Transcript
Page 1: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

1

Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges –

A Case from India and Mozambique

Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy

University of Oslo

Page 2: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

2

Information Systems Can be best understood as Social systems Web of social and technical elements(Walsham et

al,1990) Heterogeneous networks (Braa & Sorenson,1998) ``Information systems (IS) as systems of human and

technical components that accept, store, process, adapt and transmit information. Can be any combination of human endeavours, paper based methods and IT.’’ (Heeks1998,p5)

Information infrastructure (Hanseth, 2000) Contd…

Page 3: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

3

Information Systems as… Technological discrete artefacts (Technological determinism)

(Kling et al,2000) Why technological determinism cannot be applicable in ISs is: Pure technological view on Information Systems Predefined and expected effects has not always been realised in

practice.(Technological determinism cannot adequately account for the interactions between ICT, the people who design, implement and use them, and the social and organisational contexts in which the technologies and people are embedded.“ (Kling et al. 2000 p.49-50)

Also, it has limited value in dynamic and complex situations that unfurls over longer periods of time.

Page 4: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

4

ISs–Using Concept of Web Models (Social Informatics) ISs can be studied using web

models(Kling and Scacchi 1982 “Web models draw broad boundaries

around the focal computer system and examine how its use depends upon a social context of complex social actions.

Page 5: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

5

ISs–Using Concept of Web Models (Social Informatics) And social context here refers to the

social relations between the set of participants concerned with the information system, the infrastructure available for its support, and the previous history within the organisation of commitments made in developing and operating related computer-based technologies.” (Walsham 1993 p.55)

Walsham G. 1993 “Interpreting Information Systems in Organizations”John Wiley & Sons Ltd

Page 6: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

6

ISs can be best understood as Organisational Informatics Organisational Informatics.... is concerned with IS and the organisation where it is

implemented Social systems perspective demands a much more complex

view on the processes of change involved and the interactions between the information system and the organisation (Walsham 1993).

To analyze the social interactions between information systems and organisational contexts three theories have been put forward and they are:

a. Structuration theory, b. Information infrastructures and c. IS & Politics,(Walsham 1993, Braa 1997, Puri and Sahay

2003).

Page 7: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

7

Brief definitions of the theories… Structuration theory allows for change, it puts forward the

fact that organisational structure can change and human actors are able to cause this change(Giddens, 1984)because social structures are constructed by social action.

Information Infrastructures encompasses a whole network of human, social and technical components.

Information Infrastructure are described as shared, evolving, open, standardised and heterogeneous, and it is also referred to as Installed Base (Hanseth and Monteiro,1998).

Page 8: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

8

Brief definitions of the theories Information Systems and Politics: Politics of organisations are considered as an important

elements in the IS development process (Feldman & March,1981).

Political perspective has been used as part of an analytical framework for IS and organisational change(Walsham,1983).

People with different political agendas create barriers to information sharing (Buchanan-Smith et al, 1994).

Example( Information use and collection is seen as important for decision making, it has an important symbolic value in these organisations and their decision making processes).

Page 9: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

9

Health Information Systems….. ``..as a combination of people,

equipment and proceedures organised to provide health information to health workers and others in a way that enables them to make informed decisions’’(Boerma,1991).

Page 10: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

10

Types of Health Information Systems

A. Clinical Health Information Systems

Clinical HISs are typically large and complex hospital information systems that focus on patient specific data. These sophisticated health information systems that are often large hospital systems have proven to be difficult to develop both in developed and developing countries, and about three quarters of these systems have failed (Littlejohn, Wyatt and Garvican 2003, Heeks and Bhatnagar 2001).

Page 11: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

11

b.Routine Health Information Systems “Information that is derived at regular intervals of a year

or less through mechanisms designed to meet predictable information needs” Potomac Statement (RHINO 2002 p.2)

Examples of routine health information systems are :Health service statistics for routine services reporting and special program reporting (malaria, TB, and HIV/AIDS), administrative data (revenue and costs, drugs, personnel, training, research, and documentation), epidemiological and surveillance data, data on community-based health actions, data on vital events (births, deaths and migrations).

Page 12: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

12

b.Routine Health Information Systems

An important strength of routine HISs is that decision makers and managers at all levels of the health system has direct access to data.

Useful in health planning and management,

Empowers practitioners and managers to identify problems as they arise and solve them (ibid.).

*HISP will focus on Routine HIS at Primary Health Centres & District Based Health Information Systems.

Page 13: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

13

Why HIS? HIS is essential for strengthening the information

management practices within the Primary Health Care (PHC) sector with the larger aim to improve processes concerning health care delivery for the rural community.

To develop capacity of the health staff to better deal with computers, health information systems, and health indicators and targets.

Development of this capacity will lead to better governance of the health sector and improved delivery of health care to the community.

Page 14: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

14

Why HIS in Developing Countries? To strengthen information management

practices within the Primary Health Care (PHC) sector with the goal to improve more effective health delivery to the rural community.

Rationalization of data collection, computerization of information flows from the PHCs to Districts & State

Page 15: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

15

Why HIS in Developing Countries? Developing tools for analysis, and training of

health care workers , Medical Officers in PHCs; District Medical and Health Administration, State Health Department including Family Welfare

To increase feedback leading to Decentralisation

An opportunity to bridge the digital divide by using ICTs in HIS( Castells, 2001)

Page 16: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

16

Information Systems and Developing Countries

To bring the developing countries on par with the developed countries agencies such as UN have stressed on ‘Technology Transfer’.

Page 17: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

17

What is Technology Transfer? Dore (1984) defines the process of technology

transfer as the effort of getting knowledge that is only in the head of some foreigners to the practise of the nationals in developing countries.

Odedra (1990) sees the process as transferring knowledge on how the system works, how to operate it, maintain it and assemble the different components of it.

Page 18: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

18

Different Perspectives Towards Technology Transfer Heeks (2002) states that the failure rate of IT

projects in developing countries is higher than the 75% failure that is found in the western world, and this he attributes to ‘design-reality gaps’.

Gaps can be of all kinds- culture, organisation, information use, power structures, knowledge level, infrastructure etc., or more likely, a combination of several of these.

Page 19: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

19

Different Perspectives Towards Technology Transfer Technology transfer is not neutral & value free

(Sahay &Walsham,1997) TT even from South-South is not problem free

(Kaasboll & Nhampossa,2002) as they need to be more sensitive to the social context and more adaptation is needed than just transferring ICT infrastructure or tools.

“Technology is not just an isolated machinery or artefact, but involves the social and cultural context.

Page 20: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

20

Different Perspectives Towards Technology Transfer Technology cannot be transferred and put

into use as initially planned as all users shape and adapt systems in ways which were not planned (Bijker and Law,1992).

Technology transfer can be sustainable provided the local knowledge is sufficient to maintain the technology (hardware & software) (Castells,1996)

Page 21: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

21

What is Primary Health Care and District Health System Concept of PHC – initiated at the WHO and UNICEF

conference in 1978. Introduction of PHC - shift in health focus from the larger

hospitals to health centres and from curative to preventive health care.

“ Primary health care is essential health care based on practical, scientifically sound and socially acceptable methods and technology made universally accessible to individuals and families in the community through their full participation and at a cost that the community and country can afford to maintain at every stage of their development in the spirit of self-reliance and self-determination.

Page 22: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

22

What is Primary Health Care and District Health System It forms an integral part both of the country's

health system, of which it is the central function and main focus, and of the overall social and economic development of the community.

It is the first level of contact of individuals, the family and community with the national health system bringing health care as close as possible to where people live and work, and constitutes the first element of a continuing health care process. ” (WHO 1978 p.1)

Page 23: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

23

Health District System WHO (1995) lists some characteristics of the health

district system: A defined administrative area with a population of

approximately 50,000 – 3,00,000. A segment of the national health system. It comprises all facilities and individuals in the district

who are involved in health care at the various intervention levels, including not only governmental, but also church, charity, and private health care providers.

The vertical programmes (e.g. immunization, family planning or AIDS control) should be coordinated with the horizontal health services and integrated as far as possible, at least at the primary level.

Page 24: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

25

Health Information Systems Programme (HISP) HISP was initiated in South Africa to

develop a health information system. Software - District Health Information

System was developed and was used as the basis for the development of a health information system that focused on local health management.

Page 25: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

26

HISP: A Global R&D Network

Other initiativese.g. Nigeria

NorwaySouth Africa

India

Mozambique Tanzania

Malawi

EthiopiaCuba

Mongolia

Page 26: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

27

HISP in India In India Andhra Pradesh was selected –overall

policies and practices on IT provided the favorable clime for HISP.

Objectives: Strengthen health information management at district and community levels to support local analysis and use of data

Empowerment of health workers through the use of ICTs – developing “knowledge workers.”

Integrate HISP with ongoing e-governance initiatives in AP

Page 27: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

28

Flow Chart Depicting the Hierarchy Levels in Health Sector

Commissioner of Family Welfare

Primary Health Centre (PHC)

Sub-Centre

State level:

District level:

Health programme officers:

Department of Health

District Medical & Health Officer (DM&HO)

Leprosy Tuberculosis

Malaria

Other programs

Health Programs

APVVP (Hospital Structure)

DCHS - District Hospital Services

All Hospitals

incl . uding the smaller CHCs

Maternal Obstetric Delivery Units (PPU) Part of Hospitals

Health facility & institution level:

Family planning

Page 28: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

29

India

Page 29: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

30

Andhra Pradesh

Page 30: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

31

Chitoor District

Page 31: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

32

Kuppam Constituency

Page 32: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

33

Situation Anlaysis- HISP in AP December 2000-September 2001: Systems study and

developing of Minimum Data Sets (MDS). Phase1(Sept’01-Aug’02)Piloting in Kuppam,9 PHCs,

placing of computers in PHCs and in DM&HO. Customization and adaptation of software. ”On-site” and ”Off-site” training programmes Implementation and modification of MDS Creating routine database from Jan 2001 Generation of various reports Presentation to CM: Instructions for extension Systems handover to district in July ’02 Stabilization of existing 9 Kuppam PHCs

Page 33: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

34

Situation analysis… (contd) Sep 2002 –Nov 2002: Development of AP Reports

module(25-30 reports) Sept 2002- Project evaluated by CFWD Oct 2002-MoU signed for expansion to Madnapally- total

46 PHCs Nov’02 –Feb’03- Creation of Chittoor district database(84

PHCs & regular updation of the data base. Feb’03- July’03- Implementation of HISP in 46 PHCs Aug’03- Dec’03 – Stabilisation of HISP in PHCs &

customisation of DHIS Jan’03 –Training of trainers on advanced knowledge in the

health domain, Development of MM & IM rate web enabled data base.

Page 34: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

35

Situation Anlaysis (contd) Feb’04 till May ’04 – CFWD contracted HISP to

create state level database for a period of one year(2003-’04)

Web enabled the state data base(www.aphealth.org)

Creating a HISP Spatial Analyst(integration of the routine data, indicators and infrastructure with village boundary maps, over layed also with population and road maps )*

Local language translation** Proposal for integration of DHIS and FHIMS***

Page 35: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

36

Page 36: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

37

Page 37: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

38

Parallel System in AP – FHIMS Name based system for providing services

at the community level based on the H.Hold level data.

Piloted in Nalgonda DHIS and FHIMS are complementary

Proposal to pilot the Integration of FHIMS &DHIS to reap the potential synergies

Page 38: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

39

Household level data for various services like

immunization, disease statistics, etc.

FHMIS

Routine monthly data for SC, PHC, and district

PHC profilesTarget and indicatorsPopulation (census)

Maps (Village boundaries, population, roads, etc.)

HISP

Integration Bridge

Routine monthly reports to be sent from PHC to districtRoutine monthly reports to be sent from district to stateAnalysis reports of performance of respective targets and indicators for the facilitiesLocal level reports for ANMs like schedulingTracking reports for particular disease like TBTracking reports for particular services like immunizationAll reports will be GIS enabled and also web enabled

Outputs reportsThis program will take the export files from FHMIS, reformat the file into notepad text file, and then imported to HISP

This program will take the export files from FHMIS, reformat the file into notepad text file, and then imported to HISP

Page 39: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

40

Value Added Features of Integration FHIMS name based functionality can support

MPHA scheduling of work Tracking action on diseases like TB and HIV

HISP can provide All facility based reports, different formats and levels Based on improved data collected through FHMIS

Overall through integration Overall improved information support at all levels Cost effective solution, rapid implementation Can draw upon HISP network locally and globally

Page 40: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

41

Strategies used.... Evolutionary step by step strategy Building rapport at all levels Developing institutional capacity within

the health sector in information management and use

Participatory design & prototyping Continuous support and motivation

Page 41: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

42

Action Research… ...is a social research carried out by a team of

researchers or professionals from different disciplines and members of community to improve the existing situation in the health sector.

… promotes broad participation in the research process and supports action leading to a more just or satisfying situation for stakeholders’’(Greenwood and Levin,1998)

Page 42: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

43

Action research ... has helped in understanding of an immediate

social situation assists in practical problem solving and expands

scientific knowledge is performed collaboratively and enhances the

competencies of the respective actors thus implying a process of participatory observation.

primarily applicable for the understanding of change processes in social systems.

Page 43: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

44

Ongoing Challenges in India Top down approach by the government Change of governments Lack of decentralisation Collection of large volumes of duplicated data. Poor quality data –no validation, manipulation of

data at all levels Limited usage of data Lack of standards Large data sets Little or no analysis

Page 44: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

45

(contd..)Ongoing Challenges Formal approvals are delayed Funding (e.g. from EU or World Bank) requires HISP

to be ”state project” Lack of resources, state funds for HISP over two

years is less than Rs. 4 lakhs Weak district support at Chittoor Infrastructure conditions in PHC areas Needs stronger institutionalization, e.g. setting up

cadre of health information officers. Bureaucratic procedures cause long delays

Page 45: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

46

(Contd…)Ongoing Challenges. Transfers, technical limits, time pressures.

Institutionalisation issues: parallel systems, building routines and creating information culture Social factors

Political Complexities Parallel system developed by GoAP (FHIMS- a

name based system). HISP treated as outside agency

Page 46: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

47

HISP in -Mozambique Computer based HIS (called SisProg) in 1992 in all its 11

provinces and the national level. Routine health data in the paper forms from the districts

entered into SisProg at the province level. Aggregated data sent in electronic (floppy disks) or paper

formats to the national level. Kinds of problems that exist with data quality, structures

of reporting, and aspects related to non-use of data. SisProg though irrelevant in local decision –making still

over the period got embedded in to the practices of the Ministry making it difficult to replace.

Page 47: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

48

Situation Analysis – Mozambique

In 1999 a team comprising of staff and students from Ifi, UiO attempted to customise and implement DHIS in three selected provinces on a pilot basis.

Customization of DHIS -2 categories:a. Global-standardized reports (like missing data),

indicator generator, data mart, analysis tool, etc. Changes in global features were coordinated by the South African development team.

b. Location Specific- language, data elements, indicators, local reports, lookup tables, procedures and definitions, such as reporting frequency, need to be adapted locally by the HISP team.

Page 48: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

49

Situation Analysis – Mozambique

a. Language was a crucial issue as many in the health sector could not understand English.

b. Translation from English to Portugese (DHIS and documentation was in English).

c. Translation process could not be carried out on multiple machines as the team implementing HISP in Moz depended on S.Africa for creating the Set up CD.

Page 49: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

50

Challenges….. Initial constraint on translation resulted in poor

training facility. Translating and customizing the DHIS. For example,

there were many ambiguous data elements.

Institutional and technical challenges in the process of populating the data base in the software

No formal permission and financial resources from MoH

Parallel systems existed.

Page 50: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

51

In spite of all the benefits why there are challenges in implementation of HISP in AP?? Political agenda Bureaucratic Structure Top down approach Large Funding from International funding agencies Limited global experiences in implementation of HIS Limited actors involved and Participatory design is not

encouraged. Lack of committment both in training and in

implementation Fear of transparency – Access to data should be curbed by

outsiders.

Page 51: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

52

In spite of all the benefits why there are challenges in implementation of HISP in AP?? Lack of expertise and understanding at the higher

echleons in health department both in Technical (IT)and Social domains (Process of Implementation).

Ex: Wants DHIS reports without DHIS software 2 -3 day mass training of users on FHIMS(14

module) software. Repeating the exercise(developing reports etc using

commercial companies-waste of time,efforts & resources)

Page 52: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

53

Reasons for facing these Challenges in India Limited resources Considered to be a research project Not funded by huge International

funding agency Lack of support from health

department at the higher level

Page 53: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

54

Tackling the political complexities…. By approaching the officials at the CMs office. Demonstrating the benefits of implementing the

integrated softwares at less cost. Highlighting the flexibility, user compatability &

other components of DHIS Highlighting the users capacity gained through

DHIS to analyse and make decisions using health data.

Page 54: 1 Implementation of HIS: Complexities and Challenges – A Case from India and Mozambique Dr.Zubeeda Quraishy University of Oslo

55

Tackling the political complexities….

Presenting different outputs generated through DHIS -Strength of DHIS

Providing Continuous On-site training to the Users at the PHCs –’ increasing support & confidence’ at bottom level

Building the demand from Users for DHIS