25
[The Cold War: East v. West] [Modern World History] Greg Hurley [The Cold War is the name given to the tensions that existed between the “East” and the “West” during the second half of the 20 th century. Though much of this unit focuses on the rivalry of the major superpowers, the United States and the Soviet Union, it also has the students examine how this rivalry impacted allies of these countries and those countries who were not aligned with either superpower. This unit aims to give students a complete and thorough examination of the major events of the Cold War from beginning to end, and around the world. Each lesson brings to light specific events of the Cold War as well as bringing up the running themes of competing political systems and just how much is morality maintained or degraded in order to defeat a major enemy. ] Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 1 of 25

UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

  • Upload
    lehanh

  • View
    216

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

[The Cold War: East v. West][Modern World History]

Greg Hurley

[The Cold War is the name given to the tensions that existed between the “East” and the “West” during the second half of the 20th century. Though much of this unit focuses on the rivalry of the major superpowers, the United States and the Soviet Union, it also has the students examine how this rivalry impacted allies of these countries and those countries who were not aligned with either superpower. This unit aims to give students a complete and

thorough examination of the major events of the Cold War from beginning to end, and around the world. Each lesson brings to light specific events of the Cold War as well as bringing up the running themes of competing political systems and just how much is morality maintained or degraded in order to

defeat a major enemy.]

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 1 of 18

Page 2: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Table of Contents

Unit Plan ……………………………………………………………………………………………..………………………………………………….… p. 3

Stage 1………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. p. 3

Stage 2………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. p. 7

Stage 3………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. p. 8

CEPA Overview…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..……………… p. 13

CEPA Teacher Instructions …………………………………………………………………………………………………..………………….… p. 13

CEPA Student Instructions …………………………………….……………………………………………………………..………………….… p. 14

CEPA Rubric …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………...… p. 16

CEPA Resources ………………………………………………………………..…………………………………………………………………….… p. 17

Stage 1 Desired ResultsMassachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education

Page 2 of 18

Page 3: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

ESTABLISHED GOALS GThe Cold War Abroad, 1945-1980

WHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

WHII.28 Explain the consequences of World War II. (H, E)

A. physical and economic destruction

B. the enormous loss of life, including millions of civilians through the bombing of population centers and the slaughter of political opponents and ethnic minorities

C. support in Europe for political reform and decolonization

D. the emergence of the U.S. and the Soviet Union as the world’s two superpowers

WHII.29 Describe reasons for the

TransferStudents will be able to independently use their learning to… T

MeaningUNDERSTANDINGSStudents will understand that

Intervention was a primary policy of superpowers in the Cold War.

Governments have engaged in unethical behavior in order to preserve their way of life.

People tend to be drawn to either communism or capitalism and often will judge the other negatively.

Patriotism takes many forms; it can be construed as evil by those from an opposing viewpoint.

ESSENTIAL QUESTIONS Q

Do the ends justify the means?

When and why does one nation have the right to intervene in the affairs of another nation?

AcquisitionStudents will know… K

The history of communist expansion around the world.

Superpowers often view undeveloped allies as disposable

After WWII, Soviet and US tension became evident, particularly in war-torn Germany where both sides

Students will be skilled at… S

Interpreting ideas from primary and secondary sources through reading, listening, and observation

Identifying and validating multiple perspectives on the same event.

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 3 of 18

Page 4: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

establishment of the United Nations in 1945 and summarize the main ideas of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. (H)

WHII.30 Summarize the factors that contributed to the Cold War, including Soviet expansion in Eastern Europe and the differences between democracy and communism. (H, C)

WHII.31 Describe the policy of containment, including the Truman Doctrine, the Marshall Plan, and NATO, as America’s response to Soviet expansionist policies. (H)

WHII.32 Describe the development of the arms race and the key events of the Cold War era. (H)

A. the Korean War

B. the emergence of the People’s Republic of China as a major power

sought to prove superiority to the other.

Berlin became a symbol for the struggle between communism and capitalism and east v. west.

The Soviet Union sought to protect itself by expanding communism and giving itself a cushion of protection from the West.

The US sought to protect capitalism around the world by containing communism and not allowing it to grow.

Leaders of the Soviet Union and United States have both threatened world peace and worked towards achieving that same peace.

Key Terms: Arms Race, Cold War, Hot War, atomic weapon, nuclear weapon, Soviet Union, Berlin Arilift, East Germany, West Germany, Marshall Plan, Truman Doctrine, Communism, Capitalism, Proxy War, Cuban Missile Crisis, Korean War, Vietnam War, “east”, “west”, United Nations General Assembly, Politburo, NATO, Warsaw Pact

Identifying sequences of events

Interpreting and analyzing maps and graphs

Analyzing cause and effect

Identifying change over time

Independently researching for understanding of specific topics

Presenting research findings orally in a engaging manner.

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 4 of 18

Page 5: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

C. the 1956 uprising in Hungary

D. Soviet-U.S. competition in the Middle East

E. conflicts involving Cuba and Berlin

F. the Vietnam War

G. the “Prague Spring”

H. arms control agreements (including the ABM and SALT treaties) and détente under Nixon

I. the Soviet war in Afghanistan

WHII.35 Describe the global surge in economic productivity during the Cold War and describe its consequences. (H, E)

A. the rise in living standards

B. the economic recovery and development of Germany and Japan

WHII.36 Explain the various factors that

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 5 of 18

Page 6: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

contributed to post-World War II economic and population growth. (H, E)

A. the long post-war peace between democratic nations

B. the policies of international economic organizations

C. scientific, technological, and medical advances

WHII.38 Describe the development and goals of nationalist movements in Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the Middle East, including the ideas and importance of nationalist leaders. (H)

A. Fidel Castro (Cuba)

C. Ho Chi Minh (Vietnam)

D. Gamal Abdel Nasser (Egypt)

E. Jawaharlal Nehru (India)

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 6 of 18

Page 7: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

F. Juan Peron (Argentina)

Stage 2 - EvidenceEvaluative Criteria Assessment Evidence

CURRICULUM EMBEDED PERFOMANCE ASSESSMENT (PERFORMANCE TASKS) PT

Overview: Students will work in pairs and will be assigned a country. They will research this country to determine which of the two superpowers most negatively affected the assigned country and identify details which support this point of view. They then will write a report (which they will read aloud) in order to persuade the UN General Assembly (who will be made up of their classmates) to award them reparations due to the damage they suffered during the Cold War.

Goal: To exhibit through presentation of research how a developing nation was impacted by the Cold WarRole: Ambassador of that country to the UNAudience: the United States and Russian governmentsSituation: You need to convince the UN to force either the US or Russian government to pay reparations for damages done during the Cold War to your country. You must decide which government you are demanding payment from.Product: a 2-3 minute oral presentation laying out the history of the country was damaged by the Cold War and how that damage still impacts the world today.(Model UN Skill: how to collaboratively research a country and identify how that country’s perspective is different from the perspective of a US resident)

Countries: Cuba, Vietnam, Myanmar (Cambodia), Afghanistan, Iran, Argentina, Nicaragua, North Korea, South Korea, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Poland, Hungary, Greece, Romania, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Germany

For Cold War history of European Nations, go here:

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 7 of 18

Page 8: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

http://www.nationalcoldwarexhibition.org/explore/cold-war-countries.cfm

For all countries go here: http://countrystudies.us

Other websites with brief cold war histories for students to use:

The student should research that country’s government website, the US State Department website (www.state.gov),

the CIA World Factbook (https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/index.html), and UN.org to identify the following:

1) The role of this country in the Cold War and how the superpowers intervened in that country2) What form of government does it have today? Has that changed since the Cold War ended?3) What influence remains in that country of either the US or USSR?4) Describe daily life for the average person in this country using info like: Per capita income, GDP,

Dependency Factor, Religion, transnational issues5) How Americans view this country in comparison to those countries’ views of themselves.

The research is done in pairs, and the analysis of this research should be done together. The reports are done individually and can be either presented orally or recorded for the class to view.

OE Quizzes and Tests on different sections

Stage 3 – Learning PlanStage 3 – Learning Plan

Lesson 1: Introduction to the Cold WarBegin with a Cold War Pre-assessmentReview effects of WWII – End of WWII, how Europe and Asia were effected-Death Rates, Yalta, Potsdam – Textbook/2 column notes of these“1945 This is what life is like in the US, and then this is what life was like in the USSR (use Soviet Union National Anthem in this)”US: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/general-article/tupperware-consumer/Soviet Union:Intro students to EQ’s and CEPA

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 8 of 18

Page 9: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Lesson 2: Political Foundations of the Cold WarDisagreements between Stalin and Western democracies, Truman Doctrine, containment, Forming NATO and Warsaw Pact - http://edsitement.neh.gov/curriculum-unit/origins-cold-war-1945-1949#sect-introduction also good sources at: http://people.hofstra.edu/alan_j_singer/242%20Course%20Pack/3.%20Tenth/135.pdf Create a Cold War timeline. www.timetoast.comGive students a basic introduction to the concepts of Communism and Capitalism

Lesson 3 Berlin: a city torn between two worlds

The Newseum does a great job laying out what happened in Berlin from the wall being erected to it coming down: a webquest with two column notes and an analytical writing piece would be sufficient for this unit: http://www.newseum.org/berlinwall/

Berlin Airlifts – Photo Analysis – https://docs.google.com/document/d/1x_WSV9pye7TEKKoqgeT75W4Z_l3BRQCFrCH0t9xKaQE/edit Mark up & Comparison – Truman Library Summary of Airlifts: http://www.trumanlibrary.org/teacher/berlin.htm Truman Audio - I Hear/It Means - #1 http://www.trumanlibrary.org/audio/MP2002-65.wma #2 http://www.trumanlibrary.org/audio/MP2002-354.wma Stalin quote excerpt – Speech 1946 -

Stalin stated in a speech on February 9, 1946, "he [Stalin] blamed the last war on 'capitalist monopolies' and warning that, since the same forces still operated, the USSR must treble the basic materials of national defense such as iron and steel, double coal and oil production, and to delay the manufacture of consumer goods until rearmament was complete."

Who are the "capitalist monopolies?" How does this statement enlighten the Soviet viewpoint against the United States? Were the Allies justified in cancelling the shipments of German

reparations to the Soviets at the end of World War II? Why did the Soviets rely so heavily on Germany for food and industry? http://www.trumanlibrary.org/teacher/berlin.htm Kennedy: Ich Bein Ein Berliner: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYEdRiBPDXQ Reagan “Tear down this wall”: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjWDrTXMgF8 Tom Brokaw reporting as the Berlin wall comes down: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fK1MwhEDjHg

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 9 of 18

Page 10: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Lesson 4: Korea Divided Watch the following Khan Academy Video: https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/history/euro-hist/cold-war/v/korean-war-overview Read the following: http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/korean-conflict/ Analyze the document, The Truth about Korea: http://www.trumanlibrary.org/whistlestop/study_collections/korea/large/documents/pdfs/ki-18-

4.pdf#zoom=100 Persuasive Writing Assignment: As an advisor to President Truman, write a policy brief (persuasive essay) which convinces him that Korea is not a

threat to the United States, refuting what is said in the document above. More documents on Korean War: http://www.trumanlibrary.org/whistlestop/study_collections/koreanwar/index.php

Lesson 5 – Failed interventions by both superpowers: Vietnam and Afghanistan

Case Study 1: Vietnam and the Domino Theory Read http://civics.sites.unc.edu/files/2012/05/VietnamWar8.pdf Watch: https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/history/euro-hist/cold-war/v/vietnam-war Use the following resource from the National Archives to teach about Vietnam using pictures: http://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/vietnam-

photos/ Comparative Assignment: create a graphic organizer which compares and contrasts the politics of the Vietnam and Korean conflicts News story: You’re an embedded reporter with US troops at the My Lai Massacre – film a 3 minute news story explaining what happened and explain

the US soldiers’ point of view

Case Study 2: Afghanistan and the Soviet Union Look at this website for a brief overview http://www.ducksters.com/history/cold_war/soviet_afghanistan_war.php Good resource for teachers: http://fmso.leavenworth.army.mil/documents/miredinmount.htm Was the US responsible for sparking Al Qaeda and the Taliban? http://www.global-politics.co.uk/issue6/Stahl/ Compare the real life Charlie Wilson: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JgVc8jAHIw with the Hollywood version starring Tom Hanks

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4t7GADjRIuAo Does the film version do the real man credit?o In retrospect was his desire to help the Afghans foolish in that it taught the Afghans how to oppose foreign forces?

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 10 of 18

Page 11: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Lesson 6 – Cuban Missile Crisis

Cuban Communism Begin by watching the following summary of the Cuban Revolution: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynDus_RvuJs Read this summary: http://teacher.scholastic.com/scholasticnews/indepth/upfront/features/index.asp?article=f090108_Cuba Then explore the documents, paying particular attention to the testimonies of Cubans on the threat of Communism in the Caribbean:

http://www.latinamericanstudies.org/cuban-revolution.htm Open response: Why might communism appeal to Cubans? Was Cuba a threat to the United States before it allied with the Soviet Union? CIA Factbook research: Why are Cuba and the United States still opponents despite the fall of the Soviet Union?

Cuban Missile Crisis Case Study: Cuban Missile Crisis

o “World on the Brink” – JFK and the Cuban Missile Crisis: http://microsites.jfklibrary.org/cmc/ Read/examine/listen to the documents provided and analyze the President’s actions For each day of the crisis, students summarize if they agree or disagree with JFK’s actions, providing evidence and analysis as support To shorten teachers should have students read Day by Day summaries and focus on the following documents:

Map on Day 1 showing Missile sites Day 3: Ted Sorensen’s Memo Day 7: Letter from JFK to Khruschev, listen to JFK speech to the US Day 8: Read Khruschev’s reply letter to JFK Day 12: Khruschev to kennedy Day 13: Kennedy’s Public Statement ending the crisis

Extension Activity (or replacement activity) – watch film: “13 Days” and have students analyze President’s actions, explaining if they agree or disagree

Arms Control: after the Cuban Missile Crisis – Pages 9-12 of Choices, The Challenge of Nuclear Weapons Nuclear Weapons Reduction Treaties: Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (START I and II), Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty

(Pages in Choices, The Challenge of Nuclear Weapons – 15-19) UNODA page on UN treaties: http://www.un.org/disarmament/WMD/Nuclear/

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 11 of 18

Page 12: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Lesson 7 – Unconventional BattlefieldsExamine how the Cold War was fought beyond politics and traditional military build-ups. Content to include: Moscow Olympics boycott, Miracle on Ice, Space Race, “Star Wars”, Metallica plays Moscow, Rocky IV

Kennedy begins the race to the moon “We choose to go to the moon”: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g25G1M4EXrQ http://edition.cnn.com/2012/08/07/sport/olympics-2012-moscow-boycott-1980-don-paige - An Athlete’s story of missing the 1980 Olympics End of the Miracle on Ice: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qYscemhnf88 Rocky trains in the basement while drago trains in the complex: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1SUzcDUERLo (Background – the US is the

underdog who doesn’t have the fancy equipment but will surely be triumphant as he is the “good” guy) Metallica plays Moscow and the beatings of the audience begin (note interaction between government forces and the crowd):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_W7wqQwa-TU (Background – first western style concert allowed in Soviet Union, free festival “Monsters of Rock,” officially crowd estimated between 150,000 and 500,000, unofficial estimates put it at 1.6 million. Crowd control was provided by uniformed members of the KGB, who did not understand how kids reacted to western music and 53 people were killed during the day. Video shows those interactions (though not necessarily the beatings). Fascinating watching Soviet military helicopters fly patrol over western musicians.

Star Wars: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dO6rb8qcCo

Lesson 8 – The end of the Cold War –

Reagan / Gorbachev relationship and their goals/ desires: Collapse of the Berlin Wall - watch Tom Brokaw at the Brandenburg Gate: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fK1MwhEDjHgPolitburo dissolves itself and Yeltsin takes powerIndependence movements among the Warsaw Pact

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 12 of 18

Page 13: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Curriculum Embedded Performance Assessment

Persuasive Presentation to the United Nations General Assembly

Overview: Students will work in pairs and will be assigned a country. They will research this country to determine which of the two superpowers most negatively affected the assigned country and identify details which support this point of view. They then will write a report (which they will read aloud) in order to persuade the UN General Assembly (who will be made up of their classmates) to award them reparations due to the damage they suffered during the Cold War.

Teacher Instructions

GRASPSGoal: To exhibit through presentation of research how a developing nation was impacted by the Cold WarRole: Ambassador of that country to the UNAudience: the United States and Russian governmentsSituation: You need to convince the UN to force either the US or Russian government to pay reparations for damages done during the Cold War to your country. You must decide which government you are demanding payment from.Product: a 2-3 minute oral presentation laying out the history of the country was damaged by the Cold War and how that damage still impacts the world today.(Model UN Skill: collaboratively researching a country and identify how that country’s perspective is different from the perspective of a US resident)

Countries: Cuba, Vietnam, Myanmar (Cambodia), Afghanistan, Iran, Argentina, Nicaragua, North Korea, South Korea, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Poland, Hungary, Greece, Romania, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Germany

For Cold War history of European Nations, go here: http://www.nationalcoldwarexhibition.org/explore/cold-war-countries.cfm

For all countries go here: http://countrystudies.us

Other websites with brief cold war histories for students to use:

The student should research that country’s government website, the US State Department website (www.state.gov), the CIA World Factbook

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 13 of 18

Page 14: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

(https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/index.html), and UN.org to identify the following:

1) The role of this country in the Cold War and how the superpowers intervened in that country2) What form of government does it have today? Has that changed since the Cold War ended?3) What influence remains in that country of either the US or USSR?4) Describe daily life for the average person in this country using info like: Per capita income, GDP, Dependency Factor, Religion, transnational issues5) How Americans view this country in comparison to those countries’ views of themselves.

The research is done in pairs, and the analysis of this research should be done together. The reports are done individually and can be either presented orally or recorded for the class to view.

Student Instructions:

Welcome to the United Nations!

You and your partner have been assigned a country. You are now the representatives of this country to the United Nations. For this project you will be taking on the perspective of this country and how that country views the superpowers of the Cold War.

Your job will be to write a persuasive essay in which you determine which of the two major superpowers (the United States and the Soviet Union) caused your country the most damage during the Cold War and has left the most lasting negative impact on your country today.

In order to do this you will need to research your country today, and its history during the Cold War. Particularly you need to pay attention to how your country was hurt by the superpowers during the Cold War and how that has directly impacted your country today.

Your research should include a summary of information from the CIA World Factbook. You should also make use of the links which describe the history of your country during the Cold War.

Finally each group member will be responsible for writing a persuasive report on which superpower should pay reparations to your country. In proving this point you will lay out specific details about how that superpower damaged your country specifically and how that damage is still hurting your country today.

One of these reports will be presented to the General Assembly (the rest of the class) aloud and then you will submit to questions by the other nations. Your goal is to convince your classmates of the validity of your argument.

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 14 of 18

Page 15: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 15 of 18

Page 16: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Criteria 4 Advanced 3 Proficient 2 Developing 1 Limited 0

Argu

men

t and

Cl

aim

CLAIM: precise and knowledgeable argument is exceptionally clearTOPIC KNOWLEDGE: demonstrates exceptionally accurate, sophisticated and thorough knowledge of the topic within a greater contextOPPOSING CLAIM: highly effective distinction between claim and alternative or opposing claimAUDIENCE: Shows clear awareness of audience, purpose, values and bias

CLAIM: argument is generally clear TOPIC KNOWLEDGE: demonstrates generally accurate, somewhat sophisticated knowledge of the topic, within a greater contextOPPOSING CLAIM: generally effective distinction between claim and alternative claim; does not elaborate on how the claims differAUDIENCE: Shows general awareness of audience and purpose

CLAIM: suggests, but does not explicitly state an argument or claim.TOPIC KNOWLEDGE: demonstrates simple knowledge of the topic; greater context lacks clarityOPPOSING CLAIM: somewhat effective distinction between claim and alternative or opposing claimAUDIENCE: Shows limited awareness of audience and purpose

CLAIM: argument is unclear or not includedTOPIC KNOWLEDGE: does not demonstrate knowledge of the topic nor of the greater contextOPPOSING CLAIM: ineffective distinction between claim and alternative or opposing claimAUDIENCE: Shows no awareness of audience and purpose

Student Provides No Answ

erO

rgan

izatio

n

PARAGRAPHS: exceptionally clear use of distinct paragraphs which sequence claim, supporting evidence, conclusion. TRANSITIONS: Highly effective words, phrases, clauses and varied syntax to link major portions of the text and create cohesion between claims and evidenceINTEGRATION OF EVIDENCE: Highly effective paraphrasing and integration of relevant information within each body paragraph.CONCLUSION: concluding paragraph shows how the evidence follows from or supports the argument or claim.

PARAGRAPHS: generally clear use of distinct paragraphs with some organized progression of ideas.TRANSITIONS: Generally effective use of words, phrases and clauses to signal transition and clarify relationships between claims and evidenceINTEGRATION OF EVIDENCE: Generally effective paraphrasing and integration of relevant information within each body paragraph.CONCLUSION: concluding paragraph shows substantial understanding of how the evidence follows from and supports the claim.

PARAGRAPHS: lacks clarity with use of distinct paragraphs for claim, supporting evidence, conclusion. TRANSITIONS: Somewhat effective use of words, phrases and clauses to signal transition and clarify relationships between claims and evidenceINTEGRATION OF EVIDENCE: Somewhat effective paraphrasing and integration of relevant information within each body paragraph.CONCLUSION: concluding paragraph shows moderate understanding of how the evidence follows from and supports the claim.

PARAGRAPHS: unclear use or no use of distinct paragraphs for claim, supporting evidence, conclusion.TRANSITIONS: Ineffective use of words, phrases and clauses to link major portions of the text and create cohesion between claims and evidenceINTEGRATION OF EVIDENCE: Ineffective paraphrasing and integration of relevant information within each body paragraph. CONCLUSION: no concluding paragraph; or concluding paragraph shows serious misunderstandings in how the evidence supports, follows from and relates to the claim.

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 16 of 18

P e r s u a s i v e W

Page 17: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Evid

ence

PERSUASION: highly effective use of most significant relevant, accurate, credible evidence that demonstrates an expertise in the topicCOUNTER-CLAIM: Is highly effective at integrating and using evidence to point out limitations of counterclaims

PERSUASION: generally effective use of relevant, accurate, credible evidence that demonstrates a general understanding of the topicCOUNTER-CLAIM: Is generally effective at using evidence to point out limitations of counterclaims

PERSUASION: attempts effective use of relevant, accurate, credible evidence that demonstrates a partial understanding of the topicCOUNTER-CLAIM: attempts to effectively use evidence to point out limitations of counterclaims

PERSUASION: ineffective use or lack of relevant, accurate, credible evidence that demonstrates a misunderstanding of the topicCOUNTER-CLAIM: Uses no evidence to point out limitations of counterclaims

Wor

d Ch

oice

WRITING FOR A PURPOSE: highly effective use of content specific, academically appropriate vocabulary and writing techniquesTONE: Precise language creates a powerfully convincing tone which speaks to the expertise of the reader

WRITING FOR A PURPOSE: generally effective use of content specific, academically appropriate language and vocabularyTONE: generally effective word choice to create a formal, moderately persuasive tone

WRITING FOR A PURPOSE: attempts effective use of content specific, academically appropriate language and vocabularyTONE: attempts effective word choice to create a formal, persuasive tone

WRITING FOR A PURPOSE: ineffective, content specific, academically appropriate language and vocabularyTONE: ineffective word choice to create a formal, persuasive tone

Conv

en-

tions

Not Applicable for exams only CONVENTIONS: generally accurate writing mechanics with mostly correct spelling, punctuation, sentence structure, and paragraph structure that do not interfere with understanding.

CONVENTIONS: moderately accurate writing mechanics with major errors in spelling, punctuation, sentence structure, and paragraph structure that interfere with understanding.

CONVENTIONS: highly inaccurate writing mechanics with major errors in spelling, punctuation, sentence structure, and paragraph structure that severely interfere with understanding.

TotalScore

____/19

Resources:It is suggested that instructors utilize the following website made by Carol Mastromauro and adapt much of the resources to meet the needs of the students in

the CEPA:http://mrsmmodelun.wikispaces.com/Country+Research

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 17 of 18

Page 18: UbD Template 2.0 - Wikispaces · Web viewWHII.7 Describe the rise of unions and socialism, including the ideas and influence of Robert Owen and Karl Marx. (H, E)

Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education Page 18 of 18