20
Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom Dr. Pauline Rooney Irish Symposium on Game-Based Learning June 2012 1

Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Presentation at Irish Symposium on Game Based Learning, June 2012

Citation preview

Page 1: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

1

Exploring higher education students'

attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

Dr. Pauline Rooney

Irish Symposium on Game-Based LearningJune 2012

Page 2: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

2

Some background: digital natives & serious games

Research overview & methodology Findings Conclusions Questions

Overview

Page 3: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

3

Claims that they have different learning styles/skills/habits:◦ Expect participatory, sensory-rich environments (Oblinger

2008)◦ Oriented to visual media ◦ Prefer learning-by-doing (Bennett et al. 2008)◦ Prefer bite-size, chunked information (Conole 2010)◦ Effective multi-taskers (Prensky 2001)◦ Function best when networked ◦ Adept at social networking via multiple modes (Oblinger &

Oblinger 2005)

Today’s HE students

Immersed in digital technologies/social

networking

“Digital natives” “Net

generation”

Page 4: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

4

Claims that students no longer respond to traditional instruction (Prensky 2001)

Serious games viewed as mechanism for engaging students, meeting their needs and expectations.

Digital natives, pedagogy & serious games

But is this the case?

Page 5: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

5

Most focuses on school children: reveals mixed picture:◦ Not all are technologically literate / game players

(Bourgonjon et al. 2010, Bekebrede et al. 2011)◦ Preference for games as leisure pursuit (Sandford

et al. 2006)◦ Perceived as inappropriate for HE (Graham 2007).

Most lit on HE demonstrates assumption that students will embrace serious games.

Previous research on students’ perspectives of serious games

Page 6: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

6

Investigated students’ attitudes as part of larger case study which explored implications of in-house approach to design/ development/ implementation of serious games in HE.

Led to development of “Serious Gordon”

Research overview

Page 7: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

7

Serious Gordon piloted with 37 undergraduates. Data sources:

◦ Field observation during pilot (myself and colleague)◦ Online survey (post game-play)◦ Semi-structured focus group interviews

Cross-tabulations conducted across survey and qualitative data to identify significant trends.

Qualitative data analysis techniques:◦ Categorical aggregation ◦ Direction interpretation (Stake 1995)◦ Constant comparison method (Glaser and Strauss 1967)

Data collection & analysis

Page 8: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

8

Participants’ profiles (1)

73% - first years27% - fourth years

Page 9: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

9

Participants’ profiles (2)

Familiarity with PCs/gaming:• Over 75% familiar/very familiar with computers• Almost 84% had played video games previously• Most were not “gamers” (73%): i.e. they did not play

computer/video games at least “a few times per week”• All gamers were male

Majority aged 18-22 yrs

Age

Page 10: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

10

“Playing computer/video games is a waste of time” YES: 19% NO: 81%

*Overwhelmingly positive attitude towards game play*

Initial findings

All female

Page 11: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

11

“I think that learning food safety through playing computer/video games is a good idea”

YES: 83.7% NO: 16.3%

Initial findings

• Majority non-gamers (so negative impact of lack of prior gaming experience• No gender link (contradicting previous research)

Page 12: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

12

For those in favour of serious games..... Consensus that it would be easier to learn

via games:◦ more engaging/interactive/motivating◦ more visual◦ appealing alternative to lectures◦ fun

“you can do stuff yourself

instead of sitting there

listening”

“You start off and you want to get to the next level..... you want to get to the end of it and see the

final outcome. “keeps you entertained for a

while”

“If you can visualise what you’re learning

it’s a lot easier.

“good for a bit of relief”

Page 13: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

13

Three key findings:(1) Link between gender & reasons underlying

students’ antipathy towards serious games(2) Conflicting perceptions of play and

educational processes(3) Difficulties reconciling notions of interactive

game play with traditional pedagogical expectations

For those against......

Page 14: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

14

For those against serious games: Males: tended to regard games as leisure

activities only (& majority were non-gamers) Females: lack of gaming experience led to fears

of disadvantage

Gender and antipathy towards serious games

Reinforces Bourgonjon (2010) who linked gaming experience with positive attitudes towards serious gaming (mediated by gender). But also shows that one does not need to be a gamer to hold view that gaming is inappropriate for learning purposes.

Page 15: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

15

Some females, although disinterested in leisure gaming, embraced it when it had an educational purpose.

Shows gender differences in perspectives on the purposes of gaming (unmediated by gaming experience).

Perhaps unsurprising when we consider previous studies on gender-based perceptions of ICTs (Colley 2003)◦ Males: playful, exploratory approach to ICTs.◦ Females: utilitarian approach, use tools to assist

with particular tasks.

Gender, games & perceptions of ICTs

Page 16: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

16

Games and education as dichotomous pair

Games undermine seriousness of content. Inappropriate for HE.

Terminology: Difficulties reconciling the term “game” with serious purposes.

(2) Perceptions of play vs education

“...a classroom environment should probably be a classroom environment and taken seriously because it is serious issues that

are being dealt with ...”

Games = FUN

Education = SERIOUS

I: “Would you like the idea of using computer games to learn.. if they were designed specifically for your course? []”

S: “Not so much games, computer programs.”

Page 17: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

17

Difficulties reconciling notions of interactive game play with traditional conceptualisations of formal education.

Belief that traditional, didactic model of education is most effective way to learn at third level.

(3) Pedagogic expectations & beliefs

“You couldn’t really learn a whole syllabus on just a game. You’d have to have a list or whatever at the

end... like a list of questions or a bit of information, or a handout.”

Page 18: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

18

Majority show positive attitude towards serious games.

However today’s students are not a homogenous group.◦ For minority, conflicting perceptions of game play and

educational processes – often mediated by gender and/or prior gaming and educational experience – may constitute a barrier.

Challenges tacit assumptions that today’s HE students will embrace serious games.

Highlights needs and perceptions that should be addressed when introducing serious games to the HE classroom.

Conclusions

Page 20: Exploring higher education students' attitudes towards serious games in the classroom

20

Bennett, S., Maton, K., Kervin, L. (2008) The 'digital natives' debate: A critical review of the evidence. British Journal of Educational Technology, 39 (5) 775-786.

Bourgonjon, J., Valcke, M., Soetaert, R., Schellens, T. (2010) Students' perceptions about the use of video games in the classroom. Computers & Education, 54 (4) 1145-1156.

Bekebrede, G., Warmelink, H.J.G., Mayer, I.S. (2011). Reviewing the need for gaming in education to accommodate the net generation. Computers & Education, doi: 10.1016/j.compedu.2011.02.010.

Colley, A. (2003) Gender differences in adolescents' perceptions of the best and worst aspects of computing at school. Computers in Human Behaviour, 19 (6) 673-682.

Conole, G. (2010) Stepping over the edge: the implications of new technologies for education. In: M. J. W. Lee and C. McLoughlin (eds) Web 2.0-based Elearning: Applying Social Informatics for Tertiary Teaching. Hershey: IGI Global

Graham, S. (2007) Re-playing history: The Year of the Four Emperors and Civilization IV. The Higher Education Academy. Available from: http://www.heacademy.ac.uk/hca/resources/detail/re_playing_history [Accessed 5 November 2008].

Oblinger, D. (2008) Growing up with Google: what it means to education. Emerging Technologies for Learning Volume 3. Coventry: BECTA. Available from: http://partners.becta.org.uk/index.php?section=rh&rid=13768 [Accessed 11 September 2008].

Oblinger, D. and Oblinger, J. (2005) Is it age or IT: First steps toward understanding the Net Generation. In: D. Oblinger and J. Oblinger (eds) Educating the Net Generation. EDUCAUSE. Available from: http://www.educause.edu/educatingthenetgen [Accessed 25 June 2008].

Prensky, M. (2001) Digital Game-Based Learning. New York: McGraw-Hill. Sandford, R., Ulicsak, M., Facer, K., Rudd, T. (2006) Teaching with games: Using commercial

off-the-shelf computer games in formal education. Bristol: Futurelab. Available from: www.futurelab.org.uk/download/pdfs/research/TWG_report.pdf [Accessed 12 November 2008].

References