6
The “Greek” on Wonder Woman’s Equipment in Batman v. Superman Dr. Vincent Tomasso ([email protected]) 1. Both inscriptions 66sword: υFαναμρ + αμαμταμυFαναμ…ηας/ατιατιιθαβαλαντα λριFα...σαης/αδατικα ησαζαοθρασαλα...ατι 66transliteration: uwanamr amamtamuwanam...êas/atiatiithabalanta lriwa...saês adatika êsazaothrasala...ati 66shield: ατιψFαηαFατι + ατιιθαβαλαντ + αησαδατικα + ησαζαοθρασα ρατιψFαηασατι + υFαμαμραμαμ 66transliteration: atipswaêawati atiithabalant aêsadatika êsazaothrasa ratipswaêasati uwamamramam 66repeated strings: υFαναμ (uwanam), αδατικα (adatika), ησαζαοθρασα (êsazaothrasa), ατι (ati), θαβαλαντα (thabalanta), ραμαμ (ramam; across two “words”), ρατιψFαηα (ratipswaêa) 2. Shield 66inscription: ατιψFαηαFατι + ατιιθαβαλαντ + αησαδατικα + ησαζαοθρασα ρατιψFαηασατι + υFαμαμραμαμ 66Shield 1.jpg [left6hand side, bottom to middle; overlap with Shield 4]: digamma6alpha6 eta6alpha6digamma6alpha6tau6iota + alpha6tau6iota6iota6theta6alpha6beta6alpha6lambda6 alpha6nu6tau + 66Shield 2.jpg: [right6hand upper and partial lower]: alpha6eta6sigma6alpha6delta6alpha6 tau6iota6kappa6alpha + eta6sigma6alpha6zeta6alpha6omicron6theta6rho6alpha6sigma– alpha + rho6alpha6tau6iota6psi6digamma6alpha6eta6alpha6sigma6alpha6tau6iota + 6 upsilon6digamma6alpha6mu6alpha6mu6rho6alpha6mu6alpha6mu 66αησαδατικα ησαζαοθρασα ρατιψFαηασατι [?]υFαμαμραμαμ 66Shield 3.jpg (right6hand middle and lower): letters checked against previous image 66Shield 4.jpg (left6hand lower): letters checked against previous image 3. Sword Blade 66entire inscription: υFαναμρ + αμαμταμυFαναμ…ηας / ατιατιιθαβαλαντα + λριFα...θσαης / αδατικα ησαζαοθρασαλατ...ασατι + 66line 1: *6upsilon6digamma6alpha6nu6alpha6mu6rho + alpha6mu6alpha6mu6tau6alpha6 mu66upsilon6digamma6alpha6nu6alpha6mu [baldric strap] alpha6tau6iota6alpha6tau6iota6 iota6theta6alpha6beta6alpha6lambda6alpha6nu6tau6alpha lambda6rho6iota6digamma6 alpha…theta6sigma6alpha6eta6sigma / alpha6delta6alpha6tau6iota6kappa6alpha eta6sigma6 alpha6zeta6alpha6omicron6theta6rho6alpha6sigma6alpha6lambda6alpha6tau [baldric strap] alpha6sigma6alpha6tau6iota *: I’ve not been able to find a letter that looks like this in any Greek script. It looks something like an upward6pointing arrow () and is used a total of three times in the shield and sword inscriptions.

Wonder Woman's Greek in BvS - Nerdistnerdist.com/.../2016/03/Wonder-Womans-Greek-in-BvS.pdf · The$“Greek”$on$Wonder$Woman ... (Steel.$Perhaps$we$can$deduce,$then,$that$Wonder$

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Wonder Woman's Greek in BvS - Nerdistnerdist.com/.../2016/03/Wonder-Womans-Greek-in-BvS.pdf · The$“Greek”$on$Wonder$Woman ... (Steel.$Perhaps$we$can$deduce,$then,$that$Wonder$

The$“Greek”$on$Wonder$Woman’s$Equipment$in$Batman&v.&Superman&

Dr.$Vincent$Tomasso$([email protected])$$1.$Both$inscriptions$

66sword:$↑υFαναμρ$+$αμαμταμ↑υFαναμ…ηας/ατιατιιθαβαλαντα$λριFα...σαης/αδατικα$ησαζαοθρασαλα...ατι$

66transliteration:$↑uwanamr$amamtam↑uwanam...êas/atiatiithabalanta$lriwa...saês$adatika$êsazaothrasala...ati$

66shield:$ατιψFαηαFατι$+$ατιιθαβαλαντ$+$αησαδατικα$+$ησαζαοθρασα$ρατιψFαηασατι$+$↑υFαμαμραμαμ$

66transliteration:$atipswaêawati$atiithabalant$aêsadatika$êsazaothrasa$ratipswaêasati$↑uwamamramam$

66repeated$strings:$↑υFαναμ$(↑uwanam),$αδατικα$(adatika),$ησαζαοθρασα$(êsazaothrasa),$ατι$(ati),$θαβαλαντα$(thabalanta),$ραμαμ$(ramam;$across$two$“words”),$ρατιψFαηα$(ratipswaêa)$

2.$Shield$66inscription:$ατιψFαηαFατι$+$ατιιθαβαλαντ$+$αησαδατικα$+$ησαζαοθρασα$ρατιψFαηασατι$+$↑υFαμαμραμαμ$66Shield$1.jpg$[left6hand$side,$bottom$to$middle;$overlap$with$Shield$4]:$digamma6alpha6eta6alpha6digamma6alpha6tau6iota$+$alpha6tau6iota6iota6theta6alpha6beta6alpha6lambda6alpha6nu6tau$+$66Shield$2.jpg:$[right6hand$upper$and$partial$lower]:$alpha6eta6sigma6alpha6delta6alpha6tau6iota6kappa6alpha$+$eta6sigma6alpha6zeta6alpha6omicron6theta6rho6alpha6sigma–alpha$+$rho6alpha6tau6iota6psi6digamma6alpha6eta6alpha6sigma6alpha6tau6iota$+$↑6upsilon6digamma6alpha6mu6alpha6mu6rho6alpha6mu6alpha6mu$$ 66αησαδατικα$ησαζαοθρασα$ρατιψFαηασατι$[?]υFαμαμραμαμ$66Shield$3.jpg$(right6hand$middle$and$lower):$letters$checked$against$previous$image$66Shield$4.jpg$(left6hand$lower):$letters$checked$against$previous$image$

3.$Sword$Blade$66entire$inscription:$↑υFαναμρ$+$αμαμταμ↑υFαναμ…ηας$/$ατιατιιθαβαλαντα$+$λριFα...θσαης$/$αδατικα$ησαζαοθρασαλατ...ασατι$+$66line$1:$↑*6upsilon6digamma6alpha6nu6alpha6mu6rho$+$alpha6mu6alpha6mu6tau6alpha6mu6↑6upsilon6digamma6alpha6nu6alpha6mu$[baldric$strap]$alpha6tau6iota6alpha6tau6iota6iota6theta6alpha6beta6alpha6lambda6alpha6nu6tau6alpha$lambda6rho6iota6digamma6alpha…theta6sigma6alpha6eta6sigma$/$alpha6delta6alpha6tau6iota6kappa6alpha$eta6sigma6alpha6zeta6alpha6omicron6theta6rho6alpha6sigma6alpha6lambda6alpha6tau$[baldric$strap]$alpha6sigma6alpha6tau6iota$

*:$I’ve$not$been$able$to$find$a$letter$that$looks$like$this$in$any$Greek$script.$It$looks$something$like$an$upward6pointing$arrow$(↑)$and$is$used$a$total$of$three$times$in$the$shield$and$sword$inscriptions.$

Page 2: Wonder Woman's Greek in BvS - Nerdistnerdist.com/.../2016/03/Wonder-Womans-Greek-in-BvS.pdf · The$“Greek”$on$Wonder$Woman ... (Steel.$Perhaps$we$can$deduce,$then,$that$Wonder$

Tomasso$$ 2$

This$might$be$to$give$the$impression$that$as$in$Battlestar(Galactica$the$ancient$Greeks$were$Kryptonian$colonists$(per$Mike$Shaw)$and$so$their$Greek$is$slightly$“different”$from$the$historical$inscriptions.$

66line$2:$alpha6tau6iota6alpha6tau6iota6iota6theta6alpha6beta6alpha6lambda6alpha6mu6tau6alpha$+$lambda6rho6iota6digamma6alpha$[baldric$strap]$theta6sigma6alpha6[unclear$letter]6sigma$66line$3:$alpha6delta6alpha6tau6iota6kappa6alpha$*$theta[?$or$eta?]6zeta6alpha6zeta6alpha6omicron6theta6rho6alpha6sigma6alpha6gamma$(?)6alpha6tau$[baldric$strap]$alpha6sigma6alpha6tau6iota6phi$

4.$General$notes$about$the$inscriptions$$ 66the$letter$forms$seem$to$be$mostly$in$upper$case,$as$befits$an$ancient$Greek$inscription$$ 66the$cross$sign$[+]$seems$to$be$a$separator;$it$appears$elsewhere$in$the$inscription,$as$$

well$as$at$the$ends$of$the$first$and$third$lines$(as$decoration,$I$think;$in$other$words,$it’s$$outside$the$inscription,$not$within$it)$66the$letter$forms$are$not$standardized$ancient$Greek.$Their$forms$in$many$cases$appear$to$be$from$regional$alphabets—see,$for$instance,$the$frequent$appearance$of$the$digamma$(F;$a$“w”$sound)$that$dropped$out$of$most$alphabets$by$the$seventh$century$BC.$The$designer$may$be$trying$to$impart$a$sense$that$these$inscriptions$are$older$than$most$ancient$Greek.$66these$letters$don’t$form$any$ancient$Greek$words$that$we$know.$Michael$Wilkinson,$the$costume$designer,$has$said,$“There$is$ancient$Greek$script$on$Wonder$Woman’s$weapons,$too”$(reference:$http://www.themarysue.com/wonder6woman6costume6design/;$see$further$below),$so$the$inscription$on$the$armor$is$supposed$to$represent$a$language$(but$invented$instead$of$real).$66I$can’t$make$out$any$English$words$either,$nor$do$I$see$references$to$the$universe$of$Man(of(Steel,$including$“Krypton.”$Surprisingly,$there$aren’t$any$references$to$“Amazons”,$“Themiscyra”,$“Athena”,$or$“Aphrodite”$either.$66I’m$unable$to$make$out$the$letters$surrounding$the$figure$near$the$blade’s$hilt.$The$figure$looks$like$a$seated$deity$similar$to$Roman$coins$like$the$one$on$the$right$(figure$1).$66$Man(of(Steel’s$Kryptonian$(http://kryptonian.info/man6of6steel/about.html)$looks$very$similar$to$our$world’s$Arabic.$Dr.$Schreyer,$the$anthropologist$consultant$who$invented$Kryptonian$for$the$film,$has$said$that$a$big$influence$on$her$creation$was$the$native$American$Cree$language$as$well$as$Japanese$(http://kryptonian.info/news6feed.html/2013/07/22/interview6with6man6of6steel6linguist6christine6schreyer/).$Man(of(Steel’s$Kryptonian$is$a$syllabic$language,$meaning$that$syllables$are$formed$around$vowels.$This$is$very$different$from$the$ancient$Greek6like$language$on$Wonder$Woman’s$armor.$Some$of$the$syllables$look$similar,$however.$I$find$it$suspicious$that$the$creator$of$Kryptonian$in$Man(of(Steel$has$been$very$publicly$credited,$whereas$nothing$(to$my$knowledge)$has$been$said$about$the$“creator”$of$Wonder$Woman’s$language.$This$may$be$because$the$language$only$appears$on$her$equipment,$whereas$Kryptonian$appears$in$numerous$place$in$Man(of(Steel.$Perhaps$we$can$deduce,$then,$that$Wonder$Woman’s$Greek$is$a$one6for6one$letter$substitution$system?$In$other$words,$that$

Figure(1(

Page 3: Wonder Woman's Greek in BvS - Nerdistnerdist.com/.../2016/03/Wonder-Womans-Greek-in-BvS.pdf · The$“Greek”$on$Wonder$Woman ... (Steel.$Perhaps$we$can$deduce,$then,$that$Wonder$

Tomasso$$ 3$

Wilkinson$chose$a$letter$of$the$ancient$Greek$alphabet$to$represent$a$letter$from$the$American$alphabet.$$

$In$The(Secret(History(of(Wonder(Woman,$historian$Jill$Lepore$remarks$that$one$of$William$Marston’s$wives,$Sadie$Elizabeth$Holloway,$enjoyed$reading$Greek$poetry$(Sappho$in$particular).$This$is$significant,$since$Holloway$had$a$strong$influence$on$the$creation$of$Wonder$Woman—some$say$she$was$a$model$for$the$character.$$Michael$Wilkinson$on$the$costume$design$In$an$interview$with$DC(All(Access$(available$at$https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSAO2Ff09SU),$Wilkinson$reveals$that$Zack$Snyder$asked$him$to$put$some$words$in$Kryptonian$on$Superman’s$suit:$“Zack$loved$the$idea$that$there$was$actually$some$Kryptonian$script$embedded$in$the$suit.$He$gave$me$this$fantastic$quote$that$he$wanted$us$to$translate$into$Kryptonian$and$incorporate$into$the$suit.$It$deals$with$the$nature$of$power$and$the$responsibility$that$comes$with$power.”$We$know$what$these$words$are.$They’re$a$quote$from$Joseph$Campbell:$“Where$we$had$thought$to$stand$alone,$we$will$be$with$all$the$world”$(source:$http://www.msn.com/en6us/lifestyle/pets/kryptonian6quote6on6supermans6suit6in6batman6v6superman/vp6AAg7E0e).$Could$the$same$quote$be$on$Wonder$Woman’s$armor?$Wilkinson$further$says:$“With$Wonder$Woman,$what$Zack’s$talked$to$me$about$is$creating$a$character$who$has$incredible$power$and$strength.$Her$presence$as$a$warrior$is$completely$legitimate$and$unquestionable,$but$at$the$same$time,$has$a$grace$and$elegance$of$the$Amazonian$culture.$It’s$quite$a$formal$culture;$their$way$of$fighting$is$very,$very$disciplined,$so$we$wanted$to$sense$that$majesty$with$her$look.”$Wilkinson$also$mentions$that$he$and$the$production$team$combined$Wonder$Woman’s$fantastical$and$realistic$elements:$“When$we$were$creating$our$textures,$we$were$referring$to$metals$that$exist,$but$also$creating$new$finishes$of$metals$that$might$have$this$supernatural$kind$of$power$to$them,$so$hopefully$we$created$something$original$and$eye6catching.”$This$philosophy$might$also$be$applied$to$the$script$on$her$armor—it$looks$like$real$ancient$Greek$but$also$is$partly$invented.$$Greek$in$Wonder$Woman$comics$

$1)$All@Star(Comics$#8$(=Chronicles$p.$7;$12/41;$figure$2):$the$Amazons$use$a$“magic$sphere”$that$has$inscriptions$in$English$around$its$rim$similar$to$new$shield’s$design.$2)$Sensation$Comics$#3$(=Chronicles$p.$43;$1942;$figure$3):$Wonder$Woman$gets$a$job$as$a$secretary,$and$her$shorthand$style$is$

depicted$in$one$panel.$It$looks$like$gibberish,$but$in$a$later$comic$it’s$revealed$to$be$Greek.$

Figure(2( Figure(3(

Page 4: Wonder Woman's Greek in BvS - Nerdistnerdist.com/.../2016/03/Wonder-Womans-Greek-in-BvS.pdf · The$“Greek”$on$Wonder$Woman ... (Steel.$Perhaps$we$can$deduce,$then,$that$Wonder$

Tomasso$$ 4$

3)$Wonder$Woman$#1$(=Chronicles$p.$100;$6/42;$figure$4):$a$nurse$finds$a$scroll$dropped$by$Wonder$Woman$after$she$leaves$Steve$Trevor$at$a$hospital.$Three$lines$of$ancient$Greek$are$more$or$less$visible:$η$ιστορια$των$αμιχων$Αμαζονα$(grammatically$incorrect$Greek$for:$“The$history$of$the$unconquerable$Amazons”,$which$imitates$the$first$line$of$the$ancient$Greek$historian$Herodotus:$Ἡροδότου$Θουρίου$ἱστορίης$ἀπόδεξις$ἥδε$=$“This$is$the$display$of$Herodotus$of$Thurii”).$

$$$4)$A$newspaper$strip$(8616644)$has$the$following$exchange$between$Diana$Price$and$her$employer:$"For$heaven's$sake,$Diana,$explain$your$shorthand$symbols$to$Miss$Dollar!"$"Why,$er,$those$are$Greek$letters!"$"D'you$mean$to$tell$me$you$use$Greek$letters$for$shorthand$symbols?"$"I$didn't$say$that6"$$

5)$In$Wonder(Woman:(the(Hiketeia$(Rucka$and$Jones$2002;$figure$5),$Wonder$Womanand$the$Furies,$spirits$of$vengeance$in$ancient$Greek$myth,$speak$Greek$to$one$another.$This$is$represented$by$angled$brackets$$(<>).$$

Figure(5(

Figure(4(

Figure(5(

Page 5: Wonder Woman's Greek in BvS - Nerdistnerdist.com/.../2016/03/Wonder-Womans-Greek-in-BvS.pdf · The$“Greek”$on$Wonder$Woman ... (Steel.$Perhaps$we$can$deduce,$then,$that$Wonder$

Tomasso$$ 5$

$(

6)$In$Frank$Miller’s$The(Dark(Knight(Strikes(Again$(200162;$figure$6)$Wonder$Woman’s$belt$is$emblazoned$with$a$Greek$alpha$(=“A”).$$$$$7)$Azzarello’s$run$on$Wonder$Woman$in$The$New$52$makes$much$more$(explicit)$use$of$Greek$mythology$than$previous$iterations,$with$gods$like$Apollo,$Poseidon,$Hades,$Hermes,$and$Hera$playing$major$roles$in$the$

story.$It’s$ironic,$then,$that$Greek$script$doesn’t$appear$in$the$run.$Take,$for$instance,$the$panel$in$issue$#1$(2011;$figure$7)$that$gives$us$a$glimpse$of$Wonder$Woman’s$armor$wardrobe.$We$see$a$bit$of$her$shield,$and$there$are$no$Greek$letters$on$it.$When$she’s$outfitted$with$new$armor$by$Hephaestus,$she$chooses$pieces$that$Hephaestus$call$“archaic”—but$still$no$Greek$lettering$(2013;$figure$8).$

$$$$$

$Conclusions$Although the “words” on Wonder Woman’s equipment are not from ancient Greek, I still think something can be said about them. Most of the letter-forms are recognizably ancient Greek, which suggests, combined with the fact that there are no decipherable Greek words, that Snyder and co. are jettisoning Wonder Woman’s usual mythology in which Wonder Woman’s native language is Greek. Grant Morrison recently complained about the New 52’s Wonder Woman having armor and a sword—perhaps the inscriptions suggest a similar re-invention. This idea is also bolstered by the fact that many of the letters, including the digamma form, are archaic—that is, they make the Greek look like it’s from an older stratum than many historical inscriptions that we have. It seems that costumer designer Michael Wilkinson was tasked with “translating” certain key phrases and incorporating those phrases both onto Wonder Woman’s equipment and into Superman’s suit. We might then suspect that the Kryptonian and Wonder Woman’s ancient Greek are similar in some way, shape or form. Snyder’s Wonder Woman is making a break with all previous incarnations of Wonder Woman, who have had no Greek on their equipment (with the very marginal exception of Miller’s version). It’s sort of in line with the golden age version, who reads and writes (in

Figure(7(

Figure(8(

Figure(6(

Page 6: Wonder Woman's Greek in BvS - Nerdistnerdist.com/.../2016/03/Wonder-Womans-Greek-in-BvS.pdf · The$“Greek”$on$Wonder$Woman ... (Steel.$Perhaps$we$can$deduce,$then,$that$Wonder$

Tomasso$$ 6$

some cases real) ancient Greek, but it adds the twist that it’s not actually ancient Greek (though it would look so to the casual viewer, which is probably the point). Snyder’s version also combines the New 52 version’s penchant for using armor that looks like it’s from ancient Greece. My strong suspicion is that Snyder and his production crew are implying through these inscriptions that their Wonder Woman is from an older culture, one of whose offshoots was the historical ancient Greece. This is similar to the re-imagined Battlestar Galactica, which posited that the human civilization was the basis for human cultures on Earth (and it was implied that their gods, which were named after Greek and Roman deities, became the basis for the ancient Greek and Roman religions).