Forgotten People and NGS - Securing Economic & Climate Justice

  • View

  • Download

Embed Size (px)


  • 1. Navajo Generating Station Securing Environmental andClimate Justice
    • Navajo Generating Station Meeting with
  • US DOI, Salt River Project, Arizona Public Service,
  • Tucson Electric Power, and Nevada Power
  • February 4, 2011, Pera Club, Page, AZ
  • Forgotten People
  • [email_address]

2. Roadmap Transition not Retrofit

  • Transition to clean energy-solar, wind, photovoltaic, concentrated solar, geothermal, and biomass
  • Invest in a transition to clean energy instead of spending hundreds of millions of dollars to retrofit
  • Uncertain water and coal supply
  • Grand Canyon visibility
  • US EPA Clean Air and BART regulations
  • Toxic coal ash/Health effects/Climate change

3. Forgotten People Overview

  • The Forgotten People is a grassroots organization representing communities in the western portion of the Navajo Nation.
  • The communities are spread over almost 2 million acres of remote desert terrain in the northeast of Arizona.
  • Only 3 percent of the families in these communities have electricity and only 10 percent have running water (HR5168, 2004).

4. Challenges: The Bennett Freeze

  • For over 42 years, a US law called the Bennett Freeze prohibited any home repairs or community improvements in most of the western Navajo Nation.
  • The community infrastructure has deteriorated and while city residents pay 30 cents for a hundred gallons of water, the cost for the water haulers can be over $25 for a hundred gallons, 100x as much for a basic necessity of life.

5. Challenges: Achieving Environmental Justice

  • If a fraction of the deadly contamination the Navajos live with every day had been in Beverly Hills or any wealthy community, it would have been cleaned up immediately. But there's a different standard applied to the Navajo land...while time passes, people get sick, people die, people develop kidney disease, children, babies are born with birth defects, bone cancer develops and gets worse, lung cancer, leukemia, while we wait US Senator Henry Waxman, 2007

6. 43 Years of Third World Conditions The Bennett Freeze 7. Challenges: The Bennett Freeze 8. Forgotten People Partnerships 9. Forgotten People with CDC & US EPA 10. Addressing Interlinkages: Health 11. Hard life for water haulers 12. Peabody Kayenta mine 13. Coal dust over Black Mesa 14. School bus on Peabody mininghaul road by J-28 15. Navajo Generating Station 16. Navajo Generating Station emissions

  • The Navajo Generating Station produces 1/4 of all US greenhouse gas emissions - 300 lbs. of mercury each year, and emits as much pollution as LA and Denver, impairing visibility locally and at the Grand Canyon.
  • Based on a ranking by the US Environmental Protection Agency, a 2009 report "America's Biggest Polluters" stated the Navajo Generating Station is the eighth dirtiest plant in the nation, releasing 20.1 million tons of carbon dioxide in 2007.

17. Grand Canyon visibility concerns Grand Canyon National Park (GCNP) is a mandatory Class I federal areathat is afforded visibility protection under the Federal Clean Air Act. 18. Toxic coal ash

  • Coal that is mined gets burned and creates coal ash. Big coal has spent millions of dollars touting the virtues of what the industry calls clean coal, but coal is the dirtiest fossil fuel and this cost is not factored into the price.
  • When coal is burned it releases monstrous quantities of deadly compounds and gases and it all has to go somewhere.
  • The worst of the waste heavy metals like arsenic, cadmium and mercury, all of which are highly toxic are concentrated in the ash thats left over after coal is burned or in the dirty sludge thats scrubbed from smokestacks.

19. Navajo Generating Stationdoes not have areliable source of coal

  • The Navajo Generating Station does not have a reliable source of coal.Los Angeles Department of Water and Power contract with Peabody expires in 2016.
  • The life-of-mine permit for Peabodys Black Mesa mine was vacated by an administrative law judge in January 2010 and the mine has been closed since the Mohave Generating Station shut down.
  • Peabodys Black Mesa and Kayenta mine lease expires with the Navajo Nation in 2011.
  • Peabody cannot mine one piece of coal at the Black Mesa mine and any lease issued to do activity by law requires a permit.
  • The Kayenta mine is running out of good coal.

20. Railroad carrying Kayenta coal has no transportation permit

  • The railroad carrying coal from the Kayenta mine to Navajo Generating Station has no transportation permit as required under Surface Mining Coal Reclamation Act.No barrier arms and warning lights at the railroad crossings which has resulted in the death of people and livestock.

21. Navajo Generating Stationdoes not have areliable source of water

  • Lake Mead, which dams the Colorado River near Las Vegas and is one of the largest reservoirs in the country, is 59 percent empty and the water level is so low that the giant turbines in Hoover Dam could soon stop turning.

22. Changing water patterns andLake Mead & Lake Powell

  • Changing rainfall patterns, natural climate variability, high levels of evaporation, reduced snow melt runoff, and current water use patterns are putting pressure on water management resources at Lake Mead as the population depending on it for water and the Hoover Dam for electricity continues to grow.
  • A 2008 paper in Water Resources Research states that at current usage allocation and projected climate trends, there is a 50% chance that live storage in lakes Mead and Powell will be gone by 2021, and that the reservoir could drop below minimum power pool elevation of 1,050feet (320 m) as early as 2017.

23. Public Health Effects

  • Observed adverse impacts of the burning of coal are affecting air quality, water quality and access to water for water haulers living in the vicinity of Peabody that do not have piped water, electricity, and are experiencing health effects including Black Lung, Silicosis, asthma, widespread chronic lung problems, coughs, sore throats, eye irritations, flu like symptoms, asthma, dark yellowish mucous coughed up by children and adults due to pollution, especially the dust and smoke generated by NGS.
  • Testimonies of Black Mesa and NGS area residents

24. Public Health effects 2

  • A 2008 study found that people living in mining communities are 70 percent more likely to develop kidney disease, 64 percent more likely to have chronic lung diseases such as emphysema, and 30 percent more likely to report hypertension. Those who live near coal-burning power plants are also at higher risk.
  • 4/18/2010 The Great US Coal Disaster

25. Call to Action

  • Forgotten People joins environmental, human rights and social justice organizations to urge US Department of the Interior, Salt River Project, Arizona Public Service, Tucson Electric Power and Nevada Power to abandon Navajo Generating Station retrofit and create a timeline for transition to clean energy sources.

26. US EPA enforcement of emissions limitations & BART

  • Forgotten People supports the US Environmental Protection Agencys finalization of a Federal Implementation Plan under the Clean Air Act to:
  • Regulate emissions from Navajo Generating Station;
  • Establish federally enforceable emissions limitations for sulfur dioxides, total particulate matter, and opacity;
  • Best Available Retrofit Technology limits for NOx and PM emissions.

27. Coal Plants in Transition

  • March of 2010 report, Coal Plants in Transition: An Economic Case Study used the NGS as a case study to examine the costs and benefits of the plants future favored the phasing out of existing coal plants over retrofitting them with scrubber technology.
  • The report notes that retrofits can entail substantial costs, running into the hundreds of millions of dollars and it may be more profitable to abandon retrofit plans and instead embrace a full range of clean energy resources, including wind, photovoltaic and concentrated solar, geothermal, and biomass, combined with large-scale supply and demand-side efficiency measures.

28. Phase out coal & eliminate 80% of the solution to the global warming crisis

  • Coal-fired power plants are responsible for one-third of Americas carbon dioxide (CO2) emissionsabout the same amount as all transportation sources -- cars, SUVs, trucks, buses, planes, ships, and trains -- combined.
  • Coal-fired power plants are largest single source of carbon dioxide in the country. NASA scientist James Hansen said that phasing out coal is 80% of the solution to the global warming crisis

29. Recommendations 1

  • TheUS Department of the Interior , Salt River Project, Arizona Public Service, Tucson Electric Power, and Nevada Power shall begin installing SCR and bag houses o