7/27/2019 Week 5 : Presentation on Workbook Evaluation based on Williams checklist

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/week-5-presentation-on-workbook-evaluation-based-on-williams-checklist 1/7

Workbook Evaluation

By

RahmatElsa

Cressida

Vanessa

7/27/2019 Week 5 : Presentation on Workbook Evaluation based on Williams checklist

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/week-5-presentation-on-workbook-evaluation-based-on-williams-checklist 2/7

Natural Englishby

Ruth Gairns & Stuart Redman

•

Intermediate student’s book• Unit Evaluated – Unit 3 & Unit 7

7/27/2019 Week 5 : Presentation on Workbook Evaluation based on Williams checklist

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/week-5-presentation-on-workbook-evaluation-based-on-williams-checklist 3/7

 The Checklist

•  The checklist used was William’stextbook evaluation checklist.

•  The chapters were divided intosections – The checklist also dividedinto sections - it is easier to do

evaluation.• Each sections in the checklist have

further specification to help us

identify the requirement of the book.

7/27/2019 Week 5 : Presentation on Workbook Evaluation based on Williams checklist

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/week-5-presentation-on-workbook-evaluation-based-on-williams-checklist 4/7

• We encountered some difficult terms– hard to understand the criteria.

•  The rating system is a bit difficult touse.

• It have too specific criterias – some

of the criteria are not fulfilledbecause of the content of the book istoo short.

7/27/2019 Week 5 : Presentation on Workbook Evaluation based on Williams checklist

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/week-5-presentation-on-workbook-evaluation-based-on-williams-checklist 5/7

 The Book

• Both chapters are not arranged in awell manner.

•  The book also integrate usage of sidematerial and make it hard to doevaluation – part of the section are

not clear.• The content of each aspect is too

short and brief – several criteria in thechecklist are not fulfilled

7/27/2019 Week 5 : Presentation on Workbook Evaluation based on Williams checklist

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/week-5-presentation-on-workbook-evaluation-based-on-williams-checklist 6/7

Solutions Taken

• We refer to the content list of thebook – have specification for the

chapters.• We evaluate according – only

evaluate the criteria available.

7/27/2019 Week 5 : Presentation on Workbook Evaluation based on Williams checklist

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/week-5-presentation-on-workbook-evaluation-based-on-williams-checklist 7/7

Conclusion

•  The checklist is appropriable for theteacher – even unexperienced

teacher can do evaluation becausethe checklist have focuses.

• However, they need to take some

time to understand the checklist andhow to applied it to do evaluation.