160
Managing the whole child in the classroom - a rationale and practical guidance (with additional data on provision at 16+ & 18+) Professor Amanda Kirby Dyscovery Centre University of Wales, Newport

P A T O S S 2008 Newport

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Managing the whole child in the classroom

- a rationale and practical guidance(with additional data on provision at 16+ & 18+)

Professor Amanda KirbyDyscovery Centre

University of Wales, Newport

Page 2: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Key points aiming to be covered.

1. Developmental disorders are not discrete but part of a spectrum 2. Segmented training on specific learning difficulties can lead to

confusion and delays in referral as parents traverse a system3. Need for a common language and pathway4. Whole school training especially in secondary schools about

approaches not diagnoses5. Need to train those working with children with

“ behaviour” issues to check out what else MAY be going on.6. At risk kids should be automatically screened for SPLDs’7. Post 16 education needs to have a more social or medical

model// diagnosis or support?

Page 3: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

How do we see children today?

Page 4: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

"The children now love luxury;

they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders and love chatter in place of exercise. Children are now tyrants… They contradict their parents, chatter before company, and tyrannize their teachers”.

"The trouble with youngsters today..."

Page 5: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Socrates 470-399 BC

"The trouble with youngsters today..."

Page 6: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Young people may present in different ways

Page 7: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

What do YOU see?

• Too loud• Answering out of turn• Inappropriate comments• Seemingly not listening • Not following instructions• Annoying others• Fidgety• Fiddling with mobile phone• Talking to mates• Doodling• Attacking others verbally or physically• Anti- social behaviour- not recognising the rules

Page 8: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

ADHD

Dyslexia

Asperger's Syndrome

DCD

ODD

Conduct disorderSpecific language impairment

Pragmatic language impairment

Dyspraxia

Page 9: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Autism friendly schools

Dyslexia friendly schools

Lots of initiatives………………

Page 10: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Fixed thinking

Page 11: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Behaviour SEN

SERVICES

Page 12: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Children

Page 14: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

How often do we see a “pure” child with ONLY

one difficulty ?

The rule…. ……Or the exception

Page 15: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Start from any point and you will end up seeing overlap

Page 16: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Language + behaviour

• Approximately 75% of children with identified emotional and behavioural difficulties have significant language deficits.

• The prevalence of language deficits in children who exhibit anti-social behaviours is 10 times higher than in the general population.

Page 17: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Facts Summary by the Centre for Integrated Healthcare

Research, 2006

EBD children with unsuspected receptive disorders were rated the most delinquent, the most depressed (by parents) and aggressive (by teachers) and had more severe challenging behaviour.

Children with expressive language disorders were rated as more socially withdrawn and anxious.

Page 18: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

And more…….

• 10% Young offenders significant SLCI (Hamilton, 1999, Bryan 2004)

• Early language difficulties are a predictor of later difficulties- e.g. mental health problems ( Clegg,1999)

• 50% of children with speech and language difficulties have associated emotional and behavioural difficulties ( Beitchman et al, 1990)

Page 19: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

ADHD and ASD

21% of children with severe ADHD met full criteria for Asperger’s syndrome and 36% showed ‘autistic traits’ (Fitzgerald and Corvin, 2001)

Page 20: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Dyslexia AND

• Speech and language difficulties is linked to poorer literacy skills (Snowling)

• Early years with SLI… 60% had associated DCD ( Missiuna and Gaines , 2007)

Page 21: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

SLI and DCD

• Early years with SLI… 60% had associated DCD ( Missiuna and Gaines , 2007)

• SLI and DCD -Hill et al

Page 22: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

14%

12%

4%

2%

4%

6%

6%

10%6%

2%

14%

14%6%

DCD only

DCD+Dyslexia+ADHD+ASD

DCD+Dyslexia+ASD

DCD+ADHD+ASD

DCD+Dyslexia

DCD+ADHD

DCD+ASD

DCD+Dyslexia+ADHD+ASD+speech/language

DCD+Dyslexia+ASD+speech/language

DCD+ADHD+ASD+Speech/language

DCD+speech/language

DCD+Dyslexia+speech/language

DCD+ASD+speech/language

Take 50 children with Dyspraxia (DCD)

Page 23: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

ADHD AND

Oppositional Defiant

Disorder40%

Tics11%

Conduct Disorder14%

ADHD alone31% Anxiety

Disorder 34%

MTA Cooperative Group. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1999; 56:1088–1096

Mood disorders

Page 24: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

ADHD + DCD Impact of combination

Page 25: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

2 sets of data both from clinical settings

• Children with DCD- meeting criteria (<5% on M-ABC Battery, and fulfil criteria for DSM1V)

• Children with ADHD- meeting criteria for ADHD on DSM1V(mostly combined subtype).

To consider social and emotional impact:All parents completed • Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ)• Autism Spectrum Screening Questionnaire

(ASSQ)

Page 26: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

60%

40%

DCD

DCD-ADHD

DCD sample

ADHD sample

N=30

40% combined

N=58

34% combined

%

ADHD

Combined

Page 27: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

*

Significant difference with DCD alone- compared to all other groups

on total difficulties, conduct, and hyperactivity ( p<0.01)

* * * *

Page 29: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

0102030405060708090

100

HMP Cardiff%of participantswith > than the

cut off score

PARC YOT% ofparticipants

with > than thecut off score

ITB College%of participantswith > than the

cut off score

Reading and Writing

Social and Communication

Attention andConcentration

Co-ordination

Page 31: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

We sometimes see behaviour

and don’t look what’s beneath it

FrustratedAngry

WithdrawnFidgety

Page 32: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

“Kieran”

School report (aged nearly 8 yrs)

“Below average in English, Maths & Science. Not achieving full potential, difficulty staying on task, rarely finishes work, frequently disturbs others, no general organisational skills, does not co-operate with peers, limited attention span, impulsive behaviour both within the class and playground. Behaviour of concern since nursery years. On School Action Plus”

Page 33: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

“Kieran”

• Educational psychology assessment (aged 8 ½ years)• School concerns identified as before. In addition

problems identified: with• Social interaction- speaks inappropriately to teachers

and involved in disagreements with peers in the yard, • Co-ordination- poor ball skills, untidy handwriting,

difficulty holding knife and fork, • Literacy and numeracy -delayed basic attainments but

“school have not noticed any dyslexic tendency” • Advice given re-strategies to use in the school

Page 35: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Keiran

3y 7m, HV18m, P

4y, P 4y, SLT

4y, EP

4y, OT4y, OT

4y, SEN

5y, SLT

5y, OT

6y, GP

6y, EP

6y, EP

7y, P

7y, Physio

7y, SLT

7y, CP

7y, OT 7y SLT

8y, SLT

8y, SLT

8y, SLT8y, EP 8y, OT

8y, OT9y, SLT (Feeding)

9y, Physio9y, EP

10y, OT

10y, OT

10y, EP

8y, SEN Tribunal

Education

HEALTH

Page 36: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

There is a need for a common pathway

Page 37: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Children do not live in a vacuum

Ecological approaches ( Bronfenbrenner)

"life is process, not substance" Weiss 1993

CHILD

Page 38: P A T O S S 2008  Newport
Page 39: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

SPOT THE DIFFERENCE

Page 40: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Context is keyPlaying football in the UK

Reading in the jungle

Page 41: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

A child is not an islandand is affected by……

• Their environment

• The tasks they are being asked to do

• Their experiences before coming into school including their social setting

Page 42: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Is our system unfair?

• Reward those diagnosed with support

• What if the child is unaware, or others

Page 44: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

WE ARE ALL SHADES OF GREY

Page 45: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Where are YOU on the curve? (trait)

• Make some spelling errors, need to re-read words on the page, take longer than others to retain information

• Slower learning a new skill, difficulty with right and left, a bit clumsy, took longer than others to learn to drive

• Find it hard to sit still, prefer to flit from one thing to another, see the big picture but not so good at the detail

• Prefer detail, not so good at the big picture, uncomfortable in large social groups, don’t always get the jokes, take things literally

Page 46: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

A common clinical pathwayin line with Special Educational Needs Code of Practice (DfES, 2001b),

• A graduated response • An inclusive response for childrenand professionals and parents• An evidence base response

Page 47: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Lets at least start with

• at risk groups

• They may be identified for a number of reasons… – behaviour, language, motor difficulties

• They represent a future risk group

Page 49: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

The want:partnership working in children’s

services is important

Audit Commission, 1999; DfE, 1994; DfES/DoH, 2002; Department of Health, 1997; Department for Health, Department for Education, 2004a; HAS, 1995; House of Commons Health Select Committee, 1997; WAG, 2002; WAG, 2004

Page 50: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Everyone's business

• Children’s mental health now seen as the business of all the people, agencies and services in contact with children and young people (EWG, 2003; Every Child Matters, 2003;

NAW, 2001; NSF, WAG 2004)

Page 51: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Need for an interdisciplinary approaches for the “complex” child

A right

• Who should do it?

• Can we screen all or should it be opportunistic?

Page 52: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Need to start to support in school first

Page 53: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Starting at Tier 1

• The Audit Commission (1999) identified three roles for Tier 1 professionals: – Early identification of mental health problems;– Offering treatment for less severe problems;– Pursuing health promotion and problem

prevention.

– BUT AGAIN NEED TO SEE NOT ONLY MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES

Page 54: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Need a common language

• Meaning the same thing- – developmental disorders, specific learning

difficulties, ASD, semantic pragmatic disorder, Autism, EBD, BES

• EVERY CHILD MATTERS

Page 55: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

General good practice approaches

Group approaches

Specific tailored approaches

Page 56: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Support first

• Not labelling

x

Page 57: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Stages

• Awareness and training

• Attitude

• Benchmarking of present understanding

• Monitoring and evaluation processes implemented

• Individual needs assessed

Page 58: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

• Strategies to meet all children's needs

• Identifying when they are not working

• Screening for complex difficulties- not as an add on but as an essential ( sticky kids)

• Again.. There is the evidence PRU, LAC, SLI, DCD, ADHD……………………….

Page 59: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

The present situation

• May only get help when your bucket is in one colour

• We don’t check for the other colours routinely• When bucket is brown… don’t check on how it

became that colour• Refer when the bucket is full/half full without

trying to empty it first• Different levels in different places get

referrals/diagnosis

Page 60: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

DCD

Dyslexia

ADHD

Behaviour and social difficulties

DAMP

Page 61: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

80% full75% full

Get help… called Dyslexia, ADHD etc

Don’t get help…

Page 62: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Get help… called Dyslexia,Asperger's Syndrome?

Don’t get help called ADHD or SLI

Same level of difficulty- different diagnosis

Page 63: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

2 difficulties filling the bucket

Behaviour Language

BUT ONLY TRYING TO SWITCH OFF 1 TAP

Page 64: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Need to consider an individual map

Page 65: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Stages of support

1. Whole school

2. Whole class

3. Enrichment

4. Additional guidance by SENCO

5. Referral

Page 66: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

If this approach is not working

Then check out symptoms and signs

BUT

be aware of the overlap

Page 67: P A T O S S 2008  Newport
Page 68: P A T O S S 2008  Newport
Page 69: P A T O S S 2008  Newport
Page 70: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Referral only

• When all previous stages completed

• Unless there are red flags seen

Page 71: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Provide inclusive approaches

• Make sure the environment is not Dyslexia friendly or autistic friendly….. – BUT CHILD FRIENDLY

Page 72: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Changes in views in emerging adulthood

Page 73: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Growing up - impact on the family

• Physically bigger• Taking up more family time than other siblings• Parents losing time from work because of

difficulties• Coping with puberty and experiences at a

different stage to others• Gaps in provision• Problem coping with transition from primary to

secondary school

Page 74: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Impact on family

• Mothers of children with ASD showed 50% higher rates of depression– associated with low levels of family support

and with bringing up a child with higher levels of challenging behaviour ( Bromley et al, 2004)

• A strong association between parental emotional distress and unmet need was found. – Parents reported -more autism-specific

intervention and support ( Hare et al, 2004)

Page 75: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Leaving school

• No formal structures unless continue with college/university

• Can get lost- no formal systems• Fewer formalised social opportunities• Less visible support from parents• Less forgiving support networks• No negotiator/translator to help mediate• Increased risk.. forensic pathway, sexually

Page 76: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Greater interaction without potential support

Page 77: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Additional new skills required

Page 78: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Misinterpretation of new information

Page 79: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Time pressures, new and varying work rules

Social interactionSocial isolationNew people to interfacetravel and living

ILS

increased risk of mental health disorders

CUMULATIVE EFFECT

Page 80: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Young person

Agencye.g. employer/FE/HE

Parent

OUT OF THE LOOP

Page 81: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Situation mismatch

e.g. Interviewing for a job or being in a tutorial at college

COMMUNICATION

SOCIAL RELATIONSHIPS

INTERESTS

Page 82: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

What is emerging adolescence?

Arnett and Taber (1994) states that

“Adolescence spans most of the second decade of life and is a period of economic dependency and knowledge acquisition in which information is accumulated and problem - solving techniques are learned.

Adulthood is the stage in which knowledge is applied.”

Page 84: P A T O S S 2008  Newport
Page 85: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

“Socially( at school) I tended to be isolated, but this was partly me trying to isolate myself from those who were not understanding. I ate my lunch inside classrooms, spent breaks in the library etc. anything I could to keep away from people. Throughout my entire secondary school experience I had about four friends, and they were all outcasts of one form or another, thus my group of friends were quite understanding and ignored my 'quirkiness'. I think finding people who can empathise is very important, and is possibly the only reason I survived school at all. At university I could start all over again, no one was knew who I was and therefore their opinion was not clouded by a view of me when I was at my most clumsy.”

Student in HE

Page 86: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

To become an adult

Need for separation and individuation (Meeus et al,2005) has been seen as essential developmental stages to go through in order to reach adulthood

Page 87: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

• Separation from parents may be later than peers

• Individuation may be later as less peer-peer interaction

Delay in this process

Page 88: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

• Evidence in children with DCD :– Lower general self concept-Skinner and Piek,

2001 – Stigmatisation ( Segal et al, 2002)– Internalisation (Sigurdsson et al, 2002)

– Therefore less social practice

Lower peer-peer interaction

Page 89: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

“I was later than most of my peers in starting to experiment, starting just a few weeks before my 18th birthday. I didn't really have a lot of people to go out with, and I didn't usually enjoy it when I did because it simply seemed to be a less controlled extension of the social dynamics of school... i.e. I was outcast to varying degrees. Now, at university, I definitely don't drink more than some, but I'd say I was about average for my peer group at the moment”

• Third year student

Page 90: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

“I certainly remember when I was at school; some of my friends did go out to pubs/clubs a couple of years before being 18. I never did though. I only went out with them, the night of the day the A-Levels results came out. I also didn't go out again, despite being at uni, until that Christmas. At university, I didn't go out until the end of the second semester in 1st year. So in school and university I have been going out later than my peers.”

• 2nd year student

Page 91: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Factors at play

• Less social experiences.. leads to more social isolation

• Greater need for parental support• A model that has concentrated on deficits e.g.

practising handwriting etc• NOT a strengths model- allowing the child to see

what they CAN do.• Little focus on gaining the core set of skills

( especially if academically able)… e.g. organisation/independent living skills

Page 92: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Lerner at al (2001) describe a

3 stage process in progressing towards adulthood

1. Trying out a range of skills and having a wide range of goals to start with

2. Narrowing down strengths

3. Learning to optimise these areas

Page 93: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Adults with DCD may have poorer ability in appraising a situation and to goal set accurately and create an appropriate hierarchy of importance

Page 94: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

SOC model(Baltes, 1999)

• Successful adults select what they CAN do

• Optimise their skills

• Compensate for their difficulties

Page 95: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

“ I have difficult time being organised on every level, even in thought. My wife thinks that if I plan out every single level of my actions before I do them whether I am driving or walking, that this will compensate for my problems. I genuinely try but often have trouble accomplishing my goal .Establishing a habit of organising everything I do is a daunting task. I have difficulties even remembering to plan everything”

(E-mail correspondence from a male, 32 years with DCD)

Page 96: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Selection

• the development by directing and focusing resources i.e. goal setting and to produce a goal hierarchy.

• Guidance on making relevant, appropriate and achievable goal choices may be important for longer term functioning.

Page 97: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Optimisation

-acquiring, refining, and applying goal relevant means or resources in the selected goals.

• Creating goal hierarchies is important. • Children with DCD may remain at a stage of over

selection and poor optimization resulting in following too many and the wrong goals.

• This may have been associated with using a deficit model pursued by professionals in the past concentrating for too long on the skills they found the hardest.

Page 98: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Compensation

Additional skills need to be acquired to maintain function and reset more appropriate goals- this is termed “ loss based selection”

Page 99: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

What factors might influence the “successful” outcomes for

adults with DCD?

• The severity of motor skill difficulties as a child

• Level of co-occurrence( e.g. ADHD/ASD)• Cognitive ability• Self esteem/self worth• Ability to make the right choices- find

strengths?• OR are there other particular resilience

factors ?

Page 100: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Evidence that:

The longer an individual is on a particular developmental pathway the less likely he or she will deviate from this pathway

(Bowlby, 1973,Cicchetti, 1993, Sroufe, 1997)

Page 102: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

“the capacity to "bounce back" from adversities.”

Masten (2004)

Resilience is

Page 103: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

• Temperament• higher IQ

• good social skills• awareness of strengths and limitations• empathy for others• an internal locus of control,• a valued social role in the household • good parent-child relationship• a sense of humour

• attractiveness to others• a belief that one’s efforts can make a difference. • supportive extended family

• successful school experiences• a close relationship with an unrelated mentor

• participation in extra curricular activities.

Influencers for resilience

Page 104: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Interaction

Parental support

Peer interaction

ASD/DCD etc.

Typically developingIndividual

0 years 10 years 18 years 20 years

Delay in progression towards adulthood

Page 105: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Successful progression

Dependent on a range of factors– Support structures around you– Adaptability– Resilience– Self esteem

Page 106: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Changing relationships with service providers

• Adolescent becoming the client

• Parents wanting information

• Issues of disclosure

• Still remaining a child

• Isolation

• Mismarriage of skills

Page 107: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Changing needs

• Focus on adaptation and avoidance

• Narrowing of choices

• Increasing need to be independent and socially able

Page 108: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

After school choices

Page 109: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Sam - 16 ½ years (2007)

Diagnosed with AS with co-ordination difficulties at the age of 6 ½ years. (WISC V=110, P=57)

At 6 ½ years he had seen 5 different professionals

Seen at the centre at 8 years and 10 years- no local provision

Has had a statement of educational since 7 years of age

Now 16 ½ - about to sit GCSEs’ this summer- predicted to do very well… but failed all at mocks…

parent told “ it’s how you interpret our information”

Page 110: P A T O S S 2008  Newport
Page 111: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Sam

• Can’t walk to the shops alone

• Can’t make a snack for himself

• Has no friends

• Has a younger sister who is worried about him as when he gets angry he bites himself .In play he pushes her hard and now can hurt her

Page 112: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Mum went to GP…

• Referred to CAMHS.. told “don’t expect to hear for a while, we will contact you”

• Referred to disability service- “… he may not fit our criteria”

• Visited college… good advice- vocational taster course… but with only learning disabled students – “ he may be too bright for this course”

Page 113: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

What help has he had?

• Full time LSA for 10 years!!!- practicing handwriting still… written in IEP for past 2 years

• No social skills intervention in place

• No NAS befriender scheme in the area

• No transition plan for the next stage even though the LEA has one on their website!

• Sitting on his own for the summer….

Page 114: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

What does he need?

• A real transition plan for the next stage of his life

• Practical help now with examinations- he has a laptop (weighs 2kgs and has a short battery life) but cannot spell and has a typing speed below acceptable levels to be used

• Training in independent living and social and communication skills

IEPs’ and an ILPs’- looking forward 5 years

Page 115: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Going to university

Page 116: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Present….

• May have already have a diagnosis

• May have a diagnosis but not disclose to others

• Others increasingly concerned

• He/she may not be concerned

Page 117: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

University offers

New opportunitiesFocussing on interestsHall of residence to stay inStudent support/DSA/mentor programmes

Page 118: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Diagnosis at 15 years

New assessment and reportIndividual pays for it

Apply for DSA if full time… not available for short courses

Access Centre…. Another town

Meet student support services…delay in provision for a term after starting…

Processes complex

Page 119: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

John 21 years

• ASD diagnosed at 11 years, speech unclear and co-ordination difficulties

• He has 3 A levels- in SEN unit- had lunch every day in the unit until he left..

• Advised to join the Christian Union to make friends!

• Left university 2nd term- could not cope with group work/getting to university/planning assignments

• Currently on a psychiatric ward being treated for anxiety/depression

Page 120: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

John

• No support locally available

• Little or no independent living skills

• Does not want to grow up!

• Mum and dad getting older- needing time off work to go to appointments with him or being run at work 10 times a day by Chris

• Anxious using public transport

Page 121: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

FE and HE issues

• Managing daily living without the support of family members and lack of contact with parents with student support ( as an adult!)

• Staying on schedule• Keeping living space clean• Personal hygiene• Taking care of health needs• Finances• Navigating an unfamiliar campus• Trapped in bedroom• Noisy and confusing places (e.g. the dining hall)

Page 122: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Specific course issues

• Interpreting academic expectations and requirements

• Balancing course demands

• Working in groups

• Sitting in noisy and crowded lecture theatres- knowing when work applies to him… “ everyone” may not mean Bob!

Page 123: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Preparation for success

• Attend summer school

• Work buddy

• Befriender scheme starting before the start of term/student mentor- show around campus

• Study skills and student support services

• Lecturers aware of issues

• Appropriate examination arrangements

Page 124: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

To diagnose or not??

Page 125: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

To receive help in university:

Disability Student Allowance

“In addition to the use of standardised measures of underlying ability, cognitive processing, and attainments in literacy (and numeracy), supplementary methods of information-gathering that inform the diagnostic process may be employed. These might include information concerning conditions such as Dyspraxia/DCD and disorders of attention, drawn from qualitative evaluations of the student’s functioning, from assessments carried out by other appropriate professionals (e.g. occupational therapists) and from recognised checklists.”

p.10

Page 126: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

In order to receive DSA

1. Recognise you have a difficulty

2. Disclose to others

3. Have a “test” in the past 2 years

4. Show you have a motor deficit

Page 127: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Issues

1. Awareness

2. Want to have a label and tell others

3. No where to go to be tested- have clear cut symptoms

4. Have a standardised test

5. Meet diagnostic criteria

6. Have support appropriate to you not the label

Page 128: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Issues

1. Awareness-Insight2. Want to have a label and tell others- peer

views/fear of fixed perceptions3. No where to go to be tested- have clear cut

symptoms- few professionals4. Have a standardised test-no ecologically valid

test5. Meet diagnostic criteria- DSMIV written for

children6. Have support appropriate to you not the label-

likely to have co-ocurring disorders

Page 129: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Diagnosis/labellingSocial v medical model• Medical model

– you have a problem/different from the norm– Someone diagnoses you– You need to be changed

• Social model– Society has to provide for all shapes and sizes– Society’s responsibility– the position of disabled people and the discrimination against

them is socially created. e.g. a written assignment for an electrician’s course.

– Need for universal design– In university- different assessment processes– Lectures accessible in different formats

Page 130: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Assessment needs to include

• Cognitive functioning + associated comorbidities (e.g.ADHD,expressive/receptive language, motor difficulties)

• Level of independent functioning- ? Using an ICF framework

• Availability of help

• Corroboration from additional sources e.g. parent/teacher/employer/friend

Green, J., Gilchrist, A., Burton, D., et al (2000) Social and psychiatric functioning in adolescents with Asperger syndrome compared with conduct disorder. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders, 30, 279–293

Page 131: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

General issues

Page 132: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Falling through the gaps

Page 133: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Key challenges

• Terminology

• Training ( Shirley Foundation report)

• Transition planning starting too late, not linked to independent skills

• Tracking

Page 134: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

TerminologyGPs and health professionals understanding

about Asperger’s Syndrome

Survey of 100 GPs 18 % did not know what Asperger’s Syndrome was- gave no definition

Kirby,2003

UK survey of 1500 people in mainstream population66% had heard of AS but only 35% knew what the symptoms

were compared to Dyslexia (96.3% and 90%) (2007)

Page 135: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Out of 72% of GPs’ who said they knew what AS was

some descriptions given:

• Sudden jerky movements and use of abusive words• Hyperactive learning difficulties• Attention and co-ordination difficulties• Attention in an older age group• More severe form of ADD• Disorders of mucociliary movements !• Genetic disorder- attention problems• ADHD, Dyslexia and social• Part of Dyspraxia• Spectrum of disease, hyperactive and learning difficulty

Page 136: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Transition planning

• Know the dates and plan ahead• Consider the comorbid issues such as ILS• Provide relevant information on ASD in

adulthood• Make contact with local support groups• Educational accommodations planned in

advance• Life skills coaching started early• Vocational services

Page 137: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Local initiatives

• BOLD and Fingerprint project- key worker scheme, highlight functional difficulties and provide tailored training packages and enable move from training into supported employment

Page 138: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Health Condition Health Condition ((disorder/diseasedisorder/disease))

Interaction of ConceptsInteraction of ConceptsICF 2001ICF 2001

Environmental Environmental FactorsFactors

Personal Personal FactorsFactors

Body Body function&structurefunction&structure

(Impairment(Impairment))

ActivitiesActivities(Limitation)(Limitation)

ParticipationParticipation(Restriction)(Restriction)

Page 139: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Consider what adjustments have already been useful

• Photocopied notes• Additional time for assignments• Use of Microsoft Outlook or Access to lectures

on Blackboard• Text to speech software – Dragon Dictate ( take

time to learn it)• Speech to text- listen to what you have read-

e.g. Claroread• Use of a phone with a diary/timer/to do

list/recorder

Page 140: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Need to talk to student support services/employers

• Additional time for tasks

• Information in a written format

• Showing how to do “ simple” tasks such as photocopying

• Setting up systems on the computer to file

• Posture and seating

Page 141: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Considering choices for moving to college /uni/away

Risk analysis when choosing place and course

• Number of changes- independent living skills• Orientation around a new place• Making friends• Managing money• Managing transport• Level of support required at present

Page 142: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Preparation for new college/employment /university

• Find out the lay of the land- campus or in town• Practice the journey• Walk around the campus- orientate buildings• Check out early disability provision- amount of

student support, type, knowledge of students with Dyspraxia

• Social times – how will they meet others, drinking experience, clubbing..

Page 143: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Advice to providers or employers

• Additional time for tasks• Information in a written format• Showing how to do “ simple” tasks such as

photocopying• Setting up systems on the computer to file• Posture and seating• What training has been given to staff?• Where to go for help/advice

Page 144: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Consider room in hall or flat

• Mix of students ….

• Large laundry basket

• Coloured trays to “ throw “ notes

• Easy kit to clean bathroom/kitchen

Page 145: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

• Notice board- pins to pin up all papers/bills/time table etc

• PDA or Phone to use for appointments

• Cook’s survival kit of a couple of recipes practiced- one pot meals e.g.mince +

Page 146: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Dress and ILS codes

• Shaving/washing/changing rules

• Social codes- going for a drink/coffee

• Local pubs- drinking experiences- ordering, asking, balancing drinks

Page 147: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Consider also extracurricular activities

• What clubs are there that could be joined?

• Is there a student buddy /mentor system

• What about housing/accommodation?

Risk analyse….the ability to work AND

cook, shop, budget etc associated… v living at home

Page 148: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Preparing for the workplace

• Application - printing or writing cover letter• Interview - have some questions prepared,

assess the job and think where problems may occur

• Issues around disclosure to consider• Ask for time to learn new processes• Think of type of job to choose- self

employed, part time, outside, structured office

Page 149: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Perseverance is not a long race; it is many short races one after another.

Walter Elliott

Page 150: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Training initiatives

• For trainers: OCN level 2 and 3 train the trainers programme e.g. social service workers/colleges

• PACTS project- training for FE/colleges and employers- after needs analysis undertaken by direct/CD training materials and website www.pactsproject.com

Page 151: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Setting training standards

• For employers

• For colleges and universities

• Dyslexia friendly/AS friendly….. Friendly

Page 152: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Training events across the UK

and train the trainers packs for over 800 employers and vol. sector organisations

Targeted at those working with post 14

e.g. The FA , Police, Sports centres,

Page 153: P A T O S S 2008  Newport
Page 154: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Who is the keyworker?

Page 155: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Barriers to effective inter-agency working

Professional ‘silos’

Separate systems History

Conflicting policies, procedures, priorities and funding streams

Lack of understanding about

roles and responsibilities

Lack of co-ordination

Different organisational

cultures

Communication difficulties

Page 156: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Conclusions

• Supporting the child , adolescent and family needs a key worker to plan well ahead for times of transition- who this is may change over time

• Predicting the difficulties rather than waiting for them to occur

• Need to develop appropriate adolescent services- education/OT/social services/psychiatry

• Training and information giving for parents once adults left the formal systems

Page 157: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

The issues are ELEPHANTINE!

` Beyond Ghor there was a city.  All its inhabitants were blind.  A king with his entourage arrived near by; he brought his army and camped in the desert.  He had a mighty elephant, which he used in attack and to increase the people's awe.

 The populace became anxious to see the elephant, and some sightless from among this blind community ran like fools to find it.  As they did not even know the form or shape of the elephant they groped sightlessly, gathering information by touching some part of it.  Each thought that he knew something, because he could feel a part.

Page 158: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

When they returned to their fellow citizens eager groups clustered around them.  Each of these was anxious, misguidedly, to learn the truth from those who were themselves astray. They asked about the form, the shape of the elephant; and listened to all that they were told. The man whose hand had reached an ear was asked about the elephant's nature.  He said: "It is a large, rough thing, wide and broad, like a rug." And the one who had felt the trunk said: "I have the real facts about it.  It is like a straight and hollow pipe, awful and destructive." The one who had felt its feet and legs said: "It is mighty and firm, like a pillar."

Page 159: P A T O S S 2008  Newport

Key points

1. Developmental disorders are not discrete but part of a spectrum

2. Segmented training on specific learning difficulties can lead to confusion and delays in referral as parents traverse a system

3. Need for a common language and pathway4. Whole school training especially in secondary schools

about approaches not diagnoses..5. Need to train those working with children with “ behaviour” issues to check out what else MAY be going

on.6. At risk kids should be automatically screened for SPLDs’