr-m

nni r*ng

nhfrng

nhfi

hfle

lr?c

hiQn

dang

np,hi4n

cuu

lf;nb

vgc

chidu

h?in

thuit

chu

kh6ng ptrli

nhfing

r':gudi

khOng

hb

ngtrri€n

cuu, Ren6

G'6non

cfing

phri

I

ll

__-'-._*_-



TITUAT

CHIEU H6N.

btrrrr

rluoc

tfit

ci

nt&ng

tir

kE

ra

ciing

dAng

li

hay

sao

?

nhl

Lhoa

hgc.

k6

dB

cho

nhA

I}

Nhu

rh6

rhi

dbng

khoa

hoc

thd

lqy

sB chr?ng

ml'h

riing

l{p

lu{n

cira

mQt hocgi&

c6

ti6ng

lgi

c6

tinh

cAch

phidn

diQn

nhu

thd

nio,

chring

tOi irlch

,au

dftl

j

kidn

c&a

rngt

viltu si

trong

d4o

Thi6n

Chrla,

m0r

hbng

y

gi{o

chfr.

lliing y girlo

chfi Ldpicier

trong

t{c

pkrhno

c

Le

monde

ini'isihle

>

ciing

ceing

kich

chi0u

hhn

ilruf t song

,

tAc

gi:i

lai

r6ng nhgn

c{c

hiQn

tnqng

lA

c6

th*t

vi l$p

luf,1

rli' d{t

hon.

Oug

vl6t

:

\

(

... Chn

dAy r:gu<ii ta

c6 tAnh

b5t

chu6c

d6

goi

ii

lrop

ttrli

khi

cho

rfrng

t{t

cA cAc

hiQn

tuong

cira

phd.i

ci:i6u

hiin tl"ru$t

dbu lA do dbng-

tfr

hla

bip

cfr.

EiFu

nAy

t6 lh6

rftlng

trong

mOt

phhn

l&n

ciic

hi6rr

trcyng

song khi

,clio

riin6;

tfit c[ dbu

lA

lila

bip

bfit

chlnh

ttrl ta

df,

dirrr;1

ui.il

phutrng-phAp.hodrr

toAn

phin

khoa

hgc

vay.

))

Yrl

Uiir:g

y

gi{c

chfr

lai

cho rfrng

ndn

khi

ndo gida

lf

rufr

hbn

nguiri

cUf,t l€n

n6i

rn

c6

rinlr

cAch

c 6 tiQu

(rrais

tl'une lnoialil6

abjecte)

thi giio

hoi

c6 thB

ciro

rfii,fi

thrlr.51 linlr tirugdt

t{

mqt tA

thu}6t

c6

hei

cho

,

ngr;ivi

lltet;'

lrdr"

Sig

r:Ong

klch

cria rnQt

vi

chuc

sfrc cir

,

u.*

tln

trong

6,iAt

hOi

ddi

v6i th{rng.

linh'rhuydt

khOng

phii

lS

khong

od J-du

nhf,t

ld th6ng

linh

thuygt

& enep. Tai

dAy

Allan

Kardee

.IA

s$p dflt

.tbAnh

mQt hQ

thdn6

gifo

lj

(doetrir:e]

trcrr:g

d'5 Ong

cOng nh{n

ad

lugt lu&n

hbi.

Tin

nhrr

thd

I

,,rl

'71

i

'|

THi.N

LINIr

Hoc

cdng

n[{u

cAc hiQn

tugng

cfia

chi€u hbn thu$t

lt c6

th6t

song

d{rg

ta

ch rfing

khi

gi&i

rntcn

cdc bign

tuong

vb

chiOu

$bn

nguqi

ta

e6

th6

dua

ra nhibu

gifr

thuydt

kh{c

nhau

v& khongt phii

clri c6

gil

thuydr cira

Th6ng

tinh

thuy6t

ln

drirrg

vdi

sqr

thft(trnng

?G cfra r{g

phhm

trich,

dfrn)

Th0ng

linh

thuy6t

nrA

llen6 Gurlnon

n6i

,IAy

lA he

thdng

gifo

lf

dria Allan

Kardec

vAy.

,]

Rend

Gu6rion

phfi

nb{n

nr6t

c{ch

tr&ng trqn

cfc hi6n

ttrryng tIfr

tluoc

William

Croohes

nghidu

criu.

Ong chc

r&ng

c{c cuOe

thi nghiQm

cira

Crookes

ddi

vdi 6ng

khirrrg

c6

itnh

c{ch qnan

trgng.'

Ong

,chi

c6ng

nhdn

Crookes

c(r

rhhm

qnll '

lrong

rlliluat

bod

.h<2c

drlrfi

khong

c0ng

rrhs'

cr'olies

6

nQt

,tlia

hgt

htr6c.

Ve

danh

tir cfc

chric

v khr:a

hoc

kh0ng

bio

dfim

drclc

c6c

cuQc

tht nghignr

cfra

hq

cldi

vdi

c{c' dbng

tii.

Hq c$

rh6

bi

dling

rr?

nny

bip

bgm

(nryslifier

par

dn

rnddium).

f

Do4u

kdt

iuArr

llen6

Gudnon

.cho

r$ng

phong

tr{r.r

cd,

tinh

ndch

ma

qrii

vA chdng

lni

't'iri6rr

Cfrrla..

clrrirng

ta

dd

hi6t

rfing

Reird

Gu6'on

rtii

vi6t vb

r'Qt

tb

ciiirc ti.h

rtilin q'6c-tr1

hhr'rc

nhr.r thf;

ndr:"

p6

lil

khi

0rrg

pb6

binh

lf$ong

tl:isrr

hqn

(

ftreosophie)

cii'g

mot iufl*

di€u

chii

quan,

m{"it

chibn

(l)

Ilend

Gudnoir

(15

v(F

dlia

cfi

n$.m

v[

ligt.

tfrt cd

c/rs

cuQe

khiro

sAt

4.ira

gidi

hho*

trgc

vb

chi6u

hbn

thu{t nhu

kh6ng

c0

;iiA

tri. Ong

ra

ciro

rfurg

tlbng

tfr

co ihA

)rip

(l)

Rft

tidc

lA

0rrg

Nguy6n

duy

Cln

rll dirug

d6

lep

lu{n

trong

r

vin nrinh

D0ng

phucrng

vfi TAy'

ptrucng

r

va khOng

,

ilrra

ti;$ng

cbuong khAc

cfia

rfoi

rtoos

thian

hgc dd

tra ldi

tgi

Iton6

Gu6nou"

I



76

te

lr{i

vfi

Thfdn

fchira

gido

chi

tin c6

mi

thdi, nh?it

lA khi

thfing

lirrh

thny6t

thilnh

mQt

t6'r

qii1o.

VAy

su c6ng hich

kh0ng

phii

hoAn

I

toin

tlua tr€n It

do

mQt

l5i

do

dilc

hiQt

( I

)

ru8t

nrutln

lhOng

l

hrrc l6

2l

Tin l.,rinlt

qiio,

'f'heo

nquv0n-tfic

{.'ilng

mOl nguiin

gde

viri

'l'hi6n

chua

fiiiro

'l'hidrr

dAng

din

rrgtrc

tbl

cAc

muc srr

dgo le

clrdirg

tqi

th0r:g Iinh tiirr.r,6l.

MOt

trong

cd,l

o.vrrrt

su,

Iloger

(ilarrloir

trong

l{c

plrhm

o

Le spilit:srne

en liree de l'hisloire, tle

la

sr:ierrce

ct

rle

la

religion

n

([,arasanne

1 ll]B)

slrl l- ri

r)n

lrgrri

'i

lrOr:q

lir..h

lhuv{t

"ti

'n/v

drr{vnf{

elriirr{

la.i

rlrr

y

'i+t

ctrir

'rgliir

ii;i

rll

l4r;1

rli,l y",',; ki,r,1 ftr:r. efiri J' ,iti

lrgllif

a

4;'r11 [j1,11

;.

11

,

lfrru

lir'h

-r

r;6r:

$iQn

lu'nn11 liirjr.: tlrurlrnt.,

lt0,'rri

hi*h'['irdnp;

l;iir.r/rt:

llu

p'r,1,t

t0n

j

gif,o.

3\

Plujt

qitio"

iil{t:'

lriiu

tu.r}rifi

v}

rll,rg

lr4rrpl

rliivc

11i: r

eifii

t rfelr

irlrrr

ihd

rri,o

? l'rorrir

k:r-.h

< I rirrc

lillli{"rr

,lt'rc

l',rli

t

i:lr<1

rlirrl

trrjltg lr c ln

ir.inh

lrid

ir

5{)

rr}qiil

rra chttiv:tfi

poi

hl

< rrqli

frn

Vi

rlu:

q

vl

nr+

uh$p

lf,n

nll:']'

lirr.

I

Lr;l

f),

iirrh

tirnr

{i

11:i

larrf

rlrtrrfi drn,i 3ir

l thurGt r:iia

rn}roh

rri:r

{tlanq

2l'[);

I

i'l'

tlnrrb

210

:

<r

lihi

d6

llrrrf;n

tif

ll

rrdn

n6

xrrfit

lrbn

(l)

Lilnn

rl)enis

rnft

mdn aib

tAr:

ph"im

a

Drrns

l'invisitrle I

;

spiritisrne ro.

I

(2)

Xem

ri.i

li6u

ttlarn

khio

cira

,\llan

harrlec

ilI

tri ldi trong

c

Ap1[5 la nrort

r

v&

<

Christianisnre

l:.i€n

iliR

nlr[1r

viic t',

clrr0r:

I'i

uri

c

4.c

et

sd

7

trang

2(t3

trir tb

sau.

]'fIiN

LINT{

I'IOC

ki6p s$ng

dflt mlnh

linh

thuydt

nrA cdrr c6

riqo

'l'in

LAnh

lin

e6

Llhrl:r

vr)

t?it

nhi*rr

cfingl

i

rl

ll

T]IUA'f

CIIII)U

IION

kra

lri

khO'g

biil

tu

cho

rni'h

dri'g

ttgo

vo

rhuong

ni6r

irdrr

r:[inp1

tfnrtrng

n6i nr

kinh

phf;p.

'l'rong

giliy

phrit

th6n

hinlr nrirrt.ri

bi

'hAp

ki.

bi{u

hr$n

rR

ong

rhhv,

cr)

Di,

vi rlii

thi.,h

hny pirlr

nii,

v.v...

ho{c

& trong

ni:A

tcri,

tu

noi

qirsrr

[ri-r

r;hi6u

la

hio

quang

sAng

f.nh.

I.lguui

ddi

lhrn

cir. ir\

ijii i'rit

th*t

riii

rin

nghe

theo

l(ii

rna giao

hoA

srrnil lni.r)

l-ril'3rig

lung phdr

giiri

lu{t

t:rjin

lrhat,

lcn larn

viQc

t"hlr-r'"

ciur:

li"u

uoi

nfrli'ng

tlibu

tai rr

i:n la

iuug:

Hoilc

rrr-yi

r:lrr-r

iri.

clr lt.i.irii

ra

rtr'vi,

ndrn

'ao

rrbi

rlao

bi'h

gi[i:

61iii,

;:;i;r'

lr:ri

r:ir

hcil

hr)lrrr.,

lriri.lrll irr-i

tirrlr

tlrhrr

rlirr

chling

lr^tri6rr

r:lr,

ri:'ir"i

hau

l:li

t0n

ciia,

I)rirr rrrri

rrra kil

nlllir^

chri

rr

lrri

I,,

lliil-t'

Lo

rrgrrlni

hi

rua

rrh:l1r

kia

dErr

hi

gianr

r:iiru.

ciir irirpi

birjt

Ir'rrcvc

thi

khdi

.,ao

lur\u

l-r5i

cr.lir ln6

lhm,

llht)rr;r

.i;il(

ri;l

rllr..

vo.tr

rtc d;to

>

vAl:iic

tloau

sau

c[pg ttli

f

h\:

,(

I

Jris*

m&

be

tufrrr

hi6u

tridt

d*,crc

(lip

thrrfin

tig'

uiri,'u

iriri rr€r:

lru

xnitt

hilri

nlrirp

cho

nguol,..

>

.ie'rrr

iriru

th6

rbi

tu-y

rlgo

l)ir{t

kfrOng

chinh

thuc

t*5rirr

l-rii

rl iirr+r

lai

cac hinh

thirc

ctia'l'hfirrg

li'h

trr*r'4t

vd

tlar_r

I'lrit

1lf.t':g

lu tlo

Iin

ugufrrrg

cirrr

rnoi rrgutri

song

tr,ong

ki'rlr

sfir:ir

l'ilat

da t6

'a

hinh

ttrr.rc

rri)ng bring

la

hinh

iirrh

rfir nra

rtruf

cfing

gil. gidng

rihu

cluan

di6ur

cfra

rt'hi0n

clrri',

i;

f

o.

vd ie tiit

rrhi6n

cf;c

rrht

trurbn

girio

crla,lqo

l,h0l

kbdrr6g

bao

gro'

thn

thAnh

viQc riu

db

cira

rro

rhe. clbng

lrr-rrr;1 r'a

xenl dri

nhu rnQt

su nquy

hi6m

rldi

v6i

clrrinh

ptrip

cirn

tlt'c

'l'hie

h

Csr

vfly.

'l'6m

i+i

ngtroi

ta

kh6ng

thb qunn

niQur tluo'c

rr-rQt

phat

ti'r

chf,n

chAnh

lai

c6

th8

16rr

iliirrg

xudhg

bong

hay

rli

t0 b{i

&

ciic am

dbn.

Nhu

vA) ld

tirng phtlc

ngoai

dgo.

l

fi

li

1l

1l

I

i

I

didn >

l.iot g$p

dlp

r'gu',)li

bi nhAp

l:

t:

ll

ii, -

't"l19

i.l,

i

itJ

.

i-r.,i

.i.${

,.,J.r

l:E

i:j

i



Nhrfng

I

ngudi

ta

kl6ns-.

o'+:

Tj-:t1*ôolln""t::

-::::

I

,I

,"uo

iiiJ"ii,

fri

nglei

"i6r-rn

chira

nio

cirdg

'c6

citng

cd

bbn,l

ho{c

mlnn

"16

rhm

th&ng

b&y

<

xa

tQi'

vong

nhan

>

i"arT;*-"i?,-{oo"

dbu

to

imQt

btn

thu

vong'

va

i

viQc

cdng

cilu

si6u

n{u

cho

rirnq

luguli

chdt khsng

cdn

gl

hdt

thl

lAu

sao

u,

iii"-

*ai

r

Ftay-

dao

Ph0t'

cO[g

nlr6n

ngudi

ra

.ctidtl

tnt

oA*f

.i,t,

song

dbng

b6ng

li

hi'h

thuc

md

i,'

".ii

u"""

"r

;;;"

'ile"

]y

-q

:"i.

"o1l-'

noo

vr

;qt

' .tt"6,

"*"

\ttreo.t

DiEu

']nt

"u

l€-

ttring

hsn'

,lo,

nrOt

hom ihhv

'ffr

Cdng

n6i

l(trting

Ti't

r&ng:

<

Ngurli'tr6r,;t

crr

nl6t'gr

riila

hhrl'g?

>

Ngili

rrit

ldi

:

< NEu

t*

fit

chf

t

rbi

rnil

con

'hi6t

thui

sq

uh&ng

ro'

charr

hi6*

l;;l"-,rie"

tnit

'lb

theb

(rr:g cha'

-ndu

la

i;;;;';il

;t

k[ong

bi6t

sl

rbi

scr

coil

chiu

bilt

hidu'

chtt

me

chdt

L6

khQ;;"tuot'

tlg"tti

mudn'

bi6t

-ng-udi

chdt

co

bi6t

hav

khong]

liCt'

churQn

d6

khOng

phli

'li

chnvQrt

'chn

kip

ng*y

lUay

gid'

rbi

sau

sE

bi6t

D

(xed

Nho

si{o

cira

't'r6n

,,no[

'lt*

trang'

137)'

Lgi

&

rtoq'n

khnc

t(trbng

:

Tit

luan

,

,

ch;i

*""t

cugi

lA

rn'dt

hfrn

lihoirg

bi6t

gi

nfta

ie

b{t

nban

]tnotg

qOn

'.h*o'

:ho

1"l.ttÔi

chdt

li

cdn

bi6t

nlru

[ri0

ilut

tli'l

-d"q

lla

bdt

tri

h;h0ng

ndn

tireo

{Lo

kY

1

'Irhn

]tqoe'Kim)'

,

I

'lrudc

r,et

lfnbng

f'A

cho

r[ng

vi{c

hi6n

d}i,

sdng

o"ruJ;1"#;$;t

"gl

cho

nnnn

sintr'

Eqo

xft

ttrd

li

chn'

vt

v{y

cb

ngu,<ri

iU

1ot

rlrlg

Khbng

gidg

khOng

-

phfri

ln

mQt

r6n

gi6o

lmd

chi

li

mQt

m1

loAn

'li

thOi'

Nhuug

c6'i

siqns

beng

hai

.u-,;;;qif'

oltt"

11u"j.o:|t':t'"":1

t:::

giqng

beng

ha1

cua,

auuuB

*:

"':''

bi6t,

kh0ng

nq-

iui

mOt

iipu

gt

mdi

m6

e '

Gigng

niy'

ll

..

:

- -- * *

I *---.-*.*--' ''

.

.''

-'""t-'' '-r.'t

rsANI

LrNII/

Hqc

rHuAr

cnrEu

L

chung

1l

sE

d6

dip

tbfly

trong.hgo

ilruydr_cfia

Krishnamurri

&

cAc

ldogn

sau.

-

,

51 i'ao

qiao.

E6i

v6i

vfin

ctb'

c quf

tnho

c6

hay

kh6ng

r

Lf;o

Tit

cOn

,

crrua

q.fr

quydt.

Lffo

'tfr

chi

rie

t ,xng

dtrr

c6-

ura

quf

thl

ma

quy

cfing

phfii

theo

lE

tg

nhi0n

khdng

thA

hau

phric,

gieo

hgn eho

ngudi

ta

rlugc

cho

n0n Lf;o

'ffr

ndi

ti6p:

<

I(h0ng

phAi

nra

q'j.

cfin

nhfrng

nu&c

c6

rI4,:

l<h0:rg

lf'h

thi0ng

le

tqi

sF

fhi0ng

fin,rg

cira

'6

hOng

linr

hqi

ngrrdi.

md

kh0ng phli

sr1

thidng

li6ng

cria

nti

kl-erirlg

lArn

hqi

ngutri

lA

tai

tlflng,

thArrh

nh$n

&

d6

hhong

Li'r

lir.ri

ngudi,

D

(l,hi

kj'

'{ui

ir{t

trriin.

rri,

thiin

i\

,l

),

a;

;

.

i:,

ndr.r

biit

thucrng

nhdn,

phi

k

ilrhn

b{t

rrhfin

di-dc

bl{r

thwcrng

nhAu.

I

(l)

tbnuog'irhiiu"

tlrirr r

6)

Crto ttdi

,ido.

I1i0ng

fi,

r/igr

Nam

'c6

raQt,tOn

gito

rur'ri

th,r;rh

{p

tu

nrim

lg20

&

Nnrn

vigt

do

cao

Ddi

'iien

O]"9

D+i,

Ilii

'fAl

I\Ia

[Ia

Tfrt

rrnybu

'lQnh

sLtug

tap.

Cotr

cftli

gi;l'

c6

rn0t

he

theing

giAo

lf

ri6ng

,

vA

truibn

b,{

brng

li5i

crr :dt

chn

c6c

clbng

tfr.

ch6ng

,

tdi

kirdug

drroc

rd

r,;ic

sfch

vb

cia

't'h0ug

linh

rhnye{t

(Allan

Kardec,

v.v..).

c6 rln'oc

c; e

'bfi

truybn

girio

dao'

nay

.xem

x6'

rric

ban

dxu

khc;rg

*hrng

cr't rdi

drlng

ctbng

tri

dg

ridp

xdc

v{yi

eai

d3[ng

rbhn

ri0u

rrrr

cao

E*i

.giao

dd

dilng

hinh

rhric

cira

I'hiirg

lirh

thuydt

uhu,li

mQt

phuong

rign

c6

trurD*

*l$o

v{y,r

Gifra

Cao

DAi

giAo

vA

f,hOng

tinh

rhuydt

nhu

rhd

tdr

plriri

cd

ch6

itli'g

f

vb

nrQt

vai

ai$m.

viy

thi

y

ki6n

crin

Cao

DAi

rldi

v6i

I'h0:rg.linh

ahuydt

ch*c

kh6ug

phii

It

mQt

l{p

trudng

chdng

ci6i

mA

eo

'ld

.

cd

mQt

l$p

(1)

Xem

rli

liQu

,tham

khio,sti,b

trang,

91.

,,

1l

I

lj ..

:

,.:.,

'i

.

r:':t

t

,'

]:

'''"

,f

'll

,t



sl.r

hi8u

bi6t

tinh

Nbn,

ting

cria

Cao

hqrc

r.

Nhu

thd

ta

Cro

dAi

gi{o

vil,

lA

thhn

linh

hoc.

in

lhln

.rr

de

dei

giAo

th{v

hoc

\'

(1)

nhung

8{,

,

,1,,

I

'

IHAN LtNtI

IIQc

')

trudng

gln

gi6ng

uhau.'

I'uy

nhi0n

itdi

vdi

< dbrig

b6ng>

6'

ngoAi

v0n

dqo Cao

Djli

thl

nh&ng hi$n

lunng

dy

dqo

cao

Ddi

xern

nhu

klidng

duoc

chinh

xf,c

l[rn,

Itg

ctri

tin

c{c

elbug

{fr

do

Eqo 'tuy6n

uhgn

nia

th6i

vA

cfc

dbng

tfr dy chiu

Sqt

quy

lu{t

pidng

.c3a,,

Elo.

{.}uan

di8m

cirn

Cao

dlni

gi6o

durrc

minh

dinh mqt

TnuAr

cHtEu

HbN

t

c6

th$

girip

lch

cho

rnQt

cAu

nhu

sau :

((...

de

bi6t

ldr

Ttrhn

liuh

thhn

.linh.

rdt

gln

vdi

th6

blo

Oao

dei

gi{o

81

dirng

nhu ta,

thuS

6t

kh6ng

I

Quan

di8m

cirn

Cao

dlni

gi6o

durrc

minh

dinh mqt

rd

r&ug

trong

rnQt

bili

thuJdt

gido

cirq

u...

Churrg

ta

cdrn

c$q

ttn'db

m&

c$c

cu$c

tifip xtlc

vdi

c*.c

thhni

finn

do nl1&lng

dQrrg

tri'

kh0ng

chinh

thuc

(des

rnddiul.rrs

non

officieis).

i

.,.'Thbyl chrlng.ta

ciing bio

chring

ta

pluii coi

c'[rung

.:

rrbtii'g

cugc

;v{n

dQng

*fiq

cfic

ltrln linh

xi{u vd

cu6i,

cilng

tt+y

cds

clQ

tfr

ptrf,i,

ih+n

trorg

oidi

voi sq

ludng

gttt

cira quf sir

(Eatarr)

(1).

.l

Gabriel

Gorbon

nghi0n cu'u

vb

Cao tsAi

gi6.o cho

lAl

ruqt

hinh

thjrd

cfrs

rhhn

lfnh hgr:.

Vigt

t'{sin.

l'h{t

ra

Cao

rl$i

giAo lil

FOt

rOn

giso,

tuy

c6

drlrrg hiuh

thuc chi€u-

hiin

de llml mQt

ptrucrng

diQn

truybn

dAo

song

ngodi

ra,

cOn

cd nO

he

thdng giAo-lf

cln

cu

vao

su

ph6i

hop

cha

bn

tOn

gi6o

lchanrr

.

gbm

:

t{tro-Lf,o-1'hich.

\

,)

i

Henri

Rdgnault

pho cnfi iicn

iiy l-ran

qu6c

t6. vE

h$i

'tliutr

iirhn tiqo ih6

gi6i

{a

te

pno

tbng

thu

kJ

hQi

'Itrhn

linh

iroc PhNn.

tlai di6n

cho

Cao

dCi

gifo

tqi

hQi

nghi

Nhdn

tiQn

day

chring

ta

cfing

n6n

bi6t

qua

co hrit

cfia

d+o

Cao

DAi.

Co li

vAt

dtrng

dD

thinh

Ti6n

'fhAnh

duong

bXng

lre

nhrr

cAi git't

hioh

bhu

duc,

ngoAi phdt

gi{y

vAng

c0 c*n

biing

nh{nh

dau

dai

ldi

l-r

hay

6

tdc,

dhu

c6n

thuong

_khHe

dfru

chirm

loan,

cfi,n

mQt

o0y

.cq

lilng

mAy

hay tfd

,IE

vi6t

b{'ng

tr0n

m{t.

bdn

biing

cAy

bay cao

su. Th&

co

hay

chnp

co' c6 urQt

,hay

hai

vi

tlbng

tir'

ggi

IA

phd

touo,

Kbt

lidp di6m

tay

dbng

tfr

cfr .dong

vA

di6n

tfi

tw

tu6,ng

r';r

biing rdn

tu

thi phri,

tAn

vln.

Vi

ph{p

ddn rtqc

cbii

'E

itit

horg

cdn

vi

diEn

kf

'

rhi

ch6p

chfu.,

1Zy

s'n

ffrue

nhu

r6.

pqo

Cao EAi

chi

rrh{n

ciro

diing rfi'

vi6t.

lltnh

tlich

hi8nn

soht

cAc

hi6n

t,

cae

hgi TAm

linh

quiic

giAo

ly

do thlrr

ti6n

truybn

chu

clao

Ceo

EAi khdng

c6

tugng

cira dbng tfr

dua

re.

tE

vi

cdc hQi

Thhn

tinh

qudc

c6ng

klch

di6m riOng

llnh

irQc

Phfp,

tl+i

diQn

lcho

Cao

dCi

gifo

tqi

hQi

nghi

t1u6[

td

ph0c

trlnh

dou

tg.i hQi

nghi

ndy

nh6m

& LuAn

EOn

tir

16

ddn

20-5-1952

vor.

nhan

db :

<

Cao

Dei

giAo

li6.t

ludn.

T6m

tii

cAc

r0n

gi{o hi0n

nay

hay

bCnh

vuc

chi0u

hbn

thudt

tuy

theo

qnan

cr'ia

dflc

vi

giAo

chfi hay

6ido

If

cfia ho.

i."i

''

- i, I

tx"nt

tei f

teo

(2)

Xem

tai

liQu

tham

kbio

sd 61.

tham

khio

sd

8

cudn

1

I

lrang

72,

i

t{r

16

{6n

20-5-1952

voi.

nhan

d6

:

<

Uao

Dar

gra$

,L

--+-

r) 'xem t{t ll6u

tham

khlb

sd 60.

'r":flIsrdi't$,r 19n

n x

&:H

;:.,Liffi

,4/-W*^

tu'

d

.

y#7ffi,

L+-+i

W

ifi;1

;r7 iI4'

ni--a

-

Fefit;l--

rc'tW/.-:

Tr^

294

a.

2-,fi'cfi-$:4,--Q



rnudr

cnrriu lrdN

,

6ay bqn

be

cira tOi tlfi

cbdt

rbi

v&

nhu

thd cO cl nhftng

n?iu

'chu5gn

'vil

nhfrng

trudng

hqp

vb cAi

ch6t

{y.

Do

aO

y

nghi

ch6t

cO

thb

nOi

mQt cAch

ndm

na IA

-"*

nghi

chlnh vi ta c6 ttrb

dlt

cho

n6 danh

tt

y

,nghi

K.

f

rr(

thich

(tous

les

lfaits

oir

la vig

et.

'ia

pens€e

trous

paraissent

s€

manifester

lprr

,des pheqorndnes inexplicabies)

(1).

Quan

dibrn

cfra

phAi

t$m

linl

hgc

ddi

v&i

Th0ng

linh

thuyOt

nhu

th6

nfo

?

Phln nhibu

phAi

'Iilm

tinh hgc

cirng

cdng

nh{o

ctc

hiQn

tugng chi0u

hbn thu$t

cfira Thpng

tinh

thuy6t,

lho

c6

lh{t song

hq

khOng

gili

ttrtch

nhu

Th0ng'

linh

t$uydt ve

hq

cho

rffng

hiQn tucrag

ttbng, b6ng

chi

lA hiQn.

t,uQng

do

tlbng

tir

,xfy

dung u0n.

-

"t'

llt.

IIQI

trongi

hgc'gifi

thuQc

phii

nAy IA

ry.

Carington

nhf,n

vi0n

hQi

khlo

cuo

T0m

linh

&

Anh

gili

thtch

hiQn

tugng

dy

tt+i.

y

nUu sau

:

,

<

Vi

'dg'

t<)i mu6n

ddn

xeno

nrQt

dbng

tfr.l

CnNc

chln

rXng trong

tri

tOi

c6 hinh

$nA

cfia

nhiing

ngull

(hdt

vt

nhu

v{y c6

hinh'inh

cira

nhiing

cha

mg

10

tham

khlo

s{

20

louvrage

co-uronod

prr

I'acad6mle

hbnt

ma,

in

dilu

tay

holc

nhiing logi chfi

trqc

ti6p

vA

Io4i chli lu

dOng

ml

c6

cl chfr kj

vA

net

c\fr

gi6ng

y

nguli

chdt

tf5

vi6t I

hic

cdn

sdng,

l(hi

ktrio

cuu vb

v{n

itE

oAy,

chring t6i thi6t

tu&ng

c6

tb6 so

luqc cuQc

tranh

luSn c6

v6 hto hung

gifta

mdn

tlb

cira

ph{i

tf,nr

linh

hoc

vd

th6ng

]inn

thuydr

C6

hai

lubng

tu

tu&ng

ddi l{p

'

q1{*

it

nghi

nny

cd

gifia

ta

vi

dbog

tfr

vt

th&

jclm tho

duoc

f

ngtri

dy

i[0

di6n

vai

I

tr0

cfia

mr)t

ngu&i

chdt nhflp

rdc'

cfia Carington

d{t

dudi danh

tri

li

(dssociation

d'iddes).

do

d6 dbng

tir c6

tl

ra

vl

y

d[

d6ng

dbng

r

(l)

Gil

thoy6t

< li0n

hdt

tu tu&og

>

cAc'.hiQn

tuong dbng

b6ng

dbu

vdo

dbng

tfr ml

phtt

sanh ra.

l

cAc hiQn tuqng

'dbng

b6ng

chi

iNhung

thich lrong

tir

li

mQt

tu&ng

cfis

tri

tt8

gili

1)

MQt

phfi

cho

ring

do

hbn ngubi

ch6t nhfp

EO

Ii

th0ng

linh

thuydt.

2)

MOt ph6i

cho

rXng

chring ta

nh& r&ng

.

hiQn

tucrng

niy

cbi

glii

mQt

sd edc trulnglhqp

"'i

te

cho'rfrngp;db'ng

k6

c6

linh fuQ

'(clairvoy{nt)

dA doc

dusc tu

ngudi t16n

xem

song

n6

hodn toin v0

gie

thich

cdc

hiQn

tuqng

nhu

c6

th8

chup

rluryc

I

(l)

Xem

tll

lilu

dcs sciences).

]

(l)

Xem tAi liQu tham

khlo.

'

hr,':

t;X'

u<..[u

.-.1

e&L-l

,l-.;- 4-t

lz.^^

.t^-

o 6Jn-

f)q''

t

-/f

E

-+* ?:"un

4o)

a

4,*

E+

4

-

>"

{s4'a,4'

's;

&ifi?a4".>" ;;E-;t=W*,

ro4

nb

--'e-c,;'

,t^#"

u4

1k

Lf,,/.;



W'

ruau

LINH Hoc

hU

i,e

trA

4,r.."

-

W'#.'F,T2h

L,^^r^,,i,

tA'.?4

*-ygffi^

i

-an

.tu\ca".4^;+

-

-

C-O*i

Y^

hL

t-'

6

|.b)Saukhich6tthtphInyt6riccfraconngudivfin

p

hiQn

lugng

flo

quybn

n[n{

cria

con

ngudi

cdu

r+o

ra

trlc

Id

i

tlbng

rrii

OO

tA'

gil

thuydt

cfia

ph6i

tf,m

linh

hgc.

Vf

di6m

uly,

chring

ra

ldy

lim

thich

rht

d0

trtnn lAy

curQc

trenh lugri

hAo hring

xly

ra gifra

bdn

hoc giA

lA

:

Siroliver

'Loclge,

vft ly

hoc

gia

ngurli

Anh

sinh

nlno

1851

vi

mdt 1943, gido

su vA

vipn

tru6,ng

Egi

hoc

du&ng

Birmingham,

nbfrn

vi6n

hQi

khoa

bgc

Ludn

E6n

t6c

gifi

nhibu cdng

trlnf

vb

quang

hoc,

itiQn

lrqc,

v6t

lf hoc

vii

di

thai (6lher)

va

vdr triydn

rliQn

d+i

diQn

cbo

ptrai

rtr6ng

linh

lhuydt,

v& giAo

su ngu{ri

phAp

Charler

ilicher

sinh

nilnr.

lB50

vf

{dt

19Bb

gi6o

iu

dqi hoc

ducrng

Bal€,

nhfin

vi0n

vi9n HAn-Ipam

Y-Khoa

phAt

mintr nhibu

cOng

rrrnlr

tbuQr

linh

vrlc

y-t6

dni-di{n

cbo

phii

tdru

ir:h

hoc.

'i

i'

Vd

cuQc

tr{nh

lufn

gi&a

:

MOt

bOn

h] Errvesr

Bbzzlno

mQr

hg:

gii

f

<Iai

toi

dai dign

cho

th0ng

linh

Thlydt vt

mot bOn

ti

Ren6

srrdre

mQt

hgc

gil

ngudi

Phhp tlai-tlign

cho

trirn

lintr

hoc,

,L

I

*i'

;

1)

franh,i

{y$l

Ricnet

-

Loctse.

I

ttrl.t

cdng

kioh

.

thdng

lintr

rhuydt

bing,

cAc luSn .

c&

sau

dAy

a)

Hlnh

nUuf

trt

tue

c&a

con

ngudi

dbu

do

b0

6c.mir

ra.

VSy,

tbi

'gt{}i

ta khOng

tlhb

bio

tu*ru,&ng

ru

ntridn

mi

c6

ivd

tu-trt&ng

chn phrli]

c6

ccr

quan

chria

dr,rng

no.

D6

Ino0

6c.

)

/

I

t.

ii,],]",,,.1

rL'

-:.:.i..:3t.,,,4=:t*g:*;roLlrl

.ar:r*i*n.s.J'-.-;*-.*

l,,li.

)i"-

* ,

'rlJ,.).|u'KIucneItnlphfinfthticcfiaconngudivfin

j:

,

":1

rb:r"

tqi.

phtn

nty

ii0n

ddi

voi

tri

nhd.

Soog

c6

nhibu

bfrng

chung

de

cho

- ta

thf,y

trl

nh0

c6

tfrE-

soy

,,,,,

gilm

theo

tubi

tdc.

Viy

,thi

eOn

s6ng

sau

hhi

ch6t

mA

i

ktrong

co

f

rrruc

c6i

ra

in

rrt

khong

phri

rt

s6ng

(sur.vivre

''

sans

avoir

la

conscience

du

moi

ancien

ce

n.ett

pas

survivre;.

,,'j,

c)

Ngudi ra

thdy

trong

c{c

hign

tugrrg

chiOu

hbn

c6

,

,,

rdtrrhiEu[rudngho.pkhAcnhaunhutruJnghqpd{cbiQt

Georges

lrelbam

(mot

nhr

vln

vd

tri6t

gia

-dt:.fit

tr6

va

,'nbSp

vdo

tlbng

tri

lA

bA

piper,.

mQt

rtbng

tir

danh

ri6mg

&

fli

vA

Anb)

song

cflng

c6

nhiEu

trudng

hqp qu6

u

tiimthucrrrtrq.NhuvAyctrringta.'ldfi'n8ti6uchuhnnlod6

phAn

bidt

gii

chAn

?

vA

nirirng

hiQn

tuoDg

ma,dbng

t,l

biilt

rtu'ge

'hirng

diEu

bt

An

.

thl

Ri:het

d{t

cho

mOt git

thu3

6t

gni

Ifl

r cryuresrhdrie

>

(ngubn

g6c

b&i

chii

Hy iqp

Kruptor

:

Kin

d{o

vd

aisth6sis

: crm

xtc),drnh

tu

do

charles

Riclret

ct{t

ra

rra

chi

t6

khi

nrng

cfia-

cac

con

diing

cb

th6

bi6t

nh&ng

clibu

ngoAi

cdc

6i*c

quan

thOng

thuong

cfia

con

rrguoi.

nh0p

vAo

dbng

rfr

c6

nniEu

Lann

9hi

tr6

1on,

.nhibu

sF qupn

lfrng"

d)

Cr{c

hbn

kE

chdt

qlQng

sai

lhm,

nhibu

cfi,

rI)

Cdc

dibu

gi

ci.

nAo

vF

cAc

,cfing

ti$y.

trbn

kA

ctrdr

Phhn

nhibu

n4dnh

khba

I6m,lgi

Ricbet

c6ng

ktch

l)

F,l

dbng

nhdt

giilra

rAm

2)

lrri

nh0'

khOng

rbn

rgi

kh6og

girip

dd

cho

chrtng ta

khOng

cho

ta

mQt

ti6n

b0

cho

d{n

ci

ngdnh

tAm

linh

th6ng

linh

thuy6t

&

5

dilm

:

linh

vl

tri

nf,o.

vinh

v)dn

l6n

hg

hqc

-r-':i-L'&..

..,,

i'

14

,q - -

'/a,C

"-

2.lrn

y.

u

try

,

vfl

-u"/^1x

x-l';

l/,&r

(3

ni"'te-/-)

,u

'o.;,

r.,

]

'

,

l, /i

-/

] .--,

-i

'

THIIAT cstnu

Hbx



tnAN LINH

HQG

6

.'i,

3)

S\r

gil

t4o

cn]

Adf,

le

ke chdt

itd nh{p

,vio.

4)iTtnh

cach tnofi

bQ

cfra

,

c{c .bubi

chicu

hbn.

5)

Sq

ttm

thudn

vA v0

bb' cfia

cac

cuQc

chi6u

hbn.

Oliver

rLoage

trt]

ldi

nhu

thq

n*o ?

(1)

Ly

rE

d8

nhA

cinh

v$t

hgc'chdng

I4i

th'Ong

tinU

tnuydt

tonn

t5't td

r

trI nhd

cfih

uguoi

ita

&

trong

6c >

song

nguoi,

ta d{t

git

thuy6t

:'nhqc

si

p6

chn

OunE

crr

kh0ng

?

V{y

n6u

ph{

nhqc

kht

thl

n +c si

c6

cdn

l

khOng

?

Ld tf,t

nhr0n

/

khong

co

nh+c

cu tpi

nq3c pi

khpng

tdu ntrgc

dugc song

khong

ptr{i

le mdt

6t

lan

nhgc

I

v4y

thi fim nlr4c

&

trong;11gab

foui

im

l6ne

vt:,khon*

c6

dunS cu chu

khdng,

phii

lA

qhdpg

c6

[p,'n[qc

,va

nf,+c si vfln

cor.

I

'

T6m

i+i

iZ

tti6m

tthu clra

RichBt

chdng

l4i

lhOng

linh

thuydt

gbp

trong

l6h

t6

liOn

l$c

giira

th6

xf,c

vd

tinh

thhn.

NgL+Ui

ta

bi6t

rfrng vdn

d€ nAy

cd th6

nhin

duoi

nhiEu

khin

dtph

khAf

uhau

: tri6t

bgc,

tAm lf

sinh

IJ

hgc'

thln

kinh

t1mlthhn

bQnh hgc

(neuropsychiairie)

tilt ci

c6c

trign

tuqng

vb

ulm

]mQpg

vE

ctm]

ung

vE

linlr

tu$

tt6u

chung

minh

r[ng:

ttlm

ltnh vugt

ba

ngoAi

gior hgn

cire

thAn

rlc.

Dfry

lA

vfin

db

nghrOn

:":

bin trrb

.:,""

con

nguui

vi

c{q

nflpg

tlfc tibm

t]r.r5.

noi chung

ta.

(2)

2)

Tranh

luln

Sudre

--

Bozzano),

Yb.

ba

di6m

dudl

dU,iog

ta

c6

th6

mugn

cuQc

tranh'

lu{n

cfra

Rend Suart

vi

Ernest

fozzano

tl-

di€n

drn

(l) Xem

hcruo

Mdta{sychiquc

l92l

sd

2

treng

05 tr&

ili.

(2)

D6u

rom

:

(

Si€r]r

hi;h

hoc

nhfp

,m6n

r

cira

Nguy6n

kho*

Huln

sE

ru{t

bln.

chung

Ren6 Sutlre trong tAc phhm

e lntroduetion

n

la

mdtapsychique

>

(Payot

1926)

ughi6n cuu cdc

hiQn

tugng

vb chi6u hbn

thu{t

vA

Ong di itdu

k6t

lugn

rhdng

thOng

linh

thuy6l.

Ering trudc

hi6n

tuqng

,bil

Piper

l0n

dbng

noi l&

hbn

cfia l'ellrim,

ngu&i ta

dff thfr vt

cOng

nh{n

rirng

c6c

ioi

nOi

cira

Pelharn'r{t driug

(Georges

Pelham

nh{n rd

r& 30 bgn cil

cira

mlnh

hOu

ding

tOn

ho

vl,

dirng

clc

cAu

n6i

ri0ng'mA Pelham

thuddg'

n6i

vdi

cdc

bgn

6o9

trong hic

sinh

tibn vA

chi

c6

mQt

cO

bqn

lA

Wamer

thl

Pslham

kh6ng

bi6t rqd

rrhdi,) Gr[

thuydt

tdm

Iinh

hgc

rihu thd

nAo ?

Ngu&i ra d{t vdn

db

Pelbam

khi

ch6t

Ab

Qi

m0t, sd kf-niQm

cd

j

thrlc hay kh0ng

vA

nh&

nhfrng

ru4g cflm

mA

bA

Piper

di6n,t[

lqi.

Gil

thuydt

nry

ldm

cho bi

Piper

ro

th0

d{t

tluoc

nhftng

vai trd

(personnage)

.

vA

'ngu&i

ta

goi

lA

gifi

thuy6t

cryptesth€rl"

-

prosopopdse

(Si& thuy6d

cfia Charles Richet)

vA

Sudre

d{t

la

gia

thuy6t

mdtagnomie

*

prosopopdse

(1)

(srf

hi6u

bi6t nhfrng

diEu

mA

th0ng

thu&ng

chring

ta

kh6ng

th€ ni6u duqc). Theo d6

'bA

Piper

df,

dirng

nhfrng

phucrng

tiQn ngo{t

giic

quan

(extrasensoriel)

ho{c

&

trong th6 gi6i

v{t

th6

ho{c trong

l&m

linh rQhg

l6n

cira

nhfrng

pgu&i

sdng, nhflng

lAi

lign

dE

,th6

hign

ra hinh'

inh

G.

pelham.

,

Edi

v&i th6ng linh

thuydt

dbng

r&

'dA

bi6u

hifn duqc

nhfrug

nhqf

v0t

(persodnes)

m.{

t0m

ilinh

thuydt xem

chi

ll

nhiing

vai

trd

(personnages).

,

|,i

T6m l4i

c&

hai

phAi

i[Eu

c0ng

nh{n

c6 biQn

ruong

'

song

l6i

gili

thlch

cia

hai

ptrti

khAc

nhau.

Th{t

ra

khi

(1)

Xem

tAc

Parir

1946).

phhm

PersoDnages

de.l'au-dell

cria Reo6

Surtrc

(Dbnsol



,i

,.

r i

i

,q

'

-:''i:

,',s

ri ,*



ti

L"l

i

'L

chuons

ut.-

lruYEhr

e[

HQc

e6t

v6t

KHoA

cHl3u

f,,em

Ir

qhef

dc

lq

thdosobhlc

(trang

272'274)

par

Blevastky-

I

l

I

iit,r,

I

-**** * ' ' * *

i ---i.rscLl

nbr.r.

L

I

:

'Huybn

bi hpc

c6

nhiBu lrulng

nhiEu

ph{i

khf,g

nhau.

"

0

rtay

i

s6rir*

tbi

chi

tqa

chQn

nrst

sd

cic.

nh&

huyBn

bi

-a

piJog tol

clo

dip kh*'o

citiu

dE duara

du'"lnfln

cira

hg'

,lj,

:

7)

Quan

ilibp

cdc

.hoc

gi&

hdi

I'hdrtg1

thiin hgc"'

Illpt

tb

cbuc c6

tinf

cach

nghi6ni

cuu,

cdc ri6ng

lup

c6n

tiErn

tnng

niri'

con

nlgudi

(mu';

*lich

thu

bn)

tA

hQi

Th6ng

thi6n

foc

la,i

ba

Illalvastky

mQt n$utri Nga

vi

6ng

Olcott

qot

.nl

ngu&i

j${yr

thildh

lflp 1875

&l

Au-Do'

LI

Br

nlavats{y

cOng

ktch,tir6ng,

linh

thuydt

&

ctr6

linr

cno

lcab

A6og

{,f

li

b$nh

vQ t0m

thhn

vA

t}tE x{c

dua'

t-J

adn

]sqi

ki*t

sup

vi

di6n

"o{og

lrunng

hsp

cac

dbng

tft

Eglifton,

Slade,l

Duglas

flome

(l)

i

f,rgfi

t+i 6ng

Leadbeater,

jmQt

nhAlhuybn

bt

hgc

khAc

cfia

lndi

'nnf

l1i cp

mQt

qnqn niQm

rQng

r[i

hon'

. powell

trodg

khi

kh&o

{oo

tb

Th0ng

thiOn

hgc

vidt:

trong

ttc

phhm

:

< Le

corps

astral

n

chuong

XII

(trang 2tG

212)

n6i

vB thfng

linh

thuy{t

c6

cho

hay

6ng

Leadbeater

'

cilng

c6

thi

nNhiQm

vb

chi0h

hbn

thust

vl 6ng

c6ng

--rJ-

(t)

xem

Ir

qhef dc

le

th6osolhte

ltrang

272-274)

par

Blevastky.

THUAT

CHIEU

HbN

nhsn

cAs

.

hi$n

tugng

sof,t

cAc

hiQn

tuong

Leadbeatbr

cho

rffng

thiOn

hoc

c6

nhtng

,| 9t

i

ohi0u

hbn'c6

thflt

chinh

6ng

tll

hi8m

6y

v{

cho

rlng

:Phhn

d0ng

ld

dung

gi&a Th0ng

linh

thuY6t

vl

Th6ng

diSm

gi6ng nhau:

.

1)

su

bdt

t&

sau

khi ch6t'

,

2)

srl

tidn

h6a

vinh

vi6n

cho

moi

ngudi'

Ong

hl,:

rXng

nhftng

kE thlch

nhfrng

hiQn

tuong'

c6

dhu

Oc

tt,ql0

nglriQm,

thl

tlm

-

ddn

chi0u

hbn

thu{t'

c<):t

ngu&i

ct1

6c

tri6t

ty

tht

tlm

6tdn

'fhdng

thiOn

hqc'

Nhurrg

mudn

c6

i

ki6n

chic

chin

hon

cA

thl chring

ta

pU[i

tim

dQc

t6'c

p'nhm

<

Premiers'enseignementr

des

nraitres

q

dn

cd

hqi

tru&ng

Th0n$

thi0n

hgu

Jinarajadasa

sao

lrrc

ir

trang

114

c6

<loan

nhu

sau

:

<

".,

Cht'rng

tOi

kh0ng

phli

ch6ng l4i

Th0ng

linh

thuydt

chA.

shiirh

1ril

chdng

l4i

vi4c

dnng

bdt

cu

mQt

logi

dbng

tri

niro

te

chdng

lqi

cdc

sq

bi6u

lO

birng

vat

thA

nhdt

ln

d6i

v&i

hiQn

tuong

hign

hbn

vi

nh{p

xfrc

(Nous

notts

oppotonE

non

pas

au

spiritirme

vrai

mais

seulement

d I'em-

ploidesrn6dlumsqnelconquesetauxmanifestationsphysiques

en

particulier

aux

mat6rialisations

et

A

la.

meiliumnitd

d

incarnation)

vi

Th0ng

thi€n

hgc

cho

rXng

dd

chi

li

n,hfrng

c{i

< v6

n

cira ngu}i

oh6t

(les

ph6nom0nes

spirites

presque

tous

attiibuOs

I

ces

esprits

mais

I

der

coques)'

vbdiBmcfnth6c&acon.ngu}iThOngthiOnhgcvil

Th0ng

tinh

thuydt

giAi tbich

khAc

nhau'

Theo

rhong

tinh

lhuydr

con

ngu&i

c6'

ba

thl

ris

ltran,,

I

'

,

..'t

..s

E

,.'l{

l.

",fr

r: II

.:iri.:r$l

'.;" r' lJ

;Tt

'

".t-i,

:-*i

,-'rii

:,'4i

'

i.$.

i:f

:',11,1'

.

,.J:

,;.j.

r

,,i,

:'

o{

,i

'

.t'

;l

i}

-

,1

..

i.i

'.

,l

I

.l

,{

,l

'j

',il

'

l,

10t

I

i

THUAT



93

CIIIEU

0og

Olcoft

sn[g

Up

viOn

sfia

HQi

trudc

cl6

drr

ki6n

cAc bubrj

chieu

hbn

&

*y'"n'ru

",n,"

People

iroro

thei

orher

worltl.,ri

*o{t

bln.

1g7b

cic

hiQn

tuo-rig

cnheu

nbn

li

c6t

thf,t.

bing

cAch

dem

lgi

bXng

chrtng

vl

an

fii

sAu

xa

d6i

voi

nhiing

ngrrdi

vi

mudn

ttm

roi

vb

sqr

tb;

tutl.a"'"rn

ngndi:

sau

khi

chdt

vi

khOng

mu6n

xem

dny

v{t

chi

nghia

Ii

mQt

gifro

dibu

cho

su

seing

kh6ng

chilp

thu{n,

kh0ng

blo

chring

vE

nbfrrrg

f

itinh

c&a

cric

hbri di.u

khign

vi

ngoai

nhilng

sr.tlnguy.hiEm

cho

rihfrng

k6

nio

chdp

thu4n

c6c

gi6o

rtri.u

cfia

Thhn

lirrrr

hos

,,;

kh.n;

o;;-

lii,,

"n,i,rg

di,

cAc

hQi

vi0n

Th0ng

thi€n

hoc

tAn

thdnh

cOng

viQc

ldm

err'

nhau

loai

thoat

kh6i

sqt

vd

minrr

vb

vfln

db

cdi

cbdt vir

hOrr

kia

cr'ra

tfr

eiia

c{:

nha

lh0ng

linh

hoc

trong

1116

fli''i'

song

crrring

ta

chn

phfii

phdn

iue*

,

rogi

th'ng

linh

hoe

:

Logi

tbri

ntr{r

&

-Hr1y

chfrqg

qu6c

noi

mA

thur6r

.fh0ng

linh

hgc

b6t

ngubn

trb&i

sE

1,a

A

Anh

; ci

t

ai

noi

ugy

hq

dbu

bdc

b6

thuydt

luAu

lrbi.

Cee

thln

linh

,nh4p

vlr)

c6c

d6ng

rfr

dEu

b{c

16

thuydt

ndy.

s";;--

,iJ]*

tinh

hoc

&

Itre-rlia

(&

Ph{p

vA

&

cnao

My

r,

i'-ni'il,i

rtai

d€

lqi

crrffp

rhufl'

thuydt

lu'n

hiii

ve

ghn

tIAy

&

Ila

tfiy'

cdc

hiin

ri6p

xrlc

l+i

gifing

dty

vb

nhdn

quS,

n6i

mot

c{ch

liirric

ndu

ant'il,

e

tsa

Tdy

arh

,d

';;;g-;;,;;;

;;;

a

'l'A_y

vd

ho

sE

lem

eho

,anfr

tin

d6n

lu{n

hbi,

vA

n6u

a'h

mfit

&

Anh

hay

Hoa

K}

cAc

b6n

sE

fero

.io

*ntr ph{ir

dcli

vigr

nAy

(Dibu

ndy

.:Lring

16

rriQr

"Oi"

U:"

;

quan

.iQ*r

r*

iu&ng

vb

cuos

dui:

cris.

ugud,i

s6ng

ra

sao

ttti

khi

eh6t cfing

nhu

vfy).

Chinb

trong

sF

khring

bolng

tlo

n:d

lI.P.lJ.

xudt

hi4n

ra

dE

xac

nhan

uri

t;;"".;'

Thhn

ItlO

hoc,

frong

cu6n

nhlt

fy-sO

mor

cfia

bA

&

Adyar,

'A

eidt:

l3i

chri

quan

trong:

Vdng

ldi

l{y

lAm

ri6e

r6i

dx

gi*o

ri6p

vni

cac

hbn

dg

t4t

rhy

dbng

t&

Holmes.

T6i

cln phdi

cuu'

vfln

tinh

trgng

vA

t.i

duoc

ptrAi

t,f

ts;;

rsAN

LINH

IIoc

cilng

c6

lai

trong

cOng

nh{n

ndw

l

C. Jinarajadasal

lqi

vidt

trong

rqp

chi

Thdosophisr

f

kidn

chln

la

de

thAnh

cOng

i

'

r

1';.]lFFq ,rrr

Jrinl

,t

l

t

i

Kim

thAn

(corps

bouddhique),

Tiqtr

rh6

(corirs

atomique)

]

'

Thong

thi0n

l.-?r.:0"

rtog

jml

dgng

tfr

vA k6

ch€rgiao

ti6p

rhl

kB

ch6t

abng

r,",.

a;,;

ff

;il-^ff"_i:lo

jil

;l",:llJin'f

;;:

inh

nr0t

chrir

'"f1-,ro.ng

cAi

vla

thl

cdi

b6ng

gidng

ntru

lir0y

rna

dA

sinhj

Ngudi

ta

goi

l&

nhfrng

cAi

v6.

No

bi

Iubng

tinh

krri

rr6n

cdi

truug

iior

ao"

rr6i

nbrr

.u*"siail

mAy

mtr

song

q6u

nd

g{p

clbng

c6t

nhtp

uo

ti.,o

,n"g

l:n,t, ,r."^

ch&

cfra

]ngu&i

ch6t.

N6

li

mQt

16

bAo

ru

dQng

ll:

Olo"*

phti

rd

hbn

k6

ch6t

sau

rdr

n6

rfl

ra

ltrdnh

khl

nhc

truoc.

1' I

I

l---r-

Hn

trt

(corps

rnental)

lhuong

rri

(cbrps

eaosal)

i

Phdch

(doubleierh6rique)

i

.-

|

VIa

(corps

asfrst)

COn

ltheo

'fhfnf

rhi0n

hoc

ccn

ngudl

co

Z

rhg

:

Xlc

thAn

(corps

dense)

I

:1t

lft

nay

bqcl

&

ngoAi

(p6iisprit)

vt

linh,

hbn

(esprir)

hay

chon

ftnh.

:l

nhu,

sau

:

(

...

Ihfn

Unh.

frq,

1Ul,

TNAN

I,INH

HOC

THUAT

cHIfg HdN



I

thuc

(clairvoyante

consciente)

& trong

trqng

thAi

tinh

vd

c6

tfrp luyQn (entrainde)

iii

bI,ta quen

slt

lich

trlnb

tiCn

tri6n

dang

di6n

ro, b&i

mqt

tu

tu&ng

g*n

libn

&

muc

cira tu

tu&ng dy, vr)

c6c

tu tu&ng

ling

vlng trong

nh6m n6n

dbng tfr < thd.y

>

vd

<

nghe

n

vi

h9

giii

thlch

lai

biing

nhiing

t[

cfrnh vA nh&ng

thOng

bAo. EiEu

nAy

c6

th8

ldnn

cho ngu&l

ta

tin

c6

su

hign

diQn

cira

mQt

k6

qu,

cti.

Song

til{

cl

chrlng

ta

dbu c6

trong

tri

u6t

chflt don

gifin

c6 th6

tgo

ra

hinh

inh

clAng

tin

cfia nhb'ng ngudi

m:i

cbilng ta

y€u

d,'6n.

|

.

,"d6n

Mj

lA

-vi

ch&ng

hoc.'

'

d4

cbrlng

t6

clc

hi$n

tuong

vA

su

thlt

cfia

n6

tlnh

cacn

sai

llm

cic

lf

thuydt

cira

thhn

linh

t6

TAi

llolmes

vdi

su:

girlp

dS

cfia

M'

:

toi

tta

lAnn'

nbi

b*t

htnh

lnh

.lohn

King

vir

Katie t(ing

trong

dnh

s{ng

ctra

"irh-,tttg

gidi,

tOi

df,

tao

ra

c6c

biQn

-tugng.hi9"

hbn

vi

dB

cho

cfc

lhhn

linh

hqc

gil tu&ng

rfing

dibu

:iy

dA

do

Holmrs

tao

ra.

cbinh

Holnres

ctng

ngqc

nhion

vi

nang

bi6t

rhog

..y

I

nigo

lbo

dv

i

co

lhit'

c6

phli

la

t6

tla c6

l5i

cre[nc

?

'l'h6

gioi

chua

1

sin

sing

dB

hiau

16

tridt

ljr

;f*

tt

oi

nqc

tri

lruyEn'

Ddy

ln

vfin

ilB

c6

nhfrng

nhau

v4t

trong

cAnh

vb

hlnh,

thhn

hbrr

c6c

li6

ch6t

hay

c6c

con

tinh

ctr{t

h"y

dd

le

rlo'quybn

n[ng

hn

ting

tropg

con

n'{udi?AGatdnervi6ttro0g'fheosoplristinActiondth{ing

1)

vA

lo-i950.

t(

...

Tu

'[SSo

.o

mQt

C6

ttbng

tli

hinh

nhu

rlugc

fing

Nb:i

thOng

H,:dson

trong'

vcri

rr

han

rlb

.:

gu&

ct){)

r)guol

))

.r

'A

?

r .

thd cua

co'l

ngrltyi

[hi*n

hoe d+y

con

thi6n

hoc ki6m

huybn

bl hgc

Geoffroy

mot bubi

dt6n

thuydt

21-8-1959 &

Siigon

<

QuyBn

nhng tlii0ng

liOng

vi

phi

thudng

del

db

cap

ddn

vdn

rlB

nghi€n criu b&n

hiing

hai

phuong

phAp,

Ong

n6i

:

<

Th6ng

ngnoi

vdn

96

2

quyEn

n[ng

si€u

nhi6n

;

tlch

cuc :

cbir

dQng.

ti€u

,

crlc :

thu dQng."

h0

vi

mQt

i6

c{c

bi0u

hiQn

hlnh

nhu

co

gif tri

vi

du

foqt

i

nieo

tuqog

vE

Katie

Kiug'

ThAt

khd

ldng

cho

ching

ta'gifiit

,ni.nl

.a.

su

li6n

I

hiQn

nAy

nhu

lt

nlrftng

fio

Jl

nb

ii

rq

{o

,na,

ctrn

nirfrng

uubi

chiou

hbn

chi

Id

hai

L""

ba

phln

trlm.

Phln

cdn

l4i

dbu

'do

cAi

mA

la

goi

lA

stic

thu

hrit

ctra.tu

tu&ng

(osrnose

d'iddes)

do

'c6i

tri

v0

thitc

cfra

nh6m

nguli

i

dua

d6n

cho

tlbng

tr?'

Nhu

cAc

ta

gllll lnlcu

cau

str

ulEu

urvu

.

rre

ni*."

.n"

vO thuc.

Ngdy

nay

nhfrng

rtitu

Cy

'ilH

thoy

dbi'

Ric si vt ilA

Bendit

vu'a

lrbi

de

m&

mQt

cuQc

nghi6n

Bfc

si

vi

fd

Uendit

vua

i

rot

oa

urLt

ruvr

uuvv

Lrrlg'vu

"lio

i

vi

nq

vl6t

mQt

cudn

i

sich

vE

vdn

db

niy

vA

ho

rnudn

Ul6tr

ro "b rdo

tlb.'llq

ddn

laF

cdc

cufc

lhtnghiQm

voi

mqt

,.d

aoog

ttbn{

tfr

kha

nhdt

&

Lu0n

40o'

Cl'

hai,

fEu

ttbng'

1) quybn

2)

qqyEn

nhng

ndng

Quybn

ndng

thu

dQng,(pouvoir

n€gatif) thuQc

tAnh thrr

<ldng

duoc dirng b&i nguci

goi

lA

dbng

tfr

(m€dium).

Nhitng

qu3bn

n6ng

116

c6 nhfrng s&

doln

_

hhi nguli

ta dirng

dA

khio

cuu,

suu thm. N6

kbdng

do nsi

sr5

cd

gfing luyQn

trl

hay

x{c

thfin tu

luy{n

rl$o ml

c6

nhung n6

xly rt6n

mqt

c{ch

tu

.nhi0n

c6

th8 do

tlnh cd mA c6

:'Nguoi

ta

khdng

th6 dirng

n6

l&m

khi

cu

khlo

cuu suu

tlm

mQt

khoa

nAo

x€t

vi

n6

lA

nhiing

quybn

nhng

thu dQng

ndn

n6

d6n

vdi

mQt ngubn

gdc

bOn

ngoti. Nhfrng

quybn

ndng

o

lnuc

cua

noour

DB,rfur

arua

ueu

vuv

svgb

r--

-''

rban

dfi

bidtl

bA

Bendit

11

I

mqt

k6

c6

linh

'tuQ

hay

minh

't

ri.

TELr/iT CHIEU

HdN.

s7

THIN

LINTI

HQC



'i

I

cbnong

UuYEn

bt

Kbi

dA

ilqi

fi,ong

tbiOn

bqt

.oe: ,r

--.Ar

rh

rhr.rc

onu#'pii

;il";lit'""ho

rilog

hQi

nitv

t&

ruqt

tb

chuc

huybn

bl

vA

clri

chny0rr

vb

truy6n

bi mA th6i vl

muc

dll;h

cira

h(ii cr)ir

li

ughiOn cuu

ddi

chi6u

khoa hgc, trj6t

hoc,

vA

t6n gido.

I'uy

nhi0u

vi m6t vAi

hgc

gil

ctra

hQi

la

nhfrng

nh$ huSEu bi ho; tru

danh nhu Blayaslhy, Learl-

berler Jinarriudasn,

flodson nOn

ching

l0i

thdy trlch

,cdc

j

kidn

yi.

rrh&n

xdt

cfia

e{c

Vi

ndy

vd

Uet

vAo

chutrng

rr:iv khirrig

phii

lA

quA dfrng.

2)

Qrtitn

ttrhm

cia cd.c

',hoc

gi& khdc.

trl(t

s6

rin

nhd

huybn

hi

hoc

&

I'Sy

Phuong

cr5 rlunn

niQrn

gi

ldtii

'crl

l.'hX,:lg

linh thuydt

? Chting t0i trrdng

ta

c() th6

kd

nrfit sd

cic ntrrl

lru';lln

bi hor:

&

t'lnp"

llrpur

(t0rr thflt

kl b{s si Girard

liucausse)

cri

nhirrrfi

y

kidn nhu' snu

:

*

Huyhn

hi

lr.r;:

klific

rrui phhn

tl6ng

c*c

tin

dli

cfia

't'h6rg

linh

tiru3,6t {r

th6 hulbn

bi

hgc kh6 rnil c0ng nh{rr

c$c su

tidp x*e

6iiin

rrgrrdi

.1n*

vt

ngud'i chdt.

(t)

'

(

llurbn

trl

hoc ciing khOirg

phri

nh{n

vA

khOng bao

gi}

phri

nh0n vi1,e

cr5

fh6 tidp

,

xric

v6i

ngucli

ch6t

nhurrg

huyEu bi hoc

han chfi

riit

nhiFu c{c bubi

thi

n6hi$m

cd

tlnh cfch clrdn

thi'.

PhXn

nbiBu lA

nhilng

su

hign

thuQc

vb tu hj

Arn

tiri

hay

thdi

mi0n

trong

d6 cAc

ltrc

cfra dbng

tri'

vA

cri'

loa

pbdi

trqp

v6i nheu

dB

cdu

t+o

thAnh.

(2')

c

Srl

thi nghi€m

vE

chi6u

hbn

thu$t lim

eho

cfc

rlbng

tft' c(

th6

d.au

bdnh

'thhn

kinh

vi

di0n

logn.

(1)

Xeu

(2)

Xem

Papur

s

Qu:est

ce

qus

I'occultismo

r.

Papur c

La science

des Mdgies

l.

i

i .

Uonr,

ttruirng

tlii

v6

d6

\nquoi

ra

t{hoPg

thb

tt^^

i

th.Ao

hlnp,

\thudng

pa

lihong

tu0\

tnre

rhAch'

hav

tht

nghiQm

du{c

frtl

nhfr{s

1a"t'

""aat

\"u*:-

*ot

ml

do

do

ta

co'

Vl

116

irt6,

nhitdg

nguai

thon[

thi0n--hgc-

chu

trqng

hsn

vb

rt#

q,ryeo

pnof

titrt

ttlt

buy

chir

itQng'

\"1

t,

orraf

th{v

ntrlrq

q,:'bo

ndng

thu

done

thuc

hnnh

\nhrt

cacl

abng

til'

a"t{

aen

cho

ta

nhftng

nguy-hi8m

nhfrn

ngudri

ldd

;chi

cang\

:snv.

t"T*-::

"::,::n:

Tfi

;t

Tt-

ff;;;

i

*"ut

db

i'lo"

luon

n4p

'minrr

ho'

x{c

i.

thon

vd

tu

tqonfi

rq

cbo

loc

m+ol

hen

:soil"itiy..'l:

:'lT

il

,unt

"l[o

ton''

Nso'pi

ra

thi

ncr

cdn

larn

clro

ta

i,i

'uJ'

{"n

l"

luni'

\ , .

r,..

Nhirng

o*itut

thuc

hinhl

an"g

b6ng

cing'trtr

n0n

thu

deng

rdt

tloi

rpi

lnn

'nodns

J'el

ugoai.

:rT

'|':ii:

'|;:

lgng

rdt

tlOi

t1i

trnh

huong

r)Eu

usu'rr

A(^."

v------

bu&n$

t16

vn

J

klrous

'u

*u11

9:1:

'u

tU"

bq

nlbe

ttr{v

;;;;",Ji-oo

{ion-

tl"'

1no \*1

lhrng

biin'{'

Nhiing

ti6ng

nbi

dd

c*ng

rmau""''uot

on

ntao'

quni

gE-

11T,

n:|t'i,l^*;

il:

il'

*"

on

-'i

the

'bi

anh

bu&ng

*"

qoli.

'xau'r

nhflp

khons

tU

chiri

duoc'

DO

lA' mQt

tL:h

trsqg

kh6

tri

cho

"'

l- ra *'A

-'''lri

tb6ng

.

thi0n

hgc

csng

cht

h0ng

tq

chirt

ttuvc'

uo

ra

mer

"^;

,;,;-J i,oc

c'n

trdt

duon.

Vi

lE,

*

tU

ngpli

ltr6ng.

thi0n

hgc

csng

cht

trong

d$n

qubbn'"u''*

ti1tr1-

cuc

n":

t1,::o,,:;tu:,r:T:

lt"ir,ff}g

";ffit;-n1''-*op.s-quv€n

nrng

tich

ctlc

drd

c6

do

tuygn

1an,-io

"ii*

llj'*

;{t

.::.

t::,"::,,,:':'-t:'T:i:

;;-";;tiit

itL

oou'

*t

I

*oo

thm

moi

ptrucrns

diQn

va

luo

nbi$u

thni

ctng

tluoc

hLi

ta

uru6n

'ti

:O:.-t:' :i::

ao

nhi$u

thni

ctng

tluoc

KUr

t:

.

khlo

cuu

tlo

l"o"ta

fap

lqi

dA

tbtr';emc6

dting

cban

lf

kh0ng...

>

-

I

-.

.l^

r:

^ ^

.,.\^

^hr"dT

no

tlurEn

bj

TEAN

LINH

IIOC

\-

iuuAr

cHIDU

EON

.99



{

Clc

$F ttrtr nghiQm fiy

cdng

tr khdng

cdn

t[

chir

vi

df, dhu

(

YA

utriEu

ti6p

thec..

Papus

tlru{t

c0

ciiug

nhir

dudng

dly

eqrm

bdy

IVI$I

mOn

tlg

ctra

Mot

'f.C4.s

1J

_

.

t

"

"

i - r

nguy hi6m

bQi phhn

khi

hing"

sq An lnh,

sU rdi logn tAm thhn

<

Ri€ng

vl

lphln

c{

nhiq

cfra

,t6i,

10i

c6

nh{n

elugc

nhibu

thu

do

rfhi8u

ttbng

tfr

dAng thnong

g&i

Udu.

Nli&ng

ttbng

tfr nfy

d$

ph6

m{c

cho c6c

cuQc thi

nghi$m

vi

hiSu

nay

b

n[iing

kE

m4o

htr$u

lt

hbn

ngudi

chdt

ddn

Am

Anh

nnQt

cAch

ghO gdm.

(1)

>

:

Ao

u6c

rnQt cAch

tbidt tha

thily

mQt

ngudi

chdt

ily

lA

truy

niQm hlnh

inh cfia

ngudi

{y, k0u

gAi

ngucri

Cy

vl

linir

chr.r

ngudi

fly

tir troug

6nh

sfing cira

cdi

lrung

gi6i

hay di

thAi

rni

& d0

c{c

hlnb lnh

cfra

dI

rfing

dugr:

in

sfiu

cd th6 b{t

tung

ra.

D6

tI uhfrng

ttibuidfl x$y ra

trong cdc

cuQc

thi

nghlQrn.

Cfc

nht

thOng

'linh

thuydt

klrOng

biilt minh

lt.ti lfr

.

nhii'n6

phap

su.

fi6

cbo cuQr

ti6p xrlr

r,6i

trt

tu&ng

tuEng

vsi

tlrit:r

nhiOu

rluor: thryc hiQn

chn

phii

ugir

hay & trorrg

trgng

thsi

say

srra ha3,

IOu

clhng

ho{c

& trong

tr4rrg

thfi

bf,t

dQnfi

hay

tli0n- loqn (1),

Sau

.l0y lA

y

ki6u

bi

Anne

Osuont

chir

tich

hQi

nglriAn

criu huybn

bi

hqc &

Ph/rp ddi

vcri

Th0ng

linh

thuydl

:

a

Ndu

,

b4n mu6n

thi

nghiQm

vD thOng

linh

thu16t

a

"l

Eugc

rbi.

Khdng

n6n

Ctrng

phucrng

phf,p

chi€u

triln

nhu

mQt

trd choi

gili trt

nhlrng

ll

mQt

cdng

vi{c c6 tlnh

efrch khoa hoc.

Hfiy

cfi nhttng dtic

tir,h

sau

niy :'srr

chuy6n

cbt,

6c

khdch

qrlan,

slr ki$m

soAt,

n6u kh0ng,

cdc

trgn sE

bi

nbiErr

lhm

lac.

1)

Trong 1000

uubi

chi0u

hbn

thl

cl.ri

c<i

20 bubi

a

c6

th6

triern

rrhu

chfic chsn

nhftng

dib.n

la tlrn

tdi.

2)

I'hhn

l<rn

c{c

bgn

d[

dirng

bAn lay iim

mqt

noi

dA tich

lril tir

di8n

chung

vd

ngudi

nAo

c6

tir

tli8n

mgnh

trong

cril

tga sE

diEu

khiEn cuQc

tbl

ngtriQm.

3)

Ttrdi

gian

cic

bnbi chitu hbn.

chn

phii

ngln.

(2)

(D

,\"-

-,a

mort

r

trang

326.

(2)

Xetn

Clart6s

sur

I'occultlsme

llnr

Anne

Osmont.

nLriEu

tgi

$oi

,X,rg : < Nhirng ngtri

16

th8 xbm rdt

ogoy tiid,t

ddi

vcri

hbn

kg

chdt,

Con

'dtrd'ng

thgc

n

bdy

vi nguy

bi6m.

(2)

>

cira chi6u l:6n

ngrrui

k0u

goi

nghi$m ln con

Morius

Decrespe

cho' r&ng

:

'{{

{l

li

I

i

'l

I

Papus

li

trong

trhfrng

ltipu

ki$n khirug khi6p

vi

dE

mu6n

tli

s0u

vlo c6c

cuQc

fhi

nghiQm.

Vfly

khOng

phAi

vO

lf

md

giAo

hQi

cfirr

<Ioin

jnhfrng

htnh

thuc

rna

qnAi

dy.

(3)

,

fim

<lo{n

jnhfrng

htnh

thuc

rna

qnAi

dy.

(3)

,

il"ir

f--- . ..t r

'rU

<

Nguy

nidrln

lep

lA

phln

ddng

tr&

uOn

di0n logn

nhtr

huyEn

bt hoc

c6

ti6ng kb6o cfia

Ph6p

li

liliphar

Levir cP cho

bfdt

f

ki6n

"hT

sau

:

r<

Nh&ng

cuBc

cbi€u

.nbn

btri

lA

su ddc

h6a

cfra

trl

nh6

vn

Vi€C

nhuQm

i

mAu

tu&ng

trlqng

cAc

hlnh

b6ug (la conden-

utign

lde

la m€lmoire,

la

gololation

i*aginaire

des ombres).

-'i-

r

(l)

)iem Trait{ 6l6montrtre

do

magie

pratique

pai

Papus

(trang

505

-

507)

i

(p)

{erdinand

jDivoire

tilch

dfin

trong

Occultisme

cassc

cou.

1b1

La maln

dt ses mystdres, l[me

I,p

70,

T.tTAw

LINE

TIoc



-+

Cic

i[i$u

ki$n

vA

nht'ng nh{n x€t

cha

bfi

Anne

tri. Thtri

kh6i bi

phin

biQt

d6 trAnh

Iuenl m6t

sd

cfqo si Arl

NtrA dqo si

jSwami

Vivekauanda

c6

quen niQm

nhu

sau

:

(2)

< GiiIa

c6

hiirrg

Lrh

sa

sd

sinh v$t

nhftng cLnh

gidi

khAc

ntrau. l

i;

Do4n khfrc

ltrong

tdc

phhm

Raja

Yoga, tf

+o

si Vivekananda

lqi

c0ng

kich

lchidu

hbn

thu$t mot

'lhn

niia.

(Trlch

dfin

l)&i

H.

I\{. De

Cnmpigny

trong

Thdorie

et

pratique des

Yogas

traog

198).

Nhn

dqo

si

Ramana

Maharshi :

qua

su

di6n t& ctra

(l)

Xeo Lett

'l

tomc

I,

trang,

296,

r

par

Vivskaoanda

trung 309

TT{UA.T

CI{IEU HdN

Jr

an

,d, tlS

cdi

ti6p

llehert

trong

lic

phhm

<

Les

grands

maltres

spiritneis

l'Inde

conremporaine

I

bAy

td r$ng

mudn

khdnr

pbd

v0

biuh

cbi

bfing

c6ch

cirdt

vl

vdo

c6i

ch6t.

GiAn

hinh,

lrung

nrA

I

n6i

lhl

d6

li

du&ng

ldi

thu

hai cfia

khoa

si0r.r

dich

thAn

vio

cdl

r0

hlrrh

chu

lrhdng

phli

qua

su

gian

cria tlbng

tri

nhu

chidu

hbn fhu$t.

l0t

Osmqnt

tuy

lt

nhung

theo

j

chting tOi

c6

giA

6ian

jchi0u

n4n

ugfin

lil

"61

y

dA cho dbng

tfr

'mdt,

i*6,

srlcf vl tAm thld kb6i

rdi

loqn,

Sr3

Si4

ch0n frong cdc

cuQc

dhieu

[,tio

chn thi6t

tdil

u;0 rin

di

doan,

tin

c?rh,

tin

nhim

rnfi

kh0ng

chn

1

rhf

n

lticlr

srg

dlqn.

u

dA

bi6t

Y

ki6ri

nrQt

sS c{c nhi huybn

bt

hoc

Qhring

t0i trtrrh

biv

ntrfrng

f

ki6n i,fio

mQt

"i

a i'

.Xf;tr

ctrc

6

An

dlQ

iid,n

{afn

tl6n

viln

db.

i

hgc

gilt

khdc.

Shn khi

&

Au

Chan,

s5

lcAp

nh:ir

il

3)

Quarr

Shri

Aurolpindo

ndri

vb

cihi6u

hbn nhu

sa.u

:

(

Rfit cdl

rti8

l$

rih&ng;

j

rrgrr0i

ohdt hay mft

rli

vi

nhiing

rrgrrli

nAy

hhdng

phli

lfl

cbdt

th$t

song dang

&

trong

nhiiug

ving

siin

dia clu

r[&

ti6p

xtc

vo'i

nhfrng

ngudi

sdng.

(1) >

,

silswaori

Vi'vekauan

I

t0i

I

v.n

bsn

c6

lh8

t)

Qttan

di?m

cfia

mdt

sd

ll.

Speneer

Lewis

troug

ph{i

Rosicrucien

vi6t

{r tAc

phhnr

.r<

[,es demeures

de

l,lmer

f

ki6n

nhu

sau,:

Ilrii

:

Cri phli

trong

c{c bubi

cbi6u

hbn

tEi

t*c

phdng

t$i,. hbn

c{c

kA

chdt dE

tr&

vb vA

hign lOn

bfrng

Eqr

binh

rhrr

khi6n

cbd

"intog

ta

khdng

sao ph&n

bigt

duryc

th6

nlo

rlil

mQt

xAc

tirOn

v&

th6 ndo

ld

hbn

hiQu

ra

?

D{p :

0hic

cbin

r*ng

kh6ng

c6

mgt linh

hbn

nlo

Igi

tr&

vb

trAi

rlfit

rrir.

phi

dt.

dhu

thai

tai.

VA nhu

vgy

kh0ug

bao

gid

lgi

c6

th&

bay trong

kh6ng

giau

bay

d6n

drl

vio

cf,c

bubi

chiOu

hbn

bay

clc

phdng

thi

nghiQm.

VA

chfic chfin

riing

liph

hbn

kh0ng

th0

mang

mQt

thf,n

x{c

tru

plri

tli

dlu

thai

vlo

x{c

mQt

rl&a

b6

m0i

sanh.

Vo'i

quan

di0m

nAy tht

Ong

cIE phfr

nhin

holn

toin

cAe

cuQc

chi0u hbn.

II.

M.

De

Campigny

trong

<

La

magie

poor

tous r

lOn

tidrrg

c&nh

cAo

cAc

'bubi

chiCu

hbn. Ong

ta

vi6t

:

<

Hdy tlirng tiu

c{c

hlnh

thric

chi0n

hbn

ml

theo

0og, tslavatsky

vA

Stanilas

de

Guaita

ciro

hay

dE

lAm'hai

hAng

ngAn

ngudi,

vA khi6n nhiBu

k6

khAc

di

ctdn

chd

tr.l

vdn...

r

'0'

tics,

togr

2)

r Jnaua

ilpttr*,eiitfr

-

it,

l

',-)'

,

'

'

'

TIIUAT

cHlEu

rIbN

r03



rfing

vl{c

cho

lA.ctbng

tft

lira

blp

lai

kh0ng

chfrc

chfin

bilng

cdc

hi{n

trrryng

p".Oharles

ltichet

(m[s

dhu

rrhu

ta dd

ith{y

khOng

o0ng

rrtr{u

ty thuydt

cfia

chitiu

hbn

song

c0ng

nli{n

|riQn

trrcrng)

x6c

ntr&n

trong

rtTraite

mdtaprychique

> :

<

Edi

voi

tfri

tri{n

tr .1 ng{

fiy

rfit

dgp

d€ thuQc

linh

vr1*

si4u

t6m

lirth.

Nhirrrq

ridil4

gd

fiy

'hhorig

th$

blo lil

do 'ti6ng

keu

rflc

r'fia

96

vl

c6

lirtir

e{ch

'lh

ing

min .

D

liAc

si

Jos'";rrir

l-'appoui

trdp :

<

Ndn

clrurlg

tn cho

riirrg

nhiing

lidrrg

t1']'rr;1

fiy

tn

do

cic

bhp

thit

eo

giflu ra

vio

thi

lArn sqo

ta

lnl cil

tlrb

gi&i thtch

tlngs

rXng

ntrfrn$

ti6ng

fiy

96

khi

k6r-r

b&1

p1fii, cO

khi kdu

bBn

trAi,

c6

k6i

rrghe lbn

&

tr0n

f,rllrr

rrb&

c0,[,bi

nhu

&"

dw6i

thbru

d:il

(l).

,,

Ailan

Kardoc

c0ng

kich

thuydt

blp

thit

nhtr

ttr6 ndo

?

0lrg

ti r-r

lfit

:

1) Sno

lqi

hiQn tucrng

6y

xAy

ra nhibu

noi vA

rir$i

mfii

?

2) Dbng

tft

lrtrdng cd

ich

lqi

gi

tt6 lAm

cho

minh

nlQt

lu{rn

trong mdy

gi&

eibng

hb

trong

cAc

bubi

chi€u

hbi-

,3)

Kfr$ng ttr&

gi$i

rlilch

tlutr':

cfc

tidng gd

lq-i x&y

ra tr8n

c{c

cfrnh

er?n vh

tr0n

c{s

huc

tu}ng.

Ilrtssel Waltace

nhAn vi0n

hQi [Iln

IAm Anlr

qudc-tu16n

bd

:

4

'fiil lil

mQt

kB

duy

vdt

tri4t

d6

cho

n0n

t6i

khfrng

th6

dilng

ngp mQt

tu tu&ng

tinh

thln

nAo.

Song

cf,c

rnfiu

chuyQn

lA

nhfi'ng

dibu

cay d6ng

vt

sn

th{.t

d[

lim

cho

lOi

tin

turlng.

Cdc

hiQn

tuqng

ctra

chi€u

hbn

lhu{t

dA

f; i.

L'hyprotisme

ct

spiritisme

r

Aksahof .

"* '

"

€truong

tV,

*.

(ltOA

r{gg

D6t

V6t

KXteA

CHTGU

nbr*.

Chung

ta

d.i.

,1.6"

ttiSm

cudi

rron6

clr'ytrnfi

u.$..y.

Erl

lil

vdn

dE

khoa

trr2c

hay

i

kifin

ciia

cqu

rrh'ir

mQnh

danh

IA

hhoa

hou

t16i v&i

Th0ng

linh

ttru5dt'

-i

0'

Uey

.itti"14

ta

sE

thdy

{i"g

cf

hsi

tr'the'

Nhtittg

nhir

khoa

ho[

n&o

df,

nghi6n

cuu

c ri4'

hB'

tlu$t

thl

thly

abu

cfirld

nhsn

ilng

chr6u

Siip

t5*f

t crr

r.Qt

ptrhn

sU

th4t

trongl

c6;

sF

hiQn

ilf;

rlttc'c nqhi€n

cu'u'

cdir

mQt

s6

kh6c

c6

U

kUOng

tq rnlnh

nghi4n

cum

riii chi

lf{y

J

ki6n

riOng

ctra

urlnh

dB

c6ng

hietr'

frong

m$t

tAc

phhrn

ff,c

si,

L Wanthy

<

Scieace

et

spiritisme

r

p6

cl5n

atru'g

1j

hidn

cira

nhibu

nhil

bfc

lroc

rtdi vd,i

ffr0r{e

tinh

thuYdt:

Itlorselli

jgi6o

su

tfim

1f

hqc

t]ai

hq'c

dur]ng

Ggnes

&

V tuy6n

bd

r&ng

:

('toi

Ltro

rxng Tho'g

linh

thuydt

dang

rluoc

cac

nh[

b6c

hgc

nghign

cuu

"rA

10i

thir

'h4u

rhng

tOi

'trotn

toin

tin

ttr&ng

qb

tn0ng

linh

thuydt'

n

Camille

Flammarion

thi€n

vin

hoc

gia

PhSp

trong

mQt

t6c

pbhm nh]an

db,

<

Les fgrces

naturelles

inconnues

r

vi6t

:

<

Nilfrng

ridnfi

dgp

cira

cdc

{in

chi6u

lrbn

thutrng

cluqc

ch"o

ll

do

mtnn

t<U$e

tta

bip mfil

ra

hay

ngu.&i

ta

gili

thich

b1ng

cltc

I

tOi

nUul

ao

hflp

thit

cfra

tlbng tri

tgo

thinh..

Sau

cds

cFA+

nghien]

otu

itdi

cbidr

cla

t6i,

tOi

cd

thb

xdc

'hfln

l,.t

r01

I

1HAN

LlNrr

HOC

THUAT

CIIIIIU

HbN

105



I

,dugc

chfng

rhinh cilug

nhtr

moi

hign

tuqng

cira

c{c

linh

vqc

khoa. hoc

kh{c. r

lt5slop

(giAo

su

dgi.

.hoc

dur}ng

Columbia)

tht

pdi

:

q

Edi

voi

nhfrng

diEu do

cbinh

rnfit

l0i

d[

thily tdi

kherng

bi6t

lim

sao

c6

th&

rft

b6

Bit

thuydti

su

hign hfru cfia rnQt

cuQc

attri

vE sau.

))

Oliver

Lodge

y+t

if

gia

c6

f

ki6n

nhu

sau

:

(

TOi

dd

di

d6rr

sq

tin

lurlng

ring

ngudi

ta,cdn

sdug

rlqra

vrlo

cAC hfing

ad

d{[ trdn

nrdt

nbn tlng

hotn

toAn

kiroa

hgc.

Ndu tdi

tuyOn

bd

ring

t6i

li

'kE

theo thOng

hub

rhuy6r chtnh lh

vi

t$i

j x&c

-l[re

n

nhfrng

inign

tuang nhu nhii'ng

str

tb{ti

kdt

qufr

;

c0,rg cuQc

k( lo cuu vts tAnr linh

cfia

r6i

dA

lln'i

lhn

ldm cho t6i

tin

{n[.

*uo

hai rnrroi

nilnn nghi0n

eriu

I

rilng

kh0ng

uhiing

con

fgurli

cOn

hign

irfru

;sau

khi

ch6t

mA sqr g'ao

ti6p

thinh

thofing

vcri

ng,rbi

chdt

tuy

r&ng

hh6

kh{q

vA

trong

nhhng

dibu

,

kiQn

d{c

bier

vfin

c0

th}

rh*nh

lituu

duoe.

I

6if,o

su

thiOn

v{n hgc rlqi

lrgc

clu0ng

Cnm-

nh$n :

<

Cle

bfing

c&

c6 qu6

nhibu

vA

ntrirng

hi

i

phn

hqp

vtri nhau

.tA ta

cd

th6

ch{p

cAc

1

srp ki$n

ml ngud.i

ta

tlua

ra li

elrtng

ntru

phfi

nhsn

t{t

cl

mgi chrlrrg

nhgn

cfia kB

F-rdddric

Meyers

gi6o

su

rdm

ly

d1i

hgc

dudng

Cam-

;bridge tuyOn

b6l

:

<

Sr;

quan

sAt

vA

sq

nghi€n

cuu

rlil

lAm

cho

naiEu

h6

ttm tOi

trong

tlO

cO

,r6i

di

ddn

viQc

rin

rfing

c0 lhE

(,6

sq

diao

thiQp

truc tiep

ho{c

bXng

m6i

clm

ung

giira

ngudi

ctrdl

cffng

nhu

ngudi

.

s6ng. I

Cdsare

Lombroso

hgc

gil

Y

dd lqi

tuy0n

b6 :

r

TOi.

trht

buQe

phAi

c0ng

nbin r[ng

cAc

hi$n trrong vL

clri0u

.hbn

tlririt

cfr

mQt

gi{

tri

l6n lao

vd gidi

khott

hr;c chring

{a

rtFu

cd

bbn

ptrdn

chri f

tirc

khlc etchi$n

tugng6y.rt

Y

ki6n

cin

cdo

nhA

trdc

hgc

cOn

r{t

nhibu, Chring

tOi

chi

lllch

ra

mOt

sS. Nhirng

nhA

bdc

hgc kh0itg

ttghi0n

euu

thi

cri

5t

ki6n

8i

?

Alexis

Carrel mQt

bAc

sI &

PhAp

ilE

vi6t

trorrg

<<

L'homme

cot

iricorrnu

>

lrang 253

mOt

rlo4n

uhu

sau :

<

C{: chuy0n

vi0n

vb

'fh0ng

linh thuydt

gi&i

thlch cAo

biQn tusng

i&nr liuh nhu nhiing blng c;'r

rB'

su trucrng

tbn cria

j

thrc sau khi

ch{t.

Dbng

tir

tu:&ng rilng

mlnh

kri

hdq

hd ch{t nh{p

vio. EOi khi thb

lQ

cho nhiing.

nhi

khio cuu

rrhiing

chi

li6t

rni

cbi

c6

khAn

gifi

bi6t

mA

rhoi

'vi

s&u d6

ki€m

so6t

lqi

thi

dring.

c

Ngubi

ta

cd

rtr0

gifri lhlch

theo llrord

rfing

nh&ng su

ki$n

fiy *h&ng t6

kh0ng

phii'srl

trulng

tbn

sau

khi

ctrSt

.

cir6

ciron

liuh

mA

mQt

y6u

td tf,m linh

c6

th0

thAp

ttng

tqrn

tbd'i

vrlo

lbAn

xic

cria

tlbng t&.

Y6u-td

t{m

linh

{y

hhi

nh{p vdo

mQt

nguc}i

sdng lgo thAnh

mQt

y

thitc rho ci

dbng

tfr

vC

h6

r:hdt.

Su sinh tbn cfia

'n6

tgr

bq.

Dln

dln

nd

tan

rfi

yA

cudi ctrng

mdt hdt

hodr

toln.

Kdt

qu[

c{c cuoc

thi-nghi$m

cira cflc nhA chi0u hbn thu{t

c6 mqt

y

nghia

quan

itrgng

rdt

lcrn

ho

song

tdi

giii

thtch

c&a

hg

dilng

c0

rnQt

gi6

tri

dAng ngd

(valenr douteuse).

Chrirrg

ta

hi6t rXng tu

turlng

crla

ru$t kE

c6 linh

tug c0ng

c6

th.0

bftt

gtp

dugc

,quA

kht

vA vi

lai.

E6i v0i hg

hhOng

crl

gl ld

bi

m&t.

Hi$n

ney

kh6

lOng

il8

phAn

bi$t

gifre

sqr

bdt tt? cfia

y6u t6

lAm

linh

v0i

hiQn

tugng

linh

tu$

rlo

dbng tr?

nh{n

thdy...>

l

i

I

Chhillis

bridge

xlc

blng

c&

dy

nh0n

rXng

vAy hay

li

khfc.

>

li

ii,

tt

i:

THAN

LINH

IIOO

I'HUAT

CIIIUU

NdN

10i



Grr "=is==-

linh

tn$

kiri

nr;lt

hiQn tu'ong xfry

ra

nrQt

ai

bii{t

wl,

l

vi

dd

d[t

r:fi:r

nhd b{c

cliinp

tri'

cil

lr'$

do

linh

hbn

lrti

cli4t"

Soug cd

r$.'rg

t\lri'ilrlt

thA

cr:

str

rull

lro,r61

r;;* ion

Nrhdng

nhu tArn

ly

hoc chny

xung

quanh

danh lri

< tibm-thuc >

vtl

ctrng n;rdrrg

lun6

dO

cf5

gfrng

bAc

h6

viQc

hbn ngu:rli

c6

th6

nhAp

vAo

,flbne

tfr,

Ilurbn

bi

hgl

ttrt c6ng kinh ciri0u

hdn

?.hu$.t

6" tli6nr trrS'

c0ng

ntrfn

c6 hi$n

ttrqng soit;l cho

rlng

vi{c rlirrr;1

,Shrrg

tfr

nguy-triAno

n6 hl}i

vd

clto

rXlg tlilnEl

khoa

r:l,iAn

irhn

chung mirrtr

ttr6

gi6i

si0tt

hi'rlt

ehtri

lrii'r

clil

x{c tlr{,1 vi

cO

lh0

bi

rrhibu

llim

l4c

c ',{^g Irir't*

fii

Irau'rvi

luu

rlv

i'tri

:

c

I(6

rd'

t{trqc

cf

i rlu{'i'

olfiii'ii

I

t.:

r':i:

rili

rrgurlr

ru cii

chff.u,

k6

rd c{i

tai

rhi

m5i

r:gtrrii

llp

ln$n

lhgs 1p,'1[

lili lillr.g.

))

'[ir.1i

ctr-c

rtr/,i

l$p

vtri [ruSbtr

hi

ho': l]

]r.lior'lto'r

trhi

'r":

eUu

triiit

rrgiri

ngd"

ddi

voi

c'hi0u

hiin

tbu'4t

('t:"r

lf

i'{lr

}ir

b;r

bom,

lirn

gst.

{jhfrng

nhfrrrg

th6 ntrfrng

ntrA

}ri{r

ltQi,

tli

rr

nghl0ft

r:dtu

{}rl

hi

5io'i

khon

hoc

la

6

cho lil

qu'li dl

(lr;ntirr;1

hr:'p

Rocl.rrs

giArn

rldc

trrz/-rng

B6-ch

khoa

&

L)iripr

l;ttAi

irft

tru&il5y

ifi

vl

hi

ci{rn

aft:An deo

dubi

cAc

cu$:

fhl-npilri(rnr

r:dr

linh

r':li.c[

<<

(:Irrr

>r

*

tl"rrr]ng fuqp

hAC

si G;[ir:r

crf;lt

(]i,i

Ilasteur

pl-rli

grla

I\Iy

dA ughi6u-crirn).

VA

hlri

efio

nhil.

bic

hoc {y

cOng

bd

cAc

cuQ: thi-nghifrn

ctra

rnith

t,il

phe

ddi

lap

cho

rHn6 toAtr

In nlr&ntl

cn$n

tl.ri-ngiriEm

khilng

cS

ki8rn

sout

uh[t

chd

hl{':

dA hi

dD,rg

lfi'

ltra

ttQt.

I\,IQ[

tb

chrlrc

c6

tlnh cAch

ghn

vdi

Thdlg linb

fhuydt

rilrfit

iA

tb.ch{tc

T'Am

linh hoc'

fb-chuc

nily ciiiitrl

c4

n

uc-

<lich ngtri0n-cun

eAn

hiQn-tuong

ilbng

bdng

song

cd

ti'rh

circh

khoa-hoc'

hsn

vil

hq

hhdng

gifri

thich

nhn

'I'hdng

linh

thuycir

dc thhn

thrinh

vil

ngudi

ch6t

uh$p

vao

mi

c&c

hign

tno-ng

Sy lqi

do

ilbng

tfr

tqo

ra.

l

1

Sq

nh{n

xit

co

ptrhn

cdn nbfic

hoe

Pllfp irry

cii

pbhn

dring

r

di8rn

tng

rnil

l:i6t,

r."iri vci

rnBo

xrtng

lA

nhiEu

cn{re

f.iril

rrghif m x{s

nhfirl

0:16

iileri:elL

llull

tidn

sj

hhoa

Irqri':

r,-rr.\[

lro

,

;,il

r]

tlilfrp

tr6r

i:ri

t'ry

khihnfi

hts

dA

tftrn

ngbli

r

.,uu

,lsin

[r en

1u'1rrr{l

diing

hdrrl{

scrr4

(lng

r:ir

vi6t cAn

rrilo

ur0t

tdc uhhm

cir.n

6ug nhan

116

<il-'occultisme

de[ant

ln

l.;ie

"rce

'r

(lg.trl)

rl,qi-

j

dn;i

ctlnfi-hkrll

th&ru-t$

huyiin

bl [ror:

r;i

rlirnlj

rrlribn

danLr

tu

cliu

r:llu,:g,hE

nghiOl-;fn

la

lrgu

tlln,

bilr

buur, tlirsLr

cnbng

vA

Ong cdng

kicir n51ny

oi

irhii:np{

nlrir h{i,;

Frqrc

niro,

d0

tSm

nghiOr.r-briu

nhirn,g hipn

tu:irng

fiv,

d*it

':ho

rhng

nhil

bdr:.1;o0

li

rnOt kG

phO

binfr

rfit

d&

diii

ru"i

r:irii'ng

k6

liiisr

trd

i'rn

ttril{t

v:l

c{c dbng

tfr

Ong b&o nhfi

hAi: lrqc

cho

rflng

khi

nri

gi6c

quan

bi6t tht

kh6

trlng

rr"rrr

frnc

b6

tri4r.r

tui/ng.

IIo tfn

ncri

con mft

vi t6 tni

h'r.

Tlifii d0

c&a 6ng Marcell

llolt

dw.c"c

r,TQt

ngwdri

llh{p

kh$.c l{

Iterna{d

Divoire

cho

IA

<

Crc

kh,}:rg

khoa

hoc

crin

vr\i

k6

,:uiirrg

ll{r

ridi

vryi

hhoa-iroc

p

vi

tiuir

l*

p}rfin

khoa

fiqt

khi

tr

dr.r

,lotn-

trrdrc

lthi tn

ph:',.

t1u;6t.

r>

(l)

Ii6.l-l"udn:

Ctri0u

liliir

tnuet

bi

cOng

kir;h

rilt

nhibu

ru

r6c

tlia

h4t

ktrfic nfran

tua

ra nhu

tOn

t{i{u

+hi

I0y tin

nrud'irg

long

tiu

giAu

cllfi

minh

vi

dr-ta

vdo cdn

lOrrh lqc

cr'ra cac

cdp tr0n

d3 d$

nh{.

COn

tri6t

l} thi

rlua

v*o

tnQr

vt\i

ptrat

(l)

Xem

Uoccuttlsme

casse

corl.

tt

TITAN

LINI{

FIOC



CnQc

tranh

lugn c6

v6 sOi

nbi

vd

hio

hring

gifia

phni,

TAm

linh

hoc

vA Th0ng

linlr

thuydt

lf,

rlhu

d

hting

rh*

uht{t

va

cd th8

dfiu

dlt

chung

ta

tl6u

nhfr'g

kham phfl

m'i

m6

nhdt

vb

cse

lrign

tugng

dbng

b6ng.

Thdi

gian

cOn

.hiBu

tlB

chring

tB

c6

iha

chiOrn

nguigm

rfi.g

cugc

tranh

lu&*

ily sE

dua

d6n

tllu

?

Ed

lI

dip

tI6 cho

tAc phhrn

niy

duo,c

bb

rkhuydt,

ru

cnlinn

ihOm

nhfrng

ph{t

nrinh

nr6i

rn6

nbdt

trong

dip t{i

bln

cac lln

s&u.

su cli6n

ri6n

c&a

cac

phAt

rninh

dv

sd

pluoc

bi0n

khfio

lrat

rbinh

f,v

sd

gluoc

bi0n

khfio phu

dlnh

vio

theo rhtli

gian

trrng

rrtriirrg kj

tdi

bsn

tira

tcrc

pbhrn

ndv

116

si&

bhrn

nAy

116

gi&

'lhrr

tAe

phhm

co

lttnh

cich mdi

m6

nhitt

vc thqli

sq

irhfir.

lrIIilN

Il/

elf;ru'ong

t

-

r$e

IRU&NG c0a

,

THU&r

vA rmuvfr

t(HoA

fi{rEil

rr&r.r

IHAN

Hl{tN

r{$e.

t

LCorr

l)enis

rnQt

f,nh

tu

cfrn

plr6.i

Chiin

trlii.:

Lrlrfip

,]inir

ntli"in

'l'lr0ng

linh

thuydt

: {

lUOt

khr:n

hc'g.

r:r}i

li

r

njrlr0,ng

rir"ii,

rln

cu tr0n

nhfrng

su

ki{n

vA

pirlp

elro

rra.

tu$rre

lri.,3n

:it

rrhiirig

dinh

tuAt

vi'h

cfrn

r,0

ti{n

b0

v;i cr)rrrl

l .

,

(ialriel

l)elanne

lsi

ndi:

(MOt

khoa hoc

er,)

,nrlr:

dirh

r:hrilr:

iriirrlr

lliuc

nghigm

vb sq

hign h&rr

cire

linh

hhn

vd

su

biir

tri'

crrn

nqi

nh,r

c6

phrrorrg-pirap

clli4u rriin

mir.griri

ta

r:lii

(hri'fi

rla

qoi

hiin

uhi?ng

k6 mri

churg

ta cho

ll rlf,

chci'.

r

lJcr:ri

llegnault rlinh

nglrin

tom

tir

: << l)ir

l{

su.

nshiFn_

r:rlu

cric

rlinh

luat

lr1 nbi0n

ssu

khi

clrdt

n

vri

Iiequnnli

lai

tii;r: r<lirn

s*o

rr8

cbfrrg

fa

cil

ttrO lrirlrr nhii,16 rrinh

lu r

il;r.

DiBrr

{v

cb

th6

bi6t

rlu.sc

nhcr

r.'rdc

<lbla

tu gii?a

ciii

t:r}

hiulr

vA

ch',1n9

la. n

Ddn

,lfiv

Regnault

ilbng

1r

vcri

trapr,s

nhi

hrrr-In

bi

hoc

ir

l'lrAp

hhi

0rrg

nay vi6t

trong

tdc-ph.l'n

<

scieirces occrrlirs

et

dc'scquilibre

mental

r

doan

sau

tl&'y

:

<

ulnh

ntru

hiOn

ney

nhitrrg

trd

hu5'Bn

bl

cing

duoc

ngud.i

to.

chu

j

r.hcr

nd'sd

nhiing

nguli

ungo

nh{u cbo

mtnh

cc li'h

tu6

vs,

tu

cho

lA

chiO,n

tinh

gia

xufit hign

mQt

cdctr

qrlA

suc

tu&ng

tucrng

r'd

rlAng

ti6c.

il0

'TIIi,N

LINII

}IOC

i

'fnual'

clllr:;u

rrt)n

il1



ta

tr-riy

r{t

ly

thu

dqr:

mQt

l{c

pbiiut

trgc

clrn

Ong

Robert

'for:-quet

nhf,u

ViQn

Ngiri0n-cim

Si0u

ffirn

linh

tludc-

gi6

hny

irr

di{u

fny

rA

c{c nhil xlo

tl:udt ndi

lnh

dn'r1i:

,lii,r

n:a

nhung

su

th{t

kh6ng

ptr[;.

DA

prrfln hidt

phtrn

ch0n

vfr

girl

trong

mQt

r"fin,il;i

ti

rhi.'l'ocrluet

df;

e6

c0ng

chring la

-r'ri'irg

th'i

doqrr

gian

trd

flv.

rfing

chup

khi

lrghiOu

crin

trinh

bily

vo'l

(il,6l

rry

nhi8n

hg

tl<-ri

tiln

bgc

vb

uhfrng

nfng

Lhi6u

dfic

t;

bi$t

nrA

I

hr2

qr.rfi

lquydt

lA mlnh

c6"

Song

ndu

tl4i

chf

rrg

nrd

ho truc

Lltli

nrQt

lcArh

tro

trEn

vb

sr1 md

tJn

nhu

thd

lti6t

mOt

lt

vb cdc

airlu

tuAt buybn

bt

hrlc

lht

t{t

hQ

sE

hi6u

r[ng

rheo

|ruybn

bi

lrr,ic

tflt ci

bira clni

dem

b0n

kh0ng

c6

git tri

gi

pd|

vr\

chrr

ptirli A6c.biQt

k$d.g

n0.'

tin

trr&ng gt trdt rb

cdc

116 c

buor.r ihdnlt,

bfn

thln

r,

tfft

cA

lr+ng

blp

b'Jm

mr\

bi6i

bao

rrhi0u

bco

chl

df;

qufrng

c{o

trin

rn{t

ir6o.

tl6

nhiln5t

logi

qulnfi

c6o

nhcv

bhn

rnA tn

chn

phfri

gqt b6'

>

Kboe

hon

vB

rlrien hbn

thu$t

'tA

nrrlt

khoa

hgc

l$u

ddi'vd

ifldtng

din

song

qirng

c6

nhfrng

tt[:

trtrc loi

cling.

nhu

rnoi

t]in

5rt

hti:ic

cliirrgltn

fhdy

cd

nh{i:n6

larig

}ritm

6h*

h6n trhirng

k6 tlitng

r frn,

rinitr

I

dao

si

gi6

danh

rtri

nhfrng

tigo-si

'loeqr:et

rli-r

lrinh

biy

ti$u srl

cira

25

rlbng

tfr qndc

{6 co durlr t'4rrq

rrlrung

k6t

ln{n

6ng

chl ertng

nhfiu

c6

5

rlilr,g

lfr

r1nd,:

r(i

cdr

thb xem

ubu

kh0ng

lua bip

mi cfc

ctrtir lhi

tt1::rr$p1 1{5

duo; h 6*

so.{t

chfit

etr€.

Dri

l]

clbng

t;

1lp'rnpin

I'ailuilirlrr,

Grzik.lenn,

lIome

(Danirtr

I)uglns)

Ii uski

(Irr'lrr

k)

','ii

l-icirejrier' (llndi),

VS

hi{rr'.

tncrrtq

qd

bin

l'ocquet

cho riir:A

phrrcng

ph{p

{l[

trirrh

srr

fiian

lAn

hrdu qui

nhfit la nirn lfiv

hei tnv

dtlnf,

tr? r,lro chirc.

'l'ocquet

cd

,

cho

hay

nhi6u

rlbng

tir

nlrtr

Valiee.

Alireitine

vii Staneslawn

bi tr{c

si Osty

biit

qnfi

tnn6

durrg tay

d8 tqo

r8r

hiQn

turlng.

thtt srt,

v.Y.," D

I

'Yb

rli0m

nf,j' chilug

ct'n

giA

tri vb

tfrm

linh

vi0rr

ban r:hiip

h,lnh

cira

rd

t

t'lr$.p

(1),

I

'f

rong

lfir:

p}hm rrfiy

'fotrquet

d[

dung

trdn

quan

tliFrn

cfin

mfit

ltiiur

lintr

troc

gi&

d&

trtritr

b$ry cfc

rnd'nh

16i vb

su

lu&

irip ciia

cic

k6

ru{nh

darrir

lil

ttbng tfr,

d?o

si

hay

hA e6

liuh

tu$. Ntr&ng

nhfn

xdt

cirn

6ng

rdt

bb

ich

cho

rrhiing

j

ai

mudn

ngh:dn

ctu

rE

th6'g

linh

thu5tlt

(hay

'l'hln

linhi

hq:

ho{c

chi€u

hbn

thu$t)

vl

CIng

vqch

trhn c6c

ru{nh

ltUoe

c&a

c{c

tlbng

tfr

'16

nns

hiQn

hbn

lray

lAm

inh

$eng

&

ngay

trong

phdng

thi

rrghiQm

hoflc

(D

,.(*

Tr:ut

ji'occultlrme

ddvoil6.

(Anlot

Dumont

xufit

binl'

Vh

iii4n

rirn14

i,gmili

c6

hni

lti'p

bfrngi

deu

Sii.

Ngu;,i

phique

v*.

ch& hifn

V*

hr$'.-

tuong

dnh

linh

(dbng lfr

Valentine

Dbng

fri

t),Erro

bi

s6ug

c0

th8 dirng dhu cri ch{t

lAn

bi

De

Rochas ilit

qufi

lang).

bAc

si

Geley

l{t

thy

vl

d[ dirng

tr'ouq

vi'5t

ehfr tr6n

l7lni4

den

Tnrrluei

eho

tn

c,; thft

I'hn

bip

bfi.ng

c{eh

rir}ng

birig

rlen

i'il

Oniq t.a cho

rfrng

dbng

tfr

c6

th6

tlila

loqi

ih'\t

r:lio

ta

ki8ur

soit

vA

gifiu

logi blng tlen

la

tilng

c6

th&

vidt

trudc

bfing

hut

chi lithogra-

lrfl'rdyi

la

d&ng

hL[n

crl

thilm phfin

d( '

chti

thl

t€,r

(diirrg

tir.

Slsde

de bi lAt

tiit).

ttz

THhN

LINfl

IIOC

I

Tnuar

cHrEu

HoN

r13



mOt

mfinh

sfit

(ferro

cdriurrt)

vS

tuQt

gdi th6p

dB

lqo

ra

bi$n

lu:ung

ilr-rh

sf,ng.

r.

t-lc

tla rrqhi cdrlfi

lA

urOt

tli8u

hay

soir{{

hh0ng

tt0n

th{i

quir,

C4

dd}i hhi

s$

phfr

n}if,rr

cira

Oug

kirfirill

c6

cdp

cdr rrhtt

kili

phS

binh

db6g

tr? I\Irl'er

dutri

sr.{'

thi

lghi0ur

ctio [)e'tanne, De*is

yir

De

Vi:sme

(t)

Ong

hlr0uq

rlln

bhnpl

chrinrSi

ldo

dAn rnit

dtittg

tfr chn,hlQn

hiin

rna?

Ong

rd

rAng

lA

t0n

Blaise

gil

lfiy

hbn

da

tr?o lA rlbng

libn

bi

nhdm

cfr

to4

cria

ruot

trgn

phfii

chgy

bin

ta

thi{y

su

hia

bip

vdn

cria

mQt

.

sd ngucri

nhim

Ngoii

ra

e6

hai

qnh

William

(lBlt

-

1877)

gdc'

(l)

Ili6n

tugog

&

Mantes

vA

nhibu ngudi

c6ng

nhsn

:

vfiy chfin gii

l6u l6n.

nhau.

mqo

lino

hbn

ma.

Hai

Ong

nlm

lr?

gii

mqo

lim

hbn

Ee,

thi

IhIn

tinh

hgc

do

ra

dlnh

cho

sdng

b{n

ch6t.

Nhu

vAy

cbring

c6

vi

thAi

dO

tin

tu&ng mir

quAng

mflt tin

c&n

(i)

sai

llm li

bao.

em

Davenport

Jra (1S39-1911)

vl

nguli

Hoa

;K],

cfing .bip

l&n.

trong

phhn

II

tli

iiuqe

ttl

cip tlCn

Rione

d

dny

lai

.ndi

Blaise bip.

Nhu

cho

i16

1.1 4i

trrfrrig"tugrtfi

dn

t+o

ra

ul:fi:regl hintr &nh

(imaqina',if

I

irl'erprelantrl)

rntc

dSu

, iiirB

i

tfr t{rller

tlii

rltrcrc

r:,ii

do qit tr

v. ,

nrilt:

vdo

rnot

b,.l

dii

r.i{ng

r:ira'.cAr: trird

r:l:ri8n

rb.r tfin0t

strn

ra.

l

ll'otquet

lcon

eho

rfrn;l

dii,ri4

tft'

cir thd

trtr{5t

r:,1r:

db

"rf,o

trong

lrrrng'

rlii

rrrin

r i"

(")

rg

ii?i

lri

"trbn;;

tfr

rt0n

(

ryii:clin

ur re

;urilitnteur)'

Trong

sS nhfrng

ttbng

rfr bi

I{t

.rhy,

chrtng

ra

rhdy

rfit nhibu

:,

La

mfi

1863

&

hoi

r&

1890 bip,

chu

bdc

Irt0t

chuygn

kh6;

bubn

cuiri

kh0ng

k6rn

cAu

chuyQf

&

I\fantes

lt

6ng

Volckman

phAi

vi0n cfia

hQi

e Socidrp

-.

I t

--

-

dialectique n

& LuAn

ddn

chuy0n

n6n

dibu trr vb

'vdn

dE

ttr[n linh.

Ngdy

9-12-1873

Ong

uhAy xb

vio

ltc

hbn

Katib

hign

l6n,

Om

lfir

Katie

vi coD

nna

n&y

gif,y giua

chqy

{Ao

pbr}ng.

trong hic

liai

ngu&i

xem

nhly

ra

ch{n

6ng vA

hu ilfi vcri

6ng Ltc

dy

ddn

tit.

Cu6i

cfing

hto

,

b{t

den

I6n

thi

Florence

Coot<

vdn nHm

trong

phOng

tht

nghiQm.

ViQr':

ntv c6

lnh

hu&ng

:hhOng

t6t rldn

roAn

th0

cAc

cuoe

thl

nghiQm

cfia

W.

Crookes

ddi

v6i

F.

C.

Vi du

dbng

lr?

Caraciui (Francesao)

sinh

&

bi

Durville

l{t

thy

trong

c6c

cuQc

thl

nghifm

di6n

PhAp 1913,

Ellng

tix

Cazzepa (Linda).

f,

sinh

bi

bAc

si

Imode

l{t

thy.

Ebng

rr} nty

I df, y6u

si Imoda

thl nghiQrn

trong

b6ng

t6i.

i

CA

bi0:nr b[n

24-2-Ill2?

th{ rrghi$rn

vr'ri

dhrrg

lfr

Evner

Ni"l*.n";A

{ltnistania

ttu'rcrd

kiftrr*

snrtl

k}

rttim

auduJl

lton$,

r4ni,

tai,

nrft

r..d

m{c

:io

quftrr

citn

nllii:nfi

rlit&

nghidn

"1"o,

CIug

'r,dn

ktr6rrg

tin

iA

chn ct?

vig

l;lifi

l)rt:rdt

<

r{iiLrg

tir

nOn

n

r"Uill4p

lufn.

Ong

bho

ritng cdr

fluo,:r

*hi

nqhit,rn

cila

b{c

si

trnrceia

I'oi

tlhng

tf{

Bva

C.

';A

l.inda

Aazze:,n

tr]r0ng

co

FiA

tr , mfic

dhu

lap

lu$n ctra

rirrg

hh0ng

elrinh xAc.

I

nt'lt

riqil bubn

crrtri

nhdt

ld

cbiivd,r

'{ii'rg

tfr

F-tirlise

6

Itltarites

(t)irn{; cho

hi$n

[rbre

ct]

ma

Made?eine

vdo

ndm

192+ H6i t{rn

linh

hQc

qn[ie td c;:

prr6i

'rgt

nhi].*

viCIn

lF,

dng

Charl$s

euartier

ddit

drl

ki6,r vA

rirng

rJi

vni *0t

nhi

ir*o

lA

0trg

tNlasson

binh

tft tcr

Jout'nal'

tlai

Ong

rlf, th{y

',:*

1l+

rsl,n LrNE

Hoc"

t,

THUAT

CHIEU

HON

:

r.

l','.;

. ;':'

iJ

.

.

;..i

,,

,:,"1.:.

:,h

-

.,r'i

,

,

":.ti

i^.



.i

rd

rAng lA

&

Mabtes lA

6ng

V

Ngodi

ra

c6

,hgi

1

William

(1841

-

0,s77)

""1.'H

,

. ,

r.l,l

r:ri;lr.'i

,.,.;.'.

.,.11,

pt

jminh

s{t,lferro

cdriurn)

vir

mQt

g6i

r:^- i..------- r'-L

I

-r--

l

:

hipn.i'tuqrng

{nh

sAng.

(1)

Xem

Arinales

thdp

tl6

l$o

#,

Ir&

ri

jdrau

c

da

nghi

ciiug lA

{0t

<liBo hay

song

khOng

'nOn

iqoa.

Cr]

dOi

hhi

str

I

phir

nh{n

cha 6ug

khdr:g c6

iBo hay

song

khOng

'nOn

thii

i

libn

b nh6m

cr?

to4

cfra

rhlni

il;

he;;orll

a]on

.uo

mot

tr{n

phii

ehqy bli,u

sdng

,

ben

cn6i.

Nhu

v{y

chtng

ta

thfiy

sr.r,

hia bip

v6n po

il,

thAi

dQlhnrg&ng

m,f

queng

'cria

mqt.sd

nguli

nhim'm[t]tinrqi,t

(]l

saf

[m

n

bao.

'frong

sd nhiing

.ttbng

tr?,bir

I{t

lthy-

chrtng

ra

rh{y

rfit

nhiBu

:,

''

"

'

|

'

"

'

'

'

i

i'

Vi du

dbng

tir'

Carasini (Francesco)

sinh.&

l-"

mE lg68

bi

Durville

l{t

thy'

trong

clc

cu6c

thl

nghifm

&

hQi rft

di8n PhAp

1913.

Eltng

ttt.:Cazzeie.(Lindai

Y, sinh.1g90

btp,

r

rlng ll-

rOn

Blaisc

gil

mgo llm

hbn

ma.

Hai

Ong nfim

lfiy

hbn

da

tric lA ttbnq

tfi.

Bii

meo ttrn

.

hhn

-o

rhl

,dBng

trri

gii

mso lltm.nbn

Et, thi

bi b6.c

si Imodr

lflt

tby."Eb"ng.',tft':.nlj,. '

r

Dac

sl

lmod&

tf,t

tAy.

Dd.ng

t&_

nly,.l

dfi you

chu.

b6o

si Imoda

tht.nghiQm

trbng

bgogt161.'.:i,.:,i

',

,

i

----

1-.-'

;-

lr

c[h

cri

nhu

tkirl

phe

blnh dbng

tfr

Mil'er

ducri sq

thi

nghi{m

cfin

delanne,

Deni.s

vi

De Vesrne

(l)

Ong

kbOng

dfrn

bflng

chitng

'po

dflu mi

dbng tfr

cho,hiQn

hbn

ma?

cho atd

li

,6c,

tu&ng'

tuqDg

de

t+o

rn

nh&ng

hlnh

(imaginatifs

injlerprdtantd)

milc

dhu

<tbng

,tr?

Mrller

tlfl

cdi {o

qu}n

;vA

m{r:

vto

InQt

b}

dD

ri€ng cira'

c{c

chi0u hbn

thu$t

slm

ra.

Tocquet

bon

cho

r&ng tliing tfr

cd

th6

uudt

c{c db,

vio

troog bung'rbi rr0n re, 0"g

gqi

lA

nlbng

tfr nOn

(m€diu

nr

rcSurgitatgul),

CA

bi6n

bln

24-2-1922 tbi

nghiQrn

voi

ttbug tfr

Evner

'

NielsenivA Ohristania

tluoc

ki6no

so{t

k} nbm

oudng hoog,

ririii, tai, mfit

vA'

m6c

Ao

quiln cria nhiing nhll

ughi€n

':

cnu, Ong

vfrp khdng

tin

vA

c[n cu vAo

6qi6

thuydt

< t{6ng

,

tfr ndn

r rbi

Bp

tudn. Ong

gho rXng

cAc c,u0;

thi nghiQm

cf,a

bAc

si

lmoda

voi

dbng

tfr

Eva

C. vA Linda

Cazzeta khdng

c6

6i{

tri,

mlc

'dhu

lap lu$n ctra

r)ug hhOng

*chlnh

xAc.

,l

NIQI viQ;j

bubn cutri. nbfit

'ld

chny$n

dbng

tfr'

tstaise 6'

Mantes

(Phap)

cho

hiQn

hbn

c0

ma

Madeleine

vAo

nirn

L922.

HQi t6.rn linh

hec

qudc

t6

c6

plrAi

'mQt

nhiln

viOn

lA

Ong

Oharles

Quartier

ddn

dF ki6,r vA

cirng

tti vdi rnQt

nh&

b{o li 6ng

Massou

binh btt'

ld

Journal.

Hai Ong

dfl

thdy

oog

&nh

tluoc

rrhA

':""tt

.,Yf

]6

,

fufl:

1';"'

'

I

,

i

o

r..

:

,

,.,

j-

'-:r

'i,J:'

MQt

phuyQn

khlc

bubn

pu&i

,

Lh0nc' l

budn

pq&i

,

Lh0ng

,

L6m

'dAu

olckmau'

.phdi;

.vien.:i.tre

nQi

;

vi0nl,cfrr

hQi r

Soci6tp

,

m

'dau'i

cuuy$i,

',,,'1,,i..,'(

|,:r:;..:

.

.'-'.

:

qnh

eq

Davenporl

Jra (1839-1911)

rA

gf,ol

pgudi

oq

;Kf,

cfing

lpip

ldn.

,:

troug

phln,ll

lQa

,fuge

tll

ofp

rtCn

Rileg

n

qur'lsi'

,ndt

Bt3tse

bfp,,

Nhu

'dialectique

u'

&, LuAn

it6n'chuy0n

biiq..aiCu

tre vb

'viln

dts

thhn

linh.

Ngdy

9-12:1873'Ong-nhly:xb

rvlo

1ic

bbn

Katie

hign

l€n,

0m

ldy

Ketie

vi

con

ma

nAy

gifiy

giqa

cbgy

vAo

pbdng,

trbng,ltc

hai

ngudi

,xem

nhfiy ra

ch{n

6ng

vA.

hq

d[

vcri

Oug lrtg'Cy

deg

tA .:

,.Cugi

l

ctqg

ltio

b{t ddn

l€n thi

Florencg

Cook.rvdg

.ufim'

qrong

ph0ng

tht

nghiQm.

Vige nly

c6

:lnh

hu&ng

ihOog

t6t dCn

rotn

.th8

cAc

'cuQe

thl

ngbiQm

qfia

W.

Crpotes

a6i

v0i

'

F.

C.

des

Sciencos

psychlqyes

thing

;

(l)

Hi6n tugDg

&

Mentps

vA

nhilu

ugudi c6ng

nhfn:

vay

chAn giA

lin

lgu

..nhau;

lr

:.,

114

TI]AN LINI{

IIOC

THUTIT

CIIIEU

IIdN

t5



.Ebng

tfr

illdred

(Charles)

ngu<)i

Anh,

bi bAc

si

Abraham

Waltace

t{t

tly,

ttbng

tfr

Erto

(Pasquale)

ngu&i

Y bi

bAc

si

Willihm

l'lnckeasie

lQt m{t

nqr.

Dting

trl

Bsl;6rattce

( d'lltisabettr)

rri{t

1 }19 c6

hhi

bip

hhi

khOug.

cd

khi

khting,

oAc hiQn

turnrg co

kbi

tlfng

c6

DDng

tfr

liurnpia

Paliatlinn

(l8il

'*

l91S) nrQt

<lbng

tr?

rlrro-c

nlribu

hq.c

giC[

nghi6n

cuu

Irhilt

vlt

c0rrg

nhin

giA

tri

cAo

hiPn

l*gttg

Dbrlg

ru

i

Sla.te

bi

,gido

su llay

kr0n

lil' bip

bgm

&

Lttfitt

,1Ertt.

IB{c

si

0$'y

lSt

rhy

dhrrg

tti' \.*it6e

1927. hltlt

trong

rAe

cltirrg

tr?

du*h

ti6ng

nhttt

ld

tlbng

tir

D.

D.

llome

ve

Franbk

lrolclL.Jrore

mot

tny

rliii

t$p

r:u

ktrOi

*hdng lgi

cf;c

bi{u

tucrDg

vb

dbrrg

bdng

nhfit

tldnh

phfii

hing

iihrlc"

Poldmot'e

riii rlum

vi6t

L,

I

'filt

r,{

vdn

db

ttrhrr

liirh

hoc

co

t56

qui

ru

ncli

rlbirg

tti'

D.

t).

llome

(tin

l)'

D llome,

je

l'6sume

--

a,

tolrla

ln

rlue$litltr

tltt

sprrilisnre')

Nnn'ng

rrlii4u

iriln

tlu-gc hiirn

J

oe

qt1

41

thhp

hhoa

Si€tr

l'll

,n

i

stl

g an

ddi

trong

lTnh

rhfr{t c6

th{t

slrng

nhii'ug

sp{t

clr6t

t:trE

ldn

cd.

cillng

rrir6n

cdc

cOng

trlub

ir5-rc

ciia

br{c

si

0stY

vA

li

rlh

rluiic

16,

l,rc

tlri

n,qhiQm

v0

biirr{

chung

cLr

th0

rrghi&n

curt

c6

phucrnn

fdrl

si Geley

tai

'o'iPrr

lirr0r

lhJ nghiQnn

vcri

rlbng

tir

Grtzih

('lean)

t'?i

t

NI

v<vi

bAc si

(ielry rbi

bAc

si

OstY.

.

T-hi-ngldim

5-&-1926,-

Khi''Guzik & trong tr4ng

thAi

l0n dtiirg

tui

tOi

co

cfiur

giAc

vai bOn

tay milt vi

cfnh

lay

tr0n m{t

uhu

c6 mQt biln tay

d6n

sd

m6

v&o.

Ngudi

ta nghe

nhilng bn'oc

chAn di

trrhia

sau tOi, vA

tOi

c6

c&m

trr&ng

r:;r

hat

b:In

lrty drlg l6c

hai

vai

tOi.

Mqt

*lnh

sdrirg

rlqp

va

lo'n bny

trOn tI[u

Guzik vA c6

v6 cao.

Anh

elr-r6;

iiy lray tt] tir vE

phin

t0i vA bny

d6n

trurrc rnqlt

l0i.

'f4i

nbin

lltr,{y rrrQt nii'a thAn

}rlnh m+t

frguoi

q{rirg

gfin

nhu

diinr

sinb.

Itiii

ba hinb

m{t

ngnui ktrrlc hiQrr

l0rr

riiu

r-rhtr

cd

phfi

khiin.

tlai khuOn

m{t

ddu

6ng. vi

nrQi

hhutiri

rnllt dan be.

rltgt

trorig

ha

hluh

c6

vt

imr

i{ng

vA-d,Im

ciu.0u. Hai hirrir

khic ttri ntii

vA

Orn

lfly

tli truuc h[i

tfrt deu.

MQt

trong

nlrfrug

k6

vd

hinir

nui

r'$i

ltri

mA

idi kh$ng Lri6u.

frong

hio 116

tOi cd cfrru

tu&ng

cb

m0t

brin

tay

st)

vAo

trAn

t6i

vA

t$i vfirr

ch[un

cieu

uhin

cl6n ir."ng rnn hiQu

l6n. Tdi

thfiy

nhu

khuSn

ruirt

rn0t

rr;,4urri

rrr:\

Arrir

sdng hi0rr l0n rnr

[o

nhrr cic

col

dom

rloru"

liSrg do ti6n ddn

0m vA

hdn

toi

>.

(jLlrrn

rlilirn crila

tLrhn

linh troc lfi. cho

rfrnq

minh

cri su

lr:giih

r:ltiltng

t6

su trirt

tir cia

liuh hbn, ttibn

rnir

tdn

gi; u

,-:hi,lua

ra

c# l<)ng tin.

'l'trfiu

lirrtr

iroc

cito

rirng *ugc

tiiSrr

hrla c&a

nhfinicai

.l:i

{i0rr rnQt

Eii:ti

doan

rrrril

khoa

troc

dang li\nr

,*[rir

ti.

$trnfirr cl.ro

rrtr*lrr

ittqi tr&

vb oon riutrug

d4o

clrrc

vA ltrrr

lirrh irhorrg

th3

ctri rtirng

y

tlmydt

tuv0n

truyiirr sudrrii

erl;'

ngrrf"ri

trl

{:o

thb

tiu

trrr}ng

rluqc.

t-}5

d6n

hic rrgudi

ta

rkti

chung

crr,

rldi su

kiQn

r:u

th€. I'h&n

hnh hoc

tbly

riing

hrc ihuydt

ctia

mi::h cb

tLrrS

tiln tqi

cluoc

vA hqrp

viyi rihu

cfiu

hi$n

lai

vi cln cir

tr6n

t'cuc

nghiQm

ctra

110 TrriN

LrNr{

rrQc



kdoa

hoc

mlnh

hoc

vl

16

ily

thlrr

llnh

li

hail

m{t

cria

rnQt

v{n

le

khoa

hgc tinh

thhrr

vi

tlI

vu

linh

bft

hb

c0ng

D6

vA

-su

bf,t

tth

cirn

linh lrbn.

Nhftng

nhAn xCt

&

chuong

tru:6c

'dii

cho

chung

ta

thf;y riing

l{R

tru}ng

cira

Thlu

linh

:gc

cd tlrrh

cdeh

n

dung

hoi vii

tbng

hgp ktroa hrlc

vA tOnigi{o,

lqi bi cl

khoa hoc

tfrn tOn

gifro dbu

ctng

nhnn

nh?ii toat

rtl

kich

ll chu'ng

nio I

Etng

&

gita

hai

th{i cgc

< tdn

giAo

b$t

ktrl

tri

tn$n

bft

kbfr

tu

nghi

n

ctng khoa

boc

tnyQt ddi,

tu

cao

Iroc

.

xem

tOn

gi{o

vi khoarr'

rlt

clbng

nhdt

qi

tu

chg

hay

khoa hoc

tAno

linh.

ctng khoa

boc

tnyQt ddi, tu cao

dli, thtn

linh

hgc

lhfiy kb6

khltn

dA

lim trdn

nhi$m

vi ly

lu'&ug

cfia rnlnh.

Tb0m nfia

troc

thuy6t th[n

cfing

chi

tlugc mQt

,

s6 mdn

db

+

cAc

nutlc

Au

My

nhin

mA

thoi.

l'hln

linh

hoc cho r*.ng

mluh

ktrOng

chtSng

lqi Thidn

chua

gido

i

cring

theo

gifo diEu

cira

du'c

Chrla

nhu'ng

thRn

linh hQs

lqi

cOng

ntr{n

r:o

lu4t

luin

hbi,

nhfi.n

qui

li hai

lu{rt

chfnh cira

PhSt

giAo

tr:ong

khi

dO

tlii

thhtr

linh

iroc

dttot

xenr nhu rnQt

b'|

ph&n

cfin

tinh

thln

hoa

(spiritualisnire)

vA

Tinh thhn

hoc

c$n6

uh{n co

Thugng

otruons

n.--

NHiiNG

5U NGuY nrtrEr

vt

cHrFu

H6n

rHu[r. chnr sAruu eb

rni

riru

o1

EoAN

l{hoa

chi0u

hbn nguy bi8m

&

ch5

ln

dbng

tfr c6

th6

ni

zm

finh

nrflc

b$ntr

rlidrr

cuiing

(t0

khi

diing tt?

bi

ma

utr{p).

Ddri

vOi eAc hi$n fu'ong ma

hi6n

hbn,

tbiln

xdc

vil

tinh

tlrhn

dilnp4

tri'

r:qi

thb

bi

'h€rs

r:rirn

kipl

qu6 ciing

drra

4l

.(:rl

rdi

lonu

{llru

thli

n.

C

ir&n

[a nhibu

tl6ng

tfr

sdng

vb

dbng

h6ng

tuy khr.]rrg

ur}c

hdnh

<

cnblg

tlir

r

<

iing

tlug

D,

c

gAn

budng

> tu'c

Li

.mdt

chirng

b$nl-r

nira

m0

nirn

tirrh.

Phhn l&n

phli

nf5ng

ruou vl siuh

luc

bi

milt

l'fit

ion.

Diii vdn

r14o

Cao

tlfii su

tuybrr

hlea

clbng tfr

rilt

ky

vl

chi

c0 cfic tin

rlb

trr.rCrng

trai

nrdi

cd th$

ti? p

di6n

cirn

t /rc

cdi

c&o thhn

ti0n"

Cir*ng

la

chua c6

m(it

su

tliiiu

tra vB tb6ng

kd hgu db xem

ii

l+

rflbn6,

lfr

alen

loqn lroug ngsntr

tlbng

b6ng

l[

beo

:r[ridn

?

L'rolrg

mQt

tdc

phii

na

eira

nhit v[n hio

Phdp

'Tean

[-oujs

[inillaume,

nhan

qlb

<

Les entretiens

de Montparna*se

t'

rlE

ndi ddn nhfrng

su

ngtry hi$m

cira chi4u

hbn

thtr{t

vl

su

HiO

tin

rli

doln

qua d0 cfra

nhilng

kA

theo

ldi

nly vi

c6ng

ktch

th$m

te

mQt h4ng

khAc

hoin

todn

kh0ng

tin tu&ng.



20

THiN

LINII

IIOC

m{t

btn tay

fnAo d0

mbm

mlnh

vA

blt

h[

rfl

th6

rbi

XTTUAT

CI{IEI]

II6N

vAng

bqc

l2l



anh

ndi.

Tr.{g

hie

ua.y

anh

vfin

tinh

trt

kh0ng

bi

'rd

rAn

toin.

Aph

n,ji

chnyQir

v&i gia

dl.nh

116

chdt

mi

auh

ld

hbn

r]fiutri

crr6t.

snu

cung

anh

doi ptr*i

d6t

cho

tr:h

lnQt

cAi

lhrr

cAu

vl

auh

rnudn

cf,rr

c{...

Bo4n

nnh

ifl"

bi

hai

_

h[n

tay

xd

viri

xudug

.dfit

vA

bfly

git]

xitc

d?ing

d,

nh& ra. r

.

Tmng

hf{ri

ruqng

n*y

hnh

T.

V.

e.

kirOng

bi

triin

k6

chiit ehi yrhtJi

hoAn

'sn

rrghia

r,i

rrhy

cai

prrdrh

anrr

rn

t.r6

nh6p

vAo

xdc.

song

ehi frnh

hurlng

rl{n

rh0 phdch

v,

via

tio

anh

ri6

tifit

anrr phfri

[]6i

ther.r

t *ria

rro

(trr*ir

rhr're

glrr

.rili*g

nhq

khoa

thr)i

rni€n.

6'

d{;;,

arrlr

.t,.

V_

e.

hi

h6

{,r, r

.r,rr_r*f{

ro'l

knoa

th0i

mi€n.

0'

tl{;;,

arrlr

.t'.

V_

e.

}ri

h6

.rr)

hinh

tfr0i

yri6n),

Vi

t6

fiv anh

darrg

cdn

&

r,:onfi

Itrng

fhAi

i'n

etrfi rluelr:

thA nh{eh rr/trr ,,A. ri*r. *ei

luerr:

tLrA

ptr*gh

n6rr

vfin

iinh

trr.

Antr

khOrlg

bi{t:

ngutri

eh6t

rdc

{ruon

thicrr

rri

ofln

,,fiv

nrl

'auh

nfii

rh rrio

sHm

chu cau.

,

6

l.rr nhi*n

,rru.r,i

nhd

snir

buiij

phi6u

h6n

nay

sE

*"* ;,r*

"Or"onu""li*

ifiy

dr\

rndt.

Ngurli

chdt

theo

h*ybn

bl

hoc

rfin

bi

dm

{n[r

hd,i

nlrling

hinh

inh

hlc

cdn

siuh

tibn,

v)

vSy trong

trr

tu&ug

ho

rnudd

nAo

l[

nhA

lhu,

xe

hoi,

vq, .lqp,

tiBr;

cfis,

dii

choi,

{o quiln,

Xrr

u6nf,

vi

n6n

nhip

;;;

aAog'

.Ot

la

hp doi

nh[ 'ug

vf,r fi1.

ri

ddy'k6

arr6t

.h&

d6n

c6i

i'hn

ch*

thst

ra

trdng

c6i

vrj

hlnh'rnQt

c6i l&m

bilng

rrr

ru,&'g

v{

rung

dgng

tht

cAc

db

gifiy tlAu

c6

drtng <tutrc

?

Vi

quan

nigrn

sni

l[rn

cfia

ngudi

ch6t.

&

cOi

trung

6i6i

(mQt

cdi

tlang

eOn

vb

rninh

chua

eluoc

sAng

su6t

nOn

moi

x6y

ra

mdy

chuy{n

bubo

cucri

uhrr

trOn.)

CO ngu&i

clu

co,

hbn

ma y€u

chu

cho

tibn

ti0u.

..----.,-,.t.,-

Ngudi

tn ddt

'*"ing

b+: clro

y.

Ngucri

ddt

clc

c&

cdt

(ti

vii

t& khOng

ddt

tht

hbn

ma

lOn

c{j

blo

(:('

gi(u.

mot s6

khong il6t.

0.

aay

khOng

phfri

ngrrrll

dd

nhan

dutrc

tibn,

ti*n al6m

thi6u

mi

doi,

song

hbn nra

th?[y

tlucrc

tu tu[ing

ngudi

s6ng,

nCn

bi6[

arth

kin

d[

chui

hh[rn

mirr]r

mfi

hh0ng

ddt dir

sd

tihn.

2)

Ei6rn thtir hai cirs

tai hai

d6ng

b$ng

IA

nguo'i

ta

vi

.inO

liu

t16n

t[r{r-rh

tbhn

quA rlQ rni tIB

cho

cAc

cOn

dhng

lArn

ngilB

hrdrn

dn hip

ltr1,11

:nOt

eAch

trfl.ng

trgn.'Chring

lrt xi.rng

a,,)

e$u dA

dr\i

niri

16

qny

16 no,

noi

nhiin&

k6

r'irlln

xin

xr."r

t}

cdc

'rniOu

aln, Clrtln6

I6n

girl nrao.

I,dr:

riro

lrlriin biel

c[nr"o'c

chiln

fii4

khi ngu]i

la

ctri

nltf.tn

nr,{t

tiri

r-{n"

{)lrrirrq liri

l}i6t

cu

-rthfrnq

con dbrrg

rlfi tu

'thrl

irr

l/lur

su'

viii

cbung

tOi

lA

c6

kiri

ho lOn

gii.

Nbu

v$y

riii

;nr{t

fi.bn,

{Cin'

c0ng

r.rr.&

chi

duoc

chin

nudro

lf,

tl\n

nhar:g

ndug,f

ii.o

*6 th6

ch6t

tXrrcrc, nhfit

lA nhfrng

tr{nh

mt

Y

si biro

i<i0n6

cft

uu:ivc lanh.

Su

tin

tu&np;

rl

nlrr

miin

vb

rrrQf vai

churg

bpnh

nhu

rli6n

loqn

rrd ir{rrtri

fa

cho

lfi

tfr

rnnhiit

chn

phAi

ph&n

biQt thlnh

xfic.

tl$nh

diOtr loan

do

thhn kinh

liQ,

6c n5o

l-li hrt ho{c'

do

nhftng

chlrug

bQnh

l'^hfin lirm

ra nhn

throng

hAn,

cire

b$rrh

/hon

li6n,

cfe

vi

tritng

cfra

cric bQnh

& nu<rc dQc. Ndu

htr/

rli*n logn

ta dem

b$nh d6n am

rui6u

d8 lo

,'chu

r{do

uri

[hOng

[o

thudc

men

thl ch&ng

nhfrng

cou

'bQnh

cO

thb

d,i d{n

cAi

cb6t

chHc

chHn

'*rA

ta

ndn milt

c0ng

cria

nnQt

c{ch

v6

icLr.

Dibu

chn thi6t Ie

dern d6n

y

si dB xin

thusc men

dibu

tri.

Chi

khi

nilo

y

si

bd tay ta mdi

cln

ddn

th{nh

thln.

P6ll diEs

trinh

cbo

nbiing

cAi

chdt

vi

m0 tln

di

doan

ml

ra.

122

Yi€c

ou[o,

bi.

tA

bit

c6

thflt song lil

THiN

LINII

IIOC

tru<rrrg

hop

hidm

.THUA.T

CIIIEU

HdN

<

bi6t

rXng

123



cd.

Sau

<Idy lA

bi

l:i

biit.

L

lrri

crja

nrgt

hdc

si ndi

vb hiQn

tuong

k6

.,. Sau ktri

crir

mQt

ddn

Srrr

duh

kA

bi diAn lngn dtr

li6

chCIt

lgo

rn, chn

ph&i

tlm

mei

lh&

diEu

il.y cdr

rlring

hay

lA

sai,

tir"oritj.

lq'c hay

thdn

linh nAo

lui:

dy do

kE

s$r:g hay

phuong

ph*,p rlt

xem

th{t lray

li

trr6ng

Bdc si

dhvor-rd

Worcester,

ngrtr-ri

l{oa-kj'

rIfi

tirng

o0'rg

tAc

voi

b{c

si

Hys.lop.

clrii

tieh

hoi

u.4bi6u-crtu

'l]rlin-hnh

Itl

vA

tr$r

si

Titus

Iieil

gi:im-il6r

'l'fr

nr

y

hr.rc

(psyctriSlrie)

&

Nilu*U'6'c, dii

ltir,8 ririia

nhibu

b]nh

ctiBrr

loatt

md

cdr:

bic-si

&

irhrl

tirurrng

clln

h.llfing

chiia

tlrrg'e

vA

cou rii'rg

bi

nlriing

lus cii'rl

t,iit

v0

triiulr

firn

firrh.

San

risy

il} ltli

b,{.c

si

Wnrcesler

:

(

't'0i

lhiiv

rilng

s:rrr

ia

rnuoi

rilm hirrh

r:giri0ln'ulfi

d6n

hjro

t6i

tu5dri-h$ vb

nlrii'ng

srr

rhi?a

lirnlt

bf;irh

do su

phdi

trQp cAt

phuorng

phdn

tfir,:-l$

;';lr{n

tteh

(psycho-annlxtique)

v*

tiuh-tl"rhu

(s;rrriinel r:).

'

t

((

.."

.caur

rnlrd'i n[Ln chdng

ddi

vcri gifi

thu16t cho

rlng'

s/r

trudrrrg

lr'-'l]

b$nh tlidn

lo4n do ciii'

vd

hinh

6m rlnlt

*

vt

aii

thu'ii:f

uiy iroin

toAn

phtrn

khoa-hoc

atdi

v6'i tu

trr'&ng vd

c'*ic

eu0c

nphi0n-criu

khoa hec cfia

t6i,

sorig,

litron hoe

I'dli

budc

phii

qdng

nhAn

eAe

hXng

c&

quA

nhibu

vd

cudi

cir,rfi

tOi rtAnh

phrii

lhfi

nh{n

ld tdi

khOng

th8

n:)o

bAe

h6

giA tri

cfra

gifi.

rhuydt

fi

ta

lfit.

< Y

,l;"hl

lhrio

lsfin

vdn-ttb

m0

f in n{y

r:6

vE

trAi

vdi

giAo

r'

",-

h{Lrn

rlich

dhita

b$nh

cfra

tdi li IArn

c?irt

ir€

+r/,tr

6r'e r ,rh

nglre"ri

Li

A;:r'

intr

phdi ttr h6

y.

6:i'io

drrr:

rnr.l

tA

nal',

lirrr:

cAch

n:io cho con

tA

bi6t

minh dii

lj

r.,

lrli

rrslrirf litrr*c.

lli'x dir:lt

cira chring

ti)i Li

lAru

r:t't(.)

hirtlr

nirftn

rTil' iJ.l''r tir

cho

hbn

hB ch6t

bi6t

rfin*,{

r,'irtlt

rl'i

ch;i5t

r,:A

}ifrr'

tim

h4nh

plrir;

t

ronfi

(di

tlthrr iu'r

lto'tr

ir

nu0i

nI

nr

r:iii

trhn.

<

Ifur

l<h0nrg

phfii

I*

rnrlt

nhiQrn

vrr

dE

diu6;,

Cle

irbn

$ra

if.v

co

khi

chdug aldi

l+i

qi

r{t

hhOu

hhdr.r

trorif, c{r

hrgn

tli6u

cfiet

ho.

lihhn nhibu klrOng

bi6t

rXug

ho

rlfl

chdt

v;l ho

tu'6'ng

tr.ioirg rhng

trg clnng &

trong cili tr

iln

tA

nru0n tr&

vb ciii nil. IIo

tin

tn&ng

ntrtr

ihS

trong

rrhibn

thdrrg c6 khi

hAn6

nfm. Ho tu&ng

r$.og

lhfrn

thF

r:,rA

hbn

ur.t

nb{p\vAo chlnlr

lA thftn thb

cfin

y vir

ho c?.i

cfiriil

cr,rii'ng

lEi

\rnoi

sq lOi h6"o

"

bq

ra kn6l

thfiu

th6

nqn nhtin.

Dd lA.

uhfi'\g

hE

itrui wrtl

b6n kia

th6

girri.

\'l'0i

bi6t

\rfing

ly gii 6,y

cd

v6

lq

hlng

vA

ktr0ng

thO

tiu

tn

\

o

il,f',,,:

iiii

vdi,

nhfrng kA

nAo khdng

c6

kinh

nqhiftn

rE

1fi"

dtb

niy,

song cAc

trudng

hop

kiBm

sof,t

iqi

bQnlr

viQn

voi'

cfc

chi

tidt ithy

dfi mi

tdi c6

th8

ddn cr

c6

th0

r:lr&ng

minh

rtng

tOi khOng

thAu

dqt

gl

cfi vd

tdi

I

:::s"

l'--:".i...

.124

THIN

LINH

HOC

TITUAT

ctIIEU

HbN

125



ohi

t6

nh&ng

rlibo

;

ruA

tOl

c6 trli qna

rnQt

thdi kj'

kinh

nghi$m

liu

dili cfih lOi

(1).

3)

Su urO

lin s6 khi

lim eho nhting nguli

ddn

chu

xin

rlanh

loi h6i

yB

tuong

lai

thAn th6 cfra urlnh

rlf,

bi6n

cAc

eon

dbng

thhnh

nhfrng thly tudng sS

kh6ng

hcrn

khdng

hom.

Ilnybn

bt

hoil

xdc

nh"{n

trong

tran[

thfit

lOn

dbng

hbn ma

c6

th8

rlof

rdwqc

cfc

su

rnng tl6ng

trong

th6

ph*ch

vi via

ho{c

tri

cria

ngu}i

xin dA bi6t

nhiBu

viQa.

I

Dri

xAe

d$r'g

t}

t'iong

trqng

thfii

linh

tng

li

trqng

thdi

ktrOrrg

16

hbn

rnn rrh{p

vdo1,

xAu

ilbng

cfinErl

ctl

thO

thAnh

kA b6i

trttrrrq.

0

rlny

,liing

*dt

nrlpAi

riQc trr

bidrr

mitrtr

th*trtr

lurrr'tr1

y

cirn

h:dn

nrlprh

thAnh

rlhfr tuOrtg

u6'

.

Sr:nS

tlhir

ph[n1

hi{t. lrong

tlrrr'rng

hop

nio

con

elbng

hi

l,bn

I

ntR

uhip

tAo" truffug

trqrp

r.r.Ao

con dling

chi

ln

rtr6 hr$ri

rnqt

rrqn$ ihii

lirrh

tu$

ughia

lil su

hi6u

bi6l

ilv chi tlu

I

ncri

diSrig

tfr

rn* lh0i chu', khOng

do

nui

quyEn

nirng

{lii€n

tieng

[ao,

"n

truong ho.'p

nfro

li trrrung

hgp

con

dh.lg

ctri

lA'+{0t

t6n

bip

brym

l0n

gi&

hi{n

m+o

xrng

th{nh thhn.

PhArr biet

duoc cAc

tru&ng hqrp

fiv

rilt

kh6'

thAnh

thri'

su

bip

j

hqrn

ntribu

hcrn li

sip linh

ung (mudn

hirlm

sofit

vA

phA1r lich cfrc hiQn

tuo'ng

eiia

cou

rtrbng

chi

c6

nnQl

tb

chrlc nhu

cAe

{r$i tAm

liuh

c1t

th0

girip

ich

cho

kE nplri0n c*u).

ch

cho

k6 nglriOn c*u).

\

Yier:

ahn

dauhl

chu

lgi,

ncri

tlbng

bdng

clri

lA binh

tiruc tftit

cfia

ndi

i

lg cno

thhn

thfnh khi

te

tlern

16

vit

ddl

cfng t6.

Vigc

I

r&y

nguy hi'6m

tA

ldm cho c{c

6on

(1)

Xeu

tti

ll€n thrm

hhlo

rd tg

trang

46"47

I

.t

nguiri

&

cdi

trung gidi

crh.

brim

vlu

cdi

trhn

mi

kh0ng

cltiu tidn

hoA

vil kh0ng

bi6t

nninh

dfi

sang

bOn kia

c&a

tir.

l\tQt

vdi

su

doa

n4t

cfia

con

dbng

khi xung rfing

<

ta

cr5

eulEn

hht

uhil

nguoi

ch6t

r

chi

lt

mQt

su

doa

n+t

ml

thdi.

ClAc

hlin

ma Ac

qu{i

kh0ug

th6

bfit

nguo'i

ta

ch6t

drrgc.

Chdt

ha"y

khOng

lt

rlo

sd

mgnh

'ohtt

kh6ng

pbAi

do hung

tJriin t4o.ra.

Ndn cf,c

hbn

ma nh{F dbng cd

quybn bfil

ngucri

ta

chdt

duoc

thi

ho

cflng

phii

chiu lu*t

nhln

qnl

vA bo

sd

bi

trrlng

tri

n{ng

nb

.b€n

kia cdi vO

hinh

VAy

nh&ng

khi

dbng

b6ng

l0n

doa ngt

ngrrtli ta, fhrlng

la chu

nOn

sq

sQt, scr

hfii'sE dua

tl6n nhiing

diEu

khrlng

t6l

theo tbuydt

tq

ki

{m

thi. TOi

con

nhd

mQt

(rng

hla

thual

churlin

r.rl-ru

sau :

'I'roriE4

rn0t

bubi

chu

co, hbn

kia tu

xuns lA

eon

qoi.

6

noi

nri6u

vA

doi

nhC

ctrm

quybn

cring

td cho

rro,

n6n

khO;rg

nrb

s€

phrl

ph{ch.

MQt

vi8n cht'tc lrur

vigc

tqi d6 c6 m{t

trouq

bubi

cllu

ccr

titc quA thdt

len nhi

riguoi

lr\

qu$

thl

nhr\

rrgucri

phhi

& drrri

quybn

sai

ktridn ci.la

qnar).

s& tgi

din-

phu'<rng

fihay r*{t

triEu

dtnh

-r\tri

tai d$_r.

Nbir vua

1if,

phong

tu'ric

vi

cho quan

tbt quj'

nlo-]Ql

dAm

doi nhu

th6?

N6uoi

cilu

co m{t 116

tla tei,

ctr

chay-b{y

c/.r

rG

dF

ton,

{:ou

rl8rrpg

tfr

thl hGu

la,

cdnh

tay

bi te

rn6.i nhuc nhsi

quA

rt6i.

Vi0n

cdng

chrlc no

ciing

nbi gi6n

rbi

lf{y

tay

c flp

r'[cg

coo crv

mitt,

ldc

bfiy gid

dbng

tir

m{ri

rrlt

tsy l.a

,luqc,

DiEu

tuly

clning

t6 cAi

phAch

cfra

htin

mr

ltrm t6, liQt cdnh

tay arrh

rrly

vd

su

ouong

truc

cira

Vi0n

chriLc

kia

khOr

g

il

dea

rral"

Mqt

chu5

gn

ktiAc xfi-v rn iy

ViQt-Nar.rr.

Ay l&

chuygn

con

qui

Nglr ,

Chuyfn

ney chung tOi luo,:

rlich

trong

cu6n

a

Conl,es

et

ldgendes

aunanites

r

cira

A,

:

rJ

tli

i

itl

IHAN

LlNa

troc

126

I

rrinr\

ura

127

HUa',r

Cnrriu HbN



'Landds

ndm

138tl,

dirng

cud'

niyicd

rfit nhi6u

chuyQn

rna

quf

xly

ra

ir

VrQt-Nauc)

l

.

Trti

chry

cirv

ling

'['rtr:crng

f,uu

tinh

UA

T'inh

cd

m(]t

tOn

Nghi

larn

nghb

niii

chcr.

Y

ch6t

h6a

ra

qnir,

l)dn

trons

j.tng

tAp

rthn

rhr'r,

;tao;1

ndrn

phli

[.im

16

cring

bAi"

f]An

h]

di

ngang

ddn

dd

cb

lLrc

le

kh6rtg

bay

lA

phfii

litr6a

thfin

m6i

rli tlnoc.

Nhu

th6

ho

tin

bufin

b6.n

nio'i

rlfrt.

ilon

qui

nAy

hiQn

&

utribu

rrhi

vA trAnh

hnng

vtli dArr

bit. Khi

eu}

'ttri€u-t'ri

ngu

giA

ia

IldlnQi

(1810-1S17)

trong

rlip

I0n

irg$i

nghe

chur0n

{y,.

rig.qi'

trOn

ra

lQr15

rldt

cdi

r13n

ffy.'fir

rl/r

vF s|ln

rtAn

ling

.ioqr,

ytln

bn.

Dily

lA

hintr

thitc

tli

rlo;rtr

quA

rlir

nhung; ktri

rtdt

rtFn

thl

con

qnf

ilv

rliin eb

lh0

bfit

Dqt

cXE

pldr

dl"n

tirrlg

'iia

hay

hgi

tldn

tfrrlr

rr{n$

cirir

ntri

vua

?

'l'6rar

lai

rlbng

b6ng

bCIn

la

ct-r

nhiEn

hinh

thr'rc

rne

tiu

',,A.

bip

b*rn

nhung

ciing

c$

nhilng

su

linh

tnl;'

Dbng

h'\il54

bOn

ta

lai

kh$ng

d6

nr0t

hA

thilng

piAo

ljr

'6rr

rl?inq

b6nri

ir

rrgoai

quiSc

(pbrii

'llhhrr

linh

hoe'r

l)hh

p ti;'r

All;'ln

I(nrdr:u

dIn

din),

SrI

nghiCIn-cun.lF

ttbirg

.h6nq

}rgn

la

l6n

rJ6o

cti

16

sd

c6

nSiFn

dhnp

ti'r

{.0

trtrilng

ktri

pf,ng

cirntr1

h6{

lr}

14

cirfine

h6m

eic

,liing

tr?

[udc-td

lil tlriln

rni

nr$t

LrOi'f&'rr-linh

r:dr

tinh

erl::h

e{inq

i'h

tray

lA

rn$t

lrQ

phsn

rrgiri'3n-ciru eite

trO

Y*td

lirm tronq

phf,.n

cuSe

Si0u*lfrrn

linh,

iiFn

lar:

lrtrc

tirjl-r

vrii c{::

nh"1

ttlu"err.{$

di0,n

d6

rltrng

ldi

tfiin

plirln

l.rqn

hhltr

sft

hi0n

tuor:g

hdu

girip

crto

t&

f'hiEu

lAi

liQu

qni

bfu

chct

lfti

kh[O

crin

vb

'iia

hgt

tArn

thhn

ben]r

hoc

rtr

tliiug

ihui

sifp

ta

tAi li{.

lrSlnrn

ph$ hB'

fhb

co,

trgrr/}i

n}iv

tlhu

cbg

khoa

hqc

tdru

linh

:

I

Cdc con

dting

hh0ng

ph*i

IA

kh0ng

c6,

Chl

cln

c6

nhiEu nhrl n6hi0n

cfnr

bit

tay

vAo

viQc.

CAc luf,n

d|

vl

ti6n

si

tri6t

hoc,

thtrn

hoc

hay khoa

hoc

ho{c

y

khoq

c6

rfit

nlril,u

lf

tht'r

trorg

ri*h-vuc

hhai

thic

r$c

r:on

dbng

cfrr"g

uhu

cOng viQr:

c,ira

chc

nhir

birc

hoc

t

bn

tidu

tr0rr

th6 giai

mdr clriirrg

iOi

o15

r:{r

dip lur;c

tlinh

trrln"

ctiinh

vi

ld

d0

mi

chrirg

toi t.i, chtii

kh0r:g

soan

m(rt cudn

n

Clridu

hbn

thu{t >

h'y

diing

b4nq

irorirr

frAn

rr6i

car

rdi

u6u

vigl-Nanr

vi

viQr; r,a)'

(li)i

hdi

ru0t

c0ng rinh

^ghidn-eiru

irlu

niim

vbi

cAc

eliin6i

tr'r

Vi$l-Narn

vi

it

nhdt

eliung

tili phfri

cr)

phuorrg

{i4rr

vir

.

u

trcl

giup

cria

nhibu

ccr

(rllilrr

y

lrcc

vA

it

nLrit

prh;1i

lhirrrh

lirp

ducrc

"iot

rb

uhirr

nrr,r,rrign

sidu

'fAni

l-intr

r1u4r:-td

&

elAp

hofc cAc

hQi rrghidu-crin

vb

'['Anr

linh

nhu

6

Anh I,tS.

Su

n6hi0n-criu

cie con rliing

eo

ich

lei--j{rlu,a

{nh

srlng

khon"

rroe

vAo

m(it

rlia

lrAt

c6

tiuh

ctlch lluyLth-b1

vA

rn0

{,irr

rli

tlnan

hhn

tlanir

qlb

cdc

ni6i l6

trai

Bliy

ra

tr,ri}

xfi

hOi

Vi0t-Irlnnr

vl

tin

ngniirrg

sai

lhtrr.

Db

cro

la'

lr4i

nho

quhn

chllrrg

nlri\n thfiy t 0n

lil sm

thfl[

song tl6ng

tlrrii sij;.g

dlrr

rliit

ch{rrrg

ta

dli

r,I'5n

."'i6c

khAm

ph{

shu

s$s

vb

bin

thO

va

pbsn

nOi

tg.i cfia con

nguui

Sirlp

tlr0m

tAi

tifu

cho

lrhoa

liiur

ph0n

hoc

uir

t,idt

rlau

chfrng

di.rr ta

d6n

rrhli.ngg

plrai

rrrinh

rn'ri irr6

tr€n

t.La

hat

tfirn

linh

vi

{i'l-l-tlr}n

da

churrl;

miir,*r

$'* sien viOt

tira

con

n4udi

ho{c c}llh git'ri

.;6

hinh

r,tgoAi

cl,nh

gi6i vat

chiit

(ptruung

plriipr

rnA

cis

lrr'ri

tfim

linh

qndc-i6

rl.fi

th€{t

bai).

U'

Vifi-l{arn

nhd. s6

tlbng

tfr.siur

c6,dbi

dio

ehing

ta

cri

tlr6

biit

tay

vio

cdng

vifc

nghi0n-crln

vd

bi6t

rlAu

rrorg

126

THAN

LINTI

EOC



tay cri

kh0i

cCI

th€

lAm

(vb phAn

tf,m hoc)

ho{c

Kardee)

hay

circ

thuY€t

cAc

gii+huydt

cira

cAc

hilng ngii

ta

l+i

khOng

cd

nhftng

dlo

lQn

c{c

thuYdt

c&a

Freud,

Jnng

oAc

ttruydt

thhn

linh

hoc

(cfia

Allan

vB

tf,m ljr

hgc

cira

Binet,

v.v..'

haY

tru&ng

huSbn

I

bl

hoc

khic

?

I

I'

I

Gtru'crns

llt,

-

nilOr

NAM

rni-nre

nlf

nr

vE-

cnrEu

Hdn

rHuAr

vA

cAc

rAr

lrQu

vE

cnriu

nbru

&

vlir-NAM'

Phhn

lrinh

bay,

vb

ly

thuydt

tr0n

cira

chring

tOi

li

do

r:ttn6

phu

nghi0n

cuu

t10n

sfch

v&'

Chrlng

t6i

tu6ng

cflng

co

th6

denr

it

cilu

chuyQn

kinh

nghiQm

cfia

chrlngfitdi

da

lrlnh

bAy

vdi

qnl

dOc

Bii

vb vfin

dB

chiOu

'hbn

thu{t'

Sau

mQt

rlm

thi

nghiQm

vE

thuflt

chi0u

hbn

bing

phuuug

pb{p

l0rr

ccr

(c0

nhibu

c{ch

chung

t6i

'le

trinh

bhy

6'

doan

rlsn s{ch)

chfng

tOi

nhfn

thdy

:

l)

t)trdn

ltrtt

cdc

bubi

chi0u

hbn

do tu

tu&ng

cfia

tl0ng

ti-r.

vir

cii'

toB

t0o

n0n,

nhfi'ng

bbn

chdt

tulrng

tuong

rni

khongl

c6

su

thf,t.

c6c

nh&n

v{t

n6i

chuyon

vdi ehirng

ta

c6

tf.$

ao

ptriln

ti6nn

ttrric

cira

dbng

tfr

ho[c

cri

tog

lgo

ra"

2) Su

diBu

khiffn

co'r

cu

.<ll

bai

hay

ba

ngrdi

116

tay

n6u

"frUy

co

tt]6

clo

mOt

ngucri

trong

bon

mudn

-

bip

ltfti

tlhv

di

(mQt

rrp,uli

b4n

vcri

t6i

thfl

nhfln

tlil

dhy

ccr

di

db

lu

xung

mqi

kA

v6

hinh

'18

doi

cring

tlb da'

Anh

ta

ddng kich

rilt

tAi

n€n

nh&ng

ngudi

ngbi

clu

bi

enh

lta

gnt.miktrdnglray.C6khinguirilAmd6ic6edi'hf,nh=-

ai+o

vi

sung

sudng

lua

duoc

k€

khAc

n0n

y

c*

ti6p

lrlc

lq.r-r

re

kE

nAl'

k6

kia

)

D6

le

nhilng

trudng

hqp

gi6

tgo'

Song

ndu

mudn

thi

nghiQm

khon

clri0u

hbn

chting

ta

chn

phli

thlnh

that vdi

\

l

l

nhiu

vl ,lEp

c6

muc

rlich

tlm

tdi nghi0n

cuu chu

khOng

rHUAr

cruEu

HbN

6).M6i hiQn tucrng

chn

ki8m

soAt.

Vi

du

mQt

hbn

THAN

LINH

IIOC

t3l



vt d6

lt

mQt

l6i

bhoi

dta

hay

mQt trd bip

bcrm

d6ng

kich.

P"g:

nhu iu6 nhiing

ngudi

crlng thl-nghigm

vdi chrtng

ra

SE

dnn6

nhiEn cdch

d0

lhi nghigm

nhu sau

:

i"l

*

r)

Neu

I

)

N6u

lrong

ba

ngudi

nghi

ba

ch& ktr{c

nhau

blt

dlu

blng

t,

t,

y

I

md

con

oo

lqi

chi

cbfr

h

thi

lAm

sao

ta

lai

ma

l6n tu xung lA T[n EA

ti6n sinh

llm thcr. Ndu

lim

tho

d& kh0ng

tlring

vtrn

hay

Am

tligu ho{c

khOng cd

giong

khinh

bnc cria TAn

Di

thi

lf,m

sao

ta lgi

c6 th$

tin ato

alrlnh le

bbn cfra Tln Et

?

Ndu

ta

c6 mQt

bdi tho.

hay

cb

ttrigng

tho

gidng

thi

si Tin

EA

thl

ta

cfing

khOng th6

Kcm

d6 tA chlnh

'trln

EA.

Ta

phli

xem

dbng

tr'r

(o tb6

nh8 l+i

rnQt bili thcr cil ntm

trong

tibm

thuc cfia

y

chflng

?

hay

li

do

tibm

thuc

cria cri

tog

?

Song

n6u

lA

fln

Dn

lhst

thi lhi si

cilrrg

c6

thb

doc

cho

ta

n$he mQt

bii

thcr

cfi

chfrng bqn.

VB

ttiAnn ndy

lAm

sao

phAn

bi$t

duqc

bii

tho nao do tlbrrg

tir

lAm

vi

bii tho

nAo

do

Tln

Di

lAm

?

N6u

le

m(rt

bti tho m&i

ta

sE

il{t

hai

gi$.

tlru5dt

:

trtrirng hqfr

nio thi bAi tho

fiy

.do

Tfrn Di

thdt ch6t

di

hiQn

hbn lim vd

trutlng hop

nio

ll

dbng

tri

hay

cr?

toa

dii phdi

hqvp

l4i

ttrinh

m0t

J'

tbuc

t{p

th6

(conscience

collective)

dA

s6ug

t{c ra

? Ei6m

nily

cfrng

l+i ln

kh6.

Song

ndn

di

sAu

viro

ta

e6

th$

phf,n biet

duor"

Ndu

lA

mot

bdi

thtv rnrti

thi

m6i

ngnli

trong

ct?r

tQa

pnli ntrO

Bhi

trr tu&ng

cfia

minh

tr0n mQt

tap

5-ifiy

xem

cAu

tha

$y

cdr

phfri

do

f

ughi

minh dfi

tfic

dQng

nAo

ttiing tfr

ktr0ng

?

'lruo'ng

hop

so sAnh nhftng

di0m

ghi lrdn

gity

vA su

cdn

tgo

toirn

th6

bili tho

n6n

c6

nhfrng

i

nghi

vA lui rui

chlnh

rl6ng

tfr vi

cAc

nguoi

ydu

tho

du

trubi

chu

trbn kbOng

thb

c6

ducrc

tn

c6

thB

xem

hi€n

tuong

dy

c6

ptrhn

hj'

di$u,

vA

n6u

n{

c6

rrhfrng

tti8m

trirng

v&i

f

nghi sfia cir tog

la

c6

th8

xem hiQn

tuong

nly

do

t&m

lf

chung

cfia

crl

to+ t+o

n6n.

DB

cdng

bi6n

clc

b+n

nn$t

mhu

chuyQn

tdi trich

dudi

dAy mot bubi

chu hbn mi tbi si TAn

DA

dA ung lOn

rtb

lai

blo

dd

tt

nbftng

rtiBu

tu&ng tuong

cria chung

ia

tgo

ra

?

I{ay

trong

mQt cflu ml ba

ngudi

dofin

sE chi

chfr

vui

vE,

h0n hoan, mtrng

rO,

mA. con

co

lgi

chi chfr

sung

su&ng

tht

lsrrn sao

bfro

dO lA

tibm thuc

hay

tu&ng

tnong

cfia

ngudi

ta

lgb

ra

?

2)

C{c

ilgn

thi

nghiQm

cach

khfc:

ua

ngudi

nghi

ba

ch&.

N{u

trudng

hq'p

no

ra

mqt

chit

cria

trong

ba

ngudi

lhl

ta c6

th6

blo rfing

tu

tu&ng

cira

ngudi

ndy

mgntr

hon nCn df, ldn

Ap

tu

tu&ng.cAc kE

kh{c

(chffng

khdc

gl

trudng

hop thdi

miOn).

3) Hai

bgn

ctrng dO tay

vAo

m0t con

co

vA hai

bnn

nghi

hai ch&

vl

dU

n hay b

vd

chi

tay

cfia bai ngudi

cfing mudn bhqy'

ddn

ch6

fry

song

ctr

lai chi

ch& t.

VAy

lhl

gil

thuy6t nhAn rli$n (magnCtisme

humain) do

ngud.i

ta

dhy ccy

tli

hh0ng tbB

dung

vfrng duqc.

Ndu ccr

chAy

t16n

mQt

troog hai chfr

a hay b

ta

nncri

c6

th8 blo

d6

It

di0n

(lluide)

cfra

mot ngudi

mqnh hon

ngu&i kia

de

dhy

d6o.

4)

DA

mpt kE

khOng bi6t chfr

ngbi

mA

vi6t

I0n

tlugc

ti6ng

Viet

nam hay

ngo4i

qudc.

5) Bit

mit

mQt

ngudi

mA

y

rAn

vi6t rluoc

t32

.

TIIiN

LINH HOC

x.ITUAT

cHIIiU

EdN

1

3:r

ngAm vinh

ivt

dgc mQt bAi

tho

(tni

liQu

cira anh

N K

Il)



cbCp

theo

ibidn

bln trubi

hqp. Tdi

rfim

thdng

tu

(23.5.19,1ft)

Theo nhu

lei hgn

lhn

tru6c,

tdi

hdrn nay dring chirr

gl&,

b6n

vi :

ha

thi

si,

vl

mQt

nfr

nhac

si

dfi d6n

cho'i

vA

t{Dg

chfrng

t6i

nbqc

vA

lh<v.

Tht

si

I'hi

Y6n l0rr tru&c

liOn

bio

chung

tOi rhng

:

<

Cac

ngAi

bdy

vE

thirrh

st-ran

quA lfrm

6j"

n6y

ldng

chrlng

t0i. D

Rbi

0n*

b?n lqi

ti6p

:

<

Cdc

b4n

sao m&

d[t

nhfrng

danh tft to

l{t th6. HQi ngh

viln-hoA

vA

6ng doc

ctruong-

lrinh

bubi

t$i

<

nhgc

vl lhcv

>.

l)

Iln

EA:

Dcm

trlng

2)

ItAn

m{c f.fr:

Phong

3)

Bach

lhn

V0n

:

Nhqc

mo

rn0ng

(birr

nbac

niy

cd

ghi

kj,

frm

phfip

song

chrlng

tOi

kirOng

chdp

lqri

trong

tdi

liiu

ney cO

rf

lrii

nh4c).

4) l'hi

Ydn

:

Thuybn

xnOi.

Xong

ttli si ra

vA

crr

'Iin

DA

vAo

v& Idi

dlu

ti0n

,*ul cu

dA

lday

ch$ng tOi

lA

:

< Eenn rrqn ra

rldy

>

lChrtng

lfi

r6t ruon

vA

dem nem l0n.

Cu'lgi

ti6p

thdm

lAul

cho

cdring

tOi

hinh

dnn6 lai nhfrng ngAy

cu

cdn &

trhn

gian

rhi

trr

ldy

lArr|

sunp su&ng

tluoc g{p

cu gia

d[m

xua

ebm

tno

lOn

bfn

chtv

Trdi. Tny

khOng

tluqc

vinh

du

g{f

m{t

song ch,$ng

tOi cfing hAn hqnh

duqc

g{p

cu liong

m{l

Bi0ng'tho

mi

tu&ng kh0ng bno

ti,i

S{p

duoc.

say ru

flu.

Lau,

thri blng

'

ruou

phi

i khOng cf,c

L

i

ngdi

nbi

?

Tr?u

nhsp

mOn xuft

dl6

lt

l€

Troi

vfy.

Ta

n6i

nhC

:

Itbi

cu

dgy

:

Dt${

TRANc

say

RU,()u

It{dg

ndno

trfing

bgc

il6.n

ngdn

sao

(ctr

ngring

vi

nbdp ruou).

-

A

hd

nhdp

ruou

d[

chu

ITaou

nh&p

ronq,

brrbn

klfi

b6c

cao

Suo'nq

bi6.c

Ifi

loi

nwn

tr6n

t6c

Crr

lqi

blo

: o

Egc

cho

te

ruug

dui

thi?

nilo.

A

hl

t

l

Gi6

udnq n{l&

ngctn uu6t

ue

rdu,

Cu lgi

khidm

tdn

:

<

I'ho

dudng

ddy

clc

ngii

9,

nhurrg

tu

rdt

nrdi

cdc

ngii

b6

qua

cho

gii

ney

nhe

,r

'

IIbn

bag

chuq

uu.i

ldn

rntlg

trfrng,

I-onq

ttqi ddn

theo

chin

rr:qu

ttdo.

Crr l4i

kh6i

hii

(

I)oc

lai

tlA ta

nghe

rhii'

n6

c6

c16i

ch{t

ch{t htrdng ?

o

Dt/c

xong

crl

d?y

o

Duoc r.

Trdi

ddt

tan

rn

thanh

bibn

IC

Jfu?a

giim

tt

nlrrlnq

u6.t tlwong

rlau.

(Een

d[y

dfi

h6t bli,

cu

chlo

chung

t6i :

chi

nh0n

ctng

qul

vi

thtnh

gil

nh6

giA

re

a A

hl,

chlo

d0ytr

cHihnlCOn

gl

l"i

134

THX.N LINH

IIOC

'l'fr

TIiUAT

CHIEU HdN

135



BAy

gid

ddn

luot

thi si

Hin

m{c

vAo, sau

vli

phrit

ti6p chuyQn

Ong

cho

tho

nhan db

:

1

PIIONG

LAN

l'rdnd uba

I6n,

Pho,ng

Lan trong bdng

ln,

IilG

ltttint

cubi

chdo

il6n ilLnt

pln

li,

Cdnh Phong

Lan

siittg

ho'n

dnh

tuu

lg,

.

Hdo quang

bdt

ldm cln

trdng so'

sr?'nq

.

Phong

Lan

ld

mdt

trbi

tdg

llw

rttdnq,

Eiig

&o lugbn ud

ddg

nhfrng

w|c

rtto',

Ii6.l titrh'b&ng nltfrng

glrot

rc

lrsrtq

ln,

Cfia

l

bao

cu6c

tlnh

dugAn iluonq

t0'

d6',

Ilituu nhrlng hbn

th&g

lfnh

bao

thi6u

nft,

IT

u|l

dd.ng

tronq

ntit

bu"Ai

chibu

td.

(EE

ta rrgbi,

met

lim )

Phorlg

Lan

ildg ld chfta

tb,

lodi

hoa,

i\rrin

ftrang

thom

nltr rttt

cad'i

trinh

rtfi',

I)hong Lan

hmvnq

thdtt g6p nilrtr

lhaong

nh6',

Oi.a

lhti ndo

ra rdm

ld.m,

thrti t:ra,

'

'I'r6n,

trao curttl

ld'i

llmn

udn

ngdt

ngt,

(lia

el::.nh

phlt

o(rn

phdnq

klfin11

lrrnh

12.o,

Cho

n6,n

cld

mdi

kl:,i

ldn

gio

hto'

(Xin

l5i cAc

bqn nhd, cho

tOi nghi

mQt lnl)

Ii6o

ldrt

htong

IA

thA kh&p

tll:.nh

gian,

l'ht ta

nqhe

lbi

rLn

nhudnt

ddg

lanq

D6 thdi

IlET

I

t

IIAN

MIC

TT]

Tdi rfim

lhtng

i-r.-

Tho

nhan

dL

:

<

IrHONti

LAN

HUONG

)

I'hdng phd.t

ctdu

dAg

mt\i hlronq

thent

nmrr

Nht uu6t

ue,

nlnr

6m dp lhiin ta,

llfii

lwnne

lhom

nh:.: tlnh

(ii

Ni

Cd

Vd

trinh

bqch nlllr

linh

ltbn l)trc

n[c.

Gi6

manq

ltaonq

uaot qua

nqd.n

sdnq

b'A,

Rog

u?.

ddg

thom

nq(rt

c& khdng

oian,

Iilfinq

qian

t6

runq t6nq

nh:;-

to

utirt11,

Chem hoi

th6',

uitnq

trdng

sdu aa

IC,

il

t6i

dti bi6t"

rbi. t6i

iId

bi6.l

Ilactnq

ddg Ia

ltaonq

c&a

Irca

phonq

lart,

Thom tho

qud,

nqot lim

iI6.n litilt

hbn

Vd

nqa|'i

tdi

run

IAn

vl

nqtg

nqAI

A tCi mu6n

ldn ltaong kfa si6.t

chdt,

Ld.g

dd,u

t6i

cho

du di6t

iIA

nt€

Clro

boo

nhi6u

rrflnr dau khb sdu

bi.

Cfra

ltnh

ltbn

dp sau mdn

raonq

m6ng.

Dbu

tudn

ra

nhr

Ia nufin I|p

sdnq

Tran

tr&i

cilng1

lri.n

canh qio

IIm phr

tnq

Cho

rr5;udi

I6i

d0 but

ndi bi

thao'nr1

Nlrurrg than 6i /

/rbn

tlte/o

lwong

di

ntdt,

Eb

cln

tdi

bi6.t

drcrc nqubn ,sF

thdt,

ntdc,

il

lIIAN

LINH

si

:

HQC

rHUA'r'ctttriu

Hbn

THtlYtN XUoI (tho

cfia

phi

Ydn)

r37

136



khlc

cira

Hln

thi

Tlmgln

rudi.,.

tlteo

gi6

thug4n

rudi,

'I'hugbn

xnLi mang

c&

mdt

trdi

nhd'

nhung,

ThugEn

tudi theo

dnh trdng

trong,

Nhg

nhdng

lda

nhflng

mitnh

udng tr€n

sdng,

I{&"ng

nga

ch6.t

ilu6i

trdn

ddng,

'l'hAn

lan

nghln mdnh,

gi6 ngdn

khdc

than.

Ilugln

7'rdn

h6'i

bi6.I

chd.nq

tim

tha thi6t,

Cita

anh tdg

cilng

nftrr

hdrr trlfutg

I)r(ti

strc

rrrgnft

cfia

mtii

chi:o

lg btQI,

.

V6'

tan ra tttnq

m&nh

u|i kh6ng. gian,

T'hugEn

rudi

theo gi6

thugbn

rudi

'l'hughn

xudi

mang

cir m|t trdi

rth|

nltung.

'l'hugbn

ru6i

bubm lrdng

tlrcn thing.

Plwi minh

cho

qid

chdn

ctng

chdu

thtin.

Cdrth bubn nhu\)nt nt6t

nrdu lang,

'l'hugd,n

rudi theo

qid

thugln

rudi.

'l'hugEn

rr:nrii

ntanq

cli

ldng

tdi di

rdr

Tlwgd.n

:rudi

trdi.

lfii

thugEn

ru\i

,li

ddu

?

niu.

lqi

qiim

tdi

tldnq

td'i.

Chdp

tag

rin

lgg

cirng

trdi,

7'rldi

sor

db

qn&

ciirr

ndg

tlfinh

btingl,

D'e

cIrc I6i daoc

cilng nang

[,im

ili

lrong

mdt

qidc

udnq

qud

sag,

Ndnr m'6 tlo

dnh

trdng

*iig,

Cftdn sdu

iI6i. trdi

tim

ngdg

tho ndg.

Vt

dny

lt

mQt

bAi

tho

cgriitl

Bli

Tdi

thich

ng6-m

nhrlng

chflu

fte

rqc

16'

Nd

ahn

hbng

tltim

nhudm

c&

hbn

iluu

7'6i

thlch

ng&'rn

nftr?ng

chilu

hi

t&t

th&

LA

mtinh

iti

trong

bdng

tdi

dAm

sdu'

Ddg

ddng

tdng

nftg

clfit

trdi

lfi"ng

ld

7'r6i

',thAg

vE.

il6n

ldn

rn

cd

IiAu'

IIai

lttn

bd

rqng

lii6u

g6'u

rllu

hfu'

Eftnql

clfiu

tang

nhb

ntd.g

tudnl

dono

IC'

Tb

f:ing

r6m,

ldn

khdi

lam

qu&n

qugi'

Yuonlmlnh

IAn

chdt

cftng

giila

lchdng

gian

fndi

Lnang

ildg

;

mQt

linh

hbn

u'

t6i'

Ed

rrlnq

ilau

lcltb

I&'m

lri'n

trdn

gfan'

tO

aa

I

yd

nfodi

r,a,

nqodi

rdt

citttg

rlbrrg

ndi'

nfigl

kh6ng

anh

? mdt

m&nh

ntd't

|rbi

solr'

nono\

ngdt

noa

tim

c&m

vd'o

dirtlt

nrti'

Mdu

trdn

trb

nl:Lu6'm

dd

c&

chi\u

buiin'

ildg"

ilEnq

rd.n

ngudi

duo'i

m6'

Idn

7

d6.

{ta,

oan

rcudn

THAN

LINII

HOC THUAT

CHIEU

HdN

Tr

lr6ng

xudng.

Chao

oi

mA

'fa

139

138



Rbt

frdE

['hi

si6

BAn

ftb

su6f

nggc

Dd

Ih

nhfrng

giPt

rc

nbng,

LenA

lunq

nhd

rudng

khdc

thtonq

l6i

ndng'

nbi

ltfdg

/thi

n&Lng

ild

turt,

Lnal

thaa

udi

dnh',

sao

udng

trt'u

hlfing"

E6

Xd

nltfi'ttg

nin

hr.ottg

ldnq

'

I

C&a

I

n&ng

Nga

th&p

chi\u

hbn

chunq

I6i'

rYlrulrg

trti

0i,

hO'i

lrdi

oi

I

f

nulrEn'

rudi

thttgbn

udn'

cti'

tudi

llteo

ddnq'

I'6'i

I6i

cung

tt0i

Idrt

'srt(/'|rq

ffdn

lon

udo

cdt

lt

kh6ng

u

hotii'

Thu[En

rudi

lheo

qi6

thugbn

tudl'

Tnu[bn

t'udi

nranq

c&

m

t

lr|i

nlft

nhunq

Ifr.c

tag,

Id"m

roi

suong

hbnu,

B

4.1943.

-

MQt

v[n

si

lu

xung

l*

llgch

bAi

vln

xu6i

nhan

tl6

:

[huYBn

co'

sao

ngqp lh6.

tudng

ta dang

&

tr0n

cao ng6

xu6ng,

hbn ta

sqo

mA

b&

ng6',

6c te

rnudn luOn

dnh

sAng

ra

vi d[ dung nhiEu sao

qu{.

Ta

kh6ng

d{m

nbin

nfra. Hai

bOn

b'}

tring htng

lC

li6u

bubn fi ri

ttung

cqnh

nhfrog

cAy

th0ng\cao

vf

t sao

rui

mAn

thufir

th6.

'I'a chot

hi6u:

ei'

Aai

kh6nq nOn

mcr

rnQng nila.

'l'a

khdng

nen

b6t chudc le

li6u

kia vi ta

thdy

ndr

lA [:du

hq,

Ta

cBn

pbfii

rdn

luyQn

nhu

cAy

lhfrng

tbAn

cao

cAnh rQng

th{t lA xring

d6ng v{y.

'IbuyBn

ccr trOi

song

hbn

r0[ ttfi

khAc

rbi

vi

roi

dd hi6u

t0

s6ng.

ThuyBn

cil tr0i xudi

tlOng.

*t*

i

'1

I

1i

;i

,i

I

1i

I

i

{i

I

,aj

I

il

ThuyIn

i

I .o

trOi

trOn

ur{t

hb

gu'ang

sing

loiing'

I\I{t

lt.o

tldy

l$

bii thcr

<

'I'i€u

SIu

r

c&a

Hdn

m{c

'I'i"

lAm

vlo

rd6m

tt.5.1918.

TII.]TI

SAU

0

rl\m

nag

trdi

trong nht

goo',rg,

1'

I{h,lnq ldn m(rg utonq kh6ns

ho'i srortg,

)

To

trdnq

Dttdno.

qn

l€.rt

mndrt cdn/i,1

Ts

trdnq udW

(un)nlur

dnt

thanh.

4

T'b

dtiu,

titu

sci}-reo

ui

uu,7

Ilutin nhu lrin

ntdg chibu

m{la

t/rtr

\

firrr

nht

ddnq

ta,

trAn uai

nrrlnq.

I

Monq

manhnlut

Id

lbi

giu duonq.I

/

7'6i.

phi€u

dii.u

cung

nqdn

sao

bdnq.

tL

Im

Mitng

tdi trd.ng

Id

trilnq.

A

ha I Trdng t^dn

ddg

cltdu

thd.n,

Omg

lhi"Em tt(tg

rdi

huong

ngAg nqdg,

Trong

tlOnt

Y

l6n

tfng

ntOt

nuqc

in

irlnh

ta

vA thntbn'

Hai

bOn

b&

khoi

trBm bav

n(o

ngfrc.

f'nni

ch[ug

dAy

lA

dbng

ngAn

giang

mi.

ta

lA

kim

dbng Ja,tg

c6i

thuvErr

trfing

di

ngo4u cfrnh

?

U'

ph&i

;;

;i;

{r'ai

hflng

da

sa'sd

sno

du<vi

rhuvbn

ta

'vl

ta

thdy

ttuybn

trOi

0m

nhu

nhung'

nhtr

dang

tli

vAo

tloug

c{i

r6ng

trt6ch

cfia

khdng

gian'

'fhuybn

khdng

mQt

co

tr6i,

lAn

s6ng

ta

trOi,

M[r

hbn

qgo'

trdi

theo

lAn

nu0c

bgc,

hb

in

iAu

bhu

troi

thfrm

- **-

TIIAN

LINE

TIOC

lrdg chdu

hrg

quilnh

d'ao;

'THUAT

CHIEU

EbN

tdi

y0u

clu

bgn

ndo

c6

dip .lec

rbi

ho{c

do

chinh

bai

t-l

I



O

b&ng

Md

m|nt

cllo

tdi boo

|Inlt

sog.

Nd tdi

n&t

bao

dong

nqot

ttgdoi

GhA

thabng\

rc,t

khoi

nubngl

H&ng

Ngo

Ilaong

trln

brittg khuting

qugQn

nlnh

hoa.

Nlrrp

nfrdn

gi,

nudng

iIi

theo nhiP

Am lhanh

lin

cao

rth(tc htrdtttl

'1'6i

lrri

giln bAn,

b

lrl

nlwdng,

Nrrlnq

ftdfig,

b

chinh

ld

l'haong

Tluong'

Ngnrif

ldi

'rung

ddng

nl:nr dm

thanh

Nu6f

ft/rtinO

nqtrng

dtbi

t6i

laA

tcinh.

Hoi'uttt

nitttOi

6rn

chdm

ldg

Nadng,

T'lmn

6il

Nuonq

dd

bi{.n

ra

sayng.

7'6i dm clihn

ph&i

li6nq 'I'i6u

sd'u,

Vi-uu

reo

b'ubn

trong

dent

thdtt,

NgAy

t6 5.1948

ltc 10

gi&

t6l,

thi

si t'hi

fdn ung

ldn

nhqp

co

vi

Jeu

Flo

cii

chfirtr miiy

chfr

trong

bAi

tho

cira

llln

vl

H&n

lUnOng

tl6n

dtu.oc.

0og

sfta

chfr

t bu&cB

vAo

chfr

dt

(tron$ cAu

Nhip

nhdng Nudng

di theo

nhip

dtn) chii

< trdi

oi

, vlo

chfr

the'

oi

(trong

cfru

:

Than

di

nA.ng

df,

hi6n

*a

suorg)

vi ch&

<

choAng

>

vAo

chfr'

chlm

(trong c0u

,t0i

6m

chtm),fNdm

1951 chung

t0i

c6

rl[ng

tfrc gil

trdn

df;

r6n6

t{c

rrong

hrc

sanh tibn

xin

clro

ehung

tOi

bi6t

ngubn

gdc

dA

kiEm

sott

tat

hign

ruong

ho{c

lA mOt

bdi

thcr

cfia

rnQt

tdc

6ifr

khdc

?

Itieng

tho

TAn

Bi

lA

mOt bdi

rtro

cii.

()'

ttAy

gii

rhuyGr

bdi

thcr dy

u&ne trong

tiBm

thuc

cfia

rtbng tri

co

th0

chflpr

lhuAn

droc.

Ila

hii

thrr cirn

H. M T'.

vA

thi

si

p. y.

klr0ng

ha-v

(khdc

vCri

bii

Tidu

siu

c$

giong

cria

l{dn)

nhrrnq

c'6

nhii.ng

(r

khA lq. ltlng.

Con

hlo

<

Chibu

he

I

cria

II. l\f.

T

thi

t-ldn

lir

thi

s'i

c0ng

gi{o

dAu

c6

gieng

v[n

ndr

ddn

<

clrudnc

cbria thong ttrfi

db

D

?

IJii

vAn

xudi

s

'I'huybn

co

)D

c6

rG

s0u

sfrc

nhrrng

tdi

l:.ri

nhtr

dCr lA rnQt trdi

cira

Hdu

I\I{c

T'fr

de

thuong

L\nl

hinh nhrr trong

cu6n

?

mA

tdi

qu€n

t

(iiao

thi{:p

m0t tbili

gian

rbi

l[:\n P]ri tn

gifi

arrh

N.

ti. D. ra tli

ludn.

'Iu'

db

khOng ttrb

clu

eAc

Ong cluo'r:.

N6u

b$o r$.ng do

clbng

tfr

tao

ndir

hidrr tutrng

thl

sao hi6n

ttrcng lar

ktrdng

th8

ti6p tuc

u: il

dug;

theo

f

mudn

cfia

diing lil

?

'[uy

nhidn gifi

thuydr

ciro

rirng

c6 ntri$u

hbn

rnfl

mgo

nlr{u

ngudl

niy

k& no

riit

c6 th6

xdy ra

droe

cilug nhu

trOn

cdi

trhir

thd

c6

nhjEu

hang

hip

bom

rl6ng

vai

tro

gid

d6i

rnA

cAc b6o

thuoi:g rl[ng

tAi

song

n6n

vai

tro

dy

ddng

kh6o

kbi6n

nguoi

ra

lhrn tu.&ng

la

ttrit

thl ngbe thuit

h6

ra

cirug

kbA

cao rbi t

*

a*

tldn.

ran,

I

i

'l

.tt

C6

hi$n

TEAII

t

tNs

noc

ra

ml

bAy

khOng

thCY

il ? Gln

cfra

I

TTTUAT

CT]IEU

HdN

M5

Ca :

Vua

rtii

tao

cd

hi{n dAu

mA

ttrdy,

f+i

h0y

lAo.

Ccr



C6

gd

06

S0,

Cd

eily

hhOng

?

rIAn

tranh

ltbOng

?

c6.

ThC

UAy

gid hiQn

lgi

tlusc

kh6ng

?

NhiEu

lhn

qufi

'khOug

ti$n.

tliQn

sao

kh6ng

ttrdy.

tlhi

c6

mQt ngrdi

thfiy

?

Phin

nhiEu

dhn

bil

dC

clnr

xric

th{y rd

}:on.

I

Xin

liiQn

lai.

Sas

cuOe

lhi

ughiQnr

r.uiv

chtng t0i

k6t

lu{n :

II6i

Ccv

n6i

Cs

H6i

Co

rr6i

cd

H6i

0o

H0i

t,.- ll0i

tbii"y

b*ng

ma

ni ba

nguoi

r:(r

th8 cho lA vl

tOi qu{

tin

rnA

sintr

illlrb. i.rih

uily

ch

lh0

clro

lir

ktrOng

cd

2,-*

Soiifi lrai

ihrr gd

btrn

(ci

,l€g

bii

rrt6n 4

rrguc.r,i

X

2

trai

:

8 lai.

";

tidng

X

[i ini

:

Z,t

lh.n.

2l

X

2'lhn

1;6

:'

4fl

triin;4.

Vai'

t'()':$

{tltlr'3.

ll.*

Ti6rrg

rlirn

lr'nnh

c<tr th0

cho

bir

hn"

nrqo.nirt

sollg.l''r rhi le

rnot

cr

thii

,lr1

tA hifn fuort;g

fi6

lhAt.

kia

khOng

thf,y

ra

r.qng

tu&rrg"

that"

r:rgbe).

Ndu

ldnr

thi

khfirrg

th$ gqi

li

g'fi

thuydi nrQt

con

gi.{

thuy6t,

vl

ciing

i

i. , a r.

Rua

fi

qu6

n6

lirLn d6'

I

'Irong

khi

tri$q

c6 ndi

chuyQn

tlrtoc

hhirng

?

l

Ctl

:

Ducrr:,1

nhrng

im

l{irg

thl

tdt hon.

Sau

khi

khhtr

kho&n

aE

xin

itriEn

lqi

co trl

lrri

:

<'I'hoi

nB

ldi. Goi

cS

ntrvnrr

.l-:

nhd

rldy ta,t

sd

higrr

lqi

noi cfra

cho mA

coi

con

khOng

gd

cr?a

vil

tle{r

utru

hbi

dAu,

trhung

ptrdi

ctro

ttfr

m{t

tilt

c[

ngudi

trorrg

nhA

(vl

cfre

ngudi

lrnng nhA

phhn

'IOng

dA

di ngfi

n0tr

chring

tdi

khOng

lhu{u

de hg

dty).

flo :

Tao

phi

hiQn

tblnh

b0n6

rdt rnd

klrfing

c6

ehi

dAng

so

cl.

'ffOi

biia

sru tao

cdr

rl6n thi

ndi

chuyQu

ci-rtl

kl:Ong

tiQu

hiJ$n

ra.

i

Ltic ily

chiing

tOi

d{nh

lua,

trl

l&i

:

r

Efi

d[y

dfi

i^

Co

:

'l'frt

d0n.

(Bdn

tfit

song

hhOng thdy

gl

c6).

'l'rinlr

biy

cu0o thl

nghi€rn lr0n

eria

r:hrirril

t$i dA

(16:

chifrr

viri c{e

cuQc

tlrl

ng}ri{rn

tludc 16

khAc

nr;l

eh{tr.rg

tOi

xin t'.irn ltros dulri

rlAl':

u)

l'E

higrt

trontt

ti[.no

qi)

Ndr: lti{};

th,ri

tA

rle

Rochas

l}lcir

hlron Pliirp thi

trghi$rn

vcri

I]0y

ln

rnQt

doqn

t'ong

bi6n

lio cai

nro'Dg p,6

d{t &

phia

rl6irg

tfr'

liusapia

vni I\,Iaxrvet

r.

Niim

1871

William

Groohes tht

llorne

vd sau ddy lA

mQt

dogn

:

nguy0n

gi6m

rl6u

truong

dbng

tfr

F'.usopin

Palndino.

bip.

27-9.

<

Ba

ti0ng

gd

sau

l\laxwei

vi

cdch

xa

nghiQm

v6i

dbng

tfr

146

a

V{t

ily

rhdy trong

s6u'

pbur

vi trudc

khi bi6n

mdt

THiN

LINH

HoC

TI{UAT CHIEU

H6N

147

ntrflt

l:r trong

bubi

thi*ngtriQm

c6 tidng

ttQng

khi

lgnir elng



j;'

i,

il

Il

I

h

fi

I

gd

ba ii6ng

tr0d bAn

vdi ti6ng

dQng

gitSng

nhu

mQt

v{t

cung

r$n

>"

(trt1h

trong Recherches

exp6rimentales

sur

une

force

nouvelle

1;7-1877),

'Iizane

trong,,

< Sur la

pisle

de l'homme

inconnn

n

c6

ndi

hipn

tnong

lma

gd.cira,

tnd'ug

vAch,

vrl

rlb

tlac

trong

cdc

r:gOi

nhi tri

rna

pbd.

b)

VE

hitn

lio'ng , ti6ng

l)hrlc trinh

cira riy

ban

do

Hqi bign

r:hring

?:t

LuAn

Bdn

(Soci6l6

dialectiqne

de

Londres) dl nghi6r;-cirn

chc Lri0n

luong

tu cho l$ thln liutr vt

df, c6 sn nhAn xdt qua

50 bDbi

thl

r:gh{Qm,

rrlca 18(i9

nhu sau

:

r Mulri ba

ngudi

bln

nhgc

phb

ri

tron

c6

rnQt ilntr

hu&ng

l{c

phhrn

trEn tfang

Camille

lrla

rhmarion

vi6t

trong

I.t s

[orces

ineonnues

vi6t

: v0i

dbng

tfr

Ilusnpia Palladino,

lAm

chung

tuydn

bd cd nghe nhfrng

nh&hg

n "ric

cu

mr\

Nrdn

116

hh0ng

ndo

trio

dQIg

vio",. (Ilochas

trcng

33r).

nalu

rellcs

nguli ta

ngtre ti{Ing din

t0y

ban

chm

(Guitare),

Nhu

vAy

cnQc

tbt-ngbiQrn

cfrr

tOi

cd nhiing ttiEm

gieirig

vdi

cdc.

cuQc thf-nghiQm

qudc'16.

l[,)9.

Sau

dAy

li

nfic

tht-nghiQrn

qudc-td chung

nninh

cho

rti6ur

nhirr xet crin chring

tOi..

e)

I),or:has

viit :

<

I)rli khi

mQt

lnbng

gi6

l4.nh

t6n

ra

lroris

l0c

higrr

twon61

tqo thArrh.

Nhr,n

l9llt

bAe

si

Osty

giAm-tldc viQn

Si€u t$.nr-linh

qudc-t6

rrr& cfc

euQc

ttri

nghiQur

vdi

dilne

ti'r r:grroi

Ao

lh

lludi S;hneider.

()ng

c$ng

bd c{c

k6t

quA ci'ra

Ong

tl'ung

llic

phhr:r ;

<

Les

ponvoirs

inconnus

de

l'flsprit

sur

la

uralidrr".

r.

Nur

ri&y

ln

rnQt dogn

&

trang

59 :

<

'l

hrrcrug llrlronB ci'r

toa

hSng

nhi6n ho{c

rliirrg

thi:t

r*u van

rinr{

lhintr

linh iro

c:lm

thfiy

lqnh vA

phhn

nhibu

lil

tr:cing

efic

hnbi

thi-nghi{m

c6

hi€.n

tuqng

phit

xudt

(extririorisatior')

>

ilair

Willia*-r Grookes,

cling

xirn nh&n

tri0u

r.tri5rrg

nhiiin

tlQ...u

(trich

le

spiritrralisure

t anfl

15t),

kht

lnnh

;

q

lJirn

thri'

troug llecherches sur

,)

Kh0ng

chuc

hodn

phli

b6

dfr.

c)

MQt

li lrong

co

tqt

gid

plrtrong

tign

vA

khdng

c6

mQr

lb

hflo,

]cAc

cuQc

lht-nghiQm

cfia

chring

t0i

rtdnh

mfi

chring

tOi xie

ntrfln

tldng

lqnh

tir

tay dbng

t&

ti6t ra

Price ciing

t{{t

hdn

tlrfr

bi6u

vA

ghi

rluoc

.khi

lanh

t;fi

rrrJdn

11 4

vcri

cAc

hlQn

tuong nghidn-cuu cirng

dbng

t&

Stella

C.

(trong

Stella C.

,

an

account

of

some

Original

experimentr

in

trrstchical

rese&rch London

1935 vi.

r\baisse-

ment

cle i*

tempCrature

trocg

T'ra

t6

de

parapsychoiogie

Rend Su<lre

trang 271).

Khi

hruh

t6a

ra dfi

dusc chrlng

ldi

tudng thu{t

trong

eudrr

r

Nhtlng

hiQn

tuong si0u

blnh

> do chtrng

tOi

sog'n

ir

chu'ong

<

OAc

ng0i'nhA

bi ma

pbfr.

r

'T'FIAN

LINH

ITOC

il8

I

C

rlfi

th{y

TIIUAT

C{III'U

HdN

I49

tliDn

lq

liu:g

htrn

c&

tA

Ong

gia

frng

A chua

hb

bidt

clu

co

lir

gi.

vua

&

Qufirrg

l€n

thdy s$m

bln

co,

rl{t

tay

ngbi



Cf,u

chu5Qn

&

Nha-trang

md

anlr

hoc

sinh

hbn

ma

cta.r,

h.

H

Ue"

l€n

trong

phong'

t{ht

l4uh

&

trong

ptrOng

nAy

rfit

nbibu.

*

.

r*

|

NlrfrrrrT

cudc

|.hi

nqli4m

khftc.:

Vio

hhofrng

1933

6ng

X'

lArn

viQc

tqi

Kontum'

nnQt

tinh

tbn$c

cao

rtguyCn

r:ibn

rtanr.

Cdc

Ong

b+n

bey

tlrir

chu

co.

Dbng

tt't

ld rnQt

ngu0i

ch{u

c{ra

6ng

Y' CO

niry

l$n

ccr

vd

mlit

trOrn

lpn

tq

xung

lil

Nl'tJ,

Mtj

rr6i

t*

nay

kh6ng

eho

clic

hiin

kttAc

duoc

d6n

rlfly

choi

vil

tu

na1'

ctt6

nAy

d$rr6

rieng

clf

cau

ts

mil

t60i.

Qufr

',,1.13'

ti.

d4\

vb

sart

clri

cn dnnh

tr.ren

l\, .lt

xuf,r hi$n

ruil

ttrili.

Iliing

tri'lxh

c0

s

df,

lihong

cllr

c./

niia.

lldy

gin

cd

th0

cflrn

titlt

rtrir'

vrl t"

MQt

lttlut

c0

F'ii5t

nrot

trlic

thu

ngfiu

gdi

cLro

6119

Y

vir

hgrr"

vtri

hni

dng

XY

i6i

h(ru

dy

l IL)

l0n r:hsi'

i

Nhuug

OngiX

vtl

Y

sau

$icr

lArn

vi{c

ra

vF

qudn

ruilt

liri

hgn

r;{ri

cdn

M,tl.'['6i

fiy

hai.dng

ou5i

di

r?6rr

rrhCt

dng

A

choi.

'['rottgIt,r,

U"

u6uoi

ugiii

neri'cktry$rr

dr

ugoiri

ltti

ttrinh

llnh

ngirl lno

"r,

"o"y.

Ong

X

hOn

ir&i

tling

r\

:

r l{lnh

nlrr.r

bAq

**i-

qfiol

c$

?

D

0n1q

A

trfi

ltri

phAi'

rbi

nrui

hai

ngurii

barr

cirr:f,

hudc

vlo

gian

p :tlng

b0lr

rqnh'

.

0

aav

Oug

gia

6ng

A

tu

tinh

Qufrr'g

Ng[i

moi

lOn tlarrg

xony

m6t

cei

do

rdt

nhanh

'rA

rn

vE

giSn

dfr'

l-lir'

mffi

crr

vAn

khdng

chip

vidt.

Sau

cuug Ong

Y n'rfi

srpc

nghi

rJAn

cAn

I\t.13

hqn

tOf

nay

l6n choi

nri

v0

tlnh

hai

0rg

dii

qu0rr

nOu

m0i

ti6i

:i

t C{u

M

It, cldy

phli

khbrg

? >

Il6i

trai

bn

itr,

.o

m6i

tr*.

ldi

ld

phli,

tlnqn

tr6ctr

sao

hai

0'g

nAv

thir

thi b6trg

nhiOu

co

clrqy.

DiEu

niy

chung

16

rfing

6ng

gift

trrrg

A

hLr0ug

hb

b16t

cdr hai

clng

bgn cfia

Orrg

A

clang

rigiii rrguii

ndy,

vA

khfiug

hb

hi6t

cf,u

ctrutt?n

giao

du

gifra

gin

f4.I3

vd

lrni

Ong

K'r'A

Y. C&

lrai

Ong

X' Y

cflng

hhOng

frift

Ong

A c0

sfrrir

bdn

c<v

ntru'

thd

gifi

thuydt

truyEn

y

kht'irg

tiii

Irr\o to dttoc.

Snu

rni\t

thiii

E4ien

giao dn,

rnilt

hOm

c$u

M'

ll

l8n

co

nr0t

cfii,lr

bubn

r&n va

lt

gif,

hai

6ng

trqn

gii

rn

di

kh6ng

rdrr

lrr_:n

r

giry

tr6 lqi.

'Iu

dd

trong cdc

bubi

chn

co

kh0ng

l'E

cd

tlrr il{.

B^

[)rEn

nfiy

elrung

t6 su

xudt

hi$n

cin,

c{c;

vi

trorg

ciii

drn

iirrh

cri

tlnl.r

elictr

rlQe

fap

vi

sF

gi6 lu

cfra

bo

niia.

Nhu'

"fiy

blo

rirug

clbng

tft

dfi

lqo ra cAc

nhAn

v$t

theo

-f

rriuSu

cirn

ho

lr\

hodn

loin

sni

lqc.

Ohtng

la

khdng

thE

hfro

ri bi drn

intr

lray

tu8rig

tuo-ng

df,

tqo

ra

nhAn

v{lt'

ttl

irinh

kbi

su

tl6n

{ti cria

hq

ngodi

f

mu6n

cita

clrrlrrg

ta.

i

San

d(rlt td

trwtngt

hnp

utta

Quang

Trnnq

ftnq

il6ng

ldnt

lhr,r. IJti

niy

tlhrr6 tron

trong

tap chi

Ptrb

't.hdng

s6

207

ngAy

15.1.19(i8,

XuAn

M$u

'fh$n.

Nay

xin

tom

luoc

lqi

:

<

I(hofing

1 34

v*o

tlln

tbAng

nrudi

mQt

ndm

dy'ba

tOi

Ir\

Cfrrr

;\n

lOn hnyQn'T'frn

An.

Ngay

chibu

bclm

{y

ba

tOi

tiin thdm

Orrg

huy{n

lA

t'.

[.

vA rr1 nhan

di

birn

chim

c*ch

lru5fn

ly

dO

2

rdy

s6.

Tu&r:g

cling

nOrt

n6i

th€m

It

rrgdy

thudng

ha tOi

ft

6ng

dy

bay

phu diing

ti6n

hfing

cAn

vidt

tl*o.

I{ai

i'grrc'i

crlng

tli vi li}ri

thdy

nhiEu

bui

tre

lrt ngA

nXm r&i

lAc,

xen lf,n

nh&ng

dbi

ddt

xung

quanh lt

ruQng ba tOl

bdn hdi

6ng

huydn:

16l

hgn.

150

I

THAN

LINH

HOC

*

-

A

,t0y

nguli

ta eirrrg

c6

.

trbng

tre

lA

ng&

i ?

>

TIUAT

CHIBU

EbN

Ila

tdi

tlfp

16

:

(

Xin

chlo

NgAi.

r

Lfe

fiy

6n6

huyQn

151



0og

huyQn

dlp

:

r

Df,y xua

lA

lfty

'I'ty

son

hign

cdn

di

ttch

mQt lt rr

vta

dua tay

ctri nh&ng

dbn

lfry

hoang

vu.."

Khi tr& vB huyQn

dirng

errm xong

rrdi

tl5

hoAng

h6n,

c{ hal

nrdi

d{rn

xe

trdng

&

t}tnh

Dinh

l6n

.t8

vb

d+o

Kcrnlurrr.

T'rong

ldc

xe

vdn ch$y vA ngbi

tr0n

xe

ba

t6i

rndi

cii'u

tAc

mQt

hli

tho

tu

tuyQt vi6ng

liiy

'l'Ay

scrn

d8

doc

cho

dng huydq

ngtre.

Mrli dQc

cfiu

pI:A

:

s'l'hAnh

lfiy

ai

dAy

thil1'

rrgbn

ngnrrg.

r

(fng

hulQn

b6ng

nhi0n rtrng

rnilh ld_y

cui

tay

nid thric

nhg

vdo

urinh

ba tOi

'rfi

n*i

:

<

Linh

lfrm

I

>

0ag

hu'6rri thu&ng

lil

mr)t

c6t

rlhng (,nddiulr)

vi

flng

ily toin

ung

dbng.

CAi

ly

kj'

cria

e0u

chnj,'gn ndy

lA

I^n

rlbng

ngay

tr0n rnQt

chi6c

x'e

hoi

darr;;

ch?y

gii?a

r 0m,

mi

tdi xd vi

bo

hinh khdng

bi6u

gi

ri

chl

thfiy

hai

Ong

l

gr

n6i ctrulQn v&i

nhau, vA

thinh

thodng

Ong

huy0n

lqi.

rung lay I6n

khdng

vdi

cAi.

Ila

tOi

nhrnh

tri vi

uhu

-

<

Ndu

qufi

ll

thidrr

co

tray r

Ong

t.

L

libn quo

tay

trong

dOm

r6i

gi{ta

thiuh

kh0ng,

sb

nhiing

ndt chil

nbo rbi

dqc

ruQt

giqbg

trinlr

trgng

:

-

r

NgE

,Quang

Trung

Vuong

>

(uglria

tA :

Ta

li

Vua,

Quang

Trung

)

linh

c

(n

tlusc

diEu gl

ddp

:

hfiu

linh

m{

chrlng

gi6m

cdng

vi6t vdo

kholng

trdng

khdng

vi

n6i

:

r

DQc r

(nghia li

ttqc.)

Ila

tOi

bdn

doc lai

c&u

pbA

:

<

l'hdntr

lfif ai

rlily thfiy ngbn

ngang

>

rbi

ti6p:

<

(I

xua

llug Nhqc,

gi[c

l'Ay

Son

>

I

0og

I).

L f6

vE

ndng

nly

vung

mgnh tay, qugt

vd

sb

trong

ktr0n6 vu.n

la

:

<

Ngii

sb.

ngdi

rhy,

linh

l$nn.

n

, Ila

tdi bi6t

cnl

rnua

lAm

mdt ldng

vi auh

hung

df,n

tt)c

vi

ti6p l<)i :

<

TriEu

Ngur6n

'hjQn

thdi

goi

ngAi lA

ngul

triEu

tus

ld

gi{c

md

tfii

lA

l{guy6n

tritsu thln

tir

b{t <l[c

b{t

hiiu

xurrg

hO

> (nghia

lA

chtrns

tOi

ldm.

toi

Ng'.rydn tribu n6n tbAt kh0rrg

bi6t goi

Ngti

lA gl

cho

ph:ii)

bfit gi{c

nlgo

phgm

rl6n

oai

linh

cira

NgAi

cbo

t6i

xin

sfi'a lai

nhu

sau

:

<

NgAn

xrra dB

lai

ti6ng

Tly

son

r.

Ong lr.

L

dua

tay

l0n

rhi

ri6i

:

<

Ngii

khuy€n

> (cho

rti6m

son)

vi dng

ti6p

u

Ngf,

tue

cbi

,

(,lA

ta

lAm

ti6p

theo cbo

)

Cbi dO

6i6y

l0u

chua tht{y

ti6p

ba

tdi

thua

:

(

IOi

dfl lArn

sin xin

cho

pbep

duo..c

dgc luOn

iIb

NgAi

phir-clrlnh

cho.

))

Ong huygn

,lip

gen

:

r

DQc

r.

Ba

tdi

liEn

ng0m:

.

Bd lre

chung g6c

cdn

ranh nqdt,

Khi6.n

khdch

qua

itatng lu6ng thi'.

thon.

TrrAN

LiNg soc

(ngu

J

vl

su

ctria

r€

clra

ba nnh

tm'I'Ay Son

nOn su ngtri6p

arrtr

htng

phii tnn v& kh0ng

duoc chnng

ndng

lilu

dAi

nhu

TT{U,/IT CTIITIU

IION

Lt'rc

iry

vu{t

Qunng-'[rung

tlrilt

"

l8n

IXng : < Di NgnJdn

rti

\ruryrrg,

rlnygt

ril

tigu;,Q1

di

Nguy,

khl

qi6u

I r

(dgi

,34

153

152



b& tre

ng&r' bdm

nar).

Nghe

drrc

xong

vus

(Junng-'l'nurrs

clrinh

lqi

ngsy

:

McTc

khttch

qua

rtrirng

thw&ng

utvi lhott.

l)

{.y

A

cAi khl

phAch

ci,a

vnn

Qrrnrrg

'l'cutt,g,

klr0irg

cRl

su

ehO

hhen

qi

theo

su

nb{n

xdt cita

thAu

P[ru

chting

t(ri

thl Ong

P.l,

khdhg co

cAi

khi

ptrfich

hi0n

ng*ng

dy

vd

thi

titi ciilrlJ

rhru thgong

kh$ng

sao

sii'a

lhry

nltnrirh rrltrr

ti

6

d

rn

tl-C

l'ho

)rol)F

b4 t0i

rndri

xin

l6i vd

xi,r nri6n

chfip

rlto

su

xur.g hO ban

niiy"

Vur

Queng-.lirung

trl

ldi

:

Chich klugbn

plft

Nohi|u

phi

ki

cltit

:li,i.

(Tgnr

dich:

ch6

thlng

dn

tr0m

tdn

Chieh

efn

vua

N6[ri€n

vt

khdng

pbli

lf chtr

n6,

J

rrghia

chuy$n

rtrtri

thdng

thurfng

lA ttid

dy,

vA

cd

f

mia mai

tlr0tr

phu

l0i ln

k0

tOi

rl$t

cfia

nbA

Nguy6n).

$du

d6

bn tQi llm cAu

ddi

dA

kf

niQrn

bubi

b.grh

ng6:

Anh

lphno thdnh

bsi

bdt di

hQn,

Cb

n{rdn

ngtu mii

yhd

thilA

h6.

(cd

f

blo

:

ngu{i

anh hirng hop

thun

kh0ng

cln.

'fhfii

dO

eira

ngu&i

xua

t{

dhu

ai kOn

mllh

bhng ngqa'

hiirrg

trAu

cfrn6

ktr0ng

cEi, nghia

lt thci

dq cfia

k6

qu[n

tri khdng

ldy

su

d6

lAm

qurn Ltrong).

CAu

ily ciing

ll

l6i

choi

ch&

ddi

dfp od

thlrn

f

dtng

(

Dguu mH

r

tr& tri

ldi

ch&

s

KhuyDn

n.

cirrg

lri ho

Ngri16,r

vtivl

nban

mi

kE

vua,

ugur'ri

pifc

budn

clrcrl

l.ha'r.

f

u,it

rrrr)t

bErr

lA

(]ra

Lor.'g N6uydn

Anh,

n:Qt

trdn

l;\

Ngu16n'tAy-Snn)

lla

tui

tidp

ltri:

tl)i

SBuyGn

{li

Vucrng

rlul

f.t

di

Ngu

i

6n

cli

Ngrry,

'

huu

di Nqnydrr

di

tiri

bin

vuong,

h,}n

nrrly

chi

gi.'tir

cAnh

kll&

li6u

I (y

noi rict

bdu

Ngulijn

lA

vua, urQt

hOn

Ngnriin

lA

nguy

(gi{t}

nrrl

Nguy6n

l0i

iai

&

5,iiin

Vuung

rr\

N6uy,

Igi ln

chulQu

'i6ng

bubn

ctrcrr

horr

nirn).

X(hr

xe

lilt

r

el6n

Irleikrr

thi

hi

Iiu

tu{y,

pl:fii

ngrlrng

l4i

srin

chiin.

Iili t6i

,rA

dng

huy€n

budc

xrrdrnq

rirrdrirg

di rlao

clroi.

t,rir: bi\y

g

cr

trfirrg

vrla [0n,

Ong hnyQn

lui

urrg d0rrg,

ebi

n:{t

lrdrrg

mt t-rpffm

rrOt

bfri

ttro"

I'rour1 b:\i nAy ?rIa

,Quang'['rung

rr6i

{b

su

n6tri$p

cira Ngr}i.

R$t lific biii

nguy€n

tA: iiy

bn

l6i

khdng

ntru

chi

nho

bAi

hoa

v{n ciia

ba

t{il

lAilr

r:hu

satl :

Cao lhdur

b\t

ttic thi tri

thdnh I

7'rrbng

tliir ar:dr.

hilnq

it?ii rtouptl

nrrrrh.

Thi\n

ib

lwu'lunn

thdnh

beii

s{r

Ngd

birrh

tton(t'nh[t kli6p

phong

thanh.

(l)i0n n0rn

1l+i

9

;

rtrAritr

iao,

no

sdn

khfirrg

dir

kE'

nb*rrg

ktrt

phdch

anl.r

htrng'

'vdn

chdi

rqng

nhu nrdt

trlng'

Etros

thua ehuyQn

rrpiv

xua'chi

s{

k0,

ndn

ghi

nh&

ngdv

no

qusn dQi

'XAu

nghe

tl6ng

gi6 mA

khi6p

sa oni

rlanh

ngAi)'

Khi,fly

Ong

P'L

hign

thtn

r{c

dbng

cira

Qurng-Trung

'Yuong,

cn&i

l0n,

Phe

blnh

hhen

rflng

:

l5t

I

ttrArv

uNu noc

<

.-

Thinh

vhn

hq

dfrc

hu&rrg,

blnh

mang thri:

cr? dai

hfiu

lm

vln.

(Nfihia

lA hqa v{n

thinh rdt

c6

lnh hu&ng"

TIIUAT CIIIOU

Hd)N

tb5

CuQc

g{p g&

c6

mQt

khdng

bai

nty

chi

x&y

rn

mQt

lln

md

thOi, m{}

dlu

con

dbng P.

L vAn

edn

c6 kh6



chuy6n

udy

dang

tli dgp lo4n c6c

bQ

lqc chfrc duoc

ti6ng

riu,)

1*

Luc

bdy

git}

re sfra Kong

n6n

lrai

Ong

bqn

ti6p tuc

cuOc

hAnh

trinh

vA

ddn

Pleiku.

Xe

ugung t+i

dirng

gili

kh{t vA c$u

chu}Qn thfin

tiCn ciing

l6ng xao.

Ddn

Korrlum

lirc

ily de

1?

gic

khuya,

Ong

bqn

N.

'I'"

cfing thua

ptr{i

6'

tigo

Kontum

ben bAy but tiOn

ra.

Ong

l)

t,

lqti

ung

tlbng

chm

vi6t

soo vi6t.

Vong

Unh

vua

Quang

'l'rung

lai

lnh{p

vb

lom

thta

rn& dIu

cdu

nhu

sau

ntrng

l6n nhfrng vu

dbng khAc

vA rn[c

cho long

ao utrc

mong

tAi ngQ

cfia thf,n

phu

t0i. Ntru

o4.y

hiQn

tuong

nAy

r{Sng

lrru y" Ta c6 thb d{t

giA tbuy6t

:

._

hbn

ma

ndo

rlii

nl+o danh

Quang

Trung

?

Ndu

gifi mqo

mA

ddrrg

duo.

c

nhu

ttr6

cflng ddng

khen

I

Nhrrng tr6

gil

nrao

chlrr6

niia no

cilng

chung

u:inh

rluoc

crf rnQt

tLtE

gioi

si0u hinir ugoii

th6

gioi

cfia chung

ta.

--

con dbng

t'}hgm

L,

dn

b6c

rlling

v,A

clri

do

tibin

th*c ctra

y

ctrfing?

ViQc

ndy

th{t khd

dfr ll\ cim

hung

(inspiratiorr) tqo

ra b&i

vi

seo

colr dbng

[).

[,

kbdng

co

co

hQi tqo

,8. nhfrng bubi

khdc

vA

hhrh

*ntr

Quarig

I'rung chi

lcre

16:r trong

ddm

ldi

mQt

lin

thdi ?

chrtnpr,

(6

tinh

cAch

dQc

I$p cira

su

xufit

hiQn.

-

vi$c

ldn

tlbrrq ngay

tr0n

xe dang

chqy,

pi6a

rirng

nui,

di

tir

tloqn

tlu&ng

Pleihu-I(onlunr

rdt

lv

ky,

so

voi

cAc

cuoc lhl,

nghiQur cira cic

nhA

bdc

hoc Au-Mj

trong,

phdng

thi

nghiQrn thl

rilt

nOn

ttro

vA

phdnq kho6ng.

at

a

CAc cngc

tbi

nslri$m

khfic.

B6ru

29.tt

l9)t).--

.

I-ric

9

gid

nr8i.

Co

lOn vA hrli

:

CO

mudn

bi6t

l€n

khOng. Giu.

<'Ibi6u dilu

vi6t

cho

dir

dilu. Ihi6u chfr

ri6ng

(qo[

thst

tr0n

bAn

co

quOn

ghi

chft

h,san

c6

th€rn

vio),

Minh

ngdgdt

so

canh chiEu

cb

thdnlt

1l

l,

i

I

Itiit ti6c

mdy cf,u

sau bn tOi

khOng

qr

rgb

v$n

cira

Vua

durli

dfty

:

nircv nnl

tho cfra

tii

liQu

Ong nghd

chi

cdu

nhd bAi

r n6

ry0n

theo lh&i

gian

:

N.

T

bea

bAi

n

Qu6c

th&. lud.n uonq Imdnq

thfr

thdrth

I'h&

ldm trudng d4r nqugtt c6

ntinh.

Anh hlrng

di hdn,

nan

ltlnm

:vtr

I[6i

thinh Ifi

tla"

itoqn tuc

thanh

(Bqi

i

;

Nuqc cdn

nghidng

ldng

nAy

r,ii

sdng

rrlnh

trln

j;

clm

gi$n lirn khi nghe

ti6ng

fm

chi

hlc

Cy

ngucri

PhAp

d0

kdn cdc

llnh thuong

thbi

tbi

nfio nb

cbua

x6t t)

vlo kholng

3

git

khuya.

. s * . .

tlb

budng

chi

lirinh

kia".

khuya, cfi ch6

anh hirng

kou rhb d&n

rhbi

to ie

h0

df,n

ta

ndn

khi

nghe

cAi nhue vong

qudc

th4t

Vua

Quang

'Irung

khen

bAi

tha

hay

rbi thlnfi.

Lric

fiy

.

TTIAN

T,INII

EOC

san

d6 xuns

ll

Knai

Hun6).

phqc

TlIU,iT

CHIEU

HdN

Khrli srl I

giir

tdi.

l5;

-.

Giu

inni ch{t

(r'd

r:hdl



vi

u.rtrl

Lrbn

lSi iltS

c"i

v*o.

XiLr

D6 rhd

llirng

&

120

(ialli6ni

SAi

gc"rn,

tl;rrrrilg

Clrcv

l&n

vi hdnh

brii 2

giti

nrdt hon sirrh trurhg

'I'aberl.

tl

6iir

trma.

Hbn'Au thi

Ntji Lf,

rri?

(snn

l<ri n0i

chnS$n

phi6m

vF

r,f,rr

'l'oirrr

g{p

rna

vA

vong

ndi

kh0rrg

th,\nh

tr6

b'ii

nhilng

chuy$n

khdi

hdi rni cucri

tri

rrgrrr. i

trong cry

vi

gifri

tAn hft.

l.rie

l0

'l

iray

ngu&i

chci

co,

cc

chqy

ra

v6

trang

l(tri'ri

su vi6t:

-*.

'l'a

tlAv (ehi

chfr

ydu),

Kii0r"ig

tlucc

hii

lril

lhdri.

Pi:fri

lhlrlr

ldrrr.

6'

Any

cf

ai kh.6ug

tin bCu kia

rhd

E,i{.'i

li

cl

urr)i

,rii-lilr

tlii3.

huytir-bi

ttridng liOn{,

cd

rrrur,rir

ir"i(u

sinh

lirrir

lJiri

Ito,r.i't

tung

linlr-hiin

mQt tr&

vb que

rlrrAn.

Ilo

t;,1ni{

rouEg

ttiu'n

tnr ruo

hti, tin tu&ng

quA

nhiErr

{l

''40

eiri.l

hiri;rir nhtrirnSl

ciii u

rn nh,

tq

l4o

Id.y ngl:iQp uhu:drng

',,otg

l0

gio

i)0 n- qrt trii

xi-(

lOn cho

hnv bi

klch

dv

FId ug

(

trlc F)t

niirrp,

).

12

girlr

05

(lrr'/i

rnua)

khri::

l0n

xr-r

nl;

lh thg

miry

r'r' Hfri

phr)na

m{t

iric

lrhiip

trh&i

iiiln

iI

tlrii

plrong

ngoii

khsi

bXn

trrl

ri:Qt

lAt

rili

xirr

rli, Vu

con

chdt

hirt.

clrrrv€n

ndn ban

116

xeru

tlrtrti'ng

gi,r

I6n

llng.

nglri6m"

v

ue

12

64in

25

xtr;,g

lA

ho:

f

rd

ehil't

(}

rrhd

hl:uYa

ngriy

'l4,ll

l9;0

.'igir

28

8

191-10

lrl::

1A

b,;nh

vi{rr

Vinh

y(u)

c,tr tho

ii;

--

[1rn

apr&y

lny

thAn

I'oirr

rli

Yinh

Sachnnakhet

Nirrr

nio

?

19 t6,

--

Hi hufin

?

..*

Y t[

gifii

phdng

qufrn

dr)i

cirdt

t'l

L&o

phfin,

lheo

anh

Viln nyArr

oanh

t$c..

'Irdn

eno

VAn

hhu

hdt

hQ

l0n ndi

giqng

luy0tr

truy8n.

hhOng hilm soAtilt tl69 chung

tOi

khdn$

?

17

tbAng

7

0m

lieh

ntrm Canh

dln).

niii:ir

r:lr,1Lr

ciic n6uui tid tin-lu6'ng

liri ta.

Nay

c$

riiilu

V'itki

thiir

rn.4c

?

Chdt

di lil trirt

tfit

e&

n.h[]ng

r.['r

bfr

,'ii{

1[q1

x1'[r:4

rr0,

Ngr:rui ln

lirog

l'gn

trlro'c

o{i

c'rrit

r0

l;tr drr,rc

sdr;g

rnQt

rllrli

inh-tiin,

hbling hi

tri

iroii c, rrr

d6,

kririug

lhiinr

lunr" sdng trong

tiuh-llo"l

ctra

r,

;rl t,ol'll l;ir

lrrt"r;rgi

lhanh-rinh ciia

ldnF |rgr::r.l

nili

liirrrrl{{

(:i

r);,1

hl

c/:. c{r liirrg ldr hhOnp"

l)un dS diilt

la

r:lrliti

lrar:h

cl e np'uoi,

Nav

rnudn

l.6i

iii

?

i{6rii

tu

xwng

ld

ydir.

Xin rio h

6rr nshin

ehii r0ri

tdi

ttrdy

lcri

16

cfia

l{gnr

r:lrung

t{'i

kirrlr

rn6n ra

rlu

kh0irg

pbfri

lA

Yeu.

t*n nla dai

vl

giiia

dtrtrng tri

chl

cirp

clrri

yrhu

van

ria o.

rJir ir

i

lrii

:

t',i:

rt

l g

l)ris t

d0

m$t

hbn

tu

v$

Nhiing

lAi

li{u niy

tgi

dB

xem c$

rftlng hay

[n',hp :

]ihdng,

khOng, YAu

li-

tu: rl,rn :

ta.

Ngrrcri

nAo

Iltu6u

f;i

?

llrir

:

Lin NgAi

cho

b,6t

bif

t h,;rr

rrra

N.ei,

Dr[p:

llodng

Long.

'I'irng

s:guol

ruot nruiin

gt

cho

thAnh

that

lo st

xdt vA

trl

ldi.

Ngrv

THtrN

LINII

IIOC

I{UAT

CHIEU

I'dN

Edp : Nguo.i

giA

thl sinh

bgnh

trduh

sao khdi luat

ru

nhiOn,

cdn lho y6u

lA

m{nh

trcyi.

1 l-r9

t58

0. I-. : []Au khdi

tlau

ydu

vA

g;s

tlinh doln

trr.



O"

t,.

: f

l6i cflirrg darrh

llf,p:

Ngrl'1,i 11 i

cS

cotl

lcrn g,{rnLr vtic

"'j0n

gia

dinir,

' o

gl

flr-.r'p

rhiir.g rrgiy

cfi

r r6r.

la

hLoug lrfi

gifitr nlrrng

ra

s1I

ldu

l\ri6n

eu

qd

h4i

cho

ngroi.

il

t;,

hiri

:

t'lli ef

giAn

khOnn ?

Drlp: Nguo'i

erl

gfrng thi

mo'i

rhinlt

cftng. N6oc

khOng

gi{ia

khCrcg

rn:ii

clrng

thAnh

t'6

dung.

0.

g.

hdi:

ll6i

y

ki6n vb nrot

cu$n

srleh.

Dirp:

llitu

rA

lq

nhi6n'huung sao nguo'i

lqi

h6i

ta

?

0

D"

h6i:

ioi

cd

Ong cu

nilm

nay

82

tubi tbutrng

dau

l6u

ln(rn, Jl0nh

liuh

th6

rrio

Ong cho tri$t.

FI6i:

Xin cho

n:Qt

cfiu.

A0 tam

chArn ngrln.

H6p

:

'I'tri€n

{c

rlAo

rltrn

e

hung

hfiu

bdn.

Cfii dur0rr lni tlo

du-

lsri

tiry.

'

tioi

: Xin tu

nry

n:6i khi

eliu

err

du'oc

g{p

lrh6t

'l'trAnh

'l'rir-r

1io5.

uUn nhAn

kirdri bi r,an

vong

khufly rdi.

Brip'

lli6u

rrlrfin li

rr ot

d:ie

tinh

rlA

lhrinh

tun

&

<l<ri.

Kh0ng

udn

l'ffp 1dp" I)uc

ndc

hi{t

rlat.

Iliri : lrl6n clrrvi

rry

khfinc ?

DAtr :

i)Av kh0ng

plrfri

Ir\

ru0l,

trr) chr:yi

qili

trt.

Bf;y

lA

un$i ngn6'ng

cri'a

glit

trhitr

rru$. th6

gi<ri

b0n

kia.

r1r,6 lruc,rrq

virrir vi6lurrln

n'oi

tri6p

n6rlr.:i

tAm

h,/.

t'ir

l

tlreo

lr)nq

thAuh

rnA

r:r'r

f

nghia

Ich

lqi.

tlt'ri

:

Ngdi cd

tir

rla.r

l)hdi

kirdrrg

?

I)Ap:

'['6r

r:iirg

bi6t it

nhibu

rlgo

ly

qna il&y

fip

eAn

ngud',i

hrinh tilrrr

n0rr

glre

l*.i

rlArn

dao

ddi cArr.

itiri:

Ngii

&

ttilu

ddn

'l

Ddp

:

Il0n

dli

sdq( u

i.nlulr

fihdng gian

tuy

c6

n.rd

h'bdIrg.

ldng

thr)uh

m$t

gifl;'

trrirng

ni$m,

ngin

d{m

ciing

td tflc

garrg,

Ii6i

:

VAng

b4c

vb

crii

rr

r:rrirrh

cr

dirnS{

dmgc

kh0ng

?

D0p : Ddt

ving

nn5

lA mOt

tin tu.&ng

cfra tring

ng*dri

cha lne

hc{c

0rrg

bi tih

trr&ng,

dr)

"dng

mir kia cd <lirng

duoc

hay khdrrg

nhung it

ra

cfing

lAm

vua

ldng

nguoi th&n

quy6n clfi

khudt.

Ddp, Nhrln tdt

thi

sanh

qufr

tdt.

Chu

ngny$n

cbi

dA

t6

1016 mlnh criii lnrong thi$n chir

phii

eIAu

id

su

nintr hdt

bo <tii'

thr'rrrh thdn.

Ii6i:

Xirr

rlrfr

{hudc

u<jng

li6o

hay dnu

l6u.

It4fi : Ililrg 16

ta

chilng n6j

ra. I'{hu'ng

edc

ngroi thirrh

lAin

lhl

la

nrAclr

li0

tlelt ln

nghi. Drlng

bf,n

hboi-{n rrhii'ng

cAi

\tri r'g

,ldu

ttll nroi s1r

liit

.lnnh.

(

).

L"

'

{

lorr

trni

t0i li

tl

rtrirrlr

rrgr\"y

thr\ulr

h,}n

lfr

l'i

lhir

rrg cli,rp

1., lrr'rrfl

l)

6t

v<r chbr,g

rltriirg

n{.r

san rri.y

th{

nio

?

D'ip: Vrr

rlriing

lA

drr\,0n

ncr

,rLii

ddi

cfirr

nqnr0n trr'ri

rlirrtr

pt

rii

'rAn

ll\

ldt

x?Iu

lai

tlrrlng rrgiy ruA

phdi

thIr

rr:iic

cho

hAn

l$

rrr.

cdu

ndi

r60

lIIAN LINII

HOC

Il6i:

Eai

srr

Vi€n-GiAu

Chira

Bala.

'liro'::6

THIJ,il'

CrrrEU HdN

Dtp

:

TAur

tqm

bift,

t6l



ciii mdrrg

lrrng

ngutr.i

{y ilf

tl4t

n6u;gn

riii.

Dqt ngu_y$n

tuc

ld

thdnh

rlgo

chdng

?

Nguoi

lin

ti6n

lr0tr

sor

durln,nfi

tlqg

v0

bi(lp.

Nfrr.r

rrg:ii

rndi

V.

(lif.s tl+i

su,

'I'a

khOng

cb

quy8n phdp

l{1.

Xirr rrrQt

ldi

d+y

cho Di{n

.r\rrlr,

Di

it

:

Di{u

Anh,

trong

tOn

r0 chil

l),$n tri.e

ctrn lrE;'ry;i

rr

.rui

I)lr0t dau

c0rr lirr s'h1il lj' rlAu

tl6i

: Xirr

n{Ai

cho

tri

rrtiCr.

Hdp

:

Cfi

rlinLi

tJl.nr

fit lil phiri

,,1r,:..

CEn

u,.ong

rrfiil,n6;

srr

viS

r

',,0r':r{

klrrlng

phfri

ln

viQc

rlA;,g

ltrr.r.

tl6i :

,Krn

,i:hci

N.

K.

E. rnQt l*i

rla,-

i-)lp

:

'l

fi'rr

ihinh cfiru

thi6n

rIi.a.

(l)u

rririiln

hiri

chi lr[la

chdn11

?

IIbi :

Xin

,:ho

lri6t

thli

cuQc

edir

ho.,)

l0u

rnoi

ilr.ri

dinl;

'/

I

Ilrip

I'ang

thuorg.

Il6i

:. Kin

ngS.i

cho rd: c

Ydu

lA

tlr

r

dqnh

ta.

)

Dl|pl lllrlo

lA

dudng

elri

ctt mot :

qrrdrr

mlrrh.

I]fit

t{t

phfii

lhfic

mfi.,: irEn

nhirug darrh

tft.

t'l6i

:

tl'rrg

tr6i

gt

niia

kllerng

'l

I)Ap

:

Kin

ti*

on ngAi,

chring

tOi

dff

rnEu

ngu5gn...

lrtc

di

thIru

ngu<]i

c0 &

Lang

Son

dau tinr

h1,: ffy

17 tubi.

Qud

qu6n

tru

rrnl;

l')Ong

Kh6ul-r.

(Ithrlng

ki&ru

Luc

fiv l*

2

gi,)

kiruya.

Itc

B

gid

20.

ilIQt hbn tq

xung

l;I

Nguy6n thi

'I'tranh-IIi

rnfit ilong

nfun

1939,

Llm

binh

d

lJlnh

[)inh

c6 lroe

so{t

lqi

ly

lich

dn,oc).

DSrn

7-10-195{)

Cry

chr,v vil

vi6t

bii

Lircy

linirng

:

N$u$cI l$:

6 tE .suo'ns

nrdn

thitn.

Giurttt

plnnq nql

h6u rt6r

sdu

mi|n.

Cd

ld tlrunh

nsolLi

hdtt

sort

ttp,

'

I)Ct

btitt chunq

tlnnh

tld,o

khdch

l/rrrglri.

ll6i

:

Xin

chn

hi6t

t6o

eifr

bdi

thry.

C:

llny

rht

ng0m

choi. Cho

rui.

C6c

ehn

t6c gii

cfing

chliug chn

hgc ai.

VEn

chuong

ln

cria

chung

cfra

cria

nhfin loai.

fl,ii

:

Xin ngii

cho

bi6r

danh

hiQu"

Ddp :

Ddn

,IAy

rinh

cd g{p

cfic

Ong

rhl

n6i

chuyQn

choi. Crdc

nira

no6i

ngu&i

m6i

ngl bidt

t6n

nhau

chi

lh0rn b{rr

long

nhau.

HCri : Xin

cho bidt

de khi

cln

mrii

ngAi.

D6p:

Am ducrog

rl6i

ngl

li6t

nhau

khi

nio

hay

khi

dy. l,inh

bbn

lsnu

ng{y

lia xAc

thit

sC dung

hda

cirng

Ddp

H6i

DAp

rI6i

Brilr

II6i

D€m

9

9-11J50

li

cri

x8.

:t

,tt

il

ir

it

i.

{

;l

'fl

,i

',

,|

fir

t1

{ l

dI

ll

,J

lr

rli

rl

i

i

102

TEAN LINE

Eoc

vfi

tru dAu

cilng

lt

c6,

dAu

cfing

lt

khdng, khdng cdn.

c6

su

phin

niet

giila

lbln

ngfi

vdi

nh&ng sinh

linh,

TTIUAT

CIIIEU

EdN

S&a

rnlnh

chua duoc

tOi dtu'dlm

day

et

?...

(rlfry

r03

c6

lE ln



ry

Il6i

:

Ngni

c6

phli

rl

II6i,: Ngii

c6

DAp:

1'hi6n ildn

r'i

stu

khi ttfl

"b

QuCIn

ghi

nglv.

Ccr lOn

:

'l'Ae

gi6

ll6i: Ddi

sdng

nlt&

biu

tinh

Lhdng

phli

li

I

mlnh,

phf

tan buc

thinh

lch

hi

gifra

mlnh

vl

nguiri;

ngudi

vir

minh,

khOng

c6

sq

tranh

gilnb,

gi{t bfrn su

LrQng

trfing trong lOng, dfim

nrlnh tronf, v{t

dtrc

thdi

lha,

gAf

lily cho

mlnh mai

snu nr0t nghl$p chudng

khOng

bi6t

bao

lgid

mdi

gQt

sqch.

C{c

nguiri

mudn

h6i

gl

?

lA

HoAng

Long dqo si

kh0ng

?

mQt

kE

phO

tro

lroug

cdi vO hlnh c6

nhtQrn

vu

nhfrng kA

mdi

viro

cdi ttt).

Oon

riit

nhibu

chuy$n

ccr'chung

tOi

ch6p

thirnb

hai

lAp

v&

song

rrhfn thfiy

viQc lrlch

dfin

lhOm

khOng

tiQn vl

tlly

li

mQt

t4p kbfio

ludn.

Vgy

chring ta hfiy di

vio

phln

hdt

lu|n & dogn uly :

Sau cric cugc

thi nglriQm, chrlng l0i

nh{n

ttrily

rfing

eic

bubi chi0u

hlin

thuAt kh0ng

dua

lqi

kdt qul

rtrong nrudn,

vl rffng:

1.

-

CAc

hbn h6

ch6t

kb6ng bi6t

gl

ho'n

ta vb

cdi ho

& ho[c

bo c:ho

ta

nhibu

qnan

nigm sai llm

nOn

Df,p

:

Kh6ng.

FIoAng

[,ong

le mQl

b$c

thidng liOng,

pbrip

cao

si0u l0i ld[u

dAm

sAnh.

la

gilp

cira

cty

gifp

d&

viQc

hge

rlugc

cAc

lrrit

ti6p

phii ln

mQt

nhd tu hAnh

ktrong

?

&

trong

l6ng

mqi

ngudi

rlEu c6.

Hon

tlrrrnng

gibi

linh

trhn

kbdng edn

bfn

bfr

lo-i

danli, rl:lm

dudi

tfonq

eic

dqc,

nOn

ldng

rlusc

tfirl

no

rho;...

:

llo-vo,

lrOn

hia

th6 gioi

?

DAp

:

Nguoi

tribn

thl

ch6t

cfiug nhu sting. Tfrm

tbBn

lfc

nio

cirng

lhu

thdi

Am

duang

cd

khAc

6l

nhau bao rrhiOu.

Ch6t

ctri ti trrit

btt nhfrng

phln

tr?

nf,ng

nL cfia

tQi

16i...

'tdi

rilt

bubn mA

n6i

chuy$n

linh dit

rlqo

lf

v&i c{c

6ng.

BE

bro

n[m

lang thang

tlAy

tl6 tOi

kh6ng

mfiy

khi

thf,y

ai nghe

tlibn

phli

mA

chiu khd srla minh.

Nghe

tbfly

diBu linh

nhu

xem trd

mtld rdi. Vi

th6 nghe

h6i

chuy{n

dqo

lJ' dtng

ra

tOi

iivui,

t6i ding nly bubn

lqi

th6m buiin.

h6i

hda

ra

r'0

ich

trir rfit

f

t

co

hQi

chring

vi

ti6n

lrda hon

ta.

'l'heo

hurbn-lil hoc

ciii

xrlc

phkn

nhrEu

tA

cdi

trung

gidi.

Cdn c{c

trdv

vts vtri

su binh tinh

c0

ra

circ

bQnh

lo4u t0m

thhn

kh6 liOn

lqc.

2.-

CAc

Uubi chi0n

hbn

cd

hgi

vl sinh luc

cira

rn

iri

rdt

uQt

F.hhn

ri6u bi

inh

hu&ng

cfia

pdc

htln hem

c6i"

3.-

CSc Uubi

chiOu

hbn c6 hqi ndu

dbng r&

khdng

cbi

ceo

hcln

rilt

mQt

tfim

hbn

cung rln dG

sinh

(trudng hop

nty

tlf,

xiy

ra

cho

ntQt ngutii

quen

vdi

chrlng tOi).

'1.--

SF

thi6n

thl

giri,

phuong

tiQn,

tb

chric dE

chdng

lOi rufr cAc

cuQc

lhi-nghiQm sf,u rQng

hon

c6

ttnh

cdcb cdc

cuQc

tht nghlQm

.

cfia

cdc

hQi

Tdm

linh

hlu c6 rh6

ki€m

nh{n

c{c

hiQn

tugng

mQt c6ch khoa

hgc.

161

TTTAN LINH

HOC

5,-

Theo

truyEn

bl

hoc

rilt kho

phtn

biQt

duoc cfi

titth



cfia

ctg

hbn trong

co,

nh{n

diCn durvc

hn

lil

ai,

vi

coil

mlt

thit

c&a

phiilr

trhn

;

nhu

v4v hg

cd

thb

lira

bip

duoe

to,

ugay

c& rltin tfr

cfrn6

cd

th6

lfta

la niia. Vt

cfic

lE dd

cbring

tdi tt5

qu 6t

dinh

chdm

ddtt

loqt

thi-rrglri$r.rr

san hon

mQt

ndrn

thqc

lghi$m.

I{F.t-lud"n:

D$u

sao

k6t

lu{n

cira

chrtng

tdi

vdn

t

: Cd

mQt

th6

girti

si6p

hinh

ngoli

ttrd

gi6i

c&a

'

chung

ta'

Cltc

hiQn

tuong

vi)

ttbng

b6ng

cd

khi

do dbng

tfr trny

cfr

tga

tqo

ra,

sorg

cd

khi

li

do thd

gio'i

v0

hinh"

,

Muiir

ki6ur

s[rfit

hiQn

tuotrg

it

nhiit

phfii cltra l'2

giA

tlruydt

dE

tlenn

{b

nhu

chuong

trutvc

dAl

rt6

rlb

cfip

d6n'

ctruans

lv.- slAl

tnicH

vAl

HIEN

rugNo

obrus

BONG.

1)

Ldnt sflo

qua

r{uryc

udl

chdt

ud

phdn

ldch

hiin

tLrortq

c/rrry?tlt

di.

l{hfirig

k6

ktr&o

eu,n

vE thhn

linh

hoc

d5

duoc chirng

hi4n

nhibn

hieu

tuong

la hi'

uhu

lroDg

phdng

tht

nghidnn

uE

chi0u

lriin

thuat

b6ng nhi6n

hi$n

i6n

rrhfi ng

v0

t

la

{rl

a hon,

rnQt

vien

d[)

trong

lirc

3{y bfin

lrt cfra

dirrg

hin

rnit hinh

nhrr

ln

nhfrng

vSt

df

dii

di xuy0n

rlna

vr{ch

trro.ng

ktrSng

kA

gl d6n

vflt chdt

c& tro{c

ldi

chfr v0

hinh

tll

nhi6n

hiQn

l0n

trong

nhfrng

htlp

dtrng

kln"

l(trOns

n6i

r 6n

sr.r

hip

ltcrm cira

dbng

tri' mh

chring

ti'ri

dn

trinh

biy &

rloqn

truoc

song

ndu

d{t vdn

tlE

lA

hi{n

tnong

r:6 that

thi

chfng

ta

phai

gili

thlch uhrr

th6

ndo

?

IlAc

si

Gibier

vA

lrAc si

Sanguineti

rJii

chung

ki6n

hi(n

t'.rong

{y.

B{ tuoc

Centurione,

rnot dbng

tt'r c6

khfl

nlrrg,

tri mfit

tlch

rrong mot

cuQc

tiri

rrgbiQnn &

lau dii Millessirno.

Sau

rldl

ngu<ri

ta tlm

tirdy

6ng

ta

lrong

rnQt

phong

ctra

toi

lAu

.ini

irfiy. Orig

hh6ng

hiEu

si

sao

O0g

ta

lqi

niim

t,

d6?

IliQn

txqng

Cy

cfing

duoc

Alfred

Russel

Wnllace

rl

I

THAN

LINH

IIOG

THUAT

CUIT]U

H6N

hoDg

vu bt

Guppoy duqo

dua

trt

mqt

phdbg

bd

ra srog

I

c{c

cupc

tht

nghlem

v chlcr

hbo

thu{t

trong

sd

Cy cd

Dgoi

nbt

&

LtrrF

al6D

ve cia Loebroso

ri rruang

hop

I ;

-"H-

,rra"o-rin

it5

rdi

ru6ng

tet

pbdtrg

tht

trgbieD

cdc anh

em

Rn{o

tl} Molner

d

rrong

trlDg

lbdi

167



t€u

clu

c&e

c,i

toa

itt

pbli

tdy

Eot

vgr

&

nhi

nQr

v

|

sin

rdt

trong phdo[

dEu

do

kbdp

Ydi

Dbau'

that

bac

si dii

rroilt

cai

chai

{y.

Nhfi'ng

k6

vd

hlnh

cirrrg

| ,"o

,

ti

nhi.

cfia blc

isi

hic

dy

rfit

rldng.

-

|

"fn

si Benezdch

cho

hay

tbeo

ldi yeu

chu

cfia

OrrS

|

"fro

bi6t

j/

ki6n

vl

th6r

ra

hcri

kh6

giii.

mQt

vflt

da

&rtro'g

tfi

kr'h

cia

mot thu vi6n

bA'tius

I

cno

or't

-v

arrf,u

vr

'uY'i

6'

llrrd

tci

quf,n

t,hri

L6e

cr

6ng

dbng

tt6n.

Ntqr

h6m

|

*r.t

,o

th6

ttlt

htnh

A

lon

hinh

u.

l

L

I

if,

l

u

s

rne'

lroqg

ltc

dbDl

Tu

si

HararEnr

Nielsod riiDs

cho hal

rrodb

Eot cuoc

i

;;

""

,0..'-:r"i:,1"-tn^:-":::,0':"^t:iltlt::.:n',f."*:

,0,

"*0,e.ffi;;';iilil#Tt"il"U1.-.";;r"*

I

ilnrv

& rqt

nsuia

t'aos-.caob"t'.,i'l

.t|;;l'"l",.lll

onn

-ol1o"'

l"*;;;-;.";;"-;;';;"iir# "; ]

"ou"

,t'tor'

g'e

lev

:l'f'.,h.l."lll

lai-cia

Lbdc

rhnnb

bdc

al

cbi

'tinh)'

I vdr

'lE

vdt

chgt

liE

sso

di

qot

vqt

chdt

dE

Err

li

hicn r*ofr*

cburEu

'a'

1'sou1.

|

;

ro

sily.

N{o

lrJ

,':

t..

1ry-'::,ji'_t9:'l::j':l:

| ;;;

thl'chring

ra

thiy

rhng

hai

hQp

di€m

fiv

chi6ru

mQt

Eietr thoqi

cpo bdc

si

vd

snu

hht

ki6B soAr

thl

qoa

I

duqo

W.

Sread

mgr

rhe

lhld

litrh

hoc

Aoh

trl ldi

Dhu

thdt

b{c ai da

hdr cit

cbai

dy.

NbilDg

}6

yd

blnh

cio*

|

"*o

,

|

"

..'

'I'Oi

dr;n

vio l{p

lu{n

cira

Wrlliau

Crookes

itt

rnQt

Y{t de

Ortrong

t[

klnh ciii

Eot thu vlenbloriug

I

'--

tqi

tbltlr

ph6

dd

kbo{ kln

vdy

md

n6

bi6n

dru

rh{t

"t

I Ngu

,nh

€

rran

E{t

gidy

hai

cdi htnh

voong

ttc

tA

biQn

l8n

tqi

phdle

lhl

ngbieo

ohitu bbn

rbq4t, I

"on

rc

hei

c{t

blnh

car

hei

chilri

(ngang

vd

dli)

vl

aDh

sa

rto senelcch

cho

hay vlt

D.y

hodn rai

ri

cii

|

;;s

tbe

tip

hai

c{i

hltrh

-tv.

"':.

"']"

10"::..-::0.-"1-'

".:

ouos

bEns

"nJ

ey.'-wor;;

;;t;'o*ii

ia"*"".i

I

i"

i.,&oe

tnnog,'ios--oo.:€.

oo

]:,',

:1T

,::T,iJt:^::

g'u',r'

"

-

i

-'-"'

Yqr\

v'u

rduu

I

;;;

kb6i;

ur -;o

dlt

ht$h

tuoDs

DdJ'

l6u btnh

vuong

|

il

ioq"""l*ng

n{u

anh

lcv

kdo

clt

hsi

blnh

{v

tbl

clo

kbr

cu

cbAnr]

crio

6trC

dA deo drroc

mty cai

kim I

riDg

vd

l,qc

d

lnbn

6Dg

t.

i'.

g.

aolg

y

si rb

nta

I

r'nt

sao

? o&i

vl

anh

d[

cho

tbem

hlnh

tooDg

Engl

o's

nic

dln

otrq

t'Jndy

6ns

Hy ii"i

ii,t""g'it,

I

critrr

niie

(day

bolc

c8o)

Elv-li.

ol

9:{.t':: :19::

_,-

tn:.

.t,

:o"."rl"to.

.

"u-

lon_"_

0",

cbtr6i

bor

rroD8

hoo

I

ii"a*

r.ong

ltoog

girtr.

Anh

kbdng

sao

lim cbo

hai

coa

Edr dir

con gdi

chgr

dl choD.

I

OOO

tie_

Uo"

thtnh

mol.

,-, :::,^li: lnl :."14'.9011"*l

Prp

d rbfr

do tsto

sri

I

un

v{t

I, hqd

ctu

rrat

ir{r

Es''}r

tr

blo

hil

r{t

rqr btrdtPell

ngEdt

lr

da

dl

c6c Yll

then

lu.n

lluqc

troDg

I

ltoog

rt6

"tng

onuo

chi6m

Eot

Lholog

trong

LbODg

8ian.

il

t70

rnhn

LINII

Hoc

lli du irhr mbt

cAi

dbng

hb treo tr6n tudng

lrong

mQt

phdng,

dir anb

c6

di

dung th6

nio

anh

ciing ttrfiy

nd

vi

'l'uy

THUAT

CIIIEU

[TdN

rfing

nbi?ng

hlnh

lnh dy

gi6ng

nhu

nh&ng

hlnh

nbi

tren

tilm

klnh

md

eira

phdng

rdi

rfra phim

&nh.

N6u

anh

nhin

thdv

hinh

t7l



lii

| ['.

u,

il

,

rii

tr

r

Ir

t.

tr'

II

fi

trl

fi

$i

1$I

c{l dbog hb tr;i

lqi

inh

sang

d[ chi6n

d6n

n6

vi

tri

snb dung

xenr

n6, n6 sE

cO htnh

th6

khAc

nhnu. CAi

f,y

td do

con

mfit

anh nhAn

<lugc

nhiing

khdi

Anh

sAng

theo

rndt shiEu n{o

vi

hinh lnh

cii dbng hb

ph6r:g

ktrfip

dhy

phong,

vi

lE

{nh

srlng hh0ng theo

hd

tbdrrg

khr:a (sysleue

l'erme)

ntru

cich

cdu

tgo

cfia

nguydn

tfr vi

plid:r

tfr,

vi lE

d6

Anh

sfng

cb thb di

tr6o

nbau

mi

khdng

ptrdi

hop

(nlrtr

cdc dirng tliQn

herlzienne

trou

vfr

tnl

hay

cdc tia

ptr6ng

xa

quang

tuydn)

'l'rorrg

trqng tlAi

cao nhdt cfra

v&t

chflt

ngrrrri

ta

nhAn

tbdy

c{c

dou

vi

irguyAn tfr

cd th8

rli

qna

cAc

vAt

cl{e,

BiEu

ndy

rfit

thrldng

nhr quang tuy6n

X

*.Tiuh

c{ch

cqc

ti8u

cira

cdo

ydu td ph6n6

x+ c6 ttr$ ldrn

cho

ctrfng la

di

qtra

clic

h$

thSng nh6 gbrn

cd

c{c

pbAn

tfr

trbng

tr&u.

Churrg

i

c*ch

xainhau

nOn

c{c

su.

Lro

gilin

cfc

phAn tir

kbOng ngfln

tr& viQc

xuy0n

qtr&.

'[hanI

khi

cA nhfrng

tli8rn

lgieiuq

nhu tr4ng thAi taii

cao cfr&

v{t ch{t,

nhung

clc tf+ng

th,ii tinh

vi

nhi[t

cfia

bin

tlr0

hbng

trbtr,

ldm thAnh

jgicri

hqn

p.iiia

b&n

chfit

c$nh

gioi hiing tlBn vi

clnh

gioi

thuong

giiri

lirrn trhng

chf,t

thnnh

khi; C,{c

y€u

t6

c[n

bfin cflu

lqo

ctrdt

thanh khi

khdug

phrlc

tap b[ng

chfit

hbng lriln.

Niri

ru0t cdch

khfrc,

su

c0tt

lUo

cAc Aur

drQn

tfr

vtr

tlucrng

di0n

tfr

cfra

chfit

thanh t bi

ktrOng

phur

tgp nhu

sr c{u tAO cd:

diQrr

tir

c0a cdi

vit

chdt.

N6u

Inh

c6 thb thily tluoc chfit thanh

kht

thl

nh&ng

hlnh lnh ch[t

"nl

t8o

ra

llm

cho

anh c6 clm

tu&ng

sfng

c&a rnQt

cfi

cot

bHng

chrn

thqctl

v&i

cac

dhu cQt

triing

dbng

d6,

cfrm

tu{rng

Anh

s{ns

iv

s6

ldnr

cho

antr

c$

cim gidc

lA

cQt

fly

bfing

d{

ch,u

thqch

vi

dhu

c4t fiy

b&ng

dbug

d6.

'I'rong

ciuh

trang

gioi.

_

rldi

voi

c:lrrlr

hbng

trln

cdc'

v0t htnh

']ru

ldm

b&ng

dnh

sAug v&

su

th$t

ld

chring

dbu

lAm

bftng

flntr

sriug.

Arih

sarre

cria

,rdi

v4lt

chflt

do

uhilng

ngub'gdc

tlridn

nhi0n hay

rrh[n

tqo

phdt

r,a,

trdi lai

intr sdng

cria

cdi

trurrg

gicri

ld

co

uh.r'ig cria

cdc

si'h

vst,

mdi

mQt

sinh

r6t

la

mQt

ngntln

gdc

thicn

nhicn vb

AntrsAng

vl

tdm

phat

sinh

ra

r:biirg

slr rung

dQng

dnh sing

dr6n

r[

ra

bfrng

nhi?ng

hi'h

rh6

vcr

mdu

sfic

tuong

to'rru

hinh

ttr$

va

nrlu

sic

c&e

htnh

{nh

anh

sfing

phdug

ra lr0n

tdrn

kinh.

nno

cria

phdag

t6i

phinn

flnh.

cac

ngu3'€u

td

cflu

tao

chift

tha'l-r

khi

c6

,nhfr'g

su

cach

lriet

k\m

tfl co

th6 d$t

ilr&nh

nhfrng y6u

t6

nfng

hoiic

uhg ugtrin lA

c6 th6

r'rng

dap

lqi

s*

ru'g

olQng

ctr{rn

hon holc ]nau

hcrn.

Nhiing

chdt

nflug

tron

gi6ng

nhu

cac

chfrt

r{n

&

cdi vat

chilt

va cac

chdt

manli

hrrrr

gioilg

cdrc

ctrilt

thauh

11

cdi

vflt ch{t.Nhung

c{i: y6u

t6

dy khd^g

phdi

hqp

th*nh

''rrti".g

tb

hqp

prruc

rq.p

dd

lAur

ilr&nh

'hflng

h0 thdng

kho6

nhu' cdc

nguydrr

tfr

vrrr

ph0n

rfr

bi)ng

trkn.

tlhrinn

lanr

tha*[r

'hitog

trnng

td,rr

cfin

csc

su

rung

tlfing

d{p

ung

lgi

mOt

vdi

su

kich

l.ht:h

rnd

nguydn

'h&n

do

l$r*

linh

:

chriug

di6n

t&

tu

tu&'g.

rndi

tu

t*&ng1

ld

mqt

c0n(

thirc

chi dinh

bfing

mOt

sinh

lur:

tjnfr

t\i,

.

't

dt

ad

diEu

6t

c6

rrong

cAnh gioi

vAr

chitt

dEu

d[

c0 trnoc

trorrg

cantr

rruog gidi

(te

gbm

rhau

tra'

tr i

I

ll

'n72

cfia

it{t

cl

cdi

gl

hi8u

hiQn

trong vii

lru,

DB

so s{nh

rcinh

trung'g.id{

ngudi

ta c6

th6 vi

drr

vdi

f,nh

slng mit

rnng

dQng

hon vA

THUAT

CHIEU

T{bN

173I

'Iom

l4i

do4n trOn

ln

khii

quit cira

v{n

tlB'

Rdt

kho

dO cho

cdc

bqn hi6u

vl

hai

cAnh

gi6i khac

nhnu

khd

so

THAN

LINH

I{OC



lrtri

gbm

cd hbng

ngoqi

tuydn

'ch{m

nhu

t\6

gi6rg vcrl

vcri

cic

vat

nfng

trong cdi

trung

git'ri,

vf,

fi'r rrgogi

tuydn

rung

rtQIrg

nhanh

hon

vi

gi6ug

vcri cAc

'ol

vit

thahh

htrn

trong

cdi

trung

g,itri.

bibo

nlo

dfr

fin rtinh

n€n hinh

th6,

dv lA tu

tulrng

dirng

dO

t*o

nbn,

dit

ttr

tu&ng Sy

li

tu

tu&ng vb

mOt

v,Lt

hirn

khl,

rn$t

cdi

eiy,

dqt

con thf

hay mQt n6uoi'

N6i

l6m

pr,t,

,lti

ln

sinh

v6t tiph

thiln

& 50n lrorrl;

cl;i

giir;i

bqnr

tA

fin

illdtr

hlrrh

th&

chflt

trun6X

gi6i'

(f

1r

Frr

n

trirg;

r'ira tlt

trr &n5;

lil

sdng

l4o

tilt

ntrlit. t{rln

nnir

ugtri

rlin

I

nn0t

trAi

dito

tbi

atrh

d5 dirntr1

tr.r

tufvng

<1$

fee

,t$og

vdlo

c$i

thanh

klrt alE

l$iil hinir mQt trfii

dAo.

(,inh

trung 6lpi

dh-v'

c&

hintr

th&,

nhftng

trinh tu

trr6'ng

135y

tlrrh

cAch

s{ng t1o.

N{r

r:ting

tt[y

dfiy

ci itr

lrrt]ng

r:ira

rrgrrli

sdne.

Ngu&i

ta

ktr0ng

th6

<lirng

c{c hintr tu

trrfi'14

thnnh

lihi

dE

lim

ra

v4t

th0

vi

uggui

ta.

htrO'g

hi6t

c5n

bi

qu36t

cfin

su di

qua

tu mQt

cfirrtr

gi&i

nriy

sang

mgt

clnh

gi6i

khAc

m{c

dhu trong hiQn

tuong

bi$n

trbn

vA

churYbn

di

til nhftng

li'

Ohihu

thrt

tu

tA

d{c tAnh

cfra

chdt

thanh kht

ddi

vdi

chf,t

bbng

trhh,

song

diEu

rrAy

h:p0lg

phli

biro

rffng

czlc

vrrt

thanh

ktrt

cb

bdn

chibu.

(,tAy chi

le mqt

trqng thAi

(6tat)

chri

kh0n6

pnfii

lir

nrQt bE

(rlimension).

N6

chi

In

hinh

lnh

*nh

rAng

mi

chirng

toi

d[

trltrh

bty

trudc

kia.

CAc

nhip

ruog

dQng

c6

thO

lreo

vAo

nhnn

rnl

kh0ng

cd

srt

trtng

hsp.

Hai

cAi

khAu

blog

chilt

tbanh

khi,

cd thB

.cirng

chi'fm

mQt

ch6

trong

hhOng

giah..'

sinh

vA

nhflt

lA cho

dbng

tr

nb$n

tt&

C 0n

l&

16

rAng

(trirh

tron6

[.'ormes

matdrialisees

R, Montandon,

treng

3llJ

rlo

ttbrrgg

tir

Yver ung

itbng)"

2)

GiAi

thich

hiQn

tuong

hi$n

hbn.

ViQc

tl?ing

tfr

cd

fhB

dirng4

nrQt

cb{t

mA

cAc

nhi

chi0n

hbn

thrrtt

gqi

lA

ecioplasme

(dr: ti6ng

[Iy

19p

ektos

:&

rrgoAi vfi

plasr'n

:

r:6i

ktrl0n)

ngliia

lil cai

khurln

bao

hoc

b0u

ng6ii

r:fli

f

hf,rr

xfcmd

chri'g

t6i f4n

clich

lil

a

ltll

ngoni

t5A'

n

116 tn6

ndrr

nfiirrr51

[i0rr

trrgng

hidn

hlSrr

rlH {trsr:

nlriFtt

rtlii

kirio cr?n

;b chi0n

hbn

thuflt

nghi0n

etiu.

idg,lrv

tt-11-1931

by

su

Ilk.

Mriller,

n11uoi

fhic

dA

c0

rh6

l{y

nr$t

it chdt

(

khl

ngoqi

than

y

nd .

nh6

r&

ntri

rrr0t irtin

m& hi$n

ra

c0

tlnh

cich

niru

nlt{tng

giat

ttuoc

,

vd c,ii mni

vi

uhu

ch{t

cur}rrg

loan'

It6r

sT

.lulien ochorow,erz

Sau

nlri€u

r,[ fi

nptli0n

c*u

di

d6,r

h6l

lu4n

c6

nhftng

ldn s6ng

nttu

tin

sAng

plt{t

xudt

tu:

nrl

rllsng

tfr

dA

tqo

cdc

tiing

11orr51.

v.\'..

Ocho-

rowier

z

chup

inh

tlugc

nhfrng

lArr

s{rtrg

nAy

l(j'

sn

J. Crawford

&

llelfast

nghidn

ct'rn

vi

cilng

di

ddn

kdt

lu$n

cdr

nhfrng

tia

s{ng

lir

rtbng

tfr

phfit xrrdt

ra vi lit

ugubn

gdc

ptrdt sinh

ra

c6'c

bi|n

tuong

da

bAn,

xoxy

bfin,

tidng

gd

v.v...

Khi

phAtl Kufrt

r&

sinh

lqc

ndy

rhi e,s

kbi

lcbh

va

c6

lh6

cbu

[r

A nh

ducrc

nhfrng

su run{J

dgng

ndy.

Crawford

cfing

cho

r ilng

efr

tga

du

thlnh

cfing

iIA

Bi$p

cho

hiQn

tuong

uiy

phAt sunh'

Ildc si

sehrenck

Nolzing

ngrroi

Duc

ngtri0n

ctlu

vtr

178

THX,N LINH

TIOC

Ii6.I-Iu8n:

Treng c6i

vlt

chflt

ta khOng

thB

dirng ly

16

thuQc

mQt



cira

cdi

vit

chilt

d8

gili

thtoh

c*c hiQn-lugng

odi

khAc.

Chi0u

hbn

thult

cbi

lA mQt tia

sing

nh6

trong

d0m

ldi thdi.

Phli

v*n

clung clc

"oo

nlng cfia

con

ngudi

d&

khtm

phA

cl4h

gl0i

kh{c

chu

klr0ng

phli

blng

c{p

mlt

rhir.

MQt

frudng

hgp Thbn

Llnh

&

VlQr-Nam

:

Kim

Llnh

T9

Ndnr

1960

l+i

Nha-Trang,

tdi

mey

nrhn

g{p

mQt vi$c

tq bhi6n

lOi

kh0ng

th6

khdng

kD

lrong

t$p tAch

nAy.

Dd

lA

sqr

tlch

ng6i

chira Kiur

Linh

Trp

&

sd

6

kiet

.3

(HiEn

Luong),

dudng

sd

1

(Ct?rn-Long)

bhu

Phudc

H{i

Nba-

I

rang.

Ngn16n

tOi cd

tbf,n

nbdn

bi bfnh

nOn

lau

dd

dA

deur

llrr

cl:fi'a

l+i

chira nAy.0og

E{ng-nhu-Fli{n

phip

danh

'I

hi$r-Otri{t,

mQt

ri

ctr

si t+i

tia

sAng

l{p

cliira

ney,

nn6i

khi

n6bi

thibn

tlinh

tru&c

bAn

thtt

dtic

Qudn

Thd

Aur Bb

IAt

tbt

Quhn

Ti0n HOi

nbm

t6c vi

Ti6u

'l'hrinh

nhrr

:

'f

hi0n

Y

A Na,

Li6n

fl4nh, Ngg"

Nii

Ctrria

'l'i0n,

IIA

'['i0n

C0,

tilch

S<rn, Hdm

IIAi,

I'rhn hung

l,]qo,

L6

v[n

Du5$t

vA nhiFu

vi

khAe...

vAng

lQnh Euc

QttArt

Thg Aur Bii

'ldt

luAn

phi6n

nhau

giAng

birt

ban

tbi

gido

dqy

tldi vd

,lQ

bQ1h.

[I;Qn nay

n6i

cn]Eu

thu nfim

vi

chfi

nhflt

dbn

cb

lb

ctruc

t+i

Kim

L,inh Tu. fOi

cltnryc

tli6t

trong

th&i

gian

ghn,l&y

tb

ehuc

nly

sd

hinh

,trqo

t+i

SAi-tidn

vA cdn

tinh khAc, vl cdi

sir mgng

<

cuu

blrb,

ctiu

n?u D

theo lQr:h

cfra

Ditc

QuAn

Thd Am

IIB

T'et

vA

Qnhn

T'i0n F{0i.

'I'rong

kinh

Phb NI0n

co ehdp

:

a

I11

tfic tlrhn thOug

lgc,

quilng

tn lri

phuong

liQn, lh{p

phuor.,g

chu

qufl{c dO,

v0

s6t

blt

hiQn

thAn

>.

Tsm

dieh

:

Cdr dir

plrdp

l.

e

qnylu ul,

dhy dfi cdc

pbuong ti$n

b

hfip

cdc

,1.

t

l7.l

,l

I

,/2^

r)

,hnlur.

t\tq

[r;

.

a

THI.N

LINH

}Ioc

:

Ylt

chdt ta

ttrOng

th8

dilng

ly l€

gilt

thtoh

cAc hiQn-tuong

thuQc

mQt



,;/

du/o^'*

db,'

l'

p

''l'

i

l

r

thull ohi

lA mQt

tia sing

nh6

trong

.di vln

dunS cAc.oo

nlng

cfia

con

ngu&i

itntr

gtoi

khAo

chu

kh0ng

phli

bfing c[p

mf,t

MOt

trudng hgp Thln

Unh

&

Vl$t-Norn:

Kim

Llnh

f

y

Nln

1969

lai

Nha-Trang,

tOi

may

mhn

g{p

m0[

vi$c

tq hhi6n

tOi

hhdng

th6 khdng

kt trong

t$p

r{ch nly.

ES

lA

su

tlch

ngdi chira Kiur

Linh

Tq

& sd

6 kiet

.3

(HiEn

Luong),

dudng

sd

1

(Ciru-Long)

lhu

t'hudc

HAi Nba-

-l'rang.

Ngny0n

tOi cd th{n

nbAn

bi bfnh

n0n lau

dd

dA

dern

ltn

chiia

l+i

chira

ney.0og

Dfng-nhu-Fli{n

phnp

danh

l

hi$n-Chitt,

mQt

ri cu si

lgi

gia sAng

lAp

chira

n:iy, no6i khi

n66i

thrbn illr:h

trubc

biln

lhit duc

Qn{n

'I'hd

Anr

Ilii 1'At

tbl

(luhn

Ti0n H0i

tbm

cAc

v

fi0n

Thrlnh nhu :

'l

hi0n

Y

A

Na,

t,i6u tlgnh, Ngg.

Nii

Chrta

"fi0n,

ItA

't'i0n

CO, Ilich Son, Him

lIdi,

'frln

hung

F+o,

L6'vEn

Du5Qt

vA nhilu

vi

khAe...

vAng

lQnh

Euc

QuAn

Thd Arn Ilii

'tdt

luAn

phi6n

nbau

giAng_

but ban thi

giCo

dqy

.lrli vd

d0 bQntr. ttiQn

nay

n6i

chlEu thtt

ndm

vi

chri

nh{t

dbu

cd

lb

clr{rc fAi

Kim

Linh Tu. t'6i

dnsc

bjdt

trong

th0i

gian

F,hn

d&y

lb

chuc

nly

s€

htnh

rtr+o

t+i SAi-GOn

vA cA*

tiuh

khAc, ri c6

su mgng

t

cuu klrb,

criu

nau

theo lQnh

cfia

Edtc

QuAn

Thd

Am

Bb

1-{t

vA

Qnhn

TiCn

HQi.

T'rong

kinh t)hb NI0n co

chCp

:

<,

C,r.r

lfic

ttriin th6rg l,Ic,

qu&ng

tn

lri

phuong

tiQn, lhdp

phuc"ng

chu

quf,c

dO,

v0

s{t

hdt

hiQn

thAn

r.

TAnr

dieh

: Co

rlir

phdp

tfi,*

qoyln

ilfr *lhy d&

e*t

phuong

liQn & hhiip

air:

THAN

LINH

TIOC

nufc

trong mrrdi

phuong

vl ncvi

nAo

c6

su

8i6t

ctr6c

ttr Ngni

liEn t'tng

hi$n.

Trluar

CrilEU IrdN

lu$n

tai

Sii6on

m& rndt

thiOn

pi6ng su

vt

Kirn

Liuh Cbinh

Gr6o

fISi

vA

Ohta

t(irn

Linh

Tr,r

dlog snst tr0n

mu&i

sd

bto

bilt

tiIu

tu

sd

1059

ngiy

29'.1-71

tr& dl,

xAc

irh&n

viQn

huybn

181

180



Lln

n:iy

NgSi

nru$'n

tay cfia

'ft)ng

Sanh

'l'hiQn

[Ch{t

rrhu

kinh

Phb

NI6n

tlfl

ghi

I

<

U'ng

di

cu

si

ttrAn

elflc

tl0

gil

tdtc

hiQa

clr

si

thAn

nhi

vi

thny6t

phfp

n.

CAc

gi{o

lhi

cria

Qnhn

Ti0n

I{Oi

dA c6

hAug

trrlm bii.

llhi

giAo ri6t

rflt

rrhanh,

khtlpg

th$ cd

su

slp

tl{t

tru&n

vl

c6

khi

'gu<}i

ngilrii

rt6n

xin

thi lhl

tlffGc tr&

i{il

trgay. NgAy

nQ

e6

n:Qt

qnAn

nhAn

ngulri

Ml6n

meng

bhn ngli

dty

mltrh

ddn

fi"ipr

Linll

Trr

dA

th&

xem cf

thAt

lil

'fi0n

T'h{nh

hnv

chnl'{n

trf

n

dtii

thl

y

dn

'

phfii

}'nn so

qny

ru(irrg

lay

rirlr

r ri

cittr

npr\i

bnn

thi

girto.

Srtr

d6

ttli

cb

dilt

hi.ri

y

thi

y

lj

o

'fi€n

'l'hiuh

lhlt.

vidt

qu'i rihnnlr,

dfi.nh

miy

chii' c4rn

I

tlrua,

flrtr:

ryi

sir l{rm

'[

rirrg

l]l'c

"l'tirrg

t'i

tln

db

cila

ef,c

trln

6ifr-o lthfi.c

riOn

ttri'r

thdrr:tr

hr;ilc

xii:

tri

b$rrir

pb[n L:rn

,Jbu

rlm,;r,-r

cic

nlitii

r&

tni'td

rtQ

Yir

he

d$u

eAng nhfln

dl4y

il e0ng

vigc

cira

thiA

niq

li$rrS

rhfi

strr

ngrfii

kh'bng

kin tIF.c.'cr

'l' reo

s'.t

f

r2 h6i

r:fi4 c'hring

l(\i

tl'r'rtc

hl6t l(im

[,in]r

(lir{ln1i

(ii{o

dqi

dil

cb

nghi

tlin'r s'i

1)trr l}\V/ns/t4

rig'hy

1fi

l1-11)7{) cira

lt$

NOi

Vu

cno

ph6H

hr:4t

'lQnfi

toArr

qnde

v*

rliErr

ztl c,\.

Dihn-t,{

ghi

r ii

(}i{o

tI0i

khO'rg

hoqt

d0n;1

nhinh

tti,

v"i.

ng{y

1il

tlrdn*

i" trii n

1971

tilr*:

trgAy

1l)-2

'l'Arr

tlq'i

16

ktrfinh

thiuh

tlirirs

I(llt

-

LINII

-'l't,l'

vd

Kllt-Llstl-crIA'NrI

GtAo

n()I

k"rai

{iiflo

<1[ dncvc

cri

hAnh

trcng tir&

& Ntrn-t'rang.

ltogt

d$nf thuhn

t,iy

dqo

rlr?c tr*y

rlfl

co

ti6ng

vlng

trong

nu&,:.

I}$nh

nhAn

trong

ts*n

quf5o ddn

Ki nn

Linh

'l'u

khA

tl0ng, khidn

bAo

'Ir&ng

I)on,

mQt

cu

qu&n

ngf'ru

lrnh

vA n6ay

chluh

vg

chbng

Ong

ehri-ntrifm

eiirtg

dff

dl,:h

thAn

diln

Nha-'frang quan

slt.

'l'di

rlf,

nh$n

xdi

vi

.[Ong

sanh ThiQn

Chfit tirc

lA

vi

pliling

brlt

chm

kim

ccy nhu

sau :

lii{c

d0

b{nh

vd

ban

64iAn

thi

do Ti0n

tbrlnh

giirrq

l{lin

rlirng

'.ii

'l'r}r

g

Sarri-i

ttr8

chSp

brit.

\ri

't'6ng

San}r

ht-inrrg

nlrlii

r: ri

l:r rrr0t xlc riiir:g

hay dbng

tft

thudng.

'ftreo

lfri

hn)g

l'i,i0rr

(ltrfit

lbi rn6i rg:1y

d0r:r

0rifi

phii

thiEn

iiinh

;i0

r:6u

rrgrn'f

n

on

l'0n

1i6p

d

6n cA

bnri

0n huQ

cirl

cir-irrfl

'r;.fli:il

(i,r'"li're

illii

iAp r:liira

qlns

r-lS

thilr:r ilinh

r;hjIu

i:iinr

rri

r;, r:rr r;1rr

hiCIn

dAng

cuQc

,.liri

vr\ ttilin

x*c

Ong

cho

lle

Qu{rn

Anr)"

Vi ray

trong

k}ri

lhibn

tlirrh

0ugt

dii

rftao'c

[.]n

tr0ir

(ley

chr"r

pliuo'ng ptiAp

toa

thir hhn

trauh

$il

l<hrrfiy

pirfi

rirn l*.

rna

3

0u qutii

cho

n€

n

ktrtlng

plr&i

nbu

cd.c

:xric

ribni,

trr:ng cfc arn

rui6u,

v& sau

lhi xl tlribn tAnr

lhhn

0r;g'

ldn

nrinh

rnfrn

sing

sn$t.

N{u

rgmdi

ta

rl{t

cf,c

6il

rtiu]6t

nhu

ctrfia

LrQnh

do

tir rli8n (r:]rAn

di4n

chnrrp), ttay

duc tin

(rlo

su cBu nguyQn

vd ldrg

tin

tu&ng

cfia [bn dao)

Lc{c

bhrig

16

cbuySn

di

tu.

ttrr}'ng

(do

v dbng

tfi')

hoi.c

lirruo

liii dr;e

tluqc

tu

tu&ng

f

ngtri cfin nguoi d&i nrA

rho

tha

rhing

nhu nguo'i

h6 ,

tht la

ciirg

khOng rtr8

loql

bd

quyEn

ntrrrg

cie lbi6ng

li0rg.

l'iri

qu58n

ndng

nAy

Ong

lsng

sanh khdng

tb0

ct

phCp

lq

duoc, Flcyn

niia

cu ldi tulng

llru$t cfia

trbn

dgo lhi

Ti€n Thdnh

con

b{o

mQng

cdc

dQ

tti

cho

nhiEu

trudng

hgp lq

ling

hhAc

vi

ngat chlnh

-Ong

T0ng sanh ofing

dugo clc

ng&i

bdo

mQng.

(Chring

tOi

t82

t€

cd

I

dip

vi6t ri6ng

mQt

cndn sdch

vb

Krill

LrNil

'tu.).

TTIAN

LTNII

HOG

nhllng

su

k5':

la

y6

Nhung

sq

ldQ

bgnh

ktr0ng

phfii

ai ciing

hoin

toiln

IAnh

TTTUAT

CHIEO

HE}N

c6 th0

xAc

nbAn

rf,ng,

ngodi

o6

nhilu

cOi

s6ng

cira

cdc vi

chring

ta c6

th}

tidp

xuc.

_

t83

thd

gidi

cfin

ngrtdi

ch6t,

cdn

Ti€n

ThAnh

lhhn

Linh

mi



hirr vl

c<)n

tu/

nbiF. ydn

td

ktrac

rrh*

ilrai

ds

cfia

bgntr

nhAn

(e6

tb&nh

tln

khdng,

c6

lrr niirr

sfm

h$i

lo h6

dir

lAm l&nh

kheing,

c6 ki0n

eft trong

vir)c

iln

udug,

diBu

d6

trong

rliri

sdng

kh0ug)

vA

cdrr

ruQt

rlibu

qnan

tlong

l&

nghi{p qrr&

nirng

hay

nhc.

'I'lnlr

cir

tCIi

duoc

doc

cu6n

siieh

'hnlr

db <

'l'hurrnr:

D6

cixr l:im ph6p

lg

>

do

bl

l(athr,,'

r(nhlrr_ra.r

vi6t

(h&n

rtich

rl r

n:0t

rrh6rn

I

rrgu&i

vi0t

l{arrr

sA

rrl;oai

qutlc

rhrrc

}iiQtr}

trorq

dri

plr6p

14 cira

lhu'orig

Di

rlr

trrrcr;

rr

6u rQ.rrrng

cirlnh

bh

Iinthrl:n

Kuhluar

eling

pLrii

tn[:

ruir:

dg

ira

brit

vidt r

firrg

<

'l"ai

sao

khdng plrii

tilt

crl rlrcr

chiia

I]nh

?

flrir:r

tri

lri

charr

thilnir

nhfit

rni

tOi c6

th6

n6i

la

ktr0ng

I

ir

u

(tr

ni,g

2

| |

),

Vd

ei

r

ii ng

bi6t

rrtrii,og

plrdp

19

& LO

Du.c

(l,ourrlei)

ciir:g

v$y.

lt 0ng

cfrc

vi

'l'i0n

'['ha'h

trcrrg

eua*

'l'i4n

Il )i rlr

dung

lirp

luAn

cfia

lrhN.t

Gi6o

a6 trfi

td,i

chn

clt{r,g

tGi b'dt

vi

du

c6

kE

rnir

xrrr

rlrt_r,,:

stng,

cri:

n6di

bl'rrr,rng

rnot

riB'ki6P

c6.c

rr.iy

2{){)

}ldm

can

tOi g16t

nguri

r]0ir

n11iy

nay prrfri

bi

tlLri

riii,r.

c rc

n0n

T'i0tr

I'hAnh

ciii:;,,

ria'h

cirid rnil

ktrOng

tba

lArn

sai

lar

Iuiit

,han

qnl,

ir.firr

lrili

r'lrroc,

vi ndu

cuu tlql

cbo

rtrQt

k[

lrhqrm

tOi

cLu,a

phli

t"i rtv

tiri

v0

rti.h

'l'r0*

['rr{nrr

l}rn

nr{t

su

}riit

c0ug

Il6n

dAy

chirng

tOi

th{y

c6

tb8

tanr

rlung

trdt

v& quan

tri{m

el:o

rfing

cAo

hign

tuqrng

tlbn

do

dbng

tii.

cflu

tqo

vi

pl:it

sanh

holn

toln

kbOng

dr.'rng

sr.r

lrrf

t.

I'r.u

nh*'g

tru]ng

hqp

lila

bip

cb

bfrng

c6 xic

dring

thi

khOng

kg,

chirng

tOi

Cfc

vi chAn

tu

dic

tlgo

cira

clc

tOn

"

ddn. l\{orrg

ring

treu

dur}ng

rli

ttm

Chln

c6c ban

od

th8

tu

mlnh

chr,'rng

nghiQm

vAo

su

rrhdn

xdt

cfia

chring

l0i.

gi{o

dBu

c6

n6i

Lf

mQt

ngly

kia

thay

vl phli

tin

rbr.rs ru[nr

IHUAT

CHII1U HdN

thu{t mi

rlfing

sr.r nghiCn-crlu cAc

hi$n

tuong khfc

vl

tlrt

v0

linh-tuQ,

linh- c|rur,-

hay su nghi0n-cuu

cAc

6idc

mQng

cd linh c6ch bdo

diBm

tiCn-liQu,

cAc

srl hi$n

hbn, cAc

ng0i

nhA

erl

ura, cA:

lii

thllir

gino

efch

c&m, v.v..,

ndi

l6m

lai

185



'l'rinh

biy vA

phAn

tich

chilu-bbrr

lirrit

durli

cAc

hiiie

c4nh

hh{c

nhau,

rt{t

cnQc

lrantr

lu{n

ctrn ihhn

liuh

hoo

ht,y

th0ng

lirrtr

hob

thnydt

vdri

cric

phe

tt6i llip cirr

no,

<:hirng

tOi

,,'hi

c6

f

mnf,n

lAm s{ng

tt5

urQt

tliOru

chir

chiJt

:

rii)

I

I

chirrg

ln c6 th$

dtrng

ohi6u

trbn thn{lt

tihtt

ntQt

phurrrrg

tiilr

db

h,hfi;r slt

ifinh

vuc

siOu

trinh hqc

hny

noi

hgp

lron

cll

tim

hi$l

hOn

ikia

efta

lir

,:r5

irhii'ng

6l

vi

nlrilt

lt tfii

t,rn

rd

ngubn

gdc cira

bln

rhB t*c lA

di[u h6i

tAru

li:rL:,

dilu

16i nQi

lgi,

lLrtrn

td

nhi ribfit

cira

xfc lhtn

khdng

?

(,fic

mrJn

1116 lfia

phAi thln

linh lioc

tlruS6t

hlo riin,q

cb

r

h0 trong

lrhi

cAc

phe

diii

l{1p

t:bu

li

khtl

thge

irii'r.

Nhung

d{t

v{n

dB sir m{n}r.

ctra

'l'hBrr

ljnh bg:

giiin

cl-rn

kj

ti6n h6a

cfia nh{n

loqi rrgdy

uB},

chirng

tOi

rlii

n0tt

rd vi

tri

dung

bba khoa-hgc

vA

iOn-tido

cfra

n6, cilng

rtltu

su

mQuh

clrdng

hQc

thuydt

duy vat

bilng

phuong

plihp

hhoa

i:oc tbqc

nghiQm.

GiA

lri

cfia

Thhn

linh

hoc

cd

lh$

t6m tEt &

rti0m

tA

de

chting

rninh

duoo

srl

bft tfr

cfia con

ngurli

sau

khi chdt

bfing

phucng phAp

lhgc

ugtriQm.

Thtl ra ndi tidp

eho

hgo

thuydt

Thln

linh hgo,

chir

lruong

cfia

phAi

Tlm

linh

hoc

c6

phtrn

ktroa

hqc hon

vl

muc

tllch ctrng

phucng-pb{p

c6

phhn holn

bi

hon.

Nhu

v$y

lmu6n

tlm hiEu

phln

nQt

lqi

ngly

nay c6c

mOn

db ofia

TAm ltnh hgo

hh0ng

mudn

dirng tdt

chi0u

bbn

I

c c hi{n

tugrrg t}ru0c

vE tAm linh

con

ngudi

md

hhoa

hoe

ciin'rr

girtri

tirich

nb;

t

'l'q

dqi

hgc

rltrdrrg

Utrecilt

(&

l-li), girto srr

'l'e.rilr:rr'il'

i.; rrlq

Cn

6iArrg

r

ifi,i rn0n

sidu tr1

m

li

(par

npsycf

rolcgic)

rl5

rlirrrg.t

(lii

ptrft

Iiitrnh va b6o-shi

(1i

m6' crrdc

rliiJu

tra

sri

$r.r

ti0ir

i0u

(pr€nrr-rnition),

(.1{r:

hiri lf,in

linb Anh

r';l

.lli'

ri1

lrii.'n-.:rru

hing

r'r,1i.u

trtrlng

hup

<

vil

giAc qunn thu'.li1tt

'r

lrirlAnrir

sc

ns),

i,b

thXn

tih6n

(ieutlr,de

vle).

il*r:

ht)i rr;\v

ri i

tiur

rlEru'c

rn0t

ti

si 2,9L

lrtrdnpl brr;r xri: tl:rit

m

hitl,'r

':()iii

b&i

r:4e r:hrr-r'0n vi6n

cila

y

hr;c,

tfi.rn-lf

[r'.1s,

:i5 hq'li

boe

-

ri

vrlt

j

hon.

iiot

rong

ctrn

vi{n

la irrrg nh{

lA

v d'r

nsfriilrr c.riu lilrtr

,i.rilr

lrribourq

tI

l)iic

rni

g1i{o

su

llerrdel',

r*frr

tfin',

lf

}rcr

iiiti

r:n

(i6n4

ttln

f-itl{'-g1*i

nghi0rr-rtru

eilc

"ffn

rlb

ll\lr:-lillr

,lu'rli

sr.r hiro

trry

cfra

l.r0

Y-'l'6

Duc,

'lni

1\'lT

{r

D4i hoc tlirung Duko,

gi{o

err-

Rlrir,e

r:iing

lghiOrr-c*u

cAc

hiQrr-tu'ong

lAm

lirrh tgi

phr)rrg

hl-nghi{rn

c'ia

dr:rg.

{l)

'l'qi

Ao

gi6o-su

Llrban,

gi6rn

rldc

utrA

lhircrrrg

tlau

bQnh

ttrln

kintr

lrrnsbruck, ttri

nghif

nr ning ktrido tlrln

giao

cdch

cflur

noi

c{c cou

bQrrh.

Cfc

uhil khoa

boc

btt rtlu

d0

y

ve

ngbl0n

criu

ll6n

phln

tinh

thtrn

cfta

con

nguiri.

(l)

Xcm Hblne

J.ts.

Extrt rensory

pcrceptloo

(lloslon)

S

P.R.

l{}34.

186

THAN

LINH

EOG

r

Nguoi

hfiy

tu bidt

nguoi,

rbi

lu

hhfic

ngucrl

sE

bi6t

vil-tru

vi

jc[c

thhn

tbo

Delpher

c6

thD

linh

>.

CAu

thAnh

rrgOn khilc

trOn

ttbn

lAm

ti6u chuhn

cho

nhil'ng ai

drng

ngbi6n-cuu

ptrtU

tiBu

ttri6n

r it dB

tirn

hiEl

phhn dqri

tbien

TIIUAT

CHIEU

Hf)N

l8i

cic

thqc-th0

(ordre

de

rdalitds)

nhung

quan

trong

dA cho

ta

thha

(univers

mental)

cting

nhu

vflt

chilt

ndy.

sr1 khAm

phn

mQt

trdt

tu

danh

tu

kh0ng

dgP

l[m,'

hiEu

b:6t vE

vtr

tru

tlnh

tti$n

lnc

il6i

v&i

th6

gifr1



die,

Khria

hoc

dn

d6n

gi6i

hqn

ktrAm

phA

cAi

v0

trt\trg

nhrS

crih

v{t

chflt

t*

nguyCIn

lfr,

Nliung

d6n

ddy

ktrca

hgc

vflt

chilt

khOng

th8

tlm ra

chln

lf ctrtt

cuQq

dcri

v't

xAy

dung mQt

Y

thuc

hg mdi

khA

di dAp

lqi vfln

de

nhsrr

siuh

vi

vfi

tru

ciing

gili lhlch

c{n

kE

ngubn

gdri

cira

sr.r

rAt.

W.

Oaringtcln,

m$t

nhAn

vidtr

hQi

I'Aur

iinh

Anh

qu6o

nli{n

x6t

ri{t rtrlng

khi 0ng

vi6t

(trorrg

La

td16pathie)

:

<

llfiy

gitr cirutrg

la

tlfl

hlln

bi6i vb

thfin

th$

crin

nguo'i

;

'

srl

lugng

luong

thqc chn

ptrfii

cd il$

rtudi

tlud'ng

trd,

edch

Irr

rn{c

thG

nAo

cho

hqp,

ldi

tY'

vA

ctich

giil gin

sri';:

kh6e,

hi6u

hdt

vi

trirng

phA

hoqri

thAn

xlic thd

nio,

vi

tbi6u

sinh

td

thd

nio,

song

so

sirrh l+i

chriug

[s hi0u

biAt

r:It tt

vE

linh

thIrr

cfra cb'r

ngrrriri

I'd

cAc

mdi

lidrr

6.,r

cira

tip6

thhn

vryi

e6.i

cdg

lti

c[rn

v[i-lru,

vir

gi{ tfiurdt

diri

ra

ld c)

sF

li€n

lqc

i{y th5

m:l

sriu

r'6t

tfit

cri,

chinlr

tr4ng

tir6i

rinh thhn

dy {n

dinh

hay

t{rn

tirdnir

cho

col}

n6utri

hqntr

pLrtle tray

dibu

trAi

l$i"

.

.

.

Ndu

l6i thln

gioo

cfi,rh-crlm

vd

circ

lt'$n

lucmg

tuo'g

tu AEu

ie

nhii'g

sqr

th.lt

thi

'hiing

ditu

fiy

cliung

t6

sr;

hiQn

hfi.u

not

bitn chdt

cln

bdn

crla

tinh

thhn

chu

khong

pbii chl

lA

mot

vii

tlnh

ch{t

dii:

biQt

phu thuQt:

cira

n6.

Theo

$

tOi

chtng

c6

thb

dfin

tlfit

chtng

tB tl6u

Su'

khOn

ngoan cira

con

ngudi

vE

co

51i6i

df,

r'ttr;l

quA

btrc,lqo

ilirc

cira ho

(sagesse)

vA

rlarlg

(ti

il6n corr

ttuo'ng

hiiy diet

nbn

v[n

minh

md

ho

tu

hfro,

cl

nga\

chirih

mlnh

nta.

Vi

th6

hy

Yqnt

duy

nhilt

ddi

vcri

trr0i

tuong

lni t6

t dgp

va

tAu

trbn

-

tt6i

l{p

vcri

cflc

plrtrcrrtg

thu6c

cilp

thdi

hi$n

nay

chi

lA

mQt

8u

hi6u

hiCl

rff

rAng

qb

trln

thB

cira

rninlt,

vi tri

cfra

ruinh

trorrr

vii -

lrLr

rrlriit

ld

1hff'.g

rndi

li6rr

lqc

cltr

lri*

giii'a

c1t

rtrrB

rr

vir

doAn

th$

tlo tinh

chilt

nly

gf,-y

ra.

I) iti

i

rri

t'itt:

'

iirt

iIb

ntru

tl-rd

fiy,

v{t

tjr hg; khOng

tlua

'l6n

nrQt

d'rrh

sit'g

ndo.

sinir

lf ho:

ctng

th6

vd c[

tlm

lj,

Lro:

cirn6

]rhoilg

c6 nrfi1'.

'l'riii

l4:i,

sr

phAt

minh

(dnnh

ttr nly &

dAy

l<trrlrril

phii lal

qr6.tl{crg)

ctic

hifn

tuo-'r;1

piri

thrr}np,

n}rflt

ti

cA;

sn

ki6n

vE

thhn

giao

cfii:h

cflm

int

dudnl4

t:L{)

c6.r

cnsc

tim

tdi

cirn

chrinf,

ta

mQt

ttr6

gidri

hnltn

toirt

rqbi

rrri:'

m{.rt

thd

gilri

c6

tfnir

c{ch

quan

trgng

dr1i

vdi

bln cri'l1

clrfiu

ihgt v,\

s,#

c{u

tqo

cira

ron

I}8tr$i

c&ng

tt}rn

tliirr

lq,:

ddi

vt-r'i

bln

chdt

vA su

cdu

tqo

lita

eA

ciriit'

cii th5

6i(li

t(y chtng

ta

dauA

kh6

$

pira ttrot

*:icli

khiii;ri hbuydt

vi

mqt

c{ch

1g{u

nhidl

1 tt,t

di

d

\ rlfrnr

lhrr

lHrr

v6i

rrhibu

su

vflp

td

ciing

rl

lrt s1 phl 'r

''f:'

ruOi

ngrrtii

rli

lru6'c

s0ng

Chfrnq

thA.

r$

t'0n

llirrl

ktr(,'rl;'

'li.

l{4ntr

ptrirc

cira

rriran

lo4i

trli

crh&

:

cirii'r

chi ctr

th$

dat

tlrqc

do

sr,.r

r,6

l$c cil

git'g

cira

ll

dA Ji

'16'r

tr8

su

hiEu

l.rtdt

lh0t

lt

quan

e{p

nhibu

su

chiu

btdt

tl6n

TH;,N

LINII

HOC

v.i

irp

dung

su

hi0n bi6t

(song

hoAn c{rrh

trong

vA tucrng

lai

rlen

tdi)

lt

chl'rng

ta

nguy

hi6rn

ndu

clrring

ts

ntrdt

dinh

khOnq

cAc

su

kiQn

cd th8

tlra ta

d6n vdn

{lb

THUAT

CHINU

HbN

tu

giAc,

gi6:

tha soi

slng dudc

chAn-lf,

phA

lan

cAc

Ac

thhn

eria

vO

nninh,

giilc

tngQ

duoc chAn

tu6rrg

cria

vgn

vit

l8?



fiy do

su

n:& rQlfl

thm

bi6u

bi6t

cfra

chring

ra. r

Ndi

tdrur

lci

carrirrgton

ciing

nh*

cde

nrri nghi0n

cilu

vb

t{im

linh

ruu6n

krr'a

rroc

l,s

con

drrr}ng

vr.lt

.triit

rJO

tlin

Ir:tu

c(-,:t

tlu&r'g

tin[r thln,

Su

rurong

u:,udn

ao

uo,,:

ily

c/.l

ttlfr giirp

cbo

chring

l;t

thodt

kh6i

rnQt

crru

ki'hfir

*rn.

Nhfi'g

viQc

rli

lCIrr

{: rrrg

tiitrrg

va

klrhm

prLri

c.ri.*

ii6n

hdnh

,i'h

rlrl.u

c11

qua*

h0 Li'r,r:r

rr

iiur

lriln

rrrirrh

t.i rri,

c6

rrlrir;ur

ru

fii

tr.0n

rrrr,{

dia

c

ilrr

nr'ry,

rrd dI

gAy

ra

k]:0ng

bi6i

hao

rrlri6u

cuo.i

chi6n

lrarrtr.

sr-r

'li

i€n

Lung

trfirig

hay

ktianr

pirir

c1tc

lrirni-r

ririh

hhdc

dau

co

rtrern

rl$n

banh phric

cho

r lrArr

loqi

khi

rorr 'qu'dri

cOn

v0

n:inir,

khi

cc.

nguoi

crrr

prrrit

tri€rr

ph&rr

ri thlre

mi

chi

lA phsrr

hq

rri

(kiAu

ilgqo

hhoe

khnnrrg

thi0rr

vb

oc

ph0

rrinrr

chi

trictr)

'r,i

hhdng

phrit

tri0n

phiirr

rlru'*g

tri

rdn

li

da'

tiftc

rtrucrrrg

5

0u

va

rinir

lhhn

ltirig

hgp,

cira

mqt

nEn

khoa

hgc

co gioi

,-lang

di

ddn

ehd

phA

sln,

'['im

v&t

chilt

cho

d6n

e6i

vi

t6

cf:a

nguy6'lrlr,

con

nguoi

shi

i

liv

todn

lA

mOt s\r

lq.

nrOt

IE hul

bn-bl

nhrrng

cling

khdng

der:r

lai

cho

con

ngudi

hr'r

rnc

trm hi6u

v{t

crrfit

rngt

chAn

lf

gl

n:6i

mE

rb

b&n

thb

c$a con

ngu&i

vA

liOn quan

crle

n6 vdi

nhAn

togi vA

vil-trq

rt8 lAm

cbo

m6i

giao_t6

.giila

thd gioi

cing

tflt dgp

hnn

vl

xfry

dung

mqr

f

thuc

;h$

ghn

vdi

cugo

,tidn

h6e

crla rbln

logi

hiQn

nay.

Cbi

d.On

c6

rifc

tr&

Iqi

ttm

ngay

noi

chlnh

con

ngudl,

bi6t riing

noi con ngubi

c6

nhfrng duc t{n'l

hop

v(ri

chAn

lhitl,i

iir

chri

kh0ng

ph&i

chi cd tdn

bao

vh vd

luong t&:n,

\,*

hiiin

h'6t

rluqrc

cAc. dai lu{t

cai

qu[n

tlia c,hn vA

vii

lru,

rihi,orrrg

dqi

luAt

mA

qudc

gia

d&n

tQc

ni.o

khdn*

theo

tlurrg

<tlr<rrrg

16i

lfy dBu lri d;qt vong,

dho

thlli,

lhl nhiiu

hai

nrrii

(;o

hda

binh

vA

hqnh

phric

duoc"

(l)

'l'iir

cir

c&ng

vir;c

cria

nlrfrng nhA

l<hoa

hoc

hgr t:ltJlLr

*irirrii lci

liiiv

ughi0n-cuu

co:r

rgut'ri

ktr0ng

ph&i

hi.ng

klnh

hii rr vi

','l\

con

dao gili

phflu

mA

]riin

g

crl*

y;ll.i

rrrrg-li$rr ciis

r.,r,i1.

l.it,,;;i-[r{.rC

lirrll-lirSrr

li

iii

rhrlr.rl4

tn

chung

minh rlrro'c

vA

lAnr

r:itr,

'tttli

lii;i',

rirrriir;

l)li.An

nQi

tai,

th[i

tirrh

vi nl''iit

rt

tt',fl

ii{t;l

|:'ilrrr..,

hiri

sf,ug

vh

snu

khi

cltdt

ttri

nr0t sd

ir'r

r

cri

:

ltQ

ir;c

I

('.

r:hir.

n,qhTa

hi$n

nav

lr: klriic

irirni

su

ir

rii)

r,rii

r,]i

'i

plr'ii

trrarrh lrrAn,

,;0

su

tranh

lrrArr g'[i'e

t:ir.r

ir'ur

1r'ii:i li'

lri0rr nny

tr0n

thd

giui ciing

khOng

r:r,rr rriiit

r'rfir.tir

1

nguoi

t

li

i'r

r-,

g

l li,-1r'g

fiiS

t.r

lilri

ii3.

{in[r

clch

ttryi-116ng

giii'*

liir'^r,i

ltt,,i

tri klrit:

tittr,t'rl

si;'; r

l

vli-lru

riia

ut*

lru'ir'1

lti

.'A

qufln ni0rgr

vb

nhAn

sii

[(gn

rrl:$n

ri0ng

loSi ngudi

urtr

<Jitlirril

cir

rrq

kitirng

ct-t,r

ir

tl,i tii:'

tfr

nlla,

I)Ii'

ln

v?in-db

quan

llong nh?tt 0irr

ni'ti'r'rrrar

hiAn nly

(l)

L)fn xom

(

t{hftog

rtinh

lufit

cfra

vii trs

r',

xuft

hlu

crln51

rn$1

tdc

p,il,

sE

T'Va

I\AI-]C

LLIC

FtrBn

I

1'rang

h



{-;huong

Chtrong

Chuong

l.hrro'n4

il,-

I.

*

il,

--

tll'rrrlrrg

Ii

-

{.)b

urr

i:

rq

I1.

Llirurrrrtri

IIL

-*

flhuons

IV.i

."-

(

l11rr

6'nq

I,-.--

tihu'rng

I |

-

Clrrrrrng

lll -

,-'Quan

nitm

ub.srr bdl

tft

crta Unh ltbn

cdc

thili

dgi, {dlr

qidct

ud

dtln

tdc

Ngrrbn

sdc

u(i lich trlnh

ti6n

tri"en

cfia

chid,u

Iftn

thudt

Phhn

tl

CrIc

sv

lhi

nqli4m

crtu

khoa

chi\u

ltbn

19

Cluinq

ntinh

c{u;

litu

tup'nq,

Cdc

qi{t

thug{.t

ph&ri

t{.6i

ud

tdJt

h.ttln trft

l6i

5,1

qua

11

II

32

90

102

12

Fhhn

lll

T'<)rt

.oitio

tti{i

uo'i

khoa chi(tt

ltiln

'l'rif,t

hac

dr\i urlri

];hon

t:lt.ittt hiirt

Ilugln

bI

Ircc tf <ii

uo'i

ki,oft

rlieu

h,ru

Iiltou

lnc

iii

vri'i

lthr.tq

r

hiiu iiiir

'

Flrhn

lV

.[-dp

trrrdr,q

cila htrca

t'

tilrt

jriirr

f

llrrii

ud thuu[1

llriirr

/rrr/r

/ror:

lf/ri?rq

sV

nqury ftiijiir

irii

clit.u

hbn

llrud.t"

Ciln

rldnh

116

mi lin

Lli

doan

Il'I6t

ndm

lht

tr(thi(m

ui

chtttr

liitr

Iltndt

ud

cLic

ldi

lilu

chidu li)n

tr

ViiI-Nont

Llru'rrug

IV.-*

Girii

thiclt

uai

lrii.tt

lunnr1

dinq

bdnq

IVt)i

lrad'ng

Iryp

T'hkn Linh

iy

Vidl-Nam ;

Iittn

Li.nh

Tr.r

7'6ng

Iurln

T'di

IiEu

thant

kldo

'iuAN

iinH

rroc

=

rrruA r

crrrnu-u0,rr

ciTe

NGUYfiN.KIIOA-IIUAN

In

lal nhl In

rl0ng cfra

nhA xu?it

bln

10(t

1. t'?

I

:21|

'i

6,1

779

784

190

rAl

uEu THAM

rnAo

rrn

sAcn

Elng

bdng

Xe

hdi

Vi6t-Nanl

rAc

cri

Nhdl Lrtttll

Lttu

nlJ

tl{rc 7'ltiiilt

I.

,

I

}

*

31,

[,'hommc,

cet

Inconnu

35.

L'occullisme

devant

la sclence

36,

lout

I'occttltirmo

devoild

ir7.

Technlquo

tt

;ranthd'on

,lcr

mddiums

vi0tnamlens

.

,{leris

Qarrcl

llttrccll

Iktll

7'ocrltrct

]lurtrice

l)unLttrl



Vi6t-Nanr

vin

hda

sir

cnong

Vi(t-Nam

vin

hgc

sfr

toln

thu

Lto

Tir

Tdng

Nho

Iricr

lj

rla.o

Ph{t

bay rhi

khli

Kinh ling

nghi0m

Nhon

vflt

tdn hd a

Ddi sdng

tgrn

Hibn

ehln

phA

vgng

litittlt

Nhfrng biQn

tuqhg

silu

hlnh

MQt

sd

lap cbln

bfo

Vi6t-Natn

Yocabulaire

tcchil irlue et

tritiqtrc

tle

la

philosophie

l,l.

L'Occultisme

casse

cou

15.

IlIensoole

et

dari6,er

du sltiritlsntc

l6

Le

116mon

spirile

17.

[,'erreur

spirite

i

Itt, Le nronde

invlsiblc

It). Le

cp'r"tisnrc

cn facc

rle l'bistoire

rle

lr

scrience ct

rle

la

lleligion

Lr

psycbologie

lirconnue

Mors et vila

l)ersonnatres

de

I'au

dell

I-e clef de la

th6osophle

Pretniers

g115eig

ndnrcn ts

des

rrraitres

Lc eorps

rstral

Qu'e

st

cc

quc

I'occultisme

?

La

science

dcs

lntf,es

Clartes

sur

I'occult: sme

Jnana

toga

:Ddo dtty

'lrtlt

Ilodnq

lrgng

XIittt

Ngd t?it

't'?;

Ilitu

Chnt

7'hiclt

7'ltiQtt

Iha

Ltortg uiin

llbi

IIfii diclt l{risnanrurli

l{g'ugdn lehoa Iluritt

tlndri Lalande

Iic.rritttd

Diuoirc

Entile Chrislopht:

lrrnrrcis

de ilIirckrir

Ilctti

(:iuinort

(lorditml

L(picicr

Iloger

(l.kulort

Iintile lloiruc

l{ltdtrq

l0rr

Iletft

Suclre

II

P, Blauastkll

,I

ittat'n

jatltrstr

Iroruell

I'aprts

tltute

()smortl

Vit'e

Iirttntrdtt

Sri

Atrrobittdo

(

)anti

lle

F

[trttt

rtrttt'

r

t

tt

IIicheI

,Io

st'plt

Lappotul

4,

o

6.

n

L

a

10.

I l.

1',)

l2

tr'l

2r,

22.

21.

25.

26.

27,

'Q

)(l

30.

31.

q.)

33

38. L'bornme

et

sa destinde

.31).

Croy

ances

r

t

pretiques

re,i6ltuses

iles

vi6toamiens

10.

I-e

nronde

invlsiblc

et

nous

-

I.

Messagesdc

I'audoll

41.

-

Il l:ormt

s

mat6rlaliries

42,

La mort cettc

inconnue

4l|.

l,a

photographle

lranscondenlale

44.

L'au-dell

4i>

La melapsyohiquo

'l(i

l-'tnconsciont

17,

l,'a

prds

m ort

48, La

vdrit6

spirite

et

th6csophlque

source

tle bon hou

r

Les

grar,

ds maitrer

tplrlluels

tlaos

l'Inde

conle rrpor&lne

Psychologlc

des

elats

n(lrvcllx

I)r

l,e bonleur

pat

I'ait

J,'aulrc

cdtC

de

la

mort

La vle

aprCs

la

morI tl:tns

les

croyances

de

l'humanil6

Pr6cis

unlversel

rle

reliSion et

de morale

La

magie

pour

Itttts

Animisine

et

sPlrilisme

l)a

ns

l'rnvi

siblc

f,a

personnalit6

humaine

I.'cc

oplasmie

el

la

clairvoisnce

.Ilislorre

et

philt suphie

du

caorlllisme

Le

raodaislne

La teld

pathie

This

is spirllualisrn

Slrange

orvors

of

the

mintl

4l|.

50.

'

,.ll

52

t.)

5l

i)i).

50.

t8.

59

60.

61.

02,

63

{i

l.

P. Le comte

de

Noiitl

Ltopol

d

(

)ut' rl i i:

r'

r:

llaou I

IlIo ttlantlt

t

tt

Ii

r

an

'

o

i

s

G

r,:'

y1,, i,',,

1-

uo

rttttt

Ctrs

I c I I

r t

t

t

,Itutt-(

i-IIiIkttt.t

(l

lJttt'bttt'irt

JosePh

llira

'I

eut

llerltt

rI

tl

I

e.t

arul

t'

c

Lc s lclii

t

t

s k

i

IIcnri lltrltrttttlt

I'eadbetrlr'r

J onrcs

7'lru11cr

Artttic llevttrl

II

trl,

Cumpillttyr

Aksu ko

/'

I'tott

I)ettts

XI

Yer

s

GuslaPe

Geltll

(]altriel

Gorbort

W.

Cut'itrtll'ttt

JI uttr

ic e llarltr

rtu: Il

\l'arrctt

SntilJr

LUC

rl

Trang

D



chi€u

hbn

Cdc

gi&

tr& Idi

hbn

thudl

'rr

:t

72 ;o:

71,,

.

82i

'...:

',90

102

19

,53

.l

ti,:

'i

|p:

l"

I

j

09

117

Chucrng

"

M6t

8rtoh

KHOfi,

Bdn tgl tthf;"

rdch

I

T.i

ut-'frl

Tir

vi trQ

-

G}"

Lrrcrl

{

HOC

HUYEN.BT

:t;l'Sffi

lf-rsr

-

suscn

d&i

:

Nam

mang

ddi

: Nti

mang

OUOI

NHC'N

lr

sd thuc

hilnh

'irfifl

l;:t

l{iy

iv

j)

:f

t

1l

trf

lj'



:hm"tam

illd

rp chinh

.t0r1g

|

,'.

llrhn

trrdarf;

'No

llNl{

r hgc

tlrtrc

hbnh

il,l'f#,l

,TJ

"

i*

Di6n

Ngqc

{l

illt-

l

(lhi0rtt

ti

I

TiCng

Bi

m{

iitrbng

ttlin

')

Bdt

(

..1

:l

,

i'\

,1

i"-)

,.1',

I

ii..':l

,f:.,

r'{

ll,ii

,t

{'{,,;;

i,''fl

"h'r.;

il

li,

ffioi

E0t:

f

i'

Documents

THUAT CHIEU HON.pdf