21
ViCiSi .eu ViCiSi - The Virtual City Simulator Dynamic cost assessment related to outages in critical infrastructure by assessing Societal Activities EffectPlus Amsterdam July 4—5 2011 Tekn. Lic Mats B-O Larsson MML Analys & Strategi AB 1

Viking vi cisi

  • Upload
    fcleary

  • View
    453

  • Download
    3

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

 

Citation preview

Page 1: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

ViC

iSi

-

The

Vir

tual

Cit

y

Sim

ula

tor

Dyn

am

ic c

ost

ass

essm

ent

rela

ted t

o

outa

ges

in c

riti

cal

infr

ast

ruct

ure

by

ass

essi

ng S

oci

etal

Act

ivit

ies

Effe

ctP

lus

Am

ste

rda

m J

uly

4—

5 2

011

Te

kn

. L

ic M

ats

B-O

La

rsso

n

MM

L A

na

lys &

Str

ate

gi A

B

1

Page 2: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Who a

m I?

! 

Mats

B-O

Lars

son

! 

Consultant,

MM

L A

naly

s &

Str

ate

gi AB

! 

Chairm

an o

f th

e B

oard

of

Directo

rs o

f Telg

e E

nerg

i N

ät

AB (

A S

wedis

h m

id s

ized

Infr

astr

uctu

re D

istr

ibution C

om

pany

- W

ate

r And S

ew

age,

- Ele

ctr

ical G

rid,

- D

istr

ict

Heating,

- 

Bro

adband

! 

Chairm

an o

f th

e B

oard

of

Directo

rs o

f L

yckeby R

esearc

h F

oundation

! 

Mem

ber

of

the B

oard

of

Directo

rs o

f L

yckeby S

tarc

h A

B (

a g

lobal Sta

rch P

roducer)

! 

Mem

ber

of

the B

oard

of

Directo

rs o

f C

ulinar

AB (

a g

lobal Sta

rch P

roducer)

! 

Tech.

Lic

. of

Engin

eering,

Royal In

stitu

te o

f Technolo

gy in

Sto

ckholm

, 2005

! 

M.S

c.,

(Engin

eering P

hysic

s),

Royal In

stitu

te o

f Technolo

gy in

Sto

ckholm

, 1980

2

Page 3: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

“M

icro

org

an

ism

s” a

re

the

gre

ate

st

thre

ats

! 

1)

Mic

roo

rga

nis

ms,

su

ch

as v

iru

se

s

an

d b

acte

ria

, w

hic

h in

fects

ou

r w

ate

r d

istr

ibu

tio

n s

yste

ms

 N

ot

ne

ce

ssa

ry f

rom

an

tag

on

ists

 M

ore

pro

ba

ble

by c

are

lessn

ess a

nd

la

ck o

f h

yg

ien

e w

ith

in t

he

wa

ter

dis

trib

utio

n s

yste

m

! 

2)

Cyb

ero

rga

nis

ms w

hic

h in

fects

ou

r p

ow

er

grid

SC

AD

A s

yste

ms

 A

nta

go

nis

t th

rea

ts b

y t

roja

ns,

viru

se

s,

De

nia

l o

f S

erv

ice

att

acks,

etc

.

… t

o o

ur

Cri

tic

al

infr

as

tru

ctu

re

! 

Ele

ctr

ica

l P

ow

er

Grid

! 

Te

leco

mm

un

ica

tio

ns

! 

Pa

ym

en

t syste

ms

! 

Wa

ter

an

d s

ew

ag

e

3

Page 4: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Asse

ssm

en

t o

f so

cia

l co

sts

aft

er

an

ou

tag

e

in c

ritica

l in

fra

str

uctu

re

! 

We n

eed m

eth

ods to a

ssess the c

osts

to the s

ocie

ty fro

m

dis

turb

ances in the c

ritical in

frastr

uctu

re

! 

To

op

tim

ize

ou

r in

ve

stm

en

ts t

o m

itig

ate

ou

tag

es

! 

The tw

o c

om

mon w

ays to m

easure

socia

l outa

ge c

osts

are

:

 A

lt.

1 A

ss

es

s t

he

co

ns

um

ers

pre

fere

nc

es

:

! 

Ask t

he

cu

sto

me

r! C

usto

me

r su

rve

ys a

re t

he

mo

st

co

mm

on

. T

he

re a

re a

nu

mb

er

of

su

rve

ys d

on

e in

mo

st

co

un

trie

s.

Ma

ny

pro

ble

ms!

 A

lt.

2 A

ss

es

s t

he

de

cre

as

e o

f a

cti

vit

y i

n t

he

so

cie

ty:

! 

Asse

s t

he

GD

P in

flu

en

ce

! 

Th

e d

raw

ba

ck

is

th

at

it r

eq

uir

es

a p

rofi

le o

f th

e a

cti

vit

ies

in

th

e s

oc

iety

4

Page 5: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

The G

ross D

om

estic P

roduct (G

DP

) is

a m

easure

ment

of econom

ic a

ctivitie

s in a

socie

ty! 

Th

e e

co

no

mic

activity in

a s

ocie

ty is b

est

de

scrib

ed

by t

he

Gro

ss D

om

estic P

rod

uct

! 

GD

P is m

ea

su

red

in

th

ree

alte

rna

tive

pe

rsp

ective

s:

1)

Pro

du

cti

on

pe

rsp

ec

tiv

e,

2)

En

d-

us

e (

co

ns

um

pti

on

) p

ers

pe

cti

ve

an

d 3

) D

istr

ibu

tio

n p

ers

pe

cti

ve

! 

Th

e c

ost

of

an

ou

tag

e in

th

e p

ow

er

su

pp

ly c

an

be

me

asu

red

as t

he

re

du

ctio

n in

on

e G

DP

-p

ers

pe

ctive

! 

How

ever,

it is

im

port

ant to

be a

ware

of

whic

h p

ers

pective the c

ost m

easure

ment

concern

s

! 

Costs

fro

m tw

o p

ers

pectives c

an’t b

e

added to g

et a tota

l cost.

! 

Busin

ess a

ctivity is m

easure

d in the

Pro

duction p

ers

pective

! 

Household

activity is m

easure

d in the

End-u

se p

ers

pective

! 

Thus:

! 

Ou

tag

e c

osts

≠ O

uta

geC

ost B

usin

ess +

C

ou

tag

eC

ost H

ou

seh

old

5

Page 6: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Activity P

rofile

s in a

Socie

ty

6

! 

To

asse

ss t

he

de

cre

ase

of

activity in

th

e s

ocie

ty w

e n

ee

d a

su

m o

f a

ll e

co

no

mic

activitie

s in

an

u

nd

istu

rbe

d s

ocie

ty,

co

llecte

d f

rom

ea

ch

in

div

idu

al o

bje

ct,

to

ge

t a

n a

gg

reg

ate

d A

ctivity P

rofile

fo

r a

S

ocie

ty

i.e. a function, b(t

), w

hic

h r

eflects

the s

ocie

tal activity a

t every

a s

ingle

opera

tion a

t every

mom

ent, s

uch a

s

∫ one y

ear b(t

) dt =

GD

P

Th

ere

are

no

pu

blic

ly a

va

ilab

le B

usin

ess p

rofile

s!

ViC

iSi cre

ate

s B

usin

ess A

ctivity P

rofile

s f

or

all

EU

27

co

un

trie

s +

No

rwa

y a

nd

S

witze

rla

nd

One y

ear

EU

R/h

Page 7: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Pow

er

Resto

ration

Socie

ty R

esto

ration

Norm

al opera

tion

Norm

al opera

tion

Resto

ration a

fter

an o

uta

ge c

om

prises d

iffe

rent kin

ds o

f re

sto

ration; fo

r exam

ple

Po

wer

Resto

rati

on

and

So

cie

ty R

esto

rati

on

! 

Po

we

r R

es

tora

tio

n is t

he

sta

ge

wh

ere

th

e d

em

an

d f

or

po

we

r is

in

cre

asin

g a

fte

r th

e g

rid

ha

s

be

en

en

erg

ize

d.

So

me

lo

st

en

erg

y w

ill a

lso

be

re

co

ve

red

.

! 

So

cie

ty R

es

tora

tio

n is t

he

sta

ge

wh

ere

th

e e

co

no

mic

activity in

th

e s

ocie

ty is in

cre

asin

g a

fte

r th

e g

rid

ha

s b

ee

n e

ne

rgiz

ed

. S

om

e lo

st

eco

no

mic

va

lue

s w

ill a

lso

be

re

co

ve

red

.

! 

So

cie

ty R

esto

ratio

n is n

orm

ally

co

nsid

era

bly

slo

we

r th

an

th

e P

ow

er

Re

sto

ratio

n

7

Page 8: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Why a

Virtu

al socie

ty?

! 

Wh

y d

o w

e u

se

a v

irtu

al so

cie

ty w

he

n t

he

re a

re s

o

ma

ny r

ea

l so

cie

tie

s,

with

re

al in

fra

str

uctu

res?

! 

An

d m

ore

ove

r w

he

n t

ho

se

so

cie

tie

s h

as p

ut

lots

off

e

ffo

rts t

o d

igita

lly m

ea

su

re a

ll a

sse

ts?

! 

A v

irtu

al so

cie

ty h

as a

nu

mb

er

of

ad

va

nta

ge

s:

 N

ot conflic

ting w

ith n

ational security

issues.

 T

he c

oncern

of th

e n

ational security

after

9/1

1 h

as m

ade it m

ore

or

less im

possib

le to u

se “

sharp

” geogra

phic

al and e

lectr

ical

data

!

 E

specia

lly w

hen w

e u

se larg

e s

cale

socie

ties.

 W

e c

an

ad

ap

t sim

ula

tio

ns a

nd

re

su

lts t

o

va

rio

us e

nviro

nm

en

ts a

nd issu

es

 W

e c

an

ad

ap

t sim

ula

tio

ns a

nd

re

su

lts t

o o

the

r co

un

trie

s

 W

e d

on

’t n

ee

d t

o c

oo

pe

rate

with

a s

pe

cific

co

mp

an

y t

o g

et

ge

og

rap

hic

al a

nd

ele

ctr

ica

l d

ata

8

Page 9: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

ViC

iSi S

tatic O

bje

cts

! 

Assets

 B

locks,

 H

ou

se

s,

 A

pa

rtm

en

ts a

nd

 L

oca

tio

ns

! 

Str

eets

and r

ailw

ays

! 

Ele

ctr

ical grid

! 

Wate

r and s

ew

age (

not

imple

mente

d y

et)

! 

Tele

com

munic

ations (n

ot

imple

mente

d y

et)

9

Page 10: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

ViC

iSi D

ynam

ic O

bje

cts

! In

habitants

! O

pera

tions

 In

dustr

ies,

 P

ublic

and p

rivate

Serv

ice,

 U

tilit

ies,

 A

griculture

farm

s

! A

ctivity p

rofile

s

! 

Socie

ty A

ctivity p

rofile

! 

Pow

er

Load P

rofile

10

Socie

ty A

ctivity

Manufa

ctu

ring

Reta

i

l

School

Hospital

Load

facto

r

(Pm

ax/

Pm

ea

n)

Page 11: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

ViC

iSi G

eogra

phic

al F

eatu

res

! 

All

ob

jects

in

ViC

iSi h

as a

g

eo

gra

ph

ica

l d

istr

ibu

tio

n

! 

Pla

ne

an

d S

ph

erica

l co

ord

ina

tes (

Go

og

le e

art

h

co

ord

ina

tes)

! 

Th

ree

co

ord

ina

te s

yste

ms

 G

lob

al (E

art

h)

 L

oca

l (C

ou

nty

)

 B

lock

11

Page 12: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

ViC

iSi E

lectr

ical F

eatu

res

! 

The e

lectr

ical grid insid

e V

iCiS

i is

a s

implif

ied

but corr

ect ele

ctr

ical grid

 dim

ensio

ned fro

m the p

eak load o

f every

subscriber,

 T

akin

g c

are

of th

e p

ow

er

coin

cid

ence w

ith

oth

er

subscribers

 R

eflecting the g

eogra

phic

al str

uctu

re o

f blo

cks a

nd s

treets

 H

andle

s d

iffe

rent voltage levels

in the g

rid

 P

erf

orm

s tra

nsfo

rmation b

etw

een d

iffe

rent

voltage levels

! 

Calc

ula

tion:

 T

ime r

esolu

tion 1

/100

th s

econd

 A

ctu

al lo

ad flo

w d

ata

is c

alc

ula

ted a

t each

arb

itra

ry tim

e p

oin

t (A

ctive +

Reactive p

ow

er)

 T

he lin

e losses (

Active +

Reactive p

ow

er)

 G

eogra

phic

al dis

tances, M

anhattan length

of

lines

! 

The v

oltage levels

insid

e V

iCiS

i are

! 

40

0/2

20

kV

! 

11

0 k

V

! 

40

kV

! 

10

kV

(b

lack)

! 

0.4

kV

(ye

llow

)

12

Page 13: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Input to

ViC

iSi

! 

EU

-27

+ N

orw

ay +

Sw

itze

rla

nd

! 

Eco

no

mic

sta

tistics f

rom

Eu

rosta

t (y

ea

r 2

00

7)

(h

ttp:/

/

epp.e

uro

sta

t.ec.e

uro

pa.e

u)

 G

ross D

om

estic P

rod

uct

(GD

P)

 E

ne

rgy c

on

su

mp

tio

n

 D

em

og

rap

hic

sta

tistics

 E

mp

loym

en

t

 B

ran

ch

sta

tistics

 C

ou

ntr

y A

rea

! 

Po

we

r L

oa

d P

rofile

s f

rom

TS

O’s

(h

ttp://w

ww

.ents

oe.e

u)

 H

ou

r va

lue

s o

f co

un

try p

ow

er

de

ma

nd

(ye

ar

20

07

)

! 

Tim

e U

se

sta

tistics H

ET

US

H

arm

onis

ed E

uro

pean T

ime U

se

Surv

eys

8https://w

ww

.h2.s

cb.s

e/tus/tus)

13

Page 14: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

ViC

iSi O

utp

ut: B

usin

ess A

ctivity to

Outa

ge C

ost A

ssessm

ent

! 

Actu

al B

usin

ess A

ctivity (

EU

R/h

) are

sum

med for

each o

bje

ct

! 

Outa

ge c

osts

after

Pow

er

Dow

n/

Up (

EU

R/h

) are

sum

med for

each

obje

ct

! 

Busin

ess R

esto

ration a

nd

Busin

ess R

ecovery

(slo

wer

than

Pow

er

Resto

ration)

14

Page 15: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

ViC

iSi O

utp

ut:

Movie

s

15

Page 16: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

ViC

iSi O

utp

ut:

M

ap

s  

Maps o

f th

e infr

astr

uctu

re

! 

Blo

cks, apart

ments

, str

eets

, E

lectr

ical grid, etc

.

 In

Euclid

ic p

lane thre

e d

imensio

nal coord

inate

s (

x,y

,z)

(XM

L-f

iles)

 O

r spherical coord

inate

s (

longitude, la

titu

de, z)

for

Google

Eart

h (

KM

L-f

iles).

The

km

l-file

s c

an b

e im

port

ed to G

oogle

Eart

h a

s a

n o

verlay to the G

oogle

Eart

h M

aps

16

Page 17: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Ind

us

tria

l P

art

ne

rs

AB

B A

G (

Ge

rma

ny)

E.O

N A

G (

Ge

rma

ny)

Astr

on

(H

un

ga

ry)

MM

L A

na

lysis

& S

tra

teg

y (

Sw

ed

en

)

Ac

ad

em

ic P

art

ne

rs

Ro

ya

l In

stitu

te o

f T

ech

no

log

y (

Sw

ed

en

)

ET

H Z

urich

(S

witze

rla

nd

)

Un

ive

rsity o

f M

ary

lan

d (

US

A)

ViC

iSi in

the V

ikin

g p

roje

ct

17

Page 18: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Fro

m s

ecu

rity

re

qu

ire

me

nts

to

so

cia

l co

sts

Att

ack

SC

AD

A s

yste

m

Po

we

r n

etw

ork

So

cie

talco

st

18

Page 19: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Test &

Monitoring

AB

B T

ransm

issio

n

syste

m s

imula

tor

(OT

S)

&

HV

model

AB

B P

rim

ary

SC

AD

A

Inclu

des 4

0 b

usbar

model

AB

B S

econdary

SC

AD

A

Astr

on s

ubsta

tion s

imula

tor

(NT

S)

and M

V m

odel

RT

U

2 H

V/M

V s

ubs.

Data

Exchange

as file

IEC

IEC

IEC

IE

C

ICCP

ICCP

IED

Vik

ing C

ountr

y S

imula

tor

and L

V m

odel

(ViC

iSi)

VIK

ING

City 1

V

IKIN

G C

ity n

2 H

V/M

V s

ubsta

tion

XM

L c

om

m.

inte

rface

XM

L

XM

L

Inte

rnal D

ata

Exchange

WA

N e

mula

tor

IEC

104

Data

Exchange

as file

Penetr

ation a

nd A

naly

sis

Tools

Sessio

n

Manager

ViC

iSi is

a p

art

of

the

Vik

ing

-Te

st

Be

d

19

Page 20: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Po

ssib

ilitie

s t

o u

se

ViC

iSi in

oth

er

pro

jects

! 

Th

e s

co

pe

of

ViC

iSi is

to

use

a v

irtu

al

so

cie

ty t

o t

est

the

dyn

am

ics a

nd

re

sili

en

ce

o

f critica

l in

fra

str

uctu

res

 T

he d

ynam

ics b

etw

een the indiv

iduals

and the

socie

ty a

nd the d

ependency o

f w

ell

functionin

g

infr

astr

uctu

re

 V

iCiS

i is

built

bottom

up, i.e. fr

om

the the m

icro

-level

 P

resents

the c

osts

to the s

ocie

ty o

f diffe

rent kin

ds o

f dis

turb

ances

! 

ViC

iSi

 C

an r

un o

n d

iffe

rent pla

tform

s L

inux, W

indow

s, M

ac)

 H

as a

well

defined x

ml-in

terf

ace

! 

Ne

w f

ea

ture

s a

nd

oth

er

critica

l in

fra

str

uctu

res w

ill b

e im

ple

me

nte

d/

exte

nd

ed

, su

ch

as

 W

ate

r dis

trib

ution a

nd s

ew

age r

em

oval

 T

ele

com

munic

ations

 P

aym

ent syste

ms

 T

ransport

ation (

Railw

ay a

nd b

uses)

 T

ime U

se s

tatistics

! 

De

pe

nd

en

cie

s b

etw

ee

n d

iffe

ren

t in

fra

str

uctu

res

! 

Ele

ctr

ical grid "

Tele

com

munic

ation

! 

Tele

com

munic

ation "

Paym

ent syste

m

! 

Ele

ctr

ical grid "

Wate

r and S

ew

age

! 

Oth

er

dis

turb

an

ce

s w

ill b

e im

ple

me

nte

d in

to

the

so

cie

ty,

su

ch

as:

 P

ois

on in the fre

sh w

ate

r

 P

rolif

era

tion o

f in

fections a

nd d

iseases

 D

istu

rbances in tele

com

munic

ation a

nd the p

aym

ent

syste

m

 D

istu

rbances in tra

nsport

ation

 N

ew

Pow

er

pro

file

s in S

mart

grid

! 

Th

e a

pp

lica

tio

n o

f V

iCiS

i in

sim

ula

tio

n a

nd

re

al-lif

e a

pp

lica

tio

ns

 C

ost of cyber

attacks (

the V

ikin

g P

roje

ct)

 T

o g

ive e

stim

ate

s o

f outa

ge c

osts

 in

vestm

ent pla

nnin

g

 F

or

main

tenance (

cost of pla

nned o

uta

ges)

  M

easure

ments

of th

e r

esili

ence in a

socie

ty

 N

ew

custo

mer

behavour

in S

mart

Grid S

yste

ms

20

Page 21: Viking vi cisi

ViC

iSi.

eu

Conta

ct

Mats

B-O

Lars

son

MM

L A

naly

se &

Str

ate

gy A

B

mats

@m

ml.se

ww

w.v

icis

i.eu

,w

ww

.mm

l.se

Phone +

4670 6

508376

21