Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
APPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTAIBILY
DECISION MAKING
DESIGNERS’ AND DESIGN’S ETHIC
Blanca Calvo
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
APPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTAIBILY
DECISION MAKING
ACCOUNTABILITY
ETHICS
SPATIAL EQUITY
OPPORTUNITY ACCESSPEOPLE SERVED
DESIGNER ROLE
DESIGN PROCESS
DECISION MAKING
COMMUNITIES NEEDSCONTROL EFFICIENCY
EQUALITY
JUSTICESPATIAL EQUITY
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DPEFF
S E EQ J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DMDM
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
EQUITY
EQUITY from Latin aequitās, from aequus (equal)• The quality of being fair or impartial• Something that is fair and just
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
EQUITY vs.EQUALITY
EQUITY from Latin aequitās, from aequus (equal)• The quality of being fair or impartial• Something that is fair and just
EQUALITY from Latin aequalitas, from aequalis (equal)• The state of being equal, especially in status, rights,
or opportunities.
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
Equality aims to ensure that everyone gets the same things in order to enjoy full, healthy lives.
Equity involves trying to understand and give people what they need to enjoy full, healthy lives.
Like equity, equality aims to promote fairness and justice, but it can only work if everyone starts from the same place and needs the same things.
EQUITY vs.EQUALITY
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
Cicero defined aequitas as "tripartite":
• The first, he said, pertained to the gods above (ad superos deos) and is equivalent to pietas, religious obligation;
• The second, to the Manes, the underworld spirits or spirits of the dead, and was sanctitas, that which is sacred;
•And the third pertaining to human beings (homines) was iustitia, “justice”
EQUITY FROM LATIN AEQUITAS
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
EQUITY from Latin aequitās• The quality of being fair or impartial• Something that is fair and just
JUSTICE from Latin justitia, from justus (just)1. The quality of being just; fairness:2. a. The principle of moral rightness; decency
b. Conformity to moral rightness in action or attitude; righteousness
3. a. The attainment of what is just, especially what is fair, moral, right, merited, or in accordance with lawb. The upholding of what is just, especial, fair treatment and due reward in accordance with honor standards, or law
4. Conformity to truth, fact, or sound reason:
EQUITY vs. JUSTICE
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
SAPATIAL EQUITY
In the context of urban public facility planning, spatial equity means equal spatial separation from or spatial proximity to public facilities among residents.
Geographical and political research on urban service delivery— who benefits and why —within the context of territorial justice.
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
EQUA
LITY
EQU
ITY
JUST
ICE
???
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
EQUALITY EQUITY JUSTICE
ETHICS?
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
ETHICS vs. ETHICETHIC from Greek ēthikós, from ethos (habit, custum)
Set of moral values and principles which, taken collectively, guide and influence the life of a group or, less commonly, of an individual.
ETHICS from Greek ēthikós, from ethos (habit, custum)
Code of behaviour considered appropiate to a particular group, especially a group defined by its ocupation and proffession.
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
CANON I General Obligations
CANON II Obligations to the Public
CANON III Obligations to the Client
CANON IV Obligations to the Profession
CANON V Obligations to Colleagues
CANON VI Obligations to the Environment
http://www.aia.org/
ARCHITECT ETHICS
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
http://www.aia.org/
The Pelican Bay Security Housing Unit Debate
“Members should uphold human rights in all their professional endeavours.” (AIA)
“I believe that too many people are being incarcerated and that our society must immediately develop and implement alternatives to incarceration. I believe in creating a society with real security and social justice for all, and I will not contribute my design to the perpetuation of wrongful institutions that abuse others. In recognition of the deep injustice of the present prison system, I pledge not to do any work that furthers the construction of prisons or jails.”
Architects / Designers / Planners for Social Responsability
ARCHITECT’S ETHIC
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
ARCHITECT’S ETHIC
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
SHOULD ARCHITECTS FOLLOW A CODE OF ETHICS?ARCHITECT’S ETHIC
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
ARCHITECTURE ETHIC’S
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
C
CN
EFF
S E
EQ J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
DM
DR PS
E
AC
CN
EQ
S E
J OA
DP
E
DP
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
CN DMDR PS
CNCN
CN CN
CN
CN
CNCNCN
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
DESIGNING FOR / BY / WITH PEOPLE:•ENSURING DESIGN ADDRESSES PEOPLE’S NEEDS•EMPOWERMENT
SLUM / SHACK DWELLERS INTERNATIONAL (SDI)
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
SDI METHODOLOGY
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
SDI LEADERSHIP AND COMMUNITY STRUCTURING AND STRENGTHENING
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
SDI PROFILING AND ENUMERATING
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
SDI PROFILING AND ENUMERATING
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
SDI CAPACITATION (WORKSHOPS &EXCHANGES)
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
SDI DESIGNER´S ROLE
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
DESIGN AS A PROCESS, NOT JUST AN OUTPUT
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
UTILITAS, VENUSTAS, FIRMITAS - VITRUVIUS
C
CN
DP
EFF
S E
EQ
J
PS
OA
E
DR
A
DM
CONTROL
COMMUNITIES NEEDS
EFFICIENCY
DESIGN PROCESS
SPATIAL EQUITY
EQUALITY
JUSTICE
PEOPLE SERVED
OPPORTUNITY ACCESS
ETHICS
DESIGNER ROLE
ACCOUNTABILITY
DECISION MAKING
