406
Education and Demographics Presentation -Myron Orfield-

Myron Orfield Slides

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Presented on 9 July 2013 the Minnesota House Education Policy Committee held a hearing on integration policy at the Crosswinds Arts & Science School in Woodbury, MN.

Citation preview

Page 1: Myron Orfield Slides

Education and Demographics Presentation

-Myron Orfield-

Page 2: Myron Orfield Slides

Twin Cities School Demographics

Page 3: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 4: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 5: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 6: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 7: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 8: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 9: Myron Orfield Slides

GRADGraduation-Required

Assessments forDiploma Test

Page 10: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 11: Myron Orfield Slides

Dropout andGraduation Rates

Page 12: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 13: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 14: Myron Orfield Slides

Completion Rates

Page 15: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 16: Myron Orfield Slides

Minneapolis Schools Demographics

Page 17: Myron Orfield Slides

Minneapolis SchoolsRace and Ethnicity

Page 18: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 19: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 20: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 21: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 22: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 23: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 24: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 25: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 26: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 27: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 28: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 29: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 30: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 31: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 32: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 33: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 34: Myron Orfield Slides

Minneapolis SchoolsFree Lunch Eligibility

Page 35: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 36: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 37: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 38: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 39: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 40: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 41: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 42: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 43: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 44: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 45: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 46: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 47: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 48: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 49: Myron Orfield Slides

Minneapolis SchoolsMCA Testing

Proficiency Rates

Page 50: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 51: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 52: Myron Orfield Slides

Neighborhood(Residential)

Segregation andTransition

In Minneapolis

Page 53: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 54: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 55: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 56: Myron Orfield Slides

Twin Cities Metro Neighborhood Type

1990-2010

Page 57: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 58: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 59: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 60: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 61: Myron Orfield Slides

Saint Paul-South Suburban School Demographics

Page 62: Myron Orfield Slides

Saint Paul-South Suburban Schools

Race and Ethnicity

Page 63: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 64: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 65: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 66: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 67: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 68: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 69: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 70: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 71: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 72: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 73: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 74: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 75: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 76: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 77: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 78: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 79: Myron Orfield Slides

Saint Paul-South Suburban Schools

Free Lunch Eligibility

Page 80: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 81: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 82: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 83: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 84: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 85: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 86: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 87: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 88: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 89: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 90: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 91: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 92: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 93: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 94: Myron Orfield Slides

Suburban School Demographics

Page 95: Myron Orfield Slides

Northwest Minneapolis Suburban School

Demographics

Page 96: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 97: Myron Orfield Slides

Northwest MinneapolisSuburbs

Race and Ethnicity

Page 98: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 99: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 100: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 101: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 102: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 103: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 104: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 105: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 106: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 107: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 108: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 109: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 110: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 111: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 112: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 113: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 114: Myron Orfield Slides

Northwest MinneapolisSuburbs

Free Lunch Eligibility

Page 115: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 116: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 117: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 118: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 119: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 120: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 121: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 122: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 123: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 124: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 125: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 126: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 127: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 128: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 129: Myron Orfield Slides

Northwest MinneapolisSuburbs

MCA TestingProficiency Rates

Page 130: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 131: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 132: Myron Orfield Slides

Crime in SchoolsMinneapolis andWestern Suburbs

Page 133: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 134: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 135: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 136: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 137: Myron Orfield Slides

Southwest Minneapolis Suburban School

Demographics

Page 138: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 139: Myron Orfield Slides

Southwest MinneapolisSuburbs

Race and Ethnicity

Page 140: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 141: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 142: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 143: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 144: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 145: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 146: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 147: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 148: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 149: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 150: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 151: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 152: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 153: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 154: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 155: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 156: Myron Orfield Slides

Southwest MinneapolisSuburbs

Free Lunch Eligibility

Page 157: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 158: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 159: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 160: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 161: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 162: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 163: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 164: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 165: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 166: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 167: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 168: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 169: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 170: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 171: Myron Orfield Slides

Southwest MinneapolisSuburbs

MCA TestingProficiency Rates

Page 172: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 173: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 174: Myron Orfield Slides

Northeast Saint Paul Suburban School Demographics

Page 175: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 176: Myron Orfield Slides

Northeast Saint Paul SuburbsRace and Ethnicity

1995-2011

Page 177: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 178: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 179: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 180: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 181: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 182: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 183: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 184: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 185: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 186: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 187: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 188: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 189: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 190: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 191: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 192: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 193: Myron Orfield Slides

Northeast Saint Paul SuburbsLunch Eligibility Status

1997-2011

Page 194: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 195: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 196: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 197: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 198: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 199: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 200: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 201: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 202: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 203: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 204: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 205: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 206: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 207: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 208: Myron Orfield Slides

Southeast Saint Paul Suburban School Demographics

Page 209: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 210: Myron Orfield Slides

Southeast Saint Paul SuburbsRace and Ethnicity

1995-2011

Page 211: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 212: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 213: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 214: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 215: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 216: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 217: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 218: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 219: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 220: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 221: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 222: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 223: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 224: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 225: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 226: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 227: Myron Orfield Slides

Southeast Saint Paul SuburbsLunch Eligibility Status

1997-2011

Page 228: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 229: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 230: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 231: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 232: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 233: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 234: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 235: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 236: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 237: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 238: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 239: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 240: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 241: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 242: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 243: Myron Orfield Slides

School Boundaries and Race

Page 244: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 245: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 246: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 247: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 248: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 249: Myron Orfield Slides

Eden Prairie and Surrounding Area

Race and Ethnicity

1995-2010

Page 250: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 251: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 252: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 253: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 254: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 255: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 256: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 257: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 258: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 259: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 260: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 261: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 262: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 263: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 264: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 265: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 266: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 267: Myron Orfield Slides

Eden Prairie and Surrounding Area

Lunch (Economic) Status

1997-2010

Page 268: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 269: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 270: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 271: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 272: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 273: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 274: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 275: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 276: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 277: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 278: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 279: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 280: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 281: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 282: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 283: Myron Orfield Slides

Eden Prairie Boundaries

Current and Proposed Attendance Boundaries

Page 284: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 285: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 286: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 287: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 288: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 289: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 290: Myron Orfield Slides

High-poverty, segregated schools undermine opportunity for their

students in many ways, including:

• Lower test scores

• Higher dropout rates

• Lower college attendance rates

• Lower earnings later in life

• Greater risk of being poor as adults

Page 291: Myron Orfield Slides

Characteristics of High-Poverty Schools that Undermine Quality of Education

• Less qualified and less experienced teachers due to high turnover among teachers

• Limited curricula taught at less challenging levels, which limits educational and career options

• Absence of positive peer competition and influence, which lowers educational expectations

Page 292: Myron Orfield Slides

A large number of school districts in the Twin Cities are at risk of

re-segregating if nothing is done.

Page 293: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 294: Myron Orfield Slides

Many of these districts have recently gone through (or are now going through) school boundary changes as a result of

school closings, openings or other types of reorganization.

These include: Osseo, Hopkins, St. Louis Park, Burnsville, Chaska/Chanhassen,

and Eden Prairie.

Page 295: Myron Orfield Slides

Larger, multi-district approaches to desegregation could ease this process by

providing alternative approaches like multi-district magnets near job centers

and inter-district transfer programs.

Page 296: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 297: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 298: Myron Orfield Slides

Twin Cities Jobs and Job Centers

Page 299: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 300: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 301: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 302: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 303: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 304: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 305: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 306: Myron Orfield Slides

Twin Cities Municipal Property

Tax Base

Page 307: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 308: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 309: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 310: Myron Orfield Slides

Twin Cities Charter School Demographics

Page 311: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 312: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 313: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 314: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 315: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 316: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 317: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 318: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 319: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 320: Myron Orfield Slides

Charter School Time Series 1995-2010

Page 321: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 322: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 323: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 324: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 325: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 326: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 327: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 328: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 329: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 330: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 331: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 332: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 333: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 334: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 335: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 336: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 337: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 338: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 339: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 340: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 341: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 342: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 343: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 344: Myron Orfield Slides

Serious Crime in Twin Cities Metropolitan Area

Page 345: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 346: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 347: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 348: Myron Orfield Slides

Residence of Felons

Page 349: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 350: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 351: Myron Orfield Slides

Health

Page 352: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 353: Myron Orfield Slides

Migration of White Children

Page 354: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 355: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 356: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 357: Myron Orfield Slides

Subprime Lending and Foreclosure Crisis

Page 358: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 359: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 360: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 361: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 362: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 363: Myron Orfield Slides

Subsidized and Affordable Housing

Page 364: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 365: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 366: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 367: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 368: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 369: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 370: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 371: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 372: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 373: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 374: Myron Orfield Slides

Low Income Housing, Schools and Choice is Yours

Demographics

Page 375: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 376: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 377: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 378: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 379: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 380: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 381: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 382: Myron Orfield Slides

Key Key

Note: data are from representational survey for 53% of all LIHTC units in Twin Cities

Page 383: Myron Orfield Slides

Key

Page 384: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 385: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 386: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 387: Myron Orfield Slides

Metropolitan School Integration Scenarios

Number of black students that would have to change schools in order to achieve racial balance. 12,580

Number of additional black students that would already be in a racially integrated school if:

LITHC units were assigned randomly by race. Section 8 project units were assigned randomly by race.

738 789

Number of additional black students that would already be in a racially integrated school if:

LIHTC units were distributed across the region in proportion to school enrollment. Section 8 project units were distributed across the region in proportion to school enrollment.

655 1,301

Additional Section 8 vouchers in the suburbs if they were distributed in same proportions as school enrollment.Additional black households in suburbs (at 2000 shares in voucher program).

Children aged 6-17 in the added suburban black households (at 2000 average).

4,750 2,215

1,788

Grand Total additional black school-age children in the suburbs 5,271 (42%)

Page 388: Myron Orfield Slides

Working in the inner suburbs alone is not enough.

• In 2001, just 5 of the 65 inner suburb schools participating in the Choice Is Yours program had free and reduced cost lunch eligibility rates greater than 40%.

• In just 5 years, this number had nearly quadrupled to 19.

• Higher poverty rates are associated with both lower test scores and lower retention rates for suburban districts participating in the program.

Page 389: Myron Orfield Slides

Receiving School District CIY Retention Rates by FRLE(correlation = -.87)

25

50

75

100

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80FRLE Rate

CIY

Ret

urn

Rat

e 20

05-0

6

Page 390: Myron Orfield Slides

Receiving School District CIY Retention Ratesby Reading Proficiency (correlation = +.77)

25

50

75

100

40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Reading Proficiency Share

CIY

Ret

urn

Rat

e 20

05-0

6

Receiving School District CIY Retention Rateby Math Proficiency (correlation = +.79)

25

50

75

100

50 60 70 80 90 100

Math Proficiency Share

CIY

Ret

urn

Rat

e 20

05-0

6

Page 391: Myron Orfield Slides

Working in the inner suburbs alone is not enough.

• In 2001, just 3 of the 65 inner suburb schools participating in the Choice Is Yours program had minority shares greater than 40%.

• In just 5 years, this number had risen by 7 times to 21.

Page 392: Myron Orfield Slides

U.S. School Integration Trends

Page 393: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 394: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 395: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 396: Myron Orfield Slides

2000 Distribution of 633 Tracts that were White/Black Integrated in 1980in 15 Metro Areas with County- or Metro-wide Busing in the 1980's and 1990's

0

25

50

75

100

12 17 22 27 32 37 42 47

Percentage Black in 1980

Conclusion: Tracts were more likely to remain integrated than to resegregate during the next 20 years from all starting points.

Per

cent

age

of T

ract

s in

200

0

Remained Integrated Changed to Segregated Changed to Predominantly White

Page 397: Myron Orfield Slides

Suggested Policies:

Page 398: Myron Orfield Slides

Expanding Children’s Opportunities: School desegregation and integration

• Local solutions alone cannot turn schools around. Already existing segregation and regional processes like white flight and fragmented land-use planning mean that local areas and school districts cannot go it alone. Regional approaches are needed.

• Local approaches can help, if designed to complement regional solutions.

Page 399: Myron Orfield Slides

Regional Approaches to School Integration:Metro Collaborative Integration Districts

• Schools within the collaborative districts share pupils and funding to integrate all schools within the collaborative district.

• Such districts already exist in the Twin Cities, but are not metro-wide.

• In the Twin Cities, collaboration districts would be more efficient and integrative, for instance, if the metro area were divided into five metro “meta-districts,” drawn to maximize diversity within each meta-district.

Page 400: Myron Orfield Slides
Page 401: Myron Orfield Slides

Regional Approaches to School Integration:The Choice is Yours

• Choice is Yours allows low income students to move to suburban districts. It initially resulted in some integration of suburban districts and academic gains for the participating students.

• The program does not cover the entire region and a number of participating suburban schools have become racially isolated, high poverty schools, implying that the program needs to be expanded further into the suburbs.

• Choice is Yours should also be linked to housing choice programs in high opportunity school districts and suburbs.

Page 402: Myron Orfield Slides

Regional Approaches to School Integration:Integration Revenue

• Integration Revenue is extra funding meant to promote integration that is provided to Minnesota school districts with racially isolated schools.

• Integration revenue funds currently provide little or no incentive for school districts to desegregate their minority and low-income students.

• The purpose of the funding should be changed from “increasing interracial contact” to the physical integration of school districts, schools, and classrooms.

Page 403: Myron Orfield Slides

Neighborhood Approaches to School Integration:Charter schools

• Although charter schools were presented as an integrating force in public education, segregation and poverty is more severe in charter schools than in traditional public schools and there is little evidence that charter schools are bridging the achievement gap.

• Integrated middle-class schools have a proven track record of improving the school performance and life opportunities students of color. This is not the case for charter schools.

Page 404: Myron Orfield Slides

Neighborhood Approaches to School Integration:Magnet schools

• While highly segregated inner city schools are often failing, the solution cannot be just moving students into the suburbs; inner-city communities need strong schools.

• One way to do this, is to develop magnets schools in inner-city neighborhoods that appeal to commuting parents. Downtown areas are a likely target.

• These magnet schools could offer extended days to match the schedules of commuting parents by providing high-quality daycare and link the magnets to public institutions in the central cities.

Page 405: Myron Orfield Slides

Neighborhood Approaches to School Integration:Addressing segregation within schools

• Minority students and white students are often tracked into separate programs, even within otherwise integrated schools.

• In order to prevent damaging in-school segregation, school districts should be monitored for racial disparities in gifted and talented programs and other advanced standing classes and in special education.

• Community groups could also help actively monitor schools and challenge segregative classroom assignment practices to ensure that students have equal opportunities in integrated schools.

Page 406: Myron Orfield Slides

Contact Us:http://www.law.umn.edu/metro.html