IDEA CELLULAR LIMITED Idea is a integrated GSM operator and has its

own national long distance and international long distance operations.

IDEA Cellular is an Aditya Birla Group Company.In March, 2011, the Company launched its 3G

services.On January 20, 2011, the Company launched

mobile number portability (MNP), an invite to all Indian mobile customers to change their wireless operator, while retaining their mobile number

Board Of DirectorsKumar Mangalam Birla Chairman

Non Executive DirectorRajashree Birla Biswajit A Subramanian Sanjeev AgaGian Prakash GuptaRakesh JainJuan Villalonga Navarro

Independent Director

Tarjani VakilP MurariMadhabi Puri BuchArun ThiagarajanGyani MohanR C Bhargava

Tata CommunicationTata Communications Limited incorporated on March,

19, 1986, is a provider of wholesale international voice services and operates a submarine cable network in the world.

The Company offers a number of other services, such as national long distance (NLD), mobility services, and retail and small business services.

The Company’s retail and small business services include calling cards, gateway Internet access services, broadband through metro Ethernet, broadband through DSL, broadband through WIMAX, Internet leased line circuits, net access using Wi-Fi, Internet telephony and content services.

Board Of DirectorsMr. Subodh Bhargava Chairman

Vinod KumarManaging Director and Tata Communications Limited Group CEO

N. SrinathDirector

Mr. Kishor A. ChaukarDirector

Mr. Amal GanguliDirecto

Mr. S. RamadoraiDirector

Mr. Arun GandhiDirector

Dr. Ashok JhunjhunwalaDirector

Uday B. Desai Director

Financial dataIDEA Cellular TATA Com.

in crores

Sales 4966.45

Net profit/loss 844.60

No. of Shares 330.32

Face value per share

10

Book valuePer share

37.15

LoansSecured loanUnsecured loan

7760.042797.42

Net Current Assets

-2410.30

Investments 2572.81

in crores

Sales 3611.76

Net profit/loss 160.16

No. Of Shares 28.5

Face value per share

10

Book valuePer share

245.88

LoansSecured loanUnsecured loan

1250964.98

Net Current Assets

2363.67

Investments 1832.82

Idea Tata Comm.

Number of shares (in crores)

330.32 28.5

Net Profit/ Loss (Rs in crores)

844.60162.56

Market price (7th Feb 2012)

93 222

EPS (March 2012) 2.55 5.70

PE (6th Jan 2012) 37.80 40.57

RECCOMENDATIONI would like to suggest my investors to invest in Idea

because:The market price of Idea i.e. 93.00 is lower than that

of Tata i.e. 222And secondly the Sales of Idea i.e 4966.45 is higher

than that of Tata i.e 3611.76And Profit of Idea i.e 844.60 is higher than Tata i.e

160.16So looking overall to these I would suggest to invest in

Idea Cellular company