71

Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Professional Development Workshop, AOM Annual Meeting, Montreal, Aug 6, 2009 Eric Barends, Barbara Janssen, Dirk Ubbink, Wendelien van Eerde

Citation preview

Page 1: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 2: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 3: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 4: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 5: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 6: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 7: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 8: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 9: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 10: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

Page 11: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  Evidence-based medicine, nursing, surgery, practice, …

 Originated from McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada

  Accountability (for cost-effectiveness) of healthcare workers to:   Patients   Insurance companies   Hospital boards   Government

  Bridges the gap between research and practice

  Helps keep up efficiently with professional literature

Page 12: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

Five-step method to find, appraise & apply the best available

evidence from research literature

1.  Formulate problem (PICO)

2.  Search literature databases (e.g. PubMed, Cochrane)

3.  Critical appraisal (CAT)

4.  Assess applicability in your situation

5.  Evaluate process

Page 13: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  EBM starts with critical attitude towards daily clinical activities

  Routine procedures used for years might be useless rituals!

  Judgment of expert or opinion leader is not sacrosanct!

  Evidence-based guidelines are needed if there is:

  Variation in policy

  Doubt about effectiveness of an intervention

  New or additional process / product

Mainly a ‘pull’ approach

Page 14: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  Evidence-Based Practice

  Considered essential to improve quality of health care

  Focuses on actual clinical problems

  Introduced in medical, nursing, & paramedical curricula

  Principles integrated throughout curricula

Page 15: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  Evidence-Based Practice for undergraduates

  E-learning modules about EBP principles & five-step approach

  Searching medical literature databases

  Critical appraisal of recent publications & new drug ads

  Weighing benefits against harms of medical interventions

  Transparent medical decision making

Health Canada warns that drugs purchased over the internet from unlicensed sources could pose a risk. (CBC News, July 27, 2010)

Page 16: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  Evidence-Based Practice for postgraduates

  Online E-learning modules for students & trainers

  European initiative: www.ebm-unity.org

  Postgraduate courses

  Incorporated in clinical training programs (for residents and specialists)

  For surgeons, pediatricians, gynecologists, GPs, public health, etc.

  For nurses, midwives, physical therapists, dieticians etc.

  Master EBP

Page 17: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  EBP integrated in:   Ward rounds

  Handovers & other formal meetings

  Journal clubs

  Patient case discussions

  Clinical teaching of trainees

  Medicine = dynamic profession life-long learning

Page 18: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  Integration in health care leads to:   Evidence-based decision making

  Evidence-based protocols

  New questions for further research

  Improved uniformity & quality of health care

Page 19: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  Patients expect quality care according to the latest scientific insights and developments.

  Their choice becomes easy when dr. B turns out to be dr. EBP!

Page 20: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

  Customer expects quality products that meet the latest scientific insights and developments.

 Manager / Consultant = dynamic profession life-long learning

  Preconditions:

  Body of (pre-appraised) systematic research data

- Evidence-based management theories & models

  Peer review of each other’s performance

  Management as uniform profession

Page 21: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Academic Medical Center

University of Amsterdam

Page 22: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 23: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 24: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 25: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 26: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 27: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 28: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 29: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 30: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 31: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 32: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 33: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 34: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 35: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 36: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

ABI/INFORM, Business Source Premier, PsycINFO, Science Direct, Google Scholar

Page 37: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 38: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 39: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 40: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Synonyms or related terms

•  ….

•  ….

•  ….

•  ….

Synonyms or related terms

•  ….

•  ….

•  ….

•  ….

Synonyms or related terms

•  ….

•  ….

•  ….

•  ….

Synonyms or related terms

•  ….

•  ….

•  ….

•  ….

Keyword 1 Keyword 2 Keyword 3 Keyword 4

Page 41: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

• Organizational behavior

• Organizational character

• Corporate identity

• Core beliefs

• Shared values

• …

Corporate culture

• Fusion

• Combination

• Merger

• Take over

• Acquisition

• Unification

• …

Merger -

• Return on investment

• Return on assets • Innovation power • Productivity • Market share • Shareholder value

Profitability

Page 42: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 43: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 44: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 45: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 46: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 47: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

B I A S

Page 48: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 49: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 50: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 51: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 52: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 53: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 54: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 55: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 56: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 57: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 58: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 59: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 60: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

  Positive

  Clear (completely new) approach,

  Library search useful (much more evidence than expected)

  Strong arguments in decision making process

  Difficulties

  Access to relevant databases

  Lack of aggregated evidence

  Time consuming method

  Translating conclusions to the own context

Page 61: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

CAT as a tool for junior/middle managers

  searching instead of learning answers

 managers can search for themselves (independency)

  powerful arguments (evidence speaks for itself)

Page 62: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 63: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 64: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 65: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 66: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 67: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Experiences in Master of Business Studies

Page 68: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Experiences in Master of Business Studies

Page 69: Teaching Evidence-Based Management

Experiences in Master of Business Studies

Page 70: Teaching Evidence-Based Management
Page 71: Teaching Evidence-Based Management