21
Endowment Management Spend Policy Jeff Sobers Senior Product Marketing Manager

Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

This is the third presentation in the Endowment Management series. After discussing distribution basics and unitization in the first two, this presentation tackles spending policy, including what it is, the pros and cons of having one, and various methods to determine the optimal spend policy.

Citation preview

Page 1: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Endowment Management Spend Policy Jeff Sobers Senior Product Marketing Manager

Page 2: Endowment Management: Spend Policy
Page 3: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Review of Distribution Basics

Blackbaud Confidential 3

Page 4: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

The Endowment Process

Endowed Fund

Create

Fund

Invest

Earn

Distribute

Spend

Page 5: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Income Distribution Methods

Proportional Unitized

Page 6: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Proportional Distribution Example $5,000 investment earnings

A; 22,500; 23%

B; 29,250; 29%

C; 38,250; 38%

D; 10,000;

10%

Endowment Balance

A; $1,125.00;

23%

B; $1,475.00;

29%

C; $1,912.50;

38%

D $500.00

10%

Earnings

Page 7: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Review of Unitization

Blackbaud Confidential 7

Page 8: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Definition According to Investopedia: A unitized endowment pool is a form of endowment investing that has mechanics similar to a mutual fund. A unitized endowment pool allows multiple endowments to invest in the same pool of assets. Each endowment owns individual units in the unitized investment pool, and the units are generally valued monthly. New endowments entering the pool can buy in by receiving units in the pool that are valued as of the buy-in date.

Page 9: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Benefits of Unitization

Relatively simple to distribute earnings Pool total return / pool total units = return per unit Return per unit * units per endowment = return per endowment

Mutual fund is a familiar concept to most endowment donors

Page 10: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Drawbacks of Unitization

Adds complexity for no reason Dollars must be converted to units and back again Additional piece of information to track, usually in spreadsheet

Often donors aren’t even aware of the units their fund owns

Page 11: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Final Thoughts on Unitization

Unitization is a simple way to calculate earnings distributions, but it can be

time-consuming to manage unit calculation and upkeep for distributions and additions.

Page 12: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Final Thoughts on Unitization

Because the earnings per unit is calculated on the last day of the

earning period, unitization unfairly rewards late additions that weren’t earning income the entire period.

Page 13: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Spend Policy

Blackbaud Confidential 13

Page 14: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

What is Spend Policy?

• Defines how much each endowment can spend as a percentage or dollar amount

• Dependent on how the endowment is invested • For example, if investments are limited to government

issued notes and bonds, it is unlikely ever to be able to generate sufficient returns to permit a 4% annual payout.

• Also establishes rules for whether returns may be used should the organization face a financial crisis (which also should be defined).

Page 15: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Why Have a Send Policy?

• Dampen the volatility of spending • Maximize the endowment’s value

over the long-term • Preserve purchasing power over time

on par with mission support

Page 16: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Spending Under UPMIFA

Spend as much as the board deems prudent, based on: • the duration and preservation of the endowment fund • the purposes of the institution and the endowment fund • general economic conditions • the possible effect of inflation or deflation • the expected total return from income and capital

appreciation • other resources of the institution • the investment policy of the institution

Page 17: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Optimal Spend Policy

• Inflation-Based Rules • Inflation-Protected • Banded Inflation

• Smoothing Rules • Moving Average • Spending Average • Stabilization Fund

• Hybrid Rules • Alpha-Beta Approach • Yale/Stanford Rule

Page 18: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Demonstration

Blackbaud Confidential 18

Page 19: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Speaker Follow-up Slide

Jeffrey.Sobers@Blackbaud 843.654.3088 (optional) @jeffsobers For more information, resources, and conversations, visit: blackbaud.com/research npEngage.com

Blackbaud Confidential 19

Page 20: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

Save the Date!

October 6 – 8, 2014, Gaylord Nashville, TN

Page 21: Endowment Management: Spend Policy

About Blackbaud, Inc. Serving the nonprofit and education sectors for 30 years, Blackbaud (NASDAQ: BLKB) combines technology and expertise to help organizations achieve their missions. Blackbaud works with more than 28,000 customers in over 60 countries that support higher education, healthcare, human services, arts and culture, faith, the environment, independent K-12 education, animal welfare, and other charitable causes. The company offers a full spectrum of cloud-based and on-premise software solutions and related services for organizations of all sizes including: fundraising, eMarketing, social media, advocacy, constituent relationship management (CRM), analytics, financial management, and vertical-specific solutions. Using Blackbaud technology, these organizations raise more than $100 billion each year. Recognized as a top company by Forbes, InformationWeek, and Software Magazine and honored by Best Places to Work, Blackbaud is headquartered in Charleston, South Carolina, and has operations in the United States, Australia, Canada, Mexico, the Netherlands, and the United Kingdom.

Blackbaud Confidential 21