37
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance for Paul Simon Public Policy Institute Colleen Coyle Mathis April 30, 2013

A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Paul Simon Public Policy Institute Colleen Coyle Mathis April 30, 2013

Citation preview

Page 1: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

forPaul Simon Public Policy Institute

Colleen Coyle MathisApril 30, 2013

Page 2: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

AIRC Overview

• Creation• Process• Results• Lessons Learned

2

Page 3: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

“In a spasm of good sense…”

• Arizona’s redistricting process is governed by the state Constitution, as amended by voters in 2000 with the passage of Proposition 106.

• It stipulates that the Arizona Independent Redistricting Commission redraw Arizona’s congressional and legislative districts to reflect the results of the most recent census.

• Passed with 56% of the vote

3

Page 4: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Origins of Proposition 106

4

• A serendipitous combination of champions:– Two non partisan organizations: League of Women Voters and

Common Cause– A native Arizonan with money in the bank who wanted to

give back• Goal: A healthy exchange of ideas and better

governance• Poll conducted to determine what people really want.

“Let the People Draw the Lines”• Over 200,000 signatures collected to get Prop 106 on

the ballot

Page 5: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Proposition 106

“Relating to ending the practice of gerrymandering and improving voter and candidate participation in elections by creating an independent commission of balanced appointments to oversee the mapping of fair and competitive districts.”

5

Page 6: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Some Arizona Context• ~ 6.4 million people (3.5 million in Maricopa County)• 2 x the land area of Illinois• 21 Native American reservations (rural and urban)• Growing Hispanic/Latino population ~ 30%• From 2000 to 2010, Arizona added almost 1 million new registered

voters. Of that, 19% went to Republicans, 18% to Democrats, and nearly 63% chose to be Independents.

– Republicans: 35.4 %– Democrats: 30.4 % – Independent/Other: 34.2%

6

Page 7: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

What are the requirements of the State Constitution via Prop 106?New district boundaries must:A: Comply with the U.S Constitution and the Voting

Rights ActB: Equal Population

Criteria A and B are federally mandated.

To the extent practicable the districts must be:C: Compact and ContiguousD: Respect communities of interestE: Use visible geographic features, city, town and county

boundaries, and undivided Census TractsF: Favor competitive districts where no significant

detriment to other goals 7

Page 8: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

A: Voting Rights Act– Arizona is one of 9 states covered as a whole meaning

that its congressional and legislative districts must receive preclearance or approval from the Department of Justice or a federal court under Section 5. To get preclearance, Arizona must demonstrate that the new districts do not discriminate against minority voters in purpose or effect, which means there can be no intentional or accidental discrimination.

– Under Section 5, Arizona's redistricting plans cannot be retrogressive. The plans cannot weaken or reduce minority voters' rights.

– The presence of discrimination can be determined by analyzing population data and election results. 8

Page 9: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Step 1: Setting up the Commission – Commissioners are appointed following a thorough screening process.

Timeline

9

Process

Page 10: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

ProcessStep 2: First-Round Hearings

Before drawing a single line, the Commission held 23 public hearings around the state in July and August to get input from the public about issues relevant to redistricting such as geography, communities of interest, minority voting rights, and competitiveness.

10

Page 11: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

29,000+ miles traveled

11

Page 12: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

12Maps

The AIRC Wants You to Stay Connected

Maps Meetings

Public Input

Page 13: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

ProcessStep 3: Mapping – • Start with a clean slate• Then divide the state into equal population in a grid

like pattern -- Grid Maps Approved August 18, 2011.• After adopting the grid maps, the Commission met

more than 25 times to consider adjustments to the grid to accommodate all of the state constitutional criteria. During this time they received additional public comment and draft maps.

• Approval of Draft Maps – Occurred on October 3, 2011 for the congressional map and October 10 for the legislative. 13

Page 14: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Previous Congressional Map

14

Page 15: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Starting Point – New Congressional Map

15

Page 16: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

New Congressional Grid Map

16

Page 17: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

New Congressional Draft Map

17

The draft congressional districts included:

•Two predominantly rural districts •Three border districts •Three districts in the greater Tucson region •Five districts that are entirely in Maricopa County

•It avoids splitting Arizona's Indian Reservations

•Two districts where minority voters have the opportunity to elect their candidate of choice

Page 18: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

ProcessStep 4: Second Round Hearings – • Visited 30 towns and cities all over the state

to share the draft maps and receive additional public input during October and November 2011.

18

Page 19: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

What does Independent mean?

• It means independent from the Legislature.• It does not mean that politics is entirely

removed from the process

19

Page 20: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

20

Page 21: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

21

“After having been served written notice and provided with an opportunity for response, a member of the IRC may be removed by the Governor, with the concurrence of 2/3 of the Senate for:

- Substantial neglect of duty- Gross misconduct in office or- Inability to discharge the duties of office.”

Supermajority in Senate with 21 R’s and 9 D’s in combination with a draft map the supermajority didn’t like = Removal of Chair

The Perfect Storm…

Page 22: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

22

November 17, 2011Reinstatement by Arizona Supreme Court

Page 23: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

23

Step 5: Final Maps• Upon completion of the public comment period, the

AIRC adopted tentative final maps December 21, 2011 and final maps January 17, 2012.

Step 6: Preclearance • The Congressional map was precleared April 9, 2012

and the legislative map on April 26, 2012.

Page 24: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Sweet Relief

24

Page 25: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Precleared New Congressional Final Map

25

Features:• Four Republican leaning districts (44% of map vs. 35.4% R registration; two Voting Rights Districts (22% of map vs. 30.4% D registration) where minority voters have the opportunity to elect the candidate of their choice; three competitive districts (33% of map compared to 34.2% Ind/Other registration).•Two predominantly rural districts•Three districts in the greater Tucson region•Avoids splitting Arizona's Native American Reservations

Page 26: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Pre-cleared New Congressional Final Map

26

Page 27: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

New Legislative Final Map

27

Page 28: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

28

Results

• Public had numerous opportunities and methods to engage:– 58 business meetings– 43 public hearings– 5364 in attendance; more than 1800 via internet– 2350 requests to speak– 7403 pieces of public input– 224 maps submitted

Page 29: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

2012 Election Results• Congressional:

– 4 safe R seats; 2 safe D seats and 3 competitive• Democrats swept all 3 competitive seats with one race

taking almost two weeks to call (2454 vote difference).• 2 of the competitive seats have been designated as

most likely to flip in 2014 (CD 1 and CD 2)• In 2008, the Arizona delegation was 5D and 3R.

• Legislative:– Senate: 17 R’s and 13 D’s won seats– House: 36 R’s and 24 D’s

29

Page 30: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

More Results• First time Arizona has ever received

preclearance on both maps on first try.• Center for Public Integrity conducted a state

integrity investigation and rated all 50 states in 14 areas, one of which was redistricting, for which Arizona received an A, our only one. (source: stateintegrity.org)

• Independent redistricting is preserved…so far.

30

Page 31: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Litigation Happens!

• Shelby County vs. Holder (Constitutionality of VRA) Awaiting US Supreme Court decision

• 3 Pending Arizona Lawsuits:– Leach, et.al. vs. AIRC (challenging Congressional districts in

state court)– Harris, et.al. vs. AIRC (challenging legislative districts in

federal court) (Trial ended 3/29/13). Awaiting decision from 3 judge panel.

– Arizona State Legislature vs. AIRC (assignment of task to redraw Congressional districts is sole purview of Legislature)

• Continue defending maps as necessary

31

Page 32: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Lessons Learned• Importance of shielding commission from

outside partisan forces• Striking the balance between flexibility and

constraint• Having a healthy and courageous 3rd branch of

government and fourth estate• Legislative privilege/immunity; independent

procurement; funding; oversight

32

Page 33: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

A potential solution?

33

redistricting

Page 34: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Transparency, Accountability…

34

Page 35: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

Are there adjustments to IRC’s composition that make sense?

Having the commission more closely reflect the electorate

– Larger?– Geographic– Partisan – The Rise of the Independent

• 2000: 43% R / 38% D/ 18% Other• 2010: 36% R/ 32% D/ 32% Other

– Racial/ethnic – Hispanic Example• 2000: 1,295,617• 2010: 1,895,149 – 46.3% increase

– Gender 35

Page 36: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

If you want a friend in Washington, get a dog. ~ Harry Truman

36

redistricting

Colleen Mathis

Page 37: A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Preclearance

37

Thank you …

for your interest in independent redistricting!

(You’ve got a friend in Arizona…)